Ad Reinhardt michael corris
With a Preface by Dore Ashton
ad reinhardt
Ad Reinhardt Michael Corris
reaktion books
...
139 downloads
4113 Views
876KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Ad Reinhardt michael corris
With a Preface by Dore Ashton
ad reinhardt
Ad Reinhardt Michael Corris
reaktion books
For m.v.d. – ice met rock / and happily / chewed away
Published by Reaktion Books Ltd 33 Great Sutton Street, London ec1v 0dx, uk www.reaktionbooks.co.uk First published 2008 Copyright © Michael Corris 2008 Publication of this book has been aided by a grant from the College Art Association Publication Fund.
All rights reserved No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publishers. Printed and bound in Great Britain by Cromwell Press Ltd, Trowbridge, Wiltshire British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Corris, Michael Ad Reinhardt 1. Reinhardt, Ad, 1913–1967 – Criticism and interpretation I. Title 759.1'3 isbn-13: 978 1 86189 356 7 This book is not authorized by the Reinhardt estate. Permission to quote from the letters of Thomas Merton is granted by the Merton Legacy Trust. Permission to quote from material held by The Getty Research Institute’s Special Collections and Visual Resources is granted by the Research Library, The Getty Research Institute, Los Angeles, California (930100).
Contents
Foreword by Dore Ashton 7 Introduction: ‘Starting over at the beginning’ 11 1 ‘Every person is a special kind of artist’ 19 2 Cartoons and Communists 33 ‘Hack’ 33 Public Art and Public Media 36 Comrade Cubist 41 The Origins of ‘Art-as-Art’ 47 Comrade Ad 52
3 ‘Painting-Reason’ and ‘Picture-Purpose’ 61 Abstract Art for Society’s Sake 61 The Inconsolable Polymath 65 Collage as Destruction 68 ‘Painting is more than the scum of its pots’: Beyond Formalism 70
4 The Intellectual Gift of the Post-Historic Artist 75 ‘Blue in art is blue. Red in art is red. Yellow in art is yellow. Dark gray in art is not dark gray’: Aesthetics and Indeterminacy 75 ‘How to Look at Modern Art in America: Fifteen Years Later’ 78 Perfection and the End of Art 83 Neither Secular nor Sacred 86 Systems of Strife 91
5 ‘An Invasion of the Ultimate’ 95 Jamming 95 Rules 98 Convictions 100 Realignment 104
6 ‘Every Dogma has its Day’ 107 ‘The re-reformulation of formalism’ 107 ‘A dark flame, fog forming in the unformed’: Responsive Eyes 112 Unfinished Business 118 The Success of Failure 123
7 Reinhardt and the Art of the Sixties 129 Empty Devices, Dead Diagrams and Invisible Spectacles 129 Trailer 146
8 Political Art and Political Power 149 Scepticism 149 The Artist as Citizen 153 Art and Resistance 158
9 Reinhardt’s Difficult Freedom 163 appendix: guide to visual resources 169 references 172 bibliography 213 artist ’s chronology 228 acknowledgements 235 index 237
Foreword by Dore Ashton
During his lifetime Ad Reinhardt became legendary as our resident scourge, an inveterate nay-sayer whose wit was to be both admired and feared. Those of us who remembered William Empson’s discussion of the power of the negative in poetry, as when Keats began his ‘Ode to Melancholy’ with the ringing ‘No, no: go not to Lethe’, could well understand Reinhardt’s singular value to our community. Few of us, however, were fully aware of the range of his passions. Or rather, the many personae this man of tremendous intellectual and artistic energy inhabited. There was, first of all, the painter, whose evolution from competent Cubist rehearsals, to delicate, even tender informal abstractions, to sternly cruciform black paintings, we watched with admiration for his skill and intelligence as a painter. But there was also the intellectual idealist who searched among the world’s great thinkers for wisdom and moral probity. Every once in a while Reinhardt would issue thoughtful comments drawn from his wide range of readings – everyone from Confucius, to Nicholas of Cusa, to Nietzsche. Eventually we learned of his deep friendship with the poet Thomas Merton, who became a Trappist monk and exchanged thoughts about art and religion regularly with Reinhardt. But what we didn’t know, which Michael Corris now fully explores in this splendid book, was the depth of Reinhardt’s political commitment. Because of the peculiar circumstances in the United States post-World War ii, summarized in the single epithet McCarthyism, even Reinhardt was reticent about his political history, most particularly that of the Depression years. To put it bluntly, Reinhardt was a political radical of the far Left. His life as a political dissenter took place on the pages of the most notable leftist publications, including New Masses and The Nation. Under a number
7
8
of pseudonyms, Reinhardt produced political cartoons reflecting, in various styles that he invented copiously, a burning indignation that even in later years never flagged. Although most artists who knew him after the war thought of him only as a political dissenter within the confines of what is called the art world, a few old comrades remembered his earlier life as a cartoonist, but even they were unfamiliar with the many names he adopted in his life as a subversive. This significant chapter in Reinhardt’s earlier lives is only now revealed in Corris’s book. One of the more complicated questions for any critical biographer is how to treat Reinhardt’s own history of Reinhardt. There are many versions of his fiddling with his autobiography, often modified prudently because of the political climate. Corris has tracked down Reinhardt’s omissions and his camouflage techniques, and offers a portrait of a far more complex person than even those who knew him knew. While I, like everyone else, both coveted and dreaded those missives in elegant art-school script, usually indited on a common postcard, our interpretations of the man always fell short. Since Reinhardt tried to be his own art historian, even art historians were usually reluctant to deal with his pronunciamientos. Yet, a careful reading of all his published writings, and of certain documents that have surfaced since he died, still does not tell the whole story. Who was he? Was he the purist who, in 1948, insisted he was ‘against all involvements’? Or was he a secret agent fulminating from within? And if so, an agent for what or for whom? Was he indeed the black monk gliding in the corridors of an impregnable intellectual fortress, or was he a sly and distinctly public propagator of worldwide moral news? It seems, as Corris amply demonstrates, that he was all these things and much, much more. Those of us who navigated the seething tides of opinion during the epoch of the New York School always paid attention to Reinhardt’s public statements. Sometimes we sat at the famous Club meetings on Friday night, waiting eagerly for him to rise and excoriate. Sometimes, as in my own experience, we had the good fortune to encounter him fortuitously in other countries. To stand in line with Reinhardt in Paris waiting to enter some special exhibition at the Louvre, or to find him in a gallery known only to the few of the most inner vanguard circles, was always exciting, and, I must say, enlightening. Once I had the good fortune to take a long bus ride into Woodstock,
New York, and found myself seated next to him – a conversation I would never forget. I saw him then as a prophet and court jester of Shakespearean dimensions, and he was both, as I now see through reading this book. It is no easy task to tease out a single figure from this immensely active man whose influence is still with us. At the time that Reinhardt was diligently assembling his vast collection of slides of Asian art, most New Yorkers had not yet understood how important a knowledge of Asian thought and art would become, as we now see. Reinhardt, however, was fully aware of the global dimensions of human thought and works, and alerted us. His inclusion of Asian thoughts in his general art philosophy eventually led to his most famous defence of ‘art-as-art’. Although the slogan has been interpreted in many ways, the essential integrity of the thought has remained germinal. All the battles Reinhardt fought – against the compromises of artists, and against, quite simply, capitalism – are still there for the fighting, as a few younger artists know. Reinhardt, for them, is still holding aloft the banner. As Reinhardt once said: ‘God . . . does not wear art on his sleeve.’ Nor did Reinhardt.
9
An important rule of argumentation is that an argument does not reveal the ‘true beliefs’ of its author. An argument is not a confession, it is an instrument designed to make an opponent change his mind. Paul K. Feyerabend Science in a Free Society (London, 1982), p. 156
The first word of an artist is against artists. The first word of an art historian is against art historians. Ad Reinhardt ‘Art vs. History’, Art News (January 1966), p. 62
Introduction: ‘Starting over at the beginning’
This is the first study of the American artist Ad Reinhardt to provide an account of all major aspects of his life and work. From the outset, my research on Reinhardt has been motivated by a desire to make sense of everything that seemed to be out of place or left out. Rather than mine the certainties that cluster at the heart of what might be called the orthodox view of Reinhardt, I have chosen to examine the anomalies and marginalia that pepper the artist’s life and work. These are treated alongside Reinhardt’s undeniable achievement as a painter, in an effort to add a beginning and middle to the story of an artist’s life and work that is most often presented to us in conclusion. There is good reason to adopt such a position. My sustained interest in Reinhardt began with the unexpected discovery of a clutch of cartoons and illustrations drawn by the artist for New Masses, an important left-wing journal of politics and culture of the 1930s and early 1940s. By the end of what turned out to be merely the first phase of an extended project of research on the artist, I had uncovered more than 400 examples of cartoons and illustrations, many of which were signed using a variety of pseudonyms and some of which were drawn in collaboration with another artist, Abe Ajay. These works were produced over the course of a decade – 1936 to 1946 – during the most important formative period of Reinhardt’s career. It was the time when Reinhardt studied art in earnest with painters such as Francis Criss and Carl Holty, made the acquaintance of Stuart Davis, Harry Holtzman and Peggy Guggenheim, became involved with the American Abstract Artists group and mounted his first solo exhibitions in New York. While the cartoons, paintings and collages that emerged from this period were clearly intended for different purposes, it is not so clear that they
11
12
were produced in response to different needs. Reinhardt was no stranger to a conception of abstract art that was hardly removed from the political realities of the day and presumed to address social and existential concerns. Harking back to an earlier definition of aesthetics, Reinhardt frequently remarked during the 1940s on the potential of abstract art to challenge the chaos and fragmentation of what he called ‘the impoverished reality of present-day society’.1 That phrase, mildly chastising capitalism, was meant to welcome a certain kind of artistic practice into an imagined socialist future. The kind of abstract art that Reinhardt had in mind would leave nothing to chance. It would emerge from a rational and transformational discipline: ideal, beautiful and harmonious. It would be constructed through a ‘standard procedure’: a ‘sequence’, ‘series of steps’, ‘system’, ‘devices, exercises, problems, frames, collages, cutouts, and paste-ups’.2 Between these two bodies of work – fine art and applied art, as Reinhardt would have said – there are remarkable conceptual and formal coincidences, strong enough and clear enough, I believe, to argue for a causal link. Moreover, the relationship between painting and illustration is fluid, dialectical, since we find evidence of Reinhardt taking full advantage of his dual talents to interrogate and advance both aspects of his visual output. As Reinhardt wrote in 1949, referring to his practice as painter, cartoonist and satirist: ‘contradictory as though these roles may seem, they can be viewed as aspects of a unified stance’.3 As interesting as the existence of this new body of visual work is in itself and as much as it supplements our previous knowledge of Reinhardt’s various visual practices, some might argue that there is little cause to relate it to the artist’s mature practice as a painter. After all, Reinhardt’s major theme for the 1950s is summed up in a catalogue entry with the unpromising title ‘Abstract Art Refuses’.4 That text seems to put an end for Reinhardt to any associative meaning of abstract art. The meaning of painting for any given period may be discerned, Reinhardt argues in his new creed, by attending to what artists refused to do, refused to represent, refused to include in their painting. One imagines that this rhetoric signals a change of heart for the artist and functions as Reinhardt’s renunciation of his own misguided conflation during the 1930s and ’40s of art and leftwing idealism. It certainly rehearses Reinhardt’s dismissal of social realism and puts to rest the kind of semi-abstraction and abstraction from nature that he had worked through by 1940. It was, in fact,
aimed principally at Abstract Expressionism and functions as a draft theory for an art that has been shorn of referential meaning. To the extent that ‘Abstract Art Refuses’ is also an attempt at self-criticism, it is a reminder that a specific material link between cartooning and painting has been severed. Yet it says nothing about the separation of the cultural from the social; nor does it deny Reinhardt’s embrace of versatility. During the 1950s Reinhardt established himself convincingly as an artist devoted to saving art from the mistakes of other artists and the machinations of the corrupt institutions of art. Compared to the 1940s, Reinhardt’s practice of the 1950s is far narrower ideologically, and the artist himself appears as a far more divided figure. By any measure – ideological or formal – the distance between Reinhardt’s paintings of the 1950s and any other visual material he was producing at the time appeared to be unbridgeable. From the early 1950s to the end of his life, Reinhardt remained adamant about the need to separate art from non-art, the cultural from the social, art from life. As far as most of his commentators are concerned, the only sensible conclusion to be drawn is that Reinhardt’s various visual competencies and other interests must likewise be segregated. This includes, of course, the artist’s long-standing political activism. When we consider Reinhardt’s practice from 1960 onwards – the period that seems to overshadow all that came before it and to define his identity as an artist – the reality of the artist’s separate selves is most forcefully asserted as a theoretical armature. This is because there is nothing in the appearance of the ‘black’ paintings themselves to suggest that a reconsideration of the link between Reinhardt’s various practices would add anything to our understanding of his artistic practice. While we might learn a great deal about Reinhardt the concerned citizen and the committed socialist from the wealth of his activist-inspired graphic design and illustration, such activities would say little, if anything, about his paintings as aesthetic objects or their historical significance. Yet the extreme nature of the ‘black’ paintings, the very way they ‘work’ in the world as art contradicts their alleged dissociation from ideology. Thanks to Reinhardt, the discourse on the ‘black’ paintings of the 1960s was fixated on purity and supported by a mass of formidable rhetoric that often buried its historical truths in a torrent of self-aggrandizement. Ironically, this combination enabled Reinhardt’s painting
13
14
to be hijacked by critics promoting Minimal art and, later, Conceptual art. The more astute critics understand Reinhardt’s affiliation with the utopian project of early modernism – particularly the work of Mondrian – and suggest the ‘black’ paintings signal the failure of that project.5 For the most part, however, Reinhardt’s ‘black’ paintings were taken to have no connection to any other world than that of art; to convey no meanings other than the self-evident fact of their own materiality. One of the reasons I undertook this current project was to respond to such criticism and to turn it on its head. The image of Reinhardt’s modernism we have inherited is, I would argue, a caricature and a fraud. It soon became apparent that the principles that enabled me to revalue the first half of Reinhardt’s career – the period from 1935 to 1950 – could not necessarily be applied to the remainder of the artist’s life and work. There are substantial differences to be noted in Reinhardt’s practice after 1950, but the most significant one relative to the previous decade is its consistency and coherence. While Reinhardt continued to produce art cartoons, they all followed the model established in 1946 by his famous series of collage cartoons, ‘How to Look’. By 1952 Reinhardt’s paintings had returned to geometry; the all-over quality of the calligraphic and manylayered surfaces of the mid- to late 1940s were now expressed succinctly as monochrome fields of close-valued hues arrayed in a variety of grid patterns. The sheer volume and inventiveness of Reinhardt’s political cartoons of the 1930s and ’40s – combined with the accelerated pace of development of his concurrent painterly practice – seemed reason enough to be suspicious of folding them into the ranks of the artist’s applied art and thereby rendering them irrelevant to the material development of his painting. The formal stability and coherence of the artist’s painterly practice of the mid-1950s onwards, however, make it impossible to hypothesize the same sort of connection between material aspects of his various visual practices. One can say that by the beginning of the 1950s Reinhardt had learned all that could be learned about painting through cartooning and vice versa. This does not alter my contention that Reinhardt’s work for New Masses should not be relegated to the margins of any serious account of the artist’s development; it merely limits their scope and forces us to look elsewhere for evidence that will fracture the edifice that was Reinhardt’s practice of the 1950s and ’60s.
Whenever abstract art was in danger of being manipulated by the business world or made more available through the innocence or greed of artists, Reinhardt was quick to point out that he valued abstract art as an end in itself and for its own content. Reinhardt likened the making of abstract art to the conduct of scientific research: a disciplined practice that did not necessarily require the interest or understanding of a broader public. This analogy, too, is an act of negation, one that had serious consequences for the artist. Reinhardt’s escape route was the repetition of a simple schema; another way of establishing difference. In the context of post-war America, Reinhardt’s considered, dispassionate mode of working seemed private, self-absorbed, extremist and mute. The paintings did not celebrate the prevailing anxieties of American life or partake of the vulgarity of the New York School. Some commentators have taken this as an expression of dissent and resistance in the face of the Cold War. The fact of the Cold War, however, does not account for everything. Reinhardt’s difference was easily misunderstood; the paintings of the early 1950s, for example, were hailed by theologians as emblematic of a deeply religious sentiment. In response, Reinhardt argued more strenuously for the meaninglessness of abstract art and distanced himself from the call for integration that he had expressed so publicly throughout the first half of his career. Reinhardt was not simply responding to the political climate; he was also responding to the dramatic changes that were taking place in the support structures of art: the art market, art criticism and museums. Even as he dissociated himself from the milieu of the ‘Irascibles’ – many of whom had also exhibited at Betty Parsons Gallery during the late 1940s and the early 1950s – Reinhardt remained deeply wed to the idea of a New York art community and continued to participate in its discourse as an outspoken critic of artists, dealers, critics and curators. These aspects of Reinhardt’s environment – described somewhat abstractly as the conditions and means of production and distribution of art – are real and have their own history. Reinhardt’s response to the upsurge in art during the early 1960s was to represent his personal artistic development as an alienated and autonomous programme of research in art, as if to say: as art is further integrated into the world of commerce and spectacle, I shall retreat further into the Imaginary Museum of world art.
15
16
Some of these literary offerings descended into excruciating self-parody, as in Reinhardt’s 1965 auto-interview, ‘Reinhardt Paints a Picture’, or his ‘Timeless Stylistic Art-Historical Cycle’.6 As documents of self-knowledge, they share something of the attitude expressed by his friend Thomas Merton, when he remarked: ‘I hide my head from the American hubris that starts and will start wars and violence all over the place, I go back to be dean of the small silent calligraphy and weep for the peace race.’7 Among other sobriquets, Merton called Reinhardt the ‘Dean of the Great Quiet’. Merton, of course, was well aware of, if not mainly responsible for, Reinhardt’s engagement with the ideas of Zen Buddhism and Christian mysticism. Unlike Merton, however, Reinhardt had little interest in sacredness and art and would tease his friend, asking if he could tell a Holy Ground from an impasto.8 What was fascinating about Zen and certain mystic tracts for Reinhardt was the way in which they coupled meaninglessness and nothingness to enlightenment and seemed to respond closely to the artist’s need to discover the terms of an alternative discourse of abstract art. Of course, there is more to this embrace of contemplative and devotional practices and their ethical precepts: they engage the body as well as the intellect. Reconnecting the body, vision and thought – another kind of integration – is very much the point of one’s experience of Reinhardt’s late ‘black’ paintings. Reinhardt’s painterly practice from 1960 to 1967 was dedicated to ‘starting over at the beginning’, the point where the same perfection of ‘creation, destruction, creation’ is ‘made’, ‘unmade’, and ‘remade’. The post-historic artist, as Reinhardt called himself in 1966, ‘forms himself by a series of denials, refusals, but continues to be haunted by realities refused, denied’.9 The personal, it seems, cannot be transcended; the hope that one could open oneself to the ‘general’ and the ‘universal’ is really just another form of nostalgia for a non-bureaucratized wholeness of body and mind. Yet integration and security are precisely what Reinhardt struggled for, what he tried to keep alive, in his art. Our experience of the ‘black’ paintings – how they work in the world as objects of art – is never completely articulated by Reinhardt in his writings, although the artist has a great deal to say about what that experience, what that object of art, does not signify. I believe that Reinhardt made a conscious decision not to describe what would be patently obvious to anyone who took the time to look closely at his ‘black’ paintings. This
embodied aesthetic experience was direct and accessible. It is a work to be read and experienced. And the experience is absolutely counter to the essential experience of commodity culture, which is the experience, first, of the image of the thing, rather than the thing itself. What is more, the beholder of Reinhardt’s ‘black’ paintings can control their experience; they can end it by simply walking away. The ‘black’ paintings present the beholder with a challenge: to refuse to engage with them is to risk rendering them invisible and mute. To the careless spectator, the ‘black’ paintings appear to be undifferentiated dark grey monochromes. In one sense, Reinhardt’s art-as-art dogma, with its musings on the making of an art that is un-reproducible and nearly invisible, does more than gently invite us to experience the paintings themselves. If there is one value that seems to run throughout this account of Reinhardt’s practice, it is the value of criticism. For Reinhardt, the aim of art is to be critical, to interrogate its own existence and that of other works in the world. What this meant to artists, from the mid-1930s to the late 1960s, is a historical question; how Reinhardt realized it is the enduring legacy of his work: It’s not what you started that matters, it’s what you finished Not what you began with but what you ended up with Not so much how much you sold but what you sold out.10
17
1 ‘Every person is a special kind of artist’ 1
Ad Reinhardt (1913–1967) enjoyed a long-standing connection to cartooning and illustration. By the time he had graduated from Newtown High School in Elmhurst, Queens, New York in 1931, his considerable talents as a humorist and illustrator were clearly evidenced and were continuously exercised throughout his course of study at Columbia University.2 Apart from two brief periods of fulltime employment as a newspaper staff artist on pm between 1943 and 1947, Reinhardt worked in the commercial art field on a parttime or freelance basis from the 1930s to around 1950, engaged as ‘art editor, art director, artist, typographer, layout artist, and visualizer’.3 As is customary for freelancers, Reinhardt worked for several clients at once. While his clients were grouped mainly in the field of publishing, print-based media was not the only area of his expertise; the artist’s commercial art output encompassed many facets of modern communication design, display and marketing. Reinhardt worked for the architect and industrial designer Russell Wright on a number of projects for the 1939 New York World’s Fair; he produced art work for the Office of War Information, several souvenir magazines for the Brooklyn Dodgers baseball team and designed and executed some decorative ‘cartoon murals’ for Barney Josephson’s Sheridan Square jazz bistro Café Society, the cocktail lounge of the Hotel Buckingham in midtown Manhattan and the Newspaper Guild Club.4 As a freelance art director, Reinhardt was responsible for the design and production of in-house publications for R. H. Macy’s (1937–9) and the recording-industry monthly, Listen.5 The artist also designed book jackets, decorative lettering, binding designs and end papers and drew illustrations, maps and diagrams for Harcourt, Brace & Company, Viking Press, Modernage Books, the Foreign Policy Association and the typographic design consultancy
19
20
headed by Robert Josephy.6 Under the esteemed art director Cipi Pineles, Reinhardt’s illustrations were published during the mid1940s in the mass-circulation magazine Glamour.7 Finally, Reinhardt freelanced for one of Madison Avenue’s leading advertising agencies, Batten, Barton, Durstine & Osborne, Inc.8 Prior to his induction in the us Naval Reserve in 1944 Reinhardt’s earnings as a commercial artist were likely to have averaged as much as $125 per week, a salary comparable to that earned at the time by university lecturers.9 Despite his prolific output, Reinhardt claimed in 1945 that he did not ‘like being classified as a “cartoonist” or “illustrator” having spent some good time satirizing these professions.’ Reinhardt also disapproved of the professional titles of art editor and art director, finding them to be ‘too limiting’.10 Reinhardt’s deprecation of the professional trappings of commercial art should not distract us from the fact that during the 1920s and ’30s this industry drew attention to itself by claiming competencies that mapped onto the practice of fine art. The commercial artist of this period was encouraged to grasp vigorously ‘movements in art’ and ‘new products with their modern design’ as resources of expression of pragmatic value to the field rather than as exotica comprehensible to the devotee of modern art alone. This tough talk about cultural levelling, especially as applied to commercial art, appealed to Reinhardt. He would have probably identified such attitudes with the ongoing development of graphic design as a modern profession. As naive as such pronouncements may have seemed to professional artists and critics, this kind of offhand debunking of the aura of modern art was something that Reinhardt could and did use to recover his commercial art practice from the abyss of the routine, the mechanical, the commonplace: literally, the domain of the hack. For longer than is generally acknowledged, Reinhardt’s prominence in the commercial art world actually threatened to eclipse his reputation as a young abstract painter. Nevertheless, his graphic design practice occupied a place of considerable importance in his life, both as a source of income and a marker of his political identity. Between 1936 and 1948 he maintained an active profile in the labour movement and was engaged mainly, but not exclusively, in the production of illustrations and cartoon strips for use in the practical political education and organization of fellow workers.11
As an undergraduate at Columbia University during the 1930s, Reinhardt was a prolific cartoonist and illustrator for student-run publications like The Columbia Jester.12 Thomas Merton, Jester’s art editor in 1936 and a lifelong friend of the artist, praised Reinhardt as ‘the best artist that had ever drawn for Jester, perhaps for any other college magazine’.13 Thomas Hess, editor of the influential New York magazine Art News from the 1950s to the early 1970s, remarked that the majority of illustrations for Jester by Reinhardt exhibited ‘a whiff of the dash, gaiety and Art-Deco-Stork-Club style of undergraduate Columbia during the Depression’.14 Reinhardt’s graphic art for Jester was drawn before he began to consider seriously becoming a fine artist, and owes much to the conventions of illustration and graphic design tinged with an appreciation of Cubism. I wish to set aside, for a moment, the complex stylistic relationship that obtains between Reinhardt’s cartooning and illustration and his interest in modern art – an issue that will be revisited in my discussion of Reinhardt’s total visual output of the early 1940s – in order to concentrate on the social context of Reinhardt’s illustrative work; to consider how that context informed the conjunction of a particular form of image-making and radical political practice. The cartoons and illustrations, which mimicked an earlier Jazz-age sophistication and the visual appeal of illustrations and cartoons found in fashionable cosmopolitan magazines like The New Yorker, accounted for the bulk of Reinhardt’s known visual output at the time; a handful of these images ventured into the realm of politics, prefiguring his later editorial work for New Masses. Striking early examples of Reinhardt’s political cartooning appeared in 1935 as cover illustrations drawn for campus publications while the artist was deeply involved with left-wing student groups.15 These works demonstrate that Reinhardt was prepared to turn what he had learned about Cubism into a means for making illustrations. When the purpose was political agitation or satire, Reinhardt created inventive, dense emblematic compositions that demanded to be decoded rather than simply read off as an unambiguous propaganda image. In one illustration, Reinhardt pairs Hitler with Mussolini, Franklin Delano Roosevelt with Nicholas Murray Butler (an establishment figure who was then president of Columbia University) and Herbert Hoover with Huey Long; individuals tagged ‘enemies of the people’ or ‘social fascists’ by the Communist Party of the
21
22
United States of America (cpusa), to recall a term used by the Party to discredit liberals.16 Each political figure is depicted in portrait form and takes on both abstract and realist qualities. The realism is that of a caricature, while the abstraction of the subject is geometric and tends to push the portrait to the condition of a motif. The portrait is constructed like a puzzle, but here and there the logic of abstraction is rendered incoherent by Reinhardt’s introduction of differing pictorial devices; here an emphasis on transparency and vision, there a return to dimensionality and tactility. Quoting Reinhardt, Hess refers to this play of pictorial resources in the cartoons and illustrations of the mid-1930s as ‘Cubist-mannered’. From this morass of influences, Reinhardt began to select out approaches to painting that centred on colour, geometry, opticality and, above all, non-referentiality. As a student-run publication dedicated to producing mostly gentle satire that surveyed everyday aspects of campus academic and social life, Jester provided its audience with a mildly irreverent, yet ultimately comforting picture of middle-class privilege enjoyed by the majority of Columbia students. All the time, Reinhardt’s understanding of class bubbled under the surface. A typical visual gag showed a young businessman crossing Union Square in lower Manhattan, a favoured site of the Left for mass political rallies, cheering ‘Mellon and prosperity’. The magazine’s overall editorial content took the dynamic cultural and social urban environment of New York for its raw material and then refracted this rich terrain through the pretensions and anxieties of the male, white Ivy League undergraduate. The anxieties associated with such class privilege were hardly abstract. This was, after all, the early 1930s, when the country was still in the grip of the Great Depression, on the cusp of the Roosevelt era of the New Deal and with the ferocious labour struggles of the late 1930s yet to come. Reinhardt’s blasé attitude afforded him a degree of psychological distance from the rest of the student body, who were not quite so hip, so stunningly literate or quite so tortured by the mannerisms and absurdities of middle-class life. Such defensive posturing is understandable; as a young man coming from a working-class background, we can imagine that Reinhardt’s barbs were bristling with a deep-seated resentment. Reinhardt’s gags repeatedly featured class as their hook, refracted through the topics of sex, alcohol, sports and popularly held attitudes towards contemporary political affairs and expectations about academic performance.
