ADVANCES IN GENETICS VOLUME 16 Edited by E. W. CASPARI Department of Biology University of Rochester Rochester, New York...
24 downloads
1681 Views
24MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADVANCES IN GENETICS VOLUME 16 Edited by E. W. CASPARI Department of Biology University of Rochester Rochester, New York
1971 ACADEMIC PRESS
NEW YORK AND LONDON
COPYRIGHT 0 1971, BY ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED NO PART OF THIS BOOK MAY BE REPRODUCED IN A N Y FORM, BY PHOTOSTAT, MICROFILM, RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, OR ANY OTHER MEANS, WITHOUT WR-N PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHERS.
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC.
111 Fifth Avenue, New York, New
York 10003
United Kingdom Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. (LONDON) LTD.
24/28 Oval Road, Londoi NWl IDD
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOQ
CARD NUMBER:47-30313
PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
DEDICATION M. Demerec Editor of Advances in Genetics
About two years ago, I was approached by some of his former collaborators with the suggestion to dedicate a volume of Advances in Genetics to the memory of M. Demerec. I gladly accepted this proposal since it seems to me fitting that Advances in Genetics honor in this way the memory of its founder and the Editor of its first nine volumes. Demerec became concerned about the “information explosion” in the sciences long before it became a popular topic of complaint. H e was possibly more aware than others of the resulting lack of communication between scientists in different though related fields, because he himself refused to be confined by artificial boundaries, and changed the object of his research several times in his life. H e had thus to get acquainted with new techniques and with a completely new literature. Part of his prodigious energy was therefore devoted to various means by which communication between scientists active in different fields could be established and extended. The founding of Advances in Genetics was one of his main activities in this direction. It was particularly designed to make it possible for geneticists working in a particular area and with a particular organism to get acquainted with work done in other fields of genetics. H e writes in the Preface to Volume I (1947): This series of review articles, Advances in Genetics, has been started in order that critical summaries of outstanding genetic problems, written by competent geneticists, may appear in a single publication.The articles are expected to deal with both theoretical and practical problems, and to cover plant breeding, animal breeding, and human heredity, as well as the related fields of biophysics, biochemistry, physiology, and immunology. The aim is to have the articles written in such form that they will be useful as reference material for geneticists and also as a source of information to nongeneticists.
The way these stated goals were implemented can be seen from the contents of the volumes which appeared under Demerec’s editorship. They have continued to serve as guidelines for the editorial policies of Advances in Genetics. Y
vi
DEDICATION
The review papers contained in this volume have been prepared by friends and former collaborators of Demerec. They reflect, therefore, to a certain degree, his interests during the last half of his scientific life. But since his interests were always wide ranging, and encompassed the whole range of genetics, the articles contained in this volume are not much more uniform than those in other volumes of this series. We hope that this volume constitutes a fitting memorial to a great geneticist who, by his own work, and by stimulating and facilitating the work of other scientists, has deeply influenced the direction genetics has taken in the last twenty years, and has contributed greatly to the conspicuous progress of genetics during his lifetime. I want to thank sincerely those geneticists who, by their contributions to this volume or by service on the Editorial Committee, have helped to make the appearance of this volume possible. Particular recognition is due to Dr. A. Eisenstark who, as chairman of the Editorial Committee, contributed a great deal to the organization of this volume. It gives me great personal satisfaction to have collaborated on this tribute to a man I have always admired and esteemed as a great investigator, as an original thinker, as a resourceful and indefatigable organizer of scientific activities, and as a staunch, reliable friend. Ernst Caspari Rochester, New Yo& June 1971
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 16 Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors’ contributions begin.
BBUCEN. AM= ( l ) , Department of Biochemistry, University of California, Berkeley, California
L. ELIZABETH BERTANI(199) , Microbial Genetics Laboratory, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden
GIUSEPPM BERTANI(199) , Microbial Genetics Laboratory, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden
DONJ. BRENNER(81), Division of Biochemistry, Walter Reed Army and the Department of Institute of Research, Washington, D.C., Microbiology, Schools of Medicine and Dentistry, Georgetown University, Washington, D.C.
H. J. CURTIS(305) , Biology Department, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New York
A. EISENSTARK (167) , Division of Biology, Kansas State University, Manhattan., Kansas STANLEY FALKOW (81), Division of Biochemistry, Walter Reed Army Institute of Research, Washington, D.C., and the Department of Microbiology, Schools of Medicine and Dentistry, Georgetown University, Washington, D.C. PHILIPE. HARTMAN ( l ) , Department of Biology, The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland
ZLATAHARTMAN (1), Department of Biology, The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland
ROLLIND. HOTCHKISS (325) , The Rockefeller University, New Yorlc, New York RICHARD B. MIDDLETON* (53), Department of Biology, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada
* Present address: Faculty of Medicine, Memorial University, St. John’s, Newfoundland, Canada. xi
xii
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME
16
TOBIASMOJICA-A*(53), Department of Biology, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada HOWARD B. NEWCOMBE (239), Biology and Health Physics Division, Atomic Energy of Canada Limited, Chalk River, Ontario KENNETHE. SANDERSON (35),Department of Biology, T h e University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada D. A. SMITH(141), Genetics Department, University of Birmingham, England RUTHC. STAHL( l ) ,Department of Biology, T h e Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland H. E. UMBARGER (119) , Department of Biological Sciences, Purdue University, Lafayette, Indiana
* Present address: Polish Academy of Sciences, Institute of Biochemistry and Biophysics, 36 Rakowiecka Street, Warszawa 12, Poland.
M. Demerec
MlLlSLAV DEMEREC* (1895-1966) To Milislav Demerec, research in genetics was far more than a profession; it was his way of life. He lived it to his last hour. On April 12, 1966, he submitted a paper by two colleagues for publication in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. This day he spent mostly in discussing with a younger colleague the plans of work in his new laboratory a t the C. W. Post College of Long Island University. They parted around 8 P . M . ; a t about a quarter past nine Demerec was found dead in his study and bedroom. Milislav Demerec was born on January 11, 1895, at Kostajnica in Croatia (Yugoslavia), the third of eight children in a family of a school teacher, later a n inspector of schools. He attended a school in the town of Petrinja, where he lived with his grandfather and his aunts. Later he attended a high school (Realschule) in Zagreb, and the College of Agriculture a t Krifevci, near Zagreb. H e was an excellent student i n both, and upon his graduation was given the position of adjunct at the Krifevci Experiment Station, where he worked with the pioneer Croatian plantbreeder Professor B. Bohutinsky. The First World War was still going on, but Demerec was released from military service to work for a commission charged with purchasing foodstuffs for the civilian population. After the Armistice, he obtained a small scholarship t o study at the College of Agriculture in Grignon, France. He attended the lectures of Professors Ducomet, Scribeaux, and Crepin, and made short visits to the Institute for Agricultural Research in Versailles and the famous plant-breeding establishment of Vilmorin in Verier, France. I n 1919 Demerec became a graduate student a t the Department of Plant Breeding, Cornell University. He joined the group of investigators working on the genetics of maize under the leadership of Professor R. A. Emerson. This was one of the most active centers of research in genetics in the United States. It produced several outstanding geneticists in addition to Demerec, among them G. W. Beadle, M. M. Rhoades, and B. McClintock. Demerec was awarded his Ph.D. degree in 1923, having by then published four articles and notes on the genetics of maize, the number rising to fifteen by 1927. These early publications
* Reprinted through the courtesy of the Year Book of the American Philosophical Society, 1966,pp. 115-121. xv
mi
OBITUARY
already show the personal style which was to be the earmark of Demerec’s writing to the end of his career-abundance of exact and carefully recorded observations and experiments, thoughtful analysis, avoidance of hasty speculation and theorizing, and austerely economical use of words, which made his writings err occasionally on the side of abridgment but never on the side of prolixity. I n summers of 1920 and 1921 Demerec visited the Marine Biological Laboratory in Woods Hole, where he met C. W. Metz and members of the school of T. H. Morgan, working on the genetics of Drosophila. He was fascinated with this, new to him, material for genetic experimentation. In 1923 he joined Metz, as resident investigator a t the Department of Genetics, Carnegie Institution of Washington, at Cold Spring Harbor, on Long Island. He became assistant director in 1942, and was its director from 1943 to 1960. In 1941 he added also the directorship of the neighboring, in fact the adjacent, research institution, the Biological Laboratory of the Long Island Biological Association, remaining in this post likewise until 1960. Demerec’s dedication to, and his identification with Cold Spring Harbor and with the scientific research institutions of which he became a member and eventually a leader, were quite extraordinary. The genius loci took firm possession of him, or it is perhaps more accurate to say that he became that genius personified. Although, especially in later years, Demerec traveled rather widely in the United States and abroad, no spot anywhere in the world was to him a worthy rival of Cold Spring Harbor in attractiveness as a place to live and to work (and, of course, to live and to work were synonyms). No work hours were too onerous, no kind of work and no detail were to be avoided or overlooked, if they helped his beloved laboratories. His directorships were, quite literally, full-time occupations. Demerec worked successfully on many research problems and on diverse materials. After his early studies on maize, he took up the study of mutable genes in Drosophila virilis and in the larkspur, Delphinium ajacis. Some of these genes were observed to mutate only in somatic cells, others only in germ cells, and still others in both. This led logically to a series of investigations of radiation-induced mutations in the genes and the chromosomes in Drosophila melanogaster. Together with H. Fricke he studied the mutability under the influence of X-rays of different wave lengths, with M. E. Hoover the effects of deficiencies of small groups of genes or of single genes (discovering the so-called “cell lethals”), with B. P. Kaufmann and H . Bauer the nature and frequency of radiation-induced chromosomal changes. The Second World War presented the challenge of research to help the war effort. With Demerec’s help, E. R. Sansome undertook induction of mutations in the mold Peni-
OBITUARY
xvii
cillium, selecting those which were increasing the yield of penicillin. They were quite successful in this endeavor. I n the late 1930’s and early 1940’s Demerec began to look for materials for mutation studies in which very large numbers of individuals could be observed. Microorganisms naturally suggested themselves. Max Delbruck and Salvador Luria, then “enemy aliens,” came to Cold Spring Harbor in 1941 to work jointly on bacteria and bacteriophages. I n 1943 they published their classical studies on mutations which confer a resistance to the attack of bacteriophages on colon bacteria, Escherichia coli. Demerec and Fano were quick to appreciate the advantages of the Luria-Delbruck experimental procedures, and published in 1944 preliminary accounts and in 1945 detailed reports of their experiments on bacteriophage resistance in bacteria. From then on, Demerec worked almost exclusively in the rapidly growing field of the genetics of microorganisms. Mutations which make bacteria resistant to such antibiotics as penicillin and streptomycin, then coming into general use in medical practice, engaged his attention during the late forties. Somewhat later came a series of works on the influence of certain chemical substances on the mutability of bacteria. The main result was that different mutagens (mutation-inducing agents) increase the mutability of different genes in different proportions. This phenomenon still awaits its explanation. During the last decade of his life, Demerec showed again his undiminished ability to shift to new objects and new methods. His main and enduring interest, which runs through his entire scientific life, remained the same: The phenomena of mutation and the gene theory. However, he now worked with biochemical mutants of Salmonella typhimurium, using the method of transduction to analyze the hereditary materials in this organism. Together with numerous collaborators, among them one of his two daughters, Zlata Demerec (Mrs. P. E. Hartman), he made elegant studies of complex loci in Salmonella. Most interesting has been the discovery that, at least in this organism, the functionally related genes are often clustered together in the same part of the chromosome. The list of Demerec’s publications up to 1965 contains some 205 titles, and some papers are still in press. Demerec was Secretary-Treasurer of the Genetics Society of America, 1935-1937, its Vice-President in 1938, and President in 1939; Treasurer of the American Society of Naturalists in 1933-1935, Vice-president in 1947-1949, and President in 1954; member of eight different committees of the National Research Council at various times between 1940 and 1953 ; member of the International Committee of the International Genetics Congress from 1939 to 1953; Chairman of the section of Zoology
xviii
OBITUARY
and Anatomy of the National Academy of Sciences from 1958 to 1961; member of various other committees, editorial boards of scientific journals, and active participant in meetings, symposia, and congresses too numerous to mention. Together with C. B. Bridges he founded “Drosophila Information Service,” the prototype of several such bulletins sent periodically, usually free of charge, to workers studying a given material or problem. He continued to be the editor of this “D.I.S.” long after he himself abandoned active research on Drosophila, in fact until his retirement from Cold Spring Harbor in 1960. Already in the 1930’s Demerec planned a book, Biology of Drosophila, chapters of which were to be written by a series of authors, some of whom came to Cold Spring Harbor to do the necessary studies. As so often happens with such collective works, some chapters were delayed so long that the book was published only in 1950 (by John Wiley, New York). Yet the book had a success, being a manual which any student of Drosophila needs. The book soon went out of print, and a new printing was issued in 1965. From 1947 to 1958, Demerec edited nine volumes of Advances in Genetics, a series of publications of considerable importance in the development of modern genetics. Another undertaking which was destined to play an important role in the development of genetics started modestly in 1945, when M. Delbruck gave his first “bacteriophage course” to summer visitors, some of whom were coming regularly or occasionally to Cold Spring Harbor to work at the Biological Laboratory, using the laboratory facilities and the helpful hospitality extended by Demerec. This and related courses soon became a regular feature of the summer activities a t this Laboratory, together with the more formal Symposia on Quantitative Biology. These Symposia were initiated earlier, in 1933, but they developed under Demerec’s sponsorship and have been held annually since 1941, each symposium resulting in the publication of a rather awkwardly large red-bound volume, now found in libraries of most institutions where genetics research is carried on, as well as in the personal libraries of many geneticists. Demerec’s organizing ability and good judgment attracted to these symposia at one time or another probably all, or a t least most, of the outstanding geneticists and evolutionists living in the United States, and many foreign ones. Topics ranging from biophysics, biochemistry, embryology, molecular, microbial, population, and evolutionary genetics, to ecology, demography, and anthropology have all had their places in these symposia. Many an important discovery, including the now celebrated Watson-Crick model of the structure of DNA, was first discussed in these Cold Spring Harbor Symposia and the summer courses following the Symposia.
OBITUARY
XiX
For nineteen years, from 1941 to 1960, Demerec carried a heavy load of administrative duties, directing two scientific institutions, as well as the manifold responsibilities of editorships, committee memberships, etc. What is most remarkable and admirable is that, carrying this load, he not only did not abandon his personal research work but much of this research continued to be done with his own hands and eyes, rather than by technicians and assistants. Demerec was a master of the gentle art of “grantsmanship”; in a sense he was, fashionably, one of the scientific “empire builders”; but he was one of the few of these (personally, I know of no other) who managed at the same time to remain an active, practicing, research worker in his own right, as well as a busy administrator. Some of his friends wondered how he accomplished this feat, which many beginning administrators hope to accomplish but few actually do. A part of the answer is that the field of his interests became narrower and more specialized as time went on. I n his thirties, Demerec had a living interest in all branches of genetics and a broad understanding of the whole field. As genetics grew by leaps and bounds, he was able to learn new ideas and new methods; a t the same time he developed some blind spots. This was, however, not the whole story. By far the most important component of this story was Demerec’s total dedication to science, which dominated his personality to the end of his life. So complete it was, that it virtually eliminated small talk; Demerec was able to spend an evening in a friendly gathering without uttering a word, and yet enjoying the company! He was not a t all taciturn in scientific or organizational discussions. I n 1921 Demerec married Mary Alexander Ziegler, who survives him, as do their two daughters, Mrs. Philip E. Hartman and Mrs. Neville Dyson-Hudson. One of Demerec’s most engaging personal qualities was his kindness, which led him to trust people sometimes rather indiscriminately. H e made some unfortunate appointments and overoptimistic plans. Upon his retirement from administrative posts in 1960, he was unable t o continue his work in his beloved Cold Spring Harbor laboratories. To terminate his research was to him unthinkable. The Brookhaven National Laboratory came to the rescue, made him Senior Geneticist, and enabled him to work happily with a small group of enthusiastic collaborators for five years (1960-1965). He continued, however, to live in his house near Cold Spring Harbor, and the daily commuting to Brookhaven was increasingly becoming a strain, especially as his health began to weaken. His spirit was not weakening, however, and neither was his enthusiasm for genetics research. He accepted a research professorship a t the C. W. Post College, and proceeded to organize another new laboratory; the
xx
OBITUARY
laboratory was beginning to function when death came with merciful suddenness. Demerec had his share of academic honors. He was, in addition to being a member in the American Philosophical Society (elected in 1952), a member of the National Academy of Sciences, the Yugoslav Academy of Sciences, Royal Danish Academy of Sciences, Genetics Society of Japan, Society of Biology of Chile, and served his turn as president of the Genetics Society of America and the American Society of Naturalists. He received the Kimber Genetics Medal of the National Academy of Sciences, and honorary doctorates from Hofstra College, the University of Zagreb, and Long Island University.
Theodosius Dobzhanslcy
With his daughter, Mrs. Rada Dyson-Hudson
MlLlSLAV DEMEREC* (1895-1966)
I n 1919, when a certain young Yugoslav agricultural student came
to Cornell University to pursue graduate study in genetics under R. A.
Emerson, the first great decade of American genetical studies was just drawing to a close. The ensuing four and a half decades, to the very time of his recent death, have been identified with Milislav Demerec’s own career and contributions as with few others. H e was among the dozen or so giants whose work has made the United States preeminent in this biological science. His own contributions reflected not only good judgment in recognizing the most important problems but astounding initiative and flexibility in shifting from one area of significance to another, a t the cost of abandoning tried techniques and acquiring skill in entirely new ones. Yet equally important to the advancement of science, have been his services as scientific leader and administrator. Even the briefest account must not ignore their value. Demerec began his genetic investigations with a study of the basis of variable phenotypic traits. The striping of leaves and the variegations of maize seeds and the virescence of seedlings that at first are albino but later turn green evoked in him a deep interest in the basis of somatic mosaicism. Suspecting somatic mutation to be a prevalent cause of such changes, he very early directed attention to this phenomenon, and shifted from maize to Drosophila virilis and to delphiniums as appropriate organisms for probing the nature of the factors that control mutation rates. His classic papers on the unstable genes of Drosophila virilis remain basic to an understanding of the mutation process. A second period in Demerec’s genetic investigations began with the study of X-ray-induced mutations and deficiencies in Drosophila in the early 1930’s. Here, too, an interest in the role of gene mutation in ontogeny was evident, since one of his most important early contributions to this new area was the relation of induced deficiencies to cell lethality. With the introduction of salivary gland chromosome analysis, the work on deficiencies and other types of chromosome aberrations advanced *Reprinted through the courtesy of the Cold Spring Harbor Symposium on Qwntitative Biology ~~:XXI-XXII. xxiii
xxiv
OBITUARY
rapidly, in collaboration first with Margaret Hoover, and later with B. P. Kaufmann, Eileen Sutton, and others. Demerec’s interest in the factors controlling spontaneous mutability was not lost, however. From this period date also those extremely significant studies of the differences in mutability in various wild-type strains of Drosophila melanogaster, and the identification of a mutability-stimulating gene in the Florida stock. By the 1940’s, Demerec was studying the effects of ultraviolet radiation and of neutrons in inducing gene mutations and chromosome aberrations, but the advent of the phage group, which summered in Cold Spring Harbor for the first time in 1941, and the practical demands of World War 11, brought about a shift of activity in his laboratory a t Cold Spring Harbor. Of enormous practical importance was the work performed to induce, in Penicillium, mutations that would increase the yield of penicillin. Of greater long range value were the parallel studies of mutations evoking resistance on the part of Staphylococcus to penicillin and other antibiotic agents or to drugs. The 1945 paper of Demerec and Ugo Fano on bacteriophage-resistant mutants in Escherichia coli marked a definite change in direction in Demerec’s work. B y the end of the 1940’s Drosophila studies had been fully replaced by studies of chemical mutagens and their effects on the genes of bacteria, especially in relation to mutations promoting bacterial resistance. This work in turn led, in the 1950’s, to the studies that were to occupy Demerec until the end, namely, the investigation of recombination and the fine structure of the gene in Salmonella. Independently, and in collaboration with Philip Hartman and others, Demerec analyzed the functional organization of the bacterial chromosome and discovered a remarkable parallelism between the sequence of genes and the sequence of steps in a biosynthetic chain. Aside from his earliest scientific studies while a graduate student, and his years following retirement, which were spent a t the Brookhaven National Laboratory and a t C. W. Post College, all of Demerec’s long career was identified with Cold Spring Harbor, from the first day in 1923 when he arrived as a fresh Ph.D. to join the staff of the Department of Genetics of the Carnegie Institution of Washington, to the day in 1960 when he retired as Director of both the Carnegie Institution’s Department of Genetics and of the Long Island Biological Laboratory. I n the span of nearly forty years of activity, Demerec had not only made scientific contributions that earned him membership in the National Academy of Sciences, the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, the American Philosophical Society; and honorary memberships in the British Genetical Society, Yugoslav Academy of Sciences, and the
OBITUARY
XXV
Royal Danish Academy, as well as the highest award among geneticists, the Kimber Medal (1962), he had also made Cold Spring Harbor a worldwide focus of inspiration and leadership in genetics. This role began when he became Director of the Biological Laboratory in 1941, and in 1943 Director of the Carnegie Institution’s Department of Genetics. The close and fruitful collaboration of the two neighboring biological institutions thus started toward the fusion that eventually took place. The outstanding series of Cold Spring Harbor Symposia on Quantitative Biology brought scientists from all over the world to engage in relaxed, informal conversations on the sandspit and the veranda of Blackford Hall, as well as in the formal sessions where interesting and sometimes epochal papers were presented and discussed. From 1941, when the symposium on “Genes and Chromosomes” was held, until the year of his retirement, it was chiefly the foresight and wisdom of Milislav Demerec in choosing subjects of most timely interest, selecting participants of worldwide eminence, organizing the program, and editing the proceedings that made Cold Spring Harbor in June the mecca of genetic biology, where genetics, evolution, and biochemistry came together in fruitful interaction. Stimulating contacts spread through the summer as visiting research workers exchanged ideas with each other and with members of the permanent staffs of the Biological Laboratory and the Carnegie Institution. At least one visitor can testify that he never worked harder than during those summers and never had a better vacation for himself and his family than in those years when Cold Spring Harbor was a summer home and laboratory. By judicious appointments to the research staffs of the two institutions, Demerec kept the spearheads of investigation probing into significant new fields. Especially noteworthy was the arrival of A. D. Hershey in 1950. Cold Spring Harbor had already become a center of the phage group. Summer meetings had led in 1945 to the establishment of a special summer course for instruction in the theory and techniques of genetic investigation with bacterial viruses. A parallel summer course in the genetics of bacteria was started in 1955. These and later additions to the summer courses have made Cold Spring Harbor the biaological center where germinated much of the work that resulted in present-day microbial and viral genetics. Somehow, year after year, Demerec made this possible on a financial shoestring. The Carnegie Institution provided new laboratories for its own staff, and grants were obtained to support the permanent staff of the Biological Laboratory and the summer courses, and to maintain the charming but ancient buildings. Year after year local friends of the Cold Spring Harbor community were encouraged to help maintain the Laboratory through their gifts. The scientific community throughout
xxvi
OBITUARY
the United States was canvassed. I n mysterious ways, and with real courage, for two decades Demerec found the means not only to keep the summer programs and the year-round research going, but to expand them in significant directions of the new molecular biology that was springing into being. Demerec served the scientific community in many ways. For twenty years he helped to organize the International Congresses of Genetics, both as a member of the Permanent International Committee and as a member of Organizing and Program Committees. H e filled every office, including that of president, in the Genetics Society of America. H e was treasurer and later president of the American Society of Naturalists. He served on the U.S. Committee of the International Union of Biological Sciences and on the Committee on the Genetic Effects of Atomic Radiation of the National Academy of Sciences. H e served as chairman of the Section of Zoology and Anatomy of the National Academy of Sciences. He started Drosophila Information Service, the first of the professional newsletters and information services in genetics; and he established the Drosophila stock center a t Cold Spring Harbor in the Carnegie Department of Genetics, the first of such stock centers to maintain the important experimental stocks of Drosophila and to supply them to Drosophila workers around the world. H e founded the series Advances in Genetics (Academic Press) and served as editor for nine volumes, from 1947 through 1958; and he served on the editorial boards of several genetical journals. Yet in the end those of us who knew him well will remember him as the characteristic spirit and impulse of Cold Spring Harbor, the man who made it a nerve center of modern genetics.
H . Bentley Glass
With Dr. Richard 0. Goldschmidt
MlLlSLAV DEMEREC* (1895-1966)
We mourn Dr. M. Demerec’s sudden death. It was reported that Dr. Demerec had passed away suddenly, though it was a cheerful day in the middle of April. We have lost another very great geneticist who was one of the pioneers in genetics. This follows Dr. F. Ryan’s sudden death of just three years ago. Dr. Demerec has made a great contribution to the Genetics Society of Japan as an honorary member. Also, many Japanese researchers working a t the present time were recipients of his kind and valuable comments. With these persons, we would like to look back upon Dr. Demerec’s biographical sketch, scientific achievements, and so on . . . with prayers for the repose of his soul from the bottom of our hearts. The New York Times reported Dr. Demerec’s death with this headline : Dr. Milislav Demerec, 71, Dies; Discoverer of Mutable Genes. H e was over 70 years old, although it was quite difficult t o realize this since he still looked very active. Dr. Demerec was born in Kostajnica in Yugoslavia in 1895. He was educated a t an agricultural college in KriBevci in that country and then studied in France. When he was 24 years old, in 1919, he went to the United States to study the genetics of corn as a Research Assistant a t Cornell University. When he was awarded his Ph.D. from Cornell University, in 1923, he was appointed Resident Investigator in the Genetics Department at the Carnegie Institution a t Cold Spring Harbor i n New York State. He had worked a t the Institution for 37 years, until he retired a t the age of 65, in 1960. During this time, he received United States citizenship, in 1931, and he served as Director of the Institution for 17 years, 1943-1960. Furthermore, he served as a Director of the Long Island Biological Laboratories adjacent t o the Carnegie Institution from 1941 to 1960, and held an additional post as an Associate in Genetics at Columbia University. Retiring from the Carnegie Institution in 1960, he was appointed Senior Geneticist a t Brookhaven National Laboratory in New York State, and worked solely as a researcher for the rest of his life, leaving most of his other responsible positions. And he just recently organized a new laboratory at C. W. Post *Reprinted through the courtesy of the Japanese J o u m l of Genetics, 41:25& 251. Translation by Ikuo Ino. xxix
xxx
OBITUARY
College on Long Island, planning to continue his research activity in the future. However, unfortunately, he passed away on the night of April 12th a t his peaceful home, surrounded by trees, near Cold Spring Harbor. It was said, also, he was so active that he even attended a party taking place just before he passed away. The time must have come suddenly and peacefully. Dr. Demerec was member of the National Academy of Sciences, the American Philosophical Society, the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, the Genetics Society of America, and other societies and academies. He was also awarded many honors for his remarkable studies in genetics. It might be appropriate to mention the following honors: Honorary Degree of Doctor of Humanities, given by Hofstra College in 1957 for his role in developing techniques to obtain higher yields of penicillin through mutation ; the Kimber Genetics Medal, awarded by the National Academy of Sciences in 1962. As we can see in Dr. Demerec’s research achievements, he has changed his experimental materials from corn to Drosophila to microbes, e.g., E . coli and Salmonella, each of which had advantages for study a t the time. However, his main interest was concentrated on one main problem, that is, the clarification of the nature of the gene. As we can see from the headline of the New York Times mentioned above, he discovered and studied mutable genes. He also made studies of mutation and of fine structure of genes in bacteria by using transduction techniques, and he greatly contributed toward establishing a concept of the gene as a functional unit (i.e., cistron) through pseudoallelism. Furthermore, he found that genes with related biochemical functions tend to be adjacent on the chromosome, and these findings were linked to the Operon Theory proposed later. In this manner, with some resolution of gene structure, one of his interests moved to the genetic structure of the whole bacterial chromosome. Comparing the genetic maps of the chromosomes of E. coli and Salmonella, he found that the arrangements of the genes are similar; nevertheless there are various grades in homology among species for genes with corresponding functions. In his last paper, he discussed the problems of evolution in bacteria by summarizing these results. This relatively short paper, evidence of a distinguished career in research, must have stimulated new ideas (Demerec, M. 1965. Gene Differentiation, Nat. Cancer Inst. Monogr. 18, 15-20). Furthermore, we cannot remember Dr. Demerec without thinking of the many young Japanese researchers, including the authors, who, not long after graduation from college, were introduced to microbial genetics by his kindness a t either the Carnegie Institution or a t Brookhaven National Laboratory. We will list these Japanese researchers in our
OBITUARY
xxxi
memory. I n 1953, Takashi Yura (1953-1955) was first introduced to Dr. Demerec by Prof. Hitoshi Kihara who was then a t Kyoto University, and was followed by Haruo Ozeki (1955-1957), Tadashi Miyake (1957-1959), Kazuo Hashimoto (1957-1958), Jun-ichi Ishidsu (19591961) , Kiyoshi Mizobuchi (1960-1961), Yasuo Nishioka (1961-1963), Norika Ohta (1962-1964), Ikuo Ino (1965 to the present), Hiraku Itikawa (1965 to the present). I n this way, we have been obliged to him always. We should like to thank Dr. Demerec sincerely for giving an opportunity to study abroad to these young, unknown researchers, for introducing them to the study of microbial genetics, and also for giving them an opportunity to see personally many internationally outstanding scientists. When he was the Director a t the Carnegie Institution, visiting Japanese researchers a t Cold Spring Harbor were too plentiful to enumerate. I n any event, we will make a list of the names of visitors who stayed for several weeks or months and who we can recall when the authors were staying there: Drs. Itaru Watanabe (1955), Tetsuo Iino (1956), Hisao Uetake (1957), Tsunehisa Amano (1957), Tsutomu Watanabe (1957) , Chozo Oshima (1957) , Hideo Kikkawa (1958), Tadao Horiuchi (1959) , and also Jun-ichi Tomizawa (1956-1958) and Teiichi Minagawa (1958-1959), both of whom were working on phages in the laboratory of Dr. A. D. Hershey, and Japanese researchers in Dr. B. P. Kaufmann’s laboratory. These persons have a pleasing memory of Cold Spring Harbor. All those listed above, and many others, have been obliged to Dr. Demerec directly or indirectly. We would like to pray for the repose of Dr. Demerec’s soul with these persons again. We were looking forward to seeing Dr. Demerec and to talking with him cheerfully again a t the International Congress of Genetics which will take place two years from now in Japan. Unfortunately, it is now impossible. Nevertheless, we should like to wish sincerely that Dr. M. Demerec could watch the development of genetical studies in the future, if possible even from the other world.
Jun-ichi Ishidsu Haruo Ozeki Tadashi Miyalce Takashi Yura
With Sir Alexander Fleming
MlLlSLAV DEMEREC* (1895-1966) Milislav Demerec died suddenly on April 12, 1966, a t his home in Laurel Hollow, New York. He was seventy-one years old. Dr. Demerec was born in Yugoslavia, and began his scientific training there. His graduate work was done at Cornell University, in Ithaca, New York, where he obtained the Ph.D. degree in 1923. I n the same year, he joined the staff of the Department of Genetics of the Carnegie Institution of Washington, in Cold Spring Harbor, New York, remaining there until his retirement in 1960. In 1941, he was appointed Director of the neighboring Biological Laboratory, and Acting Director of the Carnegie Institution’s Department of Genetics. Two years later, he became Director of the Department of Genetics, and served as head of both units until 1960. After his retirement, Dr. Demerec continued to live in the Cold Spring Harbor area, while carrying on his research a t the Brookhaven National Laboratory, in Upton, New York. In January, 1966, he became Research Professor in Biology a t the C. W. Post College of Long Island University, and was engaged in organizing his new laboratories there a t the time of his death. Dr. Demerec contributed richly to the growth of genetics, not only through his own extensive research, but also through his key role in the development of the Cold Spring Harbor laboratories as a world center for progress in genetics. It was an extraordinary accomplishment to combine an active career as an investigator with the burden of administering as complex an institution as the Cold Spring Harbor laboratories. Even for a man of Dr. Demerec’s unusual stamina, the normal working day could not encompass all that he had to do. His solution was to arise, most days, a t about four A. M., and to make use of the early morning hours for tasks requiring concentration-planning research, writing papers, studying data. By the time most of the other staff members were starting work, Dr. Demerec had been in action for four or five hours. Dr. Demerec’s characteristic style of approaching scientific or administrative problems was a unique blend of optimism and energy that often
* Reprinted through the courtesy of Mutation Research 4, 237-239. xxxvii
xxxviii
OBITUARY
worked wonders. Not many other geneticists of his generation, trained and experienced entirely in the methods and materials of classical genetics, were intrepid enough to plunge into work with microorganisms in the forties. Dr. Demerec had sensitive antennae for new directions in genetics, and his appreciation of the possibilities of work with bacteria and viruses helped to catalyze the explosive development of microbial genetics that began about twenty-five years ago. He was not content, however, with merely encouraging and providing facilities for such pioneers as Max Delbriick and Salvador Luria. Converting a part of his Drosophila quarters into a microbiological laboratory, he was soon himself entrenched in the new avant garde, carrying on an active program of experiments with Escherichia coli, and going on to make some of his most important scientific contributions as a bacterial geneticist. Dr. Demerec’s earliest work was on the inheritance of chlorophyll characters in maize, initially as part of the intensive investigation of linkage relationships being carried out by Professor R. A. Emerson a t Cornell University. While still engaged in this work, he began to look for an experimental approach to the nature of the gene, always to him the most fascinating question of all. He was attracted by the possibilities of variegated characters in plants, which Emerson had proposed might be due to “unstable genes.” Since no way was yet known to alter genes experimentally, and since changes in ordinary “stable” genes were rare, the study of variegation seemed to Dr. Demerec a promising approach. At Cold Spring Harbor, while continuing his work with maize, he began an intensive study of “unstable genes” in Delphinium, and later in Drosophilia virilis. At the same time, he tried repeatedly to find a way to increase mutation rates by experimental treatments of various kinds. Although these efforts were not successful, they explain the eagerness with which he welcomed the new tool of X-ray induction of mutations discovered in 1927 by Muller. Using Drosophila melanogaster, he studied the frequency and types of changes induced by X-rays a t 22 loci of the X-chromosome. In 1933, in a lecture entitled W h a t Is a Gene?, he described his concept of the gene as a complex organic molecule, within which different kinds of chemical rearrangements were responsible for different allelic states. I n what now seems a remarkable flash of intuition, he used a diagram of the molecular structure of thymus nucleic acid (as it was believed to be in 1933) to illustrate the kind of complex organic molecule a gene might be. During the latter thirties, Dr. Demerec continued to work mainly with Drosophila, correlating X-ray induced lethal mutations with cytologically observable changes in salivary-gland chromosomes, and adding important data to the growing body of information about position
OBITUARY
XXXiX
effects. His work was never far from the most advanced frontier in genetics. His contributions were solid and substantial. I n 1941, Dr. Demerec took over the leadership of the Cold Spring Harbor laboratories. Without slackening the pace of his own work, he began the formidable task of molding the two laboratories into a smoothly functioning unit, which soon became a gathering-place for geneticists from all over the world, and a center from which some of the most exciting discoveries of our time were to emanate. He did not readily delegate authority, even in small matters, and concerned himself as intensely with the clipping of hedges and painting of sheds as with the planning of experiments and organizing of Symposia, shifting gears easily from one kind of problem to another. Partly owing to this devotion to details, the Cold Spring Harbor center bore Dr. Demerec’s personal stamp in countless ways, not the least of which was the atmosphere of friendly informality in which he believed that science could best thrive. During World War 11, Dr. Demerec gave much time and energy to the war effort, supervising (among others) a project aimed a t improving the yield of antibiotics from molds. During this period, too, he played a major part in the birth of bacterial and bacteriophage genetics, starting with his invitation to Max Delbriick to participate in the 1941 Cold Spring Harbor Symposium. With Dr. Demerec’s enthusiastic support, the “phage group” adopted Cold Spring Harbor as unofficial summer headquarters, and as a training center for new recruits. The spectacular progress made by this group, and by others working in microbial genetics, was reported a t the 1946 Cold Spring Harbor Symposium, one of the most historic of the series of memorable meetings organized by Dr. Demerec. B y this time, he had made an active ‘start on his own work with bacteria, having done some of the earliest experiments on radiation-induced mutations in E . coli. For a while, he worked on both Drosophila and E . coli, gradually increasing his involvement in the bacterial work. His contributions include studies of spontaneous and induced mutations to bacteriophage-resistance, to resistance to antibiotics and to prototrophy. In much of this work, he developed basic methods still widely used in bacterial mutation studies. He worked also on chemical mutagenesis, and made important observations on “mutagen-stability.” I n 1954, only six years before his retirement, Dr. Demerec began the work that seems certain to be considered his most valuable scientific contribution. Once again exhibiting the flexibility that characterized his approach to research, he decided to work with Salmonella typhimurium, in order to make use of the newly discovered tool of genetics transduction. In these studies, he provided the first direct evidence for intracis-
XI
OBITUARY
tronic recombination in bacteria, and for the clustering of genes determining functionally related enzymes. Far from slowing down after his retirement, Dr. Demerec continued, literally until the day he died, to pursue with vigor and enthusiasm the implications of these important discoveries. His latest work includes studies of the fine structure of certain genes, of the evolutionary significance of fine-structure differences between homologous genes in different bacterial species, and of the phenomenon of “selfing” in transduction. Dr. Demerec enjoyed gardening, boating on Long Island Sound, and talking shop ; he disliked conventional social gatherings, practical jokes and displays of emotion. He was embarrassed by his many honors, which included the Kimber Genetics Award, election to the National Academy of Sciences and to the Presidency of the Genetics Society of America. He served genetics well, and his life and work are a part of its story forever. Evelyn M . Witkin
With Dr. Bernard D. Davis
MlLlSLAV DEMEREC* (1895-1966) Milislav Demerec was an outstanding geneticist. He was the Director of the world-famous laboratories a t Cold Spring Harbor (The Biological Laboratory and the Department of Genetics of the Carnegie Institution of Washington) during what might easily prove to be their Golden Era. Furthermore, he was a kind and good person. He died on April 12, 1966. Dr. Demerec was a quiet-nay, silent-man. Thus, despite eleven years association with him, I know remarkably little about his early life; the few facts that are known are to be found in his own curriculum vitae or must be learned from his friend of early school days, Alojz TavEar of Zagreb. I n brief, he was born a t Kostajnica, Croatia (Jugoslavia) on January 11, 1895. He attended high school and college in or near Zagreb. Following World War I he attended the College of Agriculture a t Grignon, France and then became a student of R. A. Emerson a t the College of Agriculture, Cornell University. After obtaining his degree in 1923 for work on the genetics of maize, he went to Cold Spring Harbor as a staff member a t the Department of Genetics, Carnegie Institution of Washington; it was this laboratory of which he was Director from 1943 until 1960. Somewhat earlier, in 1941, he had acquired the directorship of the physically adjacent laboratory, The Biological Laboratory-a position he also held until 1960. Following his retirement from the laboratories a t Cold Spring Harbor, he was appointed Senior Geneticist at the Brookhaven National Laboratory for a period of five years. At the age of 71, while organizing a new laboratory a t C. W. Post College, he died. To know these details is not to know Dr. Demerec. H e was, as I said, a quiet man. I n part, he was shy; in part, preoccupied with his own thoughts. During evening parties a t his home, he wanted no more than to have the conversation and activity involve everyone else while he, silent but contented, sat to one side in his favorite chair. What experiments were planned, what sources of funds were identified, what symposia topics were selected, or what committee business was organized during these social evenings only Dr. Demerec knew. Promptly a t ten
* Reprinted through bhe courtmy of Genetics 87:13. xxxiii
xxxiv
OBITUARY
o’clock, if no senior guest had already done so, Dr. Demerec would arise, look a t the clock with a startled exclamation, and announce that the morrow was coming. And so the evening would end. Dr. Demerec was physically a strong man. His day began before six each morning working a t his house-gardening in the spring and summer, otherwise going over data or papers in his study. As Director of two laboratories, he arrived on the grounds a t eight with the first workers, supervised the work schedules, discussed financial matters, listened to and commented on new experimental data described by various colleagues and staff members he happened to encounter, went over carefully the data from his own laboratory staff; and, in addition, carried out the multitude of other tasks that fell on his shoulders either through committee work, editorial duties, or the affairs of various scientific societies and congresses. He was an exceptionally well-organized man but that in itself was not enough, he needed, and possessed, tremendous physical stamina to withstand this routine work load. One of his remarkable abilities was that which enabled Demerec to evaluate a problem, reach a decision, and then to put the matter out of his mind. This ability reduced the strain of supervising the day-byday operations on the laboratory grounds, of supervising the housing and dining of hundreds of summer guests, and of assuming responsibility for the research efforts of numerous post-doctoral fellows and research associates. In each of these matters, he serenely did the best he could do under the circumstances and then refused to fret over what might otherwise have been. The Cold Spring Harbor Symposia on Quantitative Biology were Dr. Demerec’s special joy. With the exception of the periodically recurrent topic, The Gene, suggestions for appropriate subjects came from his many friends and colleagues ; he invariably favored those proposals that were just beyond what a t the moment was fashionable research. His only instruction to the members of each year’s Program Committee was for them to prepare the ideal program as if unlimited funds were at their disposal ; raising funds for these meetings was his responsibility and, should he fail to find enough, it was then that the program would be modified. He had a complete and well-justified faith that funds are easier to find for excellent symposia than for mediocre ones. The only foreign scientist who could not be brought to the meetings a t Cold Spring Harbor despite Demerec’s repeated efforts was J. B. S. Haldane; federal regulations concerning visas effectively barred Haldane’s entry into the country. Ironically, Haldane finally came to the United States to participate in a symposium sponsored by the space agency. The summer courses, including the nature study course for children
OBITUARY
xxxv
of the scientific and neighborhood communities, were also a source of great pride to Dr. Demerec. The Phage Course, first under the direction of Max Delbruck and then for many years under that of the late Mark Adams, was in many respects the birthplace of molecular genetics. The talent that was involved in P. U. (Phage University) a t one time or another during Demerec’s years a t Cold Spring Harbor is nearly unbelievable; four Nobel Laureates come to mind immediately but the list of truly superb research men who passed through this course would be at least twenty times as great. The physical nature of the gene remained throughout Dr. Demerec’s life his main research problem. During the course of his work he passed with deceptive ease from maize t o delphiniums to flies and to microorganisms leaving behind a body of excellent data in the literature on each. The climax of his work was undoubtedly the finding that the linear arrangement of genes (Demerec was reluctant to adopt new terminology such as “cistron”) controlling tryptophan synthesis in Salmonella typhimurium corresponds to the order of biochemical reactions that these genes mediate. “The assembly line has finally been found,” was Haldane’s comment upon hearing of this work. Subsequent studies on S. typhimurium involved analyses of the fine structure of its chromosome (including its large “silent” regions) a comparison of this structure with the corresponding one of Escherichia coli, and a study of the consequences of transferring genes from the chromosome of one of these species to that of the other. In short, Demerec had started a systematic attack on evolutionary genetics a t the molecular level. Dr. Demerec succumbed to a heart attack. His death reminded me of a morning many years before when we walked together from Jones Laboratory (on the waterfront a t Cold Spring Harbor) up the steps toward Bungtown Road. About midway up the rather long slope Dr. Demerec paused, turned toward the harbor and its surrounding hills, and gazed a t the familiar but always beautiful view. Then, quietly as if he were discussing the sea gulls in the mud flats of the inner harbor, he said that his doctor had told him to take it easy and so he would like to rest for a moment. “Anything serious?” I asked as we stood there. “Doughhhh, just my heart, nothing really serious.” Many times during my subsequent years a t Cold Spring Harbor I saw Dr. Demerec pause halfway up those steps and turn to gaze out over the harbor; to the casual observer it would appear that he never tired of his laboratory and its surroundings. And, of course, he never did.
Bruce Wallace
CLASSIFICATION AND MAPPING OF SPONTANEOUS AND INDUCED MUTATIONS IN THE HISTIDINE OPERON OF Sahonella
.
.
Philip E Hartman. Zlata Hartman. Ruth C Stahl Department of Biology. The Johns Hapkinr University. Baltimore. Maryland
Bruce
N. Ames
Department of Biochemistry. University of California. Berkeley. California
I . Introduction . . . . . . I1. Materials and Methods . . A . Isolation of Mutants . . B. Characterization of Mutants I11. Results . . . . . . . I V. Discussion . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Deletion Mutations . . . . . . . . . B . Stable Mutations . . . . . . . . . .
C . Frameshift Mutations . . . . . . . . . D Base Substitutions . . . . . . . . . . E The Ratio of Missense to Nonsense Mutations . . F . Multiple Mutations . . . . . . . . . . G Polarity . . . . . . . . . . . . . H Cross-Reacting Material (CRM) . . . . . . I Spontaneous Mutations . . . . . . . . J . Screening Potential Mutagens . . . . . . . K . Intragenic Complementation . . . . . . . L . Gene-Enzyme Relationships . . . . . . . M . Genetic Mapping . . . . . . . . . . V . Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
1 2 2 3 3 9 9 21 21 22 23 24 25 25 26 26 26 27 28 29 30
.
I Introduction
The senior author’s undergraduate class notes in introductory college bacteriology for 1948 carry the notation : “Nucleus-not organized.” The intervening years have seen a drastic reassessment of this idea; now over 250 gene loci have been precisely located on the closed-circular Salmonella typhimurium chromosome (Sanderson. 1970) . I n fact. we 1
2
PHILIP HARTMAN, ZLATA HARTMAN, RUTH STAHL, BRUCE AMES
have devoted considerable effort in elucidating the organization and functioning of about 0.3% of this ‘ h o t organized” entity. Genetic results are reviewed here. Our work on Salmonella grew entirely out of Zinder and Lederberg’s classic report on transduction (1952) and Dr. Milislav Demerec’s recognition that this new technique would allow analysis of genetic fine structure. In what seemed at the time a rash move, Dr. Demerec converted his entire laboratory from studies on Escherichia coli to pursuit of the gene in S. typhimurium. The mutational and recombinational complexity of genes in bacteria was immediately established (Demerec, 1955, 1956; Demerec et al., 1955, 1956; Demerec and Demerec, 1956). Furthermore, these same studies demonstrated that genes with related functions were clustered on the chromosome. One question important to basic genetics had been answered but new questions arose. The strictly genetic work of two of us in Dr. Demerec’s lab was abandoned for two years and then, guided by Dr. Demerec’s inspirations, reinitiated elsewhere (Hantman et al., 1960a,b). Concurrent enzyme analyses promptly established gene-enzyme relationships on a sound basis and demonstrated coordinate control of enzyme production by genes of a cluster (Ames and Garry, 1959; Ames et al., 1960). These lines of evidence were relied upon by Jacob and Monod in their brilliant synthesis outlining the operon theory of gene regulation (1961). I n work since, genetic experiment has paved the way for critical biochemical analysis. II. Materials and Methods
A. ISOLATION OF MUTANTS Almost all mutants were isolated in strain LT2 of 8. typhimurium except for one series isolated as spontaneous mutations in strain LT7 (Tables 1 and 2). The origins and methods of isolation, after penicillin selection, of many mutants with isolation numbers below l 4 l l are given elsewhere (Hartman e t al., 1960b; Loper et aZ., 1964). Also available in the literature are descriptions of the isolation of spontaneous mutations selected for polarity (Fink et al., 1967) and of ICR-induced mutations (Oeschger and Hartman, 1970). Additional mutations not previously described in the literature are included in Table 1 and were isolated by similar procedures. A series of mutations was induced by N-methyl-N‘-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (NG) in an arabinose nonutilizing mutant (am-9) of strain LT2. An overnight nutrient broth culture of bacteria was washed and
MUTATIONS IN THE HISTIDINE
OPERON OF
Salmonella
3
suspended for 30 minutes at room temperature in minimal E medium (Vogel and Bonner, 1956) lacking glucose and containing 200 pg/ml NG (Aldrich Chemical) . The suspension was centrifuged, resuspended in E medium, and diluted into a large series of tubes of the same medium containing 20 pg/ml L-histidine. After overnight growth, histidine-requiring mutants were isolated by screening through E medium containing penicillin and an amino acid mixture complete except for the omission of histidine. This screening procedure paralleled that used for isolation of most of the other mutants surveyed here (Hartman e t al., 1960b).
B. CHARACTERIZATION OF MUTANTS Genetic mapping was performed using P22-mediated transduction (Zinder and Lederberg, 1952; Demerec et al., 1956), Hfr crosses (Nikaido e t al., 1967; Sanderson, 1970), or F’ lac-mediated crosses ( A n t h , 1968). Often, preliminary genetic classification was carried out in complementation tests with a series of F’ his of E. coli K12 origin (Garrick-Silversmith and Hartman, 1970; G. R. Fink and J. R. Roth, personal communication). Complementation tests were performed by P22-mediated abortive transduction (Demerec e t al., 1956; Hartman e t al., 1960a; Loper et al., 1964) and additionally in gene hisD, by matings with strains carrying complementing mutations on F’ his of E. coli (Greeb e t al., 1971). Data on the presence and absence of immunologically cross-reacting material have been published: hisB (Loper, 1961), hisC (Whitfield e t al., 1966), hisA (Margolies and Goldberger, 1968), and hisD (Greeb et al., 1971). Procedures for reversion tests follow those outlined previously (Ames, 1971; Whitfield et al., 1966). Identification of nonsense mutations has relied on phenotypic suppression by streptomycin coupled with the detection of nonsense suppressors among revertants (Berkowitz et al., 1968) Strains SB393, SB789, and SB948 were used to test for ochre-amber, amber, and UGA suppressors, respectively. I n addition, some strains were tested by transduction into strains deleted for a large segment of the his operon and carrying amber or UGA suppressors, or by infection with an F’ episome carrying an ochre suppressor (Garrick-Silversmith and Hartman, 1970). Ill. Results
Table 1 lists the pat’terns of reversion of 1020 independently isolated mutations leading to a histidine requirement and mapping in the histidine
TABLE 1 Histidine-Requiring Mutants* NG+ ICR-
NG- ICR-
cp
Deletion (NG- ICR-)
NG- ICR+
NG+ ICR+
Spontaneous LT-2
Bal4m,C15m,Ba20m+, Bad2la,C31a-, A33mi. Db39m-,Bd40m+, F420, C4W, F a , F45m, G46m, Db49m-, C a y , G52m. F58u. Bc59m. BbBlm+, Bad102a-, Dbl3Om-, F1310, Bc136a. Dab139m-, Dbl4lm-. F144, F147, F148m, DablSLlr-, c1516, C163m-, B185m. F186m, BaclWm, Db45lm+, F453a, Db474m+, Da476m+, C5278, A528m+, Dab52%-, A530m+, AS32m+, Db55Sm-
BalZ, B&-, Dab27, H32. Bd47s+, A&. Dab@-. D a m ,ABW, 19% F103. F132a. Dab1378-, Dab142; Dab154, Db477s-, F479, D24418, F2446e
2 2 , F4l,55-, 57,133, 129,134-, 135,152, A478-
C l F , D a b l e - . Bbcd138 Bcdllr, Iab146, C14(T, ~ a b i 4 9 - ~, a b i ~FHS a,
None
Spontaneous LT-7
A30m+, Dab&-, Bd65m+, Db66m. Db68m-. A69m+, G70m. G72m. F73m. Dab74m-. F76m, Db77m+, Dab78m-, Ba79m+. A80m+, Db82m-, DbBm-, Db84m+, C86m, Db88m-. DbWm-, F91. Db92m+. F9fm. F95m. A100n-. C104m, Ibl05m. AlWm-, CllOm. Dblllm+. Dbll3m+,C115m. Bcll6m-, Cll70, G11%, C120m. C121a, Dab123n-, Dablam-, Ia125m, Da126m-, Ealblm, DalGBm-, Bc167m-, Dbl7Om-, Dbl'llm-, 172, 174n. A178m-, A179m+, A181n-, Db182m+, H193m. F212u, Bd213m+, Db214m+, Db215m+, Db216m-. Bd217m+, F218m. F219m, Da220m+, W21, Db223m-, F224, C225m, DbZ26m-, F227. W28, Bcd229m+, Db233m+, Bdd234+, F235m, Db236m+,Db237m-, Db239m-, FHOm, Bcd241n. Ia242m. Bad2438, Db244m-, Db245m+, A247m+, Db248m-, F251, Db254m+, G255m, A263n. EaZMm, Ia266m, A269m-. Db271, Dab274m-, F277m, Bad278u, A279m+, Ea284m. Bd28%+, Db29lm-, F293m, A294m+.Db295m. A300m+, Ia30lm, Db302m+, I177m
A67s-, AH-, Ia998, H107, DblOBe-. F1098, DallZ, F1148. Ball&, Dab1278, A1538, A1578, A1598, Dabl76-, Dabl91-. 81923, C194, Dab23V. -I-. A246-, A253-, Dab273-, Dab4OOn-, AS&
96-, 101-
B d F , F71, Dab85-. C87, C122, Fl68,F180,F232, F256
Cll70
x-ray
Bb53m+, G200u. C201m+, G204m. C202, DS2088,CZW, Jab%. A481h, 203,386,388,399, C207-,C377-, Dab391-, C516-, G205u. Bb206m+. C21Om+. Bb374m. A M , F466~.Dab48%, C493. B482.515, 519.520, C540, B.824 Bcd380a. Db381m+, F382m,Ba39lm, DaMSBs, Dab497, Iab498, A617eT, 533,538,801, D W , Dab.5186, A521-, C5248, 533s. 8Oa,SG9,810,813Db392m+. F3958, Dab396a-. F398m, C483m-, A485n-, C487a+. Dab49om-, F5438, Da54.5-, A547S. AS%-, F557s, F576n, Bd578e, H586n. F59&, C491a, Db492m+, C496m, G499m. F808, A8ll8+. Db81.5+, ABIBs-, A522m-, C5258-. F526u. F534m, A8288, Db8338 A535m+, Dab536a-, C537m. Iab539n. Bd542m, C M a , F548m, A550n-, A551mf, Ia553m. A561m+, Dab563a. F565m.F568m, Ia.570~.Ea571. G5720, Ba-d573a, G575m, G5810, C588m. Bb59om. A593m-, A594m+. E596m. F806m. Bad807a, Bc8128, A820n-, F823a, Ba-d82k, A834-
ZAminopurine G255n, A263n-, F336a. G337m. A338m+, A9678, Da988s+, D2443a F3390, C34Oa, C3418, Ia352m, Bcd353a, C3540, Bc3558, Dab362m-, Db363m-, C3648. C367mC. C368m. Dab4lOa-, Dab4lla-. DWOm-, G4210. DaMZh-. A423m+. F424m, Ba-d425n, C426a-, Ia427m, G4280, Bc429a-. A430m+, A431m-. F432a. C4348-. Dab4368, C439a-, F440. C441, Dab442a-. Dab443a-, A m - , C446a-,A449m+, Da450m-, Db451m+ A4521-, Dab47ln-, F5ooa. CWIa, c5020, Iab50k, C5078, c50&-, A512m+, A513m+, (25140, Ba-d573n, Ba-d647n, F8590,A%&-. A864m+, Bc8658, F8680, C869a. F8720, Dab873a-. A875n-, G8760, C879a. Dab88Oa-, C881a. Dab@%-, AW-, Ea885m. A8866, Dab889n-. C890m, Dab89ln-, Dab892a-, Dab893a-, Dab%-, Dab895m-, Dabs%-, F897m, A916m+, Db924m-, DbMIm-, Dab946n-. F9490,Dab952a-, A955nDab956n-, DabSGOn-, Dab962n-, Da986m-, B9&, Dab992a-, DabNBn-, F1027m, A1031n-, B1032m A1400u. B1408, D24360, A2782m, C2783m, C2785n, C2793o. C2794m, D2812a, A3701m, Dab37100
950
None
None
zz z
Y
3
Ei C W - , DMlZm-. F413o.
