ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY VOLUME 79
CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS VOLUME K. P. BARLEY J. W. DUDLEY E. L. GFEACEN R. H. HAGEMAN K. ...
38 downloads
1848 Views
19MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY VOLUME 79
CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS VOLUME K. P. BARLEY J. W. DUDLEY E. L. GFEACEN R. H. HAGEMAN K. A. HANDBCK EDWINJAMES L. H. P. JONES SIGURDLARSEN E. R. LENG C. B. MCCANTS J. R. QUINBY M. RAUPACH w. G. WOLTZ
ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY Prepared under the Auspices of the AMERICANSOCIETY OF AGRONOMY
VOLUME 19
Edited by A. G. NORMAN The University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan
ADVISORY BOARD R. R. DAVIS F. A. HASKINS
J. A. JACKOBS J. P. MARTIN
W. A. RANEY
1967
ACADEMIC PRESS
New York and London
COPYRIGHT @ 1967, BY ACADEMICPRESSINC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO PART OF THIS BOOK MAY BE REPRODUCED IN ANY FORM, BY PHOTOSTAT, MICROFILM, OR ANY OTHER MEANS, WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHERS.
ACADEMIC PRESS INC. 111 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003
United Kingdom Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. (LONDON) LTD. Berkeley Square House, London W.l
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOG CARDNUMBER:50-5598
PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 19 Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors’ contributions begin.
BARLEY,K. P. ( l ) ,Reader, Agronomy Department, Waite Agricultural Research Institute, The University of Adelaide, Glen Osmond, South Australb DUDLEY, J. W. (45),Associate Professor, Plant Genetics, Department Agronomy, University o f Illinois, Urbana, Illinois GREACEN,E. L. ( l ) ,Principal Research Scientist, Diuision o f Soils, Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Orgunization, Glen Osmond, South Australia HAGEMAN,R. H. (45),Professor of Plant Physiology, Department of Agronomy, University of Illinois, Urbana, Illinois HANDRECK, K. A. ( 107), Experimental Oficer, Division of Plant Industry, Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization, University of Melbourne, Parkville, Victmh, Australia JAMES, EDWIN (87), Head, National Seed Storage Laboratory, Agricultural Research Sewice, United States Department of Agriculture, Fort Collins, Colorado JONES, L. H. P. (107), Principal Research Scientist, Division of Plant Industry, Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization, University o f Melbourne, Parkoille, Victoriu, Australia LARSEN,SIGUFUJ(151), Chief Soil Scientist, Department of Soil Science, Levington Research Station, Levington, Ipwich, Suffolk, England LENG,E. R. (45),Professor of Plant Breeding and Genetics, Department of Agronomy, University of Illinois, Urbana, Illinois MCCANTS,C. B. (211), Professor of Soil Science, Department of Soil Science, School o f Agriculture and Life Sciences, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, North Carolina QUINBY,J. R. (267), Head, Sorghum Breeding, Pioneer Smghum Company, Plainview, Texas RAUPACH, M. (307), Head, Soil Chemistry Section, Division of Soils, Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization, Glen Osmond, South Australia WOLTZ,W. G. (211 1, Professor of Soil Science, Department of Soil Science, School of Agriculture and Life Sciences, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, North Carolina V
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PREFACE The purpose of this serial publication is to provide authoritative reviews of progress in crop science, soil science, and agronomic practice. If there is a single theme, it is the soil-plant relationship. Most of the articles in this volume exemplify the theme. One indeed goes further and in an interesting way brings in consideration of the role of the animal in the cycling sequence. Great strides have been made in the improvement of crop plants through genetic recombination. The acre yield of many crops has been substantially increased by developing varieties better adapted to the environment, but there are still potential gains to be made, both in yield and quality, if the limiting biochemical processes can be identified. In their chapter on this topic, Hageman and colleagues discuss the nature of the opportunities thus presented. Physiological factors under genetic control are dealt with by Quinby in reviewing the maturity genes in sorghum, a crop the geographic range of which has been considerably extended in recent years. All plant breeders are properly concerned with the preservation of seed stocks and the maintenance of gene pools. The unique facility erected by the U. S. Department of Agriculture for this purpose is described by its Director, Edwin James. More applied topics are treated in a chapter on the growth and nutrition of flu-cured tobacco by McCants and Woltz and in one on the soil and nutritional requirements of an important Australian tree crop, Pinus radiata, by Raupach. In another article Barley and Greacen, Australian authors, take up in an analytical mood one of the oldest problems of plant growth, the penetration of roots through the soil and the emergence of seedling shoots, as affected by the mechanical stress of the environment. Recent developments in our understanding of soil forms of phosphorus and phosphorus transformation in soils are presented in a scholarly review by Sigurd Larsen. This is another old topic that is steadily reshaped because of continuing attention to the essential and dynamic role played by this element in plant growth. The eight chapters in this volume are indicative of the diversity and vitality of researches in soil and crop science that lead to improvements in practice and to the benefit of man. A. G. NORMAN Ann Arbor, Michigan June,1967 vii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CONTENTS CONTRI~UTORS TO VOLUME19 PREFACE
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
V
. .
.
.
vii
.
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE AS A SOIL FACTOR INFLUENCING THE GROWTH OF ROOTS AND UNDERGROUND SHOOTS BY K. P. BARLEYAND E. L. GREACEN
I. 11. 111. IV. V. VI. VII.
.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . Types of Deformation Produced by Plants . . . . . Forces Required to Deform Soils . . . . . . . Forces Exerted by Roots and Shoots . . . . . . . Effects of Mechanical Stress on the Growth of Roots and Shoots . Growth in the Soil . . . . . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
.
1 2 5 18 24 30 40 40
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . Heterosis and the Gene-Enzyme Concept . . . . . . Heterosis and Enzyme Activity during Germination . . . . Genetic Control of the Initial Reaction of Nitrogen Metabolism . . Specific Chloroplast Activity . . . . , . . . . Some Recent Developments in Plant Biochemistry Related to Heterosis A Concept for the Future . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . .
45 46 54 63 72 74 80 83
.
. .
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
BY R. H. HAGEMAN,E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
.
11. 111. IV. V. VI. VII.
PRESERVATION
OF SEED STOCKS
BY EDWINJAMES I. 11. 111. IV.
.
.
Introduction . . . . Theories Regarding Seed Deterioration Methods of Preserving Seeds . . The National Seed Storage Laboratory References . . . . . ix
.
. .
. .
.
. . . .
.
.
.
.
. .
. . . .
.
. . . . .
. . .
. .
. . .
87 88
.
101 105
.
94
CONTENTS
X
SILICA IN SOILS. PLANTS. AND ANIMALS BY L. H . P. JONFS I. I1. 111. IV V. VI .
.
AND
K . A. HANDRECK
Introduction . . . . . . . Factors Affecting the Silica Content of Plants Silica in the Plant . . . . . Silica in Relation to Plant Growth . . Silica in the Ruminant Animal . . . The Silica Cycle . . . . . . References . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
.
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
107 108 122 129 135 144 145
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
151 152 154 167 182 193 196 205 206
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
212 213 215 216 222 233 238 243 245 248 251 254 257 258 260 261
.
.
SOIL PHOSPHORUS BY SICURDLARSEN I. I1 I11 IV V VI VII VIII .
. . . . . .
Introduction . . . . . . . Geochemical Aspects of Soil Phosphorus . Phosphorus in Soil Solution . . . Soil Phosphorus in the Solid Phase . . Kinetics of Soil Phosphorus Reactions . Mobility of Soil Phosphorus . . . Agronomic Considerations . . . . Outlook . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
GROWTH AND MINERAL NUTRITION OF TOBACCO BY C. B . MCCANTSAND W . G . WOLTZ I. I1. I11. IV . V. VI . VII . VIII . IX . X. XI . XI1. XI11. XIV. XV .
. . . . . . . Introduction . Origin and Characteristics of Classes of Tobacco Seedling Growth . . . . . . . Plant Growth and Nutrient Uptake . . . Nitrogen . . . . . . . . Phosphorus . . . . . . . . Potassium . . . . . . . . Calcium . . . . . . . . Magnesium . . . . . . . . Liming . . . . . . . . . Chloride . . . . . . . . Boron . . . . . . . . . Sulfur . . . . . . . . . Manganese . . . . . . . . Other Minor Elements . . . . . . References . . . . . . . .
.
. . . . . .
.
.
.
.
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
xi
CONTENTS
THE MATURITY GENES OF SORGHUM
.
BY J R . QUINBY
1. I1. I11. IV . V VI VII . VIII IX . X. XI
. . . .
XI1.
XI11. XIV.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . Cultivated Sorghum . . . . . . . . . The Four Maturity Gene Loci of Sorghum . . . . Effect of Environment on Time of Flowering . . . . Control of Leaf Number by Time of Floral Initiation . . Interaction of Maturity Genes in the Milos and Hegari . . Interaction of Maturity Genes in the Heterozygous Condition Identification of Sorghum Varieties for Maturity . . . Allelic Series at the Maturity Gene Loci . . . . . Influence of Time of Floral Initiation on Plant Size . . Maturity Gene Loci and Heterosis . . . . . . Effect of Heterosis on Time of Flowering . . . . Physiology of Flowering in Sorghum . . . . . Discussion and Summary . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
. .
. .
.
.
. .
. .
.
.
.
.
267 268 269 271 277 278 279 282 290 296 297 298 300 301 304
SOIL AND FERTILIZER REQUIREMENTS FOR FORESTS OF Pinus radiata BY M . RAUPACH
I. I1. 111. IV . V VI VII . VIII .
. .
Introduction . . . . . . . . The Importance of the Species . . . . Characteristics of Growth and Climatic Tolerance . . . Soil Factors Restricting Growth . Assessment of Limiting Factors . . . . Effective Addition of Fertilizers . . . Field Practices . . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
307 308 311 314 322 343 347 349 350
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
AUTHORINDEX.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
355
SUBJECTINDEX .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
368
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE AS A SOIL FACTOR INFLUENCING THE GROWTH OF ROOTS AND UNDERGROUND SHOOTS K. P. Barley and E. L. Greacen Waite Institute, University
of Adelaide and Division of Soils, Commonwealth Scientific
and Industrial Research Organization, Adelaide, Australia
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Types of Deformation Produced by Plants . . . . . A. Tensile Failure . . . . . . . . , B. Shear Failure without Compression . . . . . C. Shear Failure with Compression . . . . . , 111. Forces Required to Deform Soils . . . . . . A. Theory . . . , . . . . . . B. The Assessment of Mechanical Resistance . . . . C. The Effect of Pore Water Pressure and Void Ratio on Mechanical Resistance . . . . . . . . IV. Forces Exerted by Roots and Shoots . . . . . A. Morphological Adaptations . . . . . . , B. Magnitude . . . . . . . . . . C. Physiological Origin . - . . . . . . V. Effects of Mechanical Stress on the Growth of Roots and Shoots A. Steady Stress . . . . . . . . . B. Perturbation of Stress . . . . . . . VI. Growth in the Soil . . . . . . . . . A. Growth in Media of Known Mechanical Properties . . B. The Interaction of Mechanical Resistance, Water Supply, . . . . . . . . . and Aeration . VII. Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
. .
I.
,
.
. .
. . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . .
Page 1 2 3
4 4 5 5 10 14 18 18 19
. . . . . . . . .
. . . .
24 24 29 30 30
.
.
37
.
.
40 40
. .
.
. .
20
Introduction
Man has been aware of the importance of the mechanical properties of the soil since agriculture began. He cultivated the soil when it was moist because it was then easier to deform. He was well aware that the emergence of his seeded crops could be hindered by a hard crust. In the late nineteenth century the work of Darwin and others stimulated considerable interest in the adaptation of plants to their mechanical environment. In the same period fundamental discoveries were made 1
2
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
about the chemistry of the nutrition of plants, and after the turn of the century interest was centered on this subject. Later the center of scientific interest shifted to physical studies of the water, air and heat relations of the plant. Although it was realized that the mechancial properties of the soil could sometimes be of great importance, the slow development of soil mechanics hindered further analysis of the influence of this soil factor on plant growth. The fact that soil mechanics has been the domain of the engineer has been a further handicap in applying the subject to agronomic problems. Frequently a practical empirical solution has been obtained by the engineer, which, although it solves a construction problem, may do little to explain the processes involved. Recent discoveries in soil and in plant mechanics promise better understanding of the way in which mechanical properties of the soil influence plant growth. In this review we intend to discuss chiefly the penetration of the soil by roots and emerging shoots. We remind the reader that mechanical factors also operate in other processes of considerable agronomic interest; a few examples are the burial of fruiting organs by certain crop and pasture legumes, the radial enlargement of edible underground organs, and the uprooting of crops or trees. Although roots and shoots may grow mainly through existing voids in openly structured soils, whenever these organs penetrate peds or horizons that lack wide pores they have to deform the soil. The soil resists deformation, and the growing organ is stressed mechanically by the reaction of the soil to the force that the organ exerts. It is well known that strongly cemented or indurated horizons exclude roots, and that strong crusts prevent emergence (Lutz, 1952); but in this review we aim to assess the importance of mechanical resistance in ordinary soils. We define mechanical resistance as the reaction of the soil to forces exerted by the growing plant. As the intercellular or “pore” space within plant organs is normally highly permeable to both air and water, differences in pore fluid pressure cannot be long sustained across a plant-soil boundary. Large gradients, of course, may exist within the soil itself. It follows that, except in transient states, we are concerned with the reaction on the plant of the solid phase of the soil. II.
Types
of Deformation Produced by Plants
The theory of soil mechanics, and the methods used to measure the mechanical properties of soils have been developed almost exclusively for engineering applications. The foundations engineer is concerned with the maximum force that a soil can withstand without undergoing a large displacement, that is, with the ultimate strength of the soil; whereas the biologist wants to know the force that will deform a soil sufficiently
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
3
to allow a root or shoot to grow. Differences in scale are also important: the engineer deals with stresses acting over areas of square meters and can employ a statistical concept of stress; in plant studies we are concerned with areas of the order of one square millimeter, and the plant organ is often commensurate in size with the structural or mechanical elements of the soil. A. TENSILE FAILURE One manifestation of tensile failure is the rupturing of soil crusts by emerging shoots. An appropriate measure of the strength of crust materials being deformed in this way is the modulus of rupture (Carnes, 1934). The force required to rupture the crust depends on the dimensions of the ruptured plates, and emergence should be related to this force rather than to the modulus itself. Arndt (1965) points out that rupture of the surface crust can be followed by jamming of the broken plates of soil (Fig. l a ) , This increases the force required for emergence.
FIG. 1. ( a ) Examples of soil deformation by emerging seedlings. The surface seal has cracked naturally, or been ruptured by the plant, with the plates subse(a' + z')"'. ( b ) Shear failure quently jamming. Jamming occurs when a + dl d' in the form of an inverted cone. (From Arndt, 1965.)
+ <
Roots can also rupture soils by tensile failure. Barley et al. (1965) observed that radicles of peas, Pisum sutivum L., 2 mm. in diameter, were able to split cores of compact loam (Fig. 2 ) . In contrast, the thinner (0.3 mm. diameter) radicles of wheat, Triticurn aestivurn L., formed channels in cores of compact loam, but the bursting force was not great enough to rupture the cores. Rupturing may involve either general or local tensile failure. When
4
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
-
0
5 cm.
FIG.2 . Tensile failures produced in a core of compact loam by pea radicles. (From Barley et al., 1985.)
a failure is general, by definition, it spreads to a soil boundary; in local failure the tension cracks do not extend to the boundary but are accommodated by compression of the soil. B. SHEARFAILURE WITHOUT COMPRESSION Besides failing under tension, soils also fail under shearing stresses imposed by plant organs. Terzaghi (1943, p.119) describes general shear failure in soils under shallow foundations. In Terzaghi’s model the soil compresses little with increasing application of the load until a critical load is reached, when the soiI fails completely. Failure takes place on a sliding surface described by a plane and a logarithmic spiral. The load that the soil will support depends on the strength parameters, (Terzaghi, apparent cohesion, c, and the angle of internal friction, 1943). The kind of failure described by Terzaghi has been observed when roots first penetrate saturated clay (Cockroft, unpublished data). An example of general shear failure caused by seedling emergence has been given by Arndt (1965) (Fig. l b ) ; the soil fails along the surface of an inverted cone having its apex at the top of the seedling,
+
C. SHEARFAILURE WITH COMPRESSION In unsaturated compressible soil much of the volume increase of the growing plant organ may be accommodated by compression, and the
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
5
zone of shear failure in which the stresses are in “plastic equilibrium” (Terzaghi, 1943, p.23) may frequently fail to spread to a soil boundary. When this is so we speak of “local shear failure.” Examples of local shear failure with compression caused by growing roots have been given by Barley (1954, 1963). Roots were shown to have compacted coarse textured media for a radial distance of several millimeters around the root. The volume of the cores in which the roots were grown remained constant. Shear, together with compression, is probably the most common way in which growing plant organs deform ordinary, unsaturated soils. In saturated clay plant organs may form channels by consolidation together with shear failure. If the volume of the root is accommodated without displacing the boundaries of the clay, as water and clay are only slightly compressible, water must be either absorbed by the penetrating root or drained through an outer boundary of the clay. This process, by definition, involves consolidation ( Terzaghi, 1943, p.265) , but, as a hole is being formed, shear failure must also occur. The process described above differs from one-dimensional consolidation as met in engineering practice. In one-dimensional consolidation the consolidating axial stress, ul,and the resulting radial stress, us,are not in plastic equilibrium but are related by the expression u3 = K,u,, where KO is the coefficient of earth pressure at rest. For medium-textured soils with 9 = 40°,K Oz 0.5, and for clays with lower values of 9, K O varies from 0.6 to 1.0. When consolidation is accompanied by shear failure the two stresses are related by the coefficient of active earth pressure, K , (Terzaghi, 1943, p.50); K , is as low as 0.2 for coarse-textured soils but can approach 1.0 for clays. Ill.
Forces Required to Deform Soils
A. THEORY
1. Tensile Failure General tensile failure of surface crusts is commonly treated in terms of elasticity theory. In the modulus of rupture test the force, F , required to rupture a slab of length a, width b, and thickness z, for single-center point loading is given by
and for two-point loading at a / 3 and 2 a/3 by
6
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
where up is the tensile strength of the soil. Analyses of tensile failure for more complicated configurations are available in the theory of elasticity ( Timoshenko and Goodier, 1951) . The tensile rupture of bulky structures can also be described theoretically. Applying a spherical model, the zone of plastic equilibrium around the base or point of a probe can be treated as a pressure bulb of radius R (see Section 111, A, 3 ) . The radial pressure at R, u ~will , burst a soil clod if the cross-sectional area of the structural element is such that tensile resistance is less than the force developed over the cross section of the pressure bulb. Whether a clod will fail in tension depends then on the magnitude of uR,the tensile strength of the soil uT,and on the size of the clod. If rupture occurs during radial enlargement rather than during penetration a cylindrical model should be used. Local radial cracks may develop either around individual roots or between adjacent root channels (Fig. 2 ) . Using either a spherical or cylindrical model, the tangential stress U t , which reaches a maximum at R, closely approaches the tensile strength of the soil. Where the plastic zones of adjacent roots overlap v(Tt is increased, and local rupture is likely to occur. 2. Shear Failure without Compression The conventional description of forces acting on the base of a pile or probe (Terzaghi, 1943) shows that the bearing capacity qp of a shallow ( z = d ) foundation, of depth z and width d, failing in general shear, is given by qp = cNc
+ P Z N ,+ pdN,
(3)
where c = apparent cohesion, p = bulk density, and N,, N,, Np = bearing capacity factors. The values of the bearing capacity factors depend only on the angle of internal friction, When saturated clays are distorted with negligible drainage, the strength of the clay is not altered by an applied load since the load is carried by the pore water (see Section 111, C, 1). Shear strength is then determined solely by c, and the soil is called a frictionless or = 0 soil. For circular shallow footings in saturated undrained clay qpz 7.5 c. According to Terzaghi’s model qp increases continuously with x. This relation applies to rough probes entering saturated “undrained” clays, the requirement of the “undrained condition being met either because the clay is so impermeable that it fails to consolidate, or because the rate of loading or penetration is so high that there is time for only a negligible amount of consolidation.
+,
+
7
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
With the exception of Terzaghi’s analysis for shallow foundations there are few analyses of general shear failure appropriate to biological problems. The general shear failure that sometimes occurs above upward acting penetrometers and seedling shoots is described in an analysis given by Balla (1961) for the anchorage of mushroomed pylons. Sohtions require the strength parameters c and + and the configuration of the system. 3. Shem Failure with Compression
Where the soil does not behave as an ideal brittle or plastic material, but is compressed or consolidated during deformation, conventional theory is inadequate. For deep piles, z > 3d, a “plasticity” theory modified from that of Terzaghi is usually employed (Meyerhof, 1951). Although Meyerhof‘s theory implicitly describes local shear failure, as shearing is depicted as occurring in a localized zone around the base of the pile, compression is not described explicitly. According to Meyerhof, for homogeneous saturated clay soils failing without drainage ( 4 = 0), qp attains a steady maximum at depth where qp = 10 c. Strictly, qpcannot attain a steady maximum in such materials, because the shearing zone would have to extend to the full depth of the pile. But real clays are neither truly saturated nor homogeneous, and in practice the volume of the pile may often be accommodated locally, for example by displacement of the clay into cracks or fissures. In compressible soils, following Terzaghi (1943, p.130) an arbitrary reduction is made in c and 4. The bearing capacity factors have been elaborated by Meyerhof (1961) to include the shape and roughness of the pile. His theory is useful for saturated clays and for soils having 4 < 35” and failing with little compression. Since the factors become highly sensitive to changes in for values > 35”,and as a large arbitrary reduction in + must be made in compressible soils, the theory lacks general utility. An analysis of the resistance offered to probes in compressible soils has recently been made by Farrell and Greacen (1966). Following earlier work on the distribution of stress in soil around holes (de Jong and Geertsma, 1953) , tunnels ( Terzaghi, 1943), and around piles (Nishida, 196l), they postulate the existence of two main zones of compression around the point of a penetrating probe: a zone of shearing failure called the plastic zone, and outside this an elastic zone (see Fig. 3 ) . Farrell and Greacen assume that the pressure on the base of a probe is equal to the pressure required to form a spherical cavity in the soil. This approach is not new. Previously Bishop et al. (1945) had used the model of an expanding cavity in a study of indentation tests in copper. Ladanyi (1963) used a similar model to describe pile penetration into a
+
8
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
saturated undrained clay, and Nishida ( 1961) calculated the pressure required to expand a cylindrical cavity in the soil. The new contribution of Farrell and Greacen is their treatment of the compressibility of the soil. The analyses of Bishop et al. and Ladanyi concerned incompressible material. Nishida assumed that the volume u2 ~,)/3, change was determined by the mean principal stress, ( u1 where the subscripts refer to the principal stresses. Vanden Berg et al. (1958) also used the mean principal stress, but Sohne (1958) used the major principal stress. Farrell and Greacen largely overcome this ambiguity by using an experimental curve for compression accompanying
+ +
PRINCIPAL STRESS
U,. (bar)
(a) FIG. 3. Compression curves ( a ) associated with the zones of compression I-IV ( b ) around the point of a penetrometer in compressible soil: I , e = emin,11, failure zone, I l l , rebound zone, and lV, elastic zone.
shear failure. In the plastic zone there are three distinct subzones of compression (Fig. 3 ) : I, where the soil is compressed to the minimum void ratio’ emin;11, where the soil undergoing failure behaves as a material being compressed for the first time; 111, a rebound zone where the soil behaves as an “overconsolidated”material (see Section 111, C, 2 ) . After equating the change in volume of voids in the various zones with the volume of the probe, Farrell and Greacen find the radius of the plastic zone, R, and, knowing this, the pressure qp on the base of a smooth (frictionless) cylindrical probe. The theoretical value of qp for a smooth
’I t is mathematically convenient to express the state of compaction of the soil as void ratio, e, rather than bulk density, p . e = p./p - 1, where p . = absolute density of solid phase. Similarly, volumetric water content, 8 , is conveniently replaced by e , and air space, a, by e,.
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
9
probe can be checked experimentally by rotating a real probe to dissipate friction in the tangential direction. When this was done Farrell and Greacen found good agreement between theoretical and measured values of qpin a range of finely structured soils. Ordinarily, friction is mobilized both at the base (“point” friction) and along the curved cylindrical barrel (“skin” friction) of a probe. Point friction is appreciable for metal probes in soil. For example, it increases the value of qp for real as opposed to smooth probes by as much as 40 percent when the angle of soil-metal friction, 8, = 23” (Farrell and Greacen, 1966). When the additional expression for point friction is incorporated, the theory of Farrell and Greacen may be used to predict qp for real, nonrotated probes. The agreement obtained with measured values for steel probes in three soils is shown in Table I (see p. 15). It seems likely that qP for root tips is less than qp for steel probes, as an estimate of the friction angle, 6, for the interface between root tips < Ssteel-soil (see Section and sand (Barley, 1962) suggests that SrOOt-SO,l 111, A, 4). However no data are available for the immediately relevant interface between root cap and soil. It is possible that the well known secretion of mucigel by cells of the root cap is a means of reducing 6. Recently Farrell and Greacen have extended their theoretical analysis to include cylindrical enlargement. Surprisingly, when 4 is large, say 40”,the pressure required for the radial enlargement of a cylindrical cavity is only one-fifth of that required for a spherical cavity. The difference between the two pressures decreases with decreasing values of 4. Clearly, the shape of a penetrating object may have a large influence on the resistance encountered in high 4 soils. The cylindrical model is likely to be more appropriate when the tip is acutely tapered.
4 . Skin Friction In foundations-engineering the total axial pressure, q, that a pile can withstand, or, in other words, the axial pressure that has to be applied to penetrate the soil, is termed the bearing capacity and is given by
(4) where qp = point pressure; qf = axial pressure needed to overcome skin friction on the curved cylindrical wall of the pile. Usually adhesion and skin friction are lumped together and estimated empirically. For rough piles in “undrained clay, skin friction per unit curved wall area may be s e t equal to c, and the bearing load due to skin friction Qf = %JOzcrdz, where r is the radius of the pile. For drained conditions Eide et al. (1961) represent the radial load on the shaft as Kuz, where a, is the effective axial pressure and K is a coefficient of earth P=
QP
+,Qf
10
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
pressure. Then, Qr = 2 ~ / o x K tan ~ Z r6 dx. For rough piles 6 may be set equal to 4. Little is known about the skin friction and adhesion at the interface between plant organs and the soil. One value of 8, reported for a root“soil” interface, pertains to the root tip of maize and a moistened plate of cemented sand (Barley, 1962). This value of 6 was obtained directly by the following method: first, root tips with a flattened “face” were obtained by pressing roots against the plate as they grew. The tip was then severed and secured to a slider with small barbs. Finally, the flat face of the root tip was forced against a portion of the plate mounted on a friction trolley. The measured value of 8 was 17”. Recently Barley and Stolzy (1966) used as a crude measure of Qf the force required to pull out a penetrating root tip. For peas (Pisum sativum L.) in a moist loam Q, was one-fifth of the total resistance to penetration Q. The pulling method is used in engineering to measure Q, for piles, and it is usefuI in clays. In sands the radial pressure on the pile is relieved by the upward pull and friction is underestimated. In contrast to piles, where the whole buried length is pushed through the soil and meets with frictional resistance, in the root only the short length from the cap to the proximal limit of the zone of elongation is pushed through the soil. Friction occurs behind the zone of elongation, but it is mobilized as anchorage to assist penetration, For emerging shoots the location of the zone of elongation relative to the apex differs widely between species (Leonhardt, 1915). In many plants an appreciable part of the shoot is pushed upward through the soil, and skin friction cannot be safely neglected in any analysis of the resistance opposed to emergence.