It has been pointed out that, as a college graduate ‘rather than the product of an art school’, Reinhardt was something of an exception among artists with working-class backgrounds.17 His education meant that he had much in common with more socially privileged artists of his generation, such as Robert Motherwell and Burgoyne Diller. Of his peers, he was probably closest in circumstance to the poor yet fiercely intelligent Mark Rothko, who had dropped out of Yale University after two years.18 For the most part Reinhardt was far more comprehensively educated than artists he came in contact with during the 1940s. As the son of RussoGerman immigrants, whose father worked in the garment trade as a skilled worker and labour organizer, it is not difficult to imagine the attraction that an Ivy League scholarship must have held for Reinhardt. Speaking of the degree of social mobility afforded by an Ivy League diploma, James Wechsler, a member of the Young Communist League while at college and later a friendly witness at the McCarthy hearings, spelled out the advantages, recalling that ‘we were at Columbia to prepare for conventional success in life . . . to be a Columbia man meant to have a certain running start in the great competition ahead.’19 How Reinhardt responded to this gift and how his level of learning contributed to his future identity as a so-called ‘downtown’ or Bohemian artist is quite another story. One could say that Reinhardt’s enthusiastic participation in the university’s studentrun press, his engagement on campus with radical political groups, and a troublesome, spotty attendance record during his last academic year are evidence of a more detached, even cynical view of Ivy League privilege. According to Hess, Reinhardt’s decision to attend Columbia was a ‘turning point’ in the artist’s life, ‘arrived at under considerable stress’ by an individual who ‘came from a very poor family’. Despite there being ‘every reason for him to begin making money’, Hess continued, Reinhardt had decided to take up a scholarship at Columbia.20 While an Ivy League college education may have struck others of Reinhardt’s generation as ‘an easy way out, a way of floating on the tide, of doing the expected, admired thing’, Hess concluded that for the artist ‘it meant going against the grain’ and ‘evidences his early admiration for learning and formal education.’21 According to Abe Ajay, Reinhardt’s father would have preferred his son to have entered the commercial art profession. By attending
23
24
Columbia, Reinhardt announced his decision to turn his back on a career in commercial art. But his mind was far from settled about the future course of his life. It is not the case that Reinhardt had decided to become an artist by the time he entered Columbia; he was fundamentally interested in studying literature and, like all Freshmen, was required to take a course in the humanities built around the so-called ‘great books’ of the Western world. We do know that Reinhardt was gifted artistically and a high academic achiever at high school. He seemed to place great store in the value of a ‘liberal arts education’ as opposed to a more vocationally orientated course of study directed at illustration or advertising design. Confused, but powerful, signals of intellectual snobbery and class striving seemed to dog Reinhardt’s moves between academia and art for some time. As the art historian James Beck notes, ‘the distance between Columbia College and the Art Students League was much greater than 59 blocks.’22 Reinhardt’s shift to art was due largely to the influence and encouragement of the art historian Meyer Schapiro, who taught courses in art history at Columbia. After graduating from Columbia in 1935, Reinhardt began to take art classes at a variety of schools in New York, such as the National Academy of Design and the American Artists School. By 1937 he was more confident about his prospects as a painter: as with most young artists, he was more certain of the art he wished to avoid, and that was any form of naturalism in painting and especially social realism. The kind of art he longed to create had to be modern, abstract and avant-garde. In his youthful embrace of Communism and abstract art, Reinhardt, like so many ambitious young New York artists and intellectuals of the 1930s, aspired to combine the seemingly incompatible demands of political activism and avant-garde art. This challenge, taken up by many abstract artists associated with the Federal Art Project (fap) during the late 1930s, remained a significant aspect of the interwar American experience of modernity. For Reinhardt and his circle, the promise of a socially integrated practice of abstract art was precisely what modernism offered. Texts and public presentations produced throughout the 1930s and early 1940s by American artists such as Stuart Davis, Balcomb Greene and Burgoyne Diller mainly reflected on the relationship between art and society, abstract art and social change, and the selforganization of the artist as a producer. Some of these statements
echo the utopian tone of the innovative theory and practice advanced by earlier modernist artists, such as El Lissitsky and Ilya Ehrenburg, who asserted optimistically that ‘progress in art is possible only in a society that has already completely changed its social structure.’23 Referring enthusiastically to the paintings and writings of Piet Mondrian, Reinhardt in 1943 noted that ‘in a social structure which permitted the artist only an independent and selfish relation to art’ the most one could hope for was ‘the recognition of the limitations of the medium and the development of individual sensibility to lines, colors, [and] spaces.’ What was required, he concluded, was a new social structure that enabled a different type of relationship to art, for artist and public alike. For Reinhardt, as for so many others at the time, this translated into a passionate commitment to the political ideal of socialism.24 During the 1930s modernist architecture and interior design were of tremendous interest to Reinhardt, principally because of the directness with which these constructive activities exemplified a modernist vision that linked creative practice and social organization in a way that suggested the aesthetic as a model informing social life. Yet Reinhardt remained sceptical of the ability of such a practice to realize its goals in isolation from a specific political programme. While a student at Columbia, he was inspired by writings and lectures on architecture and sociology delivered by Jacques Barzun and Lewis Mumford, and from periodic visits to the Museum of Modern Art, where he most likely viewed the historically significant exhibition Modern Architecture.25 His earliest reflections on the social and political dimensions of architecture may be found in a term paper on the International Style, written in 1934 for an art history course at Columbia. Essentially a critique of Mumford’s liberalism, he concluded his essay on a sceptical note, as he altered Le Corbusier’s famous battle cry to read ‘Architecture would be Revolution!’26 During the 1940s Reinhardt revisited the theme of architecture in remarks on housing made in a text of 1943; in a graduate paper on ‘The Spiral Form in Architecture’, written in 1946 as part of the coursework for his Master’s course at the Institute of Fine Arts of New York University; in an enthusiastic review of Fredrick Kiesler’s ‘environmental’ exhibition of art, which had attempted to ‘achieve an integration of architecture, sculpture and painting’,27 and in a speculative proposal showing the integration of painting and
25
26
sculpture into the plan of a modernist interior. In this last work, one of Reinhardt’s paintings of the late 1940s is imaginatively reconfigured as a ‘partition painting’ that functions as a partial dividing wall or screen in the setting of a generic International Style interior. This is perhaps the singular example of Reinhardt considering such a use for his ‘fine’ art. As such, it was an attempt to realize what had been implicit throughout the 1940s in his thought on the potential relationship between abstract art and everyday life. Reinhardt’s engagement with modern design flowed over into his domestic life, as well. A series of photographs of the Reinhardt family home at 209 East 19th Street in Manhattan, taken by Hans Namuth during the late 1950s, show a modestly furnished openplan interior that is at once stylish and mischievous in its simplicity and symmetry.28 The hoped-for democratization of abstract art – achievable, it was thought, through a continuation of State support for the arts and which might serve, in Reinhardt’s words, as ‘propaganda for integration’ – did not materialize. By the end of the 1940s in America, the active suppression of the Communist movement and the widespread demonization of the Left was under way. Along with an entire generation of political radicals and activist artists that came of age during the late 1930s and early 1940s, Reinhardt was forced to witness the brutal dismantling of what many took to be the only real alternative to the political and cultural realities of capitalism. How devastating this must have been for someone who had devoted no less than half his professional career, from the mid1930s to the early 1950s, to the support of political goals defined by the Communist movement. What had kept the dream of the socialist integration of abstract art and social life alive for Reinhardt and others was the existence of a culture of artist-activists linked, directly or otherwise, to a vibrant radical political party and a popular movement for social justice. In Reinhardt’s case, this political structure was the cpusa operating in concert with the organizations and collectivities that constituted the Popular Front.29 The Popular Front – known initially as the People’s Front, then the Democratic Front, in the United States – was a shift in policy announced by the Seventh Congress of the Comintern in August 1935 that responded to the rise of fascism during the 1930s and sought to address the failures of the Communist movement worldwide. Georgi Dmitrov, a principal architect of the
Popular Front policy, called it a ‘new tactical orientation’ that intended to prioritize the political offensive directed at fascism in order to cultivate a united front with former ‘class enemies’ such as socialists and social democrats. The Comintern resolution enjoined all sections of the Communist International to overcome, in the shortest possible time, the survivals of sectarian traditions which prevented them from finding a way of approach to the socialdemocratic workers and to change the methods of agitation and propaganda which hitherto were at times abstract in character and scarcely reached the masses. 27
In the United States, this new emphasis on linking the Communist political agenda to the ‘immediate needs and day-to-day interests of the masses’ meant that the cpusa would need to take up the formidable task of addressing and organizing workers, farmers and the middle classes in the struggle for ‘genuine social legislation’ and ‘unemployment insurance’; a struggle against ‘banks, trusts, and monopolies’; and, of course, against fascism. To do so, the cpusa set aside its commitment to third-party politics, lent its support to the policies of the Roosevelt administration, and focused strongly on mass organizations that engaged labour and professionals in the fight against fascism, at home and abroad.30 The Popular Front culture and its remnants, of course, did not survive much past the conclusion of World War ii. Historians point to a number of factors to explain this collapse, the most significant being the chaos caused by the cpusa’s doctrinal shifts between 1939 and 1946 and the us government’s attacks on the Party and its associated organizations, which culminated in the McCarthy witchhunts of the Cold War. Along with the collapse of the Communist movement, a specific form of American modernism – what I refer to as the Modernist Left – was rendered redundant and, potentially, seditious. As a veteran of the political turmoil of the 1930s and ’40s, Reinhardt could well understand the tensions that existed between the Communist movement in America and the post-war aspirations of the Truman administration. A map that contains elements in Reinhardt’s hand, though not necessarily composed by him, and published in New Masses in 1946 under the pseudonym ‘Tony’, prefigured the emerging global strategy of the Cold War
28
by identifying military bases within the us and the ussr in terms of their distance from their respective sovereign borders. The fact that this map was a polar projection anticipated the geopolitical preoccupation of a generation of Cold War politicians and consultants obsessed with the likely routes that might be traversed by Soviet icbms as they rained down on America’s heartland.31 A decade later, in the devastating wake of McCarthyism and the open criticism of Stalin by Krushchev, the Communist movement, along with a broader spectrum of left-liberal political dissent, was effectively eliminated from American political life. Under these circumstances, the socialist optimism that had underpinned Reinhardt’s artistic practice proved unsustainable. As the artist’s familiar political culture was being altered irrevocably before his own eyes, so too his focus and his choice of rhetoric as an artist underwent profound revision. The partisanship of his politically charged writings on art of the 1940s transmuted into caustic satire and piercing irony. This was no exercise in sympathetic or constructive criticism, either: rather, an expression on Reinhardt’s part of almost total contempt for the social and economic complicity of the so-called art world that emerged in the aftermath of the war. It was a community that the artist subjected continually throughout the 1950s to a strident rhetoric of negation and dissent. More often than not, these attacks were cast in the dour language of moral instruction. One way or another, Reinhardt’s need for political engagement remained vital to his self-identity as a politically conscious citizen and to his self-image as an artist. At the height of World War ii Reinhardt asserted optimistically that ‘every person is a special kind of artist’ and ‘aesthetic values are found to be around in all activities’.32 By the mid-1950s his statements reflected a darker vision of art under siege as the wartime agenda of ‘more leisure, more education, more direct and complete participation of all people in aesthetic activity’ was replaced by the compensatory realism of the ‘universal’ in art.33 From Reinhardt’s perspective, the challenge faced by the abstract artist during the 1940s was to become a whole human being. He was aware of ‘the implications and potentialities of scientific knowledge, projected with a democratic political philosophy of the possibility, ultimately, of every individual being his own artist, his own architect’. Under such an enlightened political and social environment, ‘the central problem in art . . . will be one of democracy and education’.34 The strong theme of cultural
democracy, seemingly remote from Reinhardt’s subsequent statements of the early 1950s on ‘art-as-art’, emerged in a somewhat coded form during the 1960s in the context of the artist’s ‘art-as-art dogma’. Like the mid-1930s and early 1940s, this was another historical moment when the agendas of cultural production and social change appeared to coincide. Radical politics, architecture, graphic design, mass media and abstract art: these are the terms of reference that organize and contextualize Reinhardt’s full creative practice. What is clear is that any account of the fortunes of his vision of art and society must also acknowledge the practices of artists who emerged toward the end of his lifetime and with whom he has been closely linked. Many commentators have asserted that it is the work of young artists of the 1960s – notably Carl Andre, Robert Morris, Christine Kozlov, Joseph Kosuth and Robert Smithson – that truly vindicates Reinhardt’s view of art and that constitutes his enduring legacy. These emerging artists, who were openly hostile to Abstract Expressionism and its apologists, set about inventing the terms for a host of new artistic practices that would eventually be collected under the rubrics of Minimal art and Conceptual art. It is claimed that the work of these artists was informed by the example of Reinhardt’s use of negation, schema and repetition to form a credible artistic practice. On the other hand, it is also true that these artists did not deem it necessary or desirable to emulate the full complexity of Reinhardt’s example. While Reinhardt’s political and moral obligations were considered to be of great importance to figures like Andre and Morris, his position as a writer on art was, for many, far more compelling. What seemed to be most instructive to arch-polemicists like Kosuth and Smithson, for example, was Reinhardt’s apparently endless stream of blistering and inventive attacks directed with precision against the conformist values and errors of his peers. Even Reinhardt’s achievement as a painter was set aside, as Conceptual artists of the 1960s attempted to recast artistic practice in terms of the framework of language or discourse. As Lawrence Weiner aptly put it while explaining how he had arrived at his ‘public domain’ works, which placed the responsibility for the production of the work in the hands of the work’s custodian, ‘the idea of a Reinhardt is always more exciting than a Reinhardt.’35 Initially playful and subversive notions like generic art, meta-art
29
30
and dematerialization in time gave way to grim and often tedious obsessions to discover the philosopher’s stone of art: the art ‘act’ divorced from any material support and rendered pure. For some artists, this was what Conceptual art meant and the humourless quest for a formless, style-less, content-less and timeless form for art defined their project. It has always been Weiner’s hope that art would coexist with human beings in a fluid, matter-of-fact relation. The appropriate form for such art would be one that was unfettered to any particular media, place or time. During the late 1950s and the ’60s Reinhardt proselytized for something very different: he was a painter devoted to seeing through to its bitter end the modernist project of negation through painting. Weiner, along with his Conceptualist peers, had found themselves in a different world of art: a world in which the point of departure for artistic practice – namely, the diminished importance of the object to the idea of art – was already beyond the outer limit set by Reinhardt of art-as-art. Unlike Weiner and his generation, Reinhardt did not reckon on a world of art at peace with the world at large.
Reinhardt was more than a generalist. There was a purpose to the development of his considerable multiple talents, to the mobilization of what he later called his ‘separate selves’. The artist’s reflections on the pragmatics of a compound practice reveal the difficulties attached to attempts to theorize complex, integrated practices in the context of an increasingly managed and fragmented practice of art. To avoid the potential banality of a holistic description of Reinhardt’s practice, we need to attend to the artist’s practice historically while holding at a distance his own self-interested framing of it. Elsewhere, I have introduced the concept of versatility as a means to gain critical purchase on Reinhardt’s ability to enact simultaneously the multiple roles of artist, graphic designer and political activist.36 Accounts of Reinhardt’s life generally mention the artist’s satirical cartoons on art and his polemical writings (the so-called ‘art-as-art’ dogma) only to place them in opposition to his painterly pursuits. Segregated in this way these non-painterly practices are considered to be irrelevant to, rather than in profound conversation with, Reinhardt’s project as an abstract painter.37 In terms of form and process, the explicit cross-fertilization that engaged all of
Reinhardt’s visual practices during the late 1930s and the ’40s remains largely unexamined. As late as 1950 he had made no attempt to segregate his practices publicly; he was simply and widely known as a painter, teacher and illustrator and thought of himself in those terms.38 Reinhardt’s questioning of the claustrophobic professionalization of art led to the conclusion that the mature artist must be more than a mere denizen of the studio; the artist’s insightful and scathing critique of the culture of art serves to illuminate, rather than detract from, our understanding of his paintings.39 Reinhardt’s various activities were far from incidental to his artistic identity, but it was certainly a condition of his culture that such practices should be seen to be, or portrayed as, profoundly discontinuous rather than integrative with respect to the job of the artist. While we pride ourselves on a pluralistic culture of art that admits to no boundaries between subject matter and media, few have been willing to consider the totality of Reinhardt’s practices as a ground upon which our current conditions of art may depend. More common are those voices complaining bitterly that Reinhardt’s paintings are always in danger of being swamped by his polemics, activism and cartooning.
31
2 Cartoons and Communists
‘hack!’ ‘Hack!’ is an insightful, even exotic, cartoon drawn by Reinhardt for Jester in 1933.1 Unique among his collegiate cartoons, ‘Hack!’ closely mirrors what we know to have been the actual terms of the personal dilemma faced by the artist during the early and mid-1930s as he pursued his creative and intellectual interests. Beyond the cartoon’s biographical associations, it remains a powerful allegory of Reinhardt’s perception of the struggle between ‘high’ and ‘low’ in art. ‘Hack!’ is neither an editorial illustration nor a graphic intended to fill a gap in the layout of the magazine. Because of its scale and internal complexity, the cartoon presents itself as a visual essay in its own right. While the cartoon’s rendering of social types meshes perfectly with the satirical intent of the magazine, the faintly menacing portrayal of class conflict sets it apart from Reinhardt’s other visual gags for Jester. ‘Hack!’ reveals the hollowness of the selfassurance and snobbish optimism that pervaded much of the undergraduate satire produced at the time for Jester. As a visual document of culture, the cartoon offers a complex and sobering view of urban class hierarchies. In this regard, its message may not be entirely irrelevant to the concerns of the moderately dissolute middle-class undergraduate racing towards a Wall Street job and a house and family in the Connecticut suburbs. Stylistically, the cartoon’s form is inconceivable without the example of late Cubism. The mechanical, abstract quality of its rendering aligns it as well with the ambitious 1920s visual project known as Isotype, conceived by Otto Neurath, a leading logical positivist philosopher.2 As a keen graphic artist with a basic knowledge of modern art, Reinhardt grasped the fruitfulness of a formal relationship between cartooning and Cubism.
33
34
With elegance and economy ‘Hack!’ stages a chance encounter between a municipal sign-painter laying down the road markings of a ‘No Parking’ zone and a more prosperous artist. The image of the worker is a clear enough symbol, the identity of the second figure, less so. In my view, the second character represents a type of artist that has limited currency in our contemporary world of caricature. For Reinhardt, this fastidiously dressed figure, with brushes and canvases tucked under his arm just so, embodies a particular attitude towards creativity as well as calumnizing a specific type of professional. This dandified character, full of arrogance and swagger and suggestive of Jimmy Walker (the dapper, scandalous mayor of New York in the early 1930s), is far removed from the stockbohemian, Greenwich Village artist. The physiognomy and the haughtiness undoubtedly found their target in New York waspishness, or at least some rehearsal of it. The figure could have easily been modelled after A. E. Gallatin, the artist and founder of the Museum of Living Art, or George L. K. Morris, artist, critic and patron of Partisan Review, or any other of the so-called ‘Park Avenue Cubists’ who became an important contingent within the American Abstract Artists (aaa) group. In 1937, when Reinhardt became a member of the aaa, he came into contact with serious abstract artists who were indeed wealthy and as impeccably dressed as his caricature.3 Alternatively, this problematic figure may have simply been a caricature of a different sort of artist: namely, the Madison Avenue advertising artist, the jobbing illustrator of Fortune magazine covers, the work-for-hire creator of tasteful consumer advertising. Reinhardt’s image of the artist embodies a range of imagined qualities of such creative personages, making it an allpurpose repository for assumptions about art, class and creative activity. The worker/sign-painter, garbed in overalls, is a stock ouvrieriste icon. He is going about his job inelegantly, down on all fours, in the gutter. Both figures are depicted with the tools of their profession, yet only one – the sign-painter – is expected to ply his trade in public, literally in the street. Indeed, where else but the street could two characters from such different walks of life find themselves thrust together and forced to negotiate what amounts to a moral right of way? Reinhardt’s use of the urban setting for this cartoon turns out to have been quite typical of modern, sophisticated magazine illustration at the time.4 We must not lose sight of the fact that this is
the street as seen from the perspective of the politically turbulent 1930s, not merely as a sign of the modern urban experience. The expression of disdain on the gentleman’s face is unmistakable, leading one to conclude that such a disapproving gaze is directed at the workman toiling away at the kerbside. The caption, which simply reads ‘Hack!’, would support this reading were it not for the ambiguousness of the gestures portrayed and the spatial disposition of the figures. There are, in fact, several plausible readings. One assumes the artist is addressing the worker directly. A second imagines the artist in the act of hailing a cab. In this case, the utterance ‘Hack!’ – overheard by the worker – could have been misunderstood and taken as an insult. A third interpretation of the cartoon, in an unexpected reversal, positions the worker directly addressing the artist. In all three scenarios, the cartoon assumes a social hierarchy. Yet the third possible reading remains for me the wittiest of the lot. Even if it is not the most straightforward explanation of the joke, it is the reading closest in spirit to the punning humour that Reinhardt deployed in his cartoon captions even at this early stage, and would continue to refine and employ to devastating effect throughout his career as cartoonist and illustrator. The multiple meanings of the term ‘hack’ enabled Reinhardt to dramatize economically a gentleman artist’s brief encounter with the base underside of his calling: in other words, to picture the sensibilities and experiences that the practice of fine art was meant to hold at bay and ultimately defeat. In the eyes of the gentleman artist, the sign-painter will never be anything other than an individual who responds to the order to perform some dull and uninspiring job. The sign-painter is a technician possessing a trivial facility; a degree of manual dexterity, perhaps, but no true creative imagination to call his own. This reading of the caption, then, animates the entire cartoon, to the point of transforming it into a pastoral. If the utterance ‘Hack!’ originated from the workman himself, then surely it must have been intended to be an insult directed at the figure of the artist. If so, it is a delicious example of ‘hailing’ out of synch. The indeterminacy of address does not seem to me to be a failing. Rather, it is the point of the cartoon and a testament to Reinhardt’s inventiveness as an illustrator and his talent for puns. ‘Hack!’ was the first of Reinhardt’s many reflections on the class character inscribed in the hierarchies of visual practices in a modern, capitalist society.
