An Historian’s Life
For Alex
An Historian’s Life Max Crawford and the Politics of Academic Freedom
Fay Anderson
MELBOURNE UNIVERSITY PRESS An imprint of Melbourne University Publishing Ltd (MUP Ltd) 187 Grattan Street, Carlton, Victoria 3053, Australia
[email protected] www.mup.com.au First published 2005 Text © Fay Anderson, 2005 Illustrations © Belong to the individual copyright holder as acknowledged in the text. Design and typography © Melbourne University Publishing Ltd 2005 This book is copyright. Apart from any use permitted under the Copyright Act 1968 and subsequent amendments, no part may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted by any means or process whatsoever without the prior written permission of the publishers. Designed by Phil Campbell Typeset in Utopia by J&M Typesetting Printed by University of Melbourne Design & Print Centre National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication entry Anderson, Fay. An historian’s life : Max Crawford and the politics of academic freedom. Includes index. ISBN 0 522 85153 3. (paperback) ISBN 0 522 85154 1. (e-book) 1. Crawford, R. M. (Raymond Maxwell), 1906-1991. 2. University of Melbourne. Dept. of History - Employees Biography. 3. Historians - Australia - Biography. 4. Academic freedom - Australia. 5. History - Study and teaching (Higher) - Victoria - Melbourne. 6. Liberalism Australia. I. Title. 994.0072
Contents Introduction
1
1. Origins and Influences
15
2. ‘Forward the Professors’
53
3. War and Diplomacy
101
4. Brave New World
153
5. Academic Freedom and the Australian Story
217
6. ‘Things Will Never Be the Same’
278
7. ‘Into the Night’
321
Conclusion
366
Bibliography
375
Index
388
vii
List of abbreviations ABC ACCL AIF ADB ANU ASIO CPA FAUSA MI5 MUSA MUP NAA NLA SRC UMA VOKS WEA
viii
Australian Broadcasting Commission Australian Council of Civil Liberties Australian Imperial Force Australian Dictionary of Biography Australian National University Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Communist Party of Australia Federation of Australian University Staff Associations Military Intelligence Service, section 5 Melbourne University Staff Association Melbourne University Press National Archives of Australia National Library of Australia Students Representative Council University of Melbourne Archives All Union Association for Cultural Relations with Foreign Countries Workers Educational Association
Acknowledgements There are many people to thank for assisting and inspiring me in this endeavour. They include: Liz Agostino, Perrie Ballantyne, Tony Birch, Andy Brown-May, Robert Dare, Don Garden, June Factor, Barbara Falk, Patricia Grimshaw, Ken Inglis, Jamie Mackie, Janet McCalman, Peter McPhee, Carolyn Rasmussen, Ron Ridley, Richard Selleck, Ann Standish, Richard Trembath, Graham Willett, Sara Wills and Bart Ziino. Colleagues in the History Department and Australian Centre have generously commented on my work in progress and provided guidance. My particular thanks to Stuart Macintyre who was a great supervisor and continues to offer advice and encouragement. Thank you also to the Director of the Centre, Kate Darian-Smith for providing me with the support and time to see the work to completion and Roger Averill who emphasised the book’s contradictions and flaws, with humour. I am also indebted to the many people who granted me interviews: the late Clem Christesen, the late Nina Christesen, the late Dymphna Clark, the late Lloyd Churchward, Ken Crawford, the late Lloyd Evans, Sheila Fitzpatrick, Frank Ford, Betty Hayes, Donald Horne, Laurie O’Brien, June Phillip, John Poynter, the late Geoffrey Serle, Geoffrey Sharp, Nonie Sharp, Barry Smith, Valerie Tarrant, Arthur Turner and Cynthia Turner. My sincere gratitude goes to Ian Crawford and Margaret Cheshire who allowed me to intrude in their lives, generously offering important information and correcting the inconsistencies in my work. Over many years the staff at the National Library of Australia and the National Archives of Australia have been most helpful. I am particularly grateful to the University of Melbourne Archives for providing me with advice and access to their collections. Special thanks go to past and present staff members, most notably Cecily Close, Sue Fairbanks, Michael Piggott, Mark Richmond and Jason Benjamin. The staff at Melbourne University Publishing have been wonderful. Thank you to the publisher Louise Adler, Amanda Finnis, Nathan Katz and Monica Dux, who is always so encouraging. To Sue Lake, Deanne McLaren and the ‘Gin Club’ for their unerring patience and understanding when I have been distracted, exhausted and simply annoying. Final thanks I owe to my parents, and Alex who has lived with this research for much of his life. ix
x
Max Crawford at Oxford Hill and Saunders: Oxford
xi
Introduction
In 1952, at the height of the Cold War, Colonel Charles Spry, the Director of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (better known as ASIO), instructed his agents to vet all academics at Australian universities. ‘I am sure that you will readily appreciate’, Spry wrote to Robert Menzies, the Prime Minister at the time, ‘the inadvisability of employing, in any University, lecturers who are likely to infect students with subversive doctrines’.1 In Australia as in the United States, the intellectual as an ideologue had been an object of suspicion and resentment since the 1930s, and the Cold War confirmed and intensified this mistrust.2 Politicians, public agencies (most notably ASIO) and the press had hounded ‘suspect intellectuals’ and advanced the notion of manipulative academics for years. Raymond Maxwell Crawford (who was always known as Max), one of Australia’s pre-eminent historians, was considered highly suspect; his career was sometimes under siege and views often vilified. As both a participant in and observer of many decisive episodes of the era—Europe in the midst of the Depression, America and Russia at the height of World War II, post-war reconstruction and the Cold War in Australia—Crawford was regarded as a ‘radical’ and outspoken defender of intellectual autonomy. A study of his life provides insight into one man’s experience in the midst of political turmoil and change and the backlash against the intellectual community that these events
Introduction
1
inspired. The trajectory of Crawford’s political experiences suggests the changing nature of Australian progressive liberalism and the precarious state of intellectual freedom. This is the first lengthy biographical study of Max Crawford. His life and legacy have attracted considerable attention; he has been described as a ‘profound influence’ in Australia and a man who raised the quality of its intellectual life.3 But in other accounts of public life in the middle decades of the twentieth century, he is no more than a peripheral bit-player. These different estimates and the reasons for his faded acclaim raise intriguing questions. Despite Crawford’s diminished fame, his legacy casts an enduring shadow on subsequent generations of historians and public figures. His life intersected with some notable figures: English intellectuals such as Kenneth Bell, Christopher Hill, A.D. Lindsay, and Richard Tawney, and noted Americans Hans Baron and Merle Curti, as well as prominent Australians that included John Anderson, Kenneth Bailey, Macmahon Ball, Jim Cairns, Clem and Nina Christesen, H.V. Evatt, Brian Fitzpatrick, Kathleen Fitzpatrick, Keith Hancock, Donald Horne, Charles Lowe, Robert Menzies, Ian Milner, Keith Officer, Sydney Orr, Nettie Palmer, Stephen Roberts, Charles Spry and Russel Ward. Then there are students, such as Geoffrey Blainey, Manning Clark, Inga Clendinnen, John Mulvaney and Hugh Stretton, whom Crawford taught, mentored and encouraged during his thirty-four years as Professor of History at the University of Melbourne. This study considers Max Crawford as a historian and a public intellectual. It relates his experiences as a student at Sydney and Oxford, as a schoolteacher, commentator and struggling writer, a diplomat in wartime Russia, and a Cold War victim and accuser. Crawford is variously regarded as an inspiring or an aloof teacher, an advocate or detractor of Australian history, a great defender or betrayer of academic freedom. These contrasting evaluations are important. So too is Crawford’s role as a flawed ideologue: his compassion, hubris, imagination, self-obsession, sensitivity, courage and weakness. Political Denial and Self-invention There are three particular themes, which will be addressed in this biography. The first is the political denial and self-invention that dominated Crawford’s retrospective autobiographical writing. Born
2
An Historian’s Life
in a small country town in New South Wales in 1906, he was one of twelve children in a family guided by an informed and ambitious mother and a father who was a stationmaster and committed unionist. Two of Crawford’s uncles were parliamentarians who followed W.A. Holman out of the Labor Party in the wartime split over conscription. Although his political inheritance was substantial, Crawford insisted that his family was not political, and that he followed the family tradition in keeping his conscience free of political commitments. The ideology that he espoused, and afterwards was at pains to deny, was politically active and advocated the liberal values of freedom, tolerance and morality. The book will explore how he was drawn to progressive causes and lent his academic authority to them, only to retreat when he encountered fierce criticism. It is my contention that Crawford finally adopted a stance of independence from all engagement because of the cumulative effects of the Cold War and the firestorm surrounding his decision to write to the Bulletin in 1961, ostensibly to expose an alleged Communist plot. By this time he was aligned with a remarkable and influential group including: Vincent Buckley, Sidney Hook, Frank Knopfelmacher, Richard Krygier and James McAuley. In analysing Crawford’s political and academic experiences and charting the course of events that embroiled his life, the emphasis will be on the formation and development of his political beliefs, liberal perspective and intellectual role. I reconstruct the complex, evolving nature of Crawford’s political and historical ideology and his responses during the combative debates between radicals and conservatives. Crawford was a product of the Sydney cultural tradition and a member of the Melbourne intellectual elite, a celebrated dichotomy in Australian cultural history. His political and intellectual ideology is not easy to define. At various stages in his life, he adopted the guise of a self-confessed conservative, a civil libertarian, a public activist, a borderline radical, an advocate for the left and an accidental Cold War warrior. What apparently remained unchanged was his identification and acceptance of the obligations and expectations of the intellectual life. He maintained the liberal academic’s anxiety about intellectual independence, which was a prevailing characteristic of the Sydney intellectual tradition.4
Introduction
3
Crawford was an enthusiastic proponent of academic freedom when it was unfashionable and under threat. He understood it to embody free intellectual enquiry; the right and duty to offer new ideas and controversial or unpopular opinions; the freedom to follow a line of research where it led; and the freedom of the university to conduct its own affairs without external interference, particularly from the government.5 At the core of Crawford’s autobiographical construct was an insistence that he was ‘unpolitical’.6 This biography follows Crawford’s self-conscious re-invention, from an Australian working-class boy to Oxford scholar, and from confident public intellectual to unwitting or intentional victim. The Place of Academic Freedom The second theme is the place of academic freedom in Australian universities. I argue that it was often tenuous and never completely accepted by administrators, politicians or the press, which expected universities to avoid controversy. The limits of academic freedom on Australian campuses will be discussed, as well as the suspicion of liberal intellectuals in Australian public life, the repression of academic radicals and the attempts to stifle dissident voices. This surveillance culminated in deliberate and conscious political manipulation of the academy and the collusion and compliance of university authorities in such interference. At other times, the authorities displayed remarkable courage in defending civil liberties despite considerable criticism from politicians and the press. As the Cold War progressed, the public and political expectations demanded self-censorship and unwavering loyalty of Australian intellectuals. These themes will be analysed in the context of Crawford’s experiences and his transformation from a highly conspicuous, progressive and engaged liberal to a more traditional and reticent one. The lengths ASIO went to in its investigation of ‘subversive’ intellectuals will also be examined and the fate of those, like Brian Fitzpatrick and Russel Ward, who did not submit. Crawford’s Intellectual Style The third theme concerns Max Crawford’s intellectual style. His approach to the theory and method of history exercised a strong influence on the discipline, as it assumed a central position in
4
An Historian’s Life
Australia’s intellectual culture. The History School that Crawford shaped was celebrated for its scholarship, and its students achieved important positions in other universities and in public life. The book will consider the life of the Department, its influence, the approach to history and its legacy, which has been retrospectively celebrated and dismissed. The legacy attributed to the Melbourne School of History and its pedagogical innovations are closely related. I believe that Crawford’s historical approach gave his political activity resonance and relevance. His experiences reveal a political conscience linked closely to a particular understanding of history and the role of the historian. Crawford implied that this political awareness was an impediment. ‘The pleasing art of historical narration was at times’, he wrote, ‘elbowed out by the insistent demand that the past must somehow illuminate the present, that history must find answers to the problems which beset us ... How can you observe principles in political life?’7 The historians who were considered suspect were regarded as such not just because of their political activities, but also because of their writing which, by the 1950s, had moved away from a British attachment and emphasised the need for an independent Australian identity. The political interference of historians who pursued this divergent interpretation is an important and neglected aspect of Australia’s Cold War. This study is also concerned with the changing role of universities as they grew from small, intimate communities of scholars to large national institutions with new responsibilities. It considers the way that academics and their Staff Association responded to intellectual suppression, the role of female historians and their struggle to establish their careers, the changing conceptions of research, and the way that the historical profession took shape as a result of the growing interest in Australian history. While Crawford played an important role in the development of Australian history, he was by no means persuaded of its centrality. His own historical practice merits consideration for the way it shaped and expressed his activity as a public intellectual. * * *
Introduction
5
This is not a conventional biography, a full account of a life from birth to death. Rather, I am concerned with Crawford as a particular type of intellectual who became engaged in radical causes. I take from Richard Hofstadter the definition of the intellectual as ‘a person for whom thinking fulfils at once the function of work and play; more specifically, as a person, whose relationship to society is defined, both in his eyes and in the eyes of the society, principally by his presumed capacity to comment upon it with greater detachment’.8 The intellectual class is a relatively modern phenomenon, and the intellectuals’ relation to the rest of society is never entirely comfortable, because the attention and respect paid to their views seem to rest on a measure of detachment.9 The grievance against intellectuals as ideologues intensified when a large part of the intellectual community aligned themselves to communism and fellow-travelling in the 1930s and the 1940s.10 Radicalism and conservatism are important political concepts that constantly operate in this work, although both have various shades of meaning. Radicalism here largely applies to left-wing radicals: those who, in different degrees, embraced the doctrines of socialism and subscribed to progressive beliefs. The idea of political radicalism has long been bound up with this idea of change and progress. ‘To be radical was to have a certain view of the possibilities inherent in history—radicalism meant breaking away from the past.’11 Tim Rowse provides a useful definition of the form of radicalism that had the greatest currency among Australian intellectuals in the midtwentieth century—antagonism to both imperialism and inequality: Radicalism…endorsed the move away from Britain’s orbit and a patriotic rationale to the controversial plans of Reconstruction…A serious effort was made to exploit the socialist potential of this ‘national character’ to extend its political effects into a struggle against capitalism itself. Intellectuals from the Communist Party…inhabited a world that seemed to be turning inexorably leftwards after the war; and this brightening world included an Australia that had recently rediscovered the democratic strengths of its own traditions.12
6
An Historian’s Life
On the opposite side of the ideological divide are the conservatives, a label that also allows a number of different interpretations but, for the purpose of this book, has the characteristics discussed below. The main thrust of conservative thought has been a suspicion of left-wing radical change in all of its forms.13 In an Australian context, the conservatives were pessimistic about schemes for secular progress, convinced of the need for strong authority and attached to stability, tradition and hierarchy. After the Second World War, the Cold War and anti-communism brought a wider coalition of conservatives and more cautious liberals. The opponents of communism were concerned at the threat to Australia, but only as part of a worldwide struggle. They saw communism as ‘a danger to the whole European intellectual and cultural tradition, from which all that was valuable in Australia derived.’14 * * * This biography originally intended to avoid Crawford’s personal and domestic life. The private sphere seemed irrelevant to my purpose, which was to explore the life of a public intellectual. This intention had to be reassessed. Crawford’s youthful experiences inevitably and profoundly influenced aspects of his personality. His denial of the impact of his working-class roots and the family’s political engagement—indeed his place as the favoured son—had a lasting effect on his subsequent behaviour. Crawford’s tendency to alter and reinvent episodes of his early life is a strong theme of the biography. The complex friendship with his fellow historian, Kathleen Fitzpatrick, is also essential to understanding the development of his career, and her story provides a vivid account of the struggle experienced by women academics in the middle of the twentieth century. Crawford’s second marriage to Ruth Hoban is important. She was a leading protagonist in the controversy that erupted after Crawford accused staff of communist subversion, involving the Bulletin and ASIO. This was a devastating episode that provoked criticism of Crawford’s motives. Had he become a political reactionary, a puppet of the right? Or was he motivated by misguided considerations of personal loyalty? As the book was nearing completion, I was asked if I now ‘understood’ Crawford and if I had resolved the contradictions. As with all
Introduction
7
lives, there are secrets and inconsistencies that I cannot possibly comprehend or resolve. There is no conclusive evidence as to what drove Crawford to write to the Bulletin in 1961, thereby effectively destroying his reputation. Although the assumption that people are responsible for their actions might be overly simplistic, there is a moral continuity between the inner and outer person.15 Janet Malcolm claims that biography is a flawed genre.16 One of the most problematic aspects of writing it is the precarious balance of interpretation and historical evidence. The genre offers great scope for imaginative interpretation, although this is constrained by the innate difficulties of understanding another person and fathoming the complexities and frailties of human nature. I draw conclusions, but not, I hope, at the expense of concealing ambiguities, gaps, confusions and inconsistencies in the evidence. Bernard Crick observed that a biographer has an obligation to show how he or she reaches conclusions, not to pretend omniscience. The biography should also reveal to the reader things that are mute, problematic and uncertain.17 I never met Max Crawford, nor did I know about his reputation or legacy when I began this study. The contradictions of his life emerged from the tattered suitcases and shabby boxes that contained his correspondence, diaries and papers. Letters were scattered, papers randomly filed and tutorial notes piled in disorder. The only semblance of order existed in the folders documenting his political and public experiences and the abandoned research undertaken for the intended books on contemporary events. Copious notes, letters and drafts were painstakingly ordered in neat folders with succinct titles: Sydney University, Oxford, Bradfield College, the Spanish Civil War, the Australian Council for Civil Liberties, Brian Fitzpatrick, censorship, conscription, the press, the Australian Legation to the Soviet Union, Russia 1940s, Australia-Soviet Friendship League, the refusal of the American visa, the Bulletin and Communism. These titles offered a clue to Max Crawford’s priorities and preoccupations. The papers relating to the Social Studies/Bulletin Enquiry in 1961 were present, but so also was a stipulation that they would be closed to the hungry eyes of researchers for thirty years after Crawford’s death. Hence the collection was available to me with this one important exception. Although the restriction might reveal Crawford’s
8
An Historian’s Life
bitterness, grief or even shame about the episode, the chapter on the Social Studies Enquiry is dependent on alternative sources. George Paton, the Vice-Chancellor at the time, requested that the Council members destroy all papers of an incriminating or confidential nature. I utilised the oral testimony of the main, surviving players. Geoffrey Sharp, Cynthia and Arthur Turner and Laurie O’Brien were at the centre of the storm and have kept relevant documents, so their perspectives are fundamental to the account. The version of their adversaries is sadly lacking, with only Donald Horne still alive. The material in the remainder of Crawford’s private collection forms the most important source of my research. I quoted at length from the diaries and extensive correspondence. Biographers prize such sources because, as Janet Malcolm suggests, letters are the ‘conduit of unmediated experience’.18 Max Crawford’s personality and motives emerge from his vivid correspondence, notes and writing; the clarity of his careful and melodic voice is important. The letters from his contemporaries, colleagues and former students provide an added dimension, and I hope the vulnerabilities, humour, grace, loyalty, ambition, bitterness and indecision are apparent in their words. The close and sometimes brittle relationships with former students like Manning Clark emerge clearly in this correspondence. When conducting interviews, I avoided those who have already written at length about Crawford. Instead, I spoke to individuals who have not been involved in retrospectives on the History School and Crawford’s legacy.19 Some of his protégés have been almost hagiographical in their recollections. This is inevitable. Crawford was compassionate and generous towards the young historians he mentored. Some of the women I interviewed, however, were far more critical in their recollections. This book, then, will attempt to reconcile the ‘filial attachment’ felt by many of Crawford’s students with the harsh criticism from those who thought the Melbourne School was too pleased with itself.20 With the exception of Crawford’s last surviving sibling, Ken Crawford, and a brief conversation with his son Ian Crawford, I had not previously interviewed family members for the basis of this work, which was the foundation of my PhD. This is not because I adhere to Janet Malcolm’s belief that ‘relatives are the biographer’s natural enemies’ (although they pose unique challenges),21 but because as stated
Introduction
9
earlier, the purely domestic sphere is not a major aspect of my enquiry. This decision was reversed when I sought copyright permission from Max Crawford’s surviving children, Ian Crawford and Margaret Cheshire. The challenges came to the fore as they attempted to reconcile memories of their father and their contented childhoods with some of the more critical assessments presented in this book. What could be more confronting than reading a stranger’s interpretation of your father or of a marriage? What could be more challenging than considering the contemporary views offered in diaries and letters? Both Ian and Margaret’s perception and understanding enriched the book and gave me an insight that was previously lacking, though Ian Crawford quite rightly conceded that his perspective was as a child. Curiously Crawford’s colleagues and Crawford himself (possibly unwittingly) had presented an occasionally contrasting view of his domestic life. And others who knew Crawford (and there are a multitude of former colleagues and students) have sometimes taken exception to the interpretations that I make and the conclusions that I reach. Crawford’s work has been kept alive in recent publications. The most recent contained the proceedings of a symposium involving thirty of Crawford’s former students. They reflected on his contribution to history in Australia as a teacher, practitioner and the ‘creator’ of the Melbourne School.22 It was a celebration that provoked sharp criticism by some historians who were not present. The Discovery of Australian History 1890-1939 presents the lives of ten historians who pioneered the academic discipline of Australian history and includes essays on Crawford, Jessie Webb and Kathleen Fitzpatrick. On Crawford’s retirement, a special issue of Historical Studies was dedicated to his work and influence. It included the recollections of former students and colleagues, Crawford’s own graceful and reflective article on the ‘School of Prudence’ (which was reprinted) and a survey of the 575 Honours graduates of the Melbourne School of History from 1937 to 1966.23 Making History includes three eloquent essays by Max Crawford, Manning Clark and Geoffrey Blainey on the practice of history.24 While these works are extremely informative, they largely neglect the political dimensions of Crawford’s life. And it is the magnitude and ramifications of intellectual
10
An Historian’s Life
autonomy that is so important in Crawford’s story. There are many accounts of academic freedom, liberalism and intellectuals in America, but a dearth of research on academic freedom in Australia. Fiona Capp’s fascinating account of security surveillance of Australian authors and intellectuals was groundbreaking.25 Yet, while it emphasised the political allegiances and attachments, it tended to neglect the experience of academics, the intellectual concerns and the formative role of universities in Australian public life. There is a growing interest in the history of ASIO. Works include Frank Cain’s The Origins of Political Surveillance in Australia and The Australian Security Intelligence Organization: An Unofficial History;26 Brian Martin’s Intellectual Suppression: Australian Case Histories, Analysis and Responses;27 and in particular, David McKnight’s chapter entitled ‘Trenchcoats and mortarboards’ in his work on ASIO, Australia’s Spies and their Secrets, where he examined academic autonomy in universities.28 Certain controversial episodes have attracted attention. Stuart Macintyre and Anna Clark’s History Wars has explored some of the seminal battles.29 Phillip Deery’s recent exposé of Ian Milner as a Russian spy rather than a Cold War victim is insightful.30 Cassandra Pybus reconsidered the Orr case in Gross Moral Turpitude.31 Peter McPhee’s biography of R.D. ‘Pansy’ Wright,32 and Craig Munro’s profile of Inky Stephensen,33 considered the issue of intellectual autonomy. Humphrey McQueen’s book on the Courier Mail’s posthumous campaign against Manning Clark was astute in parts.34 Russel Ward’s vivid autobiography examined his own devastating experiences.35 However, a fuller analysis of university collusion and ambivalence towards intellectual freedom has yet to be written. Robert Dare has correctly observed that Max Crawford was ‘an unremitting autobiographer’.36 The narrative that he constructed so carefully was indeed meticulous and prophetic. Crawford’s story is characterised by the idea that he embarked on a pilgrimage from humble beginnings to the glories of Oxford, that he progressed from an unknown and unpublished historian to the visionary head of one of Australia’s finest university departments.37 Underpinning these recollections is the constant denial of a political mission and the representation of his political commitments as being secondary and incidental. As Dare observes, any experiences that might threaten the
Introduction
11
‘myth of origin were eased gently into line’ or dismissed completely.38 Most of Crawford’s autobiographical writing was completed after he retired, and it is touched by disillusionment and the desire to avoid political and ideological fervour. Crawford never mentioned the Bulletin debacle, the tragic postscript to his life. Humphrey McQueen maintained that Crawford’s biography of George Arnold Wood was a ‘scarifying’ autobiographical confession and Crawford’s ‘literary mask’.39 Crawford made only one fleeting and somewhat unconvincing reference in his autobiographical writing to the political activity that had absorbed so much of his time and energy. ‘I was commonly considered very radical myself, even rather more radical than I was, much of it being little more than a Balliol-fostered belief that diversity of opinion should be heard’, he wrote somewhat defensively. ‘I often found myself pushed by the circumstances of the late 1930s in particular into uncomfortable stands that were, in the terms of that time, radical.’40 Crawford was here implying that at times he was an unenthusiastic and accidental participant. Tim Rowse has observed that Australian liberal intellectuals derived much of their legitimacy and institutional security from the myth of political independence.41 Crawford perpetuated this myth, but I believe that his insistence on placing himself outside politics sits oddly with his background and early life. Indeed, he attempted to conceal or at least minimise his inheritance. Despite his later denials, his working-class origins and his family’s significant political connections did mould him. This provided a clue as to how to approach Max Crawford, and a place to begin. As Andre Malraux once observed, ‘a man’s first truth is what he hides’.42 Notes 1
David McKnight, Australia’s Spies and their Secrets (Sydney: Allen & Unwin, 1994), 145.
2
Richard Hofstadter, Anti-Intellectualism in American Life (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1974), 38.
3
Geoffrey Serle, ‘R.M. Crawford and his School’, Melbourne Historical Journal No. 9 (1970), 3.
12
An Historian’s Life
4
Tim Rowse, Australian Liberalism and National Character (Melbourne: Kibble Books, 1978), 29.