B. THEASSESSMENT OF MECHANICAL RESISTANCE Estimates of the mechanical resistance opposed to growth must be based on knowledge of the type of deformation produced by the plant root or shoot. The type of deformation determines not only the soil properties to be measured, but also, as we shall see, the methods to be used in measurement. 1 . Determinatwn. of Strength Parameters The parameters that describe the strength of a soil failing by shear with little or no compression are the classical strength parameters c and 4. The relationship between these parameters and certain derived measures of strength is described diagrammaticaIIy in Fig. 4.For any particular normal load, un, acting on a plane of failure, c and 4 give the shear strength, sn, according to the Coulomb equation sn = c
+
U~
tan
ip
(5)
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
11
The Mohr circle for the unconfined compressive strength, uc, is shown in Fig. 4;it can be seen that uc depends on c and 4. Farrell et al. (1967) have shown that, at pore water pressures as high as -0.3 bar, compact loams behave as brittle materials, for which uc = Sor (Griffith, 1924). Where the sample is in the form of a core, either natural or remolded,
FIG.4. Mohr diagram for an unsaturated soil with the failure envelope described by c and @, u1 and u3 are the principal stresses; in a triaxial test these are the axial and the radial stresses, respectively. The shear stress 7 = ( uI - u3)/2. Mohr circles for the compressive strength, uc, and the tensile strength, uT, are also shown.
can be measured indirectly by means of the so-called Brazilian test (Kirkham et al., 1959) or uC can be measured by an unconfined loading test. Both tests are performed in a compression test machine; in the Brazilian test the lateral load required to rupture the core in tension is measured, and, in the second, the axial load required to rupture the core in shear is measured. Rogowski (1964) has pointed out that the above methods measure bulk strength of the soil and that the bulk strength is usually limited by the inter-aggregate strength. Rogowski suggests that intra-aggregate strength may be more important in controlling root penetration, because the root may often penetrate by deforming the adjacent aggregates rather than an extensive zone. He proposes that aggregate density be measured, strength then being determined on cores of soil remolded and compacted to the measured density. However soil strength is known to depend on the stress history of the soil, and there is no simple relation between density and strength (Section 111, C, 2 ) . Rogowski also developed a techUT
12
K. P. BAFLEY AND
E. L GREACEN
nique for measuring the crushing strength of small ( 2 to 3 mm.) aggregates, by rupturing them in an unconfined compression test between two plates. He postulates that roots encounter a resistance that depends on the crushing strength of the aggregates. However, even if this is so, his analysis is unsatisfactory as it stands because it neglects deformations that precede and accompany failure of the aggregates. Rogowski's criticism of the measurement of bulk soil properties hardly applies when the deformation spreads over a zone that is large compared with the size of the aggregates, that is, in finely structured soil. In soils where the aggregates are commensurate in width with the plant organ concerned, Rogowski's approach may be profitable. The derived measures: modulus of rupture, the Brazilian test, the compressive strength, and the crushing strength each give a single Mohr circle on the strength diagram (Fig. 4 ) . Because of this any one of these measures provides useful comparative data only where 4 is constant or almost so. As mentioned in Section 111, A, 2, saturated, undrained clays behave as if they were 4 = 0 materials. In unsaturated soils or in fully drained clays 4 usually varies between 20" and 45" (Fountaine and Brown, 1959), not being greatly affected by changes in void ratio or pore water pressure. It should be noted, however, that occasionally much lower values have been reported (Payne and Fountaine, 1952). A satisfactory characterization of strength for failure with little or no compression is obtained by describing the failure envelope on a Mohr diagram with one of the recognized techniques. The torsion shear box (Payne and Fountaine, 1952) or the direct shear box (Terzaghi and Peck, 1948) are often employed, the former being useful for small (25 cc.) samples or peds. The most versatile method for soil cores is the triaxial compression test, a comprehensive account of which is given by Bishop and Henkel (1962). Where the deformation involves local shear failure with compression, analytical estimates of mechanical resistance require the strength parameters c and 4 together with a measured compressibility curve. The compressibility characteristics may be expressed as a Young's Modulus and as the gradients of the failure and rebound curves for compression with shear (see Section 111, A, 2). The parameters c and 4 and the compressibility characteristics are equally important in determining the resistance to penetration. As Farrell and Greacen (1966) have shown they can be measured with sufficient accuracy by means of the triaxial cell, No general relation is to be expected between void ratio, e, and the resistance that soils offer to penetration, Q. When e>>e,,i, for a particular soil most of the volume change occurs in the zone of compression with failure; as e approaches eminthe rebound zone and the zone of
13
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
elastic compression become important. This change of process is responsible for the lack of any general relation.
2. Empirical Measures of Mechanical Resistance Although empirical measures of mechanical resistance, such as penetrometer data, contribute little to physical understanding and provide little scope for generalization, they may be useful in diagnostic work. As illustrated in Fig. 5 the point resistance, Qp,offered to a probe
A
0
I
2
3
4
RELATIVE DEPTH OF PENETRATION (Z/d)
FIG.5. Fractional point resistance, Qp/Qp mnx, as a function of z/d for a shallow ( z > 3 d ) test in a compressible soil.
( z = d ) and a deep
increases with z to a steady maximum when x exceeds several diameters. The force required to indent the soil is customarily measured by a shallow test or “indentation” test in which x = d. It can be seen from Fig. 5 that Qp is still increasing rapidly where x = d. This introduces a serious source of variability in the shallow test, as errors of +2O percent can easily be made in measuring the depth of penetration of say a 5 mm. diameter probe. An alternative to penetrometer testing that has been fashionable in foundations engineering is the vane shear test (Carlson, 1948). This method was developed initially for saturated clays that behave in rapid tests as if 4 = 0. Evans and Sherratt (1948) have shown that for 4 < 10” the vane shear strength can be related to c and +, but for higher values of the frictional component becomes overriding. No adequate analysis has been made of the mechanics of the vane test in high 4 soils.
+
14
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
In a recent study emergence of shoots has been related to indentation test data using downward acting probes (Parker and Taylor, 1965) (see Section VI, A ) ; but upward acting probes would seem to be preferable in that the boundary conditions for the test are then more appropriate (Morton and Buchele, 1!360). Arndt (1965) devised an upward acting probe for use in the field, the apparatus being buried in the soil before weathering of the seed bed had taken place, As the use of Arndt’s device in the field is extremely tedious, simpler methods should be examined. Bennett et al. ( 1964) measured the force required to pull up a line buried horizontally in the soil, and showed that the pull was negatively correlated with the emergence of cotton seedlings. A simple empirical test that is mechanically more apt could be conducted by using a buried bead several millimeters in diameter and measuring the force needed to pull this from the soil with a fine wire. Although cylindrical probes provide a relative measure of resistance to penetration, and are useful in correlative studies (see Section VI, B, 2 ) , probe data should not be identified with the absolute resistance encountered by growing organs. Discrepancies arise for many reasons; the chief reasons are as follows: ( 1) Growing organs are flexible and tend to grow around obstructions. ( 2 ) The shape of plant organs differs from that of cylindrical probes; moreover the shape is influenced by the resistance of the soil. ( 3 ) The stress distribution around a plant organ, unlike a rigid body, depends not only on its shape and on the soil properties, but also on the anisotropic properties af the tissue. (4)Friction and adhesion at the interface between plant and soil may differ from that between probe and soil. (5) Uptake of water by roots causes local changes in the pore water pressure and hence in the strength of the soil. ( 6 ) In saturated soils the root creates additional opportunities for drainage. The biological aspects will be further explored in Section VI, A. Unless the differences between probes and plant organs are understood we cannot hope to relate theoretical or measured values of Q to the mechanical resistance experienced by roots or shoots.
C. THEEFFECTOF POREWATERPRESSURE AND VOID RATIO ON MECHANICAL RESISTANCE The data in Table I provide a clear illustration of the extreme dependence of qp on pore water pressure, uw,and void ratio, e. It is worth noting that the strength of unsaturated soils can change considerably even when there is little change in the water content; indeed the change in strength is most rapid when the water-filled void ratio, e,, is appreciable and the gradient de,/du, is small. Note, for example, that for the Parafield loam described in Table I, at e = 0.56, qp increases from 20 to 34 bar when
15
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
TABLE I Comparison of Theoretical with Measured Values of Point Pressure ( q p ) for Steel Probes in Three Soils Void ratio Soil l’arafield loam
Pore water pressure” (bar)
-0.3
-0.7
Urrbrae loam
-0.3
Coleraine clay
-0.3
QP
(bar)
Water-filled Total e
ew
Theoretical
Measured
0.77 0.66 0.56 0.77 0.66 0.56 1.04 0.89 0.77 1.65 1.41 1.21
0.46 0.45 0.44 0.41 0.41 0.40 0.79 0.79 0.79 1.26 1.26 1.26
7.8 14.9 22.0 13.1 21.8 30.2 6.0 8.6 13.5 4.4 6.7 10.0
9.3 12.6 19.9 18.3 24.5 34.0 5.7 9.5 17.8 6.1 8.0 13.3
Pore water pressure uul = -h, where h is the suction in the soil water, both uwand h being referred to atmospheric pressure as datum. It is more convenient to employ uw in mechanical studies, as pressures above and below the datum exist simultaneously in different parts of the soil-plant system.
urnis decreased from -0.3 bar to -0.7 bar, the decrease in e , being only 0.04. 1. Pore Water Pressure and Effective Stress In a saturated soil a decrease in u, has the same effect on strength as an increase of equal magnitude in the externally applied pressure (Childs, 1955). Skempton (1960) has discussed the effect of amon the strength of saturated soils from the engineering point of view, and should be consulted for a more detailed account. Terzaghi (1923) showed experimentally that for a saturated soil the degree of unidirectional consolidation depended on the “effective” stress, d,defined as d = u - urn,where u is the applied normal stress. Similarly the bulk modulus, p, of a saturated soil experiencing isotropic compression is given by p = dp’/dc, = d ( p - u,) /da,, where p and p’ are the applied and effective pressures and E, is the cubical dilation. Generally, if c and 9 had been defined in this review as intrinsic properties of the soil at datum pressure, effective rather than applied stresses would have had to be substituted in equations such as (5) that contain c or $. In practice it is often more convenient to work in terms of applied stresses and use apparent values of c and 0 obtained under conditions of testing
16
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
(drainage, rate of deformation) that pertain to the deformation being studied. For example, if mechanical properties are to be related to root penetration, tests should be conducted with full drainage at low rates of deformation (slow drained tests). In unsaturated soil, where the pores contain both air and water, the pore water pressure is regarded as acting over an effective area x per unit area of the soil. The effective stress is then given as u’ = (u - xuw)
(6)
When the soil is saturated x = 1 and Eq. ( 6 ) may be identified with Terzaghi’s definition given above. Bishop ( 1960) shows experimentally that x is a nonlinear function of the degree of saturation. The function exhibits hysteresis and depends on the stress history of the soil. Bishop’s relations between uw and effective stress are satisfactory where U, is held constant during deformation, or alternatively where the volume of soil being strained is so small relative to the bulk of the sample that uw is buffered by internal drainage. However, where the bulk of the soil is deformed, as in most testing procedures, u, may differ markedly from the initial pressure, particularly if the test is rapid or the moisture conductivity is low. Croney and Coleman (1954) show that in undrained saturated soils uw changes considerably with the degree and rate of straining. Greacen (1960) and Bishop (1960) extended this result to unsaturated soils. Again, where the deformation involves compression, the influence of uw on compressibility must be taken into account by measuring the compressibility curves at a number of initial water contents (Farrell and Greacen, 1966). In addition to changes in uw arising from deformation of the soil, we have to remember that the transpiring plant can transmit large suctions to the soil water. The probable magnitude of gradients in uwaround roots arising from transpiration is shown, for example, by Gardner (1960). As the elongating tip of the root is permeable (Rosene, 1937), the tip presumably takes up water together with the proximal parts of the root. Indeed the local decrease in uw due to transpiration may often be more significant than the change associated with deformation. 2. Void Ratio Although it is obvious that compact soils are hard to deform, failure to appreciate the nature of the relation between void ratio and penetrability has hindered progress. Veihmeyer and Hendrickson ( 1948) proposed that the inability of roots to penetrate particular soils below a certain critical void ratio could be attributed to the lack of pores of sufficient width. It is now recognized that the mechanical resistance of the
17
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
soil determines the chances of penetration, small pores usually but not always being associated with higher strength. For a saturated soil that is being consolidated for the first time (Fig. 6, curve a b ) the relation between e and the uniaxial consolidation pressure, U, is given by
(7)
e = eo --~I~In7(u/uO)
where I, = a constant for the particular soil called the compression index; and e, = the void ratio at an arbitrary pressure u0. In soils that have been consolidated and then unloaded (curve b c ) , the void ratio depends on the maximum consolidation pressure experienced, ub, and the extent of swelling following unloading. The effect of a previous cycle of compression on the compressibility of such “overconsolidated soil is evident from the reloading or “rebound” curve ( c d ) . If the pressure is increased beyond ~b the soil is compressed along a continuation of the “virgin” or “normal” consolidation curve (ub) . In the classical Coulomb equation (Eq. 5) the effect of void ratio on shear strength is not separated. For saturated clays Hvorslev (1937) attempted to express this in the following equation:
+
s = co exp (- e f / l c ) a’, tan 40
(8)
where sf = the shear strength at failure; ef = the void ratio at failure; = the effective normal stress acting on the plane of failure; and c,, are constants for the particular soil. The first term of the R.H.S. of Eq. ( 8 ) represents the cohesion as a function of ef. The meaning of the second term can be illustrated by reference to Fig. 6. It can be seen that any particular void ratio, em,may be arrived at by different loading paths, and that the soil may be in equilibrium at any given value of em at distinct effective normal stresses. Similarly, shear failure at a given value of ef can occur at a number of values of u’f. It is found that sf increases linearly with u’,, and is the slope dsf/du‘f. Scott (1963 p. 383) discusses refinements of the Hvorslev equation. The effect of void ratio on the mechanical properties of unsaturated soil is not as well understood. As in saturated clay, e is usually related directly to In u (Farrell and Greacen, 1966).Analogous behavior can also be seen in a tendency for u, to decrease as overconsolidated, unsaturated soils are sheared. In a soil consisting of overconsolidated aggregates the deformation is far from simple; individual aggregates can dilate positively while the soil as a whole undergoes compression and shear (Greacen, 1960). Such observations emphasize the need to base analytical estimates
+,,
~ ’ f
+,
18
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
In U
ub
FIG. 6 . Void ratio, e, as a function of the logarithm of consolidation pressure, In (I,for a saturated soil.
of mechanical resistance partly on empirical data, such as a measured compressibility curve, and to eschew the use of overidealized mechanical models when dealing with ordinary unsaturated soils. IV.
Forces Exerted by Roots
and Shoots
Two classical papers prepared the way for modern work on plant mechanics: Schwendener (1874) not only described ways in which anatomical adaptations help the plant withstand mechanical stress, but he also made the first measurements of the elasticity and strength of plant tissues; Pfeffer ( 1893) provided the first detailed, quantitative account of the forces exerted by roots and shoots. By comparing the forces that can be exerted by plant organs with those that are needed to deform the soil, we can see whether the mechanical properties of the soil are likeIy to influence pIant growth. A. MORPHOLOGICAL ADAPTATIONS Underground plant organs frequently show striking morphological adaptations to growth in a resistant medium. One class of adaptations reduces the resistance encountered; for example, in roots the localizing of elongation in a short zone just behind the cap makes it easier for the root to grow around obstructions and minimizes skin friction. Other adaptations assist the organ to withstand the reaction of the soil; for example, the apex of rhizomes is often protected with hardened tissues.
19
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
Others again enable the meristem to evade stress, as does the nutant habit of the seedling shoot in many dicotyledons. It is not proposed to go into further detail here, as clear accounts of mechanical adaptation are to be found in the literature. The most comprehensive source of information is still Haberlandt’s classical text “Physiologische Pflanzenanatomie.” Numerous further examples of the mechanical adaptations to be found in underground shoots are given by Leonhardt ( 1915).
B. MAGNITUDE In Pfeffer’s experiments part of a root or shoot was secured within a gypsum block; a second but movable block was then cast around the exposed tip or around one side of the organ, Any force exerted on the second block by the growing organ could then be measured by balancing against a known resistance. In practice Pfeffer was concerned solely with static equilibria, measuring the resistance that had to be applied to the second block to prevent it from being moved. Pfeffer found that when an organ was so confined it soon exerted a force. The force increased rapidly at first and then more slowly, approaching a maximum in 2 to 3 days. The maximum force corresponded to a pressure of from 5 to 10 bar distributed over the largest cross section within the growing region. Although he did not make many measurements, Pfeffer’s results suggest that the pressure exerted by root tips is greater in the direction of the longitudinal axis than in the radial direction (see Table 11).On the other hand, Pfeffer found that the axial and TABLE I1 Pfeffer’s Data on the Maximum Pressure Developed by Confined Root Tips0 Axial pressure (bar) Species
No. of roots
Mean max.
Range
Vicia faba L. Zea mays L.
6 3
9.0 10.2
7.0-10.7 9.5-11.2
~
a
T: 17-20°C; length of tip
Transverse pressure (bar) No. of roots
Range
5.3 6.6
4.3-6.1 -
4 1
~
< 1 cm.; pressure
Mean max.
~
=
force
~~~
+ max.
cross section.
radial pressures developed by shoots were similar. Pfeffer was not altogether surprised by the magnitude of the pressures that he recorded for roots and shoots, as Muller (1872) had found previously that a mechanical pressure of 14 bar was needed to prevent the elongation of pith isolated from the stem of the sunflower, Helianthus annuus L., and
20
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
Krabbe (1884) had reported that a radial pressure of 10 bar was needed to prevent an increase in the girth of trees. After the publication of Pfeffer’s paper in 1893 the subject appears to have been neglected until Williams (1956) measured the force exerted by the arching hypocotyl of small-seeded legumes. Although papers of Gill and Miller (19%) and Barley (1962) helped renew interest in the topic, these authors were mainly concerned with the efEects of stress on growth (see Section V, A, 3 ) . Recently, Barley and Stolzy ( 1966) have described a method of measuring the force exerted by root tips penetrating a soil. The soil is supported by a force transducer that measures the reaction to the root tip. Providing measurements are restricted to the time during which the hairless part of the tip is penetrating the soil, only a small correction is needed for skin friction. From Pfeffer’s work it is clear that, for a given species and organ, the pressure developed is largely independent of the diameter attained, so that the force exerted increases with the size of the growing organ. Even though roots apply a smaller pressure in the radial than in the axial direction, the force exerted in the radial direction is by far the greater, as the pressure acts over a larger area. For example, roots of the broad bean, Viciu faba L., can exert maximum radial and axial pressures of 5 and 9 bar, respectively, but the radial and axial forces that can be exerted by a 4 cm. length of root are 5 kg.wt. and 0.3 kg.wt. The upward acting forces exerted by seedling shoots range from 15 g.wt. for the thin hypocotyls of alfalfa, Medicago satiua, L., (Williams, 1956) to 401) g.wt. for the thick hypocotyls of the broad bean (Pfeffer, 18913). Evidently, any environmental factor that changes the dimensions of a growing organ influences the total force that can be exerted on the surroundings. The ability of roots or shoots to exert force on the soil depends not only on their physiological properties and shape, but also on the anchorage provided by the proximal parts of the plant; that is, the force exerted cannot exceed the ability of the proximal parts to withstand the reaction. Anchorage is provided by skin friction together with the resistance that has to be overcome to dislodge the seed, root hairs and root laterals. Pfeffer found that forces of the order of 40 g.wt. per centimeter length were required to pull the hair-covered radicles of broad bean from soils, and that several centimeters of branched root could stand a pull equal to the maximum axial force exerted by the growing tip of the root.
C. PHYSIOLOGICAL ORIGIN 1. Osmotically Induced Turgor
The exertion of force by plant organs is most readily explained in terms of their osmotic behavior. When pressures are measured with
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
21
respect to the ambient solution as datum, for a semipermeable tissue at osmotic equilibrium a-T=O
(9)
where x = osmotic pressure of the cell contents, and T = hydrostatic pressure within the cell. Strictly, an equilibrium expression for an imperfectly permeable osmometer should be given here, but the nature of cell permeability does not affect the present argument. We disregard variaand T within the turgid cell, arising from the presence of tion in differentially permeable cytoplasmic membranes. Treating forces directed toward the center of the cell as positive, at the cell wall,
-T
=
W+B- P
(10)
where W = pressure exerted by the wall (“wall” pressure); B = pressure exerted by other cells (“tissue” pressure); and P = pressure applied externally by the plant. Thermodynamically, osmotic and swelling pressures are identical (Hermans, 1949); so, if we assume that meristematic cells offer little internal resistance to water transfer, then the vacuolar liquid and protoplasm should be in or near osmotic equilibrium. Further, providing supply of water is not limiting, osmotic equilibrium with the ambient solution is thought to be attained, or nearly so, throughout the zone of cell enlargement ( Ordin et al., 19.56). If plant forces are osmotic in origin, they may be mobilized either by an increase in x or by relieving W and B . The pressure exerted by , W = B = 0. the plant attains a theoretical maximum, P,,,,, = x ~ when Pfeffer believed that both processes were operative. Measuring ro with the plasmolytic method of de Vries (1884) and with the “minimum length” method often ascribed to Ursprung (1923) in modern texts, Pfeffer (1893) concluded that in broad bean T o rose gradually after the root tip or seedling shoot had been confined, Secondly, Pfeffer showed that elastic strain disappeared from the cells of confined root tips. He found that root tips confined for 48 hours or more failed to shrink when plasmolyzed. This was not due merely to maturation of the apical tissue, as the tips at once began to elongate when transferred to iced water. Unfortunately, as Pfeffer used potassium nitrate as the osmoticum, his r0 values are excessively high ( > 15 bar). It is now known that this salt penetrates excessively into root cells. Using sucrose at 2”C., Barley (1962) did not find any increase in x in compressed growing radicles of the tick bean (Viciu faba L., var. MINOR). Neither Pfeffer nor Barley detected any increase in T in compressed radicles of corn. Whether or not there is a buildup in x in some species, the relief of wall and tissue
22
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
pressure appears to offer a ready means of mobilizing osmotic turgor to perform external work. Although the plant material is not directly comparable, it is interesting to note that the value of P,,, found by Pfeffer for the root tips of corn agrees with the r,,value obtained by Barley: P,.,, = To = 11 bar. 2. Nonosmotic Contributions to Turgor
Even if we can account for the magnitude of the pressure measured by Pfeffer without the need to invoke other than osmotic processes, this in itself does not show that osmosis is the only process involved. However, no other process has conclusively been shown to raise the hydrostatic pressure within plant cells. Bennet-Clark ( 1959), having reviewed the evidence in favor of “active” uptake of water by plant cells, suggested that the strongest evidence was provided by data showing the osmotic pressure of expressed sap to be generally less than the plasmolytically determined value. A more straightforward explanation of this discrepancy, however, is provided by the tendency for osmoregulation to occur during exposure to an osmoticum, either by solute transfer or by hydrolysis of cell polymers. In commenting on the water relations of Nitella, Dainty (1963) notes that although small differences in electrical potential across charged pores might theoretically lead to substantial turgor differences across the membranes concerned, such differences could not in fact be realized in Nitella as outward flow can occur through numerous uncharged pores. Similar reasons may rule out electroosmotic or other “active” contributions to turgor in higher plants, but at present too little is known about the properties of cell membranes for us to decide. 3. Other Forces of Metabolic Origin
So far we have considered only those forces that depend on cell turgor. We also need to ask whether forces might not arise from the propensity of growing tissues to accumulate, synthesize, or transform materials other than water. A sol + gel transformation, for example, is associated with cell division; before furrowing begins protoplasmic sols are converted to gels. Furrowing and cleavage are then brought about by the contraction of the gels, and energy used in building up the structure of the gel can be expended as work as the gel contracts and reverts to a sol (Landau et al., 1955). Forces that might be associated with the surface extension of the cell wall or cell membranes also need to be considered, whether or not they are adsorptive in origin as Bell (1961) suggests. Although such phenomena provide interesting examples of ways in
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
23
which metabolic energy may be expended as work, it has to be remembered that the rigidity of meristematic tissue is almost wholly dependent on cell turgor. When the tissue is turgid, the cell walls cannot themselves be load bearing, as they are stretched, not compressed, and wall pressure is directed centripetally. Only when turgor is fully mobilized against an external resistance, and when wall tension is removed, can the tendency for surface extension of the wall lead to the exertion of a force. By measuring the force exerted by root tips of broad bean growing at incipient plasmolysis, Pfeffer (1893) concluded that wall growth gave rise to forces about one-tenth as large as those produced by turgor. His experiment has not yet been repeated. One might expect that compression of thin, flexible cell walls would lead to buckling and bending of the wall, and changes of this kind have been described by Hottes (1929). Where cell walls have been strengthened, continued growth of the wall may well give rise to forces independent of those produced by turgor. Even so, the ability of thin-walled cells within an organ to withstand compression may continue to set a limit to the pressures developed during growth. In this connection it is worth noting that the pressures exerted by enlarging trunks of trees, in which many of the cells have strong walls, are comparable with those produced by delicate root tips (see Section IV, A ) .
4. Energy Expended on External Work We have considered contributions to plant forces that may be made by osmotic and “active” uptake of water, by cell division, and by wall growth. The forces observed arise most obviously from osmotically induced turgor. Whatever contributions may or may not be made by other processes, it is important to consider also the energy required for external work in relation to the total energy available to the plant. To give an example, a root of 1 mm. diameter, elongating at 1 mm. hr.-l against a resistance of 10 bar, performs external work at the rate of 0.2 erg sec.-l; whereas energy is released during respiration by the root tip at rates of the order of lo2 erg sec.-l. Work may also be performed in stretching the cell wall, but again this is small ( Frey-Wyssling, 1952). It is clear that the energy expended on mechanical work during growth is trivial compared with the output of respiratory energy, Because of this, it is sometimes inferred that mechanical resistance is not likely to be important. However, little is known about the efficiency with which the plant “engine” performs mechanical work. Moreover, even if sufficient energy is available, growth may be altogether prevented by a sufficient resistance, as there is a definite upper limit to the force that a plant organ can exert on its surroundings.
24
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
V.
Effects of Mechanical Stress on the Growth of Roots and Shoots
In Section I11 we saw that large pressures are often required to create channels in soils. For example, in loams of modest strength the pressure needed to lengthen a channel is of the order of 10 bar. Clearly, root tips or emerging shoots experience large stresses as they penetrate finely structured layers or peds of soil. Although the study of stress-stain relations in a particular organ may help us to interpret a growth response, we are much less concerned here with the strains produced in a given organ when a stress is first applied, than we are with the way in which growth proceeds after a stress has been applied. It may sometimes be overlooked that in studying underground shoots we are dealing with dark-grown or etiolated organs, and that conclusions reached with shoots growing in the light may not apply. Particular care needs to be taken in extrapolating from experiments with specialized shoots such as tendrils, that show marked growth responses both to contact stimuli and to tension ( Brush, 1912). as the external normal stress acting in In what follows we define the direction of the longitudinal axis of a plant organ, and a,, ay as the external normal stresses acting in the direction of the remaining Cartesian = uy we replace them by ur, the radial stress. Although we axes. When deal only with applied stresses we note that these are superposed on whatever stresses arise within the plant organ. The effects of mechanical stress on the processes of cell division, cell enlargement, and differentiation have rarely been separated in experiments, so that it is more expedient to classify the available data according to the nature of the applied stress. We begin by considering the influence on growth of a simple axial tension or pressure. A. STEADYSTRESS 1 . Uniaxial Stress ( # 0, = 0) When devising methods to push or pull a radially unconfined plant organ, it is simpler to use shoots than root tips; a shoot offers more points of attachment for an object transmitting a force; furthermore, many young shoots contain collenchyma and are less readily buckled or bent than are root tips. The influence of tension on stem growth has been studied intensively by physiologists for two distinct reasons. First, following claims by Pfeffer’s school at Leipzig, considerable interest was taken at the turn of the nineteenth century in the question of whether applied tension led ( T ~
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
25
to the regulatory development of woody tissues in stems. Unfortunately from our present point of view the work concerned was conducted entirely with stems grown in the light. Although good evidence was obtained showing that the tensile strength of certain stems increased when grown under tension (see, for example, Bordner, 1909) results were often contradictory, The literature on the topic has been reviewed by Schwarz (1930). Secondly, following proposals of Heyn (1931) that the rate of cell elongation was limited by the plasticity of the wall material, considerable attention was given to the behavior of cellulose fibers and samples of cell wall material under tension. For example, it has been shown that, above a certain yield stress, strips of Nitella cell wall creep at a rate that is roughly proportional to the applied stress (Probine and Preston, 1962). Obviously, these studies need to be supplemented by experiments with living shoots, but, as any applied stress disturbs the turgor relations and tissue stress initially present in a shoot, results are difficult to interpret. Recently, Lockhart et al. (1964) avoided this problem by working with sections of pea hypocotyl incubated in a slightly hypotonic solution, and found that the living sections underwent irreversible extension in response to tensions greater than 50 g.wt. ( u zz -2 bar). Such studies are of considerable interest in relation to growth processes, but they are of less interest in relation to emergence as the emerging shoot is subject to axial compression rather than tension. Before proceeding to examine the effects of compression, it is worth noting that roots are subject to simple tension in many plants, as part of the root proximal to the zone of elongation tends to shorten, sometimes to a considerable degree. For example, de Vries (1879) measured extenin the primary roots of red clover, TrifoEium prutense L., as sions (d/E) large as -0.25 over a period of several weeks. This process helps to anchor the plant to the ground, and young seedlings can sometimes be drawn further into the soil. The influence of a steady push, in the opposite sense to growth, on the elongation of etiolated shoots has been described by Sedgley and Barley (1963), who found that this slowed elongation. In their experiment, a load of 35 g.wt. ( uz = 0.5 bar) was applied to the top of the plumular hook of etiolated epicotyls of tick bean. The reduction in elongation rate that followed was due to a change in shape, epicotyls grown under axial compression being wider than controls. The rate of volumetric enlargement was unchanged. As the epicotyl of tick bean lacks an intercalary meristem, the growth response observed in this particular experiment cannot have been due to any change in cell division. In general it is known that, where internal controls are not overriding, as in poorly differentiated dividing tissues, the direction of cell
26
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. CREACEN
division can be influenced by an applied stress. For example, Kny (1896) showed that in the periderm of cut slices of tuber of the potato, SoZunum tuberosum L., the plane of cell division became oriented normal to an applied tension, and parallel to an applied pressure. Clearly, such changes could influence the form of growth, at least in simple tissues. 2. Plane Stress ( a1 = 0,
uX,u,
# 0)
The state of plane stress is found in nature when roots or rhizomes tend to enlarge radially against the resistance offered by a strong soil. Underground organs may also be compressed radially by the swelling action of wetting clay. In an isotropic soil the stresses uZ = uy can be replaced by the radial stress, ur. Roots sometimes grow through compact layers of soil when the soil is moist, but if the soil subsequently dries its increasing strength may prevent an increase in girth, Tabenhaus et al. (1931) described field situations where lengths of the taproot of cotton had been constricted in this way; and Taylor et al. (1963) showed that gross constrictions could lead to a reduced yield of tops. In earlier work Newcombe (1894) studied the influence of radial confinement on the development of stems of a number of species, and noted that halving the diameter of a short length of stem reduced transpiration at high but not at moderate rates of transpiration. A recent report suggests that translocation toward the tip of the root can be reduced by radial compression of proximal tissues. Barley (1965) found that, when a pressure of 1 bar was applied to a proximal length of corn radicle, the apical part gained weight less rapidly, even though it received a plentiful ambient supply of water and oxygen. The experiment also showed that, while the application of pressures > 3 bar damaged cells, radicles that had developed under pressure showed no signs of cell damage. Perhaps compression has little effect on translocation within tissues that have developed under stress. In general the response of a growing tissue to stress is likely to be much influenced by the rate at which the stress builds up, as this determines the degree to which the stress may be accommodated by changes in the pattern of growth.
