Democratic Government in Poland Constitutional Politics since 1989
George Sanford
Democratic Government in Poland
A...
20 downloads
984 Views
839KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Democratic Government in Poland Constitutional Politics since 1989
George Sanford
Democratic Government in Poland
Also by George Sanford POLISH COMMUNISM IN CRISIS MILITARY RULE IN POLAND: The Rebuilding of Communist Power 1981–1983 THE SOLIDARITY CONGRESS, 1981 DEMOCRATIZATION IN POLAND, 1988–90: Polish Voices POLAND: World Bibliographical Series (with A. Gozdecka-Sanford) HISTORICAL DICTIONARY OF POLAND (with A. Gozdecka-Sanford) BUILDING DEMOCRACY: The International Dimension of Democratization in Eastern Europe (with G. Pridham and E. Herring) POLAND: The Conquest of History
Democratic Government in Poland Constitutional Politics since 1989 George Sanford Reader in Politics University of Bristol
© George Sanford 2002 All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1T 4LP. Any person who does any unauthorised act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The author has asserted his right to be identified as the author of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. First published 2002 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010 Companies and representatives throughout the world PALGRAVE MACMILLAN is the new global academic imprint of the Palgrave Macmillan division of St. Martin’s Press, LLC and of Palgrave Macmillan Ltd. Macmillan® is a registered trademark in the United States, United Kingdom and other countries. Palgrave is a registered trademark in the European Union and other countries. 0–333–77475–2 This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Sanford, George. Democratic government in Poland : constitutional politics since 1989 / George Sanford, p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0–333-77475–2 (cloth) 1. Poland–Politics and government–1989– 2. Contitutional history–Poland. I. Title. JN6760 .S26 2002 320.9438–dc21 2002020059 10 11
9 10
8 09
7 08
6 07
5 06
4 05
3 04
2 03
1 02
Printed and bound in Great Britain by Anthony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham and Eastbourne
Contents List of Tables
vii
List of Abbreviations
viii
Preface
xiii
Chronology
xv
1
The Constitution and History Poland’s quest for security and modernization Historical traditions and constitutional values The effects of foreign rule and war on state institutions Constitutions and political frameworks The usable past of Polish constitutionalism
1 1 4 10 11 15
2
The Communist Experience and Legacy The debate on the Polish People’s Republic The communist party-state in Poland The significance of communist constitutionalism Judgement on the PRL (Polish People’s Republic)
24 24 27 31 39
3
Democratic Transition and Consolidation The constitutional abdication of communism The controlled transition in practice The consolidation of democracy
50 50 56 60
4
Constitution Making and Consensus Building National sovereignty and citizenship Constitutional engineering and institution building The politics of the temporary: writing the Little Constitution Towards the 1997 constitution The April 1997 constitution
74 74 76 80 85 91
5
Parliament and Democratic Politics Organization, functioning and composition of the Sejm Deputies Legislation Debates and plenary sessions Committees Parliamentary control of government Organization, functioning and composition of the Senate Rationalized parliamentarianism? v
103 105 110 115 120 120 123 124 128
vi Contents
6
The Executive: Dual or Fragmented? The presidency Formation, dismissal and accountability of governments The Council of Ministers The emergence of the prime minister Mechanisms of coalition government From Office of the Council of Ministers (URM) to cabinet office Ministries What sort of executive in Poland?
138 138 147 151 155 157 162 164 166
7
Government and the Mechanisms of Representation Electoral framework Presidential elections Sejm elections Senate elections Local government elections Dynamics and political consequences of voting behaviour Party system and government
173 173 176 183 188 188 190 192
8
The Active Constitution in Practice The constitutional and state tribunals Organs of state control and rights protection The Lustration Act and process
208 208 216 219
9
Conclusion: the Polish Constitution as a Framework for Democracy
230
Bibliography Index
236 247
List of Tables 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7 5.8 5.9 5.10 5.11 5.12 6.1 6.2 6.3 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5
Polish deputies by gender Polish deputies by age Number of Sejm terms sat by Polish deputies on election Polish deputies by education Polish deputies by occupation Source of legislative initiative The work of the Sejm Sejm committees Political composition of the Senate The work of the Senate Political composition of the Sejm Party control of the Sejm Duration and type of government Size and composition of the Council of Ministers Party composition of governments Presidential election of 25 November–9 December 1990 Presidential election of 5–19 November 1995 Presidential election of 8 October 2000 Percentage of votes and seats and number of seats gained in Sejm elections of 1991, 1993, 1997 and 2001 Size of party membership
vii
111 111 112 112 113 117 119 122 126 127 130 131 150 154 159 178 180 182 184 194
List of Abbreviations AK AWS AWS-RS BBN BBWR BdP BSiE CAP CBOS CDIIIRP COMECON CPSU CUP EBRD EU FDP FJN GATT GDP GKBZpNP
GUC GUS IFiS IMF IPN ISP KAW KIE
Armia Krajowa/Home Army Akcja Wyborcza ‘Solidarno´sc´ ’/Electoral Action Solidarity Akcja Wyborcza ‘Solidarno´sc´ ’–Ruch Spol⁄ eczny/Electoral Action Solidarity–Social Action Biuro Bezpiecze´nstwo Narodowego/National Security Bureau Bezpartyjny Blok Wspierania Reform/Non-Party Bloc for Supporting the Reforms Blok dla Polski/Bloc for Poland Biuro Studiów i Expertyz/Bureau of Studies and Reports (Analyses), Sejm Chancellery Common Agricultural Policy Centrum Badania Opinia Spol⁄ ecznej/Centre for the Study of Public Opinion Chrze´scia´nska Demokracja III RP/Christian Democracy of the Third Republic Council on Mutual Economic Assistance Communist Party of the Soviet Union Centralny Urz ad ˛ Planowania/Central Planning Office European Bank for Research and Development European Union Forum Prawicy Demokratycznej/Forum of the Democratic Right Front Jedno´sci Narodowej/National Unity Front General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade Gross Domestic Product Gl⁄ ówna Komisja Badania Zbrodni przeciwko Narodowi Polskiemu/Main Commission for Investigating Crimes against the Polish Nation ˛ Ce⁄l/Main Customs’ Board Gl⁄ ówny Urz ad ˛ Statystyczny/Main Statistical Office Gl⁄ ówny Urz ad Instytut Filozofii i Socjologii/Institute of Philosophy and Sociology International Monetary Fund Instytut Pamieci ˛ Narodowej/Institute of National Memory Instytut Studiów Politycznych/Institute of Political Studies Krajowa Agencja Wydawnicza/National Publishing Agency Komisja Integracji Europejskiej/Committee on European Integration viii
List of Abbreviations ix
KERM KiW KL-D KO KOK KOR KPEiR KPEiRRP KPN KPP KRN KRRiTV KRRRM KRS KSAP KSZpNP
KSORM KSRM KUL LOK LRP MON MSW MSZ NATO NBP NFOS NIK
Komitetet Ekonomiczny Rada Ministrów/Economic Committee of the Council of Ministers Ksi a˛zka ˙ i Wiedza/Book and Knowledge Publishers Kongres Liberalno-Demokratyczny/Liberal-Democratic Congress Komitet Obywatelski/Civic Committee Komitet Obrony Kraju/National Defence Committee Komitet Obrony Robotników/Workers’ Defence Committee Krajowa Partia Emeritów i Rencistów/National Party of the Retired and Pensioners Krajowa Partia Emeritów i Rencistów/National Party of the Retired and Pensioners of the Polish Republic Konfederacja Polski Niepodlegl⁄ ej/Confederation for an Independent Poland Komunistyczna Partia Polski/Communist Party of Poland Krajowa Rada Narodowa/National Council for the Homeland Krajowa Rada Radiofonii Telewizji/National Council on Radio and Television Komitet Rozwoju Regionalnego RM/Committee for Regional Development of the Council of Ministers Krajowa Rada Sadownictwa/National ˛ Council for the Judiciary Krajowa Szkol⁄ a Administracji Publicznej/National School for Public Administration ´ Komisja Scigania Zbrodni przeciwko Narodowi Polskiemu/ Commission for Investigating Crimes against the Polish Nation Komitet Spraw Obronnych Rady Ministrów/Committee on Defence Questions of the Council of Ministers Komitet Spól⁄ eczny Rady Ministrów/Social Committee of the Council of Ministers Katolicki Uniwersytet w Lublinie/Catholic University in Lublin Liga Obrony Kraju/League for the Defence of the Country Liga Rodzin Polskich/League of Polish Families Ministerstwo Obrony Narodowej/Ministry of National Defense Ministerstwo Spraw Wewn˛etrznych/Ministry of the Interior Ministerstwo Spraw Zagranicznych/Ministry of Foreign Affairs North Atlantic Treaty Organization Narodowy Bank Polski/National Bank of Poland ´ Narodowy Fundusz Ochrony Srodowisku/National Fund for Environmental Protection Najwy˙zsza Izba Kontroli/Supreme Control Chamber
x List of Abbreviations
NSZ OECD OKP OPZZ OZON PAN PAP PC PChD PiS PKP PKW PKWN PO PP PPPP PPR PPS PR PRiTV PRL PRON PSL PUS PWN PZPR RBN RD-S RIP RLP RP ROAD ROP ROPCiO
Narodowe Sil⁄ y Zbrojne/National Armed Forces Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development Obywatelski Klub Parlamentarny/Civic Parliamentary Club Ogólnopolskie Porozumienie Zwiazków Zawodowych/AllPoland Alliance of Trade Unions Obóz Zjednoczenia Narodowego/Camp of National Unity Polska Akademia Nauk/Polish Academy of Sciences Polska Agencja Prasowa/Polish Press Agency Porozumienie (Partia) Centrum/Centre Agreement (Party) Partia Chrze´scija´nskich Demokratów/Christian Democratic Party Prawo i Sprawiedliwo´sc´ /Law and Justice Polskiej Koleje Pa´nstwowe/Polish State Railways Pa´nstwowa Komisja Wyborcza/State Electoral Commission Polski Komitet Wyzwolenia Narodowego/Polish Committee of National Liberation Platforma Obywatelska/Civic Platform Porozumienie Polskie/Polish Agreement Polska Partia Przyjaciól⁄ Piwa/Polish Party of the Friends of Beer Polska Partia Robotnicza/Polish Workers’ Party Polska Partia Socjalistyczna/Polish Socialist Party Polska Rzeczpospolita/Polish Republic Polskie Radio i Telewizja/Polish Radio and Television Polska Rzeczpospolita Ludowa/Polish People’s Republic Patriotyczny Ruch Odrodzenia Narodowego/Patriotic Movement for National Rebirth Polskie Stronnictwo Ludowe/Polish Peasant Party Polska Unia Socjaldemokratyczna/Polish Social Democratic Union Pa´nstwowe Wydawnictwo Naukowe/State Publishing House Polska Zjednoczona Partia Robotnicza/Polish United Workers’ Party Rada Bezpiecze´nstwa Narodowego/National Security Council Ruch Demokratyczno-Spol⁄ eczny/Democratic-Social Movement Rzecznik Interesu Publicznego/Spokesman for the Public Interest Ruch Ludzi Pracy/Movement for the Working People Rzeczpospolita Polska/Republic of Poland Ruch Obywatelski Akcja Demokratyczna/Democratic Action Civic Movement Ruch Odbudowy Polski/Movement for Rebuilding Poland Ruch Obrony Praw Czl⁄ owieka i Obywatela/Movement for the Defence of Human and Civic Rights
List of Abbreviations xi
ROP RS SD SdRP SGH SGPiS SK-L SL SLD SN SP SP TK TKN TVP UAM UD UMC-S UP UOP UP UPR URM USSR UW WAK WiN WP WRON WSI WUWr ZCh-N ZLP Znak
Rzecznik Praw Obywatelskich/Spokesman for Citizens’ Rights Ruch Stu/Movement of One Hundred Stronnictwo Demokratyczne/Democratic Party Socjal-demokracja Rzeczpospolitej Polskiej/Social-democracy of the Polish Republic Skzkol⁄ a Gl⁄ ówna Handlowa/Main Trade School Szkola Gl⁄ ówna Planowania i Statystyki/Main School for Planning and Statistics Stronnictwo Konserwatywno-Ludowe/Conservative-Popular Party Stronnictwo Ludowe/Peasant Party Sojusz Lewicy Demokratycznej/Alliance of the Democratic Left Stronnictwo Narodowe/National Party Solidarno´sc´ Pracy/Labour Solidarity Stronnictwo Pracy/Labour Party Constitutional Tribunal Towarzystwo Kursów Naukowych/Association of Academic Courses Telewizja Polska/Polish Television Uniwersytet Adama Mickiewicza/Adam Mickiewicz University, Pozna´n Unia Demokratyczna/Democratic Union Uniwersytet Marie Curie-Skl⁄ odowska/Marie Curie-Skl⁄ odowska University, Lublin. University Press Urz ad ˛ Ochrony Pa´nstwa/Office for State-Protection Unia Pracy/Labour Union Unia Polityki Realnej/Union of Real Politics Urz ad ˛ Rady Ministrów/Office of the Council of Ministers Union of Soviet Socialist Republics Unia Wolno´sci/Freedom Union Wyborcza Akcja Katolicka/Catholic Electoral Alliance Wolno´sc´ i Niezawisl⁄ o´sc´ /Freedom and Independence Wojsko Polskie/Polish Army Wojskowa Rada Ocalenia Narodowego/Military Council for National Salvation ˙ Informacyjne/Military Intelligence Service Wojskowe Sl⁄ uzby Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Wrocl⁄ awskiego/University of Wrocl⁄ aw Publishers Zjednoczenie Chrze´scija´nsko–Narodowe/Christian National Union Zwi azek ˛ Literatów Polskich/Union of Polish Writers ‘The Sign’
xii List of Abbreviations
ZNP ZSL ZUS
Zwi azek ˛ Nauczycielstwo Polskiej/Union of Polish Teachers Zjednoczone Stronnictwo Ludowe/United Peasant Party Zakl⁄ ad Ubezpiecze´n Spol⁄ ecznych/Social Insurance Enterprise
Preface Poland has since 1989 enjoyed an unprecedently favourable international situation which has facilitated its political democratization although the process has been hampered by major problems of delayed socioeconomic modernization. Democratic political institutions and constitutional politics have been consolidated. The country’s elites have successfully developed Poland’s historical traditions as well as the evolutionary consensus methods which emerged out of the negotiated revolution which ended communism. The result, examined in this study, has been the gradual working out of a widely accepted institutional balance. Parliamentary sovereignty and judicial review have been defined, executive power has shifted from the president to the prime minister, supported by a more efficient, although still far from perfect, cabinet and civil service and the full powers of the Constitutional Tribunal have all been embodied in the 1997 constitution. This constitutional and institutional dimension has stabilized Poland’s democratic political life despite powerful ideological and socioeconomic cleavages which have produced an exceptionally fluid party system. Electoral volatility was demonstrated most dramatically in the September 2001 parliamentary election which saw the disappearance from the Sejm of the two governing parties (Electoral Action Solidarity and the Freedom Union) which had supported Jerzy Buzek, the outgoing prime minister, since 1997. As this book went to press the issue was whether the near majority achieved by the Union of the Democratic Left, which had been reconstructed in a strongly pro-European and social democratic direction, supported by the 1990’s constitutional compromise, would be strong enough to resist party fragmentation and the electoral success of the populist ‘Self-Defence’ (Samoobrona) movement. Regular cyclical swings against incumbents in Poland since 1991 have been fuelled by popular reactions against the costs of socioeconomic transformation balanced by the desire to restructure sufficiently to join the European Union and to achieve consumer prosperity. This study, nevertheless, demonstrates that Poland’s political institutions and traditions have a basic underlying solidity. A strong sense of constitutionalism and rule of law has been hammered out through long drawn out struggles against occupying partitioning powers, the Nazi onslaught and communist rule. They are now rooted deeply in what the Poles consider to be their national tradition, derived from a ‘usable past’ based on adapted memories of ‘gentry democracy’ and the interwar Second Republic. This holds out the realistic likelihood that what outsiders might regard as dangerous forces of instability will be contained as Poland successfully completes its systemic transition. xiii
xiv Preface
Since my first stay in Poland for a year of postgraduate study in the History department of Warsaw University during 1965 to 1966, I have visited Poland about 40 times. During the period of East–West ideologicalsystemic struggle, my warmest links were with ‘Third Way’ reformists and patriotic-minded intelligentsia, forces which eventually achieved the compromises which ended communism. They have, subsequently, been a significant element of the political elites which have kept the Third Republic on course, achieved the democratic normality examined in this study and done their best to protect Poland and its national culture from the more excessive depradations of democratic capitalism. Of the many, many Poles who I have met over the years it would be invidious to acknowledge my intellectual, and in some cases, personal debt to more than a leading handful of the academics – mainly in my fields of politics, history and state law – who have supported me at various times, notably Wojciech Sokolewicz; Stanis⁄law Gebethner; Hieronim Kubiak; Jerzy Wiatr; Leszek Garlicki; Ryszard Mojak; Ryszard Zelichowski; Krzysztof Skotnicki; Hubert Izdebski; Stanisl⁄ aw Bielen; Andrzej Paczkowski; Grzegorz Rydlewski; Piotr Winczorek; Wojciech Materski; Wojciech Roszkowski; Wies⁄law Skrzydlo; Zdzis⁄law Jarosz; Eugeniusz Zieli´nski; Karol B. Janowski; Andrzej Rychard; Krzysztof Jasiewicz; Adam Bromke; Zbigniew Pelczynski. Finally – but above all – I would like to dedicate this, my ninth book, to my mother in gratitude for a lifetime of selfless support and encouragement. GEORGE SANFORD Bristol
Chronology 10th century 966 1025 12th century 1386 1410 1505 1569 1572–1764 1653 1683 1717 1772 1788–92 1791 1793 1794 1795 1807–13 1815–30 1830–31 1863–64 1867 1918 1920 1921
1926
Piast dynasty establishes distinct Polish state. Mieszko I adopts Christianity. Boles⁄law the Brave crowned King of Poland. The feudal state disintegrates. Jagiel⁄ l⁄ o marries Jadwiga inaugurating the Jagiellonian dynasty which rules until 1572. The Teutonic Order is defeated by the Polish-Lithuanian alliance at the battle of Grunwald. Nihil Novi statute. Union of Lublin formalizes the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth. Election of monarchs mainly from the Waza and Saxon dynasties. First use of Liberum veto. Jan Sobieski defeats the Turks at Vienna Russian domination confirmed by the ‘Dumb Sejm’. First Partition of Poland. Four Year Sejm. Constitution of Third of May. Second Partition. Ko´sciuszko’s Uprising. Third Partition ends the Polish Commonwealth. Grand Duchy of Warsaw and introduction of Napoleonic Code. Congress Kingdom and Free State of Kraków are established. Suppression of November Uprising by Russia. Russia puts down the January Uprising. Galicia gains autonomy within Austro-Hapsburg Empire. 11 November Poland regains independence with Pi⁄l− sudski as Head of State. August Bolsheviks defeated by Pil⁄ sudski at battle of Warsaw. Promulgation of democratic constitution of 17 March: Treaty of Riga secures Poland an extended eastern frontier. May coup by Pil⁄ sudski inaugurates growing authoritarian rule. xv
xvi Chronology
1935 1939
1940 1944
1945
1947 1948 1956 1968 1970
1976
1978 1979 1980
1981
1982 1983
April The authoritarian constitution is promulgated; May Pil⁄ sudski dies. Poland, invaded by Nazi Germany on 1 September and the USSR on 17 September; is divided up on the basis of the Ribbentrop–Molotov Pact. Spring–Summer Soviet massacre of over 22 000 Polish Prisoners of War, colloquially known as ‘Katy n ´ ’. Spring Anders corps fights for Monte Cassino; August–September Warsaw Uprising; December Polish Committee of National Liberation becomes the Provisional Government. Red Army occupation and establishment of communist rule within new frontiers on the Oder–Neisse in the west and around the Curzon Line in the east. Elections and elimination of remaining opposition. Gomul⁄ ka’s downfall; Stalinist domination under Bierut and Rokossowski. June Pozna´n uprising; October Popular unrest returns Gomul⁄ ka to power. March Student and reform opposition is crushed by the anti-Zionist purge. West German recognition of the Oder–Neisse line; demonstrations on the Baltic seacoast are suppressed; Gierek replaces Gomul⁄ ka. Period of growing prosperity and détente ends; June Food price increase is abandoned after Radom and Ursus riots. Suppression leads to dissidence and the Workers’ Defence Committee. Cardinal Karol Wojtyl⁄ a of Kraków is elected Pope. John Paul II’s first visit to Poland. Summer Growing protests against the food price-rise. August sit-in strikes in the Baltic dockyards; Gda´nsk, Szczecin and Jastrzebie ˛ Agreements concede rights to strike and to organize free trade unions; emergence of ˛ Solidarity, led by Wal⁄ esa. Consumer collapse and socioeconomic discontent. July The PZPR and Solidarity hold their congresses; Jaruzelski assumes party as well as state power; December The Military Council of National Salvation declares the State of War and suppresses opposition. Organization of underground counter-society. State of War ends: John Paul II visits Poland for a second time.
Chronology xvii
1986 1987 1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
General amnesty: Jaruzelski establishes Consultative ˛ the Solidarity Provisional Council. Council and Wal⁄ esa Narrow failure of referendum. Spring–Summer strikes; August PZPR plenum initiates ˛ sets up Civic reform course; December Wal⁄ esa Committee. January PZPR plenum confirms reform leadership and decision to negotiate with the opposition. 6 February–5 April Round Table negotiations and contract. April Relegalization of Solidarity. June PZPR is defeated in the Sejm and Senate elections. July Jaruzelski is barely elected as president. August Mazowiecki is nominated as prime minister. September Sejm confirms the Solidarityled coalition government with communist participation; signing of EEC trade and economic agreement. December Constitutional amendment excludes PZPR’s leading-role. January Dissolution of PZPR and formation of SdRP and PUS; initiation of Balcerowicz’ economic shock therapy. May Local government election. Summer Resignation of communist ministers: ‘war at the top’ splits Solidarity. November Polish–German Treaty confirms inviolability of their frontier: Tymi´nski eliminates Mazowiecki in first ˛ elected ballot of presidential election. December Wal⁄ esa as president. January Bielecki replaces Mazowiecki as prime minister. February Signing of Vi˘segrad Agreement; Solidarity Congress elects Krzaklewski as national chairman. October First fully free election produces a fragmented Sejm. December Olszewski appointed prime minister of a centre-right government; signing of EEC associate membership agreement. May Timetable for withdrawal of Soviet troops in Poland agreed. June Interior minister Macierewicz attempts to release secret files; Olszewski’s government falls. Pawlak is nominated, but not confirmed, as prime minister. July Suchocka forms a Solidarityorientated coalition. November Promulgation of Little Constitution. ˛ dissolves Sejm after Suchocka loses vote of May Wal⁄ esa confidence. September Last operational Soviet troops leave Poland. October SLD and PSL win a large majority of seats in Sejm election while Solidarity, KLD, PC and
xviii Chronology
1994
1995 March
1996
1997
1998
the national-catholics are excluded. November Pawlak leads an SLD-PSL coalition government. February Poland joins Partnership for Peace. April Formal amalgamation of UD with KLD to form Freedom Union (UW). May Borowski is replaced by Kol⁄ odko as minister of finance. June Local Government elections. ˛ signs Treaty with Lithuania in Vilnius. July Wal⁄esa Oleksy replaces Pawlak as prime minister: Zych becomes Sejm-Marshal April UW Congress elects Balcerowicz as leader in place of Mazowiecki. November presidential ˛ heads off challenges by Kuro´n, election – Wal⁄ esa Gronkiewicz-Waltz and Olszewski but is just defeated by Kwa´sniewski on the second ballot. December Interior Minister Milczanowski accuses Oleksy of betraying state secrets. March Cimoszewicz takes over as prime minister on Oleksy’s resignation April Suspension of investigation against Oleksy; Constitutional Tribunal rules that the abortion law is unconstitutional. July Sejm postpones ratification of Concordat. October Publication of White Book on Oleksy affair. November Bugaj’s Sejm Commission report closes Oleksy Affair. Winter Reform of central ministries. February Bel⁄ ka takes over from Kol⁄ odko as Minister of Finance. March Wilecki dismissed as Chief of Staff; April Sejm passes constitution despite rightist and clerical opposition; AWS elects its co-ordinating committee; Lustration Law passed. May Referendum barely approves constitution on low turnout. June John Paul’s fifth papal visit to Poland; EU Amsterdam summit decides to begin negotiations for full membership entry with Poland. July Serious flooding in southern and western Poland; NATO Madrid Summit endorses Polish membership. September Sejm election produces an ‘Electoral Action’ Solidarity (AWS) and Freedom Union (UW) majority. October Jerzy Buzek forms an AWS-UW coalition government. December Finance Minister Balcerowicz launches an economic austerity programme. January Ratification of the Concordat with the Vatican. March Jan Kulakowski appointed Government Plenipotentiary for EU entry negotiations. April Opening of first stage ‘screening’ negotiations with EU. June Amended Lustration Law is passed – Nizie´nski appointed Public Interest Spokesman. October Local
Chronology xix
1999 2000
2001
government elections. December Institute of National Memory is established. March Poland becomes a NATO member. June Sixth Papal visit. January Treasury Minister Wasacz ˛ resigns. May Buzek forms a minority government on UW withdrawal. August Lustration Court approves Kwa´sniewski’s and ˛ electoral declarations. September Kwa´sniewski Wal⁄ esa’s vetoes Universal Wealth-Holding Law. October Presidential election – Kwa´sniewski is re-elected decisively on the first ballot – Olechowski does well, Krzaklewski poorly. February Formation of PO. April New electoral law. October SLD almost wins a majority of seats in the Sejm and does so in the Senate in the parliamentary elections. The PSL, PO, Samoobrona as well as Catholic and conservative groups win Sejm representation but the AWS and UW fail to do so; Leszek Miller forms SLD-PSL government with Cimoszewicz as Foreign Minister.
