ADVANCES IN AGRONOMY VOLUME VIII
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN
AGRONOMY Prepared under the Auspices of the
AMERICAN SOCIETY OF AGRONOMY
V O L U M E VIII Edited by A. G . NORMAN University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan
ADVISORY BOARD G. H. AHLGREN G. W. BURTON J. E. GIESEKING W. P. MARTIN
R. W. PEARSON R. W. SIMONSON G. F. SPRAGUE H. B. SPRAGUE
1956 ACADEMIC PRESS INC., PUBLISHERS NEW YORK
Copyright @ 1956, by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. 125 EAST 23x1 STREET NEW YORK
10,
N. Y.
All Rights Reserved
N o part of this book m a y be reproduced in any form, by photostat, microfilm, or any other means, without written permission from the publishers.
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: (50-5598)
PRINTED I N THE UNITED STATES O F AMERICA
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME VIII
Senior Principal Research Officer, Commonwealth A. J. ANDERSON, Scientific and Industrial Research Organization, Canberra, A.C.T., Australia.
W. B. ANnREws, Agronomist, Department of Agronomy, Mississippi Agricultural Experiment Station, State College, Mississippi.
H. B. CHENEY,Head, Department of Soils, Oregon State College, Corvallis, Oregon.
J . RITCHIE COWAN,Agronomist, Department of Farm Crops, Oregon State College, Corvallis, Oregon. J . E. DAWSON, Associate Professor of Soil Science, Department of Agronomy, New York State College of Agriculture, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York. S. T. DEXTER, Professor of Farm Crops, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan.
J . W . FITTS,I n Charge, Soil Research, Department of Agronomy, North Carolina State College, Raleigh, North Carolina.
W . H. FOOTE,Associate Agronomist, Department Oregon State College, Corvallis, Oregon.
of
Farm Crops,
E. G. KNOX,Assistant Soil Scientist, Department of Soils, Oregon State College, Corvallis, Oregon.
L. B. NELSON, Head, Eastern Soil and Water Management Section, Agricultural Research Service, U . S. Department of Agriculture, Beltsville, Maryland.
W .L. NELSON, Midwest Manager, American Potash Institute, Lafayette, Indiana. H . H . RAMPTON, Agronomist, Agricultural Research Service, U . S. Department of Agriculture, Corvallis, Oregon. D. C. SMITH,Chairman, Department of Agronomy, University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin. Y
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Preface
As one looks at the topics reviewed in this and the preceding seven volumes of this series, one cannot but be impressed by their diversity and breadth, yet all deal essentially with agricultural soils and the crops which they can support. Progress in soil and crop science in the past two decades has been greatly accelerated by the application of many disciplines to the solution of theoretical and applied problems in agronomic practice. The empiricism which characterized so much of the agronomic research of the past has given way to more rationaland more rewarding-approaches. Consider, for example, the chapter on grass breeding by D. C. Smith in this volume as evidence of the changes that have taken place. Studies on soil management and cultural practices, which have not seemed to lend themselves to the same sort of refinement, are nevertheless changing in character. The development of recommendations for economic applications of fertilizer and lime, based on chemical soil tests, as described herein by Fitts and Nelson, are becoming more solidly based as information is secured on the forms and availability of essential plant nutrients in soils. Other examples will readily occur to the reader. Once again there is included a regional survey, in which the soil resources and crop patterns of an area are reviewed in some detail. This time it is the “new agricultural empire” of the Pacific Northwest states, which, as shown by Cheney and his colleagues, presents a wide array of agronomic problems and an unusual challenge and opportunity to bring to bear on them the best agronomic skills. The overall objective of this series remains unchanged. It is to survey and review progress in agronomic research and practice. The central theme is soil-plant relationships, but in choosing topics the editor is not concerned about the precise boundaries of agronomy; only that the material presented should be useful to agronomists. Ann Arbor, Michigan August, 1956
A. G. NORMAN
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CONTENTS Page
. . . . . . . . . . . . . v . . . . . . . . . . . . . vii
Contributors to Volume VIII Preface . . . . . . .
Field Crop Production and Soil Management in the Pacific Northwest BY H B. CHENEY.W. H. FOOTE. E. G KNOX.Oregon State College. Corvallis. Oregon. A N D H H RAMPTON. Field Crops Research Branch. Agricultural Research Service. United States Department of Agriculture. Corvallis. Oregon
.
.
. .
1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Regional Characteristics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I11. SoilResources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . .
IV Soil Management . . V Crop Zones of the Region VI Field Crops of the Region References . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2 3 7 17 33 37 59
Anhydrous Ammonia as a Nitrogenous Fertilizer BY W B ANDREWS. Mississippi Agricultural Experiment Station. State College Mississippi
. .
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Behavior of Anhydrous Ammonia in the Soil . . . . . . . . I11. Response of Crops to Anhydrous Ammonia . . . . . . . . .
.
IV Anhydrous Ammonia Equipment V.Summary . . . . . . . VI. Conclusions . . . . . . References . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
62 70 79 . 110 . 119 . 123 . 123
Progress in Grass Breeding BY D C. SMITH.University of Wisconsin. Madison. Wisconsin
.
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . I1. Diversity of Grasses . . . . . . I11. General References . . . . . . IV. Nature of Varieties . . . . . . V. Environmental Effects . . . . . VI. Cytology . . . . . . . . . VII. Interspecific and Intergeneric Relations VIII. Fertility and Sterility . . . . . IX . Inbreeding . . . . . . . . ix
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
128 129 130 131 134 . 135 . 139 . 141 . 142
X
CONTENTS
. Combining Ability . . Crossing Techniques .
. . . Hybrid Varieties . . . . Agronomic Aspects . . . Disease Resistance . . XV. Nutritive Value . . . XVI. Variety Maintenance . XVII . Discussion . . . . . References . . . . . X XI XI1 XI11 XIV
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Page 143 149 150 151 152 154 156 158 159
Molybdenum as a Fertilizer
BY A . J . ANDERSON. Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization. Canberra. A.C.T., Australia I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. The Field Occurrence of Molybdenum Deficiency . . I11. The Nature and Detection of Molybdenum Deficiencies IV. The Correction of Molybdenum Deficiency . . . . V. Factors Affecting the Response to Molybdenum . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
164 166 173 182 184 199
. . . . .
204 208 210 235 236
The Evaluation of Crop Plants for Winter Hardiness
BY S. T. DEXTER.Michigan State University. East Lansing. Michigan I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . I1. Theories of the Winter Hardiness of Plants I11. Methods of Testing for Hardiness . . 1V.Summary. . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
The Determination of lime and Fertilizer Requirements of Soils Through Chemical Tests BY J . W . FITTS.North Carolina State College. Raleigh. North Carolina. AND WERNER L . NELSON.American Potash Institute, Lafayette. Indiana
I. Introduction . . . . . . . I1. Calibration of Soil Tests . . . I11. Representative Soil Samples . . IV. Chemical Testing Procedures . . V. Interpretation and Recommendations VI . Soil Test Summaries . . . . . VII Future Trends in Soil Testing . . References . . . . . . . .
.
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. 242 . 244 . 252 . 257 . 269 . 274 . 278
. . . . . . . . . . .
280
Tall Fescue BY J . RITCHIE COWAN. Oregon State College. Coruallis. Oregon I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 283 I1. Production and Utilization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 286 I11. Cultural Practices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 292
xi
CONTENTS
IV. Genetics and Cytology . V Varieties . . . . . VI. Breeding Behavior . . VII . Seed Production . . . VIII Fescue Poisoning . . . IX Diseases . . . . . X . Future of Tall Fescue . References . . . . .
.
. .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Page . 295 . 298 . 303 . 310 . 313 . 315 . 316 . 318
The Mineral Nutrition of Corn as Related to Its Growth and Culture BY LEWISB. NELSON.United States Department of Agriculture. Beltsuille. Maryland I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 321 I1. Nutrient and Water Absorption by Corn Roots . . . . . . . . 323 111. Foliar Absorption of Nutrients . . . . . . . . . . . . . 334
. . . . . .
IV Growth and Accumulation of Dry Matter . . . . . . . . . . 336 V Accumulation and Movement of Elements within the Plant . . . . 338 VI Symptoms of Nutritional Disorders . . . . . . . . . . . 351 MI Effect of Fertilizers on Nutrition and Growth . . . . . . . . 355 VIII Influence of Plant Population . . . . . . . . . . . . . 362 IX Effect of Soil Moisture on Nutrition and Growth . . . . . . 363 Acknowledgment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 368 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 368 Organic Soils BY J . E. DAWSON. New York State College of Agriculture. Cornell University. Ithaca. New York
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Organic Soil Materials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I11. Stratigraphy of Organic Soils . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Rate of Formation of Peat Soils . . . . . . . . . . . . V . Subsidence of Organic Soils . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI. Some Chemical Properties of Organic Soils of Significance in Crop Production . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII Recent Chemical Work on Peat Soils and Related Materials . . . . VIII . Some Problems in Stratigraphy, Formation. Subsidence and Chemistry of Organic Soils . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
Author Index Subject Index
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
378 378 381 384 385 387 390 398 399 403 417
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Field Crop Production and Soil Management in the Pacific Northwest'
.
H. B. CHENEY. W . H. FOOTE. E. G. KNOX. AND H H. RAMPTON Oregon State College. Corvallis. Oregon. and Field Crops Research Branch. Agricultural Research Service. United States Department of Agriculture. Corvallis. Oregon
I. Introduction . . . . I1 Regional Characteristics
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.LandForms. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.Clim~te . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Water Resources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.LandUse. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I11 Soil Resources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. Sierozem Zone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.BrownZone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Chestnut Zone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Chernozem Zone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Brown Forest-Gray Wooded Zones . . . . . . . . . . 6. Podzol-Brown Podzolic Zones (Mountainous Areas) . . . . . 7. Brown Podzolic Zone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 . Brown Latosol Zone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9. Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Upland Areas . . . . . . . 10. Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Lowland Areas . . . . . . . I 1. Reddish Brown Latosol-Noncalcic Brown Zones . . . . . . . IV. Soil Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. Use of Soil Management Practices . . . . . . . . . . a. General . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . b. Irrigation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . c. Fertilizers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . d. Liming Materials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Sierozem Zone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.BrownZone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Chestnut Zone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Chernozem Zone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. Brown Podzolic Zone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7. Brown Latosol Zone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8. Reddish Brown Latosol Z o n e u p l a n d Areas . . . . . . .
.
Page 2 3
3 4 4 7 7
9 10 11 12 12 13 14 15 15 16 16 17 17 17
18 18
19 20
22
23 25 27 28 29
Approved for publication as Miscellaneous Paper No. 22 of the Oregon Agricultural Experiment Station I
.
2
H. B. CHENEY, W. H.FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, A N D H. K. RAMPTON
. . . . . . .
9. Reddish Brown Latosol Zon-T-wland Areas 10. Reddish Brown Latosol-Noncalcic Brown Zones. V. Crop Zones of the Region . . . . . . . . . M.Field Crops of the Region . . . . . . . . . 1. Cereals. . . . . . . . . . . . . a.Wheat . . . . . . . . . . . b. Barley . . . . . . . . . . . c. Oats . . . . . . . . . . . . d. Rye . . . . . . . . . . . . e. Corn. . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Forages . . . . . . . . . . . . a. Hay Crops . . . . . . . . . . b. Silage . . . . . . . . . . . c. Improved Pastures. . . . . . . . 3. Field Seed Crops. . . . . . . . . . a. Importance of the Region . . . . . b. Legume Seed Crops . . . . . . . c. Grass Seed Crops 4. Potatoes . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Sugar Beets . . . . . . . . . . . 6. Annual Legumes. . . . . . . . . . References. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Page
31
. . . . . . 33 . . . . . . 33 . . . . . . 37
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . .
.
. .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
37 37 40
. . 41 . 42 . 4a . 43 . 43 . 46 . 47 . 47 . 47
. . . . . . 49
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
54 56 58 58 59
I. INTRODUCTION The Pacific Northwest is a region of contrasts in relief features, geology, climate, soils, natural vegetation, and water resources. Timber and agriculture have shaped its economy in the past but processing is increasing in importance. The Pacific Northwest is used here in its narrowest sense to include the states of Idaho, Oregon, and Washington, although many would also include western Montana. Some farming on a small scale was started in the western part of the region shortly after 1800. Major development of land for crop production has occurred during the past 75 years. Only 12 per cent of the region is used for crops. Owing to the wide diversity of physical characteristics a large variety of crops can be produced. Even within the Willamette Valley of western Oregon over 25 different crops are produced commercially. Major emphasis in this review is placed on the production of field crops and associated soil management in the Pacific Northwest. As a background for this discussion, land forms, climate, water resources, and soils of the region are considered. Since the soil is such an important factor in crop production and soil management, it is treated more thoroughly than the other regional characteristics. Owing to the broad scope of the subject, many of the generalities presented contain exceptions that cannot be discussed here.
FIELD CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL MANAGEMENT
3
11. REGIONAL CHARACTERISTICS Land forms, climate, and water resources, along with soils, which are discussed under Section 111, markedly influence the entire economy of the region. Land use, field crop production, and soil management are all controlled to a large degree by these factors.
I. Land Forms Varied and strong relief is characteristic of the region. Six physiographic provinces are recognized in the region, namely: (I) Pacific Border Province, (2) Cascade Mountains, (3 ) Columbia Intermontane Province, ( 4 ) Northern Rocky Mountains, ( 5 ) Middle Rocky Mountains, and (6) Basin and Range Province. Only a small portion of the latter two provinces occur in the region in south central to southeastern Oregon and the southeast corner of Idaho (Allison, 1953). Mountains occur along the entire Washington and Oregon coast in the Pacific Border Province. Except for the Olympic Mountains in north Washington, which are higher, they are less than 4000 feet in elevation. The Brown Latosol Zone and adjacent Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Upland Areas cover most of this area (see Fig. 3). The Willamette-Cowlitz-Puget lowlands are inland from the coastal mountains. They extend 350 miles from central Oregon to Canada and vary in width from 20 to 70 miles. These are primarily stream valleys containing alluvial terraces and, in the Puget lowland, glaciofluvial gravel. The Brown Podzolic Zone and Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Lowland Areas occur in this province (see Fig. 3). The dominant feature of the western part of the region is the Cascade Mountains, which range in width from over 100 miles near the Canadian border to less than 50 miles at the California line. The crest of the Cascade Range is approximately 5000 to 8000 feet with many higher peaks, most of which are volcanic. The surface consists largely of extrusive igneous materials. This mountain range in many ways separates the eastern and western portion of the region into two separate spheres or realms. It is cut only by the Columbia River. The soils of the Cascade Mountains are mostly in the Podzol-Brown Podzolic Zones of western Washington and Oregon and in the adjacent Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Upland Areas (see Fig. 3). The Columbia Intermontane Province covers nearly all of Oregon east of the Cascades, western and southern Idaho, and the southern part of eastern Washington. It is dominantly underlain by basalt lava flows. One of the largest areas of volcanic rock on the earth's surface occurs in the Pacific Northwest. Most of the province has elevations of 1000 to 5000 or more feet above sea level. The region has a highly
4
H. B. CHENEY, W. H. FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, A N D H. H. RAMPTON
varied surface including mountains with peaks of 10,000 feet elevation. Within the area are found the Sierozem, Brown, Chestnut, Chernozem, and Brown Forest-Gray Wooded soil zones (see Fig. 3). The Northern Rocky Mountains contain deep valleys and high mountain ridges, often 2000 to 8000 feet above the surrounding land. Some of the valleys are large enough for agricultural development and settlement. The soils are largely in the Podzol-Brown Podzolic and Brown Forest-Gray Wooded Zones of Idaho and northeastern Washington (see Fig. 3). 2. Climate Climate in the Pacific Northwest is most variable. The Cascade Range divides the area into two realms-a more humid west side and a drier east side on the interior as shown in Fig. 1. The climate west of the Cascades can be characterized as follows: ( I ) abundant precipitation, most of which comes during the winter, (2) small range in temperature for the latitude, with relatively warm winters and cool summers, (3) long frost-free period, and ( 4 ) winds predominantly from the Pacific Ocean. Total precipitation is high in the Coast Ranges and the Cascade Mountains but in the “dry shadow” east of each of these barriers it drops rapidly. The Willamette-Cowlitz-Pget Sound lowland receives 30 to 40 inches. In the interior east of the Cascades precipitation falls below 20 inches and often below 10 inches, except where increased precipitation occurs over mountains. In the interior the climate is more continental than it is along the coast, although it is modified by winds from the Pacific Ocean. The interior has greater extremes of temperature in both summer and winter than the coast. Low humidities and abundant sunshine prevail. The growing season as shown in Fig. 2 is generally shorter and limits the type of crops that can be grown in some irrigated regions. The low amount of summer precipitation has a marked effect on crdp production. Even in the more humid region west of the Cascades the normal total precipitation during July and August is 1.5 inches or less in most agricultural areas. Consequently, irrigation is increasing not only in the drier area east of the Cascades but also in the more humid region. Selected climatic information is given with the description of each of the soil zones under Section I11 and with the discussion of crop zones under Section V. 3 . Water Resources The water resources of the Pacific Northwest are one of its most important assets. The stream runoff in the region is greater than the
FIELD CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL M A N A G E M E N T
5
Y
." l3
Bl
FIG.1. Anmial precipitation in the Pacific Northwest. (Source: Highsmith, 1956.)
6 H. B. CHENEY,
w. H. FOOTE, E. G . KNOX, AND H. H. RAMPTON
.I
d
FIG. 2. Growing season in the Pacific Northwest. (Source: Highsmith, 1956.)
7
F I E L D CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL M A N A G E M E N T
total from all other areas of the United States west of the Mississippi River. This water resource is still being developed for irrigation, electric power, fishing, industrial and domestic use, and other purposes. Water for irrigation on 4.4 million acres is the most direct contribution to crop production. The availability of relatively low-cost electric energy also has contributed to the development of sprinkler irrigation. Moreover, since the agricultural production in a region is affected by its total development, the water resources have exerted many indirect effects on crop production and soil management. 4. Land Use
As given in Table I, over 88 per cent of the land is used for forests and range. Less than I2 per cent is used for the production of field TABLE I Land Use in the Pacific Northwest' (In thousands of acres) Land use Cropland Forest land Range land
Total
Idaho
Oregon
Washington
5,230 18,813 28,729
5,537 29,755 26,349
7,721 24,100 10,929
18,488 743,668 66,000
543,97Q
61,641
4'2,743
157,356
- -
Total
* Sourcea of data: Cropland acreage and total acreage from 1960 U. S. Census of Agriculture. Forest land acreage baaed on U. S. Department of Agriculture Forest Service Reappraisal Data, 1946. Range land acreage by difference.
and horticultural crops. Approximately one-fourth of the forest land is noncommercial owing to high altitude, rugged topography, and inadequate moisture, or because it has been set aside for recreation or watershed protection. Wild animals and domestic cattle graze much of the noncommercial forest area. T h e land used for crop production is widely distributed throughout the region (Fig. 4). One-fourth of the total cropland acreage is irrigated. In 1949 about 60 per cent of the total cropland was in harvested crops, 22 per cent was in cultivated summer fallow, 13 per cent was used only for pasture, and 5 per cent was idle or in crops not harvested. Owing to the diversity of climate and soil, the types of crops grown vary widely. Similarly, crop production and soil management problems change sharply from one area to another.
111. SOILRESOURCES The Pacific Northwest has been divided into 11 major kinds of soil area (Fig. 3), primarily on the basis of soil differences related to dif-
8 H. B. CHENEY,
w. H. FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, AND H. H. RAMPTON
FIQ.3. Soils of the Pacific Northwest. (Source: Highsmith,1956.)
FIELD CROP PRODUCTION AND SOIL MANAGEMENT
9
ferences in climate. These 11 kinds of area or map units consist of single soil zones, combinations of soil zones, or subdivisions of a soil zone. (A soil zone is a geographic unit within which there is uniformity in those soil characteristics which are determined by climate.) Each map unit is described in terms of climate, natural vegetation, the common soils, map inclusions, and land use. The soils are characterized by reference to 28 great soil groups, in terms of horizon sequence and selected properties of the dominant horizons. In the descriptions, horizons designated with an asterisk are essential for the group. Those designated by parentheses are permissible but not common. Horizon nomenclature and descriptive terms are defined in the Soil Survey Manual (Soil Survey Staff, 1951). The concepts and nomenclature of the great soil groups are based on an unpublished family grouping of soils of the Far Western States made by Ray C. Roberts in May, 1952. For many groups the concepts and names are those given in the 1938 Yearbook of Agriculture (Baldwin et al., 1938) or by Thorp and Smith (1949).The names of other groups are designated by quotation marks. It is thought that there is general but not complete agreement about the groups among those concerned with classification in the three states. The map itself is compiled from many sources. The primary sources are unpublished soil association maps of the Far Western States prepared by members of the correlation staff (mainly by R. C. Roberts and W. J. Leighty) of the Soil Conservation Service, United States Department of Agriculture. Important revisions were suggested by R. C. Roberts, M. A. Fosberg (Idaho Agricultural Experiment Station), W. A. Starr (Washington Agricultural Experiment Station), and R. W. Chapin, W. W. Hill, and C. F. Parrott (Soil Conservation Service).
1. Sierozem Zone Precipitation: Mean Jan. temp.: Mean July temp.: Typical natural vegetation:
Dominant welldrained soils: Dominant wet soils:
5 to 10 inches 30 to 33” F. 65 to 75” F. Big sagebrush (Ariemisia trideniata Nutt.),bluebunch wheatgrass (Agropyron spicuturn (Pursh) Scribn. & Sm.), and hopsage (Gruya spinosa (Hook.) Moq.) on Sierozems. Shadscale (Atriplez confertifolia (Torr.) Wats.) and bud sage (Ariernisiu spinescens D. C. Eaton) on Desert soils. Greasewood (Sarcobntus verrniculutus (Hook.) Torr.) and salt grass (Distichlis stricta (Torr.) Rydb.) in saline and alkali areas. Sierozem, with Desert soils in the dryst areas. “Calcic Gley,” Solonetz and solodized-Solonetz soils. In irrigated areas there is an increasing proportion of artificially saline soils.
10
H. B. CHENEY, W. H. FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, AND H. H. RAMPTON
Other soils: Inclusions of other soil zones: Land use:
Lithosols (especially on lava flows in southern Idaho), Regosols (especially in wind-deposited materials in Washington), and Alluvial soils. Brown, Chestnut, and Brown Forest-Gray Wooded Zones with increasing elevation and precipitation and decreasing temperatures. Range for cattle and sheep on Sierozems. Winter range for sheep on Desert soils, Horticultural and field crops with irrigation chiefly on soils from alluvium in the valleys.
Typical characteristics of common soils: Desert soils-A1*, BI, Bs*, Bs.., (Bm), Cca, (Cm), (D), C, Dr. The A is 1 to 4 inches thick, light gray when dry, low in organic matter, vesicular, and calcareous. There is a thin surface crust, polygonal cracking, and desert pavement. The B is commonly a horizon of clay accumulation, darker in color and higher in organic matter than the A, calcareous, and with small blocky or subangular blocky peds. Sierozem soils-Al*, B , Br*, BI, (Bats), Cca, (Cm), (D), C, Dr. The A is 3 to 6 inches thick, light brownish gray when dry, low in organic matter, vesicular, not calcareous, and has a thin surface crust, polygonal cracking, and pH values from 7.0 to 8.0. The B is commonly a horizon of clay accumulation, darker than the A in color and calcareous, with blocky or subangular blocky structure. Solonetz soils-A*, Bz*, Bs, (Bm), (Cm), (D), C. The A is 2 to 10 inches thick with properties which vary from zone to zone. The B is a horizon of clay accumulation, with dark-coated, prismatic, or columnar peds and pH values from 8.5 to 10.0. “Calcic Gley” soils-(A1), C,*, Cm, (D), G. The Cl is calcareous with pH values from 8.5 to 10.0. I t is a horizon of evaporation from a relatively high water table. Solodized-Solonetz soils-Refer to the Brown Zone. Lithosols-Refer to the Podzol-Brown Podzolic Zones. Regosols-(Aoo), (Ao), A,, C*, (Cca), (Cm). Regosols are from unconsolidated material other than alluvium. They have weakly expressed or no developed horizons. Alluvial soils-Refer to Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Lowland Areas.
2. Brown Zone Precipitation: Mean Jm. temp.: Mean July temp.: Typical natural vegetation: Dominant welldrained soils: Dominant wet SO&:
Other soils: Inclusions of 0th- soil zones:
8 to 12 inches. 20 to 32” F. 65 to 75” F. Perennial bunch grasses and big sage. Greasewood and salt grass in saline and alkali areas. Brown soils.
“Calcic Gley,” Solonetz, solodized-Solonetz and “Humic Gley” soils. Alluvial soils and Lithosols (in southern Idaho). Sierozem Zone in the dryest parts of the delineation, especially on south-facing slopes and in shallow areas. Chestnut Zone in the parts of the delineation with highest rainfall espe-
FIELD CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL MANAGEMENT
Land use:
11
cially on north-facing slopes. Brown Forest-Gray Wooded Zones at high elevations. Range land, wheat-fallow cultivation in best areas, and horticultural and field crops with irrigation, chiefly on soils from alluvium in the valleys.
Typical characteristics of common soils: Brown Soils-A1*, b,Bl, &*,B,, Cca, (Cm), (D), C, Dr. The A is 5 to 10 inches thick, grayish brown when dry, with platy breaking to granular structure, and pH values from 6.5 to 7.5. The B is commonly a horizon of clay accumulation, slightly brighter in color (with higher chroma) than the A, with prismatic breaking to blocky or subangular blocky structure, and pH values from 7.0 to 8.5. “Calcic Gley” soils-Refer to the Sierozem Zone. Solonetz soils-Refer to the Sierozem Zone. Solodized-Solonetz-Al, A*, &*, B8, (Bm), (Cm), (D), C. The A is 5 to 15 inches thick with pH values from 6.0 to 7.0. The B is a horizon of clay accumulation, with prismatic or columnar structure, dark coatings on the peds, and pH values from 6.5 to 7.5. “Humic Gley” soils-Refer to the Chernozem Zone. Alluvial Soils-Refer to the Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Lowland Areas. Lithosols-Refer to the Podzol-Brown Podzolic Zones.
3. Chestnut Zone Precipitation: Mean Jan. temp.: Mean July temp.: Typical natural vegetation: Dominant welldrained soils: Dominant wet soils: Other soils: Inclusions of other soil zones: Land use:
10 to 15 inches. 90 to 32” F. 65 to 75” F. Perennial bunch grasses. Greasewood and salt grass in saline and alkali areas. Chestnut soils.
“Humic Gley” soils, solodized-Solonetz soils (or Planosols), “Calcic Gley” soils, and Solonetz soils. “Grumusols” on parent materials very high in clay. Alluvial soils. Brown Zone in dryest parts of the delineation, especially on south-facing slopes and in shallow areas. Chernozem Zone in parts of the delineation with highest rainfall. Brown ForestGray Wooded Zones at high elevations. Dry land wheat-fallow or continuous wheat cultivation. Range. Horticultural and field crops with irrigation, chiefly on soils from alluvium in the valleys.
Typical characteristics of common soils: Chestnut soils-A1*, A, BI, &*, B,, Cca, (Cm), (D), C, Dr. The A is 7 to 15 inches thick, dark grayish brown when dry, with platy breaking to granular structure and pH values from 6.5 to 7.5. The B is commonly a horizon of clay accumulation, brighter in color (with higher chroma) than the A, with prismatic breaking to blocky or subangular blocky structure and pH values from 7.0 to 8.5.
12
H. B. CHENEY, W. H. FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, AND H. H. RAMPTON
“Humic Gley” soils-Refer to Chernozem Zone. Solodized-Solonetz soils-Refer to Brown Zone. Solonetz soils-Refer to Sierozem Zone. “Calcic Gley” soils-Refer- to Sierozem Zone. “Grumuso1s”-Refer to Reddish Brown Latosol-Noncalcic Brown Zones. Alluvial soils-Refer to Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Lowland Areas.
4 . Chernozem Zone Precipitation: Mean Jan. temp.: Mean July temp.: Typical natural vegetation: Dominant welldrained soils: Dominant wet soils: Other soils: Inclusions of other soil zones: Land use:
15 to 22 inches. 20 to 32” F. 60 to 70” F. Perennial bunch grasses with shrubs such as snowberry (Symphoricarpos albw (L.) Blake.) and rose, and forbes especially in Prairie areas. There is a strong tendency for sod formation in Prairie areas. Chernozem and Prairie (Brunizem) soils.
“Humic Gley” soils, Planosols (or solodized-Solonetz), and “Calcic Gley” soils. Alluvial soils. Chestnut Zone in dry areas. Brown Forest-Gray Wooded Zones at high elevations. Dryland cultivation (continuous wheat or wheat-peas) Range. Horicultural and field crops with irrigation.
.
Typical characteristics of common soils: Chernozem and Prairie soils-Al*, As, B,, BZ*, Bs, Cca’, (D), C, Dr. (1. Cca is essential for Chernozem and not permissible for Prairie.) The A is more than 12 inches thick, very dark grayish brown or darker when dry, with granular structure and pH values from 6.0 to 7.0. The B is commonly a horizon of clay accumulation, lighter than the A in color, with blocky or subangular blocky structure and pH values from 6.5 to 8.0. “Humic Gley” soils-A,*, A, B,, Bt, Bs, (Cm) , (D) ,C. The A is 6 to 30 inches thick, dark gray to black, with pH values from 6.5 to 8.0. T h e B is a horizon of either clay accumulation or maximum color intensity. It may be gleyed. Planosols-Refer to Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Lowland Areas. “Calcic Gley” soils-Refer to Sierozem Zone. Alluvial soils-Refer to Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Lowland Areas.
5 . Brown Forest-Gray Wooded Zones Precipitation: Mean Jan. temp.: Mean July temp.:
15 to 30 inches, 15 to 25” F. 60 to 70“ F.
The growing season is short. Typical natural vegetation:
Ponderosa pine (Pinw ponderosa Laws.) or lodgepole pine (P.contorts Loud.), white fir (Abies concolor Lindl.), bitterbrush (Purshiu tridentata (Pursh) D.C.), manzanita (Arctostaphylos spp.) , and mountain mahogany (Cercocarpus ledifolius T. & G.).
FIELD CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL MANAGEMENT Dominant welldrained soils: Dominant wet soils: Other soils: Inclusions of other soil zones: Land use:
13
Brown Forest soils, with Gray Wooded and Prairie soils in northern Washington and Idaho. “Humic Gley” soils. Alluvial soils. Brown, Chestnut, and Chernozem zones at low elevations and in low rainfall areas. Podzol-Brown Podzolic Zones at the highest elevations. Forestry. Summer range, Gray Wooded and Prairie areas are cultivated.
Typical characteristics of common soils: “Brown Forest” soils--Am, A, Al*, (AS), B,, &*, Bt,(Cm), (D), C, Dr. The & is an F layer 0 to 2 inches thick. The A1 is 4 to 8 inches thick, dark grayish brown when dry, with granular structure and p H values from 6.0 to 7.0. The B is commonly a horizon of clay accumulation, warm brown (with high chroma) in color, with blocky or subangular blocky structure and pH values from 5.5 to 6.5. Gray Wooded Soils-&, A*, (A1), A*, B2*,Bs, Cca, (D), C, (Dr). The A includes F and H layers and is 1 to 6 inches thick with pH values from 5.0 to 7.0. The A is Ito 8 inches thick, light gray, platy or massive, with pH values from 5.5 to 7.0. The B is a horizon of clay accumulation, with blocky or subangular blocky structure and pH values from 6.0 to 8.0. Prairie soils-Refer to the Chernozem Zone. “Humic Gley” soils-Refer to the Chernozem Zone. Alluvial soils-Refer to the Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Lowland Areas.
6. Podzol-Brown Podzolic Zones (Mountainous Areas) Precipitation: Mean Jan. temp. : Mean July temp.:
30 to 100 inches. 15 to 30’ F. 55 to 65” F.
The growing season is short. Typical natural vegetation: Dominant welldrained soils: Dominant wet soils: Other soils: Inclusions of other soil zones: Land use:
Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii (Mirb.) Franco) , hemlock (Tsugu heterophylla (Raf.) Sarg.), western redcedar (Thuju plicaiu Donn.), larch (Larii occidentalis Nutt.), spruce (Picea spp.), white fir, pine. Brown Podzolic soils and Podzols with “Mountain Meadow” soils at high elevations. “Humic Gley” and Alpine Meadow soils. Lithosols and Regosols on steep mountain slopes. Brown Forest-Gray Wooded Zones at lower elevations in Idaho and eastern Oregon and Washington. Brown Latozol Zone at lower elevations in the Oregon and southern Washington Cascades and on the Olympic peninsula. Forestry. Recreation. Summer range (in open areas especially).
Typical characteristics of common soils: Brown Podzolic soils-Refer to Brown Podzolic Zone. Podzol Soils-&, A*, (Al), AS*, &*, (Bm), BI, (D), C. The A includes F and H layers and is 2 to 10 inches thick, with p H values from 4.0 to 5.0. The b is 1 to 10 inches thick, light gray, platy or massive, with pH
14
H. B. CHENEY,
w. H.
FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, AND H. EI. RAMPTON
values from 4.5 to 5.5. The B is a horizon of humus and iron oxide accumulation, yellowish brown, with fine or very fine crumb structure, and pH values from 5.0 to 6.0. “Mountain Meadow” soils-AI*, AS, B,, Ba,Bi, (D), C. The A is 6 to 20 inches thick, very dark grayish brown or darker, with fme granular structure and pH values from 4.5 to 5.5. The B is a horizon of maximum color intensity, yellowish brown, with pH values from 4.5 to 5.5. “Humic Gley” soils-Refer to the Brown Latosol Zone. Alpine Meadow mils-A1*, A, BG*, (D), C. The A is 6 to 10 inches thick, nearly black, with pH values from 5.0 to 6.0. The BG is a gleyed horizon with gray and/or mottled colors and pH values from 5.0 to 6.0. Lithomls-((Am), (Ao), Al, C, Dr*. Lithosols are shallow to bedrock, with weakly expressed or no developed horizons. Regosols-Refer to the Sierozem Zone.
7. Brown Podzolic Zone This zone is in an area of continental glaciation. Precipitation: Mean Jan. temp.: Mean July temp.: Typical natural vegetation: Dominant welldrained soils: Dominant wet soils: Other soils: Land use:
20 to 60 inches. 35 to 40” F. 55 to 65” F. Douglas-fir, hemlock, alder (Alnus rubra Bong.), and western redcedar. Brown Podzolic soils, with “Gray Podzolic” soils in the dryer areas. Ground-Water Podzols and “Humic Gley” soils. Alluvial soils. Horticultural and field crops. Forages. Forestry. There is intensive cultivation on Alluvial soils.
Typical characteristics of common soils:
A’, AI, (At), Bz*, (Bm), Bs, (D), C. Brown Podzolic soils-&, The includes F and H layers and is 1 to 6 inches thick with pH values from 4.0 to 5.0. The Al is 0 to 3 inches thick. The B is a horizon of humus and iron oxide accumulation, yellowish brown, with fine or very fine crumb structure and pH values from 5.0 to 6.0. “Gray Podzolic” soils-&, A*, A*, B*, (D), C, (Dr). The A is 1 to 4 inches thick with pH values from 5.0 to 6.0. The At is 2 to 10 inches thick, light brownish gray or lighter, commonly with spherical concretions, and with pH values from 5.0 to 6.0. The B is darker than the AZ and has poorly defined subangular blocky structure and pH values from 5.0 to 6.0. Ground-Water Podzols--Am, &*,A,, A,*, Bh, B2*, Bs, (D), C. The A, is 2 to 8 inches thick with pH values from 4.0 to 5.0. The A1 is 1 to 10 inches thick and black with pH values from 4.5 to 5.5. The G is 3 to 15 inches thick, light gray or lighter, and mottled, with pH values from 4f.5 to 5.5. The B is a horizon of humus and iron oxide accumulation, and commonly cemented into a pan (orstein), with pH values from 4.5 to 5.5. “Humic Gley” soils-Refer to the Brown Latosol Zone. Alluvial soilsRefer to the Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Lowland Area.
FIELD CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL MANAGEMENT
15
8 . Brown Latosol Zone Precipitation: Mean Jan. temp.: Mean July temp.: Typical natural vegetation: Dominant welldrained soils: Dominant wet soils: Other soils: Land use:
60 to 140 inches. 35 to 45” F. 55 to 65” F. Douglas-fir, hemlock, western redcedar, Sitka spruce (Picea sitchemis (Bong.) Carr.), and alder. “Brown Latosols.”
“Humic Gley” soils and Planosols. “Fern prairie” or “Ando” soils on nonforested areas near the coast. Podzols and Ground-Water Podzols on sands of the coastal area. Alluvial soils. Forestry. Cultivated crops (chiefly forages on dairy farms) on soils from alluvium in the valleys or on marine terraces along the coast.
Typical characteristics of common soils: “Brown Latosols”-&, A,*, A, BI, &*, BI, (D), C, Dr. The A is 10 to 20 inches thick, dark brown or darker, with strong granular structure and pH values from 5.0 to 6.0. The B is a horizon of residual iron and aluminum oxides, brown or dark yellowish brown, friable, with clay texture and pH values from 4.0 to 5.0. “Humic Gley” soils-A,*, G,BG*, CG, (D), C, Dr. The A is 6 to 30 inches thick, black or very dark gray, with pH values from 5.0 to 6.0. The BG is a gleyed horizon, mottled or gray, with pH values from 5.5 to 6.5. “Ando” soils-&*, A, &, &, B+ (D), C, Dr. The A is 10 to 30 inches thick, very dark grayish brown or darker, light in weight, with fine or very fine granular structure, and pH values from 5.5 to 6.5. The B is a horizon of maximum color intensity, of clay accumulation, or of residual iron and aluminum oxides, with p H values from 5.0 to 6.0. Podzols-Refer to the Podzol-Brown Podzolic Zones. Ground-Water Podzols-Refer to the Brown Podzolic Zone. Alluvial soils-Refer to the Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Lowland Areas. Planosols-Refer to the Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Lowland Areas.
9. Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Upland Precipitation : Mean Jan. temp.: Mean July temp. : Typical natural vegetation: Dominant welldrained soils: Dominant wet soils: Inclusions of other soil zones: Land use:
Areas
40 to 60 inches. 32 to 40” F. 60 to 65” F. Douglas-fu; western redcedar. “Reddish Brown Latosols.” “Humic Gley” soils and Planosols. Reddish Brown Latosols Zone-Lowland Areas in narrow river valleys. Forestry. Field and Horticultural crops in areas of favorable topography.
16
H. B. CHENEY,
w. H. FOOTE,
E. G. KNOX, AND H. H. RAMPTON
Typical characteristics of common soils: “Reddish Brown Latosols”-&, AX*, A, B,, BI*, Ba, (D), C, Dr. The A is 6 to 12 inches thick, dark reddish brown or darker, with strong granular structure and spherical concretions, and with pH values from 5.5 to 6.5. The B is a horizon of residual iron and aluminum oxide accumulation (it may also show evidence of silicate clay accumulation), dark red or dark reddish brown, friable, with clay texture, and pH values from 4.5 to 5.5. “Humic Gley” soils-Refer to the Brown Latosol Zone. Planosols-Refer to the Reddish Brown Latosol Zon-Lowland Areas.
10. Reddish Brown Latosol Zone--Lowland Precipitation: Mean Jan. temp.: Mean July temp.: Typical natural vegetation: Dominant welldrained soils: Dominant wet soils: Inclusions of other soil zones: Land use:
Areas
35 to 50 inches. 35 to 40” F. 60 to 65’ F. Douglas-fr, Oregon white oak (Quercus garryam Hook.), and grasses. An unclassified group, “Reddish Brown Latosols,” and Alluvial soils. Planosols, “Humic Gley” soils. Reddish Brown Latosol-Noncalcic Brown Zones.
Horticultural and field crops with and without irrigation. Forages. Grass and legume seeds. There is intensive cultivation of horticultural crops on Alluvial soils with irrigation.
Typical characteristics of common soils: Unclassified group-Al*, A, BI, BI*, B , (D), C. The A is 6 to 15 inches thick, very dark grayish brown when moist, grayish brown when dry, with granular structure and pH values from 5.5 to 6.5; the B is a horizon of clay accumulation, with blocky, subangular blocky, or prismatic structure, and pH values from 6.0 to 7.0. “Reddish Brown Latosols”-Refer to Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Upland Areas. Alluvial soils-(Aou), (AO), At, C*, (Cca), (Cm). Alluvial soils are from recent alluvium. They have weakly expressed or no developed horizons. Planosols-Al*, A*, BI*, BI, (D), C, (Dr). The A, is 2 to 10 inches thick, with pH values from 5.0 to 6.0. The A is 4 to 12 inches thick, grayish brown or lighter, with p H values from 4.5 to 5.5. The B, is a horizon of intense clay accumulation, with prismatic or columnar structure, and pH values from 4.5 to 7.0. “Humic Gley” soils-Refer to Brown Latosol Zone.
11. Reddish Brown Latosol-Noncalcic Brown Zones Precipitation: Mean Jan. temp.: Mean July temp.: Typical natural vegetation :
20 to 60 inches. 32 to 40” F. 62 to 70’ F. Douglas-fw, ponderosa pine, sugar pine (Pinus larnberiiam Dougl.), California black oak (Quercus kelloggii Newb.), madrone (Arbutus rnenziesii Pursh), grasses, manzanita, poison oak (Rhus diversiloba T. & G . ) , rose.
F I E L D CROP P R O D U C T I O N A N D SOIL M A N A G E M E N T
Dominant welldrained soils: Dominant wet soils: Other soils: Land use:
17
“Reddish Brown Latosols,” Noncalcic Brown soils, Prairielike soils, and “Grumusols.” “Humic Gley” soils and “Grumusols.” Alluvial soils. Forestry. Unimproved pasture (range). Cultivation of horticultural and field crops with irrigation.
Typical characteristics of common soils: “Reddish Brown Latosols”-Refer to the Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Upland Areas. Noncalcic Brown soils-A,*, BI, &*, (Bm), Bs, (D), C, Dr. The A is 3 to 10 inches thick, low in organic matter, with weak structure, and pH values from 5.0 to 6.0. The B is a horizon of clay accumulation, reddish or yellowish in color, with prismatic, blocky, or subangular blocky structure, and pH values from 5.0 to 6.0. Prairie-like soils-Refer to Chernozem Zone. “Grumusols”-AI*, G,(D), C, Dr. The A (divided into A and B by some) is 8 to 41) inches thick, black, or less commonly gray, olive or red, extremely hard, very plastic, and very sticky, with clay texture. With drying, the horizon cracks deeply and the surfaces mulches into small granules. “Humic Gley” soils-Refer to the Brown Latozol Zone. Alluvial soilcRefer to Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Lowland Areas.
IV. SOILMANAGEMENT Owing to the diversity of soil management problems and practices, they will be discussed largely by soil zones as shown in Fig. 3. The Podzol-Brown Podzolic Zones and Brown Forest-Gray Wooded Zones are not discussed. Crop production in these zones is largely confined to narrow alluvial valleys, many with unique local soil problems. The general use of soil management practices will be summarized for the entire region insofar as information is available. 1. Use of Soil Management Practices a. General. Information on the extent to which most soil management practices are used is not available for the region. Only general comments can be made about their use. For a few practical statistical information is available. Practices to reduce runoff and aid erosion control, such as contour farming, contour strip cropping, contour planting of orchards, vineyards, and cane fruits, terraces, field diversions, and wind strip cropping, are used to a limited extent. In 1953, 17 per cent of the total Agricultural Conservation Program payments in the region was used for mechanical practices primarily for erosion control. Crop residues are generally used and not burned, except in a few local areas. Stubble mulch is practiced in the drier wheat-growing areas. The use of crop rotations, green manures, and cover crops varies widely.
18
w. H. FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, AND H.H. RAMPTON Individual farmers, especially in western Oregon, have been making progress in improving drainage, Some community projects also are underway. Approximately 10 per cent of the total Agricultural Conservation Program payments in 1953 in the region were used for drainage. b. Irrigation. Approximately 25 per cent of the total cropland in the region is irrigated. As shown in Table 11, the number of acres irrigated is increasing. This increase in acreage is occurring largely in Oregon and Washington, but Idaho still has about one-half of the irrigated land in the region. Much of the increased acreage in Washington during the past five years is in the Columbia Basin Project of the Bureau of H. B. CHENEY,
TABLE I1 Irrigated Land in the Pacific Northwest' (In thousands of acres) Stat+!ear Idaho Oregon
Washington Total
1920
1939
1949
1954
$181 899 499
1896 1030 494
2137 1307 689
2144 1490 778
-
-
-
-
3579
3419
4033
4414
~
1 Source:
U. S. Ceniua of Agriculture for 1930. 1940,1960,
1964 (Preliminary).
Reclamation located in the central part of the state. In Oregon, 40 per cent of the increase from 1949 to 1954 occurred in the western part of the state. Much of the increased acreage is sprinkler irrigated. In 1949, sprinklers were used on 4 per cent of the irrigated acreage. Over onehalf of the sprinkler irrigation was in Oregon. Improvement in irrigation practices and improvement and development of irrigation systems is progressing. In 1953 over one-fourth of the total, or nearly 1.5 million dollars, spent under the Agricultural Conservation Program was used for irrigation practices. Irrigation will continue to expand, both in small tracts and in large projects such as the Columbia Basin Irrigation project in central Washington. Estimates of potentially irrigable land indicate that the acreage under irrigation in the region may eventually be twice the present acreage. c. Fertilizers. Fertilizer consumption in the region in 1953-54 was 438,665 tons, according to Scholl et QZ. (1955). This is approximately double the annual use from 1947 to 1950. Washington leads in fertilizer consumption, with Oregon second and Idaho third. Consumption in Washington increased 60 per cent from 195!2-53 to 1953-54. Consumption of nitrogen (N) , available phosphoric acid (P,O,), and potash (K,O) in the region during recent years is given in Table
19 111. Nitrogen use has been increasing rapidly whereas phosphate and potash consumption has held nearly constant since 1947. Phosphate use did increase markedly in 1953-54. A large portion of the increase in nitrogen use occurred in the dryland wheat area of the Chernozem and Chestnut Zones. The use of anhydrous and aqua ammonia have both increased rapidly in this area since they were introduced two to five years ago. The average content of available nutrients in the fertilizers used is relatively high, averaging 28 per cent in 1953-54. It increased from 24 per cent in 1947-48. For the region the average ratio of N-P,O,-K,O FIELD CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL M A N A G E M E N T
TABLE I11 Consumption of Primary Plant Nutrients in the Pacific Northwest' (Thousands of tons)
Year 1955-51 1953-5s 1951-5Q 1950-51 1949-50 1948-49 1
Nitrogen 74 59 40
Available pzos 41
3s
3% 3s 352
2s 16
31 528
K2O
Total
8 7
12s
7 7
80 73
8 6
63 60
98
Source: Scholl and Wallace (1050, 1951, 1050, 1055) and Sclioll el ul. (1954. 1955).
was 1.0-0.55-0.11 in 1953-54. However, this ratio varies widely in different areas. In 1953-54 only 13 per cent of the total tonnage of fertilizers used consisted of mixed fertilizers. Separate materials have always been popular in the region. Mixed fertilizers have been used most extensively in the western parts of Washington and Oregon. They are used to a greater extent on horticultural crops and potatoes than on other field crops. d. Liming Materials. The use of liming materials is confined largely to western Oregon and western Washington. The use of liming materials during the past 10 years has fluctuated between 40,000 to 60,000 tons annually in Oregon and between 20,000 and 40,000 tons in Washington. Ground limestone is used most extensively but other liming materials, such as waste sugar beet lime, are also important. Owing to lack of high-quality limestone deposits in the acid soil areas most of the high-purity limestone must be transported several hundred miles. Consequently, the price, which averages about $12.00 per ton, is high compared with the price in Midwest areas. Limestone quality is variable, but it has been improved in recent years.
20
H. B. CHENEY,
W.
H . FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, A N D H. H. RAMPTON
2. Sierozem Zone Irrigation is essential for crop production in the Sierozem Zone; hence soil and water management problems on irrigated land are the only ones considered. Similar problems also exist where land is irrigated in the Brown, Chestnut, and Chernozem Zones. Much of the earlier irrigation was started on the alluvial or lowlying soils, but an increasing acreage of zonal soils has been brought under irrigation as new projects have been developed. Most of the irrigated land in the drier regions east of the Cascades was developed on a project basis by the Bureau of Reclamation, or in some cases by private enterprise. Much of it depends on flood water stored in large reservoirs. However, an appreciable acreage is irrigated by individual ranchers or farmers from streams or from wells. A considerable acreage of wild meadows in the range area is flooded in the spring with little control of the water. Irrigating the “desert” provides abundant opportunities but at the same time creates many problems. Except for soil acidity, most of the problems of the humid or semihumid regions are encountered, plus a host of new ones. They may be listed briefly as follows: ( I ) quality of irrigation water, (2) irrigation practices, (3) fertility, ( 4 ) soil physical condition, (5) drainage, (6) salinity and alkalinity, (7) low organic matter content, and ( 8 ) erosion. The major irrigation waters are of high quality for irrigation usage (Jensen et al., 1951; Singleton et al., 1950). However, certain areas do have poor-quality water. Some water provides nutrient ions in sufficient quantities to meet crop needs. This is true of potassium, boron, and sulfur in some areas. Most of the irrigation water is applied by surface methods such as strip borders, basins, corrugations, and contour flooding. However, sprinkler systems are increasing. The agronomist is concerned primarily with water, soil, and plant relationships. Parks (1951) has reviewed the development, present status, and future trends of irrigation agriculture. Physical characteristics of the soil affect the design of irrigation systems and the water management programs to be followed. Moisture movement and its availability to plants is receiving increased attention in research programs. Nitrogen must be supplied in large amounts for all nonlegume crops and for some legumes such as peas and beans. Since the organic matter content of most of these soils is low-often less than 1 per cent -the reserve of total nitrogen in the soil also is low. Both legumes and fertilizers are used extensively to supply the ni-
F I E L D CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL M A N A G E M E N T
21
trogen needs. Alfalfa is grown on one-quarter to one-third of the land in some projects. The use of Ladino clover in pastures is a common practice. Sweet clover generally has not been satisfactory. Other legumes also are used in the rotation for hay, seed, pasture, green manure, or cover crops. These crops not only supply nitrogen but also aid in the control of erosion and maintenance of organic matter (Morrison et al., 1954; Nelson and Larson, 1946). Nitrogen fertilizers are used quite generally for crops such as sugar beets, corn, potatoes, and horticultural crops. Recommended rates are relatively high, especially in the Columbia Basin. For example, on sugar beets they range from 80 to 120 pounds of nitrogen per acre following alfalfa to 240 to 300 pounds per acre on new land previously in dryland wheat (Nelson, 1954). For corn following alfalfa the suggested rate is 80 to 120 pounds of nitrogen and on new land from 120 to 160 pounds per acre (Nelson, 1953). Hunter and Yungen (1952, 1955) and Yungen, Hunter, and Bond (unpublished data), after conducting a large number of fertilizer experiments in the Ontario area of eastern Oregon, concluded that somewhat lower rates of nitrogen generally would produce maximum yields in this area. For sugar beets, potatoes, and corn 100 to 120 pounds of nitrogen per acre was usually sufficient for optimum yields. Deficiencies of nutrients other than nitrogen vary. Most soils are well supplied with available potassium. Sulfur deficiencies occur in some areas but not in others. Phosphate fertilizers are used by many farmers f o r crops such as sugar beets, potatoes, and alfalfa. The response to phosphate fertilizers is quite variable. Significant increases in yield are obtained on many sites. Many farmers use phosphate fertilizers consistently even though field experiments show no response to phosphorus. All three states encourage the use of soil tests as a guide to the need for phosphorus. Trace element deficiencies exist under some crop and soil conditions. The zinc problem has been studied extensively in Washington by Wets et al. (1953a, b, 1954). Zinc deficiencies also are apparent under some conditions in Oregon and Idaho. Lime-induced chlorosis, for which ferrous iron has been used (Blodgett, 1946), and boron deficiency also occur. Drainage problems arise largely as the result of overirrigation, although some river bottom areas had a high water table before irrigation. Usually the low-lying land was irrigated first. Later successively higher areas may have been irrigated; often this has resulted in higher and higher water tables in the older irrigated section. If underlying geological formations are complex and variable, surface topography may give little information as to the real nature of the drainage prob-
B. I . C H E N E Y , W. H. FOOTE, E. G. K N O X , A N D H.’H. RAMPTON 22 € lem. This type of problem needs to be approached on a physiographic area basis. The State College of Washington (unpublished data) has developed and applied this approach in the Moxee Valley. Since much of the drainage problem results from overirrigation, greater use of presently known irrigation techniques for efficient water use will help, as will installation of drainage systems. High water tables in an arid area are usually accompanied by the formation of saline or alkali soils. Saline and alkali soil conditions reduce the value and productivity of a considerable acreage. Fireman d al. (1950) give the characteristics of saline and alkali soils in the Emmet Valley area of Idaho. These problem soils were characterized by high water table conditions, low salinity, high pH, high soluble and exchangeable sodium percentages, and low rates of infiltration and permeability. They suggest the following points for consideration in the proper management and reclamation of these soils:
“I. Control of excessive and wasteful use of irrigation water. 2. Improvement of the drainage system based upon studies of the subsoil and ground water conditions in the valley. 3. Use of gypsum and other chemical amendments for the reclamation of high sodium soils. Consideration should be given to the use of barnyard and green manures. 4. Investigation of leaching for reclamation, including the use of drainage water during the initial stages.”
The diagnosis and improvement of saline and alkali soils is reviewed and discussed thoroughly by Richards ( 1954). Mech (1949) points out that it is possible to have serious erosion on the upper end of irrigated fields even when neither soil or water is wasted at the tail end of irrigation runs. The control of wind erosion on the sandy soils in the Columbia Basin involves several practices, according to Mech (1955). These include cultivation when the soil is wet to produce clods, use of crop residues and plant cover, and leveling in late summer.
3. Brown Zone The amount of available moisture, more than any other factor, limits the production of wheat, which is the dominant cultivated crop grown without irrigation, in the Brown Zone. Although wind erosion predominates, some of the land also is affected by water erosion. Balancing the available nitrogen supply with the moisture supply is often difficult. Farmers of Brown soils must be satisfied with relatively low yields (10 to 30 bushels of wheat per acre). Even with summer fallow, which
F I E L D CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL M A N A G E M E N T
23
is nearly universally practiced in the area, the moisture supply is insufficient for higher yields. In addition to evaporation losses, some moisture is lost by runoff on certain slopes. Moreover, some soils are shallow in depth and lack sufficient storage capacity to conserve all the precipitation that falls. Since most of the wheat is seeded in the fall and most of the rainfall comes in the winter, there is always a considerable element of risk in this near-marginal rainfall area. Stubble mulch or trashy fallow is used extensively by farmers in this area. It is a very effective practice for reducing both wind and water erosion. Reduction in yield with trashy fallow in this area is much less (averaging 1 to 3 bushels per acre) than in the higher rainfall area (Chestnut and Chernozem Zones). Owing to low yields of straw, trashy fallow in the Brown Zone is far easier to prepare and till than is true in the higher rainfall area, where large yields of straw are common. Cushman (1955) and McKay and Moss (19M) give additional information on this practice. The supply of available nitrogen from soil organic matter is often adequate or even excessive for maximum yields where a low supply of available water is the limiting factor. In fact, additions of nitrogen fertilizer may cause “burning,” shriveled kernels, and reduced yields in some cases as a result of stimulation of excessive vegetative growth in the early spring and early exhaustion of available soil moisture. Nevertheless, in many instances improved yields can be obtained with the addition of nitrogen fertilizer, but the risk is greater &an in higher rainfall areas. From none to 20 pounds of nitrogen per acre is a customary recommendation. Large areas of the Brown soils and their associates are irrigated. The management problems are similar to those encountered in the irrigated areas of the Sierozem Zone. 4. Chestnut Zone
Soil management problems and practices in the Chestnut Zone of the Columbia Basin dryland wheat area are intermediate between those of the Brown and Chernozem Zones. Available moisture and nitrogen to a considerable extent control the yields of wheat, which is the dominant crop. Both erosion and the wheat-fallow system of farming have contributed to the decline of soil organic matter. Since many of the slopes average 5 to 10 per cent, sheet erosion by water is a problem. Especially in certain of the drier parts of the area wind erosion also occurs. The summer fallow practice aids in (I) increasing the supply of moisture, (2) the release of nitrogen from organic matter, and (3) control of weeds. On most soils in the area it is still considered an essential
24
H. B. CHENEY,
w.
H. FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, AND H. H. RAMPTON
practice for maximum wheat production. However, in recent years some growers are re-evaluating this practice. Nitrogen can be supplied from commercial fertilizers. Where the soils are shallow, 18 to 30 inches in depth, the entire soil profile may become wet to field capacity within one season. Chemicals are aiding in the weed control program. Consequently, before acreage allotments made decreases in wheat acreage mandatory, some farmers were trying either continuous wheat or only occasional fallow on their shallower soils. A careful check of rainfall and of soil moisture is used as a guide in determining when to recrop and when to fallow. In recent years, nitrogen fertilizers have been used extensively throughout most of the area. On deep soils, in years of average or above average rainfall, insufficient available nitrogen rather than moisture has limited yields. The need for balancing the rate of application of nitrogen fertilizer with the supply of available moisture is well recognized. From 20 to 30 pounds of nitrogen per acre for wheat following fallow is typical. On shallow soils or when moisture supplies are inadequate no nitrogen may be needed. But in the higher rainfall areas when wheat is grown without summer fallowing the rates may be doubled. Extensive research is now in progress to further clarify the relationship between moisture supply and available nitrogen. Also of considerable interest is the calibration of a soil test for estimating the available nitrogen. Current research by the Oregon and Washington agricultural experiment stations is designed both to evaluate existing methods critically and to explore new methods. A number of commercial soil-testing laboratories are collecting and testing soil for moisture and for nitrate and ammonia nitrogen. Samples are usually taken to 6 feet in depth or to a restricting layer. Rain gauges are used to get a better estimate of local rainfall. From existing research and experience on the relationship between moisture, nitrogen, and yield, nitrogen fertilizer recommendations are made. A considerable acreage is being tested and some fields have been sampled regularly for several years. The role of legumes or legume-grass mixtures in the cropping sequence has been given consideration to aid in maintaining organic matter, reducing erosion, improving soil tilth, and adding available nitrogen. Interest in this possibility has increased with wheat acreage allotments. Only a few farmers attempt to use legumes or grasses in their cropping sequence in this zone. Agronomists are not agreed as to the future of this practice. It takes large amounts of water to grow legumes to add nitrogen which now can be added relatively cheaply in commercial
FIELD CROP P R O D U C T I O N A N D SOIL M A N A G E M E N T
25
fertilizers. Existing research does not support the practice from the economic standpoint on most farms. Yet, some agronomists are concerned with the possible consequences of continuing the wheat-fallow system indefinitely. Continuous wheat, where it is practical, is an improvement over the wheat-fallow program. Returning the wheat straw and using nitrogen fertilizers also aids in maintaining soil organic matter. Trashy fallow is the most effective single practice for reducing erosion in the area. Yet, most farmers still use fallow prepared with a moldboard plow. Trashy fallow is practiced to a greater extent in that portion of the zone where yields are relatively low than in the higher yielding parts of the zone. Trashy fallow and other management practices for dryland wheat also are discussed for the Brown Zone and the Chernozem Zone, under Section IV, 3 and 5. Management problems and practices on the soils in this zone under irrigation are many and varied. They are discussed under Section IV, 2. Some of the fertility problems are complex in certain localized soil areas. For example, on the calcareous mucks in Klamath County, Oregon, deficiencies of phosphorus, zinc, copper, and manganese occur.
5. Chernozem Zone Water erosion and fertility are the dominant soil problems in the Chernozem Zone. Soil organic matter has declined from 20 to 40 per cent during about 50 to 65 years of cultivation. Inadequate moisture may limit crop yields in the drier portion of the Chernozem Zone, but generally it is adequate for high yields of wheat and peas, which are grown extensively in this zone. Soil erosion by water is considered to be more of a problem on cropland in this zone than in any other part of the Pacific Northwest. This led to the establishment of the Palouse Conservation Experiment Station (cooperative USDA and State) at Pullman, Washington, in 1930. The Pendleton, Oregon, Branch Experiment Station (cooperative State and USDA) also has given special attention to machinery and tillage practices in relation to erosion control. Soil losses occur largely during November through March. They result from rains of long duration and from snow melting on frozen soils (Kaiser et al., 1954; Horner et al., 1944). Numerous practices can be used to reduce erosion losses. Since the heaviest soil losses occur on land seeded to winter wheat, any practice that improves the growth of the wheat during the winter is beneficial. Crop sequence has a marked effect on soil losses. Greatest losses occur under the wheat-fallow system. Any system of continuous cropping such as is followed in most of the area helps reduce erosion. Continuous
26 H. B. CHENEY, w. H. FOOTE, E. G . KNOX, AND H. H. RAMPTON wheat, especially with stubble mulch, is superior to the wheat-peas rotation. The lowest soil losses occur when a legume-grass sod is included in the rotation, but the turning under of sweet corn with a moldboard plow and cultivating as is usually done may cause severe erosion losses. Crop residues can be used effectively in reducing soil erosion. In the earlier years straw burning was a common practice, but this is no longer true. Stubble mulch or trashy fallow does an excellent job of controlling erosion on summer fallow land. Kaiser et al. (1954) report a IO-year average annual soil loss per acre on winter wheat after fallow of only 3/4 ton when the fallow was prepared with a duckfoot cultivator (straw left as a mulch) and of 12 tons when the fallow was prepared with a moldboard plow (straw turned under). Trashy fallow as yet has not been adopted widely by farmers in either the Chernozem or higher rainfall part of the Chestnut Zone. New types of machinery such as the rotary hoe, skew treader, deep furrow drill, and “stubble buster” are necessary to handle the heavy stubble mulch. Control of weeds has been more of a problem under the trashy fallow than the clean fallow system. Yield of wheat averaged 38 bushels per acre for moldboard plowing and 32 bushels per acre where subsurface tillage was used during a 12-year period at the Pendleton Branch Experiment Station (unpublished data). This reduction of wheat yields on trashy fallow can be corrected by the use of nitrogen fertilizer. Since under the wheat-fallow system trashy fallow is such an effective erosion control measure, much research has been directed towards making it more practical and profitable. The results of the research at the Pendleton Branch Experiment Station have been summarized by Cushman (1955). In the wheat-pea area both soil and fall tillage may be saved by leaving the ground rough after plowing following pea harvest. Moreover, the yields of wheat have been just as high as when a fine tilled seedbed was prepared (Horning, 1955). Alfalfa and sweet clover alone or in a mixture with a grass aid in maintaining soil organic matter, decreasing erosion, and supplying available nitrogen. Continuous wheat with straw returned, plus nitrogen, has been equally effective in maintaining soil organic matter, In areas normally receiving 16 to 18 inches or more of precipitation legumes in the rotation usually increase yields of wheat. In lower rainfall areas this is not always the case. Legumes and grasses have been used to an appreciable extent in the cropping system only in the higher rainfall areas, principally the wheat-pea area along the WashingtonIdaho line. During the period 1935 to 1950 only about 14 per cent of the cultivated land in this area was in sod.
FIELD CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL MANAGEMENT
27
Fertilizer usage has increased tremendously during the past 10 years. Wheat responds well to nitrogen fertilizer except following sweet clover or alfalfa. It is common to get a yield increase of 1 bushel of wheat from 3 to 4 pounds of nitrogen applied. Maximum yields are obtained only by balancing the generally favorable moisture supply with adequate available nitrogen from some source. Some excess of nitrogen results in inefficient use and under some conditions a large excess occasionally may reduce yield and quality somewhat. The wheats currently grown are of the soft wheat type, in which baking quality is reduced by excessive protein content. The generally recommended rates of nitrogen fertilizers vary as follows: none following a legume, 30 to 40 pounds of nitrogen following summer fallow, 30 to 50 pounds following peas, and 50 to 70 pounds following wheat. Commercial soil testing is being used by some growers as a guide to better balancing their nitrogen rate with moisture and available nitrogen in the soil. Sulfur deficiencies for legumes have long been recognized in this zone, especially in eastern Washington and western Idaho. I n recent years, where sulfur has not been applied for legumes, wheat has shown a response to sulfate sulfur. Sulfur responses have occurred generally in the higher rainfall area on recropped wheat, especially springseeded wheat. Deficiencies of phosphorus have been detected only rarely. Management problems and practices on the wet soils in the zone are varied, including drainage, fertility, and irrigation.
6. Brown Podzolic Zone Drainage, fertility, and irrigation are the management practices of primary importance in this zone. Major attention in the research program has been given to the proper use of fertilizers, particularly on horticultural crops. Drainage is essential on many soils. Although much land has been drained there is still need for additional surface and subsoil drains. Irrigated acreage has more than doubled in the past five years and approximately 25,000 acres are now irrigated. Sprinkler irrigation is used almost exclusively. Vegetables, small fruits, and forage crops are the main crops irrigated. Even though total rainfall is 30 to 50 inches, summer droughts often occur. Fertilizers are used extensively especially on the high acre-value vegetables and small fruits. These crops also have received the most attention by research workers in the area. Recommendations for nitrogen for field crops ranges from none to 60 pounds of nitrogen per acre.
28
H. B. CHENEY,
w. H.
FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, AND H. H. RAMPTON
Most of the soils are deficient in available phosphorus and some in POtassium. From 40 to 60 pounds of P,O, and K,O per acre are commonly recommended for field crops. Larger applications of nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium are used on horticultural crops (Tremblay and Harston, 1952).Research at the Western Washington Experiment Station, Puyallup, indicates no residual effects from applications of phosphate fertilizers (60 to over 100 pounds of P,O, per acre) banded for vegetables. The extent to which this occurs on other soils is not established. Since dairying and poultry are important, considerable manure is available to supply part of the fertility requirements. Little limestone is used in the area, but the soils often have a pH of 4.9 to 5.5 with some either lower or higher. Research on the value of limestone is limited but new work is being started. In recent years there have been some indications that magnesium is deficient on certain soils in the area. 7. Brown Latosol Zone
The soil management problems in this zone include inadequate drainage, insufficient summer rainfall, high acidity, and low fertility. Sand dune movement along parts of the coast is a unique special problem. Research information for this area is quite limited. Considerable progress has been made in improving the drainage on the tideland, river bottom, and terraces on which forage crops are grown. However, drainage has not been improved on much of this land. Moreover, even with drainage improvement the soil may be quite wet or flooded from November to April. During the winter, average rainfall of 6 to 12 inches per month is typical of most of the coastal area. However, the average rainfall of l to 2 inches during July and August is not sufficient for optimum forage production. Consequently, irrigation has been increasing for several years. Sprinkler systems predominate. The nature of the acidity and fertility problem is known only in a general way. The cation-exchange capacity ranges from 30 to 45 me./100 g.; base saturation from 10 to 40 per cent; exchangeable potassium and available phosphorus are often low; and nitrification is slow. The cost of agricultural limestone is quite high, approximately $13.00 per ton. Experimental results in the area that definitely establish the economic value of lime and fertilizer treatments are lacking. Currently, research is in progress in the laboratory, greenhouse, and field to aid in the solution of this problem. Farmers are making some use of lime and fertilizers in the area. However, they rely largely on forage species that grow reasonably well with a minimum modification of existing fertility conditions. The John Jacob Astor Branch Experiment Station located in Oregon at the mouth
F I E L D C R O P P R O D U C T I O N A N D SOIL M A N A G E M E N T
29
of the Columbia River has some excellent New Zealand white clovergrass pastures on reclaimed tideland where lime and phosphate fertilizer were used. Drifting sand dunes were a menace along parts of the coast in the 1930’s and 1940’s. Through the work of the Soil Conservation Service aiding Soil Conservation Districts large acreages have been stabilized with grasses and other permanent vegetation. 8 . Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Upland
Areas
Soil acidity, low fertility, summer drought, and erosion are the dominant problems of this zone, in which a wide variety of crops are grown. The management problems on the alluvial soils are similar to those in the Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Lowland Areas and are discussed under Section IV, 9. Although limestone has been applied for many years, its use is far below estimated needs. The high cost of limestone is a considerable deterrent to its use. High-quality limestone costs here about $12 a ton delivered and spread. This is two to four times the cost in Midwest areas, where limestone is used extensively. With lime requirements of 2.5 to 4 or more tons per acre the cost per acre appears prohibitive to many farmers, even though cost-sharing under the Agricultural Conservation Program will cover approximately one-half the cost. All the high-quality limestone must be shipped in from a distance, since only low-purity deposits are available in the area. Research information showing the effects of limestone on the yields of the wide variety of crops grown in the area is limited. Owing to the high cost of limestone more precise information is needed than in most acid soil areas of the United States. A comprehensive research program is being initiated by the Oregon Agricultural Experiment Station to study both fundamental and applied aspects of the soil acidity problems in the area. Field experiments also are being initiated by the Washington Agricultural Experiment Station. The fertility management programs followed on these soils varies widely. Small grain was grown extensively in earlier years and red clover reportedly grew well. Then more and more farmers experienced difficulty in growing red clover. Vetch has been grown for many years. In most cases no lime or fertilizer was used except land plaster or gypsum to supply sulfur for the legumes. In recent years the use of lime and fertilizers has increased. In 1939 the Oregon Agricultural Experiment Station established the Red Soils Experimental Area near Oregon City. The farm had been heavily cropped to small grain without lime, fertilizer, or manure.
30
w. H. FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, AND H. H. RAMPTON It has served as an excellent demonstration of how production can be increased on these soils with improved management. Nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, boron, and sulfur deficiencies OCCUT. All are widespread except potassium deficiencies, which are more variable. The growing of legumes such as red clover and vetch to supply available nitrogen as well as for other purposes has been encouraged for over 50 years. Since 1940 the use of nitrogen fertilizers has increased rapidly. Nitrogen for grass seed production was adopted quickly by most growers when its value was determined about 1940. Its value for all crops except legumes is now well recognized. The need for regular additions of sulfur, especially for legumes, is widespread. Response of legumes to sulfur was established by Powers (1923) in 1912. For many years gypsum or land plaster was the only fertilizer or soil amendment used extensively. In recent years barley yields have been increased by additions of gypsum on land that had not had sulfur applied recently. Although the total phosphorus content of these soils is comparatively high, the available phosphorus supply is generally low. Phosphorus fixation is quite high. Farmer use of phosphate fertilizers, except on horticultural crops, is still far from universal. Potash fertilizers have not been used widely on these soils except for horticultural crops. Response to potash fertilizers on field crops has occurred only occasionally. Pope ( 1955) with greenhouse and laboratory methods found a wide variation in the potassium-supplying power of the soils in this zone. Additional research is needed to determine the need for potassium under field conditions. Many of these soils are deficient in available boron. Agricultural borax is used on alfalfa, broccoli, walnuts, and other crops. Powers and Wood (1947) have summarized the research work on boron. The fertility problems in this zone are complex. Multiple deficiencies of nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, sulfur, and boron as well as strong soil acidity may occur. Interactions between several of the elements have been established in a number of unpublished field experiments. The application of one or even several of the deficient elements may give a poor response if all are not supplied in adequate amounts in proper balance. The lack of a full understanding of this fact along with inadequate information on the interactions involved may well have contributed to farmers’ reluctance to use lime and fertilizer extensively on much of their cropland. Summer drought limits both the kinds and yields of the crops that are grown. Some sprinkler irrigation is used for horticultural crops and pasture in the upland area, but most irrigation is confined to the lowland areas. H. B. CHENEY,
FIELD CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL M A N A G E M E N T
31
Erosion is not a serious problem in most of the zone even though the slopes are often steep and long. A high per cent of the land is in forest trees or grass which provides a protective cover. Rainfall intensity is usually low. The soils are generally permeable and fairly resistant to erosion. Considerable erosion has occurred on some cultivated land, and a few areas are severely eroded. The most critical situations where erosion occurs are: (I) in clear cultivated orchards and small fruit plantings, (2) in strawberry plantings where the rows invariably run up and down the hill, and ( 3 ) on land where small grain crops fail to provide adequate cover in the fall and winter.
9. Reddish Brown Latosol Zone-Lowland
Areas The management problems on the alluvial soils in the Reddish Brown Latosol Zone include inadequate drainage, midsummer drought, stream flooding and erosion, low fertility, and some soil acidity. A large number of both field and horticultural crops are grown. The management problems of the upland areas in this zone are discussed under Section IV,8. The installation of open ditches and tile for drainage has increased during the past decade.' Approximately one million acres require improvement in the natural drainage for maximum crop production. About one-half of this wet land has been adequately drained and the other one-half would benefit from additional improvement in drainage. Because of the near drought-like conditions that prevail during the summer months irrigation is essential for intensive land use. The first recorded irrigation in the area was conducted at the Oregon Experiment Station, Corvallis, in 1896. Irrigation was proven practical and economical early in the present century, .but did not begin to receive popular support until sprinkler irrigation was developed. Irrigated land in the zone increased from 81,000 acres in 1949 to 153,000 acres in 1954. Sprinklers are used on nearly all this acreage. Irrigation undoubtedly will continue to increase in this area. The ground water supply is not adequate to permit much expansion. Additional water will be needed for flood control dams in the Willamette Basin Project Program, since practically all the usable summer flow of streams in Oregon is now appropriated or overappropriated. Blanch et al. (1955), reporting for the School of Agriculture Water Resources Committee at Oregon State College, estimate that by the year 2000 the irrigated acreage in this zone may feasibly increase fivefold over the present acreage. Vegetables, small fruit, mint, and pasture are the principal crops irrigated. Grass seed crops and fall- and spring-planted small grain and vetch are grown successfully without irrigation.
32
H. B. CHENEY,
w.
H. FOOTE, E. G . KNOX, AND H. H . RAMPTON
Approximately 500,000 acres in the Willamette Valley of Oregon has been subject to damage from floods. The Willamette Basin Project Program includes the construction of numerous multiple-purpose dams. The Corps of Engineers estimates that these dams will largely eliminate the flood hazard on the valley floor. Some of the most productive soils are generally flooded during the winter. Protective plant cover during the fall and winter is an essential feature of the management program on such soils. Winter cover crops must be seeded early enough to provide a good growth by the time the floods start or serious erosion may occur. Nitrogen is the principal nutrient needed. Application of 80 to 100 pounds of nitrogen per acre on grass seed crops and vegetables is a common practice. Smaller amounts are used on small grains such as barley and oats. Since the soil rarely freezes and rainfall during the fall and winter season usually exceeds 20 to 25 inches, fall-applied nitrogen leaches readily. Sulfur is recommended especially for legumes but also for other crops. Sulfate from either gypsum or other fertilizers is preferred over elemental sulfur. Most of these soils are well supplied with available phosphorus and potassium. The Planosols, used largely for ryegrass seed production, commonly are deficient in available phosphorus. They also are relatively low in exchangeable potassium but have adequate amounts for grass seed crops. Growers generally apply nitrogen-phosphate-potash fertilizers in a band by the row at planting time for vegetables. Rates of 60 to 100 pounds of P,O, and K,O are not uncommon. Phosphate fertilizer, even on soils well supplied (by usual standards) with available phosphorus by soil test, has been quite effective in increasing the yield of pole beans and sweet corn. Potash responses have been less certain. Phosphate in combination with nitrogen is used somewhat on small grains and pastures but field crops do not respond to either phosphate or potash fertilizers on most of these soils. The need for boron on alfalfa and a number of horticultural crops is recognized. Other trace elements are also required on the small areas of organic soils. Soil acidity is not a major problem on most of the soils as yet. The soils formed on recent alluvium are mostly only slightly acid, usually above pH 5.7. The soils on the terraces are more acid. Some lime is used on these soils when less acid-tolerant legumes are to be grown. The Planosols are quite acid but owing to poor drainage are not adapted to crops requiring a high pH or high per cent base saturation. Few farmers follow a regular rotation. The cropping pattern con-
FIELD CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL M A N A G E M E N T
33
tinually shifts as new crops are introduced and economic conditions or technology change. Many unanswered questions on crop sequence or rotations exist.
10. Reddish Brown Latosol-Noncalcic Brown Zones The soil management problems of this zone include insufficient summer rainfall, inadequate drainage, low fertility, and water erosion. Most of the cultivated land is confined to the alluvial soils and lower slopes. Gravity irrigation is used on most of the 85,300 irrigated acres, but sprinkler type irrigation has been increasing. Additional storage dams are needed to supply supplemental water on about one-half of this acreage (Beck et al., 1952). Improved irrigation practices will help to extend the existing supply of water for irrigation. Moreover, they will aid in alleviating the drainage problems resulting in part from overirrigation. As in most irrigated districts, especially where flood irrigation is practiced, the drainage problem is severe in parts of the area. The “Grumusols” or “sticky” soils are often nearly impermeable to water. The underlying strata are quite variable. Excess water in one area may move underground a considerable distance before causing a high water table. Crop response to additions of sulfur was established by Reimer and Tartar ( 1919) in the area over 40 years ago. The need for both nitrogen and sulfur is widespread. Many soils also are deficient in phosphorus, potassium, and boron. Greenhouse experiments indicate a few soils may be lacking in available molybdenum. Certain soils are quite high in exchangeable magnesium. It is possible that this condition may be associated with reduced yields of alfalfa. Most of the soils have a pH above 5.7 and practically no research has been conducted on the use of limestone. However, the yield of alfalfa was increased significantly by the application of limestone in one experiment in 1955 (unpublished data). The greatest erosion problem occurs on nonirrigated sloping land devoted to grain crops. It is also a problem where cultivated crops are irrigated by gravity irrigation on sloping land.
V. CROPZONES OF
THE
REGION
The crop zones of the Pacific Northwest region as shown in Fig. 4 and as referred to in the following crop discussions, have been arbitrarily drawn up to serve as a simplified guide under Section VI, “Field Crops of the Region.”
34 H. B. CHENEY, W. H. FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, A N D H. H. RAMPTON
B
a
e
a
4
U
ea
0
~-
FIG.4. Crop zones of the Pacific Northwest. (Sources: Cropland map from Highsmith, 1956; crop zones added by authors.)
F I E L D CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL M A N A G E M E N T
35
The following is an outline of the principal crops in each zone, and the range of climatic conditions found in the different cultivated land areas within each crop zone in the Pacific Northwest. Zone 1. Coastal-Lower Columbia River Belt. Practically all the cultivated land is in forage crops, used mainly for pasture and grass silage. Average precipitation: 55 to 100 inches. Mean temperature: Jan. 39 to 46" F. July 58 to 61" F. Extreme temperatures: Lowest, 0 to 16" F. Highest, 97 to 105" F. Average length of growing season: 185 to 285 days. Elevation of cultivated lands: 5 to 200 feet. Zone 2. Puget Sound Lowlands. The principal crops are forages, small fruits, fresh vegetables, vegetable seeds, potatoes, bulbs, and nursery stock. Average precipitation: 16 to 32 inches. Mean temperatures: Jan. 37 to 39" F. July 61 to 63" F. Extreme temperatures: Lowest, 2 to 5" F. Highest, 92 to 98" F. Average length of growing season: 184 to 255 days. Elevation of cultivated lands: 5 to 500 feet. Zone 3. Western Oregon-Western Washington Valleys. The crops are widely diversified. The most important crops are small grains, forages, grass and legume seeds, small fruit, tree fruits, nuts, vegetables, bulbs, and nursery stock. Average precipitation: 40 to 52 inches. Mean temperatures: Jan. 38 to 39" F. July 63 to 66" F. Extreme temperatures: Lowest, -20 to -2" F. Highest, 104 to 107" F. Average length of growing season: 164 to 191 days. Elevation of cultivated lands: 30 to 1000 feet. Zone 4. Rogue and Umpqua River Valleys. Diversity of crops characterizes this zone. The main crops are tree fruits, small grains, forage crops, legume seeds, vegetables, small fruits, and nuts. Average precipitation: 16 to 30 inches. Mean temperatures: Jan. 37 to 41 F. July 67 to 71' F. Extreme temperatures: Lowest, -6 to 2" F. Highest, 107" F. Average length of growing season: 170 to 234 days. Elevation of cultivated lands: 450 to 1500 feet. Zone 5. South Central Oregon-Southwestem Idaho Arid Highlands. The principal crops in this zone are forages, small grains, grass and legume seeds, and potatoes. Average precipitation: 8 to 13 inches. Mean temperatures: Jan. 21 to 32" F. July 65 to 77" F. Extreme temperatures: Lowest, -45 to -15" F. Highest, 102 to 119" F. Average length of growing season: 103 to 130 days. Elevation of cultivated lands: 2250 to 4500 feet. Zone 6. Blue Mountains. Crops produced in this zone are mainly small grains, especially wheat, forages, and grass and legume seeds. Average precipitation: 10 to 22 inches. Mean temperatures: Jan. 25 to 29" F. July 65 to 72" F. Extreme temperatures: Lowest, -38 to -24" F. Highest, 108 to 112" F. Average length of growing season: 108 to 168 days. Elevation of cultivated lands: 2700 to 3800 feet.
36
H. B. CHENEY,
w. H.
FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, AND H. H. RAMPTON
Zone 7. Columbia Basin Irrigated Lands. This zone is widely diversified as to crops. The most important crops are forages, tree fruits, small fruits, small grains, legume seeds, sugar beets, potatoes, vegetables, and dry beans. Average precipitation: 7 to 9 inches. Mean temperatures: Jan. 26 to 28" F. July 71 to 76" F. Extreme temperatures: Lowest, -33 to -23" F. Highest, 111 to 116" F. Average length of growing season: 149 to 190 days. Elevation of cultivated lands: 500 to 1500 feet. Zone 8. Columbia Basin Wheat-Fallow Lands. The principal crops in this zone are small grains, mostly wheat, and forages. Average precipitation: 10.5 to 16 inches. Mean temperatures: Jan. 29 to 33" F. July 68 to 72" F. Extreme temperatures: Lowest, -29 to -21" F. Highest, 109 to 119" F. Average length of growing season: 120 to 168 days. Elevation of cultivated lands: 1000 to 3000 feet. Zone 9. Northern Washington Mountain Valleys. The main crops in this zone are forages, small grains, and tree fruits. Average precipitation: 10 to 14 inches. Mean temperatures: Jan. 22 to 25" F. July 65 to 74" F. Extreme temperatures: Lowest, -35 to -23" F. Highest, 108 to 114" F. Average length of growing season: 96 to 173 days. Elevation of cultivated lands: 800 to 3000 feet. Zone 10. Northern Forest Cut-Over Lands. The crops produced in this zone are principally forages and small grains. Average precipitation: 16 to 23 inches. Mean temperatures: Jan. 22 to 24" F. July 64 to 67" F. Extreme temperatures: Lowest, -42 to -26" F. Highest, 102 to 107" F. Average length of growing season: 93 to 151 days. Elevation of cultivated lands: 1600 to 2500 feet. Zone 11. Palouse-High Prairie. The crops of this zone are mainly small grains, chiefly wheat, forages, dry edible peas, green peas for canning and freezing, and grass seeds. Average precipitation: 14.5 to 26 inches. Mean temperatures: Jan. 28 to 33" F. July 67 to 74" F. Extreme temperatures: Lowest, -39 to -22" F. Highest, 105 to 118" F. Average length of growing season: 118 to 210 days. Elevation of cultivated lands: 1000 to 3350 feet. Zone 12. Central Idaho Mountain Valleys. The main crops in this zone are forages and small grains. Average precipitation: 7 to 15 inches. Mean temperaures: Jan. 15 to 19" F. July 64 to 70" F. Extreme temperatures: Lowest, -46 to -28" F. Highest, 101 to 110" F. Average length of growing season: 75 to 148 days. Elevation of cultivated lands: 5000 to 6000 feet. Zone 13. Snake River Valley. The crops of this zone are diversified. The most important are forages, small grains, potatoes, sugar beets, legume seeds, dry beans, dry peas, tree fruits, small fruits, vegetables, and vegetable seeds. Average precipitation: 8 to 15.5 inches. Mean temperatures: Jan. 18 to 30" F. July 65 to 74" F. Extreme temperatures: Lowest, -44 to -21" F. Highest, 100 to 121" F.
F I E L D CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL M A N A G E M E N T
37
Average length of growing season: 97 to 177 days. Elevation of cultivated lands: 2100 to 5000 feet. Zone 14. Southeastern Idaho. The principal crops of this zone are small grains, forages, and sugar beets. Average precipitation: 10 to 17 inches. Mean temperatures: Jan. 16 to 28" F. July 62 to 71" F. Extreme temperatures: Lowest, -50 to -25" F. Highest, 97 t o 108" F. Average length of growing season: 74 to 128 days. Elevation of cultivated lands: 4500 to 5500 feet.
VI. FIELDCROPSOF
THE
REGION
1. Cereals a. Wheat. Wheat is the major cereal crop grown in the Pacific Northwest. It is grown extensively in crop Zones 3, 6, 8, 1 1 , and 14, with the bulk of the acreage found in the Columbia Basin area of Oregon and southeastern Washington, and the Palouse area of Washington and northern Idaho. Some wheat is grown in almost every agricultural zone of the region, Wheat production in the Pacific Northwest began about 75 years ago. Much of the wheat land was plowed directly from the native grasses, and wheat is the only crop that has ever been grown. The rolling topography characteristic of the wheat lands, particularly in Zones 8 and 11, and the establishment of large farm holdings have led to the development of many new farming practices unique to the area. Most of the wheat is produced under dryland conditions, using the summerfallow or alternate cropping system. By the nature of the rainfall pattern and the environment wheat is the crop best adapted to these areas and as such, it has become the dominant agricultural crop of the economy. In areas of higher rainfall, wheat may be grown each year or in a rotation with peas or other annual legumes. On the irrigated farms, wheat is commonly grown as a rotational crop when the price and other factors are favorable. The acreages and production of wheat for the three states for 1954 and the averages for the years of 1942-51 are given in Table IV. The production of fall- and spring-sown wheat in 1954 was about 128,656,000 bushels on some 4,173,000 acres. The total acreage seeded to wheat for 1954 harvest was about 10 per cent less than the average acreage for the years of 1942-51, whereas the production increased almost 5 per cent. Most of the wheat acreage is seeded to winter varieties but spring-sown varieties produce about one-quarter of the total crop. The spring varieties are grown mainly on the irrigated farms and to a certain extent replace the fall-sown wheats when the crop has been damaged by winter injury or when the weather or lack of moisture has prevented successful fall seeding and establishment.
38
H. B. CHENEY,
w. H.
FOOTE, E. G . KNOX, AND H. H. RAMPTON
Most types of wheat are adapted to the area and can be grown successfully. A varietal survey in 1954 listed some 57 varieties grown in the Oregon, Washington, and northern Idaho region of the Pacific Northwest. In the higher rainfall areas of Zones 6, 8, and 11 and in Zones 3 and 13, the white wheats are well adapted and high yielding and recently have been grown almost to the exclusion of other types. Hard red winter wheat is grown mainly in the drier areas of Zones 8 and 14.Hard red spring and soft red winter types are grown to a lesser TABLE IV Production and Acreages of Wheat for the Three States in the Pacific Northwest in 1942-51 and 1954 Acreages
Production
(1000 acres)
(1000 bu.)
1942-51
Oregon Winter Spring
Total Washinglon Winter Spring
Total Idaho Winter Spring
Total GRAND TOTAL 1
1954*
1942-51
1954
719 217 956
70 1 149 850
18,794 5,156 85,930
20,429 4,415 24,844
1,854 654 8,488
1,865 so5 2,168
61,069 14,854 65,905
61,059 8,247 69,306
768 470 1,328 4,653
646 509 1,155 4,175
18,606 14,505 55,111 128,944
17,202 17,504 54,506 128,656
Agricultural atatiatics 1954. U. S. Department of Agriculture.
* U. S. Bureau of Census,
[email protected] Agricultural Census Preliminary.
extent. The production of the important wheat varieties in 1954 is given in Table V. Wheat grown in the Pacific Northwest is used primarily for food purposes, and, because the population in the region is not large, about 50 to 70 per cent of the crop must find a market outside of the region. Until rather recently, the bulk of the wheat was exported to other parts of the world, mainly the Orient. The wheat varieties grown produce a soft to semihard wheat with a medium low protein content. These wheats are used extensively for pastry and other specialty flours. They are often characterized as good milling wheats, but some varieties are notoriously poor. The hard red winter varieties can often be milled directly into bread flour, but are more often blended with other
F I E L D CROP P R O D U C T I O N A N D SOIL M A N A G E M E N T
39
wheats to extend their usefulness. The use of wheat as a livestock feed has expanded some in recent years with the increased interest in livestock feeding in the area, and wheat may become a much more important source of feed grain in the future. Industrial utilization of wheat has not proven to be of economic importance as yet. Diseases are one of the most important production problems in the region. Covered smut (Tilletia caries (D. C.) Tul.) and in some limited areas dwarf smut (Tilletia breuaficieus G. W. Fish.) are serious TABLE V Estimated Production of the 1954 Wheat Crop in the Pacific Northwest (Oregon, Washington, and North Idaho) by Varieties' Production Varieties White Wheat ELMAR BREVOR EMIN-ALICEL QOLDEN FEDERATION
REX IDAED BAART
Hard Red Winter Wheat TURKEY-RIO RIDIT WASATCB
Soft Red Winter Wheat R E D RUSSIAN TRIPLET
Hard Red Spring Wheat
(1000 bu.) 95,743 51,206 8,960 8.234 3,980 3,743 3,688 3,470 3,110 12,640 11,737 412 a13 347 229 73 786
HUSTON
258
MARQUIS
241 116
REDMAN
% of total
87.3 46.7 8.2 7.5 3.6 3.4 3.4 3.2 2.8 11.6 10.7 0.4 0.2
0.3 0.a
0.1 0.7 0.2 0.2 0.1
1 Pacific Northwest Wheat by Varietiea, Acreage Harveated and Production, I040 and 1964. U. S. Department of Agriculture. AMS.
diseases. Loose smut (Ustilago tritici (Pers.) Rost.) may be important in the irrigated humid areas. The smut diseases take their large annual toll by reducing yields and the quality of the wheat. Most of the seed is treated prior to seeding but soil infection often prevents complete control. The development and widespread use of resistant varieties has been a successful means of control. I n some areas, particularly the irrigated and higher rainfall areas, both stem rust (Puccinia graminis tritici, Erik. and Henn.) and leaf rust (Puccinia rubigo-Vera tritici, Erik.) may reach epidemic proportions. Foot rots, snow mold, and
40 H. B. CHENEY, w. H. FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, AND H. H. RAMPTON other soil-borne diseases are frequently found and cause serious damage in some areas. Insects on wheat have not been found to be an economic factor as yet. b. Barley. The principal barley-producing areas are the Willamette Valley of Zone 3, Klamath Basin of Zone 5 in Oregon, Zones 13 and 14 in Idaho, and the Nez Perce and Camas Prairie of Washington and northern Idaho. Barley, while not the major cereal, is grown extensively in almost every agricultural area and recently has become the replacement crop for wheat on the “diverted” wheat acres in the Columbia Basin. The acreages and production of barley for 1954 and the averages for the years 1942-5 1 are given in Table VI. TABLE VI Production and Acreages of Barley for the Three States in the Pacific Northwest in 1942-51 and 1954 Acreages
Production (1000 h . )
(1000 acres)
Oregon Washington Idaho Total
1944-5 1’
19542
1942-51
1954
299 174 345 818
484 597 541 1,622
9,907 6,332 11,961 28,200
17,851 29,136 17,749 57,736
* hgricultural Statistirs 1054. U. S. Department of Agriculture. 2
U. S. Bureau of Census, 1055. 1064 Agricultural Census Preliminary.
The total production of barley in 1954 of some 57,736,000 bushels represents an increase of 51 per cent over the average production for the 1942-51 period. This increase has largely taken place in the wheatproducing areas. Barley is grown primarily as a feed grain, but sizable quantities are grown for a specialized use as malting barley. The malting barley production is concentrated largely in the Klamath Basin and Willamette Valley of Oregon, the Camas Prairie and Palouse area of Washington and northern Idaho, and to a limited extent in Zone 14 of southeastern Idaho. Outside of these areas barley is grown largely as a feed grain, particularly in the irrigated areas where it is used as a rotational crop, often with legumes such as alfalfa or red clover. Both fall and spring varieties are grown with the production of the winter types in the areas west of the Cascades and in other areas where the winters are mild. Spring-grown varieties, both the common sixrowed and two-rowed types, predominate in the region. Most of the
FIELD CROP PRODUCTION AND SOIL MANAGEMENT
41
malting barley is the two-rowed type, with HANNCHEN and HANNA the leading varieties. WHITE WINTER, a six-rowed variety, is also grown and sold as a malting barley. Other leading barley varieties grown are TREBI, BONNEVILLE, GEM, WINTER CLUB, and FLYNN, which are grown primarily as feed grain. The future of barley production in the Pacific Northwest depends upon many factors, some of which are the governmental farm programs, the expansion of livestock feeding operations, the shifting and expansion of markets for malting barley. Barley is grown in the area without too many production hazards. Often winter killing occurs when attempts are made to grow spring or semiwinter types. Barley mildew (Erysiphe graminis D. C.) and TABLE VII Production and Acreages of Oats Grown in the Pacific Northwest in 1942-51 and 1954 Acreage
Production (1000 bu.)
(1000 acres) 1942-51'
Oregon
Washington Idaho Total 1
335 159 185 679
1954'
1942-51
1964
225 178 174 577
9,682 7,361 7,756 24,749
8,991 8,013 8,183 25,187
Agricultural Statistics, 1054. U. S. Department of Agriculture.
:U. S. Bureau of Censur, 1955. 1054 Agricultural Census Preliminary.
loose smut ( Ustilago nuda (Jens.) Rost.) are sometimes important. Excessive lodging of barley when grown under conditions of high soil fertility is an important production problem. On much of the irrigated land, barley is underseeded with legumes and excessive straw growth often results in reduced stands of the legume. The development of high-yielding, disease-resistant stiff-strawed barley varieties has been an important contribution to the success of barley in the region. c. Oats. I n the Pacific Northwest oats are used as a grain for livestock feed or as a forage. The production of oats is widely distributed throughout the area with the Willamette Valley of Crop Zone 3, the Palouse area of Zone 11, and the irrigated areas of the Snake River Valley in Zone 13 the most important. Oats are also grown to a limited extent as a hay crop in Zones 1,2, and 8. The acreages and production of oats for the three states are given in Table VII. The production of oats has changed very little during the past sev-
42
H. B. CHENEY,
w. H.
FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, AND H. H. RAMPTON
era1 years. Oats are used frequently as a nurse crop for legumes, such as red clover and alfalfa in the irrigated areas, and oats and vetch are grown together in western Oregon as a seed crop and to a limited extent as a hay crop. On the wheat farms oats are commonly grown around the edges of the fields and harvested for hay. Winter oats are grown in western Oregon and Washington, where the winters are mild, and the gray seeded types of WINTER TURF such as GREY WINTER and SUPPORT are the predominate varieties. The spring oats are mainly white but there are some yellow and red varieties grown on a limited scale. VICTORY, MARKTON, OVERLAND, BANNOCK, and CODY are some of the well-known present-day varieties. TABLE VIII Production and Acreages of Rye for the Three States in the Pacific Northwest in 1942-51 and 1953 Acreage (1000 acres)
Oregon Washington Idaho Total 1
Production (1000 bu.)
1949-61'
1963'
1942-51
1963
130 64 11 196
199 34 7 163
380 206 64 650
304 138 46
487
Agricultural Statistics. 1064. U. S. Department of Agriculture.
Little change in oat production in the region is anticipated. Oats will always occupy a favorable place in the crop rotations on the irrigated farms and as a support crop for some of the seed crops. Use as hay will fluctuate with the need for a supplemental hay crop in areas where wheat production is the main enterprise. Oats are not damaged seriously by diseases, although stem rust (Puccinia graminis avenae, Erik. and Henn.) may be important. d . Rye. Rye is grown mainly as a hay and cover crop in the Pacific Northwest and to a lesser extent as a grain crop. The acreages and production of rye for the three states for 1953 and the averages for 1942-51 are given in Table VIII. The production of rye is confined largely to Crop Zones 2 and 3, where it is grown as a cover crop in orchards and on vegetable lands and used as a pasture. I n areas east of the Cascades rye is grown for hay and grain usually on land unsuited for wheat production. Rye has become a serious weed on the wheat lands and the production of rye has not been encouraged.
F I E L D CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL M A N A G E M E N T
43
Both winter and spring types of rye can be grown but the predominant types west of the Cascades are winter types such as ABRUZZI and BALBO. On much of the acreage seeded to rye for hay and grain improved varieties are not used but the seed consists of a mixture of types. Seed is often bought and sold or exchanged among growers with little concern for varietal designation. Diseases are not important in the area. By f a r the most important problem if rye is to continue even as a minor crop is the acute seed problem of known adapted types. e. Corn. Corn is a minor crop in the Pacific Northwest when compared with some other crops and with other agricultural areas in the United States. The Pacific Northwest does not have strong factors favoring corn production in most of the region. Some of the warmer, TABLE IX Production and Acreages of Corn for the Three States in the Pacific Northwest in 1942-51 and 1954 Acreage (all corn) 1949-51'
Oregon Washington Idaho
Total
33 90 33 86
Production
1954' 1943-51 97 37 44 108
1918 1007 1504 3739
1954 744 1433 853
3098
* Agricultural 9
Statistics. 1954. U. S. Department of Agriculture. U. S. Bureau of Cenaua. 1955. 1954 hgricultural Censua Preliminary.
long-growing-season irrigated areas east of the Cascades and to some extent areas west of the Cascades are suitable for corn. Corn is grown on a sizable acreage, both irrigated and nonirrigated, in Crop Zone 3, while the bulk of the successful production is found in the Yakima Valley and the Grand Coulee irrigated area of Zone 7 and the Snake River and Boise valleys in Zone 13. The acreages and production of corn in the three states for 1942-51 and for 1954 are given in Table IX. Corn, where it can be grown successfully, is used either as a grain or as a silage crop. Production of corn for grain is highly competitive with other cereal grains, and corn silage with grass and legume silage. Hybrid varieties are grown almost exclusively in the area, with some emphasis placed on the development of hybrids for the areas. 2. Forages
a. Hay Crops. (Statistics are shown in Table X.) ( I ) Alfalfa. Alfalfa (Medicago saliva L.) is adapted in all crop zones of the region with the
4'4
H. B. C H E N E Y , W. H . FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, A N D H. H . R A M P T O N
exception of Zone I.Adaptation is limited by poor drainage and acid soils in Zone 2 and 3. East of the Cascade Mountains, most of the alfalfa is irrigated. There, the principal limiting factors on cultivated lands are insufficient moisture, short growing season, impeded drainage, and the often accompanying high salinity and alkalinity. Insects and diseases sometimes limit production, but development of resistant varieties has solved the most serious problems with the exception of outbreaks of such pests as cutworms, grasshoppers, and alfalfa weevil. The most popular alfalfa varieties and their special values are as follows: RANGER, ORESTAN, and VERNAL, having resistance to bacterial wilt of alfalfa; LADAK, which possesses a moderate amount of alfalfa wilt resistance and is suited to areas that are marginal for alfalfa production because of deficiency of moisture; TALENT, having resistance to the leaf and stem nematode; and LAHONTAN, having resistance to the spotted alfalfa aphid (not yet known to occur in the Pacific Northwest), bacterial wilt, and the leaf and stem nematode. The greatest concentration of alfalfa acreage and hay production is in the Snake River Valley of Idaho, which makes up almost all of Zone 13. Twin Falls County alone produced a quarter of a million tons of alfalfa hay in 1954.The second largest hay-producing area is in Zone 7, all of which lies in the state of Washington, the center of production being in Yakima County. Most of the alfalfa hay is baled for convenience in handling, especially in marketing the product. Considerable amounts are still stacked as loose hay, some is chopped and blown into stacks or barns, and a portion is made into alfalfa meal. Little alfalfa is grown primarily for pasture, although much of it is pastured at some time during the year. Some of the alfalfa crop finds its way into silage, particularly in areas where early summer rains cause difficulty in the curing of hay. Some alfalfa forage is utilized for winter livestock feed in the form of threshed alfalfa, a by-product of seed production. Practically all the alfalfa hay produced in the states of Oregon and Washington is fed within the state of origin, although sizable amounts are shipped from Zones 5, 6, 7, and 8, chiefly to dairy operators in Zones I, 2, and 3. The acreage of alfalfa for hay is increasing in the region. The increase in 1954 over the 1942-51 average was nearly 10 per cent in Idaho, 20 per cent in Oregon, and 23 per cent in Washington. ( 2 ) Red clover. Red clover (Trifolium pratense L.) is adapted in all crop zones of the region. The greatest production is in Zone 3, where growing the crop for forage is often combined with the seed production enterprise. Red clover is highly esteemed for its soil-improving qualities in Zones 1, 2, and 3, where it is an important feature in many crop rotations. On the cultivated lands west of the Cascade mountains the principal limiting factors in successful red clover production are soil
FIELD CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL MANAGEMENT
45
acidity, poor drainage, and shallow soils. On the cultivated lands east of the Cascade Mountains the principal factors limiting successful production of red clover are insufficient moisture, insufficient depth of soil, poor drainage, and soil salinity and alkalinity. The most serious pests of red clover in the region are the clover root borer and the clover root curculio, which have, for all practical purposes, made the crop a biennial. Other insect pests are the common garden slug and the western spotted cucumber beetle, both of which are particularly destructive in the seedling stage. Grasshoppers and cutworms also limit forage production at times. Diseases are present but generally are not of great effect on forage production. The principal variety grown is KENLAND, especially where seed and forage production are combined. Red clover production for hay has decreased markedly in the state of Idaho during recent years. There has occurred a slight decrease in Washington and a moderate increase in Oregon, mostly in Zone 3. (3) Vetches and peas for hay. These crops are generally fall-sown in combination with winter oats for hay, and under such culture, are best adapted in Zones 1, 2, 3, and 4.The vetches most used for hay are common vetch (Vicia sativa L.) and WILLAMETTE, a variety of common vetch on the better lands; hairy vetch (Vicia uillosa Roth), which has special value on the less productive hill lands; and Hungarian vetch (Vicia pannonica Crantz) on poorly drained soils. The Austrian winter pea (Pisum satiuum L. var. arvense) is the most popular of the forage peas. Over 80 per cent of the vetch and pea hay production occurs in Zone 3, and most of the remainder is in Zone 4.The common hazards of production are unusually low winter temperatures, plant damage caused by soil heaving in periods of nighttime freezing and daytime thawing, seedling loss due to depredations of the garden slug, plant loss during winter and spring due to one or more of a number of diseases, and aphid attacks. ( 4 ) Cereal grains for hay. The cereal grains are widely used for hay in the Pacific Northwest. They have broad adaptation and are represented by the four principal species, wheat, oats, barley, and rye. The greatest tonnage is produced in Crop Zone 8, where most of the cultivated land is cropped to wheat and portions of wheat fields may be regularly cut for hay. Zones 3 and 5 are practically identical in tonnage of cereal grains grown for hay, but the use of winter oats is much more intensive in Zone 3. In Zone 5 winter rye is frequently used. Little of this type of hay enters into commerce except in Zone 3, most of it being fed on the farms and ranches where it is produced. The use of cereal grains for hay, especially in the wheat-growing areas, has markedly declined because of the replacement of horses and mules by tractors and the gradual expansion of the use of alfalfa.
46
H.B. CHENEY, w. H.
FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, AND H. H. RAMPTON
( 5 ) Wild hay. Wild hay production occurs chiefly in high mountain valleys where winter and spring moisture may be excessive, drainage poor, and saline and alkali soils are often present. The plants are mainly native species, mostly perennials, having considerable winter hardiness and tolerance to excessive moisture and soil salinity and alkalinity. The principal grasses are Nevada bluegrass (Poa nevadensis Vasey ex Scribn.) , meadow barley (Hordeum brachyantherum Nevski), tufted hairgrass (Descharnpsia caespiiosa (L.) Beauv.) , and beardless wild rye (Elymus triticoides Buckl.) . Various rushes (Juncus spp.) and sedges (Carez spp.) are generally important components of the forage. Numerous legumes are found but it is seldom that they make up important amounts of the forage. The most common ones are cow clover (Trifolium wormskoldii) , a perennial, and white-tipped clover (Trifolium variegaturn Nutt.) , an annual. By far the greatest production of forage from wild meadows is in Crop Zone 5, of which Harney County, Oregon, is the highest producing county. Ranchers in Zones 14 and 6 also produce appreciable amounts of this type of hay. Such forage is used primarily for winter feeding of beef cattle, and a lesser amount for sheep roughage. This hay is generally of rather low feed value owing to the advanced stage of growth at which much of it is cut, and to the long period of exposure generally permitted before stacking. These objectives are difficult to overcome because ( I ) yields are generally quite low, averaging a little over 1 ton per acre, and (2) areas of harvest are large. Quality can be improved by use of fertilizers, by earlier cutting, and by handling more quickly, but the values of the first two have not yet been fully demonstrated to ranchers, and considerable time is always necessary to handle the large acreages involved. Acreages of wild meadow hay are decreasing in all three states of the region. ( 6 ) Other hay. This forage is chiefly made up of miscellaneous cultivated forage grasses that occur commonly in the region. Legumes vary considerably in prominence in this forage. They are chiefly the common cultivated species. The main producing areas, in order of importance, are Crop Zones 3,1,and 2. b. Silage. (Statistics are shown in Table X.) The four principal silages of the Pacific Northwest are sugar beet pulp, pea vines, grasslegume mixtures, and corn. Most of the corn silage is produced in Crop Zones 13 and 7. It is principally field corn, but some is the by-product of sweet corn processing. About 682,000tons were grown in 1954. Most of the mixed grass-legume silage is produced in the western part of the region, with Crop Zone 2 the highest producer, followed by Zones 3 and Iin descending order. The use of this type of silage is
F I E L D CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL M A N A G E M E N T
47
expanding rapidly. Its use fits well into conditions in Zones 1,2, and 3, because of rains which usually occur in late May and early June, making hay curing in the field extremely difficult and wasteful. Over 600,000 tons were produced in 1954. Pea vine silage is a by-product of the green pea freezing and canning industry. The greatest production in the region is located in the narrow neck of Zone I1 extending to the southwest. Almost 700,000 tons were produced in 1955. Most of it is fed in the area of production, but some is hauled considerable distances. Sugar beet pulp silage is a by-product of the sugar beet industry. The greatest amount is produced in Zones 13 and 7. The 1954 production is estimated to be over 2,000,000 tons. c. Improved Pastures. (Statistics are shown in Table X.) Most of the improved pastures in the Pacific Northwest region are irrigated, but some, under the relatively favorable rainfall of Crop Zones 1, 2, 3, 6, and 11, may not be irrigated. Most of the improved irrigated pastures contain either Ladino clover (Trifolium repens L. var. Ladino) or white clover ( T . repens L.) and one or more of the better grasses such as orchard grass (Dactylis glomerata L.) , Alta fescue (Festuca arundinacea Schreb.) ,perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.) ,smooth bromegrass (Bromus inermis Leyss. ) , and timothy (Phleum pratense L.) . The plants commonly used in nonirrigated pastures include Ladak alfalfa, sweet clovers (Melilotus alba Med. and M. oficincinalis), desert wheatgrass (Agropyron desertorum Fisch.) , intermediate wheatgrass ( A . intermedium (Host) Beauv.) , pubescent wheatgrass ( A . trichophorum (Link) Richt.), slender wheatgrass ( A . trachycaulum (Link) Malte), and smooth bromegrass in the crop zones east of the Cascade Mountains. I n the zones west of the Cascades, nonirrigated pastures commonly include subclover (Trifolium subterraneum L.) , red clover, white clover, orchard grass, Alta fescue, and perennial ryegrass. The greatest concentration of improved pastures occurs in Zones 13, 7, and 5. Acreage is being expanded rapidly in Zone 7. Production of nutrients per acre varies widely, depending upon the pasture plants used, cultural and management practices, and length of growing season. Irrigated Ladino grass pastures may yield less than 1 ton of alfalfa hay equivalent per acre, or up to 10 tons per acre.
3 . Field Seed Crops a. Importance of the Region. The generally favorable climate of the Pacific Northwest provides good conditions for seed production. Adequate natural rainfall in the more favored areas, well-developed irrigation water supplies in some of the drier portions, and growing seasons
P
03
x
TABLE X
and Production, by States, in the Pacific Northwest'.'
Forage Crops-Acreage Idaho
B
Oregon
0
Washington
4
1942-51
Alfalfa hay Red clover hay3 Vetch or pea hay Cereal grain hay Wid hay Other hay Corn silage Grass-legume silage Pea vine silage4 Sugar beet pulp silage6 Improved pastures
1945-51
1954
1954
1942-5 1
000 Acres
000
000
000 Acres
000
000
Acres
000 Tons
000
Tons
Tons
Acres
Tons
756.0 199.0
1919.0 172.0
830.9 95.9
2387.0 137.0
239.0 126.0
654.0 227.0
-
-
-
151 . O
292.0
330.0
-
-
53.3 154.1 19.8 393.7
-
139.0
58.2 129.9 14.8 28.4
-
-
587.0 148.3 48.1 143.1 276.3 59.0 12.3 36.6
900.7
-
77.5 1176.7
799.4 577.6 85.9 183.3 300.3 94.7 131.9 248.3 295.0 291.7
-
248.6
-
559.5
-
-
-
398.3
000 Acres
1954
000 Tons 684.0 410.0
63.0
000
000
Acres
Tons
375.4 188.2 6.5 92.9 45.9 43.9 12.7 54.0
839.7 374.8 .!! 10.5 M 128.6 9 64.4 w 6 9 . 0 2! 156.7 $ " 356.7 395.0 570.7
291.2
-
-
137.2
-
"2 3 ?
3
3
-
.z
Y
I4
Data from 1954 Agricultural Censua. Preliminary, unless otherwise noted. 2 Figures in units of thousands. a Reported as clover or timothy for hay. Presumed t o be chiefly red clover. 4 Estimates based on produrtion of green peas in 1955, reported by U. S. Department of Agriculture, .4grirultural Marketing Service, Crop Reporting Board. Estimates based on production of sugar beets in 1954. reported by U. S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Marketing Service. Crop Reporting Board 1
'
s >
5
H
0
z
F I E L D CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL M A N A G E M E N T
49
of adequate duration make it possible to produce a variety of field seeds over much of the region. Not the least of the conditions favorable for seed production is the generally warm, dry summer which provides excellent conditions for retention of high quality as to germination and appearance of the seed. These natural advantages, plus the long distances to large markets for produce of the land, have made the region well suited to the development of field seed production. The industry is not confined to just growing seeds. The segments of it have become highly specialized with many skilled growers, research and promotion by public agencies, exacting seed certification systems, and a welldeveloped seed processing and handling business. The result has been that the Pacific Northwest has become important in the production of seeds of cool-season grasses and legumes for forage, soil conservation, and turf, and for seed of winter legumes, most of which are marketed outside of the region. The seed production enterprise on a farm generally fits in well with livestock production. Most of the seed crops provide pasture in substantial amounts at sometime during the year, and the threshed straw can generally be utilized as roughage. b. Legume Seed Crops. (Statistics are shown in Table XI.) ( I ) Alfalfa seed. The successful production of alfalfa seed requires, in general, the same conditions as those that result in high production of alfalfa hay. Alfalfa seed is produced in most of the crop zones of the Pacific Northwest, with the bulk of production centered in Zones 7 and 13. Seed production is heaviest in the Yakima Valley of Zone 7, where about 50 per cent of all the alfalfa seed of the whole region was grown in 1954. Most of the production is of varieties and types that are adapted to use in the northern half of the United States. I n addition to common alfalfa seed, considerable acreage is devoted to the production of certified seed of a number of varieties. These include the bacterial wilt-resistant varieties RANGER, VERNAL, BUFFALO, ORESTAN, and LADAK. The principal non-wilt-resistant varieties are G R I M M , NARRAGANSETT, and TALENT. Some of the problems faced by seed producers include weed control, pollination, and disease and insect depredations. The use of chemicals in weed control is assuming an increasingly important place in the handling of this problem, with most of the chemical treatments being applied during the dormant stage of the alfalfa. I n the larger producing areas adequate pollination is obtained by the now standard practice of placing bee stands at desired intervals through the fields. Bees are usually obtained through commercial beemen. Fees for this service are generally quite standardized. The most troublesome disease problem is that of stand loss due to bacterial wilt. This problem has been
Field Seed Crops-Acreage
TABLE XI and Production by States, in the Pacific Northwest'.'