3. Triaxial Stress ( 0 1 , (I=, U~ # 0) Root tips or underground shoots experience stress in each of the three principal directions when penetrating the soil. In an isotropic soil ox = q,, = ur, but, due to skin friction and shape factors (see Section 111, A, 3 ) , u1
>
UP
Using closely related techniques Gill and Miller (1956) and Barley
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
27
(1962, 1965) measured the effect of triaxial compression on root growth. Small corn seedlings were grown between a rigid plate and a flexible diaphragm, gas pressure being applied to the diaphragm to compress the seedlings. In the experiment of Gill and Miller the seedlings grew in a thin bed of 50 p. beads between an impermeable plate and the diaphragm. In Barley’s experiments beads were omitted and the seedlings were grown between a porous plate and a thin diaphragm. The stresses operating on the root were difficult to ascertain, particularly when beads were present. Without the beads the radial pressure, u ~ ,acting on the root only slightly exceeded the gas pressure on the thin diaphragm, but uZ exceeded u+.at the proximal end of the zone of elongation because of the force needed to overcome skin friction. Whether or not beads were present, the rate of root elongation decreased continuously as gas pressure on the diaphragm increased, until elongation almost ceased at gas pressures of 4 to 5 bar. The first increment of gas pressure reduced elongation more than later increments, but the large initial effect vanished when elongation was plotted against estimated values of V Z (Barley, 1962); elongation then decreased steadily almost ceasing at U Z = 7 bar. When the applied stress is not isotropic, the apparent growth response may be largely due to a change in shape. Data on cell shape obtained in one of the above experiments (Barley, 1965) at one pressure, u+.= 1 bar, show that the decrease in length of the cortical cells (-68 percent), compared with the control, accounted for most of the observed reduction in radicle elongation (-80 percent). Setting aside the change in shape, a genuine reduction in growth rate may well have been caused by the influence of compression on the internal aeration of the tissues (Section VI, B, 1 ) . Gessner (1961) points out that, as gas-filled intercellular spaces are always present in the tissues or higher plants, their compressibility is high. From the physiological point of view data on the effects of isotropic compression would be particularly informative. As meristematic cells do not fall below a certain size, the rate of cell division declines rapidly after an organ has been completeIy confined (Hallbauer, 1909). But this does not tell us what will happen when an organ enlarges against a steady ambient pressure. The ideal method of compressing an organ isotropically is to elevate the pressure of an ambient fluid. However, a clear distinction should be made between experiments with permeating and nonpermeating fluids. In particular, if a permeable plant organ is compressed by raising the pressure of an ambient aqueous solution, the original turgor, T,defined as the pressure difference between the intracellular liquid and the ambient solution, is restored when osmotic equilibrium is regained. This
28
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
is not the case when the organ is compressed by the reaction of the solid phase of the soil, as the pressure of the intercellular water remains in or near equilibrium with the pore water pressure, u, [see Eq. (9)]. Similarly, the intercellular air pressure is in equilibrium with the pore air pressure, u,. Thus, a nonpermeating fluid has to be used to produce compression of the kind experienced by organs growing through the soil. Although it may not be easy to ensure an adequate internal supply of water and air to the growing region, this approach appears to be promising for, say, short lengths of root or stem connected proximally to a supply of air and water at datum pressure. Surprisingly, no experiments of this kind have yet been reported. The peculiar response of the root cap to mechanical “wear” warrants special mention. Generally the peripheral cells of the cap are sheared off rather easily, being only loosely cohesive. When the root grows in resistant media, increased cell destruction at the periphery of the cap is accompanied by more rapid cell division at the base of the cap (Stalfelt, 1920). As the mean length of cells in the cap is reduced little if at all, the rate at which the cells elongate must also be increased so that cells are transferred more rapidly to the periphery. This response does not appear to have any counterpart in the main body of the root tip.
4. Bending Moments In coarsely structured soils less resistance is encountered by root tips than by probes, as the growing tip tends to bend when it meets an obstruction. Emerging shoots also avoid local obstructions in this way, but bending can reduce emergence if shoots encounter a strong, continuous crust. Root tips are bent by very small moments, but older parts of the root are often less flexible, The prop roots of corn, that brace the tops of the plant to the ground, are well adapted to resist bending; they contain two concentric rings of fibers, the outer subepidermal ring consisting of fibers with very thick walls (Haberlandt, 1914). Turgid etiolated stems can withstand small bending moments, but many are bent markedly when moments greater than 5 g.wt.cm. are applied suddenly. Generally, shoots are weakest in the region where elongation is proceeding most rapidly. When bending occurs, the degree of bending increases as turgor decreases ( see Fig. 5, Lockhart, 1959). If bending moments are increased gradually or applied intermittently over extended periods of time, shoots often become more resistant to bending. In the course of a classical paper on translocation in stems, Knight (1803) noted that frequent bending of the stem accelerated secondary thickening in the plane of bending. Rasdorsky (1925)
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
29
reviewed earlier work, and provided a number of examples of strengthening by changes in growth associated with bending, However, the effects on growth that he reports need not have been caused directly by mechanical stress, as changes in orientation with respect to gravity and light during bending could equally well have been responsible.
B. PERTURBATION OF STRESS In Section IV, C, 1 we noted that, after root tips or seedling shoots had been confined mechanically for a few days, elastic strain disappeared from the walls of cells in the meristem. The resulting loss of wall pressure, W, enabled the turgor, T , to act on the surroundings. Pfeffer (1893) attributed the loss of strain to continued surface extension of the cell wall during the period of confinement. He noted that, when a growing organ met an obstruction, the force exerted increased gradually over several days to reach a maximum. Because he believed that wall growth was an essential part of this process, he concluded that, if an organ suddenly encountered a resistance, no further elongation could occur until wall growth during an “induction period allowed the force to increase sufficiently to overcome the resistance. Lengthy induction periods observed by Pfeffer may, however, have been more apparent than real. In his experiments the plant organs, particularly roots, tended to widen within the thin gap that separated the fixed block from the movable block (Section IV, B). This would have led to a continuing increase in the force measured at large times, without there necessarily being any increase in the pressure applied by the organ. In fact turgor may be mobilized rather rapidly to act against an external resistance. When a root or shoot meets an obstruction, as soon as wall growth or relaxation permits a directed force to act externally, stresses arise within the organ that tend to distort its cells. It is known that even small shearing stresses can considerably distort young growing organs over periods of the order of minutes (Sedgley and Barley, 1963). The change in shape greatly magnifies the initial effect of growth or relaxation on wall pressure, W. In this manner elongating root tips or underground shoots are accommodated to the short-term perturbations in stress that they experience when they grow through mechanically heterogeneous soils. In experiments stress may be perturbed suddenly by applying a force. A single or small number of stress cycles may have little effect, but much depends on the duration and intensity of the stress. Providing the tissues have not been damaged by excessive stress, roots or shoots that have been subjected to compression for several hours elongate mole rapidly when the stress is removed. Acceleration continues until they regain the
30
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
rate that prevailed before compression (Pfeffer, 1893). If a main root is grown under compression for more than a few hours, on release of the pressure a cluster of laterals develops from that part of the main root which grew during the period of compression. If the stress is maintained for several days, the main apex may fail to regain its initial, unstressed rate of growth, possibly because of the diversion of translocated material to the numerous laterals (Barley, 1962). It has long been known that repeated cycles of stress produce tropic responses in a wide variety of etiolated shoots, even when the stress is small. For example, Stark (1917) showed that lightly rubbing one side of the etiolated stem of seedlings of certain dicotyledons and grasses caused the stem to bend during growth toward the rubbed side. In 1941, Bunning claimed that etiolation could be inhibited equally well by light or by perturbation of stress. In Bunning's experiment epicotyls of Phaseolus multiflurous Willd., were bent at lbminute intervals in the dark. It would be interesting to know whether a response would have been obtained, as in Stark's work, without any change in orientation. It is curious to find high sensitivity to small perturbations of stress in what are normally subterranean organs. Possibly continuous local perturbation of the stress, of the kind experienced when a shoot grows through a heterogeneons soil, causes the organ to lose its sensitivity. In this connection it is interesting to note that repeated perturbation of stress reduces the degree of seismonasty shown by Mimosa, and that, with continuous shaking, for example, the leaves may regain their original position ( Stiles, 1950). VI.
Growth in the Soil
A. GROWTHIN MEDIAOF KNOWN MECHANICAL PROPERTIES A copious literature describing the adverse effects of excessive soil compaction on plant growth has been reviewed recently by Rosenberg ( 1964). Many of the experiments described by Rosenberg merely demonstrate empirical relations between bulk density and growth, and cannot explain why growth is affected. Here it will be more profitable to consider the relatively few experiments in which the design makes it possible to evaluate the role of mechanical factors. 1. Homogeneous Media a. Rigid matrix. In field soils hardpans are sometimes found that behave essentially as materials having a rigid matrix (Lutz, 1952). The soil in such pans has a high strength, and the matrix is subject only to elastic strain. Because of the concentration of stress at contacts between
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
31
grains ( McMurdie and Day, 1958), the elastic strain is not negligible. Nevertheless, root growth does not seem to occur in such media, other than in continuous pores commensurate in width with the normal, unstressed root tip. Wiersum (1957) found, for example, that the roots of tomatoes having tips of 0.3 mm. diameter grew through sintered glass disks in which the diameter of the pores ranged from 0.20 to 0.50 mm., but they were unable to penetrate disks in which the range was 0.15 to 0.20 mm. b. Deformable matrix. Little attempt has been made to utilize the relatively simple properties of purely cohesive media in experiments with growing plants. Taylor and Gardner (1960) and Gardner and Danielson (1964) measured the penetration of roots into cohesive waxes of different hardness; these workers used the waxes simply as convenient materials with which to rank the penetrating ability of plant roots that had been subject to various treatments or grown in various soils ( Section VI, B, 1 ) . Although saturated clays are often treated as purely cohesive ($I = 0 ) media in the classical theory of consolidation and bearing capacity (Terzaghi, 1943), it is not profitable to regard them as such when dealing with deformations by plants. The reasons for this have been described in Section 111; here we need only remind the reader that effective normal stresses are in general not negligible around growing plant organs even in saturated, impermeable clays. As described in Section 11, seedlings often emerge from cohesive soils by rupturing and lifting slabs of the overlying soil. When this kind of deformation occurs, it is appropriate to relate emergence to the breaking forces, obtained from the dimensions of the slab and the modulus of rupture of the soil. Relations of this kind were measured by Richards (1953) and by Allison (1956), but their data are of little value as the strength tests were conducted on slabs reconstituted in the laboratory from fine earth and dried at 50°C., rather than on the crusts through which the seedlings actually emerged. Moduli of rupture pertaining to the moist crusts through which seedlings emerged were measured by Hanks and Thorp (1956, 1957). But it is doubtful whether this measure was appropriate in their experiment; emergence was not reduced by increasing the thickness of the crust, as would have been expected if tensile failure were the means of emergence. Rather, the shoots may have penetrated the crust by causing continuous, local failure. On the other hand, Parker and Taylor (1965) related the emergence of guar, Cyamopsis tetragorwloba ( L . ) Taub., to indentation test data, even though the seedlings emerged in their experiment by rupturing a crust. Clearly, the kind of deformation involved should be ascertained
32
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
before mechanical criteria are chosen, Careful interpretation is needed, particularly when one kind of deformation tends to pass into another with time or distance. For example, radial thickening of the proximal parts of the root sometimes ruptures peds or layers of soil. When this happens the failure may be propagated ahead of the root apex, so that the point stress, qp, falls to a small value. The initial penetration of the soil by the root always involves shear failure, but, in the later stages, penetration may result from tensile failure of the soil. So far we have been dealing with growth in soils where compression is unimportant, We now turn to the more general situation, where growth is accompanied by local shear failure and compression of the soil. Working with compressible moist clays and with gelatin, Pfeffer (1893) related mechanical resistance, q, to the growth of radicles. He measured q with steel probes having relieved tips. The tips were similar in size and shape to those of the broad bean and corn radicles used in his experiment. Initially each radicle was placed in a 2-cm. deep channel, SO that the resistance encountered by the growing tip would be constant during the experiment. In separate tests the channel was formed adjacent to a glass plate so that the radicle could be observed at intervals during elongation. When bean radicles were placed in a clay, for which the value of q measured with the probe was 4 bar, the roots did not elongate for the first 4 hours. After this delay elongation proceeded at a rate 20 percent below that attained in water or in a slurry of clay in water. Similar results were obtained with corn radicles. When bean radicles were grown in a firm gelatin ( q = 1.0 bar) elongation proceeded with little or no delay at a rate equal to that attained in water or in a gelatin sol. Pfeffer also reported that roots would not elongate in clays when q exceeded 12 bar, However he did not provide any experimental data for such strong clays, and it seems likely that he merely inferred this value of q from his knowledge of the maximum plant pressures measured in his plaster-block experiments. As the clays used in Pfeffer’s work were quite moist, gaseous diffusion through the clay would have been very slow. In commenting on this, Pfeffer suggested that sufficient oxygen would be obtained by diffusion through the intercellular air space, providing the radicles were not more than a few centimeters long. To support this argument he quoted his observation that bean radicles grew equally well and at moderate rates (0.8 mm.hr.-l) for at least 48 hours in either de-aired or aerated water. Unfortunately Pfeffer did not measure the pore water pressure, u.,,,, in his clays. In the stronger samples uw may have been large and negative, leading to loss of turgor in the radicles (Section VI, B, 1). Except at high void ratios a hard-grained soil is difficult to compress
MECHANICAL
RESISTANCE OF SOIL
33
with an isotropic pressure; nevertheless it can be compressed rather easily when the applied stress has a large shear component. In such a soil y is related directly to the applied pressure, p , or more generally, taking account of pore water pressure, to the effective pressure, p’. Barley (1963) made use of these properties to separate strength from variables that depend upon the porosity of the medium. In his experiment a moistened pack of 10 to 70 p Ballotini beads was housed within a modified triaxial test cell. The level of p’ in the medium could then be controlled by regulating the ambient pressure, p, applied to the pack. AS isotropic compression was negligible ( c v = -0.002) over the range of pressures applied ( 0 to 1 bar), volumetric air and water contents of the bulk of the medium were not affected by the change of pressure. Corn radicles were allowed to grow through inlets; they penetrated the medium readily, when strength permitted, by producing local shear failure. The rate of elongation decreased from 1.6 to 1.1mm.hr.-l as p‘ increased from 0.08 to 0.28 bar; the radicles were prevented from elongating at p‘ = 0.58 bar. At this value of p’ the resistance offered to a cylindrical steel probe corresponded to y = 22 bar. This is about twice as great a pressure as the radicles are thought to be able to exert (see Table 11). Among a number of reasons that could account for this large discrepancy (Section 111, B, 2), differences in shape between the root tips and the probe may be important. The problem of relating probe data to the resistance offered to a root tip is increased, as shown in the above experiment, by the dependence of the shape and size of the tip upon the strength of the medium through which the root grows (see Fig. 7 ) . Recently, three related sets of experiments have been conducted with ordinary, unsaturated soils. Phillips and Kirkham ( 1962a) studied the influence of mechanical resistance on the growth of corn radicles in an unsaturated clay; Taylor and Gardner (1963) and Taylor et al., (1966) studied both root growth and seedling emergence for a range of plant species and soil types; Barley et al. (1965) studied the root growth of two contrasting species in a loam. The experiments will be discussed further in Section VI, B, 2, where factor interactions are considered. Here we are concerned with the methods used to characterize the resistance, q, and with the values of y at which elongation growth ceased. In the last of the investigations mentioned above point pressure, qp,and skin friction, yf, were measured independently, and theoretical values of qp were calculated after data had been obtained for the relevant soil parameters. Table I11 lists the methods used in the experiments, together with the limiting values of y. The latter have been recalculated from the original data where necessary, and expressed uniformly as resistance per unit cross section, y, to the penetration of a deep ( z > 3 d ) steel probe. The
The effect of mechanical resistance on the form of the elongating root tip of corn, Zea mays
L. The roots were
TABLE I11
5
Values of Probe Pressure (9) a t Which Growth Ceased in Several Soil-Plant Systems
(g.cc.-')
Pore water pressure (bar)
0.9-1.3 1.55-1.85
( X -1) 0.01-0.1 0,2-0.7
1.5-1.7
0.3-0.7
N.D.
0.3-0.5
Bulk densitya Experiment
Plant organ
Phillips and Kirkham (1962a) Taylor and Gardner (1963)
Corn radicles Cotton radicles
Barley et ul. (1965)
Pea and wheat radicles Grass shoots
Taylor et al. (1966) 5
Soil texture Clay Fine sandy loam Loam Sandy loams
Void ratio not calculated as absolute density is not reported.
Measure of resistance
Limiting p (bar)
Constant load probe Constant depth probe
8 34
Strength parameters, constant rate probe Constant depth probe
36 15-24
@zi; $
Ht: e
18 vl
8
w vl
36
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
wide variation found in the limiting values of q is not surprising. The low values of q obtained by Phillips and Kirkham may arise for two reasons: First, the samples of clay that roots failed to penetrate were nearly saturated, and may have behaved as low 4 materials in tests with impermeable probes, Secondly, instead of allowing developed radicles to penetrate the soil, as in the other investigations, Phillips and Kirkham germinated the seeds within the body of cores of consolidated clay. If pIant forces are osmotic in origin, then as x rarely exceeds 10 bar in roots, the roots that grew through the stronger loams cannot have had to overcome resistances as large as those opposed to the probes (see Table 111).As we have seen in Section 111, there are a number of reasons why root tips may meet less resistance than probes in unsaturated loams. Briefly, the root may penetrate the soil by cylindrical rather than spherical compression; qf is likely to be less for root tips than for steel probes; also, the propagation of cracks produced by thickening of the proximal part of the root may reduce resistance to penetration. It is even more difficult to relate the resistance encountered by shoots to the limiting values of q measured by Taylor et al. As mentioned previously, more relevant data could have been obtained if the authors had used upward rather than downward acting probes. Apart from this, qf may be underestimated in shallow tests or in deep tests where probes with relieved tips are used, since the zone of maximum elongation often lies some distance behind the apex of the shoot. 2. Heterogeneous Media Lack of anchorage or support in loose layers of the soil may hinder roots or shoots from penetrating stronger layers or crusts. If seed is planted in loose soil, and the seedling shoot meets a superficial crust, the shoot may push the seed deeper rather than emerge (Carnes, 1934). Also, the shoot is more likely to be bent in a loose soil because of the lack of radial support. Similarly, in a study of the ability of corn radicles to penetrate a layer of hard wax, Taylor and Gardner (1960) found that more radicles penetrated when grown in lightly compacted soil than when grown in loose crumbs. In a subsequent paper Gardner and Danielson (1964) reported that compacting the soil above a wax layer failed to improve the penetration of roots into the wax. This result appears to be inconsistent with that obtained in 1960; but in the 1964 experiment the hard wax was separated from the soil with a layer of soft wax, and anchorage may have been obtained in the soft wax rather than in the soil. Although mechanical resistance was not measured, morphological evidence suggests that this may have been the controlling factor in an experiment conducted by Schuurman ( 1965). His observations of the
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
37
growth of oat roots across the boundary between layers of a humic sand showed that roots penetrated a highly compacted layer more readily when this was overlain by a moderately compact rather than by loose sand. The main roots grown in loose sand branched profusely just above the boundary with a highly compacted sand. Laterals penetrating the highly compacted layer were short, thickened, and distorted. Little attention has yet been given to the possible role of mechanical factors in controlling the entry of roots into discrete peds. A recent study of the distribution of corn roots in a silty clay loam B horizon (Edwards et al., 1964) revealed that, although the main roots were restricted to the voids between the peds, laterals penetrated about one-half of the total number of discrete peds. The peds entered by the laterals were, on the average, less dense than those which the laterals failed to penetrate; but the factors limiting entry were not determined, The shape and orientation of a ped in the soil may have a large influence on root entry, insofar as these factors influence the angle at which the geotropic root tip approaches the surface of the ped. The chance of entry is known to be reduced when the angle at which the root tip approaches a slab of hard wax becomes more acute (Gardner and Danielson, 1964). Ped size may also be important, since small peds are more easily ruptured by internal pressure. OF MECHANICAL RESISTANCE, WATERSUPPLY, B. THE INTERACTION AND AERATION
1. The Nature of the Interaction The growth of roots and underground shoots at a given temperature is influenced strongly by the physical factors: mechanical resistance, water supply, and aeration. These factors interact for two kinds of reasons. First, as shown in Section 111, C, the factors themselves are interdependent; secondly, the response of the plant to a change in one factor may modify its response to another. Two examples will serve to show the importance of this second kind of interaction. As a soil dries uw decreases, and the plant exhibits a loss of turgor. This is true even when transpiration is slow, as the plant and soil water are then in or close to osmotic equilibrium. If the forces exerted by plants arise almost entirely from osmotic turgor, as suggested in Section IV, C, the ability of an organ to exert force should decline as uw decreases. Also, the rigidity of the root decreases as turgor is lost. Gardner and Danielson (1964) show that the penetrating ability of plant roots is indeed reduced for physiological reasons when u, decreases. In their experiment cotton roots were grown through a loose soil to meet a hard
38
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
layer of wax. The percentage of roots that penetrated the wax decreased continuously at u, < -0.5 bar. No penetration occurred with U, < -11 bar, Over this range of pore water pressures the water content of the root decreased from 1200 to 600 percent, implying a considerable loss of turgor. The authors did not determine whether the roots failed to penetrate because they exerted less force or because they were more easily bent. If the roots had met a firm soil rather than a wax, the effect of u, on the resistance offered by the soil would have operated also. The interplay of mechanical stress and oxygen supply provides a second example of soil factor interaction mediated by plant response. In their pressure cell experiments (Section V, A, 3), Gill and Miller ( 1956) and Barley (1962) found that a smaller confining pressure prevented the elongation of corn radicles when the ambient concentration of oxygen was reduced below 5 percent. Data on root weight increase, Aw, obtained in the latter experiment show that neither a small increase in confining pressure ( 0.0 to 0.5 bar) nor a reduction in oxygen concentration (20 to 5 percent) reduced A w when acting singly, but, when the variabIes acted together, A w was halved. The simplest explanation of this interaction is provided by the effect that mechanical stress had on the shape assumed by the radicles, the volume per unit length being twice as great when the radicles grew under compression. This increase in bulk, taken together with compression of the intercellular spaces, would have increased the ambient concentration of oxygen needed to maintain a diffusive supply of oxygen to cells in the interior of the root. Changes in shape similar to those described above occur when roots grow in firm media (Fig. 7 ) ; moreover, high mechanical resistance is frequently associated with compaction and poor aeration. In a study of the penetration of compacted soils by cotton roots, Tackett and Pearson (1964) found that at a bulk density of 1.3 g.cc.-l roots elongated at a high and constant rate when the oxygen concentration remained greater than 5 percent, but at a density of 1.5 g.cc.-l the threshold concentration of oxygen rose to 10 percent. Morphological observations suggested that mechanical resistance was likely to have been the other factor involved. 2. Correlation of Growth with Mechanical Resistance
Although the simple correlation of mechanical properties of the soil and plant growth may be useful in diagnosing physically adverse soil conditions ( Culpin, 1936), correlation does not identify the particular factors controlling growth. Fortunately, it is often possible to detect mechanical effects by visual observation, as when shoots are seen to be bent beneath a superficial crust. Further examples of gross morphological symptoms are given by TayIor and Burnett ( 1964).
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE 'OF SOIL
39
Circumstantial evidence that mechanical resistance may be limiting is sometimes presented by showing that other physical factors are unlikely to be limiting. Having found a simple correlation ( r = 0.6 - 0.7) between probe resistance and corn yield in a field experiment on soil compaction, Phillips and Kirkham (1962b) proceeded to show that the soil temperature and the oxygen content of bulk samples of the soil air were similar at the various levels of compaction. Also, they noted that the soils were kept moist by sprinkling during the growing period. But arguments of this kind are often too tendentious to lead to any satisfying conclusion. While it is possible to design experiments in which other than mechanical factors are nonlimiting, this may limit the range of values explored, as the soil properties, e and uw,that govern air and water supply also determine the level of mechanical resistance. A nonlimiting supply of water can be assured by working at small pore water and osmotic pressures, and by keeping the shoots in a humid atmosphere so that transpiration is minimized. Paul (1965) found, for example, that when wheat seedlings were covered with Mylar film to minimize transpiration, the rate at which the roots elongated in a sand remained constant at volumetric water contents ranging from 4 to 17 percent, corresponding to uw = -0.25 to -0.03 bar. It is more difficult to ensure a nonlimiting supply of oxygen, particularly when mechanical properties are varied by compaction. Various workers have employed either forced aeration (Smith and Cook, 1946), a source of oxygen within the soil (Scott and Erickson, 1964), or elevated ambient concentrations of oxygen (Rickman et al., 1966). The effectiveness of such methods is best assessed by sampling and analyzing the gas permeating the interior of the soil under test (Tackett and Pearson, 1964). Although data on mechanical properties were not obtained in these several investigations, the results show clearly that aeration is not the only factor involved in reducing root growth in compact soils. Generally we wish to examine soil-plant systems in states where each of the physical factors capable of influencing growth may vary over a wide range. If we aim to determine the relative importance of the different factors it becomes necessary to design experiGents to separate the variables. To do this Phillips and Kirkham (1962a) took advantage of the known relations between mechanical resistance, q, pore water pressure, uw,void ratio, e, and air void ratio, e,. When uw is varied at a constant e, q and e, change in the same sense; but when e is varied at a constant uw, q and e, change in the opposite sense. It is true that the capillary conductivity, k, changes in the opposite sense to q when either uw or e is varied. However even wide changes in k may have little influence on growth if the rate of transpiration is minimized (Paul, 1965). Also, by
40
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
employing a soil with a high friction angle, it is not necessary to use large negative values of u, or to vary ufowidely to obtain a useful range of q. The system studied by Phillips and Kirkham is described in Table I11 together with systems studied by later investigators in experiments of similar design. Although data obtained in experiments of the kind described in Table I11 lend themselves to covariance analysis, this was utilized only in one of the investigations (Barley et al., 1965). The partial correlation coefficients were significant for root length, L, and resistance, q, but not for L and e, or for L and the gaseous diffusivity parameter ( e,/e)4 proposed by Currie (1961). Though given only in graphical form, the data of Taylor and Gardner (1963) show clearly that most of the variation in the number of roots penetrating a sandy loam over a range of e and u, values was associated with the variation in q. Taken together with morphological observations, the correlative data obtained in the experiments described in Table I11 provide unmistakable evidence that mechanical resistance can exert a considerable influence on root growth and seedling emergence in finely structured soils at field densities and water contents. VII.
