ADVANCES IN GENETICS VOLUME IV Edited by
M. DEMEREC Carnegie Institution, Cold Spring Harbor, N . Y.
Editorial Board G...
23 downloads
2071 Views
21MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADVANCES IN GENETICS VOLUME IV Edited by
M. DEMEREC Carnegie Institution, Cold Spring Harbor, N . Y.
Editorial Board G . W. BEADLE WILLIAMC. BOYD TH. DOBZHANSKY L. C. DUNN MERLE T. J E N K I N S JAY L. LUSH
A LFRED MIRRKY 11. J. MULLER
J . T. PATTERSON M. M. RHOADER 14. .J. STADLER CURT STERN
1951
ACADEMIC PRESS INC., PUBLISHERS N E W YORK, N . Y .
COPYRIGHT0 1951 BY
ACADEMICPRESS INC.
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED NO PART OF THIS BOOK MAY BE REPRODUCED IN ANY FORM BY PHOTOSTAT, MICROFILM, OR ANY OTHER MEANS, WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM T H E PUBLISHERS
ACADEMIC PRESS INC. 111 FIFTHAVENUE NEW YORK. NEW YORK 10003
United Kingdom Edition Published by
ACADEMIC PRESS INC. (LONDON) Lm. BERKELEY SQUARE HOUSE, LONDON W. 1
First Printing, 1951 Second Printing, 1964
PRINTED IN T H E UNITED STATES O F AMERICA
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME I V
A. CARVALHO, Instituto Agrm6mico, Campinas, SGo Paulo, Brazil SALOME GLUECKSOHN-WAELSCH, Department of Zoology, Columbia University, New Y m k , New York ERNSTIIADORN,Zoologisch-vergl. amtomisches Ircstitut, University of Zurich, LYwitzerland
ALOHAHANNAH,Department of Zoology, University of California, Berkeley, California
C. A. RRUG,Instituto Agrolzdmico, Campinas, SGo Paulo, Brazil
R. MATTHEY, Laboratoire de Zoologie, Universite' de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland SEIJINNAGAO, Plant Breeding Institute, Hokkaido University, Sapporo, Japan T. R. RICHMOND, Texas AgriculturaJ Experiment Xtatim, Texas Agricultural and Mechanical College System, College Station, Texas, and U . S. Department of Agricultirre
S . G. STEPHENS, Department of A g r o w m y , North Carolina State College, Raleigh, North Carolina
M. J. D. WHITE,The University of Texas, Austin, Texas
Physiological Genetics of the Mouse SALOME GLUECKSOHN-WAELSCH Department of Zoology. Columbia Vniversity. New Pork. New Pork CONTENTS
. . .
.....................
I Introduction I1 Analysis of the Yellow Lethal. a Classic Case of a Lethal Mutation I11 Analysis of Gene-Determined Pigment Characters 1 Autonomy of Pigmentation a Mutant Spots b Transplantation 2 Histological Studies of Pigmentation in Different Gene Substitutions 3 Biochemical Studies of Pigmentation in Different Genotypes 4 Correlation of Histological and Biochemical Results 5 Tyrosinase System in the Determination of Pigment Pattern I V Analysis of Gene-Determined Abnormalities of the Blood 1 Siderocytic Anemia in Flexed 2 Macrocytic Anemia in Dominant Spotting V Analysis of Mutat.ions Affecting the Skin and Its Derivatives 1 Transplantation Studies in Waved-2 2 Transplantation Studies in Rhino 3 Rhino and Vitamin A 4 Developmental Studies of Crinkled V I Developmental Studies of Mutations Affecting the Urogenital Sy.stem 1 Kidney Development in Myelencephalic Blebs 2 Kidney Development in Danforth’s Short Tail 3 Inductive Relationship between Ureter and Metanephros 4 Urogenital Syndrome V I I Developmental Studies of Mutations Affecting the Central Nervous System and Sensory Organs 1 Hydrocephalus 2 Congenital Hydrocephalus 3 Pseudencephaly 4 X-Ray-Induced Translocations and Pseudencephaly 5 Shaker Short a Central Nervous System b Ear 6 Effect of Kreisler 011 the Central Nervous System and Ear 7 Eyelees 8 Microphthalmus VIII Analysis of Endocrine Disturbances-Pituitary Dwarfism I X Analyeis of Mutations Affecting the Skeleton 1 Skull a.Harelip 1
.
.
. . . . .
.
.
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. .
.................. .. . ......... ....
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
Page 2 5 7
. . . .
. . . .
. . .. . .. . .
.
. . . .
.
. . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. .
.
.
. . . . ... .
....
..
............ . . . . . ... . . . . . . . ..... ................. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................... ............... ................... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .... ................ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . .. . . . ..... . . . . ................ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . .
7 7
8 8 9 10 11 11 11 12 14 14 15 15 16 17 17 17 18 18 19 19 20 21 22 23 23 24 24 26
27 28 29
29 29
2
SALOME QLUEOKSOHN-WAELSCH
.
.
.
X
.
.
. .
. . .
. .
. .
. .
. . .
. . .
. . . . . .
XI. XI1 XI11
. . .
. .
.
. . .
.
Page 29 29 30 30 30 30 31 31 31 32 32 32 33 33 34 35 35 36 36 37 37
. . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .......... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .................... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
b Tooth Abnormalities i Grey-Lethal ii Screw Tail 2 Extremities a L u x M o n g e n i t a l Absence of Tibia b Luxate c Polydactyly i Development ii Polydactyly and Embryonic Blebs iii Polydactyly and Central Nervous System iv Polydactyly and Maternal Age d Grey-Lethal and Failure of Secondary Bone Absorption 3.Sternum a Screw Tail b Short Ear 4 Spinal Column a.Flexed b Shaker Short c. Screw Tail d Undulated e Danforth's Short Tail The Developmental Effects of Mutations in Chromosome I X of the Mouse 1 Brachy6ry-Heterozygous Effect of T 2 Taillessness T/tn 3 Homozygous Effect of T 4 t-Type Mutations-Developmental Effects of t", t', t' 5 Kink-Homozygous Effect of Ei 6. F u s e d 7 Abnormalities of t ' / P Embryos 8 Miscellaneous Abnormalities in Individuals Carrying Mutations of Chromosome I X 9 The Role of Chromosome I X in Embryonic Growth and Differentiation Developmental Changes Induced by X-Rays Concluding Remarks References
. . . . . . . . . . . . . ....................... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
......................
38 39 40 40 42 42 43 44 44 45 46 47 49
I. INTRODUCTION A review article on the physiological genetics of the mouse might at first sight appear to have chosen too limited a n object for discussion . But there are a number of reasons why just the house mouse (Mus musculus L.) lends itself well to a discussion of problems of physiological genetics. It is true that microorganims. for example. provide a material more accessible to the analysis of biochemical gene effects. It also is true that Drosophila has been analyzed so thoroughly genetically that it might offer better material for the study of the physiological mecha-
PHYSIOLOGICAL GENETICS OF THE MOUSE
3
nisms of gene effects. On the other hand, the problem of gene effect and gene action in a vertebrate organism stands alone in many respects, both from the theoretical and the practical point of view. The vertebrate organism differs from lower organisms in so many obvious ways that they need hardly be enumerated here. I n its structure, physiology, metabolism, endocrinology, etc., gene-controlled mechanisms and processes are operative which in many respects offer a unique material for the physiological analysis of gene effects. The vertebrate organism is, of course, of particular interest from the point of view of the relationship between genes and processes of embryonic and cellular differentiation because of the epigenetic nature of its development, and by virtue of the character and interdependence of its developmental mechanisms which have been analyzed in such detail, particularly in amphibian embryos. But Amphibia do not lend themselves easily to a genetic analysis, so that it has been difficult to use that particular group of vertebrates for extensive studies of the role of genes in development and differentiation. I n the mouse we know of a considerable number of genes with effects on embryonic processes offering a material on which to study the relationship between genes and embryonic differentiation. I n many cases these same genes may actually serve as tools for the causal analysis of embryonic processes and mechanisms which would defy elucidation by other means. Frequently the creation of an abnormal situation is the prerequisite for the causal analysis of the normal mechanism. The mammalian embryo because of technical difficulties has not been a ready subject for an experimental approach similar to that used in other vertebrates. It is, therefore, fortunate that mutations have been discovered which produce abnormal situations in mouse embryos that resemble those observed in other vertebrates resulting from delicate experimental operations. The analysis of such changes in developmental patterns and the examination of the steps preceding the abnormalities frequently make it possible to discover causal connections between processes which could not have been revealed through a study of the normal alone. The mutations whose effects have been studied in detail and which will be reviewed in this article concern different organ systems of the mouse. These include among others, the skeleton, integument, nervous system, pigment-forming system, blood, and developmental systems of the embryo. Different levels of development are affected by the mutations to be discussed. There are those, just mentioned, which interfere with processes of early embryonic organization and with inductive relationships between different parts of the embryo severely enough to cause death of
4
S-4LOME QLUECKSOHN-WAELSCH
the embryo. I n other cases, the interference of a mutation with an inductive effect does not interfere with viability but leads to abnormalities of structure. Mutations will be discussed where an effect on enzyme systems can be demonstrated, such as those affecting pigmentation. Hemoglobin synthesis will be shown to be disturbed in different hematopoietic tissues and in different phases of development by the action of mutational changes with far-reaching effects. One syndrome of abnormalities will be discussed which will be shown to have arisen as the result of a mutational effect on a hormone. The developmental analysis of some abnormalities of the nervous system will demonstrate how the original effect of a mutation may show no direct relation to the eventual symptoms. The analysis of other mutations reveals that their effects are due to changed rates of growth and differentiation of certain tissues. I n general, developmental studies of the type to be discussed here demonstrate the way in which genes express themselves developmentally, where the term “developmental” is used in a broad sense and is not necessarily restricted to the embryonic phase of the organism. The developmental analysis of mutations will be shown frequently to group gene effects which had appeared a t first sight to have quite different manifestations, while separating, on the other hand, gene effects which had originally shown close resemblance. J ust as the analysis of biochemical mutations in microorganisms has contributed considerably to the general knowledge of biochemical mechanisms, so the analysis of mutations in mice has increased our knowledge of normal developmental processes of different types in mammals, and this aspect will be stressed particularly in this review. From the practical point of view there exists, of course, always the hope that the results obtained from the genetic studies on mice may eventually have some bearing on other mammals, particularly man. F or the purposes of this discussion a considerable degree of selection ha5 been practiced, and we have considered only those mutations and those aspects of a particular mutation whose analysis was thought to contribute to the “physiology of heredity’’ i n the sense of Goldschmidt. The problem is not so much what particular effects some mutation may have but rather how the effect is brought about, i.e., to attempt to trace the steps that lead from primary action of the gene to its eventual manifestation. Thus, many mutations will be omitted from the discussion which have only been described and analyzed genetically, while others are going to be discussed incompletely. Gruneberg’s book (1943a) on the genetics of the mouse contains a complete compilation of data on mouse genetics and is a n invaluable
5
PHYSIOLOGICAL GENETICS OF THE MOUSE
help to anybody working in this or related fields. More recent data from the field of mouse genetics are included in Gruneberg’s second book, Animal Genetics and Medicine (1947). Another book with useful information is the Biology of the Laboratory Mouse edited by Snell (1941). This contains a very good chapter on early mouse embryology. For more detailed descriptive information about early mouse development the reader is referred to a series of papers by Sobotta (1895, 1902, 1911).
11. ANALYSISOF
YELLOWLETHAL,A CLASSICCASEohi LETHAL MUTATION
THE
A
One of the classic cases of a lethal mutation is the so-called yellow lethal in the mouse. Its study also represents the earliest attempt of a n analysis of a n embryonic lethal effect in a mammal. The first abnormal symptoms of yellow homozygotes are recognizable a t the time of implantation in the uterus ; this is the earliest stage a t which detailed observations of effects of any mutation have ever been recorded. The yellow mutation at the agouti locus is dominant over all other members of the agouti series. The absence of yellow homozygotes from the offspring of matings between yellow parents was discovered and pointed out by Cuenot (1905). Cuthot assumed that a “yellow” egg could not be fertilized by a “yellow” spermatozoon. The lethal vharacter of the yellow homozygote was ascertained by Castle and Little (1910) who concluded from their breeding experiments of yellow mice “ t h a t a Mendelian class may be formed and afterwards be lost by failure to develop.” I t was demonstrated later by Kirkham (1919) and still later by Robertson (1942) that the yellow homozygous zygote actually does form but dies in early embryogeny. The earliest reports of the findings of remnants of yellow homozygotes came from Ibsen a n d Steigk d e r (1917) and Little (1919). Kirkham (1919), however, made the first more or less complete study of these homozygotes, and reported the first abnormalities to be the indistinct cell boundaries of embryos of’ the morula stage. Blastocysts with a shrunken appearance, small crowded cells and shrunken blastodermic vesicle were assumed to be yellow homozygotes on the basis of their numerical frequency. A more extended descriptive analysis as well as a n experimental attack on the problem of the yellow homozygote was undertaken by Robertson (1942) who examined embryos from matings of yellow by yellow from the cleavage stages on and could not confirm earlier reports of abnormalities in late cleavage stages. The yellow homozygous embryo develops normally through stages of cleavage and blastodermic vesicle formation. It
6
HALOME QLUECKSOHN-WAELSCH
becomes lodged in a decidual crypt and the uterine epithelium surrounding it changes its character from columnar to low cuboidal while the subepithelial uterine connective tissue cells proliferate to a great extent. But the cuboidal epithelial cells do not disappear as they do in the normal implantation process and the further development of the implantation site is arrested, The blastocyst cavity disappears in the abnormal embryos. “Since the resulting cell mass is so small and has no appearance of differentiation into the various blastocyst structures, it is concluded that upon contact with the uterine epithelium the trophectoderm of the homozygous yellow blastocyst collapses and then quickly degenerates, leaving only the inner cell mass the cells of which soon become abnormal. ” I n the next stage, the egg cylinder stage, the decidual crypts of the abnormal embryos.are small and contain only a few scattered cells : the remnants of homozygous yellow embryos. The uterine mucosa is in a progestational phase and uterine epithelial cells are present in cuboidal form, as on the previous day. Death of the homozygous yellow embryo is assumed to occur after the trophectoderm of the blastocyst has come in contact with the uterine epithelium. Robertson (1942) used a very interesting approach to study the development of homozygous yellow embryos in an environment other than that of the heterozygous yellow mother. He transplanted ovaries from yellow mothers to nonyellow agouti hosts whose own ovaries had been removed. About a week after the operation, the host female underwent a test mating. If yellow offspring appeared in a cross to a male not carrying yellow, the graft was considered successful and the host female was mated to a yellow male; embryos were obtained from the female a t different stages. I n cleavage and preimplantation stages no abnormalities are observed, as expected. The appearance of the abnormalities occurs a t the same stage as in the normal environment, i.e., in the yellow mother. But the homozygous yellow embryo in the agouti mother can be clearly distinguished from the homozygotes in the yellow mother by an advance in development which Robertson summarizes as follows: “1) the development of an ectoplacental cone; 2) the more complete differentiation of a n area of the cell mass corresponding to the embryonic region of the normal implanted embryo j 3 ) the further development of the implantation site as exhibited by the disintegration of the uterine epithelium and the relatively greater depth of the implantation crypt ; and 4) the development of a n extra-embryonic membrane which appears to be Reichert ’s membrane. ’ ’ The onset of lethal action in the yellow homozygote is supposed to occur a t the time of implantation and to be due to the absence of a n
PHYSIOLOQICAL QENETICS OF THE MOUSE
7
enzyme normally secreted by the blastocyst roof and responsible for the erosion of the uterine epithelium and successful implantation. The effect of yellow in homozygous condition may be directed on this enzyme. “Since the homozygous yellow mouse embryo develops further in the agouti uterus than in its usual uterine environment, it is evident that the developmental phenomena peculiar to this embryo are a result of the uterine environment of the heterozygous yellow mother as well as the hereditary factors inherent in the embryo itself.”
111. ANALYSISOF GENE-DETERMINED PIQMENT CHARACTERS One of the developmental systems in the mouse most thoroughly studied from the point of view of gene action is that of pigmentation. Pigmentation offers a number of advantages for the stcdy of the chain of events between gene and character. The development of pigmentation may be observed in situ and is a strictly localized process apparently not determined by circulating substances. That this is the case is evident from observations on mutant spots and from transplantation experiments. I n addition to the strict localization and the autonomous behavior of pigmentation there are other features which make the pigment system a most suitable subject for studies of gene expression and its development. Since hair is being shed and replaced frequently during the lifetime of the mouse, the developmental events leading to pigment formation repeat themselves and can thus be observed continuously within the same organism. The hair, with its differences in pigmentation along the hair shaft, is an image of the processes going on in the hair bulb during the formation of pigment as determined by the individual genes of the particular cell. It has been shown (Rawles, 1947) that the pigment-forming cells of the mouse originate from the neural crest and that they make their way into the developing hairs and bring about their pigmentation. The melanophores reach their definitive positions in the skin of the mouse embryo by the twelfth day after fertilization. Determination of pigment pattern is thus completed a t that stage. The deposition of pigment in the hair by melanophores was demonstrated in witro by Hardy (1949) with the help of tissue culture techniques. 1. Autonomy of Pigmentation
a. Mutant Xpots. On the basis of the generally accepted conclusion that the color reaction of a cell is determined chiefly by the cell’s genes, the color mosaicism of a male mouse has been interpreted as being due
8
SALOME QLUECKSOHN-WAELSOH
to the presence of a changed locus in each of the abnormal color spots (Dunn, 1934a). The same male showed gonadal mosaicism, and a mutation in the cell ancestral to the gonadal and the somatic tissue was assumed to have been responsible for the mosaicism observed. The distribution of the patches which originally arose from a common mutant cell was considered an indication of a complex series of differential growth rates or migrations of the epidermal tissues in different directions. The existence and persistence of the mutant spots is an argument in favor of the local determination of pigmentation as against the decisive influence of generally circulating substances. b. Transplantatim. The autonomous behavior of hair pigmentation in mice indicated by the existence of mutant spots has been studied more closely with the help of transplantation experiments. I n a series of papers (Reed, 1938a, b ; Reed and Henderson, 1940) transplantation of skin of newborn mice between genetically different individuals has been reported. In the case of albinism, agouti pigmentation, dominant spotting, and piebald, complete autonomy of the pigment pattern of the transplanted tissues was found which must thus have been determined before birth. In the case of the black-and-tan mutation there seems to be a difference between tissue and cell determination. Tissues from the black-and-tan mutant ( a W ) themselves are autonomous in respect to their dorsal or ventral organization ; however, the individual prospectively “black-and-tan” cells are capable of forming either black or tan pigment, depending on whether they find themselves in an environment, of dorsal or of ventral cells.
2. Histological Studies of Pigmentation in Different Gene Substitutions Since the gene dependency of pigmentation is thus established the next questions concern the way in which the genes exercise their control, and the mechanisms of their effects. The effect of genes on pigmentation seems to be fairly direct, and the chain of processes connecting gene action and expression rela,tively short, making genetic pigmentation differences a most suitable material for the study of gene physiology. A number of studies have attempted to analyze the effect of differ. ent genic substitutions on pigmentation. Dunn and Einsele (1938) investigated the changes in the dark granular melanins of the hair in different combinations of the albino series with black ( B ) and with brown ( b ) . They found a graded reduction in amount of pigment, as measured by weight, in combination with black ( B ) . The changes in quantity of pigment were shown to be due to a decrease in size of pig-
PHYSIOLOGICAL QENETICS OF THE MOUSE
9
ment granules. “Each mutant gene in the c series thus exerts a characteristic effect on granule size.” Systematic histological studies of pigment in the hair cells of the mouse in different gene substitutions were done first by Werneke (1916). Using the same approach E. S. Russell (1946, 1948, 1949a) tried to ascertain the basic natnre of gene action in five of the main allelic series of mouse coat-color genes : agouti, albino, black/brown, intense/pinkeyed dilution, intense/blue dilution. Thirty-six different genotypes were examined in a series of very careful and thorough studies, and a number of different attributes of pigment granules were observed; it could be shown that a large number of different variable pigmentation attributes contributed to the differences in appearance of coat color mutants. They are color, size, shape, number, arrangement of granules, and several others. A certain amount of interdependence among these different pigment attributes makes it possible to separate them into four groups controlled by four key pigment characteristics : nature of granule color, granule size, granular clumping, level of pigmentation. The eventual goal of these studies is to relate the basic action of each of five allelic series (agouti, albino, black/brown, intense/pink-eyed dilution, intense/blue dilution) to variations in these pigment attributes. The nature of the pigment produced at any particular level of hair (i.e., whether i t is of the xanthic or the eumelanotic type) is determined by genes of the agouti series, while the genes of the albino series determine quantitative changes, i.e., degrees of pigmentation, by altering shape, color intensity, number, size, and distal arrangement of pigment granules. The change from dominant B (black) to b (brown) expresses itself mainly in a change in the nature of eumelanin from black to brown, i.e., in a change from the process leading to pigments of the black-fuscous series to one leading to brown pigments, while the quantitative effect is only minor. Size of pigment granules and deposition of pigment are affected by the change from P (full color) to p (pink). I n animals homozygous for d (dilution), the amount of pigment is a t least as high as in DD, but it is disarranged into large granular clumps and it is distributed unevenly. 3.
Biochemical Studies of Pigwentation in Different Genotypes
The biochemical aspects of pigment formation in various genetic backgrounds were studied (Russell and Russell, 1948) with the aim of getting closer to the actual effect of the pigment genes. The behavior of the dopa reaction was examined on frozen sections of mouse skin, a technique which permits a histological localization of dopa-oxidase activity. This method has a number of advantages over others using tissue
10
SALOME C?LTJEUKSOHN-WAELSCH
extracts: it avoids the inclusion of nonpigmented cells which may introduce inhibitors ; the activity of specified parts of a, cell can be determined ; and each section serves as its own control, since autoxidation of dopa would lead to uniform darkening of the entire section instead of differential darkening localized in the hair bulb as produced by enzymatic oxidation. The same genic substitutions were used which had been studied histologically, and the studies were done on animals of 6-7 days of age since it was found that a t that age the follicles produce that part of the hair which had been examined in the histological compaxison of genotypes. The biochemical results could thus be easily correlated with the histological data. It was found that there existed a close parallelism between the amount of yellow pigment as determined histologically and the activity of the dopa reaction in different gene substitutions ; when a gene mutation had a n effect on the natural yellow pigment it would have a parallel effect on the activity of the dopa reaction. This effect was found in the yellow as well as in the corresponding nonagouti types, and from this fact the authors conclude that “the dopa reaction measures some phase of the yellow producing system and that this system is present in sepias as well as in yellows.” The authors propose several interpretations of their results for the nature of the black-yellow differentiation, one of which postulates that ‘‘sepia-yellow differentiating genes act to produce different substrates. ” “ The discovery of another chromogen whose effect paralleled sepia both in yellow and sepia genotypes would prove the postulate that the sepia-yellow difference was one of substrates rather than enzyme systems, and the relation between this chromogen (presumably akin to the sepia substrate) and dopa could provide a. chemical clue as to the action of sepia-yellow differentiating genes.” 4.
Correlation of Histological artd Biochemical Results
Correlating the results of the histological studies with the biochemical results it appeaxs that the activity of the enzyme system measured by the dopa reaction is not affected by the genes of the agouti series. The genes of the albino series, on the other hand, affect the activity of the enzyme system which in turn is responsible for the intensity of the pigmentation reaction. The change of eumelanin from black to brown due to the genic substitution bb is not accompanied by any change in enzyme as measured by the dopa reaction activity. The effect of the pink substitution on size of granules and level of pigmentation appears to be correlated with a slight but probably significant decrease in dopa. oxidase activity. The dd substitution surprisingly results in a n increase of the
PHYSIOLOGICAL GENETICS O F THE MOUSE
11
reaction system, which runs parallel with some increase of natural pigment in dd individuals. Of the five allelic series studied, the genes a t the C and possibly a t the P locus seem to be involved in the control of the enzyme system measured by the dopa reaction which shows a correlation with the natural yellow pigment. 5. Tyrosinase System in the Determimtivn of Pigme& Pattern Some preliminary studies (Foster, 1951) deal with the role of tyrosinase activity in the determination of the pigment pattern of different genotypes in the mouse. The method used for measuring tyrosinase activity was that of determining oxygen consumption in a Warburg respirometer. The enzyme preparations consisted of homogenized skin, suspended in distilled water. Tyrosine was used as a substrate. The results of this study seem to demonstrate the significance of the tyrosinase system for the development of eumelanin pigment, and the presence of tyrosinase inhibitors in the skin of mice. The very slight amount of tyrosinase activity and the presence of a. tyrosinase inhibitor in yellow skin seem to indicate that the yellow pigment is independent of the tyrosinase system. Albino skin seems to be devoid of the enzyme as well as of its inhibitors. These preliminary results may indicate the decisive role of the tyrosinase system in the control of the black (sepia) pigment system which had been assumed on other grounds to differ from the yellow pigment system (cf. section 111-3). IV. ANALYSISOF GENE-DETERMINED ABNORMALITIES OF THE BLOOD There exist a number of well-analyzed genetic conditions in the mouse which involve the hematopoietic system ; the systematic investigation of the effects of these mutations and the embryogeny of the conditions caused by them has contributed much to our knowledge of the formation of the blood in the mouse. 1. Siderocytic Anemia in Flexed
One of the best-analyzed mutations affecting the blood is the flexed mutation ( f l ) . It was reported by Hunt and Permar (1928), and its effect in the blood system was studied by Kamenoff (1935) and by Griineberg (1942a, c). Flexed ( f l ) also has an effect on the tail and produces a belly spot. However, we want to concern ourselves here only with its effect on blood. The first observations on flexed showed that newborn fljl mice were anemic but that this anemia was transitory and
12
SALOME QLUECKSOHN-WAELSCH
the mice recovered soon. I n studies of the blood of flfl embryos it waa possible to place the onset of the anemia at a time before the fourteenth day after fertilization, i.e., preceding the beginning of the hematopoietic function of the bone marrow (16 days) ; later its beginning was traced hack to 13 days after fertilization. Actually, the anemia of the flp mice hegins to improve at the time when the bone marrow starts its normal hematopoietic function. The flexed gene is thus not concerned with the functioning of the bone marrow. This point was confirmed by red cell counts of adults which were practically normal. Apparently the flexed mutation causes some abnormality in the hematopoietic function of the liver, as indicated by the studies of Oruneberg (1942a, c). Bruneberg reports the abundance of siderocytes in flexed mice, i.e., red blood cells whose iron can be demonstrated in the form of granules by means of the Prussian Blue reaction. Oruneberg originally suggested that flexed anemics were unable to synthesize hemoglobin normally but produced only a hemoglobin precursor, the iron of which could be demonstrated. This inability to synthesize hemoglobin would be, however, restricted to the liver since only its hematopoietic function is affected by the flexed mutation. Lately, on the basis of some work indicating that siderocytes are actually aging cells, Qriineberg (1947) has taken the point of view that the anemia of flexed tailed mice arises from an increased hemoglobin breakdown. Of course, this might in turn be considered a consequence of abnormal hemoglobin synthesis. We thus cannot draw any definite conclusions from the embryonic study of the flexed anemia except that the normal allele of flexed must be involved in the control of either hemoglobin synthesis in the liver, or in its structural maintenance in the erythrocytes derived from the liver. The question remains open why the other hematopoietic systems of the animal should be affected mildly a t the most, and be capable either of normal hemoglobin synthesis, or of producing hemoglobin resistant to premature breakdown. One would perhaps expect this synthesis to be equally disturbed throughout the entire organism. A time factor does not seem to be involved since the first red blood cells originating from the yolk sac are fully hemoglobinized and probably normal. The effect of fl seems thus to consist of a localized disturbance of erythrocytes originating from the liver. If some general agent were operative in the flexed mice, one could expect the bone marrow red cells to be equally affected. 2. Mncrocytic Anemia in Dominant #potting A different step in the development of blood is interfered with by the W mutation. Mice homozygous for the W gene are anemic and in-
PEKYSIOLOGICAL GENETICS ON' THE MOUSE
13
viable; they die soon after birth. Their anemia is of the macrocytic type, i.e., these mice have fewer but larger cells than normal mice of the same age. DeAberle (1927) traced back the anemia to the sixteenth day of embryonic life by the observation of markedly pale embryos a t that stage, and Russell, Fondal, and Smith (1950) by establishing the erythrocyte level found WW embryos to be definitely anemic at 14 days after fertilization. There is some increase in the erythrocyte level of the anemics during embryonic life, so that the W anemia is a hypoplastic rather than a n aplastic anemia. The failure of WW to improve during the period when the bone marrow takes over its hematopoietic function clearly shows that the effect of W differs from that of fl. W apparently has a general effect on erythropoiesis of the entire organism and is considered by Russell et d.to cause a deficiency of a substance essential to erythropoiesis from earliest embryonic stages. The normal allele of W thus seems to be involved in the control of hemoglobin synthesis in general. There exists another allele of the W series, W" (Little and Cloudman, 1937)? which, when homozygous, produces a condition intermediate between that of normal and of W W mice. W"W" mice also have a macrocytic anemia but less severe than that of WW mice with a reduction to about one-half the normal number of erythrocytes; they are viable and actually improve their condition during their lifetime. Their anemia is definitely of the hypoplastic type and W" seems to affect hematopoiesis in the same qualitative manner as W , but to a lesser degree. The same substance essential for normal hemoglobin synthesis and presumed to be deficient in the case of WW would perhaps be less deficient in the case of WOW". A peculiar phenomenon is the existence of a mild anemia in the presence of one dose of W " :lower erythrocyte counts and hematocrit readings were established in W"heterozygotes by Griineberg (1942b), while animals heterozygous for W , which in homozygous condition produces a severe anemia, had a completely normal blood picture. Both alleles, W and W", were recognized first by their effects on pigmentation. When present in one dose, W produces a white belly spot, while W u heterozygotes, in addition t o the white belly spot, show a dilution effect of dorsal and ventral pigmentation. Both homozygotes have unpigmented f u r and black eyes. The dominance relationship of the two alleles in their effects on blood and pigment was analyzed most thoroughly by Russell (1949b) , who showed that W had no effect in one dose on either blood or pigment, but a severe effect in two doses. Wv had an effect on both systems in one dose, expressed in a decrease of granule number and size in the case of pigment, and in lower erythro-
14
SALOME GLUECKSOHN-WAELSCH
cyte counts in the blood ; but it had a milder effect than W on the blood in two doses, while the effect on the pigment equalled that of W. Russell points out the clear parallelism between the effects on the two different systems, blood and pigment : whenever one system is affected, the other one is affected too; in addition, there is a parallelism in degree of abnormality of blood and pigment. On the other hand, the reviewer feels that the divergence in the dosage effect of the two alleles should not be overlooked. One dose of W v is more effective than one dose of W, but two doses of W v are less effective than two doses of W. A hypothesis for the explanation of the simultaneous effects of mutations in mice on pigmentation and blood was put forward recently by Serra (1947), who supposes that an effect on copper may link the manifestations of these mutations in two systems. W and W” would, according to this hypothesis, exert an effect on copper compounds involved both in the formation of pigment and blood. I n the absence of any experimental proof, this idea can be regarded as a n interesting hypothesis only.
v.
