!. "#!$"
%!&" "''&()!( (#*(#* "!#$+*,*(-(. XIX (/, ! 0!-"#"0!1
2
!"!#$%&#$'( ()&*+('*"!, -(##!.#/(. 0%1%&*2!! 3$1%4...
7 downloads
238 Views
6MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
.!. "#!$"
%!&" "''&()!( (#*(#* "!#$+*,*(-(. XIX (/, ! 0!-"#"0!1
2
!"!#$%&#$'( ()&*+('*"!, -(##!.#/(. 0%1%&*2!! 3$1%4 "*5/! ! '6#7%. 7/(46 *18!"!#$&*2!! 9&:*";%4<#/(. ()4*#$! =(#51*&#$'%""(% ()&*+('*$%4<"(% 5>&%?1%"!% '6#7%;( @&(A%##!("*4<"(;( ()&*+('*"!, «B(8(&#/!. ;(#51*&#$'%""6. 5"!'%&#!$%$ !8%"! .C. D(8("(#('*»
.!. "#!$"
%!&" "''&()!( (#*(#* "!#$+*,*(-(. XIX (/, ! 0!-"#"0!1 !"!#$%&'(
9&:*";%4<#/ B(8(&#/!. 5"!'%&#!$%$ 2004
3
)*+*",*"-.: 1(/$(& A!4(#(A#/!: "*5/, @&(A%##(& .,. /232425 1(/$(& A!4(#(A#/!: "*5/, @&(A%##(& (. . /6789:25; /*"1!1*$ A!4(#(A#/!: "*5/, 1(2%"$ &.,. -2:;<25
/*0%-%*-1( 2! $*3*"'4 $*5%6+'!""!-',5%-*7816!#! 1!9*-% /!:!$16!#! ;"'9*$1'-*-%
3 741
"4=>25 .!. !&('(++&%"!% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/* ! A!4(#(A!,: ("(;&*A!,. — 9&:*";%4<#/: B(8(&#/!. 5"!'%&#!$%$, 2004. — 654 #. ISBN 5-88086-401-4
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— A!4(#(A#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., !8%GF%;( >%&$6 #5F%#$'%""(;( #:(1#$'* # A!4(#(A!%. ' &*8/*: %% #('8%#$"(;( # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8 #5F"(#$"(;(, &*2!("*4<"( (&;*"!+('*""(;( @(+"*"!, @&!&(16. H##4%1('*"!% @&%1"*+"*>%"( 14, !#$(&!/(' A!4(#(A!!, @&%@(1*'*$%4%., *#@!&*"$(', #$51%"$(' ! '#%:, !"$%&%#5GF!:#, !#$(&!%. A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,.
ISBN 5-88086-401-4 © 3#!@(' C.H., 2004 © B(8(&#/!. 5"!'%&#!$%$, 2004
4
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– $(. ?% #*8(., >$( &*"%% &*+&*)*$6'*4*#< – 2%4%"*@&*'4%""(, #/&5@54%+"( –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– !#$(&!/(–A!4(#(A#/(8 @4*"%, "( ! ' @4*"% $%(&%$!>%#/(8, #()#$'%""( A!4(#(A#/(8. M*/ @!#*4 ' /("2% XIX '%/* A&*"25+#/!. A!4(#(A 9. 0544<%, «!#$(&!, "*5/! "% #(#$*'4,%$ ()6/"('%""( >*#$! E$(. "*5/!; "*@&!8%&, !#$(&!, A!+!/! "% %#$< ($1%4 A!+!/!. J(4$()6 )6$< $*/('(., 1(4?"* +*/4G>*$< ' #%)% #'(G !#$(&!G. 0!4(#(A!, ! !#$(&!, A!4(#(A!! !8%G$ ' #'(%. (#"('% (1!" ! $($ ?% ()I%/$ – 15:, &*+8674,GF!. ( #'(%. @&!&(1%, "*>*4*: ! 2%4!. J(, >$( /*?16. !"1!'!1558 ($/&6'*%$ ' #%)% #*8(8 @(#&%1#$'(8 A!4(#(A#/(;( #*8(#(+%&2*"!, (&%A4%/#!!), $( !#$(&!, A!4(#(A!! @(+'(4,%$ "*8 ($6#/*$< /*/ )6 ' (1"(8 5'%4!>%""(8 ()&*+%, ' 1(/$&!"*: (5>%"!,:), #4%1('*'7!: 1&5; +* 1&5;(8 ' $%>%"!% '%/('. H#$(&!,, $*/!8 ()&*+(8, ,'4,%$#, ;(4(#('*"!%8 1*""(. $%(&!!: ("* $( @(1$'%&?1*%$ !4! 1(@(4",%$ %%, $( !#@&*'4,%$ !4! @&%15@&%?1*%$ (7!)/!» (385, #. 1). (?"(, /("%>"(, "*.$! ! 1&5;!% ()(#"('*"!,, "( +1%#< '*?"* #*8* #5$< !#:(1"(;( $%+!#* – !#$(&!, A!4(#(A!! ' #'(%8 $%(&%$!>%#/(8 /*>%#$'% %#$< "%($I%84%8*, #5F%#$'%""*, >*#$< #()#$'%""( A!4(#(A!!. H @($(85, /*/ #>!$*4 "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A 9. -!4<, «$(4*, !#$(&!G A!4(#(A!!, 86 #8(?%8 @(",$<, >$( @&%1#$*'4,%$ #()(G A!4(#(A!,» (373, #. 3). C #5F"(#$"(8 (@&%1%4%"!! !#$(&!! A!4(#(A!! 0544<% ($8%$!4 #4%15GF%%: «H#$(&!, A!4(#(A!! %#$< !#$(&!, &*+8674%"!,, @5$%8 /($(&(;( >%4('%/, @(+"*'*, #*8(;( #%),, '#% )(4%% ! )(4%% 5,#",%$ #%)% !88*"%"$"6. @&!"2!@ )6$!,, +*/4G>*GF%;( '#%4%""5G» (385, #. 355). H
5
%#4! / !#$(&!! &*+8674%"!. A!4(#(A(' 1()*'!$< !#$(&!G A!4(#(A#/!: @( #'(%. #5$! &*+8674%"!. %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. @&(74(;(, $( E$!8 #(+1*%$#, '(+8(?"(#$< 14, ()F%;( !#$(&!/(–A!4(#(A#/(;( !##4%1('*"!, ' &*8/*: #&*'"!$%4<"(;( *"*4!+* A!4(#(A#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ' %;( 1%$*4<"(8 #(@(#$*'4%"!! # #(($'%$#$'5GF!8! '(++&%"!,8! A!4(#(A(' @&(74(;( – # 2%4%#$'%""( &*+4!>"6: 5&('",: >%4('%>%#/(;( @(+"*"!, – ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!! ! A!4(#(A!!. C E$(8 ($"(7%"!! )(4<7!% '(+8(?"(#$! 14, !##4%1('*"!, ($/&6'*%$ ()&*F%"!% / A!4(#(A#/(85 8!&('(++&%"!G '61*GF!:#, 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/*, @( @&*'5 "*+6'*%8(;( «'%/(8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!,». K(#$!?%"!, @(#4%1"%;( ' !: /*/ $%(&%$!>%#/!:, $*/ ! @&*/$!>%#/!: @&%$'(&%"!,: '@(4"% ()(#"('*""( @()5?1*4! $(;1* (2%"!'*$< XIX '%/ /*/ «51!'!$%4<"(% #$(4%$!%», /*/ «>51%#"6. '%/». C #'(%. /"!;%, $*/ ! "*+'*""(. «N51%#"6. '%/», – !+'%#$"6. *";4!.#/!. 5>%"6. 9.-. O(44%# ' /("2% XIX '%/*, @(1'(1, %;( !$(;!, @!#*4, ' >*#$"(#$!, ( $%: «'%4!/!: 8*$%&!*4<"6: ! 58#$'%""6: 5#@%:*:, /($(&6% (#()%""( ($4!>*G$ 1%',$"*12*$(% #$(4%$!% ($ '#%: 1&5;!:, %85 @&%17%#$'('*'7!:», ( $(8, >$( )4*;(1*&, E$!8 5#@%:*8 XIX '%/ «8(?"( #8%4( @&($!'(@(#$*'4,$< 1*?% '#%. @&%1615F%. !#$(&!>%#/(. E@(:%» ! >$( "* "%;( «#4%15%$ #8($&%$<, /*/ "* "*>*4( #('%&7%""( "('(. E&6 # @&(;&%##% >%4('%>%#/(;( &(1*» (366, #. I. P8. $*/?% #. 152). C%4!/!% 58#$'%""6% 5#@%:! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, XIX '%/* (1"!8 !+ #'(!: "%():(1!86: ! #5F%#$'%""6: #4%1#$'!. ' 8!&('(++&%">%#/(. #A%&% !8%4! $(;1* %F% ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% #$!:!."6%, "( 5?% 1(#$*$(>"( (@&%1%4%""6% ! !"$%44%/$5*4<"( %8/!% #5F"(#$"6% @&(,#"%"!, ! /("/&%$"6% &%7%"!, 8"(;!: A!4(#(A#/!: @( #'(%85 :*&*/$%&5 @&()4%8. L$( !8%4( #'(! ()I%/$!'"6% '"5$&!"*5>"6% (#"('*"!,: $'(&>%#/! 86#4,F!. 5>%"6.–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– *"$(4(;!>%#/!%, *"$&(@(4(;!>%#/!%, ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/!%, 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/!% ! 1&. 0!4(#(A#/!% «'/&*@4%"!,», )(4%% !4! 8%"%% +"*>!$%4<"6% @( ()I%85, @( #'(%. 8!&('(++&%">%#/(. +"*>!8(#$!, 8(?"( ()"*&5?!$< '( 8"(;!: #@%2!*4<"6: &*)($*:, ' "*5>"(-@(@54,&"6: #$*$<,:, $%/#$*: '6#$5@4%"!. $*/!: '!1"%.7!: +*@*1"(%'&(@%.#/!: ! &5##/!: 5>%"6:– %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX – "*>*4* XX ''., /*/ K.M. */#'%44, D. Q(4<28*", =. =%&2, =.9. D(&%"2, =. =%4<8;(4<2, N. K*&'!", L. =%//%4<, J. =%/#4!, M. Q%&"*&, L. *:, C. 3#$'*4<1,
6
9. B5*"/*&%, K.R. D%)%1%', K.H. %"1%4%%', 9.=. P$(4%$(', H. . P%>%"(', M.9. J!8!&,+%', R.9. O8(' ! 1&. P('(/5@"(#$< A!4(#(A#/!: #5?1%"!. /*?1(;( !+ "!: 1(#$*$(>"( @(4"( ! /("/&%$"( @&(,#",%$ !: 8!&('(++&%"!% ! ' /*>%#$'% $*/('(;( @&%1#$*%$ /*/ (@&%1%4%""6., #5F%#$'%""( '*?"6. ()I%/$ 2%4%"*@&*'4%""(;( #@%2!*4<"(;( *"*4!+*. H+5>%"!% A!4(#(A#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, '61*GF!:#, 5>%"6:%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. @&(74(;( !8%%$ ' "*7%. 4!$%&*$5&% 1*'"GG – %F% # 1(&%'(4G2!(""6: '&%8%" – $&*1!2!G, "( %;( (#"('"*, "*@&*'4%""(#$< (;&*"!>!'*4*#<, /*/ @&*'!4(, 1%$*4<"68 *"*4!+(8 A!4(#(A#/!: '(++&%"!. /*/(;(-$( (1"(;( !+ '67%"*+'*""6: 5>%"6: – ' #@%2!*4<"6: &*)($*: (8("(;&*A!,:, #$*$<,:), '#%2%4( @(#',F%""6: %;( 8!&('(++&%"!G (E$(, "*@&!8%&, &*)($6 B.J. Q%4('*, P.0. C*#!4<%'*, .0. C%1%"('*, C. . M*>*"('*, 9.H. M(8@*"%.2*, 9.H. M5&(%1('*, . . */(&%"! ! C.9. 3)5:('*, =.C. B4*$("('* – #8. @&!4(?%"!% / ''%1%"!G), 4!)( ' A!4(#(A#/!: &*+1%4*: &*)($ )(4%% ()F%;( :*&*/$%&*, @(#',F%""6: ?!+"! ! "*5>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! $(;( !4! !"(;( 5>%"(;( (#8., "*@&!8%&, ' @&!4(?%"!! &*)($6 9.J. =&!;(&<,"* ! 9.R. C,4<2%'*, K.K. =54(, D.R. M*&4!/*, C.D. =&*>%'#/(;(, B. D*+*&%'*, 9.C. D!)%1!"#/(;(, R.H. -(1"(;( ! S.H. P(4('<%'*, 9.-. P%&1G/('*, .P. P(8!"#/(;(, 9.C. T5;*.4!"*. J*/(. ?% !"1!'!15*4<"6. @(1:(1 ' *"*4!+% A!4(#(A#/!: '+;4,1(' '61*GF!:#, 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX –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«%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! – @4(:!% A!4(#(A6» (463, #. 200), $( @&!1%$#, @&!+"*$<, >$( #*8! @( #%)% A!4(#(A#/!% '+;4,16 5>%"6: !"$%&%#"6, ;4*'"68 ()&*+(8, 4!7< ' /*>%#$'% /("/&%$"6: :*&*/$%&!#$!>%#/!: (@&%1%4!$%4%. !: 8!&('(++&%"!,, "( 8*4( >$( 1()*'4,G$ / #()#$'%""( A!4(#(A#/(. @&()4%8*$!/%, / %% #5F"(#$"68 &%7%"!,8. C E$(8 ($"(7%"!! ;(&*+1( )(4%% #5F%#$'%""68, )(4%% @&(15/$!'"68, $%(&%$!>%#/! )(4%% +"*>!868 @&%1#$*'4,%$#, @&!"2!@!*4<"( !"(. @(1:(1, * !8%""( – 1%$*4<"6. *"*4!+ A!4(#(A#/!: '(++&%"!. 8"(;!: '61*GF!:#, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., #('&%8%""!/(', A!4(#(A#/!: %1!"(8674%""!/(' (8*$%&!*4!#$(' !4! !1%*4!#$('), @&%1#$*'!$%4%. &*+"6: #$&*" (9";4!!, 9'#$&!!, =%&8*"!!,
7
-(##!!, 0&*"2!!), &*+"6: %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/ (A!+!/!, :!8!!, )!(4(;!!, A!+!(4(;!!) – # $%8, >$()6 "* (#"('% ()()F%"!, ! #!#$%8*$!+*2!! E$!: '(++&%"!. (#5F%#$'!$< A!4(#(A#/5G &%/("#$&5/2!G !:, 5>%"6: A!4(#(A#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, (("$(4(;!!, *"$&(@(4(;!!, ;"(#%(4(;!!) ' /*>%#$'% 1(#$*$(>"( 2%4(#$"(;( !"$%44%/$5*4<"(;( ()&*+('*"!,, ($"(#!$%4<"( #*8(#$(,$%4<"(;( A%"(8%"* 15:('"(. /54<$5&6 – "*&,15 # A!4(#(A!%. !, >$( (#()%""( '*?"( ' 1*""(8 #45>*%, ' #(($"%#%"!!, ' #&*'"%"!! # "%. – /*/ #( #$(&("6 (#"('"(;( /("2%@$5*4<"(;( #(1%&?*"!, ()F!: @&()4%8, $*/ ! #( #$(&("6 A!4(#(A#/(. 8%$(1(4(;!! !: &%7%"!,. R%():(1!8(#$< 5/*+*""(;( #&*'"!$%4<"(;( *"*4!+* (>%'!1"*: (" @(+'(4,%$, # (1"(. #$(&("6, 5#$*"('!$< #',+< 8%?15 A!4(#(A#/!8 8!&('(++&%"!%8 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ! A!4(#(A!%., ()F!% 14, "!: 8(8%"$6, #'(%;( &(1* !"'*&!*"$"(% ' "!:, * # 1&5;(. –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– "*>*4% XX ''., ' ($4!>!% ($ "*7%;( '&%8%"!, A!4(#(A6 #>!$*4! 1(#$*$(>"( '*?"68 14, #%), (@&%1%4!$< #'(G @&!"2!@!*4<"5G @(+!2!G @( ($"(7%"!G / 8*$%&!*4!+85 ! !1%*4!+85, #'(% @("!8*"!% $(;( ! 1&5;(;(, #'(G @&!"*14%?"(#$< / /*/(85-$( (1"(85 !+ E$!: 1'5: @&($!'(@(4(?"6: A!4(#(A#/!: "*@&*'4%"!.. J( ?% ! A!4(#(A#$'5GF!% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! $(;( '&%8%"!. 3"! $*/?% #>!$*4! "%():(1!868 >%$/( ()(+"*>!$<, * ;4*'"(% – /("2%@$5*4<"( '6&*+!$< ' #(($'%$#$'5GF!: @(",$!,: +*/&%@!$< #'(G «@*&$!."5G @&!"*14%?"(#$<» ' A!4(#(A!!, #'(G 8!&('(++&%">%#/5G (&!%"$*2!G ("* 8*$%&!*4!+8 !4! !1%*4!+8) ! @(1 E$!8 5;4(8 +&%"!, &%*4!+('6'*$< ' ()()F*GF!: 58(+*/4G>%"!,: #'(! &*2!("*4<"( @(4(?%""6% 8!&('(++&%">%#/!%, A!4(#(A#/!% @&!"2!@6. B(E$(85 ' #5F"(#$"(8 *"*4!+% @(#4%1"!:, ' !: A!4(#(A#/(. &%/("#$&5/2!! >%&%+ 1%$*4<"(% @&(,#"%"!% ! #!#$%8*$!+*2!G !: ("$(4(;!>%#/!: ! ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/!: @&%$'(&%"!. @( "%():(1!8(#$! @&!:(1!$#, ()&*F*$<#, / 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!8 ! !1%*4!#$!>%#/!8 *#@%/$*8 A!4(#(A#/!: '(++&%"!. 5>%"6:. V1%#< 58%#$"( @&!'%#$! @(,#"%"!% 9.0. D(#%'*, @( 8"%"!G /($(&(;( /*$%;(&!! 8*$%&!*4!+8* ! !1%*4!+8* «,'4,G$#, /*$%;(&!,8! ($"G1< "% @&(#$( *)#$&*/$"68! ! ($"G1< "% @&(#$( @(",$!."68!. L$( /*$%;(&!! !#$(&!>%#/!%. B&!8%",, !:, '#%;1* "5?"( 5>!$6'*$< $5 !#$(&!>%#/5G !: (/&*#/5… /($(&5G ("! @(45>*G$ ' #',+! # &*+"68! @%&!(1*8! !#$(&!>%#/(;( &*+'!$!,» (220, #. 140).
8
B&%()4*1*GF%. @( #'(%. #@%2!A!>%#/(. «(/&*#/%» @&!"2!@!*4<"(. A!4(#(A#/(. @(+!2!%. ' 8!&('(++&%"!! '61*GF!:#, 5>%"6:%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX – "*>*4* XX ''. )64 %#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/!. (%#$%#$'%""("*5>"6.) 8*$%&!*4!+8. U*&*/$%&"( ' E$(8 ($"(7%"!! #'!1%$%4<#$'( C4. P(4('<%'*: « 6 '!1!8 "%@(#&%1#$'%""( +* ;%;%4<,"#$'(8 ;(#@(1#$'( 8*$%&!*4!+8*, (#"('6'*GF%;(#, "* E8@!&!>%#/!: 1*""6: %#$%#$'(+"*"!,… B&%1#$*'!$%4! 8*$%&!*4!+8* )64! ! #5$< )(4<7%G >*#$!$%4<"( E8@!&!>%#/!% 5>%"6%, :!8!/! ! +((4(;!…» B( 8"%"!G C4. P(4('<%'*, «"('%.7!. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. 8*$%&!*4!+8 1*4%/( "% %#$< $( ?% #*8(%, >$( 8*$%&!*4!+8 =*##%"1!, =())#*, D*8%$&! !4! =(4<)*:*: (" !8%%$ 1&5;!% (#"('6 ! (#()6. :*&*/$%&» (339, #. 38-39). =(#@(1#$'( 8*$%&!*4!+8* ' 8!&('(++&%">%#/(. #A%&% %#$%#$'(+"*"!, #$*'!4(#< $(;1*, /*/ '!1!8 ' @&,85G @&!>!""(-#4%1#$'%""5G #',+< # %;( 1(#$!?%"!,8!. J*/, 1&5;(. '!1"6. &5##/!. A!4(#(A $(;( '&%8%"! ;%;%4<,"%2 R. P$&*:(' @!#*4, >$( «8*$%&!*4!+8 %#$< #*8(% ()6/"('%""(% 5)%?1%"!% "*$5&*4!#$(' ! 8%1!/(', >$( ("… %#$< $(4$( «!+5>%"!% @&!&(16 ($+6'*%$#, '#%;1* ' @(,'4%"!! 8*$%&!*4!+8*» (346, #. 58-59). P 1&5;(. #$(&("6, @&!+"*'*4*#< ! (@&%1%4%""*, 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/*, +"*>!8(#$< 8*$%&!*4!+8* %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ' 5#@%7"(8 (#5F%#$'4%"!! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. J*/, &5##/!. A!4(#(A–!"$5!$!'!#$ R.3. D(##/!., '#4%1 +* "%8%2/!8 !#$(&!/(8 (! /&!$!/(8) 8*$%&!*4!+8* /*"$!*"2%8 9. D*";% (#8., "*@&., 193, J. 2, #. 342), @(#$54!&('*4 '+;4,1 "* 8*$%&!*4!+8 ' XIX '%/% /*/ "* 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/!. @&!%8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!,» (225, #. 92). H ' ()F%#$'%""(8 #(+"*"!! $(;( '&%8%"!, ' "*5>"6: /&5;*: 8*$%&!*4!+8 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '#%;1* !8%4 '%#<8* ;&(8/!. &%+("*"#. J*/, ' #%&%1!"% XIX '%/*, /*/ ($8%>%"( ' «0!4(#(A#/(8 4%/#!/("%» (1859), 8*$%&!*4!+8 A!+!(4(;(' (4%7($$*, QG:"%&* ! 0(;$* )64 «@&%18%$(8 #*86: ?*&/!: #@(&(' ' =%&8*"!! ! @('(1(8 /( 8"(;!8 )&(7G&*8, ' /($(&6: (#"('*"!, 8*$%&!*4!+8* )64! @(1'%&;"5$6 #$&(;(85 #2!%"$!A!>%#/(85 &*+)(&5» (374, #. 429). J( ?% #*8(%, $(4*."6. 5#@%:, &%1/!. ' ()4*#$! >!#$( "*5>"6: $&51('. M"!;* @%&%'%1%"* "* &*+4!>"6% ,+6/!; ' 9";4!! ! ' =%&8*"!! @(,'!4!#< "*&(1"6% !+1*"!,» (387, #. 31). 3#"('"6% @&!"2!@6 A!4(#(A#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/* "%@(#&%1#$'%""( '6$%/*4! !+ 1(#$!?%"!. %#$%#$'(+"*"!, $(;( '&%8%"!, A(&8!&('*4!#< ' @&(2%##% !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. &*)($6 5>%"6:. B&! E$(8 #4%15%$ @(1>%&/"5$<, >$( #@%2!A!/* ()I%/$(' %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/, !: 8%$(1(' !+5>%"!, ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% (@&%1%4,4* /("/&%$"6% A(&86 8!&('(++&%">%#/!: 5#$*"('4%"!.. 3) E$(8 8(?"( #51!$< :($, )6 @( $(85, >$( 5>%"6%, @&%1#$*'4,GF!% &*+"6% ($&*#4! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, &*+4!>*4!#<
9
! @( #'(!8 A!4(#(A#/!8 !"$%&%#*8, ' 2%"$&% '"!8*"!, 5 "!: – &*+"6% *#@%/$6 A!4(#(A#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!,, ("! !+)!&*4! &*+"6% @(1:(16 / &%7%"!G '6,'4,%86: !8! A!4(#(A#/!: @&()4%8. 9 # 1&5;(. #$(&("6 – >$( %F% @(/*+*$%4<"%. – 5>%"6% (1"(. ! $(. ?% "*5>"(. #@%2!*4!+*2!! (;&*"!>!'*4!#<, /*/ @&*'!4(, ()4*#$*%86: ()I%/$('. J*/, %#4! A!+!/! )(4<7% '"!8*"!, ()&*F*4! "* '(@&(#6, /*#*GF!%#, 8*$%&!!, %% #$&(%"!,, A(&8 %% #5F%#$'('*"!,, +*/("(8%&"(#$! @&!&(16 (@&!>!""(#$!), $( 5 )!(4(;(' ;(&*+1( @(4"%% ! (#"('*$%4<"%% @&%1#$*'4%"* A!4(#(A#/*, @&()4%8*$!/*, ($"(#,F*,#, / #(+1*"!G, %;( @&(!#:(?1%"!G, &*+'!$!G, %;( A5"/2!("!&('*"!G. J*/*, "*@&*'4%""(#$< A!4(#(A#/!: ()()F%"!. 5>%"6:– %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* ()5#4('!4* (@&%1%4%""5G #',+< !: #$!:!."(;( %#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* # A!4(#(A#/!8 8*$%&!*4!+8(8. B(",$"( @(E$(85, >$( 1%$*4<"(% #(@(#$*'4%"!% 8!&('(++&%"!, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. # A!4(#(A!%. ' 1*""(8 #45>*% @( "%():(1!8(#$! @&%1@(4*;*%$ #(($"%#%"!% !: A!4(#(A#/!: '+;4,1(' # #(($'%$#$'5GF!8! '(++&%"!,8! '!1"%.7!: A!4(#(A('-8*$%&!*4!#$(' XVII–XIX ''. – 0. QE/("*, J. =())#*, K. B&!#$4!, B. =*##%"1!, M.9. =%4<'%2!,, K. K!1&(, B.9. =(4<)*:*, M. *&/#*, 0. L";%4<#* ! 1&. H8%%$#, ' '!15 #&*'"!$%4<"6. *"*4!+ ("$(4(;!>%#/!:, *"$&(@(4(;!>%#/!: ! ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/!: *#@%/$(' ' 8!&('(++&%"!! 5>%"6: ! A!4(#(A('–8*$%&!*4!#$(', "( @&! E$(8 "*!)(4%% +"*>!8(. ' !##4%1('*"!! @&%1#$*'4,%$#, %;( ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/*, #(#$*'4,GF*, – @(#$(4"(. &%A4%/#!! ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, #*8(@(+"*"!! ' "%8, '( '$(&(. @(4('!"% XIX – "*>*4% XX ''. +*"!8*4* 2%"$&*4<"(% 8%#$( ' 8!&('(++&%"!!, ' @(+"*'*$%4<"(. @&*/$!/% A!4(#(A#$'5GF!: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., * &*'"( ! A!4(#(A('. B(/*+*$%4<"( ' E$(8 ($"(7%"!! 8"%"!% !+'%#$"(;( &5##/(;( A!4(#(A* $(;( '&%8%"! 9.H. C'%1%"#/(;(: «W#4! A!4(#(A!, 1%.#$'!$%4<"( #(#$*'4,%$ (#()5G "*5/5, $( $*/('(. %% 1%4*%$ $%(&!, @(+"*"!, ! %% #'(%()&*+"(%, ($4!>*GF%%#, ($ '#%: (#$*4<"6: "*5/, '4!,"!% "* "*7% 8!&('(++&%"!%. H"*>% #/*+*$<: (1"* 4!7< $%(&!, @(+"*"!, @&!1*%$ #4('5 «A!4(#(A!,» '@(4"% (@&%1%4%""(%, * '#4%1#$'!% E$(;(, ()F%(),+*$%4<"(% +"*>%"!%. B(E$(85, !+5>*, ! (2%"!'*, 4G)(;( A!4(#(A*, ' !#$!""(8, $.%. ()F%(),+*$%4<"(8 #86#4% E$(;( #4('*, "*1( ()&*F*$< @&%?1% '#%;( '%4!>*.7%% '"!8*"!% "* %;( $%(&!G @(+"*"!,» (58, #. 42). L$( ?% ' @(4"(. 8%&% 8(?"( ($"%#$! / !+5>%"!G ! (2%"/% 8!&('(++&%"!, 4G)(;( A!4(#(A#$'5GF%;( %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,. C*?"(#$<, @&!(&!$%$"*, '61%4%""(#$< ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/(. @&()4%8*$!/! (@&%1%4,%$#, @&%?1% '#%;( ()F%. +"*>!8(#$%#$', %% @&%!85F%#$'%""(. "*@&*'4%""(#$! "*
10
>%4('%>%#/!. A*/$(& ' #(($"(7%"!! 8!&* ! >%4('%/*, +*"!8*%$ 2%"$&*4<"(% 8%#$( ' A!4(#(A#/(8 @(+"*"!!. R* E$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'( ' #'(% '&%8, ()&*$!4 '"!8*"!% R.9. Q%&1,%': «B&()4%8% ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/(. )%##@(&"( @&!"*14%?!$ 2%"$&*4<"(% 8%#$( ' 58#$'%""(. ?!+"! "*7%. E@(:!. M&!$!>%#/*, ;"(#%(4(;!, – $(">*.7!. @4(1 58#$'%""(. /54<$5&6. !8( ;"(#%(4(;!!, %% #(8"%"!., %% '(@&(7%"!., %% +*@&%$(' @&(.$! "%4<+,» (21, #. 68-69). ="(#%(4(;!>%#/!. *#@%/$ ' *"*4!+% 8!&('(++&%"!, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. 1*%$ '(+8(?"(#$< "*!)(4%% ;45)(/( &*#/&6$< !1%."(% #(1%&?*"!% %#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8*. C8%#$% # $%8 !8%""( ' #A%&% ;"(#%(4(;!! A!4(#(A#$'('*"!% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. 1(#$*$(>"( (@&%1%4%""( ()"*&5?!'*%$ ((#()%""( ' /("2% XIX – "*>*4% XX ''.) ! +"*>!$%4<"6% !1%*4!#$!>%#/!% $%"1%"2!! (!1%*4!+8 «A!+!>%#/!.», «A!+!(4(;!>%#/!.», «E"%&;%$!+8»). R* !: (#"('% ' "*>*4% '%/* #4(?!4(#<, "*@&!8%&, @&%1#$*'4%"!% ( $(8, >$(, /*/ @!#*4 $(;1* &5##/!. A!+!/ 9. Q*>!"#/!., «;4*'"*, !+ !1%. 0!:$% '(+"!/*%$ ' &%+54<$*$% /&!$!>%#/(;( &*##8($&%"!, 8%$(1(' #('&%8%""(. A!+!/!, @&!'(1, / #!#$%8%, /($(&*,… @( #'(!8 !#$(>"!/*8 ! 8%$(15 ,'4,%$#, 1(#$*$(>"( #'(%()&*+"(., >$()6 "(#!$< (#()(% !8,: E$( – "*$5&*4!#$!>%#/!. !4! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. !1%*4!+8»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– >$( ;(&*+1( )(4%% #5F%#$'%""( –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
11
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–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– ' $(8 ?% ()F%8 A!4(#(A#/(8 /("$%/#$%, >$( ! #5?1%"!, =(4<)*:*, Q%&/4!, S8*, M*"$*, =%;%4, ! 1&. -%>< "! ' /(%. 8%&% "% !1%$ () *@%44,2!! / '6#/*+6'*"!,8 *&/#* /*/ / */#!(8*$!>%#/! )%##@(&"68, /*/ / !#$!"*8 ' @(#4%1"%. !"#$*"2!!. H8%%$#, ' '!15 @&%?1% '#%;( ()&*F%"!% / $(85 "%@&%:(1,F%85 ' A!4(#(A!! *&/#* (/*/ ! 4G)(;( 1&5;(;( '%4!/(;( 86#4!$%4, @&(74(;(), >$( "% @(1'%&?%"( /*@&!+*8 8(16, $&*"#A(&8*2!,8 /("IG"/$5&6, >$( '#%;1* (#$*%$#, '"% 1(;8*$!>%#/(. ! !1%(4(;!>%#/(. *)#(4G$!+*2!!, * !8%""( – / ;45)!"% ! #!4% !F5F%. A!4(#(A#/(. 86#4!, / %% !1%."68 ! /("2%@$5*4<"68 @&%$'(&%"!,8, / !: $%(&%$!>%#/(. +&%4(#$! ! 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/(.
12
(#"('*$%4<"(#$!, / 4(;!>%#/(. ,#"(#$! ! 5)%1!$%4<"(#$! *&;58%"$*2!! ' !: 1(/*+*$%4<"(8 &*+'%&$6'*"!!. K('4%/*GF!8 @()51!$%4<"68 8($!'(8 +1%#< ,'4,%$#, #$&%84%"!% / "*5>"(. ()I%/$!'"(#$! ! )%#@&!#$&*#$"(#$! – #$&%84%"!%, /($(&(% @()51!4(, "*@&!8%&, +"*8%"!$(;( &5##/(;( &%4!;!(+"(;( A!4(#(A*, )6'7%;( (' 8(4(1(#$!) 8*&/#!#$* R.9. Q%&1,%'* @&!+"*$< ' /("2% ?!+"!: « *&/#* , #>!$*4 ;%"!*4<"68 >%4('%/(8 ! #>!$*G ! #%.>*#» (20, #. 120). X#"(, >$( ;%"!*4<"(#$< *&/#* #(($'%$#$'5GF!8 ()&*+(8 &%*4!+('*4*#< ! ' %;( A!4(#(A!!, >$(, /#$*$!, $*/?% "*74( ($&*?%"!% ' %% )%#@&!#$&*#$"6: (2%"/*: ()I%/$!'"( 86#4,F!8! @&($!'"!/*8! 8*&/#!+8*. J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, M. B(@@%&, @&! '#%8 #'(%8 "%#(;4*#!! # @(#4%1"!8, $%8 "% 8%"%% #>%4 "%():(1!868 @(1>%&/"5$<: *&/# «"* 8"(;(% ($/&64 "*8 ;4*+* ! ()(#$&!4 "*7% +&%"!%… C(+'&*F%"!% / 1(8*&/#!#$#/(. ()F%#$'%""(. "*5/% 5?% "%86#4!8(. C#% #('&%8%""6% !##4%1('*$%4! @&()4%8 #(2!*4<"(. A!4(#(A!! (),+*"6 *&/#5, 1*?% %#4! ("! E$(;( "% (#(+"*G$. L$( (#()%""( '%&"( 14, $%:, /$( "% #(;4*#%" # %;( $%(&!,8!, /*/, "*@&!8%&, ,» (310, #. 98). H4!, #/*?%8, $*/(. 1*4%/!. ($ 8*&/#!+8* A!4(#(A, /*/ +"*8%"!$6. "%8%2/!. E/+!#$%"2!*4!#$ M. X#@%&# #$(4< ?% ()I%/$!'"( ($(+'*4#, ( 8*&/#!#$#/(. $%(&!! /*/ ( «$%(&!!, !8%GF%. E@(:*4<"(% +"*>%"!%» (420, #. 168). C #'%$% #/*+*""(;( '67% #$*"('!$#, (#()%""( (>%'!1"(. ()I%/$!'"*, "%():(1!8(#$< (#5F%#$'4%"!, *"*4!+* #(($"(#!86: # A!4(#(A!%. ("$(4(;!>%#/!: ! ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/!: 5#$*"('4%"!. ' 8!&('(++&%"!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ! >%&%+ #(($"%#%"!% E$!: 5#$*"('4%"!. # #(($'%$#$'5GF!8! A!4(#(A#/!8! '6'(1*8! M. *&/#*, * $*/?% – ' 8%&5 $(. ?% "%():(1!8(#$! – 0. L";%4<#* ! $*/!: '!1"%.7!: &5##/!: 8*&/#!#$(', /*/ =.C. B4%:*"(' ! C.H. D%"!". C A!4(#(A#/(. 4!$%&*$5&% "*>*4* '%/*, ' /*>%#$'% @&!8%&* $*/(;( #(($"%#%"!,, 8(?"( "*+'*$< &*)($6 X. Q%&8*"* (23), 0. 914%&* (421 #. 133-186), R. C*4%"$!"('* (54), L. O"$%&8*"* (365), D. C(4<$8*"* (69). P4%15%$, "*/("%2, ($8%$!$< %F% (1!" "%8*4('*?"6. ()I%/$ *"*4!+* ' &*8/*: ()(+"*>%""(. '67% @&()4%8*$!/!, * !8%""( –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– ($%>%#$'%""(. ! +*&5)%?"(. – @( ($"(7%"!G / "!8 @&%()4*1*%$ $($ ?% !"1!'!15*4<"6. @(1:(1, ( /($(&(8 &%>< 74* '67%, $( %#$< !: A!4(#(A#/!% '(++&%"!, !##4%15G$#, ($1%4<"( @( /*?1(85 !+ "!: (#8. "*@&., 422, 423, 432, 437-440, 445, 446). H8%%$ #86#4 @(E$(85 ! ' 1*""(8 #45>*% *@&()!&('*$< "*8%>%""6. ()()F*GF!. *"*4!+
13
A!4(#(A#/!:, ' >*#$"(#$!, ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/!: '(++&%"!. "*+'*""6: 5>%"6:. B&!4(?%"!%: @%&%>%"< &*)($ @( $%8% !##4%1('*"!,.
14
!"#$%&'"& 1. 9)&*7"%' . . W#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/!. 8*$%&!*4!+8 ! 1!*4%/$!/*. =(&"6. 8*$%&!*4!+8 ! 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/*, 1!*4%/$!/*. ., 1981. 3. 94%/#%%' B.C. R*5/* ! 8!&('(++&%"!%. ., 1983. 4. Q%4(' B.J. 0!4(#(A!, '61*GF!:#, &5##/!: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX – "*>*4* XX ''. ., 1970. 5. C*#!4<%' P.0. 0!4(#(A#/!% '(++&%"!, DG1'!;* Q(4<28*"* //H+ !#$(&!! "*5>"6: 8!&('(++&%"!.. .–D., 1935. 6. C%1%"(' .0. Q(&<)* L. =%//%4, +* 8*$%&!*4!+8 ' )!(4(;!!. ., 1963. 7. C%&8%4< W. . H#$(&!, 5>%"!, ( /4%$/%. ., 1970. 8. =&*"('#/!. C.D. =%&8*" =%4<8;(4<2 (W;( ?!+"< ! &*)($*). ., 1930. 9. =&!;(&<," 9.J., C,4<2%' 9.R. =%"&!: =%&2. ., 1968. 10. =54( K.K. R!/(4*. 94%/#%%'!> O8('. ., 1971. 11. M*;*"(' C. . !&('(++&%"!% H. . P%>%"('*. ., 1948. 12. M*&4!/ D.R. M4(1 Q%&"*& (1813–1878). ., 1964. 13. M(4(8!%2 J.9. M("2%@2!, >%4('%/* '( A&*"25+#/(8 8*$%&!*4!+8% XVIII '%/*. M!%', 1978. 14. M(8@*"%%2 9.H. Q(&<)* R.9. O8('* +* 8*$%&!*4!+8 ' A!+!/%. ., 1954. 15. M5&(%1(' 9.H. Q(&<)* '61*GF!:#, 5>%"6: +* 8*$%&!*4!+8 ' )!(4(;!!. ., 1966. 16. D*+*&%' B.B. =%4<8;(4<2. ., 1959. 17. D%)%1!"#/!. 9.C. =%4<8;(4<2 (1821–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–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. //K!*4%/$!/* #(+"*"!, ! )%##(+"*$%4<"(;(. %?'5+('#/!. #)(&"!/ "*5>"6: $&51('. D., 1988. 26. 3#!@(' C.H. B&()4%8* A*/$* ' '(++&%"!,: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. #%&%1!"6 XIX – "*>*4* XX ''. //0*/$6 ' #!#$%8% @(+"*"!,. %?'5+('#/!. #)(&"!/ "*5>"6: $&51('. C(4(;1*, 1988.
15
27. 3#!@(' C.H. P*8(#(+"*"!% %#$%#$'(+"*"!,: ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/!. *#@%/$ //P*8(#(+"*"!% ' A!4(#(A!!. %?'5+('#/!. #)(&"!/ "*5>"6: $&51('. D., 1987. 28. 3#!@(' C.H. 3#()%""(#$! #$&5/$5&6 A!4(#(A#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, 5>%"6:–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– !#$(&!>%#/*, ()5#4('4%""(#$< //[%""(#$"6% 1%$%&8!"*2!! ' "*5>"(8 @(+"*"!!. %?'5+('#/!. #)(&"!/ "*5>"6: $&51('. C(4(;1*, 1984. 34. B%$4%"/( C.B. 0!+!(4(;!>%#/!. !1%*4!+8 ! "%/($(&6% A!4(#(A#/!% '(@&(#6 $%(&%$!>%#/(. 8%1!2!"6. D., 1960. 35. B4*$("(' =.C. K*&'!", 1*&'!"!+8 ! A!4(#(A!,. ., 1959. 36. B4*$("(' =.C. !&('(++&%"!% M.9. J!8!&,+%'*. ., 1952. 37. -(1"6. R.H., P(4('<%' S.H. C!4<;%4<8 3#$'*4<1. ., 1969. 38. P%&1G/(' 9.-. B%$& R!/(4*%'!> D%)%1%'. ., 1978. 39. P(8!"#/!. .P. 94%/#*"1& =&!;(&<%'!> P$(4%$('. D., 1970. 40. 0(;%4< =. W#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. 8*$%&!*4!+8 ' A!4(#(A#/!: &*)($*: B4*"/* ! Q(&"* //C(@&(#6 A!4(#(A!!. 1974, Z 3. 41. T/5&!"(' B.P. B(+!$!'!+8 ' -(##!! XIX '%/*. ., 1980. 42. T5;*.4!" 9.C. C61*GF!.#, A!+!/–8*$%&!*4!#$ B.R. D%)%1%'. ., 1980.
16
@3;5; I 0=3242A=9 = B=8252CC8DE=D: ;E;3=C >2E9F=G B&%?1% >%8 @&!#$5@*$< / 1%$*4<"(85 *"*4!+5 A!4(#(A#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, /("/&%$"6: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX – "*>*4* XX ''. ' #(($"%#%"!! # #(($'%$#$'5GF!8! '(++&%"!,8! /("/&%$"6: A!4(#(A(' @&(74(;( 2%4%#(()&*+"(, "* "*7 '+;4,1, #"*>*4* >%$/( ()(+"*>!$< – :($, )6 ' *)#$&*/$"(. A(&8%, ' #:%8*$!>%#/(8 "*)&(#/% – (#"('"6% @&!"2!@!*4<"6% 8(8%"$6 '#%. !##4%15%8(. @&()4%8*$!/! ! # E$(. 2%4$()6 "* E$(. (#"('% &*+'%&"5$< #()#$'%""(% 4(;!>%#/(% ()(#"('*"!% A5"/2!("*4<"(. – @($%"2!*4<"(. ! */$5*4<"(. – +"*>!8(#$! A!4(#(A!! @&!8%"!$%4<"( / 8!&('(++&%"!G %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%.. P4%15%$ @(1>%&/"5$<, >$( (#"('"*, +*1*>* $*/(;( &(1* !##4%1('*"!, –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«D!)( 86 >!$*%8 A!4(#(A(' @&(74(;( $*/, >$()6 #1%4*$< !: &%4%'*"$"68! #('&%8%""68 @&()4%8*8 ! +*",$!,8, @&%'&*F*, !:, "*#/(4%8 ("! )64! )6 /*/ >*#$< "6"%7"%. A!4(#(A!!.., 4!)(, "*@&($!', 86 +*)($!8#, ( $(8, >$()6 >!$*$< !: ' #()#$'%""6: $%&8!"*:» (442, #. 31). H 8(?"( #(;4*#!$<#, # @&%14*;*%868 &%7%"!%8 E$(. 1!4%886: "%():(1!8( «'(#@&!",$< A!4(#(A#/(% @&(74(% A!4(#(A#/! ! ' $( ?% '&%8, !#$(&!>%#/!» ($*8 ?%, #. 40). J*/(. A!4(#(A#/!-!#$(&!>%#/!. @(1:(1 ' %;( @%&#("!A!2!&('*""(. &%*4!+*2!! ! #(#$*'!$ (#"('5 @(#4%15GF!: 5#$*"('4%"!., * ( $(8, "*#/(4*$ !8, () E$(8, %#4! '(()F% %#$< $*/*, "%():(1!8(#$<, #4%15%$ ;('(&!$< (#()(. § 1. $82H3DB; A=3242A==: E;6<; =3= F528ID4F52? P5F"(#$< A!4(#(A!! "%(@&%1%4!8* ' $(8 #86#4%, >$( %% "%'(+8(?"( @(",$!."( +*A!/#!&('*$< ' (1"(+"*>"(., @&!%84%8(. 14, )(4<7!"#$'* )%##@(&"(. 1%A!"!2!!: #4!7/(8 8"(;( &*+"(/*>%#$'%""6: #(#$(,"!. A!4(#(A#/(;( +"*"!,, A!4(#(A#/!: #!#$%8, 7/(4, "*@&*'4%"!., 5>%"!. (@&%1%4!4(#< ' &*+"(% '&%8,, "* &*+"6: E$*@*: &*+'!$!, A!4(#(A!! '
17
&*+"6: #$&*"*:. L$!8 ()5#4('4!'*%$#, "%!+)%?"*, &*#@46'>*$(#$< @(",$!, «A!4(#(A!,», #86#4('*, >%&%#@(4(#!2* ' %;( &%*4<"(8 5@($&%)4%"!!. «R*+'*"!% A!4(#(A!! !4! «A!4(#(A#/(%», – @!#*4 C. K!4<$%., – !8%%$ $*/!% &*+4!>"6% +"*>%"!,, ' +*'!#!8(#$! ($ '&%8%"! ! 8%#$*, ! $*/ 8"(;(($4!>"6 15:('"6% ()&*+('*"!,, ()(+"*>*'7!%#, !: *'$(&*8! E$!8 !8%"%8, >$( 8(?"( 158*$<, >$( ' &*+4!>"6% '&%8%"* @&%/&*#"(%, @&!158*""(% ;&%/*8! #4('( «A!4(#(A!,» @&!8%",4(#< / &*+4!>"68 15:('"68 ()&*+('*"!,8. …=1% ?% '"5$&%"",, #',+<, ()I%1!",GF*, #$(4< &*+4!>"6% ($$%"/! @(",$!, A!4(#(A!!, #$(4< &*+4!>"6% @&%1#$*'4%"!, ( "%., ;1% %1!"*, #5F"(#$< A!4(#(A!!? W#4! ("* "% 8(?%$ )6$< "*.1%"*, $( 86, (>%'!1"(, )51%8 !8%$< 1%4( 4!7< # &*+4!>"68! @&(,'4%"!,8!, '6#$5@*'7!8! @&! !+8%",GF!:#, !#$(&!>%#/!: 5#4('!,: /*/ @($&%)"(#$< /54<$5&6 ! 4!7< '"%7"%, )4*;(1*&, !#$(&!>%#/! #45>*."(85 "*!8%"('*"!G, (/*+*'7!8!#, #',+*""68! ()F!8 "*!8%"('*"!%8 – 86 )51%8 !8%$< A!4(#(A!!, "( "% )51%$ A!4(#(A!!» (148, #. 1-2). 3$#G1* ! A*/$!>%#/*, "%(@&%1%4%""(#$< ! +*'%1(8*, "%(@&%1%4!8(#$< @(",$!, A!4(#(A!!, %% #5F"(#$!, "%(@&%1%4!8(#$<, (>%'!1"*, @&%?1% '#%;( 14, #*8!: A!4(#(A('. J*/, (1!" !+ "!:, !+'%#$"6. "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A C. C!"1%4<)*"1 @!#*4 ' /("2% XIX '%/*: «R*+'*"!, !8%G$ #'(G #51<)5, "( &%1/(% !+ "!: !8%4( #51<)5 #$(4< #$&*""5G, /*/ #4('( «A!4(#(A!,». W#4! 86 ()&*$!8#, / !#$(&!! # '(@&(#(8 ( $(8, >$( #()#$'%""( %#$< A!4(#(A!, ! #@&*'!8#, 5 4G1%., /($(&6: "*+6'*4! ! $%@%&< %F% "*+6'*G$ A!4(#(A*8!, () !: '(++&%"!,: "* @&%18%$ !: +*",$!., $( 86 @(45>!8 #*86% &*+"(()&*+"6% ! )%#/("%>"( 1*4%/( ($#$(,F!% 1&5; ($ 1&5;* ($'%$6; $*/ >$( @(@6$/! '6&*+!$< E$( @%#$&(% 8"(;(()&*+!% ' (1"(. @&(#$(. A(&854% ! @(1'%#$! '#G E$5 "%(@&%1%4%""5G 8*##5 ,'4%"!. @(1 %1!"(% @(",$!% )64( )6 1%4(8 #('%&7%""( )%+"*1%?"68» (54, #. 1). R( ' &*8/*: $(;( !4! !"(;( /("/&%$"(;( #(#$(,"!, A!4(#(A#$'('*"!,, "* @&!#5F%8 %85 !"$%44%/$5*4<"(8 ! #(1%&?*$%4<"(8 5&('"% "%!+)%?"( @&(,#",%$#, 4(/*4!+('*""(% 4!>"68 !"$%&%#(8 A!4(#(A* #'(% 4!>"(% #5F"(#$"(% @("!8*"!% #*8(. A!4(#(A!!, &%*4!+5GF%%#, ' #(($'%$#$'5GF%8 (@&%1%4%"!! %% #5F"(#$!. L$( ' @(4"(. 8%&% 8(?"( ($"%#$! ! / A!4(#(A!! &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( @%&!(1*. 31!" !+ %% @&%1#$*'!$%4%. "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A 3. MG4<@%, !8%, ' '!15 &*+"(()&*+!% (@&%1%4%"!. A!4(#(A!! ' @&(74(8, @&!'%1, @&! E$(8 8"(;(>!#4%""6% /("/&%$"6% @&!8%&6, 1%4*%$ '6'(1: «X#"(, >$( '#% E$! "('%.7!% (@&%1%4%"!, "% #$(4%#/(8 ,'4%"!!, #/(47!. #@(#() A!4(#(A#$'('*"!, ' !: E@(:5. B(E$(85 E$! (@&%1%4%"!, @&%1#$*'4,G$#, "*8 #/(&%% @&(;&*88*8! (@&%1%4%""6: #!#$%8, 51*>"68 &%+G8% +*1*> ($1%4<"6: A!4(#(A(', >%8 @(@6$/*8! '6&*+!$< ' ()F%(),+*$%4<"(. A(&854% '"%'&%8%""5G #5F"(#$< A!4(#(A!!» (182, #. 11).
18
B(",$"6 @(E$(85 #%$('*"!, A!4(#(A(', "*@&!8%&, 9. -!4, "* ()!4!% ! &*+"(()&*+!% (@&%1%4%"!. A!4(#(A!!, %% +*1*>, ' >*#$"(#$!, "* $(, >$( «&*+4!>!,8 ' A!4(#(A#/!: #!#$%8*: #(($'%$#$'5%$ @(>$! #$(4< ?% )(4<7(% &*+"(()&*+!% ' @("!8*"!! ! (@&%1%4%"!! ()F%. +*1*>! A!4(#(A!!. P$(4/"('%"!, A!4(#(A#/!: "*@&*'4%"!. "*>!"*G$#, "% $(4"6: #!#$%8, "( 1*?% # (@&%1%4%"!, A!4(#(A!!» (230, #. 3). C $( ?% '&%8, 1&5;!% A!4(#(A6, ' >*#$"(#$!, =. V!88%4<, @(18%$!4!, >$( «$(4"(#$< ' @("!8*"!! A!4(#(A!! ()"*&5?!'*%$#, ' &*+"6: *#@%/$*: ! @&%?1% '#%;( – ' (@&%1%4%"!! %% #5F"(#$!, ' @(!#/*: ($'%$* "* '(@&(#: >$( %#$< A!4(#(A!,? R*5/*? J'(&>%#$'(? !&('(++&%"!%? N$(-$( %F%? B&! E$(8 )(4<7*, >*#$< &%7%"!. #(#&%1($(>!'*%$#, ' &*8/*: *4<$%&"*$!'6 «"*5/* !4! $'(&>%#$'(» – ' @4*"% 5$'%&?1%"!, (1"(;( ! !#/4G>%"!, 1&5;(;(: A!4(#(A!, %#$< "*5/*, "( "% $'(&>%#$'( !4!, "*()(&($, – $'(&>%#$'(, "( "% "*5/*. B%&'5G @(+!2!G ' #'(% '&%8, >%$/( ()(+"*>!4 =%;%4<: « (!8 "*8%&%"!%8 )64( – #@(#()#$'('*$< @&!)4!?%"!G A!4(#(A!! / A(&8% "*5/! – / $(. 2%4!, 1(#$!;"5' /($(&(. ("* 8(;4* )6 ($/*+*$<#, ($ #'(%;( !8%"! 74<9' 6 ,"%"'4 ! )6$< 5*=1-9'-*78".: ,"%"'*:» (81, #. 3). 3#$*'!8 ' #$(&("% $(, "*#/(4*%, #$( 4%$ #@5#$,, L. =5##%&4<, /*/ )6 ($'%>*, =%;%4G, #>%4 "5?"68 /("#$*$!&('*$<: «X "% ;('(&G, >$( A!4(#(A!, – "%#('%&7%""*, "*5/*, , ;('(&G @&(#$(, >$( ("* %F% '('#% "% "*5/*, >$( ' /*>%#$'% "*5/! ("* %F% "% "*>!"*4*#<…» (136, #. 2) . C ()(!: #5?1%"!,:, ($'4%/*,#< ($ &*+"(;4*#!, ' "!:, '61%4!8 ()F5G @&!"2!@!*4<"5G 5#$*"('/5: "*+"*>%"!% A!4(#(A!! – )6$< "*5/(., A!4(#(A!,, %#4! %F% ! "% ,'4,%$#,, $(, '( '#,/(8 #45>*%, 1(4?"* )6$< "*5/(., «$(>"(. "*5/(.», «1%.#$'!$%4<"68 +"*"!%8». L$5 @&!"2!@!*4<"5G 5#$*"('/5 ' @("!8*"!! A!4(#(A!! '!1"6. "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A C. C!"1%4<)*"1 #A(&854!&('*4 #4%15GF!8 ()&*+(8: «…C6#7!8 @(",$!%8 @( ($"(7%"!G / A!4(#(A!! #45?!$ @(",$!% "*5/!» (64, #. 2). H /*/ )6 ' &*+'!$!% E$(;( !#:(1"(;( $%+!#* 0. B*54<#%" ($8%$!4, >$( # "*5/*8! «A!4(#(A!, !8%%$ ()F%G $(>/(. ($@&*'4%"!, &*##51(>"(% @("!8*"!% 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!; ("* – "*5/*» (298, #. 15). R( @&! '#%8 $(8 C A!4(#(A#/(. 4!$%&*$5&% '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX – "*>*4* XX ''. 8(?"( ()"*&5?!$< /("#$*$*2!G ! $&%$<%. @&!"2!@!*4<"(. @(+!2!! ' &*##8*$&!'*%8(8 '(@&(#%: A!4(#(A!, ;>* @%&%#$*4* (!4! @%&%#$*%$) )6$< "*5/(.. J*/('(, "*@&!8%&, 8"%"!% &5##/(;( A!4(#(A* C. D%#%'!>*: ' @&(2%##% &*+'!$!, @(+"*"!, «1%4( 74( #*8( #()(., "%51%&?!8( ! )%#@('(&($"(, / 5@&*+1"%"!G A!4(#(A!! /*/ ($1%4<"(. "*5/!… 0!4(#(A!,, @%&%#$*' )6$< ($1%4<"(. "*5/(., @&("!/4* #()(G '#% "*5/!, &*#$'(&!4*#< ' !: #(1%&?*"!!, #$*4* "% "*5/(G A!4(#(A!%G, * A!4(#(A!%G "*5/ !4! "*5>"(G A!4(#(A!%G» (209, #. 14-15).
19
A!4(#(A!, '#% ?% – "*5/* #@%2!A!>%#/*,, /*>%#$'%""( ($4!>"*, ($ 1&5;!: "*5/. O "%% !"6% 8%$(16, 1&5;!% +*1*>!. «V*1*>* "*5/! #(#$(!$ ' $(8, >$()6 @5$%8 8%$(1!>%#/(;( (@6$* 1()6$< #'%1%"!, ( A*/$*:; +*1*>* ?% A!4(#(A!! #(#$(!$, "*@&($!', ' $(8, >$()6 @5$%8 #'(.#$'%""(;( %. 8%$(1* @(/*+*$< @(14!""5G #5F"(#$< ! '"5$&%""GG #',+< '%F%.» ($*8 ?%, #. 16). H $5 ?% :*&*/$%&!#$!/5 #@%2!A!>%#/(. "*5>"(#$! A!4(#(A!! '61%4,%$ 9. %##%&, (@&%1%4,, @&! E$(8 A!4(#(A!G /*/ «&%*4<"5G "*5/5, +*1*>* /($(&(. – @(#$!>< #5F"(#$< 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!, @(#/(4"(, !"$%44%/$5*4<"*, @(1(@4%/* #@%2!A!>%#/(. "*5>"(#$! A!4(#(A!! ($"G1< "% !#/4G>*%$ ! %% (@&%1%4%""(. @&!>*#$"(#$! / @(+"*'*$%4<"(85 (#'(%"!G $(;( A*/$!>%#/(;( 8*$%&!*4*, # /($(&68 !8%G$ 1%4( 1&5;!% "*5/!, "* >$( $*/?% ()&*F*4! '"!8*"!% A!4(#(A6 &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( @%&!(1*. J*/, @( 8"%"!G *8%&!/*"#/(;( A!4(#(A* 9.M. -(1?%&#*, A!4(#(A!, "*5>"* @&%?1% '#%;( @($(85, >$( !8%%$ $5 ?% ()I%/$!'"5G @(+"*'*$%4<"5G – A*/$5*4<"5G – (#"('5, >$( ! "*5/*. «K*""6%, /($(&68! @(4<+5%$#, A!4(#(A, '('#% "% #($/*"6 !8 !+ #()#$'%""(. ;(4('6 ! "% ,'4,G$#, >!#$68 @&(15/$(8 !"$%44%/$5*4<"(;( $'(&>%#$'*, – "%$, E$( – $% #*86% A*/$6, # /($(&68! @&!:(1!$#, !8%$< 1%4( "*5/%…» (332, #. 6). 9 "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A–/*"$!*"%2 9. -!4<, "*#$*!'*, "* "%():(1!8(#$! (;&*"!>%"!, A!4(#(A!! #A%&(. $%(&!! @(+"*"!,, 5$'%&?1*4, >$( «A!4(#(A!, ' 7!&(/(8 #86#4% #4('* @&(#$( #('@*1*%$ $%@%&< # "*#$(,F%. "*5/(G; * '+,$*, ' )(4%% $%#"(8 +"*>%"!!, ()&*+5%$ !+'%#$"5G (#()5G "*5/5 "*&,15 #( '#%8! @&(>!8!» (331, #. 13). J(>"( $*/ ?% Q. U&!#$!*"#%" #>!$*4, >$( «$%(&!, @(+"*"!, @&*'(8(>"* ! "%():(1!8* ' /*>%#$'% #*8(#$(,$%4<"(. "*5/!» (390, #. 13). 9. C'%1%"#/!. $(?% "*#$*!'*4 "* $(8, >$( A!4(#(A!, ' (#"('"(. #'(%. – ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/(. – !@(#$*#! «8(?%$ )6$< (@&%1%4%"* /*/ "*5/* ( "%#(8"%""(8 @(+"*"!!» (55, #. 1). K&5;!% A!4(#(A6, 5?% )%+ '#,/!: (;('(&(/, (1"(+"*>"( @(#$54!&('*4! "*5>"6. #$*$5# A!4(#(A!!: ("*, @( !: 8"%"!G, )64* ! (#$*%$#, "*5/(., $(4!$*4, >$( «&'7!1!&'( 6%6 0'1-!* ,"%"'* !8%%$ @(4(?!$%4<"6% +*1*>! ! #$&(!$#, "* $'%&16: (#"('*"!,:», @(E$(85 ("* «"% @&($!'(@(#$*'4,%$ #%), ' #'(%8 !#/4G>!$%4<"(8 @(4(?%"!! 1&5;!8 "*5/*8, @($(85 >$( ("* #*8* – "*5/*…» (397, #. 2-3). H ' 1*4<"%.7%8 E$* @(+!2!, @&(1(4?*4* 5$'%&?1*$<#, ' /*$%;(&!>%#/!: #5?1%"!,: #'(!: #$(&(""!/(', $*/!:, "*@&!8%&, /*/ C.R. H'*"('#/!., @(4*;*'7!., >$( «A!4(#(A!, – ' (#"('% #'(%. – %#$< "%;6%… ' !+'%#$"6: ($"(7%"!,: 91*!!% ($ (#$*4<"6: – >*#$"6:, !4! #@%2!*4<"6: "*5/» (160, #. 48). H /*/ @(1>%&/"54 !+'%#$"6. "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A ! @#!:(4(; C. C5"1$, «A!4(#(A!, %#$< '#%()F*, "*5/*, !8%GF*, #'(%G 2%4!'5G #!#$%85 @(+"*"!,, 1()6$6% #@%2!*4<"68!
20
"*5/*8! ! #'%#$! '#%()F!% 5@($&%)4,%86% "*5/(G 8%$(16 ! @&%1@(#64/! @(+"*"!, / !: @&!"2!@*8» (71, #. 15). C &*+'!$!% E$(;( 5#$*"('4%"!, 8(?"( @&!'%#$! #(($'%$#$'5GF%% #5?1%"!% 9. C(#/&%#%"#/(;(, #>!$*'7%;(, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( «A!4(#(A!,, /*/ 5>%"!% ( @&!"2!@*:.., "% #(#$*'4,%$, ' #$&(;(8 #86#4%, /*/(.-"!)51< "*5/!, !##4%15GF%. (#()5G ()4*#$< @(+"*'*%8(;( )6$!,, – ("* #(%1!",%$ ' #%)% '#% ($1%4<"6% "*5/! !, $*/ #/*+*$<, @&!'(1!$ !: / (1"(85 +"*8%"*$%4G, / (1"(. ()F%. «"*5/% "*5/» (20, #. 5). H @($(85, #>!$*4 =. -*?(, «8(?"( (@&%1%4!$< A!4(#(A!G, /*/ «5"!'%&#*4<"5G "*5/5», !)( ("* &*"<7% '#%;( %#$< '#%()()F%"!% "*5/!» (318, #. 1). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, @&%1#$*'4%"!% ( A!4(#(A!! /*/ "%;6* – ' &*+"6: %;( /("/&%$!+*2!,: – !8%%$ 1*'"GG $&*1!2!G ! 1(#$*$(>"( 8"(;( #$(&(""!/('. R(, # 1&5;(. #$(&("6, #$(4< ?% 1*'"( ! #$(4< ?% @&(>"( 5$'%&1!4*#< – # #(($'%$#$'5GF!8! ()(#"('*"!,8! – ! @&($!'(@(4(?"*, @(+!2!,: A!4(#(A!, – "% "*5/*, ("* @( #5$! #'(%. – $'(&>%#$'( ('*&!*"$6: !#/5##$'(, @(E+!,). J*/, 5@(8,"5$6. 5?% 9. -!4< "%#(#$(,$%4<"(#$< @&%?"!: A!4(#(A#/!: #!#$%8 (P@!"(+6, 0!:$%, =%;%4,, T(@%";*5E&*) 5#8*$&!'*4 !8%""( ' @(4"(8 ($#5$#$'!! ' "!: "*5>"(;( /*>%#$'*, ' @&%()4*1*"!! :51(?%#$'%""(;(, $'(&>%#/(;( "*>*4*: «0!4(#(A#/!% #!#$%86 ' #*8(8 /(&"% #'(%8 – +*)45?1%"!%. 3"! ()4*1*G$ %1!"#$'(8 :51(?%#$'%""(;( @&(!+'%1%"!,, !#/5##$'%""68 %1!"#$'(8 ! @($(85 @(:(?! )(4<7% "* #(+1*"!, A*"$*+!!, >%8 "*5/!. 3"! ' 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! $(, >$( P(A!, \%&8%" $*/ 51*>"( "*+'*4* «&(8*"*8! 86#4!$%4%.» (330, #. 6). J5 ?% :51(?%#$'%""(#$< A!4(#(A!!, /*/ @&%$'(&%"!% $'(&>%#/(;( "*>*4* ' "%., "( 5?% ' @(+!$!'"(8 @4*"% – /*/ %% (>%'!1"(% 1(#$(!"#$'( – 5#8*$&!'*4 '!1"6. &5##/!. A!4(#(A R.X. =&($: «0!4(#(A!,, /*/ #!"$%+, /*/ ($&*?%"!% #5)I%/$!'"(;(, /*/ &%+54<$*$ $'(&>%#$'* ! %#$< !#/5##$'(, * "% "*5/*» (133, #. 29). 3)I,#",%$#, E$( @&%()4*1*"!%8 ' A!4(#(A!! 4!>"(#$"(;(, #5)I%/$!'"(;( "*>*4*, ()5#4('4!'*GF%;( >%&%+ A!4(#(A#$'('*"!% &%*4!+*2!G $'(&>%#/!: @($%"2!. >%4('%>%#/(;( &*+58*. M *"*4(;!>"(85 '6'(15, "( # !"(. *&;58%"$*2!%. @&!7%4 ' #'(% '&%8, ! R.9. Q%&1,%': «0!4(#(A!, – !#/5##$'(, @($(85 >$( ("* – $'(&>%#$'(. 0!4(#(A!, – !#/5##$'(, @($(85 >$( ("* @&%1@(4*;*%$ (#()6. 1*& #'67% ! @&!+'*"!%, @($(85 >$( "* "%. +*@%>*$4%'*%$#, 4!>"(#$< $'(&2* "% 8%"%% >%8 "* @(E+!! ! ?!'(@!#!. R( A!4(#(A!, $'(&!$ )6$!.#$'%""6% !1%!, * "% ()&*+6. @'7!1!&'( *1-8 '16;11-9! 2!,"%"'( 9 19!/5 +&%"!, &*+1%4,4! $(;1* ! "%/($(&6% 1&5;!% A!4(#(A6. J*/, @( 8"%"!G L.D. -*14('*, «A!4(#(A!, %#$< (#()*, #A%&* 15:('"(;( $'(&>%#$'* >%4('%/*, ($4!>"*, ($ ()4*#$! "*5>"(.…» (315, #. 11). B(+1"%% #:(1"5G @(+!2!G ' @("!8*"!! A!4(#(A!! +*",4 D. C!$;%"7$%.": «B(4*;*G, >$( 8(% ($"(7%"!% / A!4(#(A!! #588*&"( 8(?"( '6&*+!$< $*/: A!4(#(A!G, @( #5$!, 8(?"( $(4!$ A*/$!>%#/! (#$*'!$< +* @&%1%4*8! A!4(#(A!! !"$%44%/$5*4<"5G
21
1%,$%4<"(#$< @( 5#$*"('4%"!G 1%.#$'!$%4<"(;( #5F"(#$"(;( +"*"!,, $( %#$< !#/4G>!$< ' "%., A!4(#(A!!, '#,/5G "*5>"(#$<. M&(8% 1'5: ($8%>%""6: '67% @(1:(1(' / @("!8*"!G A!4(#(A!!, / (@&%1%4%"!G %% #$*$5#* (A!4(#(A!, – $(4%#$'() )6$('*4!, /("%>"(, ! 1&5;!%, ' >*#$"(#$!, ! $*/(., @&! /($(&(8 A!4(#(A!, &*##8*$&!'*4*#< "% /*/ >$(-$( !-5*78"!*, E4%8%"$*&"(% ' 15:('"(. /54<$5&% ("*5/*, !#/5##$'( ! $. @.), * /*/ "%>$( !%#/(% "*>*4( ' A!4(#(A!! &*+"68! A!4(#(A*8! &*#@&(#$&*",4(#< "* &*+"6% /("/&%$"6% #(#$(,"!, 8!&*, "* &*+"6% #A%&6 )6$!, ' "%8, @5$! ! A(&86 %;( (#'(%"!, >%4('%/(8: ' (1"!: #45>*,: – ! "* @&!&(15, ! "* ()F%#$'(, ! "* 15:('"5G ?!+"<, ' 1&5;!: – 4!)( $(4%#/(8 /*>%#$'% (:'*$6'*%$ ! @&!&(15, ! 15:('"5G, ! ()F%#$'%""5G ?!+"< >%4('%/*: ("*, A!4(#(A!,, %#$< «%1!"(% 8!&('(++&%"!%, ' (1!"*/('(. 8%&% 1*GF%% ($>%$ ( ,'4%"!,: @&!&(16 ! ,'4%"!,: 15:('"(. ?!+"!, ( +*/("*: ()I%/$!'"(;( 8!&* ! ( +*/("*: >%4('%>%#/!: #$&%84%"!.» (180, #. 14). C ($4!>!% ($ E$(;( *'#$&!.#/!. A!4(#(A C. H%&5+*4%8 (;&*"!>!4 8!&('(++&%">%#/(% "*>*4( ' A!4(#(A!! #A%&(. 15:('"(. ?!+"! – 86#4!$%4<"68 (#'(%"!%8 @('#%1"%'"(;( (@6$* ! "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. «0!4(#(A!, %#$< &*)($* 8674%"!,, @&%1@&!"!8*%8*, # $%8, >$()6 #(%1!"!$< @('#%1"%'"6. ?!+"%""6. (@6$ ! &%+54<$*$6 "*5>"(;( !##4%1('*"!, ' %1!"(% 4!7%""(% @&($!'(&%>!. 8!&('(++&%"!% ! #@(#()"*, 51('4%$'(&!$< @($&%)"(#$! @("!8*"!, ! $&%)('*"!, 15:*» (162, #. 1). K&5;*, @(+!2!, ' 1*""(8 '(@&(#%, @&%1@(4*;*GF*, (;&*"!>%"!% A!4(#(A!!, /*/ ()I%1!",GF%;( 8!&('(++&%"!,, #A%&(. (1"(;( "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, ' %;( @&%!85F%#$'%""(. "*@&*'4%""(#$! "* @&!&(15 ! ()F%#$'%""5G ?!+"< @&%1#$*'4%"* ' $*/(8, "*@&!8%&, 5$'%&?1%"!! 9. C%)%&*: «B&%18%$ A!4(#(A!! #(#$(!$ ' !+6#/*"!! ()F%;( 8!&('(++&%"!, "* '#%4%""5G ! "* !#$(&!G; #()#$'%""( ;('(&,, A!4(#(A!, "% #(#$*'4,%$ ($1%4<"(. "*5/!, ("* #('8%F*%$ '#% +"*"!, ! #'(1!$ !: / %1!"#$'5, / (1"(. ()F%. "*5/%» (59, #. 1). R%>$( @(1()"(% 5$'%&?1*4 ! H.H. 0(8!": «0!4(#(A!G 86 (@&%1%4!4! /*/ @(@6$/5 '6&*)($*$< 2%4<"(% "*5>"(% 8!&(#(+%&2*"!%; 14, E$(;( ("* !##4%15%$ @&%1@(#64/! '#%: >*#$"6: "*5/…» (383, #. 18). C. K!4<$%., !8%, ' '!15 ()!4!% ! /*>%#$'%""(% &*+"(()&*+!% $&*/$('(/ "*5>"(#$! A!4(#(A#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!,, @%&%>!#4,%$ "%/($(&6% !+ "!:, "*!)(4%% :*&*/$%&"6%: «…31"! @("!8*G$ @(1 A!4(#(A!%. (#"('(@(4(?%"!% ($1%4<"6: "*5/; 1&5;!% &*#7!&,G$ E$( @(",$!%
22
A!4(#(A!!, @&!#('(/5@4,, / @(",$!G () (#"('(@(4(?%"!! ($1%4<"6: "*5/ %F% ! +*1*>5 "*:(?1%"!, @&! %% @(8(F! #',+! 8%?15 ($1%4<"68! "*5/*8!; $&%$"(, @&(14!$< E$($ @%&%>%"<, '/4G>!' ' "%;( ! $*/!% (@&%1%4%"!, 8!&('(++&%">%#/(;( #$*$5#* A!4(#(A!!, ' /($(&6:, "*&,15 # "*5>"68, +*1%.#$'('*"6 ! !"6% A*/$(&6. J*/, # $(>/! +&%"!, =.H. *&/%4('*, A!4(#(A!,, /*/ ()F%% 8!&('(++&%"!%, ()I%1!",%$ ' #%)%, "*&,15 # "*5/(., ! '#% 1&5;!% (#"('"6% #A%&6 15:('"(;( -9!$0*1-9%: «0!4(#(A!, %#$< ()I%1!",GF%% "*>*4(. J(4%#$'*, $(4%#$'*, "* @&!+"*"!! /*>%#$'%""(;( ($4!>!, A!4(#(A!! ($ "!:, %% "%#'(1!8(#$! "! / (1"(. !+ "!:, "! / ()F%85 ' "!:. 0!4(#(A!, "% %#$< >$(-$( !-5*78"!* ("*5/*, !#/5##$'(, &%4!;!,) !4! !$( !1!<*""!*, #5;5)( #@%2!A!>%#/(%, #*8(1('4%GF%% ! #*8(1(#$*$(>"(%. J*/, !+'%#$"6. &5##/!. A!4(#(A Q.C. X/('%"/( #>!$*4, >$( A!4(#(A!, 1(4?"* ()&%$*$<#, '"% &%4!;!!, '"% !#/5##$'*, '"% "*5/! ! 5$'%&?1*4, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( «$*8, ;1% "*>!"*%$#, A!4(#(A!,, &%4!;!(+"(% $'(&>%#$'( 5?% /(">!4(#<», >$( «A!4(#(A!, ;45)(/( ($4!>"* ! @&!"2!@!*4<"( ($;&*?1%"* ($ #A%&6 !#/5##$'*», >$( A!4(#(A!, «1(4?"* ,#"( ($;&*"!>!$< #%), ($ "*5/!» – @(#$(4!% ($ @(#4%1"%., «?!'%$ +* #'(. #>%$, @(4<+5%$#, $(4$( !"(% /*/ «?!+"%""(% A!4(#(A#$'('*"!%» (418, #. 51, 55, 62, 100). R%#/(4%4 "5?"68 @(1>%&/"5$<, >$( A!4(#(A!, @( #5$! #'(%. "% %#$< "! "*5/*, "! 8!&('(++&%"!%, "! !#/5##$'(, "! &%4!;!, ! '(()F% «A!4(#(A!G "%4<+, 54('!$< ! (@&%1%4!$< (/(4<"68 @5$%8 ! ' /*>%#$'% >%;(-$( 1&5;(;(, >%8 ("* #*8*. 3"* $&%)5%$, >$()6 86 #8($&%4! "% ' #$(&("5 ($ "%%, "( 1()6'*4! %% !+ "%% #*8(.… 3"* #*8* %#$< $(4%"< &*+"(&%>!'6: $&*/$('(/ A!4(#(A!!, %% #5F"(#$"6: (@&%1%4%"!., "(, 158*%$#,, ! $%:, >$( 5?% ()(+"*>%"6, '@(4"% 1(#$*$(>"( 14, $(;(, >$()6 (@&%1%4!$<#, # (2%"/*8! ! '6)(&(8 &%7%"!, &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( '(@&(#*. 3>%'!1"(, >$( @&!8%"!$%4<"( / A!4(#(A!! @(1:(1 / (@&%1%4%"!G !##4%15%8(;(
23
@(",$!,, /*/ @&*'!4(, &%*4!+5%$#, @( @&!"2!@5 !#/4G>%"!, >%;(-$( (1"(;( 1&5;!8 @( @&!"2!@5 "!4!-!4!": (@&%1%4,%8(% %#$< !4! (1"(, !4! 1&5;(%, !#/4G>*GF%% @%&'(%, ("( %#$< E$( (@&!%84%8(%), "( "% $( ("%@&!%84%8(%) ! "*()(&($. J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, (@&%1%4,%$#, #$*$5# A!4(#(A!! ' &*8/*: #(($"(7%"!, "*5/! ! $'(&>%#$'*: A!4(#(A!, ,'4,%$#, (!4! 1(4?"* )6$<) "*5/(., "( "% $'(&>%#$'(8 ! "*()(&($ – $'(&>%#$'(8, "( "% "*5/(.. J*/(. @(1:(1 ' 1*""(8 /("/&%$"(8 #45>*% '&,1 4! (@&*'1*". D(;!>%#/! (" "%/(&&%/$%" 5?% ' #!45 #'(%. #5;5)(. !5"!1-!$!""!1-': ' @&($!'(@(4*;*%8(. ! !#/4G>*%8(. :*&*/$%&!#$!/% A!4(#(A!! ("% $'(&>%#$'(, "% "*5/*), "*&,15 # >%8-$( 1%.#$'!$%4<"( "%@&!%84%868, 4(;!>%#/! (@&('%&;*%868, '#%;1* 8(?"( "*.$! – @&! 8!"!858% ()I%/$!'"(#$! – ! "%>$( ($>*#$! @&!%84%8(%, 4(;!>%#/! 1(@5#$!8(%, %#4!, /("%>"(, !#/*$<. H $(;1* ()"*&5?!'*%$#,, >$( )(4%% (@&*'1*""68, 4(;!>%#/! )(4%% 2%4%#(()&*+"68 (/*+6'*%$#, 59;1-!$!""'= @(1:(1, #!"$%+!&5GF!. /&*."(#$! ' !: '+*!8(1(@(4",GF!: 5#$*"('4%"!,:, $( %#$< @(1:(1 @( @&!"2!@5 «!–!»: (@&%1%4,%8(% %#$< ! $( (' >%8-$( @&!%84%8(%), ! 1&5;(% ($(?% ' >%8-$( @&!%84%8(%). B&*'(8%&"(#$< ! 5)%?1*GF5G 1%.#$'%""(#$< $*/(;( 1'(.#$'%""(;( @(1:(1*, %;( 4(;!>%#/5G #(#$(,$%4<"(#$< 8(?"( @(1$'%&1!$< ! @&!8%"!$%4<"( / (@&%1%4%"!G #$*$5#* A!4(#(A!! >%&%+ %% @&!"*14%?"(#$< / "*5/% ! $'(&>%#$'5 (!#/5##$'5), !#:(1, @&! E$(8 !+ ()I%/$!'"(. 1'(.#$'%""(#$! #*8(. A!4(#(A!! ' %% "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 A5"/2!("!&('*"!! – $(. 1'(.#$'%""(#$!, /($(&5G C. C5"1$, "*@&!8%&, ()(+"*>!4 #4%15GF!8 ()&*+(8: «P (1"(. #$(&("6, ' "%@&%&6'"(8 &*+'!$!! A!4(#(A#/!: 8!&(#(+%&2*"!., * # 1&5;(. #$(&("6, ' '%>"(. )(&<)% !: !+-+* '#%()F!: '(@&(#(', /*#*GF!:#, +"*>%"!, ! 2%""(#$! ?!+"! '6&*?*%$#, 59!="!* ($"(7%"!% A!4(#(A!! / #('(/5@"(#$! 15:('"6: !"$%&%#(': %% ($"(7%"!% / "*5/% ! %% ($"(7%"!% / >',"'» (71, #. 8-9). § 2. #>DJ=A=<; E;6<=: 3=IE24FEKG A;$( ' #'(%. @(+"*'*$%4<"(. !@(#$*#! A!4(#(A!, !8%%$ (@&%1%4%""(% ($"(7%"!% / "%;6*, #(;4*#!$<#,, /*/ @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8 !+'%#$"6. "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A C. C!"1%4<)*"1, «# 5$'%&?1%"!%8, >$( '6#7!8 @(",$!%8 @( ($"(7%"!G / A!4(#(A!! #45?!$ @(",$!% "*5/!» (64, #. 2), :($,, /("%>"(, 8"%"!% E$( )64( $(;1* 1*4%/( "% ()F%@&!",$68. C( '#,/(8 #45>*%, ' 1(/4*1% "* 4-8 !"$%&"*2!("*4<"(8 A!4(#(A#/(8 /(";&%##% (Q(4("<,, 1911) "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A ! @#!:(4(; D. R%4<#(" ;('(&!4 ! ( $%:, /$( #>!$*4 A!4(#(A!G «1%4(8 4!>"6: @%&%?!'*"!., >%8-$(, >$( "% 8(?%$ )6$< '6&*?%"( '@(4"% (@&%1%4%""( ' #(()F*%86: 1&5;!8 4G1,8 A(&8*:, #4('(8, 14, /($(&6: A!4(#(A!, "% %#$< "*5/*» (284, #. 64-65). C8%#$% # $%8 1(/4*1>!/ ($8%$!4 ! «?!'(. !"$%&%#, # /($(&68 )64 '#$&%>%" /(";&%##, ! (#()(% '"!8*"!%, 51%4%""(% ' %;( @&(;&*88% ($"(7%"!G A!4(#(A!! / $(>"68 "*5/*8, /*/ ($&*1"(% '6&*?%"!% '%&6 ' '(+8(?"(#$< A!4(#(A!! /*/ "*5/!» ($*8 ?%, #. 65). H
24
1%.#$'!$%4<"(, ' >%8-$( #5F%#$'%""(8 A!4(#(A!,, "%#(8"%""(, ,'4,%$#, "*5/(.. R( ' >%8 !8%""(? H /*/(. "*5/(. ("* ,'4,%$#,? C >%8 (#"('* ! #5F"(#$< %% "*5>"(#$!? N$()6 ($'%$!$< "* E$! '(@&(#6, "*1( @&%1'*&!$%4<"( &*+()&*$<#, ' #5F"(#$! #*8(. "*5/!. C &*##8*$&!'*%86. @%&!(1 ('$(&*, @(4('!"* XIX – "*>*4( XX '') ' A!4(#(A#/(., ' >*#$"(#$!, @(+!$!'!#$#/(. 4!$%&*$5&% (@&%1%4%"!% #5F"(#$! "*5/! +*>*#$5G (;&*"!>!'*4(#< &*+"(@4*"('(. /("#$*$*2!%. %% A5"/2!("*4<"(. – @($%"2!*4<"(. ! */$5*4<"(. – @&!',+*""(#$! / &%6-%:, / 1(#$('%&"(85 @(+!$!'"(85 +"*"!G. J*/, @( 8"%"!G =. P@%"#%&*, «"*5/* (+"*>*%$ 4!7< #%8*%$ 4!7< #('(/5@"(#$< +"*"!,, ()&*+5GF%;(#, !+ !: ($1%4<"6: '/4*1('» (340, #. 75). H+'%#$"6. A&*"25+#/!. A!4(#(A ! !#$(&!/ H. JE" @!#*4: «…R*7! @(+"*"!, #5$< A*/$6… W1!"!>"6% A*/$6, :(&(7( '6)&*""6%, '*?"6%, +"*>!$%4<"6%, @(1&()"( (@&%1%4%""6% ! ()!4<"( ()#$*'4%""6% – '($ "6"% 8*$%&!*4 '#,/(. "*5/!» (361, #. II). K&5;(. A&*"25+#/!. A!4(#(A L. Q5$&5, (#"('6'*,#< "* $*/(8 ?% @("!8*"!! #(1%&?*"!, "*5/!, #(($'%$#$'5GF!8 ()&*+(8 !#$(4/('*4 ! %% @(+"*'*$%4<"(% A5"/2!("!&('*"!%: «R*5/* %#$< (@&%1%4%""*, A(&8*, !+'%#$"6. '!1 +"*"!,. L$( @%&%&*)($/* ?!'(. ! )%#/("%>"(. 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! ' /("%>"(% >!#4( @&(>"6:, #$&(;( (>%&>%""6: @(",$!., /($(&6% 8(?"( #&*'"!'*$< ! #'(1!$< 1&5; / 1&5;5» (47, #. 71-72). L$* @%&%&*)($/* /("/&%$"6: 1*""6:, 5#$*"('4%""6: A*/$(' ' 8%$(1!>%#/! (&;*"!+('*""(. A(&8% @&*/$!>%#/! &%*4!+5%$#, ' !: 67%11'&'6%+'' ! @($(85, #>!$*4, "*@&!8%&, *";4!.#/!. A!4(#(A ! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4< M. B!&#(", «/4*##!A!2!&('*"!% A*/$(', &*#@(+"*'*"!% !: '+*!8"6: #',+%. ! ($"(#!$%4<"(;( +"*>%"!, – $*/('* A5"/2!, "*5/!… W#4! !8%G$#, "*4!2( A*/$6 ! 1(#$5@"6% "*)4G1%"!G >%&%1('*"!, !:, $( 86 !8%%8 '#%, >$( "5?"( 14, "*5>"(. /4*##!A!/*2!! ! 14, +"*"!,» (392, #. 19, 29). H /*/ ()F!. '6'(1 !+ @&!'%1%""6: #5?1%"!., – #5F"(#$"(% (@&%1%4%"!% "*5/!, #A(&854!&('*""(% 9. C(#/&%#%"#/!8: «R*5/(. "*+6'*%$#, #('(/5@"(#$< #$&(;( @&('%&%""6: A*/$(', ($"(#,F!:#, / !+'%#$"(. ()4*#$! +"*"!, ! @&!'%1%""6: ' "*14%?*F5G #',+< !4! #!#$%85» (70, #. 4). J*/(% @&(!+'(4<"(% (;&*"!>%"!% "*5/! #A%&(. "*4!>"(;( +"*"!,, /4*##!A!2!&('*""6: A*/$(', /("%>"( ?%, "% 1*%$ '(+8(?"(#$! 1(#$*$(>"( @(4"( ! (#"('*$%4<"( @&%1#$*'!$< %% #5F"(#$<. W#4! E$( ! "*5/* – #!#$%8*$!+!&('*""6% +"*"!, ! A*/$6, – $( 5?, '( '#,/(8 #45>*%, "% '#,, "% '( '#%8 %% 1%.#$'!$%4<"(8 /*>%#$'%. L$( "*5/* $(4*#$"(#$!, ' %% "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 A5"/2!("!&('*"!!, @(+"*'*$%4<"(8 &*+'%&$6'*"!! ' "%. @( "%():(1!8(#$! &%*4!+5%$#, (@&%1%4%""(% 5*(-*78"!1-"!* "*>*4(. L$(, /#$*$! ;('(&,, ' &*##8*$&!'*%86. @%&!(1 @&!+"*'*4(#< ! ' @(+!$!'!#$#/(. A!4(#(A!!. J*/, (1!" !+ %% @&%1#$*'!$%4%., "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A J. =(8@%&2 @!#*4: «C#,/*, "*5/*… @&%1@(4*;*%$ >%4('%>%#/5G 1%,$%4<"(#$<, ! !8%""( $*/5G 1%,$%4<"(#$<, /($(&*, !8%%$ #'(%. 2%4
25
5#$*"('4%"!% "*5>"6: #',+%. 86#4%.…» (131, #. 20). C(@&(# 4!7< ' $(8, >$( '/4G>*%$ ' #%), "*5>"*, 1%,$%4<"(#$< – 5#$*"('4%"!% #',+%. 86#4%. $(4$( )(4%% #5F%#$'%""(%. 3>%'!1"(, >$( "*5>"(% @(+"*"!% ' %;( 1!"*8!/% @&%1@(4*;*%$ "% $(4%"!% "('(;(, )(4%% #('%&7%""(;( +"*"!,. H"*>% ;('(&,, "*5/* ' /*>%#$'% @(+"*"!, '/4G>*%$ ' #%), "% $(4*4<"(. "*5/!, $( %#$< *"$!>"(. A!4(#(A!!, @%&'6: %% 1%,$%4%., (" @(1>%&/"54, >$(, %#4! ("! +*",4!#< "*5/(., «>$()6 !+)*'!$<#, ($ "%+"*"!,, $(, (>%'!1"(, / +"*"!G #$*4! #$&%8!$<#, &*1! @("!8*"!,, * "% &*1! /*/(.-"!)51< @(4<+6» (10, #. 69). C #'(G (>%&%1<, "%():(1!8(% @("!8*"!% !+5>*%86: ()I%/$(' 8(?%$ )6$< 1(#$!;"5$( ' "*5/% >%&%+ !: 86#4!$%4<"(% (#'(%"!%, >%&%+ #5F"(#$"(% 5,#"%"!% ! @(#4%15GF%% &*2!("*4<"(%, 4(;!>%#/! (&;*"!+('*""(% !"(% @(+"*"!%, #>!$*4 9&!#$($%4<, «'(+"!/*%$ @&! '#%: !##4%1('*"!,:, /($(&6% @&(#$!&*G$#, "* "*>*4*, @&!>!"6 ! E4%8%"$6, @5$%8 !: 5,#"%"!,…» (12, #. 61). B&! E$(8 «86 $(;1* @(+"*%8 @&%18%$, /(;1* +"*%8 %;( @&!>!"5» (11, #. 259). H @($(85 1!"*8!>%#/*, #(#$*'4,GF*, "*5/! – ! '( '&%8%"* 9&!#$($%4,, ! "* '#%: @(#4%15GF!: E$*@*: %% &*+'!$!, – "%():(1!8( @&%1@(4*;*%$ 1'!?%"!% @(+"*GF%. 86#4!, %% 4(;!>%#/(% &*+'%&$6'*"!% ' #5F"(#$"(8 5,#"%"!! ! 1(/*+*$%4<"(8 ()I,#"%"!! !+5>*%86: ()I%/$('. M*/ @!#*4 ' /("2% XIX '%/* A&*"25+#/!. A!4(#(A 9. D*4*"1, «1'!?%"!% 86#4!, @(#$%@%""( @&%'&*F*GF%% #@5$*""5G 8*##5 @%&'("*>*4<"6: '@%>*$4%"!. ' #$&(."5G ! #',+"5G #!#$%85 +"*"!., @%&%:(1 …($ "%@(",$"(;( / @(",$"(85 ! %#$< $(, >$( #(#$*'4,%$ "%;6;» (190, #. 5). B%&%.$! ?% ($ "%@(",$"(;( / @(",$"(85 – ! +"*>!$, ()I,#"!$< !+5>*%8(% ,'4%"!%, 5#$*"('!', ' >*#$"(#$!, %;( +*/("(8%&"5G @&!>!""5G #',+< # 1&5;!8! ,'4%"!,8!. J*/('(, "*@&!8%&, 8"%"!% %F% (1"(;( A&*"25+*, B.-0. BE/(: «R*5/* +*1*%$#, 2%4!"6, !+ "%% '6$%/*GF*,, #5$< @(E$(85 ;4*'"6% !1%! "*5/! R('(;( '&%8%"!» (314, #. 55). B&*/$!>%#/*, &%*4!+*2!, E$!: !1%. ' !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! 5>%"6: ! ()%#@%>!'*4* "*14%?*F5G 1%.#$'%""(#$< ! EAA%/$!'"(#$< "*5/! R('(;( '&%8%"!. J*/, @&!8%"!$%4<"( / %#$%#$'(+"*"!G XVII '%/* @&(A%##(& C. 0%$$%& ' #',+! # E$!8 @(1>%&/"54:
26
«R*5/* '#$5@!4* $%@%&< "* @5$< @(1'%1%"!, 8"(;(>!#4%""6: ;&5@@ &*+4!>"6: ,'4%"!. @(1 '#% )(4%% ! )(4%% ()F!% +*/("6 ! ()I,#"%"!, !: ()F!8! @&!>!"*8!; ("* # E$!: @(& @(#$(,""( @&(1(4?*4* %;( ! (1%&?!'*4* "* "%8 @()%15 +* @()%1(G» (372, #. 5). L$! @()%16 "*5/! A!/#!&('*4! ' #5F"(#$"(8 ()I,#"%"!! !+5>*%86: ,'4%"!. !: #(($'%$#$'5GF%% +"*"!% ! @("!8*"!% ' '!1% $(. !4! !"(. /("/&%$"(. "*5>"(. '1-'".. H @($(85 %% */$!'"6., 2%4%"*@&*'4%""6. @(!#/ 8(?"( #>!$*$< &%7*GF!8 #5F"(#$"68 (@&%1%4!$%4%8 "*5/!, 1%,$%4<"(#$"(;( "*>*4* ' "%.. R% #45>*."( K.H. %"1%4%%', A!/#!&5, E$5 "%():(1!85G 1!"*8!>%#/5G /("#$*"$5 "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, ($8%$!4, >$( «"('(% !#/*"!% !#$!" – E$( $(4%#$"(% !#/*"!% /($(&(. :($, ! 8(?%$ 5/4("!$< "*# "* '&%8, ($ '%&"(;( @5$!, "( "!/(;1* "% 51*4!$ "*# ($ "%;( "*'%/!» (293, #. 3). -*+4!>%"!% ' "*5/% 1'5: (),+*$%4<"6: :*&*/$%&!#$!>%#/!: "*>*4 – #$*$!>%#/(;( ("*4!>"(% +"*"!%, 5#$*"('4%""6% A*/$6) ! 1!"*8!>%#/(;( (@&(2%## @(+"*'*"!,, 1'!?%"!% 86#4!) '*?"( %F% ! @($(85, >$( "* E$(. (#"('% #$*"('!$#, '(+8(?"68 #5F%#$'%""( @&(,#"!$< "*5>"6. #$*$5# A!4(#(A!!, %% 8%#$( ! &(4< ' /("/&%$"("*5>"(8, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!!. J( ! 1&5;(% #(#&%1($*>!'*%$#, ' 4!>"(#$"(. >*#$! @&(2%##* @(+"*'*"!,, * !8%""( – ' &%*4!+*2!! $'(&>%#/!: @($%"2!., !"$%44%/$5*4<"6: 5#!4!. @(+"*GF%. 4!>"(#$!, %% #@(#()"(#$%., "*/4(""(#$%., !"$%&%#('. C "*5/% E$($ #5)I%/$!'"6., !"1!'!15*4<"( ,'4%""6. 8(8%"$ (>%'!1%" 4!7< ' %% 1!"*8!>%#/(., 1%,$%4<"(#$"(. >*#$!. O>%"6., 1%,$%4< "*5/!, ' >*#$"(#$!, 5>%"6.–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– ' ($/&6$(8 $(;1* +*/("% #(:&*"%"!, ! @&%'&*F%"!, E"%&;!! – @("!8*"!, %% #5F"(#$!. J( ! 1&5;(% – ! /("/&%$"(% +"*"!%, ! #5F"(#$"(% @("!8*"!% – ()I%/$!'"6 @( #(1%&?*"!G, ("! #(($'%$#$'5G$ &%*4<"(. E"%&;!!, #4%1('*$%4<"(, !#$!""6 ! ' E$(. #'(%. ()I%/$!'"(. !#$!""(#$! ("! ()F%+"*>!86, <*,7'0". – ' $(8 #86#4%, >$( ' "!: 4!>"(#$< 5>%"(;(, %;( #5)I%/$!'"(#$<, !"1!'!15*4<"(#$< "!/*/ #%), "% ()"*&5?!'*G$. B( 8"%"!G L. Q5$&5, ()I,#",%$#, E$( $%8 ()#$(,$%4<#$'(8, >$( «'#,/*, "*5/* !8%%$ 2%4%. – )6$< $(4
27
B&(15/$!'"6% &%7%"!, E$(. +*1*>! &%*4!+5G$#, ' #(($'%$#$'5GF!: &%+54<$*$*: "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, – ' 5#$*"('4%""6: ()I%/$!'"6: A*/$*:, ' ($/&6$6: ()I%/$!'"6: +*/("*: ! $.@. H: +"*"!% ! @("!8*"!% 5>%"68! A!/#!&5G$#,, @(",$!."( (A(&84,G$#, ' 4(;!>%#/! 5@(&,1(>%""6: #5?1%"!,:, &*'"(+"*>"6: 14, '#%: 5>%"6:, /*/!8! )6 "! )64! #5)I%/$!'"6% /*>%#$'* @(#4%1"!:, !: !"1!'!15*4<"6% (#()%""(#$!. «R*5>"(% #5?1%"!%, – @!#*4 M. B!&#(", – E$( #5?1%"!%.., #'()(1"(% ($ !"1!'!15*4<"6: #'(.#$' !##4%1('*$%4,» (302, #. 33). J*/(;( &(1* #5?1%"!, ' !: #(1%&?*$%4<"(. >*#$!, ' #86#4('(. "*@(4"%""(#$! ()&%$*G$ /*>%#$'( "*5>"(. !#$!"6, ()I%/$!'"(#$< /($(&(. #45?!$ '*?"%.7!8 (@&%1%4!$%4%8 %% #5;5)( "*5>"(;( #$*$5#*, /(&%""68 ()&*+(8 ($4!>*GF%;( %% ($ ?!$%.#/!:, #5)I%/$!'"( 5$'%&?1*%86: >%4('%>%#/!: «!#$!"». M*/ @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8 !+'%#$"6. A&*"25+#/!. 5>%"6. 0. D%K*"$%/, «!8%%$#, "% !#$!"*, * !#$!"6 >%4('%>%#/!%, ! !#$!" E$!: #$(4"*, !#$!"* !8%%$ )%+4!>"6. :*&*/$%&. K&5;!8! #4('*8!, #*86. $%&8!" «!#$!"*» "% !8%%$ "!/*/(;( #86#4* ' @&!8%"%"!! / >%85-4!)( !"(85, /&(8% "*5>"(. !#$!"6» (202, #. 214). Q%+4!>"(#$< "*5>"(. !#$!"6 (+"*>*%$, >$( ' /("/&%$"6: &%+54<$*$*: "*5>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! – ' ($/&6$6: +*/("*:, &*+&*)($*""6: $%(&!,: ! $.@. – "%$ 5"!/*4<"(#$!, "%@('$(&!8(#$!, #'(.#$'%""6: &%+54<$*$*8 :51(?%#$'%""(;( $'(&>%#$'*. 31!" ! $($ ?% "*5>"6. +*/(" ' %;( (1!"*/('(8 +"*"!! ! @("!8*"!! 8(?%$ )6$< ($/&6$ &*+"68! 5>%"68!. J($ ?% +*/(" #(:&*"%"!, ! @&%'&*F%"!, E"%&;!! "%+*'!#!8( 1&5; ($ 1&5;* ($/&64!, /*/ !+'%#$"(, -. *.%& ! =. =%4<8;(4<2. J( ?% – ! +*/("6 Q(.4,– *&!($$*, K?(54,–D%"2* ! 1&. «C "*5/%, – @!#*4 M. B!&#(" – 86 2%"!8 $(, >$( …# %% @(8(F%#$'5 A*"$*+!!» (302, #. 23). B&(#$(& !"1!'!15*4<"(85 $'(&>%#$'5 A*"$*+!!, ' ($4!>!% ($ "*5/!, 1*%$ !#/5##$'(, '#4%1#$'!% >%;( ' "%8, /*/ 5$'%&?1*4 0. D%-K*"$%/, «%#$< &('"( #$(4"*, !#$!"* %1!"*» (202, #. 217). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, ' "*5/%, ' "*5>"(. !#$!"% /*?16. +*A!/#!&('*""6. /("/&%$"6. $*,;78-%- @(+"*"!, (+*/(", $%(&!, ! @&.) ' #'(%8 ()I%/$!'"(8 #(1%&?*"!! @( "%():(1!8(#$! %1!"(()&*+%", ()F%+"*>!8, )%+4!>%". C $( ?% '&%8, #*8 2$!+*11 @(+"*'*"!,, "*8%&%""(% 1'!?%"!% 86#4! ' "%8, %;( "%@(#&%1#$'%""(% &*+'%&$6'*"!% "* /*?1(8 ($1%4<"(8 5>*#$/% "*5/! #(+"*$%4<"( "*@&*'4,%$#, ! (#5F%#$'4,%$#,, /("$&(4!&5%$#, ! &%;54!&5%$#, /("/&%$"68 5>%"68 /*/ #5)I%/$(8 @(+"*"!,, /*/ !"1!'!15*4<"( 1%.#$'5GF%. 4!>"(#$%"(;(, @(+"*'*$%4<"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! # $(. !4! !"(. @&(15/$!'"(#$"6. !"$%&%# %;( &*+58*, %;( 2%4%"*@&*'4%""(#$<, #/4*1 58*, !"1!'!15*4<"( (&;*"!+('*""(%
28
8674%"!%, 4!>"6. "*5>"6. (@6$, %;( $%8@%&*8%"$, $*4*"$, !"$5!2!,, A*"$*+!, ! @&. C#% E$( 4!>"(%, #5)I%/$!'"(%, !"1!'!15*4<"(% @&("!+6'*%$ !##4%1('*$%4<#/5G 1%,$%4<"(#$< 5>%"(;(, (@&%1%4%""68 ()&*+(8 (&;*"!+5%$, &%;54!&5%$ %% ! ' /("%>"(8 !$(;% @&!'(1!$ / #(($'%$#$'5GF%85 &%+54<$*$5 – / $(85 !4! !"(85 "*5>"(85 1(#$!?%"!G, !8@4!2!$"( '()&*'7%85 ' #%), @&%17%#$'5GF!. @&(2%## @(+"*'*"!,. P4%1('*$%4<"(, ' 1!"*8!>%#/(. >*#$! "*5/!, ' @(+"*'*$%4<"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! 4!>"(#$< 5>%"(;( ' %% !"1!'!15*4<"(8 #'(%()&*+!! – (),+*$%4<"6., #5F%#$'%""( '*?"6. 5@&*'4,GF!. A*/$(&, "*/4*16'*GF!. #'(. "%!+;4*1!86. >%4('%>%#/!. ($@%>*$(/ "* :(1 ! !#:(1 "*5>"(;( !##4%1('*"!,, "* %;( &*+'!$!% ! /("%>"6. &%+54<$*$. H"*>% ;('(&,, 4!>"(#$"6. A*/$(& ' &*+'!$!! "*5/! – E$( A*/$(& # "%!+)%?"(. #5)I%/$!'"(#$%#/!: @&%$'(&%"!. @(+"*'*$%4<"6: '(+8(?"(#$%. 5>%"(;( ' @&(2%##% 5#$*"('4%"!, ()I%/$!'"( !#$!""(;( +"*"!,, (#()%""( – ' 86#4!$%4<"(. #A%&% @(+"*"!,, ' #A%&% #5F"(#$"(;( 2!"':%"'( ! $%(&%$!>%#/(;( !*%86: ,'4%"!.. H+'%#$"6. A&*"25+#/!. 5>%"6. L. B!/*&, /*#*,#< E$(;( '(@&(#* – ( #5)I%/$!'"(#$! @("!8*"!, ! ()I,#"%"!, ' "*5/%, – @!#*4: «M(;1* 86 "*)4G1*%8 !+'%#$"(% ,'4%"!%, $( !"(;1* 86 ;('(&!8, >$( 86 %;( @("!8*%8, * !"(;1* – >$( "% @("!8*%8. N$( (+"*>*%$, #()#$'%""(, E$( '6&*?%"!%? 6 @("!8*%8 ,'4%"!% $(;1*, /(;1* – @&! "*4!>!! @&!()&%$%""6: "*8! +"*"!. – 86 8(;4! )6 %;( @&%1'!1%$<. R*7% ()I,#"%"!% #(#$(!$ ' $(8, >$( 86 &*+'!'*%8, &*+'%&$6'*%8 E$5 '(+8(?"(#$< @&%1'!1%"!,. C@&(>%8, #$%@%"< $&%)('*$%4<"(#$!, ()"*&5?!'*%8*, 5>%"68!, /(;1* ("! @&!'4%/*G$ $% !4! !"6% $%(&!! ! +*/("6 14, «()I,#"%"!,» ,'4%"!., )6'*%$ &*+4!>"(.. 3"* "% (1"* ! $* ?% ' &*+4!>"6: "*5/*:, )515>! !"(. ' A!+!/%, >%8, "*@&!8%&, ' )!(4(;!!» (301, #. 20). 3$"(#!$%4<"( ?% '#%. "*5/! ' %% @(#$5@*$%4<"(8 1'!?%"!!, ' 1!"*8!/% &%*4!+5%86: %G #5)I%/$"(–()I%/$"6: ($"(7%"!. # (@&%1%4%""68! @&(,'4%"!,8! ()I%/$!'"(#$! ! #5)I%/$!'"(#$! ' "!: B!/*& 1%4*%$ #4%15GF!. '%#<8* @&!8%>*$%4<"6. '6'(1: «V"*>!$%4<"*, >*#$< @&(;&%##* "*5/ #(#$(!$ ' $(8, >$( 86 '#% $(>"%% ! $(>"%% @(+"*%8 ()I%/$!'"6% E4%8%"$6 '%F%.. L$( '6&*?*G$ #4('*8!, >$( "*5/* #$&%8!$#, #$*$< '#% )(4%% ! )(4%% ()I%/$!'"(.… J%8 "% 8%"%%, 86 1(4?"6 @&!+"*$<, >$( @(4"*, ()I%/$!'"(#$< "*5/! – E$( :!8%&*. R*7* "*5/*, #(+1*""*, "*8! ! # @(8(F5'#$', '#%;1* )51%$ @( "*7%. 8%&/%, '#%;1* )51%$ 1( "%/($(&(. #$%@%"! +*'!#%$< ($ "*7!: ($"(7%"!. / '"%7"%85 8!&5» ($*8 ?%, #. 21). 3)(#"('6'*, E$5 ?% "%'(+8(?"(#$< @(4"(. ()I%/$!'"(#$! "*5/! ''!15 %%, "*5/!, "%!+)%?"(. +*'!#!8(#$! ($ #5)I%/$!'"(;( >%4('%>%#/(;( A*/$(&* ' @(+"*'*$%4<"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! 5>%"6:, L. M*&@%"$%& @!#*4: «-*+4!>"6% $%(&!! ! '+;4,16 "* @&!&(15, /($(&6: 86 1%&?!8#,, ,'4,G$#, 4!7< '&%8%""68! 5/*+*$%4,8! @(#4%1('*$%4<"6: #$*1!. &*+'!$!, >%4('%>%#$'*, @&! E$(8 /*?16. &,1 $*/!: $%(&!. ! '+;4,1(' (&;*"!>%#/!
29
#',+*" # $(. "&*'#$'%""(. ! E8(2!("*4<"(. #$*1!%. &*+'!$!,, "* /($(&(. >%4('%>%#$'( ' 1*""(% '&%8, "*:(1!$#, ! /($(&*, ' !+'%#$"(8 #86#4% '6&*?*%$#, ' E$!: $%(&!,: ! '+;4,1*:. J*/!8 ()&*+(8, @(@6$/* 1*$< A%"(8%"*4<"(85 8!&5 ()I,#"%"!% #*8( @( #%)% 1(#$('%&"(%, )%+($"(#!$%4<"( / #(#$(,"!G 58(' 4G1%., %;( @&%14(?!'7!:, @( "%():(1!8(#$! 1(4?"* (/(">!$<#, "%51*>%.» (170, #. 5). P(#$(,"!% 58(' /("/&%$"6: 5>%"6:, &*+&*)*$6'*GF!: $% !4! !"6% "*5>"6% $%(&!!, 1%$*4<"( !+4*;*GF!: ! ()I,#",GF!: #'(! 4!>"6% '+;4,16 "* !+5>*%86% !8! ,'4%"!, @&!&(16, #(($'%$#$'5GF!8 ()&*+(8 +*@%>*$4%'*%$#, ' /("%>"6: &%+54<$*$*: !: !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! – ' &*+&*)($*""6: !8! $%(&!,:, ' +*/("('6&*?*GF!: '+;4,1*:, !1%,: ! $.@. 0!/#!&5, E$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'( # @(+!2!. %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, (1!" !+ %;( @&%1#$*'!$%4%., H. -%."/% @!#*4 ' "*>*4% XX '%/*: «R*)4G1%"!% ! (@6$ ,'4,G$#, (&51!,8! @(+"*"!,, ()1586'*"!% ! '(()&*?%"!% – (&51!,8! ()I,#"%"!,… C 4%$(@!#! %#$%#$'('%1%"!, 5?% )64( '"%#%"( (;&(8"(% >!#4( &*+4!>"6: '(++&%"!. "* @&!&(15. H "! (1"( !+ "!: "% #'()(1"( ($ #()#$'%""6: @&!)*'4%"!. *'$(&*, ($ %;( #5)I%/$!'"6: ()I,#"%"!. 14, ($1%4<"6: >*#$%. /*&$!"6 8!&*» (322, #. 2). P('&%8%""6. A!4(#(A . -"(#$! 5>%"(;( ' &*+'!$!! "*5/!, "* '(@&(#: «N$( ($4!>*%$ !+8%"%"!, ' "*5>"(8 +"*"!! ($ !+8%"%"!., @&(!#:(1,F!: ' (&;*"!>%#/(. @&!&(1%?» 1*%$ $*/(. ($'%$: «R% ;('(&, 5?% ( >%8-$( 1&5;(8, 86 #$*4/!'*%8#, +1%#< # @&()4%8(. '*&!*2!!. R*5>"6% '*&!*2!! '#%;1* "(#,$ "*@&*'4%""6. :*&*/$%&… L$( +"*>!$, >$( M(@%&"!/, K*&'!" !4! K?. O($#(" !8%4! @%&%1 #()(. 2%4< – @(",$< @&!&(15 $(;( !4! !"(;( ,'4%"!, – ! !8%""( E$* 2%4< &5/('(1!4* !8! @&! #(+1*"!! "*5>"6: $%(&!.. K&5;!8! #4('*8!, 4!>"(#$< 5>%"(;( !;&*%$ */$!'"5G &(4< ' &*+'!$!! "*5/!» (443, #. 66). K()*'!8: "% $(4%"6% – @%&'(@&(:(126, @%&'(($/&6'*$%4! ' 2%4%"*@&*'4%""(8 @(+"*"!! @&!&(16, '"%7"%;( 8!&* – E$( $'(&26 "*5/!. «Q%+ (7!)/! 8(?"( #/*+*$<, – @!#*4 L. B!/*&, – >$( 86 $'(&!8 "*5/5, &*##8*$&!'*, ' "%. '"%7"GG &%*4<"(#$< >%&%+ @&!+85 "*7!: $%(&!. ! ($'4%>%""6: @(",$!.» (301, #. 21). H 1%.#$'!$%4<"(, #('8%#$"68! 5#!4!,8! '#%: #'(!: @&%17%#$'%""!/(' ! #('&%8%""!/(' 5>%"6% "* /*?1(8 E$*@% >%4('%>%#/(. !#$(&!! $'(&,$ "*5/5 ' %% 2%4(8, "*5/5 /*/ (#()6. A%"(8%" /54<$5&6, /*/ "%>$( 5"!/*4<"(% ' 15:('"(. ?!+"! >%4('%>%#$'*. C "%. (@&%1%4,%$#, "%@&%&6'"( #('%&7%"#$'5GF%%#, 1%$*4<"(% +"*"!% ! #5F"(#$"(% @("!8*"!% 8!&* ' %;( 2%4(8, '/4G>*, ! >%4('%/* ' "%8, $( %#$< 5#$*"*'4!'*%$#, (@&%1%4%""(% "*5>"(% :'$!9!,,$*"'*. B( #4('*8 L. M*&@%"$%&*, «"*5/* #1%4*4* (>%"< 8"(;(, (>!#$!' ($ :4*8* #5%'%&!. @5$< / )(4%% ,#"(85 ! +1&*'(85 8!&('(++&%"!G» (170, #. 3). B&! E$(8, /*/ &*+I,#",4 $(;1* ?% (' "*>*4% XX '%/*) */*1%8!/ C.H. C%&"*1#/!., «#*8( "*5>"(% 8!&('(++&%"!% "% %#$< >$(-"!)51< +*/(">%""(%, ,#"(%, ;($('(%; ("( 1(#$!;*4(#< >%4('%/(8 @(#$%@%""(, 1(4;!8 ! $&51"68 @5$%8. C &*+"6% !#$(&!>%#/!% E@(:! ("(
30
)64( &*+4!>"(… C $%>%"!% :(1* '%/(' 8(?"( @&(#4%1!$<, /*/ >5?1(% "*8 8!&('(++&%"!% @&(746: @(/(4%"!. @(#$%@%""( 8%",4(#< ! @&!()&%$*4( #('&%8%""6. '!1. R( ' $%>%"!% '#%. E$(. 8"(;('%/('(., 1(4;(. E'(4G2!! 8!&('(++&%"!% (#$*'*4(#< "*5>"68» (60, #. 38). K.H. %"1%4%%', #( #'(%. #$(&("6, ()&*$!4 '"!8*"!% "* $( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, >$( «"*5>"(% 8!&(#(+%&2*"!% #!4<"( 8%",%$#, "% $(4"6: 1%,$%4%. "*@&*'4,G$#, !8%""( / $(85, >$()6 8!&(#(+%&2*"!% #'(] !4! $(. 7/(46, / /($(&(. ("! @&!"*14%?*$, @%&%'%#$! ' &,1 "%(#@(&!86: "*>*4 "*5/!» (259, #. 460). § 3. 0=3242A=9 = E;6<;: BD8; 2HLE24F= C "*5>"(8 8!&('(++&%"!! ' (@&%1%4%""(. 8%&% @&(,'4,%$#, 4!>"(#$< N%4('%/* /*/ !#/*$%4, H#$!"6. H (1"!8 !+ "%():(1!86: ! 1%.#$'%""6: @5$%. %% ()&%$%"!, ,'4,%$#, A!4(#(A!,. B( (@&%1%4%"!G P. P5'(&('*, A!4(#(A!, «%#$< !#/*"!% !#$!"6, * "% !44G+!., – !#$!"6, /($(&*, %#$< @(+"*"!% )6$!,, !8 ()5#4('4%""(% ! %85 #(($'%$#$'%""(%» (350, #. 3). J( ?% – ! @( 8"%"!G L.D. -*14('*: «0!4(#(A!, %#$< #$&%84%"!% / !#$!"%» (315, #. 235). B(+"*'*$%4<"*, @&(15/$!'"*, &%*4!+*2!, E$(;( #$&%84%"!, @&!'(1!$ / $(85, >$( ! A!4(#(A!, 5#$*"*'4!'*%$ #'(% 1%.#$'!$%4<"(% +"*"!% ! #5F"(#$"(% @("!8*"!% 8!&* ! >%4('%/* ' "%8 ! $%8 #*868 '"(#!$ #5F%#$'%""6. '/4*1 ' ()F%% "*5>"(% 8!&('(++&%"!%. «U($!8 86 E$(;( !4! "% :($!8, – @!#*4 C.H. C%&"*1#/!., – @(8!8( "*#, "%!+)%?"( "*# 7!&(/(. '(4"(. "* /*?1(8 7*;5 (:'*$6'*G$ '(@&(#6, +*1*>! ! !"$%&%#6, $%#"( #',+*""6% # A!4(#(A!%. ! )4!+/!8! / "%. "*5/*8!… 3"! '6$%/*G$ "%!+)%?"( ! "%!##,/*%8( !+ &*+8674%"!, ! (2%"/! $(;( "*5>"(;( 8*$%&!*4*, !+ /($(&(;( #$&(!$#, %#$%#$'(+"*"!% ! 8*$%8*$!/*. 3"! ':(1,$ /*/ '#%@&("!/*GF*, #&%1* '( '#% "*7% "*5>"(% 8!&('(++&%"!%, '&6'*G$#, ' "*7 "*5>"6. ,+6/, ' /*?1(% "*7% "*)4G1%"!% ! $(>"( 5#$*"('4%""6. A*/$, ! %F% )(4%%, ' /*?1(% %;( $(4/('*"!% ! ()I,#"%"!%» (61, #. 390). B(",$"(, >$( ' E$(8 #45>*% ! #*8* A!4(#(A!, – /*/ #@%2!A!>%#/*, #A%&* @(+"*"!,, A5"/2!("*4<"( #(@&,?%""*, # "*5/(., # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8 ! 8*$%8*$!/(. – @&%1#$*%$ ' /*>%#$'% "%;6' – ' $(. 8%&%, ' /*/(. ("* ()%#@%>!'*%$ ()&%$%"!% "('(;( !#$!""(;( +"*"!, ! #(($'%$#$'5GF%;( @("!8*"!, ' ($"(7%"!! ()F%;( ()I%/$* @(+"*"!,, ' 1*""(8 #45>*% – @&!&(16, ,'4%"!. ! +*/("(' ' "%.. C &*#/&6$!! "*5>"(;( #$*$5#* A!4(#(A!! #5F%#$'%""( '*?"68, 4(;!>%#/! "%():(1!868 @&%1#$*'4,%$#, #*"*-'0*16'= @(1:(1 / ()I,#"%"!G #*8(. "*5/!, $( %#$< &*##8($&%"!% %% ' #$*"('4%"!! ! &*+'!$!!, '6,'4%"!% %% @&%1@(#64(>"6: (#"('*"!.. K4, E$(;(, ;('(&, #4('*8! 0. K*""%8*""*, «86 1(4?"6 #@5#$!$<#, / !#$(>"!/*8. B($(/ "*5/! "% 1(4?%" @&("%#$!#< 8!8( "*#. 6 1(4?"6 #4%1('*$< +* "!8, >$()6 5+"*$<, ($/51* (" !#:(1!$ ! !+ /*/!: ()4*#$%. (" #()!&*%$#,. L$( "*+6'*%$#, &*##8*$&!'*$< "*5/5 ;%"%$!>%#/!» (138, #. 63). 9 &*##8*$&!'*$< "*5/5 ;%"%$!>%#/! ! +"*>!$ @( "%():(1!8(#$! &*##8*$&!'*$< %% '
31
#(($"%#%"!! # A!4(#(A!%., !)( ;%"%+!# "*5/! ' #'(!: !#$(&!>%#/!: (#"('*"!,: "%($1%4!8 ($ A!4(#(A!!. B&*' )64 H.P. 9"1&%%'#/!.: «R*5/* !8%%$ #'(! /(&"! ' A!4(#(A!!… 0!4(#(A!, "% $(4*4( "*5/%» (9, #. 198). H#:(1"(. «/4%$(>/(.» ' &*##8($&%"!! 1*""(;( '(@&(#* ,'4,%$#, */#!(8*$!>%#/(% 5#$*"('4%"!%: A!4(#(A!, – E$( @(+"*"!%, %;( (@&%1%4%""6. '!1. M*/ @(1>%&/"54 -. C!&:(', «A!4(#(A#/(% +"*"!% "% !8%%$ 1&5;!: !#$(>"!/(', /&(8% @(+"*"!, @&!&(16» (65, #. 128). K&5;!8 #$(4< ?% (>%'!1"68 #@%2!A!>%#/!8 '!1(8 @(+"*"!, @&!&(16 ,'4,%$#, "*5/*, ' >*#$"(#$!, %#$%#$'(+"*"!%. L$( ()F!. &(1('(. @&!+"*/ A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, – !: &*'"(@&*'"*, @&!"*14%?"(#$< / @(+"*'*$%4<"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! >%4('%/*. M("#$*$!&5, E$( !+"*>*4<"(% @(+"*'*$%4<"(% %1!"#$'( "*5/! (A!+!/!) ! A!4(#(A!! (8%$*A!+!/!) !+'%#$"6. A&*"25+#/!. A!4(#(A L. %.%&#(" @!#*4: «R*5/* ! 8%$*A!+!/* @&%#4%15G$ (1"5 ! $5 ?% 2%4< – @(+"*"!% &%*4<"(;(» (258, #. XVIII). C #('8%#$"(8 @&(1'!?%"!! / "*+'*""(. 2%4!, ' @5$,: ! A(&8*: %% @(+"*'*$%4<"(. &%*4!+*2!! A!4(#(A!, ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!% ! @&%1#$*G$ /*/ 1'* '!1* (1"(;( &(1*, $( %#$< >%4('%>%#/(;( @(+"*"!,, @&%?1% '#%;( – ' %;( 86#4!$%4<"(. >*#$!. «C /*/(8–$( #86#4%, – @!#*4 9.R. O*.$:(1, – "*5/* ! A!4(#(A!, @&%1#$*'4,G$ #()(. 4!7< &*+"6% *#@%/$6 (1"(;( '%4!/(;( 1%4* >%4('%>%#/(;( 8674%"!,» (362, #. 540). C @(+"*GF%8 >%4('%>%#/(8 8674%"!! ! +*&(1!4!#< ' #'(% '&%8, A!4(#(A!, ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!%, +*&(1!4!#< '8%#$%, ' "%&*+1%4<"(#$!, ' 4("% (1"(., ()F%. 14, "!: "*>*4<"(. "*5/!. M*/ 5$'%&?1*4 ' #',+! # E$!8 9. C%)%&, «)515>! $%#"( #',+*"6 8%?15 #()(G @( #5F"(#$! ! @( !"$%&%#*8, A!4(#(A!, ! "*5/* "*:(1,$#, ' $*/(. ?% #',+! ! @( #'(%85 @&(!#:(?1%"!G…» (59, #. 1). C &*+'!$!! %'&(@%.#/(. 15:('"(. /54<$5&6 2%4%"*@&*'4%""(% "*5>"(% @(+"*"!% @&!&(16, '"%7"%;( 8!&* "*>*4(#<, /*/ !+'%#$"(, ' K&%'"%. =&%2!! ! "*>*4(#< '(+"!/7%. $(;1* A!4(#(A!%., /("/&%$"( – "*$5&A!4(#(A!%. !4%$#/(. 7/(46 (V '%/ 1( ".E.). P4%1('*$%4<"(, A!4(#(A!, "*>*4*#< /*/ "*5/* – %1!"#$'%""*, ' $( '&%8,. «H#$(&!, *"$!>"(. A!4(#(A!!, – @!#*4 C. C!"1%4<)*"1, – %#$< @&%?1% '#%;( &*##8($&%"!% @&(!#:(?1%"!, +*@*1"(. "*5/! '(()F%" (63, #. 1). H"*>% ;('(&,, *"$!>"*, "*$5&A!4(#(A!, – E$( (1"('&%8%""( ! @%&'*, "*5/* ' @(+"*"!! @&!&(16. J*/('(, "*@&!8%&, 8"%"!% 9. -!4,: «0!4(#(A!, ' ;&%>%#/(8 @%&!(1% – E$( "*5/*. 0!4(#(A!, E$( ;&%>%#/*, "*5/*» (330, #. 9). M("/&%$!+!&5, E$( ()F%% 5#$*"('4%"!% ' @4*"% @%&#("!A!/*2!! ;%"%+!#* %'&(@%.#/(. "*5/! ' *"$!>"6% '&%8%"*, K?.C. *&8%&! ($8%$!4, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$(, «"*>!"*, # 9&!#$($%4, ! @(#4% "%;(, +"*"!% 2%4(;( &,1* ,'4%"!. &*+'!'*%$#, ' "*5/5… M(&"!, 5/&%@!'7!%#, 1( 9&!#$($%4,, )64! ?!+"%""68! /(&",8!, @&%1"*+"*>%""68! / &*+'!$!G…» (245, #. 8). H 1*4%% – ( «/(&",:», ( 0*4%#%, 9"*/#!8*"1&%, B!A*;(&% ! 1&5;!: @&%17%#$'%""!/*: 9&!#$($%4,, *"$!>"6: "*$5&A!4(#(A*:. C @(+"*'*%8(. @&!&(1% @%&'("*>*4<"*, ;&%>%#/*, "*5/*, #!&%>< "*$5&A!4(#(A!,, @(#&%1#$'(8 *)#$&*/$"(;(, 4(;!>%#/! (&;*"!+('*""(;(
32
8674%"!, #$&%8!4*#< '6,'!$<, @(",$< ! ()I,#"!$< 8*$%&!*4<"5G @%&'((#"('5 '#%;( #5F%#$'5GF%;(, %1!"(% #5)#$*"2!*4<"(% @%&'("*>*4( )%#/("%>"(;( 8"(;(()&*+!, @&%18%$(', ,'4%"!. ! @&(2%##(', #(#$*'4,GF!: 1(#$5@"(% "%@(#&%1#$'%""(85 "*)4G1%"!G )6$!% '"%7"%;( 8!&*. H+'%#$"6. "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A–"%(/*"$!*"%2 L. M*##!&%& #>!$*4, >$( «4(;!>%#/*, !1%, #5)#$*"2!! #$(!$ '(()F% '( ;4*'% "*5>"(;( &*##8($&%"!, 8!&*; !#$(&!>%#/! ("* @&%1#$*'4,%$ 8%?5, ($1%4,GF5G ("*5>"(%) !##4%1('*"!% ($ 8!A*. J(4%"(;( L. B!/*&*: A!4(#(A#/!% 58(+*/4G>%"!,, «' /($(&6: '#% #'%1%"( / %1!"(. #5)#$*"2!! ! ' /($(&6: 1'!?%"!% @&%1#$*'4,%$#, #5F%#$'%""68 A*/$(&(8, ($8%>*G$ #()(. /&5@"5G 1*$5 ' !#$(&!! &*+'!$!, >%4('%>%#/(;( 15:*. V*&(?1*'7*,#, ;&%>%#/*, "*5/* )64* )%+58"( #8%4*. H##4%1('*$%4! #58%4! ($/&6$< 5 1&%'"%.7!: 86#4!$%4%. =&%2!! /*/ )6 @&%1>5'#$'!,, 1(;*1/! ( "%/($(&6: !+ "*!)(4%% ()F!: @&!"2!@(' #('&%8%""(. "*5/!» (301, #. 9). J*/, @&!8%"!$%4<"( / /("/&%$"(. @(+"*'*$%4<"(. #!$5*2!! ' #('&%8%""(. %85 A!+!/%, ()(#"('6'*, !1%G "%()&*$!8(#$! A!+!>%#/!: @&(2%##(', B!/*& #>%4 "5?"68 1()*'!$<: «=%&*/4!$ )64 @&*': "!/$( "% 8(?%$ @(;&5+!$<#, 1'*?16 ' (1!" ! $($ ?% @($(/. R%4<+, 1*$< ()&*$"6. :(1 8!&('(. 8*7!"%» ($*8 ?%, #. 26). H$*/, (#"('"68 ()I%/$(8 @(+"*"!, 14, 1&%'"%;&%>%#/(. "*5/! )64* >5'#$'%""( '(#@&!"!8*%8*, @&!&(1*, * ' "%. –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– /*?1(% ' #'(%. @(+"*'*$%4<"(. #A%&%, – &*+1%4!#< ! #(($'%$#$'5GF!8 ()&*+(8 /("#$!$5!&('*4!#<: E8@!&!>%#/(% E/#@4!2!&('*4(#< ' (@6$"(% %#$%#$'(+"*"!% ! #*8((@&%1%4!4(#< ' "%8; &*2!("*4<"(%, ' #'(G (>%&%1<, $&*"#A(&8!&('*4(#< ' A!4(#(A!G ! #*8((@&%1%4!4(#< ' "%.. 0!4(#(A!, ' #'(%8 #()#$'%""(8 /*>%#$'%, '"% &*8(/ "*$5&A!4(#(A!! – E$( !#/4G>!$%4<"( &*2!("*4<"(% @(+"*"!%, "* >%8 "*#$*!'*4! @&%?1% '#%;( #*8! A!4(#(A6 &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( @%&!(1*. L.D. -*14(', "*@&!8%&, 5$'%&?1*4, >$( «!#$(>"!/ A!4(#(A!! %#$< &*+58» (315, #. 12). (?"( 1()*'!$<: "% $(4"!/ – ' #5)I%/$!'"(8 8674%"!! A!4(#(A*, "( – ' &*8/*: ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/(;( #*8(@(+"*"!, – ! (1!" !+ %%, A!4(#(A!!, (#"('"6: ()I%/$(' !+5>%"!,. P. 9#/(4<1(', "*@&!8%&, @(4*;*4, >$( @%&'(.
33
! '*?"%.7%. 14, A!4(#(A!! ,'4,%$#, «@&()4%8* ( @&!&(1% >%4('%>%#/(;( &*+58* ! %;( A5"/2!! – @(+"*"!!» (13, #. 1). B(E$(85, /*/ @(1>%&/!'*4 C. P%+%8*", «A!4(#(A!, @( #*8(85 #'(%85 #5F%#$'5 $%+'!"%78"%. C E$(8 %% #86#4 ! +"*>%"!%… 3"* +*1*%$#, 2%4"*. -*+8674%"!% ! 5;45)4%""(% @&("!/"('%"!% ' *@@*&*$ &*+8674%"!, – &*+58 – "%!+)%?"( ':(1,$ ' A!4(#(A#/5G &*)($5. K4, A!4(#(A!! &*+58 %#$< '%&:('"6. #51<,; +*/("6 &*+58* (@&%1%4,G$ %% #5?1%"!,. L$( %#$< '%&:('"(% "*>*4( +"*"!,» (61, #. 106). B&! E$(8, ;('(&, #4('*8! 9. -%,, «/("%>"(. 2%4*%86: '%F%. – E$( $*/?% ! /("%>"*, 2%4< %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, ! 1(#$!;*%$#, ("* "% $(4%&%+ &*2!("*4<"(%, /*/ ' A!4(#(A!!, "( ! >%&%+ #(@&,?%""(% # "!8 E8@!&!>%#/(%. W#$%#$'(+"*"!% ' #'(%8 #()#$'%""(8 /*>%#$'%, +* @&%1%4*8! "*$5&A!4(#(A!! – E$(, ' 2%4(8, @(+"*"!% E8@!&!>%#/(% ! ($>*#$! &*2!("*4<"(%, E8@!&!>%#/(% @&! #(1%.#$'!! &*2!("*4<"(;(, E8@!&!>%#/!&*2!("*4<"(%. 0!4(#(A6 ! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( @%&!(1* ("% '#%, &*+58%%$#,) A!/#!&('*4! E$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'( /*/ "%>$( (>%'!1"(% ! "%#(8"%""(%. J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, A&*"25+#/!. 5>%"6. B. K%4<)E "*#$*!'*4 "* $(8, >$( «"*)4G1%"!, ,'4,G$#, (#"('*"!%8 14, '#%: "*5/. R%$ !"(;( #@(#()* @(+"*$< @&!&(15, /*/ "*)4G1%"!%» (267, #. 185). K&5;(. A&*"25+, 9. B5*"/*&%, '61%4,, !#:(1"5G E8@!&!>%#/5G #(#$*'4,GF5G %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, @(1>%&/"54, >$( «"*5>"6. 8%$(1 +*/4G>*%$#, ' "*)4G1%"!! ! E/#@%&!8%"$!&('*"!!» (313, #. 569). R( E$( $(4"(;( 8%$(1*. R% 8%"%% #5F%#$'%""(. ! "%():(1!8(. ,'4,%$#, 1&5;*,, #',+*""*, # $%(&%$!>%#/!8 8674%"!%8, # &*2!("*4<"68 (#'(%"!%8 1*""6:, @(45>%""6: @&! "*)4G1%"!! ! E/#@%&!8%"$!&('*"!!. «R*)4G1%"!% A*/$(', – @!#*4 C. !"$(, – ()&*+5%$… '*?"%.7!. ($1%4 "*5>"(;( 8%$(1*… R( @(1>%&/!'*, $*/!8 ()&*+(8 "%():(1!8(#$< $(>"(;( "*)4G1%"!,, 86 1(4?"6 (#$%&%;*$<#, $(;(, >$()6 "% '@*#$< ' 1&5;5G @&($!'(@(4(?"5G /&*."(#$<, 86 "% 1(4?"6 158*$<, >$( (1"(;( "*)4G1%"!, 1(#$*$(>"(. R*)4G1%"!%, $(>"(% @&!8%"%"!% >5'#$'… %F% "% !#>%&@6'*%$ '#%. "*5>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$!. 6 8(?%8 ($8%>*$< A*/$6 %?%8!"5$"( ' $%>%"!% 2%4(;( 1",, "( ($ E$(;( 86 "!#/(4%"!.» (274, #. 184). M*/ @(1>%&/"54 L. R*'!4<, «"*)4G1%"!% ! 58(+*/4G>%"!% #5$< "%():(1!86% 5#4('!, ($/&6$!,» (282, #. XV). J*/('( ?% 8"%"!% ! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( @%&!(1*. J*/, "%8%2/!. 5>%"6. H. -%."/%, &*#/&6'*, A5"/2!("*4<"6% (#"('6 #(($"(7%"!, E8@!&!>%#/(;( ! &*2!("*4<"(;(
34
"*>*4 ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!!, @!#*4: «R*)4G1%"!% ! (@6$ ,'4,G$#, (&51!,8! @(+"*"!,, ()1586'*"!% ! '(()&*?%"!% – (&51!,8! ()I,#"%"!,» (322, #. 2). -*2!("*4<"(%, 4(;!>%#/! (&;*"!+('*""(%, $%(&%$!>%#/! (A(&84%""(% !!$< "('6% $*,;78-%-. "*5>"6: !##4%1('*"!. ' '!1% !#$!""(;(, +*/("('6&*?*GF%;( +"*"!,, #5F"(#$"(;( @("!8*"!, !+5>*%86: ()I%/$('. N$()6 1(#$!>< $*/!: &%+54<$*$(', #>!$*4 +"*8%"!$6. A&*"25+#/!. 5>%"6. . Q%&$4(, «>$()6 #',+*$<…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» (30, #. 6). L$( ()F*, :*&*/$%&!#$!>%#/*, >%&$* %#$%#$'%""(–"*5>"(. 8%$(1(4(;!!, %% (@&%1%4,GF*, +*/("(8%&"(#$<, &%*4<"6. 8%:*"!+8 1%.#$'!, /($(&(. J. =%/#4!, "*@&!8%&, &*#/&6'*4 #4%15GF!8 ()&*+(8: «M(;1* 86 )4*;(1*&, $F*$%4<"(85 ! @('$(&"(85 "*)4G1%"!G 5#$*"('!4!, >$( >$(-"!)51< @(#$(,""( ,'4,%$#, @&!>!"(G (@&%1%4%""(;( 1%.#$'!,, !4! >$( "%/($(&6% #()6$!, '#%;1* #('%&7*G$#, ' (1"(8 ! $(8 ?% @(&,1/%, – 86 ;('(&!8 ( &*#/&6$(. $*/!8 ()&*+(8 !#$!"%, /*/ ( ,%6!"* 2$'$!5.…» (98, #. 9–10). B(",$"(, >$( ' /("/&%$"(8 @(+"*'*$%4<"(8 @&(2%##% @5$< / E$(. ?%4*""(. 2%4! – / !#/(8(. !#$!"%, $( %#$< / +*/("5 @&!&(16 – "%():(1!8( '/4G>*%$ ' #%), ! $*/(. (),+*$%4<"6. ! #5F%#$'%""( '*?"6. 5>*#$(/, /*/ &*2!("*4<"(% (#'(%"!% &%+54<$*$(' "*)4G1%"!. ! (@6$(', 5#$*"('4%""6: A*/$('. «R*)4G1%"!%, – @!#*4 M. Q%&"*&, – %#$< $(45'#$', # @(8(F%#/(% &*##5?1%"!% 14, '6'(1* +*/4G>%"!,... P"*>*4* "*1( 5#$*"('!$< A*/$ ! %;( 5#4('!, @(#&%1#$'(8 "*)4G1%"!,, * +*$%8 @%&%.$! / ($6#/*"!G @&!>!"6, $( %#$< "*.$! +*/(" ,'4%"!,…» (27. #. 8). 3)()F*GF% A!/#!&5, +*/("(8%&"6. :*&*/$%& $*/(;( :(1* "*5>"6: !##4%1('*"!., L. M*&@%"$%& @(1>%&/"54, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( «"*5/* @%&%:(1!$ ($ ,'4%"!. / +*/("*8, ($ '!1!86: ! (#,+*%86: !"1!'!15*4<"6: (#()%""(#$%. / ()7!&"68 ()()F%"!,8…» (70, #. 28). L$5 +*/("(8%&"(#$< 5#$*"('!4 ! >%$/( ()(+"*>!4 ' #'(% '&%8, %F% 9&!#$($%4<: «B5$<, @( /($(&(85 !1%$ "*5/*, !#:(1!$ ($ @&%18%$(', 1%.#$'5GF!: "* "*7! >5'#$'*, ! @&!'(1!$ / +*/("*8, @(+"*'*%868 "*7!8
35
&*+58(8. N5'#$'* 1*G$ "*8 @&%1#$*'4%"!, () ($1%4<"6: /("/&%$"6: @&%18%$*:; &*+58, &*+4*;*, !: "* @&(#$%.7!% #(#$*'"6% E4%8%"$6, "*:(1!$ 8%?15 "!8! "%>$( ()F%%. R% #5F%#$'5%$ ! "% 8(?%$ #5F%#$'('*$< "*5/* ( %1!"!>"(8, >*#$"(8, )%#/("%>"( &*+"(()&*+"(8, @(#$(,""( !+8%",GF%8#,. (?%$ #5F%#$'('*$< $(4$( 8(?%$ #5F%#$'('*$< $(4$( 8(?%$ #5F%#$'('*$< $(4%""(;(, !4! *)#$&*/$"(;(» (190, #. 7, 9). H"*>% ;('(&,, &*2!("*4<"*, #(#$*'4,GF*, %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, "%():(1!8( @&%1@(4*;*%$ *)#$&*;!&5GF5G 1%,$%4<"(#$< @(+"*GF%;( 8674%"!,, 1%,$%4<"(#$<, +*/4G>*GF5G#,, ' #'(G (>%&%1<, ' ()&*+('*"!! ($'4%>%""6: @(",$!., ' 4(;!>%#/(8 (@%&!&('*"!! !8!. C >*#$"(#$!, @( 8"%"!G A&*"25+#/(;( 5>%"(;( L. B!/*&*, «@&(2%## &*+4!>%"!,, # @(8(F%""6% @(",$!, !;&*G$ #5F%#$'%""5G &(4< ' '(+"!/"('%"!! "*5/!: "*5>"(% @(+"*"!% (#5F%#$'4,%$#, # @(8(F%""6: @(",$!.» (301, #. 17–18). 9)#$&*;!&('*"!%, (@%&!&('*"!% ($'4%>%""68! @(",$!,8! – E$( '#%2%4( @(+"*'*$%4<"*, A5"/2!, &*+58*. H @($(85, #>!$*4 Q.P. Q6>/('#/!., «'( '#%: ()4*#$,: "*5/!, (@6$ ! &*+58 1(@(4",G$ 1&5; 1&5;*. 3"! $*/ $%#"( #@4%$%"6 1&5; # 1&5;(8, >$( "*8 $&51"( !: ($1%4!$<, !+(4!&('*$<… R*5/* /*/ @&(15/$ &*+58* ! (@6$*, "!/(;1* "% #8(?%$ '6.$! !+ @&%1%4(' E$!: 1'5: A*/$(&('…» (48, #. 11, 13). C &*2!("*4<"(. >*#$! "*5/!, ' %% 1!"*8!>%#/(. #(#$*'4,GF%. – ' 1%,$%4<"(#$"(., 4!>"(#$"(. #A%&% @(+"*"!,, ' ()1586'*"!! ! ()I,#"%"!! @(+"*'*%8(;( – !8@4!2!$"( #(:&*",%$#, A!4(#(A!,, 5"*#4%1('*""*, ($ @%&'("*>*4<"(. "*$5&A!4(#(A#/(. ()F"(#$!, #(:&*",%$#, ' $%(&%$!+!&('*"!!, ' *)#$&*/$"(8, 4(;!>%#/! (&;*"!+('*""(8 8674%"!! 5>%"(;(, ' @(",$!."( (A(&84%""(8 #5F"(#$"(8 (#86#4%"!! ! ()()F%"!! E8@!&!>%#/(;( 8*$%&!*4* ' 2%4,: 5#$*"('4%"!, !#$!""(;(, +*/("('6&*?*GF%;( +"*"!,. 0&*"25+#/!. 5>%"6. L. B!/*& @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «M*/ )6 &*+4!>"6 "! )64! $%"1%"2!! ' &*+"6: ()4*#$,: "*5/!, ("* @&%1#$*'4,%$#, "*8, /*/ $%(&!, '"%7"%;( 8!&*, &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( #/'(+< ($'4%>%""6% @(",$!,, @(45>%""6% "*8! @5$%8 *)#$&*/2!! !+ (@6$* ! #)4!?%"!, 8%?15 #()(. 14, '6'%1%"!, +*/("(', 1(+'(4,GF!: #!#$%8*$!+*2!G ! @&%1'!1%"!% !:» (301, #. 28). H8%, ' '!1% E$5 "%():(1!85G &*2!("*4<"5G /("#$*"$5 ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!!, C.H. C%&"*1#/!. @(1>%&/"54, >$( «@&(2%## &*+8674%"!,, $( %#$< @&!8%"%"!% &*+58* / @("!8*G &%*4<"(#$!, ()F ! 14, "*5/!, ! 14, A!4(#(A!!» (61, #. 107). H E$( ()F%% # A!4(#(A!%. &*2!("*4<"(% ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, @(",$!."( (A(&84,,#< ' !"1!'!15*4<"6: &*+8674%"!,: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., ' !: $%(&%$!>%#/!: '6'(1*: ! ()()F%"!,:, E/#@4!2!&5%$#, ' (@&%1%4%""5G #!#$%85 A!4(#(A#/!: '(++&%"!.,
36
($4*;*%$#, ' #(+"*"!! $(;( !4! !"(;( 5>%"(;( ' /*>%#$'% %;( 7'0"!#! &'7!1!&16!#! :'$!9!,,$*"'(, /*/ #(#$*'"(. >*#$! ()F%;( "*5>"(;( 8!&('(++&%"!,. C E$(8 $*/?% @&(,'4,%$#,, :($, ! /(#'%""(, "*5>"6. #$*$5# A!4(#(A!!. C 2%4(8 ?% A!4(#(A!, – E$( 4!>"(% &*2!("*4<"(% "*5>"(% @(+"*"!% !4! &*2!("*4<"*, "*5/* A!4(#(A* – * &*'"( ! A!4(#(A#$'5GF%;( 5>%"(;( – /*/ 4!>"(#$!. § 4. ">8D7D3DE=D A=3242A==: E;6<; = F528ID4F52 N%4('%>%#/(% @(+"*"!%, /("%>"( ?%, "% !#>%&@6'*%$#, "*5/(. ' %% E8@!&!>%#/!: ! &*2!("*4<"6: @&%$'(&%"!,:. =('(&, #4('*8! L. Q5$&5, «@(+"*"!% 7!&% "*5/!» (47, #. 71). C @(+"*"!!, ' >*#$"(#$!, /&(8% E8@!&!>%#/(;( ! &*2!("*4<"(;( "*>*4, # "%():(1!8(#$5'#$'%""(%, E8(2!("*4<"(% "*>*4(, #'(% '(()&*?%"!%, #'(, A*"$*+!,, $( !4! !"(% "*#$&(%"!% ! $.@., $( %#$< '#% $(, >$( :*&*/$%&!+5%$ ! @&%18%$"( (@&%1%4,%$ >%4('%>%#/(% -9!$0*1-9!. !& @(+"*%$#, >%4('%/(8 "% $(4%&%+ #(+%&2*"!% ! (#86#4%"!% '"%7"%. 1*""(#$!, "( ! >%&%+ $'(&%"!%, #(+!1*"!% "('(;( ' $%: !4! !"6: #()#$'%""6: @&(!+'%1%"!,:. J'(&>%#/!. */$ – E$( "% $(4%4('%>%#/(. #5)I%/$!'"(#$!, "( ! 8(8%"$ #$*"('4%"!, ()I%/$!'"(. '1-'"., (@&%1%4%""6. @(+"*'*$%4<"6. */$, ($/&6'*GF!. 14, /("/&%$"(;( +"*"!, ! #5F"(#$"(;( @("!8*"!, "%>$( "('(% ' $(8 !4! !"(8 A&*;8%"$% '"%7"%;( 8!&* !4! >%4('%>%#/(;( 15:*. H#/5##$'(, :51(?%#$'%""(% $'(&>%#$'( –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
37
(?!'(@!#2*, /(8@(+!$(&*, @(E$*) ' #(($'%$#$'5GF!: @&(!+'%1%"!,: !#/5##$'*. J'(&>%#$'(, #4%1('*$%4<"(, /*/ ! "*5/*, (),+*$%4<"( @&%1@(4*;*%$ – @(8!8( '#%;( @&(>%;( – (@&%1%4%""(% ,"%"'* ! 2!"':%"'*; "( %#4! ' "*5/% $( ! 1&5;(% – ()F%%, )%+4!>"(% ' #'(!: +*A!/#!&('*""6: A(&8*:, ' /("%>"6: &%+54<$*$*: @(+"*"!,, $( ' $'(&>%#$'%, ' %;( &%+54<$*$*:, ' @&(!+'%1%"!,: !#/5##$'* – $(4"(% ! @($(85 '#%;1* 5"!/*4<"(%, "%@('$(&!8(%. B(E$(85 ' (&!;!"*4% 4G)*, /*&$!"* :51(?"!/*, 4G)(% $'(&%"!% #/54<@$(&* !4! #$!:($'(&%"!% @(E$* 5"!/*4<"6. 3$8%>%""(% @&!8%"!$%4<"( / !#/5##$'5, :51(?%#$'%""(85 $'(&>%#$'5 ' (@&%1%4%""(. 8%&% @&!#5F% ! A!4(#(A!!. H ' "%., ' %% (&!;!"*4<"6: $'(&%"!,:, ' &%+54<$*$*: A!4(#(A#$'('*"!, $(;( !4! !"(;( 86#4!$%4, (' %;( /("/&%$"6: !1%,:, /("2%@2!,:, ' %;( #!#$%8%, 5>%"!!, $%(&!! ! $.@.) 1(#$*$(>"( ($>%$4!'( @&(,'4,%$#, %;( 4!>"(#$< – ' 4!>"(8 !"$%&%#% %;( &*+58*, ' !"1!'!15*4<"6: (#()%""(#$,: 8674%"!,, ' @&%()4*1*GF%. $("*4<"(#$! ()(#"('*"!. !8 #'(%. @(+!2!!, ' (#()(8 /(4(&!$% !1%., ' #@%2!A!>%#/(8 #$!4% !: !+4(?%"!,, ' #5)I%/$!'"6: @&!#$&*#$!,:, A!4(#(A#/!: #!8@*$!,: ! *"$!@*$!,: ! $.1. J*/, @( 8"%"!G C.H. C%&"*1#/(;(, «' !#$(&!! >%4('%>%#/(. 86#4! A!4(#(A!, #6;&*4* ! !;&*%$ '%4!/5G &(4<: ("* !#:(1!4* !+ #!46 >%4('%>%#/(;( &*+58* ! >%4('%>%#/(. 4!>"(#$! !… ,'4,%$#, @(@6$/(. !+ 4!>"(#$! @(+"*$< #5F%%» (345, #. 137). L$5 ?% 4!>"(#$"5G @(1(@4%/5 @(+"*'*$%4<"(;( A5"/2!("!&('*"!, A!4(#(A!! ($8%$!4 ! "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A =. V!88%4< («(1!" !+ 15:('"6: '4*#$!$%4%.» $(;( '&%8%"!, /*/ "*+'*4 %;( C.H. C%&"*1#/!.): «R% 4!>"(#$< A!4(#(A* %#$< @&%18%$ A!4(#(A#/!: 5$'%&?1%"!., – E$! @(#4%1"!% "*@&*'4%"6 "* (@&%1%4%""5G &%*4<"(#$< ()I%/$!'"(;( #'(.#$'*, "( $*/, >$( /*?1*, 4!>"(#$< 9.(97(*- 1*<( 9 "'D» (157, #. 249). P $(>/! +&%"!, A&*"25+#/(;( A!4(#(A* L. Q5$&5, A!4(#(A!, «'('#% "% 158*%$ !#/4G>*$< #5)I%/$!'"(%, $'(&>%#/(%, '(+8(?"(%, #45>*."(%, ("* "% ($&!2*%$ ?!+"!, '4!,"!, "*7%. 86#4! ! '(4! "* 8!& A*/$('. R*@&($!', ("* #$&%8!$#, ()",$< #5)I%/$!'"(% ! ()I%/$!'"(% ' !: %1!"#$'%, ' !: @&(>"(. '+*!8"(. +*'!#!8(#$!, ()5#4('4%""(. %1!"#$'(8 "*7%;( &*+58*» (47, #. 76). D!>"(#$"(%, #5)I%/$!'"(% "*>*4( ' A!4(#(A!! (@&%1%4,%$ #@%2!A!/5 +"*"!, ! @("!8*"!, ' "%., #(1%&?*"!% ! #$%@%"< 1(#$('%&"(#$!, !#$!""(#$! $(;( ! 1&5;(;(. J*/, "*@&!8%&, B4*$(" +"*4 4! "*'%&",/*, >$( &%*4<"( #5F%#$'5G$ «!1%!» '%F%.? R%$, /("%>"(. K(#$('%&"(;(, 1%.#$'!$%4<"(;(, "* A*/$*: (#"('*""(;( ,"%"'( ( "!: 5 "%;( "% )64( ! "% 8(;4( )6$<. R( (" +"*4 – (@&%1%4%""( ! )%+5#4('"(, /*/ ! '#% 1&5;!% 4G1!, – >$( #5F%#$'5G$ #(#$*'4,GF!% 8!& %1!"!>"6% '%F!, "*@&!8%&, /("/&%$"6% &*#$%"!,, /("/&%$"6% ?!'($"6%, 1(8* ! $.1. R(, ' ($4!>!% ($ 1&5;!: 4G1%., (" @(@6$*4#, !1:.17'-8 )6$!% '#%: E$!: '%F%. ! ' #'(%8 4!>"(8 &*+58%, ' 4!>"(8 &*+8674%"!!, *)#$&*;!&5,#<, ($'4%/*,#< ! ()()F*,, 5,#"!4, 2!"(7, >$( 5 /*?1(;( /4*##* (1"(!8%""6: '%F%. – 5 '#%: &*#$%"!., '#%: ?!'($"6:, 1(8(' ! $.1. – %#$< "%>$( !
38
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«!1%.». 0&*"25+#/!. A!4(#(A J. -!)(, /*#*,#< E$(;( '(@&(#*, ($8%$!4, >$( ' !#$(&!! >%4('%>%#/(. 86#4! «@&%?1% '#%;( @(,'!4(#< ($'4%>%"!% ! ()()F%"!% >!#$( 58(+&!$%4<"(%, $( %#$< A!4(#(A#/(%… 3$'4%>%"!% '%1%$ / #*868 '6#(/!8 ()()F%"!,8; ($ "%@(#&%1#$'%""(;( ! @(#@%7"(;( 5@&(F%"!, "%#/(4/(8 1(#$!;*%$ /("%>"6: @&!>!" '%F%.... L$($ @&!%8, ;1% ($'4%>%"!% ! ()()F%"!% !;&*G$, ' #5F"(#$!, #45?%)"5G &(4< @( ($"(7%"!G / "%/($(&(. (#()(. A(&8% '(()&*?%"!,, '@%&'6% "*7%4 #%)% '6&*?%"!% ' B4*$("% ! %;( $%(&!! !1%.. P "!8 >%4('%>%#/!. 58 '@%&'6% !#@6$*4 $( "%'6&*+!8(% "*#4*?1%"!%, /($(&(% 1(#$*'4,%$ ()&*F%"!% # #*868! '6#(/!8! *)#$&*/2!,8!…» (324, #. 209). H ' E$(8 /*>%#$'% – !#$(>"!/* «"%'6&*+!8(;( "*#4*?1%"!,» – $%(&!, «!1%.» B4*$("*, %;( A!4(#(A!, – $'(&%"!% >%4('%>%#/(;( 15:* #$(4< ?% 5"!/*4<"(% ! "%@('$(&!8(%, /*/ !, #/*?%8, «3&%#$%,» L#:!4* !4! «Q(?%#$'%""*, /(8%1!,» K*"$%. J*/, @( 8"%"!G =.-=. =*1*8%&*, «A!4(#(A!, B4*$("*, E$(;( #/*+!$%4, 8!A(', /($(&6. # "%@(1&*?*%868 58%"!%8 #(%1!"!4 '(+'67%""(#$< ! !&("!G, 1&%'"GG 4%;%"15 ! >%$/( '6&*?%""5G 86#4<, '8%F*%$ ' #%), ! @(E+!G» (75, #. 117). C #(1%&?*$%4<"(. >*#$! A!4(#(A!! B4*$("*, ' %;( $%(&!! «!1%.» !#:(1"(% ,"%"'* (( %1!"!>"6: '%F*:) – ()I%/$!'"(%, )%+4!>"(%, /*/ ' "*5/%; @&(!+'(1"(% 2!"':%"'* ('(+'67%""(%, !&("!>"(% ! $. @.) – #5)I%/$!'"(%, 4!>"(%, /*/ ' @(E+!!, ' !#/5##$'%. H $*/ – 5 '#%: A!4(#(A(', $'(&2(' (&!;!"*4<"6: $%(&!., 5>%"!., #!#$%8. C E$(8 #86#4% A!4(#(A!, – $'(&>%#$'(, @(E+!,, !#/5##$'(, !#/5##$'( 2!"':%"'(. H /*/ '#,/(% !#/5##$'(, ("* @(-#'(%85 @&!>*#$"* / @&%/&*#"(85, / /&*#($% /*/ #@%2!A!>%#/(85 '6&*?%"!G '(#@&!,$!, 8!&*, %;( @(+"*"!,. C !#/5##$'%, ' :51(?%#$'%""(8 $'(&>%#$'% ' %;( 2%4(8 #'(%()&*+"( &%*4!+5%$#, ! @&(,'4,%$#, 4!>"(#$< >%4('%/* /*/ !#/*$%4, B&%/&*#"(;(, /*/ @(/4(""!/* ! 2%"!$%4, M&*#($6. H >%&%+ !#/5##$'(, >%&%+ %;( E8(2!("*4<"( (/&*7%""(% #(1%&?*"!% ! '6&*+!$%4<"6% #&%1#$'* – >%&%+ /&*#/!, $("*, ;*&8("!G, >%&%+ @(E$!>%#/(% #4('( ! 85+6/*4<"6. +'5/, >%&%+ :51(?%#$'%""6% ()&*+6 ! #('%&7%""6% #/54<@$5&"6% A(&86 – 1(#$!;*%$#, #(($'%$#$'5GF%% +"*"!% ! @("!8*"!% 8!&* ' %;( A&*;8%"$*&"(#$! ! ' %;( 2%4(8, '/4G>*, >%4('%/*, $( %#$< >%&%+ !#/5##$'( (@&%1%4,%$#, E#$%$!>%#/! ()(;*F%""(% ! ()4*;(&(?%""(% :'$!9!,,$*"'*, ()%#@%>!'*GF%% @&!()F%"!% / '1-'"* ! ' %% @&!>*#$"(#$! / @&%/&*#"(85,
39
/ /&*#($%. R*5>"*, !#$!"*, )515>! @&(>5'#$'('*""(., ,'4,%$ #()(. ! "%>$( @&%/&*#"(%, '(+)5?1*GF%% (F5F%"!% /&*#($6, @&(#$($6, #('%&7%"#$'* @(&(1!'7%. %% 86#4!. P(@&,?%""(#$< @(+"*GF%;( &*+58* # /&*#($(. ' %% #(($"(7%"!! # !#$!"(. ()"*&5?!'*%$#, 5?% "* "*>*4<"6: E$*@*: &*+'!$!, "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. J*/, @( 8"%"!G +"*8%"!$(;( A&*"25+#/(;( 5>%"(;( 9. B5*"/*&%, 1&%'"!% ;&%/!, 5>%"6% ! A!4(#(A6, «4G)!4! /&*#($5 !"$%44%/$5*4<"5G, /($(&*, #/&6'*%$#, +* /&*#($(. >5'#$'%""(., /($(&*, !8%""( ! 1%4*%$ &*+58 5'%&%""68 ! $'%&168» (313, #. 380). R* E$($ ?% E#$%$!>%#/!. *#@%/$ ' ()I,#"%"!! ! (2%"/% @(+"*GF%. 86#4! 1&%'"!: ;&%/(' ()&*$!4 '"!8*"!% ! 1&5;(. A&*"25+#/!. 5>%"6., L. B!/*&: «C E44!"#/(. A!4(#(A!! ! "*5/% @&(#$($*, &*2!("*4<"(#$< ! !#$!"* "%&*+&6'"( #',+*"6 8%?15 #()(.. PG1* #4%15%$ @&!)*'!$< %F% /&*#($5, $*/ /*/, #(;4*#"( @!A*;(&%.2*8, "*!)(4%% @&%/&*#"*, /(8)!"*2!, '%F%. %#$< ' $( ?% '&%8, ! "*!)(4%% !#$!""*, /(8)!"*2!, !:. 0!+!/* ! /(#8(4(;!, ;&%/(' )64! 1%4(8 $'(&>%#$'* "% $(4%"6:, "( $*/?% :51(?"!/(' ! @(E$('» (301, #. 10). H %F% ( $(8 ?%: «…K4, "%/($(&6: ;&%>%#/!: 86#4!$%4%. !1%! @&%/&*#"(;( ! @&(#$(;( #('@*1*4! – @( /&*."%. 8%&%, ($>*#$! – # !1%%. !#$!""(;(» ($*8 ?%, #. 12). H E$( #('@*1%"!% (#$*'*4(#< 1%.#$'%""68 A*/$(&(8 ' "*5/% "* @&($,?%"!! '#%;( %% @(#4%15GF%;( &*+'!$!,. 3$8%$!' $( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, >$( «' "*5/5 "*>*4! '%&!$< $(;1*, /(;1* 5)%1!4!#< ' %% @(4<+%», L. B!/*& 1()*'!4: «M E$(. '%&%, #'%&: $(;(, "*# @()5?1*%$ ! !+'%#$"(% E#$%$!>%#/(% >5'#$'(, >5'#$'( @(&,1/*, ;*&8("!!, !8%GF%%#, "%!+)%?"68 ()&*+(8 ' @(",$!! +*/("*. 6 (@,$< '#$&%>*%8#, # +"*/(8(. 5?% "*8 !1%%. ( #',+! !#$!""(;(, @(4%+"(;( ! @&%/&*#"(;(» ($*8 ?%, #. 19). H$*/, ' E8(2!("*4<"( '(#@&!",$(. "*5>"(. !#$!"% ()"*&5?!'*%$#, #'(, (#()*, /&*#($*. H A!4(#(A!, #( #'(%. #$(&("6 – #'(!8 !#/5##$'(8 @("!8*"!,, 8*#$%&#$'(8 8674%"!,, !+,F%#$'(8 4(;!/!, ;45)!"(. @&("!/"('%"!, ' #5F"(#$< @(+"*'*%8(;( ! $.@. – '/4G>*%$#, ' E#$%$!>%#/! @(@(4",%8(% 8!&('(++&%"!% ' /*>%#$'% "%():(1!8(;( #&%1#$'* 4!>"(#$"(;( ()&%$%"!, H#$!"6, &%*4!+5, $%8 #*868 ' E#$%$!>%#/! @&%4(84,%8(. &*2!("*4<"(#$! #'(. &(1#$'%""6. !#/5##$'5 #$*$5# $'(&>%#$'* "*&,15 # "*5>"68 #$*$5#(8. M*/ @!#*4 ' "*>*4% XX '%/* '%"#/!. A!4(#(A C. H%&5+*4%8, «A!4(#(A!, – "*5/*, @($(85 >$( ("* &*)($*%$ "* "*5>"6: (#"('*"!,: ! (@%&!&5%$ "*5>"68! 8%$(1*8!. 3"* – )(4%%, >%8 "*5/*, @($(85 >$( 1(#$!?%"!G %% 2%4! – ;*&8("!>%#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, – 1(4?"6 #(1%.#$'('*$< $*/?% A*"$*+!, ! >5'#$'(» (162, #. 11). 0*"$*+!, ! >5'#$'( (@4(1($'(&,G$ A!4(#(A#/5G 86#4< ' %% 4!>"(#$"(8, #5)I%/$!'"(8 @&%$'(&%"!!, #$!854!&5G$ ' "%. (@&%1%4%""6% $'(&>%#/!% @($%"2!!, ()5#4('4!'*, E$!8 #(($'%$#$'5GF5G A5"/2!("*4<"5G ()F"(#$< A!4(#(A!! # !#/5##$'(8. H =.-=. =*1*8%&, "*@&!8%&, &*#/&6'*, #'(% @("!8*"!% E$(. ()F"(#$!, @!#*4: « 674%"!% – E$( ! %#$< @(#$(,""*, )%#%1* 157! # #*8(. #()(.. J*/ >$( '@(4"% 8(?"(
40
#/*+*$<, >$( A!4(#(A!, +*/4G>*%$ ' #%)% $*/5G ?% "%1(#$!?!85G 2%4<, ()4*1*%$ $*/!8 ?% 1*4<"(1%.#$'!%8 ! '8%#$% # $%8 $(. ?% *)#(4G$"(. '&%8%""(. */$5*4<"(#$*,: '*?"( "%>$( 1&5;(% – ()&%#$! @&!>*#$"(#$<» (75, #. 146). B(",$"(, >$( ' 1*""(8 #45>*%, * &*'"( ! '( '#%: @&%17%#$'5GF!: &*##5?1%"!,:, !8%%$#, ' '!15 A!4(#(A!,, /*/ @&!+'*"!%, * "% /*/ @&(A%##!,, A!4(#(A!,, /*/ 5)%?1%"!%, * "% /*/ (1"( $(4*#$"(#$!, >$( «2%45*"'*, /($(&(;( @&(#$(% +"*"!% ($"(7%"!. %F% "% '/4G>*%$. 3$4!>!% A!4(#(A!! ($ "*5/! %#$< !8%""( ($4!>!% 5)%?1%"!, ($ +"*"!, ' $%#"(8 #86#4% E$(;( #4('*» (143, #. 4). H 1(4?"*, 5)%?1%""(#$< A!4(#(A* ! #(($'%$#$'5GF*, 5)%1!$%4<"(#$< %;( A!4(#(A!! @&%$'(&,G$#, ' ?!+"< "% $(4%&%+ ;45)!"5, ,#"(#$< ! $(>"(#$< %;( 86#4!, 4(;!>"(#$!, 1(/*+*$%4<"(#$! %% @(",$!."(;( &*#/&6$!,, "( ! >%&%+ E#$%$!>%#/(% "*>*4( ' "%., /&*#($5 %% !#$!""(#$!, >%&%+ «@(E+!G @(",$!.», /*/, '#4%1 +* 0.9. D*";%, (:*&*/$%&!+('*4 A!4(#(A!G C. C!"1%4<)*"1 (64, #. 3). J*/, ($"(#!$%4<"( (1"(. !+ #*86: !+'%#$"6: ! '4!,$%4<"6: A!4(#(A#/!: #!#$%8 &5##/!. 5>%"6. P.B. M(#$6>%' @(1>%&/"54, >$( «#!#$%8* T%44!";* :*&*/$%&!+5%$#, !"(;1* /*/ /&*#!'*, @(E8*, "*5>"(–A!4(#(A#/(% +"*>%"!% /($(&(. ($#$5@*%$ "* '$(&(. @4*" @%&%1 E#$%$!>%#/!8» (181, #. 8). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, '+;4,1 "* "*5/5, !#/5##$'( #/'(+< @&!+85 ()F%. 14, "!: @(+"*'*$%4<"(. A5"/2!! 1*%$ '(+8(?"(#$< '6,'!$< ' "!:, # (1"(. #$(&("6, "%>$( ()F%% , ()I%1!",GF%%, * !8%""( – &*2!("*4<"(% 4!>"(#$"(% "*>*4( ' !: 1!"*8!>%#/(., 1%,$%4<"(#$"(. >*#$!, ' #*8(8 "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 2$!+*11* @(+"*'*"!,, * # 1&5;(. –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
41
/*/ &%+54<$*$5 @(+"*"!,, $( +1%#< ()"*&5?!'*%$#, 4!7< #*8* 1*""*, "*5/* (A!+!/*, :!8!,, )!(4(;!, ! $.1.) – ! "!>%;( )(4<7%, "*5/* ' #'(%. */$5*4!+!&('*""(. 1*""(#$!, #5;5)(. #*8(1(#$*$(>"(#$!. 0!4(#(A!! – ,'"(., @(",$!."( +*A!/#!&('*""(. – +1%#<, ' ()I%/$!'"(-!#$!""(8 +"*"!!, 5?% "%$, ("* !88*"%"$"( ! !8@4!2!$"( #(:&*",%$#, 4!7< ' #5)I%/$!'"(8 #5F"(#$"(8 @("!8*"!! 5>%"68! #(1%&?*"!, E$(;( +"*"!,. C !#/5##$'%, – %#4! (;&*"!>!$<#, %;( @(+"*'*$%4<"(. A5"/2!%. ' ($'4%>%"!! ($ E#$%$!>%#/(., – @&(2%## $'(&>%#$'* $(?%, /*/ ! ' "*5/%, ' #'(%8 "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 &*+'%&$6'*"!!, ' !"1!'!15*4<"(8 (#5F%#$'4%"!! '#%2%4( (@&%1%4,%$#, ! "*@&*'4,%$#, 4!>"68! 15:('"68!, ' $(8 >!#4% ! !"$%44%/$5*4<"68!, 5#$&%84%"!,8! /("/&%$"(;( :51(?"!/* (@(E$*, #/54<@$(&* ! $.1.). R(, ' ($4!>!% ($ "*5/!, ' +*'%&7*GF%. >*#$!, ' 1(#$!;"5$(8 &%+54<$*$%, ' #(+1*""(8 @&(!+'%1%"!! (/*&$!"%, @(E8%, #/54<@$5&% ! 1&.) 4!>"(#$"(% #(:&*",%$#, ! ($>%$4!'( A!/#!&5%$#, ' %;( ;*&8("!>%#/(8 2%4(8, ' %1!"#$'% ! 86#4%., ! >5'#$' :51(?"!/*. C :51(?%#$'%""(8 $'(&>%#$'% 4!>"(#$< $'(&2* '( '#%8 )(;*$#$'% %% E8(2!("*4<"(;( ! !"$%44%/$5*4<"(;( #(1%&?*"!, ,%1-.9%*- ' %;( @&(!+'%1%"!!, ' $'(&%"!!, '(+)5?1*, ' +&!$%4%, >!$*$%4% #(($'%$#$'5GF!% 86#4! ! >5'#$'*, "*'(1,, ' >*#$"(#$!, ! "* (@&%1%4%""6% A!4(#(A#/!% &*+8674%"!,, '6#'%>!'*GF!% A!4(#(A#/(%, &*2!("*4<"(% "*>*4( ' !#/5##$'% (/*&$!"6 -*A*E4,, $&*;%1!! T%/#@!&*, &(8*"6 0. . K(#$(%'#/(;( ! $.1.). H, "*/("%2, ' A!4(#(A!!, ' &%*4!+*2!! %% @&!>*#$"(#$! / "*5/% ! !#/5##$'5, @&(2%## @(+"*"!, ' "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 &*+'%&$6'*"!! @&%18%$"(;( A!4(#(A#$'('*"!, !8%%$ #'(G (@&%1%4%""5G 4!>"(#$"5G #(#$*'4,GF5G: (" (#5F%#$'4,%$#, ' 4!>"(8 8674%"!! A!4(#(A*, "(, ' ($4!>!% ($ !#/5##$'*, ' +*'%&7*GF%. >*#$!, ' 1(#$!;"5$(8 &%+54<$*$% (' 4(;!>%#/! ()(#"('*""(. A!4(#(A#/(. /("2%@2!!, !1%%, #!#$%8% ! $.@.) 4!>"(% A!/#!&5%$#, "% '( '#%. %;( 15:('"(. @(4"($%, * 4!7< ' &*2!("*4<"(8 @&%$'(&%"!!, $( %#$< A!/#!&5G$#, $(4!$*$%4% #(($'%$#$'5GF!% 86#4!$%4<"6% &%*/2!! – #(;4*#!, !4! ($$(&?%"!,. D!>"(#$< A!4(#(A* &*#/&6'*%$#,, A%"(8%"!+!&5%$#,, @(",$!."( +*/&%@4,%$#, ' %;( (&!;!"*4<"(. A!4(#(A!! /*/ %;( 4!>"6. &*+58 – $(4%#/!: #(#$(,"!,: $(;( ! 1&5;(;(, ' (&;*"!>%#/(8 %1!"#$'% ()%!: !@(#$*#%.. B("!8*"!% E$(. "%():(1!8(. 1'(.#$'%""(#$! A!4(#(A!! ' "*>*4% XX '%/* '6&*+!4, "*@&!8%&, @&*'1*, 1('(4<"( #58)5&"( D. =*)&!4('!>: «H1%*4 "*5/! – @(+"*$<.., 2%4< $'(&>%#$'* – !#@6$6'*$< #*8(85 ! +*#$*'4,$< !#@6$6'*$< (#$*4<"6:. K4, $(;(, >$()6 @(+"*$< 8!&, "%():(1!8( %;( @%&%?!$<. %$*A!+!/* – "% 1%4( @(+"*"!,. C#,/*, 8%$*A!+!>%#/*, #!#$%8* '4*>!$ (/('6 >%4('%>%#/(. #5)I%/$!'"(#$!. 3"* – 4!7< >*#$"*, !#$!"*… -*)($* 86#4! )%#@4(1"*, %#4! $'(&>%#$'( "% 5'4%/*%$ "*# ' $*."5» (74, #. 20). Q(4%% ($>%$4!'( E$5
42
86#4< '6&*+!4 $(;1* ?% C. C!"1%4<)*"1: «…J($, /$( !+-+* @4(#/(;( '6#(/(8%&!, #('&%8%""(;( '#%+"*.#$'* "% @($%&,4 %F% 5'*?%"!, / !#$(&!!, /$( %F% #@(#()%" @&%/4(",$<#, @%&%1 ()&*+*8! '%4!/!: A!4(#(A#/!: #!#$%8, '#% ?% 1(4?%" )51%$ @&!+"*$<, >$( 1*"< %;( >5'#$'* +*#45?!'*%$ ($"G1< "% '#%;1* "*5>"(% +"*>%"!% E$!: #!#$%8, * 4!)( E"%&;!, )4*;(&(1"(;( 8!&(#(+%&2*"!,, 4!)( :51(?%#$'%""*, ;*&8("!+*2!, @&($!'(&%>!'6: !1%., 4!)( 7!&($* ()I%84GF%;( 8!& #(+%&2*"!,, 4!)(, "*/("%2, $'(&>%#/*, 8(F< #',+5GF%. &*)($6 86#4!» (64, #. 5). P(>%$*"!% ' A!4(#(A!! &*'"(+"*>"6: "*>*4 "*5>"(#$! ! :51(?%#$'%""(;( $'(&>%#$'* @(+'(4,%$ :*&*/$%&!+('*$< %% /*/ #'(%;( &(1* $'(&>%#/5G "*5/5 !4! "*5>"(% $'(&>%#$'(. C@&(>%8, E$( @(#4%1"%% ()(+"*>%"!% («"*5>"(% $'(&>%#$'(») !#@(4<+('*4(#< "%/($(&68! 5>%"68! (B!/*&, B5*"/*&% ! 1&.) ! @&!8%"!$%4<"( / "*5/% (#8., "*@&., 301, #. 11, 26; 313, #. 369). H#:(1, !+ '#%;( ($8%>%""(;( '67% ($"(#!$%4<"( #$*$5#* A!4(#(A!!, 8(?"( @(@6$*$<#, ()(+"*>!$< %% 2$*5:*-, !8%, ' '!15 @(#4%15GF%% &*+I,#"%"!% %% #(($"(7%"!, # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8, # 8!&('(++&%"!%8 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%.. §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«X» ! 1&5;!8, 8%?15 #5)I%/$(8 ! ()I%/$(8, 8%?15 >%4('%/(8 ! ()F%#$'(8, "*/("%2 –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
43
"*5/!, E#$%$!/* ! $.@.). R%():(1!8(. #(#$*'"(. >*#$%4('%>%#/(;( "*>*4* ' "%8) ,'4,%$#, ! @&()4%8*$!/*, #',+*""*, # %%, A!4(#(A!!, #*8(@(+"*"!%8 (!#$(&!, A!4(#(A!!, !#$(&!, 8*$%&!*4!+8*, !#$(&!, 1!*4%/$!/! ! @&. – ' 2%4(8 ! @( ($1%4<"68 E$*@*8, '&%8%""68 @%&!(1*8). 3>%'!1"( $*/?%, >$( ! 1&5;!% (&;*"!+('*""6% #5)I%/$6 @(+"*"!,, ' >*#$"(#$!, %#$%#$'%""6% "*5/! $*/ !4! !"*>% &%7*G$ "*+'*""5G '67% @&()4%85 (8!&, >%4('%/ ' "%8 ! 8!& ' >%4('%/%) – /*?1*, "*5/* @(-#'(%85, /*?1*, – #'(!8! #@%2!A!>%#/!8! #&%1#$'*8!, ' @&%1%4*: #'(%;( @&%18%$*, ' $(. !4! !"(. 8%&% @&!>*#$"(;( / 8!&5 /*/ ()I%/$5 @(+"*"!,, /*?1*, #( #'(!8 '/4*1(8 ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"5G /*&$!"5 8!&* ! >%&%+ "%% – ' ()F%% "*5>"(% :'$!9!,,$*"'*. J*/!8 ()&*+(8, 5 '#%. A!4(#(A!! ' %% 2%4(8 ! 5 '#%;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!, – (1!" ! $($ ?% ()F!. 14, "!: ()I%/$ @(+"*"!,, "( !: @(1:(16 / "%85, #&%1#$'* ! 8%$(16 %;( !+5>%"!, – @&!"2!@!*4<"( &*+"6%, @(1>*# @&($!'(@(4(?"6% ! @&!$(8, /*/ @&*'!4(, '+*!8(1(@(4",GF!%. 0!4(#(A!, ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!% ' E$(8 #86#4%, @( 8"%"!G C.H. C%&"*1#/(;(, «E$( #$(&("6 (1"(;( ! $(;( ?% @&(2%##* – #$(&("6 #('%&7%""( "%!+)%?"6% ! "%($1%4!86%. 3"! ($1%4,G$#, $(4"(. 86#4! "!/(;1* 1(4;( "% !1%$ 1%15/2!%. !4! !"15/2!%. – ("( 1(4?"( !8%$< #'(! /(&"! ' 1&5;(. – )(4%% @(4"(. @(E+!! ! A*"$*+!! ()4*#$!: E$(… ()4*#$<, "% #',+*""*, # $(>"(. 1%15/2!%. !4! !"15/2!%., &*2!("*4!#$!>%#/!8 @&(2%##(8 – ()4*#$< A!4(#(A!!» (345, #. 193). C ()4*#$! A!4(#(A!!, ' #&*'"%"!! # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8, @&!8%"!$%4<"( / 8!&5 (@&!&(1%) /*/ ()F%85 ()I%/$5 @(+"*"!, (#"('"(% &*+4!>!% ' @(1:(1*: (@&%1%4!4(#< ' &*8/*: #(($"(7%"!, 0%1-' ! +*7!#!, ' 1*""(8 #45>*% – #(($"(7%"!, :'$% /*/ +*7!#! ! 8!&* ' %;( 1!#/&%$"(#$!, A&*;8%"$*&"(#$!, ' $%: !4! !"6: 0%1-".D #(#$(,"!,:. M("/&%$"( E$(, ' @&%1#$*'4%"!! A!4(#(A(' &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( @%&!(1*, (+"*>*4(, >$( 8!& (@&!&(1*), # (1"(. #$(&("6, /*/ @!#*4 "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A ! @#!:(4(; J. D!@@#, «%#$< "% )%#A(&8%""*, 8*##*, * %1!"#$'(, "%/($(&(% 2%4(%, (@&%1%4%""(% @('#G15 "% $(4%'!1"(, >$( ' %1!"(. @&!&(1%, ' 8!&% /*/ 2%4(8 ()"*&5?!'*%$#, 8"(?%#$'( ($"(#!$%4<"( #*8(#$(,$%4<"6: ($1%4<"6:, >*#$"6: 8!&(', !+5>%"!% /($(&6: ! (@&%1%4,%$ 2%4! ! +*1*>! %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/, #*86. #86#4 !: #5F%#$'('*"!,, !: 8%#$( ! &(4< '( '#%8 >%4('%>%#/(8 @(+"*"!!. !/&(8!&, 8*/&(8!&, 8!& 8(4%/54, &*#$!$%4<"6. 8!&, ?!'($"6. 8!& ! $.1. ! $.@. – '#% E$! &*+"(/*>%#$'%""6% 8!&6 1%$*4<"( !##4%15G$ A!+!>%#/!%, :!8!>%#/!%, )!(4(;!>%#/!% ! 1&5;!% %#$%#$'%""6% "*5/!: 5 /*?1(. – #'(. #@%2!A!>%#/!. ()I%/$, #'(. 8!&, /("/&%$"6. A&*;8%"$ )%#/("%>"( #4(?"(;( 8!&* ' %;( 2%4(8, !&*. N%&%+ #@%2!*4!+!&('*""(% !+5>%"!% '#%: E$!: 8!&(' %#$%#$'%""6% "*5/!
44
#('8%#$"68! 5#!4!,8! $*/ !4! !"*>% @(1#$5@*G$ / @(#$!?%"!G #5F"(#$! '#%;( 8!&* ' 2%4(8, 8!&* 8!&(', "* ($1%4<"6: 5>*#$/*: '6,'4,G$ /*/!%-$( %% 1(#$*$(>"( +"*>!$%4<"6% >*#$"(#$! (*$(8"6%, 8(4%/54,&"6%, ;%"%$!>%#/!% ! @&.), "( @&("!/"5$< ' "%%, ' %% ()F%8!&('(% 2%4(%, @(",$< ! ()I,#"!$< %% ("!, /("%>"(, "% ' #(#$(,"!!, @&%?1% '#%;( – ' #!45 #*8(;( :*&*/$%&* ! #(1%&?*"!, @(45>*%8(;( !8! +"*"!,, #$%@%"! %;( 1(#$('%&"(#$!. J*/, @( 8"%"!G C4. P(4('<%'*, >*#$"6% "*5/! «1('(4<#$'5G$#, 1(#$('%&"(#$$( @(#$!?%"!% #5F"(#$! 8!&* ' 2%4(8, «/*/ )6$!, &%*4<"(;(», "%1(#$5@"(% 14, %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/, ! "% ':(1!$ ' !: 2%4! ! +*1*>!. L$( @&%1%4<"*,, * @&*'!4<"%% #/*+*$<, )%#@&%1%4<"*, +*1*>* A!4(#(A!!, %% @(#$(,""*, ! "%!+8%""*,, /*/ ;(&!+("$, /("%>"*, 2%4<. !& /*/ 2%4(%, %;( 8"(;(5&('"%'*, #5F"(#$< – ' #$*"('4%"!!, ' "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 )6$!! ! "%@&%&6'"(8 &*+'!$!! – #(#$*'4,%$ #@%2!A!>%#/!., @&%1%4<"( ()F!. @&%18%$ A!4(#(A!! ' %% @(+"*'*$%4<"(8 2%4(8. L$* 86#4< – ' $(. !4! !"(. #!#$%8% ()(#"('*"!,, ' $(8 !4! !"(8 &*+I,#",GF%8 /("$%/#$% – )64* (1"(. !+ "*!)(4%% &*#@&(#$&*"%""6: ! 5#$(.>!'6: ' A!4(#(A!! /("2* XIX – "*>*4* XX ''. J*/, @( 8"%"!G =. V!88%4,, «8!& 1*" "*8, /*/ #588* A&*;8%"$(', ! +*1*>* A!4(#(A!! #(#$(!$ ' $(8, >$()6 "*.$! 14, "!: 2%4(%» (157, #. 251). 98%&!/*"#/!. A!4(#(A 9.M. -(1?%&# #>!$*4, >$( @&()4%86 A!4(#(A!! #',+*"6 «# $*/!8 '#%()I%84GF!8 '(@&(#(8: /*/('* (#"('"*, @&!&(1* &%*4<"(#$!, '#%4%""(., ' /($(&(. 86 ?!'%8?» (332, #. 13). R.3. D(##/!., (@&%1%4,, @&%18%$ A!4(#(A!!, @(1>%&/"54, >$( «A!4(#(A!, %#$< "*5/* ( 8!&%, /*/ 2%4(8» (221, #. 19). B&! E$(8 D(##/!. ($8%$!4 #('@*1%"!% #'(%. @(+!2!! ' 1*""(8 '(@&(#% # *"*4(;!>"(. $(>/(. +&%"!, 0. B*54<#%"*, 5$'%&?1*'7%;(, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( A!4(#(A!, «' #*8(8 ()F%8 +"*>%"!! #4('* %#$< "% >$( !"(%, /*/ @(#$(,""( @('$(&,GF*,#, @(@6$/* 1(#$!;"5$< 2%4<"(;( %1!"#$'* @&%1#$*'4%"!. ! 86#4%. ( A(&8% ! #',+!, ( #86#4% ! +"*>%"!! '#%: '%F%.» (298, #. 3). J*/(% ?% @("!8*"!% @&%18%$* A!4(#(A!! +*A!/#!&('*"( ! ' #4%15GF%8 #5?1%"!! A&*"25+#/(;( A!4(#(A* L. R*'!4,: «H1%, A!4(#(A!!, /*/ ("* @&(,'4,%$#, ' !#$(&!!, %#$< !+5>%"!% @&()4%86 5"!'%&#*4<"(. (()F%8!&('(.), ' @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$< >*#$"68 "*5/*8, (;&*"!>!'*GF!8 #'(! !+6#/*"!, (@&%1%4%""68 /4*##(8 A*/$('» (283, #. 1-2). C ($"(7%"!! @(#4%1"%;( ()#$(,$%4<#$'* – ($4!>!, @&%18%$* A!4(#(A!! ($ @&%18%$(' >*#$"6: "*5/ – 8(?"( #(#4*$<#, $*/?% "* 8"%"!% =. P@%"#%&*: «R*+'*"!% A!4(#(A!! #4%15%$ @&!#'(!$< +"*"!G, !8%GF%85 "*!'6#75G #$%@%"< '#%()F"(#$!. R*5/* (+"*>*%$ 4!7< #%8*%$ 4!7< #('(/5@"(#$< +"*"!,, ()&*+5GF%;(#, !+ !: ($1%4<"6: '/4*1(', ! !;"(&!&5%$ +"*"!%, ()&*+5GF%%#, )4*;(1*&, 17'("'4 '#%: E$!: '/4*1(' ' (1"( 2%4(%» (340, #. 75).
