ADVANCES IN CATALYSIS VOLUME 36
Advisory Board
M. BOUDART Stanford. Calijomia
V. B. KAZANSKY Moscow, USSR.
G. A. S...
24 downloads
1730 Views
19MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADVANCES IN CATALYSIS VOLUME 36
Advisory Board
M. BOUDART Stanford. Calijomia
V. B. KAZANSKY Moscow, USSR.
G. A. SOMORJAI Berkeley. Calijornia
G. ERTL Berlid!hlem. F.R.G.
A. OZAKI Ilbkya Japan
W. 0. HAAG Princeton, New Jersey
W. M. H. SACHTLER Evanston, Illinoh
J. M. THOMAS London, UK.
ADVANCES IN CATALYSIS VOLUME 36
Edited by D. D. ELEY The University Nottingham. England
PAULB. WEISZ
HERMAN PINES Northwestern University Evanston, Illinois
University of &nnsylvania Philadelphia, &nnsylvania
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. Hmourt Brace Jovnnovich, Publishers
San Diego New York Berkeley Boston London Sydney Tokyo Toronto
COPYRIGHT 0 1989 BY
ACADEMICPRESS. INC.
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO PART OF THIS PUBLICATION MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM OR BY ANY MEANS, ELECTRONIC OR MECHANICAL, INCLUDING PHOTOCOPY. RECORDING. OR ANY INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, WITHOUT PERMISSION IN WRITING FROM THE PUBLISHER.
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. San Diego, California 92101 United Kingdom Edition published by
ACADEMIC PRESS LIMITED 24-28 Oval Road, London NW I 7DX
LIBRARYOF CONGRESS
CATALOG CARD
ISBN 0-12-007836-8 (alk. paper)
PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 89909192
9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
NUMBER: 49-7755
Contents CONTRIBUTORS ............................................................... PREFACE ....................................................................
vii ix
Studies of Model Catalysts with Well-Defined Surfaces Combining Ultrahigh Vacuum Surface Characterization with Medium- and High-pressure Kinetics
.
CHARLES T CAMPBELL
I. I1 I11. IV
. .
Introduction ....................................................... Experimental Design Considerations................................... Elucidation of Structure-Function Relationships in Catalysis ............. Conclusion ......................................................... References .........................................................
2 4 14 47 49
The influence of Particle Size on the Catalytic Properties of Supported Metals
.
MICHELCHE AND CARROLL 0 BENNETT I. I1 I11.
.
. . VI . VII. IV V
. . .
I I1. I11 IV V. VI .
Introduction ....................................................... Preparation of Supported Metal Particles .............................. Background for Evaluating the Catalytic Properties of Small Supported Particles ......................................... Characterization of Small Supported Metal Particles .................... Effect of Particle Size on lhrnover Frequency and Selectivity: Presentation and Comparison of the Data ............................. Possible Explanations of Particle Size Effects: Experiments versus Models ........................................... Conclusions and Future Directions .................................... References .........................................................
Metal-Support interaction: Group Vill Metals and Reducible Oxides GARYL. HALLER AND DANIEL E. RESASCO Introduction ....................................................... Titania-Supported Catalysts .......................................... Model Studies ...................................................... A Comparison of Rh/TiOl and Pt/TiO, ...............................
55 59 72 91 109 140 155 160
173 179 203
209 Current Explanations of the Promoting Effect of TiO, on Catalytic Activity ......................................... 214 Bonding and Charge 'Ikansfer in Group VIII-Ti Systems ................. 221 V
vi
CONTENTS
VII. VIII
.
I.
. Ill . IV. V. VI. VII . VIII . IX. 11
Metal-Support Interactions in Other Oxide Supports and Related Phenomena ............................................. Conclusions ........................................................ References .........................................................
226 229 230
Structure and Reactivity of Perovskite-Type Oxides LUISG. TEJUCA.Jost LUISG. FIERRO. AND JUANM . D. TASC6N Introduction ....................................................... Structure .......................................................... Preparation ........................................................ Nonstoichiometry ................................................... Stability in a Reducing Atmosphere ................................... Adsorption Studies .................................................. Perovskites in Catalysis .............................................. Miscellaneous ...................................................... Prospective Lines of Research ........................................ References .........................................................
237 240 244 254 258 270 279 315 318 319
New Catalytic Materials from Amorphous Metal Alloys ARPADMOLNAR.GERARD v . SMITH.
. 111. I I1.
IV.
AND
MIHALYB A R T ~ K
Introduction ....................................................... Preparation and Characterization of Amorphous Alloys ................. Amorphous Alloys in Catalytic 'Ifansformations ........................ Conclusions ........................................................ References .........................................................
329 330 336 374 317
ADDENDUM TO STRUCTURE AND REACTIVITY OF PEROVSKITE-TYPE OXIDES ............ 385 INDEX...................................................................... 387
Contributors Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors' contributions begin.
MrnALY BART~K, Department of Organic Chemistry,J b m f Attila University, Szeged, Hungary (329) CARROLL 0. BENNETT,Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Connecticut, Storm, Connecticut 06268 (55) CHARLES T. CAMPBELL ChemistryDepartment, Indiana University,Bloomington, Indiana 47405 (1) MICHELCHE, Laboratoire de Rkactivitk de Surface et Structure, UA 1106, CNRS, Universitk Pierre et Marie Curie (Ihris Vl). 75252 Aris Cedex 05,
Fmnce ( 5 5 ) JOSELUISG. FIERRO, Instituto de Catdlisisy €ktmleoqulmica. CS.I.C, Sermno 119, 28006 Madrid, Spain (237) GARYL. HALLER Department of Chemical Engineering, Yale University,Nav Haven, Connecticut 06520 (173) ARPADM O L N ~ Department , of Organic Chemistry,Jbzsef Attila University, Szeged, Hungary (329) DANIELE. RESASCO,Department of Chemical Engineering, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut 06520 (173) GERARDV. SMITH,Department of Chemistry and the Molecular Science h g m m , Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, Illinois 62901 (329) JUANM. D.TAXON,Instituto Nacional del Carbdn y sus Brivados, C S I C , Apartado 73, 33080 Oviedo, Spain (237) LUISG. TEJUCA, Instituto de Cbtdlisisy &tmleoquulmica, CSIC, Sermno 119, 28006 Madrid, Spain (237)
vii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
We live in the midst of an information explosion. Publications are mushrooming. Even journals dedicated to any one “field” like catalysis are multiplying. Furthermore, when we look at catalysis, we deal with a diversity of basic ingredients and interests which can be equally at home in many disciplines (chemistry, solid state physics, materials science, enzymology, chemical engineering, electro-chemistry, crystallography, to name but a few). How do we keep informed when the proliferation of reporting is so massive and scattered over a wide spectrum of the scientific information media? The answer is, and always will be, “with difficulty.” But progress in science is dependent on two equal partners in symbiotic coexistence: (1) the generation of knowledge and (2) its successful transfer. The latter has been the legitimate driving force behind the tradition of publishing. But printing alone does not lead to a successful implant in the body of knowledge In fact, the more that gets offered in print, the more difficult it becomes for that body to choose the essentials for its growth. Mere quantity of reported data, theories, and concepts does not contribute to the progress of science. It takes a continuing process of sieving, identifying, and formulating the probable key ingredients. In good science, the key concepts, observations, and theories are those that produce the most consistency within the broader experience of the field, as well as within the basic sciences in general. That characterizes the environment, challenge, and task of the editors and authors of a series such as Advances in Catalysis. It is an objective which is not served by the daily stream of publications. Nor is it served by books with subject titles of interest to us, but which are collections of diverse and unconnected symposium papers. Instead, we seek to fill the gap between the papers that “report” and the textbooks that “teach.” We look for the competent sketch of the current state of knowledge that will help us grasp, teach, or use the current “total picture”: its key elements, their meaning and implications, and the associated challenges and remaining inadequacies. Writing our traditional day-to-day publications has a large element of “look what I have done now,” with comments on what it does to the field of knowledge. On the other hand, our authors must first focus on the field of knowledge, with appropriate comments on individual contributions of course Such a task is not easy. There is not enough space to discuss all contributions, and in their choices and analyses authors cannot be infallible predictors of the ultimate truth. If that were the case, the final chapter would have been written, not in a series of Advances, but of Arrivals. We are fortunate to have authors who have dedicated their efforts to ix
X
PREFACE
recording progress. This volume of Advances could well be considered a textbook on the current state of knowledge concerning structure and catalysis of metals and metal oxide particles, old and new. Campbell addresses the basic and broad problems of what the catalytically relevant surface structures of metals are, where we stand in techniques capable of attacking this problem, and what the current state of knowledge is. The focus is on a long-standing, important, and central problem of general investigative methodology and strategy: the “pressure gap” is created by the fact that the best techniques of surface analysis require high-vacuum conditions, while “useful” catalysis is confined to conditions of near ambient or higher pressures. Che and Bennett review the basic question of the influence of particle size on catalytic behavior of metal particles which involves questions of the basic sciences as much as practical considerations of catalyst design and use. There are so many aspects involved that this chapter is a unique resource of information on preparatory techniques, analytical technology, and methods of characterization of these materials, as well as a discussion of the many phenomena, mechanisms, and catalytic effects that deal with the question of the dependence on particle size. Haller and Resasco provide an in-depth examination of another basic phenomenon, the existence and nature of interaction between metals and their oxide supports. Their approach focuses on an exhaustive study of titania as a support. That consideration then becomes a useful and central model from which to view the behavior of other supports. Tejuca, Fierro, and Tascbn review the perovskite class of metal oxides. Many challenging concepts have been associated with these. They called early attention to the relationship of catalytic activity to electronic properties; they have been seen as potential substitutes of platinum; and more recently the discovery of superconductivity has rekindled the interest in the “electronic connection” of oxide catalysts. Smith, Molnir, and Bartbk introduce us to amorphous metal alloys, recent newcomers to the scene of materials science, and catalysis. They offer new variants of metal structures to research and application. The authors point to work (some 90 publications) of only about the last 7 years, to remaining questions, and to potentials barely touched. Reading these topics in the same volume, one discovers existing and potential relationships between them; one experiences some sparks of recognition of further relationships and of matters one might connect to develop new knowledge or innovations. We hope that this is an additional attribute of the role and manner of reporting in Advances.
PAULB. WEISZ
ADVANCES IN CATALYSIS, VOLUME 36
Studies of Model Catalysts with Well-Defined Surfaces Combining Ultrahigh Vacuum Surface Characterization with Medium- and High-pressure Kinetics CHARLES T. CAMPBELL Chemistry Department Indianu University Bloomington, lndiunu 47405
The development over the past two decades of many powerful techniques for surface characterization promised to open the area of heterogeneous catalysis for a more fundamental understanding of the relationships between atomic-level surface structure and catalytic activity. The realization of this promise has been hampered by a “pressure-gap’’ problem: the reactions are generally performed at pressures above - 100 torr, whereas surface analysis is accomplishable only in ultrahigh vacuum. To overcome this problem, many researchers have recently developed equipment that combines ultrahigh vacuum surface analytical instrumentation (AES, XPS, LEED, TDS, ISS, etc.) with a medium- or high-pressure microreactor in a single apparatus, where the catalyst can be transferred between these pressure regimes without intermediate exposure to air or other gases. A “model catalyst” approach has generally been adopted, whereby well-defined surfaces are prepared (usually starting from a single crystal) that are very homogeneous in surface structure and chemical composition. Through comparison of the activity and selectivity of a series of such model catalysts with controlled changes in detailed surface structure, a fundamental understanding of structure-function relationships in the surface chemistry of catalysis is beginning to evolve. The purposes of this paper are to (1) review the apparatus design considerations for experiments of this type, (2) review the results that have been obtained thus far using this model catalyst approach in combined presI Copyright 0 1989 by Academic Press. Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
2
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
sure-vacuum experiments, and (3) discuss the future of this area of research. The results so far have given exciting but not yet completely satisfying insights into many catalytic phenomena including structural sensitivity, surface modification, poisons, alkali promoters, ensemble and electronic effects at bimetallic surfaces, and strong-metal support interactions. I. Introduction
It has long been a goal of the catalytic chemist to fundamentally understand the relationship between the atomic level structure of a catalyst surface and the materials’ performance as a catalyst (Lea,its activity and selectivity). Much beautiful work has been dedicated to this effort, especially since development of modern surface analytical techniques such as the many electron spectroscopies. A major stumbling block to progress in this direction has been the fact that, while our most powerful surface analytical techniques operate only under the pristine conditions of ultrahigh vacuum (UHV), most catalytic reactions of commercial importance occur with measurable rates only at pressures of a few torr and above. Thus, in order to inspect the surface of the working catalyst, one is faced with the problem of decreasing the pressure above the catalyst by some ten orders of magnitude while at the same time maintaining its surface chemical integrity. This is, of course, an impossible task since the weakly adsorbed species (i.e., those with short residence times) are in equilibrium with the gas phase and removed almost as rapidly. Nevertheless, much effort has been devoted to developing techniques that allow for UHV inspection of catalyst surfaces that retain, as well as possible, their high-pressure structural characteristics and thereby “bridge” this “pressure gap.” In 1974 the Somojai group published a pioneering study that combined catalytic kinetic measurements at pressures up to 1 atm with pre- and postreaction surface analysis in UHV in the same apparatus (I). The group soon developed new systems that extended the kinetic regime up to -100 atm. (2, 3). A few years later, the group of Yates et al. had developed and proved a system that allowed a catalyst sample to be transferred relatively rapidly (a few minutes) between a vessel at high-pressure reaction conditions and a UHV chamber for surface analysis (4, 5 ) . At about the same time, the groups of Bonze1 et al. (6, 7) and Polizzotti and Schwarz (8)developed similar systems, each with its own relative advantages. Since then, many applications of these and related systems have been published (see below), and numerous improvements to the original
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
3
designs have appeared (9-12). It is safe to say that this combination of high-pressure reaction kinetics or sample treatment with UHV surface analyses is now a more or less routine method of the surface scientist’s trade, and it is finding its way into many application areas such as corrosion science (1.3-15) and electrochemistry (14-18). A most enlightening utilization of these high-pressure-UHV methods involves what is referred to as the “model catalyst” approach, whereby a surface derived from a clean and well-defined, single-crystal plane is used to model a particular site or set of sites expected to exist on practical highsurface-area catalysts. Commercial catalysts are exceedingly complex materials, the surface analysis of which would undoubtedly lead to clear identification of eight or more different elements and countless structurally distinct surface moieties. The catalytic surface chemist wants to know which of these elements and surface structures are responsible for catalyst activity and selectivity, and how they participate in the catalytic reaction. Therefore, model surface structures of one or several elements are synthesized, usually starting from a polished and well-oriented singlecrystal surface. In doing this, the chemist takes advantage of “preparatory surface chemistry in UHV.” Thus, a model catalyst is created, the surface of which is now extremely homogeneous in a certain structural moiety of interest. This catalyst can then be transferred to the highpressure reaction conditions for kinetic characterization, where the activity and selectivity of the model catalyst are measured. After reaction, the chemist reexamines the surface in UHV to ensure that the structural details that were tuned into the starting material have not changed as a consequence of the reaction, or, if so, to determine exactly what is the structure of the working catalyst surface that has been kinetically characterized. Because the model catalyst is based on a single-crystal surface, the whole arsenal of surface analytical techniques can be brought to bear on these problems, including those techniques that rely on long-range surface order or smoothness. The purpose of the present article is to review the existing literature with respect to model catalyst studies in which attempts have been made to obtain and compare high- or medium-pressure kinetics over well-characterized, homogeneous surfaces. (For the purposes of this article I will define the medium-to-high pressure range as -0.1 torr to -200 atm.) I start with a thorough discussion of the design criteria that should be considered in constructing an apparatus and preparing samples for such studies. I then summarize the results of such studies and show that structure-function relationships in the surface chemistry of catalysis can, indeed, be determined and understood by using this approach. Some attempt has been made here to present a relatively exhaustive bibliography
4
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
of these types of studies, at least of those using model catalysts based on single-crystal surfaces. That is not to say that every article has been included here, and I apologize for any inadvertent omissions. I also should point out that in several cases I have omitted papers for brevity that are reviewed thoroughly in those articles that I do discuss, so that they should be relatively easy for the reader to locate. In this presentation I also attempt to discuss the articles within the more global perspective of this review format, in some cases pointing out contradictions in results or potential problems in interpretation. For most cases, only a few of the major features of a given article are presented. There is a vast amount of information in these articles that I could not cover in the limited space of this review. The reader is encouraged to seek out these articles, for they are rich in results and insightful in discussion. Finally, I conclude by attempting to critically evaluate the field in general, its impact thus far on catalytic concepts, and its potential for fundamental contributions to our understanding in the future. II. Experimental Design Considerations In general, the types of studies to be discussed here utilize a single apparatus that interfaces a microreactor for high-pressure kinetic studies with an ultrahigh vacuum (UHV)chamber for surface analysis and adsorption-desorption studies. In a typical experiment, a model catalyst is prepared by orienting, cutting, and polishing a single-crystalsurface. This sample is then mounted in the UHV chamber and the desired surface structure is prepared by using what can be called “preparatory surface chemistry.” This can include such steps as sputter cleaning with an argon ion beam, high-temperature chemical cleaning, annealing to establish surface order, vapor deposition or chemical vapor deposition of other elements (e.g., oxidation) to modify the surface composition, ion-beam surface modification, and molecular-beam epitaxy . The chemical treatments are sometimes even performed at higher pressures in the microreactor or in an atmospheric load-lock position (e.g., liquid droplets of ultrapure solutions). The surface is then characterized with an array of UHV surface analytical techniques. Typical methods of choice include Auger electron spectroscopy (AES), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), ionscattering spectroscopy (ISS), secondary ion mass spectroscopy (SIMS), high-resolution electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS), and many others. Since the samples usually have smooth single-crystal surfaces, methods such as low-energy electron diffraction (LEED) and other surface crystallographic methods that rely on long-range surface order can
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
5
also be used here. The surface analytical methods themselves will not be discussed here since they have been excellently reviewed elsewhere (1922). Following surface characterization, the sample is enclosed in the microreactor; it is pressurized with ultrapure reactant gases, and a catalytic reaction is initiated by heating the sample to the desired reaction temperature. The rate of the reaction is determined from product buildup versus time by monitoring the composition of the gaseous reaction mixture using gas chromatography, mass spectroscopy, or other methods. After reaction, the sample is again evacuated and the surface is structurally and compositionally analyzed in UHV to determine the characteristics of the working catalyst’s surface. Extreme caution must, of course, be exercised here to ensure that the surface structures observed in postreaction surface analysis are indeed those characteristic of the working catalyst under high-pressure conditions. As noted above, this is, strictly speaking, an impossible task since weakly adsorbed species with short surface residence times (<1 s) are always pumped away almost immediately as the supporting gas phase is removed. However, to assess structure-function relationships in catalysis, it is really those more permanent aspects of the surface structure that are of most interest here. For an alloy catalyst, what is the elemental composition and metal distribution at the surface? For an oxide catalyst, what is the oxidation state or stoichiometry at the working catalyst’s surface? Often, lattice mobility is slow enough at reaction temperature (compared to the transfer time into UHV) that questions such as these can, indeed, be answered. Thus, the concern is not to maintain the adsorbate coverage of all reaction intermediates exactly as they were at high pressures, but only to maintain the surface structural features of the catalytic material itself. One is, therefore, concerned with impurity problems during the transfer into UHV, such as (1) the deposition of impurity elements onto the catalyst surface from background gases, pump oils, or vapors from the vessel walls and (2) the reduction of surface oxides by reactions with background gases such as CO or H2, which are ubiquitous in vacuum technology. Once inside UHV, these problems are well under control and the model catalyst can (in principle) be rapidly cooled to minimize thermally induced changes in the catalyst surface such as, for example, lattice diffusion in an alloy or oxide. It is clear that the best experimental designs for addressing structurefunction relationships in catalysis are those that minimize exposure of the catalyst surface to undesired vapors between high-pressure kinetic measurements and surface analysis. Thus one aims for a system where the transfer to UHV is as rapid and as clean as possible, and where the sample can be cooled as rapidly as possible once inside UHV.
6
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
Very stringent cleanliness requirements are vital within the microreactor itself, for the sample surface must not be violated by foreign contaminants deposited during high-pressure reaction. Thus, to the extent possible, the microreactor and sample transfer device must be constructed of low-surface-area, nonporous, and bakeable materials. It is generally desirable that the microreactor itself be able to achieve UHV with the sample in position. The design should also ensure that, when heating the sample at high-pressure reaction conditions, very little surface area other than the sample itself becomes warm. This minimizes outgassing of contaminants and undesired side reactions and catalytic processes not due to the sample itself. Typical sample mountings are shown in Fig. 1 , where thin (0.010-0.020 in.) heating wires are spot-welded or otherwise attached to the back or sides of the single crystal. The choice of wire depends on the reaction and sample to be studied, but tantalum is often a good inert choice. (Other metals such as tungsten should be chosen if high hydrogen pressures will be used, since Ta embrittles under Hz.) These wires are then attached across two relatively massive electrically insulated conductors which themselves are in good thermal contact with a room-temperature thermal bath, such as an air-cooled transfer rod. When a voltage is externally applied across the conductors, current flows through the heating wires (and the sample) and the wires start to heat. Because the sample is in good thermal contact with these wires, it also becomes hot. A thermocouple spot-welded or otherwise attached to the sample can be used to monitor its temperature, as shown. The thermocouple wires should be thin (0.0030.005 in.) and inert to minimize side reactions on them. The lengths of the heating wires between the points where they contact the sample and the conductors should be -2-3 mm for O.OlO-in.-diameterheating wires. This is long enough to ensure sufficient heating without excessive current (< 35 A) but short enough to ensure that the sample will cool rapidly back toward room temperature when the heating current is removed. In this design, only the sample and the heating wires and a short length of thermocouple wire are heated significantly above room temperature during sample heating in the microreactor. It is also useful to note that, since the mean free path of a typical gas even at 1 torr is only -0.05 mm, the sample is usually surrounded by a thin film of gas that is at the same temperature as the sample under reaction conditions. Thus, all gas-surface collisions can be described by a single temperature, equal to the sample temperature as recorded by the thermocouple. A visual check that the thermocouple is properly attached should be performed periodically during use. According to Davis et al. (23), the threshold temperature for observing visible emission from the sample in a completely dark laboratory is 785 & 10 K
7
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
a CRYSTAL TRANSFER ROD
MODEL
ELECTRICAL FEEDTHROUGH
SLOT FOR WIRES
b
I
5 CM
I
THERMOCOUPLE -5% Re / W-26% Re)
PLE
THERMOCOUPLE FEEDTHROUGH (CERAMASEAL 80780572-1)
MOLYBDENUM SAMPLE HOLDERS
FIG.I . (a) Details of the sample mounting on the transfer rod for resistive heating (via Ta wires) and liquid nitrogen cooling (via conduction down the Cu feedthrough rods). From Ref. 10. (b) Sample head and sample mounting configuration. From Ref. 176.
(at least for metal samples). (This agrees with our experiences for Cu, Ag, and Pt samples.) Care must be exercised in all choices of material. For example, the deposition of Ni onto the model catalyst surface has been observed under reaction conditions when using nickel alloy thermocouples. It is the responsibility of the experimenter to prove that the crystal surface probed by the surface analytical methods truly represents that probed by the high-pressure kinetics. For example, in assessment of structural sensitivity, kinetics on several different single crystals with
8
CHARLES T . CAMPBELL
different surface orientations will be compared. These crystals are typically polished wafers where both faces are of the desired orientation. However, the surface orientations of the edges of these wafers are ill defined and not probed by surface analysis. Similarly, when surface additives are used to modify reactivity, these are typically dosed only to the front surface of the crystal under study. For these reasons, it is generally convenient to somehow passivate the edges and backs of the crystal. In our experience, if the front surface is cleaned by means of Ar+ sputter cleaning and care is taken to ensure that only this face is sputtered, a passivating film of impurities will naturally develop on the remainder of the crystal (by surface segregation and deposition from the gas phase). This can be verified once reproducible kinetics have been established by dosing a poison to the front surface alone and proving that this completely quenches the observed catalytic rate. Depending on the reaction studied, the front surface can be passivated for this background experiment by using a directed sulfur or chlorine doser (24, 25) or vapor-depositing an inert metal overlayer such as Au or Bi onto the front surface. It is important following such a poisoning experiment to show that the original activity of the sample can be readily regenerated by a brief sputter cleaning of the front face of the sample. Another confidence-building test is to restart the high-pressure reaction after surface analysis to ensure that the same rate is again immediately achieved. Another important consideration is the volume and compactness of the microreactor. The reactants and products must be well mixed and at observable concentrations for accurate kinetic measurements. Using a typical gas diffusivity at atmospheric pressure and room temperature D = 0.1 cm2/s, the characteristic diffusion length (0 during t = 100 s is only approximately 3 crn ( I = f i t = 3 cm). Because of convection currents due to sample heating, the actual mixing of products into a batch microreactor is considerably faster than this. Nevertheless, it should not be expected that the products will be efficiently mixed into remote parts of the microreactor that are further than -5 cm from the sample during time periods of less than 100 s. For this reason, the microreactor should be either a compact design, such as in Ref. f0, or include a recirculating mixer, such as in Ref. 2. The mixer and associated tubing should also be designed to avoid impurities or wall reaction problems. For this and several other reasons, we (10) and others (5) have preferred a compact batch reactor design. Self-mixing has always been sufficiently rapid in our experiments ( < I atrn), but it could undoubtedly be problematically slow at very high pressures. We have also considered mounting a small bellows on the side of the microreactor that could be manually pumped periodically to mix the gases.
PRESSURE-VACUUM
ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
9
Single-crystal catalysts are very low in surface area (-1 cm2). For molecules/site/s), the overall amount typical catalytic reaction rates ( of product produced in 100 s is rather small: Product = =
molecules/site/s)( 1015 sites/cm2)(1 cm2)(100 s) lOI5 molecules
If the microreactor is at I-atm pressure and has a volume of 1 liter, this corresponds to only about 40 ppb for detection. Since typical gas chromatographic (GC)detection limits are between 0.1 to 1 ppm, it is advantageous to reduce the microreactor volume by at least a factor of 10 to 100 ml or less. There are some trade-offs here because, as the reactor volume gets smaller, it becomes more difficult to take small-volume aliquots for GC analysis without significantly decreasing the reactor pressure. Similarly, it becomes more difficult with faster reactions to ensure, for example, that you are operating in a region that can be considered the limit of low conversion (i.e., no further reactions or inhibition by the products). However, yet another factor favors a small-volume microreactor. This relates to the purity requirements on reactant gases. At I atm of pressure, a trace impurity at the 0.1-ppm level serves as a potential source for about one full monolayer of impurity on the model catalyst for every 0.33 liter of reactor volume. We have chosen a reactor volume of only -30 ml (101, which greatly diminishes the purity requirements placed on reactants compared to larger designs. In our case, every I-ml aliquot extracted for GC sampling diminishes the reactor pressure by -3%. In practice, the first aliquot must always be discarded due to poor gas mixing in the valve body. In some cases, the microreactor is operated as a continuous flow device ( 6 ) , but this method suffers the same disadvantages as a largevolume batch reactor. Because of the difficulty of building a valving system capable of fully utilizing the gas aliquot extracted for analysis, we have developed a method that we call the carrier gas piston for signal enhancement in GC sampling. This is always useful when the sample pressure is below the GC carrier gas pressure. In such cases, a rapid compression of the reactor aliquot into the GC sampling loop is accomplished immediately prior to injection by using a reservoir of the carrier gas effectively as a piston for driving the gas. Details of the method, which can give increases in sensitivity by factors up to 20, can be found elsewhere (26). Cold fingers for trapping condensable product are also useful in this respect. The means of interfacing the microreactor to the UHV chamber also requires considerable thought, for, as noted above, the transition between high-pressure reaction conditions and UHV must be as rapid and as clean as possible. The two basic designs employed almost exclusively utilize
10
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
either of the following: (1) a movable cup that seals around the sample and its holder in a standard UHV chamber and therefore acts as a highpressure cell (1-3, 12) or (2) a transfer rod on which the sample is mounted for heating and by which the sample can be translated between physically isolated UHV and high-pressure vessels (5-11). Examples of these types of designs that have seen extensive successful use are shown in Figs. 2-4. Any parts of the apparatus that see the high-pressure reac-
-
-CARRIER GAS
1
818 -E I
I
w rn
'L
SS WELDED BELLOWS
1
MANIFOLD
CIRCULATION PUMP
b FIG. 2. (a) Schematic diagram of a one-tier HPLP system with high-pressure cell closed. (b) Detail with high-pressurecell open. (From Ref. 9 . )
FIG.3. Ultrahigh vacuum apparatus for studying single-crystalcatalysts before and after operation at high pressure in catalytic reactor. Position I : crystal is in position for Auger electron spectroscopy study of surface composition or of ultraviolet photoemission spectrum of surface species. Position 2: crystal is in position for deposition of a known coverage of poisons or promoters for a study of their influence on the rate of a catalytic reaction. Position 3: crystal is in position for a study of catalytic reaction rate at elevated pressures ( 5 2 atm). Gas at high pressure may be circulated by using a pump; mass spectrometric-gas chromatographic analysis of the reactants and products is carried out by sampling the catalytic chamber. From Ref. 5 .
B
A SURFACE ANA LY S IS
C MICROREACTOR
FIG.4. Apparatus combining UHV surface analytical chambers (stages A and B) with a microreactor (stage C) capable of high-pressure kinetic measurements on model, low-surface-area ( 1 cm2)catalysts. Rapid (I7 s) transfer of the crystal between the stages is accomplished by a transfer rod on which the sample is mounted. From Ref. 10.