ANALYSIS O F MUTATIONS AFFECTING THE
SKIN AND
ITSDERIVATIVES
The development of skin and hair in the mouse is dependent on the collaboration of a great many genes as evidenced by the existence of numerous different hair mutations. Quite a number of them have been reported and analyzed genetically (e.g., waved-1, waved-2, rex, naked, hairless, rhino, crinkled) ; we shall concern ourselves here only with those in which an attempt has been made of an analytical study of the mechanisms responsible for the expression of the individual mutations.
1. Transplantation Studies in Waved-2 Transplantations of skin between normal mice and those homozygous for wa-2, whose hair is waved instead of straight, seemed to show that nonwaved tissues or cells became organized to produce waved hair in the waved environment (Reed, 1 9 3 8 ~ ) . These results were interpreted as revealing not only the a.utonomous nature of waved-2 tissues and cells but also their ability to cause genetically nonwaved cells and tissues to form waved hair. The effect of wa-2 was thus assumed to be the following : “waved” cells (wa-2 wa-2) produce a growth-inhibiting substance which is responsible for the effect of wa-2 on body size and hair structure (wa-2 wa-2 mice are smaller than normal). The growth-inhibiting substance diffuses into the normal tissue and there causes nonwaved cells to produce waved hair. This interpretation has become highly doubtful on the basis of some incidental observations in a different series
PHYSIOLOQICAL GENETICS OF THE MOUSE
15
of transplantations between mice with normal hair structure (Fraser, 1946). Here it was noticed that “both graft and host hairs, when situated near the borders of the graft, were often curved or bent, like the hairs of genetically ‘waved’ mice.” The waviness of the hair was ascribed to a n antagonism between several physical factors acting on the growing hair in its abnormal position. Since this “waved” hair could be produced in transplantations between normal mice, it becomes highly doubtful whether the effect of waved on normal cells is actually due to the diffusion of a growth-inhibiting substance from waved into normal tissue.
2. Transplantation Studies in Rhino Another mutation affecting the hair of mice is rhino (hrrh)which produces hypotrichosis. The mode of action of the rhino gene which causes a follicular hyperkeratosis associated with depilation has been studied in transplantation experiments by Fraser (1946). These transplantations were performed with the aim of finding out whether a cellular condition was responsible for the expression of rhino or whether it was the result of some more general change (e.g., endocrine system) in the physiology of the animal. Grafts of normal skin to rhino hosts beha.ved autonomously and grew a normal coat of hair. But the reciprocal experiment gave a different result. Those parts of the rhino graft which were adjacent to the normal epidermis did not develop the rhino characteristics but had normal hair. It could be shown that these hairs were not invasion hairs of the host. Thus it seems that normal skin cells produce a diffusible substance which is “necessary for the normal maintenance of the cutaneous epithelium.” The effect of rhino might consist in the inability to produce this substance although rhino cells are capable of utilizing it when it is supplied from the outside. 3. Rhino and Vitamin. A Some alleviation of the skin defects associated with rhino, such as formation of cysts in the sebaceous glands and follicle ends of the rhino mouse, was obtained in rhino homozygotes by the administration of large doses of Vitamin A (Fraser, 1949). The conclusion was drawn that “the presence of the rhino gene in the homozygous condition is associated with a decreased ability of the skin cells to utilize some metabolite of Vitamin A necessary for their normal maintenance.” Thus it seems, as though perhaps the production of some substance as well as the ability to utilize it might be affected in cells homozygous for rhino.
16
BALOME OLUECKSOHN-WAELSOH
4.
Developmental #t&s
of Crinkled
A recent study of the effects and of the development of another mutation (crinkled) which affects coat texture has shed some light on the normal events taking place during the development of hair (Falconer Fraser, and King, 1951). Crinkled is a recessive mutation with a number of effects among which that on the fur of the animal is the most obvious. While the normal coat of a mouse consists of 3 types of hair, guard hairs, awls, zigzags, that of a crinkled mouse has one type of hair only, and they resemble awls, the short straight type of hair of the under fur. The question asked in the analysis of the mode of action of crinkled was whether crinkled merely inhibited the differentiation of a n as yet undifferentiated hair type into the three types and directed it into the channel of awl formation only without affecting the total number of hairs formed, or whether it suppressed the formation of guard hairs and zigzags leaving awl hairs only. I n the former case, one might suppose that the three hair types were not developmentally distinct entities, while in the second case the developmentally distinct chasacter of the three types would be strongly indicated. Normally there exist three periods of hair follicle formation in the embryo, which might correspond to the three types of hair in the coat. But while the study of normal hair development was not able to establish critical evidence for the connection between periods of hair formation and type of hair formed, the study of crinkled made it very probable that the formation of guard hairs, awls, and zigzags was linked u p with the first, second, third period of hair follicles formation, respectively. While the first hair follicles form at 14 days in the normal embryo, no follicles are found in the crinkled mouse until 17 days after fertilization when the crinkled embryo forms follicles resembling in general appearance those of the second period in normals. After birth, when the third wave of follicle formation starts in the normal, the crinkled mouse again does not form any follicles. I n the crinkled individual, therefore, the first and third wave of follicle formation seem to be suppressed. During the second wave, hairs are formed resembling awls. The suppression of first and third wave of follicle formation together with the absence of guard hairs and zigzags in crinkled mice supports the hypothesis derived from the study of normal development which postulates that first wave and guard hairs, and third wave and zigzags are connected; the activity of the second wave together with the existence of awls in crinkled mice is strongly in favor of the hypothesis that awls are derived from the second wave of follicle formation.
PHYSIOLOQICAL QENETICS OF THE MOUSE
17
VI. DEVELOPMENTAL STUDIES OF MUTATIONS AFFECTINQ THE UROQENITAL
SYSTEM
The main known genetic factors causing abnormalities of the urogenital system which have been studied from the developmental point of view are: (1) my, myelencephalic blebs; (2) 8d, Danforth’s short tail ; (3) UT, abnormality of the urogenital system. Each one of these three mutations has other effects in addition to those on the urogenital system, and some of these are described in other parts of the review. The embryonic study of two of these mutations haa contributed to our knowledge of the developmental mechanics of the mammalian kidney.
1. Kidney Development in Myelencephalic Blebs The development of kidney abnormalities in the “myelencephalic blebs” strain of mice was studied by Brown (1931) who concluded from her studies that “complete metanephric development is a response to a mutual influence and fusion of two healthy anlagen, the ureter anlage from the lower end of the Wolffian duct and the blastema of the posteriormost part of the nephrogenic mesenchyme. Either one of these anlagen or both may be retarded i n which case no functional kidney is developed and varying degrees of anomaly are produced.”
2. Kidney Development in Danforth’s Bhort Tail The probably decisive role of the ureter in inducing the metanephrogenic blastema to form the secretory elements of the kidney, i.e., secretory tubules and Bowman’s capsule, was revealed by studies of the development of the kidney system in mice heterozygous and homozygous for the dominant mutation Sd (Glluecksohn-Schoenheimer, 1945). Animals heterozygous for Sd show abnormalities of the kidneys which vary from reduction in size to complete absence of one or both kidneys, making the more extreme heterozygotes inviable. The homozygotes have no kidneys and die soon after birth. The extent of the kidney and ureter abnormalities depends on the residual genotype and modifiers play a decisive role in the determination of the anomalies of the urogenital system of both Sd heterozygotes and homozygotes. F o r the study of the development of the abnormal urogenital system and the causal analysis of the developmental processes taking place in normal development, that genotypic background was of course most desirable which permitted a good expression of the urogenital effects of fld. It was found that embryos both heterozygous or homozygous for 8d had
18
SALOME GILUECKSOHN-WAELSCH
a metanephrogenic blastema which in its histological appearance did not differ a t all from those of their normal littermates. On the other hand, a great variability in the condition of the ureters was observed. They were of varying length and the differentiation and branching of the ureter tip into cranial and caudal pole tubules was disturbed or inhibited entirely; sometimes the branching was retarded and fewer than normal pole tubules developed. There seemed to be a correlation between the condition of the pole tubules and that of the differentiation of the metanephrogenic blastema. Secretory elements were always found in conjunction with differentiating pole tubules ; the number of kidney elements and the eventual size of the kidney appeared dependent on the degree of branching of the ureter tip and the number of tubules formed. On the other hand, if the ureter tip did not make contact with the metanephric anlage or failed to branch, absence of the kidney resulted.
3. Inductive Relatiomhip between Ureter and Metanephros Since metanephric differentiation was never observed in the absence of differentiation of the ureter tip, the conclusion seems justified that the metanephros is dependent on the ureter for some inductive stimulus for its normal differentiation. A similar relationship between these two structures had been shown before to exist in other vertebrates, e.g., the chick, where the results of transplantation experiments had led to such a conclusion. Thus, one effect of the Sd mutation appears to be the inhibition of growth and differentiation of the ureter tip, resulting in the failure of a n inductive stimulus to reach the anlage of the metanephros. The existence of this inductive relationship and its significance in mammalian kidney development has been made very probable by the study of the embryonic effects of Sd. This, however, is only one of the effects of fld; its other effect, that on the axial skeleton, is discussed in another part of this review. 4. U r a g e d d flyndrorne The third mutation known to affect the urogenital system ur (Dunn and Oluecksohn-Schoenheimer, 1947) has not been investigated embryologically. Its effects, however, are quite different from those of Sd, cystic, and hydronephrotic kidneys being most prevalent among ur homozygotes ; it thus serves to emphasize the dependence of the development of a n organ on a great many genes all of which are involved in the control of different processes which contribute to the eventual goal of normally developed structure and function.
19
PHPSIOLOQICAL QENETICS OF THE MOUSE
VII.
DEVELOPMENTAL STUDIES OF MUTATIONS AFFECTINQ CENTRAL, NERVOUS SYSTEM AND SENSORY ORQANS
THE
The development of the nervous system offers a great many opportunities for the occurrence of deviations from normal. The complexity of gene-controlled morphological and physiological processes which have to proceed normally in order to give rise to a normally formed and normally functioning nervous system is so great that one is surprised a t the relatively small number of hereditary abnormalities of the central and peripheral nervous system actually observed in the mouse. The great power of regulatory mechanisms operating during vertebrate development is probably part of the explanation for the relative scarcity of nervous abnormalities; on the other hand some of the deviations from normal development are perhaps so drastic that they lead to early embryonic death of the zygote. Only special 'methods would detect such hereditary lethal factors. There exist (uite a number of hereditary functional nervous abnormalities in the house mouse for which a n organic basis has not been established. I n some cases no morphological or histological anomalies have been found in spite of careful search; the mechanism responsible for those abnormalities might be of a physiological or biochemical nature not amenable to investigation for lack of methods. It is of course difficult, if not impossible, to study the embryonic development of such nervous disorders or to use such studies for a causal analysis of normal development of the nervous system in the absence of any morphological manifestations of the anomalies in the adult. But, fortunately, at least some hereditary abnormalities of the nervous system have obvious morphological manifestations and several of these have been examined embryologically and will be discussed now. 1. Hydrocephalus
One phenomenon brought out repeatedly by the embryological study of hereditary abnormalities is the diversity of mechanisms which may lead to the same manifestation in the newborn or adult mouse. As pointed out in other parts of this review, this phenomenon emphasizes the dependence of normal form and function of a n organ or part of it on a great number of different processes for their development. Another example illustrating this situation is the study of two mutations both of which cause hydrocephalus in the house mouse. One of the two types of hydrocephalus has been studied embryologically by Bonnevie and by Brodal (1943, 1944, 1945, 1946). The condition is due to a recessive mutation (hy) and manifests itself a t or
20
SALOYE QLUECKSOHN-WAELSClH
after birth as a hydrocephalus of varying intensity. The mutation was first discovered and studied by Clark (1934)’ who reported an obstruction of the aqueduct of Sylvius as one of the anomalies of hydrocephalus. When Bonnevie studied the embryology of this type of hydrocephalus, she found a number of different abnormalities in various stages of emhryogeny. According to Bonnevie ‘(. . the manifestation of the hy-gene proves to be highly varying, a variation which is primarily attached to the fluid circulation of early embryonic stages.” Abnormalities of the embryo are traced from preimplantation stages, ((irregularities during the formation of the unilaminar trophoblast, ” to early implantation stages, “wounds)) in the trophoblast ((through which maternal material (tissue fluid, cells, blood) from the uterine endometrium will enter the embryonic yolk sac)’; the abnormal content of the yolk sac is supposed to lead to abnormal fluid circulation in the embryo, and an abnormally heavy fluid tension is indicated. The excess of fluid is directed into the hrain ventricles as soon as the activity of the choroid plexuses starts a t about 12 days after fertilization. It now follows the normal circulation of the cerebrospinal fluid, and hydrocephalic dilation of the ventricles is a consequence of the excess of fluid which fails to be reabsorbed. Finally a series of brain abnormalities results from the dilation of the ventricles. One wonders whether this causal connection of “irregularities ’)in the trophoblast and excessive fluid formation is really justified.
.
2. Congenital Hydrocephalus While Bonnevie thus traces the eventual hydrocephalus back to original abnormalities of the trophoblast in very early embryonic stages, Gtriineberg (1943b) finds a quite different “pedigree of causes” underlying another manifestation of hydrocephalus. His congenital hydrocephalus” (ch) is recessive and lethal a t birth. “The most obvious anomaly is a steeply bulging forehead consisting of bilateral protuberances which correspond to the cerebral hemispheres. These bulges are . not protected by flat skull bones; the bulges are somewhat flabby sacs, etc.” I n addition, the eyes are open a t birth, the nose is shortened, the sinus hairs are abnormal, and ossification of the sternum is retarded permanently. Gtriineberg was able to trace all these different anomalies back to a n abnormality of the early cartilage. “This condition seems to be of a transitory kind and does not seriously interfere with the development of the embryo, except a t the base of the skull” where the topographical relations are destroyed permanently so that a brain anomaly results which leads t9 the death of the ch-homozygote. The following figure from Briineberg (1943b) gives a picture of the ((
..
21
PHYSIOLOGICAL GENETICS OF THE MOUSE
“pedigree of causes” involved in the different abnormalities of ch-homozygotes which can all be traced back to an original anomaly of the cartilage consisting in a poorly developed matrix, areas of vacuolization and liquefaction, and retardation of cartilage growth. We thus see that the ch-mutation seems to have a general effect on cartilage development and we may conclude that its normal allele is concerned with the control of normal processes involved in cartilage formation ; another mutation, se (cf. section IX-3-b), was shown to afTect cartilage formation, but judging from its different effects, its normal allele seems to control different steps of the cartilage formation process than does the normal allele of ch.
CARTILAGE ANOMALY
Basicranial cartilage
I
Rletacarpals Metatarsals
Meckel’s cartilage
pituitary and Ganglion Class-
bra1 hemorrhages
Hydrocephalus
flat slrnll bones
of sinus hairs
eri
F’IG. I. Pedigree o f causes of congenital hydraeephalus. (1943b).
L
Death From Qriineberg
3. Pseudencephaly
Still another hereditary abnormality of the nervous system has been studied and traced back to abnormalities of early embryonic processes by Bonnevie (1936a). This is the so-called pseudencephaly, a deformity of the head which carries the dorsally open neural tube like a wig turned inside out. Pseudencephaly is probably due to a recessive let.hal mutation (ps). Embryos with this abnormality rarely survive iintil term; in addition to a certain degree of variability, they have a n i i m her of common characteristics, mainly the wiglike appearance of the brain which bulges out of the skull and whose two halves a.re turned
22
SALOME QLUECKSOHN-WAELSCH
inside out. Furthermore, the neural tube is crooked and shows a number of abnormal curvatures in the neck region. Two critical stages are supposed to occur during the development of pseudencephalic embryos ; the first stage occurs very early, embryos die according to Bonnevie “as gastrulae with unseparated germ layers, ” Those pseudencephalic homozygotes which survive this stage die at the end of the embryonic period after the manifestation of pseudencephaly has been completed. The complete eversion of part of the brain with the defective formation of the cranium and other consequences were all ascribed to a “purely mechanical brain catastrophy,” which in turn is supposed to be connected with the existence of abnormal wrinkles and curvatures in the neck region of the medullary tube. The origin of these curvatures is considered to lie in the fact that the embryonic neural tube is too big to find room in its normal sized mesodermal surrounding. Bonnevie considers an early shift of the growth balance of the otherwise normal anlagen the original manifestation of the ps-mutation, and a “delayed separation of the two primary germ layers” the cause of this shift. This latter failure may be severe enough to cause the death of the embryos in the first “critical phase.’’ The shift in growth balance results in a n increased growth rate of the neural folds which do not find room in the normally growing surrounding and are forced to curve and wrinkle. The connection between the early embryonic manifestation of p s and the later extensive malformations-if corroborated-would make this a particularly interesting case of developmental analysis of a mutation.
X-Ray-IitducedTranslocations and Pseudencephaly Pseudencephaly has also been demonstrated in embryos of mouse 4.
strains carrying X-ray-induced translocations (Snell, Bodeman, and Hollander, 1934; Snell and Picken, 1935). The abnormality was interpreted to be the consequence of chromosomal unbalance of the zygotes and not a result of the action of some specific factor or factors, since “nearly all translocations in mice give rise to rather similar types of abnormal embryos. ” Differences in modifying factors and in the intrauterine development are considered to be responsible for the numerous variations found among the abnormal embryos. The neural folds of the abnormal embryos fail to close anteriorly, and the ectoderm which normally forms the roof of the brain has turned outward, thus exposing the floor of the brain. The abnormal parts of the brain include telencephelon, diencephalon, mesencephalon, and the plexuses. The remarkable resemblance of pseudencephaly as determined either by a single recemive gene, or as the result of chromosomal unbalance, or as a consequence of disturbance of embryonic processes by the action of
PHYSIOLOGICAL GENETICS OF THE MOUSE
23
X-rays (cf. section XI) indicates the great sensitivity of the early developmental period of the neural folds as well as the dependence of their normal development on a great many different factors.
5 . Sh,aker Short a. Central Nervous Systeni. A very striking ahnormality of the nervous system with obvious morphological manifestations which has been examined embryologically is the so-called shaker-short mutation first described by Dunn (1934b). Shaker short is a recessive and the homozygotes show a shortening of the tail, choreic movements a n d deafness. The embryology of these animals has been studied by Bonnevie (1936b, 1940), who found brain hernias with far-reaching destruction of mesencephalon and metencephalon in homozygotes a t or shortly before birth. Bonnevie assumes that some explosive forces must have led to this brain destruction and that “the cooperation of various forces and organ systems is necessary to cause the explosive disturbance of the brain.” I n the search for these “forces and organ systems” Bonnevie reports an inhibition of the development of the brain roof and absence of the foramen of Magendie at around 9-11 days after fertilization. This stage is followed by one in which only rudimentary Plexus chorioidei are found, resulting in a deficiency of cerebrospinal fluid, which, in connection with the absence of the foramen of Magendie, leads to disturbances in the circulation of this fluid. Abnormalities of the meninges and the cranium are a consequence of the decreased distance between brain burface and the surrounding condensations of connective tissue. A sudden change of heart activity, determined from sections of embryonic hearts, is reported to set in at this stage and its slowing down is ascribed to a n abnormally high pressure on vagus and sympathetic nerve centers. Finally, brain hernias develop in the dorsal part of the mesencephalon and metencephalon. This entire complicated “pedigree of causes” was further traced back by Bonnevie to an “abnormal thickening of the epithelial parts of the early embryonic brain roof.” A t 8 days after fertilization Bonnevie reports to have observed a n abnormal thickening of the dorsal closure of the medullary tube in the form of a stringlike mass of cells in intimate contact with the medullary tissue underneath it. Moreover, even the observation of a n ectodermal hypertrophy in implantation stages prior to mesoderm formation has been reported. “The causal connection of this hypertrophy of embryos in stages of implantation with the previously described manifestation of all anomalies characteristic for the shaker-short mice may be considered certain. ” The embryonic abnormalities are striking, and their origin in a n ectodermal hypertrophy in premesodermal stages is so interesting
24
SALOME GLUECKSOHN-WAELSCH
from the point of view of developmental mechanics that one would like to see this study extended. One would, for example, like to see stages of archenteron and mesoderm formation studied and note the detailed effect of the ectodermal hypertrophy on other early embryonic formative processes. The reviewer, therefore, agrees with Criineberg (1947) in his criticism of Bmnevie’s analysis : “The resulting pedigree of causes has several weak points which require further study.” b. Ear. A lateral compression of the fourth ventricle of the brain and ensuing abnormal pressure conditions are considered to be decisive for the abnormal development of the ear vesicles of the shaker-short mouse which remain oval, laterally compressed, and practically undifferentiated. However, in analogy with Hertwig’s (1944) analysis of the “kreisler” mutation (cf. section VII-6), one might perhaps rather assume a disturbance in the developmental interrelationship between ear vesicles on the one hand and brain and surrounding mesenchyme on the other hand to be responsible for the failure of the shaker-short ears to differentiate normally. It is interesting to note that Bonnevie in her developmental analyses of abnormalities, consistently favors the disturbance of mechanical conditions as explanations for successive anomalies, rather than developmental interdependencies of different tissues and structures. Pseudencephaly, for example, according to Bonnevie arises as the result of a “purely mechanical brain catastrophy ” (cf. section VII-3), hydrocephalus is due to excessive fluid circulation (cf. section VII-1), and shakershort, to a deficiency of cerebrospinal fluid connected ultitnately with a n “explosive disturbance of the brain” (cf. section VII-5-a). Furthermore, Polydactyly in “Little and Bagg’s abnormal mouse tribe” (to be discussed later, cf. section IX-2-c-ii) is supposed to be due to localized disturbances of development by blebs originating from an abnormally high quantity of fluid expelled from the fourth ventricle through the foramen anterius and migrating eyer the surface of the embryo,
6 . Eflcct of Kreisler on the Central Nervous System and Ear I n contrast to these purely mechanical explanations of developmental abnormalities, Hertwig in her studies (1944) takes into consideration the epigenetic nature of vertebrate development, and developmental interrelationships. Whenever descriptive methods alone are used in the developmental analysis of a mutation, the causal relationship between a n early embryonic abnormality and the disturbance of a n inductive process can only be indicated ; transplantation or explantation experiments are needed for final proof of such relationships. Frequently, when working
PHYSIOLOQICAL QENETICS OF THE MOUSE
25
with an organism such as a mammal whose developmental mechanics are still largely unknown, the analysis of hereditary embryonic abnormalities may give the first strong indication of the very existence of an inductive relationship between two embryonic structures. A case which has been analyzed along these lines of thought is that of another behavior mutation in the mouse, the “ kreisler” mutation (Hertwig, 1944) where the chain of processes connecting the first visible embryonic abnormality with the eventual neurological symptoms of the young mouse has been worked out and the causal connection between a t least some links in the chain made most probable. The mutation kreisler (kr) is a n X-ray-induced recessive. “Kreislers” may be recognized 10-14 days after birth by their peculiar behavior-they tend to crawl in a circle. Older animals show behavior abnormalities such as dancing and head shaking when disturbed and are deaf ; their mortality is high. Pathological-anatomical examination revealed extensive brain defects. Cysts were demonstrated which arose from the rudimentary ductus cochlearis and extended into the subarachnoid space disturbing brain development. Deafness was shown to be the result of the absence of cochlea and the organ of Corti. The examination of “kreisler” embryos showed that a t 9 days after fertilization the invaginating ear vesicles of “kreislers’ ’ were shifted laterally so that their walls did not touch the neural tube, as is the case in the normal, but were separated from it by a layer of mesenchyme. At a slightly later stage, when the normal ear vesicle was pear-shaped and showed the anlage of the ductus endolymphaticus, no differentiation of the ear vesicle was visible in the abnormal embryos. Still older “kreisler” embryos were easily recognized by the absence of ductus and saccus endolymphaticus and by abnormalities in the semicircular canals. The separation of sacculus and utriculus remained incomplete and the ductus cochlearis did not form a spiral cochlea but remained a wide duct only coiled slightly. The defects of the membranous labyrinth resulted in underdevelopment of the periotic cartilage and consequent absence of part of the cerebellum. The absence of ductus endolymphaticus and thus of its efferent function is considered responsible for an increase in endolymphatic pressure. This in t urn gives rise to an evagination of the epithelium of the ductus cochlearis which forms cysts extending into the subarachnoid space. These cause serious defects in the rhombencephalon, the pons, and even the cerebral hemispheres. Only animals with small or unilateral cysts are able to survive. In search for the primary causes of the malformations of the membranous labyrinth Hertwig compares her descriptive results with data
26
SALOME QLUECKSOHN-WAELSCH
obtained in the analysis of the developmental mechanics of the amphibian ear. There a progressive determination of different parts of the differentiating ear vesicle and a strong dependence on normal surroundings for normal organogenesis have been demonstrated ; in analogy with it, the ear anlage of the mouse embryo is considered to be not fully determined a t the time of invagination and disturbed i n its further differentiation by the abnormal conditions of its surroundings. The greater distance of the neural tube keeps it from exerting its normal inductive influence on the ear anlage. Thus, the ear vesicle remains small and is not able to form endolymphatic duct and normal semicircular canals. The analysis of the developmental behavior of the “kreisler ” mutation has thus made very probable the existence of a developmental interrelationship in the mouse between neural tube, surrounding mesenchyme and ear vesicles j it has furthermore shown that ductus and saccus endolymphaticus are responsible for the regulation of the lymphatic pressure in the normal ear, and the efferent function of the ductus endolymphaticus. The motor disturbances could not be traced back to any definite defect. Of course, the question of the nature of the effect of the “kreisler” mutation in producing the origilral lateral shift of the ear vesicles remains open, and the developmental analysis, while showing a “pedigree of causes” and revealing a number of most interesting embryological phenomena, has not been able to find out anything about the primary action of the gene involved.
7. Eyeless Among a number of mutations which have been reported to affect the eye there is one with particularly good penetrance and expressivity, and this eyeless mutation, ey-I, has been made the subject of a careful embryological investigation (Chase and Chase, 1941). I n the anophthalmic strain studied 90% of all the animals homozygous for eyelessness lack the eyes, and the remaining 10% have abnormal eyes. The investigation of the embryonic development of the eyes of such homozygotes showed that the first evagination of the optic vesicle a t 9 days after fertilization was normal. At about 10 days a n inhibition of the eye vesicle set in which prevented it from growing sufficiently in order to come in contact with the ectoderm and induce a lens. Either no invagination a t all occurred to form an eye cup, or a small and irregular cup formed. The subsequent failure of the choroid fissure to close was considered to be either a direct result of the growth inhibition of optic vesicle and cup or an indirect result, due to the failure
PHPSIOLOQICAL GENETICS OF THE MOUSE
27
of lens formation; organogenesis of the eye did not proceed any further. At 13 days after fertilization, no eye was found in 90% of the mice of the anophthalmic strain, and no optic nerve was formed. Consequently, there was a n underdevelopment of the visual centers of the brain, and a number of abnormalities of the cranial nerves could be traced back to the absence of the eye. The absence of the eye, in turn, was not a result of degeneration but of “failure of definitive organization beyond the eye vesicle stage. ” The developmental study of this eyeless mutation seems to show that the mouse behaves developmentally like that group of species of Amphibia where the lens is completely dependent on the eye cup for its formation and where the prospective lens tissue lacks any potency for self-differentiation. Studies of the developmental mechanics of eye formation have demonstrated the principle of double assurance in the formation of the eye in some species of Amphibia, i.e., the eye cup is able to induce the lens, but the prospective lens tissue is also able to selfdifferentiate to a certain degree in the absence of a n inductive stimulus from the eye cup. I n other species, the lens is completely dependent upon the inductive stimulus from the eye cup for its development, and there exist gradations between these two extreme conditions in still other species of Amphibia. It would be very interesting if one could analyze the developmental potencies of the eye anlage of the mouse along the same lines a s done in Amphibia and thus confirm the conclusions obtained from the descriptive embryological study of “eyeless. ” While thus the abnormalities of eye formation in “eyeless” could be traced back to a primary inhibition of the optic vesicle, the effect of the eyeless mutation in producing this inhibition remains still unknown.
8. Micruphthalmus Another mutation affecting developmental processes in the formation of the eye, is “microphthalmus” ( m i ) which arose in an irradiated (X-ray) strain of mice. The homozygous animals have small eyes with colobomas. A very careful study of Miiller (1950) analyses the developmental steps leading to the eye abnormalities in this mutation and uses these findings for a n interpretation of the normal developmental mechanics of the eye. The first observable deviation from normal consists in shifts of the normal relationships of mitotic rates of nervous and pigment layers of the retina at about 10 days after fertilization. The result is a relatively increased growth rate of the pigment layer, resulting in an abnormally shaped eye cup and failure of the choroid fissure to close. Disturbances in nervous connections of eye and optic nerve follow, also eversions of the retina, abnormalities of the optic nerve, ab-
28
SALOME QLUECKSOHN-WAELSCH
normal pressure conditions in the eye chamber, lens deformities, and disturbances or complete absence of function. The successive appearance of a variety of abnormalities in the eye is utilized for a n analysis of the interdependence of different eye structures in normal development. A shift in growth rates of the different layers of the retina is thus considered to be the first observable effect of “mi” on eye development ; again, the mechanism by which the mutation produces this shift remains unknown.
VIII.