35
36
Increasingly skilful at deploying this sort of visual ambiguity, Reinhardt returned repeatedly during the 1940s to this strategy in order to reflect on the social consequences of the division of labour within modern capitalist society. In his role as editor of Jester, Reinhardt announced his intolerance for ‘pseudo-people’, ‘smug stupes’ and the ‘aesthetically insensible’. This banter conceals a deeply romantic suggestion that the creative artist represents a more authentic personality in modern society. ‘We are going off on our high horse’, wrote Reinhardt, just in case you thought he had meant it. ‘We like radicals’, he said, but ‘we are doggedly determined to be different and much funnier.’ Reinhardt concluded the editorial with an equally Wildean condemnation of the conservative as a person to be reviled simply because ‘he has bad taste’.5 The detached, cavalier tone of the editorial was just what Jester’s knowing readers craved; satire of this sort enabled Reinhardt to reflect on the opposing postures of respectability and radicalism without fear of contradiction. It would not be until the early 1940s that Reinhardt managed to resolve the encounter originally pictured in 1933 in ‘Hack!’. In an important polemical essay titled ‘The Fine Artist and the War Effort’, the tables are turned as Reinhardt levels the cultural ground of applied and fine art practices by asking ‘exactly how less creative are the artists who change our world every day . . . with their practical limitations, than the fine artists, with their imaginative restrictions?’6
public art and public media There is nothing more pathetic than an artist who, with his ‘pictures in frames’, tries to compete with pictures in magazines and movies.7
Undoubtedly, the text that most profoundly influenced Reinhardt’s thinking on art and class was the art historian Meyer Schapiro’s essay ‘Public Use of Art’. The arguments put forward by Schapiro were central to the fashioning of Reinhardt’s own position on the strategic relationship between painting and the mass media. Schapiro conceived ‘Public Use of Art’ as a corrective to contemporary discussions on the Left on the continuation of government funding through the Federal Art Project (fap).8 Called ‘the most sophisticated critical assessment of the New Deal art projects to be
published at the time’, Schapiro’s essay reflects ‘on the wider problems of the audience for art in modern capitalist societies’ that would continue to engage Reinhardt throughout the 1940s.9 Importantly, Schapiro framed his analysis in terms of class, proposing ‘theories that translated into practice – not just the practice of art . . . but the practice of artists reaching out to join with the struggles of the working classes.’10 ‘Public Use of Art’ was Schapiro’s second contribution to Art Front, the official publication of the Artists’ Union. The Union, which had been founded a few years earlier, was recognized by the fap as the de facto bargaining agent for the artists employed on the Project.11 The economic and political circumstances that turned Schapiro’s attention towards this issue were the upturn in the us economy in late 1936, followed by President Roosevelt’s order to the wpa to ‘pare its rolls in keeping with the expected absorption of workers by industry.’12 In response to these redundancies, the Artists’ Union called for resistance to the efforts by the government to eliminate artists’ jobs. In a stunning move beyond the demand for job security, the Union agitated for the fap to ‘become a permanent feature of our social and national life’.13 Against these demands, Schapiro raised a key question: what can artists do ‘to maintain these projects and to advance them further toward a really public art’? Schapiro’s reply lays bare an opportunity for artists: ‘artists must develop a public art, one that presupposes a specific constituency.’14 This call for a ‘really public art’ challenged the fixed idea that the fap Mural Project was the only proper forum for the realization of such aims. Schapiro criticized the belief that the production of murals representing working-class subjects, for example, would invariably function as a bridge between artists and workers. He asserted that there was a real difference between the economic and political interests of artists and workers and that there had never been any real support by the working class for projects that exclusively benefited artists. Artist–worker solidarity would be a hard-won social and political bond. Schapiro reminded artists that workers also wished to return to full-time employment as well as to fight to obtain social insurance, to have the prospect of a skilled job, to gain higher earnings based on a union scale of wages, and so forth. Artists, on the other hand, were more or less satisfied to maintain the projects as they were, which in any case represented a tremendous improvement
37
over ‘their former unhappy state of individual work for an uncertain market’.15 Here, Schapiro highlighted the fallacy, widely shared by artists working for the fap, that artists had somehow been proletarianized and transformed into ‘art workers’, thus suggesting a ‘natural’ alliance with the working class. Schapiro called this a delusion arising from a bureaucratic necessity; artists were simply beneficiaries of State-run emergency projects, not employees of the State. Noting the disparate class location of workers and artists in society, Schapiro pointed out that
38
Artists are usually individual producers. They own their tools and materials and make by hand a luxury object which they peddle to dealers and private patrons. They employ an archaic technique and are relatively independent and anarchic in their methods of work, their hours of labor, their relations with others.16 It was only a matter of time before the truth of this analysis would be confirmed to the detriment of the interests of artists. Unless the working class acknowledged that a permanent State programme of support for the arts had value for them, they would be justified in refusing to support it. Schapiro argued that a positive position on the part of the working class towards art and artists must be based ‘on a solidarity of artists and workers expressed in common economic and political demands’.17 Schapiro regarded the Mural Project to be seriously flawed on ideological and aesthetic grounds. (To be fair, Schapiro did not have much sympathy for easel painters, either, if they produced ‘pictures to decorate the offices of municipal and state officials, if they serve the governmental demagogy by decorating institutions courted by the present regime’.)18 He insisted that the most promising strategy for artists to pursue would be to ‘demand the extension of the program to reach a wider public’. At the same time, they should present ‘a plan for art work and art education in connection with the demands of the teachers for further support of free schooling for the masses of workers and poor farmers’.19 Schapiro’s hope was that the self-transformation of the artist might also lead to a future in which the artist’s relationship to the working class would be experienced naturally, as was already the case with respect to the present and unsatisfactory relationship of artist to bourgeois patron.
The artist could become a genuine ally of the working class through the achievement of a ‘public use of art’. This aim, in turn, was deeply embedded in the ‘achievement of well-being for everyone’ in the form of the establishment in the us of a type of socialism. In one important respect Schapiro was out of step with the Party line and Popular Front rhetoric, which had aimed to support Roosevelt and New Deal projects such as the fap. Schapiro’s veiled attack on the Roosevelt administration, notes the art historian Patricia Hills, ‘would have made the Communists in the Artists’ Union uncomfortable, to say the least, since it was published in November 1936, the month that Roosevelt won an overwhelming majority of the vote in a campaign that involved the active (if sub rosa) support of the cp’.20 Several months later, Reinhardt, employing the pseudonym ‘Darryl Frederick’, published a cover illustration for New Masses that endorsed a policy of critical, rather than unconditional, support for Roosevelt’s legislative programme. The cartoon depicts Roosevelt as a drum major parading a group of Congressmen away from the Capitol building in Washington, dc. A few independent politicians are shown breaking ranks. Roosevelt’s baton is twirling, describing its rotation as a circle with alternating black and white chords; a Futurist illusion of simultaneity modelled after Giacomo Balla’s Dynamism of a Dog on a Leash (1912). By the time Schapiro had presented the talk ‘Public Use of Art’, Reinhardt’s work at New Masses was well under way. When Schapiro asked for whom the artists were painting or carving, and what value their present work might have for this new audience, we can appreciate how these challenges would have helped to inform, encourage and enrich Reinhardt’s dialogue with the Communist movement. Reinhardt’s later vision of the socially responsible artist imagined practitioners ‘working towards a synthesis of the arts’, ‘aware of the implications and potentialities of scientific knowledge’, and imbued with ‘a democratic political philosophy of the possibility, ultimately, of every individual being his own artist, his own architect.’21 Reinhardt had fashioned himself into an artist-citizen whose practices were framed by the pleasures of the drawing board and the closely knit community of artists and activists. His immersion in the Artists’ Union and his experience working for New Masses had a profound effect on his understanding of the complicated relationship between politics and culture. A full-page cartoon by
39
40
Reinhardt titled ‘You’re a menace to civilization’, published on 2 January 1940 in New Masses, illustrates the dialectical view of history as class struggle as expounded by Marx and Engels in The Communist Manifesto. The cartoon is organized into three stacked scenarios, each of which symbolizes a stage of class struggle, covering roughly the transitions from feudalism through capitalism to socialism. At each stage, the personification of the soon-to-be superseded class points an accusing finger at its historical successor. The repetitive format foreshadows Reinhardt’s more radical deployment of cyclical repetition to suggest timelessness. Here, it signifies the iron laws of history. Surely, this is one means of elevating the sly working-class hero of the 1933 cartoon ‘Hack!’ while making a valuable point about the substance of political and social transformations necessary to reverse the fortunes under capitalism of worker and artist alike. Schapiro’s argument presented Reinhardt with a more nuanced relationship between artist and worker, one that hinged on the observation that ‘a public art already exists’: that is to say, in the form of comics, illustrated magazines and the cinema – all the forms of mass cultural production that fascinated Reinhardt and engaged a considerable measure of his creative energies. As Schapiro noted, It may be a low-grade and infantile public art, one which fixes illusions, degrades taste, and reduces art to a commercial device for exploiting the feelings and anxieties of the masses; but it is the art which the people love, which has formed their taste and will undoubtedly affect their first response to whatever else is offered them.22 One thinks not only of the sophisticated illustrations that Reinhardt emulated, but also of Walt Disney’s full-length cartoons or the utopian carnival of architecture and design that was the New York World’s Fair of 1939–40. The artist, of course, does have a choice. If he ‘does not consider this to be an adequate public art, would his present work, his pictures of still-life, his landscapes, portraits and abstractions, constitute a public art?’23 By 1942 Reinhardt was writing in a particularly enthusiastic and convincing manner about mass-market periodicals and the cinema. He agreed substantially with Schapiro’s assessment of the mass
media. Many of Reinhardt’s reflections of the early 1940s on the necessity of separating ‘picture-purpose’ from ‘painting-reason’ are elegant condensations of Schapiro’s original argument. Once ‘painting-reason’ is separated from ‘picture-purpose’, Reinhardt claimed, visual communication techniques would be ‘freed from aesthetic, personal expression and distortion and serve more efficiently as a social weapon’. As far as Reinhardt was concerned, ‘the motion picture taught people more about our natural world than centuries of representational painting’.24 Reinhardt did forge a relationship with the political arm of the working-class movement and he did so initially without risk to his art. By polarizing ‘painting-reason’ and ‘picture-purpose’, he devised a cultural space in which both could flourish and evolve. Unlike so many politically impassioned artists of the 1930s, Reinhardt did not come to political activism as a fine artist. Rather, he mobilized his considerable talents as illustrator and cartoonist for the sake of his political beliefs. Consequently, during the early 1940s he continued to oppose the production of social realist murals as a tool of ideological communication and resisted naive assumptions about the terms of art’s popularization and the substance and structure of the artist’s engagement with the working class.25 The prospect of realizing Schapiro’s vision of sweeping educational initiatives linking artists and worker died with the demise of the fap in the early 1940s. Nevertheless, the Communist movement continued to agitate for a permanent, State-funded agency to fulfill what they saw as the true democratic cultural mission of the fap.26
comrade cubist New Masses began publishing in 1926 as a political and cultural monthly under the direction of a loose coalition of Communists, socialists and ‘radical intellectuals’. In 1934 New Masses was relaunched as a weekly and achieved its peak popularity during the late 1930s. Reinhardt started to draw cartoons for the magazine during the summer of 1936, at the moment when New Masses was regarded as a central organ of the literary-political Left.27 Reinhardt’s initial contribution to New Masses was an editorial illustration accompanying a report by one Alexander Kendrick of a strike at the rca Victor radio manufacturing plant in Camden, New Jersey. Reinhardt’s drawing parodies the corporation’s well-known
41
42
logo, which was based, in turn, on Francis Barraud’s 1899 painting His Master’s Voice. Reinhardt’s caricature portrays the company labour adviser and union-buster, Hugh S. Johnson (a former member of the Roosevelt administration), as a puggish bull terrier, quite unlike the adorable fox terrier ‘Nipper’ depicted in the original logo. A stiff, fussy effort by Reinhardt, the cartoon nonetheless underscores the point of the article that company unions are not autonomous unions. Signed ‘Darryl Frederick’, this cloaked illustrative debut by Reinhardt set in train the artist’s decade-long practice of employing pseudonyms based mainly on the Anglicization of his middle names, ‘Dietrich’ and ‘Friedrich’.28 Throughout its history as a magazine dedicated to the integration of politics, art and culture, New Masses remained embedded in the Communist movement and associated with the leadership of the cpusa.29 However, the New Masses that Reinhardt encountered in 1936 was hardly a blunt political instrument wielded by Party functionaries. The impact that these links had on the editorial content of the publication then remained far from clear-cut, since many shades of opinion on the constitution of ‘progressive’ art and culture were tolerated during the Popular Front period and for some time thereafter. Alongside polemics in support of social realism, one found articles on Picasso and Mondrian and informed reviews of abstract art. On the matter of domestic and international political policy, however, the editorial content of New Masses unambiguously reflected the Party’s line. Nonetheless, artists and writers clearly benefited from the Party’s response to the influx of middle-class intellectuals during the mid-1930s.30 New Masses was split by the fault lines of class and is more accurately described as having been a magazine that ‘came to stand for, and to dialogue with . . . the largest Communist constituency outside the ethnic groups’, namely an ‘unembarrassed, radical middle class’.31 In other words, New Masses spoke ‘in the name of the working class’, not ‘for the working class’.32 Reinhardt was an extraordinary find for the editors of New Masses: an individual with a considerable talent for illustration and design, a youthful activist, an aspiring artist of working-class origins politically sympathetic to the aims of organized labour and a university graduate with a strong interest in art and culture. In all respects, Reinhardt’s engagement with the Communist movement exemplified the increased access gained by artists and intellectuals to the antifascist movement through the avenues of art, literature and music.33
By the late 1930s Reinhardt was fully conversant with the intellectual and cultural debates that characterized the vibrant and fractious New York literary and artistic avant-garde. Yet it was not the promise of a Marxified avant-garde or a ‘creeping Modernism’ that necessarily drew Reinhardt to New Masses and sustained him throughout the course of many, often troubled, years of service.34 I believe he grasped the occasion as an opportunity to reinforce – if not direct – the magazine’s move to embrace aspects of popular and mass culture in the name of socialism. By the late 1930s, popular and mass forms of culture, like folk music and the cinema, were well-established subjects of commentary for New Masses. During the Popular Front, the magazine extensively employed cartoons and cartoon strips to communicate its political message, drawing equally from the venerable tradition of political cartooning and satire as well as the more recent phenomenon of the Sunday supplement comics. What has been referred to elsewhere as the ‘subtle impact of the Popular Front’ on the journalism of the Communist movement as a whole – that is, the general interest in popular and mass culture – was also felt by artists and illustrators. This tendency could only have encouraged Reinhardt and nurtured his impressive gift for caricature and satire.35 Milton Brown, an art historian active in the Communist movement and later a colleague of Reinhardt’s at Brooklyn College, characterized the artist’s contribution to New Masses as journalistic, a backhanded compliment meant to diminish the level of innovation Reinhardt brought to a demanding job.36 While there is little specific detail concerning Reinhardt’s recruitment to New Masses, it is likely that he gained entrée to the magazine through his acquaintance with several key figures on the editorial board, some of whom were highly placed in the Communist movement. The names most frequently mentioned by Reinhardt in this regard were the cartoonists Crockett Johnson (the pen name of David Leisk) and Anton Refregier.37 Leisk was active in the daily affairs of New Masses and served on the editorial board from about 1936 until the end of 1939. Along with the well-known artist Rockwell Kent, he redesigned the masthead and layout of New Masses in 1936 in an effort to modernize the appearance of the magazine. Reinhardt, already a regular contributor to the magazine, may have lent a hand in this process.38 Leisk’s cartoons for New Masses inject a welcome measure of wit into the often lugubrious
43
44
and convoluted political positions that begged for clarifying illustration. A typical example of Leisk’s approach is a pro-Soviet cartoon strip published in New Masses during the dark days of the Ribbentrop–Molotov Pact. Leisk personifies Nazi Germany, Great Britain and the us as a gang of bumbling burglars attempting to break into the ‘premises’ of the ussr. Their plans are foiled and the gang is reduced to picketing under the name of the ‘International Imperialist Union’. The farce alludes to the West’s support of the Mannerheim regime in Finland.39 Later, Leisk would gain a measure of popular fame as the creator of the comic strip Barnaby and as the author-illustrator of exceptionally sophisticated children’s books. Leisk and Reinhardt remained in close contact throughout the mid-1930s and the ’40s. In 1944 Reinhardt illustrated the awardwinning children’s book A Good Man and His Wife, written by Leisk’s wife, Ruth Krauss. Abe Ajay recalls that Reinhardt in particular held a great deal of responsibility for the design and preparation of New Masses for printing. Accordingly, Reinhardt ‘selected type-faces, taught me how to copy-fit . . . and on Friday night both of us would go up to the New Masses offices and paste-up the “book” in galley form. And we’d each get $5.’40 Abe Magil, a political journalist and member of the editorial board of New Masses from 1940 to 1948, asserted that Reinhardt had functioned as de facto art director for the magazine for at least one year between 1939 and 1943, calling him ‘one of New Masses’ most prolific graphic contributors’.41 Reinhardt’s work of the late 1930s for New Masses grew ever more assured as the artist explicitly utilized visual motifs drawn from the example of Cubist painting. These illustrations frequently struck a dissonant chord in a magazine where many of the editorial illustrations and cartoons conformed to realist pictorial conventions. By their own admission, many artist contributors to New Masses drew upon the examples of Goya, Daumier, Walter Crane, John Sloan and George Bellows as models for the task of illustration. In a review of paintings by William Gropper, perhaps the most prolific of all New Masses artists, a young Harold Rosenberg noted the imprint of many of the same sources on the artist’s work, adding for good measure the names of Ryder, Forain and Breughel and the traditions of Japanese painting and ‘primitive art’.42 Cubism is thrown into this mix as well by Rosenberg, and it is interesting to contrast Gropper’s assimilation of the lessons of
Picasso and Braque to Reinhardt’s. An examination of works produced by Reinhardt in 1938 and 1939 for New Masses reveals numerous examples of compact, intricately constructed, Cubist-inspired illustrations, many of which used letterforms as central compositional elements. These works conform nicely to Stuart Davis’s prescriptive notion of the whole picture as a psychological gestalt, a principle that Reinhardt seems to have embraced and simultaneously applied to his painting. Additionally, between 1936 and, say, 1939 or 1940, there was a substantial thematic overlap between the two major bodies of visual work. For example, Reinhardt’s parallel treatment of urban and industrial scenes in paintings such as Untitled (Blue Hook Series), 1938; Untitled (New York World’s Fair), c. 1939; and a cover illustration of a montage of New York World’s Fair pavilions for the in-house magazine Sparks (R. H. Macy’s, ny), 1939. Here we see Reinhardt acknowledging and demonstrating the potential of Cubism as a resource of expression capable of modernizing the practice of editorial illustration, while exploring its pertinence for him as a foundation for his painting. In this new world, Reinhardt believed that ‘illustration, poster-making, applied art, freed from “fine-art” elaborations’ would fulfil ‘their functions more clearly and honestly’.43 The aesthetic territory mapped out by Reinhardt and other avant-garde cartoonists such as Ajay hardly ruffled the feathers of the readership of New Masses. On the contrary, Reinhardt was a highly celebrated contributor to the magazine. The absence of dissent may have masked a deeper, more potentially disabling prejudice of the editors and the majority of readers. This would ultimately rebound against artists whose approach to illustration and cartooning was dependent upon an affinity with abstract art: it is ultimately the journalistic text that renders illustrations, regardless of style, intelligible to the reader. What this implies is that few examples of abstract, modernist imagery were, in principle, unavailable for use – or misuse as Reinhardt, in later decades, never tired of noting – as a tool for political communication. Accordingly, even the wildest of Picasso’s experiments in perceptual dislocation could be plundered and tamed to such ends. For Gropper, Cubism’s appeal was more as a visual spice that made his illustrations more credible to a sophisticated readership aware of modern art. In the event Cubism had no lasting effect on Gropper’s illustration or painting. For Reinhardt, though, Cubism was the means to escape naturalism in illustration as well as painting
45
46
and his editorial illustrations of the late 1930s extensively explored the possibilities of late Cubism. In some respects, they were superior to comparable efforts in his painting that were struggling to find a way out of an exhausted Cubist idiom. Gropper’s practices are an instructive foil to those employed by Reinhardt. In their quest to invigorate the stock icons and motifs that comprised the lingua franca of radical political editorial illustration of the 1930s, there is a palpable sense of competition between the young Reinhardt and the older Gropper. The panoramic narrative cartoon, the full-page political caricature and the strip cartoon (the last being a format that Gropper revived in his own work around 1944) are some of the illustrative genres that were energetically reworked by Gropper and Reinhardt.44 Gardner Rea’s astute use of the conventions of the ‘bourgeois comedy of taste’ made fashionable by the urbane cartoonists of The New Yorker and Ajay’s knowing travesties of Surrealism provided New Masses readers with stark alternatives to imagery derived from social realist painting and printmaking.45 But it is the neglected cartooning of Ajay, juxtaposing blots, brushwork and swirling constellations of calligraphic line, that rank with Reinhardt’s as the most jarring to be seen in New Masses, and the most engaged with the avant-garde of the first quarter of the twentieth century. An example of how Cubism enabled Reinhardt to refashion even the most hackneyed caricature of the bourgeoisie may be found among the artist’s dozens of spot illustrations drawn for New Masses. Despite their diminutive scale, these drawings are remarkable examples of Reinhardt’s considered and sophisticated approach to illustration. In one drawing he combined a number of images symbolic of finance capital, fashioning a squat stockbroker, a ticker tape machine, a dollar sign and the ubiquitous moneybag into a marvellously complex emblem of capitalist greed. As it threads through the figure’s grasp and snakes over crossed legs, the serpentine tickertape moves downwards to form the lower lefthand frame of the drawing. It then shoots upwards, transforming itself into the tail of the s-curve of a dollar sign, which is superimposed in the negative on the moneybag. With the completion of the s-curve, the line terminates at the neck of the bag. At the terminus of this arc, however, it changes direction yet again and abruptly generates a series of verticals that suggest the peaks of a crown, which is Reinhardt’s graphic shorthand for the closure and cathexis of the
moneybag. Finally we glimpse the image of the crown echoed in the lower portion of the figure’s waistcoat.46 As an illustrator Reinhardt was a formidable all-rounder. A surprisingly naturalistic portrayal of the French writer André Malraux drawn for a New Masses cover shows Reinhardt to have been a highly accomplished draughtsman.47 The artist was equally adept working with the traditional media of lithographic and Conté crayon on cold-pressed board, a technique incorporated in a frieze on the theme of Soviet industrialization. This illustration, originally drawn for Soviet Russia Today, accompanied a New Masses lead article defending the conduct of Stalin’s notorious show trials in Moscow.48 Equally compelling illustrations by Reinhardt emerged through his emulation of the contemporary work of Stuart Davis. These included a number of open line drawings of factories and comic figures. He also borrowed a version of montage found in Davis’s 1918 canvas Multiple Views, wherein a series of anecdotally associated vignettes are grouped in an ensemble. This was an awkward solution invented by Davis to solve the problem of ‘infusing the dimension of time into painting that did not rely on the cubist vocabulary’.49 Formal echoes of this quirky painting are found in Reinhardt’s 1938 fullpage cartoon The Greatest Show on Earth: Combined Red-Baiting Circus.50
the origins of ‘art-as-art’ In contrast to most of the illustrators at New Masses, Reinhardt favoured the techniques of the layout artist, the printer and the modern painter to those of the fine arts draughtsman.51 Reinhardt’s systematic application to illustration of the montage-like assembly process of the graphic designer’s basic production method – the ‘paste up’ – resulted in a unique version of the cartoon collé, a compositional technique combining hand-drawn and pre-printed or photographic elements. The cartoon collé is a mode of visual expression most widely associated with the work of the German Dadaists George Grosz and John Heartfield, and the Surrealist Max Ernst. Utilizing a similar technique for the production of his art comics and cartoons of the late 1940s and the ’50s, Reinhardt dutifully acknowledged Ernst’s work as the key model for his mass-media reinvention of the cartoon collé. While the papier collé of Picasso and Braque of 1912 is an obvious precursor to the cartoon collé, the
47
48
iconic and mimetic functions of the cartoon collé in the hands of the Dadaists and Surrealists placed this form at some remove from the Cubist collage. Reinhardt understood the distinction even as he developed the logic of cut-and-paste simultaneously in illustration and painting.52 Because Reinhardt was a graphic designer and illustrator prior to his entry into fine art, the technical skills he had mastered initially in the context of applied art profoundly influenced his art studio habits. Later in his career Reinhardt wrote of the need for an art of ‘self-sufficient clarity’, ‘standards’ and ‘precision’. To achieve such an outcome demanded a system of repeatable sequences, a ‘series of steps’, ‘system’ and ‘devices’. The discipline of ‘standard procedure, objective operation’ prefigured an art more than superficially linked to the world of ‘paste-ups’ and the increasingly rationalized process of graphic design production.53 There are many striking similarities to be found between Reinhardt’s work at the draughting board and the easel during the 1930s and ’40s. Because of a fruitful, reciprocal technical relationship between the two practices, each in turn was inspired, informed and advanced by the presence of the other. By the late 1930s Reinhardt adopted a method of painting that used the collage technique to make preparatory studies and models for the final rendition in oils. By using collaged, hand-coloured paper to work out the structure of paintings beforehand, the need for preparatory pencil or oil sketches was eliminated. Reinhardt learned this technique from Carl Holty and Francis Criss, two of his most important art teachers of the late 1930s. It was a method of working that was widely practised among painters aligned with the American Abstract Artists group and had the virtue of engaging skills and procedures that would have already been familiar to Reinhardt in the context of graphic design layout.54 The impact of collage as a resource of expression for Reinhardt’s fine art was considerable. The introduction of new materials and techniques in Reinhardt’s paintings around 1938 had a profound effect on the nature and formal focus of his work; his increased use of collage accelerated this process.55 By 1940 Reinhardt had lost interest in the game of abstracting from reality. This does not mean that he no longer employed a model for his painting in the form of a collage; he did, but what he painted were remnants of a destroyed realism. By that time, Reinhardt was using a range of