Idaho
Oregon
1944-53
Alfalfa seed Red clover seed Ladino clover seed White clover seed Alsike clover seed Crimson clover seed Austrian winter field pea seed Hairy vetch seed Other vetch seed. Common ryegrass seed Perennial ryegrass seed Tall (Alta) fescue seed Chewings fescue seed Red fescue seed Ben tgrass seed Merion Kentucky bluegrass seed
1954
1944-55
Acres Pounds
000 000 Acres Pounds
27.9 50.5 1.7 6.9 15.6
27.0 14.5 0.1 4.1 10.0
000
-
000
5,470 7,946 175 1,458 2.593
-
45.6 34,752
-
5.1
-
0.5
-
x
-
4.050 6.655 12 1,046
2,300
-
12.0 15,000
000
000
1954 000
0
Washington
000
1944-55 000
;
1954
000
000
*
000
Acres Pounds
Acres Pounds
Acres Pounds
Acres Pounds
6.0 18.4 11.5 1.5 11.6 3.1 24.9 56.7 65.0 89.7 16.1 14.7 12.4 5.9 10.9
6.0 1.500 16.5 2,592 1.5 247 0.9 155 7.0 2,855 4.5 1,161 24.8 21.600 26.0 7,150 14.0 8,260 112.0 105,000 24.0 21,000 12.0 4,020 95.0 6,785 7.0 5,560 15.5 2,902 2.0 400
12.1 3.6 1.7
25.0
1,149 2,666 1,562 160 5,469 914 24,880 15,988 28,560 52,210 7.155 5,758 2,806 1.171 1,598
-
8.5 1.9 1.4
-
1.0
-
0.7 2.4
-
6.063 565 126
3.3 0.1
10,580 726
-
1o.oso
18.0 0.2 0.2
2,160 60 100
0.5
150
696 853
389 30s 185
-
-
-
1.5 1.7 1.6
n r
0
8
1s F. - p J 0
-
-
5
-
--
804 170 554
w
3 * 3 4 !-.
x .
x 5
6
-z cj
U
1 Data
1
F
obtained from Seed Crops, U. S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Marketing Service. Crop Reporting Board. w in units of thouspndb
51 largely eliminated or at least minimized for growers of wilt-resistant varieties, but stands of non-wilt-resistant alfalfas are generally shortlived owing to this trouble in the irrigated sections east of the Cascade Mountains. Other diseases such as black stem, leafspot, and mildew may be responsible for losses, but generally these ailments more seriously affect the early and late hay crops. The insect pest giving most concern to alfalfa seed growers is the Lygus bug. The population of this insect must be watched and controlled during the period of early flower bud stage to the end of bloom. Control measures which involve the use of insecticides must be judiciously applied to avoid excessive mortality among the bees that are frequenting the crop during this same period. Other insects frequently needing control are the alfalfa weevil, cutworms, and grasshoppers. The first growth of the season is usually removed for forage. The second growth is then the seed-producing crop. The principal exception to this rule is in the case of short growing seasons or where LADAK alfalfa seed is produced. In these situations, the first crop is usually the seed-producing crop. (2) Red clover seed. Some red clover seed production occurs in almost every crop zone of the Pacific Northwest. The most important are Zone 13, practically all of which lies in the Snake River Valley of Idaho, and Zone 3, with most of the production occurring in the Willamette Valley of Oregon. Both common red clover and certified varieties are grown. The most important of the certified varieties is KENLAND. The PENNSCOTT variety is increasing in production. In Zone 3, forage and seed production generally go hand in hand, the first growth being removed for forage in late May or in June. The seed is produced by the second growth. The whole season’s production is usually utilized in developing the seed crop in the other producing areas, namely, those east of the Cascade Mountains. Pollination of red clover, as with alfalfa, is usually accomplished through hiring the services of commercial beemen, especially in Zone 13. This is not so often the case in Zone 3, where bumblebees and other wild pollinators are largely relied upon. The weed control problem is met with a combination of cultural methods and sprays, especially sprays applied during the dormant period. Insect pests, in addition to the clover root borer and the clover root curculio, are chiefly limited to the clover leaf weevil, the small clover leaf weevil, the clover seed Chalcid, and the Nitidulid beetle. The latter two have been difficult to control by chemical means. Acreage for seed has undergone a marked decline recently in the state of Idaho. Oregon and Washington are holding nearly steady with slight declines in acreage. FIELD CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL MANAGEMENT
52
H. B. CHENEY,
w. H.
FOOTE, E. G . KNOX, AND H. H. RAMPTON
( 3 ) Ladino and other white clover seed. Ladino clover (Trifolium repens L. var. Ladino) seed production has been carried on in Crop Zones 3, 4, 5, 7, and 13. Most of the acreage has been concentrated in Zone 5, centered in Jefferson, Crook and Deschutes counties of Oregon. The highest production of seed was in 1953. Since then, acreage and production have declined rapidly owing to an oversupply of seed. The greatest production continues to be in Zone 5 . White clover (Trifolium repens L.) seed production is centered in Zone 13, with a considerably smaller amount in Zone 3. Production of seed has declined recently, with Zone 3 suffering the sharpest reduction. Production problems of both Ladino and commercial white clover producers are somewhat similar, especially with respect to disease, insect, and pollination problems. All the seed is produced under irrigation with the exception of the white clover acreage in Zone 3. Adequate pollination is obtained through hiring the services of commercial beemen. Principal insect pests of these crops are the clover leaf weevil, the small clover leaf weevil, the clover root curculio, clover seed weevils, red spider, the Ladino clover seed midge, Lygus bugs, slugs, and cutworms. Considerable emphasis is placed upon excluding such crops as white clover, birdsfoot trefoil, alsike clover, and timothy from areas producing Ladino clover seed, because these seeds are inseparable from Ladino seeds. ( 4 ) Alsike clover seed. The Pacific Northwest region is the center of production of Alsike clover (Trifolium hybridum L.) seed in the United States. In 1954, over half of the domestic production of this commodity occurred in Oregon and Idaho. Practically the whole acreage occurs in Crop Zones 5 and 13, with the most concentrated area of production in the Klamath Basin of Zone 5. Alsike clover is esteemed as a soil-improving legume in the areas of seed production. Production problems are somewhat similar to those of Ladino and white clover, especially in regard to obtaining adequate pollination and to the insect pests involved. The most troublesome insect pests are clover aphids, clover leaf weevils, the clover root curculio, clover seed weevils, the Ladino clover seed midge, and Lygus bugs. Mixtures of other crop seeds are troublesome to Alsike seed growers. The most common other crop seed mixture is white clover. (5) Crimson clover seed. Crimson clover (Trifolium incarnatum L.) is adapted in Crop Zones 2 and 3 of the Pacific Northwest. It lacks winter hardiness in areas east of the Cascade Mountains. The crop prefers deep, well-drained soil, but will grow satisfactorily on rather shallow hill lands having good drainage. Crimson clover is a good soil im-
FIELD CROP PRODUCTION AND SOIL MANAGEMENT
53
prover and fits well into rotations on seed-producing farms. Practically all the seed production in the Pacific Northwest is concentrated in the Willamette Valley area of Zone 3. The climate of this area with its mild moist winters and generally warm, dry summers is favorable for the development and harvesting of crimson clover seed crops. Most of the seed produced is exported to the southeastern states for forage and cover crop plantings. The principal variety grown in DIXIE, which is preferred over much of the southeastern United States. Opportunities for increased production are good. The 1954 seed crop from Zone 3 was 1,161,000 pounds. The annual use of crimson clover seed in the United States during the past two years was over 24,000,000 pounds. ( 6 ) Austrian winter field pea seed. The Austrian winter field pea (Pisum satiuum L. var. arvense.) is grown for seed on the better soils in Crop Zones 3,4, 5, 6, and 11. Most of the production occurs in Zones 3 and 11. From about 1930 to 1950, most of the seed was used in the southeastern states for green manure and winter cover crop plantings. More recently, this legume has been largely replaced by other winter cover crops, and production of seed in the Pacific Northwest has declined. Most of the seed now grown is used as a source of protein in concentrated livestock feeds. The most common pest in seed-growing areas is the pea weevil. This insect is controlled by properly timed applications of DDT to the growing crop, and by proper fumigation of the seed after harvest. The pea aphid, also, may be destructive during some years. (7) Hairy vetch seed. Hairy vetch (Vicia villosa Roth.) seed production in the Pacific Northwest is almost entirely confined to the Willamette Valley of Crop Zone 3. In the past, this area produced about 90 per cent of the domestic seed crop. More recently other areas in the central south have become important in seed production. This has resulted in a decrease of acreage in the Pacific Northwest. About 23 per cent of the crop originated in the region in 1954. Hairy vetch seed is chiefly used for green manure and winter cover crop plantings in the southeastern states. The most important pest of the hairy vetch seed crop is the vetch bruchid, an insect similar to the pea weevil. Control is effected by application of DDT to the growing crop and by prompt fumigation of the harvested seed. ( 8 ) Other uetches for seed. These vetches are grown for seed on the better soils in Crop Zones 3 and 4, with most of the production in Zone 3. Common vetch and WILLAMETTE, a strain of common, occupy most of the acreage. The seed is used for green manure and winter cover crop plantings in the southeastern states, and for hay and silage growing in Zones 1,2, 3, and 4, Most of the domestic-grown seed comes
54 H. B. CHENEY, W. H. FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, A N D H. H. RAMPTON from the Pacific Northwest, Reduction in use of the seed in the southeastern states has caused a marked decline in acreage devoted to seed production in the Pacific Northwest. ( 9 ) Miscellaneous legume seeds. Other legume seeds produced in commercial quantities for use principally within or near the region are NOMAD and ORESTAN alfalfa; GRANGER, CASCADE, and DOUGLAS birdsfoot trefoil (Lotus corniculatus L.) ;COLUMBIA and BEAVER big trefoil (Lotus uliginosus Schhhr.) ; the MT. BARKER, TALLAROOK, and NANGEELA varieties of subclover (Trifolium subterraneum L.) ; sweetclover (Melilotus alba Med.) , and strawberry clover (Trifolium fragiferum L.) . c. Grass Seed Crops. (Statistics are shown in Table XI.) (1) Ryegrass seed. Seed production of common ryegrass (Lolium spp.,) and perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.) is mostly concentrated on the poorly drained valley floor soils of the Willamette Valley of Crop Zone 3. The climate in this area, being moist and mild in the winter and warm and dry in the summer, favors the growth and seed production of these grasses. Common ryegrass lacks sufficient winter hardiness for survival east of the Cascade Mountains. Perennial ryegrass is more hardy but is seldom grown for seed outside of Zone 3. Most of the ryegrass seed is grown for export to other states. Perennial ryegrass seed is widely used in pasture mixtures in the more temperate portion of the country and in low-priced lawn mixtures. Common ryegrass seed is much used in the southern and southeastern states for sowing in winter lawns, for winter pastures, and for winter cover-cropping. Some of it also goes into cheap lawn mixtures. Production of common ryegrass seed varies considerably, being about 61,000,000 pounds in 1953 and 105,000,000 pounds in 1954. The production of perennial rye-grass seed is considerably less than that of common ryegrass, but it has been steadily increasing for several years. The 1954 production was about 21,000,000 pounds of seed. Both of these crops often contribute considerable forage as sheep pasture during the winter and early spring, especially during years when winter temperatures are mild and early growth is profuse. Few other crops grow well on the wet soils on which ryegrass is grown. This is especially true on the more imperfectly drained soils where most of the common ryegrass seed is produced. This situation has led to much continuous cropping and increase of weeds, many of which have seeds not readily separable from ryegrass seed. To overcome this difficulty, growers are increasing the practice of summer fallowing and late spring planting. The seed crop is harvested the following year. (2) Tall fescue seed. Tall fescue (Festuca arundinacea Schreb.) prefers deep soils having good water-holding capacity but is adapted on
FIELD CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL MANAGEMENT
55
most of the soils and in all crop zones of the region where moisture is adequate. It will endure poorly drained conditions, especially in winter, and has more salt and alkali tolerance than most other cultivated grasses grown in the region. It is winter hardy throughout the region but does not endure long snow cover. The variety ALTA is grown almost exclusively. Ten years ago most of the domestic seed was produced in the Pacific Northwest. Since that time seed production has become important in other states so that now the region produces about 16 to 20 per cent of the domestic seed crop. The 1954 production in the region was about 4,740,000 pounds of seed, of which 3,745,000 pounds was grown in the Willamette Valley of Zone 3. Most seed producers grow this crop in cultivated rows for better weed control, greater yields of seed, and increased productive life of stands. ( 3 ) Chewings and red fescue seed. Red fescue (Festuca rubra L.) and chewings fescue ( F . rubra var. commutata Gaud.) are similar in appearance, adaptations, and uses. They prefer well-drained soils and are tolerant of moderate soil acidity. They possess good winter hardiness but prefer mild winters and temperate summers. These grasses are grown in both cultivated rows and in solid stands. Most of the red fescue is grown in cultivated rows. The solid stand method is used by the majority of chewings fescue seed growers. The most important improved varieties of red fescue in the region are ILLAHEE, RAINIER, and PENNLAWN. Most of the seed of chewings and red fescue is used in mixtures with other grasses for lawn and turf plantings. Practically all the domestic chewings fescue seed crop is produced in the state of Oregon, with most of the acreage located in the Willamette Valley of Crop Zone 3 and a lesser amount in the Grande Ronde Valley of Zone 6. The 1954 production was 6,785,000 pounds of chewings fescue seed. The domestic production of red fescue seed is also almost entirely in the Pacific Northwest. The most concentrated area is in the Grande Ronde Valley of Zone 6. Other producing areas are in Zones 3, 5, and 11. The 1954 domestic production of red fescue seed was 4,452,000 pounds. Recently, large imports of red fescue seed from new producing areas in western Canada have resulted in greatly increased supplies, sharply reduced prices to growers, and a reduction in acreage in the region. ( 4 ) Bentgrass seed. Bentgrasses have wide soil adaptations. They perform well on a wide variety of soils where moisture is plentiful and temperature is favorable. These grasses are tolerant of poor drainage and soil acidity. They endure soil salinity and alkalinity, SEASIDE creeping bentgrass (Agrostis palusiris Huds.) being especially tolerant. They prefer a moist, mild climate, but seed-producing stands possess considerable winter hardiness. The principal bentgrasses grown for
56
H. B. CHENEY,
w. H. FOOTE,
E. G. KNOX, AND H. H. RAMPTON
seed in the region are COLONIAL bentgrass (Agrostis tenuis Sibth.), grown chiefly in the Cowlitz Prairie area of Crop Zone 3; HIGHLAND, a variety of colonial bentgrass produced in the Willamette Valley of Zone 3; ASTORIA, also a variety of colonial bentgrass, produced in the lower Columbia River area of Zone 1, in the Grande Ronde Valley area of Zone 6, and in the Klamath Basin area of Zone 5; and SEASIDE creeping bentgrass, produced in the Klamath Basin area of Zone 5 and the Grande Ronde Valley area of Zone 6. The bentgrass seeds are used almost solely for the planting of lawns and turfs. Practically the entire domestic crop of seed is produced in the Pacific Northwest. ( 5 ) Kentucky (Merion) bluegrass seed. The Pacific Northwest is of little importance in the production of common commercial Kentucky bluegrass (Poa pratensis L.) seed. It is of major importance, however, in the seed production of MERION, an improved turf variety. In 1954, practically the whole supply of MERION seed was grown in the region. The principal centers of production are in the Grande Ronde Valley of Crop Zone 6 and the Spokane area of Zone 11. (6) Miscellaneous grass seeds, Seeds of other grasses produced in commercial quantities for use principally within or near the region are tall oatgrass (Arrhenatherurn elatius L. var. Tualatin), Welsh S. 143 and Akaroa varieties of orchard grass (Dactylis glomerata L.) , meadow foxtail (Alopecurus pratensis L.) , Sudan grass (Sorghum sudanense (Piper) Stapf.) , tall wheatgrass (Agropyron elongatum (Host) Beauv.) , intermediate wheatgrass ( A . intermedium (Host) Beauv. var. Greener), pubescent wheatgrass ( A . trichophorum (Link) Richt. var. Topar), slender wheatgrass ( A . trachycaulum (Link) Malte var. Primar), beardless wheatgrass ( A . inerme (Scribn. and Smith) Rydb. var. Whitmar), Siberian wheatgrass ( A . sibiricum (Willd.) Beauv.), desert wheatgrass ( A . desertorurn (Fisch. ) Schult.) , crested wheatgrass ( A . cristatum (L.) Gaertn.), Manchar and Lincoln varieties of smooth bromegrass (Bromus inermis Leyss.) , big bluegrass (Poa ampla Merr. var. Sherman), hard fescue (Festuca ovina var. duriuscula (L.) Koch), and sheep fescue ( P . ovina L.) .
4 . Potatoes The Pacific Northwest has several important potato-producing areas and the production is a very important segment of the economy of the region. Both early to intermediate and late crops of potatoes are produced on the irrigated soils of the region. The production of potatoes is heavily concentrated in the Klamath Basin and Deschutes area of Zone 5, in the Yakima Valley in Zone 7, and throughout the irrigated Snake
FIELD CROP PRODUCTION AND SOIL MANAGEMENT
57
River Valley, in Zone 13. Some potatoes are grown in most other agricultural areas but often only to supply a local demand. The production and acreages of potatoes in the Pacific Northwest for 1942-51 and 1954 are given in Table XII. The acreage of potatoes has decreased slightly but the total production has increased. This is a direct result of better farming practices such as more fertilizer, better irrigation, improved insect and disease control, and better adapted varieties. I n Idaho, one of the leading states in potato production, the crop is grown chiefly on the irrigated soils of the Snake River Valley, and to a lesser extent in northern Idaho, where they are grown without irrigation. Over 90 per cent of the crop is of the RUSSET BURBANK variety, with some WHITE ROSE and TRIUMPH grown. TABLE XI1 Production and Acreages of Potatoes for the Three States in the Pacific Northwest in 1942-51 and 1954
Oregon Washington Idaho Total
* Agricultural Statistics, 1964. U . S.
Acreage
Production
(1000 acres)
(100-lh. bags)
1942-51'
19542
1942-51
1954
42 34 160 236
37 26 146 209
6,758,400 6,126,000 24,141,600 36,996,000
8,041,354 6,316,249 45,504,638 39,861,241
Department of Agriculture.
* U. S. Bureau of Census, 1955. 1954 Agricultural Census Preliminary.
Oregon has four distinct potato-producing districts. The Klamath Basin, central Oregon, northern Willamette Valley, and the Snake River Valley area of Malheur County are the important areas. The RUSSET BURBANK, WHITE ROSE, and TRIUMPH are the leading varieties. I n recent years, certified potato seed stock has been grown for shipment to California. Washington has three principal potato-producing areas, located in Yakima, Kittitas, Spokane, Benton, and Grant counties. Important commercial varieties are the RUSSET BURBANK and WHITE ROSE. Potatoes grown under irrigation are usually grown in a rotation with alfalfa and grain. The use of phosphate and nitrogen fertilizer has been increasing rapidly. Diseases and insect pests are often very serious on potatoes, seriously reducing yields and quality of the crop. The virus diseases, including
H. B. CHENEY, w. H. FOOTE, E. G. KNOX, AND H. H.RAMPTON
58
mild mosaic, rugose mosaic, leaf roll, and others, are often very serious. Scab (Streptomyces scabies), late blight (Phytophthora infectans) ,ring rot (Corynebmterium sependoricum),rhizoctonia (Rhizoctonia solani), and nematodes (Heterodera marioni) take their annual toll. The Colorado potato beetle, flea beetles, wireworms, aphids, and leaf hoppers are often serious insect pests.
5 . Sugar Beets The important sugar beet producing areas are in the irrigated section of the Snake River Valley Zone 13 and to some extent in Zone 7. The acreages and production of sugar beets for 1942-51 and for 1954 are given in Table XIII. TABLE XI11 Production and Acreages of Sugar Beets for the Three States in the Pacific Northwest in 1942-51 and 1954 Acreage (Acres)
Oregon Washington Idaho Total 2
Production (1000 tons)
1942-51'
1954'
1942-51
1954
16,700 14,800 68,700 100,200
18,378 92,622 85,844 196,844
314 308 1,142 1,743
396 728 1,558 2,689
Agricultural Statistics, 1964. U. S. Department of Agriculture. U. S. Bureau of Census, 1956. 1964 Agricultural Census Preliminary.
The acreage of sugar beets has increased slightly over the 1942-51 average, while the production is up some 54 per cent over the same period. One of the contributing factors to this increased production has been the widespread use of curly top resistant varieties, more careful farm planning or rotations, and a higher level of soil fertility through better rotations and extensive use of commercial fertilizer. Curly top, a virus disease carried by the beet leaf hopper (Eutettix tenellus), has been the most serious disease. Damping-off, nematodes, and some insects, namely, beetles, armyworms, wireworms, and aphids, are often serious in localized areas. Sugar beets are grown for seed as a specialized crop in the Willamette Valley and in southern Oregon.
6 . Annual Legumes The annual legumes such as field peas and beans are produced in several areas of the Pacific Northwest. The primary areas are in southeastern Washington and adjoining portions of Idaho, in Zones 11 and
FIELD CROP PRODUCTION A N D SOIL MANAGEMENT
59
13, and to a lesser extent in the Blue Mountains area, Zone 6, and in western Oregon and Washington Zone 3. The production and acreages of the annual legumes for 1942-51 and for 1954 are given in Table XIV. During recent years, the acreage and production of field beans and peas has declined. TABLE XIV Production and Acreages of Annual Legumes for the Three States in the Pacific Northwest in 1942-51 and 1954 Acreage
Production
(1000 acres)
(1000 pounds)
1944-51l
Oregon Washington Idaho Total 1
27 242 277 546
19542 1944-51 8 119 250
377
33,048 318,655 411,071 763,774
1954 8,568 163,870 409,372 574,810
Agricultural Statistics, 1954. U. S. Department of Agriculture.
* U. S. Bureau of Censua, 1955. 1964 Agricultural Census Preliminary.
Field peas often replace summer fallow in the wheat rotation in the Palouse area of Washington and northern Idaho. The principal varieties are the Canadian, Austrian, and the dry edible pea variety, ALASKA. The common field beans are grown successfully on both irrigated and nonirrigated soil. The Great Northern type is grown mainly in the area with some Red Mexicans, and other small white types.
REFERENCES Allison, I. S. 1953. In “Atlas of the Pacific Northwest Resources and Development” (R. M. Highsmith, Jr., ed.), pp. 3-5. Oregon State College, Corvallis. Baldwin, M., Kellogg, C. E., and Thorp, J. 1938. Soil. U.S. Dept. Agr. Yearbook, pp. 979-1001. Beck, J. R. et al. 1952. Oregon State Coll. Oregon Agr. 9. Blanch, G. E. et al. 1955. Oregon State Coll. Oregon Agr. 22. Blodgett, E. C. 1946. Idaho Agr. Ezpt. Sta. Circ. 1 1 0. C u b a n , H. 1955. Oregon Ext. Ser. Circ. 588. Fireman, M., Mogen, C. A., and Baker, G. 0. 1950. Idaho Agr. Expt. Sta. Research Bull. 17. Highsmith, R. M., Jr., ed. 1956. “Atlas of the Pacific Northwest Resources and Development,” rev. ed. Oregon State College, Corvallis. Homer, G. M., McCall, A. G., and Bell, F. G. 19M. U.S. Dept. Agr. Tech. Bull. 860. Horning, T. 1955. Oregon Agr. Progr. 3 , No. I,15. Hunter, A. S., and Yungen, J. A. 1952. Proc. A m . SOC.Sugar Beet Technol. 180-188. Hunter, A. S., and Yungen, J. A. 1955. Soil Sci. SOC.Amer. Proc. 19, 214-218. Jensen, M. C., Lewis, G. C., and Baker, G. 0. 1951. Idaho Agr. Expt. Sta. Research Bull. 19.
60
H. B. CHENEY,
w.
H. FOOTE, E. G . KNOX, AND H. H. RAMPTON
Kaiser, V. G., Pawson, W. W., Groeneveld, M. H. H., and Brough, 0. L., Jr. 1954. Washington Agr. Expt. Sta. Circ. 255. McKay, M. C., and Moss, W. A. 19M. Idaho Agr. Expt. Sta. Bull. 256. Mech, S . J. 1949. Agr. Eng. 30, 379-383. Mech, S. J. 1955.Agr. Eng. 36, 318. Morrison, K. J., Viets, F. G., Jr., and Nelson, C. E. 1954. Washington Ext. Ser. Bull. 489.
Nelson, C. E., and Larson, C. A. 1946. Washington Agr. Expt. Sta. Bull. 481. Nelson, C. E. 1953.Washington Ext. Ser. Bull. 481. Nelson, C. E. 1954. Washington Ext. Ser. Bull. 365 (Revised). Parks, R. Q. 1951. Advances in Agron. 3,323-344. Pope, A. 1955. Ph.D. Thesis, Oregon State College. Powers, W. L., 1923.Oregon Agr. Expt. Sta. Bull. 199. Powers, W. L., and Wood, L. K. 1947. Oregon Agr. Expt. Sfa. Circ. 418. Reimer, F. C., and Tartar, H. V. 1919.Oregon Agr. Expt. Sta. Bull. 163. Richards, L. A., ed. 1954. U.S. Dept. Agri. Handbook No. 60. Scholl, W., and Wallace, H. M. 1953. Agr. Chemicals 5, No. 6, 32-38. Scholl, W., and Wallace, H. M. 1951.Com. Fertilizer 82, 21-32. Scholl, W., and Wallace, H. M. 1952. Corn. Fertilizer 85, 19-35. Scholl, W., and Wallace, H. M. 1953.Corn. Fertilizer 87, 21-34. Scholl, W., Wallace, H. M., and Fox, E. I. 1954. Agr. Chemicals 9, No.6, 62-82. Scholl, W., Wallace, H. M., and Fox, E. I. 1955. Corn. Fertilizer 91, 3 5 4 . Singleton, H.P. et al. 1950. Washington Agr. Expt. Bull. 520. Soil Survey Staff 1951. US.Dept. Agr. Handbook, No. 18. Thorp, J., and Smith, G. D. 1949.Soil Sci. 67, 1 1 7-126. Tremblay, F. T., and Harston, C. B. 1952. Washington Agr. Ext. Ser. Bull. 386 (Revised). U.S. Bureau of Census 1931-32. Fifteenth Census of the United States: 1930, Agriculture. U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington. US. Bureau of Census 194M3. Sixteenth Census of the United States: 1940, Agriculture. U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington. US. Bureau of Census 1952.United States Census of Agriculture, 1950. U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington. U.S. Bureau of Census 1955. 1954 Agricultural Census, Preliminary. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Conservation Program Service 1954. Agricultural Conservation Program Summary, 1953. U.S. DeRartment of Interior, Bureau of Reclamation 1954. Columbia Basin Joint Investigation, Problem Two. Types of Farming. Viets, F. G., Jr., Boawn, L. C., Nelson, C. E., and Crawford, C. L. 1953a. Washington Agr. Expt. Sta. Circ. 215. Viets, F. G., Jr:, Boawn, L. C., Crawford, C. L., and Nelson, C. E. 195313. Agron. J . 45, 559-565. Viets, F. G., Jr., Boawn, L. C., and Crawford, C. L. 1954. Soil Sci. 78, 305-516.
Anhydrous Ammonia as a Nitrogenous Fertilizer
. .
W B ANDREWS Mississippi Agricultural Experiment Station. State College. Mississippi
I. Introduction .
1 . Use of Anhydrous Ammonia . . . . . . . . . . 2. Manufacture of Anhydrous Ammonia . . . . . . . . 3 . Historical Experimental Use of Aqua and Anhydrous Ammonia . 4. Early Work on the Use of Anhydrous Ammonia in Mississippi . 5 Physical and Chemical Properties . . . . . . . . . . I1. Behavior of Anhydrous Ammonia in the Soil . . . . . . . . 1 . Fixation by the Soil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Effect on Structural Stability . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Effect on Availability of Plant Nutrients . . . . . . . . 4. Effect on Lime Content of Soil . . . . . . . . . . 5 . Effect on the Soil Fauna . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. Effect on the Microbial Flora in Soil . . . . . . . . . 7. Nitrification of Ammonia . . . . . . . . . . . . I11 Response of Crops to Anhydrous Ammonia . . . . . . . . . 1 Form of Nitrogen Used by Crop Plants . . . . . . . . 2. Response of Cotton . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Response of Corn . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Response of Small Grains . . . . . . . . . . . . a . In Mississippi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . b . In Other Humid Areas . . . . . . . . . . . c. In Dryland Farming . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 . Response of Pasture and Hay Crops . . . . . . . . . 6. Response of Sorghum and Sugar Cane . . . . . . . . 7. Response of Truck Crops and Potatoes . . . . . . . . 8 . Response of Rice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9. Work in Other Countries . . . . . . . . . . . . 10. Placement of Anhydrous Ammonia . . . . . . . . . IV Anhydrous Ammonia Equipment . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Storage and Application . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Bleeding Losses in Filling Tanks . . . . . . . . . . 3 Distribution Pattern . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI. Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
Page 62 . 62 . 63 . 67 . 68 . 69 . 70 . 70 . 72 . 72 . 74 . 74 . 74 . 75 . 79 . 79 . 81 . 84 . 91 . 92 . 95 . 98 . 101 . 104 . 104 . 106 . 109
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
. 109 . 110 . 110
.
. 114 . 118
61
119
. 123 . 123
62
W. B. ANDREWS
I. INTRODUCTION Anhydrous ammonia is used as a nitrogenous fertilizer in most of the states in the United States, in Canada, and in several foreign countries. Though some anhydrous ammonia was used in irrigation water prior to 1947, its use in large quantities, mostly applied directly to the soil, has taken place since that time. During the 1947-1954 period, the total quantity of fertilizer nitrogen used almost tripled, and ammonium nitrate became the leading source of nitrogen, though in 1954 the quantity of nitrogen supplied by ammonium nitrate was only slightly more than that supplied by anhydrous ammonia.
1. Use of Anhydrous Ammonia In 1943, a number of farmers in the Tennessee Valley states used aqua ammonia as a source of nitrogen. A few of them continued to use TABLE I
T h e Use of Fertilizer Nitrogen in the United States, Alaska, Hawaii, and Puerto Rico Tons of nitrogen
As anhydrous Year 1900 1910 1930 1930 1940 1945 1948 1949 1950 1951 1952 1953 1954
Total
ammonia
63,000 146,000 328,000 377,000 4 19,000 641,000 841,000 913,000 1,136,000 1,265,000 1,485,000 1,648,000 1,847,000
36,566 53,789 70,122 97,107 137,984 178,089 287,389
it for several years. In Mississippi, the number of farmers using aqua ammonia increased in 1947 and 1948. However, most of those in Mississippi who formerly used aqua ammonia are now using anhydrous ammonia. In recent years, a little aqua ammonia has been used in other states, though the extent of such use is not known. The total tonnage of nitrogen and tonnage as anhydrous ammonia used in selected years in the United States, Alaska, and h e r t o Rico are reported in Table I (Scholl, personal communication; Scholl et al., 1955). The use of nitrogen increased slowly until 1945, and since has increased rapidly to 1,847,000 tons in 1953-1 954.
ANHYDROUS AMMONIA AS A NITROGENOUS FERTILIZER
63
Prior to 1947, little anhydrous ammonia was used for crop production and that which was used was applied in irrigation water, primarily in California. In the 1947-1948 fertilizer year, 35,566 tons of nitrogen as anhydrous ammonia was used in the United States. Mississippi used 10,556 tons for direct application. If other states used a similar quantity for direct application, the quantity applied in irrigation water was only about 15,000 tons in 1947-1948. In the 1953-1954 fertilizer year, anhydrous ammonia supplied 287,389 tons of nitrogen and ammonium nitrate, 309,780 out of 1,044,876 tons used as materials. It is probable that anhydrous ammonia supplied more nitrogen than ammonium nitrate for direct application in the 1954-55 fertilizer year. From 1942 to 1954, the supply of nitrogen was less than the demand, and in many cases farmers had little choice between materials and mixed fertilizers, or between sources of nitrogen. Between 1947 and 1954 the supply of anhydrous ammonia was far less than the demand and there was often a shortage of steel for making tanks. Since the present and expected immediate future capacity to produce all sources of nitrogen is larger than the demand and steel is plentiful, anhydrous ammonia will have a chance to adjust to its competitive position as a fertilizer in this country. The very rapid increase in the use of anhydrous ammonia soon after its introduction for direct application to the soil in 1947 may be attributed partly to the shortage of other sources of nitrogen at that time, but its continued increase must be attributed to its competitive position from the standpoint of cost and ease of application as well as to the good results which have been obtained from its use. In addition to its use for direct application to the soil, anhydrous ammonia is also used for the ammoniation of superphosphate and in the manufacture of ammonium nitrate, urea, nitrate of soda, sulfate of ammonia, and many other chemicals, and in many industrial processes.
2. Manufacture of Anhydrous Ammonia The capacity to produce nitrogen synthetically in the United States was estimated by Mehring (1955) to be as follows: January 1, 1954 1955 1956 1957
2,191,000 2,785,000 3,440,000 4,050,000
tons tons tons tons
The location and capacity of the plants are reported in Table I1 (Mehring, 1955, and others). In general, the location of plants is determined by the cost and availability of natural gas and coke and proximity to the anticipated area of consumption.
64
W. B. ANDREWS
TABLE I1 Syhthetic Nitrogen Plants, Capacity and Location in the United States, August I,1955 Plants in operation WEST COAST Brea Chemicals, Brea, California Dow Chemical, Pittsburg, California Hercules Powder Co., Pinole, California Hooker Electrochemical Co., Tacoma, Washington Pennsylvania Salt Manufacturing Co., Portland, Oregon Shell Chemical Co., Shell Point, California Ventura, California MIDCONTINENT AND SOUTH Allied Chemical & Dye, South Point, Ohio Allied Chemical & Dye Corp., La Platte, Nebraska American Cyanamid Co., Fortier, Louisiana Commercial Solvents Corp., Sterlington, Louisiana Coop. Farm Chemicals, Lawrence, Kansas Deere & Co., Pryor, Oklahoma Dow Chemical Co., Freeport, Texas Midland, Michigan Grace Chemical, Memphis, Tennessee Hercules Power Co., Louisiana, Missouri Lion Oil Co., El Dorado, Arkansas Luling, Louisiana Mississippi Chemical Co., Yazoo City, Mississippi Olin Mathieson Chemical, Lake Charles, Louisiana Pennsylvania Salt Manufacturing Co., Wyandotte, Michigan Phillips Chemical Co., Etter, Texas Fort Adams, Texas San Jacinto Chemical Corp., Houston, Texas Spencer Chemical Company, Pittsburg, Kansas Henderson, Kentucky Vicksburg, Mississippi TVA, Muscle Shoals, Alabama U. S. Industrial Chemicals Company, Tuscola, Illinois EAST COAST Allied Chemical & Dye Corporation, Hopewell, Virginia Atlantic Refining Co., Point Breeze, Pennsylvania Columbia-Southern Chemical Corp., Natrium, West Virginia DuPont de Nemours & Co., Niagara Falls, New York Belle, West Virginia Olin Mathieson Chemical Corporation, Niagara Falls, New York Morgantown, West Virginia Plants under Construction Calumet Nitrogen Products Hammond, Indiana Escambia Bay Chemical Corporation Pensacola, Florida Food Machinery & Chemical Corporation Charleston, West Virginia Ketona Chemical Company Ketona, Alabama Mississippi River Fuel Corporation Crystal City, Missouri
Capacity, tons nitrogen per year 70,500 6,000 90,000 18,000 90,000 53,000
234,000 62,000 90,000 110,000 52,000 54,000 58,000 72,000 34,400 170,000 88,000 54,000 84,000 26,000 126,000 128,000 30,000 145,000 65,000 59,000 74,000 41,000 328,000 '27,000 27,000 8,000 190,000 5,000 154,000
A N H Y D R O U S A M M O N I A AS A N I T R O G E N O U S FERTILIZER
65
TABLE I1 ( Continued) Plants in operation
Plants under Construction Sohio Chemical Company Southern Nitrogen Company Standard Oil Company Sun Oil Company U. S. Steel Geneva Works Utah Chemical Company Plants Projected but Not under Construction Ammonia Chemical Company Arizona Gas & Chemical Company Atlas Powder Company Canadian Hydro-Carbons Canadian Industries, Ltd. Celanese Corporation of America Cities Service Columbia River Chemical Co. Dow Chemical Company Gulf Improvement Corporation Gulf States Utility Northern Chemical Industries, Inc. Northwest Nitro-Chemicals, Ltd. Phillips Pacific Chemical Co. Quebec Ammonia St. Paul Ammonia Products Co. Salt Lake Chemical Co. Southwest Agrochemical Corporation Thunderbird Chemical Company
Capacity, tons nitrogen per year
Toledo-Lima, Ohio Savannah, Georgia Richmond, California Marcus Hook, Pennsylvania Geneva, Utah Mt. Pleasant, Utah Merced, California Northern Arizona Atlas, Missouri Winnipeg, Canada Milhaven, Ontario Baton Rouge, Louisiana Lake Charles, Louisiana Pasco, Washington Buras, Louisiana Pascagoula, Mississippi Beaumont, Texas Searsport, Maine Medicine Hat, Alberta, Canada Southeastern Washington Montreal, P. Q. St. Paul, Minnesota Salt Lake City, Utah Chandler, Arizona Kyrene, Arizona
The direct synthesis of anhydrous ammonia was accomplished first in 1908, and the first commercial plant came into production in 1913 in Germany. Construction of two major plants was begun in the United States during World War I and finished after World War I. On October 1, 1955, there were 37 plants in operation, 10 in the process of construction, 16 projected plants not under construction in the United States, and 3 projected plants to be located just inside Canada. Anhydrous ammonia is made by compressing three volumes of hydrogen and one of nitrogen in contact with a catalyst. The pressure is 4000 to 5000 p.s.i. in most plants, but as much as 15,000 p.s.i. in some plants. The temperature in the reaction chamber is about 1000"F., depending upon the activity of the catalyst. The catalyst is carefully purified magnetic iron oxide, promoted with small percentages of aluminum and potassium oxides (Thompson and Shearon, 1952). The nitrogen for making ammonia is obtained from the air, which contains about 12 pounds over each square inch of the earth's surface,
66
W. B. ANDREWS
or about 1700 pounds over each square foot. Where petroleum products are used, the oxygen is separated from the nitrogen simultaneously with the production of hydrogen. The oxygen in the air and steam combine with the carbon of the petroleum product, methane (CH,), for example, forming hydrogen gas and carbon dioxide and monoxide; the nitrogen remains in the mixture. Primarily, hydrogen is obtained by reacting petroleum products with steam which releases hydrogen and forms carbon dioxide and monoxide. Formerly, and to some extent today, hydrogen was obtained from water by applying steam to glowing coke. The carbon of the coke
FIG. 1 . Bulk storage of anhydrous ammonia (courtesy of Mississippi Agricultural Experiment Station).
combines with the oxygen in the steam, forming hydrogen gas and carbon dioxide and monoxide. In this process the coke is alternately treated with air and steam and part of the nitrogen is obtained and oxygen removed as where a petroleum product is used. Nitrogen is also obtained by liquefaction and distillation of the air. Nitrogen boils at -196O C.,while oxygen boils at -183O C. Most of the carbon monoxide is reacted with steam to give more hydrogen and carbon dioxide. The carbon dioxide is removed by absorption in water under pressure. In the process there remains a small quantity of carbon monoxide which would poison the catalyst if it should remain as such. It is removed chemically, or reacted with hydrogen, producing methane and water. The water is removed and the
ANHYDROUS AMMONIA AS A NITROGENOUS FERTILIZER
67
small quantity of methane goes through the process as an inert gas. In an economical size plant, the present cost of equipment to produce 1 ton of nitrogen as anhydrous ammonia annually is $100 to $125, as compared to $200 to $240 for ammonium nitrate. The cost of tanks for storing anhydrous ammonia is $150 to $200 per ton of ammonia capacity. The cost of good storage for ammonium nitrate is considerable, though it may be stored in buildings which are also used for other purposes. The cost of producing 1 ton of anhydrous ammonia is essentially the same as the cost of producing 1 ton of ammonia nitrate; on a pound of nitrogen basis, the cost of producing anhydrous ammonia is only about 40 per cent of the cost of ammonia nitrate. The relative costs of the two materials suggest that where suited the use of anhydrous ammonia will continue to increase relative to the solid sources.
3 . Historical Experimental Use of Aqua and Anhydrous Ammonia The first reference to the use of free ammonia in fertilization was by Johnston (1853) in England, who discussed the use of “ammoniacal liquor” for grasslands and grain crops. In 1930, Smith (cited by Andrews et al., 1951), applied anhydrous ammonia directly to the soil by means of a small cylinder attached to a one-mule plow.- In 1931, Tiedjens and Robins reported data on the use of aqua ammonia in greenhouse cultures. Waynick (1934) recommended the use of anhydrous ammonia in flood irrigation water and a small quantity has been used in this manner, primarily in California. Chapman (1936) reported greenhouse data in which aqua ammonia was used as a source of nitrogen. In 1939, Leavitt applied for a patent on the application of anhydrous ammonia to arable soils, which was granted as U. S. Patent No. 2,285,932 (1942). In 1943, Andrews et al. (1947a, b), of the Mississippi Agricultural Experiment Station, experimented with aqua ammonia for direct application to the soil in the field. Later in the year, some of the experiment stations in the Tennessee Valley area applied aqua ammonia on an experimental basis, and a limited number of farmers in this area also applied aqua ammonia on a demonstration basis. MacIntire et al. (1944) reported data on the use of aqua ammonia in greenhouse tests. The Mississippi Agricultural Experiment Station began experimental work on the use of anhydrous ammonia for direct application to the soil in 1944 (Andrews et aZ.,1947a, b). Though the work of Smith in 1930 and Leavitt in 1939 suggested that anhydrous ammonia might be applied directly to the soil, the development in the use of anhydrous ammonia came after and was based on the principles outlined by Andrews et aZ. (1947a, b) and first published in 1947.
68
W. B. ANDREWS
4 . Early Work on the Use of Anhydrous Ammonia in Mississippi The Mississippi Agricultural Experiment Station began work on the use of anhydrous ammonia in the spring of 1944. The Tennessee Valley Authority helped to finance the work. The equipment used in applying anhydrous ammonia consisted of ( I ) a “Flowrator” and fittings, ( 2 ) a cylinder of refrigeration grade anhydrous ammonia, and ( 3 ) a knifelike applicator which released the ammonia in the soil and covered it simultaneously, all of which was mounted on a tractor (Edwards and Andrews, 1947). The author still prefers the Flowrator for application of anhydrous ammonia in experimental work. In the spring and summer of 1944 side dressing tests in which anhydrous ammonia was compared with ammonium nitrate were conducted with corn and cotton. In the fall of 1944, tests were started in which fall and spring applications of these sources of nitrogen were made to fall-planted oats. In the spring of 1945 tests were started in which time and rate of application of nitrogen from anhydrous ammonia and ammonium nitrate were compared for the production of corn and cotton. Because of a shortage of solid sources of nitrogen in the winter of 1946-1947, some farmers became interested in the experimental work with anhydrous ammonia which had been conducted. An investigation revealed that sufficient anhydrous ammonia and steel for making equipment would be available to permit some use of anhydrous ammonia by farmers in the spring of 1947. Because the Flowrator used in the experimental work was both almost unavailable and considered unsuited for farm use, another metering device was developed. This metering device consisted of ( I ) a pressure gauge on the tractor tank, (2) suitable valves and connections for conducting the ammonia to ( 3 ) a manifold and orifices, before which there was a pressure gauge, for dividing the ammonia into two or more streams which were conducted into the soil. In the original equipment 3/32-inchorifices were used. The rate of flow per hour through the metering equipment was found to be a function of the pressures of the anhydrous ammonia in the tank and on the orifices, both of which vary with temperature. The rate of flow was varied by a needle valve located between the tank and the orifices. The rate of nitrogen applied per acre is a function of rate per hour and acreage covered. Specifications for the equipment were drawn up and tables were prepared which enabled farmers to apply anhydrous ammonia accurately. Though the instructions enabled accurate application of anhydrous ammonia, in practice, as has been the case with other fertilizers, farm-
ANHYDROUS AMMONIA AS A NITROGENOUS FERTILIZER
69
ers often controlled the rate of application by adjustments made on the basis of the area covered by a prior tank of ammonia rather than by following the instructions. However, the instructions enabled the manufacturer of equipment to supply farmers with starting information. The first equipment for applying anhydrous ammonia was assembled and made in local shops. Steam fittings were often used on tanks because the supply of refrigeration fittings was inadequate, and even the latter were not entirely satisfactory. Since 1947, industry has made suitable fittings for anhydrous ammonia, and several different metering devices have been developed which will be discussed in Section IV, 1 ; however, metering devices based on the principles outlined here are widely used at present. 5 . Physical and Chemical Properties
Anhydrous ammonia is a liquefiable gas which is handled in commerce as a liquid. The liquid phase boils at -28O F. at atmospheric pressure. It has a gauge pressure of 74 p.s.i. at 50" and 197 pounds at looo F. The critical temperature is 271.4O F.; the critical pressure is 1652 p s i . Though its density varies with temperature, it weighs 5 pounds per gallon at 80°F. It contains 82.26 per cent nitrogen. The fertilizer grade contains at least 82 per cent nitrogen. When air contains 16 to 25 per cent ammonia, it can be ignited, though ignition is unlikely. Because of the possibility of an explosion, tanks should not be welded where there is a mixture of air and ammonia. Ammonia is less than two-thirds as heavy as air, and when released into the air, rises quickly unless brought down by air currents. Ammonia readily corrodes copper, brass, and some of the lighter metals. It does not attack steel. Tanks for containing ammonia have a working pressure of 250 p.s.i., and are equipped with relief valves, and excess-flow valves. Tanks should never be completely filled because of the possibility of relief valve failure and an explosion from liquid pressure. In very low concentrations, ammonia is irritating to the eyes, nose, throat, and skin; high concentrations are dangerous. The characteristic odor and irritation produced by ammonia serve as signals when danger approaches. Those who work with ammonia should wear rubber gloves, and protective glasses and clothing when they are possibly needed. Water and a special first-aid kit should always be available for an emergency. In practice, there is little danger in the use of agricultural ammonia because it is handled outside of buildings, though one should always keep in mind that it is inherently dangerous. Hydrocyanic acid, a deadly poison, is formed when a mixture of anhydrous ammonia and fuel gases burns. For this reason, fuel gases
70
W. B. ANDREWS
for open heating should never be put in tanks which have previously contained anhydrous ammonia, unless the complete removal of the anhydrous ammonia has been determined by one who is competent to pass judgment. 11. BEHAVIOR OF ANHYDROUS AMMONIAIN
THE
SOIL
1. Fixation by the Soil On application to the soil, anhydrous ammonia reacts with water to form ammonium hydroxide and diffuses through the soil solution and air until it comes in contact with sufficient clay and organic matter to take it up. Ammonium ions replace hydrogen ions readily; some data (Stanley and Smith, 1955; Anderson, 1955) and observations that alkaline soils retain applied anhydrous ammonia or ammonia released on decomposition of organic matter, suggest that the ammonium ion may replace some calcium from the base exchange complex. The loss of nitrogen into the air from surface applications of ammonium salts to alkaline soils is, no doubt, a phenomenon which is not related to fixation of the ammonium ion within an alkaline soil. Unpublished data by the author show that the application of excess ammonia, as ammonium hydroxide, to strongly acid soils followed by air drying to remove the excess ammonia, results in the fixation of a quantity of ammonia, as determined by distillation, which is essentially equivalent to the lime requirement. However, soils which are only slightly acid fix a quantity of ammonia which is in excess of the lime requirement, the mechanism of which is not fully understood. Though experiments have not yet been made, it is suggested that the ammonia fixed by soils on application of an excess in a dilute solution followed by boiling off the excess is probably closely related to the lime requirement. Under wetting and drying in laboratory experiments, it has been shown that the ammonium ion may be fixed in a form which is not readily exchangeable with neutral salt solutions. However, the fact that for crop production anhydrous ammonia has usually been equal or superior to other sources of nitrogen under field conditions suggests that either anhydrous ammonia is not fixed in a position unavailable to plants or that this fixation is at least offset by additional losses from the other sources of nitrogen which have been compared to it. In field use a good job of application of anhydrous ammonia is being done if a puff of ammonia is rarely seen and if ammonia cannot be smelled by putting the nose close to the soil soon after application. A broad-pointed applicator, 3 to 4 inches wide, increases the soil exposed to ammonia and reduces the loss in application; a disk hiller, or other sealing device, facilitates the retention of ammonia by the soil.
ANHYDROUS AMMONIA AS A NITROGENOUS FERTILIZER
71
The cross-section pattern made by anhydrous ammonia depends upon the physical condition of the soil. If the soil is friable, the cross section tends to be circular. If the soil is compact and wet, the ammonia would be more concentrated along fractures made by the knife applicator and the possibility of loss in application is increased. If the soil is heavy, cloddy, and dry, much of the ammonia escapes into the air. As an illustration, in Ohio on a heavy soil which was in large dry aggregates, Mederski (personal communication) found that anhydrous ammonia was largely lost in application. Under field conditions on a sandy loam soil, Andrews et al. (1951) found that 100 pounds of nitrogen as anhydrous ammonia in 42-inch rows was absorbed in a zone with a cross section having an area of about 16 square inches. The determinations were made by applying a moist filter paper, impregnated with indicator, to a cross section of the area involved. Even though the soil was in excellent physical condition, the indicator suggested variations in the concentration of the ammonia corresponding to fractures in the soil produced by the applicator. Calculations made on Stanley and Smith's (1955) laboratory data on a silt loam soil indicate that 100 pounds of nitrogen as anhydrous ammonia per acre in 40-inch rows was absorbed in zones having cross sections of less than 13, 12, and 9 square inches where the moisture content was 2, 15, and 23 per cent, respectively. These calculations and the findings of Andrews et al. (1951) suggest that little ammonia diffuses beyond 2 inches from the point of application where 100 pounds of nitrogen per acre is applied in 40-inch rows, except in very sandy soils. As Stanley and Smith conducted their laboratory experiments, 100 pounds of nitrogen per acre as anhydrous ammonia was applied at points 40 x 12 inches apart. Their chemical data from soil taken in a plane through the point of application show the equivalent of about 262, 323, and 240 pounds of nitrogen per acre (2,000,000 pounds of soil) in 40-inch rows where the moisture content was 2, 15, and 23 per cent. Though Stanley and Smith found that the depth of application and moisture content of the soil affected the loss of ammonia at the high rates of ammonia applied, such high concentrations of ammonia are unlikely in field applications. The following differences in laboratory experiments and field applications are more favorable to retention of ammonia in field application: (1)with a starting temperature of 80° F., in field application, anhydrous ammonia leaves the applicator as about 84 per cent liquid and 16 per cent vapor and at -28O F.; in laboratory experiments, the metering equipment, no doubt, largely vaporizes the small amount of ammonia involved; because of differences in heat of ab-
72
W. B. ANDREWS
sorption, liquid ammonia is more easily absorbed by the soil water than vapor; (2) shattering of the soil by field applicators increases the exposure of the clay and organic matter and facilitates absorption and retention of ammonia by the soil; and (3) field application of ammonia is in a continuous volume of soil which is small in comparison to the total volume of the soil, whereas laboratory applications are made discontinuously and give, for the same rate of application per surface acre, much higher concentrations of ammonia at the points of application. Comparative crop yields may be the only practical means of measuring losses of anhydrous ammonia in application, though very valuable information may be obtained by applying indicator-impregnated moist filter paper to a cross section of the soil at the point of application in the field. 2 . Effect on Structural Stability In laboratory experiments, Anderson (1955) found that ammonia treatment of a sandy loam soil reduced structural stability, as shown by decreased percolation and by the appearance of “copious quantities” of clay and organic matter in the leachate. An apparent contradiction was found in that ammonia treatment and subsequent drying increased the aggregates retained in a wet-screening procedure. Though Anderson suggested the possibility of attributing the increase in the retention of aggregates to solution and reorientation of the organic matter, it appears to the author that the organic matter may have gone into solution in the wet-screening procedure as well as in the leaching procedure, and that the increase in the retention of the aggregates may have been produced by swelling of ammonium colloids. From a practical viewpoint, there is little, if any, possibility that anhydrous ammonia as applied in the field affects structural stability unfavorably because too small a percentage of the soil is affected for too short a time. From a theoretical viewpoint, it appears that in the zone of application anhydrous ammonia does affect structural stability unfavorably for a short time. As is the case with all other factors which increase yield, the application of anhydrous ammonia increases crop yields and the crop residues returned. Though the improvement is small, increases in crop residues affect structural stability favorably.
3 . Effect on Availability of Plant Nutrients When anhydrous ammonia is applied to the soil, the reaction in the area of concentration approaches pH 9.0. However, within a few weeks, as nitrification progresses, the reaction drops down to or below the original pH of the affected soil. It therefore appears that any increase
ANHYDROUS AMMONIA AS A NITROGENOUS
FERTILIZER
73
in the availability of plant nutrients produced by the alkalinity of freshly applied anhydrous ammonia would disappear on return of the soil to the original reaction, or, in the case of phosphorus, be decreased with a depression of the p H below that of the original soil. In the final analysis, the effect of anhydrous ammonia on the available nutrients probably should be no different from that of ammonium nitrate or urea. Craddock, Wisconsin (personal communication), found that increasing the quantity of ammonium hydroxide progressively increased the phosphorus soluble in water or 0.002 N sulfuric acid. Where the reaction was increased from p H 5.4 to 8.4 by ammonium hydroxide, water-soluble P& was increased 12.1 and acid-soluble P,O, 22.0 pounds per 2,000,000 pounds of soil. It is readily seen that these increases drop to insignificance when applied to a surface acre, only 5 to 10 per cent of which is affected by the anhydrous ammonia applied under field conditions. In this case, 1000 pounds of nitrogen per acre was applied as anhydrous ammonia to Spencer silt loam subsoil; at 100 pounds per acre of nitrogen, the increase is calculated to be 1.2 pounds of water-soluble and 2.2 pounds of acid-soluble P,O, per acre. The application of a quantity of anhydrous ammonia which resulted in 189 pounds of ammonium nitrogen being present, after being subject to nitrification for eight weeks in a soil of pH 6.0 under laboratory conditions, increased the soluble phosphorus 3.3 pounds of P,O, per surface acre (Stanley and Smith, 1955). With a lower rate of application of anhydrous ammonia, the increase would be smaller. Anderson (1955) found that treatment of a soil with ammonium hydroxide increased the water-soluble phosphorus. Though his data were not reported in pounds per acre, the effect on the treated zone is likely to be in line with the data of Craddock (personal communication) and Stanley and Smith (1955) when applied to a surface acre in quantities normally used in the field. According to the experience of Lancaster (personal communication), soil phosphorus brought into solution on contact with ammonia has an availability to plants of about one-third that of superphosphate; this appears to reduce further the significance of the small increases in the solubility of phosphorus reported. Where the alkali-soluble phosphorus content of the soil is very high, the application of ammonia would bring into solution larger amounts of P,O,; however, this probably would have no practical value because it is likely that additional available phosphorus is not needed on such soils. Where alkali-soluble phosphorus in soils is very low, no doubt the effect of the application of anhydrous ammonia on the solution of P,O, would be much less than that noted above. I n any case, the response of crops to the increased solubility of the phosphorus probably would not
74 W. B. ANDREWS be measurable and the quantity of phosphate ordinarily applied would not be reduced.
4 . Effect on Lime Content of Soil Anhydrous ammonia, as well as most sources of nitrogen, is acidforming when applied to the soil. For all practical purposes, the acidity of anhydrous ammonia is the same as that of ammonium nitrate and urea, and one-third that of sulfate of ammonia. The use of high rates of nitrogen in humid climates, where the soils are normally acid, speeds up the time when the application of lime is needed. Many mixed fertilizers contain sufficient lime for them to be labeled “neutral” according to the Official Method, though it is doubtful if they contain sufficient lime completely to offset their acid-forming properties (Andrews, 1954a). Because of the high cost of buying lime in mixed or nitrogenous fertilizers, applying lime, as such, directly to the soil is the most practical means of offsetting the acidity of fertilizers. According to the Official Method, 1.78 pounds of CaCO, is needed to offset the acidity of 1 pound of nitrogen applied as anhydrous ammonia. However, it is suggested (Andrews, 1954a), that a more reliable approach to the problem is to assume that all nitrogen which is applied and not recovered by the plant leaches out as Ca(NO,),. On this basis, where 3 pounds of nitrogen increases the yield 1 bushel of harvested ear corn, about 2 pounds remain in the stalks, etc., and in the soil, and which may take about 2.38 pounds of CaCO, out of the soil per pound of nitrogen applied.
5 . Eflect on the Soil Fauna Though no data have been reported on the effect of anhydrous ammonia on the insects, worms, etc., in the soil, its toxicity to other living things suggests that it may kill these in the volume of soil affected. Since the numbers of these organisms are controlled by the food supply and they multiply rapidly, they would reinvade the affected volume of soil in a short time after nitrification of the ammonia. The total effect of anhydrous ammonia should be no different from that of other sources of nitrogen, all of which should slightly increase insects, worms, etc., because of increased crop residues.
6. Effect on the Microbial Flora in Soil “Anhydrous ammonia was applied to Arredondo loamy fine sand and Lakeland fine sand at rates of 100 and 250 pounds of nitrogen per acre [Eho and Blue, 19541. In all soils, the numbers of fungi were decreased. The numbers of bacteria and actinomycetes were increased except for a period not longer than 3 days after application on the
A N H Y D R O U S A M M O N I A AS A N I T R O G E N O U S FERTILIZER
75
neutral soil, during which time they were decreased. A more detailed study of the zone of retention showed that both the numbers of fungi and bacteria were decreased on the first day. This decrease occurred in both acid and neutral soil. On the tenth day the numbers of bacteria had increased to 6 to 25 times those in the check soil. The changes in the microbiological population were noticeable while high concentrations of ammonia were present and were restricted to a 3-inch zone centered on the injector row; this corresponded to the zone in which most of the ammonia was retained. From a total population standpoint, none of the changes noted are likely to permanently disturb the ecological balance in the soil. “The drastic reduction in numbers of fungi in the anhydrous ammonia treated soil indicates that there may be a possibility of it being used as a fungicidal agent in soil.” I n another series of experiments, Eno et al. (1955) found that “The numbers of fungi and nematodes were reduced by all levels of ammoniacal nitrogen from 136 to 741 ppm. Compared to untreated soil, only 0.6% of the nematodes and 4.9% of the fungi survived when 608 ppm. of nitrogen were present in the soil. This level of ammoniacal nitrogen occurs regularly in the retention zone when anhydrous ammonia is applied in the field. The largest reduction in both nematodes and fungi occurred above 365 ppm. Field studies showed a drastic reduction in all nematodes in the retention zone. Plant parasitic nematodes were greatly decreased and in many cases certain species could not be detected during counting. Re-establishment of the nematodes was greatest among the saprophytic species and was of the same character as that following fumigation with conventional nematocides. The economic value of the reduction of plant parasitic nematodes by anhydrous ammonia, applied primarily for its nitrogen content, will require further work on a field basis. Gross elimination of nematodes is not necessary for successful crop production. Thus, it can be seen that in addition to the primary use of anhydrous ammonia as a fertilizer, the destruction of plant parasitic nematodes in the retention zone also may be of value.” 7. Nitrification of Ammonia Because ammonium nitrogen is not leachable and nitrate nitrogen is subject to leaching, the use of anhydrous ammonia for direct application has stimulated interest in rate of nitrification as related to soil properties. The interest in fall application of anhydrous ammonia for spring consumption by fall-sown and spring-planted crops has stimulated interest in rate of nitrification as related to temperature and soil properties.