12
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
tion mixture are likely to outgas once inside U H V and cause vacuum problems. One disadvantage of the “pressure cup” design is that the entire surface area of the microreactor is outgassing to UHV. In some “transfer rod” systems, only the sample itself and a small section of transfer rod outgas into U H V following high-pressure reactions (10). Another disadvantage of the “pressure cup” design is the necessity to have the gas handling system and GC sampling system physically separated by some distance from the microreactor itself, because of the presence of the vacuum chamber and surface analysis components surrounding the highpressure cell. This generally has led to the use of a gas recirculating pump in a batch reactor design (2, 9, f2),as shown in Fig. 2. This increases the volume of gas involved and greatly increases the amount of foreign surface area in intimate communication with the sample surface. Both of these factors exacerbate problems with surface cleanliness and reliable product detectability. Another disadvantage related to the greatly increased surface area is that these surfaces tend to outgas once evacuated, and times on the order of 15-30 min are required to achieve U H V following reaction (2, 12). A huge advantage of the “cup” design is that it can easily achieve reactor pressures as high as 120 atm (2, 12), which is critical for some reactions. The transfer-rod designs rely either on a long bellows for rod movement (Fig. 3) or on differentially pumped sliding gaskets that seal on the outer diameter of the rod (Fig. 4; see also Refs. 10 and 11). A great advantage of the bellows design is that it can be entirely constructed of bakeable metal parts. A disadvantage of the bellows design is that this entire bellows contributes to the volume and potential outgassing surface area of the microreactor. Restricted conductance along the surface of the transfer rod between the bellows and the microreactor could potentially eliminate this problem. In this case the bellows system begins to resemble one with sliding seals. Advantages of the sliding seal design are (1) its potential for a low-volume and low-surface-area microreactor and (2) the ability to rotate the sample on the transfer rod to access more analytical probes and even perform angularly resolved surface analyses once inside UHV. In this design, that part of the rod that extends outside the differential pumping stages is usually enshrouded in dry N2 to prevent its contamination during high-pressure reaction. The bellows is usually limited to less than a few atm. maximum reactor pressure. In transfer-rod designs, the sample can either be located at the end of the rod ( 4 , 5 , 8 ) ,or within a cutout in the rod (6, 7, 10, If) as was shown in Fig. I . When located at the end of the rod, an all-metal valve is used to isolate the high-pressure cell from U H V during reaction measurements (4, 5 ) . In this case, the microreactor must be evacuated with a separate pump before opening the valve for transfer back to UHV. Since this pump
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
13
generally joins the microreactor via a relatively small valve (to minimize reactor volume), this evacuation takes some time and sets a lower limit on the time between high pressure and UHV of at least some tens of seconds. For end-mounted sample rods, it is useful to include a section of tubulation between the microreactor and UHV that is only slightly larger than the rod diameter so that a conduction limitation is established to minimize outgassing from the microreactor into the UHV chamber when the rod tip is in UHV. When the sample is mounted in a cutout on the transfer rod as in Fig. 1 , differentially pumped sliding seals are used to isolate the high-pressure cell from UHV. Typically, two stages of differential pumping allow for reactor pressures up to 10 atm with no significant change in the UHV base pressure (10). More stages can be added to increase the maximum reaction pressure. A distinct disadvantage of the sliding seals is that the reaction gas slowly bleeds off through the seals. In a typical design where the reactor volume is only 30 ml, the reactor pressure decreases by -5% for every 5 min of reaction time (10). The time scale can be expanded proportional to the reactor volume, or a large ballast volume of reactants can be attached to the microreactor to maintain constant pressure. This ballast volume need not contribute greatly to problems generally associated with large-volume reactors (such as stringent gas purity and lower product concentrations), since it can be diffusionally isolated from the microreactor. It is straightforward to correct for the influence of product bleed-off in calculating reaction rates from the measurements of product concentration versus time. A ballast volume also eliminates the problem of decreasing reactor pressure due to GC sampling, mentioned above. A great advantage of this “sample cutout” design is that, once inside UHV, only a small portion of the sample transfer rod is outgassing because it experienced the high-pressure reaction mixture. For this reason, UHV can be achieved extremely rapidly following high-pressure reaction. One such system (10) has proved to achieve UHV (< torr and rapidly dropping) within 17 s after reaction at 1 atm of total pressure. We have proposed one design that should be capable of achieving UHV within -1 s following reaction (27). For the transfer of powdered catalysts, systems already exist that allow evacuation from high-pressure, high-temperature reaction conditions down to UHV in fractions of a second (28). It should be emphasized that transfer times on the order of 51 s are a very important goal, since typical turnover frequencies for a catalytic reaction are 10-3-1 molecule/site/s. Thus, transfer times are now potentially achievable that are a small fraction of the average time it takes a site to produce a product molecule. If the rate of reaction is limited by the conversion of some surface intermediate, then rapid transfer has the potential for capturing that intermediate for postreaction analysis.
14
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
Undoubtedly, the future will see cleaner and cleaner transfer systems that are designed to maintain as much surface structural integrity as possible during evacuation from process conditions. With these advances, our ability to make definitive assessments of structure-function relationships in catalysis will certainly improve. At the same time, we should see many new developments of in situ surface analytical methods that allow inspection of the catalyst surface while actually in the high-pressure reaction environment. Recent applications of reflection-absorption Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) (29) and extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) methods (30-32) show that this is already beginning to occur. Such in situ techniques will eventually render high-pressure-UHV transfer methods obsolete. However, the present author strongly doubts that broad-based in situ surface analytical methods will be developed so soon that the transfer techniques described above will not hold a very important place in the science of catalysis and many other surface-related technologies. One of the important advantages of the model catalyst approach is that the changes in catalyst activity and selectivity with surface structure or composition can be correlated with the influences of these surface modifications on the rates of some of the individual steps in the reaction mechanism. The adsorption kinetics of the reactants and products are typically probed in UHV by measuring surface coverage versus exposure. The reactant and product desorption kinetics are generally determined by using thermal desorption mass spectroscopy (TDS) or some measurement of surface coverage versus temperature (thermal conversion spectroscopy). The power of TDS and thermal conversion spectroscopy for determining detailed kinetic parameters of desorption and other elementary surface reactions has been carefully reviewed elsewhere (33-36). Sometimes, the kinetics of the formation or removal of some adsorbed intermediate can even be determined by timed exposures at higher pressures in the microreactor. Correlating changes in the overall reaction kinetics that are due to surface structural changes with changes in the rates of elementary reaction steps can give key insight into the rate-determining step in the catalytic process, the reaction mechanism, and the role of the various surface structural moieties in converting the reactants to products. 111.
Elucidation of Structure-Function Relationships in Catalysis
Over the past 10 years, a number of groups have become active in applying these experimental techniques to clarify the relationships between atomic-level surface structural-compositional properties and the
PRESSURE-VACUUM
ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
15
activity or selectivity of that surface for a particular catalytic reaction. In this section, we will review the results of those studies and highlight particularly illustrative examples of how they have provided unique information regarding the microscopic details of catalytic processes. A. STRUCTURAL SENSITIVITY: THEDEPENDENCE OF CATALYTIC ACTIVITY A N D SELECTIVITY ON CRYSTAL-SURFACE ORIENTATION It has long been known that catalytic reaction rates and selectivity can depend sensitively on the size of catalyst particles (37-39). Such “structural sensitivity” has generally been explained by models whereby the activity or selectivity of the reaction was assumed to vary markedly with the local geometry of the surface sites. Using the methods outlined above, it has now been unequivocally proved that, indeed, many steady-state high-pressure catalytic reactions depend sensitively on the crystal-surface orientation of the model catalysts, and that others do not. This subject has been recently reviewed by Boudart (40), who points out the potential utility of single-crystal surfaces as standards against which to compare industrial catalysts. One of the earliest reported attempts to determine the structural sensitivity of catalytic reactions over single-crystal surfaces at medium pressures was an investigation of the selective oxidation of ethylene over several different Ag single-crystal surfaces by Kummer in 1956 (41). His studies were not supported by surface analysis as in modern systems, so the state of cleanliness and crystal orientation of the sample surfaces could not be verified. A few years later, Wilson et al. (42) extended this experiment to include postreaction analysis of the silver “surfaces” using (high-energy) electron diffraction. This experiment was a true precursor to the modern approach that combines reaction rate measurements with surface analysis. The samples started out as oriented silver films, but after reaction no preferential orientation remained. Many years later, Campbell (43) repeated these types of experiments with bulk single crystals of silver and the added advantage of a surface analytical chamber attached directly to the medium-pressure catalytic reactor. The results proved that oriented Ag crystal surfaces could be maintained under reaction and showed that no strong structural sensitivity existed for this reaction. The latter conclusion was also suggested by Kummer’s original study (41), but his specific activities (rates of reaction per surface Ag atom) were significantly below those obtained on the verifiably clean Ag surfaces by Campbell (43, 44). This suggests that Kummer’s surfaces may have been largely poisoned by surface impurities. Results on high-surface-areaAg catalysts have some-
16
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
times indicated structural sensitivity for this reaction. These results, together with the recent single-crystal results, have been critically reviewed by Sajkowski and Boudart (451, who conclude that, indeed, this is a structurally insensitive reaction. This reaction further illustrates one of the advantages and one of the potential pitfalls of the pressure transfer-model catalyst approach. As noted above, Campbell found that Ag( 110) and Ag( 1 11) displayed very similar kinetics and selectivity for the epoxidation of ethylene even when the reaction was clearly rate-limited by oxygen supply. Yet, at reaction temperature, the Ag(ll0) surface was some 50-fold more active than Ag( 11 1) in the dissociative adsorption of 0 2 to form oxygen adatoms (at least for coverages below 00 = 0.5, which was the saturation coverage achievable in the UHV adsorption experiments). From this lack of correlation, he concluded that molecularly adsorbed O2 (rather than oxygen adatoms) must be the actual oxidizing agent involved in both ethylene epoxide and CO2 production (43). Recent isotopic tracer evidence supporting a mechanism involving atomically adsorbed oxygen (46, 47) suggests that the surface reaction may be occurring on oxygen islands of very high local coverage (0, > 0.5), where the activity differences between Ag(ll0) and Ag( 11 1) for 0-0 bond cleavage may not exist (45, 48). Because of their higher reactivity with background gases during transfer to UHV (49), these very high coverage oxygen states were possibly not maintained for postreaction surface analysis. This highlights the need for improved transfer methods in order to maintain truer surface integrity during evacuation. 1. Hydrocarbon Conversion Reactions over Pt
An early champion of the single-crystalapproach to studying structural sensitivity in catalysis was Gabor Somoqai, who, together with his group, has performed numerous comparative studies of hydrocarbon conversion reactions over different oriented Pt single-crystal surfaces (49-53; see also refs. cited below). The 1974 study of the hydrogenolysis of cyclopropane over a stepped Pt single crystal by Kahn et al. ( I ) was the first application of a combined atmospheric-pressure reactor with a UHV surface-analysis chamber for addressing the structural sensitivity of a catalytic reaction. In that case, a favorable comparison of the reaction kinetics with those from supported Pt catalysts suggested that this reaction was relatively insensitive to surface geometric structure. An excellent example of marked structural sensitivity in hydrocarbon conversion reactions is shown in Fig. 5, which compares the accumulation of benzene versus time in a reaction mixture of 20 tom of n-hexane and 200 torr of H2 over
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
0
30 60 90 120 Reoction Time (minutes)
17
150
FIG.5 . Product accumulation curves measured as a function of reaction time at 573 K for n-hexane aromatization catalyzed over platinum single-crystal surfaces. (0).Pt( 10,8.7); (O), Pt(ll1); (A),Pt(100); (A),Pt(l3,l,l). HJHC = 10. P,,, = 220 torr. From Ref. 54.
four different Pt faces at 573 K (54). As can be seen, the rate of benzene production increased in the order (10,8,7) < (111) < (100) = (13,1,1). Other important processes occurring in this reaction mixture included cyclization to methylcyclopentene, hydrogenolysis to lower alkanes and isomerization to 2- and 3-methylpentane. These processes showed little structural sensitivity, consistent with the conclusion based on studies over supported Pt catalysts (54). Interestingly, the overall initial rates of n-hexane skeletal rearrangement over Pt single crystals was about 10-fold faster than initial rates for the same reaction over powdered and supported Pt catalysts (54). This may be due to the greater degree of surface cleanliness of the starting catalyst in the case of the single-crystal studies, where surface cleanliness was directly verified. The structural sensitivity in aromatization was even more pronounced in reactions with n-heptane and H2 over Pt crystals, where the Pt(557) surface was some sevenfold more active than Pt(ll1) in toluene production (53,55). The rate was maximized on surfaces where there are atomic steps separated by flat, five-atom-wide hexagonal terraces (53,55). Since the isomerization of n-alkenes (six carbon atoms or longer) is believed to involve a methylcyclopentane (MCP)intermediate in C6 iso-
18
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
mer production, Zaera et al. studied the reactions of MCP over four Pt crystal surfaces (56). In contrast to results on supported Pt catalysts, aromatization was much slower than that with the use of n-hexane as a reactant. The authors concluded that Pt alone cannot catalyze the ring expansion of MCP. Dauscher et al. (57) followed up these studies with a detailed comparison of the reactions of 2-methylpentane, n-hexane, and methylcyclopentane with Hz over several Pt crystal surfaces, a polycrystalline Pt foil, and two PtlAltO, catalysts. These studies involved the use of '3C-labeled methylpentanes to track its reaction mechanism. The authors concluded that the Bs site configuration is responsible for bond-shift isomerization mechanisms and cracking reactions, and that kink and step sites are necessary for cyclic isomerization mechanisms. Garin et al. (58) also compared the contact reactions of C,j hydrocarbons over several Pt single crystals, foils, and supported catalysts. They found that isomerization by bond-shift or cyclic mechanisms and hydrogenolysis over crystalline Pt surfaces simulate well data for supported Pt of large Pt cluster size, and that isomerization by bond shift is more important when the surface is stepped. Davis et al. (2.3) also studied the isomerization and hydrogenolysis of isobutane, n-butane, and neopentane over flat, stepped, and kinked Pt single-crystal surfaces. The rates and selectivities of butane isomerization and consecutive rearrangements were maximized on (100) portions of the surfaces. Competing hydrogenolysis reactions were most rapid on surfaces containing the greatest step- and kink-site densities. The dehydrogenation and hydrogenolysis of cyclohexane has been compared over several Pt single-crystal surfaces by Herz et al. (59). By far the major product was benzene, with minor amounts of cyclohexene, n-hexane, and alkanes of less than six carbon atoms. The activity for benzene production increased by -3.5-fold in the order (1 11) < (557)< (10,8,7) < (25,10,7),whereas the strength of benzene inhibition increased in the opposite order. This suggests that the variation in activity may be related only to the ability of the specific surface to maintain active Pt sites for the reaction. Indeed, even on Pt( 11 I), adsorbed benzene is produced well below room temperature with high probability (>67%) from adsorbed cyclohexane if the surface is kept free of contaminants and other adsorbed species that block Pt sites necessary for hydrogen abstraction (60). The mechanism of benzene production from cyclohexane on Pt(ll1) is now fairly well understood, as is the ensemble requirement for this reaction (60). Other mechanisms may be important on Pt catalysts containing step and/or kink sites, or support surfaces. It is interesting to point out that significant inverse kinetic isotope effects (RDIRH= 1.3-3.3) for the initial rates of a number of alkane conver-
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
19
sion reactions have been observed by Davis et al. ( 6 0 , where the unlabeled hydrocarbon was reacted in the presence of H2 or D2 gas over a variety of Pt surfaces. They attributed this to the fact that the coverage of atomically absorbed deuterium should be lower than that of hydrogen under identical reaction conditions, and that the deuterium would block fewer Pt sites and therefore inhibit the reaction less severely than hydrogen. In the case of Dz gas, the products were extensively deuterated, which suggests that the adsorbed intermediates were also largely deuterated. Given the recent observations of strong normal isotope effects (RHI RD = 4-15) in C-H bond cleavage steps on Pt surfaces (60, 62), the inverse kinetic isotope effect in the overall catalytic reaction might instead be due to a lower extent of dehydrogenation in the adsorbed hydrocarbon layer when deuterated. Since severely dehydrogenated hydrocarbons are known to irreversibly poison Pt surfaces (52, 6.9, deuterated hydrocarbons should show a lower degree of poisoning of surface sites by carbonaceous residue. Since the overall rate of reactant conversion is positive-order with respect to H2 pressure (61),the original explanation based on inhibition of the reactions by adsorbed hydrogen (or deuterium) seems less satisfactory than a model where the main species poisoning the reaction is partially dehydrogenated hydrocarbon residue. Very high coverages of such residue are generally observed in surface analysis following hydrocarbon reactions over Pt (63). The reaction rates for hydrocarbon conversion on Pt generally decrease with reaction time, and this has been correlated with the deposition of irreversibly adsorbed carbonaceous species (55, 63). The reactions of hydrogen and cyclohexene over Pt single crystals have been studied by Davis and Somorjai (64)over ten orders of magnitude in pressure. Although benzene was the major product in vacuum conditions, when the reactions were carried out near atmospheric pressure, mainly cyclohexane was obtained. This higher pressure reaction was structurally insensitive, which was attributed to the presence of a near monolayer of carbonaceous species. Massardier et al. (65) studied the competition between hydrogenation of benzene versus toluene over several Pt crystal surfaces and compared the results to those of high-area Pt catalysts. The hydrogenation of ethylene to ethane has also been studied over Pt single crystals by the Somorjai group (66).This reaction was found to be structurally insensitive as well, a fact that again was attributed to the presence of a monolayer of carbonaceous fragments under the high-pressure reaction conditions. In this case, there is strong evidence that most of these fragments are adsorbed ethylidyne species (=C-CHd. On the basis of measurements made in the presence of D2 gas, the authors pro-
20
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
posed a reaction mechanism whereby the ethylidyne species serve as a deuterium transfer agent between the Pt surface (which cleaves the D-D bond) and ethylene molecules that are adsorbed uboue the ethylidyne adlayer. Radiotracer studies with I4C showed that the ethylidyne species are readily hydrogenated and removed from the surface at atmospheric hydrogen pressure and temperatures above 350 K, but this reaction occurs much more slowly than does ethylene hydrogenation under similar conditions (66). Similar studies (67,68) of the hydrogenation of ethylidyne on Rh( 111) and H / D exchange over well-defined ethylidyne adlayers suggest that the reaction on rhodium surfaces is very similar. Very high coverages of strongly adsorbed carbonaceous deposits are a ubiquitous occurrence in high-pressure hydrocarbon conversion reactions over Pt. The uncovered-site concentration (measured by postreaction CO adsorption-TDS) has been correlated with the total surface carbon coverage (as measured by AES) (6.3, which, in turn, has been correlated with the catalytic activity and selectivity for several reactions (55, 63). The major roles of the deposit are as a nonselective site-blocking agent and as a pool for the storage and rapid exchange of surface hydrogen (63). The ease or reversibility with which these deposits can be removed from the surface decreases with increasing temperature of their deposition or treatment and increases with their H/C atomic ratio (63). Given the constant presence of these carbonaceous deposits, it is somewhat surprising that any structural sensitivity is ever seen in hydrocarbon catalysis over Pt. The fact that some is seen is probably related to the fact that the underlying Pt structure controls the structure of this adlayer and the concentration of the few free sites found within this adlayer, which, in turn, can control the catalytic reaction rates. It is useful in this respect to point out that reaction probabilities (per collision of hydrocarbon molecule with the surface) are many orders of magnitude lower at high-pressure reaction conditions than in UHV where the surface is partially clean (64).Therefore, only a tiny (immeasurably small) fraction of free Pt sites are necessary to explain the overall observed rates of catalysis at high pressures. Oudar et ul. (69) studied the hydrogenation of butadiene over Pt( I lo), paying special attention to the mechanism of carbon deposition that deactivates the surface. At high hydrogen pressures the rate was first-order in H2 and zero-order in butadiene, but at low HZpressures the rate became second-order in H2. For high H2, they argued that the surface was covered with one butadiene molecule per two surface Pt atoms and that the sites for butadiene adsorption are different from those for H2 dissociation. At low H 2 , the sites for H2 dissociation were said to be poisoned by an additional hydrocarbon species. Above a critical temperature, irreversible
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
21
deactivation by carbon occurs. This latter was attributed to a simple siteblocking effect, since the rates of both butadiene hydrogenation and H2/ D2exchange were proportional to the remaining carbon-free area, and the activation energy was unchanged.
2. Hydrocarbon Conversion over Other Metals Goodman has compared the hydrogenolysis of ethane, cyclopropane, and butane over Ni( 100) and Ni( 1 11) (70-73). At similar pressure conditions (H2 = 100 torr, C2H6 = 1 torr) the Ni(100) surface is considerably more active and has a lower overall activation energy then Ni(ll1) for methane production from ethane (25 versus 46 kcal/mol) (72).The steadystate kinetics for Ni( 1 11) compare favorably with those for SiO2-supported Ni catalysts, which suggests that Ni(ll1) facets dominate on the supported catalyst surfaces. Indeed, this is the most thermodynamically stable facet (in vacuum, at least). The hydrogenolysis of cyclopropane to methane, propane, and ethane also proceeds much faster on Ni(100) than on Ni(ll1) (73),as can be seen in Fig. 6 by the much lower temperatures required for comparable rates on Ni( 100). The hydrogenolysis of butane to methane occurs far more rapidly over Ni(100) than over Ni(l1 l), although in this case the activation energies may be very similar (70, 71).At low temperatures (400K)large amounts of propane and ethane are also produced. Interestingly, the absolute rate and apparent activation energy for hydrogenolysis of butane to methane over Ni( 100) was very similar to that of ethane hydrogenolysis and CO methanation (70).This indicated a common rate-determining step for all three methane production reactions. This step was thought to be removal of surface carbide (or a partially dehydrogenated adsorbed methane precursor) by hydrogenation with H2 (70). Also consistent with this picture is the fact that alkane dissociation proceeds on clean Ni(100) with rates that are one to two orders of magnitude faster than the steady-state rate of their hydrogenolysis (74).These catalytic reactions proceed with steady-state rates on Ni surfaces with the buildup of only submonolayer quantities of carbonaceous residue (70, 72) and were not slowly poisoned by carbon buildup as frequently occurs for Pt (see above). Engstrom et al. (75-78) have compared the reactions of several small hydrocarbons with H2 over different single-crystal surfaces of iridium. For ethane, propane, n-butane, and neopentane, the dominant reaction pathway on both Ir( 111) and Ir( 1 10)-(1 x 2) was cleavage of a single C-C bond, except for the case of n-butane or Ir(ll1) (77). The major reaction channels involved demethylization of the parent hydrocarbon, except for butane on Ir( 1lo)-( 1 X 2), which made mostly ethane (75).This
22
CHARLES T . CAMPBELL 1.o
-
A
I
u)
i k
d 6F
10’’
8 LL
10-1
1 I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
1.7
1.8
1.9
2.0
2.1
2.2
2.9
2.4
2.5
TEMPERATURE (I/K
x lo3
FIG.6. Product formation from the reaction of cyclopropane with hydrogen over a Ni(l1l) surface (open symbols) and a Ni(100) surface (filled symbols) (total pressure = 100 tom; H2/cyclopropane = 100). (0, O), Methane; (A, A), propane; ( 0 ,H), ethane. From Ref. 73.
production of ethane was attributed to the stabilization of a special intermediate, suggested to be a metallacycle pentane, by the low-coordination C, sites present on Ir( 110) but not found on Ir(ll1). This structural sensitivity in ethane selectivity correlates well with results for supported Ir catalysts, where the selectivity increases markedly with decreasing average size in the supported Ir particles (75). At low temperatures, ethane hydrogenolysis proceeds much more rapidly on Ir( 1 1 1) than on Ir( 110)( 1 x 2), but both propane and neopentane gave comparable rates on these surfaces (77). The activation energies vary depending on the temperature and the surface structure, so distinct activity comparisons do not hold over the whole range of reaction conditions. A full analysis of the kinetic
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
23
dependencies on temperature and reactant partial pressures has been performed, and the mechanistic implications have been discussed (77). The reaction of cyclopropane and hydrogen over Ir gave both hydrogenation to propane and hydrogenolysis to methane and ethane, with the former dominating below 500 K (78). For both products, the Ir(ll0)(1 x 2) surface was more active by a factor of -3.5 than Ir(ll1) (78). Again, this difference was attributed to the presence of C7sites on Ir(l10). The hydrogenation of methylcyclopropane on both surfaces was dominated by production of n-butane, although a pathway for isobutate production was also competitive at low temperatures and had a much lower activation energy. The Ir( 1 lo)-( 1 x 2) surface has a greater activity for hydrogenation of propylene, and generally superior hydrogenation capability, than does Ir( 1 11). This finding was correlated with the presence of higher adsorption energy states for Ha on the former surface, which suggests a higher hydrogen coverage under reaction conditions (78). As with Ni, steady-state reaction rates for these hydrocarbon reactions were achieved over Ir single crystals with the buildup of only submonolayer quantities of carbon (& < 0.5) (77, 78). Wax et al. have studied the hydrogenolysis of ethane over W(100) (79). This surface is itself not active in this reaction until a monolayer of surface carbide is formed, after which an active and very stable model catalyst results. In general, the activity of cleaned metal single crystals for this reaction increased in the order W < Ni < Ru < Ir at the same conditions (573 K, 1 torr ethane, 100 torr H2)(72, 75, 79, 80). The cyclotrimerization of acetylene to benzene has been studied by Rucker et al. (81) over Pd( 11I), (loo), and (1 10) at pressure near 1 atm. The (1 10) surface was four-fold less active than Pd(ll1) or (loo), which contrasts with their relative selectivities during TDS under UHV conditions. The activity at high pressures was correlated with the fraction of the various surfaces that exposed clean Pd atoms, as probed by postreaction CO adsorption-desorption. In all cases, most of the surface was covered with a carbonaceous residue. The authors stated that the reaction rate is first-order in acetylene pressure for all three surfaces. The extensive data on the Pd(ll1) surface clearly indicate first-order kinetics in that case. However, the limited data presented for Pd(ll0) seem (to the present author) to be better fitted by an order of -2.5, which is closer to the value of three suggested by the overall stoichiometry. The structure of carbonaceous deposits formed from medium pressure exposure of ethylene between 325 and 800 K have been compared for initially clean surfaces of Ir, Pt, and Rh by Niemantsverdriet and van Langeveld (82) using SIMS and AES. On all surfaces, the hydrogen con-
24
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
tent (H :C ratio) decreased with increasing reaction temperature. The hydrogen content also decreased in the order Ir > Pt > Rh. The deposits were, however, most graphitic in nature on Pt surfaces. The authors point out that the tendency of Pt to graphitize carbon may explain the relatively low hydrogenolysis activity of Pt. 3 . Ammonia Synthesis (N2
+ 3H2 --* 2NH3)
The synthesis of ammonia over both Fe and Re single-crystal surfaces has been studied by the Somorjai group and found to be extremely structural sensitive (83-85). The activity of iron increases in the order (1 10) 4 (210) = (100) 4 (221) = (1 1 1) (83,84).Because dissociative N2adsorption is thought to be the rate-determining step, this order has been correlated (83) with increasing relative activity and decreasing activation energy for dissociative N2 adsorption, as measured by the Ertl group (86, 87, 136). They attributed the higher activity of the more open crystal planes to the more aggressive behavior of low-coordinated Fe atoms. However, Strongin et al. (84) attribute the high activity of very open Fe(ll1) and (211) surfaces to their exposure of highly coordinated C7 sites at the surface for chemisorptive bond formation. As shown in Fig. 7, Re surfaces showed amazing structural sensitivity in this reaction, with relative activitiesof(0001):(10~0):(11~0):(11~1) = 1 :94:920:2820(85). That is, the specific activity increases dramatically as the atomic roughness or openness of the surfaces increases. Again, this catalytic activity correlates well with the ability of the surface for dissociative N2 chemisorption, which is thought to be the rate-determining step (88). Strongin et al. (84) argue that the surface roughness is important only to the extent that it can again expose highly coordinated surface atoms (C,, and C ~inOFig. 7) that are present in the second and third layers. They support this argument with theoretical calculations by Falicov and Somorjai (89) (which do not consider steric hindrance). 4.
Carbon Monoxide Oxidation (CO + b Reduction (NO + CO + C02 + #N2)
0 2 4
C02) and Nitric Oxide
The oxidation of CO by either O2or NO was studied by Peden et al. and Oh et al. over Rh, Pd, Pt,and Ir single crystals (90-92). The CO + 0 2 reaction was relatively insensitive to the atomic structure of the surface, and the specific activities and kinetic parameters agreed for both crystal surfaces and for alumina-supported catalysts. The Rh surfaces deactivated at high 0 2 pressures due to the formation of a near-surface oxide (91, 92). On the other hand, the CO + NO reaction was very sensitive to
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
TF
C6(SOLID)
I4
25
C, (SOLID)
C,o(DOT TED)
f 9
I
I
FIG.7. Structure sensitivity in the ammonia synthesis over rhenium single-crystal faces. The turnover frequencies (TF) are given as NH, molecules/cm2/s (PtOtd= 20 atm, H2 : N2 = 3 : 1, TcWstd = 870 K).Schematics of the atomic structure of each surface are given above each bar. From Ref. 85.
surface geometry (90).A mechanism and kinetic model for these reactions has been successfully developed that quantitatively fits the medium-pressure kinetic data, but that was parameterized using the results of UHV adsorption/desorption kinetic studies (92). This contrasts with an earlier kinetic study of the NO + CO reaction over Rh(100) by Hendershot and Hansen ( 9 3 , who modeled their data with a somewhat different mechanism that included adjustable kinetic parameters. It is difficult to directly compare their actual data with that of Peden et al. (90) because of differences in the reactant pressures and temperatures used.