5
This definition has been taken from Christopher Lasch, The New Radicalism in America. 1889-1963: The Intellectual as a Social Type (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1966), 18, and S. G. Foster and Margaret Varghese, The Making of the Australian National University (Sydney: Allen & Unwin), 114.
6
Stuart Macintyre, ed., Making History: R. M. Crawford, Manning Clark, Geoffrey Blainey (Melbourne: McPhee Gribble/Penguin Books, 1985), 36.
7
Crawford to Vincent Crow, R.M. Crawford Papers, University of Melbourne Archives. Hereafter UMA.
8
Hofstadter, Anti-Intellectualism in American Life, ix.
9
Ibid.
10
Lasch, The New Radicalism in America. 1889-1963, 38-9.
11
Anthony Giddens, Beyond Left and Right: The Future of Radical Politics (London: Blackwell Publishers Ltd., 1998), 1.
12
Rowse, Australian Liberalism and National Character, 192.
13
Giddens, Beyond Left and Right, 2.
14
John Hirst, ‘Conservatism’, in Graeme Davison, John Hirst and Stuart Macintyre, eds., Oxford Companion to Australian History (Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 1999), 149.
15
Richard Holmes, Footsteps: Adventures of a Romantic Biographer (London: Flamingo, 1995), 175.
16
Janet Malcolm, The Silent Woman (London: Pann Macmillan, 1994), 10.
17
Bernard Crick, George Orwell: A Life (Middlesex: Penguin Books, 1980), 31.
18
Malcolm, The Silent Woman, 110.
19
Stuart Macintyre and Peter McPhee, eds., Max Crawford’s School of History (Melbourne: Melbourne University History Department Monograph, 2000).
20
Ibid., 4.
21
Malcolm, The Silent Woman, 10.
22
Macintyre and McPhee, eds. Max Crawford’s School of History. Crawford Special Issue Historical Studies,15, 57, (October 1971).
23 24
Macintyre, ed. Making History.
25
Fiona Capp, Writers Defiled (Melbourne: McPhee Gribble, 1993).
26
F. M. Cain, The Origins of Political Surveillance in Australia (Sydney: Angus and Robertson, 1983) and The Australian Security Intelligence Organization: An Unofficial History (London: Frank Cass, 1994).
27
Brian Martin, Intellectual Suppression: Australian Case Histories, Analysis and Responses (Sydney: Angus and Robertson, 1986).
28
McKnight, Australia’s Spies and their Secrets.
Introduction
13
29
Stuart Macintyre and Anna Clark, History Wars (Melbourne: Melbourne University Publishing, 2004).
30
Phillip Deery, ‘Cold War Victim or Rhodes Scholar Spy: Revisiting the Case of Ian Milner’, Overland 147 (1997), 9-12. See also Humphrey McQueen, Suspect History (South Australia: Wakefield Press, 1997), 57. McQueen contends that ‘left leaning experts remain divided about the issue’.
31
Cassandra Pybus, Gross Moral Turpitude (Melbourne: William Heinemann, 1993).
32
Peter McPhee, Pansy: A Life of Roy Douglas Wright (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 1999).
33
Craig Munro, Inky Stephensen: The Wildman of Letters (St Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 1992).
34
Humphrey McQueen, Suspect History.
35
Russel Ward, A Radical Life: The Autobiography of Russel Ward (Melbourne: Macmillan, 1988).
36
Dare in Macintyre and McPhee, eds., Max Crawford’s School of History, 13.
37
Ibid.
38
Ibid. The obedient narrative includes Crawford’s ‘University Research: History’ in A. Grenfell Price, ed., The Humanities in Australia, A Survey with Special Reference to the Universities (Canberra: Australian Humanities Research Council, 1959); Crawford, Historical Studies, 1971, 27-42; Crawford, in Making History; interview with Max Crawford by Neville Meaney, 3 November 1986, Oral History Collection, National Library of Australia (hereafter NLA); R. M. Crawford ‘My Brother Jack: Background and Early Years’ in L. T. Evans and J. D. B. Miller, eds, Policy and Practice, Essays in Honour of Sir John Crawford (Canberra: ANU Press, 1987); Stuart Macintyre, ed.,, Old Bebb’s Store and Other Poems (Melbourne: The University of Melbourne, 1992).
39
Humphrey McQueen, Gallipoli to Petrov (Sydney: George Allen & Unwin, 1984), 80-1. McQueen is interested in what compelled Crawford to document the ‘unexceptional’ life of Wood.
40
Macintyre, ed., Making History, 35.
41
Rowse, Australian Liberalism and National Character, 23.
42
Andre Malraux, Antimemoirs (Paris: Gallimard, 1967), 1.
14
An Historian’s Life
Chapter 1
Origins and Influences
‘One is all too aware of opportunities of original work missed, of work confidently planned that remains undone, of false leads followed.’1 After a career that spanned thirty-four years as Professor of History at Melbourne University, Max Crawford reflected on his chosen vocation with a mixture of satisfaction and regret. One of the original projects that remained undone was his historical study of contemporary Spain, devised whilst tutoring at Oxford in 1932. The emphasis was to be on the historical roots rather than the political implications of the conflict in that country. This project laid the foundations for his synoptic view of history. Crawford never lived in Spain; this was intended to be a purely intellectual inquiry. Yet he immersed himself in the language, examined the culture and historical events, and read modern Spanish literature to familiarise himself with the prevailing ‘attitudes and temper’.2 Although the project was terminated before it really began, Crawford would always remember its themes and inspiration with pride and sadness. The year 1932 foreshadowed the trajectory of his future scholarship and unpublished work. The excited anticipation of his careful planning would gradually diminish as he struggled to execute the plan. When Crawford was seventeen he imagined a very different
Origins and Influences
15
future. His keen perception of himself as a serious intellectual moved him to prophesise: One day I shall write. What it shall be — drama or poetry or novels I don’t know. But I do know I shall write...I feel it. I feel that I am being carried on the crest of a wave about to break, and when it does break I shall be freed. I shall write.3 Crawford described his inability to express his individuality, but was confident that maturity would liberate and strengthen him. He also hoped to inspire others. This boyish testimony, written during Crawford’s last year at High School, embodied all the determination and ambition of youth. Despite his confidence in his destiny, however, it would take nine years of struggle before he embarked on any writing project of substance. This was neither the great Australian novel, nor the poetry to which Crawford devoted a wavering commitment. Instead, it was the historical study of Spain. His roots and youthful experiences provide some indication of the intellectual he would become and the inconsistent direction his career would take. Crawford was the ninth of twelve children (the second child died in infancy). He was born in 1906 to Henry (who was always known as Harry) and Harriet Crawford and raised in the Sydney suburb of Bexley. He depicted his childhood retrospectively as one of genteel poverty. In reality, his young life was sometimes challenging, disrupted by the First World War, the enlistment of his older brother and uncle, the struggles of his father and the aspirations of his mother. The absence of the impact of the war in Crawford’s childhood recollections is startling. The war destroyed a generation of men and resulted in a break between the post-war survivors and the old men who had sent them to the battlefields of Europe.4 An uncle and elder brother served in Gallipoli and France, and a brother-in-law was one of those shattered ‘vets who took to the drink’.5 Yet Crawford did not mention the loss, the change in social attitudes and values that resulted from the wasteful carnage, nor political reaction against war. It is only in an historical account written for an American audience that he referred to the war in any length, and his style is detached, the meaning vague:
16
An Historian’s Life
I am conscious in my own retrospect of a hiatus: in those years after the war when I was a schoolboy and undergraduate, I can think of only one of my teachers of note who belonged to the generation of soldiers. We were taught by the middle-aged and the aged, and we too much lacked the bridge between of those nearer our own age who might have guided us safely past some of the pits into which we fell.6 The other notable and mystifying autobiographical disparity was Crawford’s recollection that his family was not politically minded. ‘It might seem that radical opinions were my family inheritance’, Crawford observed later in life, ‘in fact I knew little of this until recent years... We lived in a house of books and took study for granted; but I do not recall it as a political household.7 Yet his father, Harry a gentle, sociable man with the ‘soul of a poet’,8 was ‘deeply involved’ in the Railwaymen’s Union for much of his life. Max Crawford’s daughter, Margaret, was told that her grandfather contributed to the union magazine and visited union members all over New South Wales.9 As the eldest of his generation of the family, Harry had supported his younger siblings, much to his wife’s chagrin, and purchased the radical newspaper, Vedette, for his brother James, the family favourite who became a Queensland MP and was drowned in the Clermont floods. Yet the words, ‘that traitor Mannix’, uttered by Crawford’s father, were apparently the only political recollection of his youth.10 Although Crawford could not recall political debate, he would later speculate that the family’s political legacy most profoundly affected his brother Jack. That formative inheritance was a mistrust of politics. His uncles had followed W. A. Holman out of the Labor Party in the wartime split over conscription. One of them, Thomas Crawford, the former Presbyterian Minister in Newcastle and the southern Riverina, had been the Labor MP for Marrickville since 1910. He later stood as a National and lost his seat in the 1917 state elections. In the same year, he was appointed a Crown Prosecutor in New South Wales and, from 1940 until his retirement in 1947, he was Senior Crown Prosecutor. Hence, Crawford emphasised his uncles’ reluctance to bind their consciences to the dictates of one party, and suggested that such
Origins and Influences
17
independence influenced his brother Jack. Later knighted, Jack would become known as one of the ‘seven dwarfs’, one of the top bureaucrats of diminutive size who etched his career in Canberra and became a distinguished public servant, working for both Labor and Liberal-Country Party ministers.11 The family influence was not confined to Jack: Max also refused to bind himself to any party loyalty—or so he maintained. Despite this, the youngest sibling, Ken, claimed that both Jack and Max were habitual Labor voters. Max would later write that he knew nothing of his uncles as MPs or the ‘Vedette venture’.12 If Crawford could not recollect political discussion among his family, he was not unaware of his family’s sentiments or his own views. Despite his protestations, he possessed a strong vision for Australia. He confidently pondered such issues as communism, class, and attitudes towards the British in Germany and France. These were hardly the thoughts of a man who was ‘quite unpolitical’.13 At the same time he insisted that politics ‘bored him’. It was his fascination with Machiavelli that aroused an interest in statecraft, and he took from Machiavelli the moral dilemma inherent in politics that ‘good may be bad and bad good’.14 Crawford also suggested in retrospect that the influences that shaped the careers of his political uncles might have operated ‘subliminally’ in his own parents’ house. He cited a readiness to sympathise with the underdog.15 Convinced that Bexley was the setting of Christina Stead’s classic book, The Man Who Loved Children, Crawford considered the ‘real poverty’ in the Bexley-Rockdale district—the widows and deserted wives with children. He recalled that if you moved further out to Sutherland, the poverty was even more confronting. One of Crawford’s elder sisters would ‘cry her eyes out for the little girls in her class who came to school in winter barefoot and wearing worn out flimsy cotton dresses’.16 Crawford later speculated that they were probably the children of casual and itinerant workers. The humanity that he observed in his siblings was also a trait that was constantly emphasised about Crawford himself. Education was pivotal to Crawford’s childhood. He fulfilled all expectations, excelled without apparent effort at Fort Street High School and distinguished himself at the University of Sydney. He graduated with first-class honours in English and History, one of an
18
An Historian’s Life
emergent class of intellectuals who were highly motivated, upwardly striving children of the lower-middle classes. University study was, among other things, a ladder to higher status and security.17 Academic achievement was to be his escape from the sprawling suburb of Bexley and the life of his close and devout Presbyterian family. Crawford’s success inspired others.18 At Sydney University, Crawford fell under the spell of George Arnold Wood, J. F. Bruce and John Le Gay Brereton. They were an intoxicating combination, and Brereton became the object of Crawford’s unabashed admiration, which he likened to ‘just out and out hero-worshipping’.19 Even with the encouragement of his three mentors to embrace new ideas, he could not break from accepted beliefs and the need for compliance. In a letter written in 1928, when Crawford was attending Oxford, he provided a ‘mental biography’ that reviewed his performance at Sydney. ‘You probably noticed while we were in Arts’, Crawford wrote in a fit of self-criticism, ‘that if the conversation urged towards the controversial in the matter of the living, I either dodged it or asserted the conventional ideas’.20 Crawford also observed that the result of his work at Sydney University was ‘extreme conventionalism in essays and a waste of much mental energy in weaving laborious cobwebs upon the basis of canons tightly held and sheltered from criticism’.21 The self-criticism might have been provoked by his exposure to new ideas and possibilities. His achievement at Sydney suggests he was judging his performance too harshly. Both Le Gay Brereton and Wood left an indelible impression. Brereton inspired Crawford’s interest in fiction, poetry, theatre and drama. A benevolent and perceptive teacher, he recognised his student’s impatience and his ability to understand humanity with sympathy. In an essay for his English lecturer, Crawford insisted that it was only possible to write great literature ‘after a broad and intense experience of mind and the art in the faith of life’.22 Wood, a nonconformist, taught British and European history and emphasised the importance of primary research. The University also exposed Crawford to liberalism, the creed espoused by George Wood and other Sydney intellectuals. Liberalism was a doctrine of freedom - freedom from the tyranny of superstition, tradition, hierarchy and privilege.23 Wood embraced the ‘English ideal’ of liberalism:
Origins and Influences
19
a belief in liberty and a willingness to promote it for the benefit of others.24 Like Crawford, Wood’s philosophical liberalism did not prepare him for the political controversies of the day, and he suffered for opposition to the Australian government’s military action against the Boers.25 Under his tutor’s guidance, Crawford began to consider the importance of experience, liberalism, and ideas. ‘Tomorrow I Sail’ The baptism of experience began on board the S.S. Ormonde on 27 July 1927. After winning the Woolley Scholarship, Crawford accepted a place at Balliol College, Oxford, the alma mater of Wood, who had previously pointed two other protégés, George Henderson and Garnet Portus, in that direction.26 There was an assumption, indeed a conviction that education of real worth had to be undertaken in England. Ensuing ‘accidents of scholarships’ led Crawford to history and away from his favoured subject, literature. Wood predicted that he would do excellent work in Australian history if he found a year to devote to it.27 Sadly, it would be the last time the two men met, as Wood committed suicide the following year. The significance of the decision to leave Australia did not elude the reflective young Crawford, who wrote in his diary with trepidation, ‘Tomorrow I sail and in the future what?’28 The departure was marred by Crawford’s anxiety about his family. In 1925, during his undergraduate years, his father had retired from his beloved position as stationmaster of Grenfell. With an ‘incurable optimism’ and lack of business acumen, Harry Crawford accepted an offer of a partnership in a wood-and-coal business. Plagued by ill health, but still with a large family to support, he was forced to work in a series of menial jobs after the enterprise failed.29 Curiously, Crawford later remembered this selectively and described his father as having a ‘head for figures’.30 Despite familiarity with the struggle involved in raising eleven children, Harry’s difficulties came as a great shock for the family. Oxford was an enormous extravagance that they could ill afford. Crawford was sensitive to the burden he had imposed and hoped he would be able to relieve his father’s financial worry after two years of study.31 Although he did not think of delaying the trip, he did consider Leeds University rather than the more expensive Oxford. Wood
20
An Historian’s Life
persuaded him that Oxford was ‘far better’ and suggested that if the necessity arose, he could utilise the influence of an old college friend at Cambridge.32 Crawford’s feeling of guilt might have been exacerbated by his brother, Jack, who had sacrificed his education for the family’s financial benefit. Only a year before, when Harry Crawford’s ill-conceived venture into the entrepreneurial world began to look precarious, Jack had left high school in the fourth year. He had joined the State Bank and only returned to Sydney High to complete his secondary education when he had earned enough money to pay board to his mother. Later in life, it was Jack who felt great sadness at the memory of his father labouring in the quarry. Sibling rivalry was apparent between the two brothers, close in age and both possessing great potential. The youngest boy in the family, Ken, observed that Jack and Max were not close.33 Max’s son, Ian had a different impression. The brothers shared a bedroom throughout their early life and negotiated separate and acclaimed careers. The perception of competition might have been intensified by the two boys’ very different personalities. Crawford recalled a teacher who, upon watching him walk ahead of his brother Jack, described them as ‘dignity and impudence’. It was an observation that caused some mirth and reflection.34 Crawford clung to his dignity for the rest of his life, and many of his students would recall their professor’s distinctive patrician demeanour. The elitism and formality on board the S.S. Ormonde would prove a stage for Crawford’s private dramas. Shipboard society introduced him to a way of life that, until then, he had only imagined. He was mystified by the company, confused by the ceremony of dinner and distracted by menus and cutlery. Feelings of intimidation, inadequacy and alienation emerged. Having grown up in a family that did not tolerate pomposity or pretension, Crawford found the ‘hideous camouflages of social small talk’ abhorrent.35 His unwelcome exposure to polite society encouraged him to consider the differences between its shallowness and real values. He reported that ‘breeding was more than the ability to read a French menu’; it required ‘honesty and straightforwardness and consideration for others’. This distinction made him appreciate the ‘real kindness of home and Herbert Street and Glenbrook’. Anticipating the
Origins and Influences
21
seduction of affluence, Crawford hoped that he would retain this pride in his origins during his time away. He considered it a test whether he would ‘improve or merely acquire polish to cover degeneracy’.36 As the ship sailed across the Indian Ocean, Crawford navigated his own thoughts about Australian identity, nationalism and Empire. The tensions of belonging and independence, acceptance and rebellion, compromise and contradiction were constantly tested on board. On the second day of the journey, a ‘disgruntled’ English Officer complimented Crawford with the remark that he was the first Australian he had met who did not speak like one. Crawford responded in his diary with characteristic ambivalence, ‘a praiseworthy thing I suppose’.37 Although he recognised the condescension, he listened in tactful silence as the Officer attacked the Australian education system. Crawford was himself capable of snobbery and in a letter to his mother he considered the Englishman’s opinion unacceptable because it was gained from the experiences of a ‘few shop girls’. While he spoke of the varieties and efficiencies of Australian schools, he thought, but did not say: ‘If he can’t realise the differences between an old and new country, let him stay in the comfort of the old’.38 Crawford continued to harbour an ambition to be a writer. The stories he was beginning to formulate reflected his difficulties in attempting to be both socially acceptable and a patriotic champion of Australia. One story was profoundly autobiographical and somewhat prophetic, as it dealt with the tug of loyalties many Australian intellectuals experienced. The outline was as follows: Travelling from a young and raw country like Australia to an old and highly developed country like England, imbued his interest in philosophical and liberal questions. Then he found great difficulty in settling down again in his own native land, where he would not find so much sympathy of interests.39 Crawford portrayed the protagonist faced with the choice between achievement in exile and the love of native ideals and interests, and frustration when he returned home. The Australian scenario
22
An Historian’s Life
was not as hopeless as the hero anticipated. He found ‘real worth behind the lack of European polish and education displayed by Australians’, and eventually found comfort in the ‘circle of liberal minded, educated men’.40 With an odd mix of confidence and defensiveness about Australia, Crawford argued diplomatically with passengers on its behalf, accepting that Australia had not had time to develop ‘the high cultural level and natural philosophies of older countries’. He also insisted that there were ‘men who are doing much to found worthy traditions, and the universities are not the least factor in our cultural progress’.41 The pilgrimage to England provided the impressionable young man with an insight into the imperial system in operation and countless opportunities to challenge and test his compassion with the less fortunate. These sympathies were shaped by Crawford’s fervent Christian ideals. The Church was the focal point of his early life. When he recorded in his diary a discussion on the ‘degeneracy’ of the Aborigines, he pondered issues of creation and evolution, rather than invasion and injustice.42 Despite this strong emphasis on Christian doctrine, compassion was not always evident in Crawford’s youthful responses to life and, at times, he lacked the assurance to speak out against intolerance. He described his encounter with a fellow passenger who had broken the leg of a ‘disobedient’ New Guinea boy. The passenger lectured Crawford on the necessity of ‘unbroken firmness in the management of natives’ and insisted that any ‘display of kindness was regarded as weakness’. Crawford at the callow age of only twenty-one, did not contradict this claim, but wondered if Christian practices and ‘civilised ideals’ might be more successful.43 In Colombo, Crawford showed very little understanding of the poor in the ‘wretched hotels of Singhalese masses’ and was repelled by the lack of comfort and cleanliness. For all the freethinking liberalism he imbibed as an undergraduate, he could not bridge the gulf between his own comfort and the conditions of the poor. ‘Perhaps it is as well for them not to aspire too much. Still, they could live in more clean conditions without extra cost.’44 Crawford was clearly conformist at this stage. News of P. R. Stephensen, a Queensland Rhodes Scholar who was apparently
Origins and Influences
23
spreading Bolshevik doctrine at Oxford, appalled him. He thought it was outrageous that Stephensen had accepted a scholarship to oppose the ideals of Rhodes. ‘If he intends to carry on Bolshevist propaganda,’ he defiantly wrote, ‘he might at least, as a gentleman give up the Rhodes Scholarship’.45 The importance and complexity of academic freedom had not yet occurred to him. Crawford’s rectitude and conventional attitude to women also emerged on the voyage. This provides an insight into the mature liberal who was considered a champion of women. In a time of formality, his experiences were limited. They were confined to social interaction within the church, with his sisters, his fiancé Dorothy Cheetham, whom he described as a ‘little brick’ or ‘sensible’, and his mother. Harriet Crawford’s hold over her son, and the devotion and dependence she inspired, emerges from Crawford’s detailed diary entries, as well as constant correspondence between them. Crawford perceived that he was the ‘chosen one’ of his family. ‘Mum is wonderful—no detail is forgotten.’ He wrote in his diary on the day of his departure. ‘She shows no sign of the struggle I know she is going through. I have always been rather a favorite with her and I know she does not like the idea of my going away.46 The favouritism Crawford claimed was not apparent to the remainder of the family, who were oblivious to their brother’s belief.47 Harriet Crawford encouraged her son and she proclaimed that she would help him with ‘all in my power’.48 Crawford wrote at the time that she had worked ‘like a slave for him’. 49 The Crawford family, like many working and middle-class families, deemed education a social advantage and opportunity for advancement. Ken Crawford thought that a university education was restricted to the younger three boys, and the prospects for his five sisters were very different.50 Margaret Cheshire, however, contradicted this and believed that both her grandparent’s were dedicated to the idea of education and in fact all the daughters were given the opportunity to train in their chosen vocation. Lillian became a piano teacher, having studied as the Sydney Conservatorium where she was told that her hands were too small for her to become a concert pianist, Gladys became a dressmaker, Marjorie a bookmaker and both Rene and Grace were schoolteachers.51 In his youthful naivety, when categorising women, Crawford would veer between decent and good to loose and bad. His
24
An Historian’s Life
description of a young woman he had met in Melbourne was a demonstration of moralism and inexperience. She was ‘a true hearted, enthusiastic little girl and a good companion’, he wrote in his diary. ‘After all she will gain more happiness of life than the jazziest, most cocktail-saturated, most stale-tobacco intoxicated ennued hangeron.’ He did attempt to temper this simplistic outburst when he admitted that this was an individual preference and there was room for all sorts—‘although I know which one I prefer’.52 His ideals of love were inevitably immature and simplistic. In a planned story, he defined real love as ‘unselfish and moral’, and false love as ‘selfish lust and a slander to the pure nature of love’.53 He did not hold to a rigid Calvinist morality, but to a New Testament theology of redemption and love. As an undergraduate, his liberalism was not inconsistent with his religious beliefs. Both proclaimed similar values: morality, equality, and justice. Crawford’s faith would diminish with experience and the new influences he was exposed to at Oxford. His spiritual life was eroded by a growing conviction that the secular creed of liberalism was better able to explain the changing world. ‘The theology of original sin that protected society’, he wrote with sadness, ‘gave us little forewarning of the faces of evil as it really existed in the world we lived in; nor did it show us the true hell manufactured by human beings for themselves’.54 Politics, Empire and Liberalism After his long journey, Crawford arrived in London in September 1927, intensely lonely, homesick and preoccupied with money. He regretted that he had left home so early, because of the enormous expense his Oxford studies required. In the first few weeks, he searched for comforting reminders of home to ease his feelings of isolation and disorientation. So he was delighted while visiting Kew Gardens to smell the scent of gums reminiscent of the Blue Mountains. On a mission to Bexley in Kent, he gave the Headmaster of the local school ‘the best wishes of the Bexley Public School’ in Australia.55 Crawford was slowly seduced by the history and tradition of England. His exploration of London confirmed the superiority of the Empire and heartened him as he could feel ‘the fascination taking hold’.56 He visited the Tower of London and pondered issues of
Origins and Influences
25