photomechanical sources for his collage material: black-and-white and colour newspaper and magazine photographs and engravings found in second-hand illustrated books, in place of coloured paper. These new raw materials were sliced up and rearranged into patterns designed to produce the maximum defamiliarization of the source imagery. The spatial effect was paradoxically one of continuity, not fragmentation; a new, all-over surface emerged that enabled him to dispense with the faceted space of Cubism or the latent push and pull, or architectonic character, of some of his late 1930s paintings.56 In a statement of the late 1940s Reinhardt remarked on the importance of collage, characterizing it as a combination of ‘spontaneous and accidental aspects, along with the perfectly controlled’.57 From the late 1930s until the late 1940s Reinhardt’s fine art production was freely inflected by technical and formal influences from both ‘fine’ and ‘applied’ art practices. The artist’s knowledge of the technical process of commercial letterpress and photolithography played a significant role in his artistic development because it supplied him with a framework within which to explore and ground his notion of painting as process and construction. Despite his protestations to the contrary, at this point in his career the dynamic between fine and applied art techniques provided him with a valuable opportunity to view illustration and cartooning output as the occasion to work out problems that originated in, and perhaps threatened to stall, his painting practice. As Reinhardt began to apply innovative graphic design tools and new systems of composition to his cartooning, the differences between his illustrations and those of other contributors to New Masses became especially pronounced. His chief innovations were the use of pre-printed, self-adhesive Ben Day screens and, of course, his adaptations of Dadaist collage. The Ben Day screens were a product designed to eliminate the drudgery of cross-hatching, of filling in an area of an illustration or graphic design with a consistent tonal value;58 their use dominated Reinhardt’s contributions to New Masses from 1941 to 1943. What was at stake for the artist, it seems to me, was how to develop visual resources for mass political illustration that were most appropriate to the media of print rather than derivative of the practice of painting or fine art printmaking; in other words, how to make explicit the political implications of the use of readymade technical aids in contrast to labour-intensive, hand-worked
49
50
drawing techniques. A certain kind of directness was sought, as opposed to a reproduction or translation of one medium into another. The goal was to remove from cartooning all vestiges of painterly practice, while concentrating on the essential aesthetic qualities and technical methods deemed necessary for mass production of graphic designs. This entailed a move away from the more conventional pen-and-ink techniques that characterized Reinhardt’s previous cartooning; a process that began in earnest with the use of Ben Day screens, and was advanced through the publication in 1942 in New Masses of a group of anti-fascist cartoon collés such as Four Moods of Der Fuehrer and Horse and Rider on the Eastern Front. Artists such as Gropper may have largely ignored Reinhardt’s experiment to rid cartooning and illustration of the hand, but the lesson was not lost on the younger artist and fellow traveller Hananiah Harari. Harari was already familiar with modern art and had tried to develop a style of political collage that juxtaposed in a literal way an array of disparate, incompatible pictorial conventions. The greatest impetus to Harari’s ambitions as a political cartoonist may have come from Reinhardt’s work at pm; it was only in 1947, after the appearance of the latter’s series of art comics, that Harari inaugurated a collage/cartoon-strip feature of his own in New Masses. Titled ‘On Safari with Harari’, this serial feature employed many of the conventions pioneered by Reinhardt in his pm cartoons, but for the express purpose of political commentary. Harari also integrated other cartooning traditions in his series, notably the amusing and improbable chain-reaction devices depicted in the work of the celebrated cartoonist Rube Goldberg.59 In Reinhardt’s hands the unconventional use of Ben Day tonal screens functioned in much the same way as collage to ‘destroy’ the prominence of underlying images and structures. In turn, the Ben Day tonal screens suggested to Reinhardt a way to construct a work of art through a kind of destruction or ruin. This approach to the making of a painting was sustained, theoretically at least, by the example of Mondrian, who viewed destruction as a kind of constructive act – specifically destruction reined in and tamed by a supervening impulse towards rationality and order. In this context, the act of successively overlaying tonal screens almost to the point of complete obliteration of the base image signified a degree of control over what would appear to be a chaotic mixture
of line and form. It would not be an exaggeration to say that Reinhardt’s portfolio of cartoons for New Masses in the early 1940s took on the character of a covert notebook for his painting. These cartoons would suggest resources of expression that continued to inform Reinhardt’s art until around 1950, at the point when geometry – in the form of the grid – re-established itself in the artist’s painting. Reinhardt’s moiré-patterned cartoons composed of misregistered halftone screens are extreme and unprecedented in commercial illustration. As in the seemingly expressive surfaces of Reinhardt’s paintings of the later 1940s, particularly the so-called Persian rug series, appearances are deceiving. In those paintings, surfaces tend to be built up through a series of patiently applied brush strokes; the surface texture is consequently uniform, tranquil and, characteristically for Reinhardt, matt. It is analogous to the way Reinhardt achieved the effect of tonality in the Ben Day cartoons; a picture of incident, not an example of incident. It has been said of Reinhardt’s collages and paintings between 1940 and 1943 that they systematically destroyed Mondrian’s compositional idiom of ‘balances and counterbalances, the relational idea’, that they are ‘frighteningly all-over’ images seemingly ‘arranged almost at random’.60 Reinhardt’s propensity was to push to the breaking point the notion of ‘destruction’ of the surface of a painting. According to Martin James, the artist went to extreme lengths to achieve such painterly effects: during the early 1940s Reinhardt habitually washed his gouaches under running water to achieve a more uniform surface.61 Other works produced at about the same time display a claustrophobic surface composed using an aggregate of scrawls, washes and cross-hatching. It is generally agreed that Reinhardt’s collages of 1940 were important for the elimination of geometry, projection, sketching and drawing in the artist’s work. What remains to be explored fully is the link between how the collages were physically made and what some of the paintings looked as though they were of. Speaking of Reinhardt’s work of the early 1940s, Lippard observed that ‘there are oils from this time showing how the brush served the same function the scissors did in the collages, even to the point of simulating the angular sickle or blade shapes of a cut edge’ (emphasis mine).62 These are suggestive, highly metaphorical descriptions of one sort of painterly act assumed to be applicable only within the relatively
51
52
narrow field of artistic practice. There is scant reason to believe that Reinhardt was not alert to the expressive possibilities of collage in whatever context he encountered them. The comparisons being drawn here between Reinhardt’s painting and illustration of the early 1940s also argue for a more nuanced interpretation of the frequently cited tension in modernism between high art and mass culture. In Reinhardt’s case, this relationship was expressed on many levels, ranging from the sourcing of imagery to the technical means of production of pictures and paintings. Moreover, at various moments in the artist’s career these circuits of influence seemed genuinely multi-directional. Paradoxically, Reinhardt’s versatility and prolificity as a cartoonist somewhat obscured this relationship. In the face of a mass of hastily worked cartoons and illustrations by Reinhardt, some of which are hardly more than scribbles, a great deal of editing is required to appreciate the dynamic quality of the relationship between illustration and painting. From the 1950s onwards, Reinhardt famously dismissed any contact between art and mass culture while consistently demonizing the latter as fine art’s aesthetic ‘Other’, thus obscuring even more a tension that had been crucial to the development of his art throughout the 1940s.
comrade ad I was never a member of the Communist Party . . .63
Reinhardt was deeply involved in the extensive social network of artists, intellectuals, Party members, mass organizations and publications associated with the politics and culture of the Popular Front. Towards the latter part of the 1930s, he gained entry into cpusa circles and made contacts that he maintained, in some instances, throughout his life. Reinhardt’s participation in cultural and political organizations associated with the cpusa is impressive, but it is important to stress that these commitments continued well beyond the period of the Popular Front. Against the grain of the political tendencies of the majority of Reinhardt’s New York School contemporaries, the artist proved to be consistent in his support for the political policies of the cpusa.64 fbi surveillance of Reinhardt began in mid-1940; more than a decade later the artist was being considered as a candidate for
custodial detention based on his prior ‘membership and apparent activity with the Communist Party’. His work for New Masses, among other activities suspected by the fbi of being subversive, figured in early field reports.65 In 1940 and 1941, prior to us involvement in World War ii, the harassment of Communists and suspected Communists intensified. The Party surmised correctly that this was principally in response to their political line, which, since the Nazi invasion of Poland in 1939, had characterized the ongoing war in Europe as a ‘phoney’ war and an ‘imperialist’ war. Following directives from Moscow, the cpusa vigorously opposed us war preparations and interim measures that the Party believed would lead to military intervention, such as material and financial aid by the us to Britain, France or Poland. In a 1940 policy statement titled ‘The People’s Road to Peace’, Earl Browder, the General Secretary of the cpusa from 1934 to 1945, identified the Party’s first task as to ‘keep our country out of the European war’ and ‘to inform and educate the masses in the program of the socialist way out of the crisis’.66 The cpusa became more critical of Roosevelt’s moves away from neutrality, including the amendment by Congress in November 1939 of the Neutrality Act and the passage of the Lend-Lease Act in early 1941. These new Congressional resolutions enabled the us to support Britain materially in its military efforts against Germany while technically remaining outside the conflict. The cpusa interpreted the policies of the ‘War Party of the American bourgeoisie’ – Browder’s epithet for the Democratic Party – to mean that ‘Wall Street is preparing to take America into the war to save the British Empire from collapse’.67 Speaking to an anti-war mass meeting sponsored by the Young Communist League in New York in 1940, Browder claimed that ‘the second imperialist war, through the struggle of the masses to bring it to an end, will give birth to a socialist system in one or more other countries’.68 This political line was duly reflected in the editorial content of New Masses during 1940 up to the German invasion of the ussr in 1941. Without exception, all cartoons by Reinhardt that addressed foreign and domestic policy issues supported the Party line on the so-called ‘imperialist war’. The cartoon ‘Idle Hands . . .’ shows us a demonized personification of us capitalism gazing longingly at the conflict in Europe; ‘I deeply appreciate your action in this matter, Winston’ suggests the collusion of Churchill and the Axis in the sinking of a Polish rescue ship, and ‘war’ depicts Roosevelt out on a limb, supported by capitalism,
53
54
offering armaments to a grateful Churchill. There is even a drawing of the Capitol building sporting a Union Jack in place of the Stars and Stripes.69 As attacks by the cpusa against Roosevelt’s foreign policies were stepped up, the administration responded with a widespread campaign of intimidation directed at the Party and their supporters in an attempt to limit their political appeal and their ability to mobilize anti-war sentiment. The Voorhis Act, which took effect on 1 January 1941, was intended to compromise the legal existence of the cpusa by compelling it to register as an agent of a foreign power on the grounds of its affiliation with the Communist International (or Comintern). The Party effectively evaded this trap by dissolving its relationship to the Comintern and by modifying its constitution to conform to the wording of the Act. The Federal Government replied in March 1941 by prosecuting Browder on a technicality related to a 1937 passport application; he was convicted and sentenced to a fouryear prison term. The German invasion of the Soviet Union in June 1941 led to a crucial reversal of the Party’s position on us neutrality. After the us declaration of war on Germany and Japan following the Japanese bombing of Pearl Harbor on 7 December, the relationship between the cpusa and the us Government began to improve steadily. The Party became one of Roosevelt’s most enthusiastic supporters, urging repeatedly for the initiation of an Allied second front against Germany. It even ignominiously provided the us Government with documents in connection with the trial and conviction of Trotskyists prosecuted in 1941 under the statutes of the Smith Act.70 Roosevelt recognized the role being played by the Soviet Union in the eventual defeat of Germany and set about forging an alliance with Moscow. In a gesture to ‘strengthen national unity’, Browder’s sentence was commuted in May 1942.71 The immediate pre-war ‘red scare’ was over and the Communists defined the political task for the future as ‘the consolidation of the united nations’ total war effort against our common enemies’.72 Despite the cumulative negative effects on the Party’s influence among the left-wing intelligentsia owing to years of unpopular positions – the support of the Moscow trials in the late 1930s, the Ribbentrop–Molotov pact of 1939 – and the Soviet invasion of Finland in November 1939 – the cpusa was able to maintain its traditional social base. Although the Party
suffered losses to a higher degree than Browder had predicted, defections were not numerous and it was able during the late 1930s to mobilize labour and certain factions of the middle class effectively against war preparations. On the other hand, many of the carefully nurtured alliances formed by Communists with artists and intellectuals throughout the years of the Popular Front were shattered. As the historian Fraser Ottanelli notes, ‘fellow travellers and liberals who made anti-fascism their main concern [and] were bound neither by a sense of Party discipline nor by the priority to defend the Soviet Union’ abandoned the Party and Party-dominated mass organizations.73 Reinhardt, however, was not among them; his work for New Masses attested to his loyalty to the Party’s political policies throughout the tumultuous period from 1939 to 1941. fbi surveillance of Reinhardt was part of the Roosevelt administration’s anti-Communist sweep, an aggressive strategy conceived as early as 1936 and implemented in June 1939 by J. Edgar Hoover.74 Reinhardt’s investigation was triggered by information communicated to the Division of Investigation of the Federal Works Agency, wpa, which had indicated that the artist was a member of the cpusa: ‘C.D. Hollinger, Field Agent in Charge, wpa, Division of Investigation . . . was interviewed and advised from his records that Informant #1 had furnished his office with information that subject was a member of the Communist Party and subject resigned [wpa] before any investigation of this allegation was conducted.’75 The fbi concluded at the time of the initial investigation that Reinhardt had already been drawing cartoons and illustrations for New Masses for four years: ‘In November 1940 [Reinhardt] was employed by Weekly Masses Company, Incorporated . . . as Art Director . . . this firm publishes the weekly magazine New Masses.’ The fbi examined issues of New Masses dating from 31 December 1940 to 8 July 1941 for evidence of Reinhardt’s work. Six of Reinhardt’s illustrations were identified in what seems to have been a fairly desultory investigation; the agent failed to identify cartoons credited to ‘Rodney’ or ‘Rodney Frederick’ as the work of Reinhardt; nor did he widen the search of New Masses to include issues published before 31 December 1940.76 Speaking of Reinhardt’s use of pseudonyms throughout the late 1930s and early 1940s, Abe Ajay suggested that such a practice was ‘as much due to Ad’s highly developed sense of play/ploy as to any considered attempt to camouflage his identity for political reasons’.
55
Ajay recalled: We’d joke about it; ‘Frederick’ he chose because it was his middle name. Both for reasons of amusement and security, since we both needed to cast about into the freelance art world, such as it was, and make a living. Also, being on the wpa and drawing for New Masses was not necessarily a friendly combination.77
56
Indeed, the first fbi report stated that Reinhardt had voluntarily resigned from the Federal Art Project in late 1940 ‘during the course of investigation for private employment’. Apparently Reinhardt was dismissed earlier, in August 1939, because of continuous employment for more than eighteen months. He was then re-employed by the fap at the end of January 1940, only to resign in December of the same year.78 What the fbi did find of Reinhardt’s in New Masses between December 1940 and July 1941 is hardly incriminating; the field agent reported that ‘the sketches in themselves did not have any specific Communistic significance’ and noted that Reinhardt’s name ‘was not mentioned on any of the editorial pages as an art contributor’.79 While many of Reinhardt’s New Masses cartoons and illustrations between summer 1939 and June 1941 are chillingly subservient to the Party’s political line, astonishingly none of them is cited by the fbi. The fbi pursued various leads – there is a good deal of blotting out of names of informants on all the field reports – yet neither a criminal record under Reinhardt’s name in the New York Police Department files nor evidence that the artist had voted for or registered with the Communist Party in 1936 and 1939 was found.80 The investigation was concluded in 1942, a moment that coincided roughly with Roosevelt’s pardon of Browder. Allegations of Reinhardt’s Party associations haunted him. In 1958, in connection with the artist’s invitation to participate in an exhibition that was part of the American pavilion at the Brussels World’s Fair, Reinhardt was requested by the Passport Office to submit an affidavit concerning the claim that he had been a member of the cpusa in the 1930s and had been affiliated with other organizations described as Communist-controlled or as Communist fronts.81 Reinhardt complied with this request, writing: I was never a member of the Communist Party. I was a member of the American Artists Congress and I permitted my name to
be used as a sponsor of the Cultural and Scientific Conference for World Peace. I was never an ‘art director’ of ‘New Masses’ or a ‘member of the editorial council’ of ‘Soviet Russia Today’, but worked occasionally for those magazines as technical advisor [sic] with regard to typographical layout and artwork. I illustrated a pamphlet once for the American Jewish Labor Council and helped a friend of mine conduct an experimental ‘cartoon’ workshop for a few weeks one semester at the Jefferson School of Social Science. I was a freelance typographical designer and artist in the late 1930’s and early 1940’s, and none of my jobs had anything to do with the politics and editorial policies of the magazines, organizations, and institutions mentioned above.82 Reinhardt’s response is measured and clearly misleading in terms of his actual duties and responsibilities at New Masses. As de facto art director of New Masses during the late 1930s and early 1940s, Reinhardt was not simply producing work on specification; he illustrated key Party political lines through his editorial illustrations and cartoons and he wrote the captions accompanying his cartoons, thereby exercising a degree of control over their interpretation.83 Ajay and Reinhardt worked closely together on various publications and in a number of Left political organizations throughout the 1940s; both artists published cartoons in pm, The Guild Reporter and the National Guardian.84 Employing the pseudonym ‘A. Jamison’, Ajay and Reinhardt collaborated on the production of a number of illustrations and cartoon collés that were published in New Masses during the early 1940s.85 Ajay and Reinhardt also taught a class in political cartooning at the Jefferson School of Social Science during 1946.86 Ajay maintained that ‘there was no difficulty in agreement with [the Party’s] politics’ for Reinhardt, adding: he never Red-baited; he never was attracted to the people who were ‘running the show’, except Dave [Crockett] Johnson, Bruce Minton [Richard Branstein], and Joe Starobin. They [the Party stalwarts] could do it on a political level, but not art. They were so serious and unable to conduct an aesthetic argument on an abstract level.87
57
Ajay shared Reinhardt’s pragmatic view of politics and his disdain for the social realist artists associated with New Masses. As part of an informal educational campaign, Reinhardt gave a number of slide lectures to the editors of New Masses, using what he called his ‘wine glass’ theory, which occurs in one of the pm pages. He apparently bombed-out with them. Quite enraged with this, after a few such lectures, he came to the conclusion that the gap was too big . . . he could never really communicate with them.’88 58
Reinhardt’s relationship to New Masses was further strained in 1943, when Mike Gold, a leading Communist and novelist, attacked Reinhardt in The Daily Worker, blasting the artist’s paintings as ‘an extreme example of where the tenets of extreme abstractionism can lead one’.89 Thereafter, the frequency of publication in New Masses of original illustrations by Reinhardt decreased sharply. Between 1944 and the end of 1946 virtually no new work by Reinhardt was published in New Masses, a fact easily explained by his military service in the us Navy. Instead, one finds earlier examples of Reinhardt’s work being reprinted, some of it dating from the early 1930s and his student days at Columbia, or illustrations appropriated from his other political activities, such as his work on campaigns for the Congress of Industrial Organizations-Political Action Committee (cio-pac).90 Readers of New Masses were informed in early 1946 that ‘Reinhardt . . . will contribute regularly’; the artist’s name is mentioned along with those of other mobilized artists such as Gropper and Ajay in an advertisement inviting readers to ‘Meet the Returning Artists and Writers’ at the magazine’s ‘34th Annual Artists and Writers Ball’.91 Charles Keller, a staff-artist for New Masses during the late 1940s, reported that Reinhardt quit the magazine sometime in 1946, after a minor dispute with the editor, Joseph North.92 Other artists associated with New Masses and eager to vindicate the Party leadership have claimed that Reinhardt merely drifted away from New Masses for unstated reasons.93 Reinhardt did not diminish his pro-Soviet, anti-imperialist stance when he ceased to contribute to New Masses. By the end of the decade he appears to have successfully weathered the first wave of post-war anti-Communism and continued to participate in political and cultural activities in which the cpusa played a leading
role. By the 1950s Reinhardt would have been well aware of the risks associated with overt displays of sympathy for the Party or participation in its allied mass organizations. Based on Reinhardt’s denial of his membership in the cpusa, the Criminal Division of the Department of Justice considered prosecuting Reinhardt in 1958 for perjury. Reinhardt was never charged, however, since his connection with the cpusa had ‘existed at a period some twenty years before the denial in question’ and the Department of Justice concluded that such a prosecution would be unsuccessful.94 It is no wonder that he took care to veil his precise political allegiances throughout his lifetime. Recalling his experience with the Artists’ Union and the aac, Reinhardt pleaded ignorance of the political issues involved, adding disingenuously that he was certain that politics ‘wasn’t very serious except for some artists who felt they needed it in relation to their art’.95
59
3 ‘Painting-Reason’ and ‘Picture-Purpose’ abstract art for society’s sake Our present civilization is caught in the maelstrom of economic disorder and changing standards. An intense need for constructive thought predominates. The message of abstract painting, when utilized to serve this need, will be found to ring in accord with the life concepts of those great economists whose prophesies and plans are being notably fulfilled.1
During the 1930s a diverse group of American artists sympathetic to the Popular Front began to consider the problem of art and social agency and to theorize a relationship between non-figurative art and a passionate desire for a better world. The artists and critics that I collect under this term included, among others, Rosalind Bengelsdorf, Stuart Davis, Balcomb Greene, Gertrude Greene, Hananiah Harari, Louis Lozowick, Jan Matulka, Irene Rice Pereira, Meyer Schapiro, David Smith, Joseph Solman and Charmion von Wiegand. The institutions that they constituted included the Artists’ Union, the American Artists’ Congress, the American Abstract Artists and the Artists’ League of America, but also publications such as Art Front and New Masses. The Modernist Left occupied a cultural space in which versions of non-figurative art and formulations of socialism confronted each other as familiars, rather than adversaries.2 In contrast to the anti-Stalinist artists and intellectuals who effectively dropped out of mass political work during the mid- to late 1930s and early 1940s, many of these artists continued to subscribe to a range of modernist practices while remaining aligned with Marxism and organizations associated with the Communist movement. It is within this cultural space that we find the true home of Reinhardt’s practice throughout this period and, with its demise, the beginning of the artist’s turn towards negation. For Reinhardt, negation functioned in two ways: first, as a rehearsal of the idea that a completely abstract work of art
61
62
was not entirely disadvantageous; secondly, as an expression of resistance directed principally at the politics of culture embodied by the New York School. The extremity with which he set out his position during the 1950s was in part a reaction to the commonly held belief that to be an artist engaged with abstraction and geometry during that time was to be second rate. During the late 1930s and early 1940s it was still possible to imagine geometric abstraction at the leading edge of art and culture in New York. The Modernist Left crossed generations, national and ethnic backgrounds and encompassed a fairly wide range of aesthetic interests, all of which clustered broadly about abstract art. No manifesto was ever issued, although individual artists wrote copiously about their aesthetic and political aspirations. As was the case with the painter Rosalind Bengelsdorf, these aspirations included a sense of solidarity with revolutionaries abroad and coded references to the Soviet Union. What the artists of the Modernist Left shared above all was the desire to advance the practice of non-figurative art and to promote that art as a species of realism. The first and second generation of the inter-war Modernist Left may be distinguished in terms of the vectors of age, national origin, gender and orientation towards modernism. Regarding gender, the first-generation Modernist Left was overwhelmingly male. By the mid1930s – the moment of the beginning of the emergence of the second generation – this changed and the number of women artists among this population increased dramatically. This shift can be linked to the existence of the pwap and fap projects and the financial security they provided; consequently, women were able to participate more fully as professionals in other institutional aspects of art and culture of the 1930s. From the time of its inception in late 1936 to the mid-1940s, the proportion of female members in the American Abstract Artists remained relatively constant at nearly 25 per cent. With respect to national origins, we note that a high proportion of the first generation of the Modernist Left were European immigrants. This fact contrasted sharply with the demographics of the second generation, whose population was almost entirely composed of native-born Americans. Of this group, many artists, including Reinhardt, were the offspring of immigrants. While this group remained predominantly white and male, it was composed of a far higher percentage of female artists and artists of colour than previous groups in New York of artists devoted to advancing the cause of abstract art.