Conclusion
In the past the role of mechanical resistance has been relatively neglected in agronomic studies, probably because of the academic separation of “soil mechanics” in schools of engineering from “soil physics” in schools of agriculture. When applied to agronomy, engineering theories of soil mechanics need to be modified to place more emphasis on the compressibility of the soil, and to be combined with a knowledge of the mechanics of plant growth. The evidence presented in this review suggests that mechanical resistance should be regarded as having a widespread influence on the growth of roots and underground shoots, rather than as a factor that operates only in unusually strong soils. REFERENCES Allison, L. E. 1956. Soil Sci. SOC. Am. Proc. 20, 147-151. Amdt, W. 1965. Australian J . Soil Res. 3, 45-54. Balla, A. 1961. Proc. 5th Intern. Conf. Soil Mech. Found. Eng. 2, 569-576. Barley, K. P. 1954. Soil Sci. 78,205-210. Barley, K. P. 1962. J . Exptl. Botany 13,95-110. Barley, K. P. 1963. Soil Sci. 96, 175-180. Barley, K. P. 1965. Australian J . Biol. Sci. 18, 499-503. Barley, K. P., and Stolzy, L. M. 1966. Australian Soil Sci. Conf. Hbk. Paper 7-1. Barley, K. P., Farrell, D. A., and Greacen, E. L. 1965. Australian J. Soil Res. 3, 6979. Bell, G . G. E. 1961. J . Theoret. Biol. 1, 104-106.
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
41
Bennett, 0. L., Ashley, D. A., and Doss, B. D. 1964. Agron. J. !%,162-165. Bennett-Clark, T. A. 1959. In “Plant Physiology” (F. C. Stewart, ed.), Vol. 11, pp. 105-191. Academic Press, New York. Bishop, A. W. 1960. “Pore Pressure and Suction in Soils,” pp. 3 U 6 . Butterworth, London. Bishop, A. W., and Henkel, D. J. 1962. “The Measurement of Soil Properties in the Triaxial Test.” Arnold, London. Bishop, R. F., Hill, R., and Mott, N. F. 1945. Proc. Phys. Soc. (London) 57, 147-159. Bordner, J. S. 1909. Botan. Gaz. 48,251-274. Brush, W. D. 1912. Botan. Gaz. 53,453-477. Bunning, E. 1941. Ber. Deut. Botan. Ges. 41, 2-9. Carlson, L. 1948. Proc. 2nd Intern. Conf. Soil Mech. Found. Eng. 1, 265-270. Carnes, A. 1934. Agr. Eng. 15, 167-171. Childs, E. C. 1955. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (India) %A, 86-92. Croney, D., and Coleman, J. D. 1954. J. Soil Sci. 5, 75-84. Culpin, C. 1936. J . Agr. Sci. 26, 22-34. Currie, J. A. 1961. Brit. J. Appl. Phys. 12, 275-281. Dainty, J. 1963. Aduan. Bot. Res. 1, 279424. de Jong, G., and Geertsma, J. 1953. Ingenieur 65,5pp. de Vries, H. 1879. Botan. Zh. 37, 648-654. de Vries, H. 1884. Jahrb. Wiss. Botan. 14, 427-601. Edwards, W. M., Fehrenbacker, J. B., and Vavra, J. P. 1964. Soil Sci. SOC. Am. Proc. 28, 560-564. Eide, O., Hutchinson, J. N., and Landva, A. 1961. Proc. 5th Intern. Conf. Soil Mech. Found. Eng. 2 , 4 5 5 3 . Evans, I., and Sherratt, G. G. 1948. J. Sci. Instr. 25, 411-414. Farrell, D. A., and Greacen, E. L. 1966. Australian J. Soil Res. 4, 1-17. Farrell, D. A., Greacen, E. L., and Larson, W. E. 1967. Soil Sci. SOC. Am. Proc. (in press ) . Fountaine, E. R., and Brown, N. J. 1959. J. Agr. Eng. Res. 4, 5359. Frey-Wyssling, A. 1952. In “Deformation and Flow in Biological Systems” (A. FreyWyssling, ed. ), pp. 194-254. North-Holland Publ., Amsterdam. Gardner, H. R., and Danielson, R. E. 1964. Soil Sci. SOC. Am. Proc. 28, 457-461. Gardner, W. R. 1960. Soil Sci. 89, 63-73. Gessner, F. 1961. In “Encyclopaedia of Plant Physiology” (W. Ruhland, ed.), Vol. 16, pp. 66&-680.Springer, Berlin. Gill, W. R., and Miller, R. D. 1956. Soil Sci. SOC. Am. Proc. 20, 154-157. Greacen, E. L. 1960. J. Soil Sci. 11, 313-333. Griffith, A. A. 1924. Proc. 1 s t Intern. Congr. Appl. Math. pp. 55-63. Haberlandt, G. 1914. “Physiological Plant Anatomy” (Transl., M. Drummond ), Macmillan, London. Hallbauer, W. 1909. Dissertation. Leipzig. (Reviewed by 0. Damm. 1911. Botan. Cents. 116, 201.) Hanks, R. J., and Thorp, F. C. 1956. Soil. Sci. Soc. Am. Proc. 20, 307410. Hanks, R. J., and Thorp, F. C. 1957. Soil Sci. SOC.Am. Proc. 21, 357359. Hermans, J. J. 1949. In “Colloid Science” (H. R. Kruyt, ed. ), Vol. 2, p. 86. Elsevier, London. Heyn, A. N. J. 1931. Records Trav. Botan. N e e d 28, 113. Hottes, C. F. 1929. Plant Physiol. 4, 1-29. Hvorslev, M. J. 1937. Ingenioeruidenskab. Skrifter A&, 1-159. Kirkham, D., De Boodt, M. F., and De Leenheer, L. 1959. Soil Sci. 87, 141-144.
42
K. P. BARLEY AND E. L. GREACEN
Knight, T. A. 1803. Phil. Trans. Roy. SOC. London B2, 277-289. Kny, L. 1896. Ber. Deut. Botan. Ges. 14,378391. Krabbe, G. 1884. “tiber das Wachstum des Verdickungsringes und der Holzzellen in seiner Abhangigkeit von Driickwirkungen.” Reiner, Berlin. Ladanyi, B. 1963. J. Soil Mech. Found. Diu. Am. SOC. Ciu. Engrs. 89, 127-161. Landau, J. V., Marsland, D., and Zimmerman, A. M. 1955. J. Cellular Comp. Physiol. 45, 309-330. Leonhardt, W. 1915. Jahbr. Wiss. Botan. 55, 91-176. Lockhart, J. A. 1959. Am. 1. Botany 46,704-708. Lockhart, J . A., Bretz, C., and White, H. 1964. Plant Physiol. Suppl. 39, p. 5. Lutz, J. F. 1952. In “Soil Physical Conditions and Plant Growth” (B. T. Shaw, ed.), pp. 43-71. Academic Press, New York. McMurdie, J. L., and Day, P. R. 1958. Soil Sci. SOC. Am. PTOC.22, 18-21. Meyerhof, C. G. 1951. Geotechnique 2, 301-332. Meyerhof, C. G. 1961. PTOC.5th Intern. Conf. Soil Mech. Found. Eng. 2, 105-109. Morton, C. T., and Buchele, W. F. 1960. Agr. Eng. 41, 428-431, 453455. Muller, N. J. C. 1872. Botan. Untersuch. 1, 53. Newcombe, F.C. 1894. Ann. Botany 8,403-421. Nishida, Y. 1961. PTOC. 5th Intern. Conf. Soil. Mech. Found. Eng. 2, 123-129. Ordin, L., Applewhite, J. J., and Bonner, J. 1956. Plant Physiol. 31,44-53. Parker, J. J., and Taylor, H. M. 1965. Agron. J. 57, 289-291. Paul, J. L. 1965. Agrochimica 9,368-370. Payne, P. C. J., and Fountaine, E. R. 1952. J. Soil. Sci. 3, 136-144. Pfeffer, W. 1893. AbhandZ. Saechs. Akad. Wiss. Leipzig Math.-Naturw. Kl. 20, 233474, Phillips, R. E., and Kirkham, D. 1962a. Soil Sci. SOC. A m . PTOC.26, 319-322. Phillips, R. E., and Kirkham, D. 196213. Agron. 1. 54,29-33. Probine, M. C., and Preston, R. D. 1962. J. Exptl. Botany 13, 111-127. Rasdorsky, W. 1925. Ber. Deut. Botan. Ges. 43,332-352. Richards, L. A. 1953. Soil Sci. SOC. Am. PTOC.17,321-323. Rickman, R. W., Letey, J., and Stolzy, L. H. 1966. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. PTOC.30, 304307. Rogowski, A. S. 1964. Ph.D. Thesis. Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa. Rosenberg, N. J. 1964. Adwan. Agron. 16, 181-196. Rosene, H.F. 1937. Plant Physiol. 12, 1-19. Schuurman, J. J. 1965. Plant Soil 22, 352-374. Schwarz, W. 1930. Beih. Botan. Zentr. 46,306-338. Schwendener, S. 1874. “Das Mechanische Prinzip anatomischen im Bau der Monocotylen.” Engelmann, Leipzig. Scott, R. F. 1963. “Principles of Soil Mechanics.” Addison-Wesley, Reading, Massachusetts. Scott, T. W., and Erickson, A. E. 1964. Agron. J. 56, 575-576. Sedgley, R. H., and Barley, K. P. 1963. Austrakan J. Biol. Sci. 16, 19-27. Skempton, A. W. 1960. “Pore Pressure and Suction in Soils,” pp. 86-91. Butterworth, London. Smith, F. W., and Cook, R. L. 1946. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. PTOC.11, 402-406. Sijhne, W. H. 1958. Agr. Eng. 39,276-281. Stalfelt, M. G. 1920. Arkiu. Botan. 16,49-88. Stark, P. 1917. Jahrb. Wiss. Botan. 57, 189-320.
MECHANICAL RESISTANCE OF SOIL
43
Stiles, W. 1950. “An Introduction to the Principles of Plant Physiology,” 2nd ed., Methuen, London. Tabenhaus, J. J., Ezekiel, W. N., and Rea, H. E. 1931. Plant Physiol. 6, 161-166. Tackett, J. L., and Pearson, R. W. 1964. Soil Sci. SOC. Am. Proc. 28, 600-605. Taylor, H. hl., and Burnett, E. 1964. Soil Sci. 98, 174-180. Taylor, H. M., Eurnett, E., and Welch, A. H. 1963. Agron. J. 55, 143-144. Taylor, H. M., and Gardner, H. R. 1960. Soil Sci. SOC. Am. Proc. 24, 79-81. Taylor, H. M., and Gardner, H. R. 1963. Soil Sci. 96, 153-156. Taylor, H. M., Parker, J. J., Roberson, G. M. 1966. Agron. J. 58, 393-395. Terzaghi, K. 1923. Sber. Akad. W i s s . W i e n . Abt. IIa, 132, 105-124. Terzaghi, K. 1943. “Theoretical Soil Mechanics.” Wiley, New York. Terzaghi, K., and Peck, R. B. 1948. “Soil Mechanics in Engineering Practice.” Wiley, New York. Timoshenko, S., and Goodier, J. N. 1951. “Theory of Elasticity.” McGraw-Hill, New York. Ursprung, A. 1923. Ber. Deut. Botan. Ges. 41, 338-343. Vanden Berg, G. E., Buchele, W. F., and Malvern, L. E. 1958. Trans. Am. SOC. Agr. Engrs. 1, 24-27. Veihmeyer, F. J., and Hendrickson, A. H. 1948. Soil Sci. 65, 487493. Wiersum, L. K. 1957, Plant Soil 9, 75-85. Williams, W. A. 1956. Agron. 1.48, 273-274.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING R. H. Hageman, E. R. Leng, and J. W. Dudley University d Illinois, Urbona, Illinois
Page I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Heterosis and the Gene-Enzyme Concept . . . . . . . 111. Heterosis and Enzyme Activity during Germination . . . . . IV. Genetic Control of the Initial Reaction of Nitrogen Metabolism . V. Specific Chloroplast Activity . . . . . . . . . VI. Some Recent Developments in Plant Biochemistry Related to Heterosis VII. A Concept for the Future . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
I.
45 46
54 63 72
74 80 83
Introduction
Fundamental problems in analyzing the genetic control of heterosis and its effective manipulation in plant breeding programs are: 1. How do genes produce effects on growth and metabolic processes? 2. What genetic mechanisms are involved in heterosis? 3. How can plant breeders select or combine genotypes most efficiently to obtain maximum heterosis in yield and other desired characters? Obviously, none of these questions has a satisfactory answer at present. A major purpose of this paper is to discuss biochemical aspects bearing on each of these questions, with specific reference to heterosis in growth and yield of corn (Zea mays L . ) . Particular emphasis will be laid on recent research on genetic control of major metabolic processes, especially of certain important enzyme systems. Throughout this paper, a basic concept will be stressed-namely, that growth and grain yield are the end results of a series of biochemical reactions, each of which is controlled or catalyzed by one or more specific enzymes. Attention will then be focused on the likely role of major metabolic enzymes and enzyme systems in the production of heterotic effects, and on possible utilization of such information in future plant breeding programs. In discussing these concepts-admittedly on the basis of insufficient present evidence-the authors would stress the importance of basic metabolic proceses involved in: 45
46
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
1. Gene replication, 2. Gene-enzyme “information transfer.” 3. Energy transfers, particularly in early stages of plant growth. 4. Protein synthesis. 5. Photosynthetic activity. A major purpose of this paper is to stimulate other workers, particularly those concerned with economic plant species, to attack fundamental problems of growth and development on an integrated biochemical, genetic, and developmental morphological basis. Most of these problems are as yet nearly unexplored. Important as it is, specific “biochemical breeding” for altered amino acid, fatty acid, vitamin, protein, starch, or oil content does not bear directly on the fundamental question of agronomic heterosis. Therefore, the authors have omitted reference to such work, knowing that some oi“ these areas have recently been the subject of symposia and that the remaining areas will be given due emphasis in reviews at another time. II.
Heterosis and the Gene-Enzyme Concept
Hybrid vigor, or the favorable phenotypic expression of heterosis, is the basis of the present multibillion dollar corn industry. The initial recognition and development of the general nature of inbreeding depression and heterosis, which forms the foundation of this industry, are well documented ( Gowen, 1952; Kiesselbach, 1951) . With respect to corn, it is evident that in the period 1890 to 1912 several workers observed that inbreeding led to the loss of vigor. In due time, the cause was ascribed to the homozygosity of the genetic complement. It was further noted that when homozygous lines of corn were crossed, the progeny exhibited increased size, height, and yield, i.e., hybrid vigor. A simple genetic explanation of hybrid vigor still has not been provided. Shull (1914) introduced the term “heterosis” as a substitute for the phrase “stimulus of heterozygosity.” Shull (1914) and others (East and Hayes, 1912) believed that the heterozygous condition inherently provided the stimulation which led to increased vigor in the hybrid. This concept was later restated as “overdominance” by Hull (1952). The more generally accepted explanation of heterosis is expressed as the “interaction of dominant favorable genes” ( Whaley, 1944). This concept had its origin in the writings of Davenport (1908), Bruce (1910), and Keeble and Pellew ( 1910) and has been extensively discussed in previous reviews ( Whaley, 1944; Gowen, 1952; Stringfield, 1964). Although Jones (1918) suggested the procedure that made economic production of hybrid seed corn feasible, hybrid corn was not used
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
47
extensively by farmers until after 1936. Thereafter its use expanded dramatically. A t present, hybrid seed is used on a high percentage of the 100 million hectares of the earths surface planted annually to corn. Despite the extensive use and the wide acclaim given to hybrid corn, divergent views exist as to the contribution by the hybrids to grain yields, per se. Whaley (1944) states that the grain yield of the hybrid may exceed that produced by the original heterozygous parent stock by as much as 50 percent while Stringfield (1964) estimates a more conservative positive increase of 20 percent. Observations ( Richey, 1950) also indicate that the individual hybrid plant is not superior in grain yields to the best individual plant of the original heterozygous openpollinated parental stock. In this view, the superior performance of the hybrid is due to uniformly high productivity of the individual plant in contrast to the greater variability among plants of the open-pollinated variety (Richey, 1950). Overall it is obvious that the better corn hybrids are usually superior in yield to the best of the open-pollinated varieties, although exceptions have been noted ( Stringfield, 1964). Virtually all F, hybrids ( single-crosses) between two inbred lines will produce grain yields double or more those of the highest-yielding inbred parents ( Leng, 1954). Yield component analysis reveals (Leng 1954, 1963) that heterotic effects are largely concentrated in the two “primary components”: kernels per row (ear length), and kernel weight. Both these components are manifestations of increased vigor and energystoring capacity. Hybrid plants are nearly always taller and have greater leaf area (Shull, 1952) than their parental inbreds. However, total foliage leaf number (Mehrotra, 1954) of F, hybrids usually is intermediate between the parental levels. The general phenotypic manifestation of hybrid vigor, then, is an increase in growth rate and total size of the plant, with an even greater proportionate increase in kernel number and total grain weight (Leng, 1954), Both Richey (1950) and Stringfield (1964) raise the question whether hybrid corn yield performance has attained a plateau. Both suggest that there is a need for more efficient breeding methods. Since this question was raised, average yield levels have increased noticeably. Nevertheless, the basic question is valid. Richmond (1951) stated that there was a need to develop more precision in breeding programs in cotton. Precision was defined as the development of indices that would measure “genetic potential performance rather than actual end-result behavior.” These indices were not further defined. Allards discussion (Allard, 1960) of the evaluation procedure for development of corn inbreds also illustrates the problem confronting the plant breeder. Specific points are: (1) it has been estimated that only 60 corn inbreds of over 1001,OOO tested
48
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
were good enough to be useful for commercial hybrid production, and ( 2 ) the better inbreds in common commercial use were derived from a very few open-pollinated varieties including such unimportant varieties as Lancaster Surecropper. The suggestion most commonly made (Stringfield, 1964; Richey, 1950; Richmond, 1951) for genetic improvement of agronomic crops is the introduction of new germ plasm to maintain maximum genetic diversity. The reason for the small percentage of successful inbreds resides in the inability to evaluate existing and new germ plasm prior to testing the hybrids. Of course, the development of more efficient statistical methods for determining usefulness of lines has promise. Nevertheless, it is clear that most effective breeding techniques would be those based on understanding and careful evaluation of physiological efficiency. To date, such techniques have not been put into practice, and some of the basic data are lacking on which research workers could proceed to evolve “physiological breeding methods. As indicated by Whaley (1952) the interacting complex of genes, metabolism, and environment required for the expression of hybrid vigor precludes a simple genetic explanation. Yet it is obvious that genes (in some number) are the underlying basis for the physiological advantages that lead to hybrid vigor. Because all genes are derived from the same general parental stock of the species, the phenomenon of heterosis must arise from their proper recombination. Whaley (1952) states that genetic and physiological studies concerned with the early phases of development are most likely to lead to the understanding of heterosis. Although his work suggests guidelines for physiological-genetical investigations of heterosis in higher plants, specific examples especially with respect to enzymes remained minimal until the mid-1950‘s. The tremendous recent advances in knowledge and understanding of the relationship between genes, metabolism, and growth are presented in current texts and reviews (Bonner and Varner, 1965; Fincham and Day, 1965; Frisch, 1961, 1963; Pollard, 1965; Crick, 1964; Watson, 1965; Herskowitz, 1962; Sager and Ryan, 1961). Because of the complexity of the processes involved, it is understandable that most studies have been conducted with microorganisms. Even with these simpler organisms, final resolution of the complexities of genetics has not been achieved. However, there is no reason that these findings and research approaches cannot be applied in a general sense to the study of heterosis and breeding of agronomic crops. In brief, current concepts can be outlined as follows. The genetic (chromosomal) material is capable of precise replication, except for mutations, generation after generation (Fig. 1). In microorganisms which have been studied intensively, the single chromosome is a double-
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
49
stranded, helix-wound, continuous loop of polymerized deoxyribomonophosphate nucleotides ( deoxyribonucleic acid-DNA ) , Each successive nucleotide is coupled by a 3’-Y-phosphodiester bond. The molecular weight of this circular chromosome is estimated at 2 billion, and each strand contains an estimated 2.5 to 3.0 million individual nucleotides. The chromosomal (DNA) strand is composed primarily of four deoxyribonucleotides: deoxyadenosine monophosphate ( d-AMP), deoxyguanosine monophosphate ( d-GMP), deoxycytidine monophosphate ( d-CMP ), and thymidine monophosphate ( d-TMP ) ,
.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ..
PARENTAL COMPLEMENTARY
I
. . . . . . . . . . . REPLICATION (CELL DIVISION)
1
$.
COMPLEMENTARY DAUGHTER STRANDS
. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ..
FIG. 1. Schematic diagram showing the two parental strands of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA), and the replication process that involves strand separation and strand duplication. The latter process is catalyzed by the enzyme DNA polymerase. Key to the symbols: solid line connecting circles represents the 3’-5’-phosphodiester bond that couples the nucleotides forming the DNA strand; the two dots represent the hydrogen bond between the compIementary nucleotide pair; dA, dG, dC, and d T represent the four deoxyribonucleotides; deoxyadenosine monophosphate, deoxyguanosine monophosphate, deoxycytidine monophosphate, and thymidine monophosphate, respectively. dA always pairs with dT, and dG with dC.
The chromosome strands are held together by hydrogen bonds between the nucleotides, and d-AMP is always H-bonded to d-TMP and d-CMP is always H-bonded t o d-GMP. This type of bonding establishes complementary structures, i.e., the nucleotide in one strand specifies the ( complementary) nucleotide in the other chromosome strand. In replication the strands separate, and each serves as a template to make a new complementary strand, thus precisely duplicating the genetic material, A second primary function of the chromosome (DNA) strand is to specify, albeit indirectly, the kind (identical over time periods) and amount as well as time of synthesis of protein (enzymes) needed for the growth, development, and function of the cell. This process is shown schematically in Fig. 2.
50
R. H. HAGEMAN’, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
The coding procedure which specifies the kind of protein to be synthesized resides in the sequential order of the nucleotides along a single strand of DNA. Specifically three nucleotides in sequence are required to specify the insertion of one amino acid in a protein. DNA does not serve as a direct template for the synthesis of protein but does serve as a template for the synthesis from ribonucleotides, of a complementary single strand polymer of “message” ribonucleic acid (mRNA ) .
I
+
+
UNWINDING OF STRANDS
(COO€ OFmRNA READOUT INTO +@------@---------@--------@---@+SEGMENT PROTEIN)
+ OF A PROTEIN
FIG.2. Schematic diagram of the DNA strands; the unwinding and strand separation that precedes transcription or formation of the messenger ri!3onucleic acid (mRNA) [the coded information for the synthesis of a specific protein (enzyme)]; and translation, the process of forming the protein specified by the mRNA. Transcription is catalyzed by the enzyme RNA-polymerase, and translation is a very complex process that involves ribosomes ( ribonucleic acid-protein-organelles ) and soluble or transfer ribonucleic acids. Key to the symbols: the double bars between DNA and mRNA indicate hydrogen bonds between complementary base pairs; A, G, C, and U represent the ribomonophosphate nucleotides found in RNA, adenosine, guanosine, cytidine, and uridine ( rib0 ) monophosphates, respectively; the three sets of nucleotide triplets (code) on the mRNA, UUU, CAC, and GAA, specify the protein phenylalanine ( p ) , histidine ( h ) and glutamic acid ( g), respectively. The dotted line between the amino acids represents peptide bonds. Other symbols are the same as in Fig. 1.
This process is known as transcription, and the polymer formed (mRNA) directs the synthesis of the protein. Three of the four common nucleotides of mRNA are the same as the nucleotides found in DNA, except that the sugar portion of each molecule is ribose instead of deoxyribose. The fourth nucleotide, uridine (ribose ) monophosphate, is substituted for thymidine monophosphate. Again, as in DNA, the nucleotides are linked together by 3’-5’-phosphodiester bonds. The transcription operation is initiated by the unwinding of the double-stranded chromosome (DNA), which permits the “reading out”
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
51
of the mRNA. Complementation of the nucleotide bases is observed between the DNA and the mRNA. For example, if d-TMP, d-CMP, d-GMP, d-AMP, d-AMP, d-AMP and d-AMP occur in sequence along the DNA strand, the mRNA reads in sequence AMP, GMP, CMP, UMP, UMP, UMP, and UMP, respectively. It is currently visualized that a gene, defined as a segment of a single strand of chromosome (DNA) within which a chiasma cannot be formed without modification of the organism, is the template for the individual mRNA formed. The mRNA in turn serves as the template for the synthesis of the protein (enzyme or subunit of an enzyme). Since there are four nucleotides and a combination of three nucleotides is required to specify one amino acid, there are sixty-four possible codes of nucleotide triplets available to specify the position of the twenty common amino acids found in proteins. As an example, a triplet nucleotide sequence along a segment of mRNA of UMP, UMP, and UMP when read out (translated from mRNA to protein) would specify the insertion of the amino acid phenylalanine. Since there are sixty-four possible code triplets and only twenty amino acids, some amino acids can be specified by more than one code. The reasons for and implications of this multicoding are not fully established at present. Enzymes (proteins) are linear polymers of amino acids. Each amino acid in the polymer is joined to each of the two adjacent amino acids by a peptide bond. Thus its carboxyl group is linked with the amino group of one adjacent amino acid while its amino group is linked to the second amino acid. Enzymes range in molecular weight from 10,000 to several million and accordingly would contain from 100 to several thousand amino acids. In function, enzymes are biological catalysts, They are considered to operate like other catalysts, providing a surface upon which reacting components can bind while undergoing changes in orbital electron configuration. Thus reacting metabolites are bonded to the enzyme for periods of time ranging from microseconds to days. It is obvious that enzymes must be very specific as to reactions that they catalyze if they control the metabolism of an organism. This specificity is achieved by the sequential order of amino acids along the linear protein polymer and by the conformation (secondary and tertiary structure) the enzyme assumes in its active state. This specificity is not absolute, otherwise the competitive inhibition of enzymes would be impossible. In fact, compounds of related structure and charge can also bond to a given enzyme. One other important facet of enzyme structure is that only certain segments (active centers) of the molecule can bind the metabolite (substrate). Thus portions of the enzyme can be deleted (by isolation
52
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
techniques or genetic mutations) without completely destroying the catalytic efficiency of the enzyme. Usually, a deletion of part of the enzyme structure is associated with decreased enzymatic function. The bonding of metabolite (substrate) and enzyme is partially described by the Michaelis-Menten kinetics and constant ( K , ) , K, is defined as that concentration of metabolite in moles per liter where reaction velocity is one-half maximal. At this concentration of substrate, the binding site of the enzyme can be assumed to be half saturated whereas maximum reaction rates are achieved only when the binding sites are fully saturated. Because any change in active centers, charge, structure, or form of an enzyme, produced by genetic mutation or environmental conditions, could greatly affect the bonding of substrate and enzyme, the rate of individual reactions, and in turn, metabolism as a whole, could readily be altered. Changes in the sequential order of amino acids in the enzyme reflect changes (mutations) in the gene. Currently the best way to characterize a gene is by characterization of the enzyme product specified by the gene. To recapitulate, the operations synthesizing an enzyme (assumed to be monomeric in this case) containing 150 amino acids with molecular weight of 15,000, would require mRNA containing approximately 150 triplet codes, or 450 nucleotides. If the DNA undergoes no variation in sequence of nucleotides along the chromosome chain, if the transcription of DNA to mRNA proceeds without error, and if no mistakes are made in translation of mRNA into protein, enzyme molecules identical in structure will be produced. Since at present it is believed that a different mRNA must be synthesized for each enzyme, and since the number of enzymes in an organism is probably at least 2,000 to 3,000, the system obviously is extremely complex. The “lifetime” (stability) of mRNA also is variable, ranging from a half-life of minutes to several hours in the few examples which have been carefully studied. This is important because the number of individual enzyme molecules which can be translated from one mRNA varies both with the rate at which the translation can be carried out and with the “lifetime” of the mRNA. The precise number of enzyme molecules produced by any given mRNA is not known. This turnover of mRNA is obviously an important metabolic control mechanism, since stability (“lifetime”) of enzymes also varies, Jacob and Monod (1961) have developed a theory of gene action which postulates two categories of genes: (1) structural genes; ( 2 ) regulatory genes. It is considered that “structural genes” specify the kind of protein (enzyme) to be produced, and “regulatory” genes determine
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
53
whether and to what extent a given protein would be synthesized under a given environment. “Regulatory” genes would not alter the kind of protein specified by the “structural” genes. Environmental changes could affect enzyme content of cells in several different ways. One likely possibility is by enzyme induction, where a metabolite could invoke the synthesis of the particular enzyme needed for its utilization. A second is enzyme repression, the situation in which synthesis of a given enzyme is suppressed by a certain metabolite, It appears likely (Jacob and Monod, 1961) that induction and repression are basicaIly controlled by the same mechanism. It has been shown in some cases that induction is the release of repression and that different metabolites can activate the same repression. Exactly how the activation or repression of the “regulatory” gene occurs is not known. Neither are there clear indications of the nature of the control products (repressors) formed by “regulatory” genes, or of the sites of activity of the repressor materials. Currently, it is assumed that the “repressed state (“structural” genes nonfunctional) is normal. However, since the control of state is genetic, it is obvious that gene mutations could occur which would specify continuous function, intermittent function, or no function of a given “structural” gene. Finally, one “regulatory” gene could control the action of one or several “structural” genes. Such functional groups of genes have been termed “operons” (Jacob and Monod, 1961).Little evidence to support the “operon theory” has been obtained with nonbacterial organisms (Fincham and Day, 1965). With respect to agronomic plants, Filner (1966) has reported the induction of nitrate reductase in cultured tobacco pith cells by nitrate and the repression of this induction with certain amino acids. Although nitrate reductase can be induced by nitrate in corn seedlings, repression is not affected by amino acids (unpublished data of our laboratory). To summarize, the function of enzymes is to catalyze the chemical reactions which make up metabolism and which are expressed in the growth, development, and maturation of cells, tissues, and the entire organism. Since both intensity and direction of metabolic processes vary with time, it is essential that the enzyme complement or its functional effectiveness vary, both within the cell and from cell to cell, during different stages of development. Thus, as stated by Glass (1958), “genes must function differently in different cells.” Also they may function differently in the same cell at different times. From this it may be concluded that sequential development results from differential gene action, in point of time. If the ‘parsimony of nature” principle is valid for metabolic systems, it is more likely that control is exerted over the fabrication of enzymes, than that there is a constant rate of synthesis of a11
54
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
enzymes with control being achieved by preferential degradation or inhibition. From the above, it is clear that a “biochemical-genetic” approach to the problem of heterosis and its effective utilization in plant breeding must be based on the fundamentaI facts of enzyme activity and its genetic control. From this, it follows that a direct attack on the problems involved in major metabolic processes is indicated. The following sections of this paper will treat recent experimental evidence relating to several such problems. Ill.