ANALYSISOF ENDOCRINE DISTURBANCES-PITUITARY DWARFISM
While the involvement of an endocrine gland was only indicated in the case of the abnormalities produced by the grey-lethal mutation (cf. section IX-2-d), there exists another mutation where the connection between endocrine disturbance and subsequent anomalies due to the effect of a mutational change could be clearly demonstrated. This is the mutation “pituitary dwarfism, ’’ a recessive analyzed genetically by Snell (1929). Dwarfs can be recognized at the age of 2 weeks when their growth and development cease; for the next 2 weeks they do not gain weight and occasionally even lose weight. After this period some animals start to grow again, others do not. Skeletal growth and differentiation are retarded. Male and female dwarfs are sterile, and their mortality is increased. These abnormalities of the dwarf mice seemed to simulate those of hypophysectomized rats, and furthermore, a histological study of the anterior lobe of the pituitary of dwarf mice showed complete absence of eosinophiles, a reduction in number of chromophobe cells and the appearance of a connective-tissue network. Smith and MacDowell (1930), therefore, tested the hypothesis that a defect of the anterior lobe of the pituitary was responsible for all abnormalities observed in the dwarf mouse. Fresh r a t anterior pituitary lobe was implanted daily into mouse dwarfs and gave positive results : “along with the striking resumption of growth, came a rapid loss of the dwarf traits.” Soon “the dwarfs could not be distinguished from normal mice,” aside from lower body weight. Males began to breed and females showed signs of a n estrous cycle. However, “the anterior lobe of the pituitary remains in the same defective condition as in the untreated dwarfs. ” All abnormalities of the mouse homozygous for pituitary dwarfism could thus be traced back to an effect of the mutated gene on the anterior lobe of the pituitary. Further studies were directed toward an analysis of the particular hor-
PHYSIOLOGICAL GENETICS OF THE MOUSE
29
mone effected by the mutational change, b u t for details of these studies the reader is referred to the individual papers (cf. Gruneberg, 1943a). OF MUTATIONS AFFECTINQ THE Ix. ANALYSIS
SKELETON
1. Skzcll a. Harelip. Throughout this review we have stressed repeatedly how different pathways may lead to the same end result, and that thus similarities of manifestation (lo not necessarily indicate similarities of disturbed development. A good illustration of this point is provided by some studies of harelip, a hereditary condition in mice. This condition has been studied by different authors in strains which were all derived from the same parent strain. The genetics of harelip is rather complicated, and it is not even certain whether harelip is due to one or several genes. The study of the embryonic development of harelip showed that apparently disturbances of different kinds may be responsible for the manifestation of the harelip condition. Reed (1933), in his studies, found that the clefts of the jaw were due to a failure of fusion of the lateral and of the medial nasal processes. The reason for this anomaly is sought for in a retarded growth rate of the maxillary processes whose lateral pressure is needed for the completion of fusion. Retardation of growth is also responsible for the failure of the palatine processes to unite. Tn a n examination of his strain of harelip mice, supposedly with the same genetic basis for harelip, Steiniger (1941) found, in addition to embryos which showed the nonfusion origin of harelip, others where the harelip was clearly the result of a break-through of embryonic cysts into the mouth and nasal cavity, and thus of secondary origin. In view of the fact that different disturbances in the same region seem to be responsible for the existence of the harelip condition in these mice, one might perhaps think of a n increased susceptibility of the mouth and nose region i n prospectively harelip mice. Due to a lowered threshold of resistance to different kinds of embryonic traumata, these embryos might react with retarded growth or with cyst formation in the mouth region to conditions which normally would pass unnoticed by the developing embryo. The case of harelip might be similar to the case of taillessness in the rat (Dunn e t al., 1942) where it was found that no single hereditary factor was responsible for the appearance of taillessness b u t where “the genetic constitution determines the threshold of a reaction which is subject to alteration by minor and more or less random accidents early i n development. ” b. Tooth Abnormalities. (i) Grey lethal. The tooth abnormalities of mice homozygous for the grey-lethal mutation (cf. Gruneberg, 1943a,
30
SALOME QLUECKSOHN-WAELSCH
for details) can be traced back to failure of secondary bone absorption which will be discussed in greater detail below (cf. section IX-2-d). (ii) Screw tail. Abnormalities of the teeth, the mandibles, and the skull are symptoms also of another, the so-called screw-tail, mutation. Mice homozygous for this recessive mutation were first recognized by their tail abnormality. The extensive malformations of the cranium, the mandibles, and the teeth have been described in detail (MacDowell et al., 1942).
2 . Extremities a. Lrc.ccc’--C‘o~~~ywzitul Abvencr of l’ibiil,. I h e to the relative paucity of mutations aflecting the extremities of the mouse not many studies have been made which contribute to the developmental analysis of limb structures. Nevertheless, one of the very first mutations studied from the embryological point of view is one affecting the hind limbs (Hovelacque and Noel, 1923). The mutation is a recessive called lux6 and expresses itself in congenital absence of the tibia. The examination of embryos from homozygous abnormal stock showed mesenchymal blastema in the hind limb bud resembling those which, in normals, would differentiate into two anlagen, that of the tibia, and that of the fibula, and become chondrified and ossified eventually. However, the hind limb buds of the embryos with congenital absence of tibia in spite of the presence of normal-appearing blastema show differentiation of only one cartilagenous structure which later ossifies, narriely, the fibula; the tibial anlagt? develops mostly fibrous tissue and only some cartilage in its upper portion which in comparison with the fibula is retarded in its development. The mutant gene thus affects specifically one part of a general anlage, i.e., the tibial portion of the limb bud mesenchyme, preventing it from developing along the normal path of chondrification and ossification while the neighboring anlage of the fibula in the same blastema shows no disturbance whatsoever of the identical processes. The ramifications of this situation for problems of cellular differentiation, such as the respective roles of inherent cell properties and the cell’s environment, were well recognized by the authors at the time of the embryological description of the condition. b. Luxate. Recently a new niutation has been reported (luxate, Carter, 1949, 1951) which in its edects strikingly resembles “1ux6, ” the so-called congenital absence of tibia discussed before. I n homozygous luxates the tibia is reduced, and in addition there are widespread defects of digits and other parts of the leg, prevalently on the preaxial side of the hind limbs. Heterozygotes are either normal, or show abnormalities of the digits also on the preaxial side of the hind feet. Since the original
PHYSIOLOCIICAL GENETICS OF THE MOUSE
31
“1uxQ” stock is extinct, genetic tests of the identity of the two stocks could not be made. Unpublished results of an embryological study (Carter, 1950, personal communication) indicate, however, the probable identity of lnx6 and luxate. The studies of luxate were able to tracr h w k the abnormality to a ninc.11 earlier stage of embryogeny. Abnormal shape of the hind limb buds was observed in luxate homozygotes of ll$$ days embryonic age ; at this stage the hind limb buds were narrower and more symmetrical than those of normal embryos. Differences in rate of development between preaxial and postaxial halves of the hind limb are considered to be the explanation for the differential effect of the mutation on tibia and fibula. c. Polydactyly. Another aspect of limb development that could be studied ,with the help of methods of developmental genetics is that of the regulation of toe pattern. The appearance of supernumerary toes is a rather frequent phenomenon in mice and the developmental study of those cases where this abnormal condition is determined genetically might reveal some of the mechanisms involved in the control of the normal developmental pattern of toe formation. ( i ) . Development. This point of view was kept in mind especially by Chang (1939) who studied the development of supernumerary toes in Fortuyn’s strain of polydactylous mice, where chiefly the first toe of the right hind foot was more or less completely doubled. Shape differences of the right hind footplate of embryos were found to be the first symptoms of polydactyly. The medial side of the abnormal footplate bulged out more sharply than that on the normal side. In addition to the excessive local growth of the medial side of the posterior limb buds there does not seem to be any abnormality of histogenesis. I n contrast to assumptions that some change in the epidermis might be responsible for subsequent abnormalities of the affected toe, Chang considers the excessive growth of both epidermis and mesenchyme to be caused by interaction of mesodermal and ectodermal factors. Such an interaction is operative in amphibian limb development, as shown by transplantation experiments. Chang’s analysis of polydactylism represents one of the first cases to illustrate the attempt to combine descriptive studies of the development of a mutation in mice with results from transplantation studies in Amphibia, with the aim of a causal analysis of mammalian development. (ii) Polyductyly and embryonic blebs. Different causes have been made responsible for the appearance of supernumerary toes by other workers. Bonnevie (1934), in an investigation of the embryogeny of polydactyly in “Little and Bagg ’s abnormal mouse tribe, ” discovered the presence of blebs migrating over the surface of the embryos where
32
SALOME QLUECKSOHN-WAELSCH
the bleb fluid was supposed to have originated from the medullary tube and to have been expelled through the foramen anterius in abnormally high quantity. The author considers these blebs to be responsible for localized disturbance of development, causing for example, as border blebs, the characteristic polydactyly. However, there are several phenomena wliicli could not be explained by such a n assumption. One of thein is the fact that the appearance of border blebs and original abnormalities of the footplate o m i r s a t least simultaneously, if not in reversed order, i.e., abnormalitiw of shape are recognizable before first appearance of blebs. (iii) Polydactyly and central n e r u m s system. The possibly causal relationship of polydactylism and hypertrophy of the ventral motor horn cell column a t the lnnibrosacral level was investigated by Tsang (1939). IIe fonntl that a correlation cxist,rtl between polydactyly and a hypertrophy of the retrodorsolateral cell column in the homolateral ventral horn of the spinal cord. Froin his results Tsang concluded that polydactyly was the immediate consequcnce of the neural hypertrophy. Ilowever, a reverse order of cause and effect seems more likely in view of experimental evidence in frogs and birds where hyperplasia of neural growth is produced as a consequence of implantation of supernumerary peripheral structures. Furthermore, Chang 's studies reveal, as pointed out by Griineberg (1943a), that the first abnormalities in shape of the footplate appear prior to the time of neural differentiation. (iv) Polydactyly and maternal age. That polydactylism may be influenced in its expression by a number of mutually interdependent developmental factors aside from genetic ones is apparent from studies which showed the effect of maternal age in the manifestation of the polydactyly gene, which decreased with increasing maternal age (Holt, 19-18). d. G'rey-T,ethal and Foilirve of Rccondary Bone Absorption. The extremities of mice show deviations from normal a s the result of the effects of still another mutation which produces a number of additional abnormalities. The mutation is the grey-lethal, discovered and very thoroughly analyzed by Griineberg (1936, 1937, 1938). One of the main abnormalities of mice homozygous for the grey-lethal mutation is the absence of secondary bone absorption which leads to changes in the shape of all the bones, including those of the extremities. No common marrow cavity exists in the long bones, and shape anomalies of the long bones develop. I n the absence of secondary bone absorption the skeleton of the grey-lethal mouse provides very good material for a comparison with the normal slieleton for the purpose of studying normal bone absorption.
PHYSIOLOGICAL GENETICS OF THE MOUSE
33
The cells which are responsible for bone absorption, i.e., osteoclasts, are found in normal number in the grey-lethal. The embryonic effects of the grey-lethal mutation have not been studied. However, reciprocal transplantation experiments between grey-lethal and normal mice (Barnicot, 1941) at least excluded some possibilities of explaining the effect of grey-lethal, without however revealing its actual nature. These reciprocal bone transplants did not behave autonomously, but grey-lethal bones, transplanted into normal hosts, approached normalcy while normal bones, transplanted to grey-lethal hosts, would sometimes assume grey-lethal characteristics although the results were not constant. On the basis of these experiments the effects in grey-lethal mice were ascribed to either the absence of an essential substance o r the presence of an inhibitory substance in the circulation and not to any factor inherent in the bone itself. Barnicot (1945) then attempted to answer the question of whether the grey-lethal affected some endocrine gland and caused a hormonal deficiency. One of the glands to be suspected in the grey-lethal mouse was the parathyroid, since it was known that parathyroid extracts caused bone absorption. The grey-lethal mice differed from normal mice in their reaction to the injection of parathyroid extracts; there was no evidence, however, that the treatment cured the faulty bone absorption, although the skeleton reacted to large doses of the hormone with considerable bone absorption. While the interpretation of these results remains speculative, there seems no question that the parathyroid, or its hormone, is somehow affected by the grey-lethal mutation and that the function of the gland or that of its hormone is disturbed in the grey-lethal mouse. I n addition to its effect on the skeleton, the grey-lethal mutation interferes with pigment formation : animals homozygous for grey-lethal have no yellow pigment in their fur. So far no physiological connection between these different effects of grey-lethal has been discovered.
3. Sternum a. Screw Tail. One of the very striking abnormalities of the screwtailed mouse (cf. section IX-l-b-ii) is the absence of segmentation of the sternum. I n contrast to the normal mouse, where the sternum consists of six separate segments, the sternum of the screw-tailed mutant is unsegmented, and while six centers of ossification exist in the normal, the screw sternum, except for the xiphoid process, arises from a single center of ossification and is considerably shorter than normal. I n addition, there are abnormalities of the ribs. It was hoped that a study of the development of the abnormal sternum of the screw-tailed mouse might reveal some of the mechanisms operating in the development of the nor-
34
SALOME QLUECKSOHN-WAELSCH
ma1 sternum, particularly in respect to the mutual relationship between ribs and sternum. Such a study was undertaken (Bryson, 1945) and indicated the decisive role which the ribs played in the determination of the ossification pattern of the sternum and thus its segmentation. According to the author, (‘the induence of costal cartilages upon the sternum is to delay ossification at the region of contact, both in the mutant and normal structure.” Thus ossification is normally inhibited in those regions where the “opposing zones of inhibition” have come in contact medially as a result of growth of the ribs. I n the screw-tail sternum, however, retarded growth of the ribs has kept the “paired zones of inhibition” apart so that ossification can proceed throughout the entire sternum without inhibition. The screw-tail gene is considered to have a general retarding effect on the axial skeleton of which the retardation of rib growth is only one symptom. I n normal development, ((th e determination of ossification pattern occurs after the union of ribs and sternum and is due to a n inductive effect.’’ b. Short Ear. Another aspect of the development of the sternum was studied by Green and Green (1942) who used the short-ear, se, mutation in the mouse as a material. Animals homozygous for this mutation show abnormalities of the ear, decreased body size, and a malformation of the xiphisternum. Depending on the residual genotype, the xiphisternum may be either reduced, practically absent, or bifurcated. The embryogeny of this abnormality was investigated and compared with normal development ; it was found that the sternal bands appeared shortened at about 13 days after fertilization so that the last rib frequently did not attach to the sternum. When the sternal bands moved together to form the sternum, it appeared that the xiphisternum was either reduced or completely absent in conformity with the shortening of the sternal bands. I n those cases where bifurcation of the xiphisternum occurred, the abnormality did not become apparent till slightly later in embryonic life-at about 15 days the posterior ends of the sternal bands of the animal with a prospectively bifurcated xiphisternum did not unite. Preceding this stage the sternal bands were not as clearly outlined a t their posterior ends as were the normal bands and the mesenchyme appeared less condensed. On the basis of their observations the authors conclude that (‘the condensation of mesenchyme leading to cartilage formation is certainly defective in the xiphoid region of the sternal bands, ” and that thus “defective precartilage is the actual forerunner of the adult departure from normality.’’ The short-ear gene thus seems to have a locally determined effect on certain regions of precartilage.
PHYSIOLOGICAL QENETICS OF T H E MOUSE
35
A more recent paper of M. C. Green (1950) demonstrates a more widespread effect of the mutation in the bony skeleton as well as other cartilages. How f a r all these effects can be attributed to a single cause remains for future elucidation.
Spinal Colwmn The development of the spinal column is dependent on a great number of genetic factors for its normal morphogenesis. Many mutations have been found which frequently have effects on the vertebral column as well as on other organ systems. Actually, the spine and particularly its distal portion, the tail, serve as a good indicator for the detection of mutations in the mouse. As we shall see, a number of mutations with most interesting additional effects, have been recognized first by their effects on the tail. Not all the tail mutations known have been examined developmentally, and in this case the mechanisms responsible for their effects on spine and tail development are quite unknown. We shall not deal here with these mutations, but restrict our discussion to those in which a thorough investigation of the embryology of the tail abnormalities has been made. We shall see that most of the mutations to be discussed have made their appearance in other parts of this article because they all have effects in addition to those on the tail. Their pleiotropic nature is a characteristic phenomenon of these tail mutations. a. Flexed. One of the first tail mutations whose developmental effects were studied thoroughly is “flexed, ” a recessive mutation affecting both blood and skeletal system (Kamenoff, 1935). Flexed homozygotes have stiff segments i n different parts of the tail, and flexures which are due to unilateral fusions between two successive vertebrae. Typical asymmetrical fusions of vertebrae are also found in the thoracic, lumbar, and sacral region of the spine. The flexures are primarily abnormalities of the intervertebral disc where cartilaginous or bony tissue substitutes for the normal felted fibers. Vertebrae in the mouse, as in mammals in general, are formed in the following way. The posterior half of one sclerotome unites with the anterior half of the subsequent sclerotome to form the anlage of the centrum. The first evidence of the intervertebral disc is rapid proliferation of cells from the two half-sclerotomes adjacent to the intervertebral fissure, and subsequently the notochord shows bulgelike thickenings at the site of the discs. Shortly before birth the notochord is present only in the intervertebral masses as the anlage of the nucleus pulposus. The cartilagelike cells of the intervertebral disc lose their matrix, elongate, and gradually become more fibrous in their appearance ; this change proceeds from the periphery of the disc toward the center. At 4.
36
SALOME QLUECKSOHN-WAELSOH
birth, the normal intervertebral disc consists of a central nucleus pulposus surrounded by a mass of fiberlike cells which will give rise to the felted fibers of the adult disc. The first abnormality recognizable in flexed embryos appears a t 14 days after fertilization when the cartilaginous cells of the intervertebral discs fail to be modified into elongated fibrous cells. These cells produce a bridge of cartilage from one vertebra to the next. If this bridge is unilateral, a true flexure will result; if it is bilateral, a straight stiff joint will be found. I n all cases, the original abnormality consists in the failure of the early cartilage of intervertebral discs to differentiate into felted fibers. The effect of “flexed” on the blood has been discussed before (cf. section IV-1) ; flexed homozygotes stiffer from a. transitory anemia, the so-called siderocytic anemia. I n addition, the flexed mutation produces a growth retardation in early embryonic stages as evidenced by shorter lengths of vertebrae. Two hypotheses are advanced to connect the different effects of flexed: (1) that growth retardation is responsible for both anemia and abnormalities of intervertebral discs; (2) that the anemia produces, by reducing the oxygen supply, the more general retardation evident in the axial system. b. Shaker Short. The extensive effects of shaker short on the brain with ensuing abnormalities of hearing and sense of balance have been discussed in another part of this review (cf. section VII-5) ; a “pedigree of causes” traced all these anomalies back to a hypertrophy of the ectodermal germ layer in very early embryonic stages (Bonnevie, 1936a, 1940). The effect of shaker short by which the mutation was originally recognized has not been discussed yet. Homozygous shaker-short mice have short tails. I n her report on the embryogeny of shaker-short mice, Bonnevie refers only briefly to he; studies of the tail development of these mice : “. . u p to about 12 days, the tail of the embryo was quite normal. Now, however, simultaneously with the abortive formations of the plexus (chorioideus), its tip, on account of the blood tension, swells like a blister, resulting in an arrest of development and in a more or less long filamentous thinning out of this tip-known also from other mutations.” It seems thus that circulatory abnormalities may be made responsible for the abnormalities of the tail of the shaker-short mouse, although the details of the abnormal processes do not appear from Bonnevie’s description or illustrations. c. Screw Tail. Another mutation first recognized by its effects on the tail is the screw-tail mutation; its effects on the development of ribs and sternum were discussed before, and it was pointed out that the
.
PHYSIOLOGICAL GENETICS OF THE MOUSE
37
screw-tail gene was supposed to have a general retarding effect on the axial skeleton (section IX-3-a). The tail of the screw-tailed homozygote is coiled a t birth and straightens out later on (MacDowell et al., 1942). Some flexures remain in the caudal, lumbar, and thoracic region of the spine. The centra of some of the vertebrae are shortened, and two or three vertebrae are mising from the tip of the tail. The difference in tail length between normal and screw-tailed mice becomes establirhed a t about 12 days after fertilization and is not due to a decrease in number of soiriites but to a reduction in size of the individual vertebrae. The tail abnormafities are thus considered to be due to a general mesodermal growth deficiency of the axial skeleton. d. [Jnclulatecl. Recently the effects of a previously reported recessive mutation (undulated, Wright, 1947) producing abnormalities in spine and tail have been analyzed in some detail (Griineberg, 1950). Although the critical embryological evidence is still forthcoming, some interesting conclusions have been drawn on the basis of observations on animals between the ages of late fetuses and fully adult individuals. The tail of undulated individuals is shortened and has a number of kinks which are not due to fusions of the vertebrae but to irregularities in the distal ends of cauclal vertebrae. Kyphosis of the lower tlioracic and upper lumbar region may be ohserved. A niimber of anatomical abnormalities of the individual vertehrae of the spine have h e n described. The reduction in size of indivicliial vertebrae is more niarlretl distally than proximally. The undulated syndrome is explained on the following basis : “The mesenchymatous axial hlteletoii of the undulated mouse would differ from that of a normal mouse hy a reduction in size which would bring certain esposed parts below the threshold size necessary for chondrification while other parts, though reduced in size, remain above the threshold and hence chonclrify and ossify normally.’’ There is a n interesting similarity between the effects of screw tail and those of undulated on the asial skeleton, as concluded from the developmental analysis of both of these mutations. T t i both cases, a general mesodermal growth deficiency of the axial skeleton i s considered to h~ produced by the mutations. It wo~ild he interesting to esamine the genetic relationship between scww tail and undulated. This has not been done so far. e. Daiaforth’s Short Tail. The last mutation to be discussed in this group is a dominant mutation with striking effects on the tail and axial skeleton whose urogenital effects were analyzed above (cf. section VI-2) ; it is the Danforth’s short-tail mutation, Sd. Sd heterozygotes have a short tail o r no tail a t all, and sacral as well as remaining caudal verte-
38
SALOME QLUECKSOHN-WAELSCH
brae may be shaped abnormally and fused with each other (QluecksohnSchoenheimer, 1943). The abnormalities of the axial skeleton of the homozygotes are more striking; the tail is always absent, and caudal and sacral vertebrae are missing completely while the few lumbars present are abnormal. The development of the tail abnormalities was studied in heterozygotes and homozygotes (Oluecksohn-Schoenheimer, 1945) ; the tail of hetcrozygotes was found to be normal up to the age of 10 days after fertilization. At 10%-11 days small hematomata are found in the tip of the tail, the somites appear small and irregular, and a progressive degeneration of tail somites in distal-proximal direction may be noted. The hematomata increase in size and sometimes fill one-half to one-third of the entire tail, while all structures in the affected part of the tail such as neural tube, notochord, tail gut, and blood vessels, break down. Progressive cell necrosis may be observed in all affected parts of the tail even prior to the appearance of hematomata. The abnormalities of the tail of the homozygotes are similar in principle but more extensive. Pycnotic granules may be observed in earlier stages in all structures of the tail ; they increase in number as the degenerative process in the tail continues. Eventually all tail structures which had originally formed normally, such as neural tube, notochord, somites, tail gut break down, and, at the end of 12 days, only a filament is left with large hematomata inside. The effect of Sd on the axial skeleton in one and two doses seems to consist in the initiation of a cellular degeneration process which starts out in the mesenchyme of the tail and subsequently attacks notochord, neural tube, and somites. The appearance of hematomata in the abnormal tail is ascribed to a breakdown of the walls of the tail blood vessels rather than to a general circulatory defect in all distal parts of the embryo, because the extremities are always free of such hematomata. Since cell pycnosis is observed even in the absence of hemorrhages, it cannot be a consequence of breakdown of circulation. Cell degeneration is considered to be the first recognizable effect of the Xd-mutation in one or two doses.
EFFECTS OF MUTATIONS IN CHROMOSOME X. THE DEVELOPMENTAL IX OF THE MOUSE From the point of view of the experimental embryologist, the most interesting mutations in the mouse are a group located on chromosome IX. These mutations were first recognized by their effects on the tail of newborn and adult mice; but their main interest lies in their effects
PHYSIOLOGICAL QENETICS OF THE MOUSE
39
on early processes of embryonic growth and differentiation which, in most of the homozygotes of this series, are severe enough to lead to the death of the embryos in early stages. F or details about the genetic behavior of these mutations the reader is referred to earlier papers (cf. e.g., Dunn and Gluecksohn-Schoenheimer, 1950). Suffice it here to say that we are dealing with a group of three closely linked dominant mutations and a number of either allelic or pseudoallelic recessives. Most of these mutations are lethal when homozygous, and animals heterozygous for two of the lethals not showing recombination breed true as a result of a balanced lethal system. The study of the developmental effects of these genes has made it possible to trace the individual steps which lead to the manifestation of the eventual mutant conditions in the axial skeleton of the newborn or the adult. Furthermore, these mutations serve as tools for the study of the normal developmental mechanics of a mammalian organism since it is only through the comparison with the abnormal that we can analyze the processes and events of normal development. Finally, the developmental effects of these genes provide us with material to study the general relationship between genes and embryonic differentiation and thus at least certain aspects of gene action (cf. Gluecksohn-Schoenheimer, 1949b). I n heterozygous condition all the mutations in this group affect thc development of the axial skeleton, and we shall deal first with this aspect of their effects. 1. Brachyury-Heterozygozts
Effect of T
The first mutation whose enibryological effects were analyzed i n detail is a dominant, T, the so-called Brachyury mutation. Animals heterozygous for T have a short tail, and homozygotes die a t about 10 days after fertilization (Chesley, 1935). The tail of the heterozygous embryo is normal up to the age of 11 days after fertilization. At this time a sharp constriction appears in the tail, and the point of constriction determines the end of the tail of the newborn mouse. The part of the tail distal to the constriction becomes smaller and smaller and loses its segmentation. Eventually, only a short filament remains. Histologically, notochordal abnormalities are a characteristic feature of the heterozygote in stages even prior to the onset of external abnormalities. Irregularities of the neural tube are frequent but occur always in conjunction with irregularities of the notochord, indicating the primary character of the notochord anomalies.