C441n
Y
E m
E: ,Y tl
1 %M 9
P
0
3
F 0
5
N
F
(Continued)
TABLE 1 (Continued) NG+ I C R
NG- ICR-
Q,
Deletion (NG- ICB-)
NG- I C P
NG+ ICW
w +I
None
None
None
A2437a, C24388, A2447m. Db2448m. Dab9s48, C2460:E3116*, E2449s. C245On. Dab2452a. Db2462m. Db246b. Db24729.2476s Db2463m. F2464m. I2465m. I247Om. Dab2471m. Db2474m. Db2475m
None
None
None
Dblm, C2m-, A3m+, F b , C8m-, DabW, A3W, BdlSC, F197n. F198, DalGu-, Eabllo, DablZlm-. Eb35m. Bad314, Dab466-. F a % , DbBOW, Dab607 Db36m, Db37m+, C62m. F306n. F308n, F31Om,Eab31la, GWm, Dab461r. F463u, C464m-. Db465m+, Eb48’lm. Bbe470a. Dam-.DaGolm+, Dab603a-, Db604m+
None
None
None
Faat neutrona
Iab333m, GBllu, A613m-, EabBlh, Bd615m. Da619m+. C63Om. Dab&-, Db635m+, Dab639n-
F327,A3W,612, 640.642.644-
Bc328, F330
None
Nitrous acid
F319m. F321m, G3.250. G3260, Bad647a, F654, Bad6568, Bad6578, F6W, Ib648m. F650m. Aalm-. A652m-, C W F661m,.Iab6670, F671a, C683m, F689m. A1450m-
615-,646,658,669, 660.666. 695
CW-,C855, CL756, C857
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
5-Bromouncil
Bd898n. C899m, Fgoom,A901m+, AW3m+, A905m+, C906m, A907m-, G936m. Db1442m
Diethylsulfate
m~vblet light
SZP
Decay
Nitrosoguanidme
Db506m-. Dab5llm-
B1022a.DabllOSm, Bcdl710, A1712u.
None
FGOgS, Bb6248.
Dab626, F63Bs.
Bb6418
None
F1713B3115,’ A1747:B3113m,* Db1714m, Db1715m, C1716a. A1754: B3114,*A17748,A1797: F3118,* Dbl717m. F1718m, D1719a,Bac1721m, A3095 F3119* Db1722m, F17!24m,B1725m,C1726m. Da1727m. F1728m, Iab1729a, F1730m, C1731m. Db1732m, A1733m, 1734111, Db1736m. C1737m. A1738m, F1739m, Ba-c1740m, 1741. Db1742, (374%. C1744m. Da1745m. 1746, Dab1748m. Db1749m, B1750m, Db1751m. C1752m, Db1753m. Db1755m, F1756m.
E w
F e F p zl
s M
4
B
ul
Dbl757m. Ib1758, D1759m. C1760m, C1762m. Db1763m. F1764m. Db1765m. Ba1766m, G1767m. Db1768m, G1769m, Db1770m, Db1772m, G1773m, G1775m. I1776 Dab1777m, Db1778m. A1779m, E1780m, Dab1782m, Dab1783m. I1784n, G1785m, Dab1786m, Dbl787m, Eab1789m. Db1790m, F1791, G1792m, Db1793m. A1794m.
is
2+
2
0
3
Iabl796a. E1798m, Db1799m, G2453u. F2454m, H2459m. 2460. F2767a, E2768n, I2777m. C2784n. Db2788m. Bad279Om, H279lm. E2800m. E2801m, Da2802m, F2807m, Iab2808n. D28110, Db2813m. Db3080u. Db3081m. Da3082m, Iab3083a,A3084m. (33085. Iab3086a. Dab3087m. A3088m. Db3089m, Db309Om. F309ln. Dab3092m, F3094m. F3095m. G3096m. E3097a ICR364-OH
ICR372and ICR191
G3048m, B3055m
None
2
#M
52 El
30508, F3051, C3053, Dab305&, C3064. Da3073, C3077
A3056, A3075,3050 C3049, F3054. C3059. C3062, Dab3052, C3057, C3060, A306; C3063, F3066, C3067, C3069, ‘23065, Dab3068, C3072, c3070, ~ 3 0 7 1 ~. 3 0 7 4 a, 0 7 9 ~ 3 0 7 6~, 3 0 7 s
B2771, (32775, Bad277&, C2781, F2792, A3003, Da3008, Dab3009. F3015S. F3020. A3023a, (2025, A3027. A30348, F30428,Dab3045s, Dab3706
A3000
F2439, C2455, D2456, B2457, F2439. D2769, A2770. A2772, B2458. A2786, (22799, C2803, A2774, G2776, (32779. G2804. F2805. F2806, G2810, Dab2780. D2787, C2789, C2814, (33001,A3005. F3011. C2795. C2798, A3002, C3004, Dab3013, Dab3028. A3030, A3006, C3007, A3010, Dab3012, C3014. A3016, C3035, Dab3036, C3703, A3017, Dab3018, ‘23021, F3704, Dab3708. B3735 A3022. G3024, F3026. Da3029, F3031, C3032, H3033, G3037, F3038,A3039, Dsb3040, F3041, A3043, F3044,F3046. F3047, Dab3702, (3705, D3733, C3737. D3749 (Continued)
3 0
5
0
+4
2
Y 2
N
a
c1
id
TABLE 1 (Continued) Mutagen
NG+ I C R
NG- I C R
Deletion (NG- ICR-)
NG- ICR+
NG+ ICR+
Spont. LT-2 Dab2114n, G2115a. D2116n, Dab2117n. H2142s. H2144s. G2148, BS-d2150, Dab2121, B2224,2225 G2100, G2102 through G2113, G21010, Dab2119n, C2132a. selected for Dab2119n. Dab212On. A212Lh. G2159,H21678. B2178,B218&s. G2192, throngh 2228,B2229, FZ118, Dab2122, C2123, Ba-d2133a,BacdZl35a, growth of Bc2130n. Dab213ln. Bs-d2134n, F22236,C2301. (2302,G2303:C3120.* 2232 through B38, C2124, C2125, C2126,H2129, Bc2147n, B2152a, Bc2153n, mnstitutivea Ba-d2145n, Bc2161n. Bc2177n. 2308, Dab2317, A2322. Dab2369, 2253,2315, B2320, FZ136, (32137, H2138, C2139, Bad216011, G2556 at M C . Bc2179n,Bc21BOn,Bca2183n,Bc2184n. C2499u, Dab2511, Dab2549, DabZ5.50, 2323,2327,2371, H2140, Ba-d2141. H2143, Bc218Sn. Dab2186n. G2187a, FZlSBa, Dab2555, F26Ols. FZW,FZW, 2372,2497.2600,2602, C2146, C2149. C2151, C2154. Bc21W)n. B2272n. F2273n. C2304a, FZ613s,A2615s, F26lb, FZ6176, 2604,2605,2607,2610 G2155 tbmugh G2158, G2162, G2308, C23070, D23090, D2310u. F26208,p2632s. C 2 M F3117; h n g h 2612,2614, C2163, G2164, C2165, C2166, G2168. G2170, G2171. H2172. FZGPBS,26478, C2648S. A264%, D2787, 26%. 2626 tbrougb D2311a, D2312a, D2313s. 02321, Ba-c2442u,F2445n, A2606n, F2636n, F30988 2630,2633,2634,2637, G2173,G2175,G2176,G2181, C2638n 2639,2640,2643,2650 C2182, B2191,(22193,C2194, D2252, F2264 though F2267, througb 2653 F2269, F2270,F2271, F2274, F2275, F2276, D2352, B2498, DZ641 Hmtidime-fequirmg mutanta chilied according to method of induction (left-band mlnmn) and revmion pgtterns (top beadings). hlatinn procedures are described in Section 11. ICR = ICRl9I exuept wbere p i l i e d ; deletion = fails to recombme with two or more mutations that reoombime with each other. In the body of the table, each number refers to an independent mutational event. Capital lettpz prehea denote gene locus designationswhere d i a g n d ; tbis designation ban been omitted from mutations m the “Deletion” mlnmn where more tban one gene locus is affected. Lowex case prehea indica(e the complementation pattern where this has been investigate3 for mutations in tbom four genes (0, B, E . and 0 where intragenic complementation ban been observed to occur. D mutanta are c h i l e d into three mmplementation types: Da, Db, and nonmmplementing (Dab).Mutants of genes I and B exhibit three W c ctuSea. respectively, as in gene D. In gene B there are four h i c mmplementation units, and the entirely nonmmplementing claw is designated Bad. Suffires indicate the following: positive (+)or negative (-) for immunologically -reacting material; a = amber; m = misrenss; n = nomenw, (amba or ochre); o = ochre; s = stable in spontaneous and in mutagen revmion tssts (aU “deletion” mutations also are stable); u = UGA nonsense. Mutations separated by mlow and marked witb asterisks were isolated as double mutations induced in two eeparate gene loci. All sponteneously revertible atrainS that am NG- ICR-. NG- ICR+,and NG+ ICR+ and W i n g let& nuf6xea are masidered to be frameahifta.
N
W
m
2M
MUTATIONS IN THE HISTIDINE OPERON OF
Salmonella
9
operon. No mutations leading to an absolute requirement for histidine have been found to map outside of the operon. Additional properties of the mutations are given in Table 1, as described in the legend. Figure 1 shows the map positions of over 1500 mutations. IV. Discussion
The data of Table 1 are summarized and classified in Table 2. After some comments on classification of Salmonella mutants and actions of mutagens, we point out some special features in our results not directly concerned with these other two aspects. Throughout the discussion we will emphasize points that may have wide applicability in practical experimentation in Salmonella as opposed to speculation on special genetic events. As background on the structure of the his operon and its control we refer the reader to reviews (Brenner and Ames, 1971; Ames et al., 1967). The operon is comprised of nine genes, arranged in the order operator-GDCBHAFIE, and dictates the structures of all of the enzyme proteins specifically involved with biosynthesis of L-histidine. The entire operon is approximately 10,000 nucleotide pairs in length (Brenner and Ames, 1971; Ames et al., 1967). Over 375 recombinationally separable sites of mutation have been discerned in the operon (Fig. 1) , and this number could be drastically increased by further recombination tests between point mutations.
MUTATIONS A. DELETION These mutations (“Deletion” column in Table 1; Column 2 in Table 2) are defined by genetic recombination tests as mutations that fail to recombine with two or more other mutations found to recombine with each other. Some mutations are extended deletions of two or more genes while others are probably deletions of short stretches of nucleotide pairs (Fig. 1 ) . One mutation (hisDCBHAFl52) makes a ‘‘short” messenger RNA (Venetianer et al., 1968) and another (hisBH22) “skips” a period of time in the expression of genes distal to the mutation upon derepression (Marver et al., 1966). Two cases where mutations link two polypeptide chains into one long chain (Yourno et al., 1970; Rechler and Bruni, 1971) also are presumed to be deletions of genetic material including intergenic nucleotides (“intercistronic divide”) . A number of the presumed deletion mutations have been critically tested 8s donors in transduction tests, and no evidence for recombination with centrally located point mutations has been obtained. Such recombi-
I
0611
'fO2
'EL5
E96
186
I
0
D
ob837 b699R b694L ob627L ab625 b585 0459 b457L b345 b344 ob9.C ab34L
b1437L b1436L b1431L b1429L b1423L ob 1416L D 1412L 0ll5lR b941 940
b934L ob883
bI75IRm b1749Rm obI748Rm b1736m b1732Rm 11727Rm b17221 1719Rm b1717Rm blll5Rm ab1709m ob1440L
obl786Lm 2301E 0b1783Rm b2YIOE ob1782Rm 0237% 2378E b1778Rm ob1777Rm 2377E b1772Rm 23130 b1770Rm 2312a b1765m 23110 b1763Rm 23lOU 1759Rm 23390 b1717Rm b1790m bl755Rm b1787m
2433 2432 2431 2430 2429
2428n
2427R 24261 2421 2420 2418 2302E
2473 b2472s ob2471m b2469s b2463m b2462m 24161 0824520 2443. 2441s 24360 2434
b2813m 2788m 27691 26411 obZ5IIRl ob2483E ab2482E ob24elE ab248OE b2479E
k$zT2;
Ob37061 3107 ab3092Rm b3090Lm bMB9Ra ob3087m 03082m b308ILu bMBOLv ab30681 ob3M I ob3032l
03112 3711 ab371h 370% ob37081
3939
3911 24611 2152" I422L
I I52
219%
Ihrwph 2222Y
0 0 4 7 loab41 10-
b2002m
28121
3725"
3633
3635
I
3639
-
b3642
ObyZOn
abS63r ab4OOsob137r
646
2222 -37
I
2906R. 2910R. 2912R.2916R 2225
/2221 63 538
--
- ._
63 5313 2226 2213
7776
2253 0""
3603
3050
\
/
386R.399R.S I~FI.~I~P*Z-
FIG.1. For caption see pp. 18 and 19.
644,3603.3050
b3637 3632 ob6390-
D b 30091
ob95602368 ob8960-
ab895m-
ob893.r Gb8730ob6030ob490mobl54l obI5Omb141m-
C
278M
ob2440m ob2I 1% ob2I 14" b 179% b1793m b I768m b 1442m b1753m ab9960-
3646 3656 b3645 3634 3644 b3629 3630 b3087m ab3058s mb30521 0 b 3 0 I 31
926
417
sw
683-
312
6?U
310
5140 804
577 1744 5 3 7 m 1743 503 140. 5020 1403 496m 1026 160 Ice0 I510 8551
2353P 2 2316 14661 1401
1033
24941 1029 24931 6 580m 0 23021 954
687
36b
2014l 276%
2 I251 1261
307Bl
1731 1410 Iloo7 IS0
22591 2326
980
22541 225661
3540
2354" 1762
595
8441-
3711
30721
0531 653
2769 37270 b460 b1424L 3726u b20I ob92I ObU)45s b173 ob807 ab30281 025 6% eb2106n
673
299 280 298 26 I
249 225m 2071 10E
2794.74
27930-
976
107 871
964 9uI 944 89% 908
860
5401 1210 4 2021 6 h 306M 3724u
Mo 131
I I 5 m 20031
22% I I 30771 2zyI 3721 I 306441 3716" 30071 30631
or91
22571 21661 2 I651 2 I391 I631
2 1320 21371
--
6 2 m 27751
b214m*
IY
461
YI
YB
YA
PII
120m
2091
nm
1170
ne
I
75-4
ab
2630
0129
129
2236 2604
2906R.29lOR. 2912R;
2906R. 2 9 1 0 R . 2912R. 2916R
)6R
6 3 . . . 53u
712
57.2226 2253 644.3603.3050
I
1
2225 152
I
63 152
57.2226
2253 644.3603.3050
I
2650
I
2604
I
I
2605
I
2607
5uL
I
2624
YWVVWV\I
I
-
I
2652
I
712
3 8 6 R . 3 0 0 ~ . 3 9 9 R . 5 I 5 R . 5 1 9 R . 5 2 0 R . 5 3 3 R . 6 5 8 R . 6 6 0 R . 6 0 1 R . 8 0 3 R . 8 0 9 ~ . 1 4 4 8 R . 1 4 8 6 R . 1 ~ 0 7 ~ . 2 3 7 1 R . 2 3 7 2 R . 2 3 7 3 ~ . 2 4 9 7 R . ~ 0 6.ZbWR.Z6IOR.2611R.2612R ~
!I
2628
CZOZ'LWZ
\
SO92 I
b192
LZFZ
I
l
I
I
n /( X
LO92
I
bZ92 I U916Z'Ut 162 '10162 'US062
I I
bO9Z bE9Z
bC92 OZCZ
I
A
I
l
I6950
JI
ZZ
m
"__"
RSZ OZFZ
II
1092
C29Z W l b Z %216Z 'U0162'U9062
to92
5092
0592
m
22 RSZ
m
I I
8
H
ITS%
2329 2330 23u) 2144s 2167s
O b c 17-
oc1721n mr990 c 4ea 6%s429a
3114
24Sm 2351 244%
2142,
2344
I7S4 1147
2341
2336
1407
sw,
C35%
2333 2331
5641
2325
2791~
2347 2143
mz
2609
2349
I
2350
523
I
=E
I IB
I A
2339
21721
2337
2335 3095 1794
21431 z14a 21361 2l29I
644 646
2342 2340 974
.
30331
2346 2345
2336 1 1% %
622 621
1-
I
I
HA IIB
22
I
260s
fPL4R. s7
~
e
24
2253
644.712.26205050.3603 146ZR. 2602R
/
I
3
h
2633 2614
I
2604
2s27
m 1
2634 2633 2614
I
24%R 2-
~
~~
2605 69SR.2651R.2906R.2908R.2910R.2912R.2914R.2916R
2547
I
2227.2323
644.I l2%%30%.36O3
1462R260PR.Z911R.2915R
3101
26261 \ I407R.23711.237ZI).23731.24971.25~R 2 6 O O R . 2 ~ 6 1 1 4 . 2 6 1 2 R
\
26371
a .
FIG.1 (Continued).For caption see pp. 18 and 19.
Ob9
>
m
2il I
BII I
QII I
I
SEl
I
I 91b 3C1b2
rfb 4-12 aann Iemtha
17 ~
l
~
~
~
.
l
~
6
2
~
.
l
~
~
.
l
~
~
7
R
FIG.1 (Continwd). For caption see pp. 18 and 19.
.
2
3
7
l
~
18
PHILIP HARTMAN, ZLATA HARTMAN, RUTH STAHL, BRUCE AMES
FIa. 1 [pp. 10-181. Map of the histidine operon and adjacent gene region in S. typhimurium. Each gene is designated by a capital letter. The correlation of each gene with an enzyme activity is described elsewhere (Ames et al, 1967; Loper et al., 1964; Martin et al., 1971). The map is not drawn to scale. Each number represents an independently isolated mutation and carries the suffix his except for rfb-806.Mutations indicated below the heavy horizontal line are deletions. A wavy line indicates that the extent of the deletion in the wavy region is unknown and an arrow at the end of the wavy line indicates that the extent of the mutation into the particular gene is unknown. Roman numerals just below the heavy horizontal line designate subregions of each gene as determined by deletion-mapping, except in a few cases where three-point tests were utilized in an earlier map (Loper et al., 1964). Mutational sites are placed above the heavy horizontal line in their most probable map order, determined by deletion mapping and three-point tests. Mutations listed in vertical columns have not been ordered. I n a number of instances more than one column of successively numbered mutations is shown in one gene region. Parentheses indicate that the map order is unknown. Horizontal brackets indicate that the mutation(s) map in a particular region but have not been crossed further. Sets of mutations that fail to recombine with one another are enclosed by vertical brackets. Mutations not mapped in detail but placed only as to gene affected are listed in a cluster, for each gene, at the top of the diagram. Prefixes indicate complementation patterns (for genes D, B, I , and E ) ; consult text for details. Suffix designations follow: C = constitutive (Roth et al., 1966; D. B. Fankhauser, in preparation); F = mutation on E . coli F’ (Garrick-Silversmith and Hartman, 1970; G. R. Fink and B. N. Ames, personal communication; 5. C. Loper, personal communication) ; L = lysogenic stock; M = missing (lost) ; P = polar prototroph (Voll, 1967); R = rough (P22-resistant; in the case of extended deletions this is generally due to inclusion of the rfb operon in the mutation (cf. Nikaido et al., 1967) and in the case of point mutations to a separate mutation in one of the somatic antigen genes) ; a = amber (UAG nonsense) ; c = cold-sensitive, feedback hypersensitive (prototrophic a t 37°C) (St. Pierre, 1968; G. A. O’Donovan, personal communication) ; f = frameshift ; m = missense ; n = nonsense (either amber or ochre) ; o = ochre (UAA nonsense) ; r = feedback-resistant (prototrophic) (Sheppard, 1964; D. N. Ant6n and J. H. Wyche, unpublished) ; s = stable (deletions listed below the heavy horizontal line also are stable to reversion on minimal medium) ; u = UGA nonsense; - = CRM-negative; + = CRM-positive (consult text). Numbers in parentheses following deletion numbers, e.g., 90.9 under hGG, designate constitutive enzyme levels (or absence of detectable enzyme activity) for the remaining intact genes of the operon in mutants lacking the normal his operator-promotor region (Ames et al., 1963; St. Pierre, 1968). One mutation (his-984) located internally in the operon (genetic region DIB) appears to be an absolute polar mutation (S. A. McIntire and J. C. Loper, cited in Greeb et al., 1971). This map supersedes all previous ones, differing in a number of minor details. The map is a compilation of unpublished data and material published in a variety of locations (Loper, 1961; Loper et al., 1964; Whitfield et al., 1966; Fink et al., 1967; Margolies and Goldberger, 1968; Martin and Talal, 1968; Greeb et al., 1971). These publications should be consulted for further details. Description of the regions adjacent to the his operon in S. typhimurium is to be found in Sanderson (1970), Murray and Klopotowski (1968), and Nikaido et al. (1967). Mews. Morris Earl
MUTATIONS IN THE HISTIDINE OPERON OF
Salmonella
19
nation might have been expected were the mutations inversions. Finally, many of the mutations are nonpolar as expected of inframe deletions but not expected of extensive inversion. Therefore, we conclude that inversions are rare or absent in our material while deletions are quite common. The top, horizontal column in Table 2 indicates that deletion mutations are found with fair frequency among spontaneous histidine-requiring mutants of strain LT2, and this frequency is increased when selection is performed for strong polarity (second horizontal column, Table 2). Such mutants are more infrequent among LT7 derivatives since one or two mutator genes that induce base substitutions are present in many LT7 “wild-type” stocks (cf. Kirchner, 1960). Irradiation with X-rays or fast neutrons or treatment with nitrous acid are effective in increasing the relative frequency of deletions (and stable mutations) in bacteria (cf. Schwartz and Beckwith, 1969). The ends of deletion mutations in the histidine operon are located a t over 67 places (Fig. 1). Only a few “repeated” mutations have been detected. A set of five mutations (2228, 2233, 2234, 2235, and 2237) detected by Fink et al. (1967) appears to share one end in common, as do the pairs 1300-1301, 1303-2232 and the trio 2627-264-2643 (in each case the other terminus lies outside of the operon in unmapped territory). Two additional mutations, 2227 and 2323, share one common “end” while in each case the other lies outside of the operon in an unmapped region between the his operon and gnd, some P-12 “genelengths” away. Two ICR-induced mutations appear identical (Oeschger and Hartman, 1970), and hisF41 (spontaneous), and hisFS27 (fast neutrons) appear alike. I n a number of instances, pairs of multisite mutations share one end in common while the other is known to differ in extent, either extending in the opposite direction (63-2605; 2236-2652; 64.5-2315; 640-2547; 2649 and the trio 2627-2640-2643) or in the same direction (649-14.52; 2527-2634; 612-2633; 666-950). This indicates that Harper and David M. Mayer did considerable mapping and mutant characterization in gene B, extended by Miss Ann Boardley under the supervision of Dr. Mary Jane Voll. Credit for other published results incorporated here is due Drs. John C. Loper and John R. Roth. The gene labeled s u p W on the map is an amber suppressor gene and is now designated supD, in keeping with the symbol for a presumably analogous gene (also known as sul and suZ) in E . coli. Strains 203, 644, 1301, 1302, 1303, and 1304 carry a wildtype s u p D gene; other deletions have not been tested. Mutant 3934 is a cold-sensitive mutant that maps in region GV and not in GVI as shown on the map (Rothman-Denes and Martin, 1971); i123 maps in GVI; G mutants 72, 266, 337, and 936 are missense (J. Ferretti, personal communication).
TABLE 2 Summary of Reversion Patterns of 1018 Independently Isolated Histidine-Requiring Mutants and Some Additional Properties
origin SpontaneousLT2 SpontaneousLT2 (Polarity) Sponteoeous LT7
x-ray
Diethylunlhte Nitrous acid Ultraviolet light ICR364-OH ICR372 and ICR191 N-Methyl-N'-nitro-Nnitrosogunidme ZAminopurine
5-Bmmouracil
Total %
83
y
10
199
47
143
2
114
Fast Neutrons
"P b
Total 1
Frame- Frame- Frameshift: shift: shift: Presumed minus minus plus deletion (NG- (NG(NG+ Deletion (stable) I C R 3 ICR+) ICR+) 2 3 4 5 6
23
20 31 37
33 87 119
9 (23 %)
(34%I (10 . %) ..
1 ~~
66
13
11
9
236
(25%)
7 0
16
(44 %)
0
(32%)
3 1
(16 %) (15%) (8%)
0
9
20
(34%)
6
11
9
0
1
2
0
5
0
0
0
6 2
2 4 5
4-6
20
4 0
12
(13%) 3 (13%I 0
0 0
9
6
11
25
44
1
0
0
0
6
(19%) 4 (11%I 26 (79%) 80 (92 %I 0
119
0
10
0
2
0
1020
93 18%
* CRM = presence (+) or abaence (-) t One pmmotor mutation (hisWS2f).
Total additions and deletions 2-6
39
BaaeBaae mbstitnmbsti tions tutions
(NG+
ICR-) 7
44
(NG+
ICR+) 8
0
6
4
3
Total frame shifts
0
0
0
0
95
70
133
54
0 257 25%
of immunologidy orasreacting material.
(47%) 13 (57 %) 5 (25 %)
16 (52 %) 10 (27%) 31 (94%) 87 (100%) 1 (1%) 4 (3%) 0 0 445
44%
(53%) 10
(44%)
14 (70 %I 15
(48%) 27 (73 %) 2 (6%)
0
0 0 0
0
Nonsense Mkneme 9 10 15 (36 %) 45 (98%)t 13 (13%) 24 (41%) 2 (20%) 4 (29 %) 5 (33%) 10 (37 %) 0
36
-
-
29
51
16
30
2
7
0
0
1
1
0
7
0
7
11
0
-
-
-
0
-
0
m
-
-
5
F
11
52
0
3
1
0
0
2
0
0
85
(87%) 34 (59%) 8
(80%) 10 (71%) 10 (67%) 17 (63 %) 2 0
113 (95 %)
0
19 (18%) 78 (70%) 1 (10%)
85 (82%)
553
14 56 %
0
216 (40%)
0
10
0
(97%) 0 10 (100%) 2 0
Double 13
27
0
4
CRM-* 12
(64 %)
0
111
CRM+* 11
34 (30%) 9
(907%) 2 323 (60%)
78 28%
198 72%
8 8%
m 6
1: td
9 9
MUTATIONS IN THE HISTIDINE OPERON OF
Salmonella
21
the identity of termini in the few cases observed may be a consequence of regions of the map that are relatively immune to mutation and thus bare of mutations that would otherwise differentiate deletion mutations from one another. These may be regions that are relatively insusceptible to nonrandomly distributed frameshift mutations (Oeschger and Hartman, 1970) and relatively unessential for catalytic activity and thus also insusceptible to most base substitution mutations. The origin of deletion-type mutations is unknown; their occurrence in E. coli K12 is independent of rec function (Franklin, 1967; Inselberg, 1967; Anderson, 1970) and ,thus probably not due to looping out and unequal crossingover performed by the enzyme complex normally involved in recombination. Extended deletions in the histidine operon of E. coli appear proportionally more frequent and uniform than those observed in Salmonella (Goldschmidt et al., 1970; Garrick-Silversmith and Hartman, 1970).
B. STABLE MUTATIONS Stable mutations (Column 3, Table 2) are presumed deletion mutations as they have not been observed to revert spontaneously or with the mutagens NG or ICR191 (reversion frequency less than 10-lo). Many of these have been extensively crossed with closely allied mutations and not yet found to cover more than one mutational site. Others have not been extensively tested. In either case, it is likely that very extensive tests against a larger number of base substitution mutations would reveal that many of these mutations are short deletions of several nucleotide pairs. Several are nonpolar and some show intragenic complementation; on theoretical grounds these are in-phase deletions of 3 base pairs or a multiple thereof. Other stable mutations are polar and thus presumably shift the reading frame in mRNA. C. FRAMESHIFT MUTATIONS These are spontaneously revertible deletions or additions of bases that cause a shift in the reading frame in mRNA. Recent observations suggest that the vast majority of spontaneous frameshifts as well as those induced by many mutagens involve deletions of base pairs, and the mutations are not suppressed by external suppressors. I n contrast, acridine derivatives frequently cause mutations through basepair additions and are suppressible by external suppressors. Some frameshift mutations fail to respond in reversion tests to the mutagens NG and ICR191, some respond to ICR but not to NG, and a third class responds both to
22
PHILIP HARTMAN, ZLATA HARTMAN, RUTH STAHL, BRUCE AMES
ICR and to NG (Tables 1 and 2 ) . Only one mutation (G.2556) in this third class has been detected among spontaneous mutations and among mutations induced with a number of mutagens. Such NG+ ICR+ mutations are frequently found among mutants originally induced with ICR compounds (Oeschger and Hartman, 1970). Generally, they are more highly revertible in spot tests (Ames and Whitfield, 1966) with ICR191 than they are with NG. We have speculated that many of these mutations are “plus” frameshifts, as actually determined for one of them (Yourno and Heath, 1969). Many, but possibly not all, of these mutations are suppressible by external suppressors (Yourno et al., 1969; Riddle and Roth, 1970). The suppressors restore in-phase translation at an efficiency of 1-15% (Yourno and Tanemura, 1970; Riddle and Roth, 1970). Riddle and Roth (1970) found only one ICR-induced frameshift (F3704) that responded to ICR but not. to NG but is suppressible by external suppressors. None of the mutants in frameshift, stable, or deletion classes has been observed to be phenotypically suppressed by streptomycin (Whitfield et al., 1966; Oeschger and Hartman, 1970).
D. BASESUBSTITUTIONS Mutations that revert spontaneously and whose reversion is increased with NG but not by ICR (NG+ ICR- Column in Table 1 ; Column 7 in Table 2) are considered to be base substitutions. Many of these strains also are reverted by base analogs. For example, about 75% of NG-induced mutants are reverted by 2AP (about a third of these are negative in spot tests but yield positive results after extended growth in broth containing 500 pg/ml 2AP). We have not attempted to separate transition mutations from transversion mutations. Most of the NG-revertible mutations also are revertible with diethylsulfate, and about half are clearly induced to revert with p-propiolactone. Various suppression tests (see p. 3) have allowed subclassification of substitution mutations into missense and various kinds of nonsense (UAA, UAG, UGA triplets). Nonsense mutations also are characterized as polar, as very highly susceptible to NG-induced reversion and to phenotypic reversal with streptomycin, and very often as inactive in intragenic complementation in v i m . Our tests have been extensive enough to lead us to believe that our missense class includes few, if any, missed nonsense. UGA nonsense mutations are rare in our material, presumedly since most such mutants are “leaky” because Salmonella strains translate this codon with low efficiency (Roth, 1970; Ferretti, 1971).
MUTATIONS IN THE HISTIDINE
OPERON OF
Salmonella
23
A small fraction of base-substitution mutations are revertible strongly by NG and weakly by ICR compounds (Whitfield et al., 1966; Fink et al. 1967; Oeschger and Hartman, 1970): (see mutations with suffixes in NG' ICR' Column of Table 1; Column 8 of Table 2). ICR364-OH appears to be more effective than ICR191 in eliciting this type of reversion, although the latter compound is comparatively more effective in intragenic reversion of frameshift mutations (Oeschger and Hartman, 1970). The ICR frameshift mutagens are presumed to act on base-substitution mutants by induction of suppressor mutations, perhaps by adding or deleting bases in a tRNA (Fink et al., 1967). We have checked the purity of these stocks, their mutational responses, and determined for his-dl 33 that the original mutation can indeed be recovered by transduction away from the suppressor. We do not know why reversion of only a few nonsense mutations is elicited by ICR compounds. Evidence has been provided that ICR191 can cause occasional base substitutions in E. coli (Berger et al., 1968) but, based on the observations reported here, its action in this regard can be considered minimal or absent in Salmonella. Table 2 shows that NG, 2AP, and 5BD predominantly or exclusively elicit base substitutions (cf. Eisenstark et al., 1965). The few stable mutants (Column 3 of Table 2; 4 mutants per 249 mutants examined) could be closely allied double mutations, similar to others detected (Column 13 of Table 2 ) ) but within a single gene. Alternatively, the stable mutations could be spontaneous mutations fortuitously selected after mutagen treatment, or they could be a minor mode of mutagenesis by these compounds.
E. THERATIOOF MISSENSETO NONSENSE MUTATIONS Whitfield et al., (1966) noted a great shortage of missense mutations relative to nonsense mutations. They conclude that most missense mutations are not detected since the proteins are partially or completely functional due to substitution of the same or of a related amino acid, or due to substitution of an amino acid in a noncritical portion of the polypeptide chain. This shortage of missense mutations was particularly strong with the transition-inducing mutagen, 2AP. I n our more extensive investigation we find some 2 0 4 0 % of the base substitutions detected are nonsense mutations except those induced by 2AP where approximately 70% are nonsense (Column 9 in Table 2 ) . The surplus of nonsense mutations induced by 2AP and the relative rarity after mutagenesis with NG run counter t o expectations. UGA nonsense mutations are rare in our material (Roth, 1970), while UAA
24 PHILIP HARTMAN,
ZLATA HARTMAN, RUTH STAHL, BRUCE AMES
nonsense can arise by transition only from CAA, and UAG nonsense only from CAG or UGG. All of these transitions involve G/C to A/T changes. Our observed ratio for NG is the opposite of what one would expect if the major means of NG mutagenesis in stationary phase bacteria was the formation of 7-methylguanine (Lawley, 1968) which would be expeoted to lead selectively to G/C to A/T transitions (cf. Drake, 1970). Perhaps NG gives rise to a substantial proportion of transversion mutations. Also, when bacteria are grown in nutrient broth containing 2AP, as was the case in our isolation procedure, the G/C to A/T transition appears to predominate. This is not the behavior expected if the classic DNA polymerase of Salmonella resembles that of E . coli in eliciting incorporation of 2AP preferentially in place of adenine (Rogan and Bessman, 1970) and is involved in DNA replication in vivo.
F. MULTIPLEMUTATIONS Only eight histidine-requiring auxotrophs have been found to contain two mutations, each in a separate gene of the operon (separated by colons in NG- ICR- Column of Table 1 and listed in Column 13 of Table 2). Five of these were obtained in NG-treated cultures, one in a diethylsulfate-treated culture, and two were spontaneous. Although the double mutants were stable to mutagens, both mutations in each of the five NG-induced double mutants were found susceptible to NGinduced reversion when the strains were infected with F’ his episomes functional for one of the two gene loci. Additionally, mutation B3113 was recovered from a double mutant by transduction into a hisD deletion mutant on histidinol-containing plates nonselective for the single and double mutations of the donor strain. Transductional clones were screened for reversion in response to NG, and the missense mutant, B3113, which maps identically to the B mutation in the double mutant, was isolated. Numerous other strains with double mutations were found in the NGtreated bacteria even though (see p. 2) stationary phase cultures were used, NG treatment was not extreme, and selection was made for histidine-requiring bacteria. Among the doubles found were 1 classified by phage typing as rfa, 7 classified as rfb, 3 as rfc, 17 other unclassified rough strains, two p-aminobenzoic acid-requiring mutants, and 1 leaky purine mutant [see Sanderson (1970) for nomenclature]. One strain carried three point mutations, two in the histidine operon (F1713 B3116), and one (rfb-808) in the somatic antigen operon that is closely linked to the his operon (Nikaido et al., 1967). Therefore, one must be ex-
MUTATIONS IN THE HISTIDINE OPERON OF
Salmonella
25
tremely wary of NG as a mutagen; cotransducibility gives no assurance that clusters of mutations have not occurred. G. POLARITY Nonsense and frameshift mutations in the his operon lower enzyme levels of distal genes (polarity) to about 5% to 60% of normal (Whitfield et al., 1966; Fink et al., 1967; Fink and Martin, 1967; Martin, 1967; Martin and Talal, 1968; Oeschger and Hartman, 1970). The degree of polarity is a function of map position of the mutation (Fink and Martin, 1967; Martin and Talal, 1968). Frameshift mutations are polar because they generate nonsense codons (Martin, 1967). Missense mutations are uniformly nonpolar. Out of over 1000 mutations examined, only one absolutely polar mutation that maps within the structural genes of the operon has been found (stable mutation hisD984, S. A. McIntire and J. C. Loper, personal communication); all other mutations with absolute polarity have genetic defects in the operator-promotor region (Ames et al., 1963; Atkins and Loper, 1970; D. B. Fankhauser, personal communication). The rarity of absolute polar mutations in structural genes of the Salmonella his operon contrasts with E. coli K12, where absolute polar insertions of possibly redundant DNA sequences frequently are found in the structural genes of the lac and gal operons (cf. Malamy, 1970; Michaelis et al., 1969).
H. CROSS-REACTING MATERIAL(CRM) Examination of the data in Table 1 shows that only one mutation (Db802) out of 13 multisite mutations allows production of a protein that serologically cross-reacts with wild-type enzyme. About one fifth of strains carrying stable mutations contain CRM. These CRM-positive strains are thought to contain in-phase deletions with mutant protein one or more amino acids shorter than the wildtype. CRM is absent from the 35 revertible frameshift mutants examined (Table 1, NG- ICR- strains without letter suffixes; NG- ICR+ strains). Two out of 62 nonsense mutants examined for CRM contain cross-reacting material. One of these is an amber mutation, hisC487, that maps a t the extreme end of the hisC gene, distal to over 140 other point mutations (Martin and Talal, 1968; Fig. 1 ) . The second, hisB689, is an amber or ochre mutation that maps in the hisB gene, distal to a t least 50 point mutations but, by three-point tests, proximal to a t least 5 other point mutations (Fig. 1 ) . As expected from the high incidence
26
PHILIP HARTMAN, ZLATA HARTMAN, RUTH STAHL, BRUCE AMES
of nonsense mutations among 2AP-induced auxotrophs, CRM-negative strains predominate among 2AP-induced mutants. Approximately half of the missense mutations contain CRM, and the other half are CRMnegative (Loper, 1961; Whitfield et al., 1966; Margolies and Goldberger, 1968; Greeb et al., 1971).
I. SPONTANEOUS MUTATIONS If one disregards nonpolar (missense) mutations, the data in the top two lines of Table 2 indicate that spontaneous his mutations are similar in distribution in strain LT2 whether selected through penicillin or selected directly for polarity. About one fourth of the mutations are nonsense mutations and three fourths are frameshifts and deletions. Extended deletions (multisite mutations) and stable mutations (“short” deletions) together are about as common as revertible frameshift mutations. As pointed out above (see Section IV,C) , spontaneous mutations and mutations induced by all agents tested except the ICR compounds rarely include the type of frameshift mutation that is reverted both with ICR and with NG; such mutations have been interpreted as “plus” frameshifts, perhaps most commonly single-base additions. Thus, it would seem that deletion of genetic material in Salmonella is a relatively common event in mutant production. Spontaneous mutations in strain LT7 are predominantly base substitutions, since many lines of LT7 contain one or two mutator genes which seem to elicit substitutions (Kirchner, 1960). J. SCREENING POTENTIAL MUTAGENS Particular mutants have been chosen from among those reported here for use in rapid, spot-test screening of various compounds for mutagenic activity (Ames, 1971; Smith, 1966; Hartman et al., 1971). The sensitivity of tests for mutagenicity in some of the strains has been increased by the placement of additional mutations that limit repair of genetic lesions (Ames, 1971). Methodology underlying these tests and their utility in the mass-screening of potentially deleterious substances has been reviewed by Ames (1971).
K. INTRAGENIC COMPLEMENTATION Complementation has been observed in vivo among mutants of genes D , B, I , and E, respectively (Hartman et al., 1960a; Loper et al., 1964).
Three of the genes contain two basic complementation groups while the
MUTATIONS IN THE HISTIDINE
OPERON OF
Salmonella
27
fourth gene ( B ) contains four basic groups. Table 1 and Fig. 1 list noncoinplementing mutations as Dab, Ba-d, lab, and Eab ; complementing mutations are designated Da, Db, etc. Noncomplementing mutations are largely of the nonsense, frameshift and deletion classes, but noncomplementing missense mutations also are frequent. Complementing mutations are largely missense but also include a few multisite and some stable mutations (probably all in-phase, nonpolar deletions). Several nonsense and frameshift mutations in the terminal portions of genes D,B , and I also exhibit intragenic complementation in vivo (Fig. 1). All CRM-positive mutations tested in genes B (Loper, 1961) and D (Greeb et al., 1971) complement in vivo; some CRM-negative mutations also complement. The proteins of these latter strains probably undergo transformations to immunologically unrecognizable forms during extraction. Thus, in vivo complementation appears to be a more sensitive test for protein with minor alterations than does detection of CRM. On the other hand, detection of CRM may be equally sensitive to in vitro complementation or the assay of “secondary” residual enzyme function in cases where each of these activities occurs (Loper, 1961). Gene D codes an enzyme with two identical subunits (Loper, 1968; Yourno, 1968; Lew and Roth, 1971) and the gene B product shows evidence of subunit structure (Vasington and LeBeau, 1967). The relationship between the genetic map (Fig. 1 ) and the complementation map (Loper et al., 1964) appears complex for gene B. No intragenic complementation has been observed among mutants of genes G, C, A , and F , respectively (Loper et al., 1964). The tests include missense mutations in each case. While gene A specifies a protein functional as a monomer (Margolies and Goldberger, 1967), multimeric proteins built of identical polypeptide chains are specified by genes G (hexamer-Voll et al., 1967) and C (dimer-Yourno et al., 1970; Rechler and Bruni, 1971). Therefore, while the observation of intragenic complementation is an indicator of multimeric enzyme structure, lack of observed intragenic complementation does not ensure that the “native” gene product is a monomeric enzyme.
L. GENE-ENZYMERELATIONSHIPS The enzymology of histidine biosynthesis has been reviewed (Martin
et al., 1971), as have gene-enzyme relationships in Salmonella (Loper et al., 1964; Ames et al., 1967), and aspects of regulation (Ames et al., 1967; Brenner and Ames, 1971). There still remains uncertainty as to the number of polypeptide chains involved in the structures of the enzymes coded for by genes B, H , F , I, and E. Complementation
28
PHILIP HARTMAN, ZLATA HARTMAN, RUTH STAHL, BRTJBE AMES
behavior among B mutants was mentioned above. I n addition, we have noted in abortive transduction tests relatively weak complementation between a class of B mutants and a class of H mutants that we now recognize as nonsense and frameshift mutants. Whether these results are due to protein-protein interactions of gene products or to termination of transcription and consequent polarity (or to both) remains uncertain. The structure(s) of the I and E enzyme(s) also awaits elucidation. The sedimentation profiles of these two activities are very similar (Whitfield et al., 1964). The complementation patterns and map positions of mutations (Fig. 1) do not allow definite interpretation. Nonsense and frameshift mutations in gene I fail to complement E mutants, but this could be due to polarity rather than to dictation of a unit polypeptide chain by the entire E-I region. In addition, a mutation that has been thoroughly examined and classified as missense (hisI333) fails to complement either E or I mutants. Purely genetic tests cannot differentiate between several possibilities of enzyme structure for the product of this gene region. M. GENETICMAPPING Much of the genetic mapping has relied upon the all-or-none presence of wild-type recombinants in crosses involving stable deletion strains as recipients. Three-point tests have utilized double his- strains, in which case prototrophic (His+)recombinants are scored, or hishis0 double mutants, in which case the his0 serves as an unselected marker whose segregation in the cross is followed. Mapping in the operator region has relied exclusively upon three-point tests (D. B. Fankhauser, unpublished). With numerous and carefully performed three-point tests, the order of mutant sites often can be determined unambiguously, but cases do occur in which an unambiguous order cannot be established by this method (cf. Loper et al., 1964; Martin and Talal, 1968). The behavior in recombination tests appears to be an inherent property of the alleles involved in the cross. This was tested by transducing hisBl2 and hisB24, two frameshifts that fail to recombine with each other, into a standard genetic background. Even in isogenic stocks, 24 recombines severalfold more freely (i.e., produces an excess of wild-type recombinants) than does 1.2 in crosses with mutations located to either side of the mutant pair. In spite of the above difficulties, accurate two-point transduction tests do indicate that the histidine genes shown in Fig. 1 lie closely adjacent and do not bear lengthy “spacers” or other genes between them (J. Bagshaw and P. E. Hartman, unpublished, 1965). The experiments in-
MUTATIONS IN THE HISTIDINE OPERON OF
Salmonella
29
volve reciprocal crossing of several point-mutations mapping in one end of a gene with several mutations mapping in che nearest portion of the adjacent gene. These recombination figures ar2 then contrasted to those obtained in similar crosses that, for example, involve mutations a t opposite ends of the same gene. The data are expressed in terms of p, the average probability of a crossover separathg the two markers to yield wildtype recombinants (Hartman, et al., 1960b; Loper et al., 1964). Values obtained are the following: across D , 0.182; D-C, 0.024; across C 0.092; beginning of D to beginning of C, 0.221; end of D to end of C , 0.153; C-B, 0.031; across F , 0.205; F-I, 0.038; across I , 0.114; I to middle of E , 0.066. These are overestimates of the sizes of possible intergenic spaces since we now have mutations located closer to the ends of some genes than those utilized and, as pointed out below, there is evidence that mutations are not distributed randomly and that a t least the proximal portions of some genes are relatively insusceptible to mutation. Also, negative interference would maximize the smaller map distances. Rechler and Martin (1970) have begun an analysis of the D-C intercistronic divide, and a similar approach is being used to obtain information pertaining to the G-D intercistronic divide (J. Yourno, I. Ino, and P. E. Hartman, unpublished, 1970). Frameshift mutations are not randomly distributed in the histidine operon; they are clustered in particular regions (Oeschger and Hartman, 1970; and Fig. 1). In addition, nonsense and frameshift mutations (chain-terminating mutations) are frequent and missense mutations are infrequent in the proximal regions of several genes. The ratio of nonsense and frameshift mutations to missense mutations for proximal regions are (hisG, 7 : l ; hisD, 1 5 : l ; hisB, 9 : l ; hisC, 11:5; h i d , 8:6; hisF, 5:14; and hisl, 11:l (7 nonsense and 4 frameshifts). I n contrast, as the extreme example, mutations in the remaining (distal) portion of the hid gene are 10 missense, 1 nonsense, and no frameshifts. Mutations in the most distal portion of the operon, hisE, comprise 15 missense, 4 nonsense, and no frameshifts. Thus, no frameshifts have been observed in the terminal segment of the operon. I n region CIV, the distal end of the hisC gene, there is clustering of mutations of similar type: 1 missense-8 frameshifts-6 missense-8 amber mutations (Martin and Talal, 1968). V. Summary
Over 1500 histidine-requiring mutants of independent origin have been mapped in the histidine operon of S. typhimurium. About 1000 mutants have been characterized as to type of mutation. The type
30
PHILIP HARTMAN, ZLATA HARTMAN, RUTH STAHL, BRUCE AMES
of mutation (extended deletions; frameshifts of the plus and minus types; base pair substitutions causing missense or nonsense) has been determined for each mutant by the collective results of recombination tests, analysis of the pattern of spontaneous, N-methyl-N’-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine, and acridine half-mustard induced reversion, and the presence of suppressors among revertants. The type of mutation is correlated with polarity in the operon, presence of immunologically detectable cross-reacting protein, complementation, and genetic map position. The spectrum of spontaneously occurring histidine-requiring mutants is compared with that found after treatment of bacteria with a number of widely used mutagens. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We owe ever so much to Dr. Milislav Demerec. This work also has depended upon fine collaboration and stimulating discussions with Drs. R. F. Goldberger, J. C. Loper, and R. G. Martin as well as with Drs. G. R. Fink, J. R. Roth, H. J. Whitfield, Jr., and J. Yourno, and many other associates through the years. It was supported, in part, by Research Grant A141650 of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, US. Public Health Service to PEH, and AEC Grant (11-1)34 Agreement 156 to BNA. Dr. Hugh J. Creech, Institute for Cancer Research, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, kindly supplied each of the ICR compounds used in our tests. Mrs. Margaret W. Nolley brought illustrative order to Fig. 1, and Mrs. Kathryn Levine assisted in proofreading. Contribution number 621 of the Department of Biology.
REFERENCES Ames, B. N., 1971. The detection of chemical mutagens with enteric bacteria. In “Chemical Mutagens : Principles and Methods for Their Detection” (A. Hollaender, ed.), Vol. 1, pp. 267-282. Plenum, New York. Ames, B. N., and Garry, B. 1959. Coordinate repression of the synthesis of four histidine biosynthetic enzymes by histidine. Proc. Nut. Acad. Sci. U.S. 45, 1453-1461.
Ames, B. N., and Whitfield, H. J., Jr. 1966. Frameshift mutagenesis in Salmonella. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 31,221-225. Ames, B. N., Garry, B., and Herzenberg, L. A. 1960. The genetic control of the enzymes of histidine biosynthesis in Salmonella typhimurium. J. Gen. Microbiol. 28, 369-378.