Heterosis and Enzyme Activity during Germination
From the discussion above, it is clear that an experimental approach to a biochemical solution of the heterosis problem must focus on metabolic systems of major importance for growth, development, and maturation. A prime requirement of such studies is that the system to be investigated be one which is not only important to the organism, but capable of reasonably exact investigation under environmental conditions which will produce normal growth and development. Even today, this latter requirement presents major difficulties. When research was initiated at Illinois on this problem in 1954, far less biochemical-genetic information (particularly pertaining to higher plants) was available. Initially the work had to be restricted to etiolated corn seedlings because many enzymes could not be extracted in active form from green corn leaf tissue by standard and established procedures (Hageman and Waygood, 1959). The first experimental approach was to examine the energy transfer system in young corn seedlings. The basic rationale of this study was that extreme manifestations of heterosis were nearly always apparent in seedling vigor, i.e., rate and amount of early growth. Ashby (1930, 1932) postulated that this early vigor resulted from an increased “initial capital” of embryo tissue in the hybrid, as compared with its inbred parents. Groszmann and Sprague ( 1948), however, clearly showed that “initial capital” differences have little if any basic influence on heterotic early vigor. Therefore, it was clear that the explanation for this phenomenon must be sought elsewhere. The work begun in 19% at Illinois was planned to determine whether enhanced early vigor in corn hybrids could be associated with greater amounts or more efficient operation of major enzymes involved both directly and indirectly in energy transfer. The basic premise was that since the hybrid grows at a faster rate than its inbred parents, its cells must convert stored food reserves to energy, and ultimately to the
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
55
“building blocks” of new tissue, at a faster rate, Alternatively, the hybrid simply operates more efficiently than the inbred. I n either case, differences in enzyme activity should occur, since most if not all major metabolic reactions are catalyzed by enzymes. As is true for other catalysts, enzymes affect the rate (velocity) of chemical reactions but do not alter the reaction equilibrium, nor do they appear as products of the catalyzed reaction. The conclusion should be obvious that a hybrid which is growing more rapidly than its inbred parents should show either ( a ) more efficient (qualitatively different) enzymes, or ( b ) greater amount of enzymes (quantitatively different), for the enzymes involved in the major growth reactions. Logically, it would be expected that quantitative differences would be most likely, since increases in quantity of catalyst (enzyme) normally are associated with increases in the amount of reaction products per unit time of reaction. Germination studies, conducted in dark constant environment growth chambers with corn seedlings, offered an experimental approach to test the postulate that hybrid vigor was due to qualitative or quantitative differences in enzymes, The growth of etiolated seedlings for the initial 5 days is almost exclusively dependent (85to 90 percent) upon the stored endosperm starch for its energy source (Ingle et al., 1964). In addition to energy, starch is a major reserve for carbon compounds needed in growth and development. The enzyme glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (Fig. 3 ) initiates a pathway that leads to the production of ribulose diphosphate used in the photosynthetic fixation of CO, and ribose-a constituent of nucleotides. Other metabolites of the glycolytic pathway and Krebs cycle are useful and necessary for growth and development. Enzymes concerned with the release of energy and conversion of starch to other compounds are of major importance to the growth and development of the seedling. The selection of enzymes for study posed problems because of the large number of enzymes available for testing (Bonner and Varner, 1965). The enzymes, triosephosphate dehydrogenase (TPD ), aldolase ( ALD ), and glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase ( G-6-PD ) were selected for study. ALD and TPD were chosen because they are two of the ten enzymes of the glycolytic pathway (Fig. 3 ) which couples the stored endosperm starch to the Krebs cycle. Although about 80 percent of the energy derived from starch is converted in the Krebs cycle into forms [adenosine triphosphate (ATP) and reduced di- and triphosphopyridine nucleotides ( DPNH and TPNH), respectively] useful to the seedling for growth and development, the enzymes TPD and G-6-PD are the sites of first energy conversion. The functioning of the Krebs cycle is also dependent upon pyruvate supplied by the glycolytic path-
56
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
way. Another compelling reason was that methods were available to assay these particular enzymes. Ungerminated seeds and young (1-to 5-day-old) seedlings of inbreds WF9, M14, Hy2, and Oh7 and the hybrids WF9 X M14 and Hy2 X Oh7 were used as the experimental material. The seeds were graded in an attempt to negate gross inequities in initial seed size. To compensate for Starch
Ir? Glucose I - phosphate
Glucose - 6 -phosphate dehydrogenase
-+ r G l(iNl 1
Glucose 6 - phosphate
/-3
TPN
Fructose 6 - phosphate
6 - Phospho gluconate
Ri bulose 5-phosphote
+ co,
TPNH N 24 kcal
To
Pyruvate
+Krebs cycle
ZkCi-) ADP
p&ol
3 - Phosphoglycerote
Fructose I , 6 - diphosphote
\-
3 - Phospho-
Dihydroxy-
A
ocetone phosphate
7
glyceroldehyde
N
24 kcol
DL LY I , 3 - Diphosphoglycerate
?
Triosephosphate dehydrogenose
FIG.3. A portion of the metabolic process involved in the conversion of starch to pyruvate and ribulose 5-phosphate. Only those enzymes that were assayed are indicated. Note that two enzymes compete for glucose 6-phosphate.
differential plant size, enzymatic activities were expressed as utilization of substrate or formation of product per unit of time per unit of protein or plant weight. Both hybrids exhibited hybrid vigor in seedling growth (scutellum, root, and shoot only) and endosperm utilization (Fig. 4). “Efficiency” was estimated by dividing daily increases in dry seedling weight by daily losses in endosperm weight. No consistent difference in efficiency could be detected between hybrids and inbreds. Over the 5-day period, in all experiments, the hybrids were slightly Iess efficient at converting endosperm reserve into seedling growth than their respective inbred
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
57
parents. As an example, the conversion efficiencies for WF9, M14, and WF9 x M14 over the 5-day period were 64, 69, and 63 percent, respectively. In contrast, the hybrids converted their stored reserves into seedling growth (dry weight) at a faster rate than did their respective parental inbreds. Endosperm
UI
n
7
I
I
I
utilization
I
G'.," m
iI P
I 2.
A
1
O'
4
h
b
5 '
2.
0
Days
Growth
-0c
n
2.0-
0
0
WF9 W F 9 x MI4 Mi4
Days
Days
FIG.4. A comparison of the rate of utilization of endosperm and seedling (root, shoot, and scutellum) growth of corn inbreds WF9, M14, Hy2, and Oh7 and the hybrids WF9 x M14 and Hy2 x Oh7. Environmental conditions were: dark; aerobic; 29°C.; and 80 to 95 percent relative humidity.
Both hybrids exhibited heterosis with respect to TPD activity in dormant seeds and in 1- to 5-day-old seedlings (Figs. 5A and 5B). Aldolase activity was slightly higher in the seedlings (but not in the dormant seed) of WF9 x M14 than in the two parental inbreds. However, the hybrid Hy2 x Oh7 was essentially intermediate in activity level throughout, as compared with its parental inbreds (Figs. 5C and SD). Attempts to purify and characterize these enzymes were not completely successful. TPD was extracted and partially purified (tenfold) from ungerminated seeds of WF9, M14, and WF9 X M14. Based on two preparations and replicate assays, K , values of 2.1, 2.1, and 2.0 were obtained for the WF9, M14, and WF9 X M14 enzymes, respectively. These values are not statistically different. Based on this meager
58
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY TPD octivity X
I
E
1200-
\
I
I
X
WF9 W F 9 x MI4
0
MI4
I
-
-
240
E
A
0
I
I
1
2
I
I
3 Days
4
\ VI
-
2403. €
5
C 0
I
I
I
I
1
2
3
4
5
4
5
Days Aldolase
activity
600
150
150
3. E 0
1
2
3 Days
4
5
0
1
2
3 Dcys
FIG. 5. A comparison of amount of enzymatic activity in seeds and whole seedlings (endosperm, root, shoot, and scutellum) of the two sets of corn inbreds and hybrids. Enzymes assayed were triosephosphate dehydrogenase ( TPD ) and aldolase. Material was grown as described in Fig. 1.
evidence, it would appear that the higher level of activity observed for TPD in WF9 x M14 was due to greater quantity of enzyme rather than to differences in kind of enzyme fabricated by the hybrid. This work was pursued and additional data were obtained with plant material grown under two different environments-aerobic and semiaerobic (Fig. 6A-F). There are six distinctive features of data presented in Fig. 6: ( a ) The hybrids did not exhibit “heterotic” levels of enzyme activity under the aerobic or semiaerobic conditions. In fact the activities of all three enzymes in the hybrid seedlings tended to be intermediate as compared with those of the parental inbreds. ( b ) The semiaerobic environment enhanced the activities of ALD and TPD in all material, as compared with material grown under aerobic conditions. ( c ) In Hy2 x Oh7 and its parental inbreds and in M14 seedlings grown under the semiaerobic environment, ALD activity continued to increase over the 5-day period. In contrast, hybrid WF9 x M14 and inbred WF9 showed sharp decreases in activity on day 4. ( d ) TPD
59
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
Triosephosphate dehydrogenoze Avg. values Aerobic 600
1000 -0 WF
c ._ 0 a
,
Semi- 1; aerobic, 785 / \
0 Hy2
Aerobic Semiaerobic 675 695
800 -
I
0
1
2
I
I
I
3 4 5 0 1 2 3 Seedling age in days
I
4
5
0
1
2
3 4 5 0 1 2 Seedling age in duys
Aldolase Avg values
3
4
5
11,050
Aerobic Semiaerobic
0
1
2
3 4 5 0 1 2 3 Seedling age in days
Aerobic 0 X
WF9 WF9 x MI4
11.0 14.0
4
5
0
1
2
Glucose 6 - P Dehydrogenose Semiaerobic Avg. VaIUeS 11.0 14.0
Seeding age in days
-
3 4 5 0 1 2 3 4 - 5 Seedling age in days
Aerobic Semiaerobic o Hy2 16.5 14.0 x H y 2 x Oh7 16.0 13.0
Seeding age in days
FIG. 6. A comparison of amounts of enzymatic activity in seeds and whole seedlings (endosperm, root, shoot, and scutellum) of two sets of corn inbreds and hybrids. Environment was as described in Fig. 1 except that semiaerobic conditions were achieved by resealing the plant culture flat with a clear plastic film after opening for watering. Other details of plant culture are published (Hageman and Flesher, 1960b) ,
60
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
activities of the Hy2 x Oh7 set were enhanced by the semiaerobic environment only to a small degree (5 percent). In contrast, TPD activities of the WF9 X MI4 set of material were increased by 25 percent under similar treatment. ( e ) Activity of G-6-PD was decreased in both sets of material under the semiaerobic environment. This observation is not inconsistent with the current concepts of TPNH reoxidation under semiaerobic conditions. ( f ) The level of G-6-PD activity in M14 was consistently higher and in WF9 was consistently lower than in WF9 Aerobic Reduced Substrates (organic l a ( l ,acid) , N r Dc
Oxidized Substrates
+
( c l glutamate
(bl NO; H P gyenr+,
cop
(ATP)
(a1 0 2 (b) NO; ( c I (I- ketoglutaric + NH; ( d l Other similar reductions
Ana e r o b i c
I , 3 - Diphospho-
I ,3-Diphosphoglycerote
p-
Acetaldehyde
CO,
Pyruvate
FIG. 7 . A comparison of the aerobic and anaerobic conditions with respect to the systems that recycle (reduce and oxidize) diphosphopyridine nucleotide ( DPN ) . Competition for the energy of DPNH is illustrated in the aerobic phase.
x M14. In the authors’ opinion, these differences in G-SPD activity are due to genetic differences. This suggests that these two inbreds should be useful as divergent sources of germ plasm for this enzyme. The influence of the semiaerobic environment on the expression of activity of TPD and ALD (Fig. 6) can be explained. This explanation also affords an opportunity to relate environment, genetic composition, and phenotypic expression. With corn seedlings under aerobic conditions, the pyruvate formed (Fig. 3 ) is the natural metabolite to be supplied to the Krebs cycle where the oxidation of di- and tricarboxylic acids generate energy (DPNH). Much of this DPNH is reoxidized by oxygen (Fig. 7 ) , with the subsequent generation of ATP. Under conditions favorable to growth, other reactions proceed which also reoxidize
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
61
DPNH (Fig. 7 ) . As indicated in the figure, the recycling of DPN+ DPNH is also a mass-action type of control mechanism; i.e., energy (ATP) cannot be generated if DPNH is not available. An aerobic environment thus leads to conditions favoring a reasonably high level of ATP, which in turn can act to control the rate of flow of metabolites through the glycolytic pathway (Fig. 3 ) . Specifically, high levels of ATP inhibit the enzyme ( phosphofructokinase) that leads to the production of fructose 176-diphosphate ( Bonner and Varner, 1965; Passonneau and Lowry, 1962; Lowry and Passonneau, 1964). This regulation of carbohydrate catabolism by ATP offers one plausible explanation for the Pasteur effect, i.e., the addition of oxygen to a fermenting system slows down the rate of carbohydrate utilization. In the absence of oxygen, normal utilization of pyruvate, oxidation of DPNH, and most ATP production ceases. In this environment, corn seedlings initiate alternate or fermentative pathways that permit recycling of DPNH (anaerobic system-Fig. 7). This results in the utilization of large amounts of the endosperm starch and the production of an excess of ethanol that is excreted into the external medium ( Hageman and Flesher, 196Qb).This production of ethanol is wasteful, since it appears that corn seedlings cannot utilize exogenous ethanol even under aerobic conditions. However, without the production of ethanol, DPNH reoxidation and the concurrent meager (4 moles ATP per mole of glucose us. 38 moles ATP per mole of glucose under aerobic conditions) production of energy cease. When corn seedlings are placed in an anaerobic environment, growth (fresh weight) and net increase in protein stop within a few hours. However, some metabolic changes do occur. It has been shown that under anaerobic conditions, corn seedlings show a marked increase in activity of some enzymes, e.g., alcohol dehydrogenase, and a decrease in activity of others, e.g., cytochrome oxidase (Hageman and Flesher, 196Ob). It can also be shown that increased amounts of alcohol dehydrogenase could be induced in corn seedlings by the addition of exogenous pyruvate or acetaldehyde under aerobic conditions. Thus alteration of environment or level of substrate (any of the vast array of metabolites found in the plant) may increase or decrease the level of activity of the various enzymes. The semiaerobic environment (Fig. 6 ) was sufficiently depleted of oxygen for part of each day to permit limited ethanol production, but provided enough oxygen the rest of the time to permit respiration, generation of energy (ATP), and synthesis of protein. Therefore, the increased activity of TPD and ALD observed (Fig. 6A, B, and E ) was anticipated. Although the reason for the relative lack of increase in TPD activity in the Hy2 X Oh7 set of material (Fig. 6D) is not known,
62
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
genetic control is one possible explanation. From these data (Fig. 6A, B, D, and E ) it is obvious that the phenotypic expression of enzyme activity varies with environment and with genotype. The consequence of these divergencies in enzyme activity upon the subsequent go& and development of the plant are not known. However, it can be visualized that such major variations in metabolism would exert significant influences on the final characteristics of the plant. It is more difficult to explain the decrease in level of activity of G-6-PD (Fig, 6C and F) found in the seedlings grown under the semiaerobic conditions. One possible explanation is that under these conditions the reoxidation of TPNH is limited, The lack of TI" would curtail the utilization of glucose 6-phosphate, and this in turn might lead to the formation of a corepressor for G-6-PD. Inhibition of the enzyme activity by product formation provides another explanation. Since the semiaerobic environment should diminish the utilization of the products of this pathway, the accumulating products could contribute to control. The relatively high level of G-6-PD activity in M14 plants grown under semiaerobic conditions implies a genetic system less subject to control. No matter which control system is operative, the phenotypic expression of enzymatic activity obviously is significantly different when environment or genotype are altered. Based on the data in Figs. 5 and 6 it is concluded that with the possible exception of the low level of G-6-PD in WF9 there was no real difference in enzyme activity of the material tested. This statement appears paradoxical, since many of the differences observed (Fig. 5 ) were found to be significant and consistent results were noted from experiment to experiment. However, these differences were noted only as long as seed source, environment, etc. remained constant. This is verified by the data of Fig. 6. It is suggested that until experimental techniques for assaying and purifying enzymes improve and general knowIedge in this area is expanded, work of this type should be initiated by surveying a large number of corn inbreds for divergent expression of activity of the enzyme selected. In other words, it is important to establish maximum genetic variability. It is also evident that changes in environment drastically alter the level of enzymatic activity and that there are dramatic environment-genotype interactions. It is difficult to envisage the precise consequences of the interaction of genotype with environment since so little is known about the genetic control of metabolic systems in plants. Because there is competition for energy and metabolites (Moyse, 1959), the level of activity of any given enzymes established by the genotype could alter metabolism and ultimately the final phenotypic expression of yield.
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
63
The following concept can be deduced from this work: The genetic code is expressed in the phenotype through the mechanism of an enzymatically catalyzed metabolic system, and through the interaction of this system with the environment. Logically, then, hybrid vigor must be the result of a properly balanced and catalyzed metabolic system for a given environment. This implies that the amount of activity of each enzyme arising from one or more loci-regardless of the allelic composition-must be in balance with the system as a whole. Either too high or too low a level of enzymatic activity could be detrimental to the system as a whole. The work on energy-transfer systems, summarized above, was not pursued far enough to elucidate or establish the “balanced metabolic system” concept as it may apply specifically to heterosis and early vigor. However, this work made it clear that hybrid seedlings-despite their marked superiority (in vigor) to their inbred parents-do not exhibit heterotic levels of activity of these three major enzymes involved in important metabolic processes related to early growth. Clear differences were observed between inbred lines only with respect to G-6-PD-also not necessarily related to growth-rate characteristics. The essentially intermediate condition found in F, hybrids indicates that some explanation other than “heterotic” levels of enzymes must be found if hybrid vigor is to be satisfactorily explained. IV.
Genetic Control of the initial Reaction of Nitrogen Metabolism
Because of new developments in experimental procedures ( Hageman and Waygood, 1959; Miflin and Hageman, 1963), it became possible to investigate enzymes and enzyme systems of green corn leaves throughout the growing season. This type of investigation is deemed most important because it permits a better evaluation of genotype under the environment in which it is normally grown. It also provides more insight into the complex interaction of genotype-environment-metabolism stage of physiological development. Although heterosis is exhibited in early seedling growth, this early season vigor in no way assures maximum grain production per hectare ( McIlrath, 1964). Since grain production also exhibits heterosis, studies of the synthetic systems that fabricate “building blocks” needed for protein and carbohydrate synthesis in the grain should be of value. Because the corn plant has a high light requirement (Hesketh and Musgrave, 1962), it is much easier to achieve “normal” grain production under natural light than in the currently available environmental growth chambers. For these reasons investigations were shifted to metabolic systems strongly affected by light and more directly related to grain production.
64
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
Interest in this complex problem developed from the results of shading experiments with corn at Illinois (Earley et al., 1966) and other stations. Initially, this work was not directly related to the heterosis problem, but it soon became clear that field and laboratory techniques were available which would enable a study of the enzyme systems involved in nitrogen metabolism, and also of chloroplast activity. The enzyme nitrate-reductase ( N R ) was chosen for study because it is a major control-point in nitrogen metabolism, which in turn was considered to be of prime importance to yielding ability of corn grown under management systems involving high levels of nitrogen supply and high plant populations. Evidence bearing on these points will be developed in the following paragraphs. Certain corn hybrids have been clearly shown to be tolerant of high plant populations in respect to grain yield (Lang et al., 1956; Stinson and Moss, 1960). Since the “tolerant” hybrids produced more grain under shade treatment where light was presumably the only variable, it was concluded that light was the causal factor for reduced grain production (Earley et al., 1966). Duncan (1958) has shown that as rate of planting increases the log values of grain yield per plant decreases in a linear manner, regardless of fertility level. It is difficult to assess the effects of competition for light, nutrients, and moisture on grain yields under high plant populations (Brenchley, 1920), however the linear decrease in yield per plant, with increased plant population under various environments, implicates light as a major factor. Although competitive (inter- and intra-plant ) and artificial shading of plants causes both reduction in CO, fixation (Moss and Stinson, 1961; Hesketh and Musgrave, 1962; Moss et al., 1961; Thomas, 1956) and accumulation of nitrate (Schimper, 1888; Knipmeyer et al., 1962), it could be that the lack of carbohydrate and carbohydrate derivatives constitutes the first limiting factor in grain production under high plant populations. Thus when shade experiments failed to show that nitrate accumulation in plants was due to a lack of carbohydrate and carbohydrate derivatives ( Knipmeyer et al., 1962), other explanations were needed. These experiments indicated that nitrogen metabolism was more adversely affected by the decreased light intensity than was carbohydrate metabolism. Other experiments provided additional support for this view. Candela et al. (1957) observed that nitrate reductase activity disappeared from cauliflower plants placed in the dark. Zieserl et al. (1963) compared two corn hybrids rated as “tolerant” with respect to grain production at high planting rates with an “intolerant” hybrid. The “tolerant” types contained more nitrate reductase per gram of fresh leaf tissue or per milligram of protein than the hybrid intolerant of high plant
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
65
populations. Schrader and Hageman (1965) determined that Hy2 X Oh7 (tolerant) had more nitrate reductase activity per plant during the reproductive (pollination) phase than WF9 C103 (intolerant). Analysis of the whole plant at the end of the season showed that the Hy2 X Oh7 plants contained more protein but less unreduced nitrate than the WF9 x C103 plants. Hageman and co-workers (1960a, 1961) found nitrate reductase activity to decrease, and nitrate content of corn leaf tissue to increase, in rough proportion to the increase in level of shade derived from high plant populations or shade structures. Although the tolerant and intolerant corn hybrids responded in a similar manner to decreased light intensity, the tolerant hybrids maintained their superiority with respect to nitrate reductase activity throughout the range of shading. In contrast, “tolerant” hybrids used by Moss and Stinson (1961) did not differ from “intolerant” types in ability to fix CO, under either full sun or shade treatment. In addition, they found no difference in sugar content between tolerant and intolerant hybrids. The large amounts of nitrogenous fertilizers applied annually and the high plant densities are most certainly associated with the current record grain yields (6,000 kg./h.-Illinois state average, 1965). Most of the nitrogen available to plants grown under field conditions is in the form of nitrate (Virtanen and Rautanen, 1952), because in most soils microorganisms rapidly convert ammoniacal forms to nitrate. Paradoxically, nitrate must be reduced prior to elaboration into amino acids. An outline of the reduction sequence, the electron donors, and one mechanism for the union of ammonia with a keto acid are shown in Fig. 8. The diagram indicates the interlocking of inorganic nitrogen metabolism with carbohydrate metabolism (Krebs cycle) and that the reduction of nitrite and “fixed” carbon dioxide have to compete for electrons from ferredodn ( a component of the energy generation system of the chloroplasts) ( Tagawa and Arnon, 1962). The reduction sequence is initiated by the enzyme nitrate reductase (NR). NR is a substrate (NO,-) inducible enzyme (Filner, 1966; Beevers et al., 1965) and in cultured tobacco pith cells is subject to repressor-type control where amino acids serve as corepressors or derepressors (Filner, 1966). NR is not a stable enzyme as indicated by a 3%-hourhalf-life in excised corn tissue floated in water at 33°C.(unpublished data of L. E. Schrader of our laboratory). These observations suggest that NR is a major control point for the system that supplies reduced nitrogen to the plant. Further support for the concept of NR control is supplied by the following: Nitrate can and does accumulate to high concentrations (5,000 pg of NO3- per gram fresh weight) in corn leaf tissue, apparently
x
66
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
without injury to the plant. Nitrite does not accumulate in corn leaf tissue, at least not in excess of 1 pg. NOz- per gram fresh weight (the limit of the assay used on thousands of samples). The level of free ammonia in plant tissue is relatively low (Henderlong and Schmidt, 1966) as it is rapidly assimilated into glutamate or the amides glutamine From
Krebs cycle
Keto acids
NO;
DPNH ~
Amino acids
_L
D
P
N
Light Chloroplasts Fructose I , 6 Diphosphote
-
To starch
FIG. 8. A schematic diagram of inorganic nitrogen metabolism showing its relationship with carbohydrate metabolism ( a-ketoglutarate from the Krebs cycle) and with Iight-generated energy ( F D ) . The dotted lines between NOz- and NH,' indicate that the suggested intermediates, hyponitrous acid and hydroxylamine, probably do not exist in free form but are bound to the enzyme, nitrite reductase. Nitrogen metabolism competes with the Krebs cycle for carbohydrate skeletons (keto acids) and with 3-phosphoglyceric acid (3-PGA) for energy derived froin light. Evidence for the latter has been published by Moyse (1959).
and asparagine (Fowden, 1965). Other work has shown that increases in nitrate reductase activity are associated with increased protein formation and decreased nitrate content ( Hageman et al., 1961 ). With tobacco pith cells cultured on nitrate, growth has been related to NR activity ( Filner, 1966). An initial survey with 2- to 3-week-old seedlings established that the three corn inbreds C103, Oh7, and Hy2 contained about the same level of NR and were approximately twice as high in activity as WF9 (Zieserl and Hageman, 1962). Based on the importance of NR implicit in this concept, studies were undertaken to determine the range of genetic diversity for NR in Corn Belt inbred lines and hybrids. Although these preliminary results indicated that lines differed in NR, the data were obtained from seedlings grown in the greenhouse. Critical evalua-
A BIOCHEMICAL APPR0.4CH TO CORN BREEDING
67
tion of the importance of NR in determining heterotic response depends on demonstration of differences between lines per se and their hybrids grown under field conditions. In 1960 field trials were begun when 47 inbreds were evaluated for NR throughout the growing season. The highest and lowest inbreds in NR activity differed by fivefold in seasonal mean activity (Zieserl and Hageman, 1962; Zieserl et al., 1963) (Table I). Lines also differed in TABLE I Specific Activity for Nitrate Reductase (Seasonal Mean Values) of 12 Inbred Lines of Corn in 1960 and 1961 Specific activity“
a
Inbred
1960
1961
Oh43 R177 H49 WF9 A545 HY2 R181 R168 CI2lE Oh7 M14 R151
0.16 0.21 0.23 0.26 0.35 0.35 0.37 0.42 0.48 0.51 0.51 0.58
0.28 0.34 0.34 0.41 0.61 0.70 0.94 0.55 0.82 0.70 0.78 0.83
Expressed as micromoles of KNOz per milligram of protein per hour.
seasonal distribution of NR, although all lines were low in activity near the end of the season. Twelve inbred lines representing a wide range of NR activity, as observed in 1960, were evaluated for NR in 1961. Samples were taken at weekly intervals from June 28 to August 24. In general, the inbred rankings based on seasonal mean activities were the same as in 1960 even though the general mean level of activity was higher in 1961 (Table I). Thus certain inbred lines were found to differ consistently in NR activity, indicating that activity of this enzyme is under genetic control. A more important question was to determine the NR activity of hybrids between lines of known activity levels, since evidence on this point could be of prime importance in assessing the role of NR in heterotic responses. Therefore, inbreds classified as “high” and “low” in NR were crossed to produce “high X “high,” “low” X “low,” and “high” x ‘‘low’’ hybrids (Schrader et al., 1966). The hybrids and inbreds studied and
68
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
their seasonal mean values for activity per gram fresh weight are shown in Fig. 9. Seasonal means of “high x “high hybrids were significantly lower than the mid-parental level in three cases but not significantly different from the mid-parent in three other cases. No “heterotic” levels of NR activity were observed in any of the “high” x “high hybrids. The cross Hy2 x Oh7 grown in 1963 was the only one of seven comparisons of “high” x ‘‘low’’ hybrids in which the hybrid differed significantly from the mid-parent. In general, crosses of “high” x “low” lines gave hybrids intermediate between their parents in activity. Again, no cases of “heterosis”in NR activity were found. One “low” x “low” hybrid, B14 x Oh43, was significantly higher in NR activity than either parent in both 1962 and 1963 (unpublished data in our laboratory verified this observation in 19f34, 1965, and 1966). A similar result was obtained for Hy2 X B14. Thus, heterosis for NR was indicated in some “low” x “low” crosses. However, other ‘‘low’’ x “low” hybrids showed no heterosis for NR (Fig. 9). Even though heterosis for NR was observed, the activity of the “heterotic” hybrids really was in the intermediate range, since it did not approach the activity of certain “high inbreds. Yet all hybrids studied, regardless of level of NR, showed heterosis for grain yield and vegetative growth. This clearly indicates that heterotic levels of NR are not necessary for “agronomic heterosis,” though it is not likely that NR activity is unimportant to vigor and yielding ability. Some attention has been given to the question “Are the differences in levels of nitrate reductase activity among the corn inbreds and hybrids due to quantitative or qualitative differences in the enzyme?” The major difficulty in determining qualitative differences is that nitrate reductase is an extremely unstable enzyme and all attempts to obtain a pure “homogeneous” enzyme have been unsuccessful. Beevers et al. (1964) used partially purified nitrate reductase from Zea mays L. (Corn belt inbreds and hybrids and Peruvian corn) and teosinte-Zea mexicana Reeves and Mangelsdorf ( Euchleana mexicanu Schrad.) to determine apparent K , values for nitrate. K , values (magnitude M.) of 1.7, 1.6, 1.4, 1.4, 1.5, and 2.0 were determined for Hy2 X Oh7, WF9 X C103, R151, R177, Peruvian corn, and teosinte, respectively. The variation among the values are in the range of experimental error. Based on these K , values for nitrate, the enzymes from these different materials are considered to be qualitatively the same. Other attempts to purify and characterize nitrate reductase from B14, Oh43, and B14 X Oh43 were conducted by Dr. G. Ritenour (unpublished results from our laboratory). The I(, values for B14, Oh43, and B14 X Oh43 were: for DPNH ( M.) 3.9, 3.2, and 3.4 and for nitrate
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
69
( M.) 1.6, 1.4, and 1.2, respectively. These data indicate no qualitative differences in the enzymes. Over the years other evaluations (pH optima, change with purification, temperature sensitivity, etc. ) with this and other enzymes have tended to support the view that the difference in level of enzyme activity is quantitative rather than qualitative. This conclusion is restricted by High x low category
High x high category 1962
RBI
Rl8l MI4 a Oh43 Oh43aM14
W F 9 aOh43
W F 9 I 814
Cl03
814 xOh43 Oh43 814 rOh43 oh43
FIG.9. Comparison of seasonal mean values of nitrate reductase of 15 F1maize hybrids with their respective parental inbreds. Details of seasonal patterns have been published ( Schrader et al., 1966) I
the lack of success in obtaining highly purified enzymes from corn tissue. From the evidence previously cited, genetic control of NR activity has been established for maize, and some information is available from which activity levels of hybrids between lines of known NR activity can be predicted. However, the number of genes involved, the mode of action of these genes, and the way in which they affect activity are still to be determined.