26
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
The CO + 0 2 reaction also appears to be structurally insensitive over Ru, since kinetic data for Ru(0001) and silica-supported Ru are fairly similar (94). The highest activity occurs when the Ru is covered with a monolayer of oxygen. Since the reaction is, instead, inhibited by an oxygen-covered surface for the case of Rh, the higher activity of Ru compared to Rh at medium-pressure conditions could be explained (94). The oscillatory kinetics of CO oxidation over Pt single crystals has been studied at atmospheric pressure by Yeates et al. (95). They present a model to explain rate oscillations that relies on the oscillatory formation of surface platinum oxide, which was observed in postreaction analysis and was related to the presence of silicon impurity.
5 . Hydrogenation of CO The methanation reaction (3H2 + CO --$ CH4 + H2O) has been thoroughly studied by Goodman and co-workers (4,5, 71,96) over Ni single crystals. Since the specific rates, activation energies, and pressure dependencies are very similar over Ni( loo), Ni( 1 1 l), and A1203-supportedNi, the reaction is structure insensitive (71,96). Transient kinetic studies at medium pressures combined with postreaction AES analysis on Ni( 100) have identified a carbidic form of adsorbed carbon as the reaction intermediate, and graphitic carbon as a poison formed at higher temperatures (71,96). The hydrogenation of CO was studied by Castner et al. over Rh( 1 1 1 ) and polycrystalline Rh foils at 6-atm pressure (97). These model catalysts produced mainly (90%) methane and showed similar specific rates, again suggesting a lack of structural sensitivity. When the Rh surface was oxidized, the initial rates were much larger, the activation energy changed, and the selectivity increased for heavier hydrocarbons and oxygenated products such as methanol, ethanol, and acetaldehyde. Logan et al. compared C O hydrogenation over Mo(100) and polycrystalline Mo foil, which gave similar rates and, therefore, apparent structural insensitivity (98). Here, the major product was methane, but ethene and propene were also significant products. The hydrogenation of CO was observed by Udovic et al. (99) and Szuromi et al. (ZOO) to proceed readily over W(llo), with methane as the dominant product at steady state. The surface was covered with a monolayer of carbidic carbon under reaction conditions, as well as some surface oxygen. The activation energy for methanation over W( 110) was only about half that seen for Ni surfaces. The synthesis of methanol from CO and H2 has been studied over Pd( 110) at medium pressures (500-1800 torr) by Berlowitz and Goodman
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
27
(101). The (extrapolated) specific rates and activation energy agree well with results for Pd dispersed on noninteracting supports such as Si02and some basic supports such as ZnO and MgO. Palladium on highly interactive and acidic supports such as zeolite, alumina, or lanthana give rates and selectivities (i.e., significant dimethyl ether production) substantially different from those of Pd(l10). The synthesis of methanol from CO(+CO2) and H2 was also attempted by Campbell and co-workers (102) over a Cu(ll1) surface and over welldefined Cu overlayers on a ZnO(OO0i) single-crystal surface. They could set an upper limit of < 2 x 1OI2 molecules/cm2/son the methanol production rate at temperatures up to 600 K and pressures up to 1500 torr. These limits are consistent with expectations based on (extrapolated) kinetics for high-surface-area Cu/ZnO catalysts. Their results also showed that C02 has extremely low reactivity for oxidation of the clean Cu(ll1) surface (102), and they argue that it is very unlikely that significant oxygen concentrations exist on the Cu(1 1 1)-like surfaces of practical catalysts under methanol synthesis conditions (102, 103).
6 . Other Reactions Thiophene HDS Activities have been reported by Bussell et al. over three low Miller index single-crystal surfaces of Mo and four of Re (104106). The reaction over Mo was insensitive to the surface structure. The Re(0001) surface showed about the same activity as the Mo surfaces, but Re( 1121) was twice as active, and the (1 120) and (lOi0) surfaces were approximately sixfold more active (106). While Mo surfaces were covered with a near monolayer of partially hydrogenated carbon after reaction, the Re was not moderated by a carbon overlayer. The product distribution over Mo(100) was similar to that reported for powder MoS2 catalysts, although the single-crystal surface of pure Mo was much more active (104). Measurements of the rate of hydrogenation of 35Son Mo( 100) suggest that sulfur adatoms are not intermediates in thiophene HDS (104). The water-gas shift reaction (CO + H20 + C02 + H2) has been studied in detail over a Cu( 111) surface at pressures up to 15 torr CO and 200 torr HzO by Campbell and co-workers (26). The specific activity, activation energy, and reaction orders are very similar to those extrapolated from kinetics at somewhat higher pressures over Cu/ZnO and Cu/ZnO/A1203 catalysts. Similarly, doping of the Cu(ll1) surface with ZnO, had no distinct effect on the observed activity. These results suggested that there is no specific Cu-ZnO interaction necessary for an active water-gas shift catalyst, the essential ingredient of which is metallic Cu suiface. Kinetic analysis using kinetic parameters obtained from both UHV and medium-
28
CHARLES T . CAMPBELL
pressure adsorption-desorption experiments indicated that the rate-determining step was the dissociative adsorption of water. Since there is significant structural sensitivity for this step (lo?'), the catalytic activity may depend on crystal orientation. A word of caution should be remembered concerning the general concept of structural sensitivity for catalytic reactions, since this can depend in some cases on the reaction conditions chosen. This is because, as the temperature or reactant pressures are changed, the rate-determining step can change from one that is structurally sensitive to one that is not. Similarly, optimum practical catalytic conditions are often not those where a single elementary step is rate-determining, but where a delicate balance of kinetic competition exists between steps in the mechanism. Thus, global interpretation of the above results should be used only with caution and proper qualification.
B. THEROLEOF CATALYST ADDITIVES: SURFACE MODIFICATION Another major contribution of the pressure-transfer-model-catalyst studies has been to clarify the role of catalyst additives and impurities in controlling catalytic activity and selectivity. Particularly important here has been the controlled study of the influence of surface chemical modification on the medium- or high-pressure reaction kinetics. Typically, the kinetics are followed as a function of the surface coverage of an added element or complex, and the changes in global kinetics are then correlated with the influence of the additive on the rates of individual steps in the reaction mechanism. This type of data has been found to be extremely useful in identifying the rate-determining step and in clarifying the role of surface modifiers such as poisons or promoters, or the presence of a second metal in bimetallic or alloy catalysts. (The subject of bimetallic catalysts will be discussed in a following section, as will metal-support interactions.) 1.
Electronegative and Electroneutral Elements as Additives
With a few exceptions, electronegative elements have been observed to inhibit the reaction rates of catalyzed reactions when added to well-defined transition-metal surfaces. The mechanism of this poisoning, however, can vary from a simple, steric site-blocking effect to a longer range, electronic interaction acting either through the orbitals of the metal surface or through space. Sometimes selective poisoning of one competing reaction in a branching mechanism can actually lead to a desirable increase in selectivity.
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
SULFUR ON "100) AT 0.25 MONOLAYERS
1
29
SULFUR ON Ni(100 AT 0.5 MONOLAYERS
\
P
10
!i
E 10'
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
i
ADATOM COVERAGE IN MONOLAYERS
FIG.8. Rate of the methanation reaction (CO + 3H2 -+ CH4 + HzO) as a function of sulfur (0) and phosphorus (0)coverage on a Ni(100) surface (pressure = 120 tom, H2: CO = 4 : 1 , reaction temperature = 600 K). From Ref. 71. Reprinted with permission from Acc. Chem. Res. 17, 194. Copyright 1984 American Chemical Society.
The influence of sulfur or phosphorous addition on the catalytic activity of a Ni(100) surface in CO methanation has been thoroughly studied by Goodman and co-workers (71, 96, 108). As shown in Fig. 8, the rate decays very nonlinearly with the coverage of S or P. The initial slope of the curve for sulfur has been interpreted to suggest that 210 Ni surface sites are deactivated by each sulfur adatom (108).Phosphorous, which is slightly larger but considerably less electronegative than sulfur, poisons the rate much less rapidly than sulfur, so the authors concluded that longrange electronic effects were playing the dominant role in catalyst poisoning here. According to their model, a phosphorous adatom sits in a fourfold hollow site and poisons only its four nearest neighbors, while the more electronegative sulfur adsorption leads to deactivation also in the second shell of neighboring Ni atoms. This model relies on LEED studies which suggests that both sulfur and phosphorous spread uniformly over
30
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
the surface in the low-coverage range (80,109). Interestingly, sulfur addition did not alter the activation energy below 600 K (fog),which suggests that a given Ni site is either completely poisoned or not affected at all, depending on its distance from a sulfur atom. Very similar effects of sulfur were also reported on Ni/A120~catalysts (108).Nakamura et al. (109a) have shown that the rate of H2-D2 scrambling at 12 torr over Ni(100) decays linearly with sulfur coverage to zero at 0s = 0.45. Similar effects of sulfur have been observed by Goodman and coworkers for CO hydrogenation over Ru(0001) and Rh( 111) model catalysts (80) and C02 hydrogenation over Ni(100) (110).In the case of CO2 hydrogenation, the reverse water-gas shift reaction (C02 + H2 CO + H20) apparently establishes a rapid equilibrium, and then methane is produced from the resulting CO (110).The hydrogenation of CO over sulfur-dosed Mo(100) was studied by Logan et al. (981,who found that whereas methane production was poisoned, the effect was much less dramatic than on the surfaces outlined above. In addition, the amount of ethylene product became comparable to that of methane upon sulfur poisoning. The effect of adsorbed sulfur upon the rate of CO methanation over W(110) has been studied by Szuromi et al. (100, 111). The rate decayed much more slowly with sulfur than on Ni surfaces, and the activation energy was unchanged. At high coverages, the rate and the saturation hydrogen coverage decayed in a similar way. These authors also showed that low levels of 0 2 torr) completely poison the surface with oxygen. The rate of hydrogenolysis of ethane to methane over Ru(0001) is much more slowly poisoned by sulfur than is methanation (80).The hydrogenolysis of cyclopropane to methane, ethane, and propane has been studied by Goodman over sulfur-dosed Ni( 111) and Ni( 100) (7.3). The production of methane and ethane on Ni( 11 I ) and methane on Ni( 100) is dramatically poisoned by low sulfur coverages. The yield of propane plus propylene decreases much more slowly. In contrast to the clean Ni(lI1) surface, ethylene production increases, becoming a significant product, after sulfur addition. Overall, the addition of sulfur causes a reduction in the ability of the Ni surface to cleave C-C bonds. Oudar et al. (112) have studied the influence of sulfur on the hydrogenation of 1,3-butadiene and H2-Dz equilibration over Pt(ll0). The rates decayed linearly with sulfur coverage, so that each sulfur atom poisons one dissociation site for hydrogen without influencing the activation energies or mechanism. The authors established the first isotherm for sulfur adsorption under actual catalytic reaction conditions. The adsorbed hydrocarbons influenced the equilibrium coverage of sulfur on the Pt surface. The thermodynamics of adsorbed sulfur on several metal single crystal surfaces have been presented by Bernard et al. (114).
*
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
31
The general subject of sulfur poisoning of metal catalysts has been reviewed by Bartholomew et al. (115), who discussed results mostly on high-surface-area catalysts. The hydrodesulfurization of thiophane over Mo( 100) is deactivated by sulfur adsorption, although the rate for nearly a monolayer of sulfur is still almost half that measured in the absence of sulfur (104). Excessive sulfur exposure leads to formation of a MoS2 layer and severe deactivation of Mo(100)(104). Campbell and Koel have studied the deposition kinetics of sulfur from H2S onto Cu(ll1) and the resulting influence of sulfur adatoms on the kinetics of the water-gas shift reaction (H20 + CO + H2 + COZ)(24). Although H2S deposits sulfur adatoms on the surface and liberates H2 gas (H2S+ Hz + S,) with a reaction probability of -0.03 per H2S collision with the surface at 500 K, the reverse reaction proceeds only very slowly, with a reaction probability of 5 per H2collision. This kinetic discrepancy suggests that a few ppm of H2S will be sufficient to deposit almost a full monolayer of sulfur onto Cu surfaces under catalytic reaction conditions. The rate of the water-gas shift reaction decreases linearly to zero with sulfur coverage over the coverage range between zero and a saturated, close-packed monolayer. Thus, it appears that in this case each sulfur adatom simply poisons a fraction of the Cu surface equivalent to that which it can sterically block (-2.6 Cu atoms), and that only one or maybe two Cu atoms are required for the rate-determining step. The reaction is positive-order with respect to H2O adsorption (26), a fact that does not change on sulfur addition. This suggests that only one or two Cu surface atoms are needed to cleave the 0-H bond in H20. The stability of adsorbed sulfur and its influence on the water-gas shift kinetics helps to explain the well-known sulfur intolerance of Cu-based catalysts for this reaction (24). The influence of adsorbed Si, P, S, and C1 on the medium-pressure cyclotrimerization of acetylene to benzene over Pd(l1 l), (loo), and (1 10) has been studied by Logan et al. (113). Whereas both sulfur and chlorine decrease the activity, silicon increases the activity. The effect of phosphorous depends on the crystal face. According to their work function measurements, sulfur withdraws electron density from the Pd surface (as is also expected for chlorine), whereas Si donates electron density, and P has the least effect on the work function. Thus, the qualitative influences on catalytic activities correlate with the influences of the additives on the electronic character of the surface. In addition, Si decreases the carbon coverage seen in postreaction AES from -82 to -70% of a monolayer, whereas sulfur and chlorine increase the amount of carbonaceous residue. The authors interpreted these results by suggesting that the electrondonating ligands keep the Pd surface cleaner for the desirable reaction by
32
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
preventing surface polymerization. Inconsistent with this model, potassium, which should have the greatest extent of charge transfer of all the ligands studied, caused a decrease in the catalytic activity of Pd(llO), although it did double the rate on the other two surfaces. Garfunkel et al. (116) studied the influence of preoxidation of Re and Fe polycrystalline surfaces on their activity in CO hydrogenation. Oxidation usually led to higher methane selectivity and less carbon buildup on the surface. The activation energy for methanation was changed by oxidation of Fe(poly), which suggests either an electronic effect or a change in the rate-determining step. In contrast, Castner et al. (97) found that Rh surfaces produced a greater fraction of higher-molecular-weight hydrocarbons from CO + H2 mixtures when preoxidized, and that the selectivity for oxygenated products was substantial on oxidized Rh but insignificant on the metal alone. Hasenberg and Schmidt (119) studied the synthesis of HCN from CH, + NH3 mixtures at 0.01 to 10 tom over a polycrystalline Pt surface that was initially clean. Under reaction conditions the surface was covered with nearly a monolayer of carbon. Addition of 0 2 to the reaction mixture reduced the carbon coverage, decreasing the HCN production rate at the expense of NO production. A kinetic model was developed that fit the data well. Campbell and co-workers (48, 117, 118) have studied the influence of chlorine adatoms on the selective oxidation of ethylene to ethylene epoxide over Ag( 110) and Ag( 1 1 1) surfaces. As also occurs when trace levels of chlorinated hydrocarbon are added to the reactant feed over aluminasupported Ag catalysts, the deposition of chlorine adatoms on Ag single crystals led to a decrease in the steady-state rates of both epoxide production and full combustion (COz + H20). The latter was poisoned more rapidly than the former, and this lead to a marked improvement in selectivity, to a limiting value of 80-85%. This proved that the true promoter is atomically adsorbed chlorine, and that no support effects are required to understand (in first order) the role of the promoter. The selectivity is improved at significantly lower chlorine coverages on Ag( 111) than on Ag(I10) (48). In both cases the reaction rates decrease only at considerably larger chlorine coverages than those required to markedly suppress dissociative 0 2 adsorption, even under conditions where the reaction rate is limited by 0 2 supply. This was originally interpreted to indicate that molecularly, rather than dissociatively, adsorbed 0 2 was the true oxidizing agent (48, 117). The relative importance of molecularly versus dissociatively adsorbed oxygen in the reaction mechanism is, however, still a subject of some controversy (46). Figure 9 summarizes the results of a series of experiments in which the
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
c
,,
0.9
0
0.1 I
02
0.3
04
I
I
I
05 I
06 1
33
1
FIG.9. Influence of chlorine coverage on the kinetic parameters for selective ethylene oxidation over a Ag( 110) surface. Parameters for both the production of ethylene epoxide (EtO, circles) and the undesired side reaction to full combustion (COz, squares) are presented. Steady-state reaction orders in Ps and PE,and activation energies E, versus chlorine coverage near 563 K, PE,= 20 torr, and Po2 = 150 torr. From Ref. 118.
influence of chlorine coverage on the steady-state kinetics of ethylene epoxidation was determined over a range of temperature and partial pressure conditions on Ag(l10) (fZ8).The ability demonstrated here to monitor directly the changes in kinetic parameters as a function of modifier coverage highlights the strength of the surface science approach in addressing the influence of surface additives. The most obvious feature here is that the kinetic parameters for full combustion (COz) essentially track those for epoxidation (EtO), which strongly suggests that a common adsorbed intermediate is formed in the rate-determining step of both path-
34
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
ways, and that the selectivity is determined only subsequent to this step by the branching ratio of two relatively rapid competing reactions available to this intermediate. Campbell and co-workers have analyzed these chlorine-induced changes in the kinetic parameters using the results of UHV adsorption-desorption experiments (kinetics and energetics) measured for ethylene and oxygen as a function of chlorine coverage (118). For example, low chlorine coverages increase the heat of adsorption (and therefore steady-state coverage) of ethylene. As a consequence, under conditions in which the reaction rate is positive-order in ethylene pressure, chlorine addition leads to an increase in epoxidation rate and a decrease in the reaction order with respect to ethylene pressure. Tan et al. (120-122) have also studied the influence of chlorine on the epoxidation of ethylene over Ag( 111) in detail. The Lambert group (123126) has also performed numerous other mechanistic investigations of this reaction over Ag(ll1). These and other mechanistic studies of this reaction are excellently reviewed in a recent article by van Santen and Kuipers (46).
2. Alkali Promoters Catalysts of various types are frequently treated with solutions of alkali salts in order to improve their subsequent activity or selectivity in specific applications. A fundamental understanding of the role of alkali promoters has long been a goal of the catalysis community. In 1982, Campbell and Goodman (127) investigated the role of potassium promoters in nickel catalysts for CO hydrogenation by using model catalysts synthesized by the vapor deposition of well-defined K overlayers on a clean Ni(100) surface. As with K impregnation of supported Ni catalysts, the steady-state rate of catalytic methane production decreased and that of higher hydrocarbons and olefins increased (see Fig. 10). This result showed that the dominant role of the alkali in this case is unrelated to interactions with the catalyst support material. The activation barrier for CO dissociation on Ni(100) was shown to be greatly reduced by K addition; therefore, the steady-state carbide coverage under reaction conditions increased markedly. Within the accepted “carbide” mechanism, this was expected to cause an increase in the C :H ratio in the surface layer and, therefore, a decrease in the probability for hydrogenation of carbon and an increase in the probability for chain growth (C-C bond formation) in the adsorbed intermediates. Thus, less CH4 and more olefins and higher hydrocarbons were seen in the products, and the graphitization of the surface occurs at a lower temperature. Since that study, the coadsorption of CO and alkalis on transition-metal surfaces has been
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
METHANE
ETHYLENE
35
ETHANE
FIG. 10. A comparison of the product distributions (weight percent) over a Ni(100) catalyst observed during CO hydrogenation over clean (solid bars) and K-doped (crosshatched bars) catalysts at T = 500 K, H2: CO = 4 : 1, and a total pressure of 120 torr. Potassium coverage = 0.10 monolayers (ML).From Ref. 127.
extensively studied, and numerous short- and long-range electronic interactions have been shown to operate in the coadsorbed layer, which can facilitate C-0 bond cleavage (see Ref. 128 and refs. cited therein). It should be noted, however, that the K on Ni(100) was not atomically absorbed under reaction conditions, but instead stabilized by some oxygen-containing species, perhaps in a CO, H20, or OH complex (127). Similar results have been obtained for K-promoted Fe foils and surfacecharacterized Fe powders by Bonze1 and co-workers (129-132) and by Dwyer and Hardenbergh (133, 134). Many of these results over Fe have been discussed in detail in a recent paper by Wesner et al. (132). On Fe foil, the chain-growth factor (Y in the Fischer-Tropsch reaction increased by -30% on K addition. Dwyer and Hardenbergh (134) observed a new surface-carbon species (neither carbidic nor graphitic) in postreaction XPS analysis of K-promoted Fe powders and suggested this species to be “polymethylene-like.” This same K-induced species was later seen on Fe foils by Wesner et al. (132) and shown to be kinetically active in hydrogenation, and its presence was well correlated with the enhancement in chain growth. In general, postreaction surface analysis indicates much higher carbon coverages on Fe compared to Ni surfaces, both with and
36
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
without K. As on Ni, the carbon graphitizes at high temperatures. The graphitization temperature is considerably higher on Fe powders than on Fe foil (133). Similar structural and kinetic effects were observed for vapor-deposited and solution-deposited K on polycrystalline Fe foil (132), suggesting that the catalytic reaction conditions rather than the method of deposition controlled the structure of the alkali on the working catalyst’s surface. Evidence from XPS measurements suggested a surface KOH complex for this structure (131, 132). Similar influences of Na have been reported in CO hydrogenation over Re foils (116), where the selectivity for longer-chain hydrocarbons increased and the overall rate declined. Wesner et al. (135) studied K promotion of Co foils in the FischerTropsch reaction. Again, quite similar results were obtained. Like Ni, Co showed much less surface carbon following reaction than on Fe, although on Co the carbon is mostly graphitic in nature. However, after K addition, the carbon is much more carbidic. The reactivity of carbidic carbon with H2 on both Fe and Co is reduced in the presence of K. On Mo(loo), somewhat similar results were also obtained in CO hydrogenation by Logan et al. (98),where the selectivity for higher hydrocarbons and olefins increased on K addition. In this case, the overall rate of reaction also increased, which may be related to the unusual positive CO pressure dependence for this surface. The hydrogenation of C02 over K-promoted Ni(100) was studied by Peebles et al. (110), who showed a strong enhancement in both Co and methane production rates but no changes in activation energies. They also showed that K could be used as an antidote to low-level sulfur poisoning, where the combined effects of K + S was almost a coverage-weighted average of their individual effects. The addition of potassium to industrial Fe catalysts leads to an increase in activity for ammonia synthesis (Nz + 3H2 --.* 3NH3)(136).This promotion effect has been the subject of considerable attention from the surface science community, particularly with regard to the coadsorption of K or K + 0 and N2 (136-139). Ertl and co-workers have shown that potassium addition to single-crystal Fe surfaces can lead to a 10- to 100-fold enhancement in the rate of dissociative N2 adsorption, which is thought to be the rate-determining step in NH3 synthesis (136-139). However, Bare et al. (140) were unable to promote the activity of Fe( 1 1 I ) , (loo), or (1 10) surfaces for this reaction at 20-atm pressure with either K, K + 0, or K + AIO, addition. They interpreted this result to indicate that the promotional role of K in industrial catalysis may be cooperation with other promoters, such as the support material, to cause structural rather than electronic promotion. These results were for very low conversions, however, so that the product (NHj) partial pressure was low. Strongin and
PRESSURE-VACUUM
ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
37
Somojai (183) later found that potassium does promote the activity of Fe( 1 11) and (100) at higher conversions, and that the effect increases with increasing conversion. They interpreted this in terms of the poisoning of surface sites by adsorbed ammonia and a decrease in the coverage of NH3 due to the presence of potassium. They also found that potassium decreases the heat of NH3 adsorption. Asscher er al. (85) also saw at best only a very slight increase in the NH3 production rate over Re singlecrystal surfaces after potassium addition. For both Fe and Re, surface oxygen was required to stabilize the surface alkali under reaction conditions. Stolze and Norskov (181, 182) have modeled reasonably accurately the kinetics of high-pressure ammonia synthesis over Fe/AI2O3and commercial K/Fe-based catalysts using kinetic parameters for elementary reaction steps taken from UHV studies over clean and K-dosed Fe single crystals (86, 87, 136-139). Zaera and Somojai (141) studied the influence of potassium on the reactions of n-hexane and H2 over Pt( 1 11) near atmospheric pressure. The overall reaction rate decreased dramatically with as little as 2% of a monolayer of K, and the coverage of carbonaceous residue also increased slightly in this K coverage range. At higher K coverages, the rates continued to decrease but the carbon coverage also decreased. The results were explained in terms of inhibition by K of the dehydrogenation of adsorbed hydrocarbons. Campbell and Koel (142, 143) have studied cesium promotion of the medium-pressure water-gas shift reaction (H2O + CO + H2 + C02) over a well-defined Cu(ll1) surface under conditions in which the rate is limited by dissociative H2O adsorption. As shown in Fig. 1 1, they observed a 15-fold enhancement in catalytic activity at 8cs = 0.15, with no major change in reaction order with respect to H20 and only a slight increase in the overall activation energy (17 to 20 kcal/mol). Under reaction conditions, the Cs was stabilized on the surface in an oxidic or hydroxidic complex of approximate ratio Cs : 0 = 1 : 1, which formed, at high coverages, islands of ap(2 x 2) overlayer structure. The maximum promotional effect was achieved at a Cs coverage just below that required to nucleate these p(2 X 2) islands. They attribute the promotional effect to direct participation of the surface CsOH complex in H20 bond cleavage. Again, coadsorption of S poison and Cs promoter led to nearly directly additive individual effects. Campbell (144, 145) has also studied Cs promotion of the selective oxidation of ethylene over Ag( 11 1) at low conversions. Under mediumpressure reaction conditions, the Cs is stabilized as a surface cesium oxide of approximate stoichiometry Cs : 0 = 1 : 3, where bonding of the oxygen atoms both to the surface Ag atoms and to at least one Cs atom is
38
C H A R L E S T. C A M P B E L L
1.6 1.4
3
1.2
u)
s; 1.0 W
4
i , -1
o*8
0 0.6
I
v
0.4
Cs/Cu
AES RATIO / ( l / l O O )
FIG.1 I . Variation of the water-gas shift reaction rate with cesium coverage on Cu( I 1 1) at 612 K, 26-torr CO, and 10-tom H20. The open data point represents dosing of pure water (no CsOH). From Ref. 142.
suggested both by this stoichiometry and by XPS,AES, and TDS results. This C s / O complex coalesces into islands of (2 fi x 2 f i ) R 3 0 " structure according to postreaction LEED analysis. This same cesium structure results either by running the reaction over a pure Cs overlayer on atomically clean Ag( 11I), or by dosing Cs from ultrapure aqueous solutions of cesium hydroxide, carbonate, or nitrate onto Ag( 11 1) using procedures very similar to those used in preparing Cs-doped industrial catalysts. This result lays to rest fears that the vapor-deposition method chosen for alkali promotion by surface scientists yields a final alkali structure any different from what would be expected from the more industrial approach of impregnation from solution. Small coverages of Cs led to a decrease in both rate and selectivity, whereas very high coverages continued to poison the rate but led to only a very small improvement in selectivity compared to alkali-free Ag(ll1). Although these minor effects cannot be neglected, the major promotional effect in industrial catalysis appears to be related to other factors such as interactions with the support or other promoters and/or further oxidation of the product ethylene epoxide.