Ames, B. N., Hartman, P. E., and Jacob F. 1963. Chromosomal alterations affecting the regulation of histidine biosynthetic enzymes in Salmonella. J . Mol. Biol. 7, 23-42. Ames, B. N., Goldberger, R. F., Hartman, P. E., Martin, R. G., and Roth, J. R. 1967. The histidine operon. In “Regulation of Nucleic Acid and Protein
MUTATIONS IN THE HISTIDINE OPERON OF
Salmonella
31
Biosynthesis” (V. V. Konigsberger and L. Bosch, ed.), pp. 272-287, Elsevier, Amsterdam. Anderson, C. W. 1970. Spontaneous deletion formation in several classes of E. coli mutants deficient in recombination ability. Mutat. Res. 9, 155-165. A n t h , D. N. 1968. Histidine regulatory mutants in Salmonella typhimurium. V. Two new classes of histidine regulatory mutants. J. Mol. Biol. 33, 533-546. Atkins, J. F., and Loper, J. C. 1970. Transcription initiation in the histidine operon of Salmonella typhimurium. Proc. Nut. Acad. Sci. U.S. 6.5, 925-932. Berger, H., Brammar, W. J., and Yanofsky, C. 1968. Spontaneous and ICR191-Ainduced frameshift mutations in the A gene of Escherichia coli tryptophan synthetase. J . Bacteriol. 96, 167Z1679. Berkowitz, D., Hushon, J. M., Whitfield, H. J., Jr., Roth, J., and Ames, B. N. 1968. Procedure for identifying nonsense mutations. J . Bacteriol. 96,215-220. Brenner, M., and Ames, B. N. 1971. The histidine operon and its regulation. In “Metabolic Regulation” (H. J. Vogel, ed.) [Vol. 5 of “Metabolic Pathways”-D. Greenberg, ed.1, pp. 349-387. Academic Press, New York. Demerec, M. 1955. What is a gene?-Twenty years later. Amer. Natur. 89, 5-20. Demerec, M. 1956. A comparative study of certain gene loci in Salmonella. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Bwl. 21, 113-121. Demerec, M., and Demerec, Z. E. 1956. Analysis of linkage relationships in Salmonella by transduction techniques. Brookhaven Symp. Biol. 8, 75-84. Demerec, M., Blomstrand, I., and Demerec, Z. E. 1955. Evidence of complex loci in Salmonella. Proc. Nut. Acad. Sci. U.S. 41, 359-364. Demerec, M., Hartman, Z., Hartman, P. E., Yura, T., Gots, J. S., Ozeki, H., and Glover, S. W. 1956. Genetic Studies with Bacteria, Carnegie Inst. Wash. Publ. 612, 136 pp. Drake, J. W. 1970. “The Molecular Basis of Mutation.” Holden-Day, San Francisco, California. Eisenstark, A,, Eisenstark, R., and Van Sickle, R. 1965. Mutation of Salmonella typhimurium by nitrosoguanidine. Mutat. Res. 2, 1-10. Ferretti, J. J. 1971. Low-level reading of the UGA triplet in SaZmonella typhimurium. J . Bacteriol. 106, 691-693. Fink, G. R., and Martin, R. G. 1967. Translation and polarity in the histidine operon. 11. Polarity in the histidine operon. J. Mol. Biol. 30, 97-107. Fink, G. R., Klopotowski, T., and Ames, B. N. 1967. Histidine regulatory mutants of Salmonella typhimurium. IV. A positive selection for polar histidine-requiring mutants from histidine operator constitutive mutants. J. Mol. Biol. 30, 81-95. Franklin, N. C. 1967. Extraordinary recombinational events in Escherichia coli. Their independence of the rec+ function. Genetics 55, 699-707. Garrick-Silversmith, L., and Hartman, P. E. 1970. Histidine-requiring mutants of Escherichia coli K12, Genetics 66, 231-244. Goldschmidt, E. P., Cater, M. S., Matney, T. S., Butler, M. A,, and Greene, A. 1970. Genetic analysis of the histidine operon in Escherichia coli K12. Genetics, 66, 219-229. Greeb, J., Atkins, J. F., and Loper, J. C. 1971. Histidinol dehydrogenase (hisD) mutants of Salmonella typhimurium. J. Bacteriol. 106, 421431. Hartman, P. E., Hartman, Z., and Serman, D. 1960a. Complementation mapping by abortive transduction of histidine-requiring Salmonella mutants. J. Gen. MicTobiol. 22, 354-368. Hartman, P. E., Loper, J. C., and Serman, D. 1960b. Fine structure mapping by
32
PHILIP HARTMAN, ZLATA HARTMAN, RUTH STAHL, BRUCE AMES
complete transduction between histidine-requiring Salmonella mutants. J . Gen. Microbiol. 22, 323-353. Hartman, P. E., Levine, K., Hartman, Z., and Berger, H. 1971. Hycanthone: a fremeshift mutagen. Science 172, 1058-1060. Inselberg, J. 1967. Formation of deletion mutations in recombination-deficient mutants of Escherichia coli. J . Bacteriol. 94, 12661267. Jacob, F., and Monod, J. 1961. Genetic regulatory mechanisms in the synthesis of proteins. J. Mol. Biol. 3, 318-356. Kirchner, C. E. J. 1960. The effects of the mutator gene on molecular changes and mutation in Salmonella typhimurium. J . Mol. Biol. 2, 331-338. Lawley, P. D. 1968. Methylation of DNA by N-methyl-N-nitrosourethane and Nmethyl-N-nitroso-N’-nitroguanidine.Nature 218, 580-581. Lew, K. K., and Roth, J. R. 1971. Genetic approaches to determination of enzyme quaternary structure. Biochemistry 10, 204-207. Loper, J. C. 1961. Enzyme complementation in mixed extracts of mutants from the Salmonella histidine B locus. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U.S. 47, 1440-1450. Loper, J. C. 1968. Histidinol dehydrogenase from Salmonella typhimurium. J . Biol. Chem. 243, 3264-3272. Loper, J. C., Grabnar, M., Stahl, R. C., Hartman, Z., and Hartman, P. E. 1964. Genes and proteins involved in histidine biosynthesis in Salmonella. Brookhaven Symp. Biol. 17, 15-50. Malamy, M. 1970. Some properties of insertion mutations in the lac operon. I n “The Lactose Operon” (J. R. Beckwith and D. Zipser, eds.), pp. 359-373. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, New York. Margolies, M. N., and Goldberger, R. F. 1967. Physical and chemical characterization of the isomerase of histidine biosynthesis in Salmonella typhimurium. J . Biol. Chem. 242, 256-264. Margolies, M. N., and Goldberger, R. F. 1968. Correlation between mutation type and the production of cross-reacting material in mutants of the A gene of the histidine operon in Salmonella typhimurium. J. Bacteriol. 95, 507-519. Martin, R. G. 1967. Frameshift mutants in the histidine operon of Salmonella typhimurium. J. MoZ. Biol. 26, 311328. Martin, R. G., and Talal, N. 1968. Translation and polarity in the histidine operon. IV. Relation of polarity to map position in hisC. J. Mol. Biol. 36, 219-229. Martin, R. G., Berberich, M. A., Ames, B. N., Davis, W. W., Goldberger, R. F., and Yourno, J. 1971. In “Methods in Enzymology,” Vol. 17B (C. Tabor and H. Tabor, eds.), pp. 3-44. Academic Press, New York. Marver, D., Berberich, M. A., and Goldberger, R. F. 1966. Correlation between location and time of expression for genes in a single operon. Science 153, 1655-1656. Michaelis, G., Saedler, H., Venkov, P., and Starlinger, P. 1969. Two insertions in the galactose operon having different sizes but homologous DNA sequences. Mol. Gen. Genet. 104, 371-377. Murray, M. L., and Klopotowski, T. 1968. Genetic map position of the gluconate-6phosphate dehydrogenase gene in Salmonella typhimurium. J. Bacteriol. 95, 1279-1282. Nikaido, H., Levinthal, M., Nikaido, K., and Nakane, K. 1967. Extended deletions in the histidine-rough-B region of the Salmonella chromosome. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U.S. 57, 1825-1832.
MUTATIONS IN THE HISTIDINE OPERON OF
Salmonella
33
Oeschger, N. S., and Hartman, P. E. 1970. ICR-induced frameshift mutations in the histidine operon of Salmonella. J . Bacteriol. 101, 490-504. Rechler, M. M., and Bruni, C. B. 1971. Properties of a fused protein formed by genetic manipulation. J . Biol. Chem. 246, 1806-1813. Rechler, M. M., and Martin, R. G. 1970. The intercistronic divide: Translation of an intercistronic region in the histidine operon of Salmonella typhimurium. Nature 226, 908-911. Riddle, D. L., and Roth, J. 1970. Suppressors of frameshift mutations in Salmonella typhimurium. J. Mol. Biol. 54, 131-144. Rogan, E. G., and Bessman, M. J. 1970. Studies on the pathway of incorporation of 2-aminopurine into the deoxyribonucleic acid of Escherichia coli. J. Bacteriol. 103, 622-633. Roth, J. 1970. UGA nonsense mutations in Salmonella typhimurium. J . Bacteriol. 102, 467475. Rothman-Denes, L., and Martin, R. G. 1971. Two mutations in the first gene of the histidine operon of Salmonella typhimurium affecting control. J. Bacteriol. 106, 227-237. St. Pierre, M. 1968. Mutations creating a new initiation point for expression of the histidine operon in XalmoneEla typhimurium. J. Mol. Biol. 35, 71-82. Sanderson, K. E. 1970. A current linkage map of Salmonella typhimurium. Bacteriol. Rev. 34, 176-193. Schwartz, D. O., and Beckwith, J. R. 1969. Mutagens which cause deletions in Escherichia coli. Genetics 61, 371-376. Sheppard, D. E. 1964. Mutants of Salmonella typhimurium resistant to feedback inhibition by L-histidine. Genetics 50, 611-623. Smith, D. W. E. 1966. Mutagenicity of cycasin aglycone (methylazomethanol), a naturally occurring carcinogen. Science 152, 1273-1274. Vasington, F. D., and LeBeau, P. 1967. Sedimentation properties of the enzymes of the histidine B gene. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 26, 153-161. Venetianer, P., Berberich, M. A., and Goldberger, R. F. 1968. Studies on the size of the messenger-RNA transcribed from the histidine operon during simultaneous and sequential derepression. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 166, 124-133. Vogel, H. J., and Bonner, D. M. 1956. Acetylornithinase of Escherichia coli: partial purification and some properties. J . Biol. Chem. 218, 97-106. Voll, M. J. 1967. Translation and polarity in the histidine operon. 111. The isolation of prototrophic polar mutations. J. Mol. Biol. 30, 109-124. Voll, M. J., Appella, E., and Martin, R. G. 1967. Purification and composition studies of phosphoribosyl-adenosine triphosphate: pyrophosphate phosphoribosyltransferase, the first enzyme of histidine biosynthesis. J. Biol. Chem. 242, 1760-1767. Whitfield, H. J., Jr., Smith, D. W. E., and Martin, R. G. 1964. Sedimentation properties of the enzymes of the histidine operon. J . Biol. Chem. 239, 32883291. Whitfield, H. J., Jr., Martin, R. G., and Ames, B. N. 1966. Classification of aminotransferase (C gene) mutants in the histidine operon. J. Mol. Biol. 21, 335-355. Yourno, J. 1968. Composition and subunit structure of histidinol dehydrogenase from Salmonella typhimurium. J. Biol. Chem. 243,3277-3288. Yourno, J., and Heath, S. 1969. Nature of the hisDSO18 frameshift mutation in Salmonella typhimurium. J. Bacteriol. 100, 460-168.
34
PHILIP HARTMAN, ZLATA HARTMAN, RUTH STAHL, BRUCE AMES
Yourno, J. and Tanemura, S. 1970. Restoration of in-phase translation by an unlinked suppressor of a frameshift mutation in SalmoneEla typhimurium. Nature (London) 225, 422426. Yourno, J., Barr, D., and Tanemura, S. 1969. Externally suppressible frameshift mutant of Salmonella typhimurium. J . Bacteriol. 100,453-459. Yourno, J., Kohno, T., and Roth, J. R. 1970. Enzyme evolution: Generation of a bifunctional enzyme by fusion of adjacent genes. Nature 228, 82M24. Zinder, N. D.,and Lederberg, J. 1952. Genetic exchange in Salmonella. J . Bacteriol. 64, 679-699.
Genetics of the Enterobacteriaceae A. GENETIC HOMOLOGY IN THE ENTEROBACTERIACEAE Kenneth E. Sanderson* Department of Biology, The University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta
Introduction. . . . . . . . Glossary of Abbreviations. . . . Concepts of Microbial Taxonomy. . Use of Genetic Data in Systematics . A. Genetic Transfer . . . . . B. Genetic Recombination. . . . C. Comparisons of the Linkage Maps V. Use of Data on Protein Structure. . VI. Summary. . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . .
I. 11. 111. IV.
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . 3 5 . . 36 . .37 . .39 . . 40 . . 41 . .43 . .47 . .48 . .49
I. Introduction
The main thrust of the work of Dr. M. Demerec was toward a clearer view of the structure of the gene, of mutation, and of the nature of gene action. His work on maize, on Drosophila, and on Delphinium, through the 1920s and 1930s, was concerned mainly with gene structure and mutation. I n the 1930s and 1940s he analyzed the effect of environmental agents, first ionizing and non-ionizing radiation, and later chemicals, on the genetic properties of Drosophila, of bacteria, and of bacteriophages. The discovery of transduction provided a means of genetic exchange in bacteria, with which he began an analysis of the fine structure of genetic material which led to his detailed observations of clusters of genes for related functions. A bibliography of Dr. Demerec’s papers is found a t the end of this volume (p. 349).
* The author acknowledges support from the National Research Council of Canada through an Operating Grant, and from the National Science Foundation of the United States through Grant GB-20464. 35
36
KENNETH E. SANDERSON
Through his entire life, Dr. Demerec’s interest in organisms as experimental subjects was primarily in terms of their suitability for the solution of particular problems of genetics. However, in the 1950s and 1960s, while Dr. Demerec’s interest in gene structure, function, and mutation did not diminish, he also began to see the possibilities of genetic analysis to give information on taxonomic relationships in the Enterobacteriaceae. This analysis was presented in several papers (Demerec and Ohta, 1964; Demerec and New, 1965; Demerec, 1965; Ino and Demerec, 1968; St. Pierre and Demerec, 1968). This present group of three papers by Middleton and Mojica-a (this volume), by Brenner and Falkow (this volume), and by myself, reviews the work of Dr. Demerec, and others, and presents new data on the genetic and molecular relationships in the Enterobacteriaceae. It is the purpose of this paper to summarize the present data, which indicate considerable similarities of linkage maps in different members of the Enterobacteriaceae, and to try to evaluate this comparison in terms of systematics. The paper by Middleton and Mojica-a (this volume) reviews data, collected by Demerec and his associates, as well as by others, on genetic intercrosses between members of the Enterobacteriaceae ; these data reveal that the frequency of recombination in crosses between different genera, e.g., Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium, is usually quite low. In addition, Brenner and Falkow (this volume) discuss the molecular relationships among the Enterobacteriaceae based on methods of DNA-DNA and DNA-RNA hybridization. The purpose of these three contributions is to evaluate the present state of knowledge in these areas in which Dr. Demerec’s work was important.
II. Glossary of Abbreviations aromatic amino acid lac lactose nonutilization requirement nic nicotinamide requirement biotin requirement bio Pro proline requirement chl PYr pyrimidine requirement chlorate resistance cysteine requirement thi thiamine requirement CYS galactose nonutilisation thr threonine requirement gal hag, H I , H 2 H-antigen defective thy thymine requirement host specificity tna tryptophanase hap histidine requirement hut trP tryptophan requirement inositol fermentation in1 uvr ultraviolet light resistance ZY 1 xylose nonutilization aro
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : GENETIC HOMOLOGY
37
Ill. Concepts of Microbial Taxonomy
According to Dobzhansky’s concept of the genetic nature of species, ‘(Species are formed when a once actually or potentially interbreeding array of Mendelian populations becomes segregated in two or more reproductively isolated arrays. Species are, accordingly, groups of populations the gene exchange between which is limited or prevented in nature by one, or by a combination of several, reproductive isolating mechanisms.” These reproductive isolating mechanisms may be of two general types. Firstly, geographic isolation prevents two populations from interbreeding due t o spatial separation. Secondly, reproductive isolation, which prevents populations sharing the same habitat from interbreeding, may function by ecological or behavioral factors, or due to an inability of intercrosses to form fertile hybrids. The continuous process of interbreeding between organisms of the same species makes the species of sexually cross-breeding organisms generally recognizable by different investigators, regardless of the traits these investigators are using to differentiate their species. Agreement about classification to lower ranks, such as subspecies and races, or to higher ranks, such as families and orders, is much more difficult to achieve. Dobzhansky excluded the asexual species from his genetic definition of the species. He pointed out that those plant groups most difficult to classify into species were usually those with mainly asexual or selffertilization mechanisms. In these species, while variation is not completely continuous, the range of variation of each species is often greater than in sexual species, and the phenotypes are clustered around certain “adaptive peaks.’’ However, these species are not real entities, unified through exchange of genes, but only clusters of separate clones of similar phenotypes. Dobzhansky considered the bacteria to be examples of asexual species. In the past few years, three new factors have entered the field of bacterial taxonomy. Genetic exchange has been discovered in several new groups of organisms, including the bacteria. This has enabled a new look at the systematics of these groups, and such examinations have already been undertaken (Marmur et al., 1963; Mandel, 1969; Jones and Sneath, 1970). At about the same time, the concept of separation of bacterial species by individual characteristics in the manner dictated by the use of a key was not always satisfactory as more information became available, and this has generated the field of numerical taxonomy. I n numerical taxonomy, all the information comparing two
38
KENNETH E. SANDERSON
groups is used to decide on their relationship, and characters are often weighted equally (Davis and Heywood, 1963). The large amount of data used necessitates mathematical treatment and the use of high-speed computers. Over the same period, the field of molecular biology has enabled the measurement of a number of characteristics which may turn out to be of crucial importance in making valid decisions on taxonomic relations. Direct comparison of the genetic material of two organisms is possible from DNA-DNA or DNA-RNA hybridization methods, and direct comparison of proteins, a product which closely reflects the sequence of nucleotides of the genetic material, is possible through studies of amino acid sequence. In the remainder of this section, the theoretical basis for the use in bacterial systematics of data derived from the first of these new approaches, the use of intercrosses, will be considered. In the bacteria, a large number of groups has been demonstrated to be capable of genetic exchange. However, the fact that genetic exchange is possible or even proven to occur in nature cannot be taken to indicate that bacteria exist as Mendelian populations. True Mendelian populations can exist only in those species which have an obligate sexual cycle in each generation, and in which cross-fertilization rather than self-fertilization is normally or always used. In the bacteria, reproduction is normally the product of asexual division, and genetic exchange operates independently of reproduction, for genetic exchange is not necessary for reproduction. As indicated earlier, one of the isolating mechanisms which separate populations of sexually reproducing organ'isms and create species is the inability of individuals of the two populations to intercross to produce fertile hybrids. In nature, such inability may be due to ecological, seasonal, or behavioral characteristics which can be bypassed in the laboratory so that fertile hybrids may be technically possible between species which do not normally hybridize in nature. However, formation of fertile hybrids between separate Mendelian populations is often impossible, even in laboratory conditions, and such inability may indicate separate species. Genetic crossing in bacteria can be used to produce a type of taxonomic analysis similar to that in higher organisms. Crosses in bacteria differ from those in higher plants and animals in several respects: the parents are usually haploid, rather than diploid or of higher ploidy; the donor parent usually transfers only part of its genetic material to form a merozygote, rather than a holozygote as in the higher organisms; no meiosis intervenes in the life cycle; and segregation to re-form the haploid often occurs immediately after transfer. To enable an analogy
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : GENETIC HOMOLOGY
39
to crossing in higher organisms, the entire process in bacteria may be considered as two stages. First, genetic transfer is the transmission of genetic material from one cell to another; this genetic material may or may not replicate, and may or may not integrate into the recipient chromosome. Second, genetic recombination will be used in this artiple to refer to the process of integration of genetic material of the donor into the recipient chromosome, with subsequent replication. Transfer must precede recombination, but recombination need not occur following transfer. Genetic transfer is considered analogous to the formation of a hybrid in crosses between diploid, sexual organisms. Such hybrids may be formed in higher organisms in crosses between quite unrelated organisms, in which case the hybrid will usually be sterile. Sterility of hybrids is due to two major reasons, genic and chromosomal. Genic sterility results in failure of the hybrid to produce functional meiotic cells, or to produce gametes after meiosis. Chromosomal sterility results from a failure of homologous chromosomes of the hybrid to pair normally, to form bivalents, and to disjoin normally at anaphase (Dobzhansky, 1951). The corollary is that the formation of a fertile hybrid indicates sufficient genomic relationship to permit synapsis and crossing-over. Thus we may draw an analogy between the formation of a sterile hybrid due to chromosomal sterility in higher organisms, where the chromosomes can function but are not sufficiently homologous to pair, and formation of a merozygote between bacterial species where the hybrid is formed but recombination does not occur as measured by a failure of integration of the donor genes into the chromosome of the recipient. This may indicate about the same degree of relationship. The formation of a fertile hybrid in higher organisms indicates a greater degree of relationship, though it does not prove that the parents belong to the same species. In the bacteria, the observation of a high frequency of integration of genetic material of the donor into the chromosome of the recipient may be taken to indicate a similar level of relationship. To summarize, genetic transfer without recombination in bacteria, and formation of a sterile hybrid in higher organisms, suggests that the parents have a low order of relationship. Genetic transfer and recombination, as detected by integration in bacteria, is analogous t o the formation of fertile hybrids in higher organisms, and indicates a closer degree of relationship.
IV.
Use of Genetic Data in Systematics
There are two types of genetic data of value to the systematics of the Enterobacteriaceae. First, there are data on transfer and recombina-
40
KENNETH E. SANDERSON
tion from genetic crosses; the theoretical basis for the use of these data was described in the previous section. Second, the similarity of the linkage map in terms of locations of genes for identical functions can be compared among the members of this group. The value of the genetic map as a taxonomic criterion has not been clear up to now, and an attempt will be made to evaluate it.
A. GENETICTRANSFER Data on intercrosses between species and genera have been derived primarily by phage-mediated transduction and by episome-mediated conjugation. Transduction has two disadvantages, the narrow host ranges of the few transducing phages available, and the fact that only small pieces of chromosome can be transmitted. Use of the process of conjugation has produced more data, since transfer between genera is not limited by phage sensitivity. Jones and Sneath (1970) have summarized the data from many authors who have studied the transfer of episomes such as R-factors, F-prime factors, and col-factors, and they conclude that intercrosses between the following genera are frequently or invariably successful in the transfer of the episome from the donor to the recipient: Escherichia, Shigella, Salmonella, Klebsiella, Serratia, Citrobacter, and Proteus. Other groups to which transfer from the above genera was less frequent are Providence, Enterobacter, Hafnia, Aerobacter, Arizona, Vibrio, Yersinia (a part of the Pasteurella group) , and Alcaligenes. It is clear that genetic transfer is possible over a very broad range of genera, to all or almost all of the genera normally placed in the family Enterobacteriaceae (Edwards and Ewing, 1962) , and even to some usually placed in other families, such as Vibrio, Pasteurella, and Alcaligenes (Breed, Murray, and Smith, 1957). The frequencies of transfer obtained in crosses between different genera show a wide range of variability. I n fact, intercrosses involving different strains of one genus with different strains of another genus have also shown considerable variability. A number of factors which may be of only peripheral systematic importance affect the success of genetic transfer, factors such as host restriction and modification, and success in the formation of conjugation bridges between cells of different species. However, as pointed out in the previous section, genetic transfer does not prove close relationship, and so we must examine data on genetic recombination (integration) .
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : GENETIC HOMOLOGY
41
B. GENETICRECOMBINATION Intercrosses between different strains of E. coli, such as E. coli K12 Hfr X E . coli B F- (Boyer, 1964) and E. coli K12 Hfr X E. coli C F(Lieb et al., 1955) have shown a high level of acceptance and integration of the chromosomal genes of the donor by the recipient, though the frequencies of recombination are in some cases reduced by host restriction. Apparently, all the strains of E . coli so far tested belong to a single species by a genetic definition, which is the ability to give stable, integrated recombinants on intercrossing. Luria and Burrous (1957) crossed E . coli K12 Hfr X Shigella dysenteriae, and found that the frequency of recombinants was reduced by a factor of to from the frequency found with E . coli Hfr X E . coli F- crosses, but most of the hybrids were stable, indicating that the donor genes had integrated in the recipient chromosome. Falkow et al. ( 1963) and Schneider and Falkow (1964) found a reduction of only 10-1 to in crosses of E . coli K12 Hfr X Shigella flezneri F-, as compared to homologous E. coli crosses, with over 90% of the recombinants stable. Crosses of E . coli Hfr strains to other genera of the Enterobacteriaceae have revealed a different pattern, for the frequency of recombinants isolated is much lower, or undetectable, and in a high proportion of these recombinants the donor fragment does not integrate, but remains as a stable partial diploid. Crosses of E. coli Hfr to S. typhimurium F- (Baron et al., 1959; Miyake and Demerec, 1959; Zinder, 1960; Falkow et al., 1962) gave a low frequency of recombination for chromosomal genes (lo-* to though this frequency could be increased by lo4 by selection of F- lines which have enhanced recipient ability, apparently due to loss of their capacity for restriction of E. coli DNA (Okada et al., 1968; Colson et al., 1969). Baron et al. (1968) reviewed the results of crosses of E . coli Hfr to Salmonella typhosa and S. typhimurium, and concluded that the formation of recombinants is reduced to to 10-3 from homologous E. coli x E . coli crosses, and that in very few if any of the recombinants are the E . coli genes integrated into the chromosome with the elimination of the Salmonella genes to form a stable haploid. The initial conclusions were based on the observation that when the donor gene is dominant, as is usually the case, segregation of the hybrid with recovery of the recessive recipient phenotype was usually observed. However, the use of recessive genes from the donor, such as auxotrophy or streptomycin resistance, showed a low frequency of integration. In contrast, Demerec and Ohta (1964), Demerec and
42
KENNETH E. SANDERSON
New (1965) , Demerec (1965), Ino and Demerec (1968) , and St. Pierre and Demerec (1968) reported on transduction studies using E. coli H f r X S. typhimurium hybrids, and concluded that a substantial proportion of the hybrids were stable haploids. This conclusion was based on failure to obtain segregation, and on the results of P22-mediated transduction experiments with hybrids as donors, and S. typhimurium mutants as recipients. Demerec and Ohta (1964) found that the frequency of transduction for certain unselected Salmonella genes which map close to the gene selected from E. coli was reduced to as low as 1% of the frequency of transduction for genes in other regions of the chromosome. It was interpreted that the wild-type Salmonella gene was replaced by a wild-type E . coli gene. If these lines had been partial diploids, one would expect only a small decrease, if any, in the frequency of transduction, since the Salmonella chromosome would be available for transduction. Middleton and Mojica-a (this volume), review the literature and present new data on this topic. The explanation for the differing results apparently resides in the use of different strains. Gemski et al. (1967) and Baron et al. (1968) conclude that transfer of chromosomal genes from E . coli Hfr to Proteus F- occurs a t a low frequency of to lo-* recombinants per donor cell, and that all the recombinants isolated were partial diploids with no evidence that integration ever occurred. These authors demonstrated that DNA of the guanine plus cytosine ratio characteristic of E. coli (51%) was present in the hybrids in the proportion expected for the number of E. coli genes they carried. Clarke (1961) and Stouthamer and Pietersma (1970) both report failure to obtain recombinant formation in crosses of E. coli Hfr x Klebsiella species, though numerous authors have reported ready transfer of episomes into Klebsiella species (Jones and Sneath, 1970). Reports on attempts to transfer chromosomal genes from E. coli Hfr to other members of the Enterobacteriaceae were not found. It is possible that they have been attempted, but have failed and have not been reported. The data above indicate that the Enterobacteriaceae and related genera are a single group in terms of ability to accept, episomes and chromosome fragments carried on episomes from other members. However, tests for genetic recombination, involving crosses with selection for chromosomal genes using E. coli Hfr strains as donors and several genera as recipients, divide these genera into four groups: E. coli, high transfer and high integration; Shigella, transfer reduced by a factor high integration; Salmonella, transfer reduced to of lo-' to to low integration; Proteus, transfer reduced to to no integration detectable ; other genera like Klebsiella, to which transfer
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : GENETIC HOMOLOGY
43
of chromosomal genes has been undetectable, or remains untested. These data give a similar pattern to data from molecular hybridization (Brenner and Falkow, this volume), which show Shigella clmely related to E . coli, with all other species much less related. However, the data have the same shortcomings in that genera like Salmonella and Proteus can be compared only with E. coli, not with each other, for most intercrosses and studies on molecular hybridization have used only E . coli as a reference point. Studies using genera other than Escherichia as the reference point are needed. I n similar studies using Salmonella montevideo Hfr X S. typhimurium hybrids the S. montevideo genes from the hybrid were integrated into S. typhimurium in only 5 to 30% of the frequency for homologous S. typhimuriuva crosses (Atkins and Armstrong, 1969) . I n the above study the electrophoretic analysis of the reductoisomerase enzymes of the isoleucinc-valine pathway, which are distinguishable in S. typhimurium and S. montevideo, confirmed the prediction of the genetic analysis as to which parent contributed the reductoisomerase gene to each recombinant. C. COMPARISONS OF
THE
LINKAGE MAPS
A second criterion of genetic relatedness of two species is similarity of the linkage map. This comparison can be done only in those few cases where related species of genera have been genetically studied so as to yield a detailed overall linkage map, or where sections of the maps can be compared based on deletion analyses or other local analysis. I n the following discussion, the linkage maps of members of the Enterobacteriaceae will be compared, in the light of other measures of relatedness of species. Overall linkage maps of the following species of the Enterobacteriaceae have been published (the accompanying number indicates the number of genes mapped) : E . coli K12 (Taylor, 1970), 310 genes; E . coli B (Boyer, 1966), 13 genes; E . coli C (Wiman et al., 1970), 39 genes; 8. typhimurium (Sanderson and Demerec, 1965; Sanderson, 1970), 251 genes; Salmonella abony (Makela, 1963), 18 genes. I n all cases the overall linkage map is circular and was established from F-mediated conjugation studies, frequently studied with interrupted conjugation. Fine structure mapping was usually done by generalized or specialized transduction. The most detailed comparisons can be made between E . coli K12 (Taylor, 1970) and S. typhimurium (Sanderson, 1970). A total of 116 genes which are mapped in both genera appear to determine a product which has the same function in both organisms. For example, in a clearly
44
KENNETH E. SANDERSON
identified case, the structural gene for tryptophan synthetase (trp) is found in the same general location on the linkage map of E. coli (Signer et al., 1965) and S. typhimurium (Blume and Balbinder, 1966) (Fig. 1 ) . Data which illustrate that the enzyme formed by the trp genes of the two genera is similar but not identical (Creighton et al., 1966) will
FIQ.1. Linkage maps of Escherichia coli (Taylor, 1970), shown on the outside of the circle, and of Salmonella typhimurium (Sanderson, 19701, on the inside of the circle. The numbers indicate the time required for chromosome transfer, in minutes, from interrupted conjugation experiments. Only a small number of the 310 genes mapped in E . coli and of the 251 genes mapped in S. typhimurium are shown. A few genes with similar map locations in each genus are shown as reference points (thr, his, thy, zyl), though differences in the time of entry for the entire chromosome places these at time intervals which do not correspond exactly in the two genera. Several other genes which differ in map location are shown on the maps, and discussed in the text. The abbreviations used in the table are explained in Section 11. This table draws on material published in Bacteriological Review.
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : GENETIC HOMOLOGY
45
be discussed below. In other cases, the basis for assuming homology of genes is not as clear. For example, mutants which result in an inability to utilize D-xylose as the sole carbon source map in a single and similar region of the linkage map of both genera, but there are as yet no enzymatic data to indicate if the genes are really homologous in both. However, for the purposes of comparison the xyl genes and numerous other pairs like them are considered to produce homologous gene products. Of the total of 116 genes mapped in both genera, almost all occur in identical map locations so far as the data permit a comparison. A comparison in any region may show apparent differences usually resulting from uncertainties in map location in one genus or the other. However, there are a number of differences. Firstly, there is a case of a chromosomal rearrangement. The genes trpOABEDC-cysB-pyrF are all arranged in the same order in E. coli and S . typhimurium. (Different locus designations are used in the two genera, and the Salmonella designations are used here, but homologous genes are in the same order.) But this group of genes is inverted in the two genera with respect to the remainder of the linkage map (Sanderson and Hall, 1970). There are, in addition, several cases in which genes, or gene activities, or sections of genetic material are missing from one genus or the other. I n E. coli, proA, proB, and proC are rather widely separated, proA and proB by more than 2 minutes on the linkage map, while several genes including the lac operon are between proB and proC. I n S. typhimurium proA and proB appear to be contiguous by mutation and recombination studies, and are jointly transduced with proC by P22 phage (Miyake and Demerec, 1960). The inability to ferment lactose suggests the absence of the lac operon from S . typhimurium and may indicate a deletion of genetic material between proA and proC, and a similar explanation seems to be necessary to explain the close proximity of proA and proB as well. Mutant strains which can ferment lactose slowly have been isolated from Salmonella lines which were unable to ferment lactose (Schafler et al., 1960) though there is no evidence that the genetic material involved in production of the relevant enzymes is homologous with the lac operon of E. coli. T,he observation of Brenner and Falkow (this volume) that the binding of E . coli lactose messenger RNA was higher to Salmonella DNA than was the binding of E . coli bulk RNA suggests the presence of genetic material in Salmonella homologous to the lactose operon of E . coli, but further tests will be needed. Further, S. typhimurium uses histidine as a sole carbon source, while E . coli does not, and several genes and enzymes have been observed for this pathway which are absent from E. coli (Brill and Magasanik, 1969; Meiss et al., 1969). The enzyme tryptophanase, determined by the gene tna, for
46
KENNETH E. SANDERSON
breakdown of tryptophan to indole, is found in E. coli but not in Salmonella (Gartner and Riley, 1964). The gene for phase 1 flagellar antigen of S. abony is allelic to H, the gene for the only flagellar antigen of E. coli, whereas the 8. abony gene H2 has no counterpart in E. coli (Makelii, 1964). Thus the genetic maps of the two genera are strikingly similar, with few major differences. The linkage maps of E. coli C, E. coli B, and S. abony have no proven differences from those of E. coli and S. typhimurium except those differences between the genera which were already discussed. The above analysis of the linkage maps is mostly based on genetic recombination using conjugation or transduction, though deletion analysis with or without genetic crosses was used in some cases. Deletion mapping of chlorate-resistance mutants, in E. coli (Puig and Azoulay, 1967; Adhya et al., 1968), in 8. typhimurium (Stouthamer, 1969; M. Alper and B. Ames, personal communication), and in Klebsiella aerogenes (Stouthamer and Pietersma, 1970) reveals a striking similarity of gene orders in two map regions of these three genera. I n the first region, the order of genes in Klebsiella is nicA-aroG-gal-chlD-hut-biouvrB-chlA. The order in E . coli is the same, except that hut is missing since E. coli cannot utilize histidine, but Stouthamer and Pietersma (1970) point out that there seems to be an inversion of the bio-chZD region between S. typhimurium and Klebsiella. I n the second region, mutants in the chlG region have been shown to have the same order for nicB-thiB and inlB in K. aerogenes and S. typhimurium. There are striking similarities of the linkage maps of all the Enterobacteriaceae examined. This suggests the possibility that all bacteria may have related linkage maps. An examination of the linkage maps of Bacillus subtilis (Dubnau et al., 1967; Goldthwaite et al., 1970) reveals a striking similarity in that the clusters of genes for related functions so commonly found in the enteric bacteria (Demerec, 1964) are also present in the genes for synthesis of methionine, tryptophan, isoleucine-valine, and histidine, as well as other groups. However, the location of these clusters of genes one to another in B. subtilis bears no apparent relation to that in the Enterobacteriaceae. Thus it is likely that the linkage maps are basically unrelated, with clusters of genes for related functions present in each group because of a selective advantage of this arrangement (Demerec, 1964). Pseudomonas, by contrast, shows little clustering, for the histidine genes appear in five unlinked groups by transduction studies in Pseudomonas aeruginosa (Mee and Lee, 1969) instead of in one group as in the enteric bacteria, and the arginine genes are in seven independent groups instead of being partially grouped as in the enterics (Feary et
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE: GENETIC HOMOLOGY
47
al., 1969). Numerous other groups show the same pattern, with genes of the isoleucine-valine pathway (Pearce and Loutit, 1965) an exception in showing clustering in P. aeruginosa as well as the enterics. I n addition, a preliminary linkage map based on conjugation (Stanisich and Holloway, 1969) shows no similarity to that of the enterics. V. Use of Data on Protein Structure
Demerec (1965) noted that E. coli and S. typhimurium have very similar gross linkage maps, but that the genetic homology of the two genera is very low as measured by intercrossing by conjugation or transduction, followed by integration of chromosomal genes, or as measured by molecular hybridization. This suggested to him that the explanation for this divergence might be that the linkage maps are concerned with whole gene loci, whereas the studies on genetic recombination or molecular hybridization processes occur a t the subgenic, molecular level. Thus the genes might be homologous in terms of function yet differ in their molecular structure. This interpretation was based, in part, on the observations made a t this time that homologous proteins for the same function in different organisms frequently differ in their amino acid sequence (Matsubara et al., 1968). Such differences had been widely studied in other organisms by 1965, but homologous proteins had not been sequenced in the Enterobacteriaceae. Subsequently, variation in a homologous protein in different genera was confirmed by Creighton et al. (1966). They compared the structure of the tryptophan synthetase a-subunits in several members of the enteric bacteria by comparing tryptic-chymotryptic peptides. Their results indicate that the proteins in E. coli, 8. dysenteriae, 8. typhimurium and Aerobacter aerogenes appear to be homologous, with similar size based on sedimentation data, and similar numbers of peptides after digestion. The peptide patterns on two-dimensional paper chromatography indicate identity between E. coli K12 and E. coli B, whereas the pattern with S. dysenteriae differs from E . coli in about three peptide spots. The S. typhinturium and A . aerogenes subunits, though clearly related to E. coli, differed markedly from E . coli and from each other. Of 38 to 41 major peptides detected, the peptide pattern of S. typhimurium has 21 peptide spots in common with E. coli, while A . aerogenes has 18 peptides in common with E. coli. However, since the amino acid content of each peptide was not analyzed, the number of amino acid changes could only be estimated. The complete amino acid sequence of the tryptophan synthetase a-subunit of E . coli K12 was later determined
48
KENNETH E. SANDERSON
(Yanofsky et al., 1967), and recently C. Yanofsky (personal communication) has extended these data by determining the sequence of the first 50 amino acids of this protein in S. typhimurium. There are 6 amino acid differences between the two genera in these 50 residues, each of which is explainable by a ,single nucleotide change per codon. Therefore the minimum base changes per nucleotide between E . coli and S. typhimurium based on this very small sample of the total number of nucleotides (150 of a total of approximately 5 )( lo6) is 6/3 X 50 (100) = 4%. Such differences between the proteins of the two genera are not always distinguishable. For example, Neu and Winshell (1970) , studying penicillinases produced in R-factor negative strains of S. typhimurium and E . coli, were not able to demonstrate any difference in the enzymes by chromotography on DEAE cellulose and Sephadex G100, and by measures of activity, but such differences might have been discovered by more detailed tests such as fingerprint analysis. An estimate of the percentage of altered bases between the DNA of E . coli and S. typhimurium can be made by molecular hybridization methods as well. Brenner and Cowie (1968) assayed the binding of S. typhimurium DNA to E . coli DNA ; reassociation between the heterologous DNA was 35.5% at 6OoC and 27% at 66OC, where reassociation between homologous E . coli DNA is normalized to 100%. The reassociation product of E . coli-S. typhimurium DNA a t 6OoC has a reduction in melting temperature (AT,) of 12.5OC compared with similarly treated E . coli DNA, while the 66OC product has a AT, of 10.5OC. Laird et al. (1969), in studies with B. subtilis, demonstrated that hybrids between nucleic acids chemically altered from one another in 1.5% of their bases had a reduction of l 0 C in the T, compared with the homologous hybrid. Therefore the observed A T , of 10.5OC for E. coli-S. typhimurium hybrids indicates altered base pairs of 10.5 X 1.5 = 15% to 16%. VI. Summary
Four separate measures of genetic relatedness among the members of the Enterobacteriaceae and related genera have been considered. First, transfer of genetic elements can occur in intercrosses within the entire group. However, integration of chromosomal genes from Escherichia coli occurs with high frequency into the chromosome of Shigella, with much reduced frequency into Salmonella typhimurium, and is generally undetectable into other genera of the group. Second, DNA-DNA or DNARNA hybridization methods (Brenner and Falkow, this volume) indicate
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : GENETIC HOMOLOGY
49
that E. coli and Shigella are closely related, while other genera are much less related to E. coli. Third, the linkage map is a conservative character, which is relatively unaltered in the genera Escherichia, Salmonella, and Klebsiella, and may be similar in the entire family, while there is no evidence of similarity to the linkage maps of unrelated groups such as Bacillus and Pseudomonas, to which transfer does not occur. Fourth, amino acid sequences of tryptophan synthetase reveal that these proteins in E . coli and S. typhimurium are related, but with a significant number of amino acid differences.
REFERENCES Adhya, S., Cleary, P., and Campbell, A. 1968. A deletion analysis of prophage lambda and adjacent genetic regions. Proc. Nut. Acad. Sci. U.S. 61, 956-962. Atkins, C. G., and Armstrong, F. B. 1969. Electrophoretic study of Salmonella typhimurium-Salmonella montevideo hybrids. Genetics 63, 775-779. Baron, L. S., Carey, W. K., and Spilman, W. M. 1959. Hybridization of Salmonella species by mating with Escherichia coli. Science 130, 566-567. Baron, L. S., Gemski, P., Jr., Johnson, E. M., and Wohlhieter, J. A. 1968. Intergeneric bacterial matings. Bacteriol. Rev. 32, 362-369. Blume, A. J., and Balbinder, E. 1966. The tryptophan operon of Salmonella typhimurium. Fine structure analysis by deletion mapping and abortive transduction. Genetics 53, 577492. Boyer, H. 1964. Genetic control of restriction and modification in Escherichia coli. J . Bacteriol. 88, 1652-1660. Boyer, H. 1966. Conjugation in Escherichia coli. J. Bacteriol. 91, 1767-1774. Breed, R. S., Murray, E. G. D., and Smith, N. F. 1957. I n “Bergey’s Manual of Determininative Bacteriology,” 7th ed. Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, Maryland. Brenner, D. J., and Cowie, D. B. 1968. Thermal stability of Escherichiu coli-Salmonella typhimurium deoxyribonucleic acid duplexes. J. Bacteriol. 95, 2258-2262. Brill, W. J., and Magasanik, B. 1969. Genetic and metabolic control of histidase and urocanase in Salmonella typhimurium, strain 15-59. J . Biol. Chem. 244, 5392-5402.
Clarke, C. H. 1961. Genetic studies with Klebsiella pneumoniae. Nature 190, 194. Colson, A. M., Colson, C., and Van Pel, A. 1969. Host-controlled restriction mutants in SalmoneEla typhimurium. J. Gen. Microbiol. 58, 57-64. Creighton, T. E., Helinski, D. R., Somerville, R. L., and Yanofsky, C. 1966. Comparison of the tryptophan synthetase a-subunits of several species of Enterobactsriaceae. J. Bactem’ol. 91, 1819-1826. Davis, P. H., and Heywood, V. H. 1963. “Principles of Angiosperm Taxonomy.” Van Nostrand-Reinhold, Princeton, New Jersey. Demerec, M. 1964. Clustering of functionally related genes in Salmonella typhimurium. Proc. Nut. Acad. Sci. U.S. 51, 1057-1060. Demerec, M. 1965. Homology and divergence in genetic material of Salmonella typhimurium and Escherichia coli. In “Evolving Genes and Proteins” (V. Bryson and H. J. Vogel ed.), pp. 505510. Academic Press, New York. Demerec, M., and New, K. 1965. Genetic divergence in Salmonella typhimurium,
50
KENNETH E. SANDERSON
S. montevideo, and Escherichia coli. Biochem. Bbphys. Res. Commun. 18, 652-655. Demerec, M., and Ohta, N. 1964. Genetic analysis of Salmonella typhimurium x Escherichia coli hybrids. Proc. Nut. Acad. Sci. U.S. 52, 317-323. Dobzhansky, T. 1951. “Genetics and the Origin of Species,” 3rd ed. Columbia Univer. Press, New York. Dubnau, D., Goldthwaite, C., Smith, I., and Marmur, J. 1967. Genetic mapping in Bacillus subtilis, J . Mol. Biol. 27, 163-185. Edwards, P. R., and Ewing, W. H. 1962. “Identification of Enterobacteriaceae.” Burgess, Minneapolis, Minnesota. Falkow, S., Rownd, R., and Baron, L. S. 1962. Genetic homology between Escherichia coli K12 and Salmonella. J. Bacteriol. 84, 1303-1312. Falkow, S., Schneider, H., Baron, L. S., and Formal, S. B. 1963. Virulence of Escherichia-Shigella genetic hybrids for the guinea pig. J. Bacteriol. 88, 12511258. Feary, T. W., Williams, B., Calhoun, D. H., and Walker, T. A. 1969. An analysis of arginine requiring mutants in Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Genetics 82, 673-686. Gartner, T. K.,and Riley, M. 1964. Genetic studies on tryptophanase mutants of Escherichia coli K12. Bacterial. Proc. p. 18. Gemski, P., Jr., Wohlhieter, J. A., and Baron, L. S. 1967. Chromosome transfer between Escherichia coli Hfr strains and Proteus mirabilis. Proc. Nut. Acad. Sci. US. 58, 1461-1467. Goldthwaite, C., Dubnau, D., and Smith, I. 1970. Genetic mapping of antibiotic resistance in markers of Bacillus subtilis. Proc. Nut. Acad. Sci. U.S. 85, 96-103. Ino, I., and Demerec, M. 1968. Enteric hybrids. 11. Salmonella typhimurium-E. coli hybrids for the trp-cysB-pyrF region. Genetics 59, 167-176. Jones, D., and Sneath, P. H. A. 1970. Genetic transfer and bacterial taxonomy. Bacteriol. Rev, 34, 40-81. Laird, C. D., McConaughy, B. L., and McCarthy, B. J. 1969. Rate of fixation of nucleotide substitutions in evolution. Nature 224, 149-154. Lieb, M., Weigle, J. J., and Kellenberger, E. 1955. A study of hybrids between two strains of Escherichia Cali. J. Bacteriol. 69, 468-471. Luria, S. E., and Burrous, J. W. 1957. Hybridization between Escherichia coli and Shigella. J. Bacterial. 74, 461476. Makela, P. H. 1963. Hfr males in Salmonella abony. Genetics 48, 423-429. Makela, P. H. 1964. Genetic homologies between flagellar antigens of Escherichia coli and Salmonella abony. J . Gen. Microbiol. 35, 503-510. Mandel, M. 1969. New approaches to bacterial taxonomy: perspective and prospects. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 23, 239-274. Marmur, J., Falkow, S., and Mandel, M. 1963. New approaches to bacterial taxonomy. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 17, 329-372. Matsubara, H., Jukes, T. H., and Cantor, C. R. 1968. Structural and evolutionary relationships of ferredoxins. Brookhaven Symp. Biol. 21, 201-216. Mee, B. J., and Lee, B. T. 0. 1969 A map order for his I , one of the genetic regions controlling histidine biosynthesis in Pseudomonas aeruginosa, using the transducing phage F116. Genetics 62, 687-696. Meiss, H. K.,Brill, W. J., and Magasanik, B. 1969. Genetic control of histidine degradation in Salmonella typhimurium strain LT2. J . Bwl. Chem. 244, 538% 5391. Miyake, T.,and Demerec, M. 1959. Salmonella-Escherichia hybrids. Nature 183, 1586.
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE: GENETIC HOMOLOGY
51
Miyake, T., and Demerec, M. 1960. Proline mutants of Salmonella typhimurium. Genetics 45, 755-762. Neu, H. C., and Winshell, E. B. 1970. Purification and characterization of penicillinases from Salmonella typhimurium and Escherichia coli. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 139, 278-290. Okada, M., Watanabe, T., and Miyake, T. 1968. On the nature of the recipient ability of Salmonella typhimurium for foreign deoxyribonucleic acids. J. Gen. Microbiol. 50, 241-252. Pearce, L. E., and Loutit, J. S.1965. Biochemical and genetic grouping of isoleucinevaline mutants in Pseudomonas aeruginosa. J. Bacteriol. 89, 58-63. Puig, J., and Azoulay, E. 1967. Etude gCnCtique et biochemique des mutants rksistant au C103- (genes chlA, chlB, chlC). C . R . Acad. Sci. 264, 1916-1918. Sanderson, K. E. 1970. Current linkage map of Salmonella typhimurium. Bacteriol. Rev. 34, 176-193. Sanderson, K. E., and Demerec, M. 1965. The linkage map of Salmonella typhimurium. Genetics 51, 897-913. Sanderson, K. E., and Hall, C. A. 1970. F-prime factors of Salmonella typhimurium and an inversion between S. typhimurium and Escherichiu coli. Genetics 64, 215-228.
Schafler, S., Mintzer, L., and Schafler, C. 1960. Acquisition of lactose-fermenting properties by salmonellae. J. Bactem'ol. 79, 203-212. Schneider, H., and Falkow, S. 1964. Characterization of an Hfr strain of Shigella flexneri. J. Bacteriol. 88, 682-689. Signer, E. R., Beckwith, J. R., and Brenner, S. 1965. Mapping of suppressor loci in Escherichia coli. J. Mol. Biol. 14, 153-166. Stanisich, V., and Holloway, B. W. 1969. Conjugation in Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Genetics 61, 327-339. Stouthamer, A. H. 1969. A genetical and biochemical study of chlorate-resistant mutants of Salmonella typhimurium. Antonie van Leeuwenhoek J . Microbiol. Serol. 35, 505-521. Stouthamer, A. H., and Pietersma, K. 1970. Deletion-mapping of resistance against chlorate in Klebsiella aerogenes. Mol. Gen. Genet. 106, 174-179. St. Pierre, M. L., and Demerec, M. 1968. Hybrids of enteric bacteria. I. Salmonella typhimurium-Salmonella montevideo hybrids for the histidine region. Genetics 59, 1-9. Taylor, A. L. 1970. Current linkage map of Escherichia coli. Bacteriol. Rev. 34, 155-175.
Wiman, M., Bertani, G., Kelly, B., and Sasaki, I. 1970. Genetic map of Escherichia coli strain C. Mol. Gen. Genet. 107, 1-31. Yanofsky, C., Drapeau, G. R., Guest, J. R., and Carleton, B. C. 1967. The complete amino acid sequence of the tryptophan synthetase A protein (a subunit) and its colinear relationship with the genetic map of the A gene. Proc. Nut. Acad. Sci. U.S. 57, 296298. Zinder, N. D. 1960. Hybrids of Escherichia and Salmonella. Science 131, 813-815.
.
B HOMOLOGY IN THE ENTEROBACTERIACEAE BASED ON INTERCROSSES BETWEEN SPECIES Richard B. Middleton* and Tobias Mojica-at Department of Biology. McGill University. Montreal. Quebec
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Nomenclature . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Definitions and Abbreviations . . . . . . . . I1. Production of Hybrids . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Differences in Cell Surfaces . . . . . . . . . B. Differences in Genetic Material . . . . . . . . C. Effects of Restriction . . . . . . . . . . . D . Alteration of Restriction . . . . . . . . . . I11. Stability of the Hybrids . . . . . . . . . . . A. Male DNA Associated with the Chromosome . . . . B. Male DNA Not Associated with the Chromosome. . . I V . Characterization of the Hybrids . . . . . . . . . A. Homology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Normalization . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Genetic Homologies between Species. . . . . . . . A. Summary of Data . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Reliability of Homology Values . . . . . . . . VI . Use of Hybrids for Mapping . . . . . . . . . . A . Ordering of Nearby Genes Which Are Not Cotransduced . B. Orientation of the ilvE-metA Region, 122-129 Minutes . C. Locating Certain Wild-Type Genes . . . . . . . VII Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
53 54 55 55 55 56 56 58 59 59 61 62 62 63 65 65 65 72 72 73 75 76 76
I. Introduction
Mandel (1969) among others has pointed to the sexual versatility of the enteric bacteria and the resulting potential of this group for studies of genetic relatedness . A special advantage in constructing viable interspecific hybrid recombinants results from the constancy of the genetic
* Present address : Faculty of Medicine. Memorial University. W . John’s. Newfoundland. t Present address: Polish Academy of Sciences. Institute of Biochemistry and Biophysics. 36 Rakowiecka St., Warszawa 12. Poland . 53
54
RICHARD B. MIDDLETON AND TOBIAS MOJICA-A
map throughout the Enterobacteriaceae (Sanderson, 1970, 1971; Taylor, 1970). Integration of male genetic material after conjugation can, due to synapsis of similar regions of the genetic material, result in the formation of recombinant prototrophic hybrids. Early reports of genetic hybridization between different genera include studies by Luria and Burrous (1957) for Escherichia coli and Shigella, which are both included in the host range of the generalized transducing coliphage P1, and Baron et al. (1959a,b) for E. coli and various Salmonella species. Of particular interest for a quantitative description of genetic homology are subsequent studies, by means of transduction analysis, of hybrids between E. coli and Salmonella typhimurium (Zinder, 1960; Miyake, 1962; Demerec 1964, 1965a,b; Demerec and Ohta, 1964; Demerec and New, 1965; Eisenstark, 1965a,b; Middleton and Demerec, 1966; Ino and Demerec, 1968; Mojica-a and Middleton, 1970a), and between Salmonella species (Glatzer et al., 1966; Armstrong, 1967; LaBrie and Armstrong, 1968; St. Pierre and Demerec, 1968). Transduction crosses with hybrids as donors and various strains of the female parental species as recipients allow homologous genetic material of the two parental species to be involved in recombinational events. Comparison of the frequency of such interspecific recombinations provides a measure of the similarity of the genetic material in the region under consideration (Demerec and New, 1965). Other approaches to the study of the genetic relatedness of species of enteric bacteria are comparison of the genetic maps (Sanderson, 1971) and DNA-DNA and DNA-RNA associations (Brenner and Falkow, 1971). This review concentrates on the genetic homology of the enteric bacteria as indicated by transduction analysis of hybrids which result from intercrosses between species. Generally excluded is consideration of episomic transfer between species (see Falkow et al., 1961) as well as of the intensive studies, largely of Baron and his co-workers, on hybrid heterogenotes of varying stability. Much of the latter work was the subject of a recent review (Baron et al., 1968). The survey of literature for the present review was concluded in November 1970. A. NOMENCLATURE The nomenclature of Demerec et al. (1966) is followed. The designation of the five structural genes of the tryptophan operon, trpA-E, follows the E. coli convention (Taylor, 1970). Since S. typhimurium is the female parent of most hybrids discussed, all other gene symbols, locus designations, and map positions (minutes) of genes, in general, follow S. typhimurium (Sanderson, 1970) with certain exceptions, as noted.
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : HOMOLOGY FROM INTERCROSSES
55
B. DEFINITIONS AND ABBREVIATIONS Throughout this paper female refers to a strain used in a conjugation cross with another species and recipient is a strain, of the female species, used in transduction crosses with hybrids as donors. Unless otherwise specified, female and recipient refer to S. typhimurium. Similarly males participate in interspecific conjugation crosses whereas donors refer to phage preparations of hybrids which are utilized in transduction crosses with recipients of the female species. Unless specified, males are E. coli Hfr or F’ strains. Hybrids are recombinants which result from conjugation crosses between species, and unless specified, result from matings between E. coli males and S. typhimurium females. Hybrids susceptible to genetic analysis by transduction have the male genetic material integrated into recombinant chromsomes from which the corresponding female segments are displaced. The distinctions between such hybrids and heterogenotes (partial diploids) are discussed in Section 111, below. P22, a generalized transducing phage of S. typhimurium, is most commonly used for the genetic analysis of hybrids. Abbreviations are DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid) , e.0.p. (efficiency of plating), F (sex factor) , F’ (F-prime, sex factor which carries a segment of the bacterial chromosome) , fer (fertile mutation, after Miyake, 1959), NG (N-methyl-” nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine) , RNA (ribonucleic acid) , R T F (resistance transfer factor) , and UV (ultraviolet irradiation). CI. Production of Hybrids
A characteristic feature of matings between E. coli Hfr’s and Salmonella female strains is the low recovery of prototrophic recombinants. A typical frequency of recombination in crosses of E . coli Hfr’s and (Mojica-a, S. typhimurium LT2 female strains is of the order of 1971; Mojica-a and Middleton, 1970a). Strain LT7 of S. typhimurium is somewhat more fertile: 10-3-10-~(Baron et al., 1959a; Miyake, 1962; R. B. Middleton, unpublished observations). Three possible explanations for the low fertility of interspecific crosses are discussed in the light of the methods employed to overcome infertility.