70
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
Some indication of the complexity of the genetic system controlling NR may be inferred from work with microorganisms. However, in these organisms NO,- is taken directly into the cell in which it is utilized. Also, the photosynthetic process is not involved, the organisms are grown under rigidly controlled environments, and the character being determined is not level of activity, but the presence or absence of the enzyme. In a corn plant with its elaborate transport mechanism for moving ions from the soil through the root and stalk to the leaf and its long growing season with varying periods of rapid and slow growth, opportunity for expression of genes which affect NR indirectly or which mask the direct effects of genes for NR activity is many times that in microorganisms. The complement of genes affecting NR in corn therefore must be much more complex than that in microorganisms. Even in microorganisms, several Ioci have been found which can bIock production of NR. Cove and Pateman (1963) found mutants at six different loci, in at least four different linkage groups, which blocked the production of NR in Aspergillus nidulans (Eidam ) Winter. Sorger and Giles ( 1965) found mutants at four different loci which blocked production of NR in Neurospora crassu (Shear.) Dodge. Only a few mutants, each of which could utilize NO,- as a source of nitrogen, were evaluated. In both organisms, mutants which required NH,” in the medium were also found. The complete absence of NR in actively growing corn plants has not been demonstrated. This reflects the fact that NO3- is the major source of nitrogen available to plants when grown in soil. In addition, the corn material studied has been selected for its ability to produce well under a high NO3- regime. Differences in the ability of lines to grow on media having NH,” as the sole source of nitrogen have been demonstrated ( Harvey, 1939). Recent unpublished work in this laboratory indicates that certain corn mutant genotypes show more growth when nitrogen is supplied as NH,’ than when supplied as NO,-. At present, it is not possible to use the simple techniques available to the microbial geneticist to study genetics of NR in corn. However, further evaluation of divergent germ plasms under carefuliy controlled environmental conditions might make such studies feasible. Seasonal patterns of NR vary with genotype (Fig. 10).Two lines may differ widely in NR at certain times during the active growing season whereas at other times there may be no difference in activity. Lack of differences in activity late in the season may be attributed to the beginning of senescence in the plant; i.e., the grain or product is formed and the “factory” is turned off. Differences between the same lines early in the season may be amenable to genetic interpretation. A realistic understanding of the genetic mechanisms controlling NR will require study
71
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
of segregating populations at a particular time in the life cycle of the plant, and perhaps at several different times. The consistent “heterotic” level of NR activity in the hybrid B14 X Oh43 indicates that the two inbreds showing similar levels of NR may differ in genes responsible for this activity. Unpublished results from our laboratory demonstrate that genetic segregation occurs in the F, and backcross populations from B14 x Oh43. F, populations studied
5 g O c I l +. e n
I
I
1
F
1
1
1
1
1
Miscellaneous
,L-L-2 5 30 June
I
1
10 July
I
I
20
30
1
I
4
L 9
U 13
18 24
August
FIG.10. Seasonal patterns of nitrate reductase activity of groups of corn inbreds. WF9 and related inbreds exhibited similar patterns while the inbreds of divergent origin exhibited unrelated patterns ( Zieserl and Hageman, 1962 ).
showed a range in NR from the level of the F, down to the level of the lower parent. These data are not yet adequate to determine the mode of inheritance of NR, but some evidence suggests that very few loci (perhaps two to three) may be involved in the differences-at least at certain developmental stages. Though the details of the genetic mechanism controlling NR in corn are unclear, enough is known to put together hybrids of known levels of NR if this is desirable. As pointed out previously, growth (or yield) is the end result of a complex series of chemical reactions any one of which
72
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
may be limiting, The data presented make it clear that NR activity level can be controlled by genetic manipulation to the extent that NR need not be a limiting factor in nitrogen metabolism in corn.
V. Specific Chloroplast
Activity
The importance of light as a major environmental control on nitrate reductase activity, and consequently on nitrogen metabolism, has been stressed in the preceding section. Nitrate reduction, like the reduction of "fixed" CO, is indirectly related to light in that both reactions utilize chemical energy produced by the chloroplasts from light energy. Since light is the sole primary source of energy for plants, a comparison of the light-converting enzyme system of the chloroplasts ( Arnon et ul., 1958) from corn inbreds and their progeny should be of signal importance. Because standard techniques (Arnon et al., 1954; Jagendorf and Avron, 1958) would not permit the isolation of chloroplasts active in photophosphorylation (chemical energy generation) from corn leaf tissue, it was necessary to develop special isolation procedures (Miflin and Hageman, 1963). Three assays, Hill reaction, noncyclic and cyclic photophosphorylation, were used to estimate the conversion of light energy to chemical energy by the corn chloroplasts. Comparable evaluations of chloroplast activity were obtained by each method. Therefore the simplest assay (cyclic photophosphorylation ) was used to evaluate the chloroplast activities of five corn inbred lines (WF9, R151, R177, R181, and Oh43) and seven F, hybrids-counting reciprocals-among these lines ( Miflin and Hageman, 1966). Objectives were ( 1 ) to determine whether chloroplasts isolated from the different inbreds and hybrids differed in activity, and ( 2 ) to determine whether heterosis was manifested in chloroplast activity. The essential data from studies of the inbred lines are summarized in Table 11. It is apparent that the lines differed markedly in ability to convert light energy into chemical energy, per unit of chlorophyll. One line, R151, had a significantly higher level of cyclic photophosphorylative activity than the other four. Another inbred, WF9, was consistently the lowest in activity. The other three lines showed intermediate levels. These findings are of particular interest because the same inbreds had been evaluated for nitrate reductase activity, also shown in Table 11. As may readily be seen, R151 was the only inbred ranking similarly (high) for both activities. WF9, with the lowest chloroplast activity, was moderately low in nitrate reductase activity. Two of the other three lines were low in nitrate reductase activity and medium for cyclic photophosphorylation activity. R181, also intermediate for cyclic photophosphoryla-
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
73
tion, had a high level of nitrate reductase activity. This comparison clearly illustrates the expected situation, i.e., a given inbred line is likely to be high in activity of some enzymes, low in others, and intermediate in yet others. The relationships between inbred lines and their F, hybrids for cyclic photophosphorylation were much like those observed in the nitrate reductase work. No “heterotic effects” on chloroplast activity were observed. In the three hybrids studied, no significant differences between reciprocals were found. Cyclic photophosphorylation activity of the hybrids was essentially intermediate between the parental values. In TABLE I1 A Comparison of Five Corn Inbreds with Respect to Chloroplast (Cyclic-Photophosphorylation) and Nitrate Reductase Activity Inbred
Chloroplast activity’
Nitrate reductase activityb
345 317 240 220 168
0.71 0.28 0.22 0.66 0.34
~
R151 R177 Oh43 R181 WF9 ~~
~~
~
Micromoles of phosphate esterified per milligram of chlorophyll per hour. b Micromoles of nitrite produced per milligram of protein per hour. Data presented are the average of several assays.
WF9 X R151 (“low” X “high) and WF9 X R181 (“low” X “intermediate”) the cyclic photophosphorylation of the hybrid was not significantly different from the mid-parent values. In R151 X R177 ( ‘ I i g h X “medium-high”), the F, value was significantly lower than the midparent, and in fact was slightly lower than that of R177, the lower of the two parents ( Miflin and Hageman, 1966). From studies of the three major metabolic systems (i.e., energy transfer in seedling growth, nitrate reductase and nitrogen metabolism, and energy generation by chloroplasts) it is apparent that genetic variability is indicated by divergent levels of enzymatic activity. From the comparisons of inbreds and F, hybrids for activities of the various enzymes, it is obvious that heterotic activity levels are the exception-not the rule. In addition, preliminary characterization of the enzymes studied in two of the three systems failed to show qualitative differences between enzymes of the parents and hybrids. Other recent investigations have reported the occurrence of qualitative differences between enzymes of corn inbreds and hybrids. The implications of these findings are presented in Section VI.
74
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
VI.
Some Recent Developments in Plant Biochemistry Related to Heterosis
Schwartz ( 1960) reported the occurrence of qualitatively different esterases in developing corn seeds and seedlings. Starch-gel electrophoresis and stain techniques were used to separate and identify three forms (isozymes) of a basic protein with esterase activity. The substrate was a-naphthyl acetate, a nonspecific, nonmetabolic ester. According to Schwartz, three allelic genes, EF, EN, and ES, specified a single esterase in homozygous plant material, The three esterases were identifiable on the starch gel (pH 8.6) by their rate of migration toward the cathode, and were designated F, N, and S, respectively. Crosses made between homozygous plants gave heterozygotes that exhibited both parental enzyme types und a new “hybrid”enzyme. The hybrid enzyme migrated on the starch gel at a rate intermediate between those of the two parental types. It was suggested that the new enzyme was a dimer which was formed by random association of the monomers specified by each allele. In Schwartz’s (1960) initial paper, it was postulated that these hybrid esterases would be more active in metabolic transformation than the enzyme types of the parental lines. The formation of hybrid enzymes in general then would be a factor in hybrid vigor. While this concept is attractive, it is not necessary for the enzymes in the hybrid plant to exhibit a higher level of activity than their inbred parents for yield heterosis to occur. In a subsequent paper, (Schwartz, 1964), it was reported that the new (hybrid) enzyme found in maize plants heterozygous for the two allelic E, genes was synthesized as a dimer. Separation of the dimer into its monomeric units was not reported. Further, the hybrid enzyme did not appear to be formed by random association of two monomers. Schwartz ( 1962a) hypothesized a random interaction between messenger-RNA molecules specified by the two alleles, to permit the synthesis of the hybrid enzyme on the ribosome. Subsequent examination of the esterase band patterns on the starch gel after electrophoresis of extracts from selected and crossed corn and teosinte plants has permitted Schwartz et al. (1965) to conclude that there are seven alleles of the El gene. When tissue containing homozygous El alleles was treated in vivo with sodium borohydride, multiple forms of the esterase were detectable in the extract (Schwartz, 1964). Based on band positions, the new forms of the esterase were more negative in charge than the esterase from comparable untreated tissue. These new forms of the esterase, resulting from the borohydride treatment, were similar in charge (migration rate) to other naturally oc-
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
75
curring forms of the enzyme (allodimers and autodimers) specified by the various other alleles. I n vitro treatment with glyceraldehyde of various forms of the esterases derived from the El gene converted all isozymes having varying net charges, as indicated by band locations on to starch gel, to a single form with a common net charge, as indicated by a single-band location on the starch gel (Schwartz, 1962b). All treated isozymes were converted to a more acidic form, and all migrated to the anode (+) at identical rates. Most ( 6 of 7 ) of the isozymes prior to treatment were basic in nature and migrated toward the cathode ( - ). The glyceraldehyde treatment did not cause any appreciable inactivation of the E, esterases. A partially purified esterase preparation incubated with 0.2 M glyceraldehyde at 37°C. for 24 hours retained 96 percent of the activity of a glyceraldehyde-free control as measured by cleavage of a-naphthyl acetate. Essentially full activity was retained by the enzyme during the full conversion from a basic to an acidic protein by the glyceraldehyde treatment. This encompasses many of the charged forms exhibited by the various isozymes. Does this mean that the minor changes in charge, which constitute the only known difference among the various isozymes or hybrid forms, do not cause alteration in metabolic activity?” Recently Kitto et al. (1966) using tissue from chickens, demonstrated multiple forms of mitochondria1 malate dehydrogenase by electrophoretic patterns. Because it was not possible to detect differences in catalytic properties or in amino acid composition among the various forms, the term “conformers” was proposed for enzymes with these characteristics. The work of Fincham (1962) illustrates a divergent case. The TPN-linked glutamic dehydrogenase of Neurospora crassa is specified by the am locus. Thirteen different mutations of the am locus have been observed and the enzymes resulting from these mutations exhibit great variation in catalytic activities and characteristics including digerential response to temperature. In spite of these differences, all the enzymes separate in a similar manner during purification, are indistinguishable on starch gel electrophoresis, and some of the different forms exhibit similar “fingerprints” after tryptic digestion. It is obvious that both qualitative and quantitative measurements are required to obtain maximum understanding of these complex systems. Form or type of enzyme becomes important only when it effects a favorable change (either increasing or decreasing) in rate of substrate conversion (total enzyme activity) with respect to the metabolic needs of the organism. Since it is conceivable that one form of enzyme specified by a homozygous locus might be metabolically adequate only under a
76
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
limited range of environmental conditions, the increased number of enzyme forms associated with a heterozygous locus could be a causal factor in hybrid vigor. For corn, this concept must be accepted with reservations until additional characterizations of the enzymes specified by heterozygous loci have been obtained. Even for fungi, Fincham and Day (1965) state that many questions remain to be answered concerning the observation that “sometimes a pair of alleles in a heterocaryon is abIe to promote the formation of an enzyme when neither allele could do so alone.” They point out that the enzyme formed by interallelic complementation is ( a ) low (25 percent of normal or less) in activity, and ( b ) usually qualitatively abnormal with respect to the wild-type form. In addition, an active enzyme can be formed in certain cases by mixing crude extracts or purified proteins from separate strains which exhibit complementation, under conditions not conducive for protein synthesis. From these observations it has been postulated that the active enzyme is composed of two or more subunits. The subunits are specified by each allele, and when the alleles are both wild-type the normal enzyme is formed. If two different mutant alleles are present, both protein subunits are abnormal and most dimers (or multiunit enzymes) formed are inactive enzymes; however, a small number of subunits may unite in such a way that the deficiencies are masked ( complementation) and an active enzyme results. Beckman, et at?. (1964a) recently have demonstrated the existence of four different molecular forms of leucine aminopeptidase in maize endosperm by starch-gel electrophoresis techniques. Each enzyme appears to be controlled by a pair of alleles without dominance. In a similar study with corn endosperm tissue, the same workers found ( Beckman et al., 1964b) three “hybrid catalase enzymes with migration rates on starch-gel electrophoresis intermediate between their respective parental enzymes. Their observations suggested that the enzyme might be a tetramer. Supplemental work by Scandalios (1965) indicated the occurrence in a single corn inbred of tissue-specific isozymes. Several different forms (isozymes) were noted for each of the following enzymes: leucine-amino-peptidase, esterase, catalase, and peroxidase. The various isozymes were detected and described only by starch-gel electrophoresis and staining techniques. The function of these four enzymes in differentiation and development of the corn plant is not known. It is the authors’ opinion that the observations of Schwartz, Scandalios, Beckman, and Brewbaker are of great interest and importance. Work of this type presently provides the best approach to the biochemical understanding of interallelic and intergenic complementa-
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
77
tion. The proposition that many enzymes are composed of aggregates of subunits, and that these protein subunits are specified by the individual alleles, permits a logical explanation of variation in metabolic activity of corn inbreds and their hybrids. It is also obvious from the work of Kitto et al. (1966) and Fincham (1962) that the qualitative separation of enzymes needs to be supplemented by extensive quantitative evaluations. With respect to agronomic production, the authors strongly believe that such qualitative and quantitative evaluations need to be continued throughout the life of the plant. The interaction of genotype with environment is dynamic, and a valid conclusion reached in growth chamber studies may not be true under field conditions. The complexities of metabolism preclude a single factor from being the universal underlying cause of hybrid vigor. Yet in certain cases a single enzyme, hormone, vitamin, or growth factor could be solely responsible for the enhanced growth rate of a hybrid. Where such cases have been found, the experiments usually have been of short duration and have not extended over the life cycle of the plant. The work reported by Robbins (1940, 1941b) serves to illustrate this single-factor concept. In these experiments, separate extracts from equal weights of grain from two corn inbreds and their two progenies were added to a standard minimal medium used for culturing Phycomyces blakesleeaniu Burgess. When added to the media, extracts from the hybrid seeds essentially doubled the mycelial growth over that obtained with extracts from the inbred seeds. Extracts from seeds of the two corn inbreds did not enhance mycelial growth over that of the basal medium. The growthstimulating factor in the hybrid seeds was never fully identified. In a similar experiment two decades later, Matskov and Manzyuk (1961) reported that extracts of hybrid seed, seedlings of leaf tissue stimulated the growth of yeast more than comparable extracts from the parental material. Mixtures of extracts from appropriate inbred material invoked the same growth effect on the yeast as did the extracts of hybrid progeny. In some instances (four of eighteen) no differences were observed between inbreds and their progeny. The causal factor was reported to be a mixture of B vitamins. No difference was observed in auxin content of the inbreds and hybrids tested. These results are in general agreement with the nutrient supplement work of Robbins ( 1941a), who used excised hybrid and inbred tomato root cultures. The addition of pyridoxine to the minimal basal nutrient stimulated the root growth of one of the parental inbreds, whereas nicotinamide had no effect. The converse was true for the second inbred. The root growth of the hybrid was superior in all cultures. Sinkovics (1963) analyzed various plant parts of two corn inbreds
78
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
and their F, progeny for vitamins of the B group (biotin, thiamine, pyridoxine, pantothenic acid, and nicotinic acid). Except for thiamine, the hybrid contained a much higher quantity of these B vitamins. Hormones are single components that could exert manifold effects on metabolic systems and metabolism, Key (1964) reported that 2,4-D ( a synthetic auxin) enhanced the rate of cell elongation of excised soybean hypocotyl tissue. Cell elongation in turn is dependent upon nucleic acid and protein synthesis. Apparently 2,4-D enhances the formation of specific nucleic acids. Varner (1964) and Varner and Chandra, 1964) have shown that gibberellic acid causes the de w v o synthesis of a-amylase in the aleurone layer of half barley seeds. As important and exciting as these results are, it is still extremely difficult to know how to extrapolate and adapt these findings to the selection of genetic material with optimum hormonal balance throughout the life of the plant. The complexities and difficulties involved are indicated by Wright ( 1961, 1966). His data demonstrate that growth responses to exogenous gibberellic acid and kinetin were greatest in young excised wheat coleoptiles (18 to 78 hours after sowing). In contrast, exogenous indolyl-3-acetic acid exerted little effect on growth until the coleoptiles were much older (30 to 42 hours ) . Gibberellic acid and kinetin effects could be separated by alteration in temperature. It is also quite probable that at certain developmental stages hormones will exert synergistic effects and at other stages antagonistic action (Van Overbeek, 1962). McDaniel and Sarkissian (1966) reported that at 1:1 mixture of mitochondrial preparations from seedlings or scutella of two corn inbreds as well as the mitochondrial preparations from the hybrid (WF9 x C103) showed heterosis with respect to respiration and oxidative phosphorylation. In a second case, using the “hybrid Oh43 x Oh45 which does not show heterosis with respect to growth, no heterosis was observed with the hybrid mitochondrial preparation or from mixing preparations from the two respective inbreds. Interpretation of these comparisons is complicated by the fact that the “hybrid Oh43 x Oh45 actually is a cross between two very closely related inbred lines, and in fact is essentially similar to an inbred. It is not known whether the heterotic response with the WF9 C103 and WF9 x C103 material is attributable to a single chemical compound or to a complementation of enzymes. The latter alternative would appear to be quite complex. Sarkissian and Huffaker (1962) reported that a barley hybrid (Kk) derived from essentially isogenic parents, exhibited heterosis in seedling growth (weight) and ability to fix CO, via the ribulose-diphosphatecarboxylase pathway. The greater fixation of CO, could be correlated
+
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
79
with heterosis. In contrast there was no difference among these same three genotypes with respect to ability to fix CO, by the phosphoenolpyruvic carboxylase system. Thus, hybrid vigor was not found to be associated with a general stimulation of all enzymes involved in metabolism. The ability of the hybrid to fix CO, by the ribulose diphosphate pathway was greater (0.37 DS 0.26 pmoles of CO, fixed per gram fresh weight per hour) prior to and during the first 10 hours of illumination than either parental line. The hybrid apparently reached a maximum rate of CO, fixation after 10 hours. During the subsequent 14 hours of illumination, the difference in fixation rate between hybrid and parents gradually decreased, although the rate of CO, fixation by the hybrid was still greater than that of either parent at the end of the experiment. This advantage of the hybrid is stressed because it suggests that the hybrid has the ability to shift its metabolism more rapidly in response to changes in environment, and to regulate the output of specific systems to the needs of the whole system. Perhaps the parental lines ( K K and kk) in time would have attained or even exceeded the maximum rate of CO, fixation exhibited by the hybrid, even though they could not compensate for their initial disadvantage. This work (Sarkissian and Huffaker, 1962) suggests that studies of changes in enzyme activity or enzyme synthesis in response to changes in environment would permit an evaluation of the efficiency of the complex system of protein synthesis among an array of inbreds and their progeny and varieties. Under field conditions, corn hybrids customarily appear able to adapt readily to changes in environment. A change in environment would undoubtedly alter the enzyme complement, which then would alter metabolism. Rapidity of response to an environmental change, as reflected by the rate of synthesis of the needed enzyme, should be a highly desirable attribute. For precise studies, the initial level of enzyme (or other component) of inbreds and hybrids should be equal, and should be expressed on some unit of measure other than plant size. In the work with barley (Sarkissian and Huffaker, 196Z), the initial rate of CO, fixation (cpm/O.l ml) just prior to illumination was twice as high for the hybrid as for the parental lines. Based on the initial values, the rate of increase of CO, fixation was the same for inbreds and hybrids during the first 10 hours, and greater increases were exhibited by the inbreds in the subsequent 14-hour period. Some attempts have been made in our laboratories to utilize the induction and synthesis of nitrate reductase as a tool for evaluation of corn inbreds and hybrids. Corn seedlings grown on a medium devoid
80
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
of nitrate contain negligible amounts of nitrate reductase. The enzyme can then be induced in detectable amounts in the shoot tissue within a few ( 2 to 4) hours (Beevers et al., 1965). Initially, light was thought to be involved in the induction process, but subsequent work indicated that light was more directly involved in uptake and movement of nitrate to the site of induction (Beevers et al., 1965). Whole-plant induction studies measure not only the ability of the inbred or hybrid to synthesize nitrate reductase, but also its ability to absorb and transport nitrate. In subsequent work the effects of light and the root absorption and translocation process were eliminated by floating the cotyledon or excised young corn seedling in a medium containing nitrate. Since nitrate reductase is substrate inducible (Tang and Wu, 1957; Hewitt and Afridi, 1959), and since the rate of nitrate reductase synthesized is initially dependent upon the amount of nitrate present (Beevers et al., 1965)) the amount of enzyme formed in a given time per milligram of tissue or protein should also be expressed as a function of the nitrate present in the tissue. Preliminary data obtained with the hybrid Hy2 X Oh7 and its parental inbreds have not shown a consistent advantage for either inbred or progeny in induction of enzyme or uptake of nitrate. Currently, plans are underway to expand this study to an array of inbreds and hybrids. Since the rate of induction of an enzyme measures the apparent ability of the plant to mobilize and direct the complex system involved in protein synthesis, this measurement of induction rates may be useful for genetic selection. VII.
A Concept for the Future
From a practical agronomic viewpoint, hybrid vigor in corn and other crop plants is expressed phenotypically as the production of greater amounts of pIant tissue, grain, or derived products. Obviously, then, the hybrid forms exhibit greater growth than their inbred parents. Since differences in “initial capital” do not explain the heterotic effects observed, these effects must result primarily from a higher rate of growth. In turn, since growth is the product of metabolism (biochemical reactions), heterosis must be manifested either in increased rates of metabolic reactions or in a more efficiently organized metabolic system, Increased reaction rates are most likely to be achieved by enchanced enzyme activity, since nearly all important metabolic reactions are catalyzed by enzymes. Enhanced activity must result from either ( a ) the presence of more enzyme at the reaction site, or ( b ) more efficient (qualitatively different) enzymes or enzyme systems. Although there are some exceptions, most of the data now available
81
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
do not support the concept of either ( a ) more enzyme, or ( b ) more efficient systems. This suggested that the enzymes and enzyme systems are more efficiently organized as a whole in the hybrid. FENDERS
FENDERS
L,,J 10 LEFT DOORS
I
10 RIGHT DOORS
t
ID LEFT FENDERS
10 RIGHT FENDERS
L m J 14 LEFT DOORS
6 RIGHT
10 RIGHT FENDERS
10 LEFT FENDERS
L n J 10 LEFT DOORS
10 RIGHT
LOUT L,,YS t
v
Production / hr. 4 Cars ASSUME EACH LINE HAS THE SAME AMOUNT OF STEEL. AND THAT EQUAL AMOUNTSOFSTEELARE USEDFOR DOORS AND FENDERS.
FIG. 11. Diagrammatic analogy to illustrate the need for balance of systems and integrated control of these systems. (Note: The word “fender” is defined as that part of the body that covers the wheels.)