punishment and the progress of humanity, yet concluded that ‘the empires are the stepping stones towards the protection of human government’.57 Within two weeks of arrival, he wrote to his mother: ‘I wouldn’t have missed this for the world’.58 By October, Crawford was happily installed at Balliol. After a disappointing first impression, he was captivated by the orderly gardens, imposing buildings and formal silver service meals consumed in the oak-panelled dining hall. He expected the prestigious College would provide intellectual debate and lively talk, ranging from Gandhi to the ‘latest English eccentrics’. Oxford did indeed attract literary and intellectual figures during the 1920s, its luminaries including Wystan Auden, Harold Acton, Claud Cockburn, and Evelyn Waugh. Crawford told his father that he looked forward to ‘getting in touch with what was happening in Spain, Germany, Manchuria and so on’.59 This indication of his intellectual and political interest and his expectations of Oxford is important. The University always symbolised status and security. He was convinced and reassured his father that after his degree he would effortlessly find a job.60 Oxford had been a magnet for young Australian scholars since the early twentieth century. Under the aegis of its Master, Dr Benjamin Jowett, Balliol established a reputation for providing leaders of church and state for Britain and the Empire.61 Australian students had acquired a reputation for irreverence and one of them recalled how they ‘blew into the antiquity of Oxford with the challenge of their own and country’s youth’.62 Indeed, Balliol attracted some of Australia’s more progressive historians, including George Henderson and later Keith Hancock, who paved the way for the new generation of Australian historians, such as Esmonde Higgins, P. R. Stephensen and Herbert Burton, all of whom were politically engaged at Oxford. With great ‘alertness’, Crawford started work with his college tutors, Humphrey Sumner, A. D. Lindsay, Kenneth Bell and C. G. Stone. He wrote home with unbounded admiration for Bell, ‘one of the best tutors in Oxford’, and with humour about Stone, whom he found disconcerting with his speech impediment, deafness and idiosyncratic mannerisms.63 The young student quickly discovered that he was benefiting more from Oxford than he ever had at Sydney, and doing two to three times as much work with half the effort.64 He worked with Bell on a modern history syllabus, read English
26
An Historian’s Life
constitutional and political history, political theory and the American Revolution. Such intense productivity led A. D. Lindsay to express concern that he would ‘break under the pressure’.65 Instrumental in Crawford’s unrelenting drive was his desire to remain at Balliol for an additional year. It was Kenneth Bell, ‘vague, kind and inviting’,66 who became the new figure for Crawford’s pedestal. A brilliant teacher, eccentric, father of eight children and author of no books, Bell was a tireless advocate for his students.67 He felt that Crawford could do more if he remained at Oxford for another year. Bell wrote to Harry Crawford expressing this strong opinion and arranged with the Rhodes Trust to award Crawford a half-scholarship for the third year, and cajoled him to borrow the remainder. Harry Crawford was in an unenviable position and might have felt there was no alternative but to comply. Crawford informed his mother that he wanted to stay at Balliol, but also wanted to return to Sydney and do his ‘bit’ for his struggling family.68 As the economy deteriorated, Harry Crawford’s fortunes improved only slightly. The railways had re-employed him as a temporary timekeeper, and he supplemented the small income with various jobs as a rate collector and timekeeper in a railway quarry. Through comradeship and personal pride, he joined in the hard labour with the quarry workers. In a curious letter, Crawford with newly found assurance, almost assumed the paternal role, expressing his gratitude for his father’s ‘brave game’. He noted that by Harry ‘hanging on’, he would be able to remain at Oxford instead of seeking employment straight away. Under the circumstances, it was an insensitive comment. Crawford was confident that within two years he should be earning ‘something considerable’.69 His laboured insistence that he wished to return home was not entirely convincing. Crawford would later acknowledge the influence of Oxford. He had gone to England ‘an immature and naive youngster and matured rapidly’.70 The metamorphosis did not take place with the ease that he later suggested. He succumbed to periodic fits of self-doubt and moments of intense guilt about his family. In a letter to a friend during the first year, Crawford articulated these difficulties, as well as his transformation. Now free of the home environment and the force of attitudes instilled in him as a young boy, Crawford believed he was no ‘longer afraid of the consequences of ruthless thinking’.71
Origins and Influences
27
Politics, the Empire and liberalism became even more significant themes in Crawford’s intellectual and social activity at Oxford. The liberalism that had influenced him at Sydney was refined by the more patrician tradition at Balliol. The majority of students enjoyed great affluence, clung to tradition and Empire, and espoused egalitarian and liberal views. The 1920s was a turbulent decade at Oxford, as the limits of free speech and censorship were tested. In 1923, the Vice-Chancellor, Dr Lewis Farnell, a renowned political reactionary, banned a public lecture by Marie Stopes on the subject of birth control. According to J. C. Masterman, Farnell was firmly convinced that ‘the University was threatened by a subversive spirit among the young which it was his mission to suppress’.72 In reality, political activity did not attract large numbers of students. Wystan Auden provided a telling commentary on the ‘frivolous’ Oxford he remembered. ‘Looking back now, I find it incredible how secure life seemed.’ Auden wrote. ‘Revolution in Russia, inflation in Germany and Austria, Fascism in Italy, whatever fears or hopes they may have aroused in our elders, went unnoticed by us. Before 1930, I never opened a newspaper.73 Crawford’s liberalism was a cultural commitment rather than a call to overt political action. In 1928, he was elected to the Ralegh, ‘one of the University’s biggest political clubs composed of men from the colonies of the Empire’. With William Muir and other liberals, he formed a Synoptic Club.74 His political activity did not extend to the Labour Club, which was the most active and radical of the four political clubs at Oxford, or to participation in the demonstrations that had so offended Farnell. Oxford was also a cultural and social experience, a lifestyle in which to widen horizons, cultivate friendships and gain confidence. Initially England had disquieted and intimidated the young Australian, who was alone and unfamiliar with the social conventions and etiquette it demanded. Lady Francis Ryder, who welcomed ‘men and girls from the Dominions who came to her with a private introduction’, arranged for Crawford to be presented to society.75 He was rather bemused by this blatant form of elitism. He decided to accept the invitation. ‘I must admit I am a bit puzzled how to write to a real, live lady but I am going to chance. Crawford wrote to his family with humour and barely concealed pleasure, ‘“Dear Lady Ryder.” I can see I’ll have to go in for spats and an accent.’76
28
An Historian’s Life
After meeting Lady Ryder, Crawford considered her ‘nice’ and not in the least condescending. The amenities of privileged society overcame his suspicion. His letters describe with pride a visit to the House of Commons arranged by Lady Ryder. Although Crawford perceived that these social events were ‘more trial than pleasure’, he happily examined his performance and the impression he gave: ‘I think I really shone this afternoon’.77 In contrast, Manning Clark, who retraced his teacher’s journey to Balliol, eschewed the charms of the indomitable Lady Ryder. He found her ‘course for colonials’ objectionable and declined the experience.78 Clark, never an obsequious anglophile, was offended that Australians were considered in need of polish.79 Such insight, however, was observed with the benefit of hindsight. Crawford was uneasy and less confident of his Australian identity, perhaps because it betrayed the working-class roots he appeared uncomfortable with, and perhaps also because he wished at all costs to avoid the charge of parochialism. Establishing friendships was difficult initially for the young and earnest Australian. It took several months before he felt accepted. Analysing the motives, he informed his mother: ‘I seem to be making friends on every side now. England is like that. People put you on probation for three to four months and then either accept you or reject you.’ Crawford in no way condemned this selective process, and echoed the benefits of aloofness: ‘It sorts one from many rather irksome acquaintances’.80 Whereas Crawford did not challenge or question the conventions and motivations, Keith Hancock remarked that the English cliquishness, accent and style were intended to make the colonials ill at ease.81 Liberal he may have been, but this in no way mitigated Crawford’s emerging prejudices. He described in apparent disbelief an Australian schoolteacher he met ‘who had the worst accent I have ever heard on an Australian’. Tempering this, he admitted on reflection and somewhat patronisingly that the man ‘turned out to be a very decent chap’.82 Crawford also began to accept the British class system. During a holiday to Somerset with a group of Oxford friends, Crawford wrote with acquired formality that they had ‘a man here—Jenkins by name’. Whilst describing his servile and demanding duties, he concluded with an offhanded pragmatism, ‘probably this job is a way out of unemployment’.83
Origins and Influences
29
Crawford was widening his social circle, yet intimate friendships were select and included only the affable and good-natured William Muir, Christopher Hill and William Enthwistle. He was single-minded with his time and never ambitiously networked with the in-crowd or indulged in carousing. Travel on the continent was an important component of Crawford’s cultural education and he visited Brittany, Vienna and Italy and stayed with a family in Germany for a month. Many of the experiences in these foreign places were clumsily recreated in his attempts at writing fiction. He failed to capture the atmosphere and personalities. Except for a brief mention in his diary of Mussolini’s Blackshirts and an Italian’s admiration for Il Duce’s ‘firmness’, Crawford seemed unaffected by and apathetic about continental politics. There is no mention of Germany, the discontent with the Weimar Republic, mounting unemployment, left-wing activism or bans on public demonstrations. One recurring issue plagued Crawford’s last two years at Oxford: the continual wavering about the direction of his career. Kenneth Bell proved an enthusiastic and resourceful adviser, and suggested the British Colonial Service. This was an idea that apparently surprised Crawford, who still nursed feelings of social inadequacy and believed the Diplomatic Corps was confined to ‘chaps with the influence of family and wealth behind them’.84 Moreover, he was unenthusiastic about working in Africa or India and preferred to ‘keep to the academic line’.85 In reality, an academic career was an elusive ambition in the 1930s, as the Australian universities could only employ a limited number of practitioners.86 Crawford expressed concern about his weakness and susceptibility in dealing with Kenneth Bell, ‘a man of strong personality and also a strong politically minded Englishman’. He apparently feared that Bell would influence him against his ‘bent towards a political or rather administrative life’. There was actually no danger of this. Barely six months later, after Crawford declared he wanted to find an academic job, he informed his mother: ‘I do feel a strong inclination towards administrative work of some kind...Certainly more than towards academic work.’87 Despite his failure to resolve the problem and his evident confusion about it, the last term at Balliol was happy. He had become
30
An Historian’s Life
comfortable with its privileges and lifestyle. The awkward boy intimidated by the conventions during dinner on the ship had vanished and in his place was a confident young man who adopted ‘a real Oxford accent’.88 As Crawford negotiated an identity that reconciled both an Australian and a British persona, he became the quintessential Oxford man: urbane, polished and confident. As he anticipated in a letter to his family, this was a busy period of study, punting on the river, tutoring, problems to be settled, Gilbert and Sullivan, tennis, walks and club meetings. ‘There ain’t much time, but life’s not arf bad’, he quipped.89 Crawford’s Balliol education ended in 1930 with first-class honours and the Kingston Oliphant Prize, a Balliol prize for an essay on an historical subject. He had fulfilled his academic promise. His ambition to win prizes and scholarships, reiterated by Harriet Crawford, was now accomplished. Thoughts turned to home: the constant promises to his family and the commitment imparted to Dorothy needed to be fulfilled. Still clinging to the ambition of becoming a creative writer, a hope undiminished by his lack of productivity, Crawford devised a new story, with all the enthusiasm of those previously planned. ‘It had an Australian theme’, he wrote to his father, ‘based on the three generations of his parent’s family – ‘a sort of a Forsyth saga’.90 Exile The return to Sydney proved a bitter disappointment. After the stimulation and prestige of Oxford, Crawford could only describe the return as an ‘exile’.91 The belief that ‘a Balliol man could always get a job at Balliol’s recommendation’ proved false at this time of severe depression.92 Crawford’s promise and impressive academic results did not guarantee him an academic post or even well-paid employment in a position with influence. Instead, he found himself teaching at Petersham Girls’ High School and later Sydney Grammar School, starved of intellectual stimulation and teaching history that was ‘narrowly political, very dry and quite superficial’.93 The only glimmer of hope was a weekly broadcast for the Australian Broadcasting Commission. Formed in 1932, the ABC played a unique role in expounding Australian themes and culture. Its policy was stringent, and it was prevented from broadcasting controversial
Origins and Influences
31
opinion.94 Crawford, who was appropriately neutral, enjoyed the work as it accorded him a public role. He began to consider a university career and applied for academic posts—a readership in History in Hong Kong and the chair of English at Canterbury College in New Zealand. The school-teaching provided a ‘negative spur’ to the intellectual style of history he would later develop. It also encouraged the disillusioned teacher to return to the country where he was happiest and most focused. In September 1932, Crawford travelled back to England to relieve Kenneth Bell during the Michaelmas term at Balliol College. It had been an irresistible offer and apparently represented a career move made ‘at great risk in these years of depression’.95 The risk was not as perilous as Crawford suggested, because his Australian position was no more secure. Almost immediately after he married Dorothy Cheetham, his weekly broadcasting came to an end, and two salary cuts followed in quick succession at Sydney Grammar. Crawford wrote to Bell in despair, inquiring about available positions at Oxford. He received an encouraging response: ‘So I sold my furniture, chucked my job and booked a passage in a boat full of syphilitic deportees.’96 ‘Spain Indeed’ Several months after Crawford’s return, William Muir wrote to his friend: ‘Spain indeed. My God, and at Christmas too!’97 It was a jovial letter, written to confirm details of their intended holiday together. Despite the frivolity, it is the first indication of Crawford’s interest in writing about modern Spain. He had evidently been uncertain about the project, because Muir appeared surprised and bewildered: ‘work on Spain? Spain?’ From these apparently vague plans, Crawford applied to the Rockefeller Fellowship Advisory Committee for financial support. At the time of the application in January 1933, he had developed his proposal with the approval of A. D. Lindsay and Humphrey Sumner. He had written enthusiastically to Oxford friends for guidance, including William Entwhistle, who was familiar with the procedure. Entwhistle suggested potential advisers and cited the Junta de Ampliacon de Estudios, a body responsible for research and assisting foreigners.98 Crawford’s timing was impeccable. Events in Spain were exciting public interest as the country embarked upon far-reaching changes.
32
An Historian’s Life
After years of military dictatorship, elections in April 1931 produced a majority for the progressive parties. For the first time, Spain granted its citizens democratic rights, including freedom of opinion, organisation and religion. The swing to the left under Azana lasted until his defeat in the elections of November 1933.99 Crawford’s proposed research plan, still in its infancy, was repetitive in structure. He considered ‘Spain first as a good subject matter’ in which to work out his ideas about ‘historical determinism’.100 The study he envisaged was not confined to conventional narrative, the standard method of establishing events exactly as they occurred, according to Von Ranke’s dictum. Instead, Crawford intended to approach the democratic and social changes in Spain by concentrating on themes of economy, geography, demography and urban migration. The intended project was a departure from Crawford’s previous academic work. It indicated his maturing ideas about the role of history and morality and the evolving conviction that the study of history should be relevant to contemporary events. The tutoring at Oxford came to an end in November. Crawford was disheartened. It appears he had hoped the position would be extended. Jack Crawford, the boldest and most outspoken of the siblings, considered that Kenneth Bell had misled his brother.101 Seemingly drifting, Crawford accepted a temporary position at Christ’s Hospital. School-teaching proved trying. In a letter to his mother, he wrote about the experience with philosophical resignation levelled by a grudging recognition of its worth. There was a positive outcome. ‘The changing about from school to school has given me a great deal of useful experience, despite the disadvantage that it was accompanied by some unpleasant uncertainty.’ Crawford wrote pragmatically. ‘I have had more chance to try out and pick up ideas in these two terms than I ever had at Sydney Grammar.’102 Crawford’s growing attention to the history of ideas was also a legacy of his teaching in Australian and English schools. ‘The demand that history should illuminate’, Crawford remarked, ‘was probably reinforced against the narrowness and aridity of the political and military narrative that I found to pass for history.’103 Crawford’s conceived ‘plan of attack’ for the project on Spain, set down in a notebook, indicated his evolving ideas. He began to develop
Origins and Influences
33
the study beyond the brief structure devised in the application to the Rockefeller Committee. Influenced most profoundly by the intellectual Mandariago, Crawford considered themes of national character in Spanish society, writing and art from the past and present. Despite this innovative methodology, Crawford found the slow response from the Rockefeller Committee frustrating. William Muir inquired about the ‘Spanish enterprise’, but could only guess at the outcome: ‘no initiative’, ‘red tape’.104 In April 1933, with his wife still in Australia and with an infant son Michael, who he had not yet met, Crawford applied for the position of librarian at Adelaide University. Harriet Crawford expressed great concern about the welfare of his wife and Michael and imparted some well-intentioned advice on her son, writing constantly to him about his career. ‘It certainly would be hard to decide between that and the Spanish project, if both were decided in your favour,’ Harriet Crawford counselled in one letter, ‘but I certainly think Adelaide would be the wiser choice and especially as you have Dor and Michael to consider as well as yourself.’105 Even the normally restrained Harry Crawford expressed reservations about the Spanish project.106 Crawford could barely conceal his mounting frustration and fatigue; he was ‘doing the work of a man and a half and feeling rather fed up’.107 He was also concerned about his domestic situation. A proud and chivalrous man, he was ashamed that he could not provide for his young family. The exchanges between Dorothy and Crawford suggest affection, but also unease. Dorothy was preoccupied by their ‘not very bright future’.108 This was understandable. As their daughter, Margaret observed, Crawford had been overseas for three years during his prolonged engagement with Dorothy, briefly reunited after their marriage in January 1933, and then separated again when Crawford returned to Oxford. Dorothy was then expected to travel alone with an infant to England.109 Harriet Crawford exacerbated the existing strains. With characteristic humour, Jack observed that their mother, left with three unmarried daughters, of ‘whom none are too amiable as living companions’, was ‘depleted’ without her boys.110 Harriet was frantic about her sons’ prospects and was tireless in her attempts to guide them. She was particularly vigilant for her absent son. To curb his enthusiasm for study and travel, she offered sobering reminders of his
34
An Historian’s Life
duties as a husband and father. Harriet Crawford did not want to encourage ‘the adventurous streak’ that Kenneth Bell considered such a quality.111 ‘I hope you have something definite in view for the future before this reaches you’. Harriet wrote, ignoring or unaware of her son’s desire to avoid school-teaching. ‘Failing something decent over there, I wonder would the Grammar position (in Sydney) be available’.112 Her greatest priority was to see Crawford and Jack both together in Sydney: ‘That would be too great a joy’.113 The lack of confidence in their son’s research and academic prospects was logical. Crawford’s family continued to struggle in his absence. Harry Crawford, at 69, continued to work in the Grenfell quarry, which Jack Crawford described as a ‘bitter experience’.114 Crawford’s sister, Rene, an able and intelligent teacher at an Aboriginal mission, endured an ugly and public divorce, caused by the desertion of her husband. Harriet wrote in distress and anger about the proceedings, Rene’s indecision and how the ‘big man’ attended court with his ‘lady friend’. It was a painful and humiliating episode for Rene, left with the responsibilities of raising her children alone.115 The problems of the Crawford family and the difficulties Max Crawford endured while establishing his career in no way radicalised him. Nor was his situation unique. The Depression denied him and his peers the security and status that higher education had once guaranteed. This deprivation caused many intellectuals to be increasingly drawn to the left in politics. Although frustrated, Crawford never expressed anger about his plight, nor did he become antagonistic towards the capitalist system. Later in his career, he examined the legacy of the Depression in his most autobiographical lecture, ‘The Coming of Age’. He saw its significance in terms of ideological and social consequences: the backwardness of social legislation, the disappearance of the previous decade’s optimism and the new influence of economic and political doctrine. The most moving part of the narrative was his brief analysis of the people who suffered: those unaccustomed to such distress who wearily and unsuccessfully sought work and were thrown back on the dole, waiting for relief work. Perhaps in a cryptic tribute to his father, he wrote that ‘adversity calls out greatness’.116 Crawford was hardly a neutral observer in an ivory tower, yet the immediate effect of the Depression on his brother Jack was
Origins and Influences
35
apparently far more profound. Curiously Max seemed more inclined to discuss the impact of the trauma on Jack’s life than on his own. According to Crawford, it left ‘an endurable mark’ on Jack who was devastated by their father’s hardship and his own twelve months of unemployment in 1932. Crawford also observed that his brother’s social conscience strengthened his interest in economics and would eventually lead to his distinguished career.117 The Depression provided intellectuals such as Jack and Brian Fitzpatrick with an impetus for humanitarian empathy. For Max Crawford it also apparently left a thwarted ambition and a fear of what could be lost. While Crawford lived his quiet life as a struggling schoolteacher in England, unemployment reached its highest point in mid-1932. Hunger marchers converged on London, and Oswald Mosley formed his infamous British Union of Fascists. Such distress and rancour found little recognition from Crawford. Nor did Hitler’s ascension as Chancellor of Germany, the nightmare of the Reichstag fire and the beginning of persecution of the Jews and Communists. Unlike many of his contemporaries, he remained surprisingly disengaged from the social and political turmoil of the times.118 In May 1933, after months of anxiety, Crawford was finally offered a permanent teaching job at Bradfield College in Berkshire. The school provided him with his first taste of professional security, but came at the expense of his study of Spain. As the obedient son, he might have felt he had no other option but to choose the safer alternative. He accepted Bradfield College’s offer. The decision delighted his mother: ‘How very pleased I was to hear you have a permanent position at Bradfield’.119 If Christ’s Hospital was an aggravation, Bradfield would be remembered with gratitude. Reunited with his wife and son, Crawford settled happily into the role of history master, and Dorothy into a comfortable anonymity. This time of domestic stability allowed him to explore issues of national character and other historical themes. Bradfield is a school of wealth, privilege and social advantages and afforded Crawford an insight into the nuances of England’s upper class. In contrast to Christ’s Hospital, with its egalitarian and democratic principles, Bradfield was a bastion of the Empire. Clearly fascinated, Crawford began to reconsider his anglophile views. He now regarded the English public school system, with its over-anxiety that
36
An Historian’s Life
the boys should not have any feelings of inferiority, as a social mistake. He insisted that the English were at a disadvantage because they became ‘exaggerated products of the system’, while the Australian boys more easily rejected narrow attitudes.120 Crawford’s exploration of the thematic and historical relevance of Spain continued. When the College performed Aeschylus’ tragedy, Agamemnon, he considered its central themes of vengeance and destiny as being paralleled in Spain. The earlier strain of overwork in temporary jobs, however, and the pressure from home had weakened his resolve, so he abandoned the research project before the Rockefeller Committee delivered its final decision. While declaring his exasperation at the Committee’s delay, he decided he ‘could hardly accept’ a scholarship now that he had arranged to go to Bradfield.121 In a letter applying for the position as tutor to Stephen Roberts at Sydney University in 1935, Crawford offered a slightly altered version of events. He suggested that despite its approval of the work, the Rockefeller Fellowship Committee did not offer support for the project, so he abandoned it.122 Later still, in a letter to the Registrar at the University of Melbourne, he continued to place great importance on the aborted study: While I was still in England I planned a monograph on Modern Spain and I began preparation for this. Owing to the difficulties of distance and material, I have had to modify the original scheme of work.123 Whatever the circumstances, Crawford’s response to the termination of the study remained ambiguous. In 1984 he recalled that although he never completed his ‘serious’ project in 1932, it ‘did set my feet on what I believe was the proper path for me if only I had known how to follow it’.124 He did not elaborate on this comment, and it could be interpreted that he regretted the road he took. He always insisted that his vocation as a teacher was followed at the expense of published historical work based on original research. The Return of the Native By 1935 after two years at Bradfield College, Crawford wanted to return home. He applied unsuccessfully for positions in the
Origins and Influences
37
Max Crawford (front left) on his return home Photographer unknown University of Melbourne Archives, R.M. Crawford papers.