Within the Modernist Left one found individuals who exhibited varying degrees of commitment to Party politics and Marxist ideology. Some, like Stuart Davis and Reinhardt, were fellow travellers; others, like Louis Lozowick, remained more closely tied to the cpusa.3 However, the majority of those associated with the Modernist Left held more subjective views of Marxism and were generally more comfortable with a humanistic interpretation of socialism that stressed its potential to release the full range of human creativity. Many of these artists were not members of the cpusa; rather, they tended to express their political beliefs by participating in mass institutions that arose as a consequence of the Communist movement. Most remained committed to a broadly Marxist outlook, yet never succumbed to outright anti-Stalinism or anti-Communism.4 The population of this rich artistic milieu embraced a variety of approaches to abstraction, of which some were tinged with an appreciation of the role of science in the process of modernization. These artists were in general agreement about the need for centralized economic and social planning and actively engaged in antifascist, pro-Soviet and frequently pro-Party political work. Above all, the Modernist Left responded in unison to the social and economic crisis thrown up by capitalism, searching for a role for artists to play in the reconstruction of a more democratic and just society. During the Popular Front period, the activism and theorizing of Stuart Davis exemplified the social ideals of the Modernist Left and provided a strong role model for Reinhardt. Davis imagined a relationship between abstract art and society as one in which ‘abstract art is an integral part of the changing contemporary reality, and . . . an active agent in that objective process’. He was quick to challenge those who argued that abstract art amounted to little more than an aesthetic adjunct to essentially unrealizable social theories: The brains, arms, materials, and democratic purpose of abstract artists have literally changed the face of our physical world in the last thirty years. And it must be noted that the changes they have made were constructive and progressive, which puts abstract painting in direct opposition to the destructive forces of totalitarianism and reaction. Abstract art has been and is now a direct progressive social force, not simply a theory about progress.5
63
64
Reinhardt, who was close to Davis at the time, employed these ideas as the basis for his defence of abstract art during the early 1940s against the attacks of unsympathetic Communists. Most historical accounts of the confrontation between abstract art and the Communist movement stress the negligible influence exerted by the cpusa among non-figurative artists at the end of the 1930s.6 Yet a surprising number of abstract artists continued to identify with the Communist movement throughout the 1940s and, like Reinhardt, continued to press the case for the progressive, rather than meaningless or decadent, nature of abstraction. It was not easy going by any means. Reinhardt’s emphasis on autonomy as a means to accelerate the process of the unification of sensual and practical knowledge undoubtedly contributed to his isolation within the Communist movement.7 Such a view, along with the arguments Reinhardt advanced for the social significance of non-figurative art, proved to be unconvincing to many of the Party leaders he addressed, such as Joseph North, Abe Magil and Joseph Starobin. Moreover, Reinhardt’s insistence on the inappropriateness of any form of fine art as a means of explicit political education represented an unwelcome programme of cultural modernization that Party stalwarts and their allies at New Masses, such as Hugo Gellert and Rockwell Kent, rejected decisively. Reinhardt took this position because he believed in the efficacy of the mass media as the most appropriate means to disseminate political propaganda. What Reinhardt chose to deny was the extent to which the embrace of ‘socially significant art’ was a political matter of another sort. During the Popular Front, the Party’s interest in art and literature comprised one of the most visible and successful recruitment strategies aimed at winning over intellectuals and the middle classes to the anti-fascist cause and, it was hoped, to socialism. It comes as no surprise, then, to find Reinhardt’s position vigorously attacked even by those in the Communist movement who remained sympathetic to modern art. The issue that was most controversial and divisive for the Modernist Left, and thus most relevant to our understanding of Reinhardt’s role within it, was the central question of how the artist, working in a capitalist society, could participate in the class struggle for socialism. In a speech delivered as national secretary to the American Artists’ Congress (aac), Davis offered this response:
In order to withstand the severe shock of the crisis, artists have had to seek a new grip on reality. Around the pros and cons of ‘social content’, a dominant issue in discussions of present day American art, we are witnessing determined efforts by artists to find a meaningful direction. Increasing expression of social problems of the day in the new American art makes it clear that in times such as we are living in, few artists can honestly remain aloof, wrapped up in studio problems. But the artist has not simply looked out of the window; he has had to step into the street. He has done things that would have been scarcely conceivable a few years back.8 65
The artists of the Modernist Left were not unmoved by Davis’s impassioned plea to ‘step into the street’. All were actively involved in the work of one or more of the major organizations that had shaped the cultural life of the Left during the 1930s and ’40s, such as the aac and the Artists’ Union (later the United American Artists, uaa) and its organ, Art Front.9 At the same time, the social significance of specifically modernist artistic practices remained the key issue for these artists. Davis celebrated Picasso and Miró as exemplars of artists concerned with public affairs and Reinhardt and others argued for non-figurative art’s vitality as a general symbol of modernity and social progress.10 In some precincts, non-figurative art had already been charged with an explicitly functional role in the establishment of such a future; at least it had not yet been discounted altogether. In his criticism of the presumed ‘revolutionary value’ of art with ‘politically radical content’, Meyer Schapiro asserted that ‘non-political content’ did not ‘necessarily imply its irrelevance to revolutionary action’.11
the inconsolable polymath For me, there’s no need to bring a ‘painting-reason’ and a ‘picture-purpose’ together any more. I will do one or the other for completely different aims.12
‘Painting-reason’ and ‘picture-purpose’ were the catchphrases used by Reinhardt to reconcile two sets of competing obligations. From the late 1930s onwards the artist’s thinking about modernist art was never far removed from his involvement in advertising design,
66
cartooning and the mass media. Reinhardt believed that the artist could not ignore the impact of new forms of media of mass communication such as film and photographic magazines.13 He did not develop this notion beyond a general level, yet it served his polemical purpose well. Reinhardt asserted that painting – characteristically a ‘relatively private, individual activity’ – could not compete on a pictorial level with images found in magazines and on the screen. Taking a swipe at the entire public mural movement in American art of the 1930s nurtured by the wpa, Reinhardt wrote in the early 1940s that ‘if an artist is concerned with communication and a larger public he should get a job in some mass-publishing or picture industry.’14 Reinhardt’s sense of art’s autonomy was expressed through the tension between ‘painting-reason’ and ‘picture-purpose’. In a text for his first exhibition at the Artists’ Gallery, Reinhardt announced an important division within his practice, one that was not simply a consequence of his familiarity with the art theories of the early twentieth-century critics Clive Bell and Roger Fry.15 Reinhardt made clear the debt to art of graphic design and illustration, which, now freed ‘from traditional fine art elaborations’, had the potential to ‘fulfill their functions more clearly and honestly’. Consequently,‘abstract art relieved painting from its picture purpose and permitted a freer and more complete individual expression and a more direct and positive thinking in form and color’. The works in this exhibition, Reinhardt wrote, ‘are not pictures . . . The intellectual and emotional content are in what the lines, colors and spaces do.’16 Reinhardt drew these functional divisions in response to critics of abstract art who dismissed such painting as decorative and devoid of true artistic merit. Rather than inflate the practice of art so that it attained the status of spectacle, Reinhardt adopted the opposite stance and set about to clarify art’s difference from mass media in order to establish its autonomous value as art. In 1943 he wrote about abstract art as though it could be a constructive practice within a greater social and political movement. His understanding of certain Marxist texts was crucial in the development of his notion of art’s autonomy and its relation to the ideal of an integrated life. These texts provided Reinhardt with the central concept of versatility, which he related explicitly to a wider programme of social and cultural change. In this way, artistic practice and concrete political work were linked as activities that contributed to the formation and integration of the complete human being.
Numerous references to Marxism and dialectics are found throughout Reinhardt’s papers of the 1930s and ’40s indicating more than a passing familiarity with this literature.17 In a widely quoted passage from The German Ideology of Karl Marx and Fredrick Engels,18 a work that Reinhardt was capable of reading in the original German, we find the basis for the artist’s endorsement of versatility and his advocacy of a more broadly democratic conception of artistic creativity: The exclusive concentration of artistic talent in particular individuals, and its suppression in the broad mass which is bound up with this, is a consequence of division of labor . . . [W]ith a communist organization of society, there disappears the subordination of the artist to some definite art, thanks to which he is exclusively a painter, sculptor, etc., the very name of his activity adequately expressing the narrowness of his professional development and his dependence on division of labor. In a communist society there are no painters but at most people who engage in painting among other activities.19 During the mid-1940s Reinhardt advocated a future in which the ‘democratization of art’ would be guaranteed through the political transformation of the ‘social structure which permitted an imaginative artist, still, only a selfish and “isolationist” relation to his work’. This image of a world where it is possible, ultimately, for every individual to be ‘his own artist, his own architect’ was not disconnected from the Stalinist longings of the cpusa.20 The artist’s most telling paraphrase of Marx, one that also reveals Reinhardt’s deep yet conflicted affinity with Neo-Plasticism, shows him speculating on the link between the ‘direct experience’, ‘honest communication’ and clarity of ‘pure painting’ and ‘a creative completeness and total sensitivity related to personal wholeness and social order’.21 Reinhardt outstripped his artistic peers by his ability to embrace contradiction. He also understood that the fight for a new political and social world did not automatically guarantee the negation of traditional, ‘reactionary’, bourgeois cultural forms and values. While the artist may have agreed partially with Jean Hélion’s assertion that ‘the work is a solution of the subject, after which there is nothing more to do about it; it does not call for action, but contemplation’, it was Reinhardt’s optimistic conjunction of Marx and
67
68
Mondrian during the 1940s that exemplified and sustained his agenda for art and the future.22 Because of his commitment to create a space for the practice of abstract art within the political and cultural horizons of the Communist movement, Reinhardt announced that no artist, regardless of aesthetic persuasion, could ‘avoid both political responsibility and aesthetic criticism’.23 Along with other fellow-travellers, Reinhardt was ‘against a left culture which consistently valorized a realist aesthetic and treated modernist forms as at best problematic innovations which needed an infusion of “social content”’.24 Throughout the 1940s he repeatedly stressed the ‘democratic’ and progressive potential of non-objective art, which was commonly referred to by abstract artists as a higher form of realism. Twenty years later Reinhardt would offer a harsh assessment of this claim.25 Reinhardt’s uncompromising defence of fine art’s independence was directed, as well, towards other targets. He reasoned that if non-objective art claimed a privileged status within culture, it could only do so because of its intimate relationship to the technological and cultural forces found throughout modern society as a whole. Whether or not the artist is aware of it, Reinhardt wrote, ‘paintings must mean something and, at this time, very clearly’. In the context of the war emergency, Reinhardt stated flatly, one must question the ‘wisdom of any concession on the part of the painter to reach a larger audience by compromising his peculiar quality, granting also the importance of his effort in the war, as a fine-artist, not as a soldier or anything else’.26
collage as destruction A paste-up artist like Reinhardt – a ‘layout man’ – spends all day laying down columns of type and drawing red key lines to indicate the position of illustrative material on a page. This is how the architecture of the printed page was constructed before computer-aided design and desktop publishing. The resulting conglomeration of galley proofs, line illustrations, key lines, captions, page numbers, running heads and all the paraphernalia of the completed design is called a mechanical. All these bits would be affixed to a stiff, white board using rubber cement. The layout man proved himself a collagist with a purpose, which was to translate as clearly as possible the graphic design indicated by the art director’s plan, called a compre-
hensive, or ‘comp’, for short. When an illustration or cartoon was needed, the layout man was often called upon to select that image, choosing from hundreds of photographs and illustrations filed by subject matter in the suggestively named picture morgue. Today, we expect to retrieve pictorial resources from digitized clip art files resident on disks or downloadable from the Internet. In Reinhardt’s world, the layout man would need to rummage through large manila envelopes stored in a flat file or plan chest to locate his artwork. For mass-market trade magazines, an illustrator or photographer would have been commissioned to supply the required images. For a budget publication like New Masses, or any of the small magazines that Reinhardt helped to design during the 1930s and ’40s, the order of the day was to use stock photos or copyright-free artwork, or to cannibalize and modify existing illustrations. The layout man is a collagist: ‘As for collages, they are abstractions made with scissors and paste.’27 Reinhardt was producing papier collés by the end of the 1930s and into the beginning of the 1940s that were constructed of sliced magazine photographs. His painting began with the construction of a papier collé that functioned as a plan. Custom-coloured paper was cut into a variety of forms and pasted up into a composition that served as a model to be scaled up and transferred to canvas. The point was to avoid working from a preliminary sketch, to experience directly ‘color, and space structures and relationships’.28 If the artist did produce a preliminary sketch or block out the main thrust of the composition, these have rarely survived. Most likely, Reinhardt worked directly with coloured papers, pasting down and shifting areas until the right composition was achieved. The completion of the painting would then be a more or less straightforward matter of reproducing the papier collé. (Adjustments to form and colour could be made.) Sometimes the papier collé would be painted over, rapidly and freely, and blotted, as in Reinhardt’s postcard-sized Abstract Collage of 1940.29 This would soften the geometry and push the work, with some uncertainty, toward a lyrical play of floating bands of colour. These small, odd, experimental works were bridges to larger, more assured paintings that were constructed of continuous fields of deliberate brush strokes ‘simulating the angular sickle or blade shapes of a cut edge’.30 The layout man is a collagist. So it is not surprising to learn that Reinhardt sliced up photographs and assembled them in mitred compositions that destroyed every last bit of referential meaning
69
70
the photograph had to offer. We can puzzle over the identity of this and that object, but for the most part our game of hide and seek eventually succumbs to the muffled ecstasy of the surface. There is nowhere to go to find meaning, so we have no choice but to skate across the half-tone skin. It is a thin skin, to be sure, but not entirely mono-layered: overlaps and parquetry reveal Reinhardt’s fastidiousness. It was important for Reinhardt to interrupt each photograph, each fragment of an image, absolutely perfectly. The scale of these collages is remarkable, as well. With some of these from the 1940s onwards no larger than seven by nine inches, we are reminded of the dimensions of jewel-like Persian miniatures, a pictorial form admired and studied by Reinhardt, along with other non-Western and ancient art. The paintings derived from these collages were small, no larger than a tabloid newspaper page or a political pamphlet – large enough, though, to invent a universe of abstraction from a photograph’s grain. Collages are sometimes visual puzzles to be solved; a metadimension of reality to be read off the page. Reinhardt’s papier collés are nothing of the sort. They are interruptions, obliterations and exemplifications of the principle of creation through destruction. These papier collés are the result of applying the spirit of Synthetic Cubism to the matter of the mechanically reproduced photographic image. You cancel out a photograph by shredding it, artfully – just enough to dissimulate the reference, but not so much as to transform it into an ungainly patch of grey. Reinhardt’s photo-collages mostly stand on their own as artworks. Occasionally a papier collé is revisited a year or two later. This is an occasion to translate the overall effect using pen and ink, to reduce the papier collé to an elegant, spare tracery in black and white. To what end? For the sake of conjuring out of stray details arabesques, spidery compartments and labyrinths drained of their mythic charm. Yet, it remains a kind of abstraction from nature. Only now, it is the world of photographic images that is under the knife.
‘painting is more than the scum of its pots’: beyond formalism 31 The series of works that Reinhardt produced in the Virgin Islands during the summer of 1949 allude to figurative or semi-abstract subjects partially obscured by a field of daubs. The substructure or
visual ground of these paintings, described by the artist’s friend Nancy Flagg, consists of a medley of ‘exquisite drawings of shells which [Reinhardt] brutally smothered with casein paint’.32 Reinhardt’s act of destruction in the service of creation has been compared by the poet Robert Lax to the richness and variety of a coral reef, with its myriad encrustations and convoluted forms. In one sense, these watercolours of the late 1940s are sedimentations that perversely subvert traditional expectations of transparency and clarity associated with that medium. As strange as these watercolours are, there is nothing of the overall greyness or levelling of tone that we find in works on paper produced by Reinhardt around 1950. Reinhardt continued to transfer to more ambitious paintings what he had discovered through the making of a relatively incidental work. Consider Untitled (1949), in which an ultramarine ground is overlaid with a dark blue-black matrix. The ground is unevenly applied and in some areas the weave of the canvas is allowed to show through. The overall hue of the ground is also varied, with touches of lighter, greenish blues and darker, reddish blues. The blue-black matrix imparts a luminous quality to the ground, which peeks out from the thick bands like inset jewels. The ground appears to be a source of illumination, emanating through chinks in an otherwise occlusive overlay. The process of dark over light is reversed, for example, in Red, Green, Blue and Orange (1948) or Red Painting (1950). In these works, the colour appears to hover and is applied using more or less regular short, squarish strokes and deposited tone upon tone. As Reinhardt altered the composition of the ground, he moved from a calligraphic miscellany with polychrome accents that mapped out the topography of the interstices, to colour fields of minimal incident and fewer hues, and finally to uninflected monochrome. There is a corresponding change in the form of the superimposed elements, as well. Sometimes they remain relatively inconspicuous, functioning as grace notes enlivening an otherwise visually static surface, as in Blue Abstract (1947). The majority of the paintings of 1947 and 1948, riotously colourful as their ground pattern may be, are finished as it were with a monochrome matrix that functions as a framing device collecting the overall pattern into something vaguely like a centralized field. Abstract No. 1 of 1948 is typical. It shows its allegiance to Reinhardt’s spectacularly claustrophobic collages, like Untitled (1943), which is constructed principally of fragments of colour illustrations of
71
72
modern art. Number 11 (1949), one of the works completed during the summer at Henley Cay, shows a rich and visually active field of drawing and colour literally whited out as though a blizzard had ravaged the tropics. By limiting his palette and regularizing his brush strokes, Reinhardt found he could fashion a painting that settled into a kind of visual calm. Some paintings, particularly the small-scale gouaches that persisted into the early 1950s when he had already begun working on a much larger scale, effectively function as studies for more ambitiously scaled works. One can imagine Reinhardt gauging the results of his various configurations: a group of unimaginably thin slabs floating in infinite space, or a swarming field of standardized daubs deformed under intense pressure, massing against the field of vision like bugs splattered on a windshield; neither figure nor ground, pattern nor monochrome. October 1949 is an important painting of this period because it clearly reveals Reinhardt’s abiding interest in classical Chinese landscape painting and calligraphy. In this painting one finds the trails of dry and loaded brushwork and agitated, compact, oscillating and feathery strokes. His repertoire includes smooth curves, verticals, horizontals and a single ‘criss-cross’ just to the right of the optical centre of the painting. This and other similarly ‘denuded’, virtuoso skeletal compositions exemplify a parallel body of work that Reinhardt developed in the late 1940s alongside more layered, though no less meticulously constructed, gouaches and oils. Another set of variations, dating from around 1948, is far more rectilinear in composition, larger in scale and virtually depthless. In these so-called ‘brick’ paintings, which are grid-like but asymmetric, Reinhardt had discovered a way to reconsider colour. With colour areas laid mainly side-by-side, Reinhardt was able to demonstrate the relative quality of hue. These early examples are precursors to the largely monochromatic works of 1952. What they reveal is how Reinhardt’s earlier polychromatic paintings, striving for a tonal uniformity, are realized fully in the artist’s work from 1950 onwards. The absence or presence of gesture, by which I mean those highly stereotyped and modest calligraphic strokes so favoured by the artist, in one strand of Reinhardt’s production of this period is neither a sign of renunciation nor affiliation with the New York School. For Reinhardt, gesture grew out of cartooning, calligraphy and a study of Asian art. The lesson Reinhardt drew from a painting like October 1949 is that the gestural, when rendered in the
spirit of the letterform or the conventions of cartoon representation, can be used to construct a uniform, shallow visual field. October 1949 achieves this through the absence of colour. Yet it was the problem of colour that occupied Reinhardt’s energies when the kind of painting exemplified by October 1949 had run its course. The series of paintings that were most clearly driven by colour eventually prevailed and were transformed over the course of several years into the familiar symmetrical geometric schema that enables Reinhardt to focus sharply on colour. Between 1947 and 1952 Reinhardt seemed to have systematically worked through the most significant combinations and permutations of this painterly format, arriving by 1953 at a point where his production consisted entirely of blue, red or ‘black’ monochromes. In ‘Timeless Stylistic Art Historical Cycles’, a self-parody of the path of his painting since the late 1930s that Reinhardt composed as an interpretive text for his 1966 retrospective, the artist condensed and academicized this highly productive period across two dramatically defined stages: ‘archaic color-brick-brushwork impressionism and black-and-white constructivist calligraphies of the late 40’s’ and ‘early-classical hieratical red, blue, black monochrome squarecross-beam symmetries of the early 50’s’. What Reinhardt had, in practice, patiently and diligently teased out of a limited group of painterly oppositions was transformed, under the influence of George Kubler’s The Shape of Time and other rubrics scavenged from the artist’s encyclopaedic knowledge of art history, into a comedic script that was used to guide the installation of his survey exhibitions of 1965 and 1966. Reinhardt, of course, was hardly interested in presenting the struggle to reach the ‘black’ paintings of 1960 in any terms other than those related to his sense of faktura. These developments in Reinhardt’s painting obviously took place in a wider artistic and social context. Looking back from the mid-1960s – as Reinhardt did – on this period of work is not simply a matter of constructing a chronicle of negations. A conversation was taking place on many levels: between Reinhardt and himself and between Reinhardt and his peers. Personal antipathies – accumulated over the course of a decade – and the need to establish one’s work definitively in a hostile context coloured Reinhardt’s retelling of the recent past. This is why we cannot seriously expect the artist to disavow that, between the late 1940s and early 1950s, the works of Mark Rothko, Barnett Newman and Josef Albers represented little more
73
than a set of negative examples. Yet it always takes me aback to see how Reinhardt had subjected his own history of production to the kind of reduction he had previously reserved for the entire sweep of the history of art (and through his obsessive photography, other aspects of visual culture). The moment of time’s retelling, which is both coercive and liberating, was assured a happy outcome. But the resolution had a price.