40
SALOME QLUECKSOlIN-WAELSCH
2. Taillessness, T / t n The abnormalities of the tail become more extreme when T is combined with one of the recessive mutations of the t-type also located in chromosome IX and behaving like alleles of T. Animals heterozygous for T and one of the t ’ s are usually completely tailless. The embryog eny of such prospectively tailless animals was studied, and it was found that the embryo formed a normal tail which elongated u p to the age of about 11 days after fertilization (Glnecksohn-Schoenheimer, 1938a). At that time a constriction appeared, always at the base of the tail, and subsequently the constricted tail became smaller, lost its segmentation, and eventually only a filament remained. Histologically, the prospectively tailless embryo could be recognized prior to the appearance of the constriction by the absence of a notochord. Neural tube, somites, and tail were formed normally, but were unable to persist and continue differentiation. Actually these striictures dedifferentiated and eventually only undifferentiated mesenchyme was found in their place. We thus see that in T/+ neural tube abnormalities seemed to follow those of the notochord and in T/tn the complete absence of the notochord from the tail preceded the subsequent dedifferentiation of the originally normal tail structures : neural tube, somites, tail gut. An original effect of T alone or in combination with t on the notochord or its precursor is thus one conclusion to be derived from the study of the developmental eflects of T and t, while on the other hand, the decisive role of the notochord in the normal development of the axial skeleton is strongly indicated. More information about the developmental effects of T and some of the t’s and also about the role of the notochord in the developmental mechanics of the mouse embryo was obtained from the study of embryos homozygous for T and for t. 3. Homozygous Effect of 1’
Chesley (1935) reports the absence of any gross abnormalities in the embryo homozygous for T before the age of 8y2 days. A t about 9 days, “small paired or unpaired blebs or small vesicles on either side of the midline” appear. A slight irregularity of the neural tube is observed and the somites are less clear and less regular than in normals. Shortly before death, 1 0 days after fertilization, the homozygous T-embryo shows the following characteristic external features : the posterior region of the body, including posterior limb buds, is missing completely. Normal segmentation is absent but remnants of somites may be recognized. The fore-limb buds are directed dorsad instead of ven-
PHYSIOLOQICAL QENETICS OF THE MOUSE
41
trad. The closure of the neural folds does not occur along one straight mid-dorsal line but deviates laterally and is crooked and twisted. Histologically, the somites are normal in early stages and reduced in number and abnormal in shape in later stages. They are, however, not fused medially. The neural tube shows its twisted shape on sections and is found to send out secondary branches. The notochord forming material appears a t first histologically normal, but the differentiation of the chorda dorsalis is abnormal. By the day during which death occurs, no traces of notochord are present. The notochord is thus the most severely affected structure in the T-homozygote. One of the most interesting conclusions to be drawn from the developmental studies of both T-homozygotes and T-heterozygotes is the one concerning the developmental relationship of notochord and neural tube : “Abnormalities of the neural tube have not been encountered in the absence of those of the notochord while in the lumbosacral region notochordal abnormalities without those of the neural tube are common.” “From the facts reported, supported by experimental evidence from other sources, it is concluded that there is strong indication that abnormality of the notochord is one of the more fundamental of the disorders involved and that the condition of the neural tube is either wholly or in part due to the abnormality of the notochord” (Chesley, 1935). The decisive role of the notochord for normal axial development of the mouse embryo, indicated by the studies of prospectively short-tail or tailless embryos, becomes thus even inore certain as a result of the observations of the development of 7’/T embryos. Ephrussi (1935) explanted tissues from embryos homozygous for T and found that the individual tissues were able to survive far beyond the stage a t which they would have died if left in the embryo. T is thus not a cell lethal and the death of T I T embryos is supposed to be caused by a “disturbance of the normal correlations” and to be due “exclusively to internal factors.” In a n attempt to develop a method by which mouse embryos could be grown under extra-uterine conditions and details of mutant development observed and perhaps attacked experimentally, TIT embryos were explanted into the extra-embryonic coelom of the chick in an early embryonic stage (Gluecksohn-Schoenheimer, 1944). It was shown that the abnormal development of T I T embryos was determined in early egg cylinder stages before becoming apparent morphologically. An incidental observation reported is a severe abnormality of the allantois which prevents the umbilical vessels from developing normally and is responsible for the failure of circulatory connection to become established between mother and embryo. The time of death a t 10 days thus is consid-
42
SALOME QLUECKSOHN-WAELSCH
ered to be determined by the absence of nutrition of the embryo by way of the maternal circulation and the cause of death seems sufficiently explained without any additional assumptions. 4.
t-Type Mutations-Developmental
Effects of to, tl, t4
It has been estimated (Dunn and Gluecksohn-Schoenheimer, 1950) that a t least 14 changes of the t-type have occurred in chromosome I X
of the mouse, i.e., 14 different t-mutations have been detected. Five of these are known to be lethal when homozygous, three are viable, and the behavior of the others in bomozygous condition is not yet known. The first t-type mutation studied in its effects on development in homozygous condition is to (Qluecksohn-Schoenheimer, 1940). Pt0 embryos are reported to be normal u p to a stage soon after implantation in the uterus, the so-called egg cylinder stage. But while the normal embryo now enters a stage of rapid growth and morphogenesis, growth and development of the homozygous embryo cease. It remains in a stage where a n unorganized inner cell mass (=ectoderm) is surrounded by a layer of entoderm (this “inversion of germ layers” is a typical feature of many rodent embryos) until disintegration sets in and the embryo becomes necrotic and is resorbed. During a time when organization of the ectoderm and mesoderm formation characterizn +he development of normal 7 signs of these processes; embryos, the abnormal embryo fails to shou it survives for about 40 hours before it disintegrates. The failure of organization and mesoderm formation is a characteristic feature of totoembryos. Another mutation of the t-type (t’) has been reported to be lethal before implantation (Gluecksohn-Schoenheimer, 1938b). The details of the abnormalities of tltl are not known. Unpublished observations of abnormalities of t4-homozygotes ( Qluecksohn-Waelsch) indicate that the death of these embryos occurs at the age of 7-8 days after fertilization, i.e., a t a stage when embryonic growth and differentiation are most active. 5. Kink-Hmoizygous
Effect of Ki
Still another mutation located on chromosome IX seems to affect processes of early embryonic growth and differentiation. This is the dominant mutation Kink which in heterozygous condition is responsible for the rather typically kinky appearance of the tail. The embryonic events leading to the manifestation of Kink in heterozygous condition have not been analyzed as yet. But the homozygous embryos, which die at about 9 days after fertilization, have been studied in detail (Gluecksohn-Schoenheimer, 1949a). Their abnormalities are typical and strik-
PHYSIOLOQICAL QENETICS OF THE MOUSE
43
ing although varying considerably from one another individually. The feature common to all these abnormal embryos is the presence of duplications of different types and degrees. The duplications reported range from complete or partial duplication of the entire embryonic axis through duplications of organs or parts of them to the presence of only some excess growth in the form of a lump of tissue. On the basis of these observations comparisons are made with results obtained in experiments on amphibian embryos, where constrictions of eggs resulted in different types and degrees of duplications, comparable to those observed in K i / K i embryos. From the existence of these duplications it is concluded that ‘ ‘ the mouse embryo possesses a considerable amount of regulative property in early developmental stages, ’’ and ( ( t ha t organization phenomena and inductive interrelationships between different parts of the embryo known to function in amphibians and birds apparently exist in the mouse as well.’’ I n connection with the duplications in Kink homozygotes a genetically determined duplication of the posterior part of the body of the mouse described by Danforth (1930) is of interest. The details of the genetics of “posterior duplication” are not known; the morphology of the posterior doubling varies considerably from typical duplicitas posterior with ectopic viscera and two complete sets of pelvic organs and hind limbs to those with only a slight degree of doubling. A “pronounced thickening of the ventral tissues a t the posterior end of the embryo” a t 11 days after fertilization is reported as the first observed symptom of the abnormality. ((Th e hypertrophy seems to be initiated in the mesoderm,’’ and “there is evidence of some direct and determining influence of one region on another. ’’
6. Fused The development of Fused, the third dominant tail mutation in chromosome I X in heterozygous or homozygous condition has not been studied in detail but Reed (1937) reports that ( ( a n embryological study of Fused showed the first observable abnormalities to be poor alignment of the notochord and distinct curves and angles of the neural crests,” without, however, giving any evidence for his statement. I n preliminary studies of the embryology of Fused homozygotes we have observed a considerable number of embryos with brain abnormalities resembling pseudencephaly (cf. section VII-3). These embryos are apparently unable to survive until term and die in utero. The effect of Fused in homozygous condition on the development of the anterior part of the neural tube does not seem to be regular, but occurs only in a fraction of the embryos and depends apparently on the residual genotype.
44
SALOME QLUECKSOHN-WAELSCH
We may deal here with another example of the type of developmental reaction discussed above (cf. section IX-1-a). The head abnormalities in Pu/Pw embryos might be due to an increased susceptibility of the prospective head region, or in other words to a lowered threshold of resistance to embryonic traumata which normally would not leave any effect on the developing embryo. The lowered threshold of resistance might in t ur n be due to the presence of the Fused mutation in two doses.
7. A b n m d i t i e s of to/tl Embryos While the main effect of the “tail” mutations of the ninth chromosome of the house mouse a t least when heterozygous seems to be on the posterior part of the body, Fu-homozygotes are not the only individuals in this group of mutations which exhibit abnormalities of the head region. Genetic data from intercrosses of two tailless lines (A and 29) differing in the type of t ( T / t o X T / t l ) had shown that the combination of to with tl produced normal-tailed offspring. However, there seemed to be a deficiency in the number of young of this constitution (to/tl) at birth. Uteri of females supposed to carry to/tl embryos were therefore examined in a search f o r possibly abnormal P/tl embryos unable to survive until term (Dunn and Gluecksohn-Schoenheimer, 1943). Such embryos were discovered and found to have severe abnormalities of the head, such as microcephaly, microphthalmia and anencephaly. Control experiments excluded the possibility that these abnormals were not of the to/tl genotype. Just as in the case of Fused-homozygotes only a fraction of to/tl embryos developed head abnormalities and apparently again the residual genotype played a role in determining the variability of manifestation of the to/tl zygote. But there is no doubt that the anterior part of the axial system may also be affected by the action of these “tail” mutations.
8. Miscellaneous Abnormalities in IncEividuals Carrying Mutations of Chromoame I X A general fundamental disturbance of early embryonic development by mutations on chromosome IX is also indicated by another set of observations ( Gluecksohn-Schoenheimer and Dunn, 1945). Monsters with extreme malformations of the posterior region of the trunk and the extremities (sirenoid malformations), or with striking abnormalities of the head (aprosopi), o r with severe intestinal abnormalities (complete absence of large parts of the intestine) were found among newborn mice which carried different combinations of mutations of chromosome IX. Similar abnormalities had not been observed in numerous other strains at the same laboratory. While they cannot be ascribed to any par-
PHYSIOLOQICAL QENETICS OF THE MOUSE
45
ticular genotype, they seem to owe their origin to the presence of different mutations of chromosome IX. Although these abnormalities have not been traced back embryologically, they are assumed to be caused by severe disturbances of early processes of embryonic growth and differentiation. It seems that the presence of mutations in chromosome IX makes the developmental system of the mouse sufficiently labile so that i t will react with severe disturbances to some embryonic trauma which normally would leave the embryo unharmed. 9. The Role of Chromosome I X in Embryonic Growth and Differentiation Chromosome IX of the mouse thus seems to carry a group of genetic factors all of which are concerned with the control of processes of early embryonic growth and differentiation. No mutation with other effects has been located in this chromosome. This does not mean, o f , course, that chromosome IX plays a n exclusive role in the control of these processes. There is no doubt about the existence of many genetic factors which are involved in the control of the same processes of early growth and differentiation and are located in other chromosomes. The heterozygous effect of several of the tail mutations of chromosome IX has already been shown to be duplicated by tail mutations in other chromosomes of the mouse, as described above. The important point, however, is the grouping of mutations with similar effects in one chromosome regardless of the fact that other such mutations most certainly do exist in other chromosomes as well. The individual mutations in chromosome IX affect either different steps of early embryonic processes, or the same processes in different ways. Evidence for such a n assumption comes first from the fact that individuals heterozygous for two mutations, each of which causes death of the embryo when present in two doses, are viable and sometimes even normal. Furthermore, the embryonic study showed that the developmental changes produced by these mutations were clearly different in the case of the different mutations. Changes in most of these genetic factors lead to abnormalities of derivatives of the notochord-mesoderm material and to phenomena traceable to a n absence of functioning or to abnormal functioning of this same material. Any hypothesis trying to explain the close linkage of genes with closely related effects on embryonic processes has to take into account their peculiar genetic behavior which has been reported in a series of papers (for references cf. Dunn and Qluecksohn-Schoenheimer, 1950). Some speculations in this connection were advanced recently (Gtluecksohn-Schoenheimer, 1949b). The close linkage of mutations with
46
SALOME QLUECKSOHN-WAELSOH
similar embryonic effect was discussed first in the light of Goldschmidt ’s ( 1949) hypothesis about the relation of heterochromatic heredity to processes of early growth and differentiation, and then in connection with Pontecorvo’s ideas (1950) about. the relation between location of genes and the processes they control. The grouping of these genes seems of the greatest significance for problems of gene action and the relation of genes and cell differentiation. XI.
CHANQESINDUCED BY X-RAYS DEVELOPMENTAL
The developpental changes in the mouse embryo discussed so fa r were produced by changes in genes, i.e., mutations. But attempts have been made also to affect developmental processes directly, e.g., with the help of X-rays. Kaven (1938a,b) irradiated pregnant mice with X-rays in different fitages of pregnancy and studied the effect between 7 and 19 days after fertilization. The resulting disturbances of development consisted of brain hernias, hydrocephalus, tail abnormalities, lens turbidity, and fiterility. Since these abnormalities had also been observed as the result of the effect of mutations, it was interesting to compare the sensitive periods during which X-ray irradiation produced a certain type of developmental abnormality with its onset as a result of a mutational change. Kaven found a highly lethal effect as the result of X-ray treatment a t 7 clays, corresponding to the time of manifestation of lethality in embryos carrying mutations which produced changes in early processes of growth and differentiation. Brain abnormalities were induced at 8 days after fertilization, the age at which the first symptoms of genetically determined brain anomalies in mice were observed. X-ray treatment between 9 and 13 days resulted in tail abnormalities, and again it is noteworthy that this is the time at which the first recognizable deviations of tail development could be observed in animals carrying tail mutations. . Recently L. B. Russell (1950) has attacked the same problem on a broader basis, extending the stages of treatment to the very beginning of the gestation period. An analysis of the changes induced by x-ray treatment is expected to reveal “intrinsic patterns of sensitivity in the organism and the discove;y of sensitive periods in particular developmental processes. ’’ These sensitive periods were established throughout the embryonic period by determining prenatal mortality and abnormalities a t birth. A comparison is made which shows a certain degree of parallelism bet ween the abnormalities produced by irradiation and those described as the effects of mutations. However, “the entire set of changes char-
PHYSIOLOGICAL GENETICS OF THE MOUSE
47
acteristic of a particular stage-dose group is usually more inclusive than the set of features characteristic of any parallel mutant.’’ A number of abnormalities described as the result of gene action were not observed in “newborns as a result of irradiation of embryos.” This may, however, be due to the fact that embryos with such abnormalities were unable to survive to term. A combination of results obtained with this method with those arrived at from studies of developmental genetics might prove very fruitful “in bringing analysis of the development of the abnormal character even closer (chronologically) to the original gene action.”
XII. CONCLUDING REMARKS The mutations discussed i n this review have been shown to effect practically every organ system and thus have contributed to the analysis of a great number of different mechanisms involved in the development of form and function of a mammalian organism. A number of general points of interest have emerged from this discussion. When abnormalities observed in the newborn or adult organism are traced back into embryonic stages it frequently appears that the first deviation from normal recognizable in the embryo is not necessarily one in the primordium of the organ which becomes abnormal later on. Such a ease is illustrated, for example, by the analysis of congenital hydrocephalus by Griineberg (1943b) (cf. section VII-2) which could be traced back to an original abnormality of the cartilage and where the effect on the brain was thus quite indirect. Developmental studies of mutations are therefore a prerequisite for the detection of the first visible effects of a mutation before the problem of primary gene action can even be approached. The vast number of genes contributing to the normal development of any organ is reflected in the large number of different mutations which were found to effect any single organ system. Although, as pointed out i n the introduction, only a relatively small and selected number of mutations was chosen for discussion in this review, and actually many more exist, it is evident even so that, e.g., the nervous system, the skeleton, or the skin, are dependent on the collaboration of a great many hereditary factors for normal form arid function. One very interesting phenomenon emerging from developmental studies of mutational effects is the appearance of definite abnormalities as the result of a number of vastly different agencies. Pseudencephaly, for example, was shown to originate as the result of (1) a simple recessive mutation, (2) chromosomal translocations and ensuing chromosomal
48
SALOME GLUECKGOHN-WAELSUH
unbalance, (3) the presence of mutations which lower the threshold of embryonic resistance (cf. section X-6, F u l F u ) , (4 ) X-ray irradiation of embryos. The same syndrome of urogenital abnormalities and those of the posterior trunk region has been shown to result from the action of different mutations (cf. section X-8), and more examples could be cited to illustrate this. phenomenon. The existence of any particular syndrome of abnormalities does therefore not necessarily reflect an identity of hereditary changes or of developmental pathways disturbed. Different mutations and different developmental changes may lead to the same final picture, emphasizing again the interdependence of developmental processes of the vertebrate embryo. Of course all these phenomena cannot be separated from one of the most important problems of gene action, namely that of pleiotropism. Does the gene have one or more than one primary effect P Or are some of its effects subordinated to the primary effect, i.e., a consequence of it 1 The developmental analysis of mutational effects can sometimes help to eliminate the problem, by the discovery, for example, that a number of different adult effects can be traced back to one common embryonic change. However, as the result of such studies, the problem merely ceases to exist in particular cases while it is by no means solved as such. The problem of pleiotropism in a mammalian organism has been discussed repeatedly on the basis of the analysis of different mutations (cf. e.g., Briineberg, 1943b ; Gluecksohn-Schoenheimer, 1945 ; E. S. Russell, 1949b). Briineberg (1943b), as the result of developmental analyses, arrives a t the conclusion that genuine pleiotropism does not exist and that the primary action of the gene is always either cell specific or tissue specific. It has been pointed out before ( Bluecksohn-Schoenheimer, 1949b) that one cannot expect an elucidation of primary gene action from the study of morphological gene effects which in their complexity must be far removed from the original gene effect. The question of whether a gene has one o r more primary functions will have to be approached with different methods. Furthermore (Gluecksohn-Schoenheimer, 1945), it does not seem that we are justified to call the gene’s primary action cell or tissue specific just because the developmental analyses of the gene’s visible effects with the crude morphological methods a t our disposal seem to indicate such a specificity of effect. Russell in her discussion of different effects of W on blood and pigment cells (1949) points out that it is logically possible that “unity of gene action could exist without tissue or cell specificity” and that the same original gene product could be active in two types of cells. She considers the interesting “parallelism of the effects of the entire W
PHYSTOLOGICAL GENETICS OF THE MOUSE
49
series of genes upon the blood and pigment-producing tissues” a n indication of the very close original connection between the two different effects of W and its alleles (cf. section IV-2). It seems that the problem of pleiotropic gene effects will have to wait for further elucidation until a more direct approach to the problem of primary gene action is possible. While prbblems of primary gene action thus cannot be expected to be solved by developmental studies of gene effects of the type discussed here, one of the most significant contributions of such investigations lies in the discovery of normal interdependencies of developmental processes as revealed by the study of the abnormal. A number of such instances have been discussed. I shall only cite again the dependence of the metaneplrros on a n inductive stimulus from the ureter (cf. section VI-3), the dependence of ossification processes in the sternum on normal rib growth (cf. section IX-3-a), the developmental interrelationship between neural tube and ear vesicles (cf. section VIT-s), the significance of the notochord-mesodermal material in mammalian development (cf. section X-3 and 4 ) , the discovery of organizer type phenomena, and of the existence of regulation in early mammalian embryos (cf. section X-5). Most of the early embryonic changes reported concern disturbances of inductive phenomena, while degeneration processes leading to absence of structures are surprisingly rare. It seems that the study of the role of genes in early growth and differentiation should find the mouse embryo a promising object also for future research, due to the existence of organizer and inductive phenomena on the one hand, and of relatively frequent mutations, on the other hand, which interfere with these processes.
XIII. REFERENCES DeAberle, 8. B., 1927, Amer. J . Anat. 40, 219-249. Barnioot, N. A,, 1941, Amer. J . A n d . 68, 497-531. 1945, J . A m t . 79, 83-91. Bonnevie, K., 1934, J . exp. 2001. 67, 443-520. 1936a, Norske Vidsk.-Akad. Oslo Skr. K1. 1, No. 9. 193613, Genetica 18, 105-125. 1940, Handb. Erbbiol. Menschen 1, 73-180. 1943, Norske Viidsk.-Akad. Oslo Skr. K1. 1, No. 4. 1945, Norske Vidsk.-Akad. Oslo Skr. K1. 1, No. 10. Bonnevie, K., and Brodal, A., 1946, Norske 8idsk.-Akad. Oslo Skr. K1. 1, No. 4. Brodal, A., Bonnevie, K., and Harkmark. W., 1944, Norske Vidsk.-Akad. Oslo Skr. Kl. 1, No. 8. Brown, A. L., 1931, Amer. J . Anat. 47, 117-172. Bryson, V., 1945, Anat. Reo. 91, 119-141.
50
SALOME QLUECKSOHN-WAELSOH
Carter, T. C., 1949, Heredity 3, 378-379. 1951, J. Genet. 60, 277-299. Castle, W. E., and Little, C. C., 1910, Science 32, 868-870. Chang, T. K,, 1939, Peking nat. Hist. Bull. 14, 119-132 Chase, H. B., and Chase, E. B., 1941, J. Morph. 68, 279-301. Chesley, P., 1935, J. exp. 2002. 70, 429-459. Clark, F. H., 1934, Anat. Rec. 68, 225-233. CuBnot, L., 1905, Arch. 2001.exp. gSn. 4" series, 3, Nates et Rev. CBXIII-CXXXII. Danforth, C. H., 1930, Am. J. Anat. 46, 275-287. Dunn, L. C., 1934a, J. Genet. 29, 317-326. 1943b, Proc. nat. Acad. Sci., Wash. 20, 230-232. Dunn, L. C., and Einsele, W., 1938, J . Genet. 36, 145-152 Dunn, L. C., and Gluecksohn-Schaenheimer, S., 1943, Gmrtics, 28, 29-40. 1947, J. exp. 2001.104, 25-52. 1950, Proc. nat. Acad. Sci., Wash. 36, 233-237. Dunn, L. C., Oluecksohn-Schoenheimer, S., Curtis, M. R., and Dunning, W. F., 1942, J . Hered. 33, 65-67. Ephrussi, B., 1935, J. ezp. 2002.70, 197-204. Falconer, D. S., Fraser, A. S., and King, J. W. B., 1951, ,7. Genet. 60, 324-344. Foster, Morris, 1951, in press. Fraser, F. C., 1946, Conad. J. Res. D24, 10-25. 1949, Canad. J. Res. 27, 179-185. Gluecksohn-Schoenheimer, S., 1938a, Genetics 23, 573-584. 1938b, Proo. 800. exp. Biol.,N. Y. 39, 267-268. 1940, Genetics 25, 391-400. 1943, Genetws 28, 341-348. 1944, Proc. nat. Acad. Sct., Wash. SO, 134-140. 1945, Genetics, 30, 29-38. 1949a, J. exp. 2002.~110,47-76. 1949b, Growth IX, 163-176. Gluecksohn-Schoenheimer, S., and D u n , L. C., 1945, Anat. Rec. 92, 201-213. Goldschmidt, R. B., 1949, Proc. 8 t h int. Congr. Genet., Hereditas 244-255. Green, E. L., and Green, M. C., 1942, J. Morpb. 70, 1-19. Green, M. C., 1951, J. Morph. 88, 1-21. Griineberg, H., 1936, J. Hered. 27, 105-109. 1937, J. A n d . 71, 236-244. 1938, J. Genet. 36, 153-170. 1942a, J. Genet. 43, 45-68. 194213, J. Genet. 43, 285-293. 1942c, J. Genet. 44, 246-271. 1943a, The Genetics of the Mouse. Cambridge University Press. 1943b, J. Genet. 46, 22-28. 1947, Animal Genetics and Medicine. Paill R. Hoeber, New York. 1950, J. Genet. 60, 142-173. Hardy, M. H., 1949, J. Anat., 83, 364-384. Hertwig, P., 1944, 2. menschl. Vererbungs.-u. Konstitutionslehre 28, 327-354. Holt, S. B., 1948, Ann. of Eugenics 14, 144-157. Hovelacque, A., and Noel, R., 1923, Bull. Biol. France el Belg. 67, 133-142. Hunt, H. R., and Permar, D., 1928, Anat. Rec. 41, 117. Ibsen, R. L., and Steigleder, E., 1917, Amer. N u t . 61, 740-752.
PHYSIOLOGICAL GENETICS OF THE MOUSE
51
Kamenoff, R. J., 1935, J. Y o r p h . 68, 117-155. Kaven, A., 1938a, Z.menschl. Vererbungs.-u. Konstitutionslehre 22, 238-246. 1038b, Z. menschl. Vererbungs.-u. Konstitutionslehre 22, 247-257. Kirkham, W. B., 1919, J. exp. Zool. 28, 125-135. Little, C. C., 1919, Amer. Nat. 63, 185-187. Little, C. C., and Cloudman, A. M., 1937, Proc. nat. Acad. Sci., Wash. 23, 535-537. MacDowell, E. C., Potter, J. S., Laanes, T., and Ward, E. N., 1942, J . Hered. 33, 439-449. Miiller, G., 1950, 2. ntikrosk-anat. Forsch. 66, 520-558. Pontecorvo, G., 1950, Biochem. 800. Symposia N . 4, 40-50. Rawles, M. E., 1947, Physiol. Zo6l. XX, 248-266. Reed, S. C., 1933, Anat. Ilec. 66,101-110. 1937, Genetics 22, 1-13. 1938a, J . exp. Zool. 79, 331-336. 1938b, J. exp. Zool. 79, 337-346. 1938c, J . exp. Zool. 79, 347-354. Reed, S. C., and Henderson, J. M., 1940, J. exp. 2001.86, 409-418. Robertson, G. G., 1942, J . exp. 2002.89, 197-231. Russell, E. S., 1946, Genetics 31, 327-346. 1948, Genetics 33, 228-236. 1949a, Genetics 34, 133-166. 1949b, Genetics 34, 708-723. Russell, E. S., Fondal, E. L., and Smith, L. J., 1950, Rec. Genet. SOC. Amer. 122123. Russell, L. B., 1950, J. exp. Zool. 114, 545-602. Russell, L. B., and Russell, W. L., 1948, Genetics 33, 237-262. Serra, J. A., 1947, Nature, Lond. 169, 504-505. Smith, P. E., and MacDowell, E. C., 1930, Anat. Rec. 46, 249-257. Snell, Gc. D.,1929, Proc. laat. Acad. Sci. W s h . 15, 733-734. 1941, (Ed.) Biology of the Laboratory Mouse. The Blakiston Company, Philadelphia. Snell, G. D., Bodeman, E., and Hollander, W., 1934, J. esp. Zool. 67, 93-104. Snell, G. D.,and Picken, D. I., 1935, J. Genet. 31, 213-235. Sobotta, J., 1895, Arch. mikr. Anat. 46, 15-93. 1902, Arch. mikr. Anat. 61, 274-330. 1911, Arch. mibr. Anat. 78, 271-352. Steiniger, F., 1941, 2. menschl. Vererbungs.-u. Konstitutionslehre 26, 1-27. Tsang, P.-C., 1939, J. comp. Neuro. 70, 1-8. Werneke, F., 1916, Arch. EntwMech. 4 5 72-106. Wright, M. E., 1947, Heredity 1, 137-141.
Developmental Action of Lethal Factors in Drosophila ERNST HADORN * Zoologisrh-vtrgl. n n a t o n i i s c . 7 ~Institzit, ~ Uniiicrsity of Zitrich, S ’ d t z e r l n n d CONTENTS
. ... ... . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ....
I. Introduction 11. Phase a n d Type of Action 1. Embryonic Lethals , 2. E/L-Boundary Lethals . 3. Larval Lethals . . . 4. L/Pr-Boundary Lethals , 5. Prepupal Lethrtls , 6. Pupal Lethals 7. P/I-Boundary Lethals , , 8. Imaginal Lethals . , 111. The Validity of the Concept of Phase-Specificity IV. The Development of “ P a t t e r n s of Damage” V. Information Gained from Transplantation Experiments VI. Physiological Properties of Lethals VII. Phenocopies of Patterns of Darnage . V I I I . Conditioned Lethals IX. Lethality Due to Combined Genic Action X. Effects of Lethals in Heterozygotes XI. Conclusions X I I . References
. . . .
.
. . . .
. . ..... . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.. ....... .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Page 53 54 54 60 60 61 61 62 62 62 62 65 67 71 76 77 78 80 82 83
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
I. INTRODUCTION Lethal factors are Mendelian units that cause the death of the individual a t some stage during its development, thereby preventing it from reaching the reproductive stage. The different types of lethals and the terms used for them have been discussed recently by Hadorn (1949b). It is well known that lethals are among the most common mutations, arising experimentally after treatment of germ cells with ionizing radiation or with chemicals as well as spontaneously in wild populations and laboratory stoclrs. They therefore play an essential role in all theoretical and practical problems connected with gene mutability. The action of lethal factors demonstrates how development can be * I should like t o express my gratitude t o my collaborators, Dr. H. Gloor, Dr. P. S. Chen, and M. Schnitter for their contributions and kind assistance with respect to this review. 53
54
ERNST HADORN
altered fundamentally as a consequence of change or loss of genic material. Thus each lethal mutant reveals some specific developmental action of the mutated chromosomal region. We visualize normal development as a teamwork of cell constituents, to which several thousand different gene loci contribute. Any information we can gain from study of the developmental action of a lethal factor will therefore be valuable and essential with regard to the ultimate goal of a science in which embryology and genetics ought to be united. The aim of this paper is to review the information as f a r as the development of Drosophila is concerned. It is a n amazing fact that relatively few data are available, although hundreds of thousands of lethal mutants have been registered by Drosophila workers and many hundreds of them have been maintained in laboratory stocks. We find for instance in the exhaustive report The Mutants of Drosophila melanogaster (Bridges and Brehme, 1944) a total of 557 lethal mutants listed; for only about 60 of these do we have information concerning developmental effects. I n the case of the great majority of lethal factors we do not even know whether they lead to embryonic, larval, or pupal death. As to lethals with known developmental effects, only a few have been thoroughly investigated ; and cases for which both morphological and physiological studies have been made are exceedingly rare. Thus the lethal mutants represent a vast material for exploitation in future research.
11. PHASE AND TYPEOF ACTION Without discussing all details we shall restrict ourselves in this section to stating for the different known lethals the developmental stage at which they lead to death and, if such information is available, the kind of abnormality that can be considered the immediate cause of lethality. It is possible to classify the great majority of the lethal mutants according to the stage at which their development comes to a halt and death occurs.
1. Embryonic Lethals ( E ) The embryonic period of development begins with the fertilization of the egg and ends when, within the egg membrane, a fully differentiated larva is ready to hatch. I n Drosophila melartogaster this development is completed in 22 to 25 hours at 25" C." There is in this group a "Most of the information on normal development used in this paper is based on the very detailed treatises by Bodenstein, Sonnenblick, and Poulson in Biology of Drosophila, edited by Demerec (1950).