38
An Historian’s Life
Commonwealth public service and the librarianship and chair of history at Adelaide University. The Chair had recently been vacated by Keith Hancock who, feeling like a ‘deserter’, had left for an academic career at Birmingham University.125 Jack Crawford, who was a tutor at Sydney University, had informed his brother of Hancock’s departure and assumed that Fred Wood, the son of Crawford’s mentor, George Wood, might be a successful applicant—which would mean a vacancy at Sydney. Jack Crawford’s prediction proved inaccurate, but a temporary position for a lecturer at Sydney University did become available in May 1935, when Wood left for New Zealand. With Crawford’s Balliol connections and his irregular but varied employment record, as well as Jack as a persuasive intermediary, his application was successful. Once in the position, Crawford was fortunate to work with Stephen Roberts, the Professor of Modern History and one of the most influential academic historians of the period. Roberts created a ‘striking’ curriculum at Sydney, established the graduate program and began a new research-based honours degree.126 In contrast to his mood five years before, this second return home was happy. Crawford recalled in a poignant letter to his mother in 1940 that his homecoming was joyful. He had shed the shyness and awkwardness that marred his early career and was ‘a contented Australian’.127 Though he liked to think of himself as Australian, he had become a graceful, confident man who had adopted the refinement and style of Britain. His voice was distinct and melodic, and most recalled his patrician and even precious demeanour.128 Crawford formed a group of friends at Sydney that included economists and anthropologists, whom he found a constant source of stimulation. This was a time of renewed intellectual discovery reminiscent of Balliol. The unconventional and formidable philosopher and controversialist, John Anderson, became one of his regular Wednesday dinner companions. The balance of his intellectual friendships shifted, now that he was a colleague rather than a student. Although he respected Anderson, it was a more equal relationship, and Crawford was not susceptible to the charisma or intense discipleship that Anderson encouraged.129 He felt an affinity with him, as they shared similar views on Faculty matters and academic autonomy. But Crawford later admitted that a gulf lay between their
Origins and Influences
39
personalities; Anderson was a man of absolutes, who opposed all forms of censorship, while Crawford apparently still retained his ‘instinct for compromise’.130 Although invigorated, Crawford was also confronted by the daily pressures of academic life: the burden of teaching and the pressure to produce original research work. His relationship with Roberts was uneasy, partly because of the latter’s superior manner and partly because Crawford felt that he was being exploited and treated as a subordinate. Personalities aside (and, by all accounts, Roberts was an exacting man), he was living the very life Crawford craved. In 1936 Roberts spent his sabbatical in Germany doing research for what would become The House that Hitler Built. It was an historical and contemporary account, written primarily ‘for the man-inthe-street who wishes to have some idea of the German experiment’.131 It was also the first major contemporary work to expose Nazism in the time of appeasement.132 The Bulletin began its political campaign against Roberts. The implications of the book’s enormous commercial success, and its ensuing vilification by the right-wing press, would not have been lost on Crawford. The Roberts family decamped from a modest bungalow in Gordon to a spacious harbour home in fashionable Point Piper. Lady Roberts would often quip to guests that it ‘really was the house that Hitler built!’133 In response to academic expectations and international events, Crawford wrote two articles, one on the crisis in Abyssinia and the other on Spain. Both were pivotal to his development as an active liberal engaged in public debate. Vital questions remain about his sudden productivity and the reasons for his compulsion to write about contemporary issues. He might have felt that, with his new appointment, he enjoyed a greater authority to comment. He might also have assumed a more visible public role because he could no longer ignore the political situation in Europe.134 On 18 July 1935, Crawford delivered an address on the Abyssinian situation at a meeting organised by the Joint Committee for Peace.135 The crisis in Abyssinia had enduring ramifications far beyond Italy’s invasion and eventual victory. ‘The dispute is of international importance’, Crawford observed, ‘not simply because of the important appeal to the League of Nations but because of the individual interests of various nationalities in Abyssinia’.136
40
An Historian’s Life
Crawford was not the only Australian writing about an approaching war. The literary critic, Nettie Palmer, who was living in Europe at the time, experienced the events at a perilously close range. Her writing was deeply personal as she described the peculiar ambience of hope, confusion, denial and speculation that characterised life in a country preparing for war. ‘The first blows in the Abyssinia War have been struck,’ Palmer claimed. I’m not sure... that most people grasp the fact, there has been so many months of what seemed like hesitation since we saw these shiploads of young Italians.’137 Crawford also presented his address when events were clouded in political and bureaucratic confusion. He wrote with detached authority and insight, and considered the wider issues: Italy’s intentions, the economic consequence of waging war, and the interest of other nations. What was lacking was the chaotic confusion and foreboding of fascism that dominated Palmer’s prose. Crawford may have briefly described the ‘irrational emotional enthusiasm, a nationalistic fervour reluctant to count the cost or take a realistic view of the situation’. But he underestimated the essence of fascism and the most basic implications of both Mussolini and Hitler. Civil War Within a year, Crawford’s attention was drawn back to events in Spain. Early in May 1936, the Popular Front of the left (made up of Republicans, Socialists, Anarchists and Communists) won a majority in the national elections. The Spanish electorate rejected dictatorship, the church and the monarchy. On 17 July, the Spanish generals rebelled, and the right decided to overthrow the elected Government. The country erupted in a prolonged and bitter civil war. Germany and Italy assisted Franco, while England and France adopted a non-interventionist policy, and Russia’s support for the republicans remained ambiguous. Crawford’s fascination with Spain was by no means unusual. Christopher Hollis, an Oxford contemporary, defined the common interest as a ‘streak of Hispanidad’ that one found in Englishmen like Walter Starkie, Gerald Brenan and Wyndham Lewis.138 The Spanish Civil War would be the great cause that captured the imagination and conscience of a literary and intellectual generation, both prominent
Origins and Influences
41
and obscure, idealistic and cynical, of the right and the left. It provoked clichés of good and evil that fell easily into the two distinct ideological sides. As Cecil Day Lewis famously wrote, it appeared to be ‘the battle between light and darkness’. The historian Dante A. Puzzo attributed the impact of the war to its curious ‘purity’, despite the violence and corruption. ‘The enthusiasm it engendered was a springtime that briefly loosened the wintry grip of a world old, weary and cynical.’139 The Spanish war raised acutely the problem of political commitment for the intelligentsia. It offered a choice of alienation or involvement. Crawford remained a dispassionate observer, in contrast to the exuberant participation exhibited by those who joined the International Brigades to fight Franco. As a family man, such military service was hardly feasible but, even so, his level of engagement was never comparable to Nettie Palmer’s frenetic activities. When she returned from Europe, she embarked on a constant round of talks and addresses. Palmer was also instrumental in forming the Spanish Relief Committee. Crawford was never a member of the Committee and, although he collected its publications and social invitations, it is difficult to discern if this was for research purposes or if he was responding on a political and humanitarian level. In their correspondence, Crawford and Palmer remained on formal terms that suggest their relationship did not extend beyond the level of acquaintances. However, Crawford did correspond with both Nettie and Vance Palmer about intellectual issues and research. In 1939 the latter drew his attention to Aurousseau’s book, Highway into Spain. As late as 1942, Nettie Palmer was recommending Oriollo y Pollardo to Crawford because he was ‘always astonishingly clear’.140 Intense political activism was a risk for a man still establishing an academic career. By November 1935, the relatively inexperienced university lecturer found himself running the Department when Stephen Roberts departed for Germany. Despite this added burden, Crawford’s teaching allowed him to expand on the theme born in his early Spanish studies. In a general history tutorial paper presented in the following year and entitled, ‘The Decline of Spain’, his aim was to ‘see how far one can go in explaining Spain by examining the external conditioning’. The past, Crawford insisted, was fundamental to Spain’s
42
An Historian’s Life
position on 11 June 1936; the main moments of its history and nature were a legacy of its experience. He enlisted Mandariago’s argument that as a ‘further element into which the Spaniard is born we must take into account his history’. The University Extension Board allowed Crawford an opportunity to elaborate on these themes in a series of external lectures to secondary schools. Crawford sought ‘to readdress the writing of Spanish history’. He extended the original premise examined in the aborted project of 1932 and analysed Spain’s decline: its military, political decadence, economy and intellectual stagnation. Crawford argued that while Mandariago ‘treated the individual and universalism as something deep rooted in Spanish character’, he professed it was also possible to regard it as ‘a natural product of their history and environment’.141 In all Crawford’s writing, there is an awareness of the continuity of history. He was motivated by themes pursued in books and research rather than personal experience. After his retirement he would ponder the historian’s role and the legacy of his Spanish studies. ‘They underlined the historian’s fruitful role, if it needed underlying’, he wrote ‘as being the illumination, by means of accurate and percipient charting, both of situation and response, of the drama of necessity and freedom. So might chaos take on meaning and history be the School of Prudence.’142 Crawford also found time to write his second article, ‘Revolution in Spain?’143 Published on 10 July 1936, a week prior to the eruption of the Civil War, the article was, as Robin Gollan observed, ‘an informed picture of pre-war events despite the unavailability of information’.144 It is an analytical and dispassionate piece devoid of the partisan sympathies displayed by many writers who had lived in Spain. Crawford accepted the plausible comparisons between Spain in 1936 and Russia in 1917, but emphasised his interest was restricted to Spain. Referring to the country’s turbulent past, he wrote that, ‘we must realise that the political atmosphere in Spain now is one in which revolution or counter revolution does not seem remote’. Crawford did not fall into the usual simplistic stereotypes in his examination of the contradictions between the right and left, as well as the role the centre faction could play. The right, he declared, would ‘swing round to the side of a dictatorship’ if faced with a revolution.
Origins and Influences
43
The right-wing would continue to wreak havoc, including the victimisation of intellectuals such as Ortega y Gasset. Crawford found the bombing of Ortega y Gasset’s house particularly abhorrent because of its implications for intellectual freedom. He warned that this type of ‘ineffective revolution followed by prolonged disorder might give new strength to such a movement’. Crawford was no more reticent in describing the ills of the left, plagued as it was by internal conflict; ‘the divisions of the left are on fundamentals.’ He emphasised that if this turmoil could not be controlled, the balance between revolution and counter-revolution would alter. The article described the chaos, confusion and inevitability of war. The scenario he offered was not remarkable. He cited Azana’s ominous prediction that: ‘This is Spain’s last chance to revive without Civil War’. Crawford also considered a number of likely fates, including ‘counter revolution with intervals of military dictatorship’. This did not eventuate, and Franco remained dictator until his death. ‘Prophesy is not easy’, concluded Crawford: Disorder is probable, and, in the end, it is a matter of how far Azana can browbeat the middle parties into reform, and at the same time, hold in the impatience of the extreme left groups. But passion rather than patience marks Spanish politics.145 Crawford recalled this conclusion with a degree of ambivalence in an unpublished paper written in the 1970s. ‘I had been specialising in Modern Spanish History for two or three years before the outbreak of war.’ He observed with retrospective pride. ‘I predicted its outcome a month before it happened and took no pleasure in the fulfillment of my prophecy.’146 Writing in 1936, Nettie Palmer had no doubts about the direction events were taking and was considerably less subtle in her prophecy: ‘I found myself thinking the feeling of liberation here was an illusion. The dark forces that struck back, there’ll be war all over the world.’147 It was the question of ‘Spain alone’ that interested Crawford in his 1936 article. In his analysis of the conservative agenda, the absence of German and Italian motives in Spain is glaring. For most
44
An Historian’s Life
intellectuals, the Spanish War involved much more than Spain. The involvement of Italy and Germany increased the possibility that the violence would spread. The threat of the next war and apocalyptic vision of imminent destruction became part of the intellectual consciousness.148 Crawford’s lack of interest in events in Germany and Italy is made all the more surprising when considering Stephen Roberts’s absence in Germany and the exchanges between the two colleagues. Roberts’s letters afforded Crawford an insight into world affairs at their most ominous. So Crawford was neither isolated, nor without intellectual awareness; yet he apparently ignored the international ramifications of Hitler and Mussolini. Roberts informed his colleague: By the way, I am entirely and totally converted to the belief that you are fortunate in living in Australia, and, though I shouldn’t like Mills to hear this heresy...I shall be jolly glad to be back. I’ve been thoroughly disillusioned this time with England and all the war talk just makes me ill.’149 His wife Thelma also proved an informative correspondent when she wrote a fascinating, if misdirected, letter to Dorothy Crawford: Stephen’s up in Berlin holding Premier Steven’s hand at the opening of the Olympic Games. Lucky Fellow! I have been listening to the excitement over the wireless. They sounded as if they had all gone completely insane. Politics and international crisis have been put in their proper place for once at least.’150 By 1936 the fascist purposes were not obscure. Despite this, Crawford failed to demonstrate a fear of fascism and the fanatical nationalism it inspired, until the signs were impossible to ignore. At the same time, Crawford responded to the Spanish Civil War with a new idea for a book. He planned to write a scholarly account of events with the same intense enthusiasm of previous attempts. His friend from Oxford days and a committed Communist, Christopher Hill, expressed great hope: ‘I look forward to seeing Crawford’s Spanish
Origins and Influences
45
Revolution on every bookshelf next door to Carlyles’.151 The book was to be a continued exploration of the country that had absorbed his interests from 1934 to 1936. Crawford later explained that it was meant as both a contemporary and historical study: ‘For I was trying to understand the present by seeing how it developed out of its own past. My question might have been phrased’, he wrote, ‘could Spain move peacefully, if somewhat belatedly into the twentieth century?’152 Yet the writing ambitions were interrupted once again. In October 1936, Crawford applied for the Chair of History at Melbourne University, vacated by the formidable Ernest Scott. Notes 1
Crawford, Historical Studies (1971), 27.
2
Ibid., 29.
3
Essay, ‘Before the Dawn’, 1923, Box 1, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
4
Samuel Hynes, The Auden Generation: Literature and Politics in England in the 1930s (London: The Bodley Head, 1976), 20.
5
Interview with Ken Crawford, 2001.
6
R. M. Crawford, An Australian Perspective (Madison: The University of Wisconsin Press, 1960), 62.
7
Macintyre, ed., Making History, 36.
8
Crawford to Manning Clark, 1 January 1988, Box 64, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
9
Margaret Cheshire to author, 6 December 2004.
10
Crawford, in Making History, 36. (This comment was also recalled by Ken Crawford in the 2001 interview.)
11
Crawford, ‘My Brother Jack: Background and Early Years’, 2-6, in Making History, 37, and ‘Sir John does not shirk a whit of work’, The Age, 8 March 1979.
12
Max Crawford notes, Box 75, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
13
Ibid., 36.
14
Crawford, in Making History, 37.
15
Crawford, ‘My Brother Jack: Background and Early Years’, 6.
16
Crawford to Barry Hill, 24 July 1982, Box 64, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA. Crawford taught with Stead’s half-brother, David, at Bexley Primary School. His sister was in the same class with Christina Stead at Bexley Primary and at the St George Girls High School, where she kept the class ‘spellbound with her stories’.
17
Ellen Schrecker, No Ivory Tower: McCarthyism and the Universities (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1986), 36.
46
An Historian’s Life
18
Margaret Dymock to Crawford, 25 January 1924, Box 1, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA. The family had moved from Grenfell to Bexley when Crawford was in primary school.
19
Crawford to Harry Crawford, undated 1927, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
20
Crawford to Mac, 19 August 1928, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
21
Ibid.
22
Essay, ‘What is the Truth?’, Box 1, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
23
Macintyre, ‘Liberalism’, The Oxford Companion to Australian History, 388-90.
24
Macintyre and Thomas, ed., The Discovery of Australian History, 30.
25
Ibid. Wood held the first Chair in history at an Australian University. Crawford’s hero worship of Wood was such that he wrote a lengthy biography.
26
Henderson occupied the Chair at the University of Adelaide, and Portus taught at the University of Adelaide and fostered the Workers Educational Association at the University of Sydney. See respective entries in Davison, Hirst and Macintyre, The Oxford Companion to Australian History.
27
G.A. Wood to Crawford, 15 March 1927, Box 1, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
28
Diary, 26 July 1928, Box 3, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
29
R. M. Crawford, ‘My Brother Jack: Background and Early Years’, 10.
30
Crawford to Manning Clark, 1 January 1988, Box 64, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
31
Diary, 23 July 1927, Box 3, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
32
G.A. Wood to Crawford, 2 April 1927, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
33
Interview with Ken Crawford, 2001.
34
R. M. Crawford, ‘My Brother Jack: Background and Early Years’, 10.
35
Diary, 29 July 1927, Box 3, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
36
Diary, 31 July 1927, Box 3, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
37
Diary, 23 July 1927, Box 3, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
38
Crawford to Harriet Crawford, exact date unknown, August 1927, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
39
Diary, 16 August 1927, Box 3, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
40
Ibid.
41
Diary, 2 August 1927, Box 3, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
42
Diary, 29 July 1927, Box 3, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
43
Diary, 16 August 1927, Box 3, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
44
Diary, 10 August 1927, Box 3, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
45
Ibid. See Craig Munro’s fine biography, Inky Stephensen: Wildman of Letters (St Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 1992).
Origins and Influences
47
46
Diary, 22 July 1927, Box 3, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
47
Interview with Ken Crawford, 2001.
48
Harriet Crawford to Crawford, 6 October 1927, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
49
Diary, 22 July 1927, Box 3, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
50
Interview with Ken Crawford, 2001.
51
Margaret Cheshire to author, 6 December 2004.
52
Diary, 22 July 1927, Box 3, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
53
Diary, 31 July 1927, Box 3, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
54
Max Crawford, Old Bebb’s Store and Other Poems (Melbourne: University of Melbourne, 1992), 12.
55
Diary, 6 September 1927, Box 3, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
56
Diary, 3 September 1927, Box 3, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
57
Diary, 8 September 1927, R. M. Crawford Papers, Box 3, UMA.
58
Crawford to Harriet Crawford, 13 September 1927, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
59
Crawford to Harry Crawford, 18 September 1927, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
60
Crawford to Harry Crawford, 7 November 1927, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
61
Elizabeth Kwan, ‘G. C. Henderson: Advocate of ‘Systematic and Scientific Research in Australian History’ in The Discovery of Australian History 18901939, 31.
62
Ibid., 32.
63
Crawford to Harry Crawford, 23 October 1927, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
64
Crawford to Harriet Crawford, 29 April 1928, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
65
Crawford to Harriet Crawford, 18 March 1928, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
66
Crawford to Family, 9 November 1927, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA. Keith Hancock had a similar affection for Bell’s ‘lust for life’; see W. K. Hancock, Country and Calling (London: Faber and Faber, 1955), 84.
67
Manning Clark, The Quest For Grace (Melbourne: Penguin Books, 1990), 82.
68
Crawford to Harriet Crawford, 25 March 1928, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
69
Crawford to Harry Crawford, 27 January 1928, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
70
Macintyre, ed. Making History, 36.
71
19 August 1928, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
48
An Historian’s Life
72
Judy Mabro. I Ban Everything: Free Speech and Censorship in Oxford (Oxford: Ruskin College Library, 1985), 6.
73
Charles Osborne, W. H. Auden (London: Eyre Methuen, 1979), 54.
74
Crawford never defined what he meant by the Synoptic Club.
75
Lady Francis Ryder to Crawford, 27 October 1927, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
76
Crawford to Family, 8 October 1927, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
77
Crawford to Family, 16 October 1927, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
78
Clark, Quest for Grace, 67.
79
Stephen Holt, Manning Clark and Australian History 1915-1963 (St Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 1982), 51.
80
Crawford to Harriet Crawford, 11 March 1928, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
81
Hancock, Country and Calling, 85.
82
Crawford to Harry Crawford, 10 July 1929, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
83
Crawford to Harriet Crawford, 19 March 1930, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
84
Crawford to Harriet Crawford, 18 March 1928, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
85
Ibid.
86
Stuart Macintyre, ‘Ernest Scott: My History is a Romance’, in The Discovery of Australian History, 83.
87
Crawford to Harriet Crawford, 8 August 1928, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
88
Interview with Ken Crawford, 2001.
89
Crawford to Family, 21 April 1929, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
90
Crawford to Harry Crawford, 29 December 1929, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
91
Macintyre, ed. Making History, 40.
92
Crawford to Harriet Crawford, 18 March 1928, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
93
Macintyre, ed. Making History, 38.
94
See K.S. Inglis, This is the A.B.C. (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 1983).
95
Crawford to Ross, 16 August 1933, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA. The reduction in income was critical and amounted to 3 pounds a week.
96
Ibid.
97
William Muir to Crawford, 8 November 1932, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA. After graduating, Muir was employed at Glasgow University.
Origins and Influences
49
98
Crawford to William Entwhistle, 27 January 1933, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
99
A.M. Vander, Prelude to War (The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1951), 6.
100
Crawford to Rockefeller Advisory Committee, 28 January 1933, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
101
Jack Crawford to Crawford, 16 June 1933, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
102
Crawford to Harriet Crawford, 26 July 1933, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
103
Crawford, Historical Studies, (1971), 38.
104
William Muir to Crawford, 20 March 1933, Box 2, R, M. Crawford Papers, UMA. Crawford had evidently not informed his friend about the progress of the project.
105
Harriet Crawford to Crawford, 28 May 1933, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
106
Harry Crawford to Crawford, 31 May 1933, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
107
Crawford to Ross, 16 August 1933, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
108
Dorothy Crawford to Crawford, 11 April 1933, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
109
Margaret Cheshire to author, 6 December 2004.
110
Jack Crawford to Crawford, 6 October 1932, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
111
Testimonial by Kenneth Bell, 24 October 1933, R. M. Crawford Papers, Box 2, UMA.
112
Harriet Crawford to Crawford, 8 November 1932, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
113
Ibid.
114
Jack Crawford to Crawford, 18 September 1933, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
115
Harriet Crawford to Crawford, 27 May 1934, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
116
Crawford, An Australian Perspective, 63.
117
Crawford, ‘My Brother Jack: Background and Early Years’, 14.
118
Hynes, The Auden Generation, Literature and Politics in England in the 1930s, 99.
119
Harriet Crawford to Crawford, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
120
Bradfield Notebook, 1933, Box 5, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
121
Crawford to Ross, 16 August 1933, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
122
Crawford to Stephen Roberts, undated 1935, Box 6, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
50
An Historian’s Life
123
Crawford’s application to the Registrar, University of Melbourne, 15 October 1936, Box 6, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
124
Macintyre, ed., Making History, 39.
125
Hancock, Country and Calling, 81.
126
Deryck Schreuder, ‘An Unconventional Founder: Stephen Roberts and the Professionalism of the Historical Discipline’, in The Discovery of Australian History 1890-1939, 126.
127
Crawford to Harriet Crawford, 1940, R. M. Crawford Papers, Box 5, UMA.
128
Crawford’s style was constantly remarked on in interviews.
129
Brian Kennedy. ‘John Anderson’, The Oxford Companion to History, 23-4. See also Brian Kennedy, A Passion to Oppose (Carlton South: Melbourne University Press, 1995).
130
Crawford, Historical Studies, (1971), 42.
131
Stephen Roberts, The House That Hitler Built (London: Methuen Publishers, 1937).
132
Schreuder, ‘An Unconventional Founder’ in The Discovery of Australian History 1890-1939, 39.
133
Ibid., 133.
134
Christopher Hollis wrote, in reference to Evelyn Waugh’s political indifference, that the interwar years made it no longer possible for any sane man to escape from political attitudes. Christopher Hollis, Oxford in the Twenties, Recollections of Five Friends (London: Heinemann, 1976), 106.
135
R. M. Crawford, ‘The Abyssinian Situation’, Address presented at the Joint Committee for Peace, 18 July 1935. Later published in The Union Recorder, 25 July 1935. There is no indication whether Crawford chose the topic or was requested to discuss the crisis.
136
Ibid.
137
Nettie Palmer, Fourteen Years (St Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 1988), 181.
138
Hollis, Oxford in the Twenties, 28.
139
Ibid.
140
Nettie Palmer to Crawford, 13 August 1942, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
141
External Paper ‘The Decline of Spain’, 1936, Box 10, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
142
Crawford, Historical Studies, (1971), 42.
143
R. M. Crawford ‘Revolution in Spain?’, Australian Highway, July 1936. The article was published in a paper distributed by The Workers’ Educational Association. The aim of the Australian Highway was to publish articles of ‘general interest to students’ and ‘provide a place where all questions relating to adult education may be discussed openly and completely’. The objectives were listed in a University of Sydney memo to tutors, signed by
Origins and Influences
51
W. B. K. Duncan (director of tutorial classes) and Lloyd Ross (editor), June 1936. 144
Robin Gollan, Revolutionaries and Reformists (Canberra: A.N.U Press, 1975), 53.
145
Crawford, ‘Revolution in Spain?’, Australian Highway, July 1936.
146
R. M. Crawford ‘The Spanish Civil War’, drafted paper, incomplete. The occasion and date are unknown, possibly 1970s. Box 10, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
147
Palmer, Fourteen Years, 222-3. Diary entry recorded 4 July 1936.
148
Hynes, The Auden Generation, 42.
149
Stephen Roberts to Crawford, 24 August 1936, Box 6, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
150
Thelma Roberts to Dorothy Crawford, 1 August 1936, Box 6, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
151
Christopher Cook to Crawford, 4 November 1936, Box 6, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
152
Crawford, Historical Studies (1971), 29.
52
An Historian’s Life
Chapter 2
‘Forward the Professors’
In the late nineteenth century, the University of Melbourne was described as having the appearance of an ‘English village centred around its pond’. The landscaped grounds and imposing architecture imitated the Oxbridge model. The ornamental lake was devised in the 1860s to obscure swampy ground, though a lingering stench occasionally exposed its origins. Wilson Hall, considered the ‘architectural jewel’, dominated the campus and the Tudor building known as the Quadrangle remained the hub of academic life. The building housed the original professors’ apartments, the library and the lecture theatres. The theatres had a door at the back for the students and one at the front for the lecturers to maintain the academic hierarchy.1 At the time Crawford applied for the Chair of History, the University retained reminders of the ‘inward looking estate’, but changes were afoot. The lake, a place for socialising, courtship, pranks and protest, with its stories of dissident students being thrown into its murky waters, was about to be drained and filled. The buildings, badly dilapidated, were now a ‘barbarous jumble and a melancholy mess’.2 The Appointment Crawford wrote his letter of application with a shrewd combination of confidence, modesty and self-deprecation as he related his previous
'Forward the Professors'
53
The University of Melbourne in the 1930s Photographer unknown University of Melbourne Archives, Image UMA/I/1091
54
An Historian’s Life
academic experience and lack of published research.3 He did not embellish his record and hoped his general Spanish studies would prove valuable. A once raw, ungainly and rather conceited young man had been tempered by the years of adversity teaching in the English public school system and his inconsistent success within the familiar walls of Sydney University. Balliol had not quite been the imagined path to success. Crawford’s previous difficulties in employment had not, however, quite defeated his fierce ambition or his innate selfbelief. He was an indulged son in whom his sacrificial mother had placed her hopes and in whom she recognised abilities that she had done her best to nurture. If the University had had its way, the vacancy would never have been advertised. The search for Scott’s replacement had been marred by an astonishing display of misdirected confidence, as the Committee courted a more established scholar. In an urgent and rather callous mood, Kenneth Bailey, the Acting Vice-Chancellor, declared that Scott, who had informed the Council of his resignation on 21 January 1936, had aged ‘very swiftly and rather pathetically in the last twelve months’.4 Concern for Scott was understandable: he had suffered poor health since 1935 and would live for only another three years after his retirement.5 Conscious of his disintegrating constitution, he had deferred his decision to retire and negotiated with his prized pupil, Keith Hancock, to take the Chair. Scott’s confidence in Hancock was well founded. The son of an Anglican priest, educated at Melbourne Grammar and Trinity College with the benefit of scholarships, Hancock served a brief apprenticeship with Edward Shann in Western Australia as an assistant lecturer and was known as the ‘Baby Bolsh’ for his radical liberalism.6 He went on to achieve a distinguished degree at Balliol, which culminated in election to a fellowship at All Souls. In 1926, Hancock returned to Australia and became the Professor at Adelaide, where he wrote the classic text, Australia. He was described as a ‘curious maverick’, for the combination of his experience and identity.7 With all these glittering credentials, the Chair of Melbourne’s committee deemed Hancock the only worthy and ‘suitable’ successor. Apparently undeterred by the fact that he had accepted the Chair at Birmingham University a year before, they agreed in April that an invitation would be extended to Hancock by airmail. He was asked to defer his
'Forward the Professors'
55
decision until the new Vice-Chancellor, Raymond Priestley, was able to see him in London. Priestley arrived there in June 1936 and began the protracted wooing. After a ‘couple of long yarns’ with the Hancocks, he tried to make the prospect of Melbourne as appealing as possible. He empathised with Hancock’s concerns: that he should fulfill his obligations at Birmingham for five years, and that by leaving England, he would be ‘very much out of touch with his materials at the other end of the world’.8 ‘It is clear’, Priestley wrote, ‘that Hancock is persona grata at Birmingham, as I fancy that he would be in any academic circles’.9 The doubts expressed by Hancock only made him more attractive. Promises were imparted; he did not have to begin until May 1939 and would be given a long spell every five years to research and write.10 The temptations were not sufficient, and Hancock declined. He expressed his regret, but was concerned by the ‘time factor’ surrounding his multi-volume historical work on the British Commonwealth. He also did not wish to face two harried and anxious years, leaving behind ‘an obligation half performed’ and a piece of work ‘spoilt by superficiality and haste’.11 There is some discrepancy over the nature or extent of Hancock’s duties at Birmingham. They were not as exacting as he maintained, for Priestley observed he had the luxury of two complete days in a week for his research work. It is debatable whether Hancock ever seriously considered the Melbourne bid. He had left Australia in 1933 with the full knowledge of Scott’s imminent departure. Later in life, Hancock ruefully offered several reasons for rejecting Melbourne. The timing ‘did not fit’; he was in Birmingham too briefly for a resignation to be ‘decent’; and less convincingly, Melbourne might not have appointed him.12 The prestige of Birmingham, the attractions of Britain and the importance of Hancock’s writing clearly took precedence, despite his insistence that Scott’s History Department had maintained fine traditions.13 Hancock would later self-consciously confess that his record as a professor was not exemplary. The single-minded pursuit of writing took over other obligations: domestic, teaching, public demands and the monotony of administration.14 He found the tenuous balance between teaching and writing impossible to achieve. Perhaps Hancock’s voluminous body of work mitigated the neglect of other obligations.