A. DIFFERENCES IN CELLSURFACES Differences in the cell surfaces of mating cells may introduce a barrier to the conjugal transfer of genetic material. Female strains of two species
56
RICHARD B. MIDDLETON AND TOBIAS MOJICA-A
might be expected t o differ in the receptor sites presumed to interact with the sex pili of the male strain. Recently it has been shown that S. typhimurium LT2 male and female strains may have their conjugal fertilities affected by known changes in cell wall polysaccharide (Watanabe et al., 1970); in particular, fertility of female strains is markedly increased by the loss of the 0 side-chain (abequose-mannoserhamnose-galactose) %. A NG-induced mutant of S. typhimurium LT2 (J. M. Somers, onpublished observation) that has an increased fertility for E. coli RTF’s with respect to the parent strain and is sensitive to coliphage P1, appears to retain its ability to restrict E. coli-modified DNA and to impart Salmonella-modification (Middleton and Mojica-a, 1970; Mojica-a and Middleton, 1970b). It seems most likely that a cell-surface alteration is responsible for the increased fertility rather than an impairment of the restriction mechanism, but the mutant has not yet been fully characterized. IN GENETICMATERIAL B. DIFFERENCES
Differences in the DNAs of the mating cells would decrease the frequency of transfer during conjugation as well as reduce the frequency of integration of the male genetic material into the female chromosome. It has been shown that the presence in a Salmonella typhosa hybrid of the leading region of an E. coli Hfr increases the frequency with which subsequent E. coli genes are recovered upon a further mating (Johnson et al., 1964). This effect of the resident E. coli genetic material fits very well in the current model of conjugation (Curtiss et al., 1968; Curtiss, 1969) which requires early pairing of DNA molecules.
C. EFFECTS OF RESTRICTION The restriction mechanisms of the female strains may render genetically inactive the male genetic material after transfer; recent reviews of DNA restriction and modification are by Arber (1965) and Arber and Linn (1969). It was proposed (Baron et al., 1959a) that the low frequency of recombination represented the selection of rare, high-fertility female cells in an otherwise infertile culture. As expected the recombinants were found to have higher fertility with E. coli than did the female parent strain. Salmonella typhimurium LT7 mut which carries a mutator gene (Miyake, 1959, 1960) gave characteristically low frequencies of recombinants for a rather wide range of male markers in conjugational crosses with E . coli Hfr strains. By indirect selection, high
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE: HOMOLOGY FROM INTERCROSSES
57
fertility strains (LT7 f e r for fertile) have been isolated without previous participation in conjugal matings (Miyake, 1962). It was therefore concluded that S. typhimurium LT7 mut populations are heterogeneous with respect to the ability to act as fertile females in conjugation with E. coli Hfr’s. Presumably the mut phenotype induced fertility ( f e r ) in infertile (fer+) LT7 mut strains of S. typhimurium to yield fertile female strains, LT7 mut fer. These observations are consistent with the operation of restriction (Grasso and Paigen, 1968a,b). Salmonella typhimurium LT7 fer strains have in addition the following properties (Okada and Watanabe, 1968; Okada et al., 1968): (1) the frequency of transfer of R T F and F’ from E. coli K12 to LT7 f e r is considerably higher than to S. typhimurium fer+ strains-LT2 mut+, LT7 mut+, or LT7 mut; (2) the conjugal transfer of the R T F and F’ episomes from LT2, LT7 mut+,and LT7 mut to derivatives of these fer+ strains occurs at frequencies almost equal to the frequency of transfer between E. coli K12 and LT7 fer; (3) S. typhimurium phage P22 grown and titered on LT7 fer (e.0.p. = 1.0) gives a much reduced e.0.p. on any other derivatives of S. typhimurium: e.0.p. on LT2 6.0 X The e.0.p. on LT7 mut+3.0 X lo+, on LT7 mut 1.0 X of phage P22 grown on LT7 mut is only slightly lower on LT2 mut+, LT7 mut+,and LT7 mut than on LT7 fer. Radioisotope studies show that the DNA of P22 prepared on LT7 fer is rapidly degraded in LT2, LT7 mut+,and LT7 mut: in 10 minutes 3040% of the DNA is degraded to acid-soluble material. Okada et al. (1968) concluded that the results are due to host-controlled restriction and modification of the type defined by Arber (1965). Two alternative explanations were offered: (a) LT7 f e r is a restrictionless and modificationless mutant or (b) LT7 mut+ and LT2 mut+ are modificationless whereas LT7 fer and LT7 mut are able to carry out modification and LT7 fer is restrictionless. The results of Okada et al. (1968), however, favor the first interpretation. The second interpretation is less probable since a strain that is able to restrict and is modificationless has not been found in S. typhimurium (Colson et al., 1969) or in E. coli and would presumably be lethal (Boyer and Roulland-Dussoix, 1969). Eisenstark (1965a) reported induction of hybridization for crosses between E. coli Hfr and S. typhimurium LT2 females by plating mating mixtures in the presence of NG. He concluded that the action of NG in inducing fertility is only on female cells and that the selected phenotypes produced resulted from hybridization and not from reverse mutation. A small number of recipient strains and two E. coli Hfrs (CS101 and P4X6) were used. It has also recently been shown that UV treatment of female LT2 strains increases fertility to a similar extent (Mojica-a
58
RICHARD B. MIDDLETON AND TOBIAS MOJICA-A
and Middleton, 1970a, and unpublished results) . These observations are also consistent with the operation of restriction (Bertani and Weigle, 1953; Luria, 1953).
D. ALTERATION OF RESTRICTION If it is possible to induce fertile mutations and/or select for rare fertile clones in a generally infertile population of cells, i t may also be possible to find appropriate physiological conditions which will permit infertile cell populations to behave temporarily as fertile females. It has been shown that by growing the S. typhimurium LT2 female cells in minimal salts supplemented with appropriate nutritional requirements rather than in nutrient broth the frequency of intergeneric recombinations is increased approximately 100-fold. The additional treatment of preincubating the females at 5OoC for 2 0 4 0 minutes immediately before mating with the E. coli Hfr strains increases the frequency of recombination approximately 100-fold (Mojica-a, 1971; Mojica-a and Middleton, 1970a). The final frequencies of recombination observed are similar to those for S. typhimurium LT7 fer females. These effects are presumably generalized although most tests were made with various 8. typhimurium LT2 females with deletions in the tryptophan operon, and the successful E. coli Hfr strains injected the selected genes fairly early (Mojica-a, 1971). This protocol appears to have three advantages for the production of hybrids: (1) nearly all genetically studied strains of S. typhimurium are derived from LT2, rather than LT7, and these are now routinely available as female parents of hybrids; (2) uncontrolled side effects of mutagens (W and NG) are avoided; (3) the hybrid recombinants produce P22 which is not restricted by S. typhimurium fer+ recipients, in contrast with hybrids produced by fer strains, which simplifies the genetic analysis of the hybrids. Both growth medium (Grass0 and Paigen, 1968a,b) and high temperature (Gwinn and Lawton, 1968) affect host-restriction of phage DNA. The pretreatments of the female therefore appear to reduce the effectiveness of the restriction system of the female in contributing to the low fertility of Salmonella strains with E . coli males. It is concluded that there are a t least three factors responsible for the low recovery of recombinants in conjugal crosses between E . coli Hfr’s and Salmonella strains: (1) differences in the cell surface that affect genetic transfer, (2) differences in the DNA sequences of the parent strains that affect both transfer and integration of male genetic material, and (3) the restriction system of the female that inactivates
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : HOMOLOGY FROM INTERCROSSES
59
male genetic material after transfer. It is not possible to determine the relative importance of these three factors for the fertility of interspecific matings. The apparent importance of female restriction may be due to the present ability to alter its effectiveness by experimental means. 111. Stability of the Hybrids
When S. typhimurium-E. coli hybrids are used as donors in transduction crosses with S. typhimurium recipients, few wild-type recombinants are generally observed for donor genes which are derived from the E. coli parent. Is this depression in the recombination frequency due solely to inhomology of the genetic material, or might the physical state of the male DNA affect the donor efficiency of the hybrids? Various observations indicate that the physical state of the male DNA in the hybrids probably has a detectable effect on the depression of the frequency of recombination, although the mechanism by which this effect is achieved is by no means clear. There appear to be two possible physical states of the male DNA in the hybrids: it can either be closely associated (integrated) or not closely associated with the female genome. Both possibilities are discussed in the light of the effects observed. WITH A. MALEDNA ASSOCIATED
THE
CHROMOSOME
Eisenstark (1965b) has shown that P22 is able to transduce E. coli genetic material which is integrated into the S. typhimurium genome. In addition, hybrids have frequently been identified in which E. coli DNA has been stably integrated into the Salmonella chromosome (for example Ino and Demerec, 1968). I n contrast, Baron et al. (1968) have stated that if stable integration occurs at all, it is an extremely rare event. Both classes of recombinants have however been observed within the same set of hybrids (T. Mojica-a and R. B. Middleton, unpublished observations). The criteria used to establish stable integration are the following: (1) inability to segregate clones with a phenotype like the female parent strain (usually auxotrophic clones) ; (2) ability of the male genes to be transduced ; (3) demonstration, by cotransduction with a closely linked marker, of the absence of a cryptic female gene for which the integrated male gene should be substituted ; (4) absence of .extrachromosoma1 DNA. None of the above criteria is completely conclusive and the uncer-
60
RICHARD B. MIDDLETON AND TOBIAS MOJICA-A
tainties for each include the following: (1) phenotypic stability of some hybrids may reflect a very close relationship other than integration of the male genetic segment with the corresponding female region; (2) the absence of donor ability of a male gene may result either from the possible inaccessibility of a nonintegrated male segment or from very low homology of the genes of the two species; (3) the presence of the cryptic female gene cannot distinguish between integration of the male gene in a novel region or the lack of integration; (4) the presence of a satellite DNA is difficult to establish if the physical properties of the two DNAs are similar (e.g., E. coli and Salmonella) or if the satellite DNA is too small to detect. Of Trp+ hybrids generated from E. coli trp’ males X 8. typhimurium trp females, 60-750/0 are stable and “integrated” by the first three criteria outlined above (R. B. Middleton, unpublished observations; Mojica-a, 1971) : no Trp- clones are segregated, Trp’ transductants are produced, and no Trp- cotransductants are found after selection for cysB’ recombinants. Similar results were obtained by Ino and Demerec (1968) for other Trp’ hybrids. St. Pierre and Demerec (1968), however, were unable to select from conjugation crosses stable S. typhimurium-E. coli hybrids in the histidine region and conclude that the absence of integration of E. coli material may be due to the presence of the somatic antigen loci of E. coli mapping very near the histidine region. Another possibility is that the male genetic material is not efficiently recognized by enzymes necessary for recombination. Garrick-Silversmith and Hartman (1970) found that F’ his’ grid' of E. coli is stable in S. typhimurium; the episome remains intact, or is lost entirely, and yields no integrated hybrids. Similarly, a S. typhimurium F’ rfb’ his+ gnd+ episome does not appear to interact with the E. coli chromosome to give stable hybrids (M. J. Voll and P. E. Hartman, personal communication). There are two alternatives for the location of the selected, integrated genetic material: 1. The male genetic material displaces homologous female genetic material, resulting in a patchwork hybrid chromosome similar to the original female chromosome in the continuous linear arrangement of nucleotides. In this case it is possible to estimate the size of the integrated segment of male DNA by its donor efficiency in transduction. It is assumed that the replacement prototrophic alleles are regulated normally by the female regulatory machinery. 2. The male DNA is tandemly inserted into the host chromosome (not necessarily in the region of functional homology) producing a duplicated region. A genetic estimate of the size of the insertion will be difficult since the homologous female genes are not displaced and are efficiently
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : HOMOLOGY FROM INTERCROSSES
61
transmitted in transduction. There is some evidewe that tandem insertions may occur near, but not displacing, the hc,mologous female genes: about half of a group of Trp+ hybrids which sail1 harbor a cryptic trpB female allele show a significant decrease in t h z frequency of cotransduction between trpB and cysB. The lengthering of the genetic distance suggests that the Trp' male genetic material may be integrated between trpB and cysB (R. B. Middleton, unpublished observations). There are two approaches toward locating the inserted male genetic material in the chromosomes of hybrids: 1. If gene products of the corresponding genes of the two species can be differentiated electrophoretically (Atkins and Armstrong, 1969 ; Lew and Roth, 1971), the enzymes of stable hybrids can be characterized. If the male gene displaces the female gene, only the male enzyme is found (Atkins and Armstrong, 1969). If only the female enzyme is found, such a small part of male gene is integrated as not to affect the characteristic electrophoretic mobility of the female enzyme (F. B. Armstrong, L. Glatzer, and C. G . Atkins, unpublished observations). The presence of both male and female enzymes would indicate the insertion of the male gene into a chromosome which still contains the female gene. 2. If the marker selected against in the female is a mutation in a structural gene in an operon with an operator-constitutive mutation, a tandem insertion of the male gene into the female operon would result in constitutive enzyme levels for some male genes. Some female genes would at the same time become inducible or repressible due to interruption of the female operon. On the other hand, an insertion of the selected male gene into a novel region of the female chromosome, distant from the corresponding female operon, would leave the enzyme levels of all functional female genes at constitutive levels.
B. MALEDNA NOT ASSOCIATED WITH
THE
CHROMOSOME
The male DNA in a hybrid conceivably might not be associated with the chromosome. The male genetic segment would probably replicate independently of the chromosome, and its size would be measurable only by physical rather than by genetic means. A strain carrying such an exogenote would be expected to segregate clones lacking the functions coded for by this male DNA. Baron et al. (1968) reported hybrid strains that behave as if the male DNA were not integrated into the female chromosome. This is perhaps not unexpected since the functions of the markers selected, namely lac+, ara+, rha+, xyl', fuc+,tna+, r c p f , and T,rcp+ of the E. coli male, are all lacking from the wild-type female, Salmonella typhosa.
62
RICHARD B. MIDDLETON AND TOBIAS MOJICA-A
The absence of female genetic material homologous with the selected male alleles may greatly decrease the frequency of integration of the selected genes into a hybrid chromosome. I n contrast the stable integration was reported of markers carried by the wild type of both species, namely met+ and str+. I n some cases the reported losses of male material were possibly mutations to loss of function; for example, the frequency of segregation of Lac- clones was not stated and, if infrequent, might represent lac+ to lac mutations rather than loss of male genetic material from the cells. Leavitt et al. (1970) have recently reported the characterization of E. coli DNA in S. typhosa-E. coli Xyl+ hybrids by sucrose density gradient centrifugation and electron microscopy. They found circular molecules with a molecular weight of 66 X lo6 daltons and a length of 34 mp. This finding may answer the question of physical state of the male DNA in the cases of unstable diploid hybrids, and may provide an approach to the understanding of other questions, such as replication, stability, regulation, and interaction with the host chromosome of pieces of male DNA which are not integrated into the chromosome. Thus male DNA may exist in each hybrid in one of two different forms: associated with the chromosome or as an exogenote. Although both types of hybrids have been reported, it is not yet possible to make detailed statements on the interactions of the male DNA with the female chromosome or on the replication, stability, or regulation of male DNA in hybrids. IV. Characterization of the Hybrids
Transduction crosses mediated by phage P22 are carried out with hybrids and wild-type 8. typhimurium LT2 as donors. Titers are ordinarily determined on LT2. Recipients are 8. typhimurium auxotrophs representative of the chromosomal region under study, usually that region selected for in conjugation. At least one additional recipient with a marker outside the region under study should be included; the choice of this recipient depends on the conditions of the conjugation matings, particularly the Hfr used and duration of mating. It is assumed that the hybrids do not carry any male genetic material in this outside region. The additional recipient, as will be seen in Section IV, B below, is used to normalize for donor phage efficiency. A. HOMOLOGY Homology is defined as the ratio between the frequency of recombination (in phage-mediated transduction) in which an E. coli-S. typhimur-
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : HOMOLOGY FROM INTERCROSSES
63
ium (or other) recombinant is used as a donor with an S. typhimurium recipient and the frequency in which the donor and the recipient are of the same species (for example, S. typhimurium X S. typhimurium). Homology, usually expressed as a percentage, appears to relect similarities in the genetic material of related organisms. It should be noted that homology is assessed as a consequence of a recombinational event and could perhaps be better termed “recombinational homology.” Of course the relationship between “recombinational homology” and the similarity of the nucleotide sequences is not known, although small differences in DNA sequence may be reflected as great differences when recombinational events are scored since transduction analysis has high resolution. Approaches to the description of the relationship between the homology values generated by transduction analysis of hybrids and the “microhomology” of the DNA sequences of two species may be (1) DNA-RNA hybridization studies of genetically identified regions, and (2) comparison of the amino acid sequences of homologous enzymes.
B. NORMALIZATION P22-mediated transductions with wild-type S. typhimurium LT2 as donor with a series of S. typhimurium recipients permit normalization for recipient efficiencies. Donor efficiencies are calculated from the inclusion of a recipient outside the region(s) in which male genetic material may be integrated. The procedure is outlined in St. Pierre and Demerec (1968) and in Ino and Demerec (1968) ; see Table 4 in Section VI for data which have been normalized. The most common case is the analysis of a particular region of the chromosome; an example of a hypothetical case is shown in Table 1. Normalization is useful for quantitative studies of particular regions of the bacterial chromosome and is valid if the following assumptions and observations are made: 1. The outside marker does not contain male DNA. 2. The hybrid strains contain male DNA for a least the sites selected for in the conjugation cross; that is, a recombination between the female and the male has resulted in a hybrid chromosome with a linear arrangement of nucleotides functionally indistinguishable from the wild type of the female in the selected region. Cases in which the latter assumption does not appear to be valid have been described (St. Pierre and Demerec, 1968; Baron et al., 1968) and are discussed in Section I11 above. 3. The vector phage used in transduction is able to transfer male DNA from hybrids. For P22 this assumption appears to be valid. Eisenstark (1965b) made thymineless mutations in hybrids in which the
64
RICHARD B. MIDDLETON A N D TOBIAS MOJICA-A
thymine gene was of E . coli origin and used these mutations as recipients in transduction in which the donor was the prototrophic hybrid thy+ gene from E . coli parent. The high frequency of Thy+ transductants shows that P22 can efficiently transmit E . coli DNA. In addition the frequent appearance of abortive transductants in crosses a t hybrid regions indicates that P22 does carry male genetic material (Demerec 1964; Glatzer e t al., 1966; Mojica-a, 1971). 4. The number of transductants observed is greater than zero as would be expected unless (a) the homology is so low as to be not measurable TABLE 1 Determination of Percentage Homology (Hypothetical Example) Numbers of wild-type recombinants with various recipients Donors (phage preparations)
his-1
trp-1
trp-9
S . typhimurium LT2 Hybrid X*
1000 900
2000 400
1500 50
* Trp+ recombinant isolated from a cross between E. coli Hfr X S. typhimurium trp-d under conditions were the his+ region is most likely not transmitted from the E. coli parent. Normalization for recipient efficiencies: 1000 2000
-
1000 1500
-
for trp-1;
for trp-2
Normalization for donor phage efficiency:
1000 900
Normalized colony counts: 1000 1000 400 X -X - = 222
2000
1000 50X---X-= 1500
900
1000 900
37
for trp-1 for trp-8
Normalized percentage homology values : 222 X
100 = 22.2%
for trp-1
-X 100 = 3.7% 1000
for trp-d
1000
37
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE HOMOLOGY FROM INTERCROSSES
65
in transduction crosses or (b) the host specificity locus [hsp', 89 minutes in the E . coli map (Taylor, 1970)] of the male displaces the female locus, presumed to occupy a similar position, with the result that transducing fragments would be susceptible to degradation in recipient strains of the female species. The only apparent case of complete lack of transductants due to very low homology is for the lactose region (Zinder, 1960). Lac+ hybrids yield no recombinants with S. typhimurium recipients which may be a result of the characteristic lack of the lactose operon in S. typhimurium. Evidence for the effects of E . coli hsp' locus has been found in hybrids which have male genetic material incorporated near the top of the map, 0-5 min (H. Itikawa and M. Demerec, unpublished results). The low homologies found in this region and an apparently generalized lowering of donor efficiency in transduction may be consequences of E . coli hsp+ modification of the hybrid DNA. V. Genetic Homologies between Species
A. SUMMARY OF DATA Homology values calculated from the data of various workers and shown as percentages, normalized when possible, are summarized in Table 2: gene symbols and map positions (minutes) are those of S. typhimurium (Sanderson, 1970), which is the female parent of hybrids with E. coli, Salmonella nrontevideo, and Salmonella abony males. Figure 1 summarizes the homology values between S. typhimurium and E. coli.
B. RELIABILITY OF HOMOLOGY VALUES The high resolving power and sensitivity of transduction analysis yield quantitative estimates of the decrease in integration of male genetic markers due to lack of homology of the region of genetic material under consideration. To facilitate interpretation and comparison of different experiments the normalized numbers of transductants are presented as percent homologies. 1. Direct Selection for Male Genes
The most reliable values appear to be those generated from transduction analysis of male genes for which the hybrids have been directly selected. When the female markers used are stable, preferably short deletions, the hybrids are certain to contain the desired male gene. Heterogenotes are unlikely if the hybrids are phenotypically stable, and
66
RICHARD B. MIDDLETON AND TOBIAS MOJICA-A
TABLE 2 Summary of Percentage Homology Values of S. typhimurium with E . coli, S. montevideo, and S . abony Gene symbol* ara argA
H
C F AHCF B D
E
aroA B
C
aac cysA B C CD
H Z
3 gal
dt
BlyA guaA his ilV
A C D
E
leu lysA metA C
E F nkcA Pan
Ph
pheA PPC
Map position* (min) 4 128 128 128 128 128 91 8 102 45 108 108 23 76 52 90 90 90 90 90 33 33 80 79 65 122 122 122 122 122 4
91 129 103 123 128 33 9 120 88 128
Percentage homologyt with
E . coli 0h,5k,
7s'
<1b,2d-e,lgh 0.6h < lb,4d 7h 8h 7h
S. montevideo
S. abony
1l b 26',318 17b,328 27" 31' 17O
3h
17h, 0 . 1 ~(Deletion in pyrF), 0.6d 0.3d, 0.5d 0.2d 0.5d 65" 16" 21h 15h, 20b, 1000, 16h 14h 1k,40J', <0.58,
ll-16b 70b 10-150,
ll-16b 2oj 220 9' 16' 110
23',24' 10-15b 23' 24'
568
lOOb
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE
67
: HOMOLOGY FROM INTERCROSSES
TABLE 2 (Continued) Gene symbol* pwB ZlC G PYrA
C
D E F serA B thT
B
thyA tTP B
C
E ABCDE tyrA
Map position* (min) 43 79 81 2 42 41 116 51 95 1 1 1 91 52 52 52 52 52
a4
Percentage homologyt with
E. coli 10h 12h, 4d1 390,
0.7' (Deletion in F, long insertion); 12b, 66g (Deletion in F, short insertion),
S. montevideo
S . abony
ll-16b 10-15b >1000 61b 5l b 35b 81b
1000 1000
700,
1OOb
* Gene symbols and map positions are those of 8.typhimurium (Sanderson, 1970), except for locus designations of trp which follow the E. coli convention (Taylor, 1970). t a, Armstrong (1967); b, Demerec, M. (unpublished observations forwarded by Dr. P. E. Hartman); c, Demerec and New (1965); d, Demerec and Ohta (1964), and Demerec (1965b) and see Table 4; el Eisenatark (1965b); f, Glatzer et al. (1966); g, Ino and Demerec (1968); h, Middleton, R. B. (unpublished results); i, Mojica-a and Middleton (1970a), j, St. Pierre and Demerec (1968); k, Zinder (1960). are excluded if cotransduction fails to reveal a cryptic female allele as discussed in Section II1,A above. If genetic analysis of a group of hybrids is limited to a single transducing fragment, unselected male genetic material which may have been incorporated in other regions of the chromosome can be eliminated by transferring the interesting transducing fragment of a group of hybrids into a recipient strain of the female species. Examples of well-studied homologies of directly selected male genes in S. tgphimurium females are the E. coli cysC (Demerec, 1964, 1965b; Demerec and Ohta, 1964) and trp regions (In0 and Demerec, 1968; Mojica-a, 1971; Mojica-a and Middleton, 1970a) and the S. montevideo
68
RICHARD B . MIDDLETON AND TOBIAS MOJICA-A u)
mdov
0 _.
Fro. 1. Percentage homology between S. typhimurium and E. coli, from column 3 of Table 2. Inside the circle are values based on selection for the locus, on an integrated segment which includes a selected locus, or on the identification of a phenotype derived from the male parents. Outside the circle are values inferred from low donor ability of hybrids. Map positions, 1-138 minutes, are indicated at 5-minute intervals.
ilv region (Atkins and Armstrong, 1969). The recipient strains used
for transduction analysis should have stable single-site or short multisite mutations in order to assume that the homology values reflect the behavior of the gene under study rather than that of neighboring genetic regions.
W. Regions of Low Hom#ology Regions of the genetic map which have low genetic homology are more easily distinguished than regions of higher homology. I n addition to greater precision in the determination of homology values for selected markers, the ends of the incorporated male segment of genetic material can be identified. This latter characteristic permits the study of reciprocal effects of male and female segments on markers near the junction of the two types of genetic material. Demerec and Ohta (1964) reported
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : HOMOLOGY FROM INTERCROSSES
69
that the S. typhimurium genes of composite transducing fragments were incorporated into transductants with full efficiency (100%), whereas E . coli genes were incorporated a t 40%. Since homology in the cysC transducing fragment is less than 1% when all genes are E . coli, they concluded that the synaptic forces acting between homologous portions of a composite transducing fragment and recipient chromosome can increase the donor efficiency of E.coli genes about 40-fold. Glatzer et al. (1966) reported the opposite effect in S. montevideo-8. typhimurium hybrids in the ilv region, namely, proximity of a male region caused a decrease in the donor efficiency of the female ilvC+ gene of two hybrids. In addition, the genetic identification of a hybrid ilv gene cluster (Atkins and Armstrong, 1969) and hybrid trpA+ gene (Middleton and Mojica-a, 1970) makes possible the correlation of genetic analysis and biochemical studies of the gene products. The electrophoretic mobility of the product (reductoisomerase) of the ilvC+ gene for any hybrid studied was characteristic of either the male (S. montevideo) or female (S. typhimurium) enzyme and agreed with the origin of the gene as assigned to male or female by transduction analysis. Selection of a hybrid trpA+ gene resulted from a cross between an E . coli male deleted for the operator-distal portion of the trpA gene and a S. typhimurium female deleted for the operator-proximal portion of the trpA gene. Stable Trp+ recombinants with a secondary trpE mutation produce high levels of the trpA+ gene product (G. R. Drapeau, personal communication) , the A protein of tryptophan synthetase, which can be analyzed for characteristics of the parental enzymes which differ in physical properties (Creighton et al., 1966). This approach may lead to a means of associating quantitative biological homology with actual differences in the nucleotide sequence of the two genes, since the A protein of tryptophan synthetase of E . coli has been sequenced (Yanofsky et al., 1967). There are three conspicuous regions of low homology between E . coli and S. typhimurium, and hybrids in these regions indicate the lengths of male genetic material which may be integrated into the chromosome: The cysC region. Demerec and Ohta (1964) selected Cys+ hybrids from crosses between E . coli and two S. typhimurium females: with a short deletion and with two single-site mutations within the cysC gene cluster. Rather long segments of male DNA were incorporated (Table 3 ) . All 12 hybrids carried E . coli genes for the 5 genes tested within the cysC transducing fragment, and in 10 hybrids the E. coli segment extended clockwise, or both clockwise and counterclockwise. The largest E . coli segment included purG and argE, 80-102 min, and
70
RICHARD B . MIDDLETON A N D TOBIAS MOJICA-A
TABLE 3 Lengths of E . coli Genetic Material Incorporated into Hybrids (Calculated from Demerec, 196513)*
No. of hybrids
Inclusive E. coli genes
Estimated percentage of Map position total genome in (min) E . coli segment
~
2 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1
CYSJ+-C~SC+ C ~ J+-lysA S cysJ+-serA+ cysJ+-argE+ cysJ+-metC+ purG+-serA + pheA +-met C+ tyrA+-metC+ purG+-argE+ +
90-90 90-91 90-95 90-102 90-103 80-95 84-103 84-103 80-102
1 2 4 8.7 9.4 11 14 14 16
* Derived fromTable 4; based on S. typhimuriummap, total 138 minutes (Sanderson, 1970). is estimated to comprise about 16% of the total genome (Table 3) based on the total map length, 138 min. Homology is low, 0.2-7% throughout the region, purG to metC, 80-103 min. The serB-pan region. A second region of generally low homology is serB-pan, 1-9 min, with homologies, 0-1276 except for pyrA, 39% (Table 2 ) . A study of two groups of hybrids generated by E . coli Hfr AB261 and two S. typhinzurium LT7 strains again indicates a tendency for the incorporation of long E. coli segments in this region (R. B. Middleton, unpublished results). Such incorporations occur whether the selection is made within the region (thrB, 1 min) as in one group of 12 hybrids, or outside the region (ilv and trpB, 122 and 52 min) as in the other group of 31 hybrids. The largest male segments in the serB-pan region were metrl-pan, 129-9 min, 14% of the total genome, and serBpan, 1-9 min, 7% of the genome. As noted by Glatzer et al. (1966), one might account for long incorporations of male genetic material in regions of low homology as a consequence of fewer locations of identical homology. I n such regions there would be a considerable distance from one crossover to the next. They found maximum S. montevideo segments of 4% of the S. typhimurium chromosome in the ilv region, presumably a consequence of higher homology in the ilv region than in serB-pan or cysC regions and of the closer relationship between two Salmonella species than between S. typhimurium and E . coli.
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE
:
HOMOLOQY FROM INTERCROSSES
71
The trp region. A third region of low homology between E . coli and S. typhimurium is the tryptophan region; the trp transducing fragment contains the five structural genes, A-E, of the trp operon, as well as cysB and pyrF. The orientation of this group of seven genes is reversed in the two species, although the order of the genes is the same (Sanderson, 1970; Taylor 1970) : pyrF-cysB-trpOEDCBA. From the left, these genes are oriented clockwise in S. typhimurium and counterclockwise in E . coli (Sanderson and Hall, 1970). A female with a deletion for most of the trp operon yielded three clases of hybrids as determined by increasing size of the inserted male segment: trp operon only, trp operon plus most of the region between trpE and cysB, and trp operon plus cysB. A female with a short deletion of pyrF also yielded three hybrid classes: E . coli for only a part of pyrF locus, for pyrF plus cysB, and for pyrF plus cysB plus trp operon. The last class, where the entire transducing fragment appears to be E . coli in origin, generated the percentage homology values reported: pyrF, 0.7; cysB, 0.1; trp, <0.03 (In0 and Demerec, 1968). The hybrids with E . coli inserted in part of the pyrF gene were peculiar in two respects: they exhibited a partial requirement for uracil (slow growth on minimal medium) and were high-efficiency donors in crosses with pyrF recipients (apparent homology 66%). In the latter respect these hybrids resemble those generated from a female with a stable trpB point mutation; the hybrids were similarly efficient donors with a trpB recipient, 80% homology (R. B. Middleton, unpublished results). Three groups of hybrids, generated from females with deletions in trpA, C , and E , were inefficient donors in crosses with the same deletions as recipients: homology <0.05% for all groups. Higher efficiency for neighbouring genes as well as an ascending gradient of efficiency with distance from the selected gene indicate that the E . coli insertions are limited to the selected genes (Mojica-a and Middleton, 1970a). These results agree with Ino and Demerec (1968) in two respects: (1) when deletion strains are used to generate and test hybrids the homology is generally low throughout the trp transducing fragment; (2) in contrast to Demerec and Ohta (1964), and in agreement with Glatzer et al. (1966), an insertion of male genetic material can depress the donor efficiency of nearby female genes. The low homology of the trp region, and perhaps the inversion of this region between the two parental species, result in hindrance of genetic exchange which has observable consequences. A symptom of the rarity of recombination exchange in this region may be the identification of classes of hybrids (In0 and Demerec, 1968).Hybrids with very short male insertions may be of intermediate efficiency, perhaps one third
72
RICHARD B . MIDDLETON AND TOBIAS MOJICA-A
less efficient than a wholly female donor gene but nevertheless a t least 50 times more efficient than an E. coli gene (In0 and Demerec, 1968). 3. Regions of Intermediate Homology Intermediate homology values, 31-69% for example, become difficult to ascertain as the values increase since high donor efficiency of a wildtype male gene resembles the genetic behavior of a wild-type female gene. Additional difficulties arise from attempts to infer the origin of genes which are not selected in the interspecific cross or which &re not phenotypically distinguishable between the parents. The appearance in a hybrid of significantly lowered donor efficiency for an unselected wild type gene is, of course, evidence that the male gene has been integrated into the hybrid chromosome or has displaced the corresponding wild-type female gene. Hybrids diploid for the gene should permit transductions at full efficiency. Inferred homology values usually agree fairly well with the values produced from studies on selected genes (Fig. 1 ) . Wherever the inserted male genetic material is less than one transducing fragment long, however, as may be the case for unselected genes in particular, the homology values are not reliable. Such inferred values are therefore presented separately (Fig. 1, outside the circle) from the values for directly selected loci (inside the circle). The identification of regions of varying homology is of interest in considering the extent of divergence among enteric species of nucleotide sequences in the various parts of the genetic map. VI. Use of Hybrids for Mapping
A. ORDERING OF NEARBY GENESWHICHARE NOTCOTRANSDUCED The mapping of loci in enteric bacteria is usually accomplished by two methods : by interrupted matings and by three-point reciprocal crosses of markers which share a transducing fragment. Interrupted matings have a usuable lower limit of a few minutes when results from different crosses must be compared. Except in crosses with a special arrangement of mutant genes in the female strain (Sanderson, 1965), the order of genes a few minutes apart cannot be reliably determined. On the other hand, the ordering of genes, or sites, on a transducing fragment is limited by the size of each transducing fragment, about 1% of the bacterial genome or 1 min of the total map for 8. typhimurium with phage P22. As a consequence, genes which are slightly too far apart to share a transducing fragment are difficult t o order on the map. Biological hybrids provide an approach to mapping a t this intermediate level of
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : HOMOLOGY FROM INTERCROSSES
73
resolution. I n regions of fairly low homology, the ends of an integrated length of male genetic material can be identified, since wild-type genes carried in the donor region will be reflected in low transduction frequencies in crosses with recipient strains. The selection of a group of hybrids which carry a prototrophic (male) allele can result in the incorporation of various lengths of male material in the hybrids. The ordering of genes can then be made by a process analogous to that followed in mapping by means of overlapping deletions. An example (Table 4) is that of Demerec (1965b) who selected a number of hybrids with cys+ E. coli alleles in the cysC gene cluster of an S. typhiinuiium genome. Table 4 shows the transduction frequencies and normalized percentage homology values ; the genes are arranged in an order consistent with the incorporation of E. coli pieces of various lengths which include cysC+. As can be seen in Table 4, the homology between E. coli and S. typhimurium genetic material in the cysC region is low, the ends of the integrated E. coli pieces of each hybrid can be easily identified, and an unambiguous map order can be constructed of all genes which lie adjacent to the ends of the E. coli pieces. In Table 4, lysA-argB and pheA-tyrA are pairs of nearby genes for which the order could not be inferred from the group of hybrids studied although the lysA-argB order is now known from other evidence (Sanderson, 1970). I n addition, since all E . coli segments include all markers tested on the cysC transducing fragment, the orientation of the cysC fragment relative to the genetic map is not known.
B. ORIENTATIONOF
THE
ILVE-META REGION, 122-129 MINUTES
Glatzer et al. (1966) and Armstrong (1967) employed transduction analysis of S. montevideo F+-S. typhimurium hybrids and cotransduction tests to infer the order of a number of genes on the chromosome map and the orientation of genes within three transducing fragments, respectively. The segments of S. montevideo male chromosome integrated into hybrids selected for markers in the ilvE-metA region varied from 1-4% of the total map, and the patterns of incorporation led to the following proposed map order, reading clockwise from the left: Map position (min)
ilvE ilvD ilvA ilvC metE metB metF p p c argA argH argC argF purD metA 122 123 128 129
This map order agrees with that produced independently by time-ofentry conjugation crosses (Sanderson, 1970).
TABLE 4
Transductants* with 8.typhimurium Mutants as Recipients and S.'typhimurium X E. coli Hybrids as Donors Map poaition (min):
108
Recipients: cy&S82 Donors S. fuphimurium LT2 100 Hybrids A48 B33 135 B-20 A-57 45.3 B-24 113 A45 144 B-11 128 A40 A-I4 A-19 B-51 107 0-74 146 Number of hybrids with E. coli loci (normalized homology values 134%. in heavy type): 0 Percentage homology laveraze) : .
-
* Normalied (from data of
105 dCS2
104 argE116 100
95
91
serAlS
lyd8
arpB69
100
100 19.9
dGC697 @lOf!l
dGCD619 ddH76
100 2 3 0.9 0.3 0 1 0 0.6 0.1
100 1.4 0.4 0.1 0.1 0 0 0.4 0 0.2 0.8
0 0.2
1 4
40 0 0 0 0
0.3 0. I 0.9 0.3 3 0 0
0.1 0.9 0.4 1 2.5 0 5.1 1 1
0 0 0 0 0.3 0
100 0 2.2 0.5 0 0 0 0 0.6 0 0 0 0.6
4
5
8
10
10
12
9
4.9
3.4
0.32
0.94
100 18
-
100 33.1
375
-
429
-
131
-
335
101
3.5
20 85.1
80.0 105
115 479 44.0
1490 48.1
6.6
59
4.
21.4 183
74.8
89
90 cysc cluster
117 57.0 0
2.0
100 1.2
&I68
M5S8
pheAS
:WAS
100 0.2
100 72.9 65.4
100 100
100 -
100
138.3 100 136 100 136
311 119 107 108 127
100
0 0.3 -
-
0.8 0.2
0 0.4 0
100 1.3 1 0.6 0 0.2 0.2 0 2.1 0.2 0 0.2 0.2
10
7
8
12
0.34
0.47
0.18
0.5
-
0.8
-
0
-
-
80
-
0.6
-
0.1
-
0 0.2
88 119 87.5 119 0 100 84.8 0.96 9.18 14.3
0.2
-
237 1.3 16.2
purGS03
2.9
-
-
5.5
115
49.8 129
5
3
2
5.0
5.9
4.2
Demerec, 1965b) for recipient (LT2 values set a t 100 %) and for donor efficiencies (oluAl, @AS, or &AS values set at 100 %).
&/A1
-
-
100
-
100
1W
-
I00 100 100
100
0
-
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE
: HOMOLOGY FROM INTERCROSSES
75
C. LOCATING CERTAINWILD-TYPEGENES ( E . coli GENESAND MAP POSITIONS) Recombinants selected from E . coli Hfr X S. typhosa matings were used to locate the genes for 30 S ribosomal proteins on the genetic map (O’Neil et al., 1969). A hybrid, diploid for about one-third of the genome, clockwise from strA to proB (64-9 min), yielded 30 S ribosomal protein bands in gel electrophoresis which contain both E. coli (exogenote) and S. typhosa (endogenote) components. A second hybrid carried somewhat less E . coli genetic material, either integrated or as an exogenote, clockwise from malP to lac (66-10 min) ; apparently the E . coli 30 S ribosomal protein cistrons were not included since the electrophoretic pattern is characteristic of S. typhosa. The third hybrid had an integrated E . coli segment from strA to zyl ( W 7 1 min) and produced only the E . coli 30 S ribosomal protein pattern. It therefore appears that the cistrons for 30 S ribosomal proteins of both E. coli and S. typhosa are clustered in a small region, probably 64-66 min (of the E . coli map, Taylor 1970). By similar comparison of three 50 S proteins which differ in E . coli and S. typhosn, the same three hybrids indicate that the cistrons for these 50 S proteins are also located near strA, 64 min (Sypherd et al., 1969). A difference between the 23 S RNAs of these two species was found. Differentially labeled 23 S RNA was isolated from E. coli and 8.typhosa, mixed and digested with pancreatic ribonuclease. The resulting oligonucleotides were resolved on a DEAE-urea column and followed by high-voltage electrophoresis of the various size groups. A hexanucleotide unique to each species was identified: A,U from E . coli 23 S RNA, A,GC from S. typhosa. The first hybrid contains the hexanucleotides characteristic of both parental species, whereas the third hybrid has only the hexanucleotide from the S. typhosa cistron. It was concluded that the cistrons for 23 S RNA lie in the broad region from xyl to proB, 71-9 min, and that these rRNA cistrons are not closely linked to the cistrons for ribosomal proteins, near 64 min. It therefore appears unlikely that rRNA acts as message for ribosomal proteins (Sypherd et al., 1969). These examples illustrate the special use of hybrids (1) for mapping the order of genes near one another on the chromosome map but not sharing a transducing fragment, (2) for orienting a transducing fragment on the map, and (3) for placing on the map genes, common to enteric species, which are phenotypically distinguishable.
76
RICHARD B. MIDDLETON AND TOBIAS MOJICA-A
VII. Summary
The genetic behavior of interspecific hybrids in transduction analysis provides a quantitative measure of the microhomology of two species for the region considered. Whereas the similarity of the genetic maps of the enteric bacteria facilitates the formation of viable hybrids, divergence in the nucleotide sequences in the chromosomes of two species hinders efficient recombination in transduction crosses. The percentage homology values in general confirm the traditional assignments of biological relatedness: for any gene or region, closely related species have a higher homology value than do less related species. Hybrids permit an approach to the study of a number of interesting problems which include (1) the response of genes from the male species to regulatory genes of the female, (2) the elucidation of the structure of ribosomes and enzymes whose constituent parts are distinguishable between two species, (3) the properties of hybrid genes and gene products, and (4) the relative divergence of various regions of the chromosome map among enteric species.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors’ work was supported in part by the U.S.Atomic Energy Commission, Research Corporation, Medical (MA21601 and National (A3452) Research Councils of Canada, and Food and Drug Directorate of Canada. The authors appreciate the critical reading of the manuscript by a number of colleagues, and valuable comments by P. E. Hartman, K. E. Sanderson, F. B. Armstrong, Marie L. Godfrey, C. G. Atkins, and I. Takahashi.
REFERENCES Arber, W. 1965. Host-controlled modification of bacteriophage. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 19, 365-378. Arber, W., and Linn, S. 1969. DNA modification and restriction. Annu. Rev. Biochem. 38, 467400. Armstrong, F. B. 1967. Orientation ,and order of loci of the met-arg region in the Salmonella typhimurium linkage map. Genetics 56, 463-466. Atkins, C. G., and Armstrong, F. B. 1969. Electrophoretic study of Salmonella typhimurium-Salmonella montevddeo hybrids. Genetics 63, 775-779. Baron, L. S., Carey, W. K., and Spilman, W. M. 1959a. Genetic recombination between Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U.S. 45, 976-984. Baron, L. S., Carey, W. F., and Spilman, W. M. 1959b. Hybridisation of Salmonella species by mating with Escherichia coli. Science 130, 566-567.
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE
HOMOLOGY FROM INTERCROSSES
77
Baron, L. S.,Gemski, P., Jr., Johnson, E. M., and Wohlhieter, J. A. 1968. Intergeneric bacterial matings. Bacteriol. Rev. 32, 362369. Bertani, G., and Weigle, J. J. 1953. Host-controlled variation in bacterial viruses. J . Bacteriol. 65, 113-121. Boyer, H. W., and Roulland-Dussoix, D. 1969. A complementation analysis of the restriction and modification of DNA in Escherichia coli. J . Mol. Bwl. 41, 459472. Brenner, D. J., and Falkow, S. 1971. Molecular relationships among members of the Enterobacteriaceae. Advan. Genet. 16, 81-118. Colson, A. M., Colson, C., and Van Pel, A. 1969. Host-controlled restriction mutants of Salmonella typhimurium. J . Gen. Microbiol. 58, 57-64. Creighton, T. E., Helinski, D. R., Somerville, R. L., and Yanofsky, C. 1966. Comparison of the tryptophan synthetase a subunits of several species of Enterobacteriaceae. J . Bacteriol. 91, 1819-1826. Curtiss, R. 1969. Bacterial conjugation. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 23, 69-136. Curtiss, R., Charamella, L. J., Stallions, D. R., and Mays, J. A. 1968. Parental functions during conjugation in Escherichia coli K-12. Bacteriol. Rev. 32, 320-348. Demerec, M. 1964. Organization of genetic material in Salmonella. In “Struktur und Funktion des Genetischen Materials: Erwin-Bauer-Gedachtnisvorlesungen 111,” pp. 51-56. Akademie-Verlag, Berlin. Demerec, M. 1965a. Gene differentiation. Nut. Cancer Inst. Monogr. 18, 15-20. Demerec, M. 196513. Homology and divergence in genetic material in Salmonella typhimurium and Escherichia coli. In “Evolving Genes and Proteins” (V. Bryson and H. J. Vogel, eds.), pp. 505-510. Academic Press, New York. Demerec, M., and New, K. 1965. Genetic divergence in Salmonella typhimurium, S. montevideo, and Escherichia coli. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 18, 652455. Demerec, M., and Ohta, N. 1964. Genetic analysis of Salmonella typhimurium x Escherichia coli hybrids. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. US. 52, 317-323. Demerec, M., Adelberg, E. A., Clark, A. J., and Hartman, P. E. 1966. A proposal for a uniform nomenclature in bacterial genetics. Genetics 54, 61-76 [reprinted in J. Gen. Microbiol. 50, 1-14 (1968)l. Eisenstark, A. 1965a. Mutagen-induced hybridization of Salmonella typhimurium LT2 x Escherichia coli K-12 Hfr. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U.S. 54, 117-120. Eisenstark, A. 1965b. Transduction of Escherichia coli genetic material by phage P22 in Salmonella typhimurium x E . coli hybrids. Proc. Nut. Acad. Sci. U.S. 54, 1557-1560. Falkow, S.,Marmur, J., Carey, W. F., Spilman, W. M., and Baron, L. S. 1961. Episomic transfer between Salmonella typhosa and Serratia marcescens. Genetics 46, 703-706. GarrickSilversmith, L., and Hartman, P. E. 1970. Histidine-requiring mutants of Escherichia coli K-12. Genetics 66, 231-244. Glatzer, L., LaBrie, D. A., and Armstrong, F. B. 1966. Transduction of Salmonella typhimurium-Xalmonella montevideo hybrids. Genetics 54, 423-432. Grasso, R. J., and Paigen, K. 1968a. The effect of amino acids on host-controlled restriction of lambda phage. Virology 36, 1-8. Grasso, R. J., and Paigen, K. 1968b. Loss of host-controlled restriction of h bacteriophage in Escherichia coli following methionine deprivation. J. Virol. 2, 1368-1373.
78
RICHARD B. MIDDLETON AND TOBIAS MOJICA-A
Gwinn, D. D., and Lawton, W. D. 1968. Alteration of host specificity in Bacillus subtilis. Bacteriol. Rev. 32, 297-301. Ino, I., and Demerec, M. 1968. Enteric hybrids. 11. S. typhimurium-E. coli hybrids for the trp-cysB-pyrF region. Genetics 59, 167-176. Johnson, E. M., Falkow, S., and Baron, L. S. 1964. Recipient ability of Salmonella typhosa in genetic crosses with Escherichia coli. J. Bacteriol. 87, 54-60. LaBrie, D. A., and Armstrong, F. B. 1968. Transduction using ilv mutants of Salmonella typhimurium-Salmonella montevideo hybrids. J. Bacteriol. 95, 1193-1194. Leavitt, R. W.,Wohlhieter, J. A., Johnson, E. M., Ladda, R. L., and Baron, L. S. 1970. Isolation of circular DNA from Salmonella typhosa hybrids obtained from matings with Escherichia coli. Bacteriol. Proc. p. 55. Lew, K. K., and Roth, J. R. 1970. Genetic approaches to determination of enzyme quaternary structure. Biochemistry 10, 204-207. Luria, S. E. 1953. Host-induced modification of viruses. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 18, 237-244. Luria, S. E., and Burrous, J. W. 1957. Hybridization between Escherichia coli and Shigella. J. Bacteriol. 74, 461476. Mandel, M. 1969. New approaches to bacterial taxonomy : perspectives and prospects. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 23, 239-274. Middleton, R. B., and Demerec, M. 1966. Genetic homology of Salmonella typhimurium and Escherichia coli. Genetics 54,347-348. Middleton, R. B., and Mojica-a, T. 1970. Homology of Salmonella typhimurium and Escherichia coli: selection of hybrids and restriction of coliphage P1. Proc. 10th Znt. Congr. Microbiol. p. 52. Miyake, T. 1959. Fertility factor in Salmonella typhimurium. Nature (London) 184, 657-658. Miyake, T. 1960. Mutator factor in Salmonella typhimurium. Genetics 45, 11-14. Miyake, T. 1962. Exchange of genetic material between Salmonella typhimurium and Escherichia coli K-12. Genetics 47, 1043-1052. Mojica-a, T. 1971. Genetic behavior of male genetic material in enteric hybrids. M.Sc. thesis, McGill University. Mojica-a, T., and Middleton, R. B. 1970a. Genetic homology of Salmonella typhb murium and Escherichia coli: production of hybrids and analysis of the tryptophan operon. Bacteriol. Proc. p. 22. Mojica-a, T., and Middleton, R. B. 1970b. Host restriction and modification of coliphage P1 by Salmonella typhimurium. Bacteriol. Proc. p. 35. Okada, M., and Watanabe, T. 1968. Isolation of Salmonella typhimurium mutants with increased recipient ability by use of R factor. Nature (London) 217, 854-866. Okada, M., Watanabe, T., and Miyake, T. 1968. On the nature of the recipient ability of Salmonella typhimurium for foreign deoxyribonucleic acids. J . Gen. Microbiol. 50, 241-252. O’Neil, D. M., Baron, L. S., and Sypherd, P. S. 1969. Chromosomal location of ribosomal protein cistrons determined by intergeneric bacterial matings. J. Bacteriol. 99, 242247. St. Pierre, M. L., and Demerec, M. 1968. Hybrids of enteric bacteria. I. S. typhimurium-S. montevideo hybrids for the histidine loci. Genetics 59, 1-9. Sanderson, K.E. 1965. Information transfer in Salmonella typhimurium. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U.S. 53, 1335-1340.
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE
: HOMOLOGY FROM
INTERCROSSES
79
Sanderson, K. E. 1970. Current linkage map of Salmonella typhimurium. Bacteriol. Rev. 34, 176-193. Sanderson, K. E. 1971. Genetic homology in the Enterobacteriaceae. Advan. Genet. 16, 35-51.
Sanderson, K. E., and Hall, C. A. 1970. F-prime factors of Salmonella typhimurium and an inversion between S. typhimurium and Escherichia coli. Genetics 64, 215-228.
Sypherd, P. S., O’Neil, D. M., and Taylor, M. M. 1969. The chemical and genetic structure of bacterial ribosomes. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 34, 77-84.
Taylor, A. L. 1970. Current linkage map of Escherichia coli. Bacteriol. Rev. 34, 155-175.
Watanabe, T., Arai, T., and Hattori, T. 1970. Effects of cell wall polysaccharide on the mating ability of Salmonella typhimurium. Nature (London) 225, 70-71. Yanofsky, C., Drapeau, G. R., Guest, J. R., and Carlton, B. C. 1967. The complete amino acid sequence of the tryptophan synthetase A protein (a subunit) and its colinear relationship with the genetic map of the A gene. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U.S. 57, 296-298. Zinder, N. D. 1960. Hybrids of Escherichia and Sulmonella. Science 131, 813-815.
.
C MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS A M O N G MEMBERS OF THE ENTEROBACTERIACEAE
.
Don J Brenner and Stanley Falkow Division of Biochemistry. Walter Reed Army Institute of Research. Washington. D.C., and the Department of Microbiology. Schools of Medicine ond Dentistry. Georgetown University. Washington. D.C.
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 81 I1. Techniques Used in Nucleic Acid Reassociation . . . . . . . . 82 A . Density Gradient Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . 83 B . Nitrocellulose Filter and DNA-Agar Methods . . . . . . . 83 C . Hydroxyapatite Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 85 D . Measurement of DNA Reassociation from Renaturation Rate . . . 86 I11. Factors Affecting Nucleic Acid Reassociation . . . . . . . . . 86 A . Purity of Nucleic Acid Preparations . . . . . . . . . . 86 B . Base Composition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 87 C. DNA Fragment Size . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 87 D . Ionic Strength . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 87 E. Incubation Temperature . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 87 F. Nucleic Acid Concentration and Time of Incubation . . . . . . 88 I V. Interpretation of Reassociation Data . . . . . . . . . . . 90 V . Taxonomy and Nomenclature . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95 V I . Nucleic Acid Relationships among Enterobacteria . . . . . . . 96 A . Divergence among Different Strains of E. coli . . . . . . . . 97 B . Relatedness between E. coli K12, Strains of the Alkalescens-Dispar Group and Shigella Species . . . . . . . 99 C . Relative Relatedness between E coli and Other Enterobacteria . . 101 V I I . Divergencein Specific Portions of the Genome . . . . . . . . 105 A . Detection of E. coli-Specific DNA in the Genomes of Heterologous Organisms . . . . . . . . . . . . . 105 B . Divergence of the Lactose Operon among Enterobacteria . . . . 108 C . Conservation of Ribosomal RNA Genes . . . . . . . . . 110 D . Conservation of Transfer RNA Genes . . . . . . . . . 111 VIII . Relationships between Extrachromosomal Elements . . . . . . 112 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 116
.