ACTION OF LETHAL FACTORS IN DROSOPHILA
55
regrettable discrepancy between the tremendous number of lethals found by Drosophila workers and the small number of cases studied in detail. Poulson (1940, 1941, 1945) investigated a series of embryonic-lethal genotypes, in each of which development is interrupted in a specific way and a t a definite stage. These, together with the others for which ac(Inrate data are available, have been entered in Table 1. W e can draw the following conclusions from the data for these few lethal genotypes. a. Every important step in embryonic development may be interrupted or become abnormal through loss or mutational change of genic material. b. There seems to be a positive correlation between the extent of a deficiency and the severity of the developmental damage. Genotypes deficient for the whole X chromosome perform less developmental work than the half-X deficiencies, and the latter die earlier and show a more fundamental “ anormogenesis” than the smaller Notch o r white deficiencies. c. The work of I’oulson (1945) on the Notch and white lethals has shown, however, that identical patterns of damage ensue in deficiencies of many bands, deficiencies of one band only, and point-mutations that cause no visible change in the salivary chromosomes. This becomes intelligible if one assunies that the detrimental effect of a deficiency is not quantitative in nature, but a consequence of the loss of one particular gene locus. The decisive loci would be those that first enter into action in normal ontogeny. Loss of these loci, or mere inertness produced by point-mutation, would therefore lead to the same effect. The more extended the deficiency, the greater the probability that loci of fundamental importance for the earliest steps in development would be lost. This interpretation is based on the principle that as development prooeeds a gradually and steadily increasing numher o f genes enters into action (Hadorn, 1948h). I n the case of very large deficiencies (loss of whole chromosomes or whole chromosomal arms), however, we have to consider still another mechanism that can cause lethality. I n such genotypes the balance of the genic system is severely upset. Lethal effects resulting from disturbances in the quantitative relations of chromosomal materials are shown by the tetra-IV and the triplo-X genotypes. In the first of these, where two supernumerary fourth chromosomes are added t o a normal caryotype, development is interrupted in the egg or larval stage (Li, 1927). I n the second, two sets of autosomes have to counterbalance three X chromosomes. These genotypes infrequently hatch, as weak and sterile imagines (supcrfemales) ; but most of them die in a late larval or pupal stage (Brehme, 1937). Since duplications of single chromo-
56
ERNST HADORN
TABLE I Drosophila melanognster
I
I
Embryonic Lethals about Which Reliable Facts Are Known Df = deficiency ; I' = point miitants nitli iiormnl s:ilivnry-cliroinosome strnctnre ; - translocation
I . . _
Symbol, name, c h r o m -
Time c i f t w fertilization and stage of lethal action
liind of ub?inriiiality i7i hcmizygolcs (he) or ho niosygotes ( h o )
Hcfprciio s
1 hour; cleavage mitosis
he ; abnormal distribution of cleavage nuclei ; Illantoderrn not formed
Poulson, 1940
Df-XR Df (right, arm of X )
2 hours ; h1aatoder.m f or ma t ion
lie ; incomplete blosto-
I'ouIwii,
I I t,l'lll
1940
Df-XL Df (left a r m of X )
3 hours; pregastrular cell movements
he ; germ layers not separated
Poulson, 1940
Nn
6 hours; primary organogenesis
he ; incomplete separation of hypodermis front h y p e r t r o p h i c nervous system ; mesodcrmal organs incompletely differentiated ; midgnt inr.omplete
Poulson, 1945
x
ho11r.s; segmentation of hrad and trunk
ho; defects i n middlemost segmeiitn
Glool',
12 hours; Iieginning of final organogenesis
he; mesodermal tissues abnormal a n d degenera t i n g ; midgut remains sac-like
Poulson, 1945
20 hours;
he; no a i r in tracheae; m u ~ c u l a r 111 o v e in P 11 t iinptlirpd
Poulmn, 1941)
soma1 t y p e
NuUO-X Df (whole
X)
Notch-Df No* Notch-Df N**'-' Notch-Df
N"'-" Notch-Df N'"-'' Notch-Df N'"4 Notch-Df Notch-P N"'4' Notch-P Not~,l-l'~
Kr Kruppel-P
wla~-ll
wl10-1k
~
~
'
white-Df white-Df white-Df ~ - 4 ~
Df(1)so' scute-Df
t vaclieae fill
with air, larval diff wentiatiou :Ilmost ronipleted
1950
57
ACTION O F LETHAL FACTORS IN DROSOPHILA
TABLE 1-Continued ~~
Df(1)R60-2
20 hours; lie; n o air in tracheae; tracheae fill innscular m o v e m e n t with air, larval impaired tliff erentiatic~n almost completed
Kaliss, 1939
Px Plexate-Df
21 liours; larval h o ; unable t o hatcli differentiation completed
Li, 1927 Bridges,
M(2)Z Minute-Df
21 hours ; larval 110; unable to hatch ; differentintion thin chorion conipleted
Li, 1927
S Stw-P
21 liours ; l a r ~ n llio ; nn:il)lc to Iiatcli ; tlifferentiation black spot benclntli completed niieropyle
SivertzevDohzhansky, 1927
1937
somes may lead to lethal effects comparable to those produced by big deficiencies, one could interpret the effect of deficiency-mutants also on a quantitative basis. It is thus impossible to decide whether the developmental effects in the first three cases of Table 1 are caused by loss of one gene o r by a gross disturbance of genic balance. The first interpretation results from an extrapolation of data obtained on the Notch and white series of lethals ; the second is suggested in view of the duplication lethals. Apart from the mutants of Table 1, one finds in the literature many reports of the occiirrence of lethality in embryonic stages. They are based mostly on the mere observation that the lethal mutants concerned fail to hatch from the egg membrane. However, a glance a t Table 1 shows how differently embryonic lethals interrupt and change development. Therefore superficial statements furnish no useful material for tackling the problems that physiological genetics has to solve. We may only state that apparently most of the dominant lethals that have been induced by X-raying mature sperms are effective in embryonic stages (Demerec and Fano, 1941; Lea, 1946). This treatment produces gross chromosomal aberrations, which actually do not impair the capacity for fertilization but lead to severe cytological abnormalities in the developing zygote. Sonnenblick (1940) studied such abnormalities and found cleavage mitoses with isolated and clumped chromosomes as well as dicentric and acentric fragments. As a consequence of the ensuing un-
58
ERNST HADORN
TABLE 2 Postembryonic Letlials of Drosophila melanogaster
E = embryonic; L = larval; Pr = prepupal; P = pupal; I = imaginal Symbol and term
1. E/L C y Curly
-
Locus
Stage of death K i n d of abnormality References chromosomal in hemisygotes ( h e ) type or homozygotes (ho) In(2L)Cy
E/L boundary ho ; inability of larvae to develop
SivertzevDobzhansky, 1927 Hadorn, unpublished
ClB
I n ( 1 ) C1
E / L boundary he; inability of larvae to develop
Brehme, 1937
M ( 3 ) FlaMinute
3-79,7
E/L boundary ho; inability of
Brehme, 1939
l(l)w
1-66 -C allele of
larvae to develop
E/L boundary he; inability of larvae to develop
Schubel, 1934
2-101.2
First instar
ho; inability to grow and pass first instar
Brehme, 1939
3-79,7
First instar
110;
inability to grow and pass first instar
Brehme, 1939
l(2)ax
2-106.9
First instar
110; inability to grow and pass first instar
Bridges, 1937
Bd Beaded
3-93.8
First instar
110;
inability t o grow and pass first instar
SivertzevDobzhansky, 1927
First iiistar
he; defective ring gland
Cullen, 1948
Larvae of 2 mm. length
ho; abnormal development of tracheal and other chitinized parts
Bridges, 1937
2-72 f
Third instar
ho; disturbed growth r at e; unable to form puparium
Hadorn and Schmid, 1947 Sclimitl, 1949
1-0.3
Third instar
he ; obliteration of gut lumen before 70 hours
Russell, 1940
bb
2.
L
M(2)l' Minute
1( 2 ) N S
l(2)me
meander
59
ACTION OF LETHAL FACTORS IN DROSOPHILA
TABLE 8-Continued
3. L/Pr l ( 2 ) g l lethal giant larvae
Df (2)P
4. Pr
5. P
6. P/I
7. I
PaleDeficiency l(3)blo-1 bloated larvae
1-0 2
Mostly i n prepupal stages
formation of pseudopupae
Df in 2
As larvae or pseudopupae
ho; shrunken body within puparium
110;
-
Hadorn, 1937b Hadorn, 1948a Gloor, 1943
Li,1927
ho; larvae trans- T. Y.Chen, parent; irregular 1929 growth of imaginal discs 3-20,7+ Early or late ho; defects in im- Hadorn, 1941 t(3)tr pupal life aginal differentia- Hadorn, 1949 translucida Gloor, 1949a tion 3Late pupal ho; tumorlike l(3)hd Morgan, life growth in head head Bridges, Sturtevant, defects 1925 3-Zn(3R)C Late pupal ho; unable to Schultz life hatch from pupal of. Bridges and Brehme, case 1944 2-55-C Late pupal Head hidden in Hadorn u. crc Gloor, 1943 life thorax cryptoGloor, 1945 cephal Schultz and Pm' 2Late pupal Very light eye Dobzhansky, Plum color life 1934 Ives, 1942 3-35.5 Late pupal Inability t o push eYg life open pupal case; eye gone eyes and head reduced Starck, 1922 1Early imaginal Weak, short-lived i(i)sa life flies 1-29.0 End of pupal Melanotic degen- Gowen, 1934 me stage eration i n legfocal melanosis junction 2Early imaginal Leg tumors Spencer, 1(2)W life 1937 leg-tumors 3-47,7 Early imaginal Oral lobes changed Bridges and Pb life to tarsus-like or Dobzhansky, probosciarista-like struc- 1933 pedia tures; inability to feed Transloca- Early imaginal Winga not ex- Dobzhansky, T(b;C)C tion life panded; flies die 1930 early
3-
Prepupae or early pupae
60
ERNST HADORN
balanced nuclei, the cytoplasmic differentiation becomes hampered ; instead of progressive cell structures one observes syncytial masses. Thus the effect of dominant lethals is in many respects comparable to the pattern of damage that Poulson (1940) found in male embryos deficient for large parts of the X chromosome. Only a few dominant lethals become active in larval instars, and none of them seems to allow development up to the pupal stage (Demerec and Fano, 1944).
2. E/L-Boundary Lethals It is a characteristic feature of many lethal mutants that some of the individuals die within the egg membrane as fully differentiated larvae, whereas others are able to hatch but unable to grow further as larvae of the first instar. We may call this category “E/L-boundary lethals, ” indicating that the lethality crisis becomes manifest a t the boundary between the end of embryonic ( E ) and the beginning of larval ( L ) life. Whether one or the other stage can be reached may depend on different environmental factors such as breeding-temperature or moisture of the culture medium. Then, also, the genotypic milieu surrounding the lethal factor may play an important role. F o r instance, the author has found by testing the hatching rate of many different stocks all containing a Curly chromosome ( Z n (2L) Cy), that in some stocks the Cy homozygotes die before hatching, in others they die as larvae of the first instar, and in still others some of the individuals die within the chorion and the rest after hatching. Even in isozygotic stocks where all external conditions for all individuals are made as equal as possible, we may expect typical E/L-boundary lethals to show a certain amount of variability with regard to the stage at which death occurs. This phenomenon could be merely a consequence of the variability that is presumably inherent to any developing system. The existence of E/L-boundary cases does not interfere with the concept of phase-specificity of action (Hadorn, 1948a). There is hardly a significant difference of developmental progress between the E ’s and the L’s. A series of lethals which belong to the category under discussion are listed in Table 2. 3. Larval Lethals ( L ) Larval life begins after the hatching of the differentiated larva of the first instar and ends when the fully grown third-instar larva forms a puparium. I n Drosophila melanogaster this period lasts about 96 hours a t 25” C. A t 25 hours the first larval molt transforms the first instar into the second one, and at 48 hours the second molt marks the change from the second to the third instar.
ACTTON OF TiETHAL FACTORS IN DROSOPHTLA
61
A few mutants h a w been investigated (Table 2 ) which die in the first instar, apparently nnable to grow further and accomplish the first larval molt. Lethal factors that cause death in a phase-specific manner during the second instar are not known. I n some third-instar Iethals (Z(2)w~e, l ( 2 ) 7 ) abnormalities of growth ant1 differentiation have been observed. 4. L/Pr-Roiindary T~ethals
A t the beginning of metamorphosis the cuticle of the third-instar larva (L) becomes hardened and pigmented, forming A tough pupal case called the puparium. Aboiit four hours after the onset of this process, the first internal molt occiirs within the pupariuni. The epidermis separates from the old larval ciiticle and becomes snrroiindecl by the very thin prepiipal ciiticle. The prepupa ( P r ) itself is headless, withoiit any protruding extremities. F o u r hours later this prepnpa develops into a real pupa. The process of pupation is preceded by a second internal molt, in which the prepupal cuticle is shed and evagination of the imaginal discs of head and thorax takes place. It is characteristic of L/Pr-boundary lethals that their development comes to a standstill either immediately before or immediately after puparium formation. I n the latter case, puparia of more or less normal shape are formed, but within such " pseudopupae" no further development goes on. The l ( 2 ) y l mutant, for instance, never differentiates beyond the early prepnpal stage (I-Iadorn, 1937a, 1948a). Consequently, the difference between individuals dying in the L stage and those reaching the early Pr stage is by no means very great. We know that the formation of the puparium, which indicates the transition from L to Pr, is induced by the hormonal activity of the ring gland (Hadorn, 1937b). Individual variability in the quantity of hormone secreted, or variability in the sensitivity of the reacting systems, will decide whzther o r not the threshold from L to Pr is passed.
5. Yrepupal Lethals ( P r ) Almost no reliable facts are known about strictly phase-specific prepupal lethals. The Z(3)blo-1 mutant probably belongs to this category (Chen, 1929). Irregular growth and degeneration of the imaginal discs here prevent the formation of the pupa. The ensuing pattern of damage is in many respects similar tn that caused by the l ( 2 ) g L locns (Hatlorn, 1938, 1945).
62
ERNST HADORN
6 . Pupal Lethals ( P ) The only genotypes that should be considered pupal lethals are those that develop at least beyond the prepupal stage and die later a t any period between pupation and emergence of the adult fly. During this main period of metamorphosis, which takes about 34 days (at 25” C.), breakdown of the larval organs and tissues and differentiation of the imaginal structures have to take place. Two distinctly different types of anormogenesis can be distinguished. I n the first type we observe an inability of imaginal cell differentiation. It may affect, as in l ( 3)tr lethals, either the whole pupal body or only parts of it (Hadorn, 1949a). I n the second type a completely differehtiated imago develops, but is unable to hatch from the pupal case. This impotency may be due to gross morphological malformations (crc, E(3)hd) or merely to physiological “weakness” ( l ( 3 ) e Y ) .
7. P/I-Boundary Lethals The act of emergence of the imago ( I ) from the pupa ( P ) , as well as the E/L or the L/Pr change, may depend on highly variable quantitative factors, On the basis of such an interpretation we can easily understand the appearance of mutants among which some individuals succeed while others fail in overcoming the P/I threshold. Usually the emerged flies of such mutants, being weak and short-lived, are unable to reproduce.
8. Imaginal Lethals ( I ) I n spite of some hereditary malformations in imaginal differentiation, these mutants are capable of emergence; but their early imaginal life is interfered with. Such individuals are unable to feed ( p b ) , or move (me, 2(2)2gt), and consequently die before their reproductive activity sets in. 111. THE VALIDITY OF
THE
CONCEPT OF PHASE-SPECIFICITY
T o what extent lethal factors act in a phase-specific way has been discussed by the author in an earlier paper (Hadorn, 1948a). It was then concluded that interruption of development and death occur in most Drosophila lethals specifically at a definite stage. The data reviewed in the foregoing section corroborate such a statement. Many mutants that a t first do not seem to show the phase-specific mode of action can be classified as belonging to the distinct categories of E/L-, L/Pr-, or P/L-boundary lethals.
ACTION OR’ LETHAL FACTORS IN DROSOPHILA
63
Nevertheless, we have to consider whether there are known cases that contradict the principle of phase-specificity. Brody (1940) investigated six different second chromosomes of Drosophila melanogaster that contained lethal factors and found early as well as late embryonic lethality in each of the homozygotes. It is difficult, however, to see how egg mortality due to failure of fertilization might be separated in his investigations from genuine early embryonic lethality caused by the zygotic constitution. Besides, we have to consider that the manifestation of a lethal factor can be influrnced by the “genotypic milieu.’’ Hadorn (1940) , for instance, succeeded by means of continuous selection in separating from a 1(2)gZ/Cy stock two genotypes that differed considerably with respect to the time of death of the l ( 2 ) g l homozygotes. I n one line almost all lethals died in a late embryonic stage, whereas in the other only a few individuals failed to develop into full-grown thirdinstar larvae. This difference, due to chromosomal factors modifying the l g l reaction, is also subject to a maternal effect through the egg cytoplasm. With increasing homozygosity of the genotype bearing the lethal factor, a more accentuated phase-specificity of action would certainly result in many of those cases where apparently the time of death in different individuals is spread over a wide range of ontogenic stages. We shall discuss later further details of how the onset of the lethal crisis is influenced by additional genic and environmental factors. We must now consider some other facts that a t first sight do not seem to sustain the concept of phase-specificity. Thoroughly studied mutants like 1 ( 2 ) g l , 1(3)tr, and l(2)me are no doubt representative of the phase-specific type. Nevertheless, if one counts the lethal larvae and pupae in mixed cultures, where normal genotypes also develop, one finds the proportion of lethals usually short of the expected Mendelian frequency. Such deficits are due to the fact that the lethals, more sensitive than their normal culture-mates, have a higher embryonic and earlylarval mortality. Apparently lethal genotypes suffer a general weakness even before they reach their locus-specific phase of lethality. The development of any genotype is endangered by various unfavorable influences, to which lethal mutants succumb i n higher percentages than nonlethals. I n this respect, larval and pupal lethals do not differ from many “visible ” mutants that are characterized by reduced viability during ontogeny. I n both cases the developmental weakness is inseparably connected with the mutated constitution. Such early mortality, which prevents in a varying number of individuals the manifestation of the locus-specific pattern, conceals the phase-specificity of gene action. While this general mortality in early stages prevents various percentages of individuals from reaching the specific lethality phase, an-
64
ERN ST HADORN
other pheiionienon shows that development may go beyond the critical stage. It is typical of many nonlethal mutants of Drosophila that the characters specific to the mutated locus do not develop in all individuals. The penetrance of the gene is not strong enough to affect every member of its Mendelian class. Such mutants overlap the normal wild type. The same phenomenon may happen in the case of lethal factors; various numbers of individuals survive the period of phase-specific action and are able to develop further. Such "break-thronghs" (IIadorn, 1945, 1948a) may either become normal adults or die later during a second sensitive period. I n certain selection stocks of the l(2)gl mutant, whose first lethality phase is in the late embryonic stage, we find that those genotypes that break through this stage became lethal only during the L/Pr phase. I n the case of the Z(3)tr mutant we observe break-throughs from the early-pupal lethality phase, which develop to partially metamorphosed imagines (IIadorn, 1949a). Especially impressive is the fact that in rare instances even Curly homozygotes manage to break through the E/L lethality phase. Once having passed through this almost invincible danger, they differentiate into adults. Genotypes in which adult break-throughs appear regularly are called semilethals. This category of mutants is a common one, and it appears in every large sample of mutants from untreated populations or from any experiment with mutagenic agents. I n spite of this abundance of material we have a t present only a very meager insight into the developmental physiology of semilethal factors. W e know only that in many bemilethal stocks the relative frequency of lethal versus nonlethal individuals varies to a large extent as a function of environmental and genic modifiers. But in most cases it is not known at what developmental stage the lethal quota dies, o r whether a locus-specific pattern of damage can be found. Therefore future investigations are needed to show to what degree phase-specificity of action is manifested in semilethal mutants. One further dificulty presents itself in connection with problems of phase-specificity. I n spite of the fact that all cells and organs within a lethal genotype have the same genetic coastitution, they may react in entirely different ways. This has been shown especially for the Z(2)gl mutant (Hadorn, 1945, 1948a). Some systems, like the male germ cells (Gloor., 1943) and the imaginal discs (Hadorn, 1938), begin to degenerate during the early larval stages. The female germ cells, on the other hand, and most of the larval organs develop normally, whereas in the fat-body and the salivary glands there is a mere reduction of growth rate without cellular degeneration. Another example of such organspecific differences is provided by the Z(3)tr mutant (Hadorn, 1949).
ACTION OF LETHAL FACTORS IN DROSOPHILA
65
Partially metamorphosed individuals of this lethal genotype develop imaginal structures to a smaller or greater extent only in the head and thorax region, whereas the abdominal integument remains in the early pupal stage. Thus different organs and tissues of one single lethal genotype may have their own respective phase-specificities. Valuable information concerning the phase-specificity of gene action can therefore be gained only by studying the developmental fate of the different cell and organ systems separately. OF “PATTERNS OF IV. THE DEVELOPMENT
DAMAQE”
The total of all the characters in which a lethal mutant differs from the normal constitutes its locus-specific “pattern of damage’’ (Hadorn, 1945, 1948a). I n producing it the mutated locus usually acts in a rather complicated pleiotropic way. A few examples may show how such patterns develop. In the hemizygous lethals of the Notch series (Poulson, 1945), segregation within the blastema of the embryonic ectoderm proceeds abnormally. Too many cells become presumptive nervous tissue, a t the expense of the epidermis and its derivatives. At the same time, differentiation of the mesodermal and entodermal anlagen never begins. From the experimental work of Bock (cf. Seidel, Bock, Krause, 1940) on the nenropterous insect Chrysopa, we know that the pattern of segregation accomplished in the ectoderm acts as an organizing principle on which the blastema segregation of the mesodermal material depends. It is possible that in Drosophila too the ectodermal pattern plays an inducing role in the further organization of the embryo. The ensuing abnormalities in the Notch lethals might thus be the consequence of initial distortion within the ectodermal blastema. As to the cause of distorted segregation in the embryonic ectoderm we can only conjecture. I n developmental systems where one common blastema becomes separated into two or more areas, each of which later is separately differentiated, some balancing factors may control the segregation of competing fields. Patterns of damage of the Notch type might disclose genes normally engaged as regulators of such processes. Disturbance of segregation, however, is apparently not the sole damaging effect of the mutation concerned here. Apart from abnormal organogenesis, we observe that the cells are unable to differentiate. I t is true that in normal development these two processes seem to be inseparably related. I n the following section we shall discuss lethals in which one or the other of them is hampered.
66
ERNST HADORN
Gloor (1950) studied a dominant mutant “Kriippel” ( K r ) , which leads in heterozygotes to malformations in the thoracic region (Fig. 1). IIomozygous K r are embryonic lethals and manifest a very uniform pattern of damage. During normal development contraction of the embryo and segmentation of the body take place a t the age of 10 hours. I n K r lethals the primary segmentation is abnormal in many respects. The number of externally visible segments, normally 9, is reduced to 5.
FIQ.l b c FIQ.1. ( a ) K r / + heterozygous imago, showing typical abnormalities in the thoracic region. ( b ) The nervous system of a Lir/Kr homozygous lethal embryo at 15 hours (above), as compared to the normal condition (below). ( 0 ) E r / E r homozygous lethal embryo (above), showing defective segmentation and fragmentary tracheae, in contrast to normal control (below). ( a , Gloor, unpublished ; b and a, Gloor, 1949.)
ACTION O F LETHAL FACTORS IN DROSOPHILA
67
I n embryos aged 15 hours the middle sections of the ventral chain of ganglia are i n a state of disintegration, which later prevents the formation of a single subesophageal ganglion. The embryonic tracheae are represented by several fragments, which do not join closely into a continuous system. Malpighian tubules are apparently never formed. Although all these fundamental aberrations of organogenesis become manifest a t such an early stage (10 hours), histological and cellular differentiation astonishingly proceed farther. Twelve hours later the tissues have reached the same degree of structure as in normal animals ready to hatch from the egg membrane. K r lethals even show the vigorous muscular activity that normally precedes hatching ; but the defects in segmentation and abnormalities i n position and relative proportion of the organs are so severe that hatching never becomes possible. The K r mutant is a representative of those lethals that fail in the process of morphogenesis of the whole organ-anlagen, without interfering with the differentiation of histological and cellular structures. Moreover, the first abnormalities are visible long before the death-stage is reached. The development of the very complicated pattern of damage characteristic of the l ( 2 ) g l mutant has been discussed in earlier reviews (Hadorn, 1948a, 1950). It was shown that lethal effects appear in different cell-systems at quite diff’erent stages during ontogeny. By means of the transplantation technique it was further proved that the pattern of damage contains primary as well as secondary phenes (characters). The first are due to factors intrinsic to the cells involved; the second are caused by precedent abnormalities in the surrounding tissues, which have been primarily affected. As a contrast to the K r case just discussed, one fact deserves particular attention. I n embryos and larvae of the l ( 2 ) g l mutant, morphogenesis is normal as far as location and size of the primordia are concerned. Here it is histogenesis that fails. The anlagen of the imaginal discs are present in a larva, but their cells are unable to differentiate into imaginal structures. The same is true for the germinal cells within the testis. The existence of patterns of damage of either the Kr or the l ( 2 ) g l type seems t o prove that organogenesis and histogenesis may have independent gene-conditioned bases. Thus a “dissociability ” (Needham, 1942) of integrated developmental mechanisms becomes evident as a consequence of gene mutation.
v.
INFORMATION
GAINEDFROM TRANSPLANTATION EXPERIMENTS
A detailed investigation of lethal genotypes a t the stage of death usually shows that the different tissues and organs of the developing
68
ERNST HADORN
organism react very diflerently to the mutated constitution. It has already been pointed out that besides abnormal and degenerate parts one may encounter cell-systems that appear completely healthy. What are the developmental potencies of these seemingly undamaged parts 7 Reliable information may be gained by isolating such parts from their decaying surroundings in time, and then testing their autonomous potencies in witro in a suitable medium. I n spite of numerous attempts, no sufficiently successful method for insect tissue culture has been worked out so far. Thus one has to resort to cultures in vivo. The primordia are transplanted into genetically normal hosts and their further development is observed. Such experiments have been made by the author and his collaborators with many different parts of the 1(2)91, 1(3)tr, and l(2)me mutants. The results, which were reviewed recently (Hadorn, 1950), are of three types : a. The transplant does not develop beyond the stage it would have reached as part of the lethal individual. Primordia belonging t o this category are : the main imaginal discs of l ( 2 ) g l (Hadorn, 1948a), the male germ cells (Gloor, 1943), and the anlage of the adult salivary gland of the same mutant (Grob, 1946). b. The transplant distinctly passes beyond the stage characteristic of the lethal as a whole, but, after a period of progressive development during which the transplant keeps pace with the host, the lethal crisis sets in. Transplanted ovaries of l ( 2 ) g l and l(2)me behave in this way (Hadorn, 1937a ; Gloor, 1943 ; Schmid, 1949). c. The transplant develops normally and produces within the host all the expected imaginal structures. Examples are : the primordium of the imaginal ring gland (Vogt, 1947) and somatic cells of the gonads (Gloor, 1943) of Z(2)gl; imaginal discs, salivary glands, and gonads of l(3)tr (Hadorn, 1948a; Sobels, 1950) ; and imaginal discs and testes of Z(2)me (Schmid, 1949). Medvedev (1938) transplanted imaginal discs of eyes, wings, and legs from a mutant whose lethality phase is in the late pupal stage. Development of the respective parts was found to be normal. Cullen (1948) studied a lethal deficiency, B26s-20,which does not develop beyond the first instar and shows no growth whatsoever. Tissues transplanted into normal larvae and into abdomens of adult males showed essentially normal development. I n this case it was conclusively shown that the lack of growth was due to a failure of the ring gland. How are we to explain the three divergent types of transplantation behavior P Some possible interpretations are discussed below. a. Of the first-described transplants it may be supposed that they behave autonomously. They suffer from a “direct pleiotropic effect”
ACTION OF IiETHAL FACTORS I N DROSOPHILA
69
of the mutation (Hadorn, 1945). The developmental failure is irreparable, and the ensuing damage is due to intrinsic cell factors. We have to consider a n alternative interpretation, however. Since exchange of transplants between embryos is technically impossible, the experiment must be made in the larval stage. It can therefore be argued t h a t liberation from the lethal surroundings comes too late, and that systems which are not primarily affected could already have suffered from extrinsic influences before being transferred to the normal milieu. I n most cases it is impossible to refute such a n objection, yet there are a few natural “ implantation experiments” that disprove it directly. Through somatic crossing over or as a consequence of nondisjnnction i n mitotic divisions, single cells may arise that are homozygous or hemizygous with respect to a lethal factor. The lethal systems are surrounded by genetically normal tissues from the very beginning of their existence. By w i n g marked chromosomes Ephrussi (1934), Demerec (1934), and Stern (1935) succeeded in proving that different lethal factors caused inviability even in single cells that were embedded in a normal blastema. Such intrinsic cell-lethality exists, for example, in epidermal mosaics having the Notch constitution. The developmental defect observed by Poulson within the embryonic ectoderm of Notch males is therefore to be interpreted as a primary phene, conditioned directly by intrinsic cell factors. I n order to test the possible effect on intrinsically nonaffected primordia of remaining too long within the lethal organism, Oloor (1943) implanted normal testes into l ( 2 ) g l larvae, exposing them for a period of 24 hours to the lethal surroundings. These testes, after having been reimplanted into normal hosts, developed normally in every respect. 6. Transplants behaving in the second way clearly demonstrate the fact, already discussed, that every one of the different cell systems of a lethal genotype has its own phase-specificity. I n l ( 2 ) g l the imaginal discs a n d the spermatogonia degenerate during larval life, t h a t is, before the prepupal death of the whole organism. Transplanted ovaries, on the other hand, become affected only a t the beginning of imaginal life, after a prosperous period that allows them to develop f a r beyond the prepupal stage. From the fact that they nevertheless do not escape final destruction, we have to conclude that their ultimate failure is conditioned by intrinsic factors. c. The successful development to normality of some transplants from lethal organisms may be attributed to two basically different mechanisms. ( g ) The cell system in question may lie completely outside the pleiotropic pattern of damage. I n this case the difference between the normal
70
ERNST HADORN
and mutated loci is irrelevant to its developmental physiology. It is self-evident that transplants of this category differentiate normally. It is true that their development is promoted by the hosts, which furnish them with nutritious material and hormones. Nevertheless, genetically, the differentiation of the transplanted cells is to be regarded as autonomous. They receive from the host only those substances on which the development of any primordium is dependent regardless of its genetic constitution. Aid from the host is therefore not locus-specific. It by no means supplies items in which the lethal cells are deficient on account of their mutated locus. Any developmental process within a normal system may be regarded as a chain-reaction, dependent on intrinsic as well as extrinsic links (Hadorn, 1950). As long as the host furnishes only extrinsic links, it is not admissible to postulate that lethality has been overcome by specific factors. (2) The transplanted cells may belong to those parts of the organism that are primarily affected by the lethal constitution. I n this case they can develop normally only provided the host can help them in a locus-specific way. I n other words, the host has to supply in the transplant an equivalent of the function of the mutated locus. The developiiient of the transplant toward normality is therefore nonautonomous. A n “intrinsic link” has to be replaced from outside, in order to render possible developmental performances that are no longer characteristic of the genetical constitution of the cells involved, Numerous experiments, however, based on material gathered from visible mutants, have shown that the great majority of Drosophila transplants develop autonomously in hosts of different genetic constitutions. I n view of these observations, a vitalization of lethal transplants through locus-specific action on the part of normal hosts seems rather improbable. It is difficult, if not impossible, to decide whether the normal development of a given lethal transplant is due to a mechanism of type (1) or type (2). As we have shown (Hadorn, 1950) that most of the transplants that develop normally do not seem t o be intrinsically affected, one therefore need not postulate a host-engendered “ l g l + or lme+ substance” in order to explain their normal differentiation. The sole case in which an intrinsic lethality may have been overcome through genuine locusspecific action from outside was reported by Neuhaus (1941). By Xraying he obtained two mutants of the cinnabar locus ( c n ) which behaved as recessive lethals. If the homozygotes were fed during early larval stages with extracts from cn+ larvae and pupae, a few of them developed normally. This remarkable and exceptional result can be explained, however, on the basis of the following facts. According to the experiments of Ephrussi and Beadle (1937), the
ACTION O F LETHAL FACTORS IN DROSOPHILA
71
eye discs of nonlethal c n mutants show nonautonomous development as transplants within a host providing cn+ substance (oxykynurenin), which they are unable to synthesize themselves. The same effect results from feeding this substance (Beadle, Tatum, and Clancy, 1938). The lethal mutants studied by Neuhaus might be interpreted as especially strong alleles of the c n ’locus, causing not only defects in pigment synthesis but also additional disturbances in fundamental metabolism. Though the extent of the pattern of damage would be increased, it would still be curable. Such nonautonomous behavior of a lethal constitution must be considered an exceptional case, however. It might be just as rare among the total of lethal mutants as visible mutants of the cn type are rare among the total of nonlethals.