56
An Historian’s Life
The demands on Australian professors were onerous, and the casualties of the history profession at that time striking. G. A. Wood and Edward Shann both committed suicide; Scott and A.C.V. Melbourne would die at a relatively young age, and G. C. Henderson suffered from acute depression and was forced to retire early. On 3 August the despondent Melbourne Committee decided to advertise the vacant position in Australia and England. Max Crawford was under no illusions about his chances and provided only two referees, Kenneth Bell and A. D. Lindsay, both from Balliol. By late October, he was one of twelve Australian and New Zealand applicants, with an additional six applications coming from England. Crawford was in good company, and the leading contenders all brandished a swag of publications. Each candidate’s qualifications, experience and references were thoroughly scrutinised. The field was narrowed to seven contenders: Crawford, J. C. Beaglehole and J. Rutherford from New Zealand, A. C. V. Melbourne from Queensland, J. Harrison and Herbert Butterfield (Hancock’s recommendation) from England and Fred Wood, Crawford’s close friend and rival. The Committee sought a candidate who had published work and was not embedded in Australian history. A more questionable concern was with the applicant’s physical appearance. Priestley evidently had a penchant for phrenology and observed that Beaglehole was ‘quite good looking’; Melbourne had a ‘fine strong head’, but looked like an administrator; Wood was ‘pleasant’; Owen had a ‘fine head and face’ (though he wasn’t shortlisted); Rutherford had the ‘best face of all’, and as Hall’s photograph suggested that he was not their ‘man’, he was eliminated straight away. As for Crawford, Priestley described him having ‘an attractive, alive and intelligent face but not particularly strong looking. A good head and forehead, falls away rather below, but a wide and humorous mouth.’15 It was Wood, with his impeccable academic pedigree, who had blocked Crawford’s path at Sydney in 1931. He too used Bell as a referee. Bell felt compelled to write informally to another Balliol man, G. S. Browne, the Professor of Education at Melbourne University, about his two former students. Both men, according to Bell, were ‘very good indeed’, had ‘energy and initiative’ and owed their success and continued improvement ‘to their own efforts, determination and patience’. Fred Wood had the better publication record and had done
'Forward the Professors'
57
‘some excellent historical writing’ despite personal tragedies, notably his father’s suicide and the death of his first child. This, in Bell’s view, personified Wood’s ‘pluck, determination and outstanding power of work’, although the Wood family were not ‘everybody’s pigeon’ and ‘had a certain awkwardness of manner’.16 What did Crawford have to offer? By all accounts he was an instinctive, gifted and ‘first rate teacher’. ‘His pupils love him’, wrote Bell, ‘he’s got the teacher’s touch’. It was also suggested that, though fond of England, he was ‘a real Australian’. He had some devoted friends, but was not ‘a hankerer after fleshpots’, though Bell jested that a ‘marvellous superman smothered in PhD’s’ would apply and make Crawford look like an amateur.17 He urged the Committee to have courage and elect Crawford.18 Stephen Roberts was equally magnanimous in his praise to Ernest Scott. Crawford was: Energetic, loyal to a degree, has diverse interests, represented the combination of literature and history at its best, is a good mixer, takes part in all student activities, is an excellent lecturer and has many ideas.19 The Sydney School would regret his leaving. Curiously, Crawford had not called on Roberts to provide a testimonial. Equally unusual was the role Scott played in the selection of his successor. Fred Wood had seriously miscalculated when he included a vaguely positive letter from Roberts, for it had been common knowledge that their working relationship had not been happy. The Committee might well have been disconcerted when it read Roberts’ statement that ‘nobody turned out of Sydney in the last fifteen years who had come near’ to Crawford. In a further rebuff to Wood, Roberts contrasted Crawford’s ‘willingness’ with ‘his unfortunate experience with his two predecessors’.20 We can only speculate about Roberts’ motive. There is no evidence to suggest that Crawford’s relationship with Roberts was close. As a student of Scott and a post-graduate at London University, Roberts adopted the empirical school of scientific history, in sharp contrast with Crawford’s social and moral orientation.21 Although Crawford would later deny the importance of his
58
An Historian’s Life
family background, it distinguished him in the field. In particular, Stephen Roberts appeared contemptuous of those who assumed that a University education was a natural right regardless of ability.22 Known as ‘Swotty Roberts’, a none-too-flattering euphemism for his ambition and industry, Roberts had depended on scholarships to achieve the eminence he craved. In both Bell’s and Roberts’ opinion, Crawford’s very ‘humble beginnings’ had created a tenacious fighter, who also possessed the skills of a diplomatic negotiator. It was fortunate that Roberts intervened on Crawford’s behalf, since his other referee, A. D. Lindsay, had been more measured. ‘He has vigour and go’, Lindsay wrote, ‘and I think is a first class fellow. I can’t of course speak about his history.’23 There were a number of reservations about Crawford. According to Priestley’s cryptic notes, Crawford’s chief disability was his lack of research work and publication.24 This disadvantage was rationalised by Roberts, who claimed that Crawford had been ‘tied’ down by an early marriage and by the terrible grind of English schools.25 C. H. Currey also mentioned Crawford’s difficult circumstances, but provided a new dimension. ‘He is too steeped in the Oxford tradition’, Currey observed, ‘to have been able to publish anything that he would regard as worthy of publication’.26 Kenneth Bell’s qualm was of a more personal nature. He characterised Crawford as less steady and methodical than Wood, and thought he might be criticised as ‘overeager and too much inclined to dash off after all kinds of odd hares’.27 Raymond Priestley was pragmatic. He considered that Crawford was ‘rather on the modern side’ and projected an ‘excursion into Australian History’, though the Vice-Chancellor admitted it was difficult to escape at the time.28 Early opinion favoured a candidate from Queen’s College, J. Harrison. Priestley disagreed and saw Crawford’s potential, believing they could find no better candidate than the young historian.29 After ‘considerable discussion’ and by a narrow margin at the final meeting of the Selection Committee, it was agreed to see the unknown Sydney man. A delayed telegram reached Crawford on 21 December, and he was invited to an interview in Melbourne the following day. After a restless night on the interstate train, planning how to reshape the Melbourne School, Crawford was taken to the interview. Largely due to fatigue, the normally retiring Crawford did not
'Forward the Professors'
59
Max Crawford in 1937 Photographer: Austin Marcott University of Melbourne Archives, Image UMA/I/1953
60
An Historian’s Life
display his usual inhibitions. Forty years later, he described the interview: Asked why I had not published very much, I replied that Professor Roberts had been away and that I had to run the Department by myself, and that in Sydney one had to prepare three lectures a week in each subject, whereas in Melbourne they gave two. Someone asked, ‘Why do they still do that?’ And I heard myself saying to these venerable gentlemen, ‘The reasons for that will have retired within the next ten years’—and I assumed that was the end of Melbourne for me. But they loved it: I was saying something about Sydney.30 Indeed, everyone was overjoyed. It was, according to Priestley, ‘quite an important day’ and the Committee was so favourably impressed with Crawford that his appointment was immediate and unanimous. He had won them with his measured confidence, personality, scholarship and attitude towards research, teaching, and University affairs.31 ‘He is all that we could wish’, Priestley wrote with prophetic foresight, ‘and will make a most stimulating head for our history school for the next thirty years with will.’32 The Melbourne School So, from a large and distinguished field of candidates, Max Crawford emerged as Professor at Melbourne at the age of thirty. It was not his youth that was unusual, but the conspicuous lack of published writing. The announcement of Crawford’s appointment further emphasised his failure to produce original work. ‘Teaching duties so far have been too heavy to allow him to publish any research work.’ A journalist who reported for the local press wrote. ‘But he is a wellknown authority on the American Revolution and has done research work on Spanish History.’33 Crawford himself was bemused and later described the selection as ‘Melbourne’s gamble into the future’.34 Surprisingly, the appointment of a seeming novice did not cause great controversy. The History Department was already considered unconventional, with the precedent of Scott, who had worked as a journalist and had no degree.35 The selection committee was intent
'Forward the Professors'
61
on finding a general historian rather than a specialist, and a graduate from another university rather than a pupil of Scott. Crawford’s confidence in the reputation of Balliol had remained steadfast, and he was convinced that the weight Australia attached to that name had gained him the position. This was echoed by Gordon Greenwood, who congratulated Crawford on his success and wrote that Crawford was obviously correct about the Oxford clout.36 The Oxford old boys’ club was well represented at Melbourne, as Kenneth Bailey, G.V. Browne and Greenwood had Oxford credentials. Academics and prominent public figures alike were quick to express their approval and delight. They included Kenneth Bell, A. D. Lindsay, G. S. Henderson, Fred Alexander, Orwell de R. Foenander, Ian Hogbin, Fred Wood and Scott himself. Congratulating Crawford, Christopher Cook sensed the threat to his friend’s writing plans and wrote rather optimistically: ‘One thing, I hope that the projected book is not sabotaged by the new responsibilities’.37 With the news of his long-awaited success and in preparation for the new duties, Crawford took his family to Grenfell for a brief Christmas vacation. The ensuing months were fraught with the hurried completion of work in Sydney, preparation for Melbourne (he was to work in six fields and was familiar with only one) and the logistics of moving a young family for the third time in two years. During the interim, Crawford and Priestley began to develop their shared ideas about the History Department. Priestley disclosed for the first time to the new Professor his intention to make a survey of the entire University in order to convince the government and individual benefactors that they ‘must do better for their University’.38 On the advice of the Melbourne Chair Committee, which recognised his tendency to ‘overwork’, Crawford willingly took a holiday in Victoria, so he could assume his new responsibilities ‘more vigorously’.39 After years of drifting, Crawford and Dorothy now found permanence. In February they purchased a comfortable house in prosperous Kew, a solid bastion of the middle class. Crawford was now earning an impressive annual salary of 1200 pounds, a leap from the 400 pounds provided by Sydney. Although he was not a materialistic man, the salary and house reflected his image of himself and his new security. The home was very much Dorothy Crawford’s arena. The role of the academic wife was expected to be that of a silent and
62
An Historian’s Life
supportive partner whose activities were restricted to teas and childraising.40 By 1939 the Crawford family would have two new additions: Ian who was born in Sydney in 1935 and Margaret born in Melbourne in 1939. Melbourne also afforded Crawford a happy opportunity to become reacquainted with the eldest of his brothers, Stanley, who had left the parental home at the outbreak of war. After distinguished service in Egypt, Gallipoli and France, Stanley performed special duties for the Defence Department. It was not all domestic tranquillity. Crawford never deviated from the enormous task ahead of him and immediately set about transforming the History School. His selection signalled the University’s intent to break away from Scott and inaugurate ‘a new regime’.41 Crawford began with a review of resources and student numbers, and moved on to a detailed review of the Department. The results were encapsulated in two reports, the first submitted in May 1937 and the second in the following year. It was a remarkable feat for one so young to depart from the previous practices and reformulate the curriculum and pedagogy with such determination. Yet Crawford was not as much a novice as his age suggested. Unlike many academics, and despite his later protests, administration appealed to his sense of purpose and organisation. The signs were apparent as early as 1929, when he told his father that he felt quite a strong inclination towards administration of some kind.42 Crawford’s aptitude in this regard was amply demonstrated at Sydney when he wrote a letter to a senior colleague that provided a detailed inventory of necessary changes—all of which reflected his distinctive interpretation of history: An Honours School of History should have a nucleus of purely historical subjects, and for the rest, sufficient flexibility to allow the student to follow his individual bent towards an economic, social, philosophical or literary emphasis on his historical study.43 Sydney had been a valuable apprenticeship, and it was fortuitous that the mercurial, demanding Roberts had been mostly absent. Nevertheless, Crawford had oscillated between resentment that he
'Forward the Professors'
63
had been exploited and frustration that he could not implement his plans. Melbourne gave Crawford the opportunity to realise the ambitious ideas he had for many years envisaged. It was also an exchange: Roberts, the Melbourne graduate, had gone to Sydney, and Crawford now went in the opposite direction. The divergent traditions of the cities in Australian cultural discourse would be defined in this period. The Melbourne tradition was embodied in a confidently middle-class intelligentsia, which saw knowledge as central to society and was inclined to be idealistic, earnest and progressive. In contrast, the Sydney intellectuals saw their role as one of aloof detachment and tended to be attracted to activities that personified that stance: anarchism, bohemianism and anti-authoritarianism.44 As he implemented his sweeping plans, the constant in Crawford’s chaotic life was his teaching. His didacticism had always been emphasised, and Bell remembered the deep impression Crawford had made on his students as a gangly twenty-five-year-old. His approachable ease, combined with his reverence for history, inspired similar enthusiasm in his Melbourne students. Manning Clark, the son of an Anglican clergyman, was in his second year as an undergraduate when he met Crawford in March 1937. It was the Professor’s first day and, in a period of extreme formality, he was a revelation to the young Clark. ‘He had a light in the eye: he wore on his face an expression of a man who knew much about melancholy.’ Clark recounted: He said that if ever I wanted to sort out any puzzles I should just knock on the door, and, if he was free, he would be delighted to talk things over. Being friendly and democratic at Melbourne University in those days was as rare as a display of generosity and understanding by either side in the sectarian dog-fight.45 It was the era of the ‘God professor’ and Crawford, according to one student, possessed the ‘sheer ability and charismatic quality’ to make ‘the system work at its best’.46 Others were not as complimentary. One young refugee student later accused Crawford of being a ‘vile, bourgeois mechanist’.47 Deeply sensitive, this comment greatly wounded Crawford, who repeated it years later. Less judgmental was
64
An Historian’s Life
Frank Ford’s assessment: he considered Crawford a talented teacher, but uninterested in students who were not destined for the Honours stream.48 Crawford was aware of the effect he had on students. As an undergraduate, he described to his father how he attracted other students with his placid disposition, which they found comforting and soothing. It was a quality that Bell described as ‘a quietness of sympathy’.49 Crawford emulated the examples offered by Wood and Bell, who had inspired such strong feelings of admiration. He attempted to provide an ‘intellectual lead to the department’.50 In Crawford’s long and hagiographic account of G. A. Wood’s life, A Bit of a Rebel, he observed that Wood believed a professor’s duty must be to the university, however strongly he might feel his obligations to the world beyond it. It was also his responsibility to maintain a balance between teaching, obligations to the academic community and the public.51 It might have been easier for Crawford to imitate Wood’s example if he had remained at Sydney, but Melbourne University was an unknown quantity. Crawford had only fleetingly visited the campus as a hopeful scholar on voyage to Oxford. Now, as Professor, he found himself among an academic fraternity that was considered more progressive and politically engaged than that at Sydney.52 In truth, the students and teachers who did gravitate into protest did so slowly, and although some joined the Communist Party of Australia, most remained intellectual sympathisers. The rise of fascism in the 1930s, Crawford would suggest later, provoked the beginning of ‘an alive and bitter ideological discussion’.53 Political and cultural groups fostered, informed and animated debate. By 1937 such organisations thrived: the Left Book Club, the Book Censorship Abolition League, the International Movement Against War and Fascism, the Labor Club, the Australian Council of Civil Liberties and the Spanish Relief Committee. They provided a potent mix of social, cultural and political activism. The issue that galvanised the campus was the outbreak of the Spanish Civil War in 1936, though Australian intellectuals were affected by Spain less than their European counterparts. Crawford’s two English friends, William Muir and Christopher Cook, kept him informed. Muir, the more jovial of the two, found events in Europe rather ‘thrilling’.54 Cook was decidingly more grim as he described
'Forward the Professors'
65
‘lives of constant uncertainty’. He warned, ‘I think it most likely that some type of socialism will come in a few years, but whether it will bring war in its train, I don’t guess’.55 Protests over Spain gained momentum. Editors of the student newspaper, Farrago, likened a debate held on campus in early March 1937 to a ‘Spanish Bull Fight’.56 Such debates became increasingly vitriolic, firing passions comparable to those ignited by the conscription debate during the First World War. On 23 March 1937, Manning Clark witnessed another ‘talk’ on Spain at the University in the Public Lecture Theatre when the proposition ‘That the Church is the ruin of Spain’ was debated. Clark described the debate as ‘a refresher course in tribal loyalty’; the behaviour reminded him of the rabble watching a football match at the Melbourne Cricket Ground, rather than a formal intellectual debate. Howling mobs shouted down the speakers, students ran over the roof and the chairman, Professor C. A. Scutt, vainly called for order.57 Open letters exchanged in Farrago were even more poisonous, illustrated by the undergraduate B. A. Santamaria’s broadside against the economic historian Herbert ‘Joe’ Burton. In a response to Burton’s letter regarding the debate on Spain, Santamaria accused him of being ‘dangerous’, a ‘semi-communist’ and questioned his academic integrity as a senior lecturer in Economic History.58 Raymond Priestley had good reason to mock Melbourne’s reputation for radicalism and insisted that the University was far less threatening than Cambridge. The Vice-Chancellor described Melbourne’s left as small and inactive, its radical reputation as an invention of the fertile imagination of the conservative press. ‘I often think’, Priestley observed, ‘that if Cambridge University was put down in Melbourne, this place would go up in flames’.59 Although Crawford was concerned by the right-wing action in Spain, he remained uncomfortable with the form of protest it provoked. Manning Clark observed how his mentor was ill at ease with left-wing orthodoxy and some of the behaviour of his own disciples. Clark saw a man who continued to view the madness of Europe through the partial blinkers of a traditional and civilised liberalism, reminiscent of Sydney and Oxford. Clark suspected that Crawford believed ‘a man’s virtue did not depend on his material environment. A man was not born with virtue: he acquired virtue, by his intelligence and his soul.’