74
4 The Intellectual Gift of the Post-Historic Artist ‘blue in art is blue. red in art is red. yellow in art is yellow. dark gray in art is not dark gray’: aesthetics and indeterminacy 1 ‘A color in art,’ wrote Reinhardt in 1965, ‘is not a color.’ Similarly, ‘colorlessness in art is not colorlessness’.2 The process of symbol formation teaches us to expect that colour may signify something other than a visually perceptible hue. Colourlessness, too, may serve to express metaphorically, signifying non-aesthetic attributes like lassitude or the proclamation of a defiant non-conformity. Reinhardt took great pleasure in this interpretive loophole provided by polysemy, enthralled by what he called the ‘mysterious delights of multiple meanings’. But it was really the possibility of colour in the abstract that appealed to him – colour drained of its meaning, colour as pure quality, as Platonic ideal.We revel in the linguistic perversity of those inventive and maddening texts by the artist known as ‘art-as-art dogma’, as hues and their possible references couple and uncouple apparently at will. For Reinhardt, the directness of the visual experience of pure colour that lurked in the infinite complexity of the colour sign was nothing less than beautiful.3 Reinhardt ‘makes of black something witty and perverse’, but the black in Reinhardt’s paintings does not appear black: rather an extremely dark, matte grey.4 Reinhardt tells us that ‘gloss black in art is gloss black’, not simply because gloss black is a kind of black he eschewed, but because gloss black functions as a mirror, seductively reflecting the painting’s environment. Under such conditions the situation of looking can never dissolve into nothingness as it is always drawing attention to itself and providing the viewer with an opportunity to fixate distractedly on her reflected form. Reinhardt did not immediately abandon the lusciously glowing chromatics of the blue and red monochromes of the early 1950s for the dark paintings. Rather than make a decisive break with ungreyed hues, he lingered for close to four years on the problem of
75
76
how to make a painting nearly ‘black’ or very dark. Discussions of Reinhardt’s ‘black’ paintings tend to concentrate on the series inaugurated in 1960, where uniformity of size and schemata complements the single-mindedness of the artist’s project. More needs to be said about the way the ‘black’ paintings constitute a radical reinvention of the art of painting owing to the sheer novelty of the paintings’ unfolding optical effects. The rectilinear, geometric format adopted by Reinhardt from the early 1950s onwards is absolutely crucial to the generation of these optical effects. In paintings completed during 1949 and 1950 we can see Reinhardt’s ambivalence towards the adoption of a strictly geometric structure. Red and blue hues, utilized separately for monochrome paintings and in combination to produce visually dissonant canvases, were the means Reinhardt chose to eliminate illusionist space. These works were greyed or ‘un-done’ from 1952 to 1953. (With the greying also came a change of heart concerning the scale of the painting, no doubt influenced by the examples of Jackson Pollock and Barnett Newman. There are no dark grey canvases in Reinhardt’s body of work to match the heroic scale of his 1952 Red Painting, save Black Quadruptych of 1966, which was constructed of four 60 × 60-inch paintings to prodce a single 120 × 120-inch work. Assembled on the occasion of Reinhardt’s 1966 retrospective at the Jewish Museum, New York, to the best of my knowledge it has never again been exhibited in that form.) To account for the radical ‘draining of light from color’ that characterizes Reinhardt’s work from 1953 onwards, it has been suggested that the artist was responding negatively to the strong figure ground illusion present in Josef Albers’s series Homage to the Square. At Albers’s invitation, from 1950 to 1952 Reinhardt was a visiting critic at Yale University School of Art, working mainly during the summer terms. It seems likely that this contact with Albers was instrumental in convincing Reinhardt of the need to revisit geometry and to develop a more analytical approach towards colour. In Albers’s work these two aspects went hand in hand: without the stable, straightforward armature of the mise-en-abyme of squarewithin-square, the relativity of colour perception could not be demonstrated convincingly. The question that remains is, quite simply, ‘Why black?’ It is undeniable that Reinhardt had already encountered the lyrical black monochrome paintings of Edward Corbett during a 1950 summer
residency at the California School of Fine Arts (csfa), San Francisco.5 Shortly thereafter, Reinhardt saw the early series of monochrome paintings by Robert Rauschenberg: the white monochromes at the Betty Parsons Gallery in 1951, the black, glossy monochromes at Stable Gallery in 1953, and the red monochromes at Charles Egan Gallery in 1954. Many, but not all, of Rauschenberg’s monochromes are gestural, collaged paintings where paint is applied over newspapers (two important exceptions are the artist’s fourpanel white monochrome, and his matt black triptych, Untitled, of 1951). As examples of monochrome painting, the works of Corbett and Rauschenberg were suggestive, but not necessarily seminal to Reinhardt’s project. In the artist’s view, Rauschenberg’s white monochromes were a kind of sceptical nihilism, while the black glossy monochromes committed the cardinal sin of being reflective and thereby allowing the introduction of distracting, art-negating elements into the experience of looking. Reinhardt makes no mention of Rauschenberg’s matt black work. At any rate, a distinction should be drawn between the significance that the monochrome held for these two artists in the early 1950s. In contrast to Rauschenberg’s neo-Dadaist gesture, Reinhardt’s monochromes are constructive, in that the possibility of painting, rather than its hybridization or utter negation, prevails. Nevertheless, coming to terms with these various conceptions of monochrome painting bolstered Reinhardt’s conviction of the fundamental correctness of his resolve to adopt an unmotivated geometric format to structure monochrome painting. It also strengthened his resolve to present his work in a manner that emphasized its distance from the everyday. It was black that most effectively negated hue while allowing for sufficient subtle variations through the use of progressively deeper tonalities. Black also carried connotations for the Abstract Expressionists that Reinhardt would have found impossible to resist taking as a ground for contention and deconstruction.6 The aesthetic issues that Reinhardt had attempted to work through during the early 1950s included the all-over composition as a marker for non-illusionist, shallow painterly space and the use of formal symmetry to destroy hierarchical or dynamic composition. The monochrome enabled Reinhardt to reduce the number of variables in his painting so that he could concentrate on the matter of colour. The charge of ‘minor key Orientalism’ levelled against Reinhardt’s paintings of this period, while harsh, underscores a
77
78
common perception about the lack of resolution in the artist’s body of work at this time. It remains the case that for several years during the early 1950s he was groping towards a solution that was only partially revealed by any given work of the time. These paintings showed Reinhardt what would not work within his scheme. Having worked through red and blue and white, the problem of affecting optical resonance using close-valued hues based on black was the only untested option. Once that decision was reached, Reinhardt gave free reign to his vivid comic imagination as he explored through his writings the manifold and suitably gothic cultural associations of black and the religious connotations of a symmetrical, tripartite grid – the so-called Greek cross – that defined the structure of his paintings from 1960 to 1967.
‘how to look at modern art in america: fifteen years later’ 7 Reinhardt’s last collage cartoons were published between 1961 and 1963.8 These included a single-image ‘review’ of Selden Rodman’s study on art, The Insiders, published in Jubilee magazine, an updated version of the art cartoon ‘How to Look at Modern Art in America’, which had originally been published in pm in 1946, and a flyer for a group show at the Dwan Gallery in Los Angeles.9 Of the three, the art cartoon was the only item that is invested with the vitality and relevance we ordinarily associate with Reinhardt’s use of print media. A diminishing appetite on Reinhardt’s part for illustrated campaigns aimed principally at artists is suggested by the fact that a gap of five years separates the publication of his last major cartoon for Art News – the widely reproduced, much-discussed and complex ‘Portend of the Artist as a Jhung Mandala’ – and the pictorial ‘review’ of The Insiders. By the early 1960s Reinhardt’s ideological distance from his peers (and the critics and museums that supported them) could not have been greater. He had decided to confront directly what he viewed to be the inadequate critical response to his paintings and the establishment’s relative indifference to his historical role in the development of abstract art in America since the post-war period. His resolve would have been further bolstered by the fact that the Museum of Modern Art was planning a retrospective in 1961 of the work of Mark Rothko. Reinhardt’s ‘art-as-art’ dogma eventually emerged from this
process of self-reflection, as well as the desire to publish in book form a more comprehensive statement of his aesthetic and moral position. Another significant outcome of this shift in Reinhardt’s attitude was the realization of a stunning pair of self-curated retrospective surveys. These were organized in 1960 and 1965, with the Betty Parsons Gallery having played a central role in each exhibition. Reinhardt’s 1960 exhibition was publicized through a wideranging and extremely complimentary article on the artist’s career written by the British-born art historian and faculty colleague, Martin James.10 The second exhibition, however, was far more ambitious and ultimately provided Reinhardt with the critical leverage he had hoped for. The so-called ‘red’, ‘blue’ and ‘black’ exhibitions – originally planned as an even more provocative and novel four-gallery event – presented works from the 1950s and ’60s simultaneously across three galleries. At the same time Reinhardt began to cultivate relations with galleries outside New York, a move that led to important solo exhibitions in 1963 and 1964 in Paris, Los Angeles and London. In the catalogue for the 1960 exhibition, 25 Years of Abstract Painting, Reinhardt’s graphic policing of similarly scaled reproductions of his paintings converges on the seemingly inevitable perfection of the near-black trisected square, a format he employed exclusively for his oil paintings until his death in 1967. The reproductions for 25 Years of Abstract Painting are set in a sea of whiteness that is the page to create a fittingly decontextualized index of selfsustaining production. We ought to bear in mind that Reinhardt produced this layout for a self-curated retrospective organized, in part, in response to what the artist perceived as the chronic lack of interest in his career shown by New York’s museums of modern art. The chronicle of Reinhardt’s production presented in the catalogue is a supremely rhetorical example of graphic design, intended to generate the maximum cognitive dissonance between his painterly practice and that of his Abstract Expressionist peers. While the photographic reproduction of paintings and painters at work in their studios helped to construct the mythology of Abstract Expressionism that Reinhardt found so distasteful and frankly corrupting, he employed the same media in an effort to contest and demystify the encroaching culture of self-expression in painting. Reinhardt’s catalogue layout chronologically orders two and a half decades of painting as a quintessential image of ‘art-as-
79
80
art’ and nothing else. Unlike André Malraux’s musée imaginaire, which used photographic reproductions of art to unify culturally and temporally remote objects into a single concept of world art, Reinhardt’s layout, with its strict diachronic ordering of series of developing forms, edged closer in spirit to the philosophy of art of George Kubler. Ironically, the catalogue becomes the space where Reinhardt’s art is encountered on its own, largely formal, terms. The significance of this project is not only to be found in its bald reaffirmation of the aesthetic autonomy of art. It aims, as well, to place the destiny of painting, which for Reinhardt means abstract painting, squarely in the hands of the artist.11 Finally, it was a project that engenders a seriously comic view of modernism, wherein art is compelled to wear its ludicrous fate of meaninglessness with a wry smile. By all accounts the first half of the 1960s was a difficult, dispiriting time for Reinhardt. Although he had exhibited regularly with Parsons since the late 1940s, by the early 1960s he did not consider her to be his exclusive ‘agent’ and therefore felt free to establish relationships with other dealers. While Reinhardt remained with Parsons’s gallery to the end of his life, like most artists he was sometimes critical of the way his dealer handled affairs. A few years earlier he had confided to Irving Sandler that Parsons was always prone to be manipulated by her artists, implying that she simply was not forceful enough to play the game. ‘At one point’, wrote Sandler quoting Reinhardt, ‘the gallery was taken completely out of her hands.’12 In a strong letter to Reinhardt prompted by his ‘withdrawal’ from the gallery, Parsons confronted the artist with his apparent hypocrisy: Dear Ad: I have always respected your point of view and have gone along with it whether I agreed with it or not, as I have always felt that the artist had the right to express ‘himself ’ in his own way. If you wish to ‘withdraw’ from the art scene or ‘crap’ as you phrase it, that is your privilege and right. But when you ‘withdraw’ from the Betty Parsons Gallery and yet show at the Iris Claret Gallery [sic] in Paris and Dwan Gallery in Los Angeles that is distinctly ‘unfair’ and that I cannot allow as it is belittling to both of us and I would not be your friend, let alone gallery dealer, if I let this happen.13
Parsons continued in this vein, writing that ‘protest’ rather than ‘despair’ or ‘withdrawal’ would be the proper response to the ‘whorishness’ of the art scene. The prospect of Reinhardt’s collaboration with Clert so exercised Parsons that she referred to the Parisian’s gallery as a ‘notorious whorehouse . . . where corruption seems all right’. Parsons accused Reinhardt of having adopted a double standard in New York, for which ‘morals’ were demanded. Apparently unaware of the extent of the artist’s personal relationship with Clert, Parsons claimed that Reinhardt’s problem was that she herself was ‘not corrupt enough’ and suggested sarcastically that he would be happier if she ‘was more of a belly dancer in the art world’. Parsons concluded on a rather more playful, conciliatory note, writing that she and Reinhardt ‘could learn to “sin together” in New York more happily’. Then she reported the gallery had sold Blue, No. 1-1960 to Union Carbide Corporation and that she would purchase Dark Painting No. 6-1956.14 Reinhardt had remained throughout the 1950s a highly visible and vocal artist of the New York and national art scene. If we accept his own harsh standards of success and take seriously his less glowing self-assessment as an outsider, we will be compelled to dwell solely on his mediocre sales figures and the failure of major New York museums to celebrate his achievements through substantial purchases and survey exhibitions.15 Reinhardt, though, remained adamant that it was the job of an artist to exhibit work publicly; this was something he had managed to do thanks to the determination and loyalty of Parsons, with whom he exhibited regularly from 1946. His participation in various professional art forums of the 1950s, such as The Club, the College Art Association, the Woodstock Artists Association and Philip Pavia’s little magazine It Is (an attempt to extend the reach of the group that constituted The Club), remained a significant personal investment and resulted in some of his most finely crafted and genuinely humorous polemical interventions. On the whole, these gestures were aimed at his peers and produced few discernible results; indeed, they served mainly to reinforce his colleagues’ view of him as an extremist, a moralist and heir to the purist doctrines of Mondrian. The exchanges that took place at the Philadelphia Panel – organized by Pavia in March 1960 and chaired by Harold Rosenberg – must have made Reinhardt painfully aware that his criticism of the subordination of artists to the corrupt machinery of museums,
81
82
commercial galleries and art journalism had only served to highlight his ideological isolation.16 Reinhardt argued that the attempt to introduce representation into abstract art was not only aesthetically incoherent but morally wrong. Yet, by collapsing art and ethics in this way, his argument proved unintelligible to a liberal audience. ‘How to Look at Modern Art in America’, subtitled ‘Fifteen Years Later’, graphically drives home Reinhardt’s unwillingness to establish a common ground with his peers. The 1961 version of the cartoon bears a number of significant revisions that reflect Reinhardt’s sense of loss of community, isolation and a feeling that the possibility for artists to exercise their sovereignty was now far less promising than it had ever been during the immediate post-war period. The most startling of Reinhardt’s revisions was the elimination of an entire generation of painters, consisting largely of the artist’s peers and fellow-travellers of the 1930s and ’40s: the socalled ‘abstract’ branch of the tree of modern art. To selected remaining aspects of the 1946 original, Reinhardt had set about exaggerating the corrupting influences on art that were present during the 1940s but at the time, only dimly seen. By 1961 these conditions constituted the norm that Reinhardt asserted was driving the production and distribution of art. For example, the meagre funding of damagingly competitive prizes for artists by the naive ‘business as art patron’ had expanded enormously, thanks to the sophisticated intercession of foundations that funnelled funds from business to art. Kandinsky’s slogan ‘abstract art is concrete’ had been replaced by the resolutely vulgar quip ‘money talks’. The cornfield that had once served as an allegory for American Regionalism – the cultural place ‘where no demand is made on you’ – was now populated with a more diverse canon of American (more properly ‘Americanized’) art heroes. This was where Pollock, Hopper and Gorky now resided, testifying to the accommodation of the most non-conformist artists to a univocal understanding of national culture celebrated by museums and their corporate benefactors. Even Alfred Barr’s founding triumvirate of modern art – Picasso, Braque and Matisse – is replaced by Reinhardt with an idiosyncratic trinity that defies chronology but upholds the artist’s view of the privileged position of abstract art in the history of twentieth-century art. At the same time, this grouping reaffirms the artist’s famous demonization of representation, anti-art, and the confusion of art and life. Thus, we find Poussin (a genuine hero of Reinhardt, signifying all that is vital
in seventeenth-century art), Schwitters (the quintessential Dadaist) and Rubens (in Reinhardt’s view, the antithesis of Poussin) cast as precursors of a proudly ‘plural’ twentieth-century art. That the cartoon projects a bleak prospect for ‘art-as-art’ goes without saying; its bathos resides in the way in which it lays waste to the very historical and social context from which Reinhardt claimed, in his more florid pronouncements, direct descent. Despite their satirical purpose, the widely known and highly popular art comics of 1946 to 1947 are optimistic and expansive. Reinhardt’s cartoon broadsides of the 1950s, by comparison, are meaner, nastier and unsparing of fellow New York artists. Reinhardt’s strength is to be found in his use of all manner of polarizing devices intended to reveal the poverty of the art world’s liberal consensus. His collage cartoons of the mid-1940s were intended to wage a different battle and had contributed heavily, with his blessings, to his public image as an artist. Now they had served their purpose and needed to be retired, a fact that gives Reinhardt’s final 1961 art cartoon for Art News the quality of a parting shot.
perfection and the end of art How well are we prepared for the idea of post-historic art and the arrival of the post-historic artist?17
The French intellectual and adventurer André Malraux (1901–1976) devoted the last three decades of his life to publishing works on the ontology of the museé imaginaire. This phrase, which has been suggestively mistranslated as ‘museum without walls’, raises photography as a spectre haunting our understanding and consumption of art. Photography, wrote Malraux, ‘seems to reveal or to develop the creative act; to make of the history of art primarily a continuing succession of creations.’18 Malraux imagined that the album of reproductions formed a portable museum that might replace, for the mass of people, the museum gallery. ‘A museum without walls has been opened up to us’, Malraux declared, as he deftly exploited the suggestive potential of photographic reproductions of works of art, demonstrating how images function both as pictorial resource – a record of the formal qualities of an object – and as index of the power of photography to manipulate and transform art dramatically through the use of the photographic detail, angle of attack and lighting.19
83
84
On the assumption that one must not yield to the temptation to engage in what Malraux considered to be the impossible task of reconstructing the original intentions and meanings of historical works of art, the selection and sequencing of works in the musée imaginaire can only proceed from the significance accorded these works by our contemporary experience of them.20 For Malraux, the musée imaginaire was ‘a place of the mind’ where ‘it is always at the call of living forms that dead forms return to life’.21 The musée imaginaire presented the image of a world of transhistorical art, founded on ‘affinities’ and arrachement, literally the rending of the work of art from its context. Reinhardt was obsessed with all sorts of systems of classification and ordering: his teaching notes for art history, like his writings on the negative attributes of the ‘black’ paintings, were often little more than inventories that suggested an incantatory reading and bespoke a healthy disregard for the academic conventions of the discipline. In an art cartoon by Reinhardt published in the June 1951 issue of the Parisian art magazine Art aujourd’hui, an issue devoted to American art, one finds the bountiful genealogical tree of modern art boldly retitled ‘Imaginary Museum’ in deference to Malraux.22 With its mapping of historical origins and relations of succession, the genealogical tree – hardly a Malrucian trope – charts the imprint of influence and demonstrates the affinities of schools and styles of art. Malraux’s notion of the museum as a site that ‘divests works of art of their function’, and invites the viewer to witness the confrontation of works of art as art without recourse to historical context, presented Reinhardt with an enthralling, radical proposition: that there is no such thing as a history of art, only a succession of forms in space and time, the significance of which is revealed through a process of serialization that highlights contemporary attention to, and interest in, specific details re-described as formal conventions. Art could be confronted, as it were, directly. The work of art is no longer seen as a reflection of its time and place or even a moderately dense iconographic puzzle; rather, it now functions as a cipher for art itself, its voice that of the literalist. When arranged chronologically – a type of ordering eschewed by Malraux but favoured by Reinhardt – the forms we call art reveal a number of startling patterns. In this setting, a typology of form is the conceptual new tool with which to understand the significance of art. The first glimpse we have of Reinhardt’s interest in this idea
is found in ‘How to Look at More Than Meets the Eye’ (1946), an ‘art comic’ composed for pm. One of the panels – absurdly titled ‘Naked-Mind’s-Eye-to-Eye-Witness-Report’ – is an inventory of representations of eyes, harvested from the work of Klee, Miró and Picasso. Reinhardt encourages ‘gallery artists’ and ‘commerical artists’ to pilfer this stock at will. If, as Malraux suggests, the meaning of art is known to us only in the present and is determined by the conditions of the photographic reproduction of art, then any number of sequences of images of art may be devised to fit a particular hypothesis about the meaning of art. One advantage for Reinhardt of this anti-historical approach is the way in which it privileges a formalist reading of art. Comparing works of art that are historically and culturally disjointed encourages the perception that art is truly autonomous, self-contained and beholden to internal laws of development. Moreover, the Malrucian conception of the imaginary museum provides a powerful model for contesting the ground of metaphor in art. If ‘art-as-art’ is the fate of all aesthetic production – the proper home of which is the museum or archive – then appeals to the artist’s intentions regarding the meaning of art are irrelevant. In place of the existentially charged semantically specific work of art, one finds the generic work of art, the value of which is determined solely by its position within a series of other works of art. This is a grand system to which all examples of art, artefact and architecture, regardless of origin and purpose, may be assimilated. Presented in this way, Malraux’s notion of a musée imaginaire is a direct challenge to the empirical methods of art historians. This suggests a lethal attitude of indifference to the historical meaning of works of art. Indeed, this was the basis of Maurice Merleau-Ponty’s and Ernst Gombrich’s criticism of The Voices of Silence.23 The application of Malraux’s ideological system to artefacts and architecture found in Asia, the Middle East and Africa, from antiquity onwards, seemed to have brought into being a category of ‘world art’ that paradoxically tells us little about the world but a great deal about that celebrated fiction, the ‘world of art’. For Malraux, an emphasis on non-Western art and artefacts was derived, in part, from earlier, decidedly controversial dealings during the 1920s with Asian art.24 In public presentations and throughout his writings, Reinhardt made numerous references to Malraux. In an interview on the eve of his retrospective at the Jewish Museum, Reinhardt advised artists
85
86
to adopt ‘a kind of Malrauxian point of view, in which the whole history of art is known to and is part of them’. If they did not, they would be considered ‘idiots, children or romantics’.25 In a series of unpublished notes on modern art, we find Reinhardt’s transcription of a number of statements from Malraux’s Voices of Silence, including ‘art imitates art’, ‘prime mover of artist is never life but always another work of art’ [sic], ‘Cézanne does not set out to render life, but to speak the tongue of Manet’, and ‘a painter is not a man in love with scenery; primarily a man in love with painting’.26 Reinhardt’s legendary marathon slide presentations at The Club, during which up to two thousand slides of art, artefacts or architecture drawn from diverse cultural traditions were projected over a period of three hours or more, were variations on Malraux’s theme of the ‘museum without walls’.27 In place of photographic reproductions of art printed in book format and available to the reader for leisurely contemplation, Reinhardt introduced the much more confining and excruciating spectacle of hours of projected images of thematically grouped art objects occasionally interspersed with morphologically similar objects drawn from everyday life. His narrative sensibility was probably better suited to cinema and animation, since the slide shows were less about photography, and more about constructing an image flux composed of hundreds of photographic frames. It was as if Reinhardt had conceived of a film of the visual culture of the world and projected it one frame at a time.