In this connection it may be useful to visualize how closely a plant and its metabolic system resemble a modern, completely automated industrial factory (Fig. 11). Comparable parts or systems could be considered as: Factory
Plant
Automated machines tf Enzymes or enzyme systems Competition for doors and fenders tf Competition for energy and metabolites Assembly lines tf Metabolic pathways Computerized control c-f Environmental and hormonal control
In a factory, the size of the building may, but need not, indicate the rate or total of production. The rate and total production depends on the efficiency of the individual machines, and on the properly coordinated rates of operation of all machines in all assembly lines. Flow lines 1 and 2 (left to right) of Fig. 11 could, given time, reconvert components and produce 5 cars, but not within the prescribed time. As with the factory, the initial size of a plant or its meristem cannot be the basic cause of hybrid vigor. Rather, this cause must lie in the efficient and timely operation of the individual enzymes and in the proper balance and integration of the enzymatically catalyzed metabolic systems. To be sure, a larger plant, tissue, or cell may confer certain advantages to the metabolic system through providing greater amounts of needed “raw products.” Without greater efficiency of metabolism,
82
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
however, such enhanced supply could be useless or actually detrimental to metabolism as a whole. From current knowledge of metabolism and the simple analogy of the “factory” operation a possible biochemical explanation of heterosis can be developed. Admittedly, present evidence is not sufficient to fully clarify this complex situation. However, the consistent finding that highly heterotic ( in growth and yield) hybrids are usually intermediate between their parental inbreds in activity levels of important metabolic enzymes is significant. It is clear that major metabolic processes as a whole tend to be limited in rate by the least efficient (or slowest) reaction involved. Obviously, then, every highly homozygous inbred parent must have some important reactions which are severely limited in rate; i.e., in these lines, there must be serious gene-controlled shortcomings in function of major enzyme systems. While it seems most logical to assume that these shortcomings are deficiencies in function, it is also possible that they represent higher-than-optimum levels of enzyme activity, leading to repressive levels or detrimental competition for certain metabolites. In any event, it is clear that the highly heterozygous hybrid possesses a more favorable genetic constitution for overall enzymatic efficiency than does either of its parents. This suggests the following possible situations: 1. Gene action in the control of major metabolic enzymes is usually not complete dominance-i.e., the heterozygote is usually intermediate between the homozygous parents in enzyme activity. 2. The “intermediate” level of enzyme activity found in hybrids is adequate for most major metabolic processes, and may actually be more effective for overall metabolism than a higher level. 3. One “dose” of a gene-a single favorable allele-is sufficient for a satisfactory level of function of the enzyme it controls. 4. Allele “A” may specify one enzyme, allele “a” a different enzyme; thus, the hybrid could possess both enzymes or enzyme forms, The most likely explanation of the heterosis phenomenon rests on the fact that the hybrid between two inbred parents is likely to have a better-balanced metabolic system. The inbred lines, on the other hand, having had their genetic complements rapidly and effectively fixed by inbreeding, tend to have unbalanced systems, with some enzymes controlled at high levels, some at medium levels, and some genetically limited to low or ineffective levels of activity. The fact of linkage, resulting from the presence of only 10 pairs of chromosomes adds a complicating factor to the inbreeding situation since “favorable” and “unfavorable” genes may be tightly linked,
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
83
Utilization of these ideas in a planned breeding program is still almost completely in the realm of theory. Yet, if the assumptions set forth above are valid, they point the way toward the development of highly efficient selection techniques. The first and most important step is to work out the fundamental metabolic systems involved in growth and yield. Of particular importance is the determination of the major enzymatic controls involved in these processes, and, particularly, the optimum levels of activity of each such enzyme in combinations with specified levels of the other enzymes. When this information is available, breeding material can be screened for activity levels of the various enzymes. Simple inheritance studies can then be conducted, optimum combinations of levels of activity can be identified and assembled through proper genetic combination. The resulting hybrid material can be expected to give superior performance. The results from studies of nitrate reductase provide an example of the possibilities of such a breeding approach. Enough is already known about genetic diversity and hereditary patterns of NR activity to create hybrids with specified NR activity levels. If other major metabolic systems can be as accurately evaluated as NR activity, it should be much easier to screen breeding material efficiently and to produce desirable combinations than is now possible where yield testing in the field is the major selection tool. ACKNOWLEDGMENT
One of us (RHH) wishes to express his appreciation to Professor John Grafius for his encouraging comments and actions and to Professor 0. T. Bonnett for his interest and counsel. It is gratefully acknowledged that without the assistance and contributions of Leonard Beevers, Donna Flesher, Almut (Gitter) Jones, J. W. Kniprneyer, J. F. Zieserl, Jr., David M. Peterson, and L. E. Schrader this manuscript could not have been written. This work has been supported by National Science Foundation Grants Nos. 1995, 4407, G 9862, GB 263, and GB 3750. REFERENCES Allard, R. W. 1960. “Principles of Plant Breeding,” pp. 485. Wiley, New York. Arnon, D. I., Allen, M. B., and Whatley, F. R. 1954. Nature 174, 394396. Arnon, D. I., Whatley, F. R., and Allen, M. B. 1958. Science 127, 1026-1034. Ashby, E. 1930. Ann. Botany (London) 44,457467. Ashby, E. 1932. Ann. Botany (London) 46,1007-1032. Beckman, L., Scandalios, J. G., and Brewbaker, J. L. 1964a. Genetics 50, $99-904. Beckman, L., Scandalios, J. G., and Brewbaker, J. L. 1964b. Science 146, 1174-1175. Beevers, L., Flesher, Donna, and Hageman, R. H. 1964. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 89, 453464. Beevers, L., Schrader, L. E., Flesher, Donna, and Hageman, R. H. 1965. Plant Physiol. 40, 691-698. Bonner, J., and Varner, J. E. (eds. ), 1965. “Plant Biochemistry,” 1054 pp. Academic Press, New York.
84
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND J. W. DUDLEY
Brenchley, W. E. 1920. Ann. A w l . Biol. 6, 211-244. Bruce, A. B. 1910. Science 32,627-628. Candela, M. I., Fisher, E. G., and Hewitt, E. J. 1957. Plant Physiol. 32, 280-288. Cove, D. J., and Pateman, J. A. 1963. Nature 198, 262-263. Crick, F. H. C. 1964. Proc. 6th Intern. Congr. Biochem. New York 33, 1091128. Davenport, C. B. 1908. Science 28,454455. Duncan, W. G. 1958. Agron. J. 50,82-84. Earley, E. B., Miller, R. J., Reichert, G. T., Hageman, R. H., and Seif, R. D. 1966. Crop Sci. 6, 1-7. East, E. M., and Hayes, H. K. 1912. U . S. Dept. Agr. Bur. Plant Ind. Bull. 243, 1-58. Filner, P. 1966. Biochem. Biophys. Acta 118,299-310. Fincham, J. R. S. 1962. J . Mol. Biol. 4,257-274. Fincham, J. R. S., and Day, P. R. 1965. “Fungal Genetics,” 2nd ed., 326 pp. Bartholomew Press, Dorking, England. Fowden, L. 1965. In “Plant Biochemistry” (J. Bonner and J. E. Varner, eds.), pp. 361-381. Academic Press, New York. Frisch, Leonora. 1961. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 26, 1 4 0 8 . Frisch, Leonora. 1963. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Qwnt. Bid. 28, 1 4 1 0 . Glass, B. 1958. In “The Chemical Basis of Development” (W. D. McEIroy and B. Glass, eds. ), pp. 855-922. Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore, Maryland. Gowen, J. W. (ed.), 1952. “Heterosis,” pp. 1-552. Iowa State College Press, Ames, Iowa. Groszmann, A., and Sprague, C. F. 1948. J. Am. SOC. Agr. 40,88-96. Hageman, R. H., and Flesher, D. 1960a. Plant Physiol. 35, 700-708. Hageman, R. H., and Flesher, D. 1960b. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 87, 203-209. Hageman, R. H., and Waygood, E. R. 1959. Plant Physiol. 34, 396-400. Hageman, R. H., Flesher, D., and Gitter, A. 1961. Crop Sci. 1, 201-204. Harvey, P. H. 1939. Genetics 24,437461. Henderlong, P. R., and Schmidt, R. R. 1966. Plant Physiol. 41, 1102-1105. Herskowitz, I. H. 1962. “Genetics,” pp. 1-466. Little, Brown, Boston, Massachusetts. Hesketh, J. P., and Musgrave, R. B. 196%.Crop Sci. 2, 311315. Hewitt, E. J., and Afridi, M. M. R. K. 1959. Nature 183, 57-58. Hull, F. H. 1952. In “Heterosis” (J. W. Gowen, ed.), pp. 451473. Iowa State College Press, Ames, Iowa. Ingle, J., Beevers, L., and Hageman, R. H. 1964. Plant Physiol. 39, 735-740. Jacob, F., and Monod, J. 1961. J. Mol. Biol. 3, 318-98. Jagendorf, A. T., and Avron, M. 1958. J . Biol. Chem. 231,277-290. Jones, D. F. 1918. Conn. Agr. Expt. Sta. Bull. 207,l-100. Keeble, F., and Pellew, C. 1910. J. Genet. 1,47-56. Key, J. L. 1964. Plant Physiol. 39,365-370. Kiesselbach, T. A. 1951. Am. Scientist 39,629-655. Kitto, G. B., Wassarman, P. M., and Kaplan, N. 0. 1966. PTOC.Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S. 56, 578-585. Knipmeyer, J. W., Hageman, R. H., Earley, E. B., and Seif, R. D. 1962. Crop Sci. 2,1-5. Lang, A. L., Pendleton, J. W., and Dungan, G. H. 1956. Agron. 1. 48, 284-289. Leng, E. R. 1954. Agron. J. 46,502-506. Leng, E. R. 1963. CropSci. 3,187-190.
A BIOCHEMICAL APPROACH TO CORN BREEDING
85
Lowry, 0. H., and Passonneau, J. V. 1964. J. Biol. Chem. 239,3142. McDaniel, R. G., and Sarkissian, I. V. 1966. Science 152, 1640-1642. McIlrath, W. 0. 1964. M.S. Thesis. Univ. of Illinois, Urbana, Illinois. Matskov, F. F., and Manzyuk, S. G. 1961.Plant Physiol. 8,65-70. Mehrotra, H. N. 1954. Ph.D. Thesis. Univ. of Illinois, Urbana, Illinois. Mifiin, B. J., and Hageman, R. H. 1963. Plant Physiol. 38,66-70. Miflin, B. J., and Hageman, R. H. 1966. Crop Sci. 6,185-187. Moss, D. M., and Stinson, H. T., Jr. 1961. Crop. Sci. 1, 416418. Moss, D. M., Musgrave, R. B., and Lemon, E. R. 1961. Crop Sci. 1, 83-87. Moyse, A. 1959. Plant Physiol. 6, 287-298. Passonneau, J. V., and Lowry, 0. H. 1962. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 7,lO-15. Pollard, E, C. 1965. Am. Scientist 53,437-463. Richey, F. D. 1950. Advan. Genet. 3,160-192. Richmond, T. R. 1951. Advan. Genet. 4,213-245. Robbins, W. T. 1940. Bull. Torrey Botan. Club 68, 565574. Robbins, W. T. 1941a. Bull. Torrey Botan. Club 68,222-228. Robbins, W. T. 1941b. Am. J. Botany 28,216-225. Sager, R., and Ryan, F. J. 1961. “Cell Heredity,” pp. 1 4 1 1 . Wiley, New York. Sarkissian, I. V., and Huffaker, R. C. 1962. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. US. 48, 735-743. Scandalios, J. G. 1965. J. Heredity 55, 281-285. Schimper, A. F. 1888. Botan. Ztg. 46,65-153. Schrader, L. E., and Hageman, R. H. 1965. Agron. Abstr. p. 30. Schrader, L. E., Peterson, D. M., Leng, E. R., and Hageman, R. H. 1966. Crop Sci. 6, 169-173. Schwartz, D. 1960. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S. 46, 1210-1215. Schwartz, D. 1962a. Genetics 52,1295-1302. Schwartz. D. 1962b. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U S . 48,750-756. Schwartz, D. 1964. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U S . 52,222-226. Schwartz, D., Fuchsman, Lucy, and McGrath, Katherine H. 1965. Genetics 52, 1265-1268. Shull, G. H. 1914. 2. (Induktive Abstammungs. Vererbungslehre 12, 97-149. Shull, G. H. 1952. I n “Heterosis” (J. W. Gowen, ed.) pp. 1 4 4 8 . Iowa State College Press, Ames, Iowa. Sinkovics, M. 1963. “Symposium on Maize Breeding and Production,” pp. 71-73. Agr. Res. Inst. Hungarian Acad. Sci. Martonvasar, Hungary. Sorger, G . J., and Giles, N. H. 1965. Genetics 52, 777-778. Stinson, H. T., Jr., and Moss, D. M. 1960. Agron. J. 52,482484. Stringfield, G. H. 1964. Advan. Agron. 16, 102-127. Tagawa, K., and Arnon, D. I. 1962. Nature 195,537-543. Tang, P. S., and Wu, H. Y. 1957. Nature 179, 1355-1356. Thomas, W. 1956. Agron. J. 48,228-229. Van Overbeek, J. 1962. Proc. Plant Sci. Symp. pp. 37-58. Campbell Soup Company. Varner, J. E. 1964. Plant Physiol. 39, 413415. Varner, J. E., and Chandra, G. R. 1964. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. US. 52, 100-106. Virtanen, A. I., and Rautanen, N. 1952. In “The Enzymes” (J. B. Summer and K. Myrback, eds.), Vol. 2, Part 2, pp. 1089-1108. Academic Press, New York. Watson, J. D. 1965. “The Molecular Biology of the Gene,” pp. 1 4 9 4 . Benjamin, New York. Whaley, W. G. 1944. Botan. Rev. 40,461-498.
86
R. H. HAGEMAN, E. R. LENG, AND
3.
W. DUDLEY
Whaley, W. G. 1952. In “Neterosis” ( J . W. Gowen, ed.), pp. 98-113. Iowa State College Press, Ames, Iowa. Wright, S. T. C. 1961. Nature 190, 699-700. Wright, S. T. C. 1966. J. Expptl. Botany. 17, 165-176. Zieserl, J. F., and Hageman, R. H. 1962. Crop Sci. 2, 512-515. Zieserl, J. F., Rivenbark, W. L., and Hageman, R. H. 1963. Crop Sci. 3, 27-32.
PRESERVATION OF SEED STOCKS Edwin James National Seed Storage Lobaratory, United States Department of Agriculture, Fort Collins, Colorado
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . 11. Theories Regarding Seed Deterioration . . . A. Depletion of Food Reserves . . . . . B. Changes in Protein Structure . . . . . C. Inactivation of Enzymes and Respiration . . D. Development of Fat Acidity . . . . . E. Mutagenic Effects . . . . . . . 111. Methods of Preserving Seeds . . . . . A. Effect of Climate . . . . . . . B. Control of Both Temperature and Humidity . C. Control of Humidity Only . . . . . D. Storage in Moistureproof Containers . . IV. The National Seed Storage Laboratory . . . A. Historical . . . . . . . . . B. Operation . . . . . . . . . C. Kinds of Seeds Stored . . . . . . D. Contributions to Scientists . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . I.
Page
.
.
.
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
.
.
. .
.
.
. .
.
. .
.
. . .
87
88 88 88
. .
89 91 . 91 . 94 . 94 . 95 . 98 . 99 . l o 1 , 1 0 1 . 102 . l o 3 .lo4 . l o 5
Introduction
From the time of his nomadic existence man has had the problem of maintaining harvested seeds for planting. Planters living in the temperate zone have fared better, in this regard, than those of the humid tropical areas of the world, Even now all peoples continue to depend on seed stocks for survival. Primitive peoples found that storage requirements for seeds to be planted were different from the requirements of seeds used for food. To have seed for the next crop, primitive man suspended his unthreshed crops from roofs to dry, later storing the dried seed in straw bags, baskets, earthenware jars, or pits. Some of these methods are still used in some of the undeveloped countries, Why seeds maintained higher viability under certain conditions was unknown until the beginning of plant science in the eighteenth century. Although some factors related to seed longevity became clear through 87
88
EDWIN JAMES
systematic research, the problem of seed deterioration remains to be solved. Longevity of seed of many species has been extensively reviewed by Crocker (1938, 1948), James ( 1961, 1963), and Owen (1956), as has the storage of seeds for food and feed by Anderson and Alcock (1954). I shall therefore not touch on these factors, but limit my discussion to preservation of germ plasm as seeds. First, however, an examination of some of the theories relating to seed deterioration is in order. II.
Theories Regarding Seed Deterioration
A. DEPLETION OF FOOD RESERVES The earliest theory concerning the loss of seed viability was based on the supposition that the food supply for the living embryo had been exhausted. This theory was abandoned because it soon became apparent that many dead seeds appeared perfectly sound and seemed to have had an ample supply of food reserves. Furthermore, some seeds having an abundance of reserve food deteriorate more rapidly than others with limited amounts. Seeds of Zea mays L. more than 700 years old, found in the Mesa Verde cliff dwellings, appear perfectly sound upon surface examination, but no viable seeds have ever been found among them. Oxley (1948) proposed that seed viability is lost when some undetermined, unstable organic compound in the seeds becomes exhausted. In more recent years Harrington (1960) reasoned that even though there are enough food reserves in seeds to ensure long life, the moisture content may be high enough to support respiration but too low to provide for the translocation of food materials to the embryo; as a result, the embryo dies. Although Harrington presented no data to support this theory, it may have some validity. I have found that excised embryos of snap beans and soybeans, stored at 70°F. and 70 percent relative humidity, had a shorter life than that of the intact seeds, The reason for the shorter life of the embryos was not determined, however. B. CHANGES IN PROTEIN Smucru~~ Ewart (1908) stated: “Longevity [of seeds] depends not on the food materials or seed coats, but upon how long the inert proteid molecules into which the living protoplasm disintegrates when drying, retain their molecular grouping which permits their recombination to the active protoplasmic molecules when the seed is moistened and supplied with oxygen.” No experimental evidence was presented to support this theory. With this reasoning, disintegration of proteid molecules should be excessive in seeds dried to very low moisture contents. Struve (1959), however, concluded that corn dried to 0 to 4 percent moisture, sealed with
PRESERVATION OF SEED STOCKS
89
nitrogen, and stored at low temperatures, would keep indefinitely. Also, Nutile (1964), when drying a number of crop seeds to moisture contents of 0.4 to 1 percent, and storing at room temperatures for 5 years, found some damage in seeds of celery, eggplant, carrot, pepper, tomato, and Kentucky bluegrass, Poa pratensis L., but in no case was viability completely lost. Seeds of cabbage, cucumber, lettuce, onion, and Highland bentgrass, Agrostis tenuis Sibth., were not injured during storage with moisture contents as low as 0.4 percent. Crocker (1938) suggested that the loss of seed viability is due to the coagulation of proteins. Later (1948) he stated: “This theory has the fault of being very general. There are many different kinds of proteins in the embryo, and this work does not throw any light on the particular proteins which coagulate with time. Furthermore, it throws no light on the possibility of the degeneration of some particular mechanism in the cell.” Crocker may have had in mind the possibility of chromosome disintegration, which has received much attention and will be discussed in a later section. OF ENZYMES AND RESPZRATION C. INACTIVATION
A number of attempts have been made to associate the decline of enzymatic activity with losses of seed viability. This approach raises the question of separating causes from effects. Only a few of the numerous enzymes in seeds have been investigated. Considering our limited knowledge of molecular biology, they are still a fruitful field of research. Perhaps the statement by Crocker, concerning the degeneration of some mechanism in the cell, could be interpreted in terms of DNA and RNA, upon which enzymatic reactions depend. Much of the early work with enzymes and respiration, as related to declines in viability, was limited with emphasis on catalase. Although Davis (1926) was able to show a relationship between a catalase ratio and viability in lettuce seeds, his observations did not cover a wide enough range to establish a linear relationship. Leggatt ( 1929-30) also obtained high correlations between catalase activity and germination of wheat, Triticum aestivum L. Crocker and Harrington (1918) found that catalase was active in seeds of Johnsongrass, Sorghum halepense L., that lost all viability, yet established a relationship with viability. No such relationship, however, could be established with seeds of Amaranthus retroflexus L. The relationship of catalase to seed viability is questionable. Results have not been consistent, and too few species have been investigated. The function and formation of catalase have not been clarified. Lantz (1927) concluded that there was no evidence that catalase was involved
90
EDWIN JAMES
in physiological oxidation. Rhine ( 1924) suggested that the catalase content of seeds is not stable but created as needed. Apparently phenolase activity is not an indication of viability. Davis (1931) found a relationship between phenolase and germination in wheat but not with age of seeds. On the other hand, the relationship in oats was with age but not with germination. In their report on the reduction of 2,3,5-triphenyltetrazolium by dehydrogenases, Thorneberry and Smith ( 1955) concluded: “Loss of viability appeared more closely related with respiratory failure in most seeds. Malic dehydrogenase activity was more closely correlated with germination percentage and respiratory capacity than the other two enzymes
FIG. 1. Relationship of glutamic acid decarboxylase (GADA) and germination in corn as affected by storage conditions. (From Grabe, 1964.)
( alcohol dehydrogenase and cytochrome dehydrogenase ) although considerable malic activity was retained by nonviable seeds. It is doubtful whether the inactivation of these three enzymes was a major cause of loss of viability.” A close relationship appears to exist between glutamic acid dicarboxylase and viability. This was demonstrated by Linko and Sogn (1960), Bautista and Linko (1962), and Grabe (1964). Figure 1 is taken from Grabe’s work to show this association. The 12 seed lots of corn used were under increasingly poor storage conditions, ranging from favorabIe for Lot 1 to very poor for Lot 12. The correlation coefficient for this relation-
PRESERVATION OF SEED STOCKS
91
ship was found to be 0.901. Germination decreases lag considerably behind decreases in the activity of the enzyme; Grabe interpreted this as evidence of incipient damage, particularly in the range of seed lots with higher germinations. Results seem to be related to the storage of corn under poor conditions. With the possible exception of glutamic acid decarboxylase, there appears to be no clear-cut evidence that enzymes can be used as an index of seed viability as affected by respiration. Yet, in storage, seeds do respire and finally lose viability. There is a strong possibility that the end products of respiration as mutagens have a lethal effect on seeds when stored under adverse conditions. A discussion of this theory follows in Section 11, E.
D. DEVELOPMENT OF FATACIDITY In some investigations the development of fat acidity in seeds has been shown to accompany losses of viability. It has been considered the cause of these losses. Holman and Carter (1952) associated losses of viability in soybeans with an increase in fat acidity. KeIly et at. (1942) found the same association in wheat, and Zeleny and Coleman (1939) in corn. With peanuts, however, Davis (1961) found that significant increases in fat acidity occurred only after the stored seeds had lost all viability. The literature on fat acidity indicates values as high in corn germinating 70 to 80 percent as in corn with 30 to 60 percent viability. Barton (1961) concludes her review of the fat acidity problem with the statement: “The fat acidity test has been applied to several hundred samples of sound and damaged grain with the result that it has been possible to establish fat acidity values for grain showing little or no deterioration. The obvious conclusion regarding fat acidity is that even though there is often an association with viability, the results are not consistent enough to use it as a reliable index of viability.” E. MUTAGENIC EFFECTS In recent years the theory that seed deterioration is due to the development of mutagens in stored seed has gained considerable acceptance. In aging seeds, mutations have been found in onion by Nichols (1941); in wheat, barley (Hordeum vulgare L. ), rye (Secale cereale L. ), and peas (Pisum sativum L.) by Gunthardt et al. (1953); in corn, by Pet0 (1933); in Crepis spp. by Navashin (1933); in Datum spp. by Blakeslee (1954); and in sugar beets by Lynes (1945). Observed aberrations include fusion, fragmentation, bridges, micro or giant nuclei, ring chromosomes, and others. Many examples of the effect of seed age on chromosome aberrations
92
EDWIN JAMES
could be given. The work of Gunthardt et al. (1953) will serve as an illustration (Table I). With the exception of 27-year-old seeds, the number of both chromosome bridges and fragments increases with age. The abnormally low germination of the 27-year-old seeds may have eliminated many seedlings in which abnormalities may have been present. A large increase in aberrations is evident in 32- and 33-year-old seeds. TABLE I Development of Chromosome Aberrations with Age in Baart Wheat" Chromosome aberrations Bridges
Fragments
Germination Age of seeds 1
11
17 21 26 27 32
Strong
Weak
Dead
SO 74 47 66
9 9 21 17 4 45
11
-
5 15
17 32 17 -
91 40
Total No. 21 -
30 101 40 222L
No./cell -
Total No.
No./cell
-
0.11
81 -
0.41
0.15 0.54 0.31 1.66b
143 212 141 465b
0.72 1.13 1.08 3.4Tb
-
-
Data from Gunthardt et al. (1953) Seeds 33 years old.
Numerous compounds are known to induce mutations, but most of these are not normally found in seeds. The review of D'Amato and Hoffinan-Ostenhof ( 1956) covers this subject quite thoroughly, and some of their citations may bear repeating. A number of compounds which can cause chromosome aberrations are given. Among those found in plants (and quoted by the preceding authors) are adenine; the degradation products of the nucleic acids adenine, uracil, thymine, and adenosine, which can act as chromosome-breaking agents; and even the nucleic acids themselves, deoxyribonudeic acid and ribonucleic acid. One explanation in regard to loss of seed viability given in the foregoing review is that accumulations of toxic materials in cells induce massive mutations in the embryonic tissue, preventing normal cell division. Attention has also been directed to the fact that in germinating seeds the first cells most often affected are in the root tips, which are the first to divide. This possibly accounts for the fact that abnormalities in germinating seeds are often found in the failure of root primordia to develop. Three degrees of mutagenic action are quoted by DAmato and Hoffman-Ostenhof (1956). They are as follows: (1) the lethal zone,
PRESERVATION OF SEED STOCKS
93
where the accumulations of mutagens become toxic, causing the death of seeds; (2) the narcotic zone, which results in the inhibition or destruction of the spindle mechanism; (3) the subnarcotic zone, in which mutations develop. In further support of the mutagenic theory are the following observations. (1) Extracts from aged seeds induce mutations in fresh seeds. ( 2 ) There is a gradual increase in mutations with age up to a point where there i s a rapid increase coincident with loss of viability. ( 3 ) Spontaneous mutations arising in dormant seeds become evident in the pre-split phase and in the development of mutations in the adult plant. (4) The difference in reaction of the shoot and root tips in aged seeds closely parallels the reaction of the same kind of seeds when treated with X-rays. There is no evidence that mutagens develop in seeds stored under favorable conditions. All observations in this respect have been made with seeds affected by high storage temperatures, humidities, or both. The classical work with the genus Datum by Blakeslee (1954) demonstrated that age of seeds was not alone responsible for the development of mutations. When seeds were stored at room temperatures, mutations in Datum did develop, but an extremely low frequency was found in plants grown from seeds buried in the ground for 39 years, where cool conditions apparently prevailed. The final answer to the question of the relationship of mutations to seed age may now repose in the National Seed Storage Laboratory at Fort Collins, Colorado, where highly favorable conditions for seed preservation exist. The answer will not be found in the immediate future, however, because storage conditions at the Laboratory are such that respiration in the stored seeds is near the minimum. The reasons proposed for seed deterioration, with the possible exception of fat acidity, are all related to respiration, which may be the primary cause with all others related thereto. Respiration increases in proportion to the amount of moisture in seeds but is extremely low in seeds with moisture contents between 4 and 11 percent, as reported by Bailey (1940) and Harrington (1963). Respiration rates up to approximately 50°C. are also directly proportional to temperatures. With high moisture contents and high temperatures, seed deterioration progresses at a rapid rate. At 90°F. and 90 percent relative humidity (R.H.), most seeds will have lost viability in 3 months. On the other hand, seeds stored at 50°F. or below, with a low R.H., will last indefinitely. Peanuts are recognized as poor keepers, yet I have stored peanuts at the Southern Regional Plant Introduction Station, Experiment, Georgia, for 8 years at 50°F. and 50 percent R.H. without a significant drop in germination.
94
EDWIN JAMES
The requirements for satisfactory seed preservation can apparently be attained in one of three ways, all of which inhibit respiration. We can store seeds in air with a low R.H., maintain seeds at low temperatures, or both. Harrington (1960) states that if the sum of the degrees F. and percent R.H. is 100 or less, conditions for long-time storage of seeds are good. He also states that the storage life of seeds is doubled for every 1 percent drop in seed moisture content or for each 10°F. drop in temperature. Ways of satisfying these conditions will be discussed in the next section. 111.