66
An Historian’s Life
Crawford’s critics considered his liberalism outdated, and some regarded him as chimerical. Clark was sympathetic and compared his teacher ‘like a man driving a team of horses who found to his dismay that one horse after another was breaking from a trot to a canter’.60 Crawford was not alone in his concern about the Spanish protests, and Raymond Priestley felt compelled at a Union dinner to call for some calm amid the alleged abuses of academic freedom. ‘I am a keen supporter of free speech and free discussion in a University’, he was reported as saying. ‘Nevertheless, I have viewed with dismay certain manifestations arising out of discussion of political and social questions here, particularly recently.’61 Scholastic Busybodies In April 1937, Crawford wrote a provocative letter to the Argus on behalf of five of his colleagues. It was a copy of a manifesto sent to the Australian delegates who had departed to an Imperial Conference. The letter challenged the British and Australian governments’ foreign policy.62 Crawford proposed that the Empire’s trade restrictions should be reduced and the League of Nations be given stricter control. This, in Crawford’s opinion, was ‘contingent upon the fascist countries coming back into the League and supporting collective security’.63 The success of the proposal was dependent on the resurrection of this ‘collective security’ and the assumption that both Hitler and Mussolini wanted peace. Max Crawford had at last made himself conspicuous. He had translated his beliefs into a more active stance. It was an inauspicious political debut. The Bulletin condemned the academics as ‘six scholastic busybodies’. In an editorial sarcastically titled, ‘Forward, the Professors!’ it maintained that the ‘conceited’ academics in their rarefied environment were not qualified to shape the foreign policy of the Empire. ‘In his accustomed sphere the Professor is rightly esteemed,’ the editor sneered: But it is hardly questionable that the specialised nature of his training, the secluded conditions of his calling and the character of his usual contacts disqualify him outright as a possible shaper of practical policies. Habitually associated with the University life, his idea of the world tends to be a mere enlargement of his school.64
'Forward the Professors'
67
The Bulletin also alleged that the professors were in a position to subvert the Victorian youths they ‘instructed’ with realities taken out of Alice in Wonderland. The editor asked legitimate questions about the professors’ premise that economic relief by a revision of the mandate system and lowering of tariffs would undermine the Fascist dictators. In hindsight, the academic protagonists had grossly underestimated both Hitler and Mussolini. The Argus was also critical of Crawford and his colleagues. The Herald was somewhat kinder and saw merit in their peaceful political activism. In response to the mainstream press’s right-wing outbursts, Farrago commended the professors and maintained they could offer valuable contributions to discussion of the world situation.65 The Vice-Chancellor did not publicly support them. Priestley always insisted that the University as an institution was outside, even above, politics, and he subordinated his own public commentary to his duties as Vice-Chancellor.66 He did respond to a letter published in the Herald, which attacked the academics. ‘If they have sinned,’ Priestley wrote, ‘they are in good company since the Economist holds the same view’.67 This stormy debate was the start of what Crawford would recall ambivalently as ‘the noise of controversy’.68 A Memorandum of Change Politics withstanding, most of Crawford’s energy was consumed by his original reconstruction of the History School. In his first lengthy memorandum to Priestley written on 4 May 1937, he plotted three objectives: that more intensive honours work should be guided in smaller classes (hence the urgent need for more resources); that initiation into research be postponed to the graduate stage; and that the pass degree should include a new course on modern history and an aspect of Australian history.69 In Crawford’s mind, the Honours School took precedence over the remaining two objectives. It was his aim ‘to stimulate the individual student to mental activity, imaginative, sympathetic and critical, as far may be’.70 The student was expected in this process to consult a variety of sources, ‘geographical, economic and social, through political and constitutional to what one might describe as literary material’, so they might ‘analyse the relationship between men, their traditions, their environment, both human and physical’.71
68
An Historian’s Life
Crawford expanded on his objectives in an address delivered on a cold Friday afternoon in June 1937 to the Melbourne University Association. Although it was Crawford’s first public statement in Melbourne about history, the bulk of the paper had been written the previous year when he harboured hopes of transforming the History Department at Sydney University. The accompanying notes (and the surviving draft) were scribbled in one evening in May.72 They reveal a view of history that Crawford would later call the synoptic approach and that continued to inform his work. He viewed society through three prisms: the setting, the individuals and their social relationships. The method was not simply a legal, political, social or geographical one, but an attempt to synthesise these specialised perspectives. ‘History is the story of human societies agitated from within themselves and their setting to work out the nature’, Crawford declared. It was an argument that had its genesis at Oxford and Bradfield, and had been refined in Sydney.73 These themes were offered with more clarity and authority now that Crawford was Professor. His expectations of himself as a teaching historian responsible for the apprentices to his profession were at the core of the paper. History could not be built upon a ‘vague nostalgia for the past’, he maintained, but required the readiness to ‘face the role of understanding’. It is a discipline, he said, ‘training habits of thorough investigation and critical alertness’. He expected his students to understand the facts, but also to experience the process of understanding. Crawford’s exposition tended to grandiloquence as he expounded the duty of the teacher to develop critical awareness and sympathetic insight, a combination that constituted imagination. He likened the process to walking a tightrope, strung between certain fact and uncertainty. A believer in goodness, morality and integrity, he emphasised scholastic honesty as the most fundamental quality for a student.74 The roots of this approach were in Wood’s training; that the historian must guide the student to ‘live rightly’, to be men who matter in the world and matter for its good.75 Crawford’s address reveals as much about his approach to history as his plans for the History Department. He considered certain subjects particularly valuable: Greek and Roman civilisation, Europe in the Renaissance and the Reformation, the French Revolution and the Industrial Revolution. They were subjects already taught in the
'Forward the Professors'
69
Department, and Crawford validated the inclusion because they raised issues of contemporary importance: liberalism and authority, dogmatism and tolerance. It was also an address of its time. ‘The professional historians’, he stated, ‘are all very conscious nowadays that we must criticise our authority and examine our documents’. With subtle skill, Crawford indicated the responsibilities he now assumed as a public figure in a decade of increased controversy. The synoptic way of seeing was not only a methodological and philosophical approach to history, but also a way of understanding the present desire for peace and the element of fear that inspired dictatorships. The ambitiousness of the synoptic approach, the breadth of its scope and its insistence on comprehensive standards made it difficult for Crawford to uphold those standards in his own work. His passion for history and his enthusiasm for teaching are unmistakable. He was a practised public speaker, with a clear, modulated delivery and commanding presence. Crawford’s Melbourne debut was a triumph.76 Several weeks after the address, he submitted to the ViceChancellor a new report defining the changes to the History School. In an extension of the earlier memorandum, it proposed to discard Australian history as a separate subject (and combine it with British history) because, in 1937, it attracted only fifteen students.77 Lewis Wilcher of Trinity College, who was appointed to teach British History, and was totally uninterested in the Australian story, concurred. ‘My own instinct’, Wilcher wrote, ‘is to say to hell with Australian history’.78 Crawford’s reasons were different. Defending the controversial decision, he maintained that it was the ‘comparative paucity of the first class writing on the subject’ that made it ‘of less educational value’.79 In an attempt to reassure those advocating Australian history, Crawford insisted that he had ‘clear plans for an Australasian course’.80 A revised course was intended as a departure from the ‘drab’ chronicle of events.81 However, the decision to abandon Australian history looked like a backwards step in deference to British history. Priestley assured the usually confident Crawford that the necessary committees would support the modifications.82 During this formative period, Crawford began to devise the course that would become his trademark. The Theory and Method subject, which was at the heart of the fourth year of honours studies,
70
An Historian’s Life
was intended to stimulate historical inquiry and encourage an imaginative approach to tackle it.83 ‘Its inspiration’, Crawford reiterated, was not a particular conclusion, certainly not an ideology, though a belief in the importance and hopefulness of the study was implicit in it. It inspired, not acceptance, but a debate, and if there developed a Melbourne school of history, there was not a Melbourne ideology. Admittedly there was what had been called a Crawford flavour. I refer to Donald Horne’s distinction in The Lucky Country between Anderson’s influence in Sydney and mine here.84 Equally telling is Crawford’s retrospective comment that his early childhood influences—the conviction that ‘greater social justice was both needed and possible’—was not irrelevant to the ideology espoused in the Theory and Method course.85 Raymond Priestley resigned from Melbourne University late in 1937 and did not see the full impact of the new history curriculum. His successor was John Medley, a seemingly cautious and unobtrusive headmaster from Moss Vale. His appointment was controversial. Medley would prove an equally supportive and far-sighted ally of Crawford. The University had been fortunate, according to Crawford in later life, that both Vice-Chancellors ‘were able to add to the intellectual liveliness of the school by the appointment of staff of important intellectual stature’.86 Not all Crawford’s plans went as smoothly. Much to his chagrin, he failed to incorporate his Spanish studies. ‘Melbourne’s very different demands on my time ended them’, Crawford recounted. ‘A lecture course on Modern Spain would have brought them to some sort of fruition. I assumed that I would be able to return to them; in those days I was so full of energy nothing was impossible.’87 The exuberance that characterised Crawford’s administration was not apparent in his own research. Crawford implored Priestley to provide staff and redistribute the teaching and administration burden, because he found it impossible to combine these duties with research. ‘I am not willing’, he wrote defensively, ‘to publish original work based on insufficient reading and particularly insufficient thought’.88 This reluctance is consistent with Currey’s observation that the Balliol
'Forward the Professors'
71
tradition and high scholarly standards inhibited Crawford from producing work.89 In Crawford’s defence, the burden placed on staff by the growing number of students was heavy and unremitting. From 1937 to 1938, he had a staff of only two full-time officers—himself and Jessie Webb—and three part-time assistants. A change in family relations might also have sapped his confidence. His brother Jack had won a Commonwealth Fund Fellowship to Washington. During his absence at Oxford, Max Crawford had assumed a protective attitude towards his brother. This was manifested in correspondence with his mother, as they discussed Jack’s education, future and the hope that he would retrace Crawford’s pilgrimage to England. In reality, Jack Crawford was quite capable of making his own decisions, and he might have resented his brother’s paternalistic attitude.90 Close in age and ambitious by nature, the brothers had achieved an intimacy when Crawford taught at Sydney, and Jack was working as economic adviser to the Rural Bank of New South Wales. Although Crawford was delighted with his brother’s research success, it must have also been a reminder of his own failed Rockefeller Fellowship application and the demanding professorial duties that crushed his hopes for original research and travel. Later in life, Crawford wrote with a sense of regret that the early years at Melbourne had ended the luxury of time afforded him in Sydney, and the move to Melbourne was not necessarily good for him as an historian.91 He was apparently defeated by overwork and his own expectations. He might, though, have been self-mythologising. Even in the period of relative calm in Sydney, the articulated intention to embark on original research and the freedom to continue his omnivorous reading were precarious and not sustained. Despite Crawford’s writing difficulties, he maintained an avid interest in Spain. In the absence of his book on that troubled country, the surviving addresses delivered in Melbourne in 1937 and his copious notes tell us much about his frustrated ambitions to write and his increased activism. By 1937, as the Civil War became a grim and bloody contest, the character of Crawford’s narrative changed. In a half-hour talk entitled, ‘The Spanish Background’, he considered issues of fear, suspicion and the role of communism. This was a significant departure from previously dry and detached papers. With a semblance of anger he wrote:
72
An Historian’s Life
The Spanish Revolution has been caused by fear. This fear is a compound of several fears, fear of anything with danger to life and property, fear of anti-clerical violence, fear of communist and anarchist revolution, fears which are summed up for the conservative Spaniard in the bogey of Bolshevism.92 The events in Spain provided Crawford’s fascination with the country with contemporary relevance, an interested public and a stimulating context for the application of his historical ideas. The premise of his original project of 1932 remained the same, but his emphasis altered as the international ramifications increased. He pursued his synoptic vision more readily. In his talk, he analysed ‘the background of fear and suspicion and the events that bred the atmosphere’. The theme that gave a fresh perspective to Crawford’s rather stale notes was the new emphasis on the intellectual. It was the generation of 1898 who were now accorded the central role in the present events in Spain. Crawford insisted that the intellectual and aesthetic revival was not something remote: it spread from the intellectual’s writing, from the universities to professors and the middle class and then to the officers.93 This redefined and sharpened perspective indicated his own growing interest in the intellectual’s role in society. Another paper written later in the year, ‘The Troubles in Spain’, began less dramatically, but examined similar themes. This lecture was not, Crawford admitted, ‘an authoritative exposition’; instead, it approached the topic with some ‘hesitation and due humility’.94 He insisted that inadequate material hampered confident analysis. He returned to the flight of Alfonso XIII in 1931 to illustrate the importance of the background to present events, the intellectual renaissance and the hopelessness of the political system. The powerful emotion of fear and the dread of communism were ‘the main emotional stimulus to the present counter-revolution’.95 The notes suggest that, by late 1937, Crawford hoped to return to his interrupted project. In a draft plan called, ‘Spain or more’, he began to consider the origins of the Civil War. He set down his intention to ‘see how this became almost instantly a general European War fought on Spanish soil and to paint a sense of the more important international implications of the conflict’.96 The self-defeating
'Forward the Professors'
73
paranoia of Bolshevism was now a theme in Crawford’s notes. He was by no means aligning himself with the communist cause, but was attempting to introduce a rational and analytical response to a debate that had always incited hysteria. A New Approach The immediate burden on his staff was lightened when, at Crawford’s insistence and with Priestley’s blessing, the University made a vacancy available for another lecturer in November 1937. The new appointment would not be without its problems. Ernest Scott anticipated his successor’s request for new staff and wrote a glowing letter of introduction for a talented former student, Kathleen Fitzpatrick. She was a tutor in the School of English at the time, but had made it known that she wanted to be transferred, if Crawford had no objections. Scott assumed that Crawford would approve of Fitzpatrick, given their shared Oxford qualifications. ‘Unless’, Scott wrote, ‘you belong to that band of diehards (of whom I know some choice specimens) who think that Oxford is no place for women students, however blest with qualities’.97 Crawford did not harbour such prejudices and worked at a University that was considered advanced in terms of its employment of women, with fifteen per cent of its staff being female.98 He had worked successfully with the other full-time member of staff, Jessie Webb, and recommended her promotion from Senior Lecturer to Associate Professor.99 However, he might have had doubts about Fitzpatrick and enquired if she intended to devote herself seriously to work. In a lengthy and sensitive response, Kathleen Fitzpatrick catalogued her experience, character and ill-fated marriage to Brian Fitzpatrick: My situation is now that I have no children, have been separated from my husband for more than a year and have my full time and undivided attention to give to my work. I think this is the information you were seeking.100 Kathleen Fitzpatrick, nee Pitt, had at this juncture experienced a series of profound disappointments. She had graduated with first class honours, but did not obtain a scholarship to further her
74
An Historian’s Life
education. Instead her parents paid for her to enter Somerville College, Oxford, where she completed with second class honours and under some financial pressure. More tellingly, Fitzpatrick had not enjoyed Oxford where women were treated as inferior.101 Fitzpatrick had married Brian Fitzpatrick in 1932, and the marriage broke up three years later. It was such a harrowing experience that she could barely mention the marriage in her evocative autobiography. Divorce, although highly unusual for the period, was not unfamiliar territory to Crawford, whose sister had suffered the humiliation of a court divorce. Fitzpatrick was by no means the leading contender for the position, and other historians were seriously considered. Esmonde Higgins was one of the more impressive and controversial candidates. Higgins, the brother of Nettie Palmer, had distinguished himself at Scotch College and Melbourne University. After the War, he attended Balliol College without taking a degree. Higgins later insisted he could not afford the costs, but had actually been sent down for his political activities. In 1920 he joined the Communist Party of Great Britain and worked in the Labour Research Department before he returned to Australia in 1924. He was a fine teacher and had other academic qualifications suggesting a successful career, but employment was denied him because of his politics. In March 1936, Higgins was appointed tutor for the Workers’ Educational Association in Launceston, under the aegis of the University of Tasmania.102 Higgins’ politics were sufficiently controversial for Raymond Priestley to ask G. V. Portus about his WEA associate. Portus, who had supported Higgins’s application, described the younger man’s political indoctrination, qualifications and disillusionment with communism in Australia. Portus expected questions about Esmonde Higgins’ integrity and remarked that his ‘communist interlude would be regarded with deep suspicion’. ‘I don’t mean’, Portus wrote, ‘that he wants to teach communism. He is studiously careful not to do this.’103 The unspoken concern that dominated the exchange, and was constantly raised at the time, was the issue of subversion and the undue influence exerted by a teacher on young charges. This form of scrutiny was not confined to card-carrying communists. Herbert Burton’s chief disability when he applied for the History Chair was ‘his political opinions’, which would ‘count against
'Forward the Professors'
75
him with some people’.104 In reality Burton appeared to have much in common with Crawford. Like Crawford, he was an established academic with an Oxford degree. His liberalism was of the Tawney variety, and he was often portrayed as more radical than he actually was. Unlike Crawford, Burton was friendly with the infamous P. R. Stephensen, who was sent down for being a member of the Communist Party and later gravitated to the right. By 1935 the Investigation Branch had become interested in Burton’s extracurricular activities and compiled a voluminous dossier on him. In practice, most academics refused to use the lecture podium to indoctrinate or recruit. Professionalism and prudence separated their politics from their teaching. They were, after all, highly trained scholars who shared with their colleagues the norms of their calling, including objectivity and fairness.105 Even so, Portus’s efforts were in vain, and Higgins’ bid was unsuccessful. Fitzpatrick was transferred from the English Department, and Crawford was quickly convinced that Scott had ‘sent me a winner’.106 A generous man by nature, Crawford remained supportive of Higgins’ scholarship and continued to correspond with him during his candidature for a Masters degree. The Higgins case showed the limits of liberalism in University circles. Politics now played a more critical role in selection. Those, like Higgins, who had ‘strayed’ found an academic career near impossible. Radical activists such as Brian Fitzpatrick and Stephensen operated outside the universities.107 Antagonism towards communism was not new, it had been a seething feature of Australian political life since the 1920s and was dramatised in the infamous ‘Kisch affair’.108 But as intellectuals became more engaged in the public sphere in the 1930s, a re-examination of their role occurred. Official surveillance of ‘suspect’ intellectuals was intensified. Since the 1920s Higgins had been of avid interest to the Investigation Branch, Australia’s equivalent to Britain’s MI5, with which it liaised and from which it drew inspiration and operational practices. MI5 provided information about various ‘suspect’ Australians, including postgraduate students at Oxford or Cambridge who joined the British Communist Party. Higgins was reported to be a ‘drug addict and to drink very heavily’ and had ‘a mischievous and objectionable character’.109 Richard Hofstadter observed of America that the appeal of communism was stronger among intellectuals than in the larger society.110
76
An Historian’s Life
This was equally true of Australia. In the 1930s the popular front attracted intellectuals to communism for the first time. The Depression and the dangers of fascism persuaded many of the younger generation to consider alternatives and, for many, communism was the only realistic option. Those who were resistant to actual membership were often attracted to the Communist Party’s ‘ambience of cultural engagement’.111 Crawford maintained a distinction between his own progressive liberalism and his capacity for radicalism. He could never overcome his ‘instinctive liberal inhibitions’.112 Although sympathetic to radical causes, he failed to engage fully with its principal form: popular-front communism. He was neither combative nor demonstrated at this point in his life that he was a ‘joiner’, which may have precluded him from Party membership. But Crawford also never criticised communism’s totalitarian excesses. Once the press began to report on the political sympathies of the young academics, the pressure intensified. Herbert Burton had written an article for Farrago entitled ‘No Imperialism’, on behalf of the Australian Council of Civil Liberties in early 1938.113 Sane Democracy, a conservative journal devoted to the ‘maintenance of British Democracy’, responded with a scathing editorial written by the architect Kingsley Henderson, entitled, ‘Subversionists at the University’.114 Henderson maintained that decent-minded students were disgusted with the spread of communism and anti-British propaganda at Melbourne University. He went on to distinguish between idealists, ‘waned and narrowed by academic education’, and the subversives, ‘the communists, cowards, pacifists and conscientious objectors’.115 Sir James Barrett, the Chancellor, dispatched an enraged letter to the Vice-Chancellor condemning academics (and Burton in particular) for bringing the University into disrepute. Priestley before his departure, responded calmly and advocated that the University should ‘enable controversial questions’ to be asked; he suggested the propaganda outside was ‘equally bad’.116 The article provided no credible evidence, but the potential damage to the University’s reputation alarmed the Professor of Law and President of the Professorial Board, Kenneth Bailey, who assumed the role of watchdog. Bailey, with his characteristic inability to take sides (Manning Clark observed that he was renowned for never offering an opinion, just ‘yes and no’), promptly sent a memo to the
'Forward the Professors'
77
offending professors.117 Bailey claimed, that although he was impartial, the article contained ‘an indictment of some aspects of University policy’.118 As caretaker before Medley’s arrival, Bailey received a tirade of letters from Barrett. Bailey vacillated between concurring with Barrett, who advocated imposing restraint on communications to the press by staff, and defence of academic independence.119 As the Henderson campaign against Burton intensified, Bailey claimed the attacks ‘verged on the hysterical’ and was critical that there was ‘little strength in the liberal-democratic traditions’ in Australia.120 Henderson prepared a list of fifty-six seditious societies that had University staff on their executives.121 Barrett saw some merit in the list and wrote a series of letters to the new Vice-Chancellor, who did not prove compliant. ‘If fair comment inspires disgust in a Sane Democrat, I prefer to live under some other regime.’ Medley responded with tactical wit. ‘And if Sane Democracy involves unquestioned allegiance to a tribal god, let us do it properly and have a little human sacrifice to propitiate it. I could suggest a number of victims and so, I expect could you.’122 Universities were not expected to challenge orthodoxies, though the University staff was fortunate that the new Vice-Chancellor was prepared to defend their academic independence.123 A similar issue erupted whenever the Bulletin condemned the academic fraternity’s inclination to become involved in politics as partisan reporters or ‘authorities’ on international events. The editor alleged that the ‘Professors’ were destroying their credibility by ‘policy pushing’ and bringing the Universities into disrepute.124 Many believed, and Crawford was one of them, that it was the intellectual’s role to offer public leadership. Stephen Roberts was the most visible and most frequently attacked intellectual who wrote on foreign affairs. He regarded his engagement as an intellectual obligation. During his absence from Sydney, he had been delighted that Crawford kept up this aspect of ‘his work’.125 If the condemnation of Roberts was any indication, the Bulletin did not object to the cult of the expert but the academic who contradicted its own assessment. In this case, Roberts had forecast war with Hitler and discussed the persecution of the Jewish community. The Bulletin saw merit in Hitler’s treatment of communists and blamed the Kristallnacht on a deluded ‘jewboy’ who had shot an official.126
78
An Historian’s Life
Sympathy for Nazism was not restricted to the press. One of Crawford’s colleagues, David Rivett, in a letter to James Barrett, had expressed his ‘admiration for this new Germany’ and said that the conception of the Hitler regime was ‘grotesquely wrong’.127 The Australian Council of Civil Liberties The Australian Council for Civil Liberties (ACCL) was formed in Melbourne in 1935. The seminal figure in its formation was the Left Book Club leader, Roy Rawson. Other leading figures were Brian Fitzpatrick, Theo Lucas, J. M. Atkinson, Eugene Gorman, J. V. Barry, Max Meldrum, Geoffrey Leeper, Dorothy Davis (later Fitzpatrick), Mollie Baynes and Mary Lazarus.128 The Council championed the major causes of the time, including the removal of censorship, the refugee crisis, the Crimes Act, retention of civil juries and the immigration dictation test. Its position on the Spanish Civil War was not so decisive. Most of the members were sympathetic to the anti-fascist cause in Spain but the ACCL, at Burton and Boyce Gibson’s prompting, disassociated itself publicly from the issue to ensure the ACCL would not become ‘associated in people’s minds with political movements and policies’. 129 Brian Fitzpatrick exerted the most significant impact on Crawford during his involvement with the Council. Crawford had first met the dynamic and charming, if unpredictable, radical when he became Fitzpatrick’s research supervisor. A co-founder of Farrago and the Melbourne University Labor Club, Fitzpatrick had worked as a journalist in Sydney and London for almost ten years until he returned to Melbourne. They were an incongruous couple; Crawford was circumspect, mannered and careful, Fitzpatrick was uncompromising, gregarious and outspoken in his defence of freedom and Australian nationalism.130 It was never an intense friendship, rather a relationship based on mutual respect, shared liberal interests and an aversion to joining political parties. Fitzpatrick was one of a long line of strong and unconventional men who appealed to Crawford— Wood, Bell, Lindsay, Anderson and later George Paul and Tawney— although no one quite matched his reverence for G. A. Wood. The other major player in the ACCL was Joe Burton. By the time Max Crawford was invited to become its VicePresident in early 1938, the Council was a well-established and
'Forward the Professors'
79
effective pressure group. His election might have at first appeared curious, for he was hardly a keen member of committees, but in many ways he was an ideal candidate for the Council. The numerous vicepresidents supposedly represented a cross-section of the community. As individuals of social stature in various professions, they were testament that the ACCL was ‘non-party and undenominational’.131 The arrangement allayed claims that the Council was a communist tool. Crawford’s refusal in the past to commit to a political organisation was part of his instinctive scepticism and caution. His historical training encouraged the pose of an impartial observer. What then persuaded him to attach himself to this organisation? Partly flattery and partly the conviction that the ACCL was non-sectarian, but there were also other incentives. Since his rewarding days at Oxford, Crawford had harboured a conviction that public engagement was both a pleasure and a duty, but he found the opportunities in Australia uninspiring. The Communist Party and the gamut of left-wing organisations were unappealing. They had no relevance to Crawford as an intellectual, so he remained on the periphery. The Council now provided a haven of sorts, with a group of highly visible individuals who espoused a humanist liberal democracy that accorded with Crawford’s own sympathies. His initial experience in the ACCL and growing concern for academic freedom was expressed in a lecture, ‘The Burden of Freedom’, delivered to the Philosophical Association in Melbourne in June 1938. If the earlier address to the Melbourne University Association was a rationalisation of his proposed changes to the History Department, this address was an intellectual defence of both the Council and freedom of speech. In a sense Crawford was publicly defining himself. ‘For the liberal,’ he said ‘the burden of liberty is his sense that liberty cannot simply be given to those who are unprepared, and that it cannot simply be imposed’. His premise was that the growth of liberty and tolerance during the previous century had diminished. ‘Freedom is not the beginning or the end,’ Crawford maintained. ‘It is not a natural right taken away, but an apparition formulated by human consciousness.’132 Crawford was concerned about freedom on a philosophical and personal level.133 As a liberal and champion for the ACCL, he
80
An Historian’s Life
condemned apologists for censorship because they were not concerned with truth, but security.134 His solution was somewhat naïve: ‘to keep the field open to critics, to the continuation and conflict of various interests and opinions’.135 Yet free expression was being eroded. What was the liberal to do? ‘Is he to surrender his belief as hopeless’ or must he go on ‘maintaining the necessity of his belief and try to keep the field open for argument and discussion?’136 The Study of History The ACCL paper was in many ways a prelude to a more important engagement, one that advanced Crawford professionally and fused his approach to history with his conviction that the past should illuminate the present. In October 1938, he accepted an invitation to serve as President of the History Section of the ANZAAS Congress, to be held in Canberra during January of the following year. Displaying uncharacteristic temper, Crawford was offended by the lateness of the invitation and the fact that he received it by default. A.B. Walkrom, the General Secretary, was left to mollify him and explain the confusion. Stephen Roberts had originally accepted the Presidency, but had also arranged to be in Europe at the time of the Congress. Roberts had failed to inform anyone of his other obligation, nor had he relinquished the position. It was only by accident that Walkrom discovered Robert’s alternative plans.137 The historian and committee member, Laurie Fitzhardinge, was ‘glad indeed’ that Crawford accepted. The committee’s relief was well founded; they had by accident gained an enthusiastic President who, without the usual luxury of procrastination, was forced to complete the obligatory Presidential address. The circumstances surrounding the writing of the paper were later recalled with some dramatic license, with Crawford insisting he was given only twelve days notice.138 According to the surviving correspondence, he had actually over two months to complete the piece. Crawford was nervous about the public reception of his address and considering his lack of runs on the board, it is understandable that two months felt like twelve days. The paper, entitled ‘The Study of History’, was presented in 114degree heat, with the area circling Canberra ravaged by bushfires. Ignoring the chaos and soaring heat outside, Crawford delivered a
'Forward the Professors'
81
paper in January 1939 that was autobiographical in nature and confident in tone. He documented his historical journey: a series of discoveries that began at Balliol, with Toynbee, Marx and Tawney, the last of whom moulded his liberalism, and Sydney and Melbourne, where he encountered the work of both Engels and Jose d Ortego. These influences culminated in the rejection of what he perceived as the insularity and narrowness of past historians such as Clarendon, von Ranke and Acton. Crawford proceeded to invalidate the claims to omniscience of the more aggressive adherents to the materialist school. Finally, he expanded his own case that a historian should by induction from his material, ‘attain to a really synoptic understanding’.139 The purpose articulated in the paper was to reach beyond mere politics and conduct and to engage in ‘the living past—ideas, assumptions, education and religious systems, institutions, the economic, social and political system dependent in the present by the past’. It was a striking debut that made an impression on its audience. The paper represented a well-worn historical road for Crawford. Many of its definitions and themes were lifted from the address delivered to the Melbourne University Association two years previously, with one important detour. Crawford was now resolved to examine the historian’s ‘true task’, a theme that was very much affected by the cathartic research undertaken for the Theory and Method subject and would have immense implications for his own political stance. He was now concerned with the individual’s response to the challenge of any given situation. This was what he termed the ‘drama of necessity and freedom’, the dualism of fatality and choice.140 It was, Crawford later argued, an essay of the 1930s, written at a time when he was intent on breaking away from the patterns of his own past. With conviction, he insisted historians should not merely reside in their cloistered ivory tower and assume distant objectivity, but assume a moral accountability. ‘I do believe’, Crawford insisted, ‘that he has the responsibility to make up his mind on the matters of which he writes, that the historian as such is not exempt from the universal duty of making up one’s mind.’141 Crawford’s enthusiasm for his Canberra paper did not fade with the disillusionment of his later years. In some ways, his position echoed the one adopted in G. A. Wood’s inaugural lecture of 1891. There Wood stated:
82
An Historian’s Life
that the business of the historian is to study the past that lives in the present...If history teaches anything, it teaches the solemn responsibility of every citizen to act strongly on his convictions.142 Crawford later remarked upon the ‘intriguing’ likeness’ of the ANZAAS paper and Wood’s vision of history, but he dismissed any suggestion of indebtedness by explaining that Wood’s views were unknown to him at the time.143 Certainly Crawford’s approach to historical causation was far more sophisticated and complex. Even if only on a subconscious level, Crawford remained faithful to Wood’s liberalism, moralism and interpretation of history. The Presidential address won admirers. Crawford proudly sent the published booklet to friends and colleagues, and the responses were universally complimentary. R. C. Mills wrote that he could not quarrel with it and was ‘disposed to accept Crawford’s point of view’.144 Nettie Palmer said he had answered nearly all the questions reverberating in her mind,145 and Humphrey Sumner ‘greatly enjoyed reading it’.146 Beyond his circle of friends and associates, however, Crawford’s first published effort was not without its detractors. Contemporary reviews cautioned the mainstream audience that it was a work essentially for students of history. The Advertiser bemoaned that its themes and terminology was acceptable for experts, but required simplification for general readers. Most of the critics had an axe to grind: The Advocate was critical of Crawford’s failure to attach full value to the religious dynamic in history, while the China Weekly Review accused him of being highly selective.147 Crawford’s lecture was audacious and unique for the time and had a profound imprint on the Australian historical landscape. The scope of his synoptic view was perhaps over-ambitious. The historian was now expected to synthesise a wide range of perspectives—political, economic, cultural, artistic and geographical—and exercise judgment and choice. As W. A. Townsley rightly observed, Crawford’s essay was suggestive and stimulating, but failed to erect enough signposts. ‘Someday we hope’, Townsley wrote in his review, ‘to be guided still further into this fascinating hinterland that forms somewhere the condominium of the realms of history and philosophy’.148 Crawford
'Forward the Professors'
83
should have read the warning signs in the career of his mentor. Wood had never managed to advance his ideas beyond their infancy, and his body of research remained limited. The ANZAAS paper had an additional significance. Buoyed by its enthusiastic reception, Crawford became more firmly convinced that there was a need for the creation of an Australian school of research in history and for the profession to become more cohesive. Since 1937, Kathleen Fitzpatrick, Norman Harper, Jessie Webb and Frank Wilmot, the manager of Melbourne University Press, had all been privy to Crawford’s hopes for an Australasian journal. It had been thought that such a publication needed the interest and active support of Australian and New Zealand historians. A perceived lack of this meant the infant plans were temporarily shelved.149 On 6 January 1939, Crawford was introduced to Gwyn James, a gifted and disenchanted tutor at St Andrews College, Sydney, who had presented a paper arguing for the establishment of an Australian historical journal. Crawford had first heard of James in 1938 from Hancock, who thought he would be ‘an acquisition to any University department of history’.150 Crawford listened eagerly to James’ ideas, many of which confirmed his own thoughts about an Australian historical journal. The climate now seemed more conducive to such a project. After the conference, Crawford wasted little time in corresponding with James about their shared objectives. James, in a confessional mood, responded by describing his frustration in a College of the University of Sydney, a ‘glorified hostel’, with its petty disciplinary problems and simmering animosities. More importantly, he gave the Professor his unconditional assurance that if a Melbourne appointment came along, he would ‘subordinate everything!’151 One of Crawford’s most enduring talents was his ability to recognise and enlist others with potential. He quickly assessed that James would be a fine editor for a national journal. Crawford’s assistance was by no means self-serving, and he appeared to have felt empathy for a struggling and frustrated young historian. Gwyn James surmised he had found a sympathetic benefactor and ally. The overwhelming difficulty was financing the publication. In April 1939, Crawford wrote to Wallace, the Vice-Chancellor at Sydney University, requesting immediate expenditure to enable the beginning
84
An Historian’s Life
of the journal. The plan was to produce a publication of world standing, one worthy of export.152 Crawford’s instinct and enterprise were impeccable. Australia needed an historical journal of its own, and he intended to be at the forefront of its establishment. Progress was slow and to avert the risk of losing Gwyn James, Crawford established a lectureship at Melbourne for the young historian. The eventual debut of the journal was a resounding success, and Crawford diligently played the role of guardian, protector and mediator. Some Sydney historians were disgruntled. Wallace had refused to subsidise the publication and argued that the time was not ripe because the field was sufficiently covered by other publications. Sydney University was also infuriated by its perceived under-representation in the first edition. It was left to Crawford to explain patiently to the Sydney Registrar that he had written early to Roberts inviting his interest, but received no reply. James and ‘an unnamed Sydney man’ had also attempted to contact the elusive Roberts, but to no avail.153 Largely because of Sydney’s disregard, Historical Studies, which Crawford called ‘a piece of inspired madness’, became a Melbourne enterprise. In spite of the tremendous pressure on Crawford, this was the beginning of his most charmed and productive period. He was in the midst of transforming a prominent University department and expressing a genuine Australian consciousness in the country’s first professional historical journal; moreover, he was about to embark on important matters of political and public interest. Judgment and Conscience It was not only the providence of history and the infant historical journal that preoccupied Crawford. The Vice-Chancellor gave him the opportunity to enforce his synoptic and moralist view by inviting him to join the National Service Committee. The committee was formed by the Professorial Board to discuss the vexing question of mobilisation, defence and University resources in the event of a national emergency.154 The outspoken Douglas Copland, who had not been comforted by the Munich Agreement or Hitler’s assurances of peace, had precipitated such a committee. In December 1938, Copland had written a memorandum insisting that should England become heavily
'Forward the Professors'
85
involved in a European conflict, Australia would be at ‘considerable risk’. The University, according to Copland, was in a unique position to strengthen democracy by forming a University corps that would infuse ‘a strong element of discipline and self sacrifice’ into the life of the community.155 Copland intended his controversial proposal for compulsory service to be tabled at the Council meeting and transmitted to the Professorial Board. The memorandum was not greeted with universal support, and Max Crawford was one of its most outspoken opponents. In a lengthy letter, he recorded his misgivings, the most fundamental being that it confused the function of the University with that of the national government. The University’s national service was to teach and train its research workers. ‘An integral part of the preparation for defence’, Crawford wrote, ‘must be criticism of national policy, particularly if, as I believe it is a policy which ignores the working of the anti-Comintern Pact and makes the dangers apparent’.156 In private, Crawford was less diplomatic and maintained that Copland’s proposal was dangerous and harmful, as it deviated from the University’s primary function of gaining the respect of the community and it fostered hysteria. Other members of the committee objected that the University could not participate in defence preparation unless the Commonwealth government demonstrated a stronger desire to participate.157 After a number of non-productive meetings during the summer vacation, the committee finally presented a detailed response to the Professorial Board at its first meeting in 1939 and announced it would adopt, in all essentials, Professor Copland’s recommendations. The Board did not underestimate the vehement opposition of the liberal fringe. During a heated meeting on 27 February, Kenneth Bailey suggested to Crawford that he should speak to members of his department to achieve a consensus.158 ‘I am not going to bring any pressure to bear on members of my staff either to favour or to oppose it’, Crawford retorted. ‘I shall leave their individual attitudes to their private judgment and conscience.’159 He had found a strong voice and could not resist giving Bailey a lesson in historical method that championed the qualities associated with the History School. The Department’s best performance, Crawford insisted, was to teach its students to think ‘honestly and cogently’ without propaganda and coercion.