76
W. B. ANDREWS
Andrews et al. (1951) found that soils with pH of 5.0 or less nitrified ammonium nitrogen much more slowly than those with pH of 5.5 or higher, and that, in general, soils with a higher pH nitrified ammonia more rapidly than those with a lower pH. When applied in October to soils of pH of 5.0 or less, anhydrous ammonia was a very satisfactory source of nitrogen for spring consumption by f all-planted oats, but it was not on soils with pH of 5.5 or higher. The relation of rate of nitrification to soil reaction and to carry-through the winter of anhydrous ammonia applied in the fall is evident. Jenny et al. (1945) found that the rate of nitrification of sulfate of ammonia was the same as that for ammonium hydroxide. Anderson (1955) found that ammonium hydroxide nitrified more rapidly than sulfate of ammonia at pH 4.9, but there was no difference at pH 6.8. Eno et al. (1955) found that concentrations of ammonia which raise the pH above 8.5 markedly reduce the rate of nitrification. In experiments conducted by the author and associates (unpublished), it was found that aqua ammonia applied in the center of a beaker of soil nitrified more slowly than the nitrogen in readily decomposable organic matter which was uniformly distributed in the soil. As pointed out in Section 11, 1 on application of anhydrous ammonia to the soil, there appears to be considerable variation in the concentration of ammonia within the affected soil because of soil fracturing by the applicators. These variations in concentration of ammonia could result in retarded nitrification where the concentration of ammonia produces a pH of 8.5, as well as rapid nitrification in much of the zone where the pH may be less than 8.5. Though for the present it is necessary to depend upon laboratory data for information on nitrification of ammonium nitrogen, there are misgivings about applying such data to anhydrous ammonia applications in the field. Most of the data have been collected using sources of nitrogen which have been mixed with the soil, whereas anhydrous ammonia is applied in a limited volume of soil; if ammonium salts are applied, the reaction of the soil is changed little whereas anhydrous ammonia raises the pH of the soil markedly; if aqua ammonia is applied in a localized area in laboratory experiments, the concentration of ammonia would probably be uniformly high in the affected volume of soil as compared to marked variations in concentration which appear to exist in the zone of application of anhydrous ammonia under field conditions. In general, the rate of nitrification is higher in soils which are high in lime than in strongly acid soils, but the correlation between lime content and rate of nitrification is not perfect. The data of Frederick (personal communication), reported in Table 111, show a good correla-
77
ANHYDROUS AMMONIA AS A NITROGENOUS FERTILIZER
tion between soil reaction and rate of nitrification. However, the rate of nitrification in a soil of pH 6.1 (Anderson, 1955) was higher at all temperatures than that of soils with pH of 6.3 and 6.8 (Table IV). There was considerable nitrification in five soils at 52O F. and in one soil at 37O F. TABLE I11 The Effect of Soil Reaction and Temperature on Rate of Nitrification'
Temp. OF.
34 45 60
70 80 95
Genesee silt loam p H 7.7
Mellott silt loam subsoil pH 7.8
Chalmers Clermont silty silt loam subsoil clay loam 1st run 2nd run p H 6.2 p H 5.0 p H 6.2 p H 7.4 Pounds nitrate nitrogen per acre in two weeks
8 40
0
180 240 3362 3602
20 100 125
180
0 0 4 80 90 60
4 15 40
0 40 300 480 500 560
0
70 90 100
1
Frederick, unpublished.
2
All NHI-N added was converted to nitrate between the first and second weeks.
0 0 25
0 0
70
110
450
230
480 380
110
TABLE IV T h e Effect of Temperature on Nitrification of NH,OH in Four New Jersey Soils -200 Pounds of Nitrogen Per Acre'
Soil type Freehold loamy sand Washington loam Annadale loam Nixon sandy loam Nixon sandy loam 1
pH 6.8 5.9 6.1 4.9 6.8
21-days-temperature "F. 42-days-temperature "F. 37 42 47 52 37 42 47 52 Pounds of nitrogen nitrified per acre 6 2 26 0 6
20 6 54 4 0
68 14 70 12 20
92 30
8 4 42 10
84
8
86 26
114 58
122
16 90 36 48
110 72 108
102 96 118
60
84
Anderson, 1955.
The effect of temperature on rate of nitrification (Anderson, 1955) is shown by data reported in Table IV. In 21 days, three soils nitrified 84, 86, and 92 pounds of nitrogen per acre at 52O F., whereas the rate of nitrification was much lower for two soils. Even at 37O F., one soil nitrified 26 pounds of nitrogen per acre in 21 days. There is no evident explanation for the differences in nitrification rate of the soils at low temperatures unless the soils with low nitrification rates at low temperatures contained few nitrifying organisms, as suggested by Frederick (personal communication) in explaining the
78
W. B. ANDREWS
lack of nitrification in two soils with high and low pH values. Evidence of the build-up of nitrifiers is shown in Table I11 by the increased nitrification following an initial application of ammonium nitrogen. The Indiana data of Frederick (personal communication) show much higher nitrification rates at high temperatures, and by soils well supplied with lime than by soils low in lime (Table IV) . Two soils failed to nitrify any nitrogen at or below 4 5 O F., which Frederick attributed to lack of a nitrifying population. One soil nitrified 8 pounds of TABLE V The Nitrification of Ammonium Phosphate in Genesee Silt Loam, at pH 7.7, for 16 Weeks ~
~
~~
~~
Temperature, O F . Average
High
Low
Nitrate nitrogen, pounds per acre per week
PO
20
20
0
35
35 60 45
35
1.5 3.3 1.6
45 45
45 70 60
46 35
45
60
PO
6 10 10 16
60
60
33
95 80
45
29 28
35
35 45
60 60 60 60 60
70 70
80
20
36
45 45 35
33 37
nitrogen per acre in two weeks at 34O F. The New Jersey data of Anderson (1955) show nitrification proceeding down to 3 7 O F. on four of the five soils and one soil nitrified 26 pounds of nitrogen in 21 days at this temperature. The effect of fluctuating daily temperature on the rate of nitrification is shown by the data of Frederick (personal communication) reported in Table v. The rate of nitrification at low temperatures was much faster where temperatures fluctuated daily above and below a mean than for a constant temperature, suggesting that nitrification begins immediately when the temperature becomes favorable, and for some soils a favorable temperature appears to be only slightly above freezing, though higher temperatures are more favorable.
ANHYDROUS AMMONIA AS A NITROGENOUS FERTILIZER
79
The rate of nitrification does not appear to be reproducible, or there are uncontrollable factors which affect it as shown by: 1. The data in Table IV show that two soils which had a low rate of nitrification for the first 21-day period had a much higher rate during the second 21-day period, and that the rate was much slower in the second period for three soils which nitrified more rapidly in the first period. 2. Nitrification by a subsoil was many times faster the second time than the first time the nitrification test was made, suggesting that the nitrifiers were built up during the first period (Table 111). 3 . Samples taken at different times from the same area of a field had markedly different rates of nitrification (Frederick, personal communication). The data reviewed on the effect of temperature on rate of nitrification show that there are some soils that nitrify considerable nitrogen at temperatures which approach freezing and that nitrification by these soils appears to be resumed immediately when the temperature rises above freezing.
111. RESPONSEOF CROPSTO ANHYDROUS AMMONIA
I. Form of Nitrogen Used by Crop Plants Many young plants utilize the ammonia form of nitrogen more efficiently than the nitrate form, whereas the reverse is true for older plants. When the ammonium form of nitrogen is present, young corn grows more rapidly than with nitrate nitrogen; however, the author has not observed any differences in the response of corn to anhydrous ammonia and ammonium nitrate applied as early and late side dressings. Seedling cotton utilizes ammonium nitrogen more effectively; later the presence of both forms is more effective, while, in the fruiting stage, nitrate nitrogen is more effective, but fruiting and growth are better if both forms of nitrogen are present (Naftel, 1931). As applied, the author has not observed any difference in the response of young oats to ammonium nitrate and anhydrous ammonia; however, in the spring, fall-planted oats respond more quickly to nitrate than to ammonium nitrogen, suggesting that they make little use of ammonium nitrogen at this stage of growth. Though the author does not have data, it is presumed that other small grains respond similarly to oats. In the case of rice the response to nitrate nitrogen as compared to ammonium nitrogen is sometimes good and sometimes poor. However, the response is complicated by the fact that most of the ammonium form is attached to the clay, where it has less chance of being utilized
80
W. B. ANDREWS
by algae, etc., in the water, as contrasted with the nitrate form, which is in the water where it is accessible to the algae and, in addition, it may be subject to loss by denitrification. As observed by the author, nitrate nitrogen has shown up more favorably as compared to ammonium sources where the response of rice to nitrogen was low. The preference of plants for one of the two primary forms of nitrogen at different. stages of growth, the nonleaching properties of the ammonium form of nitrogen as compared to the leachability of nitrate nitrogen, and the possibility that nitrate nitrogen may be denitrified make it difficult to conduct tests comparing forms of nitrogen. Where nitrate is more effective than ammonium nitrogen, it is evident that the last optimum date for application of the ammonium form is earlier than that for the nitrate form. Under leaching conditions, the earliest optimum date for application of nitrate nitrogen is later than that for ammonium nitrogen; this relationship is further complicated by the fact that the rate of nitrification is slow in some soils and fast in others. From the standpoint of crop response, it is the objective of this paper to review the experiments in which anhydrous ammonia and other sources of nitrogen have been compared. Because of the newness of the use of anhydrous ammonia by farmers, there are very few data available on comparative responses of crops. Because of the scarcity of data on time of application of anhydrous ammonia and because of the tremendous interest in off-season application of anhydrous ammonia, some data are reviewed from tests which did not include anhydrous ammonia as a source of nitrogen. Though, inherently, there is a possibility that off -season applied anhydrous ammonia may not behave exactly as other sources of nitrogen, the shortage of actual data on anhydrous ammonia and the rapidity of nitrification, particularly by some soils at low temperature, appears to justify the use of other data until such time as there are sufficient data to describe adequately the behavior of anhydrous ammonia. When applied at a considerable time in advance of utilization, the difference between the leaching of nitrogen applied as ammonia and nitrate is probably negligible on soils which nitrify ammonia rapidly, but appreciable where the rate of nitrification is slow. However, it is likely that the behavior of anhydrous ammonia is not markedly different from that of sulfate of ammonia. For these reasons, data on time of application of sources of nitrogen other than anhydrous ammonia are also reviewed in this paper. The most intensive research work on the use of anhydrous ammonia has been done by the Mississippi Agricultural Experiment Station. This work up to 1951 was published in bulletins (Andrews et al., 1947a, by 1948, 1951) . Summaries of the published work of the Missis-
A N H Y D R O U S A M M O N I A AS A N I T R O G E N O U S FERTILIZER
81
sippi Agricultural Experiment Station and other applicable data were presented in the author’s book (1954~) ,The Response of Crops and Soils to Fertilizers and Manures, published by the author, and they are used in quotation in this paper by permission of the publisher. Republication rights to the quoted material, of course, remain with the original copyright, though the original data are available for any use which may be made of them. 2. Response of Cotton Cotton, Gossypium hirsutum L., is normally planted from three to five weeks after the last killing frost in the spring. Flowering begins about eight weeks later. Small cotton grows very slowly and makes only a small part of its total growth before flowering begins. Normally, the fruit-setting period is six to eight weeks, but may continue until frost. The fruit is normally mature in six to eight weeks after blooming. As has been pointed out, seedling cotton makes better use of ammonium than nitrate nitrogen; from the seedling stage to the beginning of fruiting, the presence of both forms is more favorable for growth than only one form; during the fruiting stage, the nitrate form of nitrogen is more efficient than the ammonium form, but growth and fruiting are better where both forms are present. “Anhydrous ammonia is slightly superior to ammonium nitrate for cotton production when applied before planting. As an average of 31 tests conducted in Mississippi, anhydrous ammonia made 38 pounds of seed cotton per acre more than ammonium nitrate [Table VI]. The depth of application was four inches; the slight superiority of anhydrous ammonia is attributed to less leaching during the first few weeks after application. “A six-inch depth of placement of anhydrous ammonia produced an average of 39 pounds more seed cotton than a four-inch depth in 18 tests when applied before planting. It should be pointed out that anhydrous ammonia is more easily sealed in the soil when applied six inches deep than at shallower depths. “Anhydrous ammonia was slightly superior to ammonium nitrate, cyanamid, nitrate of soda and sulphate of ammonia for cotton production in six tests in the Mississippi Delta. The increases in yield of seed cotton were: anhydrous ammonia 542, ammonium nitrate 530, nitrate of soda 518, sulphate of ammonia 500, and cyanamid 489 pounds of seed cotton per acre. The data are averages for 30, 45, and 60 pounds of nitrogen per acre. The slight superiority of anhydrous ammonia to sources which contain nitrate nitrogen is attributed to less leaching during the first few weeks after application. “Ammonium nitrate was superior to anhydrous ammonia for side-
a3
W. B. ANDREWS
dressing cotton when both were placed four or five inches deep. As an average of 31 tests applied as an early side dressing, ammonium nitrate increased the yield 325 pounds of seed cotton per acre and anhydrous ammonia 281 pounds. The superiority of ammonium nitrate as a side dressing is attributed to the preference of cotton at this stage of growth for nitrate nitrogen. “When moisture was adequate ammonium nitrate applied on the surface and anhydrous ammonia applied four to five inches deep as side dressings produced identical increases in yield of seed cotton. In 1944, TABLE VI The Response of Cotton to Anhydrous Ammonia and Ammonium Nitrate in Mississippi Source of nitrogen Ammonium nitrate
Pounds nitrogen per acre
Time of application
32
Early side-dress
64 33
Preplant Preplant
33
Early side-dress
Anhydrous ammonia Surface 4-5 inches deep 4-5 inches deep Increase in yield, pounds seed cotton per acre
154
Average 280
Average of 10 tests-dry year 217 Average of 31 testr 443 397 370
472 344 408
325
esi
Average of 13 tests 33 32
May side-dress June side-dress
260 277
343 356
26 1 276
when rainfall was very low, anhydrous ammonia applied five inches deep was much superior to ammonium nitrate applied on the surface, which emphasizes the need for applying fertilizers in the root zone when dry weather is likely to follow. An examination of the weather records for Mississippi suggests that surface applications of nitrogen to crops in May or later are likely to be much less effective than deeper applications in one-third of the years, because of dry weather. No doubt, deep application of nitrogen is much more effective than surface application in dry climates. “Early and late side dressing of cotton with both anhydrous ammonia and ammonium nitrate were equally effective. The early side dressing was applied soon after the cotton was chopped out and the late application about a month later. Applications of nitrogen in July
83 are usually much less effective than when applied by the middle of June, but good increases in yield may be obtained from July applications. It is doubtful if July applications of nitrogen are effective where insects are destructive; however, where insects are controlled very late applications of nitrogen may give good increases in yield, even though they might have been more effective applied at an earlier date. “Anhydrous ammonia should be applied so that it does not come in contact with banded applications of superphosphate (unpublished data from Mississippi). In three tests, where the treatment was 60 pounds of nitrogen, phosphate and potash per acre, placing the anhydrous ammonia in contact with the superphosphate and muriate of potash reduced the average yield of seed cotton 86 pounds per acre as compared to separating them. “In three other tests with 60 pounds of nitrogen, 20 pounds of phosphate and 50 pounds of potash per acre, the average reduction in yield was 211 pounds of seed cotton for putting them together as compared to separating them. In the latter tests 20 pounds of phosphate was apparently sufficient; and where 40 or 60 pounds was used, applying the ammonia with the phosphate and potash did not reduce the yield. In one test on an alkaline clay soil there was no reduction in yield at any of three rates of phosphate. “When anhydrous ammonia is applied in contact with superphosphate, no doubt, the water-soluble phosphorus is converted into less soluble forms, as takes place when superphosphate is treated with anhydrous ammonia. The data . . . show that ammoniation of 20 per cent superphosphate with an average of 4.78 per cent ammonia reduced its value to less than one-half that of untreated superphosphate” (Andrews, 1954b). “The reduction in yield obtained for placing anhydrous ammonia in contact with superphosphate would also take place with aqua ammonia or solutions of aqua ammonia and ammonium nitrate or urea. “The time of application of nitrogen to cotton may be influenced by the grass and weed problem. Since nitrogen makes weeds and grass, as well as crops, grow it may be desirable to delay application of the nitrogen until the crop is cleaned out even though earlier application might have been more effective in the absence of a weed and grass problem. “Fall and winter application of anhydrous ammonia and ammonium nitrate for summer crops is often much less effective than spring application [Table VII]. In two tests on sandy loam soils December application of anhydrous ammonia was as effective as May application. In one test on sandy loam and in one on clay soil May application of ammonium nitrate was superior to December application. On the clay ANHYDROUS AMMONIA AS A NITROGENOUS FERTILIZER
84
W. B. ANDREWS
soil both ammonium nitrate and anhydrous ammonia applied in December were much less effective than May application of ammonium nitrate, which is attributed to both leaching and consumption of nitrogen by weeds and grass. The low increase in yield from anhydrous ammonia applied in May on the heavy soil was attributed to observable loss of ammonia in application.” In addition to -the work in Mississippi on anhydrous ammonia for cotton production, one test has been conducted in South Carolina (Wolf and Hoyert, 1952); one in Oklahoma (Pack, 1954); and two in Texas TABLE VII The Influence of Time of Application of Anhydrous Ammonia and Ammonium Nitrate, Applied at the Rate of 60 Pounds of Nitrogen Per Acre on the Yield of Cotton in Mississippi
Time of application December (preplant) May (preplant) June (side-dress) July (side-dress)
Clay soil, 1950 Sandy loam soil, 1949-1950 Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Anhydrous Anhydrous Ammonium Anhydrous Ammonium ammonia ammonia nitrate ammonia nitrate Increase in yield, pounds seed cotton per acre 758 716
568 585
462 624
626
-
-
485
-
315 319
378 787
_.
-
-
-
(Flake, personal communication). Their data are essentially in agreement with those reported above, except that in the dry climate of Oklahoma, January application of anhydrous ammonia was equal to spring applications in the one test.
3 . Response of Corn Corn, Zea mays L., is normally planted from about the average date of the last killing frost until the middle of June. The data for Mississippi, reported in Table VIII (Andrews, 1954c) are for a total of 36 tests, which are averages of 7, 5, 11, and 13 tests. The nitrogen sources were paired for time of application, and there were six replications, which tends to give significance to rather small differences. When anhydrous ammonia was applied 4 to 5 inches deep and ammonium nitrate was applied on the surface of the soil as early sidedressings, the seven-test average shows that the increase in yield was 7 bushels for ammonium nitrate and 10 bushels for anhydrous ammonia. The inferiority of surface-applied ammonium nitrate is attributed to the lack of sufficient rain to leach it into the root zone. As an average of five tests, anhydrous ammonia was slightly superior to
85 ammonium nitrate for both preplanting and side-dressing. The thirteen side-dressing tests also show a slight superiority f o r anhydrous ammonia. The rate of application was 32 pounds of nitrogen per acre in these tests. In eleven tests at the rate of 100 pounds of nitrogen per acre, when applied before planting, anhydrous ammonia made 41 bushels increase in yield as compared to 36 for ammonium nitrate. The difference in the response to these two sources of nitrogen, applied before planting, is attributed to greater leaching of the nitrate of ammonium nitrate, as ANHYDROUS AMMONIA AS A NITROGENOUS FERTILIZER
TABLE VIII The Response of Corn to Anhydrous Ammonia and Ammonium Nitrate in Mississippi Source of nitrogen Ammonium Anhydrous nitrate ammonia Surface 4-5 inches deep 4-5 inches deep Increase in yield, bushels corn per acre
Pounds nitrogen per acre
Time of application
32
Early side-dress
32 32
Early side-dress Preplant
38
Side-dress
14
Preplant Early side-dress Late side-dress Preplant
-
100 100 100 200
7 12 -
40 41
Average of 7 tests-dry year 10 Average of 5 tests 12 15 12 13 Average of 13 tests 15 17 Average of 11 tesds 36 41 40 40 44 43 50 52
compared to all ammonium nitrogen, during the nitrification period, which should have been less than six weeks at most locations. The data suggest that application at a sufficient time before planting so that all nitrogen would have been converted to nitrates at planting would have made about 10 bushels less corn per acre than all ammonium nitrogen. There was no difference between anhydrous ammonia applied as an early or late side-dressing, and ammonium nitrate applied 4 to 5 inches deep, and surface application of ammonium nitrate as an early side-dressing was as effective as deeper application. Ammonium nitrate applied 4 to 5 inches deep produced 3 bushels more corn than when applied on the surface as a late side-dressing. These tests were run in years with normal rainfall; the tests, above, in which depth of application in side-dressing was important, were conducted in a dry growing season.
86
W. B. ANDREWS
With ammonium nitrate, early side-dressing produced 4 bushels more corn than preplanting application; there was no difference for these two times of application of anhydrous ammonia. When applied as a late side-dressing, ammonium nitrate made 4 bushels more corn than when applied as an early side-dressing and 8 bushels more than when applied before planting. When applied as a late side-dressing, anhydrous ammonia made 2 bushels more than when applied before planting and 3 bushels more than when applied as an early side-dressing. Similar differences are reported below, which, no doubt, are not significant in themselves, but the similarity of data
FIG.2. Local bulk storage, transport truck, and application equipment for anhydrous ammonia (courtesy of Mississippi Chemical Corporation).
from many different tests throughout the country adds significance to the small differences in favor of side-dressing as compared to preplanting application of nitrogenous fertilizers. When applied before planting, anhydrous ammonia made an average of 5 bushels more corn than ammonium nitrate and only 2 bushels more at 200 pounds of nitrogen per acre. When applied before planting, 100 pounds of nitrogen was used efficiently, producing a yield increase of 1 bushel for 2% pounds of nitrogen; whereas 200 pounds per acre was used inefficiently, producing a 1-bushel increase in yield for about 4 pounds of nitrogen. These eleven-test average data suggest that differences in efficiency of sources of nitrogen or times of application can be determined only where the nitrogen is utilized efficiently, and that large numbers of tests and replications are needed to measure small real differences. “The yield of corn was reduced eight bushels per acre by December application of both anhydrous ammonia and ammonium nitrate as compared to April application in one test. The rate of application was 120 pounds of nitrogen per acre and the top increase was 40 bushels.
87 The difference may have been greater if conditions had been favorable for high yields.” In Delaware, Cotner (personal communication) conducted separate tests (Table IX) on time of application of anhydrous ammonia and sulfate of ammonia for corn. The efficiency of both sources of nitrogen increased progressively as time of application was delayed from atplanting until the corn was 3% feet high. The difference between at-planting and side-dressing at 3% feet high was 15.7 bushels with anhydrous ammonia and 26.8 bushels with sulfate of ammonia in favor of the late side-dressing. The differences for time of application are highly significant, and they were obtained in a dry year. A N H Y D R O U S A M M O N I A AS A N I T R O G E N O U S FERTILIZER
TABLE IX Time of Application of Anhydrous Ammonia and Sulfate of Ammonia to Corn in Delaware Source of nitrogen
Time of application None At planting 8 inches tall 2% feet tall 8% feet tall L.S.D. (0.05)
NHa (NH4)zSOs Yield, bushels corn per acre 34.6 92.5 96.0
42.2 48.2 8.5
34.7 31.7 40.0 52.4 58.5 5.2
In Florida, Robertson (personal communication) showed that anhydrous ammonia, ammonium nitrate, and nitrate of soda produced about the same increase in yield when applied as a side-dressing. Anhydrous ammonia applied as a side-dressing produced 2.0 and 5.1 bushels more corn than when applied before planting at 40 and 80 pounds of nitrogen per acre; at 160 pounds of nitrogen per acre there was no difference for time of application. In Michigan, anhydrous ammonia produced slightly higher yields (7.0 bushels more) than sulfate of ammonia in two tests and about the same yields in one test (Robertson, personal communication). In the two test average, July side-dressing with anhydrous ammonia produced 5 bushels more corn than the June side-dressing; time of application was not a factor in the one test. The Minnesota Agricultural Experiment Station found that the response of corn to nitrogen is a factor in time of application (MacGregor, 1955a). Typical of the results are: on fields which gave high
88
W. B. ANDREWS
response to nitrogen the yield increases for 60 pounds of nitrogen as anhydrous ammonia were 25, 31, and 35 bushels per acre for beforeplanting in April, as a side-dressing one month later in May, or as a side-dressing two months later in June or July. The respective representative increases on more fertile soils were 10, 9, and 8 bushels per acre. In Nebraska, when the nitrogen was applied as a side-dressing at the rate of 80 pounds of nitrogen per acre in eight tests, six of which were irrigated, the average yield of corn was increased from 77 to 108 and 107 bushels per acre by ammonium nitrate and anhydrous ammonia, respectively. The average yield of corn (six irrigated tests) was 7 and 6 bushels more for the respective sources when applied as a sidedressing than when applied before planting (Lowrey and Dreier, 1951; Lowrey and Ehlers, 1954; and Lowrey et al., 1954). In Wisconsin, ammonium nitrate produced slightly higher yields of corn than anhydrous ammonia in November and April application; however, June applications of anhydrous ammonia made 5.3 and 3.2 bushels more than April applications at 67 and 100 pounds of nitrogen per acre. The increases in yield for 67 pounds of nitrogen were 27 to 33 bushels, which is efficient utilization of nitrogen (Marriot, personal communication). In three different comparisons for before-planting applications in North Dakota, Puhr (personal communication) found that anhydrous ammonia made 4.2 bushels more corn than ammonium nitrate. In one test in Louisiana, ammonium nitrate was slightly superior to anhydrous ammonia for corn production (Oakes and McCormack, 1954). In two tests in Texas, Flake (personal communication) showed that anhydrous ammonia and other common sources of nitrogen produced about the same increase in yield of corn. In nine tests in Missouri, 80 pounds of nitrogen as anhydrous ammonia or ammonium nitrate increased the yield 17 bushels of corn per acre (Smith, 1952). With rainfall normal to below normal from the fall of 1951 to the summer of 1954, Dumenil (1955) found that fall application of ammonium nitrate for 1952, 1953, and 1954 and sulfate of ammonia for 1954 was as effective for corn production in Iowa as when broadcast and disked in late April in 1952 and 1953, and side-dressed in early June of 1954 (Table X). “These tests indicate that fall application is as good as spring application in some years. But remember that the rainfall from fall of 1951 to summer of 1954 was normal to below normal at these locations.” In most comparisons, the responses to nitrogen were rather low, and there could be some doubt about the applicability of the data to conditions where applied nitrogen is more fully utilized.
89
A N H Y D R O U S A M M O N I A AS A N I T R O G E N O U S FERTILIZER
In three tests in Minnesota, MacGregor (1955a) found no difference between fall and spring application of nitrogen for corn; however, the average increase in yield was less than 10 bushels per acre for 60 pounds of nitrogen-a requirement of 6 pounds of nitrogen per bushel increase in yield. Since 60 pounds of nitrogen should increase the yield as much as 24 bushels, the data may not be applicable where normal response to nitrogen is obtained. In two of the tests (MacGregor, 1955b), the residual nitrogen from 60 pounds applied to corn increased the yield of oats 5.6 bushels per acre with little difference for time of application to corn. It is estimated that the increase in yield of corn utilized about 15 pounds of nitrogen and the oats about 7 pounds, which TABLE X The Response of Corn to Fall and Spring Applications of Nitrogen in Iowa Increase in yield
No. of Year
tests
1952
4
1953
4
2 1954
Fall
Pounds nitrogen per acre
Bushels corn
per bu.
40 40 80 30 60 30
10.9 18.7 22.4 9.5 8.2 11.8
3.7 2.1 3.6 3.2 7.3 2.5
Lb. N
Spring Lb. N Bushels corn per bu.
11.4 14.4 20.0 10.8 10.8 12.2
3.5 2.8 4.0 2.8 5.6 2.5
leaves 38 pounds not accounted for. The low efficiency of the estimated 7) pounds of nitrogen, which was not utilized by corn, for 45 (38 the production of oats, suggests that fall application of nitrogen for spring consumption is not very satisfactory. Grissom (unpublished) applied rates of nitrogen as anhydrous ammonia and ammonium nitrate to corn and cotton in Mississippi in 1952. Yields were taken in 1952-1 955 without additional nitrogen. Though there was an excellent residual effect from the high rates of application, it should be borne in mind that the 1952-1954 period was unusually dry and that the data may not be applicable under conditions of more normal rainfall. In one long-time test on a heavy soil in Mississippi, fall-applied nitrate of soda and sulfate of ammonia produced increases in yield of corn, cotton, and oats which were only about 12 per cent less than spring applications (Pitner and Kuykendall, 1943). Other data (Section 111, 4a) from many tests show that fall application of nitrogen on similar soils has been unsatisfactory for oats, suggesting that the data are
+
90 W. B. ANDREWS not widely applicable for small grains and probably not for row mops either. The residual effect of two years of nitrogen fertilization of corn on the yield of the following wheat crop was determined in Missouri, where the response of corn to nitrogen was low (Smith, 1954). The rates of nitrogen were 33, 66, 132, and 200 pounds per acre; the estimated pounds of nitrogen per acre which was not recovered by the corn were 19, 42, 90, 155, annually, or 38, 84, 180, and 310 pounds for the two-year period; the increases in the yield of wheat from the nitrogen not recovered by the corn were 2, 3, 7, and 12 bushels per acre. To illustrate, the estimated 90 pounds of nitrogen annually, or 180 pounds for the two-year period, which was not recovered by the corn, increased the yield of wheat only 7 bushels per acre under conditions where more nitrogen was needed; the ‘/-bushel increase in the yield of wheat should have been made with about 20 pounds of nitrogen applied at an appropriate time. It is evident that most of the nitrogen which the corn did not recover was not effective in increasing the yield of wheat; these data suggest that nitrate nitrogen applied or derived from other forms in the fall would be very inefficient for wheat production in a similar climate. In most cases, where good response has been obtained, side-dressing corn has been superior to at-planting application of nitrogen, regardIess of the source, and late side-dressingshave usually been superior to early side-dressings. The superiority of side-dressings as compared to atplanting applications of nitrogen may be attributed to ( I ) leaching of nitrate nitrogen where the ground water is recharged before nitrates are consumed by the plant, (2) microbiological immobilization of nitrogen where considerable quantities of carbonaceous crop residues exist, and (3) increased efficiency in the use of water as well as nitrogen because of delayed or reduced vegetative growth. As an average of five tests in Missouri (Missouri Growers, Inc., 1954a) 40, 80, and 120 pounds of nitrogen per acre increased the yield of corn 8.4, 12.6, and 17.2 bushels when applied before plowing and 3.5, 15.4, and 18.7 bushels per acre when applied after seed bed preparation and before planting; the increases for side-dressing were 14.7, 18.4, and 17.2 bushels. As compared to preplanting, side-dressing increased the yield 11.2, 3.0, and -1.5 bushels of corn per acre at the respective rates. The amount of nitrogen required to increase the yield one bushel of corn varies markedly and should receive more attention. Though under conditions where corn is very responsive to nitrogen and growing conditions are favorable the yield may be increased one bushel of corn by as little as two pounds of nitrogen, much more is required in most
A N H Y D R O U S A M M O N I A AS A N I T R O G E N O U S FERTILIZER
91
tests. The most extensive work reported on this subject was carried out by the Missouri Growers, Inc. (1954b, 1955). During the 1950-1955 period they applied an average of 69 pounds of nitrogen as anhydrous ammonia in 320 tests which increased the average yearly yield 18.4 bushels per acre which is a requirement of 3.74 pounds of nitrogen per bushel increase in yield. Though there is considerable information on leaching and microbial immobilization of nitrogen, the author is not aware of information on the effect of time of application of nitrogen on the growth curve of corn, on the total amount of stover produced, or on the stover-grain ratio, variations of which may markedly influence efficiency in the utilization of moisture, particularly when limited, as well as in the utilization of nitrogen to produce grain. There could be a parallel between the relative efficiency of side-dressing as compared to at-planting application and the early practice in this country of plowing young corn closely to retard or reduce vegetative growth and favor fruiting. Though the early close-plowing practice has been discarded, it may not have been shown that the practice does not have merit. Though delayed application of nitrogen may not be favorable for maximum yield by a single corn plant with all production factors unlimited, under field conditions the yield of the plants involved is normally limited by the factors of production to less than one-half of the potential of the plant, and it appears that retarded growth of young corn may reduce or delay the production of vegetative growth, thereby increasing efficiency in the utilization of moisture and nitrogen.
4 . Response of Small Grains The small grains which are commonly grown are oats, Auena satiua L.; wheat, Triticum vulgare, Vill.; barley, Hordeum uulgare L. ; and rye, Secale cereale L. In the South, all small grains are planted in the fall; in the central part of the country, all are planted in the fall except oats, which are spring-planted; in the northern part of the country, all are planted in the spring. The small grains are normally planted with a 7-inch drill or broadcast. These crops are not cultivated. The climate covered in these studies varies from warm to cold winters, from hot to cool summers, and from humid to arid. In the South, small grains are planted to some extent for fall, winter, and spring grazing. In other areas, excessive fall growth is often grazed before cold weather. However, these crops are grown primarily for grain. When young, oats and presumably all the other small grains use ammonium nitrogen as well as nitrate nitrogen insofar as can be observed under field conditions. I n the spring, when rapid growth and the
92 W. B. ANDREWS beginning of fruiting are initiated, oats and presumably the other small grains require nitrate nitrogen for maximum growth. a. In Mississippi, “Fall application of ammonium nitrate was unsatisfactory for oat production in all 10 tests conducted [Table XI]. It was less effective on the less acid than on the strongly acid soils, which parallels the behavior of anhydrous ammonia. As was pointed out above, in North Mississippi late October-planted oats make little growth before spring, and in order for fall-applied nitrogen to be utilized by them it must be carried through the winter in the soil. “When applied during the third week in February anhydrous ammonia increased the yield of oats 20 bushels per acre as compared to TABLE XI The Effect of Soil Reaction on the Response of Oats to Fall-Applied Anhydrous Ammonia in Mississippi Lime content of soil, test number High, pH 5.5 or higher Low, pH 5.1 or less Source of nitrogen 32 pounds per acre
Time of application 1
2
9
4
5
6
7
25 90 15
12 19 8
9
10
15 14 2% 24 8 10
6 24
8
Increase in yield, bushels oats per acre Anhydrousammonia Ammonium nitrate Ammonium nitrate
Fall Spring Fall
30 21 16
32
SO
26
25
15
16
29 27 20
19 20 10
4
15 bushels for ammonium nitrate in six tests in which the rate of nitrogen was 32 pounds per acre. The data suggest that a considerable amount of the ammonium nitrate nitrogen leached out before the oats were able to utilize it. The data also suggest that nitrate nitrogen should not be applied to fall-planted small grains until the weather is warm enough for vigorous growth to begin. “The stand of small grains is not damaged materially by anhydrous ammonia applicator knives in top dressing. If the small grains are well rooted the applicator knives usually go between plants without uprooting them. “On soils which are low in lime anhydrous ammonia applied from the last of October until (possibly) February 15 is as effective for producing oats as ammonium nitrate applied the first of March. In five tests (32 pounds of nitrogen per acre) which were low in lime (pH 5.1 or less), anhydrous ammonia applied the last of October increased the yield 28 bushels of oats per acre as compared to 23 bushels for ammonium nitrate applied in March. On one soil (pH 4.95) aqua ammonia applied the last of January increased the yield 30 bushels as compared to 27 bushels for ammonium nitrate applied early in March.
A N H Y D R O U S A M M O N I A AS A N I T R O G E N O U S FERTILIZER
93
“On a soil which was low in lime (pH 5.1 ) , anhydrous ammonia was not a satisfactory source of nitrogen for oats when applied in early March. When applied to this low-lime soil in early March the ammonia was changed into nitrate nitrogen so slowly that the increase in yield of oats was only 10 bushels per acre as compared to 19 bushels for fallapplied anhydrous ammonia and 20 bushels for spring-applied ammonium nitrate. The rate of application was 32 pounds of nitrogen per acre. “When applied the first of March on soils which are medium to low in lime, anhydrous ammonia is much less effective than ammonium nitrate for the production of oats. In an average of eleven tests applied the first of March anhydrous ammonia increased the yield of oats only 19 bushels as compared to 26 bushels per acre for ammonium nitrate. “On soils of medium to high lime content (pH 5.5 or higher) anhydrous ammonia applied the last of October increased the yield an average of only 13 bushels of oats per acre as compared to 23 bushels for ammonium nitrate applied the first of March (five tests). In three tests with 32 pounds of nitrogen per acre the following increases in yield of oats were obtained:
Date of application
Last of October Last week in November Third week in February
Source of nitrogen Anhydrous ammonia Ammonium nitrate Increase in yield, bu. oats per acre 6.6 13.4 31.3
16.9
“The last week in November is too early to apply anhydrous ammonia to oats for grain. When applied during the third week in February anhydrous ammonia is superior to ammonium nitrate. Apparently the third week in February is too early to apply ammonium nitrate to oats because of the leaching of the nitrate nitrogen. “On a high-lime soil (pH 7.8) anhydrous ammonia applied in March increased the yield 25 bushels of oats per acre as compared to 4 bushels for October-applied and, 24 bushels for March-applied ammonium nitrate. The rate of change of ammonia into nitrate nitrogen was rapid in this soil and nitrate nitrogen was available to the oats in a short time after application as anhydrous ammonia in the spring; when applied in October anhydrous ammonia was converted into nitrate nitrogen and leached out of the soil during the winter. “Anhydrous ammonia applied the last of October in four tests increased the yield of oats only 7 bushels per acre as compared to 20
94 W. B. ANDREWS bushels per acre for application during the third week in February. The lime content of the soils was high enough for nitrification to take place during the winter months. Thirty-two pounds of nitrogen per acre was applied. “A reasonable spacing of anhydrous ammonia applicators for top dressing oats for grain is 24 inches. When anhydrous ammonia applicators are spaced farther apart than 16 inches a strip of oats down the middle usually fails to send roots to the place where the ammonia was applied and they do not get nitrogen. However, the oats which do get nitrogen grow more and largely make up the difference [Table XII] . TABLE
XI1
The Effect of Applicator Spacing on the Response of Oats to Anhydrous Ammonia in Mississippi Pounds of nitrogen per acre
Spacing of applicators, inches
32 48 64 Average Increase in yield, bushels oats per acre
as
a1
81 18 18
a8 84
6
2
4
16 a4
a3 a2
S6 No. of tests
a4
as 21 1%
“Applicators spaced 24 inches apart shed trash more readily than when spaced closer, and a 24-inch spacing is recommended. On very wet and heavy soils oats may not grow roots to ammonia placed more than six inches away; however, though no data are available, it is not improbable that a good 12-inch band of oats every 24 inches will make about as much oats as uniform growth over the entire area. “Anhydrous ammonia and ammonium nitrate have been equal in value on oats for forage. As an average of 14 tests, the following yields were obtained by the first of March: Source of nitrogen
None Ammonium nitrate Anhydrous ammonia
Yield-pounds air-dry forage per acre
648 1644 1711
“A spring application of nitrogen is necessary for the production of oats for grain even though a large quantity is applied to them for forage in the fall. When 96 pounds of nitrogen per acre, which is much more
A N H Y D R O U S A M M O N I A AS A N I T R O G E N O U S FERTILIZER
95
than needed, was applied to oats for fall- and winter-forage production the yield of grain in the spring was only one bushel more than was produced with no clipping and no nitrogen in the fall or spring. Where nitrogen was applied in the fall and spring, clipped oats made 17 bushels more than where they were not clipped and received no nitrogen (9 tests).” b. In Other Humid Areas. Most of the tests on anhydrous ammonia for small grains, outside of those in Mississippi, have been conducted since 1950 and there has been less rainfall than normal in many areas. For this reason, many of the data should be regarded as tentative. “Fall-applied anhydrous ammonia was unsatisfactory for wheat in Indiana [Peterson, 19521. The average increase in yield of wheat for three rates of nitrogen was as follows:
Source of nitrogen
4.8
4.8
pH of soil in tests 5.5
6.5
6.7
Increase in yield, bu. wheat per acre Ammonium nitrate-spring Anhydrous ammonia-fall
5.1 4.0
11.4 9.5
11.9 8.4
8.9 4.3
8.0 3.0
Even on strongly acid soils anhydrous ammonia applied in the fall was less satisfactory than ammonium nitrate applied in the spring. The increase in yield for anhydrous ammonia applied in the fall on soils of pH 4.8, 4.8, 5.5, 6.5, and 6.7 was 1.1, 1.9, 3.5, 4.0, and 5.0 bushels less than where ammonium nitrate was applied in the spring. “The efficiency of fall-applied anhydrous ammonia for wheat in Indiana was similar to that for oats in Mississippi on strongly acid soils, though in Mississippi fall-applied anhydrous ammonia was equal to or superior to spring-applied ammonium nitrate. In both states fall-applied anhydrous ammonia was unsatisfactory on soils having a pH of 5.5 or higher. “In Indiana and Mississippi the f all-applied anhydrous ammonia was applied at about the same time, which suggests that soil reaction is a more important factor in nitrification of ammonia than the differences in fall and winter temperature. “In the Indiana experiments anhydrous ammonia applied in the spring and ammonium nitrate applied in the fall were unsatisfactory for wheat in all of the tests.” In New York, Musgrave (personal communication) found that 40 pounds of nitrogen as ammonium nitrate or 40 per cent nitrogen solutions (largely ammonium nitrogen) increased the yield of wheat only
96
W. B. ANDREWS
1.7 bushels when applied at planting time, while 20 pounds at planting time and 20 pounds in the spring increased the yield 7.5 bushels. The
temperature was 55OF. at planting time and dropped to 30° within 30 days. In another test, Musgrave (personal communication) obtained 3.2 bushels increase in yield of wheat for 40 pounds of nitrogen as anhydrous ammonia applied before planting and 12.6 bushels increase for 20 pounds at planting and 20 pounds in the spring as ammonium nitrate. He has “yet to observe a significant carry-over effect of summer or fall applications of NH, at any rate between 20 and 400 lb. N/A [nitrogen per acre]”; the 400 pound rate was applied to corn. The soils studied have impervious subsoils and they are giving consideration to horizontal movement of nitrate nitrogen in the plow zone and to denitrification. “Fall application of anhydrous ammonia and sulphate of ammonia on fall-planted crops should have the same efficiency. Spring application of sulphate of ammonia was much superior to fall (drilled) application for wheat in Pennsylvania [Merkle, 19521. When 20 pounds of nitrogen was applied at planting time, between September 15 and October 18, the average yield of 17 tests over a period of years was 4.6 bushels of wheat per acre less than where the nitrogen was applied in the spring. In six tests where 40 pounds of nitrogen was applied one month after sowing (freezing weather usually begins the last of November) the average yield was 4.8 bushels less than when applied in the spring. As an average of six tests, 20 pounds of nitrogen applied in the spring was superior to 40 pounds applied in the fall where good increases for nitrogen were obtained. On the basis of the above data, anhydrous ammonia applied in the fall would not be expected to go through the winter in a climate as cold as Pennsylvania.” In Missouri (Smith, 1954), before-seeding application of anhydrous ammonia was superior to December and March applications in one test with wheat. As an average of eight other tests 12-12-12 or 8-24-8 starter fertilizers containing 24 to 36 pounds of nitrogen increased the yield of wheat 8.1 bushels per acre. An additional 66 pounds of nitrogen from a solid source increased the yield 7.9 bushels when applied before seeding, 11.4 bushels when applied in December, and 8.5 bushels when applied in the spring. With the December application, which was the best treatment, 5.8 pounds of nitrogen was required to increase the yield of wheat 1 bushel, whereas in the first test 2 pounds of nitrogen increased the yield a bushel. It appears that the nitrogen treatment, 90 to 102 pounds per acre, was excessive and that the data may not provide a satisfactory basis for a critical evaluation of time of application of nitrogen to wheat.
97
A N H Y D R O U S A M M O N I A AS A N I T R O G E N O U S FERTILIZER
The relation of rainfall to the efficiency of fall, winter, and spring applications of solid sources of nitrogen is shown by data from Illinois (Tyner, personal communication), reported in Table XIII. On both years at Westfall, soil moisture was not recharged below the 24-inch depth by the last of March or the first of April when the spring applications were made; fall applications were made after seeding and TABLE XI11 T h e Effect of Time of Application of Nitrogen on the Increase in Yield of Wheat for Three Sources of Nitrogen in Illinois ~
Source of Nitrogen 30 pounds per acre
Time of application Fall Winter Spring Increase in yield, bushels wheat per acre
Westfall 1968-54; no movement of water into gh-inch depth. Cyanamid 2.5 Ammonium nitrate 11.4 Urea 5.9 Sulfate of ammonia 7.5 Solution 32 6.6
3.5 6.4 3.9 8.0 7.6
Average, except cyanamid and urea 8.5 6.5 Time of application not significant; urea and cyanamid significantly inferior. Westfall 1954-55; no leaching. Nitrate of soda 7.9 6.1 Ammonium nitrate 1.8 7.2 Sulfate of ammonia 2.6 7.1 Average Time of application not significant. Rogers 1964-55; recharge of water to 6-feet normal. Nitrate of soda Ammonium nitrate Sulfate of ammonia
3.7 9.8 4.8 6.1 6.3 6.8
8.1 6.5 10.6
4.1
6.5
8.3
2.4 -0.2 3.7
1.6 3.6 3.7
6.4 2.6 9.4
Average 2.0 3.0 6.1 Time of application significant; sulfate of ammonia significantly superior to other sources.
winter applications were made late in January. Under these conditions of no leaching, there was no significant difference for time of application of nitrogen. At Rogers, soil moisture was recharged to a depth of 6 feet by the January application date, suggesting that considerable leaching may have taken place. Under these conditions, spring application was significantly superior to fall and winter application, and sulfate of ammonia was superior to ammonium nitrate and nitrate of soda. These tests (1954-55) were both in the same county on well-drained dark-
98 W. B. ANDREWS colored soils. The differences in the leaching and in response to time of application of nitrogen are indicative of local variations which may be encountered. In Michigan, as an average of six tests, the yields of wheat with anhydrous ammonia were 41,38,38, and 34 bushels for before-planting, September-October, November-December, and March-April applications (Robertson, personal communication), The respective yields for sulfate of ammonia were 42, 41, 39, and 44 bushels. Since there were no yields without nitrogen, the data are not necessarily indicative of the results which would be obtained on responsive soils. The reason for inferior results for spring-applied anhydrous ammonia is not known. The application of 30 pounds of nitrogen per acre as anhydrous ammonia on December 1 was as effective as ammonium nitrate in the spring for spring-planted wheat and as mixed-fertilizer nitrogen in the spring for spring-planted oats in New Jersey (Anderson, 1955). The increase in yield for 30 pounds of nitrogen from both sources was 8 bushels per acre for wheat and 11 and 12 bushels for oats. For oats, at least, the response to nitrogen was too low for the data to be valid for time of application comparisons. Top-dressing with nitrogen was superior to broadcasting or spraying it on the crop residues before plowing for spring oats in Michigan (Robertson et al., 1955). The respective increases in yield for broadcasting, spraying, and top-dressing 20 pounds of nitrogen were 8.9, 12.7, and 13.6 on Fox sandy loam and 11.7, 12.3,and 21.3 bushels on Conover loam. The inferiority in the yields where the nitrogen came in contact with the carbonaceous crop residues may have been due to immobilization of nitrogen. In West Virginia, Pohlman (personal communication) found that 25 pounds of nitrogen as ammonium nitrate increased the yield of wheat 3.7 bushels when applied in the fall and 12.7 bushels when applied in March. The soil was Wheeling sandy loam, pH about 6.5. c. In Dryland Farming. Data are reported in Table X N on wheat from the Columbia Basin of Oregon (Hall, personal communication). The longtime average rainfall is 11.54inches. From 1930 to 1940,the average rainfall was 9.92inches and no response was obtained to nitrogen. Since 1950, the rainfall has averaged 13.45 inches; the data are for 1952-1 954. For 1952,which was dry, ammonium nitrate applied in the fall was superior to fall-applied anhydrous ammonia and spring-applied ammonium nitrate. Depth of nitrogen in the spring, no doubt, explains the difference between fall-applied anhydrous ammonia and ammonium nitrate in these tests. In 1953, when rainfall was good, fall-applied anhydrous ammonia
A N H Y D R O U S A M M O N I A AS A N I T R O G E N O U S FERTILIZER
99
and spring-applied ammonium nitrate at the 20- and 40-pound rates were equally effective and much superior to fall-applied ammonium nitrate. It is suggested that most of the nitrogen in the ammonium nitrate applied on the surface in the fall was immobilized in the decomposing crop residue even though the land had been fallowed. In 1954, with more rainfall, with both sources applied in the fall, anhydrous ammonia was slightly superior to ammonium nitrate. TABLE XIV The Response of Wheat to Fall- and Spring-Applied Anhydrous Ammonia and Ammonium Nitrate in Oregon Pounds nitrogen per acre
Source and time of application
NHa
NHdNOa
NHdNOp
LSD
Fall
Fall
Spring
(0.05)
Yield, bushels per acre 1952, dry year 0
20 40 60
42.7 46.1 49.0 51.0
3.9
49.9 56.5 52.7
43.6 45.6 49.2
Yield, bushels per acre 1955, more rain 0
20 40 60
42.8 48.0 50.3 49.9
3.6
41.8 43.3 45.4
48.7 52.6 44.4
Yield, bushels per acre 1954, more rain 0
20 40 60
28.6 34.4 38.7 38.9
3.0 33.3 30.0 38.9
For winter wheat production in eastern Washington (Table XV), with an average rainfall of less than 13 inches, anhydrous ammonia was as effective as sulfate of ammonia and calcium nitrate when all three sources were applied 6 inches deep and 12 inches apart at planting time. When the solids were broadcast, calcium nitrate produced 3.6 bushels more wheat than sulfate of ammonia at Lind, where straw was light, and 2.8 bushels more at Ritzville, where straw-was heavy (Jackson et al., 1952). On the average, deep-banded placement increased the yield with sulfate of ammonia 6.6 bushels of wheat as compared to 0.9 bushel for broadcast application. At another location in Washington, with surface stubble mulch, broadcasting sulfate of ammonia (40 pounds N) on the surface produced 6.3 bushels less winter wheat than banded plow sole application (Reisenauer et al., 1953). Surface banding of the sulfate of ammonia
100
W. B. ANDREWS
increased the yield 3.2 bushels over broadcasting. Where there was no surface stubble mulch, banded deep placement of the nitrogen was not superior to surface applications. The lower yields obtained for surface application of nitrogen as compared to placement 6 inches deep in bands 12 inches apart were attributed to nitrogen immobilization in the decomposition of the straw. With a rainfall of less than 13 inches, nitrogen applied as calcium nitrate on fallowed land two falls prior to seeding spring wheat was very inefficient, indicating that much of the nitrogen was made unavailable or lost during the interim. Sulfate of ammonia so applied was TABLE XV The Effect of Source of Nitrogen and Placement on the Yield of Wheat in Eastern Washington Location and placement Lind Source of nitrogen Broad20 pounds per acre cast
No nitrogen 20.5 Anhydrous ammonia Sulfate of ammonia 21.4 Calcium nitrate 25.0 Significant difference
Ritzville
Average
6 inches deep 6 inches deep 6 inches deep 12 inches Broad12 inches Broad12 inches
apart
cast
apart
cast
Yield of wheat, bushels per acre 28.5 24.5 28.2 34.1 -
2.9
apart
-
-
25.3 27.4
31.2 31.1 32.1
29.4 341.2
36.8 37.0 1.4
25.4 28.6
somewhat more efficient, but the difference may be attributed to a direct response to sulfur. Allison (1955) studied “the fate of carbon in carbonaceous crop residues decomposing under different levels of nitrogen . . . . Laboratory and greenhouse results show that although nitrogen additions offset the harmful effect of such residues on crop growth, and often accelerate decomposition, such added nitrogen does not appreciably increase the percentage of the crop residue carbon that remains in the soil as humus. Nitrogen added to cropped soils does tend to maintain soil organic matter at a higher level than in its absence, but this is due to the increased crop yields and resulting larger crop residues available for humus formation.” In Nebraska, where the climate varies from subhumid to dry, when applied in the fall, anhydrous ammonia increased the yield of wheat 10.0 bushels as compared to 8.9 for ammonium nitrate and 10.2 for spring-applied ammonium nitrate (Olson, 1955). When both were applied in April, the increase was 5.3 bushels for anhydrous ammonia
A N H Y D R O U S A M M O N I A AS A N I T R O G E N O U S FERTILIZER
101
and 9.3 for ammonium nitrate. The rate of application was 40 pounds of nitrogen per acre. The effect of rainfall on the response of wheat to fall and spring applications of ammonium nitrate is brought out by data from Oklahoma (Eck and Stewart, 1954). In 1951-1952, when the annual rainfall was more than 20 inches and most of the yields of wheat were 30 bushels or more, spring-applied ammonium nitrate (average of eight tests) made 1.8, 3.4, and 3.2 bushels more wheat than when applied in the fall at the rate of 20, 40, and 80 pounds of nitrogen per acre. In 1952-1953, when rainfall was 20 inches or less, time of application of ammonium nitrate did not affect the yield as an average of nine tests. In the year with more plentiful rainfall, 20,40, and 80 pounds of nitrogen applied in the spring increased the yield 5.6, 10.4, and 11.2 bushels; in the dry year 20 pounds increased the average yield 5.6 bushels, the higher rates giving no larger yields. In the moister year, the average protein content of wheat was increased only slightly by the 20- and 40-pound rates of nitrogen at both times of application and the 80-pound rate applied in the fall, and rather significantly by the 80-pound rate applied in the spring, indicating that the nitrogen available to the plants had been fully utilized, except from the 80-pound rate applied in the spring. In the dry year, all applications of nitrogen increased the protein content of wheat markedly.
5. Response of Pasture and H a y Crops “Anhydrous ammonia was superior to ammonium nitrate on an established stand of fescue, Festuca elatior L. var. arundinacea, and hop clover, Trifolium dubium [Table XVI]. The increase in yield for 67 and 100 pounds of nitrogen, respectively, was 1113 and 2006 pounds of air-dry forage per acre for ammonium nitrate and 2665 and 3252 for anhydrous ammonia. The superiority of anhydrous ammonia is attributed to the fact that the soil below one inch had a pH of 4.9, which retarded nitrification and subsequent leaching of the nitrogen. The top inch of the soil had a pH of 6.2, which was conducive to nitrification of the ammonia in the ammonium nitrate, making all of the nitrogen in the ammonium nitrate subject to leaching. With a pH of 6.2 in the top inch of soil there was a reasonable supply of calcium for the spring hop clover and the grasses. “Conservation of the ammonium form of nitrogen is promoted by strongly acid soils, as borne out by the above data on fescue and on oats. However, the pH should approach 7 to supply lime to many plants, to maintain phosphorus available, and to reduce the leaching of potash. These conditions may be obtained on strongly acid soils devoted to
I 02
W. B. ANDREWS
pastures and other sod crops by lightly liming the top soil after the crops are planted, and applying the ammonium form of nitrogen in the soil. With some other crops the conditions may also be obtained on strongly acid soils by applying a limited quantity of lime with or near the seed. “The nitrogen conserved by maintaining most of the soil strongly acid must be weighed against some sacrifice in the available phosphorus, and the possibility that maximum yields may not be produced under TABLE XVI The Response of Fescue and Hop Clover to Anhydrous Ammonia and Ammonium Nitrate in Mississippi
Source of nitrogen
No nitrogen Ammonium nitrate Ammonium nitrate Ammonium nitrate Anhydrous ammonia Ammonium nitrate Ammonium nitrate Anhydrous ammonia Anhydrous ammonia Anhydrous ammonia
Time, rate per acre Sept. Feb.