45
[%4(#$"(#$< @&%18%$* '#%. A!4(#(A!! ' %% @(+"*'*$%4<"(. "*@&*'4%""(#$! "* 8!& ' %;( 2%4(8 "%():(1!8( ()5#4('4!'*%$ %%, A!4(#(A!!, (>%'!1"5G #(@&,?%""(#$< # :'$!9!,,$*"'*:. B(1>%&/!'*, E$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, !+'%#$"6. "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A =. -!//%&$ @!#*4: «N$( 8!&('(% 2%4(% – @&%18%$ A!4(#(A!!, ! >$( ("* ' @(#4%1"%8 #>%$% #$&%8!$#, / $(85, >$( 86 "*+6'*%8… @(>$! "%+*8%"!868 #4('(8 «8!&('(++&%"!%», '&,1 4! /$( &%7!$#, (#@*&!'*$<. J(4!, 8(?%$ )6$< "*+'*"* A!4(#(A!%.. L$( '(()F% %1!"#$'%""6. #@(#() ($;&*"!>!$< %% ($ #@%2!*4<"6: "*5/. C E$(8 $(4$( "% $(4%#/! 2%4<"(% %1!"#$'(, $( (" ,'4,%$#, @&%1#$*'!$%4%8 5?% "% ($1%4<"(. (&;*"!>%#/(. $%(&!!, * 2%4(;( !$#%"'0*16!#! :'$!9!,,$*"'(» (224, #. 9). B(",$"(, >$( ' E$( (&;*"!>%#/(% 8!&('(++&%"!% (&;*"!>%#/! '@!#6'*%$#, – /*/ #(#$*'"*, >*#$< 8!&* – ! 0*7!9*6 # %;( #@%2!A!>%#/!8 15:('"68 8!&(8, #5F"(#$"(% @(#$!?%"!% /($(&(;( ' &*8/*: 8!&('(;( 2%4(;( $*/?% #(#$*'4,%$ /("%>"5G 2%4< A!4(#(A#/(;( @(+"*"!,, 2%4<, @5#$< ! "%1(#$!?!85G '( '#%8 %% ()I%8%, "( @(#$(,""( ! 1%.#$'%""( #$!854!&5GF5G @(!#/('6% #$&%84%"!, A!4(#(A!!. 3@&%1%4,, 2%4< E$!: #$&%84%"!., =. M(&"%4!5# @(1>%&/"54, >$( ("*, 2%4<, «%#$< %1!"(% 8!&('(++&%"!%, ' (1!"*/('(. 8%&% 1*GF%% ($>%$ ( ,'4%"!,: @&!&(16 ! ,'4%"!,: 15:('"(. ?!+"!, ( +*/("*: ()I%/$!'"(;( 8!&* ! ( +*/("*: >%4('%>%#/!: #$&%84%"!.» (180, #. 14). B&%:(1,F!. :*&*/$%& >*#$"6: 1(#$!?%"!. A!4(#(A!! ' %% @(+"*'*$%4<"(8 @&(1'!?%"!! / "*+'*""(. 2%4!, ' @(#$(,""(. #8%"% /("/&%$"6: A!4(#(A#/!: #!#$%8, 5>%"!., $%(&!., (&!%"$!&('*""6: "* &%*4!+*2!G E$(. 2%4!, "! ' /(%. 8%&% "% @&!"!?*%$ "%@&%:(1,F5G 2%""(#$< A!4(#(A#/(;( (#'(%"!, 8!&*, "*#$(.>!'6: @(@6$(/ %;( #5F"(#$"(;( @(#$!?%"!, )%#@(/(."(. A!4(#(A#/(. 86#4$( "*8 /*?%$#, "*!)(4%% 1&*;(2%""68 ' E$!: @(@6$/*:, !#:(1,F!: !+ "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, "( '67%17!: 1*4%/( +* %;( @&%1%46, >$( @&%1#$*'4,%$ #()(. "%>$( "%!+8%""(% ' E$(. #8%"% A!4(#(A#/!: #!#$%8, ' @&%'&*$"(#$,: !: 5>%"!., ' &*+'!$!! !: '(++&%"!., – E$( "% $( !4! 1&5;(% ($/&6$!%, 1%.#$'!$%4<"(% !4! 8"!8(%, $(. !4! 1&5;(. #!#$%86, * #*8( !#/*"!%, E$( – #$&%84%"!% / 2%4<"(85 8!&(@("!8*"!G, 1(#$*$(>"( 7!&(/(85 14, $(;(, >$()6 86 8(;4! ()(+&%$< "*7% @(4(?%"!% ' 8!&%, 1(#$*$(>"( ;45)(/(85 ! ?!'(85, >$()6 (:'*$!$< '#% "*7% #5F%#$'(, ()4*;(&(1!$< "*7% 8674%"!% ! "*@&*'4,$< "*7! 1%.#$'!, #$&%84%"!,, (1"!8 #4('(8, / @(+"*"!G, 8(;5F%85 @&%'&*$!$<#, ' 851&(#$<, /($(&*, 1*4* #'(% !8, #*8(. A!4(#(A!!» (328, #. 43-44).
46
J*/!8 ()&*+(8, ' 1(4;('&%8%""(., !#$(&!>%#/! &*+'%&$6'*GF%.#, @(+"*'*$%4<"(. &%*4!+*2!! '#%. A!4(#(A!! ' ()F%8 8!&('(++&%">%#/(8 #$*$5#%, (&!%"$!&('*""(8 "* #5F"(#$"(%, ' :;5$!1-8 @&%$'(&,%8(% @(#$!?%"!% 8!&* ' %;( 2%4(8 ('/4G>*, ! >%4('%/*), @(E$*@"( 1(#$!;*%86% &%+54<$*$6 "% A!/#!&5G$#, (1"(+"*>"( ' 1(#$('%&"(8 1%.#$'!$%4<"(8 +"*"!!, "% !8%G$ ! "% 8(;5$ !8%$< :*&*/$%&* )%+4!>"6:, ()F%@&!",$6:, ($"(#!$%4<"( 5#$(.>!'6:, /("/&%$"6: !#$!" – :($,, @&! '#%8 $(8, #*8* @( #%)% '1-'""!1-8, /*/ "%():(1!86. *$&!)5$ @(+"*"!,, (),+*$%4<"* ! 14, A!4(#(A!!, ( >%8 5?% 74* &%>< &*"%%. (?"( 1()*'!$< "%/($(&6% 58%#$"6% &*+I,#",GF!% 8(8%"$6. J*/, @( 8"%"!G C4. P(4('<%'*, «#()#$'%""(-A!4(#(A#/!. !"$%&%# ($"(#!$#, "! / >%85 1&5;(85, /*/ / !#$!"%» (338, #. 761). V1%#<, ' #!45 @&!>*#$"(#$! A!4(#(A!! / -9!$0*1-9;, '*?%" (@&%1%4%""6. 4!>"(#$"6. A*/$(&, #5)I%/$!'"6. "*#$&(. A!4(#(A*, %;( ?%4*"!% @(+"*$< !#$!"5, #$&%84%"!% ()&%#$! %%, "*.$! ' 4*)!&!"$% #(@5$#$'5GF%. 86#4!. «K4, A!4(#(A* @( @&!+'*"!G, – @!#*4 P(4('<%', – "%$ "!>%;( )(4%% ?%4*$%4<"(;(, >%8 (#86#4%""*, !4! @&('%&%""*, 8674%"!%8 !#$!"*; @(E$(85 (" 4G)!$ #*86. @&(2%## 8674%"!,, /*/ %1!"#$'%""6. #@(#() 1(#$!;"5$< ?%4*""(. 2%4!» ($*8 ?%, #. 762). C8%#$% # $%8, ' #!45 @&!>*#$"(#$! A!4(#(A!! ! / "%;6*, ' A!4(#(A#/(. !#$!"%, ' %% #(1%&?*$%4<"(. >*#$!, (),+*$%4<"* ! #5F%#$'%""*, 1(4, ()I%/$!'"(#$!, #(@&,?%""(. # 1(#$!;"5$68 +"*"!%8. «J%(&%$!>%#/*, A!4(#(A!,, ($'%>*, >!#$( 58#$'%""(85 !"$%&%#5, #$*'!$ '(@&(# () !#$!"% ' %% ($"(7%"!! / ,"%"'4, !4! &*##8*$&!'*%$ #'(. @&%18%$… 4!7< #( #$(&("6 %;( 58#$'%""(;( 1(#$(!"#$'*, /($(&(% #(#$(!$ @&%?1% '#%;( ' 1(#$('%&"(#$!; ! $*/ /*/ @&%18%$ "% #5F%#$'5%$ 14, "*# !"*>%, /*/ >&%+ "*7% +"*"!% ( "%8, $( '(@&(# ( 1(#$('%&"(#$! @&%18%$* %#$< #()#$'%""( '(@&(# ( 5!1-!9*$"!1-' ,"%"'( ( "%8» ($*8 ?%, #. 768). K(#$('%&"(#$<, ()I%/$!'"*, !#$!""(#$< +"*"!, @&(!#$%/*%$ !+ #*8(. %;( #5F"(#$!, A%"(8%"(4(;!>%#/(. #(@&,?%""(#$! # ()I%/$!'"( )6$5GF!8 @&%18%$(8. «V"*"!%8 '(()F% "*+6'*%$#, #('@*1%"!% 1*""(. 86#4! ( @&%18%$% # %;( 1%.#$'!$%4<"68 )6$!%8 ! #'(.#$'(8» ($*8 ?%). H %#4! ()F!8 @&%18%$(8 '#%. A!4(#(A!! '( '#,/(% '&%8, ,'4,%$#, 8!& ' 2%4(8, 8!& ' %;( '#%()F!: #5F"(#$"6: (@&%1%4%""(#$,:, 8!& '%>"6. ! )%#/("%>"6. ' #'(%8 1%.#$'!$%4<"(8 )6$!! ! ' #'(!: #'(.#$'*:, $( ! #('@*1%"!% # "!8 @(#$!;*GF%. A!4(#(A#/(. 86#4! ' %% @&(;&%##!&5GF%8 @(+"*'*$%4<"(8 &*+'%&$6'*"!! ' &*8/*: >%4('%>%#/(. !#$(&!! @( "%():(1!8(#$! @&%1#$*%$ /*/ @(#$5@*$%4<"6. 2$!+*11 '%>"(;( ! )%#/("%>"(;( @&!)4!?%"!, A!4(#(A#/(;( +"*"!, / %;( '#% )(4%% @(4"(. 1(#$('%&"(#$!, /( '#% )(4%% @(4"(85 ! $(>"(85 #(($'%$#$'!G @(+"*'*%8(. #5F"(#$! 8!&* ! >%4('%/* ' "%8. P4%1('*$%4<"(, ' A!4(#(A#/(8 @(+"*"!! !#/(8*, '1-'"% @&%1#$*'4,%$ #()(. 2$!+*11 )%#/("%>"(;( (@(/* #5F%#$'5G$ >%4('%>%#$'( ! A!4(#(A#/*, 86#4< ' %;( 15:('"(. ?!+"!) @&(2%## @(+"*'*"!,, 8674%"!,, #('%&7%"#$'('*"!, ()&%$*%8(;( 1(#$('%&"(;( +"*"!, ! #5F"(#$"(;( @("!8*"!,. C4. P(4('<%' ' #',+! #
47
E$!8 @!7%$: «B%&'(% "*8! (F5F*%8(% ! A*/$!>%#/! "%#(8"%""(% (#"('*"!% $%(&%$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! %#$< $* )%#/("%>"(#$< >%4('%>%#/(;( 15:*, /($(&*, '6&*?*%$#, +1%#< ' "%#(;4*#!! 86#4,F%;( 58* @(#$*'!$< +*&*"%% /*/!%-"!)51< '"%7"!% ;&*"!26 !4! @&%1%46 #'(%. 1%,$%4<"(#$!, +*&*"%% @(1>!"!$<#, /*/!8-"!)51< @&%1@(4(?%"!,8, "% '6$%/*GF!8 !+ #*8(. 86#4!, "% @&('%&%""68 ! "% (@&*'1*""68 %G» ($*8 ?%, #. 764). B&! E$(8 #4%15%$ 5>!$6'*$< ! (@&%1%4%""5G #$%@%"< 9*$!(-"!1-' 5#$*"('4%"!, !#$!"6, %% ()&%$%"!, A!4(#(A*8! ! '#%. A!4(#(A!%.. «…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» ($*8 ?%, #. 761). C E$(8 ($"(7%"!! %#$%#$'(+"*"!G @&!#5F* ;(&*+1( )(4<7*, (@&%1%4%""(#$<. H#$!"* ' %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/*: "% $(4!% ($ A!4(#(A!! ' %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/*:, (&!%"$!&('*""6: "* 1%$*4<"(% !+5>%"!% 8!&* (@&!&(16) ' %;( 1&()"(#$!, A&*;8%"$*&"(#$!, ' )6$!."(. /("/&%$!/%, !#/(8*, !#$!"* (1"(+"*>"( (@&%1%4,%$#, ' ;($('(8 &%+54<$*$% @(+"*"!, (' ($/&6$(8 +*/("%, ' &*+&*)($*""(. $%(&!! ! $.@.), >%$/( A!/#!&5GF%8 1(#$!;"5$(% /("/&%$"(% 1(#$('%&"(% +"*"!% ($"(#!$%4<"( !+5>*%8(;( ()I%/$* – 4(/*4!+('*""(;( /(8@("%"$* $(;( !4! !"(;( A&*;8%"$* !&*, %;( >*#$"(;( #(#$(,"!,, ($1%4<"(;(, 8*4(;( 8!&* (8!/&(8!&*, ?!'($"(;( 8!&* ! $.@.). R( 8!& /*/ 2%4(%, !& ' %;( &%*4<"(8 )6$!! – E$( "% 8%:*"!>%#/! #(%1!"%""*, #('(/5@"(#$< ($1%4<"6: 8!&(', * !: 5@(&,1(>%""*, #!#$%8*, (&;*"!>%#/(% %1!"#$'(, "%&*+4(?!86. "* >*#$! #@4*'. H $* %;( ($1%4<"*, >*#$!2* !4! #$(&("*, /($(&*, 1%$*4<"( !##4%15%$#, A!+!/(8, :!8!/(8 !4! )!(4(;(8 – E$( 1*4%/( "% $( ?%, >%8 ,'4,%$#, ("* ' #(#$*'% 2%4(;(, ' %1!"%"!! # 1&5;!8!. C6&*?%"!, «8!/&(8!&», «8!& 8(4%/54», «?!'($"6. 8!&» ! $.@. (+"*>*G$, ;('(&, #4('*8! =%;%4,, «$(, >$( @&%1#$*'4,G$ !"' 1!$( ;('(&!$#, ' !: '6&*?%"!!» (81, #. 21). B(E$(85 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(% !#$!""(% +"*"!%, /*#*GF%%#, ($1%4<"6: #$(&(", ,'4%"!. 8!&*, ($1%4<"6: %;( A&*;8%"$(' – E$( +"*"!% ' >%8-$( "%!+)%?"( @&!)4!+!$%4<"(%, @&!)4!?*GF%%#, / 1%.#$'!$%4<"( !#$!""(85, >*#$!>"(, ($"(#!$%4<"( !#$!""(%. R! (1!" !+ $%: ($1%4<"6: 8!&(', /($(&6% @(&(+"< !+5>*G$ %#$%#$'%""6% "*5/!, "% 8(?%$ )6$< 1(#$*$(>"( @(",$, *1%/'*$"( ()I,#"%" ' %;( !+(4!&('*""(#$!, ($1%4%""(#$! ($ 1&5;!: ! ($ $(;( 2%4(;(, >*#$
48
2%4(;(. M*>%#$'( !#$!"6 (@&%1%4,%$#, @(4"($(. ! 2%4<"(#$%&%+ #'(% &*+'!$!%. 3) *)#(4G$"(8 "5?"( #/*+*$<, >$( ("( @( #5F%#$'5 %#$< $*,;78-%-, >$( ("( 4!7< ' /("2% %#$< $(, >$( ("( %#$< @(!#$!"%» ($*8 ?%, #. 10). W#4! @%&%'%#$! E$( "* 5&('%"< *)#(4G$"(;( )6$!, 8!&* ' 2%4(8 ! %;( @(+"*'*$%4<"(;( (#'(%"!, %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8, $( ' $*/(8 #45>*% «!#$!""(% %#$< 2%4(%» (+"*>*%$, >$( *)#(4G$"*, !#$!""(#$< '#%;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( +"*"!, %#$< %;( @(4"*, *1%/'*$"(#$< '#%85 ()I%/$5 @(+"*"!,, $( %#$< 8!&5 (@&!&(1%) /*/ 2%4(85, !#>%&@6'*GF%% @(#$!?%"!% %;( #5F"(#$!, %;( "*>*4, '#%()I%84GF!: +*/("(', @&!>!""6: #',+%. ! ($"(7%"!. ' "%8. H / E$(85 !+"*>*4<"( 5#$&%84%"* "*5/*. «W% '%4!/!. @&%18%$, – @!#*4 +"*8%"!$6. A&*"25+#/!. 5>%"6. XIX '%/* 3. M(7!, – #(#$(!$ ' ($/&6$!! !#$!"6 $*/, /*/ ("* @&%1#$*'4%"* ' @&!&(1%; ("* #$&%8!$#, 5+"*$< @%&'("*>*4<"6% /*>%#$'* 8*$%&!! ! +*/("6, 5@&*'4,GF!% 1%.#$'!,8! ! @&($!'(1%.#$'!,8! &*+4!>"6: &(1(' 8*$%&!! – (1"! "* 1&5;!%; (1"!8 #4('(8, ("* #()!&*%$ !##4%1('*"!, ' 8*$%&!*4<"(8 8!&% ! #$*&*%$#, 5+"*$< !: '+*!8"6% ($"(7%"!,» (182, #. 76). R( 1(#$!?%"!% $*/(;( '#%(:'*$6'*GF%;( +"*"!,, '#%()I%84GF%. !#$!"6 («/*/ ("* @&%1#$*'4%"* ' @&!&(1%») –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«("* &*+ ! "*'#%;1* &*+1%4*4*#< #( '#,/!8 @&%1#$*'4%"!%8 () (/(">*$%4<"(8 :*&*/$%&% >%4('%>%#/(;( 8674%"!,… H#$!"*, /($(&5G 1(4?"* @(+"*$< A!4(#(A!,, @&%1#$*'4,4*#< =%;%4G 5?% "% ' '!1% #()&*"!, ;($('6: 1(;8*$!>%#/!: @(4(?%"!., /($(&6% (#$*%$#, $(4*4*#< ' #*8(8 @&(2%##% @(+"*"!,, ' 14!$%4<"(8 !#$(&!>%#/(8 &*+'!$!! "*5/!, @(1"!8*GF%.#, # "!+7!: #$5@%"%. +"*"!. "* '#% )(4%% '6#(/!%, "( "!/(;1* "% 1(#$!;*GF!% $*/(. $(>/!, ($ /($(&(. ("*, "*.1, "%/($(&5G $*/ "*+6'*%85G *)#(4G$"5G !#$!"5, 5?% "% 8(;4* )6 @(.$! 1*4<7% ! ;1% %. "% (#$*'*4(#< )6 "!>%;(
49
)(4<7%, /*/, #4(?* &5/!, # !+584%"!%8 #(+%&2*$< E$5 1()6$5G *)#(4G$"5G !#$!"5. H $*/ ()#$(!$ 1%4( "% $(4"(85 @(+"*"!G ' %;( 2%4(8 E$( (+"*>*%$, >$( ! ("(, @(1()"( A!4(#(A!!, )%#/("%>"( @&!)4!?*%$#, / '#%()I%84GF%. !#$!"%, "( ' %% 5?% /("/&%$"(8 (A!+!>%#/(8, :!8!>%#/(8, )!(4(;!>%#/(8 ! @&.) A*/$5*4<"(8 ! $%(&%$!>%#/(8 "*@(4"%"!!, ' ($4!>!% ($ #5;5)( *)#$&*/$"(;( @&%$'(&%"!, !#$!""(;(, #5F"(#$"(;( +"*"!, ' A!4(#(A!!. H @($(85 ;%;%4%'#/(% «!#$!""(% %#$< 2%4(%» ' 1*""(8 #45>*% 8(?"( $&*/$('*$< ' #86#4% 2%4(#$"(#$! "*4!>"(;( +"*"!, ( 8!&% (@&!&(1%): ("( @( #(1%&?*"!G – ! *)#$&*/$"(%, ! /("/&%$"(%, *, #4%1('*$%4<"(, @( #5$! #'(%. – ! A!4(#(A#/(%, ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(%, $( %#$<, !"*>% ;('(&,, / %;( @(45>%"!G, #('%&7%"#$'('*"!G, @(+"*'*$%4<"(85 A5"/2!("!&('*"!G ' &*'"(. 8%&% 1(4?"6 )6$< @&!>*#$"6 ! A!4(#(A!,, ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!% ' !: '+*!8(#',+!, '+*!8(1(@(4",%8(#$!, '+*!8"(. "%():(1!8(#$! 1&5; 14, 1&5;*. C ($"(7%"!! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, E$( (+"*>*%$ ()I%/$!'"5G @&!>*#$"(#$< A!4(#(A!! ' %% *)#$&*;!&5GF%., ()()F*GF%. A5"/2!! / #$*"('4%"!G ! &*+'!$!G #5F"(#$"(;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( +"*"!,. J*/, @( 8"%"!G 9. L."7$%."*, «%#4! @(1 A!4(#(A!%. @("!8*$< @(!#/! +"*"!, ' %;( "*!)(4%% ()F%. ! "*!)(4%% 7!&(/(. A(&8%, $( %%, (>%'!1"(, 8(?"( #>!$*$< 8*$%&"6: !#/*"!.» (403, #. 317). K()*'!8: "% $(4*#$"!2%. E$!: !#/*"!., "*&*'"% # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8. «0!4(#(A!,, – @!#*4 C.H. C%&"*1#/!., – '#%;1* +*/4G>*%$ +*&(167!, !"(;1* 1*?% @&%1'(#:!F*%$ 2%46% ()4*#$! )515F%;( &*+'!$!, "*5/!, ! $(4%4('%>%#/(;( 58* ' E$(. ()4*#$! @(45>*%$#, @&*'!4<"*, /&!$!/* "%!+)%?"( #:%8*$!>%#/!: @(#$&(%"!. "*5/!. C !#$(&!! &*+'!$!, "*5>"(. 86#4! 8(?"( ,#"( ! $(>"( @&(#4%1!$< $*/(% +"*>%"!% A!4(#(A!!, /*/ /(&"%. ! ?!+"%""(. *$8(#A%&6 "*5>"(;( 8674%"!,» (345, #. 193). N$( /*#*%$#, ($1%4<"6: %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/ (A!+!>%#/!:, )!(4(;!>%#/!: ! 1&.), $( @&!8%"!$%4<"( / "!8 ;%;%4%'#/(% «!#$!""(% %#$< 2%4(%» (+"*>*%$, >$( 14, 1(#$!?%"!, "%():(1!8(. @(4"($6 !#/(8(. !#$!"6 ' /*?1(. !+ "!: "*1(, @(8!8( '#%;( @&(>%;(, 5>%#$< 2%4(#$"(#$<, #!#$%8"(#$< $(;(, '( >$( E4%8%"$*&"( '/4G>%"( C-! A!+!>%#/(% !4! C-! )!(4(;!>%#/(%, 14, >%;( "%():(1!8( +*1%.#$'('*$< )(4%% ()F%% +"*"!%, @&!'4%>< '"%A!+!>%#/!%, '"%)!(4(;!>%#/!% #&%1#$'* ! 8%$(16 – $%, /($(&6% "*@&*'4,G$#, +"*"!%8, (:'*$6'*GF!8 1%.#$'!$%4<"(% ' %;( 2%4(#$"(#$!, $( %#$< +"*"!%8 @( #5$! #'(%. A!4(#(A#/!8, A!/#!&5GF!8 A!4(#(A#/5G !#$!"5 ' %% #@%2!A!>%#/(8, *)#$&*/$"( @&%$'(&%""(8 #(1%&?*"!!. =. V!88%4<, "*@&!8%&, #>!$*4, >$( «@(",$!% !#$!"6 ' A!4(#(A!!, @(#/(4*%$#, ($ E$(;( @(",$!, ' ()4*#$! 1&5;!: "*5/. 3"* "*@&*'4%"* "% "* ()I%/$!'"(#$< '%F%., >$( ,'4,%$#, +*1*>%. "*5/! ' $%#"(8 #86#4% #4('*, – ("* '6&*?*%$ $!@!>%#/!% (#()%""(#$!
50
>%4('%>%#/(;( 15:*, @(#/(4%&/"54 @&! E$(8, >$( ()F%. «>%&$(., /($(&*, @('$(&,%$#, ' /*?1(8 @(",$!! ($ @%&'(;( 1( @(#4%1"%;(, ,'4,%$#, !#/*"!% A!4(#(A!%., ' #'(%. #A%&% !##4%1('*"!,, 7!&(/!: ! ;45)(/!: !#$!", ' @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$< 8"(;(>!#4%""68 >*#$"68 !#$!"*8, /($(&6% ()"*&5?!'*G$#, '"%7"!8! @&(,'4%"!,8! @&%18%$(' ! 1%.#$'!.» (340, #. 73). H, @&(1(4?!8, A!/#!&5G$#, #(($'%$#$'5GF!8 ()&*+(8 ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 +"*"!!. R( )(4%% >*#$"6. :*&*/$%& E$!: !#$!", /("%>"( ?%, "% !#/4G>*%$ (@&%1%4%""(. 8%&6 !: ()F"(#$!, !8%GF%. #5F"(#$"(% #(1%&?*"!% – ' +*/("%, $%(&!! ! $.@. R*5/*, #>!$*4, "*@&!8%&, C. H%&5+*4%8, «"!/(;1* "% !8%%$ 2%4$( /*?1(% ($1%4<"(% !##4%1('*"!%, %#4! ("( :(>%$ +*#45?!$< !8, "*5/!, 1(4?"( '#%;1* !8%$< ' '!1% 2%4(%, '#4%1#$'!% >%;( '#,/*, #@%2!*4<"*, "*5/*, %#4! ("* @&%#4%15%$ #'(G 2%4< &%'"(#$"( ! #%&<%+"(, @&!'(1!$ / $%8 ?% ()F!8 '(@&(#*8, &%7%"!% /($(&6: #(#$*'4,%$ @&%18%$ A!4(#(A!!» (162, #. 10-11). H$*4<,"#/!. A!4(#(A 0. L"&!/'%#, ($8%$!' $( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, >$( «A!4(#(A!, '6&*?*%$, @( #5F%#$'5, #$&%84%"!% / %1!"#$'5 ! ()F"(#$!», "* (#"('*"!! E$(;( @&!:(1!$ / #4%15GF%85 '6'(15: «0!4(#(A#/(% 8674%"!% ($"G1< "% "*8%&%"( &*+&%7*$< ($1%4<"6: ! '@(4"% (@&%1%4%""6: @&()4%8, * #/(&%% @&%1#$*'4,%$ #()(G $%"1%"2!G >%4('%>%#/(;( 15:*, /($(&*,, $*/ #/*+*$<, @&!1*%$ #$!4< +1*"!G "*5/!…» (413, #. 9-10). J*/(;( &(1* #5?1%"!, A!4(#(A(' &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( @%&!(1* ' @(4"(. 8%&% #(+'5>"6 '6#/*+6'*"!,8 '61*GF!:#, 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. (C.H. C%&"*1#/(;(, 9. L."7$%."* ! 1&.) ($"(#!$%4<"( #5F%#$'%""(. @&*/$!>%#/(. +"*>!8(#$! A!4(#(A!! 14, %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/, 14, !: 5#@%7"(;( @(+"*'*$%4<"(;( A5"/2!("!&('*"!, ' &5#4% #('8%#$"(. # A!4(#(A!%. &%*4!+*2!! ;%;%4%'#/(;( @(4(?%"!, «!#$!""(% %#$< 2%4(%». § 6. 0=3242A=9 5 B=8252CC8DE== D4FD4F52=4>KF;FD3DG: 2>8D7D3DE=D <;ID4F5; H#$!""(% ' 2%4(8 ! ' %;( E4%8%"$*&"6: %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: >*#$"(#$,: %#$<, @( #5$! #'(%., $%+'!"%78"!*. K(#$('%&"(% #5F"(#$"(% +"*"!% ' "*5/%, %;( @(45>%"!% ! @(+"*'*$%4<"(% 86#4!$%4<"(% (#'(%"!% – E$( 51%4 &*+58*. M*/ @!#*4 &5##/!. A!4(#(A C.L. P%+%8*", «!#$!""(% +"*"!% – 127!38 $%+'!"%78"!*; !&&*2!("*4<"( '#% $(, >$( 4%?!$ +* @&%1%4*8! 1%.#$'!$%4<"(;( !4! 1*?% '(+8(?"(;( +"*"!,» (334, #. 95). H A!4(#(A!,, (&!%"$!&('*""*, "* !#$!""(% +"*"!% ' ($"(7%"!! 8!&* ' 2%4(8 ! >%4('%/* ' "%8, A!4(#(A!,, #(>%$*GF*, ' #%)% "*5>"(% ! $'(&>%#/(% "*>*4*, #(@&,?%""*, # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8 – E$( A!4(#(A!,, /*/ 5?% ($8%>*4(#<, $%+'!"%78"%( @( #5$!, @( #(1%&?*"!G, @( #'(%.
51
@(+"*'*$%4<"(. &%*4!+*2!!. H8%""( ( -%6!= A!4(#(A!! – ! $(4< 1( #!: @(& ! )51%$ !1$! '@&%1<. B&! E$(8 '6"(#!$#, +* #/()/!, "!/*/ "% 5>!$6'*%$#,, !#/4G>*%$#, !+ &*##8($&%"!, ' #(($"%#%"!! # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8, # 8!&('(++&%"!%8 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. A!4(#(A!, /*>%#$'%""( !"*, – '$$%+'!"%78"%(, 8!#$!>%#/*,, $( %#$< A!4(#(A!,, @&!"2!@!*4<"( "%#('8%#$!8*, # !#$!""68 +"*"!%8, >5?1*, /*/(. )6 $( "! )64( "*5>"(#$!. -5##/!. A!4(#(A P.H. =%##%" 1*%$ $*/!% &*+I,#"%"!, "* E$($ #>%$: «B(1 8!#$!/(. !4! 8!#$!2!+8(8 ()(4<7%. >*#$!$%4<"(% ;(#@(1#$'( !&&*2!("*4<"(;( "*>*4* ' 8!&%, 1(#$5@"(;( #('%&7%""( (#()(85, ($4!>"(85 ($ ()6>"(;( "*7%;( *)#$&*/$"(;( !4! 1!#/5&#!'"(;( 8674%"!, !"$5!$!'"(85 @(+"*"!G. K4, 8!#$!/* 8!& %#$< )%#/("%>"*, $*."*, ' 8(8%"$6 !#/4G>!$%4<"(;( E/#$*+* ($/&6'*GF*,#, %85 /*/!8–$( "%!+I,#"!868 ()&*+(8» (119, #. 119). B(",$"(, >$( ' E$(8 #45>*% "! ( /*/!: /&(@($4!'6: "*5>"6: !##4%1('*"!,:, 5;45)4%""6: A!4(#(A#/!: &*+8674%"!,:, "! ( /*/(8 )%#/("%>"(8 !#/*"!! !#$!"6 ;('(&!$< 5?% "% @&!:(1!$#,, ($@*1*%$ "%():(1!8(#$< /*/ ' E8@!&!>%#/(8, $*/ ! ' &*2!("*4<"(8 @(+"*"!! 8!&* ! '(()F% 5#$&*",%$#, #*8* @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$< E8@!&!+8* ! &*2!("*4!+8*, ("* &*#$'(&,%$#, ' )(4%% 7!&(/(8 @&($!'(@(4(?%"!! &*2!("*4!+8* ! 8!#$!/!, !&&*2!("*4!+8*, @(#/(4/! +&%"!, 8!#$!/(', «! E8@!&!/, ! &*2!("*4!#$ ' $(8 7!&(/(8 #86#4% #4('* – &*2!("*4!#$6: ("! (1!"*/('( ($'%&;*G$ !&&*2!("*4<"(% !"$5!$!'"(% @(+"*"!%» ($*8 ?%, #. 119-120). N$( /*#*%$#, &%*4<"(;( #(($"(7%"!, &*2!("*4!+8* ! !&&*2!("*4!+8* ' A!4(#(A!! $(;( '&%8%"! (/("%2 XIX – "*>*4( XX ''.), $( :*&*/$%&!+5, @(1 E$!8 5;4(8 +&%"!, @(4(?%"!% 1%4 ' "%., =%##%" @!#*4: «31"(. !+ #*86: :*&*/$%&"6: >%&$ #('&%8%""(;( &*+'!$!, A!4(#(A!! ,'4,%$#, #(>%$*"!% ' "%. 1'5:… $%"1%"2!.. P (1"(. #$(&("6, 86 @&!#5$#$'5%8 @&! /&*."%8 "*@&,?%"!! &*2!("*4!#$!>%#/(. $%"1%"2!!, @&(,'4,GF%8#, ' $(8 &*#7!&%"!! 1(#$5@"(. &*+585 ()4*#$!, /($(&(% #',+*"( # ()(#()4%"!%8 «>!#$(. A!4(#(A!!» (' >*#$"(#$!, «>!#$(. 4(;!/!»), /*/ #*8(#$(,$%4<"(. ()4*#$! +"*"!,… P 1&5;(. #$(&("6, (1"*/(, @&(1(4?*%$#, $%"1%"2!,, "*>*$*, 0!:$% ! +*/4G>*GF*,#, '( ''%1%"!! ' A!4(#(A!G !&&*2!("*4<"(;( 8(8%"$*» ($*8 ?%, #. 118). L.D. -*14(', 5#$*"*'4!'*, (#"('"6: @&%1#$*'!$%4%. '$(&(. $%"1%"2!!, 5$'%&?1*4, >$( «8!#$!>%#/*, #$&5./* ,#"( >5'#$'5%$#, /*/ ' @&*;8*$!+8%, $*/ ! ' A!4(#(A!! $'(&>%#/(. E'(4G2!!, $*/, "*/("%2, ! ' &%4!;!(+"(. A!4(#(A!! C4. P(4('<%'*. J&! !8%"!, – K?%8#, Q%&;#(" ! P(4('<%' – ()(+"*>*G$ E$($ @('(&($ %'&(@%.#/(. 86#4!, @&!>%8 @(#4%1"!., ($/&6$( @&!+"*GF!. @&!"2!@ 8!#$!2!+8*, ' $( ?% '&%8, "*!8%"%% '&*?1%)%" &*2!("*4<"(85 @(+"*"!G» (316, #. 37). C6&*?*, #'(% @("!8*"!% 8!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!!, -*14(' @!#*4: «P5F"(#$< 8!#$!/! 86 '!1!8 ' 5$'%&?1%"!! #5F%#$'('*"!, #'%&:>5'#$'%""(;( 8!&* ! (#()(;( (&;*"*
52
@(+"*"!,, – "*+('%8 %;( !"$5!2!%., – ! ' $(8, '(-'$(&6:, >$( 8!#$!/* )4!?*.7!8 ()&*+(8 #',+*"* # &%4!;!(+"(. #A%&(G» ($*8 ?%, #. 40). W#4! (@&%1%4%"!, 8!#$!/!, 1*""6% =%##%"(8 ! -*14('68, @&!",$< +* #5F"(#$"6% :*&*/$%&!#$!/! !&&*2!("*4<"(. A!4(#(A!!, $( ("* ' $*/(8 #45>*% @&%1#$*%$ /*/ "%/(% #*8(1('4%GF%% ! #*8(1(#$*$(>"(% 15:('"(% ()&*+('*"!%, /*/ A!4(#(A!, ' #%)% ! 14, #%),, A!4(#(A!,, )%+($"(#!$%4<"*, / @(+"*'*$%4<"(. &%*4<"(#$! '(()F% ! / %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(85 @(+"*"!G ' >*#$"(#$!. J*/, B.9. 04(&%"#/!. # @(+!2!. #'(%. &%4!;!(+"(. !&&*2!("*4<"(. A!4(#(A!!, "% $(4$( "%#('8%#$!8(% # "%., '&*?1%)"(%. «R% "* @('%&:"(#$! $(4!. P*86% 8!&(>5'#$'!,, R*5/5 ! 0!4(#(A!G @(&(?1*GF!%, "%#('8%#$"6 1&5; # 1&5;(8, :($, '(+"!/*G$ ($ (1"(;( $(4>/*, $(4>/* 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!. R(, @($&,#%""*, $(4>/(8, 0!4(#(A!, '(#@&!"!8*%$ ' #%), 1'!?%"!%, $( (#$&(% >5'#$'( "('!+"6, /($(&(% +('%8 86 51!'4%"!%8, !, @(",' %;( /*/ ?%4*""(%, #$*&*%$#, ( ?!+"! ' "%8. 0!4(#(A!, %#$< "%5',1*%86. 2'%$ 51!'4%""(#$!, – #*8* (&;*"!+('*""*, 51!'4%""(#$<. R*@&($!', R*5/* "%)4*;(1*&"( @&!%84%$ $(4>(/ 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!; "% *";%4* – '%#$"!/* ?!+"! – '!1!$ ' &%*4<"(#$!, /!"5'7%. '+(& >&%+ @&(&6' #*8(#$! "*7%., "( '#$&%>*%$ E$($ $(4>(/, /*/ '&*?1%)"(;( @&!7%4<2*, /*/ "*&57!$%4, /(#"(#$! %% ! #*8(1('(4<#$'*» (376, #. 132-133). L$( $(, >$( /*#*%$#, !#$(&!>%#/(. @(1(@4%/!, ;%"%+!#* ! &*+'!$!, #(($"(7%"!, A!4(#(A!! ! "*5/!, !: '+*!8"( "%+*'!#!8(;( #$*"('4%"!,, '+*!8"(. "%#('8%#$!8(#$!, @&($!'(#$(,"!,. H '#% E$( – "* $*/(8 "%(@&%1%4%""(8 ! +6)/(8 #5)I%/$!'"(8 (#"('*"!!, /*/ 51!'4%"!%, %;( "*4!>!% !4! ($#5$#$'!%. W#$< ("( – E$( :(&(7(, ' @(+"*"!! E$( – A!4(#(A!,, /*/ "%>$( ?!'(%, 15:('"(%; "%$ %;( – E$( @4(:(, ' @(+"*"!! E$( – "*5/*, /*/ "%>$( /(#"(%, )%+15:('"(%. 9 @($(85 ! @5$! &*+'!$!, @(45>!4!#< &*+"6%, '+*!8"( "%#('8%#$!86%, :($, $(4>(/ ($ 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! @&! '(+"!/"('%"!! ()%!: )64 (1!". W#$%#$'%""(, >$( (+"*>%""5G (@@(+!2!G ' #(($"(7%"!! A!4(#(A!! ! "*5/! 04(&%"#/!. &*#@&(#$&*"!4 ! "* !: "%@(#&%1#$'%""(% A5"/2!("!&('*"!%, "* 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/5G #A%&5 ' "!:: «0!4(#(A!, ' #*8(8 #5F%#$'%""(8 ($&!2*%$ 8%$(1 "*5/! – ($&!2*%$ ! )(&%$#, # "!8 ! @4*'!$ %;( "%@(1'!?"(#$< ?*&(8 #'(%;( L&(#* / @(14!""( #5F%85. C @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$! 86#4!, /($(&*, $'%&1( «#$(!$» ! «"%1'!?"*», ! 86#4!, /($(&*, «5)%;*%$ ! "% :(>%$ #$(,$<, ;1% %% @(#$*'!4!», 5/*+6'*%$#, "%#('8%#$!8(#$< R*5/! ! 0!4(#(A!!. L$* "%#('8%#$!8(#$< %#$< "%@&!8!&!8(#$< 5#4('"(. 8*"%&6 ! @(14!""(. ($+6'>!'(#$!, "%@&!8!&!8(#$< &*)#$'* ! #'()(16, "%@&!8!&!8(#$< #@%4%"*$(. 858!! ! ?!'(;( $%4*. 0!4(#(A!, 8(?%$ /&($/( @%&%"%#$! @&(#$(% ($#5$#$'!% 8%$(1* ' ?!$%.#/(8 '(++&%"!!; "( ("* )%#@(F*1"* / !#/*?%"!G ?!+"! ' 8%$(1% R*5/!… -*)#$'( R*5/! – ' %% #:%8(#$&(!$%4<#$'% !+ #%),… R*5/* '&*?1%)"* ?!+"!» ($*8 ?% #. 129-130).
53
3>%'!1"(, >$( &%>< ' 1*""(8 #45>*% !1%$ – ! E$( ,'#$'5%$ !+ /("$%/#$* – "% ( &%*4<"(. A!4(#(A!!, "% ( $(., >$( ' #'(%8 @(#$5@*$%4<"(8 &*+'!$!! +* 1'% # @(4('!"(. $6#,>! 4%$ @&(74* @5$< ($ 0*4%#* 1( =%;%4, ! 0%.%&)*:*, ! "% ( $(. &%*4<"(. "*5/%, /($(&*,, "*>!"*, # $(;( ?% 0*4%#*, @&(74* @5$< &*+'!$!, 1( K*&'!"* ! %"1%4%%'*. 0!4(#(A!, 5 04(&%"#/(;( – E$( "%/*, !#/5##$'%""( #/("#$&5!&('*""*, !1%*4<"*, 0!4(#(A!, /*/ (#()(% !&&*2!("*4<"(% @&(,'4%"!% >%4('%>%#/(;( 15:* ' %;( '(+'67%""(. )(?%#$'%""(#$! ! ' /*>%#$'% %% )%+15:('"(;( *"$!@(1* @&%1#$*%$ "%/*, !&&%*4<"*, R*5/*, /*/ '(@4(F%"!% @&!+%84%""(#$! >%4('%>%#/(;( +"*"!,, 4!7%""(;( )(?%#$'%""(;( "*>*4*. V1%#< ,'#$'%""( @&(#$5@*%$ "%;*$!'"(% ($"(7%"!% !&&*2!("*4<"(., 8!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! / &*2!("*4<"(85 "*5>"(85 @(+"*"!G, 4(/*4!+('*""(% ' &*8/*: &%4!;!(+"(. – #'%&:>5'#$'%""(. ! #'%&:&*+58"(. –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– @(#$(4*4( (#()( '61%4,%$, "*@&!8%&, L. =5##%&4<: «R*5/* %#$< @&%?1% '#%;( *"$&(@(4(;!>%#/(% %1!"#$'(, !8%""( %1!"#$'( */$(' 8674%"!,, $%"1%"2!. 8674%"!, "*&,15 # !+'%#$"68!, ($"(#,F!8!#, #G1* '"%7"!8! (&;*"!+*2!,8!» (135, #. 200). R( $*/!8 ?% *"$&(@(4(;!>%#/!8 %1!"#$'(8 */$(' ! $%"1%"2!. 8674%"!, ' #'(%. ()4*#$! ,'4,%$#, ! A!4(#(A!,. H @&! "*4!>!! ()F%;( ()I%/$* @(+"*"!, – 8!&* ! >%4('%/* ' "%8 – &*2!("*4<"(#$< A!4(#(A!! ' @&(2%##% @(+"*'*$%4<"(;( &*+'%&$6'*"!, 86#4!$%4<"6: (@%&*2!. "* (@&%1%4%""6: #('@*1*GF!: 5>*#$/*: @&!&(1('%1%"!, "%!+)%?"( @%&%@4%$*%$#, # &*2!("*4<"(#$*#$/(' – !+ >!#4* "*!)(4%% +"*>!86:, #5F%#$'%""( '*?"6: – ,'4,%$#, :'$!9!,,$*"'* 5>%"6:. C.H. C%&"*1#/!., ($ 4!2* %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «…U($!8 86 E$(;( !4! "% :($!8, @(8!8( "*#, "%!+)%?"( "*# 7!&(/(. '(4"(. "* /*?1(8 7*;5 (:'*$6'*G$ '(@&(#6, +*1*>! ! !"$%&%#6, $%#"( #',+*""6% # A!4(#(A!%. ! )4!+/!8! / "%. "*5/*8!… 3"! '6$%/*G$ "%!+)%?"( ! "%!##,/*%8( !+ &*+8674%"!, ! (2%"/! $(;( "*5>"(;( 8*$%&!*4*, !+ /($(&(;( #$&(!$#, %#$%#$'(+"*"!% ! 8*$%8*$!/*. 3"! ':(1,$ /*/ '#%@&("!/*GF*, #&%1* '( '#% "*7% "*5>"(% 8!&('(++&%"!%…» (61, #. 390). P*8( "*5>"(% 8!&('(++&%"!% (8!&(#(+%&2*"!%) ,'4,%$#, "%():(1!868 5#4('!%8 5#@%7"(;( (#5F%#$'4%"!, %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;(
54
@(+"*"!,. «R% #4%15%$ 158*$<, – @!#*4 . B4*"/, – >$( 8(?"( 1*?% ' #*8(. $(>"(. !+ '#%: %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/ @&(1'!"5$<#, '@%&%1 )%+ '#,/(;( 8!&(#(+%&2*"!,» (303, #. 82). K.H. %"1%4%%', #( #'(%. #$(&("6, (@&%1%4,, 8%#$( ! &(4< "*5>"(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, '( '#%. #!#$%8% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( +"*"!,, ' (&;*"!+*2!! ! 5#@%7"(8 (#5F%#$'4%"!! @(+"*'*$%4<"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! 5>%"6:, ($8%$!4 #4%15GF%%: «31"( #()&*"!% A*/$(', 1*?% ! (>%"< ()7!&"(%, (1"( "*/(@4%"!% !:, 1*?% ! )%#/(&6#$"(%, 1*?% ! +"*"!% ()F%@&!",$6: "*>*4 "% 1*15$ %F% 8%$(1* ()4*1*"!, "*5/(G, ! ("! "% 1*G$ %F% "! &5>*$%4<#$'* +* 1*4<"%.7!% 5#@%:!, "! 1*?% @&*'* "* !8, "*5/! ' '6#7%8 #86#4% E$(;( #4('*. V1*"!% "*5/! $&%)5%$ "% $(4"(% 8!&(#(+%&2*"!% ! #(#$*'4,%$ @4*" – $!@ "*5>"(;( +1*"!,. B&!$(8 @(/* "%$ @4*"* – "%$ ! '(+8(?"(#$! 5+"*$< 8"(;(% ! !+ $(;(, >$( 5?% )64( /(85-4!)( !+'%#$"(, >$( 5?% #4(?%"(… Q%+ 8*$%&!*4* @4*" %#$< !4! '(+157"6. +*8(/, !4! $(4$( %% @%&%'(+!$< "% )51%$ #$(!$< $&51*, !4! (@,$< $(4"(% 8!&('(++&%"!% "% (#$*%$#, "%!+8%""68, &*+ "*'#%;1* 1*""68, ("( 1!"*8!>"(, !+8%">!'(, /*/ #*8* "*5/*. «R*5>"(% 8!&(#(+%&2*"!% #!4<"( 8%",%$#, "% $(4"6: 1%,$%4%. "*@&*'4,G$#, !8%""( / $(85, >$()6 8!&(#(+%&2*"!% #'(%. !4! $(. 7/(46, / /($(&(. ("! @&!"*14%?*$, @%&%'%#$! ' &,1 "%(#@(&!86: "*>*4 "*5/!. L$( #$&%84%"!% #(#$*'4,%$ )4!?*.75G @&!>!"5 (#$!854) 45>7!: &*)($ 1%,$%4%. "*5/!. L@(:! ! 7/(46 "*5/! :*&*/$%&!+5G$#, 8!&(#(+%&2*"!%8, &5/('(1,F!8 &*)($*8!» ($*8 ?%, #. 460). R* @(1'!?"(#$<, !+8%">!'(#$< "*5>"(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, ' :(1% &*+'!$!, "*5/! ()&*F*%$ '"!8*"!% ! C.H. C%&"*1#/!.. «R*5>"(% 8!&('(++&%"!%, – @!7%$ (", – "% %#$< >$(-"!)51< +*/(">%""(%, ,#"(%, ;($('(%; ("( 1(#$!;*4(#< >%4('%/(8 @(#$%@%""(, 1(4;!8 ! $&51"68 @5$%8. C &*+"6% !#$(&!>%#/!% E@(:! ("( )64( &*+4!>"(. C $%>%"!% :(1* '%/(' 8(?"( @&(#4%1!$<, /*/ >5?1(% "*8 8!&('(++&%"!% @&(746: @(/(4%"!. @(#$%@%""( 8%",4(#< ! @&!()&%$*4( #('&%8%""6. '!1. R( ' $%>%"!% '#%. E$(. '%/('(., 1(4;(. E'(4G2!! 8!&('(++&%"!% (#$*'*4(#< "*5>"68» (60. #. 38). B&! E$(8 "*5>"(% 8!&('(++&%"!% @( "%():(1!8(#$! A5"/2!("!&5%$ "*&,15 # 1&5;!8! 15:('"68! ()&*+('*"!,8!, $*/?% !8%GF!8! 8!&('(++&%">%#/!. :*&*/$%& – /*?1(% ' #'(%. ()4*#$!. «R*5>"(% 8!&('(++&%"!% %#$< #(+1*"!% ! '6&*?%"!% >%4('%>%#/(;( 15:*; "*&*'"% # "!8 @&(,'4%"!%8 $(. ?% &*)($6 #45?*$ &%4!;!(+"(% 8!&('(++&%"!%, !#/5##$'(, ()F%#$'%""*, ! 4!>"*, E$!/*, #(2!*4<"*, ?!+"<, A!4(#(A#/*, 86#4< !4! #(+%&2*"!%. B(1()"( E$!8 /&5@"68 ($&*?%"!,8 >%4('%>%#/(. 4!>"(#$!, ! "*5>"(% 8!&('(++&%"!%… !8%%$ #'(! +*/("6 !+8%"%"!, ! (@&%1%4%""6% ,#"6% A(&86 @&(,'4%"!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 39).
55
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– ' #',+! # (#"('"(. @&()4%8*$!/(. @&%14*;*%8(;( !##4%1('*"!,, ()I%/$(8 1%$*4<"(;( *"*4!+* ' /($(&(8 ! ,'4,%$#, !*4* XX ''. – ()F%% ' $(8 #86#4%, >$( (#"('(@(4*;*GF!% :*&*/$%&!#$!/! $*/ !4! !"*>% @&(,'4,4!#< ' 7'0"!: 8!&('(++&%"!! :"!#'D 5>%"6:, A!4(#(A#/!: %1!"(8674%""!/('. R( #"*>*4* – ( 4!>"(8 8!&('(++&%"!! ($1%4<"(;( 5>%"(;(, ( %;( 4!>"(. A!4(#(A!!, @&%$'(&,GF%.#, ' %;( 8!&('(++&%"!!. '$!9!,,$*"0*16%( A5"/2!, A!4(#(A!! (@&%1%4,%$#, ' @%&'5G (>%&%1< $%8, >$( "%():(1!86% 5#4('!, (#5F%#$'4%"!, @(+"*'*$%4<"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!! "*:(1,$#, ! '"% #*8(;( @&(2%##* @(+"*"!, – ' ()I%/$!'"(8 8!&%, ' ()#$(,$%4<#$'*: #5F%#$'('*"!, 5>%"(;( /*/ >%4('%/*, 4!>"(#$! – /*/ >*#$! @&!&(16, 8*$%&!*4<"(;( 8!&* ! /*/ >4%"* ()F%#$'*, >$( ! 1%4*%$ "%():(1!868 14, "%;( (@&%1%4%""(% ()F%% '(++&%"!% "* 8!& ! #(($'%$#$'5GF5G ()F%#$'%""5G @(+!2!G. J( ! 1&5;(% ! '(@4(F*%$#, ' %;(, 5>%"(;(, 7'0"!: :'$!9!,,$*"'', /("/&%$!+!&5GF%8 ' !"1!'!15*4!+!&('*""(. A(&8% ' #@%2!A!>%#/(8 1%$*4<"(8 "*@(4"%"!! $% !4! !"6% /(8@("%"$6 ()F%;( "*5>"(;( 8!&('(++&%"!,, * $*/?% 8!&('(++&%"!, A!4(#(A#/(;(, ?!$%.#/(;(, 5 /(;(-$( – ! &%4!;!(+"(;(, E#$%$!>%#/(;( ! @&. D!>"(% 8!&('(++&%"!% /*?1(;( >%4('%/*, * +"*>!$, ! 4G)(;( 5>%"(;( &%*4!+5%$#, ' %;( #(+"*"!! /*/ #5)I%/$!'"( (@&%1%4,%8(% ' E8(2!("*4<"(8 ! &*2!("*4<"(8 @&%$'(&%"!! ()F%% (#(+"*"!% !8 ()I%/$!'"(;( 8!&*, #'(%;( @(4(?%"!, ' "%8, ($"(7%"!, / "%85 – / @&!&(1% ! ()F%#$'5, /*/ !88*"%"$"(% ! !8@4!2!$"(% @("!8*"!% !8 $(;( ! 1&5;(;(, @("!8*"!% !8 @&!&(1"6: ! ()F%#$'%""6: &%*4!. )6$!,, #'(%;( ()F%#$'%""(;( "*+"*>%"!,. « !&('(++&%"!% 4G1%., – @!#*4 ' "*>*4% XX '%/* P. P5'(&(', – @&%1#$*'4,%$ !1%."(% ($&*?%"!% !: ()F!: ?!+"%""6: ($"(7%"!., %#$%#$'%""(. ! #(2!*4<"(. !: #&%16 ! '#%;( #(1%&?*"!, !: ?!+"!, – %% (#"('"6: 5#4('!. ! +*1*>, %% #$&%84%"!. ! !1%*4(', )(&<)6 ! $&51*, #$&*1*"!. ! #>*#$<,» (350, #. 1). !&('(++&%"!% >%4('%/*, !"*>% ;('(&,, @&%1#$*%$ /*/ @&(>5'#$'('*""(% ()F%% '(++&%"!% "* 8!& – #'(. ! '"%7"!., '(++&%"!% ' %;( 2%4(#$"(#$!, ' "%&*+1%4<"(#$!, "%&*#>4%"%""(#$! %;( #(1%&?*"!,. R* E$(8 '(++&%"!! (#"('6'*G$#, (@&%1%4%""*, ()F%#$'%""*, @(+!2!, >%4('%/*, (2%"/* !8 #(1%&?*"!, ! +"*>%"!, #'(%. ?!+"%1%,$%4<"(#$!.
56
0(&8!&('*"!% 8!&('(++&%"!, – 1(#$*$(>"( #4(?"6. @&(2%##, +*'!#,F!. ($ 8"(;!: A*/$(&('. P5F%#$'%""(% '4!,"!% "* E$($ @&(2%## (/*+6'*%$, ' >*#$"(#$!, "%@(#&%1#$'%""*, @&*/$!>%#/*, 1%,$%4<"(#$< >%4('%/*, :*&*/$%& ! #(1%&?*"!% %;( $&51*, 5#4('!,, ' /($(&6: (" ?!'%$ ! $&51!$#,. J*/, 8!&('(++&%"!% 5>%"(;( #/4*16'*%$#, ' +"*>!$%4<"(. #$%@%"! @(1 '4!,"!%8 %;( "*5>"(–!##4%1('*$%4<#/(. &*)($6, 8*$%&!*4* %;( "*5/!. R( E$!8, /("%>"(, 1%4( "% !#>%&@6'*%$#,. R* A(&8!&('*"!% 8!&('(++&%"!, 5>%"(;( '4!,%$ "% $(4"*, 1%,$%4<"(#$<, "( ! %;( ?!+"< 1( @&!:(1* ' "*5/5 ('(#@!$*"!% ' #%8<% ! 7/(4%, "*@&!8%&) ! '"% #A%&6 "*5/! – %;( ()F%#$'%""*, 1%,$%4<"(#$<, @&!()F%"!% / 4!$%&*$5&% ! !#/5##$'5 (!4! ($#$&*"%"!% ($ $(;( ! 1&5;(;(), @%>*$<, ()F%"!% # /(44%;*8!, # 4G1<8! !"(;( /&5;* ! $.1. C#% E$( ()5#4('4!'*%$ 8"(;(;&*""(#$< 8!&('(++&%"!,, "*4!>!% ' "%8 &*+"(()&*+"6:, @(1>*# @&($!'(&%>!'6: #$(&(". M*?1*, !+ "!: !;&*%$ #'(G (@&%1%4%""5G &(4< ' ?!+"! 5>%"(;(, ' A(&8!&('*"!! ! &*+'!$!! %;( 4!>"(#$!, ' (#5F%#$'4%"!! %;( ?!+"%1%,$%4<"(#$!. H: 15:('"*, +&%4(#$<, ()%#@%>%""(#$< +"*"!,8! ! "&*'#$'%""68! (&!%"$!&*8!, !: #(($'%$#$'!% 1&5; 1&5;5 $%8 '*?"%%, >%8 #4(?"%% ! +"*>!$%4<"%% '+*!8(($"(7%"!, 5>%"6: # (/&5?*GF!8 !: 8!&(8, >%8 )(4<7% !: ($'%$#$'%""(#$< @%&%1 ()F%#$'(8, @%&%1 #()(.. H "*!)(4%% 1%.#$'%""68, "*!)(4%% )4*;($'(&"68 ' ?!+"%""(8 @&%$'(&%"!! ,'4,%$#, $*/(% 8!&('(++&%"!%, ' /($(&(8 %;( (#"('"6% #$(&("6 ;*&8("!>"( '+*!8(#',+*"6, "% @(1*'4,G$ 1&5; 1&5;*, "% 1(8!"!&5G$ (1"* "*1 1&5;(.. R( $*/ )6'*%$ 1*4%/( "% '#%;1*. P$!:!."(#$<, "%/("$&(4!&5%8(#$< A(&8!&('*"!, 8!&('(++&%"!, @&!'(1!$ @(1>*# / $(85, >$( 8%?15 "%/($(&68! %;( #$(&("*8! '(+"!/*G$ #5F%#$'%""6% &*#:(?1%"!,, (@&%1%4%""6% "%#(($'%$#$'!,, &*+"(;( &(1* ($/4("%"!,. J*/, ' 8!&('(++&%"!! 5>%"6:-%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. 1(8!"!&5GF%% @(4(?%"!% 8(?%$ +*"!8*$< – ! "%&%1/( $*/ #45>*%$#, – %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. *#@%/$ ' 5F%&) #(2!*4<"(85. L$( '6&*?*%$#,, ' >*#$"(#$!, ! ' $(8, >$( 5>%"6., )515>! 2%4!/(8 @(;4(F%""68 #'(!8! #5;5)( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"68! !##4%1('*"!,8!, #*8(5#$&*",%$#, ($ '#%;( (#$*4<"(;(, (/*+6'*%$#, &*'"(157"68 / #(2!*4<"68 @(#4%1#$'!,8 @(45>*%86: !8 &%+54<$*$('. J*/(% &*'"(157!% "% 8(?%$ "% $*!$< ' #%)% @*;5)"6: @(#4%1#$'!. – $%8 )(4<7!:, >%8 +"*>!$%4<"%% &(4< "*5/! ' ?!+"! ()F%#$'*. B(E$(85 5>%"(85 "%():(1!8( ,#"( #(+"*'*$< ! #(2!*4<"5G @(1(@4%/5 #'(!: !##4%1('*"!.. J*/, "*@&!8%&, 9. L."7$%.", ()&*F*,#< / #$51%"$*8, )515F!8 5>%"68, ;('(&!4: «N$()6 '*7 $&51 8(; #@(#()#$'('*$< &(#$5 >%4('%>%#/!: )4*;, '6 1(4?"6 &*+)!&*$<#, "% $(4%4('%/% ! %;( #51<)% 1(4?"* )6$< ' 2%"$&% '"!8*"!, @&! &*+&*)($/% '#%: $%:"!>%#/!: 5#('%&7%"#$'('*"!.. N$()6 $'(&%"!, "*7%;( &*+58* )64! )4*;(#4('%"!%8, * "% )!>(8 14, >%4('%>%#$'*, 86 "% 1(4?"6 5@5#/*$< !+ '!15 '%4!/!% "%&%7%""6% @&()4%86 (&;*"!+*2!! $&51* ! &*#@&%1%4%"!, )4*;. R!/(;1* "% +*)6'*.$% () E$(8 +* #'(!8! #:%8*8! ! 5&*'"%"!,8!» (403, #. 151).
57
B("!8*"!% !4! "%@("!8*"!% 5>%"68 #(2!*4<"6: @(#4%1#$'!. #'(!: !##4%1('*"!., %;( >5'#$'( ($'%$#$'%""(#$! @%&%1 ()F%#$'(8 !4! ($#5$#$'!% $*/('(;( – '#% E$( ! 8"(;(% 1&5;(% ' %;( ?!+"%1%,$%4<"(#$! $*/ !4! !"*>% +*'!#!$ ($ %;( 8!&('(++&%"!,. C($ @(>%85 $*/ '%4!/* &(4< $(;(, >$( 4%?!$ ' (#"('% 4G)(;( 8!&('(++&%"!,, (@&%1%4,%$ (&!%"$!&6 ' "%8, >$( #(#$*'4,%$ %;( ,1&(. H +1%#< #'(G "%8*4('*?"5G &(4< @&!+'*"* #6;&*$< A!4(#(A!, – @(#$(4%"68 #'(%;( @(4(?%"!, ! "*+"*>%"!, ' 8!&%, ' #5F"(#$"(8 @("!8*"!! #*8(;( 8!&* ! >%4('%/* ' "%8, ($"(7%"!, '"5$&%""%;( 8!&* >%4('%/* / 8!&5 '"%7"%85, ()F%#$'%""(;( ' >%4('%/% – / ()F%#$'%""(85 '"% %;(, ! $.@. J*/(% (#(+"*"!% ' %;( >%$/(. (@&%1%4%""(#$!, ' %;( "%():(1!8(. @(4"($%, ;45)!"% ! @(#4%1('*$%4<"(#$! "% 8(?%$ )6$< 1(#$!;"5$( ' (1"(8 4!7< %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!! – "! ' #A%&% $%(&%$!>%#/!: !+6#/*"!., "!, $%8 )(4%%, ' #A%&% "*)4G1%"!. ! E/#@%&!8%"$('. W#$%#$'%""("*5>"6% !##4%1('*"!, #*8! @( #%)% 8(;5$ #@(#()#$'('*$< 4!7< #$!:!."(85 A(&8!&('*"!G ($1%4<"6: 8!&('(++&%">%#/!: @( #'(%. @&!&(1%, "( "%!+)%?"( (;&*"!>%""6:, "%5#$(.>!'6:, >*#$( @('%&:"(#$"6: 5)%?1%"!., @&%1#$*'4%"!., 1(@5#/*GF!: 4G)6% ($/4("%"!,, "%1(@("!8*"!% 8"(;(;(, * @(1>*# ! @&(#$( "%@("!8*"!%, !, /*/ #4%1#$'!%, – (7!)/!, +*)45?1%"!,. V"*>%"!% A!4(#(A!! @( ($"(7%"!G / 8!&('(++&%"!G 5>%"(;( "% ' $(8, >$( ("*, /*/ !"(;1* 5$'%&?1*G$, (A(&84,%$ +"*"!, ($1%4<"6: @&(2%##(' ! +*/("(' ' E4%8%"$6 8!&('(++&%"!, !, #4%1('*$%4<"(, A(&8!&5%$ #*8( 8!&('(++&%"!%. 3"* 12!1!<1-9;*-, #(1%.#$'5%$ %;( A(&8!&('*"!G "*&,15 # 1&5;!8! "*5/*8! ! '"%"*5>"68! A*/$(&*8!, "( (#"('"(% %% "*+"*>%"!% #(#$(!$ ' $(8, >$( ("* ()(;*F*%$, #('%&7%"#$'5%$ 8!&('(++&%"!%, 1%4*%$ %;( !"$%44%/$5*4<"( "*#6F%""68 ! +&%468. 3"* /*/ )6 ()"*?*%$, '6#'%>!'*%$ ' 86#4!, @&(,#",%$ ' @(",$!,: 8!&('(++&%">%#/!% '(@&(#6 ! '(+8(?"6% ($'%$6 "* "!:, @&!1*%$ "('6., )(4%% ;45)(/!. #86#4 +"*"!,8 5>%"(;( ( 8!&% ! %;( +*/("*:, ( >%4('%/% ! %;( 8%#$% ' 8!&%, %;( &(4! ' ()F%#$'%, #@(#()#$'5%$ %1!"%"!G E$!: +"*"!., !: #!"$%+5. P4%1('*$%4<"(, @( ($"(7%"!G / 8!&('(++&%"!G 5>%"6: A!4(#(A!, ,'4,%$#, ,1&(8 %;( !"$%44%/$5*4<"(. #(#$*'4,GF%. ! ' E$(8 /*>%#$'% – "%():(1!868 5#4('!%8 %;( #('%&7%"#$'('*"!,, 1%.#$'%""68 #$!854,$(&(8 (#(+"*"!,, #5F"(#$"(;( @("!8*"!, @(4%+"(#$!, ()F%#$'%""(. +"*>!8(#$! !##4%1('*"!., !: /("%>"(. 2%4! ' %% "% $(4"(8, "( ! ()F%#$'%""(8 +"*>%"!!. § 7. 0=3242A=9 = B=8252CC8DE=D 5 D4FD4F52CE;E==: 2>8D7D3DE=D A6E<J== 9"*4!+ 8!&('(++&%">%#/(. A5"/2!! A!4(#(A!! @( ($"(7%"!G / %#$%#$'(+"*"!G ' %<1-$%6-"!= A(&8% '6,'4,%$, ()"*?*%$ #5F%#$'%""( '*?"5G #(1%.#$'5GF5G &(4< A!4(#(A#/(;( +"*"!,, A!4(#(A#/(;( #$!4,
58
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–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4< ' $%(&%$!>%#/(. >*#$! #'(%. "*5>"(–!##4%1('*$%4<#/(. &*)($6, ' #5F"(#$"(8 (#86#4%"!! %% 2%4%., %% :(1* ! &%+54<$*$(', ' %% @(",$!."(8 (A(&84%"!! ! $.@. ' (@&%1%4%""(. 8%&% +*'!#!$ ($ #('&%8%""(;( %85 ()F%#$'%""(;( #(+"*"!, – @(#$(4*#$< E$(;( ()F%#$'%""(;( #(+"*"!,. H @(#/(4%&%+ ()&*+('*"!% ! 1&5;!% /*"*46 – #$*"('!$#, 1(#$(,"!%8 ()F%. /54<$5&6 >%4('%>%#/(;( 8674%"!,, $( ("( ':(1!$ ' #(1%&?*"!% ()F%#$'%""(;( #(+"*"!,, * '#4%1#$'!% E$(;( – ! ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(% 8674%"!% 1*""(. E@(:!. H8 @&("!+*"6 '#% !"$%44%/$5*4<"6% #$(&("6 !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. &*)($6 5>%"(;( – %;( @(1:(1 / @&()4%8%, %;( #@(#()"(#$< @&("!/"5$< ' #5F%#$'( 1%4*, (#"('*$%4<"(#$< *&;58%"$*2!! ! $.@., :($, #*8 5>%"6. E$( +*>*#$5G ! "% (#(+"*%$, (" )%##(+"*$%4<"( «"*$6/*%$#,» "* ()F!% A!4(#(A#/!% '(@&(#6, A!4(#(A#/!% A(&86 8674%"!,. B(1 '4!,"!%8 $%: !4! !"6: ()#$(,$%4<#$' 5>%"6. @(1>*# '(()F% 8(?%$ )6$< "*#$&(%" @&($!' '#,/(. A!4(#(A!!, ($&!2*$%4<"( ($"(#!$<#, / "%.. J%8 "% 8%"%% ! %85 ("* "% >5?1* '('#%, $(4*% (" (/*+6'*%$#,, /*/ @&*'!4(, ' @4%"5 :517!: %% ()&*+2('. H+'%#$"6. *&;%"$!"#/!. A!+!/ ! A!4(#(A XX '%/* . Q5";%, /*#*,#< E$(;( '(@&(#*, @!#*4: «B&%"%)&%?%"!% A!4(#(A!%. "% !+)*'4,%$ ($ "%%. C #*8(8 1%4%, /(;1* 86 ;('(&!8 () ($#5$#$'!! !"$%&%#* / A!4(#(A!!, $(, '%&(,$"(, 4!7< +*8%",%8 A!4(#(A!G E/#@4!2!$"5G, ,'"5G, A!4(#(A!%. "%,'"(., !8@4!2!$"(., * #4%1('*$%4<"(, "%+&%4(. ! "%/("$&(4!&5%8(.» (44, #. 17). N$( /*#*%$#, A!4(#(A!! E/#@4!2!$"(., ,'"(., $( %% )4*;($'(&"(% '(+1%.#$'!% "* 5>%"(;(, "* :*&*/$%& ! #(1%&?*"!% %;( !##4%1('*"!. "% '6+6'*%$ #(8"%"!.. J*/, @&!8%"!$%4<"( / A!+!/% . Q5";% '61%4,%$ "%#/(4!$%4<"6:, "* %;( '+;4,1, "*@&*'4%"!. E$(;( '(+1%.#$'!,: «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
59
#!#$%8*8! '1(:"('!$ %;( / &*)($% "*1 1(4;('&%8%""68! !##4%1('*$%4<#/!8! @&(;&*88*8! '8%#$( #/*>/(' ($ (1"(. 8(1"(. 8*4%"%#/(;( %1!"#$'* '#%: ($&*#4%. A!+!/! ! 1&5;!: "*5/ @&%1(:&*"!$ %;( ($ #'%&:#@%2!*4!+*2!! – ;4*'"(. @&!>!"6 )%+&*)($!26 ! /&!+!#* @&(A%##!!… M&(8% '#%;( @&(>%;(, F%@($/* A!4(#(A!! 5#!4!$ '%&5 $%(&%$!/(' ! E/#@%&!8%"$*$(&(' ' #!45 !1%. ! "%():(1!8(#$! /&!$!/!. 31"!8 #4('(8, A!4(#(A!, '#%;1* # "*8!» ($*8 ?%, #. 35). P E$!8 8(?"( #(;4*#!$<#,. J*/!8 ()&*+(8, A!4(#(A!,, &%*4!+5GF*,#, ' $(8 !4! !"(8 #5F"(#$"(8 +"*"!! ! @("!8*"!!, ' 8%$(1!/% ! 4(;!/% ()I,#",GF%;( &*##5?1%"!,, @(+"*GF%;( 8674%"!, in abstracto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– @(#$(4"(#$!, &%*4!+5%$#, ()F%% ' A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!! &*2!("*4<"(%, 86#4!$%4<"(% "*>*4(. 0!4(#(A#/(% @(+"*"!% $%(&%$!>"( @( #'(%. @&!&(1%. B( 8"%"!G M. *&/#*, «#*8* @&*/$!/* A!4(#(A!! -*!$*-'0"%» (244, #. 77). B%&%A&*+!&5,, 8(?"( 1()*'!$<: #*8* @&*/$!/* -*!$*-','$!9%"'( ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!! @( #5$! #'(%. &'7!1!&'0"% – ' $(. 8%&%, ' /*/(. ' "%. +*1%.#$'('*"* &'7!1!&'( 2$'$!5., /($(&*,, ;('(&, #4('*8! =%;%4,, «! %#$< /*/ &*+ -*!$*-'0*16!*, * !8%""( :.17'-*78"!* &*##8($&%"!% @&!&(16» (83, #. 14). 0!4(#(A!, @&!&(16 ' $*/(8 %% @("!8*"!! ! #(#$*'4,%$ /(#$,/ $%(&%$!>"(#$! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,. -*#/&6'*, "%!+)%?"(#$< A!4(#(A!>"(#$! $%(&%$!>%#/(;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, =%;%4< @!#*4: «C $%(&%$!>%#/(8 ($"(7%"!! / @&!&(1% @%&'(. #$(&("(. ,'4,%$#, $(, >$( 86 ($:(1!8 ($ ,'4%"!. @&!&(16, (#$*'4,%8 !: ' "%@&!/(#"('%""(#$! ! (&!%"$!&5%8#, @( "!8. 6 @&! E$(8 "*>!"*%8 # >5'#$'%""6: #'%1%"!. ( @&!&(1%. 31"*/( %#4! )6 A!+!/* (#"('6'*4*#< 4!7< "* '(#@&!,$!,: ! '(#@&!,$!, )64! "% >%8 !"68, /*/ #'!1%$%4<#$'(8 "*7!: >5'#$', $( &*)($* A!+!/! #(#$(,4* )6 4!7< ' (#8*$&!'*"!!, @&!#457!'*"!!, ()"G:!'*"!! ! $.1., ! ?!'($"6%, $*/!8 ()&*+(8, )64! )6 $*/?% A!+!/*8!. C 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!, (1"*/(, '!1!$, #467!$ ! $.1. 15:, 86#4,F%% #5F%#$'(… C$(&(. #$(&("(. "*7%;( $%(&%$!>%#/(;( ($"(7%"!, / @&%18%$*8 @&!&(16 ,'4,%$#, $(, >$( ("! @(45>*G$ 14, "*# (@&%1%4%"!% '#%()F"(#$!, !4!, !"*>% ;('(&,, $(, >$( 86 !: @&%'&*F*%8 ' "%>$( '#%()F%%. N%8 )(4<7% '(+&*#$*%$ 1(4, 8674%"!, ' @&%1#$*'4%"!!, $%8
60
)(4%% !#>%+*%$ @&!&(1"(#$<, %1!"!>"(#$< ! "%@(#&%1#$'%""(#$< '%F%.» ($*8 ?%, #. 15). 3)&%$*, 1(#$*$(>"( +&%45G 86#4!$%4<"(#$< "* @5$! *"*4!+* ! ()()F%"!,, (#86#4%"!, E8@!&!>%#/(;( 8*$%&!*4*, %#$%#$'(+"*"!% '#4%1#$'!% E$(;( "%!+)%?"( '#$5@*%$ ' $%(&%$!>%#/5G ()4*#$<, * +1%#<, /*/ ($8%>*4 L";%4<#, «E8@!&!>%#/!% 8%$(16 (/*+6'*G$#, )%##!4<"68!, +1%#< 8(?%$ (/*+*$< @(8(F< $(4%#/(% 8674%"!%. R( $%(&%$!>%#/(% 8674%"!% ,'4,%$#, @&!&(?1%""68 #'(.#$'(8 $(4%"!, '#%. @&%17%#$'5GF%. A!4(#(A!!» (406, #. 366). R( ()&*F%"!% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. / A!4(#(A!! 2%4%#(()&*+"( "% $(4%#/(85 8674%"!G, "( ! &*1! #('%&7%"#$'('*"!, %;( "%@(#&%1#$'%""(;( (#5F%#$'4%"!,, @4(1($'(&"(;( A5"/2!("!&('*"!, %;( (#"('"6: #&%1#$', ' >*#$"(#$!, 2!"(-'=. J%(&%$!>%#/(% 8674%"!% @&%1@(4*;*%$ 58%"!% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. (@%&!&('*$< @(",$!,8!, 58%"!% ()4%/*$< ' !: *)#$&*/$"6% A(&86 ()()F*%86. E8@!&!>%#/!. 8*$%&!*4. B%&%:(1 ($ E8@!&!! / $%(&!! ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!! – E$( @&%?1% '#%;( @&(2%## %;( ':(?1%"!, ' #A%&5 @(",$!.. H 14, #*86: $%(&%$!+!&5GF!: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. E$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'( ' :(1% &*+'%&$6'*"!, '"5$&!"*5>"(. &%A4%/#!! ()&%$*%$ :*&*/$%& (>%'!1"(#$!. «B(",$!,, – @!#*4 C. =%.+%")%&;, – #(#$*'4,G$ #5F%#$'%""5G >*#$< "*7%;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( 8%$(1*, $*/ /*/ ("!… ()&*+5G$ /("%>"6. &%+54<$*$ @&%17%#$'5GF%;( &*+'!$!, >%4('%>%#/(;( 8674%"!,… 3"! #45?*$ "%():(1!868 !"#$&58%"$(8 ' "*7% '&%8, 14, '#,/(. "*5>"(. &*)($6» (85, #. 62). B&!8%>*$%4<"( +1%#< $(, >$( =%.+%")%&; :*&*/$%&!+5%$ @(",$!,, @&!8%",%86% ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!!, "* @&%1%4<"( 7!&(/(8 86#4!$%4<"(8 A("% –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– E$($ (@6$, 5#'(%""6. @&%1#$*'!$%4,8! %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/ ! @&!8%",%86. !8! ' !: "%@(#&%1#$'%""(., $%(&%$!>%#/! (A(&84%""(. !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$!, #$*"('!$#, (1"!8 !+ (),+*$%4<"6: 5#4('!. %% 5#@%7"(#$!. R(, /("#$!$5!&('*'7!#< ' #!#$%8% #&%1#$' @(+"*"!, $(. !4! !"(. %#$%#$'%""(. "*5/!, ()&%$, #(($'%$#$'5GF!% @(+"*'*$%4<"6% A5"/2!!, @(",$!, "% (#$*G$#, "%!+8%""68!. B( 8%&% &*+'!$!, 1*""(. "*5/!,
61
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… +"*>%"!%, '6:(1,F%% 1*4%/( +* @&%1%46 (1"(. $(4%#/(. "*5/!» (37, #. 516). H E$* #A%&* @(",$!."(#$!, "*:(1,F*,#, +* @&%1%4*8! A!+!>%#/(. ! 4G)(. 1&5;(. %#$%#$'%""(. "*5/!, (@,$< ?% %#$< "% >$( !"(%, /*/ #A%&* '#%;( &%*4<"( (#5F%#$'4,GF%;(#, >%4('%>%#/(;( 8674%"!,, "*!)(4%% +&%46% A(&86 /($(&(;( '(@4(F*G$#, ' A!4(#(A!!. M54<$5&* A!4(#(A#/(;( 8674%"!, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,–$%(&%$!/*, %;( !#/5##$'( (@%&!&('*$< @(",$!,8!, 58%"!% &*+'!'*$<, #('%&7%"#$'('*$< @(",$!."6. *@@*&*$ #'(%. "*5/! –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«C*?"(% +"*>%"!% A!+!>%#/(. "*5/! 14, &*+'!$!, ()F%;( A!4(#(A#/(;( 8674%"!, (#"('*"( "% $(4*#$%#/*, "*5/* '*?"* ! $%8, >$( '&%8, ($ '&%8%"! ("* 1*'*4* #45>*. @%&%#8*$&!'*$< ! 545>7*$< "*75 #!#$%85 @(",$!. /*/ (&51!% @(+"*"!,» ($*8 ?%). B(",$"(, >$( A!4(#(A!>"(#$< $%(&%$!>%#/(;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!, 1*4%/( "% '#%;1* ,'"( @&(#$5@*%$ '('"%. 3"* !8%%$ #/&6$6% ! ($/&6$6% A(&86. C @%&'(8 #45>*% ("* '6#$5@*%$ ' #5;5)( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 ()4*>%"!!, ' '!1% A!+!>%#/!:, :!8!>%#/!:, )!(4(;!>%#/!: ! $.@. @(",$!., A(&854 ! $.1. C( '$(&(8 #45>*% ("* '64!'*%$#, ' A!4(#(A#$'('*"!%
62
%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., ' (@%&!&('*"!% !8! A!4(#(A#/!8! /*$%;(&!,8!, (/&*7%""68! ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6% $("* – ' $("* $(. %#$%#$'%""(. "*5/!, ' /($(&(. #@%2!*4!+!&5%$#, 1*""6. 5>%"6.. V1%#< #',+< %#$%#$'(+"*"!, # A!4(#(A!%. "*#$(4%'!1"*, >$( %% +*8%>*G$, )(4<7% $(;( – #$*&*G$#, #(+"*$%4<"( &%*4!+('*$< ! #*8! 5>%"6%–$%(&%$!/!. . Q(&" ' #',+! # E$!8 @!#*4: «DG)(. #('&%8%""6. 5>%"6.–%#$%#$'%""!/, (#()%""( /*?16. A!+!/–$%(&%$!/, ;45)(/( 5)%?1%", >$( %;( &*)($* $%#"%.7!8 ()&*+(8 @%&%@4%$*%$#, # A!4(#(A!%. ! >$( )%+ #%&<%+"(;( +"*"!, A!4(#(A#/(. 4!$%&*$5&6 %;( &*)($* )51%$ '@5#$5G. L$(. !1%%. , &5/('(1#$'('*4#, #*8, #$*&*,#< '1(:"5$< %% ! ' #'(!: 5>%"!/('» (39, #. 44). H"*>% ;('(&,, ' #A%&% $%(&%$!>%#/(;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, (#()%""( $*8, ;1% @&%()4*1*G$ ($/&6$6% A(&86 %;( A!4(#(A!>"(#$!, "%():(1!8(#$< ' A!4(#(A!! (#(+"*%$#, ,#"%% '#%;(, ! #',+< # "%G @(E$(85 "*!)(4%% @&(>"*,, 5#$(.>!'*,. L$( ! @(+'(4!4( 9. L."7$%."5 #1%4*$< '6'(1, >$( «'#,/*, "*5/* #$&(!$#, "* "%/($(&(. &%*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A#/(. (#"('%»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«M&5; (:'*$6'*%86: "*5/(. '(@&(#(' >&%+'6>*."( &*#7!&!4#,, $%(&%$!>%#/(% @(+"*"!% '( '#%: ()4*#$,: %#$%#$'(+"*"!, "%@&%1'!1%""( 5;45)!4(#<. R( @(+"*'*$%4<"*, #@(#()"(#$< >%4('%/* (;&*"!>%"* 5+/!8! &*8/*8! ! "% !+8%",%$#,. B(E$(85 1%,$%4<"(#$< ($1%4<"6: !##4%1('*$%4%. "%!+)%?"( #$,;!'*%$#, /( '#% )(4%% (;&*"!>%""(85 5>*#$/5 '#%()F%;( +"*"!,… M*?1(85 #%&<%+"(85 5>%"(85 +"*/(8( E$( )(4%+"%""(% >5'#$'( "%'(4<"(. (;&*"!>%""(#$! '#% )(4%% #5?*GF!8#, /&5;(8 @&%1#$*'4%"!., 5;&(?*GF%. ($",$< 5 !##4%1('*$%4, 7!&(/5G @%&#@%/$!'5, @&!"!?*, %;( 1( 5&('", &%8%#4%""!/*» ($*8 ?%, #. 173). B(",$"(, >$( @($&%)"(#$< ' A!4(#(A!! 14, $*/(;( «&%8%#4%""!/*» "% (F5F*%$#, #$(4< (>%'!1"(, /*/ ' !##4%1('*"!! @&()4%8 ()F%;( :*&*/$%&*. W#4! !8%$< ' '!15 #()#$'%""( A!4(#(A#/5G @&()4%8*$!/5, '6,'4%"!% #5;5)( A!4(#(A#/(;( *#@%/$* ' !##4%15%8(8 ()I%/$%, $( ($#$&*"%"!% ($ A!4(#(A!! +1%#< ' )(4<7!"#$'% #45>*%' @(4"(%. 3@(&* "* A!4(#(A!G ' @(1()"6: #45>*,: )(4%% (@(#&%1('*""*,, ("* #/&6$* @(1 #5;5)( #@%2!*4<"68! 14, 1*""(. %#$%#$'%""(. "*5/! A(&8*8! @(+"*"!,, "*:(1,F!8!#, "* @('%&:"(#$!. O>*#$!% A!4(#(A!! +1%#< '6&*?*%$#, ;4*'"68 ()&*+(8 ' 12!1!<"!1-'
63
!##4%1('*$%4, $%(&%$!>%#/! 86#4!$<, ' 58%"!! #@&*7!'*$< 5 @&!&(16 ! "*:(1!$< ($'%$6. WF% )(4%% (@(#&%1('*""(, 8%"<7% @( ()I%85, 8%"%% (&;*"!>"( #',+*"* A!4(#(A!, # $%8! ()4*#$,8! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, #(1%&?*"!% /($(&6: #(#$*'4,G$ @&%!85F%#$'%""( E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"6% !##4%1('*"!,, "*)4G1%"!,. 3"! (#5F%#$'4,G$#,, /*/ @&*'!4(, )%+ "%@(#&%1#$'%""(. (@(&6 "* A!4(#(A#/(% +"*"!%, A!4(#(A#/(% 8674%"!%. R( (@&%1%4%""*, #',+< # A!4(#(A!%. %#$< ! +1%#< – @(#$(4%&%+ $%(&%$!>%#/!% !##4%1('*"!,. . D*5E @!#*4, ' >*#$"(#$!, ( $%(&%$!>%#/!: #(()&*?%"!,:, /($(&6% «"%@(#&%1#$'%""( 5/*+6'*4! E/#@%&!8%"$5 "('6% @5$!»: &(4< E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"6: ($/&6$!. (" '!1%4 ' $(8, >$( «("! 1(4?"6 ' @%&'5G (>%&%1< @(#$*'4,$< 8*$%&!*4, / /($(&(85 8(;5$ @&!86/*$< &*+8674%"!,» (198, #. 139). H, "*@&!8%&, $*/(% +*'(%'*"!% "*5/!, /*/ ($/&6$!% =. =%&2*, @( 8"%"!G . D*5E, «'('#% "% )64( ()5#4('4%"( "('68! E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"68! #&%1#$'*8!, * 4!7< ;%"!*4<"(. 4(;!/(. E/#@%&!8%"$*$(&*» ($*8 ?%, #. 123). H"*>% ;('(&,, ! ' #()#$'%""( E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"6: !##4%1('*"!,: A!4(#(A!, +*>*#$5G "%():(1!8*, :($, ! ' #/&6$(. A(&8%, "%():(1!8* ' @(1:(1%, ' '6)(&% ()I%/$* !+5>%"!,, ' "*@&*'4%"!! !##4%1('*"!,, ("* @&(,'4,%$#, ' «;%"!*4<"(. 4(;!/% E/#@%&!8%"$*$(&*», ' (@&%1%4%"!! !8 2%4! !##4%1('*"!., ' %;( &*+8674%"!,: ! $.@. K&5;(% 1%4(, >$( '#% E$( +*>*#$5G "% (#(+"*%$#, #*8!8! E/#@%&!8%"$*$(&*8!, '#4%1#$'!% >%;( 5 "!:, * $*/?% 5 $%(&%$!/(' ' 5+/(#@%2!*4<"6: ()4*#$,: "%&%1/( #/4*16'*%$#, 5)%?1%"!% ' "%"5?"(#$! A!4(#(A!! 14, '#%. "*5/!, @(#/(4"(;( @(+"*"!,. P4%15%$ '61%4!$< %F% (1"( &5#4( '(+1%.#$'!, A!4(#(A!! "* %#$%#$'(+"*"!%. C( '#%: !##4%1('*"!,: ' %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/*: – ! E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"6:, ! $%(&%$!>%#/!: –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
64
%% $'(&26, 5>%"6%, !##4%1('*"!,8! ! 1(#$!?%"!,8! /($(&6: "*5/*, #()#$'%""(, ! 1'!?%$#, '@%&%1, – !8%""( E$! 5>%"6% ,#"%% 1&5;!: (#(+"*G$ "%():(1!8(#$< ' A!4(#(A!! ! )(4<7% 1&5;!: ()&*F*G$#, / "%.. K.M. */#'%44, =. =%4<8;(4<2, L. =%//%4<, H. . P%>%"(', K.H. %"1%4%%', 9. L."7$%.", . B4*"/, . Q(&", R. Q(&, . D*5E – E$! ! 8"(;!% 1&5;!% 5>%"6% "% $(4*4! %%, "( ! "% )%+ 5#@%:* #*8! @!#*4! &*)($6, A!4(#(A#/!% @( #(1%&?*"!G. 0!4(#(A!,, ' !: @&%1#$*'4%"!!, )64* "%():(1!868 ! '*?"68 /(8@("%"$(8 "% $(4"(;( @(+"*"!,, "( ! '#%. >%4('%>%#/(. /54<$5&6. J*/, . D*5E, /($(&6., @( %;( #()#$'%""(85 @&!+"*"!G, «8"(;( ! ;45)(/( +*"!8*4#, A!4(#(A!%.», @!#*4: «3"* #('%&7%""( @&%()&*+!4* 8(% )6$!%; 1*?% A!+!/* /*?%$#, 8"% # $%: @(& "*5/(., "*#$(,F!8 1(#$(!"#$'(8 /($(&(. ,'4,%$#, $(, >$( ("* 1*%$ A!4(#(A!! #5F%#$'%""6% '#@(8(;*$%4<"6% #&%1#$'*. "% @&%1#$*'4,%$#,, >$( '#% "*5/! 1(4?"6 ;&5@@!&('*$<#, '(/&5; A!4(#(A!!, /*/ !: ()F%;( 2%"$&*, ! >$( #45?%"!% %. ,'4,%$#, !: #()#$'%""(. 2%4"(. /54<$5&6 @&($!' "%51%&?!8( @&(;&%##!&5GF%;( #@%2!*4!+!&('*"!, "*5/. Q%+ E$(;( %1!"#$'* '#, /54<$5&* )64* )6 ()&%>%"* "* ;!)%4<»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«'(@&(# ( $(8, ,'4,%$#, 4! 8*$%&!, "%@&%&6'"(. !4! #(#$(!$ !+ 1!#/&%$"6: >*#$%.» – E$( «$&51"6. '(@&(#, 4%?*F!. "* ;&*"!2% A!+!/! ! A!4(#(A!!. WF% #&*'"!$%4<"( "%1*'"( %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! !+)%;*4! +*"!8*$<#, ()#5?1%"!%8 @(1()"6: '(@&(#('. R( E$($ '(@&(# ,'4,%$#, 14, %#$%#$'(+"*"!, #4!7/(8 '*?"68, >$()6 %;( 8(?"( )64( ()(.$! 8(4>*"!%8. W;( ?% "%4<+, ()#5?1*$< )%+ $(;(, >$()6 "% +*$&("5$< ! &,1 1&5;!:, "*@&!8%&: ( #5F"(#$! +*/("* @&!>!""(#$!, 8*$%&!!, #!46 ! $.1., ( /($(&6: /*/ &*+ ! ;('(&!4!, >$( ("!
65
"% /*#*G$#, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ! >$( !: "5?"( @&%1(#$*'!$< 2%4!/(8 A!4(#(A!!. C "*#$(,F%% '&%8, @(4(?%"!% '%F%. !+8%"!4(#<, ! "*$5&*4!#$6 # (#()(. 4G)('%8 E$( @&!:(1!4(#< 1%4*$< A!+!/*8 @&%1615F!: @(/(4%"!.. M E$(85 A!+!/(' '6"5?1*G$ $&51"(#$! !: #()#$'%""(. "*5/!» (403, #. 248). 0!+!/*, @( 8"%"!G 9. L."7$%."*, «85>!$%4<"( A!4(#(A#$'5%$ ( @&%18%$% #'(!: !##4%1('*"!.. P$( 4%$ "*+*1 '#,/(% A!4(#(A#$'('*"!% )64( )6 # @&%+&%"!%8 ($)&(7%"(»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– @%&!(16 &%'(4G2!. ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, #8%"6 @*&*1!;8. H "*/("%2, +"*>%"!% A!4(#(A!! 14, %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/ "%(1!"*/('( "* &*+"6: E$*@*: !#$(&!>%#/(;( &*+'!$!, %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,: 8%"%% +"*>!$%4<"* &(4< A!4(#(A!! @( ($"(7%"!G / %#$%#$'(+"*"!G "* &*""!: E$*@*: %;( 1%:!1-!(-*78"!#! ($( %#$< '"% &*8(/ "*$5&A!4(#(A!!) &*+'!$!,, )(4%% +"*>!$%4<"* "* /*?1(8 @(#4%15GF%8, )(4%% #('%&7%""(8: ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!! '#% )(4<7% #$*"('!$#, $%(&%$!>"(#$!, '#% +"*>!$%4<"%% – $'(&>%#/(% "*>*4(, '#% #5F%#$'%""%% – @&%()&*+('*"!,, '#% (#(+"*""%% – "%():(1!8(#$< ' ()&*F%"!! / A!4(#(A!!, / A!4(#(A#/(85 +"*"!G, A!4(#(A#/(85 8674%"!G. -(4< A!4(#(A!!, $*/!8 ()&*+(8, @( 8%&% &*+'!$!, '#%;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( (! "% $(4"(;() @(+"*"!, '(+&*#$*%$. 3>%'!1"68 @(1$'%&?1%"!%8 E$(85 ,'4,G$#, $% !+8%"%"!, '( '+*!8(($"(7%"!! A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, $% @%&!@%$!! ' "%8, /($(&6% ()"*&5?!4!#< ' XIX '%/% ! $*/ !4! !"*>% ($&*+!4!#< ' A!4(#(A#/(8 8!&('(++&%"!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%..
66
@3;5; II (4FD4F52CE;E=D 5 XIX 5D%#/(. #A%&6. C 1%$*4<"(8 *"*4!+% A!4(#(A#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, 5>%"6:%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. (@&%1%4%""(. !#$(&!>%#/(. E@(:!, ' 1*""(8 #45>*% XIX '%/* 1(4?"*, 8%&* /("/&%$"(#$! @&%1@(4*;*%$ #(($'%$#$'5GF5G 8%&5 (@&%1%4%""(#$! ' ($"(7%"!! #*8!: 5>%"6:: ( 8!&('(++&%"!! /(;( !+ "!: – @(!8%""( – !1%$ &%>< ! @(>%85 '6)&*"6 !8%""( ("!? C #',+! # E$!8 @&%1#$*'4,%$#, "%():(1!8(. 1(#$*$(>"( @&%1#$*'!$%4<"*, '6)(&(>"*, @%&#("*4<"*, ()I%/$!'*2!, /("/&%$"6: 5>%"6: – #(($'%$#$'%""( !: 8%#$5 ! &(4! ' &*+'!$!! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, ' #$*"('4%"!! %;( 1(#$!?%"!.. B(",$"(, >$( (#()%""( @&!'4%/*$%4<"6 ' E$(8 ($"(7%"!! "*!)(4%% '61*GF!%#, 5>%"6%, $'(&26 "*5/!, @%&'(@&(:(126, @%&'(($/&6'*$%4! ' "%., 5>%"6%, >"6% !##4%1('*"!, ' &%7*GF%. 8%&% (@&%1%4!4! #(1%&?*"!%, /*>%#$'%""5G #@%2!A!/5 ! 5&('%"< &*+'!$!, %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ' &*##8*$&!'*%86. @%&!(1 %;( !#$(&!!. K(#$*$(>"( "*+'*$< ' #',+! # E$!8 !8%"* /&5@"%.7!: +*@*1"(%'&(@%.#/!: 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/* – K*&'!"* ! D,.%4,, 0*&*1%, ! */#'%44*, =%/#4! ! =%//%4,, *.%&* ! =%4<8;(4<2*, D!)!:* ! Q%&"*&*, Q(4<28*"* ! D(&%"2* ! 1&. B&! E$(8 '*?"( 5>%#$< ! !: @&!"*14%?"(#$< /( '#%8 (#"('"68 ($&*#4,8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!, – / A!+!/%, :!8!!, )!(4(;!!, A!+!(4(;!!, $( %#$< / $%8 %#$%#$'%""68 "*5/*8, /($(&6% ' &*##8*$&!'*%86. @%&!(1 1(#$!;4! "*!)(4<7!: 5#@%:(', ' @%&'5G (>%&%1< – 5#!4!,8! "*+'*""6: 5>%"6:. R*/("%2, @&%1#$*'4,%$#, "%():(1!868 5>%#$< $*/?% ! #$&*"6 !: @&(?!'*"!,, $( %#$< $% #$&*"6, ' /($(&6: &*+'!$!% %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ' XIX '%/% )64( (#()%""( @4(1($'(&"68 – 9";4!G, =%&8*"!G, 0&*"2!G, 9'#$&!G. C >!#4( $*/!: #$&*" # @(4"68 (#"('*"!%8 8(?"( '/4G>!$< ! -(##!G, ' /($(&(., @( #'!1%$%4<#$'5 H.H. %>"!/('*, ' #%&%1!"% XIX '%/* @(1 '4!,"!%8 V*@*1* «@&()51!4(#< 5#!4%""(% #$&%84%"!% / "*5/%. C "%. @&%1@(4*;*4#, /4G> / &%7%"!G '#%: (#"('"6: +*1*>, '(4"5GF!: 4G1%.. "(;!% !+ G"(7%#$'* # ?*&(8 )&(#!4!#< "* !+5>%"!% ;4*'"68 ()&*+(8 %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/» (270, #. 8). L$( !"$%"#!'"(% !+5>%"!% %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/ #(@&('(?1*4(#< "% 8%"%% !"$%"#!'"68! #*8(#$(,$%4<"68! @4(1($'(&"68! !##4%1('*"!,8!. «P&*+5 (@&%1%4!4(#< "%#/(4%"< '61*GF!:#, $*4*"$(', ! &5##/!% 5>%"6% #1%4*4! #%)% !8, ! ' W'&(@%… K(#$*$(>"( "*@(8"!$< !8%"* Q5$4%&('*, %"1%4%%'*, 94%/#*"1&* M('*4%'#/(;(, P%>%"('*, Q($/!"*, >$()6 1*$< @(",$!% ( #!4% &(#$* "*5>"(;( 1'!?%"!, ' -(##!! ' 5/*+*""5G E@(:5» ($*8 ?%, #. 5). M "*+'*""68 8(?"( 1()*'!$< ! 1&5;!%, "% 8%"%% ;&(8/!% !8%"* – D%)%1%'*, P$(4%$('*, J!8!&,+%'*, O8('* !, &*+58%%$#,, #*8(;( %>"!/('*.
67
§ 1. $D8522F<8K5;FD3= 5D3=<2N2 C;<2E;: %;GD8 = @D3OBN23OJ H+ '#%: ($&*#4%. %#$%#$'(+"*"!, "*!)(4<7%% &*+'!$!% ' UIX '%/% @(45>!4! A!+!/*, :!8!, ! )!(4(;!,. R* 1(#$!?%"!,: E$!: "*5/ ! (#$*"('!8#, )(4%% @(1&()"( – # $%8, >$()6, '(-@%&'6:, '6,'!$< #(1%&?*"!% "*5>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! "*!)(4%% '61*GF!:#, 5>%"6: '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/*, * '(-'$(&6:, >$()6 1%$*4<"( ()(+"*>!$< $($ "*5>"6. 8*$%&!*4, /($(&6. @(&(?1*4 ! @!$*4 ' "!: '+;4,16 8!&('(++&%">%#/(;( :*&*/$%&*. B&! E$(8 ;4*'"(% '"!8*"!% )51%$ ()&*F%"( "* !#$(&!G @&(!#:(?1%"!, ! &*+'!$!% $%: !1%., /($(&6%, @( #4('*8 K.M. */#'%44*, «'6+'*4! &*+4!>!% (1"(;( '%/* ($ 1&5;(;(» (231, #. 32), $( %#$< XIX-;( ($ XVIII-;(. L$! !1%! ! #',+*""6% # "!8! ($/&6$!, &*##8($&!8 >%&%+ !: '(#@&!,$!%, @("!8*"!%, !+4(?%"!%, (2%"/5, >%&%+ ($"(7%"!% / "!8 #*8!: 5>%"6: – #('&%8%""!/(' E$!: ($/&6$!., @&(1(4?*$%4%. 1%4* !: *'$(&('. H+ )(4<7(;( >!#4* 5>%"6: '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* '61%4!8 "%#/(4%4('%/, – @!#*4 */#'%44, – ,'4,%$#, %1!"#$'%""68 ' #'(%8 &(1%. C !#$(&!>%#/(8 7%#$'!! 5>%"6: 5 /*?1(;( !+ "!: #'(, (@&%1%4]""*, +*1*>* ! #'(] (@&%1%4]""(% 8%#$(» ($*8 ?%, #. 67). C($ E$( !#$(&!>%#/(% 7%#$'!% '61*GF!:#, 5>%"6:, 8%#$( ! &(4< ' "]8 /*?1(;( !+ "!:, +*1*>!, &%7%""6% !8!, ! @&%1#$*'4,%$ "*!)(4<7!. !"$%&%#. H @($(85 ;4*'"*, 2%4< +1%#< – "% ' )%##$&*#$"(8 @&($(/(4<"(8 @%&%>!#4%"!! 1(#$!?%"!. "*5/! '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/*, "% ' !+4(?%"!! !: /("/&%$"(;( #(1%&?*"!, (:($, ! "%4<+, #('#%8 ($/*+*$<#, ($ "%;(), * ' (+"*/(84%"!! >%&%+ E$! 1(#$!?%"!, # !: *'$(&*8! – «# $'(&2*8! "*5/!, 4!>"(% '4!,"!% /($(&6: "* &*#7!&%"!% 58#$'%""(;( ;(&!+("$* "!>%8 "% +*8%"!8(, ! # $%8! 8*$%&!*4<"68! @&%18%$*8!, /($(&6% '@%&'6% )64! (#86#4%"6 )4*;(1*&, !: $&51*8» ($*8 ?%, #. 67). J*/(. @(1:(1 / &*##8($&%"!G %#$%#$'(+"*"!, '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* '*?%" "% #$(4*$< @&! E$(8 "%():(1!8( # A!+!/(', @(#/(4!$%4<"6% 5#@%:!. H8%""( ' E$($ @%&!(1 #4(?!4(#<, ;('(&, #4('*8! D. Q(4<28*"*, @&%1#$*'4%"!% ( "%. /*/ ( «8*$%&! '#%: (#$*4<"6: %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/, /($(&*, 1*]$ @!F5 8*$%8*$!/% ! +*/("6 #@%2!*4<"68 '%$',8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!,» (35, #. 33). C :(1% &*+'!$!, A!+!/!, ! ' >*#$"(#$!, $%&8(1!"*8!/! ' #%&%1!"% XIX '%/* )64 ($/&6$ (1!" !+ "*!)(4%% ()F!:, 5"!'%&#*4<"6: +*/("(' %#$%#$'(+"*"!, – +*/(" #(:&*"%"!, ! @&%'&*F%"!, E"%&;!!. C@%&'6% #A(&854!&('*4 ! ()(#"('*4 E$($ +*/(" '61*GF!.#, "%8%2/!. 5>%"6. S.-. *.%& (1814–1878). C #'(!: &*)($*: 1841–1845 ;;. (" 5#$*"('!4, >$( 1'!?%"!%, $%@4($*, E4%/$&!>%#$'(, :!8!>%#/!% @&(2%##6 ! $.@. ,'4,G$#, /*>%#$'%""( &*+4!>"68! A(&8*8! «#!4» (E"%&;!!), @&%'&*F*GF!:#, 1&5; ' 1&5;* @&! "%!+8%""6: /(4!>%#$'%""6: #(($"(7%"!,:. *.%&, @( #4('*8
68
B4*"/*, «@&%1@(>%4 ()&6'(>"68 @(#$&(%"!,8 E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"(;( $(4/* ()()F%"!% ' A!4(#(A#/(8 15:%, >$( #(($'%$#$'('*4( %;( 8*"%&% 8674%"!,» (55, #. 173). B&! E$(8, /*/ @(1>%&/"54 C. 3#$'*4<1, « *.%&* 8(?"( @&!>!#4!$< / $*/!8 !##4%1('*$%4,8, /($(&6% '#G ?!+"< @(#',F*G$ @&('%1%"!G %1!"#$'%""(., '%4!/(. !1%!» (290, #. 64). 3#$'*4<1 ()&*$!4 '"!8*"!% "* #5F%#$'%""6. &*2!("*4<"6. *#@%/$ "*5>"(;( $'(&>%#$'* *.%&*, "* 86#4!$%4<"5G @(1(@4%/5 %;( '%4!/(;( ($/&6$!,, $'(&>%#/(. &%*4!+*2!! ' "%8 (#"('(@(4*;*GF%. !1%!. «N&%+'6>*."*, #!4*, # /*/(. E$* !1%, "%8%14%""( ('4*1%'*%$ 58(8 *.%&*, 5/*+6'*%$ "* $(, >$( ("*, '%&(,$"(, 1(4;( @(1;($('4,4*#< ' ()4*#$! )%##(+"*$%4<"(;(, $*/ >$( #&*+5, /*/ ' #!4<"( @&%#6F%""(8 &*#$'(&%, @&(&'*4*#< 2%4*, #588* ($1%4<"6: '+;4,1(', 14, $(;(, >$()6 ()&*+('*$< @&(>"6. /&!#$*44, $( %#$< #4(?!$<#, ' ()F5G !1%G» ($*8 ?%, #. 85). C $( ?% '&%8,, "*&,15 # &*2!("*4<"68, 3#$'*4<1 '61%4,%$ ! (@&%1%4%""(% $'(&>%#/(%, 4!>"(#$"(%, >5'#$'%""( '6&*?%""(% "*>*4( ' 5#@%7"(8 (#5F%#$'4%"!! *.%&(8 '#%;( @(+"*'*$%4<"(;( */$*, #',+*""(;( # ($/&6$!%8 +*/("*: « 6 8(?%8 @&%1#$*'!$< #%)%, /*/ 86#4< *.%&* '#% #"('* #(@(#$*'4,%$ 1(#$5@"6% %. A*/$6 # "('(. $(>/(. +&%"!, ! #/(&%% >5'#$'5%$, >%8 @(+"*%$ !: #('8%#$!8(#$<. L$( )64* 2%""*, @(1;($('!$%4<"*, &*)($*, @(1;($('/* / @(+1"%.7%. #$&(;(. &*+&*)($/% $(;( ?% 8*$%&!*4*, @(#4% $(;( /*/ "*.1%"( )64( '6&*?%"!% 14, ()I%1!",GF%. !1%! ' A(&8*: #5F%#$'5GF%. "*5/!» ($*8 ?%, #. 26). V*$%8 5?% *.%& «'#$5@!4 !+ @%&!(1* $'(&>%#$'* ' @%&!(1 (A(&84%"!, #'(%. &*)($6» ($*8 ?%, #. 88). P*8 *.%& ' @(4"(. 8%&% #(+"*'*4 $'(&>%#/!. :*&*/$%& ! @&!"2!@!*4<"5G "('!+"5 #(1%&?*"!, ! !$(;(' #'(%. &*)($6. C (1"(8 !+ @!#%8 (" $*/ '6&*+!4 #(@5$#$'5GF%% %. #(#$(,"!%: «…X ' "%/($(&6% >*#6 >5'#$'('*4 #%), /*/ )6 '1(:"('4%""68, ! "! &*"<7%, "! @(+?% "!>%;( @(1()"(;(, "*#/(4*# # #!4(G ('4*1%4! 8"(G ! "*'%4! "* "('6% @&%18%$6» ($*8 ?%, #. 63). R*&,15 # *.%&(8 ! "%+*'!#!8( ($ "%;( +*/(" #(:&*"%"!, ! @&%'&*F%"!, E"%&;!! ()(#"('*4 ! +"*8%"!$6. "%8%2/!. %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4< =. =%4<8;(4<2 (1821–1894). L$($ 5>%"6. #6;&*4 '%#<8* '*?"5G &(4< ' &*+'!$!! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, '( '$(&(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/*. W;( 8"(;(;&*""*, "*5>"*, 1%,$%4<"(#$< (:'*$6'*4* &*+4!>"6% #A%&6 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, $(;( '&%8%"!. M&5; %;( "*5>"6: !"$%&%#(' )64 "%()6>*."( 7!&(/. M*/ ($8%>*4 !+'%#$"6. A!+!/ . D*5E, «=%4<8;(4<2 )64 >%4('%/(8, #@(#()"(#$! /($(&(;( @&(#$!&*4!#< ($ 8*$%8*$!/! >%&%+ A!+!/5 1( A!4(#(A!! ! 1(#$!;4! 1*?% 85+6/!» (198, #. 133). L$5 &*+"(#$(&(""(#$< "*5>"6: !"$%&%#(' =%4<8;(4<2*, @4(1($'(&"(#$< %;( 1%,$%4<"(#$! '( '#%8, / >%85 (" ()&*F*4#,, @(1>%&/!'*4 ! K.M. */#'%44: «C/4*1, #1%4*""6. =%4<8;(4<2%8 ' 8*$%8*$!/5, A!+!/5, A!+!(4(;!G, @#!:(4(;!G ! E#$%$!/5, :(&(7(
69
!+'%#$%" '#%8, +*"!8*GF!8#, E$!8! &*+4!>"68! @&%18%$*8!» (231, #. 174). L$5 5"!'%&#*4<"(#$< "*5>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! =%4<8;(4<2* +"*8%"!$6. &5##/!. A!+!/ 9.=. P$(4%$(' &*##8*$&!'*4 /*/ #5)I%/$!'"(%, ' /("/&%$"(8 >%4('%/% @4(1($'(&"( &%*4!+('*""(% @&(,'4%"!% ()I%/$!'"(;( %1!"#$'* '#%;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!, /*/ ()F%>%4('%>%#/(. #A%&6 @(+"*'*$%4<"(;( ($"(7%"!, / @&!&(1%. «P@%&'* @&*/$!>%#/!. '&*>, @($(8, @((>%&%1"(, @&(A%##(& *"*$(8!! ! @*$(4(;!!, A!+!(4(;!!, A!+!/!, – ;%"!*4<"6. A!+!(4(; ! A!+!/ # ;45)(/!8 A("1(8 8*$%8*$!>%#/!: @(+"*"!., – =%4<8;(4<2 ,'4,%$#,, @&%?1% '#%;(, @&%1#$*'!$%4%8 %1!"#$'* ! 2%4<"(#$! *1-*1-9!,"%"'(… B&!)*'!8, >$( ' "*7% '&%8,, '#4%1#$'!% (#()%""( )6#$&(;( &(#$* ($1%4<"6: >*#$%. %#$%#$'('%1%"!,, $*/*, 5"!'%&#*4<"(#$< – "% 1!4%$*"$*, "% /(8@!4,$(&*, * '117*5!9%-*7(, @&(4*;*GF%;( "('6% @5$!, – #$*4* 8"(;( $&51"%%, >%8 @(4'%/* $(85 "*+*1, ! /*+*4(#< )6, 1*4%/( "% @( #!4*8 (1"(. 4!>"(#$!» (344, #. 142). B&! E$(8 @4(1($'(&"(#$< "*5>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! =%4<8;(4<2* P$(4%$(' #',+6'*4 # &'7!1!&16': ! -9!$0*16':, /(&%",F%8#, ' !#/5##$'%, "*>*4(8 ' "%.. «R%()6>*."*, &*+"(#$(&(""(#$< E$(. A%"(8%"*4<"( (1*&%""(. "*$5&6, %;( ;45)(/(%, A!4(#(A#/(% ()&*+('*"!%, %;( ?!'(% >5$<% / @(E+!! ! !#/5##$'5, /( '#%85, >$( '(+'67*%$ ! /&*#!$ ?!+"<, – '#% E$( 1*%$ (#()6. /(4(&!$ "*5>"(85 $'(&>%#$'5 =%4<8;(4<2*, (#()6. '%# %;( #4('*8, 1*?% '"% 7!&(/(;( /&5;* %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/» ($*8 ?%, #. 143). H, "*/("%2, ' &*+"(#$(&(""%8 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 $'(&>%#$'% =%4<8;(4<2* P$(4%$(' '61%4,%$ (),+*$%4<"(% &*2!("*4<"(%, :.17'-*78"!* "*>*4( ! #5F%#$'%""6. 7'0"!1-".= *#@%/$: «=%4<8;(4<2 )64 ' &*'"(. 8%&% A!+!/, A!+!(4(; ! @#!:(4(;, – (" &*)($*4 ! @&(4*;*4 "('6% @5$! /*/ ' ()F%. "*5/% ( @&!&(1% ()I%/$%, $*/ ! ' "*5/% ( @&!&(1% >5'#$'5GF%. ! 86#4,F%., ( >%4('%/%, ()I%/$!'!&5GF%8 ! @(+"*GF%8 @&!&(15. W;( $'(&>%#$'( @&%1#$*'4,%$, $*/!8 ()&*+(8, 1'% #$(&("6. 3"! "%&*+&6'"( #',+*"6 %1!"#$'(8 4!>"(#$!, !#/*'7%. ! $'(&!'7%. "% #45>*."(, "% @( /*@&!+5, * ' ;%"%$!>%#/! #$&(;(. @(#4%1('*$%4<"(#$! 8674%"!,, "%5/4(""( "*@&*'4%""(;( / (1"(. '6#(/(. 2%4!» ($*8 ?%, #. 200). B&! '#%8 &*+"(()&*+!! #'(!: "*5>"6: !"$%&%#(' @&%1@(>$%"!% =%4<8;(4<2 ($1*'*4 '#% ?% A!+!/% ! #1%4*4 "%8*4( 14, 5#@%7"(;( &*+'!$!, E$(. "*5/!. B( 8"%"!G P$(4%$('*, !#$(&!, $'(&>%#$'* =%4<8;(4<2* ' ()4*#$! (#"('"6: $%>%"!. ()F%. A!+!/! «%#$< !#$(&!, A!+!/! +* @(#4%1"!% 50 4%$. C( '#%: /&*%5;(4<"6: '(@&(#*:, @&!/('6'*'7!: 586 @(#4%1"!: @(/(4%"!., '( '#%: #$&%84%"!,: "*5/! &*#7!&!$< #'(! ;(&!+("$6 !, ' $( ?% '&%8,, (>!#$!$<, ($&%+'!$< #%), /&!$!/(., 5>*#$!% =%4<8;(4<2* #$(!$ "* @%&'(8 @4*"%. C (1"!: +*1*>*: (" ,'4,%$#, ;4*'"68 !"!2!*$(&(8, ' 1&5;!: – 8(F"68 #(&*)($"!/(8, ' $&%$%&%+ '(#@!$*""6: ' %;( 7/(4% 5>%"!/('» ($*8 ?%, #. 201). M("/&%$!+!&5, #(1%&?*"!% A!+!>%#/!: !##4%1('*"!. =%4<8;(4<2*, . D*5E @!#*4: «P()#$'%""( A!+!/* +"*%$ =%4<8;(4<2* /*/ ($2* +*/("(' ()&*+('*"!, '!:&%., '6'(1 /($(&6: !+ ;!1&(1!"*8!/!
70
@&%1#$*'4,%$ #()(. 8*$%8*$!>%#/!. $&51 '6#7%;( &*";*, /*/ >%4('%/*, /($(&6. #$*&(85, "%#/(4%#/(8 #&(1#$'% 1*4 (#"('*""(% "* $%&8(1!"*8!/% /(4!>%#$'%""(% ()(#"('*"!%, /($(&6. #(+1*4 $%&8(1!"*8!/5 ;*4<'*"!>%#/!: E4%8%"$(', * ' 8%:*"!/% $%(&!G 2!/4!>%#/!: #!#$%8, @(/*+*' !: &(1#$'( ' &*+4!>"6: ,'4%"!,: !+ #*86: &*+"6: ()4*#$%. A!+!/!. R( "*8 (" @&%?1% '#%;( !+'%#$%" /*/ +*'%&7!$%4< 1(/*+*$%4<#$'* +*/("* #(:&*"%"!, E"%&;!!» (198, #. 134). C 1847 ;(15 =%4<8;(4<2 ' &*)($% «3 #(:&*"%"!! #!46» '6&*+!4 #'(% @("!8*"!% +*/("* #(:&*"%"!, ! @&%'&*F%"!, E"%&;!!, @&!>%8 (" @(7%4 +"*>!$%4<"( 1*4<7% *.%&*, «@(/*+*' @&!8%"%"!% E$(;( +*/("* 14, '#%: !+'%#$"6: ' $( '&%8, ()4*#$%. A!+!/!»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– @!#*4 */#'%44, – +*'!#!$ "% $(4"(#$! 5#$*"('4%"!, A*/$* ! 1*?% "% ($ +*8%>*$%4<"6: +*/4G>%"!., /($(&6% !+ "%;( 8(?"( '6'%#$!, "( ($ @4(1($'(&"(#$! 8%$(1(', (#"('*""6: "* E$(8 @&!"2!@%» (231, #. 177). H8%, ' '!15 &*)($5 =%4<8;(4<2* «3 #(:&*"%"!! #!46», */#'%44 ($8%>*4, >$( 14, $(;(, >$()6 @(4"(#$"(% +"*>%"!%, «"5?"( )64( )6 #@&(#!$< $%:, /(85 86 (),+*"6 '%4!>*.7!8! ($/&6$!,8! ' ()4*#$! $%&8(1!"*8!/! ! ' 1&5;!: ()4*#$,: #('&%8%""(. A!+!/!, #/(4!$6'*4! E$5 &*)($5 ! /*/ >*#$( '( '&%8, !+6#/*"!. '%#/!% 5$'%&?1%"!, =%4<8;(4<2* '(+1%.#$'('*4! "* !: 58, @(1()"( "%@&%()(&!8(. 1'!?5F%. #!4%» ($*8 ?%). B( 8"%"!G C. 3#$'*4<1*, "*+'*""*, &*)($* «()%#@%>!4* =%4<8;(4<25 )(4<7(% '4!,"!% "* 1*4<"%.7%% &*+'!$!% "*5/!, !)( (" @%&'6. !+8%&!4 ! "*8%$!4 '#% @(4% ()(+&!86: ' $( '&%8, @&!8%"%"!. (#"('"(;( +*/("*, $(;1* /*/ (#$*4<"6% !##4%1('*$%4! (;&*"!>!'*4!#< &*+&*)($/(. ($1%4<"6: ()4*#$%.» (290, #. 257). -*+I,#",, +"*>!8(#$< ! &*+4!>!% !##4%1('*"!. =%4<8;(4<2* ! *.%&* ' &*+&*)($/% !1%! #(:&*"%"!, E"%&;!!, 3#$'*4<1 @(1>%&/"54, >$(, «' @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$< / +*,'4%"!,8 *.%&*, /($(&6. '(()F% #>!$*4 ! !8%4 @&*'( #>!$*$< #%), @%&'68 $'(&2(8 E$(. !1%!, =%4<8;(4<2 @&%$%"1('*4 $(45 ' /4*##!>%#/! +*'%&7%""(. A(&8%» ($*8 ?%, #. 255–256). 3#"('"(% &*+4!>!% ' #@(#()*: ()(#"('*"!, !1%! 3#$'*4<1 5#8*$&!'*4 ' $(8, >$( « *.%& !#:(1!4 !+ +*/("* #(:&*"%"!, '%#* ! 8*##6, $( %#$< ;4*'"68 ()&*+(8 !+ :!8!>%#/!: *"*4(;!. !, @(E$(85, (" @("!8*4 «#!45», !4!
71
E"%&;!G, '(()F% 1;<1-%"+'!"%78"!; =%4<8;(4<2 ?% ()(#"('*4 '6'(1 "* )(4%% )4!+/!: %85 @( #/4*15 58* +*/("*: -*!$*-'0*16!= :*D%"'6'» ($*8 ?%, #. 256). B&! E$(8 3#$'*4<1 ()&*F*%$ '"!8*"!% "* #5F%#$'%""6. 8!&('(++&%">%#/!. *#@%/$, ()F!. 14, *.%&* ! =%4<8;(4<2*, *#@%/$, 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!. @( #'(%. A!4(#(A#/(. #5$!: «H (" (=%4<8;(4<2. – C.3.), /*/ ! *.%&, %F% /&%@/( @&!1%&?!'*%$#, 15*4!+8* :%-*$'( – 1'7%, :($, @&! E$(8 ! +*,'4,%$, >$( (1"* )%+ 1&5;(. "% !8%%$ 8%#$*. B&!+"*/(8 8*$%&!! (" #>!$*4 %% @&(#$&*"#$'%""5G (@&%1%4%""(#$< ! 8*##5, $(;1* /*/ 1&5;!% %% @&(,'4%"!, @("!8*4 /*/ #!46 !4! #'(.#$'* (>$(, @( %;( 8"%"!G, (1"( ! $( ?%). V1%#< (" ' $(>"(#$! #4%15%$ +* M*"$(8, /($(&6., ' #'(G (>%&%1<, @&!8/"54 / D(//5» ($*8 ?%). 3 A!4(#(A#/(. +"*>!8(#$! +*/("* #(:&*"%"!, ! @&%'&*F%"!, E"%&;!! !+'%#$"6. *";4!.#/!. A!+!/ K. J!"1*4< @!#*4 ' 1874 ;(15: «C "*7% '&%8, 1(74! 1( '%4!/!: ()()F%"!.», #&%1! "!: (#()%""( ()7!&"(% ! ;45)(/(% '4!,"!% !8%%$ «5>%"!% ( #(:&*"%"!! E"%&;!!, /("%>"6% A!4(#(A#/!% '6'(16 /($(&(;( %F% "% @&%1#$*'4,G$#, # @(4"(G ,#"(#$"(;( A!4(#(A#/(;( '6'(1* !+ +*/("* @&%14(?!4 L";%4<#: «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» (406, #. 540). L$($ '6'(1 ' @(4"(. 8%&% #(;4*#5%$#, # @("!8*"!%8 #5$! +*/("* %;( @%&'(($/&6'*$%4,8!. J*/, ($8%$!' /("/&%$"6% A*/$6, 5#$*"('4%"!% /($(&6: @&%17%#$'('*4( %;( ($/&6$!G, =%4<8;(4<2 @!7%$ 1*4%%: «R('*, A!+!/* #58%4* @&!1*$< E$!8 A*/$*8 '#%()F%% +"*>%"!%, #1%4*$< !: @&!4(?!868! /( '#%. #('(/5@"(#$! @&(2%##(' @&!&(16 ! "%+*'!#!868! ($ (#()%""6: !"$%&%#(' ! #$&%84%"!. 4G1%.. 3"! #()&*"6 '( '#%()I%84GF%8 +*/("% 1!D$%"*"'( 1'7.» (110, #. 173). C( '$(&(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/* ' &*+'!$!! $%&8(1!"*8!/! '#] ($>]$4!'%% #$*4( @&(,'4,$<#, "('(% "*@&*'4%"!%, (#"('*""(% "* @&("!/"('%"!! ' "%] %-!:'1-'0*16'D @&%1#$*'4%"!. ! #',+*""6: # "!8! #$*$!#$!>%#/!: @(",$!.. L$* $%"1%"2!, '(+()4*1*4*, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' /!"%$!>%#/(. $%(&!! ;*+('. C%#(86. '/4*1 ' %] &*+'!$!% '"%# (1!" !+ '%4!>*.7!: A!+!/(' XIX '%/*, *";4!.#/!. 5>]"6. K.M. */#'%44 (1831– 1879). K( "%;( /!"%$!>%#/5G $%(&!G ;*+(' 5#@%7"( &*+'!'*4! $*/!% 5>]"6%, /*/ K?(54<, M&%"!";, M4*5+!5# ! 1&. 3"! !#:(1!4! !+ $(;(, >$( 1*'4%"!% ! $%@4( /*/(;(-4!)( ;*+*, ()5#4('4!'*G$#, )6#$&68! @%&%8%F%"!,8! ($1%4<"6:, )%#@(&,1(>"( 1'!?5F!:#, 8(4%/54, !: #$(4/"('%"!,8! 8%?15 #()(. ! #( #$%"/*8! #(#51*. M '6'(1*8 E$!: 5>]"6:, /*#*GF!8#, #',+! 8%?15 #&%1"%. #/(&(#$
72
1*'4%"!%8 ! 51%4<"(. $%@4($(. ;*+(', */#'%44 1()*'!4 %F] (1!", «#'(%()&*+"6., #5F%#$'%""6. ! 1*4%/( !15F!.» (303, #. 172). 3" +*158*4#, "*1 '(@&(#(8 ( '%4!>!"% #/(&(#$! ($1%4<"(., @&(!+'(4<"( '+,$(. 8(4%/546, ! ($'%$ "* E$($ '(@&(#, @( 8"%"!G . B4*"/*, «#$*4 (#"('(. "('(. ($&*#4! "*5/! – #$*$!#$!>%#/(. A!+!/!» ($*8 ?%). P$*$!#$!>%#/!. :*&*/$%& E$(;( "('(;( &*+1%4* 8%:*"!/! ()5#4('4!'*%$#, $%8, >$( ($'%$ "* "*+'*""6. '67% '(@&(# 8(; )6$< @(45>%" $(4*% $*/(;( +*/("*, /($(&6. 5#$*"*'4!'*%$ @(#4% 8"(;(/&*$"6: @('$(&%"!. (1"(. ! $(. ?% (@%&*2!!, #/(4*#$( >!#4( !: !+8%",%$#,, – @!#*4 */#'%44, – $(, $*/ /*/ /*?1*, 8(4%/54* ' #&%1"%8 51*&,%$ ' #$%"/! #(#51* (1!"*/('(% >!#4( &*+, #(()F*4 !8@54<#6 (1!"*/('(. '%4!>!"6, /*?1*, )51%$ '"(#!$< (1!"*/('5G 1(4G ()F%;( 1*'4%"!,. P4%1('*$%4<"(, 1*'4%"!% ' #(#51% 1*""6: &*+8%&(' @&(@(&2!("*4<"( >!#45 8(4%/54 ' "]8, $( %#$< /(4!>%#$'5 #(1%&?*F%;(#, ' "]8 ;*+*» (231, #. 75–76). B&! 5'%4!>%"!! #/(&(#$! 8(4%/54 /*?1*, !+ "!: )51%$ 51*&,$< ' #$%"/! #(#51* «)(4<7%% >!#4( &*+ ' #%/5"15, !, /&(8% $(;(, !8@54<# /*?1(;( 51*&* )51%$ $*/?% '(+&*#$*$< ' $(. ?% #*8(. @&(@(&2!!, $*/ >$( 1(4, 1*'4%"!,, '"(#!8*, /*?1(. 8(4%/54(., )51%$ !+8%",$<#, /*/ /'*1&*$ #/(&(#$!. R( 5'%4!>%"!% #/(&(#$! #(($'%$#$'5%$, @( "*7%. $%(&!!, '(+&*#$*"!G $%8@%&*$5&6, ! $*/!8 @5$]8 86 8(?%8 ()I,#"!$< 1%.#$'!% "*;&%'*"!, ;*+*». */#'%44 5#$*"('!4 $*/?%, >$( @&(!#:(1!$, /(;1* 8(4%/546 &*+4!>"6: 8*## #$*4/!'*G$#, 1&5; # 1&5;(8: «Q(4<7!% 8*##6 )515$ 1'!;*$<#, 8%14%""%% 8%"<7!:, $*/ >$(, ' #&%1"%8, /*?1*, 8(4%/54*, )(4<7*, !4! 8*4*,, )51%$ !8%$< $5 ?% E"%&;!G 1'!?%"!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 76). V*/(" &*#@&%1%4%"!, #/(&(#$%. */#'%44*, @( 8"%"!G D*5E, «)(4<7% 5;*1*""6. @(#4%1"!8, >%8 $%(&%$!>%#/! ()(#"('*""6.» (198, #. 130), &*+'!4, 5$(>"!4 ! $%(&%$!>%#/! ()(#"('*4 '61*GF!.#, *'#$&!.#/!. 5>]"6. D. Q(4<28*" (1844–1906). U*&*/$%&!+5, "*5>"5G 1%,$%4<"(#$< Q(4<28*"*, D*5E @!#*4, >$( (" «)64 A!+!/(8, !, "%#8($&, "* "%/($(&6% '%#<8* +"*>!$%4<"6% E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"6% &*)($6, $%(&%$!/(8 @( '4%>%"!G ! :*&*/$%&5 1%,$%4<"(#$!, # #!4<"( '6&*?%""68 A!4(#(A#/!8 5/4("(8» ($*8 ?%, #. 129). Q(4<28*" @4(1($'(&"( &*)($*4 ' &*+4!>"6: ()4*#$,: A!+!/!, "( "*!)(4<7!. '/4*1 ' &*+'!$!% E$(. "*5/! (" '"]# #'(!8! !##4%1('*"!,8! ' ()4*#$! #$*$!#$!>%#/(. A!+!/!. 3" ! ,'!4#, %] @(14!""68 #(+1*$%4%8, @%&%'%1, $%8 #*868 $%&8(1!"*8!/5 ' /*>%#$'%""( "('(% &5#4( – ' &5#4( *$(8!#$!/!. L$( ' @(4"(. 8%&% @&(,'!4(#< ' ()I,#"%"!! Q(4<28*"(8 '$(&(;( "*>*4* $%&8(1!"*8!/!, ()I,#"%"!!, (#"('5 /($(&(;( '@%&'6% #(#$*'!4! *$(8!#$!>%#/!% @&%1#$*'4%"!,. M*#*,#< E$(;( '(@&(#*, . B4*"/ @!#*4, >$( «4!7< Q(4<28*"5 '@%&'6% 51*4(#<, ''%1,
73
*$(8!#$!>%#/!% @&%1#$*'4%"!,, 5#$*"('!$< ;45)(/!% (#"('6 #(1%&?*"!, '$(&(;( "*>*4* ! '8%#$% # $%8 '#%. #('(/5@"(#$! "%()&*$!86: @&(2%##(', #'(%()&*+!% /($(&6: @&%1#$*'4,4( "%@&%(1(4!86% $&51"(#$! 14, ()F%;( 1!"*8!>%#/(;( ()I,#"%"!,» (303, #. 106). 9 8%?15 $%8 ''%1%"!% ' $%&8(1!"*8!/5 *$(8!#$!>%#/!: @&%1#$*'4%"!. @("*>*45 )64( #(@&,?%"( #( +"*>!$%4<"68! $&51"(#$,8!, 8"(;!% ()F!% @(4(?%"!, $%&8(1!"*8!/! ' $( '&%8, # $&51(8 ! 4!7< @&!)4!?]""( 8(;4! '6'(1!$<#, @(#&%1#$'(8 *$(8!#$!>%#/!: @&%1#$*'4%"!., >$( @(&(?1*4( "%/($(&(% "%1('%&!% >*#$! 5>]"6: @( ($"(7%"!G / *$(8!#$!/%. «B($&%)('*4#, ;45)(/!. *"*4!+ ! "%@&%/4(""6. "*5>"6. (@$!8!+8 DG1'!;* Q(4<28*"* 14, $(;(, >$()6 "% $(4*4(8 $%&8(1!"*8!/!, "( 1*?% ()I,#"!$< (#"('"5G !1%G '$(&(;( "*>*4* @&! @(8(F! *$(8!#$!/!»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n (#&%1"!. 4(;*&!A8 A5"/2!! &*#@&%1%4%"!,), '6>!#4,%8*, !+ &*#@&%1%4%"!, #/(&(#$%. 8(4%/54 ;*+*, 8(?%$, @&! @&%1@(#64/% 8(4%/54,&"(;( )%#@(&,1/*, !+8%",$<#, $(4/* '%4!>*.7%;( 1(#$!?%"!, Q(4<28*"*, ()%##8%&$!'7%;( %;( !8,, '#/&6$!% #',+! 8%?15 E"$&(@!%.… ! $%&8(1!"*8!>%#/(. '%&(,$"(#$$( '#% @&(!#:(1,F%% ' 8!&% %#$< @%&%:(1 ($ 8*4('%&(,$"(;( "*>*4<"(;( #(#$(,"!, / )(4%% '%&(,$"(85 /("%>"(85 #(#$(,"!G»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«R( /*/ &*+ $% A(&86 E"%&;!!, /($(&6% 86 ?%4*%8
74
&%*4!+('*$< @&*/$!>%#/!, – @(,#",%$ Q(4<28*", – ,'4,G$#, #*868! "%'%&(,$"68!» (35, #. 12). J(47% #/*+*$<, E$( E"%&;!,, &*#@&%1%4!'7*,#, 8%?15 8(4%/54*8! #*868 '%&(,$"68 ()&*+(8. (?"( 8*$%8*$!>%#/! (@&%1%4!$< #$%@%"< '%&(,$"(#$! /*?1(;( &*#@&%1%4%"!, E"%&;!!. M(4!>%#$'%""( (@&%1%4,%8*, '%&(,$"(#$<, #(($'%$#$'5GF*, /*?1(85 &*#@&%1%4%"!G E"%&;!!, – E$( ! %#$< E"$&(@!,. B&! '#%: !+8%"%"!,:, /($(&6% @&(!#:(1,$ #*8! #()(., E"$&(@!, 5'%4!>!'*%$#,. «R*@&($!', E"$&(@!, )51%$ 58%"<7*$<#, $(4*%, %#4! @&! E$(8 E"$&(@!, 1&5;(;( $%4* 5'%4!>!'*%$#, "* #$(4%4('%/* ! '8%#$% # $%8 '(+'67%"!% '$(&(;( "*>*4* $%&8(1!"*8!/! 1( #$%@%"! &%*4<"(;( @&!"2!@* ,'4,%$#, ;4*'"68 &%+54<$*$(8 "*5>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! DG1'!;* Q(4<28*"*. 3" #(#$(!$ ' $(8, >$( @(",$!% E"$&(@!! @(4"(#$!$%4<"68! 1(#$!?%"!,8! ' #A%&% !+5>%"!, E4%/$&!>%#$'* ! 8*;"%$!+8*. M /("25 XVIII '%/* (@&%1%4!4!#< @%&'6% @&%1#$*'4%"!, ( @&!&(1% E4%/$&!>%#$'*, )64! !##4%1('*"6 '*?"%.7!% ,'4%"!, E4%/$&(#$*$!/!. P "*>*4* XIX '%/* 2%"$& !+5>%"!, E4%/$&!>%#$'* @%&%"(#!$#, "* E4%/$&!>%#/!. $(/. P('%&7%"#$'('*"!% E4%/$&(1!"*8!/!, )(4<7% $(;( – '#$5@4%"!% %] ' /*>%#$'%""( "('6. E$*@ &*+'!$!, #',+*"( # !##4%1('*"!,8! ! )4%#$,F!8! ($/&6$!,8! '%4!/(;( *";4!.#/(;( 5>]"(;( . 0*&*1%, (1791–1867). «3" @(#$*'!4 #%)% +*1*>%. !##4%1('*$< A*/$6, !1%! ! "*5>"5G $%&8!"(4(;!G E4%/$&(8*;"%$!+8* ! ' &%+54<$*$% @%&%#$&(!4 E$5 ($&*#4< "*5/! @( #('%&7%""( "('(85 8%$(15» (231, #. 68). -*#/&6'*, ()F!% @&!"2!@6 "*5>"(. &*)($6 ' $(. %] A(&8%, /*/5G @&!1*4 %. 0*&*1%., */#'%44 @!#*4: « 6 "*:(1!8 5 "%;( #"*>*4* $F*$%4<"(% "*)4G1%"!% !+)&*""6: ,'4%"!., +*$%8 !##4%1('*"!% @(45>!'7!:#, ' &%+54<$*$% %;( @&%1#$*'4%"!. ! ()&*+('*"!%, ' #45>*% "%():(1!8(#$!, "('6: @(",$!. ! +*$%8, "*/("%2, !+()&%$%"!% "*5>"6: $%&8!"(', @&!#@(#()4%""6: 14, ()#5?1%"!, ,'4%"!. ' #'%$% "('6: !1%.» ($*8 ?%, #. 68–69). B&! E$(8 14, 0*&*1%, )64! :*&*/$%&"6 #*8(#$(,$%4<"(#$< ! (&!;!"*4<"(#$< 8674%"!,, "%+*'!#!8(#$< ($ 5#$(,'7!:#, 8"%"!.. H+'%#$"6. &5##/!. A!+!/ J.B. M&*'%2 @!#*4 ( "]8: «0*&*1%., ;%"!*4<"6. #*8(5>/*, "% $*/ 4%;/(, /*/ %;( #'%&#$"!/!, 2%:('6% 5>%"6%, @(11*'*4#, ;!@"(+5 >5?(;( *'$(&!$%$* ! @&!'6>"6: '(++&%"!.. 3" '6&*)($*4 #%)% #()#$'%""6% '(++&%"!,, – ! ("! )64! &%'(4G2!(""6» (184, #. 176).
75
C #'(%. "%@(#&%1#$'%""(. !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! 0*&*1%. &5/('(1#$'('*4#, ()F!8!, A!4(#(A#/!8! @( #5$! (#"('(@(4(?%"!,8!. 31"( !+ ;4*'"6: #&%1! "!: – 5)%?1%"!% ' %1!"#$'% #!4 @&!&(16. J*/, @( #'!1%$%4<#$'5 C. 3#$'*4<1*, «5?% ' 4%/2!,:, >!$*""6: !8 ' A!4(#(A#/(8 ()F%#$'% 24 4%$ ($ &(15, '#$&%>*G$#, 8%#$*, ;1% (" (0*&*1%.. – C.3.) &*##8*$&!'*%$ %1!"#$'( 8*$%&!! ! #!4, /*/ +*/4G>!$%4<"6. &%+54<$*$ "*5/!» (290, #. 127). P*8 0*&*1%. ' 1837 ;(15 ' #'(%. 4*)(&*$(&"(. /"!;% +*@!#*4: «R5?"( #&*'"!$< /(4!>%#$'( 8*$%&!*4<"6: #!4, $( %#$< #!4 E4%/$&!>%#$'*, $,;($%"!,, :!8!>%#/(;( #&(1#$'*, #2%@4%"!, ! $.@. !, ;1% '(+8(?"(, 1*$< '6&*?%"!, 14, !: E/'!'*4%"$(' ' $(. !4! !"(. A(&8%». =(1 #@5#$, 0*&*1%. 1*%$ #4%15GF5G ()()F%""5G, A!4(#(A#/5G A(&854!&('/5 5/*+*""(;( @&!"2!@*: «P!4* "!/(;1* "% &*+&57*%$#,; '#% 1%.#$'!, @&%'&*$!86 (1"( ' 1&5;(%». M 1840 ;(15 ($"(#!$#, $*/*, +*@!#<: «R( #!4* "!/(;1* "% '(+"!/*%$ )%+ #(($'%$#$'5GF%;( &*#:(1* $(;(, >$( %% @(&(?1*%$». B( 8"%"!G 3#$'*4<1*, «E$! '(++&%"!, +"*>!$%4<"( 5/&%@!4!#< @(#4% $(;(, /*/ %85 (0*&*1%G. – C.3.) 51*4(#< @(+"*$< '4!,"!% 8*;"!$* "* @(4,&!+('*""6. #'%$. P$*$<,, "*@!#*""*, @( E$(85 @('(15 ' 1845 ;(15, "*>!"*%$#, #4%15GF!8! #4('*8!: «O 8%", 1*'"( )64( @&%1@(4(?%"!%, 8*4(-@(8*45 &*+'!'7%%#, @(>$! ' 5)%?1%"!%, @&%1@(4(?%"!%, &*+1%4,%8(%, , @(4*;*G, 8"(;!8! 1&5;!8! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8!, >$( &*+4!>"6% A(&86, ' /($(&6: @&(,'4,G$#, #!46 8*$%&!!, !8%G$ ()F%% @&(!#:(?1%"!%. H4!, 1&5;!8! #4('*8!, ("! "*:(1,$#, ' #$(4< "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 ($"(7%"!! ! $*/ #',+*"6 8%?15 #()(., >$(, $*/ #/*+*$<, @&%'&*$!86 (1"* ' 1&5;5G ! ' #'(%8 1%.#$'!! ()4*1*G$ E/'!'*4%"$*8! #!46» ($*8 ?%, #. 128). L$( @&%1@(4(?%"!% 0*&*1%, '#/(&% 5)%1!$%4<"( @(1$'%&1!4 *.%&, ($/&6' ! ()(#"('*' +*/(" #(:&*"%"!, ! @&%'&*F%"!, E"%&;!!. H @($(85 3#$'*4<1 # @(4"68 (#"('*"!%8 #1%4*4 '6'(1 ( $(8, >$( «0*&*1%. ,'4,%$#, @&('(+'%#$"!/(8 +*/("* #(:&*"%"!, E"%&;!! ! '#%()F%. ()&*$!8(#$! %% A(&8»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«!8%4( 14, "*5/! '%4!>*.75G 2%""(#$<, $*/ /*/ 1*'*4( @(4"(% 1!"*8!>%#/(% 1(/*+*$%4<#$'( $(;(, >$(, ;1% )6 "! #5F%#$'('*4! 8*;"!$"6% #!46, $*8 %#$< 8*$%&!,, 8*46% >*#$!26 /($(&(. '&*F*G$#, '(/&5; (#%., @*&*44%4<"6: "*@&*'4%"!G E$(. #!46» (231, #. 214). 3#"('6'*,#< "* !1%% %1!"#$'* #!4 @&!&(16, 0*&*1%. +*1*4#, 2%4%#$'(8 ! 8*;"%$!+8(8, E4%/$&!>%#$'(8 !
76
:!8!>%#/!8! @&(2%##*8!, 8*;"%$!+8(8 ! #'%$(8. H E$( %85 51*4(#<. M*/ @(1>%&/"54 */#'%44, «0*&*1%. ,'4,%$#, ! "*'#%;1* (#$*"%$#, $'(&2(8 $(;( ()F%;( 5>%"!, () E4%/$&(8*;"%$!+8%, /($(&(% &*##8*$&!'*%$ # %1!"(. $(>/! +&%"!, '#% ,'4%"!,, !+5>*'7!%#, @&%?1% ' ($1%4<"(#$!, "% ;('(&, 5?% ( $%: ,'4%"!,:, /($(&6% ($/&64 #*8 0*&*1%., #4%15, #'(%85 5)%?1%"!G ( %1!"#$'% '#%. "*5/!» ($*8 ?%, #. 67). V1%#< (#()%""( #5F%#$'%""( $(, >$( 0*&*1%. ()(#"('*4 @&!"2!@!*4<"( "('6 '+;4,1 "* E4%/$&!>%#/!% ,'4%"!,. B( #4('*8 . B4*"/*, «@%&'!>"5G #5F"(#$< E$!: ,'4%"!. (" '!1%4 "% ' E4%/$&!>%#/!: +*&,1*:, * ' E4%/$&!>%#/!: #!4('6: 4!"!,:, /($(&6% !15$ ($ (1"(;( +*&,?%""(;( $%4* / 1&5;(85 ! /($(&68 #(($'%$#$'5G$ !+'%#$"6% 8%:*"!>%#/!% "*@&,?%"!, ' @&(8%?5$(>"(. #&%1%. R%@(#&%1#$'%""(% 1%.#$'!% "* &*##$(,"!! +1%#< #('%&7%""( !#/4G>%"(» (303, #. 117). J*/(. @&(8%?5$(>"(. #&%1(. 14, 0*&*1%, ,'4,%$#, E4%/$&!>%#/(% !4! 8*;"!$"(% @(4%. 3"( &*##8*$&!'*%$#, !8, @( #4('*8 D*5E, «/*/ !+8%"%"!% A!+!>%#/(;( #(#$(,"!, #!#$%86, /($(&(% ' #'(%. #5F%#$'%""(. >*#$! 4(/*4!+('*"( ' 1!E4%/$&!/% !4! 1*?% ' @5#$(8 @&(#$&*"#$'% 8%?15 8*;"!$*8!» (198, #. 179). B(4% 0*&*1%. @("!8*4 /*/ &%*4<"6. ()I%/$, ' /($(&(8 @&(!#:(1,$ A!+!>%#/!% @&(2%##6. H8%""( @(#4% 0*&*1%, A!+!/!, @( 8"%"!G 9. L."7$%."*, #$*4! &*##8*$&!'*$< E4%/$&(8*;"!$"(% @(4% «/*/ @(#4%1"!., "% #'(1!86. "! / >%85 1&5;(85, #$&5/$5&"6. E4%8%"$ A!+!>%#/(. &%*4<"(#$!» (403, c. 86). -*)($6 0*&*1%, )4%#$,F% @&(1(4?!4 %;( +"*8%"!$6. #(($%>%#$'%""!/ K.M. */#'%44. 3 %;( "*5>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! 5?% ;('(&!4(#< ' #',+! # &*+'!$!%8 $%&8(1!"*8!/!, ! ' >*#$"(#$!, – /!"%$!>%#/(. $%(&!! ;*+('. R( "*!)(4<7!. '/4*1 ' "*5/5 */#'%44 '"]# #'(!8! !##4%1('*"!,8! ' ()4*#$! E4%/$&(1!"*8!/!. «W#4! ' /!"%$!>%#/(. $%(&!! ;*+(', – @!#*4 . B4*"/, – */#'%44 '6#$5@*%$ /*/ '(?1<, :($, ! 1%4!$ E$5 &(4< # "%/($(&68! 1&5;!8! !##4%1('*$%4,8!, $( ' 5>%"!! () E4%/$&!>%#$'% %;( ;%"!. @&%1#$*]$ @%&%1 "*8! ' #'(]8 @(4"(8 '%4!>!!. H8%""( ' E$(. ()4*#$!… "* 1(4G */#'%44* '6@*4 $*/(. 5#@%:, /($(&6. 86 1(4?"6 @&!>!#4!$< / "*!)(4%% 51!'!$%4<"68 1%,"!,8 >%4('%>%#/(;( 15:*» (303, #. 177). */#'%44 @&(1'!"54 E4%/$&(1!"*8!/5 1*4%/( '@%&]1 ($ $(;( &5)%?*, "* /($(&(8 (#$*"('!4#, 0*&*1%.. R( +*#45;* */#'%44*, /("%>"(, "% $(4$( (" @&(1(4?!4 1%4(, "*>*$(% 0*&*1%%8, – :($, E$( #*8( @( #%)% 1(#$*$(>"( '*?"(. */#'%44 @(7]4 +"*>!$%4<"( 1*4<7%, (" #5F%#$'%""( &*+'!4 !1%! 0*&*1%,, ()()F!4 !: ' #$&(."5G "*5>"5G $%(&!G – $%(&!G E4%/$&(8*;"!$"(;( @(4, – ! $%8 '"]# "%(2%"!86. '/4*1 ' "*5/5. . B4*"/ ($8%$!4 ' #',+! # E$!8, >$( « */#'%44 ' #'(%. #8%4(. A*"$*+!! ! 8*$%8*$!>%#/(. @&("!2*$%4<"(#$! @(7]4 1*4<7% 0*&*1%,; (" ! 5$(>"!4 ! ()()F!4 %;( !1%!, #(+1*' $%(&!G, /($(&5G "% $(4%#$'* ! 8*;"%$!+8*, "( /($(&*, "*8"(;( @&%'+(74* E$! $%(&!! #'(!8! 5#@%:*8!» ($*8 ?%). -%+54<$*$6 #'(!: !##4%1('*"!. */#'%44 ()()F!4 ' +"*8%"!$(8 $&51% «J&*/$*$ @( E4%/$&!>%#$'5 ! 8*;"%$!+85» (1873). -%7*GF!8 14,
77
'#%. /("2%@2!! */#'%44* ' %] A!+!>%#/(8 #(1%&?*"!! ,'4,%$#, '6&*?%"!% 14, E"%&;!! @(4,, '6'%1%""(% !8 !+ A*&*1%%'#/!: ()()F%"!. ,'4%"!. E4%/$&(#$*$!/! ! E4%/$&(1!"*8!/!. L$! ()()F%"!, ($"(#,$#, / @&(2%##5 !"15/2!!: %#4! ' E4%/$&!>%#/(% @(4% ''(1!$#, @&('(1"!/, $( ' "]8 @&(!#:(1!$ #8%F%"!% E4%/$&!>%#/!: +*&,1(', ' &%+54<$*$% @(,'4,G$#, !"152!&('*""6% "* %;( @('%&:"(#$! +*&,16. */#'%44 &*#@&(#$&*",%$ E$($ @&(2%## ! "* #45>*. >!#$(;( EA!&*. K4, %;( :*&*/$%&!#$!/! ''(1!$#, '%/$(&"*, '%4!>!"* – #8%F%"!%; ("* !+8%&,%$#, /(4!>%#$'(8 E4%/$&!>%#$'*, /($(&(% #8%F*%$#, >%&%+ %1!"!25 @4(F*1!, @%&@%"1!/54,&"(. #!4('68 4!"!,8 @(4,. H+8%"%"!% E$(. '%4!>!"6 '( '&%8%"! @("!8*4(#< */#'%44(8 /*/ $(/; (", /*/ ! $(/ @&('(1!8(#$!, @&(!+'(1!$ 8*;"!$"6% 1%.#$'!,. J%8 #*868 «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«'6#/*+*4 #8%45G !1%G, >$( #*8 2'%$ – E$( "% >$( !"(%, /*/ E4%/$&!>%#/!% '(4"6, * "%, /*/ @&%1@(4*;*4! &*"<7%, 5@&5;!% '(4"6 ' ;!@($%$!>%#/(. #&%1%, 8!&('(8 EA!&%, ''%1]""(8 ad hoc 14, ()I,#"%"!, &*#@&(#$&*"%"!, #'%$*» (198, #. 298). 3@$!>%#/!% #'(.#$'* #&%16 #',+*"6 # %] E4%/$&(8*;"!$"68! #'(.#$'*8!. */#'%44 #1%4*4 $*/?% '*?"6. '6'(1 ( $(8, >$( E4%/$&(8*;"!$"*, '(4"* 1(4?"* 1*'!$< "* @&('(1,F5G @('%&:"(#$<. C #(+1*"!! $%(&!! E4%/$&(8*;"!$"(;( @(4, "* 1(4G */#'%44*, @( #4('*8 . B4*"/*, «'6@*4 $*/(. 5#@%:, /($(&6. 86 1(4?"6 @&!>!#4!$< / "*!)(4%% 51!'!$%4<"68 1%,"!,8 >%4('%>%#/(;( 15:*. W85 51*4(#<
78
'68*"!$< 5 @&!&(16 ' &%+54<$*$% (1"(;( 4!7< >!#$(;( 8674%"!, $*/!% $*."6, /($(&6% 4!7< #@5#$, 2%4(% @(/(4%"!% ! 4!7< >*#$!>"( 51*4(#< @(/*+*$< ' (#$&(58"6: ! $&51(]8/!: (@6$*:» (303, #. 177). J%8 "% 8%"%%, !4!, 45>7% #/*+*$<, – !8%""( @(E$(85 !1%! */#'%44* 1*4%/( "% #&*+5 @(45>!4! '#%()F%% @&!+"*"!% ' "*5/%. H "% 851&%"(, 5? (>%"< #!4<"( &*#:(1!4!#< ("! # 5#$(,'7!8!#,, #$*'7!8! @&!'6>"68! ! @($(85 /*+*'7!8!#, %1!"#$'%""( '%&"68! @&%1#$*'4%"!,8! $(;( '&%8%"!. M*/ ($8%$!4 @(+1"%% 9. L."7$%.", «A!+!/*8 @("*1()!4(#< "%#/(4$()6 @(",$< '#] +"*>%"!% ($/&6$!, */#'%44*, "*#$(4(/ '@%&]1 @( #&*'"%"!G # /("2%@2!,8! %;( #('&%8%""!/('» (403, #. 232). R( 14, $%:, /$( @(",4 #5F"(#$< !1%. */#'%44*, ' @(4"(. 8%&% (F5$!4 !: "('!+"5, /$( @&("!/#, 15:(8 "('(;( '+;4,1* "* @&!&(15, – 14, "!: (#(+"*"!% E$!: !1%. #$*4( (1"!8 !+ #!4<"%.7!: '@%>*$4%"!. ?!+"!, #5F%#$'%""( @('4!,' "* !: 8674%"!%, #$*' 8(;5>!8 #$!854(8 !: #()#$'%""(;( @(!#/* /4G>%. / $*."*8 @&!&(16. . D*5E, '#@(8!"*, #'(! #$51%">%#/!% ;(16 ! @%&'(% +"*/(8#$'( # $%(&!%. E4%/$&!>%#$'* ! 8*;"%$!+8* */#'%44*, @!#*4: « "%, /*/ ! 8"(;!8 1&5;!8, E$* $%(&!, ($/&64* "('6. 8!&. B("!8*"!% $(;(, /*/ #4(?"%.7!% &*+"(()&*+"6% ,'4%"!, 8*$%8*$!>%#/! #'(1,$#, / $*/!8 @&(#$68 ! ;*&8("!>%#/! @&%/&*#"68 5&*'"%"!,8 */#'%44*, ,'4,%$#, (1"!8 !+ #!4<"%.7!: @%&%?!'*"!., /($(&6% 1(#$5@"6 >%4('%/5» (198, #. 12). =.9. D(&%"2, (1!" !+ #*86: '61*GF!:#, @&(1(4?*$%4%. 1%4* */#'%44*, @!#*4: «J&*/$*$ () E4%/$&!>%#$'% ! 8*;"%$!+8%» @&(!+']4 "* 8%",, @(?*45., (1"( !+ #*86: #!4<"6: '@%>*$4%"!. ' ?!+"!; $(4/('*"!% #'%$* /*/ E4%/$&(8*;"!$"(;( ,'4%"!, @( #'(%. #8%4(#$! @&%'+(74( '#], >$( , 1( #!: @(& +"*4» (219, #. 175). J%(&!, */#'%44* !8%4* !#/4G>!$%4<"( '*?"(% +"*>%"!% "% $(4%&/!'*4 ' #',+! # E$!8, >$( «$%(&!, */#'%44* "% @%&%#$*4* !#@(4<+('*$<#, ' /*>%#$'% "*@&*'4,GF%;( "*>*4* ! "* @(+1"%.7%. #$*1!! &*+'!$!, *$(8"(. $%(&!!» (37, #. 73). R* @&!8%&% $%(&!! */#'%44* (#()%""( "*;4,1"( 8(?"( @&(#4%1!$<, /*/ %F% ' XIX '%/% "*+&%'*4 @%&%'(&($, #',+*""6. # @%&%#8($&(8 8%#$* /4*##!>%#/(. 8%:*"!/! ' #!#$%8% @(+"*"!, @&!&(16, – @%&%'(&($, @&!'%17!. ' /("%>"(8 !$(;% / '(+"!/"('%"!G $%(&!! ($"(#!$%4<"(#$! ! /'*"$('(. $%(&!!. P*8 */#'%44 ' 2%4(8 (#$*'*4#, %F% "* @(+!2!,: /4*##!>%#/(. 8%:*"!/!. 3" !#$(4/('6'*4 #'(! 5&*'"%"!, "* (#"('% 8%:*"!>%#/(. *"*4(;!!, (@!&*,#< "* 8%:*"!>%#/!% 8(1%4!. 3" @%&'68 @&!8%"!4 *@@*&*$ 8%:*"!/! D*;&*"?* / E4%/$&(8*;"!$"68 @&(2%##*8. R( '8%#$% # $%8 */#'%44 5?% ' @(4"(. 8%&% (#(+"*'*4, >$( %;( 5&*'"%"!, '6&*?*G$ +*/("6 @&!"2!@!*4<"( "('(. ()4*#$! A!+!>%#/!: @&(2%##(' – $*/!:, /($(&6% "% 8(;5$ )6$< 2%4!/(8 #'%1%"6 / 8%:*"!/%. */#'%44 @("!8*4, >$( '"5$&%""!% '+*!8(#',+! E$(. ()4*#$! «+"*>!$%4<"( )(4%%
79
8"(;(>!#4%""6 ! #4(?"6, >%8 4G)(. 1( #!: @(& &*+&*)($*""(. "*5>"(. 1!#2!@4!"6». L4%/$&(8*;"!$"6% @&(2%##6 '"%7"!8 ()&*+(8 #',+*"6 ! # :!8!%., * E$(, /*/ #>!$*4 */#'%44, 5/*+6'*%$ "* (#()5G '*?"(#$< "*5/! () E4%/$&!>%#$'%, «/*/ "*5/!, @(8(;*GF%. ()I,#"!$< @&!&(15». «H#:(1, !+ E$(;(, 8"% @&%1#$*'4,%$#,, – @!#*4 */#'%44, – >$( !+5>%"!% 8*;"%$!+8* '( '#%: %;( @&(,'4%"!,: /*/ #&%1#$'* 1'!?%"!, "*5/! '@%&%1 #%.>*# @&!()&%4( @%&'(#$%@%""5G '*?"(#$<» (230, #. 346). R( @4(1($'(&"(% !+5>%"!% E4%/$&(8*;"%$!+8* )64( '(+8(?"( 4!7< @&! 5#4('!! ($/*+* ($ 86#4! ( %;( 8%:*"!>%#/(8 ()I,#"%"!!. 9 E$( "% $*/ 4%;/( )64( #1%4*$<. C($ @(>%85, @( @&!+"*"!G . B4*"/*, «8*/#'%44('#/*, $%(&!,, ' #!45 %% #'(%()&*+!,, @&(74* #4(?"6. @5$<. R%'(+8(?"( #(#$*'!$< #%)% @&(#$(% ! "*;4,1"(% @&%1#$*'4%"!% ( %% A(&854*: # @(8(F%#/!: *"*4(;!., >$( # #*8(;( "*>*4* "%()6>*."( +*$&51",4( %% @("!8*"!% ! +"*>!$%4<"( (#4*)4,4( %% 5)%1!$%4<"(#$<» (303, #. 178). R%():(1!8( )64( E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"(% @(1$'%&?1%"!% $%(&!! */#'%44*. H ("( )64( @(45>%"(. «3/(">*$%4<"( &%7!$< $%(&%$!>%#/!. #@(& ' @(4<+5 $%(&!! */#'%44*… )64( #5?1%"( =%"&!:5 =%&25 – #*8(85 +*8%>*$%4<"(85 5>%"!/5 =%4<8;(4<2*» ($*8 ?%, #. 179). V*",'7!#< @( #('%$5 #'(%;( 5>!$%4, =%4<8;(4<2* E/#@%&!8%"$*8! # 2%4"6: $%(&!. E4%/$&(1!"*8!/! ! ' $(8 >!#4% – $%(&!! #*8(;( =%4<8;(4<2* ! $%(&!! */#'%44*, =%&2 @(#4% @(>$! 1%#,$!4%$"!: @(@6$(/ "*7%4, "*/("%2, ' 1867 ;(15 #@(#() ;%"%&!&('*"!, ! 1%$%/$!&('*"!, (>%"< )6#$&6: E4%/$&!>%#/!: /(4%)*"!.. L$( 1*4( '(+8(?"(#$< #1%4*$< '6)(& ' @(4<+5 $%(&!! */#'%44*. D(&%"2 @(+1"%% ($8%>*4, >$( «(#"('"*, !1%, $%(&!! */#'%44* #$*4* 1(#$(,"!%8 '#%: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. !8%""( )4*;(1*&, (@6$5 =%&2*…» (219, #. 12). 9"*4(;!>"(% 8"%"!% '6#/*+*4 ! . B4*"/, @&!+"*', >$( =%&2, @&('%1, #'(! (#"('(@(4*;*GF!% E/#@%&!8%"$6, «()%#@%>!4 @()%15 $%(&!! */#'%44* @( '#%85 A&("$5» (303, #. 154). C &%+54<$*$% #'(!: E/#@%&!8%"$(' =%&2 @(45>!4 #'()(1"6% E4%/$&(8*;"!$"6% '(4"6, !+8%&!4 !: 14!"5, ()"*&5?!4 !: ($&*?%"!%, @&%4(84%"!%, 1!A&*/2!G, !"$%&A%&%"2!G. 3)()F*, &%+54<$*$6 E/#@%&!8%"$(', =%&2 &*+'!4 1*4<7% $%(&!G */#'%44*; !+8%"!' %% 5&*'"%"!,, (" ''%4 !"(%, "6"% ()F%@&!",$(% !: "*@!#*"!%. =%&2 %F% 1*4<7% ($(7%4 ($ 8%:*"!>%#/!: @&%1#$*'4%"!. ' @("!8*"!! E4%/$&(8*;"!$"(;( @(4,. «=%"&!:5 =%&25, – @!#*4 9. L."7$%.", – 86 (),+*"6 #(+"*$%4<"68 (>!F%"!%8 @(",$!, @(4, ($ '#%;( @()(>"(;(, '"%#%""(;( 8%:*"!>%#/!8! @&%1#$*'4%"!,8!» (403, #. 86). H##4%1('*"!, =%&2* #5F%#$'%""( @('4!,4! "* #('%&7%"#$'('*"!% A!+!>%#/!: '(++&%"!.. B( 8"%"!G . D*5E, «($/&6$!% =%&2* @&%()&*+!4( (#"('"6% A!+!>%#/!% '(++&%"!,. 3"( !8%%$ "%(2%"!8(% +"*>%"!% "% $(4%$ !4! @%$. P $%: @(& /*/ =%&2 (@&('%&; $%(&!G 1*4<"(1%.#$'!, – '+*!8(1%.#$'!, )%+ #&%16 – "!/$(
80
)(4<7% "% '%&!$ ' "%% "! @&! ;&*'!$*2!!, "! ' /*/(8-4!)( 1&5;(8 ,'4%"!!. C*?"%.7!. $&51 94<)%&$* L."7$%."* @( #(+1*"!G $%(&!! ;&*'!$*2!!, /($(&*,, #(;4*#"( E$(. $%(&!!, &*#@&(#$&*",%$#, #( #/(&(#$%"6% +*",4!#< E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"68 !##4%1('*"!%8 E4%/$&(8*;"!$"6: '(4"; ' &%+54<$*$% E$(;( )64! ($/&6$6 @(>$! '#% !: 1!*@*+("6 – ($ "%#/(4%"!%, "*+'*""(% !8 U–45>*8!. C#/(&% )64( 5#$*"('4%"(, >$( &%"$;%"('#/!% 45>! – E$( E4%/$&(8*;"!$"6% '(4"6 (>%"< /(&($/(. 14!"6. V"*8%"!$6. &5##/!. A!+!/ B.R. D%)%1%' (1866–1912) '"%# #'(. – ! "%8*46. – '/4*1 ' 5>%"!% () E4%/$&(8*;"!$"6: '(4"*:. W85, ' >*#$"(#$!, 51*4(#< +*@(4"!$< @&()%4 ' ()F%. 7/*4% '(4" – 8%?15 ()6>"68! &*1!('(4"*8! ! !"A&*/&*#"68! 45>*8!. D%)%1%' #1%4*4 $*/?% ! 1&5;(% '*?"(% ($/&6$!%, (#()%""( @&(#4*'!'7%% %;(: (" E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"( 5#$*"('!4 ! !+8%&!4 #'%$('(% 1*'4%"!%, @(/*+*' %;( #('@*1%"!% # (1"!8 !+ $%(&%$!>%#/!: '6'(1(' */#'%44*. Q4*;(1*&, !##4%1('*"!,8 D%)%1%'* #$*4( (>%'!1"68, >$( E4%/$&(8*;"!$"68 !+45>%"!,8 @&!#5F! "% $(4*#$"(#$!, ()()F*, &%+54<$*$6 #'(!: E/#@%&!8%"$(', (" #1%4*4 '6'(1 ( $(8, >$( «@*1*GF!. @5>(/ #'%$* @&(!+'(1!$ 1*'4%"!% /*/ "* @(;4(F*GF!%, $*/ ! "* ($&*?*GF!% @('%&:"(#$!… P!46 1*'4%"!, #'%$* @&,8( @&(@(&2!("*4<"6 E"%&;!! @*1*GF%;( 45>* ! "% +*'!#,$ ($ 2'%$*» (199, #. 210). 31!" !+ 5>%"!/(' D%)%1%'*, !+'%#$"6. A!+!/ J.B. M&*'%2, (2%"!'*, "*5>"5G +"*>!8(#$< 1(#$!?%"!, #'(%;( 5>!$%4,, @(1>%&/"54: «…3>%'!1"(, >$( @&%1#$*'4%"!% ( '+*!8(#',+! 8*$%&!*4<"(. 8*##6 ! E"%&;!! ! () (;&(8"6: +*@*#*: E"%&;!!, #/&6$(. ' 8*$%&!*4<"(. 8*##% 4G)(;(, * ' (#()%""(#$! $,?%4(;(, *$(8*, #'(!8! /(&",8! /&%@/( #',+*"( # #!4*8! #'%$('(;( 1*'4%"!,. H 1(4;( %F% '#% $%, /$( )51%$ @!#*$< () E$!: 7!&(>*.7!: ()()F%"!,: A!+!>%#/(. 86#4!, )515$ '#@(8!"*$< @&! E$(8 !8, D%)%1%'*» (184, #. 303). C @&!'%1%""6: '6#/*+6'*"!,: "*!)(4%% '*?%" ' 1*""(8 #45>*%, /*/ #5F%#$'%""6. A!4(#(A#/!. @(1$%/#$, 8(8%"$ '+*!8(#',+! 8*##6 ! E"%&;!!, 8(8%"$, @&%1#$*'4,GF!. ' /("/&%$"(8 A!+!>%#/(8 '*&!*"$% ()F5G 14, '#%;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, XIX '%/*, '%15F5G ' "%8 $%"1%"2!G, * !8%""( – "*@&*'4%""(#$< @(+"*'*$%4<"6: 5#$&%84%"!. 5>%"6: "* '6,'4%"!% ! 5,#"%"!% +*/("(8%&"6: #',+%. ' !+5>*%86: ()I%/$*:, "* E8@!&!>%#/(% 5#$*"('4%"!% ! $%(&%$!>%#/(% ()(#"('*"!% +*/("(' @&!&(16. C &*+'!$!! E4%/$&(1!"*8!/! ' XIX '%/% @&(#4%?!'*G$#, 1'* (#"('"6: "*@&*'4%"!, – !##4%1('*"!% E4%/$&(8*;"!$"(;( @(4,, # (1"(. #$(&("6, ! E4%8%"$*&"6: +*&,1(' E4%/$&!>%#$'* – # 1&5;(.. C $%(&!! */#'%44* ' 2%"$&% '"!8*"!, )64( E4%/$&(8*;"!$"(% @(4% – '"% #',+! # E4%8%"$*&"68! +*&,1*8! E4%/$&!>%#$'*, @(&(?1*GF!8! @(4% ! !+45>*GF!8! E4%/$&(8*;"!$"6% '(4"6. P4%1('*$%4<"(, @(4% ! '%F%#$'( 5
81
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–1928). . B4*"/ #>!$*4 '%4!>*.7!8 "*5>"68 1(#$!?%"!%8 D(&%"2* $(, >$( (" (#5F%#$'!4 545>7%"!% $%(&!! */#'%44* ! =%&2* «' $(. 8%&%, ' /*/(. E$( '(()F% )64( '(+8(?"( #1%4*$<, (#$*'*,#< "* @(+!2!,: /4*##!>%#/(. $%(&!!». 3#"('"(. !1%%. D(&%"2* ,'!4(#< @&! E$(8 «''%1%"!% *$(8!#$!/! ' 5>%"!% () E4%/$&!>%#$'%» (303, #. 155). J%(&!, D(&%"2*, /*/ (" () E$(8 @!#*4, «@&%1#$*'4,%$ 8*$%&!*4<"6. 8!& #(#$(,F!8 !+ $&]: #5F"(#$%., $&%: #$&(!$%4<"6: /!&@!>%.: E$(, '(–@%&'6:, ()6>"*, (F5F*%8*,, !4! '%#(8*,, 8*$%&!,, '(–'$(&6:, E4%/$&("6, !, '–$&%$"6% >4%"6, ($&*?*GF!% '4!,"!% +*&,1(' "* E4%/$&(8*;"!$"(% @(4%. -*+'!$!% D(&%"2(8 A!+!>%#/(;( #(1%&?*"!, $%(&!! */#'%44* '6&*+!4(#< ' #4%15GF%8. */#'%44, * '#4%1 +* "!8 ! =%&2, !#:(1!4! !+ $(;(, >$( 8*$%&!, (@("!8*%8*, /*/ '%F%#$'() "%@&%&6'"( +*@(4",%$ @&(#$&*"#$'(. 3"*, * "% @&(#$&*"#$'(, #>!$*4*#< "(#!$%4%8 E4%/$&(8*;"!$"(;( @(4,. 3$#G1* #4%1('*4(, >$( "(#!$%4< @(4, ()4*1*%$ #'(.#$'(8 !8%$< #/(&(#$<, E$( &*#@&(#$&*",4(#< ! "* %;( #&%15 – EA!&. *$%&!*4<"6% $%4* &*##8*$&!'*4!#< /*/ #!#$%86 +*&,?]""6: >*#$!2, #',+*""6: E4%/$&(8*;"!$"68 @(4%8. L4%/$&(1!"*8!>%#/!% ,'4%"!, ' 1'!?5F!:#, #!#$%8*: &*##8*$&!'*4!#< ' ($'4%>%"!! ($ #*8(;( !: 1'!?%"!,. B&(!#:(1,F!% ' 1'!?5F%.#, #!#$%8% E4%/$&(1!"*8!>%#/!% @&(2%##6 "% @(1'%&;*G$#, '4!,"!G %] 1'!?%"!,, ("( @(E$(85 "% 8(;4( )6$< ()"*&5?%"( ' E4%/$&(1!"*8!>%#/!: ,'4%"!,:. B( 8"%"!G 9. L."7$%."*, «)(4<7(. +*#45;(. =. D(&%"2* )64( $(, >$( (" @&(!+']4 +1%#< @%&%'(&($, @&!$(8 #*868 5)%1!$%4<"68 ()&*+(8» (403, #. 271). B( $%(&!! D(&%"2*, @&(#$&*"#$'( "%@&%&6'"( +*@(4",%$#, EA!&(8, /($(&6. @&%1#$*'4,4#, %85, D(&%"25, «>%8–$( (#()%""68, #('%&7%""( ($4!>"68 ($ '#%: '%#(86: '!1(' 8*$%&!!» (219, #. 16). LA!&, * "% 8*$%&!, ('%F%#$'() ,'4,%$#, "(#!$%4%8 E4%/$&(8*;"!$"(;( @(4,. 3" '%+1% ! @(#$(,""( "*:(1!$#, ' @(/(%. C%F%#$'%""6% $%4* «@(;&5?%"6» ' EA!& . C%F%#$'( #(#$(!$ !+ *$(8(' ! ,'4,%$#, %1!"#$'%""68 "(#!$%4%8 +*&,1('. 9$(86 @&("!/"5$6 EA!&(8 ! 8(;5$ 1'!;*$<#, ' "]8 )%+ #(@&($!'4%"!, # %;( #$(&("6. «M*?1*, ($1%4<"*, 8(4%/54* @&(+&*>"* 14, EA!&*». L$( 1(@5F%"!% &*#@&(#$&*",%$#, ! "* *$(8, (" «,'4,%$#, "%/($(&(. 4(/*4<"(. 8(1!A!/*2!%. '#%@&("!/*GF%;( EA!&*,
82
8(1!A!/*2!%., /($(&*, 8(?%$ @%&%8%F*$<#, ' @&(#$&*"#$'% )%+ $(;(, >$()6 #*8* #&%1* #1'!"54*#< # 8%#$*» ($*8 ?%). 9$(8"(% #$&(%"!% !8%%$ ! E4%/$&!>%#$'(. W;( #(#$*'4,G$ E4%8%"$*&"6% +*&,16 – E4%/$&("6. «L4%/$&(" '8%#$% # $%8, # >%8 (" #',+*", "*:(1!$#, '"5$&! (1"(;( *$(8*» ($*8 ?%, #. 15). Q515>! #',+*""68! # *$(8*8! '%F%#$'*, E4%/$&("6 ()&*+5G$ !("6, "( ("! 8(;5$ #5F%#$'('*$< ! "%+*'!#!8( ($ *$(8(', #'()(1"( 1'!;*,#< ' EA!&%. H: @(4(?%"!%8 ! 1'!?%"!%8 #(+1*]$#, E4%/$&(8*;"!$"(% @(4%. J(4%#/!% ! 8*;"!$"6% '+*!8(1%.#$'!, $%4. «L4%/$&("6, – @!#*4 D(&%"2, – @&("!2*%86 14, EA!&* ! /*?16. !+ "!: ,'4,%$#, 2%"$&(8 E4%/$&!>%#/(;(, * @&! 1'!?%"!! ! 8*;"!$"(;( @(4,» ($*8 ?%, #. 18). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, ' E4%/$&(""(. $%(&!! D(&%"2*, /*/ ($8%>*4 9. L."7$%.", «@(4% ! E4%/$&!>%#/!% /(&@5#/546 '6#$5@*G$ &,1(8 1&5; # 1&5;(8 /*/ '+*!8(1(@(4",GF!% E4%8%"$6 14, @("!8*"!, &%*4<"(#$!» (403, #. 139). K!E4%/$&!>%#/!% #'(.#$'*, @&('(1!8(#$< ! $.@., @( $%(&!! D(&%"2*, +*'!#,$ ($ 8%:*"!>%#/!: #',+%. 8%?15 >*#$!2*8!, !+ /($(&6: #(#$(,$ $%4*. N*#$!26-+*&,16 #(+1*G$ @(4%, ("(, ' #'(G (>%&%1<, 1%.#$'5%$ "* +*&,16 >*#$!2. P(($'%$#$'5GF!% #!46 ()5#4('4!'*G$ 1'!?%"!% >*#$!2 #(;4*#"( +*/("*8 R%#/!: ! 8*;"!$"6: ,'4%"!., E4%/$&!>%#/!: ! 8*;"!$"6: #'(.#$' '%F%#$'*. D(&%"2 '6,'!4 $*/?% +*8%>*$%4<"(% #'(.#$'( )6#$&(1'!?5F!:#, E4%/$&("(' – +*'!#!8(#$< 8*##6 E4%/$&("* ($ #/(&(#$! %;( 1'!?%"!,. M&(8% $(;(, (" 5#$*"('!4, >$( )6#$&(% 1'!?%"!% $%4 – * ("! ,'4,G$#, #!#$%8*8! +*&,?%""6: >*#$!2, #',+*""6: E4%/$&(8*;"!$"68 @(4%8 – '6+6'*%$ !+8%"%"!% $*/!: !: #'(.#$', /*/ ()I]8 ! 14!$%4<"(#$< @&(!#:(1,F!: ' $%4% @&(2%##('. J%(&!, D(&%"2* #6;&*4* !#/4G>!$%4<"( '*?"5G &(4< ' &*+'!$!! A!+!/!. WF% ' 1949 ;(15 9. L."7$%.", !+4(?!' #5F"(#$< E$(. $%(&!!, @!#*4: «0!+!/ "6"%7"%;( @(/(4%"!, #(>$]$ $(>/5 +&%"!, D(&%"2* %1!"#$'%""( '(+8(?"(., * ' $( '&%8, E$( )64 @(&*+!$%4<"( #8%46. 7*;, )%+ /($(&(;( 1*4<"%.7%% &*+'!$!% )64( )6 "%'(+8(?"(» ($*8 ?%, #. 27). R*&,15 # $%(&!%. */#'%44* E4%/$&(""*, $%(&!, D(&%"2* @(1;($('!4* 5#4('!, 14, '(+"!/"('%"!, $%(&!! ($"(#!$%4<"(#$!, ,'!'7!#< %] )4!?*.7%. @&%17%#$'%""!2%.. D(&%"2 ' 1925 ;(15 @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «-*+'!'*, $%(&!G "%@(1'!?"(;( EA!&*, , @&!)4!?*4 $%8 #*868 @(,'4%"!% $%(&!! ($"(#!$%4<"(#$! L."7$%."*» (219, #. 178). P*8 L."7$%." @(1>%&/!'*4, >$( «$%(&!, */#'%44*–D(&%"2* "%!+)%?"( '%4* / #@%2!*4<"(. $%(&!! ($"(#!$%4<"(#$!» (403, #. 87). M&(8% $(;(, )4*;(1*&, !##4%1('*"!,8 D(&%"2*, * $*/?% K?. J(8#("* ! 1&. '(+"!/4! @&%1@(#64/! 14, @("!8*"!, *$(8* /*/ #4(?"(;( ()&*+('*"!,. L$( @(1$'%&1!4(#< ($/&6$!%8 ' /("2% 90-: ;(1(' XIU '%/*
83
%#$%#$'%""(. &*1!(*/$!'"(#$! (9. Q%//%&%4<, B<%& ! *&!, MG&!). Q64( 5#$*"('4%"(, >$( *$(86 "*!)(4%% $,?]46: :!8!>%#/!: E4%8%"$(' "% (#$*G$#, "%!+8%""68!, "( @(#$(,""( &*+&57*G$#,. L$( "*'(1!4( "* 86#4<, >$( *$(8 –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«1(#$!;4* $&!58A*, ' 1896 ;(15 )4*;(1*&, EAA%/$5 V%%8*"* ! %;( ()I,#"%"!G D(&%"2%8» (198, #. 313). § 3. ?24F=MDE=9 Q=B=<25: FD28== = C;<2EK 9$(8!#$!>%#/*, $%(&!, &*+&*)*$6'*4*#< "% $(4*4#, !8%""( ' $(&?%#$'% *$(8!#$!/!. O?% ' @%&'(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/* &*+'!$!% *$(8"(–8(4%/54,&"(;( 5>%"!, #$*4( ;4*'"68 "*@&*'4%"!%8 ' :!8!>%#/!: !##4%1('*"!,: K. K*4<$("*, 9. 9'(;*1&(, =. M!&:;(A*, -. Q5"+%"* ! 1&. H8%""( ' E$($ @%&!(1 A(&8!&5G$#, "*5>"6% @(",$!, :!8!! – *$(8, 8(4%/54*, E/'!'*4%"$, '*4%"$"(#$<. H: @(+"*'*$%4<"(% @&%$'(&%"!% ' #(($'%$#$'5GF%. /("/&%$!+*2!! ()"*&5?!'*%$#,, "*@&!8%&, ' !+'%#$"(. $%(&!! :!8!>%#/(;( #$&(%"!,, &*+&*)($*""(. '61*GF!8#, &5##/!8 :!8!/(8 9. . Q5$4%&('68 (1828–1886). C >*#$"(#$!, "*8%>*, @5$! @&%(1(4%"!, «"%4('/(;(» @(4(?%"!, :!8!!, (" @!#*4 ' 1861 ;(15: «B(&* (#"('*$< @(",$!, "*7! ( :!8!>%#/(. /("#$!$52!! '%F%#$' "* !1%,: *$(8"(#$! ! :!8!>%#/(;( #$&(%"!,» (45, #. 79). H1%G *$(8"(#$! Q5$4%&(' &*#/&6'*4 ' &*8/*: ($'%$* "* @&!"2!@!*4<"6. 8!&('(++&%">%#/!. '(@&(#: «N$( $*/(% *$(8 ! #5F%#$'5%$ 4! (" &%*4<"(?» 3$'%$ '61%&?*" ' ,'"( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(8 15:%: «K4, :!8!! –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» ($*8 ?%, #. 439–440).