1 The Constitution and History
Poland’s quest for security and modernization The achievement of political modernity in Poland has been dominated by the struggle to regain independence lost in the nineteenth century and to protect independence threatened in the twentieth century.1 Against this, the domestic corollary since the eighteenth century has been the continual attempt to achieve constitutional government. Constitutions, therefore, have played a crucial role in this endeavour and are deeply embedded in the national consciousness. In Poland, they have represented important signposts in summarizing the progress achieved and the nature of the project at any particular point. Some of the constitutions achieved are held to have been progressive and ‘real’: mainly those promulgated under conditions of independence. They also proclaimed the principle of the separation, rather than the unity, of state power and thus of democratic rather than authoritarian rule.2 Democratic principle applies in particular to the constitutions of 3 May 1791 and 17 March 1921; the ‘Little Constitution’ of 17 October 1992 and the fully rounded-off democratic constitution of 2 April 1997. Conversely, Pil⁄ sudski’s constitution of 23 April 1935 and the previous ‘Little Constitution’ of 19 February 1947 are held to be less legitimate as they were, in their respective ways, more authoritarian drafts. The communist constitution of 22 June 1952, in the contemporary view, was ‘a document devoid of all meaning’, designed to mask the realities of PZPR hegemonic rule.3 What is undisputed is that constitutions have been crucial to the modern Polish quest for viable and effective statehood.4 The historical significance of Poland’s independent constitutions, according to one Polish émigré newspaper, is that they provide ‘evidence of the continuity of the state’s legal system and its individual character in the international arena’.5 Poland’s history as one of the great states of Europe up to early modern times was followed by interrupted statehood from 1795 to 1918 when the partitioned country was ruled by three external empires. In the twentieth 1
2 Democratic Government in Poland
century, a threatened state independence during the interwar period and incomplete sovereignty between 1945 and 1989 have been matched by horrific extremes of subjugation by conquerors in two world wars.6 There have been question marks over Poland’s very existence at times. There have also been continual debates over her frontiers and what constitutes Polish territory as well as the very ethnic and political character of the Polish nation-state.7 Only after 1989–91, with the passing of the communist system and of Soviet control, did the fundamental security issues which had plagued Poland’s history since the seventeenth century achieve a favourable resolution.8 By the beginning of the twentieth-first century, Poland had entered NATO and was negotiating her entry, however fraught with difficulties, notably over the free movement of labour and capital and agricultural support into the European Union (EU). She had achieved a secure place in a postwar united Europe which safeguarded her against the external German and Russian threats which, since about 1700, had endangered her very existence. The modernization of her society and economy, which had been delayed by external factors for so long, was well under way. This transformation provoked varied reactions by what have been termed socioeconomic losers. However, extremist Catholic-authoritarian and Poujadist protectionist reactions, similar to those in 1950s France, were contained fairly easily. Democracy and market capitalism had been consolidated although long-ingrained patterns of political behaviour continued to affect governmental stability and the evolution of a stable and effective party system. The rule of law had been established and developed. Longstanding social pathologies of group anomie and distrust caused by foreign rule and wartime destruction, interplayed with the alleged Polish cultural vices of excessive individualism. Political scientists noted levels of corruption and clientelism at the political interface between the central political system and the economy, mass media and the emerging provincial and municipal elites. A decade earlier, comparisons tended to be made between Poland and Mexico and India, so progress, of sorts, was being confirmed. Above all, the enormous economic gap between Poland and the EU average and the inevitability that this would dominate and condition Poland’s development for a whole generation loomed menacingly over the political scene. But the normality for which the country had longed, and only achieved for short periods during the twentieth century, now seems safe, short of unpredictable global cataclysms. Poland’s elites have maintained a general consensus and accepted the parameters for the country’s development within the favourable postcommunist European framework. In sum, while the country’s external longterm prospects are positively rosy compared with the experiences of the past three centuries, the short-term domestic problems will, nevertheless, loom large. The fate of large numbers of redundant industrial workers and
The Constitution and History 3
the threat of massive peasant displacements complicated Poland’s EU entry negotiations. Considerable labour movement to the prosperous West may alleviate Poland’s socioeconomic problems at the price of aggravating a serious identity crisis in the country’s modernization drive. The historical factors which have hardened a strongly resilient, independently minded and Catholic national character will, doubtless, be undermined. It is unclear, at this stage, what new secular and market-orientated social synthesis will emerge as a result of the conflict between old and new values and interests. It is understandable why Polish studies should have been dominated for so long by issues concerning independence, security and a backward socioeconomic position in Europe.9 Social stresses and strains and political divisions also had an unfavourable impact on the country’s political system, causing major recurrent, often basic, ideological and programmatic political divisions. The country’s political culture has, therefore, often been characterized as being inherently fractious and quarrelsome. Long lines of historical continuity have been traced back to superficially similar patterns of disunity and lack of elite and state cohesion during the later periods of the Polish–Lithuanian Commonwealth, which was in gradual decline from the mid-seventeenth century onwards. A common charge is that internal division and bad state organization were crucial in causing the state’s lack of competitiveness with more ruthlessly centralized and militaristic external rivals and her consequent erasure from the map of Europe. The accusation of Poland’s ‘external anarchy’ was expressed in a most self-serving way by Frederick the Great of Prussia.10 In the nineteenth century this theme was argued, rather more sorrowfully, by the Kraków historical school. It is, therefore, obvious why such a strong connection should have been established during the last two centuries, in both the political consciousness and in academic debates, over the need for effective state and political organization to ensure sovereign independence. But is the opprobrium and low reputation attached to the state and political institutions – as being viewed as important contributory factors to Poland’s disasters – wholly merited? This study argues from the contrary premise: that significant institutional and organizational continuities developed even during the divisions of external and partitioned rule. These counteracted the ‘historical discontinuities’ of external political control and rule, varied governmental forms and a changing territorial shape and frontiers as discerned by the American political scientist, Ray Taras.11 A significant synthesis of state forms was achieved despite the superficial oscillation between the extremes of parliamentary democracy and guided authoritarianism in the interwar period. Many state and bureaucratic-legal forms continued unchanged, assuming a different character in reality during communist rule. Since 1989, they have blossomed out untrammeled with the consolidation of democracy.
4 Democratic Government in Poland
The Polish political system and its state institutions thus have long historical and developed roots and traditions, although these have evolved dramatically in substance from their original forms. Poland has many indigenous and original features which merit study and comparison with more established and familiar European equivalents. The problem is a somewhat circular one, however, as very little Polish history and politics is taught in university courses in the western world. This study has, therefore, been cast rather more as a monograph than as a student textbook – although the student is invited to refer to the tables which summarize government in Poland up to the present.12 One trusts, however, that both the general reader and the specialist will draw on it for interpretation as well as for reference.
Historical traditions and constitutional values The great issues in Poland’s early history concerned the definition of its frontiers, territorial shape and internal composition. Although it is a historical simplification to contrast a Piast model (named after Poland’s first dynasty which ruled from the tenth century until 1370) with the Jagiellonian one (which ruled from 1386–1572, with a short Angevin interlude) what is nowadays important is the popular perception; this highlights the difference between their main orientations. Piast Poland is associated with the idea of an ethnically and territorially compact state, mainly concerned to repel German aggression and to consolidate itself in the West without overstretching itself in the East.13 In practice, there was great expansion eastwards at various times. By the battle of Grunwald in 1410, the Teutonic Knights had also pushed the Poles out of much of Pomerania and East Prussia. The folk memory of the Knight’s extermination of native populations was reinforced by Henryk Sienkiewicz’s great nineteenthcentury novel, The Teutonic Knights (Krzyzacy). ˙ Unfortunately, its historically truthful depiction of Poles as victims jars somewhat with western liberals. The criticism has also been fostered by partisan German and Jewish writers. Universally read by Poles, The Teutonic Knights was made into a powerful film by Aleksander Ford during the time of the Polish People’s Republic (PRL); it reinforced the renewed twentieth-century perception, strengthened by the horrors of Nazi occupation, of Germany as the genocidal enemy ‘other’ of the Poles.14 Polish–German relations have been recast following Bonn’s recognition of the Oder–Neisse frontier in 1970, since when Sienkiewicz’ Catholic and mystical themes of forgiveness as the basis of reconciliation have become more relevant. Nowadays the idealized version of Piast Poland is also associated with a strong unitary state. In reality, there was much feudal fragmentation in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries.15
The Constitution and History 5
Poland emerged after 1945 with a new western frontier on the OderNeisse rivers, fairly close to where it had been a thousand years earlier. Its eastern frontier largely followed the Curzon Line, named after the British Foreign Minister who advocated it in 1920.16 It now excluded the bulk of the Ukrainian and Belarusan minorities, gained by the 1921 Treaty of Riga, which were incorporated in 1939–40 in their respective Soviet Socialist Republics. Roman Dmowski, the interwar National Democrat ideologue of integral nationalism, had been closer to the historical Piast reality of eastward expansion into Polish-dominated areas susceptible to, what in modern times may be termed, ‘Polonization’. The redrawing of Poland’s new frontiers at the postwar Yalta Conference produced a compact rectangular territorial shape. Postwar Poland had an area of something over 120 000 square miles as a result of losing 69 290 square miles to the USSR and gaining 39 597 square miles from Germany. The country also rationalized its frontiers. These were reduced from 3445 miles prewar to 1905 miles, but Poland’s Baltic seacoast increased from 87 miles to over 300. Large end-ofwar population movements and transfers expelled the bulk of the Germans, leaving only a few hundred thousand Ukrainians and Belarusans in the new state. Similar numbers of Jews, who had survived the Nazi Holocaust, also remained, but most left, subsequently, at various times. National Minorities made up about a third of the population in the interwar Second Republic, but were at a roughly 4 per cent level at the Polish People’s Republic’s (PRL) inception. By the end of the century, minorities had dwindled to a mere 2 per cent when the country’s population almost reached 39 million. Equally significant in terms of territory lost and gained, eastern territories and cities like Lwów (Lv’iv) and Wilno (Vilnius), which had been part of Poland for centuries, were lost irrevocably as a result of the Second World War postwar settlements. This reality has been confirmed by the emergence of independent Lithuanian, Belarusan and Ukrainian national states after 1991. Jagiellonian Poland had, at its peak, stretched from the Baltic to the Black Seas. The residual historical memory is thus that of an intermarium which, if not Polish-dominated, is potentially one of Polish regional influence. With the permanent loss of the eastern territories being clearer now in the national consciousness than in 1940, the latter formulation, one of regional influence is residually more relevant to Polish foreign policy. What then is left of the Jagiellonian tradition? Clearly, the idea of a farflung, decentralized and loosely organized quasi federal state of various national groupings under general Polish hegemony is today no longer viable. Such a state lurked as a general possibility immediately after the First World War. The successful Polish–Soviet War of 1920 gave interwar Poland its Riga frontier, stretching well into West Ukraine and West Belarus. This frontier went far beyond any strictly ethnic definitions for
6 Democratic Government in Poland
organizing the borderlands on Jagiellonian confederal principles. Such schemes, despite much misleading historical controversy on the subject, were already recognized as unworkable by Pil⁄ sudski.17 As Poland’s dictator after 1926, Pil⁄ sudski carried out a very realpolitik-minded foreign policy. His domestic policy involved centralized control and ‘Polonization’ of East Slav minorities rather than autonomy. As late as the outbreak of the Second World War, Raymond Buell could write that Poland was ‘dominated by the dream of its greatness during the Middle Ages – a great culture and a vast domain which under one ruler sheltered a large number of nationalities’.18 Poland’s rulers at the time of the Second World War could seriously think ‘in terms of unifying Central Europe’.19 The idea of a centralized unitary state based on a Polish ethnic core has, however, triumphed over any federal or confederal alternative of a Polish-led grouping of peoples in the borderlands (kresy).20 Residues of the latter conception survive in the Polish consciousness but are diminishing to almost zero amongst the young. They have largely been transformed into secondary derivative forms: that Poland has special historical skills and connections and actual regional security and economic interests in the area. On the other hand, as late as 1991, an (admittedly untypical) public opinion poll showed that a majority of Poles still thought that parts of neighbouring countries should belong to Poland itself.21 The new states in this adjacent region, notably Lithuania and Ukraine, have elites that are strongly concerned to consolidate independence within a European framework.22 The contrary Belarusan case of seeking reintegration with Russia is linked to President Lukashenko’s maverick and authoritarian behaviour.23 Since 1989, sentiments of distrust, contempt and fear of Russia as Poland’s most hostile and barbarian ‘other’, fuelled by the original perception of the ‘Return to Europe’ as rejoining European civilization, have abated.24 On the other hand, current pressures for regionalism and decentralization in Poland have a completely different meaning than in the past. Domestic opponents, nevertheless, often resort to archaic Jagiellonian vocabulary and parallels. The socialist experience of modernization had produced an exceptionally homogeneous nation-state. This state faces the global challenge of modern forms of multiculturalism rather than ethnic conflicts of the post-Yugoslav type, although defensive reactions against modernization are too easily depicted as forms of nationalist particularism.25 The other main strand of Jagiellonian state organization – estates or gentry democracy – however, remains far more germane in any discussion of Polish cultural patterns. From the second half of the fifteenth century onwards, the country’s magnates, supported by a gentry (szlachta) class, which together was estimated as, at various times, totaling around 6–9 per cent of the population, controlled local assemblies or Dietines (Sejmiki). Siemienski defines this as the ‘fundamental unit’ of the Polish system: these were ‘territorial communities (communitates) operating in the shape of
The Constitution and History 7
assemblies at which those present decided in the name of all’.26 The landed gentry became increasingly differentiated in terms of property, but remained equal in legal status. They began an irresistible drive towards domination of the central executive and representative institutions. The fairly homogeneous Piast monarchy was transformed into a multiethnic commonwealth which turned increasingly into a ‘Republic of Nobles’. As early as 1454, the general assembly of the gentry of Greater Poland forced the monarch into concessions embodied in the Statute of Nieszawa – described as ‘the charter of Polish parliamentarianism’.27 The King accepted the joint say of the Dietines and general assemblies over constitutional change and the declaration of war. These powers were gradually extended over the following century, especially over the Sejm which was the legislating body.28 An acceptable balance existed until the death of Zygmunt II Augustus, the last Jagiellonian, in 1572. The system allowed, what was for its time, a remarkably free and developed political life to flourish. The national parliament or Sejm (the Diet) assumed a recognizably modern form in 1493. The Senate representing the senior magnates and clerics began to sit separately from the lower house representing the ordinary, but legally equal, gentry. Wacl⁄ aw Uruszczak has argued that henceforward ‘the question of parliament constitutes the central problem of the history of the political system of old Poland’.29 For its time, this produced an extremely wide and broadbased electorate which elected the deputies to the Sejm. However, this originally progressive development degenerated. Politically destructive, culturally negative and socially exclusive values developed to justify gentry rule. While the Szlachta was extolled as a Sarmatian noble warrior class, racially distinct from ordinary Poles, it gradually declined into xenophobia and megalomania as well as excessive hospitality and an empty ceremonial.30 The Nihil Novi statute of 1505 enshrining the principle of no taxation – and eventually legislation – by the monarch without parliamentary approval, contributed to a Golden Age of Renaissance culture. Early balanced constitutional development initially prevented the emergence of absolute monarchy and provided an acceptable framework for the varied religions and ethnic groups within the extensive Polish–Lithuanian union. The principle of toleration was extended to Protestants in 1555 and formalized by the Confederation of Warsaw of 1573.31 The Polish–Lithuanian kingdom, based for a long time purely on a hereditary Jagiellonian dynastic union, was institutionalized by the Union of Lublin of 1569.32 This transformed it into the Commonwealth of Poland and Lithuania. The crucial innovation was that the separate Sejms of both countries now met as a single parliament in Warsaw to enact national legislation. Kraków, consequently, lost its political significance and was replaced by Warsaw as the national capital in 1596.
8 Democratic Government in Poland
The Polish word for both Commonwealth and Republic is Rzeczpospolita so the post-Lublin arrangements are often described in terms of a republican commonwealth organized on the principles of gentry democracy. There had been continual and long-drawn-out conflict between the Jagiellonian monarchs and the gentry, who demanded an extension of their privileges (the ‘Execution of the Laws’ movement); a balance was nevertheless maintained.33 The extinction of the Jagiellonian dynasty in 1572, however, allowed the gentry to replace what had been the de facto hereditary basis of the monarchy with election by the szlachta assembled in a convocation Sejm presided over by the Roman Catholic Primate of Poland as Interrex.34 This principle was enshrined in the ‘Henrician Articles’ produced by the very first such election; these have been described as the Rzeczpospolita’s fundamental law, if not proto-constitution.35 The direct sovereignty of the general assembly, allowing the supreme power of the whole of the legally qualified gentry, was thus established at the expense of rather less comprehensively representative, but more effective, parliamentary forms. The monarchy was weakened further by having to promise an increasing range of privileges, including exemptions from taxes and military service and guarantees of legal immunity and equality of rights, in a package known as the pacta conventa, in order to gain sufficient support to ensure election.36 Foreign candidates also competed for ownership of the Polish state, from the contested royal election of Henri de Valois in 1573, onwards, with disastrous and debilitating consequences. Although the reigns of Stefan Batory and of the first two Wazas, Zygmunt III and Zygmunt IV, partially camouflaged the decline of royal power, the consequence was ever-increasing weakening of the state’s international competitiveness. Gentry privileges prevented social, economic and urban development and caused military weakness and civic and cultural decay. Pawel⁄ Skwarczy´nski summarized the main constitutional features of the Commonwealth as being ‘the contractual conception of the state, elective monarchy, the reality of royal power, the organization of the diet and dietines’. He argued that three centuries of ‘organic evolution’ became ‘fully crystallised in the Polish state of the sixteenth century’ but that the latter was deformed and warped in the run up to the Partitions.37 The historic shift from the English ‘King-in-Parliament’ model to the gentry-dominated form of estates democracy, aggravated by such principles as the ‘Imperative Mandate’ and the Liberum veto, was, however, the root cause of the problem which affected Poland’s constitutional and international viability. The former doctrine of representation regarded the Sejm not as a Burkean body of representatives free to take decisions in the national interest but as a meeting place of mandated delegates. Instructions from the provincial Dietines became fully binding from the end of the sixteenth century onwards. The Dietines also increasingly became dominated by the selfish, short-sighted and contentious interests of the landed mag-
The Constitution and History 9
nates.38 The Sejm, in Raymond Buell’s expressive words, became ‘less a legislative body than a miniature League of Nations, composed of delegates from 50 to 60 sovereign “palatines”’.39 Stanisl⁄ aw Kutrzeba has also shown how the size of both the Sejm and Senate fluctuated considerably over time, thus worsening its unwieldy and quarrelsome character.40 The ‘Golden Freedom’ of the gentry thus degenerated into the ‘anarchy’ expressed in the principle that ‘Polska nierz adem ˛ stoi’ (Poland is governed by unrule). From 1652 onwards, when it was used for the first time by Wl⁄ adysl⁄ aw Sici´nski, most Sejm’s (45 out of 55 in fact between 1652–1772, including all except one out of 14 during the reign of Augustus III) were incapacitated by the exercise of the Liberum veto.41 This allowed a single deputy to veto, not just a bill under consideration, but all the legislation passed earlier by the sitting Sejm, thus ‘exploding’ it.42 The practice of confederation also degenerated by the early seventeenth century into the rokosz, a form of institutionalized insurrection, directed as often as not against the king. As a result, Poland was unable to hold its own in the international arena. The country was undermined by Chmielnicki’s uprising which resulted, before too long, in the loss of half the Ukraine by the Truce of Andruszowo in 1667. Poland was ravaged by the Swedish ‘Deluge’ of the 1650s and unable to prevent the rise of its greatest external enemies, Prussia and Russia. The gentry commonwealth went down with a flourish with Jan III Sobieski’s victory over the Turks at Vienna in 1683. After his death in 1696, Poland became a Russian satellite. The complacent rule of two Saxon kings, Augustus II and Augustus III, turned the country into the plaything and victim of Muscovy’s conflicts with Sweden, France, Prussia and Austria.43 The interplay between reforming and conservative confederations and a challenge to Russia’s overall hegemony in Poland precipitated the First Partition in 1772.44 The determined attempt to reform the country’s political and educational structures during the reign of Stanisl⁄ aw August Poniatowski, which culminated in the constitution of 3 May 1791, however, also provoked the final partitions of the country in 1793 and 1795.45 The significance of this belated attempt to produce political and social regeneration and a modern state is that it helped the Polish nation to create the constitutional values and historical memories which allowed it to survive the very extinction of that state.46 The Gentry Parliament would have been a wholly negative memory in the Polish historical consciousness without its transformation into a recognizably modern one by the Third of May constitution in 1791; Dyboski describes it as the foundation of all Polish modern development.47 Stefania Ochman, a major constitutional scholar, also points out that ‘parliamentary reform was an integral part of every programme aimed at improving the political system of the Commonwealth’.48
10 Democratic Government in Poland
The effects of foreign rule and war on state institutions After the downfall of the old Commonwealth, different parts of Poland were subjected to Russian, German and Austrian rule as well as an initial period of very strong French links. Napoleon did not restore a greater Poland to balance his dynastic enemies in the east, only a short-lived rump, the Duchy of Warsaw, in 1807. Even that was ruled by the King of Saxony, although it was extended somewhat in 1809.49 French practices and the Napoleonic Code, confirming the uniform and equal legal and administrative treatment of citizens, were introduced while serfdom was abolished. Although short-lived, such reforms were to affect popular memory as well as interwar Poland.50 William Rose considers that the code set ‘a new standard for civic relations’ and that ‘many of its principles can be discerned as lasting over’ into its successors.51 The Duchy only survived until it was replaced by the Russian-controlled Congress Kingdom in 1815 where the Sejm had some advisory powers.52 Its autonomy was curtailed after the 1831 Uprising and completely subordinated after the 1863 insurrection. Prussia and Austria also reclaimed much of their respective Polish gains at the Congress of Vienna whose territorial arrangements for Poland remained largely unchanged until the First World War.53 The history of the country’s rule by the partitioning powers, punctuated by uprisings, political emigration as well as the development of strong nationalist, revolutionary and anti-state traditions and mentalities, does not concern us directly.54 What is relevant are the consequences for the independent Polish state and twentieth-century political institutions and practices. Much of the country’s social and economic backwardness, in Austrian-controlled Galicia and Russian-run eastern Poland, could justifiably be blamed on their partitioning powers. Prussia on the other hand is held to have instilled better levels of labour discipline and even middle-class entrepreneurship in Pozna´n, Pomerania and Silesia. Jerzy Jedlicki argues that this instilled a schizophrenic attitude towards modernity in the mind of Poles by identifying it with a superior national rival.55 Poor civic traditions and distrustful Polish attitudes towards the state have been traced back to Russification and Germanization and authoritarian rule. The Austrian partition is held to have fostered more responsible conservative and peasant political elites through its post-1867 decentralization.56 Although mixed and patchy, the economic, social and civic-political legacy of nineteenth-century partition rule was largely negative. All authorities agree, however, that the dominant consequence was the creation of a strongly resilient Polish nationalist and predominantly Roman Catholic counter society to oppose the occupying powers.57 Mark Brzezinski also points out that the Poles ‘asserted and further refined their constitutional values’ through the political programmes and constitutional drafts mooted in the 1830–31 and 1863–64 uprisings.58
The Constitution and History 11
The integration of society with the state and the development of more normal civic and economic attitudes and behaviour inevitably caused difficulties after independence. Writers such as Jerzy Jedlicki and Marcin Król argue that past heroic struggles and literary models made it difficult for twentieth-century Poles to come to terms with the prosaic nature of everyday life under democratic capitalism; Wiktor Herer and Wl⁄ adysl⁄ aw Sadowski also stress the schizophrenic effect of economic backwardness coexisting with a highly self-conscious intelligentsia and developed levels of western culture in Poland.59 The coming together of state and society to support civic democratic politics of the Western European type was, however, to be delayed by the destruction of two World Wars. The PRL experience was also very diverse, with initial Stalinism mellowing into pluralist authoritarianism and domesticist nationalism by its end.
Constitutions and political frameworks The constitution of 3 May 1791 and the failure of constitutional modernization The last 30 years of the Commonwealth, coinciding with the reign of Stanisl⁄ aw Augustus Poniatowski (1764–95), were marked by two quite contrary constitutional tendencies. The Cardinal Laws of 1668 and 1775 and reactionary confederations, notably of Radom in 1767 and Targowica in 1792, attempted to confirm the system of gentry privileges and local magnate rule under Russia’s external patronage. The Czartoryski clan, however, worked for Sejm reform and constitutional monarchy through the 1768 Confederation of Bar and the Education Commission (established in 1773).60 A modern-looking governmental institution, the 36-strong Permanent Council (1775), elected by the Sejm, assumed many royal powers. Its five departments began to function as quasi ministries. The Council’s policies were, however, profoundly ambiguous and contradictory, reflecting the conflicting currents which preceded the Four-Year Sejm of 1788–92. The doubling of that Sejm’s size by new elections in 1790 allowed reform elements to seize the initiative. They attempted to profit from a favourable international situation, Catherine the Great’s temporary weakness and the 1790 treaty with Prussia.61 The result was the Constitution of 3 May 1791, the world’s second modern written constitution after the American Constitution, and a most evocative part of Poland’s political consciousness.62 Drafted by Ignacy Potocki and Hugo Kol⁄ l⁄ ataj, ˛ with the support of King ˛ (litStanisl⁄ aw Augustus, the constitution, described as an ‘Ustawa Rzadowa’ erally Government Law), was organized succinctly in a preamble and 11 articles.63 It aimed to limit magnate and gentry excesses by strengthening the powers of parliament, creating a government responsible to it and producing a constitutional monarchy close to the English model of the
12 Democratic Government in Poland
time. The formal equality of rights of the landed gentry were maintained, but the landless (zagrodowa) section was deprived of its capacity for causing political mischief. The middle and urban classes benefited from the declaration of liberal individual rights to justice, property and freedom of political life and religion (while maintaining the primacy of Roman Catholicism). The Liberum veto, the imperative mandate and right of confederation, were abolished while the elective monarchy was replaced, in principle, by a hereditary one. The constitution declared that the nation was sovereign – ‘all authority derives from the will of the nation’ – but restricted the definition of the political nation in practice.64 The peasant question was barely broached where this infringed gentry rights and this was left to Ko´sciuszko’s Polaniec Manifesto during the 1794 insurrection.65 Montesquieu’s threehold separation of the powers was accepted in the form of a bicameral parliament (an indirectly elected and constitutionally dominant 204-strong Chamber of Deputies and a 132-strong nominated Senate). The newly organized Cabinet of Ministers were accountable to parliament which could dismiss it by a two-thirds vote of both houses. The much reduced crown prerogative and the rule of law was to be supervised by this novel executive body, the ‘Guardians of the Laws’ (Stra˙z Praw). Ministerial violation of laws could also be dealt with through an early form of constitutional responsibility to a Sejm Court, which was drawn from both chambers. The constitution was an imperfect and compromise document by modern criteria but it reflected the best ideas of the Enlightenment and the views of the most progressive sections of Polish society of the time.56 By itself it could do little to prevent, and may have actually precipitated, the Second and Third Partitions by threatening Russia and Prussia with domestic Polish regeneration.67 A wide range of authorities, however, confirm that it became a ‘symbol of Poland’s national identity – an identity based on the values of constitutionalism, and limited, enlightened government’ during the long period of lost statehood and after.68 Democracy and the Second Republic: parliamentary sovereignty versus the strong executive Independent Poland was resurrected in November 1918 and the Second Republic soon assumed a parliamentary dominated form of democracy.69 This became more authoritarian upon Józef Pil⁄ sudski’s armed seizure of power in May 1926.70 The Sejm’s powers were limited by the constitutional amendment of 2 August 1926 which strengthened the presidency. Pil⁄ sudski did not, despite election, however, assume the post. He ruled indirectly through his nominee, Ignacy Mo´scicki, who remained in-office until September 1939. The initial four-year period of ‘rationalized parliamentarianism’ saw conflict between Pil⁄ sudski and the Sejm, headed by its Marshal,
The Constitution and History 13
the Polish Socialist Party leader, Ignacy Daszy´nski. This culminated with Pil⁄ sudski’s Sanacja (Moral Renewal) movement, organized in 1928 into a Nonparty Bloc for Cooperation with the Government (BBWR), gaining a majority in 1930 after opposition figures had been imprisoned in the Brze´sc´ camp.71 Even then, the April 1935 constitution, which completed the turnaround in the balance of powers a few weeks before Poland’s de facto dictator died, had to be passed by subterfuge. All this gave ammunition for foreign enemies and critics. They depicted interwar Poland as a saisonstaat (temporary state) which had failed to achieve a workable constitutional balance.72 The power struggle between Pil⁄ sudski, as Head of State (1918–22), and Roman Dmowski and the National Democrats, was settled initially in the latter’s favour by the March 1921 constitution. That document confirmed most of the key aspects of parliamentary supremacy outlined in the temporary ‘Little Constitution’ of 20 February 1919 produced by the Constituent Sejm elected that January.73 The ‘Little Constitution’ subjected Pil⁄ sudski’s acts as Head of State, to countersignature by the appropriate minister and subordinated both him and the government formally to the Sejm, thus limiting the principle of the separation of the powers.74 The 1921 document was made up of 126 articles grouped under seven chapters while its preamble began with a religious invocation – ‘In the name of God Almighty’.75 It was modelled on the theory of the French Third Republic and the practice of 1921–26 closely paralleled its behaviour.76 The fundamental democratic principles of the sovereignty of the nation, the division of powers and the guaranteeing of civic and individual rights were confirmed. But the key feature was that the president (elected for a seven-year term by a National Assembly composed of the Sejm and Senate) was ‘more or less a figurehead’ while the prime minister was ‘helpless unless he could command a majority in the House’.77 The Sejm controlled the government very closely through almost unchecked powers of appointment, censure and dismissal. Both the 444-strong Sejm and the 111-strong Senate were elected by direct and universal suffrage. The latter was clearly inferior although it could participate in legislation and could agree to a presidential request for the dissolution of the two parliamentary chambers. Deputies had no formal checks, such as the threat of dissolution, on their capacity to maintain control over the government as well as individual ministers through repeated votes of confidence and censure; the same applied to their powers over the budget and legislation. Independent Poland’s early political life thus became fragmented, quarrelsome and extremely unstable. The first president, Gabriel Narutowicz, was both elected – and murdered by a right-wing fanatic – in December 1922. His successor, the socialist Stanisl⁄ aw Wojciechowski was, in reality, deposed by Pil⁄ sudski in May 1926. Proportional representation produced a large number of parties in the Sejm, representing a wide range of Catholic,
14 Democratic Government in Poland
nationalist, conservative, peasant, leftist and national minority groupings.78 During 1921–35 about 28 communists (KPP) were also elected to the Sejm, supported by two dozen Belarusan and Ukrainian leftists, but they largely played a disruptive role.79 Party fragmentation was counteracted by the formation of blocs, such as the National Democrat-dominated Christian Alliance of National Unity in November 1922.80 Overall, Poland had 13 governments between January 1919 and May 1926, on average, lasting a mere seven months.81 Five were coalitions and eight minority or non-party specialist governments. About a third of the 90 or so political parties established in this ‘turbulent’ period gained Sejm representation;82 but the 23-month-long government of Stanisl⁄ aw Grabski in 1923–25 also demonstrated that crisis conditions provoked stabilizing behaviour and party support.83 The initial Stalinist tendency in the PRL was to stress the ‘bourgeoisfeudal landowner’ character of the Second Republic. Interpretations after October 1956 admitted the democratic value of the 1921 constitution in consolidating national independence and its progressive nature in relation to Pil⁄ sudski’s authoritarianism.84 Church-State relations were also regulated, not by the 1921 constitution, but by the Concordat signed with the Vatican and ratified by the Sejm in 1925. This remained in force until it was revoked in 1945. The three Catholic rites (Latin, Greek Catholic and Armenian) were given full organizational and religious autonomy, although the president could object to nominations of archbishops and bishops.85 Pope Pius XI also adjusted diocesses in late 1925, as agreed, to fit in with Poland’s state boundaries. The Roman Catholic church played a dominant role in interwar Poland’s public life; it benefited from a privileged position in relation to minority faiths although this was not enshrined constitutionally.86 Minority religions still had not been regulated by 1939 because of their close connection with national minority issues. The constitutional amendment of 2 August 1926 was made up of eight articles revising or replacing six articles in the March 1921 constitution. The changes tightened the government’s control over the passing of the budget, allowed the president to dissolve the Sejm before the expiry of its term and to issue decrees with the force of law subject to subsequent Sejm approval. Parliament became less capable of ‘ambushing’ a government by voting on a motion of censure at the same sitting as it was introduced. The 1935 constitution aimed to produce a presidentially dominated system.87 The Sanacja ideologue, Sejm Marshal Stanislaw Car, justified political unity in terms which were to be echoed by hardline postwar communists.88 The constitution declared that the Polish state was ‘the common good of all its citizens’; it concentrated ‘united and undivided state power’ in the hands of a constitutionally irresponsible president answering only to God and History.89 The president did not bear parliamentary responsibility as he was not subject to ministerial countersignature. On the other hand,
The Constitution and History 15
the government now became politically responsible to the president. He appointed and dismissed both the government and individual ministers and had unlimited powers of dissolution over both the Sejm and Senate. A new electoral system allowed Sanacja to pack both these bodies with its members and so constitute the majority of the college electing the president. In the event of conflict over the succession, an outgoing president could nominate an alternative candidate to challenge parliament’s choice in a vote by universal suffrage. In the case of war, the president could nominate his successor, as Mo´scicki did with Wl⁄ adysl⁄ aw Raczkiewicz on internment in Romania. Guided Democracy, of this type, based on principles of a Strong State and social solidarity, was tailor made for Pil⁄ sudski but it was promulgated just prior to his death. Poland was run, subsequently, by a triumvirate of President Mo´scicki, Marshal Edward Smigl⁄ y-Rydz, who controlled the army, and Foreign Minister Józef Beck. Their power struggles permitted a fair bit of de facto pluralism in the four years before Nazi Germany and Soviet Russia joined forces to destroy the country.90 Prewar experience is significant in that Sanacja, although a hegemonic force after 1926, and an unquestioned one after 1930, was forced to work through the Sejm and to evolve an authoritarian form of Guided Democracy.91 It was unable to dispense wholly with democratic institutions and to set up a fascist corporate state. Although the ideological content of the PRL was wholly different, there were notable structural state-society similarities between interwar and postwar Poland.