PRESSURE-VACUUM
ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
39
Lambert and co-workers (121-123, 125) have addressed this issue of further oxidation and other features of Cs promotion using model catalysts based on Cs/Ag(11 1). Their results indicate that the simultaneous presence of Cs and COz lead to marked enhancements in selectivity (125). In contrast to Campbell’s results, they report that Cs enhances the rate of epoxidation at low conversion (122). They also show that, although Ag( 11 1) is active in the isomerization of the product (ethylene epoxide) to acetaldehyde, its activity for this side reaction can be suppressed by surface Cs addition (122, 123). Since this isomerization may lead to further oxidation of the epoxide, this may help to explain the enhancement in selectivity derived from Cs addition in industrial catalysis. C. BIMETALLIC A N D ALLOYCATALYSTS The subject of bimetallic or alloy catalysis has long been of deep interest to the catalytic chemist. Addition of a second metal to a moderately good catalyst can frequently improve either the activity, the selectivity, or the lifetime of the catalyst. This improvement can arise from any combination of effects, including those that are basically electronic in nature, whereby the metal-metal bonding changes their electronic structure, or those that are basically geometric in nature, where the size, shape, and availability of the ensembles or groups of active metal sites can be altered by the presence of a second, frequently more inert metal. These subjects have been excellently reviewed in a number of recent works by Sachtler and van Santen (146, 143, Ponec (39), and Sinfelt and Cusumano (148,149).The goal of the surface science experiment here has been to carefully distinguish these two effects in certain reaction systems, and even to quantify the surface electronic, structural, or ensemble characteristics required for an effective catalyst. This hope is, of course, spurred by a knowledge that these properties can be carefully controlled and quantitatively characterized by use of the modern spectroscopic and structural tools of surface science combined with model catalysts based on single crystals. Here, the second metal is either present as an alloy in the bulk crystal itself or is vapor-deposited (or chemically deposited) onto the surface under the pristine conditions of UHV. In the latter case it has been repeatedly demonstrated that well-ordered overlayers or surface alloys of the second metal can often be generated that present the entire range of surface compositions of the two metals (see Refs. 150-154 and refs. cited therein). Although UHV adsorption-desorption studies on these types of model catalyst have been pursued extensively for some
40
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
time, actual catalytic kinetics at realistic pressures has been only a recent development. In 1983 Sachtler and Somorjai (155) studied the reactions of n-hexane + H2 at -230 torr over a Pt( 1 1 1) single-crystal surface that had been carefully modified with vapor-deposited Au overlayers and surface alloys generated by annealing these overlayers. Although Au itself is very inert for these reactions, the surface alloys were found to be more active than pure Pt( 1 1 1). Large increases in the isomerization rate and simultaneous exponential decreases in the rates of hydrogenolysis and aromatization with increasing Au concentration resulted in high isomerization selectivity. The authors attributed this result to an ensemble effect, where the probability for finding large groups of Pt sites, required for hydrogenolysis, aromatization, and possibly deactivation by carbon buildup, decreases as Au dilutes the Pt alloy. These authors soon extended this study to include cyclohexane dehydrogenation (156), where they found a large enhancement in the rate of benzene production, which maximized at a surface composition of -50% Au and declined thereafter. Gold addition also induced cyclohexene production, which occurred most readily at 90% Au surface concentration. Again, the results were explained by an ensemble effect, where a decrease in the sizes of available Pt sites reduced the extent of site poisoning by the benzene product. More recently, the authors have further extended this work to include a comparison of the Au-Pt( 1 1 1) versus Au-Pt( 100) alloy surfaces in nhexane reactions (157). As shown in Fig. 12, the same general decreases in reaction rates and increases in isomerization selectivity with Au addition were seen for both Pt surface orientations, except for the fact that, in contrast to Pt( loo), the rate of methylpentane production actually increases with Au addition. Other more subtle differences were also observed, demonstrating clearly the existence of structural sensitivity in alloy catalysis. Again, ensemble effects were used to explain the results. Unfortunately, the sizes and shapes of available Pt atom ensembles could not be determined in any of the preceding studies even for the starting alloys. This is due to the difficulty of determining the lateral distribution of elements in bimetallic surfaces, even when they give good LEED patterns as in these cases. This prevents any quantitative assessment of ensemble requirements for the various reactions and clearly highlights a glaring need for the development of surface analytical tools that determine the lateral distributions of elements on multimetallic surfaces. Recently, Campbell and co-workers (158) have demonstrated new methodology that may allow for semi-quantitative assessment of ensemble effects. This method relies on the inertness of bismuth adatoms and their
PRESSURE-VACUUM
2.0
0 0
c
1.5
X
5 l-
a
1.0
a
t
41
ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
.\
-.t
a
\
.Y
1
w
a
0.5
I L
I-
0
Q25
0.5
xA"
0.75
1.0
o
at5
0.5
0.75
1.0
xA"
FIG. 12. A plot of the initial turnover frequencies for n-hexane conversion over singlecrystal surface alloys of Pt plus Au at T = 570 K,H2/HC = 10, and P,o, = 220 torr. (a), AuPt(100); (b), Au-Pt( 1 11). Rates are plotted as molecules converted per surface atom (platinum and gold) versus the surface atom fraction of gold. From Ref. 157.
potential as nearly ideal site-blocking agents that have well-defined lateral distributions on transition metal surfaces. The bimetallic Cu/Ru system does not alloy, but supported Cu/Ru catalysts have been well studied because Cu addition very selectively suppresses hydrogenolysis reactions compared to simple dehydrogenation over Ru (148, 149). Recently, Peden and Goodman (159-163) have investigated this system using well-defined adlayers of Cu on a Ru(0001) surface. In this case, Cu adatoms clusters into two-dimensional islands on the surface. The addition of submonolayer Cu causes a dramatic (eightfold) increase in the rate of cyclohexane dehydrogenation to benzene at 100 torr (159, 160, 163) and a linear decrease in the rate of ethane hydrogenolysis to methane (159, 161). Ultimately this leads to the same marked
42
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
increase in selectivity for dehydrogenation over hydrogenolysis as seen for supported Cu/Ru (159). However, the enhanced activity for dehydrogenation has not been observed on the supported catalysts. In Fig. 13, Peden and Goodman compare the supported and single-crystal catalysts in terms of their specific activity (now on a per surface Ru atom basis) for these two reactions (159). In the case of the unsupported catalysts, Peden and Goodman (see Ref. 159 and refs. cited therein) have seen substantial spillover of hydrogen chemisorption from Ru to Cu sites on their model catalysts. Because the Ru surface atom density in the experiments with supported catalysts was measured by HZchemisorption, they conclude that there may have been an overestimation of the Ru surface concentration in those experiments (159). This correction would bring the data of Fig. 13 for the two types of catalyst at least into qualitative agreement. This subject, however, remains controversial. Peden and Goodman attribute the enhancement in cyclohexane dehydrogenation to the altered
,
0.0
50
*c_
2 c
$ y
0.2
0.4
0.6
1
I
I
0.8 ' I
I
I
40-
30
1.o
-
! I ;
-
0
20-
/
-
&
10-
c
-
# (
- - - - -t - -
-
a
I
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
h
1.o
FIG.13. Relative Ru-specific activity as a function of Cu coverage (ML)on Ru(0001) (dashed lines) and Cu atomic ratio on silica-supported Cu/Ru catalysts (points and solid curves) for the ethane hydrogenolysis (a) and cyclohexane dehydrogenation (b) reactions. Note that the atomic ratio reported for the supported system probably underestimates the surface coverage of Cu since Cu resides predominantly on the Ru surface in these catalysts. From Ref. 159. Data for silica-supported catalysts taken from Ref. 184.
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
43
geometric and electronic properties of the surface sites, or perhaps to a cooperative effect such as they see for hydrogen spillover from Ru to Cu. Ensemble effects may certainly be at work here since carbonaceous residue and Cu both suppress hydrogenolysis on the Ru surface in a similar way (163). Goodman and co-workers have also studied the kinetics of methanation and cyclohexane hydrogenolysis on their Cu/Ru(0001)model catalysts. In these cases, as with ethane hydrogenolysis, Cu merely serves as an inactive diluent, suppressing the rates on a simple one-to-one site-blocking basis (161, 162). Greenlief et al. (164) have studied CO methanation and ethane hydrogenolysis over submonolayer Ni films on W(110) and W(100). For these reactions, W alone is very inactive. They have compared the kinetics with that seen for pure Ni crystals. When compared on a per surface Ni atom basis, the turnover frequencies and activation energies for CO methanation are very similar for pure Ni crystals and for the whole range of coverages of Ni on W surfaces. This highlights the extreme structural insensitivity of this reaction on Ni. Although the activation energies for ethane hydrogenolysis over Ni/W( 110) and Ni/W(100) were very similar, the rate (per Ni atom) on Ni/W(l 10) decreased with increasing Ni coverage.
D. METAL-SUPPORT INTERACTIONS The oxidic support material (e.g., SiOz, Al203, TiO2, ZnO, ...) for a catalytically active metal can favorably or adversely influence the performance of that metal in a particular catalytic process. This has been a subject of considerable study for many years, and the general picture has evolved that the catalytic kinetics can be affected by electronic influences on the active metal atoms due to their specific bonding to the support, structural effects where the dispersion of the metal phase or its atomic geometry can be controlled by the underlying support, and cooperative effects were adsorbed intermediates bond to both the metal and the oxidic surface sites, or where certain necessary or undesirable steps in the reaction mechanism take place on the surface of the oxidic support. However, the specific details of these effects have been clarified in only a few cases. Recently, surface science methods have been applied to the study of these interactions, which are referred to as “SMSI” effects (strong metalsupport interaction) when particularly noticeable. The general subject of SMSI effects has recently been reviewed in detail by Tauster (165), who discusses results for both practical and model catalysts.
44
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
In 1982 Kao et al. (166) reported on the CO hydrogenation activity of nickel overlayers on the TiOz(100) surface as a model SMSI catalyst. They found that an average Ni thickness of -5 8, gave optimum activity, displaying a rate that was 3.3-3.7 times that for an equivalent size sample of pure Ni( 11 I ) , with an accompanying increase in the selectivity for higher hydrocarbons. As shown in Fig. 14, the activation energy for this model SMSI catalyst was unchanged from Ni(ll1). Later, Chung and coworkers (167) studied the activity of a Ni(ll1) surface containing controlled amounts of reduced titania. This catalyst was optimally promoted at a titania coverage of -0.1 monolayer, displaying an activity and product distribution similar to Ni/Ti02(100) and essentially identical to the practical Ni/TiO2 catalysts. The model Ni/TiO2 catalysts prepared by different methods showed similar surface Ti3+ concentrations. These results, together with their companion study (168) of the surface composition of model Ni/Ti02catalysts that had been given the high-temperature SMSI reduction, suggested that partially reduced titania species migrate up from the support material to partially cover the Ni surface. Since this reaction is known to be structurally insensitive (see above), these species must improve the catalysts by some favorable electronic influence on the Ni surface atoms or else by direct participation in the reaction mechanism. Demmin et al. (169-1 72) studied methanation and CO and H2 chemisorption on model SMSI catalysts prepared by deposition of titania onto T(C)
260
240
220
200
I80 I
10-41
1.8
I
1
2.2
20
I
1
1
I O’/ T(K)
FIG.14. Arrhenius plots of the methane turnover number (molecules/cm2/s)during CO hydrogenation over Ni(l1 I ) and 5-A Ni/TiO2(I00) ( P H I= 60 torr, f c o = 20 torr). (From Ref. 166.)
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
700600500 400
45
300
4-p201
IOOO/T
(K-’)
FIG. 15. Methanation rates for 100-torr CO and 400-torr H2 on a Pt foil. The turnover is in units of molecules/site/second and is based on 1 x 1OIs sites/cm2for the number (hiCH4) foil. The dashed lines indicate rates reported by Vannice and Twu (185) for Pt/TiO, (--4, Pt/Al2O3(---), and Pt/SiO, (-----). The rates for the niobia- and titania-covered foils were measured with an oxide coverage sufficient to completely suppress CO and H2adsorption. (x), Clean Pt; (O),TiOJPt; (O), NbOJPt. From Ref. 172.
Pt, Pd, and Rh foils and niobia onto a Pt foil. In all cases, a partial oxide formed uniform layers on the metal surfaces, suppressing chemisorption of H2 and CO. Nevertheless, the rate of methanation increased substantially and its activation energy decreased, as can be seen in Fig. 15. These three results are almost identical to those reported for the well-known “SMSI state” of high-surface-area niobia- and titania-supported metals. On the basis of these results, Demmin and co-workers attribute the SMSI effect to the migration of a titania or niobia species onto the metal crystallites. Demmin and Gorte (170) also showed that, while clean Pt foil showed no surface carbon in postreaction AES, the titania-dosed foil showed significant quantities of reactive carbon following reactions at low H2/CO pressure ratios, suggesting that CO dissociation on Pt is enhanced by the presence of titania species at the surface. Levin et al. (173) studied the surface structure and chemisorption properties of Ti0,-dosed Rh foil following high-temperature reduction in medium pressures of H2. Again, CO adsorption was inhibited. Later, they
46
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
showed that an optimum coverage of TiO, of -0.15 monolayers led to a threefold enhancement in activity for CO hydrogenation at atmospheric pressure, and a higher selectivity for olefins, a lower activation energy, and higher reaction orders with respect to H2 and CO (174, 186). These results are very similar to those for Ni and Pt (above). The authors argued that surface Ti3+participates in CO dissociation. In contrast to titania and niobia, alumina is a support that does not display the classic SMSI behavior outlined above, at least for practical catalysts (173, 175). Bischke et al. (176) studied CO methanation over model Ni/A1203 catalysts prepared by evaporation of Al onto a W foil, subsequent oxidation of the Al, and finally vapor deposition of Ni onto the thin A1203film. Specific reaction rates (per Ni surface atom) and the activation energy were similar to those found for pure Ni crystals and practical Ni/A1203 catalysts. This agrees with the classical picture of A1203 as a more or less inert support for this catalyst and the known structural insensitivity of this reaction over Ni (see above). Submonolayer quantities of oxidized aluminum were shown by Levin et al. (186) to only decrease the rate of methanation over a Rh foil, in proportion to the fraction of Rh sites covered by the oxide film. Lee et al. (17) prepared model Fe/MgO catalysts by deposition of Fe onto MgO(100). These surfaces were then characterized in detail following Hz + CO treatments at -0.1 torr by application of a powerful array of surface analytical methods. For Fe layers less than four atoms thick, the Fe was oxidized after reaction with CO + H2. For higher coverages, the Fe was carburized. Carbon deposition was seen at all Fe thicknesses. They saw at least two carbon species, with C-Fe distances of 1.78 and 2.06 A. A strong synergy between Cu and ZnO has been reported for highsurface-area Cu/ZnO catalysts in methanol synthesis (CO + H2 + CH20H) by Klier (see Refs. 178 and 179 and refs. cited therein). To study the pertinent Cu/ZnO interactions, Campbell et al. (102) prepared and characterized model catalysts consisting of well-defined Cu overlayers on the oxygen-terminated ZnO(0M) single-crystal surface and others consisting of ZnO, films on Cu( 111). They attempted to produce methanol on these catalysts at temperatures of 500-600 K and H2 + CO(+COz) total pressures of up to 1500 torr. Although they were unable to observe any methanol production, they were able to set an upper limit on the activities of these model catalysts at < 2 X molecules/site/s. This limit is consistent with the rates expected for high-area Cu/ZnO catalysts (extrapolated from a somewhat higher pressure regime). Campbell and Daube (26) also studied the kinetics of the water-gas shift reaction over a
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
47
Cu( 11 1) surface and saw no major changes in the rate due to the addition of ZnO, to the surface. Strongin et al. (180) studied metal-support effects in Fe-catalyzed ammonia synthesis by depositing aluminum oxide onto the Fe(l1 l), (loo), and (1 10) surfaces and observing the resulting influences on the kinetics of NH3 production from N2 + Hz.Treatment of the model catalysts in 20torr H 2 0 caused a lasting restructuring of the alumina-dosed Fe(l10) and (100) surfaces. This restructuring resulted in a marked increase in catalytic activity for these Fe surfaces, to rates near those for the (already very active) Fe(ll1) plane (see above). This was explained in terms of an alumina-induced geometric rearrangement of the Fe surface atoms to a local geometry more favorable for participation in NH3 production. IV. Conclusion It is safe to say that the combination of UHV surface analyses with medium- and high-pressure kinetics over well-defined planar surfaces has already added considerably to our understanding of structure-function relationships in catalysis. This is certainly nor to say that experiments using this approach are all that will be required to develop a thorough understanding of the relationships between catalyst performance and atomic-level surface structure. Indeed, experiments with high-surfacearea catalysts will play an equally important role. Studies of either type are certainly most meaningful when they can be directly compared with results using the other approach. We are slowly approaching a happy symbiosis between careful experiments over practical, high-surface-area catalysts and model, single-crystal catalysts. Because of the inherent surface heterogeneity of practical catalysts, many types of experiment are preferably performed over the homogeneous surfaces of model catalysts such as those reviewed here. However, present technology limits many of the kinds of experiment that can be performed on well-defined planar surfaces. For example, the amount of gaseous product is small and difficult to analyze accurately. Therefore, transient kinetics and isotope-labeling experiments designed to elucidate the reaction mechanism are currently most conveniently performed with powdered or supported catalysts. It is notable that even state-state kinetics over single-crystal metal oxides have never been reported, partly because the specific rates in oxide catalysis are very low. Similarly, the surface area of planar model catalysts is small, so that competing side reactions over undefined reactor surfaces can lead to significant problems
48
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
that are difficult to detect and avoid. In addition, recipes for preparing truly homogeneous, well-defined planar samples presently exist for only a very limited range of materials. The preparation of well-defined surfaces of more complex materials remains as one of the major challenges of “UHV preparatory surface chemistry. ” Catalysis over biphasic materials, such as is thought to be the case in many redox catalysts for selective oxidation (e.g., copper and copper oxide mixtures), represents a class of reaction where study over a single homogeneous surface may well be impossible at steady state. However, transient kinetics of elementary steps over homogeneous surfaces should provide useful insight into the relative roles of the separate phases even in this case. In any case, many types of experiments will continue to be most preferably performed over powdered and supported high-surface-area catalysts. Indeed, these catalysts certainly are much closer in structure to those of commercial import, and many methods of surface analysis can be performed only with higharea samples. It should be pointed out that this field of catalysis on well-defined, planar surfaces is still in its infancy. As in the early days of vacuum surface physics, the results should generally be taken “with a grain of salt” until they are corroborated over another sample by another group. Complications in surface preparation and cleanliness are very difficult to avoid and are more common than expected by the “high-surface-area” catalysis community. The quality of kinetic results over homogeneous surfaces is presently limited by the quality of sample preparation and mounting. There is a tendency to see the sophisticated instrumentation involved and trust implicitly any results from so impressive an apparatus. Scientifically speaking, this can be as dangerous as the reactionary response of discarding all kinetic results from the surface science approach after a few (or several) contradictions are discovered. At the same time, surface scientists must make a dedicated effort to familiarize themselves with the literature of high-area catalysis, as a knowledge of the experimental complications in that field can help them to understand and appreciate seemingly contradictory results found there. Clearly, some highsurface-area catalysts, however heterogeneous, have been better characterized than others. In the future we will see the development of more and more sophisticated surface analytical techniques capable of analyzing a variety of surface types under high-pressure reaction conditions. Eventually this will eliminate the complications of sample transfer into UHV described here. At the same time, more sensitive detection schemes for gaseous products will appear, as will reproducible recipes for preparation of homogeneous surfaces of complex materials. All these developments will facilitate the
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
49
study of accurate transient and steady-state catalytic kinetics over welldefined, planar surfaces. They will also aid in the quality of structural and kinetic characterization of high-surface-area catalysts resembling those used industrially. The present author is optimistic that investigations using these two different approaches, when coupled with proper theoretical input, will eventually lead to a relatively complete understanding of structure-function relationships in the surface chemistry of catalysis. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The author gratefully acknowledges support for this research by the Department of Energy, Office of Basic Energy Sciences, Chemical Science Division. I thank D. W. Goodman and G. A . Somojai for helpful discussions, for communication of results prior to publication, and for contribution of figures. I am also indebted to R. J. Gorte and Y.-W. Chung for contributions of figures and Elizabeth McGaw for typing of the manuscript.
REFERENCES
1 . Kahn, D. R., Petersen, E. E., and Somojai, G. A., J . Catal. 34, 294 (1974). 2. Blakely, D. W., Kozak, E. I., Sexton, B. A., and Somojai, G. A . , J . Vuc. Sci. Techno/. 13, 1091 (1976). 3 . Sexton, B . A . , and Somojai, G. A., J . Catal. 46, 167 (1977). 4. Madey, T. E., Goodman, D. W., and Kelley, R. D., J . Vac. Sci. Techno/. 16, 433 (1979).
5 . Goodman, D. W., Kelley, R. D., Madey, T. E., and Yates, J. T., J . Catal. 63, 226 ( 1980).
6 . Krebs, H. J., Bonze], H. P., and Gafner, G., Surf. Sci. 88, 269 (1979). 7. Bonze], H. P., and Krebs, H. J., Surf. Sci. 91,499 (1980). 8. Polizzotti, R. S . , and Schwarz, J. A., J . Vac. Sci. Techno/. 17, 655 (1980). 9. Cabrera, A. L., Spencer, N. D., Kozak, E., Davies, P. W., and Somojai, G . A.. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 53, 1888 (1982). 10. Campbell, C. T., and Paffett, M. T., Surf. Sci. 139, 396 (1984). 11. Ichikawa. S . , and Wilson, M. S . , Rev. Sci. Instrum. 58, 317 (1987). 12. Rucker, T. G . . Frank, K., Colomb, D., Logan, M. A., and Somojai, G. A . , Rev. Sci. Instrum. 58, 2292 (1987). 13. Castle, J. E., Surf. Interface Anal. 9, 345 (1986). 14. Peuckert, M., Coehen, F. P., and Bonze], H. P.. Surf. Sci. 144, 515 (1985). I S . Peuckert, M., J . Electroanul. Chem. 185, 379 (1985). 16. Ross, P. N., and Wagner, F. T., Adu. Electrochem. Electrochem. Eng. 13,69 (1985). 17. Hubbard, A. T., Acc. Chem. Res. 13, 177 (1980). 18. Schardt, G . C., Stickney, J. L., Stern, D. A . , Wieckowski, A . , Zapien, D. C., and Hubbard, A . T.. Lungmuir 3, 239 (1987). 19. Ertl, G . , and Kiippers, J., “Low Energy Electrons and Surface Chemistry.” Verlag Chemie, Weinheim, 1985. 20. Woodruff, D. P., and Delchar, T. A,, “Modern Techniques of Surface Science.” Cambridge Univ. Press, New York, 1986. 21. Feldman, L. C., and Mayer. J. W., “Fundamentals of Surface and Thin Film Analysis.’’ North-Holland Pub]., New York, 1986.
50
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
22. Clarke, L. J., “An Introduction to Low Energy Electron Diffraction.” Wiley, New York, 1985. 23. Davis, S. M., Zaera, F., and Somojai. G . A., J . A m . Chem. SOC. 104, 7453 (1982). 24. Campbell. C. T.,and Koel, B. E.,Surf. Sci. 183, 100 (1987). 25. Campbell, C. T., and Paffett, M. T., Appl. Surf. Sci. 19, 28 (1984). 26. Campbell, C. T . , and Daube, K. A., J. Caral. 104, 109 (1987). 27. Campbell, C. T.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A 6, I108 (1988). 28. Herglotz, H. K., and Lynch, D. R.. J . Coll. Interface Sci. 105, 447 (1985). 29. Hoffman, F. M., and Robbins, J. L., J. Electron Spec. Relar. Phenom. 45,421 (1987). 30. Fischer, D. A., Dobler, U., Arvanitis, D., Wenzel, L., Babershki, K., and Stohr. J., Surf: Sci. 177, 114 (1986). 31. Blum, L., Abruna, H. D., White, J . , Gordon, J. G., Borger, G. L., Samart, M. G., and Melroy, 0. R., J . Chem. Phys. 85, 6732 (1986). 32. Zaera, F., Fischer, D. A., Shin, S., and Gland, J. L., Surf. Sci. 194, 205 (1988). 33. Redhead, P. A., Vacuum l2,203 (1962). 34. Falconer, J. L., and Madix, R. J., Surf. Sci. 48, 393 (1975). 35. Chan, C. M., Ark, R., and Weinberg, W. H., Appl. Surc Sci. 1, 360, 377 (1978). 36. Robertshaw, G., and Estrup, P. J., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. 15, 554 (1978). 37. Boudart, M., Proc. Inr. Congr. Card., 6rh, London 1, 1 (1976). 38. Katzer. J. R., J . C u r d 32, 166 (1974). 39. Ponec, V., Adu. Card. 32, 149 (1983). 40. Boudart, M., C H E M T E C H Nov., P-688 (1986). 41. Kummer, J. T.,J . Phys. Chem. 60, 666 (1956). 42. Wilson, J . N.. Voge, H. H., Stevenson, D. P., Smith, A. E., and Atkins. L. T., J . Phys. Chem. 63, 463 (1959). 43. Campbell, C. T.,J. Card. 94, 436 (1985). 44. Campbell, C. T.,J . Vac. Sci. Technol., A 2, 1024 (1984). 45. Sajkowski, D. J., and Boudart, M., Caral. Rev.-Sci. Eng. 29, 325 (1987). 46. van Santen, R. A., and Kuipers, H. P. C. E., Adu. Card. 35, 265 (1987). 47. Delgass, N., personal communication. 48. Campbell, C. T., J. Card. 99, 28 (1986). 49. Campbell, C. T.,and Paffett, M. T.,Sucf. Sci. 143, 517 (1984). 50. Somojai, G . A., Adu. Card. 26, I (1977). S l a . Somorjai, G . A., Science 227, 902 (1985). 516. Somojai, G. A., “Chemistry in Two Dimensions.” Cornell Univ. Press, New York, 1981. 52. Somojai, G. A., Chem. Soc. Rev. 13, 321 (1984). 53. Somojai, G . A., and Yeates, R. C., J. Electrochem. SOC. l31, 228C (1984). 54. Davis, S. M.. Zaera, F., and Somojai, G. A., J. Caral. 85, 206 (1984). 55. Gillespie, W. D., Herz, R. K.. Petersen, E. E., and Somojai, G. A., J . Carol. 70, 147 (1981). 56. Zaera, F., Godbey, D., and Somojai. G. A., J . C a d . 101, 73 (1986). 57. Dauscher, A., Garin, F., and Maire, G., J . C a r d . 105, 233 (1987). 58. Garin, F., Aeiyach, S . , Legare, P., and Maire, G., J . Card. 77, 323 (1982). 59. Herz, R. K., Gillespie, W. D., Petersen, E. E., and Somorjai, G. A., J . C a d . 67,371 (1981).
60. Rodriguez, J. A., and Campbell, C. T.,J . Phys. Chem. (in press) (1989). 61. Davis, S. M., Gillespie, W. D., and Somojai, G. A., J . Caral. 83, 131 (1983). 62. Seimanides, S. M., Campbell, J . M., and Campbell, C. T., J. Phys. Chem. (in press) ( I 989).
PRESSURE-VACUUM
ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
51
63. Davis. S . M., Zaera, F., and Somojai, G. A., J . Caral. 77,439 (1982). 64. Davis, S. M., and Somojai, G. A., J . Catal. 65, 78 (1980). 65. Massardier, J., Bertolini, J. C., Tri, T. M., Gallezot, P., and Imelik, B., Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr. 3, 333 (1985). 66. Zaera, F., and Somojai, G. A., J . Am. Chem. SOC. 106, 2288 (1984). 67. Davis, S. M., Zaera, F., Gordon, B. E., and Somojai, G. A., J. Card. 92,240 (1985). 68. Koel, B. E., Bent, B. E., and Somojai, G. A., Sutf Sci. 146, 211 (1984). 69. Oudar, J., Pinol, S., and Berthier, Y., J . C a r d 107, 434 (1987). 70. Goodman, D. W., Proc. inr. Congr. Caral., 8rh, Berlin 4, 3 (1984). 71. Goodman, D. W., Acc. Chem. Res. 17, 194 (1984). 72. Goodman, D. W., Surf Sci. l23, L679 (1982). 73. Goodman, D. W., J. Vac. Sci. Technol., A 2, 873 (1984). 74. Sault, A. G., and Goodman, D. W., J. Chern. Phys. 88, 7232 (1988). 75. Engstrom, J. R., Goodman, D. W., and Weinberg, W. H., J . Am. Chem. Soc. 108, 4653 (1986). 76. Engstrom, J. R., Goodman, D. W., and Weinberg, W. H., J. Vac. Sci. Technol., A 5 , 825 (1987). 77. Engstrom, J. R.. Goodman, D. W., and Weinberg, W. H., J . Am. Chem. SOC. 110, 8305 (1988). 78. Engstrom, J. R., Goodman, D. W., and Weinberg, W.H., J . Am. Chem. Soc. (in
preparation). 79. Wax, M. J., Kelley, R. D., and Madey, T. E., J. Card. 98,487 (1986). 80. Peden, C. H. F., and Goodman, D. W., ACS Symp. Ser. No. 288, 185 (1985). 81. Rucker, T. G . , Logan, M. A., Gentle, T. M.. Muetterties, E. L.,and Somotjai, G. A., J. Phys. Chem. 90,2703 (1986). 82. Niemantsverdriet, J. W., and van Langeveld, A. D., in "Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis: Catalysis 1987" (J. W. Ward, ed.), Vol. 38, p. 769. Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1988. 83. Spencer, N. D., Schoonmaker, R. C., and Somojai, G. A., J. Carol. 74, 129 (1982). 84. Strongin, D. R., Carrazza, J., Bare, S. R., and Somojai, G. A., J. C a d . 103, 213 ( 1987). 85. Asscher, M., Carrazza, J., Khan, M. M., Lewis, K. B., and Somojai. G . A., J. Catal. 98, 277 (1986). 86. Bozso, F., Ertl, G., Grunze, M., and Weiss, M., J. C a d . 49, 18 (1977). 87. Bozso, F., Ertl, G., and Weiss, M., J. Carol. 50, 519 (1977). 88. Haase, G., and Asscher, M., Surf. Sci. (in press). 89. Falicov, L. M., and Somojai, G. A., Proc. Narl. Acad. Sci. USA 82,2207 (1985). 90. Peden, C. H. F., Goodman, D. W.,Blair, D. S., Berlowitz, P. J., Fisher, G. B., and Oh, S. H., J. Phys. Chem. 92, 1563 and 5213 (1988); Goodman, D. W., and Peden, C. H. F., J. Phys. Chem. 90,4839 (1986). 91. Oh, S. H.. Fisher, G. B., Carpenter, J. E., and Goodman, D. W., J. Carol. 100, 360 (1986). 92. Peden, C. H. F., Berlowitz, P. J., and Goodman, D. W., Proc. Inr. Congr. Catal., 9th p. 1214 (1988). 93. Hendershot, R. E., and Hansen, R. S., J . Card. 98, 150 (1986). 94. Goodman, D. W., and Peden, C. H. F., J . Phys. Chem. 90,4839 (1986); correction, J. Phys. Chem. 91, 5832 (1987). 95. Yeates, R. C., Turner, J. E., Gellman, A. J., and Somojai, G. A., Surf. Sci. 149, 175 ( 1985). 96. Goodman, D. W., and Houston, J. E., Science 236, 403 (1987).