84
3#"('"5G !1%G #'(%. $%(&!! :!8!>%#/(;( #$&(%"!, Q5$4%&(' #A(&854!&('*4 #4%15GF!8 ()&*+(8: «U!8!>%#/*, "*$5&* #4(?"(. >*#$!26 (@&%1%4,%$#, "*$5&(. E4%8%"$*&"6: #(#$*'"6: >*#$%., /(4!>%#$'(8 !: ! :!8!>%#/!8 #$&(%"!%8» ($*8 ?%, #. 72). 31"!8 !+ "*!)(4%% +"*>!$%4<"6: 1(#$!?%"!. :!8!! XIX '%/* #$*4( ($/&6$!% ' 1869 ;(15 ;%"!*4<"68 &5##/!8 5>%"68 K.H. %"1%4%%'68 (1834–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«[%4< 8(%. #$*$!"% *$(8"(;( '%#* "%#:(1"6: E4%8%"$(', "* /($(&6%, #/(4$! "!/*/(;( '"!8*"!,» (260, #. 31). C 1869–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
85
E4%8%"$(' – "*#$(4%'!1"*, ! "%+6)4%8*,, >$( "* %% (#"('% #$*4( '(+8(?"68 # '6#(/(. #$%@%""(#$! @&%1#/*+*$< ($/&6$!% $(;1* %F% "% !+'%#$"6: E4%8%"$(', >$( ! )64( #1%4*"( %"1%4%%'68. 3", /*/ !+'%#$"(, "* (#"('% @%&!(1!>%#/(;( +*/("* @&%1#/*+*4 #'(.#$'* %F% "% ($/&6$6: / $(85 '&%8%"! E4%8%"$(', (#()%""( @(1&()"( (@!#*' @&! E$(8 #'(.#$'* $&%: $(;1* %F% "% !+'%#$"6: 8%$*44(', "*+'*""6: !8 E/*)(&(8, E/**4G8!"!%8 ! E/*#!4!2!%8. C 1875–1886 ;;. '#% $&! @&%1#/*+*""6: %"1%4%%'68 E4%8%"$* (!: "*+'*4! #/*"1!%8, ;*44!%8 ! ;%&8*"!%8) )64! ($/&6$6. B&! E$(8 '6,#"!4(#<, >$( +"*>%"!, !: #'(.#$' @(>$! @(4"(#$"(#$<, # /($(&(. )64! @(1$'%&?1%"6 $%(&%$!>%#/!% @&%1#/*+*"!, %"1%4%%'*» (297, #. 133). B&%1#/*+*"!% "('6: E4%8%"$(' ! !: #'(.#$' %"1%4%%' &*##8*$&!'*4 /*/ 4(;!>%#/(% +*'%&7%"!% ($/&6$!,, $*/ /*/ E$! @&%1#/*+*"!, @(+'(4,4! "* @&*/$!/% @&('%&!$< ! @(1$'%&1!$< @&*'!4<"(#$< +*/("*, "* (#"('% /($(&(;( #1%4*"6 #(($'%$#$'5GF!% 58(+*/4G>%"!,. C «3#"('*: :!8!!» (" @!#*4: «V*/("6 @&!&(16 !#/4G>%"!. "% $%&@,$ ! E$!8 ,'"( ($4!>*G$#, ($ @&*'!4 ! @&*'!4<"(#$%., @(1()"6:, "*@&!8%&, ;&*88*$!>%#/!8… O$'%&?1%"!% +*/("* '(+8(?"( $(4%#/!. +*/(", , #( #'(%. #$(&("6 (1869–1871) '6'%4 !+ "%;( $*/!% 4(;!>%#/!% #4%1#$'!,, /($(&6% 8(;4! @(/*+*$< – '%&%" (" !4! "%$. M >!#45 !: ($"(#!$#, @&%1#/*+*"!% #'(.#$' "%($/&6$6: E4%8%"$(' ! !#@&*'4%"!% *$(8"6: '%#(' 8"(;!:, 8*4( ' $( '&%8, ()#4%1('*""6: E4%8%"$('» (250, #. 323). 0. L";%4<# 5#8($&%4 ' 8%"1%4%%'#/(8 +*/("%, ' %;( @(+"*'*$%4<"(8 (#5F%#$'4%"!! #5F%#$'%""( '*?"6. A!4(#(A#/!. @(1$%/#$: ($8%$!', ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( «@&%1#/*+*"!, %"1%4%%'*, # #('%&7%""( "%+"*>!$%4<"68! ($/4("%"!,8!, (@&*'1*4!#<», (" "* E$(8 (#"('*"!! #1%4*4 '6'(1: « %"1%4%%', @&!8%"!' )%##(+"*$%4<"( ;%;%4%'#/!. +*/(" ( @%&%:(1% /(4!>%#$'* ' /*>%#$'(, #('%&7!4 "*5>"6. @(1'!;» (406, #. 389). P*8 %"1%4%%' #>%4 "5?"68 @(1>%&/"5$<, >$( ($/&6$6. !8 @%&!(1!>%#/!. +*/(" 5;45)4,%$ «A!4(#(A#/!. @&!"2!@, /($(&6. 5@&*'4,%$ $*!"#$'%""(. @&!&(1(. E4%8%"$('» (250, #. 392). %"1%4%%' '6&*+!4 $*/?% "*1%?15 "* $(, >$( @(#4%15GF%% @(/(4%"!% !##4%1('*$%4%. 1*#$ «@%&'68 ()!4<"68 @4(1*8 @%&!(1!>%#/(;( +*/("* "('(% A!4(#(A#/(% ()()F%"!%, (@%&%' %;( "* 5#$(!, @(1/&%@4%""6% "('68! (@6$*8!, /($(&6% @&!1*15$ %F% )(4<75G @&(>"(#$< "*>*$(85 +1*"!G» ($*8 ?%, #. 394). -*+'!$!% :!8!!, * +*$%8 A!+!/! ' @%&!(1 @(#4% ($/&6$!, @%&!(1!>%#/(;( +*/("* @&!"(#!4( %85 '#] "('6% @(1$'%&?1%"!,. C /("2% XIX '%/* ($/&6$!% &*1!(*/$!'"(#$! ! &*1!(*/$!'"6: E4%8%"$(' @(+'(4!4( +*@(4"!$< @5#$5GF!% 8%#$* ' $*)4!2% %"1%4%%'*. C8%#$% # $%8 ($/&6$!% &*1!(*/$!'"(#$!, * $*/?% &%"$;%"('#/!: 45>%. ! E4%/$&("* 5#$&*"!4( @&%?"!% @&%1#$*'4%"!, ( "%1%4!8(#$! *$(8* !
86
"%@&%'&*F*%8(#$! :!8!>%#/(;( E4%8%"$*. R( @%&!(1!>%#/!. +*/(" E$! ($/&6$!, "% @(/(4%)*4!. Q(4<7% $(;(, ' "*>*4% XX '%/* '6,#"!4(#<, >$( ("! #@(#()#$'('*4! ()(;*F%"!G ! &*+'!$!G E$(;( +*/("*, @&%'&*$!' %;( !+ #5;5)( :!8!>%#/(;( ' A!+!>%#/!.. M $(85 ?% ! #*8! A!+!>%#/!% ,'4%"!,, ($/&6$6% ' /("2% XIX '%/* – &%"$;%"('#/!% 45>!, E4%/$&(", &*1!(*/$!'"(#$< – "*74! ' @%&!(1!>%#/(8 +*/("% )(4%% @(4"(% ()I,#"%"!% ! ()()F%"!%. J*/, ' ($/&6$(8 %"1%4%%'68 @%&!(1!>%#/(8 +*/("% #(74!#< 1'% (#"('"6% 4!"!! &*+'!$!, *$(8!#$!/! XIX '%/* – A!+!>%#/*, ! :!8!>%#/*,. C XIX '%/%, @(8!8( @&()4%8*$!/!, $*/ !4! !"*>% #',+*""(. # *$(8!#$!>%#/!8! @&%1#$*'4%"!,8!, ' :!8!!, &*+58%%$#,, */$!'"( &*+&*)*$6'*4!#< ! @&()4%86 !"(;( &(1*, ($"(#,F!%#, / /*>%#$'%""( !"68 #A%&*8 :!8!>%#/(. &%*4<"(#$!, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' ()4*#$! (&;*"!>%#/(. :!8!!. V1%#< (#()%""( )(4<75G &(4< #6;&*4! @4(1($'(&"6% !##4%1('*"!, +"*8%"!$(;( "%8%2/(;( 5>%"(;( S. D!)!:* (1803–1873). C8%#$% # Q%&2%4!5#(8, KG8* ! C%4%&(8 (" ,'!4#, (#"('(@(4(?"!/(8 (&;*"!>%#/(. :!8!!, ()(;*$!' %% 8"(;(>!#4%""68! 1(#$!?%"!,8!. H8, ' >*#$"(#$!, )64 &*+&*)($*" &,1 #5F%#$'%""( '*?"6: :!8!>%#/!: $%(&!., (" @(45>!4 ! 1%$*4<"( !##4%1('*4 1%#,$/! (&;*"!>%#/!: #(%1!"%"!., '6,'!4 ! ()I,#"!4 8%:*"!+8 16:*"!,, @!$*"!, ! ()&*+('*"!, $%@4* 5 ?!'6: (&;*"!+8('; &*+&*)($*4 /4*##!>%#/!. 8%$(1 E4%8%"$"(;( *"*4!+* (&;*"!>%#/!: #(%1!"%"!., /4*##!>%#/!. 8%$(1 (@&%1%4%"!, /!#4(&(1* ' ;*+*: # @(8(F%"!, ;&%85>%. &$5$! ! #%&%)&*, 5#$*"('!4 !: #(#$*'; ($/&64 &%*/2!G «#%&%)&,"(;( +%&/*4*» ! $.1. B( 8"%"!G C. 3#$'*4<1*, «(&;*"!>%#/*, :!8!,, )4*;(1*&, #5F%#$'%""( $&51*8 D!)!:*, '#$5@!4* "* @5$< #'(%;( @%&'(;(, )6#$&(;( &*+'!$!,, !"$%&%# ! ()4*#$< &*)($6 %% $'(&2* (!4!, @( 8%"<7%. 8%&%, #($'(&2*) (:'*$6'*4! @(>$! '#G ()4*#$< E$(. "*5/!» (290, #. 159). B&! E$(8 !##4%1('*$%4<#/*, 1%,$%4<"(#$< D!)!:* "% (;&*"!>!'*4*#< (1"!8! #5;5)( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"68! @&()4%8*8!, ("* &*#@&(#$&*",4*#< ! "* #A%&5 A!4(#(A#/(. @&()4%8*$!/!. J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, D!)!: @(1 5;4(8 +&%"!, #'(!: @&!"2!@!*4<"6: %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: @&%1#$*'4%"!. (#5F%#$'!4 #/&5@54%+"6. /&!$!>%#/!. *"*4!+ A!4(#(A#/!: #(>!"%"!. 0. QE/("*. C6'(16, / /($(&68 (" @&!7%4, '6+'*4! '(+&*?%"!, !+'%#$"(;( A!4(#(A* V!;'*&$* !, /*/ #'!1%$%4<#$'5%$ 3#$'*4<1, «E$( @()51!4( D!)!:* / "%/($(&68 1*4<"%.7!8 &*)($*8 "*$5&A!4(#(A#/(;( :*&*/$%&*, /($(&6%, (@!&*,#< "* %;( 4!>"6. (@6$, ,'4,G$#, '%#<8* @(5>!$%4<"68!» ($*8 ?%, #. 197). C (1"(. !+ $*/!: &*)($ («H"15/2!, ! 1%15/2!,») D!)!:, *"*4!+!&5, &*+4!>"6% #$(&("6 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, "*&,15 # E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"(. ! A*/$(4(;!>%#/(. #(#$*'4,GF!8!, '61%4!4 ' "%8 $*/?% ! (),+*$%4<"6. $%+'!"%78".= *#@%/$ ! (#"('*""(% "* '(()&*?%"!!, "* A*"$*+!! #5F%#$'%""(% -9!$0*16!* "*>*4(. «-*+58 ! '(()&*?%"!% (1!"*/('( "%():(1!86 14, "*7%;( +"*"!, ! !8%G$ (1!"*/('(% @&*'( ;&*?1*"#$'* ' "*5/%; ! $($, ! 1&5;(% @&!"!8*G$ !+'%#$"(% 5>*#$!% '( '#%: +*1*>*: A!+!/!, :!8!!, 8%1!2!"6.., ! $($, ! 1&5;(% +*"!8*G$
87
(@&%1%4%""(% 8%#$( ' ()4*#$! E$!: "*5/» (210, #. 26). -*#/&6'*, /("/&%$"6. 8%:*"!+8 @(+"*'*$%4<"(;( A5"/2!("!&('*"!, &*+58* ! A*"$*+!! ' @&(2%##% &%*4!+*2!! !"15/$!'"(;( ! 1%15/$!'"(;( 8%$(1(', D!)!: @(,#",%$: «H"15/2!,, '%1(8*, A*"$*+!%G, #(+%&2*%$ ! $'(&!$, "( ("* "% (@&%1%4]""* ! )%+8%&"*; "*@&*'4,%8*, ?% &*+58(8 1%15/2!, *"*4!+!&5%$ ! #$*'!$ @&%1%46, ("* (@&%1%4]""* ! !+8%&!8*… 0*"$*+!, #&*'"!'*%$ ! &*+4!>*%$, "( "% !+8%&,%$, @($(85 >$( 14, !+8%&%"!, "5?%" 8*#7$*), /($(&6. %#$< @&(15/$ &*+58*» ($*8 ?%, #. 26-27). -*+'!$!% :!8!! ' XIX '%/% ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% "*@&*'4,4(#< $*/?% 1(#$!?%"!,8! +"*8%"!$(;( A&*"25+#/(;( 5>%"(;( . Q%&$4( (1827–1907). 3@&%1%4,, (#"('"(% #(1%&?*"!% %;( !##4%1('*"!., !: 8%#$( ! &(4< ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, !: "*5>"5G ! 8!&('(++&%">%#/5G +"*>!8(#$<, M.9. J!8!&,+%' @!#*4: «R*'#%;1* #',+*' #'(% !8, # (1"!8 !+ '%4!>*.7!: +*'(%'*"!. '%/*, #(+1*"!%8 #!"$%$!>%#/(. :!8!! – (1!"*/('( '*?"68 ! @( %;( ;45)(/(85 A!4(#(A#/(85 #86#45 ! @( %;( @&*/$!>%#/!8 @&!4(?%"!,8, @&%1%46 /($(&6: "%4<+, ! @&%1'!1%$<; ,'4,,#< (1"!8 !+ !"!2!*$(&(' 1&5;(;(, )6$< 8(?%$, %F% )(4%% ;45)(/(;( "*5>"(;( "*@&*'4%"!, – A!+!>%#/(. :!8!!, ' %% #@%2!*4<"(. ()4*#$! $%&8(:!8!!; *'$(& )%#>!#4%""6: !##4%1('*"!., (" ,'4,%$#, 8(;5>!8 A!4(#(A#/!&*+'!$68 58(8 ' #A%&% "% $(4"(;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!, (A!+!/! ! :!8!!), "% $(4%4('%>%#/(;( +"*"!, '(()F%» (351, #. 464). C ($"(7%"!! @(#4%1"%;(, A!4(#(A#/(;( *#@%/$* !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! Q%&$4( – #A%&6 >%4('%>%#/(;( +"*"!, '(()F% – 58%#$"( @&!'%#$! "%/($(&6% :*&*/$%&"6% #5?1%"!, #*8(;( 5>%"(;(, "*@&!8%&, $% !+ "!:, /($(&6% #',+*"6 # %;( /("2%@2!%. "*5/! @(4(?!$%4<"(. ! "*5/! !1%*4<"(.. J*/, ()(#"('6'*, E$5 /("2%@2!G, Q%&$4( @&!:(1!$ / '6'(15: «R*5/* @(4(?!$%4<"*,, &*+ 5#$*"('4%""*,, 5#$*"('4%"* "*'%/!; 8%?15 $%8 /*/ "*5/* !1%*4<"*, )%#@&%#$*""( !+8%",%$#, ! '#%;1* )51%$ !+8%",$<#,. L$( ! %#$< +*/(" >%4('%>%#/(;( @(+"*"!,. C "*7% '&%8, 1(4?"( @&!+"*$< E$($ +*/(" ! # "!8 #(()&*+('*$<#,, +"*, "*@%&%1, >$( !#$!"* '#,/(. #!#$%86 5'%4!>!'*%$#, @&(@(&2!("*4<"( #588% 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! ' "%% ''%1%""(., * "% #$&(;(#$! %% 1(/*+*$%4<#$'» (31, #. 18–19). C ()I,#"%"!! !1%*4<"(. "*5/! Q%&$4( ()&*F*%$ '"!8*"!% "* %% (@&%1%4%""5G @&!>*#$"(#$< / A!4(#(A!! (8%$*A!+!/%) ! ' #',+! # E$!8 '61%4,%$ ' "%. (),+*$%4<"6. 7'0"!1-".= *#@%/$ ! ()5#4('4%""(% A*"$*+!%. -9!$0*16!* "*>*4(. «H1%*4<"*, "*5/* '(+'&*F*%$#, / +*1*>*8 #$*&!""(. 8%$*A!+!/! # $(>/! +&%"!, &%*4<"(;( #5F%#$'('*"!, ! 5@($&%)4,, 8%$(1, +*!8#$'('*""6. !+ @(4(?!$%4<"(. "*5/!; "( ("* "% 8(?%$ 1(#$!;"5$< $*/(. ?% 1(#$('%&"(#$!, /*/ @(#4%1",,. W#4! ("* 8(?%$ 54('!$< "%/($(&6% ()F!% '%4!/!% >%&$6, +*!8#$'('*""6% !+ @(+"*"!, >%4('%>%#/(. @&!&(16 ! '"%7"%;( 8!&*, ("* #',+6'*%$ E$! >%&$6 4!>"68! '+;4,1*8!. R*&,15 # 1(/*+*""68! A*/$*8! +1%#< '#%;1* +*"!8*%$ ! )51%$ +*"!8*$< '*?"(% 8%#$( A*"$*+!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 19). N$( /*#*%$#, @&!"2!@!*4<"(. A!4(#(A#/(. @(+!2!!, $( Q%&$4( '@(4"% ($>%$4!'(
88
A!/#!&5%$ $*/(. %% ,'"( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!. *#@%/$: «C%F! #5F%#$'5G$ ' (@&%1%4%""(8 @(&,1/%, "%+*'!#!8( ($ "*7%;( ?%4*"!, ! ($ "*7%. '(4!» ($*8 ?%). §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–1838 ;;. ' &*)($*: 1'5: "%8%2/!: 5>%"6: – )!(4(;* J. T'*""* (1810–1882) ! )($*"!/* . T4%.1%"* (1804–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– # ,1&(8. J%8 #*868 '"!8*"!% 5>%"6: @%&%'(1!4(#< # ()(4(>/! /4%$/! "* %% ;(&*+1( )(4%% ;45)(/!., * #4%1('*$%4<"(, )(4%% '*?"6., )(4%% #5F%#$'%""6. 5&('%"<. B&("!/"('%"!% "* E$($ 5&('%"< @&!'%4( / ($/&6$!G, &%'(4G2!("!+!&('*'7%85 )!(4(;!G UU '%/* – / ($/&6$!G +*/("('
89
"%17*51-9*""!1-'. L$!8 ($/&6$!%8 )64( @(4(?%"( "*>*4( "('(. "*5/%, #$*'7%. (1"(. !+ '*?"%.7!: ' )!(4(;!!, – ;%"%$!/%. 3#"('(@(4(?"!/(8 ;%"%$!/! ,'!4#, '61*GF!.#, >%7#/!. 5>%"6. =. %"1%4< (1822–1884). P'(!8! /4*##!>%#/!8! (@6$*8! @( #/&%F!'*"!G ;(&(:* (" 5#$*"('!4, >$( '(#@&(!+'%1%"!% ?!+"! #',+*"( # #!#$%8(. 1!#/&%$"6: E4%8%"$(' – ;%"('. H: @%&%1*>* ! &*+'!$!% @( @(/(4%"!,8 ()5#4('4!'*%$ "*#4%1#$'%""(#$< ! !+8%">!'(#$< (&;*"!+8('. C !##4%1('*"!!, (@5)4!/('*""(8 ' 1866 ;(15, %"1%4< "*8"(;( (@%&%1!4 #'(% '&%8,. W;( &*)($* "% )64* @&!+"*"* #('&%8%""!/*8!, /*/ E$( )64( @(>$! #( '#%8! '%4!/!8 ($/&6$!,8!. D!7< >%&%+ 35 4%$, ' 1900 ;(15, +*/("6, '6,'4%""6% %"1%4%8, )64! '$(&!>"( ($/&6$6 )4*;(1*&, &*)($*8 =. 1% 0&!+*, M. M(&&%"#* ! L. N%&8*/*. J*/!8 ()&*+(8, @(#4%1"!. ;(1 XIX '%/* #$*4 ;(1(8 &(?1%"!, ;%"%$!/! /*/ "*5/!. -*+'!$!% /4%$(>"(. $%(&!!, #(+1*""(. T4%.1%"(8 ! T'*""(8, @&!'%4( "% $(4%#/!: !##4%1('*"!.. C6,'!' %1!"#$'( @&!"2!@(' #$&(%"!, ! &*+'!$!, '#%: 8"(;(/4%$(>"6: (&;*"!+8(', /4%$(>"*, $%(&!, $%8 #*868 #(+1*4* @&%1@(#64/! ! 14, 5>%"!, ( $%,9'-'' %1!"(. ?!'(. @&!&(16. 3"* ,'!4*#< (1"!8 !+ @%&'6: )!(4(;!>%#/!: ()()F%"!., #$*'7!8 (#"('(. 5>%"!, () E'(4G2!! '#%;( (&;*"!>%#/(;( 8!&*. -*+&*)($/* /4%$(>"(. $%(&!!, @(8!8( >!#$( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;(, !8%4* ! #5F%#$'%""( '*?"6. A!4(#(A#/!. *#@%/$. U*&*/$%&"* ' E$(8 ($"(7%"!! $* (2%"/*, /($(&5G 1*4 ($/&6$!G /4%$/! L";%4<#: «L$( ($/&6$!% "% $(4$( &*+'!$!% ! &(#$ '#%: '6#7!: (&;*"!+8(' #('%&7*%$#, @( (1"(85 ()F%85 +*/("5, "(, @(/*+*' #@(#()"(#$< /4%$(/ / !+8%"%"!G, ("( "*8%$!4( $*/?% @5$<, '%15F!. / '!1('68 !+8%"%"!,8 (&;*"!+8(', !+8%"%"!,8, '#4%1#$'!% /($(&6: (&;*"!+86 8(;5$ #('%&7*$< @&(2%## &*+'!$!,, @&%1#$*'4,GF!. #()(. "%>$( )(4<7%%, >%8 &*+'!$!% $(4% ;('(&,, /4%$(>"*, $%(&!, ()I%/$!'"( #@(#()#$'('*4* 1*4<"%.7%. @(+"*'*$%4<"(. &%*4!+*2!! ()F%. '5*' $%,9'-'( – 5?% ' 8*#7$*)*: '#%;( (&;*"!>%#/(;( 8!&* ' @4*"% '6,'4%"!, ! $%(&%$!>%#/(;( ()I,#"%"!, %;( %#$%#$'%""(. C9!74+''. 3#"('(@(4(?"!/(8 E'(4G2!(""(. $%(&!! #$*4 '%4!/!. *";4!.#/!. 5>%"6. N. K*&'!" (1809–1882). C 1859 ;(15 '674* ' #'%$ %;( /"!;* «B&(!#:(?1%"!% '!1(' @5$%8 %#$%#$'%""(;( ($)(&*, !4! P(:&*"%"!% )4*;(@&!,$#$'5%86: @(&(1 ' )(&<)% +* ?!+"<». C E$(8 #(>!"%"!! K*&'!" !+4(?!4 #'(% 5>%"!%, ,'!'7%%#, &%+54<$*$(8 '#%;( @&%17%#$'5GF%;( &*+'!$!, "*5>"(. 86#4! ! !##4%1('*"!, ?!'(. @&!&(16. 3#"('6'*,#< "* (@6$% #%4<#/(:(+,.#$'%""(. @&*/$!/! #'(%;( '&%8%"!, "* #'(!: "*5>"6: "*)4G1%"!,: ! "* "*)4G1%"!,: 1&5;!: "*$5&*4!#$(', K*&'!" '@%&'6% ' )!(4(;!>%#/(. "*5/% 5#$*"('!4 ! ()(#"('*4 A*/$ !+8%",%8(#$! '!1('. 3)()F%""( #5$< 1*&'!"('#/(;( 1(#$!?%"!,, ' !+4(?%"!! M.9. J!8!&,+%'*, '6;4,1!$ #4%15GF!8 ()&*+(8: «H+8%">!'(#$<, 1*GF*,
90
8*$%&!*4, "*#4%1#$'%""(#$<, %;( "*/(@4,GF*, ! 1%4*GF*, %;( 5#$(.>!'68, * ;4*'"68 ()&*+(8 «%#$%#$'%""6. ($)(&», $( &(/('(% 5#$&*"%"!% '#%;( 8%"%% #('%&7%""(;(, 8%"%% #(;4*#"(;( # $&%)('*"!,8! ?!+"! @&! 1*""6: 5#4('!,: – '($ (#"('* E$(;( 5>%"!,, ($/&6'*GF*, "*8 ' @&!&(1% &%*4<"5G "*4!>"(#$< #4(?"(;( !#$(&!>%#/(;( @&(2%##*, "%8!"5%8( "*@&*'4,GF%;( (&;*"!+8 @( @5$! #('%&7%"#$'('*"!,» (296, #. 22). R*5>"(% /*>%#$'( 1*&'!"('#/(;( E'(4G2!(""(;( 5>%"!, (@&%1%4!4(#< ' &*8/*: 1%.#$'%""(;( @&%$'(&%"!, E8@!&!>%#/(;( ! &*2!("*4<"(;( "*>*4 ' !: %1!"#$'%, ' @&(2%##% 86#4!$%4<"(;( – $%(&%$!>%#/! ()()F*GF%;( ! ()I,#",GF%;( (#'(%"!, )(;*$%.7%;(, @&%1'*&!$%4<"( "*/(@4%""(;( A*/$!>%#/(;( 8*$%&!*4*. B&(>"(% (#"('*"!% E$(;( 5>%"!, #(#$*'!4 «/(4(##*4<"6. A*/$!>%#/!. 8*$%&!*4, 1(4?%"#$'('*'7!. (:'*$!$< #( '#%: #$(&(" #4(?"6., +*@5$*""6. '(@&(# ( '!1%» ($*8 ?%, #. 43). L$($ 8*$%&!*4 "%():(1!8( )64( (:'*$!$< ()I%1!",GF%., &5/('(1,F%. !1%%., $( %#$< !1:.17'-8 %;(, 4(;!>%#/! 5@(&,1(>!$<, #1%4*$< "%():(1!86% '6'(16, $%(&%$!>%#/! (A(&8!$< !:, @4(1($'(&"( +*1%.#$'('*$< $%+'!"%78"!* "*>*4( ' #A%&% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. L$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'( J!8!&,+%' @(1>%&/!'*%$ (#()(: «R* @%&'(. #$*1!! &*+'!$!, #'(%;( $&51* K*&'!" @&%1#$*'4,%$#, "*8 $'(&2(8 ;%"!*4<"(. ;!@($%+6, (@!&*GF%.#, "* /(4(##*4<"6. +*@*# A*/$('. B%&%:(1!8 /( '$(&(. #$*1!!. WF% 8*4( "*@*#$< "* #>*#$4!'5G 86#4<, – "5?"( %% &*+'!$<. R* E$(. #$*1!! "*$5&*4!#$ "*!)(4%% "5?1*%$#, ' $(8 /*>%#$'%, /($(&(% (#()%""( :*&*/$%&!+5%$ 1%,$%4<"(#$< A!4(#(A(' ! 8*$%8*$!/(', - ' #@(#()"(#$! '6#4%1!$< 86#4< '( '#%: %% !+;!)*:, 5#8($&%$<, 1( 8*4%.7!: @(1&()"(#$%., @(#4%1#$'!,, '6$%/*GF!% !+ ()F%;( @(4(?%"!,, @&%15@&%1!$< '#% '(+8(?"6% @&($!'(&%>!,. H ' E$(8 ($"(7%"!! $&51 K*&'!"* @&%1#$*'4,%$#, &%1/( 1(#$!;*%868 ()&*+2(8» (351, #. 102). P*8 @&(2%## &*2!("*4<"(;( (#'(%"!, A*/$!>%#/(;( 8*$%&!*4* ' !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! K*&'!"* – E$(, @( #4('*8 J!8!&,+%'*, «/(4(##*4<"6. $&51 – *"*4!+*, !#>%&@6'*GF%;( '#% #$(&("6 '(@&(#*, 7!&(/( ()()F*GF%;( #!"$%+* ! )4%#$,F!: @&('%&(>"6: !##4%1('*"!., #4('(8, '#%;( $(;(, !+ >%;( #4*;*%$#, '#,/(% '%4!/(% @&(!+'%1%"!% "*5/!» (296, #. 17). B&! E$(8 J!8!&,+%' ()&*F*%$ '"!8*"!% ! "* #5F%#$'%""( '*?"6. &'7!1!&16'= *#@%/$ ' &*2!("*4<"(. #(#$*'4,GF%. 1*&'!"('#/(;( 5>%"!,. «K4, $(;(, >$()6 ()I,#"!$< @&(!#:(?1%"!% (&;*"!+8(' %#$%#$'%""68 @5$%8, "5?"( "*.$! /4G> 14, ()I,#"%"!, (#"('"(. >%&$6 '#%;( (&;*"!+('*""(;( 8!&*, – %;( $*/ "*+6'*%8(. 2%4%#(()&*+"(#$!, %;( #('%&7%"#$'*; (" #(+"*'*4, >$( (#"('"(. A!4(#(A#/!. '(@&(# +*/4G>*%$#, ' 5#$&*"%"!! -*!7!#'0*16!= $(>/! +&%"!,, ' +*8%"% 6!"*0"!= @&!>!"6 @&!>!"(. 1%.#$'!$%4<"(., *1-*1-9*""!=» ($*8 ?%, #. 43). J5 ?% A!4(#(A#/5G @(1(@4%/5 '61%4!4 ' 1*&'!"!+8% ! =. =%4<8;(4<2: «J%(&!, K*&'!"* #(1%&?!$ #5F%#$'%""( "('5G $'(&>%#/5G 86#4<. 3"* @(/*+6'*%$, /*/!8 ()&*+(8 2%4%#(()&*+"(#$< ' ()&*+('*"!!
91
(&;*"!+8(' 8(?%$ @&(!+(.$! )%+ '8%7*$%4<#$'* &*+58*, @&! @(8(F! #4%@(;( 1%.#$'!, +*/("* @&!&(16» (109, #. 92). C ()F%8 @4*"%, A!/#!&5, (),+*$%4<"(#$< A!4(#(A#/(;( "*>*4* ' 1*&'!"!+8%, !+'%#$"6. "%8%2/!. 5>%"6. -. 0&*"#E @!#*4: « 6 "*:(1!8 $5$ "*)4G1%""6% A*/$6, '6'%1%""6% !+ "!: ;!@($%+6, (#"('*""6% "* $%: ! 1&5;!: $%(&!!, #4('(8, – 2%46. )5/%$ @&()4%8, >*#$%#/!:, >*#$%#/!:, >*#$%#/!:» (384, #. 3). C A!4(#(A#/(., * &*'"( ! ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(. #(#$*'4,GF!: E'(4G2!(""(;( 5>%"!, ' @&(2%##% %;( #$*"('4%"!, ! &*+&*)($/! #'(G "%8*4('*?"5G &(4< #6;&*4! 7'0"!1-".= A*/$(& ! #',+*""(% # "!8 -9!$0*16!* "*>*4( ' !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! K*&'!"*. C %% "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 (#5F%#$'4%"!! ' @(4"(. 8%&% @&(,'!4!#< %;( 4!>"6% /*>%#$'*, %;( $'(&>%#/!% #@(#()"(#$!, :*&*/$%&!+5, /($(&6%, J!8!&,+%' @!#*4: « 6 1(4?"6 @&!+"*$< ' 5>%"(8 $'(&2* ;%"!*4<"(. ;!@($%+6, ()4*1*GF%;( "%($&*+!8(G 4(;!/(. ! $*4*"$(8 !##4%1('*$%4,, 1'58, /*>%#$'*8!, 1(+'(4!'7!8! %85 '6#4%1!$< ! @&('%&!$< "('68! A*/$*8! #@&*'%14!'(#$< E$(. ;!@($%+6 ! $*/!8 ()&*+(8 @&%'&*$!$< %% ' @(>$! "%#(8"%""5G "*5>"5G $%(&!G. 31"!8 #4('(8, 86 1(4?"6 @&!+"*$< ' "%8 &%1/(%, ;*&8("!>%#/(% #(>%$*"!% $%: (#"('"6: /*>%#$', /($(&6% ()&*+5G$ !1%*4<"6. $!@ 5>%"(;(» (351, #. 107). L$! 4!>"6% /*>%#$'* K*&'!"* ! @(8(;4! %85 (#5F%#$'!$< ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!! /*&1!"*4<"(% @&%()&*+('*"!%, #5F"(#$< /($(&(;( J!8!&,+%' 5#8($&%4 ' #4%15GF%8: «K*&'!"!+8 1*4 ' @%&'6. &*+ 8%:*"!>%#/(% ()I,#"%"!% #('%&7%"#$'*, 2%4%#(()&*+"(#$! (&;*"!+8(', &*+58%, @(1 :*D%"'0*16': ()I,#"%"!%8 ()6/"('%""(% 6%;,%78"!*, ' ($4!>!% ($ -*7*!7!#'0*16!#!» ($*8 ?%, #. 298). H ' 2%4(8 «# 1*&'!"!+8(8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!% #$*4( – "% "* #4('*: $(4"(8 @4*"% @&!8%"!$%4<"( / 1*&'!"!+85, / %;( 8%#$5 ! &(4! ' !#$(&!! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, :*&*/$%&%" '6'(1, / /($(&(85 @&!:(1!$ -. 0&*"#E: «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» (384, #. 7). M E$(85 8"%"!G %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4, 8(?"( 1()*'!$< *"*4(;!>"(% 8"%"!% A!4(#(A*. Q. -*##%4, !8%, ' '!15 $% ?% @&!"2!@!*4<"5G "('!+"5 ! &%'(4G2!(""6. :*&*/$%& (#"('(@(4*;*GF!: 1*&'!"('#/!: !1%., @!#*4: «N%8 =*4!4%. ! R"(8 @4*"%. N$( /*#*%$#, A!4(#(A#/(;( *#@%/$*, $( ( "%8 ' $(8 ?% 15:% '6#/*+*4#,, "*@&!8%&, L";%4<#: K*&'!", @(
92
%;( 8"%"!G, «"*"%# #!4<"%.7!. 51*& 8%$*A!+!>%#/(85 '+;4,15 "* @&!&(15, 1(/*+*', >$( '%#< #('&%8%""6. (&;*"!>%#/!. 8!&, &*#$%"!, ! ?!'($"6%, *, #4%1('*$%4<"(, $*/?% ! >%4('%/, %#$< @&(15/$ @&(2%##* &*+'!$!,, 14!'7%;(#, 8!44!("6 4%$» (406, #. 668). !&('(++&%">%#/5G +"*>!8(#$< '%4!/(;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( ($/&6$!, – $%(&!! &*+'!$!,, &*+&*)($*""(. K*&'!"(8, – L";%4<# 5#8*$&!'*4 ' #4%15GF%8: «C (#"('"6: >%&$*: 5#$*"('4%" &,1 &*+'!$!, (&;*"!+8(' ($ "%8"(;!: @&(#$6: A(&8 1( '#% )(4%% 8"(;(()&*+"6: ! #4(?"6:.., /(">*, >%4('%/(8. Q4*;(1*&, E$(85 "% $(4%#/(. ?!+"!, "( ! 1*"* (#"('* 14, @&%16#$(&!! >%4('%>%#/(;( 15:*, 14, @&(#4%?!'*"!, &*+4!>"6: #$5@%"%. %;( &*+'!$!,, "*>!"*, ($ @&(#$(., )%##$&5/$5&"(., "( (F5F*GF%. &*+1&*?%"!% @&($(@4*+86 "!+7!: (&;*"!+8(' ! /(">*, 86#4,F!8 8(+;(8 >%4('%/*. 9 )%+ E$(. @&%16#$(&!! #5F%#$'('*"!% 86#4,F%;( >%4('%>%#/(;( 8(+;* (#$*%$#, >51(8»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–1919). P #*8(;( "*>*4* #'(%. "*5>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! (" ;45)(/( ! @(4"( (#(+"*4 #5F"(#$< 1*&'!"('#/(;( 5>%"!,, %;( !#/4G>!$%4<"( '*?"(%, "%@&%:(1,F%% +"*>%"!% 14, "*5/!. K*&'!", @( %;( #4('*8, «5)%1!$%4<"( ()(#"('*4 5>%"!% ( &*+'!$!! @&! @(8(F! #'(%. $%(&!! ! "%():(1!868! '6'(1*8! @(#4%1"%. '6+'*4… &%7!$%4<"6. @('(&($ '( '#%8 8!&('(++&%"!! >%4('%>%#$'*… L$( (;&(8"(% &*#7!&%"!% "*7%;( /&5;(+(&*, )%+ #(8"%"!,, ,'4,%$#, "*!)(4%% ;45)(/!8 ! '*?"68 +*'(%'*"!%8 ' &,15 '%4!>*.7!: "*5>"6: 5#@%:(' "*7%;( '&%8%"!» (89, #. 17). Q4*;($'(&"(% '4!,"!% 1*&'!"('#/(;( E'(4G2!(""(;( 5>%"!,, @&%?1% '#%;( ' %;( ()F%A!4(#(A#/(., 8!&('(++&%">%#/(. >*#$!, !#@6$*4 "* #%)% ! #*8 =%//%4<. H+'%#$"6. ' $( '&%8, @(@54,&!+*$(& 1*&'!"!+8* C. Q%4<7% (#()( ($8%$!4 $( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, >$( (#"('(@(4*;*GF!% !1%! K*&'!"*
93
4%;4! /&*%5;(4<"68 /*8"%8 8!&('(++&%"!, =%//%4, ' $(. >*#$!, /($(&*, /*#*%$#, "*!)(4%% #5F%#$'%""6: #$(&(" 8!&(+1*"!, – ?!+"! "* V%84% ! >%4('%/* ' @&!&(1%: «K*&'!"('#/!% !1%! #('%&7*G$ (;&(8"6. @%&%'(&($ ' %;( 157%. R* '#%: 5;4*: ! '#%: /("2*: 14, "%;( '6&*#$*G$ !+ (#"('"(. $%(&!! K*&'!"* #*86% #8%46% $%(&%$!>%#/!% ! @&*/$!>%#/!% @&()4%86. B&%?1% '#%;( %85 /*?%$#,, >$( 1'* 5;4* ' 5>%"!! K*&'!"* 1(4?"6 @(45>!$< #('%&7%""( #'(%()&*+"5G ! (&!;!"*4<"5G A!+!("(8!G. C"!+5 5;(4 5 &(1(#4('"(. 8!&*, $( %#$< $*8, ;1% '(()F% "*>!"*%$#, ?!+"<. C'%&:5 '%"%2 '#,/(;( +%8"(;( &*+'!$!, – $* A(&8*, ' /($(&(. >%4('%/ @&!#(%1!",%$#, / E$(. &(1(#4('"(.. 0!4(#(A#/!. "%&' (@&%1%4,%$, @( %;( 8"%"!G, ()* E$! @5"/$*» (18, #. 54–55). P*8 =%//%4< #>!$*4, >$( 8!&('(++&%">%#/(% +"*>%"!% 1*&'!"!+8* +*/4G>*%$#, @&%?1% '#%;( ' 5#$&*"%"!! !+ "*5/! *"$&(@(2%"$&!>%#/!: @&%1#$*'4%"!. ! ' #(($'%$#$'5GF%8 /(&%""(8 @&%()&*+('*"!! #*8(. "*5/!. J*/, ()&*F*,#< / K*&'!"5 ' (1"(8 !+ @!#%8, =%//%4< @(1>%&/"54: «C6 @(/*+*4! >%4('%/5 %;( !#$!""(% 8%#$( ' @&!&(1% ! $%8 #*868 "!+'%&;4! *"$&(@(2%"$&!>%#/!. '686#%4». H %F%: «C6 @(/*+*4! >%4('%>%#/(. "*5/% "* '#% '&%8%"* "('6. @5$< ! @(1",4! )!(4(;!G "* 5&('%"< 8%:*"!>%#/(;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!,» (431, #. 156). U*&*/$%&!+5, #(1%&?*"!% ! 8%$(1!/5 !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! K*&'!"*, =%//%4< '61%4!4 ' "%. #4%15GF!% 8(8%"$6: «…V1%#< ()"*&5?!'*%$#, #$&(;!. '"5;6-'9".= :*&*/$%& %;( ()&*+2('6: 8%$(1(' !##4%1('*"!,, >!#$( *";4!.#/(% #$&%84%"!% '#% ()(#"('*$< 8*##(. $(>"( "*)4G1%""6: A*/$(' ! ' $( ?% '&%8, 7!&(/!. ! ,#"6. A!4(#(A#/!. '+;4,1 "* @&!>!""5G #',+< E$!: '%4!/(4%@"6: ,'4%"!., >*#$( /*?5F!:#, !+(4!&('*""68!» (94, #. 35). =45)(/( ! '#%#$(&(""% (#'(!' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(% ! A!4(#(A#/(% #(1%&?*"!% 1*&'!"('#/(;( E'(4G2!(""(;( 5>%"!,, @&("!/"5'7!#< %;( @&!"2!@*8! ! (#"('(@(4*;*GF!8! !1%,8!, =%//%4< +*$%8 (>%"< 8"(;( #1%4*4 14, %;( @(@54,&!+*2!!, 14, 7!&(/(;( &*#@&(#$&*"%"!, ' /&5;*: "*5>"(. !"$%44!;%"2!!, ' ()F%#$'%""(8 #(+"*"!! $(;( '&%8%"!. M*/ #'!1%$%4<#$'5%$ -. 0&*"#E, «# +*8%>*$%4<"(. 7!&($(. '+;4,1* ! 51!'!$%4<"(. !#/&%""(#$$( !##4%1('*"!, ! !1%! K*&'!"* 1(#$!;4! $(;( "%()6>*."(;( /54<$5&"(;( '4!,"!,, /($(&(% ("! !8%4!. J(4"(. #!#$%8(. ! '(7%4 ' #(#$*' A!4(#(A!!»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
94
C ()I,#"%"!! ?!+"! =%//%4< !#:(1!4 !+ *$(8!#$!>%#/!: @&%1#$*'4%"!.. 3" @!#*4, ' >*#$"(#$!: «\!+"< '#,/(;( (&;*"!>%#/(;( !"1!'!1* "% >$( !"(%, /*/ "%@&%&6'"*, 2%@< #4(?"6: 8*$%&!*4<"6: ,'4%"!. 1'!?%"!,. L$! 1'!?%"!, 8(;5$ )6$< &*##8*$&!'*%86, /*/ !+8%"%"!, @(4(?%"!, ! #(#$*'* 8(4%/54, 8%4<>*.7!: >*#$!2 ?!'(. 8*$%&!!, #(#$(,F!: !+ '%#<8* &*+"(()&*+"( #4(?%""6: *$(8('» (89, #. 141). 0!+!>%#/!% ! :!8!>%#/!% ($"(7%"!, 8%?15 *$(8*8! ! 8(4%/54*8!, #(#$*'4,GF!8! ?!'(. (&;*"!+8, 4%?*$ ' (#"('% A!+!(4(;!>%#/!: A5"/2!., $( %#$< ()F!: ?!+"%""6: ($"(7%"!. #*8!: (&;*"!+8('. L$! A!+!(4(;!>%#/!% A5"/2!! '6#$5@*G$ ' '!1% 1'5: «'%4!/!: (&;*"!>%#/!: ()&*+('*$%4<"6: #!4, "%17*51-9*""!1-' # (1"(. #$(&("6 ! 2$'12!1!<7*"'( – # 1&5;(.» ($*8 ?%, #. 139). R*#4%1#$'%""(#$< ! @&!#@(#()4%"!% #'(1,$#, / 1'58 1&5;!8 A5"/2!,8 (&;*"!+8* – A5"/2!,8 &*+8"(?%"!, ! @!$*"!,. =%//%4< 1*%$ 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(% @( #5$! ()I,#"%"!% "*#4%1#$'%""(#$! ! @&!#@(#()4%"!,. «R*#4%1#$'%""(#$<, – @!#*4 (", – ' #5F"(#$! ()5#4('4!'*%$#, 8*$%&!*4<"(. "%@&%&6'"(#$*#$! 8*$%&!*4<"68 &*'%"#$'(8 @&(!+'(1,F%;( ! @&(!+'(1!8(;( (&;*"!+8*, &(1!$%4%. ! 1%$%.… /$'12!1!<7*"'* !4! !+8%",%8(#$< ,'4,%$#, %1!"#$'%""( $(4"*, 1%,$%4<"(#$< =%//%4, (:'*$6'*4* ! 1&5;!% "*@&*'4%"!, &*+'!$!, 1*&'!"!+8* ! '( '#%: )64* #$(4< ?% @4(1($'(&"(.. J*/, =%//%4< ,'!4#, '!1"%.7!8 @&%1#$*'!$%4%8 A!4(;%"%$!>%#/(;( "*@&*'4%"!, ' +((4(;!!. C #'(]8 5>%"!! ( A!4(;%"%+% (" #$&%8!4#,, ' >*#$"(#$!, '(##$*"('!$< ;%"%*4(;!>%#/(% &(1#$'( '#%: '!1(' ! $%8 #*868 '(##(+1*$< !#$(&!G "% $(4%#/(;( 8!&* ' 2%4(8 ' '!1% «&(1(#4('"(;( 1&%'*». J%(&%$!>%#/5G )*+5 5>%"!, ( A!4(;%"%+% =%//%4< "*7]4 ' E8)&!(4(;!!, @%&%1 /($(&(. ' #'%$% 1*&'!"!+8* '(+"!/4* @&()4%8* #(($"(7%"!, !"1!'!15*4<"(;( &*+'!$!, (#()! (("$(;%"%+) ! !#$(&!! '!1* (A!4(;%"%+). B%&'(% @&!)4!?%""(% &%7%"!% E$(. @&()4%86 ! 1*4 =%//%4<, * $*/?% 0. G44%&. B&*'1*, 1( "!: 1*""(. @&()4%8(. +*"!8*4#, ! K*&'!", "( E$( (#$*4(#< "%+*8%>%""68. B(+1"%%, ' «9'$()!(;&*A!!» K*&'!" @!#*4, >$( G44%& ! =%//%4< &*+&*)($*4! @&()4%85 #(($"(7%"!, ("$(;%"%+* ! A!4(;%"%+* «;(&*+1( )(4%% @(4"( ! ' "%/($(&6: ($"(7%"!,: )(4%% @&*'!4<"(, >%8 E$( #1%4*4 ,. (!: 8*$%&!*4(' @( E$(85 '(@&(#5 :'*$!4( )6 "* 2%45G ;4*'5, ! , 1(4?%" )64 &*+'%&"5$< ()#5?1%"!% %;( # )(4<7(. @(1&()"(#$%'!1"(, >$( 8"% "% 51*4(#< @&(!+'%#$! '@%>*$4%"!% "* 8(!: >!$*$%4%.;
95
(1"*/( !8%""( $(85, /$( #58%4 1()!$<#, E$(;(, ! 1(4?"* )6$< ($1*"*, @( 8(%85 8"%"!G, '#, >%#$< (($/&6$!,)» (139, #. 135). -%7*, @&()4%85 #(($"(7%"!, ("$(;%"%+* ! A!4(;%"%+*, =%//%4< '6,'!4 ! ()(#"('*4 +*/(", "*+'*""6. !8 (#"('"68 )!(;%"%$!>%#/!8 +*/("(8. B&! E$(8 =%//%4< 7!&(/( !#@(4<+('*4 &%+54<$*$6 E8)&!(4(;!>%#/!: !##4%1('*"!. 9.3. M('*4%'#/(;(. P5$< +*/("* ' $(8, >$( ("$(;%"%+ ,'4,%$#, /&*$/!8 ! #?*$68 A!4(;%"%+(8. «3)* &,1* (&;*"!>%#/(;( &*+'!$!,, – @!#*4 =%//%4<, – ("$(;%"%+ !"1!'!1* ! A!4(;%"%+ @(/(4%"!,, / /($(&(85 (" @&!"*14%?!$, "*:(1,$#, ' $%#"%.7%. @&!>!""(. #',+!. H#$(&!, +*&(167* %#$< !+'4%>%"!% !#$(&!! @(/(4%"!,, !4! 1&5;!8! #4('*8!: ("$(;%"!, %#$< (;4*'4%"!% A!4(;%"!!» (89, #. 231232). L$($ +*/(" =%//%4< &*#@&(#$&*"!4 ! "* >%4('%/*. B(1&()"(% ()(#"('*"!% E$(;( 1*"( !8 ' %;( «9"$&(@(;%"!!». C 2%4(8 ?% +*/(" #A(&854!&('*" =%//%4%8 #4%15GF!8 ()&*+(8: «3"$(;%"%+!#, !4! &*+'!$!% !"1!'!1*, %#$< /&*$/(% ! )6#$&(%, ()5#4('4!'*%8(% +*/("*8! "*#4%1#$'%""(#$! ! @&!#@(#()4%"!, @('$(&%"!% ((;4*'4%"!%) A!4(;%"%+!#* !4! &*+'!$!, #(($'%$#$'5GF%;( !"1!'!1*. L$( A5"1*8%"$*4<"(% @(4(?%"!% %#$< '*?"%.7!. ()F!. +*/(" (&;*"!>%#/(;( &*+'!$!,, (#"('"(. )!(;%"%$!>%#/!. +*/("» ($*8 ?%, #. 232). =%//%4< &*#@&(#$&*"!4 E'(4G2!(""5G !1%G ! "* 8!/&(8(&A(4(;!G. C #'(%. &*)($% «3)F*, 8(&A(4(;!, (&;*"!+8('» (" (>%"< 8"(;( '"!8*"!, 51%4,4 @&()4%8*8 /4%$(>"(. $%(&!! # $(>/! +&%"!, 5#$*"('4%""(. !8 #:%86 E'(4G2!(""(;( &*+'!$!, (&;*"!+8(' («A!4(;%"%$!>%#/(% 1&%'(»). C 5>%"!! =%//%4, ( A!4(;%"%+% /4%$/* !;&*%$ '%#<8* +"*>!$%4<"5G &(4<, ("* &*##8*$&!'*4*#< !8 /*/ (#"('* (@&%1%4%"!, !"1!'!15*4<"(#$! ?!'6: #5F%#$', * $*/?% /*/ !#:(1"*, A(&8* &*+'!$!, ?!+"! "* V%84%. =%//%4< 5?% ($>]$4!'( #(+"*'*4, >$( /4%$/* #*8* @( #%)% ()4*1*%$ #4(?"(. #$&5/$5&(., E4%8%"$6 /($(&(. '6@(4",G$ &*+4!>"6% A5"/2!!. 3" '61%4,%$ ' "%. 1'% */$!'"6% >*#$!, !+ /($(&6: «'"5$&%""%% ,1&( +*'%15%$ "*#4%1#$'%""(. @%&%1*>%. "*#4%1#$'%""( @&!()&%$*%86: @&!+"*/(', '"%7",, ?% 27%,:% (!4! 2!$(@4*+8*) !#@(4",%$ +*1*>5 @&!#@(#()4%"!, / 5#4('!,8 '"%7"%;( 8!&*» ($*8 ?%, #. 223). =%//%4< #$&%8!4#, $*/?% '6,'!$< @%&%:(1"6% #$5@%"! 8%?15 #4(?"68 E4%8%"$*&"68 (&;*"!+8(8 ! "%(&;*"!>%#/(. 8*$%&!%.. =%//%4< @%&'6. &*+&*)($*4 $%(&!G 8"(;(/4%$(>"(#$!, #(;4*#"( /($(&(. /(4("!*4<"6% (&;*"!+86 (;&5@@* #:(1"6: /4%$(/) @&%'&*$!4!#< ' 8"(;(/4%$(>"6% #5F%#$'*, #(#$(,F!% !+ /4%$(/, ($4!>*GF!:#, &*+4!>"(. #$&5/$5&(. ! A5"/2!%.. P ,'"( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!: @(+!2!. &%7*4 =%//%4< ! (1"5 !+ '*?"%.7!: @&()4%8 )!(4(;!! – @&()4%85 '(+"!/"('%"!, ?!+"! "* V%84%. C E$(8 '(@&(#% (" /&!$!/('*4 K*&'!"* +* %;( 5#$5@/! &%4!;!!. J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, =%//%4< '(+&*?*4 @&($!' #4%15GF%;( 5$'%&?1%"!, K*&'!"*: «X 1(@5#/*G, >$(, @( '#%. '%&(,$"(#$!, '#% (&;*"!>%#/!% #5F%#$'*, /(;1*4!)( ?!'7!% "* V%84%, '(+"!/4! ($ (1"(. @%&'!>"(. A(&86, '@%&'6% (15:($'(&%""(. J'(&2(8, #(()F!'7!8 %. ?!+"<». B&!'%1, E$( '6#/*+6'*"!% K*&'!"*, * $*/?% '61%&?/5 !+ @!#<8* K*&'!"5 "%/(%;(
96
15:('"(;( *'$(&*, (1()&!$%4<"( ($(+'*'7%;(#, ( @(1()"6: %;( 5#$5@/*: &%4!;!!, =%//%4< +*/4G>*%$: «J%, 14, /($(&6: '%&* ' #'%&:I%#$%#$'%""(% $'(&%"!% #(#$*'4,4* "%():(1!8(#$< 15:*, 8(;4! 5#@(/(!$<#, @&! E$(8 @&%1#$*'4%"!!. 3"! 8(;4! #('8%#$!$< #'(G '%&5 # $%(&!%. !+8%",%8(#$! '!1(': ! ' #*8(8 1%4%, ("! ;(&*+1( )(4<7% 1(4?"6 )64! 51!'4,$<#, #!4% !+()&%$*$%4<"(#$! ! 851&(#$! $'(&2*, #(+1*'7%;( (1!" %1!"#$'%""6. @%&'("*>*4<"6. (&;*"!+8, #@(#()"6. &*+'!$< !+ #%), @&! @(#&%1#$'% "*#4%1#$'%""(#$! ! @&!#@(#()4%"!, '#% (#$*4<"6%, >%8 ($1%4<"(85 "%+*'!#!8(85 $'(&%"!G &*+4!>"6: '!1('» ($*8 ?%, #. 254–255). J*/(. $(>/% +&%"!, =%//%4< @&($!'(@(#$*'4,%$ #'(] @("!8*"!% '(+"!/"('%"!, ?!+"!, @("!8*"!%, "% (#$*'4,GF%% 8%#$* "!/*/(85 '8%7*$%4<#$'5 #'%&:I%#$%#$'%""6: #!4. P('%&7%""( "%1(@5#$!8(, #>!$*4 (", «&*##8*$&!'*$< /*/!%-4!)( ,'4%"!, ?!+"!, /*/ &%+54<$*$ #'%&:I%#$%#$'%""(. >',"*""!= 1'7., (#()%""(., 2%4%#(()&*+"( 1%.#$'5GF%. #!46, #$(,F%. '"% 8*$%&!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 265). C #'(]8 @("!8*"!! '(+"!/"('%"!, ?!+"! =%//%4< !#:(1!4 !+ 8*$%&!*4<"(;( %1!"#$'* "%(&;*"!>%#/(. ! (&;*"!>%#/(. @&!&(16. W#4! @&!+"*$< E$( %1!"#$'(, $( «'(+"!/"('%"!% @%&'(;( (&;*"!+8* !+ "%(&;*"!>%#/(. 8*$%&!! #$*"%$ $(;1* ;(&*+1( 4%;>% 1(@5#$!868 ! 45>7% @("!8*%868, >%8 E$( )64( 1( $(;( '&%8%"!, ! '8%#$% # $%8 )51%$ 5#$&*"]" ! !#/5##$'%""6. *)#(4G$"6. &5)%? 8%?15 (&;*"!>%#/(. ! "%(&;*"!>%#/(. @&!&(1(., 8%?15 (157%'4]""68! ! 8]&$'68! %#$%#$'%""68! $%4*8!» ($*8 ?%, #. 268). 3&;*"!>%#/*, 8*$%&!,, @( 8"%"!G =%//%4,, – (1"* !+ A(&8 #(%1!"%"!, 5;4%&(1*. P(%1!",,#< # /!#4(&(1(8, '(1(&(1(8, *+($(8 ! A(#A(&(8, 5;4%&(1 ()&*+5%$ )%4/('6% $%4*. 3"! ! #45?*$ @%&'68 ! "%():(1!868 (#"('*"!%8 '#%: ,'4%"!. ?!+"!. «W1!"#$'%""( $(4%#/!% #'(.#$'* 5;4%&(1* ! !8%""( @(45?!1/(% *;&%;*$"(% #(#$(,"!% ! 4];/*, &*+&57*%8(#$< /&*."% #4(?"6: )%4/('6: #(%1!"%"!. 5;4%&(1* #5$< 8%:*"!>%#/!% @&!>!"6 $%: #'(%()&*+"6: ,'4%"!. 1'!?%"!,…, /($(&6% "*+6'*G$#, ' $%#"(8 #86#4% #4('* «?!+"!"*, # $(;( '&%8%"!, /(;1* V%84, )64* «(;"%""(–?!1/!8 7*&(8». C &%+54<$*$% @(#$%@%""(;( (:4*?1%"!, "* "%. ()&*+('*4*#< $']&1*, /(&*, * +*$%8 @(,'!4*#< ! '(1*. H $(4%#/(. !#$(&!! V%84! =%//%4< '6'(1!$ «$($ '*?"6. A*/$, >$( (&;*"!>%#/*, ?!+"< @(45>!4* #'(] "*>*4( ' (@&%1%4]""(% '&%8,, >$( +%8"6% (&;*"!+86 "% !#/("! #5F%#$'5G$, * '(+"!/4! ' @%&'6. &*+ ' /*/(.-4!)( (@&%1%4]""6. 8(8%"$» ($*8 ?%, #. 260–261).
97
§ 5. D3=<=D A=C=232N=: 724F=MDE=9 = 6HDM7DE=9 0!+!(4(;!, ' XIX '%/% #$*4* (1"(. !+ '%15F!: ($&*#4%. %#$%#$'(+"*"!,. O>%"6% &*+"6: #$&*" #'(!8! @4(1($'(&"68! !##4%1('*"!,8! #@(#()#$'('*4! %% 5#@%7"(85 &*+'!$!G, ()(;*F%"!G %% )4%#$,F!8! 1(#$!?%"!,8!. J*/, ' =%&8*"!! '!1"%.7!8! A!+!(4(;*8! )64! H. G44%& (1801–1858), @&(#4*'!'7!.#, #'(!8! &*)($*8! ' ()4*#$! !+5>%"!, 8%:*"!+8* >5'#$'%""6: '(#@&!,$!., * $*/?% ' ()4*#$! #&*'"!$%4<"(. *"*$(8!! ! E8)&!(4(;!!; -. C!&:(' (1821–1902), /&5@"%.7!. @*$(4(;, #$*'7!. (#"('(@(4(?"!/(8 2%44G4,&"(. @*$(4(;!!; =. =%4<8;(4<2 (1821–1894), #(+1*$%4< $%(&!! :(1* 45>%. ' ;4*+5, 5>%"!, () *//(8(1*2!!; L. KG)5*–-%.8(" (1818–1896), ()(#"('*'7!. +*/(" '(+)5?1%"!, "%&'* ! 86726, *'$(& 2%""6: &*)($ ( ?!'($"(8 E4%/$&!>%#$'% ! 1&. C -(##!! (#()%""( )(4<7(. '/4*1 ' &*+'!$!% A!+!(4(;!! '"%#4! $*/!% '%4!/!% &5##/!% 5>%"6%, /*/ H. . P%>%"(' (1829–1905), #(+1*'7!. 5>%"!% ( &%A4%/#*: ;(4('"(;( 8(+;*; H.H. %>"!/(' (1845–1916) #'(!8! ($/&6$!,8! ' 8!/&()!(4(;!! ! @*$(A!+!(4(;!!; M.9. J!8!&,+%' (1843– 1920) "('*$(&#/!8! &*)($*8! ' ()4*#$! A!+!(4(;!! &*#$%"!. ! 1&. C( 0&*"2!! /&5@"%.7!8 A!+!(4(;(8 XIX '%/* )64 M4(1 Q%&"*& (1813–1878), 5>%"6.–5"!'%&#*4, ()(;*$!'7!. #'(!8! )4%#$,F!8! ($/&6$!,8! @(>$! '#% ($&*#4! A!+!(4(;!! $(;( '&%8%"! – "(&8*4<"(. ! @*$(4(;!>%#/(., ' #A%&% !+5>%"!, ?!'(;( (&;*"!+8*, ' >*#$"(#$!, $*/!: #(#$*'"6: >*#$%. ! A*/$(&(' %;( ?!+"%1%,$%4<"(#$!, /*/ @%>%"<, /&('<, "%&'6, @!F%'*&%"!% ! 1&. M&(8% $(;(, M4(1 Q%&"*& #'(!8! !##4%1('*"!,8! +*4(?!4 (#"('6 E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"(. A*&8*/(4(;!! ! $(/#!/(4(;!!. R*/("%2, ' !#$(&!G "*5/! M. Q%&"*& '(7%4 /*/ #(+1*$%4< 5>%"!, ( ;(8%(#$*+%, /($(&68 (" ''%4 ' !+5>%"!% ?!'(;( (&;*"!+8* @&!"2!@ #*8(&%;54,2!!. C E$(8 ($"(7%"!! – ' @4*"% /*>%#$'%""(;( @&%()&*+('*"!, %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( 8674%"!, – M. Q%&"*&* @( @&*'5 #$*',$ &,1(8 # N. K*&'!"(8. M*/ @(1>%&/"54 .=. X&(7%'#/!., «;4*'"68! $'(&2*8! "('(. /*&$!"6 (&;*"!+8* )64! M. Q%&"*& ! N. K*&'!", @&%()&*+('*'7!% )!(4(;!>%#/(% 8674%"!% )4*;(1*&, 5$'%&?1%"!G "('(;(, 1%$%&8!"!#$#/(;( @(1:(1*, @&!"2!@(' !"$%;&*$!+8* ! #*8(&%;54,2!!» (419, #. 389). C &*#/&6$!! (#"(' ?!+"%1%,$%4<"(#$! (&;*"!+8* 5>%"!, K*&'!"* ! Q%&"*&* '+*!8"( 1(@(4",4! 1&5; 1&5;*; ' "!:, ' >*#$"(#$!, )64! &%*4!+('*"6 @&!"2!@6, «'6&*?%""6% K*&'!"(8 ! Q%&"*&(8 ' !: /*&$!"% (&;*"!+8* /*/ 2%4(#$"(. ! 2%4%5#$&%84%""(. #!#$%86, */$!'"( &%7*GF%. +*1*>! #(:&*"%"!, #'(!: (#"('"6: A!+!(4(;!>%#/!: /("#$*"$ (5>%"!% ( ;(8%(#$*+% Q%&"*&*) ' @&($!'('%# &*+&57*GF!8 '4!,"!,8 #&%16, / /($(&(. ("* @&!"(&*'4!'*%$#, (! @($(85 &*+'!'*%$#,) ' @&(2%##% %#$%#$'%""(;( ($)(&* (5>%"!% K*&'!"*)» ($*8 ?%, #. 402). R%#45>*."( @(E$(85 M.9. J!8!&,+%' "*+'*4 M. Q%&"*&* ' >!#4% ;4*'"6: 1'!;*$%4%. @%&%1('(. "*5>"(. 86#4! (#8. 352, #. 193). C #5F"(#$"(8 @("!8*"!! @(+"*'*$%4<"(. &%*4!+*2!! "*5>"(. 86#4! ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!! M. Q%&"*&, @(1()"( 1&5;!8 '61*GF!8#, 5>%"68, ' &,15
98
"%():(1!86: 5#4('!. 5#@%7"(;( (#5F%#$'4%"!, !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! '61%4,4 ! (@&%1%4%""6. #5)I%/$!'"6., 7'0"!1-".= A*/$(& ' %;( 1%.#$'%""6: -9!$0*16'D @&(,'4%"!,:. 3" 5$'%&?1*4 ' #',+! # E$!8, >$( «!#$!""6. "*5>"6. 8%$(1 #1%&?!'*%$ 58, "% @(1*'4,, %;(, @&%1(#$*'4,%$ %85 /*/ 8(?"( )(4<7% #*8(#$(,$%4<"(#$!, "*@&*'4,%$ %;(; 5'*?*, @&! E$(8 %;( $'(&>%#/5G (&!;!"*4<"(#$< ! "*5>"5G #*8(1%,$%4<"(#$<. R*5/! 1'!;*G$#, '@%&%1 $(4%#/!8 8(;5F%#$'(8 !4! (&!;!"*4<"(#$%&/!'*,, $*/!8 ()&*+(8, (),+*$%4<"(#$< 86#4!$%4<"(;(, $%+'!"%78"!#! "*>*4* ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!!, M. Q%&"*& '8%#$% # $%8 )%+(;('(&(>"( ($'%&;*4 %;( /&*."!% A(&86, 58(+&!$%4<"(#$<, *@&!(&!+8: « %$(1, #(#$(,F!. ' $(8, >$()6 #"*>*4* 1*'*$< (@&%1%4%"!, ! @($(8 '#% '6'(1!$< !+ (@&%1%4%"!..., @&($!'%" #*8(85 15:5 (@6$"6: "*5/» (26, #. 20). C $( ?% '&%8, M. Q%&"*& #>!$*4 "%@&!%84%8(. 14, "*5/! ! 1&5;5G /&*."(#$< – @4(#/!. E8@!&!+8, /($(&6., @( %;( 8"%"!G, «@&($!'(@(4(?%" &*2!("*4!+85; (" !#/4G>*%$ '#,/(% 58(+&%"!% ! @&!"!8*%$ $(4$()6 51%&?!'*$< ($ (7!)(/ @&! &*##5?1%"!!, $( #*8 @( #%)% (" #('%&7%""( "%1(#$*$(>%"; (" "!/(;1* "% #(+1*#$ "*#$(,F%. "*5/!, $*/ /*/ "*5/* $&%)5%$ '#%;1* '8%7*$%4<#$'* &*##51/* !, ' @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$< E8@!&!+85, 1(4?"* )6$< &*2!("*4<"*. H#$!"* "% 8(?%$ )6$< "%4(;!>"*, '#% !#$!""(% "%():(1!8( &*2!("*4<"(; '#%, ' /("2% /("2(', '(#:(1!$ / &*+585, '%4!/(85 /&!$%&!G M*"$*» (27, #. 434). B($&%)"(#$,8 "*5/!, #>!$*4 M. Q%&"*&, ($'%>*%$ ;*&8("!>%#/(% %1!"#$'( >5'#$'%""(;( (E8@!&!>%#/(;() ! &*2!("*4<"(;( "*>*4 ' "%.. «L/#@%&!8%"$*4<"6. 8%$(1 !F%$ !#$!"5 @&! ;*&8("!>%#/(8 5@($&%)4%"!! >5'#$'*, &*+58* ! (@6$*; %;( 1%'!+ – #'()(1* 58* ! 86#4!» (29, #. 61). P'()(1* 58* ! 86#4!, $( %#$< @(+"*"!, ' %;( $%+'!"%78"!: /*>%#$'%, @&!8%"!$%4<"( / %#$%#$'%""68 "*5/*8, / $(. ?% A!+!(4(;!!, "*@&!8%&, "%():(1!8( @&%1@(4*;*%$ (@&%1%4%""(% 5>*#$!% ! &'7!1!&16!#! 58*, A!4(#(A#/(. 86#4! ' #(($'%$#$'5GF%8 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @&%4(84%"!!, (#()%""( ' #A%&% $%(&%$!>%#/(;( (#'(%"!,, #5F"(#$"(;( (#86#4%"!, !+5>*%8(;( 8*$%&!*4*. M. Q%&"*& @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «B%&'(% 5#4('!% 14, 5>%"(;(, @&%1*GF%;(#, E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"(85 !##4%1('*"!G %#$%#$'%""6: ,'4%"!., #(#$(!$ ' $(8, >$()6 "% +*1*'*$<#, "!/*/(. #!#$%8(. ! #(:&*",$< @(4"5G #'()(15 58*, (#"('*""5G "* A!4(#(A#/(8 #(8"%"!!» ($*8 ?%). N$( /*#*%$#, 8%$(1(4(;!! E8@!&!>%#/(., E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"(. >*#$! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: !##4%1('*"!., ' >*#$"(#$!, A!+!(4(;!>%#/!:, $( +1%#< M. Q%&"*& )%+(;('(&(>"( !#/4G>*4 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/5G +"*>!8(#$< A!4(#(A!!, !8%, ' '!15 @&! E$(8 !+'%#$"6% %85 /("/&%$"6% A!4(#(A#/!% #!#$%86: «L/#@%&!8%"$*4<"*, A!+!(4(;!, "% !8%%$ "*1()"(#$! ()&*F*$<#, / /*/(. )6 $( "! )64( A!4(#(A#/(. #!#$%8%» ($*8 ?%, #. 62–63). C8%#$% # $%8
99
M. Q%&"*& @&!+"*'*4 /(#'%""5G @&!>*#$"(#$< $%: !4! !"6: A!4(#(A#/!: 5>%"!. / 1(#$!?%"!,8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!, – >%&%+ #$!854!&5GF%%, '(+)5?1*GF%% 1%.#$'!% "* 8674%"!% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%.. L$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'( M. Q%&"*& ($8%$!4, ' >*#$"(#$!, @( ($"(7%"!G / #%)%: «…H+)%;*, A!4(#(A#/!: #!#$%8, ,, $%8 "% 8%"%%, (>%"< 4G)4G A!4(#(A(' ! 8%", '%#<8* +*"!8*G$ !: 851&#$'('*"!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 63). B(+"*'*$%4<"*, EAA%/$!'"(#$< E$!: «851&#$'('*"!.»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«5/&%@4,G$ 58, &*+'!'*, %;( 58#$'%""(. ;!8"*#$!/(., ! ' $( ?% '&%8, @%&%"(#,$ %;( / "%!#>%&@*%868 &%7%"!,8 '%4!/!: '(@&(#('. 3"!, $*/!8 ()&*+(8, @(11%&?!'*G$ ?*?15 "%!+'%#$"(;( ! $($ #',F%""6. (;("< !##4%1('*"!,, /($(&6% "!/(;1* "% 1(4?"6 @&(@*1*$< ' 5>%"(8» ($*8 ?%, #. 64). H &*+I,#",, @(1 E$!8 5;4(8 +&%"!, #'(G @&!"2!@!*4<"5G @(+!2!G ' @("!8*"!! 8%#$* ! &(4! A!4(#(A!! ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, M. Q%&"*& @!#*4: «M*/ E/#@%&!8%"$*$(&, , !+)%;*G A!4(#(A#/!: #!#$%8, "( @&! E$(8 , "!#/(4%4('%>%#/!: +"*"!,:» ($*8 ?%, #. 63). C( '$(&(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/* (#()%""( )(4<75G &(4< ' 5#@%7"(8 &*+'!$!! A!+!(4(;!! #6;&*4 =. =%4<8;(4<2. M $(85, >$( ( "%8, /*/ () 5>%"(8, @!#*4! A!+!/!, 8(?"( 1()*'!$< :*&*/$%&"6% #'!1%$%4<#$'* A!+!(4(;('. J*/, @( 8"%"!G, L. KG)5*–-%.8("*, «=%4<8;(4<2 – #('%&7%""%.7!. ! '6#7!. $!@ $%(&%$!/*–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,… Q%#@&!8%&"*, @(@54,&"(#$< =%4<8;(4<2* ($>*#$! ()I,#",%$#, "%)6'*4(. &*+"(#$(&(""(#$%#/(;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, "*>!"*, # A!+!(4(;!>%#/(. *"*$(8!! ! /(">*, @#!:(A!+!/(.» (154, #. 2–3). C A!+!(4(;!>%#/(. >*#$! 8"(;(;&*""(;( "*5>"(;( $'(&>%#$'* =%4<8;(4<2* %;( ;4*'"*, +*1*>*, @( 8"%"!G H. . P%>%"('*, «4%?!$ ' $("/(. ()4*#$! >5'#$'('*"!,: +1%#< (" #(+1*4 A!+!/5 +'5/('6: (F5F%"!., @%&%&*)($*4 # 1&*;(2%""68! 1(@(4"%"!,8! '#G ()7!&"5G ()4*#$< A!+!(4(;!>%#/(. (@$!/! ! ' /("2% E$(;( 8"(;(4%$"%;( $&51* @&(4(?!4 A!+!(4(;!! @5$< ' ()4*#$< #*86: '6#(/!: @#!:!>%#/!: @&(,'4%"!., !8%""( ' #A%&5 86#4!, ($/&6' !#:(1"6% A(&86 +&!$%4<"(;( 8674%"!,» (335, #. 363–364). B&! E$(8 P%>%"(' (#()( @(1>%&/"54 @(+"*'*$%4<"5G +"*>!8(#$<, 1%.#$'%""(#$< $%+'!"%78"!= #(#$*'4,GF%. ! -9!$0*16!#!, 7'0"!1-"!#! "*>*4* ' @4(1($'(&"(. !##4%1('*$%4<#/(.
100
1%,$%4<"(#$! =%4<8;(4<2*: +* %;( /("/&%$"68! 1(#$!?%"!,8! «#/&6'*G$#, (;&(8"6% @(1'!;! $&51* ! '#% $(, >$( :*&*/$%&!+5%$ 1%4* ;%"!,–"*$5&*4!#$*: ;45)!"* 86#4!, $'(&>%#$'(, #(%1!"%""(% # )4%#/(8 (@6$*, ! &%+54<$*$6, ($/&6'*GF!% @&%%8"!/*8 "('6% 7!&(/!% ;(&!+("$6» ($*8 ?%, #. 364). M.9. J!8!&,+%' :*&*/$%&!+('*4 =%4<8;(4<2* /*/ «'%4!>*.7%;( 5>%"(;(–86#4!$%4,» (352, #. 244). =%4<8;(4<2, /*/ 5?% ($8%>*4(#<, "% (;&*"!>!4#, ' #'(!: !##4%1('*"!,: $(4%"(' @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «P4*'* =%4<8;(4<25 +* %;( 7*; ' @#!:(4(;!>%#/5G ()4*#$<, – !+ "%;( '6&(#4* "*!)(4%% &*+&*)($*""*, >*#$< #('&%8%""(. A!+!(4(;!>%#/(. @#!:(4(;!!». P%>%"(' ()&*$!4 '"!8*"!% $*/?% ! "* #5F%#$'%""( '*?"6. &'7!1!&16'= *#@%/$ ' "*5>"(8 $'(&>%#$'% =%4<8;(4<2*, (", ' >*#$"(#$!, #(;4*#!4#, # KG)5*–-%.8("(8 ' $(8, >$( «=%4<8;(4<2 #('8%F*4 ' #%)%, @&! A!4(#(A#/(8 58%, ' "%)6'*4(. %F% ' !#$(&!! "*5/! #$%@%"! 1*& *"*4!+* ! 1*& E/#@%&!8%"$*» (335, #. 374). P*8 =%4<8;(4<2 @&!+"*'*4 ()I%/$!'"5G "%():(1!8(#$< #(%1!"%"!, A!4(#(A#/!: ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: A(&8 +"*"!,, ! ' >*#$"(#$!, @&!8%"!$%4<"( / A!+!(4(;!! (" 5$'%&?1*4, >$( «$(>/*, ' /($(&(. )4!?% '#%;( A!4(#(A!, #$*4/!'*%$#, # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8, E$( 5>%"!% ( >5'#$'%""6: '(#@&!,$!,: >%4('%/*» (110, #. 5). C #*8(. A!4(#(A!! =%4<8;(4<2 )64 @(#4%1('*$%4%8 M*"$*, ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/!% !1%! /($(&(;( '6#(/( 2%"!4, @&%?1% '#%;( – ' @4*"% !: ()F%"*5>"(., ' $(8 >!#4% ! A!+!(4(;!>%#/(. +"*>!8(#$!. «0!4(#(A!, M*"$*, – @!#*4 (", – "% #$&%8!4*#< @&!58"(?!$< /(4!>%#$'( "*7%;( +"*"!, @5$%8 (1"(;( &*+8674%"!,, @($(85 >$( %% ;4*'"(% @(4(?%"!% #(#$(,4( ' $(8, >$( '#,/(% @(+"*"!% #5F%#$'5GF%;( 1(4?"( >%&@*$<#, !+ (@6$*; E$* A!4(#(A!, #$&%8!4*#< $(4!$< !#$(>"!/! "*7!: @(+"*"!. ! #$%@%"< !: 1(#$('%&"(#$!; E$( !+5>%"!% "*'#%;1* )51%$ @&%1(#$*'4%"( A!4(#(A!!, * ($/*+ ($ "%;( "!/(;1* "% @&(.1%$ )%+"*/*+*""(». U*&*/$%&"(, >$( @(1 E$!8 ?% 5;4(8 +&%"!, =%4<8;(4<2 5#8($&%4 (@&%1%4%""6% $(>/! #(@&!/(#"('%"!, A!4(#(A!! # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8, ' >*#$"(#$!, # A!+!(4(;!%. ' ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/!: '(++&%"!,: ! 1&5;(;( @&%1#$*'!$%4, "%8%2/(. /4*##!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!!: «H 0!:$%, E$($ '%4!/!. 86#4!$%4<, /($(&6. @(1 &5/('(1#$'(8 M*"$* "*>*4… #'(% "*5>"(% @(@&!F%, ! /($(&6. 5@(&"( @&($!'!4#, ()6>"(85 '(++&%"!G "* 8!&, "% "*:(1!4#,, "*#/(4!! # "*$5&*4!#$*8!. W;( @&%1#$*'4%"!, ( >5'#$'%""6: '(#@&!,$!,: #/(&%% "*:(1,$#, ' @(4"%.7%8 #(;4*#!! # $%8! 1*""68!, /($(&6% @(+?% A!+!(4(;!, (&;*"(' >5'#$' '6'%4* !+ (@6$*» ($*8 ?%, #. 4). C(+'&*F*,#< / $%8 :*&*/$%&!#$!/*8, /($(&6% P%>%"(' 1*'*4 =%4<8;(4<25 /*/ 5>%"(85 ! 86#4!$%4G, 8(?"( #/*+*$<, >$(, @( #5$!, E$( :*&*/$%&!#$!/! ! #*8(;( P%>%"('*, ' @(4"(. 8%&% @&!%84%86% ' (2%"/% %;( 8%#$* ! &(4! ' "*5/%, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' #A%&% A!+!(4(;!! ! @#!:(4(;!!. W;( 1(#$!?%"!, ' E$!: ()4*#$,: %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ($/&64! "('5G ;4*'5 '
101
!+5>%"!! "*!)(4%% #4(?"6: ()I%/$(' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, – ;(4('"(;( 8(+;* ?!'6: #5F%#$' ! !: @('%1%"!,, &%;54!&5%8(;( 1%,$%4<"(#$%"('68 5>%"!% ( &%A4%/#*: ;(4('"(;( 8(+;* /*&1!"*4<"( !+8%"!4( (#"('"5G "*@&*'4%""(#$< ! #(1%&?*"!% !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! ' $*/!: "*5/*:, /*/ "%.&(A!+!(4(;!, ! @#!:(4(;!,. C @%&'(. !+ "!: P%>%"(' &%*4!+('*4 !"$%;&*$!'"(–1!"*8!>%#/!. #@(#() !##4%1('*"!, $(;(, /*/ ($1%4<"6% "%&'"6% @&(2%##6, #(%1!",,#<, ()&*+5G$ %#$%#$'%""6% #(>%$*"!,. J%8 #*868 P%>%"(' @&%(1(4%4 @&%?"!. @(1:(1 – "* (#"('% «*"*$(8!>%#/(;( "*>*4*», (;&*"!>!'*'7%;( @(+"*"!% !+5>%"!%8 ($1%4<"6: >*#$%. "%&'"(. #!#$%86 '"% !: '+*!8(#',+!, &*##8*$&!'*%86: @(&(+"<, ()(#()4%""(. C #A%&% @#!:(4(;!! P%>%"(' $*/?% /(&%""68 ()&*+(8 !+8%"!4 (#"('"5G "*@&*'4%""(#$< *"*4!+* @#!:!>%#/!: ,'4%"!. – @%&%'%4 %% # !+5>%"!, A%"(8%"(' #(+"*"!,, &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( ' /*>%#$'% "%@&(#$&*"#$'%""(. #5F"(#$!, 1*""(. #5)I%/$5 ' %;( @%&%?!'*"!,:, "* @&(2%##6, 1(#$5@"6% ()I%/$!'"(85 "*)4G1%"!G ! &%A4%/$(&"6% @( @&(!#:(?1%"!G. 3@&%1%4,, "('(% "*5>"(% /*>%#$'( @#!:(4(;!!, P%>%"(' @(1>%&/"54, >$( «/*/ "*5/* ( 1%.#$'!$%4<"6: A*/$*: ("* @(+*)($!$#, @&%?1% '#%;( ($1%4!$< @#!:!>%#/!% &%*4<"(#$! ($ @#!:!>%#/!: A5"/2!.… C%&"*, "*>*45 !"15/2!!, ("* "% /!"%$#, #&*+5 ' ()4*#$< '6#7!: @#!:(4(;!>%#/!: @&(,'4%"!., * "*>"%$ #'(. /&(@($4!'6. $&51 # @&(#$%.7!: #45>*%'… M*/ (@6$"*, "*5/* ("* "% '(+'%1%$ "* #$%@%"< "%@(/(4%)!8(. !#$!"6 "!>%;(, >$( "% 8(?%$ )6$< @(1$'%&?1%"( #$&(;!8 (@6$(8; "* E$(8 (#"('*"!! ' 1()6$6: %G &%+54<$*$*: ;!@($%$!>%#/(% )51%$ #$&(;( ($1%4%"( ($ @(4(?!$%4<"(;(» (335, #. 242). -*#/&6'*, 1*4%% #'(! @&!"2!@!*4<"6% 5#$*"('/! ' ($"(7%"!! @#!:(4(;!!, P%>%"(' @!#*4: «…C #86#4% (@&%1%4%"!, ()F%;( :*&*/$%&* +*1*>, "*7 @&!"2!@ $&%)5%$, >$()6 @#!:(4(;!,, @(1()"( %% &(1"(. #%#$&% A!+!(4(;!!, ($'%>*4* $(4%#/(% 1'!?%"!%, @&(,'4,GF%%#, >5'#$'(8, (F5F%"!%8, @&%1#$*'4%"!%8, "%'(4<"68 !4! @&(!+'(4<"68 1'!?%"!%8, 6%6 @&(!#:(1,$ $% @&(2%##6, &%+54<$*$(8 /($(&6: ,'4,%$#, 86#4<, ! @&.» ($*8 ?%, #. 252). C 2%4(8 ?%, #(;4*#"( (@&%1%4%"!G P%>%"('*, «"*5>"*, @#!:(4(;!, @( '#%85 #'(%85 #(1%&?*"!G "% 8(?%$ )6$< "!>%8 !"68, /*/ &,1(8 5>%"!. ( @&(!#:(?1%"!! @#!:!>%#/!: 1%,$%4<"(#$%.» ($*8 ?%, #. 256). 31"( !+ $*/!: 5>%"!. – ( &%A4%/#*: ;(4('"(;( 8(+;* – 5#@%7"( &*+&*)($*4 #*8 P%>%"(', '"%#, $%8 #*868 '%#(86. '/4*1 ' 8!&('5G "*5/5. H ' 2%4(8 &%+54<$*$6 '#%. %;( 8"(;(;&*""(. !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! (/*+*4! )4*;($'(&"(% '4!,"!% "* @(#4%15GF%% &*+'!$!% %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, (#()%""( ' -(##!!. C "*7%. #$&*"%, /*/ @!#*4 M.9. J!8!&,+%', «A!+!(4(;!, 1(4?"* @&!+"*$< #'(%;( "%(#@(&!8(;( ($2* ' '6#(/($*4*"$4!'(. ! #$(4< ?% (&!;!"*4<"(. ! #'%$4(. 4!>"(#$! H'*"* !:*.4('!>* P%>%"('*. (?"( #/*+*$<, >$( E$( )64* #*8*, $!@!>%#/*, 2%"$&*4<"*, A!;5&* $(;( "*5>"(;( 1'!?%"!,, /($(&(% :*&*/$%&!+5%$
102
&*##8*$&!'*%85G "*8! E@(:5… W1'* 4! /*/(. !+ #('&%8%""6: %85 A!+!(4(;(' (+* !#/4G>%"!%8… =%4<8;(4<2*) ()4*1*4 $*/!8 7!&(/!8 (:'*$(8 ' #A%&% #'(!: #()#$'%""6: !##4%1('*"!., "*>!"*, # >!#$( A!+!>%#/!: !##4%1('*"!. ' ()4*#$! &*#$'(&%"!, ;*+(' ! /(">*, !##4%1('*"!%8 ' ()4*#$! "%&'"(. A!+!(4(;!! ! #$&(;( "*5>"(. @#!:(4(;!!, ;1% (" '6#$5@!4 $*/!8 ?% #$&(;!8 86#4!$%4%8, /*/ ! ' ()4*#$! A!+!(4(;!!… H, /("%>"(, )515F*, !#$(&!, @&!+"*%$, >$( "! (1!" &5##/!. 5>%"6. "% !8%4 $*/(;( 7!&(/(;( ! )4*;($'(&"(;( '4!,"!, "* &5##/5G "*5/5 ! &*+'!$!% "*5>"(;( 15:* ' "*7%8 ()F%#$'%…» (356, #. 165). B(#4%1"!% #4('* (/*+*4!#< @&(&(>%#/!8!: @&%1'!1%"!% J!8!&,+%'* ' @(4"(. 8%&% (@&*'1*4(#<. O@(8,"5$(% J!8!&,+%'68 !##4%1('*$%4<#/(% /*>%#$'( P%>%"('*, /*/ «#$&(;(;(», $( %#$< "*5>"( ()&*+('*""(;( 86#4!$%4,, ' @(4"(. 8%&% @&(,'!4(#< ! ' &%7%"!! !8 '(@&(#* ( A!4(#(A!! ' %% ($"(7%"!! / %#$%#$'(+"*"!G. H8%, ' '!15 (),+*$%4<"(% $%+'!"%78"!* "*>*4( ' "*5>"(8 @(+"*"!!, P%>%"(' @&!+"*'*4, >$( !+'%#$"*, %85 A!4(#(A!, (8%$*A!+!/*) #*8* @( #%)% "%():(1!8* ' "*5/%, !8%%$ (@&%1%4%""5G @(+"*'*$%4<"5G +"*>!8(#$<, ' >*#$"(#$!, ! ' %% A!+!(4(;!>%#/(8 ()(#"('*"!!. «M(&"! 8%$*A!+!>%#/!: 5>%"!., – @!#*4 P%>%"(', –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». R( ' &%*4<"(8 (#5F%#$'4%"!! A!4(#(A#/(;( @(+"*"!,, '(@4(F*GF%8#, ' /("/&%$"6: 8%$*A!+!>%#/!:, @&!$(8 !1%*4!#$!>%#/!: @( #5$! #!#$%8*:, P%>%"(' 5#8*$&!'*4 "%@&!%84%86., # $(>/! +&%"!, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,, *#@%/$ - 58(+&!$%4<"(#$< 8%$*A!+!/!, %% "*5>"5G )%#@(>'%""(#$<, ($&6' ($ >5'#$'%""(. #$(&("6 @(+"*"!,, ($ (@6$"6: 1*""6:. %$*A!+!/*, «'8%#$( $(;(, >$()6 1&()!$< #'(! ()I%/$6 ' @&%1%4*: &%*4<"(;( (@(1()"(, "*@&!8%&, +((4(;5, #(+1*GF%85 $!@ @(+'("(>"6: ! )%#@(+'("(>"6: ?!'($"6:) ! (#$*"*'4!'*$<#, ' #'(!: +*/4G>%"!,: "* 1()6$6: $(4$( '( '#%: )%+ !#/4G>%"!, #45>*,:, $( %#$< @( ($"(7%"!G /( '#%8 ;4*'"68 ($1%4*8 >%4('%>%#/(;( 8!&(#(+%&2*"!, ('"%7"!. 8!&, 157* >%4('%/* ! @&.) 58 >%4('%>%#/!. 8(?%$ +*.$! +* @&%1%46 @(+"*"!, @(#&%1#$'(8 (&;*"(' >5'#$' (@(+"*"!% @(#&%1#$'%""(% ' ($4!>!% ($ @(+"*"!, "%@(#&%1#$'%""(;( – 58(8 !4! @5$%8 >!#$(;( 58(+&%"!,)» (335, #. 278). K%$*4<"6. *"*4!+ /("/&%$"6: &%+54<$*$(' !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! '61*GF!:#, 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* ' $*/!: '%15F!: ($&*#4,: %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, /*/ A!+!/*, :!8!,, )!(4(;!,, A!+!(4(;!,, @(/*+6'*%$, >$( #*8* E$*
103
1%,$%4<"(#$<, )515>! "*@&*'4%""(. "* 8*$%&!*4<"6% ()I%/$6, "* ()I%/$!'"( &%*4<"6% @&%18%$6, ,'4%"!, ! @&(2%##6, # "%():(1!8(#$]"6:, #(($'%$#$'5GF5G ()F5G 8!&('(++&%">%#/5G 5#$*"('/5 – 5)%?1%"!% ' ()I%/$!'"(. &%*4<"(#$! '"%7"%;( 8!&*, ($&*?*%8(. >%4('%>%#/!8 #(+"*"!%8. P('(/5@"(#$< /("/&%$"6: 8!&('(++&%">%#/!: @&%1#$*'4%"!., '6&*?*GF!: E$( 5)%?1%"!%, ! #(#$*'!4* %#$%#$'%""(-!#$(&!>%#/!. 8*$%&!*4!+8 /*/ (#()5G, ($"(#!$%4<"( #*8(#$(,$%4<"5G A(&85 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, ' %;( @&%!85F%#$'%""(. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(. ()5#4('4%""(#$!. J*/!8 ()&*+(8, %#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/!. 8*$%&!*4!+8, /*/ ! '#,/(% !1%."(% ()&*+('*"!%, !8%4 #'(! 1%$%&8!"!&5GF!% A*/$(&6, ' 1*""(8 #45>*% – A*/$(&6 '"5$&!"*5>"(;( :*&*/$%&*. R(, )515>! #@%2!A!>%#/(. A(&8(. A!4(#(A#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!,, %#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/!. 8*$%&!*4!+8 ' %;( !8%""( :%-*$'%7'1-'0*16!: /*>%#$'% "%():(1!8( )64 #(@&,?]" # A!4(#(A!%., # A!4(#(A#/!8! @5$,8! ! #&%1#$'*8! (#5F%#$'4%"!, ! (A(&84%"!, @(+"*GF%. 86#4!. H @($(85 1&5;!8 (#"('"68 "*@&*'4%"!%8 %;( *"*4!+* ,'4,%$#, %;( &*##8($&%"!% ' #(($"(7%"!! # A!4(#(A!%., # (#()%""(#$,8! '+*!8(($"(7%"!, A!4(#(A#/(;( ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,.
104
@3;5; III 0=3242A=9 D4FD4F52CE;E=9 5 XIX 5D2C=F=5=CB = B;FD8=;3=CB C6,'4%"!% ! 1(/*+*$%4<"(% &*+I,#"%"!% !1%."(;(, /("2%@$5*4<"(;( #(1%&?*"!, A!4(#(A#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, ($8%>%""6: '67% '61*GF!:#, +*@*1"(%'&(@%.#/!: ! &5##/!: 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX – "*>*4* UU ''., @(8!8( #5;5)( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( *#@%/$*, "%():(1!8( @&%1@(4*;*%$ $*/?% ! (@&%1%4%""6., #(@(#$*'!86. @( (#"('"(. 2%4%'(. 5#$*"('/% 1*""(;( !##4%1('*"!, &'7!1!&16'= /("$%/#$, * !8%""(: '6,'4%"!% &%*4<"(;( '+*!8(($"(7%"!, A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ' &*##8*$&!'*%86. @%&!(1 ! #(($'%$#$'5GF!: &%7%"!. #(@5$#$'5GF%. @&()4%8*$!/! /("/&%$"68! A!4(#(A*8!, #$(4< ?% @&%1#$*'!$%4<"68! 14, $(;( '&%8%"!, /*/ ! "*+'*""6% '67% 5>%"6%. C 1*""(8 #45>*% !8%G$#, ' '!15 A!4(#(A6, @&%1#$*'4,GF!% (#"('"6% "*@&*'4%"!,, #(#$(,"!, A!4(#(A#/(. 86#4! XIX '%/*, "%@(#&%1#$'%""( – ;%"%$!>%#/! ! @&*/$!>%#/! – #',+*""6% # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8, !+"*>*4<"( (&!%"$!&('*""6% "* A5"/2!("*4<"(% '+*!8(1%.#$'!% # "!8 ! @($(85 @&%$%"15GF!% "* #$*$5# &'7!1!&'' *1-*1-9!,"%"'(. C6)(& ! (2%"/! 1!/$5G$#, +1%#< /*/ @(+"*'*$%4<"68! &%*4!,8! XIX '%/* ' #A%&% '+*!8(($"(7%"!, A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, $*/ ! '6,'4%""68! &*"%% ()F!8! @&!"2!@*8! E$(;( '+*!8(($"(7%"!,, * $*/?% # 5>%$(8 @(+!2!! ! /("/&%$"6: 8"%"!. 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ' 1*""(8 '(@&(#%. C E$(8 ($"(7%"!! "*!)(4%% @&%1@(>$!$%4<"68 @&%1#$*'4,%$#, #(@(#$*'4%"!% @(+!$!'!+8* # 8*&/#!+8(8 ! ' 2%4(8 # 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 – ' A!4(#(A!! ! ' 8!&('(++&%"!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%.. R* #('8%#$"5G, :($, ! &*+"(:*&*/$%&"5G #(@&,?%""(#$< A!4(#(A#/(;( #*8((@&%1%4%"!, @(+!$!'!+8* ! 8*$%&!*4!+8* # 1(#$!?%"!,8! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ' XIX '%/%, # @&%()&*+('*"!,8! ' %;( 8!&('(++&%">%#/(. #A%&% ()&*$!4! '"!8*"!% 5?% ' $( '&%8,, ' &*##8*$&!'*%86. @%&!(1. J*/, !+'%#$"6. "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A 3. MG4<@%, /*#*,#< E$(;( '(@&(#*, @!#*4: «…9)#(4G$"*, A!4(#(A!, ' 15:% T%44!";* ! =%;%4, @*4* @(1 "*$!#/(8 #@%2!*4<"6: "*5/. V* #*868 )4%#$,F!8 @(1I%8(8 @(#4%1('*4( ;45)(>*.7%% @*1%"!%. L$!8 @*1%"!%8 '(#@(4<+('*4!#< 8*$%&!*4!+8 ! @(+!$!'!+8, >$()6 1(#$!;"5$< #'(%. 2%4!, $( %#$< @(1>!"!$< A!4(#(A!G #@%2!*4<"68 "*5/*8. B&! E$(8 8*$%&!*4!+8 @&(#$( @&!#(%1!"!4#, / !+'%#$"68 #@%2!*4<"68 "*5/*8 ! '(+'%4 !: '6'(16 "* #$%@%"< ()F%;( 8!&(#(+%&2*"!,, @(+!$!'!+8 ?% @(1>!"!4 A!4(#(A!G 2%4,8 #@%2!*4<"6: "*5/ '(()F%» (188, #. 30). R*1( $(4!$6'*$< @&! E$(8, >$( 8*$%&!*4!+8 ' XIX '%/% (@&%1%4!4#, ' &*+"6: '!1*: ! (1"(. !+ "*!)(4%% '4!,$%4<"6: %;( &*+"('!1"(#$%. ' A!4(#(A!! )64 8*&/#!+8, 1!*4%/$!>%#/!. ! !#$(&!>%#/!. 8*$%&!*4!+8 *&/#*, L";%4<#* ! !: @(#4%1('*$%4%.. C #$*"('4%"!! ! &*+'!$!! E$(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8*, ' %;( A!4(#(A#/(8 – !1%."(8 ! /("2%@$5*4<"(8 –
105
(A(&84%"!! @&(,'!4*#< #'(, #@%2!A!/* ' ($"(7%"!! / %#$%#$'(+"*"!G. J( ?% #*8(% 8(?"( #/*+*$< ! ( @(+!$!'!+8%, ( %;( &*+"('!1"(#$,:. §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–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«A!4(#(A!, – 157* '#%: "*5/, >$( ("* '(+'67*%$ !: ! @()5?1*%$ / 1*4<"%.7%85 &*+'!$!G, >$( "*5/! )%+ $*/(;( 1'!?%"!, 5;*#"5$». 0!4(#(A!,, @( 8"%"!G =%;%4,, «2*&!2* "*5/ )4*;(1*&, /*/ #'(!8 #()#$'%""68 #'(.#$'*8, $*/ ! '+*!8(1%.#$'!G # 1&5;!8! "*5/*8!» (80, #. 247, 248). J*/(% >&%+8%&"(% '(+'%4!>%"!% A!4(#(A!!, '+;4,1 "* "%] /*/ "* «"*5/5 "*5/», «1575 '#%: "*5/», «2*&!25 "*5/» ! $.@. – '#] E$(, &*+58%%$#,, "% 8(;4( "% "*#$(&(?!$< /*/ 5>]"6:, ()&*F*GF!:#, / A!4(#(A!!, $*/ ! A!4(#(A(', &%*4<"( @&!()F*GF!:#, / /("/&%$"("*5>"(85 @(+"*"!G. R5?"6 )64! !"6% &%7%"!,, )(4%% #(@&,?]""6% # %#$%#$'%""("*5>"68 8*$%&!*4(8. H A!4(#(A!, ' "('6: #'(!: "*@&*'4%"!,:, '(+"!/7!: ' @%&'(. @(4('!"% UIX '%/*, ($&%*;!&('*4* "* E$! "('6% '%,"!,, '6+'*""6% 5#@%:*8! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, @&!>]8 ($&%*;!&('*4* "%(1"(+"*>"(. R*!)(4%% >]$/( ! (@&%1%4]""( &*#:(?1%"!, ' "('(8 @("!8*"!! @&%18%$* A!4(#(A!!, %] 8%#$* ! &(4! ' "*5>"(8 @(+"*"!!, %] '+*!8(($"(7%"!, # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8 '6&*+!4!#<, "* "*7 '+;4,1, ' @(+!$!'!+8%, # (1"(. #$(&("6, ! ' 8*&/#!+8% – # 1&5;(.. 9"*4!+ ! #(@(#$*'4%"!% '(++&%"!. (#"('(@(4(?"!/(' "*+'*""6: A!4(#(A#/!: "*@&*'4%"!. ()"*&5?!'*%$ '#G ;45)!"5 E$!: &*#:(?1%"!.. 3#"('(@(4(?"!/ @(+!$!'!+8* 3. M("$ (1798–1857) ' &%7%"!! '(@&(#* ( @&%18%$% A!4(#(A!! ! %] &(4! ' @(+"*"!! !#:(1!4 !+
106
@&('(+;4*7]""(;( !8 «(#"('"(;( +*/("*» $&]: @(#4%1('*$%4<"6: #$*1!. ' &*+'!$!! >%4('%>%#/(;( 8674%"!,. «P(;4*#"( 8(%. (#"('"(. 1(/$&!"%, – @!#*4 (", – '#% "*7! 58(+&%"!,, /*/ !"1!'!15*4<"6%, $*/ ! &(1('6%, 1(4?"6 "%!+)%?"( @&(.$! @(#4%1('*$%4<"( >%&%+ $&! &*+4!>"6% $%(&%$!>%#/!% #$*1!!, /($(&6% 8(;5$ )6$< +1%#< 1(#$*$(>"( (@&%1%4%"6 ()6/"('%""68! "*!8%"('*"!,8! – $%(4(;!>%#/*,, 8%$*A!+!>%#/*, ! "*5>"*,» (177, #. 10). C#, @&%?",, A!4(#(A!, – 8%$*A!+!>%#/*, !4! *)#$&*/$"*, #$*1!, – +*"!8*%$ ' E$(. E'(4G2!! @&(8%?5$(>"(% @(4(?%"!%, ("* @&%1#$*'4,%$ #()(. @%&%:(1"6. E$*@ ($ $%(4(;!>%#/(. #$*1!!, '6&*?*GF%. «84*1%">%#/(%» #(#$(,"!% >%4('%>%#/(;( 58*, / "*5>"(., @(+!$!'"(. #$*1!!, '6&*?*GF%. "*!)(4%% +&%4(% #(#$(,"!% >%4('%>%#/(. 86#4!. O#$*"*'4!'*, $*/5G #:%85 ' &*+'!$!! >%4('%>%#/(;( 8674%"!,, M("$ $%8 #*868 @&(!+'(4<"( &*+&6'*%$, &*#>4%",%$ %1!"6. ' #'(]8 "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 &*+']&$6'*"!! @&(2%## @(+"*"!,, ($1%4,%$ A!4(#(A#/(% @(+"*"!% ($ /("/&%$"("*5>"(;(, 5#$*"*'4!'*%$ (>%&]1"(#$< 8%?15 "!8!: #"*>*4* – (1"(, @($(8 – 1&5;(%, @%&'(% #(+1*]$ 5#4('!, 14, '$(&(;( ! 5#$5@*%$ %85 8%#$(, * #*8( #:(1!$ "* "%$, @&%/&*F*%$ #'(] #5F%#$'('*"!% +* "%"*1()"(#$%"!% A!4(#(A!!, «%] ;4*'"*, '&%8%""*, @(4%+"(#$<» #(#$(!$, @( M("$5, ' $(8, >$()6 '6@(4",$< !#/4G>!$%4<"( «/&!$!>%#/5G !4! &*+&57!$%4<"5G» A5"/2!G @( ($"(7%"!G / $%(4(;!!, «"% )515>! "!/(;1* ' #(#$(,"!! #(+1*$< >$(-4!)( @(4(?!$%4<"(%» ($*8 ?%, #. 15). J*/(% $(4/('*"!% M("$(8 !#$(&!>%#/(;( "*+"*>%"!, A!4(#(A!! '6$%/*%$ !+ %;( @("!8*"!, @&%18%$* A!4(#(A#/(;( ! /("/&%$"("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. K4, A!4(#(A!! :*&*/$%&"( #$&%84%"!% / "%1(#$!?!8(85 *)#(4G$"(85 +"*"!G. 3"* «@6$*%$#,, /*/ ! $%(4(;!,, ()I,#",$< '"5$&%""GG @&!&(15 #5F%#$', "*>*4( ! "*+"*>%"!% '#%: '%F%., (#"('"(. #@(#() ()&*+('*"!, '#%: ,'4%"!., "( '8%#$( $(;(, >$()6 @&!)%;*$< / @(8(F! #'%&:I%#$%#$'%""6: A*/$(&(', ("* !: '#] )(4%% ! )(4%% +*8%",%$ #5F"(#$,8! !4! (4!2%$'(&]""68! *)#$&*/2!,8!» ($*8 ?%, #. 14). 0!4(#(A!! @&!#5F% #$&%84%"!% *&;58%"$!&('*$<, '8%#$( $(;(, >$()6 "*)4G1*$<. D(;!/* 8674%"!, ' A!4(#(A#/(8 @(+"*"!!, @( 8"%"!G M("$*, @&%1#$*'4,%$ #()(. «!#/5##$'( )(4%% !4! 8%"%% 4('/( &*##5?1*$< #(;4*#"( #85$"68 @&!"2!@*8, /($(&6%, )515>! "%1(#$5@"68! #/(4"6% #@(&6» ($*8 ?%, #. 17). C ($4!>!% ($ E$(;( ' "*5>"(8 @(+"*"!! (' «@(4(?!$%4<"(. !4! &%*4<"(.» #$*1!!), #8%",GF%8 A!4(#(A!G, 58 >%4('%>%#/!. «($/*+6'*%$#, ($ *)#(4G$"6: !##4%1('*"!., 58%#$"6: $(4%#/(8 #(#$(,"!!, ! #(#&%1($(>!'*%$ #'(! 5#!4!, ' ()4*#$! 1%.#$'!$%4<"(;( "*)4G1%"!,, @&!"!8*GF%. # E$(;( 8(8%"$* '#% )(4%% ! )(4%% 7!&(/!% &*+8%&6 ! ,'4,GF%.#, %1!"#$'%""( '(+8(?"68 (#"('*"!%8 1(#$5@"6: "*8 +"*"!., &*+58"( @&!#@(#()4%""6: / "*7!8 &%*4<"68 @($&%)"(#$,8» ($*8 ?%, #. 16–17). C #',+! # E$!8 M("$
107
A(&854!&5%$ (#"('"(% @&*'!4( @(+!$!'!#$#/(. A!4(#(A!!, #(;4*#"( /($(&(85 «'#,/(% @&%14(?%"!%, /($(&(% "%1(#$5@"( $(>"(85 @&%'&*F%"!G ' @&(#$(% !+I,#"%"!% >*#$"(;( !4! ()F%;( A*/$*, "% 8(?%$ @&%1#$*'4,$< "!/*/(;( &%*4<"(;( ! @(",$"(;( #86#4*». 3#"('"(. @%&%'(&($, :*&*/$%&!+5GF!. '(+85?*"!% 58*, M("$ '!1!$ «' @('#%8%#$"(. +*8%"% "%1(#$5@"(;( (@&%1%4%"!, @&!>!" ' #()#$'%""(8 #86#4% #4('* – @&(#$68 !##4%1('*"!%8 +*/("(', $.%. @(#$(,""6: ($"(7%"!., #5F%#$'5GF!: 8%?15 "*)4G1*%868! ,'4%"!,8!» ($*8 ?%, #. 17). 3$/*+6'*, '#%. @&%?"%., $&*1!2!(""(. A!4(#(A#/(. @&()4%8*$!/% ! A(&8*8 %] !##4%1('*"!, ' @&*'% "* 1*4<"%.7%% #5F%#$'('*"!%, ($'(1, %. 4!7< "%;*$!'"5G &(4< @( ($"(7%"!G / @&%17%#$'5GF%85 E$*@5 &*+'!$!, @(+"*"!,, M("$ @&('(+;4*7*%$ #'(G A!4(#(A!G ' /*>%#$'% "('(. – @(+!$!'"(. – A!4(#(A!!, %1!"#$'%""( #(($'%$#$'5GF%. $&%$<%. #$*1!! &*+'!$!, @(+"*"!, – "*5>"(.. L$* "('*, A!4(#(A!,, ' @("!8*"!! M("$*, – "! 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/*,, "! !1%*4!#$!>%#/*,, ("* – «$&%$<,», @(4(?!$%4<"*,. *$%&!*4!+8 ! !1%*4!+8 («#@!&!$5*4!+8», /*/ %;( "*+6'*%$ M("$) – ' &*'"(. 8%&% :*&*/$%&!+5G$ "%#('%&7%"#$'( A!4(#(A#/(;( @(+"*"!,. «3)* E$! $%>%"!, ' #85$"6: (>%&$*"!,: ! ' &*'"( 4(?"6: A(&8*: ($&*?*4! (1!"*/('( #%&<]+"6%, :($,, / "%#>*#$!, 8%?15 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 ! !1%*4!+8(8 – @5#$6% #@(&6, "%&*+&%7!86% ' &*8/*: #*8(. A!4(#(A!! ! 5#$&*",%86% '8%#$% # #*8(. A!4(#(A!%. @(4(?!$%4<"68 +"*"!%8, @(4(?!$%4<"68 8%$(1(8. «K(#$!;7! ($"6"% #'(%. #!#$%8*$!>%#/(. +&%4(#$!, @(4(?!$%4<"6. 8%$(1 &*##%!'*%$ +*&*+ +*)45?1%"!, /*/ (1"(;(, $*/ ! 1&5;(;( @(&,1/* ! +*/*">!'*%$ E$! )%#@4(1"6% #@(&6» ($*8 ?%, #. 75). 31"( !+ "*!)(4%% '*?"6: #'(.#$' #'(%. «!#$!""(. "('(. A!4(#(A!!», #5F%#$'%""( ($4!>*GF%% %] ($ '#%. @&%?"%. A!4(#(A!!, M("$ '!1%4 ' $(8, >$()6 «"% &*+&57*$<, "( (&;*"!+('*$<». K'* @&('(+;4*7%""6: M("$(8 +*/("* – +*/(" $&]: #$*1!. &*+'!$!, >%4('%>%#/(;( 8674%"!, ! +*/(" /4*##!A!/*2!! – '6&*?*G$, @( %;( 8"%"!G, 1'% (#"('"6% !1%!, «$%#"(% #(>%$*"!% /($(&6: "%():(1!8( #(#$*'4,%$ #!#$%8*$!>%#/(% (#"('*"!% "('(. ()F%. A!4(#(A!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 74). L$( +"*>!$, >$( ' ()4*#$! "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, "*+"*>%"!% @(+!$!'"(. A!4(#(A!! M("$ '!1%4 ' #!#$%8*$!+*2!! /("/&%$"("*5>"6: 1*""6:, ' /4*##!A!/*2!! "*5/. B(+"*"!%, (#5F%#$'4,%8(% /("/&%$"68! "*5/*8!, @%&'68 (#"('"68 5#4('!%8 !8%%$ @(#$(,""(% @(1>!"%"!% '(()&*?%"!, "*)4G1%"!G. J%8 #*868 M("$ #5F%#$'%""( (;&*"!>!'*%$ "*5>"(% @(+"*"!% #A%&(. "%@(#&%1#$'%""( "*)4G1*%8(;( )%+ @(@6$(/ @&("!/"('%"!, ' @&!>!""5G #',+< !+5>*%86: ,'4%"!., ' !: "*!)(4%% ;45)!""5G, #5F"(#$"5G #A%&5. «R% $(4!'*$<#, #!#$%8*$!>%#/(. (2%"/(. $(;(, >$( %#$<, ($/*+6'*,#< ($/&6'*$< @%&'(@&!>!"5 ! /("%>"(% "*+"*>%"!%, "(, /&(8% $(;(, '*?"( @(",$<, >$(
108
E$( !+5>%"!% ,'4%"!. '8%#$( $(;(, >$()6 #$*$< /(;1*-4!)( *)#(4G$"68, 1(4?"( '#%;1* (#$*'*$<#, ($"(#!$%4<"68 ' +*'!#!8(#$! ($ "*7%. (&;*"!+*2!! ! "*7%;( @(4(?%"!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 17). [%4< "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, M("$ (;&*"!>!'*%$ #A%&(. %1!"!>"(;(, '"% %;( #',+! # ()F!8, * E$( @(#4%1"%% '(()F% 5$&*>!'*%$ ' @(+!$!'!+8% @&*'( )6$< @(+"*'*%868. 0!4(#(A!, @&%1#$*]$ ' E$(8 #45>*% 4!7< /*/ (#()*,, #@%2!A!>%#/*, A(&8* ()61%""(;( #(+"*"!,, $*/ "*+6'*%8(;( «+1&*'(;( #86#4*», ()%#/&64!'*GF%;( >%4('%>%#/(% @(+"*"!%. «C #5F%#$'% 1%4*, – @!#*4 M("$, – !#$!""6. A!4(#(A#/!. 15: '#G15 #(#$(!$ @&%!85F%#$'%""( ' #!#$%8*$!>%#/(8 &*#7!&%"!! @&(#$(;( +1&*'(;( #86#4* "* '#% 1%.#$'!$%4<"( 1(#$5@"6% 58(+&%"!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 36–37). C E$(8 @&!"!?%"!! A!4(#(A!! 1( 5&('", «+1&*'(;( #86#4*» (#()%""( "*;4,1"( @&(,'4,%$#, *"$!A!4(#(A#/!. :*&*/$%& @(+!$!'!+8*. C 2%4(8 ?% @(#4%1('*$%4<"( @&('%1]""(% @(+!$!'!#$#/(% @("!8*"!% A!4(#(A!! "*>!#$( 4!7*%$ %] (#()(. #@%2!A!>%#/(. 14, "%] @&()4%8*$!/!, !"*>% ;('(&,, (;&*"!>!'*, A!4(#(A!G +1&*'68 #86#4(8, @(1>!",, %] /("/&%$"(–"*5>"(85 @(+"*"!G, ($'%&;*, "*4!>!% 5 "%% #@%2!A!>%#/(;(, $(4%#/! / ($&!2*"!G A!4(#(A!! /*/ "*5/!, /*/ #*8(#$(,$%4<"(. ($&*#4! @(+"*"!,, / !#/4G>%"!G %% !+ #A%&6 5#$*"('4%"!, @(+!$!'"(;( !#$!""(;( +"*"!,, ' >*#$"(#$!, / ($#$&*"%"!G %% ($ #('8%#$"(;( # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8 #5F"(#$"(;( @(#$!?%"!, !+5>*%86: ,'4%"!. ! @&(2%##(' @&!&(16. O M("$* '(()F% #"!8*%$#, '(@&(# ( 9,%':!!-"!3*"'' A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,. 0!4(#(A!, ' /*>%#$'% 8%$*A!+!/!, +* "%"*1()"(#$"( !#/4G>*%$#, !+ #A%&6 "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, – @(#$(4"(#$"(% "*>*4( ' "%., A!4(#(A!!, ,/()6 1%4*%$ %% *)#(4G$"( "%1%%#@(#()"(. ' 5#$*"('4%"!! !#$!""(;(, @(+!$!'"(;( +"*"!,, )%+4!>"(;( @( #'(%. #5$!. 0&*"25+#/!. @(+!$!'!#$, 5>%"!/ M("$* L. D!$$&% 5$'%&?1*4 ' #',+! # E$!8, >$( «8%$*A!+!>%#/*, A!4(#(A!, %#$< 1%4( 58*, '4*;*GF%;( ' '%F! #'(! '+;4,16, /*/ "%():(1!86%» (214, #. 295). H @($(85 ' 8%$*A!+!/%, @(1()"( :51(?%#$'%""(85 $'(&>%#$'5, /*/ @(1>%&/"54, !+4*;*, 5>%"!% M("$*, *";4!.#/!. @(+!$!'!#$ =. D$! #$(4232N=9 = <8=F=<; 0!4(#(A!, ' 1&5;(. #'(%. !@(#$*#!, ' /*>%#$'% "%;6', 5 M("$* &*#$'(&,%$#, ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, $( %#$< @&%1#$*%$ "% #*8* @( #%)%, ' #'(%. #@%2!A!>%#/(. "*5>"(#$!, "*&,15 # 1&5;!8! "*5/*8!, * /*/ A!4(#(A!, >%;(-$(, A!4(#(A!, $(. !4! !"(. /("/&%$"(. "*5/! – A!4(#(A!, 8*$%8*$!/!, A!4(#(A!, *#$&("(8!!, A!4(#(A!, A!+!/! ! $.1. «0!4(#(A!G "*5/, – @!#*4 D!"%"!,: 3;G#$* M("$*, – )(4<7% "!;1%» ($*8 ?%).
109
3)(#"('6'*, E$($ *#@%/$ ' @(+!$!'"(. A!4(#(A!! M("$* /*/ '*?"%.7!., (@&%1%4,GF!. ' "%., D!$$&% @(1>%&/"54, >$( «"('(% ' @(+!$!'"(. A!4(#(A!!, $(, >$( #(#$*'4,%$ !+()&%$%"!% M("$*, +*/4G>*%$#, ' $(8, >$()6 +*86#4!$< ! @(#$&(!$< A!4(#(A!G, '6)&*' !+ >*#$"6: "*5/ ! 5 '%4!/!: "*5>"6: 58(' ;&5@@6 !#$!" $*/!%, >$( / "!8 '(+8(?"( @&!4(?!$< 8%$(15». H+ 1*4<"%.7!: &*+I,#"%"!. #4%15%$, >$( !#/(86% !#$!"6 – E$( "% >$( !"(%, /*/ A*/$6: «B(+!$!'"*, A!4(#(A!, %#$< #4%1#$'!% 1'5: (@%&*2!.: (@&%1%4%"!, ()F!: A*/$(' /*?1(. (#"('"(. "*5/! ! ;&5@@!&('/! !4! #(@(1>!"%"!, E$!: A*/$('. 3@&%1%4!$< ()F!% A*/$6 >*#$"(. "*5/! ! #;&5@@!&('*$< !: – +"*>!$… #1%4*$< A!4(#(A!G "*5/!» (214, #. 296). C @(+"*'*$%4<"(. &%*4!+*2!! E$!: (@%&*2!., ' "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 A5"/2!("!&('*"!! A!4(#(A!! "*5/! ! 5#$*"*'4!'*%$#, %% (#()(%, #@%2!A!>%#/(% /*>%#$'(; ()&%$*%$#, %% #()#$'%""6. #5)#$&*$, ($4!>*GF!. ! ($1%4,GF!. %% ($ @&%17%#$'5GF%. A!4(#(A!!, ($ A!4(#(A!! /*/ 8%$*A!+!/!. M(;1* 5 M("$* ' &%+54<$*$% (#5F%#$'4%"!, @%&'(. (@%&*2!! (/*+*4!#< ' &5/*: «'#% ()F!% A*/$6 @(4(?!$%4<"6: "*5/, (" @(",4 (* /$( ?% E$( @(",4 1( "%;(?), >$( 5 "%;( ' &5/*: E4%8%"$6 "('(. A!4(#(A!!, A!4(#(A#/!. #5)#$&*$, #('%&7%""( (&!;!"*4<"6. ! ($4!>"6. ($ #5)#$&*$* @&%?"!: A!4(#(A!.» ($*8 ?%, #. 297). C$(&*, (@%&*2!,, @( 8"%"!G D!$$&%, #'(1!4*#< / $(85, >$()6 «'"%#$! ' E$($ #5)#$&*$ ?!+"< ! 1'!?%"!%, $( %#$< @&!4(?!$< / "%85 @(1()*GF5G 8%$(15. J*/ /*/ A!4(#(A!, /*/(.-"!)51< "*5/! %#$< ;&5@@!&('/* %% ()F!: A*/$(', $( ($#G1* #4%15%$, >$( 2%4*, A!4(#(A!, %#$< ;&5@@!&('/* >*#$"6: ;&5@@, @(45>%""6: @&! @%&'(. (@%&*2!!… J*/ )64* #(+1*"* @(+!$!'"*, A!4(#(A!, @(#&%1#$'(8 #5)#$&*$*, /($(&6. "% )64 %F% #()&*" "!><%G &5/(G, ! @&!"2!@* %#$%#$'%""(., !#$(&!>%#/(. ! 1!1*/$!>%#/(. ;&5@@!&('/!, /($(&(;( %F% "!/*/(% 58(+&%"!% "% 5@($&%)4,4(». 3>%&>!'*, /("$5&6 "('(., @(+!$!'"(. A!4(#(A!!, A!4(#(A!! M("$*, /*/ A!4(#(A!! "*5/!, @(1>%&/!'*, @&! E$(8 %% #'(%()&*+!%, %% 8("(@(4<"(% @&*'( "* "*5>"(#$<, D!$$&% @!#*4: «J*/!8 ()&*+(8, (@&%1%4!$< '6#7!% A*/$6 '#,/(;( >%4('%>%#/(;( +"*"!,, #;&5@@!&('*$< !: ' %#$%#$'%""(. 8%$(1%, !+'4%>< !+ "!: 1%.#$'!$%4<"(% '(++&%"!% "* 8!&, #(#$*'!$< @(",$!% #$(4< @(4(?!$%4<"(%, >$()6 ("( )64( ' @(4"(8 #(;4*#!! # "*5>"68! E4%8%"$*8!, ! #$(4< ()F%%, >$()6 ("( 5/*+6'*4( !8 8%#$( ! +"*>%"!% ' ()F%8, – $*/('* @(+!$!'"*, A!4(#(A!,, $*/('( 1%4( M("$*» ($*8 ?%, #. 297–298). H$*/, @( D!$$&%, @(45>*%$#,, >$( @(+!$!'"*, A!4(#(A!, M("$* – E$( '('#% ! "% A!4(#(A!,, $( %#$< "% (#()*, #A%&* @(+"*"!,, ' >%8-$( #5F%#$'%""( ($4!>"*, ($ "*5/! ! #(@&,?%""*, # "%. ()F"(#$%#$'%: «C "*5/% "%$ "!>%;(, >$( )6 "% #'(1!4(#< / "%., ! ' E$(. A!4(#(A!! "%$ "!>%;(, >$( )6 "% #:(1!4( / "*5/%» ($*8 ?%, #. 295). 3$#G1* ! ()F%%, #5F"(#$"(% (@&%1%4%"!% @(+!$!'"(. A!4(#(A!!, ()(+"*>%"!% %% /(&%""(;( @(+"*'*$%4<"(;( #$*$5#*: «B(+!$!'"*, A!4(#(A!, %#$< $*/(% @("!8*"!%
110
8!&*, /*/(% @&(!#$%/*%$ !+ #!#$%8*$!+!&('*""(. #('(/5@"(#$! @(4(?!$%4<"6: (@(+!$!'"6:) "*5/» ($*8 ?%, #. 291). B(#/(4"6, #5F%#$'%""( ($4!>"6 (1"* ($ 1&5;(. @( #'(!8 ()I%/$*8 ! 8%$(1*8 @(+"*"!,, $(, #4%1('*$%4<"(, "*5/* ' 2%4(8 – E$( #('(/5@"(#$< ($1%4<"6: @(4(?!$%4<"6: "*5/ !, #(($'%$#$'%""(, @(+!$!'"*, A!4(#(A!, M("$*, /*/ A!4(#(A!, "*5/!, – E$( "% >$( !"(%, /*/ #('(/5@"(#$< 8"(;!: ($1%4<"6:, #*8(#$(,$%4<"6: A!4(#(A!., $( %#$< #/(4*#$"6% A!4(#(A!! "*5/, ;('(&,: A!4(#(A!, /*/(.-4!)( "*5/! %#$< @("!8*"!% E$(. "*5/! @(#&%1#$'(8 @&*'!4<"(. ;&5@@!&('/! ()F!: A*/$(' !4! (#"('"6: !#$!", %. @&!"*14%?*F!:». M("/&%$"( E$( (+"*>*%$, >$( «A!4(#(A!, "*5/! %#$< $(, >$( #1%4*"( M("$(8 14, 8*$%8*$!/!, *#$&("(8!!, A!+!/!, :!8!!, )!(4(;!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 292-293). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, @(+!$!'"*, A!4(#(A!, /*/ A!4(#(A!, "*5/, E$(, !"*>% ;('(&,, #*8! /("/&%$"6% "*5/! – #*8* 8*$%8*$!/*, #*8* *#$&("(8!,, A!+!/* ! 1&. ' !: "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 @(+"*'*$%4<"(8 A5"/2!("!&('*"!!, $(>"%% – E$( !: (@&%1%4%""*, ()F*, !1%."*,, A*/$*8! ()%#@%>%""*, >*#$< – !8%""( ! $(4'-*78"%(. P*8 M("$, &*+I,#",, #'(% @("!8*"!% @(+!$!'"(. A!4(#(A!! ' /*>%#$'% !8%""( &'7!1!&'', @!#*4: «X #(?*4%G, (1"*/(, >$( +* "%!8%"!%8 1&5;(;( 8"% @&!74(#< @&!",$< $%&8!" A!4(#(A!,, /($(&(85 "%@&*'!4<"( @&!1*'*4! 8"(?%#$'( &*+4!>"6: +"*>%"!.. "% /*+*4(#<, >$( @&!4*;*$%4<"(;( 2!7!>'-*78"%(, @&! @(8(F! /($(&(;( , !+8%",G "%#/(4%"!% #4('* &'7!1!&'(, )51%$ 1(#$*$(>"( 14, $(;(, >$()6 1*?% # @%&'(;( '+;4,1* 5"!>$(?!$< '#,/5G "%,#"(#$<… X 5@($&%)4,G #4('( &'7!1!&'( ' $(8 #86#4%, /($(&6. %85 @&!1*'*4! 1&%'"!%, ! ' (#()%""(#$! 9&!#$($%4<, ! ()(+"*>*G !8 ()F5G #!#$%85 >%4('%>%#/!: @(",$!.; @&!)*'4,, #4('( 2!7!>'-*78"%(, , :(>5 #/*+*$<, >$( !8%G ' '!15 (#()6. #@(#() A!4(#(A#/(;( 8674%"!,, /($(&6. @&!+"*%$, >$( '#% $%(&!!, / /*/(. )6 ()4*#$! !1%. ("! "% @&!"*14%?*4!, !8%G$ 2%4!% #'(%. @(4(?!$%4<"(. A!4(#(A!! ($ 1&5;!:, )4!+/!: "*!8%"('*"!. A!4(#(A!!, #',+*""(. # "*5>"68 @(+"*"!%8: «W#$<, /("%>"(, 8"(;( *"*4(;!! 8%?15 8(%. 2!7!>'-*78"!= &'7!1!&'*= ! $%8, >$( *";4!.#/!% 5>%"6%, (#()%""( @(#4% R"%%, @($(85 >$( "! $*, "! 1&5;*, "% /*#*G$#, '#%: /4*##(' ,'4%"!., $(;1* /*/ 2!7!>'-*78"%( &'7!1!&'(, ' /($(&5G , '/4G>*G !+5>%"!% #(2!*4<"6: ,'4%"!. $(>"( $*/ ?%, /*/ ! '#,/!: 1&5;!:, 5/*+6'*%$ "* (1"(()&*+"6. @&!%8 &*##5?1%"!,, @&!4(?!86. /( '#%8 @&%18%$*8, @(14%?*F!8 >%4('%>%#/(85 !##4%1('*"!G… B(1 @(4(?!$%4<"(. A!4(#(A!%., #(@(#$*'4,, %% # 2!7!>'-*78".:' "%;6%:', , @("!8*G $(4%"!% ()F!: !1%. &*+4!>"6: "*5/, @&!+"*'*, "*5/!
111
@(1>!"%""68! (1"(85 8%$(15 ! #(#$*'4,GF!8! &*+4!>"6% >*#$! (1"(;( ()F%;( @4*"* !##4%1('*"!,» (178, #. 2). C @(+!$!'"(. (@(4(?!$%4<"(.) A!4(#(A!! ' ($"(7%"!! $(. !4! !"(. /("/&%$"( (@&%1%4,%8(. "*5/! (' A!4(#(A!! A!+!/!, A!4(#(A!! :!8!! ! $.@.) 14, M("$* #5F%#$'%""* ! '*?"* ' @(+"*'*$%4<"(8 @4*"% !#/4G>!$%4<"( &*"!:*"%78"%(, ' >5'#$'*: ,'4%""*, >*#$< ' ()I%/$"(. #A%&% @(+"*"!,. J*/, @&!8%"!$%4<"( / A!+!/% M("$ #>%4 "5?"68 @(1>%&/"5$<: «B&! ()6>"(8 @("!8*"!! A!+!/! #('%&7%""( "*@&*#"( $%@%&< %F% #>!$*G$ "5?"68 &*+4!>*$< &*+"(()&*+"6% #'(.#$'*, /($(&68! ("* +*"!8*%$#,, #8($&, @( $(85, "%():(1!8* 4! !: ()F"(#$<, !4! ("* #45>*."*; E$( "%@(#&%1#$'%""( '1%$ $(4%#/!% $("/(#$! ()I,#",G$#,, /("%>"(, $(4%#/(;( 15:*, )4*;(1*&, /($(&(85 $*/ 1(4;( #>!$*4(#< '(+8(?"68 @(+"*"!% $%4 #*8!: @( #%)%, "%+*'!#!8( ($ ()"*&5?*%86: !8! ,'4%"!., @( #5F%#$'5 '#%;1* #>!$*'7!:#, #45>*."68!; 14, A!4(#(A('– @(+!$!'!#$(', "*()(&($, E$!-$( ,'4%"!, ! @&%1#$*'4,G$ ' 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! %1!"#$'%""5G @%&'("*>*4<"5G (#"('5 "*7!: /("2%@2!.» (179, #. 5). P E$!: @&!"2!@!*4<"6: @(+!2!. M("$ @(1:(1!4 / @("!8*"!G #*8(. #5F"(#$! A!+!/!, / (@&%1%4%"!G %% @&%18%$*: A!+!/* «+*"!8*%$#, !+5>%"!%8 +*/("(', 5@&*'4,GF!: ()F!8! #'(.#$'*8! $%4, @&%1#$*'4,GF!:#, ()6/"('%""( ' '!1% "%/($(&6: 8*## ! "*:(1,F!:#, @(#$(,""( ' 5#4('!,:, @&! /($(&6: #(:&*",%$#, "%@&!/(#"('%""68 #(#$*' !: 8(4%/54 !, ' )(4<7!"#$'% #45>*%', 1*?% !: '"5$&%""%% #$&(%"!%… M("%>"*, 2%4< A!+!>%#/!: $%(&!. #(#$(!$ ' #/(4< '(+8(?"( $(>"(8 @&%1'!1%"!! '#%: ,'4%"!., /($(&6% @&%1#$*'!$ $%4(, "*:(1,F%%#, @&! /*/(. 5;(1"( +*1*""(. #('(/5@"(#$! 5#4('!., +* !#/4G>%"!%8, (1"*/(, $*/!:, /($(&6% 8(;4! )6 !+8%"!$< %;( @&!&(15» ($*8 ?%, #. 7-8). K.P. !44<, #*8 @(+!$!'!#$, (@&%1%4,, "*!)(4%% #5F%#$'%""6% :*&*/$%&!#$!/! @(+!$!'!+8* M("$*, (#()( '61%4!4 !8%""( E$5, A%"(8%"(4(;!>%#/5G: « 6 @(+"*%8 (1"! $(4$( 86 +"*%8 ($"(#!$%4<"( ,'4%"!.. P5F"(#$< !: @&!&(16 ! !: @%&'!>"6%, 1%,$%4<"6% !4! /("%>"6% @&!>!"6 (#$*G$#, "*8 "%!+'%#$"68! ! 14, "*# "%1(#$5@"68!» (271, #. 7). P $%>%"!%8 '&%8%"! @(+!$!'!+8 M("$* @(45>!4 1(#$*$(>"( 7!&(/(% @&!+"*"!% ! */$!'"5G @(11%&?/5 ' "*5>"6: /&5;*: ' V*@*1"(. W'&(@%, * +*$%8 ! ' -(##!!. B(,'!4(#< "%8*4( %1!"(8674%""!/(', @(#4%1('*$%4%.,
112
@&(@*;*"1!#$(' – /*/ #&%1! A!4(#(A(', $*/ ! #&%1! 5>%"6:%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%.. "(;!8 !8@("!&('*4* (&!%"$*2!, @(+!$!'!+8* "* "*5/5, %;( *"$!A!4(#(A#/*,, * $(>"%%, *"$!8%$*A!+!>%#/*, "*@&*'4%""(#$<. B(#4%1"%% ()#$(,$%4<#$'( ()I,#",4! "%;*$!'"(. &%*/2!%. "* "%(@&*'1*""6% "*$5&A!4(#(A#/!% @&!$,+*"!, ;(#@(1#$'('*'7!: $(;1* ' A!4(#(A!! 5>%"!. T%44!";* ! =%;%4,. J*/, @( 8"%"!G !$*4<,"#/(;( 5>%"(;( 0. L"&!/'%#*, «58#$'%""(% 1'!?%"!%, ()(+"*>*%8(% E$!8 !8%"%8 (@(+!$!'!+8. – C.3.), (),+*"( #'(!8 @&(!#:(?1%"!%8 &%*/2!! @&($!' @&(!+'(4<"6: /("2%@2!. 8%$*A!+!>%#/(;( !1%*4!+8*, /($(&6. )64 $%8 (@*#"%%, >$( @&%$%"1('*4 "* '6#75G (1*?% *)#(4G$"5G) ()I%/$!'"(#$<, ($&*?*,, 8%?15 $%8, $(4%"!% #5)I%/$!'"(;(» (413, #. 41). 3. MG4<"%, &*+I,#",, #*85 #5F"(#$< @(+!$!'!+8* M("$*, 5$'%&?1*4 ' #',+! # E$!8, >$( «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» (188, #. 30–31). B(+!$!'!+8 M("$*, ' /*>%#$'% 2!7!>'-*78"!= A!4(#(A!! 2!7!>'-*78"!= "*5/!, "% @&!+"*%$, /*/ @!#*4 A!4(#(A–@(+!$!'!#$ L. D**#, «"!/*/!: 1&5;!: (#"('*"!., @(8!8( 2!7!>'-*78".D &%6-!9, $( %#$< '"%7"!: ! '"5$&%""!: '(#@&!,$!., /($(&6% ($ '#,/(;( @(4(?%"!, $&%)5G$, >$()6 @&!'%1%"6 )64! $% A*/$6 ! (@6$6, /($(&6% 4%?*$ ' %;( (#"('%» (189, #. 148). C #',+! # E$!8 1&5;(. @(#4%1('*$%4< M("$*, &5##/!. A!4(#(A D.W. 3)(4%"#/!., ' ()(#"('*"!! 1(#$(!"#$' @(+!$!'!+8*, 14, )(4<7%. 5)%1!$%4<"(#$! 5@($&%)!4 ()&*+"(% #&*'"%"!%, 5@(1()!' >%4('%/*, 1(;*1*'7%;(#,, >$( 8!& "% $*/(', /*/!8 (" /*?%$#, 8(&%@4*'*$%4G, /($(&6. ' ($/&6$(8 8(&% @(@*4 ' ;5#$(. $58*" !, 5)%1!'7!#<, >$( !+ $58*"* '6)&*$<#, "%'(+8(?"(, «(" +*8%14,%$ :(1 #51"* ! "*>!"*%$ (F5@6'*$< @&! @(8(F! 4($* 8(&#/(% 1"(, )4!?*.7%% / /(&*)4G. C($ E$( ! %#$< 1!1-!("'* 2!,'-'9',:%. 3" ;('(&!$ #%)% ! 1&5;!8: «C6)&*$<#, !+ $58*"*, 5'!1%$< 7!&(/!. ;(&!+("$, 5/*+6'*GF!. !#$!""6. @5$<, – "%4<+,. B(E$(85 1*'*.$% !##4%1('*$< )4!?*.7%%, $(, >$( 1(#$5@"( ! >$( 8(?"( !##4%1('*$<. Q51%8 !1$! '@%&%1 (F5@"(, E$( – 851&(% &%7%"!%. H, /("%>"(, +*#45;! M("$* ' E$(8 #86#4% (;&(8"6. 3" @(8(; 4G1,8 "*7%. E@(:! #(#&%1($(>!$< '#% #!46 #'(%;( 58*, '%&6 ! "*1%?1 "* @(4(?!$%4<"(. "*5/%» (286, #. 455).
113
B(",$"(, >$( ' E$(8 #45>*% #('%&7%""( )%+(#"('*$%4<"68! ! "%@&!%84%868! – @&%?1% '#%;( 14, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. – /*+*4!#< $(;1* !15F!% ($ =%;%4, @&%1#$*'4%"!, ( A!4(#(A!! /*/ «2*&!2% "*5/», "*5/% "*5/ ! $.@. M.9. J!8!&,+%', '6&*?*, E$( 58("*#$&(%"!% 5>%"6:, @!#*4: «R*5/* 1(4?"* ;&(8/( +*,'!$<, >$( ("* "% @(.1%$ ' M*"(##5. 3"* "% @&!+"*%$ "*1 #()(G ;4*'%"#$'* /*/(.-$( #'%&:"*5>"(., '"%"*5>"(., * @(@&(#$5 "% "*5>"(. A!4(#(A!!. 3"* "% @&%'&*$!$#, ' #45?*"/5 E$(. A!4(#(A!!… R*5/* #*8* #%)% A!4(#(A!,, $* A!4(#(A!,, /($(&5G ' 9";4!! #%8"*12*$(;( '%/* "*+6'*4! @&(#$( «"('(.», '(+'(1, %% "*>*4( / =*4!4%G ! QE/("5, /($(&5G '%4!/!. A&*"25+#/!. 86#4!$%4< 1%',$"*12*$(;( "*+'*4 «@(4(?!$%4<"(.» (351, #. XVIII–XIX). P E$!8 «'%4!/!8 A&*"25+#/!8 86#4!$%4%8», $( %#$< M("$(8 J!8!&,+%' #',+6'*4 «58#$'%""6. @%&%'(&($, /($(&6. "%#%$ # #()(. @(4(?!$%4<"*, A!4(#(A!, – A!4(#(A!, "*5/!» (352, #. 460). J%8 "% 8%"%% E$* «@(4(?!$%4<"*,» A!4(#(A!,, (#()%""( %% (@&%1%4,GF*, @&!"2!@!*4<"*, 5#$*"('/* – (&!%"$*2!, "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, "* "%@(#&%1#$'%""( 1*""(% – (/*+*4*#< 5,+'!8(. ' ($"(7%"!! #'(%. ()(#"('*""(#$! ! @(1'%&;4*#< /("#$&5/$!'"(. /&!$!/%, ' #'%$% /($(&(. @&(,#",4(#< ! &%*4<"(%, ()I%/$!'"( @($&%)"(% '+*!8(($"(7%"!% A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,. P'(. '*&!*"$ /&!$!/! $*/(;( &(1* @&%1#$*'!4, "*@&!8%&, L"&!/'%#. 3)I,#",, #'(% "%@&!,$!% *"$!8%$*A!+!>%#/(. #(#$*'4,GF%. @(+!$!'!+8* M("$*, (" ()&*$!4 '"!8*"!% "* "%():(1!8(#$< @&(,#"!$< #*8( @(",$!% «8%$*A!+!/*». «B&%?1% '#%;(, – @!7%$ (", – #4%15%$ 5#$*"('!$<, >$( ()6/"('%""( @("!8*G$ @(1 «8%$*A!+!/(.». Q6$< 8(?%$, "%8"(;!% !4! 1*?% ! "!/$( !+ @(+!$!'!#$(' "% #$*'!4 #%)% E$(;( '(@&(#*. H4! ?% ("!, @( /&*."%. 8%&%, >*#$( (#$*"*'4!'*4!#< "* ($'%$%: « *-%&','6% *1-8 "%;6% !< %<1!74-*, "*:(1,F%8#, @( $5 #$(&("5 A!+!>%#/(. ($"(#!$%4<"(#$!; E$($ %<1!74"*2!,"%9%*:, !, #4%1('*$%4<"(, "*5/* ( "%8 %#$< 8"!8*, "*5/*» (413, #. 43). -*+I,#",, #'(% @("!8*"!% 8%$*A!+!/!, %% #(1%&?*"!, ! #$&5/$5&6, $( %#$< @("!8*"!% #@%2!A!>%#/! A!4(#(A#/(;( @(+"*"!, 8!&*, L"&!/'%# ' !"-!7!#'0*16!= >*#$! E$(;( @(+"*"!, 5#8*$&!'*%$ (@&%1%4%""6. 2!7!>'-*78".=, #(@&,?%""6. # @(+"*'*%8(. 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!#$(8 '!1% #(:&*",%$#, 15: 8%$*A!+!/!, $($ #%.>*# ?% +*8%>*%$, >$( 1;?"!1-', !+ /($(&6: #(+!1*%$#, ' "!: 8!&, – @&%1#$*'4,G$ "% >$( !"(%, /*/ ()&*+6 &%*4<"6: '%F%.». 3$#G1* "*@&*7!'*%$#, '6'(1 ( 2%4%#(()&*+"(#$! ! "%():(1!8(#$!, "*&,15 # !"68), ! /*>%#$'%""( !"(;(, 1;"(#$"(;( (8%$*A!+!>%#/(;() @(1:(1* / @(+"*'*%8(. 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!. «C /("2% /("2(', – @!7%$ L"&!/'%#, – !"-!7!#'( %#$< 1;%4('%>%#/!8 15:(8 8(1%4<, E4%8%"$6 /($(&(., !+'4%>%""6% !+ &%*4<"6: ()I%/$(', /(8)!"!&5G$#, 14, !#$(4/('*"!, !+'%#$"(;( &,1* @(+"*"!., #(;4*#"(
114
(@&%1%4%""(. $(>/% +&%"!,, /($(&*, @&(!+'(4<"( #>!$*%$#, '#%()F%.» ($*8 ?%). C ()F%. 14, '#%;( @(+"*"!, ("$(4(;!>%#/(. @4(#/(#$! 8%$*A!+!>%#/(% '#%()F%%, #>!$*4 L"&!/'%#, "%():(1!8( #(@&,?%"( # #(($'%$#$'5GF!8 >*#$"68, ($1%4<"68, $( %#$< # $%8, >$( ' &*8/*: "%!+)%?"(;( @(+"*'*$%4<"(;( #*8((;&*"!>%"!, >%4('%>%#/(;( 15:* !##4%15%$#, %#$%#$'%""68! "*5/*8!. «-,1(8 # @(#$&(%"!,8! 8%$*A!+!>%#/!: ("$(4(;!., /($(&6% "% #/&6'*G$ #'(%;( @&!$,+*"!, #(+1*$< ,%6!"0*"";4 ! 2!7";4 "*5/5.., #$&(!4!#< ! %?%1"%'"( #$&(,$#, 1&5;!% !"-!7!#'0*16'* 1'1-*:. 14, (;&*"!>%""(. ()4*#$! @(+"*"!,. H +1%#< !8%%$#, "*4!2( $%"1%"2!, >%4('%>%#/(;( 15:* !+(4!&('*$< #%), ' #'(%8 #(+%&2*"!!…» ($*8 ?%, #. 45). C @&(2%##% @(+"*"!, 5/*+*""6% ("$(4(;!>%#/!% >*#$"(#$!, %F% "% !8%, – "* 1(#$!;"5$(8 5&('"% +"*"!, – @&(>"(;( A*/$5*4<"(;( ()%#@%>%"!,, @(1$'%&?1%"!, ' "%@(#&%1#$'%""( 1*""(8, @( "%():(1!8(#$! 5$'%&?1*G$#, ' A(&8% "*5>"6: ;!@($%+, 58(+&!$%4<"6: ' #'(%. @&%1@(4(?!$%4<"(#$!, * #$*4( )6$<, @( M("$5, 8%$*A!+!>%#/!: ! @($(85 !+4!7"!: ' "*5/%. L$!, @( 8"%"!G L"&!/'%#*, «)(4%% #/&(8"6% ! )(4%% @(4%+"6% @(#$&(%"!,, /($(&6% >*#$( '#$&%>*G$#, ' #/&6$(8 '!1% ' "*5/%, "% !+)%;4! "%58(4!8(. /&!$!/! M("$*, /($(&6. :*&*/$%&!+('*4 !: /*/ 8%$*A!+!>%#/!%. LA!& !4! ?!1/(#$!, /($(&68! A!+!/! ;!@($%$!>%#/! "*#%4,G$ "%'!1!86. 8!&, "% '#$&%$!4! 5 "%;( @(F*16; ! $( ?% 8(?"( #/*+*$< ( 1&5;!: *"*4(;!>"6: /("2%@2!,:, /($(&6% 1("6"% %F% @&!",$6 5 8"(?%#$'* 5>%"6:» ($*8 ?%). H"*>% ;('(&,, M("$ ' #'(%. «@(4(?!$%4<"(. A!4(#(A!!» # %% @(#4%1('*$%4<"(. *"$!8%$*A!+!>"(#$!% # &%*4<"(. @&*/$!/(. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, !, ' >*#$"(#$!, "* $*/(8 %;( #5F%#$'%""( '*?"(8 5>*#$/%, /*/ (@%&!&('*"!% "*5>"68! ;!@($%+*8!. H "% #45>*."( M.9. J!8!&,+%', ' 2%4(8 '6#(/( 2%"!'7!. @(+!$!'!#$#/5G A!4(#(A!G, ()&*$!4 '"!8*"!% ! "* $(, «>$( )64( %1'* 4! "% ;4*'"(. "*5>"(. (7!)/(. M("$*, – %;( @(@6$/! (;&*"!>!$< ()4*#$< @&!8%"%"!, "*5>"(. ;!@($%+6» (352, #. 101). M&!$!>%#/!. "*#$&(. %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. $(;( '&%8%"! ' ($"(7%"!! @(+!$!'!+8* 1(#$*$(>"( >%$/( ! (@&%1%4%""( '6&*+!4, "*@&!8%&, #(($%>%#$'%""!/ M("$*, '!1"6. 5>%"6. L. B!/*&, @( 8"%"!G /($(&(;(, «/("$('#/*, $%(&!,, "% +*)($,F*,#, (#()%""( ( $(>"(#$! *"*4!+*, !8%%$, &*+58%%$#,, (>%"< @&(#$(. '!1, "( ("* /&*."% @('%&:"(#$"*». H &*+I,#",, E$5 "%;*$!'"5G (2%"/5 @(+!$!'!+8*, B!/*& @!7%$ 1*4%%: «M("$, !"$%&%#('*'7!.#, (#()%""( #(2!(4(;!%., "% )64 5>%"68. 3" '#% '&%8, $(4/5%$ ( +*/(">%""(., $*/ #/*+*$<, "*5/%. 3) E$(8 #'!1%$%4<#$'5G$, 8%?15 @&(>!8, %;( "%51*>"6% @&%1#/*+*"!, ( "%!+)%?"6: ;&*"!2*:, @&!#5F!: &*+4!>"68 ($&*#4,8 +"*"!,. W;( #$*$!>%#/*, $(>/* +&%"!, "* "*5/5, /($(&5G (" ?%4*%$ '!1%$< /*/ 8(?"( #/(&%% +*'%&7%""(., "%@&!%84%8* 14, "*#» (301, #. 15). H +1%#<, #4%1('*$%4<"(, # @(+!2!! 1%,$%4<"(;( @&%1#$*'!$%4, "*5/! ($8%>%"( (>%'!1"(% @&($!'(&%>!% @(+!$!'!+8* # &%*4<"68 #(#$(,"!%8 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,,
115
'#%;1* 1!"*8!>"(;(, >5?1(;( /*/(. )6 $( "! )64( +*/(">%""(#$!, +*'%&7%""(#$!. R. H'*"2(', "*@&!8%&, ##64*%$#, "* 8"%"!% J. =%/#4!, #>!$*'7%;(, >$( @(+!$!'"*, A!4(#(A!, «"% $(4"(;( +"*>%"!,, "( ! @&,8( ,'4,%$#, #!G8!"5$"(G» (161, #. 93). 3)F!. #86#4 '(+&*?%"!. A!4(#(A(' ' *1&%# @(+!$!'!+8* ' #',+! # %;( *"$!8%$*A!+!>%#/(. "*@&*'4%""(#$%#$'%""!/* M("$*, !+'%#$"(;( A!4(#(A* L. %.%&#("*. B(4(?!$%4<"5G A!4(#(A!G M("$* (" #>!$*4 $%(&!%., «($&!2*GF%. '#,/(% ("$(4(;!>%#/(% !##4%1('*"!%, '#,/5G ;!@($%+5 ' #5F"(#$! )6$!,» (258, #. XIX). P(@(#$*'4,, E$5 $%(&!G # 8%$*A!+!/(. (A!4(#(A!%.), %.%&#(" @&!:(1!$ / '6'(15: «R*5/* ! 8%$*A!+!/* @&%#4%15G$ (1"5 ! $5 ?% 2%4< – @(+"*"!% &%*4<"(;(. M("$ E$( ($&!2*%$ "( (", )%+ #(8"%"!,, )64 "%@&*'; 5$!4!$*&"*, 2%4<, /($(&5G (" @&!@!#6'*4 "*5/%, ,'4,%$#, 4!7< '$(&(#$%@%""(., – @()5?1%"!%, /($(&(85 @('!"5%$#, 5>%"6., %#$< @&%?1% '#%;( 4G)(@6$#$'(, ?*?1* +"*"!,, @(#$!?%"!% (#"('6 '%F%.. 31!"*/('* $*/?% ! ($@&*'"*, $(>/*, – ("* "*:(1!$#, ' '(#@&!,$!! (' @%&2%@2!!), 1&5;!8! #4('*8! –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§ 3. 0=3242A=9 = D4FD4F52CE;E=D: >2C=J=9 B;8<4=CB; K4, 8*&/#!+8*, /*/ ! 14, @(+!$!'!+8*, :*&*/$%&"(. ! "%():(1!8(. )64* #',+< # 1(#$!?%"!,8! "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, "( %#4! @(+!$!'!+8 19!5'7 #'(G A!4(#(A!G / 1*""68 /("/&%$"6: "*5/, $( 8*&/#!+8 #'(G A!4(#(A!G !1"!9.9%7 "* E$!: 1*""6:, (@!&*4#, "* "!:, !#@(4<+('*4 ' /&!$!>%#/! (#'(%""(8 '!1%. C >*#$"(#$!, (@(&* "* %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. 8*$%&!*4 )64* ()I%/$!'"(. "%():(1!8(#$%#/!: '(++&%"!. "* @&!&(15. 0. L";%4<# @(1>%&/"54 ' #',+! # E$!8, >$( «14, 1!*4%/$!>%#/(;( ! '8%#$% # $%8 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(;( @("!8*"!, @&!&(16 "%():(1!8( +"*/(8#$'( # 8*$%8*$!/(. ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8» (405, #. 10–11). H (#"('(@(4(?"!/! 8*&/#!+8* 7!&(/( !#@(4<+('*4! 1(#$!?%"!, #('&%8%""(;( !8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!, 14, ()(#"('*"!, #'(!: A!4(#(A#/!: '(++&%"!., $%(&%$!>%#/!: '6'(1('. L$( 8(?"( @(/*+*$< "* @&!8%&% !: ($"(7%"!, / (1"(85 !+ ;4*'"6: 1(#$!?%"!. %#$%#$'(+"*"!, XIX '%/* – / E'(4G2!(""(85 5>%"!G K*&'!"*.
116
C #'(!: &*)($*:, ' $%(&%$!>%#/(8 ()(#"('*"!!, A*/$5*4<"(8 ()%#@%>%"!! $(;( !4! !"(;( #(2!(4(;!>%#/(;( !4! E/("(8!>%#/(;( 5#$*"('4%"!,, *&/# @(1>*# @&,8( *@%44!&5%$ / K*&'!"5, / (#"('(@(4*;*GF!8 !1%,8 ! /("/&%$"68 @(4(?%"!,8 %;( E'(4G2!(""(;( 5>%"!,. J*/, ' «M*@!$*4%» 14, @(1$'%&?1%"!, (1"(;( !+ #'(!: '6'(1(' (" ##64*%$#, "* «#(#$*'!'75G E@(:5» &*)($5 K*&'!"* «B&(!#:(?1%"!% '!1('» ! @&!'(1!$ #(($'%$#$'5GF5G '61%&?/5 !+ "%% (#8. 235, #. 353– 354). C 1&5;(8 8%#$%, ' $(8 ?% «M*@!$*4%», ' ()(#"('*"!% (>%&%1"(;( $%(&%$!>%#/(;( 5#$*"('4%"!, *&/# @&!'(1!$ #4%15GF!. *&;58%"$: «K*&'!" !"$%&%#('*4#, !#$(&!%. %#$%#$'%""(. $%:"(4(;!!, $( %#$< ()&*+('*"!%8 &*#$!$%4<"6: ! ?!'($"6: (&;*"(', /($(&6% !;&*G$ &(4< (&51!. @&(!+'(1#$'* ' ?!+"! &*#$%"!. ! ?!'($"6:. R% +*#45?!'*%$ 4! $*/(;( ?% '"!8*"!, !#$(&!, ()&*+('*"!, @&(!+'(1!$%4<"6: (&;*"(' ()F%#$'%""(;( >%4('%/*, !#$(&!, E$(;( 8*$%&!*4<"(;( )*+!#* /*?1(. (#()(. ()F%#$'%""(. (&;*"!+*2!!?» ($*8 ?%, #. 383). C &*)($*: L";%4<#* $*/?% "%8*4( ##64(/ "* E'(4G2!(""(% 5>%"!% K*&'!"*, &*+'%&"5$6: /(88%"$*&!%', (2%"(>"6: #5?1%"!.. «B&(!#:(?1%"!% '!1('» L";%4<#, /*/ ! *&/#, (:*&*/$%&!+('*4 /*/ @&(!+'%1%"!%, «#(#$*'!'7%% E@(:5» (#8. 406, #. 535). K*&'!"('#/5G $%(&!G &*+'!$!, L";%4<# &*##8*$&!'*4 ' /*>%#$'% (1"(;( !+ '*?"%.7!: A*/$(&(' /(&%""(;( @&%()&*+('*"!, '#%. 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/(. #A%&6 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, 5#$&*"%"!, !+ "%% #$*&(;(, «8%$*A!+!>%#/(;(» 8%$(1* 8674%"!,, +*8%"6 %;( "('68, 1!*4%/$!>%#/!8, (#"('*""68 "* !1%% &*+'!$!,, !1%% '+*!8(#',+!. «B(+"*"!% '+*!8"(. #',+! @&(2%##(', #('%&7*GF!:#, ' @&!&(1%, 1'!"54(#< ;!;*"$#/!8! 7*;*8! '@%&%1 (#()%""( )4*;(1*&, $&%8 '%4!/!8 ($/&6$!,8», ' >*#$"(#$!, «)4*;(1*&, '@%&'6% ' ()F%. #',+! @&%1#$*'4%""(85 K*&'!"(8 1(/*+*$%4<#$'5 $(;(, >$( '#% (/&5?*GF!% "*# $%@%&< (&;*"!+86, "% !#/4G>*, ! >%4('%/*, '(+"!/4! ' &%+54<$*$% 14!$%4<"(;( @&(2%##* &*+'!$!, !+ "%8"(;!: @%&'("*>*4<"( (1"(/4%$(>"6: +*&(167%., * E$! +*&(167!, ' #'(G (>%&%1<, ()&*+('*4!#< !+ '(+"!/7%. :!8!>%#/!8 @5$%8 @&($(@4*+86, !4! )%4/*» (407, #. 303–304). M E$(85 8(?"( 1()*'!$< 5)%?1%"!% L";%4<#* ' ,'"(. :%-*$'%7'1-'0"!1-' A!4(#(A#/(. #(#$*'4,GF%. 1*&'!"!+8*. L$5 8*$%&!*4!#$!>"(#$< @&%$'(&,4! ' #'(%8 8!&('(++&%"!! /*/ #*8 (#"('(@(4(?"!/ E'(4G2!(""(;( 5>%"!,, $*/ ! «8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/! "*#$&(%""6% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! !+ 7/(46 K*&'!"*» (406, #. 494). B(",$"( @(E$(85, >$( ' ()F%. 1!*4%/$!>"(#$! ! 8*$%&!*4!#$!>"(#$! L";%4<# ! *&/# 5#8*$&!'*4! "*4!>!% (@&%1%4%""6: $(>%/ #(@&!/(#"('%"!, #'(!: A!4(#(A#/!: '(++&%"!. # 8!&('(++&%">%#/!8! *#@%/$*8! 1*&'!"!+8*. L$( @&(,'4,4(#< @(1>*# ! ' &%7%"!,: /("/&%$"6: @&()4%8. J*/, "*@&!8%&, ' @!#<8% D*##*4G *&/# ($"(#!$%4<"( 1*&'!"('#/(;( «B&(!#:(?1%"!, '!1('» +*8%>*%$: «3>%"< +"*>!$%4<"*, &*)($* K*&'!"*, ("* ;(1!$#, 8"% /*/ %#$%#$'%""("*5>"*, (#"('* !#$(&!>%#/(. )(&<)6 /4*##('» (241, #. 121).
117
3@&%1%4%""5G #',+< 8*&/#!+8* # 1*&'!"!+8(8 #(+"*'*4!, !##4%1('*4!, @6$*4!#< $*/ !4! !"*>% ()I,#"!$< ! "%/($(&6% A!4(#(A6, #(2!(4(;! &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( @%&!(1*. J*/, "%8%2/!. #(2!(4(; ! *"$&(@(4(; D. C(4<$8*" ' #'(%. &*)($% «J%(&!, K*&'!"* ! #(2!*4!+8» @&(#4%?!'*%$ !1%."5G ()F"(#$< E'(4G2!(""(;( 5>%"!, K*&'!"* ! 8*&/#!#$#/(;( @("!8*"!, ()F%#$'%""(;( &*+'!$!,. *&/# ! L";%4<#, @( %;( 8"%"!G, «($4!>"( @(",4! ! ,#"( '6&*+!4! !1%."5G #',+< 5>%"!, K*&'!"* ( &*+'!$!! # !: #()#$'%""68 @("!8*"!%8 !#$(&!! ! #(2!(4(;!!. %?15 $%8 !: 5>%"!% )64( 5?% +*/(">%"(, /(;1* '6#$5@!4 K*&'!" #( #'(%. "('(. +((4(;!>%#/(. ! *"$&(@(4(;!>%#/(. $%(&!%.. 3"! #('%&7%""( #@&*'%14!'( 5'!1%4! ' "%. @(1$'%&?1%"!% #'(!: '+;4,1(' "* #5F"(#$< ()F%#$'%""(;( &*+'!$!,» (69, #. 4). -*#/&6'*, 1*4%% :*&*/$%& ()"*&5?%""(. !8 !1%."(. ()F"(#$!, '+*!8(1(@(4",%8(#$! 1*&'!"!+8* ! 8*&/#!+8*, C(4<$8*" /("/&%$!+!&5%$ %% @&!8%"!$%4<"( / @&()4%8% >%4('%/* ! 1%4*%$ '6'(1: «N%4('%/ /*/ !$#%"'0*16!* 1;?*1-9!, %#$< 2%"$& ! "(#!$%4< '#%: $%:"!>%#/!: ! 15:('"6: #@(#()"(#$%. ! @&(,'4%"!. – @(E$(85 "*5>"(% ()I,#"%"!% >%4('%>%#/(. /54<$5&6 $&%)5%$ ' (1!"*/('(. 8%&% /*/ )!(4(;!>%#/(;(, $*/ ! E/("(8!>%#/(;( @("!8*"!, !#$(&!!; "*>*4( $(85 ! 1&5;(85 @(4(?!4! !8%""( K*&'!" ! *&/#» ($*8 ?%, #. 5). R*&,15 # !1%."(. ()F"(#$%#/(8 @4*"%: «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» ($*8 ?%, #. 15). C(4<$8*" @&! E$(8 ##64*%$#, "* '6#/*+6'*"!% L";%4<#* ( $(8, >$( ' /*@!$*4!#$!>%#/(8 ()F%#$'% «E/#@45*$!&5%86. ! 5;"%$*%86. /4*## – @&(4%$*&!*$ – "% 8(?%$ 5?% (#'()(1!$< #%), ($ !;* E/#@45*$!&5GF%;( ! ;(#@(1#$'5GF%;( /4*##* – )5&?5*+!!, – "% (#'()(?1*, '8%#$% # $%8 &*+ ! "*'#%;1* '#%;( ()F%#$'* ($ '#,/(. E/#@45*$*2!!, 5;"%$%"!,, /4*##('(;( 1%4%"!, ! /4*##('(. )(&<)6». L$* 86#4<, @( 8"%"!G L";%4<#*, «1(4?"* 14, !#$(&!! !8%$< $*/(% ?% +"*>%"!%, /*/(% 14, )!(4(;!! !8%4* $%(&!, K*&'!"*» (407, #. 367). B(",$"(, >$( (@&%1%4%""6% >%&$6 #:(1#$'*, !1%."(. ! 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/(. ()F"(#$! ' 1*&'!"!+8% ! 8*&/#!+8% ($"G1< "% !#/4G>*G$ ! "%!+)%?"6: #5F%#$'%""6: &*+4!>!. ' "!:, /("/&%$"( – ' >*#$!, ($8%>%""(. C(4<$8*"(8, $( %#$< ' >*#$!, /*#*GF%.#, #(($"%#%"!, 8*&/#!#$#/(;( 5>%"!, ( /4*##('(. )(&<)% ' ()F%#$'% # 1*&'!"('#/!8
118
5>%"!%8 ( )(&<)% +* #5F%#$'('*"!% ' @&!&(1%. L";%4<# ' #',+! # E$!8 &%+/( '(+&*?*4 @&($!' '#,/!: @(@6$(/ ()I,#"%"!, ,'4%"!. ()F%#$'%""(. ?!+"! @(1 5;4(8 +&%"!, &%*4!+*2!! ' "!: $%: ?% +*/("(', /($(&6% 1%.#$'5G$ ! ' @&!&(1%, ' >*#$"(#$!, 1*&'!"('#/(. )(&<)6 +* #5F%#$'('*"!%. 3" #>!$*4, >$( «5?% ' ()4*#$! @&!&(16 "%4<+, @&('(+;4*7*$< $(4%#$'( – #$&%8!$<#, @(1'%#$! '#% )(;*$(% 8"(;(()&*+!% !#$(&!>%#/(;( &*+'!$!, ! %;( 5#4(?"%"!, @(1 $(F5G ! (1"(#$(&(""GG A(&8545: «)(&<)* +* #5F%#$'('*"!%». L$( +"*>!$ "!>%;( "% #/*+*$< !4! $(;( 8%"<7%» (406, #. 622). L";%4<# !#:(1!4 @&! E$(8 !+ /*>%#$'%""6: &*+4!>!. ' ()&*+% ?!+"! ?!'($"(;( ! >%4('%/*: «\!'($"(%, ' 45>7%8 #45>*%, 1(:(1!$ 1( 1!<'$%"'(, >%4('%/ ?% 2$!',9!5'-; (" #(+1*%$ $*/!% ?!+"%""6% #&%1#$'* (' 7!&(>*.7%8 #86#4% E$(;( #4('*), /($(&6% @&!&(1* )%+ "%;( "% @&(!+'%4* )6. L$( 1%4*%$ "%'(+8(?"68 '#,/(% @%&%"%#%"!%, )%+ #(($'%$#$'5GF!: (;('(&(/, +*/("(' ?!+"! ?!'($"6: ()F%#$' "* >%4('%>%#/(% ()F%#$'(». H (@&%1%4,, @&!"2!@!*4<"5G 8*&/#!#$#/5G @(+!2!G ' &*##8*$&!'*%8(8 '(@&(#%, L";%4<# @!#*4: «O?% @("!8*"!% !#$(&!! /*/ &,1* /4*##('6: )!$' ;(&*+1( #(1%&?*$%4<"%% ! ;45)?%, >%8 @&(#$(% #'%1%"!% %% / #4*)( ($4!>*GF!8#, 1&5; ($ 1&5;* A*+*8 )(&<)6 +* #5F%#$'('*"!%» ($*8 ?%, #. 623). K*&'!"!+8 ! 1&5;!% /&5@"%.7!% 1(#$!?%"!, %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ' #%&%1!"% XIX '%/*, @( 8"%"!G *&/#* ! L";%4<#*, ' #'(!: 8!&('(++&%">%#/!: #4%1#$'!,: ()I%/$!'"( #@(#()#$'('*4! '6&*)($/% 1!*4%/$!>%#/(;( '+;4,1* "* ,'4%"!, @&!&(16. L";%4<#, /*#*,#< E$(;( '(@&(#*, @!#*4: «Q4*;(1*&,… ;&(8*1"68 5#@%:*8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, 86 8(?%8 $%@%&< ' ()F%8 ! 2%4(8 ()"*&5?!$< "% $(4%#/!8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8, 8(?"( ' 1('(4<"( #!#$%8*$!>%#/(. A(&8% 1*$< ()F5G /*&$!"5 @&!&(16 /*/ #',+"(;( 2%4(;(» (407, #. 304). C*?"%.7!8 #4%1#$'!%8 E$(;( ,'!4(#< /(&%""(% !+8%"%"!% @&!"2!@(' '+*!8(($"(7%"!, A!4(#(A#/(;( ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, >$( '6&*+!4(#< @&%?1% '#%;( ' /&57%"!! "*$5&A!4(#(A!!. B(1>%&/!'*, E$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, L";%4<# @!#*4: «J%@%&< ?%, /(;1* "*8 1(#$*$(>"( '+;4,"5$< "* &%+54<$*$6 !+5>%"!, @&!&(16 1!*4%/$!>%#/!, $( %#$< # $(>/! +&%"!, !: #()#$'%""(. #',+!, >$()6 #(#$*'!$< 51('4%$'(&!$%4<"5G 14, "*7%;( '&%8%"! «#!#$%85 @&!&(16», ! /(;1* #(+"*"!% 1!*4%/$!>%#/(;( :*&*/$%&* E$(. #',+! @&("!/*%$ 1*?% ' 8%$*A!+!>%#/! '67/(4%""6% ;(4('6 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '(@&%/! !: '(4% – $%@%&< "*$5&A!4(#(A!! @&!7]4 /("%2. C#,/*, @(@6$/* '(#/&%#!$< %% "% $(4
119
%#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. M. *&/# ' @!#<8% L";%4<#5 ' 1866 ;(15 1*4 @(+!$!'!+85 M("$* $*/5G :*&*/$%&!#$!/5: «X 7$51!&5G $%@%&<, /&(8% '#%;( @&(>%;(, M("$*, @($(85 >$( *";4!>*"% ! A&*"25+6 $*/ 8"(;( /&!>*$ () E$(8 #5)I%/$%. H: @(1/5@*%$ ' "]8 E"2!/4(@%1!>"(#$<, #!"$%+. R( @( #&*'"%"!G # =%;%4%8 E$( "%>$( ?*4/(% (:($, M("$ @&%'(#:(1!$ %;( /*/ #@%2!*4!#$ ' ()4*#$! 8*$%8*$!/! ! A!+!/!, $( %#$< @&%'(#:(1!$ ' 1%$*4,:, !)( ' 2%4(8 =%;%4< )%#/("%>"( '67% 1*?% ! +1%#<). H E$($ 1&,""(. @(+!$!'!+8 @(,'!4#, ' 1832 ;(15!» (237, #. 197). R( ! ' "%@(+!'!#$#/(. A!4(#(A!! ' @%&'(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/*, ! ' >*#$"(#$!, ' 8*$%&!*4!+8% $(;( '&%8%"! (#"('(@(4(?"!/! 8*&/#!+8* "% '!1%4! &%*4<"(. #!46, #@(#()"(. @&($!'(@(#$*'!$< @(+!$!'!+85 /("2%@2!!, #(($'%$#$'5GF!% "('(85 5&('"G &*+'!$!, "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. K*?% 0%.%&)*:, /($(&6., @( 8"%"!G L";%4<#*, (1!" )64 '61*GF!8#, A!4(#(A(8, «"% #58%4 @%&%7*;"5$< +* @&%1%46 A!4(#(A!!, '61*'*'7%. #%), +* "%/5G "*5/5 "*5/, @*&,F5G "*1 '#%8! ($1%4<"68! "*5/*8! ! #',+6'*'75G !: '(%1!"(, – E$* A!4(#(A!, (#$*'*4*#< ' %;( ;4*+*: "%@&!/(#"('%""(. #',$6"%.»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– #!#$%8*$!>%#/! ! #(($'%$#$'%""( %;( '"5$&%""%. #',+!, $&%)('*4 @&!'%1%"!, ' @&*'!4<"5G #',+< &*+4!>"6: ($&*#4%. +"*"!,. «R(, +*",'7!#< E$!8, %#$%#$'(+"*"!% '#$5@*%$ ' $%(&%$!>%#/5G ()4*#$<, * +1%#< E8@!&!>%#/!% 8%$(16 (/*+6'*G$#, )%##!4<"68!, +1%#< 8(?%$ (/*+*$< @(8(F< $(4%#/(% 8674%"!%. R( $%(&%$!>%#/(% 8674%"!% ,'4,%$#, @&!&(?1]""68 #'(.#$'(8 $(4%"!, '#%. @&%17%#$'5GF%. A!4(#(A!!» (406, #. 366). R( ' "('6: !#$(&!>%#/!: 5#4('!,:, "* "('(8 5&('"% "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, A!4(#(A!, "% 8(;4* 5?% #5F%#$'('*$< ! &*+'!'*$<#, ' #'(!: @&%?"!: A(&8*:, "% 8(;4* #(:&*",$< @&%?"!% @&!"2!@6 '+*!8(($"(7%"!, # %#$%#$'%""("*5>"68 @(+"*"!%8. B&%?",, «'#%,1"(#$<» A!4(#(A!!, (:'*$ %G '#%: (#"('"6: #$(&(" "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, #8%"!4!#< )(4%% >]$/!8 (@&%1%4%"!%8 ;&*"!2 %]
120
A5"/2!("!&('*"!,, &*+1%4%"!%8 «#A%& '4!,"!,» 8%?15 "%G ! (/&%@7!8! /("/&%$"68! "*5/*8!, #5?%"!%8 ! )(4%% ,#"68 ()(+"*>%"!%8 %] #@%2!A!>%#/(;( @&%18%$*. H##4%1('*"!% ! ()I,#"%"!% >*#$"6: #$(&(" 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! "%!+)%?"( 1(4?"( )64( @%&%.$! !+ '%1%"!, A!4(#(A!! ' '%1%"!% %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/. L$( ! 1%4*4( "%'(+8(?"68 1*4<"%.7%% #5F%#$'('*"!% '#%()I%84GF!: A!4(#(A#/!: #!#$%8, @&%$%"15GF!: "* *)#(4G$"5G !#$!"5 '( '#%: #A%&*: +"*"!,. H+ '#%;( #(1%&?*"!, @&%?"%. A!4(#(A!! ' "('6: 5#4('!,: #(:&*",4( @(4(?!$%4<"5G +"*>!8(#$< 5>%"!% ( 8674%"!! ! %;( +*/("*:. L";%4<# @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «M*/ $(4%"!% ( 8674%"!! ! %;( +*/("*: – A(&8*4<"*, 4(;!/* ! 1!*4%/$!/*. C#% (#$*4<"(% ':(1!$ ' @(4(?!$%4<"5G "*5/5 ( @&!&(1% ! !#$(&!!» (405, #. 25). R( $*/(% /*&1!"*4<"(% !+8%"%"!% ' @(4(?%"!! A!4(#(A!! ! %] '+*!8(($"(7%"!! # /("/&%$"68! "*5/*8! )64( '(+8(?"( 4!7< @&! 5#4('!! ('4*1%"!, /("/&%$"("*5>"68 @(+"*"!%8 1!*4%/$!/(., 1!*4%/$!>%#/!8 8%$(1(8 8674%"!,, * ' #%&%1!"% UIX '%/* E$( '6#$5@*4( /*/ )(4%% !4! 8%"%% ($1*4]""*, @%&#@%/$!'*. «D!7< /(;1* %#$%#$'(+"*"!% ! !#$(&!>%#/*, "*5/* '@!$*G$ ' #%), 1!*4%/$!/5, 4!7< $(;1* '%#< A!4(#(A#/!. #/*&) – +* !#/4G>%"!%8 >!#$(;( 5>%"!, ( 8674%"!! – #$*"%$ !+4!7"!8, !#>%+"%$ ' @(4(?!$%4<"(. "*5/%» (406, #. 525). B&!8%"!$%4<"( / %#$%#$'(+"*"!G E$( (+"*>*%$, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( #('%&7%""( !+4!7"%. #$*"('!4*#< "*$5&A!4(#(A!,. R( (#'()(?1%"!% ($ "%] 1(4?"( !1$! "% $(4%#/!: %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: 8%$(1(' !##4%1('*"!,, "*/(@4%"!, /("/&%$"6: 1*""6:, "( ! @( @5$! 5#'(%"!, $(;( @(4(?!$%4<"(;(, >$( )64( 1(#$!;"5$( A!4(#(A!%. "* @&($,?%"!! '#%;( %] @&%17%#$'5GF%;( &*+'!$!,. «M(;1* %#$%#$'(+"*"!% "*5>!$#, 5#'*!'*$< &%+54<$*$6, 1(#$!;"5$6% &*+'!$!%8 A!4(#(A!! ' $%>%"!% 1'5: # @(4('!"(. $6#,>%4%$!., ("( !8%""( )4*;(1*&, E$(85 !+)*'!$#,, # (1"(. #$(&("6, ($ '#,/(. (#()(., '"% %;( ! "*1 "!8 #$(,F%. "*$5&A!4(#(A!!, # 1&5;(. – ($ #'(%;( #()#$'%""(;(.., (;&*"!>%""(;( 8%$(1* 8674%"!,» (405, #. 14). R( !+8%"%"!% @(4(?%"!, A!4(#(A!!, ($/*+ ($ %] @&!$,+*"!. "* (/(">*$%4<"5G !#$!"5 '( '#%: ()4*#$,: @(+"*"!, )64! @(1;($('4%"6 "% $(4"(;( @(+"*"!,, "( ! ' "%8%"<7%. #$%@%"! &*+'!$!%8 #*8(. A!4(#(A!! – 1!*4%/$!>%#/(. ! 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(., '@%&'6% #$*'7%. ' 8*&/#!+8% 1!*4%/$!/(– 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(.. H8%""( E$( @(#4%1"%% ()#$(,$%4<#$'( ! ()5#4('!4(, @( 8"%"!G (#"('(@(4(?"!/(' 8*&/#!+8*, /*&1!"*4<"(% !+8%"%"!% @(4(?%"!, A!4(#(A!! ' %] ($"(7%"!! / /("/&%$"("*5>"(85 @(+"*"!G. L";%4<#, /*#*,#< &*+&*)($*""(;( *&/#(8 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(;( @("!8*"!, !#$(&!!, @!#*4, >$( «E$( @("!8*"!% "*"(#!$ A!4(#(A!!
121
#8%&$%4<"6. 51*& ' ()4*#$! !#$(&!! $(>"( $*/ ?%, /*/ 1!*4%/$!>%#/(% @("!8*"!% @&!&(16 1%4*%$ "%"5?"(. ! "%'(+8(?"(. '#,/5G "*$5&A!4(#(A!G. J%@%&< +*1*>* ' $(. ! ' 1&5;(. ()4*#$! +*/4G>*%$#, "% ' $(8, >$()6 @&!1586'*$< #',+! !+ ;(4('6, * ' $(8, >$()6 ($/&6'*$< !: ' #*8!: A*/$*:. V* A!4(#(A!%., !+;"*""(. !+ @&!&(16 ! !+ !#$(&!!, (#$*]$#,, $*/!8 ()&*+(8, %F] $(4!#$(. 86#4!, @(#/(4%"!% ( +*/("*: #*8(;( @&(2%##* 8674%"!,, 4(;!/* ! 1!*4%/$!/*» (407,#. 316). L$( ! "%/($(&6% @&!'%1%""6% '67% '6#/*+6'*"!, L";%4<#*, @&! !: @('%&:"(#$"(8 @("!8*"!!, 8(;5$ )6$< !#$(4/('*"6 /*/ ($&!2*"!% !8 '#%. A!4(#(A!!, A!4(#(A!! /*/ "*5/!. H @(@6$/! $*/(;( !: !#$(4/('*"!, !8%4! 8%#$(. C >*#$"(#$!, ' "*7%. #$&*"% ' "*>*4% 1920-x ;(1(' '(+"!/4( !1%."(% $%>%"!%, '6#$5@*'7%% ($ !8%"! 8*&/#!+8*, * "* 1%4% ,'4,'7%%#, %;( «4%'(.» '54<;*&!+*2!%.. 3#"('5 E$(;( $%>%"!, #(#$*'4,4( "!;!4!#$!>%#/(% ($&!2*"!%, «4!/'!1*2!,» A!4(#(A!! /*/ A(&86 15:('"(. ?!+"!, ,/()6 )5&?5*+"(. @( #'(%. @&!&(1% !, #4%1('*$%4<"(, #('%&7%""( >5?1(. ! '&*?1%)"(. @&(4%$*&!*$5. 0!4(#(A!! @&($!'(@(#$*'4,4*#< "*5/*. 31!" !+ '!1"6: «4!/'!1*$(&('» P. !"!" ' #$*$<% «0!4(#(A!G +* )(&$!», (@5)4!/('*""(. ' 1922 ;(15 ' ?5&"*4% «B(1 +"*8%"%8 8*&/#!+8*», (#"('6'*,#< "* "%'%&"( !#$(4/('*""6: '6#/*+6'*"!,: L";%4<#* @&!7]4 / '6'(15, >$( « *&/# ! L";%4<# @&($!' A!4(#(A!!» (272, #. 125). 0!4(#(A!,, 14, P. !"!"*, – «E$( 15:('"6. ($$!#/ )5&?5*+!!, /'!"$E##%"2!, %] /4*##('(;( 15:*» ($*8 ?%, #. 123). B(",$"( @(E$(85, >$( 14, @&(4%$*&!*$* ("* "%@&!%84%8* "! ' /*/(. A(&8% ! ' %;( 8!&('(++&%"!! 1(4?"* 5#$5@!$< 8%#$( "*5/%. «3$ '#%. A!4(#(A!! (#$*]$#,, «@(#/(4%;( "% (#$*]$#,: A!4(#(A!, ' ;(4('% @&(4%$*&!*$* (/(">*$%4<"( '6$%#",%$#, "*5/(.…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– 8*&/#!#$#/(% A!4(#(A#/(% "*@&*'4%"!%, «%1!"#$'%""(%, /($(&(% 1%.#$'!$%4<"( @&!"%#4( @4(16» (407, #. 300). -*+&6' # !1%*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!%. =%;%4, @&(!+(7]4 «@5$]8 9!,9$%-% / 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. $(>/% +&%"!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 301. M5&#!' 8(.. – B.3.). P4%1('*$%4<"(, ' ($4!>!% ($ @(+!$!'!+8*, 8*#/!&('*'7%;(#, @(1 "%.$&*4<"(% @( ($"(7%"!G / 8*$%&!*4!+85 ! !1%*4!+85 A!4(#(A#/(% "*@&*'4%"!%, (#"('(@(4(?"!/! 8*&/#!#$#/(. A!4(#(A!! ($/&6$( @&('(+;4*#!4! %] @(#4%1('*$%4<"5G 8*$%&!*4!#$!>"(#$<: «R('(% "*@&*'4%"!% ($4!>*4(#<
122
4!7< $%8, >$( +1%#< '@%&'6% 1%.#$'!$%4<"( #%&<]+"( ($"%#4!#< / 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(85 8!&('(++&%"!G, >$( ("( )64( @(#4%1('*$%4<"( @&('%1%"( – @( /&*."%. 8%&% ' (#"('"6: >%&$*: – '( '#%: &*##8*$&!'*%86: ()4*#$,: +"*"!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 301). R(, #(:&*"!' ' #'(%. A!4(#(A!! 8*$%&!*4!+8 @&%17%#$'%""!/(', *&/# ! L";%4<# ' $( ?% '&%8, @(1",4! %;( "* /*>%#$'%""( "('5G, )(4%% '6#(/5G #$5@%"<: ("! #1%4*4! %;( 1!*4%/$!>%#/!8. H +1%#< @&(#4%?!'*%$#, #',+< # @&%17%#$'5GF%. A!4(#(A!%., # 1!*4%/$!/(. =%;%4,, ' >*#$"(#$!. «=%;%4< "% )64 @&(#$( ($)&(7%" ' #$(&("5. R*()(&($, +* !#:(1"5G $(>/5 )64* '+,$*… &%'(4G2!(""*, #$(&("* %;( A!4(#(A!!, 1!*4%/$!>%#/!. 8%$(1». R(, ' ($4!>!% ($ =%;%4,, #$&(!'7%;( #'(G 1!*4%/$!/5 "* !1%*4!#$!>%#/(. (#"('%, *&/# ! L";%4<# ' #'(%. A!4(#(A!! "*@(4"!4! 1!*4%/$!/5 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!8 #(1%&?*"!%8. «E*$";93'18 / 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. $(>/% +&%"!,, 86 #"('* 5'!1%4! ' >%4('%>%#/!: @(",$!,: ($()&*?%"!, 1%.#$'!$%4<"6: '%F%., '8%#$( $(;(, >$()6 ' 1%.#$'!$%4<"6: '%F*: '!1%$< ($()&*?%"!, $%: !4! !"6: #$5@%"%. *)#(4G$"(;( @(",$!,. K!*4%/$!/* #'(1!4*#< E$!8 / "*5/% () ()F!: +*/("*: 1'!?%"!, /*/ '"%7"%;( 8!&*, $*/ ! >%4('%>%#/(;( 8674%"!,» (/5&#!' 8(.. – B.O.). K!*4%/$!/* @(",$!. @&%1#$*4* ' 8*&/#!+8% «4!7< #(+"*$%4<"68 ($&*?%"!%8 1!*4%/$!>%#/(;( 1'!?%"!, 1%.#$'!$%4<"(;( 8!&*» ($*8 ?%, #. 301-302). C#% E$! #5?1%"!, @&!'%1%"6 +1%#< # (1"(. 2%4$( @("!8*"!% *&/#(8 ! L";%4<#(8 ($"(7%"!, #'(%. A!4(#(A!! / @&%17%#$'5GF%. – @&!"2!@!*4<"( !"(%, "%?%4! ' @(+!$!'!+8%. W#4! (#"('(@(4(?"!/ @(#4%1"%;( 3. M("$ ($'%&;*4 /*/5G )6 $( "! )64( #',+< #'(%. A!4(#(A!! #( '#%. @&%17%#$'5GF%. A!4(#(A!%., $( (#"('(@(4(?"!/! 8*&/#!+8*, "*()(&($, @(1>%&/!'*4! $*/5G #',+<. R( ' $( ?% '&%8, @&!+"*'*4! ! /*>%#$'%""(% ($4!>!% #'(%. A!4(#(A!! ($ '#%: @&%17%#$'5GF!: A!4(#(A#/!: "*@&*'4%"!., – ($4!>!%, ()5#4('4%""(% /*>%#$'%""( "('68 5&('"%8 &*+'!$!, /*/ #*8(. A!4(#(A!!, $*/ ! /("/&%$"6: "*5/. N$( /*#*%$#, "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, $( +1%#< 14, #(+1*"!, "('(. A!4(#(A!!, ($'%>*GF%. %;( @($&%)"(#$,8, 14, 5#$*"('4%"!, !"6: ($"(7%"!. 8%?15 A!4(#(A#/!8 ! /("/&%$"("*5>"68 @(+"*"!%8, "%():(1!8( )64( «@%&%7*;"5$< +* @&%1%46 A!4(#(A!!, '61*'*'7%. #%), +* "%/5G "*5/5 "*5/, @*&,F5G "*1 '#%8! ($1%4<"68! "*5/*8! ! #',+6'*GF5G !: '(%1!"(» ($*8 ?%, #. 300). H8%""( $*/5G A!4(#(A!G – ! $(4%#$'%""( !"68! +*1*>*8! !, #(($'%$#$'%""(, # !"68! @&!"2!@*8! '+*!8(($"(7%"!, # /("/&%$"(-"*5>"68 @(+"*"!%8. 3#$*'4,, +* #()(. ! '@&%1< !##4%1('*"!% +*/("(' 8674%"!,, E$* A!4(#(A!, "% ($#$&*",4*#< ! ($ !+5>%"!, ,'4%"!. @&!&(16 ! ()F%#$'*. «P('&%8%""6.