86
An Historian’s Life
Embarrassed by his emotional outburst, Crawford wrote to the Vice-Chancellor, in a more conciliatory mood, with an explanation of his behaviour. His manner during that day might have been uncharacteristic, but it demonstrated Crawford’s susceptibility to stress and his unwillingness to resist the majority. If he had not been as ‘mentally tired’, he explained, he could have made his position clearer.160 Although he was prepared to defend his staff and had no intention of enforcing uniformity on them, he was also prepared to concede ground and did so by accepting voluntary national service. On 27 May 1939, a report was drafted that acknowledged the objections and dismissed them as unfounded. However, in the face of the opposition, the Board had no other option than to let the report ‘lie for the present on the table’ and proceed with other aspects on national service on which complete agreement existed. It was decided that a University National Service organisation ‘be formed on a voluntary basis to plan and co-ordinate staff and students’. Other aspects of the ‘agreement’ remained unresolved.161 While the University was awkwardly grappling with the defence debate, larger issues loomed over the Government’s National Registration Bill. Conceived towards the end of 1938, the Register was a voluntary aid to the assessment of manpower resources. By the following March, the government was convinced that compulsion was necessary and, in May, the Minister of Defence, G. A. Street, announced that National Registration would be enacted.162 The register required all men between 18 and 65 to answer eleven questions designed to indicate the individual’s potential value in the workforce. Advocates of the University’s National Service Committee felt vindicated by the government’s decision. Despite the grievances aired in certain departments (particularly History), it was decided that the University would compile lists of ‘reserved occupations’ and of material resources and personnel available for defence service. These decisions provoked further dissent within the student body, the Student Representatives’ Council, which announced that it was unwilling to co-operate unless the scope of the register was widened.163 The National Registration Bill was passed in the Senate on 16 June 1939. If the proposal for National Service had splintered the University, the national debate divided the ACCL. Crawford had
'Forward the Professors'
87
become a more conspicuous player after he delivered a brief but controversial paper on the necessity of the Parliament as a safeguard of liberty at the fourth annual meeting of the Council on 18 May 1939. It expressed Crawford’s misgivings that the Australian Parliament was delegating too much and approaching the status of the British Parliament of the seventeenth century, which met for brief periods and dealt with only fundamental changes in constitutional or ecclesiastical matters.164 ‘The Parliament’, he said, ‘must debate the principles and effects of legislation and should be more responsive to the needs of the community or it would fall into contempt and become a political atrophy’.165 These statements were duly reported in the daily newspapers and brought a strong reply from the Prime Minister, Robert Menzies. ‘I am a great believer in regular parliament sessions and full parliamentary discussions of legislation and matters of policy’, Menzies reassured the press. Professor Crawford would no doubt agree the increased complexity of the problems which the government has to deal with means an increased delegation of powers since it would be quite impractical for Parliament to deal with a thousand and one matters of detail. 166 Menzies’ retort was patronising, as it dismissed Crawford and other ‘onlookers’ who suggested that the wellbeing of the community was served more by the number of days Parliament sat rather than ‘wise and well-considered legislation’.167 The National Registration Bill was possibly the judicious legislation Menzies was referring to. The government’s actions infuriated the ACTU, which considered the Register a device of industrial conscription that threatened trade unionism. After an endless round of meetings, an ACTU emergency committee urged a boycott.168 Melbourne University became implicated when Brian Fitzpatrick, the ACCL secretary, privately defended the ACTU decision, and the President, Herbert Burton, who assumed the unsanctioned role of public spokesman, opposed it. In July Burton became aware of Fitzpatrick’s views, and a misunderstanding arose when the rest of the University identities within the ACCL believed they were connected with the ACTU’s
88
An Historian’s Life
boycott. On 14 July Burton wrote to the Melbourne newspapers declaring that the boycott was ‘a dangerous procedure if we wish to maintain our democratic institutions’.169 His almost obsessive desire to ensure that the Council did not become a mouthpiece for the left was now apparent.170 The animosity surfaced at an Executive Meeting on 19 July 1939. The meeting was called by Fitzpatrick to acquaint all the state officebearers of the Council of ‘certain difficulties’ in connection with the conduct of the Council’s campaign. Fitzpatrick recalled that on 30 June, the committee for the Council advised the ACTU and prepared a statement that was published by the ACCL as The Case Against the National Register.171 Despite the avowed accord between the organisations, it was understood that the ACCL could not publicly support the boycott. It would, according to Fitzpatrick, inform but not ‘instruct any citizen in what their democratic duty was’. This policy was apparently discussed with Burton’s knowledge. Certain committee members were none too happy with Burton’s perceived arrogance and believed his unauthorised comments to the press had ‘damaged the campaign against the register and would create great internal discord as well as destroying the confidence of the trade union movement’. Vance Palmer claimed that Burton’s letter was ‘gratuitous and unnecessary’ and ‘weakened the cause of those who wished to see the Acts amended’. Brian Fitzpatrick’s response was to relay a stinging retort to the press that contradicted the President’s position.172 The University academics offered a united front behind Burton, who announced they were tired of being treated as ‘stuffed shirts’.173 The President informed the Executive Committee on the evening of the 19 July that unless they consented to publish a third statement of policy denouncing the boycott, he, Max Crawford, Sandy Gibson, Austin Edwards, Colin Badger and H. A. Woodruff would resign. ‘You have to choose whether you will accept this statement of policy,’ Burton informed the Committee, ‘at any rate the expression of opposition to the boycott, or whether you will become just another left organisation. If you don’t accept there will be a landslide of VicePresidents.’174 The remainder of the Council considered this threat as coercion and sought advice from Eugene Gorman. Although the image of rebel did not sit comfortably with Crawford, he began to have private doubts about the camp he was
'Forward the Professors'
89
allied with. The following day on 20 July, Brian Fitzpatrick contacted him. Perhaps sensing his wavering commitment to Burton’s position, he implored Crawford, ‘whose judgment he respected’, to reconsider the ‘facts’ of his position. He reminded him of Burton’s prior knowledge of the publication of The Case Against the National Register, his own consistent aversion to self-promotion and the damage to the ‘good relations’ that would be caused by an exodus.175 Fitzpatrick’s letter and a frantic telephone call on the Thursday evening had the desired effect, and Crawford wrote immediately to Burton withdrawing his resignation. In doing this, he was not exactly aligning himself with the other side. In fact, he maintained that the National Register was not sufficiently menacing to civil liberties to warrant resorting to the ultimate safeguard of democracy: the right to resist. The manner in which Burton courted publicity infuriated Crawford. He believed that informing the public was a matter for the Executive Committee, not an individual. If the majority voted against the publication of the statement condemning the boycott, Crawford would abide by the decision and would not feel obliged to resign as Vice-President.176 With Crawford’s self-confessed penchant for compromise, it was surprising and revealing that he remained the only dissenter in the academic camp. Fitzpatrick sought to placate the remaining five and repair the damage and disunited image of the ACCL with a letter to the press that clarified the differences over the boycott and the intention to prevent the divisions from becoming ‘political propaganda’.177 Aware of Crawford’s ‘modification’ of attitude regarding the ‘sad issue’, Austin Edwards urged him to remain united on the University front.178 He reminded all the Vice-Presidents that they could not support the boycott because it conflicted with the task of informing the public impartially, and he appealed to their sense of honour. By supporting the ACTU they would leave themselves open to the suspicion that they were a group on the left masquerading as a legitimate Council for Civil Liberties. Unconvinced, Crawford resisted the pressure. The conflict of personal affiliations and public obligations began to punctuate Crawford’s life more frequently. He later attempted to resolve his ambivalent feelings towards the nature of politics and the perception others had of him. Defensively he recalled:
90
An Historian’s Life
‘I often found myself pushed by the circumstances of the late 1930s in particular into uncomfortable stands that were, in the terms of that time, radical’.179 His conduct at the time contradicts this recollection. Crawford was not pushed or cajoled. His decisions were measured, voluntary and deliberate. In the case of the compulsory University national service, he resisted the pressure imposed by Bailey. During the ACCL conflict, he found himself on the outer, a position he was not accustomed to, and he opposed the University camp. In both examples, Max Crawford was not forced and, on both occasions, he adopted the controversial and radical position. A temporary solution was found in the ACCL that placated the chief antagonists. Burton and Fitzpatrick agreed that in future neither would publish any material without the consent of the other. In August the Council adopted a more satisfactory and democratic resolution to preserve the unity of an organisation made up of divergent political sympathies and petty jealousies. The circular to the VicePresidents read: That in the event of any major political issue arising in which issues of civil liberties appear to be inevitable, and in which members of the Council might be expected to take different views, the Executive Committee may invite all members to give their views and to attend a meeting so that a policy of the Council may be thoroughly discussed.180 It was an astute provision, because events in Europe gave every indication that there would be much to debate. Several weeks after the circular was issued, the ACCL was confronted with a decisive and unexpected political alliance. On 23 August 1939, the Nazi-Soviet Pact was signed. On this occasion the ACCL managed to arrive at an agreed position with very little negotiation. Worse was to come when Germany attacked Poland in the early hours of 1 September and, two days later, England and Germany went to war for the second time. Australians learned of their fate when, on 3 September, a solemn Robert Menzies announced on the radio that they were to join Britain in the conflict.
'Forward the Professors'
91
Notes 1
George Tibbits, The Planning and Development of the University of Melbourne (The University of Melbourne: History of the University Unit, 2000), 23.
2
Hancock, Country and Calling, 108.
3
Crawford to Registrar, University of Melbourne, 15 October 1936, Box 6, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
4
Memorandum on the Chair of History, 29 April 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA. For a complete account of Ernest Scott’s life and work, see Stuart Macintyre, Scott: A History for a Nation (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 1994) and Stuart Macintyre, ‘Ernest Scott: ‘My History Is a Romance’ in The Discovery of Australian History.
5
Professor Scott died of a coronary thrombosis on 6 December 1939.
6
Rowse, Australian Liberalism and National Character, 91.
7
Ibid.
8
R.E. Priestley to D. B. Copland, 28 June 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
9
Ibid.
10
Ibid.
11
W.K. Hancock to D. B. Copland, 13 July 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
12
Hancock, Country and Calling, 126.
13
Keith Hancock to D. B. Copland, 13 July 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
14
Julian Thomas, ‘Keith Hancock: Professing the Profession’, in The Discovery of Australian History 1890-1939, 151.
15
Chair of History, 10 November 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
16
Kenneth Bell to G. V. Browne, 7 October 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
17
Ibid.
18
Ibid.
19
S. Roberts to Ernest Scott, 16 December 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
20
Ibid.
21
Deryck Schreuder, ‘An Unconventional Founder: Stephen Roberts and the Professionalisation of the Historical Discipline’, in The Discovery of Australian History, 134.
22
Ibid.
92
An Historian’s Life
23
A. D. Lindsay to R. Priestley, 13 October 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
24
Chair of History, 10 November 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
25
Stephen Roberts to Ernest Scott, 16 December 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
26
C. H. Currey to R. Priestley, 28 October 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
27
Kenneth Bell to G. V. Browne, 7 October 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
28
Chair of History, 10 November 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
29
R. E. Priestley Diary, 18 December 1936, R. E. Priestley Papers, UMA.
30
Macintyre, Making History, 44.
31
Report by the Chair of History Committee, 30 December 1936, 1936/202, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
32
R. E. Priestley Diary, 22 December 1936, R. E. Priestley Papers, UMA.
33
Argus, January 1937.
34
Macintyre, ed. Making History, 44.
35
Stuart Macintyre, ‘Ernest Scott: ‘My History Is a Romance’, in The Discovery of Australian History, 71.
36
Gordon Greenwood to Crawford, 5 January 1937, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
37
Christopher Cook to Crawford, date unknown, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
38
R. Priestley to Crawford, 8 January 1937, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
39
Registrar to Crawford, 9 January 1937, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
40
R. E. Priestley Diary, 8 February 1937, R. E. Priestley Papers, UMA. The Vice-Chancellor described a dinner attended by Crawford and his staff.
41
Memorandum on the Chair of History, 29 April 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
42
Crawford to Harry Crawford, 24 June 1929, Box 2, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
43
Crawford to Professor Todd, 21 May 1936, Box 6, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
44
Docker, Australian Cultural Elites, 156-8. See also Holt, Manning Clark and Australian History, 98-100; Manning Clark, ‘Melbourne: An Intellectual Tradition’, Melbourne Historical Journal (1962), 4; and Donald Horne, The Lucky Country: Australia in the Sixties (Melbourne: Penguin Books, 1964).
'Forward the Professors'
93
45
Clark, The Quest for Grace, 29. Clark made a similar observation in Crawford’s presence at the History Institute’s forum in 1984, which was the genesis of Making History: Macintyre, ed., Making History, 56. Crawford’s favoured students constantly referred to his ability as a teacher.
46
Serle, Melbourne Historical Journal (1970), 4.
47
Macintyre, ed., Making History, 45.
48
Conversation with Frank Ford, 1998.
49
Kenneth Bell to G. V. Browne, 7 October 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
50
Macintyre, Making History, 35.
51
R. M. Crawford, A Bit of a Rebel: The Life and Work of G. A. Wood. (Sydney: Sydney University Press, 1975), 127 and 150.
52
Macintyre, Making History, 35.
53
Using Farrago, the student magazine from Melbourne University, as a barometer of undergraduate political expression, the reaction to the Spanish crisis was surprisingly gradual. The prevailing concerns were typical of student life: socialising, sport, essays and examinations. The only political issue of note that was written about was war and the growing pacifist movement. Spain was first mentioned in the context of civil war in August 1936: ‘That Spanish Business’, Farrago, 13 August 1936.
54
William Muir to Crawford, 13 June 1937, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
55
Christopher Cook to Crawford, 7 June 1937, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
56
Farrago, 23 March 1937.
57
Manning Clark, The Quest for Grace, 46. The speakers for the affirmative were S. J. Ingwersen, B. A. Santamaria and K. T. Kelly, and for the negative, Nettie Palmer, Dr. G. O’Day and J. W. Legge. The atmosphere of the public lecture theatre was corroborated by Farrago, 23 March 1937.
58
‘Open Letter to Mr Burton’, Farrago, 13 April 1937.
59
Raymond Priestley, Diary, 1 December 1936, R. E. Priestley Papers, UMA.
60
Clark, The Quest for Grace, 52.
61
‘Protect your Freedom. Dr. Priestley Condemns Abuses: Free Speech and Discussion’, Farrago, 4 May 1937.
62
Crawford to Editor of the Argus, April 1937.
63
Ibid.
64
‘Forward the Professors!’, The Bulletin, 28 April 1937.
65
‘Professors and Politics’, Farrago, 27 April 1937.
66
R. E. Priestley’s address to Country Party at Geelong, 15 April 1937, R. E. Priestley Papers, UMA.
67
‘Letter to Editor’, Herald, 29 April 1937, R. E. Priestley Papers, UMA.
94
An Historian’s Life
68
Crawford, An Australian Perspective, 64.
69
Crawford to R. E. Priestley, 4 May 1937, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
70
Ibid. The separation of Political Science from History was one decision that was not made by Crawford, although it coincided with his appointment.
71
Draft on Honours School, no date, History Department Papers, UMA. Please note that part of the History Department collection at UMA has not been given box numbers.
72
Crawford to Alison Patrick, 28 April 1978, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA. Crawford described the foundations of the paper and the sense of urgency.
73
R. M. Crawford. ‘History’ Address to the Melbourne University Association, 11 June 1937, Box 8, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
74
Ibid.
75
R. M. Crawford, ‘The Antipodean Pilgrimage of Arnold Wood’, Royal Australian Historical Society Journal, vol 48 (March 1963), 26-31.
76 77
‘The Historian’s Task’, Farrago, 22 June 1937. Crawford to R. E. Priestley, ‘Proposed changes in the Department of History’, 22 June 1937, History Department Papers, UMA.
78
Lewis Wilcher to Crawford, 26 January 1937, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
79
Crawford to John Medley, 1 July 1938, 1937/233, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA. See also Macintyre, A History for a Nation, 202.
80
Ibid.
81
Macintyre, ed., Making History, 6.
82
R. E. Priestley to Crawford, 1937, History Department Papers, UMA.
83
See Robert Dare, Crawford on Theory and Method of History’, in Max Crawford’s School of History, 13-40.
84
Macintyre, ed., Making History, 47. See Horne, The Lucky Country, and also Holt, The Quest for Grace, for an analysis of the cultural elites in Sydney and Melbourne.
85
Max Crawford notes, Box 75, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
86
Macintyre, ed., Making History, 46.
87
Ibid., 45-6.
88
Memorandum to R. E. Priestley, 5 May 1937, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
89
C. H. Currey to R. E. Priestley, 28 October 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
90
Interview with Ken Crawford, 2001.
91
Crawford, Historical Studies (1971), 30. Macintyre, ed., Making History, 46.
92
R. M. Crawford ‘The Spanish Background’, drafted paper, occasion and date unknown, Box 10, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
'Forward the Professors'
95
93
Ibid.
94
R. M. Crawford, ‘The Troubles in Spain’, drafted paper, 1937, Box 10, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
95
Ibid.
96
R. M. Crawford ‘Spain or more’, drafted plan, 1937, Box 10, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
97
Ernest Scott to Crawford, 15 March 1937, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
98
Carey and Grimshaw, Women Historians and Women’s History, 11.
99
The bid for her promotion was unsuccessful. Jessie Webb was the first woman to hold a permanent position in an Australian History Department. For full autobiographical details, see Ronald Ridley, Jessie Webb: A Memoir (Melbourne: History Department, University of Melbourne, 1994); Susan Janson. ‘Jessie Webb and the Predicament of the Female Historian’, in The Discovery of Australian History, 91-110.
100
Kathleen Fitzpatrick to Crawford, no date, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA. Kathleen Fitzpatrick’s biography is: Solid Bluestone Foundations and Other Memories of a Melbourne Childhood:1908-1928. (Melbourne: Macmillan, 1983). For other works relating to Kathleen Fitzpatrick, see Susan Davies, ‘Kathleen Fitzpatrick: Sculpture with Words’ in The Discovery of Australian History, 158-173; Susan Davies, ed., Dear Kathleen, Dear Manning: The Letters of Manning Clark and Kathleen Fitzpatrick, 19491990 (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 1996) and Carey and Grimshaw, Women Historians and Women’s History.
101
Susan Davies, ‘Kathleen Fitzpatrick: Sculpture with Words’ in The Discovery of Australian History, 172.
102
Michael Roe, ‘E. M. Higgins: A Marxist in Tasmania 1936-1938’, Labour History, no. 32 (May 1977).
103
G. V. Portus to Raymond Priestley, 9 December 1937, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
104
Chair of History, 10 November 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
105
See Schrecker, No Ivory Tower, for a fine analysis of the plight of American academic communists in the 1930s and 1940s.
106
Max Crawford, ‘A Tribute’, given by ‘A Celebration of the Life of Kathleen Fitzpatrick by Former Students, Colleagues and Friends’ in the History Department of the University of Melbourne on 20 September 1990, R. M. Crawford papers, UMA.
107
Bolton, The Oxford History of Australia Vol. 5, 6.
108
A delegate to the All Australian Congress Against War and Fascism, Egon Kisch arrived in Australia in 1934. He was declared a prohibited immigrant and subjected to a dictation test under the Immigration Restriction Act. While the High Court declared this use of the Act invalid, legal arguments
96
An Historian’s Life
continued for four months while Kisch travelled the country on a speaking tour. The treatment of Kirsch was used as a test case of the quality of Australian democracy, as issues of Communism, opposition to Fascism and ‘foreign elements’ came to the forefront. Gollan, Revolutionaries and Reformists, 44-8. 109
Esmonde McDonald Higgins, A6126, 411, ASIO File, NAA. In its various guises, Security had been instrumental in intimidating, banning and imprisoning radicals. The Russian Revolution intensified distrust, although the CPA was not created until 1920. For another decade, the CPA was a small and uninfluential group that had little impact, due to its alienation from trade unions and the Labor movement. It grappled with rifts over doctrine and always had a furtive and secretive aura that terrified the establishment.
110
Hofstadter, Anti-Intellectualism in American Life, 40.
111
Macintyre, The Reds. 319-20.
112
Ibid., 325.
113
The Council approached Burton, the senior lecturer in Economic History at Melbourne University, on his return from Europe in March in 1936.
114
Sane Democracy, Vol 2, No.4, April 1938, 1.
115
Ibid.
116
R.E. Priestley to James Barrett, 13 April 1938, James Barrett Papers, UMA.
117
Clarke, The Quest for Grace.
118
Memorandum by Kenneth Bailey, 29 April 1938, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
119
Kenneth Bailey to James Barrett, 10 May 1938, James Barrett Papers, UMA.
120
Kenneth Bailey to James Barrett, 2 June 1938, James Barrett Papers, UMA.
121
Geoffrey Serle, Sir John Medley: A Memoir (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 1993).
122
John Medley to James Barrett, 1 November 1938, James Barrett Papers, UMA.
123
Bolton, The Oxford History of Australia: Vol. 5.
124
‘These Professors’, The Bulletin, 6 April 1938. 12.
125
Stephen Roberts to Ernest Scott, 16 December 1936, 1936/201, Registrar’s Correspondence, UMA.
126
Bulletin, 26 October 1938 and 16 November 1938.
127
David Rivett to Sir James Barrett, 9 September 1936, James Barrett Papers, UMA.
128
Don Watson, Brian Fitzpatrick: A Radical Life (Sydney, Hale and Ironmonger, 1979), 80.
129
ACCL Executive Committee Minutes, 22 October 1936, MS 4965, Brian Fitzpatrick Papers, NLA. See also Don Watson’s interpretation.