neither secular nor sacred There’s something nice about religious points of view in which the central meanings can’t be pinned down.28
When Reinhardt complained ‘what’s wrong with the art world is not Andy Warhol or Andy Wyeth but Mark Rothko’, he added: ‘the corruption of the best is the worst’.29 Reinhardt’s invective was prompted by Rothko’s decision to take up a commission to decorate the De Menil chapel in Houston, Texas. Since the early 1950s, Reinhardt, something of an expert on the contemporary question of art and religion, had been chastising New York colleagues such as Robert Motherwell for accepting a commission to decorate a synagogue and Barnett Newman for aspiring to religious painting in his series Stations of the Cross.30 While Reinhardt was mounting these
attacks he was, alongside Motherwell, a trustee on the board of the New York-based Foundation for Art, Religion and Culture (farc), an organization that encouraged dialogue between artists and theologians for the purpose of developing a more modern understanding of the place of religion in contemporary art and culture. Reinhardt’s reasons for maintaining an interest in religion are encapsulated in a series of remarks made in 1959 while lecturing at the Dayton Art Institute: A great many people are trying to make art a religion or have it replace traditional religion in which a god or the central essence can’t be pinned down and named. But pure abstract art is very limited as to what can be read into it. Abstract Expressionist art, on the other hand, is very open, in that people can read their own wishes and fantasies and subjectivities into it. Pure abstract art doesn’t permit that.31 Reinhardt rejected left-wing criticism of Abstract Expressionism as an art devoid of meaning. On the contrary, he sought an antidote for the glut of associative meaning it enabled and to this end he turned to Zen Buddhism. By the late 1950s he had become well known for his interest in Zen Buddhism, a set of moral precepts rather than a theology, and was deeply immersed in the writings of Christian mystics. For Reinhardt, Zen Buddhism provided a clear argument for detachment that would render a particular mode of consumption of art problematic. Similarly, the writings of a figure of piety such as St John of the Cross provided Reinhardt with a vivid description of spiritual revelation expressed in terms of darkness or the void. This resource, among others, enabled him to conceptualize further his ‘black’ paintings and to demolish what he held to be the inflated metaphysical claims of the Abstract Expressionists. During the early 1950s Reinhardt’s work attracted the attention of theologians owing to its allegedly transcendental and meditative qualities. One admirer of Reinhardt’s ‘black’ paintings was the artist’s lifelong friend, Thomas Merton. Since the early 1940s Merton had been a monk of the Cistercian Order of the Strict Observance, commonly known as the Trappists.32 Throughout the mid-1950s Merton repeatedly asked Reinhardt for ‘some small black and blue cross painting (say about a foot and a half high) for the cell in which I perch’ in the Abbey of Our Lady of Gethsemani in
87
Lexington, Kentucky.33 Nearly two years passed before Reinhardt relented and produced such a painting. Summing up his consideration of the work that Reinhardt gave him in 1957, Merton wrote: It has the following noble feature, namely its refusal to have anything else around it. It thinks that only one thing is necessary and this is time, but this one thing is by no means apparent to one who will not take the trouble to look. It is a most religious, devout, and latreutic small painting.’34
88
The painting’s effect on the beholder, especially its fitness of purpose as an aid to contemplative prayer, is eloquently articulated by Merton: Almost invisible cross on a black background. As though immersed in darkness and trying to emerge from it . . . You have to look hard to see the cross. One must turn away from everything else and concentrate on the picture as though peering through a window into the night . . . I should say a very ‘holy’ picture – helps prayer – an ‘image’ without features to accustom the mind at once to the night of prayer – and to help one set aside trivial and useless images that wander into prayer and spoil it.35 By the late 1950s Merton was making a reputation for himself as a scholar of Zen Buddhism and the Christian mystics, such as Nicholas of Cusa (1401–1464) and, most importantly, the sixteenthcentury Spanish figure Juan de Yepes. Canonized in 1726 as St John of the Cross, de Yepes wrote eloquently in his allegory on negative theology of ‘the dark night of the soul’ as a path to enlightenment; both Merton and Reinhardt cite him in their writings.36 According to the theologian Peter C. King, ‘Merton very clearly understood himself as standing in the tradition of [St John of the Cross]. He used John’s language and concepts – among others – to describe his journey of faith as a contemplative and a monk.’37 Merton was well known for promoting a meditative practice known as contemplative prayer that drew upon his extensive knowledge of Hinduism and Buddhism, both of which refreshed his practice as a Cistercian monk. In New Seeds of Contemplation, he discusses three modes of contemplation while referring explicitly to similar practices in Zen Buddhism. Reinhardt’s most private
reflections on the ‘black’ paintings are indebted to Merton’s writing on this discipline and to his lively correspondence with the artist. For Merton, contemplative practices are classed as ‘beginnings’, where the decisive moment is ‘a sudden emptying of the soul in which images vanish, concepts and words are silent, and freedom and clarity suddenly open out within you until your whole being embraces the wonder, the depth, the obviousness and yet the emptiness and unfathomable incomprehensibility of God’. 38 In Contemplative Prayer, published posthumously in 1969, Merton cites the mystics of the Rhineland, such as John Tauler and Ruysbroeck (author of Spiritual Marriage), and the Philokalia, all of which stress the encounter with God ‘without intermediary’, through ‘imageless’ contemplation.39 The dominant figure of speech is that of a ‘simple light’ that ‘shows itself to be darkness, nakedness and nothingness’.40 The contemplative’s knowledge of God is a knowing ‘about’, an allusive knowledge that denies the meditative subject mastery of the object of his contemplation. Merton called this a doctrine of ‘mystical unknowing’, one that did not necessarily disregard images, symbols or other sacramental art, but prevented them from becoming ‘idols’.41 Merton wholeheartedly endorsed the notion of art as ‘a calculated trap for meditation’; that much was clear in his plaintive letters to Reinhardt requesting a small, dark, ‘cruciform’ painting.42 In Merton’s reading of St John of the Cross, ‘dark contemplation’ and ‘the night of sense’ does not necessarily signify a complete renunciation of sensation, but allows for another mode of being within a sensual life. Throughout his long and close friendship with Merton, Reinhardt found a valuable and compelling partner in conversation and a benchmark for profound attachment to the spiritual life against which to measure the ersatz or secular spirituality with which certain artists cloaked their painting and constructed their persona. In a wonderful passage that encapsulates Reinhardt’s achievement as an artist, Merton writes that ‘in the world today, one would have to make heroic efforts to keep still’.43 Yet the point of intersection of Merton’s theological concerns and Reinhardt’s aesthetic concerns is surely an uneasy place for the ‘black’ paintings to reside. While Reinhardt shared Merton’s enthusiasm for these religious doctrines and precepts, the artist chose to consider them in terms of a matrix of social and ideological concerns. In Reinhardt’s mind this may have blunted the wayward
89
90
spirituality that Merton was prepared to project onto the ‘black’ paintings. During the 1960s, however, only Merton explored the conjunction of religion and politics through his substantial commitment to what might be called a prototype of liberation theology.44 As early as 1940 Merton was convinced that Reinhardt’s painting was religious and pure owing to the artist’s rejection of naturalism in favour of ‘formal and intellectual values’.45 The ethereal quality of the experience of a ‘black’ painting – exemplified by Merton’s commentary – is frequently used to justify a connection between Reinhardt’s art and the spiritual and has been a perennial topic of interest for contemporary critics, notably Joseph Masheck, Naomi Vine and Paul J. Spaeth.46 Rather than dwell on these associations, I prefer to explain Reinhardt’s interest in theological and moral texts in terms of their practical value as surrogates for conventional aesthetic discourse. Publicly, Reinhardt had always kept religion at some remove from his painting and was bemused by being dubbed the ‘black monk’ by Harold Rosenberg.47 For Reinhardt, the classic texts of Buddhism, Hinduism and Christian mysticism were intellectually engaging resources that provided a fertile ground for the increasingly elaborate and esoteric framing of his ‘black’ paintings. These doctrines were treated in an analogous way to Reinhardt’s treatment of the religious art one encountered in the museum: such art was no longer an object of veneration or a ritual object, but an aesthetic object. One of Reinhardt’s most pertinent citations refers to the ‘art of the Adamantine path’. Whatever connotations of self-sacrifice and martyrdom may be associated with that phrase, Reinhardt’s selection of it as a point of private reflection seems to me to be emblematic of his self-declared achievement, to bestow upon painterly practice values grounded in the discipline of egoless process. In these and other instances, the self-aware subject ‘is not final or absolute’ and the moment of self-awareness is characterized as an un-visualizable void, dissolution of self rather than a self-centred entity posited by the Cartesian cogito ergo sum. Reinhardt understood this culmination in terms of ‘destruction, negation, refusals’, an ‘unencumbered, empty space . . . absolutely intangible’.48 ‘Painting that is almost possible, almost does not exist, that is not quite known, not quite seen.’49 Here the lack of finality is grasped in terms of cycles of ‘creation, destruction, creation, eternal repetition’; the ‘made–unmade– remade’ that so clearly found expression in the various processes of making that Reinhardt had employed since at least the beginning of the 1940s.50
Merton’s analysis of Zen shows it to be a means for ‘explosive liberation from one-dimensional conformism, a recovery of unity which is not the suppression of opposites but a simplicity beyond opposites’. A well-known Zen koan cited by Merton had a great deal of resonance for Reinhardt, particularly while the latter was composing his ‘art-as-art’ dogma: ‘Before I grasped Zen, the mountains were nothing but mountains and the rivers nothing but rivers. When I got into Zen, the mountains were no longer mountains and the rivers no longer rivers. But when I understood Zen, the mountains were only mountains and the rivers only rivers.’51 Reinhardt’s version of this koan echoes the ‘repetition of formula over [and] over again until [it] loses all meaning’: The beginning of art is not the beginning. The finishing of art is not the finishing. The furnishing of art is furnishing. The nothingness of art is not nothingness. Negation in art is not negation. The absolute in art is absolute. Art-in-art is art. The end of art is art-as-art. The end of art is not the end.52 Reinhardt’s Zen-like turn to politics suggests that the radical political ideology with which he was familiar may have analysed the main contradictions of capitalism, but was thoroughly unprepared to address the question of how one is to live and go on in the world.
systems of strife The first word of an artist is against artists. The first word of an art historian is against art historians.53
There is nothing academic about Reinhardt’s review of George Kubler’s influential meditation on art history, The Shape of Time.54 Appearing several years after the book’s publication, it is less a review than an opportunity for Reinhardt to decant his churlish wisdom. On this occasion Reinhardt asks the contemporary artist to consider the superiority of Kubler’s notion of a ‘meaningless’
91
92
history of art unconnected to any other history and devoted solely to the evolutionary problem of aesthetic form. As an artist with an intense interest in art history, Reinhardt appreciated Kubler’s criticism of art historical narratives based on the work of the formidable art historians of nineteenth-century Germany. Such conceptual tools, asserted Reinhardt in concert with Kubler, could no longer provide a convincing account of the development of art. In his role as a professor of art history, Reinhardt was also interested in Kubler’s assessment of the teaching methods used by that discipline over the past thirty years. Kubler’s notion of a meaningless art history was particularly resonant for Reinhardt; it became a major theme in his polemics and a catchphrase that peppered his public talks.55 By ‘meaningless’, Kubler meant the study of artefacts in terms of form classes over time, as opposed to an approach that charted the meaning of objects through iconography or textual exegesis.56 A theory of meaningless art history, for example, certainly provided Reinhardt with a justification for his practice of organizing reproductions of his paintings as a formally coherent, reductive series. Typically, Reinhardt mined Kubler’s text for material to use in his satires. For example, Kubler’s analysis of the consequences for an artist’s creative potential of his chance entry into an ongoing tradition of object-making was wryly twisted by Reinhardt into a diatribe against the so-called six types of careers for artists. Kubler’s conclusions, noted Reinhardt, ‘are not very much help to artist-careerists looking to find out where and when to make their entrances or exits in and out of the stream of contemporary art business’.57 There are other, more poignant comments in Reinhardt’s essay on Kubler on the artist’s identification with accidents of birth, remarks that underscore his well-publicized sense of alienation from his peers and a wickedly self-deprecating humour: How will any future accounts of any sequences or series of artists in our time not take into account (as old expressions go) artists caught with their bridges down, artists born at the wrong cut of time, artists left holding bags of visions and images, artists not knowing their entrances from holes in the ground . . . artists not being able to read handwriting on walls, last-exit signs, etc.?58
Kubler’s discussion of irony offered Reinhardt a means to launch a strong challenge to existential and poetic readings of Abstract Expressionism. Kubler notes that irony is always a danger to those who believe they have a stake in interpretation, whether it is a question of deciding on one meaning or on a freely articulated set of meanings or on a controlled polysemy of meanings. An ironic temper taken to the extreme can dissolve everything. In Reinhardt’s ‘art-as-art’ dogma, which demonstrates a prodigious appetite for irony or ‘absolute infinite negativity’, the artist shows how his ‘black’ paintings destabilize a conventional interpretation of referential meaning. This argument, in turn, recalls Kubler’s attack on the philosopher Ernst Cassirer’s definition of art as ‘symbolic language’.59 Reinhardt valued Kubler’s theories immensely, but parted company with the art historian over the relationship between word and image. Reinhardt agreed with Kubler’s critique of style and eagerly applied to his body of work the concept of organizing artistic production in terms of form classes rather than style. Yet the artist could not resist using his ‘art-as-art’ dogma as an interpretive counterpoint to the beholder’s experience of a ‘black’ painting.60 In a sense, Reinhardt was endorsing an aesthetic in which word and image stand in a dialectical relation to one another. The paintings required this tension in order to be seen because the interaction between art and life, in Reinhardt’s view, had threatened to subsume and destroy art. But, it was only by virtue of the possibility of art’s final demise as a token of common culture that, paradoxically, ‘pure’ abstract art could sustain itself and appear to be ethically compelling. If the wealth of associations that came to be attached to the various public interpretations of Reinhardt’s ‘black’ paintings had not existed, the artist would have had to invent them.
93
5 ‘An Invasion of the Ultimate’
jamming Reinhardt’s circle at Columbia College during the mid-1930s was obsessed with jazz. The poet Robert Lax, recalling that time, refers to that select group of undergraduates as ‘the crew’ – slang for musicians in a group – and speaks of their moments together in terms of jamming. Lax felt that the group’s intensive repartee was not ‘a competitive thing except in the very best way’; a sign of ‘being perfectly in realization, not in potentia, but right there’. Reinhardt must have had this dynamic in mind, rather than the more obvious influence of cinematic narrative, as he fashioned and calibrated the sequences of his mid-1940s art comics.1 For example, ‘How to Look at Art Talk’ takes as given the form of a standard comic strip. Each cell encloses a dialogue between unlikely interlocutors presented in the form of humans and animals or humans and artworks. Most of the images employed by Reinhardt were sourced from engravings scavenged from a wide range of illustrated books. In three locations Reinhardt inserted a hand-drawn element to set the scene, but most cells are starkly graphic, containing a couple of black-and-white line prints and dialogue balloons. In one cell, two swordsmen duel; one asks: ‘Was not the painting freed from a “picture-purpose” so that it could become freer and more imaginative?’, and the other replies: ‘Yep.’ And so the pattern of call and response, comic and straight-man, continues across the dozen-odd cells. The captions are sharp and memorable, the puns infectious. Another in the series – ‘How to Look at Iconography’ – provides a do-it-yourself kit of images and fragments to enable the reader to create her own ‘representational pictures in easy lessons’. In a sidebar – the ‘Lines seen about town lately’ column – the punning combines the visual and the textual. ‘Frau lein’ indicates a supine female; ‘private enterprise line’ is a graphic rendition of barbed wire; ‘enough line’ shows a fish
95
head at the end of a fishing line.2 It is easy to be seduced by the rhythm and playfulness of these puns and find yourself taking up the challenge of inventing your own versions. While the strenuous intellectual demand that Reinhardt places on his viewers and readers has been consistently pointed to as the salient feature of the artist’s aesthetic, few commentators have taken the time to consider the sociality accompanying such an encounter and the important role played by mutual invention lubricated by humour. As Lax put it:
96
I mean it’s just telling each other better and better jokes . . . It was a room full of people who were trying to have a good time, in which all of them were included. I think that that was it and we all knew that if we swung right we would. We all knew each other’s riffs in a sense.3 Knowing each other’s ‘riffs’ was one remarkable element that underpinned the thirty-year friendship between Lax, Merton and Reinhardt. It was also the social glue that Reinhardt tried to apply to the corner of New York’s post-war milieu he knew best. Reinhardt conceived of the relationship between the spectator and his ‘black’ paintings of the 1960s in a similar spirit of give-andtake. In Reinhardt’s words, that encounter is simultaneously ‘personal, impersonal, transpersonal’. The relationship between viewer and work is one of reciprocity; if you commit yourself fully to the work it will, in due course, reveal itself to you. Obviously, one could own a Reinhardt, but the relationship that the artist was able to evoke through the perceptual delay of his ‘black’ paintings exemplified anything but the brisk, soulless transactions of the marketplace or the certainties of ownership. Reinhardt enunciates the entailments in a wonderfully succinct, rhetorically complex text of 1963 that announces, somewhat belatedly, the consequences of the public debut of the 60 × 60-inch square painting. The value of the ‘black’ paintings is to be found in the way they destabilize the dominant culture of art by forcing one to consider the possibility of an art object that ‘belongs to anyone who wants it’ and ‘does not belong to anyone who doesn’t want it’.4 Clearly, ‘belonging’ here means something like a state of consummation rather than the mere physical or legal possession of an object.5 ‘An invasion of the ultimate’ was one of the many catch-phrases Reinhardt employed to summarize his formula of schema, square
and repetition.6 This formula was repeated mantra-like from 1960 to 1967 so as to guarantee that the ‘black’ paintings were considered to be devoid of meaning, save the perceptual fact of the ‘monotonous disappearing image’ that was the ‘focus of required one-pointed attention’.7 Reinhardt’s carefully crafted texts on ‘artas-art’ and copious notes that fleshed out that subject for a projected book place the ‘black’ square paintings at the pinnacle of abstract art. From 1960 onwards Reinhardt pursued the potentially unlimited replication of one model for painting about painting, or ‘art-as-art’. In Reinhardt’s post-historic universe, 1960 symbolizes year zero of the project to construct an artistic practice that embodies the performance of negation in modern art. The decision to fix the limits of painting to a 60 × 60-inch square format, divided into a tripartite grid, with cells assigned close-valued dark grey hues in such a manner as to yield the image of a central, symmetrical cruciform was intended to settle, once and for all, the nature of creativity, originality, stylistic development and the signifying function of art. It did not, of course; and we are apt to find the very idea of such an ambition – a practice capable of addressing and resolving every significant aesthetic issue faced by artists of the 1960s – to be ludicrous. Indeed, Reinhardt’s manic drive to wipe clean the slate of art points to a profoundly comic side of his 1960s project and highlights a thorough disregard for the conventional historian of art. The fixed schema makes stasis, rather than change, a virtue. By announcing a definitive end to the more reactive or dialogical negativity that had initially motivated his painting up to the late 1950s, Reinhardt admitted that the battle lines of art and culture had now hardened beyond accommodation or compromise. From now on, inflexibility and dogma would be the constitutive elements of Reinhardt’s autonomy. Always the fastidious intellectual, Reinhardt gathered together the most convincing models of discipline and dogma; namely, those associated with Catholicism and the practice of Zen Buddhism. Square, schema and repetition are terms that summarize Reinhardt’s quixotic programme to eliminate all exogenous elements from art. It is only when Reinhardt establishes this ‘one speech’ to which ‘nobody listens’ and about which nobody complains,8 and this ‘one art’ that few people ‘see’ and about which nearly everybody raised objections, that we can see the grand sweep of his project of painting. Reinhardt’s joke, if you will, is that the price
97
98
of clarity of an artistic project caught in the grip of modern society is to demand the undivided attention, utter silence and immobilization of the spectator. Reinhardt’s painting of the 1960s aims to project the image of immutability without necessarily lapsing into sheer repetition. Each of Reinhardt’s ‘black’ paintings is subtly different and differentiable from the rest. It was undoubtedly a difficult path to tread, and one that became all the more so as Reinhardt pushed his paintings further towards darkness and the condition of the uninflected monochrome. The task was, in his words, to drive to the very edge of the precipice where the gormless eccentricities of art are rejected decisively, where the fashionable varieties of art are exhausted and where there is nothing to do except the same thing, over and over again, endlessly. This was Reinhardt’s glimpse of freedom, which registers for the beholder of his paintings first as blindness, then as exasperation and finally as sheer exhilaration.
rules The one work for a fine artist, the one painting, is the painting of the one-size canvas – the single scheme, one formal device, one color-monochrome, one linear division in each direction, one symmetry, one texture, one free-hand brushing, one rhythm, one working everything into one dissolution and one indivisibility, each painting into one over-all uniformity and non-irregularity.9
Within Reinhardt’s schema of painting, various shades of red, blue and green are assigned to the four corner cells that comprise the infrastructure demarcated by the so-called Greek cross. He began his work by mixing mars black oil paint with, for example, ultramarine blue or alizarin crimson in a particular ratio. The ratio, however, was based on experience and would have been altered at will to produce the desired effect. The pigments were prepared in screwtop jars by progressively denaturing the oil paint using turpentine or white spirit to leech linseed and other oils from the mixture. Reinhardt mixed the colours, poured in turpentine and continuously stirred the suspension before allowing it to settle. Through this process the oily component of the paint separated and rose to the surface of the suspension, where it could be decanted. The procedure was repeated until Reinhardt was left with a freely flowing
pigment that could be brushed onto sized linen and would dry to a powdery, chalk-like consistency. Once dry, this suspension produced an extremely fragile, matte surface. Because he wished to produce flawless surfaces, Reinhardt painted his canvases horizontally, on a low bench. Working under natural light, he would set about adjusting the tonality of the cells until the desired chromatic relationship had been achieved. Gazing intently at the canvas under a raking light, Reinhardt was able to pick out the slightest surface imperfection or sign of residual brushwork. Sometimes, he used an electric eraser to eliminate the ridges that would spring up at the boundary of two tonal areas. The work of producing a ‘black’ painting was painstaking, delicate and, above all, tedious. Confronted by twenty or two hundred of these canvases, there would be little or no sense of ‘development’ over time. What we do experience is the subtle difference between each canvas in terms of the varieties of hue and their relative optical activity.10 During the 1960s Reinhardt published several statements to announce the culmination of his painting in the form of the dark, square canvas. The first effort, ‘Art-as-Art’, appeared in 1962 and attempted to consolidate themes that Reinhardt had mulled over during the 1950s, particularly his assertion of the autonomy of art, which he expressed cryptically as ‘the one thing to say about art is that it is one thing’.11 A second statement, published in Thomas Merton’s journal Pax, was also included in ‘Autocritique de Reinhardt’, a montage of three texts published in Iris-Time (the newsletter of Iris Clert Gallery) to coincide with the opening of Reinhardt’s second Parisian solo exhibition. Interestingly, the texts of ‘Autocritique de Reinhardt’, which date from 1955, 1960 and 1961, are presented in reverse chronological order as if the directional flow of time no longer obtained and the paintings described by them are somehow outside time, beyond the very idea of historical struggle. Indeed, Reinhardt’s most potent statement masquerades as an objective re-description of the qualities and processes that characterize the repetitive enterprise of his ‘black’ paintings: A square (neutral, shapeless) canvas, five feet wide, five feet high, as high as a man, as wide as a man’s outstretched arms (not large, not small, sizeless), trisected (no composition), one horizontal form negating one vertical form (formless, no top, no bottom, directionless), three (more or less) dark (lightless) no-contrasting
99
(colorless) colors, brushwork brushed out to remove brushwork, a matte, flat, free-hand painted surface (glossless, textureless, non-linear, no hard edge, no soft edge) which does not reflect its surroundings – a pure, abstract, non-objective, timeless, spaceless, changeless, relationless, disinterested painting – an object that is self-conscious (no unconsciousness) ideal, transcendent, aware of no thing but art (absolutely no anti-art).12
100
Reinhardt’s assertion of repetition as an adequate response to the expressionist position was not without admirers, many of whom fell outside his own generation. The elegant banality of the art-asart dogma that unfurled during the early 1960s allowed Reinhardt to supplement and eventually move beyond a rhetoric that was almost exclusively centred on a critical engagement with the culture of art of his contemporaries. When he ceased to address his own generation directly, he set the stage for the reception of his work by younger artists. As the critic Priscilla Colt phrased it in one of the more perceptive reviews of Reinhardt’s work of the first half of the 1960s, ‘today there are a significant number of younger artists using Reinhardt’s discoveries both as mannerism, and more legitimately, as a state of mind and a base upon which to build new structures’.13 The younger generation that took Reinhardt seriously was heartened by his work, which ‘stopped short of abandoning painting to pass into object making’ and demolished the inflated meaning claims of Abstract Expressionism.14 At the same time, it is important to recall the remoteness for this younger generation of Abstract Expressionism and the issues that defined its discourse from the 1940s through the late 1950s.
convictions There have been five shows of these ‘timeless’ paintings in the past three years in the four major cities of the Western Art World. Each show consisted of six or seven oil paintings, all monochrome, all black, all the same size, all five feet square, all painted the same, all dating since 1960.15
The year 1963 was a turning-point for Reinhardt, as his career began to gain considerable momentum. In March 1966, while preparing for his first museum retrospective, Reinhardt published
what amounted to a declaration of independence from the milieu of Abstract Expressionism. ‘The Black-Square Painting Shows, 1963, 1964, 1965’, one of three texts appearing in a feature in Artforum devoted to his painting since 1960, is another example of Reinhardt’s unembellished, forceful prose. It celebrates the socalled extremism of his exhibitions in New York, Paris, Los Angeles and London, proclaiming them ‘the most “modern” modern art’ and extolling their virtue as the ‘logical development of personal art history and the historic traditions of Eastern and Western pure painting’.16 This statement of consolidation was composed rather late in Reinhardt’s career. Since 1953, he had used his writings actively to police the distance between himself and such prominent figures as De Kooning, Pollock and Motherwell, as well as just about every other artist working in New York at the time. Because these chastising statements were filled with humour as well as invective, they held out the promise of common social ground.17 By contrast, Reinhardt’s statements of the 1960s abandon satire and stress instead the triumph of the artist’s ‘personal art history’, which is identical, of course, to the climax of the historical tradition of ‘pure painting’ in the twentieth century. Reinhardt concludes that ‘we have to face the fact that the art work itself is the problem along with the artist and let the social situation go for while’.18 This represents a significant departure from Reinhardt’s socially informed criticism of the 1950s and one that sits somewhat uneasily with, for example, the analysis advanced in ‘The Artist in Search of An Academy, Part i’. There Reinhardt addresses his ethically challenged colleagues with a barrage of stinging questions: How can a free artist accept this managed or managerialized condition? How can an artist exist without or outside institutions? Why are so many mature artists so pleased to compete for such slight prizes, purchases, and praises? Why are there still artists who feel it’s an honor to be asked to serve on a jury to judge other artists? Why are artists so eager to accommodate their behavior to the undignified and standard forms in fashion, such as artist as entertainer, parasite, sufferer, actionist, crybaby, primitive, handicraftsman, acrobat, beggar, expressionist, clod, hobbyhorse, parrot, puppet, designer, jobber, etc.?19
101
102
Reinhardt’s ideological strategy of the 1950s amounted to a relentless interrogation of the conditions of the production of art. This included speculation on what form art would take and what role artists would play in the absence of the current institutions of art. This explains the resonance and mild anarchy of the outlandish suggestion of a ‘new’ academy, but also reveals Reinhardt’s ultimate failure to locate a new social base within which to ground artistic practice. While Reinhardt adroitly positioned his own work during the 1960s within the various strata of the New York art milieu, he could do little to develop a community of artists capable of exerting the same clout as the market-driven system of art. As an individual artist, he idealistically framed his ‘black’ paintings as works that would compete for the attention of the spectator without falling prey to the corrupting influence of having to function as one commodity among a sea of others. This issue, which preoccupied Reinhardt for much of his later working life, was never resolved socially, which is why it is generally expressed through writings that adopt the syntax of artistic practices alien to modernism in the West. His insistence on the link between the public demeanour of the artist and the conceptual nature of the work of art itself is supposed to remind artists what they lose when their production is alienated and their aesthetics no longer insinuate an ethical position. Reinhardt’s appropriation of the literary style of the Tao treatise on painting that closes his widely quoted ‘Twelve Rules for a New Academy’ reflects this loss, by once again presenting his own working methods and aesthetic aspirations through the prose style of another author, another era in art. Reinhardt does not address his contemporaries in the statements published in Artforum or invited them to dialogue. This is sheer dogma: defiant, clear and bolstered, no doubt, by Reinhardt’s recent successes and growing prestige among younger artists and critics. After all, it was the editor Philip Leider’s invitation to Reinhardt to publish in a relatively new and serious art journal with a younger readership that brought to light these benchmark statements.20 This good fortune, however, was tempered by the fact that Reinhardt remained unsettled over the lack of acclaim for his achievement and by the highly visible success of his allegedly ‘despised’ contemporaries. With the exception of Andy Warhol and Marcel Duchamp, it is the names of the New York School artists that fill Reinhardt’s daybooks and animate his most personal, vitriolic notations.