The usable past of Polish constitutionalism The Second Republic had a difficult job in establishing its frontiers, gaining its western border at Versailles and extending its eastern one by the 1921 Treaty of Riga, after winning the Polish-Soviet war the previous year.92 The new democracy also made considerable progress in the long-drawn-out process of unifying the different governmental, economic, financial, postal and transport systems inherited from the three partitioning powers.93 It is, therefore, a very debatable matter to ascertain the extent to which this reconstruction was affected by older native traditions as against imposed foreign influences. Hubert Izdebski argues categorically that ‘as a result of the absence of Polish statehood in the nineteenth century the home-grown model of public administration, which crystallized in the Stanisl⁄ awian period, could not have any influence on shaping the institutions of public administration’ in independent Poland. He goes on to argue, however, that the Second Republic adopted ‘the Austrian model of administrative procedure and justice, the principles of the Prussian model of territorial organization and Russian patterns of financial institutions’.94 This may well have been true in purely technical terms. There is, however, a considerable
16 Democratic Government in Poland
weight of authority that the Poles referred back to, and adapted, many of the forms and values, and certainly the nomenclature, of their older native models and traditions. But irrespective of the influence of pre-partition traditions, one is undoubtedly on firmer ground in arguing that the diverse institutions and values of the Second Republic proved remarkably resilient in surviving the Second World War and communism. The overview of Polish constitutionalism in this chapter has aimed to demonstrate that Poland inherited long-lived, tenacious and varied parliamentary traditions from its pre-communist history.95 Extending all the way from gentry to modern forms of parliament they, in the short space of the two interwar decades, ran the whole gamut from one extreme of assembly, to another of executive, dominance. The PRL thus inherited a very mixed legacy of parliamentary traditions.96 The traumatic Second World War experience and the vast postwar socioeconomic transformations were unable to obliterate the historical roots of Poland’s political culture and many of its similarities to western Europe. External Soviet factors determined that the legacy of such experiences and values were to prove incapable of altering the formal structures of communist rule in the PRL period. The 1956, 1970 and 1980 upheavals, however, certainly had crucial implications, as will be argued in Chapter 2, on the manner and processes of that rule. As with Pil⁄ sudski’s rule before them, the communists had to adapt, work within and eventually concede to many traditional Polish values and forms. Geoffrey Pridham considers that long-established historical patterns of cultural values produce historical memories which affect the forms and limits of national identity when democratization occurs.97 Poland’s ‘usable past’ has, in this respect, been a very peculiar combination indeed. On the one hand, nineteenth-century independence seeking revolutionary traditions dominated until the Second World War and enjoyed a rebirth with the KOR-Solidarity generation.98 On the other hand, the democratic tradition has itself been rather bifurcated between gentry-Stanisl⁄ awian reform memories and interwar civic republican values. As we have seen, political memories of gentry democracy culminated in, and have been conflated, with the liberal constitutionalism of 3 May 1971.99 A cyclical pattern of activist-passive, idealist-realist reactions to a lost, or incomplete, independence was gradually eroded during the PRL until 1989 produced the opportunity for the breakthrough to full sovereignty and constitutional democracy.100 Reverting to Pridham’s typology, one can argue that the post-communist Third Republic developed a form of ‘political learning’ which drew conclusions from the lack of constitutional balance and executive weakness in gentry democracy and the Second Republic up until 1926. For understandable reasons, the rehabilitation of interwar and ‘London’ Poland has protected Pil⁄ sudski’s system from general condemnations of its authoritarianism. As we shall see, such political learning from historical
The Constitution and History 17
memory affected the detailed specifics of constitution making in the Third Republic. Overcoming the burden of Poland’s historic legacy thus produced a general elite consensus on the priority of achieving workable institutions and an effective constitutional balance. The dispute over whether all, or just part, of the PRL legacy should be dispensed with reflected a major cleavage in the Third Republic’s politics. It is not always appreciated, however, that this is part of a wider long-term division regarding the responsibility for Poland’s delayed and incomplete modernization.
Notes 1 The list of main general histories rightly starts with Norman Davies, A History of Poland: God’s Playground 2 vols (New York: Columbia University Press, 1981). Its English-language rivals are for the most part heavily dated: Vaclav L. Benes, Poland (New York: Praeger, 1970; Aleksander Gieysztor et al., History of Poland 2nd rev. edn (Warsaw: PWN, 1979); Oskar Halecki, A History of Poland 2nd edn revised by Antony Polonsky (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1983); William Fiddian Reddaway (ed.), The Cambridge History of Poland 2 vols (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1941, 1950). Jerzy Lukowski and Waclaw Zawadzki, A Concise History of Poland (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 2001) is a more recent work. More popular overviews are provided by Jerzy Topolski, An Outline History of Poland (Warsaw: Interpress, 1985) and Adam Zamoyski, The Polish War (London: John Murray, 1987). 2 See Wojciech Sokolewicz, The Principle of the Separation of Powers in Law and Constitutional Jurisprudence of the Republic of Poland, Polish Contemporary Law, no. 1–4/109–12 (1996), p. 17. 3 Deputy Jan Maria Rokita, cited in Mark Brzezinski, The Struggle for Constitutionalism in Poland (Basingstoke: Macmillan, now Palgrave Macmillan 1998), p. 1. 4 There has naturally been much Polish interest in the contrasting British case and in recent trends towards more ‘written’ forms of constitutionalism and arguments such as those put by Charter 88 for a Bill of Rights in Britain; see also Maria Kruk, Nowe projekty brytyskiej konstytucji pisanej, Pa´nstwo i Prawo, XLVIII, no. 8 (1993), 69–78. 5 Grzegorz L⁄ ukomski, Konstytucje Rzeczpospolitej Niepodleglej, Tydzie´n Polski, 5 May 2001. 6 For the modern period, see: Marian K. Dziewanowski, Poland in the Twentieth Century (New York: Columbia University Press, 1977); Robert F. Leslie (ed.), The History of Poland since 1863 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983), Wl⁄ adysl⁄ aw Pobóg-Malinowski, Najnowsza historia polityczna Polski, 1864–1945 3 vols (London: B. Swiderski, 1956–60). 7 On Poland’s changing historical frontiers, consult the following: Richard Crampton and Ben Crampton, Atlas of Eastern Europe in the Twentieth Century (London: Routledge, 1996), Wl⁄ adysl⁄ aw Czapli´nski and Tadeusz Ladogórski, ⁄ Atlas historyczny Polski 4th edn (Warsaw: PPKW, 1979), lwo Cyprian Pogonowski, Poland, A Historical Atlas (New York: Hippocrene Books, 1987).
18 Democratic Government in Poland 8 This is the underlying thesis of George Sanford, Poland, The Conquest of History (Amsterdam: Harwood Academic Press, 1999). 9 The constant reinterpretation of Poland’s history to reflect the needs of the time as well as pre-1989 cyclical swings between political idealism and realism, is examined by Adam Bromke, The Meaning and Uses of Polish History (New York: Columbia University Press, 1987). 10 Cited in William H. Hagen, Germans, Poles and Jews: the Nationality Conflict in the Prussian East, 1772–1914 (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1980), p. 36 ff. 11 Raymond Taras, Consolidating Democracy in Poland (Boulder CO: Westview Press, 1995), Ch. 1. 12 Politics specialists of my own generation lament the decline in the viability of student textbooks for even medium-sized countries like Poland. This was confirmed to me by Vincent Wright before his untimely death in 1999. As the distinguished author of books that included The Government and Politics of France, widely regarded as one of the best textbooks on France ever written, which both described and interpreted the politics of the Fifth Republic, Wright’s judgement was both authoritative and depressingly realistic. 13 Jerzy Krasucki in Polityka, 26 December 1993. 14 Cf. Michael Burleigh, The Knights, Nationalists and the Historians in Ethics and Extermination, Reflections on Nazi Genocide (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997), pp. 10–11. 15 See Witold Hensel, The Beginnings of the Polish State (Warsaw: Polonia, 1960); Pawel Jasienica, Piast Poland (New York: Hippocrene, 1985); Paul Knoll, The Rise of the Polish Monarchy: Piast Poland in East-Central Europe, 1320–1370 (Chicago: Chicago University Press, 1970); Tadeusz Manteuffel, The Formation of the Polish State: the Period of Ducal Rule, 963–1194 (Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1985). 16 Cf. Tytus Komarnicki, The Rebirth of Poland (London: Heinemann, 1957). See also George Sanford and Adriana Gozdecka-Sanford, Historical Dictionary of Poland (Metuchen NJ: Scarecrow Press, 1994), p. 54. 17 Cf. Marian K. Dziewanowski, Joseph Pil⁄ sudski: a European Federalist, 1918–1922 (Stanford CA: Hoover Institution Press, 1969). 18 Raymond Leslie Buell, Poland: Key to Europe (London: Jonathan Cape, 1939), p. 45. 19 Ibid., p. 43. 20 For the interplay between Piast and Jagiellonian ideas in the interwar Endek and Sanacja camps, see Jaros⁄law Ksia˙˛zek, Historyczne i wspólczesne watki idei Jagiello´nskiej w narodowodemokratyczne publicystyce i historiografii okresu mie˛ dzywojennego, Studia Polityczne, no. 4 (1995), 147–63. 21 Klaus von Beyme, Transition to Democracy in Eastern Europe (Basingstoke: Macmillan, now Palgrave Macmillan, 1966), p. 155. 22 The filming of Sienkiewicz’s great Trilogy was completed with the appearance of ‘With Fire and Sword’ (Ogniem i Miecziem) in 1999 – an historical romance set against the background of Chmielnicki’s uprising. It is symptomatic that the director, Jerzy Hoffman, was generally praised for diverging from the author’s more primordial stereotypes in presenting a very sympathetic picture of the Ukrainian Cossack anti-hero, Bohun. 23 See George Sanford, Nation, State and Independence in Belarus, Contemporary Politics, III (1997), 225–45.
The Constitution and History 19 24 Cf. Ilya Prizel, National Identity and Foreign Policy, Nationalism and Leadership in Poland, Russia and Ukraine (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998), pp. 129–37. 25 On the former, see David Bennett (ed.), Multicultural States. Rethinking Difference and Identity (London: Routledge, 1998) Chs 1–6. On the latter, see inter alia Andreas Klinke, Ortwin Renn and Jean-Paul Lehners (eds), Ethnic Conflicts and Civil Society. Proposals for a New Era in Eastern Europe (Aldershot: Ashgate, 1997). 26 See J. Siemienski, Constitutional Conditions in the Fifteenth and Sixteenth Centuries, in William Fiddian Reddaway, J. H. Penson, Oskar Halecki and Roman Dyboski (eds), The Cambridge History of Poland. From the Origins to Sobieski (To 1696). (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1950), p. 417. 27 Roman Dyboski, Outline of Polish History 2nd edn (London, George Allen & Unwin, 1931), p. 68. 28 Jerzy Michalski (ed.), Historia Sejmu Polskiego, volume 1. Do schyl⁄ ku szlacheckiej Rzeczypospolitej (Warsaw: PWN, 1984). 29 Wacl⁄ aw Uruszczak, in Juliusz Bardach (ed.), Parlamentaryzm w Polsce w wspólczesnej historiografii (Warsaw: Wydawnictwo Sejmowe, 1995), p. 55. 30 See Gieysztor et al. History of Poland, pp. 297–9. 31 Cf. Janusz Tazbir, A State without Stakes: Religious Toleration in Reformation Poland (Warsaw: PWN, 1973). 32 See Harry E. Dembinski, The Union of Lublin in the Golden Age (New York: Columbia University Press, 1982). 33 See Pawel Jasienica, The Commonwealth of Both Nations (Poland and Lithuania). The Silver Age (New York: Hippocrene, 1985). 34 On the historical role of clerics in parliament, see Marian Kallas and Jerzy Gutkowski, Ko´sciól⁄ a Sejm Polski (Warsaw: Wydawnictwo Sejmowe, 1999). 35 Cf. Marian Kallas, Historia ustroju Polski, X–XX w. (Warsaw: PWN, 1999), pp. 87–93. 36 See Oskar Halecki, A History of Poland, op. cit. Chs 13–15. 37 The Constitution of Poland before the Partitions, in The Cambridge History of Poland, 1697–1935, op. cit., p. 49. 38 But see the balanced appraisal by Wojciech Kriegseisen, Sejmiki Rzeczypospolitej szlacheckiej w XVII i XVIII wieku (Warsaw: Wydawnictwo Sejmowe, 1991) which revises the Sejmiki’s negative popular stereotype. 39 Buell, op. cit., p. 48. 40 Stanisl⁄ aw Kutrzeba, The Composition of the Polish Sejm, in Wl⁄ adysl⁄ aw Czapli´nski (ed.), The Polish Parliament at the Summit of its Development (Wrocl⁄ aw: Osolineum, 1985), pp. 13–20. 41 Henryk Olszewski, Sejm Rzeczypospolitej epoki oligarchii, 1562–1763 (Poznan ´: Wydawnictwo UAM, 1966). 42 Wl⁄ adysl⁄ aw Konopczy´nski, Le Liberum Veto. Étude sur le development du principe majoritaire (Paris: Bibliotheque Polonaise, 1930). 43 See Wl⁄ adysl⁄ aw Konopczy´nski in The Cambridge History of Poland (1697–1935), chs 1 and 2. Jerzy T. Lukowski, Liberty’s Folly: The Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth in the Eighteenth Century, 1697–1795 (London: Routledge, 1991). 44 Herbert H. Kaplan, The First Partition of Poland (New York: Columbia University Press, 1962). 45 Jerzy T. Lukowski, The Partitions of Poland 1772, 1793, 1795 (London: Longman, 1999).
20 Democratic Government in Poland 46 This is stressed in the older and classical interpretations by Reddaway, Dembinski and Kukiel in The Cambridge History of Poland (1697–1935) Chs 5–8, but downplayed by Lukowski in the work cited in the previous reference. 47 Dyboski, op. cit., p. 133. 48 Stefania Ochman, Plans for Parliamentary Reform in the Commonwealth in the Seventeenth Century, in Czapli´nski, op. cit., pp. 163–87. 49 Cf. B. Grochulska, Ksiestwo ˛ Warszawskie(Warsaw: Wiedza Powszechna, 1966) and J. Holland Rose, Napoleon and Poland in The Cambridge History of Poland (1697–1935). 50 See Marceli Handelsman in ibid., Ch. 11; Marian Kallas, Konstytucja Ksi˛estwa Warszawskiego (Torun ´ : PWN, 1970). Wl⁄ adysl⁄ aw Soboci´nski, Historia ustroju i prawa Ksi˛estwa Warszawskiego(Toru´n: PWN, 1964). 51 See William John Rose, The Rise of Polish Democracy (London: Bell, 1944), p. 11. 52 See Marian Kukiel, Dzieje Polski porozbiorowe, 1795–1921 (London: Puls, 1993). See Anna Rosner, Sejmy Ksi˛estwa Warszawskiego i Królestwo Polskiego, in Bardach, Parlamentaryzm w Polsce, op. cit. 53 The fate of Poland’s institutions under their rule is discussed by Andrzej Ajnenkiel, Historia sejmu polskiego volume 2, part I. W dobie rozbiorów (Warsaw: PWN, 1989). Along with the Congress Kingdom, up until 1830, the other semiautonomous region was the Free City of Kraków; see Wojciech Bartel, Ustrój i prawo Wolnego Miasto Kraków 1815–1846 (Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie, 1976). 54 See Stefan Kieniewicz, Historia Polski, 1795–1918 (Warsaw: PWN, 1987); Robert F. Leslie, Polish Politics and the Revolution of November 1831 (London: Athlone Press, 1956); Robert F. Leslie, Reform and Insurrection in Russian Poland, 1856–1865 (London: Athlone Press, 1963); Piotr Wandycz, The Lands of Partitioned Poland, 1795–1918 (Seattle: University of Washington Press, 1975). 55 See Jerzy Jedlicki, A Suburb of Europe: XIX Century Polish Approaches to Western Civilization (Budapest: Central European University Press, 1999). 56 See Józef Buszko, Sejmowa reforma wyborcza w Galicji, 1905–1914 (Warsaw: PWN, 1956) and Polacy w parlamencie Wiedenskim, 1848–1918 (Warsaw: Wydawnictwo Sejmowe, 1996); Stanisl⁄ aw Grodziski, Sejm Krajowy galicyjski, 1861–1914 (Warsaw: Wydawnictwo Sejmowe, 1993); Konstanty Grzybowski, Galicja, 1848–1914. Historia ustroju politycznego na tle ustroju Austria (Wrocl⁄ aw: Ossolineum, 1959). 57 Cf. The Cambridge History of Poland (1697–1935), Chs 13–19. 58 Brzezinski, op. cit., p. 47. 59 Contained in a highly thought provoking and much discussed symposium – Stanisl⁄ aw Gomulka and Antony Polonsky (eds). Polish Paradoxes (London: Routledge, 1990). 60 See Juliusz Bardach, Bogusl⁄ aw Le´snodorski and Michal⁄ Pietrzak, Historia pa´nstwa i prawa polskiego, (Warsaw: PWN, 1976) Ch. 7; Ryszard L⁄ aszewski, Sejm polski w latach, 1764–1793 (Warsaw: PWN, 1973); Michalski, Historia Sejmu polskiego, vol. 1, Ch. 6. 61 Jerzy L⁄ ojek, Geneza i obalenie Konstytucji 3 maja: polityka zagraniczna Rzeczypospolitej, 1787–1792 (Lublin: Wydawnictwo Lubelskie, 1986). 62 Cf. Jerzy Kowecki, Sejm Czteroletni i jego tradycje (Warsaw: PWN, 1991). See also Bogusl⁄ aw Le´snodorski, Dziel⁄ o Sejmu Czteroletniego, 1788–1792. Studium historyczno-prawne (Wrocl⁄ aw: Ossolineum, 1951); Rett Ludwikowski and William Fox, The Beginning of the Constitutional Era: a Bicentennial Comparative Analysis of
The Constitution and History 21
63
64 65 66 67
68
69
70 71
72
73
74 75
76
77
the First Modern Constitutions (Washington DC: Catholic University Press of America, 1993). The text is in Jerzy Kowecki (ed.), Konstytucja 3 Maja 1791 (Warsaw: PWN, 4th edn 1991). The traditional view on Stanisl⁄ aw Augustus’ positive role in producing the constitution presented by Emanuel Rostworowski, Ostatni król Rzeczypospolitej, Geneza i upadek konstytucji 3 Maja (Warsaw: Wiedza Powszechna, 1966) has been challenged by Jerzy L⁄ ojek, Upadek konstytucji 3 maja. Studium historyczne (Wrocl⁄ aw: Ossolineum, 1976). Andrzej Ajnenkiel, Polskie konstytucje (Warsaw: Wydawnictwo Szkolne i Pedagogiczne, 1991), pp. 62–75. Wojciech Bartel, Ustroj wl⁄ adz cywilnych powstania Ko´sciuszkowskiego (Wrocl⁄ aw: Ossolineum, 1959). Cf. Andrzej Zahorski (ed.), Konstytucja Majowa (Warsaw: PWN, 1991). Hertzberg, the Prussian Minister in Poland, conceded that the constitution of 3 May 1791 ‘was much better than the English’ one and that ‘a numerous and well-governed nation’ now posed a basic threat to Prussia’s territorial gains and state interests. Cited in Gieysztor et al., History of Poland, p. 320. See Brzezinski op. cit., p. 45; Manfred Kridl, Józef Wittlin and Wl⁄ adysl⁄ aw Malinowski (eds), The Democratic Heritage of Poland (London: George Allen & Unwin, 1944), pp. 43–4. For a detailed overview situating interwar parliamentarianism in its historical context; see Andrzej Ajnenkiel, Parlamentaryzm II Rzeczypospolitej (Warsaw: Wiedza Powszechna, 1975). Some of the best examinations remain the contemporary overviews by Buell, op. cit., and Robert Machray, The Poland of Pil⁄ sudski (London: Dutton, 1937). Joseph Rothschild, Pil⁄ sudski’s coup d’etat (New York: Columbia University Press, 1966). Andrzej Chownowski, Pil⁄ sudczycy u wl⁄ adzy. Dzieje Bezpartyjnego Bloku Wspól⁄ pracy z Rz adem ˛ (Wrocl⁄ aw: Ossolineum, 1986). Andrzej Garlicki, Od maja do Brze´scia (Warsaw: Czytelnik, 1981). But even such a Germanophile and pro-Pil⁄ sudski history like that of Hans Roos reached more balanced conclusions – see Roos, A History of Modern Poland (London: Eyre & Spottiswoode, 1966), pp. 168–9. For the reality, see Ryszard Mojak, ‘Ewolucja polskiego konstytucjonalizmu w okresie Drugie Rzeczpospolitej’, in Artur Korobowicz et al., Zarys dziejów konstytucjonalizmu polskiego (Lublin: Wydawnictwo UMC-S, 1996). The 30-strong Constitutional Committee produced the Little Constitution within a week. Kronika Sejmowa, First Sejm, nos 2–3, 30 January–12 February 1992, pp. 47–50. Cf. Stanisl⁄ aw Krukowski, Geneza konstytucji z 17 marca 1921r (Warsaw: Ludowa Spol⁄ dzielna Wydawnicza, 1977). Kallas, Historia ustroju Polski, pp. 307–8. For a discussion of the rival preliminary drafts and its final contents, see Leon Grosfeld and Henryk Zieli´nski (eds), Historia Polski, vol. IV, part 1 (1918–1926, Chs 1–13), (Warsaw: PWN, 1969), Ch. 12. For the constitutional and political debates, see Andrzej Ajnenkiel, Spór o model parlamentaryzmu polskiego do roku 1926 (Warsaw: KiW, 1972). See also Tomasz Nal⁄ ecz, ˛ Spór o ksztal⁄ t demokracji i parlamentaryzmu w Polsce w latach 1921–1926 (Warsaw: Wydawnictwa Prywatnej Wyzszej Szkol⁄ y Businessu i Administracji, 1994). See Rose, op. cit., p. 162.