I. Introduction
The family Enterobacteriaceae is a large and diverse group of microorganisms which are often found as commensal members of the intestinal 81
82
DON J. BRENNER AND STANLEY FALKOW
tract and are sometimes pathogenic for man, animals, and even plants. The medical and agricultural importance of the enterobacteria has stimulated intense interest in their serology, biochemistry, and genetics. These organisms exhibit a wide range of differences in distribution, host specificity, virulence, phage susceptibility, antigens, and biochemical capacity. This variability is not surprising in view of the fact that their guanine cytosine content in deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) varies from 37% in Proteus vulgaris to about 58% in strains of Serratia marcescens and Aerobacter aerogenes (Marmur and Doty, 1962). I n the past decade advances in nucleic acid technology and in microbial genetics have allowed a preliminary assessment of genetic relatedness among many of these organisms. Comparative recombination studies among many enterobacteria are plagued by several factors, including restriction and modification of DNA, surface incompatibility, different fertility groups, different specificities of recombinational enzymes, and dissimilarity in DNA base composition. These genetic difficulties may be circumvented by directly comparing the ability of DNA from one organism to specifically reassociate or reanneal with DNA from another organism. Nucleic acid reassociation studies have also been used for the purpose of establishing a phyletic or natural classification. This type of study attempts to establish the lines of evolutionary divergence within the Enterobacteriaceae. Polynucleotide sequence relatedness between members of the enterobacteria and enterophages has also been investigated. These investigations have been extended to assess relationships among several plasmids found in enterobacteria and between these plasmids and Escherichia coli. Nucleic acid reassociation studies have also been extended to determine relatedness among specific portions of the genome. Thus far the lactose operon, the ribosomal ribonucleic acid (rRNA) cistrons, and the transfer RNA (tRNA) cistrons have been investigated. We shall attempt to summarize results obtained from all of these studies in order to present current views regarding genetic relationships among the Enterobacteriaceae, their viruses and their plasmids. We begin with a discussion of the types of methodology employed in these studies and the parameters that affect nucleic acid reassociation studies.
+
II. Techniques Used in Nucleic Acid Reassociation
Native bacterial DNA is composed of two chains of covalently linked purine and pyrimidine bases. The two strands are held together largely by hydrogen bonds formed between the complementary bases adenine
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
83
and thymine, and guanine and cytosine. With the exception of rRNA cistrons, which are present in 6 5 copies (Kohne, 1968), the bacterial genome does not have significantly repetitious DNA. In other words, there is but one copy of each gene. DNA strands can be separated by heating them at a temperature high enough to break the hydrogen bonds and overcome base-stacking energy. If the DNA is then quickly cooled, the strands will remain separated. If, after thermal denaturation, the separated strands are incubated at a suitable temperature, they will specifically reassociate or reanneal with their complementary strands to form a double-stranded molecule. Single-stranded DNA will reassociate with a complementary DNA strand or a complementary RNA strand from the same or a different organism. This ability to dissociate DNA strands and allow them to reanneal specifically with nucleic acids from a homologous or heterologous source is the basis for all nucleic acid relationship studies. All of the methods discussed below rely on the specificity of DNA-DNA or DNA-RNA reassociation and the ability to separate reassociated nucleic acid products from any unreacted molecules.
A. DENSITY GRADIENTMETHODS These techniques involve mixing two DNAs or DNA and RNA, allowing them to reassociate, and then detecting reassociated duplexes in CsCl density gradients. In one application, DNA from one organism was uniformly labeled with a “heavy” isotope and allowed to reassociate with unlabeled DNA from another source. The presence of reassociated duplexes composed of one “light” strand and one “heavy” strand was the criterion employed to determine DNA similarity (Schildkraut et al., 1961). This technique is impractical for routine work as it is quite time consuming and also has the serious disadvantage of only detecting very closely related duplexes. CsCl has also been used to detect or confirm the presence of DNA-tRNA hybrids (Goodman and Rich, 1962; Brenner, et al., 1970). In this case one nucleic acid was labeled with 32Pand the gradient was assayed for radioactivity at the density equivalent to a DNA-RNA hybrid.
FILTER AND DNA-AGAR METHODS B. NITROCELLULOSE The DNA-agar technique was the first generally applicable method for measuring nucleic acid relatedness (Bolton and McCarthy, 1962). In this method, high-molecular-weight DNA is denatured and added
84
DON J. BRENNER AND STANLEY FALKOW
to a molten agar solution which is then quickly cooled. The DNA-agar is then extensively washed to remove any DNA not bound firmly to the agar. Radiolabeled RNA or radiolabeled, sheared, denatured DNA is incubated with the DNA-agar to allow reassociation between labeled nucleic acids and agar-immobilized DNA. DNA is sheared in order to allow free diffusion through the agar matrix so that label present in the DNA-agar after incubation is the result of nucleic acid reassociation and not physical trapping of labeled DNA in the DNA-agar. Shearing is accomplished in different laboratories by sonication or mechanical shearing in a pressure cell or pressure pump. The average DNA fragment is 125,000 or 250,000 daltons per single strand depending upon the conditions employed. Incubation is carried out for a period sufficient to insure maximum reaction between the labeled nucleic acid and the unlabeled, immobilized DNA. The agar is then washed thoroughly to remove all labeled DNA that has not reacted with the DNA-agar. Reassociated, labeled DNA or RNA is removed from the agar either by increasing the temperature and dropping the salt concentration to a point where the molecules are dissociated, or by removing the reacted labeled nucleic acid in a series of thermal elutions. It is difficult to reproducibly weigh out agar samples because each preparation contains different amounts of moisture and the moisture content varies with storage. It is also difficult to prevent or control leaching of DNA from the agar a t high incubation or elution temperatures. The nitrocellulose filter method has largely replaced the DNA-agar method because samples need not be weighed out, lower background values are obtained, and more samples can be conveniently handled. In principle the nitrocellulose filter method is similar to the DNA-agar method. High-molecular-weight, denatured DNA in dilute solution is slowly impinged on a nitrocellulose filter. The procedure for binding DNA to filters differs depending upon whether DNA-DNA (Denhardt, 1966) or DNA-RNA (Gillespie and Spiegelman, 1965) reactions are of interest. Filters are dried and then washed to remove unbound or loosely bound DNA. Sheared, denatured, labeled DNA (or labeled RNA) is added to a filter containing DNA and the reaction mixture is incubated as in the agar procedure. Elution procedures are similar to those employed in the agar method. Problems encountered with the filter method include variability in binding of DNA by different batches of filters and leaching of DNA a t high temperatures. Many laboratories are now using denaturants, such as formamide, which suppress the thermal stability of DNA and allow reactions and elutions to be carried out a t significantly lower temperatures (McConaughy et al., 1969). In the above methods, one labeled nucleic acid preparation is reacted
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE
:
MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
85
with a series of different unlabeled DNA preparations in agar or on filters. It is sometimes preferable to carry out competition experiments. In a competition experiment both the labeled DNA and the immobilized DNA are from the same source. This homologous reaction is carried out and the degree of binding is obtained. The homologous reaction is also carried out with a series of tubes containing increasing amounts of unlabeled competitor DNA from the same or different organisms to generate a series of competition curves. Homologous competitor DNA reacts with most of the labeled DNA before it can react with complementary sequences on the filter or in the agar, and the amount of binding is markedly reduced. The decrease in binding (if any) caused by each heterologous competitor DNA is compared to the decrease in binding caused by the homologous competitor DNA and an index of relatedness is obtained. Nygaard and Hall (1963) developed a method in which labeled RNA is incubated free in solution with a large excess of unlabeled DNA. This incubation mixture is then passed through a nitrocellulose filter which retains DNA-RNA hybrids and single-stranded DNA, but does not bind unreacted RNA.
C. HYDROXYAPATITE METHOD Hydroxyapatite (HA) is a modified calcium phosphate gel that is extremely effective in fractionating single- and double-stranded DNA (Bernardi, 1965; Miyazawa and Thomas, 1965; Britten and Kohne, 1966). Labeled, sheared DNA fragments (or labeled RNA molecules) are mixed with unlabeled, sheared DNA fragments and the mixture is thermally denatured. A mixture of labeled, sheared DNA fragments and unlabeled, sheared DNA fragments (or RNA molecules) is thermally denatured and incubated a t the desired temperature until maximal reassociation has occurred. The mixture is then passed through HA contained in a water jacketed column or by a batch procedure (Brenner et al., 1969a). The HA is equilibrated in 0.12 or 0.14 M phosphate buffer a t the temperature employed during incubation (usually 60 or 75OC). Under these conditions single-stranded DNA does not adsorb to HA, while reassociated DNA-DNA duplexes and DNA-RNA hybrids are adsorbed. Nucleic acids are eluted by raising the ionic strength t o a point where double-stranded DNA and DNA-RNA hybrids are not bound to HA (0.4 M phosphate buffer is usually employed) or by raising the temperature to a point where the duplexes or hybrids are dissociated and elute from HA. Reassociation of labeled DNA fragments with one another is not a
86
DON J. BRENNER AND STANLEY FALKOW
problem in the agar or filter systems as these duplexes will be washed out along with unreacted labeled fragments. I n the HA system, however, it is impossible to discriminate between the desired labeled-unlabeled DNA duplex and the undesired labeled-labeled DNA duplex. DNA reassociation is an essentially typical collision dependent, second-order reaction (Britten and Kohne, 1966). Therefore the concentration of unlabeled fragments is made the rate-determining factor (Britten and Kohne, 1966) by employing a tremendous excess of unlabeled fragments in the incubation mixture. This allows virtually complete reassociation of unlabeled fragments while virtually precluding reassociation of labeled fragments with one another. Thermal stability profiles of reassociated nucleic acids bound to HA are generated by washing a t a series of increasing temperatures. When the temperature exceeds the denaturation temperature of a duplex it will elute as single-stranded DNA.
D. MEASUREMENT OF DNA REASSOCIATION FROM RENATURATION RATE A new method based on renaturation rate determinations of DNA from each of two organisms and from their mixture has recently been reported by De Ley and his collegues (De Ley et al., 1970). The method compares optical rates of reassociation of homologous and heterologous DNA a t various temperatures. It appears to be sensitive at a 6OoC criterion with organisms showing moderate or greater relatedness. The obvious advantages of such a procedure are that no radiolabeled preparations are necessary and data are obtained in a short period of time. 111. Factors Affecting Nucleic Acid Reassociation
In a reassociation experiment, nucleic acids are incubated under a set of conditions such tha,t single-stranded DNA fragments (or RNA molecules) may collide with unlabeled DNA (or RNA) in free solution (HA and Nygaard-Hall methods), immobilized in agar, or on filters. Double-stranded DNA duplexes (or DNA-RNA hybrids) are formed, as bases in one strand form hydrogen bonds with their complementary bases in the other strand. The extent and specificity of nucleic acid reassociation in any method is affected by a number of parameters, some of which are summarized below. OF NUCLEICACID PREPARATIONS A. PURITY The extent of reassociation obtained with a nucleic acid preparation, especially a labeled preparation, is dependent upon the purity of that
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
87
preparation. The stability of reassociated DNA decreases when contaminating RNA or protein are present. It is particularly essential to remove contaminating nucleic acid and protein when looking a t a specific region of the genome or a specific population of RNA molecules. €3. BASE COMPOSITION
Guanine and cytosine base pairs exhibit greater thermal stability than adenine and thymine base pairs; therefore the greater the amount of guanine cytosine base pairs within a given DNA duplex, the higher is the thermal stability of that duplex (Marmur and Doty, 1962). In addition, the rate of reassociation increases slightly with increased guanine cytosine content (Wetmur and Davidson, 1968).
+
+
C. DNA FRAGMENT SIZE Any short sequence of bases will be present in all DNA molecules. Therefore, no specificity is to be expected in reactions between very small DNA fragments. In bacteria, the minimal specific DNA fragment size is about 15 nucleotides (about 4500 daltons) (McCarthy, 1967; McConaughy and McCarthy, 1967). The fragment size employed in most investigations is either about 125,000 daltons (300-400 nucleotides/single strand) or 250,000 daltons. The larger fragments reassociate 25% faster than the smaller ones (Britten and Kohne, 1966).
D. IONIC STRENGTH The rate of DNA reassociation increases as the ionic strength of the incubation medium is increased (Britten and Kohne, 1966). Thermal stability of reassociated DNA also increases (Marmur and Doty, 1962). One can easily shift the midpoint temperature of strand separation by 2OoC or more and increase the rate of reassociation by 10-fold or more by changing ionic strength. Most investigators tend to keep ionic strength constant during a given experiment. It has been more convenient in our hands (Brenner et al., 1969b) to vary the experimental criterion by changing incubation temperature rather than shifting salt concentration.
E. INCUBATION TEMPERATURE The temperature a t which optimal reassociation occurs is some 25 to 3OoC below the temperature a t which a given DNA is denatured
88
DON J. BRENNER AND STANLEY FALKOW
(Marmur and Doty, 1961; Marmur et al., 1963). The temperature a t which DNA dissociates is determined by its guanine cytosine content (Marmur and Doty, 1962) and the reaction conditions, especially salt concentration (Britten and Kohne, 1966). Incubation temperatures significantly below the optimum allow distantly related and unrelated sequences to reassociate (McCarthy, 1967; Johnson and Ordal, 1968). I n heterologous reactions between moderately or distantly related bacteria the amount of reaction can be shifted up to 10-fold by varying the temperature of incubation (Brenner et aZ., 1967; Johnson and Ordal, 1968). Thermal stability of interspecies DNA duplexes formed between distantly or moderately related bacteria is also significantly changed depending upon the temperature of incubation (Brenner and Cowie, 1968; Johnson and Ordal, 1968). These points will be considered in detail in a later section.
+
F. NUCLEICACID CONCENTRATION AND TIME OF INCUBATION The concentration of labeled DNA (or RNA) and unlabeled nucleic acid, as well as the time of incubation, must be carefully chosen in order to obtain meaningful data on reassociation and relatedness among bacteria. Generally, in agar and filter reactions, the ratio of unlabeled to labeled nucleic acid is kept a t 1OO:l or higher. This provides an excess of available sites with which any related labeled nucleic acid sequence can reassociate. Incubation times are chosen so that reassociation between labeled DNA (or RNA) and immobilized DNA is maximal. DNA concentration and incubation time are particularly critical in free-solution reactions. As previously mentioned, reassociation of labeled fragments with one another cannot be distinguished from the desired reassociation product of labeled with unlabeled DNA fragments. Therefore the labeled DNA concentration is kept small enough to insure little or no label-label reassociation during the course of reaction. Britten and Kohne (1966) introduced the term ‘‘Cot” in order to present measurements of the time course of reassociation. When temperature, salt concentration, and DNA fragment size are held constant, reassociation is determined by the concentration of DNA and the time of incubation. The term Cot is conveniently defined as the product of nucleic acid concentration (C,) and the time ( t ) of incubation. The Cot value is calculated as the product of nucleic acid concentration in optical density units a t 260 nm (a 1 pg/ml solution of single-stranded DNA has an adsorbance of 0.024 a t 260 nm) divided by 2 and multiplied by the time of incubation expressed in hours. For example, 83 pg/ml of DNA corresponds to an optical density a t 260
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
89
nm of about 2.0, and will give a Cot of 1 when incubated for one hour [ (83) (0.024)/2 x 1 = 11. An example of a time course reassociation reaction for E. coli DNA is shown in Fig. 1. The reassociation follows second order kinetics and is indicative of a reaction in which all segments of the DNA are re-
0.0I
0. I
I.o
Cot
10
I00
FIQ.1. Time course reassociation of E. coli DNA. Labeled and unlabeled sheared, denatured E. coli DNA were incubated to various Cot values at 60°C in 0.12 M phosphate buffer and then passed through HA to determine the degree of reassociation.
annealing a t the same rate. This is true in bacterial DNA reactions because (with few exceptions) there is only one copy of each gene: Eucaryotic DNA preparations show biphasic to multiphasic reassociation curves because these organisms contain repetitious DNA, that is, “families” of related genes present as many copies per cell (Britten and Kohne, 1966). For the E. coli reaction the midpoint of reassociation
90
DON J. BRENNER AND BTANLEY FALKOW
or C0t/2 (that Cot value a t which 50% of a given DNA has reassociated) is between 5 and 6. This value will differ with ionic strength, DNA fragment size, and incubation temperature. A comparable reaction assayed spectrophotometrically will give a C,t/2 of about 9. This reflects that, early in the reaction, DNA molecules containing double-stranded regions (and therefore adsorbing to HA) express only about half of their total hypochromicity (Britten and Kohne, 1966). A further examination of the E. coli Cot curve indicates that reassociation is essentially complete a t a Cot of 100 and that little reassociation occurs before a Cot of 0.2 is reached. With this knowledge regarding the kinetics of reassociation one can design conditions so that unlabeled DNA is completely reassociated while the possibility of labeled DNA fragments reassociating with one another is virtually precluded. The standard conditions in our laboratory are as follows (Brenner et al., 1969b): 400 pg/ml of unlabeled DNA are incubated with 0.1 pg/ml of labeled DNA for 21 hr. The kinetics of reassociation are governed by the unlabeled DNA. The optical density of 400 pg a t 260 nm is 9.6. Then 9.6/2 times 21 yields a Cot of 100.8, enough to insure complete reassociation of unlabeled DNA and of labeled DNA complementary to the unlabeled DNA. The Cot for labeled DNA under these conditions is 0.025; small enough to rule out significant label-label reassociation. The ability to carry out reactions a t these concentrations depends upon having a sufficiently concentrated unlabeled preparation and a labeled preparation with a specific activity high enough to use a t about 0.1 pg/ml. When necessary one can alter these conditions and still obtain the desired Cot. For instance, if the specific activity of the labeled preparation is too low to use a t 0.1 pg/ml, the concentration of unlabeled DNA can be increased and the incubation period can be shortened. On the other hand, if the concentration of unlabeled DNA is too low the incubation period can be lengthened in order to obtain the desired Cot. IV. Interpretation of Reassociation Data
Reassociation experiments can be used to determine the extent of relatedness between organisms, the stability of related polynucleotide sequences, the genome size and to select for specific portions of the genome. A large body of data has accumulated that attempts to define relationships in bacteria and in certain specific regions of the bacterial genome by studying heteroduplex DNA molecules. There has been a good deal of confusion in interpreting heteroduplex reassociation data. One reason
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
91
for this is lack of specificity in some early studies. By specific binding we mean binding in excess of that obtained in negative control reactions. Lack of specificity becomes a problem when one incubates a t temperatures much below 3OoC under the T, (temperature a t which 50% of a given DNA is denatured) (McCarthy, 1967; Johnson and Ordal, 1968). Furthermore, there has been a tendency to equate the degree of reassociation of DNA fragments from one species with DNA from another species ( = DNA binding) with the degree of homology between these organisms. I n other words it was assumed that percentage DNA binding meant the existence of identical stretches of nucleotide sequence between the organisms in question. It will be seen below that this is certainly not the case among most members of the Enterobacteriaceae. Moreover, it is often meaningless to assign a numerical value to relatedness among organisms as this value will change depending upon the experimental criteria. These latter points are illustrated by reactions involving labeled E. coli DNA and unlabeled DNA from Salmonella typhimurium and Shigella flexneri. These organisms were first tested for similarity by allowing a mixture of DNAs, one of which was uniformly substituted with a “heavy’) isotope such as 15N, to reassociate. After treatment with E . coli phosphodiesterase to remove unrenatured DNA, the presence of reassociated duplexes composed of one “heavy” strand and one “light” strand was determined in CsCl density gradients. I n this system, hybrids were detected between S. flexneri and E. coli, but not between S. typhimurium and E. coli (Schildkraut et al., 1961). These conditions only detect very closely related duplexes. hlore recent studies have detected between 70 and 9% binding between E. coli and S. typhimurium, and 80 to 85% binding between E. coli and S. flexneri (Bolton and McCarthy, 1962; Brenner et al., 1967, 1969b; Brenner and Cowie, 1968). What then can be implied from a DNA reassociation experiment and what is the “correct” degree of relationship between these organisms? These results are not as disappointing and irreproducible as they may appear. It turns out that each of these values is “correct” for the criterion employed; it is simply that the percentage of DNA fragments bound in any experiment does not by itself yield enough information concerning the amount of paired bases present in the reassociated nucleotide sequences. As mentioned previously, most laboratories choose to vary the stringency of reassociation conditions by varying the incubation temperature. The effect of incubation temperature on binding of labeled E . coli DNA fragments to DNA from representative enterobacterial species is shown in Table 1. The amount of E . coli DNA bound to an Alkalescens-Dispar
92
DON J. BRENNER AND STANLEY FALROW
TABLE 1 Effect of Incubation Temperature on DNA Duplex Formation* Relative binding Reaction
50°C
60°C
66°C
75°C
E. colit/E. coli E . coZit/Alkalescens-Dispar strain 08 E . colit/Shigella boydii etousa E . colit/Salmonella typhimurium E. colit/Enterobac!er hafniae
100 97
100 95 89 45 21
100
100 93 85 11 4
-
-
87 28 11
* The reactions shown were incubated at the indicated temperature in 0.14 M phosphate buffer and assayed on HA (Brenner and Fanning, unpublished data). t Indicates labeled DNA. strain and to a strain of S. flexneri is minimally affected by increasing the incubation temperature. These results are typical of reactions between closely related organisms. Increasing the incubation temperature results in a marked decrease in the amount of E. coli DNA that binds to DNA from Enterobacter and S. typhimurium. This result is typical of organisms that show 50% or less reaction with E . coli. An investigation into the thermal stability of interspecies DNA duplexes revealed that at a higher incubation temperature, decreased binding is accompanied by a significant increase in thermal stability. Thermal elution profiles illustrating this point are shown in Fig. 2. The reactions shown are representative of thermal stability profiles obtained from homologous E. coli reactions, and interspecies reactions involving organisms that are closely and distantly related to E. coli. The thermal elution profiles obtained from a homologous E. coli reaction a t both 60 and 75OC exhibit a normal distribution pattern and an elution midpoint at about 90°C. The heteroduplexes formed between E . coli and a closely related Shigella dysenteriae strain are somewhat less stable than the homologous duplexes at 6OoC, but retain an essentially normal distribution. At 75OC the E . coli-S. dysenteriae duplexes exhibit a slightly higher thermal stability. The 6OoC reaction product of E . coli and Bethesda 1A DNAs is obviously significantly less stable than the other reactions and has a very disperse elution profile. At 75OC, less than 10% of E . coli DNA can reassociate with DNA from Bethesda 1A (as compared to 45% at 6OOC). Those duplexes that do form a t the higher temperature, although still significantly less stable than homologous duplexes, show markedly increased stability and tend towards a normal distribution.
93
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE: MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
-
-20 C 3
0
E.coli/ Betherda I A
U
7 E
a 0 m
10
36
0 60
70
a0 Temperature, "C
90
100
!,?q 0.4M
PB
FIQ.2. Thermal elution profiles of enterobacterial DNA duplexes. Labeled E . coli DNA was incubated with unlabeled DNA from E. coli, S. dysenteriae, and Bethesda strain 1A. Incubations were carried out in 0.14 M phosphate buffer and held a t the temperature employed for incubation. Reassociated duplexes were eluted from HA in a series of elutions with 0.14 M phosphate buffer at increasing 2.5"C temperature increments to 100°C. The HA was then washed with 0.4 M phosphate buffer to insure that all DNA has been eluted. Part A = 60°C incubation. Part B = 75°C incubation.
94
DON J. BRENNER AND STANLEY FALKOW
Increased stability of duplexes formed a t 75OC, coupled with decreased reassociation, is due to a population of fragments that can form stable reassociation products a t 60°C, but which are not stable a t the more stringent 75OC criterion. The diminished thermal stability observed especially in 6OoC reactions may be due to unpaired bases within the duplexes. Diminished stability might also be due to .preferential relatedness among the adenine- thymine-rich sequences in enterobacteria, since adenine thymine base pairs are less stable than guanine cytosine base pairs. Experiments using E. coli and S. typhimurium DNA (Brenner and Cowie, 1968) showed that at least half of the instability of this interspecies duplex was due to unpaired bases. Unpublished experiments in this laboratory could not demonstrate preferential binding of adenine- thymine-rich E . coli DNA fractions to DNA from S. typhimurium, Enterobacter aerogenes, or S. flexneri. It is assumed, therefore, that all instability observed in interspecies enterobacterial DNA duplexes is due to the presence of unpaired bases. If decreased thermal stability is, in fact, due to unpaired bases within reassociated nucleotide strands, one would like to correlate T m ( e()= temperature at which 50% of reassociated DNA has eluted from HA) and percentage unpaired bases. Bautz and Bautz (1964) , using thermal stability of synthetic copolymers containing varying amounts of noncomplementary bases, and Laird et al. (1969) , using DNA treated with nitrous acid to deaminate bases and alter their pairing with previously complementary bases, have attacked this problem. Their data indicate that an approximate l.O°C decrease in thermal stability results from 1% unpaired bases within a DNA duplex. With this relationship between percent unpaired bases and AT^^^, , as well as quantitative reassociation data a t different criteria, an attempt can be made to categorize enterobacterial relationships from the standpoint of divergence. If it is assumed that the enterobacteria evolved from a common ancestor one can determine how much DNA has diverged to a point where it is no longer related to E. coli DNA a t the criteria employed. Furthermore, one can approximate the degree of divergence present in DNA held in common between two enterobacteria. It must again be emphasized that both percentage binding and thermal stability are dependent upon the conditions chosen for reassociation. There is, therefore, no one number to describe relatedness between two organisms. If DNA from two organisms does not reassociate these organisms are not now related. On the other hand, two organisms showing almost complete relatedness will give only minimally different values at different reassociation criteria. Since there are no formal guidelines available with which to correlate genetic and molecular information to taxonomic group-
+
+
+
+
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE: MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
95
ings, any attempt to equate the extent and stability of interspecies duplexes with lines of speciation would be somewhat premature and certainly arbitrary. A rule of thumb used in our laboratory is to employ less stringent, but specific, reaction conditions to detect overall relatedness between species. Highly related or specific interspecies DNA duplexes should be studied under stringent reaction conditions. For the Enterobacteriaceae we test for overall relatedness in 0.14 M phosphate buffer a t 6OoC, which is close to optimal for reassociation of enterobacterial DNA. Our stringent criterion for reassociation is 75OC in 0.14 M phosphate buffer. V. Taxonomy and Nomenclature
A detailed discussion of taxonomy and nomenclature of enterobacteria is, of course, beyond the scope of this report. A few comments, however, will serve to clarify both the nomenclature used here and the established taxonomic relationships among enterobacteria. For in-depth treatment of these topics the reader is referred to “Identification of Enterobacteriaceae” (Edwards and Ewing, 1966) and to the International Bulletin of Taxonomy and Nomenclature. On the basis of biochemical and serological reactions the enterobacteria are usually divided into four groups: 1. The Escherichia-Shigella group includes the genus Shigella and all strains of E. coli. Escherichia coli is the only species currently recognized, although the Alkalescens-Dispar group are usually included as strains of E. coli. 2. The Salmonella-Arizona-Citrobacter group includes the vast number of Salmonella species and serotypes and the closely related Arizona organisms. Also included is the genus Edwardsiella and the Citrobacter group (Citrobacter is the name currently used for strains formerly known as Escherichia freundii). The Bethesda organisms are identical to Citrobacter species except that they ferment lactose slowly. These organisms are usually included as members of Citrobacter. 3. The Klebsiella-Aerobacter-Serratia group. Klebsiella and Aerobacter species have very similar biochemical capabilities. The genus Enterobacter is often used to include organisms formally contained in the genera Aerobacter and Hafnia. The genuls Serratia and the phytopathogenic Erwinia are also included in this group. 4. The Proteus-Providence group includes the diverse species of Proteus and Providence strains (formerly called Proteus inconstans). A simplistic scheme depicting biochemical relationships among enterobacteria is presented in Table 2.
96
DON J. BRENNER AND GTANLEY FALKOW
TABLE 2 The Principal Taxonomic Groups of Enterobacteriaceae* Serrafia
\
Kle bsiella
"\
\/
Bethesda Cifrobacter
Enferobacfer
\ .
Escherichia coli
/
Shiiella
Proreus Providence
* This schematic representation is adapted from Edwards and Ewing (1966). It attempts to portray relationshipsof the main groups of enteric bacteria to E . coli, based, in the main, on biochemical data.
In general we have retained the names of cultures as we have received them; both for historical reasons and to test the new names and groupings from the point of view of nucleic acid relatedness. Therefore, we distinguish, for example, between Bethesda and Citrobacter and between Escherichia and Alkalescens-Dispar.
VI. Nucleic Acid Relationships among Enterobacteria
The first attempt at establishing genetic relationships among enterobacteria using nucleic acid reassociation was carried out by Marmur and his colleagues (Schildkraut et al., 1961). They were successful in showing heteroduplex formation between E. coli and S. flexneri, but were unable to demonstrate duplex formation between DNA from E . coli and S. typhirnurium, Erwinia caratovora, or E . freundii. Their
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
97
method of reassociating density labeled and unlabeled DNA and looking for hybrid bands in CsCl detected only essentially identical duplexes. Using DNA-agar, McCarthy and Bolton ( 1963) surveyed heterologous reactions in about a dozen enterobacteria and a few representatives of other bacterial families. Their experiments showed that reproducible results were obtainable using both DNA-DNA and DNA-RNA reassociation. The incubations were apparently carried out a t conditions optimal for reassociation and they obtained a range of different degrees of relatedness among enterobacteria. Subsequent studies have f ailed to confirm several of their quantitative results ; however, the qualitative relationships they obtained remain valid. These investigators realized the application of nucleic acid reassociation experiments in determining evolutionary relationships between organisms. The more recent studies on enterobacterial relatedness utilize either the nitrocellulose filter technique with labeled RNA or free-solution reactions assayed on HA (Brenner and Cowie, 1968; Brenner et al., 1969b; Brenner e t al., 1971 ; Brenner and Fanning, unpublished observations). Thus far most studies utilized E. coli strains as reference organisms. It is necessary to carry out reciprocal reactions using labeled DNA from other groups of enterobacteria and also to examine relationships among members of various enterobacterial genera and groups. Implicit in all bacterial relationship studies is that the genomes of the organisms under test have similar molecular weights. This assumption appears to be generally true, as reciprocal reactions in several groups of bacteria yield comparable binding percentages (reciprocal binding percentages are only obtained when the genome sizes are essentially equal) , however, careful determinations of reciprocal binding percentages (Brenner et al., 1971) indicate that E. coli strain BB is some 6% larger than E . coli K12. A similar finding was obtained (Gillis et al., 1970) by measuring genome size in these organisms using reassociation kinetics. These investigators find that most enterobacteria tested have a genome size within &lo% that of E . coli K12; however, certain species tested have as much as genomes 40% larger than E. coli. These data must be kept in mind when interpreting relatedness. A. DIVERGENCE AMONG DIFFERENT STRAINS OF E. coli
It was assumed that various E. coli strains differed largely by singlebase changes and that reassociation techniques would not differentiate a t the strain level. This assumption has recently been tested (Brenner et al., 1971) and it is incorrect. Reactions representative of some 30 strains of E . coli tested are shown in Table 3. Escherichia coli strain
98
DON J. BRENNER AND STANLEY FALKOW
K12 is the source of labeled DNA fragments in the reactions shown; however, comparable results are obtained when E . coli BB or E. coli 02A are employed as reference strains. Strains C600, 1485 T-,and W3110 are all derivatives of strain K12 and show virtually complete reassociation with K12 at the optimal 6OoC incubation temperature. The near identity of these strains is also evident from the minimal decrease in duplex stability (AT,,,, values are only 0.1 to 0.3OC below that of the homologous reaction). The B strains tested with K12 behave identically, exhibiting about 94% reassociation at 6OoC and 90% reaction a t 75OC. These reaction products are only slightly less stable than the homologous K12 reaction product. The remainder of the reactions shown is indicative of results obtained with some two dozen strains of diverse clinical origin. Certain of these strains (strain 128, for example) are almost identical with K12 a t either incubation criterion. I n several strains binding to K12 DNA a t 6OoC is less than 90% (190, 04) and the decrease in stability is 3OC or greater (025, 07, 04, 01A). At the higher 75OC criterion, as much as 20% of the DNA of these strains does not form stable duplexes with K12 DNA. It is also evident that the thermal stability of these reactions increases at the higher incubation temperature. Relatedness among E . coli strains may be summarized as follows: (1) at optimal reassociation conditions as much as 10-15% of the DNA of some strains has diverged to a point where it no longer reacts with DNA from K12; (2) reaction products from optimal 6OoC incubations contain as much as 4% unpaired bases (l.O°C drop in thermal stability per 1.0% unpaired bases; Laird et al., 1969) ; (3) a t incubation conditions designed to preclude formation of all but highly complementary polynucleotide sequences, up to 20% of the DNA in many E. coli strains is unable to form duplexes with K12 DNA. Those duplexes that form still exhibit as much as 3% divergence; (4) the thermal binding index (TBI; last column, Table 3) is the ratio of relative reassociation a t 75 and 6OoC (Brenner et al., 1969b). The TBI is useful in detecting the presence or absence of highly related genetic material in heterologous reassociation reactions. A low TBI indicates that most of the duplexes formed at optimal conditions are not stable, and therefore not highly complementary a t stringent reassociations. The high TBI values observed in reactions between strains of E . coli indicate that most of the polynucleotide sequences contain only minimal amounts of unpaired bases. In terms of polynucleotide sequence relatedness, it appears that the species E. coli may be described as a group of strains whose DNAs are at least 85% related. The related sequences in these strains have diverged up to about 4%.
99
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
TABLE 3 Divergence among Strains of E. coli
Reaction K 12$/K12-1 K12$/C600 K12$/1485T K12$/W3110(21) K12$/B K12 $/B/r Kl2$/BB K12#/128 K12$/0128A K12$/190 K12 $/025 K12$/07 K12#/04 K12$/01A
Relative Relative percent percent binding AT,+)* binding AT,,.) at 60°C a t 60°C a t 75°C a t 75°C 100 98 99 97 94 94 92 98 97 87 92 91 85 94
0.1 0.3 0.1 0.8 0.8 0.7 0.4 1.o 2.5 3.0 3.6 3.1 3.2
100 96 100 96 88 90 89 98 94 82 88 82 78 80
0.3 0.3 0.1 1.0 1.1 0.6 0.4
0.5 2.0 2.2 2.6 2.0 2.8
TBIt
0.98 1.o 0.99 0.94 0.96 0.97 1.o 0.97 0.94 0.95 0.90 0.92 0.85
* AT,,,(,) is the decrease in !l'+ between ) heterologous reactions and the homologous K12-1 reaction. t TBI = relative binding a t 75°C divided by relative binding at 60°C. 3 = Source of labeled DNA fragments. B. RELATEDNESS BETWEEN E. coli K12 STRAINS OF THE ALKALESCENS-DISPAR GROUPAND Shigella SPECIES Data obtained from K12-Alkalescens-Dispar group and K12-Shigella spp. reassociation reactions are presented in Table 4 and Table 5. Under. optimal reassociation conditions, DNA from members of the Alkalescens-Dispar group is 88-95% related to E. coli K12 DNA. The relative stabilities of these reaction products indicates divergence of 1 to 2.5% in the E . coli-Alkalescens-Dispar heteroduplexes. With the possible exception of AD-03, there is little decrease in binding a t more stringent incubation conditions. On the basis of these data Alkalescens-Dispar strains are as closely related to E. coli K12 as most E. coli strains. These group relationships, at 6OoC, are shown in Fig. 3. It is clear from the data and this diagrammatic representation that the Alkalescens-Dispar group is virtually indistinguishable from E. coli strains and probably should be included as members of the species E. coli as suggested by Ewing on the basis of serologic and biochemical data (Edwards and Ewing, 1966).
100
DON J. BRENNER AND STANLEY FALKOW
TABLE 4 DNA Reassociation Reactions between E. coli K12 and Members of the Alkalescens-Dispar Group
Reaction
Relative Relative percent percent binding ATm(e) binding ATm(i) at 60°C a t 60°C at 75°C at 75°C
K12*/AD-O1 K12*/AD-02 K12*/AD-03 K12*/AD-03 (Ceylonensis) K12*/AD-04 K12 */AD-05 K 12* /AD-06 K12 */AD-07 K12*/AD-08
*
89 91 88
0.9
90 93 95 88 90 94
1.8 0.5 1.5
-
2.2
-
0.5
82 86 78
1.2
88 94 89 84 89 92
1.2 0.6 1.3
-
1.7
-
0.5
TBI 0.92 0.95 0.89 0.98 1.0 0.94 0.95 0.99 0.98
= Source of labeled DNA fragments.
Those Shigellae tested form a close group with respect to relatedness to E. coli. Under optimal conditions 8049% reaction is obtained with Tmc,,values indicating 1 to 2% divergence. From 71 to 85% of E . coli DNA forms highly stable heteroduplexes with Shigella DNAs at stringent conditions. The range of binding percentages obtained is TABLE 5 DNA Reassociation Reactions between E. coli K12 and Shigellu spp.
Reaction K12*/Shigellu sonnei (a) K12*/S. sonnei (b) K12*/S. sonnei (c) K12*/8. jZexneri (Newcastle) K12*/S. jZexneri K12*/S. boydii K12*/S. boydii (etousu) K12*/S. dysenteriue I K12*/S. dysenteriue I1 K12*/S. dysentwiue I11
*
Relative Relative percent percent binding ATm(e) binding AT,(#) at 60°C at 60°C at 75°C at 75°C 87 84 87 85 84 80 89 82 89 80
= Source of labeled DNA fragments.
0.7 0.9 0.5
1.o
1.0
-
1.3 1.3
1.7
-
85 83 79 83 79 71 85 78 85 76
0.8 0.7 0.7
1.o
0.8
-
1.0 0.9 0.5
-
TBI 0.98 0.99 0.91 0.98 0.94 0.88 0.96 0.95 0.98 0.95
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE
: MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
101
slightly lower than that obtained in reactions involving E. coli strains or members of the Alkalescens-Dispar group. These data support the bulk of taxonomic observations which assign Shigella and E. coli to different genera, while acknowledging that these organisms are highly related.
C. RELATIVERELATEDNESS BETWEEN E . coli OTHERENTEROBACTERIA
AND
Except for other E. coli strains, the Alkalescens-Dispar group, and members of the genus Shigella, all enterobacteria tested exhibit 50% or less reaction with E. coli DNA. Under optimal conditions we have not observed any organism reacting with E. coli in the range 50-80%. At the stringent 75OC criterion for reassociation, no evidence of relatedness between 20 and 70% has been observed. All of the organisms to be discussed (the few exceptions are noted), form extremely unstable products at 6OOC. At 75OC the degree of relative reassociation is markedly decreased with a concomitant increase in thermal stability of those polynucleotide sequences that are able to form duplexes. TBI values for these reactions rarely exceed 0.25, in contrast to E . coli-Alkalescens-Dispar and E. coli-Shigella reactions, where the TBI is rarely below 0.9. Representative reactions are shown in Table 6 and the range of reactions for each group is given in Fig. 3. Citrobacter strains show about 50% relatedness to E. coli. The related sequences have diverged some 12-13% (heteroduplexes contain between 12-13% unpaired bases a t 6OOC). When only highly complementary sequences are allowed to reassociate, one sees about 12% relatedness and these heteroduplexes still contain 5-6% unpaired bases. Citrobacter strain 3796, which behaves similarly to the other Citrobacter strains at 60°C, a t 75OC exhibits almost twice the relatedness t o E . coli as do other Citrobacter strains. It will be of interest to isolate these sequences and determine their relatedness to E. coli and to other Citrobacter strains. Reassociation a t 6OoC of DNAs from Bethesda strains and E. coli is usually between 42 and 50%; somewhat less than that seen with Citrobacter strains. The related sequences appear t o have diverged by about 13-1676. Under stringent reassociation conditions 7-10% reaction occurs and divergence appears to be about 6-796. These reactions again appear to be slightly lower than those obtained with Citrobacter strains. The question of whether Bethesda and Citrobacter strains fall into the same group, with respect to nucleic acid similarity, remains open. These organisms must be investigated in detail. Bethesda strain 5A appears
102
DON J. BRENNER AND STANLEY FALKOW
5 t
1
C ITROBACTER
5 60W
LL
r 5 W
tY
40-
ENTEROBACTE NI I
20P.MIRABILIS
AEROBACTER ENTEROBACT~ STRAINS
FIO.3. Polynucleotide sequence relatedness among enterobacteria. This figure presents a diagrammatic representation of nucleotide sequence relatedness of enterobacteria to E . coli K12. Each box represents the range of binding percentages and AT,,,(.) values obtained from DNA reassociation reactions between a group of enteric bacteria and E . coli K12.The width of the box is the range of relative binding percentages and the length of the box is the range in AT,,,(,,) values.
to be an exception in that it exhibits only 22% reaction with E . coli a t 6OoC and only 3% reaction a t 75OC. The stability of reacted E . coli-Bethesda 5A duplexes is only slightly less than those formed between E. coli and other Bethesda strains. Only two Salmonella species have been tested. These DNAs show 45% relatedness to E. coli DNA at 6OoC and the duplexes contain about 20% unpaired bases. At 75OC 6 to 11% reassociation is observed. Salmonella species and members of the Arizona group must be examined in detail, both for relatedness to E. coli and for intrageneric relationships. Enterobacter-Klebsiella species comprise three classes based on their reactions with E . coli. At optimal conditions, an aberrent strain of Enterobacter cloacae is 48% related to E . coli. Two other E . cloacae strains and two E . aerogenes strains, as well as six strains of four Klebsiella species, show between 35 and 40% reaction with E . coli. A third class within the Enterobacter-Klebsiella group contains E . liquifaciens and E. hafniae which show 15-21% reaction with E . coli. Reassociated heteroduplexes from all 3 classes show 12-17% divergence. At 75OC binding drops significantly, as does the percentage of unpaired bases in the heteroduplexes. As is the case with other groups, these data do not answer
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE
:
103
MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
TABLE 6 Relative Relatedness between E. coli and Distantly Related Enterobacteria
Reaction
RelaPertive centage percent diverbinding gence at at 60°C 60°C
Relative percent binding
at
75°C
Kl2lCitrobacter 3796 Kl2/Citrobacter P11-C Kl2/Citrobacter “Zurich”
54 50 48
12 13 13
21 11 12
Kl2/Bethesda K12/Bethesda K12/Bethesda K12/Bethesda
8A 1A 2A 5A
50 44 42 22
13 14 15
10 7
Kl2/Salmonella typhi 643 Kl2/Salmmella typhimurium LT2
44 45
Kl2/Enterobacter cloacae Kl2lEnterobacter cloacae(aberrant) K12/Enterobacler aerogenes K 12/ Klebsiella ozaenae Kl2/Klebsiella pneumoniae I1 Kl2/Enterobacter aluei K12/Enterobacter hafniae
Percentage divergence at 75’C*
TBI
5 6 6
0.39 0.22 0.25
-
7
3
6 7
0.20 0.16 0.17 0.12
15 12
6 11
6 3
0.14 0.24
35 48 37 38 38 17 21
13 13 14 14 14 15 16
5 11 5
5 6
8 7 4 4
4 5 -
-
0.15 0.23 0.14 0.21 0.18 0.24 0.18
K12/Serratia marcescens K 12/Serratia kiliensis
24 24
14 13
3
5 5
0.11 0.18
Kl2/Proteus mirabilis Kl2lPrdteus morganii
7 17
17 17
1.5 2.5
-
0.23 0.15
K12IErwinia amyliwora K 12lErwinia caratiwora Kl2lErwinia dissoluens
30 19 35
14 15 13
6 6 8
4 2 6
0.21 0.29 0.23
4
-
* Percentage divergence is calculated by multiplying the ATm(e)by the percentage of unpaired bases (1.0%) thought to cause a 1°C drop in thermal stability (Laird el al., 1969). questions pertaining to the relationship between these three classes of organisms. All of these groups must be tested for intrageneric relatedness. It is especially interesting to determine the relatedness between E . aerogenes and K . pneuinoniae strains. Two strains of Serratia marcescens and a Serratia kiliensis strain were identical in reactions with E . coli, with 24% binding a t 6OoC and 3 4 % binding a t 75OC.
104
DON J. BRENNER AND STANLEY FALKOW
The genus Erwinia, containing plant pathogens, is significantly related to E. coli. The strains thus far examined (Brenner and Fanning, unpublished) show 15-20% and 30-3576 reaction a t 6OOC. At 75OC the reactions fall to 6-876. The thermal stability of these reactions is comparable to that seen with other groups. It is interesting to note that the two extents of relatedness to E. coli seen in Erwinia spp. do not follow the classification of these organisms into the so-called true Erwinia spp. and the soft-rot-causing Erwinia species. Neither does there appear to be EL correlation between the relatedness of these organisms to E . coli and the closeness of their guanine+ cytosine contents to that of E . coli. Both of these implications need confirmation, and, of course, these organisms must be tested for intrageneric relatedness. King and Adler (1964) reported a previously undescribed group of Enterobacteriaceae which they named the Bartholomew group. Sakazaki (1965) and Ewing and collegues (Ewing et al., 1965) had collected and studied similar cultures dating from 1959. Sakazaki called these organisms the Asakusa group. Ewing assigned them to the new genus, Edwardsiella, and suggested the species name, Edwardsiella tarda. We obtained some 20 cultures of E. tarda from W. J. Martin, including isolations from human infections and from reptiles. These strains originated in the United States, Ecuador, Japan, Canada, Israel, and the Congo. We have preliminary data as to their relatedness with E. coli under optimal reassociation conditions. Most strains show about 2Q% reaction with E . coli DNA. The reaction products, in most cases, have AT,(,, values of between 12 and 14OC. The highest binding observed was about 30% with a AT,^^, of only 7.5OC. These results must be confirmed and extended. Proteus species showed the least relatedness to E. coli. Proteus mirabilis DNA binds about 7% and Proteus morganii DNA binds about 17% to E. coli DNA a t 6OOC. At 75OC these reactions fall to 1.5 and 2.5% respectively. Reacted DNA from both of these organisms contains about 18% unpaired bases a t 60OC. The twofold difference in reactivity of P. morganii and P. mirabilis is probably attributable to the fact that P. mirabilis DNA contains only about 38% guanine cytosine, while P . morganii DNA contains 50% guanine cytosine, as does E. coli DNA. Intrageneric studies have been carried out in the genus Proteus. The data obtained indicate that the protei are a diverse group. P. mirabilis and P. vulgaris are highly related (90%), however, P . mirabilis shares only about 15% nucleotide sequences with P. inconstans and about 5% with Proteus rettgeri. Proteus mirabilis-labeled DNA incubated a t 60°C shows between 4 and 7% reaction with E. coli, S . typhimurium, Salmonella typhi, and E . aerogenes. At 75OC these reactions are all 1%or lower.
+
+
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
105
VII. Divergence in Specific Portions of the Genome
The degree of nucleic acid binding is a measure of overall relatedness between organisms; however, reactions involving unfractionated nucleic acids give no information as to the relative rates of divergence in specific portions of the genome. One may ask questions such as: (1) Are the genes involved in transcription and translation preferentially conserved in order to maintain universality of the genetic code? (2) Are essential metabolic enzyme systems conserved to a greater degree than enzymes concerned, for example, with fermentation of a carbohydrate not essential for cell growth? (3) Are rates of divergence different from enzymes that are normally constituitive as opposed to inducible enzymes? (4) Does the physical position of the gene on the chromosome have an effect on divergence? Answers to these and other questions concerning divergence in specific genetic or physical regions of the chromosome have been slow in coming because only a handful of genes have been prepared in pure form. Thus far only the genes that specify rRNA, tRNA, and the lactose operon have been tested for divergence in the enterobacteria. OF E. COli-SPECIFIC DNA IN THE GENOMES A. DETECTION OF HETEROLOGOUS ORGANISMS
One approach to isolating specific genetic regions, particularly with respect to their physical location on the chromosome, is t o detect and isolate a group of E . coli genes in the genome of a heterologous organism. This type of experiment has been carried out using S. typhi-E. coli hybrids and P . inirabilis strains with diploid regions that contain E . coli DNA. I n one series of experiments, labeled E . coli DNA fragments were allowed to reassociate at 60 and 75OC with unlabeled DNA fragments from E . coli, S. typhi, and three S . typhi-E. coli hybrid strains: S. typhi 643 lac3, which had substituted 7-13% of the E. coli chromosome for its own, and S. typhi 643 X30T and S. typhi 643 X30W, which had substituted 20-28% and 39-44%, respectively, of the E. coli chromosome (Brenner et al., 1969b). The reaction mixtures were passed through HA and the bound DNA was thermally eluted. The thermal elution profile obtained after reassociation of E. coli DNA fragments a t 6OoC tends toward a Gaussian distribution with a T m ( e ) close to 90°C. In contrast, a profile obtained from an E . coli-S. typhi reaction at 6OoC is very broad and has a Tm(e,some 13OC below that of the E. coli reaction, The presence of increasing amounts of E . coli-
106
DON J. BRENNER AND STANLEY FALKOW
TABLE 7 DNA Duplex Formation between E . coli, S. typhi, and P. mirabilis Strains
Reaction
AT,(,) at 60°C
E . eoli/E. coli E . coli/S. typhi 643 1. coli/S. t y p h i 643 lacs 1. coli/S. typhi 643 X30T E. coli/S. typhi 643 X30W E . coli/P. mirabilie E . coli/P. mirabilis F-lact
12.5 11.5 7.5 4.5 14.0 7.5
-
Relative percent binding AT,,,(#) at 60°C at 75°C 100 43 52 59 58 6 8
-
Relative percent binding at 75°C
4.5 3.5 0.5 0.0
100 9 16 32 38
0.5
3
-*
1
TBI
0.21 0.31 0.54 0.66 0.17 0.38
* Too little reassociation to allow accurate assay. specific DNA in S. typhi strains lac3, X30T, and X30W is evident from the increased relative binding percentages and the increased Tmc,)(Table 7 ) . Thermal elution profiles from E. coli-8. typhi hybrid reactions at 6OoC are biphasic in nature, with the appearance of a thermally stable E. coli-like peak (Fig. 4A). Elution profiles obtained from all interspecies reactions at 75OC show increased thermal stability (Table 7 ) . These increases are due to the loss of reassociated sequences which are stable a t 6OoC, but could not withstand the more stringent incubation temperature. The loss of these sequences results in sharper, more stable elution profiles as seen in Fig. 4B. The results obtained with 8. typhi-E. coli hybrid strains are summarized in Table 8. The data indicate that the degree of reassociation a t 75OC may be used to obtain a reasonable estimate as to the degree of specific E . coli genetic substitution in these strains, and to isolate this material. Approximately 9% relative reassociation occurs between DNA from E . coli and S. typhi at 75OC. This “background” problem was largely avoided by using a strain of P. mirabilis that carries the extrachromosoma1 element F-lac‘. The F-lac+ element is equivalent to about 2.5% of the E. coli genome and is present as an addition to the Proteus genetic material. The presence of F-lac+ does indeed increase the relative reassociation of E. coli DNA and P. mirabilis DNA by about 2% and concurrently significantly increases the thermal stability of this reaction product (Table 7 ) . The increased amounts of E. coli material in P . mirabilis F-lac+ and in the E . coli-S. typhi hybrids is readily apparent from the increased TBI values (Table 7).
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
107
E.col i - " X 3 0 T " 60%
Temperature , O C
,,I E.col i --
E.coli-"X3P W " 75% --
-'I
X 3 0 T...... " 75'c
........
Temperature , O C
FIG.4. Detection of E . coli-specific DNA in the genome of S. typhi genetic hybrids. "P-Labeled E . coli DNA fragments were incubated with unlabeled DNA from the indicated organisms. The reaction mixtures were passed through HA and bound material was eluted in a series of washes with 0.14 M phosphate buffer at increasing 2.5"C temperature increments. Part A = profiles obtained from 60°C reactions. Part B = profiles obtained from 75°C reactions.