52
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
97. Castner, D. G., Blackadar, R. L., and Somojai, G. A., J . Card. 66, 257 (1980). 98. Logan, M., Gellman, A., and Somojai, G. A., J. Caral. 94, 60 (1985). 99. Udovic, T. J., Kelley, R. D., and Madey. T. E., Surf. Sci. 150, L71 (1985). 100. Szuromi, P. D., Kelley, R. D., and Madey, T. E., J. Phys. Chem. 90, 6499 (1986). 101. Berlowitz, P. J., and Goodman, D. W., J. Catal. 108, 364 (1987). 102. Campbell, C. T., Daube, K. A., and White, J. M., Surf. Sci. 182, 458 (1987). 103. Campbell, C. T., Appl. Card. 32, 367 (1987). 104. Gellman, A. J., Neiman. D., and Somojai, G. A., J. Catal. 107, 92, 103 (1987). 105. Bussell, M. E., and Somojai, G. A., J. Card. 106, 93 (1987). 106. Bussell, M. E., Gellman, A. J., and Somojai, G. A., J . Catal. 110, 423 (1988). 107. Spitzer, A., and Luth, H., Surf. Sci. 160, 353 (1985). 108. Goodman, D. W., Appl. Surf, Sci. 19, 1 (1984). 109. Goodman, D. W., and Kiskinova, M., Surf. Sci. 105, L265 (1981). 109a. Nakamura, J., Yamada, T., and Tanaka, K., Surf. Sci. 185, L515 (1987). 110. Peebles, D. E., Goodman, D. W., and White, J. M., J . Phys. Chem. 87,4378 (1983). 111. Szuromi, P. D., Kelley, R. D., and Madey, T. E., J . Vac. Sci. Technol., A 5, 867 (1987). 112. Oudar, J . , Pinol, S.. Pradier, C. M., and Berthier, Y., J. Catal. 107, 445 (1987). 113. Logan, M. A., Rucker, T. G . , Gentle, T. M., Muetterties, E. L., and Somojai, G. A., J . Phys. Chem. 90, 2709 (1986). 114. Bernard, J., Oudar, J., Barbouth, N., Margot, E.. and Berthier, Y . , Surf. Sci. 88, L35 (1979). 115. Bartholomew, C. H., Agrawal, P. K., and Katzer, J. R., Adu. C a d . 31, 135 (1982). 116. Garfunkel, E. L., Parmenter, J., Naasz, B. M., and Somojai, G. A., Langmuir 2, 105 (1986). 117. Campbell, C. T., and Paffett, M. T., Appl. Surf, Sci. 19, 28 (1984). 118. Campbell, C. T., and Koel, B. E., J . C a r d 92, 272 (1985). 119. Hasenberg, D., and Schmidt, L. D., J . Catal. 104, 441 (1987). 120. Tan, S. A., Grant, R. B., and Lamberg, R. M., J . Caral. 100, 383 (1986). 121. Tan, S. A., Grant, R. B., and Lambert, R. M., J. Catal. 106, 54 (1987). 122. Grant, R. B., Harbach. C., Lambert, R. M., andTan, S. A., J. Chem. SOC.,Faraday Trans 1 , 83, 2305 (1987). 123. Grant, R. B., and Lambert, R. M., in “Catalysis on the Energy Scene” (S. Kaliaguine and A. Mahay, eds.), p. 251. Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1984. 124. Grant, R. B., and Lambert, R. M., J . C a d . 92, 364 (1985). 125. Tan, S. A., Grant, R. B., and Lambert, R. M., Appl. Caral. 31, 159 (1987). 126. Tan, S. A.. Grant, R. B., and Lambert, R. M., J. C a d . 104, 156 (1987). 127. Campbell, C. T., and Goodman, D. W., Surf. Sci. l23, 413 (1982). 128. Rodriguez, J . A., and Campbell, C. T., J . Phys. Chem. 91, 2161 (1987). 129. Bonzel, H. P., and Krebs, H. J., Sutf Sci. 109, L527 (1981). 130. Bonzel, H. P., and Krebs, H. J., Surf. Sci. 117, 639 (1982). 131. Bonzel, H. P., Broden, G., and Krebs, H. J., Appl. Surf. Sci. 16, 373 (1983). 132. Wesner, D. A., Coenen, F. P., and Bonzel, H. P., Langmuir 1, 478 (1985). 133. Dwyer, D. J., and Hardenbergh, J. H., J. Caral. 87, 66 (1984). 134. Dwyer, D. J., and Hardenbergh, J. H., Appl. Surf. Sci. 19, 14 (1984). 135. Wesner, D. A., Linden, G., and Bonzel, H. P.. Appl. Surf. Sci. 26, 335 (1986). 136. Ertl, G . , Catul. Rev.-Sci. Eng. 21, 201 (1980). 137. Lee, S. B., Weiss, M., and Ertle, G., Surf Sci. 108, 357 (1981). 138. Paal, Z., Ertl, G., and Lee, S. B., Appl. Surf. Sci. 8, 231 (1981). 139. Ertl, G., Weiss, M., and Lee, S. B., Chem. Phys. Lett. 60, 391 (1979).
PRESSURE-VACUUM ANALYSIS OF MODEL CATALYSTS
53
Bare, S . R., Strongin, D. R., and Somojai, G. A., J. Phys. Chem. 90,4726 (1986). Zaera, F., and Somojai, G. A., J. Curd. 84, 375 (1983). Campbell, C T , and Koel, B. E., Surf. Sci. 186, 393 (1987). Campbell, C. T., Koel, B. E., and Daube, K. A,, J . Vuc. Sci. Techno/., A 5, 810 ( 1987). 144. Campbell, C. T., J. Phys. Chem. 89, 5789 (1985). 145. Campbell, C. T., and Daube, K. A., J. Curd. 106, 301 (1987). 146. Sachtler, W. M. H., CHEMTECH July, p. 434 (1983). 147. Sachtler, W. M. H., and van Santen, R. A.. Adu. Curd. 26,69 (1977). 148. Sinfelt, J. H., Sci. A m . 253(3), 90 (1985). 149. Sinfelt. J. H., and Cusumano. J. A., “Advanced Materials in Catalysis,” p. 1. Academic Press, New York, 1977. 150. Bauer, E . , in “Chemical Physics of Solid Surfaces and Heterogeneous Catalysis” (D. A. King and D. P. Woodruff, eds.), Vol. 3B, p. I . Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1984. 151. Biberian, J. P., and Somojai, G. A., J. Vuc. Sci. Techno/. 16, 2073 (1979). 152. Weissman-Wenocur, D. L., and Spicer. W. E., Surf. Sci. 133, 499 (1983). 153. Campbell, C. T., Surf. Sci. 167, L181 (1986). 154. Campbell, C. T., Paffett, M. T., and Voter, A. F., J . Vuc. Sci. Techno/.,A 4, 1342 (1986). 155. Sachtler, J. W. A., and Somojai, G. A., J. Curd. 81, 77 (1983). 156. Sachtler, J . W. A., and Somojai, G. A., J. Curd. 89, 35 (1984). 157. Sachtler, J. W. A., and Somojai, G. A., J . Card. 103, 208 (1987). 158. Campbell, C. T., Campbell, J. M., Dalton, P. J., Henn, F. C., Rodriguez, J. A., and Seimanides, S. G., J . Phys. Chem. (in press) (1989). 159. Peden, C . H. F., and Goodman, D. W., J . Curd. 104, 347 (1987). 160. Peden, C. H. F., and Goodman, D. W., J . Card. 100, 520 (1986). 161. Goodman, D. W., and Peden, C. H. F., 1nd. Eng. Chem. Fundum. 25, 58 (1986). 162. Goodman, D. W., Houston, J. E., and Peden, C. H. F., J. Vuc. Sci. Techno/., A 5 , 823 (1987). 163. Goodman, D. W., and Peden, C. H. F., J.C.S. Furuduy 1 8 3 , 1967 (1987). 164. Greenlief, C. M., Berlowitz. P. J., Goodman, D. W., and White, J. M., J . Phys. Chem. 91, 6669 (1987). 165. Tauster, S . J., A r c . Chem. Res. 20, 389 (1987). 166. Kao, C.-C., Tsai, S.-C., and Chung, Y.-W., J. Card. 73, 136 (1982). 167. Chung, Y.-W., Xiong, G., and Kao, C.-C., J. Curd. 85, 237 (1984). 168. Takatani, S., and Chung, Y.-W., Appl. Surf. Sci. 19, 341 (1984). 169. Demmin, R. A., KO, C. S., and Gorte, R. J., ACS Symp. Ser. No. 298, 48 (1986). 170. Demmin, R. A., and Gorte, R. J., J . Curd. 105, 373 (1987). 171. Demmin, R. A., KO, C. S., and Gorte, R. J., J. Phys. Chem. 89, 1151 (1985). 172. Demmin, R. A., and Gorte, R. J., J . Curd. 98, 577 (1986). 173. Levin, M. E., Salmeron, M., Bell, A. T., and Somojai, G. A., Surf. Sci. 169, 123 ( 1986). 174. Levin, M. E., Salmeron, M., Bell, A. T., and Somojai, G. A,, J. Card. 106, 401 140. 141. 142. 143.
(mn.
175. 176. 177. 178. 179. 180.
Tauster, S . J., Fung, S. C., and Garten, R. L., J . Am. Chem. Soc. 100, 170 (1978). Bischke, S . D., Goodman, D. W., and Falconer, J. L., Surf. Sci. 150, 351 (1985). Lee, Y. C., Tong, P., and Montano, P. A., Surf. Sci. 181, 559 (1987). Klier, K . , Adu. Curd 31, 243 (1982). Klier, K., Appl. Surf. Sci. 19, 267 (1984). Strongin, D. R., Bare, S. R., and Somojai, G. A., J . Cutal. 103, 289 (1987).
54 181. 182. 183. 184. 185. 186.
CHARLES T. CAMPBELL
Stoke, P., Phys. Scr. 36, 824 (1987). Stoke, P., and Norskov, J. K., J . Card. 110, 1 (1988). Strongin. D. R., and Somorjai, G . A., J . Caral. 109, 51 (1988). Sinfelt, J . H., J . Cural. 29, 308 (1973). Vannice, M. A.. and Twu. C. C., J . Catal. 82, 213 (1983). Levin, M. E.,Salmeron, M., Bell, A. T., and Somojai, G . A,, J.C.S. Faraduy I 83, 2061 (1987).
ADVANCES IN CATALYSIS, VOLUME 36
The Influence of Particle Size on the Catalytic Properties of Supported Metals MICHEL CHE Laboratoire de RPactivitP de Surface et Structure, UA 1106, CNRS Universiti Pierre et Marie Curie (Paris V I ) 75252 Paris Cedex 05, France
AND
CARROLL 0. BENNETT Department of Chemical Engineering University of Connecticut Storrs, Connecticut 06268
1.
Introduction
Metals constitute a wide class of catalysts, and because catalysis occurs on the surface, there is an economic incentive, especially for precious metals, to obtain catalysts in the form of small metal particles. This, however, raises two main problems. One is fundamental in nature and addresses the question as to below which particle size the metallic properties are lost. The other is more practical and concerns the preparation and characterization of very small particles and their catalytic activity. Let us consider a large metal particle that has electronic levels so close that they actually form bands. The spacing between adjacent levels is approximately expressed as (l a , b ): 6
z
&FIN
where eF is the Fermi level energy and N is the number of atoms in the particle. As the spacing between the levels becomes larger than the thermal energy kT, the levels begin to behave individually and the particle may lose its metallic properties. The critical size of the particle can be calculated by the above formula. At room temperature 6 = 2.5 x eV, 55 Copyright 0 1989 by Academic Press, Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
56
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
and with eFof the order of 10 eV, N is calculated to be approximately 400, which corresponds to a diameter of about 2 nm. This estimation is, of course, very approximate, but a lot of data confirm that the physical and catalytic properties start to change near this size and that catalysis is one of the most sensitive means to probe the surface of such particles. The other problem concerns the practical ways of producing metals with particle sizes around the critical value calculated above. The easiest and most practical way to achieve this goal is to deposit the metal in low concentration on a high-surface-area support. The main purpose of using a carrier is, of course, to achieve a high dispersion of the metal and to stabilize it against sintering. In a number of reactions, however, the metal support is not inert and the overall process is actually a combination of two functions: that of the metal and that of the catalytically active support. Thus, if an intrinsic size effect on catalytic properties is to be evidenced, much care should be taken to choose as much as possible a neutral nonactive support and to avoid using conditions that could possibly induce any metal-support interaction. These precautions are often not sufficient, and the preparation methods, as we shall see, are also likely to affect the final properties of the particles obtained. In the last decade, remarkable progress has been made in the preparation methods of supported metal catalysts. This has stimulated interest in the study of the relation between the catalytic behavior of metal particles and their mode of preparation with the aim of achieving the goal indicated above. Many workers have investigated the dependence of reaction rate on particle size. Early attempts to approach this problem were made by Kobosev and co-workers in the 1930s from the viewpoint of atomic dispersion and active ensembles. They studied the behavior of catalysts containing very small amounts of supported metal and were able to derive the number of atoms within the ensembles that were active for specific reactions (one atom for SO2 oxidation, two atoms for benzene hydrogenation, three atoms for ammonia synthesis, four atoms for acetylene oligomerization) (2a-c). These results as well as later ones have been reviewed by Gil’debrand (3). Boreskov et al. (4, 5 ) were the first to complete a systematic investigation of the relationship between particle size and catalytic activity, after their development of a technique for measuring the surface area of platinum catalysts by means of the selective chemisorption of hydrogen (6). They showed that the specific activity of platinum in the oxidation of sulfur dioxide ( 4 ) and of hydrogen (5) varied by less than one order of magnitude for catalyst samples differing in platinum surface area by four orders of magnitude. A few years later, Kobosev’s ideas were further
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE AND CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
57
investigated by Poltorak and Boronin on highly dispersed metals prepared by adsorption techniques (7u-d). Their studies led to many of the conclusions reached independently by Boudart et al. (8) for the hydrogenolysis of cyclopropane over supported Pt catalysts. One of the most important conclusions was that the rate per unit surface area of metal seemed for certain catalytic reactions very insensitive to the degree of dispersion of the metal. Boudart called these reactions facile (8)or structure-insensitive (9). The term structure refers to the coordination number of surface atoms that can be varied by exposing different crystallographic planes and making them imperfect by means of steps and kinks or by varying the particle size as can be done with supported metals (10). In the early work of Boreskov et ul. an apparent exception to this lack of sensitivity of activity to platinum particle size was observed for the H2DZexchange at low temperature (11). Other examples of the sensitivity of the specific activity to particle size were reported later on. Thus hydrogenolysis of ethane was found to depend on particle size for the Ni/AI2O3Si02 (12) and Rh/SiOz (13) systems. In the former case, the catalytic activity for unit surface area decreased for increasing particle size, whereas in the latter, an optimum particle size was associated with a maximum specific activity. These reactions were called “demanding” (8) or “structure-sensitive” (9) by Boudart, who drew attention to the difficulty of differentiating between metal-support interactions, the role of impurities, and mass-transfer limitations. This author proposed to select a molecule that can react along two parallel paths and to follow the change of selectivity with the particle size or the mode of preparation of the metal. The reaction of neopentane in the presence of hydrogen is a typical example (14). Reactions can now be classified into four categories (15) depending on how the turnover frequency TOF (the rate of the reaction expressed in moles per exposed metal atom and per unit time) varies as a function of the particle size d or of the fraction exposed (Fig. 1): the TOF of structure-insensitive or facile reactions does not depend on the particle size (curve 1). The TOF of structure-sensitive or demanding reactions may vary in two opposite ways: it may decrease when the particle size decreases, i.e., larger particles are more active than small ones; this is termed a negative particle size effect or antipathetic structure sensitivity (curve 2); or it may increase for decreasing particle sizes, i.e., smaller particles are more active than larger ones; this is called a positive particle size effect or sympathetic structure sensitivity (curve 4). The TOF may go through a maximum, for instance, if small particles exhibit a negative effect and larger ones a positive effect. In this case, those of an intermediate size will have maximum specific activity (curve 3). We have chosen
58
MICHEL C H E A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
d,nm
0
3
c I
Ln
LL
0
I-
9 ; 1
c
c
\
\
2
\
0
FE
1
FIG.1. Some of the ways in which turnover frequency has been found to vary with fraction exposed and particle size (see text for a discussion of the curves).
this numbering because it appears that only curves 1-3 can be reasonably understood as explained at the end of this review. The number of papers dealing with metal particles is extremely large: a computer survey based on volumes 66-101 of Chemical Abstracts gave the following numbers of references for the Group VIII metals. Fe, 213,818; Cu, 167,896;Ni, 140,550; Co, 83,827; Ag, 59,960; Pt, 39,268; Au, 36,444; Pd, 30,150; Rh, 14,761; Ru, 13,015; Ir, 7390; and Os, 4976. The same search restricted to particle size effects still gave 3,541 references. Our coverage had to be more limited and has been restricted to those papers in which curves of the types described above were presented. Unfortunately, the catalytic results are not always fully comparable. In fact, most works do not distinguish initial rate results (on clean surfaces) from steady-state rates (on semipoisoned surfaces), even though most refer to low conversions. Further, if a true particle size effect is to be evidenced, the metal particles must correspond as much as possible to the following criteria: they must be ( 1 ) monodisperse, (2) fully reduced, (3) unpoisoned (by liquid solvents or adventitious species), (4) unperturbed (by the carrier), and (5) unpromoted (by Ca, K, etc.). This goal is most clearly approached by methods based on vaporization of a metal by laser pulses, leading to a cloud of clean clusters of bare metal containing as few as one atom. Catalytic activity of clusters as a function of number of atoms can be obtained by time-of-flight mass spectrometry (16-18). Reviews have appeared in the past on particle size effects (3, 9, 10, 15, 19-24), but in the present one we attempt to give a comprehensive and
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE AND CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
59
comparative study of particle size effects, particularly with regard to catalytic properties. Although this review is limited to the intrinsic particle size effect, as exhibited by either model or practical systems, it is clear that activity or selectivity in a useful catalyst may be altered favorably (or unfavorably) by support interaction (25a), addition of promoters (25b,c), and bifunctionality, matters that were discussed earlier. Particle size effects are also important in related fields such as electrocatalysis (25d-31). For example, the reduction of dioxygen over Pt/C shows antipathetic structure sensitivity, leading to an optimal particle size of about 4 nm for a working electrode (31). However, work on electrochemistry is not included in this review. II. Preparation of Supported Metal Particles
A. INTRODUCTION Recent years have witnessed marked progress in the preparation of small metal particles. This has been achieved by the choice of a suitable support, the selection of the appropriate preparation method, or the combination of both. The selection of the carrier is relatively simple. It may be imposed by the type of reaction to be promoted. For instance, if the latter requires a bifunctional catalyst (metal + acid functions), acidic supports such as silica-aluminas, zeolites, or chlorinated aluminas, will be used. On the other hand, if the reaction occurs only on the metal, a more inert support such as silica will be used. In certain cases, other requirements (shock resistance, thermal conductivity, crush resistance, and flow characteristics) may dominate and structural supports (monoliths) have to be used. For the purpose of obtaining small metal particles, the use of zeolites has turned out to be an effective means to control their size. However, the problem of accessibility and acidity appearing on reduction may mask the evidence of the effect of metal particle size on the catalytic properties. The choice of the method is more complicated and depends on whether an industrial or a model catalyst is prepared. The most common industrial preparation methods involve several steps: (1) the distribution of a precursor compound over a carrier, (2) the drying and calcining of the resulting solid, and (3) the reduction of the precursor compound, which may, after steps 1 and/or 2, no longer be identical to the initial precursor, to obtain the active final metallic state. Rather than describe the numerous methods available in the literature, we shall in the following emphasize the advantages and disadvantages of each method with respect to the goal
60
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
to be achieved (i.e., the preparation of monodispersed metal particles). The design and preparation of supported catalysts have been the subject of several recent reviews (Ib, 3, 32-39, 40a-c).
B. THEVARIOUSPREPARATION METHODSFOR DEPOSITING THE METALPRECURSOR OR THE METAL This review begins with the more complex methods and moves on to the simpler ones. In this context, complexity is defined as the number of species involved before finally obtaining the highly dispersed metal particles. Table I summarizes the principal features of the different methods used to prepare the metal particles on a support, which is the common feature of all the methods and thus is not included in the table. They are subdivided into groups when the principles are similar. We could have ordered the preparation methods differently, for instance, using a chemical approach starting from the oxidation state and nuclearity of the metal in the precursor compound, but this would not have served our purpose, specifically, to show the parameters that can possibly influence the behavior of the final metallic state. 1.
Coprecipitation
Most methods deal with the formation of metal particles on a support that is preformed since this leads to simpler preparation processes. There is an important route, however, typically used for metal-SiOz and metalA1203 catalysts, which involves (Table I) the coprecipitation in a precursor form (hydroxides, nitrates, carbonates, silicates, etc.) of both the support and the active phase from a solution (37a,b, 38, 41). The advantage is to produce an intimate mixing of metal precursor and support. The precipitate leads on calcination to a support with the active component dispersed throughout the bulk as well as at the surface. After reduction to the final catalyst, it is difficult to obtain metal crystallites of uniform size (42,43) because of the presence of both the oxides (of the support and of the active metal) and other intermediate compounds [e.g., nickel aluminate or silicate for the Ni/A1203 (42) and Ni/Si02 (43) systems, respectively] that have different reducibilities. The coprecipitation can be improved in various ways so as to avoid any heterogeneity during the process. This is achieved in the superhomogeneous coprecipitation method, which consists of two steps. In the first, layers of the salt solutions are superposed and then mixed into a supersaturated solution instantaneously. The second step consists of forming a
TABLE I The Various Preparation Methods of Supported Metal Particles Further activation steps" Washing, hydrolysis, Solvent
Metal precursor
Inorganic
Salt
Inorganic Inorganic Inorganic
Solvated cation Complex anion Complex cation
Inorganic
Complex cation
Inorganic
Complex anion
organic
Metal cluster compound
Organic Organic
-
-
Metal cluster compound (solid or vapor) Metal colloid
Other species present
or Example
evacuation
Support precursor Precipitating agent Counteranion Countercation Counteranion Counteranion Competing cation Countercation Competing anion
-
Pd colloids/Si02
Atoms (metal vapor) Ions Atoms (metal vapor)
+ or - indicates whether or not the corresponding activation step has been performed. The method number, as referred to in the text, is indicated in parenthesis. TMI, transition metal ion.
Drying
Calcination
Reduction
Methodb
+
+
Coprecipitation (1)
+ + +
+
+ +
Impregnation (2)
+
+
+
+
Simple ion exchange (3) Competitive ion exchange (3)
+
+
-
+
+
-
+
-
-
-
-
Decomposition of metal cluster compound (4)
Chemical deposition ( 5 )
Ion implantation (6) Vapor-phase deposition (7)
62
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
homogeneous precipitate from this supersaturated solution ( 3 7 ~ )Some . authors produce the coprecipitation of the components in an organic solvent that is then evacuated under supercritical conditions. This leads to particularly high-surface-area materials (44, 45). The disadvantages of the coprecipitation method are that the precursor ions are also distributed within the bulk of the support oxide and that the pore structure of the final catalyst is more difficult to control than when one starts from a separately produced carrier. The next type of preparation method avoids these difficulties. 2. Impregnation
This method is begun by impregnating a preformed support with a solution of a metal salt. The solvent is removed by evaporation during drying (40a,b). When the amount of solution corresponds to the pore volume of the support, the method is more precisely referred to as the incipient-wetness impregnation. This method is used when there is little or no interaction between the precursor and the support. The advantages are technical simplicity, low cost, and reproducible metal loadings. If the metal content is limited by the solubility of the metal compound, multiple impregnation steps can be used. When the pores contain only air, the impregnation is referred to as capillary, whereas when they are filled by a solvent, the impregnation is called diffusional (46a). In some cases, precipitation of an active precursor onto a separately prepared carrier is also used, and this is known as the deposition-precipitation method (46b). Here the active precursor is precipitated onto the support by means of a chemical reaction, whereas in the classical impregnation method, it is “physically” deposited onto the carrier through removal of the solvent as described above. Recently, a new type of “dry” impregnation has been presented (46c,d),which consists of heating a mechanical mixture of the active precursor and the carrier. This leads to the spontaneous dispersion of the active precursor onto the support. This solid-solid adsorption is a spontaneous entropydriven process since, in contrast to what happens in gas-solid or liquidsolid adsorption, there is a change from an ordered (three-dimensional)to a less ordered (two-dimensional) structure of the active precursor, and this is a process of increasing entropy (46e). This type of solid-solid adsorption will be the subject of a forthcoming review (46f). In the case of impregnation, the subsequent step of drying (40a,b)is an important operation in the distribution of the active phase at the surface of the support. When a pellet with a uniform pore system is heated at a fast rate, a temperature gradient is established between its external surface
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE A N D CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
63
and its interior. Evaporation starts at the external surface, and the gasliquid interface moves toward the interior. The precursor concentration increases at the menisci, and the active phase is deposited on the pore walls. After reduction, the metal particles will be rather homogeneous in size. By contrast, if the drying rate is low, the active phase, which interacts little with the support, remains in the liquid phase so that the concentration in the active phase steadily increases. When the drying is finished, the active phase is found at the bottom of the pores. After reduction, the metal particles obtained will, therefore, depend on the volumes of the pores (47). If the latter are not uniform in size, the situation is more complex and there will be a correspondingly broad distribution of particle sizes in the finished catalysts. It should be noted that there is no washing step after impregnation (Table I) because this method involves little or no interaction between the precursor and the support. Thus, any washing would eliminate the precursor phase. During the calcination step, occurring between drying and reduction, two phenomena generally occur: (1) the precursor oxide is formed by decomposition of the impregnated salt, and (2) some chemical bonding is established between the precursor oxide and the support (48). As seen in Table I, the impregnation method may involve a precursor in the form of either a complex cation or a complex anion, with the disadvantage that counterions are always present. During the calcination step, such ions may lead to uncontrolled side reactions producing strongly held species, such as nitrogen-containing species (NO, N02, NO;) for samples prepared from nitrates (49) or ammonium compounds (50). The next preparation method avoids this problem to a large extent.
3. Zon Exchange This technique is used when the precursor interacts with the support. The interactions are basically controlled (52) by (1) the type of support and state of the surface (number and nature of the functional groups, their acid-base properties) and (2) the impregnating solution (pH, type and concentration of the metal precursor, and presence of competing ions). In this method, also called dipping impregnation, wet soaking impregnation, impregnation with adsorption, or adsorption from solution, the support is immersed in a solution of the metal compound. The slurry is stirred for a given time, filtered, and possibly washed. The resulting product is then dried. The concentration of the precursor solution may be readjusted and recycled. This technique is widely used in the preparation of laboratory and industrial catalysts. Depending on the strength and conditions of adsorption of the precursor species, the concentration of the
64
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
active phase may be varied. This method thus leads to a greater control over the dispersion and distribution of the active species within a catalyst pellet. Because the precursor interacts with the support, it is not eliminated easily by washing. The metal loading is governed by the concentration of adsorption sites on the support oxide. As a consequence, the weight of the active component that can be incorporated is limited. One can increase the metal loading by successive impregnations, but this is not recommended if a careful control of the physical parameters is to be achieved. Another disadvantage is the high cost of the process because of lower productivity and complex precursor solution recycling in the case of costly precursors. a. Surface Charge of Oxides in Suspension. Most oxides are amphoteric and when immersed in an aqueous solution present surface charges that are controlled by the equilibria S-OH;
tH+ -OH7 S-OH = +OH- S-0-
+ H20
where S-OH represents a surface adsorption site. The addition of an acid shifts the equilibrium to the left, increasing the number of positive charges on the surface: the oxide behaves as an anion exchanger. Conversely, the addition of a base shifts the equilibrium to the right, increasing the number of negative charges: the oxide behaves as a cation exchanger. When the number of positive and negative charges at the oxide surface is equal, the corresponding pH is the isoelectric point of the solid (IEPS) or the zero point of charge (ZPC). The isoelectric point can be determined by electrophoresis measurements. The, values of the IEPS, which are known for a number of oxides, reflect the chemical composition of the solid and the electrolyte in which it is immersed (52, 53). Structural or adsorbed anionic impurities shift the IEPS to more acidic values, and cationic impurities shift it to more basic values or toward the IEPS characteristic of the impurity oxide (53). Above the IEPS value, the oxides will behave as cation exchangers and as anion exchangers below that value. The further one gets from this value, the larger the surface charge and the exchange capacity (54). b. Simple Zon Exchange. Among the supports, zeolites, Si02-AI203, and Si02 adsorb cations; A1203,Ti02,and Cr2O3, which are amphoteric, adsorb anions in acidic and cations in basic solutions; MgO, La203,and ZnO adsorb only anions (36, 41, 53). The adsorption equilibria can be represented by the following equations (36): S-OH
+ C+ =S-0-C+ + H+
cation adsorption
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE A N D CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
S-OH
+ A- + H+ =S-0H;A-
65
anion adsorption
A very interesting feature of the ion-exchange method is that the counterion can be easily removed by washing (Table I) because it is repelled from the surface that possesses charges of the same sign. This is an important advantage over the impregnation method, where washing cannot be used because of the weak interaction between the precursor and the surface. In the ion-exchange method, the cations C+ or the anions A- tend to saturate the first adsorption sites so that most of the compound adsorbs near the pore mouth, and a large concentration gradient develops within the pellet pore. There are several ways to obtain a more uniform distribution: (1) a large supply of compound is used so as to saturate every adsorption site, (2) the support may be left for a long time in contact with the solution, and (3) competing ions are added to the solution, which will adsorb on the same sites as the ions of the metal precursor. This is the subject of the method discussed next. c . Competitive Zon Exchange. This method, also called chromarographic adsorption, involves the competition between two types of ion for the same adsorption sites (Table I). The competitive exchange has long been known for anions (55), whereas the competitive cation exchange has been developed more recently (56). The competitive ion-exchange equilibria can be represented by the following: S-0-C+
S-0H;A-
+ D+ =S-O-D+ + C+ + B- =S-OH;B- + A-
competitive cation exchange competitive anion exchange
A typical example is illustrated by the following reactions: Si-O--H+ 2Si-0-NH:
+ NH3
+ [Pt(NH3)4]2+
Si-0-NH; (Si-0-)2[Pt(NH3)4]2+
+ 2NH:
where the NH: and [Pt(NH3)4]2+ ions are competing for the same surface Si-0- sites. By varying the concentration of NH: competing ions, it is possible to shift the equilibrium of the second reaction presented in the typical example above and to control the deposition of the precursor metal species onto the oxide surface to obtain a homogeneous distribution. The adsorption of the precursor metal species by oxide surfaces can be accompanied by a ligand reaction (57a) between a surface site and a ligand on the metal complex, with the result that the surface becomes a mono- or polydentate ligand within the metal ion coordination sphere (57b-e):
66
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
(Si-O-)2[Ni(NH,),]2+
=[(Si-O)2Ni(NH3)4] + 2NH3
This stronger interaction between the metal precursor and the surface and its homogeneous distribution leads, after reduction, to highly dispersed metal particles. Very often, though, because of their strong interaction with the surface, the precursor ions are difficult to reduce at the temperatures where metal aggregation is not important. The final state thus consists of highly dispersed metal particles anchored onto the surface by means of a “chemical glue” composed of partially reduced or unreduced ions (58). In order to avoid this problem of incomplete reduction, which becomes all the more important as the particle size decreases (59), a number of attempts have been made to bypass the reduction step and to deposit the metal directly in its zero-valent state. There are different methods for this, and they are discussed separately below. 4.