VI. PmsIoLoaIcAL PROPERTIES OF LETHALS The pleiotropic pattern of damage of a lethal factor usually includes not only morphological but physiological phenes as well. Certain characteristics of respiration, osmotic regulation, nutrition metabolism, and endocrinology may deviate from the norm. I n most cases we do not know whether a particular abnormality should be interpreted as a direct cause of lethal development or only as a secondary effect of a more fundamental disturbance. It is nevertheless valuable to know the physiological phenes and to “collect” them as fragments that mill later become integrated in a general theory of physiological genetics. Boell and Poulson (1939) measured the oxygen consumption of lethal male embryos of the Nullo-X type. They found a reduced respiration rate, which became manifest as soon as the developmental abnormalities already described were visible. Furthermore, they discovered the remarkable fact that embryonic cell division still proceeded, although the oxygen uptake was reduced to 20% of the normal amount. My collaborator, P. S . Chen (unpublished) has made extensive comparative respiration measurements on the three mutants 1 ( 2 ) g l , 1(2)*me,and 1(3)tr, in an attempt to determine the developmental pattern of this physiological trait. Only a few of the results may be reviewed here. Figure 2 shows the changes in oxygen consumption during larval development. I n this period body size increases and consequently there is a rise in oxygen uptake per individual. If the values are computed per unit dry weight, however, a rapid decrease characterizes the normal pattern. This fact does not necessarily mean that older larvae are less active than younger ones. It can be assumed, however, that the closer development approaches to the end of larval life, the greater must be the relative amount of more o r less inactive materials, and that re-
72
ERNST IIADORN
serve substances and cuticular structures may be responsible for the observed decline. The l(3)tr homozygotes form puparia with a delay of one day (Hadorn, 1949a). The physiological age of the larva 120 hours after oviposition corresponds to that of normal controls a t 96 hours, The translucida curve of Fig. 2 should be shifted correspondingly to the left. But even after such a correction the oxygen consumption of this lethal appears significantly higher than that of normal larvae. This may be
t
anL 7”
-
30 25 20 35 15 1 .0 5-
--
a
L. a
1
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
l?m 2. Changes in rates of oxygen coiisuiiiptioii for controls and lethals during larval development. Ordinate: rate of oxygen consumption in cubic millimeters per milligram dry weight per hour. Abscissa : larval age = Ztr/Ztr in hours after oviposition. 0 = controls ; lethals; A = lg3/1gl lethals; A = t m e / h e lethnls. (P.S. Chen, unpublished.)
due to a lower proportion of inactive parts (fat body) to total dry weight. On the other hand, there is ample evidence that in both the l ( 2 ) g l and E(2)me mutants the respiration rate of larval tissues is distinctly below normal. It falls gradually to zero in the “meander lethal” but remains constant at a low rate in “lethal giant larvae.” This difference becomes manifest in the period during which the lethals survive as overaged larvae. Correspondingly, l(2)me larvae never pupate, and die early; whereas most of the surviving Z(2)gl larvae finally form a puparium, sometimes even after a delay of one week. A high respiration
ACTION O F L E T H A L FACTORS IN DROSOPHILA
73
rate is apparently not an indispensable condition f o r puparium formation. Figure 3 (P. S. Chen, unpublished) indicates, first, that the respiration rate of the lethal mutants is distinctly reduced a t the moment of puparium formation. It also reveals four other interesting facts : ( a ) The lethal mutants resemble the controls in that their oxygen consumpt,ion drops sharply during the first day, but they differ from the normal by failing to show the upward swing represented by the second part of
FIG.3. Changes in rates of oxygen consumption f o r controls and lethals during pupal development. Ordinate : rate of oxygen consumption in cubic millimeters per milligram dry weight per hour. Abscism: pupal age in hours a f t e r puparium formation. 0= controls; 0 = partially = nonmetamorphosed ltr/ metamorphosed Ztr/Ztr lethals ; Ztr lethals; A = ZgZ/Z.qZ lethalu. (P. S. Chen, uiipuhlished.)
the IJ-shaped curve. ( b ) Although all progressive development comes to an end in the lethals, they survive for an almost unlimited period, during which respiration continues a t low rates. ( c ) During this period of survival, metabolic activity is highest in the l(3)tr pupae, which are partially metamorphosed in the head and thorax; lower in the nonmetamorphosed translucida individuals ; and lowest in the I ( 2 ) g l pseudopupae. ( d ) Although in the partially metamorphosed l(3)tr group about half the body cells differentiate into imaginal structures, there is no rise in oxygen consumption, corresponding to the ascending second
74
ERNST HADORN
part of the normal curve. It therefore seems doubtful to what extent the differentiation process influences the course of a respiration curve. Since Drosophila larvae live in fermenting fruits, they must be considered aquatic animals that have to solve the problem of osmotic regulation. Gloor discovered (1949b) an “anal organ” that is possibly concerned with an exchange of ions between the body fluid and the milieu (Gloor and Chen, 1950). The function of this organ might be one reason that in Z(3)tr the hemolymph accumulates excessively. Gloor and Chen (unpublished) determined the chloride concentration in the body fluid of l(3)tr and l ( 2 ) g l larvae, and found the value to be about 0.11% in both lethals. This amounts to less than half that in wild-type larvae, where an average chloride concentration of 0.24% has been determined. Although no further conclusion should be drawn from such preliminary results, we see new possibilities for penetrating deeper into the physiological properties of lethal mutants. That abnormal osmo-regulative characters might be a part of the pattern of damage was indicated by the work of Kaliss (1939) on Df 260-2. The cuticle of the lethals shows an exceptionally high permeability f o r water. Therefore dechorionated animals are unable to escape dehydration in a hypertonic solution. On the basis of a theory developed by Sikes and Wigglesworth (1930), it seems probable that abnormal osmotic properties of the tracheal wall prevent replacement of the initial water content by air, a process that fails almost completely in these lethals. Very informative observations concerning metabolic properties have been made by Schmid (1949) on the Z(2)me mutant. I n this case, as will be pointed out later, the locus-specific pattern of damage can be reproduced as a phenocopy by means of timed starvation, since inability to use the available food material seems to play a decisive role in the nutritional physiology of this lethal. Schmid starved normal as well as lethal larvae a t the age of two days and observed a characteristic reduction of the f a t body, which, formerly of a milky appearance, became depleted and transparent. Later these larvae were fed with either pure albumen, sugar, or fat. Normal genotypes showed the ability to rebuild a normal fat body with any one of these nutritivc materials. The l(2)me larvae, however, although they could utilize either sugar or fat, were completely unable to resynthesize the building material of the fa t body when fed nothing but albumen. An essential part of the protein metabolism must be regarded as being fundamentally affected by the lethal constitution. There is also some preliminary evidence of abnormal protein metabolism in the Z(3)tr mutant. Gloor (1949a) found, for instance, that the
ACTION OF LETHAL FACTORS IN DROSOPHILA
75
percentage of globulin in the total protein content of the hemolymph in lethal larvae was strikingly low. A lethality due to starvation has been found in l ( l ) 7 larvae. Russell (1940) showed that in this genotype the midgut cells become abnormal a t the beginning of the third instar. By completely blocking the intestinal lumen, the affected cells prevent further uptake of food material. Thus in this mutant a localized morphological abnormality causes starvation, whereas in the l(2)me larvae a physiological block interrupts more directly the internal nutritional metabolism. According to Beadle, Tatum, and Clancy (1938), feeding up to a larval age of 70 hours is necessary f o r continued development and metamorphosis. Since in both the l(2)me and the l ( l ) 7 mutant starvation begins before this point, a failure of metamorphosis must ensue. Another factor on which the course of metamorphosis depends is the timed action of hormones. If one finds mutants that fail in metamorphic process, the question arises whether a n endocrine dysfunction may be involved. Such considerations led to the discovery of the ring gland, which functions as the center of hormone production in Diptera (Hadorn, 193713). Larvae homozygous for the l(2)gl gene either form the puparium with great delay o r do not form it at all. Scharrer and Hadorn (1938) found a corresponding retardation in the development of the ring gland. Implantation of normal glands induces pupariurn formation regularly and at the proper time in l(2)gl hosts. Thus the reacting system is not itself affected by the lethal constitution, and would develop normally provided the hormone were available; it suffers only secondarily. On the other hand, it would be erroneous to consider the failure of hormone synthesis as a primary effect of the mutated locus. The imaginal discs, for instance, have already degenerated before the ring-gland hormone is due to come into action. The damage to the ring gland appears rather to be secondarily conditioned ( Hadorn, 1948b). Nevertheless, insight into the hormone physiology of the l(2)gl genotype has been fruitful in many respects. Larvae of the l(2)me genotype never form a puparium. Schmid (1949) found that implantation of normal ring glands was ineffective in l(2)me hosts. Here, in contrast to l(2)gl the larval integument is apparently unable to react successfully to the hormone. Still another type of metamorphic disorder is manifested in the l(3)tr mutant. Whereas puparium formation and pupation proceed normally, imaginal differentiation either fails completely o r succeeds only in the head and thorax. F. H. Sobels (unpublished), keeping l ( 3 ) t r pupae in a medium of pure oxygen, found that there was a much higher percentage of metamorphosing individuals, and also that imag-
76
ERNST HADORN
inal differentiation became possible in the abdomen. It seems as though some threshold reactions are affected in this genotype. Many more such fragmentary observations are needed before the gene-conditioned basis of metamorphosis can be understood. As to enzymatic activities in lethals, only one case has been investigated so far. Poulson and Boell (1946a,b) measured cholinesterase activity in several of the Notch-deficient embryos (see Table 1). They found the activity to be 2-3 times that present in normals a t the time of hatching. This increased activity is correlated with the hypertrophy of the nervous system of the deficient genotype.
VIT.
PIIENOCOPIES OF PATTERNS OF DAMAGE
The development of a normal genotype can be interrupted by various kinds of unfavorable environmental agents. We are here interested only in cases involving a distinct pattern of damage, more or less identical with a locus-specific pattern caused by a lethal factor. I n these, an external induence induces a “phenocopy l 1 of a known gene-conditioned abnormality. From the nature of the effective agent and the sensitive period at which it has to be administered, certain conclusions may be drawn with respect to the type and time of action of the mutative locus in question. Gloor (1944, 1945) succeeded in reproducing the pattern of damage characteristic of the mutant cryptocephal ( c r c ), by treating normal genotypes of known age either with heat (40’ C.) or with low temperature (-3’ C.). The sensitive period begins 6 hours after puparium formation and ends 5 hours later, that is, immediately before the imaginal anlagen of the head become evaginated by the process of pupation in normal development. I n the crc mutant and in the phenocopies, eversion of the head fails. Consequently the head capsule remains enclosed within the thorax. The crc pattern of damage is not restricted to this character, however. I n addition, the legs, wings, and bristles of crc individuals are reduced in size, whereas the abdomen is much longer than in normal pupae. All these phenes, which appear regularly in the pleiotropic crc pattern of damage, occur also in the phenocopied individuals. We may conclude from these results that the primary crc reaction must be of a rather simple nature, so that it can be easily induced by unspecific external agents in normal genotypes. Moreover, since the abnormal temperatures must be applied within a restricted sensitive period, this period ought to indicate the time in crc animals during which the lethal constitution causes its locus-specific pattern of damage.
ACTION OF LETHAL FACTORS IN DROSOPHILA
77
Another phenocopy of a lethal pattern of damage is that of the l(2)wt.e mutant, produced by Schmid (1949). A distorted larval growth pattern is characteristic of this genotype. Although the third instar is regularly reached, we find only a few organs, such as the pharyngeal apparatus, growing to full larval size. Most of the other parts show restriction in growth, which is clearly of an organ-specific degree. The subesophageal ganglion and the stomach reach about 80% of their normal size. More strongly affected are the tracheae (70%), the hemispheres of the brain (60% ) , and body length (55 % ) . The most extreme growth restriction is found in the salivary glands, which remain very small (30% of normal). A very close phenocopy of this pattern can be induced in nonmutated genotypes by starving normal larvae that have been kept under standard food conditions u p to an age of 48 to 60 hours (after oviposition). During the starvation period they develop a n organ-specific growth patt,ern that corresponds exactly to that of a “well-fed’’ Z(2)me mutant. It follows that the Z(2)me constitution causes a state of inanition during the second half of larval life. As was shown earlier, there is good reason to assume a fundamental disturbance of the protein metabolism. Theoretically, it should be possible to produce phenocopies of any gene-conditioned pattern of damage. Genes or gene products are regarded as specific catalysts of biochemical reactions. Hence substances that act as enzyme poisons may be potent phenocopying agents. Rapoport (1947) reported, for instance, that he produced lethal effects with strong concentrations of enzyme poisons such as sodium borate (1:600),and that in weaker concentration (1:750) the same substance caused phenocopies of visible loci. He pointed out that many cases are known of allelic series in which the weaker alleles cause visible effects whereas the stronger ones act as lethals. Since no detailed developmental studies have been made on the lethal phenocopies produced by Rapoport, it is inopportune to discuss the theory postulated by him. VIII.
CONDITIONED LETHALS
I n “conditioned lethals” (Hadorn, 1949b) the penetrance of lethality is dependent on additional genic or environmental factors. Dobzhansky (1946) reared a genotype of Drosophila pseudoobscura at different temperatures. Its viability was almost normal a t 16.5” C., whereas a t 21’ C. it behaved as a semilet.ha1 and at 25.5’ C. as a full lethal. The viable mutant “engrailed” of Drosophlila hydei (Spencer, 1942) show8 a manifold pattern of manifestation in differeut body re-
78
ERNST HADORN
gions. If the animals are raised a t a high temperature (30” C.) they die as pupal lethals. Direct proof that the degree of developmental abnormality caused by a lethal gene can be modified by different factors has been shown with the cryptocephal mutant (Hadorn and Gloor, 1943). By means of selection different crc stocks, which differed widely in penetrance and expressivity of the crc effect, were established. I n “strong” stocks almost all individuals died within the puparia as cryptocephalic imagines, the head remaining hidden in the thorax. Only a few animals showed a more or less everted head, and emerging “break-throughs” were still more rare. In “weak” stocks, on the other hand, a high percentage of homozygous crc flies developed normally into vigorous and fertile adults. Thus the genotypic milieu, whose constitution became altered by selection, changed the degree of lethality or even checked it completely. Gloor (1945) showed, furthermore, that the percentage of normally developing crc homozygotes varied greatly as a function of breeding temperature, inasmuch as lethality was increased by high temperature. There is a special type of conditioned lethality in which the degree of damage is influenced by sex. Gloor for instance found a much higher percentage of crc break-throughs in males than in females. A few cases are known in which lethality is strictly limited to one sex. Mohr and Sturtevant (1919) described a recessive autosomal gene i n Drosophila funebris that causes pupal lethality in females, whose abdomens become severely malformed. The homozygous males are scarcely or not at all changed, and develop into viable imagines. Another kind of sex-limited lethality was reported by Redfield (1926). Here, too, only the females succumb to the lethal effect. It seems as if the differences in tempo and mode of development that exist between the two sexes may influence the conditions under which lethal factors become manifest.
IX. LETHALITY DUE TO COMBINED GENICACTION Most of the lethals known in Drosophila, and all those so f a r discussed in the present review, are based on just one mutated or lost chromosomal region. I n crosses they therefore obey the laws of monofactorial segregation. Even if the penetrance of such lethals happens to be modified by additional genic loci, there is always one “main gene” responsible for the developmental disaster. We now have to consider genotypes in which lethality is caused by the combined action of two or more mutated loci. At least two of these are essential for the lethal effect ; one factor alone proves to be harmless.
79
ACTION OF LETHAL FACTORS IN DROSOPHILA
Clemente (1939) reported that double homozygotes ( p r l p r ey/ey ) for the two genes, purple (pr, 2-54.5) and eyeless (ey, 4-0.2) are invariably lethal, The single homozygotes ( p r / p r +/ey or pr/pr and pr/+ ey/ey or ey/ey) are viable and show either one or the other of the phenes characteristic of these well-known mutants. This interesting case deserves thorough study. The Minutes are dominant factors that arise through mutations a t many different loci in all the four chromosomes of Drosophila melanogaster. I n heterozygotes they produce very similar or even identical smallbristle effects. The hemizygous or homozygous individuals behave as E/L lethals. Schultz (1929) combined different Minutes and constructed in this way genotypes of the general constitution: M l / Me/ or M e / M,/ +, . etc. I n none of such hybrids was an exaggeration of the Minute characters or a lethality obtained. If one compares different doses of the same M gene in diploids and triploids, however, the following statements can be made :“ M l / + = viable Minute, M l / M l = lethal; Ml/+/+ = viable but not Minute, M l / M l / + = lethal. These and other experimental results led Schultz to the conclusion that the primary reaction of Minutes from different loci (All, M,,. * . M n ) must be qualitatively different and therefore not additive. By combining different Minutes with some alleles of either one of the dominant factors Delta (DZ, 3-66.2) or Jammed ( J , 2-41.0), one gets a series of late pupal lethals of the constitution M l / + D l / + or M , / + DZ/+,etc. The lethal effect would therefore be due to a n unfavorable combination of the Delta (or Jammed) action, with a secondary Minute reaction, which is considered as differing only in degree among different Minutes. Bauer (1943) found a new allele of the facet locus (facet notchoid, fano),which did not impair viability and in homozygous or hemizygous doses caused a typical Notch effect in the wings. I n combination with three different Notches (two of them deficiencies, the other a “point mutation”), genotypes of the supposed constitution fan0/+ N/+ were produced. They behaved as larval lethals. We can explain this combined effect by assuming that there exists in the facet region of wild flies a duplication. Two loci, fa+ and spZ+ (split), would be present, During evolution these loci, originally identical, became gradually different in some respects but retained other functions that might still be common to both. The Notch phenomenon would arise if any two of the four loci in females or either of the two loci in males were lost or inactivated. The graphic symbols of Table 3 are based on this interpretation. They show that the lethality mentioned above is effected in females when only one normal locus is present. Thus the lethal development in
+/+
+/+
+
..
+
+,
80
ERNST HADORN
TABLE 3 Interaction of Facet-Notchoid (fano)and Notch ( N ) in Producing Lethality, According to the Interpretation of Bauer (1943)
= normal locus;
-0-
-.
--
= deficient
or inactivated loc,us
-
Chromosomal constitution
Genic constitution
Phenotype
ra*/fa+
Viable wild type
fa+/rano
Viable, occasionally wit,h slight Notch effects
fa+/N
Viable Notah type
f ano/jano
Viable Notch type
-. .....-
f ano/N
Lethal in larval stage
-0.-
ra+
Viable wild type
fane
Viable Notch type
N
Lethal in embryonic stage
s! .-0 .a-.a..__
-0.-
-.......-
-0.. -0.. -0..
6
-0..
-......-
...-
.-
the combination fa.0 with N results from a system of overlapping deletions (or overlapping inert regions), and consequently is not a genuine combined effect of independent loci. This shows how cautiously one has to interpret presumable cases of multifactorial lethality. A very interesting type of combined lethals was found by Dobxhansky (1946). Through crossing over between chromosomes that were normally viable in homozygotes he obtained “synthetic” lethal chromosomes. It is probable that here the inviability resulted from unfavorable recombination of multigenic chromosomal blocks.
X. EFFECTS OF LETHALS IN HETEROZYGOTES How do recessive lethal factors act in heteroxygot,eR? A t first sight,, two sharply different types seem dist,inguishable.
81
ACTION OF LETHAL FACTORS IN DROSOPHILA
1. Recessive Lethals That Produce N o Visible Efects in Simgle Doses Many factors belonging to this category have been discussed in this review (Tables 1 and 2, all mutants with lower-case initials). Although in such cases the heterozygotes appear completely normal, their viability may be affected by the lethal locus. Stern and Novitski (1948) tested numerous X chromosomes containing different recessive lethal factors (Z1, lla;..Zn). They found that on the average the viability of heterozygotes ll/Muller - 5, Z,/Muller - 5, * * .l,/Muller -5 was reduced if they were cultured in competition with +,/Muller -5, +,/Muller - 5, * +,/ Muller -5, respectively (the Muller -5 chromosome contains only the nonlethal marker genes scB1 B Ins Wa sc8). Earlier investigations by Dobzhansky (1939) and Dubinin (l946), however, showed no reduction of viability in heterozygous carriers of recessive lethals from wild populations. According to Dubinin’s discussion (1946),no statement of general validity seems possible a t present, Even in those cases where recessive lethals influence viability, any kind of insight into the developmental physiology of the heterozygous genotypes is lacking. I n addition to investigations on large series of different lethals, which serve the purposes of population genetics, detailed studies of individual cases are urgently needed. Only if the viability characters with respect to various environmental conditions are known, and only after accurate control of the genotypic milieu has been established, will a fruitful discussion be possible of the very intricate problems involved. It is essential to test even such factors as the age of the mother. Hadorn and Zeller (1943)found that young females which were heterozygous for the two lethals l(2)gL and Cy produced eggs a t a n exceedingly high rate. But during the second week of imaginal life fecundity and embryonic viability decreased to a very low level. Compared with normal genotypes, the l g l / C y heterozygotes would appear first as “superviable,” later as subviable.
-
2. Recessive A e t h d s urlth Dmirtamt Visible Effects in Eletercrzggotes
In Drosophila nielanogasler there are over one hundred different known mutants that behave as dominants and produce in heterozygotes various visible effects. About 70% of them act as lethal factors when homozygous or hemizygous. The student of developmental physiology is interested primarily in finding out whether there is any relation between the pattern of damage in the lethal homozygotes and the pattern of manifestation in the viable heterozygotes. The work of Brehme (1938, 1941) has enabled us to compare the development of homozygous with heterozygous Minutes. The former
82
ERNST HADORN
die as E/L lethals or L lethals of the first, instar. They are not able to grow as larvae. I n heterozygous Minutes the rate of larval growth is distinctly reduced and the time of development correspondingly prolonged. The fact that in both genotypes the process of larval growth is affected may take on significance as soon as more is known about the Minute reactions. Whereas in the Minutes comparable characters of a physiological nature have been observed in homozygous and heterozygous individuals, Qloor (1950) found in the Kriippel mutant, a certain correspondence in the gross anatomy, as shown in Fig. 1. I n K r / K r individuals the middle segments are particularly abnormal. It is remarkable that in the fully developed Kr/+ heterozygotes there occur various kinds of abnormalities that are restricted to the thorax, while the head and abdomen are normal. I n other words, the main region of manifestation of the mutated constitution seems common to both genotypes. Unfortunately, no further data on the mutational pattern in either affected homozygotes or heterozygotes are available. One should know, for instance, whether or not dominant mutations that in heterozygotes change the morphology of the wings cause a special type of embryonic or larval lethality under homozygous conditions. Would the pattern of lethality of “wing loci” differ from that of “eye-color 1oci”P
XI. CONCLUSIONS It follows from all the facts reviewed here that many approaches to a developmental physiology of lethal genotypes have been worked out.
Although our knowledge is still very fragmentary, it forms a sufficient basis for the design of future studies. Hereafter our efforts should be concentrated on the following items. 1. A complete inventory of characters that are included in the pleiotropic pattern of damage at the climax of the lethal crisis. Morphological as well as physiological phenes will be found. I n addition, cell- and organ-specificity of action may often be ascertained. 2. Investigation of the developmental history of the pattern of damage. The deviations from normality should be followed from their beginnings, 3. Analysis of pattern of damage by means of transplantation experiments. This method will enable us to distinguish between primarily and secondarily conditioned phenes. 4. Attempts to produce in normal genotypes phenocopies that imitate the locus-specific patterns of lethal mutants. If this succeeds, then
ACTION OF LETHAL FACTORS IN DROSOPHILA
83
some conclusions will be possible with regard to the special nature and time of action characteristic of the corresponding lethal mutants. 5 . Tests of the penetrance and expressivity of lethal effects in relation t o the following factors : genotypic milieu, sex, temperature, nutritional conditions, and other environmental influences. 6. Determination of the nature of the primary gene effect. According to the concepts of modern gene physiology one must expect distinct biochemical abnormalities to arise after a mutational change a t a vital locus. I n none of the lethal factors of Drosophila is the specific “inborn metabolic error” exactly known a t present. 7. Comparison and integration of results obtained with many different lethal genotypes. Only after this is done will we understand development as a sequence of processes, each of which depends on the action of numerous gene loci.
XII. REFERENCES Bauer, H., 1943, 2. indukt. Abstamm.- u. VererbLehre 81, 374-390. Beadle, G. W., and Law, L. W., 1938, Proc. SOC.e x p . Bwl., N . Y. 37, 621-623. Beadle, G. W., Tatum, E. L., and Clancy, C. W., 1938, Biol. Bull. Wood’s Hole 76, 447-462. Boell, E. J., and Poulson, D. F., 1939, Anat. Rec. 76, 65-66. Brehme, I(. S., 1937, Amer. Nat. 71, 567-574. 1938, Genetics 23, 142. 1939, Genetics 24, 131-161. 1941, J . e x p . 2001.88, 135-160. Brody, G., 1940, Genetics 26, 645-650. Bridges, C. B., 1937, Cytologia, Pujii Jubil. Vol. 2, 745-755. Bridges, C. B., and Brehme, K. S., 1944, The Mutants of Drosophila melanogaster. Carneg. Inst. Publ. 566. Washington, D. C. 257 pp. Bridges, C. B., and Dobzhansky, Th., 1933, Arch. EntwMech. Org. 127, 575-590. Chen, T. Y.,1929, J . Morph. 47, 135-199. Clemente, L. S., 1936, Philipp. J . Sci. 69, 177-187. Cullen, Sister M. U., 1947, Anat. Rec. 99, 590-591. Demerec, M., 1934, Amer. Nat. 68, 165. 1941, Proc. 7 t h int. Congr. Genet. 99-103. 1950, Biology of Drosophila. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New Pork. 632 pp. Demerec, M., and Fano, U., 1944, Geneties 29, 348-360. Demerec, M., and Hoover, M. E., 1936, J . Hered. 27, 206-212. Dobzhansky, Th., 1930, Biol. Z b l . 60, 671-685. 1939, Biol. Rev. 14, 339-368. 1946, Genetics 31, 269-290. Dobzhansky, Th., aiid Spassky, B., 1944, Genetics 29, 270-290. Dubinin, N. P., 1946, Genetics 31, 21-38. Ephrussi, B., 1934, Proc. nat. Acad. Sci., Wash. 20, 420-422. Ephrussi, B., and Beadle, G. W., 1937, Bull. biol. 71, 54-74. Qloor, H., 1943, Rev. szrisse 2001.60, 339-394.
84
ERNST HADORN
1944, Rev. subse 2001.61, 394-402. 1945, Arch. Klaus-Stift. Vererb-Forsrh. 20, 209-256. 1949a, Rev. suisse Zool. 66, 281-285. 1949b, D.Z.S. 23, 89. 1950, Arch. Klawr-Stift. Vererb-Forsch. 26, 38-44. Gloor, H., and Chen, P. S., 1950, Rev. suisse Zool. 67, 570-576. Gowen, J. W.,1934, Arch. Path. 17, 638-647. Grob, H., 1946, Arch. Rlaw-Stilt. Vererb-Borsch. 21, 342-346. Hadorn, E., 1937a, Proc. SOC.exp. B i d . N. P.36, 632-634. 1937b, Proc. rmt. Acad. Sci., Wash. 23, 478-484. 1938, Rev. m k s e Zool. 46, 425-429. 1940, Rev. sztisse Zool. 47, 167-176. 1945, Aroh. Klaus-Stift. Vererb-Forscli. Xrg6nfzzrng8bnnd zu Band 20, 82-95. 1948a, 8ymp. SOC.exp. BWl., Growth 11, 177-195. 1948b, Bolia Biotheoretica 3, 109-126. 1949a, Rev. m k s e 2001.66, 271-280. 194913, Arch. Klaus-Stift. Vererb-Forsch. 24, 105-113. 1950, Rev. suisse ZooZ. 67, 115-128. Hadorn, E., and Gloor, H., 1942, Rev. suisse 2001.49, 228-236. 1943, Rev. sukse 2001.60, 256-261. Hadorn, E., and Schmid, W., 1947, D.I.S. 21, 68. Hadorn, E., and Zeller, H., 1942, Arch. Klaus-Stift. Vererb-Fcrsch. 17, 440-444. 1943, Arch. EntwiKech. Org. 142, 276-300. Ives, P. T., 1942, D.I.S. 16, 48. Kaliss, N., 1939, Genetbs 24, 244-270. Lea, D. E., 1946, Actions of Radiations od Living Cells. Cambridge University Press. 402 pp. Li, J. Ch., 1927, Genetios 12, 1-58. Medvedev, N. N., 1938, C.R. Acad. Sci U.R.S.S. 20, 319-321. Mohr, 0.L., and Sturtevant, A. H., 1919, Proc. SOC.exp. B i d . N. P. 16, 95-96. Morgan, T. H., Bridges, C. B., and Sturtevant, A. H., 1925, Bibliogr. Genet. 2, 1-262. Needham, J., 1942, Biochemistry and Morphogenesis. Cambridge University Press. 787 QQ. Neuhaus,-M. E., 1941, C.R. Acaa. Sci. U.R.S.S.N.S. 30,238-241. Poulson, D. F., 1941, Proc. 7th int. Congr. Genet. 240-241. 1940, J. exp. 2001.83, 271-325. 1945, Amer. Nat. 79, 340-364. Poulson, D. F., and Boell, E. J., 1946a, BWZ. Bull. 91, 228. 1946b, Anat. Reo. 96, 508. Rapoport, J. A., 1947, Amer. Nat. 81, 30-37. RedfIeId, H., 1926, Genetics 11, 482-502. Russell, E. S., 1940, J . exp. ZooZ. 84, 363-385. Scharrer, B., and Hadorn, E., 1938, Proc. nat. Acad. Rai., Wash. 24, 236-242. Schmid, W.,1949, 2. indubt. Abstamm- u. VrrerbLrhre 83, 220-253.. Schubel, F., 1934, Amer. Nat. 68, 278-282. Sohultr, J., 1929, Genetios 14, 366-419. Sohultz, J., and Dobzhansky, Th., 1934, Genetics 19, 344-364. Seidel, F., Bock, E., and Krause, G., 1940, Natzcrwisseneohaften 28, 433-446. Sikes, E. K.,and Wiggelsworth, V. B., 1930, Quart. J. micr. Sci. 74, 165-192.