123
8*$%&!*4!+8, – @!#*4 L";%4<#, – '!1!$ ' !#$(&!! @&(2%## &*+'!$!, >%4('%>%#$'* ! #$*'!$ #'(%. +*1*>%. ($/&6$!% +*/("(' 1'!?%"!, E$(;( @&(2%##*» (405, #. 24). C #A%&% @(+"*"!, ,'4%"!. @&!&(16 (1"5 !+ ;4*'"6: A5"/2!. E$(;( «#('&%8%""(;(», $( %#$< !8 ! *&/#(8 #(+1*""(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8*, L";%4<# '!1%4 ' $(8, >$( (" «()()F*%$ "('%.7!% 5#@%:! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, #(;4*#"( /($(&68 @&!&(1* $(?% !8%%$ #'(G !#$(&!G '( '&%8%"!». H ' $(8 ! ' 1&5;(8 #45>*% «#('&%8%""6. 8*$%&!*4!+8 ,'4,%$#, @( #5F%#$'5 1!*4%/$!>%#/!8 ! "% "5?1*%$#, )(4<7% "! ' /*/(. A!4(#(A!!, #$(,F%. "*1 @&(>!8! "*5/*8!» ($*8 ?%, #. 25). V1%#< $*/?% ,#"( @&(#4%?!'*%$#, @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$< 8*&/#!+8* ! @(+!$!'!+8*. W#4! @(+!$!'!+8 @&!7]4 A*/$!>%#/! / ($&!2*"!G A!4(#(A!! /*/ "*5/!, $( ' 8*&/#!+8% A!4(#(A!, "% $(4%#/!. @&%18%$, #@%2!A!>%#/!% A!4(#(A#/!% @&()4%86, #(:&*",%$#, #*8* /*/ "*5/*, "( ! @(1"!8*%$#, "* "('5G, )(4%% '6#(/5G #$5@%"< &*+'!$!,, @&!()&%$*%$ /*>%#$'%""( "('(%, )(4%% #5F%#$'%""(% +"*>%"!% 14, /("/&%$"("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, ! ' >*#$"(#$!, 14, %#$%#$'(+"*"!,. J%8 "% 8%"%% ! @(+!$!'!#$#/*, @&!"2!@!*4<"*, @(+!2!, ' &*##8*$&!'*%8(8 '(@&(#% (/*+*4*#< 1(#$*$(>"( @&(>"(.. C( '#,/(8 #45>*%, %% /("2%@$5*4<"*, &%*4!+*2!, "% @&%#%/4*#< @(#4% M("$*, "( @&(1(4?!4*#< ' !"(8 *'$(&#$'%, ' !"6: '*&!*"$*:. 3"*, E$* @(+!2!,, "*1(4;( #(:&*"!4* #'(G !"$%44%/$5*4<"5G "!75 ' A!4(#(A!! "*5/!, ' &*+&*)($/*: A!4(#(A(', ' 8!&('(++&%"!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%.. § 4. F282G >2C=F=5=CB: ,5DE;8=64 = %;Q C /("2% XIX – "*>*4% UU ''. "* #8%"5 @%&'(85 @(+!$!'!+85 – @(+!$!'!+85 3. M("$* – @&!7%4 @(+!$!'!+8 ' 1&5;(. %;( &*+"('!1"(#$! – ' A(&8% C:2'$'!6$'-'+',:% 7'%.2*&#/(;( A!4(#(A* -. 9'%"*&!5#* (1843–1896) ! *'#$&!.#/(;( %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4, ! A!4(#(A* L. *:* (1838–1916). 3$ /("$('#/(;( @(+!$!'!+8* (" 5"*#4%1('*4 *"$!8%$*A!+!>%#/5G #(#$*'4,GF5G ' &%7%"!! '(@&(#* ( '+*!8(($"(7%"!! A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,. P*8 E$($ '(@&(# "% )64 ;4*'"68, (@&%1%4,GF!8 ' E8@!&!(/&!$!2!+8%. 3" )64 @(1>!"%" (#"('"(. @&!"2!@!*4<"(. 5#$*"('/% – 6$'-'6* 0'1-!#! !2.-%. 3)()F%""( %% '6&*?*, @&!8%"!$%4<"( / 9'%"*&!5#5, (1!" !+ %;( @(#4%1('*$%4%. =. D*"2, @!#*4: «0!4(#(A#/!% !1%! -. 9'%"*&!5#* /("2%"$&!&5G$#, '(/&5; (1"(. (#"('"(. @&()4%86, – @&()4%86 ($"(7%"!, ! '+*!8(1%.#$'!, 8%?15 A!+!>%#/!8 ! @#!:!>%#/!8 8!&(8. L$( ($"(7%"!% 8(?%$ )6$< &*##8($&%"( # 1'5: #('%&7%""( &*+4!>"6: $(>%/ +&%"!, – # ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/(. ! # )!(4(;!>%#/(.» (195, #. 205). P ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/(. $(>/! +&%"!, &*#/&6'*%$#, «($"(7%"!% 8%?15 ()I%/$(8 ! #5)I%/$(8, «86#4%#/!. 8!& ,'4,%$#, ' E$(8 #86#4% 8"!868 ()I%/$(8 @#!:!>%#/(;(». C6,#"%"!% E$(. 8"!8(#$!, @( 8"%"!G D*"2*, «! %#$< (#"('"*, +*1*>* ! '%4!/*, +*#45;* 9'%"*&!5#*». P )!(4(;!>%#/(. $(>/!
124
+&%"!,, «A!+!>%#/!. 8!& ,'4,%$#, E8@!&!>%#/!8 5#4('!%8 14, ?!+"! ! &*+'!$!, @#!:!>%#/(;(; (" !;&*%$ &(4< *&;58%"$* 14, '#%: @#!:!>%#/!: A5"/2!., 5@&*'4,,, /*/ "%+*'!#!8(% @%&%8%""(%, '#%8! 157%'"68! !+8%"%"!,8!; ?!+"< 15:* )!(4(;!>%#/! '#%2%4( +*'!#!$ ($ ?!+"! $%4*; 1(/*+*$< E$5 '#%()F"(#$< @#!:(A!+!>%#/(. +*'!#!8(#$!, (@&('%&;"5$< '#,/5G *@&!(&"(#$< ! 8%$*A!+!>%#/5G @&!&(?1%""(#$< ! $%8 +*4(?!$< A5"1*8%"$ 14, #!#$%86 «>!#$(;( (@6$*» – $*/('* '$(&*, +*1*>* *'%"*&!5#('#/(. A!4(#(A!!. -%7*, %%, 9'%"*&!5# %#$%#$'%""( "*$*4/!'*4#, #"*>*4* "* '(@&(#6 ()F%)!(4(;!>%#/(;( :*&*/$%&* ( $(8, >$( $*/(% ?!+"< ! /*/('6 %% @&!"2!@6 '(()F%. C E$(8 #86#4% A!4(#(A!, 9'%"*&!5#* ,'4,%$#, #'(%;( &(1* ()F%. )!(4(;!%. !4!, 45>7% #/*+*$<, ()F%. 8%:*"!/(. ?!+"!» ($*8 ?%, #. 205–206). H"*>% ;('(&,, /*/ ! ' /("$('#/(8 @(+!$!'!+8%, A!4(#(A!, 5 9'%"*&!5#*, 4!7%""*, '#,/(. 8%$*A!+!>"(#$!, #'(1!$#, A*/$!>%#/! / @(+!$!'"(85 8*$%&!*45 %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, ' 1*""(8 #45>*% – / 8*$%&!*45 )!(4(;!!, @&%1#$*%$, #4%1('*$%4<"(, /*/ A!4(#(A!, )!(4(;!!. -*#/&6'*, @(1 E$!8 5;4(8 +&%"!, /("/&%$"6% "*5>"6% (#"('*"!, E8@!&!(/&!$!2!+8*, 1&5;(. %;( @&(@*;*"1!#$ K. C!/$(&(' @(1>%&/"54, >$( «A!4(#(A!, >!#$(;( (@6$* %#$< (1"( !+ ($'%$'4%"!. $*/ "*+6'*%8(. "*5>"(. A!4(#(A!!…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» (62, #. 2–3). L$( +"*>!$, >$( A!4(#(A!, 9'%"*&!5#* ' #'(%8 "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 (#5F%#$'4%"!! @&%1#$*%$ "% /*/ @&(2%## ! !$(; A!4(#(A#$'('*"!,, #5F"(#$"(;( @(#$!?%"!,, * /*/ @&(2%15&* 1%$*4<"(;( "*5>"(;( !##4%1('*"!, ! A!/#*2!, %;( /("/&%$"6: &%+54<$*$('. L$(, ' #'(G (>%&%1<, /*/ @(1>%&/"54 5>%"!/ 9'%"*&!5#* 0. M*&#$*"<%", «$&%)('*4(, "! )(4%%, "! 8%"%%, /*/ @(4"(;( ($&%>%"!, ($ ()F%@&!",$(;( A!4(#(A#/(;( #/4*1* 8674%"!,, "% ;('(&, 5?% () 5#'(%"!! >5$< "% #('#%8 "('(;( ,+6/*» (171, #. 11). 3$#G1* ! #(($'%$#$'5GF%% ($"(7%"!% / $&*1!2!(""(. A!4(#(A!!, ()F%@(+!$!'!#$#/(% ($'%&?%"!% 8%$*A!+!/!, %% !#/4G>%"!% !+ "*5/!, !+ @(+!$!'"(. A!4(#(A!!. J*/, (1!" !+ ;4*'"6: @(@54,&!+*$(&(' E8@!&!(/&!$!2!+8* 9'%"*&!5#* H. B%$2(4<1$ 5$'%&?1*4, >$( +*1*>* «E$(. #$&(;( (@6$"(. A!4(#(A!! %#$< (/(">*$%4<"(% @&%(1(4%"!% @&%1#$*'4%"!, #5)#$*"2!!, !#$(&!, /($(&(;( ! %#$< !#$(&!, A!4(#(A!!… J(4!#$(;( (@6$* 51*4(#< &*+&%7%"!% @&()4%86 !+"5$&!, !+ #*8(. #5F"(#$! 1%4*, ! 51*4(#< E$( %. )4*;(1*&, @(#4%1('*$%4<"(85 @&('%1%"!G &%4,$!'!#$!>%#/(;( @&!"2!@*.
125
9)#(4G$"(% @&($!'(&%>!% 8%?15 1%.#$'!$%4<"68 ! /*?5F!8#, )6$!%8, 8%?15 ,'4%"!%8 ! '%F%#/*, (7!)/* '#,/(;( !1%*4!+8*. J*/ /*/ '8%#$% # @&%1#$*'4%"!%8 #5)#$*"2!! @*1*%$ ! '#,/*, 8%$*A!+!/*, $( A!4(#(A!, >!#$(;( (@6$* %#$< '8%#$% # $%8 @(+!$!'!+8 ! '#%;( 45>7% )51%$, @(?*45., "*+'*$< %% $*7(-'9'1-'0*16': 2!,'-'9',:!:» (299, #. 9–10). P*8 9'%"*&!5#, ()(#"('6'*, #'(G @&!"2!@!*4<"5G @(+!2!G ' @("!8*"!! A!4(#(A!!, ($8%$!4, >$( «@&!"2!@ "*!8%"<7%. 8%&6 #!46, /($(&6. ,'4,%$#, '(()F% (#"('(. '#%: $%(&%$!>%#/!: *@@%&2%@2!., '#,/(;( #$&%84%"!, / @("!8*"!G ! '#%: "*5/, #$*',F!: @(#4%1"%% #'(%. +*1*>%., ,'4,%$#,, ' >*#$"(#$!, 6!$"*: &'7!1!&''» (2, #. 25). P(($'%$#$'%""( ' "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 A5"/2!("!&('*"!! A!4(#(A!! %% #4%15%$ &*##8*$&!'*$< «/*/ #$*'7%% "*5>"68 #$&%84%"!% 86#4!$< #('(/5@"(#$< '#%;( 1*""(;( ' (@6$% # "*!8%"<7%. +*$&*$(. #!46… R( #('(/5@"(#$< '#%;( 1*""(;( ' (@6$% !4! '#%;(, >$( '(()F% 8(?%$ )6$< 1*"( ' (@6$%, 86 "*+6'*%8 8!&(8. B(E$(85 86 &*##8*$&!'*%8 A!4(#(A!G /*/ 8674%"!% ( 8!&% #(($'%$#$'%""( @&!"2!@5 "*!8%"<7%. 8%&6 #!46». 3$#G1* «A!4(#(A!, – @( +*1*>% #'(%. – 1(4?"* )6$< @(#$*'4%"* ' /("2% &,1* "*5/, $*/ /*/ 14, %% &*)($6 "%():(1!8( 5?% &*+'!$!% >*#$"6: "*5/» ($*8 ?%, #. 30–31). H ' #'(!: &%+54<$*$*: «A!4(#(A!, %#$< "% >$( !"(%, /*/ */$ ()()F%"!, '#%: "*.1%""6: #@%2!*4<"68! "*5/*8! ! !8! ?% (>!F%""6: ()F!: (@6$"6: @(",$!. ' (1"( @(",$!% ! @&!8%"%"!% E$(;( @(#4%1"%;( / #('(/5@"(#$! '#%;( #5F%;(». H @($(85 «8%$(1 A!4(#(A!! "% 8(?%$ )6$< $(;1* "! >%8 1&5;!8, /*/ $(4%#/!8 @&(2%##(8, ' /($(&(8 +*/4G>*%$#, '#,/(% ()()F%"!% ! @("!8*"!%. H %#4! A!4(#(A!, ' E$(8 $%#"%.7%8 #86#4% @%&%#$*%$ )6$< "*5/(. ' #5F%#$'%""(8 +"*>%"!! E$(;( #4('*, $( ("* '#% ?% (#$*%$#, "*5>"68 8674%"!%8» ($*8 ?%, #. 53– 54). R*5>"68 4!7< @(#$(4!F%""68!». P4%1('*$%4<"(, A!4(#(A!,, ' %% @("!8*"!! 9'%"*&!5#(8, 4!7*%$#, #$*$5#* #*8(#$(,$%4<"(. "*5/!, #*8(#$(,$%4<"(;( "*5>"(;( $'(&>%#$'* ! #(:&*",%$#, ' "*5>"(8 @(+"*"!! 4!7< ' /*>%#$'% !88*"%"$"(. @#!:(4(;!>%#/(. @&(2%15&6 86#4!$%4<"(. ()&*)($/! – ()()F%"!, ! @("!8*"!, – &%+54<$*$(' /("/&%$"("*5>"6: !##4%1('*"!. #(()&*+"( @&!"2!@5 "*!8%"<7%. 8%&6 #!4, $( %#$<, !"*>% ;('(&,, @&!"2!@5 «E/("(8!! 8674%"!,». C 2%4(8 ?%, /*/ #>!$*4 9'%"*&!5#, «#$&(%"!% A!4(#(A!! (@&%1%4,%$#, #(1%&?*"!%8 $(;(, >$( 1*"( ' >!#$(8 (@6$%» ($*8 ?%, #. 55). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, /(&%"< A!4(#(A!!, %% +*1*>!, 8%$(1 ! #$&(%"!% +*86/*G$#, 5 9'%"*&!5#* "* &%*4!+*2!! @&!"2!@* "*!8%"<7%. 8%&6 #!46, @&!"2!@*, @&(!+'(1"(;(, ' #'(G (>%&%1<, ($ (#"('(@(4*;*GF%;( /("2%@$5*4<"(;( 5#$*"('4%"!,, ($ >!#$(;( (@6$*. R* E$(. @&!"2!@!*4<"(. (#"('% #$&(!4(#< ! ()I,#"%"!% 9'%"*&!5#(8 '#%;(
126
#5)I%/$"(–()I%/$"(;( ($"(7%"!, ' &%*4<"(8, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!!. C ($"(7%"!! ()I%/$"(. – )6$!."(. – >*#$! @(+"*"!, 9'%"*&!5# @(1>%&/"54, >$( «'#,/(% )6$!% @( #(1%&?*"!G #'(%85 1(4?"( 86#4!$<#, /*/ (F5F%"!%, * @( A(&8% – /*/ 1'!?%"!%. J*/('(, #4%1('*$%4<"(, $( ()F%% @(",$!%, @(1 /($(&(% 8(?"( @(1'%#$! '#% #5F%% ! /($(&(% "% 8(?%$ )6$< @(1'%1%"( "! @(1 /*/(% 1&5;(%, )(4%% ()F%% 8*$%&!*4<"(% @(",$!%» ($*8 ?%, #. 76). Q6$!% /*/ (F5F%"!% – E$( ,'"6. #5)I%/$!'"(–!1%*4!#$!>%#/!. *#@%/$ ' A!4(#(A!! 9'%"*&!5#*, *#@%/$, ' #5F%#$'% #'(%8 "%@&!4(?!86. / %#$%#$'(+"*"!G. N$( /*#*%$#, #5)I%/$"(. >*#$! @(+"*"!, ' %% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @&%$'(&%"!!, $( 9'%"*&!5# !#:(1!4 +1%#< !+ $(;(, >$( 2%4< %#$%#$'(+"*"!, – «#1%4*$< @(",$"68! @&(2%##6 @&!&(16. B(E$(85 # $(;( 8(8%"$*, /(;1* "%1(#$*$(>"(% '(#@&!,$!% @&%1(#$*'4,%$ #@(#()"(#$< @&%1#$*'4%"!, !+'%#$"5G #'()(15, %#$%#$'(+"*"!% )51%$ @&!#@(#()4,$<#, / @($&%)"(#$! #5)I%/$* @&%1#$*'4%"!., $( %#$< # E$(;( 8(8%"$* %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(% 8674%"!% )51%$ 1*4<7% &*+'!'*$< @&%1#$*'4%"!, ( #5F%8 ' #(($'%$#$'!! # @($&%)"(#$!$*4 9'%"*&!5#, &%*4!+5%$#, "* (#"('% "%@(#&%1#$'%""(. @&('%&,%8(#$!, ' @&%1%4*: &*"%% @(",$(;(, +"*/(8(;(, "*4!>"(;( ' (@6$%. «…K4, @("!8*"!, "%():(1!8( @(1'%1%"!% $(;(, >$( @(14%?!$ @("!8*"!G, @(1 /*/(%-"!)51< ()F%% @(",$!%, #(1%&?*F%% ' #%)% $( +"*/(8(%, >$( "%():(1!8( 14, @("!8*"!,. B(E$(85 '( '#%: $%: #45>*,:, ;1% "*5>"(% !##4%1('*"!% @(+"*]$ /*/(."!)51< @&(2%## !+8%"%"!,, /*/ @&(2%## #4(?"6., ("( @(@6$*%$#,, >$()6 @(",$< %;(, &*+4(?!$< ()I%/$ !##4%1('*"!, "* %;( >*#$!, &*+4(?!$< '%#< @&(2%## "* &,1 !4! ;&5@@5 @&(#$6: @&(2%##('» ($*8 ?%, #. 77). %$*A!+!/* (A!4(#(A!,), @( 8"%"!G 9'%"*&!5#*, "! ' /*/(. 8%&% "% ($'%>*%$ E$(85 /&!$%&!G "*5>"(#$!, %% #()#$'%""*, @&()4%8*$!/* ('%F< ' #%)%, #5)#$*"2!, ! $.@.) "*:(1!$#, '"% @&%1%4(' (1"(+"*>"(., /*/ ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, &*+&%7*%8(#$!, "%@(#&%1#$'%""(. @&('%&,%8(#$! >%&%+ (@6$. %$*A!+!/* – E$( &*)($* 86#4! ':(4(#$5G. «H ' "*#$(,F%% '&%8, %F%, – @!#*4 9'%"*&!5#, – A!4(#(A ($#$5@*%$ "*+*1 @%&%1 +*1*>%. 1*"*!1 – «@(+"*$<» '%F< ' #%)% ' %% ()I%/$!'"(. #5F"(#$! !4! !+8%&!$< ()I%8 "*7%. «#@(#()"(#$! @(+"*"!,» @( @(+"*'*%8(#$! !4! "%@(+"*'*%8(#$! E$(. '%F!. H E$( (;&(8"(% /(4!>%#$'( 15:('"6: #!4, E$($ (;&(8"6. $&51, +*158*""6. # #*868! 45>7!8! "*8%&%"!,8!, $&*$!$#, "* 8%$*A!+!>%#/(% (@&%1%4%"!% ;!@(#$*+!&('*""(;( '#@(8(;*$%4<"(;( @&%1#$*'4%"!,, "* @&()4%85, "* #*8(8 1%4% 4!7%""5G '#,/(;( ()I%/$*, "* ($6#/*"!% *&!*1"!"(. "!$! !+ 4*)!&!"$*, /($(&6. +*&*"%% )64 #(+1*" #*8!8 A!4(#(A(8 ! ' /("2% /("2(' #5F%#$'5%$ $(4%#/(. @&()4%8*$!/%. «B&!'%1%""68! &*##5?1%"!,8!, – @!7%$ 1*4%% 9'%"*&!5#, – 86 &*##%,4! #(8"%"!,, '(+8(?"( 4! '(()F% 5#$&*"%"!% @&%1#$*'4%"!, #5)#$*"2!! !+ "*7%;( 8!&('(++&%"!,. 3/*+*4(#< '%#<8* '%&(,$"68, >$( @( 8%&% "(&8*4<"(;(
127
&*+'!$!, 8674%"!, E$( @&%1#$*'4%"!% )51%$ 5#$&*"%"(. R* E$(8 (#"('*"!! 86 +1%#< )51%8 #>!$*$< %;( 5?% 5#$&*"%""68» ($*8 ?%, #. 74). R( $%8 #*868 5#$&*",%$#, ! 8%$*A!+!/*, ("* '6'(1!$#, +* &*8/! "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. M "*5/%, / %#$%#$'(+"*"!G ("* "% !8%%$ "!/*/(;( ($"(7%"!,, @(E$(85 #"!8*%$#, ! '%#< '(@&(# ( 9,%':!!-"!3*"'' A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,: "*5>"*, A!4(#(A!, ' '!1% ()()F*GF%;( 8674%"!, !88*"%"$"* #*8(85 %#$%#$'(+"*"!G; 8%$*A!+!>%#/*, A!4(#(A!, ' '!1% 58(+&!$%4<"(;( (#'(%"!, #@%2!A!>%#/(. ("$(4(;!>%#/(. ! ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/(. @&()4%8*$!/! #*8(1('4%GF*, #*8(1(#$*$(>"* ! ' #5$! #'(%. >5?1* %#$%#$'(+"*"!G, @(#/(4%"6. L. *:. 3" #*8(#$(,$%4<"(, "%+*'!#!8( ($ 9'%"*&!5#*, @&!7%4 / #:(1"68 @&!"2!@!*4<"68 @(+!$!'!#$#/!8 5#$*"('4%"!,8. 9'%"*&!5#, @(1>%&/!'*, )4!+(#$< '(++&%"!. – #'(!: ! *:*, – ($8%$!4: «C '6#7%. #$%@%"! )(1&,F% 1%.#$'('*4! "* 8%", &*)($6 L&"#$* *:*…» (1, #. 15). 31"!8 !+ #5F%#$'%""6: 8(8%"$(' ()F"(#$! @&!"2!@!*4<"6: @(+!2!. *:* ! 9'%"*&!5#* – @&!8%"!$%4<"( / '(@&(#5 ( '+*!8(($"(7%"!! A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, – ,'!4#, @&!"2!@ «E/("(8!! 8674%"!,» *:*, *"*4(;!>"6. @&!"2!@5 "*!8%"<7%. 8%&6 #!46 9'%"*&!5#*. 9. Q(;1*"(', !+4*;*, ! /(88%"$!&5, E$($ *#@%/$ ' E8@!&!(/&!$!2!+8% 9'%"*&!5#*, ($8%$!4 ! #4%15GF%%: $&%)5%$#,, >$()6 @(+"*"!% «)64( /*/ 8(?"( @&(F%, /*/ 8(?"( «E/("(8"%%» ' #86#4% +*$&*$ E"%&;!! "* %;( 5#'(%"!%; ("( $%8 «!#$!""%%», >%8 4%;>% !8 ('4*1%$<. C E$(8 +*/4G>*%$#, C6!"!:'0*16%( @&!&(1* @(+"*"!, – '6&*?%"!% 1&5;(;( '(?1, #('&%8%""(;( E8@!&!+8*, A!+!(4(;* ! A!+!/* L&"#$* *:*» (33, #. 146). B&!"2!@ «E/("(8!! 8674%"!,» *: &*##8*$&!'*4 /*/ 5"!'%&#*4<"6. @(+"*'*$%4<"6. @&!"2!@, 1%.#$'%""6., EAA%/$!'"( @&%$'(&,%86. '( '#%: (#"('"6: #A%&*: @(+"*"!,, @&%?1% '#%;( – "*5>"(;(. P*8( "*4!>!% #$!:!."( &%*4!+5%8(. «E/("(8!! 8674%"!,» *:, @( %;( #4('*8, '@%&'6% ()"*&5?!4, !+5>*, ' !#$(&!>%#/(8 @4*"% !##4%1('*$%4<#/5G 1%,$%4<"(#$< '61*GF!:#, 5>%"6: @&(74(;(. « "%, – @!7%$ *:, – )&(#!4*#< ' ;4*+* (1"* ()F*, !8 '#%8 >%&$*: ("! '#% '6)!&*4! 14, #'(%. 2%4! #&%1#$'* "*!)(4%% @&(#$6%, "*!)(4%% E/("(8"6%, "*!)(4%% )4!+/( / "%. '%15F!%». R*.1, E$(. 1(;*1/% @(1/&%@4%"!% ' #@%2!*4<"(. 4!$%&*$5&%, ' &*)($*: @( @(4!$!>%#/(. E/("(8!!, *: @(#$%@%""( «@&!'6/ &*##8*$&!'*$< 15:('"5G 1%,$%4<"(#$< 5>%"(;( !##4%1('*$%4,, /*/ 1%,$%4<"(#$< E/("(8!>%#/5G» (52, #. 125). J%8 )(4%% >$( @(1$'%&?1%"!, ()"*&5?!4!#< ! ' 1&5;(. – )!(4(;!>%#/(. – #A%&%. C >*#$"(#$!, @(1 '4!,"!%8 !1%. D*8*&/* ! K*&'!"* )(&<)* "*5>"6: !1%. #$*4* &*##8*$&!'*$<#, *:(8 «/*/ ?!+"%""*, )(&<)* # '6?!'*"!%8 "*!)(4%% @&!#@(#()4%""(;( ' &%+54<$*$% %%. L$($ '+;4,1 "% @&($!'(&%>!4
128
'(++&%"!G E/("(8!>%#/(85, *, 1(@(4",, %;(, ()I%1!",%$#, # "!8 ' (1"5 )!(4(;!>%#/!-E/("(8!>%#/5G $%(&!G @(+"*"!,». L$* $%(&!, @(+"*"!, 5$&*>!'*%$ /*>%#$'( A!4(#(A#/(. ;"(#%(4(;!! ! @&%1#$*%$ 5 *:* /*/ E/("(8!>%#/!. '*&!*"$ "*5>"(. E@!#$%8(4(;!!, #(;4*#"( /($(&(. «+*1*>* "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, #'(1!$#,… / @&!#@(#()4%"!G 86#4%. / A*/$*8 ! @&!#@(#()4%"!G 86#4%. 1&5; / 1&5;5»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» ($*8 ?%). K4, *:* ($8%>%""6% '67% !1%!, @( %;( #4('*8, #5$< «(#"('"6% &5/('(1,F!% !1%!» ' %;( $%(&!! @(+"*"!,. -*+'!'*, !:, (" !#:(1!4 !+ #4%15GF!: @(#64(/: «M(;1* 8674%"!% @6$*%$#, ($&*+!$< #'(!8! (;&*"!>%""68! #&%1#$'*8! )(;*$5G ?!+"< '#%4%""(., ?!+"<, 4!7< 8*4%"*#$%&@*$< /($(&5G 5 "%;( "% 8(?%$ )6$< "!/*/(. "*1%?16, ("( !8%%$ '#% (#"('*"!, E/("(8"( &*#:(1('*$< #'(! #!46. 3$#G1* – #$&%84%"!% A!4(#(A!! '#%: '&%8%" (:'*$!$< (#"('"6% >%&$6 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! @(#&%1#$'(8 "%)(4<7(;( >!#4* (&;*"!>%#/! &*#>4%"%""6: !1%.» (255, #. 152). C #$*"('4%"!! ! &*+'!$!! E$(. ()I%/$!'"(. ! "%!+)%?"(. E/("(8"(#$! 8674%"!, *: 5#8*$&!'*%$ (@&%1%4%""5G #(2!*4<"5G, !#$(&!>%#/! &*+'%&$6'*GF5G#, @(1(@4%/5, /*#*GF5G#, «@(>'6, "* /($(&(. '6&*#$*%$ "*5/*. R( &*+'!'*$<#, ("* "*>!"*%$ 4!7< ' ()F%#$'% !, ' (#()%""(#$!, ' &%8%#4%, @( 8%&% $(;(, /*/ '(+&*#$*%$ "%():(1!8(#$< ' ()8%"% "*/(@4%""68 (@6$(8» ($*8 ?%, #. 155–156). B&(#4%?!'*, ' #',+! # E$!8 &%*4<"(% &*+'%&$6'*"!% #$*"('4%"!, "*5/!, *: !#:(1!4 !+ $(;(, >$( «@()5?1*%86. !"#$!"/$(8 #*8(#(:&*"%"!, / @&*/$!>%#/!–E/("(8"68 1%.#$'!,8, >%4('%/ #"*>*4* #('%&7%""( !"#$!"/$!'"( &%*;!&5%$ "* 5#4('!, )4*;(@&!,$"6% ! "%)4*;(@&!,$"6% 14, "%;(. R( @( 8%&% #(2!*4<"(;( &*+'!$!,, # &*+1%4%"!%8 $&51*, # +*&(?1%"!%8 #(#4('!. &%8%#4%""!/(' ($1%4<"6. >%4('%/ '6"5?1%" ()&*$!$<#, / @&(8%?5$(>"68 #&%1#$'*8, / @&(8%?5$(>"68 2%4,8 14, 51('4%$'(&%"!, @($&%)"(#$%., ! $(4!"*%$ #(+"*$%4<"( 1%.#$'('*$< !"$%44%/$». R* #8%"5 @&*/$!>%#/(. "%51('4%$'(&%""(#$! @&!:(1!$ "%51('4%$'(&%""(#$< !"$%44%/$5*4<"*,. C %% !+"*>*4<"(. &%*4!+*2!! «!"#$!"/$!'"6% 1'!?%"!, 1!/*&,, @(45#(+"*$%4<"( +*5>%""6% @&!%86 &%8%#4%""!/* #5$< @(1;($('!$%4<"6% #$5@%"! 14, @(",$!. "*5>"(;( !##4%1('*$%4,. C+;4,16 ! )*"*4<"6% @&!%86 &%8%#4%""!/*, "* /($(&6% #8($&,$ $*/ #'6#(/*, "%+*8%$"(
129
@%&%:(1,$ '( '+;4,16 ! @&!%86 A!+!/* ! E/("(8!, 5*=1-9'( @(#$%@%""( &*+'!'*%$#, ' '"-*77*6-;%78";4 E/("(8!G "*5>"(;( !##4%1('*$%4,, /($(&*, 8(?%$ @&(,'!$<#, $*/?% ! ' #$&%84%"!! / #*868 !1%*4<"68 2%4,8» (252, #. 129–130). C #',+! # "%():(1!8(#$%&%+ E/("(8"(% 8674%"!%, #>!$*4 *:, @(,'4,%$#, @($&%)"(#$< «,#"( @&%1#$*'!$< #%)% '*?"6% #5F%#$'%""6% >%&$6 "*)4G1*%86: ,'4%"!., >$()6 1*$< !8 #(($'%$#$'5GF!% "*+'*"!, ! #(()F!$< ( "!: 1&5;!8. J(, >$( 86 "*+6'*%8 ()5>%"!%8, !8%%$ 2%4!$%4<"( #)%&%?%"!% (@6$* (1"(;( >%4('%/* @&! @(#&%1#$'% (@6$* 1&5;(;(» (255, #. 156). C /("/&%$"(8 (#5F%#$'4%"!! E/("(8"( (&;*"!+('*""(;( 8674%"!,, ' 1!!*%$#, ' "*7%8 ,+6/%. P4('* 8(?"( #&*'"!$< # ($4!$68 $!@(;&*A#/!8 "*)(&(8, /($(&6., !+)*'4,, ($ @('$(&%"!, @!#<8*, – #45?!$ #*868 &*+"(()&*+"68 2%4,8… X+6/ ! "*:(1,F%%#, # "!8 ' !+'%#$"(. '+*!8"(. #',+! *)#$&*/$"(% 8674%"!% #(#$*'4,G$, /*/ ' 8(+*!>"(. /*&$!"%, "%@(1'!?"6% ()&*+6 !+8%">!'(;( 8!&*, (#$*"*'4!'*,#< "* '*?"%.7%8, !;"(&!&5, )%+&*+4!>"(%, ?%&$'5,, @&*'1*, $(>"(#$!$, >$( ()F!% @&!"2!@6 E/("(8!>"( (&;*"!+('*""(. ?!+"! "*:(1,$ @(4"(% @&!8%"%"!% ! ' ()4*#$! ()61%""6: ! "*5>"6: @(",$!.. C "*5>"(. $%&8!"(4(;!! E/("(8!, ,+6/*, /("%>"( ?%, %F% )(4%% 5#('%&7%"#$'('*"*» ($*8 ?%). L$( 5#('%&7%"#$'('*"!% '6&*?*%$#, @&%?1% '#%;( ' 5@(&,1(>%"!! @(+"*'*$%4<"(;( A5"/2!("!&('*"!, ,+6/* @(#&%1#$'(8 #(($'%$#$'5GF!: 4(;!>%#/! (&;*"!+('*""6:, @(",$!."( (A(&84%""6: (@%&*2!., ' >!#4% /($(&6: *: '61%4,%$ !2'1%"'*. «R*5>"(% «#(()F%"!%» '#%;1* #(1%&?!$ ' #%)% (@!#*"!%, $( %#$< '(#@&(!+'%1%"!% (@6$* ' 86#4,:, 1(4?%"#$'5GF%% ,%:*"(-8 #()(G #*86. (@6$ ! $*/!8 ()&*+(8 ',<%97(-8 !- "*!%"!, ! !+5>%"!, #45?!$ !%;( 1&5;(;( "% @&%1#$*'4,G$ #()(. ! +*/("6 @&!&(16» ($*8 ?%, #. 157). C 2%4(8 ?% "*5>"*, +"*>!8(#$< «E/("(8!! 8674%"!,» @(#&%1#$'(8 @&!8%"%"!, #@%2!*4<"(;( ,+6/* +*86/*%$#, 5 *:* – ' @(4"(8 #(($'%$#$'!! # (#"('"(. @(+!$!'!#$#/(. 5#$*"('/(. – "* &%6-*, "* %;( @(+"*'*$%4<"(8 @&%$'(&%"!!. *: ($8%$!4 ' #',+! # E$!8 #4%15GF%%: «M(;1* 86 '@%&'6% ()(+&%'*%8 /*/5G-4!)( ()4*#$< A*/$(', ("* @&%1#$*'4,%$#, "*8 &*+"(()&*+"(., "%(1!"*/('(., +*@5$*""(. ! @(4"(. @&($!'(&%>!.. O1*%$#, 51%&?!'*$< ' @*8,$! 4!7< /*?16. ($1%4<"6. A*/$, '"% '#,/(. #',+! # (#$*4<"68!. 6 ;('(&!8, >$( ()4*#$< E$* 14, "*# "* (1"%. *4(-@(8*45 86 ($6#/!'*%8 ' E$(. 8(+*!/% A*/$(' @&(#$6%, (#$*GF!%#, &*'"68! #%)%, E4%8%"$6, !+ /($(&6: 8(?"( 86#4%""( #(#$*'!$< '#G ()4*#$< A*/$('. -*+ 86 1(74! 1( $(;(, >$( '( '#%8
130
&*+"(()&*+!! 8(?%8 5?% ($6#/!'*$< !5"' ' -* >* A*/$6, 86 "% >5'#$'5%8 5?% #%), >5?168! ' E$(. ()4*#$!, 86 ()(+&%'*%8 %% )%+ (#()%""(;( "*@&,?%"!, #!4, ("* 14, "*# 9.(1"*"%». 3$#G1* ! #(($'%$#$'5GF*, ()F*, #5F"(#$"*, :*&*/$%&!#$!/* +*7*2!7%#%"'( ' "*5>"(8 8674%"!!: «L$* 2%4< – ()(+&%"!% 1*""(. ()4*#$! # "*!8%"<7%. $&*$(. #!4 ! '(#@&(!+'%1%"!% '#%: A*/$(' ' !5"!: @&(2%##% 86#4! – '@(4"% 8(?%$ )6$< "*+'*"* E/("(8!>%#/(.» ($*8 ?%, #. 157–158). B&!"2!@ «E/("(8!! 8674%"!,» *: /("/&%$!+!&('*4 @&!8%"!$%4<"( / ($1%4<"68 "*5/*8, '6,'4,, ' "!: #@%2!A!>%#/!% A(&86 &%*4!+*2!! "*+'*""(;( @&!"2!@*. J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, (" #>!$*4, >$( «E/("(8!, 86#4! "*!)(4%% &*+'!$* ' $(. "*5/%, /($(&*, 1(#$!;4* "*!'6#7%;( A(&8*4<"(;( &*+'!$!, ! / 5#45;*8 /($(&(. $*/ >*#$( @&!)%;*%$ ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!%, $( %#$< ' 8*$%8*$!/%. M*/ )6 E$( "! +'5>*4( #$&*""(, "( #!4* 8*$%8*$!/! /&(%$#, ' $(8, >$( ("* !+)%;*%$ '#%: "%"5?"6: 86#4%. ! '6/*+6'*%$ /&*."GG )%&%?4!'(#$< ' (@%&*2!,: 8674%"!,» ($*8 ?%). J(>"( $*/ ?% «A!+!/* @&%1#$*'4,%$ #()(. E/("(8!>%#/! 5@(&,1(>%""6. (@6$. Q4*;(1*&, E$(85 5@(&,1(>%"!G "% $(4$( 5?% @&!()&%$%"(, "( '6,#",G$#, @&()%46 ! "%():(1!8(#$< @(@&*'(/, /*/ E$( )6'*%$ @&! ()(+&%"!! ()&*+2('(;( :(+,.#$'*. 0!+!/*, @(1()"( 8*$%8*$!/%, 1*%$ ()()F*GF%% (@!#*"!% A*/$(' ! /&*$/(%, #?*$(%, "( !#/4G>*GF%% '#,/5G '(+8(?"(#$< #8%7%"!,, ()(+"*>%"!% @(",$!.» ($*8 ?%, #. 159). R*5>"6% 2!"(-'( ' !: "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 @(+"*'*$%4<"(8 A5"/2!("!&('*"!! ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, @( 8"%"!G *:*, ,'4,G$#, "*!)(4%% 1%.#$'%""68 #&%1#$'(8 «E/("(8!! 8674%"!,»: « 6 8(?%8 /*?1(% 8;"('%"!% '(#@&(!+'%#$! '#% )(;*$(% #(1%&?*"!% @(",$!, ! &*+'!$< %;( 1( @(4"(. >5'#$'%""(. ,#"(#$!. M*/(% 8"(?%#$'( 5@(&,1(>%""6:, ;($('6: / 5@($&%)4%"!G 86#4%. (:'*$6'*%$ #()(., "*@&!8%&, @(",$!% @($%"2!*4*. R%$ @(E$(85 "!>%;( 51!'!$%4<"(;(, %#4! ' /("2% /("2(' (@%&!&('*"!% @(",$!,8!, ' /($(&6: +*/4G>%"( $*/ 8"(;( ;($('(. 5?% &*)($6, ,'4,%$#, $*/!8 4%;/!8 1%4(8» ($*8 ?%, #. 159–160). C !$(;% ?% '#% #',+*""(% # «E/("(8!%. 8674%"!,» ' "*5>"(8 @(+"*"!! '(#:(1!$ 5 *:* / 1&5;(85 8!&('(++&%">%#/(85 (#"('(@(4(?%"!G @(+!$!'!+8*, ' >*#$"(#$!, E8@!&!(/&!$!2!+8* – / !2.-;. «…B%&'6% "*7! @(+"*"!,, – @!7%$ *:, – ,'4,G$#, ' &%+54<$*$% E/("(8!! #*8(#(:&*"%"!,. Q4*;(1*&, #(()F%"!G (@6$ 8"(;!: !"1!'!1558(', !2.-, /($(&6. /(;1*-"!)51< 1(4?%" )64 )6$< @%&%?!$ ' 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!, "*/(@4,%$#, 5 !5"!#! !"1!'!1558*. B($&%)"(#$< ($1%4<"(;( 4!2* ('4*1%$< '#%G #588(G (@6$* # "*!8%"<7%. $&*$(. 58#$'%""6: #!4 #45?!$, "*&,15 # #(()F%"!%8, @()5?1%"!%8 / E/("(8!>%#/(85 5@(&,1(>%"!G. R( E$!8 ! !#>%&@6'*%$#, '#, +*;*1(>"*, 8(F< "*5/!» ($*8 ?%, #. 160). R*5>"6. !2.-, (#"('*""6. "* $'%&1( 5#$*"('4%""6:, @&('%&%""6: &%6-%D, @&%1#$*%$ 5 *:* ' /*>%#$'% '%&:('"(;( /&!$%&!, "*5>"(#$!, 1%.#$'%""(#$!, @(+"*'*$%4<"(. @&!%84%8(#$! !#@(4<+5%86: 2!"(-'=,
131
()(#"('*""(#$! ! ;&*"!2 !: @&!8%"%"!, ' $(. !4! !"(. %#$%#$'%""(. "*5/%. J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, «$(, >$( 86 "*+6'*%8 2$'0'"!= ! 17*51-9'*:, @&%1#$*'4,%$ #()(. ,&/( '61%4,GF!%#, @&!+"*/! (@6$*, !;&*GF!% '*?"5G &(4< ' '(@&(#% '(#@&(!+'%1%"!, A*/$(' ' "*7!: 86#4,:. R( ("! $%&,G$ E$( '*?"(% #'(% +"*>%"!%, 5#$5@*, %;( 1&5;!8 @&!+"*/*8, /*/ $(4"68» ($*8 ?%, #. 160–161). L$( $(, >$( ($"(#!$#, / ()F!8 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"68 @(",$!,8. N$( /*#*%$#, "*!)(4%% ()F!:, &'7!1!&16'D @(",$!., 5@($&%)4,%86: ! ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, $( /&!$%&!. (@6$*, 1*""(#$! ' (F5F%"!,:, ' >5'#$'%""6: '(#@&!,$!,:, /&!$%&!., ()%#@%>!'*GF!. «E/("(8!G 8674%"!,», @( 8"%"!G *:*, '6'(1!$ +* @&%1%46 &%*4<"(. 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! ()I%/$6, ()(+"*>*%86% E$!8! @(",$!,8!. J*/('6, "*@&!8%&, @(",$!, «1;<1-%"+'(», «9*?8 9 1*<*». 3)I,#",, E/("(8"( &%*4!+5%86. 8%:*"!+8 !: A5"/2!("!&('*"!, ' 8674%"!!, !: @(+"*'*$%4<"6. #$*$5#, #$%@%"< !: 1(#$('%&"(#$!, *: @!#*4: «M(;1* 86 '61%4,%8 ' 86#4,: /*/(%-4!)( $%4( !+ %;( @(#$(,""( 8%",GF%.#, #&%16, $( 86, #()#$'%""( ;('(&,, '61%4,%8 $(4"(. ($ #'(!: @&!+"*/(' #5)#$*"2!!, "%/($(&(. «'%F! ' #%)%», #!8'(4*8! #'(.#$' /($(&(. ,'4,G$#, "*7! (F5F%"!,. B&*'!4<"( ?% #/*+*$<, "*()(&($, >$( $%4* !4! '%F! #5$< #(/&*F%""6% 86#4%""6% #!8'(46 14, ;&5@@ (F5F%"!., #!8'(46, /($(&6%, '"% "*7%;( 8674%"!, "% #5F%#$'5G$» ($*8 ?%, #. 161–162). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, ' A!4(#(A#/(8 ()4!>!! "%!+)%?"68 #4%1#$'!%8 @(#4%1('*$%4<"(. &%*4!+*2!! *:(8 @(+"*'*$%4<"(;( @&!"2!@* «E/("(8!! 8674%"!,» ,'!4#, ' 1*""(8 #45>*% #5)I%/$!'"6. !1%*4!+8 )%&/4!*"#/(;( $(4/*. L$* @&!"2!@!*4<"*, 8!&('(++&%">%#/*, @(+!2!, ' A!4(#(A!! ()5#4('!4* ' /("%>"(8 #>%$% ! #(($'%$#$'5GF!. 8!&('(++&%">%#/!. "*#$&(. *:* ! ' #A%&% %#$%#$'(+"*"!,. J*/, ' E$(. #A%&% «'%+1% @&(/&*16'*%$#, "%+*8%$"( ' "*5/5 ;&5)(% @(",$!% #5)#$*"2!!, "( '#%;1* ("( (/*+6'*%$#, "%1(#$*$(>"68 ! @(#$(,""( @&!:(1!$#, (;&*"!>!'*$< ()4*#$< %;( @&!8%"%"!, '#% 8%"<7!8! ! 8%"<7!8! >*#$,8! 8!&*» ($*8 ?%, #. 164). J*/ ?% ()#$(!$ 1%4( ! ' ($"(7%"!! /("/&%$"(. #$&5/$5&"(. (&;*"!+*2!! "*4!>"(;( )6$!, #5)#$*"2!! (8*$%&!!), $( %#$< ' ($"(7%"!! *$(8(' ! 8(4%/54: «W#$%#$'(+"*"!G "% @(1()*%$ '!1%$< ' #(+1*""6: !8 #*8!8 !+8%">!'6: E/("(8!>%#/!: #&%1#$'*:, ' 8(4%/54*: ! *$(8*:, $*%78"!1-' @(+*1! ,'4%"!., "% @(1()*%$ %85, +*)6'*, ( "%1*'"( 5#'(%""(. 851&(. (#8($&!$%4<"(#$! )(4%% ($'*?"(. #%#$&6 %;(, A!4(#(A!!, #(+1*'*$< :*D%"'0*16;4 :'&!7!#'4 "* 8%#$( *"!8!#$!>%#/(. !4! 8%$*A!+!>%#/(. ! $%8 #(+1*'*$< 8"!86% @&()4%86» ($*8 ?%, #. 166). B(45>*%$#, $*/, >$( ' 1*""(8 #45>*% *:, ' 5;(15 #'(%. @(+!$!'!#$#/(. ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/(. /("2%@2!! («E/("(8!! 8674%"!,»), @&%"%)&%; @(+!$!'"68! "*5>"68! 1*""68!; '(@&%/! (>%'!1"68 &%+54<$*$*8 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, 5)%1!$%4<"68 1(#$!?%"!,8
132
A!+!/! ! :!8!! ' !+5>%"!! *$(8"(-8(4%/54,&"(;( #$&(%"!, 8*$%&!! (" ($'%&; ()I%/$!'"5G – A!+!>%#/5G ! :!8!>%#/5G – &%*4<"(#$< *$(8(' ! 8(4%/54, @&%1#$*'!' $% ! 1&5;!% 4!7< ' /*>%#$'% #5)I%/$!'"( 5#$*"('4%""6: #&%1#$' E/("(8"( @(+"*GF%;( 8674%"!,, '&%8%""6: "*5>"6: 5#4('"(#$%., @&!;(1"6: $(4"6% !;&57/! ! #$*&*%$#, !+5>!$< ;&*"!26 A(&86 $(;( &5#4*, @( /($(&(85 "%#%$#, ?!'(. @($(/ ,'4%"!.. P*8(% E/("(8"(% ! @&(#$(% '6&*?%"!% A*/$(' >%&%+ @(",$!, – '($ ' >%8 ("( @&!+"*%$ #'(G 2%4<» ($*8 ?%). H /*/ '%15F*,, (@&%1%4,GF*, $%"1%"2!, ' $%,9'-'', ' @(E$*@"(8 &*+'%&$6'*"!! @(+!$!'"(;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( +"*"!, ' &*8/*: @(#4%1('*$%4<"(. &%*4!+*2!! @&!"2!@* «E/("(8!! 8674%"!,» @&%1#$*%$ 5 *:* @&(2%##, ' /($(&(8, «' '!15 #8%"6 "*5>"6: !##4%1('*$%4%. >%4('%>%#/*,, #(2!*4<"( #(:&*",GF*,#, /*&$!"* 8!&* #$*"('!$#, +*8%$"( "%+*'!#!8%% ($ !"1!'!15*4<"(#$! 5>%"(;(, '#% )(4%% ! )(4%% @&!)4!?*,#< / >!#$(85 '6&*?%"!G A*/$('» (252, #. 132). H @($(85, #>!$*4 *:, ' @&(2%##% (>!F%"!, A*/$(', !#:(1, «!+ C6!"!:'0*16!= +*1*>! "*5/!, #(;4*#"( /($(&(. 14, "*# '*?"* -!786! #',+< "*)4G1%""(;(, 1*""(;( "*8.., '#% ;!@($%$!>%#/(%, 8%$*A!+!>%#/(%, @&*+1"(% 1(4?"( )6$< !+;"*"( !+ "*5/!» (246, #. 43). J*/('* /("%>"*, #51<)* 8%$*A!+!/! – )6$< !+;"*""(. !+ "*5/! +* "%"*1()"(#$2C=F=5=CB 3$"(7%"!% *:* / A!4(#(A!!, @("!8*"!% ! (2%"/* !8 %% 8%#$* ! &(4! ' @(+"*"!!, %% 8!&('(++&%">%#/(. #5$!, +"*>!8(#$! 14, %#$%#$'(+"*"!, – '#% E$( ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% )64( ()5#4('4%"( $%8 /("/&%$"68 A!4(#(A#/!8 8*$%&!*4(8, /($(&68 (" '4*1%4, ' /($(&(8 $*/ !4! !"*>% (&!%"$!&('*4#,, $( %#$< )64( ' /("%>"(8 #>%$% ()5#4('4%"( /*>%#$'(8 %;( A!4(#(A#/(;( ()&*+('*"!,. B&!()F%"!% *:* / A!4(#(A!! "*>*4(#< # !+5>%"!, &*)($6 M*"$* «B&(4%;(8%"6 /( '#,/(. )515F%. 8%$*A!+!/%, 8(;5F%. @(,'!$<#, /*/ "*5/*». «N$%"!% E$(;( @&(!+'%1%"!,, – @!#*4 *:, – 1*4( $(4>(/ 8(%85 /&!$!>%#/(85 8674%"!G» (251, #. 63). J(4>(/ (/*+*4#, "*#$(45'#$'!$%4<"68, >$( /&!$!>%#/(% 8674%"!% @&!'%4( 8(4(1(;( *:* / ($/*+5 ($ %;( @%&'("*>*4<"(;( «"*!'"(;( &%*4!+8*», $( %#$< ($ @&!#5F%;( )(4<7!"#$'5 4G1%., "% !#/57%""6: ' A!4(#(A#/!: $("/(#$,:, #$!:!."(8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(;( '(++&%"!, "* 8!&. «WF% ' 1853 ;(15, ' &*""%. 8(%. G"(#$!, – '#@(8!"*4 '@(#4%1#$'!! *:, – 8(% "*!'"(–&%*4!#$!>%#/(% 8!&('(++&%"!% )64( #!4<"( &*#7*$*"( «B&(4%;(8%"*8!» M*"$*» (252, #. 137).
133
R( 5'4%>%"!% /*"$!*"#$'(8 )64( "%1(4;!8. M&!$!>%#/(% 8674%"!% *:*, @&()51!'7%%#, )4*;(1*&, M*"$5, "% ()(74( ! #*8(;( /%"!;#)%&;#/(;( A!4(#(A*, %;( «'%F! ' #%)%» ! ' &%+54<$*$% %F% 1*4<7% 5'%4( *:* ($ 8*$%&!*4!+8* / #5)I%/$!'"(85 !1%*4!+85. «M(;1* , ;(1 !4! 1'* #@5#$, !"#$!"/$!'"( @(+"*4, >$( «'%F< ' #%)%» %#$< @&*+1"*, !44G+!,, , '%&"54#, / #/&6$( #(:&*"!'7%.#, 5 M*"$* $(>/% +&%"!, Q%&/4!». R( :*&*/$%&"(, >$( ! $(;1* *: ($>%$4!'( (#(+"*'*4 "%#('8%#$!8(#$< ($/&('%""( !1%*4!#$!>%#/!: 5#$*"('(/ # #*8(. @&!&(1(. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, @("!8*4, >$( %;( «!1%*4!#$!>%#/(% "*#$&(%"!% @4(:( ;*&8("!&('*4( # !##4%1('*"!,8! A!+!>%#/!8!» ($*8 ?%). B(!#/! )(4%% ;*&8("!>"(;( #(>%$*"!, ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/!: '(++&%"!. # %#$%#$'%""("*5>"68! !##4%1('*"!,8! *: @&%1@&!"!8*4 ! ' 1&5;!: "*@&*'4%"!,:, +* @&%1%4*8! !1%*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!!, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' ()4*#$! @#!:(4(;!!. R( ! +1%#< (" "% 1(#$!; ?%4*""(. ;*&8("!!, "% ()&%4 "%():(1!8(. ,#"(#$!, "*()(&($, %F% )(4<7% 5$'%&1!4#, ' #'(!: #(8"%"!,:. «O#!4!'*4( %F% 8(! 85/! +"*/(8#$'( # 8*$%8*$!>%#/(. @#!:(4(;!%. =%&)*&$* ! @#!:(A!+!/(. 0%:"%&*, #(1%&?*'7!8! @&!%84%8(% ! "%@&!%84%8(% ' #*8(. $%#"(. #',+!» ($*8 ?%). N$( /*#*%$#, "%@(#&%1#$'%""(. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$!, !##4%1('*"!. ' ()4*#$! A!+!/!, $( ! +1%#< !F5F*, 86#4< *:*, '6:(1, +* @&%1%46 #5;5)( A!+!>%#/(. @&()4%8*$!/!, "*$*4/!'*4*#< "* (@&%1%4%""6% ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/!% *#@%/$6. 3", ' >*#$"(#$!, 5#$*"('!4 '(+8(?"(#$< $(;(, /*/, «!#:(1, !+ (@6$* A!+!>%#/(;( 8!&*, 8(?"( 1()&*$<#, 1( @#!:(4(;!! ! @&!$(8 @&%?1% '#%;( 1( )4!?*.7%;( ($1%4* %%, 1( 5>%"!, ( >5'#$'%""(8 '(#@&!,$!!» (255, #. 74). R*/("%2, !##4%1('*"!, ' ()4*#$! A!+!(4(;!! (&;*"(' >5'#$' ' #(>%$*"!! # A!4(#(A#/!8! !#/*"!,8! '6+'*4! @()5?1%"!, / )(4%% (#"('*$%4<"(85, )(4%% 5;45)4%""(85 @("!8*"!G @&!&(16 (F5F%"!., @("!8*"!G, '6:(1,F%85 +* @&%1%46 #@%2!*4<"6: %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: A(&8 (#'(%"!, ()I%/$* !##4%1('*"!,, >$( $*/?% ' )(4<7(. 8%&% #@(#()#$'('*4( A(&8!&('*"!G 8!&('(++&%"!, *:*. 3" ! #*8 E$( @("!8*4, ! ' >*#$"(#$!, !8%, ' '!15 #A%&5 A!+!(4(;!! (&;*"(' >5'#$', @!#*4: «V1%#<, ;1% , 8(; "*)4G1*$< #'(! (F5F%"!,, "( '8%#$% # $%8 ! 5#4('!, !: ' (/&5?*GF%. #&%1%, , 1(7%4, 8"% /*?%$#,, 1( %#$%#$'%""(;( 8!&('(++&%"!,, #'()(1"(;( ($ #@%/54,$!'"( 8%$*A!+!>%#/!: @&!8%#%.. 9"$!@*$!, / 8%$*A!+!/%, '"57%""*, 8"% M*"$(8, '8%#$% # *"*4!+*8! =%&)*&$* ! 0%:"%&*, @&!'%4! 8%", / $(>/% +&%"!,, )4!+/(. $(>/% +&%"!, S8*» (252, #. 137–138). 9"$!@*$!, /( '#,/(. 8%$*A!+!/%, /*/ #4%1#$'!% #45>*."(;( ! )%##!#$%8"(;( >$%"!, A!4(#(A#/(. 4!$%&*$5&6, "%51('4%$'(&%""(#$< !+'%#$"68! %85 A!4(#(A#/!8! &%7%"!,8! @&()4%8 @(+"*"!, – # (1"(. #$(&("6, ! # 1&5;(. – &*+'%&$6'*"!% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, %;( 5#@%:!, %;( 1(#$!?%"!,, *"*4!+ E$(;( @(+"*"!, # @(+!2!. %;( "%@(#&%1#$'%""(;( 5>*#$"!/* – '#% E$( @&!'%4( *:* / 5)%?1%"!G, >$( ' &*8/*: #*8(;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, ! %;( #&%1#$'*8! ' )(4<7(.
134
8%&% 8(;5$ )6$< &%7%"6 /(&%""6% @&()4%86 @(+"*"!,, 8(?%$ )6$< ()I,#"%"* %;( @&!&(1*, $( %#$<, !"*>% ;('(&,, @&!'%4( / @(+!$!'!+85. «Q4%#$,F!. @&(;&%## )!(4(;!>%#/!: "*5/ ! &*+'!$!% $%(&!! E'(4G2!!… @&!'%4! 8%", / 86#4! &*##8*$&!'*$< '#G @#!:!>%#/5G ?!+"< ' 2%4(8 !, ' >*#$"(#$!, "*5>"5G &*)($5, /*/ '!1 (&;*"!>%#/(. ?!+"!. N!#$( E/("(8!>%#/*, 2%""(#$<, /($(&5G , @&!@!#6'*G $%(&!,8, ! ' $( ?% '&%8, @(+!2!,, +*",$*, 8"(G @( ($"(7%"!G / 8%$*A!+!/%, "*:(1,$ #'(% ;45)(/(% (@&*'1*"!% ' )!(4(;!>%#/!: $&%)('*"!,:. 3:'*$!$< "* @(>'% $(>"6: !+6#/*"!., # '(+8(?"( )(4<7%. E/("(8!%. 86#4!, '+*!8"5G +*'!#!8(#$< '"%7"%;( ! '"5$&%""%;( (@6$* >%4('%/* – $*/!8 #$*4 $(;1* !1%*4 "*5/!, '+,$(. ' 2%4(8. L$($ !1%*4, )%+ #(8"%"!,, (>%"< )4!+(/ / !1%*45 M("$*, :($, E$($ A!4(#(A ! @&!1*'*4 ($"(#!$%4<"( 8*4(% +"*>%"!% @#!:(4(;!>%#/!8 !##4%1('*"!,8» (251, #. 64–65). V*8%$!8 @(@5$"(, >$( #*8 *:, ' ($4!>!% ($ M("$*, "*@&($!', @&!1*'*4 @#!:(4(;!>%#/!8 !##4%1('*"!,8 (#()%""( )(4<7(% +"*>%"!% – ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, +"*>!8(#$< /($(&(;( )51%$ &*#/&6$* @(+1"%%. H %F%: *"$!@*$!, *:* / :*-%&','6* ($"G1< "% (+"*>*4* %;( ($/*+* ($ &'7!1!&16!#! *"*4!+* @&(2%##* @(+"*"!,, "% (+"*>*4*, (@,$< ?% ' ($4!>!% ($ M("$*, !#/4G>%"!, A!4(#(A!! !+ ()F%. #!#$%86 >%4('%>%#/(;( @(+"*"!,. R*@&($!', A!4(#(A!G, A!4(#(A#/!. #@(#() @(+"*"!, 8!&* *: @&!+"*'*4 (1"!8 !+ "%():(1!86: ! "*!)(4%% '*?"6:, "*&,15 # %#$%#$'%""("*5>"68, !8%""( – ' #A%&% 8674%"!,. «F%;0"!* 8674%"!%, – @!#*4 (", – '#$&%>*%$#, ' 1'5:, 1 9'5; 1('(4<"( &*+4!>"6:, $!@*:: ' '!1% 8674%"!, A!4(#(A* ! 8674%"!, #@%2!*4!#$*–!##4%1('*$%4,» (/5&#!' 8(.. – C.3.). V*8%$!8, >$( *: +1%#< (@&%1%4%""( '/4G>*%$ 8674%"!% A!4(#(A* ' ()4*#$< "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, ! #>!$*%$ %;( ($4!>!% ($ 8674%"!, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4, >!#$( '"%7"!8. -*+4!>!% ()(!: '!1(' 8674%"!, – E$( &*+4!>!% "% !#/4G>%"!,, * 1(@(4"%"!,: «B%&'6. #$&%8!$#, / '(+8(?"( @(4"(., '#%()I%84GF%. (&!%"$!&('/% '( '#%. #('(/5@"(#$! A*/$('. B&! E$(8 (" "% 8(?%$ '(+'%#$! 1( /("2* #'(%;( +1*"!,, "% @(+*!8#$'('*' 14, E$(;( 8*$%&!*4 5 #@%2!*4!#$('. C$(&(. #@%2!*4<"( +*",$ (&!%"$!&('/(. ! ()()F%"!%8 ' (1"(. /*/(.-"!)51< "%)(4<7(. ()4*#$! A*/$('» (254, #. 11). 3#5F%#$'4%"!% A!4(#(A#/(;( ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, @(&(+"<, ' ($&6'% (1"(;( ($ 1&5;(;( 8(?%$ @&!'%#$! / +*$&51"%"!,8, (7!)(>"68 '6'(1*8 ! $.@. J*/ ! @&(!#:(1!4(, @( 8"%"!G *:*, ' @&(74(8. 3" @&(#4%?!'*%$ &*+'!$!% '+*!8(($"(7%"!, A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, "*>!"*, # !: !#$(/(', # 1&%'"(#$!. «0!4(#(A!, ! "*5/* #(#$*'4,G$ ' $( '&%8, !5"! +*7!*». B&(;&%## ' @(+"*"!! @&!'%4 / $(85, >$( ' 1*4<"%.7%8 «"*>!"*%$#, 1%4%"!% ! &*+'%$'4%"!% "*5/!», A!4(#(A!, ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!% ($1%4,G$#, 1&5; ($ 1&5;*. R( ! ' E$(8 #45>*% "% 5$&*>!'*%$#, "%():(1!8(#$< ' A!4(#(A#/!: #&%1#$'*: @(+"*"!, 8!&*. 3"*, E$* "%():(1!8(#$<, (@&%1%4,%$#, $%8, >$( «@($&%)"(#$< >%4('%/* ' ()F%8 '+;4,1% "* 8!& (#$*%$#,. C 5;(15 E$(. @($&%)"(#$! A!4(#(A!, ($1%4,%$#, ($ #@%2!*4<"(;( !##4%1('*"!,». H"(;1*, @&*'1*, /*/
135
"*@(8!"*"!% ( )64(. $%#"(. #',+! A!4(#(A#/(;( ! #@%2!*4<"(;( @5$%. !##4%1('*"!,, ()"*&5?!'*%$#, !: #('8%F%"!% ' "*5>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! /*/(;(-4!)( '61*GF%;(#, 5>%"(;(, "*@&!8%&, K%/*&$* !4! D%.)"!2*. «C ()F%8, (1"*/(, @5$! A!4(#(A!! ! #@%2!*4<"6: +"*"!. &*#:(1,$#, '#% 1*4<7% ! 1*4<7%» (255, #. 201). *: #>!$*4 @&($!'(%#$%#$'%""68 ! @*;5)"68 /*/ 14, A!4(#(A!!, $*/ ! 14, #@%2!*4<"6: ($&*#4%. @(+"*"!, E$( !: &*#$5F%% '+*!8"(% ($>5?1%"!%. «H %#4! @(&(. @%&'*, "*#$(45?1*%$#, ($ '$(&(., >$( ("* "*1%%$#, @(#$&(!$< 8!& !+ (@6$* 1%$#/(., $( #@%2!*4<"6. !##4%1('*$%4< '@*1*%$ ' @&($!'(@(4(?"5G /&*."(#$<, '(()&*?*,, >$( 14, &*+&%7%"!, 8!&('(. +*;*1/! 1(#$*$(>"( &*#@5$*$< $($ %1!"#$'%""6. 5+%4, @&%1 /($(&68 (" #$(!$ "%@(#&%1#$'%""( ! /($(&6. ' #!45 @%&#@%/$!'6 @&%1#$*'4,%$#, %85 ' #!4<"( @&%5'%4!>%""(8 '!1%. C#,/!. 1*4<"%.7!. ()+(& (" #>!$*%$ "%'(+8(?"68 ! 1*?% !+4!7"!8» ($*8 ?%, #. 201–202). H+I,"6 5+/(. #@%2!*4!+*2!!, #',+*""6% # ($/*+(8 %% @&!'%&?%"2%' ($ '#,/(;( !#@(4<+('*"!, A!4(#(A#/!: #&%1#$' @(+"*"!,, @(18%>%"6 *:(8 1(#$*$(>"( '%&"(, ! %;( /&!$!>%#/!. "*#$&(. @( ($"(7%"!G / "%. "% '6+6'*%$ #(8"%"!. –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«C #)4!?%"!! @5$%. &*+4!>"6: A!4(#(A#/!: 86#4!$%4%., "( ' (#()%""(#$! ' )4!+/(8 #(@&!/(#"('%"!! ()F%A!4(#(A#/!: ! @(+!$!'"(–"*5>"6: #(()&*?%"!. , '!?5 )4*;(@&!,$"(% @&%1+"*8%"('*"!% 14, '+*!8"(;( #)4!?%"!, &*+4!>"6: "*5/» (246, #. 65). J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, &*+'!$!%, #('%&7%"#$'('*"!% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, @( 8"%"!G *:*, "%!+)%?"( ''(1!$ %;( ' #A%&5 A!4(#(A#/(. @&()4%8*$!/! ! A!4(#(A#/(;( ?% #@(#()* &%7%"!, @&()4%8: «=&*"!26, /($(&6% #$*'!$ #%)% #@%2!*4!#$–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» (254, #. 11).
136
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«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» (255, #. 202). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, *: /("#$*$!&5%$ +1%#< (@%&%?%"!% A!4(#(A!%. %#$%#$'(+"*"!, "% $(4*#$! +*)45?1%"!., (7!)(/. W#$%#$'(+"*"!%, ($1%4!'7!#< ($ A!4(#(A!!, &*+'!'*,#< ' #'(%8 #()#$'%""(8 &5#4%, '6)!'*,#< @&! E$(8 !+ 84*1%">%#/(;( #(#$(,"!, 86#4!$%4<"(#$!, '( 8"(;!: #45>*,: @('$(&,%$ @5$<, @&(.1%""6. &*"%% A!4(#(A#/!8 @(+"*"!%8. J*/(% 15)4!&('*"!% %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8 &%+54<$*$(' A!4(#(A#/(;( @(+"*"!, – /*/ @(+!$!'"6:, $*/ ! "%;*$!'"6: – ($"G1< "% #'!1%$%4<#$'5%$ () «E/("(8!! 8674%"!,», #/(&%% "*()(&($: @&!'(1!$ 4!7< / $&*$% '@5#$5G !"$%44%/$5*4<"(. E"%&;!!. H @&(!#:(1!$ E$( @($(85, >$( 8%?15 %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8 ! A!4(#(A!%. ($#5$#$'5G$ '+*!8(#',+< ! '+*!8(1%.#$'!%, '+*!8(@%&%4!'6 @(+!$!'"(;( +"*"!,, @%&%@4%$%"!% @5$%. ! #&%1#$' %;( @(45>%"!,. R( '(+8(?"6 – ! @&*/$!/* @(+"*"!, E$( @(1$'%&?1*%$ – $*/!% #(#$(,"!, ' #(($"(7%"!! A!4(#(A#/(;( ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, /(;1* 1(#$!;*%$#, !: %1!"%"!% ' "*5>"(8 $'(&>%#$'% (1"(;( ! $(;( ?% A!4(#(A*
137
!4! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,. J%8 #*868 *: @&!+"*'*4 #@(#()"(#$< A!4(#(A(' &%7*$< #@%2!*4<"6% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6% @&()4%86, (/*+6'*$< E$!8 #$!854!&5GF%% '(+1%.#$'!% "* &*+'!$!% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. C%#<8* /&*#"(&%>!'( ' E$(8 ($"(7%"!! #5?1%"!% *:* ( K%/*&$%, +*#45;* /($(&(;(, @( %;( 8"%"!G, #(#$(,4* ! ' $(8, >$( (" «2*$9.= 1-%7 '16%-8 /5 +&%"!, ' 8%:*"!/%. O? $*/('( #'(%()&*+"(% 1%.#$'!% &'7!1!&%, '4!,GF%% '#%;1* @4(1($'(&"68 ! '(+)5?1*GF!8 ()&*+(8 "* %#$%#$'(+"*"!%» (248, c. 251). C &*'"(. 8%&% *: @&!+"*'*4 ! '4!,"!% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: !##4%1('*"!. "* &*+'!$!% A!4(#(A#/(;( 8674%"!,, )(4<7% $(;( – #@(#()"(#$< %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '"(#!$< #5F%#$'%""6. '/4*1 ' A!4(#(A#/5G &*+&*)($/5 $%: !4! !"6: @&()4%8 ()F%;(, #5F"(#$"(;( :*&*/$%&*, $( %#$< A!4(#(A#/(. @&()4%8*$!/!. J*/!8 ()&*+(8, «/("%>"*, 2%4< '#,/(;( !##4%1('*"!, (/*+6'*%$#, (1"(. ! $(. ?%. L$( '!1"( !+ $(;(, >$( ! '%4!>*.7!% A!4(#(A6, /*/ B4*$(", 9&!#$($%4<, K%/*&$, D%.)"!2 ! 1&., ($/&64! $*/?% "('6% @5$! ' ()4*#$! #@%2!*4<"6: "*5/, * # 1&5;(. #$(&("6 $*/!% #@%2!*4!#$6–!##4%1('*$%4!, /*/ =*4!4%., R!8(#$< A!4(#(A!! 14, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. *: ($"G1< "% (;&*"!>!'*4 4!7< #A%&(. "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, "( &*#@&(#$&*",4 %% ! "* '#G ()4*#$< !: 8!&('(++&%"!,, !: ?!+"%""(. (&!%"$*2!!. C #',+! # E$!8 *: )(4<7(% +"*>%"!% @&!1*'*4 A!4(#(A#/(85 ()&*+('*"!G 5>%"6: /*/ A*/$(&5, @!$*GF%85 ' "!: #@(#()"(#$< @&($!'(#$(,$< &*+4!>"68 *"$!"*5>"68 5/4("%"!,8, !+'&*F%"!,8 ' ()F%#$'%""(. ?!+"!, «!"$%44%/$5*4<"68 @('&%?1%"!,8», /*/ (" !: "*+6'*4. J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, (" ($8%>*4, >$( «%#4! 8(?"( '#$&%$!$< !+'%#$"(;( #'(!8! ($/&6$!,8! :!8!/* !4! +"*8%"!$(;( A!+!/*, ($1*GF!:#, #@!&!$!+85.., $(, +"*>!$, !"$%44%/$5*4<"(% @('&%?1%"!% (>%"< ;45)(/( ! "% (;&*"!>!'*%$#, @5)4!/(., #$(,F%. ' #$(&("% ($ "*5/!. B&!>!"(. $*/(;( @('&%?1%"!, ' )(4<7!"#$'% #45>*%' ,'4,%$#, #4!7/(8 (1"(#$(&("",, 58#$'%""*, /54<$5&* ! "%1(#$*$(/ A!4(#(A#/(;( ()&*+('*"!,» (249, #. 8). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, 5 *:* "*4!2( #5F%#$'%""(% &*+4!>%"!% 8%$*A!+!/! ! A!4(#(A!!: ($&!2*"!% @%&'(., "%@&!,+"< / "%. ! @&!+"*"!% "%#(8"%""6: 1(#$(!"#$' '$(&(.. « %$*A!+!/*», @( *:5, "% '#,/*, A!4(#(A!,, /*/ 8(?"( )64( )6 @(158*$<, * $(4%#$'% ("*, /("%>"(, "%@&!%84%8* 14, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,. 0!4(#(A!, ?% ' %% !#$(&!>%#/(8, "*5>"(8 /("$%/#$%, /*/ ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!%, – #*8(#$(,$%4<"*, ()4*#$< @(+"*"!, ! A(&8* 8674%"!,. B(#/(4*%$ +"*"!,, @( #'(%85 "*5>"(85 /*>%#$'5 *"*4(;!>"6% $%8, /($(&6% A(&8!&5G$#, ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, ! !+ %#$%#$'(+"*"!, "%>$( @(+!$!'"(% '4!'*%$#, ' "%%, $( ! ("* #*8* @&%1#$*%$ /*/ "*5/*, !8%GF*, $5 ?%
138
/("%>"5G 2%4<, >$( ! %#$%#$'%""6%, * $*/?% «!#$(&!>%#/!%» (()F%#$'%""6%) "*5/! – @(+"*"!% 8!&*. M("%>"(, @&! $(8, >$( 5 A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, "*4!2( E$* #)4!?*GF*, !: /("%>"*, 2%4<, 8%?15 "!8!, @( 8"%"!G *:*, %#$< ! #5F%#$'%""(% &*+4!>!% ' @5$,: %% 1(#$!?%"!,, ' @(1:(1*: / ()I%/$*8 !+5>%"!,, ' /("%>"6: &%+54<$*$*: @(+"*"!,: «$(, >$( A!4(#(A #>!$*%$ +* '(+8(?"(% "%0%7!, 546)*%$#, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4G 4!7< /*/ ($1*4%""6. /("%2 %;( &*)($6. R( E$( &*+4!>!% '( 8"%"!,: "% 1(4?"( 8%7*$< !##4%1('*$%4,8 – 1* ! 1%.#$'!$%4<"( "% 8%7*%$ – 5>!$<#, 1&5; 5 1&5;*». B&*'1*, ()4*#$<, ' /($(&(. 8(;5$ 5>!$<#, ! "*5>*G$#, 1&5; 5 1&5;* A!4(#(A6 ! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4!, *: #5?*4, "( @(/*+*$%4<"( ! $(, >$( (" '/4G>*4 ' E$5 ()4*#$<: «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– #'(G 1(8*7"GG A!4(#(A!G» (254, #. 12). J( ! 1&5;(%, )%+5#4('"(, "%():(1!8(, '(@&(# 5@!&*%$#, 4!7< ' !: /*>%#$'(, * $5$, @( 8"%"!G *:*, 1*4%/( "% '#% )4*;(@(45>"(: ' #'(%8 &%*4<"(8 #(#$(,"!! ! «1(8*7"%% %#$%#$'(+"*"!%» A!4(#(A(', ! «1(8*7",, A!4(#(A!,» %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. @( )(4<7%. >*#$! "% #(($'%$#$'5G$ 1(#$!;"5$(85 ' 1*""(% '&%8, 5&('"G &*+'!$!, %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ' @%&'(8 #45>*% ! A!4(#(A!! – '( '$(&(8, ($#$*G$ ($ E$(;( 5&('",, ,'4,G$#, 5#$*&%'7!8!. B&(!#$%/*%$ E$( !+ ($#5$#$'!, "%@(#&%1#$'%""(. !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. @&*/$!/! ' #(($'%$#$'5GF!: ()4*#$,:: A!4(#(A(' – ' ()4*#$! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. – ' ()4*#$! A!4(#(A!!. «J(4*#$!% ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(. &*)($%, ! $(4%"!, 8(?"( '#$&%$!$< %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,, @(#',F*GF%;( #()#$'%""5G #'(G &*)($5 58* '(@&(#*8 A!4(#(A#/!8. 9 8%?15 $%8 $( ! 1&5;(% )%+5#4('"( "%():(1!8( 14, 1(#$!?%"!, #(;4*#!, 8%?15 $%8! ! 1&5;!8!, !)( (1"( >$%"!% "! $%8, "! 1&5;!8 @(8(>< "% 8(?%$» ($*8 ?%, #. 12–13). P*8 *: @(#$*&*4#, '"%#$! #'(G 4%@$5 ' 1(#$!?%"!% $*/(;( #(;4*#!,, /(;1*, )515>! 5>%"68-%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%8, ()&*$!4#, / #@%2!*4<"(85 &*##8($&%"!G A!4(#(A#/!: @( #'(%85 :*&*/$%&5 @&()4%8, @()5?1*%86. / E$(85 !##4%15%868 !8 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"68 8*$%&!*4(8. 3$#G1* %F%,
139
/("%>"(, "% #4%15%$, >$( 5?% (1"!8 E$!8 (" !+)%?*4 ($#$*4(#$!, 5#$*&%4(#$! #'(%. «1(8*7"%. A!4(#(A!!», ! $(, ! 1&5;(% #(:&*"!4(#< ' "%., (#()%""( ' $(. %% >*#$!, /($(&*, #',+*"* # )%&/4!*"#$'(8. R( +1%#< #5F%#$'%""( @(/* $(4$( *:, '(@&%/! @(+!$!'!#$#/(. $&*1!2!! ' %% *"$!A!4(#(A#/(. "*@&*'4%""(#$!, @&!+"*'*4 '*?"5G &(4< A!4(#(A!!, @&!>%8 "% $(4"(85 @(+"*"!G. § 6. $2C=F=5=CB = B;FD8=;3=CB: 5D84== A=3242A25 C A!4(#(A#/(. 4!$%&*$5&% '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX – "*>*4% UU ''. 1('(4<"( &*#@&(#$&*"%""68 ,'4,%$#, (@&%1%4%""(% #)4!?%"!%, * @(1>*# ! @&(#$( ($(?1%#$'4%"!% @(+!$!'!+8* # 8*$%&!*4!+8(8. M*/ #'!1%$%4<#$'5%$ (1!" !+ /&!$!/(' 8*$%&!*4!+8*, &5##/!. A!4(#(A =.H. N%4@*"(', «(>%"< 8"(;!% ($(?1%#$'4,G$ :%-*$'%7',: # 2!,'-'9',:!:» (393, #. 25). 3#"('*"!%8 14, $*/(;( ($(?1%#$'4%"!, #45?!4*, /*/ @&*'!4(, (>%'!1"*, @&!>!""(–#4%1#$'%""*, #',+< $(;( ! 1&5;(;( # /(&%""68! @&%()&*+('*"!,8! ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!. L$* ()F*, %#$%#$'%""("*5>"*, (#"('* 8*$%&!*4!+8* ! @(+!$!'!+8* 1*'*4* @('(1 5#8*$&!'*$< @&!>!"5 !: '+*!8"(. )4!+(#$! ' #@%2!A!/% #*8(;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, $(;( '&%8%"!, ' (#()%""(#$,: #5)I%/$"(()I%/$"(;( ($"(7%"!, ' "%8. C $*/(8 ()I,#"!$%4<"(8 /("$%/#$% C. K!4<$%., "*@&!8%&, &*##8*$&!'*4 @(+!$!'!+8 /*/ "%!+)%?"(% #4%1#$'!% 8*$%&!*4!+8*. 3" @!#*4, ' >*#$"(#$!: «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» (148, #. 58–59). H+'%#$"6. @(4<#/!. %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4< ! A!4(#(A C. . M(+4('#/!., "*()(&($, "* $%: ?% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: (#"('*"!,: '6'(1!4 8*$%&!*4!+8 !+ @(+!$!'!+8*, 5$'%&?1*,, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( «#/4(""(#$< / 8*$%&!*4!+85, $( %#$< '(#@&!,$!% 1(;8*$!>%#/!: '6'(1(' !+ "*5/!, @&!+"*"!% +* "!8! +"*>%"!, "%(#@(&!86: !#$!", ,'4,%$#, $%8 )(4%% %#$%#$'%""68 #4%1#$'!%8 @(+!$!'!+8*, >$( $(4%#/!% "*5/! !4! "*5/!, @(4<+5GF!%#, A!+!>%#/!8 8%$(1(8, #>!$*G$#, !8 @(+!$!'"68! !4! &%*4<"68!» (175, #. 47). B&!8%"!$%4<"( / $*/(. &*+"('!1"(#$! @(+!$!'!+8*, /*/ E8@!&!(/&!$!2!+8, $*/?% ($8%>*4*#< %;( @&!>*#$"(#$< / 8*$%&!*4!+85 – '@4($< 1( @(4"(;( ($(?1%#$'4%"!, # @(#4%1"!8, "*@&!8%&, '( 8"%"!!
140
C. C5"1$*: «…B( #'(%85 @(14!""(85 :*&*/$%&5 E8@!&!(/&!$!2!+8 @&%1#$*'4,%$ #()(. A(&85 &*+'!$!, 8*$%&!*4!+8*» (72, #. 270). R( #*8! @(+!$!'!#$6–E8@&!(/&!$!/! 158*4! !"*>%, ("! "! ' /(%. 8%&% "% ($"(#!4! #%), / 8*$%&!*4!#$*8, "*()(&($, #>!$*4! #%), @&!"2!@!*4<"68! @&($!'"!/*8! 8*$%&!*4!+8*. J*/, (1!" !+ '!1"%.7!: E8@!&!(/&!$!/(' H. B%$2(4<1$ @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «X @&!1*G +"*>%"!% (@&%1%4%"!G @(",$!, 8*$%&!*4!+8* 4!7< @($(85, >$( "%/($(&6% ! @&!$(8 *'$(&!$%$"6% /&!$!/! "%(1"(/&*$"( ()(+"*>*4!… @(+!$!'"(% 8!&('(++&%"!% 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!8, 158*, $%8 #*868 %;( !#>%&@*$<. M("%>"(, (7!)/*, 1%4*%8*, 8*$%&!*4!+8(8, "* #*8(8 1%4% "!#/(4*# !+1%'*,#< ! "*#8%:*,#< "*1 "!8. WF% )(4%% "%#@&*'%14!'( @(1()"(% ($"(7%"!% / "*7%85 @(+!$!'!+85, !)( @(+!$!'!+8, ' /*>%#$'% @&($!'"!/* '#,/(. 8%$*A!+!/!, '#,/(. A!4(#(A!!, @(#&%1#$'%""( !4! "%@(#&%1#$'%""( )*+!&5GF%.#, "* @&%1#$*'4%"!! #5)#$*"2!!, ,'4,%$#, $*/?% ! @&($!'"!/(8 8*$%&!*4!+8*» (300, #. 97–98). 3$#G1* #4%15%$, >$( 8*$%&!*4!+8, * &*'"( ! !1%*4!+8, ''!15 "%!+)%?"(. 8%$*A!+!>"(#$! $(;( ! 1&5;(;(, )%+5#4('"(, ($'%&;*4!#< @(+!$!'!+8(8 (E8@!&!(/&!$!2!+8(8), *"$!8%$*A!+!>%#/!8 @( #*8(. #'(%. @&!&(1%. P()#$'%""*, A!4(#(A!, E8@!&!(/&!$!2!+8*, @( B%$2(4<1$5, – "! 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/*,, "! !1%*4!#$!>%#/*,, ("* – 5$;#%(, @(4(?!$%4<"*,, "*5>"*,. N$( /*#*%$#, 8"%"!, #*8!: (#"('(@(4(?"!/(' E8@!&!(/&!$!2!+8*, $( @(/*+*$%4<"* ' E$(8 ($"(7%"!! @&!"2!@!*4<"*, @(+!2!, L. *:*, @(/*+*$%4<"* "% $(4$( (" )64 – '"% &*8(/ #'(%;( @(+!$!'!#$#/(;( A!4(#(A#$'('*"!, – @&*/$!>%#/! 1%.#$'5GF!8, $%(&%$!>%#/! 86#4,F!8 5>%"68-%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%8. P"*>*4* ( $(8, /*/ *: 2!"':%7 8*$%&!*4!+8 ! !1%*4!+8, /*/(. #86#4 '/4*16'*4 ' E$! @(",$!,. R*1( +*8%$!$<, >$( @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$< 8*$%&!*4!+8* (" !"(;1* "*+6'*4 "% !1%*4!+8(8, *, #(;4*#"( $%&8!"(4(;!! $(;( '&%8%"!, #@!&!$5*4!+8(8. J*/, :*&*/$%&!+5, A!4(#(A#/!. 15*4!+8, *: ($8%>*4, >$( (" «8(?%$ @&%1#$*'!$< '#% '(+8(?"6% @%&%:(16 ($ >!#$(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* / >!#$(85 #@!&!$5*4!+85, ' +*'!#!8(#$! ($ (2%"/! +"*>%"!, A!+!>%#/(;( ! @#!:!>%#/(;(, ' +*'!#!8(#$! ($ $(;(, >$( !+ "!: #>!$*$< A5"1*8%"$*4<"68, (#"('"68 ! >$( – '$(&!>"68, '6'%1%""68 !+ (#"('"(;(» (254, #. 14). N$( ?% !+)!&*%$ #*8 *:? M*/5G A!4(#(A!G? 3>%'!1"(, >$( "% 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/5G. C( '#,/(8 #45>*%, 5#$*&%4(#$<, ($#$*4(#$< «1(8*7"%. A!4(#(A!!» 5>%"6: (" 5#8*$&!'*4 ' $(8, >$(, /*/ (" @!#*4, «)(4<7!"#$'( %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. @&!1%&?!'*%$#, %F% ! ' "*#$(,F%% '&%8,, ' /*>%#$'% A!4(#(A(', 8*$%&!*4!+8*, /($(&(85 150 4%$ ($ &(15 ! "%1(#$*$(>"(#$< /($(&(;( 1*'"( 5?% &*+;4,1%4! "% $(4
141
@&!+'*"!G, "( ! 4G1! )(4%% !4! 8%"%% +"*/(86% # A!4(#(A#/!8 8674%"!%8» ($*8 ?%, #. 12). *: +1%#< 1(#$*$(>"( (#$(&(?%" ' A(&854!&('/*:: (" @!7%$ "% ( "%#(#$(,$%4<"(#$! A!4(#(A#/(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8*, * 4!7< ( %;( "*5!1-%-!0"!1-' 14, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%.. P*8 @( #%)% 8*$%&!*4!+8, 8(?%$ )6$<, ' /*/(.-$( 8%&% ! @&!%84%8 (%F% )6! '%1< )(4<7!"#$'( %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. – 8*$%&!*4!#$6), "( (1"(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8*, $(4"(. J(;1* >$( ?% %F%? N$( /&(8% 8*$%&!*4!+8*? (?%$ )6$<, / "%85 #4%15%$ 1()*'!$< ! "%>$( !+ A!4(#(A#/(;( !1%*4!+8*? R( ' $*/(8 #45>*% "*1( @&!+"*$< %;( "*5>"5G #(#$(,$%4<"(#$<. H *: /*/(%-$( '&%8, #/4(",4#, / E$(85, (#()%""( @(1 '4!,"!%8 A!4(#(A!! Q%&/4!; "(, /*/ 5?% ($8%>*4(#<, #/(&( (#(+"*4 "%#('8%#$!8(#$< !1%*4!#$!>%#/!: 5#$*"('(/ # #*8(. @&!&(1(. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, (#(+"*4, >$( %;(, *:*, «!1%*4!#$!>%#/(% "*#$&(%"!% @4(:( ;*&8("!&('*4( # !##4%1('*"!,8! A!+!>%#/!8!» (252, #. 137). B(#/(4%#/!% !##4%1('*"!, *:*, /*/ '(()F% '#% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6% !##4%1('*"!, 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., (#5F%#$'4,4!#< "* #$!:!."(-8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. (#"('%, $(, @( #'!1%$%4<#$'5 #*8(;( *:*, '(+"!/ &%+/!. /("A4!/$ 8%?15 %;( "*!'"(&%*4!#$!>%#/!8 (>!$*. – 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!8) 8!&('(++&%"!%8 ! A!4(#(A#/!-8%$*A!+!>%#/!8!, !1%*4!#$!>%#/!8! '4!,"!,8!. M("A4!/$ E$($ &*+&%7!4#, ' @(4<+5 «"*!'"(;( &%*4!+8*»: «X #/(&( @(/(">!4 #( '#,/(. 8%$*A!+!/(., ! '(+'&*$!4#, / "*!'"(85 %#$%#$'%""(85 8!&('(++&%"!G» (253, #. 16). C 1*4<"%.7%8 #'(. )64(. !1%*4!+8 *: &*##8*$&!'*4 /*/ @&(.1%""6. E$*@. 3) E$(8 8(?"( #51!$< :($, )6 @( %;( ($"(7%"!G / $*/ "*+6'*%8(85 «@#!:(8("!+85», $( %#$< #(4!@#!+85. J*/, "%/($(&6% 5$(>"%"!, ' A(&854!&('/*: ' &*)($% «B(+"*"!% ! +*)45?1%"!%», * ' "%. A!4(#(A!, *:* )64*, @( %;( #4('*8, «!+4(?%"* ' "*!)(4%% +&%4(. A(&8%» (252, #. 127), 5$(>"%"!,, (#()%""( +*8%$"6% ' #&*'"%"!! # )(4%% &*""%. &*)($(. «9"*4!+ (F5F%"!.», *: ()I,#",4 $%8, >$( (" «#>!$*4#, # *"$!@*$!%. %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. /( '#%85, >$( "*+6'*%$#, @#!:(8("!+8(8» (254, #. 20). P*8 $%&8!" «@#!:(8("!+8», ($8%$!4 1*4%% *:, «/*?%$#, 8"% $%@%&<… 8%"%% @(1:(1,F!8, >%8 E$( )64( )6 ' )(4%% #$*&5G, !1%*4!#$!>%#/5G A*+5 8(%;( 8674%"!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 22). H1%*4!+8, * $%8 )(4%% $*/5G %;( /&*."GG A(&85, /*/ #(4!@#!+8 *: #>!$*4 "%#(#$(,$%4<"68 ! "%@&!%84%868 14, %#$%#$'(+"*"!,. P(4!@#!+8 58%#$%" ! @(",$%", @( 8"%"!G *:*, @&!8%"!$%4<"( / #@%/54,$!'"(. A!4(#(A!!. «R( /(;1* *1-*1-9!'12.-%-*78 ;('(&!$ 8"%, >$( #(4!@#!+8 %#$< %1!"#$'%""*, @(#4%1('*$%4<"*, $(>/* +&%"!,, $( E$( '(+)5?1*%$ '( 8"% 51!'4%"!%… J*/*, $(>/* +&%"!, )(4%% @&!4!>%#$'5%$ A*/!&5, A*"$*+!&5GF%85 ' #'(%8 #(+%&2*$%4<"(8 "*#$&(%"!!, >%8 #%&<%+"( 86#4,F%85 ! */$!'"(85 >%4('%/5» (246, #. 290). J*/, @( %;( 8"%"!G, @%&%(2%"/* ' $%(&!! @(+"*"!, $(;( ()#$(,$%4<#$'*, >$( ' ;*44G2!"*2!,: (F5F%"!, '(+"!/*G$ )%+ "%@(#&%1#$'%""(;( '(+1%.#$'!, #&%16 «4%;/(
142
8(?%$ @&!'%#$! / #*868 5?*#"68 !1%*4!#$!>%#/!8 !4! 1*?% #(4!@#!>%#/!8 #!#$%8*8» (252, #. 139). B(",$"(, >$( #'(! )(4%% @(+1"!% '(++&%"!, *: "% #>!$*4 !1%*4!#$!>%#/!8! ! /*$%;(&!>%#/! ($'%&;*4 '61'!;*%86% ' %;( *1&%# ()'!"%"!, ' !1%*4!+8% ! #(4!@#!+8%. C (1"(8 !+ @!#%8 (", ' >*#$"(#$!, ($8%>*4: «N$( ?% /*#*%$#, $(;(, >$( "%/($(&6% @&%1#$*'!$%4! #(2!*4!#$!>%#/(;( 5>%"!, ()'!",G$ 8%", ' #(4!@#!+8%, ' !1%*4!+8%, ' ($&!2*"!! '"%7"%;( 8!&* ! $.@., $( E$( $%8 8%"%% 8%", 51!'4,%$, >$( E$( #/4(""6 @&!@!#6'*$< 8"% ! #@%2!*4!#$6–A!4(#(A6. H '&%8, ($ '&%8%"! , @(45>*G &*+4!>"6% @!#<8*, /($(&6% '6"5?1*G$ 8%", +*F!F*$<#, ($ @(1()"6:, 8"% @&!@!#6'*%86:, '%F%.. C '6#(/(. #$%@%"! #$&*""(, >$( ' 8(!: @&(!+'%1%"!,:, '(@&%/! '#%8 ,#"68 @&%15@&%?1%"!,8, #/(&%% '6>!$6'*G$ &*+"6. 5?% ($#$*'4%""6. 5>%"6. '+1(&, '8%#$( $(;(, >$()6 @&!#8($&%$<#, / @&(#$68, "% '(+)5?1*GF!8 "%1(&*+58%"!, '6'(1*8» (253, #. 14-15). 3#()( '61%4!8 +1%#< 5$'%&?1%"!% *:* ( $(8, >$( ()'!"%"!, ' !1%*4!+8% #',+*"6 # 5?% (#$*'4%""68 !8 «5>%"68 '+1(&(8», $( %#$< "*1( @(4*;*$<, # !1%,8! ! $%&8!"(4(;!%. #5)I%/$!'"(–!1%*4!#$!>%#/(;( /*"$!*"#/(;( ! )%&/4!*"#/(;( – $(4/*. P4%1('*$%4<"(, #*8! @( #%)% E$! ()'!"%"!, "% )%#@(>'%""6, $(4%"< 1*4%/, )%+ #(8"%"!,, ($ @&*'!4<"(. (2%"/! 8(%;( '(++&%"!, $($, /$(, "%#8($&, "* "%(1"(/&*$"6% @&($%#$6 /*/ # 8(%. #$(&("6, $*/ ! #( #$(&("6 1&5;!:, ($(?1%#$'4,%$ %;( # '(++&%"!%8 Q%&/4!. B&*'1*, 8(% '(++&%"!% &*+'!4(#< !+ A*+6 !1%*4!#$!>%#/(., E$* A*+* (#$*'!4* %F% /(%-/*/!% #4%16 ' '6&*?%"!,:» (246, #. 293). C )(4%% @(+1"GG, )(4%% +&%45G #$*1!G #'(%. A!4(#(A#/(. E'(4G2!! *: "! ' /*/(. 8%&% 5?% "% #>!$*4 #%), !1%*4!#$(8. Q(4<7% $(;(, #'(% 8!&('(++&%"!%, &*'"( /*/ ! 8!&('(++&%"!% 9'%"*&!5#*, (" @(1>*# "% @&(>< )64 "*+'*$< ! 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!8. C «9"*4!+% (F5F%"!.» (" @!#*4, "*@&!8%&: «X #>!$*G (#()68 #>*#$<%8 14, #%), $($ A*/$, >$( 9'%"*&!5# &*+'!4 $( ?% #*8(% (>$( ! #*8 *:. – C.3.) '(++&%"!% "* ($"(7%"!% A!+!>%#/(;( / @#!:!>%#/(85 "* '@(4"% &%*4!#$!>%#/(. (8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(., 8(?"( #/*+*$<) (#"('%» ($*8 ?%). R%#45>*."( @(E$(85 C.H. D%"!", :*&*/$%&!+5, &*+'!$!% E8@!&!(/&!$!2!+8*, ($8%$!4 ! $%"1%"2!G %;( '#% )(4<7%;( @&!)4!?%"!, / 8*$%&!*4!+85: «R*#/(4*4<"6. !1%*4!+8 *xa ! 9'%"*&!5#*, "*#$(4$( '@(#4%1#$'!! E8@!&!(/&!$!2!+8 #$*&*4#, @('%&"5$< ' #$(&("5 8*$%&!*4!+8*» (204, #. 55). C &*#/&6$!! A!4(#(A#/(. @(+!2!! *:* 1(#$*$(>"( 8"(;( @&(,#",%$ $*/?% ! %;( ($"(7%"!% / A!4(#(A#/!8 '(++&%"!,8 5>%"6:%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., %;( #('&%8%""!/('. B(/*+*$%4<"( ' #',+! # E$!8 $(, >$( *: "% )64 ' >!#4% /&!$!/(' 8*$%&!*4!+8* («8("!+8*») =%//%4,, '@&(>%8, /*/ ! !1%*4!+8* («E"%&;%$!+8*») 3#$'*4<1*. 3) ()(!: (", ' >*#$"(#$!, @!#*4: «C "*7% '&%8, #"('* #$*4! @(,'4,$<#,
143
%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4!, "% 5:(1,F!% #@(4"* ' #@%2!*4<"6% !##4%1('*"!,, "( #$&%8,F!%#, / ($6#/*"!G )(4%% ()F!: $(>%/ +&%"!,… W#4! , "*+('5 !8%"* :($, )6, "*@&., 3#$'*4<1* ! =%//%4,, '#,/!. @&!+"*%$ !: '61*GF%%#, +"*>%"!% ' ()4*#$! !: #()#$'%""(. #@%2!*4<"(#$!. C ()4*#$! ()F!: '(@&(#(' , ' ()(!: '!?5 $('*&!F%. @( #$&%84%"!,8 ! ()(!: '6#(/( 2%"G, :($, "% 8(;5 #(;4*#!$<#, # "!8! '( '#%: @5"/$*:. C 3#$'*4<1% ,, /&(8% $(;(, '6#(/( >$5 #!4<"(;( ! @()%1("(#"(;( )(&2* @&($!' +*/(#"%"!, 8%$(1*, * ' =%//%4% – >%#$"(;(, "%@(1/5@"(;( )(.2* +* @&(#'%F%"!% ! #'()(15 86#4!. N$()6 ' /&*$/!: >%&$*: '6&*+!$<, ' /*/(8 "*@&*'4%"!! , '#%;( )(4<7% ($1*4,G#< ($ E$!: 1'5: !##4%1('*$%4%., , 1(4?%" #/*+*$< #4%15GF%%: 21'D!7!#'0*16!* "*)4G1%"!% , #>!$*G ' $*/(. ?% 8%&% '*?"68 ! (#"('"68 !#$(>"!/(8 @(+"*"!,, /*/ ! "*)4G1%"!% A!+!>%#/(%» (254, #. 22-23). 3$#G1* #4%15%$, >$(, #(4!1*&!+!&5,#< # =%//%4%8 ! 3#$'*4<1(8 ' #$&%84%"!! &%7*$< #',+*""6% # %#$%#$'%""("*5>"68 @(+"*"!%8 @&()4%86 A!4(#(A#/(;( :*&*/$%&*, *: @&! E$(8 (#"('"(% ($4!>!% #'(!: @(+!2!. 5#8*$&!'*4 "% ' /(&%""6: @&!"2!@*: &%7%"!, "*+'*""6: @&()4%8, "% ' @&($!'(#$(,"!! %;( A!4(#(A#/!: '+;4,1(' 8*$%&!*4!+85 =%//%4, !4! !1%*4!+85 3#$'*4I1*, * @&%!85F%#$'%""( ' #A%&% ()F%;( 8%$(1* @(+"*"!,, #',+*""(;( «# ($6#/*"!%8 )(4%% ()F!: $(>%/ +&%"!,», ' !"(8 @(1:(1% / @("!8*"!G #*8(;( @&(2%##* @(+"*"!,, %;( "*@&*'4%""(#$!, ' )(4%% @(4"(8 5#$*"('4%"!! %;( (#"('"6: !#$(>"!/(' – ' 1()*'4%"!! / ()I%/$!'"(85 («A!+!>%#/(85») "*)4G1%"!G "*)4G1%"!, #5)I%/$!'"(;( («@#!:(4(;!>%#/(;(»), $( %#$<, !"*>% ;('(&,, ' 5>%$% #(#$(,"!, "% $(4"(;( (@&%1%4%"!, #'(%. @&!"*14%?"(#$! / 8*$%&!*4!#$*8 !4! !1%*4!#$*8, @(18%"* E$(;( ()F%;( 8!&('(++&%">%#/(;( 5#$*"('4%"!, A*/$(&(8 $%(&%$!/(-@(+"*'*$%4<"68, /($(&6., ' #'(G (>%&%1<, +*>*#$5G 4!7*%$#, ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% A!4(#(A#/(;( #(1%&?*"!,, #*8(;( A!4(#(A#/(;( #$*$5#*, '6&*?%"!%8 >%;( ,'4,%$#, @(+!$!'!#$#/*, +*+%84%""(#$< "* "%@(#&%1#$'%""( 1*""(%. *: #*8 "%1'5#86#4%""( '6#/*+*4#, "* E$($ #>%$: «K4, 8%", "% !8%%$ "!/*/(;( +"*>%"!, '#,/*, "*5>"*, &*)($*, /($(&*, "% #',+*"* "%&*+&6'"( # "%@(#&%1#$'%""( 1*""68 ! /($(&*, '8%#$( $(;(, >$()6 !+5>*$< ($"(7%"!, 8%?15 @&!+"*/*8! 1*""(;(, ;("!$#, +* @&!+&*/*8!. -*+ E$! ($"(7%"!, !+5>%"6, $( 8(?"( ($"(#!$%4<"( !: '1*'*$<#, %F% ' /*/!% 5;(1"( &*##5?1%"!,. R( , E$!8 "% +*"!8*G#<. (, +*1*>* "% &'7!1!&16%(, * >!#$( :*-!5!7!#'0*16%(» ($*8 ?%, #$&. 22). N$( /*#*%$#, A!4(#(A#/(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* ! !1%*4!+8*, $( *: )(4<7% @&%1@(>!$*4 '6&*?*$< #'(% "%;*$!'"(% ($"(7%"!% / "!8. P'(G A!4(#(A#/5G @(+!2!G (" &*+8%F*4 '"% $(;( ! 1&5;(;(. J*/, ' «9"*4!+% (F5F%"!.», !8%, ' '!15 #'(!: /&!$!/(', (" @!#*4: «R*74! '(+8(?"68 '6>!$*$< 5 8%", ()F%@&!",$6% @('#%1"%'"6% '+;4,16, @&%'&*F*$< 8%",
144
$( ' !1%*4!#$*, $( ' @(#4%1('*$%4, Q%&/4!, $( ' 8*$%&!*4!#$*, ' >%8 , #%), @('!""68 "% #>!$*G» (246, #. 58–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«G:*"% *&/#* ! L";%4<#* 8"%, /("%>"(, )64! !+'%#$"6, "( , 158*4 "*.$! 5 "!: $(4%#/!% 1*""6%, * E$* ()4*#$< (#$*4*#< #('%&7%""( >5?1(. 8(%85 !+5>%"!G» (253, #. 13). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, ! @( ($"(7%"!G / *:5 @&(,'!4(#< ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, :*&*/$%&"(% 14, )(4<7!"#$'* 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/*, ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, ($8%>%""(% L";%4<#(8, @!#*'7!8, >$( ' ()4*#$! A!4(#(A!! ("! )64! «@(45+"*./*8!». V"*"!% *:(8 8*$%&!*4!+8*, #51, @( '#%85, (;&*"!>!'*4(#< #*868! ()F!8!, / $(85 ?% "% '#%;1* $(>"( @(1*""68! #'%1%"!,8! !+ &*+4!>"6: !#$(&!. A!4(#(A!!. (?"( '#@(8"!$< ' #',+! # E$!8 %;( 5$'%&?1%"!%, >$( 8*$%&!*4!+85 «150 4%$ ($ &(15»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– / $(. %;( 5@&(F%""(. A(&8%, ' /*/(. (" ' #%&%1!"% XIX '%/* @(45>!4 &*#@&(#$&*"%"!% )4*;(1*&, A!+!(4(;*8 QG:"%&5, 0(;$5, (4%7($$5, /($(&6%, @( 8"%"!G L";%4<#*, "% '674! "! ' >%8 +* @&%1%46 5>%"!. #'(!: 5>!$%4%., $( %#$< A!4(#(A('-8*$%&!*4!#$(' UOT '%/* (#8. 407, #. 288). B(",$"(, >$( / /("25 XIX '%/* -%6!= 8*$%&!*4!+8 "% 8(; "% 5#$*&%$<, "% 8(; "% #$*$< "%1(#$*$(>"68 14, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., :($, )6 ! ' /*>%#$'% !: «1(8*7"%. A!4(#(A!!». *: E$( '!1%4 ! @("!8*4. R( (" "% '!1%4 '(+8(?"(#$! @&%(1(4%"!, 5#$*&%4(#$! ! "%1(#$*$(>"(#$! 8*$%&!*4!+8* 150–4%$"%. 1*'"(#$!, "% @("!8*4 "%():(1!8(#$! %;( +*8%"6 1&5;(., )(4%% #('%&7%""(. A(&8(. 8*$%&!*4!+8* ?%. 3$#G1* ! %;( /(4%)*"!, ' ($"(7%"!! / !+'%#$"(85 %85 8*$%&!*4!+85, '
145
(@&%1%4%"!! #'(%. A!4(#(A#/(. @(+!2!!. C $(. 8%&%, ' /*/(. 8*$%&!*4!+8 14, "%;( (+"*>*4 @&!+"*"!% ()I%/$!'"(;( #5F%#$'('*"!, '"%7"%;( 8!&*, *: #(;4*7*4#, #>!$*$< ! "*+6'*$< #'(% 8!&('(++&%"!% 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!8. R( ' $(. 8%&%, ' /*/(. 8*$%&!*4!+8 14, "%;( (+"*>*4 #'%1%"!% @#!:!>%#/(;( / A!+!>%#/(85 ! A!+!(4(;!>%#/(85, (" #>!$*4 8*$%&!*4!+8 "%1(#$*$(>"68 ! 5#$*&%'7!8. H )64, /("%>"(, @&*'. R% @&*' (" )64 ' 1&5;(8 – ' #8%7%"!! 8*$%&!*4!+8* UVT '%/*, 8*$%&!*4!+8* QG:"%&* ! 1&. # 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 /*/ ()F!8 A!4(#(A#/!8 8!&('(++&%"!%8. W;( @&%1#$*'4%"!% ( 8*$%&!*4!+8% "% '6:(1!4( +* &*8/! @&%1#$*'4%"!,, 5/(&%"!'7%;(#, ' (A!2!*4<"(. @&(A%##(&#/(. A!4(#(A!! $(;( '&%8%"!. J*/, (1!" !+ @&(A%##(&(' C. C5"1$ @!#*4: « *$%&!*4!+8 %#$< $*/(% 8%$*A!+!>%#/(% "*@&*'4%"!%, /($(&(%, #$*&*,#< ()I,#"!$< 15:('"5G #$(&("5 '%F%. !: 8*$%&!*4<"(. #$(&("(., @&(!+'(4<"( @&%1@(>!$*%$ #(#$*'"6% >*#$! /("/&%$"(. 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!, @&!5&(>%""6% / 1(#$5@"68 >5'#$'%""(85 '(#@&!,$!G #'(.#$'*8 $%4%#"(;( 8!&*, 1&5;!8 %% #(#$*'"68 >*#$,8» (72, #. 5). C $(8 ?% /4G>% #$&(!$ #'(% @("!8*"!% 8*$%&!*4!+8* ! *:, @( 8"%"!G /($(&(;(, 8*$%&!*4!#$6 «'%&,$, >$( 8*$%&!, %#$< %1!"#$'%""( "%@(#&%1#$'%""( 1*""(%, "% $&%)5GF%% 1*4<"%.7%;( '6,#"%"!,» (246, #. 290). P4%1('*$%4<"(, %#4! *: #'(G A!4(#(A#/5G @(+!2!G &*#@(4*;*%$ '"% 8*$%&!*4!+8* ! !1%*4!+8*, "*1 !: )(&<)(., $( @&!8%"!$%4<"( / @%&'(85, $( %#$< / 8*$%&!*4!+85 &%>< 1(4?"* !1$! "% ( 1%.#$'!$%4<"(8 8*$%&!*4!+8%, /($(&(;( *: "% +"*4, * 4!7< ( 2!"':%*:!: !8 8*$%&!*4!+8% –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«!"$%&%# %;( &*+58*». V1%#< (" "% #$*4 !#/4G>%"!%8 #&%1! )(4<7!"#$'* %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/*. M&(8% $(;( *: "% !+)%?*4 ! 1&5;(. @&!#5F%. !8 (7!)/!: #'(% ($"(7%"!% / #&*'"!$%4<"( :(&(7( !+'%#$"(. %85 !1%*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! (" &*#@&(#$&*",4 @(1>*# "* '#G A!4(#(A!G. 3$#G1* ! %;( *"$!@*$!, / 8%$*A!+!/% ! / $(. A!4(#(A!!, ' /($(&(. 8%$*A!+!>"(#$< @&(,'4,%$#, ' @&%$%"+!,: "* !#>%&@6'*GF%% ()I,#"%"!% 8!&* "* @5$! 58(+&%"!,. P'(G @(+!2!G *: #>!$*4 #('%&7%""( >5?1(. -%6!= A!4(#(A!!. «R*7* $(>/* +&%"!,, – @!#*4 (", – "% 1*%$ A!4(#(A5 "!>%;( !4! 1*%$ (>%"< 8*4(. C %% +*1*>5 "% ':(1!$ &*+&%7*$< (1"5 !4! #%8< !4! 1%',$< 8!&('6: +*;*1(/. 3"* '%1%$ $(4"(85 !##4%1('*"!G, ( /($(&(8 A!4(#(A5 '('#% "%$ "*1()"(#$! +*)($!$<#,, – ,
146
!8%G ' '!15 A!4(#(A*, /($(&6. +"*%$ !4!, @( /&*."%. 8%&%, 158*%$, >$( +"*%$, 5?% '%&"6% (#"('6 8!&('(++&%"!,» (254, #. 24). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, @( *xy, @(45>*%$#,, >$( "%#(#$(,$%4<"(#$< A!4(#(A#/(;( !1%*4!+8* ! "%1(#$*$(>"(#$< 8*$%&!*4!+8* @&%(1(4%'*G$#, ' 8!&('(++&%"!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,, ' 1*""(8 #45>*% – ' 8!&('(++&%"!! #*8(;( *:*, @(+!$!'!+8(8. R*4!2(, #4%1('*$%4<"(, @(@6$/* (@&%1%4!$< «$&%$!.» @5$< ' A!4(#(A!! – '"% 8*$%&!*4!+8* ! !1%*4!+8*, "*1 "!8!, @(@6$/* 5$'%&1!$< ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!! %F% (1!" '*&!*"$ #'(%., #5;5)( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(. A!4(#(A!! – "! 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(., "! !1%*4!#$!>%#/(.. 9 %#4! 5>!$6'*$< ! 1&5;!% ($$%"/! A!4(#(A#/(. 86#4! ' %% ()()F%""(8 8!&('(++&%">%#/(8 /*>%#$'%, $( (@&%1%4%""(#$< @&!"2!@!*4<"(. A!4(#(A#/(. @(+!2!! *:* 8(?%$ @(/*+*$<#, %F% )(4%% @&()4%8*$!>"(., /*/, "*@&!8%&, '( 8"%"!! !+'%#$"(;( ' $( '&%8, @!#*$%4, J. Q%%&*: «V*$&51"%"!,, # /($(&68! ' $%>%"!% $6#,>%4%$!. "% 8(;4! #@&*'!$<#, '%4!>*.7!% 86#4!$%4! 8!&* ($ =%&*/4!$*, B&($*;(&* !4! B4*$("* 1( D(//*, Q%&/4! !4! M*"$*, )64! '@(4"% @()%?1%"6 *:(8. W;( (#"('"(% '(++&%"!% "! 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!–&%*4!#$!>%#/!. *$(8!+8, "! #%"#5*4!#$!>%#/!–!1%*4!#$!>%#/!. #@!&!$5*4!+8, "! @&%#$*)!4!#$!>%#/!. (//*+!("*4!+8, "! E@!A%"(8%"!#$!>%#/!. !1%*4!+8, "! @*"!#!:!+8, "! #!"%:(4(;!+8, "! 8"!86. 8("!+8, * #*86. "*#$(,F!., >!#$6. 8("!+8…» (16, #. 111). R( %#4! A!4(#(A!, *:* – E$( 8("!+8, @5#$< 1*?% ! «"*#$(,F!.», ! «>!#$6.», $( '#% ?% (#$*%$#, ($/&6$68 '(@&(#: ' /*/(8 #86#4% E$( :!"',:? N$( (1"(, )6$!."(%, !+"*>*4<"(%, (@&%1%4,%$ %;( 8!&('(++&%">%#/5G #5F"(#$< – 8*$%&!*4<"(% !4! 15:('"(%? H # E$!: @&!"2!@!*4<"6: @(+!2!. A!4(#(A6 &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( @%&!(1* 5?% )(4%% (@&%1%4%""( ! (1"(+"*>"( #51!4! ( #5F%#$'% A!4(#(A!! *:* ! %;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( 8!&('(++&%"!,. R( %#4! A!4(#(A6–!1%*4!#$6 #/4(""6 )64! #>!$*$< @(+!$!'!#$#/5G A!4(#(A!G *:* (E8@!&!(/&!$!2!+8) 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(., $( @(#4%1('*$%4<"6% 8*$%&!*4!#$6, ' >*#$"(#$!, 8*&/#!#$6, "*@&($!', &*##8*$&!'*4! A!4(#(A!G *:* /*/ &*+"('!1"(#$< #5)I%/$!'"(;( !1%*4!+8*, /*/ #(4!@#!+8 )%&/4!*"#/(;( $(4/*. =.C. B4%:*"(', "*@&!8%&, 5$'%&?1*4, >$( «$(;(, /$(, @(1()"( *:5, #>!$*%$ $%4* @&(#$68! 4(;!>%#/!8! #!8'(4*8! 14, /(8@4%/#(' (F5F%"!., 1(4?"* @(#$!;"5$< 5>*#$<, "%!+)%?"( @(#$!;*GF*, '#%: #5)I%/$!'"6: !1%*4!#$(': (" @&!1%$ / #(4!@#!+85…» (309, #. 251). M("/&%$"( ?% A!4(#(A!, *:* «2%4!/(8 #$(!$… "* $(>/% +&%"!, !1%*4!#$* XVIII #$(4%$!, Q%&/4!» ($*8 ?%, #. 231). D. 9/#%4<&(1 (3&$(1(/#) $*/?% ($8%>*%$ «'"5$&%""%% #:(1#$'( E8@!&!(/&!$!2!+8* # 5>%"!%8 Q%&/4!», * $*/?% #'(%()&*+"5G A(&85, «/($(&5G @&!",4 #5)I%/$!'"6. !1%*4!+8 ' $%(&!! >!#$(;( (@6$*» (5, #. 182). B( 8"%"!G C.H. D%"!"*, «5>%"!% L. *:* ( '%F*:, /*/ /(8@4%/#*: (F5F%"!., %#$< #5)I%/$!'"6. !1%*4!+8, %#$< @&(#$(% @%&%?%'6'*"!% )%&/4!*"#$'*» (204, #. 35).
147
B&! E$(8, (1"*/(, # 5>%$(8 $(;( ()#$(,$%4<#$'*, >$( *: )64 "% $(4%"68-%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%8, ($8%>*4!#< "%@(#4%1('*$%4<"(#$<, @&($!'(&%>!'(#$< %;( @&!"2!@!*4<"(. A!4(#(A#/(. @(+!2!!, "*4!>!% ' %;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 8!&('(++&%"!! "%!+)%?"6: @&(,'4%"!. 8*$%&!*4!+8*. J*/, =.C. B4%:*"(' @(1>%&/"54, >$( «' /*>%#$'% "*$5&*4!#$* *:, :($, ! #('%&7%""( )%##(+"*$%4<"(, @(#$(,""( '6"5?1*%$#, @%&%:(1!$< "* :%-*$'%7'1-'0*16;4 -!06; ,$*"'(. H /*?16. &*+, /(;1* (" @%&%:(1!$ "* "%%, (" @(@*1*%$ ' 4(;!>%#/(% @&($!'(&%>!% # '5*%7'1-'0*16!= !1"!9!= #'(%. #()#$'%""(. «A!4(#(A!!»… W#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4<, ?!'5F!. ' *:%, #/4(",%$#, / 8*$%&!*4!+85. H"*>% ! )6$< "% 8(?%$: "*–8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(% %#$%#$'(+"*"!% "%'(+8(?"(. 9 «A!4(#(A», ?!'5F!. ' $(8 ?% *:%, #/4(",$#, / !1%*4!+85… C ;&51! *:* ?!'5$ 1'% 157!. 3$#G1* %;( "%@(#4%1('*$%4<"(#$<» (309, #. 259–260). R* E$( ?% ()#$(,$%4<#$'( ()&*$!4 '"!8*"!% ! C.H. D%"!": ' #A%&% #'(!: %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: !##4%1('*"!., ()()F*GF!: '6'(1(' « *: ,%<.9%*- #'(G #()#$'%""5G $%(&!G !, "*>!"*, ;('(&!$< ( &*+4!>"6: '(@&(#*: A!+!/!, &*##5?1*%$ @(@&(#$5, )%+ !1%*4!#$!>%#/!: '6/&5$*#, $( %#$< 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!. C#% «/(8@4%/#6 (F5F%"!.» ! '#, E$* )%&/4!*"#/*, @&%851&(#$< 4%$,$ @&(><» (204, #. 60). C 2%4(8 ?% «8*:!+8 %#$< @5$*"!2*, #8%7%"!% 8*$%&!*4!+8* # !1%*4!+8(8» ($*8 ?%, #. 61). P'(% 8"%"!% ( @(+!$!'!#$#/(. A!4(#(A!! *:* ' %% ($"(7%"!! / %#$%#$'(+"*"!G $*/ !4! !"*>% '6&*+!4! ! 8"(;!% '61*GF!%#, 5>%"6%– %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( @%&!(1* . § 7. $2C=F=5=CB %;Q; = D4FD4F52CE;E=D: BEDE=9 D4FD4F52=4>KF;FD3DG C #&%1% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. *:, /*/ 5>%"6., '#%;1* @(4<+('*4#, +*#45?%""68 *'$(&!$%$(8, )4*;(1*&, #'(!8 @4(1($'(&"68 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"68 !+6#/*"!,8, #'(!8 "%+*5&,1"68 /*>%#$'*8 !##4%1('*$%4, ! 86#4!$%4,. 3#()%""( '%4!/ )64 *'$(&!$%$ *:* ' /("2% UIU – "*>*4% XX ''. J(;1* %;( '4!,"!% @&(,'4,4(#< ' &*+4!>"6: ()4*#$,: %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, ! ' 8!&('(++&%"!! 5>%"6:– %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%.. D. Q(4<28*", "*@&!8%&, #>!$*4 *:* «1%.#$'!$%4<"( ;45)(/!8 86#4!$%4%8» (35, #. 185), $&516 /($(&(;( «#5F%#$'%""( @(8(;4! &*+I,#"%"!G 8(%;( #()#$'%""(;( 8!&('(++&%"!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 117). C. 3#$'*4<1 @!#*4 ( *:%, /*/ ( >%4('%/%, !8%'7%8 &%7*GF%% '4!,"!% "* %;(, 3#$'*4<1*, 8674%"!%, (294, #. 7). M*/ 5>%"(;(, *:* '6#(/( 2%"!4 9. L."7$%.": « *: '6@(4"!4 '*?"6% "*5>"6% &*)($6 ("*@&!8%&, "* (#"('% @(!#$!"% ;%"!*4<"(;( (@$!>%#/(;( 8%$(1* ($/&64 51*&"6% '(4"6)» (401, #. 17). (?"( ($8%$!$< ' #',+! # E$!8, >$( M. B(@@%& #)4!?*%$ A!4(#(A!G A!4(#(A!%. Q%&/4! "* ()F%. @(>'% !"#$&58%"$*4!+8* (#8. 311, #. 300).
*:* #
148
P'(!8! !##4%1('*"!,8! *:, @( 8"%"!G L."7$%."*, ' )(4<7(. 8%&% #(1%.#$'('*4 /(&%""(85 @&%()&*+('*"!G '#%;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( 8674%"!,: «X 5#8*$&!'*G %;( ( *:* – C.3.) '%4!/5G +*#45;5 ' $(8, >$( (" #58%4 @(&'*$< # 1(;8*$!+8(8, /($(&6. 2*&!4 ' 18-8 ! ' 19-8 '%/*: ' '(@&(#*:, #',+*""6: # (#"('*8! A!+!/!» ($*8 ?%). -*"%%, ' 1916 ;(15 L."7$%." @!#*4, >$( « *: #'(!8! !#$(&!/(–/&!$!>%#/!8! #$*$<,8!, ' /($(&6: (" # $*/(. 4G)('%"6: "*7%;( @(/(4%"!,. X 1*?% 158*G, >$( $%, /$( #>!$*%$ #%), @&($!'"!/(8 *:*, '&,1 4! #(+"*G$, #/(4$( *: (/*+*4 «(;&(8"(% '4!,"!% "* ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/5G (&!%"$*2!G %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. "*7%;( '&%8%"!» ($*8 ?%, #. 27). U*&*/$%&"(, >$( 5?% $(;1*, ' 1916 ;(15, L."7$%." @6$*4#, #",$< # *:* ()'!"%"!% ' #5)I%/$!'"(8 !1%*4!+8%: *:, @( 8"%"!G L."7$%."*, #>!$*4, >$( «'#% "*5/! ()I%1!"%"6 #$&%84%"!%8 / 5@(&,1(>%"!G E4%8%"$*&"6: %1!"!>"6: 1*""6: "*7%;( (@6$*, "*+'*""6: !8 «(F5F%"!,8!». L$($ $%&8!", ''%1%""6. $&%+'68 ! (#$(&(?"68 86#4!$%4%8, >*#$( !+-+* "%1(#$*$(>"(;( +"*/(8#$'* # %;( &*)($*8! @5$*G$ # $%&8!"(4(;!%. A!4(#(A#/(;( !1%*4!+8* ! #(4!@#!+8*» ($*8 ?%, #. 32). H, "*/("%2, L."7$%." @&!+"*'*4 '4!,"!% !1%. *:* ! "* #'(! #()#$'%""6% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6% !+6#/*"!,, ' >*#$"(#$!, "* $%, >$( @&!'%4! / #(+1*"!G $%(&!! ($"(#!$%4<"(#$!. H8%, ' '!15 $% @(",$!, 5>%"!, ( @&(#$&*"#$'% ! '&%8%"!, ! $% @(",$!, 8%:*"!/!, /($(&6% !+8%"!4!#< @(1 '4!,"!%8 $%(&!! ($"(#!$%4<"(#$!, L."7$%." @!#*4: «R!/$( "% 8(?%$ ($&!2*$<, >$( ' E$(8 #45>*% $%(&!, @(+"*"!, 5/*+*4* @5$< 1*4<"%.7%;( &*+'!$!,. N$( ?% /*#*%$#, 8%", 4!>"(, $( , 1(4?%" #/*+*$<, >$( 8"%, @&,8( !4! /(#'%""(, (#()%""( @(8(;4! &*)($6 S8* ! *:*» ($*8 ?%, #. 29). P('#%8 !"(. – /&!$!>%#/!. – "*#$&(. @&(,'4,4#, ' #5?1%"!,: 5>%"6:, /(;1* 1%4( /*#*4(#< @(+!$!'!#$#/(. A!4(#(A!! *:*, %% #(1%&?*$%4<"(. #A%&6, (#"('"6: /("2%@$5*4<"6: 5#$*"('(/ ' "%.. 32%"/! +1%#< @(1>*# )64! '%#<8* "%4!2%@&!,$"68!. «R*#/(4%#/!. "*#$&(. 5>%"6: 5#5;5)4,4#, @(@6$/*8! #$(&(""!/(' *:* @&%1#$*'!$< %;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"5G $%(&!G @(+"*"!, ' /*>%#$'% A!4(#(A!! "('%.7%;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, A!4(#(A!! )%+ '#,/(. 8%$*A!+!/!. B(+!$!'!+8 *:* ! 9'%"*&!5#* ' %;( *"$!8%$*A!+!>%#/(. >*#$!, (#"('6'*GF%.#, "* !1%"$!>"6: @( #5$! @&!"2!@*: «E/("(8!! 8674%"!,» ( *:) ! «"*!8%"<7%. 8%&6 #!46» (9'%"*&!5#), A*/$!>%#/! 5@&*+1",4 #5;5)( A!4(#(A#/5G @&()4%8*$!/5, '6'(1!4 %% +* &*8/! "*5>"(#$! ''!15 "%'(+8(?"(#$! "%@(#&%1#$'%""(. @&('%&/! %% &%7%"!. ' >5'#$'%""(8 (@6$%, "* /("/&%$"6: A*/$*:. J%8 #*868 A!4(#(A!,
149
(8%$*A!+!/*) !#/4G>*4*#< !+ #A%&6 5#$*"('4%"!, @(+!$!'"(;( !#$!""(;( +"*"!,, ! ' >*#$"(#$!, ($#$&*",4*#< ($ #('8%#$"(;( # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8 #5F"(#$"(;( @(#$!?%"!, !+5>*%86: ,'4%"!. ! @&(2%##(' @&!&(16. L$( ()I%/$!'"( '#$5@*4( ' (>%'!1"(% @&($!'(&%>!% # "*#5F"68! @($&%)"(#$,8! #*8(;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, – @&%?1% '#%;( $%8, >$( (&!%"$!&('*4( %;( "* >&%'*$(% @*;5)"68! @(#4%1#$'!,8! #5F%#$'%""(% #5?%"!% ' "%8 ()I%/$"(. >*#$! !##4%1('*"!., @&(!+'(4<"(% (;&*"!>%"!% %% "%@(#&%1#$'%""( '(#@&!"!8*%868, 1(#$5@"68 "*)4G1%"!G, (@6$"(., E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"(. @&('%&/%, "* #'%1%"!% @(45>*%8(;( +"*"!, / A*/$5 – $%8 #*868 +* @&%1%46 @(+"*"!, @&!&(16 A*/$!>%#/! '6'(1!4*#< '#, $*/ !4! !"*>% #(@&,?%""*, # A!4(#(A!%. $%+'!"%78"! (&;*"!+('*""*, ! #(($'%$#$'5GF!8 ()&*+(8 &%*4!+5%8*, #'2!-*-'0*16%(, * $*/?% ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% ! -*!$*-'0*16%( >*#$< %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: !##4%1('*"!.. H 14, 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., (#()%""( $%(&%$!/(', E$($ "%;*$!'"6. *#@%/$ @(+!$!'!+8*, @&(,'!'7!.#, ! ' A!4(#(A!! *:*, # $%>%"!%8 '&%8%"! #$*"('!4#, '#% )(4%% (>%'!1"68 ! "%@&!%84%868. V"*8%"!$6. "%8%2/!. A!+!/ 9. V(88%&A%4<1, /&!$!/5, @(+!$!'!+8 *:*, ' >*#$"(#$!, %;( @&!"2!@ «E/("(8!! 8674%"!,», 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/5G 5F%&)"(#$< @(+!$!'!+8* 5#8*$&!'*4 @&%?1% '#%;( ' $(8, >$( 14, @(+!$!'!#$* «'#, "*5/* ,'4,%$#, /(&&%4,2!%. 8%?15 >5'#$'%""68! '@%>*$4%"!,8!, ' 45>7%8 #45>*% %% @&%1#/*+*"!%8, * 2%4< '#%. "*5/! – "%/*, E/("(8!,. 3)6>"6% @&()4%86 A!4(#(A!! – 4!7< /*?5F!%#, @&()4%86, @(#/(45'#$'%""68 '(#@&!,$!%8. R% #5F%#$'5%$ "!/*/(. @&()4%86 #'()(1"(. '(4!, #*8* @&()4%8* @&!>!""(#$! #$*"('!$#, +1%#< &*#@46'>*$(. (158, #. 110–111). 3$'%&;*, ($8%>%""6% !8 @(+!$!'!#$#/!% (#"('(@(4(?%"!,, V(88%&A%4<1 ##64*%$#, @&! E$(8 "* A!4(#(A!G, ' >*#$"(#$!, "* M*"$*, /($(&6. $*/?% !##4%1('*4, '#4%1 +* S8(8, «&(4< >5'#$'%""6: '@%>*$4%"!. /*/ @%&'((#"('6 4G)(;( @(+"*"!,. R( '6'(16, /($(&6% (" ($#G1* 1%4*4, &*+!$%4<"( ($4!>*4!#< ($ '6'(1(' @(+!$!'!+8*. 3#()%""( #!4<"( ($4!>*%$#,… @(+!$!'!#$#/(% +*/4G>%"!% ($"(#!$%4<"( +*/("(' @&!&(16. K%.#$'!$%4<"( 4! @&!"2!@ E/("(8!! &5/('(1!4 */#'%44(8, /(;1* (" +*@!#6'*4 #'(! 5&*'"%"!,?» B( 8"%"!G V(88%&A%4<1*, « */#'%44 "% @&!7%4 )6 / 2%4!, %#4! (" "% )64 )6 ;45)(/( 5)%?1%" ' %1!"#$'% @&!&(16 ! ' #('%&7%""(. ;*&8("!! %% +*/("('. B(1()"68 ?% ()&*+(8 '%&* ' E$5 ;*&8("!G &5/('(1!4* L."7$%."(8, /(;1* (" +*@!#*4 5&*'"%"!, #'(%. ()F%. $%(&!! ($"(#!$%4<"(#$!, ()I%1!"!'7%. ;&*'!$*2!G ! ;%(8%$&!G. J( ?% '%&"( 14, +*/("(' /'*"$('(. $%(&!!». C @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$< E$!8 ! 1&5;!8 &%*4!,8 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, V(88%&A%4<1, @( %;( #4('*8, «"*+'*4 !#:(1"5G $(>/5 +&%"!, @(+!$!'!+8* «@&!"2!@(8 &*#:4,)*""(#$! +*/("(' @&!&(16» ($*8 ?%, #. 111). B&($!'(@(#$*'4,, *"$!8%$*A!+!>%#/(85 @(+!$!'!+85 *:* ()F5G 8!&('(++&%">%#/5G @(+!2!G %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., V(88%&A%4<1 @(1>%&/"54: «C 5$'%&?1%"!!, >$( +*/("6 @&!&(16 "%+*'!#!86 ($ "*# !
150
«1(4;('%>"%% )&("+6», )%+5#4('"(, %#$< "%>$( 8%$*A!+!>%#/(%. B(+!$!'!+8 ! @&*;8*$!+8 # @&%"%)&%?%"!%8 ($'%&;*G$ @(1()"(% '%&('*"!%, "( ("( ,'4,%$#, @(#$54*$(8 14, 4G)(;( !##4%1('*$%4,» ($*8 ?%). R*#$*!'*, "* "%():(1!8(#$! #(%1!"%"!, @(+"*'*$%4<"6: 5#!4!. A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ' 2%4,: 5#@%7"(;( @(+"*"!, @&!&(16, V(88%&A%4<1 (@!&*4#, @&! E$(8 ! "* 8"%"!, $*/!: #'(!: '%4!/!: #('&%8%""!/(', /*/ . B4*"/ ! 9. L."7$%.", ' >*#$"(#$!, (" #(>5'#$'%""( 2!$!&5%$ #4%15GF%% #5?1%"!% B4*"/*: «0!4(#(A6 @(",4!, >$( "%4<+, @&%1@!#6'*$< %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8, /*/!8! 8%$(1*8! ! &*1! /*/!: 2%4%. ("! 1(4?"6 &*)($*$<; #( #'(%. #$(&("6 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! 5)%1!4!#<, >$( !#:(1"*, $(>/* !: !##4%1('*"!. (@&%1%4,%$#, "% $(45'#$' ! >$( 1*?% %#$%#$'(+"*"!% "% 8(?%$ ():(1!$<#, )%+ (@&%1%4%""(. 1(+6 8%$*A!+!/!». B&!'%1, E$( '6#/*+6'*"!% B4*"/*, V(88%&A%4<1 1()*'4,%$: «R%#/(4!"*4 (", /*/ 8"(;!% ' $( '&%8,, # 5'4%>%"!, %G. R( E$( 5'4%>%"!%, /*/ >*#$( )6'*%$ ' ?!+"!, )6#$&( #8%"!4(#< &*+(>*&('*"!%8, /*/ $(4%"!,. C#@(8!"*, @(+1"%% (' 1910 ;(15) () E$(8 '&%8%"!, B4*"/ @!#*4: «B&*'( '6#/*+6'*$< #'(% 8"%"!% ( $%(&!! @(+"*"!, *:* 1*%$ 8"%, /*/ /*?%$#,, $( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, >$( , (#"('*$%4<"( +*"!8*4#, %G ' $%>%"!% &,1* 4%$. Q(4%% $(;(, '#% '&%8, 8(%;( @&%)6'*"!, ' M!4% (1885–1889) , #>!$*4 #%), 1*?% &%7!$%4<"68 #$(&(""!/(8 A!4(#(A!! *:*. R( '@(#4%1#$'!! , ($/*+*4#, ($ "%%, ;4*'"68 ()&*+(8 @($(85, >$( 8"% #$*4( ,#"(, >$( "*$5&A!4(#(A!, *:* "% '6@(4"!4* #*8(;( )4%#$,F%;( #'(%;( ()%F*"!,, /($(&(% @&!'4%/4( / "%. )(4<7!"#$'( %% #$(&(""!/(': %. "%#(8"%""( "% 51*4(#< 5#$&*"!$< 2%4!/(8 8%$*A!+!>%#/!% E4%8%"$6 !+ A!+!>%#/(. $%(&!! @(+"*"!,» (305, #. 34). L$! 8%$*A!+!>%#/!% E4%8%"$6, (#$*'7!%#, ' 8!&('(++&%"!! *:*, #5$< "% >$( !"(%, /*/ E4%8%"$6 !1%*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!!, ' >*#$"(#$!, A!4(#(A!! Q%&/4!. 3$ A!4(#(A!! *:* B4*"/* ($$(4/"54( !8%""( E$( – @&!+"*"!% $(;(, >$( «' @&!&(1% "% #5F%#$'5%$ 1&5;(. &%*4<"(#$!, /&(8% "*7!: #()#$'%""6: (F5F%"!., ! '#,/(% !+5>%"!% @&!&(16 ,'4,%$#, ' /("%>"(8 #>%$% $(4"68 @&!#@(#()4%"!%8 "*7!: 86#4%. / "*7!8 (F5F%"!,8, / /($(&(85 86 @&!:(1!8 @(1 '4!,"!%8 )(&<)6 +* #5F%#$'('*"!%. -*+"!2* 8%?15 A!+!>%#/!8 ! @#!:!>%#/!8 – >!#$( @&*/$!>%#/*, ! 5#4('"*,; %1!"#$'%""6% E4%8%"$6 8!&* – E$( "*7! (F5F%"!,» (304, #. 630). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, . B4*"/ "% $(4%8 – (1"!8 !+ @%&'6: #&%1! 5>%"6:– %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., "( !, >$( (#()%""( '*?"(, /&!$!/('*4 %;( # 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!: @(+!2!.. 3" @(/*+*4 "%#('8%#$!8(#$< (#"('"6: 8*:!#$#/!: @(+!$!'!#$#/!: 5#$*"('(/ # #('&%8%""68 %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8, @(1>%&/"5' @&! E$(8, >$( +"*>%"!% #!#$%86 *:* – «' #5F"(#$! >!#$(
151
A(&8*4<"(% ! #('%&7%""( "% /*#*%$#, (#"(' %#$%#$'(+"*"!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 631). 3$#G1* ! "%!+)%?"6% !+I,"6 ' A!4(#(A!! *:* ! @&%?1% '#%;( ' $(. %% >*#$!, /($(&*, ()&*F%"* "%@(#&%1#$'%""( / ()I,#"%"!G @&(2%##* @(+"*"!,. K4, B4*"/* (>%'!1"(. )64* (7!)(>"(#$< !8%""( $%(&%$!/(– @(+"*'*$%4<"6: @&!"2!@(' *:*. «J*8, ;1% *: @6$*%$#, )6$< #*8(#$(,$%4<"68, #4%15, #'(%. $%(&!! @(+"*"!,, (" 1('(4<"( >*#$( '@*1*%$ ' (7!)/!» (305, #. 38). 31"!8 !+ "*!)(4%% '*?"6: @&!"2!@(' $%(&!! @(+"*"!, *:*, ' A(&854!&('*"!! /($(&(;( (" @(@6$*4#, «)6$< #*8(#$(,$%4<"68», ,'4,%$#,, /*/ !+'%#$"(, @&!"2!@ «E/("(8!! 8674%"!,». L$($-$( @&!"2!@ ! ($'%&; ' @%&'5G (>%&%1< . B4*"/, #>!$*, %;( &%*4!+*2!G ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!! /&*."% @*;5)"(. 14, '#%;( @&(;&%##* "*5/!. «J&51"( ($1%4*$<#, ($ (@*#%"!,, >$( :(1 86#4%. @%&%1('6: 58(' )64 )6 "*&57%", @(4%$ !: A*"$*+!! (#4*)4%", * &*+'!$!% "*5/! )64( )6 &(/('68 ()&*+(8 +*1%&?*"(, %#4! )6 @&!"2!@ E/("(8!! *:* 1%.#$'!$%4<"( #1%4*4#, 2%"$&*4<"68 @5"/$(8 $%(&!! @(+"*"!,» (304, #. 632). . B4*"/, &*+(>*&('*'7!#< ' @(+!$!'!+8% *:*, @(1'%&; %;( /&!$!/% # @(+!2!. #$(&(""%;( "*)4G1*$%4, –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«C%&(,$"(, C6 "%1*'"( @(45>!4! 8(G "('5G &*)($5 () ($"(#!$%4<"(#$! ! ;&*'!$*2!!… C )515F%8 ;(15 '( '&%8, #(4"%>"(;( +*$8%"!, )51%$ @&('%&%"(, !+;!)*G$#, 4! #'%$('6% 45>! P(4"2%8 !4!, 1&5;!8! #4('*8!, '%&"( 4! (#"('"(% ! A5"1*8%"$*4<"(% @&%1@(4(?%"!% () E/'!'*4%"$"(#$! 5#/(&%""(. #!#$%86 ! ;&*'!$*2!(""(;( @(4,. W#4! E$( $*/, $( C*7! '1(:"('4,GF!% !##4%1('*"!, () (#"('*: 8%:*"!/! – '(@&%/! "%#@&*'%14!'(. /&!$!/% B4*"/* – @(45>*$ )4%#$,F%% @(1$'%&?1%"!%» ([!$. @( 388, #. 262). B( 8"%"!G L."7$%."*, '6&*?%""(85 !8 ' 1916 ;(15, *: #*8 )64 )4!+(/ / &*+&*)($/% ()F%. $%(&!! ($"(#!$%4<"(#$! – «+* @(4'%/* 1( %% #(+1*"!,! C%#<8* '%&(,$"(, >$( *: #58%4 )6 #(+1*$< ()F5G $%(&!G ($"(#!$%4<"(#$!, %#4! )6 ' $( '&%8,, /(;1* (" %F% )64 8(4(1 15:(8, A!+!/(' '(4"('*4 '(@&(# ( $(8, /*/ #4%15%$ @("!8*$<
152
@(#$(,"#$'( #/(&(#$! #'%$*» (403, #. 31). H"*>% ;('(&,, L."7$%." '!1%4 $(;1* ' *:% @%&'(@&(:(12* ' 1%4% #(+1*"!, $%(&!! ($"(#!$%4<"(#$!, #'(%;( "%@(#&%1#$'%""(;( @&%17%#$'%""!/*. R( E$( 5)%?1%"!% L."7$%."* 1('(4<"( #/(&( )64( #%&<%+"( @(/(4%)4%"( – ! "!/%8 !"68, /*/ #*8!8 *:(8. C 1921 ;(15 @(#8%&$"( )64! (@5)4!/('*"6 %;( «B&!"2!@6 A!+!>%#/(. (@$!/!». C @&%1!#4('!! / E$(. &*)($%, 1*$!&('*""(. !G4%8 1913 ;(1*, *: '6&*+!4 #'(% ($&!2*$%4<"(% ($"(7%"!% / $%(&!! ($"(#!$%4<"(#$! ! /( '#,/!8 @(@6$/*8 @&%1#$*'4,$< %;( /*/ @&%17%#$'%""!/* ! @!("%&* ' %% #(+1*"!!. 3", ' >*#$"(#$!, @!#*4: «H+ 1(:(1,F!: 1( 8%", @5)4!/*2!. ! (#()%""( !+ 8(%. @%&%@!#/! , 1%4*G '6'(1, >$( @(#$%@%""( 8%", '#% )(4%% #>!$*G$ @&%1'%#$"!/(8 $%(&!! ($"(#!$%4<"(#$!… 31"*/( , 1(4?%", /("%>"(, ($&%><#, ($ $(;(, )51$( , @&%1'%#$"!/ &%4,$!'!#$(', # $(. ?% &%7!$%4<"(#$%#/(. '%&6… X ($'%&;*G #('&%8%""5G &%4,$!'!#$#/5G $%(&!G, /($(&*, 8"% @&%1#$*'4,%$#, '#% )(4%% ! )(4%% 1(;8*$!>"(.» ([!$. @( 389, #. 215). B(",$"(, >$( E$( "% 8(;4( "% +*1%$<, ! @&!$(8 1(#$*$(>"( #!4<"(, L."7$%."* –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– @4(:*, $(>/* +&%"!,; ' ()F%8, $(, >$( #1%4*"( *:(8, E$( /*$*4(;, * "% #!#$%8*» ([!$. @( 115, #. 105). B(+1"%% ' #'(!: «9'$()!(;&*A!>%#/!: +*8%$/*:» (1949) L."7$%." @!#*4: «C 8(! 8(4(16% ;(16 "* 8%", @&(!+'%4* #!4<"(% '@%>*$4%"!%… ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/*, 5#$*"('/* *:*, /($(&*, #%;(1", @&%1#$*'4,%$#, 8"% ' #5F%#$'%""6: @5"/$*: "%#(#$(,$%4<"(.» (403, #. 266). R%#(#$(,$%4<"(#$< A!4(#(A!! *:* L."7$%." #',+6'*4 @&%?1% '#%;( # %% @(+!$!'!#$#/(. #(#$*'4,GF%.. J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, @&%15)%?1%"!% *:*, * $*/?% 3#$'*4<1* @&($!' *$(8"(. $%(&!!, @( 8"%"!G L."7$%."*, «8(?"( "%#(8"%""( ($"%#$! +* #>%$ !: @(+!$!'!#$#/(. A!4(#(A#/(. 5#$*"('/%. L$( – !"$%&%#"6. @&!8%& $(;(, /*/ A!4(#(A#/!% @&%15)%?1%"!, 8%7*G$ @&*'!4<"(. !"$%&@&%$*2!! A*/$(' 1*?% 5>%"68 #( #8%468 8674%"!%8 ! # $("/(. !"$5!2!%.» ($*8 ?%, #. 276). L$($ ?% #45>*. ! ' $(8 ?% /&!$!>%#/(8 @4*"% '61%4,%$ ! M.9. J!8!&,+%'.
153
3$8%$!', ' >*#$"(#$!, /*/ ;4*'"5G (7!)/5 M("$*, (;&*"!>%"!% !8 ()4*#$! @&!8%"%"!, "*5>"(. ;!@($%+6, (" 1()*'4,%$: «…C $5 ?% (7!)/5 '@*4! 8(1"6% ! 5 "*# "%8%2/!% "*$5&A!4(#(A6 *: ! 3#$'*4<1, 1(7%17!% "* E$(. @(>'% 1( ($&!2*"!, *$(8!+8*, +* >$( ! )64! ?%#$(/( "*/*+*"6 )4%#$,F!8! ($/&6$!,8! "('%.7%. A!+!/!» (352, # 101). M E$(85 8(?"( 1()*'!$< *"*4(;!>"(% /&!$!>%#/(% #5?1%"!% !+'%#$"(;( &5##/(;( %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4, P.B. M(#$6>%'*: «3$&!2*, 15*4!#$!>%#/(% (@&%1%4%"!% (@6$*, &*+4!>!% 8%?15 #5)I%/$(8 ! ()I%/$(8, 8("!+8 *:* '4*#$"( '$(&;*%$#, ' "*5/5, '@(4"% @(#4%1('*$%4<"( $&%)5, ($ "%% ($&!2*"!, «+*/("('» ' @&!&(1%, * $%8 )(4%% "%1(/*+*""6: $%(&!., /*/, "*@&!8%&, @&%1#$*'4%"!, () *$(8*: ! 8(4%/54*:. 3) E$(8 '%#<8* 58%#$"( '#@(8"!$< !8%""( $%@%&<, /(;1*, )4*;(1*&, Q(&5 ! 1&5;!8 !##4%1('*$%4,8, 5>%"!% ( #$&(%"!! *$(8(' @(#$*'4%"( "* E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"5G (#"('5» (181, #. 34). H 1%4( $5$, @( 8"%"!G M(#$6>%'*, "% $(4!#$( "*5>"(. "%#(#$(,$%4<"(#$! A!4(#(A#/!: @&!"2!@(' *:*, "( ! ' $%: "%;*$!'"6: @(#4%1#$'!,:, /($(&6% "%!+)%?"6 ' #45>*% @&%$'(&%"!, E$!: @&!"2!@(' ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!!, ' 8!&('(++&%"!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%.. «N$( )64( )6, %#4! )6 *:* @&!"!8*4! #('%&7%""( '#%&<%+, %#4! )6 (" @(45>!4 ;4*'%"#$'( "*1 58*8!, ! 5>%"6% #$&(!4! )6 #'(% 8!&('(++&%"!% @( @&!"2!@*8 «9"*4!+* (F5F%"!.»? 3$'%$ ,#%": )64 )6 5F%&) 14, "*5/!» ($*8 ?%, #. 35). C 2%4(8 ?% ($"(7%"!% &5##/!: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. / @(+!$!'!#$#/(. A!4(#(A!! *:* (1!" !+ %;( @(#4%1('*$%4%., :!8!/ @( #@%2!*4<"(#$!, C.C. T*&'!" (:*&*/$%&!+('*4 $*/: «O "*# 5>%"6% "% )64! (#()%""( )4*;(#/4(""6 / *:5. 31!" 1('(4<"( !+'%#$"6.… A!+!/ (9.=. P$(4%$('. – C.3.) @&!#(%1!"!4 / '(++&%"!,8 *:* E@!$%$ «1%/*1%"$#/!%». L$(. /(8)!"*2!! #4(' @(#>*#$4!'!4(#<: %% 8(?"( )64( #467*$< "*@&*'( ! "*4%'(» (394, #. 8–9). N$( /*#*%$#, ($"(7%"!, ' -(##!! / E8@!&!(/&!$!2!+85 9'%"*&!5#*, $(, @( #'!1%$%4<#$'5 P. =&5+%")%&;*, «$%>%"!% E$(, ,&/( ()(+"*>!'7%%#, ' +*@*1"(. A!4(#(A!!, "*74( #%)% #4*)6. ($;(4(#(/ ' &*)($*:, ;4*'"68 ()&*+(8, 1'5: @(@54,&!+*$(&(' 9'%"*&!5#* – Q(;1*"('* ! ($>*#$! D5"*>*&#/(;(…»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
154
!+)!&*4! 14, #%),, @&%$'(&,4! ' #'(%8 8!&('(++&%"!! ! ' #'(%. "%@(#&%1#$'%""(. !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$!.
155
@3;5; IV C;=B2459CO = 5C;=B27DG4F5=D A=3242A== = D4FD4F52CE;E=9: >2C=J=9 D4FD4F52=4>KF;FD3DG 9"*4!+ A!4(#(A#/!: *#@%/$(' ' 8!&('(++&%"!! '61*GF!:#, 5>%"6:%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/* "%():(1!8( @&%1@(4*;*%$ ! @&%1'*&!$%4<"(% #5F"(#$"(% @&(,#"%"!% !: ($"(7%"!, / A!4(#(A!!, !: @&!"2!@!*4<"(. @(+!2!! ' &%7%"!! '(@&(#* ( '+*!8(($"(7%"!! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ! A!4(#(A!!, * $*/?% ()F5G A!4(#(A#/5G !1%"$!A!/*2!G !: 8!&('(++&%"!, ' #(@(#$*'4%"!! # @(+!$!'!+8(8, 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 ! !1%*4!+8(8, # (@(&(. "* !: #()#$'%""6% #5?1%"!, @( 1*""(85 '(@&(#5. B(",$"(, >$( &%>< ' E$(8 #45>*% 8(?%$ !1$! "% ( '#%()I%84GF%. – ()F%. 14, '#%: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. –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–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. / $%(&%$!>%#/!8 '(@&(#*8, '6:(1,F!8 +* @&%1%46 @&()4%8*$!/! !: "%@(#&%1#$'%""6: !##4%1('*"!., '(@&(#*8, A!4(#(A#/!8 @( #'(%85 :*&*/$%&5. H E$( #$*4( #'(%;( &(1* +"*8%"!%8 '&%8%"!. C @&%17%#$'5GF!. @%&!(1 &*+'!$!, %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, ' @%&'(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/*, /*/(% )6 $( "! )64( A!4(#(A#$'('*"!% /*+*4(#< %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8 #('%&7%""( >5?168, ($'%&;*4(#< !8!. H E$( !8%4( #'(! @&!>!"6, /(&%"!'7!%#,, ' >*#$"(#$!, ! ' (#()%""(#$,: %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, $(;( '&%8%"!. § 1. #F;E253DE=D D4FD4F5DEE2E;6IE2N2 B=8252CC8DE=9: 2F<;C 2F E;F68A=3242A== R%():(1!8(#$< 1%$*4<"(;(, #/&5@54]+"(;( !##4%1('*"!, ()I%/$"6: >*#$"(#$%. ()5#4('4!'*4* '#] )(4%% 5+/5G #@%2!*4!+*2!G %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., $%"1%"2!G, /*/ @!#*4 K.M. */#'%44, «&*+)!'*$<#, "* +*8/"5$6% /&5?/!, ' /($(&6:, !8%""( )4*;(1*&, !: +*8/"5$(#$!, ;(#@(1#$'5G$ 8%4/!% 2%:('6% !"$%&%#6» (231, #. 31). =(#@(1#$'5GF!8 ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!! #$*"('!$#, &*+1%4%"!% $&51*, )4*;(1*&, /($(&(85 /*?16. !##4%1('*$%4< (;&*"!>!'*4#, #'(%. #@%2!*4<"(. ($&*#4"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$!, (#"('6'*'7%.#, "* '#] )(4%% 5+/(. #@%2!*4!+*2!! 5>]"6:, "%!+)%?"( @&!'(1!4 / +*)'%"!G ()F!: @&()4%8,
156
8!&('(++&%">%#/!: @( #(1%&?*"!G, @&!'(1!4 / $(85, >$( 5>%"<% ($#$&*",4!#< ($ &%7%"!, '(@&(#(', "% !8%GF!: @&,8(;( ($"(7%"!, / ()I%/$*8 !: !##4%1('*"!.. C #!45 E$(;( 5>]"6% ($/*+6'*4!#< ($ &%7%"!, '(@&(#(' ()F%;(, #5F"(#$"(;( :*&*/$%&*, !+)%;*4! '#,/(;( A!4(#(A#$'('*"!,. 3$8%>*, E$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, L. =%//%4< @!#*4: «Q%#/("%>"(% >!#4( "('6: (@6$"6: 1*""6:, # /($(&68! "*# @(+"*/(8!4 @(&*+!$%4<"6. @&(;&%## "('%.7%;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, @(']4 / 5/4("%"!G 58* ' #$(&("5 #@%2!*4<"(;( !+5>%"!, ' "%)(4<7(., (;&*"!>%""(. ()4*#$! +"*"!,. C &%+54<$*$% +*)&*#6'*%$#, '#] (#$*4<"(% ! ()F*, /*&$!"* @&!&(16 ' @&%1#$*'4%"!! 5>]"(;(–#@%2!*4!#$* "*>!"*%$ $%&,$<#, ' #'(%. ,&/(#$!» (90, #. 356). 3$#G1* #$*4( "%!+)%?"68 @(,'4%"!% ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, /*/ @!#*4 =%//%4<, 8*##6 «"% &*+8674,GF!: @(1%"F!/(', /($(&6% @&%/&*#"( !#@(4",G$ #'(G 8%4/5G #@%2!*4<"5G &*)($5, "( "% +*1*G$#, '(@&(#(8 ( #86#4% '%4!/(;( 2%4(;(; 1*?% #&%1! @(>$%""6: ! +*#45?%""6: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. "%8*4( @(@*1*%$#, $*/!:, /($(&6: #('%&7%""( "% !"$%&%#5G$ '(@&(#6 ()F%;( 8!&(#(+%&2*"!,, /($(&6% !F5$ 4!7< "('6: A*/$(', * "% @(",$!.» (95, #. 446). 3$1%4%"!% %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ($ "*$5&A!4(#(A!!, # (1"(. #$(&("6, $%"1%"2!, '#% )(4<7%;( 5;45)4%"!, #@%2!*4!+*2!! 5>]"6: – # 1&5;(., @(&(?1*4! ! @!$*4! ' "!: !44G+!G *)#(4G$"(;( «(#'()(?1%"!,» %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ($ A!4(#(A!!, !: @(4"(;( &*+8%?%'*"!,, !#>%+"('%"!, /*/(. )6 $( "! )64( #',+! 8%?15 "!8!. J*/(% «&*+8%?%'*"!%» A!4(#(A#/(;( ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, #(+1*'*4( '@%>*$4%"!%, >$( %#$%#$'(+"*"!%, /*/ @!#*4 D. Q(4<28*", «#('%&7%""( $%&,%$ !+ '!15 '%4!/!% @&()4%86 ()F%;( :*&*/$%&*» (35, #. 4). H #*8! E$! @&()4%86 @(4*;*4!#< 5#$&*"]""68!, !+I,$68! !+ "*5>"(;( ()!:(1* /*/ "%"5?"6%, 4!7"!% 14, @(+"*"!, @&!&(16. «P()#$'%""( ?% 2%4*#$"(#$%.; ' )!(4(;!! E$* 2%4<, /*+*4(#<, 1(#$!;*4*#<, %#4! # @(8(F*.7!: !"#$&58%"$(' ! #&%1#$' "*)4G1%"!, @(45>*4(#< $(>"(% +"*"!% A(&8 ! ?!+"%""6: ,'4%"!. '#%: ($1%4<"6: (&;*"!+8('» (89, #. 65). J*/(% ($&!2*$%4<"(% ($"(7%"!% / @&()4%8*8 ()F%;( :*&*/$%&* )64( &*#@&(#$&*"%"( ! #&%1! A!+!/('. 3"!, @( #'!1%$%4<#$'5 */#'%44*, «5$'%&?1*4!, >$( 8%$*A!+!>%#/!% #@%/54,2!! ($(74! 5?% ' @&(74(%, ! >$( A!+!>%#/*, "*5/* 5"!>$(?!4* !:» (231, #. 36). B( 8"%"!G =.9. D(&%"2*, A!+!/ «1(4?%" (;&*"!>!'*$<#, #'(!8 #@(#()(8 >$%"!, /"!;! C#%4%""(.». R( :*&*/$%&"( @&! E$(8, >$( «;45)(/!. #86#4 (#$*]$#, 14, "%;( #/&6$68» (219, #. 68). 3$#$&*"%"!% 5>]"6: ($ A!4(#(A!!, !: "%@&!,+"%""(% ($"(7%"!% / "%., &*+'!'7!%#, "* @(>'% 5+/(. #@%2!*4!+*2!!, 5#5;5)4,4!#< ! ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% ()I,#",4!#< !: @4(:!8 +"*"!%8 A!4(#(A!!, (#"('"6: "*@&*'4%"!. ' "%., &*+4!>!. 8%?15 "!8!, !: (#"('"6: @&!"2!@('. B( #4('*8 =%//%4,, «;(&*+1( :5?% (1"(#$(&(""(#$! "* #(#$*'4%"!% ()F%;( @("!8*"!, @&!&(16 1%.#$'5%$ !-1;-1-9'* &'7!1!&16!#! !<$%,!9%"'(,
157
/($(&68 ($4!>*G$#, 8"(;!% #('&%8%""6% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4!» (90, #. 357). C#4%1#$'!% ($#5$#$'!, 5 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. 1(4?"(;( A!4(#(A#/(;( ()&*+('*"!, ("!, /*/ #>!$*4 L";%4<#, «,'4,G$#, @(45+"*./*8! ' ()4*#$! $%(&!!, ' ()4*#$! $(;(, >$( 1( #!: @(& "*+6'*4(#< A!4(#(A!%.» (406, #. 366). 0!4(#(A!,, # /($(&(. 5>%"6% '#% ?% $*/ !4! !"*>% )64! +"*/(86 (>%&%+ 5"!'%&#!$%$#/!% /5 4%/2!. ! @&.), A!4(#(A!,, ;(#@(1#$'('*'7*, ' $% '&%8%"* (#!#$%86 T%44!";*, =%;%4,), !: "! ' /(%. 8%&% "% 5#$&*!'*4* ;4*'"68 ()&*+(8 ''!15 %% "%(@&*'1*""6: "*$5&A!4(#(A#/!: @&!$,+*"!. "* *)#(4G$"5G !#$!"5 ' #5F"(#$"(8, >!#$( 58(+&!$%4<"(8 ()I,#"%"!! @&!&(16. R* E$($ %% #%&<%+"6. "%1(#$*$(/ ' @(#4%15GF%8 ()&*F*4! '"!8*"!% @&%?1% '#%;( #*8! A!4(#(A6. J*/, @( 8"%"!G 3. MG4<@%, A!4(#(A!, =%;%4, «+*,'!4* @&!$,+*"!, "* $(, >$()6 '(#@&(!+'%#$! "*5/5, /*/ ;(85"/545#*, !+ @&(#$6: E4%8%"$(' >!#$(;( 8674%"!,. R( ("* "% @&(!+'%4* #(+1*"!,, #@(#()"(;( / ?!+"! ! &*+'!$!G. K!*4%/$!>%#/!. 8%$(1, /($(&68 =%;%4< '4*1%4 # @(&*+!$%4<"(G #!4(G ! 4('/(#$$(?!4 %;( #!#$%85. K%.#$'!$%4<"(#$< @&(,'!4* "%@(/(&"(#$<, ! A!4(#(A!, ! #@%2!*4<"6% "*5/! '#$5@!4! ' (?%#$(>%""5G )(&<)5 8%?15 #()(G. C E$(. )(&<)% #@%/54,$!'"*, A!4(#(A!,, (@!&*GF*,#, ! @(4*;*GF*,#, "* #'(! (#()6% 8%$(16, @($%&@%4* @(4"(% @(&*?%"!%» (188, #. 22). 3$#G1*, /*/ #4%1#$'!%, ()F*, "%;*$!'"*, &%*/2!, "* A!4(#(A!G, @&%"%)&%?!$%4<"(% ($"(7%"!% / "%.. B&%"%)&%?%"!% / A!4(#(A!!, 5$'%&?1*4 0. B*54<#%", «"!;1% "% )64( $*/!8 ?%#$(/!8, /*/ ' =%&8*"!!; ("( "*#$5@!4( +1%#< '#4%1 +* ;(#@(1#$'(8 #@%/54,$!'"(. A!4(#(A!!, ($#G1* (>%"< 4%;/( @&%1@(4(?!$< $5$ @&!>!""5G #',+< ! ' @&%+&%"!! /( '#,/(. A!4(#(A!! 5'!1%$< &%*/2!G @&($!' >&%+8%&"(;( #*8('(+'67%"!,, /($(&68 #@%/54,$!'"*, A!4(#(A!, ! %% @&!'%&?%"26 (#/(&)!4! /*/ "*5>"(% !##4%1('*"!%, $*/ ! +1&*'6. >%4('%>%#/!. &*##51(/» (298, #. 1). R%;*$!'"*, &%*/2!, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. "* >!#$( 58(+&!$%4<"5G, #@%/54,$!'"5G "%8%2/5G "*$5&A!4(#(A!G @*;5)"( ($&*+!4*#< "* !: ($"(7%"!! /( '#%. A!4(#(A!!, / A!4(#(A!! /*/ $*/('(.. M*/ ($8%$!4 ' #',+! # E$!8 C. D%#%'!>, «@%&%#$*' )6$< &5/('(1,F!8 "*>*4(8 ?!+"! ! 1%,$%4<"(#$!, A!4(#(A!, #$*4* 8%&$'(G ($&*#4*4!#<, "( !+5>*4!#< #('%&7%""( )%##$&*#$"(, !: "!/$( "% @&!"!8*4, "!/$( ! "% ($'%&;*4. B&%1#$*'!$%4! "*5/! ' $( ?% '&%8, 74! )(4<7%G >*#$'*, "* /($(&(. '+(7%4 @(+!$!'!+8 # %;( *"$!8%$*A!+!>%#/(. "*@&*'4%""(#$%""*, (1"!8 !+ @(+!$!'!#$(',
158
9. -%%8: «M*/!:-"!)51< $&!12*$< 4%$ $(85 "*+*1 "* '(@&(#: 86#4!8* 4! '(()F% "*5>"*, A!4(#(A!,? – /($(&6. !"*>% 8(?"( '6&*+!$< $*/: %#$< 4! ! 1(4?"* 4! )6$< 8%?15 A!4(#(A!%. ! "*5/(. @&,8*, #',+%"6%, ! A!4(#(A6 ($'%>*4! ($&!2*$%4<"(. B( E$(85 @('(15 "% )64( 1'5: 8"%"!.: "*5/* 1(4?"* )6$< – /*/ '#% @&!+"*'*4! – #('%&7%""( "%+*'!#!8(. ($ A!4(#(A!!; * A!4(#(A!, – E$( 8%$*A!+!/*; ("* &*+'!'*%$#, "*1 "*5/(. !4! &,1(8 # "*5/(. ' #('%&7%""( !"(. @4(#/(#$!» (320, #. 3). P'(.#$'%""(% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8 '(#@&!,$!% ! #(@5$#$'5GF%% %85 "%@&!,$!% "*$5&A!4(#(A!! @%&'(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* (T%44!";*, =%;%4,, 3/%"* ! 1&.) C. 3#$'*4<1 '6&*+!4 #4%15GF!8 ()&*+(8: «C E$(8 !8%""( ! +*/4G>*4*#< (7!)/* "*$5&A!4(#(A!!, >$( ("* #$*&*4*#< 1(#$!;"5$< *)#(4G$"(;( +"*"!, ! :($%4* (1"(#$(&(""% @&(.$! @5$< ($ 15:* / @&!&(1%» (294, #. 12). R* E$(8 @5$! ("* :($, ! )64* ()&*F%"* / @(+"*"!G @&!&(16, "( #*8( E$( @(+"*"!% (#5F%#$'4,4* #5;5)( A!4(#(A#/!8! #&%1#$'*8!, @5$%8 58(+&%"!,, @&(!+'(4<"6: *)#$&*/$"6: 4(;!>%#/!: /("#$&5/2!.. J*/, @( 8"%"!G H.H. %>"!/('*, «($6#/!'*, *)#(4G$"5G !#$!"5 ! 5"!'%&#*4<"6% @(#$&(%"!,, !+ /($(&6: )6 8(?"( )64( '6'%#$! '%#< &%*4<"6. 8!&, "*$5&A!4(#(A6 @&!1586'*4! #*86% @&(!+'(4<"6% @&!"2!@6 ! @&('(1!4! #*86% #45>*."6% *"*4(;!!… J*/(;( &(1* @(#$&(%"!, #>!$*4!#< "*$5&A!4(#(A*8! !#$!""68 @(+"*"!%8, ()4*1*"!% /($(&68 1*'*4( !8, @( !: 8"%"!G, @&*'( #'6#(/* #8($&%$< "* A*/$6 ! "* A*/$!>%#/(% !+5>%"!% @&!&(16» (268, #. 61–62). B(",$"(, >$( $*/(. "*$5&A!4(#(A#/!. ()&*+ A!4(#(A!! 1!#/&%1!$!&('*4 %% ' ;4*+*: 5>%"6:, ($'&*F*4 !: ($ '#,/!: /("$*/$(' # "%.. U*&*/$%&"( ' E$(8 ($"(7%"!! @&!+"*"!% =%//%4,, @!#*'7%;(, >$( «8"(;(>!#4%""6% (7!)/! @&%?"%. #@%/54,$!'"(. A!4(#(A!! @%&'(. $&%$! XIX '%/* ' +"*>!$%4<"(. #$%@%"! 5&("!4! '#G A!4(#(A!G ' ;4*+*: $(>"6: E8@!&!/('–%#$%#$'%""!/('; ! '($ $*/!8-$( ()&*+(8 '(+"!/4( 51!'!$%4<"(% #$&%84%"!% @(#$&(!$< '#% +1*"!% %#$%#$'('%1%"!, !+ @&(#$6: A*/$(', )%+ '#,/(;( A!4(#(A#/(;( ()I,#"%"!, !:, !+ @&(#$6: +"*"!., )%+ '#,/(;( !#$!""(;( @("!8*"!, !: #86#4*». =%//%4< #>!$*4 ' #',+! # E$!8, >$( «>!#$( #@%/54,$!'"(% *)#(4G$"( A!4(#(A#/(% @(#$&(%"!%, "% (@!&*GF%%#, "* "%():(1!85G (#"('5 !+ (@6$"6: 1*""6:, ,'4,%$#, '(+157"68 +*8/(8, /($(&6. &*+4%$*%$#, ' @&*: @&! @%&'(8 #$(4/"('%"!! # (@6$(8; (#()%""( 8"(;( @&%1#$*'!$%4%. $*/(;( "*@&*'4%"!, ' =%&8*"!! ("*@&., T%44!"; ! =%;%4<)» (90, #. 357–358). B( 8"%"!G =%4<8;(4<2*, «"%!+)%?"6% "* E$(8 @5$! &*+(>*&('*"!, ! (7!)/! "* "%/($(&(% '&%8, @(1(&'*4! &%@5$*2!G A!4(#(A!!. R( E$( )64* 5?% /&*."(#$<» (113, #. 67). C6&*?%"!%8 $*/(. /&*."(#$! ,'!4(#< @&($!'(@(#$*'4%"!% 5>]"68! A!4(#(A#/(;( ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, &*##8($&%"!% $(;( ! 1&5;(;( /*/ @(4,&"6: @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$%.: 58(+&!$%4<"(#$< A!4(#(A!! !#/4G>*4*#< (@6$"68 :*&*/$%&(8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!,. L$( (@&%1%4!4( ! !: /("%>"5G #51<)5. «0!4(#(A#/(% "*@&*'4%"!%, – @!#*4 H. . P%>%"(', – 5'%">*4(#< ! '8%#$% # $%8 +*/(">!4(#< ()F%!+'%#$"(. ;%&8*"#/(. "*$5&A!4(#(A!%., *
159
(@6$"(% @&(1(4?*%$#, ! 1(#%4%. R*$5&A!4(#(A!, @( #'(%85 +"*>%"!G 14, ?!+"! >%4('%>%#$'* %1'* 4! @&%'67*%$ )&%1 )(4<"(;(, 1*'"( 5?% +*)6$6. '#%8!, * (@6$"(% %#$%#$'(+"*"!%, '&6'*,#< ' ?!+"< ! ()5#4('4!'*, >*#$( #*86% A(&86 %], @&%1#$*'4,%$ ' $( ?% '&%8, ,&/5G /*&$!"5 @(#$%@%""(;( &*#7!&%"!, ! 5;45)4%"!, "*7!: #'%1%"!. ( '"%7"%8 8!&%» (335, #. 279). W#$%#$'(+"*"!% ' 1*""(8 #45>*% :($, ! @&($!'(@(#$*'4,%$#, A!4(#(A!!, "( A*/$!>%#/! &%>< !1]$ 4!7< () !1%*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!!. H E$( "% #45>*."(. H8%""( ' (7!)/*: !1%*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!!, @(&(?1*'7!: "%@&!8!&!86% @&($!'(&%>!, 8%?15 "%G ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8, #(#$(,4* (1"* !+ ;4*'"6: @&!>!" ($#$&*"%"!, 5>]"6: ($ A!4(#(A!!, !: (:4*?1%"!, / "%.. J*/, =%//%4< @&!>!"(. &*+&6'* 8%?15 %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8 ! A!4(#(A!%. ' @%&'(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/* #>!$*4 «A*"$*#$!>%#/!% '6:(1/! @&%?"!: "%8%2/!: "*$5&A!4(#(A(' 3/%"*, T%44!";* ! 1&., /($(&6% #>!$*4! '(+8(?"68 !+ #'(%. ;(4('6 '6'(1!$< +*/("6 @&!&(16, ($'%&;*, "%():(1!8(#$< (@!&*$<#, "* @(>'5 A*/$!>%#/(;( (@6$*. M(;1* E$! @&%$%"+!! '6#$5@!4! '( '#%. #'(%. @5#$($%, $( "*$5&*4!#$6, !8%"5%86% «86#4,F!8 "*&(1(8», ()&*$!4!#< ' "%>$( @&,8( @&($!'(@(4(?"(%, 158*,, >$( '6#7*, 2%4< "*5/!, @(+"*"!% !#$!"6, 8(?%$ )6$< 1(#$!;"5$( !#/4G>!$%4<"( @5$]8 ;(4(;( >5'#$'%""(;( (@6$* )%+ 8*4%.7%. &*)($6 A!4(#(A#/(. 86#4!» (89, #. 64– 65). B( 8"%"!G =%4<8;(4<2*, ' @%&'(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/* «8%?15 A!4(#(A!%. ! %#$%#$'%""68! "*5/*8!, @(1 '4!,"!%8 7%44!";(– ;%;%4%'#/(. A!4(#(A!! $(?1%#$'*, #4(?!4!#< 8*4( ($&*1"6% ($"(7%"!,. B&!>!"* 4%?*4*, ;4*'"68 ()&*+(8, ' ;45)(/(. @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$! 8%$(1(', '+*!8"( (#@*&!'*'7!: @&*'( "* #5F%#$'('*"!%» (113, #.–67). R( $( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, >$( 5>]"6% #$&%8!4!#< 5.$! ($ &%7%"!, '(@&(#(' A!4(#(A#/(;( :*&*/$%&*, ($#$&*",4!#< ($ A!4(#(A!! /*/ "*5/!, /&!$!/('*4! %], ($"G1< "% (+"*>*4( !: @(4"(;( (#'()(?1%"!, ($ A!4(#(A!!. D!7< ' #'(]8 @&%1#$*'4%"!! 5>]"6% (#'()(?1*4!#< ($ "%], ' 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! ?% ("! (/*+6'*4!#< ' @4%"5 :517!: %] ()&*+2('. L";%4<# @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «W#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! '(()&*?*G$, >$( ("! (#'()(?1*G$#, ($ A!4(#(A!!, /(;1* !;"(&!&5G$ !4! )&*",$ %]. R( $*/ /*/ ("! )%+ 8674%"!, "% 8(;5$ 1'!"5$<#, "! "* 7*;, 14, 8674%"!, ?% "%():(1!86 4(;!>%#/!% /*$%;(&!!, * E$! /*$%;(&!! ("! "%/&!$!>%#/! +*!8#$'5G$ 4!)( ($ ()61%""(;( ()F%;( #(+"*"!, $*/ "*+6'*%86: ()&*+('*""6: 4G1%., "*1 /($(&68 ;(#@(1#$'5G$ (#$*$/! 1*'"( 58%&7!: A!4(#(A#/!: #!#$%8, 4!)( !+ /&(: @&(#457*""6: ' (),+*$%4<"(8 @(&,1/% 5"!'%&#!$%$#/!: /5&#(' @( A!4(#(A!!.., 4!)( !+ "%/&!$!>%#/(;( ! "%#!#$%8*$!>%#/(;( >$%"!, '#,/(;( &(1* A!4(#(A#/!: @&(!+'%1%"!., – $( ' !$(;% ("! '#]-$*/! (/*+6'*G$#, ' @(1>!"%"!! 5 A!4(#(A!!, "(, / #(?*4%"!G, @( )(4<7%. >*#$! #*8(. #/'%&"(., ! $%, /$( )(4<7% '#%: &5;*G$ A!4(#(A!G, ,'4,G$#, &*)*8! /*/ &*+ "*!:517!: '54<;*&!+('*""6: (#$*$/(' "*!:517!: A!4(#(A#/!: 5>%"!.». 9 "* 1%4%, #>!$*4 L";%4<#, «/*/5G )6 @(+5 "! @&!"!8*4! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4!, "*1 "!8! '4*#$'5%$ A!4(#(A!,. C(@&(# 4!7< ' $(8, ?%4*G$ 4! ("!, >$()6 "*1
160
"!8! '4*#$'('*4* /*/*,-"!)51< #/'%&"*, 8(1"*, A!4(#(A!,, !4! ?% ("! ?%4*G$ &5/('(1#$'('*$<#, $*/(. A(&8(. $%(&%$!>%#/(;( 8674%"!,, /($(&*, (#"('6'*%$#, "* +"*/(8#$'% # !#$(&!%. 8674%"!, ! %] 1(#$!?%"!,8!» (406, #. 524–525). R( 1%4( $5$, /("%>"(, "% $(4]"6:, "( ! ' $%: ()I%/$!'"6: '(+8(?"(#$,: @&!()F%"!, / A!4(#(A!!, /($(&68! ("! &*#@(4*;*4!. 9 '(+8(?"(#$! E$! )64! >&%+'6>*."( (;&*"!>%""68! ' ()F%#$'%""6: 5#4('!,: $(;( '&%8%"!. J% ?% 5#4('!, @(&(?1*4! ' #&%1% 5>%"6: ! *"$!A!4(#(A#/!% "*#$&(%"!,. R( $*/(% @(4(?%"!% "% 8(;4( 1(4;( #(:&*",$<#,. 3$#$&*"%"!% %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ($ A!4(#(A!! )64( @*;5)"68 @&%?1% '#%;( 14, "%;( #*8(;(. B( #4('*8 L";%4<#*, «A!4(#(A!, 8#$!$ +* #%), +*1"!8 >!#4(8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!G +* $(, >$( @(#4%1"%% @(/!"54( %]» ($*8 ?%, #. 520). L$* «8%#$<» A!4(#(A!! @&(,'!4*#< ' @%&'5G (>%&%1< ' "%#@(#()"(#$! 8"(;!: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. / 4(;!>%#/(85, $%(&%$!>%#/(85 8674%"!G, >$( +*>*#$5G $(&8(+!4( '6,'4%"!% ! (#86#4%"!% #5F"(#$! !+5>*%86: !8! ()I%/$('. B(1>%&/!'*, E$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, L. =%//%4< @!#*4, >$( )4*;(1*&, «@%>*4<"(85 ($>5?1%"!G 1&5; ($ 1&5;* %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ! A!4(#(A!!, * $*/?% ;&5)(85 E8@!&!+85.., @(45>*%$#, 2%46. &,1 "%4%@(#$%., ;&5)6: 4(;!>%#/!: (7!)(/, ! @(4"*, "%#@(#()"(#$< 1%4*$< #*86% @&(#$6% 4(;!>%#/!% '6'(16 – /*/ &*+ !8%""( # E$!8 @&!:(1!$#, $%@%&< '#$&%>*$<#, ' +((4(;!! ! )($*"!/% /*?16. 1%"<. V1%#< "%@(#&%1#$'%""( #/*+6'*%$#, @&%"%)&%?%"!% A!4(#(A#/!8 ()&*+('*"!%8 ! "%@&!'6>"(#$< 58* / 4(;!>%#/(85 &*##5?1%"!G ! &%+54<$*$6 @(45>*G$#, @&%@4*>%'"6%» (90, c. 358). M*&1!"*4<"6% #1'!;! ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!! ' #%&%1!"% XIX '%/* ' /("2% /("2(' @&!'%4! / @%&%(2%"/% (#"(' "*5/!, / @%&%(#86#4%"!G 5>]"68! '+*!8(($"(7%"!, A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,. «O#@%:! ' ()4*#$! %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/, – @!#*4 Q(4<28*", – ' /(&"% @&%()&*+!4! 8674%"!% ! (F5F%"!, >%4('%/*» (35, #. 158). B&%()&*+('*"!% 8674%"!, /(#"54(#< ! ()F%;( 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/(;( #(1%&?*"!, ! "*@&*'4%"!, "*5>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! 5>]"6:. R*/(@4%"!% %1!"!>"6: A*/$(' 5?% "% /*+*4(#< !8 %1!"#$'%""( @(4%+"68 ! "%():(1!868 ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!!. 3"! '#] ($>]$4!'%% (#(+"*'*4! "%():(1!8(#$< ' "*@&*'4,GF!: (#"('(@(4(?%"!,:, A!4(#(A#/!: @( #(1%&?*"!G, @(+'(4,GF!: (&!%"$!&('*$<#, ' %1!"!>"6: A*/$*:. -. *.%&, "*@&!8%&, @!#*4 () E$(8 $*/: «M("%>"(, %#4! )6 86 !8%4! 1%4( # @(@6$/(. @(#$&(%"!, 8!&* a priori, $( E$( 8(?"( )64( )6 "*+'*$< '(+'&*$(8 / (7!)/*8 *"$!>"(;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ! / +*)45?1%"!,8 #('&%8%""(. "*$5&A!4(#(A!!, (1"*/(, %#4! )6 51*4(#< #',+*$< 8%?15 #()(. )%#>!#4%""6% ,'4%"!, @&!&(16 ! !+ "!: '6'%#$! (1"( '%&:('"(% (#"('(@(4(?%"!%, %1'* 4! 8(?"( )64( )6 5@&%/"5$< "*# +* $(, >$( 86 @(#4% $F*$%4<"(. @&('%&/! '(#@(4<+('*4!#< )6 $*/!8 (#"('(@(4(?%"!%8 /*/ /(8@*#(8, @(1 "*1]?"68 &5/('(1#$'(8 /($(&(;( "*8 )64( )6 4%;>% @&(1'!;*$<#, ' 8(&% %1!"!>"6: A*/$('» (229, #. 90).