108
DON J. BRENNER AND STANLEY FALKOW
TABLE 8 Detection of E. coli-Specific DNA in the Genomes of S. typhi Hybrid Strains
Source of unlabeled DNA
S. typhi 643 8.typhi 643 lacJ S. typhi 643 X30T
S. typhi 643 X30W
Estimated E . coli genetic substitution* 0 7-13 20-28 39-44
Relative binding of E . coli DNA 60°C 43 52 59 58
f4 f2 f1 f5
75°C 9 16 32 38
f 3
f1 f3 f2
Estimated E. coli DNA substitution t 0 7 25 33
* All data expressed in percentages. The estimate of the degree of E. coli substitution was calculated on the basis of E. coli characters stably present in E. coli X S. typhi hybrids assuming uniform substitution of E . coli material into the genome of 8. typhi. It was assumed that the chromosomes of E. coli K12 and S. typhi 643 are both 2.5 X 100 daltons. The genetic analysis of these hybrids is presented in detail by Falkow et al. (1962). t The estimate of the degree of E . coli-specific nucleic acid substitution into the S. typhi chromosome was calculated by subtracting the “background” reaction between E . coli and S. typhi at 75°C from the percentage of E. coli DNA bound by the S. typhi hybrid strains at this temperature. It was also assumed that the “background” binding is distributed at random along the S. typhi chromosome and tha t the genetic substitution replaces a proportional amount of this “background” reaction. E. coli/ E . coli reactions a t 60°C and 75°C were arbitrarily designated 100%; all binding percentages are relative to these homologous reactions. This type of experiment is sensitive enough to detect a few percent of specific DNA in the genome of a heterologous organism, especially when the reaction between the parental organisms is minimal, as is the case with E. coli and P. mirabilis. With the proper selection of material from small, well-defined regions around the genetic map, divergence of genetic material from the standpoint of physical location can be assayed. B. DIVERGENCE OF THE LACTOSE OPERONAMONG ENTEROBACTERIA Messenger RNA highly enriched for lactose operons was obtained by pulse-labeling RNA in E. coli under conditions where p-galactosidase was preferentially synthesized (Brenner et al., 1969b). A portion of the pulse-labeled RNA was incubated with filter-immobilized DNA from several enterobacteria for measurement of the overall relative binding of the RNA preparation. Another portion of the RNA preparation was repeatedly reacted with the DNA of an E. coli strain with a genetic deletion that included the entire lactose operon. The RNA that remained
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
109
after reaction with the deletion strain (about 3% of the original radioactivity) is presumed to be relatively enriched for lactose operon messenger RNA. This lactose messenger RNA was tested for its binding to heterologous DNA species. With most enterobacteria, the percentage relative binding with lactose messenger RNA was lower than the binding of bulk messenger RNA (Table 9 ) . With S. flezneri DNA, the binding TABLE 9 Binding of Pulse-Labeled E . coli Lactose Messenger RNA to Enterobacterial DNA Bulk messenger RNA RNaseresistant cpm bound
Source of unlabeled DNA on filter
E. coli K12 lac+ E. coli K12 lac A P. mirabilis P. morganii A . aerogenes S. typhi S. typhimurium S. jlezneri S. marcescens
39,267* 39 , 156 1,149 2 464 7,945 8,599 8, 864 32,149 3,215 8 ,864 8,334 9,868 130
Bethesda 10 Salmonella sp. (Her.) ballerup Salmonella sp. (ser.) arizonae None ~
~
Lactose messenger RNA
Relative RNaseRelative percent resistant percent binding cpm bound binding 100 99 3 6 20 22 22 83 8 22 21 25 1
1,320 27 28 26 190 220 460 910 29 340 1 ,230 270 28
100 2 2 2 14 17 34 69 2 26 93 20 2
~~
*Hybridization reactions were carried out by the procedure of Gillespie and Spiegelman (1965). Many of these bulk reactions are lower than those reported for DNA-DNA reactions. The reason is that these experiments were carried out at 66"C1 a more stringent incubation temperature than the 60°C employed in the DNA-DNA reactions.
decreased by 13%. A decrease was expected, since it has been reported that the y region of the lactose operon is deleted in strains of Shigella species (Luria et al., 1960). No measurable reaction was obtained with DNA from P . mirabilis, P. morganii, or S. marcescens. An unexpected finding was that the reaction with the lactose messenger RNA fraction was about 70% higher with Salmonella sp. (ser) ballerup and about 10% higher with S. typhimurium than was the bulk messenger RNA reaction with DNA from these organisms. It must be emphasized that these are only preliminary data and that
110
DON J. BRENNER AND STANLEY FALKOW
the lactose operon was only part of the genetic deletion in the strain employed in these experiments. Portions of the genome adjacent to the lactose operon may account, therefore, for part of the observed reaction. The deletion, however, is not more than 2%. At any rate, it appears that, assuming a common ancestor, particular regions of the genome of enteric organisms have diverged a t quite different rates. Perhaps material obtained from isolation procedures such as that used by Beckwith and his colleagues to isolate the lactose operon (Shapiro et al., 1969) will facilitate the study of divergence of specific genes. OF RIBOSOMAL RNA GENES C. CONSERVATION
Several laboratories have investigated rRNA relatedness among members of thc Enterobacteriaceae. McCarthy (Moore and McCarthy, 1967) and ourselves (Brenner et al., 196913) used labeled 23 S rRNA and reacted it with filter-immobilized DNA according to the Gillespie and Spiegelman (1965) technique. Kohne (1968) isolated and purified rRNA cistrons from E. coli and P. mirabilis and used this DNA in reassociation reactions followed by binding assays and thermal elution profiles on HA. Canter (personal communication) is presently extending Kohne’s observations. All of these results are summarized in Table 10. TABLE 10 Reaction of 23s rRNA or rRNA Cistrons from E. coli with Unfractionated Enterobacterial DNA Relative percent binding Source of unlabeled, unfractionated DNA
E . coli P . mirabilia P . morganii P . rettgeri P . vulgaris S. marcescens A . cloacae A . aerogenes Paracolobactrum aerogenoidea S . typhi S . typhimurium S . flexneri
* Moore and McCarthy
t Kohne (1968).
(1967).
$ Brenner el al., (1969b). $ Canter, personal communication.
23 S rRNA 100 84*, 76% 44 *, 52 $ 79 *
105*
77*, 741 89 * 63*, 80$ 83 * 79 $
-
92 t
rRNA cistrons 100 93t, 938 -
-
93 8 95 8
-
97ti 978
-
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
111
It is immediately apparent that the rRNA genes are highly conserved throughout the Enterobacterih'ceae. It appears that the 23 S rRNA genes have diverged to a greater extent than bulk rRNA. Thermal stability profiles carried out by Kohne (1967) and by Canter (personal communication) show very little decrease in stability in heteroduplexes formed between E . coli rRNA cistrons and DNA from other enterobacteria. The maximum is about 4% in P . mirabilis. Conservation o f rRNA sequences is not surprising in view of the evidence of a universal genetic code. D. CONSERVATION OF TRANSFER RNA GENES Goodman and Rich (1962) first assessed divergence of tRNA genes in enterobacteria by assaying tRNA-DNA hybrids in CsCl gradients. Their data are summarized in Table 11. It is again evident that the tRNA cistrons are highly conserved throughout the enterobacteria tested. The method used by these investigators requires essentially complete complementarity in order to observe hybrid formation. It is possible that the values obtained are low. Recent experiments using isolated tRNA cistrons from E . coli (Brenner et al., 1970) show 85% relative reassociation between tRNA cistrons and P . mirabilis DNA. The stability of this reaction product is only 4OC less than that seen in an intraspecies E . coli tRNA cistron reaction. The results with rRNA, as well as with tRNA, need to be expanded. TABLE 11 Hybridization of tRNA with DNA from Enterobacteria*
Source of DNA
Approximate relative percent binding of tRNA
E . coli B E . coli K12 E . freundii S. marcescens P . morganii S . typhimurium A . aerogenes K . pneumoniae P . aerogenoides P . vulgaris
100 88 68 65 60 55 52 52 47 32
* Data are approximate values taken from Goodman and Rich
(1962).
112
DON J. BRENNER AND STANLEY FALKOW
It is, however, quite clear that the genes that specify both of these classes of molecules are highly conserved with respect to the genetic pool as a whole. VIII. Relationships between Extrachromosomal E1emen.h
Extrachromosomal elements carrying a variety of functions are transmissible among many species of enteric organisms (Falkow et al., 1967; Meynell et al., 1968; Novick, 1969). These genetic elements have the advantage that they ordinarily replicate independently of the host chromosome, are usually infectious, and are not essential to the host. They provide enteric species with a gene pool which may often give a marked selective advantage without the necessity of any permanent chromosomal change. The full extent of the pool of extrachromosomal elements found in enteric bacteria is still unknown, although it is clear that the incidence is increasing. We can make this unequivocal statement because it is clear that over the last decade a significant proportion of commensal and pathogenic enterobacteria have been shown to have acquired transmissible multiple drug resistance factors (R-factors) (Watanabe, 1963). The increased use (and misuse) of antibiotics in man and his domestic animals is likely responsible for this. One can appreciate the full impact of this increase by noting that prior to 1960, few Shigella strains isolated from dysentery patients in Japan harbored R-factors; at present about 85% of the strains isolated from patients harbor these elements (Mitsuhashi, 1969). Similarly E. S. Anderson (1968, 1969) reports from England that S. typhimurium isolates harboring R-factors have increased dramatically since 1961. Furthermore, there has been an associated progressive expansion of the genes carried on R-factors. In the S. typhimurium example, starting with resistance to streptomycin and sulfonamides in 1963, successive resistance appeared to tetracycline, ampicillin, neomycin-kanamycin, furazolidine, and chloramphenicol. Presumably this successive appearance reflects a sequential buildup of the genetic complexity of the genetic element by recombination in response to the increased use of each of the respective antibiotics. We can add to R-factors a growing list of extrachromosomal elements in enteric species. They include transmissible and nontransmissible lac+ elements and colicin factors (Falkow e t al., 1967). More recently two transmissible elements have been described which appear to be associated with bacterial virulence (Smith, 1969). These two, H l y and Ent, confer upon certain E. coli hosts the ability to synthesize an alpha-hemolysin and endotoxin respectively. A common extrachromosomal element found
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
113
along with Ent and Hly is one which carries a determinant for a surface antigen (K88). Finally, we point out that lysogeny is common to bacteria; temperate phages abound in enteric organisms. Clearly then, the extrachromosomal agents are an important consideration when describing the evolution of enteric species. The recent wide dissemination of R-factors seems especially significant. Since R-factors, like most transmissible agents, promote not only their own transfer but also transfer of the bacterial chromosome, it is interesting to wonder what will be the eventual consequences to the evolution of enteric species. The presence of a transmissible plasmid in a bacterial cell is manifested by two effects. The first, obviously, is the ability of the cell to act as a genetic donor. The second major effect is that the cell produces a specific cell appendage which appears in the electron microscope as a fine filament. These proteinacious filaments are called sex pili. Recent studies divide sex pili into two types: F-like and I-like, referring to whether they resemble the pili seen in cells harboring the classical F factor of E. coli K12 or the colicin I determinant (Meynell et al., 1968; Meynell and Datta, 1969). The division into F-like or I-like pili is made with respect to both morphological and phage adsorption characteristics. It seems highly significant that approximately 85% of the transmissible plasmids studied thus far (about 65 independent isolates) fall unequivocally into one or the other of these two major classes (Meynell et al., 1968). Table 12 presents the nucleotide sequence relationships that have been observed (Guerry and Falkow, unpublished observations) between a n F-like R-factor and several other plasmids. The data indicate that all of the F-like transmissible extrachromosomal elements show a significant degree of relatedness which is precise in terms of their TBI. There is a relatively low degree of relatedness between the F-like element and any I-like element studied in our laboratory. Preliminary studies indicate that the reciprocal relationship is also true; i.e., I-like elements are significantly related to each other, but not to F-like elements. Clearly, extrachromosomal elements belonging to the sex pili type are by no means necessarily identical, but can differ in genetic and physicochemical organization in important ways. Yet, the data (still limited, to be sure) suggest that the members of each group are almost certainly related phylogenetically and that there are only two major ancestral types of transmissible extrachromosomal elements in enteric bacteria. The latter point is of interest since transmissible extrachromosomal elements can be freely transmitted in the laboratory among all enteric genera tested and, indeed, are found readily (R-factors for instance) in clinical isolates representing all enteric genera.
114
DON J. BRENNER AND STANLEY FALKOW
TABLE 12 Polynucleotide Sequence Complementarity among Enterobacterial Plasmids
Source of unlabeled DNA Rl(R, Su, Sm, Cm,S Km, Am) RTF (R) 222(R, Su, Sm, To, Cm) F+ N3(R, Su, Sm, Tc) R-l44(R, Km) col I E. coli K12
* F-like t I-like
F-like*
I-liket
+ ++ +-
-
-
+ + + -
Mol. wt. x 10' daltons
65 50 67 60 46 42 75 2500
Relative percent binding 60°C
75°C
TBI
100 67 80 36 14
100 70 74 35 8 14 16 4
1.04 0.92 0.97 0.61 0.76 0.89 0.29
18
18 15
-
= transfer agent shows sex pili characteristic of the E . coli K12 F agent. = transfer agent shows sex pili characteristic of the col I agent. Reactions
were carried out on hydroxyapatite after incubations a t 60 or 75°C sufficient t o achieve essentially complete reassociation of the unlabeled DNA preparation. R-1 DNA incubated alone showed 1-3 % reassociation under these conditions. This background level was used to correct the binding level obtained in these reactions. $ R refers to the transfer agent of the R-factor; resistance to: Su = sulfonamide, Sm = streptomycin, Tc = tetracycline, Cm = chloramphenicol, Km = kanamycin, Am = ampicillin.
A major property of transmissible elements which is often cited is their ability to occasionally acquire genes from their host. One of the first examples of this phenomenon was the demonstration that the F agent could acquire the lac+ genes of E. coli K12. That such an event can occur in nature is suggested by the isolation of transmissible lac+ elements from clinical isolates (Falkow et al., 1967, 1969). It would be interesting to examine in detail the relationships between extrachromosomal elements and their hosts. Unfortunately there are only two examples which can be cited. One is between an F-like R-factor and E . coli K12 and the other is between F and E. coli K12. I n both instances, as reported in Table 12, there was significant relatedness although the F agent possessed significantly more nucleotide sequence relationship with host DNA than did the R-factor. It may be significant that F (and a few F-like colicine factors) is the only element thus far studied which shows a high degree of association with its host chromosome. Significantly, the nucleotide relationship between the host and the extrachromosomal elements is not very precise and the degree of binding decreases sharply under stringent conditions.
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
115
A recent report (Jenkins and Drabble, 1969) indicates hybridization between an R-factor carrying resistance to tetracycline, streptomycin, sulfonamides, chloramphenicol, and kanamycin, and DNA from S. typhimurium. Neither the thermal stability of the duplexes formed nor the relative percentage of relatedness can be calculated from the preliminary data shown. It is clearly necessary to test relatedness between a variety of extrachromosomal elements and a spectrum of bacterial hosts. The relationships between temperate phages and between temperate phages and their hosts has been reviewed recently (Falkow et al., 1969) and will not be repeated here. The studies of phage-phage relationships suggest that the lambdoid phages and Salmonella phage P22 may have a common ancestor. All of the phages interact with their (nominal) host DNA to between 20 and 50% at 60°C, but a full spectrum of reassociation conditions has yet to be carried out. The significance of the relatedness between extrachromosomal elements and their hosts with respect to evolution of the element (and the host) remains to be elucidated. We should point out an example of a potential pitfall in determining nucleotide relationships between enteric species infected with extrachromosomal elements. Ordinarily a transfer factor or phage represents only a small proportion of DNA extracted from a cell. On the average, the molecular size of the element is in the range of 25-100 x lo6 daltons (equivalent to 1-9% of the E . coli K12 chromosome) , and there is usually only a single copy of the extrachromosomal element per chromosome. This is not always the case, however. I n some instances, extrachromosomal elements, particularly R-factors, may be present as multiple copies in an enteric species. Indeed, this is documented for R-factors in Proteus, Rlebsiella, and E . coli strains (Rownd et al., 1966; Falkow et al., 1969; Clowes, personal communication). I n these instances the extrachromosomal DNA may represent from 10% to more than 40% of the total DNA extracted from a cell. Clearly if such a strain were employed in relationship studies, falsely high or falsely low results would be obtained, depending upon the presence or absence of this episome in other strains. It is, therefore, useful to ascertain wherever possible the extrachromosomal DNA complement of bacterial strains selected for study. We also emphasize that the nucleotide relationships determined between different bacterial species reflect all of the DNA present without regard to whether the DNA is chromosomal or extrachromosomal. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors should like to thank G. R. Fanning, K. E. Johnson, and Patricia Guerry for their help in the preparation of this manuscript. We also thank D. E.
116
DON J. BRENNER AND STANLEY FALKOW
Kohne, Dorothy Canter, and B. P. Doctor for permitting us to cite their unpublished observations. We are indebted to A. Riggsby for preparing the figures. The work of one of us (S. F.) was supported by a grant (13035) from the National Science Foundation and by grant FR5360 from the U.S.P.H.S.
REFERENCES Anderson, E. S. 1968. The ecology of transferable drug resistance in the Enterobacteriaceae. Annu. Rev. Microbial. 22, 131-180. Anderson, E. S. 1969. Ecology and epidemiology of transferable drug resistance. In “Bacterial Episomes and Plasmids” (G. E. W. Wolstenholme and M. O’Connor, eds.), pp. 102-119. Churchill, London. Bautz, E. K. F., and Bautz, F. A. 1964. The influence of noncomplementary bases on the stability of ordered polynucleotides. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. US. 52, 14761481. Bernardi, G., 1965. Chromatography of nucleic acids on hydroxyapatite. Nature (London) 206, 779-783. Bolton, E. T., and McCarthy, B. J. 1962. A general method for the isolation of RNA complementary to DNA. Proc. Nat. h a d . Sci. U.S.48, 1390-1397. Brenner, D. J., and Cowie, D. B. 1968. Thermal stability of Escherichia colGSa1monella typhimurium deoxyribonucleic acid duplexes. J . Bacterwl. 95, 2258-2262. Brenner, D. J., Martin, M. A., and Hoyer, B. H. 1967. Deoxyribonucleic acid homologies among some bacteria. J . Bacteriol. 94, 48M87. Brenner, D. J., Fanning, G. R., Rake, A., and Johnson, K. E. 1969a. A batch procedure for thermal elution of DNA from hydroxyapatite. Anal. Bwchem. 28, 447459. Brenner, D. J., Fanning, G. R., Johnson, K. E., Citarella, R. V., and Falkow, S. 1969b. Polynucleotide sequence relationships among members of the Enterobacteriaceae. J . Bacteriol. 98, 637-650. Brenner, D. J., Fournier, M. J., and Doctor, B. P. 1970. Isolation and partial characterization of the transfer ribonucleic acid cistrons from Escherichia coli. Nature (London) 227, 448-451. Brenner, D. J., Fanning, G. R., Skerman, F. J., and Falkow, 8. 1971. J . Bacteriol. in press. Britten, R. J., and Kohne, D. E. 1966. Nucleotide sequence repetition in DNA. Carnegie Znst. Washington Year. 65, 78-106. De Ley, J., Cattoir, H., and Reynaerts, A. 1970. The quantitative measurement of DNA hybridization from renaturation rates. Eur. J . Biochem. 12, 133-142. Denhardt, D. T. 1966. A membrane filter technique for the detection of complementary DNA. Bwchem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 23, 641-646. Edwards, P. R., and Ewing, W. H. 1966. “Identification of the Enterobacteriaceae,” pp. 83-89. Burgess, Minneapolis, Minnesota. Ewing, W. H., McWhorter, A. C., Escobar, M. R., and Lubin, A. H. 1965. Edwardsiella, a new genus of Enterobacteriaceae based on a new species, E . tarda. Znt. Bull. Bacteriol. Nomenclat. Taxon. 15, 33-38. Falkow, S., Rownd, R., and Baron, L. S. 1962.Genetic homology between Escherichia coli K-12 and Salmonella. J . Bacteriol. 84, 1303-1312. Falkow, S., Johnson, E. M., and Baron, L. S. 1967. Bacterial conjugation and extrachromosomal elements. Annu. Rev. Genet. 1, 87-116.
ENTEROBACTERIACEAE : MOLECULAR RELATIONSHIPS
117
Falkow, S.,Haapala, D. K., and Silver, R. P. 1969. Relationships between extrachromosomal elements. I n “Bacterial Episomes and Plasmids” (G. E. W. Wolstenholme and M. O’Connor, eds.), pp. 136-158. Churchill, London. Gillespie, D., and Spiegelman, S. 1965. A quantitative assay for DNA/RNA hybrids with DNA immobilized on a membrane. J. Mol. Biol. 12, 829-842. Gillis, M., De Ley, J., and De Cleene, M. 1970. The determination of molecular weight of bacterial genome DNA from renaturation rates. Eur. J. Biochem. 12, 143-153.
Goodman, H. M., and Rich, A. 1962. Formation of a DNA-soluble RNA hybrid and its relation to the origin, evolution and degeneracy of soluble RNA. Proc. Nut. Acad. Sci. U.S. 48, 2101-2109. Jenkins, P. G., and Drabble, W. T. 1969. RNA from Salmonella typhimurium hybridizible with R-factor DNA. Nature (London) 223, 296-297. Johnson, J. L., and Ordal, E. J., 1968. Deoxyribonucleic acid homology in bacterial taxonomy : effect of incubation temperature on reaction specificity. J. Bacteriol. 95, 893-900.
King, B. M., and Adler, D. L. 1964. A previously undescribed group of Enterobacteriaceae. Amer. J. Clin. Pathol. 41, 230-232. Kohne, D. E., 1968. Isolation and characterization of bacterial ribosomal RNA cistrons. Biophys. J. 8, 1104-1118. Laird, C. D., McConaughy, B. L., and McCarthy, B. J. 1969. On the rate of fixation of nucleotide substitutions in evolution. Nature (London) 224, 149-154. Luria, S. E., Adams, M. J., and Ting, R. C., 1960. Transduction of lactose-utilizing ability among strains of E . coli and S. dysenteriae and the properties of the transducing phage particles. Virology 12, 348-390. McCarthy, B. J. 1967. Arrangement of base sequences in deoxyribonucleic acid. Bacteriol. Rev. 31, 215-229. McCarthy, B. J., and Bolton, E. T. 1963. An approach to the measurement of genetic relatedness among organisms. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U.S.50, 156-164. McConaughy, B. L., and McCarthy, B. J. 1967. The interaction of oligodeoxyribonucleotides with denatured DNA. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 149, 18&189. McConaughy, B. L., Laird, C. D., and McCarthy, B. J. 1969. Nucleic acid reassociation in formamide. Biochemistry 8, 3289-3295. Marmur, J., and Doty, P. 1961. Thermal renaturation of DNA. J. Mot. BWZ. 3, 585-594.
Marmur, J., and Doty, P. 1962. Determination of the base composition of deoxyribonucleic acid from its thermal denaturation point. J. Mol. Bid. 5, 109-118. Marmur, J., Rownd, R., and Schildkraut, C. L. 1963. Denaturation and renaturation of DNA. Progr. NucZ. Acid Res. Mol. Biol. 1, 231-300. Meynell, E., and Datta, N. 1969. Sex factor activity of drug-resistance factors. I n “Bacterial Episomes and Plasmids” (G. E. W. Wolstenholme and M. O’Connor, eds.), pp. 120-133. Churchill, London. Meynell, E., Meynell, G. G., and Datta, N. 1968. Phylogenetic relationships of drug-resistance factors and other transmissible bacterial plasmids. Bacteriol. Rev. 32, 55-83. Mitsuhashi, S. 1969. Review: The R-factors. J. Infec. Dk. 119, 89-100. Miyazawa, Y., and Thomas, C. A. 1965. Composition of short segments of DNA molecules. J . Mol. Biol. 11, 223-237. Moore, R. L., and McCarthy, B. J. 1967. Comparative study of ribosomal ribonucleic acid cistrons in enterobacteria and myxobacteria. J. Bacteriol. 94, 1066-1074.
118
DON J. BRENNER AND STANLEY FALKOW
Novick, R. P. 1969. Extrachromo.soma1 inheritance in bacteria. Bacte~ol.Rev. 33, 210-235.
Nygaard, A. P., and Hall, B. D. 1963. A method for the detection of RNA-DNA complexes. Biochem. Bwphys. Res. Commun. 12, 98-104. Rownd, R., Nakaya, R., and Nakamura, A. 1966. Molecular nature of the drug resistance facbrs of the Enterobacteriaceae. J . Mol. Biol. 17, 376-393. Sakazaki, R., 1965. A proposed group of the family Enterobacteriaceae, the Asakusa group. Znt. Bull. Bacteriol. Nomenclat. Taxon. 15, 4547. Schildkraut, C. L., Marmur, J., and Doty, P. 1961. The formation of hybrid DNA molecules and their use in studies of DNA homologies. J . Mol. Biol. 3, 595-617. Shapiro, J., Machattie, L., Eron, L., Ihler, G., Ippen, K., and Beckwith, J. 1969. Isolation of pure lac+ operon. Nature (London) 224, 768-774. Smith, H. W. 1969. Vetinary implications of transfer activity. I n “Bacterial Episomes and Plasmids” (G. E. W. Wolstenholme and M. O’Connor, eds.), pp. 213-223. Churchill, London. Watanabe, T. 1963. Infective heredity of multiple drug resistance in bacteria. Bacteriol. Rev. 27, 87-115. Wetmur, J. G., and Davidson, N. 1968. Kinetics of renaturation of DNA, J . Mol. Bwl. 31, 349-370.
METABOLITE ANALOGS AS GENETIC AND BIOCHEMICAL PROBES H. E. Umbarger Department of Biological Sciences, Purdue University, Lofayette, Indiana
I. 11. 111. IV. V. VI. VII.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . Tryptophan Analogs . . . . . . . Tyrosine Analogs . . . . . . . Phenylalanine Analogs . . . . . . Histidine Analogs. . . . . . . . Analogs of Isoleucine, Valiie, and Leucine Outlook and Recommendations. . . . References . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
119 122 126 127 128 131 135 136
I. Introduction
I n the course of their fine-structure studies of the genetic material in Salmonella typhimurium, Demerec and colleagues were greatly intrigued by their discovery that genes controlling related biochemical steps were often linked. At the time, Demerec (1955) suggested that this nonrandom gene distribution, which had not been noted with fungi, was not a matter of chance but a result of some strong evolutionary advantage, perhaps peculiar to bacteria. What that advantage was probably escaped him and it cannot yet be fully explained. On the basis of some of the studies that stemmed from his pioneering experiments, however, we can cite one very distinct advantage that the clustering of related genes provided. That advantage was recognized when it was discovered that the expression of gene clusters could be regulated together, presumably through another genetic element, the operator (Ames and Garry, 1959; Jacob and Monod, 1961). Clearly, the role of a regulatory element that controls the expression of a gene cluster is to “recognize” some specific signal generated within the cytoplasm that allows the gene cluster to function a t varying rates. In the case of a cluster of genes involved in amino acid biosynthesis, a signal to “turn off” or repress gene function is generated when the amino acid is supplied in the medium. Since it is quite unlikely that the DNA of the postulated regulatory element or operator could directly 119
120
H. E. UMBAROER
recognize an amino acid, some additional regulatory element must be postulated to mediate the interaction between excess amino acid and the DNA of the operator. In the model of Jacob and Monod (1961), the repressor has been postulated to play this mediating role. Proposing this second element leads to the assumption that a second regulatory gene must exist. Since regulatory elements involved in repression studies will not give the phenotype of growth factor requirement upon loss of function, genetic techniques different from those employed in the isolation of auxotrophic or carbohydrate nonfermenting mutants had to be devised. To date, the most successful probe for the analysis of these gene-gene interactions leading to control of gene functions is the use of metabolite analogs that are inhibitory to cell growth. Many examples serve to illustrate the way in which this approach has been successful, but it should be noted that the approach is far from being fully exploited. One of the striking facts to emerge from this kind of an approach is that the generation of repression signals can be far more complex than the two-element model originally postulated by Jacob and Monod (1961).In other words, there can be several elements involved in end product recognition, suggesting that a series of reactions might be involved. It might be of some interest to review some of the patterns that appear to be emerging from these ongoing attempts in several laboratories to ana1yz;e the mechanisms of gene expression. Before doing so, however, it might be well t o define some terms and to outline what this writer looks upon as the 1970 version of the Jacob-Monod model in its pure form. As postulated in 1961, expression of a cluster of structural genes, and presumably that of a single structural gene as well, is controlled by a repression recognition element, the operator. Transcription of the structural genes occurs only if the operator region is not bound to the repressor, which is itself the product of a regulatory gene. Since the regulatory gene functions via a cytoplasmic product, the location with respect to the cluster is left unspecified. While the original model did not specify the nature of the repressor, the two repressors that have been isolated are, in fact, protein (Gilbert and Muller-Hill, 1966; Ptashne, 1967). The general properties of these repressors will be taken as the criteria for a repressor in the strict sense of the word: a protein that binds specifically to a fragment of doublestranded DNA containing a specific repression recognition (operator) region (Gilbert and Muller-Hill, 1967). Thus, genetic evidence for an element required for generation of a repression signs1 is no longer sufficient evidence to postulate a repressor. The gene cluster with its adjacent operator was originally considered
ANALOGS AS GENETIC AND BIOCHEMICAL PROBES
121
to be the operon. A feature of the operon was that, even though it might have been composed of several structural genes, it functioned as a single unit of expression with presumably transcription of the genetic information beginning at the first gene in the cluster and continuing through the last. Unsettled even today is the question whether the operator is transcribed and, if transcribed, whether it is translated. The failure to find a fragment of the z gene of the lac operon in Escherichia coli corresponding to the operator region (Bhorjee et al., 1969) does not appear to be relevant since it is inferred that a t least a portion of the N-terminal region has been removed (e.g., p-galactosidase does not contain an N-formylmethionine group). That the operator might indeed be transcribed can be concluded from the demonstration of still another element, the promoter, which appears to be the point at which RNA polymerase begins its transcription. I n the case of the lac operon, for which the evidence for a promoter is strongest, the promoter is also now believed to be an element of control in that it includes the recognition region for catabolite repression or perhaps more precisely for the cyclic 2’,3’-adenosine monophosphate (CAMP)-dependent protein. Whereas the repressor is a negative control element, the CAMP-dependent protein is a positive control element (Emmer et al., 1970; Beckwith, 1970). The lac promoter thus has two postulated functions that have not been separated structurally: a point of transcription initiation and a recognition site for a positive control element. Whether these two functions will be necessary properties of all promoter regions remains to be seen. That two kinds of recognition element have evolved in the case of the lac operon can be interpreted in terms of the physiological advantage that was achieved. Although the original Jacob-Monod model did not postulate either a promoter or a positive control element, it does seem fair to retain both of these elements in the 1970 version of the model. Therefore, in this paper, the model will be considered to involve the operon consisting of the promoter, operator, and structural gene(s), in that order, and presumably, but not necessarily, two regulatory genes that are themselves structural genes for a positive and a negative control element. A minor departure, such as a series of reactions required to convert some small molecule to the metabolite that binds to the repressor or to the positive control element, would also be in accord with the model. At this point, the question of what regions are transcribed in the mRNA or translated into polypeptide can remain unspecified. Also permissible in the interpretation of the model being followed here would be an operon without an operator. It would not be difficult to imagine a system in which a repression recognition region was not
122
H. E. UMBARGER
present and the entire control of the operon resided in the kind of specificity exhibited by a positive control element. (The CAMPdependent protein appears to have a very broad specificity affecting a variety of, if not most, catabolic enzymes.) Thus, a highly specific positive control element analogous, if not homologous, to the CAMPdependent protein might eliminate the need for a repressor. Conversely, a “low-level” promoter, which recognized either no protein analogous to the CAMP-dependent protein or one in which its activity did not vary with the environment, might account for formation of proteins that are always found in fixed levels, if any such do exist (Pardee and Beckwith, 1963). For the purposes of this paper, it will be assumed that, none of the systems that will be considered here have yet been shown to fulfill the necessary features of the Jacob-Monod model. Specifically, the missing evidence in each case is failure to demonstrate a repressor, i.e., a protein binding to the operator. Therefore, general terms, noncommittal with respect to mechanism, will be preferred to the terms operator and repressor which now refer to very precisely defined physical entities. Thus, until binding to a specific repressor is demonstrated, the terms “repression recognition element” or “induction recognition element,” will be preferred to the term “operator.” (The genetic designation for such elements with the symbol 0 as in his 0 and leu 0 is heartily endorsed, however.) Similarly, “repression signal” or “induction signal” will be preferred to “repressor.” (The apparent complexity of some of the systems generating such signals is a strong justification for this operational terminology.) The model employed here is thus not intended as an alternative to the Jacob-Monod model but as a more general scheme that encompasses alternatives to the model. Furthermore, no restrictions will be made with respect to control at the transcriptional or translational level. II. Tryptophan Analogs
The technique of using an analog as a genetic and biochemical probe in bacteria had its origin with the isolation by Cohen and Jacob (1959) of 5-methyltryptophan-resistantstrains of E. coli. These workers demonstrated that the mutated genetic locus ( t r p R ) was distant from the tryptophan structural genes on the E. coli chromosome (Cohen and Jacob, 1959). It will be recalled that the trp R lesions resulted in nonrepressible synthesis of the tryptophan biosynthetic enzymes. The existence of such mutants was readily interpreted by a version of the
ANALOGS A S GENETIC AND BIOCHEMICAL PROBES
123
Jacob-Monod model in which the repressor (in this case the trp R gene product) was active only when excess endproduct was present (in this case tryptophan). Today, the trp R gene is usually referred to as the structural gene for the tryptophan repressor (Taylor, 1970). In the more general terminology recommended here, the trp R gene should be looked upon for the present merely as an element required for generating the signal, “tryptophan excess.” One does not know whether it is the only element that is required or not.” The 5-methyl analog of tryptophan was also employed by Moyed (1960) who found an entirely different kind of 5-methyltryptophanresistant mutant. This mutant was shown to have an anthranilate synthetase and a phosphoribosyl anthranilate transferase that were resistant to inhibition by tryptophan or by 5-methyltryptophan. Surprisingly, these mutants were also derepressed with respect to the tryptophan biosynthetic enzymes. Mutants of this type have subsequently been studied in both E. coli and X. typhirnurium and have thus far been only partially explained (Somerville and Yanofsky, 1965; Cordaro and Balbinder, 1967). [That two enzymatic steps were sensitive t o end product inhibition is explained by the fact that the synthetase and the transferase exist as a complex and that the inhibition of the transferase activity is due to binding of tryptophan to the synthetase (It0 and Yanofsky, 1966, 1969). It should be noted, however, that the transferase was also sensitive to tryptophan when complexed with a tryptophaninsensitive anthranilate synthetase. Clearly, the tryptophan site on the anthranilate synthetase had not been destroyed but only its interaction with the catalytic site.] The genetic study of these same mutants demonstrated that most had lesions in the “initial” region (i.e. near the beginning of the gene cluster which, in fact, begins with the anthranilate synthetase structural gene) (Somerville and Yanofsky, 1965; Cordaro and Balbinder, 1967). The simultaneous development of derepression and loss of end product sensitivity exhibited by these mutants thus raised two questions: ( a ) Was the repression recognition site (operator) part of the first structural gene in the operon? and ( b ) were end product sensitivity and repression inextricably linked in function? An affirmative answer to the first question would have been rather readily accommodated by the Jacob-Monod *It is ironical that the tryptophan biosynthetic system is one of the few in which a test for a repressor is possible. Preparations of trp DNA with and without the repression recognition region ( t r p 0) are readily available and the trp R gene has been shown to be the structural gene for a protein (Matsushiro e t ~ l . , 1965; Ito e t al., 1969). However, it is this writer’s impression that attempts to find a trp 0-binding protein in t r p R+ cells have been unsuccessful to date.
124
H. E. UMBARQER
model, whereas an affirmative answer to the second would have been strong support for an alternative that involved control at the level of translation and more specifically the binding of end product and the first enzyme in the sequence. Indeed, a very specific model to account for translational control of gene expression was proposed several years ago by Cline and Bock (1966) based on the assumption that end product inhibition and repression were linked and on the occurrence of several other observations that were not immediately predicted by the Jacob-Monod model. For the most part, however, that model was not uniquely supported by the observations that were cited. While the model proposed by Cline and Bock (1966) was perhaps much more explicit than the data would justify, there are a number of observations made on apparent relationships of end product-sensitive enzymes to repression that are difficult to account for at present by a repressor-operator model. Nevertheless, in no case do these examples point so strongly to alternative models that an ad hoc accommodation with the repressor-operator model is ruled out. Two quite different classes of 5-methyltryptophan-resistant mutants of E . coli have more recently been identified by Hiraga and co-workers (Hiraga, 1969; Hiraga et al., 1968). One of these classes was particularly important for it provided the first genetic evidence in this organism for a repression recognition region ( t r p 0). An operator region had been inferred to exist but, as well as this reviewer can determine, the inference was from analogy with the Jacob-Monod model and from the direction of polarity of the genetic information (Yanofsky and Ito, 1966). There were, however, defective @80 phages that carried varying portions of the trp gene cluster in their genomes (Matsushiro e t al., 1965). Two of these that carried all five trp cistrons differed from each other in that one was repressible and the other was not. The repression recognition element was therefore assumed to have been severed in the one case. This kind of observation, however, does not provide as rigorous evidence for a repression recognition element as does the O++ 0" type of mutation first demonstrated for the lac operon (Jacob and Monod, 1959). The other class of 5-methyltryptophan-resistant mutants has not as yet been explained biochemically. They affect a region of the chromosome (designated mtr) that is remote from t r p R , the t r p structural gene cluster, and trp S, the tryptophanyl-tRNA synthetase structural gene (Hiraga et al., 1968). At the present time there is no evidence that these mutations in any way affect expression of the trp operon. It is of interest that the genetic studies of Hiraga (1969) with the trp Oc mutant suggested that the trp 0 region was about one fourth as long as the entire t r p operon. If the t r p 0 region were transcribed
ANALOGS AS GENETIC AND BIOCHEMICAL PROBES
125
(as might be inferred from the current idea of the role of the promoter as found in the lac system), it would constitute a significant fraction of the mRNA hybridizable with trp DNA after derepression of the trp operon. However, Imamoto (1969) has shown that a mutant bearing a deletion of all but about one eighth of the operator-proximal portion of the trp operon has retained the repression recognition site. Measurement of trp mRNA formed by this mutant indicates that if trp 0 is transcribed, it cannot account for more than 3% of the trp operon. It may be, of course, that the size estimate of the trp 0 region made by Hiraga was in error because some unknown factor perturbed the recombination frequency or UV-inactivation measurements. Evidence for a repression recognition region preceding the trp structural genes has also been obtained for X. typhi1nurium by Callahan et a2. (1970) who isolated derepressed mutants with lesions in the postulated trp 0 region that were resistant to 5-methyltryptophan and t o 6-fluorotryptophan. They also marshalled evidence that the promoter element deleted in some tryptophan auxotrophs described by Margolin and Bauerle (1966) was adjacent to the repression recognition region and distal to the structural genes similar to the arrangement in the lac system of E . coli. Held and Smith (1970a)b) have analyzed the effect of another analog of tryptophan, 7-methyltryptophan, as well as two analogs of tryptophan precursors, 3-methylanthranilatc and 7-methylindole1 which can be converted to 7-methyltrytophan. They showed that all three compounds caused a derepression of the trp operon in wild type E. coli which they attributed to tryptophan starvation resulting from inhibition of anthranilate synthetase by 7-methyl-tryptophan. Two classes of 3-methylanthranilate-resistant mutants were found-one class with lesions closely linked to the trp gene cluster, and a second class with lesions close to aroG, the structural gene for the phenylalanine-sensitive DAHP synthetase. The former contained anthranilate synthetases that were not sensitive to end product inhibition. These mutants were also resistant to derepression of the t r p genes by 7-methyltryptophan. It was concluded on this basis that the primary cause of derepression by 3-methylanthranilate was the inhibition of anthranilate synthetase by the endogenously formed 7-methyltyptophan. As will be discussed later, however, it may not always be possible to identify the target site of an analog as the site of analog resistance. The 3-methylanthranilate-resistant mutant of the second class was interesting not because it pointed to an unrecognized genetic region but because it revealed a previously unrecognized metabolic relationship. This mutant had a DAHP synthetase that was resistant to inhibition
126
H. E. UMBARQER
by phenylalanine and was shown to overproduce chorismate (Held and Smith, 1970a). Since the latter is the substrate that competitively overcomes 7-methyltryptophan inhibition of anthranilate synthetase, it would appear that it was overproduction of substrate that was responsible for resistance. While overproduction of a competitive substrate had been anticipated as a mechanism of analog resistance (Davis, 19571, one cannot a priori assume that a sufficiently elevated pool of the substrate can, in fact, be achieved. The mutant in this case suggests that the chorismate pool can be so elevated. The second class of mutant is, of course, one that would account for resistance if the postulated target site were the actual one. However, it would also account for resistance if what was really necessary was increased metabolite flow over the tryptophan biosynthetic pathway and an increased internal tryptophan pool. In part, the use of analogs has been used to support the argument that the activation of tryptophan is not necessary for the generation of the repression signal recognized by the trp 0 region. That there might be some role of tryptophanyl-tRNA synthetase in repression had been indicated by the demonstration that a mutant with an altered synthetase exhibited an altered pattern of repression and derepression of the t r p operon (Kano et al., 1968; Hiraga et al., 1967). That this involvement did not include the charging of tRNA with tryptophan, however, was suggested by the observations on three analogs of tryptophan: 7-azatryptophan, 4-methyltryptophan1 and 6-methyltryptophan (Mosteller and Yanafsky, 1970). The first two could be incorporated into protein, whereas the third could not. In contrast, the first was unable to repress the formation of specifically hybridizable t r p mRNA, whereas the second and third could. 111. Tyrosine Analogs
Quite a number of tyrosine analogues have been tested in microorganisms, but only a few have been subjected to the kind of genetic and biochemical analysis that is being considered here. Among these is 4-fluorophenyla1aninel an analog shown years ago by Munier and Cohen (1956) to be incorporated into E. coli protein. More recently, 4-fluorophenylalanine-resistantmutants of S. typhimurium have been examined in which the lesions are closely linked to structural genes for two enzymes that are coordinately derepressed in these mutants, the tyrosine-repressed DAHP synthetase and prephenate dehydrogenase (Gollub and Sprinson, 1969). While other, unlinked tyrosine repressible gene products have not been examined, it may be that, in this case,
ANALOGS AS GENETIC AND BIOCHEMICAL PROBES
127
a specific repression recognition region has undergone an 0' + 0"type mutation. Another kind of mutation has been found in E. coli mutants resistant to 4-aminophenylalanine (Wallace and Pitt.ard, 1969). I n these, the mutated gene, tyr R, also causes derepression of the aroF or tyr A genes but is unlinked to them. In addition, transaminase A, an enzyme for which the structural gene has not been located, is derepressed. At present, in the operational terms employed here, tyr R is the gene for some element (not necessarily a repressor) required for generating the tyrosine excess signal. Still another analog of tyrosine, 2-aminotyrosine, has been employed with E. coli strain 9723 as a biochemical probe but not as a genetic probe. Sloane and Smith (1968), in an attempt to explain the reversal of the inhibitory effect of this tyrosine analog by p-hydroxymethylphenylalanine but not by phenylalanine, obtained isotopic evidence that p-hydroxymethylphenylalaninecould be converted to both phenylalanine and tyrosine. Further analysis yielded evidence that some phenylalanine could be converted to p-hydroxymethylphenylalanine which, in turn, could be an intermediate in the low-level conversion of phenylalanine to tyrosine that these workers observed. Whether this route is unique to certain strains of E. coli and what its relationship is to the well-known route to tyrosine via prephenate remains an open question. Interestingly, however, it is a route that, on the basis of mutant methodology with the more commonly used strains of E. coli and S. typhimurium, has been eliminated as a significant one. Finally, D-tyrosine has been employed as an analog of L-tyrosine in Bacillus subtilis by Champney and Jensen (1969). A resistant mutant was isolated in which the gene lesion was in the structural gene for prephenate dehydrogenase, which, in the mutant, differed from that in the parent in being resistant to end product inhibition by tyrosine. Such findings are extremely important, for the parallel observation that such mutants excrete L-tyrosine provides evidence that the end product sensitivity observed in vitro is indeed physiologically significant. The studies did not reveal, as these workers correctly interpreted, whether inhibition of prephenate dehydrogenase or some other enzyme by D-tyrosine was the primary cause of the growth inhibition. This principle is sometimes forgotten in the interpretation of analog-resistance studies. IV. Phenylalanine Analogs
An often used analog of phenylalanine is p-2-thienylalanine. One of the first uses of it as a biochemical probe was reported by Ezekiel (1965)
128
€ E. I .UMBARGER
who showed that it inhibited the phenylalanine-repressible DAHP synthetase as well as phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase. A resistant mutant exhibited what was very probably an altered phenylalanine repressible DAHP synthetase. The genetic analysis of this strain does not appear to have been completed, however. In B. subtilis, the site of end product inhibition by phenylalanine is prephenate dehydratase. Coates and Nester (1967) have isolated two types of p12-thienylalanine-resistantmutants in which the properties of this enzyme are altered. I n one type, the enzyme is insensitive to phenylalanine and in the other the enzyme is actually stimulated by phenylalanine. Genetic analysis verified that the structural gene for the enzyme was modified. Phenylalanine and tyrosine provide two very striking examples of amino acids for which analogs have certainly been underexploited. There is such a wide variety of analogs for these amino acids (for a list of some, see Shive and Skinner, 1963) that have not a t all been subjected to a combined biochemical and genetic analysis. V. Histidine Analogs
Probably the best example of the utility of amino acid analogs as biochemical and genetic probes is to be found in the studies conducted by Hartman and Ames and their colleagues. That the genetic analysis has been so successful is due to a great extent to the very extensive genetic mapping studies that have been conducted with the histidine auxotrophs of S. typhimurium. The introduction of histidine analogs into serious microbial studies is due to Moyed (1961), who employed 2-thiazolealanine as an inhibitor of E . coli. Moyed discovered that this compound was an inhibitor of the first enzyme in the pathway to histidine. At low levels of thiazolealanine, growth inhibition was, however, only transient, since the limitation of histidine caused the derepression of all the histidine biosynthetic enzymes including the sensitive one. This mechanism, termed by Moyed “induced phenotypic resistance,” has been found many times since with analogs. It will not occur with all analogs, however, because some will prevent protein synthesis (and hence the derepression necessary to overcome the inhibition) or may, in fact, be incorporated into protein but yield inactive or “false” proteins. Another possible reason for the absence of induced phenotypic resistance is that derepression does not occur because the analog mimics the effect of the natural amino acid as a repressor. This mechanism has often been postulated but is difficult
ANALOGS AS GENETIC AND BIOCHEMICAL PROBES
129
to distinguish from “false protein” formation. I n only a few cases does it appear that this distinction has been achieved. One of the most strongly supported cases for an analog mimicking the effect of an end product as a repressor is that of 1,2,4-triazolealanine1 studied by Levin and Hartman (1963). Triazolealanine is a histidine analog that is incorporated into protein to yield, in at least some cases, biologically inactive protein. These workers examined several histidine biosynthetic enzymes formed in the presence of triazolealanine by a mutant that had completely lost the repression recognition region as well as part of the gene for the first enzyme in the pathway but could express the other his genes, (i.e., a his Oc G mutant). It was possible to demonstrate that active histidinol phosphate phosphatase and imidszole acetolphosphate transaminase were formed in the presence of triazolealanine, whereas an active histidinol dehydrogenase was not formed. However, when a leaky mutant that, in the absence of histidine, formed both enzymes a t a derepressed rate was given either triazolealanine or histidine, both enzymes were repressed. Unless, by some peculiar mechanism, these two enzymes were formed in the deletion mutant because histidine released by protein turnover was incorporated into these two enzymes in preference to the analog, one must conclude that triazolealanine can indeed be used to mimic a “histidine excess” signal. The first extensive genetic analysis of mutants resistant to a histidine analog was that performed by Sheppard (1964) with S. typhimurium mutants resistant to triazolealanine, the analog shown by Moyed to act as a “false feedback” inhibitor. Sheppard noted that most of the mutants had lesions in a particular region of the his G gene which specified the structure of the first enzyme in the pathway to histidine. In such mutants, the enzyme was refractory to inhibition by both histidine and thiazolealanine. While this region is not necessarily that which specifies the histidine binding site, it does apparently specify a sequence in the protein that is a t least important in end-product sensitivity. The region is also of special interest since mutations occurred here that appeared to result in the generation of new transcription initiation points (promoters?) in a strain that has lost by deletion both the repression recognition region as well as the postulated promoter (St. Pierre, 1968; Ames et al., 1963). Furthermore, some of the reinitiation mutations in this region, when transferred to a strain in which the rest of the his operon was intact, led t o cold-sensitive strains that were super-sensitive to inhibition by histidine similar to the E. coli mutants described by O’Donovan and Ingraham (1965). The genetic analysis of S. typhiinurium mutants in which regulation of formation of the histidine biosynthetic enzymes was altered, has been
130
H. E. UMBARGER
more spectacular than the analysis of the mutants with altered end product sensitivity. These studies have revealed that regulation in this system is indeed more complex than was a t first realized. Because triazolealanine prevents derepression, it will prevent the growth of organisms that depend upon derepression of the histidine gene cluster for growth. Examples would be bradytrophs (“leaky” mutants in which one enzyme in the pathway was only partially active) and cells growing in the presence of 1,2,4-amino triazole, an inhibitor of imidazoleglycerol phosphate dehydrase. In such cases, derepression was required for an adequate rate of histidine biosynthesis. The first gene to be recognized by lesions leading to derepression was designated his R , undoubtedly in anticlipation that it was the gene for the repressor of the Jacob-Monod model (Roth and Hartman, 1965). Subsequently, it was found that the derepressed mutants contained lesions in any of several additional loci, which were designated his S, T , U , and W (Roth et al., 1966, Anthn, 1968). Examination of these revealed that the his S mutants had lesions in the structural gene for histidyl-tRNA synthetase, while his U , his W ,and the earlier recognized his R mutants had reduced levels of histidine acceptor tRNA (An&, 1968; Roth and Ames, 1966; Silbert et al., 1966). While there might be reason to suspect that his R, W , and U are structural genes for histidine acceptor tRNA, there is no evidence that there are three distinct species. It is not a t all clear how these genes might affect the quantity of a single species of tRNA. The possibility might be considered that they are multiple copies of a gene that does not function very effectively so that all three are required for the full quota of histidine acceptor tRNA.” The his T gene is not yet explained but it does appear to be the structural gene for a protein (B. N. Ames, personal communication). What can be concluded at this point is that activation of histidine by the histidyl-tRNA synthetase and an intact his T gene are essential for the generation of the excess histidine signal. That a deficiency of the corresponding tRNA itself also prevents the generation of the signal suggests that histidyl-tRNA itself is directly on the pathway to the repression signal. Indeed, a direct involvement of these recognized elements would still be compatible with the Jacob-Monod repressor-operator model. Alternatives are possible, however, including some in which histidine acceptor tRNA plays an indirect role. One alternative is based on the observations of Goldberger and his associates (Kovach et al., 1969) that, in certain mutants with an initial enzyme in the pathway
* More-recent observations indicate that the levels of histidine acceptor tRNA in his U and his W strains are normal. Only his R mutants exhibit reduced levels of histidine acceptor tRNA.
ANALOGS A S GENETIC A N D BIOCHEMICAL P R O B E S
131
that is histidine-insensitive, triazolealanine cannot repress the histidine biosynthetic enzymes, and that, with histidine itself, the pattern of repression is markedly altered. Their further observations that the initial enzyme binds histidyl-tRNA (though not completely specifically) had induced them to invoke some not-yet clear role for the first enzyme in the generation of the repression signal (Kovach et al., 1970). Certainly, the studies currently in progress with this system are worthy of our continued attention. Another analog of histidine, D-a-hydrazinoimidazolepropionic acid (HIPA) has been useful in the study of the active transport systems for histidine in 8. typhimurium (Ames and Roth, 1968). HIPA is an inhibitor of growth and, while the primary site of its inhibitory effect is presumably not active transport, apparently the most effective way for the organism to develop resistance is to prevent the uptake of the analog. The analysis with HIPA and a variety of other analogs indicated that histidine was concentrated in the cell by means of two uptake systems, one highly specific for histidine and histidine analogs and another for aromatic amino acids or histidine. More recently, studies involving utilization of D-histidine in place of L-histidine have revealed genetic evidence for two histidine-binding proteins in addition to the component earlier referred to as a “permease” (Ames and Lever, 1970). This example is only one of many that could be cited in which analogs have been used to select for mutants with altered uptake of the analog as well as the natural product. Clearly, analogs should be useful in helping to unravel the complex system that the word “permease” conceals. VI. Analogs of Isoleucine, Valine, and Leucine
As might be expected from the similarity in structure of isoleucine, valine, and leucine, these amino acids have sometimes functioned as analogs of each other. Indeed, one of the earliest examples of “amino acid imbalance” was observed with these amino acids by Gladstone (1939) using B . anthracis. The well-known inhibition of the growth of the K-12 strain of E. coli by valine, and its reversal by isoleucine, provided the subject of the studies conducted by Ramakrishnan and Adelberg (1965a), whose analysis provided us with our present-day picture of the arrangement of the five structural genes for the isoleucine and valine biosynthetic enzymes. Their work demonstrated that, unlike the genes in the tryptophan cluster in E . coli and S. typhimurium, there was more than one repression recognition element and, therefore, presumably more than one operon or functional grouping.