Applicator spacing, inches
33
33 67 67 67 100 100 100 100
18 18 a7 36
Air-dry yield, pounds per acre Feb. April May 14 8 21 Total 346 661 693 739
lO%O 769 1166 1319 1248 890
679 846 11a9 1138 a166 1694 1611 2370 2043 1987
1370 1327 1416 1425 1667 1375 1426 1850 1843 1839
2187 2724 3138 8500
4862 3836 4193 6439 5155 4716
these conditions. However, the most profitable yields may be somewhat less than maximum yields. “On a silt loam soil, spacing anhydrous ammonia applicators 18 inches apart for fescue and clover produced 5439 pounds of air-dry forage as compared to 5133 and 4716 pounds for 27- and 36-inch spacings. A 24-inch spacing is suggested for most conditions. “The use of anhydrous ammonia on very poor land to be planted to fescue produces a narrow band of excellent fescue directly over the ammonia, and that in between sometimes dies. If a solid stand of fescue is desired a solid source of nitrogen should be used and applied uniformly at seeding time. Anhydrous ammonia may then be used for later applications. “Anhydrous ammonia and ammonium nitrate produced equal increases in the yield of pasture forage in a season of normal rainfall [Table XVII]. The f i s t application of nitrogen was made during the fist part of July, which is too late for maximum response to nitrogen. The increase in yield of air-dry pasture forage was essentially the
103 same for ammonium nitrate and anhydrous ammonia. With sufficient rainfall to carry the nitrogen applied as ammonium nitrate into the root zone, surface application of ammonium nitrate was as effective as anhydrous ammonia applied in the root zone, which contrasts sharply with the results reported below for a dry year. The difference between the 16- and 32-inch spacings of the anhydrous ammonia applicators was small. “Higher yields of Dallis grass pasture forage, Paspalam dilatum poir., were produced by anhydrous ammonia applied in the root zone than A N H Y D R O U S A M M O N I A AS A N I T R O G E N O U S FERTILIZER
TABLE XVII The Response of Pasture Grasses to Anhydrous Ammonia and Ammonium Nitrate in a Season of Normal Rainfall, Average of Five Tests in Mississippi Pounds of nitrogen per acre Source of application Ammonium nitrate Anhydrous ammonia Anhydrous ammonia Yield without nitrogen
Spacing of applicators
45
99
Increase, pounds dry forage
Broadcast 16 inches 32 inches
768 753 714
1304 1328 1198 1392
TABLE XVIII
The Response of Pasture Grasses to Anhydrous Ammonia and Ammonium Nitrate in a Dry Year-Average of Five Tests-Mississippi Nitrogen Source
Ammonium nitrate Anhydrous ammonia Anhydrous ammonia Yield without nitrogen
Pounds nitrogen per acre Spacing
Broadcast 16 inches 24 inches
33
66
99
Increase i n yield, pounds air-dry forage 624 1094 1665 1053 1461 a014 1503 1692
by ammonium nitrate applied on the surface during a dry year [Table XVIII]. Ammonium nitrate failed to make yields equal to those produced by anhydrous ammonia because of differences in placement. The anhydrous ammonia was placed in the soil where the plants could recover it. The nitrate part of the ammonium nitrate, no doubt, was leached into the soil by a small amount of rain; however, it is necessary for the ammonium part of the ammonium nitrate to be changed into the nitrate form before it can be leached into the root zone. Even though plants have active roots in the surface soil during periods of wet
I04 W. B. ANDREWS weather, feed roots, no doubt, disappear from the surface soil or become inactive during dry weather. “In one test in a relatively dry year anhydrous ammonia was much superior to ammonium nitrate for forage production by Dallis grass pasture: ~
Treatment, June 17 66 lb. nitrogen per acre Anhydrous ammonia, 4“ deep Ammonium nitrate, surface
July 22 3085 1826
Date of clipping Aug. 23 Oct. 6 Total 981 908
1533 1114
5599 3848
Increase 3263 1514 ~
The total rainfall for the duration of the test was only 8.3 inches from June 17 to October 6. The placement of anhydrous ammonia in the root zone resulted in high yields of forage even though the rainfall was very low. The data suggest that very high yields of forage would be produced during a full season having normal rainfall and sufficient nitrogen. “Pasture sods are usually not damaged by anhydrous ammonia applicator knives, provided the grass is short. Where the grass is tall some of it may be pulled out of the ground. Where soils are so dry and hard that the knives shatter the soil instead of cutting through it, the grass on the shattered soil may die if rain does not follow in a short time. For application to sod crops a knife with a wide point, as described .below, is much superior to conventional knives.’’
6 . Response of Sorghum and Sugar Cane “The yield of sugarcane, Saccharum oficinarum L., syrup was 617 gallons with anhydrous ammonia and 598 gallons per acre with ammonium nitrate, as an average of three comparisons in six tests. The rate of application was 60 pounds of nitrogen per acre. Split applications of nitrogen were not superior to one application before planting or as an early side dressing. “The yield of sorghum, Sorghum vulgare, pers. var. sorgo, symp with anhydrous ammonia was 318 gallons per acre as compared to 308 for ammonium nitrate, 311 for nitrate of soda, 310 for sulphate of ammonia, and 322 gallons for sulfate of ammonia and lime. The data are from two four-year tests, and nitrogen was applied at a rate of 48 pounds per acre.’’ 7. Response of Truck Crops and Potatoes “Anhydrous ammonia compared favorably with ammonium nitrate for beans, Phaseolus vulgaris L., cabbage, Brassica oleracea capitata L.,
105
ANHYDROUS AMMONIA AS A NITROGENOUS FERTILIZER
tomatoes, Lycopersicon esculentum Mill., and sweet potatoes, Iponaea batatas, La. [Table XIX]. The six-inch depth of application was superior for tomatoes. In order to avoid injury to young plants, a six-inch depth of application and placement about five inches to the side of the place where the seed or young plants are to be placed is suggested. “The application of anhydrous ammonia as a side dressing to short season truck crops three weeks earlier than is usual for nitrate of soda and ammonium nitrate is recommended. Many of these crops require nitrate nitrogen at side-dressing time. The earlier application is suggested to provide time for the ammonia to be converted into nitrate TABLE XIX The Response of Truck Crops to Sources of Nitrogen in Mississippi
Sources of nitrogen
Ammonium nitrate Anhydrous ammonia Anhydrous ammonia Anhydrous ammonia Nitrate of soda Sulfate of ammonia
Depth of application
Cabbage’ 1
4 4 6 63 4
lb. 18,077 18,613 18,404 18,513 18,186
Crop, years of test, measure Tomatoes’ Beans’ S. potatoes* 2
2
Yield per acre lb. bu. 10,003 184 837% 180 9,976 171 8,727 176 9,763 153
a
bu. 186 183 184 150
’ 7 2 pounds of nitrogen before planting and 3%pounds as a side dressing. 48 pounds of nitrogen per acre. 8 All nitrogen before planting. 3
nitrogen. When anhydrous ammonia is applied close to planting time, no doubt only one application is necessary, which would save one trip over the land.” In Michigan ammonium nitrate was slightly superior to anhydrous ammonia for cabbage and pickle, Cucumis sativus, L. (Robertson et al., 1955). Though the differences were not large, the data suggest earlier application of anhydrous ammonia to vegetable crops in order to provide nitrate nitrogen earlier. The response of cabbage and cabbage greens to anhydrous ammonia and ammonium nitrate applied at the rate of 63 pounds of nitrogen per acre as a side dressing is shown by the data in Table XX from Virginia (Dunton, personal communication). With cabbage the same yields were made by the two sources in one test, and in two tests ammonium nitrate was superior, though the differences were not significant. In one test with cabbage greens, the difference in favor of ammonium nitrate was highly significant, which is attributed by the author to the need
106
W. B. ANDREWS
for nitrate nitrogen before a sufficient quantity of the ammonia had been nitrified, suggesting the desirability of earlier application of anhydrous ammonia. For potatoes, Solanum tuberosum, L., in California, Lorenze et al. (1954) showed that application of part of the nitrogen in the bed as sulfate of ammonia and part 6 inches to each side of the seed piece as anhydrous ammonia at emergence was just as effective as applying all the nitrogen as sulfate of ammonia in the bed at planting time. However, in two other tests, the increase in yield of potatoes for 100 pounds of nitrogen as sulfate of ammonia applied in the bed was 200 and 171 bushels; where 33 pounds of nitrogen as sulfate of ammonia was applied in the bed at planting and 67 as ammonium hydroxide in flood TABLE XX The Response of Cabbage and Cabbage Greens to Anhydrous Ammonia in Virginia
Source of nitrogen
Ammonium nitrate Anhydrous ammonia No side-dressing
Cabbage, 50-lb. boxes Test 1 Test 8 Test 5
458 579 378
565 $14
837
Cabbage greens, 80 lb. bu. Test 1 Test 8 Test 3
Yield per acre 551 889 353 766 815 677
1544 1405 776
931 604 587
irrigation water, the increases in yield were 104 and 126, respectively. Where all the nitrogen was applied at emergence in the irrigation water as sulfate of ammonia, nitrate of soda, or ammonium hydroxide, the results were much less favorable than with sulfate of ammonia applied in the soil at planting time. The loss of ammonia in sprinkler irrigation water was 36, 52, and 60 per cent when the concentration was 10,20, and 60 or more pounds per acre inch of water (Henderson et al., 1955). The pH of the water used was 8.3. The losses recorded do not include those which may have taken place after the solution came in contact with the soil. 8 . Response of Rice
In Louisiana, according to Miears (personal communication), three experiments have been conducted in which there were no significant differences between the increase in yield of rice, Oryza satiua L., produced by anhydrous ammonia, sulfate of ammonia, and ammonium nitrate. In other tests, the ammonium form of nitrogen has been superior to the nitrate form for rice production; in these tests, the failure of the ammonium form of nitrogen to be superior to ammonium nitrate
107 is attributed, by the author, to the small increases in yield of rice caused by nitrogen fertilization. For rice production in Texas, Fisher (personal communication) showed that anhydrous ammonia or sulfate of ammonia applied in the soil just prior to planting and five weeks later produced top increases in yield. When applied in the irrigation water in any manner, the response to these sources of nitrogen was much less satisfactory, producing as much as 21 bushels less than in the soil placement (Table XXI) . A N H Y D R O U S A M M O N I A AS A N I T R O G E N O U S FERTILIZER
TABLE XXI Comparison of Sources of Nitrogen and Methods of Application for Rice 1951-1954 in Texas
Method of application (80 pounds nitrogen per acre)
Without nitrogen In soil 6 weeks before planting In soil just prior t o planting I n flushing water I n 2 inches water 4-5 weeks after planting In 6 inches water 4-5 weeks after planting I n water on wet soil 4-6 weeks after planting' I n water on dry soil 4-5 weeks after planting' In water before muddying In mud during muddying In soil 5 weeks after planting
3
Drill planted Anhydrous Sulfate of ammonia amnionie
60.4 73.3 100.5
Water planted Anhydrous Sulfate of ammonia ammonia
Yield, bushels of rice per acre 63.6 80.5 99.0
93.4
86.4
70.5 90.8 96.8
94.6
77.0 79.1 79.3 76.8
80.g2
84.9
90.52
Before flooding. Broadcast.
In Arkansas (Beacher, 1955), placement of 60 pounds of nitrogen as anhydrous ammonia in the soil increased the yield 39 bushels of rice, but only 24 bushels when applied in irrigation water. When nitrogen is applied in irrigation water, the clay takes ammonium nitrogen out of the water as it flows across the field, which results in the rate of application being higher in the soil which receives the water first and lower in the soil which receives the water last. In addition, more nitrogen would be applied where the water is deeper and less where the water is shallow. Since the water goes fiist to the lower areas and is deeper in these areas, they receive considerably more nitrogen than the higher areas within the terraces. Irregularity in the
108
W. B. ANDREWS
distribution of nitrogen may result in uneven ripening of rice, which presents problems in harvesting. In Texas, the five-year average increase in yield of rice for 80 pounds of nitrogen as anhydrous ammonia was 12.9 bushels when applied five weeks before planting and 40.1 bushels when applied just before planting. In Arkansas, the average increase in yield of rice for 60 pounds of nitrogen as anhydrous ammonia in four one-year tests (Beacher, 1955) was 12,22, and 18 bushels for late-fall, late-winter, and before-planting applications (Table XXII) . Evidently, the response to TABLE XXII The Effect of Time of Application of Anhydrous Ammonia on the Yield of Rice in Arkansas Time of applying 60 pounds nitrogen
Late fall Late winter Before planting
Test 1
18 19 21
Test 2
Test 9
Test 4
Increase in yield, bushels per acre -6 16 18 2s 26 16 15 a0 16
Average
12
ee 18
anhydrous ammonia five or more weeks before planting rice as compared to at planting in Texas is not in agreement with that in Arkansas. One difference is that high response to nitrogen was obtained in Texas, while a low response was obtained in Arkansas. The comparative responses suggest that more nitrogen may have been applied in the Arkansas tests than needed, which, in turn, suggests that the Arkansas data may not be indicative of the effect of time of application on the efficiency of anhydrous ammonia. With conventional application equipment, there is sometimes streaking of crops like rice where anhydrous ammonia is applied. However, combination planting and anhydrous ammonia application equipment enables anhydrous ammonia to be applied at a fixed position relative to the seed, eliminating irregular response to the nitrogen. In a one-year test in Mississippi, Hogg (personal communication), with 60 pounds of nitrogen from ammonium nitrate applied at the second flooding, rice produced a total yield of 3992, 5027 and 5854 pounds per acre when seeded in lo-, 20-, and 30-inch drills. The yield with anhydrous ammonia applied two inches below the seed at planting was 5530 pounds per acre in 20-inch drills, an increase of 503 pounds of rice for anhydrous ammonia over ammonium nitrate with the same spacing. Where anhydrous ammonia was applied under the seed, the seedlings grew off more rapidly, they competed more favorably with the
ANHYDROUS AMMONIA AS A NITROGENOUS FERTILIZER
109
weeds and they were ready for flooding earlier which also favors weed control. There was much less lodging of rice in the wider spacings. Since these data are for only one year, additional experiments are needed before a generalization on their application in practice can be made.
9. Work in Other Countries Though the detailed data are not available, summaries of the work in northern Europe by Tonnesson (1953) show that: 1. In Denmark, anhydrous ammonia was equal to calcium nitrate for oats, was less effective than calcium nitrate for wheat, barley, and rye, was equal to calcium nitrate for kohlrabi, Brassica oleracea var. Cdo-Rapa, was inferior to calcium nitrate for rutabagas, Brassica Oleracea var. Napo-Brassica L., and was superior to sulfate of ammonia for potatoes. 2. In Norway, anhydrous ammonia and calcium ammonium nitrate had practically the same effect on the yield of potatoes, kohlrabi, wheat, barley, and oats. 3. In Sweden, the action of anhydrous ammonia compares favorably with that of the solid nitrogenous fertilizers with which it has been compared. In Formosa, Wang (1954) reported that the response of sugar cane to aqua ammonia is essentially the same as that to sulfate of ammonia.
10. Placement of Anhydrous Ammonia As has been pointed out, when anhydrous ammonia is applied it is fixed in a relatively small volume of soil. After nitrification, movement is largely up or down, probably with little lateral movement. In order for plants to get nitrogen applied as anhydrous ammonia, or any other source of nitrogen, essentially they must grow roots to the vertical plane of application. I n order for slow-growing plants to get nitrogen while they are still young, it is evident that it must be applied relatively close to them. For crops like corn, which grow rapidly, application midway between the rows is as effective as application closer to the plants (Robertson and Ohlrogge, 1952); though there are no data available for corn, it is likely that placement of anhydrous ammonia in every other middle would be as effective as in every middle. However, placement close to the plants is necessary for early response. When a large quantity of nitrogen as anhydrous ammonia, or any other source, is applied in contact with or just below the seed, there is danger of killing the seed or seedlings. If a moderate rate of anhydrous ammonia is applied and sealed in the soil 6 inches below where the seed are to be placed, there is little danger of damage. In practice, the
110
W. B. ANDREWS
opening made by the knife may be loosely filled with soil up through which anhydrous ammonia may rise a considerable distance, thereby increasing the possibility of seed and seedling injury. On nitrification of anhydrous ammonia, the nitrate nitrogen formed is subject to movement with the soil water. If nitrification of large quantities of nitrogen directly under the seed is followed by only sufficient rainfall to wet the soil to the depth of the nitrate nitrogen, movement of soil water may bring up sufficient nitrate nitrogen to kill seed and seedlings. The quantity of nitrate nitrogen necessary to kill seedlings is less on sandy and more on heavy soils, and less in dry weather and more in wet weather. Under most conditions the risk of damage to seed and seedlings is not large when applied 5 to 6 inches below the seed of row crops; however, unusual rainfall conditions justify the application of all nitrogen to the side of the seed. Where the rate is not more than 50 pounds for the heavier soils and not more than 25 pounds per acre for the lighter soils, placement directly under the seed is usually satisfactory; however, with these low rates care should be taken to place the nitrogen well below the seed. In side-dressing crops, escaping ammonia may burn the leaves of young plants. Though the damage to young plants is usually overcome in a short time, the ammonia which escapes is lost.
N.ANHYDROUS AMMONIA EQUIPMENT 1. Storage and Application “Anhydrous ammonia has no pressure at 28O F. below zero. At a pressure of 197 pounds per square inch. At first the high pressures exerted by anhydrous ammonia appear dangerous; they are dangerous, but they are no more dangerous than steam boilers, which have been in common use for a long time. “Many states have rules and regulations concerning equipment for handling anhydrous ammonia. In most cases the regulations should be satisfactory, though improvements no doubt will be made as the information warrants. Those who handle anhydrous ammonia should have a copy of the regulations. “Anhydrous ammonia tanks have a working pressure of 250 pounds per square inch. The test pressure is normally 400 pounds per square inch. The bursting pressure is normally over 1000 pounds per square inch. Tanks are equipped with sufficient pop-off valve area to relieve too much pressure by releasing the gas phase. The release of gas permits more gas to evaporate from the liquid phase; the evaporation of
looo F. it has
111 the liquid phase has a cooling effect on the tank and its contents, which reduces the pressure.” “High pressure tanks are most common. Horton spheres are large spherical tanks which are refrigerated. They may be of any size but 210,000-gallon capacity is a common size.” The operating pressure is normally less than 60 p s i . “All tanks and fittings are made from steel, which is not attacked by ammonia. Hose is ammonia resistant. Bronze and brass are attacked by ammonia and they should not be used for anhydrous ammonia. “Incomplete filling of tanks is a safety feature. The percentage fill of anhydrous ammonia tanks should not exceed the following: A N H Y D R O U S A M M O N I A AS A N I T R O G E N O U S FERTILIZER
Temperature of liquid ammonia in tank Degrees F. 30 40 50
Maximum volume filled with liquid Per cent 86 88 89
60 70 80
91
90
93
100
96
90
9%
Tanks are made to withstand much more than the gas pressure developed under ordinary circumstances. However, if a tank were completely filled with liquid only a little rise in temperature would be sufficient to cause an explosion if the pop-off valve failed to work. “A 30,000-gallon tank holds about 65 tons of anhydrous ammonia, which is sufficient to fertilize about 1,000 acres at a rate of 100 pounds of nitrogen per acre. Ammonia is shipped in 10,000-gallon tank cars, containing 25 to 26 tons. A 30,000-gallon tank is about the smallest size unit necessary for establishing a business. The effective size of the business may be increased by supplying farmers transport tanks and tractor equipment, or by applying the ammonia to the soil for a fee. Anhydrous ammonia is transported to the farm in 500- to 1000-gallon tanks where it is to be applied directly to the land. Where farm storage is available transport trucks are used. “Nitrogenous fertilizers are produced throughout the year. It is necessary for the manufacturing plants to run continuously. Since most of the nitrogen is applied in the spring it is necessary for it to be stored until used. During periods of scarcity farmers buy solid nitrog-
112 W. B. ANDREWS enous fertilizers when they become available; during periods of plenty they tend to buy their fertilizer only as needed. “The rate of delivery of anhydrous ammonia to the soil is controlled by the following devices: I.Needle valve and pressure gauge 2. Pressure regulating valves 3. Flowrator 4. Pump All of the regulating devices are accurate provided they have been calibrated and the orifices, delivery lines, and applicator knife openings are of a uniform size. The manufacturer should provide calibration data for each machine. The devices are listed in order of increasing cost. “The rate of application of anhydrous ammonia per acre by the needle valve and pressure gauge and the pressure regulating valves depends upon tank pressure, orifice size, orifice pressure, and acreage covered per hour. “Even though very accurate metering may be obtained with the needle valve and pressure gauge and pressure regulating valves, the rate of ammonia through them varies with the tank pressure and the valve gauge settings. For example, where it is desired to apply 300 pounds of anhydrous ammonia per hour through four 3/32-inchorifices, an orifice gauge pressure of 37 pounds per square inch is required with a tank pressure of 90 pounds per square inch, while an orifice gauge pressure of 52 pounds is required when the tank pressure goes up to 150 pounds per square inch. If a regulating valve is set so that the orifice gauge pressure is 37 pounds with a tank pressure of 90 pounds per square inch, only 220 pounds of ammonia would be delivered as compared to the desired 300 pounds per hour when the tank pressure goes up to 150 pounds per square inch, even though the orifice pressure is maintained at 37 pounds per square inch. “There is one automatic regulating valve which partially compensates for changes in tank pressure so that little change in rate of flow of anhydrous ammonia takes place even though the tank pressure varies markedly. “The flowrator is a tapered glass tube, graduated in pounds of nitrogen per hour, the rate of flow is indicated by a rotor which rises as the rate increases. Flow through this instrument is controlled by a needle valve. “The rate of delivery of ammonia by all of the metering devices, except the pump, is a function of time, and a constant speed of the tractor is necessary to maintain a constant rate per acre. The pump is
ANHYDROUS A M M O N I A AS A N I T R O G E N O U S FERTILIZER
113
geared to the tractor and should maintain a constant rate of application per acre even though the speed of the tractor varies. “A cooler is used with the pump and flowrator to prevent the formation of vapor in these instruments. The cooler is made from coiled %-inch pipe in a 3 x 12-inch pipe, with the proper fittings. The ammonia comes from the tank through the coil and leaves the pump or flowrator through the larger pipe around the coil. The pressure of the outgoing ammonia is lowered, and the evaporating anhydrous ammonia cools the incoming ammonia, thereby preventing it from bubbling. “Farm tractors are usually equipped with 70- to 110-gallon anhydrous a m m o n i a tanks which are mounted on the tractor. Trailing equipment carries much larger tanks. A 110-gallon tank holds about 420 pounds of nitrogen, equivalent to 1% tons of nitrate of soda. “Anhydrous ammonia is conducted into the soil through hose connected to the back of applicator knives. Almost any type of knife does a good job in soils which are loose and friable and free of trash. Difficulty in sealing ammonia increases as soils become less friable, more compact and more trashy, and as the rate of application per foot of row increases. “The applicator knife should slope backward and not be sharp above a vertical distance of four inches from the point. The backward slope enables the knife to take the ground and helps it to shed trash. The dull edge also helps in shedding trash. The bottom of the knife should carry a n addition to loosen and increase the amount of soil available for absorbing the ammonia. The knife . . . has a 3-inch point of a 10-inch sweep welded on the bottom, which loosens the soil so that a good job of sealing may be done in compact soils and pastures. “A covering device helps seal anhydrous ammonia in the soil. The disk hiller . . . crowds loose soil against the applicator from near the bottom up and prevents the escape of ammonia. Shovels or other covering devices may be used. Even though a covering device is not needed on soils which are loose and friable, it is usually desirable to use one. “In filling tanks the outlet valve on the storage tank should be opened last and closed first. I n filling tanks by bleeding, pumps, and compressors all connections are made and all valves are opened with the outlet valve on the storage tank being opened last. Then the pump or compressor (if used) is started and the bleeder valve is opened. The escape of a spray from the bleeder valve indicates that the liquid ammonia is up to the filling level, after which the pump or compressor (if used) is stopped, the outlet valve on the storage tank is closed, the bleeder valve is closed, the other valves are closed and the hose disconnected.”
114
W. B. ANDREWS
“The gaseous anhydrous ammonia should not be removed from anhydrous ammonia tanks. At 80° F., a 30,000-gallon tank contains 2040 pounds of anhydrous ammonia as a vapor, a 1,000-gallon tank contains 68 pounds, and a 100-gallon tank contains 6.8 pounds. At $150 per ton, the ammonia lost in bleeding these tanks after the liquid has been removed is worth $153.00, $5.10 and $0.51, respectively. “Allllllonia reacts with the inside of steel tanks in such a way that a protective coating is formed. This layer is lost on exposure to the air
FIG. 3. Transferring anhydrous ammonia to tractor equipment (courtesy of Mississippi Agricultural Experiment Station).
and rusting proceeds. Preventing rust is another reason for not releasing the ammonia vapor from tanks.” 2 . Bleeding Losses in Filling Tanks Anhydrous ammonia is usually transferred from transport to tractor tanks by bleeding gaseous ammonia from the tank being filled. Though pumps and compressors are available for this use, a discussion of them is beyond the scope of this paper. To date, bleeding losses have not been determined experimentally. The calculated bleeding losses reported by Andrews et al. (1951) are in error. Andrews and Caveness (unpublished) calculated bleeding losses based on the thermodynamic properties of anhydrous ammonia by Hodgman (1947). The calculated bleeding losses of ammonia, as obtained under the conditions prescribed, are the least that can be obtained; however, it appears that the
ANHYDROUS AMMONIA AS A NITROGENOUS FERTILIZER
115
calculated losses should be obtained in practice provided the equipment is correctly designed and operated (Andrews and Caveness, 1956). The calculations presented in Table XXIII show some of the changes which take place in both the 1000-gallon transport and the 100-gallon tractor tanks. The starting temperature is 80° F., which gives an absolute pressure of 153 p.s.i. The transport tank is filled to 90 per cent of capacity with liquid anhydrous ammonia. Ten liquid transfers of 90 gallons each were calculated. It was assumed that the fraction of the 1000-gallon tank in contact with the liquid at the start of filling and all of the 100-gallon tank supplied heat to the respective systems. On removing the 90-gallons of liquid from the 1000-gallon tank, its place is taken by both the evaporation of liquid and the expansion of the gases originally present. The evaporating ammonia is derived from the 90 gallons involved in each transfer. For the first removal from the I 000-gallon tank, there remains a large quantity of liquid ammonia to give up heat to the evaporating ammonia and only a small amount of gas to expand, which reverses as successive removals are made. Within the 1000-gallon tank, the absolute pressure drops from 153 to 151.42 p.s.i. for the first transfer and the drop increases progressively until the tenth and last transfer, where the pressure drops from 153 to 142.90 p s i . Where the pressure in the 100-gallon tank is maintained at 10 pounds less than in the 1000-gallon tank while transferring, the pressure in the 100-gallon tank decreases from 153 to 141.42 p.s.i. for the first transfer and decreases progressively with successive transfers to 132.9 pounds for the tenth and last transfer. The mean temperature of the ammonia leaving the large tank decreases only onehalf as much as that of the larger tank and its contents. The quantity of liquid ammonia which must be vaporized in the 100-gallon tank to obtain the ending pressure is 4.72, 4.76, 4.81, 4.89, 4.97, 5.09, 5.26, 5.56, 6.12, and 7.78 pounds for the ten successive transfers. In practice, when filling is started the 100-gallon tank contains a small residue of liquid ammonia and essentially 6.82 pounds of gaseous ammonia at 80° F. The total gas which must be accounted for is 4.72 . . . 7.78 plus 6.82 or 11.54 . . . 14.60 pounds. When filling of the 100-gallon tank with liquid is completed to the prescribed level, the 100-gallon tank contains 0.80, 0.80, 0.80, 0.80, 0.80, 0.79, 0.79, 0.78, 0.77, and 0.75 or an average of 0.79 pound of gaseous ammonia. Subtracting the weight of the remaining gas from the above quantities gives 10.74 . . . 13.85 pounds of gaseous ammonia which is bled off, or 2.42, 2.43, 2.44, 2.46, 2.47, 2.50, 2.54, 2.60, 2.73, and 3.09 per cent for the successive fillings, or an average loss of 2.57 per cent. Though calculations have not been made, the losses in bleeding are some less
c. Q,
TAB- XXIII Losses in Transferring Anhydrous Ammonia from 1000-GallonTransport to Tractor Tanks
1 I
1000-gal. tank 80' F., 153 lb. pressure pre square inch, absolute, a t start 100-gal. tank, 80' F., 153 lb. pressure a t start
Filling no.
Changes in 1000-gal. tank
Small tank, 80° F., atmospheric pressure a t start Tank size, gallons
Changes in 100-gal. tank 10-lb. difference in pressure 100
Ending, temp., OF.
Ending pressure. lb.
Ending, temp.,
OF.
Ending pressure, lb
.
NH* evap., lb.
NHa loss, %'
10
100 140 Pressure difference lb. 5
5
150
5
Per cent loss in bleeding
~
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
79.38 79.32 79.24 79.13 78.99 78.80 78.51 78.04 77.16 75.96
151.42 151.27 151.06 150.78 150.49 149.94 149. 20 148.00 145.84 142.90
75.36 75. 29 75.21 75.09 74.95 74.75 74.45 7%.96 73.04 71.79
141.42 141.27 141.06 140.78 140.43 139.94 139.20 188.00 135.84 132. 90
Average 1 f
See text for the details. The difference in preasure L slightly more than 6 pound. when fillins M complete.
4.72 4.76 4.81 4.89 4.97 5.09 5.26 5.56 6.12 7.78 5.40
2.42 2.43 2.44 2.46 2.47 2.50 2.54 2.60 2.73 3.09 2.57
1.00 1.01 1.02 1.04 1.06 1.09 1.12 1.19 1.32 1.69 1.15
0.50 0.51 0.52 0.53 0.55 0.57 0.61 0.66 0.76 1.02 0.62
0.002
0.00' 0.002
0.002 0.02 0.04 0.08 0.15 0.26 0.050 0.11
0.00' 0.00' 0 .OO' 0.00' 0.002 0.00'
0.00' 0.01 0.11 0.40 0.05
a pl G 3
ANHYDROUS AMMONIA AS A NITROGENOUS FERTILIZER
117
where larger storage tanks are used; likewise, filling tractor tanks larger than 100-gallonsfrom the storage tank increases the loss slightly. Accumulating, on the average, of the 449.76 pounds of ammonia involved in the transfer, 4.89 pounds evaporates in the 1000-gallon tank and is not lost; 5.40 pounds evaporates in the 100-gallon tank which contains 6.82 pounds of gas at the start and 0.79 pound of gas when filling is complete, which gives 433.44 pounds of liquid available for application plus 6.03 pounds to replace the gas in the tank as the liquid is removed; 11.43 pounds or 2.57 per cent is lost in bleeding. Since the 100-gallon tank contains 6.82 pounds of gaseous ammonia at 80° F. and 153 pounds of pressure and only 0.57 pound at 80° F. and atmospheric pressure, 6.25 pounds of ammonia may be saved by applying the gas to the soil until atmospheric pressure is reached. This change in practice would reduce the average bleeding loss from 2.57 to 1.15 per cent. By using a £ difference in final pressure and applying the gas to atmospheric pressure the loss is reduced to 0.62 per cent in a 100-gallon tank, and 0.11 and 0.05 per cent where 449.76 pounds of ammonia is involved in the transfer to 140- and 150-gallon tanks, respectively. When starting with the 100-gallon tank filled with gas in equilibrium with residual liquid and bleeding with a 10-pound difference in pressure, the average bleeding loss was calculated to be 1.79,2.10, 2.57, and 3.08 per cent at 40°, 60°, 80°, and looo F. The above calculations were based on ten transfers of ammonia from a 1000- to a 100-gallon tank. Calculations made for transferring the contents of a 1000-gallon tank at 80° F. to another 1000-gallon tank give a bleeding loss of 3.67 per cent as compared to the average loss of 2.57 per cent for the ten individual transfers. The calculations show that losses obtained on completely transferring ammonia between tanks of equal size are not applicable to bleeding losses obtained in practice. As pointed out above, the 100-gallon tank contains 6.82 pounds of gaseous ammonia at 80° F. and 153 pounds pressure, 6.25 pounds of which may be saved by applying the gas to the soil until atmospheric pressure is reached. In order to remove the gas to atmospheric pressure, it is necessary to remove the liquid phase completely, which is not feasible with a down pipe outlet; however, it would be feasible with the outlet through a sump in the bottom of one end of the tank toward which the tank is sloped downward. Larger fittings would reduce the time required in filing. Unconfirmed reports suggest that bleeding losses in transferring ammonia may be much larger than those shown in these calculations. In the opinion of the author, bleeding losses significantly larger than those calculated here can be obtained only with improperly designed equip-
118 W. B. ANDREWS ment, with differences in pressure much larger than 10 pounds, or where bleeding is continued after the liquid level has reached the end of the bleeder valve. If experiments, conducted as specified here, should show that bleeding losses with the present equipment are significantly larger than those calculated, the larger losses would be attributed to the loss of liquid entrained in the bleeder gas. With the presently used equipment, the bleeder valve is often located next to the filler valve, which may facilitate the entrainment of droplets of liquid ammonia in the bleeder gas; the separation of the filler and bleeder valves by the length of the tank would provide the least possible opportunity for the loss of liquid in bleeding. As the equipment is now used, filling is stopped when a mixture of liquid and gaseous ammonia starts discharging continuously from the bleeder valve as a spray. The entrance of the incoming liquid at the top of the tank produces turbulence which facilitates intermittent release of spray before the filling level is reached. In the opinion of the author, the bleeding losses should be essentially the same as those calculated provided the discharge of the spray is prevented which can be done by nonturbulent entrance of the ammonia, shortening the pipe to the bleeder valve, and using a gauge to indicate the filling level. To date there has been no work reported on the design and operation of the equipment in bleeding. On the basis of the theoretical studies presented here, for filling by bleeding, it is suggested that the ideal tractor tank for anhydrous ammonia would be either oblong with spherical heads, mounted vertically, or spherical. The outlet valve would be placed in the center of the bottom and the bleeder valves without a down pipe, would be placed in the center of the top; the pop-offvalve would be placed close to the top. The inlet valve would be placed near the bottom of the cylinder of oblong tanks and near the center of spherical tanks. The filling level would be indicated by a sight gauge. It may be desirable to provide a special manifold to speed up application of the gaseous ammonia to the soil after the liquid has been removed. The final difference in pressure in bleeding need not be more than 5 p s i . and the bleeding loss should be essentially 0.64 per cent when starting at 80° F. The ideal tank for transferring anhydrous ammonia by bleeding should also be ideal for liquefiable petroleum gases which are transferred by bleeding.
3. Distribution Pattern For individually owned equipment, anhydrous ammonia is, of course, best suited for large farm use. However, the anhydrous am-
A N H Y D R O U S A M M O N I A AS A N I T R O G E N O U S FERTILIZER
119
monia equipment needs of small farmers are being supplied on a rental basis and by custom applicators in many areas, and the cost per pound of a medium to high rate of nikogen applied in the ground as anhydrous ammonia is no more than the cost of that in solids at the market place. This relationship is conducive to continued increase in the use of anhydrous ammonia. There are, at present, many distribution patterns in existence some of which are as follows: 1. Producer to farmer in the farmer’s transport equipment. 2. Producer to farmer in farmer’s storage equipment. 3. Producer to local distributor to farmer. 4 . Producer to jobber to local distributor to farmer. 5 . Producer to fertilizer manufacturer to local distributor to farmer. With the present surplus capacity to produce, it may be anticipated that the trend in the distributing pattern will be influenced by costs which may be more favorable to farmer-owned storage, particularly in areas where delivery may be made by truck from the plant.
V. SUMMARY Aqua ammonia was mentioned as a source of nitrogen more than a century ago. Anhydrous ammonia was first used as a source of nitrogen in 1930 by J. 0. Smith of the Mississippi Delta Branch Experiment Station. Later aqua ammonia was used in greenhouse experiments. I n 1934, Waynick recommended the use of anhydrous ammonia in flood irrigation water. In 1939, Leavitt applied for a patent on the use of anhydrous ammonia on arable soils which was granted in 1942. The Mississippi Agricultural Experiment Station experimented with aqua ammonia in 1943 and started experimental work on anhydrous ammonia in 1944. The results of this work were first published in 1947. Since that time, anhydrous ammonia has become a leading source of nitrogen. The present capacity to produce anhydrous ammonia and other sources of nitrogen synthetically is larger than the present demands. In synthetic plants, anhydrous ammonia is produced first and is then used as such or converted into other sources. The cost of producing 1 ton of anhydrous ammonia is essentially the same as the cost of producing 1 ton of ammonia nitrate; on a pound of nitrogen basis, the cost of producing anhydrous ammonia is only about 40 per cent of the cost of ammonia nitrate. The relative costs of the two materials suggest that where suited the use of anhydrous ammonia will continue to increase relative to the solid sources. When applied to the soil, anhydrous ammonia is held by the clay and organic matter, affecting only about 5 per cent of the volume of
120 W. B. ANDREWS the surface 6 inches when applied at the rate of 100 pounds of nitrogen per acre to the average soil, and with a coverage of about 10 per cent of the surface area. These, of course, vary with soil texture and organic matter. In the zone of application of anhydrous ammonia the soluble phosphorus is increased and the soil structure could be impaired, though neither effect is of significant magnitude and both are temporary. When applied in contact with superphosphate, anhydrous ammonia markedly reduces the availability of the phosphorus. Anhydrous ammonia is acid-forming, as are ammonium nitrate and urea. In the zone of application, anhydrous ammonia markedly reduces the number of fungi and nematodes, suggesting the possibility that it may be useful as a nematocide. For 3 days after application, anhydrous ammonia reduces the number of bacteria and actinomycetes, after which the numbers increase markedly, to 6 to 25 times as many for the bacteria 10 days later. The worms, insects, etc., no doubt, are killed in the zone of application. Because of the small volume of soil affected by anhydrous ammonia and the capacity of these organisms to reproduce, any effect of anhydrous ammonia should be temporary. The rate of nitrification of ammonia is affected by both the temperature and pH of the soil. Nitrification is much slower in the strongly acid soils than in those with more lime. Nitrification is rapid at 70 to 80° F. and the rate decreases as the temperature drops. On strongly acid soils nitrification may stop below 50° F., but in soils containing a good supply of lime considerable nitrification may take place so long as the temperature is above freezing, and on these soils nitrification may be resumed immediately when the temperature increases from below to above freezing. The partial sterilization of the soil in the zone of application of anhydrous ammonia, combined with the fact that nitrogen in readily decomposable organic matter nitrifies more rapidly than ammonia which is concentrated in a small volume of soil, suggests that nitrification data collected where the nitrogen was mixed throughout the soil may not be wholly applicable for anhydrous ammonia under field conditions. Nitrogen applied in the ammonium form does not leach before it is converted into nitrate nitrogen, which may take less than three weeks under favorable conditions for nitrification. Differences in the leaching of nitrogen applied in the nitrate and ammonium forms may be of practical significance only on strongly acid soils, or when applied close to the time of utilization on soils with a fair supply of lime. The highest efficiency is obtained from the application of anhydrous ammonia, or any other source of nitrogen, as close as practicable
A N H Y D R O U S A M M O N I A AS A N I T R O G E N O U S FERTILIZER
121
to the time that it will supply the form of nitrogen needed by the particular growing plant. Corn, and probably sugar cane, sorghum, and some other plants, prefer the ammonium form of nitrogen when young and may utilize it equally as well as nitrate nitrogen as late as the application may be applied with conventional equipment. At normal side-dressing time, cotton has a small preference for nitrate nitrogen, and oats (probably other small grains also) and some of the truck crops have a strong preference for nitrate nitrogen at this stage of growth. When applied before or at planting time anhydrous ammonia has been equal or superior to ammonium nitrate. Where anhydrous ammonia has been superior to ammonium nitrate when applied before or at planting, the author attributes the difference to the leaching of nitrate nitrogen as a result of the ground water being recharged below the root zone. When applied as a side- or top-dressing, anhydrous ammonia has been equal or inferior to ammonium nitrate. Where ammonium nitrate has been superior to anhydrous ammonia in side-dressing, the author attributes the difference to higher efficiency of the nitrate form of nitrogen at this stage of growth; the difference may be overcome by earlier application of anhydrous ammonia. In most of the tests with corn where nitrogen has been utilized efficiently, side-dressing has been superior to preplanting application and late side-dressing has been superior to early side-dressing. Though the superiority of side-dressing has been higher in some tests, the most common increase is between 3 and 10 bushels. The superiority of sidedressing corn as compared to preplanting application is often larger with ammonium nitrate than with ammonium sources of nitrogen. Though less time for leaching and microbial immobilization of nitrogen may be partly responsible for the superiority of side-dressings for corn, it is probable that later applications increase the efficiency of the utilization of moisture as well as nitrogen in the production of grain because of delayed or reduced vegetative growth. When applied in the late fall on soils which are strongly acid, anhydrous ammonia is equal to spring-applied ammonium nitrate for the production of oats and, no doubt, other small grains. When anhydrous ammonia and other sources of nitrogen have been applied at efficient rates in the late fall on soils which nitrify ammonia readily and in which the ground water is recharged below the root zone prior to utilization of the nitrogen, the efficiency has been less than that of spring applications in most tests which have been conducted with fall-planted small grains and spring-planted crops. The percentage recovery of applied nitrogen by plants is low. With an increase in yield of 1 bushel for 3 pounds of nitrogen only about 50
122 W. B. ANDREWS per cent of the nitrogen applied is utilized by the corn. Following corn on dry years where most of the applied nitrogen was not utilized by the corn, its recovery by small grains has been disappointingly low. The low recovery of unused nitrogen by a following crop, in itself, raises a question concerning off-season application of nitrogen. Unfortunately, most of the tests which have been run in the Middle West on fall vs. spring application of anhydrous ammonia have been conducted during drier than normal years and the response to nitrogen has been low. The data may not be applicable for determining time of application with normal seasons and efficient utilization of the nitrogen by crops. In the South, the data on fall vs. spring application of anhydrous ammonia as well as other sources of nitrogen for row crops are inadequate; the behavior of fall applications on small grains suggests very strongly that fall application would be inefficient for spring-planted crops. The application of nitrogen in contact with carbonaceous crop residues does not increase the amount of organic matter derived from the crop residues, but it does markedly lower the potential efficiency of the applied nitrogen. Though other sources of nitrogen may be so applied, normally anhydrous ammonia is applied so that it comes in contact with a minimum of crop residues, resulting in a minimum loss in efficiency because of nitrogen immobilization. In dryland wheat growing there may be insufficient moisture for efficient utilization of nitrogen. In addition, microbial immobilization of nitrogen rather than leaching appears to be the problem in utilization. For the solid sources of nitrogen as ordinarily applied, with adequate moisture in the fall, fall-applied nitrogen may be immobilized so that spring application is superior; while with low moisture in the fall and winter fall applications appear to be superior. Drilled applications of nitrogen, as anhydrous ammonia is applied, lead to more efficient utilization of nitrogen where significant quantities of carbonaceous residues are present. The study of the data suggests, to the author, that late-winter applications of nitrogen which are drilled 4 to 6 inches deep may be superior to other times and methods of application of nitrogen to wheat in dry areas. The application of anhydrous ammonia or aqua ammonia in (1) sprinkler irrigation water, (2) flood irrigation water for drilled plantings such as rice, and (3) furrow irrigation has been very inefficient as compared to soil application where normal responses to nitrogen were obtained. When applied in sprinkler irrigation water, much nitrogen is lost into the air. When nitrogen is applied in flood or furrow irrigation water, the soil closest to the entrance and that where the water is
123 deeper receives much more nitrogen than that which is farther away or where the water is shallow. ANHYDROUS AMMONIA AS A NITROGENOUS FERTILIZER
VI. CONCLUSIONS Within a span of a few years, anhydrous ammonia has probably become the leading source of nitrogen for direct application. No doubt, its use will continue to increase more rapidly than that of other sources of nitrogen. The primary losses in efficiency of nitrogen are produced by leaching and by microbial immobilization in the decomposition of carbonaceous crop residues. As compared to other sources of nitrogen, anhydrous ammonia has accounted for itself favorably under most circumstances. In the case of some crops, corn, for example, it appears that time of application of nitrogen may have a significant influence on the efficiency in the utilization of moisture as well as of nitrogen. The application of anhydrous ammonia, or any other source of nitrogen, as close as practical to the time that it will supply the form of nitrogen needed by the particular plant has proven to be a good practice. Except for small grains on strongly acid soils, fall application of any source of nitrogen in humid climates has not often been equal to spring application for spring and summer consumption by crops where the efficiency of utilization of nitrogen and rainfall were both normal. There are insufficient data to describe adequately the conditions under which favorable results from off -season application may be obtained in humid climates. More data are also needed in subhumid climates.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT The author wishes to express his sincerest appreciation to agronomists throughout the country who made both published and unpublished data available for this paper, to J. D. Lancaster for consultation throughout the preparation of the manuscript, and to Lloyd R. Frederick and W. B. Dunwoody for reviewing parts of the manuscript.
REFERENCES Allison, F. E. 1955. Soil Sci. Soc. Amer. Proc. 19, 210-211. Anderson, 0. E. 1955. Ph.D. Thesis, Rutgers University. Andrews, W. B. 1954a. “The Response of Crops and Soils to Fertilizers and Manures,” pp. 105-151. W. B. Andrews, State College, Mississippi. Andrews, W. B. 1954b. “The Response of Crops and Soils to Fertilizers and Manures,” p. 2888. W. B. Andrews, State College, Mississippi. Andrews, W. B. 1954~.“The Response of Crops and Soils to Fertilizers and Manures,” pp. 40-75. W. B. Andrews, State College, Mississippi. Andrews, W. B., and Caveness, E. W. 1956. Mississippi Agr. Expt. Sta. Mem. Andrews, W. B., and Edwards, F. E. 1947. Agr. Eng. 28,394-396. Andrews, W. B., Edwards, F. E., and Hammons, J. G. 1947a. Mississippi Agr. Ezpt. Sta. Prelim. Bull.
1%
W. B. ANDREWS
Andrews, W. B., Edwards, F. E., and Hammons, J. G. 194713. Mississippi Agr. Ezpt. Sta. Bull. 440. Andrews, W. B., Edwards, F. E., and Hammons, J. G. 1948. Mississippi Agr. Expt. Sta. Bull. 451. Andrews, W. B., Neely, J. A., and Edwards, F. E. 1951. Mississippi Agr. Expt. Sta. Bull. 402. Beacher, R. L. 1955. Agr. Ammonia News. 5(2), 9-11. Chapman, H. D. 1936. J . Am. SOC.Agron. 20,135-145. Dumenil, L. 1955. Agr. Ammonia News 5 (3), 22,24-25. Eck, H. V., and Stewart, B. A. 1954. Oklahoma Agr. Expt. Sta. Bull. 0-432. Edwards, F. E., and Andrews, W. B. 1947. Agr. Eng. 20,396396. Eno, C. F., and Blue, W. G. 1954. Soil Sci. SOC.Amer. Proc. 10, 178-181. Eno, C. F., Blue, W. G., and Good, J. M., Jr. 1955. Soil Sci. Soc. Amer. Proc. 19, 55-58.
Henderson, D. W., Bianchi, W. C., and Doneen, L. D. 1955. California Agr. Expt. Sta. Mern. Hodgman, C. D. 1947. “Handbook of Chemistry and Physics,” pp. 1888-1891. Chem. Rub. Pub. Co., Cleveland, Ohio. Jackson, T. L., Reisenauer, H. M., and Homer, G. M. 1952. Washington Agr. Expt. &a. Circ. 179. Jenny, H., Ayers, A. D., and Hosking, J. S. 1945. Hilgardia 16, 249-457. Johnston, J. F. W. 1853. “Elements of Agricultural Chemistry.” Blackwood, London. (Cited by MacIntire et al., 1944.) Leavitt, F. H. 1942. U. S. Patent No. 2,285,932. Lorenze, A. O., Bishop, J. C., Hagle, B. J., Zobel, M. P., Doneen, L. D., Minges, P. A., and Ulrich, A. 1954. California Agr. Ezpt. Sta. Bull. 744. Lowrey, G. W., and Dreier, A. F. 1951. Nebraska Agr. Expt. Sta. Outstate Testing Circ. 20. Lowrey, G. W., and Ehlers, P. L. 1954. Nebraska Agr. Ezpt. Sta. Outstate Testing Circ. 35. Lowrey, G. W., Ehlers, P. L., and Pumphrey, F. W. 1954. Nebraska Agr. Expt. Sta. Outstate Testing Circ. 42. MacGregor, J. M. 1955a. Agr. Ammonia News. 5(2), 12-13,15-16. MacGregor, J. M. 1955b. Plant Food Rev. 1 (2), 4-5. MacIntire, W. H., Winterberg, S. H., Dunham, H. W., and Clements, L. B. 1944. Soil Sci. SOC.Amer. Proc. 8, 205-210. Mehring, A. L. 1955. Quoted in Agr. Ammonia News. 5(2), 22. Merkle, F. G. 1952. Pennsylvania Agr. Ezpt. Sta. Mem. (Cited by Andrews, 1954.) Missouri Growers, Inc. 1954a. “1954 Results, Anhydrous Ammonia,” p. 8. Carrollton, Missouri. Missouri Growers, Inc. 1954b. “1954 Results, Anhydrous Ammonia,” p. 3. Carrollton, MisSOuri. Missouri Growers, Inc. 1955. “Agricultural Ammonia Pays Off,” pp. 6 1 5 . Carrollton, Missouri. Naftel, J. A. 1931. J . Am. SOC.Agron. 23, 142-158. Oakes, J. Y., and McCormick, L. L. 1954. Louisiana Red River Valley Agr. Expt. Sta. Prelim. Rept. p. 9. Olson, R. A. 1955. Agr. Ammonia News. 5(3), 12, 14-15. Pack, M. R. 1954. Oklahoma Agr. Ezpt. Sta. Mem. Peterson, N. K. 1952. M.S. Thesis, Purdue University.
ANHYDROUS AMMONIA AS A NITROGENOUS FERTILIZER
125
Pitner, J. B., and Kuykendall, R. 1943. Mississippi Agr. Expt. Sta. Farm Research 6 , (6198. Reisenauer, H. M., Leggett, G. E., and Nelson, W. L. 1953. Washington Agr. Expt. Sta. Mem. Robertson, L. S., Guttay, J. R., and Hansen, C. M. 1955. Quart. Bull. Michigan Agr. Expt. Sta. 37, 420424. Robertson, W . K., and Ohlrogge, A. J. 1952. Agron. J . 44, 170-173. Scholl, W., Wallace, H. M., and Fox, E. I. 1955. U.S. Dept. Agr. Agr. Research Service Mern. 1820. Smith, G. E. 1952.Missouri Agr. Expt. Sta. Bull. 503. Smith, G.E.1954. Missouri Agr. Expt. Sta. Mern. Stanley, F. A., and Smith, G. E. 1955. Agr. Ammonia News. 5(2), lS21. Thompson, H. L., and Shearon, W. H. 1952. Ind. Eng. Chem. 44, 254-264. Tonnesson, R. D.1953.Norsh Hydro. No. 3, 3-5, 16. Tiedjens, V. A.,and Robins, W. R. 1931.N e w Jersey Agr. Expt. Sta. Bull. 526. Wang, Shih-Chung. 1954. Taiwan Sugar J. Quart. 1 (9), 15-22. Waynick, D.D. 1934. Calif. Citrograph 19,295. (Cited by MacIntire et al., 1944.) Wolf, J. J., and Hoyert, J. H. 1952. South Carolina Agr. Expt. Sta. 64th Ann, Rept. p. 133.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Progress in Grass Breeding
.
D. C SMITH University of Wisconsin. Madison. Wisconsin
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . 1. Nature of Review . . . . . 2. History and Scope . . . . . I1. Diversity of Grasses . . . . . . 1. Species and Varieties . . . . 2. Certification of Seed . . . . I11. General References . . . . . . IV Nature of Varieties . . . . . . V. Environmental Effects . . . . . VI. Cytology . . . . . . . . . I. Variability . . . . . . . 2. Smooth Bromegrass . . . . 3. Other Grasses . . . . . . VII. Interspecific and Intergeneric Relations I . Bromus Species . . . . . . 2. Stipa Species . . . . . . 3. Festuca and Lolium . . . . 4. Elymus Species . . . . . . 5 Poa Species . . . . . . . 6. Triticum-Agropyron . . . . VIII. Fertility and Sterility . . . . . IX. Inbreeding . . . . . . . . . X . Combining Ability . . . . . . 1. Parent-Progeny Relations . . . 2. Interpollination . . . . . . 3. Statistical Approach . . . . 4. General . . . . . . . . XI . Crossing Techniques . . . . . . XI1. Hybrid Varieties . . . . . . . XI11. Agronomic Aspects . . . . . . XIV . Disease Resistance . . . . . . XV. Nutritive Value . . . . . . . XVI. Variety Maintenance . . . . . XVII . Discussion . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . .
.
.
127
Page 128 . . . . . . 128 . . . . . . 128 . . . . . . 129 . . . . . . 129 . . . . . . 129 . . . . . . 130 . . . . . 131 . . . . . . 134 . . . . . . 135 . . . . . . 135 . . . . . . 137 . . . . . . 137 . . . . . . 139 . . . . . . 139 . . . . . . 139 . . . . . . 140 . . . . . . 140 . . . . . . 14Q . . . . . . 141 . . . . . . 141 . . . . . . 142 . . . . . . 143 . . . . . . 143 . . . . . . 147 . . . . . . 148 . . . . . . 148 . . . . . . 1" . . . . . . 150 . . . . . . 151 . . . . . . 152 . . . . . . 154 . . . . . . 156 . . . . . . 158 . . . . . . 159
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
.
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
.
.
.
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
128
D. C. SMITH
I. INTRODUCTION I . Nature of Review
This review of grass breeding is intended to indicate something of the background for present-day points of view and to describe progress which has been made in the last decade. Since space does not allow a comprehensive and complete summary the author has chosen to refer to certain illustrative work and to omit references and aspects which others may think are more vital. Only breeding of perennial forage grasses is considered. 2. History and Scope
It is difficult to ascertain when recognition was given to the possibility that grass species might be subject to variety differentiation and improvement. Perhaps the earliest grass-breeding project in the United States was that to improve timothy (Phleum pratense) begun in Minnesota in 1889 by W. M. Hays. A few years later Hopkins in West Virginia started similar work. Shortly after 1900 an extensive program was begun by Webber at the Cornell Experiment Station. Intensive work in northern Europe began at about the same time. Real emphasis on the improvement of forage crops in the United States was an outgrowth, in part, of the soil conservation program begun in the early nineteen-thirties, as well as of a growing need that available plants be obtained and improved. Dale and Brown (1955), writing broadly of the use of grass, continued the earlier established campaign for the use of grasses and legumes in conservation of soil and water. Recently the expressions “Grassland Agriculture” and “Grassland Farming” have been widely used, these being traceable to Great Britain, Australia, New Zealand, and South Africa and perhaps more directly to Sir R. G. Stapledon, formerly Director of the Welsh Plant Breeding Station. The first International Grassland Congress was held in Germany in 1927 and the sixth at State College, Pennsylvania, in 1952. This movement has been highly successful in stimulating research in all phases of grassland problems. In Northeast Regional Publication No. 19, New Jersey Agricultural Experiment Station Bulletin 777 published in 1954, it is of interest to find the opening sentence to be “Forage crops are the foundation for a stable agriculture in the Northeastern United States.” Improvement of forage crop varieties has received increasing emphasis. In the broad sense grassland improvement involves many aspects, among which are land clearing and brush removal, control of runoff
PROGRESS IN GRASS BREEDING
129
and water supply, tillage, fertilization and other amendments, irrigation, drainage, improved species and varieties, management, machinery and utilization. Breeding of improved strains is therefore but a small part of the whole program, though in many instances it may be a critical one. Owing largely to improved machinery and changes in crop, soil, and livestock management, hay and pasture production on tillable soil is undergoing revolutionary changes at present.
11. DIVERSITY OF GRASSES
I. Species and Varieties In the 1948 Yearbook of Agriculture Hoover et al. listed 60 grass species as being the “main” ones in the United States. In a tabular summary elsewhere in the Yearbook 158 species were listed as of interest. The 10 most prominent genera included 79 species. These figures illustrate the great extent and diversity of the grasses as a group of forage plants. Forty-nine species were classified as “Grasses of the Southern Great Plains .” Thus far the recognition and designation of varieties in the perennial cultivated grass species have been of generally little significance in the United States. Most of them have been named on the basis of relatively minor differences or advantages and many have failed to become important in agricultural use. In Europe, while more varieties have been named, few have been widely grown.
2 . Certification of Seed Introduction of improved varieties of grasses, as well as of other crops, and accompanying difficulties of uncertain identification, have resulted in development and utilization of certification procedures to solve this problem. In Table I a summary is given of the variety certification of grass stocks in the United States for the 1954 crop year. Some of the species listed as the bentgrasses (Agrostis spp.) and red fescue (Pestuca rubra) are principally for turf. Sudan grass (Sorghum vulgare var. sudanense) is a large-seeded annual species with a high seed requirement in pounds per acre. On the basis of an average seeding rate of 10 pounds per acre only 2,500,000 acres could be sown with the certified perennial grass seed available in the United States. It should be recognized that the data referred to cannot be taken to include all the seed of superior varieties since uncertified seed may be in use also. It is well known, however, that unless marked practical advantage is to be derived from a particular variety, certification of it may not develop. The conclusion is reached therefore that variety in most species of
130
D. C. SMITH
TABLE I Species and Varieties of Grasses Certified in the United States in the 1954 Crop Year'
Common name Bentgrasses Bermuda Bermuda Big blue Hard fescue Crested wheatgrass Intermediate wheatgrass Kentucky bluegrass Lovegrass Mountain bromegrass Tall oatgrass Orchardgrass Prairie bromegrass Red fescue Russian wild rye English ryegrass Slender wheatgrass Smooth bromegrass Sudan Switchgrass Tall fescue Tall wheatgrass Misc. grasses Totala pounds
Species
Agrostis spp. Cynodon dactylon Cynodon dactylon Poa ampla Festuca duriuscula Agropyron cristatum, etc. Agropyron intermedium. etc. Poa pratensis Eraprostis spp. Bromus can'nalus Arrhenatherum elatius Dactylis glomerata Bromus Festuca rubra Elymus junceus Lolium perenne Agropyon trachycaulum Bromus inernis Sorghum vulgare Panicum virgatum Festuca elatior var. arundinacea Agropyron elongatum (Five species)
No. of varieties
Pounds certified
4 4 1 1 1
2,012,150 91,919,000* 6,490 4,200 55,910 57,825 987,020 697,850 1,890 205,400 24,515 99,827 66,000 2,299,950 6,900 15,974,530 6,600 684,919 15,074,%80 18,899 10,649,170 18,865 5,875 46,826,940
4
6
a 9 1 1 4 1 4 1 1 1 8 9
a 8
a
-
1 Compiled from Report of Seed Certified in 1964 by State Certifying Agencies by J. M. Saundera. U. S. Department of Agriculture. a Certified atolona. 8 Stolona not included (Bermuda graaa).
forage grasses has little practical significance. In contrast approximately 68,000,000 pounds of certified alfalfa seed were produced in 1954.