22 Democratic Government in Poland 78 Jerzy Holzer, Mozaika Politycznej Drugiej Rzeczypospolitej (Warsaw: KiW, 1974). Andrzej Micewski, Z geografii politycznej II Rzeczypospolitej (Warsaw: Znak, 1964). 79 Their activities were naturally played up during the PRL; see Tadeusz Daniszewski, Posl⁄ owie rewolucyini w Sejmie, 1920–1933 (Warsaw: KiW, 1961). Such discussions, however, raised issues about the Marxist-Leninist attitude towards democracy and parliamentarianism; cf. Andrzej Gwi˙zd˙z, Posl⁄ owie Komunistycznej Frakcji Poselskej o ustroju pa´nstwowym Polski przedwrze´sniowej, Pa´nstwo i Prawo XIII, no. 12 (December 1958). 80 Antony Polonsky, Politics in Independent Poland, 1921–1939 (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1972) Chs 2 and 3. 81 Michal⁄ Pietrzak, Rz ady ˛ parlamentarne w Polsce w latach 1919–1926 (Warsaw: KiW, 1969), pp. 309–10. 82 Peter D. Stachura (ed.), Poland Between the Wars, 1918–1939 (Basingstoke: Macmillan, now Palgrave Macmillan, 1998), p. 5. 83 Equivalent to the Mendès-France phenomenon in the French Fourth Republic in 1954. Philip Williams, Crisis and Compromise. Politics in the Fourth Republic (London: Longman, 1972), pp. 45–6, 419–21. 84 Cf. Andrzej Gwizd ˙ z, ˙ Przyczynek do genezy i losów konstytucji marcowej, Pa´nstwo i Prawo, XLII, no. 12 (December 1977). 85 Jerzy Wisl⁄ ocki, Konkordat Polski z 1925r: zagadnienia prawne-polityczne (Pozna´n: Wydawnictwo UAM, 1977). 86 Kallas, Historia ustroju Polski, pp. 349–56. 87 Ewa Gdulewicz, ‘Niektore zagadnienia ustroju politycznego w Konstytucji z 23 kwietna 1935r’, Pa´nstwo i Prawo, XXX no. 3 (March 1975). 88 Cf. Jacek Majchrowski (ed.), Stanisl⁄ aw Car – polska koncepcja autorytarizmu (Warsaw: Wydawnictwo Sejmowe, 1996). 89 Dz. U. RP, 1935, n. 30, position 227. 90 See Hanna and Tadeusz Je˛ druszczak, Ostatnie lata Drugiej Rzeczypospolitej, 1935–1939 (Warsaw: KiW, 1970); Edward D. Wynot, Polish Politics in Transition. The Camp of National Unity and the Struggle for Power, 1935–1939 (Athens GA: University of Georgia Press, 1974). 91 Cf. Zbigniew Zaporowski, Sejm RP 1919–1939 (Lublin: Wydawnictwo UMC-S, 1992). 92 Paul Latawski (ed.), Poland between the Wars, 1918–1939 (London: Macmillan – now Palgrave Macmillan, 1992). 93 Cf. Wojciech Roszkowski and Zbigniew Landau, ibid. 94 Hubert Izdebski, Administracja publiczna. Zagadnienia ogólne (Warsaw: LIBER, 1998), p. 69. 95 Cf. George Sakwa, The Role of Parliament in a Communist Political System: the Polish Sejm, 1952–1972 (University of London PhD dissertation, 1974), pp. 27–8. 96 Some authorities consider that the ‘rich and broad inheritance’ of Polish constitutionalism makes it difficult to call on any single dominant tradition. See Jan Wawzryniak, Zarys Polskiego ustroju konstytucyinego (Bydgoszcz: Branta, 1999), p. 56. While I agree, to some extent, with the residual Marxist view that constitutions are specifically located in their historical and social contexts I feel that countries also develop continually recurring patterns of values which can be regarded as autonomous and long-term traditions. 97 See Geoffrey Pridham, Confining Conditions and Breaking with the Past: Historical Legacies and Political Learning in Transitions to Democracy, Democratisation VII (Summer 2000), 36–64.
The Constitution and History 23 98 On the relationship between nation building, Romantic Nationalism and revolutionary stirrings for constitutional democracy within an independent statehood, consult the seminal works by Andrzej Walicki: Philosophy and Romantic Nationalism: the case of Poland (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1982); The Enlightenment and the Birth of Modern Nationhood: Polish Political Thought from Noble Republicanism to Tadeusz Ko´sciuszko (Notre Dame IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 1989). 99 In my view, Arista Cirtautas underestimates the domestic roots of Polish liberal constitutional values in her attempt to identify Solidarity and the Polish revolution of 1989 with the tradition of the American revolution, The Polish Solidarity Movement, Revolution, Democracy and Natural Rights (London: Routledge, 1997). 100 Adam Bromke, Poland’s Politics: Idealism versus Realism (Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press, 1967).
2 The Communist Experience and Legacy
The debate on the Polish People’s Republic Since the fall of communism there has been a great debate on the place of the Polish People’s Republic (PRL) in Polish history. Should it be viewed as an externally controlled Soviet satellite run on Marxist–Leninist principles completely alien to the Polish tradition?1 Or is this just one more case of Poland subverting foreign rule from within and eventually producing an original Polonized synthesis? If it was the former, then it represented a basic discontinuity. Both the Solidarity and national-Catholic political camps have argued that communism had to be purged from both political consciousness and practice. If it was the latter, the PRL was a legitimate and continuous section of Polish history, comparable to the nineteenth-century experience; many of its features, in this light, could be regarded as leading on organically through the ‘Negotiated Revolution’ of 1989 to the democratic period. The key issues of the degree of subjugation to the Soviet Union and whether the PRL can justly be described as ‘totalitarian’, remain one of the most important cleavages in contemporary Polish political life. At the end of the Second World War, communist rule was imposed on Poland via Red Army occupation and the Yalta and Potsdam Great Power agreements.2 This involved suppression of the successors to Polish Home Army (AK) resistance, the cowing of the population and the gradual elimination of opposition within the communist-dominated Provisional Government coalition of 1945–47. The lack of popular support for the Soviet-backed Polish Workers’ Party (PPR) and the falsified nature of electoral consultations such as the referendum of 30 June 1946 and the Sejm elections of 17 January 1947, have now been amply documented.3 Kenney has, however, also shown how such campaigns mobilized support for the PPR and its Polish Socialist Party (PPS) ally.4 PPR political success in recruiting membership and drawing on genuine support for rebuilding the country as well as for nationalization, social welfare, educational, health and land reforms, has been downplayed since the PRL’s demise. But the 24
The Communist Experience and Legacy 25
dispute over the balance between external and domestic factors, mirroring the political cleavages of the 1990s, is in many respects a secondary matter. The real controversy, in my view, lies over the character of the Stalinist system which developed after 1947 and the extent to which it was either modified or replaced from 1955 onwards. The communists had achieved their monopoly of power by 1948. In that year the PPS was amalgamated forcibly with the PPR in the Polish United Workers’ Party (PZPR) which ran the PRL until its demise.5 The First Secretary, Wl⁄ adysl⁄ aw Gomul⁄ ka, an authoritarian who nevertheless took Poland’s domestic factors into account, was replaced in that post by a grey bureaucrat, Bolesl⁄ aw Bierut, who had spent the war in the USSR.6 The Muscovite team which he headed during the late 1940s and early 1950s were both totally subservient to Stalin and genuine believers in the Soviet form of ideological Marxism–Leninism.7 Hilary Minc established a command and directive economy with industrialization concentrating on heavy industry.8 Jakub Berman imposed totalitarian controls over education and Socialist Realist norms in culture. But in Poland the pace and degree of Stalinization and the amount of general political terror differed noticeably from that of Hungary and Czechoslovakia during the same time, let alone the USSR in the 1930s.9 Gomul⁄ ka and his supporters survived to play a crucial role in 1956; the communist elite in Poland was not traumatized and retained a significant capacity to struggle for its survival. The collectivization of the agriculture was very incomplete except in the Recovered Territories (i.e. territory recovered from Germany in 1945).10 The conflict with the Roman Catholic church was restricted to the trials of Bishop Kaczmarek of Kielce and a few priests as well as the house arrest of the Primate, Cardinal Stefan Wyszy´nski. This is not to deny that Poland, on Stalin’s death in March 1953, was superficially very similar to other Soviet Satellites.11 One can rightly describe the system as having been totalitarian and quasi sovereign for that short period. But the rapidity and ease with which it was subsequently transformed, supports doubts about the strength of its entrenchment. The Polish experience was also unusual in that most political violence occurred during the near civil war conditions of the period of takeover of power, 1944–47 (12–15 000 deaths), rather than in the subsequent Stalinization of 1948–54.12 The periodization of the PRL can be listed under the following headings: takeover and consolidation of power (1944–47); monolithic Stalinism (1948–54); social challenge and political restructuring (1955–57); the Gomul⁄ ka (1956–70) and Gierek (1970–80) regimes; Solidarity (1980–81); Martial Law (December 1981–Summer 1983); and the subsequent Jaruzelski regime.13 There was an enormous debate, at the time, about the extent to which the gains of October 1956 (known in Poland simply as October) represented an original and permanent form of pluralist authoritarianism.14 In practice, the boundaries of the compromise were continually fought over
26 Democratic Government in Poland
in subsequent conflicts between the communist state and Polish society. The Gomul⁄ ka, Gierek and Jaruzelski regimes15 also underwent considerable internal evolution and were not homogeneous. Political historians, in the meantime, debated the significance of subperiods such as Gomul⁄ ka’s ‘Little Stabilization’ (1958–64),16 Mieczysl⁄ aw Moczar’s Partisan challenge and its aftermath (1968–70),17 or the three periods of Gierek’s rule – O˙zywienie (political liveliness and reform, 1971), upswing and the great leap into the economic abyss (1972–76) and decline (1976–80).18 The literature on Poland is littered with now forgotten studies that discuss Solidarity’s capacity, in 1980–81, for achieving fundamental transformation by institutionalising economic and social pluralism,19 the nature of military rule and the chances of the Jaruzelski regime being able to consolidate (1982–86)20 or reform sufficiently in the Gorbachev period (1987–89) in order to survive.21 These dramatic events in Poland set political scientists some intrinsically interesting questions on the capacities of ‘actually existing’ or ‘Real Socialism’ in Poland to accommodate political, social and intellectual pluralism within a One-Party modernizing fold. Many key academic questions were formulated – in the more settled and ‘normal’ periods of PRL life – on PZPR crisis management and its ideological and social compromises.22 But such academic questions were usually squeezed out and overshadowed by what the victorious 1989 camp and earlier dissident literature interpreted as the great duel between Polish society on the one hand and the PZPR and its external protectors on the other.23 In this perspective, the near civil war of 1945–47, which saw the destruction of the AK and of an independent political system; October 1956 which limited PZPR capacity to rule; the workers’ revolt in December 1970 (and even more so, August 1980 which saw a fundamental working class and societal challenge); developed in the 1980s into a statement of developments leading in 1989 to the downfall of the communist system. This standard interpretation mirrors the East–West ideological-systemic conflict of the 1980s; it weaves together the strands of the regaining of national independence and the replacement of a Marxist–Leninist by a democratic capitalist system. Past controversies continued into the new era. One important political cleavage remained the decommunization issue. Another was lustration – the disqualification of all communist party officials from holding elected or public office in a new democracy. Had the PRL represented just one long and continuing struggle of the Polish nation against foreign rulers and their stooges? In that case historical justice demanded the punishment and removal of all traces of the latter from public life. Alternatively, did the continually varied, and often surprisingly innovative, PZPR reactions to the 1956, 1970, 1980 and 1988, outbursts represent pluralist renewal and national transformation culminating in the qualitative leap of 1989? The debate between revolutionary and evolutionary interpretations is as old as Ko´sciuszko’s Insurrection of 1794, the Napoleonic Legions and the nine-
The Communist Experience and Legacy 27
teenth-century uprisings.24 But there are also additional dimensions for controversy over whether the PRL created a modernized and secular society, despite its cyclical pattern of political and social blockages, political outbursts and economic stagnation and failure, especially after 1978. Another great controversy concerning the PRL is whether the communists were forced into their peaceful abdication of power as a result of abandonment by Gorbachev and the USSR, total economic failure, the political25 and social26 blockages caused by unrelenting societal opposition to anything short of systemic reform27 and the growth of ‘political capitalism’.28 The details concerning the course and outcome of Poland’s Negotiated Revolution are discussed in the chapters that follows.29 Jacek Kuro´n, a leading anti-communist from the 1960s onwards, when he cowrote The Open Letter to the Party with Karol Modzelewski,30 claimed that ‘totalitarian dictatorship had been defeated by society and the opposition.’31 One can agree with Andrzej Walicki, however, that the totalitarianauthoritarian and national counter society/developmental – modernizing antinomies – are part of the PRL’s rich and paradoxical complexity. Walicki gives a resounding negative to the question ‘was the PRL a totalitarian state?’32 Critical political scientists such as Andrzej Paczkowski and Wojciech Roszkowski have conceded the PRL’s major transformation in 1956 and 1980 but contended that its fundamental systemic character remained Soviet-dependent and thus, wholly illegitimate.33 The contributors to this very influential debate in the Catholic weekly, Tygodnik Powszechny, in 1994–95, also argued that change in the PRL never became qualitative in character (Jerzy Turowicz); furthermore, its totalitarianism was weak and ineffective (Krystyna Kersten and Jerzy Szacki). It collapsed because it repressed the Poles’ freedom, religion and national identity while failing to deliver consumer prosperity (Andrzej Friszke).34 On the other hand, Jerzy Holzer pointed out that the PRL had neither systemic nor international choice between 1945–89 although the country and its elites wrested the maximum possible freedom of manoeuvre. Advocating a cautious comparative perspective to PRL achievements and failures, he concluded that ‘all that happened in Poland during the years 1945–89, is part of Poland’s history’.35
The communist party-state in Poland A major dichotomy exists between popular and academic definitions of the concept of totalitarianism. The former derives from Hannah Arendt’s formulation of the totalitarian state – run symbolically in the form of a concentration camp with power-holders exercising unlimited social control.36 Such updated forms of tyranny are expressed through ideology, the cult of the leader’s personality, as well as modern technological methods of surveillance, brainwashing, social control and mobilization. George Orwell
28 Democratic Government in Poland
reflected this terrifying vision in 1984 where even language is engineered to make heretical thinking impossible. Totalitarian explanations emphasized hysterical unpredictability and the atomization of all intermediate organizations and state-society linkages, resulting in isolated and alienated individuals controlled through transmission belts. Political scientists, however, discerned much institutional regularity and increasing procedural predictability in the mechanisms of post-Stalinist rule – even in the six features (single ideology; single party; terror; economic, cultural and weapons monopolies) identified by Friedrich and Brzezinski’s generally accepted categorization.37 Leonard Schapiro later added strong leadership and the absence of rule of law and facilitated acceptance of looser, almost comparative, conceptions of totalitarianism.38 Communism worldwide had, however, changed, producing different roads to socialism in different countries.39 The domestic shift from Stalinism to successor forms within various countries after 1956 was particularly striking in Yugoslavia and Poland, and before long in Hungary as well.40 Schapiro’s argument that communist parties still had totalitarian control reflexes, and that destalinization had not altered the essential contours of the totalitarian paradigm, influenced western public opinion and this intensified in the 1980s. Conservatives such as Reagan and Thatcher equated ‘Totalitarian Stalinism’, whose crimes and failures were being revealed under Gorbachev – as they had been earlier, by Khruschev – with all forms of communism in their domestic neo-liberal drives. Solzhenitsyn’s influential Gulag literature, and dissidents such as Leszek Kol⁄ akowski in the West and Jacek Kuro´n and Adam Michnik within Poland, reinforced the popular view that intrasystemic reform of communism was impossible. By 1988, Michnik described Polish communism most evocatively as ‘totalitarianism with broken teeth’.41 The development of a differentiated and polycentric communist world naturally encouraged a wide range of comparative communist approaches and explanations within the political science community.42 The key was the shift from the totalitarian to the authoritarian model. The extent of pluralism, and even democratization, possible within the one-party fold was much debated. H.G. Skilling distinguished between integral, fundamental and specific forms of opposition within communist states as well as between totalitarian, authoritarian-pluralist and democratising forms of communism.43 Numerous economic reforms, largely of the institutions and procedures of command economic planning, were also accompanied, especially in Yugoslavia, in Kadar’s Hungary, and in Poland, by increasing discussion of how market indicators and mechanisms could co-exist with socialism. The literatures on the ‘oppositionless state’ highlighted the centrality of the concepts of monopolistic and monolithic rule in communist systems and how these dimensions had been eroded.44 Kremlinology gave way to interpretations based on elite, bureaucratic and, eventually, social pluralism.45
The Communist Experience and Legacy 29
The apparats of the party-state were held to achieve increasing degrees of consciousness of their own distinctiveness and self interest.46 This produced a form of quasi politics which resolved leadership and policy conflicts, notably (in the USSR) in the Brezhnev and (in Poland) the Gierek periods. The mass of empirical evidence prompted the professional view that communist systems could be categorized along a spectrum ranging from independent and major reform of the party-state in Yugoslavia to residual Stalinist tyranny in North Korea and Albania. The USSR and its five closest allies (Poland, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Bulgaria and East Germany), who collaborated within the Warsaw Pact, COMECON and, on a party-to-party level, were held to be intermediate. But even here, the party-society balance in Poland and Hungary, and for a while in 1963–68 Czechoslovakia, was fundamentally different to the situation in the conservative-stabilizers: Bulgaria, East Germany and Romania. An enormous literature discussed the relationship between Marxism and Leninism and whether the ideological synthesis between the two was the essence of communist systems or used purely functionally by power holders in the alleged states of the ‘Dictatorship of the Proletariat’ who were building socialism.47 Again, the whole debate has been transformed by the collapse of communist systems in Europe. Since then western Marxists have attempted to salvage their ideological core from the debris of what Brzezinski rightly calls, in his book of the same name, The Grand Failure.48 What one should note here is that there was a long drawn out redefinition of the ‘Dictatorship of the Proletariat’ and the constitutionalphilosophical framework for the exercise of PZPR hegemony. The Stalinist formulation, that People’s Democracy was an inferior variant developing towards the Soviet model, was replaced by Gomul⁄ ka’s national domestic flexibility – although he supported ideological homogeneity, albeit of a looser type, within the Soviet bloc.49 Gierek wished to redefine the PRL as a form of advanced socialist democracy in which national unity prevailed over class struggle.50 Jaruzelski, within his Marxist commitments, was open minded. He countenanced the discussion of ideological innovations concerning party rule and pluralism in his attempts to broaden his power base and increase his regime’s legitimacy.51 In Poland, constitutional and state lawyers, in general, played a positive, although reformist rather than revolutionary, role by institutionalizing and codifying the boundaries of state power, and often pushing them back as well. What might have seemed anodyne and highly specialist legal-philosophical disputes about the leading role of the communist party, Democratic Centralism, Marxist theories of state power, or Montesquieu and the separation of the powers, had important implications for civic freedom and the limits of pluralism and debate.52 It was a debate that even led some continental political scientists to argue that the PRL represented a compromise between Soviet and European parliamentary models.53
30 Democratic Government in Poland
One can, therefore, understand why the very idea of ‘communist government’ should have been contentious as well as blurred. The importance of state institutions was therefore understated, given official doctrines of the unity of state power and subordination to communist party bodies. Communist party rule has now been extinguished in Europe. Its survival – in the major Chinese exception and the residual Cuban, North Korean and Vietnamese cases – may well be largely tied up with the lives (and eventual passing) of leaders.54 So, would it be fair to conclude that a large part of communist studies, concerning the internal organization, decision-making processes, membership base and role in society of communist parties, has become of only antiquarian interest?55 The answer depends on two factors. Firstly, whether there is still a significant legacy of PRL rule which needs to be overcome, destroyed or democratized.56 Secondly, and the most important factor from the viewpoint of this study, one can ask a number of significant questions about how the communist party actually ran the state institutions and public bodies. Did the latter achieve a degree of autonomy which permitted their character as well as formal organization to carry over into the democratic era?57 The general answer to this latter question is that the charge that parliaments and representative bodies had only a formal and ceremonial role in ratifying and publicizing party decisions, despite communist constitutions formally locating legislative authority in them, is correct; but the problem lay mainly in strict communist control of elections and of the party system. When the party’s leading role loosened, under popular or reformist pressure – as in Poland in 1956 or Czechoslovakia in 1968 – the significance of representative assemblies, even of their plenary, as against committee, proceedings, increased.58 In post-1956 Poland, as in Yugoslavia, parliamentary committees and caucuses were also much more important than elsewhere – giving more than a hint of their potential.59 Overall, there was a grudging admission by western political scientists than the Sejm was, at least, ‘a minimal parliament’, despite PZPR control.60 The Polish literature from Gierek onwards rehabilitated Poland’s historical parliamentary traditions extremely strongly and publicized the activities of the Sejm.61 The formal executive government, heading the state institutions, was a large Council of Ministers composed of the chairman (colloquially the premier) and his deputies who had coordinating functions as well as numerous ministers heading highly differentiated ministries. In the full Council of Ministers, chairmen of state bureaux and provincial governors controlling what was known as territorial self-government, would be added.62 The key to understanding the party-state relationship is that the state bodies were shadowed at every level by a party committee, which in practice was always superior to it. Hence, the politburo supervised the Council of Ministers, while Central Committee secretariats controlled individual ministries in their fields. Economic and planning secretariats
The Communist Experience and Legacy 31
supervised larger factories and enterprises directly. The decision- and policy-making process was highly centralized in the party bodies whose committees were subject to vertical and largely top-down subordination in the party column while themselves enjoying horizontal control over the state organizations.63 The rather schematic picture, however, was much more complicated in practice.64 Central Committee officials and secretariats suffered from excessive work overload. The state bodies gained varying degrees of control, through policy preparation and implementation as well as through evaluation. The Soviet podmenya tendency mentioned above was denounced by communist leaders who regularly attempted to shift the blame for bureaucratic incompetence and corruption onto state organs.65 On the other hand, reform proposals attempted to redefine the communist party’s leading role, in terms of moral inspiration and general policy oversight, while leaving the state bodies to get on with their specialized administrative tasks. The PZPR Statute passed by the Extraordinary Ninth Congress in July 1981 attempted to introduce inner-party democracy and free discussion through the election of officials at every level; it also wanted to separate party, state and social organization office holding, at least on the same level of the hierarchy.66 Conversely, Ceausescu’s Romania went to the other functional extreme in fusing party and state offices.67 Overall, the dynamically changing, intertwined and overlapping character of the partystate relationship in implementing communist rules and policies can readily be conceded.68 So can Paul Lewis’s argument that such a process was as likely to produce over-institutionalization, defined as failure to adapt institutional and policy-making blockages sufficiently to prevent crises, as legitimacy.69 Recurrent crises, however, prompted reform responses. Something like a primitive form of rule of law and institutional autonomy emerged as a precursor of democracy.70
The significance of communist constitutionalism In a socialist state, the constitution was the ‘basic’ or ‘fundamental’ law and was superior to all other law. It was also argued that it was essentially confirmatory rather than programmatic.71 Stefan Rozmaryn, writing in the authoritative PRL commentary, said that ‘the social function of a socialist constitution is to give expression to, and consolidate the new political, social and economic system which has emerged as the result of revolution’.72 Social and economic progress in turn necessitated the promulgation of a new constitution to reflect such changes – as in the replacement of the transitional ‘Little Constitution’ of 1947 by the more advanced 1952 document. Likewise, the Sixth PZPR Congress resolved, in December 1972, that the 1952 constitution had ‘served its role’.73
32 Democratic Government in Poland
Marxist state lawyers categorized Marxist–Leninist constitutions under the headings of transitional (examples include Poland 1947 and USSR 1924), People’s Democratic (Poland 1952 and the first wave of East European constitutions, generally in the 1950s) and those of ‘completed socialist building’ (USSR 1936).74 Czechoslovakia in 1960, Romania in 1965, Yugoslavia in 1963, East Germany in 1968, Bulgaria in 1970 and, even, Hungary which was given an exemption in 1971, were all confirmed by the Kremlin as having reached the latter stage and allowed to declare themselves Socialist Republics. Khruschev preserved the USSR’s most advanced status in the 1961 CPSU programme’s formulation that it was now an all-people’s state, building the foundations of communism.75 Despite Gierek’s own wishes, the PZPR was deemed not to have achieved a high enough level of building socialism and was denied a wholly new constitution in the mid-1970s. Lovenduski and Woodall have stated that Poland’s experience demonstrates ‘that there are important cultural and historical components in a state’s affinity to particular kinds of regime’; such ‘cultural receptivity’ or otherwise had ‘a determining effect on elite-legitimation struggles’.76 In the PRL, this caused positive appraisals of parliamentary traditions and interwar democratic institutions as bulwarks against fascism and authoritarianism.77 The Dictatorship of the Proletariat could thus be built ‘through making use of old legal norms’.78 In practice, the PRL adapted the Sejm, as well as numerous other ancient institutions, practices and historical names, within the Marxist–Leninist framework by claiming that they were progressive and national as they ‘led up to’ the People’s State. Nevertheless, after the Second World-War, the legal-institutional framework for communist rule in Poland took some time and considerable effort to build up. The starting-off point was the PPR’s establishment of the National Council for the Homeland (KRN) in January 1944. This was followed by the formation of the Polish Committee of National Liberation (PKWN) and the proclamation of its Manifesto in Chel⁄ m on 22 July 1944.79 The latter annulled the 1935 constitution and gave the PKWN decreepowers legalizing its de facto rule in Poland against the authority of the Government-in-Exile in London. Such ad hoc measures were formalized at the end of 1944 when a Provisional Government was established in Lublin. Its widening, and transformation into a Government of National Unity, through the inclusion of Stanisl⁄ aw Mikol⁄ ajczyk and some ‘London’ Poles in June 1946, covered up the reality of the PPR’s gradual monopolization of power. The arrangement failed to ensure that the January 1947 elections would be ‘free and unfettered’, as promised at Yalta.80 The old regime was voted out and Bolesl⁄ aw Bierut was elected president by the Constituent Sejm which also confirmed the very symbolic removal of the crown from the head of the white eagle in Poland’s national coat of arms. But the new system was still highly transitional and had to be
The Communist Experience and Legacy 33
camouflaged by fine-sounding philosophical and legal principles. As a result, the Little Constitution of 19 February 1947 was based very heavily on the democratic features of the 1921 constitution although the PKWN Manifesto was given equal weight.81 The short PSL (Polish Peasant Party) draft, proposing that the former should remain in force, with some amendments until a full constitution could be drafted and approved in a referendum, was rejected. On paper, at least, the final PPR-PPS draft confirmed two things: the separation of powers and a parliamentary system.82 The final draft incorporated 26 articles from the 1921 constitution, mainly referring to the Sejm, alongside 32 new ones dealing mainly with the executive powers of the presidency and the previously established Council of State which assumed the powers of the now dissolved KRN presidium. The fact that the Sejm was controlled by the PPR and its allies, however, allowed many formalities and appearances to be maintained, even during the height of Stalinism. The conditional class-defined character of individual rights also rendered meaningless such documents, following the promulgation of the Little Constitution, as the ‘Declaration of Rights and Liberties’.83 Work on a new constitution was undertaken by two PZPR secretariat committees, established in June 1949, who reported in March 1951. One worked on the draft and the other dealt with ideological questions. They were closely supervised by Bierut, supported by Berman, who presented the politburo with crucial decisions on how the draft defined the building of socialism. It would appear that they personally decided not to include a statement on the leading role of the communist party, to replace the presidency with a collective body – the Council of State – and to exclude organs of state control such as the Supreme Control Chamber (NIK). The 103strong Constitutional Commission, set up by the Sejm through the Law of 26 May 1951, was, therefore, largely a formal body.84 It met only four times and its chairman, Bierut, did the real work as part of an editorial subcommittee.85 The constitution was modelled very closely on the Soviet Constitution of 5 December 1936. Berman has admitted that Stalin personally approved the draft which they took to Moscow.86 The Stalinist state mounted a massive campaign to mobilize approval for its constitution in Spring 1952. It claimed that 11 million Poles discussed the draft at meetings and that a quite absurdly high number of suggestions and amendments had been considered. The campaign of Stalinist terror and controlled participation culminated with the passing of the constitution by the Sejm in 22 July 1952, henceforth a day that was to be celebrated as National Day. Bierut’s keynote speech lauded the document’s historic significance: confirming Poland’s irrevocable embarkation on the victorious road of building socialism, in alliance with the Soviet Union and following its model and its experience.87 The 1952 constitution was to be amended 18 times by 1988 but it provided the legal-constitutional framework and the ideological-political
34 Democratic Government in Poland
justification for the communist elites during the whole life of the PRL. The original document was made up of a preamble and 91 articles grouped under 10 chapter headings.88 The preamble commended the Polish working class for leading the national struggle against the partitioning powers and Hitlerism, for achieving just borders in alliance with the USSR after the Second World War, and for implementing social change promised in the PKWN Manifesto. The worker-peasant alliance in Poland was modelled on the ‘historic experience of the victory of building socialism in the USSR, the first workers and peasants state’.89 The state was renamed the Polish People’s Republic, a state of People’s Democracy;90 ‘power belonged to the working people of town and countryside’ (art. 1) whose will was expressed by elected representatives to the Sejm and local People’s Councils (art. 2). The programmatic aims of industrialization and economic progress on the basis of the nationalization of the means of production were set out in article 3 and in Chapter II on the socioeconomic system (arts 7–14). The eye-catching exceptions, articles 10–13, sanctioned privately owned peasant agriculture, co-operatives, private and co-operative handicrafts as well as private personal property. Under Stalinist conditions of police control, a hysterical political atmosphere and centralized party-rule, Chapter 3 on the leading organs of state power (arts 15–28), was bound to be most strikingly at variance with reality. But many of the formal provisions were to provide the basis for later intrasystemic reform. The Sejm was declared to be the leading organ of state power, expressing the people’s will and national sovereignty (art. 15). It controlled the government and state administration, passed the national economic plan and the state budget, and appointed the Council of State which shared legislative initiative with the government and Sejm deputies. In practice, articles 25–26, giving it the right to issue decree laws, was abused during the 1952–56 period to largely replace the Sejm, whose subsequent ratification was hurried and formal. The Sejm also appointed and dismissed the Council of Ministers, defined as ‘the government’ (art. 29.i) as well as individual ministers (art. 29) although, again, the Council of State de facto assumed this function up until 1956. The Council of Ministers was defined by article 30.i as ‘the supreme executing and administrative organ of state-power’ answerable to the Sejm and the Council of State. The subsequent chapters on territorial organs, the judiciary and procuracy (the state’s prosecuting arm) and basic rights and obligations of the citizen, again, outlined the formal framework. Their high-sounding principles camouflaged the realities of Stalinist rule, especially where personal, religious and political freedoms were concerned. The obligations of obeying the constitution and socialist law, of military service and of protecting social property and state secrets, as well as being ‘on guard’ against enemies of the state (art. 79.i), were very widely construed to impose labour and social discipline and suppress anti-communist activity.