ACTION OF LETHAL FACTORS IN DROSOPHILA
Sivertzev-Dobzhansky, N. I?., 1927, Arch. EntuMech. Org. 109, 535-548. Sohels, 3’. H.,1950,Pxperientia 6, 139-143. Roiinenblick, B. P.,1938, O e w t i c s 23, 169. 1940, Genetics 26, 137. Spencer, W. P.,1937, D.Z.8. 7, 13. 1942, Amer. Nat. 76, 325-329. Starck, M. B., 1922, J . ezp. 2007..19, 531-558. Stern, C., 1935, Proc. nut. Acad. Sci., Wash. 21, 374-379. Stern, C., and Novitski, E., 1948, Science 108, 538-539. Vogt, M.,1947, 2. Naturf. 2b, 292-294.
85
Localization and Function of Heterochromatin in Drosophila Melanogaster ALOIIA HANNAH Department of Zoology. University of California. Berkeley. California
CONTENTS
. .
............ . . . . . . . . . . .
. . .
. . . .
.
. . .
.
.
.
.
. .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
..... . ......... . . . . . . . . .
. .
.
.. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ....... . . .
. .
. .
Page 87 89 90 92 92 95 101 102 104 107 108 109 112 113 114 115 117 117 118 118 119 121
........ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
I Introduction I1 Cytological Characteristics of IIeterochromatin 1 Mitotic Chromosomes 2 Salivary Gland Chromosomes a Major Heterochromatic Regions b Intercalary Heterochroinatin I11 Genetic Effects of Heterochromatin 1 Position Effect and Variegation a The Euchromntic Break and Variegation b The Heterochromatic Break and Variegation (1) X Chromosome (2) Y Chromosome (3) Autosomes c Comparison of X, Y. and Autosomal Heterocliromatiii d Modification of Variegation 2 Loci in Major Heteroehromatic Regions 3 Intercalary Heterochromatin a Interaalary Heterochromatin and Position Effect b Intercalary Heterochromatin and Location of the Gene c Polygenic Activity IV Summary V References
.. . . . .
. . . . . . .. . .
. . .
.....
. . . . . . . . . . ..... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .... .....
. . . . . . . . . . . ............. ........................ ....................... I. INTRODUCTION
.
The function of heterochromatin is a question of much controversy I n part this is due to the historical concept that heterochromatin is genetically inert. in part to the contradictory evidence and resultant confusion of fact and speculation. and finally to the lack of critical experimental data . As a result it has been found necessary. i n many cases in this review. to point out the contradictions and speculations without being able to resolve any of the basic questions regarding the fiinction of heterochromatin The few mutants which are known to be located in major hetero-
.
87
88
ALOHA HANNAH
chromatic regions are phenotypically not distinguishable from euchromatic ones (Schultz, 1939). The greater part of the heterochromatin, however, seems to have no distinctly discernible genes in classical Mendelian concepts. On the other hand, in certain genetic backgrounds, loss of blocks of heterochromatin results in inviability (Schultz, 1939) or produces gross morphological abnormalities (Morgan, Schultz, ancl Ourry, 1941 ), ancl its hyperfunction is associated with neoplasia (Daylingtoil and Thomas, 1941 ; Caspersson ancl Santesson, 1942; Kollw, 1947). Reitz (1928) introduced the term heterochromatin to describe special regions of the mitotic chromosome which retain a dense and compact htrncture during interphase. He was able to show (1928-1935) that these regions differ from euchromatin in the degree to which they change from telophase to interphase, and pointed out, after a comparative study of mitotic and salivary gland chromosomes, that there must be two types of heterochromatin : a, which cannot be uncoiled, and p , which uncoils to exhibit a diffuse mesh. When Heitz introduced the term heterochromatin he was describing only one of the characteristics of heteropycnosis. It had long been known that certain chromosomes or chromosomal regions are nucleated to different degrees during particular stages of meiosis and mitosis, If they are undernucleated they have been called negatively heteropycnotic, if overnucleated positively heteropycnotic. Some heterochromatic regions have the property of reversibility, that is, they are positive during one stage of the cycle, and negative in another; other regions do not show reversibility, being positive throughout the cycle. For this reason White (1945) defines heterochromatin as any chromosomal region which becomes heteropycnotic a t some stage in its cycle. Bchnltz (1947), on the other hand, limits heterochromatin with genetic function to “chromosomal regions which have the specific property of remaining as blocks in the intermitotic state.” Very soon after IIeitz’s cytological analysis of heterochromatin, it was realized that the heterochromatic regions in Drosophila chromosomes could be roughly correlated with the so-called genetically inert regions (Muller, 1914, 1918 ; Muller and Painter, 1932) and thus differentiated from the genetically active regions. However, the original concept of inert or degenerate genes has been replaced by that of specialized function. Muller (Muller and Gershenson, 1935 ; Muller, Raffel, Gershenson, and Prokofyeva-Belgovslraya, 1937 ; Muller, 1947) believed that the inert regions are essentially of nongenic material derived from a few active genes. Pontecorvo (1944) postulated that each gene, having its own characteristic cycle of nucleoprotein metabolism, if duplicated tandemly would give rise to differentiated regions having more or less, as the case
BETEROOHROMATIN IN DECOSOPHIZA M E Z A N O G A S T E R
89
might be, nucleoprotein than average, which would account for the unique genetic properties of heterochromatin. Mather (1941, 1944) proposed that the heterochromatin is active in the sense that it has genes, but that these genes have similar and supplementary effects governing continuous variation. Goldschmidt (1949) attributed a specific genetic fimct ion to the intercalary heterochromatin while the chromocentric heterochromatin may act in a generalized quantitative way. Caspersson and Schultz (for reviews see Caspersson, 3947; Schnltz, 1939, 1947) suggested that the heterochromatic genes function primarily i n the nucleic acid metabolism, while Koller (1947) believed its function to be that of a regulator responsible for maintaining equilibrium between supply and demand for nucleic acid. I n agreement with this concept, Vanderlyn (1949) concluded that the heterochromatin is a region of transfer of energy and/or substances at the nucleolar and niiclear membranes. Finally, Resende (1945) postulated that hetwochromatin may play an important role in speciation. 11. CYTOLOGICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF HETEROCHROMATIN
With the development of cytogenetic techniques and the resultant distinction between different types of chroma tin, two problems have emerged : the relation of cytologically distinguishable parts of the chromosome to their genetic functions ; and the analysis of the role and significance of heterochromatin, as well as euchromatin, in the metabolism of the cell, and their relation to evolution of genetic systems. This in turn raised the question of whether all heterochromatin is the same in that it is genetically active, or whether some has genetic function and other only participates in chromosomal metabolism. As the cyclic staining reaction of a chromosome is generally attribnted to synthesis and breakdown of desoxyribose nucleic acid, heteropycnosis has been interpreted by some (Koller, 1936 ; Muller and Prokofyeva, 1935) in terms of spiralization and nucleination of the chromosome. Others ( G u h i n , 1948; Koller, 1936; Koller and Darlington, 1934) presumed the determining factor t o be associated with the solitary condition of the X (as in spermatocytes). White (1940) postulated that heteropycnosis is not a function entirely of spiralization, but that heterochromatin is essentially different from euchromatin and therefore has characteristic cytological features. Schultz (1947) believed that the “genetic” heterochromatin is that which appears as bloclrs in the interphase cell ant1 has specific staining properties in prophase and metsphase stages.
90
ALOHA HANNAH
1. Mitotic Chromosomes Although the morphology of a chromosome varies during the different stages of mitosis, an estimation of the sequence and distribution of euchromatic and heterochromatic segments in mitotic metaphase chromosomes may be obtained by using certain constant structures, the constrictions, as landmarks. The chromosomes of Dyosophila melanogaster exhibit, a t metaphase, nonstaining gaps or constrictions which are constant i n position (Bridges, 1927 ; Kaufmann, 1934). The ‘‘primary constrictions” are associated with the spindle-fiber attachment regions or centromeres (Fig. 1 ) . The “secondary constrictions” are of two types, the nucleolus organizer and the gap or indentation constrictions. The gap constrictions may represent long non-nucleated but coiled chromonemata (Kaufmann, 1934) or they may be the genes responsible for the heterochromatic blocks, which do not become as coiled as other parts of the chromosome (Muller and Prokofyeva, 1935). The indentations have no known function. The heterochromatin in general extends from (and may include) the gap constrictions to the centromeres. I n D . m e l m g a s t e r the Y chromosome is totally heterochromatic, and the proximal third of the X is heterochromatic (Fig. 1). But there must also be differences within the inert regions of both the X and Y chromosomes as shown by cytogenetic tests. Translocations between the Y and fourth chromosomes, giving cubitus-interruptus position effect and affecting fertility, always occur at the distal ends of the Y (Khvostwa , 1939 ; Neuhaus, 1939). Deletions involving the proximal portion of the X either have nearly all the inert region present, or almost all absent (Dobzhansky, 1932 ; Muller and Gershenson, 1935 ; Muller and Painter, 1929 ; Painter and Muller, 1929). If the heterochromatin were genetically identical the breaks would be a t randonl. Cytologically, chromosomes 2 and 3 arc heteropycnotic both to the left and right of the centromere for about one-fifth of the length of each arm, and this heterochromatin is probably delimited by secondary constrictions (Heitz, 1933, 1935). However, I-Iinton (1942) found that the heterochromatin of the left arm of the second chromosome is composed of at least two blocks, one consisting of the region from the secondary constriction to the centromere, and another also represented by one-fifth of the left arm distally from the constriction. Presumably this heterochromatin is not heteropycnotic. The fourth chromosome in mitotic cells does not show pronounced heteropycnotic regions (Heitz, 1933 ; Kaufmann, 1934), but this may be due only to the small size of the chromosome. The extent of heterochro-
HETEROCHROYATIN IN DROSOPHILA M E L A N O f f A W E R
91
Y
0
KEY
I I I l O l l C -C(YCMROMAIIII
FIG. 1. Comparison of mitotic Chromosomes, salivary gland Chromosomes, and crossover map distance. The salivary map is reduced to 1/200 in comparison to the mitotic map. Analogous regions were determined by translocations.
matic regions in the salivary gland fourth chromosome has been variously reported by different investigators. Griffen and Stone (1940) believed that there is no heterochromatin present in either arm. Bridges (1935) postulated that there are a t least two inert regions, one a t the tip of the chromosome, resulting in its tendency to conjugate with heterochromatin of other chromosomes, and the other basal and often embedded within the chromocenter. Slizynski (1944) suggested that there may be a heterochromatic region in the proximity of the chromocenter as well as at both free ends, and pointed out that the fourth is almost devoid of the heavy capsules conspicuous in the other chromosomes. Genetic evidence points to the probability that some if not all of the genes in this chromosome have heterochromatic properties (Schultz, 1939 ; Stern, personal communication). Localization of genetic loci along the length of the metaphase chromosomes by means of translocations (Dobzhansky, 1929, 1930 a and b, 1931, 1932 a and b, 1936; Muller and Painter, 1932; Painter, 1931; Painter and Muller, 1929 ; Sivertzev-Dobzhansky and Dobzhansky, 1933) revealed that although the linear order was the same as for the crossover
92
ALOHA HANNAH
map, the distances were different (Fig. 1 ) . The distal half of the X cliromosomc contains all the sex-linked genes but bobbed, which is in the inert region, A similar concentration of genes in the distal portions is exhibited by the second and third chromosomes. Cytologically, the regions which have the fewest genes also show the phenomenon of heteropycnosis (Kaufmann, 1934). I n addition, heterochromatic sections may also be within the euchromatin, f o r certain regions condense into a few large chromomeres in prophase chromosomes (Heitz, 1935 ; Kaufmann, 1946).
2. Xalivayy Gland C h r m s m e s a. Major Heterochomatic Regions. Meiotic and mitotic chromosomes give only an idea of the gross structure and distribution of the different kinds of chromatin, for it is difficult to determine the limits of either euchromatin or heterochromatin. Likewise, it is not possible to localize small heterochromatic sections in the euchromatin, or vice versa, because, as yet, there are no precise methods for determining, genetically or cytochemically, active and inactive regions. The salivary gland chroinosomes have proved to be more useful for detailed studies, for there are at least four recognizable kinds of heterochromatin: (1) the heterochromatin of the Y chromosome and the large block near the centromere of the X (and presumably the autosomes), which become part of the chromocenter and/or retain no definite structure ; (2) the heterochromatin which retains some structure in the salivary chromosomes; ( 3 ) the nucleolus-associated heterochromatin ; (4) the intercalary heterochromatin. The length of the major heterochromatic regions in a salivary gland chromosome of D . nzelanogaster, as well as other Drosophila species, is relatively much shorter than in the somatic chromosomes (Dobzhansky, 1944; Heitz, 1934, 1935; Pavan, 1946). About one-third of the length of the metaphase X chromosome is heterochromatic, but the same region forms less than one-twentieth of the X chromosome in the salivary nucleus (Fig. 1 ) . This may be because the heterochromatic regions adjacent to the centromeres fuse together into a common mass in the chromocenter (Bridges, 1935 ; Heitz, 1934, 1935), or because relatively long sections are represented by single bands (Muller, 1947; Muller and Gershenson, 1935 ; Muller, Raffel, Gtershenson, and Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya, 1937). The Y chromosome, which is longer than the X in mitotic chromosomes, is reduced to about nine discs in the salivaries, these being homologous with the heterochromatin in section 20 of the X (ProkofyevaBelgovskaya, 1937). The heterochromatic segment, from the centromere l o the first constriction, in the left arm of the second chromosome is re-
HETEROCEIROYATIN IN D R O S O P R I L A M E L A N O Q A S T E E
93
duced to a single band in the salivaries, the bulk of the salivary heterochromatin of this arm being derived from the heterochromatin beyond the constriction (IIinton, 1942). The second kind of heterochromatin is that which retains some strncture in the salivary chromosome and therefore can be identified more or less by its banded nature. I n comparison with euchromatic regions in which all chromomeres of a band conjugate intimately, the heterochromatic bands are not as distinct, f o r the heterocliromonieres are not joined together in a regular manner. A precise differentiation between the two types of heterochromatin is even more difficult, for they have variable and overlapping morphological properties in tlifferent environments. Type 2, for example, may he a part of tlw cahvomocenter yet retain some banded structure. I n general the eii~hromomeresand Iiete~oc~liromonirres appear to be morphologically different. I n Drosophila, as in Chironomoiis, the euchromomeres may be small, completely stained dots, and the heterochromomeres large dots stained only at the periphery (Bauer, 1936). Or the heterochromomeres may be only slightly larger than the euchromomeres, yesiculate, and stained faintly (Kaufmann, 1944 ; Muller and Prolrofyeva, 1935 ; Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya, 1947). The heterochromomeres vary considerably under different circumstances, genetic and environmental. They may he capsules aggregated into a diffuse mass or meshwork, o r bands disaggregnted into chromioles (Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya, 1935, 1947) ; or they may manifeht rather distinct banding. The last is usually the case in the heterochromatic bands near the euchromatin. Even the boundary between euchromatin and heterochromatin is variable, for certain bands may appear either euchromatic or heterochromatic depending on the preparation (Pontecorvo, 1944). Nor are the characteristics of either necessarily retained in rearrangements involving euchromatin and heterochromatin. Schultz (Morgan, Schultz, and Curry, 1939) found that in one of the variegated mutants, white-variega ted-D-3 (breaks : 335.6 and following lOlF), the amount of nucleic acid in certain bands is correlated with the amount of variegation. At 25" C., when the phenotypic variegation is slight, bands in 3F shorn an augmentation of neucleic acid; a t intermediate temperatures, and intermediate variegation, the augmentation is more pronounced ; and at 16' C., and the greatest variegation, the regular arrangement of bands is replaced by an irregularity similar to that of the heterochromatic regions. Sutton (Sutton, 1940; Cole and Sutton, 1941) , on the other hand, found little heterochromatization of the euchromatic band when next to heterochromatin, and high variability within a single band. But, as pointed out by Schultz (1947), unless
94
ALOHA HANNAH
whole bands are compared the local difference between points within a band can mask differences between bands. Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya (1947) showed by use of statistical analysis that when inert regions are inserted into the euchromatin the heterochromatization decreases, and that when active regions are brought near inert ones the heterochromatization spreads to the active regions. Even though two neighboring nuclei may differ sharply, the same section being euchromatic in one and completely heterochromatic in the other, the per cent of heterochromatization has a constant value characteristic for a given stock under a definite condition. The third type of heterochromatic structure, the nucleolus-organizing region (NOR), likewise shows no morphologically distinct banding in the salivaries, although it has been established that nucleoli are produced at specific loci i n the heterochromatin but not on any specific chromosome. I n D. melanogaster, for example, the NOR’S are in the long arm of the X, adjoining 20B-C (Kaufmann, 1942) and in the short arm of the Y, whereas in D . ananassae, a closely related species, nucleoli are associated with the Y and the fourth chromosomes (Kaufmann, 1937). Transpositions or translocations of the NOR to other chromosomes in D. melanogader have occurred experimentally (Hannah, 1949 ; Kaufmann, 1938), and if it is broken in two parts each portion retains its nucleolar-organizing properties, proving that it must consist of several units (Kaufmann, 1938). The role of the nucleolus is difficult to evaluate, but it appears to be concerned with synthesis of ribonucleic acid. It may possibly act as a storehouse for products produced by the chromosomes and used by the cytoplasm, or it may participate in an intermediary step between the chromosomes and the cytoplasm (Caspersson and Schultz, 1940 ; Schultz, Caspersson, and Aquilonius, 1940). Breakage in the heterochromatic regions appears to increase the proportion of ribonucleic acid in the nucleolus (Schultz, 1939, 1941, 1944, 1947). Although the evidence for a particular function of the NOR is not conclusive, it does point to a close relation between the chromosome, particularly the heterochromatin, and the nucleolus in cellular metabolism. The limits of the major heterochromatic regions have not been established with certainty, either genetically or cytologically. However, by making use of a property of heterochromatin-greater sensitivity to breakage during or after treatment with radiation-it is possible to demonstrate the presence of heterochromatin in regions as small as the lettered subdivisions. X-ray-induced breaks are not distributed a t random on the basis of length of the chromosome as represented by genetic maps (Patterson, Stone, Bedicheck, and Suche, 1934) or by the salivary
IIETEROCHROMATIN IN D R O S O P E I L A Y E L A N O G A S T E R
95
gland (;liroitiosoiiies (lhiier, 1939 ; Raucr, Demercc, and Kaufmann, 1938 ; Kaiifmann, 1939, 1946). I n general, the distribution of breaks is at random in the euchromatin but disproportionately high in the heterochromatic sections. I n the X chromosome about one-fourth of all breaks are in division 20. If this relation always holds, wide departures from randomness of breakage frequency within short distances can be attribnted to the presence of heterochromatin (Kaufmann, 1939). Division 19, €or examplv, has a high breakage frcquency, but most of this is due to the 1)reaks in 19141 ( ICiiiiFinnnn, 1939, 1946 ; Proltofyeva-Belgovskaya and Khvostovtt, 1!):i9). ‘I’Iiiis the major heterochromatic regions of the Y niiist cxtcntl from 19E through 20. The distribiition of break frcqucncics in the autosomes, based on divisions only, ;irv random, except for the divisions adjacent to the centromeres (Bniier, 1039 ; Tlauer, Ikmerec, and Kaufmann, 1938). Therefore, thc major lirtcrochromatic regions are in sections 40 and 41 in the second and 80 ;ind 81 in the third chromosome. Tn the fourth chromosome, the brcalts occur inoat frequently near the centroniere, a n d especially in 101F (Stern, unpublished). F. I n t e r c u l a r y Hcteroclwomatin. The diffuse banding or vesiculate nature of the major heterochromatin is not a criterion of intercalary hctcrochromatin (Slizynski, 1945). On the other hand, certain regions, within the euchromatin, simulate the behavior of the major heterochromatin in that they have a high break frequency. I n the X chromsome they are found in divisions 1, 3, 4, 11, 12, and 19 (Kaufmann, 1939, 19 44, 1946). Thc l~ehaviorsuggests that these sections are heteroehroiiiatic in nature. Secondly, certain regions of the euchromatin also exhibit, the property of nonspecific pairing. As pairing of corresponding hands is taken as a criterion o€ their similarity, when two “nonhomologous” regions exhibit this property it is assumed that they have some homology. The fact that they also show a tendency to pair with proximal hetrrochroniatin (ectopic pairing [ Slizynski, 19451 o r terminal adhrsionq [ IIinton, 19-15] ) indicates that these regions are heteroehromatic. Sections 1-4, 7, 9, 11, 12, 17, 19, and 20 exhibit the property of ectopic pairing ( I Iinton, 1945 ; Kailfmann, 1946 ; Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya, 1939, 1941 ; Slizynski, 1943). Finally Kodani (1941, 1946) found t h a t the salivary X chromosome showed a differential response to alkali-urea treatment, the “chromatic” (euchromatic) regions reacting less to the treatment than the ‘ ‘achromatic” (heterochromatic) regions. On the basis of this interpretation the heterochromatic sections are found to be in 2-3, 4, 6, 10, 11-12, 13, 18. The distribution of heterochromatin to the lettered subdivisions, as determined for high-breakage coefficients by Kaufmann (1946) and Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya a n d Khvostova (1939),
96
ALOHA HANNAH
and lor ectopic pairing by Kaufmann (1946), Kaufmaiin and collaborators (1948), Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya (1941), and Slizynski (1945) is given in Fig. 2. The fairly high degree of coincidence between the subdivisions showing the properties of ectopic pairing and high breakage coefficients suggest that these sections are intercalary heterochromatin. Such an extensive analysis of the intercalary heterochromatin of the antosomes has not been made, but it is probable that it occurs in these vhromosomes as well, and in a distribution similar to that of the X chroiiiosomc. Iiauer (1939)) calculating the breakage coefficients in the X vhroriiowiii(1 on the basis of 315 breaks distributed in 19 divisions (without taking into consideration the number of bands in a division), concluded that breakage is random. Kaufmann (1946), on the basis of 1048 breaks in 114 subdivisions, showed that certain intercalary regions have a significantly higher break frequency than others. It is probable that the break distribution in the autosomes would likewise be shown to be nonrandom if the analysis could be in terms of units smaller than divisions. Even in respect to divisions, if the number of bands per division is taken into consideration, certain ones show higher breakage coefficients than others (Fig. 2 j breakage coemcients recalculated from Bauer's data). These results are substantiated by other evidence. Dubinin, Khvostova, and Mansurova (1941) reported that breaks occur more frequently in subdivisions 21D, 22A-B, 22D, 22F, 57F, and 59F in thc second cliromosome, and 61C-D, 61F, 62B, 64B, 89E-F, 93E-F, 99A-€3, and 99F in the third. Patterson, Stone, Redicheck, and Suchc (1934; also Patterson, 1940) pointed out that the majority of translocation breaks occur either a t the free end or near the spindle fiber region of a chromosome, but that in chromosome 3 a high proportion of the breaks are found, genetically, to be between ebony (70.7) and rough (91.1). I n terms of the salivary gland chromosomes, this would be between 91F and 97F. Studies of ectopic pairing of the X arid antosomes reveals that there are several sections in both the second and third chromosomes which have characteristics of intercalary heterochromatin ( Kaufmann and rd.tilw, wportcd in Kanfmann, hlcl)onald, Gay, Wilson, Wymari, and Okii(Ia, 1948). Kven these incomplete data show a fair correlation between the regions having a high breakage cocfficierit and those exhibiting ectopic pairing (Fig. 2). Sections 89, 94, and 98 in chromosome 3, particularly, have a tendency to pair with other regions. This general region is also unique in having a high incidence of Minutes: nine of the 20 Minute loci reported for chromosome 3 in Bridges and Brehme (1944) are beyond 70 in the crossover map (Fig. 2). The Minutes, a group of mutants with similar
-
HETEROCHROMATIN IN DROSOPHZLA B l E L A N O G A S T E R
f
/
I \ 11-15
--
- --
- I -
97
98
ALOHA HANNAH
phenotypic effects, are found scattered along the length of every chromosome, but are especially concentrated near the spindle-fiber regions. Of the 23 Minute loci (those showing “allelism” are considered as a single locus) in chromosome 2, nine are within five crossover units of the centromere and Minute-S-10 (and an allele, M-2-D) is known to remove a large block of the heterochromatin. In the third chromosome, one-third of all Minutes are located within five crossover units of the centromere. They are thought by some investigators to be heterochroinatic in nature, hy others to be expressions of deficiencies p e r se (c.f., Goldschmidt, 1949 ; Mohr, 1932 ; Morgan, Bridges, and Sturtevant, 1925 ; Schultz, 1929). The concentration of Minutes near the centromeres supports the hypothesis that they are heterochromatic, or somehow associated with heterochromatin. If this is the case, Minute loci in distal portions of the chromosomes may be in intercalary heterochromatin. This relationship is further suggested by evidence obtained in conjunction with other tests. Minute loci in the second chromosome, as determined by deficiency tests, are a t 21C1-2 (Lewis, 1945), between 24D and 24F (Morgan, Schultz, and Curry, 1939), between 41B and 42A (Morgan, Schultz, and Curry, 1940), and in 49 (Morgan, Bridges, and Schultz, 1938). All of them are in regions having characteristics of heterochromatin. However, further analysis will be necessary before it will be possible to determine the exact relation between the Minutes and heterochromatin. Certain intercalary regions, showing a marked increase in breakage and having irregular and disturbed pairing, also appear to be repeats (Kaufmann, 1939, 1941 ; Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya and Khvostova, 1939). The concept that repeats are heterochromatic stems from Bridges’ (1935) study of the ‘(loops and turnbacks” in the left arm of the second chromosome. They were interpreted as duplications which had become fixed during the process of evolution. Depending upon their origin, repeats can be either direct (abcabc) or reverse (abccba), and each type is distinguished by a characteristic morphology (Schultz, 1947). Both types have been found in normal chromosomes, and have arisen spontaneously and in irradiated material (C. B. Bridges, 1935, 1936, 1938; C. B. Bridges and P. N. Bridges, 1939; P. N. Bridges 1941 a and b, 1942; Demerec and Hoover, 1939 ; Kaufmann and Bate, 1938; Lewis, 1941; Morgan, Schultz, and Curry, 1941 ; Muller, 1941 ; Muller, ProkofyevaBelgovskaya, and Kossikov, 1936 ; Offerman, 1936). From cytological evidence, section 34F to 35C appears to be a direct repeat of section 32F and 33 ; section 38E to 39E is a repeat of, roughly, 37 (Bridges, 1935). The reverse repeats are of two types: those which form capsules or bulbs and those which center around a ‘(weak spot” in the chromosome. The turnback in 36 and the shield in 30A have re-
HETEROCHROYATIN I N D R O S O P H I L A MELANOGASTER
99
versed sections symmetrical about a center, and arc examples of the capsule form. The larger capsules, such as 25A and 66F, are probably also symmetrically reversed repeats, and 33B is probably a reverse repeat within the direct repeat 32-33 (Bridges, 1935). The “weak spot” type is found in regions 3C, l l A , 12D, 12E, and 19E (Bridges, 1935; Kaufmann, 1939 ; Kossikov, 1936). I n the 11-12 region, “Kossikov’s repeat,” 11A and 11B conjugate with 12D and 12E, but the bands lying between do not. The sections showing repeats as determined by C. B. Bridges (1935, 1937, 1938), C. B. and P. N. Bridges (1939), P. N. Bridges (1941 a and b, 1942), and Kaufmann (1946) are given in Fig. 2. The 3C section has been studied rather extensively (Panshin, 1941), for several well-known mutants occur in this region. The repeat includes the bands from 3C1 through 3C7 (and possibly 3B4 and 3C8), 3C1 (on the basis of the reverse-repeat concept) being a repeat of 3C7, and 3C2.3 a repeat of 3C5.6. The “buclde-shape,” assumedly due to partial synapsis of homologous bands, has been reported to disappear when chromosomes, each of which had one of the duplicate loci removed, were combined (Morgan, Bridges, and Schultz, 1937). This would be expected if the duplicate bands were still partially homologous. On the basis of their characteristic morphology, “doublets” may also be repeats (Bridges, 1937 ; Demerec, 1940). They have been grouped with the large repeats, but it is probable that they have quite different genetic properties. Of 5149 bands in the salivary chromosomes, 1299 are doublets (Bridges, 1942 ; Slizynski, 1944 ; White, 1948). These data would suggest that there may be a number of duplicate or semiduplicate loci. Griineberg (1937) and Serebrowsky (1938) have pointed out that genes with a similar phenotype could have occurred as repeats and thus a t the time of origin have had identical function, but have since developed along divergent lines. Genetically, mutants that are allelic and yet have crossing over between them have been interpreted as repeats. Several such mutant pairs are known to be located in or a t least very close to doublets. Salivary analysis of Star and asteroid placed them in a duplicate band 21E1 and 2 (Lewis, 1945) ; BithoraxoidD, bithorax, and bithorax8 (with presumably only two loci involved) are within or proximal to the 89E1 and 2 doublet; Stubble and stubbleoid2 are in the neighborhood of the 89B3 and 4 doublet (Lewis, 1948). The lozenge complex, a triplicate locus genetically (Oliver, 1940 ; Oliver and Green, 1944‘; Green and Green, 1949) with perhaps almondex as a fourth member of the group (Bridges, 1936), has been located tentatively in section eight. Achaete, Hairy-wing and scute are in a region of three doublets (1A5.6, 1B1.2, 1B3.4) (Sutton, 1943). I n the scute-8 inversion (break following 1B1.2), which leaves achaete in the left end of the
100
ALOHA HANNAH
chromosome and transfers scute to the right end, the achaete and scute “bands” tend to conjugate, suggesting a cytological homology as well as a genetic similarity (Serebrowsky, 1938). Other mutant pairs which may possibly represent repeats are : chlorotic (0.1 - ) and yellow (0.0) and possibly silver (O.O&) ; miniature (36.1) and dusky (36.2) ; pupal (51& ) and pads ( 5 5 h 3 ) ;blistered (107.3) and balloon (107.4) ; tetrapter (51.3) and bithorax (58.8); blistery (48.7) and Bubble ( 4 8 k ) (Griineberg, 1937). Another attack on the problem of repeats was by comparison of the number of loci with dominant “notch-like wing” phenotype having a “facet-like eye’’ locus next to them. Of seven wing mutants, five (Notch, vestigialD, Jagged, Serrate, and Lyra) have mutants involving disarrangement of the ommatidia to either the right or the left, while two (Beadex and Beaded) do not (Morgan, Schultz, and Curry, 1940). The distribution of these types of factors with respect to one another is therefore not a t random. One interpretation could be that the first five represent repeats of a double locus (ABAB) and subsequent translocation of one pair (AB) to another region, or another chromosome. Of the seventeen pairs mentioned above having characteristics of repeats, seven are in intercalary heterochromatin (using breakage frequency and ectopic pairing as the criterion), seven are probably in intercalary heterochromatin, two are in euchromatic segments, and one pair has one locus in heterochromatin and the other in euchromatin. There is no a priori reason why intercalary heterochromatic regions should be associated with repeats. Muller (1918, 1938) suggested that genes which had mutated either to a deleterious type or to inertness would have greater survival if they were in repeats. Since one-half of the genes in a repeat are not necessary for life, it would be possible for one gene to retain its function whereas the other could lose its specific properties. This seems to be the case in the 3C duplication, for deficiencies including 3C5.6, but not 3C2.3, do not show the white phenotypes, and deficiencies covering 3C1, but not 3C7, are not Notch (data summarized from Bridges and Brehme, 1944). I n the “Kossikov repeat,” conversely, the garnet “loci” seem to have retained their functional activity, for about one-third of the viable garnet mutations are subliminal (have no phenotypic expression) except in compounds with a visible garnet allele (Muller, 1947). If, however, the heterochromatic property is not an expression of degeneration of euchromatin, the relation between repeats and heterochromatin must have another explanation. The behavior of the repeats intimates that they must have arisen in phylogeny by inversions or duplications (Bridges, 1935 ; Kaufmann, 1939 ; Kaufmann and Bate, 1938 ;
BETEROOHROMA‘PIN IN DECOSOPHIZA M E Z A N O G A S T E R
101
Kossikov, 1936 ; Offermann, 1936). If the heterochromatic property is an expression of the linear order of chromomeres of similar function, as suggested by Pontecorvo (1944), then a heterochromatic segment should arise every time a euchromatic region undergoes duplication and the replicas remain adjacent to each other. O r the heterochromatic regions may have been present very early in phylogeny, with the duplications coming only secondarily and remaining because duplications or deficiencies in the heterochromatic regions are less subject to rigid selection. The age of several of the duplicated regions is very great, for both the bulb in section 2 and the 11-12 duplication are found in both D . sirnulam and D . melawguster (Offermann, 1936 ; Kossilrov, 1936). Even species as remote as D . rnelanogaster and D . pseudoobscura have similarly high concentrations of repeats in chromosomes which, on other grounds, are presumed to be homologous (Dobzhansky, 1941).