'Forward the Professors'
97
130
For biographical details on Brian Fitzpatrick, see Watson, Brian Fitzpatrick: A Radical Life and Don Watson, ‘Brian Fitzpatrick’ in Australian Dictionary of Biography.
131
Watson, Brian Fitzpatrick, 81.
132
R. M. Crawford, ‘The Burden of Freedom’, Philosophical Association, June 1938, 1, Box 8, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
133
Ibid., 4.
134
Ibid., 10.
135
Ibid., 14.
136
Ibid., 21.
137
A. B. Walkrom to Crawford, 21 October 1939, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
138
Macintyre, ed., Making History, 48 and Crawford, Historical Studies (1971), 33. The paper was actually drafted in November and December 1938.
139
R. M. Crawford, The Study of History: A Synoptic View (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 1939).
140
Macintyre, ed., Making History, 12.
141
Ibid.
142
Wood, G. A. ‘Inaugural Lecture, ‘Criticism and Sympathy’, May 1891. Quoted by H. Partridge, The Contribution of Philosophy and History.
143
Crawford to Alison Patrick, 28 April 1978, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
144
R. C. Mills to Crawford, 9 June 1939, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
145
Nettie Palmer to Crawford, 10 June 1939, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
146
Humphrey Sumner to Crawford, 23 July 1939, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
147
‘Book Review’, Advocate, 18 May 1939; ‘Review’, China Weekly Review, September 1939.
148
Townsley, W. A. ‘Review on the Study Of History’, Historical Studies (1940), 68-69.
149
Crawford to Wallace, 14 April 1939, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
150
This information from Hancock is quoted in a reference written for James. Crawford to the Registrar of University of Witwatersrand, South Africa, 22 March 1944, Gwyn James Collection.
151
Gwyn James to Crawford, 24 April 1939, Gwyn James Papers, UMA.
152
Crawford to Wallace, 14 April 1939, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
153
Crawford to the Registrar of Sydney University, 30 August 1939, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA. The foundations of the journal were laid by the organising committee that comprised Crawford, Scott, Portus, Wood, Fitzhardinge, James, Ida Leeson and Merab Hearns.
98
An Historian’s Life
154
Medley also drafted Copland, Greenwood, Gibson, Giblin, Burstall, Laby, Bailey and MacCallum.
155
Douglas Copland, ‘Memorandum: The University and National Service’, 28 November 1938, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
156
R. M. Crawford ‘Comment on Douglas Copland’s Memorandum: The University and National Service’, date unknown, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
157
Ibid.
158
Crawford to Kenneth Bailey, 27 February 1939, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA. This exchange was described in Crawford’s letter.
159
Ibid.
160
Crawford to John Medley, date unknown, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
161
Draft Report from the Professorial Board with regard to proposals concerning the University and National Service, 27 May 1939, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
162
Watson, Brian Fitzpatrick, A Radical Life, 94.
163
National Service Committee Report, 27 May 1939, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
164
R. M. Crawford ‘The Necessity of Parliament as a Safeguard of Liberty’, 18 May 1939. Crawford maintained that Federal parliament had sat for periods ranging from 29 to 73 days a year.
165
Ibid.
166
Sun, 18 May 1939. Menzies’ response was also reported in the Argus, 19 May 1939, and The Age, 20 May 1939.
167
Sun, 18 May 1939.
168
Watson, Brian Fitzpatrick, A Radical Life, 94.
169
Argus, 15 July 1939.
170
Herbert Burton, ‘Memorandum from the President to members of the Executive Committee and Vice-Presidents on the internal affairs of the Council for Civil Liberties’, MS 4965, Brian Fitzpatrick Papers, NLA.
171
Brian Fitzpatrick, ‘7 September 1939, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA. Memorandum to all Office Bearers.’ MS 4965, Brian Fitzpatrick Papers, NLA. The Committee consisted of Fitzpatrick, J.V. Barry and Maurice Blackburn.
172
Ibid.
173
Ibid.
174
Herbert Burton, ‘Memorandum from the President to members of the Executive Committee…’
175
Brian Fitzpatrick to Crawford, 20 July 1939, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
'Forward the Professors'
99
176
Crawford to Herbert Burton, 20 July 1939, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
177
Watson, Brian Fitzpatrick, 100-2.
178
Austin Edwards to Crawford, 21 July 1939, Box 7, R. M. Crawford Papers, UMA.
179
Macintyre, ed., Making History, 35.
180
ACCL Circular, 8 August 1939, MS 4965, Brian Fitzpatrick Papers, NLA.
100
An Historian’s Life
Chapter 3
War and Diplomacy
In 1940 Max Crawford wrote a weary and despondent letter to his mother in which he summarised the pressures of his life: I would like to pop over for a while, and even to forget for a moment the stresses of the time. Writing a text book (a thing I have steadily refused to do for five years); doing one’s best for those students who are trying to work on after having enlisted, and who are expecting to be called up at any time, and preparing to carry extra work in the hope that one of our staff who is going away with the AIF won’t have to lose too much salary; and the necessary and unpopular business of asking unpopular questions—all make this term seem interminable, though it is nothing to what we might be facing.1 Crawford had not embellished the problems facing him as a public intellectual. Nor did he elaborate on the unpopular questions and what compelled him to ask them. The key to his dispirited mood was the war and the government’s reaction to it. Neither he nor most of his ACCL associates welcomed Australia’s military support of Britain. Indeed, after Menzies’ announcement, the majority of
War and Diplomacy
101
Australians failed to react with the idealistic and patriotic fervour that heralded the corresponding call to arms in 1914. Brian Fitzpatrick and J. V. Barry had anticipated the Prime Minister’s loyalty to the Empire. On 6 September 1939 they formed an Emergency Committee within the ACCL, a select group of the more vocal and identifiable members. It comprised Barry and Crawford as Vice-Presidents, Rawson and J. G. Radford, the two members of the Executive Committee, Fitzpatrick as General Secretary and Burton as President. An uneasy truce had been established between Fitzpatrick and Burton since the threatened resignation of the academic contingent several months earlier. Crawford, however, was encouraged by the charismatic Fitzpatrick, who was ‘grateful’ for his participation and ‘good Chairmanship’.2 An experienced political activist, Fitzpatrick possibly charmed the more impressionable Crawford. The comfortable relationship between Fitzpatrick and Crawford was by no means shared within the entire group, and the war almost immediately punctured the tenuous compromises accepted by the principal figures in the Council. A. B. Gibson was the first to resign, offering two reasons for his decision. Firstly, he believed the exigencies of war diminished the importance of civil liberties and, secondly, he suspected that members of the Executive Committee were ‘active supporters of the USSR’ and therefore defenders of the Nazi-Soviet Pact, which Gibson blamed for the war.3 One week later, Joe Burton tendered his resignation as President, but not before discussing it over lunch with Crawford and the other ‘university people’. In a scrawled note to Crawford written on 15 September, he insisted that his decision was ‘in no way influenced by the present state of war’. ‘I am’, he explained, ‘still as attached as ever to the cause of democratic liberty’.4 In a long memorandum to the members of the Executive Committee and the Vice-Presidents, Burton identified the cause of his resignation as ‘internal affairs’. He observed that the left now outnumbered the ‘liberals’, who had formed a ‘homogenous block’ in the Executive in 1936.5 Burton believed that it was impossible to assure the public and government that the ACCL was more concerned with civil liberty than ‘promoting the political aims of the left’. He condemned Fitzpatrick specifically, defining his behaviour as ‘intolerable’ and blaming him for establishing ‘a self-
102
An Historian’s Life
perpetuating oligarchy’. The Council, he believed, could no longer claim to be an ‘independent body’.6 The memo caused considerable damage. Vance Palmer wrote to Fitzpatrick, concerned that various Vice-Presidents would use it as an excuse for resigning. Palmer suggested that ‘it would be different if the Council were a political body with clearly defined ends. But it isn’t, it rests on a vague basis of agreement in liberal views.’7 Burton’s resignation was short-lived and he was apparently coaxed back to the ACCL by Crawford’s moderate stance and calm presence. On Palmer’s advice, Fitzpatrick suggested that Burton discuss the ‘various acts and regulations regarding the National Security Act’ with Crawford.8 Palmer then urged Fitzpatrick to meet Burton and arrange for a ‘war cabinet’ presided over by someone like Crawford, whom he considered ‘outside the range of our present confines’.9 Crawford emerged at this time as a more confident, decisive and outspoken member for the Council. Supporting the ACCL, he believed was one way to sustain the ‘united efforts of democratic people’.10 Pacifism and anti-war protest were prominent on the campus at the time. ‘It was fashionable to be anti-war’, Niall Brennan, a student at the time, recalled. ‘Hitler’s blitzkrieg disconcerted some in the middle of the year, but even so the revue that year was full of anti-war sketches. The Labor Club was aggressively anti-war. There was graffiti all over the campus.’ The University Council became so concerned that it ruled that staff members could not become involved in the Labor Club elections. A ‘New No-Hate’ movement was also launched, involving students and staff.11 Crawford’s conviction that freedom needed defending was strengthened by the National Security Act, which curtailed liberties deemed dangerous in wartime. Enacted by Menzies five days after the grim announcement of war, the legislation was reminiscent of the War Precautions Act of World War One. For the older Council members such as Vance Palmer, Maurice Blackburn and Frank Brennan, it was a travesty, a sad repetition of the past.12 Indeed, for a whole generation of radicals, the previous war had been regarded as a mistake. None of the members of the Council denied that some restrictions were necessary to sustain the present war effort. They believed, however, that the Act was indiscriminate and that Menzies’ assurance that ‘institutions, Parliament, all liberal thought, free speech, free
War and Diplomacy
103
criticism, must go on’13 was hypocritical. Neither Fitzpatrick nor Crawford were convinced that Menzies genuinely cherished the values of a liberal democracy.14 The potential for political abuse was considerable. Section 8 allowed a judge to ‘hold’ a political trial in secret with provision for the detention of suspects by police for ten days without a charge. Any previous act of Parliament, according to Section 18, could be nullified by a ministerial regulation. The government was in effect free to govern by administrative rather than legislative practice and could introduce new regulations at its ‘discretion’.15 Some members of the Council thought the provisions were dictatorial and indicative of the government’s duplicity. Fitzpatrick likened the powers to Hitler’s methods.16 Most had three particular objections to the government’s measures: the Act did not protect civil courts and legal processes; it imposed censorship on the press; it deprived the public of their right to assemble, speak and protest.17 Accusations that the ACCL was a communist front were constant throughout 1939 and 1940. Although Crawford had made a ‘firm vow’ to avoid all public speaking and concentrate on research work, he made an exception for the ACCL.18 Undisturbed by the rumours of communist infiltration, he prepared for the ACCL summer school in February 1940 with enthusiasm. He chaired a session on the National Security Legislation, and was the featured speaker with Fitzpatrick in a session entitled, ‘What are we to do?’19 It is not known if Crawford attended another ACCL activity in the same month. Fitzpatrick had issued a request for the whole committee to meet at the tram station in Batman Avenue and ‘observe proceedings’ at the communist meeting on the Yarra Bank, where police had regularly obstructed meetings.20 Possibly in response to a series of these requests, one of the Vice-Presidents, Paul Dane resigned, claiming that the organisation was ‘a camouflage for communist or semi-communist ideas’. Dane emphasised that these ideas were ‘dangerous and foolish’.21 Fitzpatrick responded in a letter to Dane that there was no reason for his statement, and the Council was an organisation for the ‘defence of civil liberties’.22 Solidarity and Conscience The restrictions were extended in February 1940 when the Commonwealth government announced that censorship was no
104
An Historian’s Life
longer restricted to matters pertaining to the war effort. The amendment provided for all matter intended for publication to be scrutinised. Keith Murdoch, the press tycoon, was appointed DirectorGeneral of Information and given power to suppress information and censor newspapers. A letter protesting against the extension of censorship was published in April in a Western Australian newspaper. It was signed by a number of prominent people including the Archbishop of Perth, Professor Walter Murdoch and the Pro-Chancellor of the University of Western Australia. Crawford sent a telegram to Walter Murdoch asking for the text. In a mood of solidarity and ‘conscience’, he consulted with thirty of his University colleagues, and the group drafted a letter in support of the West Australian protest and offered similar objections.23 The letter acknowledged that a certain degree of censorship was necessary, but that the prohibition of communist press and trade union journals discussing the war, mentioning Russia or its government, or referring to industrial unrest within the Empire or any allied country, was excessive. The letter emphasised that the staff were writing as individuals ‘who cannot and do not attempt to express any official University view on the subject’.24 It was a courageous and radical move. Unfortunately, the protest was ‘badly timed’, for Germany had just invaded France, Belgium and Holland.25 With typical attention to proper procedure, Crawford had advised the other signatories that the Chairman of the Professorial Board, Kenneth Bailey, should be informed of the petition and be invited to sign. As a further precautionary measure, the letter was shown to the Vice-Chancellor. After their consultation, Crawford must have felt confident that the campaign was relatively safe. It was published on 14 May 1940 in all the daily Melbourne newspapers, with a glaring omission made by the editor of the Argus, who failed to include the reference to the Western Australian precedent. The letter provoked outrage, as critics identified the protest with the University. One of the signatories, Sydney Sutherland, immediately retracted his position and wrote to Medley to offer his ‘sincerest apologies’.26 A special meeting of the Professorial Board was called on the 22 May to consider the effect of the letter on the reputation of the University and whether any action should be taken against the
War and Diplomacy
105
signatories.27 Bailey, who was subtly reminded of the fact he had seen the original letter, chaired the meeting. In a confidential memo, he registered his ‘concern’ at the damage caused by the letter. In his opinion, the protest did not sufficiently disassociate the signatories from the support of communist activities, and as it was published at the height of the invasion of Belgium and Holland, ‘a demand for total freedom for the extremist press was most inopportunely timed’.28 A general meeting of staff and students was also held in Wilson Hall on 30 May to discuss the ‘University and the War’. In private, Crawford had great confidence in his students and was ‘pleased’ that they made up their own ‘minds, not in a stampede but after thought’.29 Crawford himself prepared a lengthy statement that reiterated the background of the letter and defined his intentions. ‘It was not his desire’, Crawford wrote, to weaken the war effort, but to prevent censorship that created suspicion of political oppression and accentuated ‘an enfeebling disunity in the community’. The letter was not written in support of communists or any other minority, he declared, but on behalf of civil liberties.30 One can hear cadences from Crawford’s mentors—Wood, Bell, Anderson—mingling with his current associates: William Slater, Palmer and Fitzpatrick. Within this company, he had become independently courageous and conspicuous. He had sympathy for those deprived of the freedom of thought and speech. Liberalism had sustained him in the present struggle. Crawford was less radical than the more sceptical Fitzpatrick, but not necessarily less dangerous in the eyes of conservatives. In a ‘constructive’ and slightly anxious statement that was circulated among University staff, Medley mildly admonished the signatories. Revisiting his much-used policy on ‘communication to the press and public’, he cautioned all his staff, as a matter of duty and common sense, to exercise ‘extraordinary care’ in the public expression of opinion.31 Without dissent, the Professorial Board resolved to disown the views of the thirty-one signatories in order to correct ‘the mistaken impression’ that the University was disloyal to the war effort.32 The letter Bailey drafted for this purpose had a malicious edge. He declared that a large majority of University staff disagreed with the action taken by their colleagues.33 This was actually a misrepresentation: Bailey had canvassed the staff on the issue of publishing a disclaimer, not on agreement or disagreement with the protest. He
106
An Historian’s Life
claimed that 201 members of staff responded to his invitation; 172 supported the disclaimer, 25 did not and 4 declined to express a view.34 On 24 May, Crawford and his thirty colleagues wrote another letter to the newspapers to declare their loyalty and express regret over the misunderstanding of their purpose.35 Crawford, who drafted the letter, also referred to the two omissions that had provoked particular outrage. The Argus had not made it clear that the signatories were only some of the teaching staff, and had not mentioned they were writing in support of Walter Murdoch, not in isolation. 36 Medley’s assurances of staff loyalty were accepted, but he reserved his own bitter feelings in a verse.37 The ACCL viewed Crawford’s predicament with sympathy. Maurice Blackburn, who had canvassed for nominations for the President of the ACCL, mentioned the limited number of possible candidates and could only think of Fitzpatrick, Crawford and Palmer. He realised that Crawford was in the ‘throes of a violent University dispute’ and was unable to accept.38 The Chairman of the Professorial Board announced that it ‘seemed best’ to regard the incident as closed, to avoid confusing the public and tarnishing further the reputation of the University.39 It appeared that in the opinion of the conservatives, Crawford had blundered in two ways. Firstly, he had failed to circulate the original letter widely enough, which offended the more troublesome members (although they might never have been satisfied); secondly, he had defended a political group considered indefensible. The Ban on the Communist Party of Australia On 15 June 1940 the government gazetted regulations giving it power to declare any organisation unlawful, confiscate its property, prevent its members meeting and prosecute anyone found in possession of its publications.40 Regulation 41 stipulated that ‘a person shall not endeavor to cause disaffection among persons engaged in the service of the king or the Commonwealth or in the performance of essential service’. According to the other more controversial regulation 42, ‘a person shall not endeavor whether orally or otherwise to influence public opinion in a manner likely to be prejudicial to the defence of the Commonwealth or the efficient prosecution of the war’. The passing of these regulations began a period of repression as the
War and Diplomacy
107
government outlawed the Communist Party of Australia. In the following weeks, offices and private homes were raided, literature was impounded and communist publications were outlawed41 This period was crucial to Crawford as he became increasingly distressed over the more extreme regulations. His concerns were circulated widely, and he spoke eloquently to the Melbourne University Labor Club, describing his dismay. Regulation 42 must be amended, he advised, on the basis that prejudicing public opinion should only be prohibited if achieved by false statement, false document or false report. Complete newspaper control, Crawford argued, was ‘too dangerous a power to entrust to any man or government’ and this form of surveillance would ‘result in harm, spiritual and political’.42 Not all the members of the University concurred with Crawford. James Barrett, the former Chancellor, circulated a confidential document entitled, ‘The Facts’ in which he referred to several political incidents involving Crawford and other academics.43 At a Council meeting on 3 June, Barrett vented his fury at the conspicuous public conduct of various staff members. He moved that ‘every officer of the University’ should be required to take an oath of allegiance to the Crown, and any ‘avowed Communist’ who was a member of staff should be ‘submitted to the Council for consideration and action if necessary’.44 Council resolved to discuss the matter confidentially and immediately appointed a Committee. The Council approved Medley’s earlier statement concerning communications to the press and public, and expressed satisfaction that no member of staff was disloyal to the national cause. It would ‘unhesitatingly carry out any obligation to prevent the University from being used in any way for the furtherance of disloyal or subversive activities’.45 The policy was less severe than those in America, where radical academics and teachers were dismissed. Ellen Schrecker maintained that these dismissals represented ‘a kind of academic background noise’ of political repression that tended to single out the academy’s most conspicuous and outspoken radicals.46 Barrett refined Medley’s policy on communication to the press. He wanted all staff members who wrote on educational matters to consult with the Vice-Chancellor, and when writing on other issues, they should not ‘include the name of the University in any circumstances’. The old guard in the Council, represented by Barrett, insisted that political views were completely personal and should not be
108
An Historian’s Life
associated with the University. He apparently considered Bailey a sympathetic ally. Although the latter regretted ‘keenly’ some of the incidents Barrett referred to, he rejected the former Chancellor’s accusation that some of the staff’s extracurricular activities and public statements were ‘disloyal or subversive’.47 Bailey was a particularly loyal supporter of Medley’s measured leadership and ‘deeply deplored’ Barrett’s action after the Vice-Chancellor’s ‘fine and comprehensive statement of the University’s position’.48 The Council concurred with Bailey and announced that it was ‘satisfied’ that no members of staff were disloyal to the ‘national cause’ and that the oath of allegiance was not necessary in the absence of a common rule applying to all public bodies.’49 Crawford had other related preoccupations. The government’s regulations and Barrett’s efforts attacked fundamental elements in the position he had formulated over the last decade. He borrowed Louis Halphen’s words to express his thoughts: History does not breed skepticism, but it is a marvelous school of wisdom. But only, one must add, if it is thought about, and if only the thinking is sharpened by the endless debate that had been our glory.50 In Crawford’s opinion, the historian’s responsibility to exercise moral judgment and maintain vigorous debate was now threatened by the Federal Government. There was no consensus within the ACCL. The ban on the CPA and affiliated organisations revealed the precarious nature of the compromises achieved within the Council during the previous summer. Some members opposed the ban out of sympathy for the Communist Party, some because they considered the regulations excessive. Brian Fitzpatrick reacted with characteristic outrage, reproaching the government during a speech in Wollongong. This was reported in the Sydney papers and prompted W. M. Hughes, the Attorney-General, to claim that Fitzpatrick was entitled to his opinions and the freedom he enjoyed to express them contradicted his criticisms. Still on the offensive, Fitzpatrick accused the government of hindering the war effort. Hughes responded by threatening to ban the ACCL.51
War and Diplomacy
109
Not everyone within the ACCL supported Fitzpatrick’s public campaign, and his new opponent was a former ally, the barrister J. V. Barry. Dismissive of criticism that he had brought the League under direct threat of being outlawed, Fitzpatrick happily described his exchange with Hughes to Barry. The latter responded by sending an urgent telegram: ‘You are not authorised to speak for Council and wrongful assumptions of authority will result in my and many other resignations’. Barry’s response was prompted by two considerations. Firstly, there was his belief that Fitzpatrick had breached the ACCL’s constitution by making an unauthorised comment. Secondly, he was convinced that the League should avoid ‘political activity’ lest it ‘damage’ its public image.52 Within a week, Barry decided that Fitzpatrick should resign. Accustomed to this now familiar scenario after his bouts with Burton, Fitzpatrick refused. There followed a dispute over the interpretation of the ACCL’s vague liberal objectives. Relations deteriorated further when Fitzpatrick dismissed Barry’s arguments and accused him of being uncomfortable when the Council was outspoken on controversial matters.53 To his credit, Barry did not resort to private recriminations and hoped they could keep their ‘personal relationship’ on the same ‘cordial basis’.54 The ranks divided. Crawford and Blackburn were Fitzpatrick’s strongest supporters, while Vance Palmer and J. M. Atkinson defended Barry. On 1 July the issue was raised at a meeting, but no vote was taken. The matter was resolved privately, and the antagonists resumed their friendship. Although Crawford had remained on the periphery, he was now identified as one of Fitzpatrick’s strongest allies. The episode revealed his pronounced stand in support of the controversial Secretary, a daring move when Barry’s position might have been the more secure option. In January 1941 the National Security Regulations were extended further. Statements that were considered likely to corrupt morale were defined as subversive and any criticism of the government could be interpreted as prejudicial to the war effort. Fitzpatrick, Crawford and Blackburn argued that it was the government and its excessive measures that created discord and hampered the war effort. In the previous December of 1940, two communists in Sydney came to symbolise this claim. Max Thomas, a twenty-nine-year-old
110
An Historian’s Life
printer and member of the Printing Industry Employees’ Union, and Horace Ratcliffe, a labourer and Gallipoli veteran, were tried and imprisoned under the National Security regulations for possession of unlawful documents, namely a communist publication. Both men denied the charge, and Thomas said the publications he was found with ‘represent the actual views of the working class. Far from stabbing the nation in the back, the fact that I stand in Court today is an indication of my hatred of the Nazi and Fascist creeds.’55 Thomas and Ratcliffe served a sentence of six months with remission for good conduct, but it appeared the government still considered them threats. After their release and just days after the German invasion of Russia, they were interned indefinitely and without trial under the powers conferred by Regulation 26. These men became a ‘cause celebre’ as they began a hunger strike that lasted seventeen days. On 24 July, Maurice Blackburn wrote in their defence to newspapers. He emphasised the government’s misguided and illogical position, since the change in political circumstances mitigated the potential danger Ratcliffe and Thomas presented. The government had now interned supporters of Australia’s ally.56 The ACCL, affiliated societies and unions organised petitions, public meetings, demonstrations and a twenty-four-hour strike. The press speculated that approximately 100,000 unionists would participate in the strike. The federal government refused to capitulate and resolved that Ratcliffe and Thomas would not be released. ‘Deliberately to hinder the war effort’, Menzies maintained to the press, ‘is to be guilty of something singularly like treason and represents a settled intention to deprive our fighting men of the support to which they are entitled.’57 In a public meeting called by the Council at Unity Hall on 27 July 1941 and chaired by Maurice Blackburn, Max Crawford, Brian Fitzpatrick and Jim Bergin, the Acting Secretary of the Australian Tramways & Motor Omnibus Employees’ Association, addressed a rowdy audience of over 2,000 people. Crawford had become an unlikely, if conditional, champion of Ratcliffe and Thomas. He was cautious in his support, as he cited Blackburn’s letter and professed his allegiance to the Allied cause.58 And more significantly, he avoided the communist minefield by insisting he was not primarily concerned with the past activities of Ratcliffe and Thomas, with which he was
War and Diplomacy
111
‘not in agreement’, but with the present. He said the potential to ‘reoffend’ under Regulation 26 did not warrant internment, and the use of such a power ‘invited abuse.’59 Ratcliffe and Thomas were unusual symbols for Crawford. He was not concerned with the legitimacy of their communist actions, but ‘the general defence of civil liberties’, which should not ‘depend on the will of a Minister’. Crawford also challenged the assertion that protest was an unpatriotic act. ‘The hardest test of loyalty’, Crawford claimed, ‘to the good of one’s country is unpopular protest against undemocratic action’.60 Other cases of forced detention occupied the ACCL. By the end of the war, 6780 Australians had been interned as potentially dangerous aliens.61 Crawford reported on the arrest of Victor Trikojus, a Lecturer in the Faculty of Medicine at the University of Sydney, who was interned in January 1940 under Regulation 26. A further investigation was encouraged.62 Brian Fitzpatrick also cited the inconsistencies of government policy. ‘Grave scandals have been discovered’, he declared when he described woeful conditions at Tatura of anti-Nazi refugees who were ‘prohibited immigrants’. W