Decomposition of Metal Cluster Compounds
Ever since Parkyns (60) prepared nickel particles on oxide (A1203,Si02) surfaces by decomposition of nickel carbonyl, metal cluster compounds (alkoxides, carbonyls, organometallics, etc.) have been used increasingly for the production of laboratory metal catalysts (Table I), and several reviews have appeared on this subject (61-65a,b). Metal cluster compounds were initially employed for the two following purposes. The first concerned the formation of heterogeneous analogs of homogeneous active catalysts, and the second dealt with the production of small metal particles. The major advantage of the latter approach is that the temperatures usually required to decompose the metal cluster compounds and produce small metal particles are substantially lower than those observed for the reduction of metal salts (nitrates, chlorides) involved in conventional methods so that the number of atoms initially present in the complex can be preserved, e.g., Ni3 if one starts from trinuclear nickel clusters (66). However, the results using this approach have not been always as promising as originally believed (64). Metal cluster compounds are usually anchored onto an oxide surface via the two following routes: 1.
reaction involving surface hydroxyl groups S-OH: nS-OH
+ MX,
[S-O].MX,-,
+ nHX
The metal content is controlled by the concentration of surface S-OH groups, the stoichiometry of the reaction, and the number of metal atoms within the cluster.
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE A N D CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
67
2. reaction first to produce functional anchoring groups at the oxide support surface and then to anchor the metal cluster compound [A number of functions can be selected as well as their further reactions, and this subject has been extensively reviewed (62)l.
From recent literature data, there are many cases in which the resulting surface products, after anchoring, are not in a zero-valent state but rather form a mixture of species so that the metal is both in zero-valent and partially oxidized states. Most studies on functionalized supports have been made on hydroxylated oxide surfaces. The metal particles produced on such supports are not of an unusually high degree of dispersion. The nature of the decomposition process on dehydroxylated supports has not been as thoroughly studied as on hydroxylated supports. Preliminary results, however, indicate that formation of highly dispersed zero-valent metal particles may be obtained (64). The other disadvantage of the metal cluster compound decomposition is that the ligands, which have to be removed to produce the metal particle, and the organic solvent used to impregnate the support by the precursor compound may remain on the surface and thus interfere later in the catalytic reaction. The problem of the solvent can sometimes be avoided by using volatile metal cluster compounds (6%). The next method based on depositing colloidal metal particles onto a support removes the problem of incomplete reduction, i.e., the presence of the mixture of reduced and unreduced species, but does not remove that of the solvent. 5 . Chemical Deposition from a Metal Colloid Dispersion
In this method, the preformed metal is adsorbed as individual particles onto a carrier, both suspended in a solvent (Table I) (67,68).The size and structure of the colloids are not influenced by the support (69), but the liquid medium may contain species that are by-products of the preparation and that may complicate the situation unless removed by dialysis. In various attempts to use this method the metal particle size, which depends on the metal and the preparation conditions, is usually larger than that obtained by the preceding methods. A more sophisticated technique, the so-called solvated metal atom dispersion technique, has been developed by Klabunde and Tanaka (70). It involves the evaporation of metal atoms in the presence of complexing solvents to yield “solvated” metal atoms. The solution is brought into contact with the support at low temperatures and the slurry obtained is warmed to room temperature. The excess solvent is removed by further
68
MlCHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. B E N N E T T
evacuation. Although attractive, this method presents the disadvantage that the small crystallites are surrounded by organic fragments. Those fragments may affect the catalytic and magnetic properties of the metal particles (71). Several solutions have been proposed to avoid these organic fragments, and we shall review two of those, which can, however, produce only model catalysts. In these methods, only the metal is deposited on the support; one concerns the deposition of the metal in its oxidized state and the other, in its zero-valent state. 6 . Ion Implantation
The principle of this method is to select by mass spectroscopy a positively charged ion, for example l9W+,which is implanted by ion bombardment of a given support (Table I) (72). The ion-implantation technique is simpler when single crystals are used, for instance, Mg(100) (73). Since electrons are readily available in the ion implanter, the ion is quickly neutralized and the neutralized form of the element implanted can be finally found either as a gas (e.g., Xe) or as a metal (e.g., Pt) in the outer layers of the oxide exposed to ion implantation (74). The advantage of this method is that, in contrast to all previous methods, it involves only the metal and the support and that metal-support interactions concern only a single face of the support (75). The disadvantage is that the metal is not located only at the oxide surface but also within the oxide and the concentration profile is critically dependent on the energy of the implanted ions. The other problem is that a number of defects are produced during the bombardment that may interfere later in catalysis. However, this effect can be evaluated (75) if ions of similar weight but that are catalytically inactive (e.g., Xe') are implanted under the same conditions (energy, angle, and time of ion implantation). The next method avoids the problems caused by the implantation profile and the presence of defects.
7 . Metal Vapor Deposition This method (Table I), like the preceding one, eliminates the problem of any spurious species (counterion, ligand, solvent, etc.) and has the advantage that it does not alter physically the support surface. There are a number of other advantages, which can be listed as follows: 1. When they come to land on the surface, the atoms are in their zerovalent state, except for those atoms that may be reoxidized by surface OH groups by reaction such as (61) Ni" + OH =Ni2+ + 0'-+ 1H2
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE
A N D CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
69
2. There is thus no thermal reduction step involved, and this suppresses both any sintering process and the formation of some strongly adsorbed hydrogen phase, which, for small particles, can decrease or even eliminate the catalytic activity (58, 76, 77). The “reduction” degree is thus much larger than that obtained for similar sizes with conventional methods. 3. The dispersion can be controlled by monitoring only the time of evaporation (78). For small times of evaporation, atomic dispersion can be obtained all the more easily because the system does not need to be heated as in other methods for thermal reduction. The surface atom diffusion is thus drastically slowed down. 4. Finally, heterogeneous nucleation theory can be applied (79), and it affords an independent way of estimating the particle size, particularly difficult if not impossible to measure close to atomic dispersion by conventional methods because of the low metal content of such model catalysts.
There are, of course, some limitations. An obvious one is that this method cannot be applied yet to the preparation of industrial catalysts, another one is its cost because ultra-high-vacuum (UHV) equipment is required. This drawback explains why this method is usually coupled to surface techniques such as XPS, UPS, RHEED, and AES, which also require UHV. The last disadvantage is that the best suited supports are those that are flat, i.e., oxide single-crystal faces, oxides produced by oxidation of a metal single crystal, or compressed powder oxides. There have been several examples where the preparation chamber also serves as sample chamber for surface techniques and is coupled to a catalytic reactor. Whereas there are a number of works using this approach for bulk metals (80),there are, by contrast, few studies dealing with metals supported on either single crystals (81) or polycrystalline supports (78,79,82, 83). The latter type of system appears to be the model catalysts closest to the real catalyst.
C. FURTHER ACTIVATION STEPS The preceding paragraphs have introduced the various preparation methods leading eventually to supported metal particles. These methods fall obviously into two categories depending on whether the metal is basically in its zerovalent state (decomposition of metal cluster compound, chemical deposition, ion implantation, and vapor-phase deposition) or in an oxidized state (coprecipitation, impregnation, and ion exchange)(Table I).
70
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
For the latter methods, it is necessary to reduce the ions to obtain the metal. In some cases, a calcination is performed before the reduction. We shall now concentrate on these two stages.
I. Calcination Very often, calcination is carried out in air or oxygen and leads to the following transformations: 1. formation of the oxide system on decomposition of the precursor compound and subsequent bonding of the formed oxide with the support (typically observed for catalysts prepared by impregnation), 2. removal of some of the elements introduced during the preparation by formation of volatile compounds ( S 0 2 , NO2, COZ, etc.), 3. decomposition of the precursor ionic complex and further ligand exchange reactions between surface groups (OH, 0 2 -and ) ligands bound to the metal ion, resulting in stronger precursor-support interactions (typical of catalysts prepared by ion exchange), 4. elimination of carbonaceous impurities possibly introduced during the preparation, and 5 . sintering of the precursor compound or of the formed oxide system.
Consequently, calcination may have a pronounced effect on the reducibility, dispersion, and distribution of the metal in the final catalyst. For instance, high-temperature treatment may lead to very stable solid solutions or to large oxide crystals, particularly for catalysts prepared by impregnation. In the case of solid solutions, the metal is difficult to reduce because of strong precursor-support interactions. This can be overcome by higher reduction temperatures. Because of these strong precursorsupport interactions, high dispersion of the metal can be achieved in the final catalysts (84). By contrast, large oxide crystals will lead, after reduction, to low dispersions of the metal. For catalysts prepared by impregnation, it is often observed that the final particle size distribution reflects the different types of precursor-support bonding obtained after calcination, and this depends on the metal loading. Thus, for Ir-Ti02 systems prepared by impregnation (83,it has been observed that two types of particles were formed after calcination in air and reduction by hydrogen. One corresponded to small particles issued from precursors ion exchanged on the support surface and in amount never in excess of the monolayer; the other corresponded to large particles issued from precursors impregnating the support and observed for metal loading exceeding the monolayer. There have been relatively few studies on the influence of treatment
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE A N D CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
71
conditions on metal dispersion, and most concern platinum. Kubo et ul. (86) reported that the temperature of calcination in air before hydrogen reduction was the key parameter determining the platinum dispersion in RNaY and RNH4Y zeolites. The best dispersion was obtained for air calcination at 300°C. In many cases, the calcination in air is used to carefully control the decomposition of ion complexes used as precursors and to develop strong interactions with the support so that after reduction, small metal particles are formed (58, 87u,b).
2. Reduction The conditions of reduction are particularly important since they can strongly affect the final distribution of the metal particles (88). In studies of nucleation and film growth from metal vapor, it is generally observed that the crystallite size is determined by the saturation density of nuclei, which is found to increase with decreasing substrate temperature due to shorter adatom migration distances (89).In the case of nucleation in metal oxide reduction, an opposite trend is found. Higher temperatures will favor more rapid initial reduction of the metal oxide and higher density of nuclei but also coalescence or sintering of particles. An intermediate temperature must be found that leads to the maximum nuclei concentration without any appreciable coalescence. The parameters probably effecting this compromise are the presence of nucleation sites that may correspond to surface defects (90) and the presence of water vapor, which usually leads to an increased mass transfer (92).It is thus anticipated (88)that the smaller particles should be obtained (1) by using starting materials that will maximize the defect concentration in the final support, (2) thoroughly drying the supports at the lower temperatures to avoid changing the defect concentration, and (3) using a high flow rate of hydrogen in the reduction process while keeping the temperature low. This high flow rate of hydrogen lowers the partial pressure of water vapor and increases the rate of reduction at lower temperatures (92).Once nucleation has started, hydrogen can dissociatively chemisorb on the metal nuclei that are formed. The hydrogen atoms are mobile and can migrate to the metal particle-metal oxide interface and be used in reduction of the oxide. This causes a much more rapid reduction since hydrogen atoms react with either the metal ion (93) or the oxide ion 02-(94) more readily than does molecular hydrogen at the same temperature. The technique of hydrogen atom beams produced by a microwave discharge has been used to produce small metal particles (58, 93). The microwave discharge technique has also been used to decompose metal carbonyl compounds and small metal particles have been obtained (95).
72 111.
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
Background for Evaluating the Catalytic Properties of Small Supported Particles
A. DEFINITIONS In his interesting article on particle size effects, Bond (21) gives the results of model calculations based on spheres and on cubes with five faces exposed, for Ni, Pt, and Pd. For these simple systems, the fraction of total metal atoms exposed, FE, is related to the diameter or length of a side d (in the figures, d is written with a bar above it to highlight the fact that it is an average value) by the approximate formula Bld,
FE
= 11.0,
d > 1 nm d < 1 nm
where d is in nanometers and B is about 1 nm. In discussing the literature on structure sensitivity we shall use B = 1 .O nm in Eq. ( I ) , realizing that B varies from one metal to another or as the morphology changes with d for a given metal. We define the atomic rate of reaction AR as the rate of production of a given product, with the units S - I , or moles of product per mole of total metal atoms per second. This is the rate that we strive to maximize for economic reasons, as far as catalyst development is concerned. However, it is convenient to decompose the atomic rate AR into two factors of a more fundamental nature:
AR = (TOF)(FE) (2) where TOF is the turnover frequency, s - I (per second), a rate expressed as moles of product per mole of surface metal atoms per second. In general, TOF is a function of d ; such systems are structure-sensitive. For certain systems TOF is not a function of d , and these cases are called structure-insensitive. In this work we review the behavior of TOF(d) for various metals and supports and for various reactions. The essence of this behavior was presented elegantly by Boudart (10). However, it is now clear that other factors in addition to d commonly affect the turnover frequency. We prefer the term fraction-exposed (96) to dispersion, since the latter conveys an idea of distribution in space that is not directly related to particle size and shape. The quantity FE is commonly measured by hydrogen chemisorption at room temperature, using the equation H/M FE = H/M,
(3)
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE A N D CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
73
The quantity H/M, i.e., H atoms irreversibly adsorbed divided by total metal atoms, is measured experimentally. H/M,, where M, refers to surface metal atoms, may be known on the basis of surface science studies [e.g., low-energy electron diffraction (LEED)] and is usually assumed equal to unity. However, we shall discuss some papers that show that H/M, is also a function of d and other variables. In addition, reversibly adsorbed hydrogen may also be important (97,98). For interpreting most data, nevertheless, we can only assume that FE = HIM. It seems reasonable to use surface metal atoms as a basis, and not surface sites. The number of surface atoms required to form a site is in many cases a subject of debate, whereas H/M is measured experimentally. Turnover frequency is preferred in the IUPAC report (96) to turnover number TON, for it has the correct units. A number implies a dimensionless quantity, whose magnitude is independent of the system of units. TON also seems to suggest an aura of a physical constant, referring to a property of a particular catalyst system. Since TOF is a rate, a function of temperature, pressure, and fluid composition in addition to d, etc., turnover rate had been suggested as a more appropriate name (99). These ideas are clearly discussed by Boudart and Djega-Mariadassou (100, 101), where rate is expressed as vitesse de rotation or turnover rate. We have defined TOF in terms of moles of a certain compound, relating to the idea of a yield. Thus, for methanation, we have TOFco and TOFcH,, etc. Ichikawa et al. ( 1 0 2 ~have ) used the term site-timeyield (STY), but we do not propose such a departure from ingrained habits. Often rates are expressed per unit mass of supported catalyst, and we can define the activity A, moles of product per second per kilogram of supported catalyst, as A = (AR)(C)/AW
(4)
where C is the catalyst loading, kilogram (metal)/kilogram (metal + support), and AW is the atomic weight of the metal. In line with the usual meaning of “specific,” A might be called a specific rate, but this term has, unfortunately, become associated with a rate per unit area of metal. This term seems unnecessary, because for well-defined surfaces TOF is interpreted as molecules reacted per surface metal atoms per second. Because of these difficulties, the latest version of the IUPAC manual (102b) expresses activity as mass-specific rate, rate per unit area as area-specific rate, and volumetric rate (see below) as volume-specific rate. For reactor design, the usual volumetric rate is convenient, written as r = ApB
(5)
74
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
where r is moles per second per cubic meter of bed and p~ is the bed density expressed in kilograms of catalyst per cubic meter of bed. We have taken pains to present these definitions because it seems that the organization and understanding of catalytic results is hampered by lack of agreement on these simple details. Rates may be expressed as turnover frequency, atomic rate, activity, or volumetric rate, provided the authors determine also H/M, C, and p ~ and , defend their choice of H/M,. Of course, d should be measured independently if possible, as should the morphology of the metal particles. We emphasize the simplicity of Eqs. (1-5). It would seem desirable to express all kinetic results in terms of these rates. From a fundamental point of view, results on TOF(d) furnish important data for testing models of catalysis. We shall discuss how such results may be explained in terms of the geometric and the electronic properties of supported metals. From a practical point of view, the form of Eq. (2) shows that there may be a value of d that maximizes the value of AR, depending on how TOF varies with d.
B. POSSIBLE EXPLANATIONS OF PARTICLE SIZEEFFECTS 1. Electronic Effects
As the number of atoms in an isolated metal particle is reduced, the differences in energy levels of the valence electrons will eventually become appreciable with respect to kT. In the limit the discrete levels associated with an isolated atom would prevail. Thus, we expect a variation in the catalytic properties of small particles because of this electronic effect, which applies to all the atoms of the particle. However, the proportion of the total atoms present on the surface and thus in various states of coordination with respect to the other metal atoms will also change. The electronic configuration of these surface atoms is changed, leading to changes in the catalytic properties. This second electronic effect may be viewed as having a geometric origin, so that the usual division of size effects into electronic and geometric is somewhat arbitrary. Some attempts have been made to measure the electronic properties of small particles by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). The preparation of samples of isolated small metal particles is not easy. The most successful methods are either vapor deposition of noble metals (Pt or Pd) on carbon or silica, or ion exchange used to prepare metals in Y zeolite. For the noble metals and inert supports used, it is assumed that the metal particles are isolated from each other. The results of several studies are presented in Fig. 2, in which the
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE AND CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
1 I
3.0
10
i.nm L O 2.0
1.0
7s
0.L
ZD > al
Y
m
a in
FIG. 2. Binding energy shifts ABE of metal core levels measured-by photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) versus fraction exposed F E and mean particle size d for various supported metal systems (see Table I1 for details of the studies).
TABLE I1 Details of the Supported Metal Systems Studies Presented in Fig. 2 Curve (Fig. 2)
Metal and electron
BEu for bulk (eV) 335.0 335.0 335.0 71.5 314.5 314.0 71.3 314.6
~~~
support
Referenceb
C Y-Zeolite Si02 Y-Zeolite C A1203
Si02 A1203
~~
BE = binding energy; ABE = BE(observed) - BE(bu1k). References: (a) Takasu, Y., Akimaru, T., Kasahara, K., and Matsuda, Y., J . Am. Chem. SOC. 104,5249 (1982); (b) Vedrine, J. C., Dufaux, M., Naccache, C., and Imelik, B., J.C.S. Faraday f74,440 (1978); (c) Takasu, Y., Unwin, R., Tesche, B., Bradshaw, A. M., and Grunze, M., Surf. Sci. 77,219 (1978); (d) Mason, M. G., Gerenser, L. J., and Lee, S.-T., Phys. Rev. Lett. 39, 288 (1977); (e) Huizinga, T., van? Blick, H. F. J., Vis. J. C., and Prins, R., Surf. Sci. 135, 580 (1983); (f) Masson, A,, Bellamy, B., Colomer, G., M'bedi, M., Rabette, P., and Che, M., Proc. f n t . Congr. Catal., 8th 4, 333 (1984); (g) Masson, A., Bellarny, B., Hadj Romdhane, Y., Che, M., Roulet, H., and Dufour, G., Su$. Sci. 173,479 a
(1986).
76
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
appropriate electron energies are shown to change with metal particle size. It appears that for particles of diameter greater than about 5 nm, the energy levels are those of the bulk metal. For particles of 5 nm, the fraction exposed is about 0.2, and the number of atoms varies from 3000 to 6000, depending on the metal and its morphology. For Pd, the energies stop changing below about 1.O nm, where all the atoms are exposed. For Pt, the changes continue until even smaller particles are reached. The three energies of Fig. 2 in the small-particle limit for Pd show considerable differences. Is this so because of the three different supports used? This explanation would imply that the particles are not really isolated from their supports. 2. Geometric Effects
a . Mathematical Models Based on Regular Small Crystallites. van Hardeveld and Hartog (20) have published the results of many calculations describing the arrangements of the atoms in small metal particles. Many graphs and sketches of small crystallites are presented. As an example, we show in Fig. 3a an octahedron made up of atoms in the facecentered cubic (fcc) system. The three types of surface atom are indicated by the symbols C9, face atoms; C7, edge atoms; and C4,corner atoms. A bulk atom is Clz. The subscripts on C indicate the coordination of a particular atom. The superscripts of Cj refer to a system for identifying which of the 8 atoms are missing in C4, for example. The original work should be consulted for details. For the various possible small octahedrons, the ratio N(C,)IN, has been calculated (20), where N(Cj) is the number of atoms of coordination Cj and N, is the number of surface atoms. These quantities vary with the total number of atoms, which, in turn, can be related to d for a given metal. Figure 3b shows, as a function of d for Ni, the fraction of the surface atoms that are made up of each of the three typical atoms of Fig. 3a. The fraction of face atoms C9 in Fig. 3b becomes about 0.9 at about 6 nm and falls to zero at about 0.6 nm, where all the atoms are at edges and corners. The effect of surface atom coordination makes itself felt in general for particles smaller than 4 nm. These changes are, of course, linked to changes in electronic characteristics also. Supposedly the catalytic properties of the metal are linked to N(Cj)IN, of Fig. 3b, and it is implied that one-atom sites are involved. For example, if catalysis is favored by atoms of low coordination, small particles would give higher rates. If catalysis is favored by face atoms, large particles
77
b
I
1
10
4.0- 2.0 1.0
0.L
d,nrn(Ni)
FIG.3. (a) Face-centered cubic (fcc) octahedron, m = 9 ( m is the number of atoms alon_g an edge). From Ref. 20. (b) Coordination of surface atoms versus the mean particle size d for nickel, assuming that the particle is a face-centered cubic (fcc) octahedron. The symbols cprt,. refer to atoms identified in (a).
would give higher rates (10). The former case corresponds to sympathetic structure sensitivity and the latter, to antipathetic structure sensitivity. Since ordinary supported catalysts exhibit a distribution of crystal sizes, it is clear that the effects may be more diffuse than those suggested by Fig. 3b. This distribution can be measured and controlled in model catalysts (79).
78
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
As a model of a small crystallite is built up by adding atoms one by one (103), a complete octahedron or other regular shape is reached only periodically ( 1 0 4 , for instance, at particles with a number of atoms of 6, 19,
44,etc. (20) for an octahedron. Adding the 20th, 21st, etc. atom starts a new layer and creates atoms of different coordination. At the edges of added layers, a particularly interesting ensemble of five atoms is formed, called a Bs site (20). Crystallites are considered to be fcc octahedra with extra layers of atoms on each face. If the extra layers are added in such a way as to produce the maximum total number of BS sites, the metallic particle illustrated in Fig. 4a is obtained. There are now some atoms in coordination states that did not exist in Fig. 3a. Figure 4b is based on calculations for a shape similar to that in Fig. 4a (20). For this more complicated arrangement, the fraction of face atoms CS falls to 0.9 at about 20 nm and goes to zero at about d = 2.5 nm. Geometric effects thus persist to higher d than in Fig. 3b. It is probable that catalysis for certain reactions requires a site made up of a particular ensemble of surface atoms. The number of adjacent atoms’ required may increase from 2 for the dissociative adsorption of oxygen or hydrogen to something like 12 for ethane hydrogenolysis (105). The Bs sites seem to have particular importance in catalysis, and it is claimed that they are necessary for the appearance of infrared-active adsorption of nitrogen (106). The concentration of BS sites is very sensitive to the shape of the crystallite. For various crystals containing 683 atoms, van Hardeveld and Hartog (20) calculate a number of Bs sites ranging from 76 to 0; for example, 36 for a sphere, 76 for a cubooctahedron, 13 for a cube, and 0 for many other possible arrangements. For a nickel crystal of octahedral shape van Hardeveld and van Montfoort (106) calculate that there are no BS sites for particles of d below 1.2 nm. Then the curve for the fraction of Bs sites on the surface passes through a distinct maximum of 0.17 at 1.8 nm and then falls so that it is 0.072 at 4.4 nm (4009 atoms). Sites made up of two atoms or more are thought to be important in various catalytic systems. For example, Dalmon and Martin (105) proposed that 12 atoms are needed for a site for the hydrogenolysis of ethane. At the present moment, the BS sites serve as a popular explanation of structure sensitivity, for curves of TOF versus d for a number of reactions pass through a maximum in the range of around 2-3 nm (107-112). Further discussion of this matter is reserved until after a presentation of the results from the literature. From the foregoing, it is clear that geometric effects may be important out to much larger particles than would be deduced from Fig. 2b. One lesson to be learned from these geometric considerations, which have
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE A N D CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
I
100
,
#
I
1
1
79
,
LO 2 0 -10 4.0 21) 1.0 d,nm(Ni)
FIG.4. (a) Face-centered cubic (fcc) octahedron-max B5.From Ref. 20. The shaded atoms represent one of the possible B5 sites. (b) Coordination of surface atoms versus the mean particle size a for nickel, assuming that the particle has a face-centered cubic (fcc) octahedron-max B5 structure. The symbols Cip.+‘,.-refer to atoms identified in (a).
been available for some years, is that fundamental studies on structure sensitivity must include data on the crystallite shapes. Modern computeraided electron microscopy should make this possible (113, 114). As time passes it should also become more practical to check the plausibility of models by quantum-mechanical calculations. Other calculations and experimental work (104, 114) have shown that the situation is probably in reality more complicated than that described
80
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
above. Most small fcc metal particles ( d = 10 nm) crystallize in a cubooctahedral arrangement (14 faces) illustrated by Fig. 5a. For even smaller crystallites, an icosahedral non-fcc arrangement may become more stable (22, 114-117); such a shape is shown in Fig. 5b and c. The differences in energy between the smaller icosahedrons and cubooctahedrons are small, so that the d below which the former are stable varies considerably from one metal to another. For more details and references, the reviews by Anderson (22), Gillet (116), and Hoare and Pal (117) are useful. It seems plausible that the catalytic activity of small metal particles would be influenced by the crystal structure. Yacaman et al. (If@ have studied pentane hydrogenolysis over Rhly-AlzO3. Rh/Si02, Rh/C, Rh/Ti02, and Rh/MgO. The support and preparation method, all for particles of d < 5 nrn, determined whether cubooctahedrons or icosahedrons were formed, but the catalytic properties depended more on d than on crystal type. b. Alloying Effects. The behavior of binary metal alloys of supported metals has been investigated by many researchers. Examples of reviews on this subject are those of Sinfelt (1 19), Sachtler and van Santen (120),
FIG.5. (a) Face-centered cubic (fcc) cubooctahedron (20). (b,c) Icosahedra. From Ref. 117.