111. GENERAL REFERENCES The cytogenetics and breeding of forage crops were reviewed by Atwood (1W7). Myers (1947) prepared an extensive s u m m a r y of the cytogenetics of forage grasses. Smith, Hafenrichter and Stoez, Musser et al., and Keller presented information especially pertinent to the subject of grass breeding in the 1948 Yearbook of Agriculture entitled Grass. More recent consideration was given to this subject by Burton (1951) and Hayes et al. (1955). It should be noted that almost no information on qualitative character inheritance is available for the polyploid forage grasses. This is
131 due largely to lack of emphasis but also to difficulties arising from cytology of the species concerned. General problems of studying quantitative inheritance in grasses were reviewed by Burton (1952). PROGRESS IN GRASS BREEDING
IV.
NATURE OF VARIETIES
Among cross-pollinated field crop plants studies with corn have tended to set the pattern for improvement and an attempt has been made to adapt corn-breeding techniques to the breeding of grasses. T o date this has not been especially helpful, though general broad principles are applicable. Grasses usually have relatively small, delicate, and
FIO. I.Timothy individual plant nursery with selected individuals bagged for selfing (Wisconsin Experiment Station).
hermaphroditic flowers and manipulation of selfing and crossing is difficult. An additional consideration is that whereas corn is cross-pollinated normally, it is rather highly self-fertile. Perennial grasses are usually cross-pollinated also but they are often quite self-sterile. While inbreeding, isolation of superior plants, and subsequent crossing have been attempted in strain improvement programs (Fig. 1 ) , there has been little practical progress made as a result of this system. It is of interest to note the type of origin of some of the grass varieties which have been developed. LINCOLN, ACHENBACH, FISCHER, and HOMESTEADER smooth bromegrasses (Brornus inerrnis) are from natural selection over a long period. MARTIN was more definitely a “bred” strain, having been produced from a recombination of 21 selected plants from stock obtained from an old bromegrass field in Minnesota. ITASCA
132 D. C. SMITH timothy, also from Minnesota, was derived from an interbreeding of six highly selected inbred lines, one of which was developed from commercial stock and five of which had their origin from inbreeding Cornell strains. LYON smooth bromegrass arose from mass selection from
FIG.2. Individual plants of smooth bromegrass (Brornus inermis Leyss), illustrating the variation in vegetable and seed characters often found in cross-pollinated grasses. The two left plants have good seed character (Wisconsin Experiment Station).
two generations of plants grown in breeding nurseries. The variety LANCASTER was a result of synthesis of a strain from five selected plants whose self- and open-pollination progenies had been tested. SOUTHLAND smooth bromegrass was described by Harlan (1954) as originating from five open-pollinated lines bulked and increased.
133
PROGRESS I N GRASS BREEDING
Some grass varieties have been started by selection and subsequent increase of seed of single plants. Examples are S48, S50, PRIMUS, and GLORIA timothies; SKANDIA 11 and BRAGE orchardgrasses (Dactylis glomerata) ; VICTORIA ryegrass (Lolium perenne) ; VIKING red fescue; and BLACKWELL switchgrass (Panicum virgatum) . The variations cited in mode of origin indicate the diversity in procedure which may be followed in developing new varieties. Considerable attention has been given to the lack of uniformity in commonly grown forage crop species and varieties (Fig. 2). This was referred to previously in the discussion of the nature of grass species. TABLE I1 The Yield Performance of Various Mechanical Mixtures of Parent and Hybrid Pearl Millet Seed Planted at a Rate of 10 Pounds per Acre in 30-Inch Rows' Proportions of mechanical seed Total forage production in pounds per l6-foot row mixture Hybrid 100 90 80 50 20 0
Parent 1941 1942 1943 1944 1945 1946 Average Actual Theoretical 0 10 20 50 80 100
5% L.S.D. 1 Burton,
Relative average production
51.6 49.0 51.0 51.g
62.1 62.9 61.0 58.0 - 53.8 1 1 . 3 59.6 6.5
7.9
35.5 35.5 36.5 36.3 35.5 25.1 5.2
39.0 39.5 40.4 41.7 39.1 36.5
-
49.8 49.1 50.7 45.9 43.5 41.7
_
37.8 43.4 41.1 40.5 37.6 34.4
46.0 46.6 46.8 45.6 41.9 38.6
3.1
2.4
119.1 120.7 121.2 118.1 108.5 100.0
119.1 117.9 115.5 109.6 105.8 100.0
1947.
Most workers have agreed that uniformity is desirable only for those characters such as disease resistance or similar traits where variation would lead necessarily to inferiority. There is, however, the matter of maintaining a plant population through a period of seed propagation if, by chance, selection factors favor certain characters associated with unfavorable ones. Data provided by Burton (1947) and included in Table I1 emphasize the ability of superior types seeded en masse to dominate a forage planting. The data resulted from conducting yield trials of seed mixtures composed of a graded proportion of superior hybrid and of parental type pearl millet (Pennisetum glaucum). It may be noted that significant reductions in yield did not occw until the proportion of the hybrid strain was less than 50 per cent of the total. Similar results have been obtained with other forage plants. Although
134
D. C. SMITH
perhaps not applicable to other grasses and environmental situations, the data emphasize the importance of the vigorous component.
V. ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS The effects of natural selection on plant type have been described for many species. There is evidence also that introduced cultivated grasses such as smooth bromegrass have undergone considerable natural selection and thus types and local varieties have evolved. On the basis of observations in Turkey and other experience Harlan (1951) concluded that “No form of husbandry is too primitive or too specialized to have its effect upon the development (genetic) of crop plants.” Workers in Great Britain especially have placed emphasis on plant type and growth habit in relation to farm use. This has been partly the result of the finding in studies of pasture and hay plant populations that use and management have seemed to favor certain plant types. This may have tended to place more emphasis on persistence and longevity than on productivity and vigor. It was suggested by Julen (1947),as is well recognized in Sweden and elsewhere for several forage species, that farmers growing seed locally maintain adaptability better than when seed is grown on fewer, larger farms. It was suggested that local strains might be secured eventually by assembling and mixing all good strains and growing them as a bulk in various localities. It is of interest to note that concentration on development of a hay strain may result in a type which may also be highly superior in pasture. The production and behavior of S24 perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne) as described by Hughes (1953)is a case in point. Timothy plants occurring in New Zealand pastures were classified as “hay,” “pasture-hay,” and “pasture” types by Gorman (1950).This was primarily on the basis of vigor and growth habit. The pasture-hay type was thought best, as both the hay type and pasture type were poor in pastures. Following a study of collections of perennial ryegrass in which 41 lots from southwestern England and 49 from Ayrshire, Scotland, were compared, Gregor and Watson (1954)concluded that it was very difficult to relate a particular ecotype to a total of habitat factors. Effects of individual factors might well be considered. It was indicated that ecotype differentiation had occurred and that the ecotype should be regarded as an aggregate of cultivars. Ecologic terminology was reviewed. Cornelius (1947) found wide variations in character of 16 lots of little bluestem (Andropogon scoparius) collected from a range of latitudes in the great plains and grown at Manhattan, Kansas. Northern types were earlier in maturity, more susceptible to heat, and lower in
135 forage yields. Southern collections were more susceptible to frost and winter injury. It was concluded that adaptations of collections from various areas should be checked carefully before moving them far from the point of collection for farm use. Southern-type smooth bromegrass from central United States was found to be inferior in seed production, equal in forage yield, and superior in disease resistance to Canadian stocks in trials in prairie Canada (Knowles and White, 1949). The southern type was superior in forage yield in the drier brown soil areas. Considerable variability was noted in studies of strains of smooth bromegrass by Lebsock and Kalton (1954). Evidence was found for regional strain differentiation. In comparisons of seed sources of the LINCOLN and ACHENBACH varieties differences in hay vigor, average fall vigor, and spread exceeded the 0.01 point. Harlan (1954) suggested that yields of varieties of smooth bromegrass were stratified based upon variety origin, those from more adjacent and similar areas being more alike in performance. A specific example of the rapidity and degree of natural selection in a grass was presented by Stebbins (1949) in describing the behavior of diploid and autotetraploid Ehrharta erecta. Following mixed planting of these types at ten sites near the campus at Berkeley, California, the diploid predominated markedly in eight sites after four and one-half years, owing to reseeding. The tetraploids produced seed in only four plots. In one plot, however, the tetraploid was very predominant. This site was a strikingly different habitat, and it was concluded that this favored the tetraploid over the diploid. The results cited and the general experience of taxonomists, ecologists, and plant breeders in sampling plant populations give ample support to the conception of extensive genetic variability existing within species and varieties of grasses. PROGRESS IN GRASS BREEDING
VI. CYTOLOGY Several examples of cytological studies as indicating the nature of many grass species will be cited. In reviewing the occurrence of species hybrids in grasses Stebbins (1952) stated that 70 to 80 per cent of the grass species are polyploid and that perhaps 60 per cent had arisen at least in part as a result of hybridization. It was suggested that in developing strains of practical value parents of widely different adaptation should be crossed. I . Variability Extensive polymorphism with general conformity to principal species characters was described among 59 isolates of switchgrass from 20 locations in central United States (Nielsen, 19M). Chromosome
136 D. C . SMITH numbers ( 2 n ) found were 18, 36, 54, 72, 90, and 108. Size and shape variations were noted. Chromosome number did not appear to be associated with a particular habitat or location. Results of studies by Nordenskiold (1949) suggested that timothy may have arisen from the much less important species P . nodosum following chromosome doubling. Snyder (1951 ) considered Elymus glaucus to consist of a complex of closely related and mostly self-pollinated races. It was found that hybrids between races were usually sterile and origin through alloploidy was postulated. Stebbins (1955) suggested that the existence of numerous intersterile races in Elymus glaucus may have resulted from crosses with Sitanion jubatum and backcrossing to Elymus glaucus. Evidence concerning species variability in Agrostis was obtained by Stuckey and Banfield (1946). Chromosome numbers were determined for 45 plants in progenies, presumably Agrostis tenuis. Numbers varied from 28 to 42 with all intermediate numbers except 38 and 40. Nine open-pollination progenies appeared to be uniform A . tenuis, 5 were classified as variable, and 29 as extremely variable. Only 10 per cent of 758 progenies grown were A . tenuis and reasonably uniform. In one instance A . alba, A. tenuis, and A . palustris forms were found among descendents of one plant. Davis (1953) reported results of crossing British species of Agrostis. Hybrids between A . gigantea and A. stolonifera and A . tenuis were obtained readily and the F, plants were quite fertile. Crosses of A. gigantea with two A . canina strains were unsuccessful. Bjorkman (1954) recently reported results of extensive cytologic studies of Agrostis species. A . canina was recognized as having two varieties arida and fasicularis for which 2n chromosome numbers were found to be 28 and 14, respectively, on the basis of examination of 600 plants from a wide area of Europe. Some pentaploids were found in four populations of the arida variety. In A . stolonifera about 900 plants, chiefly from Sweden but also from elsewhere, were examined. Three chromosome number groups were found, about 600 plants having 2n of 28, 160 plants 2n of 35, and 135 plants 2n of 42 chromosomes. The pentaploids usually had 14 bivalents and were fertile. The 2n = 42 plants showed autotriploid behavior. Only two plants were aneuploid. In A . gigantea ( A . alba) 217 plants from native habitats were studied. All but two plants had 2n = 42 chromosomes, the exceptions having also supernumeraries. A . tenuis was found to have 2n = 28 chromosomes in 90 plants; others had, in addition, supernumerary chromosomes. A few trisomics were found. It was suggested that the aneuploids found by Stuckey and Banfield in A . tenuis may have been from A . alba )( A . tenuis hybrids.
PROGRESS IN GRASS BREEDING
137
2. Smooth Bromegrass Knobloch (1943) found meiosis in smooth bromegrass to be fairly normal at metaphase, though “marked irregularity” occurred at anaphase. Univalents and micronuclei were reported though multivalents were not noted. Nielsen (1947) found smooth bromegrass to follow the normal pattern in macrosporogenesis, in fertilization, and in embryo and endosperm formation. The open-pollination fertility of a polyhaploid plant of smooth bromegrass with 28 chromosomes was found by Elliott and Wilsie (1948) to be about equal to that of a normal 56-chromosome sister plant. Meiosis was also relatively normal. Chromosomal relations were not simple since both pairs and multiple associations occurred. It was suggested that both auto and allopolyploidy might be involved in the genomic origin of smooth bromegrass. Meiotic behavior in smooth bromegrass was found to be very irregular by Elliott and Love (1948). Few to many chromosome pairs and many multiple associations were noted. It was proposed that cytologic analyses should accompany breeding studies better to evaluate progeny behavior. On the basis of root-tip counts of 193 plants of smooth bromegrass Hill and Myers (1948) found 192 to have a chromosome number of 56 and one to show accessory fragments in addition. It was concluded by Nielsen (1951) that the cytology of smooth bromegrass was complex and that behavior suggested allopolyploid origin. Barnett (1955) reported chromosome counts of pollen mother cells for 18 species in four sections of the genus Bromus. With one exception diploid, tetraploid, and hexaploid species showed complete pairing or nearly so. Octoploid and decaploid species studied showed varying numbers of univalents and multivalents, with quadrivalents predominating in the latter class. It was noted that chromosome size differences seemed evident both within and among the species. This conforms to the results of Nielsen (1944) in studies of switchgrass. 3. Other Grasses
On the basis of studies of white seedling inheritance Nordenskiold (1953) concluded that the six genomes of timothy have considerable homology. Meadow fescue (Festuca elatior) and tall fescue ( P . e. arundinacea) have been considered as questionably different and closely related species. Myers and Hill (1947) found the chromosome numbers to be
138
D. C. SMITH
2n = 14 and 2n = 42, respectively. Hybrids were obtained infrequently and they were both male- and female-sterile. Bosemark (1954) reported upon cytologic studies of Festuca pratensis in which accessory chromosomes occur. Among 69 plants examined 17 had no accessories, 18 had one, 5 had four, 4 had ten, and 1 had sixteen. No pairing was noted between accessories and normal chromosomes and the accessories formed bivalents at pachytene. The number of accessory chromosomes was highly constant in various plant parts and meiotic elimination was low. In Poa irrigata, considered to be a subspecies of Kentucky bluegrass ( P . pratensis), Love (1952) found higher chromosome number of plants to be positively correlated with morphological characters of economic value and greater chromosomal number stability. In extensive studies of chromosome number in relation to polymorphism in Poa alpina Muntzing ( 1954) found no correlation between chromosome number and morphological characters. All plants in progenies having the same appearance had the same chromosome number. Plants morphologically dissimilar within progenies differed in chromosome number. Grun (1955) reported great irregularity in the cytology of seven species and subspecies of Poa investigated. Juhl (1953), after studies of aneuploidy in creeping bent (Agrostis stolonifera) ( A . palustris) and red fescue from Schleswig-Holstein, concluded that there was no relation between chromosome number and growth form or habitat. Nygren (1954) reported the results of cytological and breeding studies with North American species of Calamagrostis. C. canadensis, C. purpurascens, and C . rubescens form apomictic strains through diplospory with mitotic division. Some species intercross, although this was not noted for C. canadensis. Recent studies of Jones (1954) with Holcus mollis have emphasized further the difficulties of chromosomal determination and the probable inadequacy of available information to classify most grass species as to either chromosome number or polyploid status. Grass genera of importance to the southwestern United States were described by Harlan et al. (1952) as being cytologically complex. These were Andropogon, Bouteloua, Buchloe, Panicum, and Sorghastrum. It was considered that these genera were “currently engaged in rather intense evolutionary activity.” It is possible for polyploid types of forage grasses to maintain a high degree of irregularity in sexual and cytologic behavior and still possess a practical level of seed setting. In studies of smooth bromegrass Sorensen (1955) found that pollen germination of 50 plants ranged from 37.9 to 92.0 per cent, with an average of 68.2 per cent. Apparent normality,
139 using the stainability test with IKI and lactophenol, varied from 53.2 to 99.0 per cent, with an average of 90.6.Open-pollination seed set ranged from 20.0 to 90.0per cent, the average being 64.0.Highly sigPROGRESS IN GRASS BREEDING
nificant interannual correlations were found for these characters. Pollen germination was highly and positively correlated with pollen normality, self-fertility, and cross-fertility, though the r values were not high. VII. INTERSPECIFIC AND INTERGENERIC RELATIONS Stebbins and co-workers at the University of California have made extensive studies of species and generic relations in the grasses from the viewpoint of cytologic behavior, species variation, and intercompatibility. These investigations have served to delineate more clearly origins and taxonomic relations in Stipa, Bromus, and the Hordeae especially. A more recent example of this is the study of genomic relations in crosses between strains of Elymus and Sitanion in which considerable compatibility was found (Stebbins and Vaarama, 1953).
I . Bromus Species Elliott ( 1949a) called attention to the interbreeding (introgression) of the native and introduced species, Bromus pumpellianus and B. inerrnfs,within the range of distribution of the former. Some seed was obtained by Elliott (1949b) in paired crosses of Bromus erectus, B. inermis, and B. pumpellianus. The F, hybrids were intermediate and partly sterile. B. inermis and B. pumpellianus have 2n = 56 chromosomes and B. erectus, 2n = 70. 2. Stipa Species Following earlier studies in which intercompatibility was shown to exist in Stipa the genomic relations of three species were designated by Love (1954)as follows:
Stipa lepida 14A Stipa pulchra 14A Stipa cernua 14A
+ 3B chromosomes + 3B + 15C chromosomes + 21D chromosomes
Multiple associations in the hybrids were rare, possibly owing to small chromosomes. It was considered that the hybrids might have economic value. The genetic relations of Stipa and Oryzopsis present an interesting example of grass evolution. Johnson (1945) found that Oryzopsis hymenoides crosses readily with seven species of Stipa. 0. bloomeri was Stipa occifound to be a result of combination of 0. hyrnenoides dentalis. It was named Stiporyzopsis. Subsequently Nielsen and Rogler (1952) described an amphidiploid arising from one seed as XStipory-
x
140
D. C. SMITH
zopsis. Its progeny proved to be highly fertile, cytologically regular, and true-breeding. 3 . Festuca and Lolium Seeds were obtained by Crowder (1953) in all hybrid combinations of meadow fescue, tall fescue, perennial ryegrass, and Italian ryegrass (L. multiflorum). Not all the seeds obtained germinated and all hybrid plants were sterile. It was concluded that the genomes of Festuca and Lolium were related, though the manner was undetermined. Jenkin (1955a, b) reported results of studies of interspecific and intergeneric hybrids in Festuca and Lolium. Festuca arundinacea and F. pratensis intercrossed readily, the hybrids being highly though not entirely sterile. F. e. arundinacea and F. gigantea also crossed to produce sterile hybrids. Crosses of F. rubra X F. arundinacea resulted in weak plants. Other crosses made and for which F, plants were established were sheep fescue ( F . ovina) X F . rubra, ( F. ovina X F . rubra) X F. ovina, ( F . ovina X F . rubra) x F. rubra, and Lolium perenne x F. rubra. Successful hybrids reported by Bjorkman (1954) were Agrostis stolonifera x A . tenuis, A . stolonifera x A. gigantea, A . stolonifera x A. canina, A . tenuis x A . stolonifera, A . gigantea X A . stolonifera, and A. gigantea X A . tenuis. 4 . Elymus Species
Church (1954) reported hybrids between Elymus wieganii, E. riparius, E. virginicus, and E. canadensis. E . interruptus and E. canadensis tended to intergrade. Sterile hybrids were obtained in crosses between Elymus spp. and Hystrix patula. Boyle and Holmgren (1955) in studies of Elymus macounii and hybrids derived from crosses of slender wheatgrass (Agropyron trachycaulum) x Hordeum jubatum concluded that the latter two species had given rise to the former, as previously suggested by Stebbins and co-workers. An extensive study of the nature of seed failure following mating of Elymus virginicus X Agropyron repens was.made by Beaudry (1951). It was found that though fertilization occurred and seed development was initiated, further growth failed because of disturbed nutrition. This may be a rather frequent barrier in interspecific and intergeneric crosses. Relatively few attempts have been made to culture embryos of grass hybrids. 5. Poa Species Recombination and rearrangement of Poa genomes from contrasting species were described by Clausen (1952). Seven hundred F, hybrids
141 were obtained from 80,000 seedlings grown. Successful crosses were Poa scabrella X P . pratensis, P. ampla x P. pratensis, P . scabrella X P. ampla, and P . ampla x P. pratensis L. var. alpigena, of which approximately 700 F, plants were obtained. It was concluded that more pracPROGRESS IN GRASS BREEDING
tical improvements might be made from crossing good distantly related types. It was suggested by Juhl-Noodt (1955) that apomictic types in Poa pratensis might have a selective advantage under natural conditions. Akerberg and Bingefors (1953) reported crosses of apomictic Poa pratensis X apomictic Poa alpina and sexual P. pratensis X apomictic P . alpina. Since the apomictic parents were not entirely so, there was marked segregation in the progenies. Sexual and apomictic types were derived. 6. Triticum-Agropyron A brief review of the status of the hybridization studies of TriticumAgropyron was presented by Armstrong and White (1952). This work has been of interest to both grass and wheat breeders since 1936, and though no directly practical results have been obtained, new, potentially useful characters such as disease and insect resistance have been found. On the basis of experiences primarily with wheat )( Agropyron and Stipa interspecific crosses, Love (1947) arrived at the following conclusions with respect to the use of wide crosses. “Interspecific and intergeneric hybrids are potentially valuable in the improvement of forage crops in three ways, as follows: 1. Sterile hybrids themselves may be useful as the Stipa studies indicate. Natural cross pollination between species and ease of establishment of the hybrids is helpful. 2. The amphidiploids may be used in three ways depending on the nature of the amphidiploids.
A. Nonsegregating amphidiploids-an end in themselves. B. Hybridization of related nonsegregating amphidiploids, followed by selection. C. Selection in progeny from amphidiploids that do not breed true. 3. Fertile derivatives produced by natural crossing of the nearly sterile hybrids may or may not have the amphidiploid chromosome number, but in any event, they would be used in the same way as the segregating amphidiploids previously mentioned.” VIII. FERTILITY AND STERILITY The determination of the nature of reproduction, whether apomictic or amphimictic, and the self- and cross-fertility of a particular species
142
D. C. SMITH
is of primary importance to the establishment of a breeding procedure. Brief reference will be made to recent studies in relation to self- and cross-fertility. More inclusive studies of the nature of pollination and fertilization in grasses were made by Beddows (1931), Nilsson (1934), Smith (1944) and others. Subsequently more detailed information has been obtained for many species. A number of more prominent species were classified for self- and cross-pollination by Hayes et al. (1955). Nielsen (1952), in reviewing the cytology of forage grasses and possible relations to breeding behavior, indicated that considerable additional information was needed, especially in relation to sterility. Variation in sexual behavior of some of the important southern grasses was described by Burton (1951). Common Bahia grass (Pmpahm notatum) is apomictic while the Pensacola strain is highly or entirely sexual. According to Burton (1955) Pensacola Bahia grass set seed well in 694 of 705 mutual pollinations made between 47 clones. The existence of a diploid personate type of sterility was suggested. Dallis grass (Paspalum dilatatum) is thought to be apomictic. Coastal Bermuda grass (Cynodon dactylon) and Pangola grass (Digitaria decumbens) must be propagated vegetatively. It was found by Lowe and Murphy (1955) that smooth bromegrass plants previously selected for self-sterility varied significantly in openpollination seed set. In 30 plants examined percentage of florets setting seed varied from 2.6 to 75.8. Harlan (1945) reported facultative cleistogamy to exist in mountain brome (Bromus carinatus), an individual plant possibly producing both cleistogamous and chasmogamous panicles. Crossing and subsequent inbreeding would then result in race diversification, according to Harlan. Adams ( 1953) presented evidence to establish significant differences in cross-compatibility in smooth bromegrass, using 15 open-pollination plants as one group and 14 plants from selfing in the other. Diallel crosses, including reciprocals, were made within each group and selfand open-pollination seed set was determined. Differences in seed set were noted in reciprocal crosses. A positive and significant correlation existed between open-pollination seed set and that of the most compatible single-cross combination. It was concluded that oppositional factors might be operative in determining fertility.
IX. INBREEDING Inbreeding as an improvement and selection procedure, following the pattern of studies with corn, was undertaken early in the development of grass breeding. Wexelsen (1952) presented a review of the re-
PROGRESS IN GRASS BREEDING
143
sults of inbreeding grasses and the problems in the practical utilization of the inbreeding procedure. In view of the results available he concluded: “The justification of the use of inbreeding must be that selection can be made more effectively in inbred than non-inbred material.” Hayes and Schmid (1943) found that enough selfed seed was set in smooth bromegrass, meadow fescue, and orchardgrass to make selection in selfed lines feasible. Some inbred lines of meadow fescue and orchardgrass were as vigorous as the open-pollinated checks. Crosses of S, inbreds of smooth bromegrass grown as spaced plants yielded from 126.5 to 220.9 per cent of the check strain. In D. glomerata 49 I?, crosses yielded about the same as a check variety. Julen (Akerman et al., 1948) indicated that in the progenies of crosses of inbreds of perennial ryegrass inbreeding could be continued without marked depression in vigor. Julen (Akerman et al., 1948) wrote that 27 of 199 S, lines of timothy tested yielded more than the respective So plants. Among the 2272 S4 plants, 366 were superior to their respective So origins in green weight. Work with other grass species was cited. It was concluded that effects of inbreeding depended upon the species concerned but that generally lines could be obtained which would be practically useful in crossing to obtain superior strains. Wilsie et al. (1952) found that there was little reduction in selffertility of smooth bromegrass following two generations of selfing in studies of 25 plants. Lines varied considerably in their fertility response. Thus far in the breeding of perennial forage grasses the effects and probable value of inbreeding as a procedure to obtain improvement have not been fully determined. Myers and Hill (1943) found that inbreeding in orchardgrass resulted in more extensive meiotic irregularity, although heritable differences existed among inbred plants and progenies. However, fertility might be improved by selection during inbreeding. Zimmerman (1954) indicated that inbreeding and subsequent crossing appeared to be promising in grass improvement, on the basis of results obtained in Germany with tall oatgrass (Arrhenatherurn elatius) and orchardgrass. The results presented indicate that selfed seed may be obtained in some species and that inbred lines can be established.
X. COMBINING ABILITY 1 . Parent-Progeny Relations Johnson (1952) reviewed problems and methods for evaluating breeding material for combining ability. A very good review of per-
144
D. C . SMITH
tinent literature was included. It was considered that “The most critical need in forage breeding is additional information on the relationships between general combining ability and yields of synthetic varieties.” Tsiang (1944) studied the relationships of clonal lines and their first-generation self progenies in smooth bromegrass. The correlation coefficients obtained for several characters are indicated in Table 111. TABLE I11 Relationship between Characters of Parental Clonal Lines and Their One-Year-Selfed Progenies of Parkland and Creeping Smooth Bromegrass as Indicated by Correlation Coefficients’ ~~~~
~
~~
Parkland Character studied
No. of lines
r
22
0.472 0.7a3
Plant height
10
Basal diameter
22 10 22
10 2%
Degree of leafiness Degree of culmage
10 22 10
2%
Leaf width Heat and drought resistance
8
2% 1
9
*
No. of lines
r
20 20
0.06 0.68a
20
0.29
20
0.452
20
0.30
20
0.0
-
Hay yield
Vigor of recovery
Creeping
0.40 0.03 0.693 0.04 0.452 0.32 0.38 -0.06 -0.28 0.94s
-
-
20
0.32
0.20
Taiang, 1944. Exceeds the 6 % level of significance. Exceeds the 1 % level of significance.
Except for leaf width and plant height the values obtained are not large and leave a considerable part of the variation shown to nonheritable causes. Weiss et al. (1951)in studies with orchardgrass obtained no correlation between clonal yield and that of the open-pollination progenies. A low r value was observed between yields of single crosses and the averages of the parent clones. Though the relation was variable, singlecross yields were correlated with those of the average of the openpollination progenies of the parent clones. Hawk and Wilsie (1952)found a positive correlation between the yields of open-pollination progenies of smooth bromegrass and those of
145
PROGRESS IN GRASS B R E E D I N G
their parental clones. Other progeny relations are indicated in Table IV. While the values are not consistently high, they may be as expected when environmental influences are active. Wilsie et al. (1952) found no significant relation between self-fertility and general combining ability in smooth bromegrass. Results of extensive observations of progenies from self- and mutual-pollination of smooth bromegrass at Madison, Wisconsin, have shown no relation of self- or mutual-pollination fertility to vigor of progeny. Average TABLE IV Regression Coefficients and Correlation Coefficients Showing Offspring-Parent Yield Relationships in Smooth Bromegrass' Regression coefficient2
Correlation coefficient2
0.30 0.33
0.28
So O.P. progeny on So clones S1 O.P. progeny on So clones SZ O.P. progeny on So clones
0.22 0.07 0.05
0.33 0 . 12
SI O.P. progeny on SI clones SOO.P. progeny on S1 clones SZO.P. progeny on Sz clones
0.25 0.19 0.34
0 .5 1 0.24 0.55
S1 O.P. progeny on SOO.P. progeny SZ O.P. progeny on SI O.P. progeny
0.48 0.79
0.49
Relationship Regression of: SI clones on SOclones S2 clones on S1 clones
1 2
0.26
0.06
0.56
Hawk and Wilsie, 1959. Significance not indicated.
vigor and coefficients of variability within progenies have been negatively correlated. Kneebone (1951) compared the performances of eight selected plants of smooth bromegrass with those of their polycross progenies for forage quality and other characters. It was concluded that progress might be made in breeding for higher protein content by selecting plants on the basis of their polycross performances. While not highly heritable in the studies made it was suggested that selection for leaf percentage should aid in raising protein percentage. Problems in determining breeding behavior using different types of progenies were reviewed by Murphy ( 1952). Results of tests of progenies of orchardgrass, smooth bromegrass, and red fescue were cited. Clonal replications of the parents, self seedlings, and polycross progenies were
146
D. C. SMITH
compared. Clonal differences were highly significant in all tests using space-planted rows and were higher than the clone x progeny interaction. When parental clonal plantings and polycross drilled rows were studied, differences of progenies from clones were significant in 17 of 19 trials. The performances of the parent clones were positively correlated with progeny behavior whether space-planted in rows, drilled in rows, or broadcast seeded. A summary of the correlations found in TABLE V Average Simple Correlation Coefficients Calculated from 19 Tests for Three Grass Species and the Range for Each' Correlation coefficient2 Characters correlated Same progeny and different method of planting Spaced vegetative vs. drilled vegetative Spaced polycross vs. drilled polycross Spaced polycross vs. broadcast polycross Drilled polycross vs. broadcast polycross Different progeny and same method of planting Spaced vegetative vs. spaced polycross Spaced vegetative vs. spaced self Drilled vegetative vs. drilled polycross Spaced polycross vs. spaced self Different progeny and different methods of planting Spaced vegetative vs. drilled polycross Spaced vegetative vs. broadcast polycross Spaced self vs. drilled vegetative Spaced self vs. drilled polycross Spaced self vs. broadcast polycross Spaced polycross vs. drilled vegetative Drilled vegetative vs. broadcast polycross 1 Murphy,
Average
Range
0.878 0.766 0.473
0.50 t o 0 . 9 8 -0.01 to0.08
-0.93toO.96
0.607
-0.63 to 0.89
0.739 0.781 0.784 0.698
-0.11 toO.96 -0.aato0.99 0.36toO.99 -0.81to0.93
0.603
-0.a2to0.96
0.496 .O .688
-0.40 to 0.93
0.6%9 0.556
0.693 0.548
-0.85t00.99 -0.03t00.84 -0.81to0.98 -0.61t00.99 -0.50 to 0.91
196%
All the average correlation coefficients are highly significant.
the experiments is given in Table V. It was concluded that selection of parents on the basis of progeny behavior should be effective. Heritability for yield was fair in intermediate wheatgrass according to Heinrichs (1953). It was suggested that possibilities of mass selection might be good if heritability reached reasonable levels for particular characters. Heritability for forage yield in smooth bromegrass as determined by Thomas and Kernkamp (1954), for 50 selected clones and their polycross progenies, varied from 0 to 31 per cent in tests at four locations. Heritability for protein content ranged from 1 to 25 per cent. Fertility evaluations as related to clonal performance and com-
PROGRESS IN GRASS BREEDING
147
bining ability in orchardgrass were studied by Leffel et al. (1954). Little association was found between self-fertility and panicle production, blooming date, or forage or seed production of parent clones. Selffertility was not related to combining ability of parent clones in singlecross, top-cross, or polycross tests for panicle production, green weight, or blooming date. Oldemeyer and Hanson (1955) studied combining ability in orchardgrass using seven early- and five late-maturing plants. A wide polycross of 112 clones, restricted polycrosses of 5 and 7 clone combinations, single crosses, and tiller plots of parent plants were utilized. Polycross and single-cross progeny yields were correlated. There was evidence for specific combining ability in single-cross differences. Parent-progeny reactions to leaf diseases were highly correlated. Following studies of specific and general combining ability of 11 noninbred plants of orchardgrass it was concluded by Kalton and Leffel (1955) that differences in general combining ability were more prominent than those for specific combining ability. Early spring vigor, leaf disease reaction, panicle production per unit area, and forage yield were the characters studied. In such material determination of general combining ability appeared to be most useful in development of superior synthetics, with the expectation that yield decline in successive generations would be less. Difficulties in extensive testing of selected plants in single crosses were also indicated. Combining ability in orchardgrass was found to be about equally well determined by average single-cross, polycross, or top-cross tests. The use of the top-cross was favored, advantages being fewer replications required, less effect of differences in blooming dates, smaller effects due to nonrandom mating, and ability to space plants more widely. A plan for top-cross testing was outlined (Kalton et al., 1955). Knowles (1955) in studies of smooth bromegrass found an r of 0.79 between forage yields of open-pollination selections and average yields of three test crosses of the same selections. Seed from open-pollination of replicate clones in different nursery positions resulted in progenies with rather similar forage yields. 2. Interpollination Using homozygous recessives for anthocyanin coloration Griffiths (1950) studied the relation of distance to pollen movement in perennial ryegrass. The rate of pollen dispersion decreased rapidly from 0 to 20 feet and more slowly beyond this distance. In a study of perennial ryegrass using a simple dominant character, roughness vs. smoothness of culm and upper leaf sheath, Wit (1952) determined amount of cross-pollination. Percentages of cross-
148
D. C . SMITH
pollination decreased rapidly at distances of 48 to 64 inches and subsequently decreased more slowly. It was concluded that adequately replicated polycross plantings of plants flowering about the same time were required for homogeneous pollination as desired in a polycross test. The author did not indicate what replication might be adequate, though in other studies ten replications had been used. Interreplicate progeny variation was studied by Hittle (1954) as a measure of the efficiency of the polycross test in smooth bromegrass. Twenty plants studied were replicated ten times and progenies were space-planted. Height, hay vigor, spread, hay weight, aftermath weight, and brown spot (Pyrenophora brorni) reaction were studied. Results indicated that significant differences in progeny behavior occurred among clonal replicates of individual plants, owing to heterogeneity in the pollen source.
3 . Statistical Approach Statistical aspects of determining parent-progeny relations and of minimizing environmental effects for selection purposes were reviewed and procedures suggested by Comstock and Robinson (1952). Information indicated by the authors as being most critical and generally obtainable in the breeding program included: I. Estimates of genotypic covariances, particularly those involving seed production. 2. Unbiased estimates of genotypic variances. 3. Estimates of variance from interactions of genotype with location. 4 . General It was concluded by Johnson (1952) that “The data available to date on forage crop breeding show that testing outcross progenies derived from seed produced either in polycross blocks, by open-pollination in breeding nurseries, or in top-cross blocks provides a useful means of screening non-inbred plants and inbred lines for subsequent study in more detailed tests.” Frandsen (1952) indicated that the polycross test had been effective in Denmark in breeding of grasses, though in some instances 20 replications have been used. Evaluation of spaced plants, determination of what characters to test, and lack of sufficient information for quantitative characters were indicated as special problems. Schaepman (1952) elaborated upon the use of the polycross test in grass breeding. Frandsen (1952) outlined systems of breeding cross-fertilized forage plants in such a manner as to indicate clearly the alternatives in selection and utilization of superior plants. His outline is as follows:
PROGRESS IN GRASS BREEDING
149
Selection of Individuals I. Breeding by deliberate selection of individuals. A . Selection of individuals without progeny test (mass se1.e~tion). B. Selection of individuals based on progeny test (family breeding often combined with mass selection). I . Testing of mother plants. a. After free-pollination (male parents unknown, comparison on u n e q u a 1 basis) b. After top-cross (male parents known, comparison on equal basis) c. After polycross (male parents known, comparison on equal basis) (male parents known, comd. After diallel cross parison on equal basis) 2. Testing of plant pairs. (after controlled crossing, male parents known, comparison on unequal basis) 11. Breeding by natural selection. A. Breeding for improved adaptation by testing local varieties in different places. B. Resistance breeding. 1. By natural infection (frost or other natural influence). 2. By artificial infection (freezing or other artificial influence). Strain Building I. Strain building on the basis of one or more families (lines) multiplied in mixture (synthetics). Market seed later generations than F,. 11. Strain building by crossing for the production of F, market seed. Multiplication of two or more families (lines) separately, by inbreeding and outbreeding. XI. CROSSING TECHNIQUES Crossing techniques with smooth bromegrass were described by Keller (1944). Emasculation and pollination techniques useful in the breeding of perennial cross-pollinated grasses were described by Keller (1952). Efforts have been made to obtain hybrid seed by interpollination of two plants in single-cross combinations. I n such instances mutual pollination or bagging of inflorescences together during the flowering
150 D. C. SMITH period has been practiced as well as paired isolations in the field. Bag switching (Keller, 1952) has been used also. Seed set using such techniques usually has been poor or fair only. Results with smooth bromegrass (unpublished) at Madison, Wisconsin, have indicated that small amounts of seed, sufficient for spaced plant progenies, may be expected from mutual pollination. In field and greenhouse crosses with intermediate wheatgrass (Agropyron intermedium) Heinrichs (1953) obtained 14.0 and 27.3 per cent seed set as compared with open-pollination.
XII. HYBRID VARIETIES Reference was made in Section X,1, to the need for information on synthetic varieties. It is generally accepted that selected plants will be used in initial hybrid combinations by free interpollination and that in succeeding generations of increase the variety would become synthesized and stabilized at an approximate level of behavior, depending upon conditions of culture. Graumann (1952) indicated the need for more information on late generations of synthetic varieties. Synthetic generation data including Syn 4 were cited for alfalfa. Comparisons of 5 two-clone synthetics and 14 multiple-clone synthetics grown for forage resulted in yields of 114, 102, 103, and 103 per cent of the check variety, respectively, for each of the four years based upon two second-year cuttings. Comparable yields for the multiple-clone combination were 110, 109, 105, and 104 per cent. On the basis of the available data it was concluded that 1. Two-clone combinations are more productive than multiple-clone in the first synthetic generation. 2. Forage yields decline with the advance in seed generation, the rate of change during early generations being inversely proportional to the number of parental clones comprising the synthetic. 3. Synthesis appears to be completed by the third or fourth seed generation. 4 . Upon completion of synthesis there is little or no difference in forage yield between the two-clone and multiple-clone combinations. Inclusion of the varying numbers of clones from four to ten in synthetic combinations of orchardgrass did not appear to influence significantly the performances of the recombinations in the Syn 1 or S y n 2 generations (Weiss et al., 1951) . Several first-generation synthetic strains developed by Knowles (1955) on the basis of selection for open-pollination progeny performance produced significantly higher forage and seed yields than commercial check varieties.
PROGRESS IN GRASS BREEDING
151
Results of testing synthetics of bromegrass and timothy at the New York (Cornell) Experiment Station have shown some to be superior in yield to better check varieties. Other workers are utilizing synthetic combinations.
XIII. AGRONOMIC ASPECTS One of the most difficult aspects of grass breeding is the determination of the comparative value of plants and strains in such a manner as to correlate with probable behavior under farm conditions. Burton (1951) and Kramer (1952) presented very good reviews and illustrations of the problems involved. A few selected examples will be cited to illustrate cultural and physiologic studies pertinent to determining plant behavior. Lebsock and Kalton (1954) reported a good agreement to exist in smooth bromegrass between plant performance in spaced-plant nurseries and that in solid stands simulating field conditions. There has been considerable speculation in this matter by breeders and others and few critical studies are available. One of the few reported tests of drought resistance determined artificially was made by Carroll (1943). Twelve pasture grasses were grown as sods in earthenware jars. Half of the samples were “hardened” by exposure to a temperature of 35O to 37O C. for 5 hours on 3 successive days. The relative humidity was 20 per cent during hardening. No watering was done during hardening. Samples were then subjected to 12-, 18-, and 24-hour periods with temperature and humidity as previously. After exposure plants were placed in the greenhouse and watered periodically. Wide differences in species response occurred. It was noted that hardening was helpful in enabling the plants to withstand the drought. In studies with orchardgrass Keller (1954) compared two genotypes previously selected for high and low water requirement, in greenhouse culture varying water, nitrogen, mulch, and depth of container. The yield results indicated that the genotypes varied significantly in yielding ability under the treatments given and interactions of genotypes with water levels and mulches were significant also. It was considered that the best technique on the basis of results obtained would be the use of deep cans (those used were 7 inches in diameter and 20 inches deep), high nitrogen level, and low water level. Differences of timothy seedlings within a variety in ability to resist drought under controlled moisture conditions were observed by Williams (1954). Atwood and MacDonald (1946) studied the heat resistance of individual plants of smooth bromegrass grown under greenhouse conditions. Thirty clones were grown seven weeks at 70°F.,
152
D. C. SMITH
then cut for hay. The temperature was then raised to 80° F. and two crops were taken, after which the temperature was raised to 85O F. and one harvest made. Highly significant differences were observed among plants at the several harvest periods. The use of photoperiod and low temperature as aids in rapid selection and progeny testing was proposed by Cooper (1954). Growth response and behavior and ecological classification would be observed. Genotype-environment interactions in perennial ryegrass were studied by Fejer (1955) using spaced plants in the field. Significant interactions were obtained between frequency of cutting, fertility level, and genotype. In more precise studies of temperature and light effects on selected clones it was found that high temperature increased tiller weight and decreased tiller number. Light effects were less obvious owing possibly to the fact as shown by others that “under certain conditions while light intensity increases tiller number and average tiller weight, high temperature decreases tiller number and increases tiller weight.” A reference was made to unpublished work of Corkill in New Zealand, where significant interactions were found in clonal material of perennial ryegrass at three New Zealand stations at different latitudes. Fejer emphasized also the importance of knowing the relation of nursery spaced plant behavior to that under pasture conditions. Owen (1951) has shown that selection for seed production can be highly effective as evidenced in results with Dallis grass. Variation among strains and plants of smooth bromegrass for seed quality and vigor was studied by Tossell ( 1952). Sixteen varieties, ten polycross progenies, and one hundred open-pollination plants were included. Significant differences were found in all groups for seed weight, rate of emergence, and seedling height and vigor. While vigor and seed weight were associated, significant differences were found among lots of equal seed weight. Among seven adult plant characters recorded only seed yield per plant was correlated with rate of emergence and seedling stand, height, and vigor. It is of interest to note that since Harvey (1939) reported differential responses of corn inbreds and hybrids to ammonia and nitrate nitrogen, little if any additional information is available in this respect for forage plants. XIV. DISEASERESISTANCE Although good general correlations may exist between observations for disease reactions in the field from one season to another, efficiency in screening for disease resistance requires that more certain measures be used. Dependence on natural occurrence of pathogenic organisms in
153
PROGRESS IN GRASS BREEDING
relation to favorable climatic conditions for development of epiphytotics is often impracticable. An example of a favorable interseasonal result of observation for reaction to Pyrenophora bromi on smooth bromegrass is shown in Table VI. Though a good correlation (uncalculated) may exist between the data for the two years, it should be noted that unless few plants are highly susceptible the frequencies of such plants suggest doubt as to whether disease intensity was sufficient for certain classification. Tests for reaction to leaf diseases of smooth bromegrass were made by Carter and Dickson (1952) using 10 plants previously classified as resistant and 10 as susceptible under field conditions. These plants were TABLE VI Reaction' of Smooth Bromegrass (Bromus inermis) Plants to Brown Leaf Spot (Pyrenophora bromi) in the Second and Third Years of Growth at Madison, Wisconsin Second-year reaction 2 3 4 5 Totals: 0
1
Third-year reaction
2
203
3
19 4
4 134
76
30
14
-
1737
' 0 = no disease, 1 = resistant, 6 = highly susceptible.
transferred to a clonal block in the field and artificially inoculated with Pyrenophora bromi in two successive years. The results are presented in Table VII. Although there is some irregularity in the data, the correlation coefficient for the October 1948 and October 1949 results was 0.95. Comparable results were obtained following inoculations in the field with Pseudomonas coronafaciens var. atropurpurea, the bacterial blight organism. However the correlation coefficient for results between years was 0.76, which was highly significant. Results of artificial inoculation trials verified the previous classifications made without artificial inoculation in the field, in most instances. Attempts have been made at Madison, Wisconsin, since 1941 to select plants of smooth bromegrass for resistance to bacterial blight and other diseases. Studies by Fang et al. (1950) concerning the nature of the organism and its hosts illustrate a type of investigation which is
154
D. C. SMITH
helpful to the breeder. Cultures were made from barley, wheat, rye, bromegrass, quackgrass, timothy, and Sudan grass. In artificial inoculations five special forms were differentiated, though cultures from different hosts were partially cross-pathogenic.The five forms arranged themselves into four serological types based upon cross agglutination and agglutinin absorption tests. XV. NUTRITIVE VALUE
Summaries of known available literature on breeding for quality in forage plants were given by Sullivan and Garber (1947) and Smith (1952). Recent pertinent studies will be referred to briefly. TABLE VII Disease Indices' for Lines of Smooth Bromegrass Inoculated with Pyrenophora bromi in the Field' Resistant clones
Susceptible clones
No.
19488
1
5.3 2.6 2.0 5.4 2.4 1.8 2.8 1.8
2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Mean
2.8
2.5 3.0
194Q4 6.8 5.7 5.0 4.9 4.3 5.8 5.4 4.0 4.0 4.3 4.8
6.8 5.3 3.9 4.2 2.9 3.3 4.2 3.5 4.0 3.5 4.2
Mean
No.
19486
6.8 5.3 3.9 4.2 2.9 3.3 4.2 3.5 4.0 3.5 4.2
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
1.0 1.0 1.3 1.1 1.1
20
Mean
1.2
1.0 1.2 1.0 1.1 1.1
1949' 1.0 1.9 3.3 2.3 1.8 2.0 1.7 3.0 1.9 2.3 2.2
1.8 1.3 2.6 1.8 1.3 1.6 1.2 2.0 1.4 1.7 1.6
Mean 1.4 1.4 2.4 1.7 1.4 1.6 1.5 2.1 1.4 1.7
f Average of 1% observations. *Carter and Dickson, 1960. 8 Data obtained Oct. 9. 4 Data obtained July 8 and October 14.
Levels of protein and carotene content were determined by Pickett (1950) among unrelated first-generation inbred families of smooth bromegrass. Highly significant differences between and within families for protein and carotene content were found for each of the two seasons in which studies were made. Exemplary data are shown in Tables VIII and IX. There was a high correlation between years for individual plants. Carotene and protein content were positively correlated and darker green color accompanied higher protein analysis. Protein content was found to be negatively associated with yield in intermediate wheatgrass in studies by Heinrichs (1953). Phillips et al. (1954) found that some early-maturing species were
155
PROGRESS I N GRASS BREEDING
higher in protein than late-maturing ones when harvested at the same growth stage. Sullivan and Routley (1955) determined that early and late plants of orchardgrass varied in percentage of protein, early types being favored. No significant differences were found in timothy or Reed canary grass (Phalaris arundinacea) when comparisons were made similarly. TABLE VIII Analyses of Carotene Contents of Inbred Families of Smooth Bromegrass Harvested at the Early-Pasture Stage of the Third Year of Growth* * Inbred family
Carotene content, family mean in p.p.m.
4 7 20 30
Between plants F value 6.51* 13.95** 3.39 17.126**
203 133
164 340
1 Pickett, 1860. *Exceeds the 0.06 level of significance. Exceeds the 0.01 level of significance.
**
TABLE IX Analyses of Crude Protein Contents of Selected Inbred Families of Smooth Bromegrass Harvested at the Early-Pasture Stage of the Second Year of Growth'
1
Jnbred family
Range of clonal means, %
Family means, %
F value between plants
4 11 15 20 25
49.04-38.1212 !25.80-30.73 46.4S129.44 31.74-36.00 98.82-35.37
31.53 28.SO 127.80 33.97 31.47
10.912** 9.04** 2.07 4.20* !22.89**
Pickett, 1950.
* Exceeds the 0.06 level of significance.
** Exceeds the 0.01 level of significance. An illustration of the striking differences present in palatability of grass strains was reported by Burton (1947), following studies of Bermuda grass strains. Nine strains were planted clonally in duplicate plots 30 X 60 feet in size and subsequently were grazed by Jersey cattle. The results are shown in Table X. The differences in palatability were not associated with several chemical characters studied or with observable morphological differences of the strains in question. Unpublished work was cited by Burton (1951) indicating almost a 100 per cent increase in cattle weight gains when pastured on Pensacola as compared with Paraguay Bahia grass, although yields and chemical
156
D. C. SMITH TABLE X The Comparative Palatability of Nine Strains of Bermuda Grass Grown in Duplicate Pasture Plots'
Strains Common Coastal 3 1s 36 60 85 99 107 1
Average percentage of the total cow hours spent on each strain in two years 9.1 14.9 13.8 14.1 7.8 6.8 8.1 14.3 11.0
Rating August 14 on the amount of grass left after a period of continuous grazing2 Rep. 1
Rep. 2
Avg.
5.0 1.o 4.5 1.0 3.5 5.0 3.0
5.0 1.5 5.0 1.0 4.0 5.0 3.0 e.0 4.0
5.0 1.3 4.8 1.0 3.8 5.0 3.0
2.0 3.5
2.0 3.8
Burton, 1947. Plots rated 1 were grazed closely; those rated 6 were grazed very little.
analyses were quite similar. The difference was ascribed to differential palatability. MAINTENANCE XVI. VARIETY The effects of region of seed production on performance of RANGER alfalfa are of interest in relation to forage variety adaptation. Variations in seed lots of the RANGER variety were first noted at Madison, Wisconsin, in 1945. When plants in the field were cut in early September Smith and Graber (1950) noted variations in proportions of tallgrowing plants in the later fall, this being related to latitudinal location of parental seed production. Subsequent studies by Smith (1955) showed that RANGER alfalfa grown for one generation of increase in southern latitudes showed more tall plants following early fall cutting than identical seed stocks grown comparably in a northern latitude. Tall plants were found to be less winter-hardy. It was suggested that environmental influences, perhaps associated with latitude, were having a selective effect upon seed production of various plant types within the RANGER variety. Beard and Hollowell (1952) discussed the effect on performance, of growing seed of forage varieties outside of the area of adaptation. This has been an especially serious problem with red clover and alfalfa, as previously illustrated. Although there is little information as to the effects on grass varieties so grown, it seems probable that changes may occur that are not always favorable. The reasons given for producing
157
PROGRESS IN GRASS BREEDING
seed in distant areas are more rapid and dependable seed production and more certain control of supply because of relatively sure production. In production of seed outside of the area of adaptation a program has been developed on a state and national basis to safeguard varietal characteristics and to increase efficiency in getting superior varieties into use. Preservation of varietal identity includes emphasis on the following points as listed by Beard and Hollowell. TABLE XI Frequency Distributions of Yields of Different Lots of Tennessee AnthracnoseResistant Red Clover Seed Grown in Oregon for Different Generations When Tested at Three Locations in the East Central States, 1928-1938' Lots in each yield class of Tennessee anthracnose-resistant seed grown in Oregon for indicated generations Yield class per cent2
1
110-100 100-90 90-80 80-70
1 3
6
6
3 4
9
1
1
1
1 1
1
1
1
3 3 1 3 9
9
4
3
3
3
8
4
Total lots Lots yielding significantly less than check at 5 % level 1
3
4
4 4
3 4
7 3
1 1
70-60
60-50
3
1
3
9
9
Beard and Hollowell, 1953.
' Forage yields of Tennessee Anthracnose-resistant seed grown in Tennessee equals 100 per cent. 1. Periodic return to foundation stock seed of a variety for establishing new seed production fields outside the area of its adaptation for forage to minimize genetic changes that may occur in successive seed generations. 2. Effect of cross-pollination from adjacent fields of other varieties. 3. Disappearance of plants with increasing age of stand. 4. Control of volunteer stands arising from shattered seed. 5. Availability of production fields free from old plants of other varieties. 6. Differential seed-producing capacity of plants within the variety. It should be noted also that research in determining effects of environment on varietal changes has been in progress. In this respect * notesome of the results with red clover are of interest (Table XI). It is worthy that seed lots grown in Oregon for successive generations de-
158 D. C. SMITH teriorated progressively when tested in Tennessee in comparison with locally grown seed. XVII. DISCUSSION Many fruitful areas in grass breeding remain to be more adequately explored. Although the tempo of investigations has been greatly accelerated in recent years, progress in solving technical problems has been necessarily slow. The large number and diversity of perennial forage grasses has resulted in extended scope and reduced intensity of research effort. Technically, appreciable progress has been made. Efforts have been increased to obtain and evaluate both exotic and endemic strains of grasses. Much remains to be learned of cytotaxonomy and the relations of species and genera in hybridization. The value and importance of induced polyploidy in forage plant breeding were reviewed by Love (1952). It was considered that the principal advance in polyploidy knowledge of the previous decade had been “clarification of types of polyploids.” Induction of somatic reduction and segregation was mentioned as a possible new approach to increasing variability. Hybrids otherwise unavailable may be obtained and propagated by embryo cultural methods. The possibilities of using radiation for induction of mutational and other changes in forage grasses are relatively unexplored. Results in Sweden of studies by Julen (1954) are of interest in this respect. In X-ray treatment of dry seeds of Kentucky bluegrass the percentages of aberrant plants were increased from 2.0 in the control to 14.1 when irradiated with 20,000 to 25,000 r units. Some of the aberrants were chimeral. Affected sectors could be cloned and propagated. Most of the new types were smaller than normal plants and only one appeared to be equal to the parent clone in vigor. Chimera frequencies were increased from 0.1 per cent in the control to 8.3 per cent in that given 20,000 to 25,000 r units. The X-ray treatments did not affect chromosome number and effect of treatment was not related to chromosome number. Though related in principle to those for corn, grass breeding methods are being subjected to exploration and modification. The practical value of inbreeding remains unestablished. Recent studies with corn by Robinson et al. (1955) are of interest. Genetic variances were determined for eight quantitative characters in three open-pollinated varieties of corn. Additive genetic variance was found to be surprisingly high in proportion to dominance variance. The writers suggested that selection in such populations should be effective, contrary to the general experience of corn breeders. This may have some application to selection in grasses.