161
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«O#@%:! ()&*+('*"!, '(()F%, ! ' >*#$"(#$! "*5/, 1*?% E8@!&!>%#/!: "*5/ ! "*5/ ( >5'#$'%""( '(#@&!"!8*%8(8, ' ()F%8 1'!;*,#< ' &*8/*: #*86: ()6>"6: /*$%;(&!..., @(#$%@%""( '61'!;*G$ ! )(4%% '6#(/!% ($"(7%"!, 86#4! !4! @( /&*."%. 8%&% @(1"!8*G$ !: 1( )(4<7%. '#%()F"(#$! ! $%8 #*868 +*#$*'4,G$ ()&*F*$< "* "!: )(4<7% '"!8*"!,»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– 86#4<, '6#/*+*""*, ' #'(] '&%8, =%;%4%8: «H#$!""(% %#$< 2%4(%» (81, #. 10). H /*/ )6 /("/&%$!+!&5, E$5 86#4< @&!8%"!$%4<"( / %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(85 @(+"*"!G, =%4<8;(4<2 @!#*4 @(+1"%%: « 6 "% 8(?%8 "% #(+"*$<#,, >$( >%8 )(4%% ($1%4<"6. !##4%1('*$%4< @&!"5?1]" #5?!'*$< @(4% #'(%. &*)($6, $%8 )(4%% >5'#$'5%$ (" '"5$&%""GG @($&%)"(#$< #(:&*"!$< %] #',+< # 2%468» (108, #. 44). R%():(1!8(#$< $*/(;( '+;4,1* "* 2%4(%, %;( (#()5G +"*>!8(#$<, 2%""(#$< 14, "*5/! ($8%$!4 ! Q(4<28*": «R* @%&'6. '+;4,1 /*?%$#,, >$( %#$%#$'(+"*"!% #('%&7%""( $%&,%$ !+ '!15 '%4!/!% @&()4%86 ()F%;( :*&*/$%&*. R( $%8 '%4!/(4%@"%% 5#@%:, /(;1*, # $&51(8 @&()!'*,#< ' ;5#$(. >*F% #@%2!*4<"6: '(@&(#(', 86 '1&5; "*:(1!8 "%)(4<7(. @&(#'%$, #/'(+< /($(&6. ($/&6'*%$#, "%(?!1*""6. '!1 "* '#] 2%4(%» (35, #. 4). =%//%4<, ($8%$!' 5#!4!'75G#, ' #&%1% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. @($&%)"(#$< ' ,#"(8 ! 2%4<"(8 8!&('(++&%"!!, @(1>%&/"54, >$( «#(#$*'!$< #%)% $*/('(% 1%"< ($( 1", 1%4*%$#, '#] $&51"%%, )4*;(1*&, !+58!$%4<"(85 &(#$5 #@%2!*4<"6: ($&*#4%. E8@!&!>%#/(;( !##4%1('*"!, ! #',+*""(85 # "!8 /&*."% 8%4(>"(85 &*+1%4%"!G $&51* @( ($1%4<"68 ()4*#$,8 "*5/!. N%8 )(4<7% 86#4,F!. "*)4G1*$%4< $%&,%$#, @%&%1 "%()(+&!8(. 8*##(. 8%4/!: >*#$"(#$%., $%8 (#$&%% !#@6$6'*%$ ("
162
@($&%)"(#$< ' '6&*)($/% ()F%;( '+;4,1* "* '#G ()4*#$< @(+"*"!,» (95, #. 436). § 2. S523RJ=9 B=8252CC8DE=9 D4FD4F52=4>KF;FD3DG: >25282F < A=3242A== R%():(1!8(#$< ' A!4(#(A!! ()F%8 '+;4,1%, '( '+;4,1% "* 2%4(% @()5?1*4* 86#4,F!: ! "*!)(4%% 1*4<"('!1"6: 5>]"6: ()&*F*$<#, / A!4(#(A!!, @("5?1*4* !: !#/*$< ' "%. (1"( !+ '*?"%.7!: #&%1#$' @&%(1(4%"!, (;&*"!>%""(#$! ! (1"(#$(&(""(#$! @(+"*"!,, ()5#4('4%""6: 5+/(. #@%2!*4!+*2!%.. =%//%4< ' E$(. #',+! @!#*4, >$( «>!#$(% #$&%84%"!% / @(+"*"!G 5 >%4('%/* )51%$ $%8 #!4<"%% ()&*F*$<#, / #!"$%$!>%#/(. #@%/54,2!! ! / (@6$*8 A!4(#(A#/(. #!#$%86, >%8 #!4<"%% )51%$ "*/(@4,$<#, @(1*'4,GF!. :*(# )%#>!#4%""6: ($1%4<"6: E8@!&!>%#/!: +"*"!.» (89, #. 65). C E'(4G2!! 8!&('(++&%"!, 5>]"6:, $*/!8 ()&*+(8, #"('* "*8%$!4#, A!4(#(A#/!. @('(&($. R( %#4! @%&%1 E$!8 @('(&($ )64 ($ A!4(#(A!!, $( $%@%&<, "*()(&($, – / A!4(#(A!!, @('(&($, ()5#4('4%""6. #5F%#$'%""68! #1'!;*8! ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!!. J*/, ' )!(4(;!! E$($ A!4(#(A#/!. @('(&($ )64 #',+*" ' @%&'5G (>%&%1< # @()%1(. 5>%"!, K*&'!"*. B( 8"%"!G =%//%4,, @(#4% @%&!(1* ($>5?1%"!, %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ! A!4(#(A!! (1830–1660 ;;.) "*#$5@!4 «'$(&(. A!4(#(A#/!. @('(&($, '6+'*""6. @&(!+'%1%"!%8 K*&'!"*. C @(#4%1"!% #(&(/ 4%$ #"('* '(+"!/*%$ #$&%84%"!% / @(+"*"!G ()F!: +*/("(' @&!&(16, 14, /($(&6: '#% (@6$"6% +"*"!, #45?*$ 4!7< (#"('*"!%8 ! @&! @(8(F! /($(&6: E$! @(#4%1"!% @(45>*G$ #'(] !#$!""(% +"*>%"!%. Q4*;(1*&, $(4]"68!–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8! "%():(1!8(#$! #)4!?%"!, A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, @(4"(#$%#/(. A!4(#(A!! $(;( '&%8%"!, ( >]8 #'!1%$%4<#$'5%$, "*@&!8%&, #4%15GF%% '6#/*+6'*"!% D. 0%.%&)*:*: «0!4(#(A!, 1(4?"* '"('< #',+*$<#, # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8, * %#$%#$'(+"*"!% – # A!4(#(A!%.. L$* '+*!8"*, @($&%)"(#$<, E$* #',+<, /(&%",F*,#, '( '"5$&%""%. "%():(1!8(#$!, )51%$ @&(1(4?!$%4<"%%, #>*#$4!'%% ! @4(1($'(&"%% @( #&*'"%"!G # 8%+*4<,"#(8 8%?15 A!4(#(A!%. ! $%(4(;!%., #5F%#$'('*'7!8 1( #!: @(&» (369, #. 132). B('(&($ %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. / A!4(#(A!! #$*4 '(+8(?%" "* (#"('% @&!+"*"!, !8! %] "%():(1!8(#$! /*/ (1"(;( !+ '*?"%.7!:, (),+*$%4<"6: '( '#% '&%8%"* @5$%. "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, 8!&*, "* (#"('% @&!+"*"!, !#/4G>!$%4<"(. +"*>!8(#$! '/4*1*, #1%4*""(;( A!4(#(A!%. ' &*+'!$!% @(+"*"!,, ' 1(#$!?%"!% !8 @(4(?!$%4<"6: &%+54<$*$('. B(1>%&/!'*, E$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, =%//%4< @!#*4: «W#4! #&*'"!$< '*?"%.7!% 5#@%:! >%4('%>%#/(;( 58* ' @(+"*"!! !#$!"6, $( $($>*# (/*?%$#,, >$( /*?16. &*+
163
#('%&7*4*#< &*)($* A!4(#(A#/(. 86#4!, )4*;(1*&, /($(&(. 1(#$!;"5$6 E$! 5#@%:!» (89, #. 65). V1%#< ($>]$4!'( @&(#$5@*%$ @&!"2!@!*4<"(% ($4!>!% ($"(7%"!, / A!4(#(A!! '61*GF!:#, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ($ @(+!$!'!#$#/(;( @("!8*"!, %] 8%#$* ' &*+'!$!! >%4('%>%#/(;( @(+"*"!,. K4, @(+!$!'!+8*, /*/ 5?% ($8%>*4(#<, A!4(#(A#/(% @(+"*"!% – 4!7< #$5@%"< ' &*+'!$!! '#%;( @(+"*"!,, @%&%:(1"6. E$*@ ($ %;( $%(4(;!>%#/(. #$*1!! / )%#A!4(#(A#/(. "*5>"(., «@(4(?!$%4<"(. !4! &%*4<"(.» #$*1!!. H "*+"*>%"!% A!4(#(A!! @&! E$(8 (#5F%#$'4,$< 4!7< «/&!$!>%#/5G !4! &*+&57!$%4<"5G» @( ($"(7%"!G / @&%17%#$'5GF%., $%(4(;!>%#/(., #$*1!! 1%,$%4<"(#$< ! ' E$(8 +*/4G>*%$#,, @( 8"%"!G M("$*, «%] ;4*'"*, '&%8%""*, @(4%+"(#$< 14, $(;( 8(8%"$*, /(;1* #$*&6. ()&*+ 8674%"!,, 1(4;(% '&%8, @&(;&%##!'"6. 14, #('(/5@"(#$! >%4('%>%#/(. E'(4G2!!, "%!+)%?"( 1(#$!;*%$ $(. #$5@%"!, "* /($(&(. 1*4<"%.7%% %;( #5F%#$'('*"!% (/*+6'*%$#, '&%1"68» (177, #. 15). K4, 5>]"6:, "*@&($!', ' A!4(#(A!! '*?"* !8%""( %] #(+!1*$%4<"*, #$(&("*, @(45>%"!% %G "('(;( +"*"!, "* @5$! @&("!/"('%"!, ' "*!)(4%% ;45)!""6%, "%1(#$5@"6% 14, E8@!&!>%#/!: #&%1#$' ()4*#$! 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!. K.H. %"1%4%%' ($8%>*4 ' #',+! # E$!8, >$( «A!4(#(A#/(85 8!&('(++&%"!G «"*!)(4%% ($'%>*%$ #$&%84%"!% ($6#/*$< #(/&6$5G ($ ;4*+ %1!"5G #5F"(#$<» (260, #. 567). B( 8"%"!G =%//%4,, ' "*5>"(8 @(+"*"!! )(4<75G &(4< !;&*G$ 5#@%:! «$(;( '6#7%;( +"*"!, @&!>!""(. #',+! '#%: ($1%4<"6: ,'4%"!., /($(&(% 86 ()(+"*>*%8 #4('(8 A!4(#(A!,» (95, #. 62). P(+!1*$%4<"(% "*>*4( ' A!4(#(A!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! '!1%4! ! ' %] #(1%.#$'!! 1%45 #$*"('4%"!, ! #('%&7%"#$'('*"!, "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, $(>"(;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( +"*"!, – ' $(8 "%@&%:(1,F%8 ' "%., >$( $(4%#/(. A!4(#(A!! 1*4 */#'%44: «C #*86% ($1*4]""6% '&%8%"* 1&%'"!% A!4(#(A6, 58(+&%"!, /($(&6: 1(74! 1( "*#, +*"!8*4!#< &*##8($&%"!%8 !1%. >!#4* ! "%@&%&6'"(. '%4!>!"6, @&(#$&*"#$'* ! '&%8%"!, 8*$%&!! ! 1'!?%"!, # #*8()6$"(. #!4(. 86#4!, /($(&5G, /*?%$#,, "!/(;1* "% 51*4(#< @&%'+(.$!» (231, #. 122). R( "% $(4%#/(. A!4(#(A!! @&!'4%/*4* / "%. '"!8*"!% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/*. C !: '+;4,1*: ' $(. !4! !"(. 8%&% "*:(1!4! ($&*?%"!% ! "%/($(&6% @(+!$!'"6% &%7%"!, 1&%'"%;&%>%#/(. A!4(#(A!!. J*/, */#'%44, /*#*,#< +*#45; 1&%'"%;&%>%#/!: A!4(#(A(' K%8(/&!$* ! 9"*/#*;(&* ' 1%4% #$*"('4%"!, *$(8!#$!/!, ($8%>*4, >$( «'(@&(# ( #5F%#$'('*"!! !4! "%#5F%#$'('*"!! *$(8(' "%4<+, @&%1#$*'!$<… #%;(1", # )(4<7%. ,#"(#$%8 (" 1*" ' $%(&!,: E$!: 1'5: A!4(#(A('» ($*8 ?%, #. 72). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, ! +1%#< !8%%$ 8%#$( #5F%#$'%""(% &*#:(?1%"!% '(++&%"!. 5>]"6: # @(+!$!'!+8(8, #(;4*#"( /($(&(85 @(@6$/! 1&%'"!:
164
86#4!$%4%. &%7*$< /*&1!"*4<"6% @&()4%86 )6$!,, A!4(#(A#/!% @5$! ! #&%1#$'* !: &%7%"!, – 4!7< @&(,'4%"!, "%+&%4(#$! >%4('%>%#/(;( 58*, %;( 84*1%">%#/(;( #(#$(,"!,. J*/, M("$, :*&*/$%&!+5, @(+"*"!% 1&%'"!: 86#4!$%4%., @!#*4: «C #!45 /("$&*#$*, /($(&6. ' "*7% '&%8, 1(4?%" # @%&'(;( '+;4,1* /*+*$<#, "%()I,#"!868, "( /($(&6., ' 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!, )64 $(;1* ' @(4"(. ;*&8("!! # !#$!""( 84*1%">%#/!8 #(#$(,"!%8 "*7%;( 58*, >%4('%>%#/!. &*+58 ' $( '&%8,, /(;1* (" %F] "% #@(#()%" &%7*$< @&(#$%.7!% "*5>"6% @&()4%86, ?*1"( ! @(>$! !#/4G>!$%4<"( !F%$ "*>*4* '#%: '%F%., #$&%8!$#, "*.$! 4!)( "*>*4<"6%, 4!)( /("%>"6%, (#"('"6% @&!>!"6 &*+4!>"6: @(&*?*GF!: %;( ,'4%"!. ! (#"('"(. #@(#() !: '(+"!/"('%"!,, – #4('(8, #$&%8!$#, / *)#(4G$"(85 +"*"!G» (177, #. 10). C @&%1#$*'4%"!! M("$*, @($&%)"(#$< ' $*/(8 +"*"!! – «@&!8!$!'"*, @($&%)"(#$<». K4, "%;( "%@&!%84%8* «'&(?1]""*, #/4(""(#$< >%4('%>%#/(;( &*+58* / "%&*+&%7!868 '(@&(#*8, /($(&68! @&%!85F%#$'%""( +*"!8*4*#< E$* @%&'()6$"*, A!4(#(A!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 13). H %#4!, # $(>/! +&%"!, @(+!$!'!+8*, E$! '(+"!/7!% ' 1&%'"(#$! ! #$*'7!% $&*1!2!(""68! 14, '#%. @(#4%15GF%. A!4(#(A!! «"%&*+&%7!86%» @&()4%86 1(4?"6 )6$< ($'%&;"5$6, 5#$&*"%"6 ' XIX '%/%, ' 5#4('!,: &*#2'%$* /("/&%$"6: "*5/, $( 14, '61*GF!:#, 5>%"6:, @&%1#$*'4,GF!: E$! "*5/!, ! "* #('&%8%""(8 14, "!: 5&('"% @(+"*"!, $&*1!2!(""6% A!4(#(A#/!% @&()4%86 #(:&*",G$ #'(G 2%""(#$< 14, !##4%1('*$%4%. $'(&>%#/(;( #/4*1*, 14, #8%46: 58('. J*/('(, "*@&!8%&, 8"%"!% (1"(;( !+ #*86: #8%46: 58(' XIX '%/* – */#'%44*, #>!$*'7%;(, >$( ! ' %;( '&%8, «"%$ (#"('*"!. (@*#*$<#, @&%/&*F%"!, ()#5?1%"!, /*$%;(&!. )6$!,, ! #@%/54,$!'"6% 5@&*?"%"!, $*/ ?% @&(1(4?*G$ 5'4%/*$< #8%46% 586, /*/ 5'4%/*4! !: %F% ' 1"! 0*4%#*» (231, #. 36). M("%>"(, 5>]"6% )64! 1*4%/! ($ $(;(, >$()6 !1%*4!+!&('*$< !+'%#$"5G !8 A!4(#(A!G. 3"! 5#8*$&!'*4! ' "%. ! (@&%1%4]""6% "%#('%&7%"#$'*, '!1%4! "% $(4!$*4! %;( 58(+&!$%4<"(#$<, @&($!'(&%>!'(#$< ' @(#$*"('/% ! &%7%"!! '(@&(#(', !: "*&(>!$5G 5#4(?"]""(#$< ! 1&. K*4<"%.7!. @&(;&%## A!4(#(A!!, *, #4%1('*$%4<"(, ! '(+&*#$*"!% %] &(4! 5>]"6% #',+6'*4! # 5#$&*"%"!%8 E$!: "%1(#$*$/('. H %#4!, #>!$*4, "*@&!8%&, Q(4<28*", A!4(#(A!! 51*#$#, @(#$&(!$< #!#$%85, ' /($(&(. ,#"( '6#$*'!$< "%()(#"('*""(#$< @(#$*"('/! "*+'*""6: '(@&(#(' «! $%8 #*868 51*#$#, @(1*'!$< @&!'6>"(% #$&%84%"!% / &*+&%7%"!G @(1()"6: '(@&(#(', $( ("* (1"!8 51*&(8 &*+&%7!$ #*86% $]8"6% +*;*1/!, ! A!4(#(A!, )51%$ 1(#$(."* "*+'*"!, 2*&!26 "*5/» (35, #. 173). C61*GF!%#, 5>]"6%-%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* "% $(4*#$! '#%;( "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, "( ! &*##8*$&!'*4! %;( ' (@&%1%4]""(. #',+! # @&%1#$*'4,%868! !8! %#$%#$'%""68! "*5/*8!. L$($ '(@&(# )64 !8 (#()%""( )4!+(/, ! ' %;(
165
&%7%"!! ("! 58%4! !+)%;*$< (1"(#$(&(""(#$!, (;&*"!>%""(#$!, @&!#5F%. 5+/!8 #@%2!*4!#$*8–E8@!&!/*8. 3) E$(8 /&*#"(&%>!'( #'!1%$%4<#$'5%$ $($ A*/$, >$( 5>]"6% '6#$5@*4! @&($!' *)#(4G$!+*2!! /*/ A!4(#(A#/(;(, $*/ ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, ' !: !+(4!&('*""(#$! 1&5; ($ 1&5;*. (?"( #(#4*$<#, ' #',+! # E$!8 "* =%//%4,, @!#*'7%;(, >$( «(1"(#$(&(""%% @&%5'%4!>%"!% &(4! (@6$* ,'4,%$#, #$(4< ?% (@*#"(. (7!)/(., /*/ ! @&($!'(@(4(?"*, @&%5'%4!>%""*, (2%"/* 58(+&%"!,. 3)* @(+"*'*$%4<"6% 8%$(1* "%():(1!86 1&5; 1&5;5. C%4!>*.7!% $&!58A6 #('&%8%""(;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!,… #5$< A!4(#(A#/!% A*/$6, * "% '6'(16 >!#$(;( 58(+&%"!,»(95, #. 82). H$*/, # (1"(. #$(&("6, 5>]"6% @("!8*4! '#G "%1(#$*$(>"(#$< !#/4G>!$%4<"( A!4(#(A#/(;( @(1:(1* / @(+"*"!G 8!&*. R%@(#&%1#$'%""(%, (@6$"(% !##4%1('*"!% /("/&%$"6: @&%18%$(' ! ,'4%"!. #@%2!A!>%#/!8! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"68! #&%1#$'*8! ! 8%$(1*8! – 1&5;(. '*?"%.7!. @5$< @(+"*"!,. H A!4(#(A!,, %#4! ("* !8%%$ #'(%. 2%4%"!% @(4(?!$%4<"6: &%+54<$*$(' ' @(+"*"!! 8!&*, 1(4?"* (@!&*$<#, ! "* 1(#$!?%"!, %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/. H"*>%, /*/ ($8%>*4 =%//%4<, «A!4(#(A, 4!7%""6. "%+6)4%8(;( (#"('*"!, >5'#$'%""(;( (@6$*, E8@!&!>%#/(;( +"*"!,, ' #'(]8 ()F%8 58(+&%"!! 4%;/( '@*1*%$ ' +*)45?1%"!%»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«N!#$6% E8@!&!>%#/!% "*$5&*4!#$6, – @!#*4 =%//%4<, – "% +*)($,#< ( A!4(#(A#/(8 ()I%1!"%"!! #'(!: >5'#$'%""6: "*)4G1%"!. ! "% #$&%8,#< / ()F%85 @(+"*"!G, 4!7< ' "!>$(?"(. 8%&% #(1%.#$'5G$ 5#@%:*8 "*5/!; ;4*'"*, #$(!8(#$< /&(@($4!'( #()&*""6: >*#$"6: #'%1%"!. +*/4G>*%$#, ' ()F!: &%+54<$*$*:, /($(&6% @(+?% !+ "!: )515$ '6'%1%"6 '61*GF!8!#, 58*8!» ($*8 ?%, #. 65–66). Q%+ $*/(;( 2%8%"$!&5GF%;( '(+1%.#$'!, A!4(#(A!! 1*""6%, @(45>%""6% "* @5$! E8@!&!>%#/(;( @(+"*"!,, 5$&*>!'*G$ '#,/5G @(4(?!$%4<"5G +"*>!8(#$<. V1*"!% "*5/!, «@(#$&(%""(% "* (1"!: A*/$*:, (/*+6'*%$#, "%4%@(. ;&51(. /*8"%., /($(&*, "!/(;1* "% #58%%$ +*#45?!$< "*+'*"!, "*#$(,F%. @(#$&(./!… =(46% A*/$6, @(45>%""6% "* (#"('*"!! (@6$*, '#%;1* ,'4,G$#, $(4*8!, ! )%+ A!4(#(A#/(;( #2%@4%"!, !: ' (1"( #$&(."(% 2%4(% "%4<+, @(#$&(!$< "! (1"(. "*5/!».
166
R%+6)4%8(% +1*"!% %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, #>!$*4 =%//%4<, «8(?%$ )6$< @(#$&(%"( 4!7< @5$]8 $%#"%.7%;( '+*!8(1%.#$'!, 8%?15 E8@!&!+8(8 ! A!4(#(A!%.» (90, #. 358). 0!4(#(A!, "%():(1!8* %#$%#$'%""68 "*5/*8, @( 8"%"!G 5>]"6:, ! 14, #('%&7%"#$'('*"!, %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, @5$]8 !##4%1('*"!, %;( 8%$(1(', 14, (#5F%#$'4%"!, %;( 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/(;( *"*4!+*. J*/, =. =%4<8;(4<2 !8%""( ' E$(8 '!1%4 "*+"*>%"!% A!4(#(A!! ' %] ($"(7%"!! / %#$%#$'(+"*"!G. 3" @!#*4, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( «' ()4*#$! /&!$!/! 8%$(1(' A!4(#(A!, @&*'(8(>"* ! ' %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/*:: '%1< 1(4?"6 ?% 86 !##4%1('*$< (&51!,, /($(&68! &*)($*%8» (113, #. 68). R%():(1!8(#$< ' A!4(#(A#/(8 !+5>%"!! 8%$(1(' (#()%""( '%4!/* ' +*$&51"!$%4<"6: #45>*,:. «M&!$!/(. 8%$(1(' 8(?"( @&%"%)&%;*$< 4!7< 1( $%: @(&, @(/* '(+8(?"( (;&*"!>!'*$<#, @&!8%"%"!%8 8%$(1(', 5?% "* 1%4% 1(/*+*'7!: #'(G @&*'!4<"(#$<. R( /(;1* !##4%1('*"!% 1(:(1!$ 1( $(. ;&*"!, ;1% #$*"('!$#, #(8"!$%4<"68, #4%15%$ 4! @&!@!#*$< '#$&%>*GF!%#, $&51"(#$! #*8(85 @&%18%$5 !4! "%51('4%$'(&!$%4<"(#$! 8%$(1*, $(;1* $*/*, /&!$!/* 1(4?"* '#$5@!$< ' #'(! @&*'*». B&! E$(8 )6'*%$ 8*4( @(4<+6 ($ E@!+(1!>%#/!:, #45>*."6: !##4%1('*"!.. 3),+*$%4<"68 5#4('!%8 !: 5#@%7"(#$! ,'4,%$#, !: @(#$(,""(%, #!#$%8*$!>%#/(% (#5F%#$'4%"!%. «-*##8($&%"!% ($1%4<"6: &*+&(+"%""6: @5"/$(' @&!"(#!$ 8*4( @(4<+6, "%():(1!8( 1%.#$'('*$< #!#$%8*$!>%#/!, !##4%1('*$< ! "*>*$< @(#$&(./5 # #*8(;( (#"('*"!,» ($*8 ?%). P*8 =%4<8;(4<2, "% (;&*"!>!'*,#< 1%/4*&*$!'"68! +*,'4%"!,8!, ' #$*$<% «0!4(#(A!, ! %#$%#$'%""6% "*5/!», @&%1#$*'4,GF%. #()(. ''%1%"!% / /5 $%(&%$!>%#/(. A!+!/!, ()&*F*%$#, / «)4!?*.7%85 !+4(?%"!G 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/!: @&!"2!@('». 3", ' >*#$"(#$!, &*##8*$&!'*%$ '(@&(# ( 4(;!/%, @(1&*+58%'*, @(1 "%. 4(;!/5 A(&8*4<"5G. =%4<8;(4<2 ($8%>*%$ "%():(1!8(#$< &*##8($&%"!, 4(;!>%#/!: @&!"2!@(': «B&! #!#$%8*$!>%#/(8 !+4(?%"!! &*+4!>"6: "*5/ ()6>"( "% @&!",$( ':(1!$< @(1&()"( ' &*##8($&%"!% 4(;!>%#/!: @&!"2!@(' 4%?*F!: ' (#"('% @&%1@&!"!8*%86: !##4%1('*"!., "( /*/ &*+ ' A!+!/% E$( 1( !+'%#$"(. #$%@%"! "%():(1!8(» ($*8 ?%, #. 70). 3" '6,'4,%$ &*+4!>!% 58#$'%""6: (@%&*2!., (#5F%#$'4,GF!:#, ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!! ! ' A(&8*4<"(. 4(;!/%: «C( '#%. 2%@! 4(;!>%#/!: (@%&*2!. 86 '('#% "% !8%%8 1%4* # ()&*+('*"!%8 "('6: !#$!"; ' @(4"5G @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$< E$(85, ' %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/*: "*8 @&!:(1!$#, @&!()&%$*$< +"*"!,, 1( E$(;( %F] "% 1()6$6%… H8%""( $*/(;( &(1* &*"%% "%!+'%#$"6% @(4(?%"!, ()&*+5G$ ;4*'"5G >*#$< "*5/! ( @&!&(1% ! %] #*86. #5F%#$'%""6. E4%8%"$. B(E$(85 ! 58#$'%""6% (@%&*2!!, /*/!% "*8 @&!:(1!$#, @&!8%",$< @&! &*##5?1%"!,: ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, ()"*&5?!'*G$ !+'%#$"(% /(&%""(% ($4!>!% ($ 58#$'%""6: (@%&*2!., @&!8%",'7!:#, 1( #!: @(& ' 4(;!/% @( ($"(7%"!G / @%&%7%17!8 / "*8 ($ @&(74(;( +"*"!,8». H, "*/("%2, =%4<8;(4<2 &*#/&6'*%$ :*&*/$%& «4(;!>%#/(. &*)($6, /*/5G "*8 @&%1#$(!$ '6@(4",$< @&! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6:, A!+!>%#/!: !##4%1('*"!,:» ($*8 ?%, #. 71).
167
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«X #>!$*G ;4*'"(. +*1*>%. A!4(#(A!! – ,#"( @&%1#$*'!$< "%2%4%#(()&*+"(#$< E$!: "*7!: @&!'6>%/ 86#4!, )/*8!, * 2%4%#(()&*+"68 '6&*?%"!%8 1*""(;( A*/$*» (35, #. 172). B("!8*"!% '+*!8"(. "%():(1!8(#$! 1&5; 14, 1&5;* A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/ @&!'%4( 5>]"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. / (#(+"*"!G "%():(1!8(#$! $%#"(;( #(G+* A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, #*8* 86#4< ( /($(&(8 /*+*4*#< /(F5"#$'%""(. ' ;4*+*: (;&*"!>%""(;( E8@!&!/*. O#$*"('4%"!% E$(;( #(G+* @("!8*4(#< /*/ (),+*$%4<"(% 5#4('!% 1(#$!?%"!, !#$!"6 ' @(+"*"!! @&!&(16. J(, >$( A!4(#(A!, ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!% &*"<7% 1%4*4! @(&(+"<, $%@%&< ("! 1(4?"6 1%4*$< '8%#$%. J(4*% 8(?%$ )6$< ;*&*"$!&('*" 5#@%: !8 ()(!8. J*/('(, ' >*#$"(#$!, 8"%"!% =%//%4,: «J*/ /*/ ()* 4*;%&, (A!4(#(A!, ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!%. – C.3.) &*+4!>"68! @5$,8! #$&%8!4!#< / (1"(. '6#7%. 2%4!, $( ("! '#$&%$!4!#< "* ()F%. @(>'% ! #(%1!"]""68! 5#!4!,8! '#] )(4%% @&!)4!?*G$#, / @(+"*"!G !#$!"6» (95, #. 82). C 1'!?%"!! @(+"*"!, @&!&(16 / !#$!"% #@%2!*4<"6% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6%, E8@!&!>%#/!% 8%$(16 ! 8%$(16 A!4(#(A#/!%, ' @("!8*"!! 5>]"6:, '+*!8"( 1(@(4",G$ 1&5; 1&5;*, '"(#,$ (1!"*/('( '%#(86. '/4*1 ' 1(#$!?%"!% @(4(?!$%4<"6: &%+54<$*$(' @(+"*"!,. C 5#4('!,: "*&*#$*"!, #4(?"(#$!, 5'%4!>%"!, ()I]8* @(+"*'*%8(;( 8*$%&!*4*, 5;45)4%"!, +"*"!, #$*"('!$#, "%!+)%?"68 $*/(% #(%1!"%"!% A!4(#(A#/(;( ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, @&! /($(&(8 (1"( (/*+6'*%$#, "%'(+8(?"68 )%+ 1&5;(;(. «L8@!&!>%#/!% +"*"!, ! A!4(#(A!,, – @!#*4 =%//%4<, – "! ' /*/(8 #45>*% "% #(#$*'4,G$ $*/(. !#/4G>*GF%. 1&5; 1&5;* @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$!, /*/ @&!"!8*4( 1( #!: @(& )(4<7!"#$'(; "*@&($!', ("! '+*!8"( 1(@(4",G$ 1&5; 1&5;*» (89, #. 356). J*/, ' )!(4(;!!, @&!+"*]$ E$($ '61*GF!.#, 5>]"6.–1*&'!"!#$, «)%+ "%():(1!8(. #',+! 8%?15 (@6$"68! +"*"!,8! ! A!4(#(A#/!8 @("!8*"!%8 )!(4(;!>%#/!: ,'4%"!. 86 "% 8(?%8 #(#$*'!$< #%)% "%+6)4%8(;( 5)%?1%"!, ' !#$!""(#$! E'(4G2!(""(;( 5>%"!,» ($*8 ?%,
168
#. 355). 3" ?% ($8%>*4, >$( «14, @(4"(;( @&!+"*"!, +"*>%"!, "*7%. $%(&!! $&%)5%$#, "% $(4%#/!: ,'4%"!., "( "%():(1!8( $*/?% ! A!4(#(A#/(% @("!8*"!% '%F%.» ($*8 ?%, #. 356). 9 ' A!+!/%, @( 8"%"!G Q(4<28*"*, ' &%7%"!! A!4(#(A!%. ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8 '(@&(#* () *$(8*:, () E4%8%"$*&"6: "*>*4*: «)4*;(@&!,$"6: &%+54<$*$(' 8(?"( (?!1*$< +1%#< $(4*4, >$( ($/&6$6. !8 @%&!(1!>%#/!. +*/(" 5;45)4,%$ «A!4(#(A#/!. @&!"2!@, /($(&6. 5@&*'4,%$ $*!"#$'%""(. @&!&(1(. E4%8%"$('» (260, #. 392). %"1%4%%' '6&*+!4 $*/?% "*1%?15, >$( @(#4%15GF%% @(/(4%"!% !##4%1('*$%4%. 1*#$ «@%&'68 ()!4<"68 @4(1*8 @%&!(1!>%#/(;( +*/("* "('(% A!4(#(A#/(% ()()F%"!%, (@%&%' %;( "* 5#$(!, @(1/&%@4]""6% "('68! (@6$*8!, /($(&6% @&!1*15$ %F] )(4<75G @&(>"(#$< "*>*$(85 +1*"!G» ($*8 ?%, #. 394). P(%1!"%"!% 5#!4!. A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, @( 8"%"!G 5>]"6:, '*?"( ! "%():(1!8( "% $(4$( «%1!"(157"(% #($&51"!>%#$'( A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, 1*#$ "('5G @!F5 ()%!8 "*5/*8». H @($(85, !8%, ' '!15 '+*!8(($"(7%"!% A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, Q(4<28*" #1%4*4 '6'(1: «J%@%&< "*#$*4( '&%8, 14, +*/4G>%"!, 8%?15 "*8! #(G+*» (35, #. 179). B&*/$!>%#/!8 '(@4(F%"!%8 "*8%$!'7%;(#, '( '$(&(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/* #(G+* 8%?15 A!4(#(A!%. ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8, #(G+*, "%():(1!8(#$< /($(&(;( (#(+"*'*4*#< #*8!8! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8!, @&!>]8 "*!)(4%% '61*GF!8!#, !+ "!:, @(14!""68! $'(&2*8! "*5/!, #$*4( # !: #$(&("6 ()&*F%"!% / &*##8($&%"!G '(@&(#(' ()F%;(, 8!&('(++&%">%#/(;( :*&*/$%&*, A!4(#(A#/!: @( #(1%&?*"!G. B( @&!+"*"!G =%4<8;(4<2*, «' @(#4%1"%% '&%8, ! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! 8"(;( &*##5?1*G$ ( A!4(#(A#/!: '(@&(#*:» (36, #. 68). J5$, @&*'1*, #4%15%$ #1%4*$< (1"( +*8%>*"!%. 0!4(#(A!, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ' XIX '%/% "% '64!'*4*#< %F] ' "*@!#*"!% !8! #5;5)( A!4(#(A#/!: &*)($. L$( @&!1]$ @(+1"%%, ' XX '%/%. 9 '( '$(&(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/* '6#/*+6'*"!, A!4(#(A#/(;( :*&*/$%&* ' )(4<7%. !4! 8%"<7%. #$%@%"! &*+)&(#*"6 ' #@%2!*4<"6: &*)($*: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. /*/ '/&*@4%"!,, ' &*+4!>"6: @&%1!#4('!,:, ' '6#$5@4%"!,:, ' &%>*:, ' @%&#("*4!,:, @(#',F]""6: $(85 !4! !"(85 #('&%8%""!/5, /(44%;%, @&%17%#$'%""!/5, 5>!$%4G – ! '#%;1* ' (@&%1%4]""(. #',+! #( #'(%. #@%2!*4<"(#$"6: !"$%&%#('. L$( +"*>!$, >$( '(@&(#6 A!4(#(A#/(;( :*&*/$%&* "% )64! 14, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. >%8-$( #$(&(""!8, '"%7"!8, "!>%8 "% #',+*""68 # !: "%@(#&%1#$'%""(. "*5>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$]"68! ' @&(2%##% !: !##4%1('*"!.. */#'%44 @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «C "*7%. @('#%1"%'"(. &*)($% 86 @&!:(1!8 / '(@&(#*8 $(;( ?% &(1*, >$( ! 8%$*A!+!/!» (48, #. 5), $( %#$< A!4(#(A6.
169
R( ! E$!8 5>]"68 "% (;&*"!>!'*4!#<. 3"! '#] >*F% #$*4! #$&%8!$<#, '6.$! +* @&%1%46 #'(%. 5+/(#@%2!*4<"(. @&()4%8*$!/! 14, &%7%"!, '(@&(#(', 4%?*F!: "* ;&*"!2% #'(%. "*5/! ! A!4(#(A!!. J*/, "*@&!8%&, 14, A!+!/(' $(;( '&%8%"! )(4<7(. !"$%&%# @&%1#$*'4,4, @( #'!1%$%4<#$'5 Q(4<28*"*, «'(@&(# ( $(8, ,'4,%$#, 4! 8*$%&!, "%@&%&6'"(. !4! #(#$(!$ !+ 1!#/&%$"6: >*#$%.… L$( – $&51"6. '(@&(#, 4%?*F!. "* ;&*"!2% A!+!/! ! A!4(#(A!!». B( #4('*8 Q(4<28*"*, «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– '#% E$( ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% (@&%1%4,4(#< !: +"*"!%8 (!4! "%+"*"!%8) A!4(#(A!!, 5&('"%8 !: A!4(#(A#/(;( ()&*+('*"!,, ($"(7%"!%8 / (#"('"68 A!4(#(A#/!8 "*@&*'4%"!,8. §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«C "*7%. @('#%1"%'"(. &*)($% 86 @&!:(1!8 / '(@&(#*8 $(;( ?% &(1*, >$( ! 8%$*A!+!/!, "(, "% @(4*;*,#< "* '&(?1%""5G @&("!2*$%4<"(#$< "*7%;( 58*, 86 @(1:(1!8 / "!8 @(1;($('4%""6% 14!$%4<"68 @&!#@(#()4%"!%8 "*7%;( ()&*+* 86#4%. ! A*/$*8 '"%7"%. @&!&(16» (231, #. 5).
170
B&! $*/(8 @("!8*"!! A!4(#(A#/(;( ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, @(45>*%$#,, >$( A!4(#(A!, >%&@*%$ &%7%"!, !+ #%), #*8(., @5$%8 58(+&%"!,, (#"('6'*,#< "* !"1!'!15*4<"6: (#()%""(#$,: 86#4!$%4%., "* @&("!2*$%4<"(#$! !: 58*. 3@(&* "* &%*4<"(#$< %. @(E$(85 #('%&7%""( "% #'(.#$'%""*. 3$#G1* ! %% "%1(#$*$/!, «;&%:!», /*/ @!#*4 H. . P%>%"('. 3", ' >*#$"(#$!, ($8%>*4, >$( '8%#$( $(;(, >$()6 !##4%1('*$< #'(! ()I%/$6 «' @&%1%4*: &%*4<"(;(… ! (#$*"*'4!'*$<#, ' #'(!: +*/4G>%"!,: "* 1()6$6: $(4$( '( '#%: )%+ !#/4G>%"!, #45>*,:, $( %#$< @( ($"(7%"!G /( '#%8 ;4*'"68 ($1%4*8 >%4('%>%#/(;( 8!&(#(+%&2*"!, ('"%7"!. 8!&, 157* >%4('%/* ! @&.), 58 >%4('%>%#/!. 8(?%$ +*.$! +* @&%1%46 @(+"*"!, @(#&%1#$'(8 (&;*"(' >5'#$'» (335, #. 278). J*/*, #5;5)*, &*2!("*4!#$!>"(#$< ' 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/(. ()4*#$! A!4(#(A!!, @( 8"%"!G 5>%"6:, "%!+)%?"( ()%1",%$ %% #(1%&?*$%4<"5G >*#$<, @(+!$!'"(% +"*"!% ' "%.. 3)I,#",%$#, E$( $%8, #>!$*4, "*@&!8%&, . Q%&$4(, >$( «14, $(;(, >$()6 &*##5?1*$<, 86 @&!"5?1%"6 +*8%",$< $(, >$( #5F%#$'5%$, "%/($(&68! )(4%% @&(#$68! ($'4%>%""(#$,8!, "(, 5@($&%)4,, !:, 86 4!7*%8 '6'(16 )%+5#4('"(. #$&(;(#$!. J*/('* @&!>!"* )%+1(/*+*$%4<"(#$! '#%: '6'(1(' ' A!4(#(A#/!: #!#$%8*:» (31, #. 15). B(E$(85, #>!$*4 5>%"6., «'#,/*, 8%$*A!+!>%#/*, #!#$%8*, /*/('6 )6 "! )64! %% #$&%84%"!,, !8%%$ +"*>%"!% 4!7< ' ()4*#$! 4(;!/!; ' ()4*#$! #5F%#$'5GF%;( ("* #45?!$ $(4!% ($ A!4(#(A!! %#$%#$'(+"*"!%, @( 8"%"!G 5>%"6:, @&!:(1!$ / #'(!8 @&!"2!@!*4<"68 &%7%"!,8 "* @5$! #(($"%#%"!, ()&*+* 86#4%. # A*/$*8! '"%7"%. @&!&(16, ()I%/$!'"(;( 8!&*. 3;&*"!>%"!% "*+'*""(;( @&!"2!@* !#/4G>!$%4<"( #A%&(. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, – (1"( !+ @&(,'4%"!. "%>%$/(#$! @(+!2!. %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ' '(@&(#% ( '+*!8(($"(7%"!! A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,. H#:(1, !+ @($&%)"(#$%. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, 5>%"6% @("!8*4! "%():(1!8(#$< !: #(G+*. R( ("! +*>*#$5G '%#<8* #85$"( @&%1#$*'4,4! – # 6%6!= A!4(#(A!%. "5?%" #(G+ ! 6%6 %;( @&*/$!>%#/! (#5F%#$'4,$<. V1%#< @&(,'!4*#< "%1(#$*$(>"(#$< !: A!4(#(A#/(;( ()&*+('*"!,. J( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, >$( A!4(#(A!, &%7*%$ '(@&(#6 ()F%;(, #5F"(#$"(;( :*&*/$%&*, )64( 14, "!: (>%'!1"(, ! @(E$(85, /(4< #/(&( ! 14, %#$%#$'(+"*"!, '(+"!/*4* @($&%)"(#$< ' &%7%"!! $*/!: '(@&(#(', '(+"!/*4( ! 5)%?1%"!% ' "%():(1!8(#$! %;( #',+! # A!4(#(A!%.. R( /*/*, A!4(#(A!, ! /*/ &%7*%$ 5/*+*""6% '(@&(#6 – ' E$(8 5 "!: ,#"(#$! "% )64(. B(E$(85 ("! #$&%8!4!#< #*8! "*.$! &%7%"!,. H: A!4(#(A#/!% !+6#/*"!, (#5F%#$'4,4!#<, $*/!8 ()&*+(8, '"% A!4(#(A!!, )%+ (@(&6 "* "%%. O>%"6%, /*/ 8(;4!, A!4(#(A#$'('*4! #*8! ! >%&%+ E$( #'(% A!4(#(A#$'('*"!% ("! (F5@/! #(@&!/(#"('%"!, # A!4(#(A!%., @5$! "*:(?1%"!, ()F"(#$! # "%G. 3$#G1* ! ($8%>%""(% Q(4<28*"(8 «$( >5'#$'( "%51('4%$'(&%""(#$!, /*/(% !#@6$6'*%$ '#,/!. %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4< @&! A!4(#(A#$'('*"!!» (35, #. 172).
171
J*/(% A!4(#(A#$'('*"!% 5>%"6:, A!4(#(A#$'('*"!% «'#4%@5G», )%+ #(($"%#%"!, A!4(#(A#/!:, ()F%$%(&%$!>%#/!: '6'(1(', (#"('*""6: "* %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 8*$%&!*4%, # '6'(1*8!, @(45>%""68! ' #*8(. A!4(#(A!!, @(8!8( '#%;( @&(>%;(, @&!'(1!4( +*>*#$5G / +*$&*$% 5#!4!. "* &*)($5 «':(4(#$5G», $*/ /*/ 5>%"6% +*>*#$5G @&!:(1!4! / &%7%"!,8, 1*'"( 5?% @(45>%""68 ' A!4(#(A!!, "( "% !+'%#$"68 !8 ' #!45 !: "%1(#$*$(>"(;( +"*"!, !#$(&!! A!4(#(A!!. L";%4<# ($8%>*4 ' #',+! # E$!8, >$( «+"*/(8#$'( # :(1(8 !#$(&!>%#/(;( &*+'!$!, >%4('%>%#/(;( 8674%"!,, # '6#$5@*'7!8! ' &*+4!>"6% '&%8%"* '(++&%"!,8! "* '#%()F!% #',+! '"%7"%;( 8!&* "%():(1!8( 14, $%(&%$!>%#/(;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ! @($(85, >$( ("( 1*%$ 8*#7$*) 14, (2%"/! '61'!;*%86: !8 #*8!8 $%(&!.. R( +1%#< "%1(#$*$(/ +"*/(8#$'* # !#$(&!%. A!4(#(A!! '6#$5@*%$ 1('(4<"(–$*/! >*#$( ! &%+/(. B(4(?%"!,, 5#$*"('4%""6% ' A!4(#(A!! 5?% #($"! 4%$ $(85 "*+*1, @(4(?%"!,, # /($(&68! ' A!4(#(A!! 1*'"( 5?% @(/(">!4!, >*#$( '6#$5@*G$ 5 $%(&%$!+!&5GF!: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ' /*>%#$'% #*8("('%.7!: !#$!"» (406, #. 367). M("%>"(, "% #4%15%$ '8%",$< !8 E$( ' '!"5. [%4%#(()&*+"%% )64( )6 "*.$! ()I,#"%"!% &*#@46'>*$(#$!, "%(@&%1%4%""(#$! @(+!2!. 5>%"6: ' ()#$(,$%4<#$'*: !: ?!+"! ' #('&%8%""(8 !8 ()F%#$'%, ' (#()%""(#$,: ()F%#$'%""(;( #(+"*"!, $(;( '&%8%"!. H"1!'!15*4<"(% #(+"*"!% 5>%"6:, /*/ >*#$< ()F%#$'%""(;( #(+"*"!,, '@!$6'*4( ' #%), %;( "*!)(4%% 5#$(.>!'6% ! ,#"6% 2%""(#$"6% :*&*/$%&!#$!/!. 3>%"< $(>"( #/*+*4 @( E$(85 @('(15 */#'%44: « 6…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«%#$%#$'(+"*"!%, (#()%""( ' A(&8% "%#/(. >*#$! %;( "*5>"(;( @(#$&(%"!,» (14, #. 9). L$!8 ()#$(,$%4<#$'(8 ! #()#$'%""68 '/4*1(8 M*"$* ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!% '( 8"(;(8 )64 ()5#4('4%" %;( *'$(&!$%$ ' #&%1% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%.. «R* M*"$*, /*/ "* %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,, 5/*+6'*G$ ' (#()%""(#$! 9&*;(, KG)5*–-%.8(" !
172
=%4<8;(4<2, /($(&6. @(&(. #/4(",%$#, 1*?% / $(85, >$()6 (2%"!'*$< M*"$* @&%?1% '#%;( /*/ %#$%#$'%""!/* @( '#%85 %;( #/4*15 ! !"$%&%#*8. V"*>%"!% M*"$* 14, )!(4(;!!, /&(8% T$*44%&* ! 3$$( D!)8*""*, /($(&6. @(",4 @&()4%85 ;45)?% '#%:, @(1>%&/!'*4! $*/?% =%//%4< ! T54<2%, * +"*>%"!% %;( 14, ;%(;&*A!! ! *"$&(@(4(;!! – =%&4*"1, -*$2%4< ! O"(4<1» ($*8 ?%, #. 10). H8%"* @%&%>!#4%""6: '67% ! 8"(;!: 1&5;!: A!4(#(A(' '#$&%>*G$#, ' &*)($*: */#'%44*, =%4<8;(4<2*, Q(4<28*"*, =%//%4,, %"1%4%%'*, P%>%"('* ! "%/($(&6: 1&5;!: 5>%"6:. R( @(>$! "!/$( !+ "!: (* ("! – 45>7!% @&%1#$*'!$%4! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, XIX '%/*) "% 5@(8!"*%$ "! $*/!: '!1"6: @&%1#$*'!$%4%. 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!!, /*/ QE/(", D(//, =())#, "! *";4!.#/!: ! A&*"25+#/!: 8*$%&!*4!#$(' XVIII '%/* (J(4*"1*, B&!#$4!, K!1&(, =(4<)*:* ! 1&.), "! #'(%;( #('&%8%""!/* 0%.%&)*:*. H#/4G>%"!% +1%#< #(#$*'4,%$ &*+'% >$( =%//%4< . L$($ 5>%"6. '(()F% )(4<7% ! (:($"%% 8"(;!: 1&5;!: @!#*4 ( A!4(#(A!! ! A!4(#(A*:. 3" #*8 @&!+"*'*4#,, >$( @&!1*%$ A!4(#(A!! «)(4<7%% +"*>%"!%, >%8 )(4<7!"#$'( 1&5;!: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%.» (95, #. 438). B(",$"( @(E$(85, >$( =%//%4< ! !+5>*4 A!4(#(A!G !"$%"#!'"%% 1&5;!: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., "% (;&*"!>!'*,#< (1"*?16 @&(#457*""68 5"!'%&#!$%$#/!8 /5&#(8. 3", ' >*#$"(#$!, 45>7% 1&5;!: )64 +"*/(8 # !#$(&!%. A!4(#(A!!. J*/, ' @&%1!#4('!! / « !&('68 +*;*1/*8» =%//%4< @!#*4, >$( %;( A!4(#(A!, «,'4,%$#, @(4"68 '6&*?%"!%8 5)%?1%"!.», #(#$*'!'7!:#, ' "%8 «@5$%8 8"(;(4%$"%;( ! &%'"(#$"(;( !##4%1('*"!, @&!&(16 ! "%5#$*""(;( &*+8674%"!, "*1 !#$!""(. @&!>!"(. ,'4%"!.. L$* "*$5&A!4(#(A#/*, &*)($* 86#4! $,"%$#, '($ 5?% @(4#$(4%$!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 63). H E$* "*$5&A!4(#(A#/*, &*)($* 86#4! "%():(1!8( @&%1@(4*;*4* ()&*F%"!% / '(++&%"!,8 A!4(#(A(' – @&%17%#$'%""!/(' ! #('&%8%""!/('. C $%: ?% « !&('6: +*;*1/*:» !8%G$#, ##64/! ! "* *"$!>"6: 86#4!$%4%. (0*4%#, 9"*/#!8*"1&, 9"*/#!8%", =%&*/4!$, L8@%1(/4, K%8(/&!$, B4*$(", 9&!#$($%4<, D5/&%2!., L@!/5& ! 1&.), ! "* A!4(#(A(' XVI–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«B( ($"(7%"!G / A!4(#(A#/!8 5>%"!,8, /*/ E$( 8(?"( '!1%$< !+ %;( @(#$(,""6: ##64(/ ! 2!$*$, "%8"(;!% @&(A%##!("*4<"6% A!4(#(A6 8(;4! )6 @(:'*4!$<#, $*/!8 @(4"68 ! 7!&(/!8 +"*"!%8, /*/ 5 =%/#4!, @&(!+'%1%"!. 86#4!$%4%., "*>!"*, # 1&%'"%.7!: '&%8%" ! 1( "*#$(,F%;(, "% !#/4G>*, 1*?% #&%1"%'%/('(;( )(;(#4('!,, ! !: ;45)(/!8 @("!8*"!%8 ! /&!$!>%#/(G (2%"/(.» (161, #. 93).
173
0%.%&)*:* «P5F"(#$< :&!#$!*"#$'*», @!#*4: «C((157%'4%"!% )64( '#%()F!8: '#% 86 #&*+5 #$*4! A%.%&)*:!*"2*8!. P /*/!8 E"$5+!*+8(8 @&!'%$#$'('*4 *&/# "('(% '(++&%"!% ! /*/ #!4<"( @('4!,4( ("( "* "%;(, "%#8($&, "* '#% /&!$!>%#/!% (;('(&/!, 8(?"( @&%1#$*'!$< #%)%, @&(>!$*' «P',$(% #%8%.#$'(» (407, #. 281). O>%"6% $*/(;( '((157%'4%"!, "% !#@6$*4! ! A%.%&)*:!*"2*8! "% #$*4! – ! "% @($(85, >$( (/*+*4!#< "%#@(#()"68! / '(#@&!,$!G A!4(#(A#/!: !1%. 0%.%&)*:*, * 4!7< @($(85, >$( E$! !1%! 1( "!: "% 1(74!. H '!"('*$6 ' E$(8, @( 8"%"!G L";%4<#*, $% ()F%#$'%""6% 5#4('!,, «)4*;(1*&, /($(&68 A!4(#(A#/!% /*A%1&6 +*8%F*4!#< !#/4G>!$%4<"( 851&#$'5GF!8! E/4%/$!>%#/!8! /&(:()(&*8!, 8%?15 $%8 /*/ 0%.%&)*:, )%#/("%>"( @&%'(#:(1!'7!. '#%: !:, '6"5?1%" )64 (/&%#$<,"!'*$<#, ! @&(+,)*$< ' 1%&%'%"#/(8 +*:(45#$<%» ($*8 ?%, #. 288). M*/ 0%.%&)*: )64 ($1*4%" ($ %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, $*/ ! @&%1#$*'!$%4! @(#4%1"%;( )64! ($1*4%"6 ($ 0%.%&)*:*, ($ $(;(, >$( )64( "*!)(4%% #5F%#$'%""68, "*!)(4%% +"*>!$%4<"68 ' %;( A!4(#(A!!. H8 1(#$5@"* )64* 1&5;*, A!4(#(A!,. U*&*/$%&!+5, %%, =%//%4< @!#*4: «J*… ($'4%>%""*, ! ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% 8%$*A!+!>%#/*, "*5/*, /($(&*, #$(4%#$'% «A!4(#(A!!», '%#<8* 1*4%/* ($ $(;(, >$()6 '(#@&!"!8*$< ' #%), '"('< @&!()&%$*%86% #(/&('!F* (@6$"(;( +"*"!,» (95, #. 62). J*/('( 8"%"!% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,. R( "% 45>7% '6;4,1!$ @(4(?%"!% 1%4 ! '( 8"%"!! A!4(#(A*. 32%"!'*, #(#$(,"!% ! 5&('%"< @&%@(1*'*"!, A!4(#(A!! !, #4%1('*$%4<"(, '(+8(?"(#$! @&!()F%"!, / "%. )515F!: 5>%"6:, L";%4<# @!#*4, >$( ' #%&%1!"% XIX '%/*, «' 5"!'%&#!$%$*: /("/5&!&('*4! 8%?15 #()(. &*+4!>"%.7!% #(&$* E/4%/$!+8*, 5 /($(&6: ()F!8 )64( $(4$( ("! )64! #(#$&,@*"6 !+ (1"!: 4!7< ($)&(#(' #$*&6: A!4(#(A#/!: #!#$%8 ! )64! '#% (1!"*/('( 8%$*A!+!>"6. H+ (#$*$/(' /4*##!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! #(:&*"!4(#< $(4"( "%@(+"*'*%8*, '%F< ' #%)%, $( %#$< $* >*#$< /*"$('#/(;( 5>%"!,, /($(&*, 8%"<7% '#%;( +*#45?!'*4* #(:&*"%"!,. M("%>"68 &%+54<$*$(8 )64! ;(#@(1#$'5GF!% $%@%&< &*+)&(1 ! @5$*"!2* ' ()4*#$! $%(&%$!>%#/(;( 8674%"!,» (406, #. 368). W#$%#$'%""(, >$( $*/*, A!4(#(A!, "%8"(;( 8(;4* 1*$< 5>%"68. R( @('4!,$< "* "!:, "* !: $%(&%$!>%#/!% !+6#/*"!,, @&!>%8 @('4!,$< 1(#$*$(>"( @*;5)"( ("* 8(;4*. H ("* '4!,4*, '"(#, &*+)&(1 ! @5$*"!25 ' !: '(++&%"!,. «R%4<+, $%@%&< '+,$< ' &5/! @(>$! "! (1"(. $%(&%$!>%#/(. /"!;! @( %#$%#$'(+"*"!G, – @!#*4 L";%4<#, – "% @(45>!' !+ >$%"!, %% $*/(;( '@%>*$4%"!,, >$( #*8! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! >5'#$'5G$, /*/ #!4<"( "*1 "!8! ;(#@(1#$'5%$ E$($ &*+)&(1 ! E$* @5$*"!2*, ! >$( !8%GF*, "6"% :(?1%"!%, # @(+'(4%"!, #/*+*$<, A!4(#(A!, "% 1*%$ *)#(4G$"( "!/*/(;( '6:(1*» ($*8 ?%). B(",$"* @(E$(85 "%51('4%$'(&%""(#$< %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. $*/(. A!4(#(A!%.. J*/, Q(4<28*", ()&*F*,#< / A!4(#(A!! M*"$* ' @(!#/*: ($'%$* "* A5"1*8%"$*4<"6. '(@&(#:
174
«"%@&%&6'"* 4! 8*$%&!, !1! ("* !8%%$ *$(8!#$!>%#/(% #$&(%"!%?» ()"*&5?!'*%$ @&($!'(&%>!'(#$< %;( /*"$!*"#/(;( &%7%"!, ! "* E$(8 (#"('*"!! 1%4*%$ '6'(1: «L$( "% %1!"#$'%""6. #45>*., /(;1* A!4(#(A#/*, 86#4< "*$*4/!'*%$#, "* @&($!'(&%>!,; "*()(&($, 86 E$! @&($!'(&%>!, '#$&%>*%8 "* /*?1(8 7*;5. P*86% ()61%""6% '%F! ,'4,G$#, 14, A!4(#(A!! !#$(>"!/(8 "%&*+&%7!8%.7!: +*;*1(/» (35, #. 169). K&5;*, A!4(#(A!,, /*>%#$'%""( ($4!>"*, ($ E$(., Q(4<28*"5, /*/ ! 1&5;!8 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8, )64* "%'%1(8*. 3$#G1* ! ($(?1%#$'4%"!% !8! A!4(#(A!! # (1"(. !+ %% &*+"('!1"(#$%., >*F% '#%;( – # "%8%2/(. /4*##!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!%.. 3$#G1* ! !: "%#@(#()"(#$< +*",$< 1(#$*$(>"( >%$/!% @(+!2!! ' ($"(7%"!! / 1'58 ;4*'"68 A!4(#(A#/!8 "*@&*'4%"!,8. § 4. %;FD8=;3=CB 5 B=8252CC8DE== D4FD4F52=4>KF;FD3DG: D4FD4F5DEE2E;6IEKD 24E25K 3>%'!1"(, >$( ' 5#$*"('4%"!! (#"('"(. 8!&('(++&%">%#/(. @(+!2!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/*, ' '6)(&% !8! A!4(#(A#/!: @&!(&!$%$(' &%7*GF5G &(4< – +* '6>%$(8 '"%7"!: A!4(#(A#/!: '4!,"!. ! #@%2!A!>%#/!: ?!$%.#/!: ()#$(,$%4<#$' (&%4!;!(+"(% '(#@!$*"!% ! $.@.) – !;&*4 '"5$&!"*5>"6. A*/$(&, * !8%""( –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«C "*7%. @('#%1"%'"(. &*)($%, - @!#*4 */#'%44, - 86 @&!:(1!8 / '(@&(#*8 $(;( ?% &(1*, >$( ! 8%$*A!+!/!, "(, "% @(4*;*,#< "* '&(?1%""5G @&("!2*$%4<"(#$< "*7%;( 58*, 86 @(1:(1!8 / "!8 @(1;($('4%""6% 14!$%4<"68 @&!#@(#()4%"!%8 "*7%;( ()&*+* 86#4%. / A*/$*8 '"%7"%. @&!&(16» (231, #. 5). B&!#@(#()4%"!%, #(;4*#('*"!% "%():(1!8( @&%1@(4*;*%$ 1!!-9*-1-9'* (1"(;( 1&5;(85 – ()&*+* 86#4%. %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. A*/$*8 '"%7"%. @&!&(16, ,'4%"!,8 ! @&(2%##*8 ' "%. !, #4%1('*$%4<"(, #*8 @&(2%## @(+"*'*"!, ' E$(8 #45>*% @( "%():(1!8(#$! '/4G>*%$ ' #%), (@&%1%4%""(% !-$%>*"'*, !+()&*?%"!% ()I%/$(' !+5>%"!, ' #(+"*"!!, ' 86#4,: @(+"*GF%;( #5)I%/$*. «R* "*#, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,:, – @!#*4 )!(4(; H. -%."/%, – 4%?!$ +*1*>* !+()&*?*$< /*&$!"6 ,'4%"!., #('%&7*GF!:#, ' @&!&(1%… R*7%. 2%4$( 86 ! "*+6'*%8 @(+"*"!%8» (322, #. 1).
175
Q4*;(1*&, $*/(85 – !+()&*+!$%4<"(85 – :*&*/$%&5 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, !+5>*%86% ()I%/$6 ' «@&*'!4<"(8 '(++&%"!!», ' @&!()&%$%""(8 !#$!""(8 +"*"!! ( "!:, ' A*/$*: ! +*/("*: "*5/! @&%1#$*G$ $*/!8! ?%, /*/('6 ("! ' 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!, '( '"%7"%. @&!&(1%, ' %% ,'4%"!,: ! +*/("*:. R*5/*, #>!$*4 . Q%&$4(, «@&!()&%4* ' >%4('%>%#$'% *'$(&!$%$, (@!&*GF!.#, "% "* ($'4%>%""(% &*##5?1%"!%, "( "* "%():(1!8(% #(;4*#!% %% &%+54<$*$(' # #*8(G @&!&(1(G '%F%.» (31, #. 9). R*4!>!% $*/(;( #(;4*#!,, #('@*1%"!, @(1$'%&?1*%$#, '(+8(?"(#$%#/(;( 1%.#$'!, "* (#"('% "*5>"(;( +"*"!, @&!&(16 @(+"*""6: '%F%.. M*/ @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8 M. Q%&"*&, «2%4< '#,/(. "*5/!, /*/ ( ?!'6: #5F%#$'*:, $*/ ! ( $%4*: 8!"%&*4<"6:, 8(?%$ )6$< (:*&*/$%&!+('*"* 1'58, #4('*8!: 2$*59'5*-8 ! 5*=1-9!9%-8. C($, #()#$'%""(, @(>%85 >%4('%/ # $*/!8 ?*&(8 @&%1*%$#, $&51"(85 !##4%1('*"!G "*5>"6: !#$!". M(;1* (" #$(!$ 4!2(8 / 4!25 # @&!&(1(., $( @('!"5%$#, +*/("5 #'(%;( 58*, #$*&*,#< @&%1'!1%$< (/&5?*GF!% %;( ,'4%"!, ! ('4*1%'*$< !8!. /$*59'5*"'* ! 5*=1-9'* – '($ >$( :*&*/$%&!+5%$ >%4('%/* ' %;( ($"(7%"!,: / @&!&(1%» (25, #. 313). C #'(G (>%&%1< 5#@%7"*, &%*4!+*2!, E$(. 2%4! "*5/! – @&%1'!1%"!, ! 1%.#$'!, – #@(#()#$'5%$ ()&%$%"!G "('(;( !#$!""(;( +"*"!, /*/ @&(,'4%"!, 1(#$!;"5$(;( #(;4*#!, ()&*+* 86#4%. 5>%"6: # @&!&(1(. '%F%., # A*/$*8! 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!. B( 8"%"!G L. =%//%4,, «$(>"(% ! /&!$!>%#/(% "*)4G1%"!% 1%.#$'!$%4<"6: A*/$(' ! !: '%&"(% 5#$*"('4%"!% E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"68 @5$%8 #>!$*%$#, @( @&*'5 '%4!/!8 @&%!85F%#$'(8 #('&%8%""(. "*5/!» (97, #. 3). B(",$"(, >$( 14, "%():(1!8(. @(4"($6 ! $(>"(#$! !#/(8(;( "*5>"(;( +"*"!, '%&"(% 5#$*"('4%"!% 1%.#$'!$%4<"6: A*/$(' E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"68 @5$%8 1(4?"( )6$< 1(@(4"%"( !: '%&"68 &*2!("*4<"68, $%(&%$!>%#/!8 (#'(%"!%8, $( %#$< #5F"(#$"68 (#86#4%"!%8 ! @($(85, /*/ ($8%$!4 . T4%.1%", «"*5/* !8%%$ 2%4%#/! (A(&84%""(% #5F"(#$"(% (#86#4%"!% A*/$(' 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!, '#%: @&!&(1"6: ()I%/$(' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, @&%1@(4*;*%$ '6,'4%"!% !: *1-*1-9*"".D #(#$(,"!., !: !%#$', )%+($"(#!$%4<"6: / @&(!+'(4<"(. #5)I%/$!'"(#$! !"1!'!15*4<"(;( 8674%"!, $(;( !4! !"(;( /("/&%$"(;( 5>%"(;(. K(#$(!"#$'( "*5/!, #>!$*4 =. =%&2, $&%)5%$, «>$()6 86 58%4! $(>"( &*+4!>*$< @%#$&6. "*&,1, /($(&68 (/5$6'*%8 $%(&!G, ! /($(&6., @( @(/&(G ! 2'%$5, '@(4"% "*:(1!$#, ' "*7%. '4*#$!, ($ @&(#$(. ! )%+6#/5#$'%""(. A(&86, 1*'*%8(. "*8 @&!&(1(. ! "%+*'!#,F%. ($ "*7%;( @&(!+'(4*» (117, #. 12). 3)I%/$!'"(#$< @(+"*'*%8(;( "*5/(. @&!&(1"(;( %#$%#$'* (+"*>*%$, ' #'(G (>%&%1<, %;( $*%78"!1-8, '"%@(4(?"(#$< @( ($"(7%"!G / @(+"*GF%85 #5)I%/$5. 3$#G1* ! #(($'%$#$'5GF*, 2%4%@(4*;*GF*, "*@&*'4%""(#$< %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. «R*7* +*1*>*, – @!#*4 C. 3#$'*4<1, – +*/4G>*%$#, "% ' $(8, >$()6 '!1%$< 8!& ' )(4%% !4! 8%"%%
176
()8*">!'(8 !4! /&!'(8 +%&/*4%, * "*#$(4!"6, $*/ >$(, /(;1* 1*"6 (1"!, 8(;5$ )6$< (@&%1%4%"6 1&5;!%, – '($ ' >%8 +*/4G>*%$#, +*1*>* "*5/!» (293, #. 14). 9. B5*"/*&%, ($8%$!' /*?1(1"%'"(% 8(;5>%% '4!,"!% "*5/!, @(1>%&/"54, >$( «E$( )64( )6 "%'(+8(?"(, %#4! )6 "*5/* "% 1*'*4* "*8 @(+"*"!% >%;(-$( &%*4<"( #5F%#$'5GF%;(» (312, #. 7). V1%#<, ' ($"(7%"!! (),+*$%4<"(;( 14, "*5/! @(+"*"!, &%*4<"( #5F%#$'5GF%;(, (1"(;( «"*!'"(;( &%*4!+8*» 4G)(;( +1&*'(86#4,F%;( >%4('%/*, +*'%1(8( 5)%?1%""(;( ' ()I%/$!'"(. &%*4<"(#$! @&%18%$(' ! ,'4%"!. '"%7"%;( 8!&*, /("%>"(, 8*4(. R%():(1!8* %F% ! 2%4%"*@&*'4%""*,, #(+"*$%4<"( (#5F%#$'4,%8*, &*)($* 86#4!, &*)($*, "*@&*'4%""*, "* *&;58%"$!&('*""(% @(1$'%&?1%"!%, "* 1(/*+*$%4<#$'( 1%.#$'!$%4<"(;( "*4!>!, '"%7"%. ()I%/$!'"(. &%*4<"(#$! – "* (#"('% 1*""6: (@6$*, >5'#$'%""6: '(#@&!,$!., "* !: ()()F%""(% @(",$!."(% ()(+"*>%"!%, "*/("%2. «O >%4('%/*, – @!#*4 L. B!/*&, – 4!7< @(#$%@%""( ! 8%14%""( '6&*)*$6'*4(#< @(",$!% ( &%*4<"(8. K4, E$(;( @("*1()!4(#< )%#/("%>"(% 8"(?%#$'( (@6$(', @&!>%8 "%8*45G &(4< !;&*4( +1%#< 5>*#$!% "*7%. '(4! ! &*+4!>"6: (&;*"('. J(45'#$'. M("#$*$!&5,, "* (#"('*"!! @(1()"6: (@6$(', "%/($(&6% "%!+8%""6% ($"(7%"!, 8%?15 (@&%1%4%""68 (F5F%"!%8 ! $%8! (F5F%"!,8!, /($(&6% 86 8(?%8 '6+'*$< '#4%1 +* "!8, 86 '6&*)*$6'*%8 @(",$!, ( &%*4<"(8» (301, #. 16). B!/*& @(1>%&/!'*%$ @&! E$(8, >$( «+"*"!% &%*4<"(;( "(#!$… )%##@(&"5G @%>*$< @(4<+6». -%7*GF!8 @(1$'%&?1%"!%8 &%*4<"(#$! '"%7"%;( 8!&* (/*+6'*%$#,, $*/!8 ()&*+(8, 2$%6-'6%, #',+*""6. # @(4<+(. 5#@%: "*@&*'4,%86: '1-'"".: +"*"!%8 @&*/$!>%#/!: 1%.#$'!. >%4('%/*. B!/*& ' #',+! # E$!8 ##64*%$#, "* #4%15GF%% #5?1%"!% =%4<8;(4<2*: « 6 "*+6'*%8 "*7! @&%1#$*'4%"!, ( '"%7"%8 8!&% '1-'"".:' $(;1*, /(;1* ("! 1*G$ "*8 '(+8(?"(#$< 58(+*/4G>!$< ( @(#4%1#$'!,: "*7!: @(#$5@/(' @( ($"(7%"!G / E$(85 '"%7"%85 8!&5, ! /(;1* ("! @(+'(4,G$ 1%4*$< $(>"6% '6'(16 () (?!1*GF!: "*# #( #$(&("6 E$(;( 8!&* !+8%"%"!,:» ($*8 ?%, #. 17). B&!8%"!$%4<"( / %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(85 @(+"*"!G $*%78"!1-8 %;( ()I%/$(' ' !: @&!&(1"(8 )6$!! '(@4(F*%$#, ' !: :%-*$'%78"!1-', ()()F%""68 '6&*?%"!%8 /($(&(. ' *)#$&*;!&5GF%8 8674%"!! ! #$*"('!$#, @(",$!% :%-*$''. B!/*& ($8%$!4, ' >*#$"(#$!: «B&(2%## &*+4!>%"!,, # @(8(F%""6: @(",$!.. J*/, "*@&!8%&, 86 ()&*+5%8 @(",$!% …8*$%&!!» ($*8 ?%). C %#$%#$'(+"*"!! E$( @(",$!% @&!()&%4( #@%2!A!>%#/(% #86#4('(% "*@(4"%"!% ' #(($'%$#$'!! #( #@%2!A!/(. ()I%/$(' !+5>%"!, ! 86#4!$%4<"(;( 8%:*"!+8* !: @(+"*'*$%4<"(;( (#'(%"!,. B( 8"%"!G 3#$'*4<1*, «@(1 &%7*GF!8 '4!,"!%8
177
"%"!, ( $,;($%"!!, / /($(&(85 ' /("2% '(#%8"*12*$(;( '%/* @&!#(%1!"!4#, +*/(" #(:&*"%"!, '%#* '%F%#$'* 1*?% @&! :!8!>%#/!: &%*/2!,:, '(+"!/4( @(",$!% 8*$%&!!, /*/ &%*4<"(;( "(#!$%4, '#%: ,'4%"!. @&!&(16, "*1%4%""(;( '%#(8 ! 8*##(.» (291, #. 30-31). H ' 2%4(8, /*/ #>!$*4 3#$'*4<1, «5#@%: "*5/! +"*8%"5%$#, ($/&6$!%8 '#% )(4%% ()F!: 2!1-!("".D, !… @%&'*, !+ E$!: @(#$(,""6: '%4!>!" – :%11% – &*#7!&!4*#< ' @(",$!% ( :%-*$'', $( %#$< 8*##%, ()4*1*GF%. ()I%8(8, '%#(8 ! :!8!>%#/!8! #'(.#$'*8!» (293, #. 18). V"*8%"!$6. A&*"25+#/!. 5>%"6. 9. M(7!, (@&%1%4,, «'%4!/!. @&%18%$ "*5/!», ($8%$!4, >$( ("*, "*5/*, «#$&%8!$#, 5+"*$< @%&'("*>*4<"6% /*>%#$'* 8*$%&!! ! +*/("6, 5@&*'4,GF!% 1%.#$'!,8! ! @&($!'(1%.#$'!,8! &*+4!>"6: &(1(' 8*$%&!! (1"!: "* 1&5;!%; (1"!8 #4('(8, ("* #()!&*%$ !##4%1('*"!, ' 8*$%&!*4<"(8 8!&% ! #$*&*%$#, 5+"*$< !: '+*!8"6% ($"(7%"!,» (182, #. 76). 9";4!.#/!. 5>%"6. K. J!"1*4< $*/?% @(1>%&/"54, >$( !+5>*%8(% %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8, «/51* $(4%#$'% $&*"#A(&8!&('*4*#< ' #$!:!."( &%*4!+5%85G :%-*$'%7'1-'0"!1-8 !: (#"('"(. A!4(#(A#/(. @(+!2!!. C XIX '%/% "%!+)%?"(#$< $*/(. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(. 8*$%&!*4!#$!>"(#$! (@&%1%4,4*#< ()#$(,$%4<#$'*8!, #',+*""68! # (#()%""(#$,8! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, $(;( '&%8%"!, # %;( (#"('"(. "*@&*'4%""(#$%"!, )64!, /*/ @&*'!4(, ,'4%"!, ! @&(2%##6 :%6$!:'$%, ,'"( '6&*?%""6%, "*;4,1"( @&%1#$*'!86%, 1(#$5@"6% ' 8*##% #'(%. "%@(#&%1#$'%""(85 '(#@&!,$!G. 9 E$( +"*>!$, >$( !: 8*$%&!*4<"(#$< @&(,'4,4*#< #( '#%. (>%'!1"(#$*GF%. '!1 )6$!, '%F%#$' (#8. 229, #. 62). *$%&!, 14, 5>]"6: !#>%&@6'*4*#< E$!8 %] /("/&%$"68 @&(,'4%"!%8 – 9*?*1-9!:, ! '#, @&!&(1*, ' !: @("!8*"!!, (:'*$6'*4*#< %;( &*+4!>"68! #(#$(,"!,8!. . T4%.1%" @(1>%&/"54 ' #',+! # E$!8: « 6 #(+%&2*%8, 86 @("!8*%8 '%F%#$'%""6. 8!&» (396, #. 178). «C%F%#$'(8 !4! 8*$%&!%., – @!#*4 K.H. %"1%4%%', – "*+6'*G$ $(, >$(, "*@(4",, @&(#$&*"#$'(, !8%%$ '%#, $( %#$< @&%1#$*'4,%$ 8*##6, @&!$,;!'*%86% +%84%G ! 1&5;!8! 8*##*8! 8*$%&!!, $(, !+ >%;( #(#$(,$ $%4* @&!&(16 ! # >%8 #('%&7*G$#, 1'!?%"!, ! ,'4%"!, @&!&(16» (260, #. 580). L$! $%4* ! ,'4%"!, @&!&(16 ! #45?!4! (#"('"68! ()I%/$*8! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, %;( &*+4!>"6: ($&*#4%.. J*/, @( 8"%"!G =. =%4<8;(4<2*, A!+!/* «%#$< "*5/*, &*##8*$&!'*GF*, ! !+5>*GF*, ()F!% #'(.#$'* $%4 !4!, 45>7% #/*+*$<, '#%: $%4» (113, #. 69); )!(4(;!,, #(;4*#"( L. =%//%4G, ()"!8*%$ «'#G #('(/5@"(#$< +"*"!. () (&;*"!+8*: !4! ?!'6: $%4*:» (97, #. 35).
178
J*/5G "*@&*'4%""(#$< %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, ($8%>*4! ! A!4(#(A6. J*/, L";%4<# ' @!#<8% *&/#5, ' >*#$"(#$!, @(1>%&/"54: «B&%18%$ %#$%#$'(+"*"!, – 1'!?5F*,#, 8*$%&!,, $%4*» (411, #. 67). L$!8 ()#$(,$%4<#$'(8 ! (@&%1%4,4*#< ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% 8*$%&!*4!#$!>"(#$< A!4(#(A#/!: '(++&%"!. %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/*. R(, /("%>"(, )64( )6 "%(@&*'1*""68 5@&(F%"!%8, !#/*?*GF!8 1%.#$'!$%4<"(% @(4(?%"!% 1%4, '6'(1!$< A!4(#(A#/!% @( :*&*/$%&5, 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!% @( #(1%&?*"!G '+;4,16 5>]"6: '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* '#%2%4( !+ "*;4,1"( @&%1#$*'!8(;(, 1(#$5@"(;( "%@(#&%1#$'%""(85 '(#@&!,$!G (&;*"(' >5'#$' –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«"*5/* ( 8(4%/54*: %#$< (1"* !+ $%: ()4*#$%. +"*"!,, /($(&6% !8%G$ 1%4( # '%F*8!, "%'!1!868! ! "% '(#@&!"!8*%868! "*7!8! >5'#$'*8!, ! /($(&6% "%1(#$5@"6 @&,8(85 (@6$5»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– A!+!>%#/(% @(4%, – $%8 "% 8%"%%, @( #'!1%$%4<#$'5 . B4*"/*, «#8($&%4 "* E4%/$&!>%#/!% ,'4%"!, # $(>/! +&%"!, "%@(#&%1#$'%""(;( '(#@&!,$!, ! @&!'%4 !: ' #',+< # ,'4%"!,8! 5@&5;(#$!» (303, #. 117). -*#@&(#$&*"%"!% @&%1#$*'4%"!., #4(?!'7!:#, ' @&(2%##% !+5>%"!, "%@(#&%1#$'%""( '(#@&!"!8*%86: 8*/&($%4, "* ,'4%"!, 8!/&(8!&*, "* "%1(#$5@"6% "%@(#&%1#$'%""(85 '(#@&!,$!G ,'4%"!,, #@(#()#$'('*4(, ' >*#$"(#$!, ! $(85, >$( &%*4<"(#$< ()I%/$(', /($(&6% "* $(8 5&('"% @(+"*"!, 5?% "% 8(;4! )6$< '(#@&!"!8*%86 "%@(#&%1#$'%""(, "% '6+6'*4* #(8"%"!.. =.9. D(&%"2 ($8%>*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: « 6 5)%?1%"6 ' &%*4<"(#$! 8"(;!: '%F%., /($(&6% 86 "% '(#@&!"!8*%8 #$(4<
179
"%@(#&%1#$'%""(, /*/ /*8%"< !4! /5#(/ ?%4%+*. H: #5F%#$'('*"!% 86 @&!"!8*%8 :($< ! "* (#"('*"!! '(#@&!,$!,, "( '(#@&!,$!,, 1( /($(&(;( 86 1(74! >%&%+ )(4%% !4! 8%"%% 14!""6. &,1 &*##5?1%"!.» (219, #. 67). H /*/ )6 @&(1(4?*, E$5 86#4<, L. B!/*& @!#*4: «R*7! $%(&!! #@(#()"6, $*/!8 ()&*+(8, &*#7!&,$<#,, ')!&*, ' #%), "*&,15 # '!1!868! E4%8%"$*8! ! E4%8%"$6, – @(4<+5,#< $%&8!"(8 =%&2*, – «#/&6$6%». L$! #/&6$6% E4%8%"$6 !+'%#$"6 "*8, &*+58%%$#,, 4!7< /(#'%""68 ()&*+(8 ! "%1(#$5@"6 – @( /&*."%. 8%&%, "%@(#&%1#$'%""( – "*7%85 '(+1%.#$'!G. U!8!/! 5?% 1*'"( (@%&!&5G$ $*/!8! #/&6$68! E4%8%"$*8!: , !8%G ' '!15 8(4%/546 ! *$(86, (/*+*'7!%#, #$(4< 2%""68! '*?"68! 14, &*+'!$!, :!8!!» (301, #. 25). H /*/!:-4!)( (#()6:, #@%2!A!>%#/!: #'(.#$', +*/("(' ! $.@., #5F%#$'%""( ($4!>*GF!: E$! #/&6$6% E4%8%"$6 ($ @&!'6>"6: 8*/&($%4, 5>%"6% $(;1* %F% "% 5#8*$&!'*4!. U*&*/$%&"( ' E$(8 ($"(7%"!! #4%15GF%% 5$'%&?1%"!% K. J!"1*4,: «31!" ! $($ ?% +*/(" !8%%$ (1!"*/('(% +"*>%"!% /*/ @( ($"(7%"!G / +%84% @&! %% ;(1!>"(8 1'!?%"!! '(/&5; #(4"2*, $*/ ! @( ($"(7%"!G / 8%4<>*.7%85 *$(85» (358, #. 27). O)%?1%""(#$< %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/* ' ()I%/$!'"(. &%*4<"(#$! 8*/&(- ! 8!/&($%4, '#%;( '"%7"%;( 8!&*, 5)%?1%""(#$<, (#"('*""*, "* %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 !+5>%"!! 8*$%&!! ' %% &*+"(/*>%#$'%""6: '%F%#$'%""6: @&(,'4%"!,:, ' 8!&('(++&%">%#/(. #A%&% ()5#4('4!'*4* #(($'%$#$'5GF!. A!4(#(A#/!. "*#$&(., ! ' >*#$"(#$!, &%7*GF!8 ()&*+(8 '4!,4* "* !:, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., '(#@&!,$!% ! @&!"2!@!*4<"5G (2%"/5 A!4(#(A#/(;( '5*%7',:%. § 5. "FE2:DE=D D4FD4F52=4>KF;FD3DG < =7D;3=CB6: >2E=B;E=D = ED>8=9F=D B("!8*"!% 5>%"68! "%():(1!8(#$! #(%1!"%"!, A!4(#(A#/(;( ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, # (1"(. #$(&("6, ! "%51('4%$'(&%""(#$< $(. A!4(#(A!%., /($(&*, )64* !8 )(4%% !4! 8%"%% +"*/(8*, – # 1&5;(., – '#% E$( @()5?1*4( !: !#/*$< !"5G A!4(#(A!G, )(4%% #(($'%$#$'5GF5G @($&%)"(#$,8 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. R( E$! @(!#/! "% 74! 1*4<7% #*8(;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!,. C "%8, ' %;( $%(&%$!>%#/(. #A%&% ! "*:(1!4! 5>%"6% "5?"5G !8 A!4(#(A!G, * $(>"%% – #(+1*'*4! %% #*8!. 3#"('* E$(. A!4(#(A!! – (@(&* "* %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. 8*$%&!*4. «J*/*, A!4(#(A!,, – @!#*4 =%//%4<, – 8(?%$ @(/(!$<#, 4!7< "* %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 A5"1*8%"$%, "* /&!$!>%#/(8 #(@(#$*'4%"!! '#%: ()F!: '6'(1(' (@6$"6: "*5/» (95, #. 436). C @&%1#$*'4%"!! 5>%"6:, E$* "%():(1!8*, !8 ! !8! #(+1*'*%8*, A!4(#(A!, "! ' /*/(. 8%&% "% 1(4?"* )6$< !1%*4!#$!>%#/(.. H1%*4!+8 )64 !8 >5?1 – @&%?1% '#%;( ''!15 %;( @&!"2!@!*4<"(. "%#('8%#$!8(#$! # (#"('"(. "*@&*'4%""(#$"6: !##4%1('*"!., # !: ()&*F%""(#$%"6.
180
L. B!/*& @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «Q%+ (7!)/! 8(?"( #/*+*$<, >$( 86 $'(&!8 "*5/5, &*##8*$&!'*, ' "%. '6#75G &%*4<"(#$< >%&%+ @&!+85 "*7!: $%(&!. ! ($'4%>%""6: @(",$!.. R( E$! @(#4%1"!% "% @&%1#$*'4,G$ /*/(.-$( "%!+8%""(., $'%&1(. &*8/!, /*/ /*$%;(&!! ! A(&86 A!4(#(A#/(;( !1%*4!+8*. V"*>!$%4<"*, >*#$< @&(;&%##* "*5/ #(#$(!$ ' $(8, >$( 86 '#% $(>"%% ! $(>"%% @(+"*%8 ()I%/$!'"6% E4%8%"$6 '%F%.»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–!1%*4!#$!>%#/!. @(1:(1 / @(+"*"!G 8!&*, @!#*4: «M(;1* 8%$*A!+!/ # 2%4!'*%$#, ($ 8!&* &%*4<"6: '@%>*$4%"!., @&%1#$*'4,GF!: 14, "%;( &(1 (#/'%&"%"!, 1;?"!1-*= 2$*5:*-!9 "*7!8! (&;*"*8! >5'#$', ! )&(#*%$#, @( "%():(1!8(#$! ()(4<7% )&(#!$<#, "%/51*) ' 8!& !1%. ! @(",$!., @&!$(8 # 86#4$( "%'$( $( ?%, "%':*"** $*%78"!*, @( #(1%&?*"!G ! %#$< 1%:!* 1;?*1-9*""!*, (" @( "%():(1!8(#$! '#$&%>*%$#, ( *)#$&*/$*8! !… "!8*4( "% +*1586'*,#<, ()I%/$!'!&5%$ !4! ()(#()4,%$ !: ' 1;?"!1-'» (335, #. 281). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, ' @(+"*'*$%4<"(. #A%&% ()I%/$!'"6. !1%*4!+8 !#/4G>*4 $(, "* >%8 (#"('6'*4(#< %#$%#$'(+"*"!% – (@(&5 "* (@6$"6% 1*""6%. W;( (#"('"6% @(4(?%"!,, ' @&%1#$*'4%"!! 5>%"6:, '6'(1!4!#< "% !+ (@6$*, * !#/4G>!$%4<"( !+ >%4('%>%#/(;( 58*. P@%/54,$!'"(#$<, 58(+&!$%4<"(#$< ()I%/$!'"(–!1%*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! @&!:(1!4*, #4%1('*$%4<"(, ' "%@&!8!&!8(% @&($!'(&%>!% # E8@!&!>"(#$*4*, (@&%1%4,GF%;( '(% #5F%#$'5GF%%, "%@&!%84%8* ''!15 ($#5$#$'!, ! "%'(+8(?"(#$! %% /*/(;( )6 $( "! )64( (@6$"(;( @(1$'%&?1%"!,. =%//%4<, !8%, ' '!15 !8%""( ()I%/$!'"(!1%*4!#$!>%#/5G A!4(#(A!G, @!#*4: «R%#(8"%""(, /("%>"(, >!#$( #@%/54,$!'"(%, *)#(4G$"( A!4(#(A#/(% @(#$&(%"!%, "% (@!&*GF%%#, "* "%():(1!85G (#"('5 !+ (@6$"6: 1*""6:, ,'4,%$#, '(+157"68 +*8/(8, /($(&6. &*+4%$*%$#, ' @&*: @&! @%&'(8 #$(4/"('%"!! # (@6$(8, (#()%""( 8"(;( @&%1#$*'!$%4%. $*/(;( "*@&*'4%"!, ' =%&8*"!! ("*@&., T%44!"; ! =%;%4<)» (90, #. 358). L";%4<#, '(+&*?*, @&($!' &*#@&(#$&*"%""(;( ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(. #&%1% (;54<"(;( ($&!2*"!, '#%. A!4(#(A!! =%;%4,, '8%#$% # $%8 @(1>%&/!'*4, >$( «1%4( !1%$ +1%#< ($"G1< "% ( +*F!$% ;%;%4%'#/(.
181
!#:(1"(. $(>/! +&%"!,, #(;4*#"( /($(&(. 15:, 86#4<, !1%, %#$< @%&'!>"(%, * 1%.#$'!$%4<"6. 8!& – $(4$( ' 4G)(. "*5>"(. ()4*#$! – /*/ ' ()4*#$! @&!&(16, $*/ ! ' ()4*#$! !#$(&!! – "*1( !#:(1!$< !+ 1*""6: "*8 &%6-!9, #$*4( )6$<, ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!! –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«C6:(1, !+ 86#4!, >$( '"%7"!. 8!& '(#@&!"!8*%$#, ! @(+"*%$#, "*8! @(#&%1#$'%""(, ("! (!1%*4!#$6. – C.3.) #>!$*G$ '#G &*##51(>"5G #$(&("5 86#4! "% ($;(4(#/(8 @&%18%$"6: ($"(7%"!. ! +*'!#!8(#$%., * @&!&(?1%""68! >%4('%/5 A(&8*8! !4! +*/("*8! '(#@&!"!8*GF%;( ! @(+"*GF%;( 58*, /($(&6. #('%&7*%$ '#G &*)($5 @&%'&*F%"!, '@%>*$4%"!. ' !1%."(8 "*@&*'4%"!! ! #(+1*%$, $*/!8 ()&*+(8, $(, >$( 86 "*+6'*%8 @&%18%$"68! ($"(7%"!,8! ! +*'!#!8(#$,8!». P%>%"(' ($8%>*%$ ' #',+! # E$!8, >$( «/&*."!. @&%1%4 @(1()"6: '(++&%"!. #(#$*'4,%$ ()F%!+'%#$"*, 86#4< 0!:$%, @( /($(&(. #*86. '"%7"!. 8!& %#$< "% >$( !"(%, /*/ @(&(?1%"!% "*7%;( «X» (335, #. 407). M*/ @!#*4 (1!" !+ #$(&(""!/(' $*/(. $(>/! +&%"!,, C. M5"$2%, «'"%7"!. 8!& "*8 1*" '#%;1* $(4"(;( @(+"*"!,. «W#$%#$'(+"*"!% ' ()7!&"(8 #86#4% #4('*, – @!#*4 H. . P%>%"(', – %#$< "*5/* ( #',+,:, ($"(7%"!,: ! +*'!#!8(#$,: 8%?15 @&%18%$*8! '"%7"%;( 8!&* ! !: #(#$*'"68! >*#$,8!» (335, #. 378). B&!#5F!. #5)I%/$!'"(85 !1%*4!+85 @(1:(1 / @("!8*"!G ($"(7%"!, '"%7"%;( 8!&* ! #(+"*"!, >%4('%/* ()5#4('!4 %;( "%1(#$*$/!, 1%4*'7!% %;( "%@&!%84%868 14, 5#@%7"(;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. P%>%"(' # @(+!2!. #'(%. "*5/! '61%4,%$ 1'* $*/!: "%1(#$*$/*. B%&'6. +*/4G>*%$#, ' $(8, >$( «"*@%&%/(& '#,/(. (>%'!1"(#$!» #5)I%/$!'"6% !1%*4!#$6 «#$*&*4!#< '6'%#$! '#G @#!:!>%#/5G ?!+"< >%4('%/* !+ 1%,$%4<"(#$! (1"(;( $*/(;( A*/$(&* – 15:('"(. (&;*"!+*2!! >%4('%/*, (#$*'4,, 1&5;(., $( %#$< '(+1%.#$'!, !+'"%, #('#%8 ' #$(&("% +* "%'(+8(?"(#$
182
&%7!$#, $%@%&< 5$'%&?1*$<, >$( '"%7"!. 8!& "% !8%%$ #5F%#$'('*"!, @(8!8( #(+"*"!, >%4('%/* ! >$( "%!#>%&@*%8(% )(;*$#$'( @&!#5F!: %85 1%,$%4<"(#$%. "% #45?!4(, "% #45?!$ ! "% )51%$ #45?!$< 8*$%&!*4(8 14, $(. )%#/("%>"(. 2%@! 86#4!$%4<"6: */$(', !+ /($(&6: #(+1*]$#, "*5/* ( '"%7"%8 8!&%» ($*8 ?%, #. 407-408). C$(&(. #5F%#$'%""6. "%1(#$*$(/ #5)I%/$!'"(;( !1%*4!+8* #(#$(!$ ' $(8, >$( @&%1#$*'!$%4! @(#4%1"%;( «()(#()4,G$ #5)I%/$!'"6% A*/$(&6, 5>*#$'5GF!% ' @#!:!>%#/(8 &*+'!$!!, ' (#()5G /*$%;(&!G 1%,$%4%., ($4!>"6: ($ '#%;( +%8"(;( "% $(4!#$( #:(4*#$!>%#/(% @&%1#$*'4%"!%», /*/ «*)#$&*/$, @( /($(&(85 "!>%;( "% #5F%#$'5%$ /&(8% «,», @($(85 >$( '#% @&(:(1!$ >%&%+ #(+"*"!%», '6&*?*4 5'%&%""(#$<, >$( «@(1()"6% @&%1#$*'4%"!,, "%#8($&, "! "* /*/5G 1!*4%/$!/5, 51%&?*$<#, "% 8(;5$ ' 58*: #/(4"( $*/ ?% M.9. J!8!&,+%', :*&*/$%&!+5, #('%&7%""( "%#(#$(,$%4<"5G, "* %;( '+;4,1, @&!"2!@!*4<"5G @(+!2!G #$(&(""!/(' #5)I%/$!'"(;( !1%*4!+8*, @!#*4: «3"! )64! ;($('6 '( '#%(&5?!! #'(%. 1!*4%/$!/! 5)%?1*$< 8%", ' $(8, >$( E$($ '"%7"!. 8!& "% !8%%$ ()I%/$!'"(;( )6$!,, >$( E$( – $(4"!/% /($(&(. , "% 8(;5 )6$< 5'%&%", >$( E$( $($ ?% #(", 8!&*?, ;&%+6 "*,'5» (353, #. 331). B(",$"(, >$( 14, %#$%#$'(+"*"!, $*/*, A!4(#(A#/*, @(+!2!, "!/*/(. &%*4<"(. 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/(. +"*>!8(#$! "% !8%%$. B(E$(85, #>!$*4 J!8!&,+%', 4!7%"6 '#,/!: ()I%/$!'"6: (#"('*"!. $% '6'(16, «/($(&6% 1%4*%$ ;&5@@* A!4(#(A('–"%()%&/4!*"2%' ( *:, 3#$'*4<1, B%$2(4<1, / #(?*4%"!G, ($>*#$! ! B!&#("), 5$'%&?1*GF!:, >$( "*5/* 1(4?"* (;&*"!>!'*$<#, … >5'#$'%""68! '(#@&!,$!,8!, * "% @6$*$<#, @&("!/"5$< ' ()I%/$!'"5G ()4*#$< $%: '"%7"!: ,'4%"!., /($(&68! '6+6'*G$#, E$! (F5F%"!,» (356, #. 16). V*1*>* "*5/!, @( 8"%"!G J!8!&,+%'*, «#'(1!$#, / $(85, >$()6, ($@&*'4,,#< ($ «)6$!,» /*/ 1*""(;(, ()I,#"!$< @(>%85 ("( $*/('(, * "% !"(%» (357, #. 192). (?"( @&!'%#$! ! 1&5;!% #'!1%$%4<#$'* ($&!2*$%4<"(;( ($"(7%"!, '61*GF!:#, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/* / #5)I%/$!'"(85 !1%*4!+85, (#()%""( / $*/(. %;( /&*."%. A(&8%, /*/ 1!7'21',:. P /&!$!/(. @(#4%1"%;( '6#$5@!4, ' >*#$"(#$!, D. Q(4<28*". -*##8*$&!'*, #(4!@#!+8, E$(, /*/ (" @!#*4, «#$*&(% +*)45?1%"!%», Q(4<28*" '!1%4 %;( #5$< ' #4%15GF%8: "* %;( (#"('% «@&!:(1,$ / 86#4!, >$( '(()F% '#% "*7! @&%1#$*'4%"!, #5$< #"('!1%"!, ! >$( ' 8!&% "% #5F%#$'5%$ "!>%;(, /&(8% %1!"#$'%""(;( >%4('%/*, #(+1*GF%;( E$! @&%1#$*'4%"!,, $( %#$< '!1,F%;( #"6» (35, #. 147). B( 8"%"!G Q(4<28*"*, #(4!@#!+8 "%#('8%#$!8 # "*5>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$!"!$< $(4"68! !##4%1('*"!,8!. 3"
183
@!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «H+'%#$"68 #()4*+"!$%4<"68 ! (7!)(>"68 +*/4G>%"!%8 ,'4,%$#, $*/ "*+6'*%86. #(4!@#!+8 – 8"%"!%, >$( 8!& "%&%*4%", * 4!7< ;(46. @&(15/$ "*7%. A*"$*+!!, /*/, "*@&!8%&, #"('!1%"!%. X $(?% @&%1*'*4#, E$(. '6158/%, '#4%1#$'!% E$(;( # (@(+1*"!%8 #$*4 +*"!8*$<#, @&*'!4<"(. @&*/$!>%#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$*.7%. &*1(#$! ' E$(8 , "*7%4 !#/(8(% "5?"(% 1(/*+*$%4<#$'( &%*4<"(#$! '"%7"%;( 8!&*, /($(&(% 8(?%$ +*/4G>*$<#, 4!7< ' $(8, >$( $($, /$( #(8"%'*%$#, ' E$(. &%*4<"(#$!, 8%"%% #@(#()%" / @&*'!4<"68 1%.#$'!,8» ($*8 ?%, #. 161). 3$'%&;*, #5)I%/$!'"6. !1%*4!+8 (#(4!@#!+8), 5>%"6% @&! E$(8 ()&*F*4! '"!8*"!% "* %;( "% $(4"(–@&*/$!>%#/5G, "( ! $%(&%$!>%#/5G "%#(#$(,$%4<"(#$<, 4(;!>%#/5G 5F%&)"(#$<. J*/, &5##/!. E8@!&!(#!8'(4!#$ B.P. S7/%'!>, :*&*/$%&!+5, A!4(#(A#/!. *#@%/$ ' #!$5*2!! # #(4!@#!+8(8, ($8%$!4, ' >*#$"(#$!: « !& %#$< 8(% @&%1#$*'4%"!%» – E$!8! #4('*8!, /($(&68! "*>!"*%$#, '*?"%.7%% @&(!+'%1%"!% T(@%";*5E&*, 45>7% '#%;( '6&*?*%$#, #!8'(4 '%&6 "*!)(4%% &*#@&(#$&*"%""(;( $%@%&< 8!&('(++&%"!,» (417, #. 1). -5##/!. :!8!/ .S. =(4<17$%." # @(+!2!! 4(;!/! +1&*'(;( #86#4*, :*&*/$%&"(. 14, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., '(+&*?*4: «W#4! '%#< 8!& %#$< 4!7< 8(% @&%1#$*'4%"!%, $( ! '#% (#$*4<"6% 4G1! #5$< 4!7< 8(! @&%1#$*'4%"!,, ! , #*8 @&%1#$*'4,G #'(% @&%1#$*'4%"!%… P$(!$ >!$*$%4G 4!7< '158*$<#, ' E$($ @5"/$, ! (" #%.>*# ?% 5'!1!$ $( ?*4/(% @(4(?%"!%, ' /($(&(8 1(4?%" (>5$!$<#, >%4('%/, &%7!'7!.#, #!#$%8*$!>%#/! @&('%#$! $*/(% '(++&%"!% 1( /("2*» (130, #. 9). U*&*/$%&"( ' E$(8 ($"(7%"!! ! '6"5?1%""(% @&!+"*"!% (1"(;( !+ #5)I%/$!'"6: !1%*4!#$(', !88*"%"$* H. -%8/%: «M >!#45 '(@&(#(', /($(&6% +1(&('(85, %F% "% !#@(&>%""(85 58(+&%"!%8 #(+"*"!G /*?5$#, @&(#$( @*$(4(;!>%#/!8!, ($"(#!$#,, )%##@(&"(, #$&%84%"!% 51(#$('%&!$<#, ' $(8, #5F%#$'5%$ 4! ' 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! '"%7"!. 8!&…» (323, #. 66). «V1(&('(%» #(+"*"!% – E$( ! $(, /($(&(% 2%4%"*@&*'4%""( 5#$&%84%"( / @(+"*"!G '"%7"%;( 8!&* @(#&%1#$'(8 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( !+5>%"!, &%*4<"6: '%F%., ,'4%"!. ! @&(2%##(' @&!&(16. H @($(85, @!7%$ -%8/%, «E$($ 8!& '%F%., /($(&6. 86, @5$%8 (@6$* ! "*5>"(;( !##4%1('*"!,, 1(4?"6 "*>!#$( ($1%4!$< ($ 8!&* @&%1#$*'4%"!., ()&*+5%$ "%@(#&%1#$'%""( 1*""6. '"%7"!. 8!&» ($*8 ?%, #. 96). B(",$"( @(E$(85, >$( ! #&%1! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. «$*/ "*+6'*%86. !1%*4!+8, $( %#$< ($&!2*"!% '"%7"%;( 8!&*.., @(4<+5%$#, 15&"(. &%@5$*2!%.… J*/(85 !1%*4!+85 "!/(;1* "% :($%4! @&%1#$*'!$< @&*'* ;&*?1*"#$'*» ($*8 ?%, #. 73-74). C ()4*#$! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( !+5>%"!, ?!+"%""6: ,'4%"!. #$(4< ?% "%@&!%84%868 14, 5>%"6: )64 !1%*4!+8 ' A(&8% 9'-%7',:%. P &%+/(. /&!$!/(. ' *1&%# @(#4%1"%;( '6#$5@!4, ' >*#$"(#$!, *.%&, @( 8"%"!G /($(&(;(, '#4%1#$'!% 1(@5F%"!, 1%.#$'!, (#()(. "%8*$%&!*4<"(. «?!+"%""(. #!46», «!#/4G>*%$#, '(+8(?"(#$< '#,/(;( 1*4<"%.7%;( !##4%1('*"!, ! 1%4*%$#, "%'(+8(?"68 @&!8%"%"!% +*/("(' $(>"6: "*5/ /
184
!+5>%"!G ?!+"%""6: ,'4%"!.; @&!+"*GF!% E$5 «?!+"%""5G #!45» ' @&($!'(&%>!! # 15:(8 @&(;&%##*, /($(&6. @&(,'4,%$#, ' #('&%8%""(8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, '(+'&*F*G$#, / :*(#5 "%()5+1*""(. !;&6 A*"$*+!!» (229, #. 134). P*8 *.%& +* (#"('5 !##4%1('*"!. «' /*>%#$'% */#!(8*$!>%#/(. !#$!"6» '+,4 $( @(4(?%"!%, >$( «' ?!+"%""(8 @&(2%##% @&(!#:(1!$ 4!7< @&%'&*F%"!% '%F%#$'* ! #!46, * ($"G1< "% !: #(+1*"!%» ($*8 ?%, #. 134-135). 9"*4(;!>"(;( '+;4,1* "* '!$*4!+8 @&!1%&?!'*4#, ! 1&5;(. @%&'(($/&6'*$%4< +*/("* #(:&*"%"!, ! @&%'&*F%"!, E"%&;!!, A!+!/ ! A!+!(4(; =. =%4<8;(4<2. 3" @!#*4, ' >*#$"(#$!: «C A!+!(4(;!>%#/!: "*5/*: 1(4;(% '&%8, 74* &%>< ( $(8, >$( «?!+"%""6% #!46» @&%1#$*'4,G$ #()(G, '(+8(?"(, #'()(1"6% #!46, "% +*'!#,F!% ($ /*/(.-4!)( 8*$%&!!, ! >$( >%4('%>%#/5G 1575 &*'"68 ()&*+(8 8(?"( &*##8*$&!'*$< /*/ "%/($(&5G #!45, "% #',+*""5G # 8*$%&!%., $( %#$< ($1%4%""5G ($ ()I%/$(', @(1'%&;*GF!:#, !+8%"%"!,8. R( &*+ 86 5,#"!4! #%)% @&(!#:(?1%"!% @(",$!. #!46 ! 8*$%&!!, $*/!% '(++&%"!, 5$&*$!4! '#,/!. #86#4» (113, #. 78). K&5;(. '!1"6. A!+!(4(; XIX '%/* H. . P%>%"(' $*/?% /&!$!/('*4 '!$*4!#$(', /($(&6% «#>!$*4! ?!'($"(% $%4( (1*&%""68 (#()68! «?!'68! #!4*8!», "% !8%GF!8! "!>%;( @(1()"(;( ' 8*$%&!*4<"(8 8!&%». J*/(% '(++&%"!% P%>%"(' #>!$*4 ;45)(/( >5?168 #('&%8%""(. %85 A!+!(4(;!! ! @(1>%&/"54, >$( ("( «"% !;&*%$ ' E$(. "*5/% 5?% "! 8*4%.7%. &(4!» (335, #. 226). P'(% ($&!2*$%4<"(% ($"(7%"!% / '!$*4!+85 "%1'5#86#4%""( '6&*+!4 ! N. K*&'!". C(+&*?*, $%8, /$( !+8%"%"!% '!1(' ()I,#",4 «/*/(.-$( «'"5$&%""%. #!4(. !4! #$&%84%"!%8», ( @&!&(1% /($(&(;( "!>%;( "% !+'%#$"(», '%4!/!. "*$5&*4!#$ @!#*4: «B( 8(%85 8"%"!G, "%$ "!/*/(. "5?16 @&!+6'*$< '8%7*$%4<#$'( /*/(. )6 $( "! )64( '"5$&%""%. #!46, @(8!8( "*/4(""(#$! / ()6/"('%""(. !+8%">!'(#$!, /($(&*, @&! #(1%.#$'!! !#/5##$'%""(;( ($)(&*, @&! 5>*#$!! >%4('%/*, 1*4* "*>*4( @&%/&*#"( @&!#@(#()4%""68 1(8*7"!8 @(&(1*8, * @&! #(1%.#$'!! %#$%#$'%""(;( ($)(&* $*/?% 8(;4* @&(!+'%#$! @5$%8 "%>5'#$'!$%4<"6: @%&%:(1(' %#$%#$'%""6% @(&(16 !4! '!16» (141, #. 256-257). 9 (1!" !+ '!1"%.7!: 1*&'!"!#$(' XIX '%/* L. =%//%4< @&!+6'*4 «&%7!$%4<"( '(##$*$< @&($!' $(;( '!$*4!#$!>%#/(;( !4! $%4%(4(;!>%#/(;( '(++&%"!, "* @&!&(15, @( /($(&(85 ?!'($"6% ! &*#$!$%4<"6% A(&86 ,'4,G$#, @&(15/$(8 (#()(;( "*>*4* !4! 2%4%#(()&*+"( 1%.#$'5GF%. $'(&>%#/(. %#$%#$'%""(. #!46» (89, #. 29). O#@%:! )!(4(;!>%#/!: "*5/ ! @&%?1% '#%;( &*+'!$!% 1*&'!"('#/(;( 5>%"!, ' &%7*GF%. 8%&% #@(#()#$'('*4! 5#$&*"%"!G '!$*4!#$!>%#/(;( '+;4,1* "* ?!+"%""6% ,'4%"!,. § 6. "FE2:DE=D D4FD4F52=4>KF;FD3DG < B;FD8=;3=CB6: >2E=B;E=D = 2FI6M7DE=D H$*/, A!4(#(A#/!. !1%*4!+8, ' /*/(. )6 A(&8% (" "! '6#$5@*4, ($'%&;*4#, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8! '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/*. H:
185
#()#$'%""*, A!4(#(A!, @(E$(85 "% 8(;4* )6$< !1%*4!#$!>%#/(.. H @(#/(4"(8 #>%$%, 8(?%$ )6$< $(4%"6:, $( (#$*%$#,, #4%1('*$%4<"(, 8*$%&!*4!+8. R( #*8! 5>%"6% "% "*+6'*4! ! "% #>!$*4! #'(G A!4(#(A!G 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(., @&%?1% '#%;( – ' #!45 ;(#@(1#$'('*'7%;( ' $( '&%8, A!4(#(A#/(;( @&%1&*##51/* @( ($"(7%"!G / #*8(85 #4('5 «8*$%&!*4!+8». U*&*/$%&"*, 14, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* @5$*"!2* ' @("!8*"!! 8*$%&!*4!+8* ! !1%*4!+8*, ' (@&%1%4%"!! #'(%. A!4(#(A#/(. @(+!2!! (#()%""( "*;4,1"( @&(,'!4*#< ' 8!&('(++&%"!! L. =%//%4,. 3" )64 @&($!' ($(?%#$'4%"!, #'(!: A!4(#(A#/!: '(++&%"!. # 8*$%&!*4!+8(8, "% #(;4*7*4#, # $%8! #'(!8! /&!$!/*8!, /($(&6% #>!$*4! %;( 8*$%&!*4!#$(8. *$%&!*4!+8, # %;( $(>/! +&%"!,, – "% (#"('"*, :*&*/$%&!#$!/* %;( A!4(#(A#/!: '+;4,1(' ! '(()F% "% ,'4,%$#, (1"(. !+ (#"('"6: A!4(#(A#/!: /("#$*"$, &*'"( /*/ ! !1%*4!+8. 3#"('"68 @&($!'(&%>!%8 ' A!4(#(A!! =%//%4< #>!$*4 @&($!'(&%>!% "% 8%?15 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 ! !1%*4!+8(8, * 8%?15 8("!+8(8 ! 15*4!+8(8, !4!, >$( $( ?% #*8(%, 8%?15 '(++&%"!%8 @&!>!""68 !4! 8%:*"!>%#/!8, # (1"(. #$(&("6, ! $%4%(4(;!>%#/!8 !4! '!$*4!#$!>%#/!8 – # 1&5;(.. «W#4! #(@(#$*'!$<, – @!#*4 (", – 8!&('(++&%"!, &*+4!>"6: "*&(1(' ! '&%8%" 14, #&*'"%"!, !: 1&5; # 1&5;(8, $( 8(?"( &*+1%4!$< !: "* 1'% @&($!'(@(4(?"6% ;&5@@6: 2$'0'""!* !4! :*D%"'0*16!*, ! -*7*!7!#'0*16!* !4! 9'-%7'1-'0*16!*». O$(>",, (@&%1%4%"!,, =%//%4< @!#*4, >$( @&!>!""(% !4! 8%:*"!>%#/(% 8!&('(++&%"!% «8(?"( "*+'*$< $*/?% :!"'1-'0*16': !4! *5'".: ' @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$< 59!=1-9*""!:; !4! 5;%7'1-'0*16!:; '(++&%"!G, /($(&(% "%():(1!8( #(1%&?!$#, ' $%4%(4(;!>%#/(8 8!&(@("!8*"!!» (89, #. 29). L$( @(#4%1"%% =%//%4< &%7!$%4<"( ($'%&;*4 +* %;( !1%*4!#$!>"(#$<, ($'%&;*4 # @(+!2!%. 8*$%&!*4!+8*. R( #*8( @(",$!% «8*$%&!*4!+8» ' /*>%#$'% (@&%1%4%"!, %;( 8!&('(++&%"!, "% 5#$&*!'*4( =%//%4, @&%?1% '#%;( ' #!45 8"(;(+"*>"(#$! E$(;( @(",$!,, %;( "%(@&%1%4%""(#$!, 1'5#86#4%""(#$!, /*/ ("( @&%1#$*'*4( ' )6$('*'7%8 ' $( '&%8, #4('(5@($&%)4%"!!. J*/, #*8 =%//%4< '61%4,4 $&! (#"('"6:, "% #(;4*#5GF!:#, 8%?15 #()(. +"*>%"!, ' @(",$!! «8*$%&!*4!+8». B%&'(% +"*>%"!% – E$( 8*$%&!*4!+8 «$%(&%$!>%#/!.», $( %#$< A!4(#(A#/!. 8*$%&!*4!+8 @&%17%#$'5GF!: E@(:; '$(&(% – 8*$%&!*4!+8 «%#$%#$'%""("*5>"6.». 3" "%&*+&6'"( #',+*" # %#$%#$'%""("*5>"68 @(+"*"!%8, ,'4,,#< %;( %#$%#$'%""68 #4%1#$'!%8. L$($ 8*$%&!*4!+8 !#:(1!$ !+ $(;(, >$( «'#% ' 8!&% #',+*"( # %#$%#$'%""68! '%F*8!, >$( '#,/(% 1%.#$'!% !8%%$ #'(G @&!>!"5, '#,/*, @&!>!"* @&(!+'(1!$ #'(% 1%.#$'!%… 3" &%7!$%4<"( ($'%&;*%$ #5%'%&!, ! @(1()"6% !8 @&%1#$*'4%"!, ( #'%&:I%#$%#$'%""6: @&(2%##*:… K4, "%;( "%&*+1%4<"*, #',+< 8*$%&!!, A(&86 ! #!46 #*8* #()(. @(",$"*». K4, 5>%"6: $*/(. 8*$%&!*4!+8 ,'4,%$#, >%8-$( #*8( #()(. &*+58%GF!8#,. 3" @&(>"( 5$'%&1!4#, ' #!#$%8% '+;4,1(' %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., %;( "%():(1!8(#$<
186
14, "!: (>%'!1"*. «L$($ %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. 8*$%&!*4!+8, – @!#*4 =%//%4<, – #$(4< 1*'"( ()F%@&!+"*" '( '#%. ()7!&"(. ()4*#$! "%(&;*"!>%#/(;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, ' A!+!/% ! :!8!!, ' 8!"%&*4(;!! ! ;%(4(;!!, >$( "!/$( 5?% "% #(8"%'*%$#, ' %;( @(4"(@&*'"(#$!» ($*8 ?%, #. 38). N$( /*#*%$#, (&;*"!>%#/(;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, )!(4(;!>%#/!: "*5/, $( +1%#< %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. 8*$%&!*4!+8, /*/ +*8%>*%$ =%//%4<, «%F% 8"(;!% (#@*&!'*G$, "!>%;(, (1"*/(, "% @&($!'(@(#$*'4,, %85, /&(8% 8%$*A!+!>%#/(;( @&!+&*/* ?!+"%""(. #!46 !4! $%(4(;!>%#/!: 1(;8». R( @&()!'*GF%% #%)% 1(&(;5 @&!+"*"!% %1!"#$'* '#%. @&!&(16, 1%.#$'!, ' "%. ()F!: +*/("(' #@(#()#$'5%$ 5$'%&?1%"!G %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* ! ' )!(4(;!>%#/!: "*5/*:. «C E$(8 #86#4%, – +*/4G>*%$ =%//%4<, – '#% $(>"(% %#$%#$'(+"*"!% # +*/("(8 @&!>!""(#$! '( ;4*'% – >!#$( «8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(%». W#$%#$'%""( @(E$(85, >$( =%//%4< "!>%;( "% !8%4 @&($!' $(;(, >$()6 )6$< 8*$%&!*4!#$(8 ' E$(8 #86#4%. 3" @&!+"*'*4 !1%"$!>"(#$< #'(!: A!4(#(A#/!: '(++&%"!. # %#$%#$'%""("*5>"68 8*$%&!*4!+8(8. R( (" $%8 "% 8%"%% "% #(;4*7*4#, "*+'*$< #'(% 8!&('(++&%"!% 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!8 ''!15 "*4!>!, %F% (1"(;( +"*>%"!, #4('* «8*$%&!*4!+8», !8%""( $*/(;(, /($(&(% ! ($$*4/!'*4( ($ 8*$%&!*4!+8* '(()F%. =%//%4< "*+6'*4 8*$%&!*4!+8 ' E$(8 $&%$<%8 %;( +"*>%"!! "&*'#$'%""68 !4! E$!>%#/!8. «L$($ «' #()#$'%""(8 #86#4%» 8*$%&!*4!+8 ' %;( @&*/$!>%#/(8 (#5F%#$'4%"!! "% @&%#4%15%$ "!/*/(. 1&5;(. 2%4!, /&(8% "*!'(+8(?"( )(4%% 5$(">%""(;( >5'#$'%""(;( "*#4*?1%"!,… B(E$(85 "*@&*#"( !F5$ %;( 5 $%: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ! A!4(#(A(', 14, /($(&6: '6#7%% "*#4*?1%"!% – 15:('"(% "*#4*?1%"!% @&!&(1(. ! 5 /($(&6: '6#7*, 2%4< – @(+"*"!% @&!&(16. L$($ 8*$%&!*4!+8 "*1( !#/*$< ' >%&$(;*: '#%: $%: :*"?%., /($(&6%, @&!/&6'*,#< 8*#/(. )4*;(>%#$!,, #$&%8,$#, 4!7< / 8*$%&!*4<"68 )4*;*8» ($*8 ?%, #. 38-39). H$*/, =%//%4< "% ($;(&*?!'*4#, @(4"(#$%#/!8, "( 4!7< ' (1"(8, #$&(;( (;&*"!>%""(8 +"*>%"!! E$(;( #4('*. 3" @!#*4, ' >*#$"(#$!: « R!/(85 !+ A!+!/(' !4! :!8!/(', 8!"%&*4(;(' !4! *#$&("(8(' "% @&!1%$ ' ;(4('5 !#/*$< ! !##4%1('*$< ' ,'4%"!,:, @(14%?*F!: !: "*5>"(85 !+5>%"!G, 2%4%#(()&*+"(% 1%.#$'!% (#()(. #!46. R*@&($!', ("! &*##8*$&!'*G$ E$! ,'4%"!, !#/4G>!$%4<"( /*/ "%():(1!8(% ! "%!+8%""(% 1%.#$'!% A!+!>%#/!: ! :!8!>%#/!: #!4, #'(.#$'%""6: '%F%#$'5 !4! 8*$%&!!; ' E$(8 ($"(7%"!! "*7% 8!&('(++&%"!% >!#$( «8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(%», ' (@&%1%4%""(8 #86#4% E$(;( 8"(;(+"*>!$%4<"(;( #4('*» ($*8 ?%, #. 29). R( /(4< #/(&( #5F%#$'5G$ ! 1&5;!% +"*>%"!,, #@(#()"6% $(4$()6 "% '"(#!$< @5$*"!26, #>!$*4 =%//%4<, 45>7% #('#%8 ($/*+*$<#, ($ E$(;( @(",$!, ' (@&%1%4%"!! 8!&('(++&%"!, ! +*8%"!$< %;( 1&5;!8, (1"(+"*>"68. L$( 1&5;(% @(",$!% – «8("!+8». H8%""( $*/ ! "*+'*4 =%//%4< #!#$%85 #'(!: A!4(#(A#/!: '+;4,1(', @(1>%&/"5' @&! E$(8, >$( 8("!+8 «'6&*?*%$ ,#"(% ! 2%4<"(% 8!&('(++&%"!% %#$%#$'(+"*"!, /("2* XIX #$(4%$!,», ,'4,%$#,
187
«+*'%$"68 5)%?1%"!%8 (;&(8"(;( )(4<7!"#$'* #('&%8%""6: 86#4,F!: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. – "( !8%""( 86#4,F!:» (95, #. 446). C6&*?*, A!4(#(A#/!% '(++&%"!, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/*, 8("!+8, @( 8"%"!G =%//%4,, "*>*4 #/4*16'*$<#, +"*>!$%4<"( &*"<7%. H#$(/! 8("!+8*, A(&8!&('*"!% %;( (#"('"6: @&!"2!@(' =%//%4< '(+'(1!4 / '(++&%"!,8 1&%'"%;&%>%#/!: A!4(#(A('-8*$%&!*4!#$('. 3" @!#*4, ' >*#$"(#$!: «0*4%#, 9"*/#!8%" ! 9"*/#!8*"1&, (#()%""( ?% @(#4%1"!. '6#/*+*4! '*?"6% (#"('"6% @(4(?%"!, "*7%;( #('&%8%""(;( 8("!+8*. 3"! 5?% 5>!4! ( %1!"(8 %#$%#$'%""(8 +*/("%, /*/ @%&'(. @&!>!"% &*+"(()&*+"6: ,'4%"!., ( %1!"#$'% '#%. @&!&(16 ! ( @(#$(,""(. #8%"% A(&8… J*/?% ' )(4%% @(+1"%% '&%8, 86 "*:(1!8 ' "*$5&A!4(#(A!! =%&*/4!$* ! L8@%1(/4* ! ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: #(>!"%"!,: K%8(/&!$* ! 9&!#$($%4, '%#<8* >*#$(% #('@*1%"!% # $%8! @&%1#$*'4%"!,8!, /($(&6% #(#$*'4,G$ A5"1*8%"$ "*#$(,F%;( 5>%"!, ( &*+'!$!!» (89, #. 63-64). V1%#< $*/?% #( '#%. (>%'!1"(#$%#/*, @(1(@4%/* «8("!+8*» =%//%4,. R( #*8 5>%"6. !+)&*4 !"5G (&!%"$*2!G ' :*&*/$%&!#$!/% #'(%. A!4(#(A#/(. @(+!2!!, ' ()(#"('*"!! %% ($"(7%"!, / (#"('"68 A!4(#(A#/!8 "*@&*'4%"!,8. 3" #>!$*4, >$( @(",$!% «8("!+8», '6&*?*GF%% (#"('"(% #(1%&?*"!% 8!&('(++&%"!, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., 7!&% @(",$!, «8*$%&!*4!+8». B(#4%1"!., @( 8"%"!G =%//%4,, – (1"(#$(&(""%% "*@&*'4%"!% «8("!+8*». 31"(#$(&(""(#$< 8*$%&!*4!+8* 5>%"6. '!1%4 ' $(8, >$(, «#(;4*#"( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(85 8!&('(++&%"!G, 8*$%&!,, !4! '%F%#$'(, #5F%#$'5%$ &*"<7%, >%8 1'!?%"!%, !4! ?!'*, #!4*; '%F%#$'( #(+1*4( #!45!» L";%4<#, @&!'%1, E$( '6#/*+6'*"!% =%//%4,, $*/ %;( @&(/(88%"$!&('*4: «L$( #$(4< ?% "%'%&"(, /*/ ! 5$'%&?1%"!%, >$( #!4* #(+1*4* '%F%#$'(, !)( #!4* ! '%F%#$'( "%($1%4!86 1&5; ($ 1&5;*». H +*/4G>!4: «=1% (" '6/(@*4 #'(. 8*$%&!*4!+8? (406, #. 523). P$(4< ?% (1"(#$(&(""!8, /*/ ! 8*$%&!*4!+8, ,'4,4#,, ' @&%1#$*'4%"!! =%//%4,, ! !1%*4!+8, @&(,'4%"!%8 /($(&(;( '( '+;4,1*: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX %/* )64 C"*$#*-',:. K4, =%//%4, (>%'!1"* %;( "%#(#$(,$%4<"(#$<, /*/ &*+"('!1"(#$! #('&%8%""(;( %85 «#@!&!$5*4!+8*» (#8. 95, #. 462-463). R( /(4< #/(&( ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. 8*$%&!*4!+8 ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. !1%*4!+8 (#@!&!$5*4!+8) (1"(#$(&(""% :*&*/$%&!+5G$ A!4(#(A#/!% '+;4,16 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., (#"('6'*GF!%#, "* %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 8*$%&!*4%, $( =%//%4< '!1%4 "%():(1!8(#$< ' !: ()I%1!"%"!!, ' !: @&!8!&%"!! ' &*8/*: )(4%% ()F%;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, – «8("!+8*». 3" @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «J(4*."6. B&! '#%: #'(!: :*&*/$%&!#$!/*: 8*$%&!*4!+8* =%//%4< +*)6'*%$ ( ;4*'"(., (#"('(@(4*;*GF%., &%7*GF!8 ()&*+(8 (@&%1%4,GF%. A!4(#(A#/5G
188
@(+!2!G >%4('%/*. C ($"(7%"!! 8*$%&!*4!+8* %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4< =%//%4< 1(@5#/*4 $5 ?% @&!"2!@!*4<"5G (7!)/5, >$( ! A!4(#(A 0%.%&)*:, (7!)/5, #(#$(,'75G, @( #4('*8 L";%4<#*, ' $(8, >$( (" «#8%7!'*%$… 8*$%&!*4!+8 /*/ ()F%% 8!&('(++&%"!%, (#"('*""(% "* (@&%1%4%""(8 @("!8*"!! ($"(7%"!, 8*$%&!! ! 15:*, # $(. (#()(. A(&8(., ' /($(&(. '6&*?*4(#< E$( 8!&('(++&%"!% "* (@&%1%4%""(. !#$(&!>%#/(. #$5@%"!» (407, #. 288). *$%&!*4!+8 /*/ ()F%% 8!&('(++&%"!%, (#"('*""(% "* (@&%1%4%""(8 @("!8*"!! ($"(7%"!, 8*$%&!! ! #(+"*"!,, '(()F% ($#5$#$'5%$ ' @&%1#$*'4%"!,: =%//%4,. C8%#$( E$(;( (" ;('(&!$ ( «$%(&%$!>%#/(8» 8*$%&!*4!+8%, $( %#$< A!4(#(A#/(8 8*$%&!*4!+8% @&%17%#$'5GF!: E@(:, ( «%#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8» 8*$%&!*4!+8%, $( %#$< () (#()(. A(&8%, ' /($(&(. E$( ()F%% 8!&('(++&%"!% @&(,'!4(#< ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, @&!8%"!$%4<"( / %;( #@%2!A!>%#/(85 8*$%&!*45; ;('(&!$ ! ( 8*$%&!*4!+8% «"&*'#$'%""(8», /($(&6. ! '('#% "% !8%%$ "!>%;( ()F%;( # 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 /*/ ()F!8 8!&('(++&%"!%8, "( +*$( ' @(4"(. 8%&% #(($'%$#$'5%$ A!4!#$%&#/!8 @&%1#$*'4%"!,8 ( 8*$%&!*4!+8%. L";%4<# @!#*4, >$( «@(1 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 A!4!#$%& @("!8*%$ ()?(&#$'(, @<,"#$'(, @(:($<, @4($#/!% "*#4*?1%"!, ! $F%#4*'!%, /(&6#$(4G)!%, #/5@(#$<, *4>"(#$<, @(;("G +* )*&67(8 ! )!&?%'6% @45$"!, /(&(>% – '#% $% ;&,+"6% @(&(/!, /($(&68 (" #*8 @&%1*%$#, '$*."%» ($*8 ?%, #. 290). 3 =%//%4%, /*/ ! ( 0%.%&)*:%, 8(?"( #/*+*$< #4('*8! L";%4<#*, >$( (" )64 «#('%&7%""( @&*', ($/4(",, ($ #%), '#,/5G ($'%$#$'%""(#$< +* E$($ 8*$%&!*4!+8»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«X '#%2%4( @&!1%&?!'*G#< $*/!: &%*4<"6: "*5>"6: "*>*4, /($(&6% '('#% >5?16 1'5:, @(-'!1!8(85, ;(#@(1#$'5GF!: ' @(#4%1"%% '&%8, $%>%"!. ' #$(&("6: 5$!4!$*&"(;(
189
8*$%&!*4!+8* ! /4*##!>%#/(;( #@!&!$5*4!+8*, #$&%8,F%;(#, ! 15: #'%#$! / '!1*8 A!+!/(–8%:*"!>%#/(. E"%&;!!» (260, #. 316). 37!)(>"(#$< @("!8*"!, %"1%4%%'68 8*$%&!*4!+8*, * &*'"( ! !1%*4!+8*, ()"*&5?!'*%$#, #( '#%. (>%'!1"(#$!$*4, >$( $*/!% @(",$!,, /*/ @(",$!% 8!&('(;( EA!&*, «(#$*G$#, *)#$&*/$"68! !4! 58#$'%""(. /("2%@2!%., @(1()"( $(., /($(&*, '%1%$ ! / #*8(85 5>%"!G ( "%8"(;!: #*8(#$(,$%4<"6: :!8!>%#/!: E4%8%"$*:, !+ /(!: #4*;*G$#, '#% '%F%#$'* @&!&(16» ($*8 ?%, #. 424-425). R* (#"('*"!! E$(;( %"1%4%%' #1%4*4 '6'(1, >$( «%#$%#$'(+"*"!% ' #'(!: /(&%""6: (#"('*: #(#$*'4,%$ ()4*#$<, @&("!/"5$5G !1%*4!+8(8, :($, ' #'(!: !#:(1"6: $(>/*: :*&*/$%&!+5%$#, /*?5F!8#, '#%()I%84GF!8 8*$%&!*4!+8(8» ($*8 ?%, #. 425). *$%&!*4!+8, ' @("!8*"!! %"1%4%%'*, '6&*?*%$#, ' @&!+"*"!! «"*>*4* '#%: "*>*4», /*/('68 ,'4,%$#, %1!"*, 8*$%&!,, @%&'(8*$%&!,, #(#$*'4,GF*, (#"('5 '#%: @&%18%$(' ! ,'4%"!.. B(#/(4%#$'% @%&'((#"('6 '#%;( #5F%#$'5GF%;( 8"(;!: :!8!>%#/!: E4%8%"$(' ('8%#$( %1!"(. 8*$%&!!), $( ! 8*$%&!*4!+8 #*8 @( #%)% ' #!45 E$(;( (/*+*4#, 14, "%;( "%@&!%84%868. H1%*4!+8 ?% "% %#$< "%>$( @&($!'(#$(,F%% 8*$%&!*4!+85. 3" @&%1#$*'4,%$ #()(. 4!7< *)#$&*/$"(#$<, «58#$'%""(#$<»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«%#$%#$'%""(. A!4(#(A!!», $( 4!7< ' #!45 $&*1!2!!, #4(?!'7%.#, %F% ' 1&%'"(#$!, ! @&!$(8 A!;5&!&5%$ '( '"%7"%8 '6&*?%"!! &%7%"!., 4!7< ' ()61%""(8 @(",$!."(8 ()!:(1%, "( "% ' #*8(. (#"('% «%#$%#$'%""(. A!4(#(A!!». J*/, "*@&!8%&, ()#$(,4( 1%4( ' @("!8*"!! @&!&(16 '%F%#$'*. H+4(?!' !#:(1"6% @5"/$6 5>%"!, K%8(/&!$* ' 1*""(8 '(@&(#%, %"1%4%%' 1%4*%$ '6'(1: «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
190
5>%"!,8! P(/&*$* ! L@!/5&* ' ($"(7%"!! / '%F%#$'5» ($*8 ?%, #. 558-559). L$( &*+4!>!% «' (#"('% 1%4*» %"1%4%%' '!1%4 ' #4%15GF%8: «3)* ("! (P(/&*$ ! L@!/5&. – C.3.), /*/ K%8(/&!$ ! 9&!#$($%4<, @(#@%7*, 1(#$!;"5$< %1!"#$'* ! 8%$*A!+!>%#/(. 2%4<"(#$!, #$&%8!4!#< 58%"<7!$< >!#4( !#:(1"6: /*$%;(&!., * !8%""( !4! #!45 '6'(1!4! !+ '%F%#$'*, !4! '%F%#$'( !+ #!46; $(;1* /*/ %#$%#$'%""*, A!4(#(A!, "*7%;( '&%8%"! @&!+"*%$ ()% E$! /*$%;(&!!, @(#/(4*G$#, ' #5F%#$'5GF%8 @&%1#$*'4%"!!, /*/ #*8(#$(,$%4<"6% ! "%+*'!#!86%. 3"* "% #@%7!$ @&("!/"5$< «"*>*4( '#%: "*>*4», * #$*&*%$#,, #4%15, @( #$(@*8 M(@%&"!/*, =*4!4%, ! R"6: !+8%&%"!., !+ (@6$* ! !+ "*)4G1%"!. '(#:(1!$< @&! @(8(F! 1(@5#$!86: ;!@($%+, (@6$*8! '"('< @( '(+8(?"(#$! @&('%&,%868!, 1( @("!8*"!, @&!&(16 '%F%#$'* ! ,'4%"!. # "!8 #('%&7*GF!:#,, '('#% "% '1*'*,#< ' @(#$&(%"!% /( '#%85 @&!4(?!8(;( 8%$*A!+!>%#/(;( 5>%"!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 559). H"68! #4('*8!, /*/ ! =%//%4<, %"1%4%%' @&!:(1!$ / @&('(+;4*7%"!G (#()(., «%#$%#$'%""(.», A!4(#(A!!, A!4(#(A!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., "! 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(., "! !1%*4!#$!>%#/(.. R( %#4! 14, =%//%4, A!4(#(A!%. «86#4,F!:» %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ,'4,%$#, «8("!+8», $( 14, %"1%4%%'* A!4(#(A!%. «'158>!'6:» %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ,'4,%$#, «&%*4!+8». P5$< E$(;( @(#4%1"%;( +*/4G>*%$#, ' @&!+"*"!! "%&*+1%4<"(., "( ! "% #4!'*%8(. @(+"*'*$%4<"(. $&(!26 «'%>"6: ! #*8()6$"6:: '%F%#$'* (8*$%&!!), #!46 (E"%&;!!), ! 15:*» ($*8 ?%, #. 470). -*#/&6'*, #86#4 E$(. A(&8546, %"1%4%%' @!#*4: «WF% '( 8"(;(8 #85$"(%, "( '#% ?% @(14%?*F%% 5?% *"*4!+5 @("!8*"!% !#:(1"(. $&(!26 @(+"*"!, ('%F%#$'(, #!4* ! 15:) #(#$*'4,%$ (#"('5 #('&%8%""(;( &%*4!+8*, ;45)(/( ($4!>*GF%;(#, /*/ ($ 1&%'"%;(, $*/ ! ($ %F% "%1*'"%;(, 1*?% %F% 1("6"% &*#@&(#$&*"%""(;( 5"!$*&"(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8*, /($(&6. '#% #$&%8!$#, @(+"*$< !+ '%F%#$'* ! %;( 1'!?%"!,, ! ($ %F% )(4%% 1&%'"%;( ! $*/?% /(%-;1% %F% "% +*)6$(;( 5"!$*&"(;( ?% #@!&!$5*4!+8*, '#% /*/ )51$( @("!8*GF%;(, !#:(1, !+ 15:('"(;(. K58*G 1*?%, >$( #('&%8%""6. «&%*4!+8» ,#"%% ! @(4"%% '#%;( :*&*/$%&!+5%$#, @&!+"*"!%8 '%>"(#$!, E'(4G2!. ! #',+%.: '%F%#$'*, #!4 ! 15:*» ($*8 ?%, #. 471-472). B( 8"%"!G %"1%4%%'*, $*/ «86#4,$ '158>!'6% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4!-&%*4!#$6». -*#/&6'*, 1*4<7% #(1%&?*"!% ! #(#$(,"!% '(++&%"!. %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ! (#"('"5G $%"1%"2!G !: &*+'!$!,, %"1%4%%' @!#*4: «R( 8%?15 !#$!""68! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8! "%#(8"%""( #5F%#$'5G$, '(-@%&'6:, "%'158>!'6% E8@!&!/!, '(-'$(&6:, 8*$%&!*4!#$6 !, '-$&%$$( >!#4( "%'158>!'6: )6#$&( 58%"<7*%$#,, 8*$%&!*4!#$(' (#$*4(#< (>%"< 5?% "%8"(;(, #@!&!$5*4!#$(' ?% ! @(1*'"(» ($*8 ?%, #. 472). R%$&51"( 5#$*"('!$< !#$(>"!/ @(1()"6: @&%1#$*'4%"!.. 3"! @(>%&@"5$6 ' A!4(#(A#/(. 4!$%&*$5&% $(;( '&%8%"! – +*&5)%?"(. ! ($%>%#$'%""(.. C "%. 8*$%&!*4!+85 @&($!'(@(#$*'4,%$#, #@!&!$5*4!+8 ' %;( &*+"6: #(($"(7%"!,: # !1%*4!+8(8. C (1"!: #45>*,: ("
191
($(?1%#$'4,%$#, # !1%*4!+8(8, ' 1&5;!: @&($!'(@(#$*'4,%$#, 8*$%&!*4!+85 "*&,15 # !1%*4!+8(8. J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, J. [!;%", (@&%1%4,, #(($"(7%"!% (#"('"6: A!4(#(A#/!: "*@&*'4%"!., @!#*4: « *$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!8 $%(&!,8 @&($!'(@(#$*'4,G$#, #@!&!$5*4!#$!>%#/!%. P4('( #@!&!$5*4!+8 ' !#$(&!! A!4(#(A!! "% '#%;1* 5@($&%)4,4(#< ' (1!"*/('(8 #86#4%. V1%#< 86 (@&%1%4!8 %;( ' @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$< 8*$%&!*4!+85, /*/ $5 $%(&!G, /($(&*, &*##8*$&!'*%$ 8*$%&!*4<"6% @&(2%##6, /*/ A5"/2!G @#!:!>%#/!:, ! $*/!8 ()&*+(8 @(1>!",%$ @%&'6% @(#4%1"!8… 3)(!8 8("!#$!>%#/!8 "*@&*'4%"!,8, 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(85 ! #@!&!$5*4!#$!>%#/(85, 86 @&($!'(@(#$*'4,%8 $&%$<% ! @(#4%1"%% 8!&(#(+%&2*"!%, /($(&(% 45>7% '#%;( "*+'*$< !1%*4!#$!>%#/!8… L$( 8!&(#(+%&2*"!% "*74( #'(%;( @%&'(;( '%4!/(;( @&%1#$*'!$%4, ' Q%&/4!» (391, #. 48). P $(>/! +&%"!, 9. C'%1%"#/(;(, ($"(#!$%4<"( !1%*4!+8* «"% #4%15%$ 158*$<, )51$( )6 (" 8(?%$ )6$< $(4%#/!8. R*@&($!', (" 8(?%$ ($'%&;"5$< #5F%#$'('*"!% 157!…» (56, #. 129). C ($4!>!% ($ E$(;( =. N%4@*"(' #$*'!$ +"*/ &*'%"#$'* 8%?15 #@!&!$5*4!+8(8 ! !1%*4!+8(8: «…K(/$&!"*, 1!*8%$&*4<"( @&($!'(@(4(?"*, 1(/$&!"% 8*$%&!*4!+8*, "*+6'*%$#, 12'$'-;%7',:!: !4! '5*%7',:!:» (393, #. 22). B.R. D!"!2/!. $*/?% &*##8*$&!'*4 8*$%&!*4!+8 ! #@!&!$5*4!+8 /*/ (#"('"6% @&($!'(@(4(?"6% "*@&*'4%"!, ' A!4(#(A!!, #>!$*, @&! E$(8, >$( «#@!&!$5*4!+8 #5F"(#$%'!1"(, >$(, @( #86#45, #@!&!$5*4!+8 +1%#< "% >$( !"(%, /*/ !1%*4!+8. H, /*/ #>!$*4 . G44%&, «%#4! (1"(#$(&("%" 8*$%&!*4!+8, $( $*/ ?% (1"(#$(&("%" ! #@!&!$5*4!+8» (281, #. 437). N$( /*#*%$#, $*%7',:%, $( %;( (>%'!1"*, @&!"*14%?"(#$< / 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(85 8!&('(++&%"!G 1(#$*$(>"( (@&%1%4%""( A!/#!&('*4*#< ' A!4(#(A#/(. 4!$%&*$5&% $(;( '&%8%"!, ' &*)($*: "% $(4$( (" 1(@5#/*%$ ()I%/$!'"5G $*%78"!1-8 '"%7"%;( 8!&*» (56, #. 129). B( #5$!, E$( ! %#$< 8*$%&!*4!+8 !, /*/ @(1>%&/"54 1&5;(. %;( @&($!'"!/, B.K. S&/%'!>, «"*#$(,F!. 8*$%&!*4!+8 8(?%$ )6$< &*##8*$&!'*%8 /*/ @()(>"6. @&(15/$ &%*4!#$!>%#/(;( "*#$&(%"!, "*7%. 2!'!4!+*2!!» (416, #. 196). H8%""( E$( "*#$&(%"!% ' %;( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(8 /*>%#$'% ()I%/$!'"( ! '6&*+!4 K.H. %"1%4%%' ' #'(%8 «&%*4!+8%», /*/ &*"%% L. =%//%4< ' «8("!+8%». H ' (#"('*"!! E$(;( 8!&('(++&%">%#/(;( «&%*4!+8*» («8("!+8*», 8*$%&!*4!+8*) %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. – &%*4!+8 "*$5&*4<"6., $( %#$< !+"*>*4<"*,, (>%'!1"*, &%*4!#$!>"(#$< ()I%/$"(. #A%&6 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. -5##/!. A!4(#(A H.W. 3&4(' @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «W#$%#$'(+"*"!% &%*4!#$!>"(. N$( )6 "! ;('(&!4! A!4(#(A6, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4< !##4%15%$ &%*4<"6% ()I%/$6; &%*4<"(#$< @&!&(16 – "%():(1!8%.7*, @&%1@(#64/* %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,, ($ /($(&(. (" "!/(;1* "% ($/*?%$#,» (289, #. 195).
192
« ("!+8» =%//%4, ! «&%*4!+8»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– '(@&(#*, &%7%"!% /($(&(;( ! /4*1%$ '(1(&*+1%4 8%?15 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 ! !1%*4!+8(8. *$%&!*4!#$ L";%4<# @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8, >$( «"'0*#! 5$;#!#! @%&'("*>*4<"( ! "% (+"*>*G$ '6&*?%"!,: !1%*4!+8 ! 8*$%&!*4!+8» (/5&#!' 8(.. – C.3.). H $(4%#/(. A!4(#(A!!, 1(4?"6 5@($&%)4,$<#, "*+'*""6% @(",$!, ' (@&%1%4%"!! A!4(#(A#/!: @(+!2!.. H "* @&!8%&% =%//%4, ! %"1%4%%'* 86 '!1!8, «/*/*, @5$*"!2* '(+"!/*%$ ' $%: #45>*,:, /(;1* !8 @&!1*G$ /*/(%-4!)( 1&5;(% +"*>%"!%» (407, #. 283). R(, /#$*$! #/*+*$<, /&!$!/! =%//%4, !+ @&($!'(@(4(?"(;(, !1%*4!#$!>%#/(;( 4*;%&, "!/*/(. @5$*"!26 ' :*&*/$%&!#$!/% %;( A!4(#(A#/!: '+;4,1(' "% 1(@5#/*4!. 3"! "% ()8*"6'*4!#< "* E$($ #>%$: 14, "!: «8("!+8» =%//%4, ! 1&5;!: 5>%"6:, @&!1%&?!'*'7!:#, *"*4(;!>"6: '+;4,1(', )64 "! >%8 !"68, /*/ 8*$%&!*4!+8(8. J*/, #('&%8%""!/ =%//%4,, *";4!.#/!. A!+!/ 3. D(1?, /&!$!/('*'7!. %;( # !1%*4!#$!>%#/!: @(+!2!., @!#*4, :*&*/$%&!+5, #!#$%85 8("!+8* =%//%4,: «R*+'*"!% 8*$%&!*4!+8* '@(4"% @(1:(1!$ / "%., /*/ ! "*+'*"!% !1%*4!+8* / @&($!'(@(4(?"(. #!#$%8%» (216, #. 18). J(>"( $*/ ?% "%8%2/!. %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4< ! A!4(#(A W. K%""%&$ 5$'%&?1*4, >$( L. =%//%4< #$&%8!4#, &*#@&(#$&*"!$< #'(% «8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(% !4! «8("!#$!>%#/(%» 8!&('(++&%"!%» (145, #. 2). 3 «8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! =%//%4, ! %;( 5>%"!/('» @!#*4 -. 0&*"#E (#8. 384, #. 28). B(4<#/!. %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4< ! A!4(#(A C. . M(+4('#/!. #>!$*4, >$( L. =%//%4<, @(@54,&!+!&5, 1*&'!"!+8, «#$*&*4#, ()I%1!"!$< %;( # 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 (' %;( 2%4(8) ' (1"( 8!&('(++&%"!%, "*+'*""(% !8 ?% 8("!#$!>%#/!8» (175, #. 56). -5##/!. /&!$!/ =%//%4,, @&(A%##(& M.=. =&!;(&<%' #( #'(%. #$(&("6 @(1>%&/"54, >$( «8("!+8 =%//%4,… "!>%8 "% ($4!>*%$#, ($ 8*$%&!*4!+8*» (132, #. 77). K&5;(. @&(A%##(& (@*$(4(;!!), 9. T!4$(' #$*'!4 =%//%4, ' (1!" &,1 #( «#$*&68! 8("!#$*8! ! 8*$%&!*4!#$*8!, /*/('6 QG:"%&, 0(;$, (4%7($$, 0%.%&)*: ! @&.» (395, #. 2). O @&($!'"!/(' 8*$%&!*4!+8* 8(?"( ($8%$!$< ! 1&5;!% A!4(#(A#/!% *"*4(;!! ' (@&%1%4%"!! #5F"(#$! 8!&('(++&%"!, =%//%4,, ' >*#$"(#$!, #(($"%#%"!% %;( «8("!+8*» # @*"$%!+8(8 P@!"(+6. J*/, "*@&!8%&, "%8%2/!. @&(A%##(& J. [!;%", &*##8*$&!'*, &*+'!$!% 8*$%&!*4!+8* ' XVIII–XIX '%/*:, "*>!"*, # D*8%$$&!, 5@(8!"*%$ ! «"% (#()%""( >!#$6. '*&!*"$ 8*$%&!*4!+8*», /($(&6. «%F% (>%"< !+4G)4%" '( 8"(;!: %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: /&5;*:. B( !8%"! #'(%;( ;4*'"(;( @&%1#$*'!$%4, E$($
193
'*&!*"$ 45>7% '#%;( 8(?%$ )6$< "*+'*" =%//%4%'#/!8… =!@($%+* =%//%4, #(%1!",%$ ' #%)% @#%'1(–8("!+8 P@!"(+6 # 8*$%&!*4!+8(8, !4!, '%&"%%, ("* "%(@&%1%4%""( /(4%)4%$#, 8%?15 ()(!8!» (391, #. 47). -. 0*4$( =%//%4< ' #'(%8 «8("!+8%» 5:'*$!4#, «+* #@!"(+('#/5G @*&*44%4< 8*$%&!*4<"(;( ! 15:('"(;( #5F%#$'('*"!,» (367, #. 552). 9"*4(;!>"(. $(>/! +&%"!, @&!1%&?!'*4#, ! $*/(. &5##/!. /&!$!/ 8*$%&!*4!+8*, /*/ @&(A%##(& =. N%4@*"(': «C%#<8* >*#$( ;('(&,$, >$( =%//%4< 8*$%&!*4!#$… C 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! (" "% @&(#$( 8*$%&!*4!#$, * #/(&%% @(1:(1!$ / $(85 $!@5, /($(&6. ()6/"('%""( "*+6'*%$#, #@!"(+!+8(8…» (393, #. 317). Q(4%% (#$(&(?%" ' E$(8 '(@&(#% L. Q5$&5, @( 8"%"!G /($(&(;( «=%//%4< #/(&%% #)4!?*%$, "%?%4! 1%.#$'!$%4<"( ()I%1!",%$ K*&'!"* ! P@!"(+5» (46, #. 150). 9. C'%1%"#/!. $*/?% @(4*;*4, >$( «' '(++&%"!,: =%//%4, "% )%+ (#"('*"!, "*:(1!4! &(1#$'( # !1%,8! P@!"(+6: &*+"!2* 8%?15 "!8! 4!7< ' $(8, >$( @%&'6. /4*1%$ 2%"$& $,?%#$! "* 8*$%&!*4<"(8 8(8%"$% #5F%#$'5GF%;( ! ($(?%#$'4,%$ 8("!+8 # 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, $(;1* /*/ P@!"(+* '#% &*+&%7*%$ ' #'(G #5)#$*"2!G, "*>*4( !1%*4<"(%» (57, #. 83). P$(!$ $*/?% ($8%$!$<, >$( ! A!4(#(A6–8*&/#!#$6, 5)%?1%""6%, @(#4%1('*$%4<"6% 8*$%&!*4!#$6, (1"(+"*>"( ! )%+(;('(&(>"( !"$%&@&%$!&('*4! «8("!+8» =%//%4,, %;( A!4(#(A#/(% 8!&('(++&%"!%, /*/ (@&%1%4%""5G A(&85 8*$%&!*4!+8*. J*/, 0. %&!";, #>!$*4, >$( «=%//%4< – 8*$%&!*4!#$ ! 8("!#$, "( "% '1-!$'0*16'=, * %#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/!. 8*$%&!*4!#$» (2!$. B(: 204, #. 377). B( 8"%"!G =.C. B4%:*"('*, «8("!+8» ;%//%4, %#$< "% >$( !"(%, /*/ >!#$( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(% – !, ' #5F"(#$!, )4!+/(% / A%.%&)*:('#/(85 – 5>%"!% () %1!"#$'% #5)I%/$* ! ()I%/$*» (309, #. 138). C.H. D%"!" @!#*4 ( =%//%4% /*/ ( %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%, @(/*+*'7%8, >$( «%#$< 5#$(., /($(&6. #$*"('!$#, '#% 7!&% ! /&%@>%… E$($ 5#$(. – *1-*1-9*""!'1-!$'0*16'= :%-*$'%7',:» (204, #. 372). B&($!'"!/! 8*$%&!*4!+8*, 8"(;(>!#4%""6% /&!$!/! =%//%4,, @( /&*."%. 8%&% – "%/($(&6% !: "!:, #$*&*,#< (@&('%&;"5$< %;( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!% 8!&('(++&%">%#/!% '6'(16, $%8 "% 8%"%% )64! '6"5?1%"6 @&!+"*$<, >$( 8*$%&!*4!+8 («8("!+8») =%//%4, "% )64 )%#@(>'%""68: (" /(&%"!4#, ' #*8(8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, (#"('6'*4#, "* %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 8%$(1% @(+"*"!,. J*/, (1!" !+ #*86: "%@&!8!&!86: !1%."6: @&($!'"!/(' =%//%4,, &5##/!. A!+!/ 3.K. U'(4<#(" 5$'%&?1*4, >$( «=%//%4< "%#(8"%""( ,'4,%$#, (1"!8 !+ '%4!>*.7!: +"*$(/(' E$(;( 8%$(1*; (" 1%.#$'!$%4<"( E$!8 8%$(1(8 ()4*1*%$, 58%%$ !8 @(4<+('*$<#, ' #'(!: #@%2!*4<"6: ! ()F!: )!(4(;!>%#/!: &*)($*:, ! +"*/(8#$'( # "!8, "%#(8"%""(, ! # "*14%?*F%G #$&(;(#$%"!/('» (387, #. 119). P$&(;( #4%15, E$(85 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(85 8%$(15, (#"('6'*,#< "* %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: A*/$*: ! $%(&!,:, =%//%4< ! @&!:(1!4 / #(($'%$#$'5GF!8 A!4(#(A#/!8, 8!&('(++&%">%#/!8 5#$*"('4%"!,8; @&! E$(8 (", /*/ @!#*4 9. K(1%4<, «()4*1*4 85?%#$'(8, /*/ ! @($&%)"(#$*#$"(#$!,
194
«$%(&!, &*+'!$!,, ''%1%""*, ' "*5/5 K*&'!"(8 ! %;( 5>%"!/(8 ! #($&51"!/(8 =%//%4%8, (#"('*"* "* @(",$!!, 1!*8%$&*4<"( @&($!'(@(4(?"(8 @(",$!G #($'(&%"!,, "* @(",$!! ( '(#:(1,F%8 &*+'!$!!, ( @(#$%@%""(8 @%&%:(1% ($ "!+7%;( #(#$(,"!, ' '6#7%%; "% () 5@*1/% ! &*+4(?%"!! ;('(&!$ ("*, * ( #$&%84%"!! / :(&(7%85, / 45>7%85, * 1*4<7% ($ 45>7%;( / #('%&7%""(85 – ' "%@&%&6'"(8 1'!?%"!! '@%&%1, ! E$( 1'!?%"!% '%>"(. V*/(" &*+'!$!, 1%.#$'('*4 ' @&(74(8, (" 1%.#$'!$%4%" ! 14, )515F%;(» ($*8 ?%, #. 65). B(",$"(, >$( @&!+"*"!% $*/(;( +*/("(8%&"(;( %#$%#$'%""(;( E'(4G2!("!+8* ' @&!&(1% !#/4G>*4( 1%.#$'!% ' "%. '"%7"%. $'(&,F%. ! "*@&*'4,GF%. #'%&:I%#$%#$'%""(. #!46, >$( @!$*4( ! 5/&%@4,4( ' 8!&('(++&%"!! =%//%4, *$%!#$!>%#/!% – 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!% ' #'(%. (#"('% – 5)%?1%"!,, /($(&6% (" ($/&6$( ! &%7!$%4<"( @&('(+;4*7*4 ! 1(/*+*$%4<"( ($#$*!'*4, >%8 '6+'*4 "* #%), (;("< (?%#$(>%""(. /&!$!/! #( #$(&("6 #',F%""(#45?!$%4%. ! '%&5GF!: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%.. J*/, &5##/!. #',F%""!/ R. D!@#/!. @!#*4: «R*!)(4%% (@*#"68 @&($!'"!/(8 :&!#$!*"#/(. &%4!;!! ' "*#$(,F%% '&%8, ,'4,%$#, L&"#$ =%//%4< #( #'(!8 "*$5&*4!#$!>%#/!–8("!#$!>%#/!8 8!&('(++&%"!%8» (213, #. 5). K4, .D. 94%/#*"1&('* =%//%4< – «($I,'4%""6. *$%!#$, @()(&"!/ «E'(4G2!("!+8*», /($(&6. «'6#$*'!4 2%46. *&#%"*4 A!4(#(A#/!: (&51!. ! ()I,'!4 #$&*7"5G '(."5 "%"*'!#$"(. %85 @(>%85-$( $&*1!2!(""(. '%&% ' &*+58"(;( Q(;* ! )%##8%&$!% 157!. 3" "*@&,;*%$ '#% #!46 E"%&;!!, 58* ! ;!)/(#$! @%&*, #$*&*,#< '( >$( )6 $( "! #$*4( '6&'*$< %% !+ #%&12* «7!&(/(. @5)4!/!» ! "*"%#$! %. #8%&$%4<"6. 51*&» (6, #. 16). B( 8"%"!G *";4!.#/(;( A!+!/* 3. D(1?*, =%//%4< «#4!7/(8 "%@&!"5?1%""( ! 4%;/(86#4%""( "*@*1*%$ "* &%4!;!G… 3" #8($&!$ "* "%%, /*/ "* #!#$%85 '&*?1%)"(;( "*5/% :*"?%#$'*…» (216, #. 65). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, «8("!+8» =%//%4,, /*/ ! «&%*4!+8» %"1%4%%'*, %#$< "% >$( !"(%, /*/ #5)I%/$!'"( @&%1#$*'4%""(% '6&*?%"!% ()I%/$!'"( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(;( A!4(#(A#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, ()(!: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., @(1()"(;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(85 8*$%&!*4!+85 8"(;!: 1&5;!: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. – @&%17%#$'%""!/(' ! #('&%8%""!/('. R(, ' /("2% /("2(', @&! (@&%1%4%"!!, @&! /("/&%$"(. !1%"$!A!/*2!! @&!"2!@!*4<"(. A!4(#(A#/(. @(+!2!! $(;( !4! !"(;( 86#4!$%4,, #5F%#$'%""( '*?"( "% $(4%#/! &%7*%$ (#"('(@(4*;*GF!% '(@&(#6 A!4(#(A#/(;( :*&*/$%&*. L$( ' @(4"(. 8%&% ($"(#!$#, ! / A!4(#(A#$'5GF!8 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8. B&!8%"!$%4<"( / "!8 ' $*/(8 #45>*% @%&'(#$%@%""(% +"*>%"!% !8%G$ "% !: 1%/4*&*$!'"6% +*,'4%"!, ( $(8, /%8 ("! #%), #>!$*G$ – 8*$%&!*4!#$*8! !4! !1%*4!#$*8!, 8("!#$*8! !4! &%*4!#$*8!, * #5F"(#$"(% @("!8*"!% ! ()I,#"%"!% !8! 8*$%&!! ' %% )6$!! ! &*+'!$!!, #(+"*"!, ' %;( #(($"(7%"!! # 8*$%&!%. ! $.@. H +1%#<, ' @&%()4*1*GF!: '6'(1*:, ' &*+I,#",GF!: #5?1%"!,: 5>%"6: &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( @%&!(1*, ()"*&5?!'*%$#, 5?% )(4<7*, (@&%1%4%""(#$<, @(+'(4,GF*, (1"(+"*>"(
195
!"$%&@&%$!&('*$< !: A!4(#(A#/!% '(++&%"!, /*/ ,'"( :%-*$'%7'1-'0*16'*, ()5#4('4%""6% ' E$(8 #'(%8 8!&('(++&%">%#/(8 /*>%#$'% 1(#$!?%"!,8! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, #()#$'%""(. !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$%"6: "* @%&%1"%8 /&*% "*5/!. § 7. %;FD8=;3=CB = D4FD4F52CE;E=D: >8=CE;E=9 A=3242A25 B&!>!""(–#4%1#$'%""5G #',+< 8*$%&!*4!+8* %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. – 1* ! A!4(#(A(' $(?% – # 1(#$!?%"!,8! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, $*/ !4! !"*>% @&!+"*'*4! ! 8"(;(>!#4%""6% @&($!'"!/! 8*$%&!*4!+8*. J*/, (1!" !+ "!:, J. [!;%", @(#%$('*4 "* $(, >$( 8*$%&!*4!+8 «58%4 @(4<+('*$<#, '#%8! 5#@%:*8! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, ! >*#$( 1*?% ($(?1%#$'4,4 #%), # "!8!; 1*?% %;( @&($!'"!/! >*#$( (/*+6'*4!#< "*#$(4$( ($(?1%#$'4,4! "*1%?"6% "('6% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6% ($/&6$!, # 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(G ;!@($%+(.» (391, #. 45-46). B&! E$(8 ! [!;%", ! 1&5;!% *"$!8*$%&!*4!#$6 #*85 #5F"(#$< 8*$%&!*4!+8* @("!8*4! ! (@&%1%4,4! @(-&*+"(85. N*F% '#%;( E$* #5F"(#$< #'(1!4*#< / *)#(4G$!+*2!! 8*$%&!*4<"(;( "*>*4* ' >%4('%>%#/(8 (&;*"!+8%, / ($&!2*"!G #@%2!A!>"(#$! 15:('"(;( "*>*4*, / %;( &*#$'(&%"!G ' 8*$%&!*4<"(8. J($ ?% [!;%", &*##8*$&!'*, 8*$%&!*4!+8 @(1 E$!8 5;4(8 +&%"!,, '61%4,%$ ' /*>%#$'% "*>*4<"(;( '*&!*"$* 8*$%&!*4!+8 A&*"25+#/(;( A!4(#(A* XVIII '%/* D*8%$&!: «…B#!:!>%#/!% @&(2%##6 #5$< #('%&7%""( $*/!% ?% @&(15/$6 8(+;*, /*/, "*@&!8%&, 1'!?%"!% – @&(15/$ 8672 /("%>"(#$%.. W1!"#$'%""*, &*+"!2* +*/4G>*%$#, )51$( )6 ' $(8, >$( 8(+; '#4%1#$'!% #'(%;( )(4%% $("/(;( #(#$*'* ! @&(!+'(1!$ "%>$( )(4%% $("/(%» ($*/ ?%, #. 45). B&!+"*', >$( «# $%: @(& 8*$%&!*4!+8 '6#$5@*4 ' 8"(;(>!#4%""6: '*&!*"$*:», [!;%" @&!8%"!$%4<"( / XIX '%/5 '61%4,%$, ' >*#$"(#$!, $*/!% '*&!*"$6, /*/ 8*$%&!*4!+8 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4, M. 0(;$* ! 8*$%&!*4!+8 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4, L. =%//%4,. H8%, ' '!15 8*$%&!*4!+8 ' $%: ?% %;( '*&!*"$*:, A!4(#(A– @(+!$!'!#$ H. B%$2(4<1$ @(1>%&/"54, >$( 2%4%#(()&*+"( «;('(&!$< ( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(8 8!&('(++&%"!! 4!7< $*8, ;1% ,'"( !-$'+%*-1( 15:('"(%; * @&(!+(.$! E$( 8(?%$ 4!7< ' $(8 #45>*%, %#4! @&%1'*&!$%4<"( 15:('"(% ! 8*$%&!*4<"(% @&($!'(@(#$*'4,4!#< 1&5; 1&5;5 ' /*>%#$'% #('%&7%""( &*+"(&(1"6: '%F%.» (300, #. 45). K&5;(. A!4(#(A, Q. T8!1 5$'%&?1*4, >$( «#(;4*#"( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(85 8!&(#(+%&2*"!G, 8*$%&!, @&%1#$*'4,%$ #()(G #5F"(#$< '%F%.. C#% )6$!%, A!+!>%#/(% ! 15:('"(%, 8*$%&!*4<"( !4! ()5#4('4%"( 8*$%&!%.» (373, #. 10). Q(4%% /("/&%$"( $*/(% @("!8*"!% 8*$%&!*4!+8* '6&*+!4 ' #'(%8 %;( (@&%1%4%"!! 0. B*54<#%": 8*$%&!*4!+8 %#$< «$* ("$(4(;!>%#/*, $%(&!,, /($(&*, "* '(@&(# ( @&!&(1% 1%.#$'!$%4<"(;( ($'%>*%$: #5F%%, /*/ $*/('(%, %#$< $%4(, %;( (@&%1%4%"!, #5$< @&($,?%"!% ! "%@&("!2*%8(#$<, %;( @%&'*, ! #()#$'%""*, A(&8* 1%,$%4<"(#$! %#$< 1'!?%"!%. H+ E$!: "*>*4 8(;5$ !
196
1(4?"6 )6$< ()I,#"%"6 '#% ,'4%"!, 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!, ' >*#$"(#$!, ! $*/ "*+6'*%86% ,'4%"!, #(+"*"!,» (298, #. 61). P $(>/! +&%"!, &5##/(;( A!4(#(A* . C4*1!#4*'4%'*, 8*$%&!*4!#$6 «($$(;( ! @(45>!4! #'(% "*+'*"!%, >$( 8*$%&!G :($,$ @&!"!8*$< +* @&(!+'(1,F5G @&!>!"5 157%'"6: ,'4%"!.» (68, #. 11). O$&!&5, E$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, C4*1!#4*'4%' 1*4%% @(1>%&/"54, >$( «'#% 8*$%&!*4!#$6 &*+"6: '%/(' 5$'%&?1*4! !8%""( $( @(4(?%"!%, >$( "%$ ' 8!&%, *, #4%1('*$%4<"(, ! ' >%4('%/%, (#()(;( "%8*$%&!*4<"(;( #5F%#$'* 157!» ($*8 ?%, #. 12). H #('#%8 5? /*&!/*$5&"( @&%1#$*'!4 #5F"(#$< 8*$%&!*4!+8* N%4@*"(': «B( 5>%"!G 8*$%&!*4!#$(', ' 8!&% #5F%#$'5G$ 4!7< 8*$%&!*4<"6% *$(86, /($(&6% +*"!8*G$ !+'%#$"5G >*#$< @&(#$&*"#$'* ! ()4*1*G$ #@(#()"(#$%#/(%, $*/ ! @#!:!>%#/(%. 6#4<, #(+"*"!%, 157* %#$< "% >$( !"(%, /*/ 1'!?%"!, 8*$%&!*4<"6: >*#$!2» (393, #. 24). C%#< 8*$%&!*4!+8 +1%#< #'(1!$#, / *$(8!#$!/% K%8(/&!$*. Q(4%% )%#@&!#$&*#$%" ! *//5&*$%" ' (@&%1%4%"!! 8*$%&!*4!+8* &5##/!. A!4(#(A ! )(;(#4(' C.K. M51&,'2%', @( 8"%"!G /($(&(;(, «!#:(1"68 "*>*4(8 8*$%&!*4!+8* #45?!$ "%@(#&%1#$'%""*, 5'%&%""(#$< "*7* ' &%*4<"(8 #5F%#$'('*"!! '"%7"!: @&%18%$(' ! ' 1(#$('%&"(#$! >5'#$'%""(;( +"*"!, ( "!:» (185, #. 34). H @($(85 «8*$%&!*4!+8 %1!"#$'%""( !#$!""( #5F!8 )6$!%8 #>!$*%$ )6$!% 8*$%&!*4<"(%. R( >$( $*/(% )6$!% 8*$%&!*4<"(% ! #5)#$*"2!*4<"*, (#"('* %;( – 8*$%&!,? Q6$!% 8*$%&!*4<"(%, @( %;( 5>%"!G, %#$< '#% >5'#$'%""( "*8 ,'4,GF%%#,, !8%GF%% A!+!>%#/!% #'(.#$'* @4($"(#$!, 2'%$*, +*@*:*, '/5#* ! 1&., * 8*$%&!, %#$< ()F*, #('(/5@"(#$< '#%: #'(.#$'; +* E$!8! #'(.#$'*8! "% #/&6'*%$#, "!>%;( )(4%%» ($*8 ?%, #. 35). M51&,'2%' ##64*%$#, @&! E$(8 "* (4%7($$*. C @&%1#$*'4%"!! 1&5;(;( &5##/(;( A!4(#(A*, @%&#("*4!#$* D. . D(@*$!"*, «;4*'"6. $%+!# 8*$%&!*4!+8* – @&!+"*"!% 1*""(. '"%7"%. 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! ! %% (@&%1%4%"!. +* (/(">*$%4<"5G ! %1!"#$'%""5G "(&85 '#,/(;( ()I%/$!'"(;( #5F%#$'('*"!,. L$!8 #*868 ' @&!"2!@% ($&!2*%$#, '#% $&*"#2%"1%"$"(% ' 8!&%» (218, #. 39). H#:(1, !+ E$(;(, D(@*$!" 1%4*%$ '6'(1: «C "*#$(,F%% '&%8, (' "*>*4% XX '%/*. – C.3.) '#%;( 4%;>% #(#4*$<#, "* &*#@&(#$&*"%"!% ! "%#(8"%""5G @(4<+5 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!: ;!@($%+ ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!. H 1%.#$'!$%4<"(, ("! ' +"*>!$%4<"(. #$%@%"! (@&*'16'*G$ @&%1@(>$%"!%, (/*+6'*%8(% 8*$%&!*4!+85 #&%1! 1&5;!: 8%$*A!+!>%#/!: $%(&!., @&%1@(>$%"!%, #$(4< 8*4( @(",$"(% 14, A!4(#(A*» ($*8 ?%, #. 225). U(&(7( @(",$"(%, #$*4( )6$<, 14, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,. M*/ '!1!8, 5 A!4(#(A(' &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( @%&!(1* (@&%1%4%"!. 8*$%&!*4!+8* 8"(;( ! (@&%1%4%"!, &*+"6%. 3)F%% ' "!: $(, >$( '#% ("! (#"('*"6 "* '(#@&!,$!! 8*$%&!*4!+8* !+'"%, # @(+!2!. %;( @&!"2!@!*4<"6: @&($!'"!/(', # "%!+)%?"68 ' $*/!: #45>*,: #5)I%/$!'!+8(8, ()5#4('4!'*GF!8 (@&%1%4%""6% !#/*?*GF!% 8(8%"$6 ' @("!8*"!! ! $&*/$('/%. K4, #&*'"%"!, 8(?"( @&!'%#$! (@&%1%4%"!,
197
8*$%&!*4!+8*, 1*""6% # @(+!2!. $%: A!4(#(A(', /($(&6% #*8! )64! 5)%?1%""68! 8*$%&!*4!#$*8!, ' >*#$"(#$!, 8*&/#!#$#/!% (@&%1%4%"!,. J*/, @( 8"%"!G L";%4<#*, «8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(% 8!&('(++&%"!% (+"*>*%$ @&(#$( @("!8*"!% @&!&(16 $*/(., /*/('* ("* %#$<, )%+ '#,/!: @(#$(&(""!: @&!)*'4%"!.» (406, #. 513). C (#"('% 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(;(, * &*'"( ! @&($!'(@(4(?"(;(, !1%*4!#$!>%#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, – #(($'%$#$'5GF!% &%7%"!, '(@&(#* «() ($"(7%"!! 8674%"!, / )6$!G, 15:* / @&!&(1%.., ( $(8, >$( ,'4,%$#, @%&'!>"68: 15: !4! @&!&(1*», ! @&! E$(8 «$%, /($(&6% 5$'%&?1*4!, >$( 15: #5F%#$'('*4 @&%?1% @&!&(16, ! /($(&6%, #4%1('*$%4<"(, ' /("%>"(8 #>%$%, $*/ !4! !"*>% @&!+"*'*4! #($'(&%"!% 8!&*.., – #(#$*'!4! !1%*4!#$!>%#/!. 4*;%&<. J% ?%, /($(&6% (#"('"68 "*>*4(8 #>!$*4! @&!&(15, @&!8/"54! / &*+4!>"68 7/(4*8 8*$%&!*4!+8*. R!>%;( 1&5;(;( @%&'("*>*4<"( ! "% (+"*>*G$ '6&*?%"!,: !1%*4!+8 ! 8*$%&!*4!+8…» (407, #. 283). L";%4<#5 '$(&!$ =.C. B4%:*"(': « %-*$'%7',: %#$< @&,8*, @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$< '5*%7',:%. H1%*4!+8 #$&%8!$#, ()I,#"!$< '#% ,'4%"!, @&!&(16, '#% #'(.#$'* 8*$%&!! $%8! !4! !"68! #'(.#$'*8! 15:*. *$%&!*4!+8 @(#$5@*%$ /*/ &*+ "*()(&($. 3" #$*&*%$#, ()I,#"!$< @#!:!>%#/!% ,'4%"!, $%8! !4! 1&5;!8! #'(.#$'*8! :%-*$'', $(. !4! 1&5;(. (&;*"!+*2!%. >%4('%>%#/(;( !4! '(()F% ?!'($"(;( -*7%. C#% $% A!4(#(A6, ' ;4*+*: /($(&6: @%&'!>"68 A*/$(&(8 ,'4,%$#, :%-*$'(, @&!"*14%?*$ / 4*;%&G :%-*$'%7'1-!9; '#% ?% $%, /($(&6% #>!$*G$ $*/!8 A*/$(&(8 15:, – '5*%7'1-.. C($ '#%, >$( 8(?"( #/*+*$< ( 8*$%&!*4!+8% '(()F%…» (307, #. 509). 3>%'!1"(, >$( 8*$%&!*4!+8 !8%""( ' $*/(8 %;( @("!8*"!! ! )64 @&!#5F %#$%#$'(+"*"!G XIX '%/*, ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% (@&%1%4,4#,, ()5#4('4!'*4#, %;( 1(#$!?%"!,8!, @&!>%8 ' $*/(. #$%@%"!, >$(, /*/ @(1>%&/"54 L";%4<#, «# /*?168 #(#$*'4,GF!8 E@(:5 ($/&6$!%8… ' %#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/(. ()4*#$! 8*$%&!*4!+8 "%!+)%?"( 1(4?%" !+8%",$< #'(G A(&85» (407, #. 286). J*/ ! @&(!#:(1!4( ' 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! – @(#$(4%#/(8 @&%$'(&%"!! @( "%():(1!8(#$! 1(4?%" *##!8!4!&('*$< !: 1(#$!?%"!,, ')!&*$< ' #%),, '@!$6'*$< !: /("/&%$"(–A*/$!>%#/!. ! *)#$&*/$"(– $%(&%$!>%#/!. 8*$%&!*4 ! @($(85, /*/ #>!$*4 @(4<#/!. %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4< ! A!4(#(A C. . M(+4('#/!., «8*$%&!*4!+8 ,'4,%$#, /*/ )6 /'!"$E##%"2!%. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: +"*"!., !$(;(8 !: ;!@($%+ ! $%(&!.» (175, #. 47). B&! E$(8 M(+4('#/!. #>%4 "5?"68 @(1>%&/"5$< #4%15GF%% ()#$(,$%4<#$'(: «… 6 1(4?"6 ($1%4!$< !#$(&!>%#/!% '6#$5@4%"!, 8*$%&!*4!+8* ($ $(;( 8!&('(++&%"!,, /($(&(% @&%1#$*'4,%$ #()(G @&(15/$
198
$(>"6: "*5/, ! E$( @(#4%1"%% &*##8*$&!'*$< ' )%+4!>"(. A(&8%, /*/ #!"$%+ 1%.#$'!$%4<"6: '6'(1(' "*5/!, * "% +*)45?1%"!. ! 5$(@!>%#/!: #5?1%"!. ($1%4<"6: 86#4!$%4%.» ($*8 ?%, #. 48). M(+4('#/!. +1%#< ()&*F*%$ '"!8*"!% "* "%():(1!8(#$< &*+4!>*$<, "*&,15 # A!4(#(A#/!8 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 ' %;( !#$(&!>%#/!: A(&8*:, ! #@%2!A!>%#/5G 14, XIX '%/* A(&85 8*$%&!*4!+8*, ;%"%$!>%#/! #',+*""(;( # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8, $( %#$< *1-*1-9*""!"%;0".= :%-*$'%7',: ' %;( ()F%8 8!&('(++&%">%#/(8 /*>%#$'%, )%+($"(#!$%4<"(8 / /("/&%$"68 4!>"(#$"68 '*&!*"$*8. L$($ ?% 8*$%&!*4!+8 !8%4 ' '!15 ! !+'%#$"6. 1*$#/!. A!4(#(A =. =%A1!";, /(;1* @!#*4: « *$%&!*4!+8 #>!$*%$ #%), @&(#$68 '6'(1(8 !+ 1*""6: %#$%#$'(+"*"!,» (120, #. 438). H :*&*/$%&"(% @&!+"*"!% ' "*;4,1"(. >*#$!: «R%/($(&6% !+ +*F!$"!/(' "%8%2/(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* )64! $*4*"$4!'68! ! #*8(#$(,$%4<"68! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8!, /*/, "*@&!8%&, M*&4 0(;$ ! X/(' (4%7($$». H ' 2%4(8 «A!4(#(A!,, #(+1*""*, #('&%8%""68 8*$%&!*4!+8(8, "% @&%$%"15%$ "* >$(-4!)( )(4<7%%, >%8 @&(#$(. '6'(1 !+ %#$%#$'(+"*"!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 437). L$* $(>/* +&%"!, ' &*##8*$&!'*%86. @%&!(1 @(45>!4* 7!&(/(% &*#@&(#$&*"%"!% ' A!4(#(A#/(. 4!$%&*$5&%, ' ()F%#$'%""(8 #(+"*"!!. K*?% $*/(. "%@&!8!&!86. @&($!'"!/ 8*$%&!*4!+8*, /*/ @&(A%##(& =. N%4@*"(' @&!+"*%$: «C "*7%. !"$%44!;%"2!! 7!&(/!8 &*#@&(#$&*"%"!%8 @(4<+5%$#, '+;4,1, >$( )51$( )6 8*$%&!*4!+8 ! %#$< !8%""( $( #4('(, /($(&(% '6&*?*%$ #()(G #5F"(#$< #('&%8%""(;( "*5>"(A!4(#(A#/(;( 8!&(@("!8*"!,» (393, #. 15). C #',+! # E$!8 N%4@*"(' /("#$*$!&5%$ «()6>"6. '+;4,1, @( /($(&(85 8*$%&!*4!+8 ,'4,%$#, @&(15/$(8 &*+'!$!, %#$%#$'(+"*"!, XIX '%/*» ($*8 ?%, #. 46). B&*'1*, #*8 N%4@*"(' E$($ ()6>"6. '+;4,1 ($'%&;*%$ ! #$*&*%$#, (@&('%&;"5$<, "( 1('(16 %;( – 1('(4<"( #$&*""6%, '&(1% $*/(;(: «N*#$( ;('(&,$, >$( 8*$%&!*4!+8 (#"('*" "* &%+54<$*$*:, 1()6$6: ' "%1*'"%% '&%8, %#$%#$'%""68! "*5/*8!. W#4! )6 E$( )64( $*/, $(, #@&*7!'*%$#,, ($/51* ?% 8*$%&!*4!+8 '+,4#, 5 K%8(/&!$*» ($*8 ?%, #. 26). X#"(, >$( "% !+ %#$%#$'(+"*"!, XIX '%/*, * !+ "*$5&A!4(#(A!! V '%/* 1( ".E., "*$5&A!4(#(A!!, ' /($(&(. !8%4!#< ! @%&'6% +*>*$/! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( +"*"!, ( @&!&(1%, @(#/(4%#/(% 8!&('(++&%"!% (+"*>*%$, %#4! #(;4*#!$<#, # L";%4<#(8, «@&(#$( @("!8*"!% @&!&(16 $*/(., /*/('* ("* %#$<, )%+ '#,/!: @(#$(&(""!: @&!)*'4%"!., ! @(E$(85 5 ;&%>%#/!: A!4(#(A(' ("( )64( @%&'("*>*4<"( >%8-$( #*8( #()(. &*+58%GF!8#,» (406, #. 513). H 5 K%8(/&!$*, #$*4( )6$<. 9 ' XIX '%/% )64 5$;#!= 8*$%&!*4!+8, 5$'%&1!'7!.#, "* 5$;#'D %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: (#"('*"!,: («A!+!(4(;!>%#/!.» 5 0(;$*, (4%7($$* ! 1&., (#"('6'*'7!.#, "* A!+!(4(;!>%#/(8 8*$%&!*4%, ! $.@.). 3&;*"!>%#/*, #',+< 8*$%&!*4!+8*, /*/ A!4(#(A#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!,, # %#$%#$'%""68! "*5/*8!, %;( (>%'!1"*, #(@&,?%""(#$< # !: 1(#$!?%"!,8!, # 5#$*"('4%"!%8 ' "!: @(+!$!'"(;( +"*"!, ( ,'4%"!,: ! @&(2%##*: @&!&(16 "%():(1!868 #4%1#$'!%8 !8%4! %;( 5$'%&?1%"!% ' 8!&('(++&%"!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., %;( 7!&(/(% &*#@&(#$&*"%"!% ' !:
199
#&%1%. M*/ '6"5?1%" )64 @&!+"*$< 1&5;(. !+'%#$"6. @&($!'"!/ 8*$%&!*4!+8* B.K. S&/%'!>, «' "*#$(,F%% '&%8, (' #%&%1!"% XIX '%/*. – C.3.) ' (#()%""(#$! 8*$%&!*4!+8 !8%%$ @*&$!G, #!4<"5G, @( /&*."%. 8%&%, #'(%G >!#4%""(#$%"!%8 ' ()4*#$! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,» (416, #. 195). C A!4(#(A#/(. 4!$%&*$5&% &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( @%&!(1* '(+()4*1*"!% 8*$%&!*4!+8* ' 8!&('(++&%"!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ()I,#",4(#<, /*/ @&*'!4(, "% ()I%/$!'"68! '"5$&!"*5>"68! A*/$(&*8!, * >!#$( '"%7"!8!, #45>*."68!, #5)I%/$!'"68! ()#$(,$%4<#$'*8!, ' >*#$"(#$!, "%;*$!'"(. &%*/2!%. 5>%"6: "* !1%*4!+8 (&(8*"$!+8) ' 58(+&!$%4<"(., #@%/54,$!'"(. A!4(#(A!!, ;(#@(1#$'('*'7%. ' "*>*4% XIX '%/*. J*/, @( 8"%"!G "%8%2/(;( A!4(#(A*–@(+!$!'!#$* J. [!;4%&*, &*#@&(#$&*"%"!% 8*$%&!*4!+8* ' A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!! «'6&*?*4( @&,8(. @&($%#$ @&($!' "*$5&A!4(#(A!! T%44!";*, A%"(8%"(4(;!! =%;%4, ! '(()F% @&($!' '#%;( !1%*4!#$!>%#/(;( "*@&*'4%"!, "*>*4* E$(;( #$(4%$!,» (392, #. 286). H "* '(@&(# ( $(8, «/*/ 51*4(#< 8*$%&!*4!+85 ' 50-: ;(1*: "*.$! #$(4< 8"(;(>!#4%""6: @&!'%&?%"2%' ! +*#$5@"!/(', /($(&6% %;( $*/ #$&*#$"( ($#$*!'*4!?» [!;4%& ($'%>*%$: «C#% "*#$&(%"!% $(;( '&%8%"! )64( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>"( ! 1*4%/( ($ '#,/(;( !1%*4!+8*» ($*8 ?%, #. 298). =. =%A1!"; ($8%$!4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «R*!)(4%% #!4<"*, &%*/2!, @&($!' A!4(#(A!! &(8*"$!+8* +*8%>*%$#,… ' 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. 4!$%&*$5&%, /($(&*, @&(2'%$*4* ' =%&8*"!! ' #%&%1!"% '%/*. W#4! ' @%&'(. !1%, )64* '#%8 ! '#,, $( $%@%&< %1!"(#5F!8 #$*4* 8*$%&!,. O'4%>%"!% %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8 ! $(. '%4!>%#$'%""(. @%&#@%/$!'(., /($(&5G %85 51*4(#< 5#$*"('!$< )4*;(1*&, 5>%"!G ( #(:&*"%"!! 8*$%&!! ! #!46, '@(4"% %#$%#$'%""( 8(;4( @()51!$< / $(85, >$()6 "* #*8( E$( 5>%"!% "*>*4! #8($&%$<, /*/ "* 51('4%$'(&!$%4<"5G A!4(#(A!G ! >$()6 # %;( @(8(F"( $*/ ?% "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A 0. J&*5;($$ 5$'%&?1*4, >$( «8*$%&!*4!+8 1%',$"*12*$(;( #$(4%$!, )64 '6+'*" / ?!+"! 1'58, @&($!'(@(4(?"68! "*@&*'4%"!,8! 58#$'%""(. ?!+"!: # (1"(. #$(&("6, A!4(#(A!%. @(#4%1('*$%4%. =%;%4, ! T%44!";*, @(/!"5'7%. @(>'5 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! ! '#%2%4( ()&*$!'7%.#, / #'%&:>5'#$'%""(85 8!&5, * # 1&5;(. – 7%17!8 ;!;*"$#/!8! 7*;*8! '@%&%1 %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8, 1(#$!;7!8 $*/!: 5#@%:(', ( /*/!: "!/$( "% 8(; ! 8%>$*$<» (360, #. 54). 9 $*/(. 5)%?1%""6. @&($!'"!/ 8*$%&!*4!+8*, /*/ '!$*4!#$ =. K&!7, @&!+"*4, >$( "*5>"(% 8674%"!% ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!! '( '$(&(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/* (@&%1%4,%$#,, ;4*'"68 ()&*+(8, «:%-*$'%7'1-'0*16!= :*-%&','6!=, /($(&*, '6&(#4* /*/ @&($!'('%# !1%*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! $(?1%#$'%""(#$!», * $*/?% $*/!8! 1(#$!?%"!,8! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, /*/ 1*&'!"!+8, ($/&6$!% +*/("* #(:&*"%"!, E"%&;!!, «($/&6$!% ! @4*"(8%&"(% !+5>%"!% -!"6'D 1-$;6-;$ ' ?!'6: #5F%#$'*:…» (152, #. 145-146).