The Communist Experience and Legacy 35
All rights were limited by the requirement that they accord with the aims and principles of the socialist system. Stefan Rozmaryn, the foremost constitutional commentator during the first half of the PRL, formulated the subordination of so-called universal rights to Marxist–Leninist principles and working-class interests.91 In 1947, the Roman Catholic church sent the authorities a memorandum postulating that since the Polish nation was largely Catholic the constitution should be cast in a Christian form.92 Under conditions of growing Stalinism, this somewhat naïve demand was rejected. The 1952 constitution separated church and state completely and left the detailed regulation of the issue to further legislation. Article 70 conceded the formal rights of religious belief and practice but balanced this with a declaration that any misuse of such rights was punishable. The Polish bishops had signed an agreement with the government on 14 April 1950 which conceded the church’s right to an autonomous religious life.93 But growing repression culminated in a decree of 9 February 1953 by which the communist authorities attempted to control church appointments. Resolute opposition led to conflict and to Cardinal Wyszy´nski’s internment.94 A new churchstate agreement with Gomul⁄ ka’s regime in December 1956, conceded religious freedom and a greater degree of organizational autonomy. The provisional character of diocesan organization in the Western (Recovered) Territories was, however, not settled until 1972. The issue, always a thorny one, of making Polish state and diocesan boundaries coincide was not regulated fully by Pope John Paul II until as late as 1992.95 Although the Roman Catholic church and the communist state were involved in numerous ‘growling sessions’ subsequently, church-state relations did not become a constitutional issue again until the question of negotiating a new Concordat arose after 1990.96 Polish Roman Catholicism had a very strong social, and even worker-priest, character. It developed interesting and innovative intellectual reactions to the challenges of secularization and Marxism.97 The state-society conflicts of the PRL period, however, allowed it to achieve a powerful mediating position.98 The election of Cardinal Karol Wojty⁄la of Kraków as Pope John Paul II in 1978 and his subsequent pilgrimages to his homeland contributed enormously to the rise of Solidarity and the weakening of communist power.99 Constitutional amendment was very simple in the PRL. It took the form of the Sejm passing an amendment as a law by a two-thirds majority with over half the deputies present (art. 91/1952 constitution). Procedural rules were unimportant as the PZPR controlled candidate nomination and produced the desired election results. In 1952, it claimed 99.8 per cent of the vote for its National Front lists on a 95.03 per cent turnout. The PZPR always allocated a majority of Sejm seats to itself although from 1957 onwards it conceded some more seats to its ZSL and SD allies. The changed electoral system, allowing a degree of crossing-off and choice between
36 Democratic Government in Poland
officially nominated candidates, was only really significant in January 1957 and then tailed-off.100 Of the 18 amendments between 1952–88, many concerned fairly trivial questions or unimportant organizational changes in state institutions. But most had political consequences. The first amendment in 1954, for example, by replacing 3000 communes (gmina) with 8000 boroughs/neighbourhoods (gromada/osiedle) facilitated greater party and administrative control over these bodies.101 Although Gomul⁄ ka disappointed the hopes of October for major democratization, he reduced the pathological character of the system and loosened the party-state’s control over society. Bierut always stressed that Poland ‘had a class ally in the Soviet Army, an ally who by his very presence rendered powerless the camp of reaction’.102 Gomul⁄ ka, however, conceded the ‘unique sensitivity to its independence’, as ‘specific features of the Polish nation determined by its history’.103 He justified the distinctive aspects of Poland’s road to socialism which included 86 per cent private ownership of land by peasants and, hence, major ZSL influence in the countryside, co-existence with the Roman Catholic church; a revised relationship with the USSR; a looser definition of the PZPR’s leading role; a relatively autonomous intellectual-cultural sphere; Socialist Legality and a greater role for the Sejm and other representative and social bodies. Socialist Internationalism entailed a common commitment to building socialism and similar solutions in tackling like problems. In Poland’s case, PZPR autonomy was conditioned additionally by national interest. The Soviet alliance was crucial in defending her borders against German revanchism.104 Thus, the purely constitutional changes were so small as to be barely visible. The main changes in political and social life had already been wrested by 1956 and were threatened subsequently by Gomul⁄ ka’s campaign against revisionism. The amendment of 13 December 1957 merely restored parliamentary control over the state administration by reconstituting NIK.105 Subsequent amendments under Gomul⁄ ka confirmed the number of Sejm deputies as 460 in December 1960 but replaced the original constitutional requirement of one deputy per 60 000 voters. The amendment of May 1961 merely increased Council of State membership; finally, in December 1963, the term of office of the People’s Councils was increased from three to four years to parallel that of the Sejm. A ‘rebirth of Polish parliamentarianism’ undoubtedly occurred in socialist terms;106 but most outside observers stress its limited nature and emphasize the conflicts between Gomul⁄ ka’s regime and society over a whole variety of issues. The most serious were with the Roman Catholic bishops over their 1965 letter of reconciliation to the German bishops asking for mutual forgiveness. The 1966 millennium (when Poland celebrated 1000 years of Christianity) was disputational over whether it should celebrate Polish statehood or the adoption of Christianity. Gomul⁄ ka’s rule ended
The Communist Experience and Legacy 37
with the unfortunate March Events of 1968, the one case when the Polish state, as against society or individual, could justifiably be accused of antisemitism. The motivation was largely functional, though, and designed to produce a mechanism to scapegoat reformist and democratizing pressures. The whole system was shaken further by the Baltic seacoast riots and repressions of December 1970 but rejuvenated by leadership change.107 The main administrative change of the Gierek period, the local government reform, was implemented in four constitutional amendments. The Law of 29 November 1972 replaced 4312 boroughs with about 2400 communes.108 The process concluded with the amendment of 28 May 1975 abolishing the intermediate level of 314 counties (powiaty); at the top, 49 new provinces (województwa) replaced the old 17 provinces and five cities with provincial status.109 In the early 1970s, there was much discussion of the need for a new constitution to incorporate the Gierek regime’s revised formulation that Poland had completed the tasks of People’s Democracy and was now building an ‘advanced socialist society’. Soviet objections to the private ownership of agriculture, the party’s co-existence with the Roman Catholic church – as well as with what they regarded as a non-socialist intellectual, cultural and mass media life – however, meant that a major amendment of the constitution had to suffice. The Sixth PZPR Congress in December 1975 defined Poland as an ‘all people’s state’ but balanced decreasing class struggle with the need for greater political collaboration with the USSR and economic integration with COMECON.110 A committee headed by Henryk Jabl⁄ o´nski, the chairman of the Council of State, prepared a draft in less than two months: by the end of January 1976. The proposed ‘registering of realities’ was part of Gierek’s ongoing process of institutionalising and codifying many aspects of party control. The aim was to regularize communist rule and to make it more predictable, thus producing a socialist version of the rule of law. Unfortunately for the regime, the move backfired, provoking strong social opposition, including denunciation by Primate Wyszy´nski. The amendment was passed almost unchanged by the Sejm on 10 February 1976. But the controversy marked a defining moment in Poland’s two-decade-long crisis. Although postponed in June 1976 after a price rise was rescinded immediately, following an informal general strike and the Radom riot, the major social outburst erupted with irresistible force in August 1980. The 1976 events had enormous consequences, engendering organized opposition – namely the Workers’ Defence Committee (KOR) and the national independence camp.111 The major 1976 amendment affected about one-third of the constitution and, in a sense, constituted its mid-life declaration.112 Article 1 now declared the PRL to be a ‘socialist state’. The bitterly disputed redrafted article 3 stated that ‘the leading political force of society in the building of socialism is the Polish United Workers’ Party’. This was balanced by the
38 Democratic Government in Poland
introduction of a loosely defined Front of National Unity (FJN).113 The FJN was to provide the framework for collaboration by the minor parties as well as non-party individuals in achieving national and economic goals as well as other goals such as the rebuilding of the Royal Castle in Warsaw, destroyed by German bombing in September 1939. A whole series of other redefinitions of agricultural and religious policy and of the role of social consultation and the trade unions followed. Under more favourable circumstances, these could have been used to strengthen the regime, as in Kadar’s Hungary. The price paid for these potentially constructive concessions, however, proved to be a heavy one. Article 6 went further than previous formulations in declaring outright that the PRL ‘aligns itself with the lofty traditions of solidarity with the forces of freedom and progress, and strengthens friendship and cooperation with the USSR and other socialist states’.114 This struck a raw nerve in the national psyche as it acknowledged Poland’s limited sovereignty despite balancing rhetoric that the PRL protected national ‘sovereignty, interests and security’. The immense popular and social outburst in 1980 produced the independent trade union confederation, Solidarity (Solidarno´sc´ ), but was met by a hesitant and delayed PZPR reaction. The legalization of free trade unions was never given constitutional form. The only amendment passed during the Solidarity period – on 8 October 1980 – moved NIK away from the Council of Ministers, where it has been ensconced in 1976, and brought it under parliamentary control again. On the other hand, according to many legal experts, the State of War was declared illegally on 13 December 1981.115 Military rule was suspended at the end of December 1982 and lifted on 22 July 1983, although the Sejm granted the authorities extraordinary powers until the end of 1985. The political motivation and justification for martial law continued to divide Poles but the majority were inclined to give Jaruzelski, as military and political leader, the benefit of the doubt. A 1997 poll by the Pentor polling agency showed that 21 per cent thought that martial law was justified; 29 per cent rather justified; 16 per cent rather justified; and only 12 per cent completely unjustified. Significantly, 43 per cent accepted that Jaruzelski’s main aim was to save Poland from Soviet invasion, as against 12 per cent who thought that he was primarily concerned to save communist power, 11 per cent to liquidate Solidarity and 10 per cent to prevent the state’s break-up.116 Under the prevailing conditions of internment, mass repression, and an ongoing civil war between the Military Council of National Salvation (WRON) and the Solidarity underground, the twelfth constitutional amendment of 26 March 1982, establishing a Constitutional Tribunal and a State Tribunal, was not implemented at that time. These bodies introduced important principles of the review of the constitutionality of legislation and of the constitutional responsibility of failed political leaderships such as the Gierek–Jaroszewicz tandem; but their implementation was post-
The Communist Experience and Legacy 39
poned until more normal conditions. Likewise, the next amendment, passed on 20 July 1983, and introducing the Patriotic Front of National Rebirth (PRON) as a successor to the FJN, only interested the communist camp. Article 15 guaranteed the peasant private ownership of land but the Council of State was given additional emergency powers. Its chairman could now, unhindered, declare a State of Emergency. Jaruzelski assumed this post in November 1985. As normalization was taking longer than envisaged, the amendment of 13 February 1984 extended the Sejm’s term. Elections were eventually held in October 1985 when it was officially conceded that turnout had fallen to an unprecedented 78.86 per cent.117 Polish politics are normally described as being in a state of blockage during the mid- to late-1980s. After the shock killing of Father Jerzy Popiel⁄ uszko by Security Service policemen, the Jaruzelski regime attempted to widen its base by setting up new consultative councils and by mobilizing the population in novel ways.118 The latter led to the 6 May 1987 amendment, instituting the referendum. Its use on 29 November 1987 merely confirmed the political stalemate. Although there was a 67 per cent turnout, the actual vote for economic reform was 44 per cent and for political reform, 46 per cent. These votes were therefore not binding, as there were below the required 50 per cent of the actual electorate.119 The referendum strengthened the feeling of political and economic stagnation. It contributed to the communist elite’s decision to attempt to break this the following year through a deeper dialogue and negotiation with the opposition.120
Judgement on the PRL (Polish People’s Republic) Two leading political scientists confirm the argument outlined in this chapter that the PRL was an authoritarian, not a totalitarian, system. They likewise conclude that social pluralism in the form of a strong Roman Catholic church, private landowning peasants, lively intellectuals and a powerful tradition of national independence, was, paradoxically, aided by the ethnically and linguistically homogeneous character of postwar society. These factors limited PZPR capacity to produce reliable security and military apparats which could ‘impose intense mobilization, especially in the ideological area’.121 The major study of the latter stressed its dynamic and changing (although somewhat makeshift) character. Ray Taras has demonstrated how the PZPR produced an ‘operative ideology’ to protect the fundamental Marxist–Leninist values which it embodied but whose conflict with society produced the political crises which wracked the PRL.122 The Polish communist leadership was also uniquely conditioned ‘by the extent as well as the longevity of the continuing interplay between normal Soviettype “closed” internal Party mechanisms and the more “open” ones produced by forces external to the PZPR’.123
40 Democratic Government in Poland
Political scientists have readapted Kircheimer’s long-established concept of ‘confining conditions’ to explain how communist legacies have structured post-communist democratization.124 Given the evolutionary and negotiated-constitutional character of Poland’s revolutionary breakthrough, the rupture, when it came, was more easily discerned in retrospect than at the time it happened, in 1989. The debate over how to ‘overcome the past’ was, therefore, much more complex, although in some ways less intense, than elsewhere in Eastern Europe.125 The reasons for this are numerous and reflect the ambiguity and gradualness of Poland’s transition where the gestation, breakthrough and consolidation stages blended imperceptibly into one another. Firstly, throughout the 1990s, there has been an overwhelming view (about 70–80 per cent) that the PRL contained a mixture of good and bad elements. As late as 1994, about 15 per cent of Poles wanted to restore the PRL, but the figure tailed off to 9 per cent the following year, falling subsequently to insignificant levels.126 By 1995, 91 per cent rejected such a statement outright.127 A nuanced appreciation of the PRL developed, with the extreme ‘mostly bad/mostly good’ appreciations going from 16–8 per cent in 1992 to 14–4 per cent in 1997; the view that the PRL had both good and bad sides remained fairly steady at 72 and 79 per cent respectively for those years.128 There had been no large-scale informer system and after 1956 security police repression mellowed. Spectacular examples of violent deaths – in Pozna´n in 1956; in the Baltic seacoast in 1970 – as well as Martial Law were the exception, as were even the student round-ups in March 1968 and the 1976 Radom beatings. Individual cases of lawlessness such as the killing of the students Stanisl⁄aw Pyjas in Kraków (1977) and Grzegorz Przemyk in Warsaw (1984), as well as Father Popiel⁄ uszko’s murder (1984), became cas célèbres.129 They were resented all the more for being untypical breakdowns of the informal understandings concerning self-restraint on both sides which were believed to have defused October 1956. Even a national clampdown such as the State of War produce remarkably few deaths and few serious casualties while mass internment was short lived.130 Secondly, the peaceful abdication of communism produced informal elite understandings, and even a certain feeling of collaborative camaraderie as to the desirability of drawing ‘a thick line’ under the PRL. Historical memories of bitter domestic divisions, and occasional fratricide, over resistance to the partitions, the nineteenth-century uprisings and during the Second World War, as well as the near civil war at its end, contributed to a tradition of restraint by victors in settling accounts. The temporality of events and the need for compromise was the general lesson re-learnt by Poles during the Second World War, especially by the heroic tragedy of the 1944 Warsaw uprising.131 The same sermon was also preached eloquently, as well as practiced, by Wyszy´nski during his long term as Primate.132
The Communist Experience and Legacy 41
Thirdly, much of the responsibility for the problems faced by the Third Republic could be shifted onto the external forces of conquest, oppression and destruction which had plagued Poland’s history. The post-1976 generation, admittedly, no longer accepted the alibi of what most Poles regarded as their ‘Gehenna’ during the Second World War as an excuse for inaction.133 But they recast Poland’s return to Europe and democratization in somewhat mythical and idealized terms. The difference was that post-1989 opportunities were incomparably more solid than earlier false dawns. Lastly, the survival of barely, or completely, uncompromised, younger and professional individuals of the PRL tradition in the SdRP and PSL, and to some extent in the UW and UP, produced physical guarantees that there would be no wholesale decommunization on East German lines. The term lustration, as has been said, can be defined in a broad sense as the disqualification of all communist party officials from holding elected or public office in a new democracy. More narrowly, it involves the vetting and exclusion of all individuals who had worked with or collaborated with the security services. In the Polish case, the broad definition was excluded by the negotiated nature of the transformation while the latter was postponed until the late 1990s.134 Even then, the process, when eventually introduced by Buzek, assumed a moderate self-reporting and monitoring form.
Notes 1 See the hostile view by Jerzy Pietkiewicz, Czy PRL byla pa´nstwem polski? Studia Polityczne, no. 4 (1995), 87–98. 2 See John Coutouvidis and Jamie Reynolds, Poland, 1939–1947 (Leicester: Leicester University Press, 1986), Krystyna Kersten, The Establishment of Communist Rule in Poland, 1943–1948 (Berkeley CA: University of California Press, 1991); Antony Polonsky and Boleslaw Drukier (eds), The Beginnings of Communist Rule in Poland, December 1943–June 1945 (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1980). 3 Andrzej Paczkowski, Referendum z 30 czerwca 1946r (Warsaw: ISP PAN, 1993), p. 14. 4 Padraig Kenney, Rebuilding Poland. Workers and Communist, 1945–1950 (Ithaca NY: Cornell University Press, 1997), pp. 53–6. 5 See Marian K. Dziewanowski, The Communist Party of Poland: an Outline of History (New York: Columbia University Press, 1977); Jan B. Weydenthal, The Communists of Poland (Stanford CA: Hoover Institution Press, 1978). 6 See Andrzej Werblan, Wl⁄ adysl⁄ aw Gomul⁄ ka. Sekretarz Generalny PPR (Warsaw: KiW, 1988). 7 Confirmed by the hostile presentation of interviews, used very effectively for propaganda purposes against the PRL in the 1980s; see Teresa Tora´nska, ONI. Stalin’s Polish Puppets (London: Collins-Harvill, 1987). 8 See John Michael Montias, Central Planning in Poland (New Haven CT: Yale University Press, 1962).
42 Democratic Government in Poland 9 Richard F. Staar, Poland, 1944–1962: the Sovietization of a Captive People (Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1962). There were few ‘show-trials’ except for those of some army officers during the Korean War, no significant Gulag dimension and limited expansion of the Security Police (UB). Cf. Andrzej Paczkowski, Aparat bezpiecze´nstwa w latach 1944–1956, vol. 2 (Warsaw: ISP PAN, 1996), pp. 11–12. 10 See Andrzej Korbonski, Politics of Socialist Agriculture in Poland, 1945–1960 (New York: Columbia University Press, 1965). 11 Cf. Samuel L. Sharp, Poland. White Eagle on a Red Field (Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press, 1953). 12 The controversy over whether postwar conflicts were best described as a civil war surfaced in the controversy over the historical rehabilitation of the WiN (Wolno´sc´ i Niezawisl⁄ o´sc´ ) successor to the AK, Rzeczpospolita, 21–22 April 2001, p. A6. 13 For historical overviews from varied viewpoints, see: Wl⁄ adysl⁄ aw Góra, Polska Ludowa, 1944–1988 (Lublin: Wydawnictwo Lubelski, 1986); Andrzej Paczkowski, Pól⁄ wieku dziejów Polski, 1939–1989 (Warsaw: PWN, 1996); Henri Rollet, La Pologne au Xxme siécle (Paris: Pedone, 1984); Wojciech Roszkowski, Historia Polski, 1914–1990 (Warsaw: PWN, 1991); Ray Taras, Poland. Socialist State, Rebellious Nation (Boulder CO: Westview Press, 1986). 14 See Richard Hiscocks, Poland. Bridge for the Abyss (London: Oxford University Press, 1963); Pawel⁄ Machcewicz, Polski Rok 1956 (Warsaw, Mowi˛a Wieki, 1993); Jarosl⁄ aw Maciejewski and Zofia Trojanowska (eds), Pozna´nski Czerwiec 1956 (Pozna´n: Wydawnictwo Pozna´nskie, 1990); Hansjakob Stehle, The Independent Satellite. Society and Politics in Poland since 1945 (New York: Praeger, 1965); Konrad Syrop, Spring in October. The Story of the Polish Revolution, 1956 (London: Weidenfeld & Nicholson, 1957). 15 The term ‘regime’, as used here, applies to the emergence of a specific type of communist rule associated with a long period of personalized domination by a First Party Secretary like Khruschev or Brezhnev who stamps his personality on the system. It is not used in the same sense in democratization debates. 16 Nicholas Bethell, Gomul⁄ ka. His Poland and his Communism (London: Longman, 1969) 17 See Josef Banas, The Scapegoats. The Exodus of the Remnants of Polish Jewry (London: Weidenfeld & Nicholson, 1979); Jerzy Eisler, Marzec 1968 (Warsaw: PWN, 1991); Grzegorz Sol⁄ tysiak and Józef St˛epien (ed.), Marzec ‘68. Mi˛edzy tragedia˛ a podl⁄ o´scia˛ (Warsaw: PROFI, 1998). 18 Adam Bromke, Poland’s Protracted Crisis (Oakville, Ontario: Mosaic Press, 1983). Adam Bromke and John Strong (eds), Gierek’s Poland (New York: Praeger, 1973). John Lepak, Prelude to Solidarity. Poland and the Politics of the Gierek Regime (New York: Columbia University Press, 1988). Maurice Simon and Roger Kanet, Background to Crisis: Policy and Politics in Gierek’s Poland (Boulder CO: Westview Press, 1981). 19 See Timothy Garton Ash, The Polish Revolution (London: Jonathan Cape, 1983); Colin Barker, Festival of the Oppressed. Solidarity, Reform and Revolution in Poland, 1980–1982 (London: Bookmarks, 1986); David Ost, Solidarity and the Politics of Anti-Politics: Opposition and Reform in Poland since 1968 (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1990); George Sanford, Polish Communism in Crisis (London: Croom Helm, 1983); Jadwiga Staniszkis, Poland’s Self-Limiting Revolution (Princeton NJ: Princeton University Press, 1984); Alain Touraine et al., Solidarity.
The Communist Experience and Legacy 43
20
21
22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31 32 33 34
35 36
The Analysis of a Social Movement. Poland, 1980–1981 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983). See Jack Bielasiak and Maurice Simon (eds), Polish Politics, Edge of the Abyss (New York: Praeger, 1994); Werner Hahn, Democracy in a Communist Party. The Polish Experience since 1980 (New York: Columbia University Press, 1987); George Sanford, Military Rule in Poland: the Rebuilding of Communist Power, 1981–1983 (London: Croom Helm, 1986); Andrzej Walicki, The Paradoxes of Jaruzelski’s Poland, Archives Européens de Sociologie, XXXVI (1985), 167–92. See Andrew Gerrits, The Failure of Authoritarian Change: Reform, Opposition and Geopolitics in Poland in the 1980s (Aldershot UK: Dartmouth, 1990); Paul Lewis, The Long Goodbye: Party Rule and Political Change in Poland since Martial Law, Journal of Communist Studies, VI (1990), 24–48. Jaruzelski attempted to incorporate intellectuals and the more moderate opposition in his consultative council; see Rada Konsultacyjna przy Przewodiczacym ˛ Rady Pa´nstwa, 1986–1987 (Warsaw: Rada Narodowa, 1988). Cf. Denis Pirages, Modernization and Political Tension Management Poland (New York: Praeger, 1972). See also Joseph Fiszman, Revolution and Tradition in People’s Poland. Education and Socialization (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1972); David Lane and George Kolankiewicz (eds), Social Groups in Polish Society (London: Macmillan – now Palgrave Macmillan 1973). Cf. Jakub Karpinski, Countdown. The Polish Upheavals of 1956, 1968, 1970, 1980 … (New York: Karz-Cohl, 1982). One should not underestimate the effect of films such as Andrzej Wajda’s Popiol⁄ y in maintaining the national debate on such issues during the PRL. Jerzy Drygalski and Jacek Kwa´sniewski, (Nie)realny Socjlizm (Warsaw: PWN, 1992). Jerzy Hausner and Tadeusz Klementowicz (eds), L⁄ agodnia Agonia Realnego Socjalizmu (Warsaw: SYNTEZA, 1991). Bartlomiej Kaminski, The Collapse of State Socialism. The Case of Poland (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1991). Jadwiga Staniszkis, The Dynamics of the Breakthrough in Eastern Europe. The Polish Experience (Berkeley CA: University of California Press, 1991). See Walter Connor and Piotr Pl⁄ oszajski (eds), Escape from Socialism. The Polish Route (Armonk NY: M. E. Sharpe, 1992); George Sanford (ed.), Democratization in Poland, 1988–1990. Polish Voices (Basingstoke: Macmillan – now Palgrave Macmillan, 1992). See Alexander Bregman, The strange case of Kuro´n and Modzelewski, East Europe, XV, no. 12 (1966) 7–11. ˙ Jacek Kuro´n and Jacek Zakowski, PRL dla poczatkuj ˛ acych ˛ (Wrocl⁄ aw: Wydawnictwo Dolno´slaskie, ˛ 1996), p. 282. Polityka, 21 June 1990. Spór o PRL (Kraków: Znak, 1996), pp. 49, 99. The less ‘noble’ interpretation of the Polish propensity to revolt against economic reality in the form of price rises, especially of food, during the PRL is encapsulated in what may be considered the facetious view, that there would have been no Solidarity if Gierek and the Soviets had somehow come up with an additional 5000 tons of pork in the summer of 1980. Cf. Bogdan Mieczkowski, The relationship between changes in consumption and politics in Poland, Soviet Studies, XXX (1978), 262–9. Spór o PRL, p. 31. Hannah Arendt, The Origins of Totalitarianism (London: Allen & Unwin, 1958).