Methods
of Preserving Seeds
A. EFFECTOF CLIMATE Seed storage is more difficult in warm, humid climates than in areas of moderate temperatures and low humidities. Seed deterioration progresses rather slowly in the Western Great Plains and some of the intermountain regions of the United States. Such is the case, also, in some of the desert areas, where temperatures are often high and humidities extremely low. In a 10-year study of seeds stored under atmospheric conditions at Fort Collins, Colorado, Robertson and Lute (1937) reported viability losses of only 7 percent for wheat and 14 and 13 percent, respectively, for oats and barley. James et al. (1964) found that some vegetable seeds stored in an office at Cheyenne, Wyoming, had long life. The comparative lives of the species investigated are shown in Fig. 2. Many of the seeds tested had germinations of 80 to 90 percent after storage of 25 to 30 years. Differences in longevities of the various crops are apparent, but differences within species have additional implications. All the seeds were stored under identical conditions, and differences in longevities may be due either to cultural or processing factors preceding storage or to inheritance of longevity within species. There is considerable evidence that longevity of seeds is an inherited characteristic, but damage during processing is often the first stage in the degeneration of seeds. Moore (1963) concluded that damage to parts of the embryo accelerates respiration and that the accumulation of metabolites affects the surrounding tissue, resulting in the death of the seed. In some areas of the United States it is difficult to maintain seeds at high viabilities from one season to the next under ordinary shelf storage. Seed wholesalers have usually replaced year-old seeds on the merchants’ shelves with fresh stocks so that customers would receive seeds of high viability. More recently, however, commercial seed producers have marketed their seeds in moistureproof containers. The moisture contents of all seeds are dependent on the relative
PRESERVATION OF SEED STOCKS
95
humidities to which they are exposed. Moisture equilibria values for most seeds may be found throughout the literature. Tables I1 and 111 show " the most complete ones, taken from Harrington ( 1960).
s C 0 .+ 0
.-c
E L
W (r
W
0 0
L
W
>
a
FIG. 2. Viability of vegetable seeds stored in an office for 17 to 30 years at Cheyenne, Wyoming.
The type of seed storage will depend on the climate of the area in which the seeds are to be stored. An aerated room will suffice in some sections, whereas in others an elaborate, expensive installation will be required.
B. CONTROL OF BOTH TEMPERATURE AND HUMIDITY The most complicated and expensive method of preserving seeds is one in which both the temperature and humidity are maintained at low levels. In an installation of this kind, the storage room requires thorough moistureproofing and effective insulation. The construction of such a room has been explained in detail by Munford (1965). Equipment for maintaining low temperatures and humidities is dependent upon the size of the installation. A competent engineer should be able to specify proper equipment. A popular-type article by James (1962), however, would enable one to estimate his own requirements.
96
EDWIN JAMES
Most seeds will keep well if the temperature is maintained at 40°F. Air cooled to this temperature will have a high R.H., often above 75 percent, so some provision must be made to reduce the R.H. with which the seed moisture attains equilibrium. This can be accomplished by reducing the air temperature to a point below that required in the storage room and reheating it to the desired point. The lower temperaTABLE I1 Absorbed Moisture Content of Field Seed in Equilibrium with Air of Various Relative Humidities a t Room Temperature (Approximately 77"F.)a Relative humidity, percent Seed Barley Buckwheat Shelled corn, Yd Shelled corn, Wd Shelled corn, Pop Flaxseed Oats Peanut Rice, milled RYe Sorghum Soybeans Wheat, white Wheat, durum Wheat, soft red winter Wheat, hard red winter Wheat, hard red spring a
15
30
45
60
75
90
100
6.0b 6.7 6.4 6.6 6.8 4.4 5.7 2.6 6.8 7.0 6.4 4.3 6.7 6.6 6.3 6.4 6.8
8.4 9.1 8.4 8.4 8.5 5.6 8.0 4.2 9.0 8.7 8.6 6.5 8.6 8.5 8.6 8.5 8.5
10.0 10.8 10.5 10.4 9.8 6.3 9.6 5.6 10.7 10.5 10.5 7.4 9.9 10.0 10.6 10.5 10.1
12.1 12.7 12.9 12.9 12.2 7.9 11.8 7.2 12.6 12.2 12.0 9.3 11.8 11.5 11.9 12.5 11.8
14.4 15.0 14.8 14.7 13.6 10.0 13.8 9.8 14.4 14.8 15.2 13.1 15.0 14.1 14.6 14.6 14.8
19.5 19.1 19.1 18.9 18.3 15.2 18.5 13.0 18.1 20.6 18.8 18.8 19.7 19.3 19.7 19.7 19.7
26.8 24.5 23.8 24.6 23.0 21.4 24.1
-
23.6 26.7 21.9 26.3 26.6 25.6 25.0 25.0
Data from Harrington (1960).
r, Moisture content wet basis, in percent.
ture ranges of a psychrometric chart show that for approximately every 15°F. rise in temperature the humidity is reduced by one-half. If air leakage is disregarded, in which case the absolute amount of moisture in the room would remain constant, the initial refrigeration temperature would have to be about 25". If the R.H. at 25" is 75 percent, reheating the air to 40" would result in an R.H. of 38 to 40 percent. The additional heat is generally provided by electric heaters regulated by a humidistat. In the normal operation of an evaporator (refrigerating coil), frost accumulates on the fins and has to be removed at regular intervals. The defrosting schedule at the National Seed Storage Laboratory is every 4
97
PRESERVATION OF SEED STOCKS
hours in summer and every 6 hours in winter. The use of electric coils is probably the simplest of all defrosting methods. The foregoing is only a brief explanation of providing low temperatures coupled with low humidities, and I wish to emphasize that a novice TABLE I11 Approximate Moisture Content of Vegetable Seeds in Equilibrium with Air a t Different Relative Humidities at Room Temperature (Approximately 77°F.)" Relative humidity, percent Seed Bean, broad Bean, lima Bean, snap Beet, garden Cabbage Cabbage, Chinese Carrot Celery Corn, sweet Cucumber Eggplant Lettuce Mustard, leaf Okra Onion Onion, Welsh Parsnip Pea Pepper Radish Spinach Squash, winter Tomato Turnip Watermelon a
10
20
30
45
60
75
4.2" 4.6 3.0 2.1 3.2 2.4 4.5 5.8 3.8 2.6 3.1 2.8 1.8 3.8 4.6 3.4 5.0 5.4 2.8 2.6 4.6 3.0 3.2 2.6 3.0
5.8 6.6 4.8 4.0 4.6 3.4 5.9 7.0 5.8 4.3 4.9 4.2 3.2 7.2 6.8 5.1 6.1 7.3 4.5 3.8 6.5 4.3 5.0 4.0 4.8
7.2 7.7 6.8 5.8 5.4 4.6 6.8 7.8 7.0 5.6 6.3 5.1 4.6 8.3 8.0 6.9 7 .O 8.6 6.0 5.1 7.8 5.6 6.3 5.1 6.1
9.3 9.2 9.4 7.6 6.4 6.3 7.9 9.0 9.0 7.1 8.0 5.9 6.3 10.0 9.5 9.4 8.2 10.1 7.8 6.8 9.5 7.4 7.8 6.3 7.6
11.1 11.0 12.0 9.4 7.6 7.8 9.2 10.4 10.6 8.4 9.8 7.1 7.8 11.2 11.2 11.8 9.5 11.9 9.2 8.3 11.1 9.0 9.2 7.4 8.8
14.5 13.8 15.0 11.2 9.6 9.4 11.6 12.4 12.8 10.1 11.9 9.6 9.4 13.1 13.4 14.0 11.2 15.0 11.o 10.2 13.2 10.8 11.1 9.0 10.4
Data from Harrington (1960). Moisture content wet basis, in percent.
in seed storage should not attempt to design his own equipment. Even when the equipment is set up in consultation with a refrigeration engineer, the factor of humidity control should be emphasized. I have been contacted by many people regarding deficient equipment for humidity control, which had to be corrected with additional dehumidifiers.
98
EDWIN JAMES
C. CONTROL OF HUMIDITY ONLY Using the rule of thumb mentioned in Section 11, E, it should be possible to preserve seeds satisfactorily at 80°F. and 20 percent relative humidity. This can be accomplished through the control of humidity alone. In designing such a storage, special provisions must be made for the construction of the storage room. Insulation is unnecessary but an efficient moisture barrier to prevent the ingress of external air should be included in the structure, Otherwise, moisture will enter the storage area and dehumidification will be relatively ineffective. It is practically impossible, unless a storage room is hermetically sealed, to prevent air leakage, but it can be reduced to a minimum through the use of appropriate materials. The least expensive method of providing a moisture barrier in room construction is to coat the inside and outside walls with a good waterproofing paint. Ten-mil polyethylene of high density has good moisturebarrier properties and may be used as a lining or in the periphery of the construction. The joints should be heat-sealed where possible. Aluminum foil or foil laminated with paper could be used in place of polyethylene, but this would increase construction costs. The use of foil, correctly applied, would result in a room with almost the same moisture-barrier properties as a room lined with sheet metal. Also, the door or doors to the room would require adequate sealing. Rapid air changes through entrances can be minimized by the construction of a small anteroom entrance so that each door may be opened and closed in sequence. If the construction of the room is adequate, the moisture within can easily be reduced to the desired R.H. by using a silica gel dehumidifier. Dehumidifiers required to meet most needs can be determined through the use of a psychrometric chart. Figure 3 shows a portion of such a chart. The amount of moisture per pound of dry air for combinations of temperature and humidity is shown in grains at the right of the chart. If we assume that the initial condition of the room is 80°F. and 80 percent R.H., following the intersection of the dry bulb temperature and R.H. curve horizontally to the right (dotted line), we will find that there are approximately 124 grains (or 0.0177 pound) of moisture per pound of dry air (1grn. = 0.0001429 pound). Following the same procedure for 80" and 20 percent R.H., a pound of dry air will hold 30 grains (or 0.0043 pound) of moisture. Therefore, to reduce the R.H. to 20 percent, we will have to remove 94 grains (or 0.0134 pound) of moisture per pound of air. For estimation purposes, we may assume that a pound of dry air for the conditions being considered will occupy a volume of approximately 13.8 cu. ft., and the actual amount of moisture to be
99
PRESERVATION OF SEED STOCKS
removed will depend on the total cubic feet in the room. For example, a room 20 x 20 x 8 feet would have a volume of 3,200 cu. ft. The amount of moisture to be removed, to reduce the relative humidity from 80% to 20% at &O", would be 3.11 pounds (3200/13.8 x 0.0134). The 130
I20 110 L .-
a
70
100 ,"
9
e
90; a
; L
YI
?!
80
>
265 0 L
70
0
n
E
s
?
60;
L
50'i
n 360 m
el C
3
W
40
55
30
Dry Bulb T e m p e r a t u r e Degrees F:
FIG. 3. Psychrometric chart.
dehumidifier must be large enough to take care of this amount plus any leakage, which may amount to as high as ten complete air changes in 24 hours. Approximations for any set of conditions may be determined by folIowing this procedure. D. STORAGEIN MOISTUREPROOF CONTAINERS
In Section 111, A I mentioned that commercial seedsmen market their seeds in moistureproof containers. Some seedsmen use hermetically sealed cans and others use envelopes with moisture-barrier properties. Envelopes of this type are relatively inexpensive, are adaptable to the preservation of valuable seeds, and have the advantage of being reusable, which is not the case with hermetically sealed cans. The envelopes are easily sealed with heat after they are filled. The heat-seal may be cut off, a portion of the contents removed, and the envelopes resealed. Bass et al. (1961) and Harrington (1963) have reported on the types
100
EDWIN JAMES
of materials suitable for packaging seeds. Materials containing aluminum foil have been found superior. The foil is usually laminated with other materials to give added strength. The laminates may be polyethylenefoil-polyethylene, paper-foil-polyethylene, or similar combinations. Storing seeds in moistureproof containers may be disastrous if the seeds are not dry when enclosed. Moist seeds deteriorate more rapidly in closed containers than in ordinary envelopes. In our work at the TABLE IV Moisture of Seed Packaged
Family Gramineae
Liliaceae Chenopodiaceae Cruciferae
Leguminosae Umbelliferae Solanaceae Cucurbitaceae Compositae
Kind Sweet corn Kentucky bluegrass Creeping red fescue Perennial ryegrass Onion, leek, chive, Welsh onion Beet, chard Spinach Cabbage, broccoli, cauliflower, collards, Chinese cabbage, kale, turnip, rutabaga, kohlrabi, Brussels sprouts, mustard, radish Snap bean, lima bean, pea Crimson clover Carrot, celery, celeriac Parsnip Parsley Tomato Pepper Eggplant Cucumber, muskmelon, squash, pumpkin Watermelon Lettuce
Maximum percent seed moisture 8.0 6.0 3.0 8.0 6.5 7.5 8.0 5.0
7 .O 8.0 7.0 6.0 6.5 5.5 4.5 6.0 6.0
6.5 5.5
National Seed Storage Laboratory we have found that seeds with a high oil content, sealed with 7 percent moisture and stored at room temperature, do not maintain high viability, while those with 4 percent moisture store well. Starchy seeds, such as sorghum, have kept well for 4 years when sealed with 7 and 10 percent moisture. A complete listing of moisture limits for sealed seeds is not available, but a guideline for drying is given in Table IV, showing the requirements of the California Seed Law and Regulations.
PRESERVATION OF SEED STOCKS
101
Caution must be used when drying seeds. High drying temperatures will damage seeds with high moisture contents, and drying temperatures must be adjusted accordingly. Harrington (1960) gives the temperature limits for drying as follows: seeds with more than 18 percent moisture, 90°F; seeds with 10 to 18 percent moisture, 100"; seeds with less than 10 percent moisture, 110". Some seeds, when dried to 4 to 5 percent moisture, may exhibit an induced dormancy which results in slower germination even though viability is high. When exposed to a humid atmosphere, so that moisture is slowly absorbed, many of these apparently dormant seeds will germinate as readily as those with higher moisture contents. If we assume that the primary cause of seed deterioration is respiration, any of the three methods discussed would be effective in limiting this process. Advantages of each, however, are not equal. Cold storage with low humidity prevents the growth of fungus, and any insects present in the seeds become dormant and die. In sealed storage the accumulation of carbon dioxide in the container will kill insects in 1to 4 weeks, but some damage to the seed may have resulted by that time. Where humidity alone is controlled, it may be necessary to treat the seeds at intervals to prevent insect infestation. For small lots of seed composed of genetic collections or breeding lines, storage in moistureproof envelopes provides an inexpensive, dependable method of preservation. IV.
The National Seed Storage laboratory
A. HISTORICAL Since early colonial times the introduction of seeds from worldwide sources has added to the agricultural economy of our country. With very few exceptions the crops now grown in the Western Hemisphere originated in various parts of the Old World. A systematic method of numbering introductions began with the establishment of the U.S. Department of Agriculture as an executive department in 1898. Prior to 1898 no method of recording introductions was used, but since this date over 300,000 accessions have been introduced. Many of these have been lost, partially because of lack of foresight and also the absence of adequate storage facilities. Approximately two-thirds of the oats, 90 percent of the soybeans, and 98 percent of the clovers introduced into the United States are no longer in existence. This loss may not be serious, but it is possible that some very valuable germ plasm is no longer available to plant breeders. Plant introductions have contributed materially to the development of our improved varieties. From these introductions and through the
102
EDWIN JAMES
efforts of plant breeders, thousands of varieties, breeding lines, and genetic collections have resulted. A large portion of these has also disappeared because breeders often had no further interest in an old variety that had been superseded by a better one. Yet there is no assurance that a variety of breeding line having a poor rating under prevailing circumstances would not have value in the future as new races of pathogens develop. Potentially valuable breeding materials have often been stored in a haphazard manner on office shelves, in desk drawers, or in boxes in attics or basements, and eventually discarded.
FIG.4. Front view of National Seed Storage Laboratory.
Recognizing the inadequacy of seed preservation, the National Research Council in 1946 recommended the construction of a National repository for the preservation of valuable seeds. After 10 years of groundwork by representatives of Federal agencies, State Experiment Stations, and interested private concerns, justification for a National facility was presented to the Congress. Congress appropriated funds for the construction of the Laboratory, which began operations in the fall of 1958. A front view of the Laboratory is shown in Fig. 4. B. OPERATION The Laboratory is a three-level structure. The ground floor houses all the mechanical equipment. A standby compressor can be put into
PRESERVATION O F SEED STOCKS
103
operation to take over the refrigeration load of any other compressor that breaks down. A diesel generator provides current for essentials during prolonged power failure. The offices are on the second level and the germination laboratory and 11 cold storage rooms are on the third floor. The rooms in use are maintained at 40°F. and 32 percent R.H. Should lower storage temperatures be required, three rooms can be cooled to 10". The 11 rooms are stocked with approximately 180,000 tin cans with screw-type lids. The cans are not airtight but the exchange of air between the inside of the cans and room atmospheres is very slow and has no effect on the seed moisture content during short changes in the R.H. of the rooms. Steel is used for all seed trays and shelves to reduce fire hazards. To provide enough seeds for initial germination tests, periodic tests while in storage, and disbursement of seed, we prefer to store a minimum of 4,000 to 5,000 seeds of each accession. Where difficulties are encountered by the geneticist in obtaining large quantities of seed of certain genetic stocks, we reduce our requirements to 500 seeds and adjust our germination amounts and schedules accordingly. Only clean soeds of high viability are acceptable for storage. Once seeds are accepted, the Laboratory assumes responsibility for maintenance. Documentation or descriptions giving the agronomic or horticultural characteristics of the seed are required, These characteristics are entered on our punch cards to enable us to retrieve definite genotypes. If the seeds deteriorate while in storage, reincreases will be made through contracts with growers. The grower will be required to produce a new generation under isolation or by selfing or sibbing, depending on the method of species pollination. Germ plasm identical to the original seeds should still be in storage in future generations if we assume that no mutations occur during storage. C. KINDS OF SEEDSSTORED
Recommendations as to what constitutes valuable seeds have been made as a guideline for the Laboratory. It is recognized that such a definition will vary greatly depending upon the significance attached to the present commercial value of the crop involved and the individual research worker's evaluation, whether he be a geneticist, horticulturist, agronomist, or pathologist. However, the following categories of crop seeds are accepted by the Laboratory and are in accordance with the policy under which it operates: 1. New varieties: All newly released varieties, whether of private, public, or commercial origin, including reselections from varieties continuing in current use.
104
EDWIN JAMES
2. Current varieties: Varieties currently in use and under registration by respective crop group organizations, or otherwise documented as to specific origin and distinguishing characteristics. In this group would be included those varieties approaching obsolescence which might be superseded by new varieties. 3. Open-pollinated lines: Stocks representing earlier varieties or types of specific crops which have been or will be replaced in the commercial field by hybrids. 4. Inbred lines: Parental lines of known genetic composition widely used in combination for hybrid production. 5. Obsolescent germ plasm: Samples representing holdover material from earlier research programs and of no immediate interest. This could include varieties, selections, open-pollinated, inbred, and genetic stocks. 6. Plant introductions: These are stored at one of the Regional or Federal Introduction Stations and can be transferred to the Laboratory when their supplies exceed their working stocks or for which requests are no longer received. World collections fall within this group also. 7 . Pathological hosts: Varieties or lines used as differential hosts for the identification of pathogenic races or for the indexing of plant viruses. 8. Physiological lines: Seeds of plants used in physiological studies or physiological assays. 9. Mutants and genetic stocks: Samples regarded as highly valuable for genetic studies. 10. Indexing lines: Lines or varieties used for indexing plant viruses. Except for No. 8 and No. 10, samples of all the above categories are now in storage in the Laboratory. Anyone may submit seeds for storage, but once accepted by the Laboratory, the seeds become public property and are available to all bona fide research men upon request, provided they are not available elsewhere. The only exception to this rule is that in case a plant breeder wishes to protect his release, he can request a 5-year “freeze” on the distribution of his seeds. D. CONTRIBUTIONS TO SCIENTISTS
When adequate storage facilities are not available to the geneticist or plant breeder, a considerable portion of his time must be applied to routine increases of his stocks. An example is the world collections of small grains, which were reincreased every 5 years. Now that a portion of these collections is stored in the Laboratory, the reincrease schedule can be extended for a minimum of 10 to 15 years. The services of the Laboratory eliminate the short-term reincrease programs and give the research man more time for breeding programs. His seed stocks are
PRESERVATION OF SEED STOCKS
105
protected against loss of viability, which is not always the case where he lacks storage facilities. Some seeds have been sent to the Laboratory with a germination of only 8 percent. The Laboratory has the largest collection of germ pIasm in the United States. As of October 1966 accessions totaled more than 52,000. These provide the plant breeder with a very wide base for future breeding programs. Cooperation on the part of plant breeders is necessary to widen this base, So far, requests for seeds have been infrequent, but in future years I am sure they will increase. This prediction is based on the fact that most requests have been for seeds of obsolete varieties that have not been grown for many years. We have been able to fill many of these requests because we store seeds of obsolete varieties whenever they can be obtained. The seeds stored in the Laboratory can serve as a foundation for future genetic investigations into genetic shifts resulting from selection pressures or possible climatic influences. Seeds stored at 40” would not be expected to develop genetic changes and should be valuable for future comparisons with those seeds which had been produced over successive generations. Planning of the Laboratory was projected into the future with subsequent generations in mind. The bulk of the material now stored may have little value in the future, but the preservation of one or two lines that might be resistant to new virulent strains of pathogens may result in the saving of a crop as well as paying for the building and operation of the Laboratory. REFERENCES
Anderson, J. A., and Alcock, A. W. 1954. Am. Assoc. Cereal Chemists, Monograph Ser. 2, 515 pp. Anonymous. 1964. California Seed Law and Regulations. State of California Dept. Agr., Sacramento, California. Agr. Code, Sect. 914( 1 ) ( c ) and Admin. Code Sect. 3864. Bailey, C. H. 1940. Plant Physiol. 15,257-274. Barton, L. V. 1961. “Seed Preservation and Longevity.” Wiley (Interscience), New York. Bass, L. N., Ching, Te May, and Winter, F. L. 1961. Yearbook Agr. (US.Dept. Agr.) pp. 330-338. Bautista, G. M., and Linko, P. 1962. Cereal Chem. 39,455-458. Blakeslee, A. F. 1954. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 57, 488490. Crocker, W. 1938. Botan. Rev. 4,235-274. Crocker, W. 1948. “Growth of Plants,” pp. 28-66. Rheinhold, New York. Crocker, W., and Harrington, G. T. 1918. J. Agr. Res. 15,137-174. DAmato, F., and Hoffman-Ostenhof, 0. 1956. Advan. Genet. 8, 1-28. Davis, N. D. 1961. J. Alabama A d . Sci. 3Z9251-254. Davis, W. C. 1931. Plant Physiol. 6,127-138.
106
EDWIN JAMES
Davis, W. E. 1926. Boyce Thompson Inst. Plant Res. Profess. Paper No. 2. Ewart, A. J. 1908. Proc. Roy. SOC. Victoria 21,2-203. Grabe, D. F. 1964. PTOC.Assoc. Ofic. Seed Analysts 54,100-109. Gunthardt, Helga, Smith, L., Haferkamp, Mary E., and Nilan, R. A. 1953. Agron. J. 45,438441. Haferkamp, Mary E., Smith, L., and Nilan, R. A. 1953. Agron. J. 45, 434437. Harrington, J. F. 1960. Proc. 1959 Short Course Seedsmen, Mississippi State Univ., pp. 89-107. Harrington, J . F. 1963. Uniu. Calif. Agr. Expt. Sta. Bull. 792. Holman, L. E., and Carter, D. G. 1952. Uniu. Illinois Agr. Expt. Sta. Bull. 553, 449496. James, E. 1961. U . S. Dept. Agr. ARS 34-15-1. James, E. 1962. Seedsmen’s Dig., December, 13, pp. 14, 70. James, E. 1963. U . S. Dept. Agr. ARS 34-15-2. James, E., Bass, L. N., and Clark, D. C. 1964. Proc. Am. SOC. Hort. Sci. 84, 527-534. Kelly, C. F., Stahl, B. M., Salmon, S. C., and Black, R. H. 1942. U . S. Dept. Agr. C~TC 1637. . Lantz, C. W. 1927. Am. J . Botany 14, 85-105. Leggatt, C. W. 1929-30. Sci. Agr. 10,73-110. Leggatt, C. W. 1933. Can. J. Res. 9, 571-573. Linko, P., and Sogn, L. 1960. Cereal Chem. 37,489499. Lynes, F. F. 1945. J. Am. SOC. Agron. 37,402404. Moore, R. P. 1963. PTOC.Assoc. Ofic. Seed Analysts 53, 190-193. Munford, R. S. 1965. PTOC. 1964 Short Course Seedsmen, Mississippi State Univ., pp. 144-156. Navashin, M. 1933. Nature 131, 436. Nichols, C., Jr. 1941. Genetics 26, 89-100. Nutile, G. E. 1964. Crop Sci. 4, 325-328. Owen, E. B. 1956. Commonwealth BUT.Pastures Field Crops Bull. 43, 81 pp. Commonwealth Agr. Bur., Farnham Royal, Bucks, England. Oxley, T. A. 1948. “Scientific Principles of Grain Storage” Northern Publ. Co., Liverpool. Peto, F. H. 1933. Can. J. Res. 9, 261-264. Rhine, L. E. 1924. Botan. Gaz. 78, 46-67. Robertson, D. W., and Lute, A. M. 1937. J. Am. SOC. Agron. 29, 822-834. Struve, W. M. 1959. Dissertation Abstr. 19, 2222. Thorneberry, G. O., and Smith, F. G. 1955. Plant Physiol. 30, 337343. Zeleny, L., and Coleman, D. A. 1939. U . S. Dept. Agr. Tech. Bull. 644.
SILICA IN SOILS. PLANTS. AND ANIMALS L . H. P. Jones and
K . A . Handreck
Division of Plant industry. Commonwealth Scientific a n d Industrial Research Organization. University of Melbourne. Victoria. Australia
.
I Introduction . . . . . . . . I1. Factors Affecting the Silica Content of Plants . A Soil . . . . . . . . . B . Species . . . . . . . . C . Transpiration . . . . . . . D. Nutrient Supply . . . . . . 111 Silica in the Plant . . . . . . . A Distribution Among Plant Parts . . . B . Nature of the Solid Silica . . . . C Deposition in the Tissues . . . . IV Silica in Relation to Plant Growth . . . A . Is Silicon Essential? . . . . . B . Interactions with Heavy Metals . . . C . Interactions with Phosphorus . . . D . Resistance to Fungi and Insects . . . E . Miscellaneous Beneficial Effects . . . V Silica in the Ruminant Animal . . . . A . Quantities Ingested . . . . . B . Fate and Effects of Solid Silica . . . C Fate of Dissolved Silica . . . . D. Silica Urolithiasis . . . . . . VI The Silica Cycle . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
I
.
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
.
.
.
.
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. .
. .
. .
.
.
. .
Page 107 108 108 113 116 117 . 122 . 122 . 125 . 126 . 129 . 129 . 130 . 131 . 132 . 133 . 135 . 135 . 136 . 138 . 141 . 144 . 145
. . . . . .
Introduction
The object of this review is to consider various aspects of silica in the chain from soil through plant to animal. The starting point is the soil solution because it is the immediate source of the silica which is always absorbed by soil-grown plants . This habit of plants of absorbing silica was recognized by the earliest plant scientists and in the latter half of the nineteenth century there were already claims and counterclaims about the place of silica in plant nutrition . Although it is doubtful that any plant physiologist today would place silicon in the list of essential nutrient elements. there is nevertheless increasing evidence that silica can 107
L. H. P. JONES AND K. A. HANDRECK
108
produce beneficial effects on plant growth. For the most part these effects have been observed amongst gramineous species and the best examples are seen where silica alleviates manganese toxicity and improves resistance to fungal and insect attack. The gramineous species are also notable for their relatively high silica content and they have been the subject of most of the basic work on the uptake of silica and its forms in the plant. Although this review of necessity places emphasis on gramineous species it also includes some treatment of silica in legumes and other dicotyledons which are notable for their relatively low silica content. The presence of silica in pasture plants ensures that grazing ruminants ingest rather large amounts of silica, most of which is in the solid form. Apart from slight dissolution this silica is unchanged in passing along the alimentary tract, and its known effects on the animal are physical or mechanical. The dissolved silica which is absorbed from the alimentary tract is carried to the kidney and excreted in the urine. Although it is normally excreted readily the silica is sometimes deposited to form calculi or uroliths, which can cause serious economic loss, Some consideration is given to the etiology of siliceous calculi in sheep and cattle. II.
Factors Affecting the Silica Content
of Plants
A. SOIL It has long been recognized that plants of one species contain different concentrations of silica when grown in different soils. In order to interpret the effect of soil on the uptake of silica it is first necessary to present some facts about the reactions of silica in soils. In the last few years five independent groups have concurrently investigated these reactions (Acquaye and Tinsley, 1964; Beckwith and Reeve, 1963, 1964; Gifford and Frugoli, 1964; Jones and Handreck, 1963, 1965b; McKeague and Cline, 1963a,b) and much of our present understanding of the subject has been reviewed by McKeague and Cline (1963~).This recent work followed the fundamental studies of Alexander et al. (1954) and Krauskopf (1959), who showed that silica in solution is present almost entirely as the simple molecule monosilicic acid, Si( OH),, at p H below 9. In a saturated solution of pure amorphous silica the concentration of monosilicic acid is, at 25"C., 120 to 140 ppm. expressed as SiO,. The solubility of silica is independent of pH in the range 2 to 9, but it increases sharply above pH 9 because of the formation of silicate ions. The only work dealing specifically with silica in the soil solution, as distinct from silica in aqueous extracts of soils, is that of Jones and Handreck (1963, 1965b), who used a pressure cell to obtain solutions from soils maintained at field