200
B&!8%"!$%4<"( / A!4(#(A!! 8*$%&!*4!+8, /*/ "%;*$!'"5G &%*/2!G "* !1%*4!+8 T%44!";* ! =%;%4, ! /*/ #4%1#$'!% &*+'!$!, %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, @%&#("!A!2!&('*4! ()6>"( ' D. 0%.%&)*:%. J*/, "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A 0. H)%&'%; @!#*4 @( E$(85 @('(15: « "(;( 7585 ! '(+)5?1%"!, '6+6'*4 ' $%>%"!% 2%4(;( &,1* 4%$ #@(& ( 8*$%&!*4!+8%… C#4%1#$'!% :(1* &*+'!$!, "('%.7%. A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, /($(&(%, ($@5;"5$(% (#()%""( 5>%"!,8! T%44!";*, '#% )(4%% ! )(4%% ($1*4,4(#< ($ A!4(#(A!!, !8%""( '#4%1#$'!% "*$5&*4!#$!>%#/(;( @&%()&*+('*"!, ;%;%4<,"#$'*, ' 4!2% 0%.%&)*:* ! 1&5;!:, '#@6:"54 E$($ #@(& ' @(4"(. #!4%…» (159, #. 433). R* E$( ?% ()#$(,$%4<#$'( ()&*$!4 '"!8*"!% ! &5##/!. 5>%"6.-%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4< P.B. M(#$6>%': «O>%"!/ =%;%4, 0%.%&)*:, @&%'(#:(1"( !+5>!'7!. #!#$%85 #'(%;( 5>!$%4,, @&(#$( '6'%&"54 %% "*!+"*"/5, "*>*' *&;58%"$*2!G # 1&5;(;( /("2* !, #4('"( @( 8*"('%"!G '(47%)"(;( ?%+4*, 1(;8*$!>%#/!. &*2!("*4!+8 @&%'&*$!4#, ' 1(;8*$!>%#/!. 8*$%&!*4!+8. 3$ 0%.%&)*:* ! @(74* '#, 7/(4* ;%&8*"#/(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* 19-;( '%/*» (181, #. 21-22). L$( #(($'%$#$'5GF!8 ()&*+(8 ($&*+!4(#< ! "* 8!&('(++&%">%#/(. #A%&% %#$%#$'(+"*"!, $(;( '&%8%"!. B( 8"%"!G !+'%#$"(;( "%8%2/(;( A!4(#(A* ! @#!:(4(;* L. =*&$8*"*, «'(+'&*$ ;%;%4<,"#/(. 4%'(. / 8*$%&!*4!+85 ' #(&(/('6: ;(1*: @&(74(;( (XIX-;(. – C.3.) '%/* @&(4(?!4 @5$< %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(85 @(@54,&"(85 8*$%&!*4!+85 @,$!1%#,$6: ;(1('» (76, #. 13). M*/ ($8%$!4 1&5;(. "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A, -. 0*4"(% "*#$&(%"!%, /($(&(% ' @,$!1%#,$6: ;(1*: @&!'%4( &*+1(#*1('*""6: "* !1%*4!#$!>%#/5G #@%/54,2!G / 8*$%&!*4!+85…» (367, #. 550). M E$(85 #4%15%$ 1()*'!$< ! $(, >$( ' XIX '%/%, /*/ @(1>%&/"54 Q. T8!1, «%#$%#$'(+"*"!% #1%4*4( (;&(8"6. 7*; '@%&%1, ! >$( %;( +*/("6 ! 1()6$6% !8 &%+54<$*$6… )4*;(@&!,$#$'('*4! &*+'!$!G 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(;( 8!&(#(+%&2*"!,» (373, #. 14). C#4%1#$'!% E$(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8, @( 8"%"!G "%8%2/(;( A!4(#(A* 9. C%)%&*, #$*4 «@%&'(#$%@%""(. !"$%44%/$5*4<"(. #!4(., /&%@/( @(/(,F%G#, "* (#"('*"!! A*/$(', !8%GF%. +* #()(. 1'(."(. @&%#$!? #('%&7%""(. ,#"(#$! ! ()7!&"(;(, #(4!1"(;( +"*"!,». B&! E$(8 «'( ;4*'% #'(%. ! ' #'(!: &,1*: (" #>!$*%$ !+'%#$"6: 5>%"6:, '61*GF!:#, A!+!(4(;(', ($1*'7!: %85 "* #45?%"!% #'(. @(@54,&!+*$(&#/!. $*4*"$» (59, #. 394, 395). C%)%& "*+6'*%$ ' #',+! # E$!8 !8%"* QG:"%&*, 0(;$*, (4%7($$*. B(1>%&/!'*, (+"*>%""5G %#$%#$'%""("*5>"5G @(1(@4%/5 8*$%&!*4!+8* (1!" !+ %;( #5&('6: /&!$!/(', M*&(, @!#*4 ' 1877 ;(15: «R('%.7!. 8*$%&!*4!+8 %#$< A!+!>%#/!. ! A!+!(4(;!>%#/!.» (169, #. 36). H %F% / E$(85 ?%: «B&(!#:(1, @( @&,8(. 4!"!!, :($, ! "%+*/(""(, ($ "*5/ A!+!>%#/!:, :!8!>%#/!: ! A!+!(4(;!>%#/!:, E$($ 8*$%&!*4!+8 '6#$5@*%$ '( '#%(&5?!! (@6$"6: 1(/*+*$%4<#$', # @%&'(;( '+;4,1* 8(;5F!: ''%#$! ' +*)45?1%"!%. 3$1*1!8 %85 #@&*'%14!'(#$< ' $(8, >$(, +* "%8"(;!8! !#/4G>%"!,8!, (" @(>$! '#%;1* #()4G1*%$ "*5>"6. $("…» ($*8 ?%, #. 45). C6"5?1%""6% @&!+"*"!, # :*&*/$%&"68! (;('(&/*8!.
201
J*/!8 ()&*+(8, ' XIX '%/% (>%'!1"*, ! 14, @&($!'"!/(' 8*$%&!*4!+8* %;( '"5$&!@(4(?"*, #(@&,?%""(#$< # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8 ()%#@%>!'*4* %85 @(#$(,""5G ?!+"%#@(#()"(#$<, ! =%A1!";, "*@&!8%&, "* E$(8 (#"('*"!! #1%4*4 '6'(1, >$( «8*$%&!*4!+8, /*/ %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. 8%$(1, "%#(/&57!8» (121, #. 62). (?"( 1()*'!$<: "% $(4%#/(. #A%&6 %#$%#$'(+"*"!, '( '$(&(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/*. N$( /*#*%$#, @&($!'"!/(' 8*$%&!*4!+8* ! !: )(&<)6 # "!8, %% &%*4<"6: @%&!@%$!., $( )(&<)*, "*1( #/*+*$<, '%4*#< "%75$(>"*,, ("* ($"G1< "% (;&*"!>!'*4*#< (1"!8! #4('%#"68! (@&('%&?%"!,8!, #45>*4!#< «(@&('%&?%"!,» ! @('%#(8%% – "* ;(#51*&#$'%""(8 5&('"%, # @&!8%"%"!%8 ?%#$/!: &%@&%##!'"6: 8%& @( ($"(7%"!G / 8*$%&!*4!#$*8. [!;4%&, "*@&!8%&, @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «…N&%+8%&"6% "*@*1/! %1!"!>"6: (&*$(&(' @(1*4! @('(1 14, 51*4%"!, # /*A%1&6 QG:"%&* ' JG)!";%"% ! (4%7($$* ' =%.1%4<)%&;%… B&!8%"%"!% ;(#51*&#$'(8 @(1()"6: 8%& / @(1*'4%"!G 8*$%&!*4!+8* (@&*'16'*4(#< $%8, >$( A!4(#(A!,, "* /($(&(. 4%?*4* @&,8*, (),+*""(#$< 15:('"68 (&5?!%8 ($&*?*$< "*$!#/ 8*$%&!*4!#$(', (/*+*4*#< / E$(85 #('%&7%""( "%#@(#()"(.» (392, #. 288-289). C 5#4('!,: $($*4<"(. /&!$!/! 8*$%&!*4!+8*, %;( ($/&6$(;( @&%#4%1('*"!, '4*#$,8! "%8"(;!% 5>%"6%, @(1()"( =%//%4G, ($'*?!'*4!#<, :($, ! # (;('(&/*8!, @&!+"*$< #%), 8*$%&!*4!#$*8!. Q(4<7!"#$'( ?%, @&!1%&?!'*,#< 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!: @( #5$! A!4(#(A#/!: '(++&%"!., ' $( ?% '&%8, #$&%8!4!#< /*/-$( 1!#$*"2!&('*$<#, ($ 8*$%&!*4!+8*, #",$< # #%), '(+8(?"6% ()'!"%"!, ' @&!"*14%?"(#$! / "%85. U*&*/$%&"( ' E$(8 ($"(7%"!! #4%15GF%% @(,#"%"!% M. Q%&"*&* / #'(!8 A!+!(4(;!>%#/!8 1('(1*8: « (?%$ )6$<, 8"% +*8%$,$, >$( '#% E$! ()I,#"%"!, #!4<"( ($+6'*G$#, 8*$%&!*4!+8(8. R* E$( , ($'%>5, >$( , #('#%8 "% !8%4 ' '!15 E$(;( 5>%"!,… C ()F%. A!+!(4(;!! 8*$%&!*4!+8 "% ()I,#",%$ "!>%;(. R( /("2%&$ "% 1%4*%$#, 8%"%% @&!,$"68, %#4! A!+!/ '6>!#4!$ 8*$%8*$!>%#/! '#% /(4%)*"!, '(+15:*, !+ /($(&6: #4*;*G$#, +'5/!. 0!+!(4(;!>%#/(% ,'4%"!% "% 1%4*%$#, 8%"%% 51!'!$%4<"68 ($$(;(, >$( A!+!(4(; *"*4!+!&5%$ '#% %;( 8*$%&!*4<"6% 5#4('!,. H E$($ *"*4!+, ! E$! '6>!#4%"!, "%():(1!86, $*/ /*/ )%+ "!: "% )64( )6 "*5/!» (30, #. 29). J(>"( $*/ ?% N. D,.%4<, ($#$&*",,#< ($ 8*$%&!*4!+8*, @&!'(1!$ '%#<8* 7*$/!. 1('(1: « (?"( #8%4( #/*+*$<, >$( ''%1%"!% "* +%84G, ' @(#$%@%""6% ;%(4(;!>%#/!% @%&!(16, ?!+"!, >5'#$'('*"!,, !"#$!"/$*, &*+58%"!, '6#7!: 84%/(@!$*GF!:, ;&*"!>*F%;( # &*+58(8, ! "*/("%2 #*8(;( #('%&7%"#$'5GF%;( 58* >%4('%/*, "% $(4%#/(. $%"1%"2!!, "(, "*@&($!' $(;(, @&%1#$*'4,%$ "*8 @(4"5G /*&$!"5 '(+&*#$*GF%;( '4!,"!, &*+58* "*1 8*$%&!%.» (228, #. 486).
202
B(45>*%$#,, >$( 8*$%&!*4!+8 (+"*>*%$ ($'%&?%"!% '#,/(;( '4!,"!, >%4('%>%#/(;( &*+58* "* 8*$%&!G ' 4G)6: %% @&(,'4%"!,:. R( %#4! E$( ! 8*$%&!*4!+8, $( 1*4%/( "% '#,/!., "% '%#< – +1%#< "*1( 5>!$6'*$< $( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, >$( '%#< 8*$%&!*4!+8, # %;( )(;*$(. 8"(;('%/('(. !#$(&!%., # %;( &*+"(()&*+"68!, &*+"(/*>%#$'%""68! !1%."68!, /("2%@$5*4<"68! A!4(#(A#/!8! '(@4(F%"!,8!, )64 A*/$!>%#/! "%'%1(8 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8 ! ' !: #(+"*"!! *##(2!!&('*4#, # %;( /("/&%$"(., 5@&(F%""(. &*+"('!1"(#$"68 («A!+!(4(;!>%#/!8») 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 QG:"%&*, 0(;$*, (4%7($$*, $( %#$< # $%8 8*$%&!*4!+8(8, /($(&6. ! $*/(. 5)%?1%""6. 8*$%&!*4!#$, /*/ L";%4<#, /&!$!/5%$, #>!$*%$ «'54<;*&"68». K* ! >$( ;('(&!$< ( %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,:, %#4! $(. ?% (7!)/! "% !+)%?*4! ! "%/($(&6% A!4(#(A6–8*$%&!*4!#$6 XIX '%/*, ' >*#$"(#$!, D. 0%.%&)*:. 3" $(?%, @( 8"%"!G L";%4<#*, "% #58%4 «@&%(1(4%$< ()6>"(;( A!4(#(A#/(;( @&%1&*##51/*, @&%1&*##51/* "% @&($!' #*8(;( #5F%#$'* 1%4*, * @&($!' #4('* «8*$%&!*4!+8» (407, #. 286). J*/, "*@&!8%&, (@&%1%4,, #'(G @&!"2!@!*4<"5G @(+!2!G @( ($"(7%"!G / 8*$%&!*4!+85 #'(!: A!4(#(A#/!: @&%17%#$'%""!/(' (A!4(#(A('–8*$%&!*4!#$(' XVIII '%/*) ! #'(!: #('&%8%""!/(', A!4(#(A#$'5GF!: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. (QG:"%&*, 0(;$*, (4%7($$*), 0%.%&)*: @(1>%&/"54: «K4, 8%", 8*$%&!*4!+8 %#$< (#"('* +1*"!, >%4('%>%#/(. #5F"(#$! ! >%4('%>%#/(;( +"*"!,; "( (" 14, 8%", "% $(, >%8 (" ,'4,%$#, 14, A!+!(4(;*, 14, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4, ' $%#"(8 #86#4%, "*@&!8%&, 14, (4%7($$*, ! >%8 (" "% 8(?%$ "% )6$< 14, "!: #(()&*+"( !: $(>/% +&%"!, ! !: #@%2!*4<"(#$!, $( %#$< 14, 8%", "% #*8( +1*"!%. H1, "*+*1, , 2%4!/(8 # 8*$%&!*4!#$*8!; !1, '@%&%1, , "% # "*8!». M(88%"$*&!. L";%4<#*: «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» ($*8 ?%, #. 286). L";%4<# #51!$ ( 8*$%&!*4!+8% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., "%;*$!'"( ($+6'*%$#, ( "%8 # @(+!2!. )(4%% &*+'!$(., )(4%% #('%&7%""(., "* %;( '+;4,1, A(&86 8*$%&!*4!+8* – 1!*4%/$!>%#/(;( ! !#$(&!>%#/(;(, $( %#$< # @(+!2!. A!4(#(A!! 8*&/#!+8*. B&!8%"!$%4<"( / "%. (" @(1>%&/"54, >$( «+1%#< '@%&'6% 1%.#$'!$%4<"( #%&<%+"( ($"%#4!#< / 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(85 8!&('(++&%"!G» ($*8 ?%, #. 301). P(($'%$#$'%""( E$(85 #$&(!4(#< ! $%(&%$!>%#/(% (A(&84%"!% #5F"(#$"(;( #(1%&?*"!, 8*$%&!*4!+8* – 2%4%"*@&*'4%""(, A!4(#(A#/!8! #&%1#$'*8!, # (@(&(. "* @&%17%#$'5GF5G A!4(#(A!G, '/4G>*, ! 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/5G XVIII '%/*, # A!4(#(A#/!8 (#'(%"!%8 1(#$!?%"!. %#$%#$'%""6: ! ()F%#$'%""6: "*5/. C ($4!>!% ($ E$(;(, 8*$%&!*4!+8 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/* –
203
%#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. (%#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/!.) –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–8*$%&!*4!#$*8! (K!1&(, =(4<)*:(8 ! 1&.). C $( ?% '&%8, ! 8*&/#!#$#/!. 8*$%&!*4!+8, @&! '#%: %;( #()#$'%""6: @&!()&%$%"!,: (1!*4%/$!/*, 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(% @("!8*"!% !#$(&!! ! 1&.), #(:&*"!4 ' #%)% ' «#",$(8» '!1% $% ?% ()F%8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!% (#"('(@(4*;*GF!% 5#$*"('4%"!,, /($(&6% !8%4!#< ! ' 5>%"!,: A!4(#(A('–@&%17%#$'%""!/(', 8*$%&!*4!#$(' XVIII '%/*, ! ' A!4(#(A#/(8 8!&('(++&%"!! #('&%8%""!/(', %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%.– 8*$%&!*4!#$(' XIX '%/*. H"*>% ;('(&,, '( '#%: ($8%>%""6: &*+"('!1"(#$,: 8*$%&!*4!+8* (A!4(#(A#/!. XVIII '%/*, 8*&/#!#$#/!. ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. XIX '%/*), @(8!8( #@%2!A!>%#/!: (#()%""(#$%., #5F%#$'%""6: &*+4!>!., "%():(1!8( #(1%&?!$#, ! "%>$( !%#/!: @&%$'(&%"!,:. B(#/(4%"* ()F*, 14, '#%. A!4(#(A!! (#"('(@(4*;*GF*, @&()4%8* – :'$ ! 0*7!9*6 9 "*:, – $( %% /("/&%$"(% &*##8($&%"!% ' :(1% *"*4!+* &*+"('!1"(#$%. 8*$%&!*4!+8* '6#$&*!'*%$#, ' #4%15GF%. 4(;!>%#/(. @(#4%1('*$%4<"(#$!: 8!& '"% >%4('%/* (("$(4(;!>%#/*, @&()4%8*$!/*), >%4('%/ ' 8!&% (*"$&(@(4(;!>%#/*, @&()4%8*$!/*), 8!& ' >%4('%/% (;"(#%(4(;!>%#/*, @&()4%8*$!/*). R*>"%8 # ("$(4(;!>%#/(..
204
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–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( @%&!(1* #'(!8 "%():(1!868 #4%1#$'!%8 !8%4* 1(#$*$(>"( #5F%#$'%""5G ()F"(#$< !: #$!:!."(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* # A!4(#(A#/!8 8*$%&!*4!+8(8. L$* ()F"(#$< ()"*&5?!'*%$#, @&%?1% '#%;( ' #('@*1*GF%8 &%7%"!! '(@&(#(' !"-!7!#'0*16!#! :*&*/$%&*, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' @("!8*"!! :%-*$'', /*/ @%&'((#"('6 )6$!, ! &*+'!$!, 8!&*, ' ()I,#"%"!! %% #$&(%"!,, A(&8 #5F%#$'('*"!,, ()I%/$!'"(. +*/("(8%&"(#$! ' &*+'!$!! @&!&(16. § 1. %;FD8=9 5 A=3242A== = D4FD4F52CE;E==: >2E9F=D = >82H3DB; C %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!! (#"('"68, &5/('(1,F!8 @&!"2!@(8, 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!8 @( #'(%. A!4(#(A#/(. #5$!, '#%;1* )64( @&!+"*"!% 5>%"68! ()I%/$!'"(;( #5F%#$'('*"!, '"%7"%;( 8!&*. 9. L."7$%." @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «C%&* ' #5F%#$'('*"!% '"%7"%;( 8!&*, "%+*'!#!8( ($ '(#@&!"!8*GF%;( #5)I%/$*, 4%?!$ ' (#"('% '#%;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!,» (403, #. 136). B(",$"(, >$( E$(. @&!"2!@!*4<"(. $(>/! +&%"!, @&!1%&?!'*4!#< ! 5>%"6% XIX '%/*. J*/, !+'%#$"6. *";4!.#/!. A!+!/ K. J!"1*4< @(1>%&/"54: «… K4, #(+!1*"!, A!+!>%#/!: $%(&!. 86 )%&%8 8*$%&!*4 !+ 1%.#$'!$%4<"(;( 8!&*» (359, #. 40). W#$%#$'(+"*"!%, 5$'%&?1*4 ! -. C!&:(', «#$&%8!$#, @(+"*$< $(4%'!1"68, "% @(14%?*F!8 #(8"%"!G E$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'( )64( ! 14, A&*"25+#/(;( 5>%"(;( L. B!/*&*: «Q%+ (7!)/! 8(?"( #/*+*$<, >$( 86 $'(&!8 "*5/5, &*##8*$&!'*, ' "%. '"%7"GG &%*4<"(#$< >%&%+ @&!+85
205
"*7!: $%(&!. ! ($'4%>%""6: @(",$!.» (301, #. 21). J(>"( $*/ ?%, # $(. ?% )%+5#4('"(. (>%'!1"(#$%"(' @&!8%"!$%4<"( / #'(%. #()#$'%""(. !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$!: «C (#"('*"!% '#%: &*##5?1%"!. @(4(?%"( 8"(G @&!#5F%% '#,/(85 >%4('%/5 "%@&%4(?"(% 5)%?1%"!% ' #5F%#$'('*"!! '"%7"%;( 8!&*, – "%@&%4(?"(% ' $(. !4! 1*?% +"*>!$%4<"( )(4<7%. 8%&%, >%8 5'%&%""(#$< '#,/(;( ' $(8, >$( +*'$&*, @(#4% #%;(1",7"%. "(>!, )51%$ 1%"<» (335, #. 343). P$(4< ?% "%@&(4(?"68 )64( E$( 5)%?1%"!% ! 14, R.9. O8('*: « 6 1(4?"6 &*##8*$&!'*$< (/&5?*GF!. "*# 8!& /*/ #*8(#$(,$%4<"( #5F%#$'5GF!. ! &*+'!'*GF!.#,» (364, #. 253). H %1!"#$'%""(. #5)#$*"2!("*4<"(. @%&'((#"('(. E$(;( #*8(#$(,$%4<"( #5F%#$'5GF%;( ! &*+'!'*GF%;(#, '"%7"%;( 8!&* 5>%"6% @&!+"*'*4! :%-*$'4. C6&*?*, ' &*##8*$&!'*%8(8 '(@&(#% @&!"2!@!*4<"5G A!4(#(A#/5G @(+!2!G %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '61*GF!.#, &5##/!. B.R. D%)%1%' ' #'(%8 (@&%1%4%"!! ()I%/$!'"(;( /*>%#$'* @(+"*'*%8(. >%4('%/(8 @&!&(16 >%$/( ()(+"*>!4 ()F%% 14, '#%;( #5F%#$'5GF%;( ' "%. #5)#$*"2!*4<"(% @%&'("*>*4(: «P #*86: @%&'6: 7*;(' !+5>%"!, @&!&(16 86 +*8%>*%8 #$&%84%"!% >%4('%/* +*:'*$!$< !+5>*%86. @&%18%$ '( '#%. %;( @(4"($% ! @(1(.$! / ;&*"!2*8 '(+8(?"(;(; @&! !+5>%"!! 8*$%&!!, !+ /($(&(. #(#$(!$ '#% (/&5?*GF%% "*#, $*/!8! ;&*"!2*8! ,'4,G$#,, # (1"(. #$(&("6, 8!& 8(4%/54, *, # 1&5;(., – &*##%,""6% ' )%#/("%>"(8 @&(#$&*"#$'% +'%+16» (199, #. 36). C E$!: @&%1%4*: – ($ 8(4%/54 1( +'%+1, ($ 54<$&*8*4(;( 1( 54<$&*)(4<7(;( – '#% )%#/("%>"(% 8"(;(()&*+!% @&%18%$(' ! ,'4%"!., #(#$*'4,GF!: ()I%/$!'"( #5F%#$'5GF!. '"%7"!. 8!&, @&!&(15, #'(!8 %1!"68 ! %1!"#$'%""68 #5)#$*"2!*4<"68 "*>*4(8 !8%%$ 8*$%&!G. C &*+"6: #'(!: /*>%#$'%""6: #(#$(,"!,:, ' #'(%8 @&!&(1"(8 )6$!! ("* @&%1#$*'4,%$ /*/ (#"('"(. ()I%/$ %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. C >*#$"(#$!, /*/ @(1>%&/"54 +"*8%"!$6. "%8%2/!. A!+!/ C. B*54!, «8*$%&!, '#%;1* )64* ! '#%;1* )51%$ (1"!8 !+ ;4*'"6: ()I%/$(' A!+!/!» (297, #. 31). R( ' @("!8*"!! #*8(. 8*$%&!!, ' %% #5F"(#$"6: (@&%1%4%"!,: A!+!/*8!, :!8!/*8!, )!(4(;*8!, * &*'"( ! A!4(#(A*8! ()"*&5?!'*%$#, ,'"6. #86#4('(. &*+"()(., @&($!'(&%>!'(#$< 8"%"!.. J*/, @&!8%"!$%4<"( /( '$(&(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/* &5##/!. A!4(#(A 9. C'%1%"#/!. /("#$*$!&('*4: «C @("!8*"!! 8*$%&!! ' "*#$(,F%% '&%8, ;(#@(1#$'5%$ @(4"%.7!. :*(# 8"%"!.» (55, #. V). H @($(85, @&%?1% >%8 '"!/*$< ' #5$< &%7%"!, 2$!<7*:. 8*$%&!! ' 8!&('(++&%">%#/(. #A%&% %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ! ' A!4(#(A!!, "%():(1!8( @&%1'*&!$%4<"( @(,#"!$< #*8( 2!"(-'* 8*$%&!!, (#86#4!$< '6&*?*GF%% %;( 17!9!. M*/ @(18%$!4 A&*"25+#/!. 5>%"6. 0. D%-K*"$%/, «@%&'(. (),+*""(#$"(% (@&%1%4%"!% $%: #4(', /($(&68! ("* @(4<+5%$#,» (202, #. 183). L$( '*?"(, ' >*#$"(#$!, ! @($(85, >$( «A(&8* #4(' E'(4G2!("!&('*4* "*#$(4!$%4<"(, >$( ' "%/($(&6: #45>*,: A!4(4(;*8 4!7< # )(4<7!8 $&51(8 51*%$#, '(##$*"('!$< %% !#$(&!G; #86#4, @&!1*'*%86. 4G1<8! &*+4!>"6: E@(:
206
@(#4%1('*$%4<"68 A(&8*8 /*?1(;( #4('*, )64 +*>*#$5G @&%18%$(8 %F% )(4%% /&5@"6: !+8%"%"!.» ($*8 ?%, #. 182). P/*+*""(% ' @(4"(. 8%&% 8(?"( ($"%#$! ! / @(",$!G 8*$%&!!, / A(&8% #4('* «8*$%&!,». C61*GF!.#, "%8%2/!. A!4(4(; ! ,+6/('%1 . G44%& $*/ '(##$*"*'4!'*%$ !#$(&!G E$(;( #4('* – %;( @%&'("*>*4<"6. #86#4 ! @(#4%15GF5G A!4(#(A#/5G E'(4G2!G: «W#4! 86 ()&*$!8 '"!8*"!% "* !#$(&!G #4('* «8*$%&!,», $(, /("%>"(, 5+"*%8, >$( E$( #4('( @&(!#:(1!$ ($ 4*$!"#/(;( materies, 5@($&%)4,'7%;(#, ()6/"('%""( ' #86#4% /&%@/(;( 1%&%'*, – 1%&%'* !4! 1%&%',""(;( #$'(4* 14, @(#$&(%/. B(#4% $(;(, /*/ E$( @(",$!% ()&*+('*4(#<, ("( &*#7!&!4(#< "*#$(4$( #$*4( (+"*>*$< '#% '%F%#$'%""(%, !+ >%;( 8(?"( )64( >$(4!)( @(#$&(!$< !4! ()&*+('*$<, ! '#/(&% '(+"!/4( &*+4!>!% 8%?15 A(&8(., "*@&!8%&, 1%&%',""(. #$*$5! ! %% '%F%#$'(8 !4! materies. C E$(8 #45>*% #4('( E$( @&(1(4?*4( %F% (+"*>*$< 1%&%'(, "( '#/(&%, /(;1* #$*$5! #$*4! 1%4*$<#, !+ 8%$*44* !4! 8&*8(&*, – E$! '%F%#$'* $(>"( $*/ ?% @(45>!4! "*+'*"!% materies. H $(;1* '(+"!/ '(@&(#, !+ >%;( #1%4*"6 '#% 1&5;!% '%F! ! '%#< 8!&, $( /*/ !"*>% 8(?"( )64( "*+'*$< E$( "%>$(, /*/ "% materies !4! 8*$%&!%.? J*/!8 ()&*+(8, 86 @(45>!4! @(",$!% 8*$%&!!, – #4('(, ' /($(&(8 "% +*/4G>*%$#, "!>%;( '%F%#$'%""(;(, "( /($(&(% $%8 "% 8%"%% +*"!8*%$ 586 45>7!: 86#4!$%4%. ' ;(&*+1( )(4<7%., 8(?%$ )6$<, #$%@%"!, >%8 '#,/(% 1&5;(% #4('(. R*7% '&%8,, ;('(&,$, +*&*?%"( 8*$%&!*4!+8(8, ("( – 8*$%&!*4!#$!>"( ! E$( @&(#$(% #4('( @(1'%&?%"( #!4<"(85 (#5?1%"!G. R( ' >%8 +*/4G>*%$#, !#$!""6. #86#4 8*$%&!! ! /*/!8 ()&*+(8 86 8(?%8 (@&%1%4!$< %;(? C E$(8 #45>*% 86, )%+ '#,/(;( #(8"%"!,, !8%%8 (1"( 4!7< "*+'*"!%. 3&;*"6 "*7!: >5'#$' "% 8(;5$ 1*$< "*8 "!/*/!: #'%1%"!. () E$(8 @&%18%$%, @($(85 >$( #4('( 8*$%&!, @&%1@(4*;*%$ $*/(% "%>$(, >%;( /*/ &*+ "% 8(;5$ "*8 1*$< "*7! (&;*"6 >5'#$'» (281, #. 434). L$($ *#@%/$ ' @("!8*"!! ! ()I,#"%"!! 8*$%&!! – &*##8($&%"!% %% ' /*>%#$'% &%*4!+5%8(;( 86#4%""(;( 2!"(-'(, 5/*+*"!% ' #',+! # E$!8 "* %%, 8*$%&!!, *)#$&*/$"6., '"%>5'#$'%""6. :*&*/$%& – 8(?"( ($8%$!$< ! ' 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!!, ! ' A!4(#(A#/(8 8!&('(++&%"!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/*. J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, L";%4<#, /*#*,#< E$(;( '(@&(#*, @!#*4: « *$%&!, /*/ $*/('*,, E$( – >!#$(% #(+1*"!% 86#4! ! *)#$&*/2!,. 6 ($'4%/*%8#, ($ /*>%#$'%""6: &*+4!>!. '%F%., /(;1* ()I%1!",%8 !:, /*/ $%4%#"( #5F%#$'5GF!%, @(1 @(",$!%8 8*$%&!!. *$%&!, /*/ $*/('*,, ' ($4!>!% ($ (@&%1%4%""6:, #5F%#$'5GF!: 8*$%&!., "% ,'4,%$#,, $*/!8 ()&*+(8, >%8-$( >5'#$'%""( #5F%#$'5GF!8» (406, #. 570). R%>$( @(1()"(% ()"*&5?!'*%$#, ! ' $*/(8, "*@&!8%&, 5$'%&?1%"!! H. . P%>%"('*: «V* ()F!8 @(",$!%8 «8*$%&!,» #/&6'*%$#,… >!#$( 4(;!>%#/(% ($'4%>%"!%» (335, #. 187). 0&*"25+#/!. 5>%"6. L. B!/*& @( E$(85 @('(15 @!#*4: «B&(2%## &*+4!>%"!,, # @(8(F
207
(@6$*. L$( *)#$&*;!&('*"!% '%1%$ / #(+1*"!G ($'4%>%""6: @(",$!.. J*/, "*@&!8%&, 86 ()&*+5%8 @(",$!%… 8*$%&!!» (301, #. 17). R( %#4! ' #4('% «8*$%&!,», ' %;( #86#4('(8 "*@(4"%"!! 8*$%&!, @&%1#$*%$ /*/ *)#$&*/$"(% @(",$!%, /*/ 4(;!>%#/*, ($'4%>%""(#$< ' %% 86#4!$%4<"(., '"%>5'#$'%""(. #5F"(#$!, $(, #4%1('*$%4<"(, 14, @(4"($6 @&%1#$*'4%"!,, 1(4?"( )6$< (@&%1%4%"( >%&%+ $( ?% #4('(, $( %#$< $(?% /*/ «8*$%&!,» ! $( ()I%/$!'"( $*%78"!*, >$( #$(!$ +* E$!8 #4('(8, >$( !8 ()(+"*>*%$#, ! ($ >%;( *)#$&*;!&5%$#,, 4(;!>%#/! ($'4%/*%$#, #(($'%$#$'5GF%% @(",$!%. H %#4! ' @%&'("*>*4<"(8 #4('(5@($&%)4%"!! @(",$!% «8*$%&!,» *)#$&*/$"( '6&*?*4( !5"! &%*4<"(%, (@&%1%4%""( '%F%#$'%""(%, * !8%""( – 1%&%'(, $( ' @(#4%15GF%8 #4('(5@($&%)4%"!! ("(, @(",$!%, ' #'(%. *)#$&*/$"(#$! "*#$(4$( #$*4( '6&*?*$< 91* &%*4<"(% ' %;( 8!&('(8 2%4(8 –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«W#4! 86 #@&(#!8 #*86: @%&%1('6: A!4(#(A(', >$( ("! &*+58%G$ @(1 #4('(8 8*$%&!,, $( ("!, '%&(,$"(, #/*?5$ "*8, >$( E$( #4('( %#$< (>%"< ()F!. $%&8!", ()(+"*>*GF!. '#,/!% 1%.#$'!,, @&(!+'(1!86% "* "*7! (F5F%"!,» (281, #. 435). L$($ *#@%/$ ' @("!8*"!! 8*$%&!! – &*##8($&%"!% %% ' /*>%#$'% ()I%/$!'"(. &%*4<"(#$!, ' %% E8@!&!>%#/(., >5'#$'%""(. 1*""(#$! >%4('%/5 – !+1*'"* 5$'%&1!4#, ' 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!!. J*/, %F% ' XVIII '%/% B.9. =(4<)*: ' #'(%8 (@&%1%4%"!! 8*$%&!! @(1>%&/"54: «B( ($"(7%"!G / "*8 8*$%&!, '(()F% %#$< '#% $(, >$( '(+1%.#$'5%$ /*/!8"!)51< ()&*+(8 "* "*7! >5'#$'*» (126, #. 84) . R* E$(. ?% @&!"2!@!*4<"(. (#"('%, "( 5?% ' &*8/*: 8*&/#!#$#/(. A!4(#(A!!, #$&(!4!#< ! 4%"!"#/!% (@&%1%4%"!, 8*$%&!!: « *$%&!, %#$< $(, >$(, 1%.#$'5, "* "*7! (&;*"6 >5'#$', @&(!+'(1!$ (F5F%"!%; 8*$%&!, %#$< ()I%/$!'"*, &%*4<"(#$<, 1*""*, "*8 ' (F5F%"!!» (204, #. 149). H $( ?% #*8(%: « *$%&!, %#$< A!4(#(A#/*, /*$%;(&!, 14, ()(+"*>%"!, ()I%/$!'"(. &%*4<"(#$!, /($(&*, 1*"* >%4('%/5 ' (F5F%"!,: %;(…» ($*8 ?%, #. 131). C /*>%#$'% ()I%/$!'"(. &%*4<"(#$!, 1*""(. >%4('%/5 ' %;( (F5F%"!,:, ' >5'#$'%""6: '(#@&!,$!,: 8*$%&!, ! !+5>*%$#, %#$%#$'%""68! "*5/*8!; ("* !+5>*%$#, !8! ' '!1% /("/&%$"6:, /*>%#$'%""( &*+4!>"6: 9*?*1-9*"".D #(#$(,"!., $( %#$< ' '!1% $%: «(@&%1%4%""6: #5F%#$'5GF!: :%-*$'=», ( /($(&6: @!#*4 L";%4<#. C E$(8 #86#4%, ' #86#4% &%*4<"(;( '%F%#$'* ' %;( /*>%#$'%""(8 &*+"(()&*+!!, #4('( «8*$%&!,» ! 5@($&%)4,4(#< 5>%"68! ' @(",$!."(8
208
(A(&84%"!! &%+54<$*$(' !##4%1('*"!.. B(E$(85 ! #$*"('!$#, '(+8(?"68 ;('(&!$< ( 8*$%&!! '( 8"(?%#$'%""(8 >!#4%, ( &*+"6: 8*$%&!,: – A!+!>%#/(., :!8!>%#/(., ?!1/(., ;*+(()&*+"(. ! $.@., /*/, "*@&!8%&, ' &*)($% @&(A%##(&* \. Q%//%&%4, «L'(4G2!, 8*$%&!! ! 8!&('» – ' $*/!: /("$%/#$*:: «B*1*GF!% +'%+16, /*/ ! /(8%$6, '%&(,$"(, #(#$(,$ !+ (>%"< $("/(. ! 1*?%, @( )(4<7%. >*#$!, ;*+(()&*+"(. 8*$%&!!» (17, #. 23) !4!: «…"%():(1!8(#$< $&%)5%$, >$()6 5&*" )64 @&(15/$(8 '"-*#$%+'' 8*$%&!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 13), !4!: «…"* @('%&:"(#$! "*7%. @4*"%$6 &*1!(*/$!'"6% '%F%#$'*, *, 8(?%$ )6$<, ! '#, 8*$%&!, "%@&%&6'"( '61%4,G$ ;%4!.» ($*8 ?%, #. 17) ! $.1. C #&*'"%"!! # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8 8*$%&!,, /*/ ()I%/$!'"*, &%*4<"(#$<, ' A!4(#(A!! – E$( 5?% "%>$( !"(%. M*/ ($8%$!4 &5##/!. A!4(#(A (!1%*4!#$, $%(4(;) C.K. M51&,'2%', «A!4(#(A#/*, 86#4< "% 8(?%$ 51('4%$'(&!$<#, "%@(#&%1#$'%""68 @(+"*"!%8 ,'4%"!. @&!&(16, /*/ ("! 1*"6 ' (@6$%; ("* #$&%8!$#, ' &*+"(()&*+"(8 "*.$! %1!"(%, ' !+8%">!'(8 @(#$(,""(%, +* ,'4%"!,8! ($/&6$< "%>$(, >$( ,'4,%$#, ! !+8%",%$#,. J*/(% %1!"(%, @(#$(,""(% ! "%!+8%""(% #5)#$*"2!*4<"(% "*>*4( A!+!>%#/(;( 8!&* ()6/"('%""( "*+6'*%$#, :%-*$'*4» (185, #. 244). H"*>% ;('(&,, ' A!4(#(A#/(8 @("!8*"!! 8*$%&!,, ' /*>%#$'% ()I%/$!'"(. &%*4<"(#$!, "( 5?% )%+($"(#!$%4<"( / >%4('%/5, '( '"%>5'#$'%""(. #A%&% )6$!, 86#4!$#, /*/ ()F%% 14, '#%;( #5F%#$'5GF%;( ' 8!&%, %1!"(%, )%#@&!>!""(% 2*$9!"%0%7!, ,'4,GF%% #()(. @(#4%1"%% (#"('*"!%, 2*$9!2$'0'"; '#%;( )%#/("%>"(;( &*+"(()&*+!, '%F%., $( %#$< @&%1#$*%$ ' /*>%#$'% 1;<1-%"+''. C E$(8 #86#4% #4('( «8*$%&!,» (+"*>*%$, /*/ #>!$*4 . G44%&, >$( ("*, 8*$%&!,, – «@&!>!"* "*7!: (F5F%"!., >$( ("* #5F%#$'5%$ ' @&(#$&*"#$'% ! '&%8%"!, >$( ("* %#$< %1!"(%, ,'4,GF%%#, ' )%#@&%&6'"(8 &*+"(()&*+!! A%"(8%"*4<"6: A(&8, >$( ("* (#$*%$#, "%!+8%""(. #&%1! @%&%8%" '"%7"!: A(&8» (281, #. 435). 0!4(#(A#/(% @("!8*"!% #5)#$*"2!! ' %% #',+! # 8*$%&!%. 8(?"( /("/&%$!+!&('*$< "* (#"('% #(($'%$#$'5GF!: !1%. K%/*&$* ! P@!"(+6. J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, K%/*&$, (@&%1%4,, #5)#$*"2!G, @!#*4: «B(1 1;<1-%"+'*= 86 8(?%8 &*+58%$< 4!7< $5 '%F<, /(, #5F%#$'5%$, #('%&7%""( "% "5?1*,#< 14, #'(%;( )6$!, ' 1&5;(. '%F!» (144, #. 334). J5 ?% #*8(1(#$*$(>"(#$< #5)#$*"2!! ($8%$!4 ' %] (@&%1%4%"!! ! P@!"(+*: «B(1 1;<1-%"+'*= , &*+58%G $(, >$( #5F%#$'5%$ #*8( ' #%)% ! @&%1#$*'4,%$#, #*8( >%&%+ #%),, $( %#$< $(, @&%1#$*'4%"!% >%;( "% "5?1*%$#, ' @&%1#$*'4%"!! 1&5;(. '%F!, !+ /($(&(;( ("( 1(4?"( )64( )6 ()&*+('*$<#,» (341, #. 361). R( @&! E$(8 K%/*&$, )515>! 15*4!#$(8, &*+4!>*4 1'(,/(;( &(1* #5)#$*"2!G – 8*$%&!*4<"5G ! "%8*$%&!*4<"5G, 15:('"5G. 3$"(#!$%4<"( @%&'(. (" ($8%$!4 #4%15GF%%: «…H8%%$#, "%/($(&*, #5)#$*"2!,, @&($,?%""*, ' 14!"5, 7!&!"5 ! ;45)!"5, #5F%#$'5GF*, ' "*#$(,F%% '&%8, ' 8!&% ! ()4*1*GF*, '#%8! #'(.#$'*8!, ( /($(&6: "*8 # (>%'!1"(#$$( ("! %. @&!#5F!. L$*-$( @&($,?%""*, 1;<1-%"+'( ! %#$< $(, >$( "*+6'*%$#, #()#$'%""( $%4(8 !4! 1;<1-%"+'*= :%-*$'%78".D 9*?*=» (144, #. 349). M&(8% E$(.,
209
8*$%&!*4<"(., #5F%#$'5%$ ! 1&5;*, – «"%8*$%&!*4<"*, #5)#$*"2!,, "% #(1%&?*F*, ' #%)% "!>%;( $%4%#"(;(» ($*8 ?%, #. 609). C ($4!>!% ($ E$(;( P@!"(+* @(4*;*4, >$( «'#,/*, #5)#$*"2!,, * #4%1('*$%4<"(, ! '#,/*, $%4%#"*, #5)#$*"2!,, @(#/(4$( «' @&!&(1% '%F%. #5F%#$'5%$ $(4"*» (341, #. 372). C #'(%8 &%*4<"(8 )6$!! )%#/("%>"*, #5)#$*"2!, @&%$'(&,%$ %1!"#$'(, 8*$%&!*4<"5G #',+< «%1!"!>"6: '%F%.», $( %#$< @&%18%$(' ! ,'4%"!. @&!&(16, '"%7"%;( 8!&* – #'(!: ('%F%#$'4%""6: >*#$%.. «J*/ /*/ @&!&(1% #5)#$*"2!!… @&!"*14%?!$ )6$< )%#/("%>"(., $( ($#G1* #4%15%$, >$( /*?1*, ($1%4<"*, >*#$< 2%4(. $%4%#"(. #5)#$*"2!! "%():(1!8( @&!"*14%?!$ / 2%4(. #5)#$*"2!! ! )%+ (#$*4<"(. #5)#$*"2!! ($( %#$< )%+ '#%: (#$*4<"6: >*#$%. E$(. $%4%#"(. #5)#$*"2!!) "% 8(?%$ "! #5F%#$'('*$<, "! )6$< 86#4!8(.» (342, #. 514). B&! E$(8 P@!"(+* #>!$*4, >$( «#5)#$*"2!, )%+5#4('"( "!>%8 !"68 @&(!+'(1!$<#, "% 8(?%$» (341, #. 364), $( %#$< ("* %#$< @&!>!"* #*8(. #%),, ! #4%1('*$%4<"(, "%#($'(&!8* ! "%5"!>$(?!8* ' #'(%. $%4%#"(#$!, 8*$%&!*4<"(#$!. C 8*&/#!#$#/(. A!4(#(A!! "%():(1!85G #(@&,?%""(#$< @(",$!. 8*$%&!! ! #5)#$*"2!! ($8%$!4 C.H. D%"!", 5$'%&?1*,, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$(, «# (1"(. #$(&("6, "*1( 5;45)!$< @(+"*"!% 8*$%&!! 1( @(+"*"!, (1( @(",$!,) #5)#$*"2!!, >$()6 "*.$! @&!>!"6 ,'4%"!.. P 1&5;(. #$(&("6, 1%.#$'!$%4<"(% @(+"*"!% @&!>!"6 %#$< 5;45)4%"!% @(+"*"!, ($ '"%7"(#$! ,'4%"!. / #5)#$*"2!!. K'(,/(;( &(1* @&!8%&6 1(4?"6 )6 @(,#"!$< E$(: 1) !+ !#$(&!! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ! 2) !+ !#$(&!! A!4(#(A!!. J(>"%%: "% «@&!8%&6» $5$ 1(4?"6 )6$<.., * /'!"$E##%"2!, $(. ! 1&5;(. !#$(&!!…» (205, #. 142-143). C 8!&('(++&%"!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/* @&%1#$*'4%"!% ( 8*$%&!! /*/ #5)#$*"2!! @&(#$5@*%$ !1%."( ! $%&8!"(4(;!>%#/! /*/ ($;(4(#(/ @(>%&@"5$6: ' !#$(&!! A!4(#(A!! !1%. ($(;( ?% K%/*&$* !4! P@!"(+6, "*@&!8%&) '/5@% # #(($'%$#$'5GF!8! $%(&%$!>%#/!8! ()()F%"!,8! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( 8*$%&!*4*. J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, D. QG:"%&, *"*4!+!&5, @*"$%!+8, ($8%$!4, >$( Q(;, «/*/ @(/*+*4 P@!"(+*, ,'4,%$#, 8*$%&!*4<"(. (#"('(. 8!&* !4! #*8(. %1!"(., '%>"(. ! )%#/("%>"(. #5)#$*"2!%. # 1'58, %% ;4*'"68! *$&!)5$*8!, @&($,?%"!%8 ! 8674%"!%8». C E$(8 #45>*%, #>!$*4 QG:"%&, «!#>%+*%$ '#,/(% 1%.#$'!$%4<"(% &*+4!>!% 8%?15 Q(;(8 ! 8!&(8, ! 86 #$(!8 #"('* "* @(>'% 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. !4! 8("!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!!, $( %#$< '(+'&*F*%8#, / "%+6)4%868 @(",$!,8 '%>"(. 8*$%&!! ! '%>"(. #!46» (51, #. 89). L$( @&!"2!@!*4<"*, A!4(#(A#/*, @(+!2!, ! #*8(;( QG:"%&*, @&!+"*'*'7%;(, >$( «%#$< $(4"!/(8 '#%;( #5F%#$'5GF%;(» ($*8 ?%, #. 64). 0!4(#(A#/*, /*$%;(&!, #5)#$*"2!! @&!8%"!$%4<"( / 8*$%&!! /("/&%$!+!&('*4*#< ' #(+"*"!! 5>%"6: ' $%(&%$!>%#/(8 /("$%/#$% !+'%#$"6: !8, @(45>%""6: !8! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: 1*""6:. J*/, K.M. */#'%44, /*#*,#< A!+!>%#/(. $%(&!! '!:&%'6: *$(8(',
210
&*+&*)($*""(. C. J(8#("(8 ! =. =%4<8;(4<2%8, @!#*4: «R*7* !1%, 8*$%&!! 8(?%$ '(.$! ' "*7% #(+"*"!% >%&%+ (@6$6 ! # $*/!8! #!#$%8*8! '!:&%., /($(&6% 86 "*+6'*%8 $%4*8! ! /($(&6%, (1"*/(, ,'4,G$#, "% #5)#$*"2!,8!, * 1'!?%"!,8! #5)#$*"2!.; )(4%% $(;(, @(45>%""(% $*/!8 ()&*+(8 @&%1#$*'4%"!% ( 8*$%&!! /*/ #5)#$*"2!!, ()4*1*GF%. !"%&2!%., ' 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! 8(?"( @&!8%"!$< / E$(. ?!1/(#$!, '!:&! ' /($(&(. @&%1#$*'4,G$ 1'!?%"!%» (231, #. 36). C )(4%% ()F%8 @4*"% E$5 ?% 86#4< ( #',+! A!4(#(A#/!: @&%1#$*'4%"!. 5>%"6: ( 8*$%&!!, /*/ #5)#$*"2!!, # !: "%@(#&%1#$'%""68! !##4%1('*"!,8! '6#/*+*4 ! H. . P%>%"('. «0!+!/* ! :!8!,, – @!#*4 (", – +*"!8*G$#,, /*/ !+'%#$"(, 8*$%&!*4<"68! ,'4%"!,8!, #4%1('*$%4<"(, 14, "!: 8*$%&!, %#$<… ()F%% "*>*4(. 3"! ! @&!+"*G$ %;(, @%&%"(#, "* 8*$%&!G $% ()F!% #'(.#$'*, /($(&6% '6&*)($*"6 !+5>%"!%8 8*$%&!*4<"6: /("/&%$"6: ,'4%"!.» (335, #. 187). P*8* ?% 8*$%&!, @&! E$(8 &*##8*$&!'*4*#< 5>%"68!, ' >*#$"(#$!, L. =%//%4%8, /*/ «&*+4!$*, ' )%#/("%>"(#$! #5)#$*"2!,» (95, #. 83). C /*>%#$'% $*/('(. 8*$%&!,, @( (@&%1%4%"!G K.H. %"1%4%%'*, %#$< «$(, !+ >%;( #(#$(,$ $%4* @&!&(16 ! # >%8 #('%&7*G$#, 1'!?%"!, ! ,'4%"!, @&!&(16» (260, #. 590). 0!/#!&5, @(1 E$!8 5;4(8 +&%"!, "*!)(4%% ()F!% #5F"(#$"6% :*&*/$%&!#$!/! "%@(#&%1#$'%""(;( )6$!, 8*$%&!!, 5>%"6% "* (#"('% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( +*/("* #(:&*"%"!, '%F%#$'* @&!:(1!4! / 5)%?1%"!G ' 9*0"!1-' 8*$%&!!, %% "*1!-9!$':!1-', >$( #>!$*4(#< "%($I%84%8(. >%&$(. "*5>"(;( 8!&('(++&%"!,. «R*5/*, – @!#*4 */#'%44, – "% 8(?%$ &*##5?1*$< ( #($'(&%"!! 8*$%&!! !+ "!>%;(» (231, #. 89). B( 8"%"!G QG:"%&*, «8*$%&!, # %% #'(.#$'*8!, #(#$(,"!,8! !4! 1'!?%"!,8!… '#%;1* #5F%#$'('*4* ! '#%;1* )51%$ #5F%#$'('*$<, – 1&5;!8! #4('*8!: 8!& "% 8(; )6$< #(+1*"» (52, #. 6). P$(4< ?% (),+*$%4<"68 )64( ! @&!+"*"!% "*;"'0-!>':!1-', "%&*+&57!8(#$! 8*$%&!!. =%//%4< @!#*4, ' >*#$"(#$!: « 6 "!;1% ' @&!&(1% "% "*)4G1*%8, >$()6 !8%GF*,#, ' "*4!>"(#$! 8*$%&!, !#>%+*4* !4! @&%'&*F*4*#< ' "!>$(» (95, #. 256). B&!8%"!$%4<"( / /("/&%$"(. @(+"*'*$%4<"(. #A%&% H. . P%>%"(' ($8%$!4: «C #('&%8%""(. :!8!! !#:(1"(. !#$!"(. #>!$*%$#, 86#4< ( "%&*+&57*%8(#$! 8*$%&!!» (335, #. 252). C 2%4(8 ?%, /*/ @(1>%&/"54 QG:"%&, «8*$%&!,, /*/ $*/('*,, )%##8%&$"*, "%5"!>$(?!8*» (52, #. 10). R%$&51"( +*8%$!$<, >$( '+;4,16 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. #('@*1*4! ' 1*""(8 #45>*% # '(++&%"!,8! A!4(#(A('–8*$%&!*4!#$('. C E$(8 @&(,'!4*#< ()F"(#$< !#:(1"6: @&!"2!@(' A!4(#(A#/(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* ! 8*$%&!*4!+8* %#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/(;(. C $( ?% '&%8, "*+'*""6% @&!"2!@6 ! &*+4!>*4!#< 8%?15 #()(., &*+4!>*4!#< @( #'(%. A!4(#(A#/(. ;45)!"%, @( 5&('"G A!4(#(A#/!-$%(&%$!>%#/(. ()(#"('*""(#$!, @( #$%@%"! !: (#(+"*""(#$!, @( '&%8%"! A(&854!&('*"!,, "*/("%2. J*/, %F% ' XVIII '%/% B.9. =(4<)*:, /*#*,#< &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( '(@&(#*, @!#*4: «W#4! "*# #@&(#,$, ($/51* ,'!4*#< 8*$%&!,, 86 ($'%$!8, >$( ("* #5F%#$'('*4* '#%;1*… *$%&!, "% 8(;4* "*>*$< #5F%#$'('*$<, ("* #5F%#$'5%$ ($ '%/*, "!/(;1* "% @%&%#$*"%$
211
#5F%#$'('*$<… P5F%#$'('*"!% 8*$%&!! %#$< A*/$…» (126, #. 80-81). C 2%4(8 ?% 14, A!4(#(A('–8*$%&!*4!#$(' "%#($'(&!8(#$< ! "%&*+&57!8(#$< 8*$%&!! – E$(, /*/ @!#*4 L";%4<#, «#$*&6% ()F%!+'%#$"6% A*/$6», E$( «1*'"68-1*'"( !+'%#$"6% "*8 '%F!» (405, #. 65). P/*+*$< $*/ ?% ( #%)% 5>%"6%–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* "% 8(;4!. R*@&($!', ' '(@&(#% ( 8*$%&!!, ( %% #5F%#$'('*"!! !8 @&!:(1!4(#< @&%(1(4%'*$< 5"*#4%1('*""6% ($ 84*1%">%#/(;( #(#$(,"!, %#$%#$'(+"*"!, @&%1#$*'4%"!, ( "*4!>!! ' @&!&(1% "%/!: */$!'"6: «"%8*$%&!*4<"6: 8*$%&!.», $*/ "*+6'*%86: «"%'%#(86:», /($(&6% #5F%#$'5G$ ,/()6 "%+*'!#!8( 1&5; ($ 1&5;*, 8(;5$ #(+1*'*$<#, ! 5"!>$(?*$<#,. H @($&%)('*4(#< "%8*4( @(+"*'*$%4<"6: 5#!4!. 14, $(;(, >$()6 E$! (7!)(>"6% @&%1#$*'4%"!, ( 8*$%&!! )64! @&%(1(4%"6, 5#$&*"%"6 !+ "*5>"(;( ()!:(1*. 3$/*+ ($ «"%'%#(86:» @&!'(1!4 5>%"6: / 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(85 '6'(15, /($(&6. 14, "!:, ' ($4!>!% ($ A!4(#(A('8*$%&!*4!#$(' $(;( '&%8%"!, @&%1#$*'*4 /*/ #*8("('%.7*, !#$!"*. -. *.%& ' #',+! # E$!8 @!#*4: «C6#/*?%8 '%4!/5G !#$!"5: "% #5F%#$'5%$ "!/*/!: "%8*$%&!*4<"6: 8*$%&!.»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«8*##%, #"*)?%""(. ()I%8(8, '%#(8 ! :!8!>%#/!8! #'(.#$'*8!» (293, #. 18). J*/(% ($(?%#$'4%"!% 8*$%&!! # '%F%#$'(8, '#4%1#$'!% !+8%"%"!. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: @&%1#$*'4%"!. ( "%8, ( %;( /("/&%$"6: #(#$(,"!,: (($/&6$!% &*1!(*/$!'"(#$! ! 1&.), ' 8!&('(++&%">%#/(8 @4*"% @&!'(1!4( @(1>*# / '6'(1*8 ( $(8, >$( 8*$%&!, «@&%'&*F*%$#,», «1%;&*1!&5%$» (#8. 17, #. 8, 43), * $( ! '('#% «!#>%+*%$». J*/, =. D%)(" ' #'(%. &*)($% «L'(4G2!, 8*$%&!!» 5$'%&?1*%$, >$( «8*$%&!, "% '%>"*, >$( ("* )%+'(+'&*$"( !#>%+*%$» (200, #. 3). C 1&5;(. &*)($% («L'(4G2!, #!4») # :*&*/$%&"68 @(1+*;(4('/(8 «3@6$6 "*1 1%8*$%&!*4!+*2!%G 8*$%&!!» D%)(" @!7%$: «X @(#',$!4 (/(4( 1%#,$! 4%$ !##4%1('*"!,8.., >$()6 1(/*+*$< "%(#"('*$%4<"(#$< 1(;8 "%5"!>$(?!8(#$! 8*$%&!!. *$%&!,, #(;4*#"( E$!8 (@6$*8, 1(4?"* $(?% @&(.$! >%&%+ 2!/4, >%&%+ /($(&6. @&(:(1,$ '#% '%F!, ()&%>%""6% "* #$*&(#$< ! "* ;!)%4<… *$%&!, 5"!>$(?!8*…» (201, #. 6). 9. B5*"/*&% ' "*>*4% UU '%/* !#$(4/('*4 "('6% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6% 1*""6%, ' >*#$"(#$!, ($/&6$!, ' A!+!/%, /*/ «/("%2 8*$%&!!»: «31"( !+ #*86: 51!'!$%4<"6: ($/&6$!., ( /($(&(8 A!+!/! ()I,'!4! ' E$! @(#4%1"!% ;(16, #(#$(!$ ' $(8, >$( 8*$%&!! "% #5F%#$'5%$» (313, #. 191-192). *$%&!! "% #5F%#$'5%$, * :%-*$'%78".= 8!& /*/ #5F%#$'('*4, $*/ ! @&(1(4?*%$ #5F%#$'('*$
212
8*$%&!,? M*/*, ?% 8*$%&!, ' $*/(8 #45>*% "% #5F%#$'5%$? M*/*,, @&(#5F%#$'('*' /*/(%-$( '&%8,, !#>%+*%$, &*+&57*%$#,? P/(4%+*GF!: ! #(:&*",GF!:#,? P'(G (#()5G @(+!2!G ' ($"(7%"!! @&()4%86 8*$%&!! ' A!4(#(A!! ! ' 8!&('(++&%">%#/(. #A%&% %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ' /("2% XIX – "*>*4% XX '%/* (@&%1%4!4 ! @(+!$!'!+8 (E8@!&!(/&!$!2!+8) 9'%"*&!5#* ! *:*, @&%$%"1('*'7!. $(;1* "* &(4< «A!4(#(A!! "('%.7%;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!,». § 2. $82H3DB; B;FD8== 5 >2C=F=5=CBD: 52CC8DE=9 %;Q; C &*8/*: E8@!&!(/&!$!2!+8*, #'(%. *"$!8%$*A!+!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! -. 9'%"*&!5# '(()F% ($'%&; @(+!$!'"(% &*##8($&%"!% @&()4%86 8*$%&!! ' %% A!4(#(A#/(. («8%$*A!+!>%#/(.») !@(#$*#!; (" #>!$*4, >$( «'"5$&! (>!F%""(;( «@(4"(;( (@6$*» "%$ «A!+!>%#/(;(» – «8*$%&!!» ' 8%$*A!+!>%#/(8 *)#(4G$"(8 @(",$!!, !)( «8*$%&!,» ' E$(8 @(",$!! %#$< 4!7< *)#$&*/2!,… « *$%&!, ' 8%$*A!+!>%#/(8 *)#(4G$"(8 @(",$!! %#$< @(4"*, )%##86#4!2*» ([!$. @(: 204, #. 147). *:, #( #'(%. #$(&("6, %#4! ! /*#*4#, @&()4%8, #',+*""6: # 8*$%&!%., $(, ;4*'"68 ()&*+(8, ' !: ($"(7%"!! / >5'#$'%""68 '(#@&!,$!,8 >%4('%/*, ' #',+! # *"*4!+(8 (F5F%"!., @&(2%##* @(+"*"!,, $( %#$< @&!8%"!$%4<"( / @#!:(4(;!>%#/(. ! ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/(. @&()4%8*$!/% #'(!: !##4%1('*"!.. 3" @(E$(85 !+)%;*4 @&%1%4<"( 7!&(/!: A!4(#(A#/!: («8%$*A!+!>%#/!:») ()()F%"!.. « 6 '(()F% )51%8 (#$%&%;*$<#, #4!7/(8 #/(&(#@%46: A!4(#(A#/!: ()()F%"!. ! #/(&(#@%4(. #!#$%8*$!+*2!!», – @!#*4 (", @&!#$5@*, / !+4(?%"!G #'(!: '+;4,1(' ' &*)($% «B(+"*"!% ! +*)45?1%"!%» (254, #. 27). -%*4!+*2!, E$(;( @&!"2!@* ' @(4"(. 8%&% @&(,'!4*#< ! @( ($"(7%"!G / 8*$%&!!. C+;4,1 *:* "* 8*$%&!G ! A(&86 %% #5F%#$'('*"!, – E$(, ;4*'"68 ()&*+(8, '+;4,1 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,, * "% A!4(#(A*, $( %#$< '+;4,1, (;&*"!>%""6. &*8/*8! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( 8!&('(++&%"!,. C( '#,/(8 #45>*%, $*/ #>!$*4 #*8 *:. B(E$(85 ! @&()4%8* 8*$%&!! (/*+6'*%$#, 5 "%;( ' &,15 1&5;!: #5;5)( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: @&()4%8. «K4, 8%",, – @!#*4 (", – 8*$%&!,, '&%8, ! @&(#$&*"#$'( #5$< $*/?% %F% @&()4%86, / &%7%"!G /($(&6:, '@&(>%8, A!+!/! (D(&%"2, L."7$%.", !"/('#/!.) @(#$%@%""( @&!)4!?*G$#, '#% )(4<7% ! )(4<7%. K* ! / $(85 ?% A!+!/*, E$( "% '%#< 8!&, "% #4%15%$ +*)6'*$< ! )!(4(;!!, /($(&*, $(?% !;&*%$ #5F%#$'%""5G &(4< ' /*&$!"% 8!&*» (252, #. 142). L$* *@%44,2!, / )!(4(;!! /*/ (1"(85 !+ '*?"%.7!: – "*&,15 # A!+!/(. – #&%1#$' &%7%"!, @&()4%86 8*$%&!! $*/?% '%#<8* :*&*/$%&"* 14, *:*: ' "%. ($>%$4!'( @&(,'!4(#< %;( "%?%4*"!% (;&*"!>!$<#, (1"(. $(4"(;( @(+"*"!,, ' 1*""(8 #45>*% – A!+!/!, #$&%84%"!% '6.$! +* %% @&%1%46 – ' ()4*#$<, "%@(#&%1#$'%""( #',+*""5G # @(+"*"!%8 ?!+"!, >%4('%/*, $( %#$< #$&%84%"!% 5#$*"('!$< )(4%% ()F!% @&!"2!@6 @(+"*"!, 8!&*. 9. L."7$%.", ($8%>*, E$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(,
213
@!#*4: «0!4(#(A#/!% !##4%1('*"!, *:* )64! '6+'*"6 4!7< ?%4*"!%8 '6&*)($*$< $(>/5 +&%"!,, @(+'(4,GF5G %1!"68 ()&*+(8 &*##8*$&!'*$< &*+4!>"6% ()4*#$! "*5/!, /($(&68 (" @(#',$!4 '#G #'(G ?!+"<» (403, #. 32). K&5;(% 1%4( –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– ($"(7%"!, %;( @(+"*'*"!,, "%@(#&%1#$'%""(. A(&8(. /($(&(;( ,'4,G$#, >5'#$'%""6% '(+)5?1%"!,. «3$"(7%"!, @&*'!4<"(. +*'!#!8(#$!, /($(&6% "*)4G1*G$#, 8%?15 >5'#$'%""68! '(+)5?1%"!,8! &*+"(;( &(1* @( ($"(7%"!G 1&5; / 1&5;5, –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– ! !#>%&@6'*%$#, !8!. 3$#G1* '6'(1 *:* ( $(8, >$( 8*$%&!,, $%4*, '"%7"!. 8!&, '/4G>*GF!. ' #%), E$! $%4*, 1;?*1-9;4-, "( #5F%#$'('*"!% 8*$%&!! ! $%4 9.$%>%*-1( 14, >%4('%/* ' %;( (F5F%"!,:, 5@(&,1(>%""6: (@&%1%4%""68 ()&*+(8, $(;1* /*/ #5F%#$'('*"!% '"%7"%;( 8!&* '6&*?*%$#, *"*4(;!>"68 ()&*+(8 ' (F5F%"!,: (@&%1%4%""(;( 8"(?%#$'* 4G1%.. «C#% A!+!>%#/!% +*/("6, – @!#*4 *:, – $*/ ?%, /*/ #5F%#$'('*"!% 8*$%&!! ! $%4, !8%G$ (#"('(G 5@&*'4%"!,… 8%?15 >5'#$'%""68! E4%8%"$*8!, 1*""68! >%4('%/5.
214
P5F%#$'('*"!% '"%7"%;( 8!&* "*:(1!$ #'(% '6&*?%"!% ' 5&*'"%"!,: 8%?15 >5'#$'%""68! E4%8%"$*8!, 1*""68! 4G1,8» ($*8 ?%, #. 81). R*4!2(, #4%1('*$%4<"(, A%"(8%"*4!#$!>%#/*, /("2%@2!, #5F%#$'('*"!,, @(#&%1#$'(8 /($(&(. *: @6$*4#, @&%(1(4%$< ' 8!&('(++&%">%#/(. #A%&% @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$< 8*$%&!*4!+8* ! !1%*4!+8*, #('8%#$!$< ' ()I%1!",GF%8 #!"$%+% +*'%1(8( "%#('8%#$!8(%, :($, %;( #5)I%/$!'"6% @()5?1%"!, / E$(85 '6;4,1,$ '@(4"% (@&*'1*""68! – ' @&%1%4*: %;( @("!8*"!, 8*$%&!*4!+8* ! !1%*4!+8*. J*/, "%1(#$*$(>"(#$< 8*$%&!*4!+8* *: 5#8*$&!'*4 ' *)#(4G$!+*2!! A!+!>%#/(;( @(1:(1* / @(+"*"!G 8!&* ! @(+"*GF%;( %;( >%4('%/*, ' #'%1%"!! @#!:!>%#/(;( / A!+!>%#/(85, !"*>% ;('(&,, #(+"*"!, / 8*$%&!!. B( %;( 8"%"!G, «4G1!, /($(&6% 158*G$ @(",$< 8!&, #'(1, @#!:!>%#/(% / 8*$%&!*4<"(85, "*>!"*G$ "%8%14%""( +*@5$6'*$<#,, /*/ $(4$()6 #'(1!$< (1"( "* 1&5;(%» (253, #. 17-18). *:, #4%1('*$%4<"(, '(+&*?*4 +1%#< "% $(4%#/(;(» #'%1%"!, @#!:!>%#/(;( / A!+!>%#/(85, "( ! @&($!' «@&($!'(@(4(?"(. @(@6$/!»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«M*/('6 )515$ $% @(",$!,, ' /($(&6: )51%$ ()()F%" '%#< 8!&, /(;1* 2%@< A!+!>%#/!: ! @#!:(4(;!>%#/!: A*/$(&(', &*+1%4%""*, ' "*#$(,F%% '&%8, "* E$! 1'% @(4('!"6, (/*?%$#, +*8/"5$(.?.. P(:&*"!$ 4! $(;1* /*/(%-4!)( "*5>"(% +"*>%"!% $( @(",$!%, /($(&(% "*+6'*%8 $%@%&< 8*$%&!%., !4! ("( #(:&*"!$#, 4!7< ' ?!$%.#/(8 ()!:(1%, – 86 "% +"*%8. R( @($(8/*8 "*7!8, )%+ #(8"%"!,, )51%$ /(;1*-"!)51< "%@(",$"( #4%15GF%%: /*/ 86 8(;4! ' "*7%8 A!+!>%#/(8 8!&% *$(8(' @($%&,$< '1&5; 2'%$* ! $("6, /($(&6%, '%1<, '#%;( "*8 )4!?%? M*/ 86 8(;4! !+584,$<#, $(85, >$( $(, >$( '( '"%7"%8 8!&% 758!$ ! #$5>!$, '( '"5$&%""%8 "*7%8 8!&%, ' "*7%. ;(4('%, #'%$!$ ! @(%$? M*/!8 ()&*+(8 86 8(;4! +*1*'*$<#, '(@&(#(8, /*/ 8(?%$ (F5F*$< 8*$%&!,, $( %#$< /*/ 8(?%$ (F5F*$< 86#4%""6. #!8'(4 14, ;&5@@6 (F5F%"!.?» (255, #. 170). R%$ "%():(1!8(#$! '(+&*?*$< *:5 ! 1(/*+6'*$<, >$( @(",$!% 8*$%&!! "% $(4"(% +"*>%"!%, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' #('&%8%""(8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, "( ! "*@(4"!4(#< "('68, )(4%% )(;*$68 #(1%&?*"!%8, ' /($(&(8 "*74! #'(% 8%#$( ! «2'%$* ! $("6, /($(&6% '#%;( "*8 )4!?%». 3$8%$!8 1&5;(%: /*/!8 ()&*+(8, 1%.#$'!$%4<"(, 8(?"( )64( +*1*'*$<#, '(@&(#(8, /*/ (F5F*%$ 8*$%&!,, %#4! #*8* 8*$%&!, &*##8*$&!'*%$#, @&! E$(8 /*/ «86#4%""6. #!8'(4 14, ;&5@@6
215
(F5F%"!.»? 31"( !#/4G>*%$ 1&5;(%. R*1( 4!)( @&!+"*$<, >$( 8*$%&!, ' #'(%8 /("/&%$"(8 @&(,'4%"!! – ' >%4('%/% (($'4%>%8#, ($ ?!'($"6:) (F5F*%$ #%), (#*8((F5F%"!% >%4('%/*) ! 1&5;!% %% @&(,'4%"!,, #(#$*'4,GF!% '"%7"!. @( ($"(7%"!G / >%4('%/5 8!&, ! $(;1* 8*$%&!, @&%1#$*%$ /*/ ()I%/$!'"*, &%*4<"(#$<, 1*""*, >%4('%/5 ' %;( (F5F%"!,:, 4!)(, @&!+"*' 8*$%&!G «86#4%""68 #!8'(4(8 14, ;&5@@6 (F5F%"!.», !#/4G>!$< 14, "%% $%8 #*868 '#,/5G '(+8(?"(#$< (F5F*$<. *: #('%&7*%$ +1%#< "%'(4<"5G @(1#$*"('/5: #"*>*4* @!7%$ ( 8*$%&!!, @(1&*+58%'*, $( %% @(",$!%, /($(&(% 5$'%&1!4(#< ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, ( 8*$%&!! ' %% %-!:"!: #$&(%"!!, $( %#$< /*/ ( >%8-$( $*/(8, >$(, ' @&%1#$*'4%"!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%.–8*$%&!*4!#$(', #5F%#$'5%$ ()I%/$!'"(, '"% (F5F%"!. >%4('%/* ! >%&%+ (F5F%"!, @(+"*%$#, !8, * +*$%8 @!7%$ ( 8*$%&!! ' 19!*:, 8*:('#/(8, @("!8*"!!, $( %#$< ( 8*$%&!! /*/ ( >%8-$( $*/(8, >$( "% 8(?%$ ()4*1*$< #'(.#$'(8 (F5F%"!,, "% 8(?%$ @(+"*'*$<#, >%&%+ (F5F%"!,, @(#/(4$( !"(%, /*/ «86#4%""6. #!8'(4 14, ;&5@@6 (F5F%"!.». B(#/(45'#$'('*"!, #(#5F%#$'('*"!% 4G)(. (F5F*%8(. '%F!, $( 8*$%&!,, /*/ !: «86#4%""6. #!8'(4», ' #(+"*"!! >%4('%/* 8(?%$ &*##8*$&!'*$<#, !8 4!7< @&! "*4!>!! E$!: «;&5@@ (F5F%"!.». Q%+ "!:, '"% "!: ;('(&!$< ( 8*$%&!! "%$ #86#4*. R!/*/!8 $&*"#2%"1%"$"68 )6$!%8, "*@(1()!% /*"$('#/(. «'%F! ' #%)%», 8*$%&!, "% ()4*1*%$, ("* "% ,'4,%$#, $&*"#2%"1%"$"(. (()I%/$!'"(., #/*+*4! )6 86) &%*4<"(#$5'#$'%""68 @%&%?!'*"!,8 #5)I%/$*. 3"* &*##8*$&!'*4*#< *:(8 $(4%&%+ E$! @%&%?!'*"!, – /*/ '6&*?*%8(% 86#4%8, '&%8%"*8! *:, "% 851&#$'5, 45/*'(, @&(#$( @!7%$ ( 8*$%&!*4<"(#$! /*/ ( '6&*?%"!! >%;(-$( ()I%/$!'"(–&%*4<"(;(. (?"( ' #',+! # E$!8 ($8%$!$< $*/!% %;( #5?1%"!, /*/ «8*$%&!*4<"6. 8!&» (246, #. 255, 459), «8*$%&!*4<"*, #&%1*, (/&5?*GF*, "*#», «8*$%&!*4<"6% #'(.#$'* $%4» (254, #. 332, 359) ! $.@. C $*/!: #45>*,: *:, @( 8"%"!G C.H. D%"!"*, «+*)6'*%$ #'(G #()#$'%""5G $%(&!G !, "*>!"*, ;('(&!$< ( &*+4!>"6: '(@&(#*: A!+!/!, &*##5?1*%$ @(@&(#$5, )%+ !1%*4!#$!>%#/!: '6/&5$*#, $( %#$< 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!» (204, #. 61). § 3. #F82DE=D B;FD8==: ;F2B=4F=ID4<=G ;4>D"(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* ,'4,%$#, @&!+"*"!% 5>%"68! %-!:"!#! #$&(%"!, 8*$%&!!. -%+54<$*$6 !: "*)4G1%"!. ! E/#@%&!8%"$(' ' $(. !4! !"(. 8%&% ()"*&5?!'*4! 1!#/&%$"(#$< '( '"5$&%""%8 #$&(%"!! 8*$%&!!, 5)%?1*4! ' #5F%#$'('*"!! E4%8%"$*&"6: 8*$%&!*4<"6: ()&*+('*"!. – *$(8('. D. Q(4<28*" @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «C#% "*)4G1%"!, %1!"(157"( 1(/*+6'*G$, >$( #5F%#$'5G$ $%4* $*/!: "!>$(?"6: &*+8%&(', >$(, $(4
216
#2%@4,,#< 8!44!("*8!, ("! 8(;5$ '(+)5?1*$< "*7! (&;*"6 >5'#$'. 6 "*+6'*%8 !: *$(8*8!»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« "(;( @(4<+6 @&!"%#4! *$(8!#$!>%#/!% @&%1#$*'4%"!, 14, A!+!/!, :!8!! ! /&!#$*44(;&*A!! )4*;(1*&, &*+'!$!G "*;4,1"(#$! ! ,#"(#$!» ($*8 ?%, #. 130). =.9. D(&%"2 #>!$*4, >$( «45>7!8 (@&*'1*"!%8 *$(8!#$!/! ,'4,G$#, %% @4(1($'(&"(#$< ! 2%4%#(()&*+"(#$<». C#4%1#$'!% E$(;( ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(. /*&$!"% 8!&* *$(8!#$!/* (/*+*4*#<, @( #4('*8 D(&%"2*, «"*!)(4%% @(1:(1,F%. 14, #(+1*"!, ,#"6: @&%1#$*'4%"!.» !8%""( @($(85, >$( ' %% (#"('% – ($&*?%"!% &%*4<"(;( #(#$(,"!, @&%18%$(' ! ,'4%"!. ()I%/$!'"( #5F%#$'5GF%;( '"%7"%;( 8!&*. L$( +"*>!$, >$( *$(8!#$!>%#/!% @&%1#$*'4%"!, ' "*5/% #(($'%$#$'5G$ *$(8!#$!/% ' ()I%/$!'"(. &%*4<"(#$!, ' 8*$%&!! – $(. *$(8!#$!/%, /($(&*,, /*/ @!#*4 D(&%"2, «4%?!$ ' @&!&(1% '%F%. "%+*'!#!8( ($ "*#» (219, #. 66). J%(&!, *$(8"(;( #$&(%"!, 8*$%&!!, /($(&*,, /*/ ($8%>*4 %F% . 0*&*1%., #$*4* @&%()4*1*GF%. ' #%&%1!"% XIX '%/*, &*##8*$&!'*4* *$(8, /*/ «"%>$( 8*$%&!*4<"(%, !8%GF%% "%/($(&6. ()I%8» (368, #. 292). C#% #(#$(,"!, 8*$%&!*4<"6: $%4, !: #'(.#$'* #'(1!4!#< / *$(8*8, / !: #(#$(,"!,8. C#% !+8%"%"!, ' 8*$%&!*4<"(8 8!&% ()I,#",4!#< !+8%"%"!,8! ' %;( *$(8"(8 #$&(%"!!. J*/, @( 8"%"!G K.M. */#'%44*, «#'(.#$'* $%4* !4! #&%16 (@&%1%4,G$#, /("A!;5&*2!%. ! 1'!?%"!%8 !: 8%4<>*.7!: >*#$%.» (231, #. 128). C 2%4(8 ?% *$(86 &*##8*$&!'*4!#< 5>%"68! /*/ «/&*%5;(4<"6% /*8"! 8*$%&!*4<"(. C#%4%""(.» ($*8 ?%, #. 90). « 6 "*+6'*%8 %-!:!:, – @!#*4 D. QG:"%&, – #*85G 8*45G >*#$!25 :!8!>%#/(;( E4%8%"$* !4! @&(#$(;( $%4*, #>!$*%85G "*8! "%1%4!8(. !4! "% 1%4,F%.#, 1*4%%, ! 86 @&%1#$*'4,%8 #%)%, >$( '#, 8*$%&!, !4! '#% $%4* #(#$(,$ !+ E$!: *$(8('…» (52, #. 26). R% #45>*."( @(E$(85 *$(8!+8 @&%1#$*'*4 ' #(+"*"!! 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. /*/ "%($I%84%8*, >%&$* @&(;&%##* "*5/! "* '#%: @&%17%#$'5GF!: E$*@*: %% &*+'!$!,. */#'%44, "*@&!8%&, #>!$*4, >$( «/*?1(% @(/(4%"!%, ($ #*8(;( &*""%;( &*##'%$* "*5/! 1( "*7!: 1"%., '#%;1* @(#',F*4( 1(4?"5G 1(4G #'(!: !"$%44%/$5*4<"6: #!4 "* &*+&%7%"!% '(@&(#* ( @(#4%1"%8 *$(8%» (231, #. 74). P5F%#$'%""( $*/?% ! $(, >$( *$(8!+8, ' @("!8*"!! 5>%"6:, :*&*/$%&!+5%$ "% $(4
217
@(#4%15GF%;( %% &*+'!$!,. M*/ )6 @&(1(4?*, 86#4< */#'%44*, D. Q(4<28*" @!#*4: «R*'#%;1* (#$*"%$#, (1"!8 !+ '*?"%.7!: A*/$(' %#$%#$'(+"*"!, $(, >$( #5F%#$'5%$ !+'%#$"*, 1!#/&%$"(#$< '( '"5$&%""%8 #$&(%"!! 8*$%&!!» (35, #. 102). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, 14, 5>%"6: (>%'!1"(. )64* @(#$(,""*, ?!+"%#@(#()"(#$< *$(8!#$!/!, /*/ "%():(1!8(;( @5$! @(+"*"!, @&!&(16. 9$(8, @( 8"%"!G */#'%44*, «"% @(1'%&?%" /*/!84!)( (@*#"(#$,8 ' )(&<)% +* #5F%#$'('*"!%» (231, #. 164). -*+'!$!% %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, (#()%""( %;( 5#@%:! '( '$(&(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/*, '6,'!4! "('6% '*?"6% #$(&("6 ' *$(8"(8 #$&(%"!! '%F%#$'*. 9 E$( ()5#4('!4( (#()5G +"*>!8(#$< *$(8!#$!/! ' &,15 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: !##4%1('*"!.. «C "('(% '&%8, !+5>%"!% @&!&(16 @&(4!4( #'%$ "* "%/($(&6% #'(.#$'* $%4, +*'!#,F!%, @(-'!1!8(85, ($ '%4!>!"6 ! 1'!?%"!, !: @(#4%1"!: #(#$*'"6: >*#$%., ! '(@&(# ( #5F%#$'('*"!! *$(8(' #"('* #1%4*4#, (1"!8 !+ '*?"%.7!: #&%1! 1&5;!: "*5>"6: !+6#/*"!.» ($*8 ?%, #. 22). C #'(G (>%&%1<, '6,'4%"!% "('6: #$(&(" 8*$%&!*4<"6: ()I%/$(', #$(&(", #',+*""6: # *$(8"68 #$&(%"!%8 '%F%#$'*, "% 8(;4( ($&*+!$<#, "* %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: !, ' /("%>"(8 #>%$%, "* 8!&('(++&%">%#/!: @&%1#$*'4%"!,: 5>%"6: () *$(8%, ( %;( #$&5/$5&%. R* @&($,?%"!! @(>$! '#%;( XIX '%/* *$(8 &*##8*$&!'*4#, 5>%"68! /*/ @(#4%1"!. /!&@!>!/ 8!&(+1*"!,, /*/ @&(#$%.7%%, *)#(4G$"( "%1%4!8(% 8*$%&!*4<"(% ()&*+('*"!%, $( %#$< /*/ «*$(8» ' )5/'*4<"(8 #86#4% E$(;( #4('*. «9$(8, – @!#*4 */#'%44, – %#$< $%4(, /($(&(% "%4<+, &*##%>< @(@(4*8» ($*8 ?%, #. 71). 3" '6&*?*4 5'%&%""(#$< 5>%"6: «' "%&*+&57!8(#$! /*?1(. >*#$!26 8*$%&!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 36). 3>%'!1"(, >$( ' $*/(8 @("!8*"!! *$(8* 5>%"6% '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* "% 74! 1*4<7% (#"('*$%4%. *$(8!#$!/! – 1&%'"%;&%>%#/!: A!4(#(A('-8*$%&!*4!#$('. H E$( #('@*1%"!% ()F!: '(++&%"!. "* *$(8 "% )64( #45>*."68. J*/, 0. L";%4<#, &*#/&6'*, #'(% @("!8*"!% %;( @&!>!", @!#*4: «J%(&%$!>%#/(% %#$%#$'(+"*"!%, %#4! ("( :(>%$ @&(#4%1!$< !#$(&!G '(+"!/"('%"!, ! &*+'!$!, #'(!: $%@%&%7"!: ()F!: @(4(?%"!., '6"5?1%"( '(+'&*F*$<#, / ;&%/*8. H @("!8*"!% E$(;( '#% )(4%% ! )(4%% @&(/4*16'*%$ #%)% 1(&(;5. C#% )(4%% &%1/!8! #$*"(',$#, $% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4!, /($(&6% #*8! (@%&!&5, ()&6'/*8! ;&%>%#/(. A!4(#(A!!, "*@&!8%& *$(8!#$!/!, /*/ '%>"68! !#$!"*8!, #8($&,$ "* ;&%/(' @(-)E/("('#/! #'6#(/* "* $(8 (#"('*"!!, >$( 5 @(#4%1"!: "% )64( E8@!&!>%#/(;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!,» (406, #. 369-370). H44G#$&*2!%. E$!: 86#4%. L";%4<#* 8(;5$ #45?!$< '6#/*+6'*"!, */#'%44*. J*/, ' (1"(. !+ #'(!: 4%/2!., '+,' 14, @&!8%&* /*@4G '(16, 5>%"6. @(#$*'!4 @%&%1 #457*$%4,8! '(@&(#: « (?"( 4! @&(1(4?*$< @&(2%## 1%4%"!, /*/ 5;(1"( 1*4%/(?» 3$'%>*, "* E$($ '(@&(#, */#'%44 #(#4*4#, "* *"$!>"6: 86#4!$%4%.: «P(;4*#"( K%8(/&!$5 ! *$(8!#$!>%#/(. 7/(4%, 86 1(4?"6 ($'%$!$< ($&!2*$%4<"(. B(#4% "%/($(&(;( >!#4* 1%4%"!. /*@4, &*+1%4!$#, "* >*#$!, !+ /($(&6: /*?1*, 5?% "%#@(#()"* / 1*4<"%.7%85 1%4%"!G. P4%1('*$%4<"(, 86 1(4?"6, ' '(()&*?%"!!, 1(.$! 1( *$(8*, /($(&6., /*/ )5/'*4<"( +"*>!$ E$( #4('(, "%
218
8(?%$ )6$< &*+1%4%" @(@(4*8. J*/('* *$(8!#$!>%#/*, 1(/$&!"* K%8(/&!$*, L@!/5&*, D5/&%2!, !, , 8(;5 @&!)*'!$<, – '*7%;( 4%/$(&*»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– (#"('(@(4*;*GF%. A!4(#(A#/(. '5*'. «U(&(7( !+'%#$"(, – @!7%$ D5! 1% Q&(.4<, – >$( 1&%'"!% 86#4!$%4! "%(1"(/&*$"( '6#/*+6'*4! @&%1@(4(?%"!% ( 1!#/&%$"(. @&!&(1% 8*$%&!!. 3"! @&!74! / E$(85, !#:(1, !+ A!4(#(A#/(. !1%! ( $(8, >$( "%'(+8(?"( (#(+"*$< )%#/("%>"5G 1%4!8(#$< 8*$%&!! ! @&! &*##8($&%"!! '#% )(4%% 8%4/!: /(4!>%#$' "%():(1!8( ;1%-$( (#$*"('!$<#,. K4, "!: *$(8 )64 @(#4%1"%. "%1%4!8(. >*#$%;( )64( !#/*$<. P('&%8%""*, A!+!/* $*/?% !#:(1!$ !+ @&%1#$*'4%"!, () *$(8"(. #$&5/$5&% 8*$%&!!…» (43, #. 47). K&5;(. +"*8%"!$6. A&*"25+#/!. A!+!/ B. D*"?%'%" $*/?% ($8%$!4 @(+"*'*$%4<"5G 1%.#$'%""(#$<, @(#$(,""5G, 5#$(.>!'5G ?!+"%#@(#()"(#$< *$(8!#$!/!, "*>!"*, # %% !1%."6: !#$(/(' ' *"$!>"(. A!4(#(A!!, @&(1(4?%""(. +*$%8 ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!. B&! E$(8, @(1>%&/!'*%$ D*"?%'%", «# $%>%"!%8 '&%8%"! "*7* 5'%&%""(#$< ' @&*'!4<"(#$! *$(8"(., !4! /(&@5#/54,&"(., ;!@($%+6 "%@&%&6'"( '(+&*#$*4*. L$* $%(&!,, ,'4,GF*,#, &*+'!$!%8 @&%1#$*'4%"!. ;&%>%#/!: A!4(#(A(' ( $(8, >$( (/&5?*GF*, "*# 8*$%&!, #(#$(!$ !+ >&%+'6>*."( $'%&16: >*#$!2, @(1()"6: @&!'6>"68 "*8 >*#$!2*8, "( )%#/("%>"( 8%"<7!: @( '%4!>!"%, @&%1#$*'4,GF!: #()(. @&%1%4 1%4%"!, '%F%#$'*, @(45>!4* (#()%""( )(4<7(% +"*>%"!% ' @(#4%1"!% 1'* #$(4%$!,, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' #',+! # &*+'!$!%8 :!8!!» (194, #. 586). P @(+!2!. 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! L";%4<# @(1>%&/"54, >$( «# $%: @(& /*/ A!+!/* ! :!8!, #$*4! (@,$< (@%&!&('*$< @(>$! !#/4G>!$%4<"( 8(4%/54*8! ! *$(8*8!, 1&%'"%;&%>%#/*, *$(8!#$!>%#/*, A!4(#(A!, # "%():(1!8(#$!$, >$( 5>%"6%–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* ' !#:(1"6: @&!"2!@*: *$(8!#$!>%#/(. $%(&!! @&!74! ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!! ! ' ()()F%"!! %;( &%+54<$*$(' / $%8 ?% '6'(1*8, /*/!% +* 1'% $6#,>! 4%$ 1( "!: #1%4*4! *"$!>"6% A!4(#(A68*$%&!*4!#$6, * @(+1"%%, ' A!4(#(A!! R('(;( '&%8%"! 8*$%&!*4!#$6 XVII–XVIII ''. J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, +"*8%"!$6. A&*"25+#/!. A!4(#(A8*$%&!*4!#$ XVII '%/* B. =*##%"1!, (@&%1%4,, (#"('"6% 5#$*"('/! #'(!: *$(8!#$!>%#/!: '(++&%"!., @!#*4: «H+'%#$"(, >$( (1"! $%4* – E$( #(%1!"%"!,, !4!, %#4! 5;(1"(, ("! #(#$*'"6%, #4(?"6%, 1&5;!% ?% – E$( $% $%4*, !+ /($(&6: ()&*+5G$#, #(%1!"%"!,, !4! #4(?"6% $%4*. C($ E$!-$(
219
1&5;!%, %#4! ("! @%&'!>"6% ! @&(#$6%, ! @&%1#$*'4,G$ #()(. @%&'!>"5G 8*$%&!G '%F%. ! "*+6'*G$#, @%&'("*>*4*8!, * 5 "('%.7!: ("*$5&A!4(#(A(') – $*/?% E4%8%"$*8!… R%():(1!8(, >$()6 $*/ "*+6'*%86% @%&'("*>*4* #4(?"6: $%4 )64! @( #'(%. @&!&(1% "% $(4"( ! "*+6'*%8 *$(8*8!» (77, #. 151). L$* @&!"2!@!*4<"*, @(+!2!, 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! #(:&*"!4*#< ! ' XVIII '%/%. B.9. =(4<)*:, 5$'%&?1*, %% "%+6)4%8(#$<, @(1>%&/"54: « *$%&!*4!#$6, &*'"( /*/ ! A!+!/!, 1(@5#/*G$ @&(#$6% ! "%1%4!86% E4%8%"$6–*$(86, #5F%#$'*, !+ /($(&6: #(#$(,$ '#% $%4*»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«3 #$&5/$5&% *$(8* 86 @(/* %F% "!>%;( "% +"*%8 ! "% )51%8 +"*$< ( "%. "!>%;( 1( $%: @(&, @(/* "* (#"('*"!! A*/$(', "*)4G1%""6: "*7!8! (&;*"*8! >5'#$', "*8 "% 51*#$#, #A(&854!&('*$< /*/5G-"!)51< ;!@($%+5» (35, #. 8). R( E$(, /("%>"(, "% (+"*>*%$, >$( 1( @(,'4%"!, "('6: A*/$(' 5>%"6% #('%&7%""( "% +*1586'*4!#< ( #$&(%"!! *$(8*. 6#4< ( #*8(. '(+8(?"(#$! "*4!>!, 5 *$(8* #4(?"(. #$&5/$5&6 @(#$%@%""( '6+&%'*4*, @&()!'*4* #%)% 1(&(;5 "* (#"('% 1*""6:, @(45>*%86: ' @&(2%##% $*/!: "*)4G1%"!. ! E/#@%&!8%"$(', /($(&6% "%@(#&%1#$'%""( "% "*@&*'4,4!#< "* !+5>%"!% '"5$&%""%;( #$&(%"!, *$(8*. J*/, %F% ' 1871 ;(15 K.H. %"1%4%%' '6#/*+*4 86#4< ( #4(?"(8 #$&(%"!! *$(8*. «D%;/( @&%1@(4(?!$<, – @!#*4 (", – "( @(/* %F% "%$ '(+8(?"(#$! 1(/*+*$<.., >$( *$(86 @&(#$6: $%4 #5$< #4(?"6% #5F%#$'*, ()&*+('*""6% #4(?%"!%8 "%/($(&6: %F% 8%"<7!: >*#$%. (54<$!8*$('), >$( "*+6'*%8(% "*8! "%1%4!868 (*$(8) – "%1%4!8( $(4"68! :!8!>%#/!8! #!4*8!» (260, #. 381).
220
B&%14(?%"!% :!8!/* @(11%&?*4! ! @(1$'%&1!4! A!+!/!. 9.=. P$(4%$(', "*@&!8%&, ' 1894 ;(15, $( %#$< +* ;(1 1( ($/&6$!, E4%/$&("*, @(1>%&/"54: «R* /*/!% )6 ,#"( @&%1#$*'!86% E4%8%"$6 "! &*+4(?!4! 86 @&!&(15, 86 "% 8(?%8 )6$< 5'%&%"6, >$( 1(74! 1( /("2*, >$( "*7! «*$(86» "% #5$< #!#$%86 1&5;!: *$(8(' '$(&(;( @(&,1/*» (343, #. 578). H 1%.#$'!$%4<"(, @&!"2!@!*4<"( "('6% 1*""6%, @(45>%""6% A!+!/*8! ' /("2% XIX '%/*, (#()%""( ' #',+! # ($/&6$!%8 K. J(8#("(8 E4%/$&("* (1895), "% $(4%#/(% 5>%"!% "* "('(8 5&('"% +"*"!,, "( ! +*#$*'!4! 5>%"6: @(-"('(85 '+;4,"5$< "* #*8 *$(8, @&%1#$*'4%"!, ( "%8 #5F%#$'%""( !+8%"!4!#<, ! @&%?1% '#%;( @&!74(#< ($/*+*$<#, ($ !1%! %;( "%1%4!8(#$!. «B4(1($'(&"(#$< *$(8!#$!>%#/(. $%(&!!, – @!#*4 Q(4<28*" ' 1904 ;(15, – )64* )4%#$,F% 1(/*+*"* ' "('%.7%% '&%8,… P4('( «*$(8» "% 1(4?"( "*# #85F*$< – ("( "*8 +"*/(8( # 1*'"!: '&%8%", ( "%1%4!8(#$! *$(8* "% 158*%$ ' "*#$(,F%% '&%8, "! (1!" A!+!/» (35, #. 174). -*"%%, ' 1897 ;(15, Q(4<28*" @!#*4: « (?"( @("!8*$< @(1 *$(8*8! )(4%% #4(?"6%, (1*&%""6% 4G)68! /*>%#$'*8! !"1!'!15586» ($*8 ?%, #. 125-126). =.9. D(&%"2 ' #'(%. R()%4%'#/(. &%>! ' 1902 ;(15 $*/?% @(1>%&/"54, >$( «! *$(8 ,'4,%$#, #4(?"68 ()&*+('*"!%8, #(1%&?*F!8 8"(;( E4%8%"$('» (219, #. 21). K.H. %"1%4%%', ##64*,#< "* 1(#$!?%"!, A!+!/!, @!#*4 ' 1906 ;(15: «9$(86 @&(#$6: $%4, @( 8"%"!G 8"(;!: #('&%8%""6: 5>%"6:… 1&(),$#, "* @%&'!>"6% 8*4%.7!% 1(4! (E4%/$&("6, 45>!#$*, 8*$%&!,, @&($!4 ! $.@.), >$( ,#"( 5/*+6'*%$ "* $(, >$(… – *$(86 – 1%4!86» (259, #. 458). R.9. O8(', ($8%$!' ' #',+! # E$!8, >$( «*$(8 %#$< #4(?"*, #!#$%8* 8"(?%#$'* 1'!?5F!:#, >*#$%.», ' $( ?% '&%8, @(1>%&/"54: «P('&%8%""6% 5>%"!, "% /(4%)4G$ *"*$(8!>%#/(. $%(&!! K*4<$("*: "*@&($!' $(;(, ("! ''(1,$ ' "*5/5 "*5*7':.* C7*:*"-. :%-*$'', )(4%% 8%4/!%, >%8 *$(86» (364, #. 272, 280. M5&#!' 8(.. – C.3.). B(+1"%%, ' 1936 ;(15, A!/#!&5, $5 ?% 86#4< ( #4(?"(8 #$&(%"!! *$(8* ! ' #',+! # E$!8 – ( "('(8, @( #&*'"%"!G # «*$(8(8» *"$!>"6: @&%17%#$'%""!/(', 5&('"% E4%8%"$*&"(#$!, "%1%4!8(#$! 8*$%&!!, D5! 1% Q&(.4< @!#*4: «B( #('&%8%""68 @&%1#$*'4%"!,8 *$(8, )515>! #(#$*'"(. >*#$/! +&%"!, "('%.7%. A!+!/!, $*/ "*+6'*%86% E4%8%"$*&"6% >*#$!26, "*@&!8%&, E4%/$&("6, /($(&6% &*##8*$&!'*G$#, #%;(1", (8(?%$ )6$<, '&%8%""() /*/ @(#4%1"!% "%1%4!86% #(#$*'4,GF!% *$(8(' !, #4%1('*$%4<"(, 8*$%&!!» (43, #. 47). C#% E$( #'!1%$%4<#$'5%$ ( $(8, >$( *$(8!#$!/* "* /*?1(8 E$*@% %% &*+'!$!, +*/4G>*%$ ' #%)% &%*4<"5G '(+8(?"(#$< 1*4<"%.7%;( #('%&7%"#$'('*"!, #',+*""6: # "%G %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: ! A!4(#(A#/!: @&%1#$*'4%"!.. «9$(8!#$!/*, – ($8%>*4 Q(4<28*", – #@(#()"* / +"*>!$%4<"(85 1*4<"%.7%85 &*+'!$!G» (35, #. 125). H ' E$(8 #'(%8 &*+'!$!! *$(8!#$!>%#/*, $%(&!,, @( 8"%"!G 5>%"(;(, «()%F*%$ "*# @&!'%#$! / #('%&7%""( "%(?!1*""68 +*/4G>%"!,8 ( @&!&(1% ! #$&(%"!! *$(8*» ($*8 ?%, #. 174). H 1%.#$'!$%4<"(, &*+'!$!% *$(8!#$!/! ' UU '%/%,
221
(#()%""( A!+!/! E4%8%"$*&"6: >*#$!2, @(4"(#$%""(#$< %;( )(4%% 8%4/!: #(#$*'"6: >*#$%., &*+58%%$#,, #$(4< ?% 8*$%&!*4<"6:, /*/ ! (" #*8. R.9. O8(', "*#$*!'*, "* )%+5#4('"(. 8*$%&!*4<"(#$! E$!: )(4%% 8%4/!: >*#$!2 *$(8*, $( %#$< E4%/$&("(', 5$'%&?1*%$, >$( «@(1$'%&1!4(#< @&%1#$*'4%"!% ( 8*$%&!*4<"(8 *$(8% /*/ @(4(?!$%4<"(8 ,1&%, '(/&5; /($(&(;( @(1()"( #@5$"!/*8 @4*"%$ )6#$&( 1'!?5$#, E4%/$&("6» (364, #. 403). C #',+! # E$!8 O8(' 1%4*%$ '6'(1: «R('6% '(++&%"!, ($/&6'*G$ @5$< / 5#@%7"(85 @(#$&(%"!G $%(&!! 8*$%&!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 496). § 4. ">>2C=J=9 >2C=F=5=CB;: %;Q = ;F2B=4F=<; B(+!$!'!#$#/(% ($'%&?%"!% '#,/(. «8%$*A!+!/!», @&%?1% '#%;( – /*"$('#/(. «'%F! ' #%)%», ($'%&?%"!% "% $(4%&%+ (F5F%"!,, "( ! %% &%*4<"(#$!, )%+($"(#!$%4<"(. / (F5F%"!,8, "%!+)%?"( @&!'%4( *:* ! / ($&!2*"!G ()I%/$!'"(. &%*4<"(#$! *$(8('. C#@(8!"*, &*""!. @%&!(1 #'(!: A!4(#(A#/!: ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: !#/*"!., *: @!#*4: « 6#4! M*"$* "% (#$*'4,4! 8%", ' @(/(%. «C%F< ' #%)%» $*/ @(1*'4,GF% !8@("!&('*4* 8(%. "*!'"(#$!, >$( , "% 8(; 5#@(/(!$#, 1( $%: @(&, @(/* "% 5+"*4, >$( E$( 4!7< @&*+1"(% @&%1@(4(?%"!%. R( '( '&%8, +*",$!. A!+!/(. ' 5"!'%&#!$%$%, )4*;(1*&, *$(8*8 ! 8(4%/54*8 E$($ @&!+"*/ /*/ )51$( )6 (@,$< #$*4 @(45>*$< @(>'5… D%/2!! @( @#!:(A!+!/% 0%:"%&*, ' @&(1(4?%"!% /($(&6: , @&!"5?1%" )64 &*##8*$&!'*$< *$(86 /*/ 157!.., @&!'%4! 8%", / $*/(85 &%+/(85 /("A4!/$5 8%?15 "*!'"68 8!&('(++&%"!%8 # (1"(. #$(&("6, 8%$*A!+!>%#/!8! '+;4,1*8! M*"$*, =%&)*&$* ! *$(8!#$!>%#/(. A!+!/! # 1&5;(., >$( , #/(&( @&!/(">!4 #( '#,/(. 8%$*A!+!/(. ! '(+'&*$!4#, / "*!'"(85 %#$%#$'%""(85 8!&('(++&%"!G» (253, #. 15-16). C E$(8 «%#$%#$'%""(8 8!&('(++&%"!!» *:* 8%#$* *$(8*8, /*/ '!1!8, "% "*74(#<. H ' 1*4<"%.7%8, "* @&($,?%"!! '#%. #'(%. @(#4%15GF%. 1%,$%4<"(#$! *: #(:&*",4 E$( "%;*$!'"(% ($"(7%"!% / «8%$*A!+!/%» *$(8!#$!>%#/(. A!+!/!. R(, /("%>"(, )64( )6 5@&(F%"!%8 ()I,#",$< ($&!2*"!% *:(8 &%*4<"(#$! *$(8(' !#/4G>!$%4<"( %;( *"$!8%$*A!+!>%#/!8! "*#$&(%"!,8!, #',+*""68! # /*"$('#/(. «'%F"(8 @(+"*"!!. K%4( ' $(8, >$( *$(8"*, $%(&!, &*##8*$&!'*4*#< !8 '#%2%4( ' @4*"% &%*4!+*2!! @&!"2!@(' 8%:*"!/! ' A!+!>%#/(8 @(+"*"!!. 9 @&!"2!@6 E$! (" #>!$*4 "%1(#$*$(>"68!, !: &%*4!+*2!, ' @(+"*'*$%4<"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! 1*'*4*, @( %;( 8"%"!G, (1"(#$(&(""%% +"*"!% ( 1%.#$'!$%4<"(8 8!&%. V* @&%1%4*8! 8%:*"!>%#/(;( (@!#*"!, 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! (#$*%$#, %F% 8"(;( /*>%#$'%""( !"(;(, "% 5/4*16'*GF%;(#, ' &*8/! 8%:*"!2!+8*,
222
"%@(",$"(;(, )(4<7% $(;( – @&!"2!@!*4<"( "%()I,#"!8(;( "* (#"('% (1"!: $(4$( 86 @(#$!;4! @&(2%##6 8%:*"!/! 92!7"*. H8%%8 4! 86 @&*'( ! '(+8(?"(#$< ;1-$%"(-8 "* E$(8 (#"('*"!! !+ 8!&* 1&5;!% @&(2%##6, /($(&6: 86 "% @("!8*%8? B&!1%&?!'*,#< $*/(;( @&!"2!@*, )64( )6 @&(F% '#%;( ($&!2*$< #5F%#$'('*"!% '#%;( 8!&*… 0!+!/*, &*+&*)*$6'*%8*, $*/!8 ()&*+(8, 1*%$ "*8 #:%85, ' /($(&(. %1'* 4! 8(?"( 5+"*$< 1%.#$'!$%4<"6. 8!&». C #',+! # E$!8 *: ! @&!:(1!$ / '6'(15, >$( «/*/ )6 "! )64( 2!"(-"! $( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, >$( 4G1! #$&%8!4!#< '#% A!+!>%#/!% @&(2%##6 «#'%#$! / 1'!?%"!,8 *$(8('», E$($ !1%*4 '#% ?% #4%15%$ "*+'*$< :!8%&(.» (255, #. 135). H+ E$!: '6#/*+6'*"!. *:* #4%15%$, >$( #*8 (" "% $(4"(. 6%$-'". 8!&* 5*=1-9'-*78".= 8!&, "(, "*@&($!', #$&%8!4#, #(:&*"!$< %;(, )(4<7% $(;( – #$&%8!4#, / 5#$*"('4%"!G $*/(. /*&$!"6 8!&*, ' /($(&(. 8(?"( )64( )6 «5+"*$< 1%.#$'!$%4<"6. 8!&»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«C !+'%#$"6: @&%1%4*:, – @!#*4 (", – E$* $%(&!, 8(?%$ )6$< (>%"< @4(1($'(&"(.» (249, #. 9). B(E$(85 *: #>!$*4 %% &*+&*)($/5 '@(4"% 2%4%#(()&*+"(. – ' @&%1%4*: (@&%1%4%""(;(, (;&*"!>%""(;( 5>*#$/* %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. R( @( 8%&% #('%&7%"#$'('*"!, @(#4%1"%;( E$* 2%4%#(()&*+"(#$< *$(8!+8* '#% ' )(4<7%. 8%&% #$*"('!$#, 1(#$(,"!%8 @&(74(;(. «B5#$< *$(8 (#$*%$#, #&%1#$'(8 14, !+()&*?%"!, ,'4%"!., @(1()"( A5"/2!,8 8*$%8*$!/!. R( @(#$%@%""(, @( 8%&% &(#$* !"$%44%/$5*4<"(. 1!#2!@4!"6, %#$%#$'(+"*"!% (#$*'4,%$ E$! 8(+*!>"6% !;&57/! ! #$*&*%$#, !+5>!$< ;&*"!26 ! A(&86 $(;( &5#4*, @( /($(&(85 "%#%$#, ?!'(. @($(/ ,'4%"!.»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– $(;(, >$( *$(8!+8 "% !#>%&@6'*%$#, *$(8*8!, !: #5;5)( 8%:*"!>%#/!8! :*&*/$%&!#$!/*8!, >$( '(+8(?%" *$(8!+8 ! "* !"(., "%8%:*"!>%#/(. (#"('%, *$(8!+8 )(4%% #4(?"(;( @(&,1/*, '
223
>*#$"(#$!, "* 5&('"% E4%/$&("('. K4, "%;( E$($ 5&('%"<, "*()(&($, !#/4G>*4 *$(8!+8 ! (1"('&%8%""( @(-"('(85 #$*'!4 ()F!. '(@&(# ( 8*$%&!! ! A(&8*: %% #5F%#$'('*"!,. «C "*#$(,F%% '&%8,, – @!#*4 *: ' 1906 ;(15, – &5/('(1,F*, &(4< @%&%:(1!$, @(-'!1!8(85, / C7*6-$!5'"%:'6*, >$( 4G1! )(4%% 1*4<"(+(&/!% 1*'"( 5?% @&%1'!1%4!. R( '&,1 4! 1%4( "* E$(8 (#$*"('!$#,. M(;1* @(4"(% &*+4(?%"!% *$(8"(. $%(&!!, / /($(&(85 1(4?"( @&!'%#$! @&%1#$*'4%"!% E4%/$&("*, )51%$ 1%4(8 +*'%&7!'7!8#,, #"('* #$*"5$ "* (>%&%1< @&()4%86 8*$%&!!, '&%8%"! ! @&(#$&*"#$'*» ($*8 ?%, #. 321). C &%7%"!! "*+'*""6: @&()4%8 5>*#$!% *$(8"(. $%(&!! *:(8 !#/4G>*4(#<, @(#/(4"(;( +"*"!, %% @(+"*'*$%4<"6. @($%"2!*4 @(4"(#$%&@6'*4, ! ("* "%8!"5%8( 1(4?"* )64* @&!.$! / #'(%85 /("25, / !#>%+"('%"!G !+ %#$%#$'(+"*"!,. C 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!, /*/ !+'%#$"(, '#% @(45>!4(#< !"*>%: «@&%1#$*'4%"!% E4%/$&("*» "% $(4"( $*/ ?%, /*/ ! 1&5;!% A!+!>%#/!% @&%1#$*'4%"!,, @(,'!'7!%#, @(+1"%%, ' :(1% @(#4%15GF%;( &*+'!$!, %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' /'*"$('(. $%(&!!, ' A!+!/% «E4%8%"$*&"6:»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«?!'(8 @($(/%». 9$(8"*, $%(&!,, @&(!+'(4<"( 1&(), E$($ @($(/, :.17*""! &*#>4%",, 5*=1-9'-*78"!* ' "%8 "* "%'(#@&!"!8*%86%, 2$*52!7!>'-*78"! #5F%#$'5GF!% >*#$!26, $%8 #*868 4!7*%$ %;( ?!+"%""(#$!, /&*#(>"(#$!, @(4"($6 #5F%#$'('*"!,; ("* /*/ )6 '6$*4/!'*%$ !+5>*%86% ,'4%"!, !+ >5'#$'%""( 1*""(. &%*4<"(#$! ' ()4*#$< *)#$&*/$"(. #!8'(4!/!, ()4*#$<, "%1(#$5@"5G (F5F%"!,8, * @($(85 ! 4!7%""5G 1%.#$'!$%4<"(. &%*4<"(#$! –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
224
($"(7%"!G / >%4('%/5 8!& (A!+!>%#/(%), # @(+"*"!%8, "*@&*'4%""68 "* #*8(;( >%4('%/* /*/ #5)I%/$* @(+"*"!,, "* %;( '"5$&%""!. 8!& (@#!:!>%#/(%). C /("2% XIX – "*>*4% UU ''. $*/(% @(4(?%"!% ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!! &*##8*$&!'*4(#< *:(8 /*/ 5?% !+?!'7%% #%),. J(4"6: +"*"!. ( @&!&(1% ! >%4('%/% '!1%4 (" '(+8(?"(#$< 1*4<"%.7%;( @&(;&%##* %#$%#$'(+"*"!,. «3$"(7%"!% A!+!(4(;!>%#/(. @#!:(4(;!! / A!+!/% ' #*8(8 7!&(/(8 #86#4% #:(?% # ($"(7%"!%8 :!8!! / A!+!/% ' $%#"(8 #86#4%. 3$"(7%"!, '+*!8(@(8(F! 8%?15 %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8 ! @#!:(4(;!%. )515$ ;(&*+1( $%#"%%, >%8 $% ?% ($"(7%"!, 8%?15 A!+!/(. ! :!8!%., ! @4(16 E$(. '+*!8(@(8(F! (#$*',$ 1*4%/( @(+*1! #%), ()I,#"%"!, #('&%8%""(. 8%:*"!>%#/(. A!+!/!» ($*8 ?%, #. 170). B(#/(4%#/(. A!+!/!» #(#$*'4,G$ @&%1#$*'4%"!, ( 8*$%&!! ! %% E4%8%"$*&"6: #(#$(,"!,: – *$(8*:, $(, /*/ #>!$*4 *:, 8%#$* !8 ' )515F%8 #!"$%+!&('*""(8 A!+!/(@#!:(4(;!>%#/(8 +"*"!!, @( '#%. '!1!8(#$!, "% (#$*%$#,. «M*/('6 )515$, – @!#*4 (" ' 1882 ;(15, – $% @(",$!,, ' /($(&6: )51%$ ()()F%" '%#< 8!&, /(;1* 2%@< A!+!>%#/!: ! @#!:(4(;!>%#/!: A*/$(', &*+1%4%""*, ' "*#$(,F%% '&%8, "* E$! 1'% @(4('!"6, (/*?%$#, +*8/"5$(.. P(:&*"!$ 4! %F% $(;1* /*/(%-4!)( "*5>"(% +"*>%"!% $( @(",$!%, /($(&(% 86 "*+6'*%8 $%@%&< 8*$%&!%., !4! ("( #(:&*"!$#, 4!7< ' ?!$%.#/(8 ()!:(1%, – 86 "% +"*%8. R( @($(8/*8 "*7!8, )%+ #(8"%"!,, )51%$ /(;1*-"!)51< "%@(",$"( #4%15GF%%: /*/ 86 8(;4! ' "*7%8 A!+!>%#/(8 8!&% *$(8(' @($%&,$< '1&5; 2'%$* ! $("6, /($(&6% '%1< '#%;( "*8 )4!?%. M*/ 86 8(;4! !+584,$<#, $(85, >$( $(, >$( '( '"%7"%8 8!&% 758!$ ! #$5>!$, '( '"5$&%""%8 "*7%8 8!&%, ' "*7%. ;(4('%, #'%$!$ ! @(%$? M*/!8 ()&*+(8 86 8(;4! +*1*$<#, '(@&(#(8, /*/ 8(?%$ !?;?%-8 8*$%&!,, $( %#$< /*/ 8(?%$ (F5F*$< 86#4%""6. #!8'(4 14, ;&5@@6 (F5F%"!.?» ($*8 ?%). V1%#< '#% #8%7*4(#< 5 *:*: ! @(",$!% 8*$%&!!, 4!7%""(%, (1"*/(, #'(%;( &%*4<"(;( @&(()&*+* – #*8(. 8*$%&!! /*/ ()I%/$!'"(. &%*4<"(#$!, ! &%*4<"6., "( "%8*$%&!*4<"6. 9"*3"'= 8!&, ! "%&%*4<"6%, "( 8*$%&!*4<"6% *$(86, ! &%*4<"6., "( "% #',+*""6. "! # 8*$%&!%., "! # *$(8*8! '"5$&%""!. 8!&, ! "%&%*4<"*,, "( #',+*""*, # &%*4<"(#$,8! '"5$&%""%;( 8!&* («86#4%""6. #!8'(4 14, ;&5@@6 (F5F%"!.») 8*$%&!,. R( ' E$(8 '"%7"% #45>*."(8 "*)(&% ;"(#%(4(;%8 @&! )4!?*.7%8 &*##8($&%"!! ()"*&5?!'*%$#, #'(, "%#45>*."(#$<, %#4! '+;4,"5$< "* '#% E$( @(1 5;4(8 +&%"!, #@%2!A!>%#/(;( '*&!*"$* «"*!'"(;( &%*4!+8*», /($(&6. *: #>!$*4 8!&('(++&%">%#/(. (#"('"(. #'(%. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(. $%(&!! @(+"*"!,. P (1"(. #$(&("6, &%*4<"68, ' %;( @&%1#$*'4%"!!, ,'4,%$#, '#% $(, >$( @( ($"(7%"!G / /*?1(85 ($1%4<"(85 >%4('%/5 "*:(1!$#, 9"* "%;(, +* ;&*"!2*8! %;( $%4* (($#G1* ! @&!+"*"!% 9"*3"*#! 8!&*), "(, # 1&5;(. #$(&("6, E$( '"%7"%% &%*4<"( 4!7< ' $(. 8%&%, ' /*/(. ("( $&*"#A(&8!&('*"( >%&%+ (F5F%"!, >%4('%/* ' %;( '"5$&%""!. 8!&. J(4*% 8(?"( ;('(&!$< ( @&!#@(#()4%"!!
225
86#4%. / A*/$*8 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!, ( 1(#$!?%"!! !2.-%, ( @(45>%"!! $(>"(;(, &%6-%:' ()%#@%>%""(;( +"*"!,. 9 +* @&%1%4*8! %1!"%"!, '"%7"%;( ! '"5$&%""%;( +"*"!% 8(?%$ )6$< ()&*F%"( "% "* &%*4<"(% (1%.#$'!$%4<"(%), *, ' 45>7%8 #45>*%, 4!7< "* 5!2;1-':!*, @&%1@(4(?!$%4<"( #5F%#$'5GF%%. J*/('68! ! ,'4,G$#,, @( 8"%"!G *:*, ;!@($%$!>%#/!% *$(86 ! 8(4%/546, * $*/?% 8*$%&!, /*/ ()I%1!",GF%% !: "*>*4(. 3"! @&%1#$*'4,G$ #()(. #5;5)( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6% #&%1#$'* (@!#*"!, $(4%#/(;( – ' ($'4%>%"!! ($ '"5$&%""%;( ' >%4('%/%, ($ %;( @#!:!>%#/(;(, #&%1#$'*, #('%&7%""( "%@&!8%"!86% / ()I,#"%"!G E$(;( '"5$&%""%;( – @(#/(4*"'4 5>%"6:, #(#$(!$ A!+!>%#/!. 8!&. H, /&(8% $(;(, *$(86 ! 8(4%/546, "% ()4*1*, ' E$(8 A!+!>%#/(8 8!&% &','0*16!= &%*4<"(#$!, #4%1('*$%4<"(, A*/$*8! 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!, $%8 #*868 "% ,'4,G$#, ! A*/$*8! +"*"!,, "% 1*"6 ' (@6$%, "% (F5F*G$#,, – /(&(>%, ' @#!:!>%#/(8 ("! 4!7%"6 0;91-9*""!= &%*4<"(#$!. H+ '#%;( E$(;( #4%15%$, >$( *$(8"*, $%(&!,, @( 8"%"!G *:*, "% #',+*"* # >%8-$( &%*4<"68, @(#/(4$( ()I%1!",%$ A!+!>%#/(% ! @#!:!>%#/(%, * $(4$( !-7'0%*A!+!>%#/(% ($ @#!:!>%#/(;(. V* "%., +* E$(. $%(&!%., "%$ ! "% 8(?%$ )6$< /*/(.-$( $&*"#2%"1%"$"(. &%*4<"(#$! – *$(8(', $( %#$< &%*4<"(#$!, )%+($"(#!$%4<"(. / >5'#$'%""68 '(#@&!,$!,8 >%4('%/*, ($#5$#$'5GF%. ' ,'4%"!!. C 15:% /("'%"2!("*4!+8* *: !#$(4/('6'*4 *$(8"5G $%(&!G /*/ !#/5##$'%""(% #(+1*"!%, @&(!+'(4<"( 5#$*"('4%""(% 5>%"68! 14, E/("(8!>%#/(;( '6&*?%"!, (1"(;( !+ '(+8(?"68 @5$%. ()I,#"%"!, A!+!>%#/(. &%*4<"(#$!. H @($(85 «%#$%#$'(+"*"!G "% @(1()*%$ '!1%$< ' #(+1*""6: !8 #*8!8 !+8%">!'6: E/("(8!>%#/!: #&%1#$'*:, ' 8(4%/54*: ! *$(8*:, $*%78"!1-' @(+*1! ,'4%"!.» ($*8 ?%, #. 166). 9$(8"(–8(4%/54,&"(% 5>%"!% @&%1#$*%$ ' E$(8 #45>*% "% /*/ ($&*?%"!%, %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(% ()I,#"%"!% ()I%/$!'"(–&%*4<"6: @&(,'4%"!. 8*$%&!! – *$(8(' ! 8(4%/54, * /*/ #(+1*""(% #*8!8! 5>%"68! '&%8%""(% #&%1#$'( (@!#*"!, ' *)#$&*/$"(–#!8'(4!>%#/(. A(&8% ($1%4<"6: #$(&(" $(. &%*4<"(#$!, /($(&*, ,'4,%$#, @(+"*GF%85 #5)I%/$5 ' %;( (F5F%"!,:. «W#4! 5? ()6/"('%""*, «8*$%&!,», – @!#*4 *:, –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
226
8%"%% 86 8(?%8 #(;4*#!$<#, # >51('!F"(. !1%%. '(#@(4<+('*$<#, *$(8*8! 14, ()I,#"%"!, @#!:!>%#/!: @&(2%##('. H)( >$( ?% $*/(% *$(86, %#4! "% (1"! 4!7< #!8'(46 $%: #'(%()&*+"6: /(8@4%/#(' >5'#$'%""6: E4%8%"$(', /($(&6% 86 "*:(1!8 ' )(4%% $%#"6: ()4*#$,: A!+!/! ! :!8!!» (246, #. 255). J(, >$( ' E$!: «)(4%% $%#"6: ()4*#$,: A!+!/! ! :!8!!» / "*>*45 UU '%/* )64( @(45>%"( 1(#$*$(>"( 8"(;( 8*$%&!*4* (@&!>%8 ($"G1< "% «#!8'(4!>%#/(;(», * #*8(;( >$( "! "* %#$< A*/$!>%#/(;(), @(1$'%&?1*GF%;( ()I%/$!'"5G &%*4<"(#$< *$(8(' ! 8(4%/54, )%+($"(#!$%4<"5G / «>5'#$'%""68 E4%8%"$*8», – E$( *:* "% #85F*4(. Q(4<7% $(;(, ' #'(%8 *"$!*$(8"(8 &'%"!! (" '(4<"( !4! "%'(4<"( !+8%",4 #*8(85 #%)%, #'(!8 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/!8 @&!"2!@*8, ! ' >*#$"(#$!, @&!"2!@5 A*/$5*4<"(#$! +"*"!,, !+8%",4 $%8, >$(, @6$*,#< 1(/*+*$%4<"( /&!$!/('*$< *$(8"(% 5>%"!%, (" @(1>*# $'(&!4 @&,8(% "*#!4!% "*1 A*/$*8! ' 5;(15 #'(%. @(+!$!'!#$#/(. A!4(#(A#/(. 5#$*"('/%. 9. L."7$%.", @(1>%&/!'*, E$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, @!#*4, >$( @&%15)%?1%"!% *:*, * $*/?% 3#$'*4<1* @&($!' *$(8"(. $%(&!! «8(?"( "%#(8"%""( ($"%#$! +* #>%$ !: @(+!$!'!#$#/(. A!4(#(A#/(. 5#$*"('/!. L$( – !"$%&%#"6. @&!8%& $(;(, /*/ A!4(#(A#/!% @&%15)%?1%"!, 8%7*G$ @&*'!4<"(. !"$%&@&%$*2!! A*/$(' 1*?% 5>%"68 #( #8%468 8674%"!%8 ! # $("/(. !"$5!2!%.»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«/&!$!/(. /&!$!/!», *: #$&%8!4#, /*/-$( #8,;>!$< #'(! &*+"(;4*#!, # 5>%"68!, "*.$! 1(@(4"!$%4<"6% *&;58%"$6, 5$(>"!$< $% !4! !"6% A(&854!&('/!, "% ($/*+6'*,#<, (1"*/(, ($ ;4*'"(;(, @&!"2!@!*4<"(;(. J*/, ' @(4%8!/% # . B4*"/(8 (" ($8%>*4, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( ($#$*!'*%8(;( !8 '(++&%"!, "* @&(2%## @(+"*"!, «'@(4"% 1(#$*$(>"(, >$()6 )6$< ' :'$".D ' 5%>* 5$;>*16'D ($"(7%"!,: / ()F%@&!+"*""(. ' "*#$(,F%% '&%8, A!+!/%. P5F%#$'%""(% &*+4!>!%, /($(&(% 1( #!: @(& 51*4(#< "*.$!, +*/4G>*%$#, ' 9*$* 9 $*%78"!1-8 %-!:!9» (252, #. 136). 3$#G1* #4%15%$, >$( *:, @&!+"*' /&!$!/5%85G !8 *$(8!#$!/5 1(#$(,"!%8 ()F%@&!+"*""(. A!+!/!, ' $( ?% '&%8, :*&*/$%& #'(!: &*+"(;4*#!. #( #$(&(""!/*8! *$(8"(. $%(&!!, #5F%#$'%""(% ($4!>!% #'(%. @(+!2!! ' ($"(7%"!! / &%*4<"(#$! *$(8(' @(@6$*4#, @%&%'%#$! ' @4(#/(#$< $*/(;( >!#$( #5)I%/$!'"(;( A*/$(&*, /*/ 9*$%. C &%*4<"(#$< *$(8(' ' A!+!/%, #>!$*4 (", /*/ ! ' &%*4<"(#$< "%@(+"*'*%8(. /*"$('#/(. «'%F! ' #%)%» ' «8%$*A!+!/%», 8(?"( '%&!$<, * 8(?"( ! "% '%&!$< – "% E$(
227
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«!44G+!.» ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!!, "* "*9*$'* ' ($"(7%"!! / &%*4<"(#$! *$(8(' ! "*'%4! *:* %;( $%(&%$!/(–@(+"*'*$%4<"6% !+6#/*"!,, (#5F%#$'4,'7!%#, @(1 5;4(8 +&%"!, %;( (#"('"(. @(+!$!'!#$#/(. A!4(#(A#/(. 5#$*"('/!. R( ! +1%#< @(+!2!, *:* (/*+*4*#< "%@&(>"(., 5,+'!8(. 14, *&;58%"$!&('*""(., A*/$*8! @(1/&%@4,%8(. /&!$!/! #( #$(&("6 5>%"6:, #$(&(""!/(' *$(8"(;( 5>%"!,. H *:, 5>!$6'*, E$5 /&!$!/5, @6$*,#< ' #',+! # "%G /*/-$( #8,;>!$< #'(. "%;*$!'!+8 @( ($"(7%"!G / *$(8"(. $%(&!!, @&!+"*4, :($, ! # (;('(&/*8!, %% @&!>*#$"(#$< / (@&%1%4%""(. ;&5@@% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: &%6-!9. «Q%+ #(8"%"!, ! ' *$(8!#$!>%#/(8 5>%"!!, – @!#*4 (", – 8(?"(, ($)&(#!' "%"5?"6%, '$(&(#$%@%""6% @&%1#$*'4%"!,, 5/*+*$< "*!)(4%% #5F%#$'%""5G >*#$<, /($(&*, @&%1#$*'4,%$ 4!7< '6&*?%""6. @(",$!,8! A*/$» (249, #. 85). M #5F%#$'%""(. >*#$! *$(8!#$!>%#/(;( 5>%"!, *: ($"(#!4 5/*+*"!% "* (@&%1%4%""6% '%#('6% ($"(7%"!, ! +*/(" /&*$"6: ($"(7%"!., * $*/?% (@!#*"!% @&(#$6: ()I%8"6: ($"(7%"!. #(%1!"%"!.. R( ! E$*, ' A*/$*: '6&*?%""*, «#5F%#$'%""*, >*#$<» *$(8"(. $%(&!! (@,$< ?% "! ' /*/(. 8%&% "% 5)%?1*4* *:* ' ()I%/$!'"(. &%*4<"(#$! *$(8(', ' !: )%+($"(#!$%4<"(8 / (F5F%"!,8 >%4('%/* #5F%#$'('*"!!. 3", ' >*#$"(#$!, @!#*4: «N$( /*#*%$#, «&%*4<"(#$!» *$(8(', $( , "! 8*4( "% #(8"%'*G#< ' $(8, >$( %#4! *$(8"*, $%(&!, /(4!>%#$'%""( @&!"(&('4%"* / >5'#$'%""( 1*""(. &%*4<"(#$!, $( ! 1%4*%86% !+ "%% '6'(16 1(4?"6 #(#$(,$< ' $(8 !4! 1&5;(8 ($"(7%"!! / &%6-%:, #@&*7!'*%$#, $(4%$'%&$! 14!"6 #'%$('(. '(4"6 @( S";5–0&%"%4G. J*/ ! &%+54<$*$6 *$(8"(. $%(&!! 8(;5$ %F% @(1'%&;"5$<#, &*+"(()&*+"68 ! 2!7*,".: !#$(4/('*"!,8, 1*?%
228
%#4! ! "% #@%7!$< # @&('(+;4*7%"!%8 %% &%*4<"(#$"(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, ' (1"(8 !+ %% *#@%/$('. B( 8"%"!G 9. L."7$%."*, (" «+*7%4 "*#$(4$( ' «(F5F%"!,:» '!1%4 "% $(4!% 8%?15 @#!:(4(;!%. ! A!+!/(.. W#4! )6 (" )64 '@(4"% @(#4%1('*$%4<"68, $( %85 @&!74(#< )6 ($/*+*$<#, "% $(4%#/(. &%*4<"(#$!»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«&*)($*$<» "* E$(8 "('(8 5&('"% !"$%44%/$5*4<"(. /54<$5&6 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. M("%>"(, #>!$*4 *:, *$(8"(85 5>%"!G "%4<+, ($/*+*$< «' E'&!#$!>%#/(8 ! 1!1*/$!>%#/(8 +"*>%"!!. W;( "*;4,1"(#$< +*#$*'4,%$ "*75 A*"$*+!G ! "*7 !"$%44%/$ A5"/2!("!&('*$< #*868 @&(#$68, E4%8%"$*&"68 ()&*+(8, /*/ )6 !"#$!"/$!'"(. V"*8%"*$%4%" $($ A*/$, >$( '(+&(1!4 *$(8!#$!/5 K*4<$(", >%4('%/, )6'7!. @( #'(%. #@%2!*4<"(#$! 7/(4<"68 5>!$%4%8. R( *$(8!#$!/*, #( #'(!8! 1%$#/!–"*!'"68! @&%1#$*'4%"!,8!, #$*'7!8! 5?% "%"5?"68!, "% #(($'%$#$'5%$ $(85 A!4(#(A#/(85 15:5, /($(&6. "*>!"*%$ @&("!/*$< ' A!+!/5 ' "*#$(,F%% '&%8,» (249, #. 85). §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–XVIII ''., @&%!85F%#$'%""( ' /4*##!>%#/(. 8%:*"!/% =*4!4%,–R%"!%8 )64 (:'*>%" #&*'"!$%4<"( 5+/!.
229
#@%/$& 1!"*8!>%#/!: #(#$(,"!. ()I%/$(' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. B&%()4*1*4( ?% !+5>%"!% #$*$!>%#/!: #(#$(,"!., (#()%""( ' "*5/*:, "*:(1,F!:#, ' #$*1!! #$*"('4%"!,. C XIX '%/% !+5>%"!% 1!"*8!>%#/!: #(#$(,"!. #$*4( @&%()4*1*GF!8 ' )(4<7!"#$'% (#"('"6: &*+1%4(' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. C A!+!/% E$(, "*@&!8%&, $%&8(1!"*8!/*, E4%/$&(1!"*8!/*, ;!1&(1!"*8!/* ! @&(>%%. R%>$( *"*4(;!>"(% "*)4G1*4(#< ! ' 1&5;!: %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/*:. C XIX '%/% %#$%#$'(+"*"!%, ;('(&, #4('*8! L";%4<#*, #$*4( «"*5/(. ( @&(2%##*:», "*5/(., "*@&*'4%""(., ;4*'"68 ()&*+(8, "* !+5>%"!% 1'!?%"!, 8*$%&!! ' %;( &*+4!>"6: @&(,'4%"!,:. C @!#<8% *&/#5 ($ 30 8*, 1873 ;(1* L";%4<# @(1>%&/!'*4: «B&%18%$ %#$%#$'(+"*"!, – 1'!?5F*,#, 8*$%&!,, $%4*. J%4* "%($1%4!86 ($ 1'!?%"!,: !: A(&86 ! '!16 8(?"( @(+"*'*$< ' 1'!?%"!!, ( $%4*: '"% 1'!?%"!,, '"% '#,/(;( ($"(7%"!, / 1&5;!8 $%4*8, "!>%;( "%4<+, #/*+*$<. D!7< ' 1'!?%"!! $%4( ()"*&5?!'*%$, >$( ("( %#$<. B(E$(85 %#$%#$'(+"*"!% @(+"*%$ $%4*, $(4"6: A(&8 1'!?%"!, ! %#$< @(+"*"!% $%4. J*/!8 ()&*+(8, !+5>%"!% E$!: &*+4!>"6: A(&8 1'!?%"!, ,'4,%$#, ;4*'"68 @&%18%$(8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!,» (411, #. 67-68). R%@(#&%1#$'%""(% &*+'%&$6'*"!% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, ' XIX '%/%, ()&*F%""(#$< %;( "* 1'!?5F!%#, ()I%/$6 ()5#4('4!'*4! (>%'!1"(#$< #*8(;( 1'!?%"!, ' %;( &*+4!>"6: @&(,'4%"!,:, 1(#$5@"6: ' 8*##% #'(%. '(#@&!,$!,8 (&;*"(' >5'#$'. «K'!?%"!,, – @!#*4 D. Q(4<28*", – E$( $% ,'4%"!,, /($(&6% 86 >*F% '#%;( ! '#%;( "%@(#&%1#$'%""%% "*)4G1*%8» (35, #. 159). H. . P%>%"(', @(1>%&/!'*, E$( ?% ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, @!#*4: «H+ '#%: 8!&('6: ,'4%"!. 1'!?%"!% @&%1#$*'4,%$#, "*8 "*!)(4%% @&(#$68 ! 51()(@(",$"68» (335, #. 343). 9 E$( ' #'(G (>%&%1< 1*'*4( %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8 1(#$*$(>"( (#"('*"!. 14, ()F!: A!4(#(A#/!: '6'(1(' ( #5F"(#$! 1'!?%"!,, ! ' >*#$"(#$!, 14, '6'(1* ( $(8, >$(, /*/ @!#*4 K.H. %"1%4%%', «1'!?%"!% #$*4( @(",$!%8, "%&*+&6'"( #',+*""68 # @(",$!%8 8*$%&!!» (259, #. 458). C @("!8*"!! 1'!?%"!,, %;( #(($"(7%"!, # 8*$%&!%. #( '#%. (>%'!1"(#$"(#$< '(++&%"!. 5>%"6:– %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/*. K'!?%"!% &*##8*$&!'*4(#< !8! ' "%&*+1%4<"(#$!, ' "%&*+&6'"(. 19(,' # 8*$%&!%., /*/ %% "%($I%84%8*, >%&$*, (),+*$%4<"6. 12!1!< <.-'(. «K'!?%"!%, – @!#*4 D. QG:"%&, – #(#$*'4,%$ "%():(1!86. ! "%($I%84%86. *$&!)5$ '#%;(, /*/ (&;*"!>%#/(;(, $*/ ! "%(&;*"!>%#/(;( )6$!,»» (52, #. 43). « *$%&!, – $(, >$( 1'!?%$#,», $*/ /(&($/( ! $(>"( '6&*+!4 Q(4<28*" E$($ '+;4,1 5>%"6: "* 8*$%&!G ! 1'!?%"!% (35, #. 154). P$(4< ?% (@&%1%4%""( '6#/*+*4#, "* E$($ #>%$ ! */#'%44: «P5F"(#$< 8*$%&!! – )6$< "(#!$%4<"!2%. /(4!>%#$'* 1'!?%"!, ! E"%&;!!» (231, #. 152). K.H. %"1%4%%' $*/?% ($8%>*4, >$( 8*$%&!! «)%+ 1'!?%"!,, :($, )6 #/&6$(;(, 86 "% +"*%8» (260, #. 580). J*/(. ?% '6'(1 #1%4*4 ! M.9. J!8!&,+%': « 6 "% +"*%8 8*$%&!! )%+ 1'!?%"!,» (354, #. 73).
230
C E$(8 8!&('(++&%">%#/(8, ("$(4(;!>%#/(8 @&%1#$*'4%"!! 5>%"6: ( "%&*+1%4<"(#$! 8*$%&!! ! 1'!?%"!,, ( !: "%&*+&6'"(. #',+! $*/?% @&(,'!4*#< ()F"(#$< %#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* # A!4(#(A#/!8 8*$%&!*4!+8(8. C @("!8*"!! #(($"(7%"!, 8*$%&!! ! 1'!?%"!, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! ' XIX '%/% @&!74! / $%8 ?% (#"('(@(4(?%"!,8, >$( ! A!4(#(A6-8*$%&!*4!#$6 ' XVIII '%/%. J*/, B.9. =(4<)*: @(1>%&/!'*4, >$( «1'!?%"!% – E$( #@(#() #5F%#$'('*"!,, "%():(1!868 ()&*+(8 '6$%/*GF!. !+ #5F"(#$! 8*$%&!!; >$( 8*$%&!, 1'!?%$#, )4*;(1*&, #()#$'%""(. E"%&;!!, >$( ("* (),+*"* #'(!8 1'!?%"!%8 '"5$&%""% @&!#5F!8 %. #!4*8» ! @($(85 «"% "5?1*%$#, "! ' /*/(8 '"%7"%8 $(4>/%, >$()6 @&!.$! ' 1'!?%"!%» (126, #. 75, 76). B( 8"%"!G M. 9. =%4<'%2!,, «8*$%&!, "% 8(?%$ #5F%#$'('*$< )%+ 1'!?%"!,»; !+ E$(;( «#4%15%$, >$( 1'!?%"!% @&!#5F% 8*$%&!!. P4%1('*$%4<"(, "%$ "!/*/(. "%():(1!8(#$! ' 1%.#$'5GF%. #!4%, /($(&*, #(()F!4* )6 %. 1'!?%"!%» (99, #. 126). K. J(4*"1 $*/?% @!#*4 ( «1'!?%"!! /*/ "%($I%84%8(8 #'(.#$'% 8*$%&!!» (7, #. 183), ( $(8, >$( «8*$%&!, "% 8(?%$ )6$< 86#4!8* )%+ 1'!?%"!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 157). H ' A!4(#(A!! XIX '%/*, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' 8*&/#!#$#/(. A!4(#(A!! @(45>!4* #(($'%$#$'5GF%% '6&*?%"!% E$* ()F*, 14, '#%;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* !1%, "%&*+&6'"(#$! 8*$%&!! ! 1'!?%"!,. 0. L";%4<#, /*#*,#< E$(;( '(@&(#*, @!#*4: «R!;1% ! "!/(;1* "% )6'*4( ! "% 8(?%$ )6$< 8*$%&!! )%+ 1'!?%"!,… *$%&!, )%+ 1'!?%"!, $*/ ?% "%86#4!8*, /*/ ! 1'!?%"!% )%+ 8*$%&!!» (405, #. 59). N$( /*#*%$#, $(;(, /*/ @("!8*4! 5>%"6% "%@(#&%1#$'%""(% '(@4(F%"!% 1'!?%"!, 8*$%&!!, $( +1%#< #"('* @&!:(1!$#, ()&*F*$<#, / !: *$(8!#$!>%#/!8 '(++&%"!,8. B(#/(4%"6:, #(#$(!$ !+ *$(8(', $( 1'!?%"!% 8*$%&!! – E$( @&%?1% '#%;( 1'!?%"!% #(#$*'4,GF!: %% *$(8(', 1'!?%"!%, 5?% "%1(#$5@"(% "%@(#&%1#$'%""(85 '(#@&!,$!G (&;*"(' >5'#$', "( 86#4!8(% @( *"*4(;!! # 1'!?%"!%8 8*/&($%4. J*/, (#"('6'*,#< "* ,'4%"!,: 1!AA5+!! ;*+(' ! ?!1/(#$%., */#'%44 ($8%$!4: «C(+8(?"( 1'!?%"!% 8*4%.7!: >*#$%. $%4*, "*8! "% +*8%>*%8(%» (230, #. 128). R( $*/ !4! !"*>%, *$(8!#$!>%#/!% '(++&%"!, 5>%"6: "* 8*$%&!G )64! "%&*+&6'"( #',+*"6 # @("!8*"!%8 %% 1'!?%"!,. Q(4<28*" $*/ @!#*4 () E$(8: «J%#"( / *$(8!#$!/% @&!86/*%$ ;!@($%+* ( $(8, >$( E4%8%"$6 $%4%#"(;( 8!&* "% (#$*G$#, ' @(/(%, "*:(1,#< "%@(1'!?"( 1&5; (/(4( 1&5;* ! ()&*+5, 8*$%&!G, /*/ /!&@!>! – #$%"5, "( >$( ("! "*:(1,$#, ' "%@&%&6'"(8 1'!?%"!!» (35, #. 10). Q(4<7% $(;(, !+5>%"!% &*+"(()&*+"6: 1'!?%"!. ! !: @&(,'4%"!. 1*%$ 1(@(4"!$%4<"6% *&;58%"$6 ' @(4<+5 !1%! *$(8"(;( #$&(%"!, '%F%#$'*. W#4!, #>!$*4, "*@&!8%&, K.H. %"1%4%%', «'( '#%: &*+4!>"6: #(#$(,"!,: 8%:*"!>%#/(;(, A!+!>%#/(;( ! :!8!>%#/(;( !+8%"%"!,, @%&%8%F%"!, !4! 1'!?%"!, (/*+*4(#< '(+8(?"68 54('!$< #(:&*"%"!% (1"(. ! $(. ?% #5F"(#$! '%F%#$'* @&(#$6: $%4 !4! :!8!>%#/!: E4%8%"$(', $( !: @(4%+"( ! 8(?"( @&!+"*$< 1%.#$'!$%4<"68! E4%8%"$*8!, ()&*+5GF!8! #*8(% '%F%#$'(» (260, #. 565).
231
P4%15%$, (1"*/(, ($8%$!$<, >$( 1'!?%"!% 8*$%&!!, ' @("!8*"!! 5>%"6:, ($"G1< "% #'(1!$#, / 1'!?%"!G *$(8('. J*/(. '+;4,1 "* 1'!?%"!% )64 )6 #4!7/(8 5@&(F%""68. C 8*$%&!*4<"(8 8!&% 1'!?%"!% ()"*&5?!'*%$ #%), ' !+8%"%"!,: ! !"(;( &(1*, "% #',+*""6: # @%&%8%F%"!%8 *$(8('. C #',+! # E$!8 @&%1#$*'4,%$ !"$%&%# #4%15GF%% '6#/*+6'*"!% Q(4<28*"*: «-*+58%%$#,, 86 1(4?"6 '( '#,/(8 #45>*% #(+1*'*$< @(",$!% 1'!?%"!,. W#4! @&! E$(8 8(?"( )51%$ #'%#$! '#% /*?5F!%#, /*>%#$'%""6% !+8%"%"!, / /*&$!"% ( 1'!?%"!,: !4! @%&%;&5@@!&('/*: 8%4<>*.7!: >*#$!2, $( E$( @&!'%4( )6 / >&%+'6>*."( @&(#$(85 ()I,#"%"!G @&!&(16. J(;1* @&!&(1* )64* )6 "*!)(4%% @(",$"(. "*8. R( 86 "% 8(?%8 %% @&!"51!$< / E$(85. C(+8(?"(#$< $(;(, >$( E$( "%@(#$!?!8(, >$( 14, ($()&*?%"!, @&!&(16 "%():(1!86 %F% /*&$!"6 1&5;!: !+8%"%"!., 1(4?"* (#$*'*$<#, ($/&6$(.» (35, #. 152). R%():(1!8(. :*&*/$%&!#$!/(. 1'!?%"!,, ' @&%1#$*'4%"!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., ,'4,%$#, %;( 91*!!$*4, >$( 8*$%&!, «'#G15 "*:(1!$#, ' 1'!?%"!!…» (52, #. 38). L$* 86#4< ( '#%()F"(#$!, ( @('#%8%#$"(#$! 1'!?%"!, #/4*16'*4*#< ' #(+"*"!! 5>%"6: @(#$%@%""(, @( 8%&% '#% )(4%% ;45)(/(;( @&("!/"('%"!, %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, ' #5F"(#$< !+5>*%86: %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8 1'!?5F!:#, ()I%/$('. J*/, @( 8"%"!G K.H. %"1%4%%'*, «5)%?1%"!% '( '#%()F%8 &*#@&(#$&*"%"!! 1'!?%"!, "*>*4(#< # '!1!8(;( "%)*, /(">!4(#< "%'!1!868 8!&(8 >*#$!2» (260, #. 529). C 8!&%, #>!$*4 R.9. O8(', «'#% A!+!>%#/!% ,'4%"!, '6+6'*G$#, 1'!?%"!,8!» (364, #. 63). B&! E$(8 ' #*8(8 1'!?%"!!, @( 8%&% #('%&7%"#$'('*"!, %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( +"*"!, ( "%8, '#% )(4%% (>%'!1"(. #$*"('!4*#< (@&%1%4%""*, 5@(&,1(>%""(#$< /*/ &%+54<$*$ 1%.#$'!, ()I%/$!'"6: +*/("(', @&(#$5@*GF!: #/'(+< @&(,'4,GF!.#, '('"% :*(# ($1%4<"6: 1'!?%"!.. «C E$(8 /*?5F%8#, :*(#% '#%()F%;( – ($ +'%+1 1( *$(8(' – 1'!?%"!,, (1"*/(, 2*&!$ #$&(."6. @(&,1(/» (260, #. 530). B&!+"*"!% 5>%"68! '#%()F"(#$! 1'!?%"!, /*/ #@(#()* #5F%#$'('*"!, 8*$%&!! ()"*&5?!'*%$ %F% (1!" #5F%#$'%""6. 8(8%"$ ()F"(#$! %#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/(;( ! A!4(#(A#/(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8*; "(, /("%>"(, ! ' E$(8 #45>*% A!4(#(A!, +"*>!$%4<"( (@%&%1!4* %#$%#$'(+"*"!%. 0!4(#(A6–8*$%&!*4!#$6 +*1(4;( 1( %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. @&!74! / '6'(15 ( '#%()F"(#$! 1'!?%"!,. J*/, ' XVIII '%/% B.9. =(4<)*: #>!$*4, >$( «'#% '( '#%4%""(. "*:(1!$#, ' 1'!?%"!!» (126, #. 72). K. J(4*"1 $*/?% @(1>%&/!'*4, >$( «"!/*/*, >*#$< 8*$%&!! "% 4!7%"* #'(%. #()#$'%""(. '"5$&%""%. E"%&;!!», >$( «'#,/*, '%F< @&%$%&@%'*%$ )%#/("%>"6% !+8%"%"!,, $( %#$< "*:(1!$#,… ' "%@&%#$*""(8 1'!?%"!!» (7, #. 171). J( ?% – ! ' 8*&/#!#$#/(. A!4(#(A!!, '6&*?*, @(+!2!G
232
/($(&(., 0. L";%4<# @!#*4: «9)#(4G$"( '#%()F!8 +"*>%"!%8 ()4*1*%$ (1"( 4!7< 59'>*"'*» (406, #. 554). B&!+"*"!% '#%()F"(#$!, *)#(4G$"(#$! 1'!?%"!, "%():(1!8( ()5#4('4!'*%$ ! #(($'%$#$'5GF%% @("!8*"!% @&($!'(@(4(?"(;( 1'!?%"!G #(#$(,"!, – 2!6!(. V1%#< ! 14, A!4(#(A#/(;(, ! 14, %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* :*&*/$%&"( ($&!2*"!% *)#(4G$"(;( @(/(,, +*#$(,, "%@(1'!?"(#$!, @&!+"*"!% !-"!1'-*78"!1-' @(/(,. J*/, @( 8"%"!G K. K!1&(, «*)#(4G$"6. @(/(. %#$< *)#$&*/$"(% @(",$!%, ' @&!&(1% %;( "% #5F%#$'5%$» (146, #. 445). H /*/ )6 @&(1(4?*, E$5 86#4<, B.9. =(4<)*: @(1>%&/!'*4, >$( «'#% ' @&!&(1% "*:(1!$#, ' "%@&%&6'"(8 1'!?%"!!» (126, #. 75), >$( «"%$ "! (1"(. %% >*#$!, /($(&*, "*:(1!4*#< )6 ' *)#(4G$"(8 @(/(%». C ($"(7%"!! $%: !4! !"6: @&%18%$(', $%4 @(/(. '6&*?*%$ 4!7< '!1!8(#$< !: "%@(1'!?"(#$!, $(;1* /*/ $% !+ "!:, /($(&6% @&%1#$*'4,G$#, «4!7%""68! 1'!?%"!,, "*:(1,$#, ' 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! 4!7< ' ($"(#!$%4<"(8 !4! /*?5F%8#, @(/(%… C#%, >$( /*?%$#, "*8 "*:(1,F!8#, ' @(/(%, ' 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! "! "* 8;"('%"!% "% (#$*%$#, ' (1"(8 ! $(8 ?% #(#$(,"!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 72). C @&!&(1%, /*/ #>!$*4 K. J(4*"1, «(1"( 1'!?%"!% '#%;1* #8%",%$#, 1&5;!8 1'!?%"!%8, "( "!/(;1* "% #8%",%$#, *)#(4G$"68 @(/(%8» (7, #. 193). L$( +"*>!$, >$( «"% #5F%#$'5%$ *)#(4G$"(. )%+1%,$%4<"(#$! $%4, * %#$< $(4$( «8*$%&!, "% %#$< ! ($"G1< "% 8(?%$ )6$< "%@(1'!?"(., 8%&$'(. ! )%+1%.#$'%""(. ;46)(., !"*>% ;('(&,, @&%)6'*$< ' #(#$(,"!! *)#(4G$"(;( @(/(,» ($*8 ?%, #. 69). 0. L";%4<# $*/?% @(1>%&/!'*4, >$( «*)#(4G$"(;( @(/(,, )%+5#4('"(;( &*'"('%#!, "% #5F%#$'5%$», >$( «'#,/!. @(/(., '#,/(% &*'"('%#!% $(4"68 '6'(1*8 ' XIX '%/% @&!:(1!4! ! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4!. B( 8"%"!G D. QG:"%&*, «*)#(4G$"(;( @(/(, "%$» (52, #. 43). «R!;1% "% ;(#@(1#$'5%$ @(4"6. @(/(. ! "%@(1'!?"(#$<», – @!#*4 L. =%//%4< (95, #. 282). «B(/(, "! ' >%8, 1*?% ' #8%&$! "*.$! "% 51*%$#,», – ($8%>*4 K.H. %"1%4%%', ()&*F*, ' $( ?% '&%8, '"!8*"!% "* "*4!>!% «($"(#!$%4<"(;( @(/(, '( '#%()F%8, ?!'(8 1'!?%"!!» (260, #. 470, 530). «C 8!&%, – @!#*4 R.9. O8(', – "%$ "!>%;(, >$( "*:(1!4(#< )6 ' @(/(%» (364, #. 7). J(>"( $*/ ?% B.R. D%)%1%' 5$'%&?1*4, >$( «8!& "% "*:(1!$#, ' 8%&$'(8 @(/(%» (199, #. 37). K'!?%"!% 8*$%&!!, ' @("!8*"!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/*, "% $(4%+*%$, "% 8(?%$ )6$< #(+1*"( !+ "!>%;(, "% 8(?%$ )6$< 5"!>$(?%"(. L$( 8!&('(++&%">%#/(% (#"('(@(4(?%"!%, /*/ '6'(1 !+ 1(#$!?%"!. %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, ($8%$!4, ' >*#$"(#$!, D. QG:"%&: «C @&!&(1% "%$ 1'!?%"!,, 8(;5F%;( @&(!+(.$! !+ "!>%;( !4! ()&*$!$<#, ' "!>$(» (52, #. 16). R* 1'!?%"!%, #>!$*4 QG:"%&, «#4%15%$ #8($&%$<, /*/ "* '%>"(%, "%($1%4!8(% #'(.#$'( !4! /*/ "* "%():(1!8(% #(#$(,"!% 8*$%&!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 44). B&! E$(8 QG:"%&
233
#(#4*4#, "* #('@*1*GF%% 8"%"!% L";%4<#*, ()#$(,$%4<"( !+4(?!' %;( $(>/5 +&%"!, ' &*##8*$&!'*%8(8 '(@&(#%. J(>"( $*/ ?%, @( 8"%"!G L. =%//%4,, «' "%@&%&6'"(8 ! '%>"(8 1'!?%"!! '#%: >*#$!2 C#%4%""(. "%4<+, @&%1#$*'!$< #%)% "! "*>*4*, "! /("2*» (95, #. 259). «K'!?%"!%, – @!#*4 -. *.%&, – "% '(+"!/*%$ #*8( @( #%)%». 3" ?% ($8%$!4, >$( «1'!?%"!% "% 8(?%$ @&%'&*$!$<#, ' "!>$(» (229, #. 82). B( 8"%"!G K.M. */#'%44*, «1'!?%"!% $*/ ?% "%&*+&57!8(, /*/ ! 5'%&%""(#$< "*7* ' "%&*+&57!8(#$! /*?1(. >*#$!26 8*$%&!!» (231, #. 37). L. =%//%4< #>!$*4, >$( «#5)#$*"2!, @('#G15 (:'*>%"* '%>"68 1'!?%"!%8 ! @&%'&*F%"!%8» (95, #. 406). 0. L";%4<# # @(+!2!. 8*&/#!#$#/(. A!4(#(A!! 5$'%&?1*4 $( ?% #*8(%: «K'!?%"!% "%#($'(&!8( ! "%5"!>$(?!8(» (406, #. 392). 3" ?% @(1>%&/!'*4, >$( «1'!?%"!% $*/ ?% "%#($'(&!8( ! "%&*+&57!8(, /*/ ! #*8* 8*$%&!,» (405, #. 59). -*"%% E$* !1%, "%#($'(&!8(#$! ! "%5"!>$(?!8(#$! 1'!?%"!, 5$'%&1!4*#< ' 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! XVII–XVIII ''. J*/, B.9. =(4<)*:, ()(#"('6'*, "*+'*""5G !1%G, @!#*4: «W#4! "*# #@&(#,$, ($/51* ,'!4*#< 8*$%&!,, 86 ($'%$!8, >$( ("* #5F%#$'('*4* '%+1%, '#%;1*. W#4! #@&(#,$, ($/51* 5 8*$%&!! @(,'!4(#< 1'!?%"!%, 86 ($'%$!8, >$( @( $%8 ?% (#"('*"!,8 ("* 1(4?"* )64* 1'!;*$<#, '%>"(, $*/ /*/ 1'!?%"!% – "%():(1!86. &%+54<$*$ %% #5F%#$'('*"!,» (126, #. 80). 3)F"(#$< '6'(1(' A!4(#(A('–8*$%&!*4!#$(' ! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ($"(#!$%4<"( '%>"(#$! 1'!?%"!, 8*$%&!! ! (+"*>*%$, >$( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/*, A!4(#(A!, ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!% "%+*'!#!8( 1&5; ($ 1&5;*, &*+"68! @5$,8! ! ' &*+"(% '&%8, @&!74! / #:(1"68 &%7%"!,8, / ()F%. !1%% "%#($'(&!8(#$! ! "%5"!>$(?!8(#$! 1'!?%"!, 8*$%&!!, @&!>%8 A!4(#(A!, ! ' E$(8 #45>*% +"*>!$%4<"( (@%&%1!4* %#$%#$'(+"*"!%: «0!4(#(A!,, – @!#*4 0. L";%4<#, – @&!74* / E$(85 +*1(4;( 1( $(;(, /*/ E$* !1%, 5/&%@!4*#< ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!». B( 8"%"!G L";%4<#*, «A!4(#(A!, #1%4*4* +* 2%46: 1'%#$! 4%$ 1( %#$%#$'(+"*"!, '6'(1 ( "%#($'(&!8(#$! ! "%5"!>$(?!8(#$! 1'!?%"!,» (406, #. 392). § 6. $82H3DB; PED8N==: B;FD8=;3=CB = PED8NDF=CB B&!+"*"!% "%&*+&6'"(. #',+! 8*$%&!! ! 1'!?%"!, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! /("/&%$!+!&('*4! @&!8%"!$%4<"( / A!+!>%#/(. 8%&% @(#4%1"%;( – / C"*$#''. M*/ @!#*4 ' "*>*4% UU '%/* &5##/!. 5>%"6., A!+!/ 9.9. L.:%"'*4<1, «&*+'!'*,#< "* @(>'% 8%:*"!>%#/!: @&%1#$*'4%"!., "*5/* 1(74* "*/("%2 1( 1'5: 5"!'%&#*4<"6:, ()I%1!",GF!: @(",$!.; E$! @(",$!, #5$<: 8*$%&!, ! E"%&;!,. R* E$!: 1'5: (#"('"6: @(",$!,: "*5/* #$&(!4* '%#< 8!&» (404, #. 4). H ()F*, 5#$*"('/* ' #(($"(7%"!! 8*$%&!! ! E"%&;!!: «…M(;1* 8*$%&!, 1'!?%$#,, ("* ()4*1*%$ E"%&;!%. 1'!?%"!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 10). K&5;(. !+'%#$"6. &5##/!. A!+!/ 9.=. P$(4%$(' @(1>%&/"54 ' #',+! # E$!8, >$( «()6/"('%""*, («'%#(8*,») 8*$%&!, )6'*%$ "(#!$%4%8 E"%&;!!» (343,
234
#. 483). B( 8"%"!G K.H. %"1%4%%'*, E"%&;!, «#*8* @( #%)% "% #(+"*'*%8* )%+ 8*$%&!!», $*/ /*/ 1'!?%"!% «$&%)5%$ ! @&%1@(4*;*%$ 1'!?5F%%#,, /($(&(% #*8( @( #%)% 4!7< 86#4%""( '(+8(?"( )%+ '#,/(;( 1'!?%"!, ! "*+6'*%$#, '%F%#$'(8» (260, #. 470-471). P4%1('*$%4<"(, E"%&;!,, /*/ ! "%&*+1%4<"*, # "%. 8*$%&!,, 9*0"% – "*1!-9!$':% ! "*;"'0-!>':%. W#$%#$'%""("*5>"(. (#"('(. E$(;( 8!&('(++&%">%#/(;( (#"('(@(4(?%"!, ,'!4#, +*/(" #(:&*"%"!, ! @&%'&*F%"!, E"%&;!!. 31!" !+ %;( @%&'(($/&6'*$%4%., -. *.%&, "*+6'*,, #(;4*#"( #4('(5@($&%)4%"!G $(;( '&%8%"!, E"%&;!G «#!4(.», @!#*4, >$( «#!4* ! 8*$%&!, – "%5"!>$(?!86% ()I%/$6» (229, #. 262). L. =%//%4< $*/?% @(1>%&/"54, >$( «' @(#$(,""(. #8%"% A(&8 8*$%&!, ! "%&*+1%4<"*, # "%. #!4* !4! E"%&;!,, (#$*G$#, '%>"68!, "%&*+&57!868!» (89, #. 259). B( 8"%"!G =. =%4<8;(4<2*, «'%#< 8!& ()4*1*%$ (@&%1%4%""68 /(4!>%#$'(8 #!46, /($(&*, 1%.#$'5%$ ' "%8 ' @(#$(,""( !+8%",GF!:#, A(&8*: ,'4%"!., #!46 "%&*+&57!8(., "%5'%4!>!'*%8(., '%>"(. ! "%!+8%""(., /*/ 8*$%&!,» (110, #. 173). D. QG:"%&, ($8%$!', >$( «@(",$!% #!46 )%+ 8*$%&!! $*/ ?% 4!7%"( #86#4*, /*/ @(",$!% 8*$%&!! )%+ #!46», @(1>%&/"54 @&! E$(8: «J(>"( $*/ ?%, /*/ 8*$%&!,, "%#(+1*'*%8*, "%5"!>$(?!8*, "%@&%:(1,F* ! )%##8%&$"* ! #',+*""*, # "%. #!4*» (52, #. 9, 15).L$( )64( (>%'!1"68 ! 14, X. (4%7($$*, @(#/(4"( %85 @&!#5F%% #'(.#$'(» ([!$. @(: 393, #. 50-51). B&!'%1%""6% '67% A!4(#(A#/!% @( #5$!, ,'"( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!% (#"('(@(4(?%"!, ' !: @&%!85F%#$'%""(. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(. ()5#4('4%""(#$! @&(>"( 5$'%&1!4!#< ' 8!&('(++&%"!! '61*GF!:#, 5>%"6: '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX – "*>*4* UU ''. J*/, H. . P%>%"(', /("/&%$!+!&5, A!4(#(A#/5G /*$%;(&!G «1'!?%"!%» ' A!+!>%#/(8 @(",$!! «E"%&;!,», @(1>%&/"54, >$( «' (#"('% #('&%8%""(;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( 8!&(#(+%&2*"!, 4%?!$, /*/ 1(;8*$, "*>*4( "%&*+&57*%8(#$! ! "%#(+1*'*%8(#$! 8*$%&!! ! E"%&;!!» (337, #. 10). B( 8"%"!G M.9. J!8!&,+%'*, ' @&!&(1% «#5F%#$'5%$ !+'%#$"(% /(4!>%#$'( '%F%#$'*, (1*&%""(;( !+'%#$"68 /(4!>%#$'(8 1'!?%"!,, $( %#$< #!46 – "! $(, "! 1&5;(% "% 8(?%$ "! @&!)*'!$<#,, "! 5)*'!$<#,. 3"! 8(;5$ @(>$! )%#/("%>"( '!1(!+8%",$<#, ! @&%'&*F*$<#,, "( "% 8(;5$ "! #(+1*'*$<#, '"('<, "! !#>%+"5$<» (353, #. 306-307). J(>"( $*/ ?% K.H. %"1%4%%', ()(+"*>*, 1'!?%"!% @(",$!%8 «#!4*», 5$'%&?1*4, >$( «'( '"%7"%8, $( %#$< A!+!>%#/(8, !4! 8*$%&!*4<"(8 8!&% "!>$( "% $'(&!$#, ! "% @&(@*1*%$, "! '%F%#$'(, "! #!46, ' "%8 1%.#$'5GF!%, ("! $(4%+*G$, (#$*G$#, ' $(8 ?% /(4!>%#$'%, 1*""(8 ' @&!&(1%» ($*8 ?%, #. 262). H 9.=. P$(4%$(', ,'4,, ' &*##8*$&!'*%8(8 '(@&(#% $( ?% %1!"(86#4!% # 1&5;!8! 5>%"68!, @!#*4: «'#,/!. &*+, /(;1* @%&%1 "*8! @&(!#:(1!$ "%/($(&(% ,'4%"!%, 86 !F%8 ! "*:(1!8 %85 8%&5 ' @&!&(#
%$ 235
!4! 5)64! E"%&;!! "%/($(&(. >*#$! '%F%#$'*, !F%8 ! "*:(1!8 #(($'%$#$'5GF5G 5)64< !4! @&!&(#$ ' 1&5;!: 1(4,: E"%&;!!, – ' @(4"(. ! '#%;1* (@&*'16'*GF%.#, 5'%&%""(#$!, >$( ()F!. !$(; E"%&;!! (#$*4#, "%!+8%""68» (343, #. 557). P(($'%$#$'%""( ("$(4(;!>%#/(. +"*>!8(#$! @(",$!. 8*$%&!! ! E"%&;!! 5>%"6% &*##8*$&!'*4! ! (2%"!'*4! ! !: @(+"*'*$%4<"6. #$*$5# ' "*5/%. J*/, !+'%#$"6. *";4!.#/!. A!+!/ K. J!"1*4< ' #(($"(7%"!! 8*$%&!! ! E"%&;!! (#!46) 5#8*$&!'*4 5"!'%&#*4<"6. ()I%/$ %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, ' >*#$"(#$!, %;( &*2!("*4<"(., 86#4!$%4<"(. #(#$*'4,GF%.. «P5F%#$'5G$, – @!7%$ J!"1*4<, – 1'* "*>*4*, 1*GF!%, $*/ #/*+*$<, 8*$%&!*4 '#%85 "*5>"(85 8674%"!G; '#, 1%,$%4<"(#$< >%4('%>%#/(;( 58* (;&*"!>!'*%$#, /(8)!"!&('*"!%8 4!7< 1'5: (#"('"6: @(",$!.: :%-*$'' ! 1'7.» (358, #. 47). L$( &*2!("*4<"(% "*>*4( ' @(+"*'*$%4<"(8 (#'(%"!! 8*$%&!! ! E"%&;!! – 8*$%&!! ! 1'!?%"!, ' A!4(#(A#/(8 '*&!*"$% – 1%4*4( '(+8(?"68 5#$*"('4%"!% #5F"(#$"(;( +"*"!, ' 1*""(8 '(@&(#%, ' %;( "% $(4"(8, "( ! ' @&%1'*&,GF%8 58(+&!$%4<"(8, A!4(#(A#/(8 &%7%"!!, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' 5$'%&?1%"!! (#"('(@(4*;*GF%. !1%! '%>"(#$! 8*$%&!! ! 1'!?%"!, (#!46), !: "%&*+&57!8(#$!. « 6#4< ( $(8, >$( 8*$%&!, "%&*+&57!8*, )64* '6#/*+*"* +*1(4;( 1( /*/(;(-4!)( (@&%1%4%""(;( (@6$* ' E$(8 "*@&*'4%"!!, ! '#% @(#4%15GF!% "*)4G1%"!, @(#$(,""( (@&*'16'*4! E$( @(4(?%"!%. K*4<"%.7!% !##4%1('*"!, &*#@&(#$&*"!4! !1%G "%&*+&57!8(#$! ! "* #!45»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«E"%&;%$!/*») A!4(#(A#$'5GF%;( %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,, @(#4%1('*$%4, *:* C. 3#$'*4<1*, !+'%#$"(;( "%8%2/(;( A!+!/* ! :!8!/*. B&%1#$*'4,, #'(G (#"('(@(4*;*GF5G /("2%@2!G ' &*##8*$&!'*%8(8 '(@&(#%, 3#$'*4<1 @&%?1% '#%;( 5/*+6'*%$ "* $( !1%."(% $%>%"!% ' "*5/%, # /($(&68 (" &%7!$%4<"( &*#:(1!$#, ' #5F"(#$"(8 @("!8*"!! E"%&;!!, 1'!?%"!, 8*$%&!!. « *$%&!, ! 1'!?%"!%, – @!7%$ (", – '($ 1'* /("%>"6% @(",$!,, / /($(&68 #'(1!$#, '#% 8"(;(()&*+!% ,'4%"!. @&!&(16. J*/(% 8!&('(++&%"!% 8(?%$ )6$< "*+'*"( "%;0".: :%-*$'%7',:!:» (293, #. 1). 3#$'*4<1 @&!+"*%$, >$( E$( – «()F%@&!",$(% 8"%"!%» ' "*5/% ! $%8 "% 8%"%% (" )%&%$#, 1(/*+*$<, >$( ("(, E$( 8"%"!%, «@(#$&(%"( "* '%#<8* 7*$/!: (#"('*"!,:». *$%&!,, @( 3#$'*4<15, E$( '%F%#$'(, 8*##*, ()4*1*GF*, '%#(8 ! ()I%8(8. C%F%#$'( &%*4<"( #5F%#$'5%$ ' '!1% $%4. H: 1'!?%"!%, $( %#$< 1'!?%"!% 8*$%&!!, – E$( !#/4G>!$%4<"(
236
8%:*"!>%#/(% 1'!?%"!%. P4%1('*$%4<"(, "*5>"6. 8*$%&!*4!+8 %#$< 8%:*"!>%#/!. 8*$%&!*4!+8, 8%:*"!#$!>%#/(% 8!&('(++&%"!% ' "*5/%. 3#$*%$#, @(E$(85 5)%1!$<#, ' $(8, >$( «8%:*"!#$!>%#/(% 8!&('(++&%"!% "% '6@(4",%$ $(;( "*+"*>%"!,, 14, /($(&(;( ("( '6&*)($*"(, ! >$( E$( 8!&('(++&%"!% "*:(1!$#, ' "%@&!8!&!8(8 @&($!'(&%>!! # ()F%!+'%#$"68!, @&!+"*""68! ! )%##@(&"68! !#$!"*8!» ($*8 ?%, #. 2). L$(85 «(7!)(>"(85» 8%:*"!#$!>%#/(85 8!&('(++&%"!G – «()F%@&!+"*""(85» "*5>"(85 8*$%&!*4!+85 – 3#$'*4<1 ! @&($!'(@(#$*'4,%$ #'(G «E"%&;%$!/5», $*/ (@&%1%4,, %%: E"%&;%$!/* %#$< «$( "*5>"(% 8!&('(++&%"!%, #(;4*#"( /($(&(85 A!+!>%#/(% @(",$!% E"%&;!!… "*!)(4%% @(4"( ! $(>"( ()()F*%$ '#% A!+!/(-:!8!>%#/!% A*/$6 ! +*/("6» (291, #. 80). 9 /*/ ?% 8*$%&!,? 3"* 5?% "% "5?"*: ' #'%$% +"*"!, "('(. A!+!>%#/(. &%*4<"(#$! – E4%/$&(1!"*8!>%#/(., $( %#$< "%'%F%#$'%""(., * +"*>!$, ! «"%8*$%&!*4<"(.» – ("*, 8*$%&!,, /*/ #*8(#$(,$%4<"6. A*/$(& A!+!/(–:!8!>%#/(;( @(+"*"!, @&!&(16, #$*"('!$#, !+4!7"%., '( '#%8 +*8%",%$#, E"%&;!%.. B(",$!% E"%&;!!, @( 8"%"!G 3#$'*4<1*, «3'$*, >%8 @(",$!% 8*$%&!!… L$( @(#4%1"%% $*/?% 1(@5#/*%$ E"%&;%$!>%#/(% (@&%1%4%"!%, ! 1*?%… %1!"#$'%""( ,#"(% (@&%1%4%"!% 8*$%&!!, /($(&(% '(()F% #5F%#$'5%$, %#$< !8%""( (@&%1%4%"!% E"%&;%$!>%#/(%» ($*8 ?%, #. 37). H 3#$'*4<1 $*/ ()(#"('6'*%$ E$5 «E"%&;%$!>"(#$<» 8*$%&!!: «C @(",$!! ( 8*$%&!! +*/4G>*%$#, @&%?1% '#%;( 8*##*, $( %#$< %8/(#$< 14, E"%&;!! 1'!?%"!,; +*$%8 "*@(4"%"!% @&(#$&*"#$'*, !4! E"%&;!, ()I%8*; 1*4%% '%#, !4! (#()6. '!1 E"%&;!! @(4(?%"!,, @&(,'4,GF!.#, ' #!4% $,?%#$!, !, "*/("%2, :!8!>%#/!% #'(.#$'*, $( %#$< :!8!>%#/*, E"%&;!,». C !$(;% @(45>*%$#,, >$( 8*$%&!, – E$( 5?% ! "% 8*$%&!,, /*/ #*8(#$(,$%4<"*, /*>%#$'%""*, (@&%1%4%""(#$<, ()4*1*GF*, E"%&;!%., * #*8* E"%&;!, ' &*+"6: %% #(#$(,"!,:. « *$%&!,, – @!7%$ 3#$'*4<1, – %#$< "% >$( !"(%, /*/ @&(#$&*"#$'%""( #(%1!"%""*, ;&5@@* &*+4!>"6: E"%&;!., ! '#%, >$( 86 :($!8 '6#/*+*$< ( 8*$%&!!, 86 '6#/*+6'*%8 4!7< () E$!: E"%&;!,:» (293, #. 19). P5$< E"%&;%$!/!, #4%1('*$%4<"(, +*/4G>*%$#, ' *)#(4G$!+*2!! E"%&;!! ' ()I,#"%"!! )6$!, ! &*+'!$!, @&!&(16 ' %% A5"1*8%"$*4<"6: (#"('*"!,:. L$( +"*>!$, >$(, #(;4*#"( 3#$'*4<15, E"%&;!, A*/$!>%#/! ()&%$*%$ /*>%#$'( #5)#$*"2!!. R* E$(, ' >*#$"(#$!, ()&*$!4 '"!8*"!% (1!" !+ $(4/('*$%4%. E"%&;%$!/!, "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A–"%(/*"$!*"%2 M. D*##'!2, @( 8"%"!G /($(&(;( #5)#$*"2!*4<"(#$< E"%&;!! +*/4G>*%$#, ' $(8, >$( «E"%&;!, %#$< !8%""( $(, >$( (@&%1%4,%$ #*85G '(+8(?"(#$< ,'4%"!.» (196, #. 17). H @($(85, #>!$*4 3#$'*4<1, ' @&!&(1% &%*4<"( #5F%#$'5%$, ' &*+"6: $&*"#A(&8*2!,:, (1"* E"%&;!,, #5F%#$'5%$ #*8* @( #%)%, )%+ $(;( '"!#!, >$( ()4*1*%$ %G, $( %#$< )%+ #'(%;( :%-*$'%78"!#! "(#!$%4,. 3$#G1* #4%15%$, >$( ' (),+*$%4<"(. 14, "*5>"(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* #',+/% «8*$%&!, ! 1'!?%"!%», «8*$%&!, ' 1'!?%"!!» 3#$'*4<1 #(:&*",%$ $(4%+*%$, &*#$'(&,%$#, ' E"%&;!! 1'!?%"!,. B(45>*%$#, #'(%;( &(1* «E/("(8!,
237
8674%"!,» ' 15:% A!4(#(A!! *:*: «C#%, >$( 8(?"( #%)% @&%1#$*'!$< @&! @(8(F! @(",$!. «'%F%#$'(» ! «#!4*», %F% 45>7% 8(?%$ )6$< @&%1#$*'4%"( @&! @(8(F! (1"(;( 4!7< @(",$!, «E"%&;!,». K%4( !1%$ $(4"(;( !##4%1('*"!,, 5$'%&?1*,, >$( «+*/("6 ,'4%"!. @&!&(16 8(;5$ )6$< #'%1%"6 / +*/("*8 #(($'%$#$'5GF!: A(&8 E"%&;!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 22). B&!8%"!$%4<"( / "*5/% E$( (+"*>*%$, >$( «E"%&;!, %1!"#$'%""*, '%4!>!"*, /($(&*, 8(?%$ )6$< ($"%#%"* /( '#%8 )%+ !#/4G>%"!, ()4*#$,8 "*5/!. J*/!8 ()&*+(8, 8%?15 &*+4!>"68! ()4*#$,8! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, "%4<+, #(@(#$*'!$< "!>%;( 1&5;(;(, /&(8% !#/(86: '%4!>!" E"%&;!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 23). 3$#G1* ! #(($'%$#$'5GF!% #4%1#$'!, ' 8!&('(++&%">%#/(. ! 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/(. #A%&*: %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. C >*#$"(#$!, "%!+)%?"68 14, 3#$'*4<1* #$*4 @%&%#8($& 8!&('(++&%">%#/(;( *#@%/$* A!+!/(–:!8!>%#/!: @&%1#$*'4%"!. ( :*D%"'0*16!: 1'!?%"!! 8*$%&!*4<"6: $%4 ! *$(8(' ' "!:. R* E$!: @&%1#$*'4%"!,: (#"('6'*4#, "*5>"6. 8*$%&!*4!+8, /*/ «:*D%"'0*16!* :'$!9!,,$*"'*, $( %#$< 1(@5F%"!%, >$( /("%>"*, 2%4<, /($(&(. $(4< %#$%#$'(+"*"!%, +*/4G>*%$#, ' #'%1%"!! '#%: ,'4%"!. / #!#$%8% @(1'!?"6: $(>%/ 8*##6» ($*8 ?%, #. 12). B(#/(4!$*4 3#$'*4<1, E"%&;%$!/* «8(?%$ # 5#@%:(8 +*8%"!$< ;(#@(1#$'('*'7%% 1( "*#$(,F%;( '&%8%"! @(>$! !#/4G>!$%4<"( 8%:*"!>%#/(% 8!&('(++&%"!%». J*/!8 ()&*+(8, 1%4*%$ '6'(1 3#$'*4<1, «"('%.7*, E'(4G2!, A!+!/!, )4*;(1*&, /($(&(. 86 "*>!"*%8 @("!8*$< 8%:*"!>%#/!% ,'4%"!,, /*/ #4%1#$'!, E4%/$&(1!"*8!>%#/!: @&(2%##(', @('!1!8(85, @(1$'%&?1*%$ @&*'!4<"(#$< #$&%84%"!, E"%&;%$!/! / 5#$&*"%"!G "*5>"(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8*» (291, #. 80). J( ?% #*8(% – ! ' 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/(. #A%&%. C "%. E"%&;%$!/*, >%&%+ &%*4!+*2!G @&!"2!@* «E/("(8!! 8674%"!,», #'(!8 #4%1#$'!%8 !8%4* ()F%@(+!$!'!#$#/(%, !15F%% ($ M("$*, ($&!2*"!% #'2!-*-'0*16!#! "*>*4* ' "*5/%. B( 8"%"!G 3#$'*4<1*, '*?"%.7%% @&%!85F%#$'( %;( E"%&;%$!>%#/(. $%(&!! «+*/4G>*%$#, ' $(8, >$( #$*"('!$#, '(+8(?"68 %#$%#$'(+"*"!%, 19!%#/!. 8!& @(#&%1#$'(8 #'%1%"!, '(#@&!"!8*%86: ,'4%"!. / 8%:*"!/% *$(8('». J%8 #*868, #>!$*4 3#$'*4<1, @(1&6'*G$#, (#"('6 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!: «0*/$!>%#/*,
238
"%()&*$!8(#$< 1%.#$'!$%4<"6: ,'4%"!. @&!&(16 ,#"( 5/*+6'*%$ "* #5F%#$'('*"!% $*/!: @&(2%##(', /($(&6% "% 8(;5$ )6$< '6&*?%"6 8%:*"!>%#/!8! 5&*'"%"!,8!. L$!8 @&(!+"%#%" &(/('(. @&!;('(& "*5>"(85 8*$%&!*4!+85» ($*8 ?%, #. 13). C 2%4(8, 1%4*%$ '6'(1 3#$'*4<1, «5#$&*"%"!% 8%:*"!#$!>%#/(. /("#$&5/2!! 8!&* '%1%$ +* #()(. @*1%"!% '#%: (#"(' 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, ' "*5>"(8 #86#4% E$(;( #4('*» ($*8 ?%, #. 12). R( 3#$'*4<1 ,'"( @($(&(@!4#, # E$!8 /*&1!"*4<"68 '6'(1(8. P8%&$"6. @&!;('(&, ()I,'4%""6. !8 "*5>"(85 8*$%&!*4!+85, "% )64 @&!'%1%" ' !#@(4"%"!%. W#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! ' )(4<7!"#$'% #'(%8 "% @(11%&?*4! %;(, "% @&!",4! %;( *"$!8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/5G E"%&;%$!/5. 3" ! #*8 '6"5?1%" )64 E$( @&!+"*$<: «…Q(4<7!"#$'( A!4(#(A(' ! A!4(#(A#$'5GF!: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ' "*#$(,F%% '&%8, (' "*>*4% UU '%/*. – C.3.) @(#',F*G$ #'(! #!46 ;4*'"68 ()&*+(8 )(&<)% @&($!' E"%&;%$!/!…» (291, #. 27). P( #$(&("6 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. )(&<)5 '(+;4*'!4 D. Q(4<28*". C #',+! # E$!8 . B4*"/ @!#*4: «J(, >$( ' )(&<)% @&($!' 3#$'*4<1* ! E"%&;%$!/(' ' /("2% /("2(' @()%1!4 Q(4<28*", 14, 8%", )64(… #*8( #()(. &*+58%GF!8#, A*/$(8» (303, #. 13). B4*"/ ! #*8 5>*#$'('*4 ' E$(. )(&<)% ' /*>%#$'%, /*/ (" '6&*+!4#,, «#%/5"1*"$* Q(4<28*"*» (#8. $*8 ?%, #. 12). . D*5E, /*#*,#< 1*""(. $%86, ($8%$!4 #4%15GF%%: 3#$'*4<1 ! %;( #$(&(""!/! )64! #$(4< 5'4%>%"6 +*/("(8 #(:&*"%"!, E"%&;!!, >$( «("! "% $(4%"!,8, (1"*/(, '%#<8* )6#$&( )64 @(4(?%" /("%2 8%"%% '(#$(&?%""68! #('&%8%""!/*8!» (198, #. 176). C >*#$"(#$!, B4*"/, @( #4('*8 D*5E, '(+&*?*4 @&($!' E"%&;%$!/! «# $(>/! +&%"!, $%&8(1!"*8!/!. Q(4%% 1%.#$'%""( '(+&*?*4 DG1'!; Q(4<28*" # $(>/! +&%"!, *$(8"(. $%(&!! ! #$*$!#$!/!. R*/("%2, «E"%&;%$!/*» !#>%+4*, /*/ 8"(;!% 1&5;!% +*)45?1%"!,, #( #8%&$%""(#$! 8%:*"!#$!>%#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!, ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, # >%8 3#$'*4<1 ' &*8/*: #'(%. E"%&;%$!/! #',+6'*4 ($/*+ ($ %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8*, )64( '(+8(?"68 ! @&! #(:&*"%"!! @(#4%1"%;(, $( %#$< "* #$!:!."(-8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. (#"('%. V1%#< #4%15%$ 5>!$6'*$< $( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, >$( ' /("2% XIX – "*>*4% UU ''. #5F%#$'%""6% !+8%"%"!, @&%$%&@%4! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6% (#"('*"!, A!4(#(A#/!: @&%1#$*'4%"!. ( 1'!?%"!! 8*$%&!!. C >*#$"(#$!, ' #'%$% 1(#$!?%"!. %#$%#$'(+"*"!, '#% (>%'!1"%. #$*"('!4!#< (;&*"!>%""(#$<, $%(&%$!>%#/*, ! 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/*, "%1(#$*$(>"(#$< /4*##!>%#/(. 8%:*"!/! =*4!4%,–R!#45 #*86: )4%#$,F!: ! '*?"6: 1(#$!?%"!. >%4('%>%#/(. 86#4!: 8%?15 &*2!("*4<"(. 8%:*"!/(. =*4!4%,–R
239
8%:*"!/*, @( 8"%"!G D*"?%'%"*, )64* @&%1"*+"*>%"* 14, ()I,#"%"!, ,'4%"!. '!1!8(;(, "*;4,1"( @&%1#$*'!8(;( 1'!?%"!, ! # E$(. +*1*>%. ("* 5#@%7"( #@&*'4,4*#<. H"%&2!, "*5>"(. 86#4! #'(!8 #4%1#$'!%8 !8%4* #$&%84%"!% &*#@&(#$&*"!$< E$($ EAA%/$!'"6. #@(#() ()I,#"%"!, "* '#% A!+!>%#/!% ,'4%"!, '(()F%, '/4G>*, "%'!1!86% 1'!?%"!, 8*$%&!*4<"6: >*#$!2, *$(8('. «J*/!8 ()&*+(8, &*+'!4*#< 1(/$&!"*, !+'%#$"*, @(1 !8%"%8 8%:*"!2!+8*, @&%1#$*'4,GF*, #()(. &%+54<$*$ #4!,"!, &*2!("*4<"(. 8%:*"!/! ! *$(8!#$!>%#/!: ;!@($%+» (194, #. 453). 3#$'*4<1 ' )(&<)% # 8%:*"!2!+8(8 («8%:*"!#$!>%#/!8 8!&('(++&%"!%8») @&!7%4 / ($&!2*"!G 8*$%&!!, &%*4<"(#$! *$(8(' ! "* E$(. (#"('% – / ($'%&?%"!G "*5>"(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8*. D*"?%'%" &*##51!4 !"*>%. «…R%51*>! 8%:*"!2!+8*, – @!#*4 (", – >*#$( ($"(#!4! +* #>%$ *$(8!#$!>%#/(. 1(/$&!"6, /($(&*,, (1"*/(, ' "*7! 1"! (@!&*%$#, "* "%(@&('%&?!86% E/#@%&!8%"$*4<"6% 1(/*+*$%4<#$'* !, ' #(>%$*"!! # E4%/$&(8*;"!$"(. $%(&!%., 1*4* #$(4< +*8%>*$%4<"6% @4(16 +* !#$%/7!% @,$"*12*$< 4%$». K%4(, #4%1('*$%4<"(, "% ' *$(8*:, "% ' 8*$%&!!. C 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!, #>!$*4 D*"?%'%", «@(&(>"* #*8*, @(@6$/* @&!8%"!$< / "%'!1!868 1'!?%"!,8 +*/("6 8%:*"!/!, 5#$*"('4%""6% @%&'("*>*4<"( 14, '!1!86: 1'!?%"!., $%8 )(4%%, >$( 1*?% 14, @(#4%1"!: E$! +*/("6 ,'4,G$#, @%&'68, '@&(>%8, @&%'(#:(1"68 @&!)4!?%"!%8»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» (364, #. 172-173). R%51('4%$'(&!$%4<"(#$< /4*##!>%#/(. 8%:*"!/!, %% "%1(#$*$(>"(#$< ' 1%4% *1%/'*$"(;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, &%*4<"(;( 1'!?%"!, ' @&!&(1% '#%;( (>%'!1"%% ()"*&5?!4!#< ' #'%$% "('6: *$(8!#$!>%#/!: @&%1#$*'4%"!.. O#$*"('4%"!% 1%4!8(#$! *$(8*, %;( #4(?"(;( #$&(%"!, "%!+)%?"( '6'(1!4( @(+"*'*$%4<"6% 5#$&%84%"!, 5>%"6: "* /*>%#$'%""( !"6%, "%?%4! ' 8*/&(8!&%, @&(,'4%"!, 1'!?%"!,, "* %;( !"(. – '"5$&!*$(8"6. – 8%:*"!+8. R* E$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'( ! ()&*$!4 '"!8*"!% R.9. O8('. J*/, %F% ' 1905 ;(15 ' &*)($% «L'(4G2!, *$(8*» (", ($8%$!' #4(?!'7%%#, ' $( '&%8, 8"%"!% 5>%"6: ( "%():(1!8(#$! #'%1%"!, «'#%: ,'4%"!. @&!&(16 "* 8%:*"!/5 *$(8('», ($ #%), 1()*'!4 #5F%#$'%""(% 5$(>"%"!%: «K*, "* 8%:*"!/5 *$(8(', "( "% ' $(8 #86#4%, /*/ E$(
240
@("!8*4(#< 1( @(#4%1"!: 1"%.! R% "* '"%7"!. 8%:*"!+8, #',+5GF!. *$(86 8%?15 #()(G, * "* !: '"5$&%""GG 8%:*"!/5». L$( ($/&6'*4( "('6%, &*"%% #('%&7%""( "% @&%1#$*'!86% @%&#@%/$!'6 ' 1*4<"%.7%8 &*+'!$!! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,: «R*8 @&%1#$(!$ "('*, ;&(8*1"*, +*1*>*: A!+!/* ! :!8!, *$(8* – 8!/&(A!+!/* ! 8!/&(:!8!,». H ' #',+! # E$!8, @&%1'!1, ' )515F%8 '(+8(?"(#$< "('6: /*&1!"*4<"6: !+8%"%"!. ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!!, O8(' @!#*4: «\!+"< '"5$&%""%;( 8!&* *$(8* ($/&(%$ "*8 #'(.#$'* ! +*/("6, )6$< 8(?%$, ($4!>"6% ($ $%:, /($(&6% #(#$*'4,G$ #(1%&?*"!% #$*&(., 5?% 1&%'"%. A!+!/!» ($*8 ?%, #. 284). M E$(85 (#$*%$#, $(4$( ($/&6$!% ' "*>*4% UU '%/* "('6: #'(.#$' ! +*/("(' '"5$&%""%;( 8!&* *$(8*, 1'!?%"!, ' "%8 "! ' /(%. 8%&% "% @(/(4%)*4( ()F5G 8!&('(++&%">%#/5G, 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/5G @( #'(%. A!4(#(A#/(. #5$! @(+!2!G 5>%"6: ' @("!8*"!! 1'!?%"!, 8*$%&!!, * &*'"( ! $*/!: (#"('"6: A(&8 %% )6$!,, /*/ 2$!1-$%"1-9! ! 9$*:(. § 7. 028BK HKF=9 B;FD8==: >824F8;E4F52 = 58DB9 0!4(#(A#/*, @(+!2!, '61*GF!:#, 5>%"6:–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–'&%8%""6: :*&*/$%&!#$!/ )6$!, 8*$%&!*4<"(;( 8!&*. L$( '*?"( ! "%():(1!8( !8%""( (! $(4%#/(8 @4*"% –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«E$! @(",$!,, ' $(. A(&8%, ' /*/(. 86 !8! (@%&!&('*4! 1( #!: @(& (()6>"( "% *"*4!+!&5, ' 1(#$*$(>"(. 8%&% !: #86#4*), 2%4!/(8 (@&%1%4,4!#< ! )64! ()5#4('4%"6 8%:*"!#$!>%#/(. $%(&!%., $( %#$< #!#$%8(., /($(&*, ,'4,%$#, 4!7< >*#$"(. ! @&%1'*&!$%4<"(. #!"$%$!>%#/(. /("2%@2!%. 8!&*. R*7! @(",$!, '&%8%"! ! @&(#$&*"#$'* –
241
E$( @(",$!,, /($(&6: $&%)('*4* &*2!("*4<"*, 8%:*"!/*» (194, #. 451). C >*#$"(#$!, ' &*8/*: E$!: $&%)('*"!. @&(#$&*"#$'( ! '&%8, ' !: #5F"(#$"(8 @("!8*"!! 1( UU '%/* &*##8*$&!'*4!#< A!+!/*8! '"% !: '+*!8"(. #',+!, ($1%4<"( (1"( ($ 1&5;(;(. H $(4*4% UU '%/* @(4(?%"!% 1%4 ' E$(. ()4*#$! /(&%""68 ()&*+(8 !+8%"!4(#<. J*/, ' 1908 ;(15, 5#$*"*'4!'*, @&!"2!@!*4<"( "('6% A!+!>%#/!% '(++&%"!, "* @&(#$&*"#$'( ! '&%8,, =. !"/('#/!. @(1>%&/"54: «J%"1%"2!, !: &*1!/*4<"*,. 3$"6"% '&%8, @( #%)% ! @&(#$&*"#$'( @( #%)% 1(4?"6 #1%4*$<#, '#%2%4( $%",8!, ! $(4%$*"!% #(:&*"!$ #*8(#$(,$%4<"(#$<» (273, #. 27). R( /*/ )6 $( "! )64(, @&!8%"!$%4<"( / %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8 XIX '%/* ' 1*""(8 #45>*% '*?"* ()F*, @&!"2!@!*4<"*, 5#$*"('/* ' !: 8!&('(++&%"!! – @&!+"*"!% !8! "%&*+&6'"(. 19(,' @&(#$&*"#$'* ! '&%8%"! ' )6$!! 8*$%&!! # %% 59'>*"'*:. H E$( @(",$"(: @(#/(4%8 (#5F%#$'4,%$#, %% 1'!?%"!%, $( %#$< @&(#$&*"#$'* ! '&%8%"!. «C#,/(% 1'!?%"!%, – @!#*4 H. . P%>%"(', – #4*;*%$#,, /*/ !+'%#$"(, !+ 1'5: E4%8%"$(': @&(#$&*"#$'* ! '&%8%"!» (335, #. 459). 3)(#"('6'*, !: (),+*$%4<"(#$< ' 8!&('(++&%"!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., P%>%"(' ($8%$!4 $*/?%: «C#% 86#4!86% ($"(7%"!, 8%?15 @&%18%$*8! '"%7"%;( 8!&* @(1'(1,$#, ' "*#$(,F%% '&%8, @(1 $&! ;4*'"6: /*$%;(&!!: #('8%#$"(% #5F%#$'('*"!%, @(#4%1('*"!% ! #:(1#$'(. B%&'(. !+ E$!: A(&8 #(($'%$#$'5G$ @&(#$&*"#$'%""6% ($"(7%"!,, * '$(&(. – @&%%8#$'( '( '&%8%"!» ($*8 ?%, #. 377). P4%15%$, (1"*/(, ($8%$!$<, >$( ' /*>%#$'% ()I%/$(' A*/$5*4<"(;( +"*"!, ! #5F"(#$"(;( @("!8*"!, @&(#$&*"#$'( ! '&%8, "% ()4*1*G$ $*/(. +&!8(. "*;4,1"(#$5'#$'%""( '(#@&!"!8*%8(. $%4%#"(#$%"('*, '+*!8(1%.#$'!% '( '"%7"%8, «@&%18%$"(8» 8!&% #('%&7*%$#, '#%;1* ' @&(#$&*"#$'% ! '&%8%"! ! ' )(4<7!"#$'% #45>*%' E$( '+*!8(1%.#$'!% «"% 1(#$5@"( @&,8( >5'#$'5» ($*8 ?%, #. 361). H"*>% ;('(&,, @&(#$&*"#$'( ! '&%8, #*8! @( #%)% "% A!/#!&5G$#, ' "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 (@6$%, "% @&%1#$*G$ ' ,'"(. A%"(8%"*4<"(#$!, * 4!7< @&!86#4!'*G$#, / $(85, >$( «1(#$5@"( @&,8( >5'#$'5», $( %#$< / &%*4<"68 @&%18%$*8 ! ,'4%"!,8. H @($(85 ' #(+1*"!! 5>%"6: ("! %F% "% &*#/&6'*4!#< ' /("/&%$"6: :*&*/$%&!#$!/*:, ' 1%$*4!+!&('*""(. *&;58%"$*2!!, * @&%1#$*'*4! 4!7< ' #'(%. 4(;!>%#/(. (>%'!1"(#$! /*/ "%():(1!86% ! (),+*$%4<"6% 14, #5F%#$'('*"!, ! 1'!?%"!, 8*$%&!*4<"6: $%4 A(&86 )6$!,. R% #45>*."( @(E$(85 K.H. %"1%4%%' @(1>%&/!'*4, >$( ' ($"(7%"!! 8*$%&!! ! %% 1'!?%"!,, ' !: (#86#4%"!! (),+*$%4<"68! ,'4,G$#, $*/!% /*$%;(&!!, «/*/ @&(#$&*"#$'( ! '&%8,, 1( @("!8*"!, #5F"(#$! /($(&6: 86#4< "*7* %F% "% 8(?%$ 1(#$!;*$<, "( )%+ @&!+"*"!, /($(&6: "% 8(?%$ ():(1!$<#,» (260, #. 417). H @(#/(4"(, $( "% '(+"!/*4( $(;1* ! @($&%)"(#$!, "*#$(,$%4<"(. "%():(1!8(#$! ' #@%2!*4<"(8 5;45)4%""(8 @(+"*"!! @&(#$&*"#$'* !