44 Democratic Government in Poland 37 Carl Friedrich and Zbigniew Brzezinski, Totalitarian Dictatorship and Autocracy (New York: Praeger, 1966). 38 Leonard Schapiro, Totalitarianism (London: Macmillan – now Palgrave Macmillan, 1972). 39 Cf. Ghita lonescu, The break-up of the Soviet Empire in Eastern Europe (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1965). 40 See J. F. Brown, The New Eastern Europe (New York: Praeger, 1966); Olga Narkiewicz, Eastern Europe, 1968–1984 (London: Croom Helm, 1986). 41 Adam Michnik, Letters from Freedom, edited by Irena Grudzi´nska-Gross (Berkeley CA: University of California Press, 1998), p. 104. 42 Cf. Ghita Ionescu, Comparative Communist Politics (London: Macmillan – now Palgrave Macmillan, 1972). 43 See H. Gordon Skilling in Background to the Study of Opposition in Eastern Europe, Government and Opposition, III (1968–69); see also Robert Dahl (ed.), Regimes and Oppositions (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1973). 44 Ghita Ionescu, The Politics of the European Communist States (London: Weidenfeld and Nicholson, 1967). 45 Cf. Archie Brown, Soviet Politics and Political Science (London: Macmillan – now Palgrave Macmillan, 1974). 46 Karen Dawisha, The Limits of the Bureaucratic Politics Model, Studies in Comparative Communism, XIII (Winter 1980), 300–326. 47 For pointers see: George Lichtheim, Marxism (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1964); David McLellan, The Thought of Karl Marx – an Introduction (London: Macmillan – Palgrave Macmillan, 1995); Karl Popper, The Open Society and its Enemies vol. 2 (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1966); John B. Sanderson, An Interpretation of the Political Ideas of Marx and Engels (London: Longman, 1969). 48 Cf. Alex Callinicos, The Revenge of History. Marxism and the East European Revolutions (Oxford: Polity Press, 1991). See also Zbigniew Brzezinski, The Grand Failure. The Birth and Death of Communism in the Twentieth Century (London: Macdonald, 1990). 49 See the tract by his secretary, Walery Namiotkiewicz, My´sl polityczna Marksizmu a Rewizjonizm (Warsaw: KiW, 1969). See also Sylwester Zawadzki, Spór o istote˛ dyktatury proletariatu, Pa´nstwo i Prawo, XVIII, no. 2 (1963). 50 Leszek Grzybowski and Przemysl⁄ aw Wójcik, Dialektyka Jedno´sci Narodu (Warsaw: KiW, 1980). 51 See Edward Erazmus, Spór o ksztal⁄ t partii (Warsaw: KiW 1983); Karol B. Janowski, Demokracja socjalistyczna w koncepcjach polityczno-programowych PZPR (Warsaw: PWN, 1989); Jerzy Kowalski, Barbara Radzikowska and Piotr Winczorek, Problemy rozwoju demokracji socjalistycznei w PRL (Warsaw: KiW, 1981); Marian Orzechowski, Spór o marksistowska˛ teori˛e rewolucji (Warsaw: KiW, 1984); Andrzej Werblan, Klasowe i narodowe aspekty my´sli politycznej PPR i PZPR (Warsaw: PWN, 1987); Jerzy J. Wiatr, Marksistowska˛ teoria rozwoju spol⁄ ecznego (Warsaw: PWN, 1983). 52 Officially approved versions, such as the following, can be criticized for being conservative but they gave good pictures of the state of play at any time. See Leszek Gilejko, Leninowska koncepcja demokracji socjalistycznei (Warsaw: Wydawnictwo CRZZ, 1970); Adam L⁄ opatka, Kierownicza rola Partii Komunistycznej w Stosunku do Pa´nstwa Socjalistycznego (Pozna´n: Wydawnictwo Pozna´nskie, 1963); Sylwester Zawadzki, Marksistowska teoria pa´nstwa (Warsaw:
The Communist Experience and Legacy 45
53 54 55
56
57
58 59 60
61
62
63
64
PWN, 1964) and Z teorii i praktyki demokracji socjalistycznei (Warsaw: KiW, 1980). More interesting discussions occurred during the more lively political periods: see Juliusz Bardach and Konstanty Grzybowski (eds), Monteskiuszi i jego dziel⁄ o (Warsaw: PAN, 1957). Georges Burdeau, Droit constitutionel et institutions politiques (Paris: LGDiJ, 1965), p. 198. Richard Sakwa, Postcommunism (Buckingham: Open University Press, 1999). For one of the strongest statements on the functions of the communist party and the nature of the communist political system, see Richard C. Gripp, The Political System of Communism (London: Nelson, 1973). For studies of the PZPR see: Adolf Dobieszewski and Janusz Gol⁄ ebiowski ˛ (eds), PZPR, 1948–1978 (Warsaw: PWN, 1978); Mirosl⁄ aw Karwat and Wl⁄ odzimierz Milanowski, Ciagl ˛ ⁄ o´sc i zmiana w partii (Warsaw: MON, 1985); Norbert Ko l⁄ omejczyk, Polska Zjednoczona Partia Robotnica, 1948–1986 (Warsaw: KiW, 1988); Jerzy Kuci´nski, Ustrojowe-polityczne koncepcje PZPR w latach 1948–1959 (Warsaw: KiW, 1984). The postcommunist problem is normally defined as a moral-legal one of dealing with the crimes, corruption and collaboration with the security police of the period and, to some extent, of building new democratic values, as well as the purely technical issues of overcoming economic backwardness, environmental damage and the like. Cf. Zolton Barany and Ivan Volgyes, The Legacies of Communism in Eastern Europe (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1995). In my view, the best political science textbook in this field is George Kolankiewicz and Paul Lewis, Poland. Politics, Economics and Society (London: Pinter, 1988). An earlier text is Alexander Groth, People’s Poland. Government and Politics (San Francisco: Chandler, 1972). H. Gordon Skilling, The Governments of Communist East Europe (New York: Thomas Crowell, 1966), Ch. 10. Cf. Sakwa, The Role of Parliament in a Communist Political System op. cit. David Olson and Maurice Simon, The Institutional Development of a Minimal Parliament: the Case of the Polish Sejm, in Daniel Nelson and Stephen White (eds), Communist Legislatures in Comparative Perspective (London: Macmillan, 1982). See Andrzej Burda, Sejm PRL (Wrocl⁄ aw: Ossolineum/PAN, 1975); Tadeusz Dmoch and Eugeniusz Szadurski, Sejm PRL (Warsaw: KiW, 1969); Tadeusz Mol⁄ dawa, Sejm PRL (Warsaw: KAW, 1987). The nearest to an acceptable institutional study in the PRL was Marian Rybicki, Studia nad rzadem ˛ PRL w latach 1952–1980 (Wrocl⁄ aw: Ossolineum, 1985). Other relevant studies were: Marian Grzybowski, Rzad ˛ w pa´nstwie socjalistycznym (Warsaw: KiW, 1980); Kazimierz Nowak, Sejm a Rzad ˛ w PRL (Warsaw: PWN, 1973); Wojciech Sokolewicz, Rzad ˛ a prezydia rad narodowych (Warsaw: PWN, 1964); Jerzy Stembrowicz, Rzad ˛ w systemie parlamentarnym (Warsaw: PWN, 1982). Stephen White, John Gardner and George Schopflin, Communist Political Systems. An Introduction (Basingstoke: Macmillan – now Palgrave Macmillan, 2nd edn 1987), Chs 3–5. Most of the PRL literature were constitutional and state-law tracts which claimed the opposite. For rare descriptions of the political system with elements of institutional ‘reality’ see: Stanisl⁄ aw Gebethner, Zdzisl⁄ aw Jarosz and Wojciech Popkowski, System organów pa´nstwowych w PRL (Warsaw: KiW, 1968); Tomasz Langer, Typ i forma pa´nstwa socjalistycznego (Pozna´n: Wydawnictwo Pozna´nskie, 1977). Jakub Karpi´nski produced an emigre˛ critique, Ustrój komunistyczny w Polsce (London: Aneks, 1985).
46 Democratic Government in Poland 65 See Lloyd Churchward, Contemporary Soviet Government (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1975), Chs 9, 15. 66 George Sanford, Poland, in William B. Simons and Stephen White (eds), The Party Statutes of the Communist World (The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1984), p. 329. 67 Michael Shafir, Romania. Politics, Economics and Society (London: Pinter, 1985). 68 Joni Lovenduski and Jean Woodall, Politics and Society in Eastern Europe (Basingstoke: Macmillan – now Palgrave Macmillan, 1987), Ch. 9. 69 Paul Lewis (ed.), Eastern Europe: Legitimation and Political Crisis (London: Croom Helm, 1984). 70 Wojciech Sokolewicz, Democracy, Rule of Law and Constitutionality in PostCommunist Society of Eastern Europe, Polish Contemporary Law, no. 2/86 (1990), p. 13. 71 Leslie Wolf-Phillips, Comparative Constitutions (London: Macmillan – now Palgrave Macmillan, 1972), p. 38. 72 Stefan Rozmaryn, Konstytucja jako ustawa zasadnicza PRL rev. 2nd edn (Warsaw: PWN, 1967), p. 9. 73 For Further Development of People’s Poland, 6th Congress of the Polish United Workers’ Party (Warsaw: no pub. 1972), p. 292. 74 Imre Kovacs, New elements in the evolution of socialist constitution (Budapest: Akademia Kiado, 1968), pp. 120–26. 75 Rudolf Schlesinger, The CPSU Programme, Soviet Studies, XIII (1962) 303–17. 76 Lovenduski and Woodall. op. cit., p. 427. 77 Ajnenkiel, Parlamentaryzm II Rzeczypospolitej, op. cit. 78 Tadeusz Szymczak, Ustrój europejskich pa´nstw socjalistycznych (Warsaw: PWN, 1983), p. 52. 79 Manifest PKWN (Warsaw: KiW, 1974), pp. 11–25. 80 Mikol⁄ ajczyk’s claims, on fleeing the country in October, that the PSL would have received 60–70 per cent in a really free vote without harassment and fraud, err on the high side; but his party would, most likely, have gained a majority. Ajnenkiel, Polskie konstytucje, pp. 378–9. 81 Kazimierz Dzial⁄ ocha and Janusz Trzci´nski, Zagadnienia obowiazywania ˛ Konstytucji Marcowej w Polsce Ludowej, 1944–1952 (Wrocl⁄ aw: Ossolineum, 1977). 82 For text, see Janusz Mordwil⁄ ko (ed.) Konstytucja i podstawowe akty ustrojowe PRL (Warsaw: KiW, 1988) pp. 18–29. 83 Text in Mordwil⁄ ko, op. cit., pp. 30–31. 84 Ibid., pp. 32–3. 85 Ajnenkiel, Polskie konstytucje, p. 415. 86 Tora´nska, op. cit., pp. 224–5. 87 Bolesl⁄ aw Bierut, O konstytucji PRL (Warsaw: KiW, 1952). 88 Original text in Dz. U. 1952, no. 33, position 232. See Andrzej Gwi˙zdz˙ and Janina Zakrzewska (eds), Konstytucja i podstawowe akty ustawodawcze PRL (Warsaw: Wydawnictwo Prawnicze, 1966), pp. 46–70. The English text (as of 1968) as in Jan F. Triska (ed.), Constitutions of the Communist Party-States (Stanford: Hoover Institution, 1968), pp. 332–48. 89 Gwizd ˙ z˙ and Zakrzewska, op. cit., p. 47. 90 Francis Kase, People’s Democracy (Leyden: Sijthof, 1968). 91 Rozymaryn, op. cit., p. 183–4. 92 Michal⁄ Staszewski (ed.), Ko´sciól Katolicki o Konstytucji (wybrane dokumenty z lat 1947–1991) (Warsaw: ISP PAN, 1991), p. 9 ff.
The Communist Experience and Legacy 47 93 For translated English text, see Stehle, The Independent Satellite, op. cit., pp. 306–10. 94 An indicative sign of how quickly times had changed was the appearance of a popular film in 2000, with the well-known actor Andrzej Seweryn playing the Prymas, glorifying Wyszy´nski’s ‘heroic’ opposition to the communist system in this period. Cf. Stefan Wyszy´nski, A Freedom Within: the Prison Notes of Stefan, Cardinal Wyszynski ´ (London: Hodder & Stoughton, 1985). 95 Kallas, Historia ustroju Polski, pp. 433–45. 96 See Vincent Chrypinski, The Roman Catholic Church in 1944–1989 Poland, in Pedro Ramet (ed.), Catholicism and Politics in Communist Societies (Durham NC: Duke University Press, 1990); Andrzej Micewski, Cardinal Wyszy´nski. A Biography (New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovitch, 1996); Patrick Michel, Politics and Religion in Eastern Europe (Oxford: Polity Press, 1991). 97 See Maciej Pomian-Szrednicki, Religious Change in Contemporary Poland: Secularisation and Politics (London: Routledge, 1982); Norbert Zmijewski, The Catholic-Marxist Ideological Dialogue in Poland, 1945–1980 (Aldershot: Dartmouth, 1991). 98 Cf. George Sanford, Military Rule in Poland, pp. 216–52. 99 Bogdan Szajkowski, Next to God … Poland (London: Pinter, 1993). See also the documentation assembled by Peter Raina in numerous publications, notably: Ko´sciól⁄ w Polsce, 1981–84 (London: Veritas, 1985), Ko´sciól⁄ w Polsce. Ko´sciól⁄ Katolicki a pa´nstwo w ´swietle documentów, 1945–1989 (Pozna´n: W Drodze, 1994) and Rozmowy z wl⁄ adzami PRL. Arcybiskup Dabrowski ˛ w ´sl⁄ uzbie ˙ Ko´sciol⁄ a i Narodu, 1982–1985 (Warsaw: Ksiazka ˛ Polski, 1995). See also Tajne dokumenty Pa´nstwoKo´sciól⁄ , 1960–1980 (London: Aneks, 1996) and Tajne dokumenty Pa´nstwo- Ko´sciól⁄ , 1980–1989 (London: Aneks, 1993). 100 See George Sakwa and Martin Crouch, Sejm Elections in Communist Poland: an Overview and a Reappraisal, British Journal of Political Science, VIII (1978), 403–424. 101 Dz. U., 1954, no. 43, position 190. 102 Bolesl⁄ aw Bierut and Józef Cyrankiewicz, Podstawy ideologiczne PZPR (Warsaw: KiW, 1952), p. 32. 103 Wl⁄ adysl⁄ aw Gomul⁄ ka, Przemówienia, 1956–1957 (Warsaw: KiW, 1958), p. 268. 104 Ibid., p. 200. 105 Gwizd ˙ z˙ and Zakrzewska, op. cit., pp. 110–20. 106 Wl⁄ adysl⁄ aw Machejek, Z mojego obserwatorium 1967–1968–1969 (Warsaw: KiW, 1969), p. 145. 107 See A. Ross Johnson, Polish perspectives, Problems of Communism, XX, no. 4 (1971), 59–71; William Woods, Poland. Phoenix in the East (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1969), Ch. 14. 108 Dz. U., 1972, no. 49, position 311. 109 Dz. U., 1975, no. 16, position 89. 110 VII Zjazd PZPR. 8–12 grudnia 1975. Stenogram z obrad (Warsaw: KiW, 1976), pp. 719–87. 111 See Michael Bernhard, The Origins of Democratization in Poland. Workers, Intellectuals and Opposition Politics, 1976–1980 (New York: Columbia University Press, 1993); Andrzej Jastrze˛bski (ed.), Dokumenty Komitetu Obrony Robotników i Komitetu Samoobrony Spol⁄ eczny ‘KOR’ (London: Aneks, 1994); Peter Raina, Independent Social Movements in Poland (London: LSE/Orbis Books, 1981).
48 Democratic Government in Poland 112 See the authoritative study by Wojciech Sokolewicz, Konstytucja PRL po zmianach z 1976r (Warsaw: PWN, 1978). 113 The English language text is in William Simons (ed.), The Constitutions of the Communist World (Alphen aan den Rijn: Sijthof and Noordhof, 1980), pp. 288–310. 114 Ibid., p. 291. 115 Brzezinski, The Struggle for Constitutionalism in Poland, op. cit., pp. 75–6. 116 Wprost, 14 December 1996, p. 38. 117 Trybuna Ludu, 16 October 1985. 118 On the former, see Roger Boyes and John Moody, The Priest who Had to Die (London: Gollancz, 1986) and Paul Lewis, Turbulent Priest, Politics, V, no. 2 (1985), 33–9. 119 Jerzy Jaskierna in Danuta Waniek and Michal⁄ Staszewski (eds), Referendum w Polsce Wspól⁄ czesnej (Warsaw: ISP PAN, 1995), pp. 77–88. 120 For the PZPR’s central apparatus preparations for the Round Table from mid1988 onwards, see Stanisl⁄ aw Perzkowski (ed.), Tajne dokumenty Biura Politycznego i Sekretariatu KC. Ostatni rok wl⁄ adzy, 1988–1989 (London: Aneks, 1994). 121 Juan Linz and Alfred Stepan, Problems of Democratic Transition and Consolidation (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1996), p. 256 and pp. 255–64. 122 Ray Taras, Ideology in a Socialist State. Poland, 1956–1983 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984). 123 George Sanford in Martin McCauley and Stephen Carter (eds), Leadership and Succession in the Soviet Union, Eastern Europe and China (Baskingstoke: Macmillan now Palgrave Macmillan, 1986), p. 40. 124 Otto Kircheimer, Confining conditions and revolutionary breakthroughs, American Political Science Review, LIII (1965), 964–74. 125 Even today the bitterness and lust for general systemic retribution of the National-Catholic (AWS/ZChN) deputy, Stefan Niesol⁄ owski, remains exceptional. In his case it is understandable as he was sentenced to seven years imprisonment (and sat three) in 1971, for allegedly conspiring with Andrzej Czuma and other members of the student Ruch movement at Warsaw University, to blow up the Lenin Memorial Museum in Poronin. See Stefan Niesol⁄ owski, Proste droga o Polskie z Bogiem (Warsaw: PAX, 1993), pp. 36–42; ⁄ Marian Miszalski, Z wie˛zenia do Sejmu. Niesol⁄ owski (Lód z: ˙ LIBER, 1992). Niesol⁄ owski took advantage of his parliamentary immunity to insult the Head of State, President Kwa´sniewski, in the Sejm in May 2000. 126 Fritz Plasser, Peter Ulram and Harald Waldrauch, Democratic Consolidation in East-Central Europe (Basingstoke: Macmillan – now Palgrave Macmillan, 1998), p. 103. 127 Ibid., p. 104. 128 Ibid., p. 125. 129 See Jastrz ebski, ˛ Dokumenty Komitetu Obrony Robotników … , op. cit. 130 Andrzej S´ widlicki, Political Trials in Poland, 1981–1986 (London: Croom Helm, 1988). 131 Joanna Hanson, The Civilian Population and the Warsaw Uprising (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1982). 132 See Micewski, Cardinal Wyszy´nski. A Biography, op. cit.; Ronald Monticone, The Catholic Church in Communist Poland, 1945–1985 (New York: Columbia University Press, 1986).
The Communist Experience and Legacy 49 133 Cf. Allen Paul, Katy´n. Stalin’s Massacre and the Seeds of Polish Resurrection (Annapolis MD: Naval Institute Press, 1996). 134 This naturally caused great dismay amongst the domestic and external supporters of the Solidarity tradition. Cf. Bronisl⁄ aw Misztal, How Not to Deal with the Past: Lustration in Poland, Archives Europe˛ens de Sociologie, XL (1999), 31–55.