PROGRESS I N GRASS BREEDING
159
Combining ability has received much attention during the past decade. The polycross and other types of parent-progeny tests have been used as a basis of selection, for yield particularly. In writing of methods of evaluating breeding behavior of forage plants Murphy (1952) stated “It seems that at an advanced stage in the breeding program, the differences among the parents in yield of forage become of less practical significance and that the final selection of the parents for inclusion in an experimental variety will be determined primarily by such characteristics as disease resistance, insect resistance, quality, maturity, growth habit and others.” Available experimental data indicate that differences among grass varieties in forage production and quality may be small, particularly when the grasses are grown with legumes. This has held for such important species as timothy, smooth bromegrass, and orchardgrass. It would appear, however, that yield of forage will continue to receive prominent consideration. Estimation of heritability for such characters may be helpful. Recombination of selected plants or lines to constitute synthetic varieties has been based upon insufficient information and experience. Additional data are needed concerning genetic stability and modification of synthetic variety behavior under different conditions of propagation in successive generations. Effects of area and manner of seed production in relation to forage character are of interest similarly. The relatively few investigations reported in the literature concerning chemical analysis have been relatively encouraging to the possibility of improvement of nutritive value. Little has been done on the latter aspect. Results of disease and insect resistance studies of forage grasses have suggested that major improvements may be made in varietal composition, particularly in the former case. Little is known concerning insect resistance. Agronomic problems are numerous and involve ecology, physiology, plant nutrition, and other aspects. Future improvements in strains of grasses may depend to a large degree on the development of more highly correlated results of early nursery or greenhouse trials and behavior under farm conditions. REFERENCES Adam, M. W.1953. Botan. Gaz. 1 15,95-105. Akerberg, E., and Bingefors, S. 1953. Hereditas 39, 125-136. Akerman, A., Tedin, O., Froier, K., and Whyte, R. 0.1948. “Svalof 1886-1946.” Bloms Boktryckeri A-B, Lund. Armstrong, J. M., and White, W. J. 1952. Proc. 6th Intern. Grasslands Congr. 1, 222-227. Atwood, S . S. 1947. Advances in Genet. 1 , 1-67.
160
D. C . SMITH
Atwood, S. S., and MacDonald, H. A. 1946. J. Am. SOC.Agron. 38, 824-832. Barnett, F. L. 1955. Agron. J. 47. 88-91. Beard, D. F., and Hollowell, E. A. 1952. Proc. 6th Intern. Grasslands Congr. 1, 860-866. Beaudry, J. R. 1951. Genetics 36, 109-133. Beddows, A. B. 1931. Welsh Plant Breeding Sta. Bull. Ser. H. No. 12, 5-99. Bjorkman, S. 0. 1954. Hereditas 40, 254-258. Bosemark, N. 0. 1954. Hereditas 40, 347-376. Boyle, W. S., and Holmgren, A. H. 1955. Genetics 40, 539-545. Burton, G. W. 1947. I . Am. SOC.Agron. 39,551-569. Burton, G. W. 1951. Aduances in Agron. 3, 197-241. Burton, G. W. 1952. Proc. 6th Intern. Grasslands Congr. 1,277-283. Burton, G. W. 1955. Agron. J . 47, 311-313. Carroll, J. C. 1943. I . Am. SOC.Agron. 35, 77-79. Carter, J. F., and Dickson, J. G. 1952. Agron. J . 44, 119-125. Church, G. L. 1954. Rhodora 56, 185-197. Clausen, J. 1952. Proc. 6th Intern. Grasslands Congr. 1, 216-221. Comstock, R. E., and Robinson, H. F. 1952. Proc. 6th Intern. Grasslands Congr. 1, 284-29 1. Cooper, J. P. 1954. Repts. and Communs. 8th Intern. Botan. Congr. pp. 356359. Cornelius, D. R. 1947. J. Agr. Research 74, 133-143. Crowder, L. V. 1953.1. Heredity 44, 195-203. Dale, T., and Brown, G. F. 1955. U . S. Dept. Agr. Farmers Bull. No. 2080. Davis, W. E. 1953. British Agr. Bull. 5, 313-315. Elliott, F. C. 1949a. Euolution 3, 142-149. Elliott, F. C. 1949b. Agron. J . 41, 298-303. Elliott, F. C., and Love, R. M. 1948. J . Am. SOC.Agron. 40, 335-341. Elliott, F. C., and Wilsie, C. P. 1948. J. Heredity 39, 376-380. Fang, C. T., Allen, 0. N., Riker, A. J., and Dickson, J. G. 1950. Phytopathology 40, 44-64. Fejer, S. 0. 1955. Nature 175, 944-945. Frandsen, K. J. 1952. Proc. 6th Intern. Grasslands Congr. 1, 306313. Gorman, L. W. 1950. N e w Zealand I . Sci. and Technol. 32, 1-15. Graumann, H. 0. 1952. Proc. 6th Intern. Grasslands Congr. 1, 314-319. Gregor, J. W., and Watson, P. J. 1954. N e w Phytologist 53, 291-300. Griffiths, D. J. 1950. I . Agr. Sci. 40, 19-38. Griin, P. 1955. Am. J. Botany 42, 11-18. Hafenrichter, A. L., and Stoez, A. D. 1948. U.S. Dept. Agr. Yearbook, pp. 354-356. Harlan, J. R. 1945. Am. J . Botany 32, 66-72. Harlan, J. R. 1951. Am. Naturalist 85, 97-103. Harlan, J. R. 1954. Oklahoma Agr. Expt. Sta. Bull. No. 0444. Harlan, J. R., Snyder, L. A., and Celarier, R. P. 1952. Proc. 6th Intern. Grasslands Congr. 1, 228-232. Harvey, P. H. 1939. Genetics 24,437461. Hawk, V . B., and Wilsie, C. P. 1952. Agron. J . 44, 112-118. Hayes, H. K., and Schmid, A. R. 1943. J. Am. SOC.Agron. 35, 934-943. Hayes, H. K., Immer, F. R., and Smith, D. C. 1955. “Methods of Plant Breeding,” pp. 347-391. McGraw-Hill, New York. Heinrichs, D. H. 1953. Can. J. Agr. Sci. 33, 470493. Hill, H. D., and Myers, W. M. 1948. J. Am. Soc. Agron. 40,466469. Hittle, C. N. 1954. Agron. J. 46, 521-523.
PROGRESS IN GRASS BREEDING
161
Hoover, M. M., Hein, M. A., Dayton, W. A., and Erlanson, C. 0. 1948. U. S. Dept. Agr. Yearbook. pp. 639-700. Hughes, R. 1953. J . Agr. SOC.Uniu. Coll. Wales 34, 1-4. Jenkin, T. J. 1955a. 1. Genet. 53, 81-93. Jenkin, T. J. 1955b. J. Genet. 53, 125-130. Johnson, B. L. 1945. Am. J. Botany 32, 599-608. Johnson, I. J. 1952. Proc. 6th Intern. Grasslands Congr. 1, 327-334. Jones, K. 1954. Repts. and Communs. 8th Intern. Botan. Congr., pp. 75-77. Jiihl, H. 1953. Chem. Ber. 55, 331-338. Julen, G. 1947. J. Brit. Grasslands SOC.2, 57-62. Julen, G. 1954. Acta Agr. Scand. 4, 584-593. Juhl-Noodt, H. 1955. Zuchter 25,8046. Kalton, R. R., and Leffel, R. C. 1955. Agron. J. 47, 370-373. Kalton, R. R., Leffel, R. C. Wassorn, C. E., and Weiss, M. G. 1955. Iowa State Coll. 1. Sci. 29, 631-657. Keller, W. 1944. J. Heredity 35, 49-56. Keller, W. 1948. U . S. Dept. Agr. Yearbook, pp. 347-351. Keller, W. 1952. Proc. 6th Intern. Grasslands Congr. 2, 1613-1619. Keller, W. 1954. Agron. I. 46, 495499. Kneebone, W. R. 1951. University of Minnesota Ph.D. thesis. Unpublished. Knobloch, I. W. 1943. Bull. Torrey Botan. Club 70, 467472. Knowles, R. P. 1955. Agron. J. 47, 15-19. Knowles, R. P., and White, W. J. 1949. Sci. Agr. 29, 437-450. Kramer, H. H. 1952. Proc. 6th Intern. Grasslands Congr. 1, 341-346. Lebsock, K. L., and Kalton, R. R. 1954. Agron. J. 46, 463-467. Leffel, R. C. Kalton, R. R., and Wassom, C. E. 1954. Agron. I. 46, 370-374. Love, R. M. 1947. J. Am. SOC.Agron. 39. 41-46. Love, R. M. 1952. Proc. 6ih Intern. Grasslands Congr. 1, 292-298. Love, R. M. 1954. Am. J. Botany41, 107-110. Love, A. 1952. Hereditas 38, 11-32. Lowe, C. C., and Murphy, R. P. 1955. Agron. J. 47,221-223. Muntzing, A. 1954. Hereditas 40, 459-516. Murphy, R. P. 1952. Proc. 6th Intern. Grasslands Congr. 1, 320-326. Musser, H. B., Burton, G. W., and Schoth, H. A. 1948. U.S. Dept. Agr. Yearbook, pp. 354-356. Myers, W. M. 1947. Botan. Revs. 13, 319-421. Myers, W. M., and Hill, H. D. 1943. Genetics 28, 383-397. Myers, W. M., and H l l , H. D. 1947. Bull. Torrey Botan. Club 74, 99-111. Nielsen, E. L. 1944. J. Agr. Research 69, 327-353. Nielsen, E. L. 1947. Am. J. Botany 34, 431-433. Nielsen, E. L. 1951. Botan. Gaz. 113, 23-54. Nielsen, E. L. 1952. Proc. 6th Intern. Grasslands Congr. 1, 233-239. Nielsen, E. L., and Rogler, G. A. 1952. Am. J. Botany 39, 343-348. Nilsson, F. 1934. Hereditas 19, 1-162. Nordenskiold, H. 1949. Hereditas 35, 190-202. Nordenskiold, H. 1953. Hereditas 39,469-488. Nygren, A. 1954. Hereditas 40, 377-397. Olderneyer, D. L., and Hanson, A. A. 1955. Agron. J. 47, 158-162. Owen, C. R. 1951. Louisiana Agr. Expt. Sta. Bull. No. 449. Phillips, T. G., Sullivan, J. T., Loughlin, M. E., and Sprague, V. G. 1954. Agron. 1. 46, 361-369.
162
D.
C. SMITH
Pickett, R. C. 1950. Agron. J. 42,550-554. Robinson, H. F., Comstock, R. E., and Harvey, P. H. 1955. Genetics 40,45-60. Schaepman, H. 1952. Euphytica 1, 105-111. Smith, D.1955. Agron. J. 47,201-205. Smith, D.,and Graber, L. F. 1950. Wisconsin Agr. Expt. Sta. Research Bull. No. 171. Smith, D.C. 19M.J. Agr. Research 68, 79-95. Smith, D.C. 1948. U.S. Dept. Agr. Yearbook, pp. 331-341. Smith, D. C. 1952. Proc. 6th Intern. Grasslands Congr. 2, 1597-1606. Snyder, L. A. 1951. Am. J . Botany 38, 195-202. Sorensen, E.L. 1955. University of Wisconsin Ph.D. thesis. Unpublished. Stebbins, G. L. 1949. Proc. 8th Intern. Congr. Genet. Stockholm, pp. 461485. Stebbins, G. L. 1952.Proc. 6th Intern. Grasslands Congr. 1, 247-253. Stebbins, G. L. 1955. Science 121, 625. Stebbins, G.L.,and Vaarama, A. 1953.Genetics 39,378395. Stuckey, I . H.,and Banfield, W. G. 1946.Am. J . Botany 33, 185-190,. Sullivan, J. T., and Garber, R. J. 1947. Pennsylvania Agr. Expt. Sta. Bull. NO. 489. Sullivan, J. T., and Routley, D. J. 1955. Agron. J . 47,206-207. Thomas, H. L.,and Kornkamp, M. F. 1954. Agron. J . 46,553-556. Tossell, W. L. 1952.University of Wisconsin Ph.D. thesis. Unpublished. Tsiang, Y. S. 19M.J . Am. Soc. Agron. 36,508-522. Weiss, M. G.,Taylor, L. H., and Johnson, I. J. 1951. Agron. J. 43,594-602. Wexelsen, H.1952. Proc. 6th Intern. Grasslands Congr. 1,299-305. Williams, S. S. 1954. J . Ecol. 42, 445-459. Wilsie, C. P.,Ching, C. B., and Hawk, V. B. 1952.Agron. J . 44, 605-609. Wit, F. 1952.Euphytica 1, 95-104. Zimmerman, K. 1954. Zuchter 24,33-39.
Molybdenum as a Fertilizer A. J. ANDERSON Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization, Canberra. A C T . , Australia Page I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1% I1 The Field Occurrence of Molybdenum Deficiency . . . . . . . .166 I. For Nitrogen Fixation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 166 a Herbage Legumes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 166 b. Other Legumes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 169 c. Nonlegumes. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 169 2. For Metabolism in the Plant . . . . . . . . . . . . 170 a.Legumes. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 170 b Nonlegumes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 171 3 . F o r Animals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 172 111. The Nature and Detection of Molybdenum Deficiencies . . . . . . 173 I Compound Deficiencies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 173 2 Visual Symptoms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 174 3. Chemical Composition of the Plant . . . . . . . . . . . 177 a. Molybdenum Content . . . . . . . . . . . . . 177 b . Protein and Nonprotein Contents . . . . . . . . . 179 c. Ascorbic Acid, Dehydrogenase. and Phosphatase Contenta . . 180 4. Molybdenum Content of the Soils . . . . . . . . . . 181 IV The Correction of Molybdenum Deficiency . . . . . . . . . 182 I. Method of Application . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 182 2. Form of Molybdenum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 182 3. Amount of Molybdenum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 182 4. Frequency of Application . . . . . . . . . . . . . 184 V. Factors Affecting the Response to Molybdenum . . . . . . . . 184 I Deficiencies of Phosphorus. Sulfur. and Other Essential Elements . . 185 2. Nitrogenous Fertilizers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 187 3.Lime . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 189 a. Through Effects on Availability of Molybdenum . . . . . 189 b . Through Effects on Legume Nodulation . . . . . . . . 192 c. Through Effects on Other Elements . . . . . . . . . 193 4. Sulfur. Manganese. Iron. and Other Elements Which May Decrease the Uptake of Molybdenum . . . . . . . . . . . . . 194 5 . Vanadium and Other Elements That Have Been Reported to Replace Molybdenum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 195 6. Molybdenum Present in Commercial Fertilizers . . . . . . . 196 7. Cultural Practices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 196 8. Differences between Species . . . . . . . . . . . . . 197 Referaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 199 163
.
.
.
. .
.
.
164
A. J. ANDERSON
I. INTRODUCTION Just a quarter of a century has passed since Bortels in 1930 reported the first growth responses of a living organism to molybdenum. Over those 25 years research workers have transformed molybdenum from an element of no known biological significance to a fertilizer of widespread importance. In some areas spectacular increases in pasture and crop growth have been obtained with molybdenum and every year new areas that can benefit from molybdenum are being found. Bortels (1930). found that the aerobic nitrogen-fixing bacterium Azotobacter responded to molybdenum. This discovery resulted from experiments done by him to determine the reason why soil extracts increased the amount of nitrogen fixed by Azotobacter cultures. Molybdenum was included in the test because it is used as a catalyst in the commercial production of ammonia. Over the first 10 to 15 years following Bortels’ discovery, the biological importance of molybdenum for many plant species became established. Responses of Azotobacter to molybdenum were soon confirmed by Birsch-Hirschfeld (1932), Bortels (1933, 1936), and Burk ( 1934). Steinberg ( 1936, 1937, 1939) showed that Aspergillus, which does not fix nitrogen, also responds to molybdenum. Bortels (1936) reported responses of Azotobacter to molybdenum when nitrate nitrogen was used as the source of nitrogen as well as when this organism was fixing nitrogen, and also obtained responses of Clostridium to molybdenum. Beneficial effects of molybdenum were also reported for soya bean and alfalfa (Bortels, 1937), for red clover (Bortels, 1937; Dmitriev, 1939), for peas (Obraztzova et al., 1937; Bobko and Savvina, 1940), and for lupins (Obraztzova et al., 1937). These higher plants were grown in soil for the experiments and the responses appear to have been of doubtful significance. Arnon and Stout (1939) reported clear-cut responses of tomato plants to molybdenum in water culture. The molybdenum-deficient tomato plants developed mottling of the leaves and involution of the lamineae, showing that some specific metabolic processes in the plant had been affected by the deficiency. In 1940 and 1941 deficiency of molybdenum was shown to induce specific symptoms in oats (Piper, 1940), in lettuce and white mustard (Arnon, 1940), and in plum seedlings (Hoagland, 1941), and was also shown to be an essential element for the blue-green algae Anabaena and Nostoc (Bortels, 1940). In Australia Anderson ( 1942) reported marked responses of subterranean clover (Trifolium subtenaneum) and alfalfa (Medicago sativa) to molybdenum. The commercial use of molybdenum on nearby deficient pastures followed almost immediately. The first use of
165 molybdenum as a fertilizer on a commercial scale was in the spring of 1942 on the property of Mr. Don V. Chapman, “Highercombe,” Houghton, South Australia, and in the autumn of the following year on the property of the late Mr. Norman Brookman, “Burbrook,” Meadows, South Australia. Mr. Brookman and Mr. Chapman had both cooperated wholeheartedly in the experiments on their properties and had provided many of the facilities necessary for the conduct of the field experiments. Over the last 10 to 15 years molybdenum has taken an important place in the list of elements essential for plant growth. In that period the expansion of the use of molybdenum as a fertilizer has occurred. MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
FIG. 1. Showing a response of subterranean clover to 2 ounces of molybdenum trioxide per acre on land in southeastern Australia that had failed to respond to pasture improvement because of molybdenum deficiency. On all plots the clover was s o w n with superphosphate, but normal growth occurred only where molybdenum was also applied.
The importance of molybdenum for nitrogen fixation and for nitrate reduction has become established. For many soils, effects of lime and other alkaline materials can now be explained in terms of their effect on the availability of molybdenum. A number of plant diseases, such as “whiptail” of cauliflower and “yellow spot” of citrus, which had baffled pathologists, are now known to be due to molybdenum deficiency. Discoveries of molybdenum-deficient areas have explained some of the past failures of crops and pasture. In places, particularly in Australia and New Zealand, discoveries of molybdenum deficiency have made possible the agricultural development of extensive areas of land which had previously been neglected. These transformations can be achieved usually with as little as 1 or 2 ounces of molybdenum per acre (Fig. 1). The research with molybdenum on pastures in New Zealand and Australia has recently been reviewed by Davies (1952) and Anderson
166 A. J. ANDERSON (1956b). The role of molybdenum in legumes and nonlegumes has been reviewed by Hoagland ( 1945), Hewitt ( 1951) , Purvis (1955), and Anderson (1956a). The present paper deals with the general aspects of the use of molybdenum as a fertilizer.
11. THEFIELD OCCURRENCE OF MOLYBDENUM DEFICIENCY It is important to realize that in areas where there is a potential deficiency of an element, but where the deficiency has not been recognized, responses to the element may not be obtained when the effect of the element is tested only on crops and pasture normally grown in the area. These particular crops are grown because they have been tested and found successful. Marked benefit might well be obtained, for example, with molybdenum, in such areas on crops which are not being grown because they have not been successful. In Australia there are areas where clover had failed completely in the past, and where responses to molybdenum can be obtained only when clover is sown. It is clear that when this factor is taken fully into account by testing molybdenum on crops and pasture not normally grown in an area, many new areas of molybdenum deficiency will be found. I . For Nitrogen Fixation Molybdenum is needed generally by microorganisms that fix nitrogen. By increasing the amount of nitrogen fixed, particularly in symbiotic nitrogen fixation, molybdenum can wholly or partly correct nitrogen deficiency. On the other hand, molybdenum is also needed generally for metabolism in the plant. This section deals with responses to molybdenum which appear to be mainly due to the effect of molybdenum in correcting nitrogen deficiency. a. Herbage Legumes. Many of the field responses to molybdenum that have been obtained with herbage legumes have been due to the effect of molybdenum on symbiotic nitrogen fixation (Anderson and Thomas, 1946; Anderson, 1956a). Molybdenum is needed generally for metabolism in plants, but frequently the small amount of molybdenum that the herbage legumes do obtain from deficient soils is sufficient for metabolism in the host legume. This is because less molybdenum is needed for general metabolism in the legume than for symbiotic nitrogen fixation. Where molybdenum is deficient for nitrogen fixation but not for metabolism in the host plant, a deficiency of nitrogen is induced. The responses of herbage legumes to molybdenum where combined nitrogen fertilizer has not been used are considered in this section. The responses of clover to molybdenum reported by Anderson (1942) were obtained without lime on an ironstone soil where responses to lime were known to occur. This was consistent with evidence ob-
MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
167
tained by Ferguson, Lewis, and Watson (1940)that pastures containing toxic amounts of molybdenum for stock occw on neutral to alkaline soils, but not on acid soils with an equally high molybdenum content. It had been thought that the lime counteracted the fixation of phosphate in the soil, because responses to superphosphate were much greater in the presence than in the absence of lime. This explanation became suspect when it was found (Anderson, 1946) that oats responded to phosphate but not to lime, and that the phosphorus content of stunted clover plants receiving only superphosphate was considerably higher than the phosphorus content of well-developed plants treated with wood ash. It seemed more probable therefore that the positive interaction between the lime and phosphate-that is, the effect of lime in increasing the response to phosphate-was due to the fact that the lime and the phosphate corrected different deficiencies. There was also evidence that this unknown element occurred in wood ash but not in lime, as it had also been noted (Anderson, 1946) that on another property, at Houghton where an apparently identical problem occurred, the clover plants responded to wood ash but not to lime. A search for the element concerned in the effects of lime and wood ash resulted in responses to molybdenum (Anderson, 1942). Many of the early field responses to molybdenum were obtained on liie-responsive soils or in areas where effects of wood ash had been noted. Others were obtained by testing molybdenum in areas where clover had failed or where it showed evidence of nitrogen deficiency. Ferres and Trumble (1943)obtained responses of subterranean clover to molybdenum on a wide range of soils in South Australia. Also, in South Australia a wide range of herbage legumes responded to molybdenum (Anderson, 1946; Anderson and Thomas, 1946). Stephens and Oertel ( 1943) and Fricke ( 1943) reported responses of subterranean clover to molybdenum on a lime-responsive ironstone soil in Tasmania. Responses to molybdenum in Tasmania were obtained by Fricke ( 19M) with white clover and red clover. In Western Australia responses of clover to molybdenum were obtained by Teakle (1944) and Rossiter
(1952). On the acid soils of the Tablelands of eastern Australia, effects of molybdenum have been obtained on the Southern Tablelands of New South Wales and in the Australian Capital Territory, on alfalfa (Shaw, Barrie, and Kipps, 19&), on subterranean clover grown on basaltic soils (Parbery, 1946), and on granitic and sedimentary soils (Anderson, 1948; Anderson and Spencer, 1950a; McLachlan, 1955). Responses of herbage legumes to molybdenum have now been found on or near the Eastern Tablelands in Victoria (Newman, 1955) and through New South Wales north into Queensland (McLachlan, 1955; Weir, Hart-
168
A. J. ANDERSON
ridge and Fawcett, 1955;von Stieglitz and Chippendale, 1955); on the adjoining coastal soils (Anderson and k n o t , 1953;Strang, 1954); and on the western plains (Andrew and Milligan, 1954). McLachlan (1953)has reported the occurrence of molybdenum deficiency also in some acid soils from the Northern Territory. In South Australia (Anderson and Thomas, 1946),in New South Wales (Anderson and Spencer, 1949,1950a),and in Western Australia (Rossiter, 1952) the effect of molybdenum on the herbage legumes was examined and shown to result from an increase in symbiotic nitrogen fixation. Australian work so far indicates that deficiency of molybdenum occurs in a wide variety of soils scattered mainly throughout eastern and southeastern Australia. McLachlan ( 1955) compared the effects of molybdenum on a wide range of soils in eastern Australia and concluded that the response was influenced most by deficiencies of phosphorus and sulfur. This is discussed later under Section V, 1. The other significant correlation with molybdenum response obtained by McLachlan was the tendency for greater responses to occur in the more acid soils. As pointed out later in this article under Section V, 3 soil acidity may decrease or increase the effect of molybdenum, depending upon conditions. Responses of herbage legumes to molybdenum in New Zealand were found first on an ironstone soil in the North Island at North Auckland (Davies, 1952).Later, responses were obtained in Otago in the South Island (Davies, Holmes, and Lynch, 1951; Lobb, 1952, 1953; Cullen, 1954).Molybdenum deficiency is now known to occur over a wide area of both the North and South Islands in New Zealand (Davies, 1952). In places considerable areas of third-class land have been transformed to first-class land by the use of molybdenum. Lobb (1953) has described the remarkable responses that have been obtained with molybdenum in North Otago, New Zealand, on pasture and also on other plants. The experiments of Walker, Adams, and Orchiston (1955a)indicate that on New Zealand soils the effect of molybdenum on herbage legumes is to correct nitrogen deficiency. The importance of molybdenum on herbage legumes in Australia and New Zealand has recently been discussed by Kline (1954). Responses of herbage legumes to molybdenum have now been found on alfalfa in New Jersey (Evans and Purvis, 1951), on alfalfa in Hawaii (Younge and Takahashi, 1953), on white clover in Ireland (Walsh, Neenan, and @Moore, 1952), and on a number of herbage legumes in Holland (Mulder, 1954).The responses obtained by Younge and Takahashi (1953)were on a soil with a very high manganese content. Walsh, Neenan, and OMoore (1952) found responses on acid organic as well as mineral soils.
MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
169
b. Other Legumes. Responses of peas to molybdenum through effects on symbiotic nitrogen fixation have been reported in Australia by Wade (1952) and Crofts (1954) and in New Zealand by Blomfield ( 1954). The molybdenum-treated pea plants were larger and greener and had larger nodules. Blomfield (1954)noted that the large nodules on the healthy treated plants were pink in color compared with the gray color of nodules on the deficient plants, as occurs when molybdenum stimulates symbiotic nitrogen fixation. It is interesting that there have been so few recorded responses of legumes other than herbage legumes to molybdenum. There are several possible reasons for this. Often these other legumes, such as peas, beans, and other pulses, are grown in market garden soils with sufficient nitrogen applied for the requirements of the plants. This would not always apply, for example, where the legumes are grown as a green manure crop. Many of these plants have large seed, which may contain ample molybdenum for the full growth of the plant and for seed production (Meagher, Johnson, and Stout, 1952).This also cannot alone explain why molybdenum deficiency has seldom been found to induce nitrogen deficiency in legumes other than herbage legumes. Deficiency of molybdenum for the host legume, which has an even lower requirement than for symbiotic nitrogen fixation, has been reported for beans and for peas in Australia (Wilson, 1949a; Drake and Kehoe, 1954). A factor possibly of greater importance is that special attention often is not paid to the nodulation of legumes. Perhaps absence of response to molybdenum has in many cases resulted from ineffective nodulation of the legume. c. Nonlegumes. The early work of Bortels (1930,1936) and others clearly demonstrated the effects of molybdenum on Azotobacter. Other free-living nitrogen-fixing organisms such as Clostridium (Bortels, 1936; Jensen and Spencer, 1947) and the blue-green algae Anabaena and Nostoc (Bortels, 1940) also respond to molybdenum. In fact the evidence indicates that molybdenum is needed generally by all organisms, and that deficiency of molybdenum may well influence nitrification and other nitrogen transformations in soils. Lobb (1953) has observed that grasses in mixed pasture in New Zealand are often darker green in early growth where molybdenum has been added. The writer has observed a similar effect on grasses in mixed pasture in Australia. Stephens and Oertel (1943) reported a small increase in the final yield of ryegrass following the application of molybdenum. The greening of the grasses might be due to an effect of molybdenum on the nitrogen supply. In experiments with a number of grasses and legumes on a molybdenum-deficient soil, Anderson and Thomas (1 946) found that only the legumes responded to molybdenum.
170
A. J. ANDERSON
On that soil the grasses did not respond to molybdenum either when they were nitrogen-deficient or when combined nitrogen fertilizer had been added, The evidence outlined above indicates that any effect that molybdenum may have on nitrogen fixation or other nitrogen changes in soils is insignificant in comparison with the effect on symbiotic nitrogen fixation. This is probably due to the fact that the Rhizobium organism in the nodule is much more favorably situated with respect to the supply of sugar as a source of energy than are the free-living organisms. Furthermore, it is possible that the greening of grasses that does occur may be due not to any increase in nitrogen supply but to an effect of molybdenum on protein metabolism in the plant. This is a common effect of molybdenum on nonlegumes (Anderson, 1956a). 2. For Metabolism in the Plant
Deficiency of molybdenum in plants interferes with protein metabolism, and the deficient plants are often pale green with symptoms resembling nitrogen deficiency. Where nitrate is the source of nitrogen the molybdenum-deficient plants may contain high concentrations of nitrate nitrogen. Molybdenum-deficient plants which have taken up ammonium nitrogen from the soil may be dark green. The molybdenum deficiency, if sufficiently acute, often causes specific and well-defined symptoms. This section deals with responses to molybdenum which appear to be mainly due to the effect of molybdenum on metabolism in the plant. a. Legumes. It has been established by experiments in water culture that molybdenum is needed for metabolism in the host legume (Evans, Purvis, and Bear, 1950; Hewitt, 1951; Meagher, Johnson, and Stout, 1952). The evidence with herbage legumes so far has not revealed field deficiencies of molybdenum for metabolism in these plants, apart from effects in symbiotic nitrogen fixation. The available evidence indicates that molybdenum deficiency either is not sufficiently acute to induce molybdenum deficiency in the host legume, or, where the deficiency is acute, it is masked by nitrogen deficiency. On the other hand, deficiency of molybdenum for metabolism in the plant may become evident where a nitrogenous fertilizer has been applied. In Australia, Wilson (1949a) found that a scald disease of beans (Phaseolus vulgaris) was due to molybdenum deficiency. This disease occurred on certain acid coastal soils in New South Wales. It had been thought that the disease was due to excess manganese, as the plants often contain high concentrations of this element. Furthermore, application of lime to the soil reduced the uptake of manganese and alleviated the condition. However, it is known that the uptake of manganese by plants is greater in acid soils and that the affected plants on
171 the more acid soil would therefore have been expected to contain more manganese. Before the use of molybdenum the disease had been largely overcome by using seed that had been produced in unaffected areas, presumably because of the higher molybdenum content of the imported seed. Nitrogenous fertilizer had been applied to the soil on which scald disease of beans was found (Wilson, 1949a). A similar disease of peas (Pisum sativurn) has recently been identified in Australia, in the Bairnsdale district of Victoria (Drake and Kehoe, 1954). A marked scorching of the lower leaves occurred where superphosphate and sulfate of ammonia had been applied to a sandy-loam soil of pH 5.4. Tests with diphenylamine showed a high concentration of nitrate in the affected plants. A striking response was obtained by spraying the plants with a solution containing 1/3 ounce of ammonium molybdate in 2 gallons of water. b. Nonlegumes. In his work with Aspergillus, Steinberg (1936) showed that molybdenum is needed for growth apart from any effect on nitrogen fixation. Arnon and Stout (1939) showed that molybdenum is essential for higher plants. Although there is considerable evidence that more molybdenum is needed for growth with nitrate nitrogen than where ammonium nitrogen is used, at least for some organisms, there is no doubt that molybdenum is needed by plants for the utilization of both forms of nitrogen (Vanselow and Datta, 1949; Agarwala, MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
1952). The first field response of a nonlegume to molybdenum was obtained by Davies (1945) in New Zealand. This response resulted from a study of the disease “whiptail” of cauliflowers, which could be controlled by liming. Working with an affected soil, Davies was able to demonstrate characteristic symptoms for the treatments lacking the element molybdenum. In these experiments the plants treated with molybdenum, though superior, did develop whiptail-like symptoms. The same year Mitchell (1945) was successful in controlling “whiptail” of cauliflowers in New Zealand with application of 1 pound of ammonium molybdate per acre. The reported effects of molybdenum on cauliflowers in New Zealand were shortly followed by similar effects in Australia. Waring, Shirlow, and Wilson (1947, 1949) in New South Wales were the first in Australia to show that “whiptail” of cauliflower could be corrected by the use of molybdenum. This was confirmed in Western Australia by D u n e and Jones (1948). Using sand cultures Hewitt and Jones (1947) studied the effect of molybdenum deficiency in cauliflower and showed that the deficiency in the plant induces “whiptail.” Responses of other plants to molybdenum were soon obtained in
172
A. J. ANDERSON
Australia. Fricke (1947) reported a response of oats to molybdenum in Tasmania in an area where responses of clover had been found. The deficiency severely restricted the production of grain, indicating that the molybdenum was deficient for metabolism in the plant. Wilson (1948) obtained responses of lettuce to molybdenum in New South Wales in an area where the responses of cauliflowers had occurred. Millikan (1948) found that molybdenum corrected a lower leaf necrosis in flax. At about this time also Walker (1948) in California, reported molybdenum deficiency in tomato plants grown in a serpentine soil. The symptoms were similar to those described by Arnon and Stout (1939) showing that the molybdenum was deficient for metabolism in the host plant. “Whiptail” of cauliflower has a wide distribution in many countries. The effectiveness of molybdenum for correcting this deficiency disease is now well recognized. In England effects of molybdenum on “whiptail” in the field have been reported by Jones and Dermott (1950) and by Plant (1951). Similar results with molybdenum on “whiptail” of cauliflower have been reported in Florida by Eddins et al. (1952) and Gammon et al. (1954) ; in Holland by Mulder (1954); and in new areas in Australia and New Zealand by von Stieglitz and Chippendale (1955) in Queensland and by Lobb (1953) in otago. Responses of many plants to molybdenum have now been found, generally on acid soils, and many of them in areas where responses of a legume or cauliflower had previously been obtained, or where the reason for responses to lime have been investigated. The importance of molybdenum for broccoli and for lettuce on certain soils in England has been reported by Plant (1950, 1952). In Florida it has been found that a disease known as “yellow spot” of citrus is due to molybdenum deficiency (Stewart and Leonard, 1952). Responses of a wide range of species to molybdenum have been reported by Johnson, Pearson, and Stout (1952) on a serpentine soil in California; by Lobb (1953) in Otago, New Zealand; by Mulder (1954) in Holland; and by von Stieglitz and Chippendale ( 1955) in Queensland, Australia.
3. For Animals Molybdenum is known to be an essential component of certain enzymes in animals, in xanthine oxidase (Richert and Westerfeld, 1953; Totter et al., 1953), and in aldehyde oxidase (Mahler et al., 1954). There is an important relationship between copper, sulfur, and molybdenum in animal nutrition (Dick, 1953), and it would appear that a high molybdenum intake by the animal in relation to the copper intake may induce copper deficiency, while a low molybdenum intake
MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
173
may induce effects that have been recognized as copper toxicity. It is important to appreciate the significance of these relationships, and to avoid, for example, inducing copper deficiency in stock by the application of excessive amounts of molybdenum in the field. On the other hand, heavier dressings of molybdenum may be needed in places, as in Australia in certain parts of New South Wales and Victoria, where heavy losses of stock may occur through the effects of toxic amounts of copper which accumulate in the liver and are later released suddenly into the blood (Dick, 1953, 1956).
111. THENATURE A N D DETECTION O F MOLYBDENUM DEFICIENCIES Methods used for detecting molybdenum deficiency vary with circumstances. Often in Australia compound deficiencies occur, so that there is no evidence of molybdenum deficiency in the existing pasture plants. Where there is a simple deficiency some species show welldefined symptoms while others do not. Molybdenum has certain welldefined effects in plant metabolism, and in some cases these effects have already been used as a means of detecting molybdenum deficiency. It is necessary to understand the effects of molybdenum deficiency in the plants in order to understand the methods of diagnosis of the deficiency. The matters just outlined are discussed below.
I . Compound Deficiencies Often the growth of plants in the field is restricted by the deficiency of more than one element. In general, where other elements are deficient the response to molybdenum is restricted. However, heavy dressings of lime may decrease the response to molybdenum by correcting or partially correcting the deficiency of molybdenum. Nitrogenous fertilizer may correct the nitrogen deficiency induced in the legume by molybdenum deficiency. On the other hand, a dressing of lime may be needed to induce nodulation on the clover roots before responses of clover to molybdenum can be obtained. Factors affecting the response to molybdenum are discussed later in this paper under Section V. It is apparent from the studies of factors affecting the response to molybdenum that compound deficiencies may prevent not only the response to molybdenum but also the detection of molybdenum deficiency by visual or chemical methods. This may be illustrated by observations of the writer that pasture which has been sown on molybdenum-deficient land, and hence has not responded well to superphosphate, may not be treated further by the landholder with superphosphate. Such pasture may show symptoms of phosphorus deficiency or sulfur deficiency rather than symptoms of molybdenum deficiency.
174
A. J. ANDERSON
The variation in the effects of other factors on molybdenum response shows that care must be taken to select the right conditions when testing for field responses to molybdenum. Methods of taking account of these factors in field tests for deficiencies in Australia have been described (Anderson, 1952c; Anderson and Moye, 1952). It is important to stress that the strongest molybdenum deficiencies may occur in places where the plants normally grown do not respond to molybdenum. In Australia, there are no visual symptoms due to molybdenum deficiency in the plants growing in the unimproved native pasture. In a good deal of this country there are no legumes and the native grasses do not respond to molybdenum even where superphosphate has been applied (Anderson, 1946; Anderson and Thomas, 1946). Without superphosphate deficiencies of phosphorus and sulfur are so severe that in native pasture even legumes do not respond to molybdenum. The evidence shows that any variation in soil molybdenum status would have no effect on individual plants or on the ecological association of plants on untreated land, since molybdenum becomes deficient only when other deficiencies are corrected. 2. Visual Symptoms
The symptoms of uncomplicated molybdenum deficiency are sometimes a clear-cut and reliable guide to the occurrence of the deficiency. For example, “whiptail” of cauliflower and “yellow spot” of citrus are most useful symptoms for detecting the need for using molybdenum on these crops. Symptoms of molybdenum deficiency have been described in most cases where responses to molybdenum have been recorded. Deficiencies of a number of species have been described by Hewitt and Jones (1947, 1948) and Lobb (1953). In many cases photographs of the symptoms have been reproduced in color, particularly by Wallace ( 1951) and von Stieglitz and Chippendale (1955). The effect of the deficiency on the symptoms may vary considerably. For example, where a legume is deficient in molybdenum for symbiotic nitrogen fixation the plant shows symptoms of nitrogen deficiency (Anderson and Thomas, 1946), but where the molybdenum is deficient for metabolism in the plant other symptoms usually become apparent (Evans, Purvis, and Bear, 1950; Meagher, Johnson, and Stout, 1952). Whether one or other of these symptoms on a legume is dominant depends upon the degree of the deficiency and upon the nitrogen supply (Anderson and Spencer, 1950a; Anderson, 1956a). With cauliflowers, Hewitt and Agarwala (1951) found that the appearance of “whiptail” symptoms is inhibited by severe molybdenum deficiency when the nitrogen level is also low.
MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
175
Molybdenum deficiency often induces interveinal chlorosis. Johnson, Pearson, and Stout (1952) have pointed out that whereas some species show interveinal chlorosis, in others the chlorosis is more diffuse, resembling nitrogen deficiency. Some species show cupping of the leaves, which may develop towards the upper or lower surface of the leaf. The cupping is caused by a diminished rate of expansion of the leaf edges relative to the expansion of the remainder of the leaf (Johnson, Pearson, and Stout, 1952). In New Zealand, Lobb (1953) found that a general paleness or yellowing and poorer growth were the main symptoms of molybdenum deficiency in plants of the families Chenopodiaceae (mangolds, silver beet, and chard) ,Umbelliferae (carrots and parsnips), and Graminae (wheat, oats, rye, corn, and pasture grasses). Various Cruciferae (rape, chou mollier, turnips, kale, swedes, and radish) gave stunting; paleness; often a yellowish mottling of the leaves; sometimes a marked yellowing around the margins; often cupping of the leaves of young plants; and sometimes irregular leaf margins which may run into the midrib, producing the effect recognized as “whiptail.” Where molybdenum deficiency is sufficiently acute to cause visual effects, the molybdenum-deficient pastures are a pale green color indicative of nitrogen deficiency. The grasses and clovers are in fact both deficient in nitrogen. This is because of the low nitrogen status of the soils, and because the molybdenum deficiency inhibits symbiotic nitrogen fixation in the clover. The leaves of the deficient clover plants are smaller than normal and pale green or yellow and the stems and petioles generally show a reddish-brown coloration. The stunted clover plants are nodulated, and develop to maturity, producing viable seeds which maintain some plants of the species in the pasture (Anderson, 1946). Where the deficiency is acute, the plants may measure only 1 or 2 cm. in diameter and height at maturity. Sulfur deficiency and defective nodulation of the clover roots also induce nitrogen deficiency symptoms in the clover plants, and these may be readily confused in the field with molybdenum deficiency. Both problems may occur in country where molybdenum is deficient (Anderson and Moye, 1952; Anderson and Spencer, 1950b). Sulfur deficiency can often be detected by examining the effects of current dressings of superphosphate, which correct sulfur deficiency but intensify molybdenum deficiency where they increase the growth of the clover. Furthermore, plants deficient in sulfur do not become green and grow normally when nitrogen is applied without sulfur. Defective nodulation can usually be detected by the occurrence of nodulated green plants
176 A. J. ANDERSON scattered among the much smaller, yellow, unnodulated plants, but this effect is masked if molybdenum or sulfur deficiency is severe. The nodules of molybdenum-deficient legumes are often a gray or brownish color compared with the pink color of nodules of the plants which are not deficient (Mulder, 1948, 1954). The molybdenum-deficient legumes have more nodules than a normal plant, but the nodules are smaller. This is not only because there are often many very small nodules scattered over the root system of the deficient plants, but because the deficiency restricts nitrogen fixation and restricts the size of the nodules (Anderson and Spencer, 1950a). In some cases field responses of legumes to molybdenum have been associated with marked effects of the molybdenum on the color and size of the nodules (Blomfield, 1954; Newman, 1955). In practice, the appearance of the nodules is seldom a useful guide to the occurrence of molybdenum deficiency. The effect of molybdenum on their size is often not apparent except where soil conditions are unfavorable for the survival of Rhizobium. Very large pink nodules occur where conditions are favorable for symbiotic nitrogen fixation and where, at the same time, the number of nodules is restricted by the low numbers of the Rhizobium organism in the soil, as on very acid soils (Anderson, Meyer, and Fawcett, unpublished data). By increasing the number of effective Rhizobium organisms in the soil, either by increasing the amount of inoculum or by counteracting the soil acidity, the number of nodules is increased and the amount of nitrogen fixed per nodule and the size of the nodules is decreased. Where sufficiently large numbers of nodules have formed, conversion of some of the red hemoglobin pigment to the ineffective green bilirubin pigment may occur (Anderson, Meyer, and Fawcett, unpublished data). In addition, the occurrence of small nodules deficient in the red hemoglobin pigment can be caused by infection of the roots with an ineffective strain of Rhizobium and also by deficiencies of sulfur or molybdenum, or by the application of combined nitrogen. A very common feature of land that has been sown with cl.over and is severely deficient in molybdenum is the occurrence of vigorous dark green clover plants in patches where trees have been burned. The ash of trees that have grown on molybdenum-deficient land may contain about 10 p.p.m. of molybdenum (Anderson and Oertel, 1946). Therefore, apart from increasing the pH of the soil, the ash adds significant amounts of molybdenum, and may correct molybdenum deficiency even on soils where lime is not effective. Ash patches are evident also in land where other deficiencies occur, especially in land with problems of defective nodulation, and therefore do not necessarily indicate the occurrence of molybdenum deficiency.
MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
177
The effect of molybdenum deficiency on the color of the clover plants naturally depends upon the degree of the deficiency. It is often impossible visually to detect the nitrogen deficiency symptoms. However, the paler green color often becomes apparent when a molybdenum treatment has been applied alongside a control plot for comparison. Where there is only a simple deficiency of molybdenum, this can be done by spraying a solution of molybdenum in water onto field plots, or by applying molybdenum in some other conyenient way with suitable replication and controls. Very wet sawdust is useful for confining molybdenum within plot boundaries when it is applied by hand (Anderson, 1948). Details of simple field tests for molybdenum deficiency in places where other elements are not also deficient have been described (Anonymous, 1954). It is important to note that painting or injecting a portion of a plant or leaf with molybdenum, as is used for testing for deficiency of some elements, may lead, in the case of molybdenum, to a rapid recovery of the whole plant (Meagher, Johnson, and Stout, 1952).
3 . Chemical Composition of the Plants Deficiency of molybdenum particularly affects the nitrogen content as well as the molybdenum content of the plants. The effect on the nitrogen content varies, depending upon the role of the molybdenum, and is different for legumes and nonlegumes. Other effects of molybdenum are on the ascorbic acid (vitamin C) , dehydrogenase, and phosphatase contents. a. Molybdenum Content. It is well known that there is generally only a poor correlation between the concentration of an element in plants and responses to the element. Molybdenum is no exception. However, where there is ample molybdenum in the soil, molybdenum may accumulate in the plant to quite high levels. Molybdenum deficiency is unlikely where the molybdenum content of the plants exceeds certain levels, the particular level depending upon many factors. A value of about 0.1 p.p.m. of molybdenum in the dry matter of the plant tops is regarded in a general way as a value below which molybdenum deficiency is likely, but the value may vary widely. For example, good responses of legumes to molybdenum have been found where the plants contain even 0.5 p.p.m. of molybdenum, whereas in other cases the clover may not respond to molybdenum when it contains just over 0.1 p.p.m. (Anderson and Oertel, 1946; Walker, Adams, and Orchiston, 1955a). In experiments with citrus, Vanselow and Datta (1949) found that the leaves were just beginning to show mottling, the symptom of deficiency, when they contained 0.024 p.p.m. of molybdenum. As a result of studies with a range of species, Johnson, Pearson,
178
A. J. ANDERSON
and Stout (1952) concluded that broad generalizations regarding the significance of molybdenum concentrations in plants as related to their growth are not warranted. One important factor which affects the critical level of molybdenum needed is whether the molybdenum is deficient for nitrogen fixation or for metabolism in the plant. Anderson and Oertel (1946) pointed out that in addition to a possible minimum molybdenum requirement in host plant metabolism, there would also be a minimum requirement for nitrogen fixation, and that the latter would not necessarily be reflected in the concentration of molybdenum in the tops. It is now known that there is a molybdenum requirement for metabolism in the clover plant, and that this requirement is lower than for symbiotic nitrogen fixation (Anderson and Spencer, 1950a; Anderson, 1956a). It is well known that the concentration of molybdenum is different in different plant tissues. The concentration of molybdenum in a sample taken for analysis can therefore vary according to the proportion of the different tissues in the sample. Using radioactive molybdenum, Stout and Meagher (1948) found that molybdenum may concentrate strongly in the interveinal areas of leaves. In general, leaves contain a higher concentration of molybdenum than do stems (Barshad, 1948; Evans, Purvis, and Bear, 1950), although a few exceptions have been reported (Anderson and Oertel, 1946; Barshad, 1948). Furthermore, the distribution of molybdenum between the roots and other plant parts may be influenced by phosphate and sulfate (Stout et al., 1951), and possibly also by the level of molybdenum and by the soil reaction (Anderson and Oertel, 1946). Molybdenum is more highly concentrated in the nodules of legumes than in the roots, stems, and leaves (Bertrand, 1940; Jensen and Betty, 1943; Mulder, 1948). It is probable that this higher concentration is needed in the nodule for symbiotic nitrogen fixation. Jensen (1948) found that nitrogen fixation in lucerne was restricted when the molybdenum content of the nodules fell below 3 to 10 p.p.m. This is a much higher concentration than is needed generally in plants. Seed of legumes also frequently contains high concentrations of molybdenum (Bertrand, 1939; Meagher, Johnson, and Stout, 1952). Well-grown plants treated with molybdenum do not necessarily contain a higher concentration of molybdenum than deficient untreated plants. Anderson and Oertel (1946) found in some cases that light dressings of molybdenum considerably decreased the concentration of molybdenum in the dry matter of alfalfa tops. Plant (1952) found that a dressing of even 4 pounds of sodium molybdate per acre had no significant effect on the molybdenum content of lettuce. The molybdenum increased the yield of lettuce from 3584 to 7168 pounds per acre. The
MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
179
molybdenum content of the untreated plants was 0.06 p.p.m. and that of the plants receiving 4 pounds of sodium molybdate per acre was 0.08 p.p.m. b. Protein and Nonprotein Contents. Molybdenum increases the percentage nitrogen in legumes which are nodulated but deficient in molybdenu& for symbiotic nitrogen fixation. An increase in percentage nitrogen occws even when the effect of molybdenum on color and yield is very small (Anderson and Thomas, 1946). As would be expected, by increasing symbiotic nitrogen fixation the molybdenum increases the concentration of both the protein and nonprotein nitrogen in the plant (Anderson and Spencer, 1950a). These deficient plants, which are grown on soils comparatively deficient in nitrogen and which depend on symbiotic nitrogen fixation for their nitrogen supply, do not contain high concentrations of nitrate nitrogen. Furthermore, they usually contain sufficient molybdenum for the utilization of any nitrate nitrogen which they may have obtained from the soil, as the molybdenum requirement for this is considerably less than the requirement for nitrogen fixation. When the molybdenum is needed for metabolism in the plant the effects of molybdenum on the nitrogen content are quite different from the effects described for legumes. Plants deficient in molybdenum for the utilization of nitrate nitrogen may accumulate high concentrations of nitrate (Hewitt and Jones, 1947; Wilson and Waring, 1948; Mulder, 1948; Stout and Meagher, 1948). This accumulation occurs mainly in the interveinal tissues (Johnson, Pearson, and Stout, 1952). As the molybdenum is needed in the plant for the utilization of the nitrate nitrogen, application of molybdenum decreases the concentration of nitrate and concomitantly increases the concentration of protein (Mulder, 1948j Anderson and Spencer, 1950a). The concentration of most amino acids is increased by the molybdenum (Hewitt, Jones, and Williams, 1949). There may be no effect on the percentage total nitrogen as there is when nitrogen fixation is increased (Anderson and Spencer, 1950a). The darker green color of the legumes and nonlegumes treated with molybdenum is in each case associated with the higher protein content. It is interesting to note that pale green legumes deficient in sulfur, like legumes deficient in molybdenum, have a low percentage nitrogen when grown on nitrogen-deficient soil. The sulfur deficiency decreases the percentage protein nitrogen but not the percentage nonprotein nitrogen (Anderson and Spencer, 1950b). It has recently been found that molybdenum is an essential component of the enzyme nitrate reductase, which has been obtained from Neurospora and Aspergillus (Nicholas, Nason, and McElroy, 1953). The niolybdenum undergoes oxidation reduction and serves as a carrier
180
A. J. ANDERSON
in electron transport between flavine and nitrate (Nicholas and Nason, 1954). It would seem to be beyond doubt that there is often a greater need for molybdenum for nitrate reduction than for the utilization of ammonium nitrogen (Anderson, 1956a) and that this is due, at least in some cases, to the need for molybdenum in nitrate reductase. Wilson (1949b) has used a test for nitrate in diagnosing possible Golybdenum deficiencies. However, it must be noted that nitrate accumulation in plants may result also from deficiencies of manganese (Leeper, 1941) and sulfur (Anderson and Spencer, 1950b), and may therefore occur when the deficiency is not directly involved in nitrate reduction. When nitrate has accumulated in a plant because of molybdenum deficiency, the response to molybdenum may be very rapid. Possingham (1954b) found that the application of molybdenum to deficient plants gave clear-cut increases in the concentration of amino acids and amides within 2 hours after treatment. By contrast, application of copper, zinc, manganese, and iron to correct deficiencies decreased the concentration of amino acids. Spencer and Wood (1954) found that the concentration of nitrite increased to a maximum 4 hours after molybdenum had been applied. Within 2 days the decrease in the concentration of nitrate was accompanied by an increase, first in the concentration of nitrite, then in the concentration of ammonia, amide, amino acid, and protein nitrogen. Deficiency of molybdenum can occur in plants which have been provided with ammonium nitrogen. In general, nitrification will occur in the soil and the ammonium fertilizer may result in nitrate accumulation in the plants (Drake and Kehoe, 1954). However, nitrate accumulation does not always occur in plants provided with ammonium nitrogen and deficient in molybdenum (Anderson and Spencer, 1950a; Aganvala, 1952). Mulder (1954) has reported that plants deficient in molybdenum in the field and receiving ammonium fertilizers had darker green young leaves than corresponding plants provided with nitrate nitrogen, indicating that protein synthesis had occurred. The plants also showed cupping and withering of the leaves. c. Ascorbic Acid, Dehydrogenase, and Phosphatase Contents. Deficiency of molybdenum has been reported to decrease markedly the ascorbic acid content and to lower the reducing activity of plants (Hewitt, Agarwala, and Jones, 1950; Hewitt and Agarwala, 1952). A low ascorbic acid content was found in cauliflower plants deficient in molybdenum, irrespective of the nitrogen source and accumulation of nitrate (Aganvala, 1952). Low reducing activity in molybdenum-deficient plants has been reported also by Evans, Purvis, and Bear (1950) and Mulder (1954). Spencer (1954) has shown that tomato plants deficient in molybde-
MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
181
num have a higher phosphatase activity associated with a higher rate of respiration than normal plants. The molybdenum deficiency results in a waste of energy. This effect of molybdenum is supported to some extent by the results of Possingham (1954a), who found that the application of molybdenum to deficient tomato plants decreased the inorganic phosphorus and increased the organic phosphorus content of the plants within 2 days of treatment.
4 . Molybdenum Content of the Soils Apart from a few exceptions, the total molybdenum content of soils varies from 0.5 to 3.5 p.p.m. (Robinson et al., 1951; Evans and Purvis, 1951). The most important factor affecting the molybdenum supply to the plant is variation in the soil reaction. Walsh, Neenan, and O’Moore (1952) found soils ranging from 0.4 to 3.5 p.p.m. of total molybdenum where deficiency of molybdenum occurred and also where the pasture contained excess molybdenum for stock. The soils where deficiencies were found were all acid. Excess molybdenum occurred only on alkaline soils. The yield of mycelium and sporulation of the fungus Aspergillus niger may be increased to a varying degree, depending upon the molybdenum level, by increasing the supply of molybdenum to the organism when it is cultivated in a solution supplied with nitrate nitrogen (Mulder, 1948). This fact may be used for the microbiological assay of molybdenum in soil (Mulder, 1948; Nicholas and Fielding, 1950). Grigg (1953a) has developed the use of a chemical extractant for determining “available” molybdenum, by comparing the amount of molybdate extracted by phosphate, hydroxyl, oxalate, and acetate solutions from soils showing graded field responses to molybdenum. The oxalate extraction was the only one which gave reasonable agreement with the order of the response of the soils. Ammonium oxalate is being used for measuring available molybdenum in a survey of New Zealand soils. Grigg (195313) has described the method used to counteract the influence of interfering substances encountered in determining molybdenum in the soil extracts. Some results obtained with the method in New Zealand are indicated by Davies and Grigg ( 1953). Using ammonium oxalate extraction, Walsh, Neenan, and O’Moore (1952) found 0.04 to 0.12 p.p.m. of molybdenum in the soils where molybdenum deficiency occurs. These soils were mostly within the range of pH 5 to 5.5. Soils of the same total molybdenum content (0.4 to 3.5 p.p.m.) but of pH 7 to 8 gave excess molybdenum for livestock, and by the ammonium oxalate extraction method were found to contain 0.2 to 0.7 p.p.m. of available molybdenum. Stout et al. (1951) have shown that the ability of a plant to take up
182 A. J. ANDERSON available molybdenum is greatly influenced by the level of phosphate, and to a lesser extent also by the level of sulfate present and have pointed out that these effects on molybdenum uptake may be so great as to question the value of soil tests for molybdenum.
IV. THECORRECTION OF MOLYBDENUM DEFICIENCY Molybdenum deficiency is one of the simplest and least expensive of all deficiencies to correct, mainly because of the very low levels of molybdenum required. The application of 2 ounces per acre presents no difficulty. 1. Method of Application Molybdenum can be successfully applied in a variety of ways. It is rarely applied alone in a separate operation, but is mixed with materials normally used on the crop or pasture. For pasture in Australia it is mixed with superphosphate as molybdenum trioxide or sodium molybdate at the level of 1% pounds of molybdenum trioxide per 2240 pounds of superphosphate. This molybdenum-superphosphate, as it is called, is now an important commercial fertilizer. The mixture provides for a dressing of about 2 ounces of molybdenum per acre, depending upon the amount of superphosphate applied. Molybdenum may be sprayed onto the plants in solution, as is being done to correct yellow spot of citrus, by including molybdenum with other materials used in the normal spray program (Stewart and Leonard, 1952). Molybdenum is readily absorbed by the leaves and translocated in plants (Meagher, Johnson, and Stout, 1952). It can also be applied mixed with the seed, but with some seeds it may tend to separate and even block the drill (Lobb, 1953). Molybdenum may possibly be harmful to Rhizobium when applied on inoculated seed. 2. Form of Molybdenum Molybdenum is quite effective when used as sodium molybdate, ammonium molybdate, or as the less soluble molybdenum trioxide, and appears to be needed at about the same level of application for each of these forms (Anderson, 1946). Molybdenite, the molybdenum sulfide ore, is not satisfactory. Anderson (1946) found that a dressing of 1 pound of molybdenite per acre containing 92 per cent MoSz increased the yield of clover, from 224 to 448 pounds dry matter per acre, while only 2 ounces per acre of the roasted ore (MOO,) increased the yield to 2688 pounds per acre. 3 . Amount of Molybdenum The amount of molybdenum required per acre to correct deficiencies may vary with the crop, the soil, the method of application, and other
MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
183
factors. In experiments with herbage legumes Anderson (1942) found that 1 pound of molybdenum per acre was a much heavier dressing than was needed. In subsequent experiments on very deficient soil, Anderson (1946) compared the effects of levels of molybdenum trioxide ranging from one thousandth of an ounce to 4 pounds per acre. The molybdenum was mixed with superphosphate for application to the plots. No increase in yield was obtained with less than l/la ounce of molybdenum trioxide per acre, although a slight improvement in the color of deficient plants was observed where the next lower level of l/a4 ounce per acre was applied. The response to l/ls ounce per acre was quite marked in all experiments, but significantly less effective than 1 ounce per acre or higher levels. The dressing of 1/4 ounce per acre was not shown to be significantly less effective than 1 ounce per acre but appeared to be somewhat inferior. No further benefit was obtained with levels higher than 1 ounce per acre. In general, 2 ounces per acre, which is about the average dressing applied commercially on pasture, appears to be fully effective in Australia. In New Zealand, Cullen (1954) tested levels of sodium molybdate ranging from !iG ounce to 4 ounces per acre, and obtained responses of pasture to the molybdenum at all levels. The magnitude of the response increased with the rate of application up to the 1 ounce dressing. The 1 ounce dressing was as effective as 2 or 4 ounces per acre. In New Zealand also Lobb (1953) has had marked responses of many different crops to 2 to 3 ounces of sodium molybdate per acre. Blomfield (1954) used 2 ounces of sodium molybdate per acre on peas with good result. The effectiveness of about 2 ounces per acre has been confirmed in experiments in many places. Higher levels of molybdenum sometimes appear to be needed. Waring, Shirlow, and Wilson (1947) found that a good deal of “whiptail” still remained in plots of cauliflowers where 1/4 pound of sodium molybdate per acre had been applied. The application of 1 pound per acre was adequate to prevent all but a trace of whiptail. In other experiments (Wilson and Waring, 1948) have found % pound of sodium molybdate per acre sufficient. As indicated under Section V, the amount of molybdenum needed should be increased by high levels of sulfate, iron, and manganese, by low soil pH, and by low phosphate. An indication of the variation in the level of molybdenum needed on different soils was obtained by Mulder (1948), who demonstrated that soils vary appreciably in their effect on the availability of molybdenum to the plant. Mulder (1954) reported that cauliflowers usually responded well to 1/2 kg. of sodium molybdate per hectare (about 1/2 pound per acre) but were often better with 4 kg. per hectare.