132
H. E. UMBARGER
Very briefly, they presented evidence that the structural genes were arranged in the order B , C, A, D, and E corresponding to enzymes 2, 3, 1, 4, and 5 in the sequence (Ramakrishnan and Adelberg, 1965a). One class of valine-resistant mutant was that described biochemically several years earlier by Leavitt (Leavitt and Umbarger, 1962), in which the normally valine-sensitive enzyme (enzyme 2) was resistant. Such mutants, in which the ilv B gene was altered, were useful to locate the position of that gene on the chromosome since E . coli mutants lacking this enzyme have probably not yet been found, though probably mutations leading to abnormal enzyme have been observed (Ramakrishnan and Adelberg, 1965a,b). Another class of valine-resistant mutant was one in which the enzymes coded for by the ilv genes A , D , and E were derepressed (Ramakrishnan and Adelberg, 1965b). While the basis for valine-resistance in these mutants cannot yet be explained (Umbarger, 1969), they did provide a means of identifying the repression recognition element, designated ilv 0. Another class was found to have a derepressed ilv B gene, thus resulting in high levels of the valine-inhibited enzyme (Rarnakrishnan and Adelberg, 196513). Interestingly, these mutants had only the valine-sensitive enzyme derepressed indicating that the affected repression recognition region ilv P controlled only the adjacent ilv B gene. No mutations were found to affect regulation of the ilv C gene which is now known to be controlled in E . coli and S. typhimurium by substrate induction rather than by repression (Arfin et al., 1969). The first nonnatural analog of a branched-chain amino acid employed systematically as a biochemical and genetic probe was 5’,5’,5’-trifluoroleucine, a compound shown by Rennert and Anker (1963) to be incorporated into protein of E . coli and under suitable conditions, as yet not fully understood, to replace fully the leucine of proteins in that organism. This study, initiated by Calvo with S. typhimurium, led to the recognition of four classes of trifluoroleucine-resistant mutants. One very rare class contained an isopropyl malate synthetase (the end product-sensitive enzyme) that was resistant to inhibition by both leucine and trifluoroleucine (Calvo et al., 1969a). Another class was characterized as having normal leucine biosynthetic enzymes, but derepressed levels of all three (Calvo et al., 1969b). I n these, the lesion has affected the repression recognition site (designated leu 0) adjacent to the structural genes for the leucine biosynthetic enzymes. Another kind of trifluoroleucine-resistant mutant was one in which the lesion was not linked to the leu gene cluster. I n these, not only were the leucine biosynthetic enzymes derepressed, but also five isoleucine and valine biosynthetic enzymes. This property was of particular interest because it was known that for repression of the isoleucine and valine biosynthetic enzymes
ANALOGS A S GENETIC AND BIOCHEMICAL PROBES
133
all three branched-chain amino acids had to be in excess (Freundlich
et al., 1962). The affected gene (leu S ) in these mutants was thus one that was required for generation of the “leucine excess” signal not only for interaction with the leu 0 region but with the presumed ilv 0 and ilv P regions as well. (Although ilv 0 and ilv P have not been demonstrated in S. typhimurium, the near-universal homology between gene order and function in E. coli and that in S. typhimurium serve to justify the presumption.) The leu S lesions have since been shown to result in leucyl-tRNA synthetases that have a reduced affinity for leucine. That difficulty in generation of the repression signal for multivalent repression of the ilv gene cluster accompanied the difficulty in activating leucine was not surprising in view of the findings of Neidhardt and his colleagues (1966) that under conditions of restricted valyl-tRNA synthesis the “excess valine” signal required for multivalent repression was not generated. That the “excess isoleucine” signal also required a normal activating enzyme was indicated by a study of E. coli thiaisoleucine resistant mutants (Szentirmai e t al., 1968). These mutants exhibited reduced levels of isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase. Subsequent genetic analysis of these has demonstrated that for the thiaisoleucine resistance and derepression observed in the original isolates, two mutational steps were required (Coker and Umbarger, 1970). One of these affected the structural gene, ilv S, of isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase, resulting in an enzyme with reduced activity and reduced affinity for isoleucine. The second gene, ilv U , appears to be a regulatory gene that leads to derepression of isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase when isoleucine is limiting. Cells containing only the ilv S lesion, although partially resistant to thiaisoleucine, appear to have a derepressed level of a poor synthetase. The derepression would appear to compensate at least in part for the reduced efficiency of the enzyme (resulting in about 50% of the wild-type activity) so that no depression of the isoleucine and valine biosynthetic enzymes results. When the ilv U mutation was introduced into an ilv S mutant, derepression of the poor synthetase was no longer possible, and only about 5% of the wildtype synthetase activity was observed in extracts. This introduction of ilv U was accompanied by an increase in thiaisoleucine resistance and derepression of the ilv gene cluster. [Actually in E. coli strain K-12, only the ilv ADE operon is derepressed when isoleucine is limiting, whereas in S. typhimurium all five enzymes are elevated (Dwyer and Umbarger, 1968) .] The introduction of ilv U into a wild-type organism led to levels of thiaisoleucine resistance and derepression less than those observed when ilv U and ilv S were both present. While an ilv U mutant exhibits
134
H. E. UMBARGER
a normal level of isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase when grown in minimal medium, it does not exhibit derepression of the synthetase when the isoleucine supply is restricted, as observed by Nass and Neidhardt (1967). It is of interest that the regulation of isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase is not multivalent but specifically responsive, via the ilv U gene, to isoleucine. I n some, but not all, thiaisoleucine-resistant mutants a third gene has been affected. This gene, ilv T, leads to a low level of derepression but not to thiaisoleucine resistance. It, too, may act synergistically with ilv S but its role is more obscure than that of ilv U . Thiaisoleucine has also been employed as a probe with S. typhimurium, but all the resistant mutants were those with an end product-insensitive threonine deaminase (Blatt, unpublished observations). This difference in pattern of analog resistance in two such similar organisms illustrates well the utility of examining the same analog in a variety of organisms that can be studied genetically. While the analog itself may not behave significantly differently in the two organisms, the permissible and feastble mutations leading to resistance in the two organisms may differ markedly. I n S. typhimurium, ilv S mutants were isolated as isoleucine auxotrophs with isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase with only 1/1000th the wild-type affinity for isoleucine (Blatt and Umbarger, 1970). In these organisms, the ilv S lesion itself led to derepression of all five isoleucine and valine biosynthetic enzymes. Another example of the advantage of utilizing a variety of analogs in a variety of organisms was noted when mutants comparable to those found by Calvo in S. typhimurium were sought in E . coli. However, trifluoroleucine was not a particularly effective inhibitor of E . coli, so that 4-azaleucine was employed an analog not particularly effective in S. typhimurium. Mutants of E . coli resistant to azaleucine were isolated that had, like leu S mutants of S. typhimurium, derepressed leucine biosynthetic enzymes and derepressed isoleucine and valine biosynthetic enzymes (except, of course, the inducible ilv C gene product that was not well induced because of the effectiveness of end product control on the valine-sensitive enzyme). However, this mutation was in an entirely different gene, and neither leucyl-tRNA synthetase, nor any leucine acceptor tRNA, were any different from those in wild-type E . coli. At the present time, the responsible gene, designated ad, is viewed as a necessary element along with normal leu 0, and leu S gene functions and excess leucine to generate the signal “excess leucine” and along with normal ilv 0, val S, ilv S, and ilv P gene functions and excess valine and isoleucine to generate the multivalent repression signal. Although one could formulate a model involving these elements it would
ANALOGS AS GENETIC AND BIOCHEMICAL PROBES
135
seem premature to do so. Indeed, it might be anticipated that continued use of analog probes will reveal more elements with a role in regulation of these enzymes. From the results obtained with the branched-chain amino acids, one might doubt that the genetic analysis of the regulation of any amino acid biosynthetic pathway will be complete when evidence for a repression recognition region and a single unlinked regulatory element (as postulated by the Jacob-Monod model) has been found. The generation of repression signals may well be far more complex than we have anticipated and a combined genetic and biochemical probing may be almost essential. It is also quite possible that different analogs will result in different kinds of resistant mutants. Similarly, a comparative study of 8. typhimurium and E . coli with respect to the spectrum of regulatory elements that can be recognized may yield much information that will be complementary. This prediction is based upon the great extent of genetic homology that is found between the two species until one reaches the base-pair level of resolution. It is a t this latter level that the kind of effects that can be obtained by permissible changes in a base pair is determined. Such differences may account for the observation that a given analog may select for end product insensitive enzymes in one species and derepressed operons in another. VII. Outlook and Recommendations
The theme that I have tried to develop here, is that there is yet much to be learned by using metabolite analogs to select resistant mutants. The mutants so found may not only reveal biochemical relationships not earlier recognized, but also gene functions that are not recognized until altered. One might ask, cannot these interacting elements also be discovered by sufficiently detailed biochemical analysis? The answer is usually yes, but it does appear that some biological interactions are so tightly coupled that, without genetically controlled modification, resolution of the components involved would be difficult indeed. An example might be the proteins of the ribosomes that are tightly bound and then function as a single unit. An example a t another level might be the processes of transcription and translation of genetic information which, while apparently biochemically distinct, are so difficult to uncouple that it is not yet possible to find convincing evidence that control of gene expression is a t one level or the other. (Perhaps we should keep in mind that the goal in evolution was to achieve control of gene function and perhaps the means to achieve the end has not always been the same in each case.)
136
H. E. UMBARGER
While only a few examples have been chosen for discussion here, specifically analogs of the aromatic and branched-chain amino acids and histidine, it has been possible to show that their study has had considerable impact on the attempts to understand the mechanisms of regulation of gene expression in bacteria. The results have been quite enlightening to those of us who, following the introduction in 1961 of the very clear, concise and esthetically pleasing repressor-operator model, went off to our own biosynthetic and catabolic systems in bacteria, fungi, and even in developing embryos to invoke operators, repressors, and, more recently, promoters with complete abandon, only because we had no evidence to countraindicate them. This zeal on the part of the disciples was exactly opposite to the mode of operation used by Jacob and Monod (1961), who invoked only regulatory elements for which genetic and biochemical evidence was available. The more carefully examined picture currently seems quite complex. Indeed, the differences thus far revealed, even in such similar systems as these amino acid biosynthetic pathways, cause us to hesitate before concluding (paraphasing the Philistinism of a contemporary political revertant) that to have seen one operon is to have seen them all. One might wonder whether the regulation of gene expression, which must have evolved after the appearance of the function itself, might not in each case have developed along unique lines. While we might easily recognize analogous elements involved in repression and induction of certain gene functions, whether these elements are homologous in function and structure may require more detailed study. Metabolite analogs should continue to prove valuable in this area, which is one of the many that are extensions of what Demerec began at Cold Spring Harbor.
REFERENCES Ames, B. N., and Gamy, B. 1959. Coordinate repression of the synthesis of four histidine biosynthetic enzymes by histidine. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U.S. 45, 1453-1461.
Ames, G. F., and Lever, J. 1970. Components of histidine transport : histidine-binding protein and h i P protein. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U.S. 66, 10961103. Ames, G. F., and Roth, J. R. 1908. Histidine and aromatic permeases of Salmonella typhimurium. J . Bacteriol. 96, 1742-1749. Ames, B. N., Hartman, P. E., and Jacob, F. 1963. Chromosomal alterations decting the regulation of histidine biosynthetic enzymes in Salmonella. J. Mol. Biol.
7,2342.
Anttin, D. N. 1968. Histidine regulatory mutants in Salmonella typhimurium. V. Two new classes of histidine regulatory mutants. J . Mol. Biol. 33, 633-546. Arfin, S. M., Ratzkin, B., and Umbarger, H. E. 1969. The metabolism of valine
ANALOGS AS GENETIC A N D BIOCHEMICAL PROBES
137
and isoleucine in Escherichia coli. XVII. The role of induction in the derepression of acetohydroxy acid isomeroreductase. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 37, 902-908. Beckwith, J. 1970. Gene expression in bacteria and some concerns about the misuse of science. Bacteriol. Rev. 34, 222-227. Bhorjee, J. S., Fowler, A. V., and Zabin, I. 1969. Biochemical evidence.that the operator locus is distinct from the z gene in the lac operon of Escherichia coli. J . Mol. Biol. 43, 219-222. Blatt, J. M.1970. Unpublished observations. Blatt, J. M., and Umbarger, H. E. 1970. Relation of isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase to repression of branched-chain amino acid biosynthetic enzymes in Salmonella typhimurium. Bacteriol. Proc. p. 136. Callahan, R., 111, Blume, A. J., and Balbinder, E. 1970. Evidence for the order promoter-operator-first structural gene in the tryptophan operon of Salmonella. J . Mol. Biol. 51, 709-714. Calvo, J. M., Freundlich, M., and Umbarger, H. E. 1969a. Regulation of branched chain amino acid biosynthesis in Salmonella typhimurium: isolation of regulatory mutants. J . Bacteriol. 97, 1272-1282. Calvo, J. M., Margolin, P., and Umbarger, H. E. 1969b. Operator constitutive mutations in the leucine operon of Salmonella typhimurium. Genetics 61, 777-787. Champney, W. S., and Jensen, R. A. 1969. n-Tyrosine as a metabolic inhibitor of Bacillus subtilis. J . Bacteriol. 98, 205-214. Cline, A. L., and Bock, R. M. 1966. Translational control of gene expression. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 31, 321-333. Coates, J. H., and Nester, E. W. 1967. Regulation reversal mutation: characterization of endproduct-activated mutants of Bacillus subti1i.s. J . Bwl. Chem. 242, 49484955. Cohen, G. N., and Jacob, F. 1959. Sur la rbpression de la synth6s des enzymes intervenant dans la formation du tryptophane chez E. coli. C.R. Acad. Sci. 248, 3490-3492. Coker, M., and Umbarger, H. E. 1970. Genetic lesions leading to thiaisoleucine resistance in Escherichia coli. Bacteriol. Proc. p. 135. Cordaro, C., and Balbinder, E. 1967. An operator constitutive mutation in a mutant for the first structural gene of the tryptophan operon. Bacteriol. Proc. p. 51. Davis, B. D. 1957. Physiological (phenotypic) mechanisms responsible for drug resistance. Ciba Found. Symp. Drug Resist. Micro-Organisms pp. 165-179. Demerec, M. 1955. Annual Report of the Director of the Department of Genetics, Carnegie Institution of Washington, No. 55, 213, Washington. Dwyer, S. B., and Umbarger, H. E. 1968. Isoleucine and valine metabolism of Escherichia coli. XVI. Pattern of multivalent repression in strain K-12. J . Bacteriol. 95, 1680-1684. Emmer, M., de Crombrugghe, B., Pastan, I., and Perlman, R. 1970. Cyclic AMP receptor protein of E . coli: its role in the synthesis of inducible enzymes. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. US.66, 480-487. Ezekiel, D. H. 1965. False feedback inhibition of aromatic amino acid biosynthesis by p-2-thienylalanine. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 95, 54-62. Freundlich, M., Burns, R. O., and Umbarger, H. E. 1962. Control of isoleucine, d i n e and leucine biosynthesis. I. Multivalent repression. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U.S. 48, 1804-1808.
138
H. E. UMBARGER
Gilbert, W. and Muller-Hill, B. 1966. Isolation of the lac repressor. Proc. N u t . Acad. Sci. U.S. 56, 1891-1898. Gilbert, W., and Muller-Hill, B. 1967. The lac operator is DNA. Proc. N a t . Acad. Sci. U.S. 58, 2415-2421. Gladstone, G. P. 1939. Inter-relationships between amino-acids in the nutrition of Bacillus anthracis. Biit. J . Exp. Pathol. 20, 189-200. Gollub, E. and Sprinson, 0. B. 1969. A regulatory mutation in tyrosine biosynthesis. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 35, 389-395. Held, W. A., and Smith, 0. H. 1970a. Regulation of the Escherichia coli tryptophan operon by early reactions in the aromatic pathway. J. Bacteriol. 101, 202-208. Held, W. A., and Smith, 0. H. 1970b. Mechanism of 3-methylanthranilic acid derepression of the tryptophan operon in Escherichia coli. J. Bacteriol. 101, 209-217. Hiraga, S. 1969. Operator mutants of the tryptophan operon in Escherichia coli. J . Mol. Biol. 39, 159-179. Hiraga, S., Ito, K., Hamada, K., and Yura, T. 1967. A new regulatory gene for the tryptophan operon of E . coli. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 26, 522-527. Hiraga, S., Ito, D., Matsuyama, T., Ozaki, H., and Yura, T. 1968. 5-Methyltryptophan-resistant mutations linked with the arginine G marker in Escherichia coli. J . Bacteriol. 96, 1880-1881. Imamoto, F. 1969. Unimpaired repressibility of transcription of the operator-proxima1 eighth of the first (E)gene of the tryptophan operon in Escherichia coli. Mol. Gen. Genet., 105, 298-305. Ito, J., and Yanofsky, C. 1966. The nature of the anthranilic synthetase complex of Escherichia coli. J. Biol. Chem. 241,4112-4114. Ito, J., and Yanofsky, C. 1969. Anthranilate synthetase, an enzyme specified by the tryptophan operon of Escherichia coli: comparative studies on the complex and the subunits. J. Bacteriol. 97, 734-742. Ito, K., Hiraga, S., and Yura, T. 1969. Temperature-sensitive repression of the tryptophan operon in Escherichia coli. J. Bacteriol. 99, 279-286. Jacob, F., and Monod, J. 1959. GBnes de structure et gknes de r6gulation dans la biosynthhse des prot6ines. CJZ. Acad. Sci. Ser. D 249, 1282-1284. Jacob, F., and Monod, J. 1961. On the regulation of gene activity. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 26, 389-401. Kano, Y., Matsushiro, A,, and Shimura, Y. 1968. Isolation of the novel regulatory mutants of the tryptophan biosynthesis system in Escherichia coli. Mol. Gen. Genet. 102, 15-26. Kovach, J. S., Phang, J. M., Blaai, F., Barton, R. W., Ballesteros-Olmo, A., and Goldberger, R. F. 1970. Interaction between histidyl tRNA and the first enzyme for histidine biosynthesis of Salmonella typhimurium. J . Bacteriol. 104, 787-792. Kovach, J. S., Phang, J. M., Ference, M., and Goldberger, R. F. 1969. Studies on repression of the histidine operon, 11. The role of the first enzyme in control of the histidine system. Proc. N a t . Acad. Sci. U.S. 63, 481-488. Leavitt, R. I., and Umbarger, H. E. 1962. .Isoleucine and valine metabolism in Escherichia coli. XI. Valine inhibition of the growth of Escherichia coli strain K-12. J . Bacteriol. 83, 624-630. Levin, A. P., and Hartman, P. E. 1963. Action of a histidine analogue, 1,2,4-triazole3-alanine, in Salmonella typhimurium. J. Bacteriol. 86, 820-828. Mmgolin, P., and Bauerle, R. H. 1966. Determinants for regulation and initiation
ANALOGS AS GENETIC AND BIOCHEMICAL PROBES
139
of expression of tryptophan genes. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 31, 311-320.
Matsushiro, A,, Sato, K., Ito, J., Kida, S., and Imamoto, F. 1965. On the transcription of the tryptophan operon in Eschem’chia coli. I. The tryptophan operator. J . Mol. Biol. 11, 54-63. Mosteller, R. D., and Yanofsky, C. 1970. Repression of the tryptophan operon of E . coli. Fed. Proc., Fed. Amer. SOC. Exp. Biol. 29, 598. Moyed, H. S. 1960. False feedback inhibition : inhibition of tryptophan biosynthesis by 5-methyltryptophan. J. Biol. Chem. 235, 1098-1102. Moyed, H. S. 1961. Interference with the feedback control of histidine biosynthesis. J. Biol. Chem. 236, 2261-2267. Munier, R., and Cohen, G. N. 1956. Incorporation d’analogues structuraux d’amino acides dans les protCines bactbriennes. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 21, 592-593. Nass, G., and Neidhardt, F. C. 1967. Regulation of formation of amino acyl-ribonucleic acid synthetases in Escheiichin coli. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 134, 347-359. Neidhardt, F. C. 1966. Roles of amino acid activating enzymes in cellular physiology. Bacteriol. Rev. 30, 701-719. O’Donovan, G. A., and Ingraham, J. L. 1965. Cold-sensitive mutants of Escherichk coli resulting from increased feedback inhibition. Proc. Nut. Acad. Sci. U.S. 54, 451457. Pardee, A. B., and Beckwith, J. R. 1963. Control of constitutive enzyme synthesis. I n “Informational Macromolecules” (H. J. Vogel, V. Bryson, and J. 0. Lampen, eds.), pp. 255-269. Academic Press, New York. Ptashne, M. 1967. Isolation of the phage repressor. R o c . Nut. Acad. Sci. U.S. 57, 306-313. Ramakrishnan, T., and Adelberg, E. A. 1965a. Regulatory mechanisms in the biosynthesis of isoleucine and valine. 111. Map order of the structural and operator genes. J . Bacteriol. 89, 661-664. Ramakrishnan, T., and Adelberg, E. A. 196513. Regulatory mechanisms in the biosynthesis of isoleucine and valine. 11. Identification of two operator genes. J. Bacteriol. 89, 654-660. Rennert, 0 M., and Anker, H. S. 1963. On the incorporation of 5’5’5’-trifluoroleucine into proteins of E. coli. Biochemistry 2, 471476. Roth, J. R., and Ames, B. N. 1966. Histidine regulatory mutants in Salmonella typhimurium. 11. Histidine regulatory mutants having altered histidyl-tRNA synthetase. J. Mol. Biol. 22, 325-334. Roth, J. R., and Hartman, P. E. 1965. Heterogeneity in P22 transducing particles. Virology 27, 297-307. Roth, J. R., Antbn, D. N., and Hartman, P. E. 1966. Histidine regulatory mutants in Salmonella typhimurium. I. Isolation and general properties. J . Mol. Biol. 22, 305-323. St. Pierre, M. L. 1968. Mutations creating a new initiation point for expression of the histidine operon in Salmonella typhimurium. J . Mol. Biol. 35, 71-82. Sheppard, D. E. 1964. Mutants of Salmonella typhimurium resistant to feedback inhibition by L-histidine. Genetics 53, 445-459. Shive, W., and Skinner, C. G. 1963. Amino acid analogs. In “Metabolic Inhibitors” (R.M. Hochster and J. H. Quastel, eds.), Vol. I, pp. 1-73. Academic Press, New York. Silbert, D. F., Fink, G. R., and Ames, B. N. 1966. Histidine regulatory mutants
140
H. E. UMBAROER
in Salmonella typhimurium. 111. A class of regulatory mutants deficient in tRNA for histidine. J. Mol. Biol. 22, 335-342. Sloan, N. H., and Smith, S. C. 1968. Hydroxymethylation of the benzene ring. IV. p-Hydroxylmethyl-L-phenylalanine, a naturally occurring amino acid in Escherichia coli: identification and biochemical properties. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 158, 394401. Somerville, R. L., and Yanofsky, C. 1965. Studies on the regulation of tryptophan synthesis in Escherichia coli. J . Mol. Biol. 11, 747-759. Szentimai, A., Szentirmai, M., and Umbarger, H. E. 1968. Isoleucine and valine metabolism in Escherichia coli. XV. Biochemical properties of mutants resistant to thiaisoleucine. J. Bacteriol. 95, 1672-1679. Taylor, A. L. 1970. Current linkage map of Escherichia coli. Bacteriol. Rev. 34, 155-175.
Umbarger, H. E. 1969. Regulation of the branched-chain amino acids. Curr. Top. Cell. Regul. 1, 57-76. Wallace, B. J., and Pittard, J. 1969. Regulator gene controlling enzymes concerned in tyrosine biosynthesis in Escherichia coli. J. Bacteriol. 97, 1234-1241. Yanofsky, C., and Ito, J. 1966. Nonsense codons and polarity in the tryptophan operon. J. Mol. Biol.21, 313-334.
S-AMINO ACID METABOLISM AND ITS REGULATION IN Escherichia coli AND Salmonella fyphimurium
D. A. Smith Genetics Department, University of Birmingham, England
I. The Enzymes and Genes Involved in the Synthesis of Methionine and Cysteine. . . . . . . . . . . . A. The Synthesis of 0-Succinylhomoserine from Aspartate . . B. The Synthesis of Cysteine from Sulfate . . . . . . C. The Synthesis of Homocysteine . . . . . . . . . D. The Methylation of Homocysteine . . . . . . . . E. Uptake of Methionine . . . . . . . . . . . F. The Fate of Cysteine and Methionine . . . . . . . 11. The Genetic Map Location and Nature of the Structural Genes 111. Regulation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Cysteine Pathway . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Methionine Pathway . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Possible Cysteine and Methionine Regulatory Relationships IV. Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . .
142 144 144 145 146 147 147 147 151 151 152
157 158 161
It is almost unnecessary to say that many lines of work which are now culminating in increasingly deeper understanding of the regulation of anabolic pathways in bacteria were either initiated by Dr. Demerec himself or fostered in his laboratories at Cold Spring Harbor and Brookhaven during the last 15 years of his life. The work on cysteine and methionine synthesis is no exception, and it is a privilege and pleasure to contribute to a memorial volume to one whose influence in many areas of genetics has been so profound. I shall always be proud to acknowledge my personal contact with Dr. Demerec as one of the many who shared with him the exciting experience of working a t Cold Spring Harbor in the mid-l950s, a contact which was sustained by somewhat succinct, pithy, but always helpful occasional correspondence until his death in 1966. The justification for the joint consideration of cysteine and methionine synthesis in bacteria is that convergent rather than divergent pathways and scattered genes rather than neatly defined operons are involved, 141
142
D. A. SMITH
a situation much more akin to that in higher organisms. We restrict our consideration to work with Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium because both the biochemical and the genetical information relevant to regulation is more complete for these microorganisms than for others. I n spite of the obvious attempt to make this review as up-to-date as possible, it really describes only the early and, perhaps, some of the middle stages of this work. The layout of the review is conventional, with biochemical and genetical considerations of the various parts of the pathways initially dealt with separately and then, in terms of regulation, with closer integration. There is inevitably unevenness because as one small area of the overall regulation of S-amino acid synthesis is explored, the paucity of information in other areas becomes only too apparent. A number of related reviews appeared recently. A general account of cysteine synthesis is included in the comprehensive article by Trudinger (1969) ; aspects of the methylation of homocysteine are covered by Weissbach and Taylor (1966) in an account of the role of cobalamin in methionine synthesis. A number of excellent papers on various aspects of regulation appeared in the 1966 volume (33) of the Cold Spring Harbor Symposia on Quuntitative Biology, and Umbarger (1969) has more recently dealt specifically with the regulation of amino acid metabolism. In addition, although an article by de Robichon-Szulmajster (1967) is concerned mainly with the regulation of the two separate but related pathways of synthesis of threonine and methionine and of isoleucine and valine in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, many comparisons with the equivalent bacterial systems are made.
1. The Enzymes and Genes Involved in the Synthesis of Methionine and Cysteine
The known steps in the pathways of synthesis of these two amino acids in 8. typhimurium and E . coli and their utilization are summarized in Fig. 1. Mutants deficient in most of these steps have been isolated and the nature of their defects deduced from the results of enzyme assays and from their growth responses and behavior in cross-feeding experiments, thus permitting the identification of many of the genes involved. Where enzymes have been partially or completely purified, their relevant properties will be described. Biochemical homology between the two organisms is assumed unless an explicit distinction is made. As the pathways of synthesis of O-succinylhomoserine and cysteine
Aspartate
I-l,
P-Aspartyl phosphate
Enzyme
H,R<
Enzyme
T&F Glycine
cysA
* Met1
Serine
tRNA-Protein
cysD
cySC
?
A
cysH
cysllG
................. .......................................... "I
metE
-
t OAS cysE j
Serine
......................................
I
z
I
met met tRNA
FIG.1. An ouhline of the metabolism of S-amino acids in Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium. A list of genes, plus their nomenclature, full and abbreviated, follows. cysA, sulfate permease ; cysC ATP-adenylplsulfate 5'-phosphotransferase-APS kinase or PAPS synthetase; cysD, ATP sulfate adenylyl transferase-ATP sulfurylase or PAPS synthetase ; cysE, serine transacetylase ; cysH, adenosine 3'-phosphate 5'-sulfatophosphate reductme-PAPS reductme ; cysGIJ, hydrogen sulfide NADP oxidoreductase (cysGPQ in E . col)-suliite reductase ; metA, homoserine-0-transsuccinylase ; metB, cystathionine-y-synthehse ; metC, p-cystathionase; metE, N5-methyltetrahydropteroyltriglutamttite-homocysteine transmethylase-cobalamin-independent methylase; metF, N6N'O-methy1tetrahydrofolate reductase-tetrahydrofolate reductase; metG, methionyl-tRNA synthetase; metH, N'-methyltetrahydrofolate homocysteine transmethylase-cobalamin-dependent methylase; metP, methionine permease. APS, adenosine-5sulfatophosphate ; PAPS, adenmine-3-phosphate 5-sulfatosphospha~te; OAS, 0-acetylserine ; H,PteGlu, tetrahydropteroyl monoestablished repression; or triglutamate; SAM, S-adenosylmethionine; ---- +, feedback inhibition; ..... -, induction; x-X-D g ~ g r assumed , repression.
.
144
D. A. SMITH
converge in the formation of cystathionine, the synthesis of these two compounds will be dealt with first. Two further convenient blocks of reactions are those involved in the synthesis of homocysteine from O-succinylhomoserine and cysteine and the alternate routes for the methylation of homocysteine. Although the uptake of methionine is not strictly a step in its synthesis in the sense of the uptake of sulfate in relation to cysteine synthesis, the recent recognition of a methionine-specific transport system in S. typhiinuriurn and one of its structural genes is reported if only for the relevance of this work to the regulation of methionine synthesis. The fate of methionine and cysteine in bacteria while not part of their syntheses is similarly relevant to regulation and so this is discussed as well. OF 0-SUCCINYLHOMOSERINE FROM ASPARTATE A. THESYNTHESIS
p-Aspartokinase catalyzes the phosphorylation of aspartate to yield p-aspartyl phosphate, which is then reduced by aspartate semialdehyde dehydrogenase to give aspartate semialdehyde, the common precursor of lysine, threonine, and isoleucine as well as methionine. The next stage in methionine synthesis is also common to that of threonine and isoleucine synthesis. It is the reduction of aspartate semialdehyde by homoserine dehydrogenase to give homoserine (Stadtman, 1963; Cohen, 1968). I n E. coli K12, p-aspartokinase comprises three (I, 11, and 111) and homoserine dehydrogenase two (I and 11) isofunctional enzymes, each exhibiting different end-product inhibition and repression control. Protein complexes are formed between aspartokinase I and homoserine dehydrogenase I (mol. wt. 300,000) and aspartokinase I1 and homoserine dehydrogenase I1 (mol. wt. 150,000). Complex I1 is absent from E . coli B (Cohen, 1968; Pattk e t al., 1967). Mutants have been isolated with deficiencies for the different components of complex I (one or other or both the aspartokinase and the homoserine dehydrogenase) and also for both components of complexes I and 11, and both components of complex I1 alone or in combination with a defective aspartokinase I11 (Janin e t al., 1967; Patt6 et al., 1967; Richaud and Cohen, 1968). The first specific precursor of methionine, 0-succinylhomoserine, is formed by acylation of homoserine with succinyl coenzyme A by homoserine-0-transsuccinylase (rnet.4) (Rowbury, 1964; Rowbury and Woods, 1964a ; Smith and Childs, 1966).
B. THESYNTHESIS OF CYSTEINE FROM SULFATE Uptake of sulfate involves a specific permease (cys.4) (Dreyfuss, 1964; Ellis, 1966; Howarth, 1958; Mizobuchi et al., 1962), and its subse-
E . coli
AND
S. typhimurium S-AMINO ACID
SYNTHESIS
145
quent activation by ATP is catalyzed by ATP sulfate adenylyl transferase ( c y s D ), resulting in the formation of adenosine 5‘-sulfatophosphate (APS) . A specific kinase, ATP adenylylsulfate 5’-phosphotransferase ( c y s C ), produces a phosphorylated derivative, adenosine 3’-phosphate 5’-sulfatophosphate (PAPS) (Dreyfuss and Monty, 1963; Pasternak, 1962). This is reduced first by PAPS reductase ( c y s H ) to sdfite (Demerec et al., 1963; Dreyfuss and Monty, 1963; Pasternak et al., 1965) and then by hydrogen sulfide NADP oxidoreductase (sulfite reductase) to sulfide. Sulfite reductase involves several gene productsthose of the cysG, I , and J genes in S. typhimurium (Demerec et al., 1963; Dreyfuss and Monty, 1963; Mizobuchi et al., 1962) and the cysG, P , and Q genes in E. coli (Jones-Mortimer, 1968a; Mager, 1960). This complexity is reflected in the structure of the enzyme. It is a large flavin and iron-containing NADPH-dependent complex with a molecular weight of 700,000, capable not only of, catalyzing the reduction of sulfite to hydrogen sulfide, but also that of nitrite and hydroxylamine to ammonia (Kamin et al., 1967; Lazzarini and Atkinson, 1961). The final reaction to give cysteine is that between sulfide and O-acetylserine (OAS) . This convergent step is catalyzed by O-acetylserine sulfhydrylase. No mutants deficient in this enzyme are available. O-Acetylserine is synthesized from acetyl coenzyme A and serine by the cysE enzyme serine transacetylase (Kredich and Tomkins, 1966; Jones-Mortimer et al., 1968). O-Acetylserine sulfhydrylase of S. typhimurium is a dimer of two identical polypeptides of molecular weight 34,000.The molecular weight of serine transacetylase is 160,000; it may consist of two subunits. Cysteine synthase consists of two molecules of sulfhydrylase and one molecule of transacetylase and has a molecular weight of 309,000 (Becker et al., 1969; Kredich et al., 1969).
C. THESYNTHESIS OF HOMOCYSTEINE Homocysteine is the immediate precursor of methionine and it is synthesized in two stages. The succinyl group of O-succinylhomoserine is replaced by cysteine in a reaction catalyzed by cystathionine-y-synthetase (metB) to give the thioether cystathionine (Kaplan and Flavin, 1966a; Rowbury and Woods, 1964b; Smith and Childs, 1966). I n S. typhimurium this enzyme is oligomeric and comprises four identical subunits each of molecular weight 40,000 (Kaplan and Flavin, 1966b). Cystathionine is then hydrolyzed by p-cystathionase (metC) to homocysteine, pyruvate, and ammonia; this enzyme has been only partially purified (Delavier-Klutchko and Flavin, 1965a,b; Rowbury and Woods, 1964b; Smith, 1961; Wijesundera and Woods, 1962).
146
D. A. SMITH
D. THEMETHYLATION OF HOMOCYSTEINE Two sources of methyl groups for this reaction are the methylated derivatives of the folic acid cofactors tetrahydropteroyl monoglutamate (H,PteGlul) or triglutamate (H,PteGlu,). These compounds are synthesized in two steps. First, iV5,,Nt0-methyleneH,PteGlu, or Glu, is formed by the transfer of the hydroxymethyl group from serine by the action of serine hydroxymethyl transferasc (glyA) , glycine being formed as a by-product. The methylene derivatives are then reduced by N5N10methyltetrahydrofolate reductase (metF) to give N5-methyl H,PteGlu, or Glu3 (Cauthen e t al., 1966). There are alternative pathways for the actual methylation of homocysteine (Woods et al., 1964). In one, the enzyme involved, N5-methyltetrahydrofolate homocysteine transmethylase ( m e t H ), is cobalamin-dependent, and either N5-methyl H,PteGlul or Glu3 can serve as a methyl donor (Childs and Smith, 1969; Guest et al., 1964; Katzen and Buchanan, 1965; Taylor and Wcissbach, 1967a,b). It should be mentioned that in E . coli B, Taylor and Weissbach (1967a,b) have shown that S-adenosylmethionine and methyl cobalamin can also act as methyl donors in reactions catalyzed by the same enzyme, a large molecule with a molecular weight of 140,000. The reactions involving N5-methylfolate and S-adenosylmethionine require a reducing system and a methionine synthetase [purified from E . coli K12 by Galivan and Huennekens (1970) ] with a similar requirement consists of two components, designated M and S, with molecular weights of 125,000 and 3000, respectively. I n the other main pathway of methylation, which is independent of cobalamin, only N5-methyl H,PteGlu3 is the methyl donor in a reaction catalyzed by N5-methyltetrahydropteroyltriglutamate-homocysteine transmethylase ( m e t E ) (Cauthen et al., 1966). Using E . coli K12, Whitfield and Weissbach (1968) demonstrated the binding of folate substrate to a purified preparation of this enzyme. Physical studies of a preparation of 94% purity from a derepressed mutant indicated a molecular weight of 80,000 for the enzyme; it could be denatured into subunits of molecular weight 50,000 (Whitfield et al., 1970). M e t E mutants require cobalamin for growth in the absence of methionine (Davis and Mingioli, 1950; Smith, 1961) presumably because they are unable to synthesize enough of it to facilitate function of the cobalamin-dependent metH enzyme. A third way of methylation of homocysteine has been demonstrated in E . coli Texas M by Balish and Shapiro (1967). Either methylmethionine or adenosylmethionine can act as methyl donors ; presumably this methyltransferase requires that either the cobalamin-dependent or independent methylation pathways function normally.
E. coli
AND
S . typhimurium S-AMINOACID
SYNTHESIS
147
E. UPTAKEOF METHIONINE Although a methionine-specific transport system in E. coli K12 has been described by Piperno and Oxender (1968), it has only recently been studied in S. typhimurium (Ayling and Bridgeland, unpublished). Wild-type S. typhimurium grown in the presence of chloramphenicol and methylmethionine-IT at 25OC were sampled a t 15-second intervals over periods of one minute using a membrane filtration technique, and the amount of isotope in whole cells and TCA-precipitable material determined. The results obtained suggested involvement of two permease systems, one with an affinity for methionine 50 times that of the other. Uptake of methionine was significantly reduced by the presence of the analogs a-methylmethionine, ethionine, norleucine, and methionine sulfoximine, at a concentration 1000 times that of methionine, but not by any other amino acids normally occurring in protein at concentrations 100 times that of methionine. Mutants resistant to inhibition by a-methylmethionine and others resistant to both a-methylmethionine and to methionine sulfoximine each possessed a defective high-affinity permease system, the gene for which is designated metP.
F. THBFATE OF CYSTEINEAND METHIONINE Cysteinyl-tRNA and both species of methionyl-tRNA (Bruton and Hartley, 1968) are formed by their respective tRNA synthetases in normal protein synthesis, and the metG gene of S. typhimurium is the structural gene for methionyl-tRNA synthetase as mutants of i t possess a methionyl-tRNA synthetase with a K, for methionine 100-1000 times greater than that of wild-type (Gross and Rowbury, 1969,1970). Cysteine is a component of the tripeptide glutathione and is the source of the sulfhydryl group of such substances as tRNA and biotin. X-Adenosylmethionine (SAM), which is involved in all transmethylation reactions (Cantoni, 1965), is synthesized from methionine by SAM synthetase, and although this reaction has been well studied (Mudd, 1965) it is only recently that mutants of E. coli with low levels of the enzyme have been reported (Green et al., 1970). Methionine is also involved more directly in the synthesis of other substances; for example, it is the source of both the methyl group and the sulfur atom of the thiazole component of thiamin (Johnson et al., 1966). II. The Genetic Map location and Nature of the Structural Genes
On the basis of conjugation and transduction analysis the positions of most of the cys and met genes on the linkage maps of 8.typhimurium
148
D. A. SMITH
and E . coli (Fig. 2) are the same (Sanderson, 1970; Taylor, 1970). The study of both cysteine and methionine mutants of S. typhimurium has been more extensive than in the case of E . coli. Genetical analyses by complete and abortive transduction of large numbers of S. typhimurium mutants have been carried out, resulting not only in more precise mapping but also in shedding light on the structure of some of the enzymes.
FIQ. 2. Part of the linkage map of Salmonella typhimurium. Map positions, 1-138 minutes, are indicated at 20-minute intervals. { = Transduction fragment. { I = Transduction fragment, orientation unknown. ( ) = Precise location unknown. *Equivalent to cysP and Q translocated in E . coli. Gene abbreviations: arg, arginine ; aro, aromatic ; cys, cysteine ; his, histidine, leu, leucine ; met, melthionine; pur, purine; pyr, pyrimidine; rfa, rough; ser, serine; thi, thiamin; trp, tryptophan; trz, triazole resistance.
I n mapping experiments some clustering of related genes in both the cysteine and methionine systems is apparent, but there is no evidence of extensive contiguity as for the histidine (Ames et al., 1967) and tryptophan (Bauerle and Margolin, 1966) genes (Fig. 2). The genes
E. coli
AND
S. typhimurium S-AMINO ACID
SYNTHESIS
149
for APS kinase (cysC) and ATP sulfurylase (cysD) are contiguous, as are two of the sulfite reductase genes ( c y s l and J ) , but although these and the cysH (PAPS reductase) gene are all cotransducible, there are gaps of unknown function, the so-called “silent sections,” between cysCD and H , and cysH and I J . (Clowes, 1958; Demerec et al., 1963; Itikawa and Demerec, 1967; Mizobuchi et al., 1962; Qureshi, personal communication). The cysA (permease), cysE (transacetylase), and another sulfite reductase gene (cysG) are each located in quite different regions of the map. The six methionine structural genes are, if anything, more scattered. M e t A and H , the genes for homoserine-0-transsuccinylase and the cobalamin-dependent transmethylase are cotransducible (Ayling and Chater, 1968; Childs and Smith, 1969), as are metB and F (Smith, 19611, the genes for cystathionine synthetase and tetrahydrofoloate reductase, but in neither case are the pairs of genes likely t o be adjacent. The metC (cystathionase) , metE (cobalamin-independent transmethylase), and metG (methionyl-tRNA synthetase) genes are located separately, and recently the site of mutation of an additional mutant deficient in the cobalamin-dependent methylation of homocysteine has been located in the serA region of the map (Whitehouse, personal communication). The glyA (serine hydroxymethyl transferase) gene is unlinked to any methionine genes (Dalal and Gots, 1965). Complete homology of cys and met gene location in S. typhimurium and E . coli is disturbed in two regions. The linked cys gene sequence is cysCDHIJ in S. typhimuriurn. The cysI and J genes of this organism presumably correspond to cysP and Q in E . col?:,and the sequence most compatible with the results of recent transduction analysis is cysC ( P Q )H , (Jones-Mortimer, personal communication). Also the CYSB gene is located counterclockwise to the trp cluster in S. typhimurium and clockwise in E . coli. M e t P (permease) mutants have been studied only in S. typhimurium; their sites of mutation are located in the leu-purE region of the map (Ayling and Bridgeland, unpublished ; Chater, 1969). It is of interest to consider the results of abortive transduction analysis (Ozeki, 1956) of cysteine (Clowes, 1958; Demerec et al., 1963; Howarth, 1958) and methionine (Childs and Smith, 1969; Smith and Childs, 1966) mutants of S. typhimuriurn in relation to the structure and function of relevant enzymes. C y s A mutants, which comprise three complementation groups, are unable to take up sulfate but they possess normal sulfate-binding properties (N. Ohta an1 A. B. Pardee, personal communication to Jones-Mortimer). A protein able to bind sulfate and of molecular weight 32,000 has been
150
D. A. SMITH
purified by Pardee (1966) ; no sulfate binder negative mutants have been reported and there is no information on the sulfate transport system. Further studies of genetical and biochemical aspects of sulfate uptake could reveal more of an interesting permeability system. The cysC, D, and H enzymes have not been purified; the cysC mutants form two cistrons (Qureshi, personal communication) and the cysD and H mutants one each. Mutants in three different cistrons (cysl, J, and G ) are unable to reduce sulfite to sulfide; cysI and J are adjacent, but cysG is located well away from them. This situation is compatible with the existence of the large sulfite reductase enzyme complex (Kamin et al., 1967). Similarly, the cysE mutants fall into two complementation groups and the cysE enzyme, serine transacetylase, comprises two subunits (Kredich et al., 1969). The purified metB enzyme (cystathionine-y-synthetase) is an oligomer of four identical subunits (Kaplan and Flavin, 196613). This is reflected in the complex pattern of complementation between metB mutants. The complementation map of the metC gene is also complex, suggesting that P-cystathionase may be similer. Another oligomer whose structure is supported by complementation data is the methionyl-tRNA synthetase, although the enzyme, a tetramer with a molecular weight of about 173,000 was purified from E . coli K12 (Lemoine et al., 1968) and the complex pattern of abortive transduction was obtained between metG mutants of S. typhimurium which possess this enzyme in an altered form. A puzzling situation exists with respect to the metE mutants which are unable to carry out the cobalamin-independent methylation of homocysteine. Mutants of each of the two complementation groups I and I1 into which they fall have the same enzyme deficiency (Cauthen et al., 1966). No in witro complementation between mutants of different groups has been detected, but the tetrahydrofolate reductase (metF) activity of group I mutants was twice that of group 11, suggesting a possible regulatory role for some metE mutants. Three complementation groups have been recognized among cobalamin-dependent transmethylase mutants ; two cistrons (met H ) may be adjacent but the site of mutation of the single representative of the other group is probably located a t least 30 minutes from them in the serA region (Fig. 2). As the cobalamin-dependent methylation of homocysteine is catalyzed by an enzyme of high molecular weight (Taylor and Weissbach, 1967a,b), and as there is already evidence that the enzyme required for two of the reactions involved comprises two subunits (Galivan and Huennekens, 1970), further biochemical studies of the different metH mutants should shed more light on the nature and function of what could be an interesting enzyme complex.
E. coli
AND
8 typhimurium S-AMINO ACID
SYNTHESIS
151
111. Regulation
Against the background of apparently identical pathways of cysteine and methionine synthesis involving similar structural genes in E . coli and S. typhimurium, a unified consideration of regulation of the pathways in both organisms is probably justified, although in some cases different aspects have been studied with different organisms. Regulation will be considered in relation to the cysteine and methionine pathways separately and then in terms of their possible inter-relationship. An indication of established feedback inhibition, repression, and induction is incorporated in Fig. 1.
A. CYSTEINEPATHWAY The activity of the sulfate transport system of E. coli (Ellis, 1966) and of serine transacetylase, the cysE enzyme of both E . coli and S. typhimurium (Kredich and Tomkins, 1966), are subject to inhibition by cysteine. I n addition to this fine control, the syntheses of all the other cysteine enzymes are repressed by cysteine although this repression is not coordinate (Dreyfuss and Monty, 1963; Kredich and Tomkins, 1966; Mager, 1960; Pasternak, 1962; Pasternak et al., 1965; Wheldrake and Pasternak, 1965). On the other hand, OAS is required for the cysA (sulfate permease) and cysD (ATP sulfurylase) enzymes and the sulfite reductase complex (Jones-Mortimer et al., 1968). Pleiotropic cysB and cysE mutants of E. coli K12 which do not synthesize any of the cysteine-repressible enzymes have been identified and studied by Jones-Mortimer (1968a,b). CysB+is dominant to a pleiotropic negative mutant allele in heterozygotes, thus strongly suggesting positive control of sulfate activation and reduction in cysteine synthesis. The product of the cysE gene (serine transacetylase), is necessary for the synthesis of OAS, which induces the cysteine enzymes, so it would seem that both the cysBCgene product and OAS are necessary for induction. Essentially similar results have been reported by Spencer et al. (1967) from work with cysteine mutants of S. typhimurium. Another approach to the regulation of cysteine synthesis may be developing through study of mutants resistant to the inhibitory effects of selenate, which prevents sulfate activation in E. coli (Pasternak, 1962). Although the sites of mutation of these mutants are 90% contransduced with cysA, the permease gene, they are not deficient in this structural gene but are derepressed at least for sulfite reductase (D. Hulanicka, personal communication). Studies of the nature of the inhibitory effects of triazole on wild-type
152
D. A. SMITH
S. typhimurium and the properties of mutants resistant to this inhibition could shed further light on the regulation of cysteine synthesis (Hulanicka, unpublished). She found that triazole does not inhibit the activity of any of the cysteine enzymes in vitro but that extracts of wild-type organisms grown in medium supplem.ented with triazole and OAS show very low cysteine enzyme activities as compared with similar extracts from organisms grown in the presence of OAS alone. It is suggested that triazole interferes with the induction of cysteine enzymes by OAS. Neither the sulfate permease nor the PAPS synthetase of triazole resistant mutants (trzA) is derepressed, whereas induction of these enzymes by OAS is unaffected by triazole. Cotransduction (50%) of trzA mutants with the cysA (permease) gene has been obtained, and the wild-type trzA+ allele is dominant to trzA in partial diploids. It could be that uptake of triazole is defective in trzA mutants, thus eliminating an assumed intracellular competition between triazole and OAS for some site of interaction with the cysB+ gene product. On the other hand triazole may still enter trzA mutants but fail to interact with a cysB+ gene product whose configuration had been altered as a result of the trzA mutation, i.e., perhaps the key activating molecule is a polymer comprising trzA+and cysB+components. B. METHIONINEPATHWAY 1. Feedback Inhibition
The activity of the metA enzyme homoserine-0-transsuccinylase is subject to feedback inhibition by methionone and its derivative, S-adenosylmethionine, either separately or, more effectively, in combination (Rowbury, 1964; D. A. Lawrence, unpublished; Lee et al., 1966). False feedback inhibition is achieved by the analog a-methylmethionine which is unable to replace methionine in protein synthesis and whose addition to cultures of both E . coli and S. typhimurium rapidly inhibits their growth (Lawrence et al., 1968; Rowbury, 1968; Schlesinger, 1967; Smith, 1968). Mutants of S. typhimurium resistant to inhibition by a-methylmethionine were repressible by methionine but overproduced it. They were originally designated metI mutants (Lawrence et al., 1968). These authors found that metI sites of mutation were greater than 95% cotransducible with metA. A complem.entation test in appropriate partial diploids showed that metI was dominant to metI+ only when coupled in the cis-position with metA+ (Chater and Rowbury, 1970). The same authors also showed that a careful deletion analysis of eight metI mutants indicated that their sites of mutation were located in a t least three
E . coli
AND
S. typhimurium S-AMINO ACID
SYNTHESIS
153
different regions within the metA gene. In addition, D. A. Lawrence (personal communication) has shown that the homoserine-0-transsuccinylase activity in cell-free extracts of four metI mutants was insensitive to inhibition by either a-methylmethionine or methionine; finally, Smith and Childs (1966) failed to detect complementation in paired combinations of 38 metA mutants. The overall conclusion is that metA is another example of a gene which codes for a single polypeptide species (homoserine-O-transsuccinylase) which includes both catalytic and regulatory sites. With this in mind, the metI designation has now been dropped; all feedback-resistant mutants have been given a metA number. It should be noted that the hisG feedback-resistant mutant situation is similar but that the sites of mutation are clustered in particular regions of the hisG gene (Sheppard, 1964). d. Repression
The information of relevance to the control of the synthesis of the methionine enzymes concerned with the direct pathway from aspartate to homocyteine is much more precise than that relating to regulation of the subsequent complex alternative pathways of methylation of homocysteine (see Fig. 1 ) . One of the reasons for this is that in the published genetical regulation work on this system (Lawrence et al., 1968) the enzymes of this last stage have been assayed as a unit “methylase complex” in contrast to the individual assays carried out for the other enzymes. Despite this reservation, some clear deductions about methionine regulation are permissible. These will be presented first and then the early stages of an analysis of the interplay and regulation of the various enzymes concerned with the methylation of homocysteine in relation to their substrates and products will be discussed separately. Regulation of the methionine enzymes is apparently similar in wildtype E. coli and S. typhimurium. The syntheses of the methionine-specific p-aspartokinase and homoserine dehydrogenase of complex I1 (Patt6 et al., 1967; Pattk et al., 1963; Rowbury et al., 1968), and homoserineO-transsuccinylase, cystathionine-7-synthetase,p-cystathionase, and the homocysteine methylase complex (Rowbury, 1964; Rowbury and Woods, 1961, 196413, 1966), are all repressed by methionine, although, as would be anticipated in a scattered gene system, this repression is not ccjordinate (Lawrence et al., 1968). MetJ and metK mutants of S. typhimurium described by Lawrence et al., (1968) possess regulatory defects. They were originally isolated as resistant to inhibition by methionine analogs; metJ mutants are resistant only to ethionine, and metK mutants to ethionine, a-methyl-
154
D. A. SMITH
methionine, and norleucine. All nietJ mutants grow slightly more slowly than wild-type organisms in minimal medium, overproduce methionine, and have derepressed and nonrepressible levels of methionine enzymes. MetK mutants fall into two groups. Some overproduce methionine and are very similar to metJ mutants, differing only in their very slow growth rate in normal medium. Others do not excrete methionine and their regulatory abnormalities are less well marked. (All enzymes except homoserine-O-transsuccinylase have been assayed.) The sites of mutation of all metJ and metK mutants are each located in separate clusters, those of metJ being close to the metB gene and those of metK loosely linked to the serA gene (Ayling and Chater, 1968; Lawrence et al., 1968). Suppression of metG mutants which possess a methionyl-tRR’A synthetase with a high K, for methionine by metJ and metK mutations (but, curiously, not by feedback-insensitive metA mutations) is thought to reflect a high intracellular methionine concentration in these double mutants (Chater et al., 1970). Partial diploids established by the transfer of F’ factors carrying metJ+ and metK+ from E. coli to metJ and metK mutants, respectively, of 8. typhimurium were sensitive to the relevant analogs. Cystathionase (metC) activity was then assayed in these merodiploids and showed normal methionine repressibility, i.e., the wild-type alleles were dominant (Chater, 1970). From these results it can be concluded that the overall regulation of methionine synthesis is by negative (repression) control involving the metJ and K gene products. The recent isolation of metJ and metK mutants revertible by nonsense suppressors (Minson, personal communication), is evidence that these products are likely to be proteins. Do either or both of these genes code for the aporepressor itself or components of it, and what is the most likely corepressor? Chater (1970) cites three observations in support of the metJ protein being the aporepressor. First, one mutant metJ allele was not completely recessive to metJ+ whereas all three metK alleles tested were recessive to metK+. This suggests that the metJ protein may be oligomeric and that the incompletely recessive allele may produce a subunit capable of interacting with and thus inactivating wild-type subunits, a situation similar to that of the lac aporepressor of E. coli (Miiller-Hill et al., 1968). Second, a metJ mutant obtained by D. A. Lawrence (unpublished) was found by Chater (1969) to possess a partially derepressed cystathionase activity, whether grown in the presence or absence of methionine, suggesting the possession by this strain of a methionine aporepressor whose conformation is unaffected by the corepressor but which retains some regulatory activity. Third, ethionine inhibits growth by replacing methionine in
E. coli
AND
S . typhimurium S-AMINOACID
SYNTHESIS
155
protein synthesis (Spizek and Janecek, 1969) ; metJ mutants are resistant only to ethionine and all overproduce methionine so, presumably, their possession of a defective aporepressor results in a high intracellular concentration of methionine which competes successfully with ethionine for incorporation into protein. In contrast, all metK mutants are resistant to a-methylmethionine as well as ethionine and they do not all overproduce methionine, indicating a different regulatory defect (Lawrence, et al., 1968; Chater, 1970). What of the role of the metK protein? The resistance of metK mutants to a-methylmethionine could result from altered feedback sensitivity, Le., an alteration in a component of homoserine-0-transsuccinylase, but if that was so, resistance would have been dominant to sensitivity (unless the original mutation had been an amber mutation) but in any case it has been shown that this enzyme is sensitive to feedback inhibition in cell suspensions of a metK mutant (Chater and Rowbury, 1970). On the basis of an apparent defect in the uptake of ethionine-I4C by metK in contrast to metJ organisms, Lawrence et al. (1968) suspected a permeability defect, but the rate of uptake of methionine-14C is unaffected by a metK mutation and the metP gene for the high affinity permease is located far from metK (Ayling and Bridgeland, unpublished). Finally, the suggestion by Lawrence et al., (1968) that metK was involved in the synthesis of methionyl-tRNA is eliminated because the metG gene for methionyl-tRNA synthetase has been identified and is also located away from the metK gene, and metG mutants possess normal methionine repressibility (Gross and Rowbury, 1969, 1970). Perhaps as Chater (1970) suggests, the fate of methionine in, for example, the synthesis of X-adenosylmethionine (SAM), is relevant in considering the metK gene. SAM can act cooperatively with methionine as a feedback inhibitor of homoserine-0-transsuccinylase (Lee et al., 1966) and if SAM is also involved in repression control, mutants with defects in SAM synthetase could be resistant to both a-methylmethionine and ethionine, and might well grow more slowly than wild-type organisms. If metK mutants do possess a SAM synthetase deficiency it is difficult although not impossible to accommodate the feedback sensitivity of their homoserine-0-transsuccinylase (Chater and Rowbury, 1970), but the existence of SAM synthetase deficient mutants of E . coli K12 which are ethionine resistant and possess high levels of cystathionine synthetase and cystathionase and of intracellular methionine (Green et al., 1970) strengthens the case for S. typhimurium metK mutants possessing a similar deficiency. On the other hand, in preliminary experiments, Gross and Rowbury (personal communication) found no evidence of SAM synthetase deficiency in metJ or K regulatory mutants.