242
'&%8%"!, ' !: #5F"(#$"(8 (#86#4%"!! ! $%(&%$!>%#/(8 ()I,#"%"!!. B(E$(85 ' $%: A!4(#(A#/!: @( #'(%85 :*&*/$%&5 '6#/*+6'*"!,: ( @&(#$&*"#$'% ! '&%8%"!, /($(&6% '#$&%>*G$#, ' &*)($*: 5>%"6: XIX '%/*, '6#/*+6'*"!,:, /*/ @&*'!4(, "* E4%8%"$*&"(8 5&('"% ("$(4(;%8, "%!+)%?%" +"*>!$%4<"6. "*4%$ 58(+&!$%4<"(#$!. J*/, K.M. */#'%44 ($8%>*4, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( «8*$%&!,», /*/ $*/('*,, "%@&%8%""( 1(4?"* !8%$< (@&%1%4%""6% #'(.#$'* – #5F%#$'('*$< "%@&%&6'"( ' @&(#$&*"#$'% ! '&%8%"!» (231, #. 163). L$5 ! @(1()"6% %. A!4(#(A#/!% !#$!"6 5>%"6%, @( 8"%"!G K.M. */#'%44*, !#@(4<+5G$ ' #'(%. &*)($% 14, 2%4! 1%15/2!!, "( ("! «"!>%;( "% 1*G$ 14, &*+8674%"!, () !: @&(!#:(?1%"!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 164). B&! '#%: (;('(&/*: ! @(,#"%"!,: "%#(8"%""(. (#$*%$#, '(+8(?"(#$< (1"(+"*>"(. A!4(#(A#/(. !1%"$!A!/*2!! @&!"2!@!*4<"(. @(+!2!! 5>%"6: ' @("!8*"!! @&(#$&*"#$'* ! '&%8%"!. C >*#$"(#$!, (>%'!1"*, 8*$%&!*4!#$!>"(#$< E$(;( @("!8*"!, ()"*&5?!'*%$#, @&%?1% '#%;( ' @&!+"*"!! &%*4!+*2!! @&(#$&*"#$'* ! '&%8%"! ' /*>%#$'% (),+*$%4<"6: A(&8 #5F%#$'('*"!, 8*$%&!!, "%():(1!86: 5#4('!. )6$!, '#%: @&%18%$(' ! ,'4%"!. &%*4<"(. 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!. «R%$ @&(#$&*"#$'* )%+ 8*$%&!!, "%$ 8*$%&!! )%+ @&(#$&*"#$'*», – 5$'%&?1*4 D. QG:"%& (52, #. 3132). «C#% #('%&7*GF%%#, '( '"%7"%8 8!&%, – @!#*4 H. . P%>%"(', – #('%&7*%$#, ' @&(#$&*"#$'% ! '( '&%8%"!» (335, #. 378). V1%#< "*4!2( @&,8(% #('@*1%"!% # 5#$*"('4%"!,8! 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!!, 14, /($(&(., @( #4('*8 D. 0%.%&)*:*, «2$!1-$%"1-9! ! 9$*:( #(#$*'4,G$ A(&86 )6$!, '#%;( #5F%;(. J(4%#$'% (#"('"6: A(&8 #5F%#$'('*"!, 8*$%&!! "%():(1!8( @&!'(1!4( 5>%"6: / @&!+"*"!G !%&%1< $%8, >$( %#$%#$'(+"*"!%, ;('(&, #4('*8! C.H. D%"!"*, «"% '6:(1!$ +* @&%1%46 '&%8%"! ! @&(#$&*"#$'*, +* @&%1%46 8*$%&!*4<"(;( 8!&*» (204, #. 186). L$( @&!"2!@!*4<"(% ()#$(,$%4<#$'( ()5#4('!4( ()F"(#$< A!4(#(A#/(;( ! %#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8*. «B&!+"*'*, #5F%#$'('*"!% ()I%/$!'"(. &%*4<"(#$!, $( %#$< 1'!?5F%.#, 8*$%&!!, "%+*'!#!8( ($ "*7%;( #(+"*"!,, 8*$%&!*4!+8 "%!+)%?"( 1(4?%" @&!+"*'*$< $*/?% ()I%/$!'"5G &%*4<"(#$< '&%8%"! ! @&(#$&*"#$'*» ($*8 ?%, #. 181). J*/, H. . P%>%"(', #(@(#$*'4,, «@&(#$&*"#$'(» ! «&%*4<"(#$<», @(1>%&/"54, >$( «@(",$!% «@&(#$&*"#$'%""(%» '#%;1* +*/4G>*%$#, ' @(",$!! «&%*4<"(8» /*/ >*#$< ' 2%4(8» (335, #. 276). O#@%:! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ' !##4%1('*"!! 8*$%&!*4<"6: ()I%/$(' ! !: #(#$(,"!. 5/&%@4,4! 5)%?1%"!% 5>%"6: ' ()I%/$!'"(. &%*4<"(#$! (#"('"6: A(&8 #5F%#$'('*"!, 8*$%&!!. J*/, "*@&!8%&, L. =%//%4G E$! 5#@%:! @(+'(4!4! #1%4*$< '6'(1: «-%*4<"(#$< @&(#$&*"#$'* ! '&%8%"! ' "*#$(,F%% '&%8, (/(">*$%4<"( 1(/*+*"*» (95, #. 286). -%*4<"(#$< @&(#$&*"#$'* ,'"( ()"*&5?!'*%$#, ' %;( $&%:8%&"(#$!. « *$%&!,, – @!#*4 P%>%"(', – '#%;1* +*@(4",%$ @&(#$&*"#$'(, !+8%&!8(% ' $&%: "*@&*'4%"!,:» (335, #. 187). H
243
%F% ( $(8 ?%: «C#% @&%18%$6 '"%7"%;( 8!&* !8%G$ $&! !+8%&%"!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 122). K4, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/* #$*4* (>%'!1"(. ! "%#(#$(,$%4<"(#$< )6$('*'7!: &*"%% ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!! @&%1#$*'4%"!. ( @5#$(8, 4!7%""(8 8*$%&!! @&(#$&*"#$'%. J*/, R.9. O8(' ($'%&; "*'75G "*4!>!% 8%?15 $%4*8! @&(8%?5$(>"(. 8*$%&!*4<"(. #&%16. C #',+! # E$!8 (", ' >*#$"(#$!, @!#*4: «J%@%&< !1%, ( '(+8(?"(#$! '+*!8(1%.#$'!, 8%?15 $%4*8! "* &*##$(,"!! )%+ @(#&%1#$'5GF%. #&%16, '#%;1* @&($!'"*, 585 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,, (#$*'4%"* "*5/(.… K%.#$'!% "% @%&%1*%$#, >%&%+ @5#$($5, * $(4%&%+ 8*$%&!G» (364, #. 107). O8(' #>!$*4, >$( "%$ @5#$(;( @&(#$&*"#$'*, "%+*@(4"%""(;( 8*$%&!%.. H @(#/(4%#/(. 8%&(. 1'!?%"!, @(#4%1"%. ,'4,%$#, E"%&;!,, $( '+*!8(#',+< ! '+*!8(1%.#$'!% 8%?15 %% &*+4!>"68! A(&8*8! ()5#4('4%"6 @&(8%?5$(>"(. 8*$%&!*4<"(. #&%1(.. R* "%'(+8(?"(#$! @5#$(;( @&(#$&*"#$'*, "* %;(, @&(#$&*"#$'*, "%&*+1%4<"(#$! # 8*$%&!%., "*&,15 # R.9. O8('68, "*#$*!'*4! ! 1&5;!% '!1"%.7!% 5>%"6% '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/*. J*/, K.H. %"1%4%%', (@&%1%4,, 8*$%&!G, @(1>%&/"54: %G «"*+6'*G$ $(, >$(, "*@(4",, @&(#$&*"#$'(, !8%%$ '%#» (260, #. 590). B( 8"%"!G H. . P%>%"('*, «'%#< '"%7"!. 8!& @&%1#$*'4,%$#, >%4('%/5 @&(#$&*"#$'(8, "*@(4"%""68 &*+1%4<"68! @&%18%$*8!. H4!, >$( $( ?%, ;&5@@(. @&%18%$(', !+ /($(&6: /*?1(85 @&!#5F* @&($,?%""(#$< ! !+'%#$"(% ($"(#!$%4<"(% @(4(?%"!%» (335, #. 378). 3$/*+ ($ @&%1#$*'4%"!. ( @5#$(8 '&%8%"! ! @5#$(8 @&(#$&*"#$'% ,'!4#, 14, 5>%"6: #5F%#$'%""68 @(1$'%&?1%"!%8 ,'"(. 8*$%&!*4!#$!>"(#$! !: A!4(#(A#/!: '(++&%"!.. U*&*/$%&"( ' E$(8 ($"(7%"!! #4%15GF%% '6#/*+6'*"!% =%//%4,: «P>*#$4!'( 5@&*+1"!' "%#(#$(,$%4<"(% @&%1#$*'4%"!% ( «@5#$(8 @&(#$&*"#$'%», 86 $%@%&< (#$*4!#< @&! )%#/("%>"(., «+*@(4",GF%. @&(#$&*"#$'( #&%1%», 8*$%&!!… P 1&5;(. #$(&("6, 86 #>!$*%8 «'&%8, +*@(4",GF!8 ,'4%"!%8» '%>"(% 1'!?%"!%, '6&*?*GF%%#, ' "%@&%&6'"(. E'(4G2!! #5)#$*"2!!» (95, #. 286). J*/(% @("!8*"!% @&(#$&*"#$'* ! '&%8%"! @&!)4!?*4( '+;4,16 5>%"6: ' 1*""(8 '(@&(#% / @("!8*"!G #(($"(7%"!, 8*$%&!! ! A(&8 %% #5F%#$'('*"!, ' 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!!. 0. L";%4<# ( @&(#$&*"#$'% ! '&%8%"! @!#*4, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( «()% E$! A(&86 #5F%#$'('*"!, 8*$%&!! )%+ 8*$%&!! #5$< "!>$(, @5#$6% @&%1#$*'4%"!,, *)#$&*/2!!» (406, #. 550). R( %F% )(4%%, >%8 +* 100 4%$ 1( E$(;( *"*4(;!>"5G 86#4<, /*/ "%>$( #*8( #()(. &*+58%GF%%#,, ($#$*!'*4! A&*"25+#/!% A!4(#(A6–8*$%&!*4!#$6. M.9. =%4<'%2!., "*@&!8%&, #>!$*4, >$( «@&(#$&*"#$'(, '+,$(% ($'4%>%""( (($ 8*$%&!!. – C.3.), %#$< >!#$(% "!>$(» (99, #. 173). K. J(4*"1, /*#*,#< E$(;( '(@&(#*, @!#*4: «X "% 8(;5 @('%&!$< ' *)#(4G$"(% @&(#$&*"#$'(, #5F%#$'5GF%% ,/()6 ($1%4<"( ($ 8*$%&!! ! '8%F*GF%% %% ' #%),, /*/ "% 8(;5 @('%&!$< ! $(85, >$( %#$< *)#(4G$"(% '&%8,, ($(&'*""(% ($ '%F%., ( 14!$%4<"(#$! /($(&6: !1%$
244
&%><» (7, #. 165). P4%1('*$%4<"(, ! ' 1*""(8 #45>*% "*4!2( (@%&%?%"!% 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!%. %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ' 5#$*"('4%"!! 8!&('(++&%">%#/!: (#"('(@(4(?%"!. ' @("!8*"!! 8*$%&!! ! A(&8 %% #5F%#$'('*"!,. J( ?% #*8(% @&(,'!4(#< ! ' &%7%"!! '(@&(#* ( 9*0"!1-' 8*$%&!! '( '&%8%"! ! %% <*16!"*0"!1-' ' @&(#$&*"#$'%. K. J(4*"1, !+4*;*, #'(! @&!"2!@!*4<"6% 5#$*"('/! ' E$(8 '(@&(#%, @!#*4: «M(;1* 86 ;('(&!8, >$( @&(#$&*"#$'( '#%()I%84GF%, 86 !8%%8 ' '!15 )%#/("%>"5G 8*$%&!G… M(;1* 86 ;('(&!8, >$( @&(#$&*"#$'( %1!"(, 86 !8%%8 ' '!15 %;( )%#/("%>"(#$< ! "%1%4!8(#$<, !)( %#$< $(4!#4%""(% 8"(?%#$'( 8!&('… M(;1* 86 5$'%&?1*%8, >$( ("( (@&(#$&*"#$'(. – C. 3.) (1"(&(1"(, 86 !8%%8 ' '!15, >$( 8*$%&!, '#%;1* (1"* ! $* ?%, /*/ )6 "! )64! &*+"(()&*+"6 %% 8(1!A!/*2!!… Q%#/("%>"*, 8*$%&!, ! %#$< &%*4<"(% @&(#$&*"#$'( ! '8%#$!4!F%, * $*/?% &%*4<"6. #5)I%/$ #'(!: #()#$'%""6: >*#$%. 8(1!A!/*2!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 184-185). « !&('(% @&(#$&*"#$'(, – @!#*4 L. =%//%4< @(>$! 1'* #$(4%$!, #@5#$,, – )%#/("%>"( '%4!/( ! "% !8%%$ ;&*"!2… C&%8, $*/?% )%#/("%>"( ! )%+;&*"!>"(: ("( "% !8%%$ "! "*>*4*, "! /("2*, ("( %#$< '%>"(#$<» (95, #. 282). B( 8"%"!G D. QG:"%&*, «%#4! 8*$%&!, )%#/("%>"* '( '&%8%"!, $( %#$< )%##8%&$"*, $( ("* $(>"( $*/ ?% "% !8%%$ "! "*>*4*, "! /("2* ! ' @&(#$&*"#$'%» (52, #. 22). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, ' @("!8*"!! 8*$%&!!, %% '"5$&%""%;( #$&(%"!,, %% 1'!?%"!,, #5F%#$'('*"!, ' @&(#$&*"#$'% ! '&%8%"! 8*$%&!*4!#$!>"(#$< '(++&%"!. '61*GF!:#, 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* @&(,'!4*#< #( '#%. (>%'!1"(#$$( (#()%""( '*?"(, E$* 8*$%&!*4!#$!>"(#$< 8!&('(++&%"!, 5>%"6: "% ,'!4*#< >%8-$( #$(&(""!8 @( ($"(7%"!G / !: "*5>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$!. 3"* #45?!4* "%():(1!868 #&%1#$'(8 @(+"*"!, ' !: !##4%1('*"!,:, !8%4* )(4<7(% 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/(% +"*>%"!% 14, !: "%@(#&%1#$'%""(. !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. &*)($6. *$%&!,, /*/ ()F%% "*>*4( '#%;( #5F%#$'5GF%;(, @&%1#$*'4,4* #()(. /("%>"5G 2%4< !##4%1('*"!. 5>%"6:, !4!, ;('(&, #4('*8! H. . P%>%"('*, «!1%*4<"5G $(>/5, ' #$(&("5 /($(&(. "*@&*'4%"6 !: 5#!4!,» (335, #. 188). C #'(!: !##4%1('*"!,: 5>%"6% $*/ !4! !"*>% &5/('(1#$'('*4!#< ()F!8! '(++&%"!,8! "* 8*$%&!G, @%&%:(1, ($ E$!: '(++&%"!. / !+5>%"!G ! @("!8*"!G >*#$"6: ,'4%"!., "* @(+"*"!% /($(&6: "*@&*'4,4*#< !: "%@(#&%1#$'%""*, "*5>"*, 1%,$%4<"(#$<. */#'%44 @!#*4, ' >*#$"(#$!: «J(, >$( 8*$%&!,, /*/ $*/('*,, "%@&%8%""( 1(4?"* !8%$< (@&%1%4%""6% #'(.#$'* – #5F%#$'('*$< "%@&%&6'"( ' @&(#$&*"#$'% ! '&%8%"!, >$( '#,/(% 1%.#$'!% %#$< '+*!8(1%.#$'!% 8%?15 1'58, >*#$,8! 8*$%&!! ! $.1. – !#$!"6 $*/(;( @(&,1/*, /($(&6% 8%$*A!+!/! #>!$*G$ "%!+)%?"68!. 6 8(?%8 !#@(4<+('*$< E$! !#$!"6 14, 2%4%. 1%15/2!!» (231, #. 163-164). J*/*, (@(&* %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* "* ()F%% @(",$!% 8*$%&!!, "* @(",$!,, '6&*?*GF!% %% ()F!% #'(.#$'*, (@&%1%4,4*#< @&%?1% '#%;( $%8, >$( (#"('5 E$!: !1%*4<"6: ()&*+('*"!. #(#$*'4,G$ &%*4<"6% 8*$%&!*4<"6% ()I%/$6, !: &%*4<"6% #',+! !
245
($"(7%"!,, "* @(+"*"!% /($(&6: ! "*@&*'4,4*#< "%@(#&%1#$'%""*, !##4%1('*$%4<#/*, 1%,$%4<"(#$< 5>%"6:. «C#,/!. "*$5&*4!#$, – @!#*4 H. . P%>%"(', – @&! '#%: #'(!: !##4%1('*"!,: @(#$(,""( (@!&*%$#, "* $*/ "*+6'*%86% ()F!% #'(.#$'* 8*$%&!!, $*/ /*/ ' (#"('% !: 4%?*$ &%*4<"6% A*/$6, !4! ($"(7%"!,» (335, #. 188). C#4%1#$'!% E$(;( @(",$!% 8*$%&!! @&(>"( 5$'%&1!4(#< ' #!#$%8% '+;4,1(' %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* ! /*/ (),+*$%4<"6. E4%8%"$ !: 8!&('(++&%"!,, ! /*/ E4%8%"$ 8%$(1(4(;!! !: %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: !##4%1('*"!.. R% #45>*."( @(E$(85 P%>%"(' @(1>%&/!'*4, >$( «"!/$( !+ "*$5&*4!#$(' "% @(#,;*%$ "* 8*$%&!G» ($*8 ?%). L$( #'!1%$%4<#$'('*4( @&%?1% '#%;( ( @&(>"(#$! 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!: 5#$*"('(/ ' 8!&('(++&%"!! 5>%"6: – ' $(. %;( >*#$!, /($(&*, /*#*4*#< @("!8*"!, 8*$%&!! /*/ @%&'((#"('6 '#%;( #5F%#$'5GF%;(. Q4!+(#$< %#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* # 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 A!4(#(A#/!8 @&(,'!4*#< +1%#< (#()%""( @(4"(. R( "*1(, /("%>"(, &*+4!>*$< )4!+(#$< '"5$&%""GG ! '"%7"GG, $( %#$< )4!+(#$< @( #(1%&?*"!G ! @( A(&8% %;( '6&*?%"!,. B&!8%"!$%4<"( / $*/!8 /*$%;(&!,8, /*/ «8*$%&!,», * $*/?% «1'!?%"!%», «@&(#$&*"#$'(», «'&%8,»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«8*$%&!,», «1'!?%"!%», «@&(#$&*"#$'(», «'&%8,», >$( '6&*?*G$ 1*""6% @(",$!,, /*/(. #86#4 ' "!: '/4*16'*%$#, – '( '#%8 E$(8 &*+4!>!, "%!+)%?"6. «X+6/, "* /($(&(8 '6&*?*G$#, A!+!/!, – @!#*4 B. D*"?%'%", – "%&%1/( ($4!>*%$#, ($ ,+6/* A!4(#(A('» (194, #. 477). K4, A(&86 '6&*?%"!, 86#4! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., 1*?% ! ' A!4(#(A#/(8 @4*"%, :*&*/$%&"* $*/ !4! !"*>% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"*, !4! ()61%""*, (/&*#/* @(",$!., #4('. W% @(1>*# $&51"( '61%4!$<, '6>4%"!$<; ("* #/(&%% >5'#$'5%$#,, "%?%4! A%"(8%"!+!&5%$#, ' /*/!:-4!)( ,+6/('6: %1!"!2*:. V1%#< "*4!2( (@&%1%4%""6. #5)I%/$!'"6. 8(8%"$, 5:(1,F!. ' @#!:(4(;!G. C #A%&% ?% ,+6/* #('@*1*%$ +*>*#$5G 4!7< '"%7"(#$< #4(': ! ' %#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/(8 ! A!4(#(A#/(8 8*$%&!*4!+8% – «8*$%&!,», «1'!?%"!%» ! 1&5;!% ()F!% @(",$!,. R( +* "!8!, @(1 "!8!, ' "!: – 86#4< ! 86#4< +*>*#$5G &*+"*,. 31"*/( ?% "* @('%&:"(#$< #4('(5@($&%)4%"!, ("* «'6$*4/!'*%$» (1"! ! $% ?% @(",$!, !+ !+'%#$"(;( '#%8 #4('*&"(;( +*@*#*. P4%1('*$%4<"(, @&*'!4<"%% +1%#< ;('(&!$< "% #$(4%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ! A!4(#(A('–8*$%&!*4!#$(' ' ($"(7%"!! / 8*$%&!! ! A(&8*8 %% #5F%#$'('*"!,, #/(4"(8 #>%$%, ' @4*"% @&*/$!>%#/!: #4%1#$'!., #$*"('!4(#<
246
'(+8(?"68 ! 5#@%7"(% &%7%"!% (1"(. !+ '*?"%.7!:, ' @("!8*"!! R.9. O8('*, 1!+'%78".D +*1*> %#$%#$'(+"*"!, – +*1*>! «5$'%&?1*$< '4*#$< >%4('%/* "*1 E"%&;!%., '&%8%"%8, @&(#$&*"#$'(8» (364, #. 390). L$(, /("%>"(, +*1*>* "* '#% '&%8%"*, ! %% @(#$%@%""(%, @(E$*@"(% (#5F%#$'4%"!% @&%1@(4*;*%$ "* /*?1(8 !#$(&!>%#/(8 E$*@% #(($'%$#$'5GF!. 5&('%"< %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( +"*"!, ! A!4(#(A#/(;( @("!8*"!, 8*$%&!!, %% #$&(%"!,, %% 1'!?%"!, ' @&(#$&*"#$'% ! '&%8%"! ! $.@., #4('(8, '#%;( $(;(, >$( &%*4!+5%$#, ' @&!&(1%, ' %% ()I%/$!'"6: ,%6!"%D. M*/ @(1>%&/"54 M. Q%&"*&, «86 8(?%8 5@&*'4,$< ,'4%"!,8! @&!&(16, $(4!",,#< ;(#@(1#$'5GF!8 ' "%. +*/("*8» (29, #. 55). § 8. ';<2E2BD8E24FO >8=827K: ED2HQ27=B24FO = >8=I=EE24FO K'!?%"!% 8*$%&!! ' @&(#$&*"#$'% ! '&%8%"! ' 8*#7$*)*: '#%;( '"%7"%;( 8!&* %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! XIX '%/* &*##8*$&!'*4! /*/ @&!&(1"6. 2$!+*11, (@&%1%4,%86. ! "*@&*'4,%86. 1%.#$'!%8 %#$%#$'%""6: ,%6!"!9. M. 0(;$, "*@&!8%&, ' #',+! # E$!8 ($8%$!4, >$( «@&%?1% #5F%#$'('*4* A(&8* 8*$%&!!, @&%'&*F%"!% /($(&(. ' %% "*#$(,F%% #(#$(,"!% #('%&7!4(#<… @5$%8 %#$%#$'%""(;( +*/("*» (377, #. 13). B&! E$(8 0(;$ @(@6$*4#, (@&%1%4!$< #*85 #5$< +*/("*. R* #'(. ?% '(@&(#: «R( >$( ?% "*+6'*%8 86 '(()F% +*/("(8?», (" ($'%$!4: «B(&,1(/, ' /($(&(8 '!1!8 "%!+8%""(% (1"(()&*+!% ! @(#$(,"#$'(» ($*8 ?%, #. 11). 3$#G1* #4%15%$, >$( 5*=1-9'* %#$%#$'%""6: +*/("(' '( '"%7"%8 8!&% @&%1#$*%$ /*/ #@("$*""*, &%*4!+*2!, #!#$%8"(. ;2!$(5!0*""!1-' ' "%8, ' %;( #(#$*'"6: >*#$,:, /*/ (@&%1%4%""*, "*@&*'4%""(#$< 1'!?%"!, ' &*8/*: !88*"%"$"(;(, #*8(1%,$%4<"(;( ;2$%97*"'(. C E$(8 #45>*%, @!7%$ 0(;$, «#!#$%85 8!&(5@&*'4%"!, 86 )51%8 @("!8*$< ! !+5>*$< /*/ ,%6!"» ($*8 ?%, #. 333). P*8* ?% /("2%@2!, +*/("* @&!&(16 &*#/&6'*4*#< ! ()(#"('6'*4*#< 0(;$(8 ! 1&5;!8! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8! "* ,'"( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. (#"('% # (@(&(. "* /("/&%$"6. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. 8*$%&!*4. *$%&!*4!#$!>"(#$< @("!8*"!, 5>%"68! +*/("(' @&!&(16 '6&*+!4!#< @&%?1% '#%;( ' @&!+"*"!! !%4('%/*, #5)I%/$* @(+"*"!, ! @&*/$!>%#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$!. M*/ &*+I,#",4 K. J!"1*4<, «"*5/* $&%)5%$ !#/(&%"%"!, '#,/(;( @&(!+'(4*, @&($!'(@(#$*'4,, %85 )%+5#4('"5G '%&5 ' #!45 +*/("* @&!&(16» (358, #. 108). «V*/("6 @&!&(16, – @!#*4 =. =%4<8;(4<2, – ,'4,G$#, 14, "*# >5?1(. #!4(., 86 "% 8(?%8 '6)!&*$< !: @&(!+'(4<"( ! 5#$*"*'4!'*$< !: ' "*7%8 8674%"!!» (108, #. 47). B&(,'4%"!, +*/("(' '( '"%7"%. @&!&(1% @&%1#$*G$ )%+ !: @&!>!""(#4%1#$'%""(. #',+! # '"5$&%""!8 8!&(8 >%4('%/*, # %;( #5)I%/$!'"(#$$( '6&*?*%$#, +*/("(8, #>!$*4 =%4<8;(4<2, "*#$5@*%$ «"%+*'!#!8( ($ "*7%;(
247
@&%1#$*'4%"!,, "%+*'!#!8( ($ "*7!: ?%4*"!.… 6 "% ' #(#$(,"!! (/*+*$< "!/*/(;( '4!,"!, "* $%>%"!% '"%7"!: @&(2%##(' @(#&%1#$'(8 @&%1#$*'4%"!., @&($%/*GF!: ' #(+"*"!! (1"('&%8%""( # E$!8! @&(2%##*8!» (113, #. 77). B( 8"%"!G D. QG:"%&*, +*/("6 @&!&(16 «"%1(#$5@"6 "!/*/(85 @&(!+'(45 !4! '"%7"%85 '8%7*$%4<#$'5» (52, #. 56). J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' "%(&;*"!>%#/(. @&!&(1% A!+!>%#/!% ! :!8!>%#/!% #!46 '%F%#$', @( #4('*8 =%4<8;(4<2*, «1%.#$'5G$ )%+ @%&%&6'* ! )%+ @&(!+'(4*», «!: #$&(;*, +*/("(8%&"(#$< "% "*&57*%$#, "! "* (1"( 8;"('%"!%» (108, #. 57). 3)(#"('6'*, E$( 5#$*"('4%"!% "* @&!8%&% /("/&%$"(. @(+"*'*$%4<"(. #!$5*2!!, /*#*GF%.#, !"$%&@&%$*2!! «#!46» ' $(8 %% @("!8*"!!, /($(&(% )64( &*#@&(#$&*"%"( ' A!+!/% %;( '&%8%"!, =%4<8;(4<2 @(1>%&/"54, >$( «#!4* %#$< ()I%/$!'!&('*""6. +*/(" 1%.#$'!,. P!4*, (@&%1%4,%8*, "*4!>"(#$%#/!. #86#4 E$(;( &*'%"#$'* +*/4G>*%$#, ' #4%15GF%8 +*/("%: @&!#5$#$'!% $*/!:-$( ! $*/!:$( 8*##, @&! ($#5$#$'!! '#%: @&(>!:, '6+6'*%$ $*/!%-$( ! $*/!%-$( 5#/(&%"!, ($1%4<"6: $(>%/ E$!: 8*##». C A!4(#(A#/(8 #86#4% +1%#< "*!)(4%% #5F%#$'%""( $( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, >$( «+*/(" E$($ "% @&!158*" "*8! @&(!+'(4<"(, "( >$( (" ()"*&5?!'*%$#, ' #*8!: ,'4%"!,: @&!&(16, /*/ "%>$( )%+5#4('"( "%():(1!8(%» ($*8 ?%, #. 48). J(>"( $*/ ?% ! ' (&;*"!>%#/(. @&!&(1% E$* )%+5#4('"*, "%():(1!8(#$< +*/("(' @&(,'4,%$#, # $(. ?% "%@&%4(?"(#$$( ! )64( #( '#%. (>%'!1"(#$%#/(;( 8*$%&!*4*. C E$(8 @4*"% $%(&!, K*&'!"*, @( 8"%"!G =%4<8;(4<2*, #(1%&?!$ ' #%)% $( #5F%#$'%""( "('(%, >$( «("* @(/*+6'*%$, /*/!8 ()&*+(8 2%4%#(()&*+"(#$< ' ()&*+('*"!! (&;*"!+8(' 8(?%$ '(+"!/"5$< )%+ '8%7*$%4<#$'* &*+58* @&! @(8(F! #4%@(;( 1%.#$'!, +*/("* @&!&(16» ($*8 ?%, #. 58). H '(()F%, /*/ )6 &*+4!>"6, @(1'!?"6, !+8%">!'6 ! 7*$/! "! )64! @&%18%$6 '"%7"%;( 8!&*, #>!$*4 X. (4%7($$, «!: #5F"(#$< ! 1'!?%"!%, @%&%8%"6 ! /(4%)*"!, #(($'%$#$'5G$ +*/("*8 @&!&(16, (#"('*""68 '#%;1* ! '#G15 "* "%():(1!8(#$!» (275, #. 197-198). B&(1(4?*, 1*4%% E$5 ()F5G 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/5G 4!"!G A!4(#(A#/(. !"$%&@&%$*2!! +*/("(' @&!&(16 ' @4*"% &*#/&6$!, !: ()I%/$!'"(#$! @( ($"(7%"!G / >%4('%/5, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4!, !#:(1, !+ ("$(4(;!>%#/(. !1%! '%>"(#$! ! )%#/("%>"(#$! 8*$%&!*4<"(. '#%4%""(., @&!:(1!4! / '6'(15 ( 91*!%&/"54 ! M. Q%&"*&, «'#% ,'4%"!,, /*/(;( )6 ("! "! )64! @(&,1/*, #('%&7*G$#, @( "%!+8%""68 +*/("*8 @&!&(16…» (29, #. 57). J(>"( $*/ ?%, @( 8"%"!G K*&'!"*, «'#% ' @&!&(1%
248
,'4,%$#, &%+54<$*$(8 $'%&16: +*/("('» (139, #. 100). L. =%//%4<, '6&*?*, 58("*#$&(%"!, 5>%"6:, #',+*""6% # 1(#$!?%"!,8! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, @!#*4: « 6 @&!:(1!8 / 5)%?1%"!G '( '#%8!&"(8 %1!"#$'% @&!&(16 ! '%>"(. (),+*$%4<"(#$! %% +*/("('» (95, #. 406). K.H. %"1%4%%' $(?% '6&*?*4 «5'%&%""(#$< '( '#%()F"(#$! ()F!: +*/("(' @&!&(16» (260, #. 578). H. . P%>%"(' ($8%>*4, >$( ,'4%"!, 8*$%&!*4<"(;( 8!&* @(1>!"%"6 «"%@&%4(?"68 +*/("*8» (335, #. 23). B(",$"(, >$( E$* '#%()F"(#$< ! (),+*$%4<"(#$<, "%@&%4(?"(#$< ()I%/$!'"6: +*/("(' &*#@&(#$&*",4*#< %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8! "% $(4"(. 8*$%&!*4<"(. '#%4%""(.. «J*/!8 ()&*+(8, – @!#*4 M. 0(;$, – '#% '@(4"% @(1>!",%$#, (1"(85 "*>*45: "%)%#"6% $%4* ()&*+5G$#, ' #!45 +*/("(', ' #!45 +*/("(' #$*"(',$#, ("!, – /(;1* "*#$5@*%$ '&%8,, – *&%"(. 14, &*#$!$%4<"(. ! ?!'($"(. ?!+"!; (F5F%"!,, #/4(""(#$!, 58 – '#% &*+'!'*%$#, @(1()"68 ?% ()&*+(8 ! 1%.#$'5%$ "* (#"('*"!! +*/("('» (377, #. 320-322). J(. ?% ("$(4(;!>%#/(. @(1(@4%/(. ()I,#",%$#, @&!+"*"!% 5>%"68! 9*0"!1-' 1%.#$'5GF!: ' @&!&(1% +*/("('. «0(&8* '#%()F"(#$! ' @&!&(1% – E$( ,%6!", ! "!/$( "% ;('(&!$ $*/ 8"(;( ( 9*0"!1-' ,%6!"!9 2$'$!5., /*/ %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4!» (406, #. 549). C @(1$'%&?1%"!% E$!: #4(' 0. L";%4<#* 8(?"( @&!'%#$!, "*@&!8%&, '6#/*+6'*"!% L. =%//%4,, @!#*'7%;( «( )%+5#4('"(. (),+*$%4<"(#$! «'%>"6:, ?%4%+"6:, '%4!/!: +*/("('» 14, '#%. '#%4%""(.» (95, #. 406). D. QG:"%& $*/?% @(1>%&/!'*4, >$( +*/("6 @&!&(16 «1(4?"( #>!$*$< $*/!8! ?% '%>"68!, /*/ #*85 8*$%&!G ! @&!&(15» (52, #. 56). L$( ()F*, >%&$* 8*$%&!*4!+8* – ! A!4(#(A#/(;(, ! %#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/(;( – @&!+"*"!% $(;(, >$(, /*/ @!#*4 0. L";%4<#, «"!>%;( "% '%>"(, /&(8% '%>"( !+8%",GF%.#,, '%>"( 1'!?5F%.#, 8*$%&!! ! +*/("(' %% 1'!?%"!, ! !+8%"%"!,» (406, #. 362-363). -*"%%, %F% ' XVIII '%/%, ' @&%1%4*: @(+"*'*$%4<"6: '(+8(?"(#$%. A!4(#(A!! $(;( '&%8%"!, E$5 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/5G /("2%@2!G +*/("* '61'!"54 ! ()(#"('*4 =(4<)*:; ' %% ("$(4(;!>%#/(8 *#@%/$% @&!8%"!$%4<"( / 8*$%&!! ! %% #5F%#$'('*"!G (" $*/?% '61%4,4 «'%>"6% +*/("6 @&!&(16», #>!$*4 @&! E$(8, >$( @&!&(1* «#5F%#$'5%$ "%():(1!868 ()&*+(8; '#% @&!#5F!% %. 1%.#$'!, (@&%1%4,G$#, +*/("*8!, '6$%/*GF!8! !+ '"5$&%""!: #'(.#$' &*+4!>"6: +*/4G>*GF!:#, ' "%. #5F%#$' ! !+ ()#$(,$%4<#$', "%!+)%?"( #(+1*'*%86: )%#@&%&6'"68 1'!?%"!%8» (126, #. 495). =(4<)*: ($'%&;*4 /*/5G )6 $( "! )64( *"$&(@(8(&A"(#$< +*/("('(@4(F%"!. ' @&!&(1%, !: @&!>!" ! "%@(#&%1#$'%""6: #(#$(,"!., 5$'%&?1*,, >$( 5 @&!&(16 «"%$ "! &*+58*, "! 2%4!; ("* 1%.#$'5%$ ' #!45 "%():(1!8(#$!, $*/ /*/ #5F%#$'5%$ "%():(1!868 ()&*+(8. W% +*/("6 "%!+8%""6 ! (#"('*"6 "* #*8(. #5F"(#$! '%F%.» ($*8 ?%, #. 493).
249
=(4<)*: @(1>%&/!'*4 $*/?% 91*!$( E$! +*/("6 !5?1(. #'%&:I%#$%#$'%""(. #!4(., "( !88*"%"$"( @&!#5F! %. #*8(.. «C#% $%4* 1%.#$'5G$ #(;4*#"( +*/("*8, "%($1%4!868 ($ !: #()#$'%""(. #5F"(#$!, ! "! "* 8;"('%"!% "% 8(;5$ ($/4("!$<#, ($ +*/("(', #(;4*#"( /($(&68 1%.#$'5%$ #*8* @&!&(1*» ($*8 ?%, #. 12). 3)I%/$!'"*, +*/("(8%&"(#$< @&!&(16, @( 8"%"!G =(4<)*:*, !8%%$ :*&*/$%& "%():(1!8(#$! ! ' /*>%#$'% $*/('(. #(#$*'4,%$ #5F"(#$"(% #(#$(,"!% @&!&(16, (),+*$%4<"(% 5#4('!% ! "*@(4"%"!% %% ?!+"%""(#$!, (4!2%$'(&%"!% #*8(;( %% )6$!,. «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» ($*8 ?%, #. 102-103). C ;"(#%(4(;!>%#/(8 @4*"% =(4<)*: !#:(1!4 !+ @&!+"*"!, @(+"*'*%8(#$! +*/("(' @&!&(16; (", ' >*#$"(#$!, @!#*4: « 6 +"*%8… @&(#$6% ! '#%()F!% +*/("6, #(;4*#"( /($(&68 1'!?5$#, $%4*» ($*8 ?%, #. 94). B&! E$(8 ' 1'!?%"!! @(+"*"!,, E/#$&*@(4!&5, @&!"2!@!*4<"5G @(+"*'*%8(#$< +*/("(' @&!&(16 ! "* !: )515F%% +"*"!%, =(4<)*: &*##8*$&!'*4 !: @(1 5;4(8 +&%"!, &%*4!+*2!! E'&!#$!>%#/(. A5"/2!! "*4!>"(;( +*/("('6&*?*GF%;( +"*"!,, ()(#"('6'*, '(+8(?"(#$< ($/&6$< "* %;( (#"('% "('6% +*/("6 @&!&(16. «V*/("6 %#$%#$'%""6: ,'4%"!., /($(&6% 86 ' #(#$(,"!! @(+"*$< ! ( /($(&6: 8(?%8 #(#$*'!$< #%)% #5?1%"!%, 1(#$*$(>"6 14, ($/&6$!, +*/("(', 5#/(4<+*GF!: ($ "*7%;( "*)4G1%"!,. C( '#,/(8 #45>*% ( @(#4%1"!: 8(?"( #51!$< @( *"*4(;!! # @%&'68! ! %#4! 86 #$*"%8 '"!8*$%4<"( !+5>*$< @&!&(15, $( &*#/&6'*%86% %G @&(2%##6 "*5>*$ "*# "% @&!:(1!$< ' +*8%7*$%4<#$'( ! @%&%1 $%8! @&(2%##*8!, /($(&6% ("* #/&6'*%$ ($ "*#» ($*8 ?%, #. 93). O>%"6%–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– E$( "% $(4"*,,
250
4(/*4!+('*""*, ' @&(#$&*"#$'% ! '&%8%"! #*8(#$<, "( ! /("/&%$!+!&('*""(%, )6$!."( '(@4(F%""(% @&%$'(&%"!% ! '6&*?%"!% +*/("*. B(E$(85 @(+"*"!% $%: !4! !"6: /("/&%$"6: ,'4%"!. ! @&(2%##(' @&!&(16 /*/ A*/$(' 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! – E$( "% #$(4"(;( @(+"*"!, X. (4%7($$ ()&*$!4 '"!8*"!% "* $( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, >$( «=*4!4%. @%&'6. '6+'*4 / ?!+"! $*/(;( &(1* (@6$, /($(&6. 8(?%$ +*#$*'4,$< @&!&(15 ($/&6'*$< A*/$6, '6,#",GF!% "*8 +*/("6, 5@&*'4,GF!% ,'4%"!,8! "* '#%: #$5@%",: !: &*+'!$!,» (276, #. 163). J*/ ?% ! =. =%4<8;(4<2, :*&*/$%&!+5, /("/&%$"5G #!$5*2!G ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!!, @!#*4: «B%&'6. /&5@"6. @&!8%& @(1>!"%"!, ()7!&"(. ()4*#$! &*+"(&(1"6: A*/$(' (1"(85 ()F%85 +*/("5 86 "*.1%8 ' $%(&%$!>%#/(. 8%:*"!/%, (#"('"6% @(",$!, /($(&(. '@%&'6% ,#"( 5#$*"('!4 =*4!4%.. C(@&(# +*/4G>*4#, $(;1* ' $(8, >$()6 "*.$! '#%()F!% +*/("6» (108, #. 49). M("%>"(, "*:(?1%"!% $*/!: 91*!"(;( @(+"*"!, / "!8 "* &*+"6: 5&('",: A*/$5*4<"(;( +"*"!, '6,'4,%$#, &*+"*, #$%@%"< "*:(1!86: +*/("('. C >*#$"(#$!, 8(;5$ )6$< 5#$*"('4%"6 «+*/("6, (:'*$6'*GF!% $(4$( @(+"*"!% "* E$(8 "% (#$*"*'4!'*%$#,, ! ' %;( @(#4%15GF%8 1'!?%"!! '(+"!/*%$ "%():(1!8(#$< «@%&%.$! ($ "%#/(4"(;( @(+"*"!, ' %;( +*/("(@(#$!;*GF%8 1'!?%"!!, =. =%4<;(4<2 @!#*4: «B&! &*+&%7%"!! "*7%. +*1*>! – ($6#/*"!, +*/("(' ($1%4<"6: ,'4%"!. @&!&(16 – 86 @&%?1% '#%;( 1(4?"6 "*@&*'!$< "*7! 5#!4!, "* ($6#/*"!% +*/("(' '(+8(?"( ()F!:, $( %#$< $*/!:, /($(&6% 1*G$ "*8 '(+8(?"(#$< @("!8*$< '(+8(?"( )(4<7%% >!#4( ($1%4<"6: #45>*%'. N%8 )(4<7% "*8 E$( 51*%$#,, $%8 ;45)?% &*#@&(#$&*",%$#, "*7% +"*"!%» (113, #. 83). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, 5;45)4%"!% +"*"!, "* /*?1(8 E$*@% &*+'!$!, %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% (@&%1%4,%$#, 1(#$!;"5$(. #$%@%""6: A*/$('. L$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'( "*74( ($&*?%"!% ! ' #*8(8 (@&%1%4%"!! +*/("* "*5/! ' %;( #(@&,?%""(#$! # '#%()F!8! +*/("*8! @&!&(16 ! !+5>*%868! A*/$*8! 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!: «V*/(" – @!#*4 =%4<8;(4<2 – %#$< '#%()F%% @(",$!%, @(1 /($(&(% 8(?"( @(1'%#$! &,1 (1"(&(1"( @&($%/*GF!: ,'4%"!. @&!&(16» (108, #. 47). H $(4
251
&%*4!+*2!, (#"('(@(4*;*GF%;( 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/(;( $&%)('*"!,, !88*"%"$"( #(1%&?*F%;(#, ' E$(. 1%A!"!2!! +*/("*, 1%4*%$ '(+8(?"68 !#$!""(% @(#$!?%"!% #5F"(#$! #(@&,?%""6: # +*/("(8 ,'4%"!. @&!&(16, $( %#$< @&(,'4,GF!: E$($ +*/(" A*/$(' 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$!. M*/ @(1>%&/!'*4 ' #',+! # E$!8 D. Q(4<28*", «+*/("(8%&"(#$< ' ,'4%"!,: @&!&(16 ,'4,%$#, (#"('"68 5#4('!%8 !: @("!8*"!,» (35, #. 47). 3@&%1%4,, @(1 E$!8 5;4(8 +&%"!, #(1%&?*"!% ! #*8( @&%1"*+"*>%"!% !##4%1('*$%4<#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., =. =%4<8;(4<2 @!#*4: «R*7* +*1*>* #(#$(!$… ' ($6#/*"!! +*/("(' ,'4%"!. @&!&(16» (113, #. 81). 3$#G1* ! #(($'%$#$'5GF*, ()F*, 2%4%'*, 5#$*"('/* ' ($"(7%"!! '#%;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, %;( (#"('"(. @(+"*'*$%4<"(. "*@&*'4%""(#$!: «V*1*>* %#$%#$'(+"*"!, #'(1!$#, / "*:(?1%"!G +*/("('» (108, #. 55). H # +*1*>%. E$(. %#$%#$'(+"*"!% 5#@%7"( #@&*'4,%$#,. «W#$%#$'(+"*"!%, – @!#*4 R.9. O8(', – ($/&6'*%$ ' @&!&(1% "%/(4%)!86% +*/("6» (364, #. 159). M("/&%$"68 '6&*?%"!%8 ()F%;( @&%1#$*'4%"!, 5>%"6: ( 1%.#$'5GF%. ' @&!&(1% ()I%/$!'"(. +*/("(8%&"(#$! ,'!4(#< @&!+"*"!% !8! 2$'0'""!–17*51-9*""!= 19(,' ,'4%"!., %% ()I%/$!'"(#$! ! 5"!'%&#*4<"(#$!. Q(4<7% $(;(, #*8* +*/("(8%&"(#$< @&!&(16 @("!8*4*#< @&%?1% '#%;( /*/ @&!>!""*, #',+< ,'4%"!.. =%4<8;(4<2, ' >*#$"(#$!, @!#*4: «R*7% $&%)('*"!% 2!"(-8 ,'4%"!,, $( %#$< "*.$! 5@&*'4,GF!% !8! ,%6!". 8(?%$ )6$< A(&854!&('*"( !"*>%: "*7* +*1*>* #'(1!$#, / ($6#/*"!G 1'7, #45?*F!: 2$'0'"%:' ,'4%"!.. V*/("(8%&"(#$< @&!&(16 @("!8*%$#, /*/ @&!>!""*, #',+< ,'4%"!., &*+ @&!+"*"* "%+*'!#!8(#$< E$(. #',+! ($ "*7%. '(4! ! "*7%. 86#4!$%4<"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$!» (108, #. 48). R* E$( ?% ()#$(,$%4<#$'( ()&*$!4 '"!8*"!% ! H. . P%>%"(': «J*/ /*/ '#,/!. %#$%#$'%""6. @&(2%## '#%8! #'(!8! #$(&("*8! @(1>!"%" (1"(85 ! $(85 ?% +*/("5, #4%1('*$%4<"(, '%#< #('(/5@"6. :(1 ,'4%"!, ! ($1%4<"6% A*+6 %;( 1(4?"6 #$(,$< ' @&!>!""(. #',+!, '+*!8"( (@&%1%4,, 1&5; 1&5;*» (336, #. 170). M.9. J!8!&,+%', /("/&%$!+!&5, E$5 +*/("(8%&"(#$< @&!8%"!$%4<"( / $*/(85 @&!&(1"(85 ()&*+('*"!G, /*/ ?!'(. (&;*"!+8, @!#*4: « 6 "% ' @&*'% &*##8*$&!'*$< %1!"!>"6. (&;*"!+8 /*/ #*8(#$(,$%4<"(%, +*8/"5$(% ,'4%"!%: E$( – $(4!""(. #',+"68 &,1(8 @&%17%#$'5GF!: +'%"<%' !, ' #'(G (>%&%1<, '4!,GF%% "* @(#4%15GF!% +'%"<,» (355, #. 158). C &*##8*$&!'*%8(8 '(@&(#% #4%15%$ 5>!$6'*$< ! $( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, >$( ' XIX '%/% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. 8*$%&!*4 %F% "% #$*'!4 @%&%1 5>%"68! $&51"6: $%(&%$!>%#/!: @&()4%8, #',+*""6: # @&!>!""(#$!""(–#4%1#$'%""*, #',+< ' $( '&%8, ()"*&5?!'*4*#< ' ()I%/$*: !+5>%"!, ' #'(!: @&(#$6: A(&8*:. B(E$(85 ! ' A!4(#(A#/(8 @&(,#"%"!! @&()4%86 @&!>!""(#$! 5>%"6% (;&*"!>!'*4!#< #5?1%"!,8! ()F%;( :*&*/$%&*. H. . P%>%"(' @!#*4, "*@&!8%&: «N$( ?% #4%15%$, "*/("%2, &*+58%$< @(1 @(",$!%8 «@&!>!"*» ! «@&!>!""*, +*'!#!8(#$<»? P4('* E$! 5@($&%)4,G$#, ! @(1"%#< "% $(4
252
' 5>%"6: $&*/$*$*:». 3@&%1%4,, #'(% #86#4('(% "*@(4"%"!% "*+'*""6: !8 @(",$!., P%>%"(' ($8%$!4: «B(",$!, E$!, ' @&!4(?%"!! / A*/$*8 '"%7"%;( ! '"5$&%""%;( 8!&*, #5$< @%&'6% 7*;! ' ()I,#"%"!! $(. #$(&("6 1*""(;( ,'4%"!,, !+-+* /($(&(. @&%17%#$'5GF!% +'%"<, ' "%8 (/*+6'*G$#, #',+*""68! # @(#4%15GF!8 &(/('68 ()&*+(8» (335, #. 514). K. J!"1*4< ' $(8 ?% @4*"% '61%4,%$ ' (#"('*"!! '#%: "*5/ «@(",$!% ( @&!>!""(. #',+! ,'4%"!., $( %#$< ( $(8, >$( "!>%;( "% '(+"!/*%$ ' @&!&(1% #*8( #()(., "( '#% ()5#4('4!'*%$#, "%'!1!868! @&%17%#$'('*'7!8! ,'4%"!,8!» (359, #. 4). R( (>%'!1"(#$< #*8(;( 1%.#$'!, @&!>!""(–#4%1#$'%""(. #',+! '#% ?% "% 8%7*4* 5>%"68 '6&*+!$< "%/($(&6% @&!"2!@!*4<"6% 5#$*"('/! ' E$(8 '(@&(#%, (@&%1%4!$< #'(! @(+!2!!. V1%#< #4%15%$ @&%?1% '#%;( ($8%$!$< '61%4%"!% !8! $*/(. #5F%#$'%""(. :*&*/$%&!#$!/! @&!>!""(#4%1#$'%""(. #',+!, /*/ %% 91*!%&/!'*4, >$( «'#,/(% 1%.#$'!% !8%%$ #'(G @&!>!"5, '#,/*, @&!>!"* @&(!+'(1!$ #'(% 1%.#$'!%» (89, #. 38). «O8 >%4('%>%#/!., – 5$'%&?1*4 ! M. Q%&"*&, – "% 8(?%$ #%)% @&%1#$*'!$< 1%.#$'!, )%+ @&!>!"6; /*?1(% ,'4%"!% '(+)5?1*%$ ' "%8 !1%G @&!>!""(#$! ! '#, >%4('%>%#/*, "*5/* #(#$(!$ ' $(8, >$()6 ($ +*8%>%""6: "*8! 1%.#$'!. '(#:(1!$< / !: @&!>!"*8» (29, #. 39-40). Q4*;(1*&, E$(85 ' @(+"*'*%8(. @&!&(1% #$*"('!$#, '(+8(?"68 '6,'!$< ! ()I,#"!$< $($ !4! !"(. +*/(", @(#/(4%&/"54 -. C!&:(', «(#5F%#$'4,%$#, @5$%8 @&!>!""(#$! ! "%():(1!8(#$!. B&!>!"* "%():(1!8( '4%>%$ +* #()(G 1%.#$'!% ! E$( 1%.#$'!% #"('* #$*"('!$#, @&!>!"(G "('(;( 1%.#$'!,. 31"( @&(!+'(1!$ 1&5;(%…» (66, #. 91). L$(, ' @&!"2!@%, $( ?% #*8(%, >$( ! 5 A!4(#(A*–8*$%&!*4!#$* D. 0%.%&)*:*, @( 8"%"!G /($(&(;( '#% ' @&!&(1% «"*:(1!$#, '( '+*!8(1%.#$'!!, '#% (#"('*$%4<"(, '#% (1"('&%8%""( ,'4,%$#, 1%.#$'!%8 ! @&!>!"(., '#% '#%#$(&(""% ! '+*!8"(» (369, $. II, #. 602). -*"%%, ' XVIII '%/% K. K!1&( $*/ (@&%1%4!4 #'(G @(+!2!G ' E$(8 '(@&(#%: «…C#,/(. @&!>!"% #(($'%$#$'5%$ 1%.#$'!% ! 4G)*, @(#$(,""*, @&!>!"*, /*/ )6 8*4* ("* "! )64*, @&(!+'(1!$ # $%>%"!%8 '&%8%"! +"*>!$%4<"(% 1%.#$'!%» (147, #. 382). B&!>!""(-#4%1#$'%""*, #',+< &*##8*$&!'*4*#< 5>%"68! ' %% "%($'&*$!8(#$!: $*8, ;1% ("* 5#$*"*'4!'*%$#,, ("*, @( !: 8"%"!G, "% 8(?%$ "% )6$<. W% 1%.#$'!% ' #!45 E$(;( @&!()&%$*%$ :*&*/$%& "*!$( ! )64( @(1>%&/"5$(, "*@&!8%&, N. K*&'!"(8, @!#*'7!8 ( #',+! 8%?15 @&!>!"(. ! #4%1#$'!%8, /*/ ( #',+!, /($(&*, «@(&*?*%$ "*# #'(!8 (:*&*/$%&(8) "%():(1!8(#$!» (139, #. 105). L$( ?% ()#$(,$%4<#$'( '61%4!4 ! =%//%4<: (" #>!$*4, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( @&!#5F!. %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!. '+;4,1 "* @&!&(15 5#$*"*'4!'*%$ '( '#%. #('(/5@"(#$! %% ,'4%"!. «+*/(" "%():(1!8(. #',+! @&!>!"6 # 1%.#$'!%8» (89, #. 38). -. C!&:(', /*#*,#< E$(;( '(@&(#*, @!#*4: «C#G15, /51* "! +*;4,"%8 86 – @&!>!""(#$<, "%():(1!8(#$<, +*/(""(#$<» (66, #. 93).
253
C #'(!: %#$%#$'%""6: #(#$(,"!,: @&!>!""(-#4%1#$'%""*, #',+<, @( 8"%"!G 5>%"6:, (1"*?16 5#$*"('!'7!#<, "% 8(?%$ "*&57*$<#,, "% 8(?%$ !#>%+*$<. «C 2%@! @&!>!" ! 1%.#$'!., – @!#*4 -. *.%&, – "% 8(?%$… /(;1*-4!)( (1!" >4%" !4! >*#$< /*/(;(-4!)( >4%"* #1%4*%$#, "54%8. L$( @%&'(% #'(.#$'( '#%: @&!>!" 86 "*+6'*%8 !: "*$%,$;3':!1-84» (229, #. 76). L$( #'(.#$'( @&!>!" 4%?!$ ' (#"('% ()I%/$!'"(;( 8!&*. J*/, +*/(" #(:&*"%"!, E"%&;!! *.%& &*##8*$&!'*4 «/*/ (#"('*""6. "* ()F%8 +*/("% "%&*+&57!8(#$! @&!>!"» ($*8 ?%, #. 80). R( E$* "%&*+&57!8(#$< @&!>!" "% (+"*>*%$, (1"*/(, !: "%!+8%""(#$!, @(#$(,"#$'* A(&8. R*@&($!', ("! 8(;5$ 8%",$< A(&86. «P@(#()"(#$< @&!"!8*$< &*+4!>"6% A(&86, %#$< '$(&(% #5F%#$'%""(% #'(.#$'( '#%: @&!>!". B&!"!8*, '( '"!8*"!% ()* #'(.#$'* '8%#$%, 86 ;('(&!8: @&!>!"6 #5$< (/(4!>%#$'%""() "*$%,$;3':.* ! (/*>%#$'%""() 12!1!<".* 6 2$*9$%?*"'(: ()I%/$6» ($*8 ?%, #. 76). 3)I%/$!'"*, @&!>!""(–#4%1#$'%""*, #',+<, ' @&%1#$*'4%"!! 5>%"6:, ()5#4('4!'*%$ ' /("%>"(8 #>%$% '(+"!/"('%"!% !4! !#>%+"('%"!% $%: !4! !"6: ,'4%"!. 8*$%&!*4<"(;( 8!&*, >$( @(4"(#$*%$ '(+8(?"(#$< '8%7*$%4<#$'* ' E$! @&(2%##6 /*/!:-4!)( '"%8!&('6: #'%&:I%#$%#$'%""6: #!4. =%//%4< ($8%>*4, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( 8!&('(++&%"!% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., (#"('6'*,#< "* @&!+"*"!! ()I%/$!'"( 1%.#$'5GF%;( +*/("* @&!>!""(#$!, «&%7!$%4<"( ($'%&;*%$ #5%'%&!, ! @(1()"6% !8 @&%1#$*'4%"!, ( #'%&:I%#$%#$'%""6: @&(2%##*:» (89, #. 38). L$( @(+'(4!4( 5>%"68 @&*'!4<"( ()I,#",$< !+5>*%86% !8! ,'4%"!, ! @&(2%##6 @&!&(16. J*/, @( 8"%"!G K*&'!"*, «'!16 ()&*+5G$#, ! !#$&%)4,G$#, )4*;(1*&, 8%14%""(85 1%.#$'!G ! $%@%&< %F% #5F%#$'5GF!: @&!>!", * "% ' #!45 >51%#"6: $'(&>%#/!: */$('» (141, #. 448). L$( ?% (),+*$%4<"( ! 14, !+8%"%"!, '!1('. L";%4<#, *"*4!+!&5, 1*&'!"('#/5G $%(&!G, ($8%$!4, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( K*&'!" !##4%1('*4 '(@&(# – «"%4<+, 4! "*.$! ' #*8(. @&!&(1% $*/!: @&!>!", /($(&6% 1(4?"6 )64! # $%>%"!%8 '&%8%"! – )%+ '#,/(;( #(+"*$%4<"(;( '(+1%.#$'!, #%4%/2!("%&* – '6+'*$< ' ?!'6: (&;*"!+8*: !+8%"%"!,, @(1()"6% $%8, /($(&6% #(+1*G$#, !#/5##$'%""68 ($)(&(8. B&!>!"6 E$! (" "*7%4 ' "%#(($'%$#$'!! 8%?15 ;&(8*1"68 >!#4(8 #(+1*'*%86: @&!&(1(. +*&(167%. ! "%+"*>!$%4<"68 /(4!>%#$'(8 (&;*"!+8(', A*/$!>%#/! 1(#$!;*GF!: +&%4(#$!» (405, #. 68). H8%""( $*/(. @(1:(1 5>%"6:%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. / @("!8*"!G @&!>!""(#$! ' @&!&(1% 1*4 (#"('*"!% H. K!2;%"5 @(1>%&/"5$<, >$( «%#$%#$'%""6% "*5/! !F5$ #'(! @&!>!"6 "% 9"* !4! 2!,%5' ,'4%"!., "( 9";-$' !: !4! 0*$*, 2!1$*51-9! !:» (149, #. 49). C @&!&(1%, ' %% &%*4<"(8 )6$!!, /&(8% @&!>!""(-#4%1#$'%""6:, 1%.#$'5G$, /("%>"(, ! 1&5;!% #5F%#$'%""6% #',+! ! ($"(7%"!,. C#% ("! ' !: %1!"#$'% ()&*+5G$ '#%8!&"5G, 5"!'%&#*4<"5G 9,%':!19(,8, '+*!8(+*'!#!8(#$< @&%18%$(' ! ,'4%"!.. 0&*"25+#/!. A!4(#(A– 8*$%&!*4!#$ ! '&*> XVIII '%/* B. M*)*"!# 5$'%&?1*4, "*@&!8%&, >$( «'#% >*#$! '#%4%""(. "*:(1,$#, ' !+'%#$"6: ($"(7%"!,: 1&5; / 1&5;5, '#%
254
1'!?%"!, "*:(1,$#, ' #(($'%$#$'!!, '#% ,'4%"!, #',+*"6 8%?15 #()(G, 5&*'"('%7!'*G$ !4! "%():(1!8( '6+6'*G$ (1"( 1&5;(%» (164, #. 356). B&! E$(8 «'#% $%4* '#%4%""(. (/*+6'*G$ '+*!8"(% 1%.#$'!% 1&5; "* 1&5;*» ($*8 ?%, #. 57). L$* (#"('(@(4*;*GF*, A!4(#(A#/*, !1%, – '+*!8(#',+! '#%: @&%18%$(' ! ,'4%"!. @&!&(16 – @&(>"( 5$'%&1!4*#< ! ' 8!&('(++&%"!! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/*. M*/ @(1>%&/"54 M. Q%&"*&, «' @&!&(1% '#% "*:(1!$#, '( '+*!8"(. +*'!#!8(#$! ! "!>%;( "%4<+, &*##8*$&!'*$< ($1%4<"(» (29, #. 67). L$* '+*!8(+*'!#!8(#$< ,'4%"!. @&!&(16, !: +*/("(8%&"*, '+*!8(#',+<, ' #'(G (>%&%1<, "%():(1!8( @&%1@(4*;*%$ #(($'%$#$'5GF%% 9,%':!5*=1-9'* 8%?15 "!8!. «C#% '(()F% ,'4%"!,, – @!#*4 K.H. %"1%4%%', – @&(!#:(1,$ '#4%1#$'!% '+*!8(1%.#$'!, &*+4!>"6: $%4» (264, #. 369). 3>%'!1%" ()I%/$!'"6. :*&*/$%& E$(;( '+*!8(1%.#$'!, ' %;( &%*4<"(8 @&(#$&*"#$'%""(–'&%8%""(8 &*+'%&$6'*"!!. C @&%18%$"(8 8!&%, #>!$*4 H. . P%>%"(', #5F%#$'5%$ «'+*!8(1%.#$'!%, #('%&7*GF%%#, '#%;1* ' @&(#$&*"#$'% ! '&%8%"!» (335, #. 361). C+*!8(1%.#$'!, '#%: @&%18%$(' ! ,'4%"!. '"%7"%;( 8!&* ' #'(!: "%@(#&%1#$'%""6: #('(/5@"6: #(#$(,"!,: @&%1#$*G$ /*/ @&%18%$"( @&%$'(&%""(% 59'>*"'* 8*$%&!!, @&(,'4,GF%%#,, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' (@&%1%4%""6: !+8%"%"!,:, A!/#!&5GF!: ' #%)% &%*4<"(% $%,9'-'* @&!&(16. B&! E$(8, /*/ ($8%$!4 9.=. P$(4%$(', «@&!&(1* @&%1#$*'4,%$ "*8 &*+(8 – ! '!1!85G )%+;&*"!>"(#$< @('$(&%"!,, ! ()F!. +*/(" &(?1%"!,, &*+'!$!, ! #8%&$!» (343, #. 72). B(45>*%$#,, $*/!8 ()&*+(8, >$( ' &%*4<"(8 )6$!! @&!&(16 +*/("(8%&"*, '+*!8(#',+< ,'4%"!. ()5#4('4!'*%$ '#%()I%84GF!. @&(2%## !: +*/("(8%&"(;( &*+'!$!,. M*/ )6 ()()F*, @&!'%1%""6% '67% '6#/*+6'*"!, 5>%"6: "* E$($ #>%$, L";%4<# @!#*4: «C#, 1(#$5@"*, "*8 @&!&(1* ()&*+5%$ "%/5G #!#$%85, "%/5G #('(/5@"5G #',+< $%4… C $(8 ()#$(,$%4<#$'%, >$( E$! $%4* "*:(1,$#, '( '+*!8"(. #',+!, 5?% +*/4G>%"( $(, >$( ("! '(+1%.#$'5G$ 1&5; "* 1&5;*, ! E$( !: '+*!8"(% '(+1%.#$'!% 1&5; "* 1&5;* ! %#$< !8%""( 1'!?%"!%» (406, #. 392). C &*8/*: 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! E$5 !1%."5G 5#$*"('/5 '61%4!4 ! H. K!2;%", @(1>%&/"5', ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( ' 8!&% «(1"( +*'!#!$ ($ 1&5;(;(; +%84,, 1%&%'(, $5>! ! #(4"2% 4!7< ' #',+!, 4!7< ' ()F%. 8!&('(. #',+! ,'4,G$#, $%8, >%8 ("! #5$< "* #*8(8 1%4%». P$(4< ?% (>%'!1"( ! @&%1#$*'4%"!% ( $(8, >$( '#4%1#$'!% '+*!8(#',+! ,'4%"!. «'(()F% @&(!#:(1!$ $%,9'-'*, /($(&(% #('%&7*%$#, '( '#%. @&!&(1%» (150, #. 105, 118). 3$#G1* ! #(($'%$#$'5GF!. @(1:(1 / !+5>*%868 ()I%/$*8 ' @(+"*'*$%4<"(8 ($"(7%"!! >%4('%/* / 8!&5 – &*##8($&%"!% @&%18%$(' ! ,'4%"!. @&!&(16 ' !: '+*!8(#',+!, ' !: 1'!?%"!! ! &*+'!$!!. J*/, @( 8"%"!G K. J!"1*4,, «,#"(#$< ! #@(/(.#$'!% 15:* 1(#$!;*G$#, >%4('%/(8 $(4%#/!. @&!"2!@ 5,#"!$ %85 (&;*"!>%#/5G #',+< ,'4%"!. @&!&(16» (359, #. 37). K.H. %"1%4%%' ($'%&;*4, /*/ #('%&7%""( "%@&!%84%86., 8%$(1 &*##8($&%"!, ,'4%"!. '"%
255
!: #',+%. ! ($"(7%"!.: «R!>$( "% 8(?%$ )6$< (@&%1%4%"( #*8( @( #%)% ! #*8( !+ #%),» (262, #. 193). H+5>%"!% !+(4!&('*""6: ,'4%"!. "% 1*%$ ! "% 8(?%$ 1*$< !: #5F"(#$"(;( +"*"!,. «D!7< ' ()F%. #',+! '#%: ,'4%"!. 8(?"( !#/*$< ($'%$ "* '(@&(#6, /*#*GF!%#, #5F"(#$! ,'4%"!.» (264, #. 445). -*#/&6$!% #5F"(#$! ,'4%"!. @&!&(16 >%&%+ 5#$*"('4%"!% #',+%. 8%?15 "!8! (#()%""( 5#@%7"(, (#()%""( @(4"( ! ;45)(/( (#5F%#$'4,%$#, ' 2%4%"*@&*'4%""6:, #@%2!*4!+!&('*""6: %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: !##4%1('*"!,:. J*/*, "*@&*'4%""(#$< @(+"*'*$%4<"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! (),+*$%4<"* 14, %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, ,'4,%$#, %;( "*!)(4%% #5F%#$'%""(. :*&*/$%&!#$!/(., (#"('"68 %;( (@&%1%4!$%4%8. «W#$%#$'(+"*"!% ' ()7!&"(8 #86#4% E$(;( #4('*, – @!#*4 H. . P%>%"(', – %#$< "*5/* ( #',+,:, ($"(7%"!,: ! +*'!#!8(#$,: 8%?15 @&%18%$*8! '"%7"%;( 8!&* ! !: #(#$*'"68! >*#$,8!» (335, #. 378). C XIX '%/% $*/(. :*&*/$%& %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, @&(,'!4#, ' @(4"(. 8%&%. M 50-8 ;(1*8, /*/ #'!1%$%4<#$'5%$ R.9. O8(', )64! «($/&6$6 #',+! ' &*+4!>"6: /4*##*: ,'4%"!. 8%?15 '%4!>!"*8!, 1(#$5@"68! "%@(#&%1#$'%""(85 !+8%&%"!G, ($/&6$* '+*!8"*, @&%'&*F*%8(#$< ,'4%"!.» (364, #. 66). Q4*;(1*&, ($/&6$!G K*&'!"* '#%4%""*,, @!7%$ O8(', «"% #$(!$ 5?% @%&%1 "*8!, /*/ /5"#$/*8%&* A(&8 8%&$'6: !4! ?!'6:, #',+*""6: (1"(G 2%4%4('%/5. B%&%1 "*8! %1!"*,, !+ #%), )%#@&%1%4<"( &*+'!'*GF*,#, ?!+"<» ($*8 ?%, #. 335). H, /*/ @(1>%&/"54 D. QG:"%&, «# /*?168 "('68 ($/&6$!%8 ' %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/*: 86 '#% )4!?% @(1:(1!8 / '%4!/(. !#$!"%, >$( @&!&(1* %#$< '%4!/(%, "%&*+1%4<"(%, ' "%@&%&6'"(. #',+! &*+'!'*GF%%#,, @( +*/("*8 @&!>!""(#$! 1'!?5F%%#,, 2%4(%» (53, #. 152). P$(4< ?% (@&%1%4%""( "* E$($ #>%$ '6#/*+*4#, ! X. (4%7($$; !8%, ' '!15 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(% @(+"*"!%, (" @!#*4: «…P8%4( @(;&5+!8#, ' @($(/ A*/$(', $( '(#:(1, / %;( !#$(>"!/5, $( 1('%&>!'( @&%1(#$*'4,, #%), )6#$&($% $%>%"!,; '%+1% 5'!1!8 86 #',+< 8%?15 ,'4%"!,8!, 8"(;(#$(&(""(#$< 1%.#$'!., #(>%$*"!% ($@&*'4%"!., ! !+ @&!>!""(. #',+!, !+ '#%#$(&(""%;( #2%@4%"!, ($"(7%"!., (/*+6'*GF!:#, "%():(1!868! 8%?15 '#%8! >*#$,8!, '(+"!/"%$ 14, "*# %1!"#$'(» (276, #. 180). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, '#, !"-!7!#'0*16%( #(#$*'4,GF*, ' 8!&('(++&%"!! )(4<7!"#$'* %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/*, ' !: A!4(#(A!! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, ' #'(%. A!4(#(A#/(. (@&%1%4%""(#$! ()"*&5?!'*%$ (>%'!1"5G, 1(#$*$(>"( (#"('*$%4<"5G, :($, '( 8"(;(8 ! #$!:!."5G, 8*$%&!*4!#$!>"(#$< ' %% @&%!85F%#$'%""(. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(. ()5#4('4%""(#$!. C #(1%&?*$%4<"(8 – !1%."(8 ! /("2%@$5*4<"(8 – @4*"% E$* ("$(4(;!>%#/*, #(#$*'4,GF*,, )515>! ' (#"('"(8 &%+54<$*$(8 #*8(#$(,$%4<"(;( 8674%"!, 5>%"6:, !: #*8(1%,$%4<"(;( A!4(#(A#$'('*"!,, $%8 "% 8%"%% A*/$!>%#/! 4!7< @('$(&!4*, '(+()"('!4* "* %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(. (#"('%, @&!>%8, /*/ @&*'!4(, ' 5@&(F%""(8 '!1%, "* E4%8%"$*&"(8 5&('"% ("$(4(;%8, *"*4(;!>"6% @&!"2!@!*4<"6% 5#$*"('4%"!, 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! XVIII '%/*. L$( "%
256
"%1(#$*$(/ A!4(#(A#$'('*"!, 5>%"6:, "% @&(,'4%"!% !: "%1(86#4!,, E$( $($ "%!+)%?"6. 2$*5*7, 1( /($(&(;( !: A!4(#(A#/*, 86#4<, ' &*8/*: !8%""( ("$(4(;!>%#/(. @&()4%8*$!/!, 1(:(1!$ ' $%(&%$!>%#/(. #A%&% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,. P@(&*1!>%#/*,, A!4(#(A#/! *8(&A"*, /("#$*$*2!, ()F!: 14, '#%;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* 8!&('(++&%">%#/!: (#"('(@(4(?%"!. ("$(4(;!>%#/(;( :*&*/$%&* – E$( :*$% &%*4!+*2!! !"$%44%/$5*4<"(. @($&%)"(#$! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ' &*##8($&%"!! ("$(4(;!>%#/(. @&()4%8*$!/! /*/ #(#$*'"(. >*#$! !: A!4(#(A#/(;( (#'(%"!, 8!&* ' :(1% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, 8%&*, #(($'%$#$'5GF*, !"$%&%#5 !: &*+58*. R%#/(4% ' E$(8 #86#4% ()#$(!$ 1%4( ' #A%&% A!4(#(A#/(. @&()4%8*$!/! *"$&(@(4(;!>%#/(;( :*&*/$%&*.
257
@3;5; VI ,EF82>232N=ID4<;9 >82H3DB;F=<;: ID325D< 5 B=8D B(4(?%"!% >%4('%/* ' 8!&%, %;( 8%#$( ! &(4< ' )6$!! @&!&(16 ()5#4('!4! %;( (#()6. @(+"*'*$%4<"6. #$*$5#, "%@&%:(1,F!. !"$%&%# / "%85 /*/ ;4*'"(85 ()I%/$5 @(+"*"!,, @&%?1% '#%;( – A!4(#(A#/(;(. «R('*, A!4(#(A!,, – @!#*4 D. 0%.%&)*:, – @&%'&*F*%$ 0*7!9*6%, 96740%( ' 2$'$!5;, /*/ )*+!# >%4('%/*, ' *5'"1-9*"".=, ;"'9*$1%78".= ' 9.13'= 2$*5:*- A!4(#(A!!, @&%'&*F*,, #4%1('*$%4<"(, %"-$!2!7!#'4, 9 -!: 0'17* ' &','!7!#'4, 9 ;"'9*$1%78";4 "%;6;» (369, #. 202). H # $(>/! +&%"!, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,, ' 1*""(8 #45>*% X. (4%7($$*, ' !##4%1('*"!! A!+!(4(;*8! ;&*"!2 >%4('%>%#/(. @&!&(16 «'#% )(4%% !4! 8%"%% ,#"( '!1,$, >$( ("! $&51,$#, "*1 &%7%"!%8 (1"(. !+ '6#7!: +*1*> '#%()F%. "*5/!, $( %#$< A!4(#(A!!» (275, #. 200). -%>< +1%#<, /*/ ! 5 0%.%&)*:*, !1%$ ( A!4(#(A!! ! A!+!(4(;!! XIX '%/*. H8%""( ' E$(8 #$(4%$!! @&()4%8* >%4('%/* @&!()&%4* (#()5G +"*>!8(#$< '( '#%. #A%&% @(+"*"!,. M. 0(;$ @!#*4, ' >*#$"(#$!: «Q%+ #(8"%"!,, "*!)(4%% +*"!8*$%4<"6. @&%18%$ !+6#/*"!., !##4%1('*"!. ! "*)4G1%"!., %#$< #*8 >%4('%/. C( '#,/5G "*75 1%,$%4<"(#$<, /*/(;( )6 &(1* ("* "! )64*, 86 "%'(4<"( '"(#!8 @(+"*"!% >%4('%/*» (381, #. 1). B(",$"( @(E$(85, >$( @&()4%8* >%4('%/* ' %% "% $(4"(8, "( ! ' ()F%A!4(#(A#/(8 #(1%&?*"!!, $*/ !4! !"*>%, @&!'4%/4* '"!8*"!% 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/*, @()5?1*, / (@&%1%4%""68 &*+8674%"!,8, / @(!#/*8 #5F"(#$"6: &%7%"!., / #(($'%$#$'5GF!8 /("/&%$"68 '6'(1*8 ! ()()F%"!,8, A(&8!&('*'7!8 #5F%#$'%""( '*?"6. /(8@("%"$ !: ()F%;( A!4(#(A#/(;( 8!&('(++&%"!,. H+'%#$"6. "%8%2/!. A!4(#(A, '&*> ! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4< =. D($2% $*/ (@&%1%4!4 E$5 "%@&%:(1,F5G 8!&('(++&%">%#/5G +"*>!8(#$< @&()4%86 >%4('%/*: «N%8 )(4%% >%&$6… '%4!/(. /*&$!"6 8!&* )515$ ':(1!$< ' ()F%% #(+"*"!%, $%8 ?!'%% )515$ ("! '(+'&*F*$< "*# / #*8!8 #%)% ! #"('* '(+)5?1*$< "%($#$&*"!86% '(@&(#6: /*/(% ?% +"*>%"!% !8%G$ >%4('%/ ! %;( ?!+"<, # @(#$(,""68! %% ,'4%"!,8! ! # !+8%">!'68 :(1(8 !#$(&!!, ' 2%4(8 #(#$*'% $(. @&!&(16, /($(&(. "%(#4*)"(% '4!,"!%, )4*;(1*&, '6'(1*8 "('%.7%. "*5/!, 86 "6"% >5'#$'5%8 "* #%)% )(4%% >%8 /(;1*"!)51%4('%/* ' 8!&('(++&%"!! '61*GF!:#, 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/* #(#&%1($*>!'*4!#< ;4*'"68 ()&*+(8 '(/&5; @&()4%86 >%4('%>%#/(;( 1!,"%"'(, %;( #5F"(#$!, 8%:*"!+8* %;( A5"/2!("!&('*"!,, %;( @&(!#:(?1%"!, – ' &*8/*: %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: !##4%1('*"!. ' #A%&% A!+!(4(;!!, 1*&'!"('#/(;( E'(4G2!(""(;( 5>%"!, ! 1&. H+"*>*4<"*, (&!%"$*2!, E$!: !##4%1('*"!. "* !+5>%"!% #(+"*"!, ' %;( "%():(1!8(. #',+! # 1%.#$'!%8 8*$%&!*4<"6: A*/$(&(' (1%,$%4<"(#$< ;(4('"(;( 8(+;*, (&;*"(' >5'#$', "%&'"(. #!#$%86, '4!,"!% '"%7"%. #&%16 ! $.@.) ' A!4(#(A#/(8 /("$%/#$% ()5#4('4!'*4* !: "%!+)%?"6%, '%#<8*
258
+"*>!$%4<"6% 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!% @( #'(%. #5$! @&%4(84%"!,, '( 8"(;(8 *"*4(;!>"6% $%8 '6'(1*8, /($(&6% &*"%% (' XVII–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– %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8!, $*/ ! A!4(#(A*8!–8*$%&!*4!#$*8!. § 1. UD325DID4<2D 5 >8=827D: 42CE;E=D = B;FD8=9 *$%&!*4!#$!>"(#$< '(++&%"!. 5>%"6: XIX '%/* &*#@&(#$&*",4*#< "* 8"(;!% *#@%/$6 @&()4%86 #(+"*"!,, ' $(8 >!#4% ! "* "*!)(4%% ()F!%, 8!&('(++&%">%#/!%. H @&%?1% '#%;( #4%15%$ ($8%$!$< %% @&(,'4%"!% ' ()F%8 ! "*!)(4%% #5F%#$'%""(8 14, '#%;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* 5#$*"('4%"!! – ' @&!+"*"!! 2*$9'0"!1-' 8*$%&!! ! 9-!$'0"!1-' #(+"*"!,. J*/, H. . P%>%"(' @!#*4: «B&%18%$"6. 8!& #5F%#$'('*4 ! )51%$ #5F%#$'('*$<, @( ($"(7%"!G / /*?1(85 >%4('%/5, &*"<7% %;( 86#4!, #4%1('*$%4<"(, @%&'!>"68 A*/$(&(8 ' &*+'!$!! @(#4%1"%. '#%;1* )64 ! )51%$ 14, "*# '"%7"!. 8!& # %;( @&%18%$"68! #',+,8! ! ($"(7%"!,8!» (335, #. 362). 3)(#"('6'*, '$(&!>"(#$< #(+"*"!, @( ($"(7%"!G / 8*$%&!!, D. QG:"%& ($8%$!4, ' >*#$"(#$!: «P4('*: 5;3%, 5;D, :.178, !?;?*"'*, 9!7(, >',"8 "% ()(+"*>*G$ /*/!:-4!)( #5F"(#$%., !4! /*/!:-4!)( 1%.#$'!$%4<"6: '%F%.; ("! 4!7< #'(.#$'*, #@(#()"(#$!, ($@&*'4%"!, ?!'(. #5)#$*"2!! !4! &%+54<$*$6 #5F"(#$%., /(&%",F!:#, ' 8*$%&!*4<"6: A(&8*: )6$!,» (52, #. 176). B(",$"(, >$( $*/*, @(+!2!, 5>%"6: XIX '%/*, #4(?!'7*,#, ' 4("% /&%@"5F%;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, @(4"(#$!#4% ! ' $($ @%&!(1, /(;1* (" %F% "% 8(; 1(#$*$(>"( (#"('*$%4<"( (@%&%$<#, "* %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(% !+5>%"!% #(+"*"!,. J*/, %F% ' XVIII '%/% A&*"25+#/!% A!4(#(A6–8*$%&!*4!#$6 #(+"*$%4<"( '61'!;*4! @&!+"*"!% @%&'!>"(#$! 8*$%&!!, )6$!, ! '$(&!>"(#$! #(+"*"!,, @&!+"*"!% $(;(, >$( )6$!% (@&%1%4,%$ #(+"*"!%, ' /*>%#$'% (#"('(@(4*;*GF%;( @&!"2!@* #'(!: A!4(#(A#/!: #!#$%8. =(4<)*:, "*@&!8%&, @!#*4: «R*7 ()&*+ 86#4! (@&%1%4,%$#, "*7!8 #@(#()(8 )6$!,» (126, #. 219). Q4*;(1*&, @(#4%15GF!8 5#@%:*8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ' !+5>%"!! #(+"*"!, ! A!4(#(A#/!. 8*$%&!*4!+8 @(45>*4 ' &*##8*$&!'*%8(8 '(@&(#% @&(>"(% A*/$!>%#/(% (#"('*"!%. C.H. D%"!" @!#*4, >$( «8*$%&!*4!+8 ' @(4"(8
259
#(;4*#!! # %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8 )%&%$ +* @%&'!>"(% 1*""(% 8*$%&!G, #>!$*, '$(&!>"68 #(+"*"!%, 8674%"!%, (F5F%"!%» (204, #. 39). K&5;(. '*?"%.7!. ()F!. 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!. *#@%/$ '( '+;4,1*: 5>%"6: "* #(+"*"!% – &*##8($&%"!% %;( ' "%&*+&6'"(. 19(,' # 8*$%&!%.: «K5: ("*7), – @!#*4 . T4%.1%", – #',+*" # $%4(8 ! ' (#()%""(#$! # "%&'"(G #!#$%8(., #( #'(!8 (&;*"(8; 15: @&(,'4,%$#, "% !"*>% /*/ >%&%+ @(#&%1#$'( E$(;( (&;*"*; %#4! @(#4%1"!. "% 1%.#$'5%$ '('#% !4! $(4/! +&%"!, X. (4%7($$*, 15:('"6% ,'4%"!, «"% '(+"!/*G$ )%+ 8*$%&!!, "% #5F%#$'5G$ )%+ 8*$%&!!, "% 8(;5$ )6$< '(#@&!",$6 )%+ 8*$%&!!» ([!$. @(: 393, #. 54). 3$1%4!$< ' >%4('%/% 15:('"(% ($ 8*$%&!*4<"(;( 8(?"( 4!7< ' @&%1#$*'4%"!!, *)#$&*;!&5, (1"( ($ 1&5;(;(, $(;1* /*/ !: &%*4<"(% #(#$(,"!% :*&*/$%&!+5%$#, !: %1!"#$'(8, "%&*+1%4<"(#$!$*, "%()(#"('*""68 «&*+4!>%"!% ! 1*?% @&($!'(@(4(?%"!%, %F% "%&%1/( '#$&%>*GF%%#, ' '!1% (#$*$/* ($ #&%1"!: '%/(', 4!7< 8*$%&!*4<"(;( ($ 15:('"(;(», 5$'%&?1*4, >$( «15:('"(% 86#4!8( 4!7< ' *)#$&*/$%, ' 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$! ?% @(+"*%$#, >%&%+ 8*$%&!*4<"( (F5F*%8(%, $( %#$< ' #(>%$*"!! # '%F%#$'(8 ! E"%&;!%G» (260, #. 470). B( 8"%"!G =.9. D(&%"2*, «8%?15 15:('"68 ! 8*$%&!*4<"68 8!&*8! !8%%$#, '%#<8* $%#"*, #',+<» (219, #. 153). QG:"%& $*/?% @(1>%&/!'*4, >$( «86#4< "%&*+&6'"( #',+*"* # (@&%1%4%""68! 8*$%&!*4<"68! 1'!?%"!,8!», >$( «'8%#$% # 8*$%&!%. !#>%+*%$ ! 86#4<» (52, #. 177, 178). =%//%4< '6'(1!4 /(&"! E$(. #',+! #(+"*"!, ! 8*$%&!! !+ #*8(;( A5"1*8%"$* @(#4%1"%. – '@4($< 1( *$(8('. «R%8*$%&!*4<"6. ?!'(. 15:» – @!#*4 (", – $*/ ?% "%86#4!8 /*/ «8%&$'*, 8*$%&!, )%+ 15:*», «' /*?1(8 *$(8% 15: ! 8*$%&!, "%&*+&6'"( #',+*"6» (93, #. 52). C E$(8 '(@&(#% $*/?% 8(?"( )%+ $&51* ()"*&5?!$< ,'"5G ()F"(#$< A!4(#(A#/!: '(++&%"!. '61*GF!:#, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* ! A!4(#(A('–8*$%&!*4!#$(', 14, /($(&6: "%&*+&6'"*, #',+< #(+"*"!, # 8*$%&!%. $(?% )64* '@(4"% (>%'!1"(.. J*/, ' XVIII '%/%, '6&*?*, 5)%?1%""(#$< ' "*4!>!! $*/(. #',+!, =(4<)*: @!#*4: «0!+!>%#/!. 8!& ! 8!& 15:('"6. $%#"( #',+*"6 8%?15 #()(.» (126, #. 339). -*#/&6'*, :*&*/$%& E$(. #',+!, =(4<)*: '61%4!4 #4%15GF!% '*?"6% 8(8%"$6: «86 @(/*+*4!, >$( 1*?% @&%1@(4(?!' "%8*$%&!*4<"(#$< 157!, @&!:(1!$#, @&!+"*$<, >$( 157* '#%;1* '!1(!+8%",%$#, '8%#$% # $%4(8, )515>! @(1>!"%"* '#%8 %;( 1'!?%"!,8, )%+ /($(&6: ("* (#$*'*4*#< )6 !"%&$"(. ! 8%&$'(.. P4%1('*$%4<"(, 157* @(1>!"%"* '4!,"!G 8*$%&!*4<"6:, A!+!>%#/!: @&!>!", '(+1%.#$'5GF!: "* $%4(, #@(#() )6$!, /($(&(;( – @(#$(,""6. !4! '&%8%""6. – +*'!#!$ ($ 8*$%&!*4<"6: E4%8%"$(', #(#$*'4,GF!: %;( $/*"<, ()&*+5GF!: %;( $%8@%&*8%"$, ':(1,F!: ' "%;( '8%#$% # @!F%., @&("!/*GF!: ! (/&5?*GF!: %;(… 6 1(/*+*4!, "*/("%2, >$( '#% "*7! !1%!, $%(&!!, 1'!?%"!, "*7%. 157!, !#$!""6% !4! 4(?"6% @(",$!,, /($(&6% 86 #%)% #(#$*'4,%8, ()5#4('4%"6 "*7!8! 8*$%&!*4<"68! ! A!+!>%#/!8! (&;*"*8!» ($*8 ?%, #. 208).
260
(?"( $*/?% #(#4*$<#, "* 8"%"!% K!1&(, #>!$*'7%;(, >$( «#@(#()"(#$< (F5F%"!, %#$< '#%()F%% #'(.#$'( 8*$%&!! !4! @&(15/$ %% (&;*"!+('*""(#$!» (146, #. 387). C.H. D%"!", (#"('6'*,#< "* E$(8 '6#/*+6'*"!! K!1&(, @&('(1!$ #(%1!"!$%4<"5G 4!"!G 8%?15 A!4(#(A#/!8 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 XVIII '%/* ! %#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/!8 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/*. 3$8%$!', ' >*#$"(#$!, $( @&!"2!@!*4<"(% ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, >$( ! «' A5"1*8%"$% #*8(;( +1*"!, 8*$%&!!» 8(?"( 4!7< @&%1@(4*;*$< #5F%#$'('*"!% #@(#()"(#$!, #:(1"(. # (F5F%"!%8», C.H. D%"!" 1()*'4,%$: «J*/('( @&%1@(4(?%"!%, "*@&!8%&, !+'%#$"(;( "%8%2/(;( %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4, L&"#$* =%//%4,, *";4!.#/(;( )!(4(;* D4(.1* (&;*"* ! 1&., "% ;('(&, ( 1(;*1/% K!1&(» (204, #. 40). P( #'(%. #$(&("6, C.H. D%"!", '61%4,, $5 ?% "%&*+&6'"5G #',+< #(+"*"!, # 8*$%&!%. ' /*>%#$'% ()F%;( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(;( 5#$*"('4%"!,, @(1>%&/"54, >$( «#(+"*"!% %#$< '"5$&%""%% #(#$(,"!% 8*$%&!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 84). B&!+"*"!% 5>%"68! '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* "%&*+&6'"(. #',+! #(+"*"!, # 8*$%&!%. (+"*>*%$, @&%?1% '#%;(, >$( ,'4%"!, 157%'"(. ?!+"! >%4('%/*, #(#$*'4,GF!% %% @&(2%##6 ' !: &%*4<"(#$!, ' !: "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 )6$!!, "% 86#4!4!#< ' ($&6'% ($ (@&%1%4%""6: :%-*$'%78".D 2$!+*11!9, @&($%/*GF!: ' (&;*"!+8% >%4('%/*. 3) E$(8, "*@&!8%&, @!#*4 D. QG:"%&; (" ($8%$!4, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( '#,/*, @#!:!>%#/*, 1%,$%4<"(#$< «&*+'!'*%$#, !+ >*#$( @('$(&,GF!:#, ! @(#$%@%""( 5#!4!'*GF!:#, (F5F%"!. !4! '@%>*$4%"!. '"%7"%;( 8!&*, @%&%1*'*%86: "%&'*8!» (52, #. 178). R* E$( ()#$(,$%4<#$'( ()&*$!4 '"!8*"!% ! =%//%4<: «C#% )%+ !#/4G>%"!, ,'4%"!, 157%'"(. ?!+"! #',+*"6 # 8*$%&!*4<"68! @&(2%##*8! ' ?!'(8 '%F%#$'% (&;*"!+8*» (95, #. 166). =%//%4< "*#$(.>!'( @('$(&,%$ E$5 86#4<: «K57%'"*, ?!+"< '6#7!: ?!'($"6:, &*+58 ! 8674%"!% >%4('%/* @(/(,$#, "* 8*$%&!*4<"6: @&(2%##*:» ($*8 ?%, #. 262). V"*8%"!$6. &5##/!. 5>%"6. R.3. M('*4%'#/!. $*/?% 5$'%&?1*4, >$( «#(+"*"!% "% %#$< #!4*, "( 4!7< #'(.#$'( "%&'"6: @&(2%##(', @&(,'4,GF!:#, @&! !+'%#$"6: (@&%1%4%""6: 5#4('!,:», >$( @#!:!>%#/!% @&(2%##6, «/*/ 8*$%&!*4<"6%, #('%&7*G$#, ' @&(#$&*"#$'% ! '( '&%8%"!», #(+"*"!% – «E$( #'(.#$'( #'(%()&*+"(;( @("!8*"!, $%: !4! 1&5;!: "%&'"6: @&(2%##(', /($(&6% !15$ @(1 '4!,"!%8 '"%7"%;( !8@54<#* !+'%#$"68 8*$%&!*4<"68 @5$%8» (174, #. 160-161). M("/&%$!+!&5, E$( ()F%% @(4(?%"!% @&!8%"!$%4<"( / "%@(#&%1#$'%""68 @&%1@(#64/*8 ! @&(,'4%"!,8 157%'"(. ?!+"! – / ($1%4<"68 "%&'"68 */$*8, H. . P%>%"(' @!#*4: «C "%&'"(8 */$% #5F%#$'%""68 ! %1!"#$'%""( &%*4<"68 ,'4,%$#, #588* $%: 8*$%&!*4<"6: @&(2%##(', /($(&6% @&(!#:(1,$ ' $(8 !4! 1&5;(8 ($1%4% "%&'"(. #!#$%86» (335, #. 251). *$%&!*4<"6% @&(2%##6, 4%?*F!% ' (#"('% '#%: */$(' #(+"*"!,, 5>%"6% &*##8*$&!'*4! @&%?1% '#%;( ' !: ($"(7%"!! / 1%,$%4<"(#$! 8*$%&!*4<"(;(, $%4%#"(;( (&;*"* – :!,#%. C #',+! # E$!8 #(+"*"!% @("!8*4(#< /*/ @&(15/$ 8(+;*, /*/ %;( A5"/2!,, /*/ %;( (@&%1%4%""*, 1%,$%4<"(#$<. =%//%4<, "*@&!8%&, # @(+!2!. A!+!(4(;!>%#/(. "*5/! 1%4*4
261
'6'(1 ( $(8, >$( «#(+"*"!% >%4('%/*, @(1()"( '#%8 1&5;!8 15:('"68 1%,$%4<"(#$,8, #(#$*'4,%$ A5"/2!G 8(+;*» (97, #. 12). 3" ?% @!#*4 ( ;(4('"(8 8(+;% /*/ () «(&51!! #(+"*"!, ! '#%: '6#7!: 157%'"6: A5"/2!.» (95, #. 91), ( $(8, >$( 157* >%4('%/* «%#$< A5"/2!, 8(+;* ! "%&*+&6'"( #',+*"* # E$!8 8*$%&!*4<"68 «(&;*"(8 157!» (97, #. 43), >$( «#(+"*"!% %#$< #4(?"*, 1%,$%4<"(#$< 8(+;*» ($*8 ?%, #. 127). 9"*4(;!>"(. $(>/! +&%"!, @&!1%&?!'*4!#< ! 1&5;!% 5>%"6%. C >*#$"(#$!, M. 0(;$ $*/ (@&%1%4!4 #'(G @(+!2!G ' E$(8 '(@&(#%: «X @(4*;*G, >$( /*?16. %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4<, @&! #/(4$( '#% #@(#()"(#$!, !+'%#$"6% @(1 "*+'*"!%8 157%'"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$!, #5$< $(4$( 86#4< "*:(1!$#, @(>$! ' $*/(8 ?% ($"(7%"!! / ;(4('"(85 8(+;5, /*/ ?%4>< / @%>%"! !4! 8(>* / @(>/*8». B&! E$(8 0(;$ ##64*4#, "* #4%15GF!. &*+I,#",GF!. /(88%"$*&!. (4%7($$*: «P&*'"%"!% E$( "%(#@(&!8(, %#4! @(",$<, ' /*/(8 #86#4% 0(;$ 5@($&%)4,%$ %;(. (+; $*/ ?% "%():(1!8 14, ()&*+('*"!, 86#4!, /*/ @%>%"< 14, @&!;($('4%"!, ?%4>! ! @(>/! 14, ($1%4%"!, 8(>!. R( 86#4< $*/ ?% 8*4( @(:(?* "* ?!1/(#$<, /*/ ! $%@4($* !4! +'5/. 6#4< – 1'!?%"!%, @&%'&*F%"!% 8(+;('(;( '%F%#$'*; 8674%"!% $*/(% ?% "%():(1!8(% ! "%&*+1%4<"(% #'(.#$'( 8(+;*, /*/ '(()F% '#,/*, #!4*, #(#$*'4,GF*, '"5$&%""%%, "%($I%84%8(% #'(.#$'( 8*$%&!!. R%@('&%?1%""6. 8(+; $(>"( $*/ ?% "% 8(?%$ "% 86#4!$<, /*/ ! 86#4< "% 8(?%$ )6$< ()&*+('*"* 1&5;!8 '%F%#$'(8, /&(8% 8(+;('(;(» (380, #. 335). -*+58%%$#,, /*/ @(1>%&/"54 QG:"%&, «8(+; "% $(4!$%4<"( ' #%&(8 /(&/('(8 '%F%#$'%, "( ! %1!"#$'%""(% 8%#$(@&%)6'*"!% 157!, ()(+"*>*, E$!8 #4('(8 /*/ 1%,$%4<"(#$< '#%;( 8(+;* '( '#%: %;( >*#$,:, '/4G>*, >5'#$'%""6% ! 1'!;*$%4<"6% A5"/2!!, !4! >5'#$'%""6% ! '(4%'6% */$6, #('%&7*GF!%#, @&! @(#&%1#$'% 2%"$&*4<"(;( (&;*"*, $*/ ! 5@&*'4%"!% '#%. "%&'"(. #!#$%8(. ' #('(/5@"(#$!» (52, #. 186). (?"( @&!'%#$! ! 1&5;!%, #$(4< ?% @(/*+*$%4<"6% ' 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(8 @4*"%, #5?1%"!, 5>%"6: ($"(#!$%4<"( "%&*+&6'"(. #',+! #(+"*"!, # 1%,$%4<"(#$$( "*+6'*G$ 1%,$%4<"(#$*4, >$( !"$%44%/$5*4<"*, 1%,$%4<"(#$< >%4('%/* #',+*"* «# A!+!>%#/!8 #(#$(,"!%8 8(+;* ! # A!+!(4(;!>%#/!8! @&(2%##*8!, @&(!#:(1,F!8! ' "%8» ($*8 ?%, #. 153). C 2%4(8 ?%, /*/ @!#*4 QG:"%&, «@#!:!>%#/*, 1%,$%4<"(#$< %#$< A5"/2!, !4! ($@&*'4%"!% 8(+;('(. #5)#$*"2!!. L$* !#$!"* @&(#$*, ,#"* ! @(1/&%@4,%$#, )%#>!#4%""68! A*/$*8!» (52, #. 178).
262
L$* !#$!"*, 1()*'!8, )64* ,#"* ! @&(#$* $(4%8 '( '#%: %;( &*+"('!1"(#$,:. J*/, "%&*#$(&?!8*, #',+< #(+"*"!, # 1%,$%4<"(#$%'!1"(., "% @(14%?*F%. #(8"%"!G 14, A!4(#(A('–8*$%&!*4!#$(' XVIII '%/*, "*@&!8%&, 14, =(4<)*:*, @( 8"%"!G /($(&(;(, «#(+"*"!% #(#$(!$ ' ,'#$'%""(8 #($&,#%"!!, ' '(#@&!",$(. "*8! 8(1!A!/*2!! 8(+;*» (126, #. 145-146). P 1%,$%4<"(#$%4('%/* #(%1!",G$#, ' 8(+;5, ! E$($ (&;*" ,'4,%$#, "*#$(,F!8 #&%1($(>!%8 (F5F%"!.» ($*8 ?%, #. 142). N$( /*#*%$#, 8674%"!,, $( ! ("(, /*/ #>!$*4 =(4<)*:, (#5F%#$'4,%$#, $(4*%$ ($ '"%7"!: @&%18%$(' !4! '6+6'*%$ ' #%)% #*8» ($*8 ?%, #. 150). C 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! XIX '%/* "* A("% 1(#$!?%"!. %#$%#$'(+"*"!, 86#4< ( "%&*+&6'"(. #',+! #(+"*"!, # 1%,$%4<"(#$$( «8674%"!% %#$< A5"/2!, 8(+;*», «8674%"!% %#$< @&(15/$ 8(+;*», «8674%"!% %#$< 1%,$%4<"(#$< 8(+;*» (149, #. 17). L";%4<# $*/?%, /*/ ( #*8( #()(. &*+58%GF%8#,, @!#*4 ( $(8, >$( 8674%"!% ! #(+"*"!% #5$< «@&(15/$6 >%4('%>%#/(;( 8(+;*» (405, #. 34). «B(",$!, '6#7!. @&(15/$ 8(+;*, '6#7%;( @&(15/$* 8*$%&!!» (205, #. 149). «K5: %#$< '$(&!>"(%, A5"/2!, 8(+;*», – @(1>%&/!'*4 C.H. D%"!", 1()*'4,,, >$( ' E$(8 '(@&(#% «%#$%#$'(+"*"!% #$(!$ "* #$!:!."(, )%##(+"*$%4<"( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. $(>/% +&%"!,» (204, #. 88, 85). B&(,'4%"!%8 E$(. #$!:!."(. 8*$%&!*4!#$!>"(#$! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ! ,'!4(#< ' 1*""(8 #45>*% 5)%?1%"!% )(4<7!"#$'* %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* ' $(8, >$( #(+"*"!% >%4('%/* "%&*+&6'"( #',+*"( # 1%,$%4<"(#$!$%4<"(. 8%&% "* &%+54<$*$*: %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( !+5>%"!, >%4('%>%#/(. @#!:!/!. B&! E$(8 '*?"( @(1>%&/"5$<, >$(, ' @&%1#$*'4%"!! 5>%"6:, 1%,$%4<"(#$< 8(+;* (@&%1%4,%$ #(+"*"!% "% #*8* @( #%)%, "( ' %1!"#$'% # 1&5;!8! @&(,'4%"!,8! ?!+"%1%,$%4<"(#$! (&;*"!+8*. « 6 "% 8(?%8, – @!#*4 =%//%4<, – ($1%4!$< 157%'"5G ?!+"< >%4('%/* ($ (#$*4<"6: ?!+"%""6: A5"/2!.»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«#'(1!$#, / A!+!>%#/!8 ! :!8!>%#/!8 @&(2%##*8 ' /4%$/*: /(&6 )(4<7(;( 8(+;*» (97,
263
#. 12). R% #45>*."( @(E$(85 L";%4<# @!#*4 ' 1886 ;(15 ( $(. '54<;*&!+('*""(. A(&8%, ' /($(&(. 8*$%&!*4!+8 XVIII '%/* @&(1(4?*4 #5F%#$'('*$< '( '$(&(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/* ' ;(4('*: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ! '&*>%. (#8. 407, #. 286). R(, /("%>"(, )64! ' $( '&%8, ! $*/!% 5>%"6%, /($(&6% ' #(($"(7%"!! #(+"*"!, ! 8*$%&!! '!1%4! !: /(&%""(% &*+4!>!%, ,#"( (#(+"*'*4! /*>%#$'%""5G #@%2!A!/5 15:('"(;(, %;( "%#'(1!8(#$< / (1"!8 4!7< 8*$%&!*4<"68 @&(2%##*8 ' 8(+;5. =.9. D(&%"2, ' >*#$"(#$!, @!#*4: «X 1*4%/ ($ $(;(, >$()6 #'(1!$< 15:('"6% @&(2%##6 / ,'4%"!,8 ' 8*$%&!!, "%#&*'"!8(% "%4<+, '6'%#$! (1"( ($ 1&5;(;(» (219, #. 68). C 2%4(8 ?%, /*/ ,'"( '6&*?%""6. 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!. *#@%/$ 8!&('(++&%"!, 5>%"6: XIX '%/*, #4%15%$ '61%4!$< @&!+"*"!% !8! $(;(, >$( #(+"*"!% %#$< @&(15/$ 8*$%&!!, %% A5"/2!("*4<"(% #'(.#$'(. 9 $(, >$( E$( !8%""( 8*$%&!*4!+8, )64( (>%'!1"( ! 14, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%.. U*&*/$%&"( ' E$(8 ($"(7%"!! #4%15GF%% '6#/*+6'*"!% =%/#4!: «0!+!(4(;!, K%/*&$* @(1()"( #('&%8%""(. A!+!(4(;!!, 15: /($(&(. ("* @&%1'(#:!F*%$, '%1%$ @&,868 @5$%8 / 8*$%&!*4!+85 @(#$(4!$, >$( 86 "% 8(?%8 +"*$< 86#4,F%. #5)#$*"2!! '"% #5)#$*"2!!, ()4*1*GF%. @&($,?%"!%8, ! >$( 86#4< ,'4,%$#,, ' $(8 ?% #86#4%, /*/ ! 1'!?%"!%, A5"/2!%. 8*$%&!!» ([!$. @(: 308, #. 339). J*/(. @(1:(1 / @("!8*"!G #(+"*"!, ' %;( ($"(7%"!! / 8*$%&!! #(#$*'4,%$, /*/ !+'%#$"(, '*?"%.75G, "%($I%84%85G >%&$5 ! A!4(#(A#/(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* '( '#%: %;( (#"('"6: @&(,'4%"!,:. =.C. B4%:*"(' @( @('(15 @&!'%1%""(;( '67% '6#/*+6'*"!, =%/#4! @!#*4: « *$%&!*4!+8 ' $(8 '!1%, /*/ (" )64 &*+&*)($*" ' '(#%8"*12*$(8 #$(4%$!! ! /*/ (" )64 @&!",$ (#"('*$%4,8! #(2!*4!+8*, ,'4,%$#, $%(&!%., /($(&*, 5>!$ "*#, >$( «86 "% 8(?%8 +"*$< 86#4,F%. #5)#$*"2!! '"% #5)#$*"2!!, ()4*1*GF%. @&($,?%"!%8, ! >$( 86#4< ,'4,%$#,, ' $(8 ?% #86#4%, /*/ ! 1'!?%"!%, A5"/2!%. 8*$%&!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 339). (?"( / E$(85 1()*'!$<: 86#4< – ! #(+"*"!% '(()F% – ,'4,%$#, $*/?% @&(15/$(8 8*$%&!!. K4, K!2;%"*, "*@&!8%&, "% @(14%?*4( #(8"%"!G, >$( «15: %#$< @&(15/$ 8*$%&!!» (140, #. 26). L";%4<#, &*#/&6'*, E$5 #$(&("5 A%.%&)*:('#/(. A!4(#(A!!, @!#*4, >$(, #(;4*#"( 0%.%&)*:5, «"*7% #(+"*"!% ! 8674%"!%, /*/ )6 "! /*+*4!#< ("! #'%&:>5'#$'%""68!, ,'4,G$#, @&(15/$(8 '%F%#$'%""(;(, $%4%#"(;( (&;*"* – 8(+;*. *$%&!, "% %#$< @&(15/$ 15:*, * 15: %#$< 4!7< '6#7!. @&(15/$ 8*$%&!!. L$(, &*+58%%$#,, >!#$6. 8*$%&!*4!+8» (407, #. 285-286). C.H. D%"!", (@&%1%4,, ()F5G 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/5G @(+!2!G ' E$(8 '(@&(#%, @!#*4: « *$%&!, %#$< @%&'!>"(%. 3F5F%"!%, 86#4<, #(+"*"!% %#$< '6#7!. @&(15/$ (#()68 ()&*+(8 (&;*"!+('*""(. 8*$%&!!. J*/('6 '+;4,16 8*$%&!*4!+8* '(()F% ! *&/#*–L";%4<#*, ' >*#$"(#$!» (204, #. 50). H %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4!, ,#"( ! "%1'5#86#4%""( '6&*+!' *"*4(;!>"5G $(>/5 +&%"!, "* #(+"*"!%, $%8 #*868 ()I%/$!'"( +*,'!4! ( #'(%. @&!"*14%?"(#$! / 8*$%&!*4!+85, :($, ! '( 8"(;(8 #$!:!."(85, %#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/(85. « *$%&!, %#$< @%&'!>"(%, 86#4<, #(+"*"!%, (F5F%"!% – @&(15/$ (>%"<
264
'6#(/(;( &*+'!$!,. J*/('* 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/*, $%(&!, @(+"*"!,, "* /($(&(. #$!:!."( #$(!$ %#$%#$'(+"*"!%» ($*8 ?%, #. 72). L$* @(+!2!, %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, /*/ 5?% ($8%>*4(#<, ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% (@&%1%4,4*#< &%+54<$*$*8! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( !+5>%"!, &*+4!>"6: @&(,'4%"!. 1%,$%4<"(#$! ;(4('"(;( 8(+;* >%4('%/*. R(, "*1( #/*+*$<, $*/!: &%+54<$*$(' – 1(#$*$(>"( #5F%#$'%""6: @( #'(%85 "*5>"(85 /*>%#$'5 – ' #%&%1!"% XIX '%/* )64( %F% (>%"< 8*4(, $*/ /*/ #!#$%8*$!>%#/(%, #@%2!*4!+!&('*""(% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(% !+5>%"!% 8(+;* $(;1* A*/$!>%#/! $(4!"*4(#<. R% 51!'!$%4<"( @(E$(85, >$( 14, 5>%"6:, * &*'"( ! A!4(#(A(' ' @&()4%8% #(+"*"!, )64( $*/ 8"(;( "%,#"(;(, "%@(",$"(;(. -. C!&:(', "*@&!8%&, 5$'%&?1*4, >$( «/*/ 14, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,, $*/ ! 14, A!4(#(A*, ! 14, $(;( ! 1&5;(;( '8%#$%, #(+"*"!% %#$< A*/$ #$(4%4('%/* %F% ?1*4* #'(%;( "*14%?*F%;( &%7%"!,. B%&%1 "*)!&*GF%. #!46 "*5/(. >%4('%>%#/!. 8(+; # %;( #@(#()"(#$$( $*/(% #(+"*"!%, 8674%"!%? – ()&%$*4* @(#$%@%""( A(&85 "*5>"6: @&()4%8, ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!%, "*&,15 # A!4(#(A!%., "% )%+ (#"('*"!, @&%$%"1('*4( "* &(4< L1!@*. O#@%:! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, '( 8"(;!: 1&5;!: ()4*#$,: @!$*4! ' 5>%"6: "*1%?15 "* $(, >$( ! E$* +*;*1/* ' /("2% /("2(' )51%$ &%7%"*. R( "* @5$! / %% 5#@%7"(85 &%7%"!G "%():(1!8( @&%(1(4%$< +"*>!$%4<"6% $&51"(#$! – /*/ ' #*8(8 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!!, $*/ ! +* %;( @&%1%4*8!, ' #A%&% 8!&('(++&%">%#/!: (#86#4%"!. @&!&(16 #(+"*"!,. M*/ ($8%>*4 !+'%#$"6. @#!:(4(; P.D. -5)!"7$%.", «#(($"(7%"!% #(+"*"!,, 86#4!, '(()F% @#!:!>%#/!: ,'4%"!. ! 8*$%&!*4<"(;( 8!&* – (1"* !+ $&51"%.7!: ! (#$&%.7!:, %#4! "% @&(#$( $&51"%.7*, ! (#$&%.7*, !+ '#%: @&()4%8, /($(&6% /(;1*-4!)( #$(,4! @%&%1 >%4('%>%#/(. 86#4!%8 )(&<)6 8!&('(++&%"!.» (333, #. 7). B(",$"(, >$( 5>%"6%, ()&*$!'7!#< / "%+'*"(. @&()4%8%, "% 8(;4! (#$*'*$<#, ' #$(&("% ($ E$(. )(&<)6. § 2. $82H3DB; 42CE;E=9 = =7D;3=CB: H28OH; B=8252CC8DE=G K4, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* (>%'!1"(. )64* !#/4G>!$%4<"*, '*?"(#$<, "*5>"*, +"*>!8(#$< @&()4%86 #(+"*"!,. C $( ?% '&%8, E$* @(#4%1",, &*##8*$&!'*4*#< !8! ! /*/ "*!)(4%% #4(?"*, ! $&51"*, 14, @(+"*"!, "*5>"*, @&()4%8*. «X'4%"!,, ()6/"('%""( ()(+"*>*%86% #4('*8! 5;3*9"%( >',"8, !4! @#!:!>%#/*, 1%,$%4<"(#$<, – @!#*4 L. =%//%4<, – ,'4,G$#,, # (1"(. #$(&("6, #*868! '*?"68! ! !"$%&%#"68!, * # 1&5;(. – "*!)(4%% #4(?"68! ! +*;*1(>"68! !+ '#%: !+'%#$"6: "*8 ,'4%"!.» (95, #. 147). J*/(% '(#@&!,$!% @&()4%86 #(+"*"!, ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% ()5#4('4!'*4(#< #@%2!A!/(. #*8(;( ()I%/$* !+5>%"!, – 8(+;*, /*/ (&;*"* #(+"*"!,, 8674%"!,, "%()6>"(#$
265
/(;1* ()I%/$ !+5>%"!, – 86#4,F!. 8(+; – ' !+'%#$"(8 #86#4% '6#$5@*%$ (1"('&%8%""( ! /*/ %;( #5)I%/$. 9/*1%8!/ H.B. B*'4(' ' 1909 ;(15 @!#*4, >$( «"%51%&?!86. #( '&%8%" =*4!4%, :(1 %#$%#$'(+"*"!, '@%&'6% +*8%$"( @&!(#$*"*'4!'*%$#, @%&%1 '6#7!8 ($1%4(8 8(+;*, !4!, ()F%% ;('(&,, @%&%1 (&;*"(8 #4(?"%.7!: ($"(7%"!. ?!'($"6: / '"%7"%85 8!&5. H /*+*4(#<, >$( E$( – "%1*&(8, >$( +1%#< – 1%.#$'!$%4<"( /&!$!>%#/!. 8(8%"$ %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, $*/ /*/ 8(+;, /($(&6. ' '6#7%. %;( A(&8*2!! – >%4('%>%#/(;( 8(+;* – #(+1*'*4 ! #(+1*%$ %#$%#$'(+"*"!%, #*8 #$*"('!$#, ()I%/$(8 E$(;( %#$%#$'(+"*"!,» (295, #. 29). M E$(85 '6#/*+6'*"!G A!+!(4(;* 8(?"( 1()*'!$< *"*4(;!>"(% '6#/*+6'*"!% @#!:(4(;*, P.D. -5)!"7$%."*. M*#*,#< @&()4%86 #(($"(7%"!, #(+"*"!, ! 8*$%&!!, (" @!#*4: «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« (+;! N$( 86 +"*%8 ( 8(+;% ! ( #',+! 8674%"!, # "!8?» 3$'%>*, "* E$($ '(@&(#, D. 0%.%&)*: @!#*4: «R!>%;( (@&%1%4%""(;(; %#4! 5;(1"(, 1*?% &('"( "!>%;(»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«H8%""( @($(85, >$( 86 "!>%;( "% +"*%8 (( #',+! 8674%"!, # 8(+;(8. – C.3.), 86
266
'#4%1#$'!% !+'%#$"(. «)(,+"! @5#$($6» !4! @( *"*4(;!! # "%G 1(@(4",%8 @5#$($5 "*7%;( "%+"*"!, '(()&*?*%8(. ! '68674%""(. #5F"(#$!"(. #*8(;( #%),. H "%$ "!>%;( 51!'!$%4<"(;( ' $(8, >$( 86 8*4( +"*%8 !4! 1*?% "!>%;( "% +"*%8 ( #*8(8 )4!+/(8 / "*8, @( /&*."%. 8%&% "% +"*%8 "!>%;( (@&%1%4%""(;(»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«M(;1* ' )515F%8, – @!#*4 (", – 4G1! )515$ $&*$!$< #$(4!, !:, $(;1* ("!, /("%>"(, 45>7% 5+"*G$ #',+< 8674%"!, # 8(+;(8» ($*8 ?%, #. 547). W1!"#$'( 15:('"(;( ! 8*$%&!*4<"(;( '(@4(F*%$#, ' 1%,$%4<"(#$! 86#4,F%;( 8(+;*. *$%&!*4<"(#$< @(#4%1"%;( #(+1*'*4* '(+8(?"(#$< @&!8%"%"!, $(>"6: %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: 8%$(1(' !+5>%"!, &*+4!>"6: @&(,'4%"!. %;( 1%,$%4<"(#$!, #$!854!&('*4* #(($'%$#$'5GF!. @(!#/ &%7%"!, +*;*1/! #(+"*"!,. «P()#$'%""*, #5F"(#$< #(+"*"!,, – @!#*4 =%//%4<, – /*?%$#, "*8 (>%"< +*;*1(>"(.» (97, #. 127). H %#4! ' "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 @(+"*"!! E$* +*;*1(>"(#$< #(+"*"!, &(?1*4* !"$%&%# / "%85, @()5?1*4* / %;( 1%$*4<"68 !##4%1('*"!,8, /($(&6% ' /("%>"(8 !$(;% @&!'(1!4! / )(4%% !4! 8%"%% (1"(+"*>"68 '6'(1*8, $( ' 58(+&!$%4<"(8 @4*"% – ! ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!!, ! +* %;( @&%1%4*8! – ("*, @( 8"%"!G 5>%"6:, ()5#4('4!'*4* &*+4!>"6%, @(1>*# @&,8( @&($!'(@(4(?"6% @(+!2!!, @!$*4* &*+"(;( &(1* 1(86#46, &%4!;!(+"6%, !1%*4!#$!>%#/!% @&%1#$*'4%"!,. «P(+"*"!%, – @!#*4 =%//%4<, – ' )(4<7%. #$%@%"!, >%8 '#,/*, 1&5;*, @#!:!>%#/*, A5"/2!,, 1*'*4* @('(1 / (7!)(>"68 @&%1#$*'4%"!,8 ( /*/(.-$( «"%8*$%&!*4<"(. 15:('"(. #5F"(#$!» ! / #',+*""68 # "!8! #5%'%&!,8 ( «4!>"(8 )%##8%&$!!», / "!8 #'(1,$#,, ' /("2% /("2(', 8"(;!% !+ $,;>*.7!: +*)45?1%"!., ;(#@(1#$'5GF!: %F% ! @("6"% ' "*7%. #('&%8%""(. «/54<$5&"(.» ?!+"!». =%//%4< "*+'*4 #(+"*"!% «2%"$&*4<"(. @#!:(4(;!>%#/(. $*."(.». 3"(, @( %;( 8"%"!G, – «/&%@/*, 2!$*1%4< '#%'(+8(?"6: 8!#$!>%#/!: ! 15*4!#$!>%#/!: +*)45?1%"!., ( 8(;5>!% $'%&16"! /($(&(. ;&(+,$ &*+)!$<#, '#% @&!#$5@6 "*!45>7% '((&5?%""(;( &*+58*» (95, #. 217). R% #45>*."( @(E$(85, >$( !8%""( ' &%7%"!! @&()4%86 #(+"*"!, (#()%""( (#$&(. )64* !1%."*, )(&<)* 8%?15 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 !
267
!1%*4!+8(8, )(&<)*, ' /($(&5G ' $(. !4! !"(. 8%&% '('4%/*4!#< ! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4!. H: @(+!2!! @&! E$(8 1*4%/( "% '#%;1* ! "% 5 '#%: #('@*1*4!, "(, /*/ $%"1%"2!G, ()F5G 14, )(4<7!"#$'* '61*GF!:#, 5>%"6:, #4%15%$ '61%4!$< !: #/4(""(#$< – +*>*#$5G #$!:!."5G, "%#(+"*'*%85G – / 8*$%&!*4!+85 ! #(($'%$#$'%""( – "%;*$!'"(% ($"(7%"!% / !1%*4!+85, "%@&!,$!% @&!"2!@(' %;( @(1:(1* / ()I,#"%"!G #(+"*"!,. L$(, &*+58%%$#,, "% 8(;4( "% '6+'*$< ($&!2*$%4<"(. &%*/2!! #( #$(&("6 A!4(#(A('–!1%*4!#$(' ! !1%*4!#$!>%#/!, &%4!;!(+"( "*#$&(%""6: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. –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«'54<;*&"6.» 8*$%&!*4!+8, ! ' >*#$"(#$!, "* $% %;( #$(&("6, /($(&6% /*#*4!#< @("!8*"!, #(+"*"!,. M("2%@$5*4<"( +*/&%@4%""(% 5@(1()4%"!% 8674%"!, A!+!(4(;!>%#/!8 @&(2%##*8, $( %#$< #'%1%"!% !1%*4<"(;( / 8*$%&!*4<"(85, !: "%&*+4!>%"!%, !;"(&!&('*"!% !: /*>%#$'%""6: &*+4!>!. –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–1808). « (+;, ;('(&!4 (", @&%1"*+"*>%" 14, 8674%"!, $(>"( $*/ ?%, /*/ ?%451(/ 14, @!F%'*&%"!, !4! @%>%"< 14, ($1%4%"!, ?%4>! !+ /&('!». P*8 QG:"%&, "% ?%4*, )6$< ' >!#4% (#5?1*GF!:, ' $( ?% '&%8, #>%4 "%():(1!868 ($8%?%'*$<#, ($ $*/(;( @("!8*"!, 8674%"!,: « 6 $%8 "% 8%"%% "% 8(?%8 "*.$! E$( #&*'"%"!% @(1:(1,F!8 !4! 51*>"( '6)&*""68» (92,
268
#. 174). B( 8"%"!G QG:"%&*, «$*."* 8674%"!, +*/4G>*%$#, "% ' '%F%#$'*: 8(+;*, /*/ $*/('6:, * ' (#()(8 '!1% !: #(%1!"%"!, ! !: #('8%#$"(;( 1%.#$'!,». 3" @(1>%&/"54, >$( «58 !4! 86#4< "% #*8* 8*$%&!,, ("! 8*$%&!*4<"6 4!7< ' $(8 #86#4%, >$( @&%1#$*'4,G$#, @&(,'4%"!%8 8*$%&!*4<"(;( #5)#$&*$*, ($ /($(&(;( $*/ ?% "%($1%4!86, /*/ #!4* ($ 8*$%&!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 175). L$( 5?% )(4%% @&!%84%86., "%?%4! 5 0(;$*, @(1:(1 / @("!8*"!G 8674%"!,. R( /*/ )6 $( "! )64(, $*/(% &*##8($&%"!% #(+"*"!, ' %;( "%&*+&6'"(. #',+! # 8*$%&!%. "% 8(;4( "% '6+'*$< 8"(;(>!#4%""6: @(@6$(/ (@&('%&?%"!, #( #$(&("6 @&($!'"!/(' 8*$%&!*4!+8*, @&!>%8 /&!$!/* «'54<;*&"(;(» 8*$%&!*4!+8* (QG:"%&*, 0(;$*, (4%7($$*) @&%1#$*'4,4*#< !8! /*/ /&!$!/* 8*$%&!*4!+8* '(()F%, 8*$%&!*4!+8* /*/ $*/('(;(. 31!" !+ $*/!: @&($!'"!/(' 8*$%&!*4!+8*, A&*"25+#/!. A!4(#(A–E/4%/$!/ B. \*"% ' #'(%. /&!$!/% '(++&%"!. QG:"%&* $*/ ?%, /*/ ! (", @6$*4#, (@%&%$<#, "* %#$%#$'(+"*"!%. P(#4*'7!#< "* "%"*+'*""6: +"*8%"!$6: A!+!(4(;(', (" ($8%$!4, >$( «A!+!(4(;!, 8(+;* "*:(1!$#, %F% ' 1%$#$'% ! ($"(7%"!% 8%?15 8(+;(8 ! 86#4%#/(. ($*8 ?%, #. 234-235). B(#/(4$( 8(+; "%():(1!8 14, @&(!+'%1%"!, 86#4!, 8(; @&!1$! / +*/4G>%"!G, >$( 8(+; %#$< ! #*86. #5)I%/$ 86#4!» ($*8 ?%, #. 236-237). Q(4%% «;45)(/!.», "%?%4! 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!., '+;4,1 @&!'(1!$ \*"% / '6'(15, >$( «#5F%#$'5G$ &%7!$%4<"6% A*/$6, ($4!>!$%4<"6% >%&$6 86#4!, *)#(4G$"( "%#('8%#$!86% # 8*$%&!*4!+8(8»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«)%##8%&$"*, "*:%-*$'%78"%( #5F"(#$<, 15:('"6. *;%"$, +*;*1(>"*, 1%,$%4<"(#$< /($(&(;( "*8 #('%&7%""( "%'%1(8*. L$($ $&!'!*4<"6. '+;4,1, /*/ $*/('(., >!#$( #@!&!$5*4!#$!>%", * @&!"2!@!*4<"( @&($!'(@(4(?"6. %85 – ' !+'%#$"(8 #86#4% 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%"» (95, #. 148). H1%*4!#$!>%#/*, (#@!&!$5*4!#$!>%#/*,) /("2%@2!, 14, =%//%4,, /*/ 14, !#$!""(;( 5>%"(;(, – E$( «#'%&:I%#$%#$'%""*,» /("2%@2!,, «!)( ("* 5$'%&?1*%$ "*4!>"(#$< #!4, #5F%#$'5GF!: ! 1%.#$'5GF!: )%+
269
8*$%&!*4<"(. (#"('6, ("* (@!&*%$#, "* @&%1@(4(?%"!%, >$( '"% @&!&(16 ! #'%&: %% #5F%#$'5%$ «15:('"6. 8!&», "%8*$%&!*4<"6. 8!&, ( /($(&(8 !+ (@6$* 86 "!>%;( "% +"*%8, 1* @( "*7%. @&!&(1% ! "% 8(?%8 +"*$<» ($*8 ?%). B(",$"(, >$( $*/(. '+;4,1 "* #(+"*"!%, ' @&%1#$*'4%"!! 5>%"(;(, "%#('8%#$!8 # @(14!""(. "*5/(., )(4<7% $(;( – (@&('%&;*%$#, %G. M*#*,#< ;(#@(1#$'('*'7%;( ' #&%1% $%(4(;(' ! A!4(#(A('–!1%*4!#$(' @&%1#$*'4%"!, ( )%##8%&$!! 157!, =%//%4< @!#*4, >$( «%#$%#$'%""("*5>"(% 8!&('(++&%"!% XIX '%/* #('%&7%""( (@&('%&;4( E$($ '+;4,1, (@!&*,#< "* E8@!&!>%#/!% +*'(%'*"!, ' ()4*#$! A!+!(4(;!>%#/(. ! #&*'"!$%4<"(. @#!:(4(;!!»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«R* @%&'(8 @4*"% "*)4G1%"!% ! (@6$, '(-'$(&6:, !#$(&!G &*+'!$!,, * '$&%$%#/(% 58(+&%"!%, @6$*GF%%#, '(+8(?"( )4!?% @(1(.$! / "%'%1(8(. «#5F"(#$!» ,'4%"!, @5$%8 !"15/$!'"6: ! 1%15/$!'"6: 58(+*/4G>%"!.» ($*8 ?%, #. 148). B(#4%1"!%, $( %#$< A!4(#(A#/!% 58(+*/4G>%"!,, 5 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% (@&%1%4,4!#< @%&'68! 1'58,, $( %#$< #&%1#$'*8! %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/ – ' $(8 >!#4% ! @&!8%"!$%4<"( / @&()4%8% #(+"*"!,. C($ @(>%85 ' %% &%7%"!! /("2%@2!G 5>%"6: =%//%4< (@&%1%4,4 /*/ «%#$%#$'%""5G», ' @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$< !1%*4!#$!>%#/(., «#'%&:I%#$%#$'%""(.»: «W#$%#$'%""*, ?% /("2%@2!, 157%'"(. ?!+"!, +*F!F*%8*, "*8!, '!1!$ ' "%. #5885 ?!+"%""6: ,'4%"!., /($(&6% @(1()"( '#%8 1&5;!8 #',+*"6 # (@&%1%4%""68 8*$%&!*4<"68 #5)#$&*$(8». 9 E$( (+"*>*%$, >$( «%#$%#$'%""*,» /("2%@2!, #(+"*"!, ' %% A!4(#(A#/(8 '6&*?%"!! %#$< "% >$( !"(%, /*/ 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/*, /("2%@2!,. O>%"6% @(1>*# #*8! @("!8*4! E$( ! ' $%: @&%1%4*:, ' /*/!: 8*$%&!*4!+8 1(@5#/*4#, !8! ' /*>%#$'% ()(+"*>%"!, A!4(#(A#/!: '(++&%"!., ("! #>!$*4! #'(G /("2%@2!G #(+"*"!, 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(.. =%//%4< @&,8( @!7%$ () E$(8. B&!+"*' «8*$%&!*4<"5G (#"('5 '#,/(. @#!:(4(;!>%#/(. 1%,$%4<"(#$!, )%+ /($(&(. @(#4%1",, "%86#4!8*» ! 5#8($&%' E$5 (#"('5 ' (#()(8 "%&'"(8 '%F%#$'%, =%//%4< +*/4G>*%$: «C E$(8 #86#4% "*7* /("2%@2!, 8*$%&!*4!#$!>"*» ($*8 ?%, #. 149). C*?"( @&! E$(8 @(1>%&/"5$<, >$(, @&($!'(@(#$*'4,, !1%*4!+85 #'(. 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!. '+;4,1 "* #(+"*"!%, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* ' $( ?% '&%8, ,#"( (#(+"*'*4! ! (7!)(>"(#$< ($(?1%#$'4%"!, # M*)*"!#(8, 0(;$(8 ! 1&. 8*$%&!*4<"(;( ! 15:('"(;(: '8%#$% # $%8 ("! 5#8*$&!'*4! ' 8*$%&!*4!+8% 0(;$*, QG:"%&* ! @&. ! "%>$(
270
&*2!("*4<"(%, ' @&!"2!@% @&!%84%8(%, * !8%""( – @&!+"*"!% "%&*+&6'"(. #',+! #(+"*"!, # 8*$%&!%., @&!+"*"!%, @( !: 8"%"!G, )(4%% #(($'%$#$'5GF%% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"68 1*""68, "%?%4! !1%*4!#$!>%#/!. ($&6' #(+"*"!, ($ 8*$%&!!. J. =%/#4! ' #',+! # E$!8 @!#*4: «M*)*"!# 5@($&%)!4, )6$< 8(?%$, "%51*>"5G ! (7!)(>"5G A&*+5, #/*+*' >$( 8(+; '61%4,%$ 86#4<, @(1()"( $(85 /*/ @%>%"< '61%4,%$ ?%4><; "( "% ;(&*+1( 4! )(4<7% #(($'%$#$'5%$ A*/$*8 (#"('"(% @(4(?%"!%, +*/4G>%""(% ' E$(. A(&854%, >%8 ()F%&*#@&(#$&*"%""(% @&%1#$*'4%"!%, /($(&(% &*##8*$&!'*%$ 15: /*/ "%/(% 8%$*A!+!>%#/(% 2%4(%, "*:(1,F%%#,, @&*'1*, ' ;(4('%, "( "*#$(4!"('"!/ "%+*'!#!8 ($ 5@($&%)4,%8(;( !8 *@@*&*$*» ([!$. @(: 308, #. 339). R*;4,1"68 @&!8%&(8 $*/(;( "%@&!%84%8(;( 14, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. 8%$*A!+!>%#/(;( @(1:(1* / &%7%"!G @&()4%86 #(+"*"!, 8(?%$ #45?!$< @&!"2!@!*4<"*, @(+!2!, 9. Q%&;#("*. M&!$!/5, %%, H.H. %>"!/(' @&!'(1!$ ! #(($'%$#$'5GF!8 ()&*+(8 /(88%"$!&5%$ "%#/(4*#$"(#$!, 5$'%&?1*4, >$( «#(+"*"!%, "%#(8"%""(, @(1'%7%"( / 8(+;5 (@(1()"( $(85, /*/ @4*$<% 8(?%$ )6$< @(1'%7%"( / /&G>/5), "( ($#G1* %F% ($"G1< "% #4%15%$, >$()6 8(+; 8(; '(#@&(!+'%#$! '#% @(1&()"(#$! #(+"*"!,, ! >$()6 #(+"*"!% )64( ($@&*'4%"!%8 8(+;*». B( 8"%"!G Q%&;#("*, «8(+; "% %#$< 4!7< (&;*" ?%#$(', @*"$(8!86 ! $(45'#$'*, "! #(+"*"!,; "( (" ()5#4('4!'*%$ $(, >$( #(+"*"!%, >5'#$'( ! 86#4< &*#@&(#$&*",G$#, "* &%*4<"5G ?!+"< ! #$*"(',$#, #@(#()"68! / 2%4%#(()&*+"(85 1%.#$'!G» ([!$. @(: 269, #. 11). Q%&;#(" @(E$(85 5)%?1%", «>$( 15: #( '#%: #$(&(" +*:(1!$ +* @&%1%46 8(+;*, ! >$( ($@&*'4%"!, @(#4%1"%;( #(($'%$#$'5G$ 4!7< "!>$(?"(. >*#$!2% 58#$'%""(. 1%,$%4<"(#$!» ($*8 ?%, #. 12). C(+&*?*, Q%&;#("5, %>"!/(' @!7%$: «C#% E$! &*##5?1%"!,, "%#8($&, "* #'(G /*?5F5G#, ;45)!"5 ! $("/(#$<, "% 8(;5$ "! 8*4%.7!8 ()&*+(8 @(/(4%)*$< $(;( (#"('"(;( ! # 1*'"!: @(& :(&(7( !+'%#$"(;( A*/$*, >$( #(+"*"!% "*&57*%$#, '8%#$% # "*&57%"!%8 8(+;('(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! ! @&%/&*F*%$#, # @&%/&*F%"!%8 %%». P@%/54,$!'"68 &*##5?1%"!,8 Q%&;#("*, %;( >!#$( 58(+&!$%4<"68 '6'(1*8 %>"!/(' @&($!'(@(#$*'4,%$, $*/!8 ()&*+(8, (>%'!1"6% A*/$6, @(1$'%&?1*GF!%, @( %;( 8"%"!G, +*'!#!8(#$< #(+"*"!, ($ #(#$(,"!, 8(+;*, ($ %;( 1%,$%4<"(#$!: «R% $(4%#/!8 @('&%?1%"!%8, "( ! $% "%+"*>!$%4<"6% !+8%"%"!, 8(+;('(. 1%,$%4<"(#$!, /($(&6% "*)4G1*G$#, '( #"% !4! ' #!4<"(8 4!:(&*1(>"(8 #(#$(,"!!, '@(4"% 1(#$*$(>"6 14, $(;(, >$()6 !+'&*$!$< #(+"*"!%» ($*8 ?%). M #!4% A*/$(' %>"!/(' 1()*'4,%$ ! #!45 4(;!/!. C >*#$"(#$!, 5#8($&%' ' 8%>$*: 4G1%. ( )%##8%&$!! 157! (#"('5 A!4(#(A#/!:, !1%*4!#$!>%#/!: @&%1#$*'4%"!. ( "%+*'!#!8(#$! #(+"*"!, ($ 1%,$%4<"(#$! 8(+;*, (" $*/ 1(/*+6'*%$ !: )%#@(>'%""(#$<: «M(;1* 4G1! 8%>$*G$ ( )%##8%&$!! 157! ! 5)*G/!'*G$ #%), "*1%?1(. '#$&%$!$< "* $(8 #'%
%$ 271
)4!+/!: #%&125, $( !8 "% @&!:(1,$ ' ;(4('5 @%&#@%/$!'6 (>5$!$<#, $*8 # $(. #$%@%""(, #4%1('*$%4<"(, "%1(&*+'!$!, 1%$#/(;( 8(+;* !4! ()'%$7*"!, #$*&>%#/(;( 8(+;*, >$()6 "!+'%#$! "*75 #(+"*$%4<"5G ?!+"< "* "!/%8 "% ?%4*$%4<"5G #$5@%"<. M*/ ?% @&! E$(8 %F% @(8674,$< ( #(+"*"!!, @(#4% @&%'&*F%"!, 8(+;* ' 8%&$'5G )%#A(&8%""5G 8*##5» ($*8 ?%, #. 12-13). B(@6$/! Q%&;#("* *@%44!&('*$< / "*5/% /*?5$#, %>"!/('5 $F%$"68!, )%+(#"('*$%4<"68!: «B(/*+*', >$( "*5/* "% &*+&%7!4* '(@&(#* ( $(8, /*/ ' 8(+;5 ($1%4<"6% '@%>*$4%"!, 8(;5$ ()()F*$<#, ' 2%4<"(% @&%1#$*'4%"!%, #(:&*",%8(% ' @*8,$!, Q%&;#(" +*/4G>*%$ !+ E$(;(, >$( 15: "%+*'!#!8 ($ 8(+;*. R( !+ %;( /&!$!/! 8(?%$ )6$< $(4%#/! '6'%1%"(, >$( @&%1#$*'4%"!% () ($@%>*$6'*"!! ()&*+(' ' 8(+;('6: /4%$/*: "%1(#$*$(>"( '6,#"%"(, * "!/*/ "% $(, >$( @*8,$< %#$< ($@&*'4%"!% 157!, "%+*'!#!8(% ($ $%4*» ($*8 ?%, #. 13). W#4! Q%&;#(", "*#$*!'*, "* "%+*'!#!8(#$! 15:* ($ 8(+;*, '#% ?% @&!+"*'*4, >$( #(+"*"!% (@&%1%4%""68 ()&*+(8 «@(1'%7%"(» / 8(+;5, $( %#$< /*/-$( #',+*"( # "!8, $( )64! ! $*/!% A!4(#(A6, /($(&6% ($&!2*4! '#,/5G #',+< #(+"*"!,, 8674%"!, # 1%,$%4<"(#$!$*4, >$( «8(+; "% %#$< "! 8%#$(@&%)6'*"!%, "! #%1*4!F%, "! @&(!+'(1!$%4<, "! (&51!% !4! (&;*", "! "(#!$%4< !4! #5)#$&*$ ! $.1. 8674%"!,. 674%"!% "% %#$< "! ()!$*$%4<, "! @('%4!$%4<, "! 1&5;*, @(4('!"* !4! #$(&("* ! $.1., "( &*'"68 ()&*+(8 ! "% @&(15/$, 1*?% "% A!+!(4(;!>%#/*, A5"/2!, !4! :($, )6 1*?% '(()F% /*/!%-4!)( #(#$(,"!% :!,#%» (3, #. 69). « 674%"!% 8(+;*» 9'%"*&!5# &*##8*$&!'*4 /*/ (1"( !+ @&(,'4%"!. «A%$!7!+8* %#$%#$'(+"*"!,» (#8. $*8 ?%, #. 62). P'(G @&!"2!@!*4<"5G @(+!2!G ' 1*""(8 '(@&(#% 9'%"*&!5# (@&%1%4,4 /*/ !1%*4!#$!>%#/5G, @&!+"*' ' $( ?% '&%8,, >$( ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!! @&%()4*1*%$ 8*$%&!*4!+8 («&%*4!+8»). «H %#4! ,, @(#4%1('*$%4<"( &*##5?1*,, – @!7%$ (", – '"('< @&!7%4 / !1%*4!+85 ! / «#(+"*"!G, /*/ "%@(#&%1#$'%""( 1*""(85» !, #4%1('*$%4<"(, / %1!"#$'%""( 1(@5#$!8(. !#:(1"(. $(>/%, $( '6:(1!$, >$( , '&*F*4#, ' "*#$(,F%8 /&5;% !, ' /("2% /("2(', #"('* (>5$!4#, "* «#/51"(8 @*#$)!F%» A!4(#(A#/(;( !1%*4!+8*, * '(/&5; 8%", &*##$!4*4#, (@,$<-$*/! +*;&*?1%""6. ($ 8%", «+%4%"6. 45;» $*/ "*+6'*%8(;( &%*4!+8*, "* /($(&(8 $*/ @67"( &*#2'%$*G$ %#$%#$'%""6% "*5/!» ($*8 ?%, #. IX). C &*8/*: E$(;( &%*4!+8* (8*$%&!*4!+8*) %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/, ' @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$< A!4(#(A#/(. @(+!2!! 9'%"*&!5#* ' @("!8*"!! #(+"*"!,, C.H. C%&"*1#/!. ($8%$!4 ' 1901 ;(15: «P!4<"68 '(+&*?%"!%8 # "*5>"(. $(>/! +&%"!, @&($!' "%+*'!#!8(#$! 15:* ($ 8*$%&!! ,'4,%$#, $(, >$( «15:» ! 15:('"(% "*>*4( #',+*"( 4!7< # "%)(4<7(., &%+/( ()(#()4%""(. >*#$%, @#!:!>%#/!% @&(,'4%"!, !+'%#$"6 $(4"(#$< $*/(;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( ()I,#"%"!, #(+"*"!, – >%&%+ #(%1!"%"!, 5;4%&(1*, >%&%+ 1%,$%4<"(#$< 8*$%&!*4<"(;( (&;*"* (8(+;*) – )64* (>%'!1"(. ! 14, @&($!'"!/(' 8*$%&!*4!+8*. J*/, ' @%&'(.
272
?% &%2%"+!! "* &*)($5 «-%A4%/#6 ;(4('"(;( 8(+;*» %% *'$(&, H. . P%>%"(', )64 @&%1#$*'4%" /*/ 8*$%&!*4!#$, @(#4%1('*$%4< QG:"%&*: «P$*$<, E$*, "%#8($&, "* 5'%&%"!% *'$(&* ' (&!;!"*4<"(#$! %;( @(86#4(', "% >$( !"(%, /*/ &*+'!$!% ! @&!8%"%"!% / @&%18%$5, )6$< 8(?%$, #*8(85 F%/($4!'(85, ()F!: @(4(?%"!. 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. 1(/$&!"6, +*/4G>*GF%. ' !+'%#$"(8 "%8%2/(8 #(>!"%"!! « *$%&!, ! #!4*», /($(&(% @&!",$( +* /*$%:!+!# "*5>"(;( '%&(!#@('%1*"!, )(4<7!"#$'(8 "*7%;( 8(4(1(;( @(/(4%"!,» ([!$. @(: 419, #. 337). M("%>"(, "%4<+, #/*+*$<, >$( '#% )%+ !#/4G>%"!, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( @%&!(1* &*+1%4,4! 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/5G @( #'(%. #5$! $(>/5 +&%"!, ' '(@&(#% ( #(+"*"!!. Q64! ! #&%1! "!: #'(! !1%*4!#$6, @&($!'"!/! 8*$%&!*4!+8*. M*/ ($8%$!4 -. C!&:(', «! 8%?15 "*$5&*4!#$*8! %#$< #@!&!$5*4!#$6»; @&! E$(8 :*&*/$%&"(, >$( «%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%8 ('4*1%'*%$ #@!&!$5*4!+8 ()6/"('%""( $*8, ;1% (" "*$*4/!'*%$#, "* "%+"*/(85G %85 ()4*#$< @&!&(16» (66, #. 94). J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, *";4!.#/!. A!+!/ 3. D(1?, '(+&*?*, )!(4(;5 =%//%4G # @(+!2!. #@!&!$5*4!+8* (!1%*4!+8*), @!#*4: « 6 "% #(;4*#!4!#<, >$( 15: (;&*"!>%" 8*$%&!*4<"68! @&(,'4%"!,8!: 86 "% #8%%8 5$'%&?1*$<, )51$( )%+ 8*$%&!! "% 8(?%$ #5F%#$'('*$< '#% $(, >$( 86 "*+6'*%8 15:(8, &*+58(8 ! #(+"*"!%8. K5: 8(?%$ '#%4,$<#, ' 8*$%&!G !4! '(@4(F*$<#, ' "%., "( ' $( ?% '&%8, (" 8(?%$ )6$< ! $&*"#2%"1%"$"68 @( ($"(7%"!G / "%.» (216, #. 84-85). K5:, #4%1('*$%4<"(, @%&'!>%" @( ($"(7%"!G / 8*$%&!!, '(+1%.#$'5%$ "* "%%, (@&%1%4,%$ A(&86 %% #5F%#$'('*"!, ! &*+'!$!,: «8*$%&!, ,'4,%$#, @&('(1"!/(8 15:*, "( @(#4%1"!. ;(#@(1#$'5%$ "*1 "%. ! @&%'(#:(1!$ %%» ($*8 ?%, #. 94). M&!$!/5, E$5 A!4(#(A#/5G @(+!2!G A!+!/*, H.H. %>"!/(' ($8%$!4, >$( ' %% ()(#"('*"!% D(1? #()&*4 «'#%, >$( $(4%&%+ @(#&%1#$'( 8%1!58(', !, #4%1('*$%4<"(, '%&5 ' )%##8%&$!% 157!… W85 :($%4(#< )6 "*.$! "*5>"(% 1(/*+*$%4<#$'( #5F%#$'('*"!, 157! )%+ $%4%#"(. ()(4(>/!, ! (" '6)!'*%$#, !+ #!4, >$()6 5)%1!$<#, ' E$(8». R( '#% $*/(;( &(1* 5#!4!, ()&%>%"6 "* "%51*>5. H @($(85 #@!&!$!+8 "% "*#>!$6'*%$ 8"(;( @(#4%1('*$%4%.» (269, #. 21, 22). P5)I%/$!'"(–!1%*4!#$!>%#/(% @("!8*"!% #(+"*"!, $*/?% !8%4( #'(!: #$(&(""!/(' #&%1! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX – "*>*4* UU ''., @&%?1% '#%;( ' 4!2% L. *:* ! %;( @(#4%1('*$%4%.. V1%#<, "%#(8"%""(, #/*+*4(#< '4!,"!% !1%*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!!, 5#'*!'*'7%.#, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8! ' 8(4(1(#$!, ' #$51%">%#/!% ;(16 >%&%+ 5"!'%&#!$%$#/!% /5, ' /($(&6: 1(8!"!&('*4( !+4(?%"!% '+;4,1(' $*/!:, "*@&!8%&, A!4(#(A(', /*/ Q%&/4!, S8, M*"$ ! 1&. M*/ !+'%#$"(, *: ! %;( @(#4%1('*$%4!, @(1()"( Q%&/4!, @&!+"*'*4! %1!"#$'%""( &%*4<"68! $(4"!/* – 8*$%&!! ' %% /("/&%$"6: ('%F%#$'4%""6: @&(,'4%"!,:. *:, "*@&!8%&, @!#*4: «C @(4% '(#@&!,$!, /*?1(;( (&;*"* >5'#$' %#$< >*#$<, (/*+6'*GF*, "* '#% (#$*4<"6% >*#$!
273
!"(% ! )(4%% #!4<"(% '4!,"!%, >%8 E$! (#$*4<"6% >*#$! (1"* "* 1&5;5G. R( E$!8 #/*+*"( '#%. C'!15 E$(;( 86 91* E4%8%"$6, @(#/(4*#$! (($ "*7%;( $%4*), "*+6'*%8 !?;?*"'(:'. C E$(8 #86#4% 8!&, 1%.#$'!$%4<"(, %#$< "*7% (F5F%"!%» (255, #. 168). J*/(. @(1:(1 / @&()4%8% #(+"*"!,, @(1:(1 #5)I%/$!'"(!1%*4!#$!>%#/!. ' #'(%. (#"('% – $*/?% @(1'%&;*4#, /&!$!/% #( #$(&("6 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., ' )(4<7!"#$'% #'(%8 "*#$&(%""6: 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!. R%#45>*."( #*8 *: @&!+"*'*4, >$( ($ %;( $(>/! +&%"!,, !+4(?%""(. '67%, «1*4%/! %#4! "% A!4(#(A6, $( )(4<7!"#$'( %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%.» ($*8 ?%). *: ($8%$!4 $*/?%, >$( @%&'6% %;( &*)($6 «'#$&%$!4! /&*."% :(4(1"6. ! 1*?% ($&!2*$%4<"6. @&!%8, /*/ #( #$(&("6 A!+!/(', $*/ ! #( #$(&("6 A!4(#(A(', %#4! "% #>!$*$< "%/($(&6: "%8"(;!: 4!2». K( 80-: ;(1(' XIX '%/*, @!#*4 1*4%% *:, «, >5'#$'('*4 #%), $*/, )51$( , (1!" @46'5 @&($!' ()F%;( $%>%"!,» (252, #. 127). 31!" !+ $%:, /$( "*@&*'4,4 $(;1* E$( «()F%% $%>%"!%» ' 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(% &5#4(, D. Q(4<28*", /*#*,#< #5)I%/$!'"(– !1%*4!#$!>%#/(. #5F"(#$! A!4(#(A#/(. @(+!2!! *:*, @!#*4: «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«X/()6 «"('5G», «A%"(8%"(4(;!>%#/5G» $(>/5 +&%"!, *:* ! M° E$($ A!+!/ '@(4"% +*#45?%""( $&%$!&5%$, /*/ #$*&5G "%4%@(#$< A!4(#(A#/(;( #5)I%/$!'"(;( !1%*4!+8*» (204, 95-96). C(@&%/! (1"(#$(&(""(#$,8 !1%*4!+8* – /*/ ()I%/$!'"(;(, $*/ ! #5)I%/$!'"(;(, – *)#(4G$!+!&('*'7%;( ' ()I,#"%"!! #(+"*"!, /*/5G-$( (1"5 :*&*/$%&!#$!/5 – ()I%/$!'"(#$< !4! #5)I%/$!'"(#$<, – 5>%"6% '61%4,4! ! &*+4!>*4! ' #(+"*"!! ()% E$! #$(&("6, &*##8*$&!'*4! !: ' %1!"#$'%, '+*!8(1(@(4",%8(#$!. « 6 &*+4!>*%8, – @!#*4 =%//%4<, – 1'% ;4*'"6: ()4*#$! #(+"*"!, – ()I%/$!'"5G ! #5)I%/$!'"5G, #(+"*"!% 8!&* ! #(+"*"!% #*8(;( #%),» (95, #. 218). 3)I%/$!'"(#$< :*&*/$%&!+5%$, /&(8% $(;(, ! '"5$&%""!% @&(2%##6 ' >%4('%>%#/(8 (&;*"!+8%, !: #5)I%/$!'"68 ($&*?%"!%8 ! ,'4,%$#, #(+"*"!%. =%//%4< @(E$(85 ! (@&%1%4,4 #(+"*"!% /*/ «#5)I%/$!'"(% ($&*?%"!% ()I%/$!'"6: '"5$&%""!: @&(2%##('» ($*8 ?%, #. 180). 3$#G1* ! (#()%""(#$! !+5>%"!, #(+"*"!,: «M ()6/"('%""(85, ()I%/$!'"(85, '"%7"%85 "*)4G1%"!G 1(4?%" +1%#< @&!#(%1!"!$<#,
274
!"$&(#@%/$!'"6. 8%$(1, #5)I%/$!'"(% '"5$&%""%% "*)4G1%"!%, ()5#4('4!'*%8(% ($&*?%"!%8 "*7%;( «X» ' #(+"*"!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 152). 9"*4!+ /("2%@$5*4<"(;( #(1%&?*"!, '(++&%"!. 5>%"6:– %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* "* @&!&(15 #(+"*"!, @&%1@(4*;*%$ ! #(@5$#$'5GF%% &*##8($&%"!% @&()4%86 9!,"'6"!9*"'( ! $%,9'-'( #(+"*"!, –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§ 3. $82=4Q2M7DE=D ID325D<;: >27Q27 < >82H3DBD P5F"(#$"(85 &%7%"!G %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8! XIX '%/* @&()4%86 '(+"!/"('%"!, >%4('%/* ! >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,, /*/ ! '( 8"(;!: 1&5;!: #45>*,:, ' &%7*GF%. #$%@%"! #@(#()#$'('*4* (@(&* "* #(($'%$#$'5GF!. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. 8*$%&!*4, ' 1*""(8 #45>*% – "* 1(#$!?%"!, *"$&(@(4(;!!, @#!:(4(;!!, A!+!(4(;!!, E8)&!(4(;!!, #&*'"!$%4<"(. *"*$(8!! ! "%/($(&6: 1&5;!: %#$%#$'%""6: "*5/. 3#()%""( )(4<75G &(4< ' 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/(8 (#"*F%"!! ! ' A*/$!>%#/(8 ()(#"('*"!! A!4(#(A#/(;( @("!8*"!, '(+"!/"('%"!, >%4('%/* #6;&*4( E'(4G2!(""(% 5>%"!% K*&'!"*. Q4*;(1*&, %85, @( #4('*8 L";%4<#*, )64* 1*"* «(#"('* 14, @&%16#$(&!! >%4('%>%#/(;( 15:*, 14, @&(#4%?!'*"!, &*+4!>"6: #$5@%"%. %;( &*+'!$!,, "*>!"*, ($ @&(#$(., )%##$&5/$5&"(., "( (F5F*GF%. &*+1&*?%"!, @&($(@4*+86 "!+7!: (&;*"!+8(' ! /(">*, 86#4,F!8 8(+;(8 >%4('%/*. 9 )%+ E$(. @&%16#$(&!! #5F%#$'('*"!% 86#4,F%;( >%4('%>%#/(;( 8(+;* (#$*%$#, >51(8» (406, #. 512). P*8 K*&'!" @&!+"*'*4, >$( «@&!"2!@ E'(4G2!! 8(?%$ (#'%$!$< "%/($(&6% !+ "*!)(4%% #4(?"6: @&()4%8 %#$%#$'%""(. !#$(&!! >%4('%/*» (142, #. 645). B&!8%"%"!% @&!"2!@* E'(4G2!! / ()I,#"%"!G '(+"!/"('%"!, >%4('%/* ! >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!, )64( '*?"( "% $(4!#$( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: @&()4%8, "( ! 14, (@&%1%4%"!, 8!&('(++&%">%#/!: @(+!2!. 5>%"6:. R*5>"6% (#"('*"!, E$!: @(+!2!. 5/&%@4,4!#< @( 8%&% 5#$&*"%"!, (#$*$/(' 1("*5>"(;( 8674%"!,, /($(&6% @&(,'4,4!#<, ' >*#$"(#$!, ! ' $(8, >$(, @( #'!1%$%4<#$'5 =%//%4,, «851&(% !