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE A N D CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
81
b
FIG.5 . (continued)
Clarke and Creaner (121), and Ponec (122). Alloys are sometimes used as practical catalysts because of their selectivity or resistance to poisoning. Here we mention this kind of research because of the similarity of the effect of alloying a relatively inert Group Ib metal with a Group VIII metal
82
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
to the effect of decreasing the metal particle size. This similarity arises because in the present view the valence electrons of each metal in these alloys retain their identities, so that relatively inert Cu can be considered a diluent in an active Ni particle, for instance. The physical basis for this notion that each constituent in an alloy retains its own atomic character was first obtained through photoelectron spectroscopy in the period 19681970, notably by Seib and Spicer ( 1 2 3 ~ )Evidence . based on catalytic results led to similar conclusions (120). A geometric interpretation has been applied to kinetic measurements on the hydrogenolysis of cyclopentane which indicates that a mixed PtRe ensemble is much more active than either pure metal (123b). Thus in our discussion of the role of the multiatom sites (ensembles) usually considered important in antipathetic structure sensitivity we shall have occasion to refer to related results on catalysis over alloys. For example, the hydrogenolysis of ethane over Ni is inhibited as Cu is added and the necessary ensembles are broken up. c. Experimental Models via Stepped Single Crystals. The understanding of adsorption and catalysis has been advanced by studies on well-defined surfaces, to which it is possible to apply a variety of electron spectroscopic and electron diffraction methods. Often it is found that the TOF varies from one face to another of a single crystal. Thus, changes in TOF for supported particles may be related to changes in the relative surfaces of the faces exposed as a function of d , method of preparation, or catalyst history. In order to apply the powerful methods of surface science to atoms of low coordination, such as those encountered on small particles, the use of stepped surfaces of single crystals has been developed. Davis and Somorjai (124) have reviewed this method. If a single crystal is cut at a slight angle from that required to produce a principal face, steps or kinked steps are formed. The heights and orientations can be changed, as expressed for example by the Miller indices shown in Fig. 6. Atoms at the edges of the steps and at the corners of the kinks can be assimilated to the low-coordination C7 and C4 atoms of Fig. 3. Thus we have a geometric model for some of the effects produced by small supported particles. Of course, the low-coordination atoms are still surrounded by many other metal atoms. Somorjai and his collaborators have studied a number of such systems [Blakely and Somorjai (125); Smith et al. (126); Davis and Somorjai (127)l. The data shown in Fig. 6 for cyclohexane dehydrogenation imply that this reaction should be structure-sensitive. Some results from the older literature [e.g., Cusumano et al. (128)] seem to indicate that this is a structure-insensitive reaction over Pt/A120, and Pt/silica-alumina. A
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE A N D CATALYTIC PROPERTIES 10
1
1
I
I
1
1
I
83
I
15 torr Cyclohexone 100 torr Hvdroaen
Time (minutes)
FIG.6 . Dehydrogenationof cyclohexane. Benzene accumulation in the gas phase at 573 K and I atm in a closed (batch) reactor containing a Pt crystal of known exposed surface. The crystals expose the flat Pt(l11) (M), stepped Pt(557) (V),kinked Pt (25, 10, 7) (O),and Pt(l0,8,7)(A) surfaces. Initial rates are proportional to the slopes at zero time. From Herz, R. K., Gillespie, W. D., Petersen, E. E., and Somojai, G . A.. J . C u d . 67, 371 (1981).
number of possible reasons for such differences will be discussed in later sections. C.
MODELCATALYSTS V I A CONTROLLED DEPOSITION OF SMALL PARTICLES
In discussing electronic effects and Fig. 2, a number of references have been made to model catalysts formed by deposition of metal from the vapor phase onto an inert support. An attempt is made to simulate the surface of a real catalyst so that it can be better studied by XPS and electron microscopy. In addition, Masson et al. (78, 79) have developed techniques to control and make almost uniform the size of the particles. Rutherford backscattering is used to find the total number of atoms deposited, and the number of nuclei that grows into discrete metal particles is found by electron microscopy. From these measurements the average number of atoms per particle is obtained. Longer deposition times give larger particles. With such a model catalyst (79)it is possible to measure both electronic and geometric characteristics of the metal particles, along with their reactivity, as the particle size is changed. It is of interest to apply this method not only to particles smaller than 4.0 nm, for which electronic effects may
84
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
be important, but also to particles up to 50 nm. For the latter, catalytic effects must be related to the identities of the exposed faces of the metal crystallites, and these are particularly accessible because of the method of sample preparation. In this way the structure sensitivity shown by many systems above d = 4 nm may be better understood. D. EXPERIMENTAL DIFFICULTIES In the preceding sections we have discussed how observations on the effect of d on catalysis might be explained by electronic and geometric factors. Usually it has been assumed that one is dealing with isolated crystallites of completely reduced metal. Often such may not be the case, and we now consider some common situations in which complicating factors may arise. 1. Metal Bonding with the Support
The atoms of a metal that are in contact with the support may undergo some electron transfer with the support, leading to some ionic or covalent bonding. Such effects would influence only a small fraction of the atoms of a large particle, but the fraction of atoms affected can be expected to increase as the particle size decreases. Thus measured variations in catalytic behavior may be due to a combination of intrinsic size effects and support effects. Strong metal support effects are often observed even for particles larger than 4 nm, after reduction at temperatures above 450°C. These results on supports such as Ti02 have been explained as arising from a large increase in metal-support contact made possible by the decoration of the metal by a reduced form of the oxide support [Resasco and Haller (129); Tatarchuk and Dumesic (130); Sadeghi and Henrich (131a)l. Clearly the decoration also permits a geometric interpretation (129) similar to that invoked to explain the effects of alloying. In any event, most studies of the effect of particle size do not involve the consequences of high-temperature reduction on reducible oxides.
2. Incomplete Reduction of Metal What may seem to be an intrinsic decrease in TOF with particle size may sometimes be caused by the decreasing extent of reduction of smaller particles. Thus, for nickel, small particles are not completely reduced, and the degree of reduction must be considered in evaluating the effect of particle size on TOF (59). Attempts to produce small clusters of iron
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE A N D CATALYTIC YKOPERTIES
85
supported on alumina by the decomposition of iron carbonyls led mostly to iron oxides (64). 3 . Changes in Crystal Structure Figures 3 and 4 are based on the maintenance of the same crystal shape as the size varies. For small particles, needles or even two-dimensional shapes may predominate, as discussed by Bond (21). More subtle changes may occur, such as the replacement of cubooctahedrons by icosahedrons for crystals of d < 2 nm. For large crystals kinetic effects during the preparation may cause deviations from the expected equilibrium distribution of faces, often assumed to be equal portions of the (1 1I), (loo), and (1 10) planes. In their measurement of the TPD of CO on small Pt particles on A1203, Altman and Gorte (13Zb) explain their results by proposing that (1 1 1)-type facets are preferred on the larger particles. 4.
Changes in Deactivation with Particle Size
Deactivation may be structure-sensitive. Thus Lankhorst et al. (132) have shown that variations of TOF with d for hexane reforming on Pt were caused more by increases in carbon deposition with d than by decreases in the intrinsic rate of reaction with d. For model stepped-surface single crystals of platinum, Somorjai and Blakely (133) showed that carbon deposition was favored on terraces over edges and corners, so that the reforming reactions favored by the latter sites are poisoned less rapidly than those occurring mostly on the flat surfaces. Thus small particles are expected to be poisoned less rapidly than large ones, for this example.
5 . Metal Reconstruction It has long been suspected that chemisorption and catalysis may actually cause major changes in the shapes of small crystallites from those observed in the absence of adsorption. The reality of such changes has been demonstrated dramatically by van’t Blik et al. (134) for the chemisorption of CO on well-reduced crystallites of 6-10 Rh atoms supported on alumina. On adsorption the particles are broken up to form Rh(C0): bonded to the oxygens of the support. In the absence of CO, a raft structure for such Rh particles has been observed ( 1 3 5 ~ )However, . in the presence of CO this structure is destroyed and the Rh atoms oxidized, on alumina. For nickel, a dramatic change in particle size may occur by another process. When kinetically and thermodynamically favored, gaseous
86
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
Ni(C0)4 may be formed in the presence of CO so that there is transport of Ni from small particles to large ones (135b). Under certain conditions, usually to be avoided, all the nickel may be removed from the support and deposited on cold surfaces downstream of the reactor. OF STRUCTURE SENSITIVITY E. SOMECONSEQUENCES
Before considering some of the details of structure sensitivity in catalysis, it is of interest to present a few examples. In this way some of the practical consequences of structure sensitivity are illustrated, although it must be kept in mind that there are many steps between the laboratory results we show and the development of an industrial process.
I . Structure Sensitivity and Reaction Rates Results that illustrate three examples of structure sensitivity are presented in Fig. 7. Curve 1 represents the TOF for the structure-insensitive reaction of benzene hydrogenation on Pt/SiOz (136). The TOF is about 0.22 s - I and is not a function of particle size over the range studied. Also plotted for this system is the atomic rate AR, calculated from TOF by Eq. (2). As already mentioned, the atomic rate is an approximate measure of
u) l[O
Y
i,nm
2,5
1,0
AR
2;5
1p
0;C
I
FIG.7. Turnover frejuency (rate) TOF and atomic rate AR versus fraction exposed FE and mean particle size d for a selection of reactions and metal systems (see Table Ill for details of the studies).
87
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE A N D CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
TABLE 111 Details of the Structure Sensitivity Studies of Metal Systems Presented in Fig. 7 Curve (Fig. 7)
Metal
1
Pt
Si02
2
Rh
Si02
3
Ru
AI2O3,SOz, etc.
Support
Temperature, pressure
Reaction
Reference
50°C, 1 atm, Hz/C6H6 = 12.75 253"C, I atm, H*/C2H6 = 6.67 250°C I atm, HJCO = 2
C & ,-k 3H2 --* C6Htz C2H6 f H2-* 2CH4 co -F 3H2+ CH4 + H20
136 13 137
the rate of product produced per unit cost of metal in the catalyst. Thus, it is of interest to maximize the atomic rate, and for the present example this reasoning leads to using a catalyst of the highest FE that is practical. The dotted parts of the curves are extrapolated to FE = 1, where TOF = AR. Naturally, processing costs may become prohibitive as FE increases, and this factor is not included in the above reasoning. Curve 2 of Fig. 7 shows TOF and AR for a sympathetic structuresensitive system, the hydrogenolysis of ethane over Rh/Si02 (13). The TOF rises with FE and then falls for very small particles. The authors expressed some reservations about this behavior, but in our review of the literature we shall see that such behavior is often observed. The curve for AR goes through a maximum in the region of d around 1.5 nm. Thus, for this system there is an optimal value of d, close to the smallest sizes that are practical. Finally, curve 3 of Fig. 7 shows some results for an antipathetic structure-sensitive system, the hydrogenation of carbon monoxide over supported ruthenium (137). For such systems there is usually a maximum in the curve of AR versus d, and this occurs at about 5 nm for the present case. For particles smaller than 5 nm, the decrease of TOF is the predominating effect, and for particles larger than 5 nm, the decrease in FE is the predominating effect. We shall see that CO hydrogenation over almost all systems studied shows an antipathetic structure sensitivity, so that there is no economic incentive to decrease the crystallite size below a fairly large size, 5 nm for the data shown. This reasoning is based on a consideration of the reaction rate, but the selectivity is also important, and we discuss this matter presently. It should be noted that in constructing Fig. 7 and the other figures in this article we use Eq. (1) with B = 1 nm. Actually, B may vary between 0.7 and 1.0 nrn, depending on the metal and the shape of the crystallites.
88
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
However, in view of the precision of the data and the facility of presentation with only one value of B, we have retained B = 1 nm for all figures. It should also be clear that the relation between d and FE loses its meaning as FE approaches I .O. From the geometric point of view, the properties of the surface atoms of a small cubooctahedron are different from those of the same atoms arranged as a one-dimensional raft. From Figs. 3a and 3b, it is deduced that structure sensitivity should appear only for particles with d less than about 5 nm. It is convenient to call systems that actually exhibit this behavior systems with limited structure sensitivity. On the other hand, if geometric effects are governed by ensembles of several atoms, then structure sensitivity should extend to diameters considerably greater than 5 nm. This behavior we call extended structure sensitivity. In other words, with limited structure sensitivity, the system is structure insensitive ford > 5 nm. A glance at the figures in the rest of this review shows that many actual systems present extended structure sensitivity. 2. Structure Sensitivity and Selectivity
The key to the practical exploitation of a catalyst is often its selectivity, so it behooves us to see how the selectivity may vary with d . Curve 1 in Fig. 8 sketches the variation of the molecular weight of the product of the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis over supported cobalt as a function of FE (1.38). Large particles favor a higher production of hydro-
1
100 - 1.0 1
25
i,nm 10
25
10 L
0 L
al
>
a
FE FIG.8. Selectivity ad ! average carbon number of product versus fraction exposed FE and mean particle size d for a selection of reactions and metal systems (see Table IV for details of the studies).
TABLE IV Details of the Reactions and Conditions of the Metal Systems Studies Presented in Fig. 8 Curve (Fig. 8)
Metal
Support
1
co
2
Pt
A1203, Ti02, Si02, C Si02
3
Ag
Si02
Temperature, pressure 225"C, 1 atm, H-JCO = 2 240-375"C, 1 atm, HJC5 = 10.5 220°C, 1 atm, 02/C2H4 = 1.0
Reaction
CO + H2hydrocarbons nCsH,2 + H2 + isomerization, hydrogenoly sis C2H4 + 0 2 -, C2H40. c02
Reference
Comments Fischer-Tropsch synthesis Selectivity = (isomerization)/ (hydrogenolysis isomerization) Selectivity = (C2H4OV ( 0 2 + C2H4O)
138 140
+ 141
90
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
carbons in the gasoline range, one of the original goals of the process. Since the atomic rate is also favored by relatively large particles, the use of such particles is doubly indicated. This is in accord with the old literature, which indicated that highly dispersed supported catalysts were not desirable. Precipitated or fused (iron) catalysts were preferred (139). Curve 2 of Fig. 8 concerns the competitive isomerization and hydrogenolysis of normal pentane as a function of particle size over Pt/Si02 catalysts (140). Isomerization is favored over large particles and hydrogenolysis over small particles. It is clear again that the best catalyst probably corresponds to an intermediate particle size. For the partial oxidation of ethylene over Ag/SiOz catalysts (141), curve 3 shows that the selectivity toward ethylene oxide (versus COz) is favored by the largest crystallites studied. However, both the production of CzH40 and of COz show sympathetic structure sensitivity. Thus, there must exist an optimal crystallite size for the most effective catalyst. It should be noted here that the rates and selectivities usually reported are initial rates, found in a differential reactor. It is clear that there exists a complicated optimization problem in the design of the industrial reactor and catalyst. The best values of crystallite size, conversion, and other operating conditions must be sought. Often these various searches are carried out by separate groups, at separate times, so that the attainmknt of the optimal process is difficult to achieve. It is worth noting here that the metal loading on the catalyst [C in Eq. (4)] is an important variable. Crystallite size can be manipulated by variation of C and of the pretreatment (sintering) temperature and gas-phase composition. For instance, a given d may be obtained from a low loading and a high sintering temperature, or from a high loading and a low sintering temperature. Most authors find that the TOF is about the same for two or more such catalysts of the same d (or FE) and different combinations of loading and sintering temperature. Thus we express results with d as independent variable rather than C. An early review actually used metal loading as the independent variable, reporting catalytic activities as a function of metal loading without reference to FE or d (3). For Ti02 and other reducible supports, a high reducing temperature may induce a strong metal-support interaction (SMSI). In this case TOF becomes a function of sintering (reduction) temperature at a given d. SMSI is absent in most of the literature we shall discuss. However, in the observed variation of TOF with d, the explanation of the observations may be sought as arising from electronic effects, ensemble effects, support effects, reconstruction effects, etc. We shall see that which explanation, or combination thereof, is valid is not evident for many of the literature studies.
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE AND CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
91
3 . Structure Sensitivity and Chemisorption In our discussion of the influence of structure on the turnover rate our understanding is frequently hampered by lack of information on the ratedetermining step and the most abundant surface intermediate. It would be logical to consider the structure sensitivity of the rate of an elementary step, such as the desorption of a chemisorbed gas. Results on temperature programmed desorption as a function of particle size might be simpler to interpret than those of global reactions consisting of a sequence of steps. However, few such data are available. There are, however, a number of papers that treat the equilibrium relations in chemisorption, and we shall discuss some of these. Such measurements can lead to information on the structure and binding of adsorbed species, and also to the characterization of metal catalysts. For example, CO adsorbed on PtO shows a lower stretching frequency in the infrared than when adsorbed on oxidized platinum (142). Another reason to consider chemisorption in this review is that it is often used as the basis for estimating d or FE and thus also influences TOF via Eq. (2). As already mentioned, hydrogen is usually used for measuring FE and in most cases the best value of H/M, seems to be close to 1.0. However there are a number of complications, and we discuss them in the following section on characterization.
IV. Characterization of Small Supported Metal Particles
A. INTRODUCTION In order to obtain data on structure sensitivity, a reliable measure of the metal fraction exposed is needed. The simplest method of measuring FE is via chemisorption of hydrogen; carbon monoxide and oxygen are also sometimes used. After a discussion of chemisorption, we consider later in this section other methods of characterization. Chemisorption leads to an estimate of the average particle size; by electron microscopy and electron microdiffraction, information can be obtained on the particle size distribution and in favorable circumstances on the morphology of the small particles. It is also important to know the chemical state (degree of reduction) of the particles, and to this end electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), ultraviolet photoelectron spectroscopy (UPS),Auger electron spectroscopy (AES), and infrared spectroscopy (IR) are useful. These and other methods will be discussed in what follows. Our goal in the discussion is not to review the methods
92
MICHEL CHE AND CARROLL 0 . BENNETT
considered but to show how they are used to further the study of small particles. In order to determine the effect of d or FE on TOF,evidence is required that the metal particles are indeed approximately monodisperse, fully reduced, unpoisoned, little influenced by the support, and unpromoted. These matters have been reviewed in the previous section under the heading “Experimental Difficulties.” Thus we shall discuss how FE can be measured and then consider other methods of characterization that will furnish more details about the geometric and chemical states of the small particles. We shall, however, not consider metal-support interactions since this aspect is covered in a separate review (25a).
B. PARTICLE SIZEA N D PARTICLE SIZEDISTRIBUTION 1. DeJinitions
Although the expression “particle size” is very often used in the literature, it is very seldom clearly defined, mostly because many definitions are possible and none is unambiguous except if crystallites are all-cubic or all-spherical. This, in practice, never happens and it is necessary to define arbitrarily some quantity as the particle size. Matyi et al. ( M a ) propose that the simplest way to do this is to equate “size” with “diameter,” where the diameter is defined as any straight line passing through the center of mass of the particle and terminating at the particle boundary. The authors present other definitions and show that the most suitable choice depends on both the experimental technique used and the nature of the system being examined. As discussed in Section V, we do not need be too concerned about this aspect, as important as it might be, since there are other more important difficulties to resolve before any rationalization of the data becomes possible. The same type of problem is encountered in the definition of particle size distribution since the starting assumption is that all particles have the same shape. In this case, the particle size distribution is defined as the relationship between a given particle size and the frequency, or number of particles, with that certain diameter or size. Matyi et al. ( 1 4 3 ~discuss ) in detail for a given particle size distribution the several features that can be interpreted as the average size. We refer the reader to this review article.
2. Chemisorption a . Hydrogen. The use of the chemisorption of hydrogen to characterize metal catalysts has been discussed in a useful review by Scholten et al. (14%). Usually an isotherm is measured at room temperature, and mono-
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE AND CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
93
layer coverage (H/M, = 1.0) is assumed to correspond to irreversibly adsorbed hydrogen. The latter is determined by some arbitrary definition. In the best cases, the actual average particle size and morphology have been determined by some reliable physical methods, so that the chemisorption method is calibrated. Following a certain recipe of waiting and pumping, the amount of H2 adsorbed at 25°C and a given pressure are said to correspond to a certain H/M, ratio, preferably unity. Sometimes the appropriate amount of H2 is taken as that found by extrapolating the highpressure part of the isotherm (supposedly linear) to zero pressure. In some cases the isotherm of total adsorption is obtained, the reversibly adsorbed H2 is removed according to a recipe, and then the reversibly adsorbed isotherm is measured. The irreversibly adsorbed H2 isotherm is obtained by difference, and then the monolayer is deduced from this isotherm. For details we refer the reader to Scholten et al. (143b) and appropriate textbooks (e.g., 1b). We next discuss a number of points to keep in mind concerning the use of H2 chemisorption as a method of characterization. 1. Chemical adsorption on metals is usually considered as nonactivated. For H2 on Ni/A1203, however, the isobars pass through a maximum at about 100°C (144), meaning that at 25°C kinetic factors (adsorption time) have an important influence on the amount of H2 adsorbed. For Rh/SiOz (144) the amount of H2 adsorbed is found to depend very little on time; the isobar descends smoothly as the temperature is increased. Thus each metal has its own behavior, which must be taken into account. The thermodynamics and kinetics of adsorption and desorption are discussed in the literature (145, 146). 2. As discussed in the interesting article of Crucq et al. (145),for most chemisorptions the AH of adsorption (exothermic) decreases owing to lateral repulsive interactions as coverage increases. Often the relation is approximately linear, leading to a Temkin isotherm. The change in AH may arise because of a distribution of metallic sites and/or because of increasing interactions between adsorbed H a s the coverage increases. Thus the fraction of adsorbed gas that can be removed depends on temperature, time, and arrangement of the equipment; the activation energy for desorption obviously also decreases with increasing coverage. Thus the term reversible adsorption has only an artificial meaning and might better be replaced by weak (and strong) adsorption (147). Sayari et al. (98) have studied the weak adsorption of H2 on various supported ruthenium catalysts of 0.9 < d < 12.4 nm. They express their results in terms of the ratio HwIHT,where the subscripts W and T, stand for weak and total adsorption. At 0.9 nm, HwIHTis about 0.1, passes
94
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
through a maximum of 0.32 at 1.5 nm, and drops to zero above 2.5 nm. The authors (98) associate the weak adsorption with special sites, invoking in particular the Bs sites. Although these sites do reach a maximum concentration at about the right d, their decline for higher d is gradual (106) and extends far above 2.5 nm. It is interesting to recall that Aben et al. (97) have found that the hydrogenation of benzene is structure-insensitive if the TOF is based on the FE on the basis of the adsorption of weakly bound hydrogen only. In Fig. 13 (Section V,B,5), the TOF (curve 4) is based on strongly adsorbed hydrogen and shows a maximum at about 2.0 nm. 3. Although a calibration of H2 chemisorption may be desirable, there must exist another reliable measure of particle size, and such has not been the case for d < 3 nm. In recent years, however, improved techniques in electron microscopy have permitted the measurement of particle sizes down into the range 0.3-1.0 nm. Even though the resolution of modern instruments may be of the order of 0.3 nm, it is often difficult to obtain enough contrast to distinguish the metal from the support. By careful sample preparation McVicker et al. (148) were able to see particles of Ir on A1203of about 0.6 nm. They found that for particles in this range HIM, is about 2, whereas it drops to 1.O for larger particles (strongly adsorbed H2). The contrast in electron micrographs can be remarkably enhanced by computer-aided image processing. An example is the recent work of Fuentes et al. (149) for Rh/Ti02,but they did not report results for hydrogen chemisorption. It is also possible to use extended X-ray absorption fine-structure (EXAFS) spectroscopy to deduce particle sizes, and this method has been used, along with hydrogen chemisorption, to study Rh, Pt, and Ir supported on Si02 and A1203 (147, 150). The average coordination number of the metal atoms is calculated from the EXAFS results. A model implemented by computer is then used to estimate the particle size from the coordination number. Metal support interaction can be included in the model. Kip et al. (147) have used total adsorbed hydrogen in reporting chemisorption results. For Pt they find 0.6 C H/M, C 1.2; for Rh (FE always > 0.8), 1.5 < HIM, < 2.0; and for Ir, 2.5 < HIM, < 3.0 for 0.2 < FE < 0.9. In these data the higher H/M, refers to FE close to 1 .O and the lower one, to the samples of lowest dispersion measured. Although there is some scatter in the results, it is clear that H/M, is a function of FE for a given metal, and that its range changes from one metal to another. Roughly, at FE = 1.0, it seems that H/Pt, = 1, H/Rh, = 2, and H/Irs = 3, where H/M has been obtained by extrapolating HT/M to zero pressure.
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE A N D CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
95
It should be noted that hydrogen held by refractory supports such as SiO2 and A1203 usually has a negligible effect on the results, either via physisorption or spillover (147, 148, 149a) at 25°C. Clearly, metal-support interactions are important, for instance, in the formation of rafts of rhodium or the location of groups of only one or two atoms (149b).However, on the flat Rh particles found on a Ti02 support, there should be at least two H atoms adsorbed per Rh atom (147, 148). For hydrogen adsorption on reducible oxides, there may be an apparent slow adsorption that actually arises from the reduction of the support. For Rh/TiOz it has been found that at 22°C there is rapid chemisorption of Hz corresponding to H on Rh followed by further slow disappearance of H2 corresponding to the gradual creation of Ti3+by spilled-over hydrogen (151). The resulting lines representing Hz adsorbed versus In (time) have slopes and intercepts that are functions of reduction temperature (SMSI) and subsequent oxygen treatments. Oxygen adsorption is also measured and a coherent picture of the various processes is presented (151). It should be noted that the preparation of catalysts of low metal loading (<0.5%) leads to particular difficulties. For instance, chemisorption by hydrogen may be falsified by reaction with oxide or other impurities or actual adsorption on the support. Also, the metal particles may attract trace impurities from the support that surrounds them in great excess. b. Carbon Monoxide. Since carbon monoxide may dissociate and/or adsorb on support materials, it is not used as much as HZfor catalyst characterization by chemisorption. Sometimes volatile carbonyls are formed [e.g., Ni(C0)4]. However, unlike H2, it is convenient to study adsorbed CO by infrared spectroscopy, so that there is a large literature on CO adsorption on supported metals. Discussion of this matter is deferred until the section on the structure sensitivity of chemisorption. 4.
3 . Electron Microscopy The most important advantage of electron microscopy is that the experimentalist can test the effectiveness of the preparation method by directly observing the metal particles. One can obtain the particle size distribution, derive the average particle size, and determine whether the particles are evenly distributed or packed up in larger aggregates. If the particles are sufficiently large, their shape can be distinguished and their crystal structure determined. The most obvious difficulty, however, is that the electron micrographs used must be representative of the sample under investigation. This can be achieved only if a number of electron micrographs are taken so that
96
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
one can estimate whether they are representative of the sample, but this is a painful and time consuming task. Another difficulty is that the observation of small metal particles may be affected by the support microcrystallinity (58, 152), orientation of particles and imaging conditions (153). It appears now that bright-field techniques are increasingly unreliable for particles below 2 nm and that other contrast methods-hollow-cone (154) and other dark-field methods (155u,b),the z contrast technique (156)-are useful for extremely small particles (36). There are cases where the contrast is so poor that the support has to be removed by dissolution as in the case of the Pt/Ce02 (157). In this instance, some information is lost, such as spatial distributions of the metal and the metal-support interaction, and even some metal particles can be removed during the dissolution process. As stated earlier (Section IV,B,l,a), the contrast can be enhanced by computer-aided image processing (149). Other difficulties include electron beam effects, crystallite agglomeration, and the selection of the diameter when examining irregularly shaped crystallites (158). Despite the problems mentioned above, modern atomic resolution TEM is now available in many university and industrial research laboratories and successfully applied to characterize microstructure of a wide range of materials at resolution on, or approaching, the atomic scale (159163). Recently, controlled atmosphere electron microscopy (CAEM) or in situ TEM has allowed in situ observation of gas-solid reactions at a resolution of about 25 A. The principal feature of the technique is that a relatively high gas pressure is obtained at the specimen while preserving the low pressure needed for operation of the microscope. Various types of cell and differentially pumped systems have been described (164). The applications of CAEM to catalysis have been reviewed with special emphasis on carbon deposition, carbon gasification, and sintering studies (165). The electron microscopes can be divided into two types (166): scanning electron microscopes (SEM), which use a 10-nm electron beam at the specimen surface, and transmission electron microscopes (TEM). With current TEMs, resolution of about 0.2 nm can be achieved, provided very thin (<20 nm) samples are available. With conventional inorganic oxidesupported metal catalysts, particles of approximately I nm can be detected. Scanning transmission electron microscopes (STEM) use a high brightness dark-field emission gun to produce a probe about 0.3 nm in diameter and combine the techniques of SEM and TEM. Further experimental and theoretical aspects of electron microscopy applied to catalysis have been reviewed recently (113, 167-169).