156
D. A. SMITH
Very recently Su et al. (1970) reported the isolation of mutants of E. coli K12 similar to the metJ mutants of S. typhimurium. They were constitutive for SAM synthetase as well as methionine enzymes, their sites of mutation were cotransduced at high frequency with metB, and the mutant alleles were recessive in diploids, thus underlining the implication of SAM in methionine regulation and keeping open a possibility that metJ may be the SAM synthetase gene. Concerning the nature of the corepressor, the wild-type repressibility of methionine enzymes of metG mutants with an altered methionyltRNA synthetase (Gross and Rowbury, 1969, 1970) and the normal methionyl-tRNA synthetase and methionyl-tRNA of metJ and metK mutants (Gross and Rowbury, unpublished) eliminate serious consideration of methionyl-tRNA as the corepressor. Does this only leave methionine as the most likely corepressor? If the properties of the SAM synthetase deficient mutants of E. coEi K12 (Greene et al., 1970) are taken into account some doubt about this must be retained because these mutants with their high levels of intracellular methionine nevertheless have elevated rather than repressed levels of methionine enzymes ; this could implicate SAM as the corepressor. The further work with the SAM synthetase constitutive mutants (Su et al., 1970) is also compatible with this hypothesis. Thus, in the negative repression control of methionine synthesis, the metJ protein appears to be the aporepressor but the nature of the corepressor is unresolved; it may be methionine or SAM. If it is SAM, the metK or possibly the metJ protein may facilitate the regulatory function of this compound. Concerning the methylation of homocysteine, some uncertainty exists as to which enzyme or enzymes were being assayed in the regulation work described so far, as the overall conversion of homocysteine to methionine was measured. A candidate for a rate-limiting role is the tetrahydrafolate reductase (metF) enzyme which controls the formation of the methyl donors for both the cobalamin-dependent and independent pathways. Certainly this enzyme was earlier reported to be more sensitive to methionine repression than the cobalamin-independent transmethylase (metE) enzyme. (Foster et al., 1963). However, some involvement of cobalamin itself in methylase activity seemed likely from the observation of Lawrence et al. (1968) that extracts of wild-type and regulatory mutants of S. typhimurium gave lower levels of methylase activity assayed in the presence of cobalamin than in its absence. I n further studies of the rate-limiting steps in methylation, J. Dawes and M. A. Foster (personal communication) have shown that cobalamin represses both the metF and the metE enEymes, and also that in the presence
E. coli
AND
S. typhimurium S-AMINO ACID
SYNTHESIS
157
of cobalamin the metF enzyme is rate limiting but in its absence the metE enzyme assumes this role. Also Milner et al. (1969) have evidence that the synthesis of the metE enzyme is repressed and that the synthesis of the metH enzyme, the remaining component of the methylase complex, is activated by cobalamin. Although the tetrahydrofolate reductase levels differ in mutants defective in the cobalamin-dependent transmethylase, they are in general lower than in wild-type (Whitehouse, personal communication), which could indicate a reductase regulatory abnormality. All this evidence could indicate that cobalamin is involved directly in the regulation of the methylation of homocysteine. The situation is further complicated by observations of Cauthen et al. (1966) that extracts of cobalamin-independent transmethylase mutants of one of the two metE complementation groups possessed very low levels of metF reductase; the possible regulatory significance of this has not been explored. Also Whitehouse (personal communication) has carried out enzyme assays on extracts of a recently recognized mutant with an otherwise wild-type phenotype whose growth is stimulated by serine. This is almost certainly due to a deficiency of C, units necessary for the formation of N”N’O-methylene H,PteGlu, (Fig. 1). She found that this mutant also has a reduced level of tetrahydrofolate reductase (metF) bringing out the importance in regulation of the intracellular concentration of these C, units. Finally, the discovery of S. typhimurium mutants physiologically and genetically similar to metJ mutants which can suppress a deficiency in the metH enzyme (Smith, unpublished) may indicate a firm relationship between the overall regulation of the methionine pathway and the cobalamin-dependent transmethylation of homocysteine. There could be interesting similarities between these mutants and those of E. coli K12 which are derepressed for SAM synthetase (Su et al., 1970).
C. POSSIBLE CYSTEINEI AND METHIONINE REGULATORY RELATIONSHIPS There is no evidence that cysteine represses the synthesis of methionine enzymes although it can inhibit some of them (Rowbury, personal communication ; Rowbury et al., 1968 Wijesundera and Woods, 1962). Ellis et al. (1964) showed that methionine does not repress the cysteine enzymes of sulfate activation except in the presence of sulfate, and JonesMortimer ( 1968 ~ )found that this repression did not occur in mutants unable to reduce sulfite, suggesting that endogenous cysteine (rather than exogenous methionine) is responsible for this control. This view was confirmed by the observation of Wheldrake (1967) that the intracellular cysteine concentration is greater in wild-type cells grown in the
158
D. A. SMITH
presence of both sulfate and methionine than in the presence of sulfate alone. The observation of Hulanicka (personal communication) that methionine enhances the inhibitory effect of selenate in both wild-type and selenate-resistant mutants is also compatible with this hypothesis. Another line of work which sustains interest in the effect of these two related amino acids on each other’s synthesis and activity is being carried out by Qureshi (personal communication). He is studying a number of mutants (CYM) of S. typhimurium able to grow equally well in the presence of cysteine or methionine as their sole source of sulfur. The protein of these CYM mutants after growth on r n e t h i ~ n i n e - ~con~S tains no c y ~ t e i n e - ~ ~thus S , eliminating direct conversion of methionine into cysteine. Inhibition of the growth of CYM mutants by selenate is overcome by cysteine but not methionine, indicating that the cysteine enzymes are functioning during the growth of these mutants on methionine. On the results of complete and abortive transduction experiments with CYM mutants they fell into 7 distinct groups. Single groups were each located within the cysCD region and the cysH, I, and J genes, respectively; two groups were contransduced with the cysA gene, and another is as yet unmapped. CYM mutants whose sites of mutation were located within the cysCD region lacked the relevant cysteine enzyme, PAPS synthetase, and, similarly, those in the cysl and J regions lacked sulfite reductase. Does the growth response of CYM mutants to methionine result from a sparing effect on their intracellular cysteine requirements (see Fig. 1) ? If this was so they should possess leaky cysteine enzyme deficiencies, but the PAPS synthetase or sulfite reductase levels in CYM mutants were similar to those of non-leaky cysC and D or cysI and J mutants, respectively. Also, in titration experiments, the minimum amount of methionine to support maximum growth both of a CYM mutant and wild-type organisms in sulfur-free minimal medium was the same. For the moment the conclusion is that these mutants possess neither normal structural nor regulatory properties ; perhaps mutation at certain sites in cysteine genes results in an enzyme requiring activation by methionine. IV. Conclusions
I n broad summary the pathways of synthesis of cysteine and methionine in E . coli and S. typhimurium and the way in which they relate to each other are well established. Large numbers of mutants with clearly identified structural gene defects and also some with regulatory defects are available. Although some groups of related structural genes are lo-
E. coli
AND
S. typhimurium S-AMINO ACID
SYNTHESIS
159
cated close enough to be cotransduced there is limited clustering, only two pairs of the 17 known structural genes being actually contiguous. Some understanding of the regulation of the methionine and cysteine parts of the pathway has been obtained. I n addition to feedback controls, the synthesis of cysteine enzymes is under positive control and for the methionine enzymes as a whole, negative control has been demonstrated. I n neither case is this control coordinate. One cysteine and two methionine regulatory genes have been recognized ; the probable methionine aporepressor gene is adjacent to one of the methionine structural genes. There is no evidence that cysteine affects the synthesis of methionine enzymes and the effect of methionine on cysteine enzymes is probably an indirect biochemical one. The existence of mutants with cysteine structural gene deficiencies but able to utilize methionine as their sole source of sulfur and the effect of methionine on the specific inhibition of cysteine enzymes could indicate some other form of interrelationship. Future study of the systems as a whole requires that many deficiencies are made good. Although mutants of E. coli which lack components of the p-aspartokinase and homoserine dehydrogenase exist (Janin et al., 1967; Patt6 et al., 1967; Richaud and Cohen, 1968) no genetical analysis of them has been reported. Thus the relationship between the p-aspartokinase and homoserine dehydrogenase genes and those concerned with methionine (and, for that matter, threonine and isoleucine) synthesis has not been worked out. Sulfate-binder negative, O-acetylserine sulfhydrylase, and cysteinyl-tRNA synthetase mutants are required to make the collection of cysteine mutants fully comprehensive, but OAS sulfhydryalse mutants might well accumulate intracellular sulfide a t a toxic level so that they would be inviable (Jones-Mortimer, personal communication). I n relation to the later stages of methionine synthesis (and perhaps its overall regulation) S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) synthetase-deficient mutants of S. typhimurium should be identified or sought; they should be ethionine-resistant (Greene et al., 1970) a phenotype which would permit genetical analysis. As SAM is a methyl donor in the cobalamin-dependent methylation of homocysteine, assays of SAM synthetase in each of the different types of metH mutants might be profitable. With respect to the uptake of methionine, the isolation of mutants defective in the low affinity permease could be achieved by isolation of a frameshift, nonsense, or deletion metP (high-affinity permease) mutant, coupling it with a metE mutation so that the double mutant will respond to either methionine or cobalamin, and then isolating from this a mutant unable to utilize methionine (Ayling and Bridgeland, personal communication). At the purely genetical level the precise location of the metH site
160
D. A. SMITH
in the serA region of the S. typhimurium map and the metP gene in the leu-purE region is desirable and so is the position of the unmapped CYM sites of mutation. It should be noted that mapping work with cys mutants of E . coli and S. typhimurium has revealed further differences between them in gene sequence (Sanderson, 1970; Taylor, 1970). The relative positions of the cysP and Q genes in E . coli (equivalent to cysI and J in S. typhimurium) with respect to cysC appear to result from a translocation with or without inversion. With regard to regulation, the unequivocal recognition and study of mutants derepressed for cysteine synthesis seems a high priority, and a preliminary report of such mutants has appeared (Spencer et al., 1967). Further information may come from work with selenate- and triazole(trzA)-resistant mutants. A search for suitable analogs of cysteine to permit a similar approach to that made in the methionine system has not yet been successful (Jones-Mortimer, personal communication) . The role of the metJ and K proteins in methionine regulation needs to be clarified, especially against the background of apparently conflicting results concerning their relationship to SAM ; in particular, assays of SAM synthetase measuring K,,, and V,,,, should be carried out. An interesting extension of the work with metJ and K mutants could be the isolation of superrepressed mutants which would be more sensitive to inhibition by methionine analogs than wild-type organisms if, as seems to be the case, resistance to inhibition by the analogs is related to the intracellular concentration of methionine. Detailed knowledge of the regulation of the methylation of homocysteine is minimal. The part played by cobalamin needs further exploration, preferably with mutants altered in their response to this compound. Other potentially interesting approaches could be through further studies of the regulatory abnormalities of some metE and H mutants and a better understanding of the nature of the mutation resulting in stimulation of growth by serine and the accompanying effects of the intracellular concentration of C, units vital for methylation. Genetical studies of the homocysteine transmethylation in which methylmethionine and adenosylmethionine act as methyl donors and which is inducible by homocysteine (Balish and Shapiro, 1967) could add an extra dimension to this work. Perhaps the most outstanding requirement is for operator constitutive cysteine and methionine mutants but their isolation will require unique techniques as yet undevised although seriously contemplated. The recent successful isolation of such mutants in the arginine scattered gene system of E . coli is an encouragement and stimulus (Jacoby and Gorini, 1969; Karlstrom and Gorini, 1969). The CYM mutants are a puzzle and the results of current experiments
E. coli
AND
S. typhimurium S-AMINO ACID
SYNTHESIS
161
designed to test methionine activation of altered cysteine enzymes to confirm or deny this hypothesis are awaited. In the context of the relationship between control of cysteine and methionine synthesis, it could be of interest to study the effect of coupling a methionine regulatory and a CYM mutation in the same organism (Jones-Mortimer, personal communication).
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This review could not have been put together without the willing communication of unpublished results and comments on the manuscript by Drs. P. D. Ayling, E. Bridgeland, M. C. Jones-Mortimer, and Mr. M. A. Qureshi and Mrs. Julie Whitehouse of the Genetics Department, Birmingham University; Dr. A. C. Minson of the Virology Department, Birmingham University; Dr. K . F. Chater of the John Innes Institute, Norwich; Dr. R. J. Rowbury of the Botany Department, University College, London; and Dr. T. S. Gross, of the Genetics Department, Sheffield University; Dr. M. A. Foster and Mrs. Joan Dawes of the Microbiology Unit, Department of Biochemistry, Oxford University; and finally, Dr. D. Hulanicka, of the Institute of Biochemistry and Biophysics, Warsaw. I would like to thank all of them and hope that they feel that an appropriate commentary on enjoyable and fruitful collaboration has been achieved. Financial support by the Science Research Council, both in the form of a research grant to the author and Research Studentships to Ph.D. students, and by the Wellcome Trust for a Research Scholarship is also gratefully acknowledged.
REFERENCES Ames, B. N., Goldberger, R. F., Hartman, P. E., Martin, R. G., and Roth, J. R. 1967. The histidine operon. I n “Regulation of Nucleic acid and Protein Synthesis” (V. V. Konigsberger and L. Bosch, eds.) Elsevier, Amsterdam. Ayling, P. D., and Chater, K. F. 1968. The sequence of four structural and two regulatory genes in the Salmonella typhimnrium linkage map. Genet. Res. 12, 341-354.
Balish, E., and Shapiro, S. K. 1967. Methionine biosynthesis in Escherichia coZi: Induction and repression of methylmethionine (or adenosyl methionine) homocysteine methyltransferase. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 119, 62-68. Bauerle, R. H., and Margolin, P. 1966. The functional organization of the tryptophan gene cluster in Salmonella typhimurium. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. US. 56, 111-118. Bccker, M. A,, Kredich, N. M., and Tomkins, G. M. 1969. The purification and characterization of 0-acetylserine sulphydrylase-A from Salmonella typhimurium. J . Biol. Chem. 244, 2418-2427. Bruton, C. J., and Hartley, B. S. 1968. Subunit structure and specificity of methionyl-transfer-ribonucleic acid synthetase from Escherichia coli. Biochem. J . 108, 281-288.
Cantoni, G. L. 1965 S-Adenosylmethionine revisited. In “Transmethylation and Methionine Biosynthesis” (S. K. Shapiro and F. Schlenk, eds.), Univ. of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois. Cauthen, Sally E., Foster, M. A., and Woods, D. D. 1966. Methionine synthesis by extracts of Salmonella typhimzirium. Biochem. J . 98, 63C635.
162
D. A. SMITH
Chater, K. F. 1969. Linkage and dominance studies of genes controlling methionine synthesis in Salmonella typhimurium. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Birmingham. Chater, K. F. 1970. Dominance of the wild-type alleles of methionine regulatory genes in Salmonella typhimurium. J. Gen. Microbiol. 63, 95-109. Chater, K. F.,and Rowbury, R. J. 1970. A genetical study of the feed-back sensitive enzyme of methionine synthesis in Salmonella typhimurium. J. Gen. Microbiol. 63, 111-120. Chater, K. F., Lawrence, D. A., Rowbury, R. J., and Gross, T. S. 1970. Suppression of methionyl-transfer RNA synthetase mutants of Salmonella typhimurium by methionine regulatory mutation. J. Gen. Microbiol. 63, 121-131. Childs, J. D., and Smith, D. A. 1969. New methionine structural gene in Salmonella typhimurium. J. Bacteriol. 100, 377-381. Clowes, R. C. 1958. Investigation of the genetics of cysteineless mutants of Salmonella typhimurium. J. Gen. Microbiol. 18, 154-172. Cohen, G. N. 1968. “The Regulation of Cell Metabolism” New York. Holt, New York. Dalal, F. R., and Gots, J. S. 1965. Glycine auxotrophs of Salmonella typhimurium. Bacteriol. Proc. p. 89. Davis, B. D., and Mingioli, E. S. 1950. Mutants of Escherichia coli requiring methionine or vitamin BIZ.J. Bacteriol. 80, 17-28. Delavier-Klutchko, C., and Flavin, M. 1965a. Role of a bacterial cystathionine p-cleavage enzyme in disulphide decomposition. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 99, 375-377. Delavier-Kutchko, C., and Flavin, M. 1965b. Role of a cystathionine @-cleavage enzyme in potassium transport. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 99, 377-380. Demerec, M., Gillespie, D. H., and Mizobuchi, K. 1963. Genetic structure of the cysC region of the Salmonella genome. Genetics 48, 997-1009. de Robichon-Szulmajster, H. 1967. RBgulation du fonctionnement de deux chaines de biosynthsse chez Saccharomyces cerevkiae. : threonine-methionine e t isoleucine-valine. Bull. SOC.Chim. Biol. 49, 1431-1462. Dreyfuss, J. 1964. Characterization of a sulphate and thiosulphate transporting system in Salmonella typhimurium. J. Biol. Chem. 239, 2292-2297. Dreyfuss, J., and Monty, K. J. 1963. The biochemical characterisation of cysteinerequiring mutants of SalmoneEla typhimurium. J. Biol. Chem. 238, 1019-1024. Ellis, R. J. 1966. Sulphur metabolism : the usefulness of N-ethyl-maleimide. Nature (London) 211, 1266-1268. Ellis, R. J., Humphries, S. K., and Pasternak, C. A. 1964. Repressors of sulphate activation in Escherichia coli. Biochem. J. 92, 167-172. Foster, M. A., Rowbury, R. J., and Woods, D. D. 1963. Control of the methylation of homocysteine in Escherichia coZi. J. Gen. Miciobiol. 31, xix. Galivan, J., and Huennekens, F. M. 1970. Resolution of the methionine synthetase system from Eschen’chia coli K12. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 38, 46-51. Greene, R. C., Su, Ching-Hsiang, and Holloway, C. T. 1970. S-Adenosyl methionine synthetase deficient mutants of Escherichia coli K12 with impaired control of methionine biosynthesis. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 38, 1120-1126. Gross, T. S., and Rowbury, R. J. 1969. Methionyl-transfer RNA synthetase mutants of Salmonella typhimurium which have normal control of the methionine biosynthetic enzymes. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 184, 233-236. Gross, T. S., and Rowbury, R. J. 1970. Biochemical and physiological properties of methionyl sRNA synthetase mutants of Salmonella typhimurium J . Gen. Microbiol. (in press).
E. coli
AND
S. typhimurium S-AMINO ACID
SYNTHESIS
163
Guest, J. R., Friedman, S., Foster, M. A., Tejerina, G., and Woods, D. D. 1964. Transfer of the methyl group from N5-methyltetrahydrofolates to homocysteine in E. coli. Biochem. J. 92, 497-504. Howarth, S. 1958. Suppressor mutations in some cysteine-requiring mutants of Salmonella typhimurium. Genetics 43, 404-418. Itikawa, H., and Demercc, M. 1967. Ditto deletions in the cysC region of the Salmonella chromosome. Genetics 55, 63-68. Jacoby, G. A., and Gorini, L. 1969. A unified account of the repression mechanism of arginine biosynthesis in Escherichia coli. I. The genetic evidence. J. Mol. Biol. 39, 73-87. Janin, J., Truffa-Bachi, D., and Cohen, G. N. 1967. Subunits of the complex protein carrying the threonine-sensitive aspartokinase activity in a mutant of Escherichia coli K12. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 26, 429-434. Johnson, D. B., Howells, D. J., and Goodwin, T. W. 1966. Observations on the biosynthesis of thiamine in yeast. Biochem. J. 98, 30-37. Jones-Mortimer, M. C. 1968a. Positive control of sulphate reduction in Escherichia coli. Isolation, characterization and mapping of cysteineless mutants of E. cox K12. Biochem. J . 110, 595-602. Jones-Mortimer, M. C. 196813. Positive control of sulphate reduction in Escherichia coli. The nature of the pleiotropic cysteineless mutants of E. coli K12. Biochem. J . 110, 597402. Jones-Mortimer, M. C. 1968c. Sulphur metabolism in micro-organisms. D. Phil. Thesis, University of Oxford. Jones-Mortimer, M. C., Wheldrake, J. F., and Pasternak, C. A. 1968. The control of sulphate reduction in Escherichia coli by 0-acetyl-L-serine. Biochem. J . 107, 51-53. Kamin, H., Masters, B. S. S., Siegel, L. M., Vorhaben, J. E., and Gibson, Q. H. 1967. Stopped flow studies of NADPH-flavoprotein interaction. Abstr. 7th Znt. Congr. Biochem, Tokyo pp. 187-188. Kaplan, M. M., and Flavin, M. 1966a. Cystathionne-ysynthetase of Salmonella. Catalytic properties of a new enzyme in bacterial methionine synthesis. J. Biol. Chem. 241, 4463-4471. Kaplan, M. M., and Flavin, M. 1966b. Cystathionine-y-synthetase of Salmonella. Structural properties of a new enzyme in bacterial methionine biosynthesis. J . Biol. Chem. 241, 5781-5789. Karlstrom, O., and Gorini, L. 1969. A unified account of the repression mechanism of arginine biosynthesis in Escherichia coli. 11. Application to the physiological evidence. J. Mol. Biol. 39, 89-94. Katzen, H. M., and Buchanan, J. M. 1965. Enzymatic synthesis of the methyl group of methionine. J . Biol. Chem. 240, 825435. Kredich, N. M., and Tomkins, G. M. 1966. The enzyme synthesis of L-cysteine in Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium. J . Biol. Chem. 41, 49554965. Kredich, N. M., Becker, M. A,, and Tomkins, G. M. 1969. Purification and characterization of cysteine synthetase, a bifunctional protein complex, from SaZmonella typhimurium. J . Biol. Chem. 244,2428-2439. Lawrence, D. A,, Smith, D. A,, and Rowbury, R. J. 1968. Regulation of methionine synthesis in Salmonella typhimurium: mutants resistant to inhibition by analogues of methionine. Genetics 58, 473-492. Lazzarini, R. A., and Atkinson, D. E. 1961. A triphosphopyridine nucleotide specific nitrite reductase from Escherichia coli. J. Bwl. Chem. 236, 3330-3335.
164
D. A. SMITH
Lee, L. W., Ravel, J. M., and Shive, W. 1966. Multimetabolite control of a biosynthetic pathway by sequential metabolites. J. Biol. Chem. 241, 5479-5480. Lemoine, F., Waller, J. P., and van Rapenbusch, R. 1968. Studies on methionyl-transfer RNA synthetase from Escherichia coli K12. Eur. J . Biochem. 4,213-221. Mager, J. 1960. A TPNH-linked sulfite reductase and its relation to hydroxylamine in enterobacteriaceae. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 41, 553-555. Milner, L., Whitfield, C., and Weissbach, H. 1969. Effect of L-methionine and vitamin BS on methionine synthesis in Escherichia coli. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 133, 413419. Mizobuchi, K., Demerec, M., and Gillespie, D. H. 1962. Cysteine mutants of Salmonella typhimurium. Genetics 47, 1617-1627. Mudd, S. H. 1965. The mechanism of the enzymatic synthesis of S-adenosylmethionine. I n “Transmethylation and Methionine Biosynthesis” (S. K. Shapiro, and F. Schlenk, eds.), Univ. of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois. Miiller-Hill, B., Crapo, L., and Gilbert, W. 1968. Mutants that make more lac repressor. Proc. Nut. Acad. Sci. U.S. 59, 1259-1264. Ozeki, H. 1956. Abortive transduction in purine-requiring mutants of &Salmonella typhimurium. Carnegie Inst. Wash. Publ. 612, 97-106. Pardee, A. B. 1966. Purification and properties of a sulphate-binding protein from Salmonella typhimurium. J . Biol. Chem. 2-41, 5886-5892. Pasternak, C. A. 1962. Sulphate activation and its control in Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis. Biochem. J . 85, 44-49. Pasternak, C. A., Ellis, R. J., Jones-Mortimer, M. C., and Crichton, C. E. 1965. The control of sulphate reduction in bacteria. Biochem. J. 96, 270-275. Patte, J. C., Le Bras, G., Loviny, T., and Cohen, G. N. 1963. Retroinhibition et repression de I’homoserine deshydrogenase d’Escherichia coli. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 67, 16-30. Pat%, J. C., Le Bras, G., and Cohen, G. N. 1967. Regulation by methionine of the synthesis of a third aspartokinase and a second homoserine dehydrogenase in Escherichia coli K12. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 136, 245-257. Piperno, J., and Oxender, D. L. 1968. Amino acid transport systems in Escherichia coli K12. J . Biol. Chem. 243, 5914-5920. Richaud, F., and Cohen, G. 1968. Selection of Escheiichia coli mutants devoid of one or both of the activities carried by a multifunctional protein. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 30, 45-49. Rowbury, R. J. 1964. The accumulation of 0-succinylhomoserine by Escherichia colz and Salmonella typhimurium. J . Gen. Microbiol. 37, 171-180. Rowbury, R. J. 1968. The inhibitory action of a-methylmethionine on Escherichia coli. J. Gen. Microbiol. 52, 223-230. Rowbury, R. J., and Woods, D. D. 1961. Further studies in the repression of methionine synthesis in Escherichia eoli. J . Gen. Microbiol. 24, 129-144. Rowbury, R. J., and Woods, D. D. 1964a. O-succinylhomoserine as an intermediate in the synthesis of cystathionine by Escherichia coli. J . Gen. Microbiol. 36, 341-358. Rowbury, R. J., and Woods, D. D. 1964b. Repression by methionine of cystathionine formation in Escherichia coli. J . Gen. Microbiol. 35, 145-158. Rowbury, R. J., and Woods, D. D. 1966. The regulation of cystathionine formation in Escherichia coli. J . Gen. Microbiol. 42, 155-163. Rowbury, R. J., Lawrence, D. A,, and Smith, D. A. 1968. Regulation of the methionine-specific aspartokinase and homoserine dehydrogenase of Salmonella typhimurium. J . Gen. Microbiol. 54, 337-342.
E. coli
AND
X. typhimuriuin S-AMINO ACID
SYNTHESIS
165
Sanderson, K. E 1970. Current linkage map of SaZmonelkz typhimurium. Bacteriol. Rev. 34, 176-193. Schlesinger, S. 1967. Inhibition of growth of Eschetichzn coli and of homoserine-0transsuccinylasc by a-methylmethionine. J . Bacteiiol. 94, 327-332. Sheppard, D. E. 1964. Mutants of Salmonella typhimzirium resistant to feed-back inhibition by L-histidine. Genetics 50, 611-623. Smith, D. A. 1961. Some aspects of the genetics of inethionineless mutants of Salmonella typhimiii iima. J . Gen. Microbiol. 24, 335-353. Smith, D. A., and Childs, J. D. 1966. Mcthionine genes and enzymes of Salmonella typhimuiizim. Heiedity 21, 265-286. Smith, R. C. 1968. Growth and nucleic acid synthesis of Salmonella typhimuiium inhibited by a-methylmethionine. Con. J . Microbiol. 14, 331-335. Spencer, H. T., Collins, J., and Monty, K. J. 1967. Sequential regulation of cysteine Exp. Biol. biosynthesis in Salmoiiella 1yphininrium. Fed. Pioc. Fed. Amer. SOC. 26, 677. Spizek, J., and Janecck, J. 1969. The effect of cthioninc on thc synthesis of p-galactosidase : formation of an immunologically cross-reacting protein. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 34, 17-21. Stadtman, E. R. 1963. Enzymc multiplicity and functions in the regulation of divergent metabolic pathways. BacterioZ. Rev. 27, 170-181. Sn, Ching-Hsiang, Grccne, R. C.. and Holloway, C. T. 1970. Regulation of S-adenosylmethionine synthctasc in Exherichin coli K12. Bacteriol. Proc. p. 136. Taylor, A. L., 1970. Current linkage map of Escherichia coli. BacterioZ. Rev. 34, 155-175. Taylor, R. T., and Weissbach, H. 1967a. Isolation of methyl-B,? from Escherichia coli B. N5-methyl-H4-folate homocyateine vitamin BI2 transmethylase. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 27, 398-404. Taylor, R. T., and Weissbach, H. 1967b. N’-Methyl tetrahydrofolate-homocysteine transmethylase. Partial purification and properties. J . BioZ. Chem. 242, 1502-1508. Trudinger, P. A. 1969. Assimilatory and disimilatory mctabolism of inorganic sulphur compounds by microorganisms. Advan. Microbial Physiol. 3, 111-158. Umbarger, H. E. 1969. Regulation of amino acid metabolism. Aiinu. Rev. Biochem. 38, 323-370. Weissbach, H., and Taylor, R. 1966. Role of vitamin BIZ in methionine synthesis. Fed. Proc. Fed. Amer. Soe. Exp. Bzol. 25, 1649-1656. Wheldrake, J. F. 1967. Intracellular concentration of cysteine in Escherichia C O Z ~ and its relation to repression of sulphate-activating enzymes. Biochem. J . 105, 697-699. Wheldrake, J. F., and Pasternak, C. A. 1965. The control of sulphate activation in bacteria. Biochem. J. 96, 276-280. Whitfield, C. D., and Weissbach, H. 1968. Binding of substrate to N‘-methyl-tctrahydropteroyl-triglutamate-homocysteinetransmethylasc. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 33, 996-1003. Whitfield, C. D., Steers, E. J., Jr., and Weissbach, H. 1970. Purification and properties of 5’-methyltetrahydropteroyl-triglutamate-homocysteine transmethylase. J . Biol. Chem. 245, 39M01. Wijesundera, S.,and Woods, D. D. 1962. The catabolism of cystathionine by Escherichia coli. J . Gen. Microbiol. 29, 353-366. Woods, D. D., Foster, M. A., and Guest, J. R. 1964. In “Transmethylation and Methionine Biosynthesis” (5.K. Shapiro, and S. Llenk, eds.), Univ. of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois.
MUTAGENIC AND LETHAL EFFECTS OF VISIBLE AND NEARULTRAVIOLET LIGHT ON BACTERIAL CELLS* A. Eisenstarkt I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Comparison of Biological Effects Produced b y UV, NV-V, and PH-A 111. Mutation by NV-V. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Membrane Involvement . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Photodynamic Action (Ph-A) . . . . . . . . . . VI. Sensitization with SBromouracil . . . . . . . . . . . VII. Internal Sensitizers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII. Possible Target Molecules (Chromophores) for NV-V . . . . IX. Photoreactivation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . X. Relation of Light-Sensitive Chromophore to Recombination . . . XI. Groa-th Inhibition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XII. NV-V Effects on Transforming DNA and on Viruses . . . . . XIII. Action Spectra . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XIV. Significance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XV. Summary. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
.
. . . . . . .
.
167 169 174 176 177 179 180 181 183 184 18.5 187 188 188 189 191
I. Introduction
Twenty-eight years ago, Hollaender (1943) focused attention on biological effects of light with wavelengths longer than those emitted by “germicidal” lamps. Although a number of observations had already been reported (Blum, 1941), Hollaender clearly demonstrated, in quantitative terms, that such wavelengths were lethal t o bacteria. The intervening years have offered little in clarifying the molecular mechanisms
* Abbreviations used : W-ultraviolet light (below 300 nm) . NV-V-near-ultraviolet and visible light (above 300 nm). ( I t is recognized that different NV-V wavelengths may produce a multitude of effects. All of these are lumped together in this review; hopefully, future research will sort these out and specific effects will be assigned to specific wavelengths.) PH-A-photodynamic action ; BU-5-bromouracil. PRE-photoreactivating enzyme. t Permanent address : Division of Biological Sciences, University of Missouri, Columbia, Missouri. 167
168
A. EISENSTARK
involved in the killing and mutagenesis of bacterial cells by these longer wavelengths. Until a short time ago, the same lack of understanding might have been said of UV” research; but in contrast to NV-V studies, the lethal and mutagenic effects of UV had been described from many aspects in thousands of research papers. Recent discoveries with regard to both W and NV-V effects bring new attention to these older observations. Now that we are aware of pyrimidine dimer formation by UV, and the defined steps in DNA repair following UV, information may now be viewed in a more critical fashion. Perhaps the paucity of NV-V experiments, as compared to those with other radiations, reflects certain skepticisms of scientists, i.e., (a) whether wavelengths above 300 nm are really lethal, or whether the lamps that are used emit a stray, lower UV that escapes detection; (b) if the mode of death and/or mutation by NV-V were the same as by UV, whether there is a serious need to use the former in experiments; (c) whether the longer exposures necessary for experiments with NV-V may present difficulties for quantitative experiments; (d) since there is a huge literature on the effect of light in terms of energy transfer in biological systems (e.g., photosynthesis), and since this still is somewhat of a “blackbox” in terms of biochemical mechanics, whether one should be optimistic that studies of lethal effects of NV-V would lead to new molecular concepts; (e) in view of an extensive literature on photodynamic action of NV-V, whether a cellular component may be acting as an internal sensitizer in NV-V lethality; thus, it may be argued that there is nothing unique about NV-V effects that is not already known in more quantitative terms by the use of external sensitizers. The validity of some of these skepticisms will be examined in this review. This is a particularly appropriate time to focus attention on the effects of NV-V. Not only have important steps been taken recently in our understanding of W genetic damage and repair, but a number of new studies concerning NV-V effects have appeared. The observation in our own laboratory (Eisenstark, 1970) that recombinationless (rec) mutants are highly sensitive to NV-V, raises questions as to whether light chromophores may have roles in repair, recombination, and replication of chromosomes. The specific questions in need of attention may be stated as follows: (a) What biological effects produced by NV-V are the same as those produced by UV? What biological effects are distinctly different for the two? (b) What NV-V wavelengths are most effective for each of the biological alterations (i.e., what is the action spectrum for each of the effects) ? ( c ) What are the critical receptor molecules (chromophores) for NV-V in the cell? (d) How is each chromophore altered, and what
GENETIC DAMAGE BY VISIBLE AND
NEAR-UVLIGHT
169
is the energy chain to other molecules? (e) Is death and/or mutation due to a direct alteration of DNA, or does DNA change represent the end result of a chain of reactions? ( f ) If the DNA is altered, what are the photoproducts? Pyrimidine dimers alone? (g) When damage from light is repaired, is the repair mechanism identical to that of UV repair? (h) If NV-V death is actually a photodynamic action with an internal sensitizer, why are rec mutants more sensitive than wild-type? (i) Is recA strictly a fault in one of the enzymes of the repair process, or could recA mutants involve aberrant chromophores? These might either alter the energy chain, act as hypersensitizers, or as inhibitors of normal replication-recombination function [recB and recC are now known to have endonuclease deficiency, as reported by Oishi (1969) and Goldmark and Lynn (1970) ; also, recA could lack an inhibitor of these two]. II. Comparison of Biological Effects Produced by UV, NV-V, and PH-A
One of the first matters t o be settled is whether NV-V produces the same effect as UV. NV-V death might be the result of stray UV emitted from lamps, or perhaps NV-V and UV alter the same receptor molecules. If either is the case, then this review is comparatively trivial. If, on the other hand, NV-V is an effective lethal and mutagenic agent that strikes a critical macromolecule other than those altered by UV, it is important to identify the event and the molecules. This review will attempt to show that NV-V is indeed different from W, and to evaluate the involvement of certain biomolecules. The work of Webb and Lorentz (1970) supports our conclusions that NV-V produces biological alterations that are uniquely different from those produced by UV. Table 1 lists various observations following non-ionizing irradiation of bacterial cells; similarities and differences produced by UV, PH-A, and NV-V may be noted. Sensitization with BU will be listed under PH-A since the BU studies are few in number and superficially resemble those of PH-A, although it is recognized that the mechanism of action is very different. The list of differences between NV-V and UV (Table 1) warrants the impression that NV-V does something unique as compared to UV. It is difficult to evaluate earlier reports as to which of these differences is critically significant without going to the laboratory and repeating experiments under special conditions, especially the elimination of stray wavelengths. Nevertheless, from this inventory of the many ways that biological effects can be observed, one can now choose critical experiments that might lead to distinguishing the various molecular mech-
170
A. EISENSTARK
anisms involved in radiation damages. Not all of the biological effects listed in Table 1 will be discussed, since many of the observations are self-explanatory, although the significance may remain obscure. To settle the matter as to whether NV-V produces an effect different from UV, the most direct approach would be to identify the receptor molecule of NV-V and to determine its biochemical alteration. With UV, thymine dimers in the DNA are formed as a major photoproduct. To show that NV-V is different, the obvious answer would be to photoinactivate cells and to assay for thymine dimer and other photoproducts. When such an experiment was conducted (Ferron, 1971), photoproducts were formed after blacklight exposure with rf values in one dimensional chromotography similar to those of thymine dimers. If thymine dimers are formed by blacklight, per lethal unit, they are far fewer than the number produced by UV. There is convincing evidence (Table 1) that the lesion of NV-V differs from that of UV. Following UV, the DNA of recA mutants of Salmonella typhimurium and Escherichia coli undergoes rapid degradation (Howard-Flanders et al., 1969). This is not true for NV-V; for the same degree of killing, degradation does not exceed that of unirradiated cells (Ferron and Eisenstark, 1971). While we do not know the event that initiates degradation, a possibility is that a lesion in DNA is a starting site for nuclease activity. Since degradation does not occur for NV-V-treated cells, we may assume that the lesion is different; perhaps the nuclease has no recognition site a t which to start its activity. This difference between UV and NV-V confirms other evidence that degradation is a secondary effect, following the initial lethal event. There are other ways of preventing degradation of recA while still killing cells, including the stopping of protein synthesis and the irradiation of cells without replication forks (Horii and Suzuki, 1968; see also Cramp and Watkins, 1970, for DNA degradation in E . coli B/r). Also, double mutants of uvrA recA degrade their DNA far less than the r e d allele following UV (Ferron and Eisenstark, 1971; Horii and Suzuki, 1970). Interestingly recA recB double mutants do not degrade their DNA following UV exposure (Willetts and Clark, 1969; Goldmark and Lynn, 1970), probably because recB mutation makes the cell endonuclease deficient (see also Hertman, 1969). Following UV, single strand breaks are formed in rec cells, as revealed by alkaline sucrose density gradient centrifugation studies. Such breaks are not formed after rec S. typhimuriuin are exposed to NV-V (Ferron, 1971). The stricter oxygen demand for NV-V killing is an important indication that the biochemical events are different from W killing (Eisen-
TABLE 1 Comparison of Effects of Ultraviolet, Photodynamic Action, and Near-Ultraviolet-Visible Light * Observation
UV (218-300 nm)
DNA degradation in recA mutants Single-strand breaks in DNA
Yes (1) Yes (3) (76)
Mutation
Yes (4)
Oxygen demand for killing Growth inhibition (division delay) Liquid-holding recovery Photoreactivation
Low (23) Moderate (25, 26) Yes for rec (28) Yes (30, 31)
DNA synthesis rate Pyrimidine dimer formation Photoproducts other than T T dimers Induction of lysogenic cells Action spectrum
Slower (37) Yes (38) (38a) (74) Yes (69) (72) Yes Max 260 nm
Ability to support phage multiplicaYes, T2, T1 phage (45, 46) tion after host-cell irradiation Comparison of large and small phage Large phage more sensitive (47) Inactivation of transforming DNA Yes-not pH-dependent respond t o photoreactivating enzyme (PRE) (48)
PH-A
+
[BU UV-yes, 500 times greater than UV alone (3)] Yes (5-19) (71) High (6) Yes (27) No (32) [No with BU (33, 34)]
NV-V (300490 nm)
No (29) No (20) Yes (21, 22) High (24) Very high (20) (73) No for rec at room T (29) Yes, frozen cells (35) No, transforming DNA, room T (36)
No (39, 40, 41) Yes (42, 43, 44) depends upon absorption range of each sensitizer [BU-max. 313 nm (38)]
Yes (49, 50, 70)
Division delay, 300-380 nm (26) (75) Growth inhibition, 338 nm (25) (75) No, T2, T1 (45, 46) Small phage more sensitive (47) More sensitive at low p H ; does not respond to P R E (48)
TABLE 1 (Continued) Observation
UV (218-300 nm)
Shape of killing curve
Little shoulder (20)
Relative killing of recA and recB
recA more sensitive than recB
Linkage of DNA to protein Alteration of protein Salt toxicity Leakage of ions Target molecule (chromophore) Carotenoid protection Membrane damage
(29) Yes (52, 53)
No (20) No (55) Pyrimidine in DNA No (also X-ray) (58)
Fe-sensitization Sensitization to nitrous acid Thiol protection Yes (X-ray also) (61) Polyamine protection Lethality by irradiated medium Yes (63, 64) Interference with transcription tRNA loss of acceptor and inactivation More effective inactivation of growing vs. stationary cells Yes, moderate (24)
PH-A Both single and multiple hit curves (51) Yes (52) Yes (6, 54)
NV-V (300-490 nm) Long shoulder (20) Same sensitivity for recA and recB (29) Yes (20) Yes (55)
Guanine (15, 56, 57) Yes (58) Lysozyme permeability (59J 60)
Yes (61) Yes (62) Yes (11, 66)
* E
m M
3
2
E Yes (11) Yes (36) Yea (65)
Yes (67, 68) Yes, higher (24)
*Numbers in parentheses refer to the following references: (1) Buttin and Wright, 1968; (2) Ferron and Eisenstark, 1971; (3) Hutchinson and Hales, 1970; (4) Witkin, 1969; (5) Calberg-Bacq e t al., 1968; (6) Spikes and Straight, 1967; (7) Bohme and Wacker, 1963; (8) Zampieri and Greenberg, 1965; (9) Kubitschek, 1967; (10) Webb and Kubitschek, 1963; (11) Singer and FrankelConrat 1966; (12) DeMars, 1953; (13) Webb and Tai, 1969; (14) Mathews, 1963; (15) von Lochmann and Stein, 1964; (16) Brenner et al. 1958; (17) Ball and Raper, 1966; (18) Leff and Krinsky, 1967; (19) Richie, 1965; (20) Hollaender, 1943; (21) Webb and Malina, 1967; (22) Kubitschek, 1967; (23) Donini and Epstein, 1965; (24) Eisenstark, 1970; (25) Jagger et al., 1964; (26) Phillips et al., 1967; (27) Teresa et al., 1965; (28) Ganesan and Smith, 1969; (29) Eisenstark, unpublished; (30) Setlow, 1966; (31) Rupert and Harm, 1966; (32) Uretz, 1964; (33) Greer, 1960; (34) Stahl et al., 1961; (35) Brown and Webb, 1970; (36) Cabrera-Juarez, 1964; (37) Rupp and Howard-Flanders, 1968; (38) Grossman and Brown, 1969; (38a) Boyce and Howard-Flanders, 1964; (39) Newmark, 1965; (40) Van Vunakk et al., 1966; (41) Sastry et al., 1966; (42) Geissler, 1963; (43) Smarda, 1964; (44) Freifelder and Freifelder, 1966; (45) Dulbecco and Weigle, 1952; (46) Hill, 1956; (47) Wahl and Laterjet, 1948; (48) Cabrera-Juarez and Herriott, 1963; (49) Bellin and Grossman, 1965; (50) Bellin and Oster, 1960; (51) Harrison and Raabe, 1967; (52) Smith, 1962; (53) Smith, 1966; (54) Spikes, 1968; (55) Bruce, 1958; (56) Simon and Van Vunakis, 1962; (57) Wacker, 1963; (58) Mathews and finsky, 1965; (59) Allison e t al., 1966; (60) Slater and Riley, 1966; (61) Geissler, 1963; (62) Brendel and Winkler, 1966; (63) Wyss et al., 1948; (64) Chopra, 1969; (65) Lorentz and Webb, unpublished; (66) Chandrs and Wacker, 1966; (67) Tsugita et at., 1965; (68) Amagasa and Ito, 1970; (69) Setlow, 1968; (70) Ponce-De Leon and Cabrera-Juarez, 1970; (71) GabreraJuarez and Espinoza, 1970; (72) Donnellan and Setlow, 1966; (73) Jagger, 1970; (74) Setlow and Carrier, 1966; (75) Takebe and Jagger, 1969; (76) Davison and Freifelder, 1966.
u
P
F0 M
*td
174
A. EISENSTARK
stark, 1970). This oxygen demand also provides an insight into the biochemistry of NV-V, as noted elsewhere in this review. Another indication that NV-V and UV lesions are different is the fact that transforming DNA of Haemophilus influenme can be reactivated with photoreactivation enzyme after UV, but not after NV-V inactivation (Cabrera-Juarez, 1964). Also, UV-treated host cells can still support growth of phages T2 and T1, whereas this is not so after treating cells with NV-V (Dulbecco and Weigle, 1952; Hill, 1956). This is a good example of the difference between the two types of radiation, but it also points out our lack of knowledge of some of the critical biochemical events following phage infection. A number of additional findings that distinguish UV from NV-V will be emphasized elsewhere in this review. However, the differences listed in Table 1, especially those of DNA degradation following irradiation, oxygen demand, and intracellular phage growth, permits the confidence that the two irradiations strike different chromophores. Ill. Mutation by NV-V
While Hollaender (1943) did not observe mutation by NV-V, several later studies describe increased mutation frequencies following exposures (Table 1 ) . We now need information from a molecular standpoint to gain some insight of the mechanism of NV-V mutagenesis. For example, if one of the events following NV-V is the exposure of single-strand gaps, there is now convincing evidence that one may anticipate an increase in frameshift mutations a t sites within this gap. This is examplified by increased proflavin mutagenesis of T4 phage with a ligase mutation in which joining of DNA pieces is impaired (Sarabhai and Lamfrom, 1969). An obvious test for single-strand gaps would be to NV-V irradiate a light-sensitive mutant containing a frameshift mutation. If singlestrand gaps are formed after NV-V, one would expect occasional corrections of the frameshift, and thus an observable increase in reversion rate. This test may not work for one particular (i.e., the recA lightsensitive) strain, since Witkin (1969) has evidence that recA strains cannot correct frameshifts. If this is correct, a more suitable test strain would be a recB or an hcr with a frameshift mutation. Although hcr mutants are not nearly as NV-V sensitive as rec, they are somewhat more sensitive than wild-type. On the other hand, excision of thymine dimers does not occur in hcr, thus there may be few single-strand gaps, and little correction of frameshifts. Still another view is that if NV-V does not produce frameshifts, this would suggest that it may not produce single-strand gaps in DNA.
GENETIC DAMAGE BY VISIBLE AND
NEAR-UVLIGHT
175
While awaiting insights as to the molecular mechanisms of NV-V mutagenesis, i t is interesting t o note experiments that lead to the conclusion that NV-V wavelengths are indeed mutagenic. These include the work of Kubitschek (1967) , who found that T5-resistant mutants were produced more frequently by NV under aerobic conditions and showed that the mechanism of mutation is different from that of UV. Webb and Malina (1967) presented similar results in which their exposures were restricted to visible light with wavelengths above 400 nm. An interesting aspect of NV-V mutagenesis is that mutation is much higher if E. coli B cells are irradiated while they are dehydrated (Webb and Tail 1969). These investigators (Webb and Tai, 1969; Webb and Bhorjee, 1967) state that light may prevent association between DNA and certain amino acids in protein involved +ith DNA replication and other DNA functions. As expressed elsewhere in this review, one protein candidate might be ligase, which requires NADH (absorption = 340 nm) for activity, and this NADH could be altered by NV-V. Cells are particularly susceptible to NV-V when they are frozen at -2OoC, (Ashwood-Smith, 1965; Zetterberg, 1964) , but no explanation is offered. It should be pointed out that in the case of frozen and dehydrated samples, the action of 254 nm germicidal UV differs from that of NV-V, further evidence that the two act via different mechanisms. Mutagenic action of blacklight is most effective a t relative humidity of 55-65% where the water content is between 15-20%. I n these experiments (Webb and Tail 1969), the number of auxotrophic mutants was scored after irradiation and penicillin screening. The papers by Webb and associates discuss many interesting aspects of the lesions produced by UV and NV-V under conditions of limiting water. It should be emphasized that light-sensitive mutants are defective in some aspects of chromosome function. It is reasonable to anticipate, therefore, that they might have higher, or lower, mutation rates than wild-type, depending upon the nature of the impairment. The above cited case of reduced frameshifts in recA mutants (Witkin, 1969) is a good example. Other cases include radiation-sensitive E . coli ras mutants (Walker, 1969) with greatly increased UV mutability (frameshift?) , a uvr Proteus mirabilis (Bohme, 1967) , a uvr Neisseria meningit i d h (Jyssum, 1968) , and an X-ray sensitive yeast (von Borstel et al., 1968) with increased mutability. We have screened about 60 Salmonella radiation-sensitive mutants (Eisenstark et al., 1969) for streptomycinresistance frequencies. We found no general pattern, but two hcr mutants, out of 30 examined, were high in mutability, as well as two uvr Salmonella anatum cultures (Eisenstark, unpublished). Interestingly, 2 of 15 rec+ revertants of recA S. typhimurium were highly mutable. The reason for
176
A. EISENSTARR
testing revertants was that phenotypic revertants might represent an overcompensation of the mutant recA defect, and thus lead to excess mutability. It would be interesting to test whether NV-V can induce deletions. In E. coli, deletions can be tested by scoring for phage T1 and T 7 resistance (these become pro) and colicine B and V resistance. Such phenotypes contain deletions, and occur spontaneously (Anderson, 1970). Surprisingly, these deletions are found in equal frequency in wild-type, recA, recB, and recC mutants. Since deletions are thought to occur after a recombinational event, these results are difficult to explain. Induction of lysogeny, also considered a recombinational event and formally a type of deletion, does not occur in recA mutants (Eisenstark et al., 1969). IV. Membrane Involvement
Many cellular chromophores are known to reside in membranes. This has been intensively studied in mitochondria1 membranes where enzymes involved in energy transfer form integral parts of the structure. Also, since bacterial DNA is bound to cell membrane fractions (Ganesan and Lederberg, 1965), it is conceivable that a chromophore may have a role somewhere in the course of chromosome function (i.e., replication, transcription, repair, or recombination). As may be seen in the discussion of repair synthesis, Olivera et al., (1968) have shown D P N involvement in ligase activity. D P N may be located in cell membranes. How would one assay for a role of a chromophore in membrane-DNA interaction? If the chromophore role involves the binding of DNA and membrane, an obvious experiment would be to expose cells to NV-V and to look for quantitative alteration of this DNA-membrane binding. It is conceivable that this could go in either direction: If excess light cripples the chromophore, the membrane could lose its binding force, or, conversely, the membrane might fail to release a particular chromosomal attachment point after completing its function. We have tested this in our laboratory but our preliminary experiments have shown no effect of NV-V on either light-sensitive or wild-type strains (Ferron, unpublished). Another approach would be to test mutants that have an aberrant chromophore, assuming that these may reside in the membrane. There are some E. coli candidates for these, including, ubiA, ubiB, and ubiD (unable to form ubiquinone) (Cox et al., 1968; Cox et al., 1969), to& and chr2 (iron-transport mutants) (Wang and Newton, 1969a,b), hemA, B (hemin) (Sasarman et al., 1968, 1970; Wulff, 1967; Sanderson and
GENETIC DAMAGE BY VISIBLE AND
NEAR-UVLIGHT
177
Hamplova, 1970), and nad, A , B , C (nicotinic acid requirement) (Gholson et al., 1969; Olivera et al., 1968). As yet, there are no reports of altered membrane functions in these mutants. Niacin mutants of E. coli and S. typhimuriunz have been tested for light and UV sensitivity and were found to be negative (Ferron and Eisenstark, unpublished data). The membrane fraction contains DNA polymerase activity (Ganesan and Lederberg, 1965) which could have a chromophore involvement. (It is interesting to note the skepticism in this paper as to whether this polymerase is really involved in replication. See deLucia and Cairns, 1969, for further doubt.) The fact that NV