275
2%4%#(()&*+"(% 5#$&(.#$'( (&;*"!+('*""(;( #5F%#$'* @&!'(1!$ "%@(#&%1#$'%""( / #&*'"%"!G @(#4%1"%;( # @4*"(8%&"68, !#/5#"68 @&(!+'%1%"!%8 &5/ >%4('%/*, * "%(@&%1%4%""(% @&%1#$*'4%"!% ( «4!>"(8 )(;%» @&%'&*F*%$#, ' @(",$!% #(+!1*GF%;( #(;4*#"( (@&%1%4%""(85 @4*"5 $'(&2*. B(#4%1"!8 '61*GF!8#, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%8, /($(&6. @&!1%&?!'*4#, E$(;( 8"%"!,, )64 D5! 9;*##!#, 58%&7!. ' 1873 ;(15… 3" #( '#%. @(#4%1('*$%4<"(#$! @(#4%1('*$%4%8 MG'<%, #$(&(""!/(8 !1%! "%!+8%""(#$! '!1(', 5$'%&?1*4, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( «/*?16. ($1%4<"6. '!1 ' 8!&% ?!'($"6: ! &*#$%"!. E$( – «()4%>%""*, ' $%4%#"5G A(&85 $'(&>%#/*, 86#4< Q(;*» ([!$. @(: 93, #. 5). L$( @&%1#$*'4%"!% 9;*##!# &*#@&(#$&*",4 ! "* >%4('%/*, "*+6'*, %;( «'(@4(F%"!%8 $'(&>%#/(. !1%! Q(;*» ([!$. @(: 87, #. 22). P4%15%$ @(1>%&/"5$<, >$( $*/!% *@%44,2!! 9;*##!#* / Q(;5 ' :(1% &%7%"!, >!#$( "*5>"6: @&()4%8 "% )64! /*/!8-$( "%#5F%#$'%""68 1('%#/(8, ("! @&%1#$*'*4! "% /*/ >*#$"6% #5?1%"!, '%&5GF%;( :&!#$!*"!"*, )%+ /($(&6: 8(?"( )64( )6 ()(.$!#<, * /*/ (1"( !+ '*?"%.7!: +'%"<%' ' 2%@! "*5>"6: 1(/*+*$%4<#$', /*/ #*86% '%#/!% «"*5>"6%» *&;58%"$6, '*?"6% 14, 9;*##!#* /*/ 14, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,. 3 )(?%#$'%""(8 $'(&>%#/(8 @4*"% ' ()I,#"%"!! %#$%#$'%""(. #!#$%86 (&;*"!+8(' 9;*##!#, /*/ ($8%>*4 =%//%4<, «"% @%&%#$*%$ 158*$< 1*?% $(;1*, /(;1* &*##8*$&!'*%$ %#$%#$'%""5G #!#$%85 /*/ %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4<» (89, #. 56). R%#45>*."( L";%4<#, &*#/&6'*, #5F"(#$< 8%$(1(4(;!! $%: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., /($(&6% #'(! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6% '6'(16 (#"('6'*4! "* $%(4(;!>%#/!: @&%1#$*'4%"!,:, ' /*>%#$'% ()&*+>!/* $*/(;( 8674%"!, @&!'(1!$ «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« "(;(>!#4%""6% '"5$&%""!% @&($!'(&%>!, ! @(&*+!$%4<"6% "%4%@(#$! ' '(++&%"!,: 9;*##!#*, @&!'%17!% %;( / &%7!$%4<"(. )(&<)% # 5>%"!%8 ( @&(!#:(?1%"!!, – @!#*4 =%//%4<, – 1(4?"6 $%8 )(4%% '(+)51!$< "*7% 51!'4%"!%, >$( (" #'(!8! @&%?"!8! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"68! &*)($*8! '( 8"(;!: ($"(7%"!,: @(1;($('!4 @(,'4%"!% K*&'!"*, (#()%""( #'(%. 1%,$%4<"(#$%#/!: !##4%1('*"!,: 9;*##!# ($/&64 "%/($(&6% ()F!% +*/("6 &*+'!$!, (&;*"!+8(', "( (" "% #58%4 !: "*5>"(
276
()(#"('*$< ' #!45 $%(4(;!>%#/(. ()5#4('4%""(#$! #'(%. ()F%. 8!&('(++&%">%#/(. @(+!2!!. L$! +*/("6, @( 8"%"!G =%//%4,, «#$(,$ ' &%+/(8 ! "%@&!8!&!8(8 @&($!'(&%>!! #… !#$(&!%. #(+1*"!, 9;*##!#* ! #( '#%8! @&%1#$*'4%"!,8! ( 2%4%#(()&*+"(. 4!>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! P(+1*$%4,»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«R%4<+, 158*$<, >$()6 '#% E$! A*/$6 #'!1%$%4<#$'('*4! 4(?"(. J($, /$( "% #8($&!$ @(1()"( 1!/*&G "* ,'4%"!, @&!&(16 /*/ "* "%>$( )%##',+"(%, "% 8(?%$ 1*4<7% 158*$<, >$()6 >%4('%/ )64 @4(1(8 ($1%4<"(;( */$* $'(&%"!,» (142, #. 645-646). WF% )(4%% &%7!$%4<"( E$5 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/5G, *"$!$%(4(;!>%#/5G $(>/5 +&%"!, 5>%"6: '6&*+!4 QG:"%&; @( %;( 8"%"!G, #4%15%$, «#(;4*#"( "6"%7"!8 "*5>"68 '(++&%"!,8… ($"%#$! ' ()4*#$< 1*'"( (#$*'4%""6: @&%1*"!. #$*&(% '(++&%"!%, (@!&*GF%%#, "* &%4!;!(+"6% 8!A6, )51$( >%4('%/ ' '!1% ;($('(;( #(+1*"!, '67%4 !+ &5/ $'(&2* #( '#%8! @&%!85F%#$'*8! &(1*» (52, #. 142). P$(4< ?% "%@&!%84%868 14, 5>%"6: '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* (/*+*4!#< ! @&%1#$*'4%"!, ( @&!&(1% ! %% +*/("*:, )6$('*'7!% ' !1%*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! $(;( '&%8%"!, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' ;%;%4%'#/(. #!#$%8%, 14, /($(&(. )64( :*&*/$%&"( ($&!2*"!% %#$%#$'%""(. !#$(&!!, /*/ >%4('%/*, $*/ ! '#%;( &*#$!$%4<"(;( ! ?!'($"(;( 8!&*. B&!&(1* #*8* @( #%)%, @( =%;%4G, /*/ !+'%#$"(, "% &*+'!'*%$#,, &*+'!$!% @&!#5F% $(4!$*,, >$( «@&!&(1* 1(4?"* )6$< &*##8($&%"* /*/ 1'1-*:% 1-;2*"*=, /*?1*, !+ /($(&6: "%():(1!8( '6$%/*%$ !+ 1&5;(.», =%;%4< ' $( ?% '&%8, 5$'%&?1*4, >$( «+1%#< "%$ *1-*1-9*""!#! (natürlich) @&(2%##* @(&(?1%"!,, * %#$< 4!7< @(&(?1%"!% ' 4("% '"5$&%""%. !1%!, #(#$*'4,GF%. (#"('*"!% @&!&(16». *-%:!$&!,* @(1'%&;*%$#, 4!7< @(",$!% /*/ $*/('(%, $*/ /*/ 4!7< %;( !+8%"%"!, #5$< &*+'!$!%» (83, #. 33). B(E$(85 =%;%4< #>!$*4 "%():(1!868 «'(+1%&?*$<#, ($ $*/(;( &(1* $58*""6:, >5'#$'%""6: ' #'(%. (#"('% @&%1#$*'4%"!., /*/, "*@&!8%&, @&%1#$*'4%"!%… ( 2$!'1D!>5*"'' )(4%% &*+'!$6: ?!'($"6: (&;*"!+*2!. !+ "!+7!: ! $.1.» ($*8 ?%, #. 34). B(",$"(, >$( (#"('6'*GF!.#, !8%""( "* $*/(8 @&%1#$*'4%"!! 1*&'!"!+8 "% 8(; "% '6+'*$< ' 5>%"6:, &*+1%4,'7!: %;( @&!"2!@6, "%;*$!'"(% ($"(7%"!% / !1%*4!+85, (#(+"*"!% !8! "%'(+8(?"(#$! &%7*$<
277
"* %;( (#"('% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6% @&()4%86, ' $(8 >!#4% ! @&()4%85 @&(!#:(?1%"!, >%4('%/*. M("2%@2!, &*+'!$!, ' $(. %% A(&8%, ' /*/(. ("* )64* '6&*?%"* 5 =%;%4,, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. "% 5#$&*!'*4*, ! @&%?1% '#%;( – ''!15 %% !1%*4!#$!>"(#$!, ($(&'*""(#$! ($ &%*4<"6:, E8@!&!>%#/! A!/#!&5%86: 8*$%&!*4<"6: @&(2%##(', '6&*?*GF!: ! #(#$*'4,GF!: 1%.#$'!$%4<"(% &*+'!$!% @&!&(16. C ;%;%4%'#/(. #!#$%8% E$( &%*4<"(% &*+'!$!% @&!&(16, !##4%15%8(% %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8, ($'%&;*4(#<, @(18%",4(#< &*+'!$!%8 %% 15:('"(. #5F"(#$!, &*+'!$!%8, @&%1#$*'4%""68 ' %;( !1%*4<"(#$!. H"*>% ;('(&,, &*+'!$!% @&!&(16 @(18%",4(#< @&!&(1(. &*+'!$!,. P*8* ?% @&!&(1* 4!7*4*#< &*+'!$!,. «O =%;%4,, – @!#*4 L";%4<#, – @&!&(1*, /*/ @&(#$(% «($>5?1%"!%» !1%!, "% #@(#()"* / &*+'!$!G '( '&%8%"!; ("* 8(?%$ 4!7< &*+'%&$6'*$< #'(% 8"(;(()&*+!% ' @&(#$&*"#$'%, !, $*/!8 ()&*+(8, (#5?1%""*, "* '%>"(% @('$(&%"!% (1"!: ! $%: ?% @&(2%##(', ("* '6#$*'4,%$ (1"('&%8%""( ! (1"5 &,1(8 # 1&5;(. '#% +*/4G>*GF!%#, ' "%. #$5@%"! &*+'!$!,» (407, #. 287). R( 1*?% $(;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( 8*$%&!*4*, /($(&6. 5?% !8%4#, ' "*>*4% XIX '%/*, )64( 1(#$*$(>"( 14, $(;(, >$()6 5)%1!$<#, ' $%(&%$!>%#/(. "%#(#$(,$%4<"(#$! ;%;%4%'#/(;( @("!8*"!, &*+'!$!, @&!&(16, $(>"%% – %;( ($&!2*"!,. «Q%##86#4!25 &*+'!$!, ' @&(#$&*"#$'%, "( '"% '&%8%"!, – /($(&(% ,'4,%$#, (#"('"68 5#4('!%8 '#,/(;( &*+'!$!,, – =%;%4< "*',+6'*4 @&!&(1% /*/ &*+ ' $( '&%8,, /(;1* 5?% 1(#$*$(>"( )64! &*+&*)($*"6 ! ;%(4(;!,, ! E8)&!(4(;!,, ! A!+!(4(;!, &*#$%"!. ! ?!'($"6:, ! (&;*"!>%#/*, :!8!,, ! /(;1* "* (#"('% E$!: "('6: "*5/ 5?% @('#G15 +*&(?1*4!#< ;%"!*4<"6% 1(;*1/!, @&%1'(#:!F*'7!% @(+1"%.75G $%(&!G &*+'!$!,» ($*8 ?%). H %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4!, "%@(#&%1#$'%""( &*+&*)($*'7!% "%#/(4%#/(. /("2%@2!! &*+'!$!, @&!&(16 # !+5>*%868! !8! 8*$%&!*4<"68! @&(2%##*8!, "% 8(;4!, #4%1('*$%4<"(, "% ($'%&;"5$< %%. =%//%4< @!#*4 ( "%., >$( «E$( $*/ "*+6'*%8(% «&*+'!$!%» &*+58* "(#!4(#< '6#(/( "*1 @&!&(1(. ' >!#$(8 EA!&% *)#(4G$"(;( 15:* ! )64( #'()(1"( ($ '#%;( $(;( 8*$%&!*4<"(;( )*44*#$*, /($(&6. 1%.#$'!$%4<"( ($/&64* E8@!&!>%#/*, !#$(&!, &*+'!$!, '#%4%""(., +%84! ! ?!'5F!: "* "%. (&;*"!+8('» (87, #. 13). P&%1! E$(;( «8*$%&!*4<"(;( )*44*#$*» )64! ! A*/$(&6, @(1;($('!'7!% '(+"!/"('%"!% >%4('%/* ! >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,. R%#('8%#$!8(#$< &%4!;!(+"6: ! !1%*4!#$!>%#/!: @&!"2!@(', !#/4G>*GF!: #*85 86#4< ( '(+"!/"('%"!! >%4('%/* ! $%8 #*868 –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
278
>%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!, # @#!:!/(. ?!'($"6:. QG:"%&, "*@&!8%&, #>!$*4, >$( «>%4('%/ #( '#%8! #'(!8! '6#(/!8! @&%!85F%#$'*8! ! #@(#()"(#$,8! "% #(+1*"!% ()F%#$'*, * @&(15/$ @&!&(16, /*/ ! '#% (/&5?*GF!% %;( $'*&!…N%4('%/ #$(!$ "% '"% @&!&(16 !4! "*1 "%G, * '#%2%4( ' "%. #*8(.» (52, #. 141, 143). «N%4('%>%#/!. 15: %#$< @&(!+'%1%"!% @&!&(16», – 5$'%&?1*4 ! (4%7($$ (275, #. 199). -*##8*$&!'*, >%4('%/* '#%2%4( /*/ >*#$< @&!&(16, 5>%"6% $%8 #*868 *)#(4G$!+!&('*4! )!(4(;!>%#/!%, ?!'($"6% !#$(/! >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,. J*/, K*&'!" #>!$*4, >$( A!+!>%#/!% ! 58#$'%""6% !+8%"%"!, >%4('%/* «'6+6'*G$#,, @&,8( !4! /(#'%""(, $%8! ?% #*868! ()F!8! @&!>!"*8! ! @(1>!"%"6 $%8 ?% #*868 ()F!8 +*/("*8, /*/ ! 5 "!+7!: ?!'($"6:» (142, #. 171). K*&'!" '(()F% #/4("%" )64, /*/ ($8%$!4 =.C. B4%:*"(', «@&!8%",$< #'(G <'!7!#'0*16;4 $%(&!G / ()I,#"%"!G 1!+'%78".D ,'4%"!.» (308, #. 678). J%8 )(4%% E$( /*#*4(#< @&(2%##* #$*"('4%"!, >%4('%/*, @&(2%##*, ' /($(&(8 )!(4(;!>%#/!% A*/$(&6 ! "*&(?1*GF*,#, #(2!*4<"(#$< @%&%@4%4!#< ' $*/(. /45)(/, >$( $&51"( )64( )%+ #@%2!*4<"(., &'7!1!&16' (#(+"*""(. 8%$(1(4(;!! &*+()&*$<#, ' #',+,: ! @%&%:(1*: ($ (1"(;( / 1&5;(85 – ($ )!(4(;!>%#/(;( / #(2!*4<"(85. K*&'!" ! 1&5;!% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! $*/(. 8%$(1(4(;!%. "% '4*1%4! ! @($(85 !8 "% (#$*'*4(#< "!>%;( 1&5;(;(, /*/ @&!8%"!$< @&!"2!@6 #'(%. "*5/! / ()4*#$! ,'4%"!. )(4%% 7!&(/(. ! # !"68 /*>%#$'(8, "%?%4! ' !: #@%2!A!>%#/(. #A%&% @(+"*"!,. Q!(4(;!+*2!, &%7%"!, K*&'!"(8 @&()4%86 '(+"!/"('%"!, >%4('%/* @&(,'!4*#<, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' $(8, >$( (#"('"6% @&!"2!@6 #'(%;( 5>%"!, – )(&<)5 +* #5F%#$'('*"!% ! %#$%#$'%""6. ($)(& – (" &*#@&(#$&*"!4 ! "* @&(2%## A(&8!&('*"!, >%4('%/*. B( 8"%"!G K*&'!"*, @&*&(1!$%4! >%4('%/*, /*/ '#% ?!'($"6%, &*+8"(?*4!#< !"$%"#!'"%% ()&%$%"!, ' @&!&(1% "%():(1!86: #&%1#$' / #5F%#$'('*"!G, * E$( «"%!+)%?"( @&!'(1!4( / )(&<)% +* #5F%#$'('*"!% ! / %#$%#$'%""(85 ($)(&5» (142, #. 184). L$( ($"(#!4(#< ! / A(&8!&('*"!G ! #('%&7%"#$'('*"!G #(+"*"!,. «3>%"< '%&(,$"(, – @!#*4 K*&'!", – >$( 5 4G1%. 58#$'%""6% #@(#()"(#$! #('%&7%"#$'('*4!#< @5$%8 %#$%#$'%""(;( ($)(&*» ($*8 ?%, #. 241). C#% E$( @&!'(1!4( / ()F%85 '6'(15, >$( >%4('%>%#/!. &*+58 «&*+'!4#, !+ $(;( ?% &*+58*, /*/!8 ()4*1*%$ ?!'($"(%» (140, #. 288). W#$%#$'%""6. E'(4G2!(""6. @&(2%## 4%?!$ ! ' (#"('% A(&8!&('*"!, 8674%"!,. J*/('(, "*@&!8%&, 8"%"!% D. Q(4<28*"*, #>!$*'7%;(, >$( «+*/("6 8674%"!, ()&*+('*4!#< '#4%1#$'!% $(;( ?% +*/("* E'(4G2!!, /*/ (@$!>%#/!. *@@*&*$ ;4*+, !4! */5#$!>%#/!. *@@*&*$ 5:*, !4! "*;"%$*$%4<"6. *@@*&*$ #%&12*» (35, #. 170). R( $( ()#$(,$%4<#$'(, >$( K*&'!" ! 1&5;!% 5>%"6%, +*"!8*'7!%#, @&()4%8(. @&(!#:(?1%"!, >%4('%/*, )!(4(;!+!&('*4! %% ()F!% &%7%"!,, ($"G1< "% (+"*>*%$ ($#5$#$'!% ' E$!: &%7%"!,: /*/(;( )6 $( "! )64( A!4(#(A#/(;( #(1%&?*"!,. R*@&($!', #4%15%$ @(1>%&/"5$<, >$( @(45>%""6% 5>%"68! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6% &%+54<$*$6 ' "*+'*""(. ()4*#$! !##4%1('*"!. #$*4! (#"('(. ! 14, '6'(1(' ()F%;(, A!4(#(A#/(;(
279
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«()I,#",%$ @&(!#:(?1%"!% >%4('%/* ! %;( #@(#()"(#$%. # $(>/! +&%"!, <'!7!#''. R( 5 "%;( %#$< "%#/(4%"!% ! 14, 1!+'!7!#!9» (308, #. 206). P*8 K*&'!" ($8%>*4 E$( @%&%@4%$%"!% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( ! A!4(#(A#/(;( @(1:(1(' / &%7%"!G @&()4%86 '(+"!/"('%"!, >%4('%/*. 3" @!#*4, ' >*#$"(#$!: « 6#4<, >$( >%4('%/ "*&*'"% # 1&5;!8! '!1*8! ,'4,%$#, @($(8/(8 /*/(.-4!)( 1&%'"%. "!+7%. ! '68%&7%. A(&86, '('#% "% "('*. D*8*&/ 8"(;( '&%8%"! $(85 "*+*1 @&!7%4 / $*/(85 +*/4G>%"!G, ! ("( @(11%&?!'*%$#, $%@%&< 8"(;!8! +"*8%"!$68! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8! ! A!4(#(A*8!, /*/, "*@&!8%&, O(44%#(8, =%/#4!, D,.%44%8, 0(;$(8, K%))(/(8, QG:"%&(8, -(44% ! 1&.» (142, #. 134). K*&'!" (#()( '61%4,%$ @&! E$(8 =%//%4, /*/ (1"(;( !+ #'(!: )4!?*.7!: @&%17%#$'%""!/('. P(#4*'7!#<, ' >*#$"(#$!, "* %;( &*)($5 «W#$%#$'%""*, !#$(&!, 8!&($'(&%"!,», K*&'!" ($8%>*%$, >$( ' "%. =%//%4< «'#%#$(&(""% &*+()&*4 &(1(#4('"5G >%4('%/*. W#4! )6 E$* /"!;* @(,'!4*#< @&%?1%, >%8 )64( "*@!#*"( 8(% #(>!"%"!% («B&(!#:(?1%"!% >%4('%/* ! @(4('(. ($)(&». – C.3.), ,, @( '#%. '%&(,$"(#$!, "% (/(">!4 )6 %;(. B(>$! '#% '6'(16, / /($(&68 , @&!7%4, @(1$'%&?1*G$#, =%//%4%8, ! %;( +"*"!, '( 8"(;!: ($"(7%"!,: ;(&*+1( @(4"%% 8(!:» ($*8 ?%, #. 135). C6'(16, / /($(&68 @&!74! K*&'!", =%//%4< ! 1&5;!% 5>%"6%– %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4!, 4%;4! ' (#"('5 A!4(#(A#/(;(, ' >*#$"(#$!, 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(;( &%7%"!, @&()4%86 @&(!#:(?1%"!, >%4('%/*, #$*"('4%"!, ! &*+'!$!, %;( #(+"*"!,. L$! '6'(16 ' !: @(+!$!'"(8 #(1%&?*"!! "% 5$&*$!4! #'(%;( +"*>%"!, ! ' "*7! 1"!. K*'"( 5?% #$*'7!% ()F%!+'%#$"68! ! ()F%@&!+"*""68!, ("! '( '$(&(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/* '6#$5@*4! /*/ #*8("('%.7!% !#$!"6, &%'(4G2!("!+!&('*'7!% @&%1#$*'4%"!, ( >%4('%/%, ( %;( @&!&(1"(8 %#$%#$'%. 3$'4%/*,#< ($ 1%$*4%. *"*4!+*, ($ (#()%""(#$%. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(. *&;58%"$*2!! 5 /*?1(;( 5>%"(;(, ($ 1(/*+*$%4<#$', #@(&(', &*#:(?1%"!., '61%4!8 ()F%% – /("%>"6% '6'(16, !: 8!&('(++&%">%#/(%, A!4(#(A#/(% #(1%&?*"!%. § 4. 0;89B2Q2M7DE=D = F867 R*>*$<, '!1!8(, #4%15%$ # $(;(, >$(, (@!&*,#< "* E'(4G2!(""(% 5>%"!% /*/ "* 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/5G, * &*'"( ! A*/$!>%#/5G (#"('5, 5>%"6% $F*$%4<"( ! '#%#$(&(""% @&(#4%?!'*4! @&%16#$(&!G >%4('%/*. L$*
280
@(#4%1",, &*##8*$&!'*4*#< !8! /*/ E'(4G2!, ?!'($"6: A(&8 – ($ @&(#$%.7!: /( '#% )(4%% #4(?"68. -%+54<$*$(8 $*/(;( @(#$%@%""(;( &*+'!$!, ,'!4(#< '(+"!/"('%"!% 84%/(@!$*GF!:. K*&'!" @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8, >$( «84%/(@!$*GF!% @&(!+(74! ($ (1"(;( ()F%;( @&%1/*» ($*8 ?%, #. 646). =%//%4<, @(1>%&/!'*, $( ?% #*8(%, ($8%$!4, >$( «'#% /(8@%$%"$"6% 5>%"6% #>!$*G$ @&(!#:(?1%"!% '#%;( /4*##* 84%/(@!$*GF!: ($ (1"(;( ()F%;( @&%1/*… $'%&1( 5#$*"('4%""68 !#$(&!>%#/!8 A*/$(8» (87, #. 30). L'(4G2!, 84%/(@!$*GF!:, ' #'(G (>%&%1<, (#5F%#$'4,4*#< @(#$(,""( ' "*@&*'4%"!! '(+"!/"('%"!, '#% )(4%% (&;*"!+('*""6: A(&8 ! "* 5&('"% @&!8*$(' ("* # "%():(1!8(#$%4('%/5, /($(&(85 @&%17%#$'('*4* 8%"%% &*+'!$*, A(&8*. «N%4('%/, – @!#*4 K*&'!", – @&(!+(7%4 ($ "%/($(&(. 8%"%% '6#(/( (&;*"!+('*""(. A(&86» (142, #. 645). P$(4< ?% (@&%1%4%""(% 8"%"!% "* E$($ #>%$ '6#/*+*4 ! QG:"%&: «P('%&7%""( ,#"(, # $(>/! +&%"!, "*5/!, >$( >%4('%/, E$( '6#7%% #5F%#$'(, (),+*" #'(!8 @&(!#:(?1%"!%8 4!7< @(#$%@%""(85, 8%14%""(85 '(+"!/"('%"!G !+ )4!?% '#%;( #$(,F%;( / "%85 ?!'($"(;( 8!&*» (52, #. 142-143). 9 )4!?% '#%;( / >%4('%/5 ' ?!'($"(8 8!&% #$(!$ >%4('%/(()&*+"*, ()%+<,"*. L$( ! @(+'(4!4( 5>%"68 #1%4*$< '6'(1, >$( >%4('%/, ;('(&, #4('*8! =%//%4,, ,'!4#, «($@&6#/(8 ()%+<,", * !8%""( 1*'"( '68%&7!: >%4('%/(()&*+"6: ()%+<,"» (87, #. 31). H.H. %>"!/(', /*/ 1(/*+*""6. A*/$, /("#$*$!&('*4: «N%4('%/ @&(!+(7%4 ($ ()%+<,"6, )(4%% '#%;( @&!)4!?*GF%.#, / #(:&*"!'7!8#, 1*""68 '!1*8 >%4('%/(()&*+"6: ()%+<,"… L$($ '6'(1 )64 @(>$! %1!"(;4*#"( @&!+"*" ' "*5/%…» (269, #. 13). L$($ '6'(1 "%():(1!8( #4%1('*4 !+ 1*&'!"('#/(;( E'(4G2!(""(;( 5>%"!,. WF% ' 1866 ;(15, 1( $(;(, /*/ #*8 K*&'!" ()&*$!4#, / @&()4%8% @&(!#:(?1%"!, >%4('%/*, =%//%4< ' #'(%. «3)F%. 8(&A(4(;!!» @!#*4: «B(4(?%"!%, >$( >%4('%/ &*+'!4#, !+ "!+7!: @(+'("(>"6: ?!'($"6:, ! @&%?1% '#%;( !+ "*#$(,F%. ()%+<,"6, %#$< >*#$"6. 1%15/$!'"6. '6'(1, #4%15GF!. # *)#(4G$"(. "%():(1!8(#$$( «@&(!#:(?1%"!% >%4('%/* ($ ()%+<,"6» #(#$*'4,%$ "%():(1!8(% #4%1#$'!% 1*&'!"!+8* ! >$( 1&5;(;( "*5>"(;( ()I,#"%"!, @(,'4%"!, "* +%84% >%4('%>%#/(;( &(1* '(()F% "% 8(?%$ )6$< 1*"(» ($*8 ?%, #. 139). 9 @%&'68 !1%G @&(!#:(?1%"!, >%4('%/* ($ ()%+<,"6 '61'!"54 ! ()(#"('*4 "%8%2/!. +((4(; M. 0(;$ – ' @5)4!>"6: 4%/2!,:, @&(>!$*""6: !8 ' 1862 ;(15 ' R%'7$*4% (T'%.2*&!,). B(1>%&/"5', ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( @( ($"(7%"!G / ?!'($"(85 8!&5 «>%4('%/ %#$< $(4*%$: «H##4%15, ($"(7%"!% >%4('%/* / )4!?*.7!8 / "%85 ?!'($"68 – ()%+<,"*8, ! #:(1#$'(, (#"('*""(% "* %;( $%#"(8 #&(1#$'% # E$!8 '6#7!8 $!@(8 84%/(@!$*GF!:, 5/*+6'*, "* &*+4!>!,.., 86 1%4*%8 E$( $(4$( $*/!8 ()&*+(8 !1%8 @&,8( / ()I,#"%"!G "*7%. #()#$'%""(. @&!&(16…» (381, #. 119).
281
B(",$"(, >$( @&(2%## @&%'&*F%"!, ()%+<,"6 ' >%4('%/* 8(; (#5F%#$'4,$<#, 4!7< "* @&($,?%"!! '%#<8* 14!$%4<"(;( @&(8%?5$/* '&%8%"!. B( E$(85 @('(15 =%//%4< @!#*4: «N$( /*#*%$#,… $(;( 14!""(;( @%&!(1* !#$(&!! V%84!, ' @&(1(4?%"!% /($(&(;( 8%14%""( ! @(#$%@%""( #('%&7*4#, @%&%:(1 ($ #*8(. )4!+/(. / >%4('%/5 ()%+<,"6 / "*#$(,F%85 >%4('%/5, $( %;(, /("%>"(, "%4<+, !+8%&,$< "! ;(1*8!, "! '%/*8!» (90, #. 311). W#4! (2%"!$< '&%8, #5F%#$'('*"!, "* +%84% >%4('%/* «' 20000, 100000 4%$ !4! ' "%#/(4"( 8*46 @( #&*'"%"!G # $%8! "%!+8%&!868! @&(8%?5$/*8! '&%8%"!, /($(&6% @($&%)('*4!#< 14, @(#$%@%""(;( &*+'!$!, 14!""(;( &,1* @&%1/(' 1( >%4('%/* '/4G>!$%4<"(» ($*8 ?%, #. 312). M*/ ($8%$!4 @&!8%"!$%4<"( / #%&%1!"% XIX '%/* N. D,.%4<, «"! (1!" @&%18%$ "% '(+)5?1*4 $*/(;( 4G)(@6$#$'* ! !"$%&%#* 8%?15 ;%(4(;*8! ! ' @5)4!/%, /*/ '(@&(# ( 1&%'"(#$! >%4('%>%#/(;( &(1*» (228, #. 1). C E$(8 14!$%4<"(8 @&(2%##% '(+"!/"('%"!, >%4('%/* 1%4(, /("%>"( ?%, "% (;&*"!>!'*4(#< 4!7< !+8%"%"!,8! ' A!+!>%#/(. (&;*"!+*2!! %;( ?!'($"6: @&%1/(', &*+'!$!%8 !: ! %;( $%4*. B&(2%## @(#$%@%""(;( #('%&7%"#$'('*"!, "% ' 8%"<7%. #$%@%"! (:'*$6'*4 ! ,'4%"!, @#!:!/!. «B(1()"( $(85 /*/ "*7% >%4('%>%#/(% $%4(, – @!#*4 =%//%4<, – 8%14%""( ! @(#$%@%""( &*+'!'*4(#< !+ 14!""(;( &,1* @(+'("(>"6: @&%1/(', &*+'!'*4*#< ! "*7* 157*, @&(:(1, $5 ?% 4%#$"!25 #$5@%"%. &*+'!$!,» (93, #. 47). L$( +"*>!$, >$( @&!"2!@6 E'(4G2!(""(;( 5>%"!, &*#@&(#$&*",4!#< %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8! ! "* @#!:!/5 ?!'($"6:. 3"*, ' !: @&%1#$*'4%"!!, $*/?% @(1'%&?%"* @(#$%@%""(85 &*+'!$!G, @&!:(1,F%85 ' /("%>"(8 #>%$% / '(+"!/"('%"!G '6#7!: ' ?!'($"(8 8!&% A(&8. R( ! E$! A(&86 #@(#()"6 / 1*4<"%.7%85 #('%&7%"#$'('*"!G. «C#,/!., /$( @&!+"*%$ @&!"2!@ E'(4G2!!, – @!#*4 K*&'!", – 1(4?%" '!1%$<, >$( 58#$'%""6% #@(#()"(#$! '6#7!: ?!'($"6:… #@(#()"6 / 1*4<"%.7%85 5#('%&7%"#$'('*"!G» (142, #. 648). -%*4!+*2!, E$(. #@(#()"(#$! @#!:!/! '6#7!: ?!'($"6: / #('%&7%"#$'('*"!G ! #(+1*4* )!(4(;!>%#/!% @&%1@(#64/! A(&8!&('*"!, >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,. K4!$%4<"(#$< ! @(#$%@%""(#$< #/4*16'*"!, E$!: @&%1@(#64(/ )64! #$(4< ?% (>%'!1"68! /*/ ! @( ($"(7%"!G / @&%17%#$'5GF!8 E$*@*8 &*+'!$!, @#!:!/! ?!'($"6:. =%//%4<, ' >*#$"(#$!, @(1>%&/"54: «K4!""6. &,1 @&(8%?5$(>"6: #$5@%"%. #(%1!",%$ 157%'"5G ?!+"< '6#7!: ?!'($"6: # 157%'"(. ?!+"%4('%/* # (1"(. #$(&("6 ! # 157%'"(. ?!+"%#/*, E'(4G2!, ?!'($"6: @&%1/(' >%4('%/*, #('%&7%"#$'('*"!% !: A!+!>%#/(. (&;*"!+*2!! #(@&('(?1*4!#< ! #('%&7%"#$'('*"!%8 !: @#!:!/!, >$( @(#$%@%""( '%4( / A(&8!&('*"!G >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,. C @%&!(1 @&%'&*F%"!, ()%+<,"6 ' >%4('%/* >!#$( ?!'($"6% A(&86 @#!:!/!, (#"('6'*'7!%#, "* !"#$!"/$*:, @(#$%@%""( #8%",4!#< >%4('%>%#/!8!, &*##51(>"68! A(&8*8!. «C '%#<8* ($1*4%""5G E@(:5, @&%?1% "%?%4! >%4('%/ ()&%4 #'(% >%4('%>%#/(% 1(#$(!"#$'(, (" &5/('(1!4#, ' )(4<7%. 8%&% !"#$!"/$(8 ! 8%"<7% &*##51/(8» (142,
282
#. 170). B(4"(% '61%4%"!% >%4('%/* !+ ?!'($"(;( 8!&* (+"*>*4( ! /(&%""(% @&%()&*+('*"!% %;( #(+"*"!,, ' /($(&(8 '(+()4*1*4! ' /("2% /("2(' >!#$( >%4('%>%#/!% A(&86 @&(,'4%"!,. K*&'!" ' #',+! # E$!8 ($8%$!4: «R%$ #(8"%"!,, >$( #5F%#$'5%$ (;&(8"*, &*+"!2* 8%?15 58(8 #*8(;( @&!8!$!'"(;( >%4('%/* ! #*8(;( '6#7%;( ?!'($"(;(» ($*8 ?%, #. 238). O#$*"('4%"!G E$(. &*+"!26 #@(#()#$'('*4! &*+"(()&*+"6% A*/$(&6 )!(4(;!>%#/(;( ! @&!8!$!'"(–#(2!*4<"(;( @(&,1/*. 3$8%$!8 "%/($(&6% !+ "!:, "*!)(4%% +"*>!$%4<"6%. C >!#4% &%7*GF!: A*/$(&(', ()5#4('!'7!: (>%4('%>!'*"!% ()%+<,", #$*"('4%"!% >%4('%/* !, #4%1('*$%4<"(, %;( #(+"*"!,, %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! (#()( '61%4!4! 9*$-'6%78"!* 2!7!>*"'* ! >4%"(&*+1%4<"5G &%><. «3)% E$! &','!7!#'0*16'* A5"/2!!, – @!#*4 =%//%4<, –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» (90, #. 313). M. 0(;$ #>!$*4, >$( ' >%4('%/%, @( #&*'"%"!G # ()%+<,"(., «"*#$(,F5G !#/4G>!$%4<"(#$< #(#$*'4,%$ !-9*-"!* 2!7!>*"'*, :(?1%"!% #$(.8,, /*/ #5F%#$'%""6. *$&!)5$ >%4('%>%#/(. "*$5&6, ($4!>*GF!. 1'5&5/!: ($ '#%: 1&5;!: 84%/(@!$*GF!:. =4*'"%.7!% ($4!>!, #$&(%"!, >%4('%>%#/(;( $%4* "*:(1,$#, ' !+'%#$"(8 ($"(7%"!! / E$(85 @(4(?%"!G ! ($>*#$! $(4%&%+ "%;( #$*"(',$#, '(+8(?"68!, !4! ($"(#,$#, 1&5; / 1&5;5 /*/ @&!>!"* ! 1%.#$'!%» (381, #. 121). R( >%8 )64! '6+'*"6 /*&1!"*4<"6% !+8%"%"!, ' A5"/2!,: /("%>"(#$%. ?!'($"6: @&%1/(' >%4('%/*? N$( '6"51!4( ()%+<,"5 (/(">*$%4<"( '#$*$< "* "(;!, #8%"!$< )64(% @&(#$&*"#$'%""(% @(4(?%"!% "* "('(%, '%&$!/*4<"(%? K*&'!" @!#*4 () 5?% #A(&8!&('*'7%8#, >%4('%/%, >$( «(" ()4*1*%$ )(4<7(. #!4(. @&!"(&*'4!'*$< #'(! @&!'6>/! / "('68 5#4('!,8 ?!+"!. 3" !+()&%$*%$ (&5?!%, (&51!, ! "('6% #@(#()6 14, $(;(, >$()6 1()6'*$< @!F5 ! +*F!F*$< #%),» (142, #. 240). B(",$"(, >$( $*/(. #!4(. ()4*1*4 ! )4!?*.7!. @&%1(/ >%4('%/*. 3"*, E$* #!4*, @(+'(4!4* %85 '6?!$< ' ($1*4%""6% '&%8%"*, "( 14, E$(;( ' !"6:, !+8%"!'7!:#, 5#4('!,: @($&%)('*4(#< /*&1!"*4<"( !+8%"!$< ()&*+ ?!+"!, "*.$! "('6% @5$! ! #&%1#$'* 1()6'*"!, @!F! ! +*F!$6, @(1%&?*"!, #5F%#$'('*"!,. H"*>% ;('(&,, >%4('%/(()&*+"(. ()%+<,"% # "%():(1!8(#$!" E$(;(, K*&'!" @!#*4: «M(4< #/(&( /*/(.-"!)51< 1&%'"!. >4%" ()7!&"(;( &,1* @&!8*$(', '#4%1#$'!% 4! @%&%8%" ' #@(#()% 1()6'*"!, #&%1#$' #5F%#$'('*"!, !4! @%&%8%" ' (/&5?*GF!: 5#4('!,:, #$*4 ?!$< "%#/(4
283
1%&%'<,:, %;( @&!'6>"6. #@(#() :(?1%"!, 1(4?%" )64 !+8%"!$<#, ! (" 1(4?%" )64 #1%4*$<#, !4! >%$'%&("(;!8 ' )(4%% #$&(;(8 #86#4% !4! 1'5"(;!8 ?!'($"68» ($*8 ?%, c. 174). B&%1(/ >%4('%/* «'6)&*4» '$(&(%: (" #$*4 1'5"(;!8 #5F%#$'(8. J*/!8 ()&*+(8, @%&%:(1 ()%+<,"6 / @&,8(:(?1%"!G K*&'!" #$*'!4 ' @&,85G +*'!#!8(#$< ($ $*/!: 8*$%&!*4<"6: A*/$(&(', /*/ !+8%"%"!, ' #@(#()% 1()6'*"!, #&%1#$' / #5F%#$'('*"!G !4! ' (/&5?*GF!: 5#4('!,:. M E$(85 8(?"( $(4"%"!,, >$( #(G+ «!4!» +1%#< '&,1 4! 2%4%#(()&*+%": #'(G &(4< #6;&*4 /*?16. !+ "*+'*""6: A*/$(&(', )(4<7% $(;( – !+8%"%"!% ' #@(#()% 1()6'*"!, #&%1#$' / #5F%#$'('*"!G @&(!+(74(, "*1( @(4*;*$<, !8%""( '#4%1#$'!% @%&%8%" ' (/&5?*GF!: 5#4('!,:, @%&%8%", 4!7!'7!: ()%+<," @&%?"!: #@(#()(' @(11%&?*"!, #5F%#$'('*"!,. R%():(1!8(#$< 52%4%$< ' )(&<)% +* #5F%#$'('*"!% ' !+8%"!'7!:#, 5#4('!,: $(4/*4* ()%+<,"5 / @(!#/*8 !"6:, @( #&*'"%"!G # @&%?"!8!, #&%1#$' +*F!$6 ! 1()6'*"!, @!F!. L$! «@(!#/!» ! @&!'%4! ' /("2% /("2(' /( '#% )(4%% #!#$%8*$!>%#/(85 @&!8%"%"!G $%: !4! !"6: @&%18%$(' ' /*>%#$'% !$;5'= -$;5%, * +*$%8 ! / !: 1!,"%-*78"!:; !+;($('4%"!G. R% '6+6'*4* #(8"%"!. >&%+'6>*."*, 14!$%4<"(#$< E$(;( @&(2%##* @(#$%@%""(;( @&!()F%"!, ()%+<,"(@(1()"(;( @&%1/* >%4('%/* / !+;($('4%"!G (&51!. $&51*. K*&'!", #(#4*'7!#< "* 8"%"!% *&:%(4(;(', @!#*4, >$( «@&(7%4 (;&(8"6. @&(8%?5$(/ '&%8%"!, @&%?1% >%8 "*7! @&%1/! 1(158*4!#< 74!A('*$< (#/(4/! /*8",, @&%'&*F*, !: ' ;4*1/!% (&51!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 173). R( $($ A*/$, >$( ("! '#%-$*/! 5!5;:%7'18 1( E$(;(, #'!1%$%4<#$'5%$ ( +"*>!$%4<"(8 @&(;&%##% ' #$*"('4%"!! >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,. «B&!8%"%"!% (&51!., /*/ ("! "! )64! "%#('%&7%""6, – @!#*4 =.C. B4%:*"(', – @&%1@(4*;*%$ ($"(#!$%4<"( (;&(8"(% &*+'!$!! 58#$'%""6: #@(#()"(#$%.» (308, #. 153). M*/!8 ()&*+(8 ()%+<,"(@(1()"6% @&%1/! >%4('%/* 1(#$!;4! $*/(. #$%@%"! &*+'!$!, #(+"*"!,? 3) E$(8, @( 8"%"!G B4%:*"('*, «"*8 #4%15%$ #@&*7!'*$< "% !#$(&!G, * ,!!7!#'4. K*&'!" 1*4 ($'%$ +* +((4(;!G. 3", @( /&*."%. 8%&%, @(/*+*4, /*/ +((4(;!>%#/*, E'(4G2!, >%4('%/* :!#7% 1(#$!;"5$< !"$%&%#5GF%;( "*# @5"/$*» ($*8 ?%, #. 154). V1%#<, @(?*45., 8(?"( #/*+*$< # )(4<7%. (@&%1%4%""(#$$( #1%4*4! K*&'!" ! 1&5;!% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/*: ("! 1(#$*$(>"( *&;58%"$!&('*""( @(/*+*4! "% $(4%#/*, E'(4G2!, >%4('%/* :!#7% 1(#$!><, "( ! /*/ A*/$!>%#/! 5!1-'#7% «!"$%&%#5GF%;( "*# @5"/$*», $( %#$< 5&('", &*+'!$!, #(+"*"!,, 1(#$*$(>"(;( 14, (#(+"*""(;( !+;($('4%"!, ! @&!8%"%"!, (&51!. $&51*. «M*/ )6 $*8 "! )64(, "( +((4(;!, @%&%1*%$ !#$(&!! #'(%;( homo 5?% ()4*1*GF!8 #@(#()"(#$,8!, "%():(1!868! 14, !+()&%$%"!, ! 5@($&%)4%"!, @&!8!$!'"%.7!: (&51!.. B(E$(85 !#$(&!, 1(4?"* 4!7< 2$!17*5'-8 &*+'!$!% !#/5##$'%""6: (&;*"(' ! ()"*&5?!$< !: '4!,"!% "* &*+'!$!% 15:*, /*/ E$( #1%4*4* +((4(;!, @( ($"(7%"!G / *1-*1-9*"".: !$#%"%:» ($*8 ?%).
284
M*/ !8%""( K*&'!" ! 1&5;!% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* ()I,#"!4! «+* +((4(;!G» @&(2%## (>%4('%>%"!, ()%+<,"6, * $%8 #*868 ! #$*"('4%"!, >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,? B&(#4%1!8 :(1 !: &*##5?1%"!. @( @('(15 #(($'%$#$'5GF!: %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: A*/$(', 5>!$6'*,, >$( E$! «+((4(;!+!&('*""6%» &*##5?1%"!, !8%G$ ! +"*>!$%4<"5G #(2!(4(;!>%#/5G, A!4(#(A#/5G (/&*#/5. M*>%#$'%""( "('*, A5"/2!, (&;*"!+8* ?!'($"(;( @&%1/* >%4('%/*, #',+*""*, # !+;($('4%"!%8 ! @&!8%"%"!%8 (&51!. $&51*, @($&%)('*4* #'(%;( #@%2!*4<"(;( 8*$%&!*4<"(;( "(#!$%4, – $;6'. «K4, $(;(, >$()6 ($%#*$< /&%8%"< ! #1%4*$< !+ "%;( #*8(% ;&5)(% (&51!% !4! '61%4*$< !+ /(#$! +*(#$&%""(% /(@<% !4! /&G/, "5?"( ()4*1*$< &*+'!$(. &5/(.», – @!#*4 K*&'!" (142, #. 173). 9 &*+'!$<#, &5/* 8(;4* $(4"(#$%. ()%+<,"6. R( 14, E$(;( ("! 1(4?"6 )64! (#'()(1!$<#, ($ A5"/2!! @%&%1'!?%"!,. «-5/! ! /!#$! &5/ %1'* 4! 8(;4! 5#('%&7%"#$'('*$<#, "*#$(4$()6 '61%46'*$< (&5?!% !4! 8%$/( )&(#*$< /*8"! ' 2%4< 1( $%: @(&, @(/* !8! @(4<+('*4!#< @&%!85F%#$'%""( 14, @%&%1'!?%"!, ! 14, @(11%&?*"!, '#%;( '%#* $%4*, !4! @(/*… ("! )64! #@%2!*4<"( @&!#@(#()4%"6 / 4*+*"!G @( 1%&%'<,8». 3$#G1* #4%15%$, >$( &5/! 8(;4! A5"/2!("!&('*$< ! #('%&7%"#$'('*$<#, 4!7< @&! (@&%1%4%""6: 5#4('!,:, * !8%""( – @&! @(#$(,""( #(:&*",%8(8 '%&$!/*4<"(8 @(4(?%"!! $%4* – /*/ @&! @%&%1'!?%"!!, $*/ ! @&! (#5F%#$'4%"!! &*+4!>"6: 1%.#$'!., #',+*""6: ' @%&'5G (>%&%1< # !+;($('4%"!%8 ! @&!8%"%"!%8 (&51!. $&51*. «B&! 8"(;!: 1%.#$'!,: "%():(1!8(, >$()6 ()% &5/! ! '#, '%&:",, >*#$< $54('!F* )64! #'()(1"6, * 14, E$(;( (" (>%4('%/. – C.3.) 1(4?%" $'%&1( #$(,$< "* "(;*:… P(;4*#"( # @&!"2!@(8 &*+1%4%"!, A!+!(4(;!>%#/(;( $&51*, &*#@&(#$&*"%""68 '( '#%8 ?!'($"(8 2*&#$'%, ' $( '&%8, /*/ &5/! #('%&7%"#$'('*4!#< ' #:'*$6'*"!!, "(;! 1(4?"6 )64! #('%&7%"#$'('*$<#, ' @(11%&?/% $%4* ! @%&%1'!?%"!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 175). L$5 ?% 86#4< '6#/*+6'*4 ! =%//%4<. C #$*"('4%"!! >%4('%>%#/(;( (&;*"!+8* (" '61%4!4, ' >*#$"(#$!, «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
285
"% (1"(4!"%."(% &*#@(4(?%"!% @&!>!"6 ! #4%1#$'!,, * !: '+*!8(@%&%:(16 – $*/(% !: #(($"(7%"!%, @&! /($(&(8 (1"( ! $( ?% '6#$5@*%$ ! /*/ @&!>!"*, ! /*/ #4%1#$'!%. R% #45>*."( K*&'!" @(1>%&/!'*4, >$( #'()(1"(% 5@($&%)4%"!% &5/ )64( «>*#$!"(., >*#$%4('%/*» (142, c.176). R( %#4! *)#$&*;!&('*$<#, "* '&%8, ($ E$(. &%*4<"(. @&!>!""(#4%1#$'%""(. #',+!, ($ %] #4(?"(#$! ! @(@6$*$<#, '61%4!$< (@&%1%4,GF%% "*>*4(, &%7*GF%% @&!>!""(–#4%1#$'%""(% #(($"(7%"!%, $( @&!1%$#, @&!+"*$<, >$( "% 1!AA%&%"2!*2!, ! #@%2!*4!+*2!, /("%>"(#$%. ()%+<,"6 ,'!4!#< #4%1#$'!%8 @&,8(:(?1%"!,, *, #/(&%%, "*()(&($: '#% '(+&*#$*GF*, "*;&5+/* "* @%&%1"!% /("%>"(#$!, (#()%""( ' #',+! # @(#$%@%""68 5'%4!>%"!%8 >!#4* ! #4(?"(#$! $&51('6: (@%&*2!., +*#$*'4,4* ()%+<,"5 '6@&,84,$<#,, #$*"('!$<#, 1'5"(;!8 #5F%#$'(8, @&%'&*F*$<#, ' >%4('%/*. K*&'!", #&*'"!'*, >%4('%/* # ?!'($"68!, #@(#()"68! / @&,8(:(?1%"!G, @(1>%&/"54: «N%4('%/ (1!" #$*4 1'5"(;!8, ! 86 8(?%8, , 158*G, ($>*#$! @(",$<, /*/!8 ()&*+(8 (" 1(7%4 1( '%&$!/*4<"(;( @(4(?%"!,, #(#$*'4,GF%;( (1!" !+ "*!)(4%% :*&*/$%&"6: %;( @&!+"*/('. N%4('%/ "% 8(; 1(#$!;"5$< #'(%;( "*#$(,F%;( ;(#@(1#$'5GF%;( @(4(?%"!, "* +%84% )%+ 5@($&%)4%"!, #'(!: &5/, /($(&6% $*/ 51!'!$%4<"( @&!#@(#()4%"6 / 1%.#$'!,8 ' #(($'%$#$'!! # @&%1@!#*"!,8! %;( '(4!» ($*8 ?%, c. 174-175). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, @%&%:(1 >%4('%/(()&*+"(. ()%+<,"6 / '%&$!/*4<"(85 @(4(?%"!G, / @&,8(:(?1%"!G ' @&(2%##% @(#$%@%""(;( &*+'!$!, +*>*$(>"6: A(&8 $&51('(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% #@(#()#$'('*4 %% (>%4('%>!'*"!G. (?"( #/*+*$<, >$(, '#$*' "* "(;!, ()%+<,"* #1%4*4* &%7!$%4<"6. 7*; ($ ?!'($"(;( / >%4('%/5. -%7!$%4<"6., "( %F% "% &%7*GF!.. K4, $(;(, >$()6 E$($ @&(2%## (>%4('%>!'*"!, ()%+<,"6 1(#$!; #'(%;( @(4"(;( '6&*?%"!,, @("*1()!4#, %F% (1!" #5F%#$'%""6. A*/$(&. § 5. U3DE28;C7D3OE;9 8DIO: ID325D< N25289L=G -%7*GF!. 7*; ' @%&%:(1% ($ ()%+<,"6 / >%4('%/5 )64 #1%4*", @( 8"%"!G 5>%"6:, ' @&(2%##% A(&8!&('*"!, ! #('%&7%"#$'('*"!, >4%"(&*+1%4<"(. &%>!, ,+6/*. P@(#()"(#$< / &%>! K*&'!" "*+6'*4 «(1"!8 !+ ;4*'"%.7!: ($4!>!. 8%?15 >%4('%/(8 ! "!+7!8! ?!'($"68!» ($*8 ?%, #. 201). B(",$"(, >$( &%>< "% $(4!% >%4('%/* ($ ?!'($"6:, "( ! #(+1*4*, ()5#4('!4* %;(. L$5 86#4< (#()%""( >%$/( ! (@&%1%4%""( '6&*+!4 =%//%4<: «H8%""( &%><, "%#(8"%""(, #(+1*4* ;45)(>*.75G @&(@*#$< 8%?15 >%4('%/(8 ! ?!'($"68!» (90, #. 314). N4%"(&*+1%4<"*, &%><, @( 8"%"!G 5>%"6: '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/*, ,'4,%$#, (),+*$%4<"68 5#4('!%8 A5"/2!("!&('*"!, #(+"*"!,, "%():(1!8(. @&%1@(#64/(. 8674%"!,. 674%"!% '(()F% "%'(+8(?"( )%+ &%>!, )%+ E$(;(, @( #4('*8 K*&'!"*, «1!'"(;( 8%:*"!+8*, /($(&6. ()(+"*>*%$ &*+4!>"(;( &(1* @&%18%$6 ! #'(.#$'* (@&%1%4%""68! +"*/*8!
286
! '6+6'*%$ &,1 86#4%., /($(&6% "!/(;1* "% 8(;4! )6 &(1!$<#, !+ (1"!: >5'#$'%""6: '@%>*$4%"!. !4!, %#4! )6 1*?% ! &(1!4!#<, "% 8(;4! )6 &*+'!'*$<#,» (142, #. 648). C($ @(>%85 ! '(+"!/"('%"!% &*+'!$(;( #(+"*"!, ' @&(2%##% @&%'&*F%"!, ()%+<,"6 ' >%4('%/* #$*4( '(+8(?"68 4!7< "* (#"('% @&%17%#$'5GF%;( A(&8!&('*"!, >4%"(&*+1%4<"(. &%>!. «-*+'!$!% 58* 1(4?"( )64( #1%4*$< +"*>!$%4<"6. 7*; '@%&%1, /(;1* )4*;(1*&, @&%?"!8 5#@%:*8 5 >%4('%/* '(74* ' 5@($&%)4%"!% &%>< /*/ @(45!#/5##$'( ! @(45!"#$!"/$» ($*8 ?%, #. 243). C6#/*+6'*"!, 5>%"6:, @(1()"6% E$(85, 1*&'!"('#/(85, ! @(+'(4!4! QG:"%&5 #1%4*$< '6'(1 ( $(8, >$( >4%"(&*+1%4<"*, &%>< – «($4!>!$%4<"6. @&!+"*/ >%4('%>%#$'*, "% #4%1('*'7!., @( 8"%"!G 45>7!: 5>%"6:, +* &*+'!$!%8 '6#7%. >%4('%>%#/(. 58#$'%""(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! ! >%4('%>%#/(. /54<$5&6, * "%():(1!8( @&%17%#$'('*'7%. %85» (52, #. 144). B%&%:(1 ?!'($"6: @&%1/(' >%4('%/* / '%&$!/*4<"(85 @(4(?%"!G, / @&,8(:(?1%"!G (#5F%#$'4,4#,, @( 8"%"!G "%/($(&6: 5>%"6:, &*"<7% @(,'4%"!, 5 "!: >4%"(&*+1%4<"(. &%>!. J*/, =%//%4<, '61%4,, (#"('"6% E$*@6 (>%4('%>!'*"!, ()%+<,"6, @(1>%&/"54 @&! E$(8, >$( «@&(!#:(?1%"!% 07*"!$%,5*78"!= $*0' ! #',+*""(% # "%G '6#7%% $%,9'-'* #!$-%"' "*1( &*##8*$&!'*$< 4!7< /*/ '$(&5G, @(+1"%.75G ! '*?"%.75G #$5@%"< &*+'!$!, &(1* >%4('%>%#/(;(» (90, #. 314). 3$#G1* #4%15%$, >$(, @( 8"%"!G =%//%4,, ' @&(2%##% #$*"('4%"!, >%4('%/* )64* (#()*,, @&(8%?5$(>"*, #$5@%"< – «)%##4('%#"6.» >%4('%/, #5F%#$'( 5?% # @&,8(. @(:(1/(. >%4('%/*, "( %F% )%+ &%>!, ()%+<,"(>%4('%/ (@!$%/*"$&(@), «/($(&6., @&*'1*, ! "% ($4!>*4#, @( #$&(%"!G $%4* #5F%#$'%""68 ()&*+(8 ($ #('&%8%""6: 4G1%., (1"*/(, >4%"(&*+1%4<"(. &%>! %F% "% +"*4» ($*8 ?%) . P4%1('*$%4<"(, ;('(&!$< ( "%8, /*/ ( >%4('%/% 5?% #A(&8!&('*'7%8#,, %F% "%4<+,. L$( )64 >%4('%/ A(&8!&5GF!.#,, 5?% "% ?!'($"(%, "( %F% ! "% >%4('%/ ' @(4"(8 #86#4% #4('*, @(45?!'($"(%, @(45>%4('%/, – ! $(4$( (" "% '4*1%4 &%>%4('%>%#/!.. «W#4! ?% )%+ &%>! "% 8(?%$ )6$< &*+58*, – @!#*4 QG:"%&, – $( ! @%&'6. !4! @%&'()6$"6. >%4('%/ "% 8(; )6$< &*+58"68 #(+1*"!%8 !4! "% 8(; )6$< >%4('%/(8 ' $%@%&%7"%8 #86#4% #4('*, (" #/(&%% )64 >%8-$( #&%1"!8 8%?15 >%4('%/(8 ! ?!'($"68»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– ()%+<,"(>%4('%/*. R( /*/('( )6 "! )64( ($"(7%"!% 5>%"6: / !1%% ()%+<,"(>%4('%/*, '*?"( $(, >$( ()F!8 14, "!: ,'4,%$#, @&!+"*"!% !#/4G>!$%4<"( '*?"(. &(4! >4%"(&*+1%4<"(. &%>! ' 1%4% A(&8!&('*"!, >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,.
287
#$*1!! (>%4('%>!'*"!, ()%+<,"6, #$*"('4%"!, >%4('%/*, @&%1@(#64/(. '(+"!/"('%"!, #5F%#$'*, #(%1!",GF%;( ' #%)% >%&$6 ()%+<,"6 ! >%4('%/*. H"*>% ;('(&,, "* E$(8 E$*@% >%4('%/(()&*+"*, ()%+<,"* @&%'&*$!4*#< ' ()%+<,"(@(1()"(;( >%4('%/*. B(#4%15GF%% 5#4(?"%"!%, #('%&7%"#$'('*"!% $&51('(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! ' %] #',+! # A(&8!&5GF%.#, >4%"(&*+1%4<"(. &%>%4('%/*, @&!'%4( / @&%'&*F%"!G ()%+<,"(@(1()"(;( >%4('%/* ' >%4('%/* @(4"(#$%4('%/*. «R*#$(,F!% 4G1!, – @!#*4 =%//%4<, – 2$!',!37' !+ ()%+<,"(@(1()"6: 4G1%. @5$%8 @(#$%@%""(;( &*+'!$!, ?!'($"6: +'5/(' ' >4%"(&*+1%4<"5G &%><, #(#$(,F5G !+ #4('. -5/* () &5/5 # &*+'!$!%8 E$(. A5"/2!!, /("%>"(, 74( ! &*+'!$!% %] (&;*"(', !8%""( 45>7*, 1!AA%&%"2!&('/* ;(&$*"! ! 8(+;*»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«5@($&%)4,G$#, !4! 14, &*+4!>"6: #!;"*4<"6: /&!/(', !4!, /*/ ' (1"(8 #45>*%, 14, 85+6/*4<"6: /*1*"#(', $(;1* /*/ 5 >%4('%/* (>%"< )4!+/!% @( 5#$&(.#$'5 ;(4(#('6% (&;*"6 #1%4*4!#<… #@(#()"68! / >4%"(&*+1%4<"(. &%>!» (142, c. 173). M*/ '(+"!/4* $*/*, #@(#()"(#$< ;(4(#('6: (&;*"(' >%4('%/* / >4%"(&*+1%4<"(. &%>!? -%7*, E$($ '(@&(#, 5>%"6% "% (;&*"!>!'*4!#< 5/*+*"!%8 "* '4!,"!% /*/(;(-$( (1"(;( %#$%#$'%""(;(, 8*$%&!*4<"(;( A*/$(&*, * ($8%>*4! "%#/(4!#4% E$!: A*/$(&(' )64* '61%4%"*, ' >*#$"(#$!, #@(#()"(#$< ()%+<,"6 / 2!5$%>%"'4. «R%4<+, "% ()&*$!$< '"!8*"!,, – @!#*4 K*&'!", – "* #$(4< #!4<"(% #$&%84%"!% "*7!: )4!+/!: &(1#$'%""!/('–()%+<,"… @(1&*?*$< '#%85, >$( ("! #467*$». L$* #@(#()"(#$< ()%+<," / @(1&*?*"!G, !: 1-$*:7*"'* @(1&*?*$< ! #@(#()#$'('*4! ' )(4<7(. 8%&% '(+"!/"('%"!G &%>!. «R*7* &%><, – @!#*4 K*&'!", – (),+*"* #'(!8 @&(!#:(?1%"!%8 @(1&*?*"!G &*+4!>"6: %#$%#$'%""6: +'5/(', ;(4(#(' 1&5;!: ?!'($"6:». B&!>!"6, @()5?1*'7!% ()%+<," @&!)%;*$< / +'5/(@(1&*?*"!G, K*&'!" 5#8*$&!'*4 ' #*8!: ()#$(,$%4<#$'*: !: ?!+"!. B(1&*?*"!% $%8 !4! !"68 +'5/*8 "% )64(, #4%1('*$%4<"(, >%8-$( #45>*."68, ("( )64( "%():(1!8(#$! (,+6/*). C /*>%#$'% @&!8%&* 8(?"( #(#4*$<#, "* @&%1@(4(?%"!% K*&'!"* ( $(8, >$( ' ;45)(/(. 1&%'"(#$!
288
/*/*,-$( )(4%% 1&5;!: (1*&%""*, >%4('%/(()&*+"*, ()%+<,"* #$*4* «@(1&*?*$< &%'5 :!F"(;( +'%&,, >$()6 5'%1(8!$< #'(!: $('*&!F%.()%+<," ( &(1% ;&(+,F%. (@*#"(#$!. 9 E$( )64( )6 @%&'68 7*;(8 / ()&*+('*"!G ,+6/*» ($*8 ?%, #. 205). B(",$"(, >$( "%():(1!8(#$< ' @(1&*?*"!! (@&%1%4%""68 +'5/*8, ' !: '!1(!+8%"%"!! 14, 2%4%. #!;"*4!+*2!!, * +*$%8 ! "%():(1!8(#$< ' #*8(#$(,$%4<"(8, "%+*'!#!8(8 @&(!+"%#%"!! !"6: +'5/(' ' #',+! # !"68! 2%4,8!, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' #',+! # (@&%1%4%""68! $&51('68! (@%&*2!,8! – E$* "%():(1!8(#$< '(+"!/*4* @%&%1 «)(4%% 1&5;!: (1*&%""68!»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«B( 8%&% $(;(, /*/ ;(4(# '#% )(4%% ! )(4%% 5@($&%)4,4#, ' 1%4(, ;(4(#('6% (&;*"6 1(4?"6 )64! &*+'!'*$<#, ! #('%&7%"#$'('*$<#, @( +*/("5 "*#4%1('*"!, &%+54<$*$(' 5@&*?"%"!,, * E$(, ' #'(G (>%&%1<, 1(4?"( )64( @('4!,$< "* &*+'!$!% &%>!» ($*8 ?%). R( /*/(. )6 +"*>!$%4<"(. "! )64* &(4< +'5/(@(1&*?*"!, ! 5@&*?"%"!, ;(4(#('6: (&;*"(' ()%+<,"6 – (1"! E$! A*/$(&6 #*8! @( #%)% "% 8(;4! %F% @&!'%#$! / '(+"!/"('%"!G #@%2!A!>%#/! >%4('%>%#/(. &*+1%4<"(. &%>!. B(#/(4< "%($1%4!8* ($ #(+"*"!,, $( ' %% A(&8!&('*"!! "%():(1!8( )64( "%@(#&%1#$'%""(% 5>*#$!% (&;*"* #(+"*"!,. C $(. 8%&%, ' /*/(. A(&8!&('*4*#< ! #('%&7%"#$'('*4*#< &%><, A(&8!&('*4(#< ! #('%&7%"#$'('*4(#< #(+"*"!%, ! E$($ '+*!8(#',+*""6. @&(2%## (#5F%#$'4,4#, "* (@&%1%4%""(. 8*$%&!*4<"(. (#"('% – "* (#"('% &*+'!$!, ;(4('"(;( 8(+;* ()%+<,"6. -*+'!$!% 8(+;* –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«#(($"(7%"!% 8%?15 @(#$(,""68 5@($&%)4%"!%8 ,+6/* ! &*+'!$!%8 8(+;* @&%1#$*'4,4( %F% )(4<75G '*?"(#$<». C E$(8 #(($"(7%"!! K*&'!" '6,'4,4, ' >*#$"(#$!, '4!,"!% 5@($&%)4%"!, >4%"(&*+1%4<"(. &%>! "* #('%&7%"#$'('*"!% 8(+;*. «B(#$(,""(%
289
@&!8%"%"!% ! 5#('%&7%"#$'('*"!% &%>! (/*+*4( '4!,"!% "* 8(+;, 1*'*, %85 '(+8(?"(#$< ! @()5?1*, %;( '6&*)*$6'*$< 14!""6% &,16 86#4%.» ($*8 ?%). J*/(% #$!854!&5GF%% '(+1%.#$'!% 5@($&%)4%"!, &%>! "* 8(+;, "* %;( &*+'!$!% )64( "%!+)%?"68, ! "%!+)%?"(#$< E$* (@&%1%4,4*#< @&%?1% '#%;( $%8 ()#$(,$%4<#$'(8, >$( 8(+; – (&;*" 8674%"!,, * 8674%"!%, @( 8"%"!G K*&'!"*, "%&*+&6'"( #',+*"( # ,+6/(8: 14, /*?1(. 86#4! (),+*$%4<"68 ,'4,%$#, &%>%'(%, #4('%#"(% ()4*>%"!%. R( E$( +"*>!$, >$( ! 5@($&%)4%"!% &%>! @&%1@(4*;*%$ (@&%1%4%""5G A(&85 ! #$%@%"< 8674%"!,. P4%1('*$%4<"(, ! $( 5@($&%)4%"!% &%>!, /($(&(% ' @&(2%##% (>%4('%>!'*"!, ()%+<,"6 @('4!,4( "* &*+'!$!% %% 8(+;*, "* #$*"('4%"!% >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!, – ("( $(?% "*@&*'4,4(#< 86#4< (@&%1%4%"!% K*&'!"(8 @%&'("*>*4<"(., $(4! /*/ @(45!#/5##$'* ! @(45!"#$!"/$*. L$( &%><, /($(&*, 5?% «9!37% ' 5@($&%)4%"!%» 5 >%4('%/*. 9 9D!5'7% ("* ' 5@($&%)4%"!% 5 ()%+<,"(>%4('%/* ! ':(1!4* %F% "% )515>! @(45!#/5##$'(8, 1* ! @(45!"#$!"/$(8 $(?%. C $($ @%&!(1 ("* )64*, #/(&%% '#%;(, @&(#$( !"#$!"/$(8 ! @&%!85F%#$'%""( !"#$!"/$(8, (#$*'7!8#, ' "*#4%1#$'( ($ @&%1/*–()%+<,"6. K* ! &%>!, #',+*""6% # #!;"*4!+*2!%. ! +'5/(@(1&*?*"!%8. C :(1% E'(4G2!!, '( '+*!8(1%.#$'!! # &*+'!'*GF!8#, 8(+;(8 ("! >%&%+ &%><, /*/ @(45!#/5##$'( ! @(45!"#$!"/$ $&*"#A(&8!&('*4!#< @(#$%@%""( ' &%>< /*/ «!#/5##$'(», $( %#$< #(+"*$%4<"5G &%><, ' &%><–8674%"!%. L$( 8(?"( &*#/&6$< $*/!8 ()&*+(8, >$( 8(+; ?!'($"(;( @&%1/* >%4('%/*, @(45>*, «$(4>/!» ($ @%&'("*>*4<"(;(, !"#$!"/$!'"(;(, "% "*@&*'4,%8(;( ! "% "*@(4",%8(;( 86#4%'6: */$(', ($ "%(#86#4,%8(;( +'5/(@(1&*?*"!,, ' /("2% /("2(' ()&%4 #@(#()"(#$< @(&(?1*$< 86#4! ' !: &%>%'(8, #4('%#"(8 "*@(4"%"!!. «K4!""6. ! #4(?"6. &,1 86#4%., – @!#*4 K*&'!", – "% 8(?%$ $%@%&< #5F%#$'('*$< )%+ #4(' "%86: !4! ;&(8/!:, /*/ 14!""(% !#>!#4%"!% – )%+ 2!A& !4! *4;%)&*!>%#/!: +"*/('. B(-'!1!8(85, 1*?% ()6/"('%""6% &,16 86#4%. $&%)5G$ /*/(;( )6 $( "! )64( '6&*?%"!, !4! +"*>!$%4<"( ()4%;>*G$#, !8» ($*8 ?%, #. 205-206). C4!,"!% 5@($&%)4%"!, &%>! "* &*+'!$!% 8(+;* ($8%>*4! ! 1&5;!% 5>%"6%. =%//%4<, "*@&!8%&, E$(85 '4!,"!G @&!1*'*4 &%7*GF%% +"*>%"!%. 3", ' >*#$"(#$!, #>!$*4, >$( &%>< «()5#4('4!'*4* '*?"%.7!% 5#@%:! 157%'"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! ! #',+*""(% # "%G 5#('%&7%"#$'('*"!% 8(+;*». H8%""( )4*;(1*&, &%>! 8(+; ()%+<,"(@(1()"(;( @&%1/* >%4('%/* @&%'&*$!4#, ' >%4('%>%#/!. 8(+;. «H%:!* 9.1!6!* $%,9'-'* ! ;1!9*$3*"1-9!9%"'* :!,#% ! 5;3*9"!= 5*(-*78"!1-', /*/ '6#7%. &;"6+'' :!,#%, 74( '#% '&%8, &5/* () &5/5 # 5#('%&7%"#$'('*"!%8 &%>!» (90, #. 314). R( %#4! 5@($&%)4%"!% &%>! '4!,4( "* 8(+;, #45?!4( @&!>!"(. %;( #('%&7%"#$'('*"!,, $(, # 1&5;(. #$(&("6, &*+'!$!% 8(+;*, 5#4(?"%"!% %;(
290
A5"/2!("!&('*"!, "% 8(;4( "% !8%$< #'(!8 #4%1#$'!%8 #('%&7%"#$'('*"!% &%>! (,+6/*). P4%1('*$%4<"(, ! ' E$(8 '(@&(#% 5>%"6% 1(4?"6 )64! @&!+"*$< ()&*$!8(#$< @&!>!""(–#4%1#$'%""(. #',+!, '+*!8(@%&%:(16 @&!>!"6 ! #4%1#$'!,, ()%&"5$(#$< #4%1#$'!, / @&!>!"%. H 1%.#$'!$%4<"(, 5 K*&'!"* 86 "*:(1!8 '6&*?%"!% $*/(;( '+;4,1* "* #(($"(7%"!% 5@($&%)4%"!, &%>! ! &*+'!$!, 8(+;*. 3" 5$'%&?1*4, ' >*#$"(#$!, >$( «@&%1@(4(?!$%4<"(% 5@($&%)4%"!% &%>! 1(4?"( )64( ($&*+!$<#, "* 8(+;% ! ()5#4('!$< "*#4%1#$'%""6% !+8%"%"!,, * E$!, ' #'(G (>%&%1<, 1(4?"6 )64! @('4!,$< "* 5#('%&7%"#$'('*"!% ,+6/*» (142, #. 648). W#4! '#@(8"!$<, >$( &*"%% $*/*, ?% ()&*$!8(#$< @&!>!""(#4%1#$'%""6: #',+%. )64* 5?% ($8%>%"*, @&!>%8 1'*?16 (' '(@&(#% ( #(($"(7%"!! 5@($&%)4%"!, &5/ ! @%&%:(1* / '%&$!/*4<"(85 @(4(?%"!G ! ' '(@&(#% ( #(($"(7%"!! &*+'!$!, &%>! ! "*#4%1#$'%""6: !+8%"%"!. ;(4(#('6: (&;*"('), $( 8(?"( "* E$(8 (#"('*"!! '61%4!$< ()F!. 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/!. @(1:(1 K*&'!"* / ()I,#"%"!G &*+4!>"6: ,'4%"!. E'(4G2!(""(;( @&(2%##*, ' 1*""(8 #45>*% – @&!8%"!$%4<"( / @&%16#$(&!! ! "*>*45 !#$(&!! >%4('%/*, * !8%""( – &*##8($&%"!% !: '( '+*!8(#',+!, '+*!8(()5#4('4%""(#$!, '( '+*!8(@%&%:(1*: !: @&!>!""(– #4%1#$'%""6: ($"(7%"!., (#5F%#$'4,GF!:#, "* 8*$%&!*4<"(. (#"('%. L$(, "%#(8"%""(, #'!1%$%4<#$'5%$ ( "*4!>!! '*?"(;( A!4(#(A#/(;( /(8@("%"$* ' ()F%. #!#$%8% 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/!: @&!"2!@(' K*&'!"* ! #5F%#$'%""( #)4!?*%$ %;( A!4(#(A#/5G @(+!2!G, * ' %;( 4!2% ! @(+!2!G 1&5;!: 5>%"6:–1*&'!"!#$(', # !#:(1"68! 5#$*"('/*8! 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!!. B(1'%1%8 "%/($(&6% @&%1'*&!$%4<"6% !$(;!. W#4! @(@6$*$<#, ()"*?!$< 4(;!/5 &*##5?1%"!. 5>%"6: @( '(@&(#5 ( @&(!#:(?1%"!! >%4('%/*, $( %% (#"('"68! 8(8%"$*8! ,'4,G$#, #4%15GF!% @(#64/!: )4!?*.7!. ?!'($"6. @&%1(/ >%4('%/* – >%4('%/(()&*+"*, ()%+<,"* – ' !+8%"!'7!:#, 5#4('!,: '6"5?1%"* )64* 14, @(11%&?*"!, #5F%#$'('*"!, @%&%.$! / '%&$!/*4<"(85 @(4(?%"!G, / 5@($&%)4%"!G &5/, "%():(1!8(85 14, (#5F%#$'4%"!, $&51('(. 1%,$%4<"(#$!, 14, !+;($('4%"!, ! @&!8%"%"!, (&51!. $&51* (K*&'!", =%//%4<, 0(;$, QG:"%&). Q4*;(1*&, E$(85 "* "*>*4<"6: E$*@*: &*+'!$!, $&51('(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! ()%+<,"* #5F%#$'%""( @&(1'!"54*#< ' "*@&*'4%"!! / >%4('%/5, @&%'&*$!4*#< ' ()%+<,"(>%4('%/* – #5F%#$'(, #&%1"%% 8%?15 ?!'($"68 ! >%4('%/(8, # @%&'68! @&()4%#/*8! >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,, #5F%#$'( # @&,8(. @(:(1/(. >%4('%/*, "( %F% "% ()4*1*GF%% >4%"(&*+1%4<"(. &%>%4('%>%#/!8 #(+"*"!%8 (=%//%4<, 0(;$, QG:"%&). R* #4%15GF%8 E$*@% / ($8%>%""68 A*/$(&*8 (>%4('%>!'*"!, ()%+<,"6 1()*'!4#, %F% (1!", (#()%""( '*?"6. – >4%"(&*+1%4<"*, &%><, 5@($&%)4%"!% /($(&(. (/*+*4( &%7*GF%% '(+1%.#$'!% "* 8(+; @&%1/* >%4('%/*, #@(#()#$'('*4( %;( @&%'&*F%"!G ' >%4('%>%#/!. 8(+;, (/(">*$%4<"(85 '(+"!/"('%"!G >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,.
291
J*/('* ' ()F!: >%&$*: 5#$*"('4%""*, 5>%"68!–1*&'!"!#$*8! '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* @(#4%1('*$%4<"(#$< A*/$(&(', #$!854!&('*'7!: '(+"!/"('%"!% >%4('%/*, #$*"('4%"!% >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,. R( E$( !8%""( $* @(#4%1('*$%4<"(#$< $%: ?% A*/$(&(' ! $($ ?% /("%>"6. &%+54<$*$, ( /($(&6: @(+1"%% @!#*4 L";%4<#, '6&*?*, @(+!2!G 8*&/#!#$#/(. A!4(#(A!! ' 1*""(8 '(@&(#%: «P"*>*4* $&51, * +*$%8 '8%#$% # "!8 >4%"(&*+1%4<"*, &%>< ,'!4!#< 1'58, #*868! ;4*'"68! #$!854*8!, @(1 '4!,"!%8 /($(&6: 8(+; ()%+<,"6 @(#$%@%""( @&%'&*$!4#, ' >%4('%>%#/!. 8(+;» (406, #. 490). § 6. "HLD4F5DEEKG 2H8;C M=CE=: 4F;E253DE=D 42J=;3OE24F= J&51('*, 1%,$%4<"(#$< ! >4%"(&*+1%4<"*, &%>< – E$! '*?"%.7!% A*/$(&6 (>%4('%>!'*"!, ()%+<,"6, #$*"('4%"!, >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!, – )64! )6, /("%>"(, "%'(+8(?"6 ' 5#4('!,: &*+()F%""(;( #5F%#$'('*"!, ?!'($"6: @&%1/(' >%4('%/*, !: ?!+"! ' (1!"(>/5. P4%1('*$%4<"(, "*+'*""6% A*/$(&6 8(;4! '#$5@!$< ' #!45, 8(;4! ()"*&5?!$< #'(G 1%.#$'%""(#$< $(4!! %F% (1"(;( A*/$(&* – !',"' @&%1/(' >%4('%/*. L";%4<# @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «R*7! ()%+<,"(@(1()"6% @&%1/!… )64! ()F%#$'%""68! ?!'($"68!, '@(4"% (>%'!1"(, >$( "%4<+, '6'(1!$< @&(!#:(?1%"!% >%4('%/*, E$(;( "*!)(4%% ()F%#$'%""(;( !+ '#%: ?!'($"6:, ($ "%()F%#$'%""6: )4!?*.7!: @&%1/('» ($*8 ?%, #. 488-489). -*"%% ( $(8 ?% @!#*4 M. 0(;$: «N%4('%/, @&%!85F%#$'%""( @%&%1 '#%8! (#$*4<"68!, %#$< ?!'($"(% ()F%?!$%4<"(%» (380, #. 716). B( 8"%"!G X. (4%7($$*, «>%4('%/ %#$< %1!"#$'%""(% ?!'($"(%, /($(&(% ?!'%$ "% $(4%4('%>!'*"!, ()%+<,"6 ,'!4#, (@&%1%4%""68 !"$%;&!&5GF!8 "*>*4(8 ! (1"('&%8%""( – !: (#"('(.. H 1%.#$'!$%4<"(, $&51('*, 1%,$%4<"(#$< @&%1/(' >%4('%/* 8(;4* '(+"!/"5$< 4!7< ' 5#4('!,: !: ()F%#$'%""(;(, * $(>"%% #/*+*$< – #$*1"(;( ()&*+* ?!+"!. «P 1&5;(. #$(&("6, – @!#*4 L";%4<#, – &*+'!$!% $&51* @( "%():(1!8(#$! #@(#()#$'('*4( )(4%% $%#"(85 #@4(>%"!G >4%"(' ()F%#$'*, $*/ /*/ )4*;(1*&, %85 #$*4! )(4%% >*#$6 #45>*! '+*!8"(. @(11%&?/!, #('8%#$"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$!, ! #$*4( ,#"%. (#(+"*"!% @(4<+6 E$(. #('8%#$"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! 14, /*?1(;( ($1%4<"(;( >4%"*» (406, #. 489). Q(4%% $%#"(% #@4(>%"!% >4%"(' #(()F%#$'* ' @&(2%##% 5#4(?",GF%.#, $&51('(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! @($&%)('*4( ! )(4%% #('%&7%""6: #&%1#$' !: ()F%"!,. «M(&($/( ;('(&,, A(&8!&('*'7!%#, 4G1! @&!74! / $(85, >$( 5 "!: @(,'!4*#< 2!-$*<"!1-8 0-!--! 16%,%-8 1&5; 1&5;5» ($*8 ?%). L$* @($&%)"(#$< ! @&!'%4* / '(+"!/"('%"!G >4%"(&*+1%4<"(. &%>! # %% #(+"*"!% ()5#4('4!'*GF%. A5"/2!%..
292
J*/!8 ()&*+(8, ! $&51('*, 1%,$%4<"(#$<, ! >4%"(&*+1%4<"*, &%>< #$*4! '(+8(?"68! 4!7< ' 5#4('!,: ()F%#$'%""(;( ()&*+* ?!+"! @&%14G1%.. H8 ?% (@&%1%4,4!#< !: '+*!8(#',+< ! '+*!8(()5#4('4%""(#$<, !: @(#4%15GF%% #('%&7%"#$'('*"!% ! '( '#%8 E$(8 – #$*"('4%"!% >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,. 3)F%#$'%""6. ()&*+ ?!+"! ,'!4#,, #4%1('*$%4<"(, $%8 @(4%8, "* /($(&(8 &*+'%&$6'*4#, @&(2%## (>%4('%>!'*"!, ()%+<,"6, ! $%8 #$%&?"%8, /($(&6. #(%1!",4 ! #/&%@4,4 (#"('"6% #(#$*'4,GF!% "*+'*""(;( @&(2%##*. B(",$"(, >$( ' ()I,#"%"!! @&(!#:(?1%"!, >%4('%/* ! %;( #(+"*"!, 5>%"6%-1*&'!"!#$6 "% 8(;4! @&(.$! 8!8( E$(. %;( @&%1@(#64/!, "% 8(;4! "% ()&*$!$< '"!8*"!% "* %% (),+*$%4<"(#$< 14, (>%4('%>!'*"!, ()%+<,"6. «N%4('%/ – ()F%#$'%""(% ?!'($"(%», – @!#*4 K*&'!" (142, #. 224). 3" #>!$*4 @&! E$(8, >$( #('&%8%""6. >%4('%/, «1*?% ' #*8(8 1!/(8 #'(%8 #(#$(,"!!, %#$< '#%$*/! #*8(% ;(#@(1#$'5GF%% ?!'($"(%, /*/(% /(;1*-4!)( @(,'!4(#< "* +%84%. 3" &*#@&(#$&*"!4#, 1*4<7% '#%: 1&5;!: '6#(/( (&;*"!+('*""6: #5F%#$', ! '#% 1&5;!% ($#$5@!4! @%&%1 "!8. 3>%'!1"(, (" (),+*" E$!8 "%!+8%&!8(85 @&%'(#:(1#$'5 #'(!: 58#$'%""6: #@(#()"(#$%. ! ()F%#$'%""(85 ()&*+5 ?!+"!, /($(&6% "*5>!4! %;( @(8(;*$< #'(!8 $('*&!F*8 ! +*F!F*$< !:, * $*/?% #'(%85 A!+!>%#/(85 #$&(%"!G» ($*8 ?%, #. 172). O8#$'%""6% #@(#()"(#$! ! ()F%#$'%""6. ()&*+ ?!+"! K*&'!" #>!$*4 «()#$(,$%4<#$'*8! @%&'(#$%@%""(. '*?"(#$! 14, >%4('%/*» ($*8 ?%, #. 173). W#$%#$'%""(, >$( @%&'(#$%@%""*, '*?"(#$< ()F%#$'%""(;( ()&*+* ?!+"! ! #',+*""(;( # "!8 &*+'!$!, 58#$'%""6: #@(#()"(#$%. @&(,'4,4(#<, @&%?1% '#%;(, ' @%&!(1 (>%4('%>!'*"!, ()%+<,"6, @(#$%@%""(;( @&%'&*F%"!, E$(;( #$*1"(;( ?!'($"(;( ' ()F%#$'%""(;( >%4('%/*. «C6#(/(% +"*>%"!% E$!: #'(.#$', – @!#*4 K*&'!", !8%, ' '!15 ()F%#$'%""6. ()&*+ ?!+"! ! 58#$'%""6% #@(#()"(#$!, – @&(,'!4(#< ' (/(">*$%4<"(8 &%+54<$*$% )(&<)6 +* ?!+"<» ($*8 ?%, #. 172), $( %#$< ' (/(">*$%4<"(8 '61%4%"!! >%4('%/* !+ ?!'($"(;( 8!&*. V((4(;!>%#/!. A*/$(& ! +1%#< @%&%7%4 ' #'(G @&($!'(@(4(?"(#$< – ' A*/$(& #(2!*4<"6.. =.C. B4%:*"(' ($8%$!4 ' #',+! # E$!8, >$( «()F%#$'%""6. >%4('%/ – @&(15/$ 14!$%4<"(;( +((4(;!>%#/(;( &*+'!$!,» (308, #. 207). C.H. D%"!" )(4%% $(>"( '6&*+!4 E$5 86#4< ( 8%#$% +((4(;!>%#/(;( ! #(2!*4<"(;( ' #$*"('4%"!! >%4('%/*, ( @%&%:(1% ($ (1"(;( / 1&5;(85. J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' @!#<8% 9. . =(&%#/(;( !"1!'!15*4!+8* ' A(&8!&5GF%8#, >%4('%/%, C.H. D%"!" @(1>%&/"54, >$( «()5+1*4( %;( ! @%&'()6$"(% #$*4( ! @%&'()6$"*, /(885"*» (206, #. 232), $( %#$< &%7*GF%% +"*>%"!% ' '(+"!/"('%"!! >%4('%/*, ' (/(">*$%4<"(8 '61%4%"!! %;( !+ ?!'($"(;( 8!&* C.H. D%"!" @&!1*4 ()F%#$'%""(85 ()&*+5 ?!+"! – E$(85 '*?"%.7%85 #(2!*4<"(85 A*/$(&5. R( #(2!*4<"68 (" #$*4, /("%>"( ?%, 1*4%/( "% #&*+5. C #$*1% >%4('%/(()&*+"6: ()%+<," %;( '"%7",, A(&8* ()F%#$'%""(#$! !8%4* !"(%, "% #(2!*4<"(%, * )!(4(;!>%#/(% #(1%&?*"!%. 3"(-$( ! #(#$*'!4(
293
(#"('5 (1"(;( !+ '*?"%.7!: *#@%/$(' 1*&'!"#/(;( ()I,#"%"!, (>%4('%>!'*"!, ()%+<,"6. P5$< 1%4* ' $(8, >$( #@(#()"(#$< / ()F%#$'%""(85 ()&*+5 ?!+"!, @($&%)"(#$< ' "%8 +*4(?%"* ' )!(4(;!>%#/(. (&;*"!+*2!! ?!'($"6:, ' >*#$"(#$!, ()%+<,", / /($(&68 @&!"*14%?*4! ! )4!?*.7!% @&%1/! >%4('%/*. «J*/ /*/ >%4('%/ – ()F%#$'%""(% ?!'($"(%, – @!#*4 K*&'!", – $(, (" $(?% "*#4%15%$ "*/4(""(#$< )6$< '%&"68 #'(!8 $('*&!F*8 ! @('!"('*$<#, '(?1G #'(%;( @4%8%"!, @($(85 >$( E$( >%&$*, #'(.#$'%""*, )(4<7!"#$'5 ()F%#$'%""6: ?!'($"6:» (142, #. 224). «3)F%#$'%""6% !"#$!"/$6, – @!#*4 . =G.(, /(88%"$!&5, '6'(16 K*&'!"*, – #5$< "%!+)%?"6. @&(15/$ ;17!9'= >',"', ' /($(&6: "*:(1,$#, ?!'($"6%» (137, #. 173). 3)F%#$'%""6. ()&*+ ?!+"! ?!'($"6: @&%1/(' >%4('%/* )64 "%!+)%?%" 14, "!: /*/ (1"( !+ '*?"%.7!: 5#4('!. @(11%&?*"!, !8! #'(%;( #5F%#$'('*"!,: !: ($"(#!$%4<"*, #4*)(#$< ' #&*'"%"!! # 1&5;!8! ?!'($"68!, (#()%""( :!F"!/*8!, @()5?1*4* !: ?!$< ! 1%.#$'('*$< #(()F*. «\!'($"(%, ()4*1*GF%% )(4<7!8 &(#$(8, #!4(. ! #'!&%@(#$%4('%/* )64( )6 )%#/("%>"( '6;(1"%% @&(!+(.$! ($ /*/(;("!)51< #&*'"!$%4<"( #4*)(;( #5F%#$'*» (142, #. 185). R( 1%4( $5$, /("%>"(, "% #$(4%8-$( #5)I%/$!'"(8, * ' ()I%/$!'"(. "%():(1!8(#$!. N%4('%/ "% 8(; "% @&(!+(.$! ($ #&*'"!$%4<"( #4*)(;( (A!+!>%#/!) #5F%#$'*. B&%'(#:(1#$'( >%4('%/(()&*+"(. ()%+<,"6 ' A!+!>%#/(. #!4% @%&%1 1&5;!8! ?!'($"68! ,'!4(#< )6 ;4*'"68 $(&8(+(8 "* @5$! / %% (>%4('%>!'*"!G. 0(&8!&5GF!.#, >%4('%/ "%!+)%?"( 1(4?%" )64 5#$5@*$< ' #!4% 1&5;!8 ?!'($"68 – @&($!'"!/*8 ' )(&<)% +* #5F%#$'('*"!%, 1* ! +* !#$(>"!/! @!F! $(?%. « *4*, #!4* >%4('%/*, %;( "%+"*>!$%4<"*, )6#$&($*, "%1(#$*$(/ @&!&(1"(;( (&5?!, ! 1&. )64! )(4%% >%8 5&*'"('%7%"6, '(@%&'6:, %;( 58#$'%""68! #@(#()"(#$,8!, @(#&%1#$'(8 /($(&6: (", "*:(1,#< %F% ' 1!/(8 #(#$(,"!!, 5?% #(+1*'*4 #%)% (&5?!%, (&51!, ! @&., !, '(-'$(&6:, %;( ()F%#$'%""68! #'(.#$'*8!, /($(&6% "*5>!4! %;( @(8(;*$< #'(!8 #()&*$<,8 ! @(45>*$< @(8(F< ($ "!:» ($*8 ?%). R( 58#$'%""6% #@(#()"(#$! ! ()F%#$'%""6. ()&*+ ?!+"! 8(?"( +1%#< &*##8*$&!'*$< "% $(4%#/5G #4*)(#$< ?!'($"6: @&%1/(' >%4('%/*. %?15 "!8! 8(?"( 5#$*"('!$< ! (@&%1%4%""5G @&!>!""(–#4%1#$'%""5G #',+< – @(1 5;4(8 +&%"!, $(. ?% A!+!>%#/(. #4*)(#$!. C ?!'($"(8 8!&% ' )(&<)% +* #5F%#$'('*"!% '6?!'*%$, /*/ !+'%#$"(, )(4%% #!4<"6.. R%():(1!8(#$< '6?!$< 14, A!+!>%#/! ($"(#!$%4<"( )(4%% #4*)6: #5F%#$' "*$*4/!'*4* "* %1!"#$'%""6. @5$< 5'%4!>%"!, #!46 – "* @5$< #(%1!"%"!, 8"(;!: #4*)6: #!4 ' %1!"5G #!45 #(()F%#$'*, #$*1*. 3$"(#!$%4<"( '6#(/!. 5&('%"< &*+'!$!, 58#$'%""6: #@(#()"(#$%.
294
?!'($"6: @&%1/(' >%4('%/* ((@&%1%4%""(. @(&(16 >%4('%/(()&*+"6: ()%+<,") @(+'(4,4 !8 '6)&*$< E$($ @5$< 5'%4!>%"!, #!46, &*+58%%$#,, #"*>*4* >!#$( !"#$!"/$!'"(, @(1()"( 1&5;!8 #$*1"68 ?!'($"68. «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» ($*8 ?%, #. 242). O#$*"('!'7!%#, ()F%#$'%""6% /*>%#$'* +*/&%@4,4!#< @(#&%1#$'(8 %#$%#$'%""(;( ($)(&*: '6?!'*4! $% (#()!, /($(&6% "*:(1!4!#< ' #(#$*'% )(4%% $%#"6: ()I%1!"%"!., ! E$* @&!'6>/* ?!$< ! 1%.#$'('*$< #(()F* #$*4* @%&%1*'*$<#, @( "*#4%1#$'5 – #$*4* 14, /*?1(;( >4%"* #(()F%#$'* 5"*#4%1('*""(. @&!'6>/(.. J*/ )64( 5 "!+7!:, @( #&*'"%"!G # @&%1/*8! >%4('%/*, ?!'($"6:. R( «()F%#$'%""6% /*>%#$'*, ;&(8*1"5G '*?"(#$< /($(&6: "!/$( "% (#@*&!'*%$ 14, "!+7!: ?!'($"6:, )64!, )%+ #(8"%"!,, @&!()&%$%"6 &(1("*>*4<"!/*8! >%4('%/* *"*4(;!>"68 ()&*+(8, $( %#$< @5$%8 %#$%#$'%""(;( ($)(&* # @(8(F/!» ($*8 ?%). P('%&7%"#$'('*"!% #',+%. ! ($"(7%"!. '"5$&! #(()F%#$'* ?!'($"6: @&%1/(' >%4('%/* ' )(4<7(. 8%&% #@(#()#$'('*4( #('%&7%"#$'('*"!G !: 58#$'%""6: #@(#()"(#$%., '!1(!+8%"%"!G @(#4%1"!: @&!8%"!$%4<"( / "('68 ()#$(,$%4<#$'*8 ?!+"! ! 1%,$%4<"(#$! !, ' /("%>"(8 !$(;%, #@(#()#$'('*4( @(#$%@%""(85 #$*"('4%"!G >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,. «M*/ $(4*4<"!/! >%4('%/* #1%4*4!#< ()F%#$'%""68! (* E$( #45>!4(#<, '%&(,$"(, ' (>%"< &*""!. @%&!(1) 58#$'%""6% #@(#()"(#$! @(1 '4!,"!%8 @(1&*?*"!, ' #(%1!"%"!! # &*##51/(8 ! (@6$(8 1(4?"6 )64! &*+'!$<#, ! '!1(!+8%"!$<#, ' $*/(. #$%@%"!, >$( 86 "*:(1!8 $(4%&%1<, #5F%#$'%""( '4!,4( "* #('%&7%"#$'('*"!% ()F%#$'%""6: ($"(7%"!., "* 5/&%@4%"!% #',+%. 8%?15 @%&'68! 4G1<8!, #@(#()#$'('*4( A(&8!&('*"!G (@&%1%4%""6: E$!>%#/!: "(&8, (),+*$%4<"6: 14, >4%"(' #(()F%#$'*. «B( 8%&% $(;(, /*/ 86#4!$%4<"6% #@(#()"(#$! ! @&%15#8($&!$%4<"(#$< >4%"(' @4%8%"! #('%&7%"#$'('*4!#<, /*?16. !+ "!: 8(; 4%;/( 5)%1!$<#, !+ (@6$*, >$(, @(8(;*, 1&5;!8, (" ()6/"('%""( @(45>*4 @(8(F< ' #'(G (>%&%1<». R* E$(. (#"('% 5 >%4('%/* @(#$%@%""( '6&*)($*4*#< @&!'6>/* @(8(;*$< #'(!8 #(@4%8%""!/*8, * «@&!'6>/* 1%4*$< 1()&(, )%+ #(8"%"!,, 1(4?"* )64* 5#!4!$< >5'#$'( #!8@*$!!, #45?*F%% @%&'68 $(4>/(8 / 1()&68 1%4*8» ($*8 ?%, #. 243). P5F%#$'%""68 (@&%1%4!$%4%8 @('%1%"!, '"5$&! #(()F%#$'*, #!4<"68 @()51!$%4%8 / 1*4<"%.7%85 &*+'!$!G
295
()F%#$'%""6: /*>%#$' %;( >4%"(' #$*"('!$#, $*/(. 8(&*4<"6. ' #'(%. (#"('% A*/$(&, /*/ (1()&%"!% ! @(&!2*"!% #( #$(&("6 #(@4%8%""!/('. «R* @%&'()6$"(;( >%4('%/*, – @!#*4 K*&'!", – ' (>%"< ($1*4%""(% '&%8, '4!,4! (1()&%"!% ! @(&!2*"!% $('*&!F%.. 3>%'!1"(, >$( >4%"6 (1"(;( @4%8%"! (1()&,4! @(#$5@/!, /($(&6%, @( !: 8"%"!G, #45?!4! / ()F%. @(4<+% ! (#5?1*4! $%, /($(&6% /*+*4!#< !8 '&%1"68!» ($*8 ?%, #. 244). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, &*+'!$!% #(+"*"!, ' %;( #',+! # ()F%#$'%""68! ($"(7%"!,8! (/*+*4(#< 5 K*&'!"* "% $(4%4('%/* @( 585 !, '%&(,$"(, $*/?% @( ()F%#$'%""68 "*/4(""(#$,8, – @!#*4 K*&'!", – #$(,4!, )%+ #(8"%"!,, "!?% #*86: ;&5)6: !+ "6"% #5F%#$'5GF!: 1!/*&%.; "( '%#<8* 4%;/( @(",$<, >$( ("! 8(;4! #5F%#$'('*$< ! 1*?% )4*;(1%"#$'('*$<, %#4! "*&,15 # $%8, /*/ @(#$%@%""( 5$&*>!'*4!#< !: +'%&!"6% #@(#()"(#$!, /*/, "*@&!8%&, 4*+*"!% @( 1%&%'<,8 ! $. @., ("! &*+'!'*4!#< ' 58#$'%""(8 ($"(7%"!!» ($*8 ?%, #. 185). B&!+"*"!% K*&'!"(8 '*?"(. &(4! ()F%#$'%""6: ($"(7%"!. ' #$*"('4%"!! >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!, (+"*>*%$ A*/$!>%#/! ''%1%"!% !8 ' #!#$%85 *&;58%"$*2!! @( 1*""(85 '(@&(#5 '*?"%.7%;(, #(2!*4<"(;(, A*/$(&* ' %;( @%&%@4%$%"!! # 1&5;!8!, )!(4(;!>%#/!8!. L$( !8%""( $($ #45>*., ( /($(&(8 8(?"( #/*+*$< #4('*8! =.C. B4%:*"('*, >$( «K*&'!" ()I,#",%$ @&(!#:(?1%"!% >%4('%/* ! %;( #@(#()"(#$%. # $(>/! +&%"!, <'!7!#''. R( 5 "%;( %#$< "%#/(4%"!% ! 14, 1!+'!7!#!9» (308, #. 206). C >!#4% E$!: #$&*"!2 +*8%$"6 ! $%, "* /($(&6: #(1%&?*$#, @(4(?%"!,, /*#*GF!%#, &(4! ()F%#$'%""6: ($"(7%"!. ' #$*"('4%"!! #(+"*"!,. R( !: #(2!(4(;!>%#/(% +'5>*"!% @&!;457%"( )!(4(;!>%#/!8! 8($!'*8!: ()F%#$'%""6. ()&*+ ?!+"! >%4('%/* &*##8*$&!'*%$#, K*&'!"(8 /*/ #'(.#$'(, '(+"!/7%%, &*+'!'7%%#, ! ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% #(:&*"!'7%%#, "* )!(4(;!>%#/(. (#"('%. R( /*/ )6 $( "! )64(, 86#4< '6&*?%"*, 1%4( – ' %% @&(>$%"!!. 3"( 8(?%$ )6$< "*@&*'4%"( /*/ "* 1%$*4!, $*/ ! "* ()F5G A!4(#(A#/5G, 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/5G @(+!2!G. C @(#4%1"%8 #45>*% "%!+)%?%" '6'(1 ( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>"(#$! 1*&'!"('#/!: (#"('(@(4(?%"!. ' &*##8*$&!'*%8(8 '(@&(#%. -(4< #(2!*4<"(;( A*/$(&* ' #$*"('4%"!! ! &*+'!$!! >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!, ' $(. !4! !"(. 8%&% (#(+"*'*4! ! 1&5;!% 5>%"6%. J*/, =%//%4< '61%4!4, "*@&!8%&, «8%14%""(% ! @(#$%@%""(% #('%&7%"#$'('*"!% >%4('%>%#/(;( 15:*, (),+*""(% $6#,>%4%$!,8 6;78-;$"!= ?!+"!» (93, #. 39). 3$8%$!' 1*4%%, >$( «#('8%#$"*, ?!+"< ' (&;*"!+('*""6: ()F%#$'*: ()5#4('4!'*%$ &*+'!$!% #(2!*4<"6: ($"(7%"!. ! (),+*""(#$%.», =%//%4< @&! E$(8 @(1>%&/"54, >$( @&!8%"!$%4<"( / >%4('%/5 $% ! 1&5;!% «#1%4*4!#< '*?"%.7!8 &6>*;(8 %;( 58#$'%""(;( ! "&*'#$'%""(;( @&(;&%##*» ($*8 ?%, #. 54). P&%1! 1&5;!: 8*$%&!*4<"6: A*/$(&(', #@(#()#$'('*'7!: (/(">*$%4<"(85 '61%4%"!G >%4('%/* !+ ?!'($"(;( 8!&*, (>%"< '*?"5G
296
&(4< 5>%"6% '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* ($'(1!4! 5@($&%)4%"!G !#"(. 3$/&6$!% !#/5##$'* 1()6'*$< (;("<, @( 8"%"!G K*&'!"*, «'%&(,$"(, #*8(% '%4!/(% !+ '#%:, +* !#/4G>%"!%8 &%>!». B%&'(#$%@%""(% +"*>%"!% E$(;( A*/$(&* – "% $(4"!/* $%@4*, "( ! ' 545>7%"!! /*>%#$'* @!F!, >$( "% 8(;4( "% ($&*+!$<#, "* '#%8 (&;*"!+8% A(&8!&('*'7%;(#, >%4('%/*, * #4%1('*$%4<"( – "* 8(+;%, "* 545>7%"!! %;( A5"/2!("!&('*"!,. K*&'!", &*#/&6'*, &(4< (;", ' %;( ($"(7%"!! / @!F%, @!#*4, >$( @%&'6. >%4('%/ «($/&64 !#/5##$'( 1()6'*$< (;("<, @&! @(8(F! /($(&(;( $']&16%, 1%&%',"!#$6% /(&"! 8(?"( #1%4*$< 51()('*&!868!, * ,1('!$6% /(&"! ! $&*'6 )%+'&%1"68!» (142, #. 172). R( )4*;($'(&"*, &(4< (;", @&(,'!4*#<, /("%>"( ?%, "% $(4%#$'( @&!()&%4* ?!'($"*, @!F*, 8,#(. L";%4<#, /*/ !+'%#$"(, @&!1*'*4 8,#"(. @!F% !#/4G>%"( '*?"(% +"*>%"!% ' 1%4% A(&8!&('*"!, >%4('%/*. B( %;( 8"%"!G, >%4('%/ '(()F% « "% 8(; #$*$< >%4('%/(8 )%+ 8,#"(. @!F!», @(#/(4$! ;($('(8 '!1% "*!)(4%% '*?"6% '%F%#$'*, "%():(1!86% (&;*"!+85 14, ()8%"* '%F%#$'. «B&!'6>/* / 8,#"(. @!F% "*&,15 # &*#$!$%4<"(. >&%+'6>*."( #@(#()#$'('*4* 5'%4!>%"!G A!+!>%#/(. #!46 ! #*8(#$(,$%4<"(#$! A(&8!&('*'7%;(#, >%4('%/*. R( "*!)(4%% #5F%#$'%""(% '4!,"!% 8,#"*, @!F* (/*+*4* "* 8(+;, @(45>*'7!. )4*;(1*&, %. ' ;(&*+1( )(4<7%8 /(4!>%#$'%, >%8 &*"<7%, $% '%F%#$'*, /($(&6% "%():(1!86 14, %;( @!$*"!, ! &*+'!$!,, >$( 1*4( %85 '(+8(?"(#$< )6#$&%. ! @(4"%. #('%&7%"#$'('*$<#, !+ @(/(4%"!, ' @(/(4%"!%»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«#5$< @&,86% @(#4%1#$'!, &*+'!$!, %;( "*)4G1*$%4<"(. #@(#()"(#$!, @*8,$!, @6$4!'(#$!, '(()&*?%"!, ! &*##51/*» (142, #. 172). C #',+! # E$!8 K*&'!" '6&*+!4 #'(% "%#(;4*#!% # 5$'%&?1%"!%8 O(44%#* ( $(8, >$( «@5$%8 %#$%#$'%""(;( ($)(&* 1!/*&< 8(; @&!()&%#$! 8(+;, &*+'!$6. 4!7< "%#/(4%8 5 ()%+<,"6» ($*8 ?%, #. 172-173). B( 8"%"!G K*&'!"*, 5&('%"< &*+'!$!, 8(+;*, * +"*>!$, ! 58#$'%""6: #@(#()"(#$%. @%&'6: 4G1%. )64 "*8"(;( '67%, >%8 5 @&%17%#$'%""!/(' – >%4('%/(()&*+"6: ()%+<,".
297
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– '#% E$(, '4!,, "* A5"/2!("!&('*"!% 8(+;*, '6+6'*4( (@&%1%4%""6% !+8%"%"!, ' "%8, >$( "% 8(;4( "% ($&*+!$<#, ! "* %;( ()I%8%. K*&'!" ' #',+! # E$!8 '6&*+!4 5)%?1%"!%, >$( «5 >%4('%/* #5F%#$'5%$ $%#"*, #',+< 8%?15 ()I%8(8 8(+;* ! #$%@%"$(, #4%1('*$%4<"(, «# @(#$%@%""68 &*+'!$!%8 58#$'%""6: #@(#()"(#$%. 8(+; 1(4?%" )64 5'%4!>!$<#,», ($#G1* «)(4<7!. ()I%8 8(+;* 5 >%4('%/* @( ($"(7%"!G / %;( $%45, ' #&*'"%"!! # 8(+;(8 ;(&!446 !4! (&*";*, $%#"( #',+*" # )(4%% '6#(/!8! 58#$'%""68! #@(#()"(#$,8! >%4('%/*»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«C6#7!% 58#$'%""6% #@(#()"(#$! >%4('%/*, – @!#*4 K*&'!", – "*@&!8%&, 8674%"!%, ($'4%>%"!%, #*8(#(+"*"!% ! $.1., 1(4?"6 )64!, '%&(,$"(, @&(!+(.$! ($ @&(1(4?!$%4<"(;( 5@($&%)4%"!, ! 5#('%&7%"#$'('*"!, 1&5;!: 58#$'%""6: #@(#()"(#$%.» ($*8 ?%, #. 648). O8#$'%""6% #@(#()"(#$! >%4('%/* ' @&(2%##% !: #('%&7%"#$'('*"!, "%!+)%?"( ()&%$*G$ 5*(-*78".= :*&*/$%&: "%():(1!8(#$< (#86#4%"!, "*/*@4!'*%8(;( (@6$* ' ()#$(,$%4<#$'*:, #',+*""6: # ()F%#$'%""(. ?!+"*$4%"!., A5"/2!("!&('*"!% ,+6/* – '#% E$( ! 8"(;(% 1&5;(% @()5?1*4( &*+'!'*GF!.#, >%4('%>%#/!. 8(+; / !"$%"#!'"(. 86#4!$%4<"(. &*)($%. «N%4('%/ '#4%1#$'!% 1%,$%4<"(;( :*&*/$%&* #'(!: 58#$'%""6: #@(#()"(#$%. "% 8(?%$ !+)%?*$< &*+8674%"!.: @&(746% '@%>*$4%"!, ! ()&*+6 # )(4<7(. ,#"(#$!"*%$ (:'*$6'*$< "% $(4
298
! !: @(#4%1#$'!,, '#% )(4%% ! )(4%% ($1*4%""6%. «P "*&*#$*"!%8 (@6$* ! &*+58*, – @!#*4 K*&'!", – >%4('%/ +*8%>*%$ #*86% ($1*4%""6% @(#4%1#$'!, #'(!: @(#$5@/('». H"*>% ;('(&,, &*+'!'*%$#, $*/(% >!#$( >%4('%>%#/(% #'(.#$'( #(+"*"!,, /*/ 2$*59'5*"'* <;5;?*#!, !1%*4<"(% '(#@&(!+'%1%"!% '(+8(?"6: &%+54<$*$(' 1%,$%4<"(#$! ' "*#$(,F%8, >$( ' )(4<7(. 8%&% #@(#()#$'('*4( '(+&*#$*"!G %% 5#@%7"(#$!. B&!8%"!$%4<"( ?% / !-"!3*"'(: 8%?15 @%&'68! 4G1<8! ' 5#4('!,: 5/&%@4%"!, ()F%#$'%""6: A(&8 ?!+"! "*+'*""(% #'(.#$'( #(+"*"!, !8%4( %F% (1"( "%8*4('*?"(% #4%1#$'!%: )4*;(1*&, %85 #$*4( '(+8(?"68 A(&8!&('*"!% (@,$< ?% #5;5)( >%4('%>%#/(;( – "&*'#$'%""(;( – >5'#$'*. «-*+'!'*%$#, 8*4(–@(8*45 $( >&%+'6>*."( #4(?"(% >5'#$'(, /($(&(% !8%%$ @%&'68 !#$(>"!/(8 ()F%#$'%""6% !"#$!"/$6, &5/('(1!$#, ' +"*>!$%4<"(. #$%@%"! (1()&%"!%8 #%)% @(1()"6:, 5@&*'4,%$#, &*##51/(8.., @(1/&%@4,%$#, ()&*+('*"!%8 ! @&!'6>/(., ! ' ()F%. #4(?"(#$! #(#$*'4,%$ "*7% "&*'#$'%""(% >5'#$'( !4! #('%#$<» ($*8 ?%, #. 224). 9"*4!+!&5, E$($ *#@%/$ ' 5>%"!! K*&'!"*, A&*"25+#/!. A!4(#(A XIX '%/* . =G.( ($8%$!4, ' >*#$"(#$!: «N$()6 @&(!+'%#$! !+ !"#$!"/$(', 1(#$*'4,%86: "*8 ?!'($"68 2*&#$'(8, "$%91-9*""!* 1!,"%"'* ' #()#$'%""(8 #86#4% E$(;( #4('*, 1(#$*$(>"( )64( @&!#(%1!"!$< / "!8 &*+8674%"!%, ()1586'*"!% – /*>%#$'*, /($(&6: "!/$( "% )51%$ ($&!2*$< ' >%4('%/%. K*&'!" "*7%4 5 ?!'($"6: &(1 #*8(@&(!+'(4<"(. 1()&(1%$%4!, "&*'#$'%""6% !"#$!"/$6, %F% #/&6$6% ' )(4%% 7!&(/(. ;&5@@% #(2!*4<"6: !"#$!"/$('; @&!#(%1!"!$% / "!8 58 ! '6 @(45>!$%, @( K*&'!"5, >5'#$'( "$%91-9*""!= !<(,%""!1-', 5!7#%, /($(&(% @&%17%#$'5%$, #(@5$#$'5%$, $*/ #/*+*$<, 1%.#$'!G ! #4%15%$ +* "!8» (137, #. 169-170). C 2%4(8 ?%, !#:(1, !+ '#%;( ($8%>%""(;( '67%, 8(?"( #1%4*$< '6'(1, >$(, (@%&!&5, %#$%#$'%""("*5>"68! 1*""68!, 5>%"6%–1*&'!"!#$6 '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* #'(% ()I,#"%"!% #$*"('4%"!, ! &*+'!$!, #(+"*"!, #$&(!4! "* 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. (#"('%, ("!, #4%1('*$%4<"(, ! ' E$(8 '(@&(#% "% (#$*'4,4! 8%#$* 14, &%4!;!(+"6:, !1%*4!#$!>%#/!: '(++&%"!.. J*/(% ()I,#"%"!%, @( 8"%"!G =%//%4,, «1*%$ '(+8(?"(#$< @("!8*$< «5;3;» 0*7!9*6%, 6%6 &;"6+'4 *#! :!,#%, * "% /*/ "%/($(&(% (#()(;( &(1* 8!#$!>%#/(% ! "%8*$%&!*4<"(% #5F%#$'(… 9 '8%#$% # $%8 @*1*%$ "*'#%;1* ! !#$*#/*""6. 8!A )%##8%&$!, 157! – #$*&*, #/*+/*, /($(&*,, '@&(>%8, '($ 5?% # @(4#$(4%$!, 5$&*$!4* '#,/!. /&%1!$, )4*;(1*&, 8(;5>%85 &(#$5 #&*'"!$%4<"(. *"*$(8!! ! ("$(;%"!! (E8)&!(4(;!!), A!+!(4(;!! ! @*$(4(;!!» (90, #. 344-345). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, 1(#$!?%"!, &*+4!>"6: ($&*#4%. %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, (@&%1%4!'7!:#, ' )(4<7!"#$'% #'(%8 '( '$(&(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/*, #5F%#$'%""( @('4!,4! "* :(1 )(&<)6 8!&('(++&%"!. ' #A%&% A!4(#(A#/(;( @("!8*"!, #(+"*"!,. C6,'4%"!% ! A*/$!>%#/(% ()(#"('*"!% %#$%#$'(+"*"!%8 8*$%&!*4<"6: A*/$(&(' '(+"!/"('%"!, >%4('%/*, #$*"('4%"!, %;( #(+"*"!,, @( 8"%"!G 5>%"6:, 4!7*4( @(>'6 &%4!;!(+"6%, !1%*4!#$!>%#/!% @&%1#$*'4%"!, ( 157% >%4('%/*, ( %%
299
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§ 7. $82H3DB; ID325D<; 5 B;FD8=;3=4F=ID4<2G A=3242A== XVIII 5D<;: ID325D< = >8=827; *$%&!*4!#$6 XVIII '%/* ' &*##8($&%"!! A%"(8%"* >%4('%/* !#:(1!4!, @&%?1% '#%;(, !+ 8*$%&!*4<"(#$! %;( $%4%#"(. (&;*"!+*2!!, !+ @("!8*"!, >%4('%/* /*/ (@&%1%4%""(;( @&(,'4%"!, 8*$%&!! ' %% '!1(!+8%"%"!!. =(4<)*:, "*@&!8%&, @!#*4: «W#4! "*# #@&(#,$, >$( $*/(% >%4('%/, $( 86 ($'%$!8, >$( E$( – 8*$%&!*4<"(% #5F%#$'(, (&;*"!+('*""(% $*/, >$()6 >5'#$'('*$<, 86#4!$< ! !#@6$6'*$< '!1(!+8%"%"!,, #'(.#$'%""6% 4!7< %85 (1"(85, %;( (&;*"!+*2!! ! (#()68 #(>%$*"!,8 #()&*""6: ' "%8 '%F%#$'» (126, #. 123). *$%&!*4<"(#$< >%4('%/*, @( 8"%"!G =(4<)*:*, (@&%1%4,4*#< %;( @&!"*14%?"(#$%4('%/* ;(#@(1#$'('*'7!8 ' $( '&%8, &%4!;!(+"68, !1%*4!#$!>%#/!8 '(++&%"!,8. C %;( @("!8*"!!, >%4('%/ @( #'(%85 @&(!#:(?1%"!G @&%1#$*%$ "% /*/ )(?%#$'%""(% $'(&%"!%, "% /*/ @(&(?1%"!%, '(@4(F%"!% 15:('"(;( "*>*4*, * /*/ 2$!5;6- 2$'$!5.. P5F"(#$< >%4('%/* #(#$*'4,%$ ($4!>*GF!. %;( #@(#() @&!&(1"(;( )6$!,. L$( @(#4%1"%% !8%%$, # (1"(. #$(&("6, "%>$( ()F%% # )6$!%8 1&5;!: ?!'6: #5F%#$', "*@&*'4,%$#, 1%.#$'!%8 (1"!: ! $%: ?% +*/("(' @&!&(16, * # 1&5;(. – !8%%$ #@%2!A!/5, (@&%1%4%""(% #'(%()&*+!%, ()5#4('4%""(% 1%.#$'!%8 +*/("(', @&!#5F!: $(4*#$"(#$!: «W#4! "*# #@&(#,$ ( @&(!#:(?1%"!! #5F%#$'
300
>%4('%>%#/(;( &(1*, 86 ($'%$!8, >$( >%4('%/ %#$< @&(15/$ @&!&(16 @(1()"( @&(>!8 #5F%#$'*8, ' "%/($(&6: ($"(7%"!,: @(:(? "% @(#4%1"!:, @(1>!",,#< $%8 ?% +*/("*8, >$( ! ("!, "( ($4!>*%$#, ($ "!: ' 1&5;!: ($"(7%"!,: !, /&(8% $(;(, #4%15%$ #@%2!*4<"68 +*/("*8, '6$%/*GF!8 !+ (#()%""(#$%. %;( #$&(%"!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 123). R( ! E$! #@%2!*4<"6% +*/("6 #5$< $*/?% +*/("6 @&!&(16. H8! (@&%1%4,G$#, "% $(4%4('%/*, (#()%""(#$! %;( A!+!>%#/(;( #$&(%"!,, "( ! 15:('"*, #$(&("* %;( )6$!,, %;( #(+"*"!%. H8%""( @&!&(1*, @( 8"%"!G =(4<)*:*, "*1%4!4* >%4('%/* #(+"*"!%8 (#8. $*8 ?%, #. 119). (?"( ($8%$!$< 5 =(4<)*:* @(#$*"('/5 5?% $*/!: '(@&(#(', /*/: «C#%;1* 4! #5F%#$'('*4 >%4('%/? C%>%" 4! >%4('%>%#/!. &(1 !4! @&!&(1* #(+1*4* %;( ' (@&%1%4%""(% '&%8,? C#%;1* 4! #5F%#$'('*4! @(1()"6% "*8 4G1! ! '#%;1* 4! ("! )515$ #5F%#$'('*$%4('%/ )64 $%8, >%8 ,'4,%$#, $%@%&<, !4!, @&%?1% >%8 1(.$! 1( $%@%&%7"%;( #(#$(,"!,, (" 1(4?%" )64 @&(.$! )%#>!#4%""(% 8"(?%#$'( @&(8%?5$(>"6: #$*1!.? R*/("%2, 8(?%$ 4! >%4('%/ #>!$*$<, >$( (" 1(7%4 1( (/(">*$%4<"(;(, "%!+8%""(;( #(#$(,"!,, !4! >%4('%>%#/(85 &(15 @&%1#$(,$ %F% "('6% !+8%"%"!,?» ($*8 ?%, #. 123-124). P*8 =(4<)*: #>!$*4 '(+8(?"68 @&!+"*$<, >$( «>%4('%/ '(+"!/ ' (@&%1%4%""6. 8(8%"$ '&%8%"!, ,'4,%$#, #5F%#$'(8, :*&*/$%&"68 !8%""( 14, +%84!, !, #4%1('*$%4<"(, 8(?%$ #5F%#$'('*$< 4!7< # 8(8%"$* '(+"!/"('%"!, V%84!, ,'4,,#< &%+54<$*$(8 5@&*'4,GF!: %G #@%2!A!>%#/!: +*/("('» ($*8 ?%, #. 124). C &*+'!$!!, @(#$%@%""(8 #('%&7%"#$'('*"!! >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!, A&*"25+#/!% 8*$%&!*4!#$6 XVIII '%/* '*?"5G &(4< ($'(1!4! $*/(85 A*/$(&5, /*/ 5@($&%)4%"!% $;6. J*/, =%4<'%2!., *"*4!+!&5, '(@&(# ( @&!>!"*:, #@(#()#$'5GF!: 8674%"!G, ()&*+('*"!G !1%., ! ($8%$!' ' #',+! # E$!8 &(4< $*/!: #@(#()"(#$%. >%4('%/*, /*/ A!+!>%#/*, >5'#$'!$%4<"(#$< ! @*8,$<, ' $( ?% '&%8, @(1>%&/"54: «L$! #@(#()"(#$!, ' /($(&6: , '!?5 @&!>!"5 ()&*+('*"!, "*7!: 86#4%. ! /($(&6% #'(.#$'%""6 "% $(4$(?"(% >!#4( !1%., %#4! )6 ("! "% )64! ' "*# #',+*"6 # !+'%#$"(. (&;*"!+*2!%.» (99, #. 148). B(1 E$(. '"%7"%. (&;*"!+*2!%., #'(.#$'%""(. 5?% $(4%4('%/5, =%4<'%2!. ! @(1&*+58%'*4 &5/!, #@(#()"6% / (#5F%#$'4%"!G &*+"(()&*+"6:, ' @%&'5G (>%&%1< – $&51('6: (@%&*2!.. Q%+ &5/ «4G1! "% +"*4! )6 "! &%8%#4*, "! ?!4!F, "% 58%4! )6 +*F!F*$<#, ($ ?!'($"6: !, (+*)(>%""6% !#/4G>!$%4<"( 1()6'*"!%8 @!F! ! #$&%84%"!%8 !+)%?*$< 1!/!: +'%&%., '#% %F% )&(1!4! )6 ' 4%#*: @5;4!'68! #$*1*8!» ($*8 ?%, #. 149). P4%1('*$%4<"(, 5@($&%)4%"!% &5/, "*@&*'4,%8(% "* @(11%&?*"!% #5F%#$'('*"!, ! @&%?1% '#%;( "* !#@(4<+('*"!% (&51!. $&51*, ,'4,%$#,, @( 8"%"!G =%4<'%2!,, (),+*$%4<"(. @&%1@(#64/(. A(&8!&('*"!, ! #('%&7%"#$'('*"!, >%4('%>%#/(;( 8674%"!, ' %;(, >$( (#()%""( '*?"(, "%&*+&6'"(. #',+! # (,.6!:. «W#4! )6 '6>%&/"5$< !+ ,+6/* 4G)(;( "*&(1* #4('*: 7;6, 1-$*7., 1*-' ! @&. – '#%, >$( @&%1@(4*;*%$ 5@($&%)4%"!% &5/, – @!#*4 =%4<'%2!., – $( (" (/*+*4#, )6 ' 58#$'%""(8
301
&*+'!$!! "!?% "%/($(&6: 1!/!: "*&(1(', "% !8%GF!: 1'5:#($ !1%. ! 1'5:#($ #4(' 14, '6&*?%"!, E$!: !1%., ! %;( ,+6/, @(1()"( ,+6/5 ?!'($"6:, #(($'%$#$'%""( )64 )6 #'%1%" / @,$!–7%#$! +'5/*8 !4! /&!/*8. 3$#G1* , +*/4G>*G, >$( )%+ (@&%1%4%""(. '"%7"%. (&;*"!+*2!! >5'#$'!$%4<"(#$< ! @*8,$< )64! )6 ' "*# )%#@4(1"68! #@(#()"(#$,8!» ($*8 ?%). N$( /*#*%$#, #*8(;( A(&8!&('*"!, >4%"(&*+1%4<"(. &%>!, $( ! ("( &*##8*$&!'*4(#< A&*"25+#/!8! 8*$%&!*4!#$*8! /*/ %#$%#$'%""6. @&(2%##, '6$%/*GF!. !+ @&!&(1"6: /*>%#$' >%4('%/*. J*/, B. =*##%"1! %F% ' XVII '%/% ($8%>*4 45>75G, @( #&*'"%"!G # ?!'($"68!, #@(#()"(#$< >%4('%>%#/(;( ,+6/* !+1*'*$< «8"(;( >4%"(&*+1%4<"6: +'5/(', @&!;(1"6: / ()(+"*>%"!G (>%"< 8"(;!: @&%18%$('. 3$#G1* ! '(+"!/*%$ &*+;('(&, !4! &%><, @&! @(8(F! /($(&(. 4G1! ()F*G$#, 8%?15 #()(.» (77, #. 260). L$* #@(#()"(#$< / &%>! ! #*8* &%>< ,'!4!#< &%+54<$*$(8 %#$%#$'%""(;( &*+'!$!, >%4('%/* /*/ @&!&(1"(;( #5F%#$'*. «B%&'6% 4G1!, – @!#*4 =*##%"1!, – 1*4! '%F*8 "*+'*"!, "% ' #!45 @(14!""(;( +"*"!, ! "% @( ><%85-4!)( @&!/*+*"!G !4! @('%4%"!G.., * ' #!45 "%/(%;( %#$%#$'%""(;( @()5?1%"!,, @(1()"(;( $(85, /($(&(% +*#$*'4,%$ /*74,$<, >!:*$<, #$("*$<, 86>*$<, 4*,$<. C($ @(>%85 8(?"( 5$'%&?1*$<, >$( "*+'*"!, #5F%#$'5G$ "% ' #!45 5#$*"('4%"!,, * ($ @&!&(16, @(#/(4$(, "%#(8"%""(, %#$< &%+54<$*$ &*)($6 @&!&(16)» ($*8 ?%, #. 261). N4%"(&*+1%4<"*, &%>< "%():(1!8* 4G1,8 @&%?1% '#%;( /*/ #&%1#$'( !',"' 4G1%.. H 8*$%&!*4!#$6 XVIII '%/* :(&(7( (#(+"*'*4! E$(. 3"! '(()F% &*##8*$&!'*4! ()F%#$'%""6. ()&*+ ?!+"! /*/ (1!" !+ '*?"%.7!: A*/$(&(', (),+*$%4<"6: 14, >%4('%/*, 14, '#%;( %;( #5F%#$'('*"!,. J*/, @( 8"%"!G J(4*"1*, «>%4('%/ – ?!'($"(% ()F%#$'%""(%, /($(&(% "% 8(?%$ "! :(&(7(, "! #>*#$4!'(, "! 1*?% '(()F% ?!$< )%+ @(8(F! ! #(1%.#$'!, 1&5;!:» (7, #. 355). =(4<)*: $*/?% ($8%>*4 @&!#5F%% >%4('%/5 >5'#$'( ()F%#$'%""(#$!, $( %#$< «$(. #/4(""(#$!, /($(&*, @()5?1*%$ >%4('%/* ?!$< #('8%#$"( # @(1()"68! %85 #5F%#$'*8!. DG)('< / ()F%#$'5 – %#$%#$'%""(% >5'#$'( >%4('%/*, &*+'!'*%8(% ! /54<$!'!&5%8(% &*+58(8» (127, #. 87). N%4('%/, @( 8"%"!G =(4<)*:*, '#%;1* #5F%#$'('*4 ' ()F%#$'%. B&*'1*, /*/ ! K*&'!" '@(#4%1#$'!!, =(4<)*: '6'(1!4 ()F%#$'%""6. ()&*+ ?!+"! >%4('%/* !+ @&!&(16. H E$( @(",$"(. B(#/(4%4('%/ &*##8*$&!'*4#, /*/ @&(15/$ @&!&(16, $( ! >5'#$'* %;(, *, #4%1('*$%4<"(, ! >5'#$'( ()F%#$'%""(#$! $(?% – ($ @&!&(16. «B&!&(1*, #(+1*' >%4('%/* >5'#$'5GF!8 #5F%#$'(8, "*1%4!4* %;( >5'#$'(8 ()F%#$'%""(#$!» ($*8 ?%, #. 97). L$( @&!&(1(. ()5#4('4%""(% >5'#$'( ()F%#$'%""(#$! ! ()I%1!",%$ 4G1%. ' ()F%#$'(, #/&%@4,%$ #',+! ' "%8, @(11%&?!'*%$ !: @(#$(,"#$'(. P4%1('*$%4<"(, ! ()F%#$'(, @(1()"( >%4('%/5, ' #'(%8
302
'(+"!/"('%"!! ! @(#4%15GF%8 #5F%#$'('*"!! "% @(1'%&?%"( '8%7*$%4<#$'5 /*/!:-4!)( '"%7"!: #!4, ("( – &%+54<$*$ &*+'%&$6'*"!, %#$%#$'%""6: @&(2%##(', @&(15/$ @&!&(16. «3)F%#$'(, – @!#*4 =(4<)*:, – ,'4,%$#, @&(!+'%1%"!%8 @&!&(16, @(#/(4%4('%/* ' ()F%#$'%» ($*8 ?%, #. 87). 9&;58%"$6, @&!'(1!86% =(4<)*:(8 ' @(4<+5 $*/(;( '+;4,1* "* ()F%#$'%""6. ()&*+ ?!+"!, $*/?% '( 8"(;(8 "*@(8!"*G$ *&;58%"$*2!G K*&'!"*. J*/, =(4<)*: '(+'(1!4 >5'#$'( ()F%#$'%""(#$! / "%():(1!8(#$! ' "%8 14, 2%4%. #*8(#(:&*"%"!,, / (#(+"*"!G >%4('%/(8 @(4%+"(#$! ?!+"! ' ()F%#$'% #%)% @(1()"6: !, #(($'%$#$'%""(, '&%1"(#$! ?!+"! ' (1!"(>/5, $( %#$< '(+'(1!4 "*+'*""(% >5'#$'( / >!#$( %#$%#$'%""68 @()5?1%"!,8. =(4<)*: @!#*4, ' >*#$"(#$!: «DG)('< / ()F%#$'5, !4! >5'#$'( ()F%#$'%""(#$!, %#$< >5'#$'( '$(&!>"(%, ,'4,GF%%#, @4(1(8 (@6$* ! &*##51/*. -*##51(/ ?% %#$< "% >$( !"(%, /*/ '6&*)*$6'*%8(% (@6$(8 !4! &*+8674%"!%8 58%"!% ($4!>*$< @(4%+"(% ($ '&%1"(;(» ($*8 ?%). -*+'!'*, E$5 86#4<, =(4<)*: @&(1(4?*4 1*4%%: «N%4('%/ ?!'%$ ' ()F%#$'% @($(85, >$( !8%""( $*8 @&!&(1* @&%1(@&%1%4,%$ %;( &(?1%"!%, (" 4G)!$ E$( ()F%#$'(, $*/ /*/ #>!$*%$ %;( "%():(1!868 14, #%),. B(E$(85, /(;1* ;('(&,$, >$( 4G)('< / ()F%#$'5 – >5'#$'( %#$%#$'%""(%, E$( (+"*>*%$, >$( >%4('%/, #$&%8,#< / #*8(#(:&*"%"!G ! #>*#$!'*$<; &(?1%""6. #( #@(#()"(#$5'#$'('*$<, (" @&%1@(>!$*%$ :(&(7%% 15&"(85; )515>! '(#@&!!8>!'68 / (@6$5 ! #@(#()"68 / &*+8674%"!G, (" @(#$5@*%$ &*##51!$%4<"(, $( %#$< @&(,'4,%$ #@(#()"(#$< #&*'"!'*$< @&%!85F%#$'*, 1(#$*'4,%86% %85 ()F%#$'%""(. ?!+"$( 2%"!$ )4*;(@(45>!% ! >5'#$'5%$ #%), :(&(7(, "*:(1,#< ' )%+(@*#"(#$!. L$! >5'#$'* %#$%#$'%""6, $( %#$< '6$%/*G$ !+ #*8(. #5F"(#$! !4! @&!&(16 #5F%#$'*, /($(&(% #$&%8!$#, / #*8(#(:&*"%"!G… C#% 1(/*+6'*%$ >%4('%/5, >$( ()F%#$'%""*, ?!+"< #$*'!$ %;( ' )(4%% '6;(1"(% @(4(?%"!%, @&!'6>/* @&!',+6'*%$ %;( / ()F%#$'5, ! (" >5'#$'5%$ #%), "%#>*#$"68, /*/ $(45'#$'* ()F%#$'%""(#$!» ($*8 ?%, #. 88). H E$( >5'#$'( ()F%#$'%""(#$! @&!#5F% >%4('%/5 "* '#%: E$*@*: %;( !#$(&!!, #4%1('*$%4<"(, ! "* #*86: &*""!:, "*>*4<"6:. B&!8%"!$%4<"( / @%&'68 4G1,8, 4G1,8 @%&!(1* 1!/(#$! 86#4< ( "%!+)%?"(#$! !: ()I%1!"%"!, ' #(()F%#$'* &*+'!'*4, ' >*#$"(#$!, =%4<'%2!.. 3", /*/ ! K*&'!" '@(#4%1#$'!!, ()I,#",4 E$5 "%!+)%?"(#$< ($"(#!$%4<"(. A!+!>%#/(. #4*)(#$/5 1()6'*$< @!F5, @&($!'(#$(,$< :!F"!/*8 ' )(&<)% +* #5F%#$'('*"!%. «N%4('%/ @( #'(%. @&!&(1%, – @!#*4 =%4<'%2!., – ! $&*'(,1"(%, ! @4($(,1"(% #5F%#$'(. B&! E$(8 (" #4*), @4(:( '((&5?%", !, #4%1('*$%4<"(, 8(?%$ #$*$< ?%&$'(. @&(?(&4!'(#$! )(4%% #!4<"6:, >%8
303
(", ?!'($"6:. B(E$(85, >$()6 1()6$< #%)% @!F5 !4! #@*#$!#< ($ ,&(#$! $!;&* !4! 4<'*, >%4('%/ 1(4?%" )64 #(%1!"!$<#, # 1&5;!8! 4G1<8!. [%4$()6 @(%1*$< !:, 4!)( 14, $(;(, >$()6 +*F!F*$< ($ "!: @4(16 ! ('(F!, #45?!'7!% >%4('%/5 @!F%.» (100, #. 93). H =%4<'%2!. #1%4*4 '6'(1, >$( «5 >%4('%/*, /*/ ! 5 ?!'($"(;(, ()F!$%4<"(#$< %#$< &%+54<$*$ @($&%)"(#$!» ($*8 ?%, #. 94). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, !8%%$#, 1(#$*$(>"( (#"('*"!. 14, '6'(1* ( $(8, >$( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! XVIII '%/* +* #$( 4%$ 1( K*&'!"* ! 1*&'!"!#$(' )64! '@(4"% >%$/( ()(+"*>%"6 8"(;!% @&!"2!@!*4<"( '*?"6% *#@%/$6 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(;( &%7%"!, @&()4%86 #$*"('4%"!, >%4('%/* ! %;( #(+"*"!, –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«B&! ($#5$#$'!! (@6$"6: 1*""6: >%4('%>%#/(. 4G)(+"*$%4<"(#$!, '#%;1* 5#$&%84,GF%.#, +* @&%1@!#*""6% "*7%85 15:5 ;&*"!26, @&!:(1!$#, ()&*$!$<#, / ;!@($%+%» (126, #. 124). L$( !8%4( #*8(% "%@(#&%1#$'%""(% ($"(7%"!% ! / &*##8*$&!'*%8(. @&()4%8%. «W#4! "*# #@&(#,$, ($/51* @(,'!4#, >%4('%/, – @!#*4 =(4<)*:, – $( 86 ($'%$!8, >$( (@6$ "% 1*%$ "*8 '(+8(?"(#$! &%7!$< E$($ '(@&(#» ($*8 ?%, #. 123). (?"( )64( @(E$(85 4!7< #$&(!$< )(4%% !4! 8%"%% @&*'1(@(1()"6% 1(;*1/!, '61'!;*$< (#$(&(?"6% @&%1@(4(?%"!, ($"(#!$%4<"( '(+8(?"(;( &%7%"!, @&()4%86. =(4<)*: #>!$*4, "*@&!8%&, >$( «%#$< &,1 #(()&*?%"!., ;('(&,F!:, @(-'!1!8(85, ' @(4<+5 ;!@($%+6 ( $(8, >$( >%4('%/ '(+"!/ ' (@&%1%4%""6. 8(8%"$ '&%8%"!, ,'4,%$#, #5F%#$'(8, :*&*/$%&"68 !8%""( 14, V%84!, !, #4%1('*$%4<"(, 8(?%$ #5F%#$'('*$< 4!7< # 8(8%"$* '(+"!/"('%"!, V%84!, ,'4,,#< &%+54<$*$(8 5@&*'4,GF!: %G #@%2!A!>%#/!: +*/("('» ($*8 ?%, #. 124). J*/!8 ()&*+(8, 86#4< ( '(+"!/"('%"!! >%4('%/* ! %;( #(+"*"!, @(1 '4!,"!%8 >!#$( @&!&(1"6: A*/$(&(' '6#$5@!4* @%&'("*>*4<"( ' A(&8% A!4(#(A#/(. ;!@($%+6, '61'!"5$(. ' XVIII '%/% A!4(#(A*8!8*$%&!*4!#$*8!, * $*/?% H. M*"$(8. C 1(/&!$!>%#/!. @%&!(1 #('%. "*5>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! ' &*)($*:, @(#',F%""6: '(@&(#*8 %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ! A!4(#(A!! @&!&(16, M*"$ '61'!"54 "%8*4( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!: !1%.. P&%1! "!: )64! $*/!%, /($(&6% @(+'(4,G$, @( #'!1%$%4<#$'5 =%//%4,,
304
&*##8*$&!'*$< '%4!/(;( /%"!;#)%&;#/(;( A!4(#(A* /*/ «@%&'(;( ! '61*GF%;(#, @&%17%#$'%""!/* K*&'!"*» (89, #. 79), ' $(8 >!#4% ! ' &%7%"!! '(@&(#* ( '(+"!/"('%"!! >%4('%/*, ( "*>*4% >%4('%>%#/(. !#$(&!!. M*"$ @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8: «…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«#$*&68! $('*&!F*8!», ?!'($"68!. J*/, "*@&!8%&, ' &%2%"+!! "* /"!;5 (#/*$! «3 #5F%#$'%""(8 &*+4!>!! ' #$&(%"!! $%4* ?!'($"6: ! 4G1%.» (1771) M*"$ @!#*4: «B%&'*, +*)($* @&!&(16 #(#$(,4* ' $(8, >$()6 >%4('%/ ' /*>%#$'% ?!'($"(;( #(:&*"!4#, 57( 1*<( ' 57( 19!*#! $!5%, * 14, E$(;( #5F%#$'('*4(… @(4(?%"!% 0*-9*$!"!#!#!; "( +*)($(. @&!&(16 )64( $*/?% ! $(, >$()6 ' >%4('%/% )64 +*4(?%" %F% ! +*&(167 &*+58*, @(#&%1#$'(8 /($(&(;(, %#4! E$($ +*&(167 &*+'!'*%$#,, >%4('%/ @&%1"*+"*>*%$#, 14, !%85 (", # (1"(. #$(&("6, )%#/("%>"( 8"(;( '6!;&6'*%$ @( #&*'"%"!G # ?!'($"68!, "( +*$( %85 @&!:(1!$#, 8!&!$<#, $*/?% # "%51()#$'*8!, @&(!#:(1,F!8! ($$(;(, >$( (" $*/ ;(&1( 1%&?!$ ;(4('5 '67% #'(!: #$*&6: $('*&!F%.» (166, #. 441). «B%&'6. >%4('%/, – 5$'%&?1*4 M*"$, – 58%4 1-!(-8 ! D!5'-8; (" 8(; ;('(&!$<.., (" 58%4 $*/?% &*+;('*&!'*$<, $( %#$< #',+"( '6&*?*$< @(",$!,.., *, #4%1('*$%4<"(, 86#4!$<. X 1(@5#/*G $*/?%, >$( (" 5?% @&!()&%4 "*'6/!, /($(&6% #*8 1(4?%" '6&*)*$6'*$<…» (168, #. 45). C /("2% XVIII – "*>*4% XIX ''. &*##8*$&!'*%8*, !1%, '(74* 5?% ' !"(% – %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(% – &5#4(. R( ! +1%#< ("* !8%4* #"*>*4* @&%!85F%#$'%""( ;!@($%$!>%#/!. :*&*/$%&. H E$( )64( "%!+)%?"( ' #!45 1%.#$'!, ()F%. +*/("(8%&"(#$! 1'!?%"!, @(+"*"!,, +*/("(8%&"(#$!, ( /($(&(., @&!8%"!$%4<"( / %#$%#$'%""68 "*5/*8, L";%4<# @!#*4: «0(&8(. &*+'!$!, %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, @(#/(4*4% XIX ''. %#$%#$'(+"*"!% ' %;( )!(4(;!>%#/(8 ($'%$'4%"!!, /*#*GF%8#, @&(!#:(?1%"!, >%4('%/*, #5F"(#$! #(+"*"!,, $(4$( %;( 86#4!$%4<"(#$< ' +"*>!$%4<"(. 8%&% (@&%1%4,4*#< E$(. "%1*'"%. "%&*+1%4<"(#$"(8 ()I,#"%"!! '(+"!/"('%"!, >%4('%/* ! %;( #(+"*"!, @&!"2!@(', #:(1"6: # $%8!,
305
/($(&6% &*"%% )64! &%*4!+('*"6 ' 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! XVIII '%/*. H $*/(% #:(1#$'( @&(,'!4(#< ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!! &*##8*$&!'*%8(;( @%&!(1*, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' "*5>"(8 $'(&>%#$'% +"*8%"!$(;( A&*"25+#/(;( %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4, ! 86#4!$%4, D*8*&/*, «($2* )!(4(;!!» '( 8"%"!! 5>%"6: (#8. "*@&., 267, #. 196). W;( "%@&%:(1,F%. +*#45;(. @%&%1 "*5/(. ,'!4(#<, @&%?1% '#%;( $(, >$( (" '( 8"(;(8 @&%1'(#:!$!4 5?% ' %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(. #A%&% 1(#$!?%"!, K*&'!"* ! %;( @(#4%1('*$%4%., ' $(8 >!#4% ! ' &%7%"!! @&()4%86 '(+"!/"('%"!, >%4('%/*. K*&'!" ' #',+! # E$!8 @!#*4: « 6#4<, >$( >%4('%/ "*&*'"% # 1&5;!8! '!1*8! ,'4,%$#, @($(8/(8 /*/(.-4!)( 1&%'"%. "!+7%. A(&86, '('#% "% "('*. D*8*&/ 8"(;( '&%8%"! $(85 "*+*1 @&!7%4 / $*/(85 +*/4G>%"!G» (142, #. 134). =%//%4< #>!$*4, >$( «(#()%""(. +*#45;(. D*8*&/* ,'4,%$#, @(@6$/* %;( !+4(?!$< &*+'!$!% 0*7!9*0*16!#! $!5% !+ "!+7!:, @&%?1% '#%;( ()%+<,"(@(1()"6: 84%/(@!$*GF!:» (89, #. 87). H 1%.#$'!$%4<"(, ' #'(%. +"*8%"!$(. «0!4(#(A!! +((4(;!!» (1808) D*8*&/ #A(&854!&('*4 5?% "* %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(. (#"('% !1%!, /($(&6% +* @(4'%/* 1( "%;( '61'!"54! %;( #(($%>%#$'%""!/!, A!4(#(A68*$%&!*4!#$6 XVIII '%/* ! >%&%+ @(4'%/* @(#4% "%;( ()(#"('*4! 0(;$, =%//%4<, =%/#4!, K*&'!" ! 1&5;!% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! XIX '%/*. J*/, ' >*#$"(#$!, D*8*&/, @&!+"*' A*/$ @&(!#:(?1%"!, >%4('%/* ($ >%4('%/(()&*+"(. ()%+<,"6, @(1>%&/"54 @&! E$(8 &(4< @%&%:(1* @(#4%1"%. / 2$(:!D!>5*"'4. B( %;( 8"%"!G, (#()*, @(&(1* 0*-9*$!$;6'D, – «'%&"%% '#%;(, #('%&7%""%.7*, !+ "!: – ($'6/4* ' #!45 $%: !4! 1&5;!: '"%7"!: 5#4('!. !4! @( /*/(.-"!)51< !"(. @&!>!"% 4*+*$< @( 1%&%'<,8 ! 2%@4,$<#, +* '%$'! +*1"!8! /("%>"(#$,8! "*&,15 # @%&%1"!8!» (191, #. 272). B(#/(4%"!% 2%4(;( &,1* @(/(4%"!. @(4<+('*$<#, +*1"!8! /("%>"(#$,8! !#/4G>!$%4<"( 14, :(1<)6, "% 5@($&%)4,, "* E$( @%&%1"!:», $(, ' /("2% /("2(', E$! >%$'%&(&5/!% "%!+)%?"( @&%'&*$!4!#< ' 59;$;6'D ($*8 ?%, #. 272-273). B%&%:(1 / @&,8(:(?1%"!G, !+8%"!' @&(#$&*"#$'%""(% @(4(?%"!% A(&8!&5GF!:#, 4G1%., &*#7!&!4 !: /&5;(+(&, @(+'(4!4 !8 «'!1%$< '1*4< ! '7!&<» ($*8 ?%, #. 273). =%//%4<, /(88%"$!&5, $*/(;( &(1* '6#/*+6'*"!, D*8*&/*, #@&*'%14!'( @(1>%&/"54, >$( «@&,8*, @(:(1/* '6+'*4*, @&%?1% '#%;(, )(4%% #'()(1"6. '+(& "* (/&5?*GF!% @&%18%$6 ! $%8 +"*>!$%4<"( #(1%.#$'('*4* 5#@%:*8 15:('"(;( &*+'!$!,» (89, #. 87). P@(#()"(#$< 1%&?*$<#, ! :(1!$< ' '6@&,84%""(8 @(4(?%"!! +"*>!$%4<"( &*#7!&!4* 1!*@*+(", !+8%"!4* :*&*/$%& 1%.#$'!. &*##8*$&!'*%8(. @(&(16 >%4('%/(()&*+"6: ()%+<,", 5'%4!>!4* %% #!46, '#4%1#$'!% >%;( ("* #$*4* «;(#@(1#$'5GF%. #&%1! (#$*4<"6:» (#8. 191, #. 273). 3)F%#$'%""6. ()&*+ ?!+"!, "('6% @($&%)"(#$! ! "('6% A(&86 1%,$%4<"(#$! – '#% E$( "% 8(;4( "% ($&*+!$<#, "* @#!:!/% >%4('%/(()&*+"6: ()%+<,", "% 8(;4( "% "*'%#$! %% "* @5$< #$*"('4%"!, >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,. H (#()%""( '*?"5G &(4< ' (/(">*$%4<"(8 '61%4%"!! >%4('%/* !+ ?!'($"(;( 8!&* D*8*&/ ($'(1!4 A(&8!&5GF%.#, 07*"!$%,5*78"!= $*0'. «3#()! "*7%. ;(#@(1#$'5GF%. @(&(16, +*",' '#%
306
51()"6% 14, "!: 8%#$* ! @&!()&%$*, '#% "('6% ! "('6% @($&%)"(#$!, @( 8%&% $(;( /*/ ()&*+5%86% !8! ()F%#$'* #$*"('!4!#< '#% 8"(;(>!#4%""%%, 1(4?"6 )64! "*&,15 # E$!8 5'%4!>!$< $*/?% #'(! @&%1#$*'4%"!,, !, #4%1('*$%4<"(, '(+68%$< @($&%)"(#$< ' @%&%1*>% !: 1&5;!8 – #%)% @(1()"68. 3$#G1* "%():(1!8(#$< 5'%4!>!$< ! &*+"(()&*+!$< ' 1(#$*$(>"(. 8%&% #*86% ,"%6', @&%1"*+"*>%""6% 14, @%&%1*>! 86#4%.» ($*8 ?%, #. 277). L$( @(#4%1"%% ()#$(,$%4<#$'( ! @&!'%4(, ' /("2% /("2(', / '(+"!/"('%"!G >4%"(&*+1%4<"(. &%>!, ,+6/*. 0(&8!&5GF!%#, 4G1!, «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– @&(!#:(?1%"!% 51!'!$%4<"(. #@(#()"(#$! $*0' 5 E$(. (#()%""(. &*#6» ($*8 ?%, #. 278), $( %#$< 5 @&%14G1%.. J*/!8 ()&*+(8, @&(2%## A(&8!&('*"!, >4%"(&*+1%4<"(. &%>! ' %% "%&*+&6'"(. #',+! # A(&8!&5GF!8#, #(+"*"!%8 )64 ()5#4('4%", ' @&%1#$*'4%"!! D*8*&/*, >!#$( 8*$%&!*4<"68!, @&!&(1"68! A*/$(&*8!, )%+ 5>*#$!, '6#7%. #!46, 1'!?!86. (1"!8! 4!7< %#$%#$'%""68! @($&%)"(#$,8!. «C#% #(+1*"( (1"!8! @($&%)"(#$,8!: ("! @(&(1!4! 5#!4!,; (&;*"6 ?%, @&%1"*+"*>%""6% 14, &*#>4%"%"!, +'5/(', 8(;4! &*+'!$<#, @5$%8 @&!'6>"(;( 5@($&%)4%"!, !:» ($*8 ?%). B&!:(1!$#,, (1"*/(, ($8%$!$<, >$( @(!#$!"% &%'(4G2!(""6% !1%! D*8*&/*, ' $(8 >!#4% ! ($"(#,F!%#, / '(+"!/"('%"!G >%4('%/*, "% '(74! ' ()F%% &5#4( &*+'!$!, %#$%#$'(+"*"!, ' "*>*4% XIX '%/*, (#$*4!#< ' #$(&("%, "% "*.1, @&!+"*"!, ' #&%1% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., "% (/*+*', #4%1('*$%4<"(, "!/*/(;( '4!,"!, "* %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(% @(+"*"!% $(;( '&%8%"!. H.H. %>"!/(' @!#*4 ' #',+! # E$!8, >$( $%(&!, D*8*&/*, – «$%(&!,, ' '6#7%. #$%@%"! +*8%>*$%4<"*,, "( "% !8%'7*, ' #'(% '&%8, @(>$! "!/*/(;( '4!,"!,» (268, #. 435). O1%4(8 '#%. #!#$%86 '+;4,1(' D*8*&/*, (#"('*""6: "* !1%% !+8%">!'(#$! '!1(', #$*4(, ' /("2% /("2(', @(4"(% +*)'%"!%. «L$* #8%4*, @(@6$/*, – @!#*4 ( $%(&!! D*8*&/* =%//%4<, – (/*+*4*#< 14, $(;( '&%8%"! #4!7/(8 @&%?1%'&%8%""(. ! ' #&%1% #%&<%+"6: @&%1#$*'!$%4%. %#$%#$'(+"*"!, )64* #/(&( +*)6$*» (93, #. 4). H1%! D*8*&/* (@%&%1!4! #'(% '&%8,. W#$%#$'%""("*5>"(% 8674%"!% $(;1* %F% "% )64( ;($('( / !: '(#@&!,$!G ! 1(4?"(. (2%"/%, "% #(+&%4( 14, E$(;(. W85 )(4<7% #(($'%$#$'('*4! '+;4,16 MG'<%, +*F!F*'7%;( 1(;85 @(#$(,"#$'* '!1('. «C%4!/!. *'$(&!$%$ MG'<% ($",4 '#,/(% +"*>%"!% 5
307
1*4%/!: ;!@($%+ D*8*&/*, "% @(4<+('*'7!:#, @&!+"*"!%8 #('&%8%""!/('» ($*8 ?%, #. 13). B&!>!"5 E$(;( #4%15%$ !#/*$< "% $(4"6% @&()4%86 "* @5$! A!4(#(A#/!: 58(+*/4G>%"!., @&%!85F%#$'%""( 1%15/$!'"6:, @&!74( ' @&($!'(&%>!% # ;(#@(1#$'('*'7!8 ' $( '&%8, !"15/$!'"68 8%$(1(8 !##4%1('*"!,. J*/('(, "*@&!8%&, 8"%"!% =%//%4,, #>!$*'7%;(, >$( D*8*&/, (#"('6'*,#< "* !8%GF%8#, ' $( '&%8, %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(8 8*$%&!*4%, @6$*4#, &*+&%7!$< (#"('"(. '(@&(# E'(4G2!(""(;( 5>%"!, – '(@&(# ( @&(!#:(?1%"!! '!1(' «>!#$( 5*5;6-'9".: @5$%8, @5$%8 #!"$%+* ! 58(+*/4G>%"!.» ($*8 ?%, #. 14). %>"!/(' $*/?% #>!$*4, >$( $%(&!! D*8*&/* «(>%"< 8"(;( @('&%1!4* >!#$( 1%15/$!'"*, 8%$(1* %% @(#$&(%"!,» (268, #. 43). H +1%#< 8(?"( '61%4!$< @&($!'(@(4(?%"!% MG'<% ! D*8*&/*, #(#4*'7!#< "* 8"%"!% $(;( ?% %>"!/('*, #>!$*'7%;(, >$( MG'<% «/*/ 5>%"6. :*&*/$%& ,'4,%$#, @(4"%.7!8 /("$&*#$(8 D*8*&/* ! L.\. P%"$-H4%&*. C $( '&%8, /*/ @(#4%1"!% ,'4,G$ #!45 1%15/$!'"(;( 8674%"!,, #8%4( #$&(,$ $%(&!! @&! @(8(F! >!#$( 4(;!>%#/!: @&!]8(' ! #&*+5 )%&5$#, +* $&51"%.7!% @&()4%86 %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, MG'<% ():(1!$ @(#4%1"!%, "( #(#&%1($*>!'*%$ '#% 5#!4!, "* ($/&6$!! "('6: @5$%., "* '(+8(?"(#$! '#%#$(&(""%;( A*/$!>%#/(;( !##4%1('*"!,» ($*8 ?%, #. 48-49). R( %#4! 14, 5>%"6: $!@* MG'<% A*/$!>%#/(;( 8*$%&!*4* '#%;1* 1(#$*$(>"( 14, "%1*4<"!: '6'(1(', $( 14, #8%46: !1%. D*8*&/* ,'"( "%1(#$*'*4( @(1/&%@4,GF!: !: E8@!&!>%#/!: 1*""6:, >$( $*/?% @(8%7*4( !: @&!+"*"!G #('&%8%""!/*8!. =%//%4< @!#*4 ( D*8*&/%, >$( «/*/ 1*4<"('!1"6. "*$5&A!4(#(A, #$*&*,#< &*#@&(#$&*"!$< #'(G $%(&!G &*+'!$!, "* '#G @&!&(15, (" '#% ?% "% 8(; #'(! '#%()I%84GF!% ;!@($%+6 @(1/&%@!$< $%8! "%1(#$*$(>"68! E8@!&!>%#/!8! 1*""68!, /($(&6% 1*'*4 $(;1*7"!. 5+/!. /&5; "*)4G1%"!,, ! @(E$(85 &*#$%&,4#, ' )%#@(>'%""6: 58(+*/4G>%"!,:, "% @&!()&%$7! "!/*/(;( @&!+"*"!,»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
308
>%4('%/*, #$*"('4%"!, >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,. R( /*/ )6 $( "! )64(, !1%! )64! '6#/*+*"6, ! ("!, ' /("2% /("2(', #$*4! "%($I%84%868 1(#$(,"!%8 !#$(&!! %#$%#$'(+"*"!, /*/ (1"* !+ #*86: +*8%>*$%4<"6: %% #$&*"!2. -%$&(#@%/$!'"6. '+;4,1 "* 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(% &%7%"!% @&()4%86 '(+"!/"('%"!, >%4('%/* ! >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,, &%7%"!%, (#5F%#$'4%""(% ' A!4(#(A!! ! "*$5&(A!4(#(A!! XVIII – "*>*4* XIX ''., @(+'(4,%$ #1%4*$< %F% (1!" '6'(1 – ( $(8, >$( ' E$(. ()4*#$! &(4< %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: 1(#$!?%"!. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* #(#$(!$ "% #$(4$( )4*;(1*&, !8 '61'!"5$6% &*"%% A!4(#(A#/!% ! "*$5&A!4(#(A#/!% ;!@($%+6 )64! @(#$*'4%"6 "* $'%&15G @(>'5 A*/$(' ! '#4%1#$'!% E$(;( ()&%4! #$*$5# "*5>"6: $%(&!.. 3$#G1* ! ()F"(#$< (#"('"(;( #(1%&?*"!, '(++&%"!. 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* ! A!4(#(A('8*$%&!*4!#$(' XVIII '%/*. P4%15%$ @&! E$(8 @(1>%&/"5$<, >$( +1%#<, /*/ ! @( 8"(;!8 1&5;!8 '(@&(#*8, ()"*&5?!'*%$#, "% @&(#$( '"%7"%% #:(1#$'(, "% #45>*."(% #('@*1%"!%, * (@&%1%4%""*, '"5$&%"",,, 8(?"( #/*+*$< – &(1#$'%""*, #',+< 8%?15 A!4(#(A#/!8 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 XVIII '%/* ! %#$%#$'%""(!#$(&!>%#/!8 8*$%&!*4!+8(8 '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/*. H: ()F*, @(&(?1*GF*, (#"('* – @&!&(1*, @("!8*%8*, /*/ %1!"#$'%""(% #5)#$*"2!*4<"(% "*>*4(. C ()(!: #45>*,: @&!&(1* @&%1#$*'*4* @%&%1 @(+"*GF!8 %% #5)I%/$(8 ' #'(!: ()I%/$!'"( #5F%#$'5GF!:, >5'#$'%""( '(#@&!"!8*%86: A(&8*:, ' #'(%. +&!8(. ! @($(85 )%+5#4('"(. 8*$%&!*4<"(#$!, !8%GF%. (#"('*"!% ' #%)% #*8(., #4%1('*$%4<"(, !#/4G>*GF%. /*/!% )6 $( "! )64( "%8*$%&!*4<"6% ! '"%8*$%&!*4<"6% #!46. L$( ()5#4('4!'*4( ' /("%>"(8 #>%$% – ! ' A!4(#(A!!, ! ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!! – 8*$%&!*4!#$!>"(#$< '(++&%"!. "* @&!&(15 ' %% 2%4(8 ! "* #(#$*'4,GF!% %% ,'4%"!, ! @&(2%##6. V1%#< 58%#$"( '#@(8"!$< #4('* L";%4<#* ( $(8, >$( «8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(% 8!&('(++&%"!% (+"*>*%$ @&(#$( @("!8*"!% @&!&(16 $*/(., /*/('* ("* %#$<, )%+ '#,/!: @(#$(&(""!: @&!)*'4%"!.» (406, #. 513). 3#$*%$#, 1()*'!$<, >$( $*/(% 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(% @("!8*"!% – «)%+ '#,/!: @(#$(&(""!: @&!)*'4%"!.» – ! 5 A!4(#(A('–8*$%&!*4!#$(' XVIII '%/* !, $%8 )(4%%, 5 %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX '%/* )64( @("!8*"!%8 !8%""( @&!&(16 ! $(4%#/(;( @("!8*"!,. L$( ! "% @(+'(4,4( 1*$< #5F"(#$"(% ()I,#"%"!% >%4('%/* ! >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!, ! ' %;( !*4( (>%"< '*?"6% – #(2!(4(;!>%#/!% – *#@%/$6 &%7%"!, @&()4%86 %;( '(+"!/"('%"!,. J*/(% &%7%"!% #$*4( '(+8(?"68 "* !"(. "*5>"(. (#"('%. C $( '&%8, /*/ ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!! '( '$(&(. @(4('!"% XIX '%/* @&()!'*4*#< "* (#"('% #$!:!."(;( E'(4G2!("!+8* 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/*, @( #5$! /("2%@2!, >%4('%/* ! %;( @&(!#:(?1%"!,, /("2%@2!,, (/(">*$%4<"( (@&%1%4!'7*,#, ' 1*&'!"!+8%, ' A!4(#(A!! "* #(+"*$%4<"( 1!*4%/$!>%#/(. (#"('% +&%4( @(#4%1('*$%4<"( 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(% &%7%"!% @&()4%86 #$*"('4%"!,
309
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§ 8. $82H3DB; ID325D<; 5 A=3242A== B;8<4=CB;: ID325D< = 2HLD4F52 C A!4(#(A!! 8*&/#!+8*, ' ($4!>!% ($ 1&5;!: &*+"('!1"(#$%. 8*$%&!*4!+8*, 8*$%&!*4<"(#$< #$*4* #5)#$*"2!*4<"(. :*&*/$%&!#$!/(. "% $(4$( @&!8%"!8( / @&!&(1%, ($8%>*4 L";%4<#, «@&!8%"!8( /( '#%8 ($&*#4,8 !#$(&!! ()F%#$'*» (407, #. 305). R( E$* ()F*, @&!8%"!8(#$< (1"!: ! $%: ?% 1!*4%/$!/(8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!: @&!"2!@(' / @&!&(1% ! ()F%#$'5 "% (+"*>*%$, (1"*/(, !: @(4"(;( ($(?%#$'4%"!,, /*/, "*@&!8%&, 5 =(4<)*:*. L";%4<# >%$/( ()(+"*>!4 &*+4!>!% @&!&(1"(;( ! ()F%#$'%""(;(, !+)&*' ' /*>%#$'% 1%8*&/*2!(""(. 4!"!! 1!,"%"'*. H#$(&!, &*+'!$!, ()F%#$'*, @( %;( 8"%"!G, «' (1"(8 @5"/$% #5F%#$'%""( ($4!>*%$#, ($ !#$(&!! &*+'!$!, @&!&(16. C @&!&(1%… 1%.#$'5G$ (1"* "* 1&5;5G 4!7< #4%@6%, <*11!,"%-*78".* #!46, '( '+*!8(1%.#$'!! /($(&6: ! @&(,'4,G$#, ()F!% +*/("6. V1%#< "!;1% "%$ 1!,"%-*78"!=, ?%4*%8(. 2%4!… R*()(&($, ' !#$(&!! ()F%#$'* 1%.#$'5G$ 4G1!, (1*&%""6% #(+"*"!%8, @(#$5@*GF!% ()158*""( !4! @(1 '4!,"!%8 #$&*#$!, #$&%8,F!%#, / (@&%1%4%""68 2%4,8. V1%#< "!>$( "% 1%4*%$#, )%+ 1!,"%-*78"!#! "*8%&%"!,, )%+ ?%4*%8(. 2%4!» ($*8 ?%, #. 305-306, /5&#!' 8(.. – C.3.). L$* «(1*&%""(#$<»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– @&(15/$ @&!&(16, /*/ 5$'%&?1*4! =(4<)*: ! 1&5;!% A!4(#(A6–8*$%&!*4!#$6 XVIII '%/*, – E$( @&!+"*%$#, ! ' A!4(#(A!! 8*&/#!+8*. J*/, @( 8"%"!G L";%4<#*, %#4! «@(#$*'!$< '(@&(#, >$( ?% $*/(% 8674%"!% ! #(+"*"!%, ($/51* ("! )%&5$#,, $( 86 5'!1!8, >$( ("! – @&(15/$6 >%4('%>%#/(;( 8(+;*, ! >$( #*8 >%4('%/ – @&(15/$ @&!&(16, &*+'!'7!.#, ' (@&%1%4%""(. #&%1% ! '8%#$% # "%.. P*8( #()(.
310
&*+58%%$#,, ' #!45 E$(;(, >$( @&(15/$6 >%4('%>%#/(;( 8(+;*, ,'4,GF!%#,, ' /("%>"(8 #>%$%, $(?% @&(15/$*8! @&!&(16, "% @&($!'(&%>*$ (#$*4<"(. #',+! @&!&(16, * #(($'%$#$'5G$ %.» (405, #. 34-35). C.H. D%"!" ' #',+! # @(+"*"!%8 >%4('%/(8 @&!&(16 &*##8*$&!'*4 8(+; >%4('%/* «/*/ '6#7!. @&(15/$ $(. ?% @&!&(16» (205, #. 164). R( $*/(% &*##8($&%"!% >%4('%/* ' /*>%#$'% @&(15/$* @&!&(16 #(>%$*%$#, ' 8*&/#!#$#/(. A!4(#(A!! # @&!+"*"!%8 $(;(, >$( >%4('%/ – "% $(4%4('%/* – E$( @&%?1% '#%;( @&(2%## #$*"('4%"!, 1!+'%78"!1-'. H @(E$(85 ' "%., ' #(2!*4<"(#$!, ! "5?"( ' @%&'5G (>%&%1< !#/*$< !#$(/! #(+"*"!,, #*85 %;( #5$<. 3)F%% A!4(#(A#/(% &%7%"!% @&()4%86 #$*"('4%"!, ! &*+'!$!, >%4('%/* ! >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!, 1*"( */#(8 ! L";%4<#(8 %F% ' «R%8%2/(. !1%(4(;!!», "*1 /($(&(. ("! &*)($*4! ' 1845-46 ;;., $( %#$< +* 20-25 4%$ 1( $(;(, /*/ / "*+'*""(. @&()4%8% ()&*$!4!#< K*&'!", =%//%4< ! 1&5;!% %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4!. C*?"6% @(4(?%"!,, ($"(#,F!%#, / "%., E$(. @&()4%8%, #(1%&?*$#, ! ' 1&5;!: @&(!+'%1%"!,: (#"('(@(4(?"!/(' 8*&/#!+8*, ' >*#$"(#$!, ' «M*@!$*4%», @%&'6. $(8 /($(&(;( *&/# @!#*4 ' $% ?% ;(16, >$( ! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4! – #'(! @%&'6% &*)($6 ( @&(!#:(?1%"!! >%4('%/*. C61%4%"!% >%4('%/* !+ ?!'($"(;( 8!&* *&/# ! L";%4<# @(#$*'!4! ' @&,85G #',+< # %;( @&(!+'(1#$'%""(., $&51('(. 1%,$%4<"(#$%"!% "%():(1!86: #&%1#$' / ?!+"!. B&! E$(8 +* !#:(1"6. 8(8%"$ ("! '+,4! >!#$( )!(4(;!>%#/!. A*/$(& –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«DG1%. 8(?"( ($4!>*$< ($ ?!'($"6: @( #(+"*"!G, @( &%4!;!! – '(()F% @( >%85 5;(1"(. P*8! ("! "*>!"*G$ ($4!>*$< #%), ($ ?!'($"6:, /*/ $(4!"*G$ 2$!',9!5'-8 "%():(1!86% !8 #&%1#$'* / ?!+"!, – 7*;, /($(&6. ()5#4('4%" !: $%4%#"(. (&;*"!+*2!%.. B&(!+'(1, "%():(1!86% !8 #&%1#$'* / ?!+"!, 4G1! /(#'%""68 ()&*+(8 @&(!+'(1,$ ! #*8(% #'(G 8*$%&!*4<"5G ?!+"<» (243, #. 19). L$( @&(!+'(1#$'( "%():(1!86: #&%1#$' / ?!+"!, (@&%1%4,%8(% @%&'("*>*4<"( >!#$( )!(4(;!>%#/!8! #$!854*8! ! -!786! )!(4(;!>%#/!8! #$!854*8! ! (#5F%#$'4,4(#< '"*>*4% >!#$( @(– ?!'($"(85, ("( "*>!"*4(#<, #4%1('*$%4<"(, # «@%&'6: ?!'($"(()&*+"6: !"#$!"/$!'"6: A(&8 $&51*». B&!8%"!$%4<"( / >%4('%>%#/(85 ()F%#$'5 *&/# ($8%>*4 $*/?% «$( %;( 5:(1,F%% ' ;45)< @%&'()6$"6: '&%8%"
311
#(#$(,"!%, /(;1* >%4('%>%#/!. $&51 %F% "% (#'()(1!4#, ($ #'(%. @&!8!$!'"(., !"#$!"/$!'"(. A(&86» (235, #. 189). R( ! ' E$!: !"#$!"/$!'"6: %F%, ?!'($"(()&*+"6: A(&8*: $&51* )64( 5?% $(, >$( @&!#5F% %85 "* '#%: 5&('",: #('%&7%"#$'* – ',:*"*"'* @&!&(16 @(#&%1#$'(8 #@%2!*4<"6: (&51!.. H ("( "% (#$*%$#, )%+5>*#$"68 / !+8%",GF%85 %% #5)I%/$5 $&51*, '6+6'*%$ ' "%8 ($'%$"6% !+8%"%"!, – $%8 )(4<7!%, >%8 (#"('*$%4<"%% $&51('*, 1%,$%4<"(#$<. B&!8%"!$%4<"( / >%4('%/5 *&/# ($8%$!4, >$( ' @&(2%##% $&51* «'%F%#$'5 @&!&(16 (" #*8 @&($!'(#$(!$ /*/ #!4* @&!&(16. K4, $(;( >$()6 @&!#'(!$< '%F%#$'( @&!&(16 ' A(&8%, @&!;(1"(. 14, %;( #()#$'%""(. ?!+"!, (" @&!'(1!$ ' 1'!?%"!% @&!"*14%?*F!% %;( $%45 %#$%#$'%""6% #!46: &5/! ! "(;!, ;(4('5 ! @*4<26. C(+1%.#$'5, @(#&%1#$'(8 E$(;( 1'!?%"!, "* '"%7"GG @&!&(15 ! !+8%",, %%, (" ' $( ?% '&%8, !+8%",%$ #'(G #()#$'%""5G @&!&(15» ($*8 ?%, #. 188). L$( ' @(4"(. 8%&% @&(,'!4(#< ! "* "*>*4<"6: E$*@*: &*+'!$!, $&51('(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! – ' @%&!(1 #$*"('4%"!, >%4('%/*. H+8%"%"!% @&!&(16 @(#&%1#$'(8 @%&'6: !"#$!"/$!'"6:, ?!'($"(()&*+"6: A(&8 $&51* (@&%1%4%""68 ()&*+(8 '4!,4( ! "* #5)I%/$* E$(;( $&51*, ! "* #*8 $&51, '6'(1!4( %;( @(#$%@%""( +* @&%1%46 >!#$( )!(4(;!>%#/(;( "*@(4"%"!,, @(&(?1*4( /*>%#$'%""( "('6., "%#'(.#$'%""6. ?!'($"68 A*/$(& – +*7*2!7%#%"'*, '#% )(4<75G (#86#4%""(#$<. H"*>% ;('(&,, !+8%"%"!% @&!&(16 @(#&%1#$'(8 $&51* ()5#4('4!'*4( /*>%#$'%""6% !+8%"%"!, ! ' @#!:!/% #5)I%/$* $&51*. M("%>"68 &%+54<$*$(8 E$!: !+8%"%"!. ! ,'!4(#< '(+"!/"('%"!% >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,. *&/# @(1>%&/!'*4 @&! E$(8 #4!$"(#$<, "%&*+1%4<"(#$< "*>*4<"6: #(#$(,"!. ! @&(,'4%"!. #(+"*"!, # 8*$%&!*4<"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$*4<"( "%@(#&%1#$'%""( '@4%$%"( ' 8*$%&!*4<"5G 1%,$%4<"(#$< ! ' 8*$%&!*4<"(% ()F%"!% 4G1%., ' ,+6/ &%*4<"(. ?!+"!. 3)&*+('*"!% @&%1#$*'4%"!., 8674%"!%, 15:('"(% ()F%"!% 4G1%. ,'4,%$#, +1%#< %F% "%@(#&%1#$'%""68 @(&(?1%"!%8 8*$%&!*4<"(;( ($"(7%"!, 4G1%.»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– !+"*>*4<"( @&!#5F%%
312
>%4('%/5 #'(.#$'(, /(&%",F%%#, ' #*8(. %;( @&!&(1%. «N%4('%/, – @!#*4 *&/#, – @( #*8(. #'(%. @&!&(1% %#$< ?!'($"(%… ()F%#$'%""(%» (255, #. 338). R* "*>*4<"6: E$*@*: #$*"('4%"!, >%4('%/* E$($ A*/$(& – ()F%#$'%""6. ()&*+ ?!+"!, – '6#$5@*'7!. ' #'(%8 "*!)(4%% @&!8!$!'"(8 – #$*1"(8 – @&(,'4%"!!, )64 "*#$(4$( !#/4G>*4 '(+8(?"(#$< (#(+"*"!, #()#$'%""(. !"1!'!15*4<"(#$! /*?168 /("/&%$"68 >4%"(8 #(()F%#$'*. D!7< # @(#$%@%""68 @%&%:(1(8 ($ #$*1"(#$! / )(4%% &*+'!$68 A(&8*8 ()F%#$'%""(#$! ' &*8/*: @(#4%1"%. #$*4( '(+8(?"68 ! !"1!'!15*4<"(% ()(#()4%"!%, '6>4%"%"!% X !+ ^, >$( ! (+"*>*4( (/(">*$%4<"(% #A(&8!&('*"!% #(+"*"!,. «N%4('%/ ()(#()4,%$#, /*/ !"1!'!1, – @!#*4 M. *&/#, – 4!7< ' &%+54<$*$% !#$(&!>%#/(;( @&(2%##*. B%&'("*>*4<"( (" '6#$5@*%$ /*/ $!5!9!* 1;?*1-9!, 27*:*""!* 1;?*1-9!, 1-%5"!* >'9!-"!*» (239, #. 486). Q515>! #5F%#$'(8 ()F%#$'%""68, >%4('%/ "% 8(?%$ #5F%#$'('*$<, /*/ >%4('%/, '"% ($"(7%"!. # 1&5;!8! 4G1<8!. C($ @(>%85 E$! ($"(7%"!, ,'4,G$#, (#"('"68 (@&%1%4!$%4%8 #*8(. %;( #5$!. R( %#4! #5F"(#$< >%4('%/* #(#$*'4,%$ %1!"%"!% ()F%#$'%""6: ($"(7%"!., $( >%4('%>%#/(% #(+"*"!% # #*8(;( "*>*4* %#$< "%@(#&%1#$'%""(% @(&(?1%"!% E$!: 8*$%&!*4<"6: ()F%#$'%""6: ($"(7%"!., !: (#(+"*"!%, !: $&*"#A(&8*2!, ' !1%*4<"(% ' ;(4('% >%4('%/*. «P(+"*"!% "!/(;1* "% 8(?%$ )6$< >%8-4!)( !"68, /*/ (#(+"*""68 )6$!%8, * )6$!% 4G1%. %#$< &%*4<"6. @&(2%## !: ?!+"!» (243, #. 25), *, #4%1('*$%4<"(, @&(2%## &*+'%&$6'*"!, !: 8*$%&!*4<"6: ($"(7%"!.. L$($ &%*4<"6. @&(2%## ?!+"! ' %;( @%&'("*>*4<"6:, "*!)(4%% @&!8!$!'"6: #(#$(,"!,: ()5#4('!4 ! @%&'6%, @&!8!$!'"6% A(&86 #(+"*"!,, A(&86, #"*>*4* %F% 8*4( >%8 ($4!>*GF!%#, ($ @#!:!/! ?!'($"6:. «P(+"*"!%, /("%>"(, %#$< '"*>*4% (#(+"*"!% <7'>%=3*= >5'#$'%""( '(#@&!"!8*%8(. #&%16 ! (#(+"*"!% (;&*"!>%""(. #',+! # 1&5;!8! 4!2*8! ! '%F*8!, "*:(1,F!8!#, '"% "*>!"*GF%;( #(+"*'*$< #%), !"1!'!1*; ' $( ?% '&%8, ("( – (#(+"*"!% @&!&(16, /($(&*, @%&'("*>*4<"( @&($!'(#$(!$ 4G1,8 /*/ #('%&7%""( >5?1*,, '#%8(;5F*, ! "%@&!#$5@"*, #!4*, / /($(&(. 4G1! ($"(#,$#, #('%&7%""( @(–?!'($"(85 ! '4*#$! /($(&(. ("! @(1>!",G$#, /*/ #/($; #4%1('*$%4<"(, E$( – >!#$( ?!'($"(% (#(+"*"!% @&!&(16» ($*8 ?%, #. 29). J*/(. ?% @&!8!$!'"(#$*4(8 (#(+"*"!, $(;(, >$( >%4('%/ '(()F% ?!'%$ ' ()F%#$'%. R*>*4( E$( "(#!$ #$(4< ?% ?!'($"6. :*&*/$%&, /*/ ! #*8* ()F%#$'%""*, ?!+"< "* E$(. #$5@%"!; E$( – >!#$( #$*1"(% #(+"*"!%, ! >%4('%/ ($4!>*%$#, +1%#< ($ )*&*"* 4!7< $%8, >$( #(+"*"!% +*8%",%$ %85 !"#$!"/$, !4! ?%, – >$( %;( !"#$!"/$ (#(+"*"» ($*8 ?%, #. 30).
313
B( 8%&% &*+'!$!, @&(!+'(1#$'%""(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! @%&'6: 4G1%. !: ($"(7%"!, – / @&!&(1% ! 8%?15 #()(. – @(#$%@%""( (#'()(?1*G$#, ($ ?!'($"6: A(&8 !, #(($'%$#$'%""(, @%&%#$*%$ )6$< ?!'($"68 !: (#(+"*"!% "*+'*""6: ($"(7%"!.. C E$(8 ! '6&*+!4(#< &*+'!$!% #(+"*"!,, #$*"('4%"!% %;( '#% )(4%% #('%&7%""6: A(&8. H +1%#<, #4%1('*$%4<"(, ' @(4"(. 8%&% @&(,'4,%$ #%), #(2!*4<"6. A*/$(&. «DG1!, &*+'!'*GF!% #'(% 8*$%&!*4<"(% @&(!+'(1#$'( ! #'(% 8*$%&!*4<"(% ()F%"!%, !+8%",G$ '8%#$% # E$(. #'(%. 1%.#$'!$%4<"(#$%$* E$(;( #(($"(7%"!, &*##8($&%"!% &%*4!. #(+"*"!, '( '#%: ($"(7%"!,: (/*+6'*%$#, "%'(+8(?"68. H ' #*8(8 1%4%, #$*"('4%"!% ! &*+'!$!% >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,, #*8( %;( "%@(#&%1#$'%""(% A5"/2!("!&('*"!% '(+8(?"6 4!7< ' (@&%1%4%""(8 ,+6/('(8 '(@4(F%"!!, ' &%>%'(. (#4('%#"(.) &%*4!+*2!! '#%: %;( #(#$(,"!.. P(+"*"!% '"% ,+6/* 5$&*>!'*%$ #'(% /*>%#$'(, #'(G «#(+"*$%4<"(#$<». X+6/ ! #(+"*"!% "%&*+1%4<"6, ("! "%'(+8(?"6 (1!" )%+ 1&5;(;(. H @($(85 #$*"('4%"!% #(+"*"!, – E$( ' &*'"(. 8%&% ! #$*"('4%"!% ,+6/*. R% (1"( – "* (#"('% 1&5;(;( ! "% (1"( – @(#4% 1&5;(;(, * '8%#$%, (1"( – ' 1&5;(8. «R* «15:%» 1 1%:!#! "%0%7% 4%?!$ @&(/4,$!% – )6$< «($,;(F%""68» 8*$%&!%., /($(&*, '6#$5@*%$ +1%#< ' '!1% 1'!?5F!:#, #4(%' '(+15:*, +'5/(' – #4('(8, ' '!1% ,+6/*. X+6/ -%6 >* 5$*9*", /*/ ! #(+"*"!%» ($*8 ?%, #. 29; /5&#!' 8(.. – C.3.). C ,+6/% "*!)(4%% @(4"( @&(,'4,%$#, #(2!*4<"*, #5F"(#$< #(+"*"!,, %;( (@&%1%4%""(#$< ()F%#$'%""68 ()&*+(8 ?!+"! 4G1%., %;( +*'!#!8(#$< ($ @(#4%1"%;( /*/ ' "%@(#&%1#$'%""(8 A5"/2!("!&('*"!!, $*/ ! ' !+"*>*4<"(8 #$*"('4%"!!. «X+6/ *1-8 @&*/$!>%#/(%, #5F%#$'5GF%% ! 14, 1&5;!: 4G1%. ! 4!7< $%8 #*868 #5F%#$'5GF%% $*/?% ! 14, 8%", #*8(;(, 1%.#$'!$%4<"(% #(+"*"!%, !, @(1()"( #(+"*"!G, ,+6/ '(+"!/*%$ 4!7< !+ @($&%)"(#$!, !+ "*#$(,$%4<"(. "%():(1!8(#$! ()F%"!, # 1&5;!8! 4G1<8!… P(+"*"!%, #4%1('*$%4<"(, # #*8(;( "*>*4* %#$< ()F%#$'%""6. @&(15/$ ! (#$*%$#, !8, @(/* '(()F% #5F%#$'5G$ 4G1!» ($*8 ?%). H$*/, M. *&/# ! 0. L";%4<# ()&*$!4!#< / @&()4%8% #$*"('4%"!, >%4('%/* ! >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!, "% $(4$( (#()%""( '*?"(, –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
314
&*+&*)($*4! – ! $(?% "* 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. (#"('% – *1-*1-9*""!"%;0"!* ;0*"'* ( >%4('%/% ! %;( #(+"*"!!, /*/ A(&8% @#!:!/!, '(+"!/7%. %#$%#$'%""68 @5$%8 ' @&(2%##% E'(4G2!(""(;( &*+'!$!, ?!'($"(;( 8!&*. L$! 1'* 5>%"!, ( #(+"*"!! – A!4(#(A#/(% ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(% – "%/($(&(% '&%8, &*+'!'*4!#< "%+*'!#!8( 1&5; ($ 1&5;*, /*?1(% ' #'(%8 &5#4%, "% #4!'*,#<, "!;1% ! "! ' >%8 "% #(@&!/*#*,#<. W1!"#$'%""*, @(@6$/* #(%1!"%"!, A!4(#(A#/(;( ! %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(1:(1* / '(@&(#5 ( '(+"!/"('%"!! >%4('%/* ! >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!, )64* @&%1@&!",$* L";%4<#(8. H "% #45>*."(. M*/ !+'%#$"(, (1"!8 !+ '*?"%.7!: "*@&*'4%"!. "*5>"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! *&/#* ! L";%4<#* )64( @&!8%"%"!% 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. 1!*4%/$!/! / (#"('"68 #A%&*8 "*5>"(;( @(+"*"!, – / ()F%#$'%""68 "*5/*8, %#$%#$'(+"*"!G, 8*$%8*$!/%. N$( /*#*%$#, %#$%#$'(+"*"!,, * $*/?% 8*$%8*$!/!, $( 14, 5#@%7"(;( @&!8%"%"!, 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. 1!*4%/$!/! / !: &*+4!>"68 ($&*#4,8, /*/ ! '( '#%: 1&5;!: "*5/*:, "%():(1!8( )64( (#"('*$%4<"(% ('4*1%"!% #(($'%$#$'5GF!8 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"68 8*$%&!*4(8, )(4<7% $(;( – #*8(#$(,$%4<"*, !##4%1('*$%4<#/*, 1%,$%4<"(#$< ' #A%&% $(. !4! !"(. "*5/!. *&/#, ' >*#$"(#$!, 8"(;( '"!8*"!, 51%4,4 %#$%#$'%""68 "*5/*8, "( (#()%""( @4(1($'(&"68! )64! %;( +*",$!, 8*$%8*$!/(.. L";%4<# ' @&%1!#4('!! / «M*@!$*45» @!#*4: «B(#4% 1870 ;. #"('* "*#$5@!4* @*5+* (' &*)($% "*1 «M*@!$*4(8». – C.3.), ()5#4('4%""*, ;4*'"68 ()&*+(8 )(4%+"%""68 #(#$(,"!%8 *&/#*. B( ()6/"('%"!G, (" +*@(4",4 E$( '&%8, !+5>%"!%8; *;&("(8!,, *8%&!/*"#/!% ! ' (#()%""(#$! &5##/!% @(+%8%4<"6% ($"(7%"!,, 1%"%?"6. &6"(/ ! )*"/!, "*/("%2 %#$%#$'%""6% "*5/!: ;%(4(;!, ! A!+!(4(;!, ! ' (#()%""(#$! #*8(#$(,$%4<"6% 8*$%8*$!>%#/!% &*)($6 #(#$*'4,G$ #(1%&?*"!% 8"(;(>!#4%""6: $%$&*1%. *&/#*…» (410, #. 8). 3 "*5>"6: !"$%&%#*: #*8(;( L";%4<#* 8(?"( #/*+*$< $( ?% #*8(%, #1%4*', (1"*/(, */2%"$ "* %;( 5;45)4%""6: +*",$!,: %#$%#$'%""68! "*5/*8!, (#()%""( ' @%&!(1 &*)($6 "*1 «K!*4%/$!/(. @&!&(16». 3"!, E$! +*",$!,, @(+'(4!4! L";%4<#5 +*",$< ' %#$%#$'(+"*"!! #'(% (@&%1%4%""(% 8%#$(, #*8(#$(,$%4<"( 86#4,F%;( $%(&%$!/*, @(1()"( $(85, /*/ *&/# ' #'(!: « *$%8*$!>%#/!: &5/(@!#,:» @&%1#$*4 ' /*>%#$'% (&!;!"*4<"(;( 8*$%8*$!/*, 5>%"(;(, @&(4(?!'7%;( ' 8*$%8*$!/% #'(. @5$<. H /*/ ' *&/#%, ' %;( 8*$%8*$!>%#/!: !+6#/*"!,: (&;*"!>%#/! #4!4!#< A!4(#(A– 8%$(1(4(; ! 8*$%8*$!/, $*/ ! ' L";%4<#%, ' %;( %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6: !##4%1('*"!,: #(%1!"!4!#< A!4(#(A ! %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4<–$%(&%$!/. 0!4(#(A#/!% '(++&%"!, ' 1*""(8 #45>*% '6#$5@*4! ' /*>%#$'% 8%$(1(4(;!>%#/(. (#"('6 #@%2!*4<"6: !+6#/*"!.. L$( @&(,'!4(#<, ' >*#$"(#$!, ! ' &%7%"!! @&()4%86 '(+"!/"('%"!, >%4('%/* ! >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,, /(;1* / "%., $%@%&< 5?% # 5>%$(8 %% %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(. #@%2!A!/!, ()&*$!4#, L";%4<#. 3#()%""( @(/*+*$%4<"* ' E$(8 ($"(7%"!! %;( !+'%#$"*, #$*$<, «-(4< $&51* ' @&(2%##% @&%'&*F%"!, ()%+<,"6 ' >%4('%/*», "*@!#*""*, !8 @,$< 4%$
315
#@5#$, @(#4% '6:(1* ' #'%$ &*)($6 N. K*&'!"* «B&(!#:(?1%"!% >%4('%/* ! @(4('(. @(1)(&». C #$*$<% L";%4<#* ! &*)($% K*&'!"* "%8*4( #:(1"6: @( #(1%&?*"!G @(4(?%"!., /*#*GF!:#,, ' >*#$"(#$!, &(4! @&,8(:(?1%"!, ' #$*"('4%"!! >%4('%/*, &(4! !+;($('4%"!, (&51!. $&51*, >4%"(&*+1%4<"(. &%>!, ()F%#$'%""(;( ()&*+* ?!+"!. L";%4<# # @(+!2!. 1!*4%/$!/(– 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! (#86#4!4 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. 8*$%&!*4, #(1%&?*F!.#, ' &*)($*: K*&'!"* ! 1&5;!: %#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%., /*/ )6 $&*"#A(&8!&('*4 !: '6'(16 @(1 5;4(8 +&%"!, &*"%% 5#$*"('4%""6: !8 ! *&/#(8 A!4(#(A#/!: !1%.. P&*'"!$%4<"6. *"*4!+ ()F%$%(&%$!>%#/!: &%7%"!. @&()4%86 @&(!#:(?1%"!, >%4('%/* 5>%"68!-%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4,8! '$(&(. @(4('!"6 XIX – "*>*4* UU ''. – # (1"(. #$(&("6 ! A!4(#(A*8!– 8*$%&!*4!#$*8! XVIII '%/* –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– (),+*$%4<"*, (@(&* A!4(#(A#/(;( 8*$%&!*4!+8* "* @(+!$!'"6. %#$%#$'%""("*5>"6. 8*$%&!*4, @&%1#$*'4,GF!. ' +"*"!! ()I%/$!'"5G &%*4<"(#$< @&!&(16 ! %% +*/("('. 31"!8 !+ /("/&%$"6: @&(,'4%"!. 1%.#$'!, E$!: +*/("(' ! ,'!4(#< A(&8!&('*"!% 8*$%&!*4<"6: @&%1@(#64(/ '(+"!/"('%"!, >%4('%/* ! >%4('%>%#/(;( #(+"*"!,, #$*'7!: ()I%/$(8 !+5>%"!, 14, 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/(. A!4(#(A!! ! %#$%#$'(+"*"!,. O>%"6%–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–8*$%&!*4!#$6. L$( 1(/*+6'*%$, # (1"(. #$(&("6, 1%.#$'%""(#$<, EAA%/$!'"(#$< A!4(#(A#/!: – 8*$%&!*4!#$!>%#/!: ' #'(%. (#"('% – #&%1#$' @(+"*"!, @&!&(16 ! %% +*/("(', * # 1&5;(. – (),+*$%4<"(#$< 8*$%&!*4!+8*, /*/ ()F%. 8!&('(++&%">%#/(. (#"('6 %#$%#$'%""("*5>"(;( @(+"*"!,, '( '#,/(8 #45>*% – ' XIX '%/%.
316
@3;5; VII @E24D232N=ID4<;9 >82H3DB;F=<;: B=8 5 ID325D"*, ()5#4('4%""(#$< A!4(#(A#/!: '(++&%"!. 5>%"6:–%#$%#$'(!#@6$*$%4%. XIX '%/* (#()%""( @(4"( ! (#"('*$%4<"( @&(,'!4*#< ' #A%&% #"!1*!7!#'0*16!= @&()4%8*$!/!, ' &%7%"!! '(@&(#(', #',+*""6: # -*!$'*= 2!,"%"'(. H E$( @(",$"(: )515>! "%@(#&%1#$'%""68!, */$!'"68! 5>*#$"!/*8! 2%4%"*@&*'4%""(. @(+"*'*$%4<"(. 1%,$%4<"(#$! ' %% "*!)(4%% #('%&7%""(. – "*5>"(. –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§ 1. #;B2>2CE;E=D D4FD4F52CE;E=9: NE24D232N=ID4<=G ;4>D