Artists of the 1960s who believed that Reinhardt’s project was in sympathy with their own ambitions, such as Carl Andre, Robert Smithson and Joseph Kosuth, were not inclined to view Reinhardt’s works as complex paintings that necessarily excluded other types of art. Donald Judd, who was interested in writing on Reinhardt’s work as early as 1962, refused to accept the artist’s statements wholesale. In a letter to Reinhardt, Judd wrote that while the artist’s art dogma represents ‘an awesome procession’, these were clearly Reinhardt’s own rules. Judd stated with candour: ‘I agree with some, partially agree with others and disagree with others, especially, as a general consideration, the one evolution.’ Robert Morris, who was involved on a more personal level with Reinhardt, expressed his admiration differently, writing to the artist in 1963 that ‘anytime, just anytime, I would be much more than pleased to put up my things in a room with your paintings of the walls’.21 Broadly speaking, the selective reading of Reinhardt’s practice by younger artists ensured that his paintings would be grasped first as abstract, polemical objects: an idea of art, out of time and space, that was supportive of their personal and varied artistic agendas. Reinhardt’s contemporaries, on the other hand, were artists who would have felt most threatened by the suggestion that a painting is a bearer of moral authority only in so far as it represents an idea of art rather than a map of lived experience. Reinhardt’s alienation from his own generation imparted a kind of homelessness to his work of the late 1960s that facilitated its embrace by younger artists. Reinhardt’s desire to locate art in a non-sacred, non-secular space was not satisfied within the existing institutions of art; yet neither was he able, or inclined, to organize a practical alternative to the network of dealers, collectors, curators and critics. Despite the financial security Reinhardt enjoyed as a professor, he craved something more than the settled life of an academic and painter. The reality that remained unmoved by the power of his satire was the formidable presence of the institutions of art, the power of the art market to influence critical attention and the burgeoning spectacle of the artist as public figure. No tenured post in academia could compete with that. It was obvious, for example, that the artist was compelled to exhibit; as far as Reinhardt was concerned, this was the main responsibility of a practitioner. While that may have been the case during the late 1930s and early 1940s, from the mid-1950s onwards
103
104
it was clear that in order to sustain a practice, the artist needed more than the recognition of his peers. When the State was a significant patron of the arts and expectations among artists of financial success were relatively modest because of an undeveloped market for contemporary American art, getting your abstract painting seen was an achievement. Now art needed the legitimating machinery of publicity, the gallery sales room and the salon of the museum trustee. By the close of 1966 Reinhardt had indeed become a public figure; his work was the focal point of interest for a number of younger artists and a new generation of increasingly influential, widely published art critics including Gregory Battcock, Lucy Lippard, Annette Michelson and Barbara Rose. Reinhardt also began to receive offers for teaching positions and even an offer from Syracuse University to house his personal papers. Reinhardt’s market profile was improving, as well: the artist was being courted by major players in the international art market, including Frank Lloyd of Marlborough Gallery and important young European gallerists, like the Swiss dealer and collector Bruno Bischoffsberger. It would be comforting to think that Reinhardt rejected their advances, yet we have no evidence to support such a claim. While Reinhardt remained with Betty Parsons Gallery, it is evident that he felt unconstrained by that professional relationship and exhibited at other galleries in and outside New York, as he pleased. Reinhardt’s rhetorical ‘new academy’ did not survive into the 1960s. Once his vision of art was secured through the stable production of the ‘black’ square paintings, Reinhardt was more inclined to return to another of his deep convictions, namely that ‘art is involved in a certain kind of perfection’. Specifying what this might mean in terms of the realities of social and political organization, for the artist among artists or the artist within society, was a task that fell largely to the new generation of artist-activists of the late 1960s.22
realignment A general ungentlemanly agreement that ‘artists should not talk’ prevents artists from twinging each others’ consciences nowadays. A popular myth that ‘the dirty work’ takes place only outside the artist’s studio and not in his own mind also helps ease the artist’s
burden and helps make his shame a little more shameless. But if the art world is a ‘sink of corruption and crime’ that the poor struggling artist never made, who did?23
Against the likes of Andy Warhol’s expert manipulation of the media, the scripted anarchy of Allan Kaprow’s ‘Happenings’ or the participatory avant-garde antics of Fluxus, Reinhardt’s interventions must have seemed ever more quaint and alienated from the new historical configuration that revived an interest in the conjunction of art and programmes of social transformation. That is, until the late 1960s, when younger artists and critics began to rally behind Reinhardt’s slogans, and the artist’s pronouncements began to sound to them less like elaborate jokes. Reinhardt’s objections were understood as something other than an acceptable adjunct to mainstream art discourse or a provocative spice interjected by a man only half-serious. By the early 1960s, in Reinhardt’s view, the art world had outstripped his literate criticism and was beyond his reach as a satirist. Reinhardt was doubtless aware of the limits of irony and satire; nevertheless that knowledge did not shield him from experiencing a profound sense of pessimism about the future of his artistic project. The crisis of his last years was fuelled, in my view, by his realization that it was no longer clear how he could mediate or fix the meaning of the ‘black’ paintings, or even if such avant-garde work had a future. He was adamant about the necessity for an artist to control the reception of his work, yet found it impossible to control this framing without resorting to controversy of one sort or another.24 At the opening of the 1960s Reinhardt had not yet established a firm position of authority from which he could turn the art world on its head. Reinhardt’s inclination to befriend and accept younger artists, especially during the 1960s, pointed to the possibility of establishing a new base of authority. The emergence of artists like Robert Morris, Donald Judd, Bridget Riley and Carl Andre presented him with the opportunity to claim a bit of turf that was far removed from the sordid social entanglements of his contemporaries. There was also the support of artists Reinhardt had known since the 1950s, such as Tony Smith, Ellsworth Kelly and Agnes Martin. In the event Reinhardt did not have the opportunity to adjust himself successfully to what he termed the non-environment of the New York art world. He simply died too soon after hitting his
105
106
stride to make much of his newly found prestige among younger artists. Reinhardt’s hilarious and sarcastic confession directed to the art critics Thomas Hess and John Canaday, exclaiming that 1966 would be the year he had decided to ‘sell out’, may be read in this light.25 For all its sarcasm and irony, it stands as a veiled admission of a terrifying personal prospect for the artist, that the art world could render his life’s work a bit of harmless fun. Such a reception had the potential to do more than transform Reinhardt into a clown. What was truly at stake was the survival of a conception of artistic freedom, constructed out of the conjunction of ‘old left’ Marxism and abstract painting, that Reinhardt fought to uphold for three decades.26 The eclipse of this paradigm amounted to a cultural ‘death’, the utter collapse of a space for learning and sharing that Reinhardt’s versatility and allegiance to negation had struggled to maintain and make plausible as a means of continuation of a critically inflected artistic practice. That death – in the guise of a contemptible cultural indifference by capitalism to art – would amount to genuine meaninglessness, as opposed to merely the ‘meaninglessness’ of ‘reform’ and ‘atonement’ or the lyric cycle of the ‘almost’.27
6 ‘Every Dogma Has Its Day’
‘the re-reformulation of formalism’ 1 During the summer of 1964 the young American artist Robert Morris was travelling in Europe. While visiting Great Britain, Morris posted the following message to Reinhardt, written on a picture postcard of the Neolithic and Bronze Age stone circle of Stonehenge in the Wiltshire Downs: ‘Before plywood they did pretty good. Fantastic sights in The National Gallery and British Museum, too. The artists import a lot of Greenberg here. I’m on my way to perform in Stockholm. Best regards, Bob Morris.’2 Morris’s remark on Clement Greenberg’s influence on British art is borne out by John Hoyland, one of many British artists who had visited New York during the 1960s and encountered first hand the work of Kenneth Noland, Jules Olitski, Barnett Newman, Mark Rothko, David Smith and Reinhardt. While some critics held the Americans in high regard, Greenberg’s reception in Britain was not entirely welcoming; John Latham responded to the critic’s authority through the much-discussed performance prop, Art and Culture (1966–9).3 Reinhardt enjoyed a different reputation in Britain, one that was based in equal measure on his art and his polemics. The latter were decidedly opposed to Greenberg’s machinations in art; that struck a chord with some young British painters who were more than willing to tackle the challenge of comparing the aesthetic positions of the two. Reinhardt’s paintings were first received in Britain as part of the considerable influx of American art that began during the late 1950s. Yet he was absent from The New American Painting, a major European touring exhibition curated by Dorothy Miller and Frank O’Hara under the auspices of the Museum of Modern Art’s International Council and remained far from Greenberg’s imprimatur.4 In a pattern that would become typical of Reinhardt’s exposure in group exhibitions during the 1960s, he was presented to the
107
British public in a context far removed from the expected generational setting of contemporaries such as Rothko, Newman and Still. Initially, Reinhardt found this state of affairs distressing but did not refuse to participate in such exhibitions; ironically, his presence in group exhibitions that consisted principally of younger artists did much to enhance his reputation during the mid-1960s. An anecdote by the curator Bryan Robertson on the subject of Mark Rothko’s retrospective mounted at the Whitechapel Gallery, London, from 10 October to 12 November 1961, suggests what would have been lost to the public when Reinhardt’s work was torn from the sympathetic aesthetic context of one of his contemporaries: 108
Late one winter afternoon, when the daylight had practically gone . . . [Mark Rothko] asked me to switch all the lights off, everywhere; and suddenly, Rothko’s colour made its own light: the effect, once the retina had adjusted itself, was unforgettable, smouldering and blazing and glowing softly from the walls – colour in darkness.5 Reinhardt, of course, was mindful of the resonance that existed between his work and that of Rothko’s. When he wrote that ‘Abstract-Expressionists acted as if I were betraying them but they were betraying me for two decades’, Reinhardt reserved a special chastisement for Rothko, whom he accused of having ‘sold out’ during the 1960s.6 After Reinhardt’s death, his estranged friend Rothko returned the compliment after a fashion, remarking with regret that he should have painted those late, dark works.7 Reinhardt’s exclusion, during the late 1950s, from major museum survey exhibitions of post-war painting was personally hurtful, removing him from a context that he considered to be necessary for the continuation of his project, effectively isolating his work. It was one thing to place oneself intentionally at the margins, or, to set oneself the task of working against one’s peers; it was quite another state of affairs to suffer exile. British artists who had seen Reinhardt’s paintings in a setting that explicitly worked against gestural painting were astute enough to distinguish his work from the mass of so-called ‘hard edge’ painting and the work of other young American abstract painters being strenuously promoted in London by Greenberg. As early as 1961, Reinhardt’s close-valued ‘black’ paintings were presented to
Londoners in the context of ‘hard edge’ painting in a provocative exhibition titled Six American Abstract Painters at Arthur Tooth & Sons gallery (24 January–18 February 1961). The exhibition included work by Ellsworth Kelly, Agnes Martin, Alexander Liberman, Leon Polk Smith and Sidney Wolfson. The accompanying catalogue contained an awkward introductory essay by Lawrence Alloway that sought to justify this grouping of artists. The artists under scrutiny, in fact, were all represented by Betty Parsons, who must have grasped the strategic importance of introducing to the London art scene artists who were not necessarily part of the charmed circle of painters that would eventually be endorsed by Greenberg under the rubric post-painterly abstraction. Alloway, a British art critic well known for his associations with British Pop art, was favorably disposed towards American art and would eventually find a home in the us, where he held the post of curator at the Guggenheim Museum. In his essay for Six American Abstract Painters, Alloway stressed a set of common aspects to be found in the work of these painters that he enumerated as ‘forms that are few in number, though not necessarily simple in function’, immaculate, yet active surfaces, forms bounded by edges that are ‘hard and clear’, and the absence of the ‘traditional primacy of figure–field relationships’.8 The emphasis placed on these formal qualities and their bearing on the perceptual effects experienced by the viewer allowed Alloway to argue for their importance as art against the prevailing aesthetic of so-called Action Painting. Turning to Reinhardt’s work – represented by three paintings: a 152 × 101 cm (60 × 40 in) red painting of 1952 and two, smaller paintings, dated 1958 (‘black’ and blue) and 1960 (‘black’) – Alloway remarked on the ‘subtle activity of the colour’ that dissolves their symmetrical schema into a kind of ‘optical drama’. This drama, exemplified by Reinhardt’s ‘tender, fine, matt surfaces’, was named by Alloway as ‘incertitude economically presented’. This phrase referred to a wide range of perceptually complex art that simultaneously attracted and repelled the spectator. The spectator is involved, in Alloway’s view, because the close-valued colours render the schema difficult to perceive. This essential tension of Reinhardt’s work, as described by Alloway, would be challenged a few years later by Michael Fried, who brushed it aside as little more than an ‘incidental effect’, asserting that the ‘zones’ of close-value colour characteristic of the artist’s trisected ‘black’ paintings
109
110
remained, in his view, constantly and unfluctuatingly bounded.9 David Sylvester, in an insightful and enthusiastic review of Reinhardt’s 1964 exhibition at the Institute for Contemporary Art, London (ica), also tackled the question of the painting’s surface and its role in shaping the spectator’s engagement with the work, writing that it began to ‘sing’ as the ‘subtle variations of tone and colour’ became perceptible. ‘Once involved in any of these paintings’, continued Sylvester, ‘my entire capacity for attention has been focused into gazing at a contrast of colours that is scarcely perceptible and totally absorbing.’10 To be fair to Alloway, both Fried and Sylvester were describing the experience of engaging with a group of Reinhardt’s later, darker, identically scaled, ‘black’ paintings. Nevertheless, Alloway recognized a similar, though far less intense, sensation in the Tooth gallery’s modest and less coherent selection of Reinhardt’s paintings. For Alloway, however, the ‘drama’ of engaging with Reinhardt’s paintings was far from unequivocal in terms of the demands it made on the viewer. Presumably this means the difficulty one experiences in trying to resolve the schematic divisions of the surface painting while at the same time trying to grasp it as a monochromatic gestalt. It was ‘the difficulty of making accurate observation’ that registered for Alloway as the hook that Reinhardt used to snare the spectator. The technical means employed by Reinhardt to achieve this duality – ‘the tender, fine, matt surfaces’ – serve to withdraw the painting from the spectator. Alloway remained unnerved, though not unmoved: ‘one’s feeling is . . . of facing something deposited with us by a fanatic craftsman’, something ‘arrested and yet out of reach’.11 In the end Alloway must have surely understood the need to revise his judgement regarding the ‘common subject’ of this disparate grouping of artists. A common problem, perhaps, was in everyone’s sights, yet it was resolved by these artists with something less than an identity of motives and means.12 What Alloway’s remarks point to is the difficulty at the time of seizing a critical space for non-gestural abstract painting that lay outside the scope of Greenberg’s theory of modernist painting. This is particularly the case when the kind of optical experience invoked by Reinhardt’s paintings is so nuanced and fugitive compared to the works of Morris Louis and Kenneth Noland. The critical reception in London of Reinhardt and other American abstract artists was clearly not a matter of detached
aesthetic debate within the confines of the art world. At the time American cultural exchanges were seen by many as an unwanted imposition on an already vibrant cultural scene; this was a response that persisted throughout the 1960s and ’70s. Nevertheless, Greenberg’s view of modernism and the American and British artists he promoted remained influential and vital to the artistic development of one stratum of British artists and critics who came of age during the 1960s. This remained the case well into the late 1960s, even as Minimal art and Conceptual art were beginning to gain a foothold in the uk. By the mid-1970s, however, Greenberg’s critical theories were being widely challenged by artists and his influence had waned considerably.13 Some artists, such as Latham and Bridget Riley, were early sceptics of Greenberg’s imperiousness, which exemplified, in their view, the harsh, often crude commercial realities of the New York art scene. Above all, what lay behind the resistance to the prevalence of American art in London was the reality of the Vietnam War and the basing of American nuclear weapons on British soil. Both political policies were highly unpopular and gave rise during the 1960s to formidable mass protests and informed many of the artistic practices of the time, from the controversial performance work of Stuart Brisley to the extreme ‘destructive’ art of Gustav Metzger. While artists working in London during the 1960s would have had an opportunity to acquaint themselves with Reinhardt’s work first hand, it is fair to say that until 1964 they had hardly encountered a sufficient concentration of works to appreciate fully the artist’s achievement. Then came what must have seemed a veritable onslaught: three ‘black’ paintings were included in Painting and Sculpture of a Decade, 54–64 at the Tate Gallery (22 April–28 June) and a further nine for Reinhardt’s first one-person exhibition in London, which took place at the Institute for Contemporary Art. Reinhardt, already travelling in Europe, made his way to London, with wife and daughter in tow, to deliver a talk at the ica. Thanks to the efforts of the British artist Robyn Denny – an important abstract painter of the 1960s and an ardent admirer of Reinhardt’s work – the transcript of Reinhardt’s talk was published several months after the artist’s death.14 For Denny, the qualities that set Reinhardt apart from other American artists were his reputation as a severe critic of Abstract Expressionism, a debunker of the fraudulence of the art world and a guarantor of art’s independence. In
111
112
general, the response by London in 1964 to Reinhardt’s paintings and his ideas was thoughtful and highly favourable; they made a tremendous impression on young artists and helped to establish his reputation as an uncompromising, sophisticated and critically astute American artist. While the London tabloids were predictably aghast at the prospect of blank ‘black’ monochromes, more serious critics such as Sylvester and Guy Brett lauded Reinhardt’s consistent development and ranked him ‘among the best of American abstract painters’.15 In the wake of the ica exhibition, Reinhardt was invited by Gustav Metzger to participate in the Destruction in Art Symposium (dias),16 a seminal protest event for the politicized avant-garde. Among the more notable works included was Latham’s infamous tower of burning books (the so-called ‘Skoob towers’), conceived to foreground the artist’s eccentric theories of time, space and information. In 1961 Metzger had demonstrated his ‘auto-destructive art’ in a performance work titled provocatively Acid Action Painting, wherein acid was sprayed onto three large nylon panels, the point being literally to destroy the ground of illusion in the course of ‘creation’ of the work. Metzger’s manifestos on auto-destructive art offered a blunt, panoramic critique of culture, referring openly to the Cold War, the threat of nuclear armaments and the massive expenditures by the British government on defence, as well as the stifling influence of the art market and its institutions. Reinhardt asked that his text ‘39 Art Planks: Programs for “Program” Painting (Art-as-Art Dogma, Part vii)’ be read at the symposium. In these patently hilarious principles of aesthetic unity, one finds stinging references to precisely the sort of painting championed by Greenberg’s adherents, alongside Reinhardt’s characteristically hyperbolic moral dicta: ‘1. The re-obliteration of the horizontal band . . . 12. The re-abstraction of abstraction of abstraction . . . 31. The re-reformulation of formalism . . . ’ and ‘35. The re-rejection of the hero-whoreo-artist-man-of-the-world role’.17
‘a dark flame, fog forming in the unformed’: responsive eyes 18 Around May 1964 the Scottish artist Ian Hamilton Finlay encountered Reinhardt’s paintings for the first time in reproduction. Despite the fact that Finlay had not actually seen Reinhardt’s paintings
face to face, their impact on him was considerable; enough, in fact, to prompt Finlay to ask Reinhardt to produce an entire issue of his self-published journal of lyric and concrete poetry Poor. Old. Tired. Horse.19 What impressed Finlay most about Reinhardt’s painting was its ‘great dignity and seriousness’, a ‘cool quality but by no means cold’, ‘the only thing really like Malevich I’ve ever seen’. Finlay had been inclined to pepper with irony his own intimate captioned images and concrete poetry and was beginning to feel restless with that approach. ‘I used to use humour to make a distance and keep it art but now I feel that as being an inadequate means.’ What Finlay learned from Reinhardt’s example was a kind of gravity and a possible way out of his own creative impasse. Finlay told Reinhardt how the presence of humour in his concrete poetry functioned as an antidote to what he called Scottish heaviness, a quality that Finlay opposed to gravity. Finlay elaborated on his dissatisfaction with humour in his work, arguing for the necessity of the distinction between ‘evening poems as well as afternoon ones’. Taking Reinhardt to be a kindred spirit, Finlay had confided to Robert Lax, with whom he had an independent relationship, that Reinhardt ‘is a man I would like to talk to – and there aren’t many people I feel like that about nowadays’.20 Finlay made good his intention to invite Reinhardt to produce an issue of Poor. Old. Tired. Horse. (p.o.t.h.), proposing that the issue consist of the usual eight pages and be printed in offset lithography on stiff card stock, the final trim size measuring 16.5 × 23 cm (6 × 9 in). ‘Your pictures’, Finlay wrote, applying a typically British colloquialism to abstract paintings that would have certainly irritated Reinhardt, ‘please me very much by having this distance, they are absolutely art, and by not being funny.’ Finlay’s tone remained respectful and generous. ‘I like them and I wrote everyone about them. With a certain sense of awe, for I reckoned that anyone who is not thick, and who can have that distance, and yet be grave, is remarkably an adult.’21 Ultimately, Reinhardt never produced an entire number of p.o.t.h. as Finlay had hoped. It would not be until late 1965 that Reinhardt would begin to devise his contribution to Finlay’s journal. The passage of time and the circumstances under which it was offered make it a lukewarm gesture of support for Finlay’s concrete poetry project and more of a testament to his newly forged friendship with the young British artist Bridget Riley.
113
114
Reinhardt met Riley for the first time in 1965 when she travelled to New York to open an exhibition at Richard Feigen Gallery and to participate in William Seitz’s Museum of Modern Art exhibition, The Responsive Eye.22 A detail of Riley’s painting Current (1964) figured on the cover of the catalogue. At Reinhardt’s urging, Finlay invited Riley to contribute to p.o.t.h. Riley agreed to participate in the project, writing to Reinhardt that ‘this [Finlay’s invitation and a selection of his books] with your own letter, made the whole idea irresistible’.23 ‘The little publication for p.o.t.h. was a collaboration’, noted Riley, ‘Reinhardt wrote to ask me to do the images and he wrote one of his wonderful “Art is not” [sic] pieces around them.’ The resulting work is a double-page spread in which Riley’s large zeros – Untitled (Fragment 4) of 1965 – dynamically complement Reinhardt’s text, which is rendered in his distinctive calligraphic hand and arranged at a diagonal on the page. There was certainly much of mutual interest that Reinhardt and Riley could discuss and argue about in terms of painting. ‘In my earlier paintings’, Riley explained, ‘I wanted the space between the picture plane and the spectator to be active. It was in that space, paradoxically, the painting “took place”.’24 The issues that were central to her work during the mid-1960s were revealed in a short article, ‘Perception is the Medium’, commissioned for Art News by Thomas Hess.25 Riley shared with Reinhardt a handwritten draft in which she not only elaborated ideas that formed the basis for her painting but also expressed ‘feelings of violation and disillusionment’ at the way her work Hesitate (1964) had been ‘vulgarized in the rag-trade’ by the art collector and dress manufacturer Larry Aldrich. Riley, like Reinhardt, was hardly interested in ‘boundary-crossing’ to the extent exemplified in the work of the late 1950s and early 1960s of British painters such as Robyn Denny and Peter Hobbs. Her first experience of New York was coloured by the depressing consequences of The Responsive Eye, which elicited ‘an explosion of commercialism, bandwaggoning and hysterical sensationalism’. ‘Virtually nobody in the whole city’, Riley bemoaned, ‘was capable of the state of receptive participation that is essential to the experience of looking at pictures. Misunderstandings and mistaken assumptions took the place of considered and informed judgement.’ The substance of many of these complaints resonated alongside Reinhardt’s aesthetic morality, although he would have probably been perturbed by Riley’s suggestion that
her ‘paintings have some affinity with “happenings”, where the disturbance precipitated is latent in the sociological and psychological situation.’26 Following Reinhardt’s lead, commentators have generally questioned the appropriateness of the artist’s inclusion in The Responsive Eye. On that basis we might be inclined to conclude that The Responsive Eye merely compounded the error that landed Reinhardt in the 1961 exhibition Six American Abstract Painters. (Some of the artists in that exhibition – Ellsworth Kelly, Alexander Liberman, Leon Polk Smith – were also selected for The Responsive Eye.) By 1960 Reinhardt’s reputation among some curators as a difficult character coupled with his middling commercial position did not allow him to argue effectively for the placement of his work in key, historically appropriate exhibitions. Rather than stoically accept relegation to a marginal position with respect to his contemporaries, Reinhardt remained open to the prospect of working with younger artists, many of whom were not yet securely ‘located’ within contemporary critical discourse. Reinhardt’s interest in the work of Ellsworth Kelly, for example, and his willingness to collaborate with Riley should be viewed, in part, in this light. While Reinhardt’s painting enjoyed a relatively high degree of critical visibility throughout the 1950s, the terms of its reception during the early 1960s clustered unhelpfully about a lexicon of extremism and ‘purity’ and the artist’s link to Mondrian. In my view, Reinhardt’s inclusion in The Responsive Eye was a boon to his career. In his catalogue essay, Seitz deals with Reinhardt’s painting under the rubric ‘invisible painting’. Such a category poss