184 A. J. ANDERSON Younge and Takahashi (1953) in Hawaii obtained results indicating that alfalfa grew much better with 4 pounds of sodium molybdate per acre than with 2 pounds per acre on a soil high in manganese. However, there were no strict controls to test this comparison in the experiment, which was primarily designed to compare the effect of molybdenum on different varieties of alfalfa. In England, Plant (1952) found that 2 pounds of sodium molybdate per acre was less effective than 4 pounds per acre on lettuce. The significance of the effect on yield was not stated, but the difference was large, and it was shown that the concentration of molybdenum in the lettuce plants was still less than 0.1 p.p.m. where 4 pounds per acre had been applied, and was not significantly higher than in the control plants. The levels needed for spraying in water solution on a commercial scale do not appear to have been fully worked out. As molybdenum is directly absorbed by the leaves, less molybdenum per acre than is used for soil application should be required. Among the levels that have been used for spraying are 2 ounces per acre on peas, before and after emergence (Blomfield, 1954), and 1/4 ounce of ammonium molybdate in 3 gal. of water for spraying on molybdenum-deficient peas (Wade, 1952). 4 . Frequency of Application The bulk of the evidence on residual effects of molybdenum shows that a single dressing of 2 ounces per acre remains effective for many years (Anderson, 1946; Anderson, 1952b; Newman, 1955). In a recent experiment (unpublished data) it has been found that a dressing of 2 ounces of molybdenum trioxide per acre applied to a subterranean clover pasture in 1946 is fully effective in 1955, with marked responses to a current dressing of molybdenum where none had been applied previously, but no responses to a current dressing where molybdenum had already been applied in 1946. Hence, the one dressing of molybdenum had remained fully effective for 10 years. There is evidence that on some soils, and perhaps for some crops in particular, heavier dressings may be needed more frequently. Mulder (1954) has observed that whereas cauliflowers may sometimes require 4 pounds of sodium molybdate per acre, a dressing of 1 pound per acre may be sufficient for cabbage for three years.
V. FACTORS AFFECTING THE RESPONSETO MOLYBDENUM Many of the matters already discussed concern factors which influence the response to molybdenum. These include differences between legumes and nonlegumes; the nature of the effect of molybdenumwhether it is deficient for nitrogen fixation, for the utilization of nitrate
185 nitrogen, or for some other metabolic reaction; the molybdenum content of the plant and soil; and the method, form, amount, and frequency of application of the molybdenum. A very important factor which also influences the response to molybdenum is the nature of other fertilizers and soil amendments which have been applied, or the level of certain elements already present in the soil. The cultural practices that are employed are naturally important, and so are differences between species. MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
1. Deficiencies of Phosphorus, Sulfur, and Other Essential Elements The importance of correcting other deficiencies, apart from nitrogen for nodulated legumes, has already been discussed under Section 111, 1. Very frequently responses to molybdenum do not occur in the field because of the deficiency of other elements. The difficulty is increased by the fact that where molybdenum is deficient, the benefit from other fertilizers applied without molybdenum is restricted, and on such land therefore these other elements have been used less and are often very deficient in the soil. In areas where insufficient superphosphate has been applied, sown pasture may remain dominantly composed of low-yielding, low-quality native grasses, or may remain dominantly low-yielding clover (Anderson and McLachlan, 1951) . When sufficient superphosphate has been applied, provided molybdenum and other deficiencies are also corrected, a vigorous stand of clover rapidly increases the fertility of the soil, leading to a vigorous growth of associated sown grasses such as Phalaris tuberosa and ryegrass, and to the production of superior hay and grain crops. Phosphorus and sulfur are both important factors concerned in this effect of superphosphate (Anderson, 1952a). In a study of a wide range of previously untreated virgin soils in eastern Australia, McLachlan (1'955) obtained responses to molybdenum on a third of the soils when phosphorus and sulfur deficiency were corrected, but no responses to molybdenum at all when no phosphorus or sulfur had been applied. Phosphorus deficiency was the most acute, and restricted responses to molybdenum more than did sulfur deficiency. It is apparent from these results that the effect of phosphorus deficiency in restricting responses to molybdenum was of much greater significance than the known' effects of phosphorus in increasing the uptake of molybdenum by the plant, or in increasing the availability of molybdenum in the soil by exchanging with adsorbed molybdate on the clay, as reported by Stout et al. (1951) and Barshad (1951b). In no case was there evidence in the results obtained by McLachlan (1955) that the applied phosphate had corrected molybdenum deficiency. Furthermore, it is interesting that the sulfate increased the
186
A. J, ANDERSON
responses to molybdenum by correcting sulfur deficiency and did not merely induce the deficiency by decreasing the uptake of molybdenum. The sulfate treatment increased the response to molybdenum only where it increased the yield. The interaction between molybdenum and superphosphate on the yield is invariably either positive or nil, depending upon the magnitude of the response to molybdenum and superphosphate (Anderson, 1946; Anderson and Oertel, 1946). Where there are strong responses to molybdenum and superphosphate, the interaction is strongly p o s i t i v e that is, the response to molybdenum is much greater in the presence than in the absence of superphosphate. Where the responses are small there may be no significant interaction, but not a negative interaction. The above is true for the interactions between molybdenum and phosphorus and between molybdenum and sulfur so far recorded (Anderson and Spencer, 1950b; McLachlan, 1955; Walker, Adams, and Orchiston, 1955b). However, Mulder (1954) has reported that he has observed plants not treated with phosphorus showing intense molybdenum deficiency symptoms, and plants on adjoining plots treated with phosphorus showing only slight deficiency symptoms. It is possible that in areas where the phosphorus and sulfur requirements of the plant are already more nearly satisfied, the direct effects of phosphorus and sulfur on molybdenum uptake by the plant may be of much greater significance than in areas where these elements are more deficient. Before molybdenum deficiency had been detected on some properties in Australia comparatively heavy dressings of superphosphate had been applied over a number of years in order to encourage the unthrifty clover. Very marked responses to molybdenum could be obtained on these pastures, at least in the year of application, without any further superphosphate with the molybdenum (Anderson, 1946). Superphosphate applied without molybdenum to molybdenum-deficient pasture further decreases the percentage nitrogen in the clover and intensifies the pale green or yellow color of the plants where it increases the yield (Anderson and Thomas, 1946). Where no superphosphate or insufficient superphosphate has been applied, the plants may be dark green because of phosphorus deficiency, or pale green because of sulfur deficiency, irrespective of molybdenum treatment (Anderson and Spencer, 1950b; Anderson, 1952a). Other deficiencies have been reported to occur along with molybdenum deficiency and to restrict the response to molybdenum. In Australia a most important factor affecting responses is the nodulation of the clover, which is often defective on acid soils where molybdenum deficiency occurs, unless proper precautions are taken to counteract the
MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
187
problem as discussed under Section V, 3b. It should be mentioned here that recent evidence (Loneragan et al. 1955b) indicates that ammoniation of superphosphate may be a useful way of counteracting the problem. Boron deficiency (Anderson, 195213) and potassium deficiency (Rossiter, 1952) also restrict the response to molybdenum in places. Conversely, molybdenum deficiency restricts the response to these elements where the deficiencies occur. 2 . Nitrogenous Fertilizers
A good deal of evidence on the effect of nitrogen on the response to molydenum has already been given, particularly under Section I1 and under Section 111, 2 and 3. In general, where the effect of molybdenum is directly to increase nitrogen fixation, as is usually the case with nodulated legumes, the application of nitrogenous fertilizer tends to correct the nitrogen deficiency in the plant and decreases the response to molybdenum. The application of nitrogen, either as ammonium or nitrate nitrogen, improves the color and increases the yield of the molybdenum-deficient nodulated legumes, even when the nitrogenous fertilizer decreases the amount of molybdenum taken up by the plants (Anderson and Thomas, 1946; Anderson and Spencer, 1950a). The nitrogen-molybdenum interaction for these legumes is negative or nil, depending upon the magnitude of the response to the molybdenum and nitrogen, and is not positive-that is, the response of the legumes to molybdenum is either decreased by the application of nitrogen or is not significantly affected, but is not increased. The molybdenum always increases the percentage nitrogen in the nodulated clover plants where it increases the yield, but the nitrogenous fertilizer may increase the percentage nitrogen for only a limited time after application, and after a growth response has occurred may even decrease the percentage nitrogen. This may be true even for sodium nitrate (Anderson and Thomas, 1946), which increases the pH of the soil and should therefore increase the availability of molybdenum in the soil (Anderson and Oertel, 1946). In spite of the results described, it is possible to increase the response of nodulated legumes to molybdenum by applying nitrogenous fertilizer. Anderson and Spencer (1950b) obtained responses of clover to molybdenum where ammonium sulfate was applied, and no response in the absence of ammonium sulfate. This was because the ammonium sulfate corrected sulfur deficiency and was not sufficient to correct nitrogen deficiency. It is important to note that on nitrogen-deficient soil, legumes are pale green with a low percentage nitrogen when they are unnodulated,
188 A . J. ANDERSON when they are nodulated with an ineffective strain of Rhizobium, or when the nodulated legume is deficient in sulfur or molybdenum. The application of combined nitrogen improves the color and increases the yield in all these cases except for sulfur deficiency (Anderson and Spencer, 1949, 1950b; Anderson, 1951). The nature of the interaction will also depend upon the particular molybdenum levels involved. Less molybdenum is needed in the host legume than is needed for symbiotic nitrogen fixation. It has therefore been postulated (Anderson, 1956a) that a positive interaction between molybdenum and nitrogen would be obtained for nodulated legumes under conditions where the molybdenum is very deficient, and where the level of molybdenum used is sufficient to correct the deficiency in the host plant but not sufficient to satisfy the requirements for symbiotic nitrogen fixation. Anderson and Spencer (1950a) have shown that the nitrogenmolybdenum interaction for nonlegumes is positive, by contrast with the negative nitrogen-molybdenum interaction for nodulated legumes. It would also be positive for unnodulated legumes, which depend upon combined nitrogen in the soil for their nitrogen supply. By contrast with the nitrogen-molybdenum interaction, the nitrogen-sulfur interaction is positive for nodulated legumes as well as for nonlegumes (Anderson and Spencer, 1950b). This is because sulfur, unlike molybdenum, increases symbiotic nitrogen fixation through its effect in the host plant, and therefore does not correct only nitrogen deficiency in the nodulated legume. There is evidence that, at least for some organisms, more molybdenum is needed for the utilization of nitrate nitrogen than for the utilization of ammonium nitrogen (Bortels, 1936; Steinberg, 1936; Mulder, 1948). Plants deficient in molybdenum, when provided with nitrate nitrogen, may therefore not require added molybdenum when ammonium nitrogen has been applied, provided the molybdenum is not completely deficient. However, molybdenum deficiency in nonlegumes which has so far been reported, appears to occur in soils irrespective of the nitrogen source (Anderson and Spencer, 1950a; Mulder, 1954), indicating either that the differential effect is small or that it does not occur in most species. In assessing the effect of nitrogenous fertilizer on the molybdenum response it is important to take account of the effect on the soil reaction and on the availability of molybdenum. It is well known that the continued use of ammonium sulfate without occasional dressings of lime can have very marked effects in decreasing the pH of the soil. Ammonium sulfate markedly decreases the uptake of molybdenum by plants (Lewis, 1943; Anderson and Oertel, 1946).
MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
189
3. Lime The effect of lime on molybdenum deficiency varies with conditions. It may correct or partially correct molybdenum deficiency, it may have practically no effect, or it may increase the response to molybdenum. Some of the general effects of lime in relation to responses to molybdenum have recently been discussed by Kline (1955). a. Through Eflects on Availability of Molybdenum. Acid materials decrease the uptake of molybdenum, and alkaline materials increase the uptake of molybdenum, by plants (Lewis, 1943; Anderson and Oertel, 1946). Various acid clays and clay minerals strongly adsorb molybdate ions (Barshad, 1951a; Stout et al., 1951). In experiments described by Stout et al. (1951), molybdenum was removed from a column of hydrated halloysite, a clay mineral characterized by its exposed hydroxyl ions, by leaching with 0.1 N sodium carbonate. The column was then leached with dilute hydrochloric acid, followed by distilled water until free from chlorides, and a solution of sodium molybdate was poured into the column. No molybdenum could be leached through the column with water. The column was divided into segments, and it was found that nearly the whole of the molybdenum had been held by the top 1.5 cm. of clay. The molybdenum was readily displaced from the clay with 0.5 N sodium carbonate. The results show that the molybdate was very firmly adsorbed on the acid clay and was not measurably leached by water, but was readily displaced from the clay by dilute sodium carbonate. Stout et al. (1951) reported that the uptake of molybdenum by plants from a culture solution is favored by acid reactions. This contrasts with the results obtained in soil. Thus the effect of lime in increasing the uptake of molybdenum by plants is due to the effect of the lime in increasing the supply of available molybdenum in the soil, rather than to any effect of the lime in increasing the ability of the plants to take up molybdenum. The increase in the supply of available molybdenum to the plant, in those experiments where the lime samples have been examined, has been due not to molybdenum present in the lime (Anderson and Oertel, 1946; Evans, Pwvis, and Bear, 1951) but rather to the effect of hydroxyl ions in replacing molybdate ions on the clay, o r to some other mechanism affecting the availability of molybdenum in the soil. An increase in the concentration of hydroxyl ions results in the displacement of phosphate ions (Stout, 1940) as well as molybdate ions. It might therefore seem that if the effect of lime on the availability of molybdenum in the soil is through an exchange reaction between hydroxyl and molybdate ions, then the application of lime should
190 A. J. ANDERSON increase also the availability of phosphate. However, as already mentioned under Section 11, la, it was the finding that effects of lime and woodash on plant growth were not due to an increase in the availability of phosphate that led to a search for the element concerned in the response, and led to the finding of molybdenum deficiency in that soil (Anderson, 1942, 1946). The lack of response to superphosphate where no lime had been applied was due not to fixation of phosphate in the soil but to deficiency of molybdenum. There was no evidence with this soil that the effect of lime was due even in the least degree to an effect on the availability of phosphate (Anderson, 1946; Anderson and Oertel, 1946). Similar results have been obtained with a number of soils, even including a basaltic red loam of pH 5 to 6 which contains a high percentage of free iron oxide and a high percentage of phosphorus of low availability (Anderson and h o t , 1953). The evidence just discussed does not rule out the possibility that lime increases the availability of molybdenum to plants by an anion exchange reaction between hydroxyl and molybdate ions. In fact it would seem likely from the other evidence already discussed that this is at least one of the mechanisms by which the availability of molybdenum is influenced. It is suggested that differences in the effects of lime on molybdenum and phosphorus deficiency may be due, at least in large measure, to the great difference in the number of molybdate and phosphate ions that would need to be displaced to produce measurable effects on plant growth. It is possible also that lime may influence the availability of molybdenum through its effect on ions which in turn influence the availability of molybdenum, as indicated under Section V, 4. Barshad (1951a) and Evans, Purvis, and Bear (1951) showed that Lime increased the amount of water-soluble molybdenum in the soil, and that in most cases this was associated with an increase in the molybdenum content of the plants. Barshad (1951a) found that the concentration of water-soluble molybdenum in the soil increased as the soil reaction was increased to above pH 8. The concentration of molybdenum in the plants was increased to a maximum at about pH 7.5. It seems possible therefore that under some conditions the effect of lime in increasing the availability of molybdenum in the soil may be counteracted, or perhaps reversed, by the depressing effect of higher pH on the ability of plants to take up molybdenum. By increasing the availability of molybdenum in the soil, lime stimulates symbiotic nitrogen fixation in nodulated clover plants (Anderson and Oertel, 1946). In this case the effect of lime on color, percentage nitrogen, growth, and nodulation of the clover plants is similar to the effect of molybdenum. Where the lime is not concerned also in other
MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
191
effects on the plant, the response to lime disappears where either molybdenum or nitrogen has been applied. In that case the lime-molybdenum and lime-nitrogen interactions are negative, like the molybdenum-nitrogen interaction. These negative interactions with lime are due to the effect of lime in increasing the uptake of molybdenum hom the soil where no molybdenum has been applied. It occws even when the combined nitrogen treatment decreases the amount of molybdenum taken up by the plants, showing that the lime actually corrects nitrogen deficiency in the plants by increasing the uptake of molybdenum, and hence increasing symbiotic nitrogen fixation. Lime also counteracts molybdenum deficiency in nonlegumes, and has long been known to counteract the molybdenum deficiency diseases “whiptail” of cauliflower (Davies, 1945) and “yellow spot” of citrus (Stewart and Leonard, 1952). The evidence discussed shows that lime can decrease the response to molybdenum by correcting or partially correcting molybdenum deficiency. It might be suspected that under some conditions lime would be needed to increase the availability of the molybdenum which has been added to the soil, and in this way might increase the response to molybdenum. Lime does markedly increase the uptake of added molybdenum, but so far there is no evidence that this is an important effect of lime for plant growth. Molybdenum applied to unlimed soil corrects the deficiency and as indicated under Section IVY4 may remain eff ective for many years, even on soils which already contain high levels of unavailable molybdenum. The extent to which lime corrects molybdenum deficiency varies considerably. Where the soil contains sufficient unavailable molybdenum, lime may fully correct the deficiency. Where the total molybdenum content is very high, as in a soil containing 31.5 p.p.m. of Mo examined by Robinson et al. (1951), lime may increase the molybdenum content of the plants to levels harmful to livestock. Often the effect is partially to correct the deficiency of molybdenum. Where the total molybdenum content of the soil is low, lime may have no significant effect. Anderson and Oertel (1946) obtained marked responses to either molybdenum or lime on a soil containing 10 p.p.m. of molybdenum, and responses to molybdenum buj not to lime on a soil which contained less than I p.p.m. of molybdenum. Newman (1955) has also reported marked responses of clover to molybdenum on soils where the effects of lime are negligible. Lobb (1953) found that responses to lime were often not as great or as rapid as responses to molybdenum. Cullen (1954) also has obtained substantial responses to molybdenum after lime has been applied. On some soils lime may be needed in addition to molybdenum, as
192
A. J. ANDERSON
discussed under Section V, 3b, and V, 3c. On other soils a dressing of molybdenum can replace the need for lime. Soils where lime has given no response after molybdenum has been applied, have been found in many parts of Australia (Fricke, 1944; Parbery, 1946; Anderson, 1946; Newman, 1955) and in New Zealand (Davies, Holmes, and Lynch, 1951; Cullen, 1953; and Lobb, 1953). b. Through EfJects on Legume Nodulation. Molybdenum deficiency occurs most commonly on acid soils. Where the soils are more acid than about pH 5.5, clover sown on new land is often unnodulated, or ineffectively nodulated, and because of this may not respond to molybdenum (Anderson and Moye, 1952; Newman, 1955). The plants may also show little or no response to molybdenum where lime has been used at normal levels, as the lime may not only correct the problem of defective nodulation but may also correct molybdenum deficiency by releasing molybdenum from the soil (Anderson and Moye, 1952). However, the amount of lime needed to correct defective nodulation is considerably less than the amount of lime needed to release sufficient molybdenum from the soil. In Australia, vigorous growth of clover, essential for increasing the fertility of these naturally infertile soils, can now be achieved by the use of a small dressing of lime to induce nodulation, together with molybdenum to stimulate symbiotic nitrogen fixation. The results of Anderson and Moye (1952) showed that good results can be obtained with subterranean clover, even on the poorest land on soils of less than pH 5, by mixing inoculated clover seed with lime (CaCO,) , drilling at 224 pounds of lime per acre, and .applying molybdenum-superphosphate separately. Satisfactory results can also be obtained by mixing the lime and molybdenum-superphosphate together, and mixing the inoculated seed with this for sowing. More recent evidence indicates that it will be possible to correct the problem of defective nodulation over a great deal of land by pelleting the seeds with lime after inoculation (Loneragan et al., 1955a) or by ammoniation of the superphosphate (Loneragan et al., 1955b). In practice, each of these methods would have its own special place, depending upon circumstances. Further work may reveal that legumes such as lucerne, which are particularly responsive to lime, may be grown on a much wider range of soils than at present by the use of molybdenum combined with low levels of lime. Evans, Purvis, and Bear (1951) obtained a response of alfalfa to molybdenum on soil limed to pH 5.5, and where molybdenum had been added there was very little benefit from liming the soil to a pH higher than 5.5. The problem of defective nodulation, as it occurs on acid soils in
193 eastern Australia, is due mainly to the harmful effect of excess soil acidity on the survival of Rhizobium in the soil. Spencer (1950) was able to obtain abundant nodulation of clover on an affected soil by greatly increasing the amount of inoculum and sowing immediately. Anderson, Meyer, and Fawcett (unpublished data) have shown that calcium sulfate which for a time increases the acidity of the soil, increases the proportion of unnodulated plants. This effect can be counteracted by increasing the amount of inoculum. By contrast, magnesium carbonate or calcium carbonate can be equally effective in improving nodulation where superphosphate has been applied, and may have the same effect as greatly increasing the amount of inoculum. Thus the effect of the lime is through its effect in counteracting soil acidity rather than through the effect of the added calcium. Furthermore, when used at low levels the alkaline materials often have little or no effect where the seed is not inoculated, the interaction between alkaline material and inoculum being strongly positive. The effect of the lime is to increase the survival of the Rhizobium in the soil, and for successful nodulation the seed must be inoculated and the excess soil acidity around the seed must be counteracted. Where the herbage legumes have become satisfactorily nodulated, the problem does not recur if the land remains in pasture. This is so even for annual legumes like subterranean clover. Anderson and Moye (1952) found that where no lime was used clover on small ash patches was nodulated in the year of sowing, and that plants over the whole area gradually became nodulated, resulting in substantial responses to molybdenum in later years of the experiments. These results show that the lime treatment f o r inducing nodulation is required only in the year of sowing. It is most important to ensure that a well-tested effective strain of Rhizobium is used. Anderson, Meyer, and Fawcett (unpublished data) have found that in some cases lack of nodules on clover on molybdenum-deficient soil has been due to the use of inoculum which, after subculturing a number of times, has become ineffective, presumably owing to mutation of the Rhizobium. c. Through Effects on Other Elements. Lime increases the calcium content of the soil and the pH of the soil, and these in turn influence the solubility and availability of other elements present in the soil. These other elements either through exerting some direct effect on molybdenum or by correcting deficiencies of the element in the plants, may be expected to influence the response of the plants to molybdenum. The possible significance of effects that come within this category has been suggested from time to time in the literature, but the evidence so far appears to be inconclusive. MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
194
A. J. ANDERSON
4 . Sulfur, Manganese, Iron, and Other Elements Which M a y Decrease the Uptake of Molybdenum It has been suggested that one function of molybdenum is to act as a reduction catalyst to counteract the oxidizing effects of certain other metals. Burema and Wieringa (1942) claimed that molybdenum counteracts the oxidizing effect of copper in Azotobacter. Mulder (1954) subsequently tested this suggested relationship but could find no evidence of an interaction between copper and molybdenum. Millikan ( 1947, 1948, 1949) claimed that molybdenum counteracts effects of the elements manganese, nickel, cobalt, copper, and zinc on the physiological availability of iron, and hence counteracts some of the toxicity effects of these elements. Lohnis (1951) was unable to find any evidence that molybdenum can counteract the toxicity of manganese, while Hewitt (1948) and Warington (1951) found that molybdenum may actually accentuate the harmful effects of an excess of heavy metals. Wilson (1949a) examined the cause of scald disease of beans, which was previously thought to be a manganese toxicity because affected plants contained a high concentration of manganese, and found that the disease is due to molybdenum deficiency. Anderson and Spencer (1950a) found that the application of heavy dressings of manganese sulfate to soil considerably decreased the concentration and amount of molybdenum in the plants, and induced molybdenum deficiency. The induced deficiency inhibited nitrogen fixation in clover and inhibited the utilization of nitrate nitrogen in a nonlegume, and in each case was corrected by the application of molybdenum, The effect of manganese sulfate on molybdenum deficiency has been obtained on other soils (Anderson and Arnot, 1953; Mulder, 1954). Furthermore, it has been shown by Mulder (1954) that the manganese and sulfate ions are both involved in the effect. Increasing the amounts of either manganese or sulfate applied to the soil increased the amount of molybdenum that had to be applied to correct molybdenum deficiency in the plant. The effect of manganese sulfate was greater than the effect of either manganese or sulfate applied alone. It is very interesting to note that this effect of manganese was not obtained with all species. Stout et al. (1951) found that sulfate and phosphate affect the uptake of molybdenum by plants, but in opposite ways. The uptake is decreased by sulfate and increased by phosphate. In the experiments different sulfate salts decreased the concentration and amount of molybdenum in the plants in comparison with the molybdenum contents where corresponding phosphates, nitrates, and chlorides were used. The sulfates decreased the uptake of molybdenum from water
MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
195
culture as well as from soils, and there was no evidence that they decreased the availability of molybdenum in the soil. The effect was therefore due to an influence of the sulfate on the plants. Plant (1951) has noted that “whiptail” of cauliflower can be induced by gypsum. It should be noted that sulfate also increases the response to molybdenum where it corrects sulfur deficiency in the plants (Anderson and Spencer, 1950b). There is some evidence that the availability of molybdenum is influenced by iron. Anderson and Oertel (1946) found a high concentration of molybdenum unavailable to plants in a soil which contained large amounts of ironstone gravel. High concentrations of molybdenum may occur in ironstone concretions (Stanfield, 1935; Oertel and Prescott, 1944). Williams and Moore (1952) found a correlation between the concentration of soil iron and the availability of the molybdenum present in normal soils. It is of interest that the first responses of clover to molybdenum in Australia (Anderson, 1942) and New Zealand (Davies, 1952) were obtained on ironstone soils with unusually high total molybdenum contents. Mulder (1954) has indicated that in Holland molybdenum deficiency often appears to be influenced by the iron content of the soil. More work is needed to determine whether there is a causal relationship between iron concentration and molybdenum deficiency.
5 . Vanadium and Other Elements That Have Been Reported to Replace Molybdenum Vanadium has been reported to replace molybdenum in a number of experiments, and in some cases so also have tungsten, titanium, and cadmium. On the evidence it is not possible to be certain whether these effects have been real or whether they have been based on insufficient statistical evidence, or perhaps in some cases whether they have been due to an impurity of molybdenum in the salts used. Similar effects of vanadium and molybdenum have been reported for Azotobacter (Bortels, 1933, 1936; Horner et al., 1942), for Clostridium (Jensen and Spencer, 1947), for alfalfa, soya beans, and red clover (Bortels, 1937), and for other pasture plants (Lynch, 1954). On the other hand, in other experiments vanadium did not replace molybdenum in tomatoes (Arnon and Stout, 1939), in clover (Anderson and Oertel, 1946), or in the enzyme hydrogenase (Shug et al., 1954). It would appear that further work is needed to determine the extent to which these elements may be replaceable in their effects. Effects of tungsten and molybdenum have been reported for Azotobacter (Bortels, 1936) and for pasture plants (Lynch, 1954). Horner et al. (1942) found that responses to tungsten treatments in
196 A. J. ANDERSON their experiments were due to molybdenum impurity in the tungsten. Dmitriev (1939) has claimed to have obtained similar effects of titanium, cadmium, and molybdenum on red clover.
6. Molybdenum Present in Commercial Fertilizers As discussed under Section IV, 3, levels of molybdenum as low as
l/ls ounce per acre (about 2 g. per acre) may have quite significant effects on plant growth, depending on conditions. A dressing of 2240 pounds per acre of a treatment containing 1 p.p.m. of molybdenum would add about 1 g. of molybdenum per acre, which could well be of significance. Alternatively, a fertilizer containing 10 p.p.m. of molybdenum and used at 224 pounds per acre could add significant amounts of molybdenum. Where treatments are applied every year even a lower concentration of molybdenum in the fertilizer could be important. However, it is by no means certain that the molybdenum which occurs naturally in fertilizers is available to plants. Much of it may not be, as naturally occurring molybdenite is very &available (Anderson, 1946). Anderson and Oertel (1946) found less than 1 p.p.m. of molybdenum in the calcium and magnesium carbonates, calcium hydroxide, dolomite, superphosphate, ammonium sulfate, and sodium nitrate used in their experiments. Furthermore, there was no evidence that plants benefited from any molybdenum that may have been present in any of these fertilizers. Even heavy dressings of superphosphate, which had been used in an endeavor to grow better pasture on molybdenum-deficient land, resulted in severe molybdenum deficiency. Only wood ash, which contained 10 p.p.m. of molybdenum, had significant effects through its molybdenum content. Phosphatic rock varies considerably in its molybdenum content (Oertel and Stace, 1947; Robinson, 1948), some samples containing only 1 p.p.m. and some up to 100 p.p.m. or more. The availability of any molybdenum present may depend upon the treatment of the rock in the preparation of the fertilizers. Evans, Purvis, and Bear (1951) found that some limestone samples contained over 2 p,p.m. of molybdenum. Walsh, Neenan, and O’Moore (1952) found 4 to 5 p.p.m. of molybdenum in basic slag. However, most evidence indicates that molybdenum is rarely present in significant amounts in the fertilizers generally used. 7. Cultural Practices Studies have not been made to determine the specific effects of various cultural practices on the response to molybdenum. Cropping would be expected to induce molybdenum deficiency, especially for nodulated legumes, by lowering the level of available molybdenum and nitrogen. Lobb (1953) observed that the greatest responses to molybde-
197 num occurred where heavy cropping had been practiced, and also where the land had been eroded to the subsoil. Erosion would particularly lower the soil nitrogen status and in that way might increase the demand for molybdenum. Cultivation of the soil would increase the nitrogen status, and might well also influence the supply of available molybdenum through its effect on other elements and soil organic matter. These effects would increase or decrease the response to molybdenum, depending on the relative significance of the different effects. In fact it is quite possible that a cultural practice which increases the response to molybdenum on one soil, or on one occasion, may decrease the response on another. It would be necessary to understand fully the factors involved before it would be possible to forecast what the effect would be. MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
8 . Diferences between Species
Species differ in their response to all elements; molybdenum is no exception. They also differ widely in the amount of molybdenum that they take up from the soil, as shown in the early surveys of ter Meulen (1930) and Bertrand ( 1939) and in the more recent studies of Barshad (1948), Johnson, Pearson, and Stout ( 1952), and Robinson and Edgington (1954). The results of ter Meulen ( 1930) indicated that legumes generally contain more molybednum than other vegetable matter. Bertrand (1939) found a high molybdenum content in legumes and crucifers and in some legume seeds. As discussed under Section V, 2, nodulated legumes may respond strongly to molybdenum where the soil nitrogen status is low, and may not respond on the same soil when it is high. Conversely, nonlegumes and unnodulated legumes may respond to molybdenum only after nitrogen deficiency is corrected. The results of Anderson and Thomas (1946) with legumes and grasses showed that nodulated legumes on nitrogen-deficient soil responded strongly to molybdenum, whereas on the same soil molybdenum was not deficient for the host legume and was not deficient for grasses. Where no nitrogen was applied to the grasses they remained pale green and nitrogen-deficient, with or without added molybdenum, showing that there was no measurable effect of the molybdenum on the soil nitrogen status, for example, through free-living nitrogen-fixing organisms such as Azotobacter or Clostridium. Where nitrogen had been applied the grasses were all dark green and well grown, and again did not respond to molybdenum, even when the nitrogen fertilizer used decreased the uptake of molybdenum. Thus the soil which was strongly deficient in molybdenum for symbiotic nitrogen fixation, was not deficient in molybdenum for grasses. Where sufficient nitrogen was applied to legumes they also did not require molybdenum.
198
A. J. ANDERSON
Johnson, Pearson, and Stout (1952) compared the response of many plants to molybdenum on a deficient soil to which nitrogen had been applied. None of the 5 grasses or 7 legumes responded to molybdenum, apart from a response of Phleum pratense in one experiment. On the other hand, all of the other 18 species responded to molybdenum. These belonged to the families Chenopodiaceae, Compositae, Cruciferae, Solonaceae, Polygonaceae, Cucurbitaceae, and Umbelliferae. It is evident from these results that the host legume and the grasses are less likely to respond to molybdenum than most other plants. Lobb (1953) has listed a number of species in order of the response to molybdenum obtained. Of the legumes, sweet clover, alfalfa, and trigonella gave the greatest responses; Montgomery red clover and cow grass gave very marked responses; and white clover, zigzag clover, and subterranean clover gave marked responses. Lobb (1953) also obtained responses of many grasses, as well as various species of Cruciferae, Chenopodiaceae, and Umbelliferae, to molybdenum. No response was obtained with barley or with beans, peas, lupins, or tares. The lack of response of the large-seeded plants was probably due mainly to molybdenum already present in the seed, as indicated by the results of Wilson (1949a) and Meagher, Johnson, and Stout (1952). It is clear that comparisons between species in their molybdenum response should take account of any differences in the molybdenum content of the seed. In a number of experiments alfalfa (Medicago sativa) has been found to respond more strongly to molybdenum than most other legumes (Anderson and Thomas, 1946; Lobb, 1953; Mulder, 1954). Andrew and Milligan (1954) have reported a response of Medicago hispida to molybdenum on a soil where subterranean clover did not respond. It seems possible that species of Medicago, which are usually found on the less acid soils, may require more molybdenum than the Trifolium species. However, Anderson and Thomas ( 1946) have pointed out that the response of different species of legume to molybdenum will depend upon the strain of Rhizobium and that comparisons between species are valid only for the existing conditions. In some experiments Anderson and Thomas (1946) obtained very poor responses of alfalfa and of Medicago hispida to molybdenum because of defective nodulation of these plants in the acid soil. On the Southern Tablelands of New South Wales, Anderson (1948) obtained responses of subterranean clover to molybdenum on a variety of soils. In an experiment on established pasture where the subterranean clover responded to molybdenum, alfalfa grew well in association with it and did not respond to molybdenum. None of the other legumes tested in these experiments on the Southern Tablelands responded to molybdenum as well as did subterranean clover. The summer was too dry for white clover to grow well. The soil was too acid for satisfactory nodulation of
MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
199
the alfalfa and other Medicago species. Grasses did not not respond to molybdenum in the year of treatment, partly because of the low molybdenum requirement of these plants, but mainly because of the very low nitrogen status of the soils. Ultimately the grasses did benefit from the additional nitrogen fixed by the clover following the application of molybdenum. Mulder (1954) found that the application of manganese sulfate to the soil increased molybdenum deficiency for some species but not others. This suggests the possibility that soils may vary in their molybdenum status in different ways for different species. If this occurs, the species most likely to require molybdenum treatment will depend upon the nature of the soil molybdenum, or upon the effect of some soil constituent, for example, sulfate or manganese, on the ability of different species to take up or utilize molybdenum. This would make still more difficult the task of assessing which species are most likely to respond to molybdenum on a particular soil. REFERENCES
Agarwala, S. C. 1952. Nature 169, 1099-1101. Anderson, A. J. 1942. J. Australian Inst. Agr. Sci. 8 , 73-75. Anderson, A. J. 1946. J. Council Sci. Znd. Research 19, 1-15. Anderson, A. J. 1948. J . Australian Inst. Agr. Sci. 14,28-33. Anderson, A. J. 1951. Proc. Specialist Conf. Agr. Australia 1949, pp. 190-199. Anderson, A. J. 1952a. I . Australian Inst. Agr. Sci. 18, 135-139. Anderson, A. J. 1952b. J. Australian Agr. Sci. 18, 159-162. Anderson, A. J. 195%. Rural Research in C.S.I.R.O., No. 2, 9-10. Anderson, A. J. 1956a. In “Inorganic Nitrogen Metabolism” (W. D. McElroy and B. Glass, eds.), pp. 3 4 . Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore. Anderson, A. J. 1956b. Soil Sci. 81, 173-182. Anderson, A. J., and h o t , R. H. 1953. Australian J. Agr. Research 4,2943. Anderson, A. J., and McLachlan, K. D. 1951. Australian J. Agr. Research 2 , 377400. Anderson, A. J., and Moye, D. V. 1952. Australian J . Agr. Research 3, 95-110. Anderson, A. J., and Oertel, A. C. 1946. Council Sci. I n d . Research Bull. 198, Part 2, 25-44. Anderson, A. J., and Spencer, D. 194.9. Nature 164,273-274. Anderson, A. J., and Spencer, D. 1950a. Australian J . Sci. Research 3,414430. Anderson, A. J., and Spencer, D. 1950b. Australian I . Sci. Research 3, 431-449. Anderson, A. J., and Thomas, M. P. 1946. Council Sci. Ind. Research Bull. 198. Part I, 7-24. Andrew, W. D., and Milligan, R. T. 1954. J. Australian Inst. Agr. Sci. 20. 123-124. Anonymous, 1954. “Testing Pastures for Molybdenum Deficiency,” p. 7. Climax Molybdenum Company, New York. Arnon, D. I. 1940. Chronica Botanica 6, 56. Arnon, D. I., and Stout, P. R. 1939. Plant Physiol. 14, 599-602. Barshad, I. 1948. Soil Sci. 66, 187-195. Barshad, I. 1951a. Soil Sci. 71, 297-313. Barshad, I. 1951b. Soil. Sci. 71, 387-397. Rertrand, D. 1939. Compt. rend. 208, 2024-2026.
200
A. J. ANDERSON
Bertrand, D. 1940. Compt. rend. 211, 670-672. Birsch-Hirschfeld,L. 1932. Arch. Microbiol. 3, 341-361. Blomfeld, P. D. 1954.New Zealand J . Sci. Technol. A 36, 46. Bobko, E.V., and Sawina, A. G. 1940. Compt. rend. acad. sci. U.R.S.S. 29, 507-509. Bortels, H. 1930. Arch. Mikrobiol. 1, 333-342. Bortels, H. 1933.Zentr. Bakteriol. Parasitenk. Abt. I I 07, 476-477. Bortels, H. 1936.Zentr. Bakteriol. Parasitenk. Abt. I I 95, 193-218. Bortels, H. 1937. Arch. Mikrobiol. 8, 13-26. Bortels, H. 1940. Arch. Mikrobiol. 11, 155-186. Botting, G.W. 1955. J. Dept. Agr. S. Australia 58, 246. Burema, S. J., and Wieringa, K. T. 1942. Antonie van Leeuwenhoek J . Microbiol. Serol. 8, 123-133. Burk, D. 1934. Ergeb. Enzymforsch. 3,22-56. Crofts, F. C. 1954. Agr. Gaz. N.S. Wales 65, 185-186. Cullen, N. A. 1953. New Zealand Soil News No. 3, 4 1 4 . Cullen, N. A. 1954. New Zealand J. Agr. 88,241. Davies, E. B. 1945.Nature 156, 392. Davies, E. B. 1952. New Zealand Grasslands Assoc. 14th Conf. Proc. pp. 182-191. Davies, E. B., and Grigg, J. L. 1953.New Zealand J . Agr. 07, 561-567. Davies, E. B., Holmes, G. A., and Lynch, P. B. 1951.New Zealand J . Agr. 83, 247250. Dick, A. T. 1953.Australian Vet. J . 29, 1S26. Dick, A. T.1956. I n “Inorganic Nitrogen Metabolism” (W. D. McElroy and B. Glass, eds.), pp. 4 5 4 7 3 .Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore. Dmitriev, K. A. 1939. Pedology. 4,114-133. Drake, F. R., and Kehoe, J. K. 1954. J . Dept. Agr. Victoria 52, 570. Dunne, T. C., and Jones, L. T. 194.8.J . Dept. Agr. W . Australia 25,41%418. Eddins, A. H., McCubbin, E. N., Gammon, N., and Volk, G. M. 1952. Proc. Florida State Hort. SOC.65, 114118. Evans, H. J., and Purvis, E. R. 1951. Agron. J . 43, 70-71. Evans, H. J., Purvis, E. R., and Bear, F. E. 1950. Plant Physiol. 25, 555-566. Evans, H. J., Purvis, E. R., and Bear, F. E. 1951. Soil Sci. 71,117-124. Ferguson, W. S., Lewis, A. H., and Watson, S. J. 194aO. Jealott’s Hill Agr. Research
Bull. No. 1. Ferguson, W. S., Lewis, A. H., and Watson, S. J. 1943. J. Agr. Sci. 33, 6 5 1 . Ferres, H. M., and Trumble, H. C. 1943. J . Australian Inst. Agr. Sci. 9, 179-182. Fricke, E. F. 1943. J . Agr. Tasmania 14, 69-73. Fricke, E.F. 194. J . Agr. Tasmania 15, 65-70. Fricke, E.F. 1947.J . Australian Inst. Agr. Sci. 13, 75-76. Gammon, N., Volk, G. M., McCubbin, E. N., and Eddins, A. H. 1954. Soil Sci. SOC. Amer. Proc. 18, 302-305. Grigg, J. L. 1953a.New Zealand J . Sci. Technol. 34, 405-414. Grigg, J. L. 1953b. Analyst 70,470473. Hewitt, E. J. 1948. Ann. Rept. Agr. Hort. Research Sta. Long Ashton, Bristol, pp. 66-80. Hewitt, E. J. 1951. Ann. Rev. Plant Physiol. 2, 25-52. Hewitt, E.J., and Aganvala, S. C. 1951.Nature 167, 733-734’. Hewitt, E. J., and Aganvala, S. C. 1952.Nature 169,545-546. Hewitt, E. J., and Jones, E. W. 1947.J . Pomol. Hort. Sci. 23, 254-262. Hewitt, E. J., and Jones, E. W. 1948. Ann. Rept. Agr. Hort. Research Sta. Long Ashton, Bristol, pp. 81-90.
MOLYBDENUM AS A FERTILIZER
201
Hewitt, E. J., Aganvala, S. C., and Jones, E. W. 1950. Nature 166, 1119-1120. Hewitt, E.J., Jones, E. W., and Williams, A. H. 1949.Nature 163, 681-682. Hoagland, D.R. 1941. Proc. Am. SOC.Hort. Sci. 30, 8-12. Hoagland, D.R. 1945.Soil Sci. 60, 119-123. Horner, C. K., Burk, D., Allison, F. E., and Sherman, M. S. 1942. J . Agr. Research 65, 173-193. Jensen, H. L. 1948. Proc. Linnean SOC.N.S. Wales 72, 265-291. Jensen, H.L., and Betty, R. C. 1943. Proc. Linnean SOC.N.S. Wales 60, 1-8. Jensen, H. L.,and Spencer, D. 1947. Proc. Linnean SOC.N.S. Wales 72, 73-86. Johnson, C.M., Pearson, G. A., and Stout, P. R. 1952. Plant and Soil 4, 178-196. Jones, J. D.,and Dermott, W. 1950.Nature 165, 24&249. Kline, C. H. 1954. J. Agr. Food Chem. 2, 404-408. Kline, C.H.1955. J . Soil Water Conservation 10, 63-69. Leeper, G.W.1941. J . Australian Inst. Agr. Sci. 7. 161-162. Lewis, A. H. 1943. J. Agr. Sci. 33, 58-63. Lobb, W. R. 1952. N e w Zealand I. Agr. 04,356357. Lobb, W. R. 1953. N e w Zealand I . Agr. 07, 3-11. Lohnis, M. P. 1951. Plant and Soil 3, 193-222. Loneragan, J. F.,Meyer, D., Fawcett, R. G., and Anderson, A. J. 1955a.J. Australian Inst. Agr. Sci. 21,266265. Loneragan, J. F., Meyer, D., Fawcett, R. G., and Anderson, A. J. 1955b. J. Australian Inst. Agr. Sci. 21, 265-267. Lynch, P. B. 1954. N e w Zealand I . Agr. 09, 17-26. McLachlan, K. D. 1953. J . Australian Inst. Agr. Sci. 19, 197-199. McLachlan, K. D. 1955. Australian J . Agr. Research 6, 673-684. Mahler, H. R., Mackler, B., Green, D. E., and Bock, R. M. 1954. J. Biol. Chem. 210, 465-480. Meagher, W. R., Johnson, C. M., and Stout, P. R. 1952. Plant Physiol. 27,223-230. Millikan, C. R. 1947. J . Australian Inst. Agr. Sci. 13, 180-186. Millikan, C.R. 1948.Nature 161, 528. Millikan, C.R. 1949. J . Dept. Agr. Victoria 47, 3741. Mitchell, K.J. 1945. N e w Zealand J . Sci. Technol. 27, 287, Mulder, E.G.1948. Plant and Soil 1, 94-1 19. Mulder, E. G. 1954. Plant and Soil 5, 36W15. Newman, R. J. 1955. J. Dept. Agr. Victoria 53, 451-463. Nicholas, D.J. D., and Fielding, A. H. 1950.Nature 166,342-345. Nicholas, D.J. D., and Nason, A. 1954. Arch. Biochem. and Biophys. 51, 310-312. Nicholas, D.J. D., Nason, A., and McElroy, W. D. 1953. Nature 172,34. Obraztzova, A. A., Minenkov, A. R., Reviakina, E. Y., Holland, D. M. and Krassilnikova, A. J. 1937. Mikrobiologia 6, 877-897. Oertel, A. C., and Prescott, J. A. 1944. Trans. Roy. SOC.S. Australia 60, 173-176. Oertel, A. C.,and Stace, H. C. T. 1947.J . Council Sci. Ind. Research 20, 110-113. Parbery, N.H. 1946.Agr. Gaz. N.S. Wales, 57, 343-347. Piper, C. S. 1940. Empire J . Exptl. Agr. 0 , 199-206. Plant, W.1950.Nature 165, 533-535. Plant, W.1951.J. Hort. Sci. 26, 109-117. Plant, W. 1952. Nature 169, 803-804. Possingham, J. V. 1954a.Australian J . Biol. Sci. 7,221-224. Possingham, J. V. 1954b.M.S. Thesis, University of Adelaide. Purvis, E. R. 1955. Agr. Food Chem. 3, 666669. Richert, D.A.,and Westerfeld, W. W. 1953.J . Biol. Chem. 203, 915.
202
A. J. ANDERSON
Robinson, W. 0.1948. Soil Sci. 66, 317-321. Robinson, W. O., and Edgington, G. 1954. Soil Sci. 77,237-251. Robinson, W. O., Edgington, G., Anniger, W. H., and Breen, A. V. 1951. Soil Sci. 72, 267-274. Rossiter, R. C. 1952. Australian J. Agr. Research 3,244-258. Shaw, N. H., Barrie, N., and Itipps, E. H. 19M. J . Council Sci. I d . Research 17, 233-244. Shug, A. L., Wilson, P. W., Green, D. E., and Mahler, H. R. 1954. I . Am. Chen. SOC. 76, 3355-3356. Spencer, D. 1950. Australian J . Agr. Research 1, 374381. Spencer, D. 1954. Australian I . B i d . Sci. 7, 151-160. Spencer, D., and Wood, J. G. 1954. Australian J . Biol. Sci. 7,425-434. Stanfield, K. E. 1935. I d . Eng. Chem. Anal. Ed. 7.273. Steinberg, R. A. 1936. J. Agr. Research 52, 438-448. Steinberg, R. A. 1937. J . Agr. Research 55, 891-902. Steinberg, R. A. 1939.1. Agr. Research 59, 731-763. Stephens, C. G., and Oertel, A. C. 1943. J . Council Sci. Ind. Research 16, 69-73. Stewart, I., and Leonard, C. D. 1952. Nature 170, 714-715. Stout, P. R. 1940. Soil Sci. SOC.Anzer. Proc. 4, 177-182. Stout, P. R., and Meagher, W. R. 1948. Science 108,471-473. Stout, P. R., Meagher, W. R., Pearson, G. A., and Johnson, C. M. 1951. Plant and Soil 3, 51-87. Strang, J. 1954. Agr. Gaz. N.S. Wales 65, 130-134. Teakle, L. J. H. 1944. J . Dept. Agr. W . Australia 21,335-339. ter Meulen, H. 1931. Rec. trau. chim. 50,491-504. Totter, J. R., Burnett, Jr., W. T., Monroe, R. A., Whitney, I. B., and Comar, C. L. 1953. Science 118, 555. Vanselow, A. P., and Datta, N. P. 1949. Soil Sci. 67, 363-375. von Stieglitz, C. R., and Chippendale, F. 1955. “Nutritional Disorders of Plants.” Queensland Dept. of Agriculture and Stock, Brisbane. Wade, G. C. 1952. J . Agr. Tasmania 23, 153-156. Walker, R. B. 1948. Science 108,473475. Walker, T. W., Adam, A. F. R., and Orchiston, H. D. 1955a. Plant and Soil 6, 201-220. Walker, T. W., Adam, A. F. R., and Orchiston, H. D. 1955b. N e w Zealand I. Sci. Technol. 36, 470-482. Wallace, T. 1951. “The Diagnosis of Mineral Deficiencies in Plants by Visual Symptoms.” H. M. Stationary Office, London. Walsh, T., Neenan, M., and O’Moore, L. B. 1952. J . Dept. Agri. Ireland 48, 32.4. Waring, E. J., Shirlow, N. S., and Wilson, R. D. 1947. J. Australian Inst. Agr. Sci. 13, 187-188. Waring, E. J., Shirlow, N. S., and Wilson, R. D. 1949. Agr. Gaz. N.S. Wales 60, 2126. Werington, K. 1951. Ann. Appl. Biol. 38, 624-641. Weir, R., Hartridge, F., and Fawcett, R. G. 1955. Agr. Gaz. N.S.Wales 67, %7. Williams, C. H., and Moore, C. W. E. 1952. Australian J. Agr. Research 3, 343-361. Wilson, R. D. 1948. I . Australian Inst. Agr. Sci. 14, 180-187. Wilson, R. D. 1949a. Australian J . Sci. 11, 209-211. Wilson, R. D. 1949b. J. Australian Inst. Agr. Sci. 15, 118-121. Wilson, R. D., and Waring, E. J. 1948. J . Australian Inst. Agr. Sci. 14, 141-145. Younge, 0. R., and Takahashi, M. 1953. Agron. J. 45.420428.
The Evaluation of Crop Plants for Winter Hardiness S. T. DEXTER Michigan State University. East Lansing. Michigan Page I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 204 1. Agronomic Significance of Winter Hardiness . . . . . . . 204 2. A Cross Section of the Agronomic Problem of Hardiness or Cold Tolerance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 204 a . Genetic and Other Relationships . . . . . . . . . . 204 b. Sources of Seed . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 206 c. Stage of Growth . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 206 d. Hardiness of Seed . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 207 3. The Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 208 I1. Theories of the Winter Hardiness of Plants . . . . . . . . . 208 1. Development of Tolerance to Freezing in a Single Specimen . . . 208 2. Differentiation between Varieties . . . . . . . . . . . 209 3. Recently Proposed Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . 210 111. Methods of Testing for Hardiness . . . . . . . . . . . . 210 1. Field Testing of Winter Hardiness . . . . . . . . . . 210 a. “Test” Winters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 210 b. Management of the Plots . . . . . . . . . . . . 211 c. Criteria of Injury or Recovery . . . . . . . . . . 213 d. Injury, a Composite of Factors . . . . . . . . . . 213 2. Refrigeration Machines as a Substitute for Field Hardening or Freezing 214 a. Early Work and Findings . . . . . . . . . . . . 214 b. Growing and Hardening Plants . . . . . . . . . . 216 c. Maximum vs. Field Hardening . . . . . . . . . . 217 d. Preparation for Freezing . . . . . . . . . . . . 218 e. Difficulties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 219 f . Correlation with Field Tests . . . . . . . . . . . 221 g. Limitations of Artificial Hardening and Freezing . . . . . 224 3. Freezing of Hardened Plants Followed by Electrical Conductivity Measurements of Exosmosis . . . . . . . . . . . . 225 4. Other Methods of Estimating l‘njury after Freezing . . . . . . 229 5. Winter Hardiness Tests on Seeds or Small Seedlings . . . . . 230 6. Estimation of Winter Hardiness without Freezing . . . . . . 232 IV. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 235 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 236 203
204
S. T. DEXTER
I. INTRODUCTION During the past century, a vast literature has been built up dealing with the physiological nature and the practical evaluation of winter hardiness in plants. Publication of additional research reports each year gives evidence of continued active interest in these problems. Since extensive reviews and bibliographies (Maximov, 1929; Belehradek, 1935; Harvey, 1936; Luyet and Gehenio, 1940; Tumanov, 1940; and Levitt, 1941) have been made of the literature, no attempt will be made to include earlier papers unless they contribute directly to the subject of methods of evaluation of winter hardiness. Nor will papers dealing with the nature of horticultural problems be mentioned except when they contribute specifically to the problem of evaluation.
1 . Agronomic Significance of Winter Hardiness From an agronomic standpoint, the characteristic of winter hardiness in perennials, biennials, and winter annuals is of such importance that it frequently overshadows many other characteristics, particularly in colder climates. Thus, a variety of alfalfa (Medicago saliva) in the northern dairy regions may have the attributes of rapid recovery after cutting, large yields, desirable disease resistance, and abundant growth for fall pasture, and yet find no acceptance by farmers because of failure to survive winter conditions. A variety of winter wheat (Triticum sativum) or winter barley (Hordeum sativum) may have various desired characteristics but fail because of lack of winter hardiness. Similarly, the agronomist is interested in the effects of management on winter hardiness. Crops of great potential value may be ineffectively used when knowledge of helpful managerial practices is lacking or not applied. Thus, rotation management to control winter crown rots in alfalfa, etc., or satisfactory inoculation and subsequently increased vigor in birdsfoot trefoil (Lotus comiculatus) might completely alter the winter survival and agronomic value of these crops in many regions. 2. A Cross Section of the Agronomic Problem of Hardiness or Cold Tolerance
a. Genetic and Other Relationships. Certain vegetative characteristics are rather commonly associated with winter hardy varieties of crop plants, and various genetic complications often result from this. Johnson and Goforth (1953)have shown in genetic studies with sweet clover (Melilotus alba) that the plants selected for the best vigor in the first year of growth had such a poor average winter survival that their value
EVALUATION
OF CROP PLANTS FOR WINTER HARDINESS
205
as breeding material for colder climates was questionable. Coffman et al. (1949) and Atkins and Coffman (1951) found almost complete correlation between decumbency and winter survival in winter oats (Avena byzantina). They report a decided varietal and location interaction of hardiness. The fact that a variety was decumbent, with little fall growth, did not prevent comparatively early rapid spring growth, possibly because of lack of injury during the winter. Rosen et al. (1940) report attempts to hybridize oats to combine desirable fall pasturing characteristics with winter hardiness and disease resistance, but do not report favorable results, describing the attempt as a paradox. Coffman ( 1955), reporting the results of extensive winter oat trials, remarks that “obtaining oats having both hardiness and disease resistance is clearly difficult. Genes for disease resistance were originally located almost exclusively in spring-type oats (Avena sativa) .” Murphy (1939) reports the expected detrimental effects of diseases on winter hardiness in oats. Quisenberry and Bayles (1939), in a study of growth habits of winter wheat in relation to winter hardiness and earliness at eight stations, found all degrees of “winterness” or “winter habit” (as contrasted with spring habit) in 30 varieties planted in a wide range of climates. The rank of “winterness” was much the same for all stations, but it was not closely related to earliness of heading, nor with winter hardiness. Similarly recumbence in alfalfa varieties has been associated with winter hardiness for many years, and yet is not infallibly related. For example, it is doubtful if the alfalfa variety RHIZOMA is as hardy as GRIMM, although it is more decumbent. Great emphasis continues to be given to the r