111. GENETICEFFECTS OF HETEROCHROMATIN The greater part of the proximal heterochromatin appears not to have a distinctively discernible genetic function, and the few mutants located within major heterochromatic regions (bobbed in the X, light, straw, and lightoid in the second, inturned and pink in the third, cubitusinterruptus and bent in the fourth) are not in any way remarkable for their phenotypes (Schultz, 1939 ; Sntton, 1942). The lack of discrete active genes in the Y chromosome led Muller (1914, 1918) to postulate that the accumulation of inactive genes, as well as losses or duplications of chromosomal parts through translocations, could not be harmful to the fly because of the hypomorphic condition of the Y. When it was shown that the X chromosome has a similar genetically inert region (Muller and Painter, 1932) and that there is crossing over between the X and Y (Kaufmann, 1933; Neuhaus, 1936; Philip, 1935; Stern and Doan, 1937) it became obvious that the inert region cannot be full of degenerate genes. As the heterochromatin is fundamentally different in certain properties from the enchromatin, it was suggested by Muller and Gershenson (1935) that inert regions are essentially of nongenic material. This theory is substantiated by the fact that the Y and “Block A” of the X are not necessary either for life or for a normal external phenotype (hluller, Raffel, Gershenson, and Prolrofyeva-Belgoi.sItaya, 1937). It has been pointed out, however (Darlington and Upcott, 1941; Mather, 1942, 1944; Pontecorvo, 1944), that if there was a full quota of genes, each having a small quantitative effect, mutational changes would be difficult to detect, and deficiencies or duplications would consequently be less harmful. Polygenes appear to be examples of genetic fnnction
102
ALOHA H A N N A H
of this type (Mather, 1944). But heterochromatin also has functions, possibly qualitative as well as quantitative, which do not fit into the category of polygenic activity.
1. Positim Effect and Variegation. When it was found that genic action could be modified by chromosomal breaks located in the neighborhood of a gene, it was realized that the original concept of genes as discrete independent entities was somewhat too simple. Of the two theories to explain this phenomenon-(1) the theory of gene mutation, genetic suppression, or a cytological deficiency accompanying but independent of the chromosomal rearrangement (Bridges, 1923; Demerec, 1939, 1941 ; Morgan, Bridges, and Sturtevant, 1925 ; Muller, 1932 ; Muller and Altenburg, 1930) ; and (2) the theory that the function of the gene depends upon its position in the sequence, so that its properties are altered when it is transferred to a new position (Dobzhansky, 1932, 1936 ; Sturtevant, 1925)-the second, the "position-effect " hypothesis, is accepted by most today. Experimental evidence substantiating it is as follows. Cytological reversion accompanying a genetic reversion proves that no change other than the chromosomal change has taken place (Griineberg, 1937). A gene close to a rearrangement and showing position effect reverts to normal when removed by crossing over (Dubinin and Sidorov, 1935 ; Panshin, 1935). Crossing over between a white-variegated mutant (wm4)and other notquite-identical inversions shows that the decisive factor in determining variegation is located at the junction between the white locus and the heterochromatin (Schultz, 1943). Position effect may occur as a result of (1) suppression or change in the activity of the gene, either by loss or change in its position (Demerec, 1939, 1940, 1941; Muller, 1932) ; or (2) change in interactions between gene products or competition between genes for a common substrate (Muller, 1935; Offermann, 1935; Stern, 1949) ; o r (3) reversible modification of the genes o r their structural regions due to abnormal pairing (Ephrussi and Sutton, 1944) ; or (4) production of the phenotype of a mutant locus by a break occurring in the neighborhood of the normal locus (Goldschmidt, 1946). The results of numerous investigations show that alleles having phenotypic similarities may be caused by different cytogenetic changes. F o r example, of 102 mutations in the white-Notch region, 28 were fully viable point mutations at the white locus, 30 were deficiencies, 3 were lethal with no cytological changes, 39 were chromosomal changes, and 2 were both deficiencies and chromosome changes (Demerec, 1939, 1940, 1941). The rearrangements--R (4) or position-effect mutants-ould
HETEROCHROMATIN IN D R O X O P E I L A Y E L A N O B A S T E R
103
be divided into those in which the recipient region was euchromatin (10) and those in which it was heterochromatin (29). I n the former the breaks were immediately to the left or right of the Notch band (3C7), whereas those which had the second break in the heterochromatin could have the first break as far as 50 bands from the locus. Therefore, the heterochromatin must be capable of exerting a n influence over a much longer distance than the euchromatin. However, the expression of the mutant phenotype in the majority of these cases may be a “Dubinin effect”; that is, the phenotype is expressed only when heterozygous with a recessive (point mutation) allele and is normal when in the homozygous or hemizygous state. The most striking genetic property of heterochromatin is the induction and modification of variegation in somatic cells. Variegation is characterized by mottling (mosaic pattern of several colors) of eye o r body color, or mosaic pattern of affected and nonaffected bristles, or variable expressivity of the wing pattern. Structural changes, involving one break in the euchromatin and one in the heterochromatin, characteristically give rise to this type of variegation (Demerec, 1939, 1941; Demerec and Slizynska, 1937 ; Gowen and Gay, 1933, 1934 ; Muller, 1930, 1935; Noujdin, 1936, 1938; Schultz, 1936, 1939, 1941, 1944, 1947). Following the terminology introduced by Stern (Stern and Heidenthal, 1944; Stern, Schaeffer, and Heidenthal, 1946) and Lewis (1950), R(+) will be used to designate rearrangements having a position effect; those which are variegated will be referred to a s V-type and those which are somatically stable as S-type. There is some evidence that gross structural changes are not always necessary for the induction of variegation. Muller (1946) reported that a recessive sex-linked mottler mutant near vermilion, in combination with alleles of the white locus, causes them to be variegated, resembling “many of the lighter mottled alleles of white that are caused by the juxtaposition of the white locus to heterochromatin.” Among five cut mutants showing variegation, three were gross chromosomal rearrangements involving breaks in the euchromatin a t the cut locus and heterochromatin, hut in two no cytological change was detectible although there was a tendency for the 7B region to show considerably more ectopic pairing than characteristic (Hannah, 1949). It is possible that variegation in these mutants is due to a minute insertion of heterochromatin in the neighborhood of the cut locus. I n terms of the position-effect hypothesis, variegation is due to euchromatic genes being brought within the range of influence of the heterochromatic regions. Thus, if the euchromatic break is close to the white locus the eye will appear mottled for several colors. But other
SO4
ALOHA HANNAH
loci close to white (roughest, facet, split, Notch, diminutive, and echinus) may be affected as well. Other examples-yellow, Hairy-wing, achaete, and/or scute-may show variegation as a result of breaks in section 1 ; or brown, minus, and abbreviated if the breaks are in 59D or E. Schultz (1939) has put forward the following general explanation to account for the mottling effect; the juxtaposition of euchromatin and heterochromatin may alter the nucleic acid metabolism of the bands nearest to the point of breakage, resulting sometimes in heterochromatization of the bands, sometimes in an actual loss. The process appears to be a sort of inactivation, with the point of breakage acting as a center from which the disturbance spreads. I n line with this concept, Demerec (1939)attributed the instability to either a reversible chemical change, or a reversible suppression of the activity of the gene. Offermann (1935) postulated that the activity of the gene is influenced by the environment ; therefore, if a rearrangement changes the environment a different expression of the gene will be invoked. If this change is great, the affected locus may be dominant, since there is nothing corresponding to the substance produced by the other chromosome, and therefore no allele to cover it. Or the supply of substance may fail to satisfy the requirenients of the cell, and therefore is expressed in the phenotype as an absence. Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya (1947) maintained that there is no actual loss, but heterochromatization. Heterochromatin shortens the metabolic cycle. Increased heterochromatization of an active section will therefore shift it toward recessive manifestation. I n extreme heterochromatization, the genes affected may be entirely eliminated from the developmental processes, and the result will simulate the loss of the gene. a. The Euchromntic Break a.nd Variegation. Numerous loci show variegation in mutant forms having juxtaposition of euchromatin and heterochromatin. The length of the sensitive region varies for the different loci. I n the X chromosome, for instance, the sensitive region of the white-Notch groups may be as much as 30 bands in the salivary gland chromosome, that of rugose-vesiculated from 20 to 80 bands, and yellow-scute about 10 bands ; whereas in cut the breaks are always within one or two bands of 7B (Demerec, 1940,1941; Hannah, 1949). Position effect on the brown locus in the second chromosome and curled locus in the third may likewise extend an appreciable distance along the chromosome (Dubinin, 1936 ; Panshin, 1935). The relation of position effect to the euchromatic break is best shown by the white-Notch variegated mutants. Of those which have been analyzed (data from Bridges and Brehme, 1944), 48 had one or both euchromatic breaks in apposition to heterochromatin (Table 1). I n general the expression of variegation does not depend on both the euchromatic
105
HETEROCHROMATIN IN DILOSOPHILA Y E L A N O Q A S T E R
TABLE 1 Relation of the Euchromatic Break of R ( + ) white-Notch variegated Mutants to the Phenotypic Expression of White ( w ) , roughest ( r s t ) , facet or split ( f a ) , and Notch ( N ) . (Data from Bridges and Brehme, 1944.)
Euchromatic break
Heterochromatic break
Phenotype
X chrom. 2nd chrom. 3rd chrorn. 4th chrom.
Between 3B2 & 3C5.6
3
4
3G9.10 Between 3C9.10 & 3F6
3
9
2
1
w , rst, or w-rst r8t-N fa-N
W-N
-
w , rat, or w-ret
Between 3C5.6 &
5
1
1 1 3
1
1 1
TSt-N fa-N W-N
2
w , rut, or w-rst TS1-N fa-N W-N
1 2
7
ends being next to heterochromatin, but there is some evidence that the degree of expression may. The number of adjacent loci showing position effect likewise appears, in general, to be dependent on the position of the euchromatic break. Twenty of the twenty-four V-type R ( + ) mutants with breaks close to white (3C2 and 3 ) show only white, roughest, or white-and-roughest variegation ; R ( +) mutants with breaks near Notch (3C7) may have only facet and Notch phenotypes or all the mutant phenotypes (white, roughest, facet or split, and diminutive) ; breaks beyond 3C9, in eleven out of twelve mutants, show variegation for all loci from white through diminutive. Thus, some have a strict correlation of expression of phenotype with the distance of the locus from the break and others do not. This may be due to circumscribed reaction of breaks at specific loci in euchromatin, but is more likely correlated with the position of the heterochromatic break (see below). The second characteristic is progressive weakening of the expression of a specific locus the farther it is from the break. Thus in white-variegated-258-18 and white-variegated-D-3, with breaks to the right of white, in compounds with w and rst or spl, rough facets may be wild type in color (Demerec and Slizynska, 1937 ; Morgan, Bridges, and Schultz, 1938; Schultz, 1939). The extent of mottling in white-mottled-1 is directly correlated with the extent of the Notch expression (Muller, 1930). Another white-variegated mutant, however, was reported (Patterson,
106
ALOHA HANNAH
1932) to have independent expression of mottling of the eye and notching of the wings. This mutant also showed different expression in different genetic environments. It was variegated for white in the homozygous female and hemizygous male; variegated for white, Notch, facet, and TABLE 2 Summary of Effects of Rearrangements, Involving One Break in a Heterochromatic R.egion and Another in a Euchromatic Region, 011 the Expression of Position Effect at Euchromatic and Heteroehromatic Loci. (Data from Bridges and Brehme, 1944; KMTostova 1939; Stern, unpublished.)
Position of heterochromatic break
Zltduced phenotype Of :
X Chromosome 18 19
E-F A-C D Euchromatic loci None Not variegated Variegated Heterochromatie loci Both loci Not variegated
1 1 1 I? 1
E
1
20 F A
B C D
4 2 1
1 3
3 2 2
2 2 1 2 2
E F 1 1
It. rt. bb
. bb
het.
2 11 2 9
3 3 7
1 1 Chromosome 2 40
Euchromatic loci None Not variegated Variegated Heterochromatic loci Both loci VaPiegated a
B C
D
1
1
1
1
E
F 3 1 2 1
1
41 A B 6
1
C D E 2 2
2 1
8 3
1
42 F A 2 L2 Rh et . 2 1 4 2 2 3 4 1 I? 5 6 4 1 1
3
1
3
~
Chromosome 3 79 80 81 82 E F A B C C-D D-F F A - - E F A 3L 3R het. cent, 9 Euchromatic loci None Not variegated Variegated Both loci Variegated
1
1
2
1
1
1
1 1 3
2 1
1 1
1
1
1
5 7 1 6 1
3 2 5
3
3 3 9
107
HETEROCHROMATIN IN DROSOPHILA M E L A N O f f A S T E R
TABLE 2-Continued Chromosome 4 101 A B
Euchromatic loci None Not variegated Variegated Heterochromatic loci Both loci Not variegated a Variegated a
C
DE F 1
1
102
A B C D E F 4L 4R het. cent. 9 2
1
4
116
5
6
7
6
1 2 1 1 2 2 3 2
10 13 1 3 1 5
1
2
1
2
1
48 1 4
22190 1 2
Abbreviations: lt.bL, left of bobbed : rt.bb, right of bobbed ; het., heterochromatin; cent., close to the centromere; 1, position of the break not known. 1111 most of these case8 position effect on loci close to the break was not tested. This applies to both euchromatic and heterochromatic loci. *Not variegated (or variegated) refers only to the euchromatic loci.
echinus in the heterozygous female; variegated for white but not for facet o r echinus in the hyperploid female with two white chromosomes. The fact that echinus was affected would suggest that the break was beyond 3C9, but as the cytology is not known this may represent a special case ; possibly there were several breaks near white. The data, taken as a whole, point to the probability that the expression of a locus in V-type R(+) mutants is determined to a degree by the distance of the break from the locus in question. I n respect to the phenotype, the closer the point of breakage to a specific locus, the more extensive is the variegation and the more extreme is the allelomorphism in those cases where allelomorphic series are distinguished (Schultz, 1939). b. The Heterochromatic Break a d Variegation. Several lines of evidence have shown that the heterochromatic regions of the X and the autosomes exert the same effect as the Y in the expression of certain R ( ) genotypes. Extra pieces of the X, if they include the inert region, have an effect similar to that of an extra Y (Noujdin, 1936) ; X chromosomes deficient for the inert region enhance the expression of variegated mutants, and translocations of the X and Y are similar in their action (Khvostova, 1939). Breaks in heterochromatin producing variegated white-Notch mutations may have specificity in some cases, or may give quite similar phenotypes in others (Demerec, 1939, 1941). Data (compiled from all available sources) summarized in Table 2 include the effect of heterochromatin on R mutants with breaks a t the yellow-scute, white-Notch, cut, brown, curled, and cubitus-interrup-
+
108
ALOHA HANNAH
tus loci as well as others. Some-eut, for example-in which variegation was not tested are listed under the heading “Not variegated” (S-type). In actuality, this group must be smaller than is shown in Table 2. “None” (no known phenotypic change) means, in the majority of cases, that loci at the euchromatic break have not been tested for position effect, In general, the heterochromatic regions of all the chromosomes produce variegation phenotypes in R ( +) mutants. However, certain sections appear to give a higher incidence of V-type R ( +) mutants than others; e.g., 208, B, and C in the X, 40F and 418 in the second, 80C and possibly 80D in the third, and lOlF in the fourth. In spite of the fact that the centromeric heterochromatin of all the chromosomes is sufficiently alike to form a chromocenter, and all give variegated phenotypes (Tables 1 and 2 ) , there is some genetic evidence that there may be qualitative as well as quantitative differences. Certain white-Notch mutants have special characteristics dependent upon the heterochromatic break (Demerec, 1939) ; in other words, some are S-type mutants. Three scute alleles, with identical left breaks, show slight differences due to the position of the right break (Raffel and Muller, 1940). It appears probable that different regions of the heterochromatin differ in their potentiality to produce position effect and particularly to affect the expression of variegation. (1) X chromosome. The data in Table 2 concerning the X-chromosome R ( + ) mutants, compiled on the basis of the position of the break in the heterochromatin, show the following. Among three with breaks in the 3B2-3C5.6 region, two are left of the NOR and have whitemottled and roughest-bifid-mottled phenotypes, respectively ; and one in the NOR shows variegation for roughest only. Of four with euchromatic breaks between 3C5.6 and 3C9.10, one, left of the NOR, shows variegation for facet, Notch, and diminutive; one in the NOR shows variegation for facet and Notch; and of two to the right of the NOR, one shows stable changes a t facet and Notch and one a stable change a t facet and variegation for Notch. One having a break beyond 3C9.10 also has the right break to the right of the NOR and shows stable changes a t the roughest and Notch loci. These data confirm Demerec’s finding (1939) that the position of the right break of the X chromosome is partially responsible for the expression of the phenotype. The dependence of the phenotype on the heterochromatic break is even more clearly expressed in the case of the roughest locus. Expression of roughestS variegation is dependent upon the proximity of the roughest locus to that portion of the X which includes the NOR and the centromere, and
HETEROCHROMATIN IN DROSOPHILA NELANOQASTER
109
reversion always involves a secondary break a t the NOR (Kaufmann, 1942). ( 2 ) Y chromosome. It was long thought that the Y chromosome, which is completely heterochromatic, is genetically inert (Bridges, 1916 ; Muller, 1914, 1918), but several investigators have pointed out that this inertness is not complete. Although the Y chromosome of D. melamgaster is not absolutely necessary for life, since males lacking a Y are viable, it does have regions which insure male fertility (Bridges, 1916; Neuhaus, 1939; Stern, 1929), and in some species the Y has more generalized effects, and may influence the viability of the male (Sturtevant, 1937). On a priori grounds one would expect that any part of the chromosome set which was completely useless would have been lost in the course of phylogeny. The fact that the Y chromosome is preserved (only one Drosophila species is known to lack a Y ; see White, 1948), and that the inert regions in all the chromosomes retain their general position next to the centromere in so many species, makes it seem probable that heterochromatic regions have some function necessary for survial of the species (Dobzhansky, 1944). It may be that the genes of the Y were never like those of the X in their present form (Muller, 1932) and that the Y has a different genetic function from the X, which cannot be measured by our present standards. I n D . melanogaster it is possible to obtain in genetic experiments flies that have one or two Y’s in addition to the normal set, or males that lack the Y. I n normal genotypes, addition of the two extra Y’s to either the female or the male induces mottling of the eyes (Cooper, 1949). Addition of a Y to V-type R ( + ) mutants whose normal loci are in euchromatin tends t o suppress variegation, and removal of a Y (XOd) increases variegation ; likewise, addition or subtraction of an arm of the Y (-YL,Ps)influences the expression of variegation (Dubinin and Heptner, 1935; Gowen and Gay, 1933, 1934; Schultz, 1936, 1939, 1941, and 1947; Schultz and Dobzhansky, 1934). Thus, in the case of euchromatic V-type R(+) mutants, the effect of heterochromatin appears to be a matter of genetic balance; the higher the heterochromatin in proportion to euchromatin, the less the variegation, and vice versa (Schultz, 1939). In agreement with these results, the effect of the Y on V-type R ( + ) mutants whose normal loci are in heterochromatin is the reverse; the XO light-variegated male, for example, is more nearly normal, and the XYY and XYYY males have lighter eyes (Khvostova, 1939 ; Morgan and Schultz, 1942 ; Schultz, 1936). Besides modifying variegation phenotypes, changes in the Y -chromosome number may produce new morphological types when in combination with deficiencies of other heterochromatic regions. XO ;
110
ALOHA HANNAH
N(2)S-10 males have spread wings and coarser bristles than X Y ; N(2)S-lO males, and there is some evidence that the XYY condition intensifies the Minute effect (Morgan and Schultz, 1942). It may be that the Y and 2R heterochromatin are antagonistic in their action (Hinton, 1950). Increasing or decreasing the number of Y chromosomes may have other effects; the number of Y’s exerts a determining effect on the structure of the salivary gland chromosomes, particularly the ends, and on general size and staining capacity (Bridges, 1935; Schultz, 1936, 1947). X X Y females have more nucleotides than X X females (Caspersson and Schultz, 1938; Schultz, 1939; Schultz and Caspersson, 1949), although this finding has been questioned by Callan (1948). The Y has specific modifying effects on the expression of podoptera mutants, and in one of them, the podoptera phenotype cannot be expressed in the females unless a Y is present (Goldschmidt, Hannah, and KellenPiternick, 1951). The Y influences cell size of the wing and eye corneolae (Barigozzi, 1947), the length of the third longitudinal vein in the wing (Neuhaus, 1939), and the number of sternopleural bristles (Mather, 1944). Two variegation mutants, white-258-18 and Xc8, are lethal in XO males (Schultz and Catcheside, 1937 ; Schultz, 1939). The presence of extra Y’s in the male decreases X-ray-induced visible and sex-linked-lethal mutation (Kerschner, 1949). The most important function of the Y chromosome is the assurance of male fertility. XO males and males with some of the deficient ’Y’s are sterile (Bridges, 1916; Panshin, 1935; Stern, 1929). In 90% of the translocations of the Y with the fourth chromosome, the males are sterile (Muller and Qershenson, 1935). Of 46 Y-4 translocations, Neuhaus (1939) found only eight which gave fertile males ; and, of these, four had chromosomal rearrangements more complex than a reciprocal Y-4 translocation. By analysis of the 38 R ( + ) sterile mutants, he concluded that there are ten genes affecting fertility, located near the ends of the arms of the Y chromosome, The fact that deficient Y or complete loss of Y results in sterility indicates that sterility is due to the loss of fertility genes. But XYYY males are also sterile (Cooper, 1949; Schultz, 1947), and there is some evidence that the XYYYY condition may be lethal (Cooper, 1949). Therefore sterility must be due to a balance of factors as well as to individual fertility genes. The relationship may be even more complex than either a balance or loss, however, since males deficient for most of the X but with a normal Y are fertile (Qershenson, 1933; SivertzevDobzhansky and Dobzhansky, 1933) ; males with certain aberrant Y
FIG. 3. Cytogenetic map of the eentromeric region of the second chromosome, showing location of mutants, Minutes, and genetic and cytological deficiencies.
0 Q B al Y
h
Lu
112
ALOHA HANNAH
chromosomes are fertile ; but deficient-X, aberrant-Y males are completely sterile (Schulte, 1947). ( 3 ) Autosmes. It was shown, for the X chromosome that probably the number of loci affected-the length of the sensitive region-in the R ( + ) mutants of the white-Notch region is primarily dependent on the position of the euchromatic break (Table l ) , but that deviations occur because of location of the break in the heterochromatic regions (Table 2 ) . If it is assumed that the length of the sensitive region in the euchromatic section is due to specific influences of heterochromatin, the regional differences in heterochromatin may be determined. In respect to autosomal heterochromatin, when the breaks of white-Notch R (+) mutants are before 3C5.6 and after 3C9.10 the expected phenotypes occur, namely, white and/or roughest in the first case, and white-Notch in the second. But four of the eight mutants with breaks between 3C5.6 and 3C9.10 are variegated for white as well as facet and Notch, and one shows roughest but not white variegation. Thus the autosomal heterochromatin does appear to have specific properties, and that of chromosome 2 may be more effective in initiating position effect and variegation than that of either 3 or 4. The heterochromatin in the right limb of the second chromosome is advantageous material for the study of heterochromatic effects, for a number of mutants are in this region, as well as a group of deficiencies and chromosomal changes giving position effect (Fig. 3 ) . The section usually considered heterochromatic is from 41A to 42A, although only 41A and B, and rarely 41C and D, form part of the chromocenter and show ectopic pairing with other heterochromatic regions. I n respect to expression of variegation in 41A, three of the six R (+) mutants not showing position effect of euchromatic loci were Y-2 translocations, and one was a white-diminutive-variegated mutant with the breaks of the white locus attached to 57/58, and the heterochromatin of the X attached to the heterochromatin of 2R. Eight had variegation phenotypes : one white-Notch, one roughest-Notch, one white-roughest, and two white; two brown; one clot-pied. In 41B, one was not tested and the other two were variegated, one white-diminutive and the other brown. 41C had only two, neither of which was tested. One mutant, a scute, which probably was not variegated, had its second break in 41D. Two breaks in 41E with position effect on the cut locus were not tested for variegation. Among the four mutants with breaks in 41F, the forked and scute were not variegated, and cut was not tested; the white was variegated, but as it also had a break in 41A the variegation effects may have been due to that break. Tests made with deficiencies of the 41-42 region (most of which
HETEROOHROMA’PIN IN DECOSOPHIZA M E Z A N O G A S T E R
113
show the Minute character) in compound with variegated mutants white, brown, Revolute) reveal that Minute (2) S-10 and Minute (2) D have an effect equivalent to that of removal of the Y chromosome, i.e., they enhance the variegation effect; and that duplications of this region suppress the variegation (Morgan, Schultz, and Curry, 1941). The Y chromosome, on the other hand, intensifies the Minute effect of Minutes-10. Analysis of the chromosomes of this mutant discloses that the salivaries are deficient for, at the most, only several bands in 41A, whereas there is a loss of from one-fifth to one-third of the right arm in mitotic chromosomes. The fourth chromosome is not heterochromatic in cytological terms, for it is not heteropycnotic (Kaufmann, 1934), but it does seem to have heterochromatic genetic properties (Schultz, 1939). Among 24 translocations involving the fourth chromosome, which displayed position effect on non-fourth-chromosome loci, 23 had variegation phenotypes. These breaks were scattered over the greater length of the fourth chromosome, although the majority were in 101 F. Either the nonvariegated mutants are not viable, all breaks are preferentially in heterochromatin, or the fourth chromosome is primarily heterochromatic in genetic action. I n the case of “reversions” the effect of heterochromatin seems to be somewhat different. Hinton (1950) found that in “reversion-mutants” of In(2LR)40d1the degree of reversion of the phenotype is correlated with the quantitative effect of the heterochromatin, and not all regions are equally effective in changing the phenotype. The heterochromatin of section 80, for example, acts as a euchromatic region. Four types of heterochromatin are suggested by the differences in effect : ( 1 ) heterochromatin that is visible in the salivaries and has a n inhibiting effect; ( 2 ) heterochromatin not visible in the salivaries, and inhibiting; ( 3 ) heterochromatin visible but not inhibiting ; and (4) the Y heterochromatin, which is not visible and not inhibiting. c. Comparsm of X , Y , and dutosomd Heterochrmatim. Heterochromatic regions in all the chromosomes are equally effective in initiating variegation of position-effect mutants with one break in the euchromatin and one break in the heterochromatin. Some regions display a more pronounced effect on the phenotypic expression of individual mutants, whereas others manifest an action which is primarily concerned with the length of the sensitive region from the euchromatic break. A direct comparison of quantitative effects of the different heterochromatic regions upon typical variegation mutants has not been feasible because of the numerous variables involved. Such a comparison, however, has been made for a fourth-chromosome mutant (not associated
114
ALOHA HANNAH
with a n interchromosomal exchange) which is sensitive to changes in heterochromatin balance (L. V. Morgan, 1947). This mutant, sparkling (spa), shows variegation, not in a single fly but between sibs and between