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE A N D CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
97
4. X-Ray Diffraction Techniques
There are two very general X-ray techniques for study of the metal particle size distribution: the line-broadening analysis (LBA) and the small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) (Ib, 170). Other methods include the radial electron distribution (RED) and the extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS), which are aimed primarily at studying the structure of catalysts (Section IV,G). a . Line-Broadening Analysis. The breadth of X-ray reflections does not depend on the crystallite size for dimensions above approximately 500 nm. For smaller crystals and in presence of defects, the breadth is increased as a result of the limited number of reflecting planes (crystallite size broadening) or to the perturbation of interreticular spacings (stain or deformation broadening). LBA can be performed in two ways. The first is to use the Scherrer equation (171), which states that the breadth of X-ray reflections is inversely related to the dimensions of the crystals, assuming that the broadening is due to crystallite size only. The other way is to perform a complete line-profile analysis, including a correction for instrumental broadening, the separation of crystallite size broadening, and the calculation of particle size distribution. There are, however, a number of difficulties that restrict the use of LBA. The reflections from the different solid phases present in the systems might be superimposed. Neighboring reflections such as the (1 11) and (200) lines in fcc metals will overlap when the particles become very small. For supported metals, the metal reflection must be intense enough to give a measurable signal above the background contributed by the support. As the amount of metal decreases, the wings of the line profile become too weak and the smaller particles are not taken into account. LBA becomes less and less accurate, resulting in a mean size that is overestimated and a size distribution displaced toward the larger size. LBA is believed to be applicable to particles in the range 100 nm to a value around 1.5 nm (170). b. Small-Angle X-Ray Scattering. This technique uses information contained in radiation scattered, within a few degrees of the primary X-ray beam, by centers whose scattering arises from differences in electron densities. The intensity of X-ray scattering depends on the size and shape of the scattering centers, which in a three-phase system involve the metallic phase, the support, and the pores (voids) themselves. The scattering of the voids can be eliminated either by compression to destroy the pore structure or by impregnating the catalyst with a liquid (CH212 is commonly used for SiO2 and A1203) that has the same electron density as the support, so that the small metal particles are left as the only main
98
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
scattering centers. Pore masking is not always easy in a SAXS experiment because certain supports have such high electron densities that it is impossible to find a fluid that can match them (172). In such cases, neutron small-angle scattering can be particularly useful, since it is relatively easy to find a suitable fluid with the same neutron scattering length density as a chosen catalyst support (173). Important SAXS parameters are always derived from an analysis of the profile of the SAXS curve that gives the intensity Z(s) of the X-ray scattering as a function of the scattering vector s. From the so-called Porod surface extracted from the wings of the SAXS curve, a mean surfaceweighted particle diameter can be easily calculated by assuming a given shape for the distribution as reported by Whyte et al. (174,175).When the support is nonporous and in the form of spherical particles that give weak scattering, the distribution of metal particle diameters can be obtained without the use of pore-masking fluids (176). The SAXS technique is interesting and more powerful than LBA. The main advantages are that particles as small as 0.5 nm can be observed and that the particle sizes of poorly crystallized or even amorphous solids can still be measured. With both LBA and S A X S , the catalysts can be studied in situ during heat treatments or catalytic reactions. Finally, X-ray diffraction methods have the advantage over gas adsorption measurements that they are insensitive to catalyst contamination (175). In gas adsorption techniques, some of the metal surface may be inaccessible to adsorbate, leading to overestimated particle diameters. This lack of accessibility may be due to surface contamination or to the presence of micropores that are too small to allow adsorbate entrance. 5 . Magnetic Methods There are two magnetic techniques that can lead to particle size or particle size distribution; one is a static method whereas the other is a resonance one. a. Static Magnetic Measurements. When a bulk ferromagnetic metal is in the form of very small particles, there is a drastic change in the magnetic properties that can be used to derive the particle size and distribution profile. If a particle of a normally ferromagnetic metal has a size that is smaller than a ferromagnetic domain (30 nm for nickel), it will act as a paramagnetic substance with a very large magnetic moment N p o , where N is the number of atoms within the particle and p, is the magnetic moment of one atom. When subjected to a large external magnetic field H, the magnetic moment of the particle will tend to align itself with H but this orientation
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE A N D CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
99
is counteracted by the thermal agitation kT. This phenomenon is called “collective paramagnetism or superparamagnetism” (177). The resulting magnetization in the direction of the applied field H is given by the Langevin equation, valid for large values of Npo: M/M, = L ( N p o H / k T ) with L(a) = coth a - l/a, where a represents the function Np,H/kT. M, is the saturation magnetization (maximum field strength after which the magnetization becomes field independent). Two types of approximation are used: the Langevin high-field method applies to high-field strength [ 10 Oe (oersteds)] and low temperature (-4.2 K) to which the smallest particles (small values of N) are most sensitive, whereas the Langevin lowfield method refers to low-field strength (SI Oe) and higher temperature (-300 K) and concerns the larger particles (larger values of N ) . By performing measurements at different temperatures, it is possible to obtain the distribution profile. When the distribution of the particle size is described by means of a simple analytical function, it is possible to determine the latter accurately by optimization (178). The preceding equation applies to monodomains in thermal equilibrium. However, for large or elongated particles, low temperature, or short observation time, the magnetic moments remain in the facile magnetization direction, leading to a remanent magnetization that is proportional to the total volume of the particles. The method based on particle size determination from relaxation time measurements after the magnetizing field is removed is referred to as the NCel method (179). The variation of the remanent magnetization with temperature for a given observation time allows the derivation of the particle size distribution. This is the Weil method (180). Another technique (the frequency method) exists, which consists in modifying the observation time by applying a variable frequency alternating field (181). Among these various methods, the low-field Langevin approach is the most commonly used because low field strength and easily accessible temperatures are involved. It is important to realize that the magnetic properties are strongly affected by chemisorption, requiring clean particle surfaces. This has been exploited by Martin and Imelik (182) to determine the number of covalent bonds between adsorbed hydrocarbons and the metal in the Ni/Si02 system. This approach indicates that the magnetic methods are well adapted for in situ studies, although these are limited to ferromagnetic metals or their alloys. There is some promise that metals with Pauli paramagnetism can also be investigated ( 1 8 3 ~ The ) . static magnetic methods applied to chemisorption and to the determination of particle size and particle size distribution have been reviewed recently (183b, 184). b. Ferromagnetic Resonance. Ferromagnetic resonance (FMR) (185, 186) is based on the same principle as electron paramagnetic resonance
100
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
(EPR). In a FMR experiment, a microwave field is used to induce electronic transitions between Zeeman levels produced by the external applied magnetic field. However, there are two important differences. First, FMR deals with strong magnetic moments associated to the metal particles rather than with weak magnetic moments due to one or a few unpaired electrons associated typically to a radical containing a few atoms or to a transition-metal ion. Second, in a ferromagnetic substance, by contrast to a paramagnetic one, there exist strong magnetic anisotropies due to the crystalline structure, to the form of the material and to the constraints it undergoes (58, 89, 187). These anisotropies correspond to strong anisotropic magnetic fields H a , which can reach 6000 Oe and vary with temperature (89, 285). The effective magnetic field is thus the sum of those local fields and of the external applied magnetic field. The FMR signal is characterized by an intensity which is proportional to magnetization and by a value H , of the external magnetic field at the resonance which depends on the nature of the anisotropy and of its variation as a function of temperature. The latter follows the Langevin law as seen above, so that it becomes possible by recording the FMR signal intensity as a function of temperature to derive the particle size (186). It is also possible from the variation of the shape of the FMR signal as a function of temperature and of the microwave frequency to obtain information on the nature of the main anisotropy (185,186).This may lead to the form of the metal particles and to the constraints they undergo at the metal-support or metal-gas interface. The latter information allows detection of the presence of any chemisorbed phase (Section IV,D). The FMR technique presents the same advantages as EPR: in situ experiments are possible on minute quantities of samples that are not destroyed. The interpretation of the spectra is, however, rather involved and the method is limited to ferromagnetic compounds containing essentially Fe, Co, Ni, or their alloys. 6 . Miscellaneous
Several techniques have been reported to yield particle size and distribution profiles, but their use has not been generalized yet, either because the technique is not straightforward or limited to specific cases or because the method used to process the spectroscopic data is too involved. This can be exemplified by the work of Dalla Betta and Boudart (188a), who determined by infrared (IR) the particle size of platinum encaged in CaY zeolite. The size was deduced from the fraction of OH groups exchanged with deuterium, and it was assumed that the isotopic exchange at low temperature is rapid only in the immediate vicinity of the particle. This
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE AND CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
101
assumption was substantiated in a later paper (188b).Correlation between the stretching frequency of an adsorbed probe molecule and particle size has sometimes been made. Pnmet et al. (189) showed that the smaller the Pt particle, the higher the U N O frequency of adsorbed NO. Another example can be found in the use of xenon probe molecules to measure by 129Xe nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) the size of Pt particles in zeolites (190) or on conventional supports (191). In some cases the technique is not easily available, and this can be represented by the case of IssPt NMR (192). In a comprehensive study of 195PtNMR lineshapes ( 1 9 3 , relaxation phenomena (194) and microscopic variations in Knight shifts ( 1 9 3 , Schlichter and co-workers have demonstrated the power of 195PtNMR to investigate the particle size, the condition of Pt surfaces (i.e., whether metallic or nonmetallic), and the chemical nature of surface species. The IssPt NMR is, however, very time-consuming (192). Some attempts have been made to relate X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) dispersed phase-support intensity ratios to the size of the supported particles, and examples are given by Moss (158). Recently, the binding energy shift in XPS spectra has been proposed for measurement of the particle size of supported platinum prepared by vapodeposition in ultrahigh vacuum (78). This method has the advantage that it can be employed in situ and for sizes that cannot be seen by electron microscopy. Some other techniques have been applied to particle size determination such as Mossbauer (196). A certain number of catalytically important metals are Mossbauer-active. However, certain isotopes are short lived and in low natural abundance (197-199) thus increasing the experimental cost. It is possible to bypass this problem by the introduction of small amounts of easily available Mossbauer-active isotopes (e.g., "Fe) in catalytic systems (200). The magnetic dipole splitting is sensitive to ferromagnetic ordering in Fe and its alloys, so that Mossbauer spectroscopy is particle-size-sensitive. The applications of Mossbauer spectroscopy to catalyst problems have been recently reviewed (197-201). Some other techniques, including EXAFS (147,150)and EPR (202), have been proposed to estimate particle size but they have been applied to a few cases only. C. DEGREE OF REDUCTION A N D PRESENCE OF UNREDUCED IONS There are two ways to follow the reduction of catalyst precursors to yield the metal. One is quantitative in nature; the other is qualitative and both may prove useful. Most quantitative methods refer to conventional techniques, whereas the qualitative ones essentially refer to spectroscopies (optical, magnetic etc.). We review them briefly here.
102
MICHEL CHE AND CARROLL 0. BENNETT
1. Conventional Methods
The principle is to measure the oxygen consumption necessary to oxidize the metal particles and from the knowledge of the metal content to deduce the reduction degree. Alternatively, one can conduct a complementary reduction of the ions that have not been reduced during the preparation of the metal particles. This may require high temperatures. The hydrogen consumption and the knowledge of the metal content lead again to the reduction degree. The amounts of gas needed in either case (oxidation or complementary reduction) can be obtained by means of a microbalance or a volumetric apparatus (203, 204). Another useful method (35, 205-209), called temperature-programmed reduction (TPR), can also lead to the reduction degree. In this technique, by following the change in hydrogen concentration in a nitrogen gas carrier as it passes over the catalyst sample, the latter’s rate of reduction can be continuously recorded. When oxygen is used instead of hydrogen, the corresponding technique is referred to as temperature-programmed oxidation (TPO). 2 . Optical Methods a . Infrared Spectroscopy. Infrared is certainly the spectroscopy that has found widest application in catalysis ever since Eischens and Pliskin (210) adapted this technique to the study of supported metal catalysts and extended it to a broad range of adsorption systems relevant to catalysis. In the early days, the applications of IR spectroscopy were limited by its low sensitivity leading to slow data acquisition and consequently sample heating. There were also problems due to low transmittance of the catalysts. These difficulties have now been overcome by the advent of the laser and the computer. Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) methods are capable of studying intensely colored samples (e.g., transition metal based catalysts) and a number of other kinds of solid (211). Most IR studies concern metals highly dispersed on carriers rather transparent to IR radiation such as SiO2 and A1203. This dispersion is required since metal particles larger than about 100 8, create severe energy dispersion by scattering (212). Although IR gives fairly direct evidence on many surface groups (hydroxyls, sulfates, carbonates, etc.), the study of supported metal through the use of probe molecules generally provides no direct evidence on the oxidation state or even on the chemical identity of the absorbing entity. When the chemical composition of the sample is known, certain correlations exist that can lead to the identification of certain types of bonding and certain oxidation states of the adsorbing metal center.
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE AND CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
103
Several types of molecule have been used to probe the state of the supported metal (fraction exposed, structure, support-metal or metalmetal interactions) and the presence of unreduced ions. However, some IR-active species such as the hydrocarbons exhibit weak absorptions. This is one reason why most IR studies of chemisorption have been limited to strongly IR absorbing species such as carbon monoxide. Experience and analogies with spectra of known compounds have shown that bands at frequencies above or below 2000 cm-’ could be assigned to adsorbed CO in a linear (i.e., bonded by one end to one metal atom) or bridged (i.e., attached to two or more metal atoms) form, respectively (213,214). Bands observed above 2100 cm-I are generally assigned to CO adsorbed on metal atoms in an oxidation state greater than zero (215). It will be seen that CO can also be used to study the geometric and the electronic factors related to the small particles. b. Diffuse Reflectance Spectroscopy. A diffuse reflectance UV-visible spectrum is composed of several bands, the frequency of which depends on the energy involved in the transition of an electron from the ground state to an excited state. For a given unreduced ion, the number and energy of the electronic levels depends, in turn, on the symmetry of the ion environment. The lower this symmetry, the lower the degeneracy of the electronic levels and the larger the number of possible electronic transitions. The energy levels are designated by terms that indicate in which way the corresponding orbital transforms in a given symmetry operation of the group considered and the spin multiplicity of the system. When a transition ion is engaged in a solid, it experiences a crystal field whose symmetry and strength depend on the number, location, and nature of the ligands. For a given electronic configuration, the TanabeSugano diagrams, established for a particular symmetry, give the energy change of the various electronic terms as a function of D,lB, where D, is the crystal field parameter and B is the electron repulsion Racah parameter. The electronic transitions that are allowed must satisfy selection rules based on two criteria, the spin and the orbital (Laporte rule) of the excited and ground states. Diffuse reflectance spectroscopy has found wide application for the characterization of supported transition-metal ions that are the normal precursors of supported metals. It, therefore, can be used to detect unreduced transition metal ions (57a,c, 186, 216-221). 3 . Magnetic Methods
a . Ferromagnetic Resonance. The principle of ferromagnetic resonance has been given in Section IV,B,S,b. It was mentioned that the FMR
104
MlCHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
signal is characterized by its intensity and a resonance field. There is, in addition, a very important parameter, called the “Curie temperature above which the FMR signal disappears.” This parameter is a constant for a given metal and is equal to 63 1 K in the case of nickel. In some cases, the Curie temperature is lower than expected, and this lowering has been assigned to a partial reoxidation of the particles and can be accentuated by oxygen chemisorption (58,89, 186,222). It thus appears that the measure of the Curie temperature is indicative of the presence of unreduced ions. b. Electron Paramagnetic Resonance. The FMR and EPR techniques operate on the same basic principle (Section IV,B,S,b). The EPR technique, however, concerns paramagnetic species, i.e., those that possess one or several unpaired electrons and that, for solids, are located in the bulk or at the surface (223-225). The nature of the information gained from EPR may vary from the simple confirmation of the presence of a given paramagnetic species within a particular solid (226,227)to the more sophisticated and detailed description of the coordination sphere of a particular ion supported on a carrier (57a,b,228-230). The extreme sensitivity of EPR, as compared to usual spectroscopic techniques, is perhaps its most acknowledged advantage and makes it best suited to investigate and characterize unreduced ions of supported metal catalysts (58).Those ions must however be paramagnetic. 4. Photoelectron Spectroscopy
This “surface” technique is based on the relation established by Einstein (231)that the kinetic energy E k of an electron ejected by the photoemission process can be calculated as the difference between the energy of the photon hv and the binding energy Et, of the electron in the target. With the development of high-resolution spectrometers capable of measuring Ek with a high precision (232) and the Einstein relation, Siegbahn and co-workers measured binding energies of core electrons released on subjecting the sample target to X-ray photons. The discovery that these energy levels shift by several electron volts when the chemical state of the atom studied changes (233) led to the technique now referred to as electron spectroscopy for chemical analysis (ESCA) (234)or X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). A parallel development was made by Turner and co-workers with the ultraviolet photoelectron spectroscopy (UPS) to study valence electrons (235). However, only XPS has been widely applied to supported catalyst systems. Since the excitation process in XPS concerns core electrons, the technique is element-specific and elements can be identified on the basis
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE A N D CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
I05
of the binding energy values. The latter reflect the chemical environment (oxidation state, ligands) of atoms and make XPS a powerful technique to follow chemical changes during various treatment procedures (236). Shifts of about 1 eV per change in formal oxidation state are typical for catalyst applications and can be used to monitor such phenomena as the reduction of ions to prepare supported metal particles (237) and detect the presence of unreduced ions. In addition, the technique is highly surface sensitive since the investigated sample depth is limited by the escape depth of the ejected core electron, usually around 2.0 nm, and this property can be used to detect the migration of ions from or into the bulk of the support (238).The main limitation of XPS is that experiments are carried out in ultrahigh vacuum so that pretreatment procedures must be performed in separate high pressure chambers. Several reviews on the application of XPS to catalytic problems have appeared (236-239). 5. Extended X-Ray Absorption Fine Structure
Extended X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy (EXAFS) has been increasingly applied to the study of catalysts. This technique involves the absorption of X-rays by a catalyst sample as a function of photon energy (240).Once the energy of the absorption edge is exceeded, a photoelectron is ejected that is scattered by the neighbors of the central atom. The scattered electron wave can interfere constructively or destructively with the ejected photoelectron wave, producing oscillations in the X-ray absorption coefficient. The latter rises sharply at the absorption edge, and modulation of this coefficient is observed beyond the edge. The frequency of the oscillations is inversely proportional to the distance of neighboring atoms, and the amplitude is proportional to the number of neighbors. Furthermore, the area under the curve near the edge (called the “white-line area”) and the position of the edge may provide information about the chemical state of the absorbing atom and thus allow the detection of unreduced ions. The advantages of EXAFS are (23) (1) measurements can be made in situ in different gaseous environments, (2) short-range order around a particular species of atom can be determined and the metal need not possess long-range order, (3) bond lengths can be measured, (4) average coordination numbers can be calculated, and ( 5 ) the electronic structure of the atoms and the number of d electrons can be determined. The main disadvantage of EXAFS is that it is an expensive technique that is not easily available. Reviews on the applications of EXAFS to catalytic phenomena have been published recently (241, 242a,b ) .
106
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0 . BENNETT
6 . Miscellaneous
Apart from those described above, there are several other techniques for detection of the presence of unreduced ions. They are presented here because they have not been used as much as the preceding ones or are not as general. These include, for instance, Mossbauer spectroscopy. This technique is based on the recoil-free emission of gamma rays by a radioactive source and the resonant absorption of these gamma rays by Mossbauer nuclei in the sample under investigation. The resonant absorption induces nuclear transitions that are strongly influenced by the chemical (oxidation) state and/or environment of the Mossbauer nucleus affording the possibility to follow reduction processes and detect the presence of unreduced ions (197-201). Chemical methods have also been used to probe the completeness of reduction. Thus Martin et al. (243) selectively dissolved the metallic nickel obtained after reduction by a bromine methanol solution and titrated it by complexometry. For the same nickel catalysts, it was possible to measure the reduction degree from saturation magnetization data at low temperatures, and a good agreement was found between the two estimations of the reduction degrees (244).
D. PRESENCE OF POISONS A N D OF PROMOTERS As indicated in Section 11, undesired species are often found on catalysts at the end of the preparation process. It is thus advisable to probe the purity of the catalysts, and this is considered below. In some cases, these species can also act as promoters. Promoters added deliberately to the catalysts will not be considered here since this section deals basically with the detection of undesired species that would modify the intrinsic properties of the metal and compete with the true particle size effect. 1 . Temperature-Programmed Desorption
The temperature-programmeddesorption (TPD) technique provides information about the binding of adsorbed species to the catalyst surface. In a thermal desorption experiment, the adsorbent (catalyst) is given the desired exposure to the adsorbate (or reacting mixture) and then the sample is heated in a programmed manner: desorbing gases cause an increase in the measured partial pressure and the recorded pressure-time (or sample temperature) curve is known as the desorption spectrum (245). The desorption of the adsorbed species can be followed by various techniques (gas chromatography, mass spectrometry, etc.). There are several different ways to induce desorption of the adsorbed layer, which include
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE A N D CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
107
thermal desorption, electron impact desorption, field desorption, ion impact desorption, and photon- and phonon-induced desorption. The information that can be obtained from desorption methods includes surface analysis, i.e., surface concentration and stoichiometry, and sometimes the nature of the surface species (245). Because of the widespread use of molecular hydrogen as a reducing agent to produce the metal particles, the TPD of hydrogen from metal catalysts has been of course largely investigated (14.36).In many systems, the presence of several desorption peaks revealed species with different adsorption strengths. For very small nickel particles ( d below about 1 nm) it has been found that hydrogen was so strongly held that it could act as a poison and suppress catalytic activity for hydrogen01ysis (58). In some cases, specific desorption techniques like secondary-ion mass spectroscopy (SIMS) has been very fruitful. This method employs mass analysis of both negative and positive secondary ions emitted by a surface subjected to ion bombardment (245). For instance, the negative secondary-ion (SI) mass spectrum, determined by Benninghoven (246, 247), of a commercial silver catalyst used in the oxidation of ethylene indicates the presence of hydroxide, cyanide, chloride, sulfate, nitrate and many fatty acids in the uppermost monolayer. Since the low primary-ion current perturbs the surface only weakly, the SI mass spectrum can be continuously monitored while the surface is heat treated. The results of Benninghoven showed that during heat treatment, impurities could reach the surface by diffusion from within the catalyst. This aspect is very important and must always be kept in mind particularly in the context of particle size effect. The application of TPD methods to catalytic problems has been reviewed earlier (248-251). A different approach can be adopted to detect surface poisons which consists in involving those poisons in simple reactions such as combustion and to detect the products by gas chromatography or mass spectrometry. This has been performed very often in TPO experiments particularly for samples contaminated by carbonaceous impurities (252).
2. Other Analytical and Spectroscopic Methods Many techniques have been used to detect the presence of poisons on metal surfaces, particularly by chemical analysis, but the effectiveness decreases with the poison content and special techniques become necessary for traces. For instance, special analytical (gas chromatography) capabilities to measure S concentrations below 5 ppb and CH, below 1 ppm must be on-line (253). The sensitivity of spectroscopic methods becomes in those cases an important advantage. IR has often been employed to detect surface and/or bulk species by means of their character-
108
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0.BENNETT
istic vibration frequencies and a number of reports have been given on many surface groups such as hydroxyls, sulfates, sulfides, carbonates, nitrates etc. (204,211,214, 218), which can strongly influence the chemical state of a metal particle. It is known, for instance, that hydroxyl groups are capable of oxidizing metal atoms (61) (Section II,B,7); some others, such as pseudocarbonates, are capable of functioning as electron reservoirs to reduce ions into metal atoms (218). EPR, which is very sensitive, has also been used to detect surface and/or bulk species that are paramagnetic such as nitrogen-, sulfur-, and particularly carbon-containing species (50, 223, 254,255). In the same way, nonresonance magnetic methods have shown that the residues of the solvent used during preparation could strongly modify the properties of supported metal particles (70). The preceding spectroscopic methods detect both surface and bulk species. By contrast, electron spectroscopies such as XPS or Auger electron spectroscopy (AES) have been very useful to detect and identify species located in the outermost layers of the catalyst. A N D ELECTRONIC PROPERTIES OF SMALL E. STRUCTURE METALPARTICLES
1.
Structure
We have already mentioned that some of the previously described techniques can be used to study the shape of the metal particles. In view of their relevance to catalytic problems, it is also important to obtain information on the lattice parameters. The techniques that have proved most useful for this purpose are electron microscopy, EXAFS, and X-ray diffraction, which have been presented in the preceding sections. A number of papers have been published that report unusual symmetries for small particles such as atoms in abnormal positions, raft-like structures, close-packed structures different from the normal bulk structures and different textures (23). Among those unusual arrangements, there is a strong emphasis on the pentagonal symmetry. The conditions under which the different types of structure tend to be formed have been summarized by Yacaman et al. (256). The EXAFS results indicate that the lattice parameter of small particles is contracted as compared with that of the bulk metal (23). This fact is confirmed by radial electron distribution data obtained from X-ray experiments (257a,b) and also by electron diffraction measurements ( 2 5 7 ~ ) . Both this contraction and the anomalous pentagonal symmetry can be eliminated in the case of Pt particles onto which hydrogen is adsorbed. These “relaxation” effects, which are found to be reversible, will not be
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE A N D CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
I09
observed if studies are not performed under catalytic reaction. This is possible with EXAFS and small-angle X-ray scattering, which, as mentioned earlier, can both be used in situ in contrast to conventional electron microscopy (TEM, STEM, etc.) techniques.
2. Electronic Properties The techniques that have been most employed for investigating the electronic properties of small particles are photoemission (UPS, XPS), soft X-ray spectroscopy, EXAFS, photoionization mass spectrometry, and AES (23, 111, 240, 257d,e). While there is some controversy from theoretical work about the minimum particle size required to give bulk properties-from 10 (258) to several hundred atoms (259)-there seems to be a consensus that a cluster of about 150 atoms or more is required to observe a photoemission spectrum similar to that of the corresponding bulk metal (23, 260). When other properties are considered (ionization potential, density of states, valence bandwidth, etc.), the agreement is less satisfactory between the results obtained with different techniques (231. V.
Effect of Particle Size on Turnover Frequency and Selectivity: Presentation and Comparison of the Data
A.
INTRODUCTION
In presenting data on the effect of metal crystallite size we shall show mostly the results of studies in which the authors themselves have measured rates as a function of d . We do not take results from different works, each using a different d, and construct a graph of TOF. Some other studies have incorporated this approach, and we do report some such data. This selective approach means that only a small fraction of the results on the kinetics for any given reaction are reported in our survey. The rate data are reported at the temperature, pressure, and gas composition used by the authors. However, some authors have themselves converted their results to a given set of conditions, by means of activation energies and reaction orders that they consider appropriate. However, these parameters themselves may be structure sensitive, so that the results at the conditions actually used are of the most fundamental interest. When rates or dispersion data have been given in units other than TOF and d or FE, we have converted them to these units via a few simple
110
MICHEL CHE A N D CARROLL 0. BENNETT
calculations. More weight should be given to the shapes of the curves shown than to the numerical values referred to the indicated axes. The data are presented according to reaction type, not chronologically or by structure sensitivity type.
B. HYDROGENATION OF HYDROCARBONS The kinetics of these reactions has been studied extensively, but the effect of particle size has been investigated mainly for benzene hydrogenation. In general, the reactions are considered to be structure insensitive, but we shall see that there are a number of exceptions. 1. Hydrogenation of Ethylene
This reaction is usually taken as structure insensitive, following the work of Schlatter and Boudart (261). These authors collected data from many sources on the rates over various supported catalysts of differing FE. These results, along with some of their own, were plotted on an Arrhenius diagram. To a certain level of approximation the rates, when properly interpreted, lay near a single line. Thus it appeared that d and the nature of the support were irrelevant in determining TOF. Masson et al. (79) have used vapodeposited Pt to study this reaction over Pt/Si02 and their results are shown in Fig. 9. There is a clear maxi-
1.5 c
-
la -
IA
i
+ 0 CT
0.5
0
0.1
0.25 0.5 1.0 FE
FIG.9. Rate of hydrogenation of ethylene at 250°C and 1 atm on Pt/SiO, prepared by vapocondensation. (0)Atomic rate (AR), s-I; (0)turnover frequency (or rate) TOF, s-I. From Ref. 79.
METALS: PARTICLE SIZE A N D CATALYTIC PROPERTIES
111
mum in the rate at about 0.6 nm, and separate atoms do not appear to act catalytically. Masson et al. (78)have studied ethylene hydrogenation on Pt/AI,O3 also prepared by vapodeposition. The shape of the TOF/FE curve is identical to that shown in Fig. 9. The maximum TOF is also at about 0.6 nm. The XPS spectra of the Pt particles have been recorded as a function of d (78,79),and the results are among those presented in Fig. I . Most of the change in binding energy occurs below 2 nm. However, as already explained, the curves of ABE (Binding Energy) versus d appear to be about the same for all metals so that measuring ABE can be a way of estimating d as suggested by Masson et al. (78).At any rate there are important electronic effects in the region of the maximum TOF of Fig. 9, and it seems unlikely that there is any geometric ensemble that has a maximum surface concentration for particles of d near 0.6 nm. 2. Hydrogenation of Acetylene
We note here the work of Kojima et al. (262), although the effect of particle size has not been studied in their article. By using field-emission microscopy they were able to observe the surface structure of a tip of platinum. In an annealed condition a regular (1 10) plane was exposed, and the surface was relatively inert as a catalyst for the hydrogenation of C2H2.After argon ion bombardment the (1 10) surface was disrupted, and its catalytic activity greatly increased. This experiment demonstrates a form of structure sensitivity, induced in this case not by changing d but by changing the concentration of surface defects. The structure sensitivity of the selective hydrogenation of C2H2 to C2H4 over Pdlcr-Al203 catalysts has been studied by Gigola et al. (263). Industrial conditions of pressure and gas composition were used. For differential conversions, a strong antipathetic structure sensitivity was found as the FE was increased above that used for the industrial-type catalysts. Little ethylene was consumed. As the temperature and conversions were increased, however, the high FE catalysts lost their selectivity, probably through thermal effects. The low FE, industrial-type catalysts retained their selectivity (little ethylene consumption) at high conversion. 3. Hydrogenation of Cyclopropane, Propene, and 1-Hexene
In Fig. 10, curves I and 3 represent the hydrogenation of cyclopropane over Pt. The shapes are similar, but curve 2, for nickel, shows a maximum TOF at a d of about 1.2 nm, the lowest value used for the platinum data.
d ,nm 100
I
0.01
25
1
0.04
10
,
0.1
I
I
0.4
1.0
FE
FIG. 10. Turnover frequency TOF versus fraction exposed FE and mean particle size 2 for the hydrogenation of propene, 1-hexene, and cyclopropanes on various metal systems (see Table V for details of the studies).
TABLE V Details of the Metal Systems Studies Presented in Fig. 10 Curve (Fig. 10)
Symbol (Fig. 10)
Metal
I
4
Pt
Si02
2
A
Ni
Si02
3
0
Pt
AI2O1,Si02
4
0
Pt
SiOl
5
0
Pt
Si02
6
0
Ni
AIPOI
Support
Temperature, pressure 0°C. 1 atm, Hz/CP = 14 5"C, 1 atm, HJCP = ? O"C, 1 atm, H*/CP = 4.7 OT, 1 atm, H2/MCP = 14 -57°C 1 atm, HJC] = 19 25°C 4.1 atm, H2/C* = >>I