3 Democratic Transition and Consolidation
The constitutional abdication of communism There is an enormous literature on democratization and democratic transition – and on how East European patterns compare with earlier Latin American and Mediterranean ones – a literature that now evokes a certain amount of scepticism from country and regional specialists.1 These writings found it difficult to acknowledge the unique features of Poland’s ‘Negotiated Revolution’ and to fit it into their general theories. Each concept – the ‘Negotiated’ (Poland, Hungary), ‘People’s Power’ (East Germany, Czechoslovakia) and, initially successful, intra-leadership/party transformation types of revolution (Bulgaria, Albania and Romania) – has been much debated.2 The Polish situation – evolutionary constitutional character and continuity of state institutions and relative social quiescence as well as the absence of revolutionary violence – places Poland at the extreme ‘negotiated’ or national consensus end of the spectrum of 1989 revolution.3 Attila Agh describes it as ‘a constitutional revolution’ – even a conservative one – ‘since the negotiating partners changed the existing legal order within the existing constitutional framework’.4 Samuel Huntington, albeit rather embarrassedly, actually places Poland within a separate category of transplacement, differentiated from his mainline concepts of transformation and replacement.5 The Polish experience also puzzles communist system specialists who are familiar with the hardline, residually neo-Stalinist, states which underwent ‘People’s Power’ revolutions and whose subject matter harmonized better with ‘heroic’ interpretations of 1989 in the West.6 The deep roots of Poland’s transition, embedded in the state-society conflicts and transformations that stretch back to 1956, have led to comparisons with the ‘pacted transitions’ of Brazil and Chile and, in a different way, Spain.7 Linz and Stepan concede ‘Poland’s historic contribution to the fall of communism in Eastern Europe’; but they fail to understand why its path-breaking character entailed the compromises which they bemoan, but which were neces50
Democratic Transition and Consolidation 51
sary. They view the latter as having ‘harmful effects on Poland’s effort to create the political institutions necessary for political consolidation’.8 Ray Taras also considers that transitologists underestimate the inheritance of communist institutions, political forces and mechanisms which made the initial rupture possible, but at the same time incomplete and ambiguous, in such negotiated revolutions.9 One cannot stress too strongly Poland’s path-breaking role in forcing the abdication of communism in its own country, thus sparking-off Soviet bloc collapse. One also needs constantly to remember the ‘external factor’: the USSR did not break up until late 1991. The Round Table ‘set in motion a domino process that within a year led to the fall of all the communist regimes in Eastern Europe’.10 This makes Poland, simultaneously, and paradoxically, both the best exemplar of the return to Europe as well as an actor whose independent dynamics would have propelled it forward irrespective of the additional boost provided by Gorbachev.11 Without the compromises, the crucial breakthrough to full democratization would certainly have been delayed, or, possibly, have not happened at all. Although the subject remains highly controversial, the elapse of time now allows many ideological features of the East-West conflict and the domestic western neoliberal versus social democratic struggles of the 1980s and early 1990s to be viewed more dispassionately. For example, the application of civil society criteria to Poland was a natural element of the political conflict of the period and of western glorification of Solidarity.12 One must distinguish at the outset between the explanations of, firstly, communist collapse and the 1989 ‘revolution’ and, secondly, the subsequent consolidation of the new democratic and market system.13 On the former, Brzezinski’s three explanations: systemic failure; organic rejection (cultural values); and Gorbachev’s mishandling and loss of control of reform, are widely regarded as compelling; so is Holmes’ explanation of a legitimation crisis.14 The elaboration of Dankwart Rustow’s initial, and much revered, gestation-breakthrough-consolidation model by the transitology literature (see Comparative Politics II, 1970) can also be taken as read.15 What needs consideration here is the integration of the Polish experience with the broad themes of communist collapse and democratic transition. Within the literature one can identify David Ost’s compelling 1989 explanation of Solidarity’s social corporatism blending with that of Jaruzelski’s reformists to produce the 1989 compromise.16 Bova and Ekiert provide eclectic explanations, as do the insightful Bryant and Mokrzycki and the Crawford symposia, the latter being less focused directly on Poland than the Connor/Pl⁄ oszajski and Staar volumes.17 Geoffrey Pridham has defined the main transitologist approaches as the (1) functionalist and (2) the structuralist (or genetic) schools.18 The former emphasizes the long-term social and economic changes which develop the differentiated and contestatory interests required to undermine authoritar-
52 Democratic Government in Poland
ianism. Working and professional middle classes generate their own values and identity and press for a more articulated state-society relationship involving civil and economic liberties.19 In Poland’s case, after 1956, national cultural traditions of an activist intelligentsia (for example, the 1961 Holland case; the 1964 Letter of 34; the 1968 March Events; the 1976 constitutional dispute; subsequent KOR activity) melded with those of industrial struggles (1956 Pozna´n; the 1970 Baltic seacoast, the 1976 Radom, Pl⁄ ock and Ursus riots; the 1980 Baltic seacoast and nationally) to produce the growing confrontations which culminated in Solidarity’s alliance of intellectuals and workers. The second (genetic) school argues that such social change is the essential prerequisite for democratization but that it does not make it inevitable. The timing and form of the breakthrough is entirely a matter of contingency. This approach is easily applicable to Poland as it stresses the nationally unique features of any rupture. It identifies the importance of elite deals and indicates how these structure post-breakthrough development by deciding which institutions and interests will survive and which will be replaced in the new order. This is a form of what has been called ‘path dependency’ in the shift from intrasystemic liberalization to systemic transformation.20 The context of all this theorizing has been summarized brilliantly by Keith Crawford as comprising no less than a ‘sextuple transition’: politically (from communist monocracy to pluralist democracy); economically (from central-command to free market); nationally (from quasi Soviet colony to independent sovereignty); psychologically/socially (from posttotalitarian to free society); global (from COMECON to the world economy); and financially (from state-ownership to capitalism).21 The main lines of Poland’s transition in 1989 have been much discussed but their main features need to be related to our argument here.22 The Jaruzelski regime failed to break the 1980s stalemate by promoting economic reform and broadening its support base through selective incorporation of moderate Solidarity and opposition figures. The two issues were linked – as demonstrated by the regime’s qualified defeat in the 1987 referendum. We still lack reliable information about external Soviet control, but Gorbachev’s d˛etente with the West and his abandonment of the Brezhnev Doctrine loosened its limits dramatically.23 Laurence Whitehead confirms that the shift from systemic liberalization to democratization occurred in Poland during 1988. He argues that the main reason was Moscow’s lifting of its veto on the latter which had, hitherto ‘distorted democratisation patterns and timings’ in the region.24 Jaruzelski attempted to strengthen support for the Soviet connection (1) by cashing in on Gorbachev’s popularity during his Warsaw visit in July 1988; (2) by getting historians to revise ‘blank spots’; and (3) by generally stressing the alliance’s alleged economic and security benefits.25 The Legislative Council, attached to the Council of Ministers, had, as early as 1985, called for a new constitution to
Democratic Transition and Consolidation 53
replace the 1952 Stalinist document. The PZPR Central Committee established a working party in 1987 to prepare a constitutional draft liberalizing the party’s leading role, incorporating a degree of political, and a larger dose of social, pluralism, and limiting the command-distributive aspects of the economic system.26 It was in all probability Gorbachev and Jaruzelski who decided that the wave of strikes in May 1988 indicated that Solidarity’s appeal was weakening; the moment, therefore, was opportune to negotiate the incorporation of the opposition into a revised form of communist system. Some have misunderstood the communist camp’s assessment of their own situation and, therefore, the inevitability of the outcome in 1989. Millard, for example, reflects the prevalent western pro-dissident view that the PZPR was ‘helpless in an economic and political maelstrom’ and had ‘exhausted all alternatives’.27 In mid-August of 1989, Jaruzelski and the Polish Primate Glemp discussed an Anti-Crisis Pact, in order to gain social support and forbearance for the discipline of economic reform in exchange for more consultative and open methods of party rule. The eight PZPR plenum in late August delegated General Czesl⁄ aw Kiszczak, the Minister of the Interior, to talk with the opposition.28 The subsequent Autumn conversations were to become stuck over the limits of political and trade union pluralism, the procedures for re-legalizing Solidarity, and personality difficulties. The reformist Mieczysl⁄ aw F. Rakowski also emerged as prime minister with, it has to be said, some ˛ formed his Civic unusual ministerial choices.29 In December, Lech Wal⁄ esa Committee. The PZPR ‘cleared its decks’ at its two-part tenth plenum in December and January, forming the intention of promoting reformists and adopting firm decisions to democratize itself, to create a new model of political and trade union pluralism and to form a government of national understanding by revising the Sejm electoral law.30 The stage was thus set for the Round Table of 6 February to 5 April. One should remember, however, that both sides entered it with fundamentally different aims and that the final outcome was thus totally unexpected.31 There are now few secrets left about the course of the Round Table, although what concerns us most are the consequences and significance of the final agreement.32 Only two plenary sessions of its 57 full members were held, one at the beginning and one at the end. The bulk of the detailed negotiation and drafting was done in three main groups – on Trade Union Pluralism, Economic and Social Questions and Questions of Political Reform – as well as in 10 specialist sub-groups. The leading figures of what crystallized into the Government-Coalition and Solidarity-Opposition sides met informally on numerous occasions at a Ministry of the Interior villa at Magdalenka outside Warsaw to hammer out deals that would smooth the course of the negotiations.33 The necessarily elite character of the Round Table talks and the Magdalenka ‘horse trading’ inevitably aroused public fears of secret conspira-
54 Democratic Government in Poland
cies and sell outs. An academic participant, Stanisl⁄ aw Gebethner, argues categorically that it was here, in 1989, that: ‘the understanding between elites’ and the Revolution from Above came together with Polish society’s decadeslong Revolution from Below.34 In particular, there has always been speculation about the unspoken agreements concerning both the communist elite’s security from prosecution and its job prospects in the new order. The agreement was hailed as an unprecedented ‘Historic Compromise’.35 But nobody foresaw that it would lead to the abdication of communist power within four months. The parameters of the promised democratization were both highly ambiguous and uncertain. Polish commentators viewed it as an historical experiment in achieving eventual full democracy through interim steps of controlled and limited democratization36 The Round Table Agreement was made up of a mass of reports, standpoints and decisions by the various committees and subgroups.37 The main decisions concerned the much-haggled-over political changes, not the bulk of the documentation on various aspects of social policy and public life matters which have now become of largely academic and historical interest. Put simply, the two sides agreed to a contractual package of measures without being particularly clear as to the resulting outcome. The communists mistook their desires for reality rather more than the SolidarityOpposition side, whose wildest dreams were granted, rapidly and in full. The main decisions were as follows: 1. to restore a 100-strong Senate, to be filled by wholly free elections; 2. to hold contractual Sejm elections in which the PZPR would contest and win just under half the seats, while the hitherto regime supporting ZSL, SD and Catholic minor parties would hold the remainder up to the 65 per cent granted to the Government-Coalition side; 3. the Solidarity-Opposition would be allowed to contest 35 per cent of the Sejm seats. The mathematics outlined above was designed to ensure that Jaruzelski would be elected by the Parliament as a new ‘executive type’ of president in charge of the military and the police. Solidarity and Rural Solidarity would be relegalized on the basis of the political pluralism, independent judiciary and freedoms of expression and organization promised in the Agreement. All this was defined (rather vaguely) as ‘the beginning of the journey to parliamentary democracy’; the economic passages were in fact stronger on wage indexation to protect living standards than on how an efficient market economy would be produced to deliver prosperity.38 Although the Round Table agreed to the compromises concerning 65 per cent control of the Sejm by the residual communist camp as well as a communist president, the realities invalidate Linz and Stepan’s strictures on the subject.39 One should, however, stress the essentially plebiscitary character of the election in indicating social support for the Civic Committee against
Democratic Transition and Consolidation 55
the reformist communist alternative.40 The latter were trounced in the free, first-past-the-post election to the Senate: 99 Civic Committee candidates and one independent were successful. What was crucial in the Sejm election was that the Civic Committee, against other opposition candidates and on a high turnout, won all 161 seats available to it in its compartment (160 on the first ballot). A mere five Government-Coalition candidates were elected outright on the first ballot. Low turnouts and support prevailed for the Government-Coalition side on both ballots. It has been estimated that, overall, the Civic Committee was supported by about 40 per cent of the registered electorate as compared with under 20 per cent for the opposing camp.41 The ruling team was humiliated even more dramatically by the failure of 33 out of 35 of its candidates on the National List to gain the 50 per cent of the electoral vote necessary for election. Prominent regime figures, such as Rakowski, Kiszczak and OPZZ chairman Miodowicz, thus fell by the wayside. Expediency and the Round Table contract led to their ad hoc replacement by official candidates on the second ballot. But the actress Joanna Szczepkowska announcing the event, rightly declared that communist rule ended with the 4 June first ballot. The electorate had delivered a resounding blow from which the ruling team never recovered. The electoral contract was, however, formally maintained. The new Sejm was made up of 173 PZPR, 161 Solidarity, 76 ZSL, 27 SD, 10 PAX and 5 CSU deputies as agreed. But anything between two to three dozen ZSL and SD candidates owed their second ballot election to unofficial Civic Committee endorsement.42 The ruling camp had lost the political initiative. It was subsequently on the defensive during that summer which saw not only its peaceful handover of power by constitutional means to its opponents but the very abdication of the communist system itself. This was demonstrated at the outset by the difficulties involved in electing Jaruzelski as president on 19 June. The required two-thirds majority of the Sejm and Senate, sitting jointly as a National Assembly, was only achieved by a single vote due to the number of abstentions by the Solidarity leadership to counteract ZSL-SD (and even one PZPR) defections.43 This qualified PZPR success was not, however, to be repeated over the formation of a new government – the central mechanism in the actual transfer of systemic power. Kiszczak was nominated by Jaruzelski as premier-designate and endorsed formally by the Sejm. From the communist camp’s viewpoint, everything fell apart subsequently as Kiszczak was unable to form a government. The impasse was broken by Michnik’s suggestion that the slogan ‘Your president, Our premier’, would produce continuity, soothe Kremlin fears, gain social support and outmanoeuvre the ˛ seemed to vacillate but he eventually conservative nomenklatura.44 Wal⁄ esa seized the historic moment on 7 August. Solidarity agreed to lead a broadbased national coalition government to ensure adherence to the systemic changes promised in the Round Table agreement.45
56 Democratic Government in Poland
The controlled transition in practice Transitologists, disregarding Lech Wal⁄ esa’s ˛ acknowledged failings and believing their own propaganda about his alleged charismatic leadership of ‘ethical civil society’, have regarded his failure to accept office in autumn 1989 as a great political mistake with ‘deleterious’ systemic consequences.46 A consideration of Wal⁄ esa’s ˛ presidency, however, provides conclusive evidence to the contrary.47 The OKP’s three nominees for prime minister, all of whom were presented to Jaruzelski – Tadeusz Mazowiecki, Jacek Kuro´n and Bronisl⁄ aw Geremek – were in their varying ways, unlikely to endanger ˛ might have done. the systemic transformation as Wal⁄ esa Mazowiecki proved an ideal choice. A social-Catholic editor of the highly influential Kraków-based monthly Wi˛ez, ˙ and a Znak Sejm deputy in the 1960s, he was corporatist inclined; he knew how to swim in the treacherous waters between the communist and Catholic camps.48 His Grand Coalition government, endorsed almost unanimously by the Sejm on 24 August, was set initially within clear Round Table parameters. The PZPR got four ministries, with Kiszczak at the Interior and Siwicki at Defence until summer 1990, as well as Foreign Trade and Transport. Foreign Affairs were placed, and remained until 1993, in the politically neutral hands of Krzysztof Skubiszewski, a Pozna´n professor of international law with Catholic connections through his membership of Glemp’s Social Council. Solidarity and Civic Committee figures dominated the remaining domestic portfolios, notably Leszek Balcerowicz at Finance and Tadeusz Syryczyk at Industry. The evolution of Poland’s new parliamentary life and party system will be examined in Chapters 5 and 7 respectively. The mixed systemic character of the 1989–91 period was reflected in highly transitional institutions, rooted deeply in the Round Table’s ambiguous deals with the elite. Constitutional transformation would not have occurred so easily, and certainly not so quickly, without this. It is worth noting that the commitment of new elites to a general consensus on democratic values is an essential prerequisite for consolidation.49 It also bears repeating that, as late as Mazowiecki’s assumption of power, Poland was still the trailblazer for political reform despite the growing crisis in East Germany. Its freedom of manoeuvre was further increased by the successive collapse of communism in East Germany, Czechoslovakia and Bulgaria, and in Romania by Christmas as well as by the consolidation of a similar ‘Negotiated Revolution’ in Hungary. The political changes of 1989 were given constitutional form as a result of two amendments. The April amendment established the state presidency, Senate and national Council of the Judiciary and removed the constraints on the electoral law and candidate selection.50 It legalized a variety of civil and political rights of expression and association but retained some
Democratic Transition and Consolidation 57
PRL control mechanisms.51 By the end of the year, any residual formal checks on the democratisation process had fallen away. The December amendment had, therefore, to be quite major in order to register the systemic changes. Wojciech Sokolewicz terms it ‘the constitutional confirmation of the fall of the Ancien R˛egime’.52 The leading role of the PZPR (article 3) was abolished, the PRL was renamed as the Polish Republic (PR), and the crown was restored to the white eagle’s head in the national coat of arms. Sovereignty was located in the nation not ‘the workingpeople of town and countryside’. The state’s socialist character in article 1 was expunged. It was replaced by the formulation that the PR was ‘a democratic law based state implementing the principles of social justice’.53 The independence of the judiciary was implemented and the procuracy, the state’s prosecuting arm, was redefined as being autonomous of party and state controls although formally answerable to the Minister of Justice.54 Likewise, local government and the economy were freed of previous e˛ tatist constraints; all forms of property were declared to be of equal status.55 Local government’s democratization was developed in the constitutional amendment of 8 March 1990 which prepared the ground for the People’s Council elections of 27 May 1990. The final amendment of this period, on 27 September 1990, regulated Jaruzelski’s withdrawal and the election of the state president through universal suffrage.56 Once the legal-constitutional framework had been changed, the PRL was dismantled sector by sector by Mazowiecki’s government during 1990. The most important initial reform established the rule of law by democratizing and reshaping the judiciary and the procuracy while its personnel underwent a checking or verification process.57 The Army was depoliticized with the abolition of PZPR cells and control mechanisms.58 The Citizen’s Militia underwent the same process and emerged as a civil police. The hated ZOMO was reduced in size and subordinated to provincial control. The communist volunteer militia, the ORMO, was simply abolished. The security police (SB) was also constrained, reduced in size and reorganized as the Bureau for State Protection (UOP). The second aspect – personnel changeover – was gradual and cumulative but affected all walks of administrative and public life. Many had their loyalty to the new democratic order tested: the top layer of civil servant jobs, both at the central and provincial levels; the Foreign Office (MSZ) and the diplomatic corps; the judiciary and procuracy and the rectors and inspectors running higher education and schools; they were replaced, retired or sidelined, as appropriate. Thirdly, a whole swathe of communistcontrolled bureaucracies and co-operative organizations were abolished, split up or threatened with future privatization. The disposal of PZPR property, buildings and holdings proved highly contentious, especially the sale of its RSW press conglomerate. Balcerowicz also moved rapidly beyond establishing the legal and financial framework for a market system. The so-
58 Democratic Government in Poland
called ‘Small Privatization’ of shops, restaurants, services and the like was carried out easily and rapidly. The legal redefinition of about 8000 large enterprises, inherited from the PRL, as self-financing units responsible to the State Treasury was not difficult. Their ultimate fate – closure, subsidization, sale to foreign or domestic capital or management or labour buy out – dominated economic policy throughout the 1990s. The social base of power also changed dramatically in late 1989 and 1990. The PZPR wound itself up in January 1990. Thus came to an end all its committees which had provided the aktyws (hard cores of activist party members) to supervise every level and dimension of PRL life. It successor, the SdRP, not only lost most of its membership, but also suffered from a massive loss of self-confidence and direction. Its party committees became fundamentally different in character and power. PUS, the social democratic union, proved only a short-term response to interim conditions of contractualism and, eventually, split in all directions. Some of the previous PZPR influence during this transitional period was assumed by the Solidarity Civic Committees which mobilized and recruited new elites. They took advantage of the power vacuum to achieve a strong result in the April 1990 local government elections. At the top level, new leadership bodies such as the National Civic Committee and the Gda´nsk-based National Executive ˛ power base. The latter’s self perception as the Committee provided Wal⁄ esa’s real power behind the scenes was boosted by his overwhelming re-election as chairman by Solidarity’s Second Congress. Paradoxically, the Sejm’s successor-communist and peasant parliamentary clubs were too demoralized, divided and overwhelmed by the personal stampede of their members to resist Solidarity’s Parliamentary Club (OKP) or to check Mazowiecki’s and Balcerowicz’s reforms in this period. The triumph of Solidarity and the democratic-opposition camp was, therefore, complete in essentials. By the end of 1990, democracy and the market had been irrevocably established. But they were not felt as such, especially psychologically. No real purge of PRL beneficiaries took place. Many ‘hardliners’ from all walks of life were allowed to survive. Some notorious examples, such as press spokesman Jerzy Urban or ex-deputy premier Ireneusz Sekul⁄ a, secured profitable economic niches, thus giving apparent support to the nomenklatura capitalism thesis.59 In addition, democracy was far from bringing prosperity to the mass of the population. Poles faced growing unemployment, lack of job security and falling living standards, despite some protection by the economic indexation negotiated at the Round Table. Poland’s extrication from the Soviet camp, including her withdrawal from COMECON and the Warsaw Pact and the removal of the Soviet garrison, was also proving a more long drawn out affair than initially imagined. The high hopes and enthusiasm of summer 1989 had, therefore, ˛ supporters considered, by by summer 1990, largely evaporated. Wal⁄ esa’s then, that they had made a mistake in compromising with the communist
Democratic Transition and Consolidation 59
system. They wanted both to accelerate decommunization and to end the period of corporatist transition. The resulting War at the Top split Solidarity and ended its short-lived political domination. The communists went quietly, but again, as at the Round Table, one does not know if Mazowiecki confirmed the no victimization side of the original understanding. Certainly, he never toned down his commitment to drawing a thick line (gruba kreska) under the PRL. Jaruzelski has been regarded as the indispensable ‘swing-man’, comparable to Suarez in Spain or Karamanlis in Greece, playing a key role in 1989 in assuring the transformation and preventing counter-revolution.60 During 1990, he took a back seat as president and barely coordinated any action with the successor-communist clubs in the Sejm. He now agreed to the shortening of his term as president so that his successor could be elected by universal suffrage. The real political fireworks were provided by Solidarity’s split into two ˛ ’s and one Mazowiecki’s candidature for the camps, one supporting Wal⁄ esa ˛ was backed by the Civic Committees, by Tygodnik presidency. Wal⁄ esa Solidarno´sc´ and by the newly formed Centre Alliance (PC) led by the Kaczy´nski twins, Lech and Jarosl⁄ aw. The badly divided OKP replaced its ˛ . His opponents, led by chairman, Geremek, and swung round to Wal⁄ esa Zbigniew Bujak and Wl⁄ adysl⁄ aw Frasyniuk, had already formed the Democratic Action ‘Civic Alliance’ (ROAD) backed by the daily Gazeta Wyborcza, edited by Adam Michnik. Both the campaign and the results will be examined in more detail in Chapter 7, but the significance of the 1990 presidential election is twofold. Mazowiecki was eliminated on the first ballot but recovered from his ˛ humiliation to lead ROAD’s successor, the Democratic Union (UD). Wal⁄ esa was elected on the second ballot, apparently overwhelmingly against Tymi´nski, but lost his party political and trade union base. His successor as ˛ nomiSolidarity chairman, elected at its Third Congress against Wal⁄ esa’s nees, was Marian Krzaklewski, who asserted his leadership over the move˛ standpoint, the Civic Committees fell to pieces ment. Worse from Wal⁄ esa’s during the second half of 1990. He failed to lead the new right-centre ˛ quarrelled with their leaders, notably the parties which emerged. Wal⁄ esa Kaczy´nski twins, and competed with KPN leader Leszek Moczulski for the ˛ presidency mantle of Pil⁄ sudski’s strong man image. As a result, Wal⁄ esa’s was undermined, not supported, by the development of the new party system. Thus he was unable to implement his programme as he could not count on support in the Sejm. ˛ presidency, led by Jan Krzysztof The first government of Wal⁄ esa’s Bielecki, proved a stopgap until the holding of fully free elections, although Balcerowicz, Skubiszewski and Kol⁄ odziejczyk were renominated. Bielecki’s party, the Gda´nsk-based Liberal-Democratic Congress (KL-D), in collaboration with the PC, aimed to revitalize the privatization and decommuniza-
60 Democratic Government in Poland
tion drives but made little progress. It was refused emergency powers for accelerated marketization, despite the determined efforts of the Minister for Ownership Transformation, Janusz Lewandowski. The incidence of strikes rocketed as unemployment and opposition to Balcerowicz’s cap on wage increases in the state sector (the popiwek) grew. Solidarity then became ˛ won the institutional more militant under Krzaklewski. In sum, Wal⁄ esa power base of the presidency but he lost the political manoeuvring attending the end of the contractual period. The Sejm overruled his vetoes and pushed through an electoral law based on a pure form of proportional representation. Scandals over cigarettes and alcohol as well over corrupt business practices, increasing unemployment and austerity, cynicism with political division and gamesmanship, all contributed to an atmosphere of deep disillusionment in the run up to the parliamentary election of October 1991.
The consolidation of democracy Did Poland become democratic in 1989 or 1991? The formal answer may be the latter as only after those elections was Poland received into the Council of Europe. In practice, the political rupture definitively occurred in summer 1989 when the Round Table momentum and June elections produced the Mazowiecki government. It is also unclear when the Third Republic actually came into being. The most favoured dates are 4 June 1989 (the contractual election) and 12 September 1989 (the formation of Mazowiecki’s government) but others have suggested various moments during the Round Table process.61 There was a parallel debate over whether the interwar national day of 11 November (the regaining of independence) should replace the PRL’s 22 July before 3 May (the 1791 constitution anniversary) was agreed. The constitutional abdication of communist power in 1989 looks deceptively easy in retrospect but was far from being so in reality. The dismantling of the communist system only became irrevocable a year later when the dissolution of the PRL part of the party system was balanced by the splitting up of the Solidarity conglomerate. With ˛ ’s election as president, political life found institutional form in Wal⁄ esa constitutional debates over the nature of the executive and its relations with the Sejm. Similar controversies developed over the speed of socio-economic transformation and whether democratic legitimacy would be able to cope with social inequality and unrest. The right and centre trends, excluded by Solidarity’s complete victory in 1989, also crystallized in the year preceding the October 1991 elections. National-Catholic (ZChN), national independence (KPN) and liberal-democratic (KL-D) parties evolved to compete with the UD and PC as well as the peasant party (PSLSolidarity) which emerged directly out of the Solidarity movement. The parties of the PRL tradition, the SdRP and the fragmented peasant party
Democratic Transition and Consolidation 61
strands developing out of the ZSL mainly the PSL, also built up their membership, organization and public image in order to fight elections.62 Both transitologists and Polish specialists agree, however, that Polish affairs were dominated, after 1991, by the issue of democratic consolidation, despite the mixed and evolutionary character of the 1989 rupture and the early transition period. John Mueller considers that a transition period ends when further change takes place within an existing institutional framework and ‘not through further transformation of institutions’.63 Poland achieved something like this condition with the Little Constitution of 1992. This was confirmed formally by the 1997 constitution. Many erstwhile academic critics of Polish communism felt, however, that democratization was incomplete since the Solidarity elites hand bungled economic restructuring and political decommunization.64 The number of studies on Poland’s politics tends to diminish for the post-1991 period and the number of overview examinations of the Third Republic’s political life, in both Polish and English, is somewhat sparse.65 The detail will be provided through examining the institutions and various sectors of the country’s political life. There is little debate that the main caesurae were produced by elections, which provided different political frameworks for consecutive periods. The first phase, as we have seen, was ushered in by the contractual election of June 1989 which saw the two gov˛ election as ernments of Mazowiecki and Bielecki divided by Wal⁄ esa’s president. The democratic period has, in each case, been transformed by the fully free parliamentary elections of 1991, 1993, 1997 and 2001, which thus produce three additional stages. The 1991–93 period of extreme proportional representation saw the two governments of Olszewski and Suchocka as well as Pawlak’s failed endeavour. The introduction of electoral thresholds in 1993 turned the left’s victory into a rout by excluding the rightcentre. The successive governments of Pawlak, Oleksy and Cimoszewicz were, consequently, only variations of the peasant-left alliance during 1993–97. The character of the electoral system was, therefore, conclusive in 1989, 1991 and 1993. The ‘normal’ character of the 1997 election resided in an almost unchanged electoral system, producing both democratic alternation and a decisive AWS-UW majority supporting the Buzek government. Minority voices still argued that post-1989 Poland might pioneer a ‘Third Way’ as various anti-mainstream Solidarity strands propagated the original 1980–81 values of self-managing socialism.66 Anti-politics, pitting a good society against a bad state, had a wholly anti-communist connotation during the PRL;67 although such themes were redrafted by Vaclav Havel after 1989, they did not chime in well with capitalist democracy. Legitimation theory, however, claimed that democratization was not only fostered by civil society but that it also developed it further.68 Writers in
62 Democratic Government in Poland
this tradition such as Arato, therefore, argued that constitutions had dual functions. As well as regulating everyday politics, they should provide the framework for civil participation, institutionalizing the enthusiasm of 1989 and channelling it as a safeguard against populism and authoritarianism.69 Such ideas were largely buried by the global ideological-system victory of democratic capitalism. This dominant 1980 issue, nevertheless, carried a further neo liberal-social democratic division which had to be resolved with different balances in each individual domestic case during the 1990s.70 The major western scholar of Poland’s democratic consolidation, Taras, conflates gestation, breakthrough, transition and consolidation in his study. Taras has modified Almond, Flanagan and Mundt’s established system functionalism analysis, largely derived from France’s earlier transformation, to explain Poland’s development.71 Taras likewise takes a very long historical view and applies a four-stage Rustowian (antecedent system–crisis–change–resultant system) model very effectively to Poland. Although not particularly innovative, the model works well. It provides a comprehensive and flexible framework for analyzing historical development as well as the crucial Polish balance between internal and external factors. Democratic breakthrough is, however, an intellectually separate concept to democratic consolidation – although the two overlap as the former logically precedes and produces the conditions for the latter. The essence of consolidation is when the major principles and rules of the democratic game – such as alternation of power, respect for constitutional procedures and individual or group rights and so on – become internalized and selfenforcing. Threats such as right-wing extremism or imperfections such as clientelism or corrupt links between the political and economic spheres are more dangerous in newly established than in venerably old democracies. Mere length of survival is, therefore, an important consideration. There would, however, appear to be two dominant criteria for judging consolidation. The first is whether the system contains all the necessary institutions and actually functions as a democracy. The second is whether the political system is underpinned by societal legitimacy: in other words, by a democratic political culture. The East European replacement of communist with democratic capitalist systems also raises the issue, as argued by Ryszard Herburt, of the proportions of winners to losers from the socioeconomic transformation in creating the interests to support the latter.72 The foregoing themes encapsulate our old friends institutions/procedures versus culture/values in the democratization debate. The former tradition, going back to Schumpeter, identifies democracy as a core of electoral, parliamentary and judicial institutions, whose procedural functioning, however imperfect, is the benchmark. Americans are more ideological in regarding their way of life and values as breathing reality into their constitutional principles of separation of powers and federalism. The British
Democratic Transition and Consolidation 63
bequeathed democratic institutions to their ex-African colonies and, inevitably, fell back on political culture to explain why they failed to take root and were replaced, rather quickly, by native tribal authoritarian patterns. Both the continental European and Anglo-Saxon approaches contribute essential insights but the former is initially more relevant to the study of institutionalization and the development of constitutionally entrenched rights and procedures in Poland. With the advent of normal politics, Lipset’s and Kitschelt’s observations on the strengthening of democratic values through successful economic performance also become increasingly relevant.73 In a new democracy, the factor of systemic choice or preference remains very important in creating support for, or opposition to, the actual system which may be independent of its political and economic efficacy. Sympathy, support or, even, nostalgia for the PRL has remained high throughout the 1990s, something discussed at the end of Chapter 2. Such sentiments have underpinned the major cleavage in Poland’s political life but have not endangered democracy: the data that follow indicate the decline of ideological-systemic opposition. A major Austrian compendium (Plasser et al., 1998) contains indispensable public opinion findings on attitudes towards both theoretical and practical questions, as well as appreciation of particular institutions. The authors distinguish categorically between transition and consolidation. They present important distinctions between behavioural and attitudinal dimensions and maximalist-minimum definitions of the latter. They conclude with a fourfold typology of consolidation.74 The negative includes: (1) the elimination of formal and procedural constraints upon democracy; and (2) potentially hostile actors. The positive includes: (3) ‘habituation to democratic procedures’ to stabilize normal democratic behaviour; and (4) comprehensive institutionalization to anchor ‘partial regimes of democracy’.75 In detail, what the above means for Poland is as follows: in 1995, democracy was regarded as freedom by 38 per cent, but rule of law and social justice tied at 16 per cent, while a residual 7 per cent still hankered after participation.76 The emotions aroused by politics (1995) were 37 per cent negative, 40 per cent neutral and only 23 per cent positive.77 The ‘very and fairly satisfied’ as against ‘not very/not at all satisfied’ with democracy percentage responses ranged from an initial 38–37 in 1990 to lows of 27–50 in 1991 and 32–65 in 1992, a temporary improvement to 35–45 mirrored economic upturn in 1993 – but its shallow nature was reflected in a fall to 23–63 the following year. Consolidation and economic growth then produced 50–38, 43–45 and 57–33 figures during 1995–97 – which by the latter date approached average levels in the EU.78 Despite fluctuations over time, and variations on specific issues, the empirical evidence is that the indicators supporting democracy and personal satisfaction increased substantially over the period of the 1990s up to
64 Democratic Government in Poland
levels equivalent to other European democracies by 2000. As early as 1994, 60 per cent of Poles supported the 1989 systemic changes as against 29 per cent who opposed and 11 per cent who were undecided.79 The percentage figures approving and opposing democracy in the abstract, as the best system as monitored by CBOS (slightly different from Plasser’s, showing the variable, and far from definitive, character of all such statistics), moved to 61–17 in 1995, 71–12 in 1996 and 67–12 in 1997. More to the point, the percentage satisfaction/dissatisfaction balances ranged from 36–52 in 1993, to 24–67 in 1994, 30–58 in 1995 and 44–47 in 1996.80 The debate over the best type of political regime, and the constitutional and institution-building process accompanying democratic consolidation during the 1990s, will be discussed in Chapter 4. Having already stressed the importance of electoral laws, political parties and political culture, one now needs to highlight the significance of political elites in both processes. Agh defines the latter as ‘an eminently party and government elite’ of about 10 000 people, heading a largely party-created political class of about 100 000: this includes all those elected, both at the national and local levels, as well as what he terms ‘state-dependent’ functionaries in the administration.81 The negotiated and contractual beginnings of Poland’s democracy maintained the homogeneity of the successor to the communist power-elite. The process involved the passivity and demobilization of the population.82 This factor was strengthened by the very small membership anchorage of political parties in society. The professionalization and decision-making weight of elite actors varies according to their institutional framework, a conclusion borne out by studies of the parliamentary and local government sub-elites.83 The evidence, however, suggests that a growing pluralist framework since 1990 has encouraged turnover. It has also developed a party-parliamentary type of political leadership which for historical reasons continues to be heavily recruited from the universities and the administration. Critics such as Irena Panków consider that these elites still suffer from an identity problem.84 Jacek Wasilewski, despite worrying about what he terms ‘the shallow consolidation of Polish democracy’, concedes, grudgingly, that the Polish elite have internalized democratic values; they have maintained ‘a consensus on the principal questions and procedures of democratic politics’.85 The erstwhile radical anti-communist intelligentsia had many illusions, and were consequently highly disenchanted when they discovered the limited, elite-led and non-participatory aspects of western democratic systems. They were also concerned that the 1993 electoral shift, to peasantsuccessor communist left government, might challenge systemic transformation. These doubts were largely stilled by 1997 as a result of the promulgation of the constitution and the centre-right’s electoral victory. Insufficient institutionalization of pressure groups and secondary associations resulted, however, in incomplete interest aggregation and articula-
Democratic Transition and Consolidation 65
tion. Bohdan Szklarski identified over 300 political parties, 14 000 NGOs and 10 national trade union confederations. He considered that numerical proliferation had only produced fragmentation, destructive competition for the same public space or interest, and an inadequately articulated civic or public life. He consequently defined the system as ‘a direct pluralist democracy or a semi-public democracy’ where the citizen still had a potentially dangerous and volatile relationship with the state.86 Hieronim Kubiak, however, argues that the distinction between parties, without much public sympathy, and NGOs, identified with the anti-communist struggle for a civil society, remains blurred in Poland. Bodies such as Father Rydzik’s Family of Radio Maryja and Kazimierz Kapera’s Federation of Catholic Families Associations, ‘occupy the political space that was traditionally occupied by political parties’.87 Kubiak considers that the dense network of varied NGOs in Poland are practical schools for democracy, strengthening the local and sectional bases of parliamentary democracy and precursors of post-modern forms of political participation. Does non-, and imperfectly expressed, participation suggest only conditional support for democracy, as in Weimar Germany or the early period of the Bonn Republic? I do not think so. The public opinion polls by the end of the 1990s definitively confirmed diffuse support for democratic values – which were still perceived as western ones. Earlier studies had also shown popular support for the largely institutional and procedural definition of democracy.88 The concerns were that an apathetic ‘Silent Majority’, with diffuse commitment to democratic values, might be overwhelmed by a dynamic minority interest or value group. The mobilization of Ursus tractor workers by Wrzodak and of discontented peasants by the Poujadist Lepper or even the violent demonstrations of Tejkowski’s right-wing skinheads, were worrying phenomena throughout the 1990s. On the other hand, they got nowhere in elections. The evidence suggesting that the Tymi´nski experience would not be replicated by the strong-man appeal of, for example, General Wilecki, was confirmed by the 2000 presidential election. Whether such phenomena endangered the democratic system or whether they should be viewed as unpleasant safety valves, managing the discontent of losers from the transformation, is debatable. What should be noted is that the threat to democracy in Poland has come from the right. This explains why decommunization and lustration have been much weaker here than elsewhere. As a consequence, a lot of attention was paid by supporters of the democratic conditionally argument, to public opinion poll findings on economic optimism. Despite the post-1993 economic upturn, Polish attitudes on this issue were fairly negative until the mid 1990s. Positive appraisals of the marketizing economy increased from 37 per cent in 1991 to 60 per cent in 1995, but hopes for prosperity in five years’ time diminished from 72 to 49 per cent.89 Ideological support for the market economy increased from a favourable majority of 28 to 43 per cent in those respective years.90 The
66 Democratic Government in Poland
most important empirical conclusion on this subject is that, according to the Plasser team’s typology, 43 per cent of Poles in 1997 were confident democrats, 25 per cent were worried democrats, 14 per cent were alienated, while 18 per cent remained irrevocably wedded to authoritarianism.91 Post-communism in Eastern Europe was, initially, defined by Claus Offe as a Triple Transition, involving the three processes of democratization, marketization and nation building, away from communism.92 This left the time scale for the completion of these three interlocking transformations, as well as the methods by which they would be achieved, open. The balance between the rate of change in each sector, as well as between national features and general characteristics have, consequently, varied in each individual country. The process appears, to outsiders, to become more uniform the closer that the East-Central European countries have got to what looks recognizably like the democratic capitalist end point. We are primarily concerned with democratization in this discussion and, as we have seen, since the mid-1990s, the issue in the Polish case has largely been considered in terms of democratic consolidation. Intrasystemic restructuring of lagging sectors was illustrated most clearly by the Buzek government’s education, social security, health and local government reforms. Impelled by Poland’s preparations for EU membership, it also tackled the railways and coalmines but failed to tackle the agricultural problem. One now needs to pull the foregoing themes together by examining some additional interpretations of Poland’s transformation. In the 1990s, the evolutionary and incomplete process – of replacing a state socialist political monocracy and command-allocation economy with democratic capitalism – naturally produced the confusing co-existence of a mixture of conflicting principles and features. The general transition from the former to the latter also caused what the sociologist, Piotr Sztompka, describes as a cultural trauma caused by the social costs of transformation.93 This was worsened by the earlier collapse in the belief in progress and in the necessarily beneficial character of social change.94 Adaptation to new competitive social conditions and market conditions, along with the turnaround from collective to individualistic values, proved too difficult for large numbers of the elderly as well as the economically marginal and displaced.95 High levels of unemployment, estimated by unofficial sources as ranging from 17 per cent in 1992 to over 18 per cent in 2000, were psychologically and socially difficult to accommodate.96 Widespread feelings of apathy, hopelessness and personal and social withdrawal caused a variety of pathologies, ranging from drunkenness, family breakdown and petty criminality, right up to the quintessential Durkheimian anomie of suicide.97 Trust in public institutions declined most dramatically between January and June 1991 – in the government from 50 to 42 per cent, in the Sejm from 46 to 30 per cent and in the Senate from 46 to 36 per cent.98 These negative social trends produced the pessimistic and hostile public opinion
Democratic Transition and Consolidation 67
reactions discussed above. There was initially overwhelming emotional and cultural approval in 1989 for the repudiation of communism and for democracy, a sort of psychological ‘honeymoon months of the transformation’.99 This ensured that the above factors never really threatened Poland’s new democracy and were not discussed in terms of lack of legitimacy, as during the PRL.100 The rapid growth of middle, and revitalized professional, classes also provided an additional balance.101 The newly established rule of law framework and general elite consensus on the evolutionary nature of the transformation also withstood attempts at destabilization such as excessive and sudden decommunization.102 What was important for the system was that opposition took the form of protest rather than social or national conflict.103 Working-class strikes and demonstrations thus acted as safety valves and sectional protests rather than systemic threats as under the PRL, despite only partial conversion of workers to market values.104 Interest group articulation was imperfect and incomplete but even partial functioning, as argued by Bohdan Szklarski, was preferable to the controls and blockages of the previous system.105 At the elite level, the crucial factor, as demonstrated by Solidarity’s fluctuating fortunes, was that systemic transformation was no longer tied to the success of the democratic camp. Its speed and thoroughness was, however, as demonstrated by the 1993–97 slowdown.106 This chapter can, however, conclude on an optimistic note concerning the external framework for democratization. Poland’s geopolitical situation was transformed out of all recognition after 1989. The German and Russian problems which had stifled the country’s independence and development since 1700 were, arguably, eliminated. A united Germany, given a central integrating role within the EU, developed positive attitudes towards Poland’s incorporation. Russia was separated, physically, from Poland by a belt of newly independent republics. Ukraine, and after some delay Lithuania, because of the Polish national minority problem, despite historical animosities, have become friends and potential allies rather than enemies, while an isolated Belarus barely counts in this reckoning of the emerging states. A weakened Russia is hardly a threat to Poland, especially after Warsaw achieved NATO membership in 1999. Finally, prospective EU membership, despite the problems of Polish agriculture, labour movement and foreign ownership, provides an immeasurably more supportive external framework for the new democracy than might have been imagined before 1989.
Notes 1
Cf. Petr Kopecky and Cas Mudde, What has Eastern Europe taught us about Democratisation (Literature and Vice Versa), Comparative Politics, XXXII (1999),
68 Democratic Government in Poland
2
3 4 5 6
7
8 9 10
11 12
13 14 15 16 17
43–62. See Valerie Bunce, Should Transitologists be Grounded?, Slavic Review, LIV (1995), 111–35. Their very validity is largely ignored in the major political history by James F. Brown, Surge to Freedom (Twickenham: Adamantine, 1991). Judy Batt also fails to integrate the third theoretical category of successful Gorbachev-type transition as in National Salvation Front Romania, The end of Communist Rule in Eastern Europe, Government and Opposition, XXVI (1990), 368–90. Terry Karl and Philip Schmitter, Modes of Transition in Latin America, Southern and Eastern Europe, International Social Science Journal, no. 128 (1991), 269–84. See Attila Agh, The Politics of Central Europe (London: Sage, 1998), p. 142. See Samuel Huntington, The Third Wave. Democratization in the late Twentieth Century (Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1991), pp. 121–63. Cf. P. Cipkowski, Revolution in Eastern Europe (New York: Wiley, 1991). See also Gwyn Prins (ed.), Spring in Winter. The 1989 Revolutions (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1990); Gail Stokes, The Walls Came Tumbling Down (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1990). See Richard Gunther, P. Nikiforos Diamandouros and Hans-Jurgen Puhle (eds), The Politics of Democratic Consolidation. Southern Europe in Comparative Perspective (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1995). Huntington, op. cit. See also Guillermo O’Donnell, Phillip Schmitter and Laurence Whitehead (eds), Transitions from Authoritarian Rule: Prospects for Democracy, 4 vols (Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press, 1986); Geoffrey Pridham (ed.), Encouraging Democracy: the International Context of Regime Transition in Southern Europe (Leicester: Leicester University Press, 1991); Adam Przeworski, Democracy and the Market: Political and Economic Reforms in Eastern Europe and Latin America (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991). See Linz and Stepan, Problems of Political Transition and Consolidation, p. 267. Taras, Consolidating Democracy in Poland, p. 113 ff. Jon Elster, Claus Offe and Ulrich Preuss, Institutional Design in Post-Communist Societies, Rebuilding the Ship at Sea (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998), p. 65. Cf. Khrishan Kumar, The 1989 Revolutions and the Idea of Europe, Political Studies, XL (1992), 439–61. Cf. Jean Cohen and Andrew Arato, Civil Society and Political Theory (Cambridge MA: MIT Press, 1992). See also Janina Frentzel-Zagorska, Civil Society in Poland and Hungary, Soviet Studies, XLII (1992), 439–61; John Keane (ed.), Civil Society and the State: New European Perspectives (London: University of Westminster Press, 1988 and 1998); Zbigniew Rau, The State of Enslavement: the East European Substitute for the State of Nature, Political Studies, XXXIX (June 1991), 253–69. See Von Beyme, Transition to Democracy in Eastern Europe, p. 19. See Brzezinski, The Grand Failure, and Leslie Holmes, The End of Communist Power (Cambridge: Polity Press, 1993). See Dankwart Rustow, Transitions to Democracy, Comparative Politics, II (April 1970), 337–64. See David Ost, Towards a Corporatist Solution in Poland, East European Politics and Societies, III (1989), 152–74. See R. Bova, Political Dynamics of Post-Communist Transition, World Politics, XLIV (October 1991), 113–38. See also Connor and Pl⁄ oszajski, op. cit., Christopher Bryant and Edmund Mokrzycki (eds), The New Great Transformation
Democratic Transition and Consolidation 69
18 19 20 21 22
23
24
25
26
27 28 29 30 31 32
33
34
(London: Routledge, 1994); Beverly Crawford (ed.), Markets, States and Democracy (Boulder CO: Westview Press, 1995); Transition to Democracy in Poland (New York: St Martin’s Press – now Palgrave Macmillan, 1993); Grzegorz Ekiert, Democratization Processes in East-Central Europe, British Journal of Political Science, XXI (1991), 285–315; Richard F. Staar (ed.), Transition to Democracy in Poland (New York: St Martin’s Press – now Palgrave Macmillan, 1993). See Geoffrey Pridham and Tatu Vanhanen (eds), Democratization in Eastern Europe – Domestic and International Perspectives (London: Routledge, 1994). Rueschemeyer, E. Stephens and J. Stephens, Capitalist Development and Democracy (Oxford: Polity Press, 1991). See Karen Henderson and Neil Robinson, Post-Communist Politics: an Introduction (London: Prentice-Hall, 1997), pp. 29–32. See Keith Crawford, East Central European Politics Today (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1996), p. 97. See Connor and Pl⁄ oszajski, op. cit. See also Karol B. Janowski, Polski Rok 1989 (Kielce, WSP Kielce, 1998); Staar, op. cit.; Staniszkis, The Dynamics of the Breakthrough in Eastern Europe, op. cit. For participants’ accounts, see Bronisl⁄ aw Geremek, La Rupture. La Pologne du communisme a˛ la democratie (Paris: Seuil, 1991); Mieczysl⁄ aw F. Rakowski, Jak to si˛e stal⁄ o (Warsaw: BGW, 1991). For the wider context, see Valerie Bunce, The Decline of a Regional Hegemon: Gorbachev and Reform, European Politics and Societies, III (Spring 1989), 235–67; Karen Dawisha, Eastern Europe, Gorbachev and Reform 2nd edn (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1990). See East-Central Europe in Comparative Perspective, in Geoffrey Pridham, Eric Herring and George Sanford (eds), Building Democracy. The International Dimension of Democratisation in Eastern Europe rev. 2nd edn (Leicester: Leicester University Press 1997), p. 52. See George Sanford, Polish-Soviet Relations, in Alex Pravda (ed.), The End of the Outer Empire. Soviet–East European Relations in Transition (London: RIIA/Sage, 1992). See Wawrzyniak, Zarys Polskiego systemu konstytucjonalizmu, op cit., pp. 57–8. New institutions such as the presidency and the Senate were also considered so their establishment in summer 1989 by no means took the constitutional reformers by surprise. See Francis Millard, The Anatomy of the New Poland. Post-Communist Politics in its First Phase (Aldershot: Edward Elgar, 1994), p. 45. See his account of events in Witold Beres and Jerzy Skoczylas (eds), General Kiszczak mowi prawie wszystko (Warsaw: BGW, 1991), pp. 259–68. See Rakowski, op. cit. X Plenum KC PZPR. Podstawowe dokumenty i material⁄ y (Warsaw: KiW, 1989). Cf. Polityka, 4 February 1989, p. 3. See Brown, op. cit. See also Wiktor Osiaty´nski, Poland, in Jon Elster (ed.), The Roundtable Talks and the Breakdown of Communism (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1996); Konstanty Gebert, Mebel (London: Aneks, 1990); Stanisl⁄ aw Gebethner, Political Reform in the Process of Round Table Negotiations, in Sanford, Democratization in Poland, op. cit. Krzysztof Dubi´nski, Magdalenka. Transakcja Epoki (Warsaw: Sylwa, 1990). Piotr Raina, Droga do ‘Okr agl ˛ ⁄ ego Stol⁄ u’: Zakulisowe rozmowy przygotawawcze (Warsaw: Von Borowiecky, 1999). In Sanford, Democratization in Poland, op. cit., p. 67.
70 Democratic Government in Poland 35 36 37 38 39 40
41 42 43 44
45 46 47
48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58
59
The Times, 6 April 1989, editorial. Polityka, 29 April 1989. Porozumienia Okragl ˛ ⁄ ego Stol⁄ u (Warsaw: no pub. 5 kwietna 1989). Ibid., p. 4 of the Political Reforms Committee. See also the standpoint of the Economic and Social Committee. See Linz and Stepan, op. cit., pp. 267–9. Cf. Paul Lewis, Non-Competitive Elections and Regime-Change: Poland 1989, Parliamentary Affairs XLIII (1990), 90–107. See also Andrzej Malkiewicz, Wybory czerwcowe 1989 (Warsaw: ISP PAN, 1994); David Olson, Compartmentalized Competition: the Managed Transitional Electoral System of Poland, Journal of Politics LV (February 1993), 415–44. Zbigniew Pelczynski and Sergiusz Kowalski, Poland, Electoral Studies, IX (1990), 346–54. Kamienski in Polityka, 24 June 1989. Cf. Krzysztof Jasiewicz, The Elections of 1984–9, in Sanford, Democratization in Poland, op cit., pp. 110–25. Gazeta Wyborcza, 20 and 21 June 1989. Tygodnik Solidarno´sc´ , 28 July 1989. Gazeta Wyborcza, 4 July 1989. Michnik was uniquely associated with the idea that the communist and Solidarity camps were eventually fated to compromise. This was the main thesis of his Takie czasy: rzecz o kompromisie (London: Aneks, 1985). Tygodnik Solidarno´sc´ , 18 August 1989, p. 2. See Linz and Stepan, op. cit., p. 273. Doubts about Wal⁄ esa’s ˛ character and temperament surfaced with the publication of his ex-press-spokesman’s revelations; see Jarosl⁄ aw Kurski, Wódz (Warsaw: PoMost, 1991). He sets out his broad political philosophy in Un autre visage de l’Europe (Paris: Les Editions Noir sur Blanc, 1989). John Higley and Jan Pakulski, Elite Transformation in Central and Eastern Europe, Australian Journal of Political Science, XXX (1995), 415–35. Dz. U., 1989, no. 19, position 101. Wojciech Sokolewicz, The April 1989 Change of the Constitution, Polish Contemporary Law, no. 3/4–79/80 (1990), 3–23. See Sokolewicz in Sanford, Democratization in Poland, pp. 76–80. Ibid., p. 81 Dz. U., 1989, no. 75, position 444. Hanna Suchocka and Lesl⁄ aw Ka´nski, Zmiany konstytucyjnej regulacji s adown˛ ictwo i prokuratury dókonanej w roku 1989, Pa´nstwo i Prawo, XLVI, no. 1 (1991). Cf. Wojciech Sokolewicz, Rzeczpospolita Polska – demokratyczne pa´nstwo prawne, Pa´nstwo i Prawo, XLV, no. 4 (1990). Dz. U., 1990, no. 67, position 397. Cf. Stanisl⁄ aw Podemski in Polityka, 13 September 1997. Evan McGilvray, however, disputes the domestic dynamics of the reform of civilmilitary relations, arguing that the main pressure was externally directed by the need for NATO membership. The Military in Poland’s Transition from Communism, 1989–1997, University of Bradford, MPhil, 2001. Sekul⁄ a was later to be investigated by the Sejm Committee on Constitutional Responsibility and was only saved from criminal prosecution by his parliamentary immunity. He eventually committed suicide in 2000. Urban was to prosper mightily as the owner and editor of the populist weekly Nie (No). This appealed to the losers in the socioeconomic transformation by railing against corruption and the Roman Catholic Church.
Democratic Transition and Consolidation 71 60 Andrzej Antoszewski, Konstytucja w s´ wietle refleksje politologicznej, in Karol Janowski (ed.), Nowa Konstycja RP. Warto´sci, Jednostka, Instytucje (Toru´n: Marszal⁄ ek, 1991), pp. 38–9. 61 Wprost, 19 April 1998, pp. 28–30. Other suggestions by elite notables in this symposium were 28 October 1992 (the date the last Soviet soldier left Poland (Wal⁄ esa)) ˛ and 2 April 1997 (the promulgation of the full constitution (Rakowski, Jaruzelski)) with the 1992 Little Constitution gaining little support. Public opinion (Pentor poll) favoured 2 April (promulgation of 1997 constitution) most (29 per cent) followed by the 29 December 1989 constitutional amendment (16 per cent) and the opening of the Round Table on 5 February 1989 (10 per cent), Wprost, 17 May 1998, p. 29. 62 See Bogdan Szajkowski (ed.), New Political Parties of Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union (Harlow: Longman, 1991), pp. 175–217. 63 See Michael Mandelbaum (ed.), Post-Communism: Four Perspectives (New York: Council for Foreign Relations, 1996), p. 103. 64 In B. Grancelli (ed.), Social Change and Modernization: Lessons from Eastern Europe (Berlin: de Gruyter, 1995). 65 See Antoni Dudek, Pierwsze lata III Rzeczypospolitej, 1989–1995 (Kraków: Wydawnictwo GEO, 1997). See also Frances Millard, The Anatomy of the New Poland, op. cit. and Polish Politics and Society (London: Routledge, 1999); Sanford, Poland. The Conquest of History, op. cit. 66 Cf. Raina, Poland 1981, op. cit., Ch. 13; Sanford, The Solidarity Congress, op. cit. 67 See George Konrad, Anti-Politics (San Diego: Harcourt Brace Jovanovitch, 1984). See also Vaclav Havel, The Power of the Powerless (London: Hutchinson, 1985). 68 See Ost, Solidarity and the Politics of Anti-Politics, op cit. 69 Andrew Arato, Civil Society, Constitution and Legitimacy (Lanham MD: Rowman and Littlefield, 2000). 70 Francis Fukuyama’s ‘End of History?’ statement in National Interest, XVI (1989) was inevitably more declaratory, despite the question mark, than his intellectually more subtle The End of History and the Last Man (London: Penguin, 1992). 71 See Taras, Consolidating Democracy in Poland, esp. pp. 12–19. See also Gabriel Almond, Scott Flanagan and Robert Mundt (eds), Crisis, Choice and Change (Boston: Little Brown, 1973). 72 Andrzej Antoszewski and Ryszard Herburt (eds), Polityka w Polsce w latach ’90 Wybrane problemy (Wrocl⁄ aw: WUWr, 1999), p. 8. 73 See Herbert Kitschelt, The formation of Party-Systems in East Central Europe, Politics & Society, XX (1992). See also Seymour Martin Lipset, Political Man. The Social Bases of Politics (London: Heinemann, 1983). 74 Plasser et. al., op. cit., Ch. 2. 75 Ibid., pp. 47–8. 76 Ibid., p. 75. 77 Ibid., p. 78. 78 Ibid., p. 87 and 93. 79 Antoszewski and Herburt, Polityka w Polsce w latach ‘90, op. cit., p. 56. 80 Ibid., p. 67. 81 See Agh, Politics of Central Europe, p. 112. 82 See David Mason, Daniel Nelson, and Bohdan Szlarski, Apathy and the Birth of Democracy, East European Politics & Societies, V (1991), 205–33.
72 Democratic Government in Poland 83 See Janusz Sztumski (ed.), Elity w procesie transformacji spol⁄ eczno-gospodarcze i politycznej Polski (Katowice: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Slaskiego, ˛ 1995). See also Wl⁄ odzimierz Wesol⁄ owski and Barbara Post (eds), Polityka i Sejm; formowanie si˛e elity politycznej (Warsaw: Wydawnictwo Sejmowe, 1998). 84 See Jacek Wasilewski (ed.), Zbiorowi aktorzy polskiej polityki (Warsaw: ISP PAN, 1997), pp. 247–71. 85 Ibid., p. 298. 86 See Bohdan Szklarski, Semi-Public Democracy. Articulation of Interests and Systemic Transformation (Warsaw: IFIS PAN, 1997), pp. 201–14. 87 See Hieronim Kubiak, Political Parties and NGOs: Competitors for Power or two Faces of an Emerging Democracy, in Kubiak and Waitr, Between Animosity and Utility, op. cit., pp. 47–8. 88 See Wl⁄ adysl⁄ aw Adamski (ed.), Societal Conflict and Systemic Change (Warsaw: IFiS PAN, 1993). See also Marek Ziól⁄ kowski (ed.), Polacy wobec l⁄ adu postmonocentrycznego (Warsaw: ISP PAN, 1993). 89 Plasser, op. cit., p. 177. 90 Ibid., p. 179. 91 Ibid., pp. 190–1. 92 Claus Offe, Capitalism by Democratic Design? Democratic Theory facing the Triple Transition in Eastern Europe, Social Research, LVIII (1991), 876–92. 93 See Piotr Sztompka, Trauma Wielkiej Zmiany. Spol⁄ eczne transformacji (Warsaw: ISP PAN, 2000). 94 Cf. Jeffrey Alexander and Piotr Sztompka (eds), Rethinking Progress (London: Unwin and Hyman, 1990). 95 See Maria Jarosz (ed.), Dziesi˛ec lat prywatizacji bezpo´sredniej (Warsaw: ISP PAN, 2000). See also Mirosl⁄ awa Marody and E. Gucwa-Le´sny (eds), Podstawy zycia spol⁄ ecznego w Polsce (Warsaw: Instytut Studiów Spol⁄ ecznych PAN, 1996); A. Miszalska, Reakcje spol⁄ eczne na przemiany ustrojowe (L⁄ ód z: ˙ Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu L⁄ ódzkiego, 1996). Essential data on the most severe levels of political, social and economic dissatisfaction in 1991 is provided by Ewa Karpowicz and Krystyna Leli´nska, Przemiany ustrojowe w´swiadomo´sci spol⁄ ecznej (Warsaw: Sejm Chancellery, BSiE, December 1991). 96 Cf. R. Borowicz and K. L⁄ api´nska-Tyszka, Syndrom bezrobocia (Warsaw: IRWiR PAN, 1994). More restrictively defined official figures admitted a peak of 16.4 per cent in 1993 and lows of, at best, 12 per cent during the 1990s, Mal⁄ y Rocznik Statystyczny 1998, p. 120. 97 See Maria Jarosz, Samobójstwo (Warsaw: PWN, 1997). Specialists will note that this was exactly the litany of pathologies levelled against the PRL, and not only by pro-Solidarity IFiS sociologists: cf. Jerzy Wiatr (ed.), Polska 1980–1990. Warto´sci a przemiany l⁄ adu gospodarczego i politycznego (Warsaw: Instytut Socjologii-UW, 1990). 98 Informacj o spadku zaufania spol⁄ ecnego w stosunku do instytucji sprawujacych ˛ wl⁄ adze w Polsce (Warsaw: Sejm Chancellery, BsiE, 16 July 1991). 99 See M. Ziól⁄ kowski, Pragmatyzacja swiadomo´sci spol⁄ ecze´nstwa polskiego, Kultura i Spol⁄ ecze´nstwo, no. 4 (1995), 11–28. Cf. Piotr Sztompka, Looking Back: the Year 1989 as a Culture and Civilizational Break, Communist & Post-Communist Studies, XXIX (1996), 115–26. 100 The theoretical forms of legitimisation strategies are discussed by Stanisl⁄ aw Mocek in Mirosl⁄ aw Grabowska and Stanisl⁄ aw Mocek, Pierwsza Sze´sciolatka. Próba bilansu polityki (Warsaw: ISP PAN, 1997), pp. 177–88.
Democratic Transition and Consolidation 73 101 Cf. Bryant and Mokrzycki (eds), The New Great Transformation?, op. cit. 102 Andrzej Walicki, in James McAdams (ed.), Transitional Justice and the Rule of Law in New Democracies (Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 1997), pp. 185–237. 103 Adamski, Societal Conflict and Systemic Change, op. cit. 104 J. Gardawski, Przyzwolenie ograniczone. Robotnicy wobec rynku i demokracje (Warsaw: PWN, 1996). 105 Grabowska and Mocek, op. cit., pp. 151–64. 106 Jan Kofman and Wojciech Roszkowski, Transformacja i Postkomunizm (Warsaw: ISP PAN, 1999), pp. 130–5.
4 Constitution Making and Consensus Building
National sovereignty and citizenship The demolition of external Soviet controls, the return of full national sovereignty and Poland’s free negotiation of links with the EU, NATO and other European and international organizations, was connected integrally with, and reinforced, the systemic replacement of monocratic communism with democratic capitalism. National and popular sovereignty could thus be established to facilitate the completion of the third arm of Offe’s Triple Transition – nation building.1 I would define the latter quite simply as the coming together of nation and independent state in a legitimate democratic form; this overcame the historical split between the, often foreign-controlled, state and the independent nation or society. It may also be viewed as the final confirmation of civic-territorial, not ethnic, citizenship although the question was confused by diaspora issues in the late 1990s. In Poland’s case, ethnic discrimination has never taken legal form and has generally been restricted to informal social and individual behaviour and attitudes. The latter were conditioned after 1989 by Poland’s commitment to European standards through the acceptance of the necessary international agreements.2 The elite was fairly united on this